On the Concept of Development of Tariff Policy in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies
Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 13, 2005 No. 455
In order to further improve tariff policy in the spheres of natural monopolies, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan RESOLVES:
1. To approve the attached Concept of Development of Tariff Policy in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies.
2. To approve the attached Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept of Development of Tariff Policy in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies for 2005–2007 (hereinafter referred to as the Action Plan).
3. The Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation of Natural Monopolies shall submit consolidated information to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the progress of implementation of the Action Plan annually, based on the results of each half-year and year.
4. This Resolution shall enter into force from the date of its signing.
Prime Ministerof the Republic of Kazakhstan
Approvedby Resolution of the Governmentof the Republic of Kazakhstandated May 13, 2005 No. 455
Concept of Development of Tariff Policy in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies
Introduction
In industries classified as spheres of natural monopolies, the most important resources necessary for the production of goods and services in all sectors of the economy and for ensuring the livelihood of the population are produced. Natural monopoly entities largely ensure the livelihood of the country's population by supplying gas, water, electricity and heat energy, and providing transportation services. The share of products of natural monopoly entities in the cost of final products may reach 30–70% (particularly the "transportation" and "energy" components). Thus, the importance of natural monopoly entities and the extent of their impact on society and on the pace and proportions of economic development require the improvement of tariff policy towards the application of pricing systems that ensure the intensive development of natural monopoly entities while observing the interests of consumers of their products.
The dynamics of prices (tariffs) for the services of natural monopoly entities is an important factor in shaping the domestic economic environment and ensuring the competitiveness of domestic products on the world market. Not only the level of income and accumulation within natural monopoly entities themselves, but also that in other industries depends on it, which requires an integrated approach to tariff setting and the development of an optimal policy for regulating the sphere of natural monopolies. Since tariffs in the basic spheres of natural monopolies have a multiplier effect on the price level and inflation, alongside the planning of parameters for social, fiscal and monetary, and economic development, it is necessary to formulate the parameters of tariff and pricing policy with regard to prices regulated by the state in the spheres of natural monopolies.
Approximately 800 natural monopoly entities operate in the spheres of natural monopolies, including 162 natural monopoly entities in the republican section of the State Register of Natural Monopoly Entities.
Creating conditions for the development of all participants in the monopoly market (natural monopoly entities and consumers) is in the interests of the state, while pursuing the achievement of welfare parameters corresponding to the level of a developed economy. Therefore, the market-based economic system is supplemented by instruments of state regulation, the proportions of which depend on the nature of the economic tasks being addressed and the socio-economic condition of society.
With the adoption in 1998 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Natural Monopolies" (and subsequent amendments and additions thereto) and the relevant subordinate regulatory legal acts, the formation of legislation on natural monopolies in the Republic of Kazakhstan was essentially completed. This legislation became one of the effective regulators of economic life and the basis for civilized forms of state regulation in a market economy. During the period from 2002 to 2004, the "Program for Improving the Tariff Policy of Natural Monopoly Entities for 2002–2004", adopted by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated October 15, 2002 No. 1126 (hereinafter referred to as the Program), was successfully implemented. The implementation of the Program made it possible to establish a methodological framework for setting "fair" tariffs across all spheres of natural monopolies.
At the same time, issues concerning the impact of tariffs on individual sectors and the economy as a whole, problems associated with the existing differentiation of tariffs and the resulting cross-subsidization, as well as problems of tariff rebalancing and the introduction of separate accounting for income, expenses and assets employed, remained outside the scope of the Program or were not fully resolved.
This Concept has been developed in order to determine a strategic vision for the organization and methodological support of state policy on regulation in the spheres of natural monopolies, and to formulate and implement a set of measures for developing tariff policy in the spheres of natural monopolies, taking into account the coordinated development of all sectors of the economy. The development of the main areas and mechanisms of regulation is based on an analysis of the results of the Program's implementation and the identification of current problems of state regulation.
1. The Place and Role of Tariff Regulation in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies in the Economic Policy of the State
At the present stage of development of the state regulation system, it is necessary to ensure conditions conducive to the development of market relations and competition in previously monopolized sectors of the economy, to create mechanisms that ensure the restoration of potential and development of infrastructure industries, to promote the expansion and development of the real sector of the economy and increase the competitiveness of domestic products, as well as to ensure social protection of the population.
The economy of any state can be conditionally divided into two sectors depending on the degree of state intervention in economic relations: the unregulated sector and the regulated sector. The need for state influence on economic relations is determined by the degree of development of market relations, institutions and mechanisms of market self-regulation, as well as the requirements of the state's social policy. The less developed the mechanisms of market self-regulation are, the stronger the regulatory role of the state and the higher the state's responsibility towards market participants.
Under monopoly conditions, the degree of influence exerted by a service (goods, works) supplier on market relations requires state intervention in order to ensure a balance between the interests of that supplier and the consumer. Such a balance can be ensured through pricing methodology based on a comprehensive analysis of the interests of both parties: on the one hand, the service (goods, works) supplier must be guaranteed coverage of all economically justified costs and compensation in the form of a rate of return on assets employed; on the other hand, an acceptable price must be established for each category of consumer at a level corresponding to their effective demand.
At the same time, from a macroeconomic perspective, in order to achieve the best parameters of socio-economic development and stimulate economic growth and the investment attractiveness of the real sector and the economy, tariff policy is often used, alongside the state's fiscal and monetary policy, as an instrument for regulating inflation and stabilizing economic relations.
Regulation of the level of tariffs (prices, fee rates) of natural monopoly entities is an important lever for influencing the balanced development of all sectors of the economy. The level of tariffs of natural monopoly entities determines the level of tariffs and profitability in other industries, which requires an integrated approach to tariff setting and the development of an optimal and predictable tariff regulation policy. Parameters for changes in tariffs for products and services classified within the spheres of natural monopolies must be taken into account when developing plans for the socio-economic development of the republic.
Thus, the state seeks to ensure a balance of interests not only between the participants in an individual market (consumers of services and the monopolist), but also between individual sectors of the economy, while the criteria for the optimality of tariff policy (including differentiated tariffs) are aggregate indicators of economic development.
Taking into account the multiplier effect of tariffs charged by basic natural monopoly entities on the level of prices and incomes in economic sectors, tariff policy in recent years has been aimed at protecting the interests of the population and certain industrial sectors through:
- restraining tariffs at a level that does not ensure the replacement and reproduction of assets;
- differentiating tariffs by consumer groups.
The factors underlying tariff differentiation are divided into two groups: production-related factors, which affect the cost of services that differ in the quantity and quality of production factors consumed, and non-production-related factors, which are determined by the social and other principles of the tariff policy being implemented. The level of consumer solvency is classified as a non-production-related factor in tariff differentiation.
The implemented policy made it possible to avoid a rapid, avalanche-like increase in prices, reduce price pressure on industry, and play a positive role in the stable development of the republic's economy. At the same time, physical and moral depreciation of the assets of natural monopoly entities accumulated, and a significant gap emerged between tariff levels for the same services provided to different categories of consumers, requiring their rebalancing to an optimal level. The optimal level of tariff differentiation must be determined according to the criteria of its impact on economic development parameters. The absence of an appropriate methodological framework is currently a problem.
The state has a limited set of mechanisms for ensuring a balance between the interests of producers of goods and services and their consumers:
- the mechanism of state subsidization;
- the mechanism of economically justified tariff differentiation.
Sources of state subsidization may include funds from the republican or local budgets. In this case, the state may subsidize either the natural monopoly entity or consumers of its services. Subsidization may also take various forms, such as targeted subsidies for the purchase of fixed assets, the introduction of information systems, or targeted subsidies for consumers of services. Depending on their duration, subsidies may be permanent or provided for a specified period.
At present, the main mechanism for balancing the income of the monopolist and the costs incurred by consumers is tariff differentiation by consumer groups. This mechanism is обусловлен by the objective conditions of economic development, but it is necessary to distinguish between the degree of impact that different options for tariff differentiation have on the economy. Any differentiation of tariffs for the services of a natural monopoly entity results in a redistribution of benefits among consumers; therefore, economically justified tariff differentiation is understood as such differentiation that is expedient from a macroeconomic perspective.
For the further transition to the establishment of long-term tariffs and the implementation of mechanisms based on taking into account the balance of interests of consumers and producers, it is necessary to develop an appropriate methodological and information framework. The relevance of creating a regularly updated methodological and information framework is primarily associated with the fact that, in order to more accurately determine the balance of interests of the parties and assess the optimality of the tariff differentiation implemented, the regulatory authority must have both information on indicators determining the economic condition of producers and consumers and a methodology for assessing the impact of tariff levels on these indicators. The criterion for the optimality of the tariff differentiation implemented will be the achievement of target economic indicators for the development of the industry and the economy as a whole.
The following tasks are relevant to the development of the state's regulatory functions in order to ensure effective economic development:
1) determining the boundaries of natural monopoly spheres in the relevant markets in each sector of the economy, as well as identifying specific natural monopoly entities and their services classified within the sphere of natural monopolies, based on an economic analysis of the industries;
2) developing regulatory legal acts governing relations between market participants in industries undergoing reform;
3) developing a methodology for determining economically justified tariff differentiation and identifying key economic indicators affecting the levels of economically justified tariff differentiation;
4) developing mechanisms for state subsidization of the services of natural monopoly entities;
5) developing a methodology for calculating tariffs (prices, fee rates) for the services of natural monopoly entities;
6) developing mechanisms to ensure transparency in the activities of natural monopoly entities;
7) developing mechanisms for monitoring and auditing the activities of natural monopoly entities;
8) developing rules governing the application of established tariffs and determining mechanisms for monitoring compliance with them;
9) developing models and methods for determining the mutual influence of economic sectors and developing measures to ensure the effective and balanced development of all sectors.
2. Current State of the Methodology for Tariff Regulation in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies
In order to achieve a balance of interests between the state, natural monopoly entities and consumers of their services, and to create favorable conditions for attracting investment in the natural monopoly sector, a program for improving tariff policy was adopted in 2002.
Within the framework of the Program's implementation, measures were taken to create a unified methodology for regulating the sphere of natural monopolies and to introduce international best practices when improving the regulatory legal framework governing the activities of natural monopoly entities. As a result of applying these measures, it was envisaged that tariff levels for natural monopoly services would remain stable over the medium term in order to attract investment in the renewal of natural monopoly production facilities and improve the quality of services (goods, works) provided by them.
In December 2004, amendments and additions were adopted to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Natural Monopolies", aimed at achieving a balance between the interests of consumers and natural monopoly entities and improving state control and regulatory methods in the spheres of natural monopolies. These amendments and additions included, in particular, the following:
- regulation of the activities of entities within the scope of regulated services, the list of which is approved by the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan upon submission by the authorized body;
- the introduction of the possibility for the authorized body to approve an investment tariff, a tariff ceiling, and a tariff taking into account the quality of services (goods, works) provided;
- specification of the types of other activities permitted for natural monopoly entities;
- specification of provisions on restrictions on activities and the obligations of natural monopoly entities;
- adoption of provisions establishing a simplified procedure for state regulation of certain natural monopoly entities;
- specification of the rights and obligations of the authorized body;
- establishment of restrictions on the participation of affiliated persons of natural monopoly entities in tenders conducted by natural monopoly entities.
The tasks of forming a unified tariff-setting model for natural monopoly entities were addressed from a common perspective, based on the principle of determining the value of services through factors influencing the functioning of industries: restructuring processes, demand, supply and state regulation. The Concept for Improving the Tariff Policy of Natural Monopoly Entities was developed on the basis of an analysis of the impact of these factors on the pricing model.
The following principles were selected as the basis for improving tariff policy:
- structuring tariffs in connection with the processes of demonopolization of industries;
- taking into account the interests of consumers and the state when differentiating tariffs;
- ensuring the overall break-even operation of an enterprise from the perspective of the producer and investor;
- transparency of tariff structures.
The tariff calculation model must determine economically justified and transparent tariffs and provide for the possibility of their subsequent adjustment through a mechanism that takes into account the influence of balancing factors. In practical regulation, these principles are intended to be applied through the introduction of new tariff-setting methods, monitoring the condition of natural monopoly entities and their consumers, and developing instruments for analyzing tariff changes.
When calculating and approving tariffs, new tariff-setting methods are applied:
- the method of calculating the rate of return on the regulated base of assets employed;
- the method of setting tariffs for a medium-term period.
For entities operating water management systems, sewerage systems and the energy sector, tariffs are approved taking into account the rate of return on the regulated base of assets employed. Medium-term tariffs have been approved for three entities in the energy sector (Ust-Kamenogorsk and Aktobe Combined Heat and Power Plants, Almaty Gas Networks), as well as for the limited liability partnership "Water Resources Marketing".
The permissible level of profit is calculated on the basis of the market value of assets used in the provision of services, including actual investments, and the rate of return. The rate of return is determined taking into account the industry to which the natural monopoly entity belongs.
For water management systems, the rate of return is determined using the investment risk accounting method; for entities in the energy sector, the weighted average cost of capital method is used. The more an entity invests, the higher its profit.
Another important factor in attracting investment is the introduction in practice of the method of setting tariffs for a medium-term period.
The introduction of stable tariffs for a medium-term period provides for the establishment of tariff frameworks within which natural monopolies conduct their activities. Importantly, natural monopoly entities are given the opportunity to independently dispose of income generated through increased production efficiency.
A condition for granting medium-term tariffs is that the natural monopoly entity undertakes obligations to implement an approved medium-term investment program. In addition, when calculating medium-term tariffs, profit calculated on the regulated base of assets employed is taken into account.
To substantiate the level of tariffs for the services of natural monopoly entities, mechanisms for expert diagnostics of the financial and economic condition of enterprises have been developed. The main objectives of conducting financial and technical examinations are to obtain an objective assessment of the performance results of natural monopoly entities, comprehensively identify unused reserves, continuously monitor the rationality of the functioning of economic systems, and monitor compliance with regulatory legal acts.
Sources of information for financial and technical examinations include accounting systems and financial statements, statistical accounting systems and reports, management accounting systems and reports, as well as non-accounting sources: materials from inspections and audits, external and internal audits, results of tax service inspections, materials from production meetings of natural monopoly entities and competent authorities, and mass media.
3. Analysis of the Current State of the Spheres of Natural Monopolies
Paragraph 1. Railway Transport Sector
A distinctive feature of tariffs for railway freight transportation is that they not only determine the level of stability of railway transport as an independent industry operating under conditions of self-financing, but, together with other basic industries, also affect the economic position of enterprises and sectors of material production.
With the adoption of the Program for the Restructuring of Railway Transport of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2004–2006, approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated February 6, 2004 No. 145, and the introduction of amendments to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Railway Transport" in July 2004, the process of organizational and financial separation of naturally monopolistic activities from other types of activities of the joint-stock company "National Company Kazakhstan Temir Zholy" (hereinafter referred to as JSC "NC Kazakhstan Temir Zholy") was initiated. The activities related to the provision of services of the main railway network (hereinafter referred to as the MRN) and access tracks have been classified within the sphere of natural monopolies in railway transport. Other activities, including freight and passenger transportation, have been transferred to the competitive sector.
The essence of the railway industry reform concept currently being implemented in Kazakhstan is aimed at liberalization and narrowing of the regulated sector through the introduction of competition in those areas of the industry where this is possible, as well as commercialization (result-oriented operation) of the monopoly sector through economically justified and efficient pricing.
Until July 20, 2004, tariffs in the Republic of Kazakhstan for domestic transportation were applied to the transportation of goods between stations located within the territory of Kazakhstan and were calculated using the rates of Price List No. 10-01, 1989 edition, "Tariffs for Railway Freight Transportation", expressed in rubles, taking into account increasing indexation coefficients and the conversion of rubles into tenge established by the authorized body.
