Promotion and Protection of All Human Rights, Civil, Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Including the Right to Development
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education, Kishore Singh, dated 11 May 2012
Download
| General Assembly | Distr.: General 11 May 2012 Russian Original: English |
|---|
Human Rights CouncilTwentieth sessionAgenda item 3
Addendum
Mission to Kazakhstan*
Download
Summary
At the invitation of the Government, the Special Rapporteur on the right to education, Kishore Singh, visited Kazakhstan from 12 to 20 September 2011. During this visit, the Special Rapporteur obtained first-hand information on the situation regarding the right to education in the country.
By ratifying treaties such as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Kazakhstan has undertaken unequivocal obligations to protect and promote the right to education. These obligations are reflected in the Constitution of Kazakhstan, which guarantees everyone the right to free education. The Special Rapporteur acknowledges that, thanks to long-term investments in education and the country's commitment to providing universal free primary and secondary education, Kazakhstan has achieved almost universal enrolment of children in the primary and secondary education systems, as well as high literacy rates. The Special Rapporteur also welcomes the plans to expand preschool education and modernize the country's higher education system. At the same time, he notes that important challenges remain to be addressed with regard to improving the quality of education and promoting equal opportunities in education. In particular, he emphasizes the need for further investment in multilingual education, the need to allocate resources towards integrating persons with disabilities into mainstream education, and the need to ensure education for migrants and refugees residing in the country.
________________________ * The summary of this report is being circulated in all official languages. The report itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is being circulated only in the language in which it was submitted and in Russian.
Annex
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education on his mission to Kazakhstan (12–20 September 2011)
Contents
I. Introduction II. Legal framework A. International legal framework/international obligations B. Domestic legal framework and national policy III. General situation of education in Kazakhstan A. Primary and secondary education B. Preschool education C. Technical and vocational education D. Higher education E. Striving for excellence in education IV. Key challenges A. Promoting equal opportunities in education B. Addressing the imperative challenges of improving quality C. Financing of education V. Conclusions and recommendations
I. Introduction
1. In the present report, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to education, Kishore Singh, presents the findings of his mission to Kazakhstan, undertaken from 12 to 20 September 2011, and examines the situation regarding the right to education in the country.
2. During his visit, the Special Rapporteur met with officials from various government bodies, including the Minister of Education and Science, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, the Human Rights Commissioner of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights, the Executive Secretary of the Assembly of the People of Kazakhstan and the Deputy Akim of Almaty. He also met with various representatives of United Nations agencies and civil society organizations working in Kazakhstan.
3. The Special Rapporteur visited universities in Astana and Almaty, as well as primary and secondary schools in these cities and in rural areas of Almaty Region. He also visited a technical school and special schools for children with disabilities and children with behavioural problems. During his visits to educational institutions, he met with directors, teachers, support staff and students.
4. The Special Rapporteur expressed his appreciation to the Government of Kazakhstan for its invitation and comprehensive cooperation during his mission. He also extends his gratitude to the Regional Office for Central Asia of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and the United Nations Country Team in Kazakhstan. Finally, he would like to express his appreciation to all those who took the time to meet with him and share their views and experiences in the field of education.
5. Over the past two decades, Kazakhstan has demonstrated unprecedented rates of political and economic development. The country has undertaken commitments to protect and promote the right to education as provided for in the international human rights treaties it has ratified. By recognizing in its Constitution the right to free primary and secondary education, the country demonstrates very high literacy rates and ensures virtually universal enrolment of children in primary and secondary education.
6. The country's continuing high rates of economic growth provide an excellent opportunity to invest substantially more resources in the education system, which would seemingly help it ensure higher-quality education and avoid the exclusion of marginalized groups. In particular, attention needs to be paid to the integration of students living in poverty and, given the pronounced multi-ethnic and multilingual nature of Kazakhstan's population, to promoting the development of multilingual education. In addition, special measures need to be taken to ensure adequate educational opportunities for persons with disabilities, as well as migrants and refugees.
II. Legal framework
A. International legal framework/international obligations
7. Kazakhstan is a party to a number of core international human rights treaties: the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment and its Optional Protocol; the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination; the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women; and the Convention on the Rights of the Child and its Optional Protocols on the involvement of children in armed conflict and on the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography. Kazakhstan has signed, but has not yet ratified, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. All these treaties contain specific provisions on education and impose on the State an obligation to take all necessary measures to protect, respect and promote the right to education for all persons residing in its territory, on a non-discriminatory basis.
8. Kazakhstan is not a party to the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families, which provides, inter alia, for the right of access to education. Such education should be free and compulsory, at least at the primary level; the necessary opportunities for technical and vocational training should be created; and higher education should be accessible on an equal basis with nationals of the State of employment. Kazakhstan has confirmed that it does not intend to ratify this Convention in the near future owing to the long-term financial consequences that may arise from its implementation.¹
9. Pursuant to paragraph 3 of article 4 of the Constitution, international treaties ratified by Kazakhstan take precedence over national legislation and are directly applicable, except where the international treaty provides that a law must be enacted for its application. On 10 July 2008, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan adopted a normative resolution on the direct applicability of the provisions of international treaties in national courts and tribunals, according to which judges are required to be guided by the provisions of international treaties to which Kazakhstan is a party.²
10. In accordance with domestic legislation and international human rights treaties, the State is under an obligation to ensure and promote education for persons residing in its territory on a non-discriminatory basis.
____________________¹ Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review: Kazakhstan – views on conclusions and/or recommendations, voluntary commitments and replies presented by the State under review (A/HRC/14/10/Add.1), p. 2, first paragraph.
² National report submitted by Kazakhstan in accordance with the universal periodic review mechanism (A/HRC/WG.6/7/KAZ/1), para. 22.
B. Domestic legal framework and national policy
11. The Constitution, adopted by national referendum on 30 August 1995,³ has supreme legal force and direct effect throughout the territory of the Republic. Articles 19 and 30 of the Constitution guarantee all citizens of Kazakhstan the right to receive education in their mother tongue, the right to free and compulsory secondary education in State schools, and the right to free higher education on a competitive basis. Free education in private schools is provided in accordance with the terms and procedures established by law.
12. The National Human Rights Action Plan for 2009–2012 is aimed at strengthening the national system for the promotion and protection of human rights and raising public awareness of human rights and the mechanisms for their protection. The Plan identifies a set of specific measures to address gaps in national legislation and practice and to improve coordination between government institutions and non-governmental organizations working in the field of human rights protection.⁴
13. The general legislative framework is determined by the constitutional provisions concerning education and by two principal laws regulating educational activities in the country, namely the Law “On Education” of 7 July 1992 (as amended on 27 July 2007) and the Law “On Higher Education” of 1993. These laws define State policy in the field of education, the objectives and principles of education, the administrative structure and the system of private schools.⁵
14. The Law “On Education” provides for the following levels of education: preschool, secondary, secondary vocational and technical, higher and postgraduate education. Secondary education comprises three stages: (a) primary education (a four-year programme of study); (b) basic general education (a five-year programme of study); and (c) general secondary education (a two-year programme of study). The Law regulates public relations in the field of education, defines the basic principles for formulating national policy in this area and aims to ensure the protection of citizens' constitutional right to education. According to article 23, “preschool preparation for children aged 5(6) years is compulsory and is provided within the family, in a preschool organization or at school as part of the general education programme. It is free of charge in State educational organizations.” The Law also introduced a new model of higher professional education comprising three levels: general higher education (four-year programmes leading to a bachelor's degree), specialized higher education with a four-year period of study, and postgraduate professional education (two-year programmes leading to a master's degree).⁶
____________________³ The Constitution was amended by the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 7 October 1998, 21 May 2007 and 2 February 2011; A/HRC/WG.6/7/KAZ/1, para. 118.
⁴ Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review: Kazakhstan (A/HRC/14/10), para. 12.
⁵ UNESCO, “A compilation of background information about educational legislation, governance, management and financing structures and processes: Central Asia”, document 2009/ED/EFA/MRT/PI/23, p. 27.
⁶ Ibid.
15. In accordance with the two aforementioned laws, subsequent regulatory documents were also adopted, including State Standards of Higher Education and regulatory legal acts governing the activities of preschool educational organizations (Order No. 708 of the Ministry of Education and Science), which were approved on 10 July 2000.⁷ With regard to children's rights, an important role is assigned to the Committee for the Protection of Children's Rights, established on 21 February 2006 under the auspices of the Ministry of Education and Science.⁸ The Committee is competent to consider individual complaints submitted by members of the public concerning children's rights, as well as matters relating to the quality of educational services for children provided by State and public institutions. In order to ensure independent, and therefore favourable, conditions for the performance of its mandate, it is important to emphasize the powers granted to it.⁹
16. The implementation of relevant education laws, as well as the strategic planning, management and financing of the education system, including the preparation of draft education budgets, are carried out under the supervision of the Ministry of Education and Science, which is the competent central authority.¹⁰ In accordance with the Law “On Education”, the Ministry's functions include: determining and implementing State education policy; preparing draft resolutions on State funding in the field of education; preparing draft State educational standards and curricula and study plans and adopting them; preparing State orders for the professional training of specialists; assisting in the organization of the educational process in the Kazakh language; and concluding international agreements on education.¹¹
17. The Ministry of Education and Science comprises several committees and two departments (administration and finance). The committees are directly responsible for the activities of the respective sectors. The Committee on Education is responsible for managing the education system, preparing proposals for financing educational institutions from the State and regional budgets, developing educational standards and programmes, and appointing heads of higher education institutions. Article 36 of the Law “On Education” guarantees the principle of self-governance of educational institutions.¹²
18. The National Strategic Plan for the Development of Education is set out in detail in the State Programme for the Development of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2011–2020.¹³ In the context of modernization efforts, the main objective of the Plan is to enhance the competitiveness of education and develop human potential by ensuring access to quality education in the interests of sustainable economic growth.¹⁴ The tasks set out in the Plan include, inter alia, the transition to a 12-year education model, improvement of the system of inclusive education in schools and the updating of educational content. It is also geared towards integration into the European Higher Education Area.¹⁵ The Plan contains an analysis of the country's education policy in terms of its strengths and weaknesses, opportunities and challenges. It sets out detailed objectives and target indicators for all levels of education and addresses aspects such as the development of financing mechanisms, increasing the motivation of teaching staff, adapting curricula and developing educational infrastructure. The Plan further develops previously adopted strategies, such as the State Programme for the Development of Education for 2005–2010, the State Programme for the Development of Technical and Vocational Education for 2008–2012, the “Children of Kazakhstan” Programme for 2007–2011 and the “Balapan” Preschool Education Programme for 2010–2014.
____________________⁷ Ibid.
⁸ Concluding observations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child (2007) (CRC/C/KAZ/CO/3), para. 3; see also concluding observations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child (2003) (CRC/C/15/Add.213), paras. 9 and 13.
⁹ Compilation prepared by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights for the universal periodic review mechanism (A/HRC/WG.6/7/KAZ/2 and Corr.1), para. 4.
¹⁰ UNESCO, “A compilation”, p. 28.
¹¹ Ibid.
¹² Ibid.
¹³ Approved by Presidential Decree No. 1118 of 7 December 2010. The text is available at: www.edu.gov.kz/fileadmin/user_upload/npa/gosprogramma/program_2020_english.doc.
III. General situation of education in Kazakhstan
A. Primary and secondary education
19. Both primary and secondary education in Kazakhstan are virtually universal. In 2008, the enrolment ratio (for the corresponding age groups of children) was 99.8 per cent for primary education, 100 per cent for basic secondary education and 99.6 per cent for general secondary education.¹⁶ Thus, Kazakhstan has already achieved Millennium Development Goal 2 with regard to ensuring universal primary education. In addition, Kazakhstan has also achieved Goal 3, concerning the elimination of gender disparity in primary and secondary education.¹⁷
20. According to the 2010 report on Kazakhstan's progress towards achieving the Millennium Development Goals, 90 per cent of children who do not attend school come from low-income and disadvantaged families.¹⁸ Having analysed the remaining challenges in the education system in this context, the country decided to undertake additional commitments under the so-called “MDG Plus” agenda. In the field of education, the “MDG Plus” agenda covers an expanded version of Goal 2, with a particular focus on secondary education, improving the quality of learning and promoting the inclusion of marginalized groups, such as children with special needs and students from socially vulnerable groups.¹⁹ As indicated below, additional attention should be paid to the following sources of inequality: school infrastructure, teacher qualifications and working conditions, the use of teaching materials and educational technologies, unified systems for collecting education data, and the assessment of learning outcomes.
____________________¹⁴ Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2011–2020, second page.
¹⁵ Ibid., p. 3.
¹⁶ “Millennium Development Goals in Kazakhstan – 2010” (Kazakhstan and the United Nations Country Team for Kazakhstan), p. 40.
¹⁷ Ibid., p. 10.
¹⁸ Ibid., p. 47.
¹⁹ Ibid., p. 39.
21. Alongside the consistently high levels of school enrolment, the 2010 review of the implementation of the “MDG Plus” agenda emphasizes that classes in a number of schools are still held in multiple shifts and that some urban schools are overcrowded. In the 2009/2010 academic year, approximately 66 per cent of general day schools operated on a two- or three-shift basis. A total of 37.1 per cent of students attended classes in the afternoon. In view of the increase in the birth rate, the burden on educational institutions is expected to increase, despite the construction of new schools.²⁰
22. Between 2006 and 2009, the proportion of rural schools increased from 76.4 per cent to 78.8 per cent.²¹ At the same time, disparities in the quality of education between rural and urban areas are a matter of serious concern. Owing to the country's vast and unevenly populated territory, remote rural communities generally rely on small schools with limited enrolment. Despite the gradual decline in the number of such schools, it is noted that most of them are concentrated in rural areas and provide lower-quality educational services, while suffering most severely from a shortage of qualified personnel and a weak educational and technical resource base.²² The State Programme for the Development of Education includes a number of measures to improve learning conditions in small schools, including the establishment of educational resource centres to strengthen the capacity of these schools, investment in information technologies, and support for the development of alternative boarding schools and transport services.
23. Investment in new information technologies and Internet-based learning tools (e-learning) is one of the key elements of efforts to improve the quality of services provided throughout the education system. The State Programme for the Development of Education provides for the development of distance learning via the Internet and the provision of new computers and broadband Internet access to all small schools with at least 10 students. Investing in the development of distance learning processes is an understandable choice in view of the distances that exist in the country; however, the impact of this measure may be limited if its adoption is not accompanied by sufficient assistance to teachers working in remote settlements and if continuous subsequent monitoring is not ensured.
24. Another important challenge in strengthening high-quality education is improving data collection, including, in particular, strengthening the national system for analysing learning outcomes. As noted in the review of the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals, the country's long-standing participation in initiatives such as the Millennium Development Goals and “Education for All” was not accompanied by the creation of a unified database that could be regularly updated.²³ A lack of disaggregated information on quality issues may, for example, make it difficult to analyse possible elements of inequality affecting rural schools or schools for children belonging to minorities.
____________________²⁰ Ibid., p. 40.
²¹ Ibid.
²² Ibid., p. 41.
²³ Ibid., p. 48.
25. In the context of the country's planned transition to a 12-year education cycle, the Government has undertaken efforts to establish a national examination system under which standardized assessments of knowledge will be conducted upon completion of primary, basic secondary, general secondary and vocationally oriented schooling. Conducting an analysis of learning outcomes on a uniform basis is also an essential step forward in more accurately identifying and addressing elements of inequality within the education system.
26. Certain initiatives are being undertaken to ensure gender equality and combat hidden discrimination, such as the establishment of the Kazakh State Women's Pedagogical Institute and the development of teaching materials under the Gender Equality Strategy (2006–2016).
B. Preschool education
27. In accordance with the Law “On Education”, preschool education is the first level of the education system in Kazakhstan, and preschool-aged children have the same right to education as school-aged children. Preschool education in Kazakhstan is provided through nurseries and kindergartens, which are currently in extremely short supply in the country.
28. Compared with primary and secondary education, enrolment rates in preschool education are significantly lower. Many preschool educational institutions that were widespread during the Soviet period were closed in the early 1990s, as a result of which a large number of children lost access to preschool education, primarily in rural areas.²⁴ Despite the growth observed during the period 2005–2010, the national rate of enrolment of children in the preschool education system remains relatively low.²⁵
29. According to data presented in the review “Millennium Development Goals in Kazakhstan – 2010”, during the 2008/2009 academic year, only 35.6 per cent of Kazakhstani children attended preschool educational institutions; the figure was even lower in rural areas, where it stood at 20.1 per cent.²⁶ The same report indicates that more than 900,000 children aged between one and six years were not covered by organized preschool education, while the total waiting list for places in preschool institutions amounted to 260,000 children.²⁷
30. One policy review also indicated that in rural areas not only was the number of preschool institutions decreasing, but the institutions themselves were becoming increasingly small.²⁸ The same review noted that the application of an integrated approach to care and learning, together with close attention to the comprehensive development of the child, had helped improve the quality of preschool education. At the same time, it emphasized that even more could be achieved by strengthening the links between social-sector services and the education sector and directing additional investment towards improving teachers' qualifications and creating career advancement opportunities for them (taking into account the fact that this component of the workforce consists mainly of older age groups).²⁹
____________________²⁴ UNESCO, “Ensuring equitable access to preschool education: Kazakhstan's experience”, UNESCO Policy Brief on Early Childhood No. 33, first page.
²⁵ Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, ninth page.
²⁶ “Millennium Development Goals”, p. 43.
²⁷ Ibid., pp. 43–44.
²⁸ UNESCO, “Policy review report: early childhood care and education in Kazakhstan”, Early Childhood and Family Policy Series No. 12 (2005), p. 22.
31. The reasons for the low enrolment rates include limited financial support and demographic changes. Between 2007 and 2010, funding for preschool education from the State budget did not exceed 0.2 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP). In addition, it is acknowledged that the increase in the birth rate is likely to further increase the already considerable burden on preschool institutions.
32. The Government recognizes that preschool education requires additional investment and that increased attention must be paid to areas where there is a shortage of such services. Through the implementation of the “Balapan” State Programme, it is envisaged that a network of public and private kindergartens will be established, which could provide coverage for up to 70 per cent of children aged 3–6 by 2015, while the State Programme for the Development of Education sets the objective of achieving universal coverage for the same age group by 2020. Measures being taken to expand the network of preschool educational institutions vary according to regional characteristics; such measures include investment in family nurseries and the establishment of mini-centres based in schools through the use of surplus space.
C. Technical and vocational education
33. As a rule, there are opportunities to obtain technical and vocational education at two levels: in vocational schools offering basic training in accordance with labour market needs, and in secondary vocational schools offering secondary vocational education and more advanced vocational training in accordance with labour market needs. Students generally enter these institutions at the age of 15–17, after completing compulsory education. Although the country has several State colleges, most vocational colleges are private. Some educational institutions are adequately resourced and enjoy a good reputation, but they are in the minority. The number of students is relatively small, with approximately 500,000 students enrolled in some 500–800 colleges.³⁰
34. Since 1991, the number of vocational schools throughout the country has decreased by more than 30 per cent.³¹ Furthermore, the existing infrastructure and material and technical resources of the technical and vocational education system do not guarantee high-quality personnel training or attractive training programmes for young people.³²
____________________³⁰ British Council, Overview of Vocational Education and Training System—Skills around the world: Kazakhstan. Available at www.britishcouncil.org/learning–skills–for–employability–kazakhstan–country–vet–system.htm.
³¹ Ibid. According to statistical data, as of 1 July 2011, there were 786 technical and vocational education institutions in the country, including 306 vocational lyceums and 480 colleges; 22.8 per cent were located in rural areas. Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, eleventh page.
35. The Special Rapporteur notes the efforts being made and the measures being taken under the leadership of the Ministry of Education and Science and its Department of Technical and Vocational Education to modernize the technical and vocational education system with a view to achieving compliance with quality standards for vocational training. Vocational education and training are currently the subject of a number of reforms under the State Programme for the Development of Education (2011–2020), including measures such as the introduction of independent assessment of graduates' professional knowledge, developed by employers' associations, and the transition of educational institutions to operating on the basis of contracts concluded with large enterprises, for the purpose of providing students with work placements and internships,³³ as well as reforms under the related State Programme for Accelerated Industrial and Innovative Development (2010–2014).³⁴
36. The Government is striving to improve the quality of vocational education and training and to ensure that it is more responsive to the needs of the labour market, with a view to increasing employment rates among both young people and adults, as well as improving the quality and international competitiveness of the workforce.³⁵ In this regard, for example, the development objective envisaged under one of the World Bank's ongoing projects is to achieve a higher level of relevance, quality and efficiency in technical and vocational education through the improvement of the strategic framework and the strengthening of institutional capacity.³⁶
37. Budget allocations for technical and vocational education (totalling 0.2 per cent of GDP)³⁷ should be increased in order to improve infrastructure and the technical resource base in such a way as to promote innovation and adaptation to meet new labour market needs. In particular, the development and introduction of the necessary professional standards, qualification requirements, assessment and certification standards are just as important as providing vocational training for policymakers and consultants, education and vocational training developers, teachers and heads of educational institutions.
38. The technical and vocational education system requires resources, facilities and infrastructure that make it possible to provide quality education and thereby help offer young women and men the opportunity to exercise their right to education and find secure employment.
____________________³² Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, eleventh page.
³³ Ibid., forty-third and forty-seventh pages.
³⁴ Adopted by Presidential Decree No. 958 of 19 March 2010 (see www.invest.gov.kz).
³⁵ Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, eleventh page ff.
³⁶ World Bank, Technical and Vocational Education Modernization Project. See http://web.worldbank.org/external/projects/main?pagePK=64312881&piPK=64302848&theSitePK=40941&Projectid=P102177.
³⁷ Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education and Science, Education and Science in Numbers (Astana, 2011), p. 24.
Note: The translation above covers the text provided in your message, through paragraph 38. The remaining sections listed in the table of contents were not included in the supplied source text.
D. Higher Education
39. Every citizen of Kazakhstan has the right to receive free higher education on a competitive basis. In 2011, there were 148 universities in the country, 42 of which offered distance learning opportunities, while 10 offered adapted international accreditation38.
40. In 2010, Kazakhstan joined the Bologna Process39, thereby becoming part of the European Higher Education Area. A new classification system for higher education institutions was adopted: universities, national universities, research universities, academies and institutes40. The principle of university autonomy is observed with regard to academic, financial and administrative activities. In the course of the ongoing reforms, particular attention is also being paid to academic freedom and academic mobility as part of the Bologna Process. In 2012, the state standards for general secondary education were to be integrated with the state standards for higher education (bachelor's degree)41. Some universities in Kazakhstan are members of the European University Association. In addition, the integration of the country's higher education sector into the global educational environment is encouraged through the establishment of joint educational programmes with foreign partners and the development of economic mobility for students.
41. The Ministry of Education and Science is reorganizing and improving higher education, including postgraduate education, and the university system42. A three-tier system of higher and postgraduate education (bachelor's/master's/doctoral degrees) has been adopted in the country. A credit-unit system has been introduced into the educational process. The focus has shifted from monitoring the quality of education to establishing a quality assurance system. The National Accreditation Centre was established in 2005. A process has been initiated to introduce democratic principles into the management of higher education institutions, including, in particular, the establishment of boards of trustees and the introduction of corporate governance.
42. The Government allocates funds from the national budget to invite foreign lecturers and professors to Kazakhstan and annually provides approximately 200 educational grants to foreign students (from Turkic-speaking countries) to study in Kazakhstan. Although the current legislation does not provide for the awarding of so-called "transfer" grants, under the Bolashak International Scholarship initiative (launched in 1993), approximately 3,000 students from Kazakhstan receive support to pursue their studies abroad43.
43. Under the current domestic legislation, higher education institutions have the right to self-governance and independence in making decisions concerning the organization of the educational process, personnel matters and financial/economic activities44. At the same time, for example, the rector of a State institute is appointed directly by the Ministry of Education and Science45. Universities may develop their own curricula only within the framework of State educational standards adopted by the Ministry of Education and Science; with the approval of the Education Committee, universities may establish admission requirements for students. Private university-level educational institutions may provide educational services only after obtaining a licence from the Ministry of Education and Science, which monitors compliance with State educational quality standards.
38 Ibid., p. 25.
39 It currently comprises 47 countries; see www.ehea.info/members.aspx.
40 Kazakhstan, Education and Science in Numbers, p. 26.
41 Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, pp. 35–36.
42 Decree of the President No. 922 of 1 February 2010, "On the Strategic Development Plan of Kazakhstan for the Period up to 2020"; Presidential Decree No. 957 of 19 March 2010, "On Approval of the List of State Programmes".
43 Kazakhstan, report submitted as part of the application for membership in the Bologna Process (2010), pp. 20–21 (English-language text).
44 National Report on the Right to Education in Kazakhstan, p. 19.
45 Kazakhstan, report submitted as part of the application for membership in the Bologna Process, p. 2 (English-language text).
46 On 15 June 2011, following the entry into force of the lex specialis, the university's legal status changed and it became an "autonomous educational organization". "The leading university will disseminate innovative solutions and best practices throughout the country", Astana Calling, bi-weekly publication of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Kazakhstan, No. 201 (22 November 2011), p. 4.
44. Overall, national education policy is formulated at the central level by the Presidential Administration and ministries, which determine the general principles governing the education system, review strategies and priorities, and monitor the implementation of programmes.
45. The main outstanding challenges include ensuring equal access and equal opportunities with regard to university education and the realization of full university autonomy, as well as ensuring comprehensive student participation. In addition, improving education policy requires disaggregated statistical data and indicators, particularly with regard to the use of scholarships and other relevant support measures, as well as investment in university programmes.
46. The new flagship of university education in Kazakhstan is Nazarbayev University, established in Astana. This university, which operates in partnership with foreign universities and provides instruction exclusively in English, has been granted a special legal status that provides it with unprecedented independence, autonomy and academic freedom in formulating its academic policy. It is permitted to operate in accordance with its own standards, and provision has been made for the establishment of its own endowment fund46. Such autonomy enables the administration to exercise full self-governance and remain independent of Ministry of Education and Science regulations concerning programmes, curricula and other relevant matters.
47. The granting of such a special legal status ensuring full autonomy to Nazarbayev University demonstrates the limited implementation of the principle of self-governance of educational institutions, as provided for in article 36 of the Law "On Education".
48. Given that English is the sole language of instruction at this university, the possibility of providing education in the national language should be considered. The Government recognizes the importance of ensuring continuity of education in the Kazakh language from kindergarten through to higher education, so that all citizens of Kazakhstan have a good command of the State language, and plans to introduce KAZTEST, a system for assessing proficiency in the Kazakh language.
E. Striving for Excellence in Education
49. A number of programmes have been developed to improve performance in the education sector, such as the establishment of Nazarbayev University, which are intended to attract "the best and most advanced". The Presidential Daryn programme is also aimed at facilitating the selection of talented young people for subsequent education in specialized schools47. This network of specialized schools, which currently comprises 33 educational institutions, continues to expand. The Nazarbayev Intellectual Schools project was also developed for the same purpose, with the aim of laying the foundation for the development of best practices in the academic sphere; the project is to be extended to all regions of Kazakhstan, and whereas six such schools have currently been established, their number is expected to increase to 20 by 202048. Kazakhstan has set the goal of having two universities ranked among the best in the world by 202049.
50. The Bolashak initiative is aimed at providing education to talented young people from Kazakhstan. Under this programme, international scholarships are awarded on the basis of an annually compiled list of specialists most in demand in Kazakhstan; in 2011, such scholarships were awarded to nearly 3,000 students to study at 25 universities around the world50.
51. All these initiatives and programmes demonstrate the country's commitment to achieving the highest standards in education.
IV. Key Challenges
A. Promoting Equal Opportunities in Education
52. Additional efforts are required to ensure the identification and effective inclusion in the education system of children from vulnerable groups (which are increasing annually in terms of both composition and numbers)51.
53. The challenges listed below point to some of the most serious obstacles that may limit the educational prospects of children in Kazakhstan. These include economic barriers (potentially affecting all groups living in poverty), linguistic and cultural barriers (potentially affecting persons belonging to minorities), physical barriers (potentially affecting children with disabilities) and administrative barriers (potentially affecting migrants and refugees). These obstacles may be interconnected and may reinforce one another. Thus, promoting a more inclusive education system requires not only an understanding of specific problems, but also a comprehensive understanding of the relationships between them.
1. Ensuring Free Basic Education
54. The main reason for Kazakhstan's success in achieving almost universal enrolment of children in primary and secondary schools may be the country's existing and expanding system of free education. In this regard, it is of utmost importance to continuously monitor practices at the local level in order to prevent any fees from being charged to parents with low incomes.
55. The collection of additional financial contributions from parents, for example, for school and parent committees, school repairs or the purchase of school uniforms and supplies, may become a serious obstacle preventing children from poor families from accessing high-quality educational services. According to reports, families of students are increasingly required to make additional payments to preschool and secondary educational institutions, despite improvements in financial support provided to general secondary education institutions. In 2009, schools collected an average of 300 US dollars or more from each family; this amount may be lower in primary grades and higher in senior grades52. At the preschool level, the shortage of public nurseries and kindergartens results in excessively high costs for low-income families53.
56. At the same time, investment in social assistance programmes is one of the components of the Government's strategy to ensure education for low-income groups. In 2009, the total amount of financial assistance exceeded 33.9 million US dollars (approximately 2 per cent of total expenditure on the maintenance and routine repair of schools), which was twice the amount allocated in 2008. Under the annual "Road to School" campaign, children from low-income families receive financial assistance from entrepreneurs, institutions, sponsoring organizations and the public. In 2009, more than 190,000 children across the country received such support, amounting to a total of 6.8 million US dollars54. Another form of support is the provision of hot meals to schoolchildren (covering 61.3 per cent of students). Despite these measures, the number of children not attending school reportedly remains unchanged55.
57. The Special Rapporteur acknowledges the importance of investment in social assistance programmes to provide additional incentives for children from economically disadvantaged families to attend school. Since some of these programmes focus directly on children living in poverty, efforts must be made to ensure full transparency in the selection of beneficiaries and to correct possible errors where genuinely needy individuals are not included. Furthermore, efforts should be made to prevent the collection of unauthorized payments from families at the local level.
52 Ibid., p. 47.
53 Ibid., p. 44.
54 For comparison, in 2008 assistance was provided to 100,000 children, and a total of 405 million tenge was spent for this purpose (3.4 million US dollars at the 2008 exchange rate); see Millennium Development Goals, p. 46.
55 Ibid.
2. Multilingual Education and Education for Minorities
58. Kazakhstan is a multi-ethnic society, and its unique cultural diversity is one of its strengths. To preserve and develop this valuable heritage, it is essential to ensure the provision of education in different languages56. The official language of the country is Kazakh, although Russian, which is spoken fluently by the majority of citizens, is officially used in State institutions on an equal footing with Kazakh (A/HRC/13/23/Add.1, para. 3). In addition, many citizens speak English.
59. Paragraph 3 of article 7 of the Constitution of Kazakhstan, which enshrines the right of all citizens to use and study their own language, states that the State shall take care to create conditions for the study and development of the languages of the people of Kazakhstan. Furthermore, paragraph 2 of article 19 of the Constitution guarantees everyone's right to use their native language and culture and to freely choose the language of communication, upbringing, education and creative activities. These unconditional rights are further confirmed and specified in the 1997 Law "On Languages".
60. In accordance with paragraph 3 of article 9 of the Law "On Education", which provides for the right to receive education in one's native language, the country pursues a State policy aimed at providing general secondary education in the native languages of students and/or teaching them their native languages as separate subjects. Organizing multilingual education in all its diversity remains a complex challenge. According to available statistics, in the 2008/09 academic year, children from more than 100 ethnic groups attended schools, of whom Kazakhs accounted for 71.4 per cent, Russians 14.7 per cent, Uzbeks 4 per cent, Ukrainians 1.5 per cent, Germans 1 per cent, Uyghurs 1.7 per cent and others 5.7 per cent. School instruction is primarily provided in six languages57.
61. The alternatives currently available for receiving education in one's native language are provided by government institutions in cooperation with cultural associations. In this context, a number of Sunday schools (approximately 79) have been established through the efforts of national and cultural associations for adults and children to study their respective languages, including German, Korean, Hebrew, Tatar and Polish.
62. The Special Rapporteur welcomes efforts to maintain and even increase the proportion of schools offering specialized language instruction, thereby enabling children belonging to increasingly numerous and diverse ethnic minority groups to receive a comprehensive education. At the same time, he emphasizes that greater attention and resources should be devoted to improving teaching standards in minority schools. Furthermore, there is a need to allocate funds for the development and maintenance of the system and infrastructure of minority schools and to address the shortage of textbooks and teaching materials (A/HRC/13/23/Add.1, paras. 48 and 49). Beyond simply providing textbooks, it is equally important for minorities to receive new editions of textbooks whose content reflects the multi-ethnic nature of Kazakh society and the contribution of minorities to its diverse culture.
56 The ethnic composition of the population of Kazakhstan is as follows: 58.6 per cent of the population are Kazakhs, 26.1 per cent are ethnic Russians, and 15.3 per cent belong to other ethnic groups, including Ukrainians (2.9 per cent), Uzbeks (2.8 per cent), and Uyghurs, Tatars and Germans (1.5 per cent each). In addition, more than 100 other small ethnic groups live in Kazakhstan (approximately 4.3 per cent). Report of the Independent Expert on Minority Issues on her mission to Kazakhstan (A/HRC/13/23/Add.1), para. 3.
57 Millennium Development Goals, p. 41.
63. In this regard, it is appropriate to emphasize the importance of constructive interfaith dialogue promoted by the Assembly of the People. Established in 1995, the Assembly acquired constitutional status in 2007, and its membership includes nine members of Parliament representing all ethnic minorities. All legislative acts concerning ethnic issues pass through the Assembly. The Assembly plays a crucial role in strengthening mutual understanding and respect for the richness of linguistic and cultural diversity.
3. Persons with Disabilities
64. Kazakhstan signed (on 11 December 2008), but has not ratified, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which enshrines the right of persons with disabilities to unhindered access to inclusive education and establishes the prerequisites for its implementation.
65. Under the Law "On Social Protection of Persons with Disabilities in the Republic of Kazakhstan", the rehabilitation of children with disabilities falls within the competence of the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection. The Ministry is responsible for financing and administrative support for assistance programmes for low-income families in accordance with the 2001 Law "On State Targeted Social Assistance". The Ministry of Health develops policies in the field of basic medical care, undertakes initiatives for the early identification of at-risk groups in cooperation with regional education departments, and oversees the activities of the system of children's homes for young children58.
66. Although the idea of fully integrating children with special needs into society underlies Kazakhstan's State education policy, the Ministry of Education does not have the authority to consider matters concerning children with disabilities, which results in their exclusion from the mainstream education system. Special educational institutions have been established to provide children with special needs with opportunities to receive general secondary education. There are 101 special correctional educational institutions in the country (A/HRC/WG.6/7/KAZ/1, para. 122).
67. New inclusive education methods are being applied to integrate children with disabilities. More than 12,000 children with disabilities study in public schools and kindergartens, and distance learning has been organized for children with special needs in several regions. A quota system has been introduced to ensure access for children with special needs to colleges and universities (A/HRC/14/10, para. 69).
68. The Special Rapporteur visited one educational institution attended by children with disabilities and was impressed by the high standard of the facilities created there for learning. In particular, he noted the efforts made to establish an educational base that enables children with disabilities to acquire advanced computer skills. However, not all such children and adults benefit from such a good educational system, and in any case, such an educational base is more characteristic of segregated rather than inclusive education.
58 UNESCO, "A Compilation" (note 5 above), p. 28.
69. Inclusive education has not yet been sufficiently developed, and the material and technical infrastructure required to meet the needs of students with physical disabilities has largely yet to be established. There are more than 150,000 children with disabilities in Kazakhstan, and only one third of them have access to educational and development programmes. Children with disabilities are placed in special (correctional) boarding schools far from home if no such special educational institutions are available in their place of residence. Public schools lack the necessary facilities and specially trained teaching staff to work with children with disabilities. As a result, such children are unable to attend regular schools and kindergartens59.
70. A study recently conducted by the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) and the National Centre for Human Rights (the Office of the Human Rights Commissioner) in Kazakh State residential educational institutions, where care and education are provided not only to children with disabilities but also to orphans and street children, indicates that violence by staff and violence among children are serious problems in these institutions60. The study sets out a number of recommendations for preventing and eliminating all forms of violence against children.
71. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur recalls that, in the context of realizing the right to education for persons with disabilities, particular attention should be paid to integrating these persons into the general education system and adopting measures to prevent and eliminate discrimination against children with disabilities61. In order to ensure the maximum possible academic and social development of children with disabilities, consistent with the objective of their full social integration, effective measures must be taken to provide support on an individual basis.
4. Migrants
72. Kazakhstan, which is not a party to the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families, has confirmed that it does not intend to ratify this Convention in the near future in view of the far-reaching financial consequences that would arise from its implementation (A/HRC/14/10/Add.1, para. 1). However, the Special Rapporteur emphasizes that, under domestic legislation and international human rights treaties ratified by Kazakhstan, the State is bound by the obligation to ensure and facilitate education for persons living in its territory on a non-discriminatory basis and irrespective of their legal status.
73. The administration of educational activities must also ensure inclusive education and the realization of the right to adequate and accessible education. Accordingly, all children, including children of migrants, must be allowed to attend school without any administrative preconditions, such as the requirement to have a residence registration (propiska)62. In accordance with paragraph 2 of article 8 of the Law "On Education", legal and practical obstacles to the schooling of migrant children may be overcome, among other things, by adopting administrative acts and decisions declaring that all children, as such, are eligible for admission to schools.
62 According to reports, children without propiska (registration at their place of residence) were denied admission to schools in Astana and other regions of Kazakhstan. Report of the Kazakhstan NGO (see footnote 59 above), p. 35 (English-language text).
63 Order No. 468 of 28 September 2010, "On Approval of the Rules for Obtaining Preschool, Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education by Foreigners and Stateless Persons Permanently Residing in the Republic of Kazakhstan".
64 Kazakhstan, NGO report (see footnote 59 above), p. 35 (English-language text).
65 See Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe/Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, "Opinion on the Draft Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan 'On Population Migration'" (Warsaw, 24 September 2009) and "Opinion on the Draft Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan 'On Regulation of Migration Processes'" (Warsaw, 11 April 2011).
74. As an example of how administrative barriers may affect the exercise of the right to education by migrants and refugees, the Special Rapporteur was informed during his visit that, in 2010, following an inspection of schools, the General Prosecutor's Office issued an order requiring the expulsion from schools of children of foreigners who did not have permanent residence permits in Kazakhstan. As a result of joint efforts by all relevant stakeholders, the Ministry of Education and Science issued an order allowing the expelled children to return to their schools63.
75. Monitoring of schools recently conducted in Almaty, Taraz and Karaganda also revealed a number of cases in which public schools violated the right to education of refugee children and migrants by either expelling children or refusing to admit refugee children who did not have local registration and work permits64.
76. The Special Rapporteur considers that education legislation and guidelines should ensure that the right to adequate education is guaranteed to all children, irrespective of their citizenship, legal status or social status. The State should take legal, administrative and organizational measures to ensure that all children are covered by the school education system on a non-discriminatory basis. In this context, the relevant legislation and administrative practices should be harmonized and, where necessary, existing discrepancies should be eliminated, so that they clearly provide that education also includes education for children of migrants and that access to education must be universal, without discrimination and on an equal footing with citizens of Kazakhstan65.
5. Refugees
77. Paragraph 4 of article 12 of the Constitution provides that foreigners and stateless persons enjoy in Kazakhstan the rights and freedoms, and bear the obligations, established for citizens, unless otherwise provided for by the Constitution, laws and international treaties. Under article 1 of the Law "On Education", citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan, foreigners and stateless persons have the right to choose an educational institution and the form of education in accordance with the admission requirements66.
78. In accordance with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and other international standards and laws, access to public general secondary education must be universal, irrespective of the legal status of the child. By signing these international treaties, Kazakhstan undertook the obligation to recognize the child's right to education and to ensure the availability of primary and secondary education for all children. However, as indicated above, refugee children sometimes face serious obstacles in attempting to gain access to general primary and secondary education because they lack the necessary documents (school transcripts for previous grades, residence permits, personal identity documents) and because of the legal status of their parents (temporary foreign residents).
79. Additional obstacles to education for refugees include a lack of knowledge of the Kazakh and Russian languages and prohibitions imposed by some parents on girls attending upper grades or studying together with boys67. Furthermore, many migrants and refugees do not have sufficient financial resources to cover the cost of education at various levels, whether preschool, technical or vocational education, or higher education. In the absence of permanent residence permits, refugees do not enjoy the same access to public loans and scholarship programmes for higher education as permanent foreign residents and citizens of the country. The main sources of assistance at the local level are generally directed towards providing support to citizens of Kazakhstan.
66 Second and third periodic reports submitted by Kazakhstan to the Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC/C/KAZ/3), para. 71.
67 Ibid., para. 72.
B. Addressing the Imperative Challenges of Improving Quality
80. Despite the achievements in primary and secondary education discussed above, challenges relating to learning outcomes and the quality of education provided remain unresolved68. Neither the curricula nor the national standards include the acquisition of safe-living skills as an expected learning outcome69. The main concerns regarding the improvement of overall education quality are the low status of the teaching profession and the unsatisfactory quality of teacher training. Both aspects have been identified in the State Programme for the Development of Education as weaknesses of the education system and therefore deserve particular attention. For example, in 2009, 27 per cent of secondary school teachers did not have professional diplomas, and there were 2,440 vacant teaching positions in the country70.
81. The lack of attractive salaries and career advancement prospects has been identified as one of the key reasons for qualified teachers leaving the education system. In the technical and vocational education system, the most qualified and promising teachers prefer to leave their jobs in favour of employment in enterprises. In this regard, the State Programme for the Development of Education provides for a number of measures aimed at increasing teachers' salaries and improving their career prospects, as well as promoting their professional development. These measures include a salary increase (which took place during the visit to the country), the introduction of differentiated coefficients for calculating teachers' salaries depending on their qualifications and length of service, and investment in the development of professional advancement opportunities for teachers.
82. Efforts to improve the quality of education also include the revision of school textbooks and the improvement of specialized school infrastructure, including the creation of new subject-specific and multimedia classrooms. Rules governing the preparation, revision and publication of textbooks, technical materials and teaching aids have been introduced, and in 2008 more than 1,000 textbooks were found not to comply with the new standards. In this regard, additional efforts are still needed to distribute higher-quality and updated teaching materials. One of the priority tasks in improving education in Kazakhstan is monitoring compliance with the national education standards developed in 2007, particularly in rural areas71.
83. With the aim of guaranteeing high-quality education, Kazakhstan established the National System for Assessing the Quality of Education (NSAQE) to ensure the comparability of national and international indicators, as well as regional NSAQE structures to analyse quality at the regional level. In addition, Kazakhstan participates in international comparative studies and international assessments of educational quality, such as the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) and Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS). Furthermore, the Unified National Testing is also intended to improve the validity and reliability of knowledge assessment in order to ensure equal access to higher and vocational education.
C. Education Financing
84. According to information provided by the Ministry of Education and Science, public funds for education in Kazakhstan are allocated through the national and local budgets. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the efforts of the Government of Kazakhstan to expand and strengthen the education sector by increasing allocations from the State budget. The share of the State budget spent on education increased from 3.7 per cent of GDP in 2007 to 4.2 per cent of GDP in 2011, with the highest figure of 4.4 per cent of GDP recorded in 2009; maintaining a sustained increase in this share of the State budget is important. The growth in expenditure and costs in the education sector must also be taken into account: for example, between 2006 and 2009, this figure more than doubled.
71 UNICEF, "Country Profile", p. 4.
85. In the State Programme for the Development of Education, the Government openly acknowledges that underfunding of education constitutes an obstacle to achieving the goals and objectives established in the field of education72 and that there is a need to develop new financing mechanisms73. In the same context, a comparison of the results of the Unified National Testing and expenditure per student proved unexpected, as it indicated an absence of any relationship between substantial expenditure and the quality of education74. The effective allocation and utilization of resources in the field of education are hindered by a number of institutional and structural features of the national budgeting and financing system. As a result, budget allocations do not always serve as an effective means of implementing the priorities set out in education policy, despite the increase in resources.
86. In this regard, the Government seeks to move forward towards the introduction of per capita funding mechanisms by 2015, taking into account the specific characteristics of regions and educational institutions ranging from preschool organizations to technical and vocational educational institutions, with the exception of small-completion schools. Through this, it intends to introduce results-oriented financing as an integral part of reforms in the management of public expenditure in the secondary education sector. In 2011, preparations were under way to develop a methodology for per capita normative financing; this will help improve the efficiency of budget expenditure, as well as responsibility and accountability. It is important to provide for the development of grants and preferential loans for educational institutions that are smaller than others, in order to ensure a smooth transition without undermining the right to education, and to ensure transparency and accountability in financial management.
87. In view of its impressive economic progress and abundance of resources, Kazakhstan can and should continue to increase investment in education, both within the national budget and as a share of GDP, particularly since education has been recognized as one of the most important priorities in the Kazakhstan Development Strategy until 2030. Investment in this strategically important sector is not only an obligation but also a crucial step towards strengthening democracy.
V. Conclusions and Recommendations
88. Over the past two decades, Kazakhstan has achieved unprecedented political and economic progress. The country's "MDG Plus" agenda, which sets out its long-term goals and strategies in the field of education development, is of great importance in the context of global consideration of the adoption of the "Education for All" initiative for the period beyond 2015.
89. The Special Rapporteur commends the Government for achieving almost universal primary and secondary education, as well as for its determination to continue investing in the development of preschool, technical, vocational and higher education; at the same time, he emphasizes that a number of outstanding challenges remain to be addressed by Kazakhstan in order to ensure the full realization of the right to education for all.
72 Kazakhstan, State Programme for the Development of Education, p. 15.
73 Ibid., p. 3.
74 Millennium Development Goals, p. 47.
90. The Special Rapporteur notes that Kazakhstan has all the necessary prerequisites to implement the "Education for All" initiative and move towards high-quality education for all citizens of the country throughout their lives, taking into account their needs and potential. The recommendations set out below are intended to assist the Government in this regard.
1. Addressing the Imperative Challenges of Improving Quality in the Context of Ensuring Universal Education
91. Kazakhstan should improve the quality of education provided by integrating the concept of inclusive education into national education development strategies; revising and updating national educational standards and curricula on the basis of the principle of interconnectedness and continuity between preschool, primary and secondary education standards.
92. Increasing investment in teacher training and improving their professional advancement prospects are also of utmost importance for improving the quality of education. Teachers are the main source of high-quality education, and replacing an ageing workforce with highly qualified and trained teachers is a crucial task for the country. In addition, when training young teachers, Kazakhstan should take steps to ensure a more balanced gender ratio among teaching staff, which is currently characterized by an imbalance in favour of one gender.
2. Increasing Investment in Education
93. As a resource-rich country, Kazakhstan can and should allocate significantly more funds from its national budget to education, particularly since education has been recognized as one of the most important priorities in the Kazakhstan Development Strategy until 2030. In order to ensure more equal and equitable use of funds, budget financing mechanisms should continue to be adapted for this purpose. Investment in education should primarily be aimed at improving quality standards applied equally throughout the country. Priority attention should be given to reaching groups traditionally excluded from the education system, such as children living in poverty, children with disabilities and children belonging to minorities. Continued investment in education at all levels as a national priority is not only fundamental to consolidating the significant progress achieved by the country in recent years, but is also a State obligation enshrined in both national and international law.
3. Promoting Inclusive Education
94. Kazakhstan should ensure inclusive education by providing all children, including children of migrants and refugees, with access to education without any legal or administrative preconditions, such as the requirement to have a propiska. This may be achieved, among other things, by adopting a provision stipulating that administrative acts and decisions unequivocally guarantee the possibility of attending schools for all children. Targeted efforts must be made to adapt classrooms and train teachers in order to facilitate the education of children with disabilities in regular schools. The practice of placing children in boarding schools should be reviewed in light of their best interests.
4. Promoting Education for Minorities
95. In the context of Kazakhstan's historical and geopolitical circumstances and the Government's policy of strengthening the status of the Kazakh language as the State language, it should be emphasized that these efforts must not result in a weakening of efforts to provide education for minority groups. Kazakhstan should ensure high-quality education in schools where instruction is provided in minority languages, guarantee sufficient funding and resources, and ensure equal access to university education for students from all population groups.
5. Preserving the Richness of Multicultural and Multilingual Diversity
96. One of the most important challenges facing Kazakhstan is to preserve and enrich its multicultural and multilingual diversity while ensuring respect for the culture of the country's majority population. Education can play a key role in this regard. Interfaith and intercultural dialogue, promoted through the Assembly of the People, can provide greater scope for the dissemination of universal human rights values and democratic citizenship.
6. An Institutionalized and Adequate Data Collection Mechanism
97. Kazakhstan should ensure nationwide, systematic and regular collection of data in the field of education, including disaggregated data, with particular attention to vulnerable groups that are generally left outside the education system. Kazakhstan could establish an inter-agency commission to play a key role in coordination and monitoring (involving the statistical agency, ministries and relevant departments) and reach an agreement on the collection and analysis of education-related data.
Constitution, Law Code Normative Act, Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative cases and disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Decision Report Conclusion Statement Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Programme Charter Statute Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages