UNITED NATIONS MODEL DOUBLE TAXATION CONVENTION BETWEEN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
Convention, 1 January 2017
INTRODUCTION
A. ORIGIN OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
1. The United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention between Developed and Developing Countries (the United Nations Model Convention) forms part of the ongoing international efforts aimed at eliminating double taxation. These efforts were initiated by the League of Nations and continued by the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation (OEEC) [now known as the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)] and regional forums, as well as within the framework of the United Nations. Overall, these efforts have found their concrete expression in a series of model bilateral tax conventions or drafts thereof.
2. These model instruments, in particular the United Nations Model Convention and the OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital (the OECD Model Convention), have had a profound influence on international treaty practice and contain a significant number of common provisions. The similarity between these two principal Model Conventions reflects the importance of ensuring consistency between their provisions wherever possible. On the other hand, important areas of divergence between such provisions may serve to illustrate certain key differences in approaches or emphases, as reflected in the practices of particular countries, and allow special attention to be focused on them. Such divergences relate, in particular, to the question of the extent to which a country should, under a bilateral tax treaty, relinquish taxing rights that it would otherwise have under its domestic law, for the purpose of avoiding double taxation and promoting investment.
3. The United Nations Model Convention generally favours the preservation, under a tax treaty, of broader taxing rights for the so-called “Source State”, that is, the country receiving the investment, as compared with the “Residence State” of the investor. This issue has long been regarded as being of particular importance to developing countries, although some developed countries also seek to include this provision in their bilateral treaties.
4. The desirability of promoting increased flows of foreign investment into developing countries on terms that are both politically acceptable and economically and socially favourable has been repeatedly affirmed in resolutions of the General Assembly and the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations and of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. Two documents, namely the 2002 Monterrey Consensus on Financing for Development¹ and the subsequent 2008 Doha Declaration on Financing for Development², recognize the particular importance of international cooperation in tax matters for promoting investment for development purposes and maximizing domestic resource mobilization, including through combating tax evasion. They also recognize the importance of supporting national efforts in these areas through the provision of technical assistance (in which this Model Convention will play a vital role), as well as through enhanced international cooperation and participation in addressing international tax issues (one of the products of which is the United Nations Model Convention).
5. The growth of investment flows between countries depends to a large extent on the prevailing investment climate. An important element of this climate is the prevention or elimination of international double taxation in respect of the same income, the consequences of which are detrimental to the exchange of goods and services and to the movement of capital and persons.
6. Thus, broadly speaking, the general objectives of bilateral tax treaties include protecting taxpayers against double taxation in order to enhance the flow of international trade and investment and the transfer of technology. They are also intended to prevent certain forms of discrimination between foreign investors and domestic taxpayers and to provide a reasonable degree of legal and financial certainty within which international transactions can be conducted with confidence. On this basis, tax treaties can contribute to the achievement of the development objectives of developing countries. In addition, these treaties are intended to strengthen cooperation between tax authorities in the performance of their functions, including through the exchange of information for the purpose of preventing tax evasion or tax avoidance, as well as assistance in tax collection.
6.1 Finally, as a result of international attention to the problems of base erosion and profit shifting, it has become clear that treaties are not intended to facilitate the search for a convenient treaty regime or other abuses of the provisions of tax treaties.
7. The desirability of promoting the conclusion of bilateral treaties for the avoidance of double taxation between developed and developing countries was recognized by the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) of the United Nations in its resolution 1273 (XLIII), adopted on 4 August 1967. This led the Secretary-General to establish, in 1968, the Ad Hoc Group of Experts on Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries. The Group consisted of officials and experts from the tax authorities of developed and developing countries, appointed in their personal capacities.
8. In 1980, following the work of the Ad Hoc Group of Experts, the United Nations published the United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention between Developed and Developing Countries, preceded by the publication in 1979 of the Manual for the Negotiation of Bilateral Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries (the Manual). In its resolution 1980/13 of 28 April 1980, the Economic and Social Council renamed the Group the Ad Hoc Group of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters (the Ad Hoc Group of Experts), recognizing the importance of issues of international tax cooperation beyond tax treaties.
9. During the 1990s, the Ad Hoc Group of Experts recognized that significant changes had taken place in the international economic, financial and tax environment. In addition, increasing attention was being paid to the tax implications of new financial instruments, transfer pricing, the expansion of “tax havens” and globalization, which affect international economic relations. The increasingly frequent updates to the OECD Model Convention contributed to the need for a continuous analysis of the process of more actively reflecting issues of international cooperation in tax matters. Thereafter, the Ad Hoc Group of Experts began revising and updating the United Nations Model Convention and the Manual. This resulted in the development of a new version of the United Nations Model Convention (which was revised in 1999 and published in 2001)³ and a new version of the Manual (published electronically in 2003)⁴.
10. In 2005, the status of the Ad Hoc Group of Experts was elevated through its transformation into a Committee structure, which remains in place to this day. Twenty-five members of the Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters are nominated by countries and selected by the Secretary-General of the United Nations to serve in their personal capacities for a four-year term. The Committee currently reports directly to ECOSOC and meets once a year rather than once every two years.
11. In 2013, 25 new members were appointed to the Committee of Experts. At the time of completion of this updated version of the United Nations Model Convention, the Committee consisted of the following members⁵:
Armando Lara Yaffar (Mexico), Chair of the Committee; Henry John Louie (United States of America), First Vice-Chair; Mohammed Amin Baina (Morocco), Second Vice-Chair; Liselotte Kahn (Chile), Third Vice-Chair; Pragya S. Saxena (India), Fourth Vice-Chair; Nasser Mohammed Al Khalifa (Qatar); Bernadette May Evelyn Butler (Bahamas); Andrew Dawson (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland); Johan Cornelius de la Rey (South Africa); El-Hadji Ibrahima Diop (Senegal); Nur Azian Abdul Hamid (Malaysia); Kim Jacinto-Henares (Philippines); Toshiyuki Kemmochi (Japan); Cezary Krysiak (Poland); Wolfgang Karl Lasars (Germany); Enrico Martino (Italy); Eric Nii Yarboi Mensah (Ghana); Ignatius Kawaza Mvula (Zambia); Carmel Peters (New Zealand); Jorge Antonio Deher Rachid (Brazil); Christoph Schelling (Switzerland); Stig B. Sollund (Norway); Xiaoyue Wang (China); Ingela Willfors (Sweden); and Ulvi Yusifov (Azerbaijan).
Restore the original formatting exactlyMatch the source heading hierarchy precisely
1 United Nations, 2002, A/CONF.198/11
2 United Nations, 2008, A/CONF.212/L.1/Rev.1
3 United Nations, 2001, E.01.XVI.2. Available on the website: http://www.un.org/ esa/ffd/tax/index.htm.
4 http://www.un.org/esa/ffd/tax/manual.htm.
5 The list of countries appointing members of the Committee is provided for information purposes only, since, as noted above, Committee members serve in their personal capacity and not as representatives of those countries.
B. SPECIAL FEATURES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
- The United Nations Model Convention represents a compromise between the source principle and the residence principle, although, as noted above, it places greater emphasis on the source principle than does the OECD Model Convention. The United Nations Model Convention is not intended to be prescriptive, but rather to provide policymakers in different countries with the information necessary to understand the implications of different approaches for the specific circumstances of their countries. As noted in the introduction to the previous version of the United Nations Model Convention, the provisions of the Model Convention do not, in themselves, have legal force. Its provisions are not binding and should not be interpreted as official recommendations of the United Nations. Rather, the United Nations Model Convention is intended to facilitate the negotiation, interpretation and practical application of bilateral tax treaties based on its provisions.
- The United Nations Model Convention seeks to achieve a balanced approach. As a consequence of adhering to the principle of taxation at source, the articles of the Model Convention are based on the recognition by the source country that: (a) taxation of income from foreign capital will take into account the expenses associated with earning income from profits, so that income is taxed on a net basis; (b) taxation should not be excessively high so as not to discourage investment; and (c) it will take into account an appropriate sharing of revenue with the country providing the capital. In addition, the United Nations Model Convention embodies the idea that it would be appropriate for the country of residence to extend measures for the relief of double taxation, either by crediting tax paid abroad or by granting an exemption, as provided for in the OECD Model Convention.
- In using the United Nations Model Convention as a reference document, any country should take into account the important relationship between treaties and domestic law, the nature of which may differ from country to country. As a general rule, the provisions of tax treaties take precedence over the provisions of domestic law in the event of a conflict between them. More specifically, tax treaties determine which of the Contracting States will have jurisdiction to tax a particular item of income and under what conditions and limitations it may do so. Consequently, countries wishing to begin negotiations for the conclusion of a bilateral tax treaty should carefully analyse the applicable provisions of their domestic tax legislation in order to assess the changes that may be required in the event that such a treaty is applied. They should also discuss the relevant domestic laws of potential treaty partners as part of the preparation and negotiation of treaties.
- It may also be noted that, in turn, domestic tax legislation influences the content of bilateral tax treaties. These laws are an important reason for many of the differences between treaties, since countries seek to preserve their domestic taxation rights in the structure of the treaties they conclude. Such domestic laws, as well as the treaty practice reflecting them, form the basis for the policy positions that can be found in various model conventions. Conversely, if countries do not insist on including certain taxation rights in their national legislation and do not envisage doing so, they generally do not seek to preserve the possibility of exercising such taxation rights under the treaties they conclude. If policy changes at a later stage, domestic laws providing for the exercise of those rights may be adopted, but such laws will have effect only to the extent that they are consistent with the treaty relationships.
- This revision of the United Nations Model Convention marks the beginning of an ongoing review process which, the Committee hopes, will result in more frequent updates of certain articles and commentaries in order to keep pace with developments, including the practices of individual countries, new ways of doing business and new challenges. This process will therefore function as a process of continuous improvement. This means that some articles have not yet been analysed sufficiently by the Committee.
- The main objectives of this revision of the United Nations Model Convention are to take account of developments in international tax policy that are relevant to both developing and developed countries. The Committee identified a number of issues requiring further work. In particular, one of the Subcommittees was instructed to address the issue of the treatment of services in general and in a broad sense, including all related aspects and issues, while also considering specifically the taxation of fees for technical services. Accordingly, the Subcommittee focused its work on preparing a new article with commentary, which has now been included in the updated 2017 version of the Convention. However, it was recognized that this was the beginning of a substantial body of work. In the future, if the Committee so decides, the Committee's report may set out any conclusions that may prove potentially useful and may serve as a basis for the next revision of the United Nations Model Convention. The Committee's programme of work, including on the subject of services, will be posted on its website as it is prepared.6
6 www.un.org/esa/ffd/tax/index.htm
17.1 In addition, the Committee has undertaken work on issues relating to base erosion and profit shifting. Initially, the Committee focused on its own experience and engaged with other relevant bodies in order to monitor developments in the area of base erosion and profit shifting and to inform officials from developing countries (particularly the least developed countries) directly and through regional and interregional organizations about these issues. These contacts were intended to promote awareness of such issues among developing countries, to facilitate the consideration of the experience and views of developing countries in the ongoing work of the United Nations, and to facilitate the consideration of the experience and views of developing countries in the OECD/G20 Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting. In 2014, the Committee began work on amending the United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention in order to address issues relating to base erosion and profit shifting, whether arising from the work of the Group of Twenty and the OECD or relating directly to issues arising in connection with the Convention. The present update reflects the results of the work on these issues.
C. TAX POLICY ISSUES RELEVANT TO THE DECISION TO ENTER INTO A TAX TREATY OR TO AMEND AN EXISTING TREATY
17.2 In 2005, the Committee established the Subcommittee on Tax Treaty Negotiation: Practical Issues. This Subcommittee prepared an updated version of the United Nations Manual for the Negotiation of Bilateral Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries, which was adopted by the Committee in 2015 and published in 2016.7 The purpose of the Manual is to provide tax treaty negotiators with guidance on all aspects of treaty negotiations, including a brief description of the articles of the United Nations Model Convention. Although each country must formulate its own policy considerations and determine its objectives with respect to tax treaties, the Manual seeks to provide practical guidance on all aspects of treaty negotiations, including their preparation and conduct. It discusses in detail the most common reasons why a country may conclude a tax treaty with another country, such as facilitating the import and export of investment by eliminating or reducing double taxation or excessive taxation in the source country, reducing cross-border tax evasion through the exchange of information and mutual assistance in the collection of taxes, or for political reasons. Tax treaty negotiators in developing countries are encouraged to use this Manual when preparing for tax treaty negotiations, taking into account their countries' policy frameworks and the intended outcomes they wish to achieve.
7 New York: United Nations, 2016.
17.3 In particular, the Committee noted that the Manual contains the following useful checklist of the advantages and disadvantages commonly associated with tax treaties:
Advantages:
- Increased foreign investment as a result of eliminating or reducing tax barriers
- Greater access to foreign technologies and skills
- Additional benefits to the local economy resulting from increased foreign investment
- Greater certainty for both taxpayers and tax administrations
- Greater consistency in the application of the tax regime
- Protection of investments abroad
- Prevention of tax evasion
Disadvantages:
- Immediate costs associated with revenue losses
- Impact on or limitation of certain provisions of national tax laws
- Risk of abuse of international tax treaty provisions
- Risk of double non-taxation
- Need to amend and/or clarify national legislation to bring it into line with tax treaties
- Problems relating to the capacity of tax authorities to negotiate and administer tax treaties, including obligations concerning the mutual agreement procedure, exchange of information and, in some treaties, assistance in the collection of taxes
17.4 Following the work of the OECD and the G20 on Action 6 (Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances), the OECD included in the Introduction to the OECD Model Convention a section dealing with tax policy aspects relevant to the decision to enter into a tax treaty, amend an existing tax treaty or, as a last resort, terminate a tax treaty. The Committee took note of the circumstances identified by the OECD and recommends that they be considered further in the United Nations Manual for the Negotiation of Bilateral Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries. The relevant section of the Commentary to the OECD Model Convention reads as follows:
15.1 In 1997, the OECD Council adopted a recommendation that the Governments of member countries should continue their efforts to conclude bilateral tax treaties with those member countries and, where appropriate, non-member countries with which they had not yet concluded such treaties. Although the question of whether or not to conclude a tax treaty with another country is decided by each State on the basis of various factors, including both tax and non-tax considerations, tax policy considerations generally play a key role in that decision. The following paragraphs describe some of these tax policy considerations, which are relevant not only to the question of whether a State should conclude a treaty with another State, but also to the question of whether a State should seek to amend or replace an existing treaty or even, as a last resort, terminate a treaty (bearing in mind that termination of a treaty often has a negative impact on a large number of taxpayers who are not involved in the situations giving rise to the termination).
15.2 Since the main purpose of tax treaties is to avoid double taxation in order to reduce tax obstacles to cross-border services, trade and investment, the existence of risks of double taxation arising from the interaction of the tax systems of two States will be a primary tax policy concern. Such risks of double taxation will generally be more significant where there is, or is expected to be, a substantial volume of cross-border trade and investment between the two States. Most provisions of tax treaties are aimed at reducing double taxation by allocating taxing rights between the two States, and it is assumed that where a State accepts provisions of a treaty that limit its right to tax items of income, it generally does so on the understanding that those items of income are subject to taxation in the other State. If a State does not impose, or imposes only insignificant, taxes on income, other States should consider whether there are risks of double taxation that would, in themselves, justify the conclusion of a tax treaty. States should also consider whether there are elements in the tax system of the other State that may increase the risk of non-payment of taxes, which may include tax benefits that are isolated from the domestic economy.
15.3 Accordingly, two States considering the possibility of concluding a tax treaty should assess the extent to which the risk of double taxation actually exists in cross-border situations involving their residents. A large number of cases of juridical double taxation affecting residents can be eliminated through domestic provisions for relief from double taxation (usually in the form of either an exemption or a credit method), which operate without the need to conclude tax treaties. Although these domestic provisions are likely to address most forms of juridical double taxation arising from the interaction of residence and source taxation, they will not cover all cases of double taxation, particularly where there are significant differences in source rules between the two States or where the domestic laws of those States do not allow unilateral relief from economic double taxation (for example, in the case of a transfer pricing adjustment made in another State).
15.4 Another tax policy consideration relevant to the conclusion of a tax treaty is the risk of excessive taxation that may arise as a result of high withholding taxes in the Source State. Although mechanisms for the relief of double taxation generally ensure that such high withholding taxes do not result in double taxation, to the extent that such taxes imposed in the Source State exceed the amount of tax normally imposed on profits in the State of Residence, they may have an adverse effect on cross-border trade and investment.
15.5 Additional tax considerations that should be taken into account when considering the conclusion of a tax treaty include various features of tax treaties that encourage and stimulate economic relations between countries, such as protection against discriminatory tax treatment of foreign investment provided by the non-discrimination rules of Article 24, greater certainty of the tax treatment for taxpayers entitled to treaty benefits, and the fact that tax treaties provide a mechanism for resolving cross-border tax disputes through the mutual agreement procedure, together with the possibility for the Contracting States to resort to arbitration.
15.6 Since an important objective of tax treaties is the prevention of tax evasion, States should also consider whether their prospective treaty partners are willing and able to effectively implement the provisions of tax treaties concerning administrative assistance, such as the ability to exchange tax information, which is a key aspect to be taken into account when deciding whether or not to conclude a tax treaty. The ability and willingness of a State to provide assistance in the collection of taxes is also an important factor to be considered. However, it should be noted that in the absence of any actual risk of double taxation, these administrative provisions alone do not provide sufficient grounds for the existence of a tax treaty, since such administrative assistance can be provided through more targeted alternative arrangements, such as the conclusion of a tax information exchange agreement or participation in the Multilateral Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters.8
8 Available at: http://www.oecd.org/ctp/ exchange-of-tax-information/ENG-Amended-Convention.pdf.
D. MAIN FEATURES OF THIS REVISION OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
- The main differences between the articles of this version of the United Nations Model Convention and the previous version, published in 2012, are as follows:
- The amended title of the Convention and the new preamble to the Convention emphasize that treaties should not create opportunities for tax avoidance or evasion, including through the abuse of international tax treaty provisions;
- A new version of Article 1, which includes a provision concerning a fiscally transparent entity, as well as a saving clause clarifying that the taxation of residents is generally preserved under tax treaties;
- An amended version of Article 4, which includes a new “tie-breaker” rule for determining the treaty residence of persons other than individuals that have dual residence;
- An amended version of Article 5 to prevent the avoidance of permanent establishment status;
- An amended version of Article 10 to change the circumstances in which a reduced rate applies to dividends from direct ownership of shares exceeding the 25 per cent threshold;
- A new Article 12A, providing for taxation at source of fees for technical services;
- A new version of paragraph 4 of Article 13, changing the scope of application of the rule concerning land-rich companies;
- An amended version of paragraph 5 of Article 13 to ensure consistency with paragraph 4 of Article 13;
- Amendments to Articles 23A and 23B, clarifying that there is no obligation to provide relief in respect of tax levied solely on the basis of residence;
- A new Article 29, containing provisions concerning entitlement to treaty benefits. These include a limitation-on-benefits rule, a third-State permanent establishment provision and a general anti-abuse rule.
- Amendments have been made to the Commentaries on the articles to reflect the above-mentioned changes.
E. COMMENTARIES
- The Commentaries on the articles are considered an integral part of the United Nations Model Convention, together with the articles themselves. The United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention between Developed and Developing Countries is referred to in the Commentaries on the articles as the United Nations Model Convention. The OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital is referred to in the Commentaries on the articles as the OECD Model Convention, and, unless otherwise indicated, the 2014 version of that Model Convention is meant. In some cases, wording from an earlier version of the OECD Commentary is quoted as being more relevant than the 2014 version for the interpretation of the United Nations Model Convention, and such cases are specifically indicated.
- In the Commentaries on the articles of the OECD Model Convention, certain paragraphs or entire passages are sometimes partially or wholly omitted because, for some reason, they are not applicable to the interpretation of the United Nations Model Convention. In such cases, the omissions are indicated by an ellipsis […]. It should not always be assumed that such an omission, in itself, represents any disagreement with the content of the omitted provisions; rather, the context of the omitted passage should be taken into account in determining whether the omitted wording was considered irrelevant to the interpretation of the United Nations Model Convention or, conversely, was left for consideration at a later stage. In some cases, the wording of the OECD Model Convention is reproduced with minor amendments, indicated by square brackets ([ ]) to reflect the relevant differences from the United Nations Model Convention, such as the retention of the concept of a “fixed base”. Where the quoted extracts from the OECD Model Convention contain footnotes, those footnotes are renumbered rather than retaining their original OECD numbering.
- When citing the articles and Commentaries of the OECD Model Convention, it should be noted that various OECD member States have expressed “reservations” on certain articles and made “observations” on particular aspects of the Commentaries, while some non-OECD member States have expressed “positions” with respect to certain articles and Commentaries. These official expressions of differences of opinion with the OECD Model Convention are included in the text of the OECD Model Convention and are periodically amended. In preparing this update of the United Nations Model Convention, the Committee recognized that such expressions of countries' views are a useful aspect of the OECD Model Convention in terms of understanding how it is interpreted and applied by the particular countries expressing those views, although, for practical reasons, they have not been reproduced in the text of the United Nations Model Convention.
- This updated version of the United Nations Model Convention often reflects positions on which consensus could not be reached, while, for example, also noting the differing positions of one or more member States. This has made it possible to ensure a broader expression of views and approaches which, in the opinion of the Committee, may assist in the interpretation and application of bilateral tax treaties. However, this should not be taken to mean that any individual member of the Committee holds a particular opinion on any specific issue addressed in this Convention. Furthermore, in some cases, the views reflected in the Commentaries relate to discussions held by the former Group of Experts or by the Committee before or after particular individuals served as its members.
- We are grateful to the Secretariat of the Financing for Development Office, including Michael Lennard, Secretary of the Committee, for assistance in preparing this update, as well as for the technical support provided by Brian Arnold, Claire McLellan, Bob Michel and Jacques Sasseville. We also express our appreciation for the editorial assistance provided by Mary Lee Cortes and Janine Mueller.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
A. ORIGIN OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
B. SPECIAL FEATURES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
C. TAX POLICY ISSUES RELEVANT TO THE DECISION TO ENTER INTO A TAX TREATY OR TO AMEND AN EXISTING TREATY
D. MAIN FEATURES OF THIS REVISION OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION
E. COMMENTARIES
Part One
ARTICLES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL DOUBLE TAXATION CONVENTION BETWEEN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
SUMMARY OF THE CONVENTION
TITLE OF THE CONVENTION
PREAMBLE TO THE CONVENTION
Chapter I SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
Chapter II DEFINITIONS
Chapter III TAXATION OF INCOME
Chapter IV TAXATION OF CAPITAL
CHAPTER V METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
Chapter VI SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Chapter VII FINAL PROVISIONS
PART TWO
COMMENTARIES ON THE ARTICLES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL DOUBLE TAXATION CONVENTION BETWEEN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER I SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
Article 1 PERSONS COVERED
Article 2 TAXES COVERED
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER II DEFINITIONS
Article 3 GENERAL DEFINITIONS
Article 4 RESIDENT
Article 5 PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER III TAXATION OF INCOME
Article 6 INCOME FROM IMMOVABLE PROPERTY
Article 7 BUSINESS PROFITS
Article 8 INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING AND AIR TRANSPORT
Article 9 ASSOCIATED ENTERPRISES
Article 10 DIVIDENDS
Article 11 INTEREST
Article 12 ROYALTIES
Article 12A FEES FOR TECHNICAL SERVICES
Article 13 CAPITAL GAINS
Article 14 INDEPENDENT PERSONAL SERVICES
Article 15 INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT
Article 16 DIRECTORS' FEES AND REMUNERATION OF TOP-LEVEL MANAGERIAL OFFICIALS
Article 17 ENTERTAINERS AND SPORTSPERSONS
Article 18 PENSIONS AND SOCIAL SECURITY PAYMENTS
Article 19 GOVERNMENT SERVICE
Article 20 STUDENTS
Article 21 OTHER INCOME
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER IV TAXATION OF CAPITAL
Article 22 CAPITAL
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER V METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
Article 23 METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
Article 24 NON-DISCRIMINATION
Article 25 MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
Article 26 EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION
Article 27 ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES
Article 28 MEMBERS OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR OFFICERS
Article 29 ENTITLEMENT TO BENEFITS
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER VII FINAL PROVISIONS
Fix broken footnote links and formattingSeparate quoted OECD commentary clearly
Articles 30 and 31. ENTRY INTO FORCE AND TERMINATION
Part One
ARTICLES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL DOUBLE TAXATION CONVENTION BETWEEN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
SUMMARY OF THE CONVENTION
Title and Preamble
CHAPTER I
Scope of the Convention
Article 1 Persons Covered
Article 2 Taxes Covered
CHAPTER II
Definitions
Article 3 General Definitions
Article 4 Resident
Article 5 Permanent Establishment
CHAPTER III
Taxation of Income
Article 6 Income from Immovable Property
Article 7 Business Profits
Article 8 International Shipping and Air Transport (Alternatives A and B)
Article 9 Associated Enterprises
Article 10 Dividends
Article 11 Interest
Article 12 Royalties
Article 12A Fees for Technical Services
Article 13 Capital Gains
Article 14 Independent Personal Services
Article 15 Income from Employment
Article 16 Directors' Fees and Remuneration of Top-Level Managers
Article 17 Artistes and Sportspersons
Article 18 Pensions and Social Security Payments (Alternatives A and B)
Article 19 Government Service
Article 20 Students
Article 21 Other Income
CHAPTER IV
Taxation of Capital
Article 22 Capital
CHAPTER V
Methods for the Elimination of Double Taxation
Article 23 A Exemption Method
Article 23 B Credit Method
CHAPTER VI
Special Provisions
Article 24 Non-Discrimination
Article 25 Mutual Agreement Procedure (Alternatives A and B)
Article 26 Exchange of Information
Article 27 Assistance in the Collection of Taxes
Article 28 Members of Diplomatic Missions and Consular Officers
Article 29 Entitlement to Benefits
CHAPTER VII
Final Provisions
Article 30 Entry into Force
Article 31 Termination
TITLE OF THE CONVENTION
Convention between ("State A") and ("State B") for the Elimination of Double Taxation with Respect to Taxes on Income and Capital and the Prevention of Tax Avoidance and Evasion
PREAMBLE TO THE CONVENTION⁹
(State A) and (State B),
Desiring to further develop their economic relations and to enhance their cooperation in tax matters,
Intending to conclude a Convention for the elimination of double taxation with respect to taxes on income and capital without creating opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax evasion or avoidance (including through treaty-shopping arrangements aimed at obtaining reliefs provided under this Convention for the indirect benefit of residents of third States), have agreed as follows:
CHAPTER I SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
Article 1
PERSONS COVERED
1. This Convention shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States.
2. For the purposes of this Convention, income derived by or through an entity or arrangement that is treated as wholly or partly fiscally transparent under the tax law of either Contracting State shall be considered to be income of a resident of a Contracting State, but only to the extent that the income is treated, for the purposes of taxation by that State, as the income of a resident of that State.
3. This Convention shall not affect the taxation by a Contracting State of its residents, except with respect to the benefits granted under [paragraph 3 of Article 7], paragraph 2 of Article 9 and Articles 19, 20, 23 A [23 B], 24 and 25 A [25 B] and 28.
⁹ The Preamble to the Convention shall be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedures of the Contracting States.
Article 2
TAXES COVERED
1. This Convention shall apply to taxes on income and on capital imposed on behalf of a Contracting State or of its political subdivisions or local authorities, irrespective of the manner in which they are levied.
2. There shall be regarded as taxes on income and on capital all taxes imposed on total income, total capital, or on elements of income or capital, including taxes on gains from the alienation of movable or immovable property, taxes on the total amounts of wages or salaries paid by enterprises, as well as taxes on capital appreciation.
3. The existing taxes to which the Convention shall apply are, in particular:
a) (in State A): ................
b) (in State B): ................
4. The Convention shall also apply to any identical or substantially similar taxes that are imposed after the date of signature of the Convention in addition to, or in place of, the existing taxes.
5. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall notify each other of any significant changes made to their tax laws.
CHAPTER II DEFINITIONS
Article 3
GENERAL DEFINITIONS
1. For the purposes of this Convention, unless the context otherwise requires:
a) the term "person" means an individual, a company or any other body of persons;
b) b) the term "company" means any body corporate or any entity that is treated as a body corporate for tax purposes;
c) c) the terms "enterprise of a Contracting State" and "enterprise of the other Contracting State" mean, respectively, an enterprise carried on by a resident of a Contracting State and an enterprise carried on by a resident of the other Contracting State;
d) d) the term "international traffic" means any transport by ship or aircraft, except when the ship or aircraft is operated solely between places in a Contracting State and the enterprise operating the ship or aircraft is not an enterprise of that State;
e) e) the term "competent authority" means:
i) (in State A): ...............
ii) ii) (in State B): .................
f) the term "national" means:
i) any individual possessing the nationality of a Contracting State;
ii) any legal person, partnership or association deriving its status as such from the laws in force in a Contracting State.
2. As regards the application of the Convention at any time by a Contracting State, any term not defined therein shall, unless the context otherwise requires, have the meaning that it has at that time under the law of that State for the purposes of the taxes to which the Convention applies, any meaning under the applicable tax laws of that State prevailing over a meaning given to the term under other laws of that State.
Article 4
RESIDENT
1. For the purposes of this Convention, the term "resident of a Contracting State" means any person who, under the laws of that State, is liable to tax therein by reason of domicile, residence, place of registration, place of management or any other criterion of a similar nature, and also includes that State and any political subdivision or local authority thereof. This term, however, does not include any person who is liable to tax in that State only in respect of income from sources in that State or capital situated therein.
2. Where by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1 an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, his status shall be determined as follows:
a) he shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which he has a permanent home available to him; if he has a permanent home available to him in both States, he shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State with which his personal and economic relations are closer (centre of vital interests);
b) if the State in which the individual has his centre of vital interests cannot be determined, or if he has no permanent home available to him in either State, he shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which he has an habitual abode;
c) if he has an habitual abode in both States or in neither of them, he shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State of which he is a national;
c) if he is a national of both States or of neither of them, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall settle the question by mutual agreement.
3. Where by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1 a person other than an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to determine by mutual agreement the Contracting State of which such person shall be deemed to be a resident for the purposes of the Convention, having regard to its place of effective management, the place where it is incorporated or otherwise established, and any other relevant factors. In the absence of such agreement, such person shall not be entitled to any reliefs or exemptions from tax provided for by this Convention, except to the extent and in the manner that the competent authorities of the Contracting States may agree.
Article 5
PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT
1. For the purposes of this Convention, the term "permanent establishment" means a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on.
2. The term "permanent establishment" includes especially:
(a) a place of management;
(b) a branch;
(c) an office;
(d) a factory;
(e) a workshop;
(f) a mine, an oil or gas well, a quarry or any other place of extraction of natural resources.
3. The term "permanent establishment" also includes:
a) a building site, a construction, assembly or installation project or supervisory activities in connection therewith, but only if the duration of such site, project or activities exceeds six months;
b) the furnishing of services, including consultancy services, by an enterprise through employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for such purpose, but only where activities of that nature continue (for the same or a connected project) within a Contracting State for a period or periods aggregating more than 183 days within any twelve-month period.
4. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, the term "permanent establishment" shall be deemed not to include:
a) the use of facilities solely for the purpose of storage or display of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
b) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of storage or display;
c) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of processing by another enterprise;
d) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise or of collecting information for the enterprise;
e) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of carrying on, for the enterprise, any other activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character;
f) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for any combination of activities mentioned in subparagraphs (a) to (e), provided that the overall activity of the fixed place of business resulting from this combination is of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
4.1 Paragraph 4 shall not apply to a fixed place of business that is used or maintained by an enterprise if the same enterprise or a closely related enterprise carries on business activities at the same place or at another place in the same Contracting State and:
(a) that place or other place constitutes a permanent establishment for the enterprise or the closely related enterprise under the provisions of this Article; or
(b) the overall activity resulting from the combination of the activities carried on by the two enterprises at the same place, or by the same enterprise or closely related enterprises at the two places, is not of a preparatory or auxiliary character,
provided that the business activities carried on by the two enterprises at the same place, or by the same enterprise or closely related enterprises at the two places, constitute complementary functions that are part of a cohesive business operation.
5. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 7, where a person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise, that enterprise shall be deemed to have a permanent establishment in that State in respect of any activities which that person undertakes for the enterprise, if such person:
(a) habitually concludes contracts, or habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification, and these contracts are concluded:
(i) in the name of the enterprise; or
(ii) for the transfer of the ownership of, or for the granting of the right to use, property owned by that enterprise or which the enterprise has the right to use; or
(iii) for the provision of services by that enterprise,
unless the activities of such person are limited to those mentioned in paragraph 4 which, if exercised through a fixed place of business (other than a fixed place of business to which paragraph 4.1 applies), would not make this fixed place of business a permanent establishment under the provisions of that paragraph; or
(b) such person does not habitually conclude contracts or play the principal role leading to the conclusion of such contracts, but habitually maintains in that State a stock of goods or merchandise from which such person regularly delivers goods or merchandise on behalf of the enterprise.
6. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 7, an insurance enterprise of a Contracting State, other than in respect of reinsurance, shall be deemed to have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State if it collects premiums in the territory of that other State or insures risks situated therein through a person.
7. Paragraphs 5 and 6 shall not apply where the person acting in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise of the other Contracting State carries on business in the first-mentioned State as an independent agent and acts for the enterprise in the ordinary course of that business. However, where a person acts exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of one or more enterprises to which it is closely related, such person shall not be considered to be an independent agent within the meaning of this paragraph in respect of any such enterprise.
8. The fact that a company which is a resident of a Contracting State controls or is controlled by a company which is a resident of the other Contracting State, or which carries on business in that other State (whether through a permanent establishment or otherwise), shall not of itself constitute either company a permanent establishment of the other.
9. For the purposes of this Article, a person or enterprise is closely related to an enterprise if, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, one controls the other or both are under the control of the same persons or enterprises. In any case, a person or enterprise shall be considered to be closely related to an enterprise if one possesses directly or indirectly more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interest in the other (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 per cent of the aggregate vote and value of the company's shares or of the beneficial equity interest in the company) or if another person or enterprise possesses directly or indirectly more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interest (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 per cent of the aggregate vote and value of the company's shares or of the beneficial equity interest in the company) in the person and the enterprise or in the two enterprises.
CHAPTER III TAXATION OF INCOME
Article 6
INCOME FROM IMMOVABLE PROPERTY
1. Income derived by a resident of a Contracting State from immovable property (including income from agriculture or forestry) situated in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. The term "immovable property" shall have the meaning which it has under the law of the Contracting State in which the property in question is situated. The term shall in any case include property accessory to immovable property, livestock and equipment used in agriculture and forestry, rights to which the provisions of general law respecting landed property apply, usufruct of immovable property and rights to variable or fixed payments as consideration for the working of, or the right to work, mineral deposits, mineral springs and other natural resources; ships, boats and aircraft shall not be regarded as immovable property.
3. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall apply to income derived from the direct use, letting, or use in any other form of immovable property.
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 3 shall also apply to income from immovable property of an enterprise and to income from immovable property used for the performance of independent personal services.
Article 7
BUSINESS PROFITS
1. The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein. If the enterprise carries on business as aforesaid, the profits of the enterprise may be taxed in the other State, but only so much of them as is attributable to:
a) that permanent establishment;
b) sales in that other State of goods or merchandise of the same or similar kind as those sold through that permanent establishment; or
c) other business activities carried on in that other State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment.
2. Subject to the provisions of paragraph 3, where an enterprise of a Contracting State carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein, there shall in each Contracting State be attributed to that permanent establishment the profits which it might be expected to make if it were a distinct and separate enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and dealing wholly independently with the enterprise of which it is a permanent establishment.
3. In determining the profits of a permanent establishment, there shall be allowed as deductions expenses which are incurred for the purposes of the business of the permanent establishment, including executive and general administrative expenses so incurred, whether in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated or elsewhere. However, no such deduction shall be allowed in respect of amounts, if any, paid (otherwise than towards reimbursement of actual expenses) by the permanent establishment to the head office of the enterprise or any of its other offices, by way of royalties, fees or other similar payments in return for the use of patents or other rights, or by way of commission for specific services performed or for management, or, except in the case of a banking enterprise, by way of interest on money lent to the permanent establishment. Likewise, no account shall be taken, in determining the profits of a permanent establishment, of amounts charged (otherwise than towards reimbursement of actual expenses) by the permanent establishment to the head office of the enterprise or any of its other offices, by way of royalties, fees or other similar payments in return for the use of patents or other rights, or by way of commission for specific services performed or for management, or, except in the case of a banking enterprise, by way of interest on money lent to the head office of the enterprise or any of its other offices.
4. Insofar as it has been customary in a Contracting State to determine the profits to be attributed to a permanent establishment on the basis of an apportionment of the total profits of the enterprise to its various parts, nothing in paragraph 2 shall preclude that Contracting State from determining the profits to be taxed by such an apportionment as may be customary; the method of apportionment adopted shall, however, be such that the result shall be in accordance with the principles contained in this Article.
5. For the purposes of the preceding paragraphs, the profits to be attributed to the permanent establishment shall be determined by the same method year by year unless there is a good and sufficient reason to the contrary.
6. Where profits include items of income which are dealt with separately in other Articles of this Convention, then the provisions of those Articles shall not be affected by the provisions of this Article.
(Note: The question whether any profits should be attributed to a permanent establishment by reason of the mere purchase by that permanent establishment of goods or merchandise for the enterprise has been left unresolved. It should therefore be decided during bilateral negotiations.)
Article 8
INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING AND AIR TRANSPORT
Article 8 (Alternative A)
- Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic shall be taxable only in that State.
- The provisions of paragraph 1 shall also apply to profits from participation in a pool, a joint venture or an international operating agency.
Article 8 (Alternative B)
- Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic shall be taxable only in that State.
- Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of ships in international traffic shall be taxable only in that State, unless the shipping activities arising from such operation in the other Contracting State are more than incidental. If such activities are more than incidental, such profits may be taxed in that other State. The profits taxable in that other State shall be determined on the basis of an appropriate allocation of the total net profits derived by the enterprise from its shipping operations. The tax calculated in accordance with such allocation shall then be reduced by ___ per cent. (The percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations).
- The provisions of paragraph 1 shall also apply to profits from participation in a pool, a joint venture or an international operating agency.
Article 9
ASSOCIATED ENTERPRISES
- Where:
(a) an enterprise of one Contracting State participates directly or indirectly in the management, control or capital of an enterprise of the other Contracting State; or
(b) the same persons participate directly or indirectly in the management, control or capital of an enterprise of one Contracting State and an enterprise of the other Contracting State;
and in either case conditions are made or imposed between the two enterprises in their commercial or financial relations which differ from those which would be made between independent enterprises, then any profits which would, but for those conditions, have accrued to one of the enterprises, but, by reason of those conditions, have not so accrued, may be included in the profits of that enterprise and taxed accordingly.
- Where a Contracting State includes in the profits of an enterprise of that State, and taxes accordingly, profits on which an enterprise of the other Contracting State has been charged to tax in that other State, and the profits so included are profits which would have accrued to the enterprise of the first-mentioned State if the conditions made between the two enterprises had been those which would have been made between independent enterprises, then that other State shall make an appropriate adjustment to the amount of tax charged therein on those profits. In determining such adjustment, due regard shall be had to the other provisions of the Convention and the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall, if necessary, consult each other.
- The provisions of paragraph 2 shall not apply where, as a result of judicial, administrative or other legal proceedings, a final decision has been made that, by reason of adjustments to profits under paragraph 1, one of the enterprises concerned is liable to a penalty for fraud, gross negligence or wilful default.
Article 10
DIVIDENDS
- Dividends paid by a company which is a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- However, such dividends may also be taxed in the Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident and according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the dividends is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed:
(a) ___ per cent (the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations) of the gross amount of the dividends if the beneficial owner is a company (other than a partnership) which directly holds at least 25 per cent of the capital of the company paying the dividends throughout a 365-day period that includes the day of payment of the dividends (for the purposes of calculating this period, no account shall be taken of changes in ownership that would directly result from a corporate reorganisation, such as a merger or demerger, of the company holding the shares or paying the dividends);
(b) ___ per cent (the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations) of the gross amount of the dividends in all other cases.
The manner of application of these limitations shall be settled by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States. This paragraph shall not affect the taxation of the company in respect of the profits out of which the dividends are paid.
- The term "dividends" as used in this Article means income from shares, jouissance shares or jouissance rights, mining shares, founders' shares or other rights, not being debt-claims, participating in profits, as well as income from other corporate rights which is subjected to the same taxation treatment as income from shares by the laws of the State of which the company making the distribution is a resident.
- The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the dividends, being a resident of one Contracting State, carries on business in the other Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs independent personal services in that other State from a fixed base situated therein, and the holding in respect of which the dividends are paid is effectively connected with such permanent establishment or fixed base. In such case, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
- Where a company which is a resident of one Contracting State derives profits or income from the other Contracting State, that other State may not impose any tax on the dividends paid by the company, except insofar as such dividends are paid to a resident of that other State or insofar as the holding in respect of which the dividends are paid is effectively connected with a permanent establishment or a fixed base situated in that other State, nor subject the company's undistributed profits to a tax on undistributed profits, even if the dividends paid or the undistributed profits consist wholly or partly of profits or income arising in that other State.
Article 11
INTEREST
- Interest arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- However, such interest may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which it arises and according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the interest is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed ___ per cent (the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations) of the gross amount of the interest. The manner of application of this limitation shall be settled by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States.
- The term "interest" as used in this Article means income from debt-claims of every kind, whether or not secured by mortgage and whether or not carrying a right to participate in the debtor's profits, and in particular, income from government securities and income from bonds or debentures, including premiums and prizes attaching to such securities, bonds or debentures. Penalty charges for late payment shall not be regarded as interest for the purpose of this Article.
- The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the interest, being a resident of one Contracting State, carries on business in the other Contracting State in which the interest arises through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs independent personal services in that State from a fixed base situated therein, and the debt-claim in respect of which the interest is paid is effectively connected with:
(a) such permanent establishment or fixed base; or
(b) the business activities referred to in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7.
In such cases, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
- Interest shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State when the payer is a resident of that State. However, where the person paying the interest, whether that person is a resident of a Contracting State or not, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or a fixed base in connection with which the indebtedness on which the interest is paid was incurred, and such interest is borne by such permanent establishment or fixed base, then such interest shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
- Where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person, the amount of the interest, having regard to the debt-claim for which it is paid, exceeds the amount which would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner in the absence of such relationship, the provisions of this Article shall apply only to the last-mentioned amount. In such case, the excess part of the payments shall remain taxable according to the laws of each Contracting State, due regard being had to the other provisions of this Convention.
Article 12
ROYALTIES
- Royalties arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- However, such royalties may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise and according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the royalties is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed ____ per cent (the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations) of the gross amount of the royalties. The manner of application of this limitation shall be settled by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States.
- The term "royalties" as used in this Article means payments of any kind received as consideration for the use of, or the right to use, any copyright of literary, artistic or scientific work, including cinematograph films or films and sound recordings used for radio or television broadcasting, any patent, trade mark, design or model, plan, secret formula or process, or for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, or for information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience.
- The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the royalties, being a resident of one Contracting State, carries on business in the other Contracting State in which the royalties arise through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs independent personal services in that State from a fixed base situated therein, and the right or property in respect of which the royalties are paid is effectively connected with:
(a) such permanent establishment or fixed base; or
(b) the business activities referred to in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7.
In such cases, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
- Royalties shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State when the payer is a resident of that State. However, where the person paying the royalties, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or a fixed base in connection with which the obligation to pay the royalties was incurred, and such royalties are borne by such permanent establishment or fixed base, then such royalties shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
- Where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person, the amount of the royalties, having regard to the use, right or information for which they are paid, exceeds the amount which would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner in the absence of such relationship, the provisions of this Article shall apply only to the last-mentioned amount. In such case, the excess part of the payments shall remain taxable according to the laws of each Contracting State, due regard being had to the other provisions of this Convention.
Article 12A
FEES FOR TECHNICAL SERVICES
- Fees for technical services arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 14 and subject to the provisions of Articles 8, 16 and 17, fees for technical services arising in a Contracting State may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise and according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the fees is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed ___ per cent of the gross amount of the fees [the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations].
- The term "fees for technical services" as used in this Article means any payment in consideration for any service of a managerial, technical or consultancy nature, unless the payment is made:
(a) to an employee of the person making the payment;
(b) for teaching in or by an educational institution; or
(c) by an individual for services for the personal use of that individual.
- The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the fees for technical services, being a resident of one Contracting State, carries on business in the other Contracting State in which the fees for technical services arise through a permanent establishment situated in that other State, or performs independent personal services in the other Contracting State from a fixed base situated in that other State, and the fees for technical services are effectively connected with:
(a) such permanent establishment or fixed base; or
(b) the business activities referred to in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7.
In such cases, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
- For the purposes of this Article, subject to paragraph 6, fees for technical services shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State or if the person paying the fees, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or a fixed base in connection with which the obligation to pay the fees was incurred, and in such case the obligation to pay is borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base.
- For the purposes of this Article, fees for technical services shall be deemed not to arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State and carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated in that other State, or performs independent personal services through a fixed base situated in that other State, and such obligation to pay the fees is borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base.
- Where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner of the fees for technical services or between both of them and some other person, the amount of the fees, having regard to the services for which they are paid, exceeds the amount which would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner in the absence of such relationship, the provisions of this Article shall apply only to the last-mentioned amount. In such case, the excess part of the fees shall remain taxable according to the laws of each Contracting State, due regard being had to the other provisions of this Convention.
Article 13
CAPITAL GAINS
- Gains derived by a resident of one Contracting State from the alienation of immovable property referred to in Article 6 and situated in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- Gains from the alienation of movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State, or of movable property pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing independent personal services, including gains from the alienation of such permanent establishment (alone or together with the whole enterprise) or of such fixed base, may be taxed in that other State.
- Profits derived by an enterprise of a Contracting State operating ships or aircraft in international traffic from the alienation of such ships or aircraft or movable property pertaining to the operation of such ships or aircraft shall be taxable only in that State.
- Gains derived by a resident of one Contracting State from the alienation of shares or comparable interests, such as interests in a partnership or trust, may be taxed in the other Contracting State if, at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, such shares or comparable interests derived more than 50 per cent of their value directly or indirectly from immovable property, as defined in Article 6, situated in that other State.
- Gains, other than those to which paragraph 4 applies, derived by a resident of one Contracting State from the alienation of shares in a company or comparable interests, such as interests in a partnership or trust, which is a resident of the other Contracting State, may be taxed in that other State if the alienator, at any time during the 365 days preceding such alienation, directly or indirectly held at least ___ per cent (the percentage shall be determined through bilateral negotiations) of the capital of that company or entity.
- Gains from the alienation of any property other than that referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 shall be taxable only in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident.
Article 14
INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS' SERVICES
- Income derived by a resident of one Contracting State in respect of professional services or other activities of an independent character shall be taxable only in that State, except in the following circumstances, in which such income may also be taxed in the other Contracting State:
(a) if a fixed base is regularly available to the individual in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing his activities; in such case, only so much of the income as is attributable to that fixed base may be taxed in that other Contracting State; or
(b) if the period or periods of his stay in the other Contracting State during any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned total 183 days or more; in such case, only so much of the income as is derived from his activities in that State may be taxed in that other State.
- The term "professional services" includes, in particular, independent scientific, literary, artistic, educational or teaching activities, as well as the independent activities of physicians, lawyers, engineers, architects, dentists and accountants.
Article 15
INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT
- Subject to the provisions of Articles 16, 18 and 19, salaries, wages and other similar remuneration derived by a resident of one Contracting State in respect of an employment shall be taxable only in that State unless the employment is exercised in the other Contracting State. If the employment is so exercised, such remuneration as is derived therefrom may be taxed in that other State.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, remuneration derived by a resident of one Contracting State in respect of an employment exercised in the other Contracting State shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State if:
(a) the period or periods of stay of the recipient in that other State during any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned do not exceed 183 days in the aggregate; and
(b) the remuneration is paid by, or on behalf of, an employer who is not a resident of the other State; and
(c) the remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment or a fixed base which the employer has in the other State.
- Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, remuneration derived by a resident of one Contracting State in respect of an employment as a member of the regular crew of a ship or aircraft, exercised aboard a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic, and not aboard a ship or aircraft operated solely within the other Contracting State, shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State.
Add a clear document titleStandardize placeholder formatting
Ниже приведён полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением структуры, нумерации, вариантов положений, примечаний, пропусков и квадратных скобок оригинала.
Article 16
DIRECTORS’ FEES AND REMUNERATION OF TOP-LEVEL MANAGERS
- Directors’ fees and other similar payments received by a resident of one of the Contracting States in the capacity of a member of the board of directors of a company which is a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- Salaries, wages and other similar remuneration received by a resident of one of the Contracting States in the capacity of an official holding a top-level managerial position in a company which is a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
Article 17
ENTERTAINERS AND SPORTSPERSONS
- Notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 14 and 15, income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States as a professional entertainer, such as a theatre, motion picture, radio or television artiste, or a musician, or as a sportsperson, from his personal activities as such exercised in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
- Where income in respect of personal activities exercised by a professional entertainer or sportsperson in his capacity as such accrues not to the entertainer or sportsperson himself but to another person, such income may, notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 7, 14 and 15, be taxed in the Contracting State in which the activities of the professional entertainer or sportsperson are exercised.
Article 18
PENSIONS AND SOCIAL SECURITY PAYMENTS
Article 18 (Alternative A)
- Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of one of the Contracting States in consideration of past employment shall be taxable only in that State.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, pensions and other payments made under a public scheme which is part of the social security system of a Contracting State, or of a political subdivision or local authority thereof, shall be taxable only in that State.
Article 18 (Alternative B)
- Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of one of the Contracting States in consideration of past employment may be taxed in that State.
- However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the other Contracting State if the payment is made by a resident of that other State or by a permanent establishment situated therein.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, pensions and other payments made under a public scheme which is part of the social security system of a Contracting State, or of a political subdivision or local authority thereof, shall be taxable only in that State.
Article 19
GOVERNMENT SERVICE
(a) Salaries, wages and other similar remuneration paid by a Contracting State, or a political subdivision or local authority thereof, to an individual in respect of services rendered to that State or subdivision or authority shall be taxable only in that State.
(b) However, such salaries, wages and other similar remuneration shall be taxable only in the other Contracting State if the services are rendered in that other State and the individual is a resident of that State who:
i) is a national of that State; or
ii) did not become a resident of that State solely for the purpose of rendering the services.
(a) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, pensions and other similar remuneration paid by, or out of funds created by, a Contracting State or a political subdivision or local authority thereof to an individual in respect of services rendered to that State or subdivision or authority shall be taxable only in that State.
(b) However, such pensions and other similar remuneration shall be taxable only in the other Contracting State if the individual is a resident of, and a national of, that other State.
- The provisions of Articles 15, 16, 17 and 18 shall apply to salaries, wages, pensions and other similar remuneration in respect of services rendered in connection with a business carried on by a Contracting State or a political subdivision or local authority thereof.
Article 20
STUDENTS
Payments which a student, trainee or apprentice who is, or was immediately before visiting a Contracting State, a resident of the other Contracting State and who is present in the first-mentioned State solely for the purpose of his education or training receives for the purpose of his maintenance, education or training shall not be taxed in that other State, provided that such payments arise from sources outside that State.
Article 21
OTHER INCOME
- Items of income of a resident of one of the Contracting States, wherever arising, not dealt with in the foregoing Articles of this Convention shall be taxable only in that State.
- The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income, other than income from immovable property as defined in paragraph 2 of Article 6, if the recipient of such income, being a resident of one of the Contracting States, carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs in that other State independent personal services from a fixed base situated therein, and the right or property in respect of which the income is paid is effectively connected with such permanent establishment or fixed base. In such case, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, items of income of a resident of one of the Contracting States not dealt with in the foregoing Articles of this Convention and arising in the other Contracting State may also be taxed in that other State.
CHAPTER IV TAXATION OF CAPITAL
Article 22
CAPITAL
- Capital represented by immovable property referred to in Article 6, owned by a resident of one of the Contracting States and situated in the other Contracting State, may be taxed in that other State.
- Capital represented by movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one of the Contracting States has in the other Contracting State, or by movable property pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident of one of the Contracting States in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing independent personal services, may be taxed in that other State.
- Capital of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States operating ships or aircraft in international traffic, represented by such ships or aircraft and movable property pertaining to the operation of such ships or aircraft, shall be taxable only in that State.
[4. All other elements of capital of a person resident in one of the Contracting States shall be taxable only in that State].
(The question of the taxation of all other elements of capital of a resident of a Contracting State shall be decided in the course of bilateral negotiations. If the parties participating in the negotiations decide to include an article on the taxation of capital in the Convention, they will have to determine whether to use the wording of paragraph 4, as shown, or wording which leaves taxation to the discretion of the State in which the capital is situated).
CHAPTER V METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
Article 23 A
EXEMPTION METHOD
- Where a resident of one of the Contracting States derives income or owns capital which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, may be taxed in the other Contracting State (except where these provisions permit taxation in that other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State or because the capital is also capital owned by a resident of that State), the first-mentioned State shall, subject to the provisions of paragraphs 2 and 3, exempt such income or capital from tax.
- Where a resident of one of the Contracting States derives items of income which, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 and 12A, may be taxed in the other Contracting State, the first-mentioned State shall allow as a deduction from the tax on the income of that resident an amount equal to the tax paid in that other State. Such deduction shall not, however, exceed that part of the tax, as computed before the deduction is given, which is attributable to the items of income derived in that other State.
- Where in accordance with any provision of this Convention income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States, or capital owned by him, is exempt from tax in that State, such State may nevertheless, in calculating the amount of tax on the remaining income or capital of such resident, take into account the exempted income or capital.
- The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income derived by a resident of a Contracting State, or to capital owned by him, where the other Contracting State applies the provisions of this Convention to exempt such income or capital from tax or applies to such income the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10, 11, 12 or 12A; in the latter case, the first-mentioned State shall allow the deduction of tax provided for in paragraph 2.
Article 23 B
TAX CREDIT METHOD
- Where a resident of one of the Contracting States derives income or owns capital which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, may be taxed in the other Contracting State (except where these provisions permit taxation in that other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State or because the capital is also capital owned by a resident of that State), the first-mentioned State shall allow as a deduction from the tax on the income of that resident an amount equal to the income tax paid in that other State; and as a deduction from the tax on the capital of that resident an amount equal to the capital tax paid in that other State. Such deduction shall not, however, in either case exceed that part of the income tax or capital tax, as computed before the deduction is given, which is attributable, as the case may be, to the income or capital which may be taxed in that other State.
- Where in accordance with any provision of this Convention income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States, or capital owned by him, is exempt from tax in that State, such State may nevertheless, in calculating the amount of tax on the remaining income or capital of such resident, take into account the exempted income or capital.
CHAPTER VI SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Article 24
NON-DISCRIMINATION
- Nationals of one of the Contracting States shall not be subjected in the other Contracting State to any taxation or any requirement connected therewith which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which nationals of that other State in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residence, are or may be subjected. This provision shall, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 1, also apply to persons who are not residents of one or both of the Contracting States.
- Stateless persons who are residents of one of the Contracting States shall not be subjected in either Contracting State to any taxation or any requirement connected therewith which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which nationals of the State concerned in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residence, are or may be subjected.
- The taxation on a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one of the Contracting States has in the other Contracting State shall not be less favourably levied in that other State than the taxation levied on enterprises of that other State carrying on the same activities. This provision shall not be construed as obliging one of the Contracting States to grant to residents of the other Contracting State any personal allowances, reliefs and reductions for taxation purposes on account of civil status or family responsibilities which it grants to its own residents.
- Except where the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9, paragraph 6 of Article 11 or paragraph 6 of Article 12 apply, interest, royalties and other disbursements paid by an enterprise of one of the Contracting States to a resident of the other Contracting State shall, for the purpose of determining the taxable profits of such enterprise, be deductible under the same conditions as if they had been paid to a resident of the first-mentioned State. Similarly, any debts of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States to a resident of the other Contracting State shall, for the purpose of determining the taxable capital of such enterprise, be deductible under the same conditions as if they had been contracted to a resident of the first-mentioned State.
- Enterprises of one of the Contracting States, the capital of which is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State, shall not be subjected in the first-mentioned State to any taxation or any requirement connected therewith which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which other similar enterprises of the first-mentioned State are or may be subjected.
- The provisions of this Article shall, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 2, apply to taxes of every kind and description.
Article 25
MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
Article 25 (Alternative A)
- Where a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result or will result for him in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, he may, irrespective of the remedies provided by the domestic law of those States, present his case to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a resident or, if his case comes under paragraph 1 of Article 24, to that of the Contracting State of which he is a national. The case must be presented within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention.
- The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, with a view to the avoidance of taxation which is not in accordance with this Convention. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in the domestic law of the Contracting States.
- The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of this Convention. They may also consult together for the elimination of double taxation in cases not provided for in this Convention.
- The competent authorities of the Contracting States may communicate with each other directly, including through a joint commission consisting of themselves or their representatives, for the purpose of reaching an agreement in the sense of the preceding paragraphs. During consultations, the competent authorities shall develop appropriate bilateral procedures, conditions, methods and techniques for implementing the mutual agreement procedure provided for in this Article.
Article 25 (Alternative B)
- Where a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result or will result for him in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, that person may, irrespective of the remedies provided by the domestic law of those States, present his case to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a resident or, if his case comes under paragraph 1 of Article 24, to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a national. The case must be presented within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention.
- The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, with a view to the avoidance of taxation which is not in accordance with this Convention. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in the domestic law of the Contracting States.
- The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of this Convention. They may also consult together for the elimination of double taxation in cases not provided for in this Convention.
- The competent authorities of the Contracting States may communicate with each other directly, including through a joint commission consisting of themselves or their representatives, for the purpose of reaching an agreement in the sense of the preceding paragraphs. During consultations, the competent authorities shall develop appropriate bilateral procedures, conditions, methods and techniques for implementing the mutual agreement procedure provided for in this Article.
Where
(a) a person has, pursuant to paragraph 1, presented a case to the competent authority of one of the Contracting States on the basis that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States have resulted for that person in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention; and
(b) the competent authorities are unable to reach an agreement to resolve that case pursuant to paragraph 2 within three years from the presentation of the case to the competent authority of the other Contracting State,
any unresolved issues arising from the case shall be submitted to arbitration if either competent authority so requests. The person who presented the case shall be notified of such request. However, these unresolved issues shall not be submitted to arbitration if a decision on these issues has already been rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of either State. The arbitration decision shall be binding on both States and shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in the domestic law of these States, unless both competent authorities agree on a different solution within six months after receiving notification of the decision or unless the person directly affected by the case does not accept the mutual agreement which implements the arbitration decision. The manner in which this paragraph is applied shall be determined by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States.
Article 26
EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION
- The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange such information as may be relevant for carrying out the provisions of this Convention or for the administration or enforcement of the domestic laws concerning taxes of every kind and description imposed on behalf of the Contracting States, or of their political subdivisions or local authorities, insofar as the taxation thereunder is not contrary to the Convention. In particular, information shall be exchanged which enables a Contracting State to take measures to prevent fraud or evasion of such taxes or to combat tax avoidance. The exchange of information is not restricted by Articles 1 and 2.
- Any information received under paragraph 1 by a Contracting State shall be treated as secret in the same manner as information obtained under the domestic laws of that State and shall be disclosed only to persons or authorities (including courts and administrative bodies) concerned with the assessment or collection of the taxes referred to in paragraph 1, the enforcement or prosecution in respect of, or the determination of appeals in relation to, such taxes, or the oversight of the above. Such persons or authorities shall use the information only for such purposes. They may disclose the information in public court proceedings or in judicial decisions. Notwithstanding the foregoing, information received by a Contracting State may be used for other purposes where such information may be used for such other purposes under the laws of both States and the competent authority of the State supplying the information authorises such use.
In no case shall the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 be construed so as to impose on a Contracting State the obligation:
(a) to carry out administrative measures at variance with the laws and administrative practice of that or of the other Contracting State;
(b) to supply information which is not obtainable under the laws or in the normal course of the administration of that or of the other Contracting State;
(c) to supply information which would disclose any trade, business, industrial, commercial or professional secret or trade process, or information the disclosure of which would be contrary to public policy (ordre public).
- If information is requested by one Contracting State in accordance with this Article, the other Contracting State shall use its information-gathering measures to obtain the requested information, even though that other State may not need such information for its own tax purposes. The obligation contained in the preceding sentence is subject to the limitations provided in paragraph 3, but in no case shall such limitations be construed to permit a Contracting State to decline to supply information solely because it has no domestic interest in such information.
- In no case shall the provisions of paragraph 3 be construed to permit a Contracting State to decline to supply information solely because such information is held by a bank, other financial institution, nominee or person acting in an agency or fiduciary capacity, or because it relates to ownership interests in a person.
- The competent authorities shall, in the course of consultations, develop appropriate methods and techniques concerning matters in respect of which information is exchanged under paragraph 1.
Article 27
ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES10
- The Contracting States shall lend assistance to each other in the collection of tax claims. This assistance is not restricted by Articles 1 and 2. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may by mutual agreement settle the mode of application of this Article.
- The term "recovery of tax claims" as used in this Article means any amount of taxes of every kind and description imposed on behalf of the Contracting States, or of their political subdivisions or local authorities, insofar as such taxation is not contrary to the Convention or any other instrument in force between the Contracting States, together with interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or conservancy related to such amount.
- Where a tax claim of a Contracting State is enforceable under the laws of that State and is owed by a person who, at that time, cannot under the laws of that State prevent its collection, such tax claim shall, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for the purposes of collection by the competent authority of the other Contracting State. Such tax claim shall be collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes as if the tax claim were a tax claim of that other State.
- Where a tax claim of a Contracting State is a claim in respect of which that State may, under its laws, take measures of conservancy with a view to ensuring its collection, such tax claim shall, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for the purposes of taking measures of conservancy by the competent authority of the other Contracting State. That other State shall take measures of conservancy in respect of that tax claim in accordance with the provisions of its legislation as if the tax claim were a tax claim of that other State, even if, at the time when such measures are applied, the tax claim is not enforceable in the first-mentioned State or is owed by a person who has the right to prevent its collection.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 3 and 4, a tax claim accepted by a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3 or 4 shall not, in that State, be subject to any time limits or any priority applicable to a tax claim under the laws of that State by reason of its nature as such. In addition, a tax claim accepted by a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3 or 4 shall not, in that State, have any priority applicable to such tax claim under the laws of that other Contracting State.
- Proceedings with respect to the existence, validity or amount of a tax claim of a Contracting State shall not be brought before the courts or administrative bodies of the other Contracting State.
Where, at any time after a request has been made by a Contracting State under paragraph 3 or 4 and before the other Contracting State has collected and transferred the relevant tax claim to the first-mentioned State, the relevant tax claim ceases to be:
(a) in the case of a request under paragraph 3, a tax claim of the first-mentioned State which is enforceable under the laws of that State and is owed by a person who, at that time, cannot under the laws of that State prevent its collection; or
(b) in the case of a request under paragraph 4, a tax claim of the first-mentioned State in respect of which that State may, under its laws, take measures of conservancy with a view to ensuring its collection,
the competent authority of the first-mentioned State shall promptly notify the competent authority of the other State of that fact and, at the discretion of the other State, the first-mentioned State shall either suspend or withdraw its request.
In no case shall the provisions of this Article be construed so as to impose on a Contracting State the obligation:
(a) to carry out administrative measures which are contrary to the laws and administrative practice of that or of the other Contracting State;
(b) to carry out measures which would be contrary to public policy (ordre public);
(c) to provide assistance if the other Contracting State has not pursued all reasonable measures of collection or conservancy, as the case may be, available under its laws or administrative practice;
(d) to provide assistance in cases where it is evident that the administrative costs for that State are disproportionately greater than the benefit to be derived by the other Contracting State.
10 In some countries, the type of assistance provided for in this Article may be prohibited or considered unjustified under domestic law, for political or administrative reasons, or some countries may require the scope of this type of assistance to be limited, for example, to countries having similar tax systems or tax administrations, or to taxes included within the scope of this Convention. For this reason, this Article should be included in the Convention only if each State concludes that, on the basis of the factors described in paragraph 1 of the Commentary on this Article, they will be able to agree to provide mutual assistance in the collection of taxes imposed by the other State.
Article 28
MEMBERS OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR OFFICERS
Nothing in this Convention shall affect the fiscal privileges of members of diplomatic missions or consular officers under the general rules of international law or under the provisions of special agreements.
Article 29
ENTITLEMENT TO BENEFITS11
- Except as otherwise provided in this Article, a resident of a Contracting State shall not be entitled to a benefit that would otherwise be provided under this Convention (other than a benefit provided under paragraph 3 of Article 4, paragraph 2 of Article 9 or Article 25), unless such resident is a "qualified person", as defined in paragraph 2, at the time when the benefit would otherwise be accorded.
A resident of a Contracting State shall be a qualified person at a time when a benefit would otherwise be accorded under the Convention if, at that time, the resident is:
(a) an individual;
(b) a Contracting State, or a political subdivision or local authority thereof, or an agency or instrumentality of such State, political subdivision or local authority;
(c) a company or other entity, if the principal class of its shares (and any disproportionate class of shares) is regularly traded on one or more recognised stock exchanges during the taxable period that includes that time, and either:
(i) its principal class of shares is primarily traded on one or more recognised stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or entity is a resident; or
(ii) the principal place of management and control of the company or entity is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident;
(d) a company, if:
(i) at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company is owned directly or indirectly by five or fewer companies or entities entitled to benefits under subparagraph (c) of this paragraph during the taxable period that includes that time, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a resident of the Contracting State from which the benefit under this Convention is claimed or is a qualified intermediate owner; and
(ii) with respect to benefits under this Convention other than under Article 10, less than 50 per cent of the company's gross income and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments deductible in the taxable period for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (but not including arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of the tested group, not including intra-group transactions) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States and who are not entitled to benefits under subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of this Convention;
(e) a person, other than an individual, which
(i) is [an agreed description of relevant non-profit organisations existing in each Contracting State],
(ii) is a recognised pension fund 12, to which subparagraph (i) of the definition of recognised pension fund in paragraph 1 of Article 3 applies, provided that more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in such person are owned by individuals resident in either of the Contracting States, or more than [__ per cent] of the beneficial interests in such person are owned by individuals resident in either of the Contracting States or any other State in respect of which the following conditions are met:
(A) persons who are residents of that other State are entitled to benefits under a comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation between that other State and the State from which the benefits under this Convention are claimed; and
(B) with respect to income referred to in Articles 10 and 11 of this Convention, if such person were a resident of that other State and entitled to all the benefits of that other convention, it would be entitled under that convention to a tax rate in respect of the particular class of income for which benefits are claimed under this Convention that is at least as low as the rate applicable under this Convention; or
(iii) is a recognised pension fund to which subparagraph (ii) of the definition of recognised pension fund in paragraph 1 of Article 3 applies, provided that it is established and operated exclusively or almost exclusively to invest funds for the benefit of organisations or arrangements referred to in the preceding subparagraph;
(f) a person, other than an individual, if:
(i) at that time and on at least half the days of a twelve-month period that includes that time, persons who are residents of that Contracting State and entitled to benefits under subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of this Convention own, directly or indirectly, shares representing at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) of the shares of that person, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualified intermediate owner; and
(ii) less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the person and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the person (but not including arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of the tested group, not including intra-group transactions) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States and who are not entitled to benefits under subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of this paragraph; or
(g) [a possible provision on collective investment vehicles];
(a) A resident of one of the Contracting States shall be entitled to benefits under this Convention with respect to an item of income derived in the other Contracting State, regardless of whether the resident is a qualified person, if the resident is engaged in the active conduct of a business in the first-mentioned State (other than the business of making or managing investments for the resident's own account, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities activities carried on by a bank or [list financial institutions similar to banks that the Contracting States agree to treat as such], insurance company or registered securities dealer, respectively), and the income derived in the other State is derived in connection with, or is incidental to, that business. For the purposes of this Article, the term "active conduct of a business" shall not include the following activities or any combination thereof:
(i) operating as a holding company;
(ii) exercising overall supervision or administration of a group of companies;
(iii) providing group financing (including cash pooling); or
(iv) making or managing investments, unless these activities are carried on by a bank [list financial institutions similar to banks that the Contracting States agree to treat as such], an insurance enterprise or a registered securities dealer in the ordinary course of its business as such.
(b) If a resident of one of the Contracting States derives an item of income from a business activity carried on by that resident in the other Contracting State, or derives an item of income arising in the other State from a related person, the conditions described in subparagraph (a) shall be considered to be satisfied with respect to such item only if the business activity carried on by the resident in the first-mentioned State, to which the item is related, is substantial in relation to the same or complementary business activity carried on by the resident or such related person in the other Contracting State. Whether a business activity is substantial for the purposes of this paragraph shall be determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances.
(c) For the purposes of applying this paragraph, activities carried on by related persons in relation to a resident of a Contracting State shall be deemed to be carried on by such resident.
- [A provision providing for so-called derivative benefits. The question of how the paragraph on derivative benefits in the Convention should be formulated, following the detailed version, is considered in the Commentary below].
A company resident in a Contracting State which performs the functions of a headquarters company for a multinational group of companies consisting of such company and its direct and indirect subsidiaries shall be entitled to benefits under this Convention with respect to dividends and interest paid by members of its multinational group of companies, regardless of whether the resident is a qualified person. A company shall be considered a headquarters company for this purpose only if:
(a) the principal place of management and control of such company is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident;
(b) the multinational group of companies consists of companies that are residents of and carry on active business activities in at least four States, and the business activities carried on in each of the four States (or four groups of States) generate at least 10 per cent of the gross income of the group;
(c) the enterprises of the multinational group of companies whose activities are carried on in any State other than the Contracting State of residence of such company generate less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the group;
(d) no more than 25 per cent of the gross income of such company is derived from the other Contracting State;
(e) such company is subject to the same income tax rules in its Contracting State of residence as persons referred to in paragraph 3 of this Article; and
(f) less than 50 per cent of the gross income of such company and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (but not including arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property or payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank which is not a related person in relation to such company, and, in the case of the tested group, not including intra-group transactions) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States and who are not entitled to benefits under subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of paragraph 2 of this Convention.
If the requirements of subparagraphs (b), (c) or (d) of this paragraph are not met in respect of the relevant taxable period, they shall be considered to be met if the required ratios are satisfied when the gross income for the preceding four taxable periods is averaged.
- If a resident of a Contracting State is not a qualified person in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 of this Article and is not entitled to benefits under paragraphs 3, 4 or 5, the competent authority of the Contracting State in which benefits have been denied under the preceding provisions of this Article may nevertheless grant the benefits provided for in this Convention, or benefits in respect of a specific item of income or capital, having regard to the object and purpose of this Convention. However, this shall be possible only if such resident demonstrates to the competent authority that neither its establishment, acquisition or maintenance, nor the conduct of its operations, had as one of its principal purposes the obtaining of benefits under this Convention. The competent authority of a Contracting State to which a resident of the other State has submitted a request under this paragraph shall consult with the competent authority of that other State before granting or denying the request.
For the purposes of this and the preceding paragraphs of this Article:
(a) the term "recognised stock exchange" means:
(i) [a list of stock exchanges agreed upon at the time of signature]; and
(ii) any other stock exchange agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States;
(b) in the case of entities other than companies, the term "shares" means interests comparable to shares;
(c) the term "principal class of shares" means the ordinary or common shares of a company or entity, provided that such class of shares represents the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity. If no single class of ordinary or common shares represents the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity, the "principal class of shares" shall be those classes which in the aggregate represent the majority of the aggregate voting power and value;
(d) two persons shall be "related persons" if one directly or indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the beneficial interest in the other person (or, in the case of a company, at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares of the company), or another person directly or indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the beneficial interest (or, in the case of a company, at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares of the company) in each person. In any case, a person shall be related to another person if, based on all relevant facts and circumstances, one controls the other or both are controlled by the same person or persons.
(e) the term "equivalent beneficiary" means:
(i) a resident of any State, provided that:
(A) the resident is entitled to all the benefits under a comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation between that State and the Contracting State from which benefits are claimed under this Convention, on the basis of provisions substantially similar to subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of paragraph 2, or, if the benefit claimed concerns interest or dividends paid by a member of the resident's multinational group of companies, the resident is entitled to benefits under provisions substantially similar to paragraph 5 of this Article in that convention, provided that, if such convention does not contain a detailed limitation on benefits article, such convention shall apply as if the provisions of subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) and (e) of paragraph 2 (including the definitions relevant to the application of the criteria in such subparagraphs) were contained in such convention; and
(B) 1) with respect to income referred to in Article 10, 11, 12 or 12A, if the resident were to derive such income directly, the resident would be entitled under such Convention, a provision of domestic law or any international agreement to a tax rate in respect of such income for which benefits are claimed under this Convention that is less than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention. With respect to a company claiming benefits under paragraph 4 under Article 10 in respect of dividends, for the purposes of this subparagraph:
(I) if the resident is an individual and the company carries on active business activities in the Contracting State of its residence which are substantial in relation to activities that are the same as or complementary to the activities which generated the income from which the dividends are paid, such individual shall be treated as a company. Activities carried on by a person related to the company claiming benefits shall be considered to be carried on by such company. Whether a business activity is substantial shall be determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances; and
(II) if the resident is a company (including an individual treated as a company), for the purpose of determining whether the resident is entitled to a tax rate that is less than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention, indirect ownership by the resident of the capital of the company paying the dividends shall be treated as direct ownership; or
(2) with respect to an item of income referred to in Article 7, 13 or 21 of this Convention, the resident is entitled to benefits under such Convention which are at least as favourable as the benefits claimed under this Convention; and
(C) notwithstanding that the resident may satisfy the requirements of subparagraphs (A) and (B) of this subdivision, if the item of income was derived through an entity that is considered fiscally transparent under the laws of the Contracting State in which the company claiming benefits is situated, if the item of income would not be treated as income of the resident under a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 1 if the resident, rather than the company claiming benefits under paragraph 4 of this Article, itself owned the entity through which the company derives the income, such resident shall not be considered an equivalent beneficiary with respect to that item of income;
(ii) a resident of the same Contracting State as the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4 of this Article who is entitled to all the benefits under this Convention by virtue of subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of paragraph 2, or, where the benefit claimed relates to interest or dividends paid by a member of the resident's multinational group of companies, who is entitled to benefits under paragraph 5, provided that, in the case of a resident described in paragraph 5, if the resident had received such interest or dividends directly, the resident would be entitled to a tax rate in respect of such income that is less than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention to the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4; or
(iii) a resident of the Contracting State in which benefits under this Convention are claimed who is entitled to all the benefits under this Convention by virtue of subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) or (e) of paragraph 2, provided that the aggregate voting power and value of the shares (and of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company claiming benefits under paragraph 4 do not exceed 25 per cent of the total voting power and value of the shares (and of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company;
(f) the term "disproportionate class of shares" means any class of shares of a company or entity resident in one of the Contracting States which entitles a shareholder to disproportionately greater participation, in the form of dividends, redemption payments or otherwise, in the income derived from specific assets situated in the other Contracting State or from activities carried on in that other Contracting State;
(g) the "principal place of management and control" of a company or entity is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident only if:
(i) the senior officers and senior management of the company or entity have day-to-day responsibility for making the majority of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company or entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the staff carry out the day-to-day activities necessary for the preparation and making of those decisions, in most cases in that Contracting State rather than in any other State; and
(ii) such senior officers and senior management employees have day-to-day responsibility for making the majority of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company or entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the staff of such persons carry out a greater amount of day-to-day activities necessary for the preparation and making of those decisions than the officers or employees of any other company or entity;
(h) the term "qualified intermediate owner" means an intermediate owner who is either:
(i) a resident of a State which has in force in the Contracting State from which benefits are claimed under this Convention a comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation; or
(ii) a resident of the same Contracting State as the company applying the test under subparagraph (d) or (f) of paragraph 2 or paragraph 4 to determine whether it is entitled to benefits under the Convention;
(i) the term "tested group" means a resident of a Contracting State to which the test under subparagraph (d) or (f) of paragraph 2 or under paragraph 4 or 5 applies to determine whether it is entitled to benefits under the Convention (the "tested resident"), and any company or permanent establishment which:
(i) participates as a member together with the tested resident in a tax consolidation, fiscal unity or similar regime which allows members of the group to share profits or losses; or
(ii) shares losses with the tested resident under a group or other loss-sharing regime in the relevant taxable period;
(j) the term "gross income" means gross receipts as defined in the Contracting State of residence of the person for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefit is granted, except that, where the person is engaged in a business activity involving the production or sale of goods, "gross income" means such gross receipts reduced by the cost of goods sold, and where the person is engaged in a business activity consisting of the provision of non-financial services, "gross income" means gross receipts reduced by the direct costs of generating such receipts, provided that:
(i) except where relevant to the determination of benefits under Article 10 of this Convention, gross income shall not include that portion of dividends which is effectively exempt from tax in the Contracting State of residence of the person, whether by way of deductions or otherwise; and
(ii) except for the portion of dividends subject to taxation, the gross income of the tested group shall not take into account transactions between companies within the tested group;
(a) Where
(i) an enterprise of one Contracting State derives income from the other Contracting State and the first-mentioned Contracting State treats such income as profits attributable to a permanent establishment situated in a third jurisdiction; and
(ii) the profits attributable to that permanent establishment are exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State,
the benefits of this Convention shall not apply to any item of income in respect of which the tax in the third jurisdiction is less than the lesser of [a rate to be determined on a bilateral basis] of the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax that would be imposed in the first-mentioned State on that item of income if the permanent establishment were situated in the first-mentioned State. In such case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply shall remain taxable under the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
(b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income derived in the other State is derived in connection with, or is incidental to, the active conduct of a business carried on through the permanent establishment (other than the business of making, managing or merely holding investments for the enterprise's own account, unless such activities are banking, insurance or securities activities carried on, respectively, by a bank, insurance enterprise or registered securities dealer).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied under the preceding provisions of this paragraph with respect to an item of income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits with respect to that item of income if, in response to a request by such resident, such competent authority determines that the granting of such benefits is justified in light of the reasons why such resident does not satisfy the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the existence of losses). The competent authority of a Contracting State to which a request has been made under the preceding sentence shall consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or denying the request.
- Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital shall not be granted if it is reasonable to conclude, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining that benefit was one of the principal purposes of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly resulted in that benefit, unless it is established that granting that benefit in those circumstances would be in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
11 The formulation of this Article will depend on how the Contracting States decide to implement their common aspiration, reflected in the preamble to the Convention and included in the minimum standard agreed upon within the OECD-G20 project “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting”, to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax evasion or avoidance, including through the abuse of tax treaty provisions.
12 For the inclusion of this definition, see paragraph 14 of the Commentary on Article 29.
CHAPTER VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
Article 30
ENTRY INTO FORCE
- This Convention shall be ratified, and the exchange of instruments of ratification shall take place in __________________________ as soon as possible.
- The Convention shall enter into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions shall have effect:
a) (in State A): ...............
b) (in State B): ...............
Article 31
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until terminated by one of the Contracting States. Either Contracting State may terminate this Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of termination at least six months before the end of the calendar year following the year ______. In such a case, the Convention shall cease to have effect:
a) (in State A): ................
b) (in State B): ................
FINAL CLAUSE
Note: The provisions concerning the entry into force and termination, as well as the final provision concerning the signing of the Convention, shall be drafted in accordance with the constitutional procedures of both Contracting States.
PART TWO
COMMENTARIES ON THE ARTICLES OF THE UNITED NATIONS MODEL CONVENTION FOR THE AVOIDANCE OF DOUBLE TAXATION IN RELATIONS BETWEEN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
COMMENTARY ON CHAPTER I
SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
Article 1
PERSONS COVERED
A. General considerations
- Article 1 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention.
- In 1999, the title of Article 1 was changed from “Personal Scope” to “Persons Covered”. Article 1 of the Convention usually specifies the categories of persons or taxpayers to whom the Convention applies. The title “Personal Scope” did not reflect the scope of application of the Convention. Therefore, in order to reflect the precise scope of application of the Convention, the title of Article 1 was amended accordingly to “Persons Covered”.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 1
Paragraph 1
- Like the OECD Model Convention, the United Nations Model Convention applies to persons who are “residents of one or both of the Contracting States”. The personal scope of most previous conventions was more limited, since they covered “citizens” of the Contracting States. However, the scope of some earlier conventions was broader, since they covered “taxpayers” of the Contracting States, that is, persons who, although not residing in either State, were nevertheless liable to tax in respect of part of their income or capital in each of them. Some Articles provide for exceptions to this rule, for example, paragraph 1 of Article 24, paragraph 1 of Article 25 and paragraph 1 of Article 26.
Paragraph 2
- Paragraph 2 addresses particular issues arising in connection with payments to entities that are wholly or partly fiscally transparent, such as partnerships and trusts. In 1999, the OECD Committee on Fiscal Affairs approved the Working Party report entitled “The Application of the OECD Model Tax Convention to Partnerships”. The report discusses the application of the provisions of the OECD Model Tax Convention and indirectly addresses issues concerning the application of bilateral tax conventions based on that Model Convention to partnerships.
However, the Committee recognizes that many of the principles considered in that report may also apply, mutatis mutandis, to other non-corporate entities. In that report, references to “partnerships” cover entities that are classified as such under civil or commercial law, as opposed to tax law. Significant differences of opinion among OECD member countries arise from the fact that, under their domestic laws, different tax regimes apply to partnerships. In some OECD countries, partnerships are regarded as taxable entities and sometimes even as companies, whereas in other OECD countries it is not the partnerships themselves that are taxed, but only the shares of individual partners in the income of the partnerships. Similar differences exist in developing countries with regard to the tax treatment of partnerships. The purpose of paragraph 2 is to implement the principles set out in the report.
- An important question is whether the partnership itself should be granted the benefits provided for by the Convention. If, under the legislation of one of the Contracting States, partnerships are taxable entities, then, pursuant to paragraph 1 of Article 4, the partnership may qualify as a resident of that Contracting State and, accordingly, will be entitled to the benefits provided for by the Convention. However, if the partnership is regarded as fiscally transparent under the legislation of the State of residence and, accordingly, the partners are taxed on the income of the partnership, paragraph 2 provides that the provisions of the Convention should apply at the level of the partners.
- As a first step in applying the benefits of the Convention, paragraph 2 identifies a resident of a Contracting State receiving an item of income in respect of which treaty benefits are claimed. In order to be entitled to such benefits, that resident must also satisfy any additional requirements established in the applicable treaty, such as beneficial ownership of the item of income under the tax rules of the source State, any applicable ownership thresholds (for example, those specified in subparagraph 2(a) of Article 10 (Dividends)), as well as the principal purpose test or a limitation-on-benefits provision.
- These general rules are further developed in paragraphs 2–16 of the Commentary on Article 1 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention:
- This paragraph addresses the situation involving income derived by or through entities or arrangements that one or both Contracting States treat as wholly or partly fiscally transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such entities or arrangements is treated for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs, “The Application of the OECD Model Tax Convention to Partnerships”.13 That report therefore provides guidance and examples on how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
13 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at page R(15)-1.
- However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships and, although the Committee acknowledged that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate entities, it expressed its intention to consider the application of the Model Tax Convention to those other entities at a later stage. As indicated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about “cases where domestic tax legislation creates intermediate situations in which a partnership is treated partly as a taxable entity and partly disregarded for tax purposes”. According to the report:
While this circumstance may create practical difficulties in relation to a very limited number of partnerships, it represents a more significant problem in the case of other legal entities, such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to consider this issue in the context of further work on this report.
- Paragraph 2 addresses precisely this situation, since it refers to entities that are considered “wholly or partly” fiscally transparent. Thus, this paragraph not only confirms the conclusions of the Report with respect to partnerships, but also extends the application of those conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the Report [...].
- This paragraph not only ensures that the benefits provided for by the Convention are granted where appropriate, but also ensures that those benefits are not granted in cases where neither Contracting State regards, under its domestic law, the income of the legal entity or arrangement as the income of one of its residents. Thus, this paragraph confirms the conclusions of the Report in such a case (see Example 3 of the Report). Furthermore, as noted in the Report, States should not be expected to grant the benefits of a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually entitled to those benefits. Accordingly, if an entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, that State should be provided with all the necessary information in order to grant the benefits provided for by the Convention. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use a refund mechanism for the purposes of applying treaty benefits, even if it normally applies those benefits at the time the relevant income is paid. However, in most cases, the relevant information will be obtainable and the benefits of the Convention may be applied at the time the income is taxed (see, for example, paragraphs 43–45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment vehicles).
- The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
Example: State A and State B have concluded a treaty identical to the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation with respect to Taxes on Income and Capital. State A considers that a legal entity established in State B is a company and taxes that legal entity on the interest it receives from a debtor resident in State A. However, under the domestic legislation of State B, the legal entity is regarded as a partnership, and the two members of that entity, who share all its income equally, are taxed on half of the interest each. One of the members is a resident of State B, while the other is a resident of a country with which States A and B have no treaty. This paragraph provides that, in such a case, half of the interest is regarded, for the purposes of Article 11, as income of a resident of State B.
- The reference to “income derived by or through an entity or arrangement” has a broad meaning and covers any income derived by or through an entity or arrangement, regardless of the views of each Contracting State as to who derives that income for domestic tax purposes and regardless of whether that entity or arrangement is a legal person or constitutes a person as defined in subparagraph a) of paragraph 1 of Article 3. It will cover, for example, income of any partnership or trust that one or both Contracting States treat as wholly or partly fiscally transparent. Furthermore, as shown in Example 2 of the Report, it does not matter where the entity or arrangement is established: this paragraph applies to an entity established in a third State to the extent that, under the domestic tax law of one of the Contracting States, the entity is considered wholly or partly fiscally transparent and the income of that entity is attributed to a resident of that State.
- The term “income” should be given the broad meaning that it has for the purposes of the Convention and therefore applies to the various items of income covered by Chapter III of the Convention (Taxation of Income), including, for example, business profits and capital gains.
- The concept of “fiscally transparent”, as used in this paragraph, refers to situations where, under the domestic law of a Contracting State, the income (or part of the income) of an enterprise or entity is taxed not at the level of the enterprise or entity, but at the level of the persons who have an interest in that enterprise or entity.
This usually occurs where the amount of tax payable on a share of the income of the enterprise or entity is determined separately according to the personal characteristics of the person entitled to that share, as a result of which the tax will depend on whether the person is taxed on other income that they have, on personal allowances to which that person is entitled, and at the tax rate applicable to that person; moreover, the nature and source, as well as the timing of realization of the income for tax purposes, will not depend on the fact that it was derived through the enterprise or entity. The fact that the income is calculated at the level of the enterprise or entity before the share is attributed to the person will not affect this result.14 States wishing to clarify the definition of “fiscally transparent” in their bilateral conventions may, at their discretion, include a definition of this term based on the explanations above.
14 See paragraphs 37–40 of the “Partnership Report”.
- In the case of an entity or arrangement that is regarded as partly fiscally transparent under the domestic law of one of the Contracting States, only part of the income of the legal entity or arrangement may be taxed at the level of the persons having an interest in that enterprise or arrangement, as described in the preceding paragraph, while the remaining part will continue to be taxed at the level of the entity or arrangement. Thus, for example, in some countries certain trusts and limited partnerships are treated in this manner (i.e. in some countries, the part of the income derived through a trust that is distributed to beneficiaries is taxed in the hands of those beneficiaries, whereas the part of that income which is accumulated is taxed in the hands of the trust or trustees; similarly, in some countries, income derived through a limited partnership is taxed in the hands of the general partner in respect of that partner’s share of the income, but is regarded as income of the limited partnership in respect of the limited partner’s share of the income). To the extent that the entity or arrangement qualifies as a resident of a Contracting State, this paragraph will ensure that the benefits of the treaty also apply to the share of income attributed to the entity or arrangement under the domestic law of that State (subject to any anti-abuse provisions, such as a limitation-on-benefits rule).
- Like other provisions of the Convention, this provision applies separately to each item of income of the entity or arrangement. Assume, for example, that the trust deed provides that all dividends received by the trust must be distributed to the beneficiary during the term of its existence, but must thereafter be accumulated. If one of the Contracting States considers that, in such a case, the beneficiary is taxed on the dividends distributed to that beneficiary, but that the trustees are taxed on the dividends that will be accumulated, this paragraph will apply differently to these two categories of dividends, even if both types of dividends are received during the same month.
- By providing that the income to which it applies shall be regarded as income of a resident of a Contracting State for the purposes of the Convention, this paragraph ensures that the relevant income is attributed to that resident for the purposes of applying the various distributive rules of the Convention. Thus, depending on the nature of the income, this will allow the income to be regarded, for example, as “income derived” for the purposes of Articles 6, 13 and 17, “business profits” for the purposes of Articles 7, 8 and 9 (see also paragraph 4 of the Commentary on Article 3), or dividends or interest “paid” for the purposes of Articles 10 and 11. The fact that the income is regarded as derived by a resident of a Contracting State for the purposes of the Convention also means that, if the income constitutes a share of the income of an enterprise in which that resident participates, such income must be regarded as income of an enterprise carried on by that resident (for example, for the purposes of defining an enterprise of a Contracting State in Article 3 and paragraph 2 of Article 21).
- Although this paragraph ensures that the various distributive rules of the Convention apply to the extent that the income of fiscally transparent entities is regarded under domestic law as income of a resident of a Contracting State, this paragraph does not prejudge the question of whether the recipient is the beneficial owner of the relevant income. If, for example, a fiscally transparent partnership receives dividends as an agent or nominee of a person who is not a partner, the fact that the dividends may be regarded as income of a resident of a Contracting State under the domestic law of that State does not prevent the State of source from considering that neither the partnership nor the partners are the beneficial owners of the dividends.
- This paragraph applies only for the purposes of the Convention and therefore does not require a Contracting State to change the manner in which it allocates income or characterizes entities for the purposes of its domestic law. In the example given in paragraph 6 above, although paragraph 2 provides that, for the purposes of Article 11, half of the interest must be regarded as income of a resident of State B, this will affect only the maximum amount of tax that State A may levy on the interest and will not change the fact that the tax of State A will be paid by the entity. Thus, assuming that the domestic law of State A provides for a 30 per cent withholding tax on interest, the effect of paragraph 2 will simply be to reduce the amount of tax that State A will levy on the interest (so that half of the interest will be taxed at a rate of 30 per cent and half at a rate of 10 per cent under the agreement between States A and B), without changing the fact that the entity is the relevant taxpayer for the purposes of the domestic law of State A. Furthermore, this provision does not exhaustively address all treaty issues that may arise from the legal nature of certain entities and arrangements, and it may therefore be necessary to supplement other provisions to address such issues (for example, a provision confirming that a trust may qualify as a resident of a Contracting State notwithstanding the fact that, under the trust laws of many countries, a trust is not a “person”).
- The last sentence of this paragraph clarifies that the paragraph in no way limits the right of a State to tax its residents. This conclusion is consistent with the manner in which double taxation agreements have been interpreted with regard to partnerships (see paragraph 6.1 of this Commentary in the version in force after 2000 and before the inclusion of paragraph 3 in 2017).
- However, paragraphs 2 and 3 do not limit the obligation of the Contracting States to provide relief from double taxation in accordance with Articles 23 A and 23 B where the income of a resident of that State may be taxed by the other State in accordance with the Convention. There may, however, be cases where the same income is taxed by each Contracting State as income of one of its residents, and where relief from double taxation will be required in respect of the tax paid by another person. If, for example, one of the Contracting States taxes the worldwide income of an entity that is a resident of that State, whereas the other State considers that legal entity fiscally transparent for tax purposes and taxes the members of that entity who are residents of that other State on their respective shares of the income, relief from double taxation will have to take into account the tax paid by different taxpayers in the two States. In such a case, however, it will be important to determine, under Articles 23 A and 23 B, the extent to which the income of a resident of one Contracting State “may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention (except where these provisions permit taxation in that other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State [...])”. In general, this requirement will result in one State having to provide relief from double taxation only to the extent that the provisions of the Convention permit the other State to tax the relevant income as the State of source or as the State in which the permanent establishment to which that income is attributable is located (see paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 of the Commentary on Articles 23 A and 23 B).
Although the Committee generally agrees with paragraphs 2–16 of the Commentary on Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention quoted above, some members of the Committee expressed concern about the application of this paragraph in cases where income is derived by or through an entity or arrangement with a resident of a third State, and the interest holders are residents of a Contracting State under whose tax law the entity is considered fiscally transparent in respect of that income. In such a case, tax treaties of both the State of residence of the entity or arrangement and the State of residence of the interest holders may apply, creating a risk of duplicate claims for treaty benefits under different tax treaties in respect of the same item of income. However, such risks are minimized by the fact that, although several persons may in this case be regarded as deriving an item of income, the fact remains that only one payment is made from the source State, which gives that State only one opportunity to provide relief in respect of the item of income.
Moreover, in the practice of countries applying provisions similar to paragraph 2, no problems have arisen with duplicate claims for treaty benefits. According to the experience of these countries, the entity and its interest holders usually consult with one another and submit a single claim for treaty benefits to the withholding agent in respect of the payment. Furthermore, the requirement that the person deriving an item of income under paragraph 2 must also satisfy all applicable requirements set out in the treaty should reduce the number of cases involving repeated claims for treaty benefits. If a Contracting State encounters a situation involving a repeated claim for treaty benefits, it may resort to the mutual agreement procedure in order to obtain the additional information necessary to determine correctly which claim for treaty benefits should be granted.
7.1 Contracting States wishing to provide clarity both to their treaty partners and to taxpayers may conclude and publish competent authority agreements of general application pursuant to paragraph 3 of Article 25 (Mutual Agreement Procedure) concerning the application of paragraph 2.
Paragraph 3
- In the 2017 update, the Committee decided to include a so-called “saving clause” as paragraph 3 of Article 1. This corresponds to the new provision included in the OECD Model Convention in accordance with the OECD/G20 recommendations in the Final Report on Action 6 (Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances), which is based on a similar provision included in the US Model. The purpose of the saving clause is to remove any doubt that certain provisions intended to tax non-residents may be interpreted as limiting the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents. Although such interpretations have been rejected, the Committee considers that the clause in the United Nations Model Convention makes it clear that a Contracting State may tax its residents notwithstanding any other provisions of the relevant bilateral agreement.
- The 2017 OECD Commentary on this issue states as follows:
- Although certain provisions of the Convention (for example, Articles 23 A and 23 B) are expressly intended to affect the manner in which a Contracting State taxes its residents, the purpose of most provisions of the Convention is to limit the right of a Contracting State to tax residents of the other Contracting State. However, in some limited cases, it has been argued that certain provisions may be interpreted as limiting the right of a Contracting State to tax its residents in circumstances where this was not intended (see, for example, paragraph 81 below, which discusses the case of controlled foreign company rules).
- Paragraph 3 confirms the general principle that the Convention does not limit the right of a Contracting State to tax its residents, except where expressly provided otherwise, and lists the provisions to which this principle does not apply.
- The exceptions listed in this manner are intended to cover all cases where the Convention provides that a Contracting State may be required to grant treaty relief to its residents (whether or not such or similar relief is available under the domestic law of that State). These provisions include the following:
- Paragraph 3 of Article 7, which requires a Contracting State to make an appropriate adjustment for an enterprise of that State following the initial adjustment made by the other Contracting State under paragraph 2 of Article 7 to the amount of tax charged on the profits of the enterprise's permanent establishment.
- Paragraph 2 of Article 9, which requires a Contracting State to make an appropriate adjustment for an enterprise of that State following the initial adjustment made by the other Contracting State under paragraph 1 of Article 9 to the amount of tax charged on the profits of an associated enterprise.
- Article 19, which may affect the manner in which a Contracting State taxes an individual who is a resident of that State if that individual derives income from services rendered to the other Contracting State or to a political subdivision or local authority thereof.
- Article 20, which may affect the manner in which a Contracting State taxes an individual residing in that State if that person is also a student who satisfies the conditions of that Article.
- Articles 23 A and 23 B, which require a Contracting State to provide relief from double taxation to its residents in respect of income that the other State may tax in accordance with the Convention (including profits attributable to a permanent establishment situated in the other Contracting State under paragraph 2 of Article 7).
- Article 24, which protects residents of a Contracting State against certain discriminatory taxation practices by that State (for example, rules that distinguish between two persons on the basis of their nationality).
- Article 25, which allows residents of a Contracting State to request that the competent authority of that State consider cases of taxation not in accordance with the Convention.
- Article 28, which may affect the manner in which a Contracting State taxes an individual residing in that State if that individual is a member of a diplomatic mission or consular post of the other Contracting State.
- The list of exceptions included in paragraph 3 should include any other provision that the Contracting States may agree to include in their bilateral Convention if that provision is intended to affect the taxation by a Contracting State of its residents. For example, if the Contracting States agree, in accordance with paragraph 27 of the Commentary on Article 18, to include in their bilateral Convention a provision under which pensions and other payments made under the social security legislation of a Contracting State are taxable only in that State, they should include a reference to that provision in the list of exceptions included in paragraph 3. Other examples include alternative provisions in paragraphs 23, 30, 37, 38 and 68 of the Commentary on Article 18, since these provisions grant relief that is generally intended to be granted to an individual who participated in a foreign pension scheme before becoming a resident of a Contracting State.
- The term “resident”, as used in paragraph 3 and throughout the Convention, is defined in Article 4. If, under paragraph 1 of Article 4, a person is considered a resident of both Contracting States under the domestic laws of those States, paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Article will normally allow one State of residence to be determined for the purposes of the Convention. Accordingly, paragraph 3 does not apply to an individual or legal entity that is a resident of one of the Contracting States under the law of that State but is considered, for the purposes of the Convention, to be a resident only of the other Contracting State.
IMPROPER USE OF TAX TREATIES
- The main purpose of double taxation conventions is to promote, through the elimination of international double taxation, the exchange of goods and services and the movement of capital and persons. However, the provisions of tax treaties are formulated in general terms, and taxpayers may be tempted to enter into arrangements with a view to obtaining benefits in circumstances in which the Contracting States did not intend such benefits to be granted. Such improper use of tax treaties is a matter of concern for all countries, but particularly for countries with limited experience in combating sophisticated tax avoidance strategies.
- In this regard, the Committee considered it appropriate to examine various approaches through which these strategies can be countered and to provide specific examples of the application of these approaches. In considering this issue, the Committee recognized that, in order for tax treaties to fulfil their role, it is important to maintain a balance between the need for tax administrations to protect their tax revenues against the improper use of tax treaty provisions and the need to ensure legal certainty and protect taxpayers' legitimate expectations.
- In the 2017 update, the Committee made a number of changes to the United Nations Model Convention in order to prevent taxpayers from improperly using the provisions of bilateral tax treaties based on the United Nations Model Convention to obtain treaty benefits. First, the title of the Convention was amended to expressly refer to the “prevention of tax avoidance and evasion”. Second, a new preamble was added, clarifying that tax treaties are not intended to create opportunities for tax avoidance or evasion, including tax avoidance through treaty-shopping arrangements. Third, a new general anti-abuse rule was included in paragraph 9 of Article 29 of the United Nations Model Convention. This general rule and the specific anti-abuse rules included in tax treaties are intended to prevent the granting of tax benefits in respect of certain transactions and arrangements where the granting of such benefits would be contrary to the object and purpose of the Convention.
- These additions to the United Nations Model Convention will make the provisions of the Convention more effective in preventing abuse of tax treaties. However, many countries may have existing bilateral tax treaties that do not contain these new provisions, in particular the general anti-abuse rule reflected in paragraph 9 of Article 29. This part of the Commentary, which describes various approaches that countries may use to combat tax avoidance through the improper use of tax treaties, is particularly important in cases where their treaties do not include paragraph 9 of Article 29.
- Paragraphs 15–55 below are based on the 2017 Commentary on Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention, with appropriate modifications. In general, the main approaches to preventing abuse of tax treaties described below are intended to be consistent with the provisions of the Commentary on Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention.
- There are a number of different approaches used by countries to prevent and address the problem of improper use of tax treaties. Generally, these approaches involve the interpretation and application of treaty provisions or the interpretation and application of domestic law. Combating tax evasion through domestic law may involve the possible application of:
a. specific anti-abuse rules under domestic law;
b. general anti-abuse rules under domestic law; and
c. judicial doctrines and principles of interpretation that form part of domestic law.
These domestic-law approaches are discussed generally in paragraphs 16 and 17 below and separately in greater detail in paragraphs 31–47. Combating tax avoidance through tax treaties may involve the possible application of:
a. specific anti-abuse rules in tax treaties;
b. general anti-abuse rules in tax treaties; and
c. interpretation of tax treaty provisions.
These treaty-based approaches are discussed generally in paragraphs 18–30 below and separately in greater detail in paragraphs 48–56.
1. APPROACHES TO PREVENTING THE IMPROPER USE OF TAX TREATIES
ADDRESSING TAX EVASION THROUGH DOMESTIC ANTI-AVOIDANCE RULES AND JUDICIAL DOCTRINES
- Domestic anti-avoidance rules and judicial doctrines may also be used to address transactions and arrangements entered into with the purpose of obtaining treaty benefits in inappropriate circumstances. These rules and doctrines may also address situations where transactions or arrangements are entered into with the purpose of violating both domestic law and tax treaties.
- For these reasons, domestic anti-avoidance rules and judicial doctrines play an important role in preventing the granting of treaty benefits in inappropriate circumstances. However, the application of such domestic anti-avoidance rules and doctrines raises the question of possible conflicts with treaty provisions, particularly where treaty provisions are used to facilitate the abuse of domestic law provisions (for example, where it is argued that treaty provisions protect a taxpayer against the application of certain domestic anti-avoidance rules). This issue is discussed below in connection with specific legislative anti-avoidance rules, general legislative anti-avoidance rules and judicial doctrines.
PREVENTING TAX AVOIDANCE THROUGH TAX TREATIES
- Paragraph 9 of Article 29 and the specific anti-abuse rules included in tax treaties are intended to address transactions and arrangements entered into for the purpose of obtaining tax benefits in inappropriate circumstances. However, where a tax treaty does not contain such rules, the question may arise as to whether tax benefits should be granted in cases involving transactions that constitute an abuse of the provisions of that treaty.
- Many States address this issue by taking into account the fact that taxes are ultimately imposed on the basis of domestic law provisions, which are restricted (and, in some rare cases, extended) by the provisions of tax treaties. Thus, any abuse of the provisions of tax treaties may also be characterized as an abuse of the provisions of domestic law under which the tax is imposed. For these States, the question arises as to whether the provisions of tax treaties may prevent the application of domestic law provisions intended to counter abuse, and it is precisely this question that is addressed in paragraphs 35–44 below. As explained in those paragraphs, as a general rule, no conflict arises between such rules and the provisions of tax treaties.
- Other States prefer to regard certain arrangements as abuses of the tax treaty itself rather than as abuses of domestic law. However, these States consider that the proper interpretation of tax treaties allows them to disregard improper transactions and arrangements, for example, those entered into for the purpose of obtaining benefits under the provisions of such treaties that were not intended to be granted. Such an interpretation follows from the object and purpose of tax treaties, as well as from the obligation to interpret them in good faith (see Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties).
- Thus, under both approaches, States are not obliged to grant the benefits provided for by a double taxation convention in cases where the arrangements made violate the provisions of the tax treaty.
- However, it is important to note that it should not be lightly assumed that a taxpayer has engaged in the improper transactions described above. The guiding principle is that the benefits of a double taxation convention should not be available where one of the principal purposes of entering into certain transactions or arrangements was to secure a more favourable tax position and obtaining that more favourable treatment in the circumstances would be contrary to the object and purpose of the relevant provisions. This principle applies regardless of the provisions of paragraph 9 of Article 29, which merely confirm it.
- The guiding principle set out in paragraph 22 above was endorsed by the OECD in paragraph 61 of the Commentary on Article 1 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention (paragraph 9.5 of the Commentary on Article 1 of the 2014 OECD Model Convention). The members of the Committee also endorsed this principle when updating the United Nations Model Convention in 2011 and continue to adhere to it. They consider that such guidance on what constitutes an abuse of treaty provisions serves an important purpose, since it seeks to balance the need to prevent abuse of treaty provisions with the need to ensure that countries comply with their treaty obligations and provide taxpayers with legal certainty. Clearly, countries should not be able to avoid their treaty obligations simply by asserting that legitimate transactions constitute abuses, and that domestic tax rules which affect those transactions in a manner that conflicts with the provisions of the treaty are anti-abuse rules.
- In accordance with the guiding principle set out above, two elements must be present in order for certain transactions or arrangements to be regarded as an abuse of the provisions of a tax treaty:
- one of the principal purposes of entering into such transactions or arrangements was to secure a more favourable tax position; and
- obtaining such more favourable treatment would be contrary to the object and purpose of the relevant provisions.
- These two elements are also frequently found, either expressly or implicitly, in general anti-avoidance rules and doctrines developed in various countries.
- In order to minimize the uncertainty that may arise from the application of this approach, it is important that this guiding principle be applied on the basis of objective facts and not merely the presumed intentions of the parties. Thus, the determination of whether one of the principal purposes of entering into transactions or arrangements was to obtain tax benefits should be based on an objective determination, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, of whether a reasonable taxpayer would have entered into the same transactions or arrangements without those tax benefits.
- The possible application of these principles or of paragraph 9 of Article 29 does not mean that the inclusion in tax treaties of specific provisions aimed at preventing certain forms of tax avoidance is unnecessary. Where particular tax avoidance methods have been identified, or where the use of such methods creates particular problems, it is often appropriate to include provisions in the Convention aimed at preventing the relevant avoidance strategy. Moreover, this will be necessary in cases where a State adopting the position described in paragraph 20 above considers that its domestic law does not contain the rules or principles for combating tax avoidance that are necessary to adequately counter such a strategy.
- For example, certain forms of tax avoidance have already been expressly addressed by provisions of the Convention, in particular through the introduction of the concept of “beneficial owner” (in Articles 10, 11, 12 and 12A) and specific provisions, such as paragraph 2 of Article 17, concerning so-called “artiste-companies”. Such issues are also referred to in the Commentaries on Article 10 (paragraph 13, with reference to paragraphs 17 and 22 of the Commentary on Article 10 of the 2014 OECD Model Convention) and Article 11 (paragraph 18, with reference to paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 11 of the 2014 OECD Model Convention).
- Furthermore, in certain cases, claims for treaty benefits made by subsidiaries, particularly companies established in offshore zones or benefiting from harmful preferential regimes, may be denied if a careful examination of the facts and circumstances of the case shows that the place where the subsidiary's effective management is exercised is not in its purported State of residence but rather in the State of residence of the parent company, in order to make it a resident of that latter State for domestic law and treaty purposes (this will be relevant if the domestic law of the State uses the place of management of a legal entity or a similar criterion to determine its place of residence).
- A careful examination of the facts and circumstances of the case may also show that a subsidiary was managed in the State of residence of its parent company in such a way that the subsidiary had a permanent establishment (for example, a place of management) in that State, to which all or a substantial part of its profits could properly be attributed.
Align the numbering throughout the commentarySeparate quoted OECD commentary clearly
Special Legislative Rules to Combat Abuse of Tax Treaties Contained in Domestic Law
31. Tax authorities seeking to address the issue of the improper use of tax treaties may first consider applying special legislative rules to combat abuse of tax treaties that are incorporated into domestic law.
32. Many domestic rules may be relevant for addressing this issue. For example, controlled foreign corporation (CFC) rules may be applied to prevent the use of certain arrangements involving base companies or shell companies established by residents in treaty partner countries; thin capitalization rules may be applied to disallow deductions for base-eroding interest payments made to residents of treaty partner countries; transfer pricing rules (even if they are not primarily intended to serve as anti-avoidance rules) may prevent the artificial shifting of income from a resident enterprise to an enterprise that is a resident of a treaty partner country; exit tax rules, or departure taxes, may prevent the avoidance of capital gains tax through a change of residence before the realization of capital gains excluded from the scope of the treaty; and rules concerning dividend stripping may prevent the avoidance of domestic withholding taxes on dividends through transactions designed to convert dividends into capital gains excluded from the scope of the treaty.
33. The application of many of these and other specific anti-abuse rules to arrangements involving the use of tax treaties raises one common issue, namely, the possibility of conflicts between such rules and the provisions of tax treaties. If two Contracting States take different positions as to whether a particular special anti-abuse rule contained in the domestic legislation of one of those States is contrary to the provisions of a tax treaty, the issue may be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure, taking into account the following principles.
34. As a general rule, where the application of domestic law provisions and tax treaty provisions gives rise to conflicts, the provisions of tax treaties prevail. This follows logically from the principle of the binding force of treaties (pacta sunt servanda), which is enshrined in Article 26 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. Thus, if the application of these rules results in an increase in the taxpayer's tax liability beyond the limits permitted by the tax treaty, this would be contrary to the provisions of the treaty, and those provisions must prevail in accordance with the rules of public international law.
35. Nevertheless, as explained below, such conflicts can often be avoided, and each case should be analysed on the basis of the specific circumstances in the country concerned.
36. First, a treaty may specifically permit the application of certain types of specific domestic anti-abuse rules. For example, Article 9 of the Convention specifically permits the application of domestic transfer pricing rules in the cases covered by that Article. In addition, many treaties contain specific provisions clarifying that no conflict exists (or, even where such a conflict exists, permitting the application of domestic rules) in relation, for example, to thin capitalization rules, CFC rules, or exit tax rules, or, more generally, domestic rules and regulations designed to prevent tax avoidance.
37. Second, many provisions of a tax treaty depend on the application of domestic law. This is the case, for example, with the determination of an individual's permanent residence, the definition of immovable property, and the circumstances in which income from corporate rights may be treated as dividends. More generally, paragraph 2 of Article 3 makes domestic rules relevant for the purpose of determining the meaning of terms that are not defined in the treaty. Consequently, in many cases, the application of domestic anti-abuse rules will affect the manner in which treaty provisions are applied rather than produce conflicting results. For example, if, under domestic law, a profit derived by a shareholder from a company's repurchase of part of its own shares is treated as a dividend, such repurchase may be regarded as a disposal for the purposes of paragraph 5 of Article 13. However, paragraph 14 of the Commentary on Article 10 (quoting paragraph 14 of the Commentary on Article 10 of the 2014 OECD Model Convention) acknowledges that such profit will constitute a dividend for the purposes of Article 10 if the profit is treated as a dividend under domestic law.
38. Third, the application of the provisions of a tax treaty in cases of abuse of those provisions may be denied on the basis of the general anti-abuse rule referred to in paragraph 9 of Article 29 or, in the case of a treaty that does not include that Article, on the basis of a proper interpretation of the treaty in accordance with the principles set out in paragraphs 54–56 below. In such a case, there will be no conflict with the provisions of the treaty if the entitlement to treaty benefits is prohibited under the interpretation of both the treaty and the specific domestic anti-abuse rules. However, specific domestic anti-abuse rules are often drafted by reference to objective facts, such as the existence of a certain level of ownership or a particular debt-to-equity ratio. Although this approach greatly facilitates their application, it may sometimes result in the application of these rules to transactions that do not constitute abuses. In such cases, the Convention does not permit the application of domestic rules to the extent that such application is contrary to it. For example, assume that State A has adopted a domestic rule to prevent temporary changes of tax residence, under which an individual who is a resident of State B is taxed in State A on income from the alienation of property situated in a third State if that individual was a resident of State A at the time of acquiring the property and was a resident of State A for at least seven of the ten years preceding the alienation. In such a case, to the extent that paragraph 6 of Article 13 prevents State A from taxing that individual upon the alienation of the property, the Convention prevents the application of State A's domestic rule, except where, in the particular case, the benefits of paragraph 6 of Article 13 may be denied under paragraph 9 of Article 29 or the principles set out in paragraphs 54–56 below.
39. Fourth, the application of the provisions of a tax treaty may be denied on the basis of legal doctrines or principles applicable to the interpretation of the treaty (see paragraphs 43–47 and 54–56 below). In such a case, there will be no conflict with the provisions of the treaty if treaty benefits are denied both as a result of the proper interpretation of the treaty and as a result of the application of specific domestic anti-abuse rules. Assume, for example, that the domestic legislation of State A provides for the taxation of gains derived from the alienation of shares in a domestic company in which the alienator holds more than 25 per cent of the capital, if the alienator was a resident of State A for at least seven of the ten years preceding the alienation. In the second year, an individual who had been a resident of State A for the preceding ten years becomes a resident of State B. Shortly after acquiring resident status in State B, the individual sells all the shares in a small company that he had previously incorporated in State A. The facts, however, show that all the elements of the sale were completed in Year 1, that an interest-free "loan" corresponding to the sale price was provided by the purchaser to the seller at that time, that the purchaser cancelled the loan when the shares were transferred to the purchaser in Year 2, and that the purchaser exercised actual control over the company from Year 1. Although, in the absence of these circumstances, the gain from the sale of the shares could have fallen within the scope of paragraph 6 of Article 13 of the treaty between State A and State B, the circumstances surrounding the transfer of the shares are such that the alienation in Year 2 constitutes a sham in the sense in which that term is used by the courts of State A. In this case, to the extent that the sham transaction doctrine developed by the courts of State A is not contrary to the rules governing the interpretation of international treaties, that doctrine could be applied in interpreting paragraph 6 of Article 13 of the treaty between State A and State B, thereby allowing State A to tax the relevant gain in accordance with its domestic law.
40. A similar analysis applies to controlled foreign corporation (CFC) rules. Many countries have adopted CFC provisions to address issues relating to the use of companies established abroad. Despite significant differences between countries, the common feature of these provisions, which are now internationally recognized as a legitimate instrument for protecting the domestic tax base, is that they result in Contracting States taxing their residents on income associated with their participation in certain foreign companies. It has sometimes been argued, on the basis of a particular interpretation of provisions of the Convention such as paragraph 1 of Article 7 and paragraph 5 of Article 10, that this common feature of CFC legislation is contrary to those provisions. Since CFC legislation results in a State taxing its own residents, the new saving clause added to the United Nations Model Convention in its 2017 update as [paragraph 3 of Article 1] confirms that it does not conflict with tax conventions. The same conclusion should be reached in the case of conventions that do not contain a provision similar to [paragraph 3 of Article 1]. For the reasons explained in paragraph 8 of the Commentary on Article 7 and paragraph 16 of the Commentary on Article 10, an interpretation according to which those Articles prevent the application of CFC provisions is inconsistent with the text of paragraph 1 of Article 7 and paragraph 5 of Article 10. It is also inconsistent with those provisions when they are considered in their context. Thus, although some countries have considered it appropriate to expressly state in their conventions that their CFC legislation does not conflict with the Convention, such clarification is not necessary. CFC legislation drafted in this manner is considered not to be contrary to the provisions of the Convention.
General Legislative Rules to Combat Abuse of Tax Treaties Contained in Domestic Law
41. Some countries have incorporated into their domestic law a general legislative anti-abuse rule designed to prevent the use of improper arrangements that cannot be adequately addressed by specific rules or legal doctrines.
42. The application of such general anti-tax avoidance rules also raises the question of a possible conflict with the provisions of a double taxation agreement. However, in the vast majority of cases, no such conflict arises. First, conflicts will be avoided for reasons similar to those set out in paragraphs 39 and 40 above. In addition, where the main features of these general domestic anti-tax avoidance rules are consistent with the guiding principle set out in paragraph 22 above and are therefore similar to the main features of paragraph 9 of Article 29, which incorporates that guiding principle, it is clear that a conflict will be impossible, since the relevant domestic general anti-tax avoidance rule will apply in the same circumstances in which treaty benefits would be denied under paragraph 9 of Article 29 or, in the case of a treaty that does not include that paragraph, under the guiding principle set out in paragraph 22 above. This is the general conclusion reached by the OECD, as reflected in paragraph 77 of the Commentary on Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention.
Legal Doctrines Forming Part of Domestic Law and Principles of Interpretation
43. In interpreting tax legislation in cases involving tax avoidance, the courts of many countries have developed a number of judicial doctrines or principles of interpretation. These include doctrines such as sham, business purpose, substance over form, economic substance, step transaction, abuse of law and fraus legis. These doctrines and principles of interpretation, which differ from country to country and evolve over time through clarifications or changes resulting from subsequent judicial decisions, essentially represent the views expressed by courts as to how tax legislation should be interpreted.
44. These doctrines represent the views expressed by courts as to how tax legislation should be interpreted and generally become part of domestic tax law.
45. Although the interpretation of double taxation agreements is governed by the general rules codified in Articles 31–33 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, those general rules do not preclude the application of similar judicial doctrines and principles to the interpretation of the provisions of double taxation agreements. If, for example, the courts of a country have determined that, as a matter of legal interpretation, provisions concerning domestic taxation should be applied on the basis of the economic substance of certain transactions, there is nothing to prevent a similar approach from being applied to the application of the provisions of a double taxation agreement to similar transactions. This is confirmed by the example in paragraph 40 above.
46. As a general rule, and subject to paragraph 22, the preceding analysis leads to the conclusion that there will be no conflict between tax conventions and judicial doctrines aimed at preventing tax avoidance or general domestic anti-tax avoidance rules. For example, to the extent that the application of a general domestic anti-tax avoidance rule or a judicial doctrine, such as "substance over form" or "economic substance", results in the recharacterization of income or the redefinition of the taxpayer who is considered to have received such income, the provisions of the Convention will apply taking those changes into account.
47. Although these rules do not conflict with tax treaties, there is an understanding that Member States should carefully observe the specific obligations set out in double taxation agreements unless there is clear evidence that the agreements are being violated.
Specific Legislative Rules to Combat Abuse of Tax Treaties Contained in Tax Treaties
48. Some forms of treaty abuse can be eliminated through specific treaty provisions. A number of such rules have already been included in the United Nations Model Convention, including, in particular: the reference to an agent having a stock of goods for delivery (subparagraph b of paragraph 5 of Article 5); the concept of "beneficial owner" (Articles 10, 11 and 12); the "special relationship" rule applicable to interest and royalties (paragraph 6 of Article 11 and paragraph 6 of Article 12); the rule concerning the alienation of shares in companies deriving their value from immovable property (paragraph 4 of Article 13); and the rule concerning "star companies" (paragraph 2 of Article 17). Another example of a provision addressing treaty abuse may be considered to be a modified version of the "force of attraction" rule set out in paragraph 1 of Article 7, which is found in some tax treaties and applies only in cases of tax avoidance.
49. Clearly, such specific treaty anti-abuse rules provide greater certainty for taxpayers than broader general rules or doctrines. This is recognized in paragraph 22 and paragraph 62 (paragraph 9.6 of the OECD Commentary on Article 1) of the 2017 OECD Commentary on Article 1, which explains that such rules can usefully complement general anti-abuse rules and judicial approaches to combating the abuse of treaty provisions.
50. The risks of relying exclusively on specific anti-abuse rules to address problems relating to strategies designed to circumvent the provisions of tax treaties should not, however, be underestimated. First, specific treaty anti-abuse rules are often developed only after a particular strategy for circumventing tax treaties has been identified. Second, the inclusion of a specific anti-abuse provision in a treaty may weaken the argument for applying general anti-abuse measures or doctrines to other forms of treaty abuse. The addition of specific anti-abuse rules to a tax treaty may be mistakenly interpreted as suggesting that an unacceptable strategy for circumventing treaty provisions that is similar to, but slightly different from, the strategy targeted by that anti-abuse rule is permissible and cannot be challenged under general treaty anti-abuse rules. Third, complex rules and provisions may be required to specifically counter sophisticated strategies for circumventing treaties. This is particularly true where these rules seek to address the issue by applying criteria that leave little room for interpretation, rather than more flexible criteria such as the purpose of a transaction or arrangement. For these reasons, although the inclusion of specific anti-abuse rules in tax treaties is the most appropriate approach in certain situations, this approach cannot, by itself, provide a comprehensive solution to the problem of treaty abuse.
General Legislative Rules to Combat Abuse of Tax Treaties Contained in Tax Treaties
51. In the 2017 update of the United Nations Model Convention, a general anti-abuse rule was added to the Convention in the form of paragraph 9 of Article 29. Paragraph 9 of Article 29 is intended to prevent the improper use of tax treaties by denying tax benefits where one of the principal purposes of a transaction or arrangement is to obtain such benefits and granting those benefits would be contrary to the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the agreement.
52. As explained in paragraph 22 above, paragraph 9 of Article 29 is consistent with and confirms the guiding principle governing the granting of treaty benefits. Thus, many countries may deny tax benefits in cases of abuse without the need to include a general anti-abuse rule, such as paragraph 9 of Article 29, in their treaties. To this end, those countries may apply a general anti-abuse rule contained in domestic law, legal doctrines or principles of interpretation contained in domestic law, or interpret the provisions of their tax treaties in such a way as to deny treaty benefits in cases of abuse.
53. Some countries may not be confident that their domestic legislation and approach to interpreting tax treaties will enable them to adequately combat the improper use of their tax treaties. Such countries may consider including in their treaties a general anti-abuse rule similar to paragraph 9 of Article 29. A country wishing to include a general anti-abuse rule in its treaties may need to adapt the wording to its own circumstances, particularly with regard to the approach adopted by its courts concerning tax avoidance. In particular, a country that has a general anti-abuse rule in its domestic legislation should, to the extent possible, avoid any inconsistencies between that domestic rule and the general anti-abuse rule included in its treaties.
Interpretation of the Provisions of Tax Treaties
54. Another approach that has been used to counter the improper use of treaties consists of taking into account the possibility that the treaty itself may be violated and disregarding abusive transactions in accordance with the proper interpretation of the relevant treaty provisions, having regard to the context, object and purpose of the treaty, as well as the obligation to interpret those provisions in good faith in accordance with Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. As already noted in paragraph 20 above, a number of countries have long used legal interpretation to counter abuse of the provisions of domestic tax legislation, and it appears entirely acceptable to interpret the provisions of tax legislation in a similar manner in order to counter violations of tax treaties. The guiding principle set out in paragraph 22 above is equally applicable both for the purposes of interpreting the provisions of an agreement in order to prevent abuse of the agreement and for the purposes of determining whether the provisions of the agreement prevent the application of specific or general anti-abuse rules contained in domestic law.
55. Paragraphs 22–24 above provide guidance as to what should be considered abuse of a tax treaty. It is clear that such guidance is highly relevant for the purposes of applying this approach.
56. As part of the 2017 revision, the title of the United Nations Model Convention was amended to include a direct reference to the prevention of tax avoidance and evasion as one of the objectives of the Convention. In addition, a new preamble was added to the Convention, clarifying that the Contracting States do not intend the provisions of the Convention to create opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax avoidance or evasion, including through the abuse of provisions of international tax agreements. Abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements is only one example of the improper use of tax agreements; other examples are provided in paragraphs 58–117 below. Since the title and preamble form part of the context of the United Nations Model Convention, they should play an important role in interpreting the provisions of the Convention for the purpose of preventing treaty abuse.
Examples of the Improper Use of Tax Treaties
57. The following paragraphs illustrate the application of the approaches described above in various cases involving the improper use of the provisions of a tax treaty (these examples, however, are not intended to prejudge the legal treatment of such transactions under domestic law or under particular treaties).
Dual Residence and Change of Residence
58. There have been cases in which taxpayers have changed their tax residence primarily for the purpose of obtaining benefits under tax treaties. Some of these cases may be illustrated by the following examples:
- Example 1: Mr. X is a resident of State A and has accumulated substantial pension entitlements in that country. Under the treaty between State A and State B, pensions and other similar payments are taxable only in the State in which the recipient resides. Shortly before his retirement, Mr. X moves to State B for two years and becomes a resident of that State under its domestic tax legislation. During this period, he carefully complies with the requirements of paragraph 2 of Article 4 of the treaty to ensure that he is a resident of that country for the purposes of the treaty. During this period, his accrued pension entitlements are paid to him in a lump sum, which is exempt from tax under the domestic law of State B. Mr. X subsequently returns to State A.
- Example 2: Company X, a resident of State A, is considering selling shares in companies that are also residents of State A. Such a sale will give rise to a capital gain that is taxable under the domestic law of State A. Before the sale, Company X arranges for meetings of its board of directors to be held in State B, a country that does not tax capital gains on shares in companies and in which the place where board meetings are held is generally the determining factor for the company's tax residence. Company X claims that it has become a resident of State B for the purpose of falling within the scope of the tax treaty between States A and B in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 4 of that treaty, which is identical to paragraph 3 of the United Nations Model Convention. The company then sells the shares and claims that the capital gain cannot be taxed in State A under paragraph 6 of Article 13 of the treaty (paragraph 5 of that Article cannot apply because Company X does not have a substantial participation in the companies concerned).
- Example 3: Ms. X, a resident of State A, owns all the shares in a company that is also a resident of State A. The value of these shares has increased significantly over the past few years. Both State A and State B tax capital gains on shares; however, the domestic law of State B provides that residents who are not domiciled in that State are taxed only on income arising from sources outside the State, provided that such income is actually remitted or transferred to that resident. As part of the arrangements for the sale of these shares, Ms. X moves to State B for two years and becomes a resident who is not domiciled in that State. She then sells the shares and claims that the capital gain cannot be taxed in State A under paragraph 6 of Article 13 of the treaty (the relevant treaty does not contain a provision similar to paragraph 5 of the United Nations Model Convention).
59. Depending on the circumstances of the particular case, it could be argued that a change of residence whose primary purpose is to obtain benefits under a tax treaty constitutes abuse of that tax treaty. Nevertheless, in cases similar to the three examples given above, it is often very difficult to identify facts that could demonstrate that the change of residence was undertaken primarily to obtain treaty benefits, particularly where the taxpayer has a permanent home or stays in the other State for an extended period of time. As a result, many countries have concluded that specific rules are the best approach to regulating such cases.
60. One approach used by some countries is to include in their tax treaties provisions allowing the State in which a taxpayer was previously resident to tax certain types of income, such as capital gains from substantial shareholdings in companies or lump-sum payments of pension entitlements, realized within a specified period following the change of residence. An example of such a provision can be found in paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the treaty signed in 2002 between the Netherlands and Poland, which reads as follows:
The provisions of paragraph 4 shall not affect the right of each of the Contracting States to levy, in accordance with its own legislation, tax on income from the alienation of shares or enjoyment shares ("jouissance") in a company, the capital of which is wholly or partly divided into shares and which, under the legislation of that State, is a resident of that State, derived by an individual who is a resident of the other Contracting State and who was a resident of the first-mentioned State during the ten years preceding the alienation of the shares or enjoyment shares ("jouissance").
61. Countries also address such cases through provisions on so-called "exit taxes" or "departure taxes", under which a change of residence gives rise to the realization of certain types of income, such as capital gains and pensions. To the extent that the liability to pay such tax arises while the person is still a resident of the State imposing the tax and does not extend to income accruing after the termination of residence, nothing in the Convention, in particular Articles 13 and 18, prevents the application of this form of taxation. Thus, tax treaties do not prevent the application of domestic tax rules under which a person is deemed to have received pension income or to have alienated property for capital gains tax purposes immediately before ceasing to be a resident.
62. A proper interpretation of the provisions of paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 4 may also prove useful in addressing cases similar to these examples. Concepts such as the "centre of vital interests" and the "place of effective management" require substantial connections between the taxpayer and the country. The mere fact that a taxpayer has a home in a country where he or she frequently stays is often insufficient to conclude that this country is the centre of his or her vital interests; similarly, the mere fact that board meetings of a company are held in a particular country is insufficient to conclude that the place of effective management of that company is located in that country. In addition, some countries have replaced paragraph 3 of Article 4, which deals with cases of dual residence of legal entities on the basis of the place of effective management, with a rule that leaves such cases of dual residence to be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure.
63. Example 3 raises the issue of the possibility of tax avoidance arising from taxation on a remittance basis. This issue is discussed in paragraph 118 below with reference to paragraph 108 of the 2017 OECD Commentary on Article 1.
Treaty Shopping
64. "Treaty shopping" is a form of improper use of tax treaties involving arrangements through which persons who are not entitled to treaty benefits use other persons who are entitled to such benefits in order to obtain indirect access to those benefits. For example, a company that is a resident of a treaty partner country acts as a conduit company for the transfer of income that should otherwise accrue to a person who is not a resident of that country, for the purpose of improperly obtaining tax treaty benefits. The conduit is usually a company, but it may also be a partnership, trust or similar entity entitled to treaty benefits. Granting treaty benefits in these circumstances would have adverse consequences for the State of source of the income, since treaty benefits would be extended to persons who were not intended to receive such benefits.
65. As shown below, treaty shopping may be carried out through a "direct conduit company" or a "stepping-stone conduit company"¹⁵.
66. Company X, a resident of State A, receives dividends, interest and royalties from Company Y, a resident of State B. Company X claims that, under the tax treaty between States A and B, it is entitled to a full or partial exemption from the domestic withholding taxes imposed under the tax legislation of State B. Company X is wholly owned by a resident of a third State, State C, who is not entitled to benefits under the treaty between States A and B. Company X was established for the purpose of obtaining benefits under the treaty between States A and B, and it was for that purpose that the assets and rights giving rise to the dividends, interest or royalties were transferred to it. This income is exempt from tax in State A, for example, in the case of dividends, by virtue of the exemption from tax on dividends received by a shareholder from a subsidiary provided under the domestic law of State A, or under the treaty between States A and B. In this case, Company X is a direct conduit company for its shareholder, who is a resident of State C.
¹⁵ See page R(6)-4, paragraph 4 of the OECD report Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Conduit Companies. Included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at page R(6)-1.
67. The use of a stepping-stone conduit company involves a similar basic arrangement. In this case, however, the income of Company X is fully taxable in State A, and, in order to avoid the tax that would otherwise be payable in that country, Company X pays high interest, commissions, service fees or similar deductible expenses to a second related conduit company, Company Z, a resident of State D. These payments, which are deductible for tax purposes in State A, are not subject to tax in State D by virtue of a special tax regime applicable there¹⁶. Thus, the shareholder, who is a resident of State C, attempts to obtain access to the benefits of the tax treaty between States A and B through Company X as a "stepping stone".
¹⁶ Ibid.
68. Tax authorities use various approaches, described in the preceding sections, to eliminate such situations.
69. For example, specific anti-treaty abuse rules have been incorporated into the domestic legislation of a number of countries to counter such schemes. One example is the United States regulatory framework concerning financing arrangements. For the purposes of these rules, a financing arrangement consists of a series of transactions through which a financing entity transfers money or other property to a financed entity, subject to the condition that such money or property passes through one or more intermediary entities. An intermediary entity is treated as a "conduit entity", and its participation in financing arrangements is disregarded by the tax authorities if: (i) the presence of the intermediary entity reduces the amount of tax; (ii) there is a tax avoidance plan; and (iii) it is established that the intermediary entity would not have participated in the transaction but for the fact that it is a related entity of the financing entity. In such cases, the relevant income is reclassified on the basis of its economic substance.
¹⁶ Ibid.
70. Other countries address the problem of treaty shopping through the interpretation of tax treaty provisions. Under a resolution adopted by the Swiss Federal Council in 1962, which applies to treaties concluded by Switzerland with countries that provide, under the relevant treaties, an exemption from withholding tax that would otherwise be collected by those countries, a claim for such relief is considered abusive if, as a result of the claim, a substantial part of the tax benefits accrues to persons who are not entitled to them under the relevant tax treaty. The granting of tax benefits is considered improper: (a) where the requirements stipulated in the tax treaty are not met (for example, residence, beneficial ownership, tax liability, etc.); and (b) where it constitutes an abuse. The Swiss tax authorities may take the following measures if they consider that tax benefits have been claimed improperly: (a) refuse to certify the application form; (b) refuse to forward the application form; (c) cancel a certificate already issued; (d) recover withholding tax on behalf of the State of source of the income, provided that the tax benefits were granted improperly; and (e) inform the tax authorities of the State of source of the income that the tax benefits were granted improperly.
71. Some countries rely on their domestic general anti-treaty abuse rules or legal doctrines when making decisions concerning cases of treaty shopping. Nevertheless, as already noted, general anti-abuse rules and legal doctrines incorporated into domestic legislation are generally most effective where it is clear that the transactions concerned are designed to circumvent the object and purpose of the provisions of a tax treaty.
72. In addition, the problem of treaty shopping can be addressed to some extent through anti-abuse rules already incorporated into most tax treaties, such as the concept of "beneficial ownership".
73. Some countries, however, consider that the most effective approach to addressing the problem of treaty shopping is to include in their tax treaties specific anti-abuse rules on this issue, such as the rules contained in paragraphs 1–7 of Article 29, which were added to the United Nations Model Convention in the 2017 update.
74. When considering the various approaches to combating treaty shopping, countries should take into account their capacity to apply these approaches. For many developing countries, it may be difficult to apply highly detailed rules that require access to extensive information about foreign legal entities. These countries may consider that a more limited approach, consisting of denying the benefits provided under specific Articles where transactions were entered into for the principal purpose of obtaining such benefits, may be more suitable in their circumstances. This concerns Articles 10, 11, 12 and 21; the provision should be modified slightly, as indicated below, so that it addresses the specific type of income covered by each of those Articles:
The provisions of this Article shall not apply if the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of any person concerned in creating or assigning [Article 10: "shares or other rights"; Article 11: "debt-claim"; Articles 12 and 21: "right"], in respect of which [Article 10: "dividends"; Article 11: "interest"; Article 12: "royalties"; and Article 21: "income"] are paid, was to obtain the benefits of this Article by means of such creation or assignment.
75. In the 2017 update, a new preamble was added to the Convention, expressly stating that the Convention is not intended to create opportunities for tax avoidance, including through the conclusion of treaty shopping arrangements. In addition, the title of the Convention was amended to indicate that its objectives include the prevention of tax avoidance and evasion. These changes should play an important role in ensuring the proper interpretation and application of the provisions of the Convention to prevent abuse in the conclusion of tax agreements.
76. The general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9 of Article 29, which was added to the Convention in the 2017 update, may also be effective in preventing abuse of the provisions of tax agreements.
Triangular Cases
77. In the context of tax treaties, the phrase "triangular cases" refers to the application of tax treaties in situations involving three States. A typical triangular arrangement constituting an improper use of a tax treaty may involve the following:
— dividends, interest or royalties are derived from State S by a resident of State R, a country that operates a tax exemption system;
— this income is attributed to a permanent establishment located in State P, a low-tax jurisdiction where the income is not taxed¹⁷.
78. Under the tax treaty between States R and S, State S is required to grant treaty benefits in respect of such dividends, interest or royalties because they are received by a resident of State R, even if they are not taxed in that State by virtue of the tax exemption system applied in that State.
¹⁷ See page R(11)-3, paragraph 53 of the OECD report Triangular Cases. Included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at page R(11)-1.
79. In the 2017 update, paragraph 8 of Article 29 was added to the Convention to address "triangular cases". Under this provision, the benefits of the Convention are denied if the tax imposed on the income by the State in which the permanent establishment is located is less than 60 per cent of the tax that would have been imposed by the State of residence if the income had been received by a resident of that State and had not been attributed to a permanent establishment in a third State. See paragraph 35 of the Commentary on Article 29 (with reference to paragraphs 161–168 of the 2017 OECD Commentary on Article 29) concerning paragraph 8 of Article 29.
80. If similar provisions are not systematically included in agreements concluded by the State of source of such dividends, interest, royalties or fees for technical services with countries that operate tax exemption systems, there is a risk that the relevant assets will be transferred or the relevant services will be provided by associated enterprises that are residents of countries whose agreements with the State of source do not contain such a provision.
Attribution of Profits or Income to a Particular Individual or Legal Entity
81. In order to obtain treaty benefits that would otherwise be unavailable to them, taxpayers may enter into transactions or arrangements designed to ensure that income that would normally accrue to them instead accrues to a related individual or legal entity. Some of the methods used to implement such arrangements (for example, treaty shopping and the use of permanent establishments in low-tax countries) have already been discussed. Other income-shifting scenarios are considered below.
i) Transfer Pricing Not Consistent with the Arm's Length Principle
82. It has long been recognized that profits may be reallocated between associated enterprises through the use of prices that do not comply with the arm's length principle, and the tax legislation of most countries now contains transfer pricing rules specifically designed to address such cases. These rules are specifically authorized by Article 9 of the United Nations and OECD Model Conventions. Nevertheless, this is a relatively complex area, as evidenced by the comprehensive guidance developed by the OECD¹⁸ on how these rules and regulations should operate¹⁹.
¹⁸ OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, 1995 (as updated).
¹⁹ United Nations Practical Manual on Transfer Pricing for Developing Countries, United Nations, New York, 2013 (as amended).
ii) Thin Capitalization
83. In almost all countries, interest is an expense deductible from the tax base, whereas dividends, being distributions of profits, are not deductible. Consequently, a foreign company wishing to provide financing to a wholly owned subsidiary may consider it tax-efficient to provide such financing through debt rather than equity, depending on the overall tax treatment of interest. Therefore, a subsidiary may obtain virtually all of its financing in the form of debt rather than equity; this practice is known as "thin capitalization", or it may seek to deduct excessive interest in relation to its income, which is known as "earnings stripping".
84. According to the OECD report on thin capitalization²⁰, countries have developed various approaches to addressing this issue. These approaches may be broadly divided into those based on the application of general anti-abuse rules or the arm's length principle, and those involving the use of fixed "coverage ratios" — the ratio of equity to debt.
85. The first category includes rules and regulations that require an examination of the facts and circumstances of each individual case to determine whether the financing is genuinely provided in the form of debt or equity. This may be implemented through specific legislative rules, general anti-abuse rules, legal doctrines, and the application of transfer pricing legislation based on the arm's length principle.
86. The fixed-ratio approach is generally implemented through specific anti-abuse legislative rules; under this approach, if a company's overall debt-to-equity ratio exceeds a prescribed ratio, interest on excessive debt may be disallowed, deferred or reclassified as dividends.
87. To the extent that a country's thin capitalization rules apply to interest payments made to non-residents but do not apply to similar payments made to residents, this may constitute a violation of paragraph 4 of Article 24, which provides that "interest, royalties and other disbursements paid by an enterprise of a Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State shall, for the purpose of determining the taxable profits of such enterprise, be deductible under the same conditions as if they had been paid to a resident of the first-mentioned State". There is, however, a specific exception to this rule where paragraph 1 of Article 9, which governs transfer pricing adjustments, applies. For this reason, as indicated in paragraph 74 of the OECD Commentary on Article 24²¹:
Примечание: перевод выполнен по предоставленному фрагменту. Текст последнего пункта обрывается после вводной фразы и двоеточия, поэтому продолжение не добавлено. В исходнике также сохранены номера и содержание сносок; внешние гиперссылки в предоставленном тексте отсутствовали.
89. As provided in paragraph A), subparagraph (i) must be satisfied if the regime provides a preferential tax rate for interest, royalties or a combination thereof, as compared to income from sales or services. For example, a regime that provides a preferential tax rate on royalty income received by resident companies, but does not provide such a preferential tax rate for income from sales or services, meets this condition. In addition, a regime that provides a preferential tax rate for all classes of income (although, in practice, such a preferential rate is available primarily for interest, royalties or a combination thereof) satisfies subparagraph (i), notwithstanding the fact that such an approach is clearly not limited to these classes of income. For example, an administrative practice whereby the tax authority issues routine rulings establishing a preferential tax rate for companies that claim to derive predominantly interest income (e.g. group financing companies) satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (i), even if such rulings, as a technical matter, provide for a preferential tax rate for all forms of income.
90. Similarly, the provisions set out in paragraph B), subparagraph (i), must be satisfied if the regime provides for a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties or a combination thereof, as compared to income from the sale of goods or services, by one or more of the following means: an exclusion from gross receipts (e.g. an automatic fixed reduction in the amount of royalties included in income, where such a reduction is not also available for income from the sale of goods or services); a deduction without a corresponding payment or obligation to make a payment; a deduction for dividends paid or accrued; or taxation that is inconsistent with the principles of Articles 7 or 9 of the Convention. An example of a tax regime that results in taxation inconsistent with the principles of Article 9 is a regime under which interest income would not be imputed on a non-interest-bearing note held by a resident company of a Contracting State and issued by an associated enterprise that is a resident of another Contracting State.
91. A permanent reduction in the tax base of a State does not arise merely as a result of differences in timing. For example, the fact that a particular country does not tax interest until it is actually paid, rather than when it economically accrues, would not be regarded as a regime providing for a permanent reduction in the tax base, since such a rule represents an ordinary timing difference. Nevertheless, a regime that results in excessive deferral over many years should be regarded as providing for a permanent reduction in the tax base, since such a rule essentially represents a permanent difference in the tax base of the country imposing the tax.
92. Alternatively, as provided in paragraph C), subparagraph (i) must be satisfied if the regime provides for a preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base (of the type described above) in respect of substantially all income or substantially all foreign-source income for companies that do not carry on active business activities in the Contracting State. For example, regimes providing preferential tax rates only for the income of group financing companies or holding companies would generally satisfy the requirements of subparagraph (i).
93. A regime providing a favourable tax system that generally applies to all income (in particular, income from sales and services) and across all industries should not satisfy subparagraph (i). Examples of generally applicable provisions that do not satisfy subparagraph (i) include regimes allowing standard deductions, accelerated depreciation, corporate tax consolidation, deductions for dividends received, loss carry-forwards and foreign tax credits.
94. The second condition described in subparagraph (ii) of the definition applies only to royalties and is satisfied if the regime does not make the benefits conditional upon the amount of research and development activities carried out in the Contracting State, or upon the expenditures (other than any expenditures relating to subcontracting with a related party or any acquisition costs) incurred by the person benefiting from the regime for the purposes of actual research and development. Subparagraph (ii) is intended to ensure that royalties benefiting from “patent box” or “innovation box” regimes are entitled to treaty benefits only if such regimes satisfy one of these two requirements. However, some States would prefer the requirements of subparagraph (ii) to be limited and satisfied only where the regime makes the benefits conditional upon the amount of research and development activities carried out in the Contracting State. States sharing this view may prefer to use the following alternative version of subparagraph (ii):
(ii) in the case of any preferential tax rate or permanent reduction in the tax base for royalties, does not make the granting of such benefits conditional upon the amount of research and development activities carried out in the Contracting State;
Under either version of subparagraph (ii), royalty regimes that have been reviewed by the OECD Forum on Harmful Tax Practices and have not been identified as “actually harmful” would generally not satisfy subparagraph (ii) and, if they do, would not be considered special tax regimes.
95. The third condition described in subparagraph (iii) of the definition requires that the regime, as can reasonably be expected, result in a tax rate that is lower than the lower of the rates agreed bilaterally between the Contracting States and 60 per cent of the general statutory corporate tax rate applicable in the Contracting State that considers the other State’s regime to be a potential “special tax regime”.
96. States may find it useful to clarify the reference to “tax rate” for the purposes of subparagraph (iii) by including the following in a document recording the agreed interpretation of the treaty:
Except as provided below, the tax rate shall be determined on the basis of the income taxation principles of the Contracting State that has introduced the regime under consideration. Accordingly, in the case of a regime that provides only for a preferential tax rate, the tax rate that can reasonably be expected to apply under the regime should be equal to that preferential rate. In the case of a regime that provides only for a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate should be equal to the statutory corporate tax rate generally applicable in the Contracting State to companies subject to that regime, less the product of that rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base (with the baseline tax base determined in accordance with the principles of the Contracting State, but without taking into account any permanent reductions in the tax base described in paragraph B) of subparagraph ((i)), that can reasonably be expected under the regime. For example, a regime that generally provides for a 20 per cent permanent reduction in a company's tax base would have a tax rate equal to the applicable statutory corporate tax rate reduced by 20 per cent of that statutory rate. In the case of a regime providing for both a preferential tax rate and a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate would be based on the preferential tax rate reduced by the product of that rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base.
97. The foregoing explains that the tax rate is determined on the basis of the income taxation principles of the Contracting State that has introduced the regime under consideration. Accordingly, in the case of a regime that provides only for a preferential tax rate, the tax rate that can reasonably be expected to apply under the regime should be equal to that preferential rate. In the case of a regime that provides only for a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate will be equal to the statutory corporate tax rate generally applicable in the Contracting State to companies subject to that regime, less the product of that rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base (with the baseline tax base determined in accordance with the principles of the Contracting State, but without taking into account any permanent reductions in the tax base described in paragraph B) of subparagraph ((i)), that can reasonably be expected under the regime. For example, a regime that generally provides for a 20 per cent permanent reduction in a company's tax base would have a tax rate equal to the applicable statutory corporate tax rate reduced by 20 per cent of that statutory rate. Accordingly, if the applicable statutory corporate tax rate in the Contracting State were 25 per cent, the tax rate resulting from such a regime would be 20 per cent (25 - (25 x 0.20)). In the case of a regime providing for both a preferential tax rate and a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate would be based on the preferential tax rate reduced by the product of that rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base.
98. The fourth condition described in subparagraph (iv) of the definition provides that a regime should not be considered a special tax regime if it applies primarily to pension funds or organisations established and maintained exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural or educational purposes. Under subparagraph (iv), a regime should also not be considered a special tax regime if it applies primarily to persons whose taxation achieves a single level of taxation at the level of the person or its shareholders (with a deferral of no more than one year), which hold a diversified portfolio of securities that are subject to investor protection regulation in the State of residence and whose interests are primarily marketed to retail investors. This generally corresponds to the collective investment vehicles referred to in paragraph 22 above. The other exception provided for in subparagraph (iv) relates to regimes that apply primarily to persons whose taxation achieves a single level of taxation at the level of the person or its shareholders (with a deferral of no more than one year) and that hold predominantly immovable property.
99. The fifth condition described in subparagraph (v) of the definition provides that the Contracting State wishing to treat the regime of another State as a “special tax regime” must first consult with the other Contracting State and notify that State through diplomatic channels that it has determined that the regime satisfies the other conditions of the definition.
100. The final part of the definition requires the Contracting State wishing to treat the regime of another State as a “special tax regime” to issue a written public notice stating that the regime satisfies the definition. For the purposes of the Convention, a special tax regime shall be treated as such 30 days after the date of that written public notice.
Provision concerning subsequent changes in domestic law
101. Although the proposed provision on special tax regimes set out above would address the issue of targeted tax regimes, it would not address changes of a more general nature that may be made to the domestic law of a treaty partner after the conclusion of a tax treaty and which could have prevented the conclusion of the treaty had they existed at that time. For example, some Contracting States may be concerned if the general tax rate that another State imposes on corporate income falls below what they consider acceptable for the purposes of concluding a tax treaty. Some States may also be concerned if a State that taxes most types of foreign income at the time a tax treaty is concluded subsequently decides to exempt such income from tax where it is derived by a resident company. The following is an example of a provision that would address these concerns, on the understanding that the details of this provision should be restricted or expanded to take account of the specific concerns of each State:
1. If at any time after the signing of this Convention a Contracting State
a) reduces the general statutory corporate income tax rate applicable to substantially all income of resident companies, as a result of which that rate becomes lower than the lower of
(i) [rate to be determined bilaterally]; or
(ii) 60 per cent of the general statutory corporate tax rate applicable in the other Contracting State; or
b) the first-mentioned Contracting State grants resident companies an exemption from taxation in respect of substantially all foreign-source income (including interest and royalties),
the Contracting States shall consult with each other with a view to amending this Convention to restore an appropriate allocation of taxing rights between the Contracting States. If such consultations do not produce any results, the other State may notify the first-mentioned State through diplomatic channels that it is terminating the application of the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 [12A] and 21. In such a case, the provisions of those Articles in respect of payments to companies resident in both Contracting States shall cease to have effect six months after the date on which the other Contracting State issues a written public notice stating that it is terminating the application of the provisions of those Articles.
2. For the purposes of determining the general statutory corporate tax rate:
a. allowances for generally available deductions based on a percentage of what would otherwise be taxable income, and other similar mechanisms for achieving a reduction in the general tax rate, shall be taken into account; and
b. the following shall not be taken into account:
i. tax that applies to a company only upon a distribution by that company or that applies to shareholders; and
ii. the amount of tax that is refundable upon a distribution of dividends by the company.
102. The proposed provision provides that if, at any time after the signing of the Convention, either Contracting State introduces certain changes to its domestic law, the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 [12A] and 21 may cease to apply in respect of payments to companies if, following consultations, the Contracting States are unable to agree on amendments to the Convention to restore an appropriate allocation of taxing rights between the Contracting States.
103. Paragraph 1 of the proposed provision addresses two types of subsequent changes that a State may make to the tax rules applicable to companies resident in that State after the signing of a tax treaty. The first type is where that State reduces the general statutory corporate income tax rate applicable to substantially all income of resident companies, as a result of which that rate becomes lower than the lower of the rate to be determined bilaterally or 60 per cent of the general corporate income tax rate applicable in the other State.
104. For the purposes of paragraph 1, “general statutory corporate income tax rate” means the general corporate income tax rate provided for by law; where corporate tax rates are differentiated, this refers to the highest marginal rate, provided that such rate applies to a substantial proportion of corporate taxpayers and has not been established merely to circumvent the application of this Article. The general statutory corporate income tax rate applicable to business profits generally or to so-called “commercial income” (broadly including income from manufacturing, the provision of services or the trading of goods) should be regarded as applying to substantially all income of resident companies, even if narrow categories of income (including portfolio investment income or other passive activities) are excluded. A reduced tax rate that applies only to capital gains does not fall within the scope of this Article; the distinction between business profits and capital gains is made in accordance with the domestic law of the State of residence. Paragraph 2 addresses specific issues that may arise in determining the general statutory corporate tax rate of a State. Subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 provides that paragraph 1 applies equally to a reduction in the general statutory corporate income tax rate and to other changes in domestic law that would have the same effect if another mechanism were used. For example, if the statutory corporate income tax rate in a Contracting State were 20 per cent, but, after the signing of the Convention, resident companies of the Contracting State were permitted to claim deductions amounting to 50 per cent of what would otherwise be their taxable income, the general statutory corporate income tax rate would be 10 per cent (20 - (20 x 0.50)). Similarly, if the statutory corporate income tax rate in a Contracting State were 20 per cent, but, after the signing of the Convention, resident companies of the Contracting State were permitted to deduct an amount equal to a percentage of their capital, up to 50 per cent of what would otherwise be their taxable income. Generally, most companies would be able to use the maximum deduction available, resulting in a general corporate tax rate of 10 per cent. Subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 specifies the taxes that should not be taken into account in determining the general statutory corporate income tax rate. First, as provided in subparagraph (i) of subparagraph b), taxes levied at the company or shareholder level when a company distributes profits should not be taken into account in determining the general corporate tax rate (for example, if resident companies are not subject to taxation at the company level until a distribution is made, the tax imposed upon distribution would not be considered part of the general corporate income tax rate). Second, as provided in subparagraph (ii) of subparagraph b), any amounts of corporate tax that would be refundable upon a distribution of company income under the domestic law of the country should not be taken into account for the purposes of determining the general statutory corporate income tax rate.
105. The second type of subsequent changes to domestic tax law covered by paragraph 1 is where a State grants resident companies of that State an exemption from taxation in respect of substantially all foreign-source income (including interest and royalties) derived by those companies. The reference to an exemption in respect of substantially all foreign-source income derived by a resident company is intended to describe a tax system under which income (including interest and royalties) from sources outside the State is exempt from tax solely on the grounds that its source is outside that State (so-called “territorial” systems). The reference does not include tax systems under which the State of residence exempts only foreign-source dividends or business profits attributable to foreign permanent establishments from tax (so-called “dividend exemption” systems).
106. When any subsequent change in domestic law occurs, the Contracting States shall first consult with a view to amending the Convention to restore an appropriate allocation of taxing rights between the two Contracting States. If, following such consultations, the Contracting States agree on amendments or agree that the allocation of taxing rights under the Convention is not affected by the relevant changes made to the domestic law of one of the States, paragraph 1 shall cease to apply. However, if such consultations produce no results after a reasonable period of time, the other State may notify the State whose domestic law has changed, through diplomatic channels, that it is terminating the application of the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12, 12A and 21. After such diplomatic notification has been made, for paragraph 1 to apply, the State of source must issue a written public notice declaring that it is terminating the application of the provisions of these Articles. Six months after the date of that written public notice, the provisions of these Articles in respect of payments to companies that are residents of either State shall cease to have effect in both Contracting States.
Provision on notional equity deductions
107. One example of a tax regime in respect of which treaty benefits may be restricted relates to provisions of domestic law that provide for a notional deduction in respect of equity. Contracting States that agree to prevent the application of the provisions of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from such notional deductions may do so by adding the following provision to Article 11:
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1 of this Article, interest arising in a Contracting State and beneficially owned by a resident of the other Contracting State who is related to the payer (as defined in paragraph 8 of Article 5) may be taxed in the first-mentioned Contracting State in accordance with its domestic law if such resident benefits at any time during the taxable year in which the interest is paid from notional deductions in respect of amounts that the Contracting State of which the beneficial owner is a resident treats as equity.
The explanations in paragraph 85 above concerning the reference to a resident who is “related” to the payer apply equally to the above provision.
Provision on remittance-based taxation
108. Another example of a tax regime in respect of which treaty benefits may be restricted is remittance-based taxation. Under the domestic law of some States, persons who qualify as residents but do not have what is considered a permanent connection with the State (sometimes referred to as domicile) are taxed only on income derived from sources outside the State to the extent that such income is actually repatriated or remitted to that State. Thus, such persons are not subject to potential double taxation to the extent that foreign income is not remitted to their State of residence, and granting them the benefits of the Convention provisions in respect of such income may be considered inappropriate. Contracting States that agree to restrict the application of the provisions of the Convention to income actually taxed in the hands of such persons may do so by adding the following provision to the Convention:
Where, under any provision of this Convention, income arising in one Contracting State is wholly or partly exempt from tax in that State and, under the law in force in the other Contracting State, a person is subject to tax in respect of such income by reference to the amount of such income that is remitted to or received in that other State, rather than by reference to its full amount, any exemption provided for by the provisions of this Convention shall apply only to that part of the income that is taxed in the other Contracting State.
In some States, the application of this provision may create administrative difficulties if a significant period of time elapses between the time when the income arises in one Contracting State and the time when it is taxed by the other Contracting State in the hands of a resident of that other State. States concerned about these difficulties may make the rule in the final part of the above provision, namely the rule that the income in question will be entitled to benefits in the first-mentioned State only when it is taxed in the other State, subject to the condition that the income must be liable to tax in that other State within a specified period of time from the time when the income arises in the first-mentioned Contracting State.
3. The need to establish appropriate mechanisms for the application and interpretation of tax treaties
119. The Committee recognises the role that appropriate administrative procedures can play in minimising the risks of improper use of tax resources. Many substantive provisions of tax treaties must be supported by appropriate administrative procedures consistent with the procedural aspects of domestic tax law. Developing countries may consider developing their own procedural provisions concerning the application of treaties by examining the experience of countries that successfully apply treaties.
120. The Committee also recognises the importance of appropriate mechanisms for the interpretation of tax treaties. In many countries, there is a long history of independent legal interpretations of tax treaties that serve as guidance for tax administrations. Countries with weaker judicial systems or insufficient experience among their judicial authorities in interpreting tax treaties may consider alternative mechanisms to ensure the correct, prompt and accountable interpretation of treaties.
121. Although anti-abuse rules are important for preventing the improper use of treaties, the application of certain anti-abuse rules may be difficult for tax administrations, particularly in developing countries. For example, although the effective application of domestic transfer pricing rules may help countries address certain cases of improper use of treaty provisions, countries with limited experience in transfer pricing may be placed at a disadvantage. Furthermore, countries lacking sufficient experience in combating treaty abuse may be uncertain about the application of general anti-abuse rules, particularly in cases involving a purpose test. This increases the need for appropriate mechanisms to ensure the proper interpretation of tax treaties.
122. Developing countries may also be hesitant to adopt or apply general anti-abuse rules if they consider that such rules will create an unacceptable level of uncertainty that could discourage foreign investment in their territories. Although a ruling system that enables taxpayers to learn quickly whether anti-abuse rules will apply to contemplated transactions may help alleviate this concern, it is important that such a system ensure the confidentiality of transactions while also preventing discretionary interpretations (which in some countries may entail a risk of corruption). Clearly, a strong and independent judicial system will help provide taxpayers with confidence in the objective application of anti-abuse rules. Similarly, the effective application of the mutual agreement procedure will ensure that disputes concerning the application of anti-abuse rules are resolved in accordance with internationally recognised principles, thereby preserving the integrity of tax treaties.
20 Thin Capitalisation. The Report is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at page R(4)-1. Available on the website: www.oecd.org/dataoecd/42/20/42649592.pdf.
21 Paragraph 74 of the OECD Commentary on Article 24 is reproduced in the Commentary on Article 24 of this Model Convention.
Paragraph 4 does not prohibit the borrower State from applying its domestic thin capitalisation rules to the extent that they are compatible with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11. However, where such a regime is based on rules that are incompatible with those Articles and applies only to non-resident creditors (while excluding resident creditors), that regime is prohibited by paragraph 4.
88. Paragraph 3 of the Commentary on Article 9 of the OECD Model Convention, which is reproduced in paragraph 5 of the Commentary on the same provision in this Model Convention, clarifies that paragraph 1 of Article 9 permits the application of domestic thin capitalisation rules to the extent that they result in the borrower's profits being adjusted to an amount corresponding to the profits that would have been earned under the arm's length principle. Although this is generally the case where a thin capitalisation rule is based on the arm's length principle, a country that has adopted thin capitalisation rules based on a fixed debt-to-equity ratio will generally encounter difficulties in establishing that its thin capitalisation rules, which do not take into account the conduct of independent parties, satisfy this requirement.
89. For this reason, countries that have adopted thin capitalisation rules based on a fixed debt-to-equity ratio often consider it necessary to include provisions in their treaties that expressly permit the application of such rules. For example, Article 13 of the Protocol to the treaty between France and Estonia provides as follows:
The provisions of the Convention shall in no way prevent France from applying the provisions of Article 212 of its General Tax Code (code général des impôts) relating to thin capitalisation, or any substantially similar provisions that may amend or replace the provisions of that Article.
iii) Use of base companies
90. Base companies located in low-tax jurisdictions may be used for the purpose of diverting income to a country where that income will be subject to significantly lower taxation than would have been payable if the income had been received directly by the shareholders of that company.
91. Various approaches are used to counter such arrangements. For example, a company that is merely a “shell”, having no employees and carrying on no genuine economic activity, may be disregarded for tax purposes in some countries under general anti-abuse rules or legal doctrines. It is also possible to treat a base company that is effectively managed by shareholders who are residents of another State as a resident or permanent establishment in that State. The first approach is described in paragraphs 41–47 above. The second approach is described in paragraphs 29–30 above.
92. These approaches, however, may not be effective in relation to arrangements involving companies that carry on substantial management and economic activities in the countries in which they are incorporated. One of the most effective approaches to addressing such cases is the inclusion of controlled foreign corporation (CFC) provisions in domestic legislation. Although it is sometimes argued that such legislation may result in a violation of certain provisions of tax treaties, the Committee considers that this is not the case with respect to the typical CFC rules, as indicated in paragraph 40 above.
iv) Directors' and senior executives' remuneration
93. Under Article 16 (Directors' Fees and Remuneration of Senior Executives), directors' fees and remuneration received by senior executives of a company may be taxed in the State of which the company is a resident, irrespective of where the services of the directors and senior executives are performed. A “salary splitting” arrangement may be used to reduce the taxes payable in that State under this Article. Assume, for example, that Company A, a resident of State A, has two subsidiaries, B and C, which are residents of States X and Y, respectively. Mr. D, a resident of State X, is a director and senior executive of subsidiary B. State X imposes income tax at progressive rates of up to 50 per cent. State Y has a similar income tax system, but with a very low tax rate. States X and Y have a tax treaty under which State X applies the exemption method to income that may be taxed in State Y. In order to reduce Mr. D's tax burden, Company A may appoint him as a director and senior executive of Company C and arrange for the greater part of his remuneration to be paid in respect of those positions.
94. Paragraph 1 of Article 16 applies to directors' fees received by a person “in his capacity as a member of the board of directors” of a company, while paragraph 2 applies to salaries, wages and other similar remuneration received by a person “in his capacity as a senior executive” of a company. Thus, in addition to the fact that such an arrangement could probably be successfully challenged under general anti-abuse rules or legal doctrines, it may also be challenged through an appropriate analysis of the services provided by Mr. D to each of the companies from which he receives income, as well as an analysis of the fees and remuneration paid to other directors and senior executives of Company C, in order to determine the extent to which the directors' fees and remuneration received by Mr. D from that company may reasonably be regarded as attributable to activities carried out in his capacity as a director or senior executive of that company.
v) Allocation of interest to tax-exempt entities or government organisations
95. Under paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 11, countries may agree during bilateral negotiations to include in their treaties provisions exempting the following categories of interest payments from taxation:22
— interest paid to governments or government institutions;
— interest guaranteed by governments or government institutions;
— interest paid to central banks;
— interest paid to banks or other financial institutions;
— interest on long-term loans;
— interest on loans to finance specialised equipment or public works; or
— interest on other government-approved types of investment (for example, export financing).
96. Where a tax treaty includes one or more of these provisions, an organisation entitled to such an exemption may have the opportunity to establish “back-to-back” arrangements with other organisations that are not entitled to such an exemption or, where the treaty provides for interest and other types of income that are not exempt from taxation (for example, royalties), to allocate the greater part of the total remuneration (compensation) to interest payments. Such arrangements constitute an improper use of these tax exemptions.
97. Although it may be argued that the simplest solution would be to avoid including such exemptions in tax treaties, it is important to note that these categories are included in treaties for policy reasons, bearing in mind that withholding tax on gross interest payments often operates as a tax borne by the borrower. Furthermore, if a country agrees to include such exemptions in one of its treaties, difficulties arise in refraining from granting these benefits in treaties with other similar countries.
22 Many treaties additionally exempt from withholding tax interest paid to financial institutions and interest arising from credit sales (see paragraphs 12 and 13 of the Commentary on Article 11).
98. Many of the approaches described above, in the context of addressing the issue of treaty shopping, may be relevant to countering back-to-back arrangements designed to obtain the benefits of such tax exemptions. In addition, cases in which the remuneration provided for under a mixed contract has been improperly allocated to interest payments may be challenged through specific domestic anti-abuse rules applicable to such cases, general domestic anti-abuse rules or legal doctrines, or through the proper interpretation of treaty provisions. Where the total remuneration provided for under a contract is divided between associated parties, paragraph 6 of Article 11 and paragraph 1 of Article 9 may be applied to ensure that the benefits of the tax treaty exemption apply only to the appropriate amount of interest. Finally, some countries have included specific anti-abuse rules in their treaties to counter such back-to-back arrangements. An example of such a rule is paragraph (b) of Article 7 of the Protocol to the treaty signed between Australia and Mexico in 2002, which provides as follows:
The provisions of […] paragraph [2 of Article 11] shall not apply to interest derived from back-to-back loans. In such a case, the interest shall be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the State in which it arises.
Hiring-out of labour
99. The Commentary on Article 15 reproduces part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention which deals, in particular, with arrangements known as “international hiring-out of labour”. This refers to cases where a local enterprise wishing to employ a foreign worker for a short period enters into an agreement with a non-resident intermediary who acts as the formal employer. Thus, it appears that the employee satisfies all three conditions of paragraph 2 of Article 15 in order to qualify for an exemption from tax in the State where the employment activities are to be carried out. The Commentary on Article 15 includes guidance on how this problem may be addressed, taking into account that ways of challenging such arrangements are provided by domestic anti-abuse rules and legal doctrines, as well as by the proper drafting of the treaty.
Entertainers and sportspersons
100. A number of earlier tax treaties did not contain paragraph 2 of Article 17 (Artistes and Sportspersons), which regulates the use of so-called “star companies”. In order to avoid the possible application of the provisions based on paragraph 1 of that Article, residents of countries that have concluded such treaties may be tempted to arrange for income derived from their activities as entertainers or sportspersons, or part of that income, to be paid to a company established for that purpose.
101. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 17, which reproduces paragraph 11 of the OECD Commentary on that Article, such arrangements may be countered by domestic legislation that attributes such income to the entertainers or sportspersons themselves:
[…] The third situation involves certain forms of tax avoidance where remuneration for the performance of an entertainer or sportsperson is paid not to the entertainer or sportsperson but to another person, for example, a so-called artistes' company, so that the income is not taxed in the State where the activity is performed, either as income from the personal services of the entertainer or sportsperson or as business profits in the absence of a permanent establishment. Some countries, under their domestic legislation, disregard such arrangements and treat the income as having been received by the entertainer or sportsperson; in such cases, paragraph 1 allows them to tax the income derived from activities performed in their territory […].
102. Paragraph 11.2 of the OECD Commentary, which was added in 2003, clarifies that a State may also rely on its general anti-abuse rules and legal doctrines to counter abusive arrangements involving “star companies”:
11.2. As a general rule, it should be noted that, notwithstanding Article 17, the Convention does not prevent the application of the general anti-avoidance rules of the State of source contained in its domestic law, which allow that State to tax either the performing artist/sportsperson or the “star company” in abusive cases, as recognised in paragraph 24 of the Commentary on Article 1.
103. Finally, with respect to the anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 2 of Article 17, tax authorities should take into account that this rule applies irrespective of whether the “star company” is a resident of the same country as the entertainer or sportsperson. This clarification was also added to the OECD Commentary in 2003:
11.1. The application of paragraph 2 is not restricted to situations where the performing artist, sportsperson or other person to whom the income is attributed, such as a “star company”, is a resident of the same Contracting State. This paragraph allows the State in which the activities of the entertainer or sportsperson are performed to tax income derived from those activities and attributed to another person, irrespective of other provisions of the Convention that may apply on other grounds. Thus, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 7, this paragraph allows that State to tax income derived by a “star company” resident in the other Contracting State even in cases where the entertainer or sportsperson is not a resident of that other State. Conversely, if the income of an entertainer who is a resident of one of the Contracting States is attributed to a person, such as a “star company”, that is a resident of a third State with which the State of source has no tax convention, nothing prevents that Contracting State from taxing that person in accordance with its domestic law.
Transactions that change the treaty classification of income
104. Articles 6–21 allocate taxing rights differently depending on the nature of the income. The classification of a particular item of income for the purposes of these rules is based on a combination of treaty definitions and domestic law provisions. Since the contents of contracts, on which classifications for the purposes of domestic law and tax treaty provisions are generally based, are determined by taxpayers, they may in certain cases seek to influence that classification in order to obtain treaty benefits to which they are not entitled.
105. The following paragraphs provide some examples of arrangements designed to change the treaty classification of income. Depending on the circumstances, such arrangements may be countered by specific domestic or treaty anti-abuse rules, or by general anti-abuse rules or legal doctrines. Nevertheless, a practical difficulty often arises in that, in some of these cases, it is difficult to identify and establish the connection between the various transactions concluded for the purpose of changing such treaty classification.
i) Conversion of dividends into interest
106. The conversion of dividends into interest provides benefits under a treaty that provides for withholding tax on dividends but not on interest. Assume that X, a resident of State R, owns all the shares in Company A, which is a resident of State S. Planning to make a substantial dividend distribution, X arranges for the establishment of a holding company B, which is also a resident of State S, with X as its sole shareholder. X then sells the shares in Company A to Company B in exchange for interest-bearing notes (States R and S permit such a conversion without tax being paid). The payment of interest by Company B to X becomes possible through the payment of dividends by Company A to Company B, which avoids tax in State S under a participation exemption regime or a similar regime, or in connection with the deduction from the tax base of interest payments on the notes issued to X. Thus, X indirectly receives the dividends paid by Company A in the form of interest payments on the notes issued by Company B and avoids withholding tax in State S.
ii) Allocation of value under a mixed contract
107. A mixed contract covers various types of remuneration, such as the supply of goods, services, know-how and the licensing of intangible assets. As a result, different types of income arise for the purposes of the tax treaty. In many cases, the purchaser remains indifferent to the allocation of the price between the various types of remuneration, and therefore the supplier may allocate a disproportionately large share of the value in the relevant contract to those types of income that are exempt from tax in the State of source. For example, a franchise agreement may include the transfer of goods for sale, the provision of various services, the supply of know-how and royalties for the use of intellectual property (for example, trademarks and trade names). Where the non-resident franchisor does not have a permanent establishment in the State in which the franchisee is located, Article 7 will not allow that State to tax the business profits attributable to the supply of inventories and services, whereas Article 12 will allow the taxation of royalties and payments relating to know-how. Since all these payments are generally deductible for the franchisee, it makes no difference to the franchisee how the total value is allocated. The contract may therefore be structured so as to increase the value attributed to the supply of goods and services and reduce royalties and prices for the provision of know-how.
108. Since the parties to the contract are independent persons, domestic transfer pricing legislation and Article 9 of the Convention will generally not apply to such transactions. Developing countries may be particularly vulnerable to such transactions as a result of the gradual reduction of customs duties, which generally reduces the attractiveness of allocating value to the transfer of goods, while determining the appropriate category of remuneration for intangible assets is often a difficult task even for tax administrations operating under sophisticated tax regimes.
iii) Conversion of royalties into capital gains
109. A non-resident who owns the copyright in a literary work wishes to grant a resident of State S the right to translate and publish that work in that State in return for royalty payments based on sales of the translated work. Instead of granting a licence to the resident, the non-resident enters into a “sale and purchase” agreement under which all rights relating to the translated version of the work in State S are transferred by the non-resident and acquired by the resident. The consideration for such a “sale” consists of a percentage of the total sales of the translated work. The contract also provides that the non-resident will have the option to buy back those rights after five years.
110. Some countries have amended the definition of the term “royalties” to address precisely such cases. For example, subparagraph (a) of paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the treaty between the United States and India provides that the term “royalties” as used in this Article means:
(a) payments of any kind received as consideration for the use of, or the right to use, any copyright […], including gains from the alienation of any such right or property that are contingent on the productivity, use or disposition thereof […].
(iv) Use of transactions involving secondary securities
111. Transactions involving secondary securities may allow taxpayers to obtain the economic effect of certain financial transactions carried out in different legal forms. For example, depending on the provisions of the tax treaty and the domestic legislation of each country, a taxpayer may obtain such benefits as the absence or reduction of withholding tax where, in economic terms, the taxpayer is in the same position as a foreign investor investing in shares of a local company. Assume, for example, that Company X, a resident of State A, wishes to make substantial portfolio investments in shares of a company resident in State B, while Company Y, a resident of State B, wishes to acquire government bonds issued by State A. In order to avoid making cross-border dividend and interest payments that would give rise to withholding tax, Company X may instead purchase bonds issued in its own country, while Company Y may purchase shares in the company resident in its own country that Company X wishes to acquire. Companies X and Y enter into a swap agreement under which they agree to exchange payments based on the difference between the cash flows of the dividends and interest received by them annually; they also plan to enter into contracts in the future to purchase each other's shares and bonds at some point in the future. Through these transactions, the taxpayers have effectively “mirrored” the economic position of cross-border investments in shares and bonds without giving rise to withholding tax liabilities (except where the exchange of payments under the swap, which represents only the difference between the cash flows of dividends and interest, is subject to such taxes under Article 21 and the domestic law of each country).
Transactions designed to exceed thresholds specified in tax treaties
112. Tax treaty provisions sometimes use thresholds to determine a country's taxing rights over particular items of income. One example is the reduced withholding tax rate on dividends referred to in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10, which applies only where the beneficial owner of the dividends is a company that directly owns at least 25 per cent of the capital of the company paying the dividends.
113. Taxpayers may enter into arrangements to obtain the benefits of such provisions in unintended circumstances. For example, a non-resident shareholder may, in connection with a dividend distribution, arrange for the temporary transfer of its shares to a resident company or a non-resident company whose dividends are exempt from tax or taxed at a lower rate. Such a transfer may be structured so that the value of the expected dividends is converted into a capital gain that is exempt from tax in the State of source. Notwithstanding the fact that paragraph 2 of Article 10 was amended in the 2017 update to include a requirement for a 365-day holding period, provided that the company to which the shares are transferred owns more than 25 per cent of the shares of the company paying the dividends for a period of 365 days or more, the reduced rate provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 10 will apply. As noted in the Commentary on Article 10, which reproduces paragraph 17 of the 2014 OECD Commentary on that Article:
The reduction provided for in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 should not be granted in cases of abuse of this provision, for example, where a company holding less than 25 per cent has increased its shareholding shortly before a dividend payment primarily in order to obtain the benefits of the above provision, or where a qualifying shareholding is established primarily for the purpose of obtaining such a reduction. In order to counter such arrangements, the Contracting States may consider it necessary to supplement subparagraph (a) with the following provision:
provided that this shareholding has not been acquired principally for the purpose of obtaining the benefits of this provision.
Other examples of arrangements designed to circumvent various thresholds contained in the Convention are set out below.
Time limits for certain permanent establishments
114. Paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the Convention contains a rule under which, in certain circumstances, the provision of services by a foreign enterprise in a State for a period exceeding 183 days will be deemed to constitute a permanent establishment. A taxpayer may be tempted to circumvent the application of this provision by dividing a single project among associated enterprises or by dividing one contract into several separate contracts in order to claim that those contracts cover different projects. Guidance on such arrangements is provided in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the Commentary on Article 5.
Thresholds for source taxation of capital gains on shares
115. Paragraph 4 of Article 13 allows a State to tax capital gains from shares in a company (and interests in certain other entities) if more than 50 per cent of the value of the shares is derived, directly or indirectly, from immovable property situated in that State at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation of the shares. This 365-day period for determining whether more than 50 per cent of the value of shares in a company or another entity is derived from immovable property was added to paragraph 4 of Article 13 of the United Nations Model Convention as part of the 2017 update to the Convention.
116. Before the inclusion of the 365-day testing period in paragraph 4 of Article 13, attempts had been made to circumvent this provision by reducing the proportion of the value of an enterprise attributable to immovable property located in the State concerned in connection with the alienation of shares or interests in that enterprise. In the case of a company, this may be achieved by injecting a substantial amount of cash into the company in exchange for bonds or preference shares, the terms of which provide that such bonds or shares will be redeemed shortly after the alienation of the shares or interests.
117. Where an agreement does not contain a testing period, such as the 365-day period in paragraph 4 of Article 13 of the United Nations Model Convention, and the facts indicate that assets have been transferred to an entity primarily for the purpose of avoiding the application of paragraph 4 of Article 13 to the contemplated alienation of shares or interests in that entity, the general anti-abuse rules or legal doctrines of the country, or a general anti-abuse rule contained in the agreement, may well be applicable. Some countries, however, may expressly specify in their agreements that paragraph 4 applies in such circumstances. To this end, the following provision may be added to Article 13:
For the purposes of paragraph 4, in determining the total value of all the assets owned by a company, partnership, trust or estate, assets that have been transferred to that entity primarily for the purpose of avoiding the application of this paragraph shall not be taken into account.
Limitation of treaty benefits in respect of income subject to certain features of the tax system of another State
118. As indicated in paragraph 17.2 of the Introduction (quoted from paragraph 15.2 of the Introduction to the 2017 OECD Model Convention):
[…] It is assumed that, when a State accepts provisions of an agreement that limit its right to tax items of income, it generally does so on the understanding that those items of income are subject to tax in the other State. If the other State does not impose income tax or imposes low taxes, other States should consider whether there are double taxation risks that would, in themselves, justify the conclusion of a tax treaty. States should also consider whether there are features of the other State's tax system that may increase the risk of non-taxation, which may include tax benefits restricted to the domestic economy.
In this regard, the Committee decided that the following provisions of the Commentary on Article 1 of the OECD Model Convention, which were added as part of the 2017 update to that Convention, are also relevant for the purposes of the United Nations Model Convention:
83. A State may conclude that certain features of the tax system of another State are not sufficient to prevent the conclusion of a tax treaty, but may wish to prevent the application of that treaty to income that is not taxed or is taxed at a low rate as a result of those features. If the relevant features of the tax system of the other State are known at the time of treaty negotiations, provisions may be developed that specifically deny treaty benefits in respect of income that benefits from those features (see, for example, paragraph 108 below).
84. However, such features may be introduced into the tax system of the treaty partner only after the conclusion of the tax treaty, or they may be discovered only after the treaty has entered into force. Thus, when concluding a tax treaty, a Contracting State may be concerned about features of the tax system of its treaty partner that it is not aware of at that time or that may subsequently become part of that partner's tax system. Controlled foreign company provisions (see paragraph [32] above) and other approaches discussed in the preceding section, “Improper Use of the Convention”, may help to address some of these features, but since the difficulties created by these features arise from the structure of the tax legislation of the treaty partners rather than from tax avoidance strategies developed by taxpayers or their advisers, the Contracting States may wish to address these difficulties through specific treaty provisions. Examples of provisions that may be adopted for this purpose are set out below.
Provision on special tax regimes
85. Provisions may be included in a tax treaty to deny the application of specific treaty provisions in respect of income derived from regimes that satisfy the criteria of a general definition of “special tax regimes”. For example, the benefits provided for in Articles 11 and 12 may be denied in respect of interest and royalties that would be received from a related person if such interest and royalties benefited from a special tax regime in the State of residence of their beneficial owner; this may be achieved by adding the following provision to Articles 11 and 12 (which may be modified to take account of the circumstances of the Contracting States or to be included in other Articles of the Convention):
Notwithstanding the provisions of [(in the case of Article 11): paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4] [(in the case of Article 12): paragraph 1, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 3] of this Article, [interest] [royalties] arising in one Contracting State and beneficially owned by a resident of the other Contracting State who is related to the payer may be taxed in the first-mentioned Contracting State in accordance with its domestic law if such resident benefits from a special tax regime in respect of [interest] [royalties] in the State of which that resident is a resident.
For the purposes of the above provision, the reference to a resident who is “related” to the payer should be interpreted in accordance with the definition of “related person” contained in the Commentary on paragraph 7 of Article 29. As indicated in paragraph 127 of this Commentary, if the above provision is included in the Convention, it would be appropriate to include that definition in paragraph 1 of Article 3, which contains definitions applicable throughout the Convention. However, some States may prefer to replace the reference to a resident who is “related” to the payer with a reference to a resident who is “closely related” to the payer, the main difference being that, unlike the definition of “related person”, the definition of “closely related” contained in paragraph 8 of Article 5 does not apply where a person directly or indirectly owns exactly 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of the other person (if the definition of “closely related” is used for the purposes of the above provision, it would be more appropriate to include that definition in paragraph 1 of Article 3).
86. In addition, the above provision would require a definition of “special tax regime”, which could be formulated as follows and added to the list of general definitions included in paragraph 1 of Article 3:
The term “special tax regime” means any law, regulation or administrative practice in a Contracting State in respect of a tax described in Article 2 that satisfies all of the following conditions:
(i) results in one or more of the following:
A) a preferential rate of taxation on interest, royalties or any combination thereof compared with income from the sale of goods or services;
B) a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties or any combination thereof without a corresponding reduction in income from the sale of goods or services, by allowing:
1) an exclusion from gross revenue;
2) a deduction without regard to any corresponding payment or obligation to make a payment;
3) a deduction for dividends paid or accrued; or
4) taxation that is inconsistent with the principles of Articles 7 or 9; or
C) a preferential rate of taxation or a permanent reduction in the tax base of the type described in subparagraphs 1), 2), 3) or 4) of paragraph B) of this subdivision in respect of substantially all of a company's income or substantially all of a company's foreign-source income, for companies that do not carry on active business in that Contracting State;
(ii) in the case of any preferential rate of taxation or permanent reduction in the tax base for royalties, does not make the availability of such benefits conditional upon:
A) the amount of research and development activities carried out in the Contracting State; or
B) the expenditure (other than any costs relating to the subcontracting of work to a related party or any acquisition costs) incurred by the person benefiting from the regime for the purpose of carrying out actual research and development;
(iii) the tax rate is generally expected to be less than the lower of the following:
A) [the rate to be determined on a bilateral basis]; or
B) 60 per cent of the general statutory corporate tax rate applicable in the other Contracting State;
(iv) does not apply primarily to:
A) recognised pension funds;
B) organisations established and maintained exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural or educational purposes;
C) persons whose taxation results in a single level of taxation at the level of the person or its shareholders (with a deferral of no more than one year), which own a diversified portfolio of securities subject to investor protection regulation in the Contracting State and interests in which are primarily marketed to retail investors; or
D) persons whose taxation results in a single level of taxation at the level of the person or its shareholders (with a deferral of no more than one year) and which primarily own immovable property; and
(v) has been identified by the other Contracting State, following consultation with the first-mentioned Contracting State, through diplomatic channels to the first-mentioned Contracting State as satisfying the requirements of subdivisions (i) to (iv) of this subparagraph.
No law, regulation or administrative practice shall be considered a special tax regime until 30 days after the date on which the other Contracting State issues a written public notice identifying the regime as satisfying subdivisions (i) to (iv) of this subparagraph.
87. The above definition of the term “special tax regime” applies to any legislation, regulation or administrative practice (including prevailing practice) that exists before or comes into force after the signing of the treaty and that satisfies all five of the following conditions.
88. Under the first condition, described in subdivision (i) of the definition, the regime must result in one or more of the following:
A. a preferential rate of taxation on interest, royalties or any combination thereof compared with income from the sale of goods or services;
B. a specified permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties or any combination thereof without a corresponding reduction in income from sales or services; or
C. a preferential rate of taxation or a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of substantially all of a company's income or substantially all of a company's foreign-source income, for companies that do not carry on active business in that Contracting State. This part of the definition is intended to identify regimes that generally tax mobile income more favourably than immobile income.
Article 2
TAXES COVERED
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Article 2 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 2 of the OECD Model Convention.
- The purpose of this Article is to clarify the concepts and terminology relating to the taxes covered by the Convention. In this connection, it may be noted that, in one and the same country, the same income or capital may be subject to different taxes, either differing in their nature or similar in nature but levied by different territorial subdivisions or local authorities. Thus, double taxation cannot be entirely avoided unless the methods of relief from double taxation applied in each Contracting State take into account all the taxes imposed on such income or capital. Accordingly, the concepts and terminology relating to the taxes covered by a particular treaty must be clear, precise and as comprehensive as possible. As noted in the Commentary on Article 2 of the OECD Model Convention, this is necessary in order to:
- […] ensure the identification of the taxes in the Contracting States that are covered by the Convention; to extend the scope of the Convention as widely as possible by including, in agreement with the domestic laws of the Contracting States, as many taxes imposed by their territorial subdivisions or local authorities as possible; and to avoid the need to conclude a new convention whenever changes are made to the domestic laws of the Contracting States, through the periodic exchange of lists and by means of the mutual consultation procedure.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 2
Paragraph 1
- This paragraph states that the Convention applies to taxes on income and on capital, irrespective of the authority on behalf of which such taxes are levied (for example, on behalf of the State itself, its territorial subdivisions or local authorities) and irrespective of the manner in which such taxes are collected (for example, by direct assessment or withholding at source, in the form of surtaxes or surcharges, or as additional taxes).
Paragraph 2
- This paragraph defines taxes on income and on capital as taxes on total income, total capital or elements of income or capital, including taxes on profits from the alienation of movable or immovable property, taxes on capital appreciation and taxes on the total amount of wages and salaries paid by enterprises. Practices concerning taxes on the total amount of wages and salaries paid by enterprises differ from country to country, and this issue should be taken into account during bilateral negotiations. In accordance with paragraph 3 of the Commentary on Article 2 of the OECD Model Convention, taxes on the total amount of remuneration do not include "social security contributions or any other charges where there is a direct connection between the taxation and the individual benefits to be received". The OECD Commentary further states:
- It is undoubtedly the case that a State having the power to tax, and only that State, may levy the taxes provided for by its legislation, as well as any related duties or charges: on increases, costs, interest, etc. It was not considered necessary to specify this in this Article, since it is obvious that a Contracting State entitled to levy a tax may also levy additional duties or charges related to the principal tax. Most States, however, do not consider that interest and penalties accompanying taxes covered by Article 2 themselves fall within the scope of Article 2 and, accordingly, do not normally regard such interest and penalties as payments to which all the provisions concerning the taxing rights of the State of source (or situs) or the State of residence apply, including limitations on taxation by the State of source and the obligation of the State of residence to eliminate double taxation. Nevertheless, where taxation is withdrawn or reduced pursuant to a mutual agreement under Article 25, interest and administrative penalties relating to such taxation should be withdrawn or reduced to the extent that they are directly connected with the taxation (i.e. the tax liability) that is withdrawn pursuant to the mutual agreement. This applies, for example, where an additional charge is calculated on the basis of the amount of the principal tax liability and the competent authorities agree that all or part of the principal taxation is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. This also applies, for example, to cases where administrative penalties are imposed on the basis of a transfer pricing adjustment and that adjustment is cancelled because it is considered not to be in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 9.
- This Article does not refer to "ordinary taxes" or "special taxes". In general, the inclusion of special taxes in the Model Convention could be considered justified, but experience has shown that such taxes are generally levied under very specific circumstances. Moreover, it would be difficult to define them. They may be special for various reasons: because of their introduction, the manner in which they are collected, their rates, their purposes, etc. In view of this, it appears preferable not to include special taxes in this Article. However, since there is no intention to exclude special taxes from all conventions, ordinary taxes have not been mentioned either. Thus, the Contracting States are free to restrict the scope of the Convention to ordinary taxes, extend it to special taxes or even provide for special provisions.
Paragraph 3
- This paragraph gives the Contracting States the possibility of listing the taxes to which the Convention applies. In accordance with the Commentary on paragraph 3 of Article 2 of the OECD Model Convention, this list "is not exhaustive", since "it serves to illustrate the preceding paragraphs of this Article". In principle, however, it is expected that this will be "a complete list of the taxes levied in each State at the time of signature and covered by the Convention".
Paragraph 4
- The Commentary on paragraph 4 of Article 2 of the OECD Model Convention applies:
- Since the list of taxes in paragraph 3 is purely declaratory in nature, this paragraph provides that the Convention shall also apply to any identical or substantially similar taxes introduced in a Contracting State after the date of signature of the Convention in addition to, or in place of, the existing taxes in that State.
- Each State undertakes to notify the other State of any significant changes made to its tax legislation, providing it, for example, with information about new or replacement taxes. Member States are also encouraged to report other important developments, such as new rules or court decisions; many countries already follow this practice. The Contracting States may also, without restriction, extend the notification requirement to any significant changes in other laws that affect their obligations under the Convention. Contracting States wishing to take such measures may replace the last sentence of the paragraph with the following wording: The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall notify each other of any significant changes made to their tax legislation or other laws affecting their obligations under the Convention.
Commentary on Chapter II DEFINITIONS
Article 3
GENERAL DEFINITIONS
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Article 3 of the United Nations Model Convention is identical to Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention, except that Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention contains definitions of the terms "enterprise" and "business" in subparagraphs c and h of paragraph 1, whereas these are not included in Article 3 of the United Nations Model Convention. This is explained by the fact that Article 14 (Independent Personal Services) has been deleted from the OECD Model Convention, whereas it remains in the United Nations Model Convention.
- For the understanding and application of any bilateral tax convention, it is generally necessary to have several general definitions, whereas terms relating to more specific concepts are usually defined or interpreted in special provisions. On the other hand, there are terms whose definitions are not included in the Convention but are clarified during bilateral negotiations.
- As in Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention, Article 3 of the United Nations Model Convention contains a number of general definitions necessary for the interpretation of the terms used in the Convention. These terms include the following: "person", "company", "enterprise of a Contracting State", "international traffic", "competent authority" and "national". Article 3 leaves room for the definition of the "competent authority" of each State. The terms "resident" and "permanent establishment" are defined in Articles 4 and 5, respectively, whereas the interpretation of certain terms used in the Articles dealing with specific categories of income (for example, immovable property, dividends) is contained in the relevant Articles. The parties to the Convention may agree bilaterally on the definition of the terms "one of the Contracting States" and "the other Contracting State". They may also include in the definition of one of the Contracting States a reference to the continental shelf.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 3
Paragraph 1
a) The term "person"
- The term "person", which is defined in subparagraph a as meaning any individual, company or any other body of persons, should be interpreted very broadly. In accordance with the Commentary on paragraph 2 of Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention, this term also includes "any entity which, although not incorporated, is treated as a body corporate for tax purposes. Thus, for example, a foundation (fondation, Stiftung) may fall within the meaning of the term 'person'. Partnerships will also be regarded as 'persons' either because they fall within the definition of 'company' or, in other cases, because they constitute other bodies of persons".
b) The term "company"
- The definition of the term "company", like the corresponding definition in the OECD Model Convention, is formulated with specific reference to Article 10 on dividends. The definition concerns that Article, as well as paragraphs 8-9 of Article 5, Article 16 and Article 29, which correspond to paragraphs 7-8 of Article 5, Article 16 and Article 29 of the OECD Model Convention.
c) The term "enterprise of a Contracting State"
- Subparagraph c provides definitions of the terms "enterprise of a Contracting State" and "enterprise of the other Contracting State". It does not define the term "enterprise" as such, since, as noted in the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention, "the question whether a particular activity is carried on within the framework of an enterprise or is itself considered to constitute an enterprise must always be interpreted in accordance with the provisions of the domestic law of the Contracting States".
d) The term "international traffic"
- The definition of the term "international traffic" is based on the principle that the right to tax profits derived from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic belongs exclusively to the Contracting State in which the place of effective management is situated. This principle is set out in paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative A) (corresponding to paragraph 1 of Article 8 of the OECD Model Convention) and in paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative B), as well as in the first sentence of paragraph 2 of Article 8 (provided, in the latter case, that the relevant transportation activity is no more than incidental). However, the Contracting States may agree bilaterally, where necessary, to replace the reference in subparagraph d to the permanent residence in order to ensure consistency with the general nature of the other Articles dealing with international traffic. In such cases, as noted in the 2017 edition of the Commentary on Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention, the definition should read: "the term 'international traffic' means any voyage on a ship or aircraft, except where the ship or aircraft is operated solely between places in a Contracting State in which the enterprise operating the ship or aircraft does not have its place of effective management".
- As also noted in the OECD Commentary, "the definition of the term 'international traffic' is broader than the ordinary meaning of that term, in order to preserve the right of the State in which the place of effective management is situated to tax purely domestic traffic, as well as international traffic between third States, and to permit the other Contracting State to tax traffic exclusively within its borders". A ship or aircraft is operated solely between places in the other Contracting State in respect of a particular voyage if the place of departure and the place of arrival of the ship or aircraft are both situated in that other Contracting State. Thus, for example, a cruise that begins and ends in that other Contracting State without calling at a foreign port does not constitute the transportation of passengers in international traffic. Conversely, a cruise that begins and ends in that other Contracting State with a call at a foreign port constitutes the transportation of passengers in international traffic, and for this purpose a "call" takes place if passengers are permitted to go ashore, even temporarily, but only at a scheduled intermediate destination.
8.1 The 2017 edition of the OECD Commentary also explains that "in 2017, this definition was amended so that it would also apply to transportation by a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State". Although this amendment does not affect the application of Article 8, which concerns only the profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State, it makes it possible to apply paragraph 3 of Article 15 to a resident of a Contracting State who derives remuneration from employment exercised aboard a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State.
e) The term "competent authority"
- As in the OECD Model Convention, the definition of the term "competent authority" is left to the Contracting States, which are entitled to designate one or more authorities vested with the relevant competence for the purposes of applying the Convention. This approach is necessary because, in some countries, the implementation of a convention for the avoidance of double taxation cannot take place exclusively within the jurisdiction of the highest tax authorities, since certain matters may be reserved to other authorities or may fall within their competence.
f) The term "national"
- Originally, the definition of the term "national" was included in paragraph 2 of Article 24, concerning the concept of "non-discrimination". As a result, the definition of the term "national" would have had limited application solely for the purposes of Article 24. Since the term "national" is also mentioned in other Articles of the Convention, namely in subparagraphs c and d of paragraph 2 of Article 4, in Articles 19, 24 and 25, it was decided in 1999 to transfer the definition of the term "national" from paragraph 2 of Article 24 to subparagraph f of paragraph 1 of Article 3. With regard to individuals, the definition simply states that this term applies to any individual possessing the nationality of a Contracting State. It was not considered necessary to include in the text of the Convention any considerations concerning the meaning of nationality, beyond those considered appropriate for making any special remarks concerning the meaning and application of this word. In determining what is meant by "nationals of a Contracting State" in relation to individuals, reference must be made to the meaning in which this term is ordinarily used and to the laws of each State concerning the acquisition or loss of nationality.
- Subparagraph f further elaborates on legal persons, partnerships and associations. The statement contained in this provision that a national is any legal person, partnership or association deriving its status as such from the laws in force in a Contracting State resolves a problem that often arises in determining the nationality of companies. In determining the nationality of companies, some States are guided not so much by the law governing the company as by the origin of the capital on the basis of which the company was formed and the nationality of the individuals or legal persons controlling it.
- Furthermore, taking into account the legal relationship that exists between a company and the State under whose laws it was created, which resembles the relationship of nationality in the case of individuals, it seems appropriate not to deal with legal persons, partnerships and associations in a special provision, but to group them together with individuals under the term "national".
Paragraph 2
- As in paragraph 2 of Article 3 of the OECD Model Convention, this paragraph contains a general rule concerning the meaning of terms used but not defined in the Convention. According to the OECD Commentary, paragraph 2 was amended in 1995 in order to:
13.1. […] make its text more consistent with the general and common understanding of the Member States. For the purposes of paragraph 2, the meaning of any term not defined in the Convention may be confirmed by reference to the meaning that the term has for the purposes of any relevant provision of the domestic law of one of the Contracting States, irrespective of whether that legislation is tax legislation or not. However, where a term is defined differently for the purposes of different laws of one of the Contracting States, the meaning assigned to that term for the purposes of the legislation imposing the taxes to which the Convention applies shall prevail over all other meanings, including those assigned for the purposes of other tax laws. States that are able to enter into mutual agreements (under the provisions of Article 25, and in particular paragraph 3 thereof) establishing the meanings of terms not defined in the Convention should take such agreements into account when interpreting those terms.
In the event of a conflict between the legislation in force at the time of signature of the Convention and the legislation in force at the time of application of the Convention, the latter legislation shall prevail.
- The OECD Commentary states:
- Nevertheless, paragraph 2 indicates that it applies only where the context does not require an alternative interpretation. The context is determined, in particular, by the intention of the Contracting States at the time of signing the Convention, as well as by the meaning assigned to the term in the legislation of the other Contracting State (an implied reference to the principle of reciprocity on which the Convention is based). Thus, the wording of this Article gives the competent authorities a certain degree of discretion.
- Consequently, the wording of paragraph 2 provides a sufficient balance between the need to ensure the stability of the obligations undertaken by States upon signing the Convention (since a State should not be allowed to partially deprive the Convention of its effect by subsequently changing the scope of terms not defined in the Convention in its domestic legislation), on the one hand, and the need to be able to apply the Convention in a convenient and practical manner over a certain period of time (the need to avoid referring to outdated concepts), on the other hand.
Article 4
RESIDENT
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Article 4 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention with one amendment, namely: in 1999, an additional criterion — "place of registration" — was added to paragraph 1 to the list of criteria for taxation as a resident. In accordance with the Commentary on Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention:
- The concept of "resident of a Contracting State" has various functions and is considered important in three cases:
a) when determining the personal scope of application of the Convention;
b) when resolving cases of double taxation arising as a result of dual residence;
c) when resolving cases of double taxation arising as a result of taxation in the State of residence and in the State of source or situs of property.
- As in Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention, Article 4 of the United Nations Model Convention defines the expression "resident of a Contracting State" and establishes rules for resolving cases of dual residence. In the two typical cases of conflict between two residences and between residence and source or situs of property, the cause of the conflict lies in the fact that, under their domestic legislation, one or both Contracting States claim that the person concerned is resident in their territory. In this connection, the OECD Commentary provides the following explanation:
- As a general rule, the domestic laws of different States provide for unlimited tax liability — "full tax liability" — on the basis of the personal connection of taxpayers with the State concerned (the "State of residence"). Such an obligation to pay taxes is imposed only on persons who have "residence" in that State in the sense in which "residence" is ordinarily defined in legislation (private law). The number of cases involving unlimited tax liability has been extended to include, for example, persons who are permanently or, possibly, for a certain period of time present in the territory of that State. In the legislation of some States, unlimited tax liability is imposed on individuals performing services aboard seagoing vessels whose home port is situated in that State.
- Double taxation conventions themselves, when defining the conditions under which a person is considered a "resident" for tax purposes and, accordingly, bears full liability to pay taxes in that State, generally do not affect the domestic laws of the Contracting States. They do not establish standards that the provisions of domestic law concerning "residence" must meet in order for claims of full tax liability to apply in relations between the Contracting States. In this matter, the position of States is based exclusively on domestic law.
- This is quite clearly demonstrated in cases where there is no conflict between two places of residence, and the conflict exists only between residence and the source or situs of property. However, the same view also applies to conflicts between two places of residence. The peculiarity of these cases is merely that reference to the concept of residence adopted under the domestic law of the States concerned cannot lead to the resolution of this conflict. In such cases, the Convention must provide for special provisions making it possible to determine which of the two concepts of residence should be given preference.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 4
Paragraph 1
- The former Group of Experts decided to adopt paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention as paragraph 1 of Article 4 and initially decided not to adopt the second sentence, which reads: "However, this term [resident of a Contracting State] does not include any person who is liable to tax in that State in respect only of income from sources in that State or capital situated therein". The second sentence, included in the OECD Model Convention to take account, for example, of the special position of foreign diplomats and consular employees serving in a State that taxes residents on the basis of their worldwide income, who may be regarded as residents (under the domestic law of the country in which they serve) but who, nevertheless, by virtue of their special status, may be liable to tax only in respect of income from sources in that State, was also included in paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the United Nations Model Convention in 1999.
- The OECD Commentary notes:
a. Under the provisions of the second sentence of paragraph 1, however, a person is not considered a "resident of a Contracting State" within the meaning of the Convention if that person, although not having residence in that State, is regarded as a resident under its domestic legislation but is liable only to taxation limited to income from sources in that State or capital situated therein. In some States, such a situation arises in connection with individuals, for example, in relation to foreign diplomatic and consular employees serving in their territory.
b. In accordance with the wording and spirit of the second sentence, it also excludes from the definition of a resident of a Contracting State foreign-owned companies whose foreign income is exempt from taxation by virtue of privileges granted to attract shell companies. It also excludes companies and other persons that do not bear full tax liability in a Contracting State, since such persons, although they are residents of that State under its tax legislation, are considered residents of another State under a treaty between those two States. The exclusion of certain companies from the definition obviously cannot prevent the Contracting States from exchanging information about their activities (see paragraph 2 of the OECD Commentary on Article 26). In essence, States may consider it appropriate to develop voluntary exchanges of information about companies seeking to obtain treaty benefits.
- Paragraph 1, like the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention, refers to the concept of residence contained in the domestic laws of the Contracting States and lists the criteria for taxation as a resident: domicile, residence, place of management (to which the United Nations Model Convention adds "place of registration") or any other criterion of a similar nature. In this wording, the definition of the term "resident of a Contracting State", in accordance with the OECD Commentary, is intended, as regards individuals, to cover "[…] the various forms of personal connection with a State which, under its domestic tax legislation, form the basis for full taxation (full tax liability)"23
- The OECD Commentary notes:
8.4. According to the general understanding of most Member States, for the purposes of the Convention, the government of each State, as well as any of its territorial subdivisions or local authorities, is a resident of that State. Prior to 1995, the Model Convention contained no direct reference to this; in 1995, an amendment was made to Article 4 in order to bring the text of the Model Convention into line with this understanding.
(It may be noted that a similar amendment was made to the United Nations Model Convention in 1999).
8.6. Paragraph 1 applies to persons who are "liable to tax" in a Contracting State under its laws by virtue of various criteria. In many States, a person is considered to bear full tax liability even if the Contracting State does not actually impose a particular tax. For example, pension funds, charitable and other organisations may be exempt from taxes, but they are exempt only if they meet all the requirements for exemption stipulated in the tax legislation. Thus, they are subject to the tax legislation of the Contracting State. Furthermore, if they do not meet the stipulated standards, they are also required to pay taxes. Most States regard such persons as residents for the purposes of the Convention (see, for example, paragraph 1 of Article 10 and paragraph 5 of Article 11).
8.7. In some States, however, such persons are not considered liable to tax if they are exempt from taxation under domestic tax legislation. Those States may not regard such persons as residents for the purposes of the Convention if these entities expressly fall within the scope of the Convention. Contracting States adopting this view may resolve the issue within the framework of bilateral negotiations.
8.8. Where a State disregards partnerships for tax purposes and treats them as fiscally transparent entities, taxing the partners on their share of the partnership's income, the partnership itself does not bear tax liability and, consequently, cannot be considered a resident of that State. In such a case, since under the national legislation of that State the income of the partnership "passes through it" directly to the partners, it is the partners who are liable to tax on that income and, consequently, are the appropriate persons to claim treaty benefits under the conventions concluded by the States of which they are residents. This latter result is achieved even where, under the domestic legislation of the State of source, the income is attributed to the partnership, which is treated as a separate taxable entity. For States that do not agree with this interpretation of the Article, there is an opportunity to achieve this result through a special provision that would make it possible to avoid potential double taxation where different tax treatment is applied to partnership income in the two States.
Some members of the Committee of Experts disagreed with the statement included in paragraph 8.8 of the above extract from the OECD Commentary that partners in fiscally transparent partnerships may claim the application of the provisions of the Convention. They expressed the view that special rules in the Convention would be required to ensure this result. This is achieved, for example, by adopting a new paragraph 2 of Article 1, which is now included in the Convention. Paragraph 2 of Article 1 clarifies that the Convention shall apply to the income of a partnership to the extent that such income is treated for tax purposes in that State as the income of a partner who is a resident of that State. The same treatment shall apply to income from other entities or arrangements that are treated as fiscally transparent under the tax laws of a Contracting State.
6.1 Some countries would like to clarify that recognised pension funds shall be treated, in accordance with Article 4, as residents of the Contracting State in which they are established. In such a case, those countries could amend paragraph 1 of Article 4 by adding provisions concerning recognised pension funds.
Paragraph 2
- This paragraph, which reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention, lists a number of subsidiary criteria in descending order of importance, to be applied in cases where an individual is a resident of both Contracting States and the preceding criteria do not provide a clear determination of that individual's status in terms of residence. It may be noted that, in 1999, following amendments previously made to the OECD Model Convention, the word "only" was included in subparagraphs a, b and c of paragraph 2. The OECD Commentary states:
- This paragraph deals with the case where, under paragraph 1, an individual is a resident of both Contracting States.
- In order to resolve this conflict, it is necessary to provide for special rules that would make it possible to give preference to the connection with one State over the connection with the other State. As far as possible, the criterion of preference should be such that no questions arise in this regard, but that the person concerned satisfies it in only one State, and at the same time it should reflect such a connection as would make it natural to assign the taxing right to that particular State. The cases to which the special rules will apply relate to the period during which the taxpayer's residence affects tax liabilities, which period may be shorter than the entire tax period. For example, in one calendar year, an individual is a resident of State A from 1 January to 31 March under the tax legislation of that State, and then moves to State B. Since that individual resides in State B for more than 183 days, the individual is regarded as a resident of State B throughout the entire year under the tax legislation of State B. By applying the special rules in respect of the period from 1 January to 31 March, that individual is considered a resident of State A. Thus, both State A and State B must treat that individual as a resident of State A during that period and as a resident of State B during the period from 1 April to 31 December.
- This Article gives preference to the Contracting State in which the individual has a permanent home available to them. This criterion will often be sufficient to resolve the conflict, for example, where an individual has a permanent home in one of the Contracting States and is present in the other Contracting State only for a certain period of time.
- Thus, subparagraph a) means that, for the purposes of applying the Convention (that is, where a conflict arises between the laws of the two States), the place where the individual has a permanent home owned by or available to them is considered to be the place of residence; such a home must be permanent, that is, the individual must have arranged and maintained it for permanent use, as opposed to staying in a particular place under circumstances indicating that such stay will be short-term.
- With regard to the concept of "home", it should be noted that a home in any form may be taken into account (a house or apartment owned or rented by the individual, a rented furnished room). At the same time, the permanent nature of the home is of substantial importance; this means that the individual has arranged the dwelling for permanent use at any time, rather than for the purposes of temporary accommodation which, due to the reasons giving rise to it, will invariably be short-term (a tourist trip, business trip, familiarisation trip, studies at an educational institution, etc.).
- If an individual has a permanent home in both Contracting States, paragraph 2 gives preference to the State with which that individual has closer personal and economic relations, which is interpreted as the centre of vital interests. Where the permanent home cannot be determined by reference to this rule, paragraph 2 provides for additional criteria, firstly, the habitual abode and, thereafter, nationality. If the individual is a national of both States or of neither of them, the matter shall be resolved by mutual agreement between the relevant States in accordance with the procedure set out in Article 25.
- If an individual has a permanent home in both Contracting States, the facts must be examined in order to determine with which of the two States that individual has closer personal and economic relations. Thus, the individual's family and social relations, professional, political, cultural or other activities, place of business, the place from which the individual manages their property, etc., will be taken into account. All the circumstances must be examined as a whole, but it is nevertheless clear that particular attention should be paid to considerations based on the personal actions of the individual. If a person who has a home in one State establishes a second home in another State while retaining the first, the fact that the person retains the first home under the conditions in which they have always lived, where they have worked and where their family and property are located, together with other elements, may be used to confirm that the person has retained their centre of vital interests in the first State.
- Subparagraph b contains a secondary criterion for two clearly defined and distinct situations:
a) where an individual has a permanent home in both Contracting States and it is impossible to determine in which of them the individual's centre of vital interests is situated;
b) where an individual has no permanent home in either of the Contracting States.
Preference is given to the State in which the individual has a habitual abode.
- In the first situation, where an individual has a permanent home in both States, the fact that the individual habitually resides in one State rather than the other is therefore considered a circumstance which, in the event of doubt as to the location of the individual's centre of vital interests, allows a preference to be given to the State in which that person is more frequently present. For this purpose, the individual's presence should be taken into account not only at their permanent home in that State but also at any other place in that State.
- The second situation concerns an individual who has no permanent home in either of the Contracting States, for example, a person who moves from one hotel to another. In such a case, all places of residence in that State should also be taken into account, without specifying the reasons for such residence.
- Subparagraph b provides that, in the two situations envisaged therein, preference is given to the Contracting State in which the individual has a habitual abode, but it does not specify the period of time over which the comparison must be made. The comparison should cover a sufficient period of time to determine whether the place of stay in each of the two States is habitual and also to identify the intervals between such stays.
- If, in both situations referred to in subparagraph b, the individual has a habitual abode in both Contracting States or has no habitual abode in either of them, preference is given to the State of which the individual is a national. If, in such cases, the individual is a national of both Contracting States or of neither of them, subparagraph d imposes on the competent authorities the obligation to resolve the issue by mutual agreement in accordance with the procedure provided for in Article 25.
Paragraph 3
8. Paragraph 3, which reproduces paragraph 3 of Article 4 of the OECD Model Convention, deals with companies and other bodies of persons, whether or not they have legal personality. Paragraph 21 of the OECD Commentary notes that “in practice, it will rarely happen that a company, etc. is liable to tax as a resident in more than one State, but this is certainly possible, for example, where one State attaches primary importance to the place of incorporation, while another attaches primary importance to the place of effective management. Special rules of preference must therefore also be provided for companies, etc.” According to paragraph 22 of the same Commentary, “when paragraph 3 was first developed, it was considered inappropriate to attach importance to such a purely formal criterion as the place of incorporation, and preference was given to a rule based on the place of effective management, which was to be based on the place where the company, etc. was actually managed.”
9. However, the OECD/G20 recommendation contained in the Final Report on Action 6 (“Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances”) led to changes in the resolution of cases of dual residence based exclusively on the place of effective management. In 2017, the Committee decided that amendments to the OECD Commentary should also be adopted as follows:
23. However, in 2017, the Committee on Fiscal Affairs recognized that, although cases of dual residence of persons other than individuals are relatively rare, a number of cases of tax avoidance involving dual-resident companies had been identified. In this regard, the Committee concluded that the best solution to the problem of dual residence of entities other than individuals was to consider such situations on a case-by-case basis.
24. As a result of these considerations, the current version of paragraph 3 provides that the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to settle cases of dual residence of a person other than an individual by mutual agreement.
24.1 The competent authorities applying paragraph 3 will have to take into account various factors, such as the place where meetings of the board of directors or equivalent body of the person are usually held, where the chief executive officer and other senior executives usually carry out their activities, where the senior day-to-day management of the person is carried out, where the person's headquarters are located, the laws of which country govern the person's legal status, where its accounting records are kept, whether determining that a legal entity is a resident of one of the Contracting States, but not the other, for the purposes of the Convention would entail a risk of improper use of the provisions of the Convention, etc. Countries that consider that the competent authorities should not be given discretion to resolve such dual-residence cases without specifying the factors to be used for this purpose may wish to supplement the provision by referring to these or other factors that they consider important.
24.2 A determination under paragraph 3 will normally be requested by the person concerned through the mechanism provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25. Such an application may be submitted as soon as it becomes likely that the person will be considered a resident of each Contracting State under paragraph 1. In view of the notification requirement contained in paragraph 1 of Article 25, it must in any event be submitted within three years from the first notification to that person of tax measures taken by one or both States indicating that the person has been denied benefits or exemptions on account of its dual-resident status in the absence of prior efforts by the competent authorities to determine a single State of residence under paragraph 3. The competent authorities to which a request for a determination of residence under paragraph 3 is submitted should consider it expeditiously and communicate their response to the taxpayer as soon as possible.
24.3 Since the facts on which the decision will be based may change over time, the competent authorities making a determination under this provision should specify the period of time covered by that determination.
24.4 The last sentence of paragraph 3 provides that, in the absence of a decision by the competent authorities, the dual-resident person shall not be entitled to any benefits or exemptions under the Convention, except to the extent and in the manner that may be agreed upon by the competent authorities. However, this will not prevent the taxpayer from being considered a resident of each Contracting State for purposes unrelated to the granting to that person of benefits or exemptions provided for under the treaty. This would mean, for example, that the condition in subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 15 would not be satisfied in respect of an employee of that person who is a resident of one of the Contracting States and carries out employment activities in the other State. Similarly, if the person is a company, it will be considered a resident of each State for the purposes of applying Article 10 to dividends that it pays.
10. Although the updated 2017 version of the United Nations Model Convention removed the place of effective management criterion from paragraph 3 of Article 4, some States may consider it preferable to address cases of dual residence of legal entities by using that criterion. These States may assume that this provision can be interpreted in such a way as to prevent its abuse and may consider it appropriate to include the following alternative version of paragraph 3, which was included in the United Nations Model Convention before the 2017 update:
3. Where, by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1, a person other than an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, it shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which its place of effective management is situated.
Article 5
PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
1. Article 5 of the United Nations Model Convention is based on Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention, but has several significant differences. Essentially, the main differences are that, under the United Nations Model Convention:
— a six-month time criterion is provided for a building site or construction project to constitute a permanent establishment, rather than the twelve-month criterion provided for in the OECD Model Convention, and it is expressly stated that this term also includes assembly projects and supervisory activities connected with building sites, construction, installation or assembly projects (paragraph 3 a);
— the furnishing of services by an enterprise through employees or other personnel results in the existence of a permanent establishment in cases where activities of that nature are carried on for a total period of more than 183 days in any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned (paragraph 3 b);
— Article 14 (Independent Personal Services) has been retained, whereas Article 14 has been deleted from the OECD Model Convention, and situations previously governed by the “fixed base” criterion in that Article are now governed by Article 5. As will be noted below (in paragraph 15.1 et seq.), although Article 14 has been retained in the United Nations Model Convention, this Commentary provides recommendations for countries that do not wish to include such an article in their bilateral tax treaties;
— “delivery of goods” is absent from the list of places that are deemed not to constitute a permanent establishment (this list is often referred to as the list of types of “preparatory and auxiliary activities”), whereas this type of activity is included in that list in the OECD Model Convention. Therefore, under the United Nations Model Convention, the delivery of goods may give rise to a permanent establishment, whereas under the OECD Model Convention it does not;
— the activities of a “dependent agent” may be deemed to constitute a permanent establishment even if that agent does not have and does not habitually exercise authority to conclude contracts in the name of the enterprise, but habitually maintains a stock of products or goods and regularly makes deliveries from that stock (paragraph 5 b);
— it includes a special provision governing cases in which a permanent establishment is created for the conduct of insurance activities; thus, under the approach adopted in the United Nations Model Convention, the existence of a permanent establishment is more likely in such cases (paragraph 6); and
These differences are discussed in greater detail below.
2. The concept of a “permanent establishment” is used in bilateral tax treaties to determine the right of a State to tax the profits of an enterprise in another State. In particular, the profits of an enterprise of one State are taxable in the other State only if that enterprise has a permanent establishment in the latter State, and only to the extent that those profits are attributable to that permanent establishment. The concept of a permanent establishment also appears in earlier model conventions, including the model conventions developed by the League of Nations in 1928. This concept is reaffirmed in the United Nations Model Convention.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 5
Paragraph 1
3. This paragraph, which reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention, contains a definition of “permanent establishment” that emphasizes its essence as a “fixed place of business” with a specific “location of property”. According to the OECD Commentary, this definition contains the following conditions:
— the existence of a “place of business”, i.e. a facility such as premises or, in some cases, machinery or equipment;
— this place of business must be “fixed”, i.e. it must be established as a distinct facility with a certain degree of permanence;
— the carrying on of the business of the enterprise through such a fixed place of business. This generally means that persons who are in some way dependent on the enterprise (personnel) carry on the business of the enterprise in the State in which the fixed place of business is situated.
The OECD Commentary further states:
3. It may be argued that the general definition should also mention another characteristic of a permanent establishment which in the past was sometimes considered important, namely that the permanent establishment must have a productive character, that is, it must contribute to the profits of the enterprise. This characteristic has not been included in the present definition. In a well-organized business, it can be assumed with complete confidence that each participant contributes to overall productivity. Of course, not every enterprise which has a “productive character” in the broader context of the entire organization is, as a result, a permanent establishment to which profits may properly be attributed for the purposes of taxation in a particular territory (see the Commentary on paragraph 4).
4. The term “place of business” includes any premises, facilities or installations used for carrying on the business of the enterprise, whether or not they are used exclusively for that purpose. A place of business may also exist where no premises are available or required for carrying on the business of the enterprise, which makes use of certain areas at its disposal. Whether those premises, facilities or installations are owned by, rented by or otherwise at the disposal of the enterprise is immaterial. Thus, a place of business may consist of a market stall or a permanently used area in a customs warehouse (for example, for the storage of dutiable goods).
Furthermore, a place of business may be situated in the business premises of another enterprise. This applies, for example, where certain business premises (or part thereof) belonging to another enterprise are at the permanent disposal of a foreign enterprise.
4.1 As noted above, the mere fact that an enterprise has certain areas at its disposal which are used for carrying on its business is sufficient for those areas to be considered a place of business. Thus, no formal legal right to use that place is required. For example, a permanent establishment may exist where an enterprise illegally occupies certain premises from which it carries on its business.
4.2 Although no formal legal right to use a particular place is required for that place to constitute a permanent establishment, the mere presence of an enterprise at a particular location does not necessarily mean that such location is at the disposal of that enterprise. The following examples illustrate these principles in situations where representatives of one enterprise are present on the premises of another enterprise. The first example is that of a salesman who regularly visits a major customer to take orders and meets with the purchasing director in the latter's office. In this case, the customer's premises are not at the disposal of the enterprise for which the salesman works and therefore do not constitute a fixed place of business through which that enterprise carries on its business (although, depending on the circumstances, the existence of a permanent establishment may be presumed under paragraph 5).
4.3 The second example is that of an employee of a company who is permitted to use an office in the head office of another company (for example, a recently acquired subsidiary) for an extended period of time in order to ensure that the latter company fulfils its obligations under contracts concluded with the first company. In this case, the employee carries on activities related to the business of the first company, and the office at his disposal in the head office of the other company will constitute a permanent establishment of his employer, provided that the office is at his disposal for a sufficiently long period of time to be considered a “fixed place of business” (see paragraphs 6–6.3) and that the activities carried on in that office are not limited to the types of activities listed in paragraph 4 of the Article.
4.4 The third example is that of a freight transport enterprise which, for a number of years, uses a loading area at a customer's warehouse every day to deliver goods purchased by that customer. In this case, the presence of the freight transport enterprise at the loading area will be so limited in nature that the enterprise cannot regard that area as being at its disposal, such that the area could constitute a permanent establishment of that enterprise.
4.5 The fourth example is that of a painter who, for two years, works three days a week in the large office building of his main customer. In this case, the painter's presence in that office building, where he performs the most important functions of his business (that is, painting the walls), constitutes a permanent establishment of the painter.
4.6 The words “through which” should be interpreted broadly as referring to any situation in which business activities are carried on at a particular location that is at the disposal of the enterprise for that purpose. Thus, for example, an enterprise engaged in road paving will be considered to carry on its business “through” the location where that activity is performed.
5. Under the definition, the place of business must be “fixed”. Thus, there must normally be a connection between the place of business and a specific geographical location. It is immaterial how long an enterprise of one of the Contracting States operates in the other Contracting State if it does not do so at any particular location, but this does not mean that equipment constituting a place of business must be physically attached to the location where it is situated. It is sufficient that such equipment remains permanently at a particular site (but see paragraph 20 below).
5.1 Where the nature of the business carried on by an enterprise requires that its business activities frequently move between neighbouring locations, difficulties may arise in determining a single “place of business” (if an enterprise carries on activities from two places and the other requirements of Article 5 are met, it will, of course, be considered to have two permanent establishments). As recognized in paragraphs 18 and 20 below, a single place of business will generally be considered to exist where, having regard to the nature of the business, a particular area within which the provision of services moves may be regarded as constituting a commercially and geographically coherent whole in relation to that business.
5.2 This principle can be illustrated by the following examples. Obviously, a mine constitutes a single place of business, even though business activities may move from one location to another within the mine, which may be very large, since, from the perspective of the mining enterprise, the mine constitutes a single geographical and commercial unit. Similarly, an “office-hotel complex” in which a consulting firm regularly rents different business premises may be considered a single place of business for that firm, since in this case the building constitutes a geographical whole and the hotel constitutes a single place of business for that consulting firm. For the same reason, a pedestrian street, an open-air market or a fair, in different parts of which a trader regularly sets up his stall, constitutes a single place of business for that trader.
The OECD Commentary then provides a number of examples concerning the provision of services. In quoting the following two paragraphs, the Committee notes that subparagraph 3 b of Article 5 of the United Nations Model Convention contains a specific provision governing the furnishing of services by an enterprise through employees or other personnel engaged for that purpose. Thus, in practice, paragraphs 5.3 and 5.4 of the OECD Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 5 (as well as other sections of the OECD Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 5) may be of less significance for the United Nations Model Convention than in their original context.
5.3 Conversely, in the absence of commercial unity, the fact that a particular activity may be carried on within a limited geographical area should not justify treating that area as a single place of business. For example, where a painter successively performs work under a number of unrelated contracts for several unrelated customers in a large office building, so that it cannot be said to constitute a single project for repainting the building, the building should not be considered a single place of business for the purposes of that activity. However, in the case of a painter who, under a single contract, performs work throughout the building for a single customer, that activity constitutes a single project for that painter, and in this case the entire building may be regarded as a single place of business for the purposes of that activity, since it will constitute a commercially and geographically coherent whole.
5.4 Conversely, an area in which activities are carried on under a single project constituting a commercially coherent whole may not possess the necessary geographical unity to be regarded as a single place of business. For example, where a consultant works in different branches at different locations as part of a single project to train bank employees, each such branch should be considered separately. However, if the consultant moves from one office to another within the same branch, he should be considered to remain at the same place of business. The location of a branch possesses geographical unity, which is absent when the consultant moves between branches situated at different locations.
The OECD Commentary further states:
6. Since a place of business must be fixed, it follows that a permanent establishment can be considered to exist only if the place of business has a certain degree of permanence, that is, it is not of a purely temporary nature. However, a place of business may be considered a permanent establishment even where, in practice, it exists for only a very short period of time due to the nature of the business that is to be carried on during that short period. It is sometimes difficult to determine whether this is indeed the case. Although the practice of member countries with regard to the relevant time requirements is inconsistent, experience shows that, as a rule, where business activities are carried on in a particular country through a place of business that exists for less than six months, such place of business is not considered a permanent establishment (and conversely, experience shows that in many cases where a place of business exists for more than six months, such place is considered a permanent establishment). One exception is periodic activities: in such cases, each period of time during which the place is used must be considered together with the number of occasions on which that place is used (possibly over a number of years). Another exception is made in respect of cases where an activity constitutes a business carried on exclusively in that country; in this situation, the period of time during which that business is carried on may be short due to the nature of the activity, but since it is carried on entirely in that country, its connection with that country is stronger. For the convenience of administration, countries may wish to take this practice into account when resolving disagreements as to whether a particular place of business existing for only a short period of time constitutes a permanent establishment.
The Committee agreed with the approach adopted in paragraph 6 of the OECD Commentary, while recognizing that such exceptional situations rarely arise in practice and that, therefore, particular care should be exercised when applying the provisions of paragraph 6 in a specific situation. The OECD Commentary further states:
6.1 As indicated in paragraphs 11 and 19, the temporary cessation of operations cannot be considered to constitute the closure of a permanent establishment. Furthermore, as stated in paragraph 6, where a particular place of business is used for very limited periods of time, but such use occurs regularly over an extended period of time, that place of business should not be regarded as being of a purely temporary nature.
6.2 Furthermore, there may be cases where a particular place of business is used for very short periods of time by a number of similar enterprises managed by the same person or related persons, in an attempt to create the impression that the place is used by each individual enterprise for only a short period of time. In such cases, the observations in paragraph 18 concerning procedures designed to circumvent the twelve-month period provided for in paragraph 3 will be relevant.
6.3 If a place of business which was established from the outset exclusively for use over a short period of time, so that it would not be considered a permanent establishment, continues to operate for such a period that it can no longer be regarded as temporary, that place becomes a fixed place of business and, consequently, retrospectively, a permanent establishment. A place of business may also be considered a permanent establishment from the time of its establishment, even if in fact it existed for only a very short period of time because, owing to special circumstances (for example, the death of the taxpayer or the absence of investment), it was prematurely liquidated.
7. In order for a place of business to constitute a permanent establishment, the enterprise using it must carry on all or part of its business through that place. As noted in paragraph 3 above, the activity does not necessarily have to be productive in nature. Furthermore, this activity does not have to be continuous in the sense that operations must be uninterrupted, but the operations must be carried on on a regular basis.
8. If tangible property, such as premises, industrial, commercial or scientific (ICS) equipment and buildings, or intangible property, such as patents, technological procedures and similar property, is leased or rented to third parties through a fixed place of business maintained by an enterprise of one of the Contracting States in the other State, such activity will generally result in that place of business being considered a permanent establishment. The same applies to the receipt of capital through a fixed place of business. If an enterprise of one State leases or rents premises, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, buildings or intangible property to an enterprise of the other State without carrying on such leasing or rental activity through a fixed place of business in the other State, the leased premises, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, buildings or intangible property as such will not constitute a permanent establishment of the lessor, provided that the contract is limited to the mere leasing of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, etc. This also applies where, for example, after carrying out installation work, the lessor provides personnel to operate the equipment, provided that the duties of such personnel are limited exclusively to the operation and maintenance of the industrial, commercial or scientific equipment under the management, responsibility or control of the lessee. If such personnel have broader powers, for example, participate in decisions concerning the operation for which the equipment is used, or if such personnel operate, maintain, inspect and service equipment that remains under the responsibility and control of the lessor, the lessor's activities may go beyond the ordinary leasing of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and may constitute business activities. In such a case, provided that the permanence criterion is met, a permanent establishment may be considered to exist. If such activities are connected with the activities referred to in paragraph 3 or are similar in nature to them, the [six]-month time limit shall apply. Other cases should be determined according to the circumstances.
10. The business of an enterprise is carried on mainly by the entrepreneur or by persons employed by the enterprise (personnel). Such personnel include employees and other persons receiving instructions from the enterprise (for example, dependent agents). The authority of such personnel in their relations with third parties is immaterial. It is immaterial whether a dependent agent is authorized to conclude contracts if he works at a fixed place of business […]. However, a permanent establishment may nevertheless exist where the business of the enterprise is carried on mainly through automated equipment and the activities of the personnel are limited to setting up, operating, monitoring and maintaining such equipment. Thus, whether gaming and vending machines and similar equipment installed by an enterprise of one State in the other State may be considered a permanent establishment depends on whether the enterprise carries on any business activities in addition to the initial installation of such machines. A permanent establishment does not exist if the enterprise merely installs the machines and then leases them to other enterprises. However, a permanent establishment may exist if the enterprise that installs the machines also operates and maintains them at its own expense. This also applies where such machines are operated and maintained by an agent employed by the enterprise.
11. The existence of a permanent establishment begins from the moment when it commences carrying on its business through a fixed place of business. This occurs as soon as the enterprise starts carrying on at the place of business the activities for which that place is to be used on a permanent basis. The period during which the enterprise establishes that fixed place of business should not be taken into account, provided that this activity differs substantially from the activity for which the place is to be used on a permanent basis. A permanent establishment ceases to exist upon the disposal of the fixed place of business or the cessation of any activity carried on through it, that is, when all actions and measures connected with the former activities of the permanent establishment have been discontinued (the cessation of current business operations, servicing and repair of facilities). At the same time, the temporary cessation of operations cannot be considered to constitute closure. If a fixed place of business is leased to another enterprise, it will generally serve only the business of that enterprise and not that of the lessor; as a rule, the lessor's permanent establishment ceases to exist, except in cases where it continues to carry on independent business activities through the fixed place of business.
3.1. In 2017, a number of amendments were made to Article 5 and, accordingly, to this Commentary. The amendments relating to the addition of paragraph 4.1 and the modification of paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of the Article, which were introduced as a result of the adoption of the Report on Action 7 of the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, are exclusively prospective in nature and, as such, do not affect the interpretation of the previous provisions of the United Nations Model Tax Convention and of international treaties incorporating those provisions, particularly with regard to the interpretation of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the Article as they stood before those amendments were made.
Paragraph 2
4. Paragraph 2, which reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention, provides examples of places that are commonly considered to constitute a permanent establishment. However, this provision should not be regarded as independent. Although paragraph 2 notes that common types of permanent establishments include offices, factories, etc., the requirements of paragraph 1 must also be satisfied for them to be recognized as permanent establishments. Thus, paragraph 2 merely indicates that the relevant places may constitute permanent establishments; it does not mean that such an establishment necessarily exists. This position is also confirmed in the OECD Commentary, which assumes that States interpret the listed terms “in such a way that these offices constitute permanent establishments only if they meet the requirements of paragraph 1”. Developing countries often wish to expand the scope of the term “permanent establishment” as much as possible and, in particular, propose including warehouses among the specific examples. However, the exclusion of the term “delivery” from the activities referred to in subparagraphs (a) and (b) of paragraph 4 means that a “warehouse” used for this purpose is (provided that the requirements set out in paragraph 1 are met) a permanent establishment under the general principles of the Article.
Paragraph 13 of the OECD Commentary emphasizes that the term “place of management” is mentioned separately because it does not always mean an “office”, and that “if the laws of the two Contracting States do not contain a concept of ‘place of management’ that differs from ‘office’, there is no need to refer to this term in their bilateral treaties”.
5. In connection with subparagraph (f), which provides that the term “permanent establishment” includes mines, oil and gas wells, quarries or any other place of extraction of natural resources, the OECD Commentary states that “the expression ‘any other place of extraction of natural resources’ should be interpreted broadly” so as to include, for example, all places of extraction of hydrocarbons, both onshore and offshore. Since subparagraph (f) does not mention the exploration of natural resources, whether onshore or offshore, paragraph 1 must be relied upon when determining whether exploration is carried on through a permanent establishment.
The OECD Commentary states as follows:
15. […] However, since it has proved impossible to achieve unanimity on the fundamental questions of who is entitled to tax and into which category income from exploration activities should fall, the Contracting States may agree to include special provisions. For example, they may agree that an enterprise of one of the Contracting States, in connection with its activities relating to the exploration of natural resources in a place or area in the other Contracting State:
a) shall be deemed not to have a permanent establishment in that other State; or
b) shall be deemed to carry on such activities through a permanent establishment in that other State; or
c) shall be deemed to carry on such activities through a permanent establishment in that other State if such activities continue for more than a specified period of time.
Furthermore, the Contracting States may agree that income from such activities shall be subject to any other rule.
6. As noted above, the expression “any other place of extraction of natural resources” in subparagraph (f) should be interpreted broadly. Some argue in this connection that fishing vessels may be considered places of extraction or exploitation of natural resources, since “fish” constitute a natural resource. They proceed on the basis that, although all the places or equipment referred to in subparagraphs (a)–(e) of paragraph 2 as “permanent establishments” do indeed possess a certain degree of permanence or constitute “immovable property”, fishing vessels may nevertheless be considered places used for the extraction of natural resources, which may be understood to include not only minerals located in the ground. According to this view, fishing vessels may in fact be compared to a floating drilling platform used for offshore drilling to gain access to oil or gas. Where such fishing vessels are used in the territorial waters or exclusive economic zone of a coastal State, the activities of such vessels will constitute a permanent establishment situated in that State. However, in the opinion of a number of other members, some countries may disagree with this approach on the grounds that it gives an excessively broad interpretation to the term “permanent establishment” and to the actual wording of this subparagraph. Therefore, in their view, countries that are parties to a particular treaty and wish to make such a proposal in respect of fishing activities should do so by expressly including it as a new independent category in the list contained in this Article. Consequently, the question of how the nature of such activities is to be interpreted will be resolved during negotiations between the Contracting States, so that, for example, countries that consider a fishing vessel capable of constituting a permanent establishment may, at their discretion, expressly specify this in this Article, using, for example, the approach described in paragraph 13 of this Commentary. Thus, the question of the interpretation of the nature of such activities will be resolved during negotiations between the Contracting States. \
Paragraph 3
7. This paragraph covers a broader range of activities than paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention, which provides: “A building site or construction or installation project constitutes a permanent establishment only if it lasts more than 12 months.” In addition to the term “installation project” used in the OECD Model Convention, subparagraph (a) of paragraph 3 of the United Nations Model Convention includes an “assembly project”, as well as “supervisory activities” in connection with “a building site, a construction, installation or assembly project”. Another difference is that, whereas the OECD Model Convention establishes a period of twelve months, the United Nations Model Convention reduces this minimum period to six months. In special cases, the six-month period may be reduced to three months, but not less, during bilateral negotiations. The Committee notes that countries have differing views as to whether subparagraph a) of paragraph 3 is a “self-standing” provision (so that no reference to paragraph 1 is required) or whether (conversely) only building sites, etc., that meet the criteria of paragraph 1 may constitute permanent establishments, provided that they also satisfy the specific condition of existing for at least six months. However, the Committee considers that, in cases where a building site exists for six months, it will, in practice, almost invariably also meet the requirements of paragraph 1. Indeed, an enterprise that has a building site, etc., at its disposal through which it carries on all or part of its activities will also meet the criteria of paragraph 1.
8. Some countries support a more detailed version of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 3, under which the provision would also apply to a situation “where such a project or activity connected with the sale of machinery or equipment continues for a period not exceeding six months, and the costs paid in connection with the project or activity exceed 10 per cent of the sale price of that machinery or equipment”. Other countries consider that the inclusion of such a provision would be inappropriate, particularly where the machinery is installed by an enterprise other than the one carrying out the construction work.
9. Subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3 of Article 5 deals with the provision of services, including consultancy services, the provision of which does not, under the OECD Model Convention, in itself create a permanent establishment. Many developing countries consider that this subparagraph should cover managerial and consultancy services, since the provision of such services in developing countries by enterprises from industrialized countries can be highly profitable. In the 2011 version of the United Nations Model Convention, the Committee agreed to make a minor amendment to the wording of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3, changing it to read as follows: “but only if activities of that nature continue (for the same or a connected project) within a Contracting State for a period or periods aggregating more than 183 days in any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned” instead of “but only if activities of that nature continue (for the same or a connected project) within a Contracting State for a period or periods aggregating more than six months within any twelve-month period”, as previously worded.
It was decided that this would be more consistent with the approach adopted in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14. In the revised 2017 version, the Committee made a further amendment to subparagraph (b), deleting the words in parentheses “(for the same or a connected project)”. This amendment is discussed in greater detail in paragraph 12 below.
10. Several developing countries are opposed altogether to the establishment of a six-month (or 183-day) time limit in subparagraphs (a) and (b) of paragraph 3. They have two main reasons for this: first, they argue that, since modern technologies make it possible for construction, assembly and similar work to be carried out over very short periods of time while nevertheless generating substantial profits for the enterprise carrying out such activities, they are firmly convinced that the period during which foreign personnel are present in the source State has no bearing whatsoever on that State’s right to tax the income (as in the case of entertainers and sportspersons under Article 17). Other developing countries oppose the time limit because foreign enterprises may take advantage of it to create artificial arrangements designed to avoid taxation in source States. However, the purpose of bilateral treaties is to promote international trade, investment and development, and the rationale underlying the establishment of a time limit (and the setting of time limits for permanent establishments generally) is to encourage enterprises to carry out preparatory or auxiliary operations in another State that will facilitate a more permanent nature and expansion of activities at a later stage, without immediately becoming subject to taxation by that State.
11. In this regard, the 2017 OECD Model Commentary states the following (changes reflecting the different time periods in the two Conventions are shown in square brackets):
51. The [six]-month test applies to each individual site or project. In determining the duration of the existence of a site or project, time previously spent by the relevant contractor on other sites or projects that are wholly unrelated to it should not be taken into account. A building site should be regarded as a single unit, even if it is based on several contracts, provided that, from a commercial and geographical point of view, it clearly constitutes a single whole. Subject to this condition, a building site constitutes a single unit even where orders have been placed by several persons (for example, for a number of houses).
52. The [six]-month threshold period creates opportunities for abuse: there have been cases where enterprises (mainly contractors or subcontractors working on the continental shelf or engaged in activities connected with the exploration and exploitation of the continental shelf) have divided their contracts into several parts, each covering a period of less than [six] months and attributable to a separate company which nevertheless belonged to the same group. Apart from the fact that such abuses may, depending on the circumstances, fall within the scope of domestic legislative or judicial anti-avoidance rules, they may also be addressed by applying the anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9 of Article 29, as illustrated by Example J [and Example N] in paragraph [182] of the Commentary on Article 29. Nevertheless, some States may wish to address such abuses expressly. In addition, States that have not included paragraph 9 of Article 29 in their treaties should include an additional provision dealing with the splitting-up of contracts. Such a provision could be worded, for example, as follows:
Solely for the purpose of determining whether the [six-month] period referred to in paragraph 3 has been exceeded,
a) where an enterprise of a Contracting State carries on activities in the other Contracting State at a place that constitutes a building site or a construction [assembly] or installation project [or supervisory activities in connection therewith], and those activities are carried on during one or more periods of time which, in the aggregate, exceed 30 days but do not exceed [six] months; and
b) connected activities are carried on at the same building site or construction, [assembly] or installation project [or supervisory activities in connection therewith] during different periods of time, each exceeding 30 days, by one or more enterprises closely related to the first-mentioned enterprise,
these different periods of time shall be added to the period of time during which the first-mentioned enterprise carried on activities at that building site or construction, [assembly] or installation project [or supervisory activities in connection therewith].
The concept of “closely related enterprises”, which is used in the above provision, is defined in paragraph [9] of Article (see paragraphs 119–121 below).
53. For the purposes of the alternative provision contained in paragraph 52, the determination of whether activities are connected will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. Factors that may be particularly relevant for this purpose include:
— whether the contracts covering the different activities were concluded with the same person or with persons related to that person;
— whether the conclusion of additional contracts with a person is a logical consequence of a previous contract concluded with that person or persons related to that person;
— whether the activities would have been covered by a single contract but for tax-planning considerations;
— whether the nature of the work performed under the different contracts is the same or similar;
— whether the same employees perform activities under the different contracts.
The Committee notes that measures to combat such abuses will apply equally to cases governed by subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3 of Article 5. The rule against the splitting-up of contracts provided for in paragraph 52 of the OECD Commentary may be amended to also counteract abuses contemplated by subparagraph (b). Another possibility is to include the following text immediately after subparagraph (b), which is based on a similar provision contained in the 2016 treaty between Chile and Japan, but uses the closely related enterprise wording contained in the OECD provision:
The duration of activities under subparagraphs (a) and (b) shall be determined by aggregating the periods during which activities are carried on in a Contracting State by closely related enterprises, provided that the activities of such closely related enterprise in that Contracting State are connected with the activities carried on in that Contracting State by its closely related enterprises. A period during which two or more closely related enterprises carry on activities simultaneously shall be counted only once for the purpose of determining the duration of the activities.
The Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Convention contains the following relevant extracts:
19. A site exists from the time when the contractor begins its work, including any preparatory work, in the country where the construction is to be carried out, for example, when it establishes a planning office for the construction. In general, the site continues to exist until the work is completed or permanently abandoned. A temporary interruption of the work cannot be regarded as a cessation of the existence of the site. Seasonal or other temporary interruptions should be taken into account when determining the duration of the existence of the site. Seasonal interruptions include interruptions caused by bad weather. A temporary interruption may, for example, be caused by a shortage of materials or difficulties with the workforce. Thus, for example, if a contractor begins road works on 1 May, suspends those works on 1 [August] because of adverse weather conditions or a lack of materials, resumes them on 1 [October] and completes the construction of the road on 1 [January] of the following year, its construction site should be regarded as a permanent establishment because [eight] months have elapsed between the date on which the work began (1 May) and the date on which it was finally completed (1 [January]). If an enterprise (the general contractor) that has undertaken the execution of the entire project subcontracts parts of that project to other enterprises (subcontractors), the time spent by a subcontractor working at the construction site should be regarded as time spent by the general contractor on the construction project. The subcontractor itself has a permanent establishment at the site if the duration of its activities there exceeds [six] months.
The Committee considers that the reference to “parts” of the project in the penultimate sentence of this paragraph of the OECD Commentary should not be understood as meaning that an enterprise that subcontracts all parts of a project can never have a permanent establishment in the host State.
The Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Convention continues as follows:
19.1 In the case of fiscally transparent partnerships, the [six]-month test applies at the level of the partnership in relation to its own activities. If the period of time spent at the site by the partners and employees of that partnership exceeds [six] months, the enterprise operated by the partnership will be considered to have a permanent establishment. Thus, for the purposes of taxing each partner’s share of the profits of the enterprise derived by the partnership, each partner will be considered to have a permanent establishment, regardless of how much time that partner has physically spent at the site.
20. The very nature of a construction or installation project may be such as to require the contractor to constantly or at least from time to time change the location of its activities as the work progresses. This may be the case, for example, in the construction of roads or canals, dredging waterways or laying pipelines. By analogy, where parts of a large structure, such as an offshore platform, are assembled at different locations within the territory of a country and transported to another location within the same country for final assembly, that work is considered to form part of a single project. In such a case, the absence of a workforce at any particular location for [six] months is irrelevant. The activities carried on at each particular location form part of a single project, and that project should be regarded as a permanent establishment if the duration of the related work as a whole exceeds [six] months.
12. Prior to the 2017 update, the United Nations Convention contained the words “(for the same or a connected project)” in subparagraph (b). This wording was deleted because the limitation to a “project” was easily manipulated and created difficult questions of interpretation and fact-finding for tax authorities, which is particularly undesirable for developing countries as it imposes an administrative burden on them. Moreover, from a policy perspective, where a non-resident provides services in a country for more than 183 days, the non-resident’s involvement in the commercial life of that country clearly justifies taxation of the income from those services, regardless of whether the services are provided in connection with one project or several projects. The degree of involvement of the non-resident in the economy of the source State is the same, regardless of the number of projects. It is argued that it is easier for taxpayers to track the location of the activities of their employees and independent contractors on a project-by-project basis. Requiring enterprises, even large enterprises with numerous projects, to keep records of the countries in which their employees and independent contractors work does not appear to be excessively burdensome or unreasonable, particularly in view of technological progress.
However, countries concerned about the uncertainty associated with aggregating unrelated projects and the undesirable distinction that arises between an enterprise having, for example, one project lasting 95 days and another enterprise having two unrelated projects lasting 95 days each, one following the other, may add the words “(for the same or a connected project)” to subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3.
12.1 The Committee generally noted that the expansion of the scope of application of subparagraph 3(b) means that, in certain circumstances, the revised provision will apply instead of the new Article 12A in respect of fees for technical services.
13. If States wish to treat fishing vessels in their territorial waters as permanent establishments (see paragraph 6 above), they may add an appropriate provision to paragraph 3, which could, for example, apply only to catches exceeding a certain level or on the basis of some other criterion.
14. If a permanent establishment is deemed to exist under paragraph 3, only the profits attributable to the activities carried on through that permanent establishment are taxable in the source State.
15. The following extracts from the 2010 OECD Model Commentary are relevant to subparagraph (a) of paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the United Nations Model Convention, although particular account should be taken of the reference to an “assembly project” in the United Nations Model Convention, as opposed to the OECD Model Convention, and the six-month period in the United Nations Model Convention:
16. This paragraph expressly provides that a building site or a construction or installation project constitutes a permanent establishment only if it lasts more than twelve months. Any of these sites or projects that does not meet this condition does not, in itself, constitute a permanent establishment, even if it includes an installation, such as an office or workshop within the meaning of paragraph 2, connected with the construction activity. However, if such an office or workshop is used for a number of construction projects and the activities carried on there go beyond those mentioned in paragraph 4, it will constitute a permanent establishment if the other conditions of this Article are otherwise met, even if none of the projects is connected with a building site or a construction or installation project lasting more than twelve months. In this case, the position of the workshop or office will differ from that of those sites or projects, none of which will constitute a permanent establishment, and it is important to ensure that only the profits properly attributable to the functions performed by that office or workshop and the risks assumed are attributed to the permanent establishment. This may include profits attributable to the functions performed and risks assumed in relation to various building sites, but only to the extent that those functions and risks are properly attributable to the office.
17. The term “building site or construction or installation project” includes not only the construction of buildings but also the construction of roads, bridges and canals, major renovation (not limited to simple maintenance or cosmetic repairs) of buildings, roads, bridges or canals, the laying of pipelines, excavation work and dredging. Furthermore, the term “installation project” is not limited to installation in the context of construction; it also includes the installation of new equipment, such as complex machinery, in existing buildings or on open sites. Paragraph 3 also covers work relating to the design of a building site and the supervision of the construction of buildings. States wishing to amend the text of this paragraph to clearly reflect this last point may do so in their bilateral treaties.
Alternative text for countries wishing to exclude Article 14
15.1 Some countries hold the view that Article 14 should be deleted and the matters governed by it should be dealt with in Articles 5 and 7. Countries holding this view often proceed on the basis that, in their opinion, the concept of a “fixed base” in Article 14 admittedly suffers from uncertainty and that the taxing rights governed by Article 14 can be incorporated into the definition of “permanent establishment”. This approach is reflected in the Commentary on Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention as follows:
2. Until 2000, income from the provision of professional services or the carrying on of other activities of an independent character was governed by a separate Article, namely Article 14. The provisions of that Article were similar to those governing business profits, but the Article used the concept of a “fixed base” rather than that of a “permanent establishment”, since it was originally considered that the latter concept should be reserved for commercial and industrial activities. The deletion of Article 14 in 2000 reflected the fact that there should be no difference between the concept of permanent establishment used in Article 7 and the concept of fixed base used in Article 14, nor between the methods of calculating income and taxes set out in Articles 7 and 14. Thus, the deletion of Article 14 meant that everything previously regarded as a fixed base would henceforth fall within the definition of a permanent establishment.
15.2 Many countries disagree with this view and do not consider the arguments set out above sufficient to justify the deletion of Article 14. In addition, some countries consider that the concepts of “fixed base” (Article 14) and “permanent establishment” (Article 5) differ in meaning. Owing to these differences, deleting Article 14 and transferring its provisions to Articles 5 and 7 would, in practice, result, or at least could result, in a restriction of the source State’s taxing rights. In view of the disagreements on this issue, which cannot be overcome through the development of a single provision, the Committee decided to retain Article 14 in the United Nations Model Convention, while proposing in the Commentary on that Article alternative wording for countries wishing to delete Article 14.
15.3 This alternative differs from the approach provided for in the OECD Model Convention, in the preparation of which the conclusions of the OECD report on Article 14, published in 2000, were taken into account.24 That report proposed certain amendments to the Articles of the OECD Model Convention (and bilateral treaties), as well as corresponding amendments to the Commentary. Since most countries deleting Article 14 will do so for the reasons listed in that report and will probably follow the recommendations of the OECD Model Convention, the amended Articles proposed in that report, as they currently appear in the OECD Model Convention, are considered in the paragraphs below, which analyse the possible deletion of Article 14. The differences between that approach and the alternative wording set out below are due to the relevant differences between Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention and Article 14 as it previously appeared in the OECD Model Convention.
15.4 Since the deletion of Article 14 is presented merely as one option that some countries may decide to adopt, the entire discussion of the consequences of choosing this approach is dealt with in the Commentary on Article 5, including the question of the possibility — and, in most cases, the necessity — of making a number of amendments resulting from the deletion of Article 14, the mandatory removal of references to “independent personal services” and “fixed bases”, and the possible removal of references to “dependent personal services” in order to ensure greater clarity.
Amendments to Articles 14 and 5
15.5 It is proposed that Article 14 be deleted. It is proposed that subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3 of Article 5 be worded as follows:
(c) the furnishing of services, including consultancy services, by an enterprise through employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for that purpose, but only if activities of that nature continue within a Contracting State for a period or periods aggregating more than 183 days in any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned;
15.6 The differences between this version and the subparagraph appearing in the 1999 United Nations Model Convention are minor and include: (i) the deletion of the words “including consultancy services” after the words “the furnishing of services” on the grounds that the wording is unnecessary and merely creates confusion, since it is obvious that such services fall within the scope of this Article; (ii) the replacement of the six-month period with 183 days, as noted in paragraph 9 above; and (iii) the replacement of the full stop at the end of the subparagraph with a semicolon and the addition of subparagraph c. In 2017, the Committee deleted from subparagraph (b) the words in parentheses “(for the same or a connected project)”. Countries concerned about the uncertainty this may create may continue to include this wording.
15.7 It is also proposed that the following new subparagraph (c) be added to paragraph 3:
1 Issues Related to Article 14 of the OECD Model Tax Convention. Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, p. R (16)-1.
c) in the case of an individual, the furnishing of services in a Contracting State by that individual, but only if the period or periods of his or her presence in that State during any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned aggregate more than 183 days.
15.8 The purpose of subparagraph (c) is to extend the application of Articles 5 and 7 to all situations previously governed by Article 14. The wording reflects the fact that the deletion of Article 14 from the United Nations Model Convention will result in the disappearance of the “days of physical presence” test in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14 of that Model Convention, for which there was no equivalent in the OECD Model Convention at the time the decision was taken to delete Article 14 from that Convention.
15.9 It should be noted that subparagraph (c), which is intended to incorporate into Article 5 the provisions of the current subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14, makes it clearer that the scope of that subparagraph is limited to individuals. In this regard, the proposed text follows the interpretation set out in paragraph 9 of the Commentary on Article 14, which states that Article 14 applies only to individuals, and reflects this provision even more clearly. The Committee notes that some countries disagree with this view and that they should clarify this issue during negotiations on Article 14.
15.10 It should also be noted that Article 5 does not include the final part of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14: (“…in such a case, only such part of the income as is derived from his activities in that other State may be taxed in that other State”). The reason for this is that Article 7 provides its own rules for the attribution of profits, under which, in most cases, the State in which the permanent establishment is situated may tax the profits of the enterprise only to the extent that they are attributable to that permanent establishment (that is, to the physical presence referred to in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 3). In the relatively small number of cases where bilateral treaties provide for the “limited force of attraction” rule set out in Article 7, the State in which the permanent establishment operates may also tax other business activities of the same or a similar kind as those carried on through the physically present permanent establishment, which may be justified as ensuring uniform treatment of different forms of permanent establishment. Where States agree to apply the “limited force of attraction” rule set out in Article 7 and, at the same time, delete Article 14, but do not wish to apply the “limited force of attraction” rule to situations previously governed by subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14, they may expressly provide that such a rule does not apply to situations governed by subparagraph (c) of paragraph 3.
Consequential amendments to other Articles
15.11 In paragraph 1 of Article 3, the subparagraphs (c)–(f) should be renumbered as (d)–(g), and the following new subparagraphs (c) and (h) should be added:
(c) the term “enterprise” applies to the carrying on of any kind of business;
(h) the term “business” includes the performance of professional services and of other activities of an independent character.
15.12 The basis for these amendments is described in paragraphs 4 and 10.2 of the Commentary on Article 3 of the OECD Convention:
4. The question whether a particular activity is carried on within the framework of an enterprise or is regarded as a separate enterprise is always interpreted in accordance with the provisions of the domestic law of the Contracting States. Therefore, no attempt has been made in this Article to develop an exhaustive definition of the term “enterprise”. Nevertheless, it provides that the term “enterprise” applies to the carrying on of any kind of business. Since the definition of the term “business” clearly provides that this also includes the performance of professional services and of other activities of an independent character, this provision clarifies that the performance of professional services or the carrying on of other activities of an independent character must be regarded as constituting an enterprise, irrespective of how that term is understood under domestic law. States that consider such clarification unnecessary may, at their discretion, omit the definition of the term “enterprise” from their bilateral treaties.
10.2 The Convention does not contain an exhaustive definition of the term “business”, which, under paragraph 2, should generally correspond to the way in which it is understood under the domestic law of the State applying the Convention. However, subparagraph h) clearly provides that this term includes the performance of professional services and of other activities of an independent character. This provision was added in 2000 at the same time as the deletion from the Convention of Article 14, which governed independent personal services. The purpose of this addition, intended to ensure that the term “business” extends to activities previously governed by Article 14, was to prevent a restrictive interpretation of the term “business”, so that States whose domestic law does not permit the provision of such services or the carrying on of such activities to be regarded as business activities could not exclude the performance of professional services or the carrying on of other activities of an independent character from the concept of “business”. Contracting States where the situation is different may, at their discretion, agree bilaterally to omit this definition.
15.13 The text of paragraph 4 of Article 6 should be amended by removing the reference to independent personal services:
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 3 shall also apply to income from immovable property of an enterprise and to income from immovable property used for the performance of independent personal services.
15.14 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 4 of Article 10:
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the dividends, being a resident of one of the Contracting States, carries on business in the other Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs in that other State independent personal services from a fixed base situated therein, and the holding in respect of which the dividends are paid is effectively connected with such permanent establishment or fixed base. In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
15.15 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 5 of Article 10:
5. Where a company which is a resident of one of the Contracting States derives profits or income from the other Contracting State, that other State may not impose any tax on the dividends paid by the company, except insofar as such dividends are paid to a resident of that other State or insofar as the holding in respect of which the dividends are paid is effectively connected with a permanent establishment or a fixed base situated in that other State, nor subject the company’s undistributed profits to a tax on undistributed profits, even if the dividends paid or the undistributed profits consist wholly or partly of profits or income arising in that other State.
15.16 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 4 of Article 11:
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the interest, being a resident of one of the Contracting States, carries on business in the other Contracting State in which the interest arises through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs in that other State independent personal services from a fixed base situated therein, and the debt-claim in respect of which the interest is paid is effectively connected: a) with such permanent establishment or fixed base, or b) with the business referred to in subparagraph c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7. In such cases, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
15.17 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 5 of Article 11:
5. Interest shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State when the payer is a resident of that State. However, where the person paying the interest, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or a fixed base in connection with which the indebtedness on which the interest is paid was incurred, and such interest is borne by such permanent establishment or fixed base, then such interest shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
15.18 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 4 of Article 12:
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the royalties, being a resident of one of the Contracting States, carries on business in the other Contracting State in which the royalties arise through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs in that other State independent personal services from a fixed base situated therein, and the right or property in respect of which the royalties are paid is effectively connected: (a) with such permanent establishment or fixed base, or (b) with the business referred to in subparagraph c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7. In such cases, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
15.19 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 5 of Article 12:
5. Royalties shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State when the payer is a resident of that State. However, where the person paying the royalties, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or a fixed base in connection with which the obligation to pay the royalties was incurred, and such royalties are borne by such permanent establishment or fixed base, then such royalties shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
15.20 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 2 of Article 13:
2. Gains from the alienation of movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one of the Contracting States has in the other Contracting State, or of movable property pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident of one of the Contracting States in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing independent personal services, including such gains from the alienation of such permanent establishment (alone or with the whole enterprise) or of such fixed base, may be taxed in that other State.
15.21 Upon the deletion of Article 14, it will depend on agreement between the countries whether the Articles following it should be renumbered; however, in accordance with usual practice, those Articles are renumbered or some additional Article is designated as Article 14.
15.22 Countries may wish to replace the title of Article 15 with the following: “INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT”, as provided for in the OECD Model Convention as revised in 2000 and in subsequent versions of the OECD Model Conventions. This amendment is based on the fact that, if Article 14 is deleted, such deletion will ordinarily represent a deliberate decision to abandon the concepts of independent personal services and dependent personal services and to agree that Article 15 concerns only services performed by persons in employment, while any other types of services are dealt with in Article 7 or in special Articles, namely Article 16 or Article 17.
15.23 Subparagraph (c) of paragraph 2 of Article 15 should be amended by removing references to the concept of “fixed base”:
(c) the remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment or a fixed base which the employer has in the other State.
15.24 Article 17 should be amended as follows in order to remove references to the deleted Article 14 and add references to Article 7:
(a) paragraph 1 of Article 17 should be amended as follows:
1. Notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 14, 7 and 15, income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States as a professional entertainer, such as a theatre, motion picture, radio or television artiste, or a musician or sportsperson, from that resident’s personal activities as such exercised in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
(b) paragraph 2 of Article 17 should be amended as follows:
2. Where income in respect of personal activities exercised by a professional entertainer or sportsperson in that person’s capacity as such accrues not to the entertainer or sportsperson himself or herself but to another person, that income may, notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 7, 14 and 15, be taxed in the Contracting State in which the activities of the professional entertainer or sportsperson are exercised.
15.25 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 2 of Article 21:
2. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income, other than income from immovable property as defined in paragraph 2 of Article 6, if the recipient of such income, being a resident of one of the Contracting States, carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein, or performs in that other State independent personal services from a fixed base situated therein, and the right or property in respect of which the income is paid is effectively connected with such permanent establishment or fixed base. In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 or Article 14, as the case may be, shall apply.
15.26 The following amendments should be made to paragraph 2 of Article 22:
2. Capital represented by movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one of the Contracting States has in the other Contracting State, or by movable property pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident of one of the Contracting States in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing independent personal services, may be taxed in that other State.
Paragraph 4
16. In 2017, the Committee decided to include an amended paragraph 4 of Article 5 in the updated version of the United Nations Model Convention. The amendments were based on the recommendations of the OECD/G20 Final Report on Action 7 (Preventing the Artificial Avoidance of Permanent Establishment Status). Paragraph 4 was amended so that all activities covered by paragraph 4 are subject to the condition that they are preparatory or auxiliary in nature.
17. The new paragraph 4 of Article 5 of the United Nations Model Tax Convention still does not contain a reference to “delivery” in subparagraphs (a) and (b). The omission of the word “delivery” reflects the opinion of the majority of the Committee members that a “warehouse” used for this purpose should, provided that the requirements of paragraph 1 are met, constitute a permanent establishment.
17.1 In view of the similarity with the recommended text and the general relevance of the Commentary thereto, the general principles of paragraph 4 of Article 5 under both Conventions are first considered below, followed by a consideration of the practical significance of the omission of references to “delivery” in the United Nations Model Convention.
18. Following the amendments to the OECD Commentary reflecting the changes to paragraph 4 of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention, the 2017 OECD Model Commentary now reads as follows:
58. This paragraph lists certain activities which are treated as exceptions to the general definition set out in paragraph 1 and which are not permanent establishments, even if the activity is carried on through a fixed place of business. The final part of the paragraph provides that these exceptions apply only if the listed activities are of a preparatory or auxiliary character. Since subparagraph e) applies to any activity not listed in the paragraph (provided that such activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary character), the provisions of this paragraph effectively constitute a general limitation on the scope of the definition of permanent establishment contained in paragraph 1 and, when considered together with that paragraph, provide a more selective criterion for determining what constitutes a permanent establishment. To a considerable extent, these provisions restrict the definition contained in paragraph 1 and exclude from its rather broad scope a number of fixed places of business which, because the business activities carried on through them are merely preparatory or auxiliary in nature, should not be treated as permanent establishments. It is recognized that such a place of business may contribute to the productivity of the enterprise, but the services it provides are so remote from the actual earning of profits that it is difficult to attribute any profits to that fixed place of business. In addition, subparagraph f) provides that a combination of the activities mentioned in subparagraphs a)–e) at the same fixed place of business shall not be deemed to constitute a permanent establishment, provided that the overall activity of the fixed place of business resulting from such combination is of a preparatory or auxiliary character, as expressed in the final part of this paragraph. Thus, the provisions of paragraph 4 are intended to prevent the taxation of an enterprise of one State in another State where it carries on in that other State only activities of a purely preparatory or auxiliary character. The provisions of paragraph 4.1 (see below) supplement this principle by ensuring that the preparatory or auxiliary character of the activity carried on at a fixed place of business must be considered in the light of other activities that constitute complementary functions forming part of a cohesive business operation, which the same enterprise or closely related enterprises carry on in the same State.
59. It is often difficult to distinguish between activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character and those that are not. The decisive criterion is whether the activity of the fixed place of business itself constitutes an essential and significant part of the activities of the enterprise as a whole. Each individual case must be examined on its merits. In any event, a fixed place of business whose general purpose is identical to the general purpose of the enterprise as a whole does not carry on preparatory or auxiliary activities.
60. As a general rule, an activity of a preparatory character is one that is carried on in contemplation of the carrying on of what constitutes an essential and significant part of the activities of the enterprise as a whole. Since preparatory activities precede other activities, they are often carried on for a relatively short period, the duration of that period being determined by the nature of the main activity of the enterprise. However, this is not always the case, since activities may be carried on at a particular place for a considerable period of time in preparation for activities carried on elsewhere. For example, if a construction enterprise trains its employees at one location and then sends them to remote work sites situated in other countries, the training carried on at the first location constitutes a preparatory activity for that enterprise. On the other hand, an activity of an auxiliary character generally corresponds to an activity carried on to support, without being part of, the essential and significant part of the activities of the enterprise as a whole. It is unlikely that an activity requiring a substantial proportion of the assets or employees of the enterprise could be regarded as having an auxiliary character.
61. Subparagraphs a)–e) refer to activities carried on for the enterprise itself. Thus, a permanent establishment will exist if such activities are carried on on behalf of other enterprises at the same fixed place of business. If, for example, an enterprise maintaining an office for advertising its own products or services also engages in advertising on behalf of other enterprises at that location, that office will constitute a permanent establishment of the enterprise maintaining it.
62. Subparagraph a) refers to a fixed place of business consisting of facilities used by an enterprise for the storage, display or delivery of its own goods or merchandise. Whether the activity carried on at such a place of business is of a preparatory or auxiliary character must be determined in the light of factors that include the overall business activity of the enterprise. If, for example, an enterprise of State R maintains a very large warehouse in State S, employing a significant number of employees, primarily for the purpose of storing and delivering goods belonging to the enterprise which it sells online to customers in State S, paragraph 4 will not apply to that warehouse, since the storage and delivery activities carried on through that warehouse, which constitutes an important asset and requires a large number of employees, form an essential part of the enterprise’s sales/distribution business and are therefore not of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
63. Subparagraph a) covers, for example, a customs warehouse with special gas equipment which an exporter of fruit from one State maintains in another State for the sole purpose of storing fruit under controlled conditions during customs clearance in that other State. It also covers a fixed place of business maintained by an enterprise solely for the purpose of supplying spare parts to customers for machinery sold to those customers. However, paragraph 4 does not apply if the enterprise maintains a fixed place of business for supplying spare parts to customers for machinery supplied to those customers and, in addition, for servicing or repairing such machinery, since this goes beyond the mere supply referred to in subparagraph a) and is not of a preparatory or auxiliary character, as such after-sales activities constitute an essential and significant part of the enterprise’s services to its customers.
64. Questions may arise concerning the application of the definition of permanent establishment to facilities such as cables or pipelines that cross the territory of a country. Apart from the fact that income derived by the owner or operator of such facilities from their use by other enterprises falls within the scope of Article 6 where those facilities constitute immovable property within the meaning of paragraph 2 of Article 6, the question may arise whether subparagraph a) applies to them. If these facilities are used to transport property belonging to other enterprises, subparagraph a), which is limited to the delivery of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise using the facility, will not apply in respect of the owner or operator of those facilities. Subparagraph e) will also not apply in respect of that enterprise, since the cable or pipeline is not used exclusively for that enterprise and its use is not of a preparatory or auxiliary character in view of the nature of that enterprise’s activities. The situation is different, however, where an enterprise owns and operates a cable or pipeline crossing the territory of a country exclusively for the purpose of transporting its own property, and such transportation is merely incidental to the activities of that enterprise, as, for example, in the case of an oil-processing enterprise which owns and operates a pipeline crossing the territory of a country exclusively to transport its own oil to its refinery situated in another country. In that case, subparagraph a) applies. A separate question is whether a cable or pipeline may constitute a permanent establishment for a customer of the cable or pipeline operator, that is, an enterprise whose data, energy or property is transmitted or transported from one place to another. In that case, the enterprise merely receives transmission or transportation services provided by the operator of the cable or pipeline and does not have the cable or pipeline at its disposal. Consequently, the cable or pipeline cannot be regarded as a permanent establishment of that enterprise.
65. Subparagraph b) refers to the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise. This subparagraph is irrelevant where stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to an enterprise are stored by another person at facilities operated by that other person and the enterprise does not have such facilities at its disposal, since the place where the stocks are stored cannot constitute a permanent establishment of that enterprise. If, for example, a logistics company has a warehouse in State S and regularly stores at that warehouse goods or merchandise belonging to an enterprise of State R with which the logistics company is not closely related, the warehouse does not constitute a fixed place of business at the disposal of the enterprise of State R, and subparagraph b) is therefore irrelevant. If, however, that enterprise is granted unrestricted access to a separate part of the warehouse for the purpose of inspecting and maintaining the goods or merchandise stored there, subparagraph b) applies, and the question whether a permanent establishment exists will depend on whether that activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
66. For the purposes of applying subparagraphs a) and b), it is irrelevant whether the storage or delivery takes place before or after the sale of the goods or merchandise, provided that the goods or merchandise belong to the enterprise while they are at the relevant location (for example, the subparagraphs may apply even where some goods stored at a storage facility have already been sold, if ownership of those goods passes to the purchaser only upon or after delivery). Subparagraphs a) and b) also cover situations where a facility is used, or a stock of goods or merchandise is maintained, in any combination for storage, display and delivery purposes, since facilities used for the delivery of goods almost invariably also serve for the storage of those goods, at least for a short period of time. For the purposes of subparagraphs a)–d), the words “goods” and “merchandise” refer to tangible property and do not cover, for example, immovable property and data (although these subparagraphs apply to tangible products incorporating data, such as CDs and DVDs).
67. Subparagraph c) covers a situation where a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to one enterprise is processed by a second enterprise on behalf of or for the account of the first-mentioned enterprise. As explained in the preceding paragraph, the mere presence of goods or merchandise belonging to an enterprise does not mean that the fixed place of business where those goods or merchandise are stored is at the disposal of that enterprise. For example, if a stock of goods belonging to RCO, an enterprise of State R, is stored with a toll manufacturer located in State S for the purpose of being processed by that toll manufacturer, RCO does not have a fixed place of business at its disposal and the place where the stock is stored cannot therefore constitute a permanent establishment of RCO. However, if RCO is granted unrestricted access to a separate part of the toll manufacturer’s production facilities for the purpose of inspecting and maintaining the goods stored there, subparagraph c) will apply and it will be necessary to determine whether RCO’s maintenance of that stock of goods is of a preparatory or auxiliary character. This will be the case if RCO is merely a distributor of products manufactured by other enterprises, since, in that case, the mere maintenance of a stock of goods for the purpose of being processed by another enterprise will not constitute an essential and significant part of RCO’s overall activities. In such a case, unless paragraph 4.1 applies, paragraph 4 will deem that no permanent establishment exists in respect of such a fixed place of business at the disposal of the enterprise of State R for the purpose of storing its own goods to be processed by a toll manufacturer.
68. The first part of subparagraph d) refers to a case where facilities are used solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise for the enterprise. Since this exception applies only where that activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary character, it will generally not apply in the case of a fixed place of business used for purchasing goods or merchandise where the overall activity of the enterprise consists of selling those goods and the purchases are a principal function of the enterprise’s business. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 4 to fixed places of business where purchasing activities are carried on:
— Example 1: RCO is a company resident in State R and is a major purchaser of a particular agricultural product produced in State S, which RCO sells from State R to distributors located in various countries. RCO maintains a purchasing office in State S. The employees working in that office are experienced buyers with specialized knowledge of the product concerned, who visit producers in State S, determine the type/quality of the product in accordance with international standards (which is a complex process requiring special skills and knowledge), and conclude various types of contracts (spot or forward) for the purchase of that product by RCO. In this example, although the only activity carried on through the office is the purchasing of products for RCO, which falls within the scope of subparagraph d), paragraph 4 does not apply, and therefore the office constitutes a permanent establishment, since the purchasing function forms an essential and significant part of RCO’s overall activities.
— Example 2: RCO, a company resident in State R that operates a number of large discount stores, maintains an office in State S for two years for the purpose of studying the local market and lobbying the government for changes that would allow RCO to open stores in State S. During this period, RCO employees occasionally purchase office supplies. In this example, paragraph 4 applies because subparagraph f) applies to the activities carried on through the office (since subparagraphs d) and e) would apply to the purchasing, market research and lobbying activities if each of them were the only activity carried on at the office), and the overall activity of the office is of a preparatory character.
69. The second part of subparagraph d) refers to a fixed place of business used solely for collecting information for the enterprise. An enterprise often needs to collect information before deciding whether and how it will carry on its main business activities in a particular State. If an enterprise does so without having a fixed place of business in that State, subparagraph d) is obviously irrelevant. However, if a fixed place of business is maintained solely for this purpose, subparagraph d) will be relevant, and it will be necessary to determine whether the collection of information goes beyond the preparatory or auxiliary threshold. If, for example, an investment fund opens an office in a State solely to collect information about potential investment opportunities in that State, the collection of information through that office will constitute a preparatory activity. The same conclusion may be reached in the case of an insurance enterprise opening an office solely to collect information, such as statistical data, about risks in a particular market, and in the case of a newspaper bureau established in a State solely to collect information about possible news stories without carrying on any advertising activity: in both cases, the collection of information will constitute a preparatory activity.
70. Subparagraph e) applies to a fixed place of business used solely for carrying on, for the enterprise, any activity not expressly mentioned in subparagraphs a)–d); if that activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary character, such place of business shall not be deemed to constitute a permanent establishment. The wording of this subparagraph does not require an exhaustive list of the activities to which this paragraph may apply, and the examples listed in subparagraphs a)–d) are merely general examples of activities covered by this paragraph, since they are often of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
71. Examples of places of business falling within the scope of subparagraph (d) include fixed places of business used exclusively for advertising, the provision of information, the carrying out of scientific research, or the servicing of a patent or know-how, provided that such activities are of a preparatory or auxiliary character. However, paragraph 4 does not apply if the fixed place of business used for providing information not only provides information but also supplies plans, etc., specially developed for the purposes of an individual client. Nor does it apply if a research institution engages in manufacturing. Similarly, if the purpose of an enterprise is the servicing of patents and know-how, the fixed place of business of such an enterprise carrying out that activity cannot benefit from paragraph 4. A fixed place of business performing a management function for an enterprise, or even only for a part of an enterprise or a group of enterprises, cannot be regarded as carrying out preparatory or auxiliary activities, since such management activities go beyond that level. If an enterprise of international importance establishes in a State in which it has subsidiaries, permanent establishments, agents or licensees a so-called "management office", which performs supervisory and coordination functions in respect of all the enterprise's units located in the relevant region, subparagraph (e) will not apply to that "management office", since the management function of the enterprise, even if it covers only a specific area of the group's activities, constitutes a substantial part of the enterprise's business operations and therefore cannot in any way be regarded as an activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character within the meaning of paragraph 4.
72. Furthermore, if an enterprise selling goods throughout the world opens a representative office in a State and the employees working in that representative office actively participate in negotiating important parts of contracts for the sale of goods to customers in that State, without usually concluding contracts or playing the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts (for example, by participating in decisions concerning the type, quality or quantity of the products covered by those contracts), such activities generally constitute a substantial part of the enterprise's business operations and should not be regarded as being of a preparatory or auxiliary character within the meaning of subparagraph (e) of paragraph 4. Accordingly, subject to the conditions of paragraph 1 being met, such an office will constitute a permanent establishment.
73. As already mentioned in paragraph 58 above, the draft paragraph 4 provides for exceptions to the general definition in paragraph 1 in respect of fixed places of business engaged in activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character. Thus, under subparagraph f), the fact that any of the activities mentioned in subparagraphs a)–e) are combined at one fixed place of business does not, in itself, mean that a permanent establishment exists. As long as the overall activity of that fixed place of business is merely preparatory or auxiliary, a permanent establishment should not be deemed to exist. Such combinations should not be considered according to rigid rules, but should be examined in the light of the specific circumstances.
74. Unless the provisions of paragraph 4.1 on anti-fragmentation (see below) apply, subparagraph f) is irrelevant in a case where an enterprise has several fixed places of business to which subparagraphs a)–e) apply, since in such a case each place of business must be considered separately and in isolation for the purpose of determining whether a permanent establishment exists.
75. Fixed places of business to which paragraph 4 applies do not constitute permanent establishments as long as the business activity carried on through those fixed places of business is limited to the activities specified in that paragraph. This is so even if the contracts necessary for the establishment and operation of the business are concluded by the persons responsible for those places of business. The conclusion of such contracts by these employees will not constitute a permanent establishment of the enterprise under paragraph 5 if the conclusion of those contracts satisfies the conditions of paragraph 4 (see paragraph 33 below). An example would be a situation where the manager of a place of business at which preparatory or auxiliary research activities are carried out concludes the contracts necessary for the establishment and maintenance of that place of business within the framework of the activities carried on at that place.
76. If, pursuant to paragraph 4, a fixed place of business is considered not to constitute a permanent establishment, this exception also applies to the disposal of movable property forming part of the business property of the place of business upon the cessation of the enterprise's activities at that place (see paragraph 11 above and paragraph 2 of Article 13). If, for example, the display of goods during a fair or convention is excluded under subparagraphs a) and b), the sale of those goods at the end of the fair or convention is covered by subparagraph e), since such a sale is merely an auxiliary activity. The exception, of course, does not extend to the sale of goods that were not actually displayed at the fair or convention.
77. If paragraph 4 does not apply because the fixed place of business used by the enterprise for the activities provided for in paragraph 4 is also used for other activities that go beyond the preparatory or auxiliary character, that place of business constitutes a single permanent establishment of the enterprise, and the profits attributable to the permanent establishment in respect of both types of activities may be taxed in the State in which that permanent establishment is located.
19. The Committee noted that, in the opinion of some members, the scope of paragraph 4 is too broad and creates problems (see above paragraph 18, which quotes paragraph 21.1 of the OECD Commentary), which developing countries may find particularly difficult to address due to a lack of administrative capacity. Countries experiencing such concerns may consider deleting this paragraph entirely. Another option, which may also be considered by those wishing to limit the scope of this paragraph, is to exclude subparagraphs that may be considered too broad in scope, in particular subparagraphs e) and f) mentioned by members.
However, the parties negotiating an agreement should ensure that the application of the remaining paragraph is limited by the preparatory or auxiliary requirement, so that this paragraph excludes from the concept of a permanent establishment in paragraph 1 only work that has no significance, or very little significance, in the light of the other work carried out by the enterprise.
19.1 It was also noted that some States may consider that the activities specified in paragraph 4 are, by their very nature, of a preparatory or auxiliary character and hold the view that such activities should not be subject to the condition of being preparatory or auxiliary in character, since any concerns regarding the improper use of these exceptions are addressed by the provisions of paragraph 4.1. States sharing this view may make the following amendments to paragraph 4 (and may also agree to exclude some of the activities listed in subparagraphs a)–d) below if they consider that these activities should be subject to the preparatory or auxiliary condition in subparagraph e)):
4. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, the term "permanent establishment" shall be deemed not to include:
(a) The use of facilities solely for the purpose of storage or display of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
(b) The maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of storage or display;
(c) The maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of processing by another enterprise;
(d) The maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise, or of collecting information, for the enterprise;
(e) The maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of carrying on, for the enterprise, any other activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character; or
(f) The maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for any combination of activities mentioned in subparagraphs (a)–(e), provided that the overall activity of the fixed place of business resulting from such combination is of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
20. As noted above, the United Nations Model Convention, unlike the OECD Model Convention, contains no reference to "delivery" in either subparagraph (a) or subparagraph (b). The question of whether the use of facilities for the "delivery of goods" should be regarded as an activity giving rise to a permanent establishment was the subject of extensive discussions. A study conducted in 1997 indicated that almost 75 per cent of tax treaties concluded by developing countries contain the phrase "delivery of goods" in the list of exceptions in subparagraphs (a) and (b) of paragraph 4. Nevertheless, some countries consider the absence of this wording in the United Nations Model Convention to be an important point of departure from the OECD Model Convention, taking the view that the availability of stocks of goods for immediate delivery facilitates the sale of the product and, accordingly, the generation of profits in the host country.
21. During the revision of the United Nations Model Convention, the Committee decided to retain the existing difference between the two Model Conventions, noting, however, that even if the delivery of goods were regarded as an activity giving rise to a permanent establishment, only insignificant income could probably be properly attributed to such activity. A situation could arise in which the tax authorities, without examining the matter in sufficient depth, attributed excessive income to this activity, resulting in prolonged litigation and a non-uniform application of tax treaties. Therefore, despite the absence of the word "delivery" in the United Nations Model Convention, countries negotiating bilateral tax treaties may wish to consider both points of view in order to determine the practical consequences of adopting either approach.
Paragraph 4.1
21.1 In 2017, the Committee decided to adopt a new paragraph 4.1 in Article 5. The new paragraph 4.1 is an anti-fragmentation rule that was recommended for inclusion in the OECD Model Tax Convention in the OECD/G20 Final Report on Action 7 (Preventing the Artificial Avoidance of Permanent Establishment Status). The purpose of this new paragraph is to prevent the fragmentation of an enterprise's activities — both within the enterprise and between closely related enterprises — in order to qualify for the exceptions for specific activities provided for in paragraph 4 of Article 5. The Final Report also includes a new Commentary containing recommendations on the application of paragraph 4.1 in situations where an enterprise or a group of closely related enterprises attempt to circumvent the preparatory or auxiliary activity rule contained in paragraph 4 by fragmenting a cohesive business operation into several smaller operations. The 2017 OECD Commentary provides as follows:
79. […] Under paragraph 4.1, the exceptions provided for in paragraph 4 do not apply to a place of business that would otherwise constitute a permanent establishment if the activities carried on at that place and other activities of the same enterprise or closely related enterprises, carried on at that place or at another place in the same State, constitute complementary functions that are part of a cohesive business operation. However, for paragraph 4.1 to apply, at least one of the places where these activities are carried on must constitute a permanent establishment or, if this is not the case, the overall activity resulting from the combination of the relevant activities must go beyond a merely preparatory or auxiliary character.
80. The provisions of paragraph [9] apply for the purpose of determining whether an enterprise is a closely related enterprise in relation to another enterprise (see paragraphs 119–121 below).
81. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 4.1:
— Example A: RCO, a bank resident in State R, has several branches in State S that are permanent establishments. It also has a separate office in State S where several employees review information provided by customers who have submitted loan applications at these various branches. The results of the reviews conducted by these employees are sent to RCO's headquarters in State R, where other employees analyse the information contained in the loan applications and provide reports to the branches where decisions on granting loans are made. In this case, the exceptions in paragraph 4 will not apply to the office, because another place (i.e. any of the other branches where loan applications are submitted) constitutes a permanent establishment of RCO in State S, and the business activities carried on by RCO at the office and at the relevant branch constitute complementary functions that are part of a cohesive business operation (i.e. the provision of loans to customers in State S).
— Example B: RCO, a company resident in State R, manufactures and sells household appliances. SCO, a resident of State S and a wholly owned subsidiary of RCO, owns a shop where it sells household appliances purchased from RCO. RCO also owns a small warehouse in State S where several large items, identical to those displayed in the shop owned by SCO, are stored. When a customer purchases such a large item from SCO, SCO's employees go to the warehouse, where they take possession of the item before delivering it to the customer; ownership of the item passes from RCO to SCO only after the item leaves the warehouse. In this case, paragraph 4.1 prevents the application of the exceptions in paragraph 4 to the warehouse, and therefore there is no need to determine whether paragraph 4, and in particular subparagraph 4(a), applies to the warehouse. The conditions for the application of paragraph 4.1 are satisfied because:
— SCO and RCO are closely related enterprises;
— SCO's shop constitutes a permanent establishment of SCO (the definition of a permanent establishment is not limited to situations where a resident of one Contracting State uses or has a fixed place of business in another State; it also applies where an enterprise of one State uses or has a fixed place of business in that same State); and
— The business activities carried on by RCO at its warehouse and by SCO at its shop constitute complementary functions that are part of a cohesive business operation (i.e. the storage of goods at one place for the purpose of supplying those goods in fulfilment of obligations arising from the sale of those goods through another place in the same State).
Paragraph 5
22. In 2017, the Committee decided to amend paragraphs 5 and 7 of Article 5. The new paragraphs address the artificial avoidance of permanent establishment status through commissionaire arrangements and similar strategies. These amendments to the United Nations Model Convention and the corresponding Commentary are consistent with the recommendations for the OECD Model Convention contained in the OECD/G20 Final Report on Action 7 (Preventing the Artificial Avoidance of Permanent Establishment Status).
22.1 It is generally accepted that if a person acts in a State on behalf of an enterprise in such a way that the enterprise's activities are closely connected with the economic life of that State, the enterprise should be regarded as having a permanent establishment in that State — even if it does not have a fixed place of business in that State within the meaning of paragraph 1. Paragraph 5 achieves this by recognising that a permanent establishment exists if a person is a so-called dependent agent carrying out, on behalf of the enterprise, the activities specified in subparagraph (a) or (b).
22.2 Subparagraph (a) follows the substance of the OECD Model Convention and is based on the premise that if a person who habitually concludes contracts on behalf of an enterprise, relating to the transfer of ownership of, or the granting of the right to use, property belonging to the enterprise, or the provision of services by that enterprise, creates a sufficiently close connection between that enterprise and the State (or if that person habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of such contracts), it is appropriate to consider that the enterprise has a permanent establishment there. The condition in subparagraph (b), concerning the maintenance of a stock of goods, is discussed below.
23. With regard to subparagraph (a), an employee agent creates the conditions under which a "permanent establishment" is deemed to exist only if its authority is exercised repeatedly and not merely on isolated occasions. The 2017 Commentary on the OECD Model Convention provides as follows:
84. For paragraph 5 to apply, all of the following conditions must be met:
— the person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise;
— in doing so, that person habitually concludes contracts, or habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise; and
— these contracts are either concluded in the name of the enterprise, or relate to the transfer of ownership of, or the granting of the right to use, property owned by that enterprise or that the enterprise has the right to use, or to the provision of services by that enterprise.
85. However, even if these conditions are met, paragraph 5 will not apply if the activities carried on by the person on behalf of the enterprise fall within the independent agent exception provided for in paragraph 6, or are limited to the activities mentioned in paragraph 4 which, if carried on through a fixed place of business, would be considered not to give rise to a permanent establishment. This latter exception is explained by the fact that, since under paragraph 4 the maintenance of a fixed place of business exclusively for the purpose of carrying on preparatory or auxiliary activities is considered not to constitute a permanent establishment, a person whose activities are limited to such purposes should likewise not create a permanent establishment. For example, if a person acts exclusively as a purchasing agent for an enterprise and habitually concludes purchase and sale contracts on behalf of that enterprise, paragraph 5 will not apply, even if that person is not independent of the enterprise, provided that such activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary character (see paragraph 68 above).
86. A person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise if that person to some extent involves the enterprise in business activities in the relevant State. This occurs, for example, when an agent acts on behalf of a principal, when a partner acts on behalf of a partnership, when a director acts on behalf of a company, or when an employee acts on behalf of an employer. A person cannot be said to act on behalf of an enterprise if the enterprise is not directly or indirectly affected by the actions taken by that person. As indicated in paragraph 83, a person acting on behalf of an enterprise may be a company; in such a case, the actions of the employees and directors of that company are considered together for the purpose of determining whether, and to what extent, that company acts on behalf of the enterprise.
87. The expression "concludes contracts" refers to situations where, under the relevant law governing contracts, a contract is considered to have been concluded by a particular person. A contract may be concluded without any active negotiations concerning its terms; this is the case, for example, where the relevant law provides that a contract is concluded as a result of a person acting on behalf of an enterprise accepting a third party's offer to enter into a standard contract with that enterprise. Furthermore, under the relevant law, a contract may be concluded in a State even if that contract is signed outside that State; for example, where the conclusion of a contract results from the acceptance by a person acting on behalf of an enterprise of an offer to enter into a contract made by a third party, it is irrelevant that the contract is signed outside that State. Moreover, a person who negotiates all the elements and details of a contract in a State in such a way that they become binding on the enterprise may be considered to have concluded the contract in that State, even if that contract is signed by another person outside that State.
88. The phrase "or habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification" is intended to cover situations where the conclusion of a contract directly results from the actions that a person performs in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise, even if, under the relevant law, the contract is not concluded by that person in that State. Although the phrase "concludes contracts" represents a relatively well-established test based on contract law, it was considered necessary to supplement this test with one focused on the substantive activities carried on in a State, in order to address cases where the conclusion of contracts is clearly the direct result of those activities, even though the relevant rules of contract law provide that the contract is concluded outside that State. This phrase should be interpreted in the light of the object and purpose of paragraph 5, which is intended to cover cases where the activities carried on by a person in a State are aimed at the regular conclusion of contracts to be performed by a foreign enterprise, i.e. where that person acts as a commercial agent of the enterprise. Therefore, the principal role leading to the conclusion of a contract is generally associated with the actions of a person who has persuaded a third party to enter into a contract with the enterprise. The words "contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification" clarify that if such a principal role is performed in a State, the activities of that person will fall within the scope of paragraph 5 even if the contracts are not formally concluded in that State, for example, if the contracts are routinely reviewed and approved outside that State, provided that such review does not result in changes to the key aspects of those contracts.
89. The expression "habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification" therefore applies, for example, in cases where a person solicits and receives (but does not formally finalise) orders that are sent directly to a warehouse from which goods belonging to the enterprise are supplied, and where the enterprise routinely approves these transactions. However, it does not apply where a person merely advertises and promotes the enterprise's goods or services in such a way that this does not directly result in the conclusion of contracts. For example, if representatives of a pharmaceutical enterprise actively advertise medicines manufactured by that enterprise by contacting doctors who subsequently prescribe those medicines, such marketing activities do not directly result in contracts between the doctors and the enterprise; therefore, this paragraph does not apply, even if the sales of those medicines may increase significantly as a result of such marketing activities.
90. The following is another example illustrating the application of paragraph 5. RCO, a company incorporated in State R, distributes various goods and services throughout the world through its websites. SCO, a company resident in State S, is a subsidiary of RCO. SCO's employees send emails, make telephone calls or visit large organisations to persuade them to purchase RCO's products and services and are therefore responsible for major accounts in State S; SCO's employees, whose remuneration is partly based on the revenue received by RCO from the owners of these accounts, use their relationship-building skills to anticipate the needs of the account owners and persuade them to purchase the products and services offered by RCO. When an SCO employee persuades one of these account owners to purchase a specified quantity of goods or services, the employee quotes the price to be paid for that quantity, explains that a contract with RCO must be concluded online before the goods or services are supplied by RCO, and explains the standard terms and conditions of RCO's contracts, including the fixed pricing structure used by RCO, which the employee is not authorised to change. Subsequently, the account owner concludes the contract online for the quantity discussed with the employee and in accordance with the pricing structure presented by that employee. In this example, SCO's employees play the principal role leading to the conclusion of the contract between the account owner and RCO, and such contracts are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise. The fact that SCO's employees cannot change the terms of the contracts does not mean that the conclusion of the contracts is not the direct result of the activities they carry on on behalf of the enterprise by persuading the account owner to accept those standard terms and conditions, which is the decisive element leading to the conclusion of contracts between the account owner and RCO.
91. The wording of subparagraphs a), b) and c) ensures that paragraph 5 applies not only to contracts that create legally enforceable rights and obligations between the enterprise on whose behalf the person acts and the third parties with whom those contracts are concluded, but also to contracts that create obligations that will in fact be performed by that enterprise rather than by the person who is contractually bound.
92. A typical case covered by these subparagraphs is the conclusion of contracts with customers by an agent, partner or employee of an enterprise for the purpose of creating legally enforceable rights and obligations between the enterprise and those customers. These subparagraphs also cover cases where contracts concluded by a person acting on behalf of an enterprise do not legally bind that enterprise vis-à-vis the third parties with whom those contracts are concluded, but instead relate to the transfer of ownership of, or the granting of the right to use, property owned by that enterprise or that the enterprise has the right to use, or to the provision of services by that enterprise. A typical example may be contracts that a "commissionaire" concludes with third parties under a commissionaire arrangement with a foreign enterprise, pursuant to which the commissionaire acts on behalf of the enterprise but concludes contracts in its own name, which do not create legally enforceable rights and obligations between the foreign enterprise and the third parties, even though the result of the arrangement between the commissionaire and the foreign enterprise will be that the foreign enterprise directly transfers to those third parties the right to possess or use property that it owns or has the right to use.
93. The reference to contracts "in the name of" in subparagraph a) does not limit the application of that subparagraph to contracts literally concluded in the name of the enterprise; it may apply, for example, in certain situations where the name of the enterprise is not disclosed in the written contract.
94. The decisive condition for the application of subparagraphs b) and c) is that the person who habitually concludes contracts or habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise acts on behalf of the enterprise in such a way that the parts of the contracts relating to the transfer of possession or the right to use property, or the provision of services, will be performed by the enterprise, as opposed to the person acting on behalf of the enterprise.
95. For the purposes of subparagraph b), it is irrelevant whether the relevant property existed or was owned by the enterprise at the time the contracts were concluded between the person acting on behalf of the enterprise and the third parties. For example, a person acting on behalf of an enterprise may well sell property that the enterprise will subsequently manufacture before supplying it directly to customers. Furthermore, the reference to "property" covers any type of tangible or intangible property.
96. Cases to which paragraph 5 applies should be distinguished from situations where a person concludes contracts in its own name and, in order to fulfil the obligations arising from those contracts, purchases goods or services from other enterprises or arranges for such goods or services to be supplied by other enterprises. In these cases, the person does not act "on behalf of" those other enterprises, and the contracts it concludes are neither concluded in the name of those enterprises nor for the transfer to third parties of the right to possess or use property owned by, or which those enterprises have the right to use, nor for the provision of services by those other enterprises. If, for example, a company acts as a distributor of products in a particular market and sells to customers products that it purchases from an enterprise (including an associated enterprise), it does not act on behalf of that enterprise and does not sell property belonging to that enterprise, since the property sold to customers belongs to the distributor. This would be the case if the distributor acted as a so-called "low-risk distributor" (rather than, for example, as an agent), but only if ownership of the property sold by that low-risk distributor passed from the enterprise to the distributor and from the distributor to the customer (regardless of how long the distributor held title to the products sold), so that the distributor earned a profit from the sale rather than remuneration in the form of, for example, a commission.
97. The contracts referred to in paragraph 5 cover contracts relating to transactions that constitute the actual business activities of the enterprise. It is irrelevant, for example, if a person is authorised to conclude employment contracts for the enterprise for the purpose of facilitating that person's activities for the enterprise, or if that person concludes similar contracts on behalf of the enterprise relating only to internal activities. Furthermore, the question of whether a person habitually concludes contracts or habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification must be determined on the basis of the commercial realities of the situation. The mere fact that a person is present at, or even participates in, negotiations in a State between an enterprise and a customer will not be sufficient to conclude that this person concluded contracts or played the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification. However, the fact that a person was present at or even participated in such negotiations may be a relevant factor in determining the specific functions performed by that person on behalf of the enterprise.
98. The requirement that an agent must "habitually" conclude contracts or play the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification reflects the underlying principle of Article 5, according to which the presence maintained by an enterprise in a Contracting State must be more than merely temporary if the enterprise is to be regarded as having a permanent establishment and, consequently, a taxable presence in that State. The extent and frequency of activity required to conclude that an agent "habitually concludes contracts or plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded by the enterprise without material modification" will depend on the nature of the contracts and the business of the principal. It is not possible to establish a precise frequency threshold. Nevertheless, the same factors as those considered in paragraph 6 will be relevant when making such a determination.
24. The Committee discussed the meaning of the reference to contracts "that are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise". The Committee noted that even if the enterprise makes material modifications to some contracts (and even to most contracts resulting from the activities of local sales agents) before approving them, as long as there is a person who habitually plays the principal role in concluding other contracts that the enterprise concludes without any material modifications, a dependent agent permanent establishment will nevertheless arise as a result of that person's activities. Some members of the Committee nevertheless preferred to omit this phrase, as they advocated a broader formulation. They also considered that its inclusion would encourage enterprises to argue that the condition is not met and to artificially avoid the creation of a permanent establishment. Countries sharing this concern are free to omit the words "that are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise".
25. In view of the addition of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 5, concerning the maintenance of a stock of goods, this paragraph has a broader scope than paragraph 5 of the OECD Model Convention. Some countries consider that the narrower wording could encourage an agent who is in fact a dependent person to present itself as acting in its own name.
26. In the view of the former Group of Experts, subparagraph (b) of paragraph 5 should be interpreted as follows: if all sales activities are carried out outside the host State and only delivery is carried out in that State by an agent, such a situation cannot result in the creation of a permanent establishment.²⁵ However, the former Group of Experts noted that if sales activities (for example, advertising or promotion of the product) are also carried out in that State on behalf of a resident (whether by the enterprise itself or by its employees acting as agents, or otherwise) and contribute to the sale of such products and goods, a permanent establishment may exist.²⁶
²⁵ See paragraph 25 of the Commentary on Article 5 of the United Nations Model Convention, 1999 version.
²⁶ Ibid.
Paragraph 6
27. This paragraph does not correspond to any provision of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention and is included to cover certain aspects of the insurance business. Nevertheless, the OECD Model Convention refers to the possibility of including such a provision in bilateral tax treaties, as follows:
39. Under the definition of the term "permanent establishment", an insurance company of one State may be taxed in another State in connection with its carrying on of insurance business if it has a fixed place of business within the meaning of paragraph 1 or if it carries on business through a person within the meaning of paragraph 5. Since agencies of foreign insurance companies sometimes do not satisfy either of the above requirements, it is quite possible for these companies to conduct large-scale business in a State while the profits derived by them from such business are not taxed in that State. In order to eliminate this possibility, various conventions concluded by OECD member countries include a provision which provides that insurance companies of a State are deemed to have a permanent establishment in another State if they collect insurance premiums in that other State through an agent situated there — other than an agent who already constitutes a permanent establishment under paragraph 5 — or insure risks situated in the territory of that State through such an agent. The decision as to whether to include a provision of this nature in a convention will depend on the factual and legal situation prevailing in the respective Contracting States. Accordingly, the question of including such a provision will often not be considered. For this reason, it was considered inappropriate to include a provision of this nature in the Model Convention.
28. Paragraph 6 of the United Nations Model Convention, which sets out the provisions quoted above, is necessary because insurance agents usually do not have authority to conclude contracts and would therefore not satisfy the conditions of subparagraph a) of paragraph 5. However, if an insurance agent has independent status, the profits of the insurance company attributable to its activities are not subject to tax in the State where those profits were earned, since the conditions of paragraph 7 of Article 5 would be satisfied and the enterprise would not be considered to have a permanent establishment.
29. Some countries, however, prefer to extend the scope of this provision so that this activity may be taxed even in cases where representation is carried out through such an independent agent. They advocate this approach because of the nature of the insurance business, the fact that the risks arise in the country seeking to exercise tax jurisdiction, and the ease with which persons could represent insurance companies on a part-time basis under "independent status", making it difficult to distinguish between employed insurance agents and independent insurance agents. Other countries see no reason why the insurance business should be treated differently from activities such as the sale of tangible goods. They also point to the difficulty of determining the total amount of turnover where insurance is carried out through several independent agents in the same country. In view of these differences in approach, the question of how the activities of independent agents should be regulated is left to the discretion of the parties in bilateral negotiations, during which consideration may be given to the methods used to sell insurance policies and other characteristics of the insurance business in the countries concerned.
Paragraph 7
30. The first sentence of this paragraph reproduces paragraph 6 of Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention with minor editorial changes. The relevant extracts from the 2017 Commentary on the OECD Model Convention are set out below:
102. Where an enterprise of a Contracting State carries on business through an independent agent carrying on business as such, it may not be taxed in the other Contracting State in respect of those transactions if the agent acts in the ordinary course of its business [...]. The activities of such an agent, which constitutes a separate and independent enterprise, should not give rise to a permanent establishment of the foreign enterprise.
103. The exception provided for in paragraph 6 applies only where a person acts on behalf of an enterprise in the course of carrying on business as an independent agent. It therefore does not apply where a person acts on behalf of an enterprise in another capacity, for example, where an employee acts on behalf of their employer or a partner acts on behalf of a partnership. As explained in paragraph 8.1 of the Commentary on Article 15, it is sometimes difficult to determine whether the services provided by an individual constitute employment services or services provided by a separate enterprise, and for this purpose the guidance contained in paragraphs 8.2–8.28 of the Commentary on Article 15 will be relevant. However, if an individual acts on behalf of an enterprise in the course of carrying on their own business, rather than as an employee, the application of paragraph 6 will still require that the individual act as an independent agent; as explained in paragraph 111 below, such independent status is less likely where the activities of that individual are carried on exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of one enterprise or enterprises closely related to it.
104. Whether a person acting as an agent is independent of the enterprise represented depends on the extent of the obligations that the person has towards the enterprise. If the person's business activities on behalf of the enterprise are carried on in accordance with detailed instructions or under comprehensive control by the enterprise, that person cannot be considered independent of the enterprise. Another important criterion will be whether the person or the enterprise represented bears the entrepreneurial risk. In any event, the last sentence of paragraph 6 provides that, in certain circumstances, a person should not be considered an independent agent (see paragraphs 119–121 below). In determining whether an agent to whom the last sentence does not apply may be considered independent, the following considerations should be taken into account.
105. It should be noted that where the last sentence of paragraph 6 does not apply because a subsidiary does not act exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of closely related enterprises, the control exercised by the parent company over its subsidiary in its capacity as a shareholder is irrelevant when considering whether the subsidiary is dependent or independent as an agent of the parent company. This is consistent with the rule contained in paragraph 7 of Article 5 (see also paragraph 113 below).
106. An independent agent is generally responsible to its principal for the results of its work, but is not subject to substantial control over how that work is performed. It should not receive detailed instructions from the principal regarding the performance of the work. The fact that the principal relies on the agent's special skills and knowledge is an indication of independence.
107. Restrictions on the scale of business that an agent may conduct undoubtedly affect the scope of the agent's authority. However, such restrictions are irrelevant to dependence, which is determined by examining the degree of freedom that the agent exercises in conducting business on behalf of the principal within the scope of the authority granted by the agreement.
108. One feature of the operation of an agreement may be that the agent provides the principal with substantial information in connection with the business carried on under the agreement. This, in itself, is not a sufficient criterion for determining that the agent is dependent, unless the information is provided in the course of obtaining the principal's approval for the manner in which the business is conducted. The provision of information intended merely to ensure the smooth performance of the agreement and the maintenance of good relations with the principal is not an indication of dependence.
109. Another factor to be taken into account when determining independent status is the number of principals represented by the agent. As indicated in paragraph 111, independent status is less likely if the agent's activities are carried on wholly or almost wholly on behalf of only one enterprise throughout the entire existence of the business or over a long period of time. However, this fact alone is not determinative. All the facts and circumstances must be taken into account in order to determine whether the agent's activities constitute an independent business in which the agent bears the risk and receives remuneration through the use of its entrepreneurial skills and knowledge. If an agent acts on behalf of several principals in the ordinary course of business and none of them predominates in terms of the business carried on by the agent, dependence may exist if the principals act in concert in controlling the agent's activities in the course of its business on their behalf.
110. An independent agent cannot be said to act in the ordinary course of its business as an agent if it carries on activities unrelated to that agency business. If, for example, a company acting on its own account as a distributor for a number of companies also acts as an agent for another enterprise, the activities carried on by that company as a distributor will not be considered part of the activities carried on by the company in the ordinary course of its business as an agent for the purposes of applying paragraph 6). However, activities forming part of the ordinary business carried on by an enterprise as an agent will include intermediary activities which, in accordance with normal practice in a particular business sector, are sometimes carried on as an agent and sometimes on the enterprise's own account, provided that such intermediary activities are essentially indistinguishable from one another. If, for example, a broker-dealer in the financial sector carries out various types of intermediary activities in the market in the same manner, but, depending on the needs of clients, does so sometimes as an agent of another enterprise and sometimes on its own account, the broker-dealer will be considered to be acting in the ordinary course of its business as an agent when carrying out these various types of intermediary activities in the market.
111. The last sentence of paragraph 6 provides that a person shall not be considered an independent agent if that person acts exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of one or more enterprises with which it is closely related. However, this last sentence does not mean that paragraph 6 will automatically apply whenever a person acts on behalf of one or more enterprises with which that person is not closely related.
The last sentence, however, does not mean that paragraph 6 will automatically apply if a person acts on behalf of one or more enterprises with which that person is not closely related. Paragraph 6 requires that the person carry on business as an independent agent and act in the ordinary course of that business. Independent status is less likely if the person's activities are carried on wholly or almost wholly on behalf of only one enterprise (or a group of closely related enterprises) throughout the entire existence of that person's business or over a long period of time. However, if a person acts exclusively on behalf of one enterprise with which that person is not closely related for a short period of time (for example, at the beginning of that person's business activity), paragraph 6 may apply. As indicated in paragraph 109 above, all the facts and circumstances must be taken into account in determining whether the activities of that person constitute the carrying on of business as an independent agent.
112. The last sentence of paragraph 6 applies only where a person acts "exclusively or almost exclusively" on behalf of closely related enterprises, as defined in paragraph [9]. This means that if the person's activities on behalf of enterprises with which it is not closely related do not constitute a significant part of its business, that person will not qualify as an independent agent. If, for example, the sales that an agent concludes for enterprises with which it is not closely related account for less than 10 per cent of all sales that it concludes as an agent acting on behalf of other enterprises, that agent should be regarded as acting "exclusively or almost exclusively" on behalf of closely related enterprises.
113. The rule contained in the last sentence of paragraph 6, and the fact that the definition of "closely related" in paragraph 8 covers situations where one company controls or is controlled by another company, in no way restrict the scope of paragraph 8 of Article 5. As explained in paragraph 117 below, there is a likelihood that a subsidiary will act on behalf of its parent company in such a way that the parent company will be considered to have a permanent establishment under paragraph 5; in such a case, a subsidiary acting exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of its parent company will not be able to benefit from the "independent agent" exception provided for in paragraph 6.
However, this does not mean that the relationship between a parent company and a subsidiary dispenses with the requirements of paragraph 5 or that such a relationship, in itself, may be sufficient to conclude that any of those requirements are met.
31. In the 1999 revised Model Convention, the wording was amended to clarify that the essential criterion for recognising that an agent does not have "independent status" is the absence of an arm's length relationship.
- In the 2017 update, the Committee decided that the absence of arm’s length relations should not be a decisive factor in determining that an agent does not qualify as an agent of independent status, and deleted this requirement from the independent agent rule. In making this decision, it was noted that the removal of the arm’s length condition was made because, prior to the 2017 update, it was easier to qualify as an “independent agent” under the United Nations Model Convention than under the OECD Model Convention.
Paragraph 8
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 7 of Article 5 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention. The OECD Commentary on the text reads as follows:
- It is generally accepted that the existence of a subsidiary company does not, of itself, constitute that subsidiary company a permanent establishment of its parent company. This follows from the principle that, for tax purposes, such a subsidiary company constitutes an independent legal entity. Even the fact that the trade or business carried on by the subsidiary company is managed by the parent company does not make the subsidiary company a permanent establishment of the parent company.
- However, a parent company may be found, under the rules of paragraphs 1 or 5 of this Article, to have a permanent establishment in a State in which the subsidiary company has a place of business. Thus, any premises belonging to the subsidiary company which are at the disposal of the parent company [...] and which constitute a fixed place of business through which the parent company carries on its own business will constitute a permanent establishment of the parent company under paragraph 1, subject to paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Article (see, for example, the example in paragraph 15 above). Moreover, under paragraph 5, the parent company will be deemed to have a permanent establishment in a State in respect of any activities that its subsidiary company undertakes for it, if the conditions of that paragraph are met (see paragraphs 82–99 above), unless such activities are limited to those mentioned in paragraph 4 of the Article or paragraph 6 of the Article applies.
- The same principles apply to any company belonging to a multinational group, so that such a company may be found to have a permanent establishment in a State if it has at its disposal [...] and uses premises belonging to another company of the group, or if the first company is deemed to have a permanent establishment under paragraph 5 of this Article [...]. However, the determination of whether a permanent establishment exists under the rules of paragraphs 1 or 5 of this Article must be made separately for each company of the group. Thus, the existence in a State of a permanent establishment of one company of the group will have no relevance to whether another company of the group has a permanent establishment in that State.
- The Committee notes that determining the existence or absence of a permanent establishment on the basis of a separate entity may give rise to vulnerability to abuse. Depending on the domestic legislation of States, safeguards against purely artificial arrangements may be found through the application of the rule that substance prevails over form. The 2017 OECD Model Convention Commentary also states the following:
- Whilst premises belonging to one company of a multinational group may be placed at the disposal of another company of the group and may, subject to the other conditions of Article 5, constitute a permanent establishment of that other company if the business of that other company is carried on through that place, it is important to distinguish this case from the frequent situation where one company belonging to a multinational group provides services (e.g., management services) to another company of the group as part of its own business carried on in premises that are not those of that other company and using its own personnel. In that case, the place where these services are provided is not at the disposal of the second company and the business carried on through that place is not that of that company. Therefore, that place cannot be considered to constitute a permanent establishment of the company to which the services are provided. Indeed, the fact that the activities of one company at a particular location may bring economic benefits to another company in its business does not mean that the latter company carries on its business through that location: it is clear that a company that simply purchases products or services produced or supplied by another company in another country will not, by reason of that fact alone, have a permanent establishment, even though it may benefit from the production of those products or the provision of those services.
Paragraph 9
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 8 of Article 5 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention; the relevant extracts from the OECD Commentary on the text are set out below:
- Paragraph [9] clarifies the meaning of the term “a person closely related to an enterprise” for the purposes of this Article and, in particular, paragraphs 4.1 and 6. This concept should be distinguished from the concept of “associated enterprises”, which is used for the purposes of Article 9; although these two concepts overlap to some extent, they are not considered equivalent.
- The first part of paragraph [9] includes a general definition of “a person closely related to an enterprise”. It provides that a person is closely related to an enterprise if, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, one controls the other or both are controlled by the same persons or enterprises. This general rule covers, for example, situations where a person or enterprise controls an enterprise by virtue of a special arrangement that allows that person to exercise rights similar to those it would have if it directly or indirectly owned more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in the enterprise. As is the case in most instances where the plural form is used, the reference to “the same persons or enterprises” at the end of the first sentence of paragraph [9] covers cases where there is only one such person or enterprise.
- The second part of paragraph [9] provides that the definition of “a person closely related to an enterprise” is automatically satisfied in certain circumstances. Under this second part, a person is considered closely related to an enterprise if one directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in the other, or if a third person directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in both that person and the enterprise. In the case of a company, this condition is met if a person directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares of the company or of the beneficial equity interests in the company.
Electronic Commerce
- The 2017 OECD Model Convention Commentary includes the following section devoted to “electronic commerce”:
Electronic Commerce
- The question has been discussed whether the mere use of computer equipment in a particular country in electronic commerce could constitute a permanent establishment. This question raises a number of issues in connection with the provisions of the Article.
- Whilst the place where an enterprise operates automated equipment may constitute a permanent establishment in the country where it is located (see below), a distinction needs to be made between computer equipment which may be set up at a location so as to constitute a permanent establishment under certain circumstances, and the data and software which is used by, or stored on, that equipment. For instance, an Internet website, which is a combination of software and electronic data, does not in itself constitute tangible property. It therefore does not have a location that can constitute a “place of business” as there is no “facility such as premises or, in certain instances, machinery or equipment” (see paragraph 6 above) as far as the software and data constituting that website are concerned. On the other hand, the server on which the website is stored and through which it is accessible is a piece of equipment having a physical location and such location may thus constitute a “fixed place of business” of the enterprise that operates that server.
- The distinction between a website and the server on which the website is stored and used is important since the enterprise that operates the server may be different from the enterprise that carries on business through the website. For example, it is common for the website through which an enterprise carries on its business to be hosted on the server of an Internet Service Provider (ISP). Although the fees paid to the ISP under such arrangements may be based on the amount of disk space used to store the software and data required by the website, these contracts typically do not result in the server and its location being at the disposal of the enterprise (see paragraphs 10–19 above), even if the enterprise has been able to determine that its website should be hosted on a particular server at a particular location. In such a case, the enterprise does not even have a physical presence at that location since the website is not tangible. In these cases, the enterprise cannot be considered to have acquired a place of business by virtue of that hosting arrangement. However, if the enterprise carrying on business through a website has a server at its own disposal, for example, it owns (or leases) and operates the server on which the website is stored and used, the place where that server is located may constitute a permanent establishment of the enterprise if the other requirements of this Article are met.
- Computer equipment at a given location may constitute a permanent establishment only if it meets the requirement of being fixed. In the case of a server, what matters is not the possibility that the server could be moved, but whether it has in fact been moved. For a server to constitute a fixed place of business, it must be located at a given place for a sufficient period of time to become fixed within the meaning of paragraph 1.
- Another question is whether an enterprise may be considered to be carrying on its business wholly or partly at the location where it has such equipment as a server at its disposal. The question of whether the business of the enterprise is carried on wholly or partly through such equipment needs to be decided on a case-by-case basis, having regard to whether, in connection with the presence of such equipment, the enterprise may be considered to have at its disposal facilities used to perform the business functions of the enterprise.
- Where an enterprise operates computer equipment at a particular location, a permanent establishment may exist even though no personnel of that enterprise are required at that location for the operation of the equipment. The presence of personnel is not necessary to consider that an enterprise wholly or partly carries on its business at a location if no personnel are in fact required to carry on business activities at that location. This conclusion applies to electronic commerce in the same way as it applies to other activities in which equipment operates automatically, e.g., automatic pumping equipment used in the exploitation of natural resources.
- Another question relates to the fact that a permanent establishment cannot be considered to exist where the electronic commerce operations carried on through computer equipment at a particular location in a country are restricted to activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character covered by paragraph 4. The question of whether particular activities performed at such a location fall within paragraph 4 needs to be examined on a case-by-case basis, having regard to the various functions performed by the enterprise through that equipment. The following are examples of activities that would generally be regarded as preparatory or auxiliary:
— providing a communications link — much like a telephone line — between suppliers and customers;
— advertising goods or services;
— relaying information through a mirror server for security and efficiency purposes;
— gathering market data for the enterprise;
— supplying information.
- However, where such functions form in themselves an essential and significant part of the business activity of the enterprise as a whole, or where other core functions of the enterprise are carried on through the computer equipment, they would go beyond the activities covered by paragraph 4 and, provided that the equipment constitutes a fixed place of business of the enterprise (as discussed in paragraphs 123–127 above), would constitute a permanent establishment.
- It is clear that the core functions of a particular enterprise depend on the nature of the business carried on by that enterprise. For instance, some ISPs operate their own servers for the purpose of hosting websites or other applications for other enterprises. For these ISPs, the operation of their servers for the purpose of providing services to customers is an essential part of their commercial activity and cannot be considered preparatory or auxiliary. Another example is that of an enterprise (sometimes referred to as an “electronic retail outlet”) which carries on the business of selling products through the Internet. In this case, the enterprise is not in the business of operating servers and the mere fact that it may carry on its business at a particular location does not provide sufficient grounds for concluding that the activities carried on at that location go beyond the preparatory or auxiliary activities. In such cases, it is necessary to examine the nature of the activities performed at that location in relation to the business carried on by the enterprise. If these activities are merely preparatory or auxiliary to the business of selling products through the Internet (for example, the location is used for operating a server on which the website is hosted, which is used, as is often the case, exclusively for advertising, displaying a catalogue of products or providing information to potential customers), paragraph 4 will apply and that location will not constitute a permanent establishment. If, however, typical functions related to sales are performed at that location (for example, the conclusion of contracts with customers, the processing of payments and the delivery of products are carried out automatically through equipment located there), these activities cannot be regarded as merely preparatory or auxiliary.
- The final question is whether an ISP may be considered to constitute a permanent establishment under paragraph 5. As already noted, ISPs typically provide services consisting of hosting the websites of other enterprises on their own servers. The question may then arise whether, under the provisions of paragraph 5, such ISPs may constitute permanent establishments of enterprises carrying on electronic commerce through websites hosted on servers owned and operated by those ISPs. Although this could occur in very unusual circumstances, paragraph 5 will generally not apply because ISPs will not act as agents of the enterprises to which the websites belong, since they will not have the authority to conclude contracts on behalf of those enterprises and will not regularly conclude such contracts, or because they will act as independent agents acting in the ordinary course of their business, as evidenced by the fact that they host websites for a large number of different enterprises. It is also clear that since a website through which an enterprise carries on its business is not itself a “person” as defined in Article 3, the provisions of paragraph 5 cannot be applied so as to deem a permanent establishment to exist on the basis that the website itself is the enterprise’s agent for the purposes of that paragraph.
- The Committee of Experts notes that paragraph 124 of the OECD Commentary distinguishes between a contract with an Internet service provider and a place of business at the disposal of an enterprise. In this regard, the Committee recognizes that certain business enterprises could attempt to avoid creating a permanent establishment by regulating the terms of the contract in circumstances where the existing facts and circumstances would justify a conclusion that a permanent establishment exists. Such abuses may fall within the scope of statutory or judicial rules on tax avoidance.
Commentary on Chapter III TAXATION OF INCOME
Article 6
INCOME FROM IMMOVABLE PROPERTY
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Article 6 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 6 of the OECD Model Convention, with the exception of the phrase “also to income from immovable property of industrial, commercial and other enterprises and to income from immovable property used for the performance of independent personal services”, which appears at the end of paragraph 4 of the United Nations Model Convention. This phrase was included in the United Nations Model Convention as a result of retaining Article 14, which covers independent personal services.
- The taxation of income from immovable [real] property should be based on profits rather than gross income; accordingly, expenses incurred in deriving income from immovable [real] property, agriculture or forestry should be taken into account. However, this objective should not prevent the use of a withholding tax on income from immovable [real] property based on gross income; in such cases, the rate should take account of the expenses incurred. On the other hand, in the case of a withholding tax on gross income from immovable property, it will be sufficient if the owner of the immovable [real] property may elect to have the income from the property taxed on a net basis under the ordinary income tax.
Article 6 is not intended to prevent a country that taxes income from agricultural or other immovable property on an assessed or similar basis from continuing to use that method.
- It was noted that, in the opinion of some members of the former Group of Experts, the distribution of dividends by a company, as referred to in paragraph 4 of Article 13, should be considered income from immovable property and thus fall within the scope of Article 6. However, the majority of the members of the Group did not share this view.
- It has been noted that in some countries a person may derive income (usually rental income) from immovable property in circumstances where that person, instead of directly owning the immovable property, owns shares in a company that owns the property, and the ownership of such shares gives that person the right to use or to hold title to that property. The Contracting States may extend the scope of this Article to include income from such use or ownership. They may also extend the scope of Article 22 so as to provide for source taxation of shares in such companies.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 6
Paragraph 1
- This paragraph gives the right to tax income from immovable property (including income from agriculture or forestry) to the State of source, that is, the State in which the property is situated. As noted in the OECD Commentary, the basis for this provision is “the fact that there is always a very close economic connection between the source of this income and the State of source”. 27
- The OECD Commentary notes:
27 Paragraph 1 of the OECD Commentary on Article 6.
- […] Although income from agriculture or forestry is included in Article 6, the Contracting States are free to agree in their bilateral conventions to treat such income under Article 7. Article 6 deals only with income derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States from immovable property situated in the other Contracting State. It does not, however, apply to income from immovable property situated in the Contracting State of which the recipient is a resident within the meaning of Article 4, or in a third State; in respect of such income, the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 21 apply.
Paragraph 2
- The purpose of this paragraph, which gives the term “immovable property” the meaning that it has under the law of the Contracting State in which the property is situated, is to avoid difficulties in interpreting whether an asset or a right should be regarded as immovable property. In addition, this paragraph lists a number of assets and rights that are in any case considered to be covered by this term. On the other hand, this paragraph provides that ships, boats and aircraft shall not be regarded as immovable property. Article 6 does not contain a provision concerning interest on debt secured by immovable property, but this issue is dealt with under Article 11, which concerns interest.
Paragraph 3
- This paragraph provides that the general rule set out in paragraph 1 applies regardless of the form in which the immovable property is used.
Paragraph 4
- This paragraph provides that the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 3 also apply to income from immovable property of industrial, commercial and other enterprises and to income from immovable property used for the performance of independent personal services. The OECD Commentary also notes that:
- […] the right to tax vested in the State of source takes precedence over the right to tax of another State and also applies where only indirect income from immovable property is derived in the course of an enterprise or non-industrial and non-commercial activities. This does not prevent income from immovable property received through a permanent establishment from being regarded as business income, but it ensures that income from immovable property is taxed in the State in which the property is situated even where such property does not form part of a permanent establishment situated in that State. It should also be noted that the provisions of this Article do not prejudge the application of domestic law as regards the manner in which income from immovable property is taxed.
These observations apply equally in the case of non-industrial and non-commercial activities by virtue of the inclusion in paragraph 4 of the United Nations Model Convention of income from immovable property used for the performance of independent personal services.
Article 7 BUSINESS PROFITS
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention includes a number of provisions of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention, both unchanged and with substantial amendments, as well as certain new provisions. At its annual session in 2009, the Committee of Experts decided not to endorse the OECD approach to Article 7 in connection with the publication in 2008 of the OECD Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments28 (the 2008 Permanent Establishment Report). The 2008 Permanent Establishment Report provides for the recognition of dealings between different parts of an enterprise, such as a permanent establishment and its head office, to a greater extent than is recognized in the United Nations Model Convention. This OECD approach is currently reflected in the new Article 7 of the 2010 OECD Model Convention and the Commentary on that Article. The Committee of Experts decided not to endorse the OECD approach because it directly contradicts paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention, which generally does not allow the deduction of amounts “paid” by a permanent establishment to its head office (unless they are for the reimbursement of actual expenses). It was recognized that this rule continues to be relevant in the context of the United Nations Model Convention, irrespective of the changes made to the OECD Model Convention and its Commentary. Therefore, it should be noted that all subsequent references to Article 7 of the OECD Model Convention and its Commentary are consistent with the 2008 OECD Model Convention. Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention and Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention are largely consistent (except for the specific United Nations additions). Certain aspects of the 2008 OECD Commentary reflect the positions set out in the 2008 Permanent Establishment Report. In those places where the 2008 OECD Commentary reflects the approach of that Report, reference is instead made to the 2005 OECD Model Convention, which is not affected by it.
28 Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments, 2008. Available at: http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/20/36/41031455.pdf.
- The generally accepted arm’s length principle contained in the OECD Model Convention provides that the profits attributable to a permanent establishment are those profits which it would have earned had it been a wholly independent entity operating through the head office as a separate enterprise, functioning under the conditions and selling products at the prices prevailing in the ordinary market. The profits so attributed will generally be the profits reflected in the accounting records of that establishment. Nevertheless, this principle allows the authorities of the country in which the permanent establishment is located to adjust the financial accounts of the enterprise so that they properly reflect the income that the establishment would have earned had it been an independent enterprise operating through the head office at arm’s length. The application of the arm’s length principle in allocating profits between the head office and its permanent establishment in most countries presupposes that domestic legislation permits determination on an arm’s length basis.
- The application of the arm’s length principle is of particular importance in connection with the difficult and complex problem concerning the entitlement of permanent establishments to deductions from income. It is also generally accepted that, in calculating the profits of a permanent establishment, expenses should be taken into account if they were incurred for the purposes of the activities of the permanent establishment, including administrative and general management expenses. In addition to expenses that may be regarded as ordinary, there are certain categories of expenses that give rise to particular problems. These include interest and royalties, etc., paid by a permanent establishment to its head office in respect of loans of money made available to the permanent establishment or patent rights licensed to it. They also include commissions (other than reimbursement of actual expenses) for specific services or for the performance by the enterprise of management functions for the benefit of the establishment. In such cases, it is considered that these payments should not be taken into account as deductible items in calculating the profits of the permanent establishment. Conversely, such payments to the permanent establishment made by the head office should be excluded from the profits of the permanent establishment. On the other hand, the allocable share of such payments, for example, interest and royalties paid by the enterprise to third parties, should be taken into account. As noted in paragraph 1 above, this approach is consistent with the approach adopted in interpreting Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention, but differs from the approach adopted by the OECD in its 2008 Permanent Establishment Report.
- Under the OECD Model Convention, only profits attributable to a permanent establishment in the State of source may be taxed. The United Nations Model Convention supplements this principle of attribution with a force of attraction rule, which permits an enterprise carrying on business through a permanent establishment in the State of source to be taxed on certain business profits arising from transactions outside the permanent establishment in that country. If, under the force of attraction principle, profits of the enterprise other than those directly attributable to the permanent establishment may be taxed in the State in which the permanent establishment is located, such profits should be determined in the same manner as if they were directly attributable to the permanent establishment.
- The United Nations Model Convention does not include paragraph 5 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention29, which states: “No profits shall be attributed to a permanent establishment by reason of the mere purchase by that permanent establishment of goods or merchandise for the enterprise.” When the draft United Nations Model Convention of 1980 was being developed, the former Group of Experts was unable to reach a consensus on the question of attributing profits to a permanent establishment by reason of the mere purchase of goods and therefore decided to include a note in Article 7 stating that this issue was to be settled in the course of bilateral negotiations. When this issue was considered by the former Group of Experts, some members from developing countries considered that this provision could be included subject to an amendment providing that, where a permanent establishment engages in purchasing and other activities, the profits derived from purchasing activities should be attributed to the permanent establishment. Other members of the Group from developing countries considered that this provision should be excluded because, even if purchasing activity is the enterprise’s only activity in the State of source, a permanent establishment may exist in that country, the purchasing activity may contribute to the overall profits of the enterprise, and some portion of those profits may therefore be subject to tax in that country. Members of the Group from developed countries generally favoured the inclusion of paragraph 5 of Article 7 of the OECD Model Convention without amendment30.
29 Paragraph 5 of Article 7 of the OECD Model Convention was deleted in the course of the 2010 update of the OECD Model Convention.
30 The wording supported by these members of the Group was identical to the wording of paragraph 5 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 7
Paragraph 1
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention, to which subparagraphs (b) and (c) have been added. During the discussions preceding the adoption of this paragraph by the Group of Experts, several members of the Group from developing countries supported the force of attraction rule, although limiting its application. Subparagraphs (b) and (c) mean that the United Nations Model Convention strengthens the corresponding Article of the OECD Model Convention by including a limited force of attraction rule. This allows the country in which the permanent establishment is located to tax not only the profits attributable to that permanent establishment, but also other profits of the enterprise derived in that country within the limits permitted by this Article. It is noted that the scope of application of the force of attraction rule is limited to the profits of the enterprise covered by Article 7 and does not extend to income from capital (dividends, interest and royalties), which is dealt with in other treaty provisions. Those who support this rule argue that under this rule neither sales through independent commission agents nor purchasing activities will be taxable in the hands of the principal. Some members of the Group from developed countries pointed out that the force of attraction rule had been recognized as unsatisfactory and had been removed from the tax treaties they had concluded more recently because it was inappropriate to tax income from activities that were in no way connected with the permanent establishment and whose scale was insufficient to constitute a permanent establishment. They also emphasized the uncertainty that such an approach creates for taxpayers. Members of the Group from developing countries noted that the force of attraction principle makes it possible to avoid certain administrative problems, since under this approach it is not necessary to establish a connection between a particular activity and the permanent establishment or the income attributable to it. This applies particularly to transactions carried out directly by the head office in the territory of the country but similar in nature to transactions carried out by the permanent establishment. However, at the end of the discussion, it was proposed that the force of attraction rule should be limited to sales of goods and merchandise and other activities as follows: if an enterprise has a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State for the purpose of selling goods or merchandise, the sale of the same or similar goods may be taxed in that State even if it is not carried out through the permanent establishment; a similar rule applies where the permanent establishment is used for other business activities and the same or similar activities are carried on without any connection with the permanent establishment.
- During the 1999 revision of the United Nations Model Convention, however, some members of the Group of Experts considered that such a limited force of attraction rule should not apply if the enterprise could demonstrate that the trading or business activities were carried out for reasons other than obtaining treaty benefits. This thereby recognizes that an enterprise may have legitimate commercial reasons for preferring not to carry on trading or business activities through its permanent establishment.
- The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention applies to the corresponding paragraph of Article 7:
- When it comes to the part of the profits of an enterprise attributable to a permanent establishment, the second sentence of paragraph 1 contains a direct reference to paragraph 2, which provides guidance for determining what profits should be attributed to the permanent establishment. Since paragraph 2 forms part of the context in which this phrase must be read, it should not be interpreted in a manner that would conflict with paragraph 2, for example, by interpreting it as limiting the amount of profits that may be attributed to a permanent establishment to the amount of profits of the enterprise as a whole. Thus, although paragraph 1 provides that a Contracting State may tax the profits of an enterprise of the other Contracting State only to the extent that they are attributable to a permanent establishment situated in the first-mentioned State, it is paragraph 2 that determines the meaning of the phrase “profits attributable to the permanent establishment”. In other words, the guidance in paragraph 2 may result in profits being attributed to a permanent establishment even if the enterprise as a whole has never made a profit; conversely, this guidance may result in no profits being attributed to a permanent establishment even if the enterprise as a whole has made a profit.
- It is clear, however, that the Contracting State of residence of the enterprise has an interest in the proper application of the guidance in paragraph 2 by the State in which the permanent establishment is located. Since the guidance applies to both Contracting States, the State of residence of the enterprise must, under Article 23, eliminate double taxation on profits properly attributed to the permanent establishment. In other words, if the State in which the permanent establishment is located attempts to impose tax on profits that should not be attributed to the permanent establishment under Article 7, this may result in double taxation of profits that should properly be taxable only in the State in which the enterprise is situated.
- The purpose of paragraph 1 is to ensure a limitation on the right of one of the Contracting States to tax business profits of enterprises [which are residents] of the other Contracting State. This paragraph does not restrict the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents under controlled foreign company provisions contained in its domestic law, even though such tax on those residents may be calculated by reference to a portion of the profits of an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State that is connected with those residents’ participation in such enterprise. The tax imposed in this manner by a State on its own residents does not reduce the profits of the enterprise of the other State, and therefore it cannot be argued that such tax is imposed on those profits (see also paragraph 23 of the Commentary on Article 1 and paragraphs 37–39 of the Commentary on Article 10).
Some countries do not agree with the approach adopted in the second sentence of paragraph 13 of the OECD Commentary, which states that paragraph 1 of Article 7 does not restrict the right of Contracting States to tax their own residents under controlled foreign company provisions contained in their domestic law.
Paragraph 2
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 7 of the OECD Model Convention. During the discussions of the former Group of Experts, a member from one of the developing countries noted that in his country there were certain problems associated with inconsistencies in determining the profits that should be attributed to a permanent establishment, particularly in relation to turnkey contracts. Under turnkey contracts, a contractor undertakes to construct a factory or another similar facility and prepare it for operation; when the facility is ready to be commissioned, it is handed over to the purchaser, who may then begin operations. International tax problems arise when a facility is constructed in one country by a contractor who is a resident of another country. The actual construction carried out in one country, if it takes place over a sufficiently long period, undoubtedly constitutes a permanent establishment in that country. However, turnkey contracts often include other components in addition to ordinary construction work, including the procurement of production equipment, the provision of architectural and engineering services, and the provision of technical assistance. It was explained that these types of work are sometimes completed before the commencement of actual construction (and, consequently, before the establishment of a permanent establishment at the construction site), and often outside the country in which the construction site/permanent establishment is located.
- Thus, the question arises as to what portion of the total profit under a turnkey contract should properly be attributed to the permanent establishment and, accordingly, taxed in the country in which it is located. According to a member of the Group from one of the developed countries, he was aware of cases in which countries had attempted to attribute the entire amount of profit under a contract to the permanent establishment. However, he believed that only the profits attributable to activities carried out by the permanent establishment should be taxed in the country in which the permanent establishment is located, unless the profits include items of income dealt with separately in other Articles of the Convention and taxable in that country under those provisions.
- The Group concluded that this was a complex problem, capable of giving rise to disagreements and involving many interrelated issues, such as rules for determining the source of income, the definition of a permanent establishment and the profits of an enterprise. The Group recognized that this problem could be considered during bilateral negotiations but decided not to make any amendments in this regard.
- During the 1999 revision of the United Nations Model Convention, some members of the Group of Experts considered that the final part of paragraph 2 was too narrow, believing that it referred only to dealings between a permanent establishment and the head office and did not take into account dealings between a permanent establishment and, for example, other permanent establishments of the same enterprise. In this connection, the Contracting States may consider the following alternative clarification:
In each Contracting State, there shall be attributed to that permanent establishment the profits which it might be expected to make if it were a separate and independent enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions.
- Although the substance of the disagreements concerning the attribution of profits between different permanent establishments, as distinct from their attribution between a permanent establishment and its head office, was not in doubt, it was generally agreed that the concerns of the former Group of Experts should be clearly stated.
- As noted in paragraph 14 of the Commentary on Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention, paragraph 2 in its current wording “contains the basic directive on which the attribution of profits to a permanent establishment should be based”.
As stated in that Article, this paragraph is clearly subject to the provisions of paragraph 3 of this Article. Paragraph 14 of the OECD Commentary then states the following:
This paragraph contains a provision, usually found in bilateral conventions, to the effect that the profits to be attributed to a permanent establishment are those which that permanent establishment would have made if, instead of dealing with the rest of the enterprise, it had been dealing with an absolutely independent enterprise under the conditions and at the prices prevailing in the ordinary market. This corresponds to the arm’s length principle, which is discussed in the Commentary on Article 9. The profits determined in this way will generally be the same profits as would be determined in accordance with ordinary accounting procedures.
Since the arm’s length principle also applies to the attribution of profits that a permanent establishment may derive from dealings with other permanent establishments of the same enterprise, the substance of the existing paragraph 2 should ensure its specific application to such situations. Thus, where an enterprise of one Contracting State carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein, the profits that would be attributable to that permanent establishment if it were a separate enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and dealing at arm’s length with the enterprise of which it is a permanent establishment, or with other permanent establishments of that enterprise, as a wholly independent entity, shall be attributed to that permanent establishment.
- The determination of the profits attributable to a particular permanent establishment is precisely the case in which the 2008 OECD Model Convention Commentary refers to the 2008 Permanent Establishment Report. Having regard to the observations in paragraph 1 above, the Committee considers that the following part of the Commentaries on paragraph 2 of Article 7 of the 2005 OECD Model Convention applies to paragraph 2 of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention:
- In the vast majority of cases, the trading accounts of the permanent establishment — which will usually exist at least because a successfully operating business organization is generally interested in knowing how profitable its various branches are — will be used by the relevant tax authorities to determine the profits properly attributable to that establishment. In exceptional cases, there may be no separate accounts […]. But where such accounts exist, they will naturally serve as the starting point for any adjustment, if an adjustment is necessary, to determine properly the amount of attributable profits. It should probably be emphasized that the guidance contained in paragraph 2 does not provide a basis for abstract constructions by tax authorities of hypothetical profit figures; the starting point must always be the real facts reflected in the financial statements of the permanent establishment and, where necessary, adjustments must be made to the profit figures derived from those facts.
12.1 In this connection, the question arises as to the extent to which reliance may be placed on such accounts where they are based on arrangements between the head office and its permanent establishments (or between the permanent establishments themselves). It is quite clear that such internal arrangements cannot qualify as legally binding contracts. However, to the extent that the trading accounts of the head office and the permanent establishments are prepared symmetrically on the basis of such arrangements and to the extent that these arrangements reflect the functions performed by the various parts of the enterprise, such trading accounts may be accepted by the tax authorities. In this respect, accounts can be regarded as having been prepared symmetrically only if the amounts of transactions or the methods of allocating profits or expenses in the accounting records of the permanent establishment correspond exactly to the amounts and methods of allocation in the accounts of the head office, expressed in the national currency or in the functional currency in which the enterprise records its transactions. However, if the trading accounts are based on internal arrangements reflecting purely artificial arrangements rather than the actual economic functions of the various parts of the enterprise, such arrangements should simply be disregarded and the accounts adjusted accordingly. This would be the case, for example, if, under such an internal arrangement, a permanent establishment involved in sales were to perform the role of a principal (bearing all risks and being entitled to all profits from sales), although in fact that permanent establishment is nothing more than an intermediary or agent (bearing limited risks and being entitled only to a limited share of the income received), or if, conversely, it were to perform the role of an intermediary or agent while in fact being the principal.
12.2 In this connection, it should also be noted that the principle set out in paragraph 2 operates subject to the provisions of paragraph 3, particularly with regard to the treatment of amounts paid by a permanent establishment to its head office in the form of interest, royalties, etc., in repayment of a loan or as payment for patent rights assigned by the latter to the permanent establishment […].
- Even if a permanent establishment is able to provide detailed accounts intended to reflect the profits derived from its activities, the tax authorities of that country may nevertheless need to adjust those accounts in accordance with the arm’s length principle […]. Such an adjustment may be necessary, for example, where invoices for goods are issued by the head office to the permanent establishment at prices that do not correspond to this principle, with the result that profits are attributed to the head office rather than to the permanent establishment, or vice versa.
14. In such cases, it will generally be appropriate to replace the prices used with ordinary market prices for the same or similar goods supplied under the same or similar conditions. It is quite obvious that the price at which goods may be purchased on the open market varies depending on the quantity required and the period after which they are to be delivered; such factors should be taken into account when deciding whether to use the open market price. It should probably be noted here that an enterprise may sometimes have quite sound commercial reasons for invoicing its goods at prices below those prevailing on the ordinary market; for example, this may be a perfectly normal commercial means of establishing particular products in a new market, and should not be regarded as evidence of an attempt to transfer profits from one country to another. Difficulties may also arise in connection with patented goods manufactured by an enterprise and sold entirely through permanent establishments; if, in these circumstances, no open market price exists and the figures in the invoices appear unsatisfactory, it may be necessary to calculate the profits of the permanent establishment by other methods, for example, by applying the average ratio of gross profit to turnover of the permanent establishment and then deducting from the amounts thus obtained the corresponding amount of expenses incurred. It is quite obvious that particular problems of this kind may arise in certain cases, but the general rule should always be that profits should be attributed to the permanent establishment on the basis of its accounts, to the extent that such accounts reflect the actual facts relating to the matter in question. If the available accounts do not reflect the actual facts, new accounts must be prepared or the original accounts adjusted, and for these purposes figures prevailing on the open market should be used.
15. Many States regard as taxable profits the cases in which an asset, whether or not it constitutes trading stock, forming part of the property of a permanent establishment situated in their territory, is transferred to a permanent establishment or the head office of the same enterprise in another State. Article 7 permits such States to tax the profits which they consider to arise as a result of such a transfer. Such profits may be determined in the manner described below. Where a transfer takes place, whether permanent or temporary, the question arises as to when the taxable profit is realised. In practice, if such property has a substantial market value and is likely, after the end of the tax year during which the transfer took place, to be reflected in the balance sheet of the receiving permanent establishment or other part of the enterprise, the realisation of taxable profit does not necessarily take place, as far as the enterprise as a whole is concerned, in the tax year in which the transfer was made. However, the mere fact that such property leaves the tax jurisdiction may result in the taxation of the accrued profit attributable to that property, since the definition of the term “realisation” depends on the domestic law of each country.
15.1 If the countries in which permanent establishments operate levy tax on profits arising from an internal transfer immediately after it takes place, even if such profits are not actually realised until the following business year, there will inevitably be a time lag between the payment of tax abroad and the time when it is taken into account in the country where the head office of the enterprise is situated. This time lag is associated with a serious problem, particularly where a permanent establishment transfers fixed assets or, in the case of its liquidation, all its production equipment to another part of the enterprise of which it forms a part. In such cases, where there is a serious risk of excessive taxation, the country in which the head office is situated should seek bilateral solutions with the other country on a case-by-case basis.
15.2 Another important problem relating to the transfer of assets, such as overdue loans, arises in connection with international banking operations. Debts may be transferred for supervisory and financial reasons from a branch to the head office or from one branch to another within the same bank. Such transfers should not be recognised unless there are reasonable grounds for considering them to have been made for sound commercial reasons or as having taken place between independent enterprises, for example, if they are carried out exclusively for tax purposes in order to obtain the maximum tax benefits for the bank concerned. In such cases, these transfers could not have taken place between fully independent enterprises and would therefore not have affected the amount of profit that such an independent enterprise could have earned through independent dealings with the enterprise of which it is a permanent establishment.
15.3 However, there may be a commercial market for the transfer of such loans from one bank to another, and the circumstances of an internal transfer may be similar to the conditions that would be expected to prevail in dealings between independent banks. An example of such a transfer would be where a bank closes a particular foreign branch and is obliged to transfer the corresponding debts either to its head office or to another branch. Another example would be the opening of a new branch in a given country and the subsequent transfer to that branch, solely for commercial reasons, of all loans previously granted to residents of that country by the head office or other branches. Any such transfer should be treated (to the extent that it is recognised at all for tax purposes) as having taken place at the open market value of the debt on the date of the transfer. In calculating the profits of the permanent establishment, an appropriate discount should be taken into account, since, between separate parts of the enterprise, the amount of the debt on the date of transfer should have been taken into account in determining the price, and the principles of separate accounting require that the carrying value of assets be adjusted to reflect market prices.
15.4 Where overdue loans are transferred for the purpose of obtaining not an excessive, but a full deduction for such a loss, it is important that the two relevant jurisdictions reach agreement on a mutually acceptable basis for granting the deduction. In such cases, consideration should be given to whether the value of the debt being transferred on the date of the internal transfer results from an incorrect assessment of the debtor's creditworthiness or whether its value at that time reflects a proper assessment of the debtor's existing position. In the former case, it may be appropriate for the country in which the transferring branch is located to limit the deduction to the amount of the actual loss incurred by the bank as a whole, and for the country receiving the transfer not to tax the subsequent apparent profit. However, if a loan is transferred for commercial reasons from one part of a bank to another and its value increases after a certain period of time, the transferring branch should be granted a deduction based on its actual value at the time of transfer. A somewhat different situation arises if the receiving structure is the bank's head office in the country where the loan was granted, since, as a rule, the country in which the loan was granted taxes the bank's worldwide profits and, for these purposes, grants a deduction taking into account the total amount of losses incurred in respect of the loan from the time it was granted until the time it was transferred. In this case, the transferring branch will receive a deduction for the period during which the loan was held by it, in accordance with the principles set out above. The country in which the head office is located will then grant a deduction to avoid double taxation by providing relief in respect of the tax charged to the branch in the receiving country.
Paragraph 3
16. The first sentence of paragraph 3 of Article 7 reproduces, with minor editorial changes, the text of paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the 2008 version of the OECD Model Convention. The remainder of the paragraph contains additional provisions formulated by the former Group of Experts in 1980. These provisions are based on a proposal made by members of the Group from developing countries, who considered that it would be appropriate to include in the text all the necessary definitions and clarifications, particularly with a view to assisting developing countries not represented in the Group. Some of these Group members also considered that provisions prohibiting the deduction of certain expenses should be included in the text of bilateral tax treaties in order to provide taxpayers with all the information concerning their tax obligations. During the discussions, it was noted that the additions to the OECD text would enable a permanent establishment to deduct interest, royalties and other expenses incurred by the head office on behalf of the permanent establishment. The Group reached a general consensus that, where the invoices issued by the head office include the full costs, both direct and indirect, no additional allocation of the head office's management and administrative expenses should be made, since this would result in duplication of such charges in transfers between the head office and the permanent establishment. It was noted that, in this regard, it was important to determine how the price had been established and which cost elements had been taken into account. If an international wholesale price had been used, it would be natural to include indirect costs. The Group members were generally of the opinion that any duplication of costs and expenses should be prevented.
17. The profits of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein. The profits and income of the enterprise shall be calculated by deducting all expenses attributable to its business activities, other than capital expenditure that is not currently deductible, or expenses of a personal or non-business nature that cannot be attributed to the business activities of the enterprise. In determining whether business expenses are deductible, many countries generally apply criteria such as the full, exclusive and unavoidable business necessity of such expenditure for the relevant business activity. The main objective is to ensure that only expenses which relate to, are connected with and are necessary for the business activity are claimed as deductions in calculating taxable profits. There must be a relationship between the expenses and the business activity, so that the expenses incurred are justified by their commercial purpose, necessity or efficiency. Once it has been established that, according to the above criteria, the particular item of expenditure is deductible, consideration should be given to whether there are specific legislative provisions establishing monetary or other limits on the deductibility of such business expenses; otherwise, it will be necessary to consider the claim for deduction of the expenses