Freight tariffs for transportation of goods in international traffic were calculated using the rates of the price list "Tariffs for Export-Import Railway Freight Transportation", which were expressed in Swiss francs, taking into account increasing coefficients established by the authorized body, and converted into the payment currency in tenge at the exchange rate of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the date of payment. This price list was introduced on July 1, 1999.
As of July 20, 2004, tariffs for the services of the main railway network in the transportation of goods by railway transport were approved and brought into effect. These tariffs were obtained by proportionally dividing freight transportation tariffs into infrastructure and other components. Tariffs for the transportation of goods by railway transport consist of four components: tariffs for the services of the main railway network, locomotive traction, freight and commercial operations, and the use of wagons and containers.
Currently, together with interested government agencies and consumers of the services of the main railway network operator, a draft methodology for calculating tariffs for the services of the main railway network is being developed in accordance with the list of operations included in MRN services, approved by the Ministry of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
The methodology for calculating tariffs for access track services was approved by Order of the Acting Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation of Natural Monopolies dated December 30, 2004 No. 516-OD.
At the same time, the fee paid by carriers for the use of the services of the main railway network is subject to state price regulation, while the remaining components of the railway tariff (locomotive traction services and railway transportation) potentially belong to the competitive sector but are currently regulated by the state in accordance with legislation on competition and the restriction of monopolistic activities.
The existing differentiation of tariffs by individual categories of transportation (types of traffic and types of cargo) is the result of:
- the application, during a certain period of the country's economic development, of a differentiated approach to entities exporting products and supplying them to the domestic market;
- the application, over many years, of the method of indexing the base rates of Price List No. 10-01 by establishing differentiated appreciation coefficients for tariff rates applicable to individual types of cargo.
Differentiation of prices for the products of natural monopoly entities serves as an instrument of the state's social and economic policy, allowing it to regulate the economic activity of various industries. In other words, the mechanism of influencing the economy through a system of regulated prices supplements fiscal macroeconomic policy.
In connection with Kazakhstan's forthcoming accession to the World Trade Organization, it is planned to equalize tariffs for domestic and export-import traffic according to the schedule agreed upon within the negotiation process.
The tariffs introduced for the services of the main railway network through the proportional division of the tariffs under Price List No. 10-01 are temporary and will remain in effect until a new tariff methodology is developed and adopted.
At the same time, certain difficulties exist in introducing the new tariff regulation methodology, associated with the unpreparedness of JSC "NC Kazakhstan Temir Zholy" to transfer carrier functions to "KazZheldorTrans" for a number of technical and organizational reasons. Consequently, JSC "NC Kazakhstan Temir Zholy" remains the National Carrier of services until January 1, 2007.
At the same time, improvement of tariff policy in the medium term will make it possible to establish a competitive environment and bring benefits to everyone: consumers, in the form of lower prices; unregulated enterprises, in the form of greater market liberalization; and regulated enterprises, through the establishment of a stable regulatory regime conducive to new investments and technological development.
Paragraph 2. Electric Power Sector
Currently, an electricity market consisting of two levels — wholesale and retail electricity markets — has been established and is functioning in Kazakhstan.
In the wholesale market, electricity prices are formed under conditions of competition between producers on the basis of supply and demand. The Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Electric Power Industry" and the Concept for the Further Development of Market Relations in the Electric Power Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan, approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated February 18, 2004 No. 190, have created the necessary conditions for the development of a competitive retail electricity market, in which suppliers compete for the right to supply electricity to end consumers.
At the same time, prices for electricity supplied by electricity supply organizations are established independently. Simultaneously, any retail electricity market consumer directly connected to the networks of an electricity transmission organization may, at their own discretion, choose an electricity supplier from among the electricity supply organizations operating in a particular region (district, village, settlement with a separately allocated electricity supply scheme).
Electricity transmission services belong to the sphere of natural monopolies, and tariffs for these services are established by the regulatory authority. At the same time, tariffs for transmission through the National Electric Grid include a component that depends on the distance over which electricity is transmitted from the electricity generating organization to the consumer. The transmission tariff also includes costs for purchasing standard technical losses in the networks.
Tariffs for transmission through the networks of regional electricity grid companies (the "entry" tariffs) do not depend on distance; however, since April 1, 2005, they have included costs for compensation of standard technical losses.
In some regions of the country, tariffs for electricity and heat energy, as well as for water management and sewerage system services for the population, were subsidized at the expense of industry. Objectively, the costs of providing services by natural monopoly entities to the population are higher than those for industrial consumers.
Taking into account the social importance of these services, a decision was made to introduce economically justified differentiation in stages. The first stage provided for the gradual equalization of tariffs to a single level, while the second stage provided for the introduction of economically justified differentiation.
In July 1999, the Concept for Regulating the Activities of Natural Monopoly Entities in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 1999–2000 was adopted and approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 15, 1999 No. 983.
In accordance with the Concept, it was necessary to eliminate unjustified differentiation of tariffs by consumer groups for electricity in the Aktobe, Akmola, West Kazakhstan, Karaganda and East Kazakhstan regions and the city of Almaty, and for heat energy in the Atyrau, North Kazakhstan and South Kazakhstan regions and the city of Almaty, by equalizing tariffs, approving uniform tariffs for the services of natural monopoly entities, and introducing economically justified differentiation.
The application of economically unjustified tariff differentiation in Kazakhstan was expected to be completed by 2000.
However, due to objective reasons, economically unjustified differentiation of electricity tariffs has been retained in the Almaty, Aktobe, Atyrau, East Kazakhstan, West Kazakhstan, Karaganda and Mangystau regions. With regard to heat energy, such differentiation has been retained in the East Kazakhstan and Zhambyl regions.
The retention of unjustified differentiation hinders the effective development of industry. Industrial enterprises, by subsidizing other consumers, particularly the population, through tariffs for heat and electricity, incur unjustifiably high costs, which in turn negatively affects the competitiveness of the products manufactured by these enterprises.
An Instruction on the Approval and Introduction of Tariffs (Prices, Fee Rates) for a Medium-Term Period for Services (Goods, Works) of Natural Monopoly Entities was developed and brought into effect. It was approved by Order of the Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation of Natural Monopolies and Protection of Competition dated February 3, 2003 No. 30-OD and registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan under No. 217.
The introduction of the medium-term tariff-setting methodology was aimed at stimulating investment in the energy sector. At the same time, the medium-term tariff-setting methodology is currently being implemented to an insufficient extent. In order to introduce this methodology more widely in the electric power sector, it is necessary to further improve it and consider the possibility of simplifying the procedure for establishing medium-term tariffs and the operation of entities under such tariffs.
A number of regulatory legal acts have been developed in the field of operation of wholesale and retail electricity markets. Centralized electricity trading is being conducted. A mechanism for balancing in real time is being developed.
The Main Problems of the Electric Power Sector.
1. Currently, according to the applied methodology for calculating tariffs for electricity transmission services through regional and/or local-level networks by voltage classes, approved by Order of the Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation of Natural Monopolies and Protection of Competition dated December 22, 2003 No. 334-OD, all consumers, both industrial and household, pay a single "entry" tariff, while the principles of economically justified tariff differentiation are absent.
2. A low level of investment attraction for the reconstruction and modernization of electricity and heat network infrastructure. In particular, the level of deterioration of heating systems in most cities has reached a critical level, including as a result of understated tariffs. All of this leads to an increase in the level of excessive heat energy losses. In order to restore technical standards, including the level of technical losses in the district heating system, it is necessary to attract substantial investment for the major repair and replacement of heating networks within the shortest possible time.
3. Imperfection of the methodology for calculating tariffs for the services of the National Electric Grid (hereinafter referred to as JSC "KEGOC"). Currently, the level of tariffs for the services of JSC "KEGOC" depends on the distance over which electricity is transmitted. For the effective functioning and further development of the electricity market, tariff setting for electricity transmission services through the National Grid must not be discriminatory towards market participants. In this regard, it is necessary to further improve the methodology for calculating tariffs for the services of the National Electric Grid (JSC "KEGOC") in terms of reducing the dependence of JSC "KEGOC" tariff levels on the length of electricity transmission.
4. The problem of justified allocation of costs in the combined generation of electricity and heat energy, taking into account the need to maintain the competitiveness of electricity produced by combined heat and power plants.
The elimination of unjustified differentiation and the introduction of economically justified tariff differentiation will contribute, firstly, to compliance with the requirements of current legislation and the principles of tariff policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan and, secondly, to an economically justified reduction in the cost of industrial production and, consequently, an increase in its competitiveness.
Paragraph 3. Telecommunications Sector
The telecommunications services market of the republic has demonstrated progressive growth in recent years, which is undoubtedly associated both with the general trends of economic growth in the country as a whole and with the liberalization of the industry resulting from the implementation of the measures under the Program for the Development of the Telecommunications Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2003–2005, approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated February 18, 2003 No. 168.
During 2004, in accordance with this Program, a stage of partial liberalization of the telecommunications market was implemented. A new Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Communications" was adopted, and fundamental amendments and additions were introduced to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Natural Monopolies". A number of regulatory legal acts were adopted to implement these laws, which effectively laid the foundation for a new model of state regulation of the telecommunications industry, oriented towards overcoming monopoly and actively encouraging and developing competition.
The concept of a national operator has been abolished in all legislative and regulatory documents, and all operators have been placed on an equal footing in terms of their rights and obligations.
At the end of 2004, the previously monopolized market for long-distance and international communications was opened to competition through the revocation of the exclusive license held by the joint-stock company "Kazakhtelecom" (hereinafter referred to as JSC "Kazakhtelecom") and the issuance of licenses to new alternative long-distance and international communications operators.
Subscribers and communications operators of the republic gained the opportunity to choose how to receive long-distance and international communications services and to route their traffic through the networks of long-distance and international communications operators.
The previously existing requirement that operators' networks could only be connected through the network of JSC "Kazakhtelecom" was abolished, and communications operators were granted the right to freely choose interconnection arrangements with one another, with the exception of the transit of international traffic of mobile communications operators.
Amendments were introduced to the Rules for Connecting Telecommunications Networks to the Public Telecommunications Network and Regulating the Transmission of Traffic through the Public Telecommunications Network of the Republic of Kazakhstan, approved by Order of the Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Informatization and Communications dated July 12, 2004 No. 145-p and registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan under No. 3041. These amendments create non-discriminatory conditions for new operators to connect to the network and implement the principle of mandatory interconnection for dominant operators.
A new methodology for mutual settlements between traditional communications service operators was adopted by Order of the Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation of Natural Monopolies dated November 8, 2004 No. 438-OD. It is aimed at stimulating the growth of traffic of interconnected operators, which increases their share in tariff allocation.
Universal telecommunications services are not included in the sphere of natural monopolies; however, tariffs for these services are subject to approval by the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
The Plan for Rebalancing Tariffs for Universal Telecommunications Services, approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 21, 2004 No. 884, provides for the gradual elimination of cross-subsidization between services and categories of subscribers, which will create an economic basis for the emergence of competition in the local telephone communications market.
In October 2004, the first stage of tariff rebalancing for universal services was implemented, under which the subscription fee for individuals in urban areas was increased by 20%, while tariffs for international telephone communication services in all directions were simultaneously reduced by 20%.
Due to the social importance of local communications services for residents of rural areas, tariffs for these services remain at their previous level, while the losses incurred by operators providing local telephone communications services in rural areas will be covered within the framework of the universal access mechanism.
As a result of the implementation of state policy measures in the field of liberalization of the telecommunications industry, there is an objective narrowing of the sphere of natural monopolies, in which there are now effectively no telecommunications services provided by communications operators directly to end users.
The sphere of natural monopolies now includes services for interconnection and traffic transmission between operators, as well as services for leasing or using cable ducts and technological infrastructure for the purpose of connecting telecommunications networks to the public telecommunications network.
This circumstance is due to the retention, until the end of 2005, of two exclusive rights of JSC "Kazakhtelecom": the right to transit international traffic of mobile communications operators and the right to provide international and long-distance telephone communication services to its subscribers, as well as the need for a certain transitional period for the development of competition in the operator segment and the formation of inter-operator relations on the basis of the new regulatory framework, and the transition to tariff setting for inter-operator services based on separate accounting data for operators' income, costs and assets.
In addition, the development of the mobile communications segment, the services market of which is already comparable to the market for traditional telephony services, should be noted.
The absence of results from the introduction of separate accounting and the corresponding verification of the correctness of its implementation and maintenance currently does not make it possible to properly determine the cost of providing regulated services and, accordingly, to establish economically justified tariffs.
This situation also applies to the formation and establishment of calculated tariffs (rates) for traffic transmission services between communications operators' networks.
The approach currently used is based on determining the share of participation of technical elements of communications operators' networks in the transmission of specific types of traffic. At the same time, it is already clear that this approach is not the most optimal one and that, in the near future, after most operators have completed the introduction of separate cost accounting, it will be necessary to transition to a methodology for calculating tariffs for interconnection and traffic transmission by communications operators based on separate accounting data.
Paragraph 4. Pipeline and Water Supply and Sewerage Systems Sector
Enterprises engaged in the transportation of oil and/or petroleum products through main pipelines are financially stable and are characterized by positive dynamics in net income and stability in the volume of services provided.
The financial condition of enterprises engaged in the storage and transportation of gas or gas condensate through main and/or distribution pipelines is also assessed positively.
The current situation in the regulation of the water management and/or sewerage systems sector requires further improvement of state policy in the water sector of the economy.
One of the main problems of state regulation of the activities of natural monopoly entities in this industry is the absence in the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan of provisions defining the government body authorized to implement state policy in the field of municipal water supply and wastewater disposal. Without such a body, many problems remain unresolved, beginning with the general issue faced by all water utilities of the absence of a clear regulatory legal framework defining the principles for organizing the activities of water supply and wastewater disposal enterprises and ending with the absence of a state strategy for the development of this sector.
Most enterprises providing services in water management and/or sewerage systems are currently characterized by a low degree of financial stability and are operating at a loss.
In this situation, the problem lies in the relationship between the tariffs charged by enterprises for services in water management and/or sewerage systems and the income of the population (without taking into account the level of management in these enterprises).
The limited solvency of the population does not allow the inclusion in tariffs of financing for capital investments in the necessary amount for the repair and development of infrastructure, since this would inevitably lead to an increase in tariffs, often a substantial one.
At the same time, the deterioration of the fixed assets of water supply enterprises (62% on average across the republic in 2003, compared with 50% in 2001) is, in turn, the cause of increased losses (more than 32% on average across the republic) and, as a consequence, a decline in the quality of services provided.
In addition, one of the negative aspects is the low level of utilization of production capacities due to a reduction in the volume of consumption of these services (approximately 51% on average across the republic).
At present, various international financial institutions are implementing projects for the construction of new and reconstruction of existing water supply systems, as well as for improving the functioning of this sector as a whole. However, there is no unified state policy defining the strategic directions for the operation and development of the water management sector of the economy, including the municipal water supply and wastewater disposal sector, taking into account the specific characteristics and current state of the country's economy.
No less important is the issue of the absence of a detailed definition of the concept of "services of water management and/or sewerage systems", which encompasses a wide range of services differing in their functional properties, technology, scale, characteristics of suppliers and consumers, as well as many other parameters.
Given that the regulation and control of the activities of natural monopoly entities must be carried out taking into account the specific characteristics of the services they provide, the absence of an approved list of regulated services classified within the sphere of water management and/or sewerage systems, adopted in accordance with the procedure established by law, makes it impossible to conduct an effective tariff policy that ensures the observance of the interests of all participants in the natural monopoly sphere of the water sector of the economy and significantly reduces the overall quality of state regulation.
State regulation in the sphere of natural monopolies must take into account the specific characteristics of the types of activities carried out by monopoly enterprises.
At present, the types of services classified within the sphere of water management and/or sewerage systems have not been clearly defined. This significantly reduces the overall quality of state regulation and makes it impossible to conduct an effective tariff policy that ensures the observance of the interests of all participants in the natural monopoly sphere of the water sector of the economy.
Paragraph 5. Aeronavigation Sector
The regulatory policy in the field of aeronavigation is determined by the Laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On State Regulation of Civil Aviation" and "On the Use of the Airspace and Aviation Activities of the Republic of Kazakhstan".
The main functions of aeronavigation include air navigation services in the upper airspace, on local air routes and in the areas of aerodromes of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Modernization of equipment and optimization of air traffic management procedures make it possible to provide air navigation services from 12 air traffic management (hereinafter referred to as ATM) areas.
The existing network of international air routes makes it possible to meet the needs of all users of the airspace of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
The rates of air navigation charges depend on the maximum take-off weight of the aircraft, the type of flight performed and the nationality of the airline. Tariffs for Kazakhstani airlines are lower than the rates applied to foreign airlines.
Improvement of tariff policy was necessitated by the intensification of competition in the global air navigation services market, a decrease in the flow of transit flights operated by foreign airlines, and the existing tariff differentiation, which has not resulted in a substantial increase in domestic transportation or a reduction or stabilization of passenger tariffs.
The main problems in regulating this sector today include issues related to the regulation of air navigation services provided to aircraft performing transit flights, the introduction of separate cost accounting, increasing transit potential in the aeronavigation sector, maintaining financial stability and resolving social and personnel issues, and attracting foreign airlines to the domestic air transportation market of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Paragraph 6. Postal Services Sector
Publicly accessible postal services belong to the sphere of natural monopolies. These services consist of the postal operator's services for forwarding ordinary letters, postcards and printed matter (parcels) on behalf of users.
At present, given the existence of a wide postal network covering the entire territory of the country, the obligation to provide these services has been assigned by the state, as the owner, to the National Postal Operator.
The status of the National Postal Operator of the Republic of Kazakhstan has been granted to the joint-stock company "Kazpost".
According to the relevant provisions, the National Postal Operator provides publicly accessible postal services to any user in any populated locality of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
The National Postal Operator provides socially significant services and often incurs losses in rural areas, since the current tariffs for most types of services provided are established at average rates that do not take into account differences in the cost of providing services in urban and rural areas.
According to the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Postal Services", the national postal network is recognized as a public postal network operating throughout the territory of the republic and through which services are provided on the basis of a public contract.
The national postal network may be considered a system for providing publicly accessible services consisting of the networks of the National Postal Operator and alternative operators.
However, at present, due to the absence of alternative operators providing publicly accessible postal services, the postal network of the National Postal Operator constitutes the national postal network.
Certain restrictions on the provision of these services by other postal operators include the relatively low price of these services and the system of strict regulation and control of natural monopoly entities in accordance with legislation, as well as a decline in users' confidence in these services.
The volumes of publicly accessible postal services, compared with other postal services (courier and express services, special services), remain at the same level from year to year, and subscriber mailboxes in residential buildings are, in most cases, unfit for use.
External factors contribute to increasing public demand for publicly accessible services, including a favorable economic situation in the country (an increase in the solvency of the population, development of the private and business sectors of the economy, a low level of inflation, and other factors).
The following have been identified as the most important tasks of state regulation of tariff policy:
- maximum possible satisfaction of consumer demand;
- increasing the efficiency of the operations of the divisions of the National Postal Operator;
- ensuring further development and modernization of facilities, expansion of the services market and improvement of the quality of postal services;
- searching for and introducing new forms of attracting potential consumers of services;
- creating economically equal conditions for operators providing services in rural areas;
- promoting the attraction of investment for the introduction of new technologies and equipment;
- introducing advanced international experience.
In general, the development of competition in the postal market will contribute to the emergence of alternative operators capable of providing publicly accessible services. This will make it possible to consider the possibility of excluding the National Postal Operator from the list of monopolists with respect to the above-mentioned services and creating legal conditions for the entry of private operators.
In order to create equal competitive conditions for postal operators, particularly those providing postal services in rural areas, it is necessary to develop an optimal pricing strategy.
In this regard, the introduction of separate cost accounting by types of postal services is envisaged in the field of postal services.
This will make it possible to determine the actual cost of services, generate income to cover current expenses and obtain profit.
For these purposes, a methodology for cost allocation, determination of service costs and calculation of tariffs in the postal services sector has been developed.
The main regulatory problem associated with the quality of service provision and the satisfaction of potential demand for publicly accessible postal services necessitates a review of the list of publicly accessible postal services and the development of a universal service mechanism in the postal sector in order to increase confidence in postal services and ensure the preservation of subscriber mailboxes in condominium properties.
Paragraph 7. Airport Sector
At present, all airports of the republic are included in the republican section of the State Register of Natural Monopoly Entities.
In order to attract air carriers through the use of the region's transit potential by limiting state tariff regulation of airport activities, a nomenclature of airport services subject to state-regulated prices has been approved, providing for the transfer of certain services into the competitive environment.
The nomenclature includes an exhaustive list of services, the main ones being the provision of take-off and landing (arrival and departure), aviation security services, and services for providing aircraft parking spaces.
In order to ensure transparency in the formation of tariffs for services provided by airports under natural monopoly conditions, a methodology for calculating airport charges and ground handling tariffs at airports of the Republic of Kazakhstan was introduced into regulatory practice, making it possible to optimally allocate enterprise costs by types of services provided.
At the same time, despite the measures being taken, including those aimed at improving the regulatory framework, the main problem of tariff regulation in the airport sector is the need to eliminate the practice of applying unjustified tariff differentiation for the services of certain airports by consumer groups, which has remained in place to date at 11 out of 20 airports in the republic.
In addition, enterprises lack separate accounting for income, costs and assets employed.
In this regard, in order to ensure the transparency and justification of costs taken into account when forming tariff estimates and tariffs for regulated airport and air navigation services, Rules for Maintaining Separate Accounting of Income, Costs and Assets Employed by Natural Monopoly Entities Providing Services in the Airport Sector have been developed and approved.
The introduction of separate accounting will ensure the transparency and justification of costs taken into account when forming tariffs and tariff estimates for regulated services (goods, works), and will also contribute to ending the practice of cross-subsidization of certain services (goods, works) at the expense of others, including the transfer of part of the expenses from unregulated services (goods, works) to regulated ones.
Furthermore, in order to further improve the tariff-setting system for regulated airport services, it is necessary to develop a new methodology for calculating tariffs (fee rates) for regulated airport services.
Paragraph 8. Sea Port Sector
At present, sea port services are provided by two enterprises included in the republican section of the State Register of Natural Monopoly Entities: the republican state enterprise "Aktau International Commercial Sea Port" and the joint-stock company "National Maritime Shipping Company "Kazmortransflot".
Sea port services are regulated in accordance with the approved list of mandatory sea port services, under which regulated services include loading and unloading operations performed using the resources and equipment of the sea port, as well as fees for a vessel's call at a sea port for the purpose of cargo operations and/or other purposes, followed by its departure from the port (port call).
Within the framework of the implementation of the Program for Improving the Tariff Policy of Natural Monopoly Entities for 2002–2004, approved by Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated October 15, 2002 No. 1126, a methodology for calculating rates of charges and fees for works and services performed by a sea port was developed and approved.
In addition, in order to conduct a flexible tariff policy aimed at increasing the volume of services provided and creating conditions for redirecting transit cargo through the Republic of Kazakhstan, Rules for Establishing and Cancelling Temporary Reducing Coefficients to Tariffs (Prices, Fee Rates) for Cargo Transshipment Services Performed Using the Resources and Equipment of a Sea Port were developed and approved.
In the near future, it will be necessary to continue improving the tariff methodology applied to the activities of enterprises providing sea port services by introducing separate accounting of costs and assets employed and developing a procedure for establishing the rate of return on the regulated base of assets employed.
4. Goal and Objectives of the Concept
In accordance with the long-term Development Strategy of the country until 2030 and the medium-term Plan for the Socio-Economic Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2005–2007, as well as approved sectoral programs and the ongoing restructuring of industries, it is necessary to further improve the existing system of state regulation of natural monopoly markets, shifting the focus towards achieving economic efficiency while taking into account the state's regulatory objectives.
The measures being taken to regulate the spheres of natural monopolies are of a "microeconomic" regulatory nature, whereby the level of tariffs for the services of natural monopoly entities is established on the basis of the entity's justified costs, but the impact of tariff levels on other sectors of the economy and possible imbalances in the development of the state's economy resulting from uncoordinated tariffs are not taken into account.
Therefore, it is necessary to further develop such tariff regulation instruments that will make it possible to assess the degree of consistency of tariffs from the perspective of the general interests of the economy as a whole, that is, at the "macroeconomic" level.
Within the framework of the implementation of this Concept, it is necessary to further improve microeconomic regulation mechanisms while simultaneously developing macroeconomic regulation instruments.
The purpose of this Concept is to determine the main areas for improving and developing the regulatory policy in the spheres of natural monopolies, ensuring the coordinated development of all sectors of the economy.
The creation of an effective tariff-setting system for the services of natural monopoly entities, as one of the main areas of tariff policy, must be based on the following principles:
1) observing a balance between the interests of consumers and natural monopoly entities;
2) covering costs and ensuring profit sufficient for the effective functioning of a natural monopoly entity;
3) tariff stability on a medium-term basis;
4) abandoning unjustified tariff differentiation in order to ensure the process of Kazakhstan's integration into the global economy;
5) increasing the efficiency of the activities of natural monopoly entities.
Taking the above into account, it is necessary to address the following tasks aimed at improving existing regulatory mechanisms:
- improving the tariff regulation system;
- determining the boundaries between natural monopoly spheres and competitive sectors by industry;
- developing regulatory legal acts governing relations between market participants in industries undergoing reform;
- introducing mechanisms for separate accounting of income, expenses and assets employed by services of natural monopoly entities.
With regard to the development of new regulatory mechanisms, it is necessary to address the following tasks:
- developing models for assessing the impact of changes in tariff levels for the services of natural monopoly entities on economic sectors and individual groups of consumers;
- determining economically justified tariff differentiation, taking into account the specific characteristics of industries;
- developing mechanisms for state subsidization of regulated services;
- improving mechanisms for monitoring and conducting technical and financial examinations of the activities of natural monopoly entities;
- establishing a system for monitoring the activities of entities based on a balanced system of indicators;
- informatizing the activities of the central government body responsible for controlling and regulating activities in the spheres of natural monopolies.
5. Main Areas and Mechanisms of Implementation
Paragraph 1. Improvement of the Existing Methodological Framework for Tariff Regulation in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies
The need to improve the existing system of tariff regulation of natural monopoly entities is justified by the processes of reform and development of infrastructure industries, which have necessitated the revision of the regulatory legal framework and clarification of the list of "naturally monopolistic services".
In this regard, the main areas for improving tariff policy are focused on addressing problematic issues associated with creating incentives to increase the efficiency of natural monopoly entities, the need to reduce inefficient costs, and increasing the investment attractiveness of enterprises.
The main tasks that need to be addressed in order to improve the tariff regulation system are:
- improving mechanisms for ensuring transparency in tariff setting and introducing mechanisms for separate accounting of income, expenses and assets employed by the services of natural monopoly entities;
- ensuring the recovery of the value of assets employed in order to create conditions for the regular renewal of fixed assets by natural monopoly entities and increase the investment attractiveness of industries.
The most important prerequisites for introducing a system of separate accounting of income and expenses by types of services were the need to improve the tariff regulation system, that is, the need to ensure the following conditions:
- economic justification of the costs included in tariffs;
- transparency of the costs included in tariffs.
The theoretical basis of the separate accounting system must consist of the principles of economic theory and decision-making theory.
The separate accounting system must include methodologies for allocating costs to products (services) and assigning assets employed to products (services).
The main objects of analysis within the separate accounting system are types of products (services).
The frequency of preparing reports under the separate accounting system is determined as necessary, in accordance with the needs of the regulatory authority and the capabilities of the entities.
The resolution of tasks related to the development of the separate accounting system must be based on the development and use of a business model of the natural monopoly entity, founded on the organizational and financial structure and the operational model of the industry being described.
Separate accounting will ensure the transparency and justification of costs taken into account when forming tariffs and tariff estimates for regulated services (goods, works).
In addition, this will contribute to ending the practice of cross-subsidization of certain services (goods, works) at the expense of others, including the transfer of part of the expenses from unregulated services (goods, works) to regulated ones.
The cost of developing and implementing a separate accounting system at an enterprise is relatively high; therefore, it is necessary to develop differentiated requirements for its implementation by natural monopoly entities depending on the volumes of services provided and their income.
One of the most common methods of state regulation of the activities of companies operating in natural monopoly markets is profit regulation, which consists of limiting the profit generated from regulated types of activities (products or services).
Limitation of profit in the income generated from regulated types of activities (products or services) of natural monopoly entities must be based on the return on assets employed by the relevant natural monopoly entity.
The method of regulating permissible profit as part of the tariff for the provision of a particular service is implemented by determining the value of the assets employed in providing that service and the cost of capital attracted to finance the assets employed.
The permissible level of profit is used as the minimum rate for determining the entity's operating profit from that service.
The rate of return on the regulated asset base, based on the cost of capital attracted to finance the assets employed, is an instrument of economic stimulation for all participants in the market for services provided by natural monopoly entities.
It serves as:
- a criterion in the process of making decisions on investment of funds;
- a basic indicator of investment efficiency;
- a criterion in the process of making management decisions, for example, regarding the lease or acquisition of production fixed assets.
The importance of assessing the cost of capital when determining permissible profit from regulated services necessitates the correct calculation of this indicator on the basis of an appropriate calculation methodology.
In order to ensure the objectivity of this calculation, it is necessary to develop methodological tools that take into account risk factors when calculating the rate of return.
Paragraph 2. Development of New Instruments and Methodology for Establishing Optimal Tariffs
The key areas for the development of tariff regulation in the sphere of natural monopolies are determined by the principle of organically integrating the tariff policy pursued with respect to natural monopoly entities into the nationwide economic development policy of the Republic through the development of a methodology and the determination of macroeconomic criteria for setting tariffs.
The development of the tariff regulation system is based on expanding the extent to which the interests of the main stakeholders are taken into account in pricing, using developed instruments for assessing the impact of tariffs charged by natural monopoly entities on economic sectors. The mechanisms for implementing this area include monitoring key indicators of the condition of the main stakeholders and strengthening the scientific basis for supporting decision-making in tariff regulation through the application of econometric and economic-mathematical forecasting models that take into account interrelationships between indicators. The application of such models will make it possible to preliminarily assess (forecast) the impact on market entities and the economy as a whole of such factors as changes in tariffs, the application of various pricing systems for the services of natural monopolies, and changes in the policy of subsidizing individual sectors and/or entities.
Measures to improve the methodology for calculating and establishing optimal tariffs for regulated services provided by natural monopoly entities will take into account the condition of economic sectors, development priorities established by sectoral development programmes, and the pace of implementation of ongoing reforms.
For example, in the electric power sector, it is necessary to provide for the phased introduction of a methodology for calculating tariffs for the transmission of electric energy through regional (local) level distribution company (REC) networks by voltage classes, taking into account the inclusion of the cost of standard technical losses in the "transmission" tariff; the possibility of transitioning to zonal tariffs for the transmission of electric energy through the National Grid; and the development and introduction of a methodology for calculating the tariff for the production of thermal energy, taking into account the maintenance of the competitiveness of electricity produced by combined heat and power plants (CHPs), in order to ensure a fair allocation of costs for the production of electric and thermal energy.
Another determining area in the development of the tariff regulation system is the consideration of issues related to integration processes and the development of the competitiveness of Kazakhstan's economy.
At present, information support for justifying the level of tariffs for the services of natural monopoly entities is provided through an expert assessment of the financial and economic condition of an enterprise. The main objectives of financial and technical examinations are to provide an objective assessment of the performance results of natural monopoly entities, comprehensively identify unused reserves, continuously monitor the rationality of the functioning of economic systems, and monitor compliance with regulatory legal acts. Accordingly, the main tasks of expert assessment consist of checking the quality and justification of plans and budgets; analysing the "costs – production volume – profit" relationship; analysing labour and wages; analysing the efficiency of the use of material resources; analysing the efficiency of the use of fixed assets and equipment performance; and analysing the cost of services. Sources of information for expert assessment include accounting and reporting systems, statistical accounting and reporting systems, management accounting and reporting systems, and other sources: audit and inspection materials, external and internal audit materials, the results of tax authority inspections, materials from production meetings of natural monopoly entities and competent authorities, and mass media.
To address modern tariff regulation challenges, a more advanced instrument is required, one that makes it possible not only to assess the current condition of market entities and the economy as a whole but also to make forecasts for determining development prospects. Implementing this requirement entails improving the traditional financial model into an instrument that makes it possible to clearly translate tariff regulation objectives into practical tasks and criteria for their achievement.
The criteria for assessing the performance of natural monopoly entities should include not only financial indicators but also non-monetary indicators of business efficiency, which, taken together, make it possible to account for the balance of various aspects of the activities of natural monopoly entities: customer relations, the organisation of internal business processes, and new opportunities.
The priority area in the development of the information base for tariff regulation is the development of a monitoring system for the condition of natural monopoly entities, their consumers and suppliers, based on a balanced scorecard system.
The main objective of developing such a system is to ensure a systematic approach and information support for decision-making on the following issues:
justification of the level of tariffs for regulated services;
determination of demand volumes depending on the tariff levels of natural monopoly entities;
development of subsidy mechanisms;
economic justification of the need for and objectivity of tariff differentiation;
assessment of the degree of mutual influence between sectors and justification of a balanced tariff level.
At the first stage of development, the authorised body aims to address the following tasks: formulating a clear regulatory concept, ensuring a common understanding of the methods of its implementation, and communicating it to natural monopoly entities. In the future, the system of methodological support and control should be transformed from an assessment system into a regulatory system.
The development and implementation of a balanced regulatory scorecard system in the practical activities of the authorised body require the development of organisational and methodological foundations: firstly, it is necessary to develop an appropriate methodology and tools to support decision-making in the field of natural monopoly regulation; secondly, it is necessary to consider the organisation of a monitoring system based on the balanced scorecard system, with the procedure for its implementation being determined.
The methodological foundation of the balanced scorecard system as a system for monitoring and regulating the activities of natural and state monopoly entities includes a system of economic models that classify regulatory objects, methods and instruments, as well as methods for analysing and balancing the interests of producers of regulated services, their consumers and suppliers.
The organisational foundation for implementing the functions of the balanced scorecard system includes two aspects: automation of the methodological framework in order to deliver the developed regulatory instruments to the executive system; and the development of additional requirements for the functional structure of the authorised body in order to introduce the executive regulatory system. The development of an automated executive regulatory system will provide opportunities to monitor the condition of natural monopoly entities in real time, prepare operational reports on the results of applying regulatory measures over the shortest possible periods, and compare target results with those actually achieved. The introduction of an automated executive regulatory system, on the one hand, will significantly increase the efficiency of methods and, on the other hand, will impose new requirements on the formats for collecting and transmitting information, the qualifications of specialists, and the methods of organising the activities of the authorised body.
The balanced scorecard system will reflect regulatory objectives in the spheres of natural monopolies through a comprehensive assessment of the activities of natural monopoly entities, consumers and suppliers.
Such a system fills a gap in the existing regulatory mechanisms – the absence of an assessment of the interrelationship between tariffs in different sectors. The scorecard system should signal possible imbalances from the perspective of the global interests of the economy as a whole. Assessing the impact of changes in tariffs in one sector on the financial and economic condition of entities in another sector is of great importance to the state in terms of ensuring economic development.
The development of the methodological framework for tariff regulation is based on the availability of sufficient information support, and the main areas of development are determined by its capabilities. The accumulation of information through the monitoring system based on the balanced regulatory scorecard system will make it possible, firstly, to move beyond uniform methodological approaches and develop a set of sector-specific regulatory instruments that take into account the technological development characteristics of each sector and, secondly, to develop models of the mutual impact of tariffs across these sectors.
It is in the interests of the state to create conditions (improve the "environment") for the development of all participants in the monopoly market (both natural monopoly entities and consumers), while pursuing the achievement of macroeconomic objectives for economic development. Therefore, the market mechanism of economic management is supplemented by instruments of state regulation, the balance between which depends on the nature of the economic tasks being addressed and the socio-economic condition of society.
The tariff policy pursued by the regulatory authority should ensure an optimal price level that is acceptable to producers and affordable for consumers. However, in order to take into account these conflicting interests of market participants, it is necessary to differentiate tariffs for the services of natural monopoly entities for different groups of consumers.
Therefore, the issue of tariff differentiation must be resolved taking into account the interests and capabilities of all participating parties. From the producer's perspective, tariff levels based on costs will be economically justified. For consumers, however, tariff differentiation that makes services or products affordable will be justified. The state must determine economically justified tariff differentiation.
The main instrument for eliminating economically unjustified tariff differentiation is the mechanism of state subsidies. Determining state subsidy mechanisms is one of the priority tasks of the regulatory authority within the framework of developing tariff policy and is based on the development of methodological instruments for determining the objects of subsidisation, the required amounts of subsidies and their sources, which will include:
1) a methodology for determining the amounts of subsidies required;
2) the procedure for providing justification by forms of subsidisation.
The priority sectors in which state subsidy mechanisms need to be developed include railway passenger transportation, telecommunications services, the production and transmission of thermal energy, water management system services, and others.
6. Required Resources and Sources of Financing
The financial support for the Concept shall be provided from and within the limits of the funds of the republican budget.
The total financial resources required for the implementation of the Concept amount to 1,361.8 million tenge, including: 399.4 million tenge in 2005; 496.9 million tenge in 2006; and 465.5 million tenge in 2007.
The expenditure amounts for 2006–2007 shall be уточнены и скорректированы в соответствии с бюджетом на соответствующий финансовый год.
7. Expected Results of the Implementation of the Concept
As a result of the implementation of this Concept, the following results will be achieved:
creation of a mechanism ensuring that the interests of natural monopoly entities, consumers of their services and the state are taken into account with regard to the restoration of infrastructure sectors;
creation of the necessary conditions for eliminating structural imbalances between sectors and transitioning from an economic policy of survival to an economic policy of development;
creation of the necessary conditions for transitioning to the establishment of medium-term and long-term maximum tariffs and reducing administrative mechanisms of influence on the economy;
increased investment attractiveness through tariff predictability;
development and implementation of a mechanism for monitoring the activities of natural monopoly entities, monitoring their operations and increasing management accountability for results;
rebalanced tariffs;
ensuring transparency in the activities of natural monopoly entities through the application of progressive pricing methodology, separate accounting and profit calculation methods;
improving the quality of services provided through production modernisation, increased management efficiency and the reduction of excessive losses;
development and implementation of instruments that make it possible to analyse the impact of changes in tariffs charged by natural monopoly entities on their consumers and the economy, and to forecast the impact of tariff dynamics on individual sectors and household incomes;
elimination of barriers to Kazakhstan's integration into the global economy through the implementation of requirements adopted by the Republic from the World Trade Organization and the Eurasian Economic Community.
Approved by Resolution No. 455 of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 13 May 2005
Action Plan for the Implementation of the Concept for the Development of Tariff Policy in the Spheres of Natural Monopolies for 2005–2007
| No. | Measure | Form of completion | Responsible for implementation (execution) | Implementation deadlines | Estimated expenses* (million tenge) | Source of financing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Development of a methodology for calculating tariffs (fee rates) for regulated airport services | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 4.0 | Republican budget |
| 2. | Development of a methodology for calculating the investment tariff (price, fee rate) for services (goods, works) of natural monopoly entities in the railway transport and ports sector | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 6.0 | Republican budget |
| 3. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing services at seaports | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 7.0 | Republican budget |
| 4. | Development of rules for the revaluation of fixed assets of natural monopoly entities | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Justice | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 6.0 | Republican budget |
| 5. | Development of rules for providing equal access conditions to regulated services (goods, works) in the telecommunications sector where there is no competing telecommunications operator due to technological impossibility or economic inexpediency of providing such services, with the exception of universal telecommunications services, as well as in the field of granting for property lease (rent) or use cable ducts and other fixed assets technologically related to connecting telecommunications networks to the public telecommunications network | Order of AREM | AREM, Agency for Informatization and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 3.0 | Republican budget |
| 6. | Development of a methodology for calculating the maximum level of tariffs (prices, fee rates) for the services (goods, works) of natural monopoly entities | Order of AREM | AREM | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 3.5 | Republican budget |
| 7. | Development of methodological recommendations for analysing the spheres of natural monopolies in order to determine whether the services (goods, works) provided by natural monopoly entities within these spheres should be classified as regulated | Order of AREM | AREM | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 3.5 | Republican budget |
| 8. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing services for the transmission and/or distribution of thermal energy | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 4.0 | Republican budget |
| 9. | Development of a methodology for calculating tariffs for thermal energy transmission services | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2005 | None | – |
| 10. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing services for the transportation of oil and/or petroleum products through main pipelines | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 5.0 | Republican budget |
| 11. | Development of a methodology for calculating the investment tariff (price, fee rate) for services (goods, works) of natural monopoly entities in the oil and gas and energy sectors | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2005 | 7.0 | Republican budget |
| 12. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing publicly accessible postal communication services | Order of AREM | AREM, Agency for Informatization and Communications | 4th quarter of 2005 | 5.0 | Republican budget |
| 13. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing main railway network services | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 4th quarter of 2005 | 10.0 | Republican budget |
| 14. | Development of rules for maintaining separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed by natural monopoly entities providing access railway track services | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 4th quarter of 2005 | 5.0 | Republican budget |
| 15. | Determination of the competent authority in the field of water management and sewerage system services | Proposal to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AREM | 4th quarter of 2005 | None | – |
| 16. | Development of requirements for a set of methodologies and economic-mathematical models for assessing the impact of tariff changes by basic natural monopoly entities on economic sectors and intersectoral aggregated indicators | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning | 4th quarter of 2005 | 1.8 | Republican budget |
| 17. | Conducting financial and technical examinations of the activities of natural monopoly entities | Report to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AREM | 4th quarter of 2005 | 328.6 | Republican budget |
| 18. | Introduction of a methodology for calculating tariffs for electric energy transmission services through interregional-level networks using energy-deficit and network capacity coefficients | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 1st quarter of 2006 | None | – |
| 19. | Development of a methodology for calculating tariffs for water management system services (agricultural irrigation) | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Agriculture | 3rd quarter of 2006 | 8.0 | Republican budget |
| 20. | Development of a methodology for calculating the investment tariff (price, fee rates) for regulated services (goods, works) of natural monopoly entities in the field of air navigation | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2006 | 6.0 | Republican budget |
| 21. | Development of a methodology for calculating the investment tariff (price, fee rates) for regulated services (goods, works) of natural monopoly entities in the telecommunications sector | Order of AREM | AREM, Agency for Informatization and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2006 | 7.0 | Republican budget |
| 22. | Introduction of a methodology for calculating tariffs for electric energy transmission services through regional-level networks, differentiated by voltage classes (Stage 1) | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2006 | None | – |
| 23. | Development of a methodology and electronic model for determining demand elasticity by consumer groups for services provided by natural monopoly entities | Order of AREM | AREM | 4th quarter of 2006 | 23.2 | Republican budget |
| 24. | Development of a methodology for determining the consumption structure of services provided by natural monopoly entities by final consumers (households) | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning | 4th quarter of 2006 | 10.0 | Republican budget |
| 25. | Development of a methodology for determining the mutual impact of prices and tariffs in interconnected sectors, with the creation of a set of multi-sector balance electronic models (5–6 models) | Order of AREM, software product | AREM, Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning, Ministry of Transport and Communications, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Agency for Informatization and Communications, Ministry of Agriculture | 4th quarter of 2006 | 44.7 | Republican budget |
| 26. | Development and maintenance of an electronic database for monitoring the activities of natural monopoly entities | Order of AREM | AREM | 4th quarter of 2006 | 48.0 | Republican budget |
| 27. | Conducting financial and technical examinations of the activities of natural monopoly entities | Report to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AREM | 4th quarter of 2006 | 350.0 | Republican budget |
| 28. | Development of a methodology for calculating tariffs (prices, fee rates), taking into account the qualitative characteristics of services provided by natural monopoly entities in the field of air navigation | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2007 | 5.5 | Republican budget |
| 29. | Development of a methodology for calculating tariffs (prices, fee rates) for regulated services of natural monopoly entities in the field of air navigation, taking into account the maintenance of separate accounting of revenues, costs and assets employed | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Transport and Communications | 3rd quarter of 2007 | 3.5 | Republican budget |
| 30. | Introduction of a methodology for calculating tariffs for electric energy transmission services through regional-level networks, differentiated by voltage classes (Stage 2) | Order of AREM | AREM, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources | 3rd quarter of 2007 | None | – |
| 31. | Establishment of a system for monitoring the activities of entities based on a balanced scorecard system | Information to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AREM (coordinator), Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Ministry of Transport and Communications, Ministry of Agriculture, Agency for Informatization and Communications | 4th quarter of 2007 | 24.3 | Republican budget |
| 32. | Development of a methodology for assessing the impact of changes in tariffs charged by natural monopoly entities on the economy, with the formation of criteria for optimal tariff differentiation (systems of sectoral and intersectoral indicators) and a consolidated electronic model | Order of AREM, software product | AREM, Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Ministry of Transport and Communications, Ministry of Agriculture, Agency for Informatization and Communications | 4th quarter of 2007 | 34.2 | Republican budget |
| 33. | Development and maintenance of an electronic database for monitoring the activities of natural monopoly entities | Order of AREM | AREM | 4th quarter of 2007 | 48.0 | Republican budget |
| 34. | Conducting financial and technical examinations of the activities of natural monopoly entities | Report to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan | AREM | 4th quarter of 2007 | 350.0 | Republican budget |
Note:
– The financial support for the Concept shall be provided from and within the limits of the funds of the republican budget. The total financial resources required for the implementation of the Concept amount to 1,361.8 million tenge, including: 399.4 million tenge in 2005; 496.9 million tenge in 2006; and 465.5 million tenge in 2007.
The expenditure amounts for 2006–2007 shall be уточнены и скорректированы в соответствии с бюджетом на соответствующий финансовый год.
AREM – Agency for Regulation of Natural Monopolies.
MEBP – Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning.
MTС – Ministry of Transport and Communications.
MSH – Ministry of Agriculture.
MEMR – Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources.
AIS – Agency for Informatization and Communications.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative cases and disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Programme Charter Statute Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages