On the Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011
Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 27, 2008 No. 1100
In pursuance of the Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 14, 2008 No. 246 “On Approval of the Action Plan for the Implementation of the Nationwide Action Plan for the Implementation of the Address of the Head of State to the People of Kazakhstan dated February 6, 2008, ‘Improving the Welfare of the Citizens of Kazakhstan is the Main Goal of State Policy’”, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan RESOLVES:
- To approve the attached Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011 (hereinafter referred to as the Concept).
- To approve the attached Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept (hereinafter referred to as the Plan).
- To ensure the timely implementation of the measures provided for in the Plan by the central and local executive bodies of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- This Resolution shall enter into force on the date of its signing.
Prime Ministerof the Republic of Kazakhstan K. Massimov
Approvedby Resolution of the Governmentof the Republic of Kazakhstandated November 27, 2008 No. 1100
Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011
Astana, 2008
Contents
- Introduction
- Goals and objectives of the Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011
- Analysis of the current state of the permitting system3.1. Analysis in the field of licensing3.2. Analysis in the field of certification and accreditation
- International experience in improving the permitting system
- Areas and mechanisms for implementing the Concept5.1. Inventory and review of permitting documents5.2. Unification of legislation in the field of the permitting system5.3. Simplification of the procedure for issuing permitting documents5.4. Introduction of alternative forms of regulation5.5. Improvement of policy in the field of certification and accreditation
- Expected results
Introduction
Note. The Introduction was amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated April 14, 2010 No. 303.
A developed entrepreneurial sector is the foundation of the economy of any country. In developed countries, the share of small and medium-sized businesses in GDP reaches 60–80%, whereas in Kazakhstan this indicator is approximately 30%. In this regard, the implementation of state policy in the Republic of Kazakhstan is currently aimed at strengthening the position of business and, consequently, strengthening the country's economic security.
In Kazakhstan, the fundamental foundations for the accelerated modernization of economic sectors have been established, and strategic documents have been adopted, such as the Strategy for Industrial and Innovative Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2003–2015 and other legal acts. In general, the formation of an integrated system aimed at the accelerated modernization of the economy has been completed.
More than 90% of entrepreneurs are employed in the small and medium-sized business sector; therefore, successful economic and social development decisively depends on the state's ability to consistently and resolutely reduce the administrative burden on businesses and further simplify the permitting system. Extensive work is being carried out jointly with the business community to reduce administrative barriers to doing business, which will significantly improve the business climate in the country.
At the same time, Kazakhstan, like many countries regardless of their level of development, faces the problem of excessive regulation of economic activity. Complex and non-transparent procedures that entrepreneurs must follow when establishing and conducting business constitute the most serious obstacle to economic growth. These procedures increase production costs and entrepreneurs' expenses, restrict their access to the market, hinder business development, worsen the business environment, and contribute to corruption. Administrative barriers are one of the causes of the emergence of the shadow economy.
In Kazakhstan, a problematic issue is that virtually the entire range of economic activities is regulated through the permitting system.
Permitting documents include documents issued to a private entrepreneurship entity in one of the following forms: a license, permit, accreditation certificate, certification document, or registration document.
A permit is a document issued by an authorized body confirming the compliance of a legal entity, an individual, or an object, at the time of inspection, with requirements established by legislation, primarily of a technical nature, for the one-time or repeated performance of a particular operation.
In his Address to the People of Kazakhstan dated February 6, 2008, “Improving the Welfare of the Citizens of Kazakhstan is the Main Goal of State Policy”, the Head of State instructed the Government, “within the framework of administrative reform, to decisively reduce the administrative burden on businesses and further simplify the permitting system, primarily licensing, certification, and accreditation”.
In a competitive economy, the functions and responsibilities of each market participant must be clearly defined. The task of the state is to create favorable conditions for business development while ensuring compliance with the law and protecting the interests of society as a whole.
Accordingly, a well-considered and organized state policy is required, based on successful international experience and aimed at optimizing the permitting system. Addressing this task requires a systematic approach to determining the areas and measures for optimizing the permitting system and simplifying permitting procedures. This will establish a specific strategy for improving the permitting system.
2. Goals and Objectives of the Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011
The main goals of the Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011 (hereinafter referred to as the Concept) are to reduce the administrative burden on businesses and simplify the permitting system.
Achieving these goals will provide entrepreneurs with broad access to certain regulated types of activities and improve the business environment.
Within the framework of the Concept, work will be carried out to improve the permitting system by determining the list of permitting documents by law, significantly reducing the number of permitting documents, and simplifying the requirements and procedures for their issuance.
The objectives of the Concept are:
- conducting an inventory of all types of permitting documents;
- reviewing and optimizing permitting documents;
- developing state policy in the field of licensing, certification, and accreditation aimed at eliminating existing business costs;
- simplifying permitting procedures and bringing these procedures into line with international practice by providing direct access to electronic services;
- ensuring effective interaction between government bodies and public business associations in order to achieve the above-mentioned goals;
- extensive use of alternative forms of regulation of entrepreneurial activity, such as voluntary certification and accreditation, civil liability insurance, and regulation through technical regulations.
3. Analysis of the Current State of the Permitting System
3.1. Analysis in the Field of Licensing
According to the annual publication “Doing Business Report”, published by the World Bank, in 2009 Kazakhstan was to rank 70th out of 181 countries worldwide covered by this publication in the “ease of doing business” index, and 175th in the “licensing” category. It should be noted that this indicator takes into account permits only in the construction sector.
The new version of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Licensing”, which entered into force in August 2007 (hereinafter referred to as the Law), ensured certain progress in optimizing the licensing system. According to foreign experts, the Law reduced the number of licenses issued to approximately 240,000 entrepreneurs, enabling Kazakhstani businesses to save approximately USD 80.0 million without reducing state budget revenues through lost licensing fees.
The Law established:
- an exhaustive list of types and subtypes of activities subject to licensing. Under the previously applicable law, this list was determined at the level of subordinate regulatory legal acts and was constantly expanding;
- the abolition of territorial restrictions on the validity of licenses: a license is now valid throughout the entire territory of the country, with a few exceptions in special cases;
- a reduction in the number of licensed types and subtypes of activities;
- simplification of the procedure for obtaining approval for the issuance of a license from supervisory authorities, which must be carried out according to the “one-stop-shop” principle. For this purpose, licensing authorities are empowered to provide electronic services using information systems;
- introduction of the “silence means consent” principle, which provides for the automatic acquisition by an applicant of the right to engage in a licensed type of activity if no response is received from the licensing authority within the established period.
This provision establishes a procedure for the entrepreneur's “self-certification” of compliance with the prescribed qualification requirements, which is consistent with international standards.
In Kazakhstan, improvement of the licensing system is being carried out within the framework of the ongoing administrative reform, during which, from 2004 to 2007, the number of licensed types of activities was reduced threefold, and licensing functions for certain types of activities in the fields of construction, agriculture, education, and healthcare were decentralized.
Despite the measures previously taken and the results achieved, the number of types of activities requiring the receipt of permitting documents remains extremely high today.
There has also been no simplification of the licensing procedure as provided for by the Law.
Law enforcement practice has shown that certain provisions of the Law require clarification and the development of implementation mechanisms.
As the analysis has shown, the “one-stop-shop” principle, which excludes direct contact between entrepreneurs and government bodies and their officials, is not functioning. Due to insufficient coordination between licensing authorities and bodies responsible for environmental protection, nuclear, radiation, industrial and fire safety, state energy supervision, and sanitary and epidemiological services, there is no mechanism for coordinated interaction between these bodies when approving conclusions on the issuance or refusal to issue licenses.
To date, licensing authorities have not been providing electronic services using information systems as provided for by the Law “On Licensing”. There is a low level of readiness of the departmental information systems of licensing authorities to provide services electronically; specialists are not being trained to provide electronic services; an electronic licensing system has not been introduced; administrative regulations of government bodies in the field of licensing are absent; and interested government bodies, business communities, and entrepreneurs do not have access to the necessary information on licensing issues.
All these factors impede the introduction of the “one-stop-shop” principle when issuing licenses, complicate the licensing procedure, and delay the issuance of licenses. The procedure for obtaining a license has essentially remained unchanged, and the application for obtaining a license consists of a substantial package of documents containing information that is not directly related to the purposes and principles of licensing.
The principles and procedures of licensing require clarification, and, accordingly, the appropriateness of licensing certain common types of activities has not been regulated. The activities of branches and representative offices of foreign legal entities are not regulated, the implementation of licensing control over branches of legal entities is complicated, and the list of licensing authorities and a uniform form of conclusion on the applicant's compliance with the qualification requirements have not been approved.
The list of licensed types and subtypes of activities is extensive compared not only with developed countries but also with CIS countries. Currently, 349 types and subtypes of activities are subject to licensing in Kazakhstan. Meanwhile, approximately 100 types of activities are licensed in the Russian Federation, 36 in Kyrgyzstan, and 50 in Moldova. In Georgia, 86 types of activities are licensed, in Hungary — 7, and in European countries — an average of 10–12 types of activities.
In addition to licensing, accreditation, certification, permits, and approvals are classified as elements of the permitting system.
The procedures for issuing permitting documents are duplicated in many cases, particularly during the approval of license issuance and post-licensing control.
At present, there is a tendency for licensing authorities to increase the number of licensed types of activities and to further detail subtypes of activities within individual types by dividing types into subtypes (for example, in the fields of circulation of ferrous and non-ferrous metal scrap, poisonous substances, pharmaceutical activities, education, and others), as a result of which the relevant subordinate regulatory legal acts must be reapproved. This does not ensure the stability of qualification requirements.
The imperfection of licensing legislation, in turn, affects the quality and number of adopted subordinate regulatory legal acts, which have exceeded 70 acts, as well as the large number of departmental regulatory acts initiated by government bodies themselves and their subordinate structures.
An analysis of regulatory legal acts has shown that licensing rules and qualification requirements imposed on certain types of activities are most in need of improvement and optimization. Licensing rules and qualification requirements must be reviewed in order to eliminate excessive provisions that are not directly related to the purposes and principles of licensing, while departmental acts must be abolished, since orders and instructions create an additional permitting system that governs both the issuance of licenses and subsequent licensed activities.
Regulatory legal acts governing the permitting system contain numerous blanket provisions. Many provisions of licensing rules and qualification requirements duplicate both the Law “On Licensing” and sector-specific laws; some are adopted without sufficient justification or an assessment of their impact on the socio-economic environment. The mechanism for post-licensing control has not been sufficiently developed.
Unclear qualification requirements have been established for obtaining permitting documents, both for the business entity and for the business object. Such a situation creates conditions for the development of corruption and arbitrariness on the part of officials of government bodies.
The existing licensing and permitting system is characterized as a continuation of the Soviet system, under which permission had to be obtained for virtually every individual operation or type of activity. Despite the efforts of the country's leadership to actively promote market reforms, the permitting system remains an obstacle to the development of the entire economy.
In conditions of profound and rapidly changing economic and social circumstances, the existing shortcomings of the legislative framework in the field of licensing constitute an obstacle to business development, creating administrative barriers.
The imperfection of the legislative framework, excessive licensing, an unclear and non-transparent licensing system, administrative barriers, together with the low efficiency of regulation by licensing authorities, complicate business access to certain types of activities, restrain the growth in the number of small and medium-sized businesses and, accordingly, tax revenues to the budget.
Thus, there are a number of issues that require further consideration in order to improve the licensing system.
1. Further improvement of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on licensing, clarification of licensing principles, development of a mechanism for operating according to the “one-stop-shop” principle, optimization of licensed types of activities, determination by law of the list of permitting documents, and ensuring the stability of qualification requirements.
2. A substantial reduction (by more than half) in permitting documents.
3. Ensuring coordination and introducing a mechanism for coordinated interaction between interested bodies when issuing licenses.
4. Introducing electronic services in the permitting system and implementing a system for obtaining permitting documents electronically in real time.
5. Establishing an electronic register of permitting documents.
To resolve these issues, it is necessary to continue work on eliminating duplicative provisions in regulatory legal acts in the field of licensing, as well as further optimizing the number of licensed types of activities and simplifying the procedure for issuing permitting documents.
A significant portion of the problems can be resolved by bringing the licensing system closer to international practice.
3.2. Analysis in the Field of Certification and Accreditation
Currently, more than 1,000 product names are subject to mandatory certification in the republic, which is significantly lower than comparable lists in CIS countries (5,000 in the Russian Federation and 3,800 in Kyrgyzstan).
Mandatory certification is the certification of goods included in the list of goods subject to mandatory certification for compliance with mandatory requirements of a standard or other regulatory document ensuring their safety for human life and health, citizens' property, and the environment.
In Kazakhstan, starting from 2000, certification procedures have been transferred to the competitive sector. Currently, 200 conformity assessment bodies, 500 testing laboratories, and 400 metrological services are operating.
The List of products subject to mandatory certification was approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated April 20, 2005 No. 367 “On Mandatory Confirmation of Product Conformity in the Republic of Kazakhstan”. Mandatory certification applies both to products placed on the market within the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan and to products manufactured outside the republic and imported into the country.
Certification of all types of services has now been abolished.
Furthermore, with the adoption of technical regulations, the above-mentioned list will be reduced. The Plan for the Development of Technical Standards for 2007–2009 provides for the development of approximately 117 technical regulations.
The main purpose of accreditation in the field of conformity assessment is to evaluate the technical competence of laboratories and conformity assessment bodies of an entity against the relevant standards. In international practice, accreditation consists of examining an entity's documents, inspecting it at its location to determine whether the information contained in the documents corresponds to its actual condition, and subsequent post-accreditation control. This is reflected in the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Accreditation in the Field of Conformity Assessment” dated July 5, 2008. By Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2008 No. 773, LLP “National Accreditation Center” was designated as the accreditation body.
In 2008, Kazakhstan made significant progress in improving its regulatory legal framework to create a favorable environment for doing business. However, the country's low ranking in terms of creating favorable conditions for doing business requires the development and implementation of a strategy for improving the permitting system. In this context, it is important to take into account not only regulatory policy but also the methods used to develop and implement such policy.
4. International Experience in Improving the Permitting System
The regulatory legal framework governing entrepreneurial activity is based on legally established forms of regulation, including the issuance of permitting documents.
State regulation of activities through the issuance of a permitting document is carried out only where the activity or action of a business entity is directly associated with an extremely high, proven danger to human life and health and the environment.
In the countries of the European Union (EU), there is no specific legislation governing licensing. Licensing relations are regulated by different sector-specific laws in different countries, and the definition of industries and types of activities subject to licensing also varies. However, a Deregulation Directive aimed at reducing regulated types of activities at the level of EU Member States has now been adopted at the EU level.
Qualification requirements relating to the protection of human health and the environment are established by law for legal entities.
As a rule, developed countries apply two types of procedures for issuing permitting documents: simplified and standard.
In many countries around the world, only 5–10 types of activities are licensed, mainly in such fields as attracting funds from the public, healthcare, the pharmaceutical and chemical industries (production and sale of hazardous materials), and construction.
The main trends in leading international practice concerning the reform of the permitting system are:
- reducing the number of permitting documents and approving their lists by laws;
- clear regulation of requirements imposed on the procedure for issuing permitting documents;
- clear definition of qualification requirements;
- assessment of compliance with qualification requirements by independent experts;
- clear determination of the validity periods and types of permitting documents;
- simplifying procedures for obtaining permitting documents through the use of information technologies;
- electronic issuance of permitting documents, including maintaining electronic records of issued documents with free online access;
- revocation of a permitting document only through judicial proceedings.
The following can be noted as positive results of licensing system reforms.
In the Netherlands, the reduction of licensing procedures has resulted in significant savings in public funds. A program implemented by the Ministry of Finance of the Netherlands to reduce bureaucratic procedures made it possible to save USD 2.0 billion annually. By 2007, savings had reached USD 4.5 billion and amounted to one quarter of the funds allocated to improving the licensing system five years earlier.
In addition, in the Netherlands, the gradual abolition of excessive licensing was accompanied by the transfer of regulatory functions to business associations, and the reform was monitored.
In the countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the simplification of licensing procedures was carried out through the introduction of electronic licensing (establishing a uniform form of permitting documents, electronic submission of applications for their receipt, and an electronic register of permitting documents), as well as the issuance of permitting documents online (the United Kingdom, Belgium, Italy, Mexico, and New Zealand).
In Mexico, when an electronic register of licenses was established, more than 80% of licenses for sanitary activities were abolished during the inventory of permitting documents.
In India, as a result of radical reform of the permitting system, the number of licensed industries was significantly reduced, from 52 to 5, while GDP growth increased from 3.5% to 6–7% per year.
South Korea is one of the most prominent international examples of reducing state regulation. In the 1990s, the volume of industrial production in South Korea began to decline, and the country's economy was losing competitiveness due to excessive state regulation of entrepreneurial activity. At the President's instruction, each ministry conducted an inventory of regulatory legal acts in its area of responsibility, including those governing the issuance of permitting documents. Following the inventory, the President instructed each ministry to abolish, at its own discretion, at least 50% of the 11,125 regulatory legal acts identified as of 1998 that regulated entrepreneurial activity. With regard to the remaining 50% of regulatory legal acts, each ministry was required to prove the necessity of maintaining each act in force. Today, South Korea is the 11th largest economy in the world.
The Government of Kyrgyzstan plans to conduct a complete inventory of permitting documents in 2008–2009 and reduce their number by more than half.
Thus, international practice demonstrates a trend toward a significant reduction in the types of activities and operations that require the receipt of permitting documents. Requirements for conducting entrepreneurial activities have also been established through the introduction of uniform procedures for issuing permitting documents.
Based on a generalization of advanced international experience, it is advisable to:
- ensure the quality of regulatory legal acts in the field of the permitting system by conducting a complete inventory thereof;
- unify requirements for the development and content of regulatory legal acts establishing qualification requirements for conducting regulated types of activities;
- apply checklists for issuing each type of permitting document;
- maintain electronic registers of permitting documents;
- replace state regulation with flexible product safety standards;
- gradually transfer certain regulatory functions to business associations or entrepreneurs themselves (self-regulation);
- simplify regulation.
Regulatory reform contributes to improving economic efficiency. However, its impact on economic growth rates is difficult to assess. An analysis conducted by the OECD suggests that its impact may become significant only after several years. For example, following the liberalization of requirements in the field of air transportation in Europe, 800 new licenses were issued. The development of competition led to lower tariffs; in the United States, tariffs decreased by one third. In the telecommunications sector, tariffs decreased by 63% in the United Kingdom, 41% in Japan, and 66% in Finland. Employment increased by 10%.
In recent years, many countries have embarked on reforming their permitting systems. The leading countries in creating favorable conditions for ease of doing business in 2008 were Egypt, Croatia, Ghana, Georgia, Colombia, Saudi Arabia, Kenya, China, Bulgaria, and Moldova. In these countries, within a relatively short period, the time and costs required to start a business were reduced several times over, administrative barriers to obtaining construction permits were significantly eased, and many permitting documents began to be issued according to the “one-stop-shop” principle, which ensured the growth of small businesses and the inflow of investment.
As a review of international experience has shown, more than 50 countries have carried out large-scale and fundamental reforms of their systems of state regulation of entrepreneurial activity in recent years.
In the process of reform, the “guillotine” method was widely used to assess and confirm whether each regulatory legal act and permitting document complied with certain goals, principles, and requirements. Regulatory acts and permitting documents that did not meet the listed requirements were abolished, or qualification requirements were simplified. This work was carried out with the participation of all interested parties from both the public and private sectors, including public hearings and the mass media.
The “guillotine” method provides for the review, within a short period, of a large number of regulations and the identification of those that are economically inefficient, inappropriate, and increase the costs of the state, businesses, and citizens. Implementing such a rapid deregulation strategy will reduce the regulatory burden on business entities and reduce the number of economically inappropriate regulatory legal acts.
According to the principles of the “guillotine”, after a specified period, the Government will approve only those regulatory legal acts whose necessity for regulating entrepreneurial activity has been substantiated. Such justifications must be based on an assessment of the regulatory impact of permitting documents, that is, an evaluation of the positive and negative effects of the impact on society of introducing a particular regulatory document.
In all these countries, the results of reforms and their effectiveness depended directly on political support at the highest level, resistance to pressure from government departments aimed at preserving their areas and instruments of regulation, and the conduct of a complete inventory of regulatory legal acts in the field of regulation of entrepreneurial activity. A complete inventory contributed to the establishment of electronic registers of all existing permitting documents and ensured transparency of the permitting system.
5. Areas and Mechanisms for Implementing the Concept
The priority task of the state is to create favorable conditions for business development while ensuring strict and consistent compliance with legislation and the interests of society as a whole.
The Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan has identified the following main priorities for further reform of the permitting system:
- improving the quality of public services;
- reducing the administrative burden on entrepreneurial activity and bringing order to areas where excessive state intervention exists;
- continuing the development of elements of “electronic government”, primarily by ensuring the widespread provision of public services using information and communication technologies.
Reforming the permitting system must ensure a specific economic effect: the creation of new enterprises and jobs, an increase in tax revenues, and an increase in the share of small and medium-sized businesses in the country's GDP.
Within the framework of implementing the Concept, it is necessary to develop fundamentally new approaches to the entire permitting system, primarily to licensing, certification, and accreditation.
Taking international experience into account, improvement of the permitting system must be based on the following main principles and approaches:
- appropriateness of regulation;
- maintaining an acceptable level of protection of human life and health and environmental protection;
- clear regulation of the list of permitting documents and procedures for their issuance exclusively by legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
- maximally simplified access to types of activities classified as subject to state regulation and the issuance of permitting documents;
- liberalization of requirements imposed on regulated types of activities;
- transparency of permitting procedures and qualification requirements;
- effective interaction between all interested government bodies and entrepreneurs and their associations;
- clear delineation and elimination of duplication of powers of government bodies in procedures for issuing permitting documents;
- continuity, consistency, and comprehensiveness in implementing the assigned tasks, and monitoring the implementation of adopted decisions;
- development of business self-regulation instruments;
- elimination of administrative barriers hindering business development and ensuring the economic efficiency of measures aimed at eliminating them;
- optimization of the permitting system;
- use of international experience in improving the permitting system.
The following measures will be implemented to address the tasks set.
5.1. Inventory and Review of Permitting Documents
The problem of improving the permitting system cannot be resolved until the scale of the work ahead has been determined. It can be noted that currently there is not a single type of entrepreneurial activity for which obtaining at least one permitting document is not required. Entrepreneurial activity is regulated through the establishment of new requirements and types of permitting documents, the number of which continues to increase.
At present, there is no complete information on the number of permitting documents issued, the purposes of their issuance, the state's costs for issuing them, or the costs incurred by entrepreneurs to obtain them.
Based on this, the Government's initial task in the process of reforming the permitting system is to conduct a comprehensive inventory of all permitting documents.
The inventory will be conducted by the ministries and agencies themselves, with the involvement of independent experts and industry associations of entrepreneurs. As a result of the inventory, a list of all permitting documents will be compiled.
This list will serve as the basis for reviewing all permitting documents. A moratorium on the introduction of any new permitting documents will be declared for the entire period of the review.
The inventory will also serve as the basis for monitoring the results of reforming the permitting system and will ensure broader public support for this reform.
The review of permitting documents will become the second important task in the reform implementation process and will be conducted on the basis of the following approaches and criteria:
- appropriateness of issuing a permitting document (what problem the relevant permitting document addresses: prevention of an extremely high danger to human life and health and the environment, the scale of the problem, supporting arguments, and the possibility of reducing the target group of entrepreneurs);
- abolition of duplicative permitting documents;
- establishment of qualification requirements by legislative acts and their transparency;
- abolition of unclear and excessive qualification requirements;
- promotion of entrepreneurial activity;
- replacement of a permitting document with notification-based registration;
- clear determination of the time limits for reviewing an application for issuance and issuing a permitting document.
The review of permitting documents will be carried out in two stages by government bodies and a group of independent experts accountable to the Government, in order to ensure consistency and quality in the review of permitting documents.
During the review process, responsibility for ensuring that permitting documents comply with the above-mentioned criteria will be assigned to the government bodies, which must substantiate the necessity of retaining a particular permitting document. The task of the group of independent experts will be to assess the justifications submitted by government bodies and develop appropriate recommendations for the Government.
During the review process, a high level of transparency and broad participation by all interested parties must be ensured. This will increase public trust, improve the quality of work on reviewing permitting documents, and contribute to the overall progress of the permitting system reform.
As a result of this work, permitting documents for which compliance with the above-mentioned criteria has not been proven will be abolished, while permitting documents for which such compliance has been proven will be simplified.
To ensure the quality of the review, checklists will be developed for each type of permitting document. The review criteria will be selected in such a way as not to exclude any necessary permitting document that ensures the protection of human life and health and the environment against potential risks associated with activities or operations that pose a high level of danger.
As a result of the review, at least half of the permitting documents identified during the complete inventory must be abolished.
5.2. Unification of Legislation in the Field of the Permitting System
Further improvement of legislation in the field of the permitting system is envisaged with regard to optimizing the list of licensed types of activities, simplifying the procedures for issuing permitting documents, the format of applications for obtaining them, and determining the content of qualification requirements imposed on regulated types of activities.
The Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Licensing” provides a definition of the concept of “license” that is equivalent to a permit. These terms must be clearly distinguished. In this regard, a definition of the concept of “permit” will be provided, and lists of types of licenses and permits will be approved.
The concept of “permit” will be included in the list of forms of state administration as one of its forms.
It is envisaged that the Government's authority to approve licensing rules for engaging in certain types of activities will be excluded.
At the same time, mechanisms will be developed for implementing the basic principles of the permitting system: the principles of “silence means consent” and the “one-stop-shop”. A new principle of the permitting system, widely applied in other countries, will also be established: the principle of notification of the commencement of activities without prior receipt of a permitting document.
The division of licensed types of activities into subtypes will be abolished, which will accordingly make it possible to abolish the issuance of annexes to licenses.
All subordinate regulatory legal acts regulating licensing rules and the conditions and procedures for issuing licenses, reissuing them, issuing duplicates, terminating and suspending their validity will be abolished, since these procedures will be established by law.
Requirements for licensed types of activities will be established at the legislative level, thereby ensuring a reduction in the number of resolutions of the Government and departmental regulatory acts adopted. This measure will eliminate discrepancies between the provisions of regulatory legal acts (for example, in the field of production and circulation of ethyl alcohol and alcoholic products and certain other areas, where the provisions of sector-specific laws and subordinate acts — qualification requirements for the relevant type of activity — have not been regulated to date).
This approach provides for the clarification and unification of qualification requirements in accordance with the established licensing principles and ensures their stability.
For these purposes, standard licensing rules will be developed with an exhaustive list of documents to be submitted, while excluding requests for additional information.
Work will be carried out to analyze regulatory legal acts in the field of the permitting system in order to identify and eliminate blanket provisions, that is, legal provisions granting government bodies and officials the right to independently establish rules of conduct, prohibitions, and so forth. Annual confirmation of qualification requirements, provided that licensing authorities ensure the necessary post-licensing control, must be abolished.
The process of improving legislation in the field of the permitting system will also create the basis for introducing an electronic one-stop-shop and an electronic register of permitting documents, and will determine the institutional framework for ensuring the operation of these two instruments.
The requirement for notarization of documents (charters, diplomas, etc.), which entails significant costs for entrepreneurs, will be replaced by the right to have documents certified by a government body, provided that the originals of the documents are presented, without notarization. This provision will be established by law.
Government bodies will also be provided with access to state electronic databases and registers containing information necessary for the procedure of issuing permitting documents, in order to accelerate the receipt of information from other departments and eliminate the need to submit such information in paper form.
5.3. Simplification of the Procedure for Issuing Permitting Documents
The procedure for issuing permitting documents is to be simplified through the introduction of the “one-stop-shop” principle. A set of measures will be carried out in two stages.
At the initial stage, it is necessary to develop standard regulations for issuing licenses according to the “one-stop-shop” principle, taking into account existing positive experience, which will subsequently be distributed to all interested bodies and organizations for guidance.
The standard regulations will provide for sources of obtaining the necessary information for entrepreneurs, a minimum list of documents, acceptance of applications together with the package of documents, the procedure for expedited approval by licensing authorities of license issuance with supervisory bodies, and the issuance of licenses within the established time limits.
At the same time, the elimination of unnecessary interdepartmental approval procedures for the issuance of licenses and other permitting documents will be provided for. In particular, this will involve eliminating procedures whereby licensing authorities obtain approvals for license issuance from bodies whose powers include state control in the relevant areas: sanitary and epidemiological safety, fire safety, environmental protection, nuclear, radiation and industrial safety, and state energy supervision. Furthermore, state control is carried out not under the provisions of licensing legislation but under the provisions of sector-specific laws in these areas.
To issue licenses and other permitting documents according to the “one-stop-shop” principle, it is necessary to:
- develop and implement an electronic “one-stop-shop” for issuing permitting documents;
- develop and implement an electronic register of permitting documents;
- establish a minimum package of documents for obtaining a license that can be submitted via the Internet;
- train specialists of licensing authorities.
The need to create an electronic register of permitting documents is обусловed by the strengthening of post-licensing control, coordination of interested bodies when approving the issuance of licenses, as well as the need to record all valid state licenses and permits for the purposes of monitoring, evaluating the effectiveness of regulation, ensuring transparency, controlling issued licenses and permits, and providing access to information for interested bodies and business communities.
For the purpose of effective training of specialists, licensing authorities will conduct training sessions to teach specialists the skills required to issue licenses and other permitting documents according to the “one-stop-shop” principle.
In the process of creating an information system for issuing licenses and other permitting documents, administrative regulations, uniform state standards, and technical requirements in the field of licensing will be developed for government bodies. On their basis, existing information systems of government bodies will be optimized and brought into a unified architecture, new information systems will be implemented, and they will be integrated into the unified “electronic licensing” system.
At the second stage, within the framework of the “electronic government” program, it is planned to introduce the “E-Licensing” electronic licensing information system in all licensing authorities.
This system will make it possible to increase the overall efficiency of the activities of the central offices of licensing authorities and their territorial subdivisions, as well as individual specialists responsible for collecting, monitoring, and recording information on state licenses issued, refused, suspended, and reinstated; reduce applicants' time costs; and ensure transparency, which, in turn, will eliminate conditions conducive to corruption.
5.4. Introduction of Alternative Forms of Regulation
Even today, there are examples in the country of control exercised by the private sector, such as auditing, third-party liability insurance, and product conformity assessment.
For example, legal, notarial, auditing, architectural activities, activities involving the valuation of property (with the exception of the value of intangible assets) and intellectual property, the value of intangible assets, physical fitness and recreational services, sports services, travel agency and tour operator activities, and other types of activities may be regulated through the introduction of institutions of self-regulatory accredited organizations, with the mandatory existence of a civil liability agreement.
These types of activities must be removed from the permitting system, taking into account the best international experience, which provides for the replacement of state regulation with organizational standards, the regulation of issues concerning the protection of human health and safety and environmental protection by business associations or entrepreneurs themselves on a voluntary basis, as well as taking into account the potential opportunities for business self-regulation, since self-imposed requirements may be more effective than established qualification requirements.
These types of activities may be regulated through organizational standards, voluntary initiatives, codes, and agreements, that is, through a declaration mechanism. At the enterprise level, self-monitoring departments should become the instrument of this mechanism.
Furthermore, this area is justified in view of the forthcoming legislative definition of the concept of “corporate social responsibility”. This concept is a vital, necessary, and generally accepted factor in the civilized operations of any large company. Western companies perceive corporate social responsibility as a pragmatic business direction and one of the instruments for managing non-financial risks in the economic, social, and environmental spheres.
Outsourcing (the transfer of certain functions in the field of licensing, certification, and accreditation to the competitive sector and public business associations) will be carried out following the relevant review of permitting documents.
5.5. Improvement of Policy in the Field of Certification and Accreditation
In the field of certification, the permitting system will be restricted by certifying certain product names exclusively with regard to their compliance with requirements for the safety of human life and health and the environment. The document issued will be called a certificate of product safety indicators.
The list of goods subject to mandatory confirmation of conformity in the form of certification will be reduced by more than half through the application of the principle of product conformity declaration.
Declaration implies the full responsibility of the manufacturer, unlike certification, where responsibility rests with the conformity assessment body. This practice is successfully applied in EU countries, where, according to estimates by European experts, more than 30% of products in circulation on the market are subject to declaration. In countries such as Germany and the United Kingdom, this procedure is not characterized by excessive requirements — only the essential characteristics of products are declared, and the level of liability is sufficiently high, ranging from substantial fines to criminal liability.
The number of products subject to mandatory certification may be reduced by introducing mandatory conformity assessment only for products placed on the market within the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan. For products manufactured outside its territory and imported into our country, mandatory certification must be replaced by mandatory declaration or automatic recognition of certificates. This will make it possible to reduce the list of products subject to certification.
Under current legislation, the term “accreditation” has several different meanings, is purely procedural in nature, and means recognition of certain qualities of an entity to engage in a particular type of activity. In this regard, accreditation is confirmation of the special merits (qualities) of an entity.
In the field of accreditation, a uniform interpretation of the term “accreditation” will be provided by legislation, and accreditation will be voluntary in nature.
6. Expected Results
It is expected that the implementation of the measures provided for in this Concept will ensure improvement of the permitting system, which should significantly reduce the administrative burden on businesses and simplify the permitting system.
As a result of implementing the provisions of the Concept, a substantial increase in the share of small and medium-sized businesses in GDP is expected, since a number of opportunities will become available to entrepreneurs for implementing new business initiatives.
As a result of implementing the Concept, an improvement in the country's ranking in international reports assessing the business environment is also expected.
A significant reduction (by more than half) in permitting documents is expected as a result of removing certain types of activities, operations, and actions from the permitting regime.
The permitting system and procedures will be brought as close as possible to the progressive system of international practice.
Furthermore, improvement of the permitting system will eliminate duplicative permitting documents, simplify the procedures for their issuance, and increase the transparency of qualification requirements. Implementation of these measures will make it possible to significantly reduce business costs and create the conditions for its further dynamic development, since the system of state administration of market infrastructure will be simplified.
Tangible results of the reform should be expected within the subsequent two years following completion of the review of permitting documents. It is expected that the results obtained will also be improved through the implementation of other measures to be undertaken after the review of permitting documents.
For the purpose of monitoring the progress of implementation of the Concept, an action plan for its implementation will be adopted.
Approvedby Resolution of the Governmentof the Republic of Kazakhstandated November 27, 2008 No. 1100
Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept for Improving the Permitting System in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009–2011
Note. The Plan was amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 10, 2009 No. 1803.
Download
| 1. Improvement of the regulatory legal framework for implementing the objectives of the Concept | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. Simplification of the procedure for issuing permitting documents within the framework of the “electronic government” program | ||||
| 3. Introduction of alternative forms of regulation of entrepreneurial activity | ||||
| 4. Information support for the implementation of the Concept |
| No. | Measure | Form of completion | Responsible for implementation | Implementation deadlines |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Establish working groups in government bodies to conduct an inventory of regulatory legal acts governing the issuance of permitting documents | Order of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan | MEaBP (coordination), government bodies, NAC (by agreement), expert group accountable to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan, industry associations of entrepreneurs | February 2009 |
| 2 | Review regulatory legal acts in the field of the permitting system in order to optimize permitting documents | Information to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | Government bodies, NAC (by agreement), expert group accountable to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | March, June 2009 |
| 3 | Submit proposals to reduce the list of licensed types of activities and replace the licensing regime with other types of regulation | Proposals to MEaBP | Government licensing authorities | April 2009 |
| 4 | Develop and submit to the Interdepartmental Commission on Legislative Activities under the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan the concept of the draft law “On Amendments and Additions to Certain Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Licensing Issues” | Minutes of the Interdepartmental Commission on Legislative Activities under the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | MEaBP (coordination), interested government bodies, NAC (by agreement) | July 2009 |
| 5 | Approve standards and regulations for issuing each permitting document on the basis of the Standard and Regulations for the Provision of Public Services | Information to MEaBP | Government bodies, akims of Astana and Almaty, and regions | 4th quarter of 2009 |
| 6 | Establish and implement the state electronic database “E-Licensing” | Information to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AIS (coordination), interested government bodies | 4th quarter of 2009, 2010 |
| 7 | Train specialists of government bodies to work with the state electronic database “E-Licensing” | Information to MEaBP | AIS (coordination), interested government bodies | 4th quarter of 2009 |
| 8 | Ensure the maintenance of electronic registers of permitting documents and the issuance of permitting documents according to the “one-stop-shop” principle | Information to MEaBP | Government bodies | 4th quarter of 2010, 2011 |
| 9 | Prepare proposals for transferring certain functions in the field of licensing, certification, and accreditation to the competitive sector (outsourcing) | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | MEaBP (coordination), government bodies | By January 10, annually |
| 10 | Ensure the introduction of mechanisms of civil liability and business self-regulation through agreements, codes, and arrangements | Information to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | MEaBP (coordination), government bodies | By January 10, annually |
| 11 | Conduct public discussions on the progress of implementation of the permitting system reform and provide explanations of regulatory legal acts in the field of the permitting system through the mass media | Internet conferences, publications in the mass media | MCI (coordination), government bodies | Twice a year — by July 10 and January 10 |
Note. Explanation of abbreviations:
AIS — Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Informatization and Communications;
MCI — Ministry of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
MEaBP — Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
NAC — JSC “National Analytical Center under the Government and the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan”.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Program Charter Statute Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Program Rules