On Approval of the Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030
Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 29, 2023 No. 1050.
The Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan HEREBY RESOLVES:
1. To approve the attached Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030 (hereinafter referred to as the Concept).
Note. Paragraph 1 – as amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 14, 2026 No. 821.
2. Central state and local executive bodies, and other organizations (upon agreement), responsible for the implementation of the Concept shall:
1) take the necessary measures to implement the Concept;
2) ensure the timely implementation of the Action Plan for the implementation of the Concept;
3) submit information on the progress of implementation of the Concept to the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan no later than April 15 of the year following the reporting year.
3. The Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall, no later than May 1 of the year following the reporting year, submit a report on the implementation of the Concept to the authorized body for state and strategic planning of the Republic of Kazakhstan, and also publish it, signed by the first head, on its Internet resource (except for information with restricted access).
4. Control over the implementation of this Resolution shall be entrusted to the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
5. This Resolution shall enter into force on the date of its signing.
Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan
A. Smailov
Approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 29, 2023 No. 1050
Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030
Note. The Concept – as amended by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 14, 2026 No. 821.
Section 1. Passport.
Section 2. Analysis of the Current Situation.
Section 3. Review of International Experience.
Section 4. Vision for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety.
Section 5. Basic Principles and Approaches to Development.
Area 1. Human Capital Development.
1.1. Measures to Improve the Quality of Technical and Vocational Education.
1.2. Measures to Develop the National Qualifications System.
1.3. Measures to Encourage Enterprises to Improve the Competencies of Their Employees and Internal Mobility.
Area 2. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs.
2.1. Creation of Quality Jobs in the Mining Industry.
2.2. Creation of Quality Jobs in the Manufacturing Industry.
2.3. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs in the Construction and Transport Industries.
2.4. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs in Agriculture, Trade and Services.
2.5. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs Taking into Account Macro-Regions.
Area 3. Creating Conditions for an Effective Link between the Economy and the Human Capital Development System to Match Supply and Demand.
3.1. Restructuring the Operations of Labour Mobility Centres and Further Improving the Digital Labour Market Ecosystem.
3.2. Formalization of Platform Employment.
3.3. Increasing Labour Market Inclusiveness.
Area 4. Ensuring Occupational Safety.
4.1. Modernization of the National Occupational Safety and Health Management System Based on a Risk-Oriented Approach.
4.2. Economic Incentives for Measures to Reduce Occupational Risk.
4.3. Development of Professional Competencies and Scientific Potential in the Field of Occupational Safety and Health.
4.4. Improving the Effectiveness of Control and Monitoring in the Field of Occupational Safety and Health.
Area 5. Ensuring State Policy in the Field of Industrial Safety.
5.1. Development of Regulatory Policy in the Field of Industrial Safety.
5.2. Digital Transformation of Industrial Safety.
5.3. Resource Provision for Industrial Safety.
Section 6. Target Indicators and Expected Results.
Section 7. Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept (Appendix to this Concept).
Section 1. Passport
1. Name
Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030.
2. Grounds for Development
1. Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 30, 2024 No. 611 "On Approval of the National Development Plan of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2029 and Declaring Certain Decrees of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan Invalid".
2. Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 16, 2023 No. 353 "On Measures for the Implementation of the Address of the Head of State to the People of Kazakhstan dated September 1, 2023, 'Economic Course of a Fair Kazakhstan'".
3. National Security Strategy of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2021–2025.
4. Instruction of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated October 30, 2023 No. 23-5069 dсп.
5. Instruction of the Head of the Administration of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 22, 2025 No. 11035 ПАБ-4.
3. State Body Responsible for Developing the Concept
Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
4. State Bodies Responsible for Implementing the Concept
Ministry of Agriculture of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Transport of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Industry and Construction of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Trade and Integration of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Tourism and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation and Development of the Financial Market;
Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
local executive bodies.
5. Implementation Period
Until 2030.
Section 2. Analysis of the Current Situation
The labour market is one of the key factors of the country's economic and social development, as it determines the level of employment, income, qualifications and well-being of the population. In addition, the labour market reflects the degree to which the economy adapts to changing domestic and international demand conditions, as well as to new technologies and innovations.
Understanding its main parameters and dynamics is important for government bodies, private businesses, the education and retraining system, and society as a whole.
The labour market of the Republic of Kazakhstan has been continuously developing under the influence of political and various socio-economic factors over the past 30 years.
As a result, the labour market model has its own characteristics associated with historical, geographical, demographic and institutional factors, such as the elasticity of wages in relation to employment growth, an increase in self-employment, and a decline in the quality of human capital.
The current state of the labour market is determined by the level of economic complexity, in which the Republic of Kazakhstan ranks 55th in the world. This is due to the high share of raw materials, in the form of hydrocarbons and metals, in production and exports, as well as the low diversification of the economy. The expansion of the range of technological products is mainly taking place through low-complexity industries. This results in a shortage of complex jobs, since only 30% of existing jobs in the Republic of Kazakhstan require workers to have a high level of skills.
Thus, an economy with a low level of complexity primarily requires an intermediate level of qualifications and lacks sustainable incentives for human capital development.
It should be noted that every workplace, depending on its level of complexity, requires comprehensive occupational safety measures, which are determined on the basis of special indicators analyzed at the national, sectoral or regional levels and characterizing occupational injuries (hereinafter – OI), occupational diseases (hereinafter – OD), harmful and (or) hazardous working conditions (hereinafter – HHWC), and other factors.
The Address of the Head of State to the People of the Republic of Kazakhstan "Economic Course of a Fair Kazakhstan" highlights the extremely acute problem of the high level of occupational injuries and points to significant infrastructure deterioration, leading to a series of accidents, environmental degradation and damage to health in the areas surrounding major hazardous industrial facilities. President of the country K.K. Tokayev speaks of the need to take decisive measures to improve the technological and environmental condition of the occupational health protection system at enterprises. Industry is one of the leading sectors of the economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan, accounting for approximately 29.7% of the country's gross domestic product (hereinafter – GDP), reaching 50% or more in certain regions.
Non-ferrous and ferrous metallurgy, the chemical and petrochemical industries, and the mining sector are of particular importance in industry and in terms of their impact on the country's economy. The importance of industrial safety in these sectors is обусловлена its influence on the formation of a strong industrial framework of the country. The focus of state policy is on the accelerated development of such areas as deep metal processing, petrochemicals, gas chemistry and coal chemistry, heavy engineering, uranium conversion and enrichment, and the production of automotive components and fertilizers. Each of these areas is characterized by the presence of hazardous production factors; therefore, industrial safety issues and ensuring the necessary level of protection at hazardous production facilities, as mandatory factors in industrial development, require close attention from government bodies.
Over the past three years, a positive trend in the growth of the country's labour resources has been observed. According to official statistical information, the number of employed persons increased by 0.8% and, as of December 31, 2025, amounted to 9,724.6 thousand people, of whom 7,142.074 thousand (73.44%) were employees.
However, a 3% decrease in the number of employees working under HHWC has been noted over the past three years. In 2025, 1,641.515 thousand people were employed under HHWC (1,671.149 thousand people in 2023), of whom:
245.600 thousand people worked under the influence of physical production factors;
58.149 thousand people worked under the influence of chemical production factors;
13.070 thousand people worked under the influence of biological production factors;
159.999 thousand people worked under the influence of psychophysiological factors affecting the body.
It should be noted that an identical methodology for determining the number of employees working under HHWC is applied in the Russian Federation (hereinafter – RF) and the Republic of Belarus. However, in these countries, by contrast, an annual decrease in the share of employees in this category is observed, averaging 0.7% and 0.3%, respectively.
Analysis based on official statistical data shows that the number of employees who, for working under harmful and other unfavourable working conditions, have been granted at least one type of compensation (reduced working hours, additional paid annual leave, provision of milk and (or) equivalent food products, therapeutic and preventive nutrition, additional payments for harmful and other unfavourable working conditions) decreased by 2.2% and amounted to 681.968 thousand recipients at the end of 2025 (697.301 thousand recipients in 2023). At the same time, one employee working under HHWC may simultaneously receive several social guarantees.
The largest amount of occupational safety expenditure allocated to providing social guarantees to employees working under HHWC is observed at enterprises in the mining and quarrying industry (35%), manufacturing industry (27.58%), and transport and warehousing (10.9%).
In the regional breakdown, the regions with the highest employment under HHWC are Karaganda (10.93%), Aktobe (10.85%), Pavlodar (9.86%) and East Kazakhstan (9.52%) regions.
The key indicators of safe work are OI indicators, which characterize the level of occupational risk in the workplace and reflect the actual state of occupational safety and health at enterprises.
According to official statistical information, at the end of 2024, the total number of persons injured in work-related accidents increased by 0.9% compared with 2022 and amounted to 2,471 people, including 202 fatalities.
In international practice, relative values are generally used to compare occupational injury indicators. For example, the International Labour Organization (hereinafter – ILO) uses such an indicator as the incidence rate (frequency coefficient) of total and fatal occupational injuries per 100,000 workers.
At the end of 2024, the incidence rate of persons injured in accidents, calculated on the basis of official statistical information, amounted to 27 people per 100,000 workers (the corresponding indicator in 2022 was 44). However, in developed countries, the incidence rate of persons injured in accidents per 100,000 workers is significantly higher than in the Republic of Kazakhstan, for example, in the United States of America (hereinafter – USA) – 2,400; Italy – 1,137.4; Germany – 1,396.8; Spain – 2,319.6; France – 2,580.8; Finland – 1,261.5. At the same time, the incidence rate of fatalities resulting from accidents per 100,000 workers in countries such as France – 8.2 and the USA – 3.5 is comparable to the level in the Republic of Kazakhstan – 2.19 (3.7 in 2022), but higher than in Italy – 2, Spain – 1.7, Germany – 0.7, and Finland – 1.
At the same time, for a correct assessment of the level of occupational injuries, it is important to evaluate the ratio between non-fatal and fatal OI, which the ILO uses as an indicator of concealed occupational injuries, that is, an indicator of the level of underreporting of non-fatal OI. Thus, at the end of 2024, the concealed occupational injury indicator in the Republic of Kazakhstan amounted to 6:1, which is a high level compared with the indicators of developed countries around the world, for example, Finland – 1260:1, Germany – 1994:1, Italy – 568:1. This problem is exacerbated by the transfer of compensatory liability for minor accidents from insurance companies to employers, low liability for failure to report an accident, the absence of a unified information database for registering accidents, shortcomings in state control, and other factors.
By industry, the highest level of OI is observed in the mining industry (incidence rates of persons injured/fatalities resulting from accidents per 1,000 workers – 5.24/0.29) and manufacturing industry (8.75/0.39, respectively). The manufacturing industry is characterized by high rates of fatal injuries, including as a result of group accidents. On average, 17.8% of all fatalities and 32.4% of all injured workers in the country were employed in ore and coal mining. In 2025, 9.5% of all group accidents occurred in the city of Astana. An average of 8 workers became victims of such accidents.
In terms of concealed occupational injuries, the worst indicators are observed in the construction industry (4:1) and the electricity, gas, steam, hot water and air-conditioning supply industry (6:1), which is explained by the low level of organization of the occupational safety and health management system (hereinafter – OSHMS). In the mining (27:1) and manufacturing industries (36:1), the lower indicators are due to the proper registration of non-fatal injuries.
The regions with high levels of OI are Karaganda (incidence rates of persons injured/fatalities resulting from accidents per 1,000 workers – 4.38/0.27), Ulytau (3.1 and 0.02, respectively), and East Kazakhstan regions (2.6 and 0.19, respectively). The worst indicators of concealed occupational injuries are observed in such regions as Zhetysu and West Kazakhstan (2:1), Kostanay and Turkistan (5:1), Kyzylorda and the city of Shymkent (7:1).
Alongside OI, OD is an important indicator of safe work.
OI and OD are consequences of working under HHWC, including working conditions that do not comply with sanitary and hygienic standards, strenuous work, unsafe equipment and other conditions. According to official statistical information, over three years the number of persons affected by OD increased from 657 in 2022 to 2,471 in 2024, or by 3.76 times. As of January 1, 2026, more than 8 thousand people were registered for dispensary observation with occupational pathology. The structure of OD is dominated by diseases caused by exposure to industrial aerosols (40.4%), exposure to chemical factors (4.2%), and, to a lesser extent, exposure to biological factors (0.8%), diseases associated with functional overstrain and excessive loads on individual organs and systems (30.0%), and exposure to physical factors (23.8%).
In the regional breakdown, the highest level of OD is registered year after year in Karaganda and East Kazakhstan regions, which account for more than 90% of cases. This negative trend is explained by the fact that almost the entire mining and mining and processing industry of the republic is concentrated in these regions.
In addition, the labour market of the Republic of Kazakhstan is constantly influenced by such internal and external factors as demographics, migration and regional disparities in the distribution of the workforce, digitalization and automation of workplaces, and the introduction of artificial intelligence, which, among other things, lead to structural changes as a whole.
2.1 Demographic Changes in the Labour Market
By 2030, the annual inflow of young people into the labour market in the Republic of Kazakhstan will exceed 300 thousand people due to the demographic growth of the 2000s. The first wave of the "baby boom", with general secondary and secondary vocational education, is already reaching the labour market; in 2026, young people with higher education will begin to enter it.
The urbanization process is a global trend, and the Republic of Kazakhstan is no exception. Today, approximately 63% of the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan lives in cities. At the same time, the urbanization rate in the countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (hereinafter – OECD) exceeds 74%. By 2050, the population of the megacities of the Republic of Kazakhstan will increase by 2.2 times. The average annual growth in urbanization over the past 10 years has amounted to 5%. The infrastructure development of megacities is not synchronized with the process of creating new quality jobs. Upon arriving in cities from rural areas, labour migrants do not have the opportunity to find quality jobs. At the same time, not only geographical migration is taking place, but also sectoral migration – from the agricultural sector to the services and trade sectors.
Thus, high demographic pressure on the labour market may lead to an increase in unemployment, particularly among young people. The urbanization process will continue and will approach the level of OECD countries. The outflow of skilled personnel abroad will affect business competitiveness and the shortage of professional personnel.
According to the realistic scenario, by 2030 the labour force in the Republic of Kazakhstan will increase to more than 10.1 million economically active people (an increase of 5% compared with 2024).
At the same time, more than one-third of the entire labour force will be concentrated in the southern macro-region (Almaty, Zhambyl, Zhetysu, Kyzylorda and Turkistan regions and the city of Shymkent). For comparison, the northern and central-eastern macro-regions are projected to lose 7% and 4% of their labour force, respectively, by 2030. The combined share of these regions in the total labour force will also decrease from 30% to 27%.
In the western macro-region, which includes Atyrau, Mangystau, West Kazakhstan and Aktobe regions, the situation will remain largely unchanged. A slight increase in the labour force of 3% is expected by 2030. At the same time, its share of the total labour force will decrease from 16.2% to 15.8% due to the more active growth of the southern macro-region.
Thus, regional disparities in the distribution of the labour force in the labour market of the Republic of Kazakhstan will intensify, with the population predominating in labour-surplus southern regions and declining in the labour-deficient northern, eastern and central regions of the country.
The disparity between regions will persist due to differences between demographic growth and gross regional product (hereinafter – GRP). Southern regions, despite their high population density, will maintain low levels of GRP and labour productivity. For example, with a population of more than 7.6 million people, the combined GRP of Almaty, Zhambyl, Zhetysu, Kyzylorda and Turkistan regions and the city of Shymkent amounts to 17.4 trillion tenge, meaning that 30% of the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan accounts for only 20% of GDP.
2.2 Low Quality of the Workforce
Today, the labour market is characterized by unsatisfactory quality of both the current and future workforce.
There is a mismatch between demand from businesses and the supply of labour, as a result of which up to 25% of technical and vocational education (hereinafter – TVE) graduates work outside their field of specialization. The quality of knowledge of TVE graduates is determined by statistics on unemployed graduates and the number of employed graduates working outside their field of specialization (39.5% and 25%, respectively). An analysis of workforce skills conducted in 2024 using the PIAAC methodology (an international survey of adult competencies) revealed a threefold difference in skills between the younger and older generations.
The future workforce, which is expected to enter the labour market over the next 3–10 years, is in an unsatisfactory state. For example, in terms of schoolchildren's knowledge, the Republic of Kazakhstan ranks 49th out of 79 countries in the PISA ranking, which assesses performance in reading, mathematics and natural sciences.
The main demand in the country is for mid-level skilled specialists, amounting to 1,385 thousand people (according to the medium-term forecast for 2026–2035), whereas the number of TVE graduates (2018–2025) amounts to 1,025 thousand people. The existing personnel training system is characterized by an insufficient number of qualified teachers, outdated curricula and weak links with actual business needs.
At the same time, highly qualified personnel are predominantly employed at state-owned enterprises, while the private sector prefers employees with intermediate qualifications. Despite the fact that salaries in the public sector are lower than in the private sector, it attracts a very high proportion of people with above-average education. More than half of the personnel at private enterprises work in elementary occupations and are employed in services and sales, administrative support and office work, agriculture, as production equipment operators or workers in industry, construction and transport, and as unskilled workers.
According to international assessments, skills are becoming obsolete at an accelerating rate. According to the World Economic Forum, by 2030 approximately 39% of key skills will change, and approximately 60% of workers will need training or retraining.
The main problem with the current workforce is the low proportion of employees covered by professional development programmes.
Over the eight-year period (2018–2025), the proportion of employees covered by professional development programmes decreased. At the same time, there has been a decline both in the percentage of employees improving their qualifications at the employer's expense, from 8% to 5.7%, and in absolute terms, from 586 thousand in 2018 to 526.7 thousand in 2025.
At the same time, the corresponding indicator in OECD countries is 47%, which is eight times higher than the indicator for the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Thus, in the medium term, the main demand from businesses for quality human capital will be for intermediate-level specialists. Low coverage of personnel retraining programmes significantly reduces the quality of labour resources, particularly against the background of the rapid obsolescence of knowledge.
2.3 Insufficient Quantity and Quality of Jobs
One of the main challenges facing the labour market of the Republic of Kazakhstan is the low rate of creation of new jobs.
In the early 2000s, during a period of growing demand in commodity markets, the Republic of Kazakhstan gradually increased its exports, which ensured economic growth. The country began integrating into international commodity, transport and financial flows, which stimulated the development of all sectors of the country. As a result, real economic growth amounted to 60% in 2002–2006, which also had a positive impact on the labour market. The number of jobs increased by 19%.
However, in subsequent periods, economic growth rates were not as rapid, partly due to the influence of various crises. The average annual real GDP growth rate began to slow down, which had a negative impact on the creation of new jobs. For example, during 2021–2025, the economy grew by 21%. Over this period, the number of employees increased by 4.9%, from 6,687 thousand to 7,015 thousand people.
At the same time, the share of the private sector in generating new highly productive jobs remains consistently low, amounting to only 25%.
As a result, it should be noted that the private sector generates an insufficient number of new jobs. For comparison, in Canada the private sector created 46% of new jobs (2024), while in the USA this figure amounted to approximately 80% (2024).
Approximately 40% of the GDP of the Republic of Kazakhstan is accounted for by the quasi-public sector, with more than 26 thousand enterprises involving state participation operating in the country. The state's presence in the economy is higher than in OECD countries.
It should be noted that, at present, the increase in jobs is ensured by low-productivity industries and the public sector. 44% of employed people work in industries with low labour productivity, which affects their income.
The Economic Complexity Index (ECI), developed by scientists from Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, is used to assess the level of "economic complexity". It measures the accumulated knowledge in a country as reflected in its industrial structure. International trade statistics are used for this assessment. Products in whose production a country has a sustainable competitive advantage are taken into account, that is, products that it exports in greater quantities than the average economy of a similar size. The Economic Complexity Index reflects how complex and diversified the range of products manufactured by a country is. Specialization in simple technologies does not make it possible to achieve a sustainably high level of well-being.
In 2024, the Republic of Kazakhstan improved its position in the ranking, rising by 27 places over the past five years, from 82nd to 55th out of 145 countries (in 2021, the country ranked 93rd). Nevertheless, the country's export basket is still dominated by products with low added value. In the ranking, the Republic of Kazakhstan is positioned alongside countries such as Lebanon, Brazil, Ukraine and the UAE. The leading positions in the ranking are occupied by countries such as Japan, Switzerland and Taiwan.
2.4 Regional Aspect of the Labour Market of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Urbanization and the concentration of economic activity in the largest agglomerations continue to have a key impact on employment dynamics. Over the past ten years, the largest increase in jobs, as well as economic growth, has continued to be recorded in the cities of Astana and Almaty, where employment growth is accompanied by a faster increase in gross value added and labour productivity. In the western regions with developed raw-material specialization, employment dynamics continue to correlate with economic growth, with consistently high levels of labour productivity. In the southern regions, the contribution of employment to the economy remains higher than their contribution to overall economic growth, reflecting the more labour-intensive and low-productivity nature of regional economies.
Employment growth accompanied by high labour productivity in industrial regions is due to the continued focus on the extraction and export of raw materials. In megacities, the key factor is a diversified economic structure with a high share of high-value-added service industries (financial activities, professional and scientific services, information and communication technologies, and business services). The concentration of human capital, infrastructure and investment activity creates favourable conditions for their further expansion.
At the same time, regional employment outflows persist, amounting to more than 300 thousand people in total and concentrated primarily in the northern and eastern regions. The largest losses are recorded in North Kazakhstan and East Kazakhstan regions. The main reasons remain population outmigration, demographic ageing and limited rates of economic growth, which lead to a reduction in labour potential and a decline in business activity.
Regional disparities between population size and the scale of the economy persist. Approximately 38% of the country's population lives in the southern regions (excluding the city of Almaty), while their contribution to GRP amounts to approximately 17–18%. In the northern regions, where approximately 22% of the population resides, about one-quarter of the total GRP is generated. The economy of the northern territories is characterized by greater industrial diversification, whereas in the south, up to 60–65% of the regional economy is accounted for by trade and other services.
The mining industry remains one of the most productive sectors of the economy; however, employment in a number of regions is largely dependent on external price conditions in raw material markets. This structure increases the sensitivity of regional labour markets to external shocks and reflects the continuing technological differences between industries and territories.
The lowest level of productivity continues to be observed in agriculture, where a significant proportion of self-employed and informally employed workers remains. The transfer of labour resources from low-productivity forms of employment to more productive industries remains one of the key factors in increasing economic growth and, to a large extent, takes place in parallel with urbanization processes.
The services sector continues to account for the majority of employed people – in 2025, more than 60% of workers were concentrated in this sector. At the same time, the structure of the sector remains heterogeneous: high-productivity activities (finance, digital technologies and professional services) are concentrated primarily in the largest cities, whereas in the regions employment is generated in low-productivity segments (retail trade, catering, household and personal services). In most territories, services are oriented towards domestic consumer demand and directly depend on the dynamics of household incomes and the condition of the real sector. Therefore, employment growth is not always accompanied by a comparable increase in productivity and contribution to GRP.
Self-employment in the southern regions, with the exception of the cities of Almaty and Shymkent, remains widespread among the least educated population groups. For a significant proportion of self-employed people, education is limited to secondary education, while approximately 30% of such workers predominantly reside in rural areas, which results in low labour productivity and reflects structural constraints on the demand side for skilled labour. In Kyzylorda region, the share of this category reaches approximately 45–48%, while in Almaty and Turkistan regions it amounts to approximately 40–45%.
Low rates of urbanization, demographic ageing in certain territories, limited territorial mobility and reluctance to relocate contribute to the persistence of unproductive forms of employment, including small-scale trade, private transportation services and other types of activities that do not require high qualifications. In the context of the accelerated introduction of digital technologies and automation, the productivity gap between groups of workers with different levels of education continues to widen, which intensifies the structural imbalance in regional labour markets and increases the risks of socio-economic differentiation between territories.
2.5 Structural Changes in the Labour Market
The digital economy is transforming the labour market, and traditional employment has begun to shift towards the "gig economy". Today, flexible employment arrangements, including platform work, are actively developing in the labour market and are not merely a passing trend but dynamically developing areas.
The main advantages of platform employment are low barriers to entry, the possibility of combining it with a primary job, flexible working hours, and a balance between career and personal life. Thus, platform employment creates additional employment opportunities.
At the same time, platform employment also entails risks, such as unstable employment and income, the absence of entitlement to social benefits in the event of job loss or temporary incapacity for work, the absence of paid leave, and restrictions on the possibility of joining trade unions.
Platform employment refers to a type of work organization in which people are hired through online platforms to perform short-term or project-based tasks.
The total number of online platform workers to date, based on the mandatory social contributions made for 2024–2026, amounted to 399,212 people, of whom 398,203 were residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan and 1,009 were non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
In 2020, the European Commission identified 10 types of platform employment:
online sales – the sale of goods or services through electronic marketplaces;
transport services – the provision of transport services through platforms;
accommodation services – the rental of housing;
freelance work – the provision of freelance services (writing texts, design and programming);
delivery services – the provision of delivery services;
domestic services – the provision of domestic services (cleaning and gardening);
care services – the provision of care services (childcare and care for the elderly);
crowdsourcing – participation in crowdsourcing projects;
online tutoring – the provision of tutoring services online;
gig economy – performing short-term or one-off tasks on platforms such as TaskRabbit and Gigwalk.
Changes are also being observed in the structure of the self-employed category. At present, a 10% increase in the share of people with higher education in this category has been recorded. An expert survey showed that, for 22% of respondents, freelancing is their main source of income, whereas for 78%, "gig work" is a form of additional income, primarily in the education and trade sectors.
The situation will become more complicated with the entry of a new demographic wave into the labour market. By 2030, 74% of the labour force in the Republic of Kazakhstan will consist of "millennials" and Generation "Z"¹, who differ significantly from the older generation. They choose new behavioural models and values, meaning that they value flexible forms of employment. This generation has its own understanding of the balance between professional and personal life and may make financial concessions in exchange for a flexible work schedule. The new generation is not fixated on professional careers and lifelong commitment to a single occupation. They are willing to spend more time and money on education.
Demographic growth and the arrival of young people in the labour market will force the labour market to adapt to a new reality in which the younger generation will reshape the labour market according to its priorities and conditions.
The range of platform employment will expand every year, penetrating the services, tourism, IT, trade, construction, real estate and other sectors. Over the next decade, platform employment will reach maturity. Such risks as low wages and the uneven and unpredictable income of participants will no longer be as significant.
Digitalization will provide the state with electronic channels and tools for targeted influence on new challenges arising from platform employment. Having a "digital footprint" for every platform worker, the state, together with businesses, will be able to develop alternatives to such traditional benefits as health insurance, paid leave and pension contributions. Platform workers will form new types of trade unions that will differ in having less hierarchy and a greater level of self-organization, mobilization and autonomy.
Today, the labour market of the Republic of Kazakhstan faces a number of problems and challenges that require a comprehensive and systematic approach to their resolution. These problems and challenges include the following:
low labour productivity and insufficient economic diversification, dependent on the extraction and export of natural resources;
mismatch between the qualifications and skills of workers and labour market requirements, as well as insufficient development of the vocational education and training system;
a high share of informal employment, particularly in rural areas, as well as a low level of protection of workers' rights and interests;
inequality in access to jobs and income among different population groups, such as women, young people, persons with disabilities, ethnic minorities and others.
Thus, in the coming decade, the Republic of Kazakhstan faces a dual task.
The first task is to achieve a high standard of living, fair income distribution and a significant reduction in inequality among citizens. The most effective measure for reducing inequality is the provision of quality education, which, in turn, becomes the foundation for high labour productivity and efficiency.
The second task is to complete the transition from an "economy of simple things" to a "complex economy" – an economy based on the acquisition and use of productive knowledge to build complex and technologically advanced goods, services and industries.
_________________________________________
¹ A term used worldwide for the generation of people born approximately between 1997 and 2012 (English: Generation Z).
2.6 National Occupational Safety and Health Management System
The OSHMS currently operating in the Republic of Kazakhstan is a set of interrelated measures for implementing occupational safety and health policies, fulfilling occupational safety requirements and managing occupational risks. Occupational risk management, as one of the key elements of the OSHMS, includes the identification and assessment of occupational risks (hereinafter – ORA), corrective measures, and occupational risk control and monitoring. In turn, occupational risk assessment involves determining the degree of occupational risk based on the analysis of information on risk identification and official statistical information on morbidity and occupational injuries within the organization, as well as the availability of collective and personal protective equipment. In other words, it is effectively a tool for assessing working conditions in the workplace.
Working conditions are assessed on the basis of the current occupational safety and health management model and in the Republic of Kazakhstan through the certification of production facilities in terms of working conditions (hereinafter – CPF) or through ORA. The first procedure was introduced by law as early as 1986, while the second was introduced in 2020. Thus, state policy in the field of occupational safety and health has established a course towards transitioning from compensatory management to a risk-oriented approach. Therefore, CPF, introduced during the Soviet period, will gradually be phased out, since identical (standard) working conditions and production processes characteristic of the planned economy of that period require, under current market economy conditions, the consideration of risks and differentiation for each workplace.
The difference between the ORA procedure and CPF is that ORA provides a comprehensive risk assessment based on five indicators (harmfulness, hazardous working conditions, safety of production equipment, provision of personal protective equipment, and morbidity), taking into account the specific characteristics of each workplace, including an assessment of the impact on the health of employees working there.
CPF does not allow an overall assessment of an enterprise that could be used for state control purposes or to determine a classification when differentiating approaches to insuring employees against accidents, because CPF covers only production facilities.
The introduction in 2017 of the requirement for specialized organizations to have an accredited laboratory did not fully resolve the problem of the quality of CPF procedures. The absence of qualification requirements and automated reporting on CPF results makes it impossible to organize state monitoring of working conditions and promptly identify unscrupulous service providers.
In addition, CPF is characterized by a lack of connection with the economic components of the national OSHMS and does not contribute to economic incentives for employers to improve working conditions.
A positive effect in reducing OI and OD is possible provided that a link is established between all components of the OSHMS, the basis of which is ORA. At the same time, the methodological framework of ORA needs to be strengthened in terms of:
classification of working conditions, assessment of the harmfulness and hazard of industrial environment factors, and the severity and intensity of the work process;
application of cumulative and (or) combined exposure to harmful and (or) hazardous production factors during assessment;
application under special working conditions and at collective workplaces (outdoors, underground work, work at heights, and the like).
ORA must ensure full coverage of workplaces, taking into account the type of activity of the enterprise. By analogy with the experience of developed countries, for example, the methodology for non-production enterprises may be simpler and more accessible.
The results of ORA must be taken into account when selecting personal protective equipment (hereinafter – PPE), which prevents and (or) minimizes exposure to harmful and hazardous factors of the industrial environment. Unfortunately, the current approach to PPE selection under the intersectoral PPE standards (hereinafter – the standards) is not relevant when taking occupational risk into account. For example, PPE is issued when a harmful factor is absent or, conversely, is not issued if it is not provided for by the standards. The standards do not make it possible to cover the full range of all probable harmful and (or) hazardous production factors. In addition, the standards contain differences in the periods of use for identical types of PPE and similar occupations, which creates difficulties and does not allow workers to be provided with modern and comfortable PPE.
2.7 Economic Support for Safe Work
An effective economic instrument for improving working conditions at enterprises is the system of compulsory insurance of employees against accidents related to their work activities (hereinafter – CIA). Under this system, in 2025 the amount of insurance premiums paid was 1.8 times higher than the 2023 indicator and amounted to 154.9 billion tenge. The ratio of insurance payments to premiums also increased from 17.2% in 2023 to 29.3% in 2025.
Thus, there is a redistribution of the financial burden associated with the payment of compensation to injured employees from insurance organizations to employers, which results in low coverage of enterprises by CIA. As of the end of 2025, only 48.02% of legal entities had insurance contracts. The low coverage by CIA contracts is associated with employers' lack of interest in the CIA system, which makes it necessary to introduce an effective "bonus-malus" model that takes into account employers' expenditure on ensuring safe work.
Firstly, it is necessary to determine the list of enterprises, including payment of mandatory occupational pension contributions (hereinafter – MOPC), expenses for CIA, CPF and ORA, training and knowledge testing of responsible persons, collective protective equipment, PPE, sanitary and household facilities and equipment, periodic medical examinations, medical assessments and other occupational safety measures. Secondly, it is necessary to determine the conditions for applying preventive and rehabilitation insurance programmes. Thirdly, it is necessary to determine the size of adjustment coefficients to the insurance tariff, taking into account ORA results.
An analysis of expenditure on ensuring safe work showed that such expenditure is largely associated with the provision of social guarantees ("benefits" and "compensation") to employees working under HHWC. In 2025, more than 109.9 billion tenge was allocated for these purposes. In addition, the amount of pension savings through MOPC in 2025 amounted to 724.44 billion tenge, which is 12.7% more than in 2024 (653.77 billion tenge).
All economic instruments applied must be updated and linked to ORA results. Implementation of the specified occupational safety measures based on a risk-oriented approach will ensure full coverage of employees working under HHWC, taking into account the targeted and systematic nature of the social guarantees provided to them, while enabling enterprises to increase the efficiency of their investments in improving working conditions.
2.8 Training and Professional Development
The main causes of OI are shortcomings in occupational safety training, resulting from a shortage of qualified personnel and the lack of accountability of training centres for the quality of training.
Every year, one in eight accidents occurs due to shortcomings in training on safe working practices and violations of safety regulations.
At the same time, the absence of records makes it impossible to track the number of occupational safety and health specialists and assess their level of education and professional training.
The market for training and professional development services for persons responsible for ensuring safe work in the Republic of Kazakhstan is sufficiently developed; however, due to the lack of an adequate level of state control, it does not ensure proper quality of specialist training. Certain training organizations significantly understate the cost of professional development services for managers and persons responsible for occupational safety and health, which indirectly confirms the low quality of services and the qualifications of lecturers. There are cases of certificates being issued without the actual provision of training and knowledge testing.
Among the problems in the field of occupational safety and health is the inadequate training of occupational safety specialists. Many enterprises lack occupational safety and health services, which, under labour legislation, must be established in organizations engaged in production activities with more than 50 employees. The position of occupational safety and health specialist is not introduced, and responsible persons are not appointed in organizations with a staff of fewer than 50 employees. While in 2024 state labour inspectors identified 35 cases of the absence of occupational safety and health services or responsible persons at production enterprises, this indicator increased in 2025, when 62 violations were recorded.
According to the Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan, there are 4,138 large and medium-sized enterprises operating in the country, where occupational safety and health services should consist of an average of 5 people (in accordance with the standards, from 2.5 to 10 positions) and comprise approximately 20 thousand specialists. At the same time, in 2026, the actual number of employees in the occupations of "occupational safety and health engineer", "occupational health and safety engineer" and "occupational safety and health specialist" amounted to 10,068 people.
In the Republic of Kazakhstan, targeted professional training of specialists in CPF, state inspectors and technical inspectors in occupational safety and health is practically not carried out.
Personnel training in occupational safety and health is conducted within the educational programme group "Sanitary and Preventive Measures". Only 247 educational grants are allocated annually for this area, including: 160 for bachelor's programmes, 80 for master's programmes and 7 for doctoral programmes. In this area, following the 2025 competition for educational grants, the competition ratio for one place in bachelor's programmes was only 1.9 applicants.
Given such low interest in obtaining education in this field, measures should be taken to promote occupations for specialists in occupational safety, including increasing the number of state educational grants and state orders, as well as encouraging enterprises to finance the training of their own personnel.
Further improvement of the educational process is impossible without the introduction of distance learning technologies, training simulators and simulation models.
Science in the field of occupational safety and health is insufficiently developed. There is only one scientific organization – the Republican Research Institute of Occupational Safety and Health of the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter – RRIOSH), which conducts applied scientific research mainly related to the implementation of important and urgent state tasks, whereas fundamental research in the field of occupational safety and health requires a comprehensive and systematic approach, which presupposes the existence of a mechanism for sustainable and continuous funding. Scientific research is also carried out at the request of industrial enterprises on the basis of non-governmental research institutes; however, due to the absence of state registration and scientific and technical expert review, it is difficult to assess their number and quality. It is difficult to build up a scientific knowledge base in terms of scientific publications and their contribution to global science, as well as to track citation dynamics.
Overall, taking into account international experience in regulating activities related to occupational safety and health, measures must be taken to improve the quality of training and develop the country's scientific potential.
2.9 Monitoring and Control in the Field of Occupational Safety and Health
Statistical and departmental recording of safe work indicators is an important element of monitoring. Statistical records of the number of employees working under harmful and other unfavourable working conditions are maintained for a limited range of harmful and hazardous production factors. Taking into account the current situation regarding the introduction of ORA, the methodology applied needs to be updated. Departmental records are maintained manually, require continuous data collection and updating, and have significant discrepancies with official statistical information.
The country lacks information and analytical support for monitoring the registration, investigation and recording of occupational accidents, working conditions, and the results of CPF and ORA at enterprises. The automated information system "Occupational Safety and Health" is not integrated with the databases of government bodies. There is no visualization of any data on the state of occupational safety and health, as is done, for example, in European Union countries on the OSH Barometer platform.
In this regard, there is insufficient reliable information for management decisions, situation assessment, taking measures and preventive work.
Monitoring of the state of occupational safety and health in the country plays an important role in ensuring safe work and is implemented through state, public and internal control. Unfortunately, there is no interconnection or joint work between these types of control.
The effectiveness of state control in the field of occupational safety and health can be increased through the introduction of a mechanism for preventive measures based on the results of accident investigations and a vertical management model through the transfer of state labour inspectors to the subordination of the authorized state labour body.
The effectiveness of public control in the field of occupational safety and health can be increased by raising the status of the production council provided for in Article 203 of the Labour Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, strengthening social dialogue and expanding the competence of technical inspectors.
The effectiveness of internal control in the field of occupational safety and health can be increased by expanding the application of positive practices of enterprises in the construction industry involving vertical control from the customer to the contractor within the framework of contractual relations.
2.10 Shortcomings of Regulatory Mechanisms in the Field of Industrial Safety
Industrial safety, pursuant to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Civil Protection", is aimed at compliance with industrial safety requirements established in technical regulations, industrial safety rules, instructions and other regulatory legal acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan. This establishes the fundamental importance of regulatory policy, legal and technical standards in the field of industrial safety. The framework regulatory provisions apply to activities carried out at hazardous production facilities, which include enterprises, production units and other facilities of such enterprises possessing the characteristics established by law.
The current situation in the field of industrial safety can be characterized by quantitative parameters analyzed at the national, sectoral or regional levels. One of the basic indicators is the total number of supervised entities and hazardous production facilities within them.
Thus, at the end of 2025, 10,963 supervised entities were registered in the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of industrial safety. Due to the country's natural need for continuous economic development, modernization of production facilities and industrialization, the increase in the number of supervised entities over the past 5 years amounted to +20%, with an average growth rate of +4.6% over the past three years. Their total number was 10,478 units in 2023 and 10,680 units in 2024. Currently, among the supervised entities there are 2,692 enterprises operating lifting mechanisms; 1,279 enterprises in the petrochemical and oil refining industries; 1,013 enterprises in the gas sector; 1,262 enterprises in the mining industry; 531 boiler-house enterprises; 399 enterprises for the storage and processing of plant raw materials; 283 enterprises in the chemical industry; 220 enterprises in the oil and gas production industry; 143 enterprises using atomic energy; 86 enterprises in the metallurgical industry; 55 enterprises in the transportation of hydrocarbon raw materials through main pipelines; and 3,000 legal entities performing work in the field of industrial safety.
More than 99% of supervised entities belong to the private sector, more than half of which are classified as high-risk entities, including 14% large enterprises, 24% medium-sized businesses and 62% small enterprises. It should be noted that among state-owned supervised entities, 62% are classified as high-risk entities, including 92% large enterprises, 2% medium-sized enterprises and 6% small enterprises. Thus, there are differences attributable to state participation.
An analysis of the geographical distribution of supervised entities in the field of industrial safety showed that the largest proportion is located in the city of Astana (9%), Akmola region (8%) and Almaty region (7.3%), while the smallest number of supervised entities is located in Ulytau region (1%), the city of Shymkent (2%), Kostanay region (3%) and Kyzylorda region (3%). At the same time, in terms of the geographical distribution of high-risk supervised entities, the leading regions are Almaty (10%), Akmola (8%), Aktobe (8%) and Pavlodar (7%), while the smallest numbers are recorded in Ulytau region (2%), the city of Shymkent (2%), Turkistan region (2%) and East Kazakhstan region (2%). An analysis of the geographical distribution of supervised entities in the field of industrial safety, taking into account their size, showed that small entities are concentrated primarily in Almaty (16%), Akmola (10%) and Pavlodar (7%) regions.
At the same time, as of the end of 2025, supervised entities included 229,301 hazardous production facilities. An upward trend is also observed here: over the past 5 years, the growth rate amounted to +2.5%, and over the past three years, +1%. Their total number was 209,875 units in 2023 and 219,628 units in 2024. A structural analysis of hazardous production facilities by identification criteria showed that the largest share (60%) consists of production facilities possessing the characteristics established by Article 70 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Civil Protection":
facilities associated with the production, use, processing, generation, storage, transportation (by pipeline) and destruction of at least one of the following hazardous substances having the characteristics of a source of ionizing radiation: flammable, explosive, combustible, oxidizing and toxic substances;
facilities associated with the production of melts of ferrous, non-ferrous and precious metals and alloys based on these metals;
facilities associated with mining, geological exploration, drilling, blasting, mineral extraction and mineral raw material processing, and underground operations, with the exception of geological exploration of common minerals and mining operations for their extraction without blasting operations.
In addition to the above-mentioned hazardous production facilities, the structure of supervised entities includes 25% hazardous technical devices operating under pressure exceeding 0.07 megapascals or at a water heating temperature exceeding 115 degrees Celsius, and 15% lifting mechanisms.
An analysis of the geographical distribution of hazardous production facilities in the field of industrial safety showed that the largest proportion is located in Mangystau (19%), Aktobe (15%), Karaganda (15%), Kyzylorda (12%) and Atyrau (9%) regions. The smallest number of hazardous production facilities is located in Zhetysu region (0.2%), the city of Almaty (1%) and Almaty region (0.3%).
A structural analysis of the distribution of hazardous production facilities by identification criteria shows that those possessing the above-mentioned characteristics under Article 70 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Civil Protection" are predominantly located in Mangystau (19%), Aktobe (15%), Karaganda (13%) and Kyzylorda (12%) regions. Hazardous technical devices operating under pressure exceeding 0.07 megapascals or at a water heating temperature exceeding 115 degrees Celsius (with the exception of heating networks) are concentrated primarily in the city of Shymkent (15%) and Pavlodar region (12%). Lifting mechanisms are most frequently used in East Kazakhstan region (15%) and the city of Astana (14%). Regarding the location of other types of hazardous production facilities across the regions of the Republic of Kazakhstan, it should be noted that escalators (99%), cableways (100%), funiculars (100%), mine hoisting installations and lifting machines (42%), mobile and stationary installations for the manufacture of explosives and explosive devices (27%) are located in Karaganda region; elevators (55%) – in the city of Astana; drilling and well-repair installations with a drilling depth exceeding two hundred metres (46%) – in Mangystau region; mobile storage facilities for explosives and explosive devices (46%) – in Almaty region; and mixing-charging and delivery-charging machines for explosives and explosive devices (40%) – in East Kazakhstan region.
An analysis of the main industrial safety indicators by region made it possible to establish a strong correlation between them. For example, high correlation coefficients were obtained between the number of supervised entities and the number of accidents (0.97), the number of high-risk supervised entities and the number of accidents (0.97), the number of hazardous production facilities and the number of incidents (0.97), the number of accidents and the number of incidents (0.85), and the number of violations and the number of accidents (0.96) (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Correlation analysis of the main industrial safety indicators (based on a standardized sample)
The data presented indicate that regulatory policy with regard to the activities of supervised entities and hazardous production facilities must become the fundamental basis for preventing industrial accidents and incidents.
An analysis of the industry affiliation of supervised entities in the field of industrial safety showed that the largest proportion belongs to the petrochemical and oil refining industries (16.4%), the gas sector (11.5%) and the mining industry (10.1%). Among high-risk supervised entities, a similar situation is observed in the gas sector (11.6%), petrochemical and oil refining industries (10.3%), and mining industry (8%).
An analysis of hazardous production facilities in the field of industrial safety by industry showed that the largest proportion belongs to the oil and gas production industry (33.2%), mining industry (9%) and boiler-house sector (8%). A structural analysis of hazardous production facilities by identification criteria shows their clear classification according to the industry in which they are used. For example, in the oil and gas production industry (46.2%) and mining industry (12.4%), hazardous production facilities possessing the characteristics specified in Article 70 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Civil Protection" are used, while in the boiler-house sector (30.9%) and gas sector (23.7%), hazardous technical devices operating under pressure exceeding 0.07 megapascals or at a water heating temperature exceeding 115 degrees Celsius (with the exception of heating networks) are used.
