On Approval of the Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029
Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 28, 2023 No. 263.
The Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan HEREBY RESOLVES:
- To approve the attached Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029 (hereinafter referred to as the Concept).
- Central and local executive bodies, state bodies directly subordinate and accountable to the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan (upon agreement), and other organizations (upon agreement) responsible for the implementation of the Concept shall:
- take the necessary measures to implement the Concept;
- submit information on the progress of implementation of the Concept in accordance with the procedure and within the time limits established by the Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 29, 2017 No. 790 "On Approval of the State Planning System in the Republic of Kazakhstan".
- Control over the implementation of this Resolution shall be entrusted to the Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- This Resolution shall enter into force on the date of its signing.
| Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan | A. Smailov |
|---|
| Approved by the Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 28, 2023 No. 263 |
|---|
CONCEPT FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELECTRIC POWER INDUSTRY OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN FOR 2023–2029
Contents
Section 2. Analysis of the Current Situation
2.1 Assessment of the Current State of the Industry
2.2 Production and Consumption of Electric Energy
2.3 Transmission of Electric Energy
2.6 Digitalization of the Industry
2.7 Electric Power Industry Markets
2.8 International Electricity Market
2.9 Professional Personnel Issues
2.10 Main Problems of the Electric Power Industry
Section 3. Overview of International Experience
3.4 Development of Generation by Types of Energy Resources Used
Section 4. Vision for the Development of the Electric Power Industry
Section 5. Main Principles and Approaches to Development
Section 6. Target Indicators and Expected Results
Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029
Section 1. Passport
Name: Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029.
Basis for Development: Instruction of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. ЗТ-К-17709,1 dated January 26, 2022.
State Body Developer: Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
State Bodies Responsible for Implementation: Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Agency for Protection and Development of Competition of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Ministry of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Implementation Period: 2023–2029.
Section 2. Analysis of the Current Situation
2.1 Assessment of the Current State of the Industry
The electric power industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan is a vital sector that forms the basis of the country's life support, the functioning and development of the economy, and ensures national security. The reliability of energy supply to consumers depends on the effectiveness of the regulatory environment, the condition of the electric power industry, including the technical condition of energy equipment, the level of investment, and the quality of management.
Over the past twenty years, a number of institutional, market and regulatory reforms have been carried out in the electric power industry, which have produced both positive effects and negative consequences.
From 2009 to 2015, under the "Tariff in Exchange for Investment" program, with the introduction of the regulatory instrument of marginal tariffs for electric energy, a medium-term capacity reserve was created through repair campaigns, reconstruction, restoration and construction of 3 GW of capacity for a total amount of slightly more than 1 trillion tenge.
However, the completion of the program, accompanied by a freeze on tariffs and, as a consequence, chronic underfunding and a low level of investment attractiveness that persist to this day, has led to rapid ageing of assets and low rates of modernization of energy equipment.
Since January 1, 2019, alongside the electric energy market, the electric capacity market has been operating, aimed at ensuring the attraction of the necessary amount of investment in the generation sector for the construction of new power plants and the maintenance of existing capacities. The capacity market is aimed at ensuring the recovery of investment costs of energy-producing organizations (hereinafter referred to as EPOs). The volume of investments attracted to the generation sector under the electric capacity market over four years of operation amounted to only approximately 300 billion tenge.
Within the framework of the "Modernization of the National Electric Grid" project, high-voltage equipment was modernized at 43 substations during Phase I and at 55 substations during Phase II; the SCADA/EMS (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition/Energy Management Systems) dispatch control and management system was installed, and an automated commercial electricity metering system (hereinafter referred to as AMR) was introduced, which increased the reliability of the national electric grid (hereinafter referred to as NEG).
The implementation of the projects "Construction of the Second 500 kV Line of the North–South Kazakhstan Transit" (1,097 km) and "Construction of the 500 kV North–South Transit Line via the East" (1,700 km) made it possible to increase the transmission capacity between the Northern and Southern zones to 2,100 MW, thereby increasing the reliability of electricity supply to the southern regions, which are energy-deficient.
Under the "Development of Heat and Electric Power Engineering" and "Lending to Regional Budgets, Budgets of Cities of Republican Significance and the Capital for the Reconstruction and Construction of Heat Supply Systems" programs, 53 projects worth 96.2 billion tenge were implemented from 2020 to 2022. These projects were aimed at the reconstruction, modernization and construction of heat supply systems, substations and power transmission lines with a voltage exceeding 35 kV.
Since 2009, the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan has established a system of state support for the development of renewable energy sources (hereinafter referred to as RES). The adoption at the state level of a decision to improve the investment climate in the RES sector, taking into account international practices, became the foundation for the development of this energy sector in our country.
The basis of Kazakhstan's electric power industry is coal-fired power generation, while coal deposits are mainly concentrated in Northern and Central Kazakhstan, where the main sources of electric energy are also located. Furthermore, for the purposes of energy security, coal-fired power plants will retain their presence in the generation sector in the medium term.
2.2 Production and Consumption of Electric Energy
As of January 1, 2023, electric energy is produced by 204 power plants (74 conventional and 130 RES facilities). The total installed capacity of Kazakhstan's power plants amounted to 24,523.7 MW, while available capacity amounted to 19,024.3 MW.
At the same time, the total installed RES capacity amounts to 2,388 MW, including wind power plants – 957 MW, solar power plants – 1,149 MW, hydropower plants (hereinafter referred to as HPPs) – 280 MW, and biogas power plants – 2 MW.
In 2022, electricity generation across Kazakhstan amounted to 112,865.9 million kWh (in 2020 – 108,085.8 million kWh, in 2021 – 114,447.9 million kWh), with coal being the main fuel (the share of coal-fired power plants – 66.7%, gas-fired power plants – 21.5%, HPPs – 7.3%, RES – 4.5%).
Electricity consumption amounted to 112,944.6 million kWh (in 2020 – 107,344.8 million kWh, in 2021 – 113,890.3 million kWh), of which 78.7 million kWh was covered by electricity imports from neighboring countries.
In 2022, the historical maximum level of consumption for all years was recorded, amounting to 16,459 MW, with generation at 15,203 MW. As a result, 1,256 MW was imported from the Russian Federation, which represents a sharp increase compared to previous years (in 2018 – 268 MW, in 2019 – 301 MW, in 2020 – 300 MW, in 2021 – 388 MW) (Diagram 1).
Diagram 1 – Peak Load and Generation for 2018–2022
The reasons for the shortage of electric energy and capacity are the high accident rate, technical limitations of generating equipment, and the limited number of flexible generating units to compensate for imbalances in the power system (due to the historically established structure of generating capacities).
At the end of 2022, 55.5% of the generating equipment of thermal power plants (hereinafter referred to as TPPs) was more than 30 years old (Diagram 2).
Diagram 2 – Age of TPP Generating Equipment
2.3 Transmission of Electric Energy
The electric grids of the Republic of Kazakhstan constitute a set of substations, switchgear and connecting power transmission lines with a voltage of 0.4–1,150 kV, intended for the transformation, transmission and/or distribution of electric energy.
The role of the backbone grid in the Unified Electric Power System of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter referred to as UES RK) is performed by the NEG, which includes interregional and/or interstate power transmission lines with a voltage of 220 kV and above. As of January 1, 2023, 83 substations with a voltage of 500–220 kV are in operation, and the total length of power transmission lines amounts to 26,970.8 km.
The NEG is managed by the joint-stock company "Kazakhstan Electricity Grid Operating Company" (hereinafter referred to as KEGOC JSC), which combines the functions of a power transmission organization and a system operator. At the same time, within the framework of the development of market relations, the activities of KEGOC JSC as a system operator require greater transparency, the elimination of risks of creating discriminatory conditions in the market, and the prevention of conflicts of interest with market participants.
At the same time, electricity losses during transmission in 2022 amounted to 5%, whereas standard technical losses in the national electric grid amount to approximately 6–7%.
Electricity transmission at the regional level (within the country) is carried out by 19 regional electric grid companies (hereinafter referred to as REGs) and 126 small power transmission companies, which own electric grids with a voltage of 0.4–220 kV.
The average level of depreciation of Kazakhstan's electric grids is 66%. The highest depreciation level is in Kostanay Region – 85.3%, and the lowest is 29.5% in the city of Astana.
The average loss level of REGs is approximately 14% and ranges from 6% to 18% due to differences in topology, voltage classes, the length of electric grids and the number of substations. In turn, significant losses in distribution grids are associated with the operation of most power transmission lines for more than 40 years and their considerable length.
The electric grids of Western Kazakhstan remain isolated from the UES RK, and the backbone grid of the Western Zone is fully loaded, resulting in insufficient transmission capacity for transit flows.
In addition, the presence of a large number of small private players at the regional level has a significant impact on the increase in the final price for consumers.
2.4 Supply of Electric Energy
Electric energy supply is provided by energy supply organizations (hereinafter referred to as ESOs), which purchase electric energy on the wholesale market and sell it on the retail market. At the beginning of 2023, more than 500 companies held licenses to carry out activities related to the purchase of electric energy for the purposes of energy supply. At the same time, approximately 140 organizations actually conduct such activities, including 35 ESOs subject to state regulation.
Electricity tariffs of ESOs are formed on the basis of the selling prices of energy-producing organizations, expenses for the service of ensuring the readiness of electric capacity to carry a load, tariffs for the transmission of electric energy, and the supply surcharge of the energy supply organization itself.
At the same time, for regulated ESOs, average selling tariffs are approved by the authorized body and differentiated by consumer groups: individuals (the population), legal entities and individual entrepreneurs, and budget-funded organizations. As a rule, in order to prevent social tension, tariffs for individuals are set below average selling tariffs through cross-subsidization by tariffs for legal entities and budget-funded organizations.
For guaranteed suppliers, tariffs for legal entities are higher than those of unregulated ESOs, which can offer more attractive tariffs, thereby fundamentally eliminating equal competition. The outflow of legal entities leads to an increase in tariffs for legal entities and budget-funded organizations due to the impossibility of increasing tariffs for the population. In turn, unregulated ESOs are not interested in concluding contracts with individuals due to low tariffs.
Currently, in pursuance of the instruction of the Head of State, the Agency for Protection and Development of Competition of the Republic of Kazakhstan is carrying out work on the gradual reduction and elimination of differentiated tariffs between consumer groups for electricity supply services in order to create equal competitive conditions among ESOs.
2.5 Heat Power Engineering
Heat Energy Production
Heat energy production in Kazakhstan is carried out by more than 2,500 heat sources, of which 118 have a capacity exceeding 100 Gcal/h, as well as individual consumer sources.
Heat sources in centralized and local heat supply systems are divided into combined heat and power plants (hereinafter referred to as CHPPs) and boiler houses.
As of January 1, 2023, 37 CHPPs are operating in Kazakhstan, 15 of which are state-owned (in the cities of Semey, Kostanay, Kentau, Uralsk, Arkalyk, Shakhtinsk, Astana, Kyzylorda, Taraz, Aktau and Almaty).
The total installed capacity of heat sources amounts to 43,231 Gcal/h. The available capacity of heat sources amounted to 37,566.7 Gcal/h.
Heat energy production across Kazakhstan in 2022 amounted to 94 million Gcal/h (2020 – 91 million Gcal/h, 2021 – 93 million Gcal/h).
The types of fuel used for heat energy generation are coal from Kazakhstan's deposits (~80%), natural gas (~15%) and fuel oil (~5%).
Heat Energy Transmission
The total length of heat networks in the Republic, calculated on a two-pipe basis, amounts to approximately 12,680 km. At the same time, about 49.2%, or 6,246 thousand km of networks, require replacement. The average depreciation of heat networks is 57%.
The heat supply sector is characterized by a low efficiency coefficient from heat energy production to consumption (an average of 75% for boilers and 58% for the entire system), high emissions and heat losses (18–42% at the heat transportation and distribution stage).
Heat Energy Supply
The heat energy supply sector is represented by ESOs, which purchase heat energy from heat-producing organizations and subsequently sell it to consumers. In most regions, power transmission organizations carry out energy supply activities. Heat energy supply is provided only within centralized and local heat supply systems.
Centralized heat supply systems based on CHPPs have received the greatest development in the Northern Zone of Kazakhstan – 64% of the total available heat capacity of CHPPs in the Republic of Kazakhstan, in the Southern Zone – 19%, and in the Western Zone – 17%.
The majority of heat power organizations are on the balance sheets of local executive bodies and, due to insufficient tariff revenues, the possibility of allocating budget subsidies is provided for the purpose of ensuring the safe passage of the heating season.
2.6 Digitalization of the Industry
Digitalization of the industry affects all levels of the electric power industry: generation, transmission, distribution, supply, consumption and system operation.
At the beginning of 2023, the elements of Smart Grid (Intelligent Networks) introduced in Kazakhstan include automatic frequency and power control systems (AFPCS), an automated commercial electricity metering system (AMR), substation monitoring and control systems (SMCS), an automated process control system (APCS), a centralized emergency automation system (CEAS), a supervisory control and data acquisition system (SCADA/EMS), a monitoring and control system based on synchrophasor technologies (WAMS/WACS, Wide Area Monitoring System/Control), a geographic information system (GIS), a billing information system (BIS), an electricity balancing market system (EBMS), substation equipment monitoring and diagnostics systems (SEMS), fiber-optic communication lines (FOCL), a flexible alternating current transmission system (FACTS, Flexible Alternating Current Transmission System), and partially intelligent electricity meters (Smart Meters).
However, the above technologies have not been introduced at all levels of electric energy production, transmission and consumption and/or their coverage remains limited.
2.7 Electric Power Industry Markets
Wholesale and retail markets operate in Kazakhstan.
The wholesale electric energy and capacity market consists of the wholesale electric energy market, the balancing electric energy market, the electric capacity market, and the market for system and ancillary services (Figure 1).
The wholesale electric energy market includes decentralized and centralized electric energy purchase and sale markets, operating on the basis of contracts concluded between market participants at prices and under delivery conditions established by agreement of the parties, as well as based on the results of centralized electric energy trading through spot trading for medium-term and long-term periods.
The balancing electric energy market has been operating in simulation mode for more than 15 years, that is, without financial settlements (actual monetary settlements for imbalances).
The electric capacity market is a market model with a Single Buyer, which carries out centralized purchase and sale of services for maintaining and ensuring the readiness of electric capacity, respectively. The capacity market operates under long-term contracts within the framework of investment agreements with the authorized body, as well as short-term contracts with energy-producing organizations, including CHPPs, and based on the results of competitive selection (through centralized trading) among existing energy-producing organizations for the right to sell their capacity service for the upcoming calendar year.
Fig. 1 – Wholesale Market
The market for system and ancillary services operates as a market for services provided by the system operator to wholesale electric energy market entities for transmission, technical dispatching, organization of balancing electric energy production and consumption, capacity reservation, as well as services purchased by the system operator from wholesale electric energy market entities to ensure the required volumes and structure of electric capacity regulating reserves, regulation of active and reactive power, and restoration of the power system from a de-energized state.
Wholesale Electric Energy Market
Currently, an energy-producing organization sells electric energy at a price not exceeding the selling price, which is determined as the sum of the marginal tariff for electric energy of the energy-producing organization and the surcharge to support the use of renewable energy sources. At the same time, the marginal tariff values are not indexed to the inflation rate. In addition, the introduction of individual price regulation for energy-producing organizations in 2019 minimized and practically eliminated conditions for competition between them.
Under conditions of the absolute predominance of bilateral electric energy purchase and sale contracts over centralized trading, energy supply organizations and wholesale consumers have limited access to electric energy from energy-producing organizations with low marginal tariff levels. Under these conditions, the above-mentioned entities are forced to purchase electric energy from energy sources with high marginal tariff levels.
Currently, several major entities operate in the electricity market (Samruk-Energy JSC, Eurasian Group LLP, CAEC JSC, Kazakhmys Corporation LLP), which own a significant share of conventional power plants, power transmission organizations and energy supply organizations.
Diagram 3 – Distribution of Electric Capacity
At the same time, access of third-party entities to the electricity generated by the above-mentioned groups is limited. Dominance by a limited number of entities is observed, whose total share in installed capacity exceeds 75% (Diagram 3). The remaining 24% belongs to owners holding more than 30 energy-producing organizations.
In fact, electricity prices for end consumers in the country, as a basic commodity, differ significantly between regions, which in turn creates unequal conditions for the population and businesses. At the same time, the main reason for differences in electricity prices, apart from individual price regulation for energy-producing organizations, is the policy of local executive bodies and the natural monopolies regulation body regarding tariff differentiation.
Centralized Trading
An analysis of the organization and conduct of centralized electricity trading shows that over the past five years (Table 1), demand for electricity from consumers and ESOs in the Northern and Southern zones of the UES RK has significantly exceeded the amount of electric energy offered for trading by energy-producing organizations, while the number of participants has reached a minimum level. Accordingly, the volume of transactions during this period has decreased to a historical minimum.
Table 1 – Comparative Table of Demand and Supply Volumes, million kWh
Download
Name
Spot Trading
Long-Term and Medium-Term Trading
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Northern–Southern Zone of the UES RK
| Supply volume |
|---|
1042
480
221
962
165
26006
17334
1425
2338
2066
| Number of sellers |
|---|
6
8
4
5
5
19
8
8
5
5
| Demand volume |
|---|
539
1163
631
1400
398
126614
293118
36995
31005
9561
| Number of buyers |
|---|
26
39
24
20
12
84
82
69
39
50
| Transaction volume |
|---|
98
345
190
794
109
21049
17598
749
2460
1254
| Demand-to-supply ratio |
|---|
52%
243%
285%
145%
241%
5 times
17 times
26 times
13 times
4.6 times
| Transactions / demand |
|---|
18%
30%
30%
57%
27%
17%
6%
2%
8%
13%
Western Zone of the UES RK
| Supply volume |
|---|
0
0
0
107
762
0
0
0
0
0
| Number of sellers |
|---|
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
| Demand volume |
|---|
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
| Number of buyers |
|---|
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
| Transaction volume |
|---|
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
| Demand-to-supply ratio |
|---|
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
| Transactions / demand |
|---|
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0% |
In 2022, at centralized spot trading in the Northern–Southern Zone of the UES RK, demand amounted to 398 million kWh, supply amounted to 165 million kWh, and transaction volume amounted to 109 million kWh. In the Western Zone, there was no demand, supply amounted to 762 million kWh, and no transactions took place.*
An analysis of the functioning of the centralized trading market shows that energy-producing organizations are generally not interested in participating in the market due to the high concentration of vertically integrated energy companies in Kazakhstan. They do not seek direct and open competition with one another, having divided the market (consumers) among themselves.
Retail Electricity Market
The retail electric energy market is a system of relations operating on the basis of public energy supply contracts between retail electric energy market entities outside the wholesale market.
The retail electricity market in its modern form emerged in 2004, when, in addition to the wholesale market, this segment of the electricity market was liberalized. For these purposes, in particular, the activities of regional electric grid companies related to electricity transmission were separated from their energy supply activities, and ESOs were established as legally independent enterprises.
The introduction of a competitive market model envisaged that private ESOs would be established to compete with guaranteed suppliers and with one another for the supply of electricity to retail consumers, thereby ensuring competition in the market.
As can be seen, numerous private ESOs have been established in the market; however, it has not yet been possible to fully establish an optimal commodity market structure for the development of competition among ESOs.
At the same time, the development of competition in the retail market between ESOs is conceptually limited by:
- the current structure of monopoly affiliations in the market;
- price regulation mechanisms in the form of cross-subsidization;
- insufficiently developed activity of retail consumers, particularly with regard to changing suppliers.
2.8 International Electricity Market
Within the framework of cross-border electricity trading, the Republic of Kazakhstan is currently participating in the establishment of two markets.
- Common Electric Power Market of the Eurasian Economic Union (hereinafter referred to as the CEM EAEU).
This market is being formed as a regional market based on the integration of the wholesale electricity markets of the five EAEU Member States, which have very different wholesale electricity trading designs and rules.
Taking into account the specific features of national markets, the parties have reached an agreement to preserve the existing national electric power markets when forming the CEM EAEU.
The methods of conducting mutual electric energy trading between participants in the Union's common electric power market will include:
- free bilateral contracts;
- centralized trading in forward contracts (week, month, quarter, year);
- centralized day-ahead trading;
- settlement of hourly deviations of actual electricity balance flows from planned values.
The opportunities of each entity in the domestic wholesale markets of the Member States when participating in the CEM EAEU will primarily depend on energy stability in the participating countries and the global economic situation, the development of generating capacities, and, of course, the policies pursued in the field of electric power engineering.
- Regional Electricity Market of Central Asian Countries (CAREM – Central Asia Regional Electricity Market).
Within the framework of the project, technical assistance is provided to the five Central Asian states (hereinafter referred to as CA), and support is provided for building their capacity to establish a regional market. Such a market is expected to strengthen the region's energy security, attract private investment in the energy sector of each country and contribute to economic growth, as well as enable electricity trading between Central Asia, Afghanistan and Pakistan.
The main objective and benefits of the Central Asian Regional Electricity Market consist in increasing the efficiency of electricity markets through:
- optimization of the use of primary energy resources;
- increasing the reliability and efficiency of the relevant power systems through the joint use of reserves and support in emergency situations;
- improving conditions for integrating continuously growing volumes of unstable generation based on RES into power systems through the pooling of balancing resources.
An important circumstance for the integration of the electricity markets of the CA countries is that the power systems of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan are already interconnected, while Turkmenistan intends to join the Unified Power System of Central Asia after its disconnection in 2003.
2.9 Professional Personnel Issues
The electric power industry continues to experience low remuneration levels for production personnel, resulting in an outflow of qualified personnel to related industries, where wage levels are higher by 1.5–3 times in most regions.
Diagram 4 – Average Salary
Diagram 4 presents consolidated information on the average salaries of CHPP production personnel compared with average salaries in the region and in the regional industrial sector.
Compared with the average salary in the region, satisfactory salary levels for CHPP production personnel are observed only in the city of Almaty, Almaty Region, East Kazakhstan Region, Kostanay Region, Pavlodar Region and North Kazakhstan Region.
In the remaining two cities of republican significance and 12 regions, the average salary at CHPPs does not reach the regional average salary level. The situation is particularly critical in Kyzylorda Region (44% of the regional level) and Abai Region (49% of the regional level).
Compared with the average salary in the regional industrial sector, satisfactory salary levels for CHPP production personnel are observed only in the city of Almaty, Almaty Region, Kostanay Region, Pavlodar Region and North Kazakhstan Region.
In the remaining two cities of republican significance and 13 regions, the average salary at CHPPs is not competitive with the average salary level in the regional industrial sector. The situation is particularly critical in Atyrau Region (30% of the regional industrial sector level), West Kazakhstan Region (34% of the regional industrial sector level) and Mangystau Region (37% of the regional industrial sector level).
Diagram 5 – EPO Personnel Shortage
According to a survey of EPOs, there is a shortage of personnel, which also negatively affects the reliable operation of organizations. Diagram 5 shows information on the shortage of production personnel at power plants across the country at the end of 2022. The greatest shortage of workers is observed at Aktobe CHPP JSC, Ridder CHPP JSC, Stepnogorsk CHPP LLP, Pavlodarenergo JSC (CHPP-3), Teplokommunenergo State Municipal Enterprise and Ekibastuzenergo LLP.
2.10 Main Problems of the Electric Power Industry
High accident rates. In 2022, 1,789 technological violations occurred at power plants, which is 23% more than in 2021 (1,456). Major accidents at Petropavlovsk CHPP-2, Ekibastuz CHPP and Ridder CHPP should be taken into account. A total of 20,017 technological violations occurred in electric grids, which is 48% more than in 2021 (13,525).
The main factors contributing to the increase in accident rates and the level of depreciation of the main equipment are:
- lack of accountability of shareholders (founders) and senior executives of energy enterprises for the quality of repair campaigns carried out;
- declining qualifications of authorized bodies and employees of energy companies, as well as a general decline in production discipline;
- declining investment attractiveness of the industry and, as a consequence, limited opportunities for the reconstruction, modernization and major repairs of energy assets, which has resulted in their physical and moral depreciation.
Shortage of electric energy and capacity. Due to insufficient generating capacity, according to the Forecast Balances of Electric Energy and Capacity for 2023–2029 (approved by Order No. 20 dated January 20, 2023), the following shortages are projected:
- electric energy: in 2023 – 0.8 billion kWh, in 2024 – 1.6 billion kWh, in 2025 – 1.6 billion kWh, in 2028 – 1.3 billion kWh, in 2029 – 5.5 billion kWh;
- electric capacity: in 2023 – 1,414 MW, in 2024 – 1,239 MW, in 2025 – 1,354 MW, in 2026 – 454 MW, in 2027 – 1,184 MW, in 2028 – 2,158 MW, in 2029 – 3,076 MW.
At the same time, a number of planned projects for the commissioning of new capacities are being implemented with delays of more than five years or have been suspended altogether.
Need to ensure the integrity of the power system. With the commissioning of new generating capacities, it is necessary to strengthen and develop the national electric grid and utilize the potential of regulating capacity in the western part of the country.
Insufficient development of heat power engineering. Despite its social importance, the country's heat power sector is not being properly developed. At the beginning of 2023, the technical condition of heat infrastructure in many regions was unsatisfactory; legal gaps in sectoral legislation regulating relations in the field of heat power engineering and control issues remained unresolved. Heat supply development schemes (plans) are absent in the regions. In addition, the market is characterized by low tariffs for heat energy, low investment attractiveness and a lack of qualified personnel. At the same time, there is a local problem of the absence of complete and reliable information on the technical condition and productivity of centralized heat supply systems, which makes it impossible to assess the state of the industry for high-quality planning and development.
Insufficient level of digitalization of the industry. At the beginning of 2023, the low level (limited coverage) of digitalization and automation in the processes of energy production, transmission and consumption leads to:
- the absence of a unified system for collecting and verifying data reliability, and the predominance of manual data collection;
- low observability of electrical operating conditions in real time and limitations on the effectiveness of power system management;
- restrictions on consumers' ability to manage their own energy consumption modes.
Restrictions on achieving environmental commitments. In order to achieve carbon neutrality, the country has embarked on a course of decarbonization of the industry. Accordingly, the implementation of environmental commitments has begun through the development of renewable energy sources (RES) and alternative energy. However, for the purposes of energy security, taking into account the decline in explored natural gas reserves and the limited gas transportation infrastructure (the pace of commissioning gas-fired power plants will decrease), coal-fired power plants will retain their presence in the generation sector in the medium term. The introduction of best available techniques (hereinafter referred to as BAT), an automated environmental emissions monitoring system (hereinafter referred to as AEMS), carbon capture and storage, and direct air capture (DAC, Direct Air Capture) are capital-intensive, and the costs of these measures are not provided for in the existing tariff-setting methodology. Thus, at present, there is no mechanism or source of financing for environmental measures (implementation of AEMS and BAT, financial provision for the elimination of the consequences of operating Category I facilities). In addition, there are no agreed plans for the commissioning and decommissioning of generating capacities in the long-term transition to carbon neutrality.
Ineffective tariff-setting system. Due to the long-term restraint of tariffs, a low level of investment in the industry has developed, which has led to the problems listed above. These problems cannot be resolved without a sufficient amount of funds being invested in the industry, which, in turn, requires a revision of tariff policy. Under current conditions, indexing tariffs to the inflation rate is insufficient, since tariffs have been artificially restrained for many years, which has led to the depreciation of grids and the outflow of qualified personnel due to low remuneration levels. In addition, there are no state support measures for concessional lending for capital-intensive investments in the electric power industry.
Ineffective energy supervision system. The industry requires measures to improve the effectiveness of the existing energy supervision system, such as mutual obligations, increased accountability of energy sector entities and their senior executives, compulsory enforcement of instructions, and transparency of procurement procedures carried out by energy enterprises and natural monopoly entities (hereinafter referred to as NMEs).
Need to develop the wholesale market model. The existing wholesale market model has the following shortcomings: speculative transactions in the purchase and sale of electricity, unproductive intermediaries, lack of equal and non-discriminatory access to electric energy, operation of the balancing market in simulation mode, absence of obligations on the part of energy-producing organizations in the capacity market regarding the targeted use of funds, underdevelopment of the market for system and ancillary services and its almost complete dependence on imported supplies, and continued high concentration of vertically integrated companies.
Absence of an institutional framework. At the beginning of 2023, a weak institutional foundation had developed in the energy sector, including the absence of an Energy Development Institute to conduct analytical work, develop strategies and proposals for improving legislation. In addition, there is no investment support for conducting research and developing new technologies.
Low salary levels and shortage of qualified personnel in the industry. One of the critical problems of the electric power industry is the low level of remuneration for production personnel. As a result, there is a sharp outflow of qualified personnel to related industries. It should be noted that the payroll funds of energy enterprises are limited by the tariff estimate and, accordingly, by tariffs.
Conclusions of the Analysis of Problems and Trends
Most of the problems are common to individual areas of the electric power industry and are cross-sectoral in nature. They include:
- Technical condition and limitations:
- projected shortage of electric energy and capacity;
- high level of depreciation and, as a consequence, high accident rates of UES RK energy assets (generating and power transmission assets);
- limited transmission capacity between individual energy nodes of the NEG and isolation of the Western Zone of the UES RK;
- low level of digitalization and automation of the industry.
- Investment costs:
- reduction in investment in energy assets due to the existing tariff regulation system, which also fails to provide incentives for reducing own costs and increasing efficiency;
- absence of a long-term state tariff-setting policy that takes into account tariff indexation to the inflation rate;
- absence of state support measures for concessional lending for capital-intensive investments in the electric power industry.
- Market shortcomings:
- contradictions between the market-based principles of the rules and design of the electricity market and the price regulation policy applied to market segments (electricity production and supply).
- Regulatory issues:
- a large number of power transmission organizations;
- absence of an independent Market Council.
- Restrictions on achieving environmental commitments:
- inconsistency between environmental policy and the industry's tariff regulation policy;
- absence of mechanisms and sources of financing for environmental measures (implementation of AEMS and BAT, financial provision for the elimination of the consequences of operating Category I facilities);
- absence of agreed plans for the commissioning and decommissioning of generating capacities in the context of the transition to carbon neutrality.
- Institutional issues:
- absence of an institution and/or scientific and technical council for the development of the electric power industry (conducting analytical work, economic modeling and calculations of the impact of the electric power industry on the economy, developing proposals for improving legislation and a strategic vision for the industry).
- Socio-economic issues:
- general deterioration of production discipline in energy companies;
- low remuneration in the industry and, consequently, staff shortages;
- declining qualifications of government bodies and employees of energy companies.
Section 3. Overview of International Experience
3.1 Electricity Market Models
Summarizing global experience in electric power industry reform, four basic models of the functioning of the electric power industry can be identified:
- vertically integrated model – the entire cycle, from electricity production to sales, is carried out within an integrated company, with sales being conducted at regulated tariffs;
- independent producers model – essentially a vertically integrated model, provided that competition exists among producers;
- single buyer model – competition among producers to obtain a contract for the supply of electricity to a single buyer, which sells electricity to sales companies at regulated tariffs;
- competitive model – competition among electricity producers within the wholesale electricity market, the main buyers in which are sales companies that directly interact with consumers.
Each of the listed models has both advantages and disadvantages, and their combination with internal factors characteristic of a particular country influences the choice of the target model for the functioning of the electric power industry. The advantages and disadvantages of each of the four models are presented in Table 2.
Table 2 – Advantages and Disadvantages of Electric Power Industry Models
Download
| Models | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Vertically integrated model | preservation of the existing structure; possibility of price control – predictability for consumers and the state | absence of economic incentives to increase efficiency; need for state participation in financing the industry or transferring costs to consumers |
| Independent producers model | attraction of private investors with minimal structural changes; possibility of price control – predictability for consumers and the state | need for state guarantees to attract private capital to the industry in terms of price levels and policy regarding other market components |
| Single Buyer Model | attraction of private investors with limited structural changes; possibility of price control; predictability for consumers and the state | need to ensure transparency in the operations of the "single buyer"; occurrence of cash flow gaps for energy-producing organizations due to delays in receiving payment for electricity from the "single buyer" |
| Competitive model | attractiveness to private investors; availability of incentives to increase efficiency; stimulation of the industry's self-development | inability to control prices; need for significant structural transformations; adjustment of prices to an economically justified level |
Models for organizing economic relations in the electric power industries of different countries were developed in accordance with their main objectives and based on the availability of initial economic conditions (sufficiency of generating capacity, relative volume of electricity production, level of integration of transmission within the country with neighboring countries, ratio of wholesale market prices to economic cost, access to the stock market, etc.). Depending on the reasons for restructuring, specific approaches and directions were selected.
Specific approaches to market transformation of the electric power industry differ from country to country. At the same time, each country addressed common fundamental tasks without which restructuring would have been impossible. Such tasks include: the process of transferring electric power facilities into private ownership, determining the types of independent market entities, choosing the form of organization of the electricity market, developing a mechanism for trading and settlements in the electricity market, and determining the degree, form and methods of electricity market regulation.
The transition to a market-based, more or less competitive model of the functioning and development of national energy systems is associated with certain problems that every country embarking on the restructuring of electric power enterprises faces, in one way or another:
- separation of the industry by functions, i.e. separation of electricity generation from its transmission and distribution;
- creation of a competitive generation market;
- formation of the infrastructure of the electric power sector;
- application of a more restrained state regulation policy;
- price regulation only by limiting the upper price level, moving away from regulation through limiting the rate of return;
- separation of the electricity transmission function from its distribution and sales;
- gradual creation of conditions for competition in the field of electricity trading;
- attraction of foreign investment in national electric power industries;
- creation of independent system operators.
The resolution of problems and the choice of the path for restructuring electric power enterprises in an individual country are primarily associated not only with national specificities but also with the investment capabilities of each particular state.
As a result of the analysis of the nature and content of the restructuring processes of national energy companies based on functional separation and the introduction of a competitive mechanism for their operation and development, it can be concluded that, in the modern period, a wholesale electricity market has been established to varying degrees, and positive results have been achieved in most countries, such as increased reliability of electricity supply to consumers, improved efficiency of the electric power industry and reduced prices for industry products.
Thus, based on international experience, the wholesale electric energy market model in Kazakhstan will be reformed.
3.2 Experience in the Organization and Operation of Self-Regulatory Organizations in the Electric Power Industry
International experience of four self-regulatory organizations in the field of electric power engineering – the Russian Federation, the European Union, the State of Texas in the United States of America (ERCOT – Electric Reliability Council of Texas), as well as the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC – North American Electric Reliability Corporation) – was taken from the report on the Kazakhstan Market Council – a new model prepared by TETRA TECH ES, INC for the USAID (United States Agency for International Development) project "Central Asia Energy".
Market Council (Russian Federation). The Market Council was established to ensure the functioning of the commercial infrastructure of the electricity market, effective interaction between wholesale and retail markets, the creation of favorable conditions for attracting investment in the electric power industry, and the development of a common position among wholesale and retail market participants on electric power industry issues and the promotion of self-regulation in the electricity market.
The Market Council maintains a register of wholesale market entities; develops forms of wholesale market regulations and standard contracts; organizes pre-trial dispute settlement (mediation) processes between wholesale market entities and other electric power industry entities; establishes a system and procedure for applying property and existing penalty sanctions to wholesale market entities, including exclusion from the Wholesale Electricity Market; participates in the preparation of draft rules for wholesale and retail markets and proposals for their amendment; monitors compliance by wholesale market entities with wholesale market standards and rules; confirms the volume of generation based on RES by qualified generating facilities; monitors price conditions in wholesale and retail markets; and assesses the economic consequences for consumers in wholesale and retail electric energy (capacity) markets resulting from the possible decommissioning of a power plant in respect of which the owner has submitted an application for decommissioning.
ERCOT (Texas, USA). Texas operates a power system with dozens of connected wholesale and retail electricity suppliers operating in an open market. ERCOT is an independent non-profit organization that manages the operation of the state's power system, as well as the wholesale and retail markets, while ensuring non-discriminatory open access to the transmission system. ERCOT is regulated by the state Public Utility Commission.
The main responsibility of ERCOT is to ensure the balancing of supply and demand to guarantee the reliable operation of the power system and to manage electricity flows for approximately 26 million residents of the state.
ERCOT also ensures the maintenance of competitiveness in the electricity market by monitoring and managing exchange transactions between electricity suppliers and energy-producing organizations, while monitoring the compliance of transactions with the rules and regulations established by ERCOT. In addition, as in other organized markets, ERCOT has a designated market monitor whose role is to assess market competitiveness, potential or actual abuses by market participants, and develop recommendations for improving market operations. Furthermore, regulatory authorities also monitor the market to ensure the fairness and reasonableness of outcomes, including the prices obtained in the market.
As of April 2021, ERCOT stated that it was funded through a system administration tariff of 55.5 cents per MWh, which amounts to 0.0555 cents per kWh. For most Texans, this means that approximately 50–60 cents of their monthly electricity bill goes toward funding ERCOT.
NERC (North American Electric Reliability Corporation). NERC is an international organization established to ensure the reliability of North America's high-voltage power systems (Bulk Power System or BPS). Its mission is to ensure effective and efficient risk reduction to guarantee the reliability and security of power system operations. To this end, it "develops and enforces reliability standards; annually assesses seasonal and long-term reliability; monitors high-voltage power systems; and conducts training, preparation and certification of industry personnel". NERC's area of responsibility covers the continental United States, Canada and the northern part of the State of Baja California in Mexico. NERC is the Electric Reliability Organization (ERO) in North America, whose activities are overseen by the US Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (hereinafter referred to as FERC) (Federal Energy Regulatory Commission) and Canadian government authorities. NERC's jurisdiction includes consumers, owners and operators of high-voltage electricity systems serving nearly 400 million people.
NERC's annual business plan and budget are subject to approval by FERC, and after approval, NERC's annual funding is provided primarily through contributions from organizations serving consumers. These contributions are distributed according to the "demand for electricity" principle. Similar financing mechanisms are provided in Canada in accordance with the specific laws and regulations of each province. Funding requirements for regional organizations are considered separately in the relevant business plans and budgets, which must be reviewed and approved by NERC and FERC. Assessments for regional organizations in the United States are included in the overall NERC assessments for organizations serving consumers. NERC is also funded through third-party financing, fees for training, testing and seminars, software services, and deductions from fines for violations of electric grid reliability requirements.
Nord Pool (Northern Europe). The Nord Pool Group operates Europe's leading electricity market in terms of electricity trading, clearing, contract conclusion and the provision of related services in day-ahead and intraday markets in 16 European countries. Interconnections between the Nordic countries, continental Europe and the Baltic region have made it possible to create a large market, which has increased the reliability of energy supply and provided access to various sources of energy generation. Approximately 360 companies from 20 countries trade on Nord Pool markets in the Nordic and Baltic regions, the United Kingdom (Great Britain), Central Western Europe (covering Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg and the Netherlands), and Poland.
Nord Pool belongs to markets where only electricity is traded (markets without capacity trading), unlike markets where capacity is paid for and traded, as is the case in Russia, for example. In Nord Pool electricity markets, consumers do not pay for the availability of generating capacities, and electricity suppliers do not receive capacity payments.
The Nord Pool market system consists of four independent markets – spot, futures, options and base markets. The Scandinavian electricity market has the following features: unified trading rules, absence of cross-border duties on electricity purchases and sales, and electricity trading on the centralized market in two forms (physical delivery of electricity, i.e. direct electricity supplies from producer to consumer, and financial instruments).
In Kazakhstan, taking into account international experience, the Market Council will also be reformed and improved.
3.3 Digitalization
Internet of Things
According to estimates by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), when introducing the Internet of Things into Russia's electric power grid infrastructure, the focus should be on improving the controllability of substations, power transmission lines and other grid elements through remote monitoring. Such projects will help reduce operation and maintenance costs while preventing technological and commercial losses.
As for the electricity generation sector, the use of the Internet of Things (hereinafter referred to as IoT) will make it possible to reduce fuel consumption, the procurement of which currently accounts for more than half of the operating costs of power plants. According to expert forecasts, the overall economic effect of implementing IoT in the electric power industry will reach 532 billion rubles by 2025, of which 180 billion rubles will represent prevented energy losses.
IoT-based solutions in the energy sector are increasingly combined with artificial intelligence (hereinafter referred to as AI) and machine learning functionalities for processing and analyzing large volumes of data generated during equipment operation. These technologies help identify non-obvious patterns in the operation of facilities, literally "hear" an enterprise and establish a dialogue at a new level based on this information. In international practice, power plants are already emerging that are capable of effectively monitoring and managing key operating processes in a fully autonomous mode using data collection and analysis tools. For example, AI and machine learning capabilities are entirely sufficient to handle the monitoring and adjustment of gas turbines – these tasks have already been automated in one way or another at thousands of enterprises around the world.
Examples of successful IoT projects in the Russian electric power industry include a project implemented at "Inter RAO Electric Power Generation". The system for collecting, transmitting and calculating technological information introduced at the company helps reduce excessive fuel consumption and increases operational reliability. The payback period of the project is estimated at 5–7 years, taking into account that the system makes it possible to save 130 billion rubles annually on fuel.
Where there is no technical possibility of installing sensors, the task is solved by equipping personnel with eSOMS systems (electronic Shift Operations Management System). Rosenergoatom Corporation introduced such solutions at the Smolensk and Voronezh nuclear power plants (hereinafter referred to as NPPs), where they helped optimize facility inspection tasks, report preparation and verification of historical data, with the possibility of creating predictive models.
Robotics
Investment in creating a new level of safe working environments for power plant personnel is increasing in the electric power industry, and one of the leading areas in this field is the commissioning for commercial operation of robots resistant to extreme working conditions and controlled remotely. Such solutions are also based on AI/IoT technologies, and recently their capabilities have been supplemented with augmented reality functionality, through which images from cameras installed on robots acquire an interactive component.
In Western countries, robots are being developed and introduced to perform diagnostic and maintenance functions for high-voltage power transmission lines. Such mechanisms are suspended from the line wires, and their actions are controlled from the ground by an operator using a controller. The robots are equipped with sensors and video cameras that make it possible to identify problem areas on the wires.
In areas with long winter periods, cleaning robots are used to remove snow and ice from power transmission lines. Some models are capable of unscrewing and tightening bolts and nuts and removing foreign objects from wires. Nuclear power plants are also being robotized: for example, robots are assigned the task of inspecting the primary reactor circuits using ultrasound.
Smart Grids (Smart Grid)
The problem of ensuring the uninterrupted operation of power grids remains unresolved worldwide: even in countries that are relatively well off in this respect, it has not been possible to achieve 100% grid reliability. In the United States, this figure stands at 99.97%; just a few outages per year can result in losses of $100–150 billion.
To address this problem, technologies belonging to the Smart Grid family, or “intelligent power grid”, are used. Essentially, this is a less centralized, more controllable and automated infrastructure built on the basis of several concepts that are actively being developed today. These include advanced infrastructure for measuring consumption and various solutions for visualizing load distribution and the available grid capacity in real time.
In the European Union, the adopted Smart Grid concept envisages the full integration of small-scale distributed generation into power systems using modern telecommunications and information technologies. There are also interpretations of the Smart Grid concept that focus on distribution power grids incorporating distributed generation, with active and adaptive grid properties being developed through the advancement of a distributed adaptive automation system, the extensive use of computer technologies and modern control systems.
Some of the main properties of power systems under the Smart Grid concept are self-restoration in response to emergency disturbances and resistance to adverse impacts.
Two illustrative and effective examples of the implementation of the Smart Grid concept are the Jeju Smart Grid Demonstration Project in South Korea and Smart Grid Smart City (SGSC) in Australia.
Jeju Smart Grid Demonstration Project. South Korea imported up to 97% of its energy, while the country's climatic conditions increased the need for autonomy: in autumn, Pacific typhoons pass through coastal areas, most frequently along the coast of Jeju Island. The Jeju Smart Grid Demonstration Project was launched in 2009 and tested until 2013 on Jeju Island, whose sunny and windy climate makes it an ideal location for implementing the Micro Grid concept. The project, which covers 6,000 homes, is monitored by the Korean Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy (MOTIE). By 2030, the island is planned to become carbon-neutral and energy-independent. A total of 169 companies are participating in the project.
It is expected that, if the planned objectives are achieved, by 2030 South Korea will generate 11% of all its energy from renewable energy sources (compared with 2.1% in 2012), eliminate 230 million tonnes of CO2, create 50,000 jobs, receive 74 trillion won ($64 billion) in domestic demand for new technologies, save at least 47 trillion won ($40 billion) currently spent on energy imports, no longer need to build new power plants costing 3.2 trillion won ($2.8 billion), and earn 49 trillion won ($42 billion) from exporting its developments.
Smart Grid Smart City (SGSC). The Smart Grid Smart City (SGSC) project in Australia was developed and funded by the Australian Government in cooperation with Ausgrid, Energy Australia and their partners: IBM Australia, GE Energy Australia, Sydney Water and Newcastle City Council. Project funding consisted of a government grant of $100 million and $400 million from the project consortium. The project commenced in 2010 and was officially completed in 2014.
An analysis of the system's performance results indicates an economic benefit of between $9.5 billion and $28 billion over 20 years, while private consumers will save between $156 and $2,000 per year.
In Russia, Smart Grid technology is being implemented by Rosseti as part of 10 pilot projects. This is the company's own solution, which is expected to reduce electricity losses by 225.3 million kWh and achieve an optimization level of RUB 35.8 billion in repairs.
One of the first “digital” 110 kV substations (hereinafter referred to as substations) was commissioned in Krasnoyarsk in 2018. The substation is based on the iSAS hardware and software complex, an integrated substation protection and control system designed to provide relay protection, emergency automation and an automated control system. Digitalization made it possible to reduce the amount of cables of various types by a factor of 10: from 150–160 km to approximately 15 km. Overall, the substation cost 5% less than comparable facilities of the previous generation. In the long term, taking into account the increased reliability of its operation due to a high degree of automation, improved monitoring quality and controllability, as well as the absence of operational personnel, the substation is expected to generate an economic benefit of approximately RUB 75 million over 30 years of operation.
Electricity Demand Management
The development of telecommunications, the widespread adoption of automation and control systems, as well as the evolution of developed electricity markets, have led to the emergence of the demand management concept, which envisages increasing demand elasticity through targeted intervention in consumer equipment when the relevant economic or technological conditions arise.
The cheapest capacity in the energy market is held by consumers in the form of the ability to manage their own demand. It costs the market nothing in terms of investment, yet it solves current problems, for example, in regulation more effectively than any generation facility. This is in addition to the substantial savings on the construction of peak energy infrastructure that demand management can provide once it reaches a certain scale.
The main objectives of electricity demand management are to reduce peak loads in the power system, which is necessary both to lower electricity market prices and to prevent excessive capital-intensive construction of power plants and electricity grids, optimize power system management, and integrate renewable energy sources.
Various types of equipment used by industrial, agricultural, commercial and household consumers may participate in demand management.
The main opportunities for consumers to participate in demand management are associated with shifting consumption schedules to periods of lower prices, stopping or reducing the intensity of production processes, fully or partially switching off lighting, ventilation and air-conditioning systems, as well as using their own sources, including starting backup power sources or disconnecting from the grid to operate in island mode, with their own consumption supplied by a backup power source.
According to various estimates, the potential for reducing peak loads in the power system through demand management programmes amounts to 10–15% of the peak load.
The creation of aggregators as a new function in the electricity market is a key driver ensuring an increase in the volume of controllable demand, the attraction of private investment and greater competition.
Practice shows that an important element of the regulatory framework is allowing independent aggregators to operate in the market. For example, in some US markets, more than 80% of demand management capacity is provided by independent aggregators (82% in PJM according to 2015 data), despite the fact that suppliers may also act as aggregators.
Automation of Maintenance and Repair
Repair work and maintenance of facilities (maintenance and repair, M&R) are among the fundamental components of the business processes of the largest system-forming companies in the energy sector. The FSA (field service automation) segment can currently be described as one of the fastest-developing areas in the electric power industry. IT solutions in this field make it possible to promptly obtain information on the status of a task after a crew has visited a facility, avoid duplication of tasks when recording network defects, strengthen control over work performance, and eliminate typical shortcomings in the workflows of service engineers and repair crews.
Modern solutions in this field offer extensive opportunities for scaling and integration with other industrial information systems: ERP, EAM and CMMS. They support compatibility with mobile platforms (Android, Windows 8.1/10), are NFC-compatible and ensure prompt real-time data exchange through any wireless communication channels.
PJSC Kubanenergo began using such a system in its operations at the end of 2018, connecting approximately 800 employees to it.
Centralized Monitoring
In the thermal power plant and hydroelectric power plant segments, there is a high demand for and relevance of solutions for centralized monitoring of the technical condition of power units, compliance with industrial safety regulations and monitoring of personnel activities.
It is clear that control rooms have always existed at such facilities. However, the actual implementation of the centralized monitoring concept became possible relatively recently, thanks to the development of data exchange protocols (FC, iSCSI, etc.), which together made it possible to reliably connect geographically remote monitoring systems to a central control point. Virtualization technologies have also played an important role in the development of centralized monitoring, as they make it possible to reduce the load on local IT resources at facilities while handling critical data-related tasks in a remote data processing centre.
Based on international experience, further digitalization of the sector is necessary in Kazakhstan, and therefore an “Intelligent Power System” will be introduced.
3.4 Development of Generation by Types of Energy Resources Used
France. In November 2021, a strategic decision was made to resume the construction of nuclear reactors in order to ensure the country's energy security, with the main focus up to 2050 to be placed on nuclear power plants.
The operating life of the 56 existing nuclear reactors is planned to be extended to 50 years, whereas 40 years had previously been considered the safe operating life. Six new-generation EPR-2 reactors will also be built. Their construction will begin in 2028, and commissioning is scheduled for 2035. At least EUR 50.5 billion will be invested in the project. Furthermore, eight additional units of this type are envisaged and will be built at a later date.
As regards renewable energy sources, whose share in France's energy balance is still small, the emphasis will be placed on solar energy rather than wind power.
The amount of energy obtained from the sun is planned to increase tenfold, while wind energy is to increase twofold. To achieve this, 50 offshore wind farms will be established. Currently, nuclear power plants generate more than 70% of all electricity consumed in the country (this figure is planned to reach 80%). Solar energy accounts for up to 2%, wind power for 8%, and gas and coal for up to 9% of total generation. At the same time, thanks to its substantial nuclear capacity, France generates more electricity than it consumes, exporting it to Germany and Italy.
Germany. According to estimates by the German Government, in 2022 the country will import approximately 35% of its natural gas from Russia (compared with 55% in 2021), using most of it for heating and industry.
In 2021, electricity generated using natural gas accounted for approximately 15% of Germany's total electricity production. In 2022, a decline in the share of gas in electricity generation was observed. Germany outlined a number of steps intended to accelerate the reduction of the share of gas in its energy sector and create reserves for the following winter.
The Government will allow companies to expand the use of coal-fired power plants as an alternative energy source, taking into account delays in achieving environmental targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The Coal Use Act will remain in force until 31 March 2024, by which time the Government hopes to establish a sustainable alternative to Russian gas.
The Government plans to introduce an auction system that will encourage industry to reduce gas consumption. Coal-fired thermal power plants in Germany have a total capacity of 45 GW and generate approximately one-third of the country's total electricity. As early as 2022, it was planned to disconnect thermal power plants with a capacity of 12.5 GW from the power grid.
Germany had previously decided to phase out nuclear power by 2022. However, in order for the country to meet its national and international climate protection targets, the Federal Republic of Germany must accelerate its transition to clean electricity. By 2050, carbon dioxide emissions in the country must amount to 80–95 percent of the 1990 level.
Japan. Japan intends to reduce its energy dependence by resuming the operation of nuclear power plants that were shut down following the accident at the Fukushima-1 nuclear power plant in 2011. Requirements for nuclear facilities have been tightened, and only a few of the 30 nuclear power units are currently operational. Before the accident at the nuclear power plant in Fukushima Prefecture, nuclear energy accounted for approximately 30% of Japan's energy balance, whereas this figure currently stands at approximately 4%, with the main burden having shifted to thermal power plants. The country's Government expects a partial restart of nuclear power plants in the near future.
Japan will increase its energy independence not only through nuclear power plants but also by developing green energy and diversifying its energy supply sources.
By 2030, it is planned to attract JPY 150 trillion (USD 1.16 trillion) in new investment to implement a roadmap that includes the following initiatives: maximum use of growth-oriented carbon pricing, which increases predictability for companies while simultaneously promoting growth and innovation; the use of investment incentives that integrate regulatory measures, such as energy efficiency standards, and financial support, such as assistance in promoting long-term large-scale investments, as a package; reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 46% by 2030; and achieving carbon neutrality by 2050.
United States. Nuclear power plants in the United States produce more than half of the country's carbon-free electricity. Therefore, support is being provided for the operation of these plants in order to achieve clean energy objectives. The United States will allocate $6 billion to support commercial nuclear power plants that are at risk of closure due to financial difficulties.
British and American companies are developing an electronic platform and engineering solutions for projects involving the conversion of coal-fired power plants into nuclear power plants. It is proposed that modular reactors be installed at thermal power plants and combined heat and power plants in place of coal-fired boilers, with conversion work beginning as early as 2030. The installation of small modular reactors (hereinafter referred to as SMRs) at thermal power plants and combined heat and power plants is expected to reduce costs by 35% compared with the construction of new nuclear power plants, with the first reactors expected to appear by 2027 and the conversion process potentially beginning in 2030. For the time being, project participants plan to operate in the United States, where coal-fired generation ranks second only to gas-fired generation.
According to the International Atomic Energy Agency, the construction of SMRs is the most promising option for the development of nuclear energy. The main advantages of SMRs, with a capacity of up to 300 MW per power unit, include rapid construction (3–5 years, depending on the technology), compactness (the required area is approximately 6 hectares), cost-effectiveness (fuel replacement every 3–7 years, and in some cases up to 30 years), and disposal (lower disposal costs).
China. China, which ranks first in the world in terms of carbon dioxide emissions into the atmosphere, is simultaneously a leading investor in alternative energy sources. In 2016, approximately two-thirds of all electricity generated in China came from coal, while one-quarter was obtained from clean energy sources. Nuclear power accounted for 3.4 percent of total electricity production. In just the last year, China increased the total capacity of its nuclear power plants from 27 to 34 GW, representing the largest increase in the country's history.
The Chinese leadership's objective is to have 110 nuclear power plants with a capacity of 130 GW by 2030, which will make it possible to implement plans to reduce greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere. To achieve this, Beijing will commission four to six new reactors annually. Reactors manufactured in China will be installed not only within the territory of the People's Republic of China but also in neighbouring countries along the so-called new “Silk Road”, which passes through the countries of Central Asia and Pakistan.
India, Pakistan and South Korea. Other countries in the region are also in no hurry to abandon peaceful nuclear energy. The Indian economy is growing by 6–7 percent annually; however, power supply interruptions and outdated infrastructure are hindering the country's development. Like Beijing, New Delhi is also focusing on the development of alternative energy. At the same time, the country's political elite is convinced that India must use every available opportunity to generate electricity, including nuclear power plants. In May, the Indian Government decided to construct ten new reactors. At present, 21 nuclear power plants are operating in the country.
Neighbouring Pakistan is also struggling with power supply interruptions and outdated infrastructure. Four small reactors are currently in operation in the country, and the Government plans to build seven more by 2030. China will also participate in the construction of the new nuclear power plants.
At the same time, as many as 25 nuclear power plants are currently operating in the relatively small territory of South Korea. Another three are under construction, and two are to be commissioned by 2029. According to the authorities' plans, the share of nuclear energy in the country's energy balance should increase from 30 to 40 percent.
Active discussions on this subject are also taking place in other Southeast Asian countries. Vietnam intends to build eight new reactors, while Thailand plans to build five. Malaysia and the Philippines also plan to commission one reactor each.
Taking into account international experience in generation structures, in addition to further developing renewable energy sources, it is advisable for Kazakhstan to develop alternative energy, particularly nuclear energy.
Section 4. Vision for the Development of the Electric Power Industry
Taking into account global challenges and constant changes in the world economy, as well as international experience, the Republic of Kazakhstan needs an accelerated and comprehensive transition to a sustainable, efficient and flexible electric power industry capable of being ready at any time to meet challenges and threats.
The development of the electric power industry is focused on the following:
Technical re-equipment will ensure coverage of the projected demand for electricity and heat, reliability of energy and heat supply, strengthening of the electricity grid transit potential, reduction of losses in electricity grids through the modernization of existing generation facilities and construction of new ones, and integration of the Western Kazakhstan power system with the Unified Power System of Kazakhstan;
Digital transformation will ensure the organization of primary data collection without human involvement, the creation of infrastructure for data transmission / storage / protection / processing, the creation of a system for managing and monitoring the reliability of energy supply, and the development of customer services for consumers;
Improvement of the tariff-setting system will make it possible to cover the costs of energy enterprises, which will subsequently strengthen the technical condition of assets, increase energy supply security (reduce accident rates), enable the introduction of best available techniques, and improve the socio-economic situation of industry employees;
Reforming the wholesale electricity market through the introduction of a centralized electricity purchase and sale model and the launch of a real-time balancing electricity market will ensure the principle of full competition among market participants, an average electricity tariff for consumers, equal conditions for wholesale market entities, reduced deviations between electricity production and consumption by entities, improvement of the market for system and ancillary services, and development of export potential. At the same time, following the successful resolution of tasks within the framework of the single purchaser concept, the issue of further liberalization of the electricity market, with the exclusion of the single electricity purchaser mechanism, will be considered;
Improvement of the Market Council will strengthen the institutional foundations of the electric power industry and consolidate the interests of energy enterprises, electricity consumers and potential investors;
Taking into account global challenges and constant changes in the world economy, environmental commitments, as well as international experience, the Republic of Kazakhstan needs an accelerated and comprehensive transition to a sustainable, efficient and flexible electric power industry capable of being ready at any time to meet challenges and threats;
Fulfilment of environmental commitments in the electric power industry will be achieved through the further development of renewable energy (alongside the development of flexible generation capacity) and distributed generation, the application of energy-saving measures, the use of ACM and carbon capture and storage technologies at coal-fired power plants;
Expanding the functions and powers of the Sectoral Centre for Technological Competencies will make it possible to conduct comprehensive research into the problems of developing the electric power industry and develop systemic measures to address them. In addition, centralized analytical work, economic modelling and calculations of the impact of the electric power industry on the economy will be ensured, as well as the development of proposals for improving legislation and forming a strategic vision for the development of the sector.
Section 5. Main Principles and Approaches to Development
The development of the electric power industry will be based on compliance with the following principles:
Unity of management of the electric power complex of the Republic of Kazakhstan as a particularly important life-support system for the country's economic and social complexes;
Improvement of the technical and economic performance indicators of the efficiency of operation and management of the Unified Power System of Kazakhstan under specified parameters of reliability, environmental sustainability and affordability of electricity supply for consumers;
Customer orientation – full satisfaction of consumer demand for energy under specified reliability parameters, and protection of the rights of participants in the electricity and heat markets by creating competitive market conditions that guarantee consumers the right to choose electricity and heat suppliers;
Development of the institutional foundations of the electric power industry in terms of formulating a balanced and long-term development strategy for the sector and a data-driven policy;
Diversification and digital transformation of the sector, as a result of which full transparency, openness and quality of all processes in the electric power complex will be ensured, the efficiency of all sectors will be increased, an intelligent metering and operational and technological control system will be created, the role of consumers will be enhanced, low-carbon and distributed energy will develop on a large scale, and the role of the electric power industry in the country's economy will increase;
Environmental sustainability of energy sources in light of the Republic of Kazakhstan's transition to a green economy, the creation of conditions and implementation of environmental and economic mechanisms to fulfil environmental commitments in the electric power industry in order to stimulate the use of best available techniques and attract investment.
The vision, principles and approaches set out in the Concept are aimed at ensuring electricity consumer demand and protecting the rights of participants in the electricity and heat markets, as well as ensuring accelerated development and the safe and stable operation of the electric power complex of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Thus, taking into account the analysis of the current situation, international experience and global trends incorporated into the Concept, the vision for the development of the electric power industry and the main principles for achieving the stated objective, it is envisaged that tasks will be implemented in the following areas:
Area 1. Technological Re-equipment
1. Development of a long-term scheme for the location of Kazakhstan's electric power capacities
A long-term scheme for the location of Kazakhstan's electric power capacities will be developed. This will make it possible to establish the structure of generating capacities (identifying facilities to be decommissioned) and power grid facilities for the long term, create conditions for ensuring a prospective balance of electricity production and consumption, and prevent electricity and capacity shortages by the most efficient means.
2. Modernization of existing and construction of new generating capacities, including the prospective development of nuclear power plants
Modernization of existing capacities and construction of new capacities will be carried out (within the framework of further development of coal-fired power plants, investment agreements, and auctions for the construction of generating units with flexible generation modes). This is a key task in light of the current shortage of generating capacity and the lack of flexible generation. In accordance with the Energy Balance until 2035, prospective sites will be identified and studied, and measures will be taken to ensure the implementation of specific projects for the further construction of energy capacities, including nuclear power plants**.**
The issue of the prospective use of small modular nuclear reactors in Kazakhstan will be considered.
3. Strengthening electricity connections and integrating the unified electric power system of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Modernization and construction of electricity grids will be carried out in order to complete the formation of the country's Unified Power System (UPS), increase the country's energy security and enhance the transit potential of the Unified Power System of the Republic of Kazakhstan by strengthening the electricity connections between the Southern and Western zones, including the implementation of the following projects:
Integration of the Western Kazakhstan power system with the Unified Power System of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
Modernization and expansion of the regional electricity grid;
Major repairs, modernization and reconstruction of electricity grids of electricity transmission organizations.
4. Development of master plans for the development of district heating in the regions
A methodology for developing master plans for district heating development will be approved. These plans will contain a set of measures for the development of district heating, including heat supply schemes and heat sources in the relevant territory, in order to ensure prospective demand for heat supply services, taking into account the specific characteristics of the relevant territory.
Master plans for district heating development will provide for:
Actual condition and performance indicators;
Development of heat supply schemes and heat sources;
A set of measures to achieve strategic objectives and establish an optimal combination of different heat supply systems (current and prospective demand);
Planned values of key performance indicators;
Optimal solutions taking into account the requirements for ensuring the reliability and safety of heat supply, minimizing harmful environmental impacts, developing energy- and resource-saving technologies, expanding the use of renewable energy sources, securing financing and other factors;
Determination of methods for achieving the objectives (including through tariff regulation and financial support), and identification of mandatory zones for the use of centralized heat supply.
5. Introduction of the “Intelligent Power System”
As part of the digital transformation, Kazakhstan's intelligent power system will be introduced. This will ensure the organization of primary data collection at the equipment and consumer levels, infrastructure for the transmission, storage, protection and processing of information, the development and implementation of solutions for decentralized control of regional power system operating modes (including regulation of capacity, voltage and frequency, as well as maintenance of the required level of reliability), timely provision of the information required by participants to stimulate their activity, assessment of power system capabilities and operational decision-making based on synchrophasor measurements, reduction of technical barriers to the integration of distributed generation, including renewable energy sources, development and implementation of intelligent analysis and decision-support systems (including tools for forecasting, preventing, localizing and eliminating abnormal situations), and introduction of FACTS devices with their involvement in regulation.
Digitalization on the end-consumer side is particularly important. From passive and largely uninformed users, consumers will become active and informed participants in the electricity supply system, increasing their own energy awareness and gaining the opportunity to act as “local sources of energy and demand management”.
Area 2. Development of Clean Energy
6. Construction of new renewable energy generation capacities
This task will be implemented through the approaches of the “Renewable Energy Zones” concept, which provides for the identification of the most promising sites with significant resource potential (wind and solar radiation), preparation of sites by the Government (construction of the necessary infrastructure), establishment of “clear and transparent” rules of engagement for potential investors, and competitive selection through electronic auctions.
In accordance with the instruction of the Head of State to achieve carbon neutrality by 2060, specific target indicators have been established for achieving a 15% share of renewable energy sources by 2030 and 50% by 2050, taking into account alternative energy sources.
In addition, the adoption of the new Environmental Code, which provides for the introduction of new standards and the imposition of penalties on those who fail to comply with them, will require a number of costly environmental measures, which will increase the cost of electricity generated by conventional power plants. As a result, the competitiveness of green energy will increase.
7. Implementation of ESG principles
Relevant legislative acts or separate strategic documents will be developed to address issues related to energy transformation, low-carbon development and climate change.
The main areas for implementing ESG principles will be identified. These principles constitute a system for sustainable investment under which investors assess not only the financial and operational performance of a business but also its social, environmental and governance risks. The transition to ESG principles should encourage the country's energy companies to restructure their management systems with regard to environmental issues and pay close attention to improving the quality of services provided.
Thus, taking into account an analysis of international experience, requirements for energy-producing organizations based on ESG principles will be identified and regulated at the legislative level, with their entry into force in 2026. Energy-producing organizations will be required to develop measures to assess and reduce their negative environmental impact and submit reports on their implementation. Based on the data obtained, conditions will be created to ensure priority access to state support measures for energy-producing organizations that comply with ESG requirements.
The development of long-term corporate strategies and policies for compliance with ESG principles, as well as the determination of an appropriate rating, will enable investors (including foreign investors) to assess the activities of energy companies in terms of environmental and social indicators and cash flows.
The following planned indicators characterizing compliance with ESG principles will be established:
Levels of environmental impact reduction;
Indicators of the quality of services provided;
Reduction of workplace injuries at the country's energy enterprises;
Growth in wages and social benefits;
Transparency and accessibility of companies' economic and financial indicators, including information on the use of attracted investments.
Area 3. Market Development of the Electric Power Industry
8. Implementation of the “Tariff in Exchange for Investment” programme
The programme will provide for a long-term tariff policy with indexation in line with inflation amid projected cost growth, an increase in maximum capacity tariffs, and an increase in the limits under investment agreements with a payback period of 10 years or more.
At the same time, the role of owners of energy-producing organizations will be strengthened through the identification of priority projects based on technical audits of power plants, investment of their own funds in investment projects, fulfilment of target indicators and measures (reducing the wear and tear of main generating equipment, reducing specific fuel consumption, improving environmental performance), increasing the transparency of the use of funds (open procurement by entities and public hearings), and assuming responsibility for the quality of repair work performed.
In the transmission sector, the programme provides for the introduction of technical audits of operating assets, individual assessment of the economic and technical condition of monopolies, optimization of the activities of small monopoly companies by merging them into a single regional company, transfer of monopoly companies to specialized management companies under long-term trust management agreements, introduction of the “Technical Regulation of SEM” mechanism, and elimination of intermediary electricity transmission monopoly companies.
The transformation of the market model will be accompanied by an improvement in the investment climate through the effective and economically justified attraction of investment in the electric power industry, including through the establishment of a clear and predictable tariff policy, indexation of tariffs in line with annual inflation by eliminating cross-subsidization of heat and electricity tariffs (which will improve the competitiveness of combined heat and power plants in the electricity market), development of targeted assistance measures, and attraction of credit funds on preferential terms for the purchase of major generating and grid assets.
State policy on tariff regulation will focus on determining tariff levels for a period of up to ten years, with provision for their indexation in line with inflation. Under current conditions, indexing tariffs in line with inflation is insufficient, as tariffs have been artificially restrained for many years, resulting in worn-out networks and an outflow of qualified personnel due to low wages.
It will be possible to increase energy workers' wages to the regional level. Reducing staff turnover and increasing energy workers' wages are possible only if equal wage conditions are established within a region. The current approach of restraining heat energy tariffs and differentiating tariffs by consumer groups, including through an increase in electricity tariffs, will become a thing of the past. The owner will invest part of the funds on a repayable basis using its own or borrowed funds, while the tariff will be determined based on the principle of cost recovery for the measures implemented and repayment of the owners' funds.
Furthermore, to protect certain categories of consumers from the impact of tariff increases, conditions for targeted subsidies will be created, taking into account current experience. At the same time, energy conservation and the active implementation of energy efficiency principles among the country's economy and population will be encouraged, making it possible to achieve a reduction of approximately 10–20% in energy consumption.
Taking into account the social aspect of the heat energy sector, a hybrid model will be introduced to stimulate investment and ensure guarantees of investment returns, incorporating existing mechanisms for financing the heat energy sector.
Changes to tariff regulation will make it possible to fulfil environmental commitments. The achievement of sector decarbonization objectives will be implemented through a revision of the mechanism for supporting energy companies, which will encourage the introduction of best available technologies (which will increase costs).
9. Examination of the issue of preferential lending at an interest rate of no more than 7% per annum for projects involving the development of energy and energy infrastructure
The issue of financing energy and energy infrastructure development projects through JSC Development Bank of Kazakhstan at an interest rate of no more than 7% per annum for final borrowers, for a term of no more than 20 years, with the enterprise's own contribution amounting to at least 20% of the project cost, will be examined.
The sources of financing will be budget funds and market funding in a ratio of 85/15. Budget funds will be allocated in the form of a budget loan and an increase in the authorized capital of JSC Development Bank of Kazakhstan to ensure compliance with the covenants established by the Law “On the Development Bank of Kazakhstan”.
To obtain financing, an entity in the energy sector will submit a package of documents to JSC Development Bank of Kazakhstan, the list of which is approved by the internal regulations of JSC Development Bank of Kazakhstan. The procedure and deadlines for providing financing will be determined by the internal regulations of JSC Development Bank of Kazakhstan.
10. Transition to centralized purchase and sale of electricity
In the electricity generation sector, the principles of full competition will be ensured, based on the abandonment of bilateral agreements and the transition to centralized purchase and sale of electricity, with the exception of bilateral agreements between energy-producing organizations and consumers belonging to the same Group of Persons.
At the same time, the possibility of retaining direct contracts with reciprocal technical and financial obligations for certain market entities will be considered, provided that such contracts do not result in an increase in the weighted average price of electricity sold to wholesale consumers by the single purchaser.
The transition to centralized purchase and sale of electricity will ensure:
Creation of a favourable investment environment for the timely modernization of existing generating capacities and construction of new ones, taking into account improvements in the sector's efficiency and the transition to modern environmental standards;
Optimization of the composition of generating capacities, including from the perspective of energy independence, as well as the development of renewable energy sources and their integration into the power system;
Elimination of the possibility of market power being exercised by individual market participants;
A single weighted average electricity price for all wholesale consumers for a specific hour of the day and, accordingly, equal market conditions for them;
Maintaining the competitiveness of industrial enterprises' products in foreign markets;
Development of market mechanisms, stimulation of consumers to participate actively (demand management), full transparency and strengthening of the role of consumers in the market.
11. Reform and launch of the real-time balancing electricity market
In order to ensure the stable operation of the electric power system in the short term, a real-time balancing electricity market (with financial settlements) will be introduced, and the market for system services will be improved. This step will require relevant amendments to legislation, adoption of new rules, configuration of the necessary software, designation of a settlement centre for the balancing market, and identification of balance providers. At the same time, it will be necessary to transition to the purchase and sale and payment of planned electricity volumes included in the daily schedule, with all deviations from that schedule being settled through the balancing electricity market.
12. Creation of conditions for strengthening Kazakhstan's position in global energy markets, including the development of export potential
The advantages of parallel operation will be used through the further development of regional electricity grids and integration of the markets of Central and South Asian countries. The increase in energy capacities and efficient domestic consumption of energy resources will enable domestic energy enterprises to enter the energy markets of neighbouring countries. The main emphasis will be placed within the framework of the planned Common Electric Power Market of the EAEU and the regional electricity market of Central Asian countries, with prospective supply destinations in Europe and Southeast Asia.
13. Development of a plan to meet the electric power industry's demand for professional personnel
A plan to meet the electric power industry's demand for professional personnel will be developed, within which an effective system for monitoring and analysing staffing needs in the medium and long term will be established. The implementation of professional standards will be completed, and cooperation between energy enterprises and foreign higher education institutions and partners will be expanded.
14. Improvement and transformation of the Market Council as a body ensuring the institutional foundations of the electric power industry
In order to improve efficiency, a new model of the Market Council will be introduced based on an analysis of the local context and best international practices. Establishing the Market Council's specific functions in national legislation, forming a strong management structure and a culture of compliance with rules and procedures, strengthening the decision-making powers of the organization's members, and introducing a dispute resolution (mediation) procedure for market participants will contribute to the effective performance of the Market Council's duties.
15. Expansion of the functions of the Sectoral Centre for Technological Competencies under JSC KOREM in terms of research activities
The functions and powers of the Sectoral Centre for Technological Competencies will be expanded to conduct developments and research into the problems of the electric power industry's development, ensuring reliability, efficiency, affordability, safety and environmental sustainability, taking into account the country's climate commitments.
At the same time, the activities of the Sectoral Centre for Technological Competencies will be financed from extra-budgetary funds.
Section 6. Target Indicators and Expected Results
Target Indicator 1.
Volume of newly commissioned electricity generation capacity, cumulative – 11.7 gigawatts by 2029.
Expected results:
- 100% coverage of the electricity needs of the economy and population;
- 100% coverage of the heat energy needs of the economy and population;
- Operation of the integrated power system of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- 100% provision of modern systems for metering, collecting and processing data on electricity production and consumption.
Target Indicator 2.
Share of electricity from renewable energy sources – 12.5% of total production by 2029.
Expected result:
An increase in electricity generation from renewable energy sources by 2.8 times compared with 2022.
Target Indicator 3.
Total volume of potential investment returns in the generation sector – up to KZT 2.8 trillion by 2029.
Expected result:
A 10% reduction in the depreciation of the main assets of the existing generating capacity infrastructure compared with 2022.
| Appendix to the Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029 |
|---|
Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept for the Development of the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2023–2029
Download
| No. | Name of reforms / main activities | Form of completion | Completion deadline | Responsible executors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1
2
3
4
5
| Area 1: Technological re-equipment. Target indicator. Volume of newly commissioned electricity generation capacity, cumulative – 11.7 gigawatts by 2029: 2023 – 0.5 gigawatts; 2024 – 1.6 gigawatts; 2025 – 3.5 gigawatts; 2026 – 4.8 gigawatts; 2027 – 6.8 gigawatts; 2028 – 9.3 gigawatts. | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Development of a long-term scheme for the location of electric power capacities | Electric power capacity location scheme | July 2023 | ME, MEPR, energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed), JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 2 | Modernization of existing and construction of new generating capacities, including: | Commissioning certificates | December 2029 | ME, energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| 2.1 | Consideration of the issue of the prospective use of small modular reactors | Proposal to the Government | December 2026 | ME, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed) |
| 2.2 | Volume of newly commissioned electricity generation capacity from combined-cycle gas turbine (CCGT) plants (Almaty, Turkestan and Kyzylorda Regions) | Commissioning certificates | December 2026 | ME, energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| 2.3 | Volume of newly commissioned electricity generation capacity through the implementation of 12 investment agreements with energy-producing organizations | Commissioning certificates | December 2027 | ME, energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| 3 | Strengthening of the Southern and Western zones, integration of the Western zone with the Unified Power System of the Republic of Kazakhstan, including: | Commissioning certificates | December 2028 | ME, JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 3.1 | Construction of the second 220 kV transmission circuit between West Kazakhstan, Atyrau and Mangystau Regions | Commissioning certificates | December 2023 | ME, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed), JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 3.2 | Reconstruction of cable networks in Almaty | Commissioning certificates | December 2025 | ME, MNE, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed) |
| 3.3 | Strengthening of the electricity grid of the Southern zone of the Unified Power System of Kazakhstan. Construction of 500–220 kV power grid facilities in Zhambyl, Kyzylorda, Turkestan, Zhetysu and Almaty Regions (implementation period 2023–2027) | Commissioning certificates | December 2027 | ME, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed), JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 3.4 | Integration of the Western Kazakhstan power system with the Unified Power System of Kazakhstan. Construction of power grid facilities (implementation period 2023–2028) | Commissioning certificates | December 2028 | ME, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed), JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 4 | Development of a methodology for master plans for district heating development in the regions | Methodology | December 2024 | ME |
| 5 | Creation of the “Intelligent Power System” | Commissioning certificates | 2023–2029 | ME, JSC KEGOC (as agreed), JSC KOREM (as agreed), energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| Area 2: Development of alternative energy. Target indicator. Share of electricity from renewable energy sources – 12.5% of total production by 2029: 2023 – 5%; 2024 – 5.5%; 2025 – 6%; 2026 – 7%; 2027 – 8%; 2028 – 10%. | ||||
| 6 | Construction of new renewable energy generation capacities, including: Volume of newly commissioned renewable energy generation capacities | Commissioning certificates | December 2025 / December 2029 | ME, energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| 7 | Development of a roadmap for the implementation of ESG principles | Roadmap | December 2026 | ME, MEPR, MNE, JSC Sovereign Wealth Fund Samruk-Kazyna (as agreed), Astana International Financial Centre (as agreed) |
| Area 3: Market development of the electric power industry. Target indicator. Total volume of potential investment returns in the generation sector – up to KZT 2.8 trillion by 2029: 2023 – up to KZT 400 billion; 2024 – up to KZT 400 billion; 2025 – up to KZT 400 billion; 2026 – up to KZT 400 billion; 2027 – up to KZT 400 billion; 2028 – up to KZT 400 billion. | ||||
| 8 | Implementation of the “Tariff in Exchange for Investment” principle | Roadmap | March 2023 | MNE, ME, AZRK, MEPR, National Chamber of Entrepreneurs Atameken (as agreed) |
| 9 | Examination of the issue of preferential lending at an interest rate of no more than 7% per annum for projects involving the development of energy and energy infrastructure | Proposal to the Government | December 2023 | MNE, MF, ME, National Chamber of Entrepreneurs Atameken (as agreed) |
| 10 | Introduction of the centralized electricity purchase and sale mechanism | Adoption of legislative amendments | July 2023 | ME, MNE, JSC KEGOC (as agreed), LLP Financial Settlement Centre for Renewable Energy Support (as agreed) |
| 11 | Launch of the real-time balancing electricity market | Adoption of legislative amendments | July 2023 | ME, MNE, AZRK, JSC KEGOC (as agreed) |
| 12 | Introduction of the Common Electric Power Market of the EAEU | EAEU rules | December 2025 | ME, MNE, AZRK, JSC KEGOC (as agreed), JSC KOREM (as agreed) |
| 13 | Development of a plan to meet the electric power industry's demand for professional personnel | Plan | December 2024 | ME, associations of legal entities (as agreed), energy enterprises of the Republic of Kazakhstan (as agreed) |
| 14 | Reform of the Market Council | Draft Law | December 2023 | ME, MNE, AZRK, Market Council (as agreed) |
| 15 | Expansion of the scope of activities of JSC KOREM in terms of research work | Amendments to the Company's Charter | December 2024 | ME, MF, JSC KOREM (as agreed), Market Council (as agreed) |
List of abbreviations:
JSC – Joint-stock company;
AZRK – Agency for Protection and Development of Competition of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
LLP – Limited Liability Partnership;
“Financial Settlement Centre for RES” – “Financial Settlement Centre for the Support of Renewable Energy Sources”;
ALE – Association of Legal Entities;
MIID – Ministry of Industry and Infrastructure Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
MF – Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
SWF – Sovereign Wealth Fund;
NCE – National Chamber of Entrepreneurs;
MNE – Ministry of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
AIFC – Astana International Financial Centre;
ME – Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
MEPR – Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
“KOREM” – “Kazakhstan Electricity and Power Market Operator”;
“KEGOC” – “Kazakhstan Electricity Grid Operating Company”.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Programme Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Addresses