Infliction of Physical or Mental Suffering Through Violent Acts Committed with Humiliation
1. General Characteristics of the Elements of the Offence
Part 1 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan provides for criminal liability for:
the infliction of physical or mental suffering through violent acts committed with particular cruelty or humiliation, with the purpose of causing torment to the victim, provided that such acts do not result in the infliction of grievous or moderately serious bodily harm.
The sanction under Part 1 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan provides for corrective labour in an amount of up to 1,000 monthly calculation indices (MCI), community service for up to 600 hours, or imprisonment for up to three years. (Law and Legal Practice)
Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
It is fundamentally important to take into account that the current version of Article 110 differs from its previous version. Following the amendments introduced in 2024, the legislator abandoned the former wording based on the “systematic infliction of beatings” and established a legal construction involving intentional violent acts committed with particular cruelty or humiliation for the purpose of causing torment. In 2024, the Supreme Court specifically supplemented the relevant regulatory resolution with an explanation concerning the mandatory elements of torture.
(Әділет)
Therefore, for an act to be classified under the current Part 1 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, establishing only the fact of a beating or physical pain is insufficient. The following combination of mandatory elements must be established:
- intentional violent acts;
- particular cruelty and/or humiliation as characteristics of the method employed;
- the infliction of physical and/or mental suffering;
- a specific purpose — to cause torment to the victim;
- the absence of grievous or moderately serious bodily harm as a consequence covered by Part 1 of Article 110.
The Supreme Court expressly identifies this combination as the mandatory elements of the offence under Article 110 of the Criminal Code. (Әділет)
2. What Should Be Understood by “Humiliation”
The term “humiliation” in Article 110 of the Criminal Code cannot automatically be equated with:
- insults;
- rudeness;
- a single blow;
- an ordinary domestic dispute;
- the infliction of pain without a specific purpose;
- any humiliation of personal dignity.
Humiliation is primarily a method of treatment of the victim, whereby violent acts acquire the character of tormenting, degrading and demonstratively cruel treatment and are used to cause suffering to the victim.
The specific nature of the offence lies in the combination of the objective nature of the acts and the subjective direction of the intent.
For example:
One and the same act — a blow — may constitute entirely different offences depending on the circumstances:
- the ordinary infliction of physical pain;
- the infliction of minor bodily harm;
- torture;
- the infliction of bodily harm with an aggravating qualifying element;
- hooliganism;
- violence against a minor;
- torture where a special offender and a specific purpose are present.
Consequently, for the purposes of Article 110, it is important not only what the perpetrator did, but also how, why, against whom and under what circumstances the act was committed.
3. Supreme Court Clarification of the Elements of Torture
Of key importance is Paragraph 31-2 of Regulatory Resolution No. 1 of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 11 May 2007, “On the Qualification of Certain Criminal Offences Against Human Life and Health”.
In 2024, this paragraph was supplemented with a specific clarification concerning Article 110.
The Supreme Court indicated that the mandatory elements of torture are:
- intentional violent acts;
- particular cruelty;
- humiliation;
- the infliction of physical and mental suffering upon the victim;
- the purpose of causing torment to the victim.
At the same time, torture may take the form of prolonged and/or repeated acts, including:
- beatings;
- the infliction of minor bodily harm;
- striking with a whip, rods, and similar objects;
- pricking;
- biting;
- pulling out hair;
- setting a dog on the victim;
- deprivation of food;
- deprivation of water;
- deprivation of warmth;
- other violent acts. (Әділет)
This clarification is of enormous practical importance.
It demonstrates that the existence of bodily injuries alone is not required for torture. Violent acts may cause physical suffering, mental suffering, or both types of suffering simultaneously.
4. The Object of the Offence
The principal direct object of Article 110 of the Criminal Code is the social relations ensuring:
- the physical inviolability of a person;
- health;
- mental inviolability;
- personal dignity;
- the prohibition of treatment that causes torment and suffering.
Constitutional protection is determined primarily by Article 17 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, according to which human dignity is inviolable and no one shall be subjected to torture, violence, or other cruel or degrading treatment or punishment.
Thus, Article 110 lies at the intersection of the protection of:
life and health + dignity + the physical and mental inviolability of the individual.
5. The Objective Element
The objective element consists of:
violent acts → causing physical or mental suffering → committed with particular cruelty/humiliation → aimed at causing torment.
For the purposes of qualification, it is necessary to prove a causal relationship between the perpetrator's actions and the suffering of the victim.
For example:
A. systematically struck the victim, forced the victim to remain in a painful position for an extended period, deprived the victim of food and water, humiliated the victim, and continued the violence despite requests to stop.
In this case, the subject matter of proof must include not merely the fact of the blows, but also the nature of the violence, its duration, intensity, sequence of actions, the victim's condition, the circumstances and the perpetrator's purpose.
6. Can a Single Incident Constitute Torture?
Yes, the mere absence of repetition does not exclude the application of Article 110.
This is fundamentally important following the legislative amendments.
The former construction of Article 110 was associated with the systematic infliction of beatings. The current version of the provision does not directly establish such a mandatory element.
The Supreme Court states that torture may take the form of prolonged and/or repeated acts, but this does not mean that the legislator has established a formal criterion of “at least two or three incidents”. (Zan)
Consequently, the decisive factor is not the mathematical number of blows, but the presence of the entire combination of mandatory elements of the offence.
However, where repetition is absent, it is particularly important for the prosecution to prove:
- the exceptionally tormenting nature of the method employed;
- the humiliating character of the acts;
- the specific purpose of causing torment;
- the actual occurrence of physical or mental suffering.
7. Physical Suffering
Physical suffering does not necessarily imply bodily harm of a particular degree.
This is a fundamental distinction between Article 110 and offences in which a specific medical consequence is a mandatory element.
Physical suffering may be expressed in:
- severe pain;
- prolonged pain;
- multiple blows;
- painful restraint;
- twisting of limbs;
- biting;
- burns;
- pricking;
- deprivation of food or water;
- exposure to extreme temperatures;
- other acts causing agonising physical pain.
At the same time, the degree of bodily harm is determined by a forensic medical examination. The Supreme Court expressly states that the degree of harm is established on the basis of an expert opinion in accordance with the rules governing forensic examinations. (Law and Legal Practice)
8. Mental Suffering
Mental suffering may constitute an independent consequence of the offence.
For example:
- prolonged intimidation through physical violence;
- demonstrative humiliation;
- forcing a person to endure violence;
- creating a state of constant fear;
- violence committed in the presence of family members;
- threats accompanied by physical force;
- forced humiliating acts;
- deprivation of sleep combined with violence;
- forcing a person to remain in tormenting conditions.
At the same time, it is necessary to distinguish ordinary emotional distress from mental suffering having criminal-law significance.
Therefore, the following may be relevant in a particular case:
- statements of the victim;
- witness statements;
- correspondence;
- audio and video recordings;
- medical documentation;
- a psychologist's report;
- a forensic psychological examination or a comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric examination, where there are grounds for conducting one.
9. Particular Cruelty
Particular cruelty is a characteristic of the method of committing the offence.
It must be established on the basis of the specific circumstances.
The following may be relevant:
- the duration of the violence;
- its intensity;
- the multiplicity of acts;
- the use of a tormenting method;
- the deliberate infliction of additional suffering;
- the victim's physical helplessness;
- continuation of the violence after pain has clearly been caused;
- the demonstrative nature of the acts;
- the combination of physical violence with humiliation;
- the infliction of suffering through deprivation of basic necessities.
Particular cruelty must not be inferred solely from the existence of bruises or abrasions.
Otherwise, an unacceptable situation would arise in which any instance of inflicting physical pain would automatically be classified as torture.
10. Humiliation as an Independent Aggravating Method
“Humiliation” should be established through a combination of circumstances.
The following questions may be significant for the court:
- Was there intentional humiliation of the victim?
- Was the violence accompanied by mockery?
- Were the acts committed demonstratively?
- Did the perpetrator continue the violence after being asked to stop?
- Were humiliating forms of physical force used?
- Was the specific purpose to cause torment?
- Was it apparent to the victim that the perpetrator was intentionally causing suffering?
- Was there a connection between the nature of the acts and the suffering experienced by the victim?
Thus, “humiliation” is not merely an evaluative word in an indictment.
It must be given specific factual substance.
The wording:
“the accused humiliated the victim”
is insufficient in itself.
It is necessary to specify:
how the humiliation was manifested, what acts were committed, how long they lasted, what consequences they caused, and which evidence confirms each of these facts.
11. The Subjective Element
The subjective element of Article 110 is characterised by intent.
The purpose is of particular importance:
to cause torment to the victim.
It is precisely this element that makes it possible to distinguish torture from an ordinary fight or conflict.
For example:
Situation 1
Two people had an argument, and one of them struck the other.
In the absence of other circumstances, Article 110 should not be applied automatically.
Situation 2
A person deliberately strikes the victim numerous times, takes breaks, observes the victim's suffering, continues the acts despite requests to stop, and accompanies the violence with humiliation.
In this case, the circumstances may indicate the specific purpose of causing torment.
12. Subject Matter of Proof
In a case, it is necessary to establish not only:
“Did violence occur?”
but also:
- who committed the acts;
- what specific acts were committed;
- when;
- where;
- against whom;
- by what method;
- how long they lasted;
- whether there were repeated incidents;
- whether humiliation took place;
- whether particular cruelty was present;
- whether physical suffering was caused;
- whether mental suffering was caused;
- whether there was a purpose to cause torment;
- what bodily harm was inflicted;
- whether moderately serious or grievous harm is absent;
- whether there are aggravating circumstances provided for in Part 2;
- whether a causal relationship exists;
- the form of guilt;
- the motive;
- circumstances affecting the sentence.
13. Distinction Between Article 110 and Article 109-1 of the Criminal Code
Article 109-1 of the Criminal Code provides for liability for beatings or other violent acts that cause physical pain but do not result in minor bodily harm.
Part 1 of Article 110 differs in that it requires a significantly more complex combination of elements:
violence + suffering + particular cruelty/humiliation + purpose of causing torment.
Therefore, not every instance of inflicting physical pain constitutes torture.
On the contrary, if beatings acquire the character of torture and the mandatory elements of Article 110 are present, the acts must be classified under Article 110.
The Supreme Court expressly clarifies that beatings and the infliction of minor bodily harm covered by the offence of torture do not require additional qualification under Articles 108-1 or 109-1. (Әділет)
14. Distinction from Article 108-1 of the Criminal Code
Article 108-1 establishes liability for the intentional infliction of minor bodily harm.
The key distinction is:
Article 108-1
The main element is the medical consequence.
Article 110
The main element is the nature of the violent impact and the purpose of causing torment.
Therefore, the existence of minor bodily harm does not in itself exclude the application of Article 110.
If minor bodily harm is inflicted in the course of torture, it may be covered by Article 110.
15. Moderately Serious or Grievous Bodily Harm: The Critical Boundary
Part 1 of Article 110 expressly provides:
provided that such acts do not result in the infliction of grievous or moderately serious bodily harm.
Consequently, if it is established that moderately serious or grievous bodily harm has resulted, it is necessary to examine the possibility of qualification under the relevant article of the Criminal Code rather than mechanically retaining Part 1 of Article 110.
The Supreme Court clarifies issues concerning the determination of the degree of bodily harm through forensic medical examination. (Law and Legal Practice)
16. Distinction from Article 146 of the Criminal Code — Torture
This is one of the most important distinctions.
Article 146 of the Criminal Code provides for liability for cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment and torture.
In cases of torture, the following are relevant:
- a special offender;
- official status or the corresponding position;
- or the instigation, direction or tacit consent of the relevant person;
- a specific purpose of torture.
The purposes of torture include, in particular:
- obtaining information or a confession;
- punishment for an act;
- intimidation;
- coercion;
- discriminatory motivation. (Law and Legal Practice)
The Supreme Court has specifically established that if an act contains all the elements of Article 146 of the Criminal Code, it should not additionally be classified as torture under Article 110. (Law and Legal Practice)
Article 146 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
This is consistent with Article 1 of the United Nations Convention against Torture.
17. International Legal Standards
17.1. United Nations Convention against Torture
The Republic of Kazakhstan acceded to the United Nations Convention against Torture on 29 June 1998.
The following provisions are particularly important:
- Article 1 — definition of torture;
- Article 2 — obligation to prevent torture;
- Article 12 — prompt and impartial investigation;
- Article 13 — right to lodge a complaint;
- Article 14 — right to compensation;
- Article 16 — obligation to prevent other acts of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
United Nations Convention against Torture on ZakonPravo.kz
Article 16 of the Convention is particularly important for Article 110, as it concerns cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment that does not reach the level of torture. (Law and Legal Practice)
18. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
Article 7 of the ICCPR establishes that:
no one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
Kazakhstan is a party to the Covenant.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights on ZakonPravo.kz
This provision should be considered in conjunction with the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Articles 110 and 146 of the Criminal Code.
19. Court Jurisdiction
It is necessary to distinguish between:
investigative jurisdiction and judicial jurisdiction.
Investigative jurisdiction answers the question:
which authority conducts the pre-trial investigation?
Judicial jurisdiction answers the question:
which court hears the criminal case?
Article 187 of the Criminal Procedure Code, in the current system, regulates investigative jurisdiction, while Article 193 and Chapter 40 of the Criminal Procedure Code regulate matters of judicial jurisdiction over criminal cases. Within the structure of the current Criminal Procedure Code, Article 306 concerns criminal cases falling within the jurisdiction of district and equivalent courts. (Әділет)
For the ordinary offence under Part 1 of Article 110, the criminal case falls within the competence of a court of first instance in accordance with the general rules of territorial and subject-matter jurisdiction.
Courts of first instance include district and equivalent courts, including the relevant city and specialised courts within the limits of their competence. (Әділет)
20. Allocation of Jurisdiction Between Authorities
In the strict procedural sense, the term “allocation of jurisdiction between authorities” is primarily characteristic of civil and administrative proceedings.
In relation to a criminal case, it is more appropriate to refer to:
- the competence of the criminal prosecution authority;
- investigative jurisdiction;
- judicial jurisdiction.
Under Part 1 of Article 110, there is no situation in which the victim independently chooses between a civil court and a criminal court for the purpose of bringing a person to criminal liability.
Criminal liability is established exclusively through criminal proceedings.
Correct the Article 110 terminologyResolve the torture terminology consistently
21. Procedure for Commencing Proceedings
Part 1 of Article 110 is expressly included by Article 32 of the CPC in the list of criminal offences subject to private-public prosecution.
This is of fundamental importance.
Article 32 of the CPC expressly classifies Part 1 of Article 110 of the CC as an offence subject to private-public prosecution. Proceedings in such cases are generally initiated only upon a complaint by the victim; however, termination on the grounds of reconciliation is permitted only in the cases provided for by Article 68 of the CC. (Zakon i Pravo)
Article 32 of the CPC of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
22. Exception: The Victim's Helplessness or Dependency
The prosecutor is entitled to initiate or continue proceedings in a case involving private or private-public prosecution without a complaint from the victim if:
- the victim is in a helpless condition;
- the victim is dependent on another person;
- for other reasons, the victim is unable to exercise their rights independently;
- or the interests of society or the State are affected in cases provided for by law.
This is particularly important in cases of torture within a family environment, where the victim:
- is financially dependent on the perpetrator;
- is under the perpetrator's control;
- fears further violence;
- is a minor;
- is psychologically unable to exercise the right to protection independently.
Article 32 of the CPC expressly provides for the relevant mechanism. (Zakon i Pravo)
23. Pre-Trial Procedure
In relation to Article 110, it is incorrect to refer to “pre-trial settlement” in the civil-law sense.
The criminal procedure established by law applies here.
If a case falls under private-public prosecution, the victim's complaint constitutes a procedurally significant ground for initiating proceedings, except for the exceptions provided for by law.
In other words:
A claim against the perpetrator, negotiations, a letter, a demand for an apology, etc., do not constitute a mandatory pre-trial procedure.
The victim files a report concerning the commission of a criminal offence.
24. Reconciliation Procedures
Part 1 of Article 110 relates to criminal offences in respect of which the question of applying Article 68 of the CC may, in principle, arise.
Article 68 provides for exemption from criminal liability in connection with reconciliation, subject to the statutory conditions:
- the relevant category of criminal offence;
- reconciliation with the victim;
- reparation for the harm caused;
- the absence of a statutory prohibition.
Article 68 of the CC of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
However, there is a crucial exception.
Part 4 of Article 68 prohibits the application of reconciliation in respect of a number of criminal offences, including offences involving violence against minors.
Consequently, if Article 110 is applied in respect of a minor and the relevant act falls within the statutory definition of a criminal offence involving violence against minors, the prohibition under Part 4 of Article 68 of the CC must be examined. (Zakon i Pravo)
This is particularly important following the legislative amendments of 2026, since Article 3 of the CC contains a special definition of criminal offences involving violence against minors and expressly includes certain cases under Article 110. (Adilet)
25. Mediation
Mediation is possible within the framework of the institution of reconciliation only if all the requirements of criminal law are satisfied.
The following must not be confused:
mediation as a procedure
and
automatic termination of criminal proceedings.
The mere signing of a mediation agreement does not, in itself, mean that the case will automatically be terminated.
It is necessary to establish:
- voluntariness;
- actual reconciliation;
- reparation for the harm caused;
- the absence of a statutory prohibition;
- the relevant category of criminal offence.
The Supreme Court specifically indicates that the criminal procedure authority must explain to the parties their right to reconciliation but must not compel them to reconcile. (Zakon i Pravo)
26. Parties Involved in the Case
The main participants are:
26.1. The Victim
Article 71 of the CPC defines a victim as a person who has suffered moral, physical or property damage directly as a result of a criminal offence.
The victim has the right to:
- give testimony;
- submit evidence;
- file motions;
- have a representative;
- examine the case materials;
- receive procedural documents;
- file a civil claim;
- demand compensation for harm.
Article 71 of the CPC of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
26.2. The Suspect
Has the rights provided for by the CPC, including the right to defence.
26.3. The Accused
Upon acquiring the relevant procedural status, obtains the full set of rights of the defence party.
26.4. Defence Counsel
A lawyer or another person in cases provided for by the CPC.
26.5. The Prosecutor
Exercises supervision and maintains the public prosecution.
26.6. Investigator/Inquiry Officer
Conducts the pre-trial investigation within the scope of their competence.
26.7. The Victim's Representative
Is particularly important in cases where the victim:
- is a minor;
- has limited ability to exercise their rights;
- is dependent on the accused.
26.8. Civil Claimant
Acquires this status upon filing a civil claim.
27. Civil Claim in Criminal Proceedings
The victim has the right to claim:
- property damage;
- medical treatment expenses;
- expenses incurred for the recovery of health;
- legal representation expenses;
- compensation for moral harm;
- other losses provided for by law.
Article 71 of the CPC is of particular importance: a claim for moral harm may be considered directly within criminal proceedings. If such a claim was not filed or was left without consideration, the victim has the right to apply through civil proceedings. (Zakon i Pravo)
When a civil claim is filed in criminal proceedings, the claimant is exempt from paying the State duty. The jurisdiction of such a claim is determined by the jurisdiction of the criminal case. (Adilet)
28. State Duty
In Criminal Proceedings
No State duty is payable when the victim files a report concerning the commission of a criminal offence.
For a Civil Claim in Criminal Proceedings
The claimant is exempt from paying the State duty.
This is fundamentally important for a victim who simultaneously claims:
- material damage;
- moral harm;
- medical treatment expenses;
- legal representation expenses.
If a Civil Claim Is Filed Separately
In that case, the provisions of the current Tax Code governing State duty apply.
As of 1 January 2026, the new Tax Code is in force — the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 18 July 2025 No. 214-VIII.
Article 665 establishes the rates of State duty payable in courts. Percentage-based rates are предусмотрены for property claims, while a rate of 0.5 MCI applies to non-property claims; a special rate is предусмотрена for certain claims for compensation for moral harm. (Zakon i Pravo)
Therefore, when filing a separate civil claim, the legal nature of each claim must be determined individually.
29. Moral Harm
Regulatory Resolution No. 7 of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27 November 2015 defines moral harm as mental or physical suffering.
Physical suffering includes physical pain experienced as a result of violence or bodily injury.
Mental suffering may include:
- humiliation;
- fear;
- depression;
- despair;
- shame;
- a sense of inferiority;
- other emotional distress. (Zakon i Pravo)
This is of direct relevance to a case involving torture, since the nature of Article 110 presupposes the existence of physical and/or mental suffering.
30. Time Limit for Filing a Report of a Criminal Offence
Here, it is essential to distinguish between three different time limits:
1. Time limit for filing a report of a criminal offence
This is a procedural issue.
2. Limitation period for criminal liability
Governed by Article 71 of the CC.
3. Limitation period for a civil claim
Governed by the CC.
These must not be confused.
31. Limitation Period under Part 1 of Article 110
Part 1 of Article 110 provides for a maximum penalty of up to three years of imprisonment.
Under Article 11 of the CC, an intentional criminal offence punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment not exceeding five years is classified as a medium-gravity offence. (Zakon i Pravo)
Consequently, Part 1 of Article 110 of the CC falls within the category of medium-gravity offences.
Under Article 71 of the CC, the limitation period for a medium-gravity offence is five years.
The period is calculated from the date of commission of the criminal offence until the court judgment enters into legal force. (Zakon i Pravo)
Article 71 of the CC of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
32. Suspension of the Limitation Period
If a person evades the investigation or the court, the running of the limitation period is suspended.
After the person's arrest or appearance, the period resumes.
Therefore, in each case, it is necessary to establish:
- the date of commission of the offence;
- the date of registration;
- the dates of procedural decisions;
- whether the person was wanted;
- whether evasion took place;
- the date of arrest;
- the date the case was referred to court;
- the date the judgment entered into legal force.
33. “Restoration of the Time Limit” in Criminal Proceedings
Terminology is of particular importance here.
The limitation period for criminal liability is not a civil limitation period.
Therefore, Article 185 of the CC of the Republic of Kazakhstan concerning the restoration of the civil limitation period cannot be applied to the five-year period under Article 71 of the CC.
Article 185 of the CC applies specifically to civil limitation periods and permits restoration of an expired period in exceptional circumstances relating to the claimant's person, such as serious illness, a helpless condition or illiteracy. (Zakon i Pravo)
34. Limitation Period for a Civil Claim
The general limitation period under the CC is three years. (Zakon i Pravo)
However, claims for the protection of personal non-property rights and intangible benefits are subject to a special regime.
Subparagraph 1 of Article 187 of the CC provides that the limitation period does not apply to claims for the protection of intangible benefits and personal non-property rights, except in cases established by legislative acts.
This position is also reflected in judicial practice and regulatory resolutions of the Supreme Court. (ZakonPravo Pochta)
Therefore, in a claim for compensation for moral harm resulting from an infringement of health and dignity, it is necessary to determine separately:
- whether the claim constitutes a claim for the protection of a personal non-property right;
- whether any specific exception applies;
- whether a property claim has been filed;
- whether there are expenses or losses to which the general limitation period applies.
35. Restoration of the Civil Limitation Period
Article 185 of the CC applies exclusively within the scope prescribed by law.
The court may restore an expired period in the presence of exceptional circumstances relating to the claimant's person, such as:
- serious illness;
- a helpless condition;
- illiteracy;
- other circumstances of a similar nature.
Furthermore, Article 185 establishes an additional restriction: the valid reasons must have existed during the last six months of the limitation period or, where the limitation period is six months or less, throughout the entire period. (Zakon i Pravo)
In practical terms, for a victim of torture, the following evidence may be particularly important:
- prolonged medical treatment;
- hospitalisation;
- psychological trauma;
- inability to freely apply to court;
- dependency on the perpetrator;
- threats;
- being in a helpless condition.
However, these circumstances cannot automatically be extended to the limitation period for criminal prosecution under Article 71 of the CC.
36. Evidence
The general system of evidence is governed by the CPC.
The key categories of evidence include:
36.1. Victim's Testimony
Usually constitutes one of the central items of evidence.
However, testimony must be analysed together with other evidence.
36.2. Witness Testimony
Witnesses who are particularly valuable include those who:
- directly observed the events;
- heard what was happening;
- saw the victim immediately after the incident;
- observed the consequences;
- were told about what had happened by the victim immediately after an incident.
36.3. Medical Documents
- ambulance records;
- medical records;
- discharge summaries;
- photographs of injuries;
- examination results;
- medical certificates;
- expert reports.
36.4. Forensic Medical Examination
Is particularly important for determining:
- the nature of the injuries;
- the mechanism by which they were sustained;
- the degree of harm;
- the time when the injuries were sustained;
- whether the injuries could have occurred under the circumstances described.
The Supreme Court directly links the determination of the severity of harm to a forensic medical examination. (Zakon i Pravo)
36.5. Electronic Evidence
- WhatsApp;
- Telegram;
- SMS messages;
- social media;
- voice messages;
- video recordings;
- CCTV footage;
- photographs;
- geolocation data;
- device data.
37. Particular Importance of Video Recordings
In cases involving torture, a video recording may be of exceptionally great importance.
It may simultaneously confirm:
- the fact of violence;
- its duration;
- its intensity;
- the nature of the perpetrator's conduct;
- the victim's reaction;
- the presence of abuse;
- the perpetrator's words;
- the purpose of the actions;
- the victim's condition.
At the same time, the procedural admissibility of the evidence must be ensured.
It is not sufficient simply to show the court a file on a mobile phone.
It is necessary to establish:
- the source;
- the method of obtaining it;
- its integrity;
- the absence of editing;
- the storage medium;
- the circumstances in which it was discovered;
- its connection with the specific incident.
38. Inadmissible Evidence
The Regulatory Resolution of the Supreme Court on the Assessment of Evidence emphasises that evidence obtained in violation of guaranteed human rights or under circumstances specified in Article 112 of the CPC is inadmissible.
The court must establish a specific violation rather than exclude evidence on formal grounds. (Zakon i Pravo)
This is particularly important in cases involving torture, since Article 110 itself is intended to protect individuals against violence.
If a confession was obtained through violence, threats or cruel treatment, the issue of the admissibility of such evidence must be examined with particular care.
39. Examination of Psychological Suffering
In certain cases, a party may raise the issue of ordering:
- a forensic psychological examination;
- a forensic psychiatric examination;
- a comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric examination.
However, an expert must not substitute the court.
The expert establishes specific factual circumstances requiring specialised knowledge, such as the psychological condition, the presence of certain psychological reactions and causal relationships within the scope of their competence.
The legal conclusion as to:
whether a criminal offence under Article 110 was committed,
is made by the court.
40. Measures of Procedural Compulsion
Article 155 of the CPC provides for other measures of procedural compulsion.
These include:
- an undertaking to appear;
- compulsory appearance;
- temporary removal from office;
- seizure of property;
- a prohibition on approaching.
The following measures may be applied to the victim, witness and other persons:
- an undertaking to appear;
- compulsory appearance;
- monetary penalties. (Zakon i Pravo)
Article 155 of the CPC of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz
41. Prohibition on Approaching
In cases involving torture, a prohibition on approaching is of particular importance.
It may be used for the following purposes:
- preventing repeated violence;
- protecting the victim;
- preventing pressure;
- preventing contact;
- ensuring the safety of witnesses;
- preventing interference with the investigation.
Such a mechanism is particularly important in cases involving:
- domestic violence;
- cohabitation;
- financial dependence;
- shared residence;
- employment-related dependence.
42. Detention
Detention is a measure of procedural coercion.
Article 128 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides for the grounds for detaining a suspect. It is applied, in particular, to prevent a crime and to resolve the issue of imposing pre-trial detention as a preventive measure or, in cases provided for by law, to ensure the conduct of proceedings. (Law and Legal Practice)
The mere severity of an emotionally charged situation does not constitute an independent ground for detention.
The existence of lawful procedural grounds is required.
43. Preventive Measures
Depending on the circumstances, the following preventive measures may be considered:
- a written undertaking not to leave the place of residence and to behave properly;
- personal surety;
- bail;
- house arrest;
- detention in custody.
The choice of a preventive measure depends on procedural risks:
- absconding;
- obstructing the investigation;
- exerting influence on the victim;
- destroying evidence;
- continuing criminal activity.
In a case involving torture, the risk of exerting pressure on the victim may be of practical significance, particularly where dependency exists.
44. Supreme Court Practice: Key Approach
The most important source is Regulatory Resolution No. 1 of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 11 May 2007.
In 2024, the Supreme Court expressly formulated the mandatory elements of Article 110 of the Criminal Code.
This means that judicial practice must not be based on the simplified formula:
“multiple blows = torture”,
but rather on a more complex formula:
intentional violence + particular cruelty/abuse + physical/psychological suffering + the purpose of inflicting torment.
(Adilet)
45. Supreme Court Practice on Distinguishing Torture from Cruel Treatment
The Supreme Court separately emphasized that where the elements of torture under Article 146 of the Criminal Code are established, no additional qualification under Article 110 is required.
This precludes the double qualification of the same conduct solely because of the similarity of the wording “physical or mental suffering”. (Law and Legal Practice)
Accordingly, it is first necessary to establish:
- the subject;
- the status;
- the purpose;
- the circumstances;
- the existence of the elements of Article 146.
Only if the elements of torture are absent, but the elements of cruel treatment are present, should Article 110 be applied.
46. First-Instance Court Practice: The Bishimbayev Case
The widely publicized case of K. Bishimbayev is relevant to understanding how a court examines an accusation under subparagraph 1) of part 2 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code.
According to the published materials, the prosecution described a prolonged period of violence, repeated blows to various parts of the victim's body and head, as well as the victim's moral suffering accompanied by humiliation of her honour and dignity. (Bizmedia.kz)
This is indicative for the analysis of Article 110 for two reasons.
First, the case involved an examination not only of a specific bodily injury, but also of the totality of conduct over time.
Second, the following circumstances were simultaneously of legal significance:
- repetition;
- the nature of the violence;
- physical suffering;
- moral suffering;
- humiliation;
- the relationship between the accused and the victim.
When using materials from this case in a legal document, references should be made specifically to official judicial acts, if they are available to the party, while media publications should be used as secondary sources.
47. First-Instance Court Practice in 2026: Kostanay
In August 2026, reports were published concerning the examination by Court No. 2 of the city of Kostanay of a case under part 2 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code — torture for hire.
According to the published information, the accused agreed, in exchange for remuneration, to establish the whereabouts of the victim and use violence against him; the court sentenced him to four years of imprisonment. (Azattyq-ruhy.kz)
This demonstrates the practical importance of distinguishing between:
part 1 of Article 110
and
the aggravated offences under part 2 of Article 110.
In this case, the legally significant factor was the aggravating element of “for hire”.
48. Appellate Practice
In appeals concerning cases of torture, the key issues are generally:
- whether the fact of violence has been proven;
- whether the legal classification is correct;
- whether the element of abuse is present;
- whether the special purpose is present;
- whether medical evidence has been properly assessed;
- whether the victim's testimony is reliable;
- whether electronic evidence is admissible;
- whether there are contradictions between the evidence;
- whether a causal link exists or is absent;
- whether the sentence has been properly imposed.
Particular importance is attached to verifying whether the court of first instance drew a legal conclusion from the established circumstances, rather than merely listing the evidence.
49. Typical Error by the Prosecution
One potentially vulnerable formulation of an accusation is:
“the accused systematically beat the victim, thereby causing physical pain”.
Such a description may be sufficient for other offences, but Article 110 requires the following to be explained:
- why this constituted abuse;
- why particular cruelty was present;
- what specific suffering was caused;
- how the purpose of inflicting torment was manifested.
If these elements are not disclosed, the defence has grounds to raise the issue of incorrect legal classification.
50. Typical Judicial Error
The following must not be substituted for one another:
proof of physical pain
and proof of:
the purpose of inflicting torment.
For example, a medical report may confirm the presence of bruises and contusions.
However, a medical examination does not, in itself, establish the legal purpose of the perpetrator.
The purpose is established through the totality of the evidence:
- words;
- actions;
- sequence of conduct;
- duration;
- circumstances of the conflict;
- conduct after the infliction of pain;
- the perpetrator's attitude towards the victim's suffering.
51. Defence under Article 110: Main Areas
The defence may analyse the case according to the following blocks.
Block 1. The Event
Did the violence occur at all?
Block 2. Attribution
Was it committed specifically by the accused?
Block 3. Consequences
Was physical or mental suffering caused?
Block 4. Method
Was there particular cruelty or abuse?
Block 5. Purpose
Has the intention to inflict torment been proven?
Block 6. Medical Distinction
Was moderate or serious harm to health caused?
Block 7. Alternative Legal Classification
Does the conduct correspond instead to Article 108-1, 109-1, 107, 106, 115 or another provision?
Block 8. Admissibility
Was the evidence obtained lawfully?
52. Position of the Victim
The victim should record the following in as much detail as possible:
- date;
- time;
- place;
- sequence of actions;
- each individual act of violence;
- the perpetrator's words;
- threats;
- humiliation;
- duration;
- witnesses;
- consequences;
- seeking medical assistance;
- psychological condition;
- photographs;
- videos;
- correspondence;
- telephone calls.
It is particularly important not to limit the description to the statement:
“he abused me”.
It is necessary to describe the facts from which the court can independently draw a legal conclusion.
53. Example of a Factual Description
Instead of:
“The accused abused the victim”.
It is better to establish the following:
“After delivering the first blows, the accused continued the violent acts despite the victim's repeated requests to stop, struck various parts of the victim's body, accompanied his actions with degrading statements, forced the victim to remain in a painful position, and continued the physical impact even after the victim reported experiencing severe pain”.
Such a description enables the court to examine each element of the offence.
54. Subordinate Regulatory Legal Acts
The following play a key role:
- regulatory resolutions of the Supreme Court;
- regulatory orders of the Ministry of Justice;
- rules governing forensic examinations;
- departmental regulatory acts of criminal prosecution authorities;
- regulatory acts in the field of child protection;
- international treaties.
Of particular importance is Order No. 484 of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27 April 2017, which approved the Rules for the Organisation and Conduct of Forensic Examinations and Studies in Forensic Examination Bodies. The Supreme Court expressly refers to these Rules when determining the severity of harm to health. (Law and Legal Practice)
55. Law on Forensic Expert Activities
When conducting an examination, it is necessary to take into account the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Forensic Expert Activities”.
It regulates:
- the organisation of forensic examinations;
- the status of an expert;
- the rights of an expert;
- the duties of an expert;
- requirements for an expert report;
- grounds for conducting an examination;
- the procedure for conducting examinations.
56. Regulatory Resolution on Human Liberty and Dignity
Regulatory Resolution No. 7 of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 28 December 2009 is of particular importance.
It addresses:
- personal liberty;
- inviolability of human dignity;
- torture;
- violence;
- cruel;
- inhuman;
- degrading treatment.
The Resolution expressly requires a legal assessment of every instance of cruel or degrading treatment. (Law and Legal Practice)
57. Judicial Practice Concerning Evidence
Regulatory Resolution No. 4 of the Supreme Court dated 20 April 2006, “On Certain Issues of the Assessment of Evidence in Criminal Cases”, is of universal significance.
The court must:
- examine the evidence;
- compare it;
- establish its reliability;
- verify its admissibility;
- assess the totality of the evidence.
No evidence may have predetermined evidentiary value. (Law and Legal Practice)
This is particularly important for Article 110, since cases are often based on a combination of:
- the victim's testimony;
- medical records;
- witness testimony;
- photographs;
- videos;
- correspondence.
58. Causal Link
It must be proven that the accused's actions specifically caused the established suffering.
For example:
if the victim sought medical assistance several weeks after the conflict, and the medical records also document other illnesses or injuries, the defence has the right to raise the following question:
Are the injuries identified related to the incident under consideration?
On the other hand, the absence of pronounced bodily injuries does not exclude mental suffering.
Therefore, the causal link must be assessed in relation to the specific type of suffering.
59. Assessment of the Victim's Testimony
The victim's testimony constitutes evidence, but it is subject to verification.
The court must analyse:
- consistency;
- internal coherence;
- consistency with medical data;
- correspondence with objective traces;
- the existence of personal interest;
- the possibility of perceiving the events;
- the victim's conduct after the incident.
However, the mere existence of personal relationships between the parties does not automatically mean that the testimony is unreliable.
60. Family and Domestic Context
Torture may be committed by:
- a spouse;
- a former spouse;
- a relative;
- a cohabitant;
- a parent;
- another close person.
The mere fact of family relations does not constitute a separate offence under Article 110, but may be relevant to:
- establishing dependency;
- assessing the duration of violence;
- motive;
- the risk of repeated violence;
- selecting a preventive measure;
- applying special protection mechanisms.
61. Minor Victim
If the victim is a minor, it is additionally necessary to examine:
- age;
- the accused's awareness of the victim's age;
- the child's dependency;
- psychological consequences;
- the need for special conditions for questioning;
- participation of a legal representative;
- the need to prevent repeated trauma.
Current legislation treats certain forms of violence against minors as a special category. Article 3 of the Criminal Code expressly links the relevant concept, in particular, to subparagraph 1) of part 2 of Article 110 where the offence is committed against a minor. (Adilet)
62. Reconciliation Where the Victim Is a Minor
Particular caution must be exercised in this regard.
Part 4 of Article 68 of the Criminal Code establishes a prohibition on reconciliation in respect of offences involving violence against minors, subject to the exception provided by law for an offender who is a minor.
Consequently, a simple statement that:
“the victim has forgiven the accused”
does not mean that the criminal case must necessarily be terminated.
It is first necessary to establish:
- which part of Article 110 applies;
- the age of the victim;
- the age of the perpetrator;
- whether the act falls within the category of offences involving violence against minors;
- whether part 4 of Article 68 of the Criminal Code is applicable.
63. Connection with Hooliganism
If the violence arose as a result of a personal conflict, Article 293 of the Criminal Code should not automatically be applied solely because the actions took place in a public place.
The Supreme Court's regulatory resolution on hooliganism requires a distinction to be made between:
- a personal conflict;
- hooligan motives;
- a gross violation of public order.
If the actions were caused by personal animosity, they are classified under the relevant offences against the person, provided that there is no separate offence of hooliganism. (ZakonPravo Post)
64. Aggregation of Criminal Offences
In a particular situation, an aggregation of criminal offences may arise, for example:
- torture + threat;
- torture + unlawful deprivation of liberty;
- torture + property damage;
- torture + another offence.
However, the issue of aggregation is resolved only after determining whether the additional actions are covered by the disposition of Article 110.
Artificial multiple qualification of the same factual act is inadmissible.
65. Prolonged Conduct
Torture may extend over a period of time.
For example:
- violence lasting several hours;
- repetition of violent acts over several days;
- successive application of various methods of inflicting suffering.
In such cases, it is necessary to determine:
whether this constitutes a single continuing offence or an aggregation of independent offences?
The answer depends on the unity of intent, the nature of the actions and the factual circumstances.
66. Significance of Breaks Between Episodes
A break between episodes does not, in itself, determine the issue of legal classification.
The court must establish:
- whether a single intent was maintained;
- whether the actions were directed towards the same purpose;
- whether the episodes formed part of a single course of conduct;
- whether a new intent arose on each occasion.
Therefore, it is advisable to distinguish the relevant time periods as clearly as possible in the indictment.
67. Procedural Motions of the Victim
The victim has the right to submit motions concerning:
- the appointment of an expert examination;
- the inclusion of documents in the case file;
- the questioning of witnesses;
- the requisition of video recordings;
- the conduct of an investigative experiment;
- the examination of correspondence;
- recognition of a person as a victim;
- ensuring safety;
- the imposition of a prohibition on approaching;
- the seizure of property to secure a civil claim.
Article 99 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides for the right of participants to apply with motions concerning procedural actions and decisions. (Law and Legal Practice)
68. Seizure of Property
If the victim brings a substantial civil claim, the issue of securing its enforcement must be raised in a timely manner.
Among other measures of procedural coercion, Article 155 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides for the seizure of property. (Law and Legal Practice)
Practical purpose:
to prevent the accused from disposing of property before the civil claim has been resolved.
69. Private Judicial Ruling
If the court identifies reasons and conditions that contributed to the commission of a criminal offence, or violations of the law by investigative authorities, the issue of issuing a private judicial ruling may arise.
The Supreme Court has specifically provided explanations regarding the practice of issuing private judicial rulings in criminal cases. (Law and Legal Practice)
This may be relevant in cases involving the identification of:
- inadequate responses to reports of violence;
- unjustified refusal to recognise a person as a victim;
- inadequate investigation;
- violations in dealing with a minor;
- violations of the procedure for conducting a medical examination.
70. Main Regulatory Legal Acts
For a comprehensive analysis of a case under Article 110, the following regulatory framework should be used.
Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan
In particular:
- Article 13 — judicial protection;
- Article 14 — equality;
- Article 17 — human dignity;
- Article 18 — inviolability of private life;
- Article 77 — principles of justice.
Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Key articles:
- Article 1 — criminal legislation;
- Article 3 — concepts;
- Article 11 — categories of crimes;
- Article 14 — recidivism;
- Article 68 — reconciliation;
- Article 71 — limitation periods;
- Article 106 — serious harm;
- Article 107 — moderate harm;
- Article 108-1 — minor harm;
- Article 109-1 — battery;
- Article 110 — torture;
- Article 111 — harm caused in a state of passion;
- Article 115 — threat;
- Article 146 — torture.
Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
In particular:
- Article 32 — types of criminal prosecution;
- Article 71 — victim;
- Article 99 — motions;
- Article 112 — admissibility of evidence;
- Article 113 — circumstances subject to proof;
- Article 128 — detention;
- Article 155 — other measures of procedural coercion;
- Article 187 — investigative jurisdiction;
- Article 188 — place of investigation;
- Article 189 — forms of investigation;
- Article 193 and Chapter 40 — jurisdiction;
- provisions concerning civil claims.
Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on ZakonPravo.kz / Regulatory Framework
Civil Code
- Article 178 — general limitation period for claims;
- Article 179 — application of the limitation period;
- Article 185 — restoration;
- Article 187 — claims to which the limitation period does not apply;
- Article 951 — moral damage;
- Article 952 — compensation for moral damage.
Tax Code of 2025
- Article 665 — state duty rates;
- Article 672 — payment procedure.
Law on Forensic Expert Activities
Order No. 484 of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27 April 2017
Rules for the Organisation and Conduct of Forensic Examinations and Studies.
International Treaties
- Convention against Torture;
- International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights;
- Convention on the Rights of the Child — if the victim is a minor;
- other treaties ratified by the Republic of Kazakhstan.
I can also prepare a consolidated Russian–English legal version with uniform terminology for use in a legal memorandum or court submission.
71. Main Regulatory Resolutions of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan
The following regulatory resolutions are particularly important for Article 110:
No. 1 dated May 11, 2007
“On the Qualification of Certain Criminal Offences Against Human Life and Health”.
This is the principal source for interpreting torture (systematic infliction of physical or mental suffering). (Adilet)
No. 7 dated December 28, 2009
On issues concerning personal liberty, the inviolability of human dignity, and combating torture, violence, and other cruel or degrading treatment or punishment. (Zakon i Pravo)
No. 4 dated April 20, 2006
On the Assessment of Evidence. (Zakon i Pravo)
No. 4 dated April 20, 2018
“On the Judicial Verdict”.
It is relevant to the requirements concerning the content and reasoning of a judgment. (Zakon i Pravo)
No. 7 dated November 27, 2015
On Compensation for Moral Harm. (Zakon i Pravo)
No. 4 dated June 21, 2001
On the Application of Article 68 of the Criminal Code – for issues concerning reconciliation. (Zakon i Pravo)
72. Practical Table for Distinguishing Between Offences
| Situation | Main Qualification Issue |
|---|---|
| A single blow causing physical pain | Article 109-1 may apply |
| Intentional infliction of minor bodily harm | Article 108-1 |
| Agonizing violence involving humiliation and mockery, with the purpose of inflicting suffering | Article 110 |
| Torture of a minor | Article 110, Part 2, Subparagraph 1), where the relevant conditions are met |
| Torture committed for hire | Article 110, Part 2, Subparagraph 5) |
| Torture by an official for a specific purpose | Article 146 |
| Moderate bodily harm | Examination of the relevant provision concerning bodily harm |
| Grievous bodily harm | Examination of Article 106 and other qualifying provisions |
| Violence motivated by hooliganism | Examination of Article 293 and provisions concerning bodily harm |
| Threat to kill following violence | A combination with Article 115 may apply |
73. Main Qualification Formula
For the practical application of Article 110, Part 1, the following formula may be used:
Act =
intentional violent act + exceptional cruelty / humiliation + physical and/or mental suffering + purpose of inflicting suffering + absence of moderate or grievous bodily harm.
If at least one mandatory element is absent, alternative legal qualifications must be examined.
74. Practical Formula for Proving Humiliation
For the prosecution, it is recommended to establish five consecutive evidentiary blocks:
I. Act
What exactly did the accused do?
II. Method
Why does this method constitute humiliation or differ by its exceptional cruelty?
III. Consequence
What specific physical or mental suffering occurred?
IV. Causation
Why is this suffering the result of the accused's actions in particular?
V. Purpose
What circumstances confirm the intention to inflict suffering on the victim?
This makes it possible to transform the evaluative concept of “humiliation” into a provable set of facts.
75. The Most Important Practical Errors
Error 1
Considering any beating to constitute torture.
Error 2
Considering the presence of bruises to be proof of a specific purpose.
Error 3
Failing to examine psychological consequences.
Error 4
Failing to order a forensic medical examination when there are disputed bodily injuries.
Error 5
Failing to establish the degree of bodily harm.
Error 6
Failing to distinguish between Article 110 and Article 146.
Error 7
Automatically applying reconciliation.
Error 8
Confusing the limitation period for criminal prosecution with the civil limitation period.
Error 9
Considering the three-year limitation period under the Civil Code to be the limitation period for bringing a person to criminal liability under Article 110.
Error 10
Limiting the description to the statement “subjected the victim to humiliation” without describing the specific actions.
76. Final Legal Conclusion
Part 1 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan establishes an offence in which the legislator protects a person not only against direct harm to health, but also against a painful method of treatment that causes physical or mental suffering.
Establishing the mere fact of violence is insufficient for qualification under Article 110.
It is necessary to prove the combination of circumstances formulated by the Supreme Court as follows:
intentional violent acts + exceptional cruelty/humiliation + physical and/or mental suffering + purpose of inflicting suffering. (Adilet)
Particular importance must be attached to distinguishing Article 110 from:
- Article 109-1 – battery;
- Article 108-1 – intentional infliction of minor bodily harm;
- Article 107 – moderate bodily harm;
- Article 106 – grievous bodily harm;
- Article 146 – torture;
- Article 293 – hooliganism;
- Article 115 – threats.
Part 1 of Article 110 constitutes a medium-gravity criminal offence, since the maximum penalty is imprisonment for up to three years. Therefore, the general limitation period for bringing a person to criminal liability is five years pursuant to Article 71 of the Criminal Code. (Zakon i Pravo)
From a procedural perspective, Part 1 of Article 110 falls within cases of private-public prosecution. (Zakon i Pravo)
At the same time, a criminal case cannot be treated exclusively as a dispute between two private individuals: the State is obliged to ensure an effective investigation of violence, and in cases where the victim is helpless or dependent, the prosecutor has the powers provided for in Article 32 of the Criminal Procedure Code to initiate or continue proceedings regardless of the ordinary requirement for a complaint by the victim. (Zakon i Pravo)
A civil claim for compensation for harm may be filed directly within the criminal proceedings, and the victim is exempt from payment of the state fee. (Zakon i Pravo)
With regard to international standards, Article 110 must be applied taking into account Article 17 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Article 7 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the United Nations Convention against Torture, including Article 16 thereof, which is aimed at preventing cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment that does not reach the threshold of torture. (Zakon i Pravo)
Key Sources of ZakonPravo.kz
Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan – Torture
Article 71 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan – Victim
United Nations Convention against Torture
Brief Practical Framework for a Lawyer
When preparing a legal position in a specific case under Part 1 of Article 110 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, it is advisable to prepare the following table:
| Element | What Must Be Proved | Main Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Violent act | Specific actions | Victim, witnesses, video recordings |
| Humiliation | Specific method of degrading/painful treatment | Video recordings, correspondence, witnesses |
| Exceptional cruelty | Intensity, duration, method | Medical records, video recordings, expert examination |
| Physical suffering | Pain, torment | Testimony, medical records |
| Mental suffering | Fear, humiliation, psychological consequences | Testimony, specialist, expert examination |
| Purpose | Intention to inflict suffering | Words, conduct, sequence of actions |
| Causation | Connection between the actions and the suffering | Expert examination, medical records |
| Degree of harm | Absence of moderate or grievous bodily harm for Part 1 | Forensic medical examination |
| Offender | Age, criminal responsibility and mental capacity | Documents, expert examination |
| Qualifying circumstances | Minor victim, dependency, group commission, etc. | Documents, testimony |
| Procedural admissibility | Lawfulness of obtaining evidence | Records, rulings |
| Reconciliation | Article 68 and exceptions | Application, agreement, documents concerning harm |
| Civil claim | Material/moral harm | Receipts, medical records, calculations |
Key Practical Principle: In a case under Article 110, the prosecution must prove not merely the fact of causing pain, but a qualitatively different level of violent conduct – the painful and humiliating nature of the treatment and the specific purpose of directing such conduct at inflicting suffering on the victim. This particular element is central to distinguishing torture from battery and ordinary intentional infliction of minor bodily harm.
Attention!
The Law and Pravo Law Office draws your attention to the fact that this document is of a basic nature and does not always meet the requirements of a specific situation. Our lawyers are ready to provide legal advice and assist in preparing any legal document suitable for your particular situation.
For further information, please contact an Attorney / Lawyer by telephone: +7 (708) 971-78-58; +7 (700) 978 5755, +7 (700) 978 5085.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Attorney Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Programme Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Programme Rules Addresses