Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (General Assembly)
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai. Human Rights Council on 16 June 2015
Addition
Mission to Kazakhstan*
Summary
The Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association visited the country at the invitation of the Government of Kazakhstan on an official visit from 19 to 27 January 2015 to assess the situation with regard to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association in the country.
Sections II and III, following the introduction, describe a number of examples of good practices and continuing challenges in the exercise of the right to freedom of association by political parties, non-governmental organizations, trade unions and religious associations, as well as the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.
In conclusion, the Special Rapporteur makes recommendations on ways to address the challenges identified.
Reissued for technical reasons on 7 August 2015.
** The summary of the present report is being circulated in all official languages. The report itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is being circulated only in the language in which it was submitted and in Russian.
*** Submitted late.
Annex
[English and Russian only]
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai, on his mission to Kazakhstan (19–27 January 2015)
Contents
Paragraphs
I. Introduction................................................1–12
A. Historical and political background......................5–9
B. Legal framework.........................................10–12
II. Freedom of association....................................13–51
A. Political parties....................................19–32
B. Trade unions.................................33–38
C. Public associations...............................39–45
D. Religious associations................................46–51
III. Freedom of peaceful assembly..............................52–89
A. Exercise of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.........52–71
B. The Zhanaozen crisis.....................................72–89
IV. Conclusions and recommendations.................................90–98
I. Introduction
Pursuant to Human Rights Council resolutions 15/21 and 24/5, the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association visited Kazakhstan from 19 to 27 January 2015 at the invitation of the Government. The purpose of his visit was to assess the situation with regard to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association in the country.
The Special Rapporteur would like to thank the Government for responding to his requests to arrange meetings and to express his sincere appreciation to all those who took the time to meet with him in a spirit of constructive dialogue. The Special Rapporteur is pleased that the Government has extended a standing invitation to all special procedure mandate holders and has received six Special Rapporteurs on visits since July 2009. He considers this to be a demonstration of the Government's will and readiness to cooperate with the mechanisms of the Human Rights Council in the interests of strengthening the protection and promotion of all human rights, including the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association. The Special Rapporteur takes this opportunity to thank the Government for providing detailed responses to the communications he has sent to date, as well as to the letter sent following the visit.
The Special Rapporteur also expresses his gratitude to the Office of the United Nations Resident Coordinator in Kazakhstan and the regional office of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) in Central Asia for their excellent support in preparing for and during the visit.
While in Kazakhstan, the Special Rapporteur visited Astana, Almaty, Aktau and Zhanaozen. He met with representatives of the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government in Astana, and with representatives of regional and local authorities in Almaty, Aktau and Zhanaozen. He also met with representatives of the national human rights institution, international organizations, the diplomatic corps and civil society organizations, as well as survivors and victims of egregious human rights violations that occurred during the Zhanaozen crisis in December 2011. The Special Rapporteur thanks the Government of Kazakhstan for facilitating a meeting with Vladimir Kozlov, the imprisoned leader of the public association People's Party "Alga!", who is currently serving a seven-and-a-half-year sentence.
A. Historical and political background
Kazakhstan gained independence almost 24 years ago and has since made significant economic progress. High rates of economic growth and infrastructure development, including the construction of a new capital, have enabled Kazakhstan to become an important player on the regional and global stage. Such impressive economic achievements have been made possible by Kazakhstan's abundance of natural resources, the impressive mobilization of human resources and significant efforts to maintain stability in a society known for its ethnic and cultural diversity. Kazakhstan is currently pursuing far-reaching international ambitions, including its bid for a non-permanent seat on the Security Council for the period 2017–2018 and its proposal to host the 2022 Winter Olympic Games. The main objective of its national strategic plan, "Kazakhstan 2050 Strategy", is to join the world's 30 most developed countries by the middle of the century.
Despite its undeniable wealth and reputation as a prosperous and stable country, Kazakhstan faces a number of challenges. Socio-economic inequality persists in the country, and not everyone is afforded the opportunity to properly exercise certain human rights, particularly the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association.
Since the country's independence, political and economic affairs have been under the strict control of President Nazarbayev. He was elected the first President of Kazakhstan in 1991 and has remained in power ever since, receiving 95.5 per cent of the vote with a voter turnout of 89.9 per cent in the 2011 presidential elections. On 25 February 2015, at the initiative of the Council of the Assembly of the People of Kazakhstan, supported by Parliament, President Nazarbayev announced that early presidential elections would be held on 26 April 2015 instead of December 2016, as originally planned. As a result, the opposition was left with very little time to prepare for the elections.
In the view of the Special Rapporteur, Kazakhstan is at a crossroads. The pace of economic progress since independence has been impressive, but, owing to the lack of corresponding progress in ensuring other human rights, such progress remains somewhat fragile. Although this may seem paradoxical, the true measure of stability in a country is its tolerance of peaceful criticism of the established order, that is, the provision of channels for the peaceful expression of dissent and political pluralism. If such channels are not created, protest sentiments will not disappear on their own; on the contrary, they will only accumulate and multiply until they develop into something far more serious than street protests or reports by non-governmental organizations criticizing government policies.
During the visit, government representatives repeatedly emphasized that stability and cohesion were inherent characteristics of Kazakh society, pointing out that the views of minorities, as well as those of the nation as a whole, were represented in the Assembly of the People of Kazakhstan. The Government of Kazakhstan deserves credit for its ability to preserve stability and cohesion in a vast country comprising 140 ethnic and 17 religious groups. Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur concluded that stability is often improperly used as a pretext for restricting the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association. He emphasizes that the protection of human rights and the maintenance of peace and harmony are two sides of the same coin and are interconnected, mutually reinforcing and interdependent elements. In his view, the free exercise of the rights to peaceful assembly and association provides the authorities with a unique source of information about the challenges faced by the population. This is particularly relevant for a young and large country developing in a relatively difficult and ambiguous geopolitical context, such as Kazakhstan. There is no better way to understand the needs of one's people and to establish a system of checks and balances in government.
B. Legal framework
Kazakhstan has ratified many international human rights treaties, including the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women, the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment and its Optional Protocol, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and its Optional Protocol, the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance and, finally, in 2015, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities; all of these contain provisions relating to the protection and promotion of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association. In addition, Kazakhstan has ratified a number of conventions of the International Labour Organization, including the Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention, 1948 (No. 87), and the Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention, 1949 (No. 98). Given Kazakhstan's relatively short history as an independent country, the authorities' demonstrated commitment to compliance with international human rights law deserves praise.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the fact that the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association are guaranteed by the Constitution, which also recognizes ideological and political diversity. He notes that, under the Constitution, international treaties take precedence over domestic legislation and their provisions may be directly applied. In theory, this means that courts may directly refer, inter alia, to articles 21 and 22 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in their decisions. The Special Rapporteur positively notes that, under the Constitution, the right to peaceful assembly may be restricted only by law and in the interests of national security, public order, the protection of health, and the protection of the rights and freedoms of others, which clearly demonstrates that freedom is considered the norm and restrictions the exception, as provided for under international human rights law.
Despite these provisions, the Special Rapporteur is concerned that, following the events of 2011 in Zhanaozen, during which at least 16 people were killed in clashes with government forces deployed to suppress a protest by hundreds of oil workers dissatisfied with their working conditions, new laws were adopted that are being used to restrict the right to freedom of association. He is also concerned that, during the same period, participants in unauthorized assemblies appear to have increasingly been subjected to intimidation, fines, imprisonment and administrative sanctions.
II. Freedom of association
Before turning to the consideration of freedom of association as such, the Special Rapporteur would like to share his serious concern about an incident that occurred during his visit.
At the conclusion of a meeting with representatives of civil society held in Aktau on 24 January 2015, a car was observed parked directly opposite the entrance to the building where the meeting had taken place; unidentified individuals sitting in the back seat photographed the Special Rapporteur's driver and representatives of civil society as they exited the building. The quality of the photographic equipment they used and the manner in which they took the pictures leave virtually no doubt that this operation was carried out by secret police agents and was intended to intimidate activists.
The Special Rapporteur approached those individuals and demanded that they explain who they were and why they were taking photographs, but they quickly drove away without answering. On the same day, the Special Rapporteur lodged an official complaint with the Head of the Department of Internal Affairs of Mangystau Region. The following day, representatives of the internal affairs authorities informed the Special Rapporteur that a suspect had been detained and presented a confession allegedly made by that individual. However, the Special Rapporteur did not recognize the suspect as the person he had approached in the parking lot the previous day.
The Special Rapporteur considers this incident alarming, as it simultaneously demonstrates a lack of respect for individuals who hold or are presumed to hold views different from those of the Government, and a sense of impunity among certain officials.
The Special Rapporteur takes the issue of reprisals against individuals cooperating with United Nations bodies and mechanisms extremely seriously, in accordance with Human Rights Council resolution 24/24. The incident in Aktau provides compelling evidence that much more needs to be done to protect human rights defenders in Kazakhstan, particularly in view of the country's bid for a non-permanent seat on the Security Council. Creating an enabling environment for the development of civil society requires not only ensuring protection against acts of persecution and intimidation, but also proactively making efforts to bring those responsible for human rights violations to justice and adopting positive measures aimed at supporting individuals who hold views and beliefs that are different from those generally accepted or not shared by the majority.
The Special Rapporteur notes that, since then, no matters of concern directly related to his visit have been brought to his attention; however, he will remain in contact with the civil society activists who attended the meeting with him and will maintain a firm position on this issue.
A. Political parties
The space for expressing opposition political views in Kazakhstan is very limited. The intricacies of politics, established practices and mentality contribute to an overall environment in which participation in political activities becomes a difficult, unrewarding and sometimes dangerous undertaking. Dissent may be subject to criminal prosecution, and critical political statements are often portrayed as a threat to the stability of the State.
In 2002 and 2009, Kazakhstan amended the 1996 Law on Political Parties. The version of the law adopted in 2009 represents an improvement over the previous version, including by reducing the number of members required to establish a political party and introducing a provision allowing a political party to be registered by the State even if errors have been made in its membership lists, provided that such errors do not affect the final number of party members required for State registration. Nevertheless, much remains to be done to ensure its compliance with international standards.
The Law on Political Parties establishes burdensome registration requirements, including a high initial membership threshold, which serves as an obstacle to the formation of small parties, and a requirement to submit an extensive package of documents, the preparation of which is time-consuming and relatively expensive. For example, the establishment of a political party requires an initiative group consisting of at least 1,000 founding members representing two thirds of the regions, the city of republican significance and the capital, and the party must have at least 40,000 members.
22.
According to the reports of the observer mission deployed by the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, the parliamentary elections held in Kazakhstan in 2012 failed to comply with the “fundamental principles of democratic elections”; in particular, examples were provided of the “selective” cancellation of the registration of candidates and one party list¹. Although the ruling Nur Otan party, like its predecessor, the Otan party, enjoys broad public support and has achieved significant economic development since 1991, over the past two decades it has left little room for the expression of dissenting or minority views. There are nine political parties in the country, but only three of them are represented in Parliament. None of them is capable of acting as a genuine opposition party. For example, during the 2011 presidential elections, one of the candidates stated that he had cast his vote for President Nazarbayev.
23.
The Special Rapporteur is particularly concerned that the registration of political parties, i.e. entities that ultimately compete with the Government for power, is the responsibility of executive authorities, namely the Ministry of Justice. Under the Law on Political Parties, the authorities are permitted to repeatedly extend the period for considering an application submitted by a prospective political party, while the law does not establish clear criteria to guide officials responsible for the registration process. Although government representatives assured the Special Rapporteur that individuals may apply to the courts to challenge the Ministry's decisions on registration, his own observations indicate that the level of public confidence in the independence of the judiciary is low. To ensure transparency and accountability within public institutions, the registration and regulation of political parties should be entrusted to an independent body.
24.
Another cause for concern is the grounds for suspending the activities or dissolving a political party. At the end of December 2014, a court suspended the activities of the Communist Party after the competent authority discovered an inaccuracy in its membership list.
25.
On 1 January 2015, the new Criminal Code, the new Code of Administrative Offences and the new Code of Criminal Procedure entered into force. Although some amendments represent a significant step forward in strengthening the guarantees of legality in criminal proceedings, a number of other provisions could result in criminal liability and penalties being imposed for the lawful activities of associations, including political parties. Of particular concern are the provisions of article 174 of the Criminal Code concerning the incitement of social, national, clan, racial, class or religious discord. The Code does not clearly specify what exactly is meant by “incitement of discord”, thereby creating the possibility of arbitrary interpretation extending beyond the scope of article 19, paragraph 3, and article 20 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, as well as article 4 of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. This provision was already contained in the previous version of the Criminal Code; however, in the new version, the maximum penalty was increased from 12 to 20 years of imprisonment. In essence, this vaguely worded provision could be used, for example, to accuse any opposition party attempting to mobilize workers of inciting social discord against employers.
26.
During his visit, the Special Rapporteur met with Vladimir Kozlov, the imprisoned leader of the Alga! party, who had been sentenced to seven and a half years of imprisonment on charges of “inciting discord”. Mr. Kozlov was arrested in January 2012 after publicly expressing support for the oil workers who had participated in demonstrations in the city of Zhanaozen and condemning human rights violations following the events of December 2011. Mr. Kozlov had been involved in opposition political movements since 2000, when he joined the Democratic Choice of Kazakhstan party, which was dissolved by a court decision in January 2005, also, alarmingly, on charges of political extremism, provoking social tension and creating a threat to national security.
27.
At the time of his conviction, Mr. Kozlov had spent seven years unsuccessfully seeking registration for the Alga! party, which had succeeded the Democratic Choice of Kazakhstan party. The court decision in Mr. Kozlov's case was subsequently used as a basis for banning the Alga! party, together with 34 non-State media outlets, on the pretext that they were engaged in “extremist” activities. In practice, it would appear that the only offence committed by those media outlets was reporting on the situation in Zhanaozen.
28.
During the judicial proceedings in Mr. Kozlov's case, a court-appointed expert concluded that Mr. Kozlov had incited social discord because he had allegedly distributed leaflets containing the following text: “Rise from your knees, Kazakh, throw off the tyrant and thief from your neck!” According to the expert's testimony, this act was intended to turn protesters against their employers and the State authorities, since the information contained in the leaflet suggested that, given the difficult living conditions experienced by people in many regions of Kazakhstan, they might join the protests in support of the oil workers. Furthermore, Mr. Kozlov's actions allegedly contributed to the systematic undermining of labour negotiations between employers and employees. A connection was established between Mr. Kozlov and the opposition figure Mukhtar Ablyazov, who is currently under investigation in France on charges of embezzlement.
29.
The Special Rapporteur is seriously concerned that Mr. Kozlov's ordinary political speeches and his participation in the activities of a public association were classified as criminal acts of inciting social hatred. Moreover, the proceedings in Mr. Kozlov's case, particularly the fact that his lawful and peaceful political activities were portrayed in the judgment as a threat to the country's stability, clearly reflect a broader trend towards the marginalization of dissenting political leaders. The suppression of political opposition through such despotic measures is all the more surprising given that the Government of Kazakhstan enjoys considerable public trust and approval.
30.
In the opinion of the Special Rapporteur, article 174 of the new Criminal Code has had a powerful chilling effect on political activity, which appears to be an ineffective and counterproductive way of combating genuine extremism. The dissolution of political groups or the prosecution of their representatives on the above-mentioned vague grounds means that any opposition political party or its members seeking to compete with the ruling party risk being prosecuted for such criminal offences as incitement of discord, “dissemination of false information” or “defamation”.
31.
The already limited opportunities for expressing opposition views are further restricted by the fact that opposition parties do not have full access to the mass media, which are themselves subject to restrictions. In recent months, the offices of several independent newspapers have been closed; in particular, in December 2014, the well-known magazine ADAM bol, which covered political and human rights issues, was closed by court order. The ruling was issued after the magazine published an interview with an opposition leader who had called for military support to be provided to the Ukrainian army to suppress separatists in Ukraine.
32.
The Special Rapporteur recognizes that Kazakhstan is a young, large and diverse country facing unique challenges. Nevertheless, he believes that its current approach to regulating the activities of political parties and political opposition in general leads to the suppression of dissent and pluralism, which may have harmful consequences for development and stability in the long term. Twenty-four years have passed since independence, and it is time for the political system to fully embrace the spirit of pluralism. This will require extensive reforms, beginning with a reorganization of the system for regulating the activities of political parties and a more tolerant attitude towards the expression of dissenting views. At the same time, the Special Rapporteur has no doubt whatsoever that Kazakhstan possesses all the necessary resources and human capital to become a symbol of development and democracy not only in Central Asia, but throughout the world.
_________________________________________________________________
1 See www\.osce.org/odihr/elections/89401?download=true.
B. Trade Unions
33.
In June 2014, a new Law on Trade Unions was adopted in Kazakhstan, and trade unions were given one year to ensure compliance with the new rules. At the time of preparation of the present report, the law had not yet been fully implemented.
34.
In general, the new law provides for the mandatory inclusion of trade unions in regional or sectoral federations. Trade unions are denied the right to freely establish and join labour organizations of their own choosing. These new requirements are inconsistent with international law, under which the right not to belong to a particular association is one of the key components of freedom of association. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the authorities review the new Law on Trade Unions with a view to bringing it into line with international standards, as specifically emphasized by the International Labour Organization in its memorandum containing technical comments on the draft Law on Trade Unions of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
35.
During the visit, the Special Rapporteur was informed that, in previous years, registration had been refused to a number of trade unions, including the Zhanartu trade union, whose registration applications had reportedly been rejected eight times since 2010; the Independent Trade Union of Journalists, which had reportedly been repeatedly denied registration on technical grounds, most recently in November 2014; and the Zhezkazgan trade union, which had unsuccessfully attempted to obtain registration three times in recent years. According to reports, these organizations have yet to submit documents for registration in accordance with the provisions of the new law.
36.
The Special Rapporteur is concerned that the right to strike is restricted by the requirement to undergo mandatory preliminary mediation procedures, without which a strike cannot be recognized as lawful. Furthermore, under the Labour Code, strikes are prohibited in certain sectors, including the railway, transport and oil industries. It also provides employers with the right to terminate the employment contracts of workers participating in strikes declared unlawful. In addition, a new criminal offence consisting of “actions provoking continued participation in an illegal strike” was introduced into the new Criminal Code (article 402). In the view of the Special Rapporteur, the legal framework governing strikes is more geared towards restricting them than facilitating the exercise of the right to freedom of association.
37.
In May 2011, workers at three enterprises in the oil sector began striking in a region known for its extensive development of natural resources (see paragraphs 72–89 below). In August 2011, several months after the first strikes began, Natalia Sokolova, a trade union lawyer who had defended the interests of the striking oil workers and called for changes to the system for calculating workers' wages, was sentenced to six years of imprisonment for “inciting social discord”. The Special Rapporteur is dismayed that charges involving such a vaguely worded offence could be used against a trade union lawyer. Public statements concerning working conditions are essentially one of the main functions of trade unions; public discussion of such issues is also normal practice in a capitalist economy. Ms. Sokolova was released in March 2012; however, the Special Rapporteur is concerned that her arrest and the arrests of several other strike organizers contributed to increased social tension, which ultimately culminated in the tragic events of December 2011.
38.
In the Kazakhstan–2050 Strategy, President Nazarbayev emphasized that one of the most serious challenges facing Kazakhstan was that certain “social groups had not been integrated into the overall modernization process”. Although the unemployment rate in Kazakhstan is reportedly low, significant disparities in welfare levels persist across different regions, despite certain efforts undertaken to address this problem, for example, in the Zhanaozen region. Economic reforms are important in this regard, but they may also prove insufficient to ease social tensions when conflicts arise. In this respect, independent trade unions play a positive role, as they help the authorities establish dialogue with the population in order to identify needs and challenges and find solutions.
C. Public Associations
39.
Under the 1996 Law on Public Associations, all associations are required to obtain State registration. The Special Rapporteur recalls that unregistered associations are protected under international law relating to freedom of association. Creating opportunities for the existence of unregistered associations is all the more important given that article 489 of the new Code of Administrative Offences establishes liability for managing the activities of unregistered public associations, participating in such activities or financing them.
40.
During the visit, the Special Rapporteur was informed about certain public associations, such as the environmental group for the preservation of Kok-Zhailau and the Amanat Aktau and Voice of Aktau groups, which had attempted to support the families of victims of the Zhanaozen crisis but had recently been denied registration, reportedly, according to the version presented by the Government, owing to inaccuracies in the submitted documents. He calls upon the authorities to proactively facilitate the formation of public associations, taking into account their crucial role in promoting human rights and contributing to development.
41.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the fact that the Constitution of Kazakhstan prohibits unlawful State interference in the activities of public associations, but is nevertheless seriously concerned that the same article of the Constitution also refers to unlawful interference by public associations in the activities of the State. The new Criminal Code also warns associations against unlawfully obstructing the lawful activities of State bodies and against committing acts that cause substantial harm to the rights and legitimate interests of citizens or organizations, or to the interests of society (article 403). The concern of the Special Rapporteur was not dispelled by the fact that, as government officials explained to him, this law was intended exclusively for political parties. In his opinion, the wording of article 403 is too vague and allows for broad and subjective interpretation. For example, it is unclear what constitutes “interference in the activities of State bodies” and under what circumstances such interference is considered “unlawful”. He strongly urges the Government to review the above-mentioned provisions to ensure that they do not have negative consequences for members of public associations.
42.
The Special Rapporteur was encouraged by the many human rights defenders and other representatives of civil society organizations whom he met during his visit and who are engaged in crucial work aimed at strengthening the rule of law in Kazakhstan. In this context, the Special Rapporteur is deeply concerned about the situation of Zinaida Mukhortova, a former member of the bar association, who has repeatedly been subjected to compulsory psychiatric treatment over the past four years. The Rapporteur considers it extremely alarming that, since Ms. Mukhortova urged the authorities to investigate cases of possible corruption, she has been placed in psychiatric institutions several times. Furthermore, he is seriously concerned that, following the arrests, many human rights defenders decided to discontinue their human rights activities. The Special Rapporteur emphasizes that human rights defenders play a crucial role in the realization of civil, cultural, economic, political and social rights in any country, and strongly urges the authorities to take appropriate measures without delay to ensure respect for and protection of their rights.
43.
The new Criminal Code provides for a separate criminal offence carrying more severe penalties for persons belonging to the category of leaders of public associations. At the same time, the definition of “leader” is formulated so vaguely that representatives of civil society fear that any member of a public association could be recognized as a leader. The Special Rapporteur does not understand why leaders of public associations are considered more dangerous elements than other persons and why more severe criminal penalties should be applied to them. To his knowledge, no unequivocal link has been established between a person's profession or position and their propensity to commit crimes. Instead, this law appears simply to serve as a means of instilling fear among civil society leaders who dare to criticize the Government and its policies. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the authorities to repeal any laws that discriminate against people on the basis of their membership in an association engaged in peaceful activities.
44.
The Special Rapporteur positively notes the establishment by the Government of an advisory body, or the Platform for Dialogue on the Human Dimension with Non-Governmental Organizations, which is primarily engaged in preparing recommendations for the Government and Parliament. The advisory body, organized under the auspices of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, includes various organizations, including human rights groups and groups known for their critical attitude towards the Government. The participation of civil society in the State decision-making process is an important component of pluralism and democracy and can only serve the interests of Kazakhstan. According to reports, the Government has adopted 168 recommendations made by this body, which indicates that space for dialogue is opening up. At the same time, the Special Rapporteur strongly urges the Government not to limit itself to technical recommendations and to give positive consideration to recommendations addressing systemic shortcomings.
45.
The Special Rapporteur expresses concern that the new grant mechanism, the establishment of which was advocated by the advisory body and which, at the time of preparation of the present report, had received the support of the Ministry of Culture and Sports, may not fully comply with international human rights standards. Article 6 of the draft law on amendments and additions to certain legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan concerning the activities of non-governmental organizations proposes the appointment of an operator to provide grants to public associations and monitor their use. Since the operator is responsible for distributing all grants among public associations — both State and private grants — the entire sector could end up being placed under its complete control. The Special Rapporteur strongly recommends limiting the scope of the draft law to applications for State grants. State authorities should not be able to allocate private, international or foreign funds to public associations. Otherwise, there is an unacceptable risk that funds will be distributed on a subjective and arbitrary basis. The Special Rapporteur also recommends guaranteeing the independence of such an operating institution, for example, by including representatives of civil society in its composition.
D. Religious Associations
46.
Religious pluralism is a distinctive feature of Kazakh society, and both the State and the country's population may justifiably take pride in this tradition of inclusiveness. Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur remains concerned about the numerous legislative provisions that excessively restrict the right to freedom of association in the religious context. The Special Rapporteur supports the recommendations relevant to his mandate made by the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief following his official visit to Kazakhstan in 2014 (see A/HRC/28/66/Add.1). In particular, the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association shares the concerns of the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief regarding the mandatory re-registration requirements established by the 2011 Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations. He agrees that registration should not be compulsory and that unregistered communities should be able to carry out their activities without discrimination or fear of intimidation.
47.
Under the provisions of this Law, religious groups are required to undergo re-registration within a specified period (namely, one year) in order to obtain the status of a registered national, regional or local religious association. Registration of a religious group at the national level requires a membership of at least 5,000 persons; in the case of a regional association, 500 persons are required, while registration of a local religious association may be initiated by at least 50 persons. At the national level, only Sunni Muslims, the Russian Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church are registered, while the remaining communities are recognized only in certain regions or localities. Religious groups without registration are effectively prohibited from performing collective religious functions. At the same time, their followers, even when regularly performing their religious rites in private homes, face the threat of administrative sanctions, as confirmed by official representatives during the Special Rapporteur's visit. In the interests of ensuring compliance with international standards, the Special Rapporteur recommends that the authorities seek assistance from the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe and the Constitutional Council of Kazakhstan. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the establishment of an advisory group comprising representatives of religious associations and government bodies to develop proposals for further improvement of the legislation.
48.
Government representatives explained to the Special Rapporteur that such strict regulation of the activities of religious groups was necessary to protect society from extremism, emphasizing that at least 300 people from Kazakhstan had travelled to Iraq and the Syrian Arab Republic to fight on the side of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant. The Special Rapporteur agrees that extremism is a serious cause for concern. Nevertheless, he emphasizes that extremism is more likely to develop in conditions of significant socio-economic inequality and limited opportunities for citizens to express their grievances. Extremism most often finds support among people who have been driven into desperate circumstances, and the Government should exercise caution to ensure that its policies do not exacerbate their situation. This is precisely what the prohibition of peaceful religious groups risks doing.
49. Officials informed the Special Rapporteur that amendments to the Law on Religious Activity and Religious Associations might be introduced in the future, but that, at present, it appeared necessary to increase the transparency of religious organizations themselves. In the Special Rapporteur’s view, criminal groups would always find ways to circumvent transparency requirements, and the Law on Religious Activity and Religious Associations was unlikely to make a significant contribution to curbing extremism. He also considers that the problem of extremist groups should be addressed through the Criminal Code rather than through the Law on Religious Activity and Religious Associations. While combating criminal activity is one of the State’s primary functions, the Special Rapporteur cautions against adopting any measures to counter extremism and terrorism that may adversely affect freedom of association.²
50. Finally, the Special Rapporteur is concerned that persons performing religious functions, by virtue of which they become more or less visible to the public, are required to register as “missionaries”. In particular, the Special Rapporteur was informed that the adoption of the Law on Religious Activity and Religious Associations had had negative consequences for Jehovah’s Witnesses, who, until then, reportedly had not encountered significant obstacles in exercising their rights to freedom of association and freedom of religion or belief. The Special Rapporteur would like to draw attention to the case of a representative of the Christian Centre of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Kazakhstan, a Russian citizen who had been residing in Kazakhstan for more than ten years. In November 2013, he was charged with engaging in illegal missionary activity on the grounds that he had participated in a peaceful weekly religious meeting of Jehovah’s Witnesses. The Special Rapporteur was informed of several other cases in which substantial fines had been imposed and documents confiscated from individuals for engaging in “missionary activity” without registration.
51. As officials informed the Special Rapporteur, Jehovah’s Witnesses do not always enjoy the support of all segments of society. Nevertheless, this in no way justifies restricting their rights under international law. The Special Rapporteur sees a certain contradiction in the fact that, on the one hand, they are portrayed as a group isolated from society, while, on the other hand, they are prevented from gathering together and openly discussing their religious beliefs with relatives, friends or neighbours. He emphasizes that State authorities have an obligation to take proactive measures to protect everyone from all forms of stigmatization or discrimination and to ensure that everyone is able to enjoy their rights and freedoms. He strongly urges the authorities to meet with representatives of Jehovah’s Witnesses and any other religious groups in order to discuss how to ensure the exercise of their rights.
² See the report of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of human rights while countering terrorism (A/61/267).
III. Freedom of Peaceful Assembly
A. Exercise of the Right to Freedom of Peaceful Assembly
1. Legislation
52. The right to assemble peacefully and to hold meetings, rallies and demonstrations, marches and pickets is guaranteed by the Constitution. In practice, however, the Government’s approach to regulating freedom of assembly deprives this right of any real meaning. Under the 1995 Law on the Procedure for Organizing and Holding Peaceful Assemblies, Rallies, Marches, Pickets and Demonstrations, authorized representatives of labour collectives, public associations or individual groups of citizens of Kazakhstan who have reached the age of 18 are required to obtain prior authorization from the local authorities no later than ten days before the scheduled date of the event. Such requirements are inconsistent with international standards, according to which peaceful assemblies do not require authorization and everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association (Human Rights Council resolution 15/21).
53. Furthermore, under the law, the maslikhats and akimats, which are the local representative and executive authorities, respectively, are empowered to designate specific locations for holding authorized assemblies. These locations, which are generally situated in remote areas, deprive organizers and participants of the opportunity to choose a gathering place that they consider most suitable for expressing their aspirations and grievances.
54. During his visit, the Special Rapporteur visited Saryarka Square, the only place in Almaty where assemblies are permitted. The square is located approximately seven kilometres from the city centre, which deprives demonstrators of the opportunity to express their views and opinions in places where their intended audience, such as government officials or fellow citizens in the city’s most densely populated areas, can see and hear them. The Special Rapporteur is seriously concerned that, in a city with a population of approximately 1.5 million, the only designated assembly venue is barely larger than a football field and is situated in a residential area relatively far from the city centre.
55. In these circumstances, it is hardly surprising that, according to the Ministry of Justice, 324 of the 497 assemblies recorded between 2012 and 2014 were deemed “unauthorized”. Data submitted by the Government also indicate a trend in recent years towards a decline in the number of applications to hold assemblies, particularly those concerning civil and political rights. Officials in Aktau informed the Special Rapporteur that no applications to hold assemblies had been received in 2013 or 2014.
56. Holding an unauthorized assembly may entail serious criminal liability. Article 400 of the new Criminal Code establishes penalties for participating in “illegal” assemblies that result in “substantial harm to the rights and legitimate interests of citizens”. Although the penalties were reduced in the new Criminal Code, they still appear to be disproportionately severe and may include imprisonment.
57. The Criminal Code also prohibits providing “assistance” to participants in “illegal” assemblies, including through “means of communication”. The Special Rapporteur considers that this provision excessively restricts the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, association and expression, since, under it, even disseminating information about a protest could potentially constitute a criminal offence. In fact, this provision appears to be intended to prevent activists from using social networks and other means of communication for organizational purposes. For the same reasons, the Special Rapporteur is concerned about the amendments made to the Law on Communications in April 2014, under which the prosecution authorities are empowered to suspend the operation of any communications network, including the Internet, without a court order.
58. The Special Rapporteur emphasizes that, although the right to freedom of peaceful assembly may be subject to certain restrictions permitted under international human rights law, such restrictions must remain exceptional and must not undermine the very essence of this right. The Special Rapporteur gained the impression that, during his meetings with government representatives, greater emphasis was often placed on restrictions rather than on the rights themselves. In seeking to justify the numerous restrictions imposed on assemblies, the authorities frequently referred to problems with street traffic and the need to protect the “rights of others”. Government representatives also informed the Special Rapporteur that restrictions on the right to peaceful assembly were necessary as a means of preventing mass disturbances and cited recent events in Ukraine as an example. The Special Rapporteur considers this justification unconvincing. Kazakhstan has a completely different political, economic and social context.
59. The Special Rapporteur sees this as a misinterpretation of the concept of human rights. Although certain restrictions are permitted under paragraph 4 of Human Rights Council resolution 15/21, the Siracusa Principles on the Limitation and Derogation Provisions in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights provide a clear framework for determining the restrictions permitted under international human rights law. In particular, the scope of any limitation referred to in the Covenant must not be interpreted in such a way as to undermine the essence of the right concerned, but must be interpreted strictly and in a manner favourable to the rights in question (see E/CN.4/1985/4, annex, paras. 2–3). In this context, the Special Rapporteur emphasizes that the right to peaceful assembly should not be made dependent on prior authorization by the authorities; at most, its exercise may be subject to a notification procedure, the purpose of which is to ensure police protection for demonstrators and passers-by.
60. In the Special Rapporteur’s view, given the restrictions requiring authorized assemblies to be held only in specially designated locations and subject to obtaining State authorization, the right to freedom of assembly is treated more as a privilege or favour granted by the Government than as a right. Although the right to peaceful assembly may legitimately be restricted in specific circumstances, for a limited period and in particular places, a ban on holding assemblies in all locations except one designated venue constitutes a violation of international human rights law.
61. Moreover, in November 2014, when considering the case of Bakhytzhan Toregozhina, the Human Rights Committee concluded that, in her case, the provisions of Kazakh legislation had violated the right to peaceful assembly and instructed the Government to review its legislation, particularly the Law on the Procedure for Organizing and Holding Peaceful Assemblies, Rallies, Marches, Pickets and Demonstrations (see CCPR/C/112/D/2137/2012, annex, para. 9).
The Special Rapporteur urges the Government of Kazakhstan to implement that decision promptly and effectively and to take into account all other views of the treaty bodies that form an integral part of the human rights protection mechanism.
62. The Special Rapporteur supports the conclusions of the Human Rights Committee and notes that the Government itself has repeatedly acknowledged that the provisions of the Law on Assemblies are inconsistent with international standards. For example, in 2007, the Human Rights Commission, acting as an advisory body to the President, concluded in its baseline report on the human rights situation in Kazakhstan that the 1995 law was not in conformity with international standards. Among other things, it noted that the law failed to distinguish between participants in an assembly and observers or accidental passers-by, as a result of which the latter were often subjected to arrest.
63. In 2010, during the universal periodic review of Kazakhstan, the authorities undertook to make efforts to develop and implement, as soon as possible, a new law on the right to assembly containing fewer requirements regarding prior registration and other formalities (see A/HRC/14/10, para. 97). This commendable commitment was reaffirmed during the universal periodic review of Kazakhstan in 2014, when the authorities announced that the concept for developing a new draft law on peaceful assemblies and rallies was being considered by the competent State bodies with the participation of civil society (see A/HRC/WG.6/20/KAZ/1, para. 120). In preparation for the Special Rapporteur’s visit, the Ministry of Justice prepared a report stating that the Government had decided to draft a bill amending certain legislative acts relating to ensuring security during mass sporting, cultural and entertainment events and other public events.
64. The Special Rapporteur welcomes these developments but considers that the promised reforms should be implemented more expeditiously. In particular, he notes that, during his visit, none of the government representatives was able to provide updated information on the status of the proposed amendments to the Law on Assemblies.
65. The Special Rapporteur fears that such strict regulation of peaceful dissent has contributed to an overall decline in open civic engagement, as illustrated by the decrease in the number of applications to hold assemblies. As a result, there is an increasing perception that mounting discontent may escalate and play into the hands of followers of extremist ideologies. He recalls that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly is extremely important also because it provides people with an opportunity to express their accumulated grievances peacefully. For this reason, this right is essentially a key guarantee of social stability and harmony.
66. In view of the above, the Special Rapporteur urges the authorities to consider fundamentally changing their approach to regulating peaceful assemblies, beginning with the abolition of the requirement to obtain prior authorization and allowing assemblies to be held not only in specially designated “protest locations”. The Special Rapporteur reiterates that he stands ready to provide the authorities with any assistance they may require in drafting a new law.
2. Practice
67. During his visit, the Special Rapporteur learned that several dozen people had planned to hold peaceful assemblies between 24 and 27 January 2015 in ten different locations. In nine cases, the authorities did not permit the participants to hold assemblies at the locations of their choice; they were allowed to use only the specially designated venues. The organizers of the tenth assembly ultimately decided to cancel it. In addition, the Special Rapporteur received reports that some participants in the planned protests had been subjected to “preventive detention”.
68. In some cases, the authorities followed the excessively broad provisions of the law regulating freedom of peaceful assembly so blindly that this led to absurd situations. For example, the police repeatedly used force to disperse “one-person protests”, usually organized by members of the environmental movement “Antiheptyl”. A peaceful citizen who attempted to submit a petition in support of the editorial staff of the closed newspaper ADAM Bol was arrested on 2 February 2015, allegedly for violating the Law on Assemblies. On 6 October 2013, the police dispersed dozens of peaceful participants in a race organized at one of the stadiums in Almaty under the slogan “Kazakhs for Sport”, because the event had not been authorized. On 31 October 2013, on the same grounds, a costume party celebrating Halloween, organized through a social network by a group of fifteen peaceful students in Pavlodar, was dispersed. On 5 March 2014, the authorities used force against a group of young children and their parents who had staged a peaceful demonstration against forced evictions in Astana. These are just a few examples of those brought to the attention of the Special Rapporteur. The Special Rapporteur considers that, in all these cases, the authorities’ actions violated international law and standards.
69. Although officials assured the Special Rapporteur that local authorities did not differentiate between assemblies on the basis of their subject matter or message, reports from civil society groups indicate otherwise. Applications to hold assemblies are considered differently depending on their content; protests concerning potentially controversial issues are less likely to be authorized. For example, a peaceful demonstration against the proposed deportation from France of opposition leader Mukhtar Ablyazov, held in Astana on 2 September 2013, was promptly dispersed by the police. A month later, however, a protest in which participants called on the French authorities not to release Mr. Ablyazov from prison until Kazakhstan’s official extradition request had been considered took place without any police interference, in a manner consistent with the position adopted by the authorities themselves.
70. The Special Rapporteur is also concerned about the practice of placing individuals in “preventive detention” or issuing “warnings”. Government representatives justify the use of such measures by describing them as a service provided to the public, intended to “inform” citizens about the provisions of the law. In the Special Rapporteur’s view, however, this constitutes a form of intimidation. Moreover, it represents a flagrant violation of the right to peaceful assembly, as well as the rights to security and liberty.
71. Despite the numerous challenges arising in ensuring the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, the Special Rapporteur is pleased to note that violence and the excessive use of force against protesters are rare in Kazakhstan, with the dramatic events in Zhanaozen standing out as a clear exception to the general pattern. In particular, tear gas appears never, or almost never, to be used during mass events in Kazakhstan. Furthermore, an official order categorically prohibits the detention of assembly organizers directly at the scene of an event, in order to avoid provoking unrest,³ although the Special Rapporteur was informed of repeated cases in which participants in assemblies were forcibly placed in police vans. This demonstrates a high level of responsibility on the part of all concerned, which should be used by the authorities as a basis for further expanding democratic space.
³ See Order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs No. 665 of 6 December 2000.
B. The Zhanaozen Crisis
72. The Special Rapporteur visited the city of Zhanaozen, which became the epicentre of a seven-month oil workers’ strike that lasted from May to December 2011. On 16 December 2011, clashes with the police resulted in the deaths or injuries of numerous protesters. During the first weeks following the incident, the authorities issued two official statements. According to the statement made by the Prosecutor General on 25 January 2012, “64 persons sustained gunshot wounds as a result of the clashes, 14 persons died (the deaths of two other persons were unrelated to the mass disturbances), and 35 police officers sustained various bodily injuries”. According to the second statement by the Prosecutor General, published on 22 February 2012, “12 persons died from gunshot wounds, two persons died from injuries sustained, one person died from burns during the looting of the Sulpak shopping centre, and the death of another person, who died from shotgun wounds, was unrelated to the mass disturbances”.
73. The strike began in May 2011, several weeks after the presidential elections, at the initiative of oil workers from Karazhanbasmunai JSC, Ozenmunaigas JSC and ERSAI Caspian Contractor LLP. The workers demanded an increase in wages and an end to company interference in trade union activities. Several weeks after the strike began, local courts declared the protest action illegal on the grounds that the assemblies were being held at hazardous facilities in violation of the law. As a result, hundreds of striking workers were dismissed for participating in such “illegal” assemblies, which, it should be emphasized, were entirely peaceful. Nevertheless, the strike continued and was also accompanied by public gatherings in the main square of Zhanaozen.
74. In December 2011, the local authorities decided to hold celebrations marking Independence Day in the same square where workers had been on strike for several months. On 16 December 2011, the day on which Kazakhstan celebrates its independence, clashes occurred between a group of protesters and participants in the festive event. According to reports, police officers intervened and pushed the striking workers into a corner of the square before taking up their initial positions. Shortly thereafter, a group of young men, some of whom were wearing jackets bearing the insignia of oil companies, reportedly began destroying equipment used for the Independence Day celebrations. Several objects were allegedly set on fire.
75. In response, police officers opened fire on the crowd with live ammunition. Video footage posted on social networking websites⁴ shows police officers firing indiscriminately and shooting unarmed demonstrators in the back as they retreated from the square.
76. The Special Rapporteur discussed the Zhanaozen crisis with officials of the General Prosecutor’s Office, persons who had lost their loved ones and numerous workers who had taken part in the demonstration on 16 December 2011. He gained a clear and disturbing impression that, more than three years after the tragic events, the wounds had still not healed.
77. The Special Rapporteur expresses his appreciation to the Government for its efforts to increase the resources available in the region, which may help address some of the root causes underlying the 2011 strikes. He notes that most of the workers who participated in the strike were in paid employment at the time of his visit. He also notes that virtually all persons convicted in connection with the mass disturbances (see para. 84 below) had by then been granted parole. However, this is not enough.
78. One of the most important steps towards improving the situation is to establish exactly what happened in Zhanaozen. To date, conflicting information remains concerning the events of 16 December 2011, particularly with regard to the actions of the workers, the role of possible provocateurs and the police response. It remains unclear who participated in the violence, how police officers distinguished between aggressive individuals and peaceful demonstrators and passers-by celebrating Independence Day, what circumstances prompted the police officers to open fire with the intention to kill, and who gave the police officers that order.
79. In view of the lack of a clear understanding of the sequence of events, the Special Rapporteur supports the call by OHCHR for an independent international investigation into what happened. Such an independent investigation would provide an opportunity to shed comprehensive light on the circumstances of the crisis, restore confidence in the justice system and enable victims to overcome their trauma, including through moral compensation.
80. The investigation should also establish what happened in the town of Shetpe, located several kilometres from Zhanaozen, where one person was killed as a result of clashes between the police, workers and local residents on 17 December 2011. Dozens of other people sustained gunshot wounds. Workers and local residents reportedly demanded that communications with Zhanaozen be restored, since telecommunications had allegedly been cut off and a number of websites had been blocked for several days following the clashes there.
81. Upon completion of the investigation, the Government should hold accountable those responsible for their actions in Zhanaozen, including State officials. Although five police officers were convicted of abuse of power following the events of 16 December, none was convicted of killing demonstrators. Moreover, the overwhelming majority of police officers who were on duty that day continued to perform their duties.
82. Furthermore, it is striking that no charges were brought against any of the senior officials who directed the actions of the police. This is particularly concerning since, as President Nazarbayev stated on 21 December 2011, the workers’ demands were justified.⁵ According to reports,⁶ during the trial the prosecutors stated that the police officers should have used alternative methods to suppress the mass disturbances.
83. The Special Rapporteur was informed that the administration of Mangystau Region had established a special fund to assist those affected by the events in Zhanaozen. Several persons who sustained bodily injuries in 2011, including accidental passers-by, have since been unable to find employment. The Special Rapporteur urges the Government of Kazakhstan to take measures to ensure that, following the ratification of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, victims have additional opportunities to seek compensation for damages.
84. According to civil society organizations, at least 700 people were arrested in the days following the clashes. Although the overwhelming majority of them were released in the following days, 37 oil workers were charged with various offences, including “organizing and participating in mass disturbances”. Among them was the strike leader, Roza Tuletaeva, who was released on parole in November 2014. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the steps taken by the authorities to grant parole to convicted workers and create employment opportunities for them in the interests of their social rehabilitation and reintegration. At the same time, he is deeply concerned that, during the trial, almost all of the 37 defendants wholly or partially recanted their statements, alleging that they had been subjected to physical and psychological abuse while in police custody. In particular, allegations were made of such forms of ill-treatment as severe beatings, suffocation and threats against relatives, all of which were clearly intended to force detainees to testify against themselves or others. Moreover, most of the defendants who had pleaded guilty subsequently stated that they had been subjected to torture or other forms of ill-treatment. On 20 December 2011, one of the detainees, Bazarbay Kenzhebayev, who had been arrested four days earlier, died from injuries apparently sustained while in custody.
85. Many of the victims and survivors whom the Special Rapporteur met in Zhanaozen expressed their fears of being subjected to reprisals for meeting with him. For example, the above-mentioned incident involving surveillance in Aktau occurred on the eve of a meeting with sources concerning the 2011 events in Zhanaozen.
86. The Government established a task force to investigate allegations of torture and ill-treatment of detainees, but it was composed of representatives of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the General Prosecutor’s Office and was therefore not sufficiently independent to conduct a proper investigation. The expert group found that no crimes had been committed against the detainees, and, as a result, no one was held criminally responsible on charges of torture. Although officials repeatedly stated that the trial of the workers had been transparent, this is insufficient to meet international standards relating to the right to a fair trial, which require thorough, independent and impartial investigations into all allegations of ill-treatment.
87. Kazakhstan’s recent decision to pursue a policy of zero tolerance for torture and the establishment of a national preventive mechanism are commendable. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the Government to apply these mechanisms retroactively and to review the convictions handed down against the Zhanaozen workers. This would make it possible to ensure that the convictions were not based on evidence obtained under coercion and to ensure that the alleged perpetrators are held accountable.
88. In addition, the Special Rapporteur is alarmed by the fact that most of those convicted in connection with the Zhanaozen events were known to be among the most active organizers of the 2011 strikes. They had been engaged in legitimate public activities and should not be held responsible for what happened.
89. The tragic events in Zhanaozen had a serious negative impact on attitudes towards peaceful protests in Kazakhstan and triggered a wave of legal reforms that appear to have pursued one single objective: prohibiting assemblies under any pretext. It is also extremely important to change public perceptions of freedom of peaceful assembly in general and of the Zhanaozen strikers in particular. Since the media in some cases portrayed demonstrators as criminals, alcoholics and drug addicts, the authorities have an important role to play in ensuring that persons exercising their rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association are protected from all forms of stigmatization, intimidation, threats or defamation. In 2011, an opportunity to initiate dialogue between the striking workers, company management and State representatives was missed. In this regard, it is extremely important to restore mutual understanding and confidence in the authorities in order to avoid repeating past mistakes. The Special Rapporteur recognizes that creating conditions conducive to protest activities may prove challenging, but strongly urges the Government to undertake this task with determination, using the same strength and energy with which Kazakhstan has pursued its economic development since 1991.
⁴ See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gX8I2JzFfpo.
⁵ See www.kt.kz/rus/state/kulibaev_budet_osvobozhden_ot_dolzhnosti_glavi_fnb_samrukkazina_1153549470.html (the article is available only in Russian).
⁶ See http://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/prokuror-politseyskie-mogli-oboytisdubinkami-podavlenii-213066/ (the article is available only in Russian).
IV. Conclusions and Recommendations
90. During the visit of the Special Rapporteur, government representatives repeatedly invoked the rule of law in an attempt to justify restrictions on freedom of peaceful assembly and association. In the Special Rapporteur’s view, however, in practice the Government’s policy is driven more by the principle of the “rule by law”.
91. The Special Rapporteur recalls that the law is an expression of the will of the people and is therefore intended to serve the interests of the people. The principle of the rule of law implies that everyone is free to exercise their human rights without prior authorization from the State authorities. Otherwise, the principle of the rule of law may turn into the arbitrary norm of the “rule by law”, threatening to undermine the very essence of these rights. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the Government of Kazakhstan to pay attention not only to the technical aspects of its human rights obligations but also to their spirit. Although the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association are not absolute, their essence must not be jeopardized by restrictions imposed by the State that are not only unlawful but also disproportionate to the aim pursued. Restrictions are compatible with international human rights law only if they are clearly defined and narrowly interpreted.
92. The Special Rapporteur is concerned that the State’s current approach to the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association has had a negative impact on public discourse. Opinions that differ from or contradict generally accepted views are often regarded as a potential source of instability rather than as a means of strengthening the rule of law. Since 1991, Kazakhstan has come a long way. In seeking to expand opportunities for its population, the main emphasis has been placed on economic reforms, but the aspirations of the younger generation, which did not experience the harsh realities of the Soviet era, extend far beyond that. It is therefore entirely natural that they wish to take their society’s future into their own hands and participate in public life. As government representatives noted, Kazakhstan has experienced rapid economic development, which, in the context of financial difficulties and geopolitical changes, may be accompanied by social upheaval. Such concerns are justified and can only be addressed by ensuring that legislation complies with international human rights standards and by expanding democratic space. Creating an enabling environment for civil society is an indispensable means not only of continuing ongoing reform processes with broader public support but also of laying a strong institutional foundation for a representative, responsive and accountable system of governance capable of shielding society from excessive upheaval. All change is difficult. Reforms require a certain degree of political courage and will, but the Special Rapporteur is convinced that Kazakhstan is capable of ensuring respect for the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association within a short period of time.
93. The Special Rapporteur proposes that the authorities ensure the wide dissemination of the present report so that it may serve as a starting point for initiating a public dialogue on expanding civic space. The action plan on human rights up to 2020 being developed by Kazakhstan, which will be aimed at implementing the recommendations made following the universal periodic review, should set out, taking into account the views of civil society, comprehensive measures necessary to bring laws and practices into conformity with the various recommendations of international human rights mechanisms.
94. Although the present report identifies certain shortcomings in the implementation of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association, the Special Rapporteur would like to reiterate that both his review and his recommendations should be viewed in the spirit of constructive dialogue. Since gaining independence, Kazakhstan has made tremendous progress in the economic sphere, and the Special Rapporteur firmly believes that the country is capable of achieving similar successes in the area of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association. The Special Rapporteur reiterates that he is always ready to assist the authorities in achieving these objectives and remains open to the possibility of conducting a follow-up mission and providing technical assistance in drafting new laws or amendments.
95. The Special Rapporteur makes the following general recommendations:
a) Recognize, de jure and de facto, that the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association play a crucial role in promoting pluralism and fostering tolerance and open-mindedness, thereby ensuring respect for and protection of opposing, unconventional or minority views and beliefs;
b) Ensure that no one is held criminally liable for exercising the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association and that no one is subjected to threats of violence or violence, harassment, persecution, intimidation or reprisals;
c) Ensure that any restrictions on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association pursue a legitimate aim, are prescribed by law, are proportionate to the aim pursued and are necessary in a democratic society;
d) Ensure that victims of violations and abuses of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association have access to an effective remedy;
e) Implement recommendations concerning freedom of association and freedom of peaceful assembly, including recommendations contained in the views adopted by United Nations treaty bodies in connection with individual communications.
96. With regard to the right to freedom of association, the Special Rapporteur urges the competent authorities to:
a) Provide a clear and narrow definition of the offence of incitement to discord (article 174 of the new Criminal Code), in order to bring it into conformity with international human rights law and avoid any negative consequences for the exercise of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association;
b) Amend the Law on Political Parties in order to expand opportunities for citizens to establish political parties, including by reducing the number of persons required to form a political party and establishing clear time limits for registration, with registration applications to be considered by an independent body;
c) Ensure that people are able to establish and join trade unions of their choice, including by abolishing mandatory State registration;
d) Ensure that the Law on Public Associations provides for the possibility of unregistered associations to operate freely and that any amendments concerning access to funding do not affect the independence of associations, including by limiting the scope of the proposed new grant-making mechanism exclusively to public funds;
e) Repeal the provision under which “unlawful interference by members of public associations in the activities of State bodies” constitutes an offence (article 403 of the new Criminal Code);
f) Review the Law on Religious Activity and Religious Associations so that religious associations may be established and operate freely without prior State consent.
97. With regard to the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, the Special Rapporteur urges the competent authorities to:
a) Adopt, within clearly established time limits and with the participation of civil society, a new law on public assemblies that complies with international human rights standards. The new law should abolish the procedure for obtaining prior State authorization to hold an assembly; provide a clear and narrow definition of the limited number of locations where assemblies are prohibited; explicitly state that the responsibility for ensuring public order and security rests exclusively with the State; and abolish criminal liability for “participation in an illegal assembly” (article 400 of the Criminal Code);
b) Respect the rights to security and liberty and the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty, including by ensuring that no one is subjected to “preventive detention” for exercising their right to peaceful assembly;
c) Ensure that law enforcement officers resort to non-violent means of restraint before using force and, in cases where the use of force is unavoidable, exercise restraint, guided by the seriousness of the offence and the objectives pursued, and acting with due respect for human life;
d) Conduct an independent international investigation into the tragic events in Zhanaozen and Shetpe, with a view to holding accountable those responsible for human rights violations and compensating the victims;
e) Consider the possibility of granting early release to Vladimir Kozlov for “good behaviour”, as provided for under national legislation;
f) Review the convictions handed down against the Zhanaozen oil workers who claim that they were forced to make confessions through torture or ill-treatment.
98. In addition, the Special Rapporteur urges the competent authorities to:
a) Ensure that the recommendations of the Human Dimension Dialogue Platform are fully taken into account, in order to expand opportunities for civil society participation in public affairs;
b) Increase the budget and strengthen the independence of the national human rights institution.
Improve consistency in terminology and styleClarify the report’s recommendation hierarchy
Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages