On Approval of the Concept of Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 27, 2001 No. 886
The Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan hereby resolves:
- To approve the attached Concept of Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- This Resolution shall enter into force from the date of its signing.
Prime Ministerof the Republic of Kazakhstan
Approved byResolution of the Governmentof the Republic of Kazakhstandated June 27, 2001 No. 886
Concept of Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Introduction
Social protection is a system designed to ensure a certain level of access to essential necessities and a certain level of well-being for citizens who, due to certain circumstances (old age, health condition, loss of a breadwinner or employment, and other legal grounds), are unable to be economically active and provide themselves with income through participation in adequately paid employment.
The International Labour Organization, of which Kazakhstan is a member, defines the social protection system as a set of measures that includes:
promotion of stable, paid employment;
prevention and compensation of part of income in the event of the occurrence of major social risks through social insurance mechanisms;
provision of social assistance mechanisms intended for vulnerable population groups that are not participants in the social insurance system;
access of citizens to basic rights and services, such as education and medical care.
The quantitative indicators of the social protection system are largely determined by the level of economic development, while the degree of solidarity between individuals, the participation of government institutions and the level of incentives are interrelated with the selected socio-economic model.
Due to historical, cultural, political and other factors, countries with the same level of development have different degrees of solidarity in organizing social protection systems and different levels of participation by government institutions.
Full solidarity implies the absence of a relationship between contributions and benefits, whereby the right to receive benefits depends not on contributions but is determined from the moment a risk event occurs. The financial burden falls on all taxpayers, and all citizens are entitled to receive social protection. In such a system, the mechanism for redistributing income and the sole source of financing is the state budget, while the state acts as the regulator. Systems based on the principle of full solidarity usually provide the same, generally minimum, level of social protection to all citizens.
Under limited solidarity, the right to receive benefits depends on an individual's contributions. As a rule, such a system is financed through contributions made by employees and employers, and only those citizens who have made contributions (or on whose behalf contributions have been made by their employer) are entitled to receive benefits depending on the amount of contributions. Such systems usually provide additional protection to a certain group of the population, for example, employees in the formal sector or a specific workforce.
In addition, there are systems in which solidarity is absent (zero solidarity), where each citizen makes personalized contributions, on which benefits upon the occurrence of social risks directly depend.
Based on an analysis of international experience, it can be concluded that the most effective and comprehensive social protection systems usually include the following main elements: 1) state benefits; 2) compulsory social insurance; 3) funded pension provision; 4) social assistance.
State benefits are intended to provide all citizens with guaranteed payments at a certain level in the event of circumstances subject to social protection.
Compulsory social insurance, financed through contributions made by employers and employees, is intended to provide additional protection to employees in the formal sector, depending on the level of contributions made by the payer.
Funded pension provision is intended to regulate the processes of creating pension savings by each citizen.
Social assistance is intended to provide additional protection to certain categories of citizens at the expense of budget funds.
In addition, citizens have the right to take out voluntary insurance against the occurrence of social risks.
Such a combined system makes it possible to combine the advantages of both solidarity-based and personalized systems.
Kazakhstan is completing its transition to a market economy. Changes in economic relations require the establishment of an appropriate social protection system.
At the initial stage of the transition period, the state was forced to address current social protection issues against the background of inflation, budget deficits, declining production and an increasing share of the informal sector of the economy. As a result, reforms in the social sphere were fragmented in nature, representing responses to the resolution of current problems, with the exception of the introduction of the funded pension system and the replacement of in-kind benefits with cash payments.
Despite the transformations carried out, the current social protection system is characterized by complex and insufficiently systematic legislation and low incentives for participation in the system.
Favourable changes in the economy in recent years and the measures being taken to ensure sustainable growth make it possible to proceed with the establishment of a comprehensive social protection system in the event of social risks. In this regard, there has arisen a need to develop a new concept of social protection of the population, taking into account Kazakhstan's priorities and capabilities both at present and in the future.
This Concept does not address issues relating to ensuring citizens' access to services in the fields of education and medical care, since these are determined by other policy documents.
Current State of the Social Protection System of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan
The existing social protection system is characterized by the predominance of the principle of full solidarity, a high level of government participation and low incentives.
Social security in respect of disability, loss of a breadwinner, social protection of unemployed citizens and old age is organized on the principle of full solidarity. All individuals – citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan, foreigners and stateless persons permanently residing in the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter referred to as citizens) – receive state benefits at the same level when risk events occur, regardless of their participation in employment and contributions, unless otherwise provided for by laws and international treaties. Furthermore, due to the absence of economically justified standards for calculating social payments and their relationship with the remuneration system, an adequate link between the income levels of the working population and the social payments received has been lost. As a result, some employed persons receive wages lower than the amounts of social benefits paid even to those citizens who have made no contribution to the system.
The Republic does not have a system based on the principle of limited solidarity, that is, there is no system providing additional protection to employed citizens when social risks occur, with benefits depending on the amounts of contributions made.
The solidarity pension system partially takes into account a citizen's labour contribution. The funded pension system is the only type of provision upon the occurrence of old age that is based on the principles of savings without solidarity among participants and has effective incentives for participation in the system.
The current legislation provides for voluntary insurance against the occurrence of social risks, which, due to a number of factors, has not yet become sufficiently widespread.
The state is the main source of financing and the general regulator of the social protection system. In accordance with the legislation, certain categories of citizens are provided with social assistance at the expense of state funds. Incentives for participation in the system, with the exception of the funded pension system, are minimal.
The main shortcomings of the existing social protection system that impede its effective functioning are:
imperfect legislation – legislation regulating the social sphere is primarily structured according to types of payments rather than according to social risks and the grounds for making payments;
insufficient fairness and low incentives – the absence of advantages for employees in the formal sector of the economy who make tax contributions over those who do not make such contributions when exercising their right to receive social benefits;
insufficient transparency – the system of individual identification for tracking the process of receiving social payments is still at the development stage.
Maintaining the existing system may lead to a deepening of the current shortcomings, further weakening of the relationship between the amount of payments and contributions to the system and, as a consequence, an increase in the number of citizens evading the payment of taxes and mandatory contributions to the funded pension system.
Main Areas for the Development of the Social Protection System of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan
General Approaches to Reforming the Social Protection System
The main areas for the development of the social protection system are based on an analysis of international experience and the current situation. It is proposed to establish a system that meets market conditions and promotes the creation of incentives for stable, paid employment, while ensuring broader population coverage with minimum administrative costs.
The new system will be mixed and will include elements of both solidarity-based and personalized systems, as well as compulsory and voluntary insurance, and will be intended to protect the population against the main risks that a person may encounter throughout their life.
The fundamental goals and objectives of the new social protection system should contain elements aimed at supporting economic growth: fairness in providing protection to all citizens when risk events occur, effective functioning and the widest possible coverage of the population.
Legislation regulating the social sphere will be structured on the basis of social risks.
The proposed social protection system to be implemented must be:
fair – the exercise of the right to social protection must be easily accessible to potential recipients. The minimum amount of benefits guaranteed by the state must provide an equal level of payments for identical social risks, regardless of length of service and earnings. At the same time, the additional level of protection must depend on the duration and amount of each individual's participation in the system;
incentivizing individual responsibility of each citizen rather than their dependence on the state. In general, all able-bodied citizens should strive to be responsible for their own future and the well-being of their families;
effective – benefits must be targeted, that is, provided to those who are entitled to them and who need them most;
efficient, that is, transparent, well-managed, low-cost and simple. The main components of the system must be flexibly regulated;
accessible, that is, ensuring the widest possible coverage of the population within a specified period.
Taking the above into account, it is proposed to organize the social protection system on the basis of social risks, including the following elements of protection:
state payments at the expense of budget funds to all citizens at the same level, depending on social risks;
compulsory social insurance, initially financed through employers' contributions and, in the future, also through employees' contributions;
the funded pension system;
social assistance and special state programmes to support certain categories of citizens at the expense of budget funds.
In addition, voluntary insurance by citizens against the occurrence of social risks will be encouraged.
Taking into account Kazakhstan's specific circumstances, based on international experience, preference should be given to a mixed system when considering the institutional framework of the social protection system, under which the capabilities of both public and private institutions are used effectively.
For more effective management and control over all social payments, a nationwide personal identification system and a national database shall be developed, with each citizen being assigned a personal identification code.
Comprehensive social security for motherhood and childhood will be one of the priorities of the entire state social protection system. In the future, as the social protection system improves, the list of social risks giving rise to the need for social protection will be expanded. Thus, in order to support demographic processes, the birth and upbringing of children will be regarded as a situation requiring social protection. As support measures, one-time benefits upon the birth of a child and additional benefits for families raising minor children will be introduced.
Measures are expected to be developed to address disability-related issues, provide state support to industries producing goods for the needs of persons with disabilities, and ensure the introduction of state standards guaranteeing access for persons with disabilities to basic rights and services. Measures will be taken to develop individual programmes for the prevention of social risks and rehabilitation of persons with disabilities (medical, social and vocational), establish a system for the social and labour adaptation of persons with disabilities, and facilitate their integration into society. These proposals will be reflected in the Programme for the Rehabilitation of Persons with Disabilities for 2002-2005.
Targeted social assistance will be provided only to the most vulnerable segments of the population on the basis of actual eligibility criteria. In addition, special programmes will be developed aimed at providing additional protection to certain groups of persons – war veterans, persons with disabilities and mothers with many children.
An important aspect of the general approaches to reforming social protection is increasing the role of social standards, gradually increasing the minimum wage and bringing it closer to the subsistence minimum. The amount of social payments will be calculated on the basis of a standard having a real socio-economic basis.
In order to prevent and reduce the likelihood of social risks occurring, the state will take preventive measures. To prevent the risk of job loss, as well as to encourage citizens to obtain stable, paid employment, the state will improve programmes for creating jobs. To prevent the risk of harm to the health and lives of citizens while performing their employment duties, state supervision over compliance with labour legislation and occupational safety legislation will be strengthened. In order to reduce the risk of disability, it is proposed to improve the system of medical care, including through the improvement of its financing mechanisms.
The principles for ensuring payments to recipients of state benefits for old age, loss of a breadwinner and disability that have already been assigned at the time of the introduction of social insurance will remain unchanged.
It is proposed to increase the level of participation in the social protection system not only of each individual citizen but also of the Government's social partners – trade unions of workers and employers' associations, since all social protection systems are directly or indirectly financed from the funds of employees and employers.
Main Mechanisms of Social Protection upon the Occurrence of Social Risks
All employees working in organizations that pay social tax will become participants in the social insurance system in respect of loss of a breadwinner, loss of working capacity and loss of employment. The launch of the social insurance system will take into account the specific features of the implementation stage. At the initial stage, the social insurance system will be financed through employers' contributions and, in the future, also through employees' funds.
Social Protection in the Event of Loss of Working Capacity and Loss of a Breadwinner
When assessing the degree of disability of citizens of working age, it is proposed to take into account not only the degree of limitation of vital activities but also the degree of limitation of working capacity. Measures will be taken to regulate the procedure for assigning disability status and determining the degree of loss of working capacity, as well as to delineate the responsibilities of medical personnel and experts of medical and social expert commissions.
Reforming the social protection system in the event of loss of working capacity and loss of a breadwinner provides for the introduction of the following structure.
First level: provision of benefits to all citizens at the same level, at the expense of budget funds, depending on the types of social risks.
Second level: provision of additional payments to employees in the formal sector from the compulsory social insurance system until they reach retirement age or until the circumstances that served as the basis for insurance payments cease to exist.
The amount of payment from the social insurance system will be calculated on the basis of a replacement coefficient relative to the average wage over a specified period, the duration of contributions and the degree of loss of working capacity or the number of dependants. Mandatory pension contributions will be withheld from payments made by the social insurance system. The maximum income limit from which contributions are made and payments are assigned will be established by law.
Third level: in the event of loss of working capacity or loss of a breadwinner as a result of an accident or occupational disease occurring during the performance of employment duties, additional social protection will be provided in the form of payments from an insurance organization until retirement age or until the circumstances that served as the basis for insurance payments cease to exist. A system of compulsory insurance of employers' liability for harm caused to the life and health of an employee while performing their employment (official) duties will be introduced. Insurance will be carried out through mandatory contributions made by the employer to an insurance organization under the terms of an insurance agreement concluded between the employer and the insurance organization. In the event of loss of working capacity or loss of a breadwinner while performing employment duties, a citizen shall be entitled to receive a benefit from budget funds under the relevant type of social risk, payments from the social insurance system and payments from the insurance company. In addition, the insurance company will cover the injured person's expenses for prosthetics, treatment and rehabilitation, restoration of working capacity, etc. Mandatory pension contributions will also be withheld from payments made by the insurance organization.
Minimum amounts of payments from insurance companies will be established by law, and a system of penalties will be introduced against employers for failure to conclude insurance agreements in a timely manner. The introduction of this type of insurance will serve as an incentive for employers to comply with and improve occupational safety conditions.
For employees of state institutions financed from the republican and local budgets, a special procedure will be established for compensating harm caused to the life and health of an employee while performing their employment duties, in the form of lump-sum compensation payments from the estimates of state institutions. The amount of compensation will be regulated by the relevant legislation.
In addition, voluntary insurance by citizens at their own expense against loss of working capacity and loss of a breadwinner will be encouraged.
Social Protection in the Event of Loss of Employment
Reforming the social protection system for citizens in the event of loss of employment provides for the introduction of a two-tier structure.
First level: social protection of all unemployed citizens through assistance in finding employment, vocational retraining and the provision of paid public works at the expense of local budgets.
Second level: provision of payments to employees in the formal sector from the compulsory social insurance system for a specified period.
A citizen's right to receive payments from the social insurance system will arise if the citizen is recognized as unemployed in accordance with the procedure established by law and is actively seeking employment, as well as if the citizen has made a certain contribution to the system. The amount of payment will depend on the level of wages and the duration of insurance contributions. Mandatory pension contributions will be withheld from payments made by the social insurance system. A maximum income limit from which contributions to the social insurance system are calculated and payments are assigned will be established.
A system of disqualification of varying degrees will be applied for certain violations, which may postpone, reduce or cancel a payment, for example, for refusing suitable employment if it corresponds to the person's specialty and qualifications, voluntarily resigning, etc.
The introduction of a compulsory unemployment insurance system will significantly improve and expand the system of providing support to citizens during periods of job loss. Potential recipients will know the expected amount of benefits and, given the limited period during which benefits are paid, will be encouraged to actively seek employment. For the purposes of providing information support to unemployed citizens, a centralized database of labour market demand and supply by occupation and region will be established.
Social Protection upon the Occurrence of Old Age
The parameters of the solidarity pension system will be improved. When increasing pension payments, the period of retirement will be taken into account. The amount of pensions from the solidarity system will be gradually increased, taking into account the growth of consumer prices and payment restrictions established by the legislation on pension provision Z970136_.
It is envisaged that efforts to promote and explain the provisions of the funded pension system will be intensified. Measures are planned to expand the coverage of the population, primarily rural residents, by the services of funded pension funds through the use of the capabilities of the postal savings service, the State Centre for Pension Payments and other institutions.
Measures taken by tax authorities to monitor the completeness and timeliness of enterprises' transfers of mandatory pension contributions will be tightened. In addition, amendments will be made to the Code of Administrative Offences K841000_ in terms of increasing penalties for enterprises that fail to transfer mandatory pension contributions.
The mechanism for making pension payments from funded pension funds will continue to be improved, taking into account the adequacy of payments from the solidarity pension system and the availability of state guarantees in the form of additional payments up to the minimum pension amount where pension savings are insufficient. Measures will be proposed to develop the pension annuity market, including incentives for married couples to purchase joint annuities in order to ensure that citizens receive monthly payments from the funded pension system in an amount of at least the minimum pension (a pension annuity is a type of personal insurance providing for periodic insurance payments in the form of a pension or annuity upon the insured person's reaching retirement age).
Amendments will be made to the current pension legislation to abolish the function of the State Accumulation Pension Fund as the "default fund" and to grant funded pension funds the right to independently invest pension assets, subject to compliance with the requirements established by law.
Social Protection of Low-Income Citizens
The potential for poverty reduction will be achieved by creating new jobs and increasing wages. Targeted state social assistance will be provided to citizens in cash and in kind, as well as in the form of paid public works. Improvements will continue to be made to both the mechanisms for providing targeted social assistance and the methodology for assessing income levels.
Social assistance in kind will be provided only to citizens who are unable to work: children, pensioners and persons with disabilities. Social assistance to the able-bodied population will also be provided through the financing of public works, retraining programmes and employment assistance. The level of remuneration for public works will not encourage citizens to participate in them for extended periods, but will instead encourage them to actively seek permanent employment.
It is proposed to develop, alongside traditional forms of institutional assistance, such as maintaining residential institutions for elderly persons and persons with disabilities, new forms of targeted institutional assistance, such as opening shelters for persons without a fixed place of residence, social hotels, canteens for low-income persons, etc. The provision of assistance through social institutions in the form of in-kind assistance to those in need will be applied where there is no possibility of accumulating, substituting or reselling such assistance.
Areas for Improving the Legal and Information Support of the Social Protection System
A phased systematization of legislation according to types of social risks and grounds for payments is proposed. Special legislative acts concerning additional protection for certain categories of citizens will be developed. It is planned to continue improving the methodology for determining social standards.
Since the reform of the social protection system affects the interests of the entire population of the Republic, particular importance must be attached to providing the population with reliable and complete information on all relevant issues. Necessary explanatory work will be carried out among the population with the participation of social partners.
Taking into account the growing role of social insurance in the reformed social protection system, information support and accounting within the social protection system will become important issues.
It is planned to develop a model under which citizens will receive social payments through a single registration code for individuals, based on the existing identifiers of various government agencies. The key element of such a system will be the state database "Individuals", which will make it possible to reduce administrative costs for maintaining infrastructure and establish a link between the payment of insurance contributions and the right to receive social payments. Measures will be taken to improve the methodological framework for actuarial calculations for the needs of the social protection system (actuarial calculations are economic and mathematical calculations of the amounts of liabilities under insurance and reinsurance contracts for the purpose of ensuring the necessary level of solvency and financial stability of an insurance organization).
Areas for Improving the Financial and Institutional Support of the Social Protection System
It is assumed that until the completion of the reforms, the state will remain the main source of financing for the social protection system of the population. This situation will gradually change as government participation decreases and social insurance mechanisms develop. The state will ensure the completeness and timeliness of all social payments from the budget.
The social insurance system will be financed through a 3% reduction in the social tax rate and the introduction of mandatory insurance contributions amounting to 3% of an employee's income. At the initial stage, employers will be the payers of these contributions. Personalization of social insurance contributions will increase the motivation of employees, trade unions and employees' associations to monitor the process of transferring funds. The introduction of personalized accounting of social insurance contributions is one of the most important conditions for reforming the social protection system.
State regulation of the social security system is the fundamental principle of implementing the new social protection policy in the Republic of Kazakhstan. The role of the state will remain leading even in the event of a high level of development of the social insurance system and the funded pension system, which is not financed from the state budget, since supervision over the activities of system participants will remain the responsibility of the state. The authorized state body responsible for social protection of the population will strengthen its actuarial capacity to take measures to change social parameters in the areas of the funded pension system, the social insurance system and compensation for harm caused to the life and health of employees.
The introduction of compulsory types of social insurance entails the establishment of specialized institutions for accumulating contributions from citizens participating in the system. Taking into account international experience in the development of social insurance systems based on the principle of limited solidarity, it is proposed, for the purpose of ensuring full population coverage and the reliability of the entire system and reducing administrative costs, to establish a State Social Insurance Fund (hereinafter referred to as the Fund) in the form of a closed joint-stock company with 100 per cent state participation. The Fund, with individual accounting of participation and the amount of contributions, will make it possible to cover the formal labour sector with social insurance within a short period of time, including remote rural areas that are of little interest to private organizations. At the same time, effective control mechanisms will be introduced to prevent the misuse of the Fund's financial resources. The limits of the Fund's investment activities, procedures for managing and investing funds, and the Fund's rights and obligations regarding the custody and accounting of assets will be established by law. It is envisaged that the Fund's resources will be invested primarily in government securities. Taking into account the close relationship between the State Centre for Pension Payments and the social insurance system, its functions and responsibilities will be expanded. The Fund's obligations will constitute obligations of the state solely in its capacity as a shareholder, within the framework of the current legislation on joint-stock companies. At the same time, in the future, the participation of private institutions in organizing payments from the compulsory social insurance system may be envisaged. Adjustments to the main parameters of compulsory social insurance will be made in a timely manner as socio-economic conditions change.
Final Provisions and Stages of Implementation of the Concept of Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Following approval of this Concept, it is planned to develop, on its basis, a number of regulatory legal acts aimed at improving the social protection system of the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan. It is advisable to divide the implementation measures into two stages.
Stage I (2001-2002):
conducting actuarial calculations;
preparation and adoption of legislative acts on compulsory insurance of employers' liability for causing harm to the life and health of employees while performing their employment duties, effective from July 1, 2002;
preparation and adoption of legislative acts regulating the introduction of social insurance in respect of disability and loss of a breadwinner, and its implementation from the end of 2002;
introduction of amendments and additions to legislation on social protection of the population, including legislation on pension provision and taxation;
development of pension annuities;
preparation of the regulatory framework governing the activities of the State Social Insurance Fund;
implementation of the information support system.
Stage II (2003-2005):
inclusion of the risk of job loss in the list of social risks subject to compensation through compulsory social insurance;
transition to the assignment of social payments on the basis of a single registration code for individuals;
improvement of the methodological framework for accounting for citizens' income;
gradual alignment of the minimum wage with the subsistence minimum;
development of new forms of targeted assistance to low-income citizens, inclusion of one-time benefits upon the birth of a child and payments to families raising minor children among the mandatory types of assistance provided at the expense of the budget.
(Specialists: N.A. Martina,O.Ya. Puchkova)
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Programme Charter Statute Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Addresses