Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Convention / Resolution / Concept / On Approval of the Cybersecurity Concept (“Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan”)

On Approval of the Cybersecurity Concept (“Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan”)

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

On Approval of the Cybersecurity Concept (“Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan”)

Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2017 No. 407.

For the purpose of implementing Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated February 15, 2017 No. 422 “On Measures to Implement the Address of the Head of State to the People of Kazakhstan dated January 31, 2017, ‘The Third Modernization of Kazakhstan: Global Competitiveness’”, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan HEREBY RESOLVES:

1. To approve the attached Cybersecurity Concept (“Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan”) (hereinafter referred to as the Concept).

2. Central state bodies of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall:

1) take the necessary measures to implement the Concept;

2) submit information on the progress of implementation of the Concept to the Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan once every six months, no later than the 10th day of the month following the reporting half-year.

Note. Paragraph 2 as amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 17, 2023 No. 236 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

3. The Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall:

1) within three months, develop an Action Plan for the implementation of the Concept and submit it for consideration to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan in accordance with the procedure established by law;

2) submit consolidated information on the progress of implementation of the Concept to the Office of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan twice a year, by July 25 and January 25.

Note. Paragraph 3 as amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 17, 2023 No. 236 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

4. Control over the implementation of this Resolution shall be entrusted to the Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

Note. Paragraph 4 as amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 17, 2023 No. 236.

5. This Resolution shall enter into force on the date of its signing.

Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan

B. Sagintayev

Approvedby Resolution of the Governmentof the Republic of Kazakhstandated June 30, 2017 No. 407

CYBERSECURITY CONCEPT (“CYBER SHIELD OF KAZAKHSTAN”)

Contents

1. Introduction

2. Analysis of the Current Situation

3. International Experience

4. Goals, Objectives, Expected Results and Implementation Period

5. Basic Principles and Approaches

6. List of Regulatory Legal Acts through Which the Concept Is Intended to Be Implemented

1. Introduction

The Cybersecurity Concept (“Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan”) (hereinafter referred to as the Concept) has been developed in accordance with the Address of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan “The Third Modernization of Kazakhstan: Global Competitiveness”, taking into account the approaches of the Kazakhstan-2050 Strategy concerning Kazakhstan’s entry into the group of the 30 most developed countries in the world.

The Concept is based on an assessment of the current situation in the field of informatization of government bodies, automation of public services, prospects for the development of the “digital” economy and technological modernization of production processes in industry, as well as the expansion of the provision of information and communication services.

The Concept defines the main areas for implementing state policy in the field of protecting electronic information resources, information systems and telecommunications networks, and ensuring the secure use of information and communication technologies (hereinafter referred to as ICT).

The Concept is intended to ensure uniform approaches to monitoring information security among government bodies, individuals and legal entities, as well as to develop mechanisms for preventing and promptly responding to information security incidents, including in circumstances involving social, natural and man-made emergencies, and the introduction of a state of emergency or martial law.

In developing the Concept, international experience was studied in the field of establishing approaches to protecting the national information and communication infrastructure of countries that are leaders in the development and use of information and communication technologies, as well as countries seeking to expand their application in order to achieve socio-economic development objectives.

Implementation of this Concept will contribute to the further modernization of Kazakhstani society and constitute Kazakhstan’s contribution to the implementation of the UN Global Cybersecurity Agenda.

Terms and Definitions

For the purposes of this Concept, cybersecurity means the state of protection of information in electronic form and the environment in which it is processed, stored and transmitted (electronic information resources, information systems and information and communication infrastructure) against external and internal threats, that is, information security in the field of informatization.

Information protection, or the protection of electronic information resources and information systems, is a set of physical, technical, software, cryptographic and administrative measures aimed at ensuring information security.

The classical information security model is based on ensuring three attributes of information that are significant for security: confidentiality, integrity and availability.

Information confidentiality means that information may be accessed only by a strictly limited group of persons determined by its owner.

If an unauthorized person gains access to information, unauthorized access or a breach of confidentiality occurs.

For certain types of information protected by law or by its owner, confidentiality is one of the most important attributes (official information, types of information constituting legally protected secrets, personal data subject to restricted access, for example, information about bank customers, creditors, tax data, information held by medical institutions concerning the health of patients, etc.).

Information integrity is the ability of information (data) to remain unaltered. Unauthorized changes to information that are not provided for by its owner (as a result of an operator error or deliberate actions by an unauthorized person) result in a breach of integrity.

The integrity of data related to the operation of critical information and communication infrastructure facilities is particularly important (for example, automated air traffic control systems, electricity and energy supply systems, and so on).

Information availability is determined by the ability of an information system to provide timely and unhindered access to information to entities possessing the appropriate authority. Destruction or blocking of information (as a result of an error or deliberate action) results in a loss of availability.

Availability is an important attribute for the operation of information systems intended to serve customers by providing information and communication services (information systems for the sale of railway and airline tickets, banking services, and the distribution of products through Internet resources and electronic media on the Internet). A situation in which an authorized user cannot access certain services (most often network services) is referred to as a denial of service.

In connection with the development of communication (network) technologies, two additional properties of information security are also distinguished, relating to the identity of the person who manages or uses an information system or electronic information resource remotely via a network: authenticity and non-repudiation.

Authenticity is the ability to reliably establish the author of a legally significant action involving information or a message in the provision of information and communication services, for example, in electronic commerce, where an electronic digital signature or another authentication method is used.

Non-repudiation is the ability, in the event that authorship is denied, to prove that the user in question, and no one else, was the author of actions involving information in an information system or resource, through the recording of the actions performed.

Authentication (establishing authenticity) is the verification that the identifier presented belongs to the access subject and the confirmation of its authenticity.

Identification is the assignment to subjects accessing an information system or electronic resource of a personal identifier that ensures the establishment of authenticity and the determination of the subject’s authority when granting access to the information system, the monitoring of authority during a work session, and the recording of actions.

Identification and authentication form the basis of modern software and hardware security tools, since any ICT services and systems are primarily designed to serve user entities.

An information security threat is a potentially possible event, process or phenomenon which, through its impact on information or components of an information system or resource, may directly or indirectly cause damage to the interests of owners and users.

The most common information security threats include equipment failures (cabling systems, disk systems, servers, workstations, and so on), improper storage of archived data, violations of data access rights, incorrect actions by users and maintenance personnel, and information losses (due to unauthorized access or infection by malicious software, including computer viruses).

A computer attack is a targeted attempt to implement a threat of unauthorized interference with information, an electronic resource, an information system or access thereto using software or hardware and software tools (or inter-network interaction protocols).

All other terms are used in the meanings established by the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences, the Laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On National Security of the Republic of Kazakhstan”, “On State Secrets”, “On Counteracting Terrorism”, “On Electronic Documents and Electronic Digital Signatures”, “On Informatization”, “On Technical Regulation”, “On Permits and Notifications”, “On Mass Media”, “On Communications”, “On Personal Data and Their Protection”, “On Access to Information”, and national technical standards.

2. Analysis of the Current Situation

The global trend characteristic of recent decades, namely the introduction of advances in information and communication technologies at a pace significantly outstripping the development of a culture of their use and the establishment of social and industrial relations characteristic of an “information society”, particularly in matters of cybersecurity, is also confirmed in Kazakhstan.

Nevertheless, since 1998, when Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 1998 No. 1384 “On Coordination of Activities for the Formation and Development of the National Information Infrastructure, Informatization Processes and Ensuring Information Security” was adopted, three new versions of the Laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Informatization” (2003, 2007 and 2015) have been adopted, along with several specialized laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan introducing corresponding amendments concerning electronic formats for presenting information (data), including issues relating to information and communication networks and “electronic government”.

Over the past period, electronic information resources and information systems have been introduced into economic circulation alongside other types of property assets, and the scope of their commercial use has expanded.

The field of automation of public services, the electronic commerce and electronic payments market are developing on the principles of ensuring the security of individuals, society and the state when using information and communication technologies, as well as conducting activities on the basis of uniform standards ensuring the reliability and manageability of informatization and communication facilities.

Since the establishment of information security arrangements, legal regimes for publicly accessible and confidential electronic information resources and systems have been differentiated, taking into account the nature of the information they contain, and the rights and obligations of their owners, proprietors and users with regard to their protection have been established.

The activities of government bodies and other entities in ensuring information security in the field of informatization and communications are carried out in accordance with their sectoral competence, as well as the goals and objectives of the relevant subject areas associated with the use of ICT (regulation of communications and information technologies, protection of personal data, protection of state secrets, counteraction to foreign technical intelligence activities, operational-search activities in communication networks, investigation of crimes committed using ICT, and others).

In general, in the Republic of Kazakhstan, the organizational, legal and technical foundations of the system of measures to ensure information security in the field of informatization and communications (cybersecurity) were developed and legislatively established as components of information security and ensuring the security of the information space and communications infrastructure in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On National Security”.

In recent years, various interrelated aspects of ensuring information security in the field of informatization and communications have been reflected and developed in the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences, the Laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On State Secrets”, “On Personal Data and Their Protection”, “On Electronic Documents and Electronic Digital Signatures”, “On Communications”, and a number of subordinate regulatory legal acts developed to implement the new version of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Informatization”, which entered into force on January 1, 2016.

A number of subordinate regulatory legal acts adopted recently have not yet been subject to extensive law enforcement practice. In particular, Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 20, 2016 No. 832 “On Approval of Uniform Requirements in the Field of Information and Communication Technologies and Information Security” (hereinafter referred to as the Uniform Requirements), which constitute a codification of legal and technical standards drawn from national and harmonized standards. The document describes in detail the procedures and rules for the use of information and communication technologies when processing types of information protected by law, and contains important provisions on ensuring the technological security of information infrastructure, information systems and resources, software and technical equipment at all stages of their life cycle.

At the legislative level, the functioning of the system for monitoring information security of the informatization facilities of “electronic government” has been regulated, including both state and non-state information systems integrated with government systems.

The Rules for Monitoring Information Security, Protection and Secure Functioning of the Informatization Facilities of “Electronic Government”, approved by Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 26, 2016 No. 66, establish the basic principles of interaction between interested parties in the event of technological failures or signs of computer attacks, as well as response algorithms for emerging information security events and incidents.

The Security Monitoring Center of “electronic government” identifies unresolved vulnerabilities on a daily basis and sends notifications to the owners of information systems that form part of its infrastructure so that appropriate measures can be taken. There is a positive trend in the number of vulnerabilities identified and the measures taken in response to them. Thus, 1,241 unresolved vulnerabilities were identified in 2014, 469 in 2015, and 355 in 2016.

Furthermore, Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 8, 2016 No. 529 approved the Rules and Criteria for Classifying Facilities as Critical Information and Communication Infrastructure Facilities among particularly important state and strategic facilities, as well as facilities in economic sectors of strategic importance.

Such facilities included in the list of critical information and communication infrastructure facilities are subject to the Uniform Requirements, as well as to the requirement to participate in joint activities provided for by law to ensure monitoring of their information security, protection and secure functioning, including the obligation to report information security incidents.

Procedures for commissioning information systems for industrial operation are being improved. In this regard, security measures for information systems have been differentiated depending on their classification, and the period during which an information system may remain in trial operation has been limited.

More than 500 certification assessments of state and non-state information systems integrated with government systems have been conducted for compliance with information security requirements. As a result, 199 certificates have been issued, which serve as the basis for commissioning such systems for industrial operation. The remaining information systems, in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Informatization”, must undergo certification by the end of 2018.

Since January 1, 2016, information systems of government bodies and non-state information systems integrated with government information systems at the trial operation stage have been subject to testing for compliance with information security requirements. During testing, source codes and security function settings are examined, network and server equipment is inspected, and load testing is carried out.

The results of testing are reflected in increased security and fault tolerance of information systems, improved software security of information systems, reduced impact of factors causing breaches of information security in information systems, and the introduction of mechanisms for monitoring and controlling the security of information systems.

The technical regulation system provides for confirmation of conformity of software and telecommunications equipment, including the determination of cases in which their mandatory certification is required when used in the public sector. For these purposes, a consolidated list of national and harmonized technical standards in the field of information security, information protection and information technology security is updated annually. Currently, this list contains 68 technical standards.

Thanks to the centralization of Internet connectivity through the Unified Internet Access Gateway of government bodies, threats of unauthorized access to and malicious impact on electronic information resources of government bodies have been significantly reduced. More than 180 million attacks of various levels are recorded and reflected on a daily basis.

A system of legal, organizational, technical and cryptographic measures for protecting state secrets processed using computer equipment has been established and is being improved.

The most sensitive information from the perspective of state security, when transmitted in electronic form, is transmitted exclusively through special-purpose telecommunications networks that are physically separated from the Internet and use cryptographic information protection tools.

Approaches to ensuring the security of communications infrastructure and public telecommunications networks are structured around a centralized telecommunications network management system, using the capabilities of backbone communications operators that implement the “electronic border” concept on their boundary equipment.

The national Internet segment contains more than 120,000 Internet resources in the .KZ and .ҚАЗ domains, which, in accordance with legislation, are physically hosted within the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan. In order to assist owners and users of information resources and systems in matters concerning the secure use of ICT, the national Computer Incident Response Service KZ-CERT has been operating since 2010. The Service is a member of a number of international organizations, including FIRST (Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams), TI (Trusted Introducer for Security and Incident Response Teams), and OIC-CERT (Organization of Islamic Cooperation Computer Emergency Response Teams).

The Service has concluded 20 memoranda of understanding and cooperation with relevant foreign organizations and has recorded and processed more than 66,000 information security incidents.

The first domestic companies specializing in instrumental security audits (penetration testing) for compliance with information security requirements have appeared in the Kazakhstani market. These companies specialize in investigating the circumstances, causes and conditions of information security incidents, as well as in the technical examination of malicious software. The first domestic antivirus protection products have been developed.

A number of national companies and private organizations have technical event and technological process monitoring units that provide round-the-clock duty coverage to ensure prompt response to emergency situations.

The purposes of collecting and processing citizens’ personal data in electronic form, as well as the procedure and measures for their protection, have been defined by law. Legislation regulates both the procedures for collecting such data exclusively with citizens’ consent and their destruction at the request of citizens by personal data operators, as well as the conditions for secure storage of personal data within the country and their cross-border transfer.

Security requirements for banking information systems are ensured by regulatory legal acts of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan, taking into account sectoral and international requirements for information system security.

The new version of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, in force since 2014, provides for a separate chapter dedicated to crimes committed in the field of informatization and communications. Taking into account qualifying circumstances, it contains 38 elements of crimes against electronic information resources and systems or telecommunications networks.

The Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences also contains a number of administrative offences for which administrative liability measures are предусмотрed, including in respect of officials who fail to perform their duties to ensure information security, in the form of violations of requirements governing the operation of electronic information resource protection tools, failure to comply with the Uniform Requirements, and failure by owners or proprietors of information systems containing personal data to take measures to protect such data, or improper implementation of such measures.

At present, the curricula for the specialty “Information Security Systems”, in addition to applied disciplines, include subjects that develop knowledge and skills in applied programming of microprocessor systems and devices, computer-aided design and development of radio-electronic devices used in integrated security systems.

Leading technical higher education institutions in the country teach the following disciplines: “Applied Engineering Software”, “Microprocessors and Microprocessor Systems”, and “Programming and Implementation of Embedded Systems”.

A practice of conducting analytical research, scientific research and experimental design work, and organizing specialized conferences and seminars is emerging, reflecting the growing interest of society, academic circles and informatization entities in various aspects of information security activities.

A study conducted by the International Telecommunication Union entitled “Global Cybersecurity Index” (hereinafter referred to as the Global Cybersecurity Index), which assesses the legal, technical and organizational readiness and potential of 195 countries, recorded Kazakhstan in 23rd place among 29 groups of countries, with an index of 0.176.

Key Problems

1. In the Republic of Kazakhstan, between 2010 and 2016, Internet user penetration increased from 36.1% to 75%, while the number of mobile Internet users, which stood at 3 million 694 thousand, almost tripled, reaching 10 million 567 thousand. Such an exponential increase in the number of Internet users increases the criticality of technical equipment and makes the consequences of failures or malicious interference more significant.

The prevalence of malicious software for personal computers and mobile devices is increasing along with the number of their users. At the same time, the overwhelming majority of users do not use specialized software to protect their personal computers, smartphones and tablets.

This factor is exploited by “hackers”, resulting in an increase every day in the number of attacks aimed at infecting subscriber devices with malicious software.

While the number of subscriber devices connected to the Internet is increasing and most users continue to ignore measures of “digital hygiene” in relation to themselves and their devices, the concept of the “Internet of Things” only exacerbates the problem of their secure use.

Whereas traditional electronic devices, such as personal computers and laptops, have the capability to install and update antivirus software, users of the “Internet of Things” often do not even know how to ensure the security of their operation.

Such devices are, in principle, still being developed without taking technological risks into account, making them potential components of malicious networks (“botnets”) used to carry out various network attacks aimed at depriving information systems of availability and causing denial of service for legitimate users when information and communication services are provided.

Neglecting security considerations when using Internet resources and social networks leads to an increased risk to privacy, unauthorized use or modification of publicly available personal data, as well as disclosure of personal data subject to restricted access or its extraterritorial accessibility to criminal communities or intelligence agencies when such data is stored in other countries.

Low legal awareness of information security issues and the lack of established demand for improving such awareness among the population, ICT sector employees and heads of organizations create favorable conditions for the development of offences and crimes in the information sphere.

Lack of knowledge about legal restrictions creates an illusion that actions violating the rights and freedoms of other citizens, the rights of holders of copyright and related rights to software products, and actions affecting the functioning of information resources are permissible.

Thus, the low level of digital literacy among end users in matters of personal data protection, combined with the absence of basic knowledge of general methods of distributing malicious computer programs and software products (especially “phishing” pages imitating fake online stores and banks, the distribution of viral and “Trojan” programs through “hacked” websites, and the downloading of unlicensed (“pirated”) software), results in thousands of cases in which citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan become victims, while the technical devices belonging to them become instruments of unlawful use of ICT.

2. Insufficient awareness of information protection methods and inadequate provision of information security systems in small and medium-sized businesses, including those engaged in the provision of information and communication services, which often cannot even assess the condition of their own information and communication infrastructure, result in a large number of unanalyzed information security events and incidents, making it difficult both to prevent technological vulnerabilities and to combat criminals who use ICT as a means of committing crimes.

Furthermore, such business entities pose a threat to other entities, primarily large enterprises or government bodies and organizations with which they work as partners or contractors.

At the same time, large private-sector and financial-sector entities tend to rely exclusively on their own capabilities, underestimating the importance of joint efforts and sectoral initiatives in creating a truly secure operational environment.

Meanwhile, low employer interest and the absence of professional competition are demotivating factors for the proactive self-development of practicing information security specialists and also create prerequisites for their involvement in illegal activities.

3. The existing Kazakhstani model of school, specialized secondary, higher and postgraduate education in the field of ICT, including specialization in information security, requires constant and thorough analysis by all interested parties (including the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan, higher education institutions and potential employers) in terms of its compliance with the current needs of society and trends in ensuring the secure development of information technologies, given the dynamic development of this field.

In particular, educational and professional standards, specialty classifiers, disciplines, their content and learning outcomes require periodic revision. There is a need to develop a mechanism that would allow a more flexible response to contemporary challenges in the field of ICT. Given that knowledge in this field quickly becomes outdated, periodic confirmation of specialists’ qualifications is required.

Of the 93 higher education institutions that train specialists in the field of ICT, only 7 train specialists in the specialty “Information Security Systems”. Of the 32,439 students enrolled in the above-mentioned higher education institutions in 2015–2016, only 362 (1.1%) studied in the specialty “Information Security Systems”, of whom 226 were enrolled under the state educational order. The planned number of graduates in 2016 was 85.

In the 2016–2017 academic year, 40 state-funded places were allocated for training specialists in the specialty “Information Security Systems”, compared with 60 places in the 2014–2015 academic year and 60 places in the 2015–2016 academic year.

In this regard, increased attention will be paid to career guidance activities for the specialty “Information Security Systems”, including drawing applicants’ attention to the relevance of this specialty and the demand for specialists in this field within the industry.

The admission of applicants to study in the specialty “Information Security Systems” on a fee-paying basis is insufficiently promoted and advertised. Specialized disciplines lack the content necessary for graduates to apply their knowledge in special state bodies after completing their studies.

Educational programs do not take into account the requirements for knowledge, abilities and skills set out in the professional standard “Information Security Specialist”, approved by the National Chamber of Entrepreneurs “Atameken” and based on the sectoral qualifications framework.

As a consequence, there is a shortage of information security specialists in the ICT sector, both in the public and private sectors. Thus, staffing levels in central government bodies amount to only 25%, and in local government bodies to 6%.

4. The domestic IT industry does not make a significant practical contribution to the national economy diversification program (less than 5 percent of the products used in the public sector are of Kazakhstani origin), and a culture of cybersecurity, including a production culture in the development and use of products, is not always a determining factor.

Despite the high level of informatization achieved in public administration, including defense and security, and the widespread use of ICT in various areas of individual and public life, Kazakhstan, as a country, still imports (borrows) not only IT technologies but also ready-made software products, including information security products in the field of informatization and communications. This indicates, on the one hand, pressure from IT industry giants and, on the other, insufficient efforts and measures to rationally replace such products by relying on domestic capabilities in critically important areas of development on which state security depends.

5. Measures related to the automation of government functions and the provision of public services in electronic form, as well as the ongoing digitalization of access to information about the activities of government bodies, entail certain risks.

Low-quality services and applications provided to citizens and private organizations within the framework of “electronic government”, including machine-readable open data, may result in violations of the rights and legitimate interests of citizens.

Deviations from established technical standards caused by a low level of production and operational culture, negligence and carelessness on the part of customers and developers of solutions at the development stage, and the principle of residual financing for information system protection and security monitoring systems entail high risks of technological failures.

Untimely elimination by information system owners of software vulnerabilities significantly increases the threats of unauthorized access.

The volume of data processed in the public and private sectors is growing, leading to the need to develop new forms of data storage. At the same time, such data storage methods as cloud storage or the use of online services are often based by operators and service providers on non-transparent or non-standardized solutions, including from the perspective of data security. Moreover, harmonized standards differ significantly from their original sources due to the poor quality of their translation and adaptation.

The situation is exacerbated by the possibility of deliberately introducing undeclared functions (so-called “backdoors”) into software and telecommunications equipment, which cannot always be detected during certification, the elimination of vulnerabilities during operation, or recognized by antivirus programs and may therefore be used to disrupt the operation of information systems and telecommunications networks.

6. The transnational and cross-border nature of many ICT products and the international interconnectedness of public telecommunications networks are exploited by criminals to commit unlawful acts against users and operators of ICT services and owners of Internet resources hosted in the national segment, as well as information systems interacting with the Internet.

The high latency of detection and the frequently international nature of such crimes increase their public danger. The situation is exacerbated by entrenched stereotypes in society concerning the impunity of so-called “cybercrime”, the alleged uselessness of state measures to strengthen the sphere of secure ICT use, and the limited capabilities of law enforcement agencies to bring those responsible for high-tech crimes to justice, despite the developed criminal law institutions in the field of information security.

7. The militarization of the ICT sphere promoted by certain countries, the difficulties in proving the involvement of states in using ICT in violation of the principles of international law, largely caused by the spontaneously established nature of the existing international Internet governance system, and the continuing digital divide between countries impede the formation of reliable international legal instruments within the international community to prevent the military use of advances in informatization and telecommunications.

At the same time, in essence, the arsenal used for military purposes does not differ from the arsenal of software and hardware tools used by cybercrime, as evidenced by numerous cases of ICT being used for intelligence, subversive and other purposes that threaten the maintenance of international peace and security.

Thus, Kazakhstan faces the following serious cybersecurity threats:

- low legal awareness of the population, ICT sector employees and heads of organizations regarding information security issues;

- violations by state and non-state informatization entities and users of ICT services of established requirements, technical standards and regulations governing the collection, processing, storage and transmission of information in electronic form;

- unintentional personnel errors and technological failures that adversely affect information systems, software and other elements of information and communication infrastructure;

- actions by international criminal groups, communities and individuals involving theft in the financial and banking sector, and malicious interference aimed at disrupting the operation of automated control systems for technological processes in industry, energy, communications and the provision of information and communication services;

- activities of political, economic and terrorist organizations, as well as intelligence and special services of foreign states, directed against the interests of the Republic of Kazakhstan through intelligence and subversive activities targeting information and communication infrastructure.

3. International Experience

The term “cybersecurity” and its derivatives (cyberspace, cyber protection, cyberattacks, cyber aggression and others) do not have a single universally recognized legal definition at the international level.

At the same time, a number of documents exist at the UN level, such as the Global Cybersecurity Agenda of the International Telecommunication Union and the UN General Assembly Resolution “Creation of a Global Culture of Cybersecurity and Assessment of National Efforts to Protect Critical Information Infrastructures”, which contain approaches to understanding cybersecurity that cover the secure use of information and communication technologies in matters concerning (1) privacy, (2) confidentiality, integrity and availability of information in electronic form, and (3) protection of critical information and communication infrastructure interacting with the Internet (including information systems, hardware and software complexes, telecommunications systems, telecommunications networks, information protection systems and software) against malicious interference through software and hardware methods.

At the same time, many countries do not address in their policy documents issues concerning protection against harmful or illegal information disseminated through ICT within the context of cybersecurity, due to concerns about excessively restricting the right to access and freely disseminate information.

Certain countries consider, through the lens of cybersecurity, only the uncontrolled dissemination on the Internet, as a global system of interconnected telecommunications networks and computing resources, of electronic materials promoting terrorism, child pornography and certain types of illegal information, primarily due to the technical difficulty of establishing the source of dissemination of such information.

At the same time, some countries, when assessing threats and the measures taken to counter them, adhere to the concept of information security as applicable to all aspects of ICT use, developing an appropriate model of legal regulation and public administration.

For example, Norway’s strategy notes that new services and devices place very high demands on the competence of ordinary users. However, the main responsibility for ensuring the security of information, systems and networks rests with the owner or operator. Such activities must form part of daily operations and be financed alongside current operating expenses. The cost of measures to promote information security must be proportionate to the risk assessment in individual areas of governance (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.735).

Estonia attaches particular importance to the security of information systems. The recommended measures are civilian in nature and are based on legal regulation, education and cooperation (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.706).

Finland’s strategy is based on an understanding of cybersecurity as an economic issue closely linked to the development of Finnish information society (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.618).

Slovakia considers information security to be a necessary condition for the normal functioning and development of society. Therefore, the objective of its strategy is to serve as a solid foundation for information protection. The strategy is aimed both at preventing threats and at ensuring preparedness and resilience of the means used to prevent them (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.618).

The key objectives of the cybersecurity strategy of the Czech Republic include protecting information and communication systems against the vulnerabilities to which they are exposed and reducing potential damage caused by attacks on such systems. The strategy primarily focuses on issues of free access to information services, and the integrity and confidentiality of data in the Czech Republic (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.500).

France aims to ensure that information systems are capable of withstanding events that may adversely affect the availability, integrity and confidentiality of information, emphasizing technical information protection tools, the fight against cybercrime and the establishment of cyber protection (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.588).

Germany’s strategy lays the foundation for the security of critical information systems. Germany focuses on preventing and prosecuting cyberattacks, as well as IT equipment failures caused by accidental factors. Germany’s Cybersecurity Strategy defines the level of cybersecurity as the sum of all national and international measures adopted to protect and provide access to information and communications, ensure the integrity, authenticity and confidentiality of data in cyberspace, and strengthen German technological sovereignty and economic potential across the entire range of key strategic IT competencies (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.706).

Lithuania’s Electronic Information Security Development Program focuses on defining objectives and measures aimed at ensuring electronic information security, developing electronic information circulation, and ensuring its confidentiality, availability and integrity in cyberspace. In addition, Lithuania’s strategy is aimed at protecting personal data, telecommunications networks, information systems and critical infrastructure against security breaches and cyberattacks originating from outside the “electronic perimeter” (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.441).

The Netherlands, on the one hand, seeks secure and reliable information and communication systems, concerned about serious disruptions in such systems, while, on the other hand, recognizing the need for freedom and openness of the Internet environment. The strategy provides the following definition of cybersecurity: “Cybersecurity is protection against disruptions and improper use of information and telecommunications systems. Disruptions and improper use may adversely affect the availability and reliability of information and telecommunications systems and jeopardize the confidentiality and integrity of information stored in such systems” (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.676).

Austria’s ICT Security Strategy consists in extending integrated security approaches implemented within the “electronic government” system to other areas, including those that must be established at the transnational level in order to ensure the long-term viability of Austria’s economy (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.676).

The United Kingdom’s approach is aimed at developing cybersecurity. Its objective is to make the United Kingdom the leading country in innovation, investment and quality of services in the field of information and telecommunications technologies, thereby fully benefiting from all the advantages and opportunities of cyberspace. Risks such as cyberattacks by criminals, terrorists and other states must be eliminated in order to make cyberspace safe for citizens and the economy (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.706).

Switzerland’s National Strategy emphasizes the need to reduce the influence of the prevailing interests of several countries participating in the Internet industry and considers the application of the measures described therein to take place “in peacetime, thereby explicitly excluding wars”.

At the same time, resilient military infrastructure is considered an important element of the strategic reserve for other entities in the event of a full-scale crisis. Since the current legislation in various sectors reflects cyber-related aspects of the existing tasks and responsibilities of the public and private sectors, addressing cybersecurity issues through a single special cyber law in Switzerland is considered unsuitable, as “the existing legislation must continuously adapt to changes” (the Global Cybersecurity Index is 0.353).

Thus, the national understanding of cybersecurity and key priorities differs significantly from country to country.

As a consequence, approaches to developing cybersecurity strategies also differ. Nevertheless, policy documents covering cybersecurity issues generally provide for:

- establishing a state governance system in the field of cybersecurity;

- defining an appropriate mechanism (primarily public-private partnership) enabling private and public stakeholders to discuss issues concerning the security of national information infrastructures;

- defining the necessary security policy and regulatory mechanisms, clearly establishing the roles, rights and responsibilities of the public and private sectors (for example, mandatory reporting of security incidents, basic security measures and guidelines for action, and new standards for material and technical support).

As global experience demonstrates, it is impossible to achieve complete protection against software errors or information security incidents. However, it is vital, through conscious and responsible behavior, to reduce their frequency and likelihood and ensure a high speed of restoring the operability of information systems and resources in order to prevent destructive consequences.

In many countries, coordination in this field is largely structured around a civilian regulator in the field of information technology and communications (the Korea Internet & Security Agency (KISA) in Korea, the Information Security Center of the Ministry of Information Technologies in the Republic of Uzbekistan, etc.), or an authority responsible for information protection and security (the Federal Office for Information Security – Germany; the National Cybersecurity Agency of France under the Ministry of Defense; the National Cyber and Information Security Agency of the Czech Republic; the Federal Security Service and the Federal Service for Technical and Export Control of the Russian Federation; the Operational and Analytical Center under the President of the Republic of Belarus; the State Service of Special Communications and Information Protection of Ukraine). In the European Union, the regulator in this field is the European Union Agency for Cybersecurity.

4. Goals, Objectives, Expected Results and Implementation Period

The goals of the Concept are to achieve and maintain a level of protection of electronic information resources, information systems and information and communication infrastructure against external and internal threats that ensures the sustainable development of the Republic of Kazakhstan in conditions of global competition.

Objectives of the Concept:

1. Creating the necessary conditions for increasing awareness of threats, developing human capital and the potential of the domestic ICT industry to create software products and cybersecurity systems aimed at blocking and suppressing malicious software and hardware interference, as well as secure telecommunications equipment.

2. Improving law enforcement practice, the methodological framework, and the regulatory, legal, organizational and technical support for the secure use of ICT within the national information protection system and the security of automated control systems for technological processes.

3. Creating a highly adaptive and integrated system of public administration of information security in the field of informatization and communications with respect to the entire national information and communication infrastructure.

Expected Results:

1) Kazakhstan’s Global Cybersecurity Index will reach 0.200 by 2017, 0.300 by 2018, 0.400 by 2019, 0.500 by 2020, 0.550 by 2021, and 0.600 by 2022;

2) increased awareness of information security threats compared with the 2018 baseline period: by 5% in 2019, by 10% in 2020, by 15% in 2021, and by 20% in 2022;

3) the number of retrained information security specialists will be 300 in 2018, 500 in 2019, 600 in 2020, 700 in 2021, and 800 in 2022;

4) an increase in the share of domestic software products in the field of informatization and communications used in the public and quasi-public sectors compared with the 2017 baseline period: by 10% in 2018, by 20% in 2019, by 30% in 2020, by 40% in 2021, and by 50% in 2022;

5) the share of domestic security certificates used for encrypted data transmission by Internet resources with the .KZ and .ҚАЗ domains will amount to 20% in 2018, 40% in 2019, 60% in 2020, 80% in 2021, and 100% in 2022;

6) the share of information systems of government bodies, non-state information systems integrated with government systems, and information systems of critical information and communication infrastructure facilities connected to information security monitoring centers will amount to 20% in 2018, 40% in 2019, 60% in 2020, 80% in 2021, and 100% by 2022.

The implementation period of the Concept comprises two stages:

1) the first stage: 2017–2018;

2) the second stage: 2019–2022.

During the first stage, the following will be achieved:

- the development of comprehensive law enforcement practice concerning compliance with the already established requirements in the field of information security, based on the results of which the necessary amendments to legislation will be introduced;

- a review of educational programs and professional standards, an increase in the number and quality of specialists trained in information security, and the provision of advanced training for existing employees engaged in this field;

- the establishment of an effective framework for interaction and cooperation between industry and science in developing domestic solutions, which will create a foundation for the development of national and sectoral information security operations centers, thereby enabling the following during the second stage:

- key participation of Kazakhstani IT companies in providing the national information and communication infrastructure with information security systems;

- providing domestic electronic industry enterprises with orders for the acquisition by government bodies and the quasi-public sector of telecommunications equipment manufactured and certified within the country for compliance with information security requirements.

5. Basic Principles and Approaches

Basic Principles:

1) observance of the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of individuals, as well as the rights and legitimate interests of legal entities;

2) ensuring the security of individuals, society and the state when using information and communication technologies;

3) conducting informatization activities within the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the basis of uniform standards ensuring the reliability and manageability of informatization facilities;

4) clear delineation of the powers of government bodies;

5) continuous monitoring of the information security of information and communication infrastructure facilities;

6) integration of the national security system with international security systems.

To implement the objective of creating the necessary conditions for increasing awareness of threats, developing human capital and the potential of the domestic ICT industry to create software products, information security systems and telecommunications equipment resistant to malicious software and hardware interference, the following is proposed:

To develop in society a stable understanding of “cyber hygiene” and instill a high level of production culture in the development and use of ICT at all stages of the life cycle of software products, information systems, software, technological platforms, information and network infrastructure, and supporting equipment.

To apply training sessions and educational practices on personal data protection and privacy among underage Internet users and their parents.

For the professional development of employees responsible for the state of information security in government bodies and the standardization of the measures they take, to appropriately adapt professional standards and expand requirements for practical skills and technical knowledge that improve protection profiles and parameters for monitoring the security of information resources and systems.

To assign a key role in implementing educational and research objectives in the field of information security to higher education institutions in Kazakhstan, which will expand the technical capabilities of special state bodies in ensuring state security and improve the level of analytical and research support for activities undertaken to implement the Concept.

To address the objectives of establishing and maintaining a high level of professional competence and technical readiness to counter cybercrime by involving research organizations in assisting law enforcement agencies in investigating the most complex cybercrimes.

To increase Kazakhstan’s potential in scientific, scientific and technical, and educational activities, it is necessary to focus on scientific research and experimental design work, ensure a close link between the educational process and the production activities of electronic industry enterprises, and bring educational programs into line with sectoral professional standards and the current level of technological development.

To give priority to research and the domestic school of applied mathematics, the development of cryptographic information protection tools, cryptology, developments in programmable logic integrated circuits, quantum cryptography and the development of protection for information transmission, processing and storage systems, as well as information security systems.

To overcome the problem of insufficient demand for domestic developments, since cybersecurity ultimately depends on the level of development of the domestic IT industry and electronic industry. One of the reasons for this is the absence of a mandatory requirement to give priority to the use of their products in government bodies.

To establish measures to support them, including through the promotion of public-private partnerships and increased competitiveness. The criteria should include compliance with localization requirements for development and technical support, the supplier’s possession of exclusive intellectual property rights to the design and technical documentation of software products and telecommunications equipment, as well as the availability of the scientific and production facilities necessary to organize manufacturing, warranty and post-warranty servicing.

To conduct, jointly with industry representatives, continuous analysis of software and telecommunications equipment purchased by government bodies and the quasi-public sector in order to identify prospects for replacing them with trusted domestic or foreign products that have undergone mandatory certification procedures for compliance with information security requirements.

To establish a Cybersecurity Council under the authorized body for information security, one of whose main tasks should be to consider current cybersecurity issues, maintain policy documents and the regulatory framework in an up-to-date state, facilitate the priority use of products from the domestic electronic and software industries, and conduct public assessments of socially significant IT projects.

To establish ongoing direct dialogue with the country's leading companies and enterprises, educational institutions and scientific research organizations, which will make it possible to combine efforts and introduce a systematic and comprehensive approach to addressing cybersecurity issues in the most significant areas of ICT use.

In addition to monitoring and analyzing the security of government information systems and resources and assisting citizens in the secure use of ICT, to identify the promotion of “cyber hygiene” measures as an additional priority of the national Computer Incident Response Service KZ-CERT.

Taking into account their economic capabilities, owners and proprietors of private information systems should strive to follow standardized processes for the development, creation, testing and operation of information systems, providing for the necessary information security measures. Technical standards and other regulatory and technical documents that can serve as the necessary guidelines for this purpose are available.

To address the objective of improving law enforcement practice, the methodological framework, and the regulatory, legal, organizational and technical support for the secure use of ICT within the national information protection system and the security of automated control systems for technological processes, the following is proposed:

Strict compliance with the requirements already established by legislation and technical standards for ensuring information security in the public sector, as well as the prompt introduction of necessary amendments thereto, taking into account the pace of technological development without compromising cybersecurity.

Ensuring compliance with established requirements through effective state control measures.

For a comprehensive assessment of the security of informatization facilities, taking into account the nature of the activities of cybercriminals and foreign technical computer intelligence agencies, which rely on complacency and negligence on the part of owners of information resources and systems, it is necessary to strive for continuous monitoring of the condition of information systems and resources using technical security monitoring tools and to conduct activities to identify information leakage channels (vulnerabilities, viruses, Trojan programs, undeclared functions and implanted malicious components).

This approach will make it possible to preserve the ability to perform government functions in the event of technological or social emergencies caused by information security incidents threatening national and public security and, in the event of a state of emergency or martial law, to ensure the possibility of using resilient information and communication infrastructure belonging to the national security forces in the interests of the functioning of critical information and communication infrastructure facilities.

Alongside establishing procedures for working with critical information and communication infrastructure facilities among strategic and particularly important state facilities and facilities in strategic sectors of the economy, to revise the criteria for classifying facilities as critical information and communication infrastructure facilities, with the possibility of including facilities focused on providing information and communication services to the population.

To extend preventive and precautionary measures not only to government bodies and owners of private information systems integrated with government systems, but also to owners of industrial enterprises, financial organizations and other categories of economic facilities with automated technological processes, the disruption of which may adversely affect the country's economic development.

On the basis of the Uniform Requirements and the existing Rules for Monitoring Information Security, Protection and Secure Functioning of the Informatization Facilities of “Electronic Government”, to provide for the development of policy documents serving as guidelines not only for the public sector but also for privately owned facilities, in order to effectively localize and prevent the realization of threats on a nationwide scale.

In order to maintain a high level of trust among citizens and businesses in the services provided by government bodies, to develop, at the legislative level, information security measures for software product providers, communications service providers and other information and communication infrastructure providers, to be specified in agreements, tender documentation and technical specifications for purchased products and solutions, including mandatory technical support for purchased goods and services for a period of at least three years.

To provide for requirements in the field of security of automated control systems for technological processes and telecommunications equipment used in public telecommunications networks. Particular attention should be paid to infrastructure in public life-support systems, the fuel and energy sector, communications infrastructure and other areas.

To substantially deepen the understanding of the resilience of elements of the critical infrastructure of the national Internet segment and data processing centers (data centers), as well as hardware and software complexes ensuring the functioning of publicly accessible electronic information resources (Internet resources).

Ensuring reliable identification, authentication and registration of user actions, combined with measures to ensure the confidentiality of their personal data, reduces the risk of the most common threats related to user authenticity in information systems and publicly accessible electronic resources, including hardware and software complexes of electronic mass media. This will make it possible to eliminate falsification in the national segment in the fields of electronic commerce, electronic payments, banking activities and other information and communication services provided through Internet resources.

To create a highly adaptive and integrated system of public administration of information security in the field of informatization and communications with respect to the entire national information and communication infrastructure, the following is proposed:

Government bodies and service providers should adopt a risk-based approach to security, giving priority to efforts that ensure the highest possible level of reliability of information systems being developed in normal and emergency operating modes and their resilience to deliberate disruptions.

To expand interaction between departmental and sectoral information security monitoring and incident response structures in order to assist owners of information resources and systems and provide mutual notification of emerging threats. Their participants must regard security considerations as an essential element in the planning, design, development and operation of sectoral information systems and networks and become key reference points determining the resilience of the country's entire information and communication infrastructure.

The specialization of information security incident response services will make it possible to expand the range of organizations and experts involved, thereby contributing to the professional development of employees engaged in information security, taking into account sector-specific characteristics, and facilitating the expansion of the information security audit services market for small businesses, which often do not have the opportunity to employ qualified IT and information security specialists.

Computer attacks launched from foreign cyberspace should be prevented to the maximum extent possible at the “electronic border” – the virtual perimeter of the country.

Policy documents governing the Unified Telecommunications Network of the Republic of Kazakhstan should be updated, taking into account its growing vulnerability as a result of the convergence of telecommunications networks and information and communication networks, as well as the need to reduce the volume of malicious traffic and ensure the timely blocking by communications operators of abnormal network activity.

To create conditions for effectively combating cybercrime by continuously improving the qualifications of personnel in specialized units and expanding the range of technical tools for recording and forensic examination of “digital” evidence.

Ensuring cybersecurity is the responsibility of all entities whose activities involve the use of ICT. Therefore, cooperation aimed at ensuring information security will contribute to protecting the interests of all stakeholders.

In order to combine efforts with the participation of the scientific community and the private sector, to prepare the establishment of a National Information Security Coordination Center, which will process information online regarding the security status of the “electronic border” and the most important components of the national information infrastructure, and ensure information exchange, thereby making it possible to:

- provide citizens and businesses with access to qualified assessments of information security threats and additional knowledge on how to reduce the negative impact of threats associated with the exploitation of vulnerabilities in software and information and telecommunications systems;

- enable the Ministry of Internal Affairs to reduce the number of crimes committed using information technologies, which are largely latent in nature, and ensure a high crime detection rate;

- enable government bodies to maintain a high level of fault tolerance, prevent technological failures and promptly eliminate their consequences in the infrastructure forming part of “electronic government” and other government information systems and resources;

- enable owners of critical information and communication infrastructure facilities to receive timely information about possible impacts on the security of their automated control systems for technological processes;

- enable the National Bank and second-tier banks to receive additional information about current threats to the financial and banking system.

The Ministry of Defense, within the framework of developing the country's military organization, shall prepare proposals for establishing a system for effectively protecting departmental information resources, forecasting and promptly identifying computer attacks, and assessing and classifying them in terms of threats to the military security of the state.

At the foreign policy and foreign economic levels, to consistently promote the national interests of the Republic of Kazakhstan aimed at overcoming the “digital” divide between members of the international community in the information sphere, identifying as priorities the implementation of initiatives to strengthen the international information security system on the basis of the norms and principles of international law.

Within the framework of bilateral and multilateral diplomacy, to continue strengthening Kazakhstan’s role as a strong and consistent partner opposing the use of ICT for military purposes, following a course of openness and strengthening confidence-building measures in the field of international information security, while unconditionally respecting the sovereign equality of states in choosing their paths of technological development. The key platforms for dialogue should be international, regional and subregional organizations (the UN, SCO, EAEU, CSTO, CIS, etc.), with further promotion of their initiatives in various international formats.

Coordinated implementation of the “Cyber Shield of Kazakhstan” Concept will significantly improve Kazakhstan’s position in the Global Cybersecurity Index and enable it to achieve an index of 0.600 by 2022.

Necessary Resources

Implementation of the Concept in 2017–2022 will be financed from the state budget within the framework of the budget programs of the interested government bodies and the resources provided for in the Implementation Plan of the “Digital Kazakhstan 2020” State Program.

6. List of Regulatory Legal Acts through Which the Concept Is Intended to Be Implemented

During the implementation period of this Concept, the established goals and objectives are intended to be achieved through the following regulatory legal acts:

1. Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 3, 2014.

2. Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences dated July 5, 2014.

3. Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated October 29, 2015.

4. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 15, 1994 “On Operational-Search Activities”.

5. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 31, 1995 “On Banks and Banking Activities in the Republic of Kazakhstan”.

6. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 7, 2003 “On Electronic Documents and Electronic Digital Signatures”.

7. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2004 “On Communications”.

8. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 27, 2007 “On Education”.

9. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated February 18, 2011 “On Science”.

10. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 6, 2012 “On National Security of the Republic of Kazakhstan”.

11. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 21, 2013 “On Personal Data and Their Protection”.

12. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated April 11, 2014 “On Civil Protection”.

13. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 16, 2014 “On Permits and Notifications”.

14. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 24, 2015 “On Informatization”.

15. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 4, 2015 “On Public Procurement”.

16. Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 8, 2013 No. 464 “On the State Program ‘Information Kazakhstan – 2020’ and on Amendments to Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 19, 2010 No. 957 ‘On Approval of the List of State Programs’”.

17. Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 23, 2012 No. 1080 “On Approval of State Compulsory Education Standards for the Corresponding Levels of Education”.

18. Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 23, 2016 No. 298 “On Approval of the Rules for Conducting Certification of an Information System, the Information and Communication Platform of ‘Electronic Government’, and a Government Body’s Internet Resource for Compliance with Information Security Requirements”.

19. Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 8, 2016 No. 529 “On Approval of the Rules and Criteria for Classifying Information and Communication Infrastructure Facilities as Critical Information and Communication Infrastructure Facilities”.

20. Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 20, 2016 No. 832 “On Approval of Uniform Requirements in the Field of Information and Communication Technologies and Information Security”.

21. Order of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 29, 2015 No. 66 “On Approval of the Uniform Rules for Interaction and Centralized Management of Telecommunications Networks”.

22. Order of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 25, 2015 No. 1240 “On Approval of the Rules for Issuing a Security Certificate”.

23. Order of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 25, 2015 No. 1241 “On Approval of the Rules for Applying a Security Certificate”.

24. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 25, 2016 No. 60 “On Approval of the Rules for Interaction between Government Bodies on Issues of Compliance with the Legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Telecommunications Networks”.

25. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 26, 2016 No. 66 “On Approval of the Rules for Monitoring Information Security, Protection and Secure Functioning of the Informatization Facilities of ‘Electronic Government’”.

26. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 26, 2016 No. 63 “On Approval of the Methodology and Rules for Testing a Service Software Product, the Information and Communication Platform of ‘Electronic Government’, a Government Body’s Internet Resource and an Information System for Compliance with Information Security Requirements”.

27. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 26, 2016 No. 67 “On Approval of the Rules for Providing Internet Access Services at Public Internet Access Points”.

28. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 26, 2016 No. 65 “On Approval of the Rules for Connecting the Networks of Long-Distance and International Communications Operators to the Internet Traffic Exchange Point”.

29. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 28, 2016 No. 108 “On Approval of the Methodology for Conducting Certification Assessments of an Information System, the Information and Communication Platform of ‘Electronic Government’, and a Government Body’s Internet Resource for Compliance with Information Security Requirements”.

30. Order of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 28, 2016 No. 118 “On Approval of the Rules for Registration, Use and Allocation of Domain Names in the Space of the Kazakhstani Internet Segment”.

Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Opinion Application Opinion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Program Charter Statute Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Program Rules Address