The introduction of a risk-oriented approach in industrial safety requires taking into account accident patterns based on the dynamics of their indicators. These important indicators provide information on the state of industrial safety in the industry.
The analysis shows that approximately 20 accidents occur annually at hazardous production facilities, the majority of which involve facilities operating lifting mechanisms, as well as facilities in the mining and oil industries. Over the past five years (from 2021 to 2025), 112 accidents were registered, including 20 at facilities in the mining industry (17.9%), 26 at facilities operating lifting mechanisms (23%), 25 in the oil industry (22%), 20 in the gas industry (17.9%), 8 in the chemical and petrochemical industries (7%), 5 in the metallurgical industry (4.5%), 4 at boiler-house facilities (3.6%), 3 at facilities for the storage of plant raw materials (2.7%), and 1 at facilities operating main gas pipelines (0.9%).
The dynamics of accidents over the past three years, expressed in figures, are as follows: 21 in 2023, 21 in 2024 and 22 in 2025. Compared with data for the past 5 years, this shows that the number of accidents ranges from 20 to 28 per year; however, the severity of these accidents increases every year. For example, whereas in 2021 and 2022 the average number of injured persons was equal to the number of accidents, in 2023 the number of injured persons in each accident increased to five.
The dynamics of industrial accident risk make it possible to draw conclusions regarding the ineffectiveness of organizational and technical measures to ensure industrial safety and production control in certain industries. A comparison of these indicators with national values makes it possible to identify improper compliance with industrial safety requirements within the framework of legislative procedures for substantiating safety, declaring industrial safety and establishing acceptable levels of accident risk.
For example, at the end of 2025:
in the mining industry, 1,262 supervised entities and 40,456 hazardous production facilities were recorded; 5 accidents occurred, resulting in 14 injured persons, of whom 8 died;
in the gas sector, 2 accidents occurred, resulting in 2 fatalities, while 1,013 supervised entities and 14,743 hazardous production facilities operate in this industry;
in the oil and gas production industry, 220 supervised entities and 73,777 hazardous production facilities were recorded; 4 accidents occurred, resulting in 1 injured person;
across the country, 7,813 supervised entities and 221,445 hazardous production facilities were registered; 22 accidents occurred, resulting in 30 injured persons, of whom 18 died.
Thus, a comparison of quantitative indicators established the following:
the ratio of the number of injured persons per accident across the country is 1, in the mining industry – 3, in the gas sector – 1, and in the oil and gas production industry – 0;
the ratio of the number of fatalities among injured persons across the country is 0.6, in the mining industry – 0.6, in the gas sector – 1, and in the oil and gas production industry – 0;
the ratio of the number of supervised entities to the number of accidents across the country is 355, in the mining industry – 252, in the gas sector – 506.5, and in the oil and gas production industry – 55;
the ratio of the number of hazardous production facilities to the number of injured persons across the country is 7,381.5, in the mining industry – 2,889.7, in the gas sector – 7,371.5, and in the oil and gas production industry – 0;
the ratio of the number of hazardous production facilities to the number of supervised entities across the country is 28, in the mining industry – 32, in the gas sector – 14.6, and in the oil and gas production industry – 335.4.
Among the injured persons, 60% suffered fatal injuries, 30% sustained severe injuries, and 10% sustained minor injuries. Accidents most frequently involve mining, geological exploration, drilling, blasting, mineral extraction, mineral raw material processing and underground operations, with the exception of geological exploration of common minerals and mining operations for their extraction without blasting operations (22.7%); exploration of gas and oil fields, surveying, drilling wells, oil and gas production, and the organization of transportation of extracted resources through the construction of pipelines (18%); and the operation of hazardous technical devices (13.6%).
By location of occurrence, accidents most frequently occur at hazardous production facilities in the mining industry (22.7%), oil and gas industry (18%), construction industry (13.6%) and chemical industry (13.6%).
Among the accidents, it is worth noting those that occur every year. For example, major accidents at the coal mines of ArcelorMittal Temirtau Joint Stock Company (November 2021 – at Abayskaya mine, 6 people died; November 2022 – at Lenin mine, 5 people died; August 2023 – at Kazakhstan mine, 5 people died; October 2023 – at Kostenko mine, 46 people died; February 2025 – at the Zhomart mine of Kazakhmys Corporation LLP, 7 people died). Such incidents must be subject to special monitoring by the state body.
The market for services and the transfer of many functions of the state body in the field of industrial safety to the private sector must be ensured by a high level of responsibility and fair competition. For example, at present, 70 professional emergency rescue services (hereinafter – PERS) operate in the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of mine rescue, gas rescue and blowout prevention operations at hazardous production facilities.
One of the effective measures will be the introduction of a unified decision-making centre in the field of industrial safety and the implementation of a risk-oriented approach providing for the following regulatory policy parameters:
classification of the activities of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs into a specific risk category;
formation of lists (registers) of state-controlled and supervised facilities depending on their assigned risk (hazard) categories;
development and implementation of uniform criteria for assessing accident risks at hazardous production facilities and categorizing such facilities;
improvement of the inspector professional development system, including the introduction of a system for confirming the qualifications of specialists in occupations providing services in the field of industrial safety.
In the current situation, it is necessary to improve state policy in the field of industrial safety in order to consistently reduce the risk of accidents at hazardous production facilities.
Modern conditions for the development of state policy are characterized by the widespread use of virtual forms of interaction: e-government, electronic digital signatures, digital maps, electronic wallets, etc. Digital technologies are becoming a key factor in the accessibility and transparency of public services.
In the field of industrial safety, digitalization tools are used to a limited extent, and the implementation of goals and objectives assigned to the authorized state body is carried out manually, while information collection is not automated.
At present, there is an urgent need to introduce digital solutions at the republican level and further develop industrial safety through the introduction of platform-based solutions:
for maintaining a register of owners of gas filling stations, gas filling points, autogas filling stations and industrial consumers who own pressure vessels used for storing liquefied petroleum gas, in accordance with amendments and additions to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Gas and Gas Supply", concerning the granting of the authorized body in the field of industrial safety the relevant competence (the procedure for maintaining the register was approved by Order of the Minister of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 13, 2023 No. 607 "On Approval of the Rules for Maintaining the Register of Owners of Gas Filling Stations, Gas Filling Points, Autogas Filling Stations and Industrial Consumers – Owners of Pressure Vessels Used for Storing Liquefied Petroleum Gas", according to which territorial divisions in the field of industrial safety compile a list of owners and collect and process the necessary information for inclusion in the register; until this process is automated, the register will be maintained manually);
for creating a digital system for control and supervisory activities in the field of industrial safety to address a range of state tasks, including maintaining a list of supervised entities; assigning supervised entities to risk categories; maintaining a list of hazardous facilities of supervised entities; maintaining a register of hazardous technical devices registered and deregistered; maintaining a register of registered industrial safety declarations; maintaining a register of certified organizations authorized to perform work in the field of industrial safety; maintaining a register of permits issued for the use of technologies applied at hazardous production facilities and hazardous technical devices; recording accidents and incidents at hazardous production facilities; recording inspection results, instructions to eliminate identified violations, acts prohibiting or suspending activities (certain types of activities); acts investigating accidents and incidents at hazardous production facilities; and automated analysis of the results of supervisory activities carried out by territorial divisions of the authorized body in the field of industrial safety.
The introduction of this system is one of the areas of development of the architecture of the Ministry of Emergency Situations (developed by the National Information and Communication Holding "Zerde" Joint Stock Company and approved by the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan in April 2022), the measures for which are included in the digital transformation roadmap of the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
It should also be noted that, within the framework of the implementation of one of the state's initiatives aimed at improving the quality of life of the population, the authorized body needs to transfer the testing procedure for legal entities declaring industrial safety to an online format. This will make it possible to fully automate the testing procedure, ensure objective transparency of the testing process and eliminate contact with service recipients, thereby eliminating corruption risks.
In this regard, the introduction of a digital system in the field of industrial safety will make it possible to properly implement all the tasks assigned to the department.
Insufficient resource provision for industrial safety and inefficient use of resources (material and technical, human, scientific, etc.).
Industrial safety largely depends on the resource component and its provision, the degree of balance and efficiency in the use of each resource, and their sufficiency for their intended purpose.
An important resource-providing factor is the national management system in the field of industrial safety, which, unlike other state regulatory systems, has a history of formation and development spanning 100 years. Even during the period of our state's independence, the industrial safety system underwent continuous transformation:
a separate state body – the Committee for Supervision of Safe Work in Industry and Mining Supervision of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 1996;
as part of the State Committee of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Emergency Situations, reorganized in 1997 into the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Emergency Situations and in 2004 into the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan, where the functions of ensuring industrial safety were concentrated until 2014;
as part of the Ministry of Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2020;
as part of the Industrial Safety Committee of the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Constant reforms have led to negative consequences, and the industrial safety system has lost its coordinated mechanism for interaction between various departmental structures with one common objective – preventing the harmful effects of hazardous production factors arising from accidents and incidents at hazardous production facilities.
Previously, the structure included 1,648 inspectors exercising state supervision, the Central Headquarters of Professional Paramilitary Emergency Rescue Services with more than 3 thousand rescuers performing preventive and emergency rescue operations at hazardous production facilities, as well as the National Scientific and Technical Centre for Industrial Safety, which included 4 sectoral institutes conducting scientific activities, developing and revising regulatory and technical documents, and providing training for inspectors. Unfortunately, in 2017, the National Scientific and Technical Centre for Industrial Safety and its 4 sectoral institutes in the cities of Atyrau, Karaganda, Ust-Kamenogorsk and Shymkent were liquidated (Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 24, 2017 No. 286 "On the Liquidation of the Joint Stock Company 'National Scientific and Technical Centre for Industrial Safety'"), and the Central Headquarters of Professional Paramilitary Emergency Rescue Services in the field of industrial safety, with more than 3 thousand rescuers, was sold through a two-stage procedure. The continuous reorganization of departments in the field of industrial safety contributed to the outflow of inspectors. For example, the partial transfer of certain industrial safety functions to local executive bodies resulted in the loss of prompt vertical response in the event of an accident. The scientific potential of the department was completely eliminated, inspector professional development centres were liquidated, as was the material and technical foundation for emergency rescue operations. The industrial safety system has repeatedly undergone reductions in staffing levels. At present, only 381 inspectors exercise state supervision in the field of industrial safety. Competencies in emergency rescue operations, scientific activities, training and professional development, etc., have been outsourced under market conditions, with legal entities performing work in the field of industrial safety and specialized market entities acting as service providers.
Compared with 1991, the number of state inspectors has decreased fourfold, while the total number of supervised facilities has increased by 15% (in 1991 – 186 thousand, in 2023 – 214 thousand hazardous production facilities). Thus, in 1991, each inspector was responsible for 113 facilities, and the annual coverage by inspectors exceeded 120 thousand facilities, whereas in 2025 each inspector is responsible for 623 facilities, and the annual coverage by inspectors amounts to more than 37 thousand facilities. The workload assigned to inspectors is disproportionate to their number. In this regard, it is necessary to consider eliminating the shortage of staffing positions for inspectors in the field of industrial safety, taking into account labour standards.
Given the current situation, the performance of the assigned functions and powers aimed at preventing conditions that contribute to accidents at industrial enterprises causes certain practical problems. In addition, the status of "inspector" currently provides no privileges compared with an ordinary administrative civil servant, and therefore no additional social support measures are provided (medical benefits, public transport benefits, housing benefits, etc.).
It is also important to have a clear understanding of the distinction between concepts of industrial safety, which is primarily understood as a preventive system for assessing the hazards posed by supervised hazardous entities and production facilities and establishing safety requirements for them, as well as monitoring and controlling the implementation of these requirements and conditions.
In some cases, the causes of accidents include exceeding the service life of equipment, poor-quality or untimely maintenance and repairs, ill-considered design and technical solutions, and extremely low technological and labour discipline, which is clearly reflected in violations of safe work rules and practices, technological regulations and industrial safety requirements.
The system for training and retraining specialists and personnel for hazardous production facilities is not at the required level. The role of science in developing methods for improving and maintaining the state of industrial safety is insufficient.
Section 3. Review of International Experience
International experience shows that sustainable job creation, increased labour productivity and ensuring occupational safety most often arise from reproducible cause-and-effect chains: expansion of demand, structural transformation and firm dynamics, accumulation of skills, improvement of occupational safety and health at production facilities, and institutions that enable the economy to adapt without losing the quality of employment. This is fully consistent with the frameworks of the OECD, ILO and World Bank, which regard employment, productivity and inclusive institutions as interrelated objectives.
The World Development Report indicates that the combination of conditions required to generate quality jobs comes down to creating positive externalities (for example, an effective link between the economy and external markets and the creation of functional cities), rather than simply increasing output. According to the report of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development and the World Development Report (2020), integrating the economy into global value chains can accelerate growth and employment; however, these effects must be supported by high-quality domestic institutions and external conditions (market access, logistics, competition and complex competencies). The combined external structural factors – geography, logistics costs, access to large markets, demographics and technology – in some cases play no less important a role than internal factors and targeted state employment policy.
The foundation of national occupational safety and health strategies in OECD countries consists of ILO provisions enshrined in the Global Strategy on Occupational Safety and Health for 2024–2030 and the Occupational Safety and Health – Global Action for Prevention (OSH GAP) programmes integrated into that Strategy, as well as the provisions of the European Commission's Strategic Framework on Health and Safety at Work for 2021–2027.
Occupational safety and health covers the entire spectrum of economic activities, including the field of industrial safety, which is one of the most important areas.
Industrial safety issues are a priority in the formulation of state policy in all countries around the world; they are periodically updated and continuously supported.
The main objective of the ILO's strategic documents in the field of occupational safety and health is to promote the creation of a global culture of prevention in order to achieve a real reduction in the number of work-related deaths, injuries and diseases.
For example, the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction (2015–2030) was adopted by UN Member States to replace the Hyogo Framework for Action (2005–2015) and is currently the most comprehensive international agreement on disaster risk reduction. It covers technological hazards, including hazards associated with the chemical industry, as well as radiological, nuclear, biological and other hazards. Importantly, the Framework provides for the sharing of responsibility for disaster risk reduction between the Government and other stakeholders, such as local authorities, the private sector and other non-state entities.
The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction establishes 4 clear priorities for action and 7 global targets for substantially reducing disaster risk: understanding disaster risk; strengthening disaster risk governance to manage disaster risk; investing in disaster risk reduction for resilience; enhancing disaster preparedness for effective response and the principle of "Build Back Better" in recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction.
It should be noted that in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, during 2022–2023, within the framework of the Convention on the Transboundary Effects of Industrial Accidents, a project entitled "Accounting for Technological/Industrial Accident Risks in National Disaster Risk Reduction Strategies and Plans" was implemented by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) jointly with the United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR). As a result of this project, strategic national programmes addressing industrial safety issues were prepared for these countries.
At the same time, during the review of global experience, universal approaches of a number of countries that had successfully implemented policies for economic and employment development were studied. These countries included the Asian countries of Vietnam, South Korea and Malaysia, as well as the USA, Canada, Chile, Saudi Arabia and Poland. These countries focused on industrialization and export-oriented production. The main success factor was the proper balancing of industrialization policies with the development of a highly productive agro-industrial complex and support for small and medium-sized businesses (hereinafter – SMEs).
3.1 Stimulating Businesses to Develop the Labour Market
Experience of South Korea
During the formation of the South Korean economy in the 1960s–1970s, the country's Government successfully managed large-scale migration of the population from agricultural regions to cities and, accordingly, from the agricultural sector to the industrial sector. This was facilitated by the country's industrialization and the establishment of large and medium-sized industrial enterprises. The main focus of production was on exports.
Starting in the 1980s, industry began to focus on research and scientific and technological development, which yielded results by the early 2000s.
Subsequently, the focus shifted to innovative and creative industries. Success was driven by the provision of tax and financial preferences, as well as massive investments in research and development and education.
Experience of Malaysia
Like other "Asian Tigers", Malaysia focused on developing export industries. At the same time, the task was set to gradually increase production complexity and raise product quality requirements.
Lacking its own large industrial conglomerates, Malaysia pursued a policy of attracting transnational companies with their own capital and production technologies.
Taking advantage of its favourable geographical location, the country's Government focused on the development of industrial agglomerations, such as industrial parks, special economic zones, science and technology parks and regional economic corridors. Comprehensive support for SMEs was provided at the state level.
Experience of Poland
Before and after joining the Eurozone, the Government of Poland pursued a policy of gradually reducing income tax while providing substantial social support to the population in the field of labour. Strong emphasis was placed on the development of domestic industrial sectors, support for agribusiness and agricultural processing.
After joining the European Union, Poland managed to effectively use funds from European funds for infrastructure development, industrial support and agricultural subsidies. Traditionally, a full range of support was provided to SMEs.
Experience of Vietnam
Following the People's Republic of China, Vietnam began a gradual transition from a centrally planned to a market economy in the late 1980s, which later became known as the "Doi Moi" policy.
At the first stage, agricultural collectives were abolished and price controls on agricultural products were lifted. The Government then liberalized the domestic market and adopted measures to stimulate private business.
The country opened access to transnational corporations with their own capital and production technologies, as well as to foreign investment. Thanks to a competitive labour market, low wages, gradual increases in productivity, stable macroeconomic policies and a favourable geographical location, Vietnam began creating quality jobs and high-tech, export-oriented industries starting in the 2010s.
3.2 Human Capital Development
Experience of South Korea
South Korea has achieved significant success in human capital development over the past several decades. The country's education system is highly regarded, and its workforce is known for its strong work ethic, discipline and technical skills.
One of the key factors in the development of human capital in South Korea has been the Government's focus on education. The country has a highly centralized education system with an emphasis on academic achievement. Students are required to attend school for 12 years, and the curriculum is designed to prepare them for university entrance examinations.
South Korea also has a strong vocational education system that provides students with technical skills in high demand in the country's industrial and technological sectors. The Government has invested heavily in vocational education, and many students choose this path instead of entering university.
Experience of Malaysia
Malaysia has also achieved significant success in human capital development, although the country faces certain unique challenges.
One of the key factors in the development of human capital in Malaysia has been the Government's focus on education. However, there are concerns about the quality of education, particularly in rural areas. The Government has implemented various initiatives to address this issue, such as allocating additional resources to rural schools and expanding access to vocational education.
Overall, Malaysia's focus on education and healthcare has helped create a skilled workforce that is well positioned for economic growth. However, challenges remain to be addressed, particularly in terms of improving the quality of education, promoting equality and ensuring inclusiveness.
Experience of Poland
The country has made significant progress following its transition to a market economy in the 1990s. It has a well-developed education system with an emphasis on science and technology. An important aspect of human capital development in Poland is the relatively low level of income inequality in the country. People from low-income families have greater opportunities to obtain higher education. Nevertheless, challenges remain in the area of emigration. Many highly qualified specialists have left Poland in search of better jobs abroad, which may limit the country's economic growth potential.
Experience of Saudi Arabia
In recent years, Saudi Arabia's education system has undergone significant improvements, particularly in the fields of natural sciences, technology, engineering and mathematics. The country has invested heavily in education, with a particular focus on developing a skilled workforce to support economic diversification.
The Government has implemented various initiatives to expand access to education, particularly for women. Saudi Arabia has established several specialized universities and research institutes, including King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) and King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST). These institutions have helped develop a strong research culture in the country and have made significant contributions to areas such as renewable energy, nanotechnology and biotechnology.
Ниже представлен полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением исходной структуры, нумерации, заголовков, примечаний, терминологии и всех гиперссылок.
3.3 Institutional Measures
The analysis focused on the experience of the following countries: Canada, the United States and South Korea, as they employ distinctive institutional support mechanisms.
South Korea uses direct labour market management instruments within the framework of medium-term economic planning.
Canada places emphasis on understanding and analysing medium-term prospects and trends, paying particular attention to statistics and foresight, and preparing businesses and society for new challenges.
The United States relies on existing fiscal and monetary instruments and has the opportunity to use the “invisible hand” of the market, giving greater initiative to large and medium-sized businesses.
Canada’s Experience
One of the distinctive features of the Canadian Government’s work is the availability of comprehensive and up-to-date labour market statistics. At the regional and local levels, considerable attention is paid to the vocational guidance system for assessing employment prospects.
Retraining support programmes are available for employed people aged 25–65.
At all levels, programmes are implemented to promote workplace inclusiveness, as well as social grant and social innovation programmes. The preparation of high-quality foresight studies, trend analyses and forecasts helps businesses better navigate labour market planning.
South Korea’s Experience
The distinctive feature of the South Korean approach lies in medium- and long-term employment planning at both central and regional levels. Employment stabilisation programmes are adopted with a focus on increasing the number of employed women and older people.
Separate programmes regulate the inflow of foreign labour. Given the special status of Korean trade unions in the country's political life, a long-term employment system with enhanced protection of workers’ rights operates effectively. Public and private (sectoral) employment exchanges operate in major cities.
United States’ Experience
At the federal level, a tax credit programme for job creation has been adopted, which stimulates the creation of new jobs in sectors of the economy requiring additional support. Programmes are being implemented to attract talented migrants with technical, engineering and IT education.
At the regional level, each state takes measures to attract new manufacturing enterprises through tax and other incentives.
The “Made in the USA” programme is being implemented to support large and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises.
Overall, international experience provides an opportunity to examine which institutional measures have been successfully implemented by other countries.
To stimulate demand:
- an economy oriented towards industry ensures high-quality jobs and increased incomes;
- higher employee incomes are primarily ensured by private companies engaged in export-oriented production;
- support for entrepreneurship and the development of SMEs contribute to the creation of new jobs.
To stimulate supply:
- medium- and long-term planning ensures predictability in the labour market;
- the formation of an ecosystem involving businesses ensures continuous access to reliable information on labour market demand for making well-founded systemic decisions and implementing prompt measures;
- a safe and healthy working environment becomes one of the fundamental principles and rights in the field of labour.
3.4 Reforms in the Field of Occupational Safety and Health
The ongoing reforms in the field of occupational safety and health in most OECD and Eurasian Economic Union (hereinafter referred to as the EAEU) countries provide for:
1. Prevention of hazards and risks in the field of occupational safety and health, and the application of a risk-based approach to occupational safety and health management.
Procedures for assessing working conditions and occupational risks (OR) at each workplace are mandatory for all employers and must be carried out systematically. In the countries of the European Union, occupational risk assessment is a mandatory procedure for enterprises of all industries and sizes. It includes the development of appropriate preventive measures, monitoring their effectiveness and documenting the risk assessment procedure. The only difference lies in the assessment method. The results of the assessment serve as the basis for analysis and management decision-making to ensure safe working conditions. For example, according to official data from the online platform of the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (ESENER 2024), as of the end of 2024, 76% of enterprises in the European Union regularly conduct occupational risk assessments.
Government authorities conduct examinations to verify compliance with applicable regulations and standards. In South Korea, such examinations are conducted by the Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency. A positive assessment exempts an enterprise from safety and health inspections and also provides various benefits (insurance discounts of up to 20%, subsidies, grants and loans for improving occupational injury prevention equipment, etc.).
Among the EAEU countries, in the Russian Federation, occupational risk assessment became a mandatory procedure for all employers in 2022, and failure to conduct it is subject to administrative liability in the form of fines.
Mandatory for all parties to employment relationships are occupational medical examinations and recommendations for implementing rehabilitation measures. The provision of collective and personal protective equipment is an inalienable right of employees and, accordingly, an obligation of employers. In European countries, the United States and Canada, the procedure for providing personal and collective protective equipment is based on the results of an occupational risk assessment for each workplace.
A similar approach to the selection of personal protective equipment has been established in the course of reforming regulatory requirements in the EAEU countries.
The combination of international standards with national policy measures, closely aligned with and focused on ensuring safe work, makes it possible to achieve the maximum effect, which is characteristic of countries with the most developed occupational safety and health management systems (OSHMS). For example, ILO Convention No. 176, “Safety and Health in Mines Convention” (1995), has been ratified by 35 countries that are leaders in coal mining and processing, including the United States, Germany, Poland and Russia. Of fundamental importance are ILO Conventions No. 155, “Occupational Safety and Health Convention”, and No. 187, “Promotional Framework for Occupational Safety and Health Convention”, which establish the obligation of states to develop a sustainable national OSHMS.
2. Economic incentives for employers to take measures to improve working conditions through:
- establishing flexible insurance rates based on multifactor analysis (statistics on occupational injuries, working environment conditions and the level of occupational risk by profession and field of activity of each enterprise). For example, in the Republic of Belarus, differentiated insurance rates are established for budgetary organisations and other policyholders. Systems of discounts and surcharges to insurance rates are in place, and a 50% reduction in the insurance contribution rate is provided for public associations of persons with disabilities and pensioners, as well as organisations in which at least 50% of employees are persons with disabilities and pensioners. In the Russian Federation, a methodology for calculating discounts and surcharges to insurance rates is in force (up to 40% of the established insurance rate based on the policyholder’s performance over the previous three years), taking into account the state of occupational safety and health, information on the results of the special assessment of working conditions and information on the results of medical examinations. Additional contributions are established at rates of 2–8% when a special assessment of working conditions is conducted and 6–9% when it is not conducted;
- financing measures to prevent occupational injuries through insurance contributions. In OECD countries, 2–17% of the insurance fund is allocated for these purposes, including preventive measures such as employee training, occupational risk assessment, implementation of OSHMS, procurement of collective and personal protective equipment, development of documentation, etc. For example, in the United States, federal rehabilitation programmes financed through insurance funds provide, where necessary, for physical rehabilitation, retraining, educational courses, workplace changes in cases of injury, and assistance in finding suitable employment. In Germany, statutory accident insurance for occupational accidents and diseases provides prevention before an insured event occurs and after it; rehabilitation (medical, vocational and social); compensation for damage caused (cash payments), disability benefits or lump-sum payments. In the Russian Federation, preventive measures may be partially financed from the funds of the Social Fund of the Russian Federation. The list of such measures is approved annually, with financing amounting to no more than 20% of the insurance contributions paid by the organisation in the previous year;
- differentiating and linking guarantees for work under harmful and/or hazardous working conditions to the actual working conditions. For example, in France, increased coefficients are applied for harmful working conditions depending on the risk category, ranging from 0.5% to 2%.
In the United States, an additional allowance for work under hazardous conditions is provided based on a list of 16 factors and ranges from 8% to 25% of the wage rate. In Germany, the determination and amount of additional wage payments are regulated by collective agreements or agreements between employers and trade unions and range from 5% to 15%. In the Russian Federation and the Republic of Belarus, the results of special assessments and workplace certification serve as the basis for establishing increased remuneration, providing milk and therapeutic and preventive nutrition, as well as differentiated guarantees (depending on the classes of working conditions) in the form of reduced working hours and additional leave. In Japan, reduced working hours are established for persons engaged in underwater and other work associated with health risks.
3. Development of science and education in the field of occupational safety and health, strengthening of strategic partnerships, expansion of the knowledge base, and provision of methodological support to specialists, institutions and other structures operating in the field of occupational safety and health at all levels.
International practice is based on the principles of continuous training of occupational safety and health specialists; the relationship between theory and practice (dual education); adaptability of training; active government participation in national OSHMS in terms of science development, methodological support, categorisation and certification of trainees (maintenance of lists/registers/rosters of lecturers, experts and occupational safety and health specialists), quality control; and mutual responsibility of stakeholders in the field of occupational safety and health.
Training in occupational safety and health in most OECD countries is strictly regulated by the state, provided by specialised institutions and research centres, and financed through insurance contributions.
In the United States, the right to organise and conduct training is subject to restrictions. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) maintains a register of educational and research centres, finances educational programmes for occupational safety and health professionals, allocates grants for university training and coordinates more than 50% of specialist graduates.
In Germany, educational institutions providing courses are subject to mandatory licensing.
In South Korea, free training in risk assessment is provided at the national level by the Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency (KOSHA).
In Singapore, training in the form of workshops or distance learning on occupational safety and health issues is conducted at training centres under the Ministry of Manpower.
In Canada, the Safety Council provides online training on risk management programmes for employees whose work involves risk management and the implementation of risk reduction strategies. In Finland, state-level training in occupational safety and health is provided by the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health through short-term and long-term training programmes.
Under Finnish legislation, obtaining an occupational safety card is possible after completing the relevant occupational safety training and registering with the Finnish Centre for Occupational Safety. In the United Kingdom, a register of consultants in the field of safety and industrial hygiene has been introduced. In France, employers are required to contribute to the financing of vocational training through a mandatory one-time contribution amounting to 0.55–0.8% of the monthly payroll.
4. Application of digital tools for monitoring and control in the field of occupational safety and health. For example, digital and interactive platforms are used in the countries of the European Union. These platforms serve as portals for updating and visualising information on the state of occupational safety and health online. One example of such a tool is the “OSH Barometer”, which is based on statistics, surveys and publicly available data.
In the Republic of Belarus, an extensive network of 12 state control and monitoring bodies operates in the field of occupational safety and health. The state of occupational safety at large and medium-sized enterprises in Belarus is determined using the method of continuous observation, which involves collecting and obtaining information on all units of the population under study. For small enterprises, selective monitoring of occupational safety is provided, based on the principle of random selection of units from the population under study.
In the Russian Federation, among other things, upon the end of an injured employee’s period of temporary incapacity for work, the employer provides information on the consequences of the occupational accident and the measures taken to prevent future accidents. Thus, the state labour inspectorate has information on the consequences of an occupational accident and the measures taken to prevent its recurrence.
In the United States, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) publishes an annual Survey of Occupational Injuries and Illnesses (SOII). In Finland, reports on the results of investigations into occupational accidents and diseases are published on the official website of the Finnish Workers’ Compensation Centre (TVK), which maintains statistics on occupational accidents and diseases and monitors employers’ compliance with their insurance obligations.
Overall, international experience and advanced foreign practices demonstrate that well-planned and systematically implemented occupational safety and health measures generate economic returns that are 3–10 times higher than the financial investments made. Countries that regularly invest financial resources in occupational safety and health have the highest labour productivity and competitive economies.
A full-scale transition to occupational risk assessment, similar to the interactive online risk assessment used in the European Union (the OiRA web platform), will make it possible to create a digital map of enterprises in the Republic of Kazakhstan, providing visualisation of all workplaces according to working conditions and ranking them by individual occupational risk levels.
When creating a unified register of regulations and standards for personal protective equipment, the experience of Switzerland (the state website “Sapros”) may be used. When reforming compulsory insurance against occupational accidents (OSNS), the experience of South Korea, the Russian Federation and the Republic of Belarus in applying flexible insurance rates differentiated according to the level of occupational risk at an enterprise may be used. To prevent occupational injuries through the introduction of a mechanism for financing preventive and rehabilitation measures from the insurance fund, as well as to determine social guarantees, it would be useful to draw on the experience of the United States and European Union countries, including Germany and Finland.
Given the similarity between the occupational accident insurance schemes of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Finland, it would be advisable to apply the Finnish experience in determining requirements for individuals and organisations providing occupational safety and health training or conducting occupational risk assessments.
The application of digital technologies in occupational safety and health and the creation of unified digital platforms will, among other benefits, make it possible to visualise information on the state of occupational safety and health both nationwide and at individual enterprises, as implemented in the countries of the European Union.
3.5 Regulatory Policy and a Differentiated Approach to Management
An analysis of international experience shows that the need for regulatory policy in the field of industrial safety is driven by emerging technological, environmental and social challenges and threats. In the countries of the European Union (EU), a regulatory policy based on the principle of “smart regulation” is implemented. This concept refers to the continuous and systematic improvement of regulatory quality through comprehensive impact assessments at every stage of decision-making, implementation and monitoring, clear coordination among the government authorities concerned, and consideration of the views of all target groups affected. Regulatory policy includes regulatory instruments and rules establishing requirements, parameters and procedures. Its main instruments are permits, control and supervision, and information tools.
At the same time, against the backdrop of the policy pursued in the Republic of Kazakhstan aimed at deregulating state intervention, government regulation in the field of industrial safety remains unchanged in developed countries.
A differentiated approach to state management of industrial safety is applied worldwide. In particular, regulation is restricted to specific industries, for example, legislative regulation of industrial safety in the mining industry (the United States, Canada, Australia, England, Japan and the Russian Federation), without supervision in industries with lower production risks. In many countries, there is a clear trend towards introducing risk assessment systems and categorising facilities according to their hazard levels, which directly affects the degree of state control and supervision.
The organisation of emergency rescue activities in international practice also has its specific features. Rescue services are often sector-specific due to differences in production risks. For example, in the mining industry, account is taken of work in confined spaces, limited visibility, dust levels, the presence of gases harmful to human health in mine atmospheres, etc. Effective organisation of emergency rescue operations in developed countries requires professionally trained specialists in accident response and rescue operations, as well as the availability and use of modern advanced specialised equipment.
As a rule, rescue services are large organisations with several operational units and their own training centres. For example, the coal mining rescue service in England consists of six units: 4 operational units and 2 training centres. In England, legislation provides for contributions to the maintenance of the rescue service in the amount of GBP 0.16 per tonne of coal mined. Emergency rescue services are provided 24 hours a day.
Without a contract with a mine rescue service for emergency rescue coverage, coal mining and processing operations are prohibited. Australia's mine rescue service consists of 4 rescue stations, a gas analysis service, an equipment adjustment and inspection service, a training mine equipped with a modern telemetry and control system, training classrooms for theoretical instruction, and a “Virtual Reality” complex that allows mine workers to practise their actions in the event of an emergency and rescue teams to practise accident response operations in a virtual coal mine environment.
An essential element of the industrial safety system is the establishment of requirements for ensuring safety at production facilities. At the same time, enterprises are oriented towards meeting requirements beyond the established minimum standards by using high-tech equipment, automated telemetry and production management systems, emergency notification systems, monitoring systems with personnel positioning, etc.
3.6 Application of Digital Products in Industrial Safety
In the field of industrial safety, as already mentioned above, information online platforms are comprehensively used in the countries of the European Union to address occupational safety and health and environmental issues. Examples include the OSH Barometer, which is based on statistics, surveys and publicly available data, and OiRA, which is used for interactive online risk assessment. By analogy with the digital tools used internationally, it is necessary to introduce a digital safety map in the Republic of Kazakhstan that will provide real-time assessment of hazard levels and forecasting of accidents and incidents by region and industry, as well as by type of hazardous production facility. Almost all developed countries use digital products to register accidents and incidents and occupational injuries, enabling enterprises to promptly generate relevant reports. Another characteristic feature of the use of digital products in industrial safety worldwide is the availability of a systematised database of information necessary to ensure safety. For example, in the United States, there is a government website containing electronic OSHA QuickCards (including those on lifts, carbon monoxide, construction hazards, electrical safety, hydrogen sulphide, and permit-required confined spaces), as well as OSHA information bulletins (https://www.osha.gov/winter-weather/osha-resources).
Furthermore, a 24-hour information website is supported at the government level to provide assistance during natural disasters (DAIP) and facilitate data exchange between federal, local and private partners (https://www.disasterassistance.gov/about-us/overview).
When creating a unified electronic accident database, the experience of Ireland (https://webapps.hsa.ie) in the use of electronic tools by the Health and Safety Authority may be applied, including BeSMART.ie, HSLearning.ie and WorkPositive.ie (https://www.hsa.ie/eng/business_services_portal/e-tools). It is noteworthy that the safety courses offered by the online platform https://hsalearning.ie are free of charge and available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. The courses take into account industry-specific requirements and various areas of activity (approximately 30 courses), and there is an opportunity to train a group of employees from a single employer. The BeSmart application is an online tool that enables supervised entities (covering more than a hundred different types of businesses in various sectors, including retail, hospitality, manufacturing, services, construction and agribusiness) to prepare a safety statement and conduct a risk assessment free of charge. A significant advantage is the concentration of all the information required to ensure safety on a single digital resource.
Digital Product Passports (DPPs) are also a prominent example that could be introduced in the Republic of Kazakhstan. They can provide consumers and enterprises with information about products, materials, the conditions under which they are manufactured, and their sustainability performance indicators (https://unece.org/info/publications /pub/387846).
Various digital products are also widely used in the field of industrial safety in Hong Kong (https://www.oshc.org.hk/eng/main/osh_info/osh_assess_tools/). For example, a web application allows each industry to conduct inspections using individually developed checklists.
The experience of using online tools to assess whether employees comply with safe behaviour requirements is also of interest. Such tools are used for positions where safety is of critical importance, particularly frontline positions where compliance with safety procedures is essential to ensuring a safe workplace (https://www.rrp.com.au /wellbeing/online-safety-workplace-safety-assessment/).
It is also possible to identify numerous examples of commercial digital products, such as an online accident report book (https://accidentreportbook.com), a modular platform covering a wide range of safety issues, including software for accident reporting, hazard identification, workplace hazard management, etc. (https://www.incidentreport.net/product.php), and training in the field of industrial safety (https://www.testportal.net/en/product/skills-and-knowledge-online-assessment).
The application of digital technologies and the introduction of interactive online platforms will make it possible to collect and analyse data and use it to forecast the state of industrial safety across the country and at individual enterprises, as implemented in the countries of the European Union.
3.7 Resources, Control and Monitoring
Worldwide, the management approach most commonly applied is the integrated management of industrial safety, occupational safety and health, and environmental issues (Environment, Health and Safety (EHS) or HSE). It is aimed at identifying a set of requirements and measures necessary to ensure that the activities of organisations do not cause harm to anyone. In the Republic of Kazakhstan, these issues are regulated by different government authorities. In some countries, certain high-injury-risk activities are also assigned to separate agencies, taking into account their industry-specific characteristics. For example, in the United States, two administrations operate simultaneously: one is the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA), which coordinates all industrial safety issues in the mining industry throughout the United States; the other is the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), which coordinates safety in other sectors, except those falling under the jurisdiction of other federal agencies and the Atomic Energy Act of 1954. OSHA's activities extend to territorial authorities in 26 states, while in the remaining states, local authorities conduct industrial safety activities independently. Their regulatory policies are also reflected in different legislative acts: for MSHA, the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977; for OSHA, the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970. MSHA coordinates interaction among all its participants on safety issues through regulatory and legal mechanisms, the introduction and application of safe work standards, including enforcement (inspections, fines, etc.), specialised training and employer consultations. MSHA supervises approximately 8.7 million production facilities and more than 106 million employees in the private sector. MSHA's territorial bodies comprise 80 local offices subordinate to 10 regional offices. Inspectors conduct approximately 30,000 inspections of industrial facilities annually. In addition to mandatory industrial safety programmes, MSHA implements voluntary programmes according to the following procedure:
- applicants (potential programme participants) submit applications to the relevant MSHA territorial office to participate in a programme and obtain technical specifications for demonstrating compliance with the requirements;
- based on the specifications, proposals are developed and submitted to the regional office, and, following their review and approval, comprehensive inspections of enterprises and their certification are carried out;
- enterprises that successfully pass the comprehensive inspection are included in one of the industrial safety programmes;
- programme participants subsequently undergo annual internal audits of their industrial safety programmes;
- participants undergo scheduled on-site MSHA inspections once every 3–5 years (recertification), or unscheduled inspections in the event of an occupational accident or employee complaints.
The centralised control model based on the integrated management of industrial safety, occupational safety and health, and environmental issues (Environment, Health and Safety (EHS) or HSE) is applied in the Russian Federation. These functions are assigned to the Federal Service for Environmental, Technological and Nuclear Supervision (Rostekhnadzor), a federal executive authority responsible for developing and implementing state policy and regulatory legal frameworks in its designated area, as well as in the fields of technological and nuclear supervision. Control and supervisory activities are carried out directly through territorial bodies in cooperation with other federal government authorities, government authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, local self-government bodies, public associations and other organisations.
The frequency of inspections conducted as part of control and supervisory activities in the field of industrial safety varies across countries. For example, in Canada, scheduled inspections of hazardous production facilities are carried out 4–6 times a year, in addition to unscheduled inspections. No prior notification is given to the entities being inspected. Administrative and criminal liability is provided for violations of industrial safety requirements.
The frequency of scheduled inspections of hazardous production facilities operated by legal entities and individual entrepreneurs in the Russian Federation is established according to their hazard class, depending on the level of potential danger. Hazardous production facilities of Class I or II are inspected no more than once a year; Class III facilities are inspected no more than once every three years; inspections are not conducted for Class IV facilities.
A key resource for any field of activity, particularly industrial safety, where knowledge is an extremely important factor, is human (staff) resources, which must possess the necessary set of competencies. In developed countries, training and advanced professional development in industrial safety are regulated at the legislative level, as they are in the Republic of Kazakhstan, but there are significant differences. For example, in the United States, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) maintains a register of educational and research centres that have been granted limited rights to organise and conduct training and are financed by NIOSH. Similarly, in Germany, educational institutions providing courses are subject to mandatory licensing and are financed through the insurance fund. In South Korea, free training is provided at the national level by the Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency (KOSHA). In Finland, state-level training is provided by the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health through short-term and long-term training programmes, with mandatory registration at the Finnish Centre for Occupational Safety after passing an examination. In the United Kingdom, a register of safety consultants has been introduced.
Section 4. Vision for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety
The main objective of a safe labour market is to create a safe, competitive, predictable and adaptable market, with the creation of new high-quality jobs as its most important priority.
An orientation of the labour market towards quality employment, together with support for automation and digitalisation measures at industrial enterprises, fair support for SMEs, a reduction in occupational risks in workplaces, improved competencies in occupational safety and health, and a revision of the education system paradigm will ensure increased labour productivity, social protection of citizens and balanced territorial development.
In addition, the further development of a safe labour market and industrial safety in the Republic of Kazakhstan requires the following:
- systematic stimulation of demand for high-quality jobs across industries and macro-regions;
- development of human capital and improvement of workforce quality;
- development of labour market infrastructure and enhancement of its inclusiveness;
- creation of an occupational safety and health monitoring system to conduct observations and analyse occupational risks as part of the national OSHMS;
- reduction of violations, accidents, incidents and occupational injuries through the integration of industrial safety into all areas of hazardous activities within the framework of the cyclical service management model “SMART SAFETY”, with a single decision-making centre based on real-time information from digital systems concerning hazardous production facilities.
4.1 The Concept of a “High-Quality Workplace” Should Be Characterised as Follows:
- permanent employment, meaning that an employee must carry out work activities for a period of 6 months or more;
- the level of remuneration is equal to or higher than the median wage in the region (in order to absorb emerging economic shocks, the median wage in the regions is subject to revision every 6 months);
- provision of a social protection package – the presence of monthly mandatory pension contributions, social contributions to the State Social Insurance Fund and the Social Health Insurance Fund, and paid annual leave;
- a safe working environment (the safety of an enterprise's working environment is assessed using a methodology comparing the number of occupational injuries and fatalities with the number of workplaces in the relevant industry).
4.2 Creation of an Occupational Safety and Health Monitoring System for Conducting Observations and Analysing Occupational Risks as Part of the National OSHMS
The national OSHMS will be improved, taking into account the introduction of an integrated occupational risk assessment model, the creation of a digital map of enterprises and the implementation of international occupational safety standards.
A new mechanism for providing personal protective equipment will make it possible to rationalise employers' costs and increase the effectiveness of the impact of personal protective equipment on the level of occupational injuries and occupational diseases.
For the purpose of providing economic incentives to employers, the insurance rate under the compulsory occupational accident insurance (OSNS) contract will be established taking into account the enterprise's occupational risk level. Additionally, a mechanism will be introduced for financing employers' costs for preventive and rehabilitation measures from the insurance premium.
Conditions will be created for the high-quality provision of educational, informational, methodological and consulting services in the field of occupational safety and health to develop human resources, material and technical facilities, and scientific and educational potential.
The monitoring system will be used to implement control measures at various levels, which will enable the gradual improvement of OSHMS performance indicators at regional and sectoral levels, demonstrating a reduction in the existing gap between low and high levels of occupational injury risk.
4.3 Cyclical Service Management Model “SMART SAFETY”
The new cyclical service model for the development of industrial safety in the Republic of Kazakhstan should place effective interaction among government authorities, production control entities and specialised market participants at the centre of state interests, with a clear division of their respective competences, the assignment of responsibilities and the use of available capabilities to prevent accidents and incidents at production facilities through the development of digital technologies and the updating of legislation. By implementing phased measures to minimise its involvement in regulating enterprise activities, the state, recognising the priority of industrial safety, will focus on ensuring 100% safety at hazardous production facilities by establishing a vertical structure of public administration with a single decision-making centre, while promoting transparency in the regulation of specialised market participants and the development of institutional infrastructure for industrial safety.
Section 5. Main Principles and Approaches to Development
The drivers of growth in quality employment should be the industrialisation of key sectors of the economy, as well as the widespread introduction and promotion of new technologies that increase labour productivity and create new types of employment.
These areas envisage an increase in the number of enterprises, the size and scale of existing businesses, and the transition of businesses from the shadow economy into the formal sector.
An integrated systemic approach is required to effectively stimulate demand from the economy, taking into account the following factors:
- the current level of development of industries and plans for the creation of new production facilities (based on the Unified Industrialisation Map);
- strategic objectives for increasing the technological complexity of production capacities;
- forecasts of human capital development linked to demographic indicators;
- the level of development of technical and vocational education and training (TVET);
- the industrial and infrastructure characteristics of the macro-region.
Overall, to address the objective of increasing labour productivity and improving the quality of life of the population, the economy needs to create 1.5 million new high-quality jobs.
The policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of occupational safety is based on compliance with the following fundamental principles:
- systematic and continuous improvement of working conditions based on a risk-oriented approach to occupational safety and health management;
- prevention and balance based on the adaptation of international standards in the field of occupational safety and health;
- responsibility and engagement based on social partnership among all participants in employment relationships;
- objectivity and awareness based on comprehensive coverage by reliable information in the field of occupational safety and health;
- reliability of baseline data on working conditions and occupational risks at workplaces.
All the above principles, developed on the basis of a factor analysis of the current situation and global trends, are fundamental to the formation of the following development areas in occupational safety and health and the main approaches to implementing the Concept:
- modernisation of the national OSHMS based on a risk-oriented approach;
- economic incentives for measures aimed at reducing occupational risks;
- development of professional competencies and scientific potential in the field of occupational safety and health;
- improving the effectiveness of control and monitoring in the field of occupational safety and health.
The development of state policy in the field of industrial safety in the Republic of Kazakhstan will be ensured through compliance with the following fundamental principles:
- systematic, cyclical and closed-loop management based on risk assessment (effective safety management includes identifying and managing risks, developing policies and procedures, providing training, creating a strong safety culture, using protective equipment, conducting regular inspections, ensuring emergency preparedness and establishing incident reporting systems);
- progress and balance in harmonising international standards, introducing scientific developments and innovative solutions, and modernising production and technologies;
- cooperation and responsibility – active involvement of specialised market participants in ensuring safety at supervised entities through long-term and mutually beneficial cooperation and continuous dialogue;
- transparency, openness, timeliness and reliability of information, provided in full and made publicly available when formulating and implementing state policy at all stages of its implementation, as well as ensuring awareness and information access for all persons responsible for ensuring safety;
- differentiation and specificity of protection of hazardous production facilities, taking into account their hazard level, including the degree of state supervision over activities at hazardous production facilities depending on their hazard level;
- ESG principles and “safe production” reflect an orientation towards minimising impact and promoting sustainable development through the positive impact of business activities on the production, social and environmental spheres. The introduction of safe methods and technologies can help minimise negative impacts, improve a company's reputation and lead to long-term cost savings.
Direction 1. Human Capital Development
The strategic objective of improving workforce qualifications and ensuring continuous skills development should cover both young people who have yet to enter the labour market and the existing workforce.
The need for new skills arising from the automation of work processes will be addressed by creating conditions for continuous self-education and professional development, including with employer support.
Skills are of decisive importance for the future of the labour market in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Workers in the Republic of Kazakhstan need jobs. At the same time, not only their number but also their quality and accessibility are important.
1.1. Measures to Improve the Quality of Technical and Vocational Education and Training
Based on the objectives set, stimulating demand for TVET should become the central element in training and retraining personnel for the new economy. The key factors in improving the quality of TVET are close coordination with businesses and alignment with the strategic areas of economic development. For this purpose, the clustering of TVET institutions by industry and region is proposed, as well as their transfer into trust management in priority areas.
The task ahead is to change the structure of the education system. Whereas the current ratio of graduates of TVET organisations to graduates of higher and/or postgraduate education organisations is 46 to 54, the objective is to bring this ratio to 70 to 30, respectively.
The quality of TVET is expected to be improved through the following measures:
- introduction of modern management practices in TVET organisations included in clusters;
- joint work between schools and TVET institutions to provide practical skills within TVET institutions;
- transfer of TVET organisations into the trust management of large enterprises within the framework of offtake contracts;
- clustering of TVET institutions to improve the effectiveness of educational programmes, with the designation of “anchor” institutions and the introduction of modern management practices;
- specialisation of TVET organisations in line with the development of industrial clusters in the economy and the introduction of network-based learning;
- introduction of an early vocational diagnostic programme for schoolchildren and guidance towards in-demand professions;
- recognition of TVET learning outcomes for the continuation of education at higher and/or postgraduate education organisations.
A special role is assigned to TVET in addressing the issue of the spatial redistribution of labour resources to regions with growing economic potential. Taking into account migration from rural areas to cities, TVET institutions located in rural areas should be adapted to train human capital with skills and competencies applicable in industrial production and the urban economy.
To implement this area, coordination is also required among employers in target regions, TVET institutions and local executive bodies, as well as a unified digital system containing data on college students and graduates and their qualifications.
Furthermore, it is necessary to develop a system for consolidating the process of training in relevant skills (from educational programmes to practical training) and subsequent career development. In practice, TVET institutions will be able to monitor the achievement of students' learning outcomes, automatically manage the process of professional development and subsequent career progression, and standardise the training of qualified personnel in accordance with the requirements of specific enterprises by requesting the skills directly needed in workplaces. The system will contain, store and subsequently use data on college students and graduates.
Upon completion of their studies, the system will automatically upload students' CVs to the electronic labour exchange and select a list of vacancies for employment, subsequently tracking the dates of employment contract conclusion.
The full-scale use of the system will make it possible to subsequently compile rankings of educational organisations based on the employment outcomes of college students directly in their chosen field of training.
1.2. Measures to Develop the National Qualifications System
According to international practice, one of the main solutions to the problem of skills mismatches is an effective national qualifications system that timely reflects changes in skills demand amid continuous technological transformations of job functions.
The foundation for establishing a link between the labour market and the personnel training system will be laid through the regular updating of the national classification of occupations as the main instrument for diagnosing the labour market. The classification will also ensure the development of high-quality requirements for the workforce.
With the direct participation of businesses, work will continue on developing new and updating existing professional standards, which will become the basic document for establishing qualification requirements for employees and determining the complexity of types of work. Serving as a benchmark for labour market requirements in a specific field, professional standards will effectively constitute technical specifications from businesses for training specialists. By defining a comprehensive set of knowledge, skills and competencies for all professions and occupations, professional standards will serve as the basis for harmonising existing legislation.
Furthermore, professional standards should also become the basis for developing the “Skills Bank” reference guide, which will make it possible to establish a unified list of professional skills for specific groups of occupations, as well as serve as a condition for developing and updating educational programmes in technical and vocational, higher and postgraduate education, online courses, and introducing certification for the recognition of qualifications and skills in accordance with the requirements of employers, the labour market and the new economy. Data on in-demand skills, coded and appropriately systematised, should be accessible to the entire population.
In this regard, businesses, workers' associations and the state will determine the areas of human capital development and share responsibility for its future.
1.3. Measures to Encourage Enterprises to Improve Their Employees’ Competencies and Internal Mobility
An important area of state policy is the creation of conditions to encourage businesses to participate in the training and retraining of qualified professional personnel for the needs of their industries. Given the serious problems in coordinating educational organisations with business needs, transferring TVET institutions into the ownership or trust management of enterprises occupying leading positions in their industries will not only help improve the availability of qualified personnel but will also ensure the transfer of industry knowledge and innovation.
To increase workforce mobility, the following measures will be proposed:
- horizontal mobility for released workers through intersectoral transfers and involvement in entrepreneurial activities;
- stimulation of internal mobility within the framework of investment projects providing for the creation of mass employment, as well as the development of housing and transport infrastructure to create centres of economic growth outside agglomerations (the cities of Astana, Almaty and Shymkent);
- stimulation of workforce relocation to regions experiencing labour shortages and the creation of new high-quality jobs in priority sectors of the economy.
Furthermore, to encourage enterprises to invest in personnel training and retraining, measures will be provided for partial or full government subsidisation. In addition to improving workforce quality, this will, in the long term, contribute to increasing enterprises' interest in retaining and further developing their employees.
The state will provide the following measures to encourage the private sector to improve the competencies of its employees:
- provision of grants and subsidies to enterprises;
- development and introduction of a certification system to determine the level of knowledge and skills required of employees;
- support for educational institutions providing employee training in the form of government grants or subsidies;
- conducting information campaigns on the need to improve professional skills and competencies.
These measures will encourage enterprises to invest in employee training and development, resulting in improved qualifications and competitiveness of enterprises, as well as increased productivity and economic growth throughout the country.
The growing number of young people must be prepared for employment, with the main focus areas being the improvement of skills, involvement in entrepreneurship and assistance with employment in partnership with employers.
Youth internships, employment support projects involving the transfer of experience from the older generation, employment opportunities for first-time jobseekers, and support for young entrepreneurs in the creative industries will be the main areas of support for youth employment.
An important measure in partnership with employers is targeted support for NEET youth² in overcoming barriers to employment through workplace-based training.
The concept of “lifelong learning” should become central to the personal, educational and professional development of every citizen. From the school years until retirement, every person's life path should be accompanied by continuous learning. In this regard, vocational guidance is becoming increasingly important, particularly support in choosing a career path at an early age. Work is currently underway in this area to introduce and develop the digital information platform “Career Guide”.
Today, in an era of rapid industrial and digital transformation and the growing value of digital skills, the focus is shifting from a “degree in a speciality” to the actual skills of specialists. Education is a central element of skills development, but knowledge is not equivalent to skills. In this regard, alongside the traditional education system, the role of online learning is becoming critical.
The large-scale outcomes of online learning will include:
- improving qualifications or acquiring skills that are genuinely in demand in the labour market;
- ensuring prompt retraining in response to the rapid changes in professional knowledge, abilities and skills;
- eliminating digital illiteracy and developing the digital culture of citizens.
² Young people who are not employed, not engaged in education or vocational training or retraining, and are outside the employment system.
Direction 2. Stimulating Demand for High-Quality Jobs
2.1. Creation of High-Quality Jobs in the Mining Industry
The mining industry is one of the main drivers of the economy. The creation of new high-quality jobs in this sector will be associated with the modernisation and expansion of existing production facilities through:
- improving the quality, transparency and accessibility of geological information, in particular, launching the digital subsoil use system into commercial operation, which will ensure transparency of business processes and reduce transaction costs when obtaining geological information, submitting applications and monitoring investments (in turn, this will provide open access to all geological reports, followed by access to primary digitised geological materials, with the exception of classified and confidential information);
- adopting effective and optimal measures for all parties to support employees released as a result of the modernisation of enterprises in the mining and metallurgical sectors. Local executive bodies and large strategically important mining and metallurgical companies, with the support of sectoral and functional central government authorities, should develop a coordinated policy to support employees released as a result of technological modernisation and/or reductions in the scale of enterprise activities.
In 2025, there were 165.9 thousand high-quality jobs in the mining industry, while according to expert estimates, the number of high-quality jobs will reach up to 270 thousand by 2030.
2.2. Creation of High-Quality Jobs in the Manufacturing Industry
The manufacturing industry is also one of the key generators of high-quality jobs in the economy. As in the mining industry, increasing the number of high-quality jobs requires the modernisation and expansion of existing production facilities, as well as the corresponding development of sales channels and infrastructure through:
- pursuing proactive trade policies in foreign and domestic markets to develop commodity production. The development and accessibility of markets are key factors in attracting investment. There is a significant difference between trade policies in the mining and manufacturing industries. The raw materials market is generally a seller's market, and success in it largely depends on a company's ability to ensure the supply of products with the highest quantity and accessibility of extractable useful substances at the lowest possible price. Competition is primarily based on price;
- implementing a unified approach to the comprehensive systemic development of manufacturing and trade in order to realise both export potential and the basic provision of domestic market needs, following the example of most developing countries. In manufacturing, the number of business models and competitive strategies is much broader and more complex. Therefore, competent sectoral teams should be established to promote various types of industrial goods to different customer groups: from standard industrial semi-finished products such as base metals, chemicals and fertilisers, whose demand is determined by price, to consumer goods, whose demand is determined by branding;
- focusing foreign trade policy efforts on eliminating non-tariff trade barriers within the EAEU, with the People's Republic of China and with Central Asian countries. This requires continuous dialogue with existing manufacturing exporters to identify actual needs and barriers in foreign trade;
- establishing industrial cooperation systems and developing regional clusters, creating and expanding production facilities in border regions that ensure integration (taking into account the region's competitive advantages) into cross-border value chains for the development of commodity production. The Republic of Kazakhstan should become more actively involved in the markets of Central and South Asia and offer manufacturers from these countries favourable conditions for establishing production facilities serving the EAEU markets;
- stimulating technology transfer and localisation through the civil offset mechanism to gain access to technologies and localise new types of high-tech products for the Republic of Kazakhstan. The legislation on regulated procurement should provide for the possibility of concluding offset agreements alongside the main contract for the supply of imported high-tech and high-value products. An important condition for developing domestic production is the protection of the domestic market against economic smuggling and the supply of low-quality goods through the use of technical regulations and national standards. This will require overcoming sabotage and threats from powerful lobbying groups whose businesses are built on such activities;
- stimulating spatial and industrial development through the proactive provision of energy, water, transport and logistics, engineering and digital infrastructure. It is necessary to increase the attractiveness of manufacturing by reducing costs and increasing returns on invested resources. This can only be achieved through systematic work aimed at aligning industrial and spatial development to create, expand and provide specialised factors of production. Efforts should focus on developing high-quality industrial and digital infrastructure, human capital, centres of competence, and testing and certification infrastructure. The creation of spatial “growth points” with specialised factors of production will help attract investors and stimulate industry growth;
- improving the efficiency of the manufacturing industry, where it is important to identify and support enterprises capable of competing effectively in both domestic and foreign markets. Such support may take the form of reducing barriers to access to equity financing, providing long-term lending through development institutions, granting industrial grants for technological modernisation, providing industrial mortgages at a negative effective interest rate, easing regulation and introducing other incentives that strengthen enterprises' competitive positions.
At the same time, support must be provided on a transparent and fair basis, without favouritism or discrimination. It is important to identify these effective enterprises in close cooperation with the business community and provide them with the necessary support.
To ensure successful technology transfer and attract entrepreneurial talent to industrial production, migration policy will provide for reducing transaction costs associated with attracting qualified foreign human resources. Foreign specialists will be attracted to ensure the proactive training of domestic personnel and the creation of national (international/regional) centres of competence in professions experiencing shortages, in cooperation with leading global companies. Invited specialists will be provided with convenient working arrangements, simplified procedures for obtaining all necessary permits, and visas for in-demand professions with the issuance of residence permits.
In 2025, there were 317.1 thousand high-quality jobs in the manufacturing industry. According to expert estimates, the target number of high-quality jobs will reach up to 524 thousand by 2030.
2.3. Stimulating Demand for High-Quality Jobs in the Construction and Transport Industries
The labour market development policy in the construction industry is aimed at stimulating the creation of new high-quality jobs, primarily in the private sector, subject to ensuring their quality and accessibility.
Measures in the construction industry are determined by the fact that economic activity in this sector directly depends on economic activity in other sectors of the economy, primarily industry and its infrastructure. It should be taken into account that measures to stimulate quality employment in construction must be consolidated with coordinated changes in industrial or infrastructure policy.
The key measures will include revising public procurement procedures for construction works in terms of qualification requirements (median wage, occupational safety and health and other requirements, number of permanent employees), as well as changing approaches to allocating land plots for the construction of multi-apartment residential buildings in order to stimulate competition in the housing construction market. When local executive bodies conduct tenders for the allocation of such land plots, the volume of residential floor space to be provided by the developer to akimats as payment for the land plots will be established as the key criterion instead of cost. The housing obtained in this manner will be used by akimats exclusively to meet the housing needs of people on the state housing waiting list.
As of 2025, there were 152.2 thousand high-quality jobs in the construction industry. According to expert estimates, the target number of high-quality jobs by 2030, following the implementation of demand stimulation measures, will amount to 191 thousand.
The transport industry is of great importance to the economy, as it provides connections between producers and consumers and contributes to the development of trade, industry and agriculture. The transport industry also creates numerous jobs and invests in innovations and technologies that improve the efficiency and safety of transportation.
To create high-quality jobs in the transport industry, a comprehensive set of measures is required to increase the investment attractiveness of all subsectors (road transport, rail transport and air transport), as well as to stimulate further digitalisation of the industry in order to increase labour productivity.
As of the end of 2025, the number of high-quality jobs in the transport industry amounted to 232.2 thousand. According to expert estimates, this figure will reach 298 thousand jobs by 2030.
2.4. Stimulating Demand for High-Quality Jobs in Agriculture, Trade and Services
The agricultural sector is of great importance to the economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan, as it is a source of food, raw materials, income and employment for a significant part of the population. Agriculture also affects the development of other industries, such as food processing, light industry, chemicals and mechanical engineering.
To stimulate demand for high-quality jobs in agriculture, it is necessary to implement comprehensive measures aimed at increasing labour productivity and the competitiveness of agriculture as a field of employment. These measures include clustering agriculture and enterprises using a mechanism of reciprocal obligations in providing state support for priority areas (establishment of farms, anchor cooperation, financing of service businesses), developing and widely disseminating applied technologies in agricultural science, and creating a network of agricultural competence centres based at TVET institutions to train personnel.
It is also necessary to focus on the technological development of agriculture. In particular, measures should be adopted to provide state incentives for increasing land productivity (crop yields) and the productivity of animals and poultry (milk yields, weight gain, wool clip, egg production, etc.), while stimulating the introduction of new technologies, new varieties and breeds.
Ниже приведён полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением исходной структуры, заголовков, нумерации, абзацев и содержания текста.
For this purpose, it is necessary to reform the system of state support for agriculture, primarily the subsidy system.
The transition from subsidizing factors of production (machinery, seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, livestock, etc.) to direct subsidization of final products will encourage participants in the supply chain to produce larger quantities of higher-quality agricultural products.
The number of quality jobs in agriculture amounts to 64.1 thousand. According to expert estimates, this indicator will reach approximately 101 thousand jobs by 2030.
The services sector in the Republic of Kazakhstan makes a significant contribution to the country's economy, accounting for 52.5% of the country's GDP (2022). The sector covers a wide range of activities, such as trade, telecommunications, finance, real estate and public administration. Unlike more capital-intensive industries, the development of the services sector is necessarily associated with the engagement of labour resources, including those released from other sectors of the economy.
Given the potential for competitive development and the structure of the industry, the development of the labour market in the services sector requires stimulating private investment in the construction of transport and logistics infrastructure (wholesale distribution and logistics centres, warehouses, fulfilment centres, agricultural product storage facilities), as well as the development of a certification system.
For services related to the knowledge economy (creative economy, scientific and technical activities), the critical priorities are the provision of infrastructure and the elimination of institutional barriers in the form of restrictions on competition.
In order to create favourable conditions for the development of trade, including e-commerce, public policy measures will focus on addressing several key objectives:
development of modern retail formats and reduction of the shortage of modern-format retail space by introducing indicative standards for local executive bodies regarding the provision of modern-format retail space to the population, primarily in urban areas;
development of trade and logistics infrastructure, including wholesale distribution and logistics centres, warehouses, distribution centres (fulfilment centres), agricultural product storage facilities, etc.;
stimulating an increase in the volume of foreign trade transactions through a significant reduction in customs clearance times and the elimination of infrastructure bottlenecks in order to increase its capacity;
development of a product certification system to reduce the time required to obtain certificates and improve access for products from the Republic of Kazakhstan to foreign markets.
In 2025, the trade sector had 310.0 thousand quality jobs, exceeding expert expectations, which had forecast this target indicator to reach 285 thousand jobs by 2030.
2.5. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs Taking into Account Macro-Regions
Systematic demand stimulation should be aimed at the balanced development of macro-regions. To this end, it is necessary to pursue a policy of economic diversification, ensuring the transfer of investment and labour resources from the extractive industry and low-productivity agricultural sectors to manufacturing and high-productivity service sectors of the economy, which will increase the average per capita income of the country's population.
Creating conditions for labour migration following the availability of quality jobs will make it possible to effectively distribute labour flows across regions and industries.
At the same time, increasing the number and quality of jobs will require retraining and education aimed at changing regional and sectoral specialisation, which is crucial for a just transition, as well as including a criterion for expanding and creating quality jobs when providing state support to business entities.
Systematic demand stimulation in the southern macro-region – initial industrialisation and workforce mobility.
The labour force forecast through 2030 for the southern macro-region indicates an annual increase of up to 200 thousand people, primarily driven by young people. At the same time, the macro-region is expected to have a high concentration of the labour force by 2030 (more than 35% of the total labour force of the Republic of Kazakhstan).
The median wage of employees in the macro-region is the lowest in the Republic of Kazakhstan (178.5 thousand tenge). The employment structure is characterised by a high level of employment in agriculture (50% of agricultural workers are employed in the south of the country) and a low proportion of workers in the industrial sector (15% – the lowest indicator among the macro-regions).
Addressing the task of increasing incomes in the southern regions of the country, where a large proportion of the population is employed in agriculture, requires changing the economic structure of these regions. To this end, attractive conditions must be created for initial industrialisation in these regions, making the maximum possible use of the potential of existing special economic and industrial zones.
The establishment of "industrialisation hubs" in the southern regions is proposed through the implementation of such measures as the localisation of production and further development of industry clusters in light and food industries, as well as in the construction materials sector. The development of manufacturing requires the creation of infrastructure, as well as the training and retraining of personnel for initial industrialisation projects in the south (primarily in light industry).
Based on the demographic characteristics of other macro-regions, it is also necessary to ensure targeted training and the provision of workforce inflows to central and eastern Kazakhstan. Current labour market trends also require ensuring high-quality labour migration from labour-surplus regions of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
For high-quality workforce training within the framework of initial industrialisation, it is necessary to reorganise the technical and vocational education and training (TVET) system, increase the proportion of specialised colleges and enhance cooperation with industry enterprises.
Systematic demand stimulation in the central-eastern macro-region – economic reindustrialisation.
The labour force forecast through 2030 for the central-eastern macro-region indicates a 10% decrease in the total labour force in the region over seven years, as well as an increase in the proportion of young people in the labour force, with more than 30 thousand people entering the labour market annually.
The median wage of employees in the macro-region amounts to 203.2 thousand tenge. The employment structure is characterised by a high level of employment in industry.
The priority area for creating new jobs and increasing the incomes of the population in the central-eastern macro-region should be the reindustrialisation of the regional economy, that is, it is necessary first to restore industry and subsequently develop it.
To implement this objective, measures are required to develop and modernise industrial infrastructure, as well as establish modern research centres to develop technologies, increase the technological complexity of existing production facilities and attract major technology companies.
Based on the economic and demographic characteristics of the macro-region, it is necessary to ensure intersectoral labour transfers from the extractive industry to manufacturing, as well as the inflow of qualified personnel from other regions, accompanied by appropriate targeted training and retraining based on the TVET system.
Systematic demand stimulation in the northern macro-region – clustering of agribusiness.
The northern macro-region is characterised by a predominantly negative labour force forecast – the total labour force in the region has decreased by 12% over seven years, while fewer than 30 thousand people enter the labour market annually (the lowest indicator in the country). An additional factor is the high migration pressure from metropolitan areas and border regions.
The median wage of employees in the macro-region is the second lowest in the Republic of Kazakhstan after the south (186.7 thousand tenge). The employment structure is also characterised by a high level of employment in agriculture (25% of agricultural workers) and a low proportion of workers in the industrial sector (18%).
Increasing the proportion of quality jobs in the northern regions of the country, taking into account their specialisation in grain production, is possible through the clustering of agricultural enterprises. To this end, the following measures must be implemented comprehensively:
development of clusters comprising production and processing companies to cover the entire cycle of agricultural production and processing, including consumables;
increasing labour productivity through the introduction of new technologies;
creation of infrastructure for a unified system of agricultural product procurement, storage and supply chains within a single cluster.
Key objectives also include reducing the outflow of personnel by linking the workforce training system with regional industrialisation projects, as well as training personnel with an emphasis on the automation and digitalisation of agriculture.
Systematic demand stimulation in the western macro-region – development of domestic value programmes by subsoil users.
The labour force forecast through 2030 for the western macro-region is characterised by predominantly positive trends – an increase in the total labour force in the region and a 1.5-fold increase in the number of young people entering the labour market (up to 40 thousand people).
The employment structure is characterised by a high level of employment in industry and an extremely low level of employment in agriculture (6%). More than 90% of the gross regional product (GRP) of the western macro-region is generated by the extractive industry – a high-productivity sector with a limited number of jobs created. The median wage of employees in the macro-region amounts to 227.7 thousand tenge.
The priority area for creating quality jobs and increasing the incomes of the population in the western macro-region should also be the industrialisation of the regional economy – launching projects to establish long-term partnerships and consortia with subsoil users in order to support the establishment and development of businesses.
The creation of new industrial facilities must be carried out using the mechanism of offtake contracts for the localisation and establishment of new production facilities and the mechanism of offset contracts for technology transfer and investment attraction.
To ensure effective staffing for industrialisation programmes in the western macro-region, a programme is needed to attract the best personnel in order to improve the quality of preschool and secondary education and TVET.
Direction 3. Creating Conditions for an Effective Link Between the Economy and the Human Capital Development System to Match Supply and Demand
One of the main tasks of central and local executive bodies is to create new jobs.
At present, job creation is primarily generated by projects implemented within the framework of State Planning System documents, investment projects and programmes aimed at stimulating the development of small and medium-sized enterprises.
In this regard, planned job creation indicators will be included in regional employment maps.
Monitoring of job creation, as well as the employment of the population, will be carried out through the digital systems of the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan (the automated digital system "Labour Market", the digital system "Integrated Job Creation Map" and the Electronic Labour Exchange).
3.1. Reorganisation of the Activities of Labour Mobility Centres and Further Improvement of the Digital Labour Market Ecosystem
Comprehensive training systems for employees of labour mobility centres will be established, including continuous professional development based on unified programmes and methodologies corresponding to modern trends in the development of the labour market and employment services. An assessment of employees' acquired knowledge will also be conducted, qualification categories will be assigned based on the results of certification, and the remuneration system will be improved.
The task of the labour mobility centre will be to ensure an individual approach to working with unemployed persons and to develop an appropriate and sufficient range of services for them, that is, a transition to working with unemployed persons based on case management principles will be ensured.
New approaches to the work of labour mobility centres will be implemented based on the needs and interests of citizens and employers. Full digitalisation of all state support instruments will also be carried out, and digital employment services will be introduced.
Within the framework of the "Digital Employment Service" project, work will continue to reduce the proportion of services provided offline through visits to labour mobility centre offices and to shift the priority towards digital channels of interaction between job seekers and employers and employment authorities.
The digital transformation of employment authorities will provide for the complete transition of service delivery to a digital format. Mechanisms for remote career counselling, video CVs and video interviews with employers will be developed, and artificial intelligence will be used to match vacancies with CVs during job searches.
The strategy of digital employment authorities will be focused on ensuring equal access to services for all interested parties.
The digitalisation of employment services will contribute to improving the quality and transparency of services provided, the speed and convenience of obtaining state support measures for citizens and employers, and reducing bureaucratic barriers.
As part of the further development of the Electronic Labour Exchange, services for individual vacancy selection based on skills using artificial intelligence will be developed, including:
a career path builder and career guidance tool;
opportunities for regional and international labour migration;
expanding accessibility and ensuring the widespread availability of online training;
independent skills assessment and certification;
conclusion of electronic employment contracts;
the electronic service "Platform Employment".
This will enable citizens to move from simply searching for jobs to proactive employment, as well as create conditions for increasing incomes through skills development, labour mobility and simplified formalisation of employment relationships.
3.2. Formalisation of Platform Employment
In 2023, a pilot project on the formalisation of platform employment was implemented, providing for a single monthly tax payment amounting to 1% of income. On 1 July 2023, the Social Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan entered into force, establishing provisions for the regulation of platform employment, in particular, introducing a relevant article and terminology and defining the procedure for interaction between parties to platform employment, as well as their rights and obligations.
For the final formalisation of platform employment, it is necessary to introduce a new tax regime for persons engaged through internet platforms, including by amending the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Taxes and Other Mandatory Payments to the Budget" (the Tax Code), the Social Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Compulsory Social Health Insurance".
3.3. Increasing Labour Market Inclusiveness
Creating Opportunities for Persons of Pre-Retirement (Older) Age
As the retirement age threshold increases, there is a growing need to support the employment of persons of pre-retirement age in order to increase their level of economic activity.
To implement this area, it is proposed to develop three main mechanisms for ensuring opportunities for older persons:
incentivising employers to hire persons of pre-retirement age through wage subsidies, which will allow older people to continue working until they officially reach retirement age and thereby ensure a decent old age;
involving older workers in a culture of "lifelong learning" for continuous professional development through skills acquisition. Wide access to and relevance of the skills acquired during training will be ensured through online learning on a free state platform. The combination of professional experience and the acquisition of new skills will allow older persons to remain competitive in the labour market and not fall behind younger workers.
Creating Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities
Creating employment opportunities for persons with disabilities and involving them in economic activity is an important area of inclusion policy. Able-bodied citizens with special needs should not be left out but should be included in productive employment on an equal basis with everyone else. To this end, social protection and digitalisation tools for work activities will be actively used.
The following instruments will be applied to promote the employment of persons with disabilities:
incentivising the hiring of persons with disabilities through wage subsidies, as well as reimbursement of expenses for workplace adaptation and training;
establishing employment quotas for persons with disabilities, as well as incentivising the use of quotas to hire new employees rather than merely maintain existing jobs;
developing a system of support for and incentives towards employment depending on the degree of work capacity, aspirations and social characteristics of a person with a disability, without being limited to a formal assessment of the medical certificate.
Entrepreneurship among persons with disabilities should also be encouraged through the development of comprehensive targeted entrepreneurship support programmes.
Direction 4. Ensuring Occupational Safety
4.1. Modernisation of the National Occupational Safety and Health Management System Based on a Risk-Oriented Approach
The task of modernising the national OSH management system will be implemented based on a risk-oriented approach. A set of measures will be implemented to provide regulatory and methodological support for the development of the methodological framework relating to the classification and assessment of working conditions.
A new integrated occupational risk assessment model will be introduced, including data on compliance with labour legislation requirements, the results of individual occupational risk assessments, and indicators of occupational injuries (OI) and occupational diseases (OD).
Depending on the size of an enterprise, occupational safety requirements will not be reduced; however, they will have certain specific features. In this regard, simplified requirements for occupational safety and health management systems at small and micro-enterprises in certain "low-risk" industries (cleaning services, organisation of cultural and leisure events, small-scale retail trade and others) will be developed, with the introduction of the possibility of rapid occupational risk assessment (including online assessment).
Approaches will be developed for identifying and measuring occupational factors under special working conditions (underground work, outdoor work, work at heights and the like), as well as for assessing the combined impact of occupational factors and classifying workplaces according to the degree of occupational risk.
The introduction of a risk-oriented approach provides for the elimination of the APO procedure. A "Digital Enterprise Map" will be created for the integrated assessment and classification of enterprises according to their risk levels. This will require the integration of state digital systems for monitoring working conditions and occupational risks, environmental monitoring and production control.
The timeliness and quality of occupational risk assessments will become a priority. In this regard, requirements for specialised organisations will be strengthened in terms of the quality of their personnel, and liability for the results of their work will be established.
The application of a matrix method for distributing personal protective equipment (PPE), based on specific harmful and/or hazardous occupational factors and their ranking according to the degree of occupational risk, will simplify the employer's selection of PPE. Social guarantees will be provided using a similar methodology.
Research will be conducted on the introduction of preventive medical monitoring depending on the results of occupational risk assessments, aimed at strengthening methods for early identification of risk groups, as well as improving medical regulations governing the admission of employees to work under harmful and/or hazardous working conditions. The results of medical examinations will include recommendations for employers on implementing health improvement and treatment measures, including the prevention of exacerbations of chronic diseases, therapeutic nutrition, therapeutic physical exercise, medical massage, rehabilitation measures aimed at preserving work capacity, and sanatorium and resort treatment.
Increased attention will be paid to hazardous production facilities in accordance with Article 70 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Civil Protection". Measures aimed at reducing the risk of emergencies, industrial accidents and occupational diseases will be implemented, taking into account international standards.
To achieve maximum effectiveness in ensuring safe working conditions and combining international standards with national policy measures, the issues of ratifying ILO Convention No. 176 "Safety and Health in Mines", as well as the need to introduce corresponding amendments and additions to the current labour legislation, will be considered.
4.2. Economic Incentives for Measures to Reduce Occupational Risks
As part of the measures to transform the state mechanism for providing guarantees to employees working under harmful and/or hazardous conditions, a new procedure (mechanism) for determining the types and scope of such guarantees will be established, including their proactive provision based on the results of occupational risk assessments.
It is necessary to introduce new financial and economic measures that will contribute to increasing employers' involvement in improving working conditions. In this regard, methodological approaches will be developed for economic planning of occupational safety expenditures, as well as assessing their effectiveness, with the introduction of an online application for preparing occupational safety expenditure budgets (by expenditure category).
Positive international experience in financing preventive occupational safety measures from compulsory occupational accident insurance (COAI) funds will be applied, including occupational risk assessments and employee training in the fundamentals of occupational safety. A differentiated tariff based on a two-component model will be established, depending on the occupational risk class determined by the type of economic activity and the degree of occupational risk as a performance indicator resulting from its assessment. Appropriate actuarial calculations will be carried out when updating the insurance tariff. The preventive focus of COAI will be expanded, ensuring the achievement of the key objectives of insurance: tariff justification, the correctness or adequacy of the insured amount, and the completeness of data for determining risk.
In order to reduce mortality among persons with disabilities, the issue of providing medical assistance during the early period following the loss of work capacity, implementing rehabilitation programmes and taking measures in cases requiring additional treatment, including financing through COAI, will be examined.
4.3. Development of Professional Competencies and Scientific Potential in the Field of Occupational Safety
Personnel development in the field of occupational safety will be achieved through the introduction of new types and methods of training (relevant programmes, distance learning, simulators and simulation models).
For the effective implementation of the task of developing professional competencies and scientific potential in the field of occupational safety, conditions will be created for scientific and educational development, provision of material and technical equipment, and the high-quality delivery of educational, informational, methodological and consulting services in the field of occupational safety.
Mandatory training, retraining and advanced professional development will be provided for occupational safety specialists, technical occupational safety inspectors, chairpersons of production councils and occupational safety experts.
Requirements for organisations engaged in professional training, retraining and advanced professional development in occupational safety will also be strengthened. To this end, an online registration system for training organisations will be introduced. Registration will take into account the availability of material and technical facilities, certified lecturers and training programmes in the field of occupational safety.
Training and knowledge assessment procedures in occupational safety will be separated, with the establishment of a Unified Educational and Methodological Centre (hereinafter referred to as the UEMC), one of whose functions will be the assessment of knowledge on a specially created online platform and the development (revision) of standard training programmes and test questions for knowledge assessment. The UEMC will also be responsible for training state labour inspectors and experts for specialised organisations, as well as preparing, registering and maintaining a list of lecturers for training organisations.
In addition, work will be carried out to revise the sectoral qualifications framework and the professional standard "Occupational Safety". Requirements concerning the competencies and qualifications of persons responsible for occupational safety at enterprises will also be updated.
Cooperation and expanded interaction with higher and postgraduate education organisations will be facilitated by the establishment of a new self-regulatory organisation (in the form of a non-profit organisation established as an association or union), which, under the coordination of the Republican Research Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (RRIOSH), will ensure the high-quality updating of the sectoral qualifications framework, professional standards, qualification reference books and other requirements in the field of labour standardisation and occupational safety. This will make it possible to improve the level of training of future specialists for enterprises across the Republic and, accordingly, take the OSH management system to a new level of development. A number of measures will also be implemented to improve the image of professions in the field of occupational safety and increase interest among prospective students, including through career guidance activities.
Opportunities for short-term grant funding (with an implementation period of 12 months) for scientific research in the field of occupational safety will be expanded to develop scientifically based measures for preventing occupational injuries and occupational diseases in specific sectors of the economy. End stakeholders (business structures, industrial enterprises, public organisations and others) will also be involved in financing this scientific research. The results of scientific developments will make it possible to improve occupational injury and occupational disease indicators at specific enterprises across the country.
The development of science in the field of occupational safety will be facilitated by designating the RRIOSH as the basis for providing general scientific and methodological guidance, conducting scientific events and implementing scientific developments in the activities of government bodies, educational organisations and enterprises of the Republic. Thus, professional internships for master's and PhD students will be organised at the RRIOSH, strengthening the link between theory and practice. Synergy in the activities of higher and/or postgraduate education organisations will ensure an improvement in the level of professional training of scientific personnel in the field of occupational safety and will also contribute to integrating the results of scientific research into the educational process.
An annual occupational safety scientific forum will be held as part of the KIOSH conference and exhibition, serving as a platform for dialogue and discussion of scientific developments and the application of innovative approaches in enterprise activities.
In the context of increasing competition and production automation, which leads to workforce optimisation, consideration of the introduction of new progressive methods of labour standardisation for various types of economic activities is timely. In this regard, to ensure safe working conditions, intersectoral staffing standards will be introduced, which are key to implementing the Concept (for occupational safety specialists and state labour inspectors), taking into account the number of employees working under unfavourable conditions, as well as the geographical remoteness of facilities and the presence of contractors and subcontractors.
4.4. Improving the Effectiveness of Control and Monitoring in the Field of Occupational Safety
An objective reduction in occupational risks is possible through obtaining reliable and objective information about the state of the system.
As international practice demonstrates, the implementation of the task of improving the effectiveness of state control and monitoring in the field of occupational safety is carried out through automated digital systems and improved digital platforms. In this regard, an additional component, the "Digital Enterprise Map", will be created on the basis of the existing automated digital system in the field of occupational safety as a tool for analysing occupational safety indicators.
The main areas of monitoring will include the results of occupational risk assessments at enterprises, data on occupational injuries and occupational diseases, financing of measures, provision of guarantees, availability of certified PPE, sanitary and welfare facilities, therapeutic and preventive nutrition, medical services, COAI insurance and sectoral occupational risk maps.
Departmental statistical reporting forms on occupational safety will be updated by introducing indicators that adequately reflect the state of working conditions, simplifying the data collection system and subsequently preparing a national review of occupational safety.
To identify the root causes of accidents and assess the effectiveness of occupational risk management, a procedure for state examination of the quality of occupational risk assessments will be introduced in the event of an accident.
A mechanism for preventive state control over compliance with labour legislation (without visiting the controlled entity) will be introduced by comparing information obtained from various sources regarding the activities of controlled entities.
Awareness among employers, employees and the general public regarding occupational safety and occupational risks will be increased through the use of various methods of information dissemination.
An online platform will be created to provide informational and reference support for the OSH management system, with the possibility of conducting self-monitoring of compliance with labour legislation and containing an up-to-date regulatory and methodological framework, as well as expert consultations.
Under the new conditions, a set of measures will be implemented to ensure the application of international standards in organising state control over compliance with occupational safety requirements, including matters concerning the vertical management structure and improvement of the qualifications of state labour inspectors.
Measures will be implemented to increase the role of public oversight through the development of standard regulations on production councils and technical occupational safety and health inspectors, with the organisation of their specialised training and advanced professional development.
Measures will be implemented to improve the effectiveness of internal occupational safety and health control at enterprises using the services of contractors by expanding the practice whereby the general contractor coordinates the overall compliance of contractors with occupational safety and health requirements at construction sites.
At the same time, corresponding amendments to legislation are envisaged in order to strengthen the liability of parties to employment relationships for violations of occupational safety legislation, as well as the liability of employers and officials of other bodies and organisations for failure to report or concealment of accidents and/or cases of employee injuries during working hours.
Implementation of the Concept will make it possible to achieve positive changes in ensuring safe working conditions in the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Direction 5. Ensuring State Policy in the Field of Industrial Safety
The new conceptual trajectory for the development of state policy in the field of industrial safety is based on three areas – legal and technical regulation, digital decision-making tools, and a basic methodological framework for preventing accidents, incidents and occupational injuries. Therefore, regulatory policy will be specified as a target guideline, digital products will be used to the maximum extent, and the methodological framework for industrial safety will be expanded. This will make it possible to assess and forecast the technical condition of equipment, creating incentives for reinvestment in the technical capacities of industrial enterprises. Ultimately, the measures being implemented will eliminate the corruption component in inspections in the field of industrial safety.
5.1. Development of Regulatory Policy in the Field of Industrial Safety Based on a Systematic Approach
Legislative provisions concerning the identification of hazardous production facilities, determination of the overall hazard level of production facilities, classification of hazardous production facilities as facilities subject to mandatory safety declarations, certification and admission requirements, etc., will be strengthened.
- Particular attention will be paid to the development of regulatory and methodological instruments for self-identification and classification as hazardous production facilities.
The foundations for classifying facilities as hazardous production facilities will include expanding the methodological framework and introducing a differentiated approach taking into account the type of hazardous production factor, including hazardous substances, products, materials, technical devices, etc.
A system for categorising violations of safety requirements will be developed and implemented, classifiers of operational response measures will be defined, and risk assessment criteria will be revised.
The introduction of digital products and functional tools for the qualitative assessment of the hazards of production facilities and all related processes, control and supervisory procedures, training, etc., will be methodologically ensured.
Regulatory rule-making will focus on revising regulations concerning:
assessment of the hazard level of a specific hazardous production facility or its type, grouped according to a particular characteristic (for example, industry affiliation);
determination of criteria for classifying a hazardous production facility (or types thereof) into one of the groups of facilities, for each of which an optimal state control regime will be established;
determination of the procedure and frequency for assessing the residual service life of equipment used at hazardous production facilities, the procedure for extending its safe operating life, etc.
The concentration of hazardous production facilities under the supervision of a controlled entity determines the potential for accidents. If this potential is assessed as high, it is necessary to establish and maintain appropriate safety systems comprehensively at that entity.
Under the risk-oriented approach, accident occurrence is characterised not only by the frequency of accidents but also by their scale, that is, the severity of their consequences. Every accident is unique, and the damage it causes depends on numerous factors.
The existing industrial safety management system is based on retrospective data ("post factum") (the number of accidents and incidents, the number of occupational injuries and their severity, etc.) and, by indicating only failures in this system, can only respond to them. The new model assumes that the system must be reoriented towards a proactive format of operation, in which the primary priorities will be identifying existing hazards, assessing the risks of those hazards materialising, calculating and ranking risks, and implementing preventive measures, without waiting for accidents, incidents or occupational injuries to occur. Detailed planning of measures to reduce and eliminate risks, together with their mandatory and complete implementation, will make it possible to manage occupational safety, prevent accidents and incidents, and significantly reduce the level of occupational injuries in production.
The format of the new cyclical "service" safety management model consists of seven main components: identification (detection) of hazards; analysis, calculation and ranking (assessment by magnitude) of risks; declaration of commitment to safe work; provision of resources; risk management; control and monitoring, measurement of indicators; preventive and corrective measures.
The focus of the target activities is based on the management principle: "You can only manage what you have been able to identify."
- The regulatory and legal framework for industrial safety at hazardous production facilities consists of a set of rules governing activities, action procedures or behavioural instructions aimed at establishing an effective system for forecasting, identifying, analysing and assessing accident risks at hazardous production facilities, a reliable industrial safety assurance system, and the elimination of the consequences of possible accidents. The distinctive features of regulatory, technical and legal regulation of industrial safety are the multiplicity and diversity of its entities and hazardous production facilities. In view of this, unified reactive regulations must be organised into a structured system taking into account the specific characteristics of each hazardous production facility.
The system of regulatory legal acts and regulatory and technical documents establishing the conditions and specific features of the safe operation of hazardous production facilities, enabling accidents at such facilities to be prevented and, in the event of their occurrence, ensuring the containment and elimination of negative consequences, will be fully systematised and updated based on harmonisation with the standards of developed countries.
Industrial safety requirements concerning the design, construction, operation, expansion, reconstruction, technical re-equipment, conservation and liquidation of hazardous production facilities, as well as the manufacture, installation, commissioning, maintenance and repair of technical devices used at hazardous production facilities, will be harmonised to the maximum extent, taking domestic specificities into account.
Regulatory provisions will be aimed at bringing national procedures, requirements and conditions for licensing activities in the field of industrial safety closer together, as well as the procedures and conditions for the use of technical devices at hazardous production facilities, and national procedures and requirements for the training and certification of employees (specialists and personnel) of organisations operating hazardous production facilities.
- Work will continue on developing self-regulation and accreditation institutions in the field of industrial safety, but now from the perspective of a risk-oriented differentiated approach.
Regulatory provisions concerning the transition to a "service model of management" in the field of industrial safety will be revised by strengthening the liability of specialised market entities.
The Concept provides for the updating of regulatory policy governing the activities of legal entities performing work in the field of industrial safety, including specialised market entities and Emergency Rescue Services (ERS).
For example, ERS will be included in industrial safety declarations, their certification procedures will be tightened, requirements for the availability of their own equipment and facilities will be introduced, and monitoring of the accounting of ERS groupings of personnel and equipment, as well as their compliance with tender documentation requirements, will be implemented. Similar regulatory reforms will also apply to other legal entities performing work in the field of industrial safety. In addition, in order to ensure the quality of services and work performed and the liability of service providers in the field of industrial safety, the revocation of permits and suspension of the right to carry out activities will be introduced.
5.2. Digital Transformation of the Industrial Safety System
New legislative initiatives will be implemented. This entails the full integration of new departmental digital products with all major state databases. First and foremost, digitalisation will make it possible to simplify existing mechanisms, optimise and make all admission processes transparent, ensuring equal access for all entities regardless of their type of activity, size or number of production facilities. This instrument will serve as a connecting link that ensures a differentiated approach to the reciprocal obligations of responsible persons in ensuring industrial safety at a level corresponding to the hazard level of each hazardous production facility.
- Systematisation of the list of hazardous production facilities according to the degree of accident risk and the scale of their consequences, as well as the measures that enable compliance with the required level of safety, will form the basis for new methods of interaction with all participants through digitalisation and differentiated regulation.
The target purpose of the new transparent digital management model in the field of industrial safety, ensuring openness and accessibility of information, will be to facilitate the modernisation of fixed production assets, the introduction of innovative technologies, the use of modern equipment and safe materials, and improvement of the qualifications of personnel. The entire regulatory framework in the field of industrial safety will be transferred to a digital format, taking into account the adaptation of best practices in the application of IT tools and online systems.
The "Smart Safety" model will be implemented, serving as the foundation for the integration of all necessary components of industrial safety.
- The priority of digital development in industrial safety is the state monitoring system, which, through the introduction of control and measurement monitoring methods, a digital industrial safety map and an interactive map of hazardous production facilities, technological audits and control at internal, public and state management levels, must ensure 100% coverage of hazardous production facilities. One of the main innovations in this area will be the transition of state monitoring in the field of industrial safety to a proactive digital format. To this end, a new methodology for analysing the causes of incidents at hazardous production facilities will be implemented. Implementation of this methodology will require the introduction and development of digital control and supervision methods, will make it possible to digitise all basic elements of control and supervisory activities in the field of industrial safety, and will serve as the foundation for testing remote control methods, for example, the conduct of underground mining operations with the mandatory introduction of a monitoring system, accident notification, positioning and personnel search. This will make it possible to continuously monitor the condition of technological processes at hazardous production facilities and respond promptly to deviations in enterprise operations.
It is envisaged that the unified state digital system, whose main functionality will be the automatic generation of a register of hazardous production facilities, will also be capable of automatically verifying and validating their compliance with industrial safety standards and requirements. A method for assessing and forecasting the technical condition of equipment will also be introduced. It is necessary to increase the level of awareness of the authorised body in the field of industrial safety regarding the actual state of industrial safety and emergency rescue operations through the introduction of unified automated systems for recording, notification, information collection and analysis of emergency situations in real time, as well as the periodic conduct of command-and-staff exercises involving existing civil protection forces and resources, regardless of the organisational and legal form of the participating emergency rescue services. Monitoring will also cover information on the quality of services provided by entities engaged in technical support for hazardous production facilities.
To address the problem of the absence of complete and timely information about incidents at industrial facilities, an electronic database of accidents and incidents will be created. It will systematically store and, where necessary, use information about the location, causes of occurrence, accidents or incidents, employees involved, consequences, recommendations for action, etc.
- An essential component of the unified digital industrial safety system must be a 24/7 online consultation platform, including support in the event of accidents and incidents at hazardous production facilities, using artificial intelligence capabilities and promoting typical model situations in open digital systems.
It is also important that all operations of the new digital system will be automated, which will minimise corruption risks and reduce the corruption component in inspections and the commissioning of facilities and equipment.
5.3. Resource Provision for Industrial Safety Taking into Account the Balance Between Domestic and External Needs and the Establishment of a System for Its Effective Use
Resource provision for industrial safety is a multifactorial concept, the main parameters of which are characterised by three criteria:
resource potential and resource equipment (machinery and technologies, professional and qualified personnel, scientific developments, etc.) necessary for systematic, uninterrupted and effective operation in the long term;
the resource mechanism and resource balance (improving the quality of hazard assessments of production facilities; reducing the proportion of technological equipment in operation beyond its service life, etc.);
the effect of resource utilisation (reducing the hazard level of hazardous production facilities, the number of accidents and incidents, and the number of violations of industrial safety requirements, etc.).
- Improving safety culture and the effectiveness of the industrial safety system will be achieved through the development of scientific potential and ensuring professional and personnel self-sufficiency. Within this area, measures will be taken to establish a national management system in the field of industrial safety through a common decision-making and operational response centre covering the entire range of activities.
Increasing awareness, possessing information and being able to apply acquired knowledge are primary and leading factors in the field of industrial safety at all levels of management (national, sectoral, regional and enterprise levels). In this regard, within the framework of the national qualifications system, the sectoral qualifications framework in the field of professional services related to industrial safety will be updated. It should be noted that industrial safety is an interdisciplinary field of knowledge and is widely applied across industries. For example, the training of rescuers at hazardous production facilities requires knowledge of gas rescue and mine rescue operations, blowout prevention operations in the oil and gas industry, the coal industry, the mining industry and underground construction.
It is necessary to develop relevant and applicable competencies and skills for industrial safety needs, ensuring readiness for new challenges and threats in modern production.
The work being carried out will serve as an impetus for revising the standards for the certification and re-certification of specialists and experts performing work in the field of industrial safety, for example, standards for the physical fitness of rescuers.
Industrial safety is aimed at preventing a wide range of occupational risks, with the goal of achieving zero occupational injuries. Recognising the impossibility of completely eliminating hazardous production factors, particularly those caused by hazardous natural phenomena, it is necessary to understand the nature of these risks, recognise the scale of their potential negative impact and take effective protective measures. In this regard, it is necessary to conduct scientific research on an ongoing basis, study advanced experience, develop innovative methods, materials and technologies aimed at improving safety levels, train scientific personnel and strengthen the material and technical research infrastructure.
The effectiveness of industrial safety measures depends on coordinated actions at both the international and national levels. Therefore, it is necessary to establish international relations between the professional expert community represented by scientific, educational and commercial organisations, civil society and government bodies, and maintain these relations for the exchange of critically important information.
For the scientific substantiation and conduct of research, the issue of establishing a scientific and technical industrial safety centre will be considered. It will deal with cooperation with international organisations and associations in the field of industrial safety. Issues related to organising scientific research on priority topics, taking into account the industry-specific characteristics and geographical location of hazardous production facilities, will be considered, in particular, the introduction of safe and resource-saving technologies, effective methods for hazard analysis and accident risk assessment at hazardous production facilities, and innovative solutions for reducing the impact of hazardous occupational factors.
- The functioning of the industrial safety system must be provided with all necessary resources, including personnel, in accordance with the staffing standards for state inspectors responsible for control and supervision in the field of industrial safety. It should be noted that, taking into account the specific nature of their activities, state inspectors in the field of industrial safety are exposed to hazardous production factors while performing their official duties, including descending into mines, inspecting hazardous production facilities, etc. In this regard, measures must be taken to enhance the status of state inspectors and their social protection, including remuneration and social guarantees.
In view of the weak involvement of local executive bodies in ensuring safety at hazardous production facilities within their jurisdiction that form part of social infrastructure, most of which use hazardous technical devices (lifting mechanisms or pressure equipment), measures are envisaged to strengthen the organisational and legal level of state control and revise the distribution of powers in the field of industrial safety between state and local executive bodies.
To ensure prompt response, regulation and control of accident elimination, a unit for coordinating the activities of Emergency Rescue Services (ERS) will be established under the authorised body in the field of industrial safety. It will oversee issues related to the engagement of ERS in eliminating accidents of international scale, as well as accidents at ownerless hazardous production facilities and incidents involving depressurisation of abandoned oil and gas wells, and will take measures to develop ERS and consider issues related to their financing (preferential lending) and social security (guarantees, benefits, payments and compensation).
At the enterprise level, prompt decision-making and the prevention of industrial accidents and incidents will be ensured through the establishment of production control services for hazardous production facilities directly subordinate to the first heads of enterprises.
At the same time, production control over hazardous production facilities with low and medium risk levels will be assigned to specialised market entities, while control over hazardous production facilities with high risk levels will be carried out by state inspectors.
- It is necessary to revise the economic mechanisms for incentivising the safety of hazardous production facilities, including the renewal of fixed assets, modernisation and technical re-equipment of hazardous facilities, and the decommissioning of equipment at hazardous facilities that has exhausted its service life and has a limited remaining period of fitness for operation.
Incentive mechanisms for reinvestment at industrial enterprises will be introduced. At the same time, the issue of non-fulfilment of technical re-equipment plans by enterprise managers for various reasons will be considered. To this end, it is necessary to introduce a monitoring mechanism taking into account the economic conditions in the country and encourage the participation of public institutions in the practical implementation of the principle of corporate social responsibility, etc.
Important innovations in this area will include the consideration and introduction of preventive insurance programmes in the field of industrial safety and the application of a differentiated insurance tariff taking into account the hazard level. Rapidly changing production conditions and economic relations require the search for insurance instruments and methods that correspond to institutional transformations in the risk assessment and accident prevention system. In this regard, it is necessary to introduce mechanisms for compensating costs associated with accident containment and the elimination of their consequences.
Issues related to non-compliance with industrial safety requirements and strengthening the liability of owners of hazardous production facilities for violations committed will also be comprehensively examined, including the revision of administrative proceedings, the application of operational response measures, an increase in fines and the duration of suspension of activities, and the introduction of criminal liability.
Section 6. Target Indicators and Expected Results
Achievement of the objectives will be measured using the target indicators specified in the table attached to this Concept.
Table. Target Indicators
Standardize the section numberingClarify ambiguous technical terminology
Ниже приведён перевод на английский язык с сохранением исходной структуры, нумерации, последовательности разделов, показателей, сроков, ответственных исполнителей, примечаний и сокращений. Числовые значения и содержание не изменяются.
TARGET INDICATORS
Download
| No. | Target indicators | Unit of measurement | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 | 2027 | 2028 | 2029 | 2030 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Increasing the share of in-demand occupations covered by professional standards | % | 50 | 55 | 60 | 65 | 75 | 85 | 90 |
| 2 | Increasing the number of quality jobs | thousand persons | 2 452 | 2 847 | 3 085 | 3 324 | 3 562 | 3 801 | 4039 |
| 2.1 | Agriculture, forestry and fisheries | thousand persons | 65 | 71 | 78 | 85 | 92 | 101 | 108 |
| 2.2 | Mining and quarrying | thousand persons | 156 | 178 | 201 | 224 | 247 | 270 | 293 |
| 2.3 | Manufacturing industry | thousand persons | 323 | 361 | 400 | 441 | 481 | 524 | 564 |
| 2.4 | Electricity, gas, steam, hot water and air conditioning supply | thousand persons | 64 | 70 | 76 | 82 | 89 | 95 | 102 |
| 2.5 | Water supply; waste collection, treatment and disposal; pollution remediation activities | thousand persons | 16 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 24 | 25 |
| 2.6 | Construction | thousand persons | 152 | 159 | 166 | 174 | 182 | 191 | 199 |
| 2.7 | Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles | thousand persons | 211 | 226 | 240 | 255 | 270 | 285 | 300 |
| 2.8 | Transportation and storage | thousand persons | 211 | 228 | 244 | 261 | 280 | 298 | 317 |
| 2.9 | Accommodation and food service activities | thousand persons | 22 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 28 | 30 | 32 |
| 2.10 | Information and communication | thousand persons | 79 | 90 | 101 | 112 | 124 | 136 | 148 |
| 2.11 | Financial and insurance activities | thousand persons | 57 | 58 | 58 | 59 | 59 | 60 | 60 |
| 2.12 | Real estate activities | thousand persons | 21 | 22 | 23 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 |
| 2.13 | Professional, scientific and technical activities | thousand persons | 66 | 68 | 70 | 72 | 74 | 76 | 78 |
| 2.14 | Administrative and support service activities | thousand persons | 62 | 66 | 70 | 72 | 76 | 80 | 84 |
| 2.15 | Public administration and defence; compulsory social security | thousand persons | 260 | 268 | 276 | 285 | 293 | 301 | 309 |
| 2.16 | Education | thousand persons | 372 | 394 | 420 | 439 | 456 | 466 | 483 |
| 2.17 | Human health and social work activities | thousand persons | 256 | 276 | 297 | 318 | 339 | 358 | 379 |
| 2.18 | Arts, entertainment and recreation | thousand persons | 30 | 33 | 35 | 38 | 40 | 44 | 46 |
| 2.19 | Other service activities | thousand persons | 29 | 31 | 32 | 35 | 36 | 39 | 40 |
| 2.20 | Platform employment | thousand persons | - | 205 | 253 | 302 | 350 | 398 | 446 |
| 2.21 | Abai Region | thousand persons | 60 | 69 | 71 | 74 | 76 | 80 | 82 |
| 2.22 | Akmola Region | thousand persons | 99 | 116 | 126 | 136 | 148 | 158 | 170 |
| 2.23 | Aktobe Region | thousand persons | 127 | 148 | 161 | 174 | 187 | 200 | 213 |
| 2.24 | Almaty Region | thousand persons | 98 | 113 | 125 | 136 | 148 | 160 | 172 |
| 2.25 | Atyrau Region | thousand persons | 111 | 129 | 141 | 153 | 164 | 175 | 186 |
| 2.26 | West Kazakhstan Region | thousand persons | 89 | 103 | 113 | 122 | 131 | 141 | 150 |
| 2.27 | Zhambyl Region | thousand persons | 100 | 115 | 124 | 134 | 143 | 152 | 161 |
| 2.28 | Zhetysu Region | thousand persons | 73 | 83 | 88 | 95 | 101 | 107 | 113 |
| 2.29 | Karaganda Region | thousand persons | 150 | 169 | 180 | 189 | 199 | 209 | 219 |
| 2.30 | Kostanay Region | thousand persons | 108 | 123 | 130 | 136 | 144 | 151 | 159 |
| 2.31 | Kyzylorda Region | thousand persons | 79 | 93 | 100 | 108 | 115 | 123 | 130 |
| 2.32 | Mangystau Region | thousand persons | 98 | 116 | 130 | 142 | 154 | 166 | 178 |
| 2.33 | Pavlodar Region | thousand persons | 99 | 111 | 116 | 121 | 125 | 131 | 135 |
| 2.34 | North Kazakhstan Region | thousand persons | 67 | 75 | 78 | 81 | 85 | 88 | 92 |
| 2.35 | Turkestan Region | thousand persons | 147 | 174 | 191 | 207 | 224 | 241 | 258 |
| 2.36 | Ulytau Region | thousand persons | 30 | 33 | 35 | 37 | 39 | 40 | 42 |
| 2.37 | East Kazakhstan Region | thousand persons | 96 | 108 | 112 | 118 | 122 | 127 | 131 |
| 2.38 | Astana city | thousand persons | 252 | 296 | 326 | 354 | 384 | 412 | 442 |
| 2.39 | Almaty city | thousand persons | 466 | 553 | 610 | 668 | 725 | 783 | 840 |
| 2.40 | Shymkent city | thousand persons | 103 | 120 | 128 | 139 | 148 | 157 | 166 |
| 3 | Increasing the share of digitised employment promotion measures from 86% to 100% | % | 86 | 88 | 90 | 92 | 94 | 98 | 100 |
| 4 | Increasing the share of recipients of public employment services and coverage by employment promotion measures in online format from 44% to 73% | % | 50 | 54 | 58 | 62 | 65 | 70 | 73 |
| 5 | Increasing the share of career centre employees who have completed training in business processes from 14.2% to 85% | % | 25 | 30 | 35 | 50 | 65 | 80 | 85 |
| 6 | Increasing the coverage of active legal entities operating in the Republic of Kazakhstan by professional risk assessment | % | - | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 |
| 7 | Frequency rate of fatal occupational accidents per 1,000 employees | coefficient | 0.035 | 0.033 | 0.031 | 0.029 | 0.027 | 0.025 | 0.023 |
| 8 | Level of concealment of occupational injuries and occupational diseases | ratio | 12:1 | 13:1 | 14:1 | 15:1 | 16:1 | 17:1 | 18:1 |
| 9 | Coverage of active privately owned legal entities by the compulsory insurance system for employees against accidents in the performance of their employment (official) duties | % | 60 | 65 | 70 | 75 | 80 | 85 | 90 |
| 10 | Share of persons responsible for occupational safety and health who have successfully passed the assessment of their knowledge of occupational safety and health requirements | % | - | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 |
| 11 | Number of scientific and technical programmes and projects being implemented | number | 3 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 6 | 6 |
| 12 | Coverage of enterprises (active legal entities) by state monitoring of occupational safety and health conditions | % | - | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 |
| 13 | Level of coverage of hazardous production facilities by the state monitoring system in the field of industrial safety | % | - | 75 | 80 | 85 | 90 | 95 | 100 |
| 14 | Level of availability of regulatory requirements (rules, regulations, standards, etc.) for industrial safety at hazardous production facilities | % | - | 30 | 50 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 |
| 15 | Level of digitalisation of industrial safety | % | - | 30 | 50 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 |
| 16 | Growth rate of users of the state monitoring digital system based on the "Smart Safety" model | % | - | 0 | 50 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| 17 | Rate of reduction in the number of accidents caused by man-made factors | % | - | -3% | -5% | -6% | -7% | -8% | -10% |
| 18 | Number of scientific and technical projects implemented in the field of industrial safety (including ongoing projects) | units | - | 0 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| 19 | Average level of assessment (forecasting) of the technical condition of equipment at hazardous production facilities (wear and tear) | % | - | 70 | 50 | 40 | 30 | 20 | 10 |
The implementation of the proposed measures will result in an increase in the number of quality jobs, an improvement in the employment structure, a reduction in the frequency rate of occupational accidents per 1,000 employees to a stable level not exceeding 0.23 over an extended period (actual figure for 2025 – 0.18), a reduction in the share of violations in the field of occupational safety and health out of the total number of detected violations of labour legislation to a stable level not exceeding 23% over an extended period (actual figure for 2025 – 18.2%), ensuring full coverage of all hazardous production facilities by the state monitoring system in the field of industrial safety up to 100%, ensuring coverage of regulatory procedures by digital products up to 100%, and reducing the number of accidents caused by man-made factors by 10%.
By the end of 2030, the economy is projected to have 4.0 million quality jobs, representing 45% of total employment.
The average annual growth rate of quality jobs will amount to 10%.
1.7 million people will increase their incomes to a level exceeding the median wage.
Every year, the number of people whose incomes exceed the median wage will increase by an average of 288 thousand.
Appendix
to the Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030
ACTION PLAN
for the implementation of the Concept for the Development of a Safe Labour Market and Industrial Safety of the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2030
Download
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
Area 1. Human Capital Development
Target Indicator 1. Increasing the share of in-demand occupations covered by professional standards to 90% by 2030 (2024 – 50%, 2025 – 55%, 2026 – 60%, 2027 – 65%, 2028 – 75%, 2029 – 85%, 2030 – 90%).
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Introduction of modern management practices in TVET organisations included in the cluster | Order of the Ministry of Education | December 2024 | ME, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 2 | Introduction of network-based education in the TVET system | Order of the Ministry of Education | December 2026 | ME, MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 3 | Introduction of a programme for early vocational diagnostics of schoolchildren and guidance towards in-demand occupations | Early vocational diagnostics programme | December 2024–2030 | ME, MSHE, MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 4 | Joint work of schools and TVET organisations to acquire practical skills within TVET institutions | Diploma | December 2024–2030 | ME, MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 5 | Specialisation of TVET organisations with the designation of "anchor" organisations | Resolutions of akims of regions and the cities of Astana, Almaty and Shymkent | December 2024–2030 | LEBs, ME, MLSPP | Not required | Not required |
| 6 | Recognition of TVET learning outcomes for continuing education in higher and/or postgraduate education organisations | Recognition of TVET learning outcomes | December 2024–2030 | MSHE, ME | Not required | Not required |
| 7 | Identification of occupations for which professional qualifications will be recognised | Register of occupations | 2024–2030 | MLSPP, interested state bodies, NCE "Atameken" (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 8 | Development and updating of professional standards | Orders | 2024–2030 | Interested state bodies | Not required | Not required |
| 9 | Development and updating of TVET and higher and/or postgraduate education programmes based on professional standards | Updated educational programmes | 2024–2030 | ME, MSHE, MLSPP | Not required | Not required |
| 10 | Expanding access to information for effective career guidance through the digital "Career Guide" | Career guide | 2024–2030 | MLSPP, MSHE, ME | Not required | Not required |
| 11 | Transfer of TVET organisations to trust management by large enterprises and within the framework of offtake contracts | Resolutions of akims of regions and the cities of Astana, Almaty and Shymkent | December 2024–2030 | LEBs, ME, MLSPP | Not required | Not required |
| 12 | Monitoring horizontal labour mobility in terms of interregional and intersectoral labour flows and involvement in entrepreneurial activities | Report | December 2024–2030 | MLSPP, ME, MSHE, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 13 | Developing proposals to stimulate internal mobility within investment projects providing for the creation of mass employment opportunities and the development of housing and transport infrastructure to establish centres of economic growth outside agglomerations (the cities of Astana, Almaty and Shymkent) | Analytical information | December 2024 | MLSPP, MPS, MT, MNE, MEEPR, MAF, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 14 | Stimulating the relocation of personnel to regions experiencing labour shortages | Analytical information | December 2024 | MLSPP, MPS, MT, MNE, MEEPR, MAF | Not required | Not required |
Area 2. Stimulating Demand for Quality Jobs
Target Indicator 2. Increasing the number of quality jobs, in thousands of persons (2024 – 2,452; 2025 – 2,847; 2026 – 3,085; 2027 – 3,324; 2028 – 3,562; 2029 – 3,801; 2030 – 4,039).
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 | Commissioning for industrial operation of the subsoil use information system, including: a digital database of geological information; a "single window" for obtaining public services; interactive geological maps (laboratories, core storage facilities, processing plants, metallurgical plants, logistics routes, etc.); provision of open access to the information system for potential investors and existing subsoil users | Acceptance certificate for commissioning into industrial operation | June 2024 | MIICD, MPS, ME | Not required | Not required |
| 16 | Development of proposals for amendments to the Labour Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan concerning interaction between central state bodies, local executive bodies, as well as major mining and metallurgical organisations and subsoil users planning to release employees in connection with production modernisation | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | June 2027 | MLSPP, MPS, MNE, MEEPR, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 17 | Introduction of a civil offset mechanism to develop domestic value through the localisation of production within regulated procurement and public-private partnership projects | Draft legislative amendments | December 2024 | MPS, MF, MNE, MAF, MEEPR | Not required | Not required |
| 18 | Industrial cooperation and offering a package of incentives for foreign investors to expand and/or establish joint production facilities in border regions, ensuring integration into cross-border value chains | Analytical information and recommendations | June 2025 | MPS, MNE, MLSPP, MAF, ME, MF | Not required | Not required |
| 19 | Development of proposals concerning the establishment of a mechanism for allocating land plots through open auctions for housing construction, taking into account the developer's obligations to transfer a share of the residential floor area in the development project | Analytical information and recommendations | December 2024 | MAF, MPS, MF, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 20 | Development of railway infrastructure, construction of the second tracks on the Dostyk–Moyynty and Darbaza–Maktaaral sections, the new Bakhty–Ayagoz railway line and the railway bypass around Almaty station. Repair of 11 thousand km of railway sections by the end of 2029 | Certificate of completed works | December 2029 | MT | 1. Dostyk–Moyynty – 542,863,679 tenge; 2. Darbaza–Maktaaral – 284,400,000 tenge; 3. Bakhty–Ayagoz – 572,300,000 tenge; 4. Almaty station bypass – 154,281,723 tenge; 5. Repair of 11 thousand km of railway sections at the expense of JSC NC KTZ | 1. Dostyk–Moyynty – National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan; 2. Darbaza–Maktaaral – 15% from the National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 85% from market borrowings from international financial institutions, AIIB and ADB under the guarantee of JSC Samruk-Kazyna; 3. Bakhty–Ayagoz – borrowed funds from the Development Bank of Kazakhstan, China Exim Bank and China Development Bank; 4. Almaty station bypass – international financial institutions, AIIB and ADB under the guarantee of JSC Samruk-Kazyna; 5. Repair of 11 thousand km of railway sections – funds of JSC NC KTZ |
| 21 | Establishment of a package of incentives to attract investors to the development of logistics centres based at major regional airports of the Republic of Kazakhstan | Analytical information and recommendations | December 2026 | MT, MFA | Not required | Not required |
| 22 | Development of proposals for establishing a network of agricultural competence centres based at TVET organisations for personnel training | Agricultural competence centres | December 2024–2026 | ME, NCE "Atameken" (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 23 | Establishment of a package of incentives for the expansion and construction of modern retail formats | Analytical information and recommendations | June 2028 | MTI, MF, MPS, NCE "Atameken" (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 24 | Prioritisation of medium-sized businesses in the allocation of resources under budget programmes and inclusion of a criterion concerning the creation of quality jobs when providing state support measures to small and medium-sized businesses | Adoption of a package of regulatory legal acts | December 2024 | MNE, MF, MPS, MAF, ME, MEEPR, NCE "Atameken" (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 25 | Increasing capacity at border crossing points and effectively digitalising checkpoints to reduce customs clearance time | Analytical information | June 2024 | MF, MT, MTI, MIICD | Not required | Not required |
| 26 | Industrialisation of the south, development of existing and creation of new production infrastructure, and offering a package of incentives for simple, non-resource-intensive manufacturing industries in labour-surplus southern regions | Analytical information | December 2027 | Akimats of Almaty, Zhambyl, Kyzylorda and Turkestan regions, Zhetysu Region, and the cities of Almaty and Shymkent; MNE, MPS, MF | Not required | Not required |
| 27 | Reindustrialisation of the central and eastern regions, and offering a package of incentives for the expansion and/or establishment of production facilities with medium or high technological complexity | Analytical information and recommendations | December 2027 | Akimats of East Kazakhstan and Karaganda regions, Abai and Ulytau regions; MNE, MPS, MF | Not required | Not required |
| 28 | Clustering and specialisation of agribusiness, establishment of integrated systems for procurement and storage of agricultural products and sales chains within a single cluster (based on geographical principles), and offering a package of incentives to increase the share of quality jobs through the clustering of agricultural enterprises | Analytical information and recommendations | December 2024 | MAF, MNE, MF, NCE "Atameken" (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
Area 3. Creating Conditions for an Effective Link Between the Economy and the Human Capital Development System to Match Labour Supply and Demand
Target Indicator 3. Increasing the share of digitised employment promotion measures from 86% to 100% (2024 – 86%, 2025 – 88%, 2026 – 90%, 2027 – 92%, 2028 – 94%, 2029 – 98%, 2030 – 100%).
Target Indicator 4. Increasing the share of recipients of public employment services and coverage by employment promotion measures in online format from 44% to 73% (2024 – 50%, 2025 – 54%, 2026 – 58%, 2027 – 62%, 2028 – 65%, 2029 – 70%, 2030 – 73%).
Target Indicator 5. Increasing the share of career centre employees who have completed training in business processes from 14.2% to 85% (2024 – 25%, 2025 – 30%, 2026 – 35%, 2027 – 50%, 2028 – 65%, 2029 – 80%, 2030 – 85%).
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 | Approval of regional employment maps providing for job creation indicators within the framework of national projects and/or state programmes | Regional employment maps | 2024–2030 | LEBs, MNE, MAF, MPS, MT, MTI, MCI, MTS, ME, MSHE, MH, MEEPR, MWRI, ME, MIICD, MLSPP | Not required | Not required |
| 30 | Monitoring of job creation and employment of the population through the digital systems of the MLSPP | Report | 2024–2030 | MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 31 | Introduction of a comprehensive training system for employees of labour mobility centres (career centres): development of individual training plans, continuous professional training, certification and assignment of qualification categories, and creation of a pool of internal trainers | Orders of the MLSPP | December 2024 | MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 32 | Transfer of active employment promotion measures to the online format on Enbek.kz: remote career counselling for unemployed persons, digitalisation of employment processes – video CVs and video interviews, organisation of digital work placements, and matching of vacancies and CVs using artificial intelligence | Provision of employment services in digital format | 2024–2030 | MLSPP, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 33 | Introduction of the electronic "Platform Employment" service to automate the registration and social protection of platform workers and apply a special tax regime | Electronic "Platform Employment" service | December 2024 | MLSPP, MIICD, MF | Not required | Not required |
Area 4. Ensuring Occupational Safety
Target Indicator 6. Increasing the coverage of active legal entities operating in the Republic of Kazakhstan by professional risk assessment (2025 – 30%, 2026 – 40%, 2027 – 50%, 2028 – 60%, 2029 – 70%, 2030 – 80%).
Target Indicator 7. Frequency rate of fatal occupational accidents per 1,000 employees (2024 – 0.035, 2025 – 0.033, 2026 – 0.031, 2027 – 0.029, 2028 – 0.027, 2029 – 0.025, 2030 – 0.023).
Target Indicator 8. Level of concealment of occupational injuries and occupational diseases (2024 – 12:1, 2025 – 13:1, 2026 – 14:1, 2027 – 15:1, 2028 – 16:1, 2029 – 17:1, 2030 – 18:1).
Target Indicator 9. Coverage of active privately owned legal entities by the compulsory insurance system for employees against accidents in the performance of their employment (official) duties (2024 – 60%, 2025 – 65%, 2026 – 70%, 2027 – 75%, 2028 – 80%, 2029 – 85%, 2030 – 90%).
Target Indicator 10. Share of persons responsible for occupational safety and health who have successfully passed the assessment of their knowledge of occupational safety and health requirements (2025 – 40%, 2026 – 50%, 2027 – 60%, 2028 – 70%, 2029 – 80%, 2030 – 90%).
Target Indicator 11. Number of scientific and technical programmes and projects being implemented (2024 – 3, 2025 – 4, 2026 – 4, 2027 – 5, 2028 – 5, 2029 – 6, 2030 – 6).
Target Indicator 12. Coverage of enterprises (active legal entities) by state monitoring of occupational safety and health conditions (2025 – 30%, 2026 – 40%, 2027 – 50%, 2028 – 60%, 2029 – 70%, 2030 – 80%).
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 34 | Revision of the rules for professional risk management in terms of changing the procedure for professional risk assessment, taking into account the introduction of: 1) an integrated assessment of the professional risk of an enterprise (differentiation of enterprises according to the degree of professional risk); 2) a separate procedure for assessing professional risks under special working conditions (underground work, outdoor work, work at heights and the like); 3) a simplified procedure for assessing professional risks at small and micro-enterprises | Order of the MLSPP | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MLSPP | Not required | Not required |
| 35 | Development of amendments concerning: 1) elimination of the procedure for certification of production facilities in terms of working conditions; 2) strengthening requirements for specialised organisations, the procedure for their registration, and establishing liability for the results of their assessments | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MH, MPS, MES, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 36 | Introduction, on the basis of the existing automated information system of the authorised labour body, of a module for registration and recording of professional risk assessment results | Commissioning certificate | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MIICD, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 37 | Introduction, on the basis of the existing automated information system of the authorised labour body, of a digital map of enterprises and its integration with the information systems of state bodies | Commissioning certificate | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MIICD, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 38 | Taking measures to provide employees with personal protective equipment depending on professional risk | Order of the MLSPP | 2nd quarter of 2026 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 39 | Conducting research to improve the procedure for periodic mandatory medical examinations | Report | 2025–2027 | MLSPP, MH, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 40 | Consideration of the issue of ratification of International Labour Organization Convention No. 176 "Safety and Health in Mines", as well as the need to introduce related amendments and additions to the current labour legislation | Proposal to the Interdepartmental Commission on International Humanitarian Law | 4th quarter of 2024 | MLSPP, MPS, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 41 | Carrying out activities to reduce the accident rate at hazardous production facilities through their technological re-equipment jointly with organisations operating hazardous production facilities | Report | Annually | MES, MPS, MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 42 | Introduction of approaches for: determining the procedure for differentiating the types and amounts of guarantees for employees engaged in harmful and/or hazardous working conditions, taking into account the degree of professional risk; economic planning of occupational safety costs | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2028 | MLSPP, MNE, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 43 | Introduction of a two-component insurance tariff for compulsory employee accident insurance based on the classification of professional risks by type of economic activity and the results of professional risk assessment | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, ARDFM (as agreed), republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 44 | Introduction of preventive measures aimed at reducing professional risks and rehabilitation programmes for injured employees at the expense of insurance organisations under compulsory employee accident insurance agreements | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2024 | MLSPP, ARDFM (as agreed), republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 45 | Conducting a study on the implementation of rehabilitation programmes at an early stage following the loss of working capacity by injured employees, including the provision of medical care and additional types of treatment | Report | 2027–2029 | MLSPP, MH, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 46 | Introducing amendments concerning: separation of occupational safety training and knowledge assessment procedures, with the establishment of a unified educational and methodological centre; advanced training of technical occupational safety inspectors, chairpersons of production councils, lecturers of training organisations and experts of specialised organisations; establishment of requirements for occupational safety training organisations, including the procedure for their registration and liability for the quality of services provided | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 47 | Introduction of an online platform for knowledge assessment (centralised issuance of certificates confirming successful completion of knowledge assessments and unified registration of all persons who have completed occupational safety training) | Commissioning certificate | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MIICD, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 48 | Taking measures to introduce standard training programmes for the development of specialised professional competencies by industry, taking into account the degree of professional risk (in industries with high injury rates), and assigning the relevant competence to industry associations | Order of the MLSPP | 3rd quarter of 2024 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 49 | Revision of the sectoral qualifications framework and the professional standard "Occupational Safety" | Order of the MLSPP | 4th quarter of 2024 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 50 | Organisation and holding, jointly with higher education organisations, of an online career guidance exhibition for 11th-grade students on the topic "Safe Work: Profession and Career" | Career guidance exhibition | Annually | MLSPP, MSHE, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 51 | Examination of the issue of establishing a mechanism for allocating research grants to develop domestic scientific schools in the field of occupational safety | Report | 2026–2028 | MLSPP, MSHE | Not required | Not required |
| 52 | Ensuring integration of the scientific and educational potential of higher education institutions and research organisations within the framework of joint cooperation, including the preparation of dissertations and research grants | Agreements, memoranda | Annually | MLSPP, MSHE | Not required | Not required |
| 53 | Expanding cooperation with foreign research laboratories, educational centres and leading universities worldwide conducting research and training specialists and experts in the field of occupational safety | Agreements, memoranda | Annually | MLSPP, MSHE | Not required | Not required |
| 54 | Introduction, on the basis of the existing automated information system of the authorised labour body, of digital state control in the field of safe work based on a risk management system | Commissioning certificate | 4th quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MIICD, LEBs, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 55 | Development of amendments concerning: strengthening the liability of parties to employment relations for violations of legislation in the field of occupational safety; introduction of state expert assessment of professional risk assessment results in an organisation following an occupational accident; mandatory establishment of production councils in organisations | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MH, MPS, MES, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 56 | Introduction of functionality in the automated information system "Occupational Safety and Health" for generating reports on occupational injuries and occupational diseases | Commissioning certificate | 4th quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, MH, BNS (as agreed), republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 57 | Introduction of functionality in the automated information system "Occupational Safety and Health" enabling employers to self-monitor compliance with labour legislation in the field of occupational safety | Commissioning certificate | 3rd quarter of 2024 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 58 | Updating intersectoral standard staffing regulations for occupational safety services | Order of the MLSPP | 1st quarter of 2026 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 59 | Granting the authorised labour body the competence to develop standard regulations on production councils and technical occupational safety inspectors | Order of the MLSPP | 1st quarter of 2025 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 60 | Examining the issue of introducing vertical control at enterprises to ensure occupational safety and health from the customer to the contractor | Report | 3rd quarter of 2026 | MLSPP, republican associations of employers (as agreed), republican trade union associations (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
Area 5. Ensuring State Policy in the Field of Industrial Safety
Target Indicator 13. Level of coverage of hazardous production facilities by the state monitoring system in the field of industrial safety (2025 – 75%, 2026 – 80%, 2027 – 85%, 2028 – 90%, 2029 – 95%, 2030 – 100%).
Target Indicator 14. Level of availability of regulatory requirements (rules, regulations, standards, etc.) for industrial safety at hazardous production facilities (2025 – 30%, 2026 – 50%, 2027 – 70%, 2028 – 80%, 2029 – 90%, 2030 – 100%).
Target Indicator 15. Level of digitalisation of industrial safety (2025 – 30%, 2026 – 50%, 2027 – 70%, 2028 – 80%, 2029 – 90%, 2030 – 100%).
Target Indicator 16. Growth rate of users of the state monitoring digital system based on the "Smart Safety" model (2025 – 0%, 2026 – 50%, 2027 – 10%, 2028 – 10%, 2029 – 10%, 2030 – 10%).
Target Indicator 17. Rate of reduction in the number of accidents caused by man-made factors (2025 – -3%, 2026 – -5%, 2027 – -6%, 2028 – -7%, 2029 – -8%, 2030 – -10%).
Target Indicator 18. Number of scientific and technical projects implemented in the field of industrial safety (including ongoing projects) (2025 – 0, 2026 – 0, 2027 – 2, 2028 – 2, 2029 – 2, 2030 – 2 units).
Target Indicator 19. Average level of assessment (forecasting) of the technical condition of equipment at hazardous production facilities (wear and tear) (2025 – 70, 2026 – 50, 2027 – 40, 2028 – 30, 2029 – 20, 2030 – 10).
| No. | Name | Form of completion | Deadline | Responsible executors | Amount of funding | Source of funding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 61 | Development of regulatory and methodological tools for self-identification and classification through the introduction of a differentiated approach taking into account the type of hazardous production factor, including hazardous substances, products, materials, technical devices, etc. | Methodology and criteria for classifying a facility as a hazardous production facility | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MES | Not required | Not required |
| 62 | Development of a system of regulatory, technical and legal regulation of industrial safety for forecasting, identifying, analysing and assessing accident risks at hazardous production facilities and eliminating the consequences of potential accidents | List of technical and legal regulatory standards for each type of hazardous production facility, taking into account its specific characteristics | 3rd quarter of 2025 | MES | Not required | Not required |
| 63 | Updating the existing system for self-identification of hazardous production facilities and assessing their hazard levels, and classifying them as facilities subject to mandatory declaration, taking into account the analysis of accident risks at hazardous production facilities and strengthening the relevant provisions by introducing amendments and additions to regulatory legal acts: Order No. 300 of the Acting Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26 December 2014 "On Approval of the Rules for Determining the Overall Hazard Level of a Hazardous Production Facility"; Order No. 341 of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 December 2014 "On Approval of the Rules Determining the Criteria for Classifying Hazardous Production Facilities as Facilities Subject to Mandatory Declaration, and the Rules for Developing an Industrial Safety Declaration for a Hazardous Production Facility"; Order No. 353 of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 December 2014 "On Approval of the Rules for Identifying Hazardous Production Facilities"; Joint Order No. 1206 of the Minister for Investment and Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 15 December 2015 and Order No. 814 of the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 28 December 2015 "On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and Inspection Checklists Used for Preventive Control with Visits to the Entity (Facility) Subject to Control and Supervision in the Field of Industrial Safety and for Inspections of Compliance with Permit Requirements under Issued Permits" | Order of the MES | 4th quarter of 2025 | MES, MNE, MPS, ME, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 64 | Development of regulatory standards for the development of self-regulation and accreditation institutions in industrial safety within the framework of a risk-oriented differentiated approach, as well as amendments concerning the strengthening of requirements for specialised market entities, the procedure for their registration, and the establishment of liability and warranty obligations for the quality of services provided in the field of industrial safety | Order of the MES | 1st quarter of 2026 | MES, MNE | Not required | Not required |
| 65 | Examination of the issue of creating an electronic database of accidents and incidents that will ensure the systematic storage and use, where necessary, of information on the location and causes of accidents or incidents, employees involved, consequences, recommendations for action, etc. | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 1st quarter of 2025 | MES, MIICD | Not required | Not required |
| 66 | Implementation of a set of measures to introduce a state monitoring digital system based on the "Smart Safety" model, which will serve as the foundation for integrating all necessary industrial safety components, as well as measures for the full integration of new departmental digital products with all major state databases, including: control and measurement monitoring methods; a digital industrial safety map and an interactive map of hazardous production facilities; control at internal, public and state management levels | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 3rd quarter of 2026 | MES, MLSPP, MIICD | Not required | Not required |
| 67 | Examination of the issue of introducing an online 24/7 consultation platform, including support in the event of accidents and incidents at hazardous production facilities, using artificial intelligence capabilities and promoting typical model situations in open digital systems | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 1st quarter of 2027 | MES, MIICD | Not required | Not required |
| 68 | Organisation of a new training model in the field of industrial safety in terms of: separation of industrial safety training and knowledge assessment procedures; advanced training of state industrial safety inspectors, experts of specialised market entities and responsible persons of supervised entities; establishment of requirements for industrial safety training organisations, including the procedure for their registration and liability for the quality of services provided, including by engaged lecturers | Order of the MES | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MES | Not required | Not required |
| 69 | Examination of the issue of introducing an online knowledge assessment platform (centralised issuance of certificates confirming successful completion of knowledge assessments and unified registration of all persons who have completed industrial safety training) | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 2nd quarter of 2025 | MES, MIICD | Not required | Not required |
| 70 | Revision of the sectoral qualifications framework, as well as the standards for certification and re-certification of specialists and experts performing work in the field of industrial safety | Register of certified specialists and experts performing work in the field of industrial safety | 4th quarter of 2025 | MES | Not required | Not required |
| 71 | Development of measures to improve the national industrial safety management system in terms of: introduction of a common decision-making centre for operational response across the entire range of activities; raising the organisational and legal status of state control and supervision; revising the distribution of powers in the field of industrial safety between state and local executive bodies; establishing, under the authorised industrial safety body, a unit to coordinate the activities of professional emergency rescue services in the field of industrial safety | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan on improving state control and supervision in the field of industrial safety | 4th quarter of 2025 | MES, MNE, LEBs | Not required | Not required |
| 72 | Examination of the issue of conducting scientific research to address industrial safety problems | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 1st quarter of 2027 | MES, MF, MSHE | Not required | Not required |
| 73 | Examination of the issue of establishing an industrial safety scientific and technical centre | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 1st quarter of 2027 | MES, MF | Not required | Not required |
| 74 | Expanding cooperation with foreign research laboratories, educational centres and leading universities worldwide conducting research and training specialists in the field of industrial safety | Agreements, memoranda | 1st quarter of 2027 | MES, MSHE, MF | Not required | Not required |
| 75 | Revision of mechanisms for incentivising measures to renew fixed assets, modernise and technically re-equip hazardous production facilities, and decommission worn-out technological equipment | RIA CD | 1st quarter of 2027 | MES, MPS, ME | Not required | Not required |
| 76 | Revision of preventive insurance programmes for hazardous production facilities subject to mandatory industrial safety declaration, applying a differentiated insurance tariff taking into account the hazard level and compensation of costs associated with accident containment and elimination of their consequences | RIA CD | 2nd quarter of 2027 | MES, MF, MPS, ME, ARDFM (as agreed) | Not required | Not required |
| 77 | Examination of the issue of strengthening the liability of owners of hazardous production facilities for violations committed in the field of industrial safety | Proposals to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 3rd quarter of 2027 | MES | Not required | Not required |
Note: List of Abbreviations
| Abbreviation | Full name |
|---|---|
| ADB | Asian Development Bank |
| AIIB | Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank |
| MAF | Ministry of Agriculture of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| NCE "Atameken" | National Chamber of Entrepreneurs of the Republic of Kazakhstan "Atameken" |
| MSHE | Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MIICD | Ministry of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| CEI | Compulsory employee insurance against accidents |
| MH | Ministry of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MLSPP | Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| LEBs | Local executive bodies |
| MT | Ministry of Transport of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MF | Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| DBK | Development Bank of Kazakhstan |
| ARDFM | Agency for Regulation and Development of the Financial Market of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| JSC NC KTZ | Joint-stock company "National Company 'Kazakhstan Temir Zholy'" |
| MCI | Ministry of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| ME | Ministry of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MPS | Ministry of Industry and Construction of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| RIA CD | Regulatory Impact Assessment Concept Document |
| MWRI | Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MTI | Ministry of Trade and Integration of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MFA | Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| TVET | Technical and vocational education |
| MES | Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MTS | Ministry of Tourism and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan | National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| BNS | Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MNE | Ministry of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| Interdepartmental Commission on IHL | Interdepartmental Commission under the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan on International Humanitarian Law and International Treaties on Human Rights |
| IFI | International financial institution |
| ME | Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| MEEPR | Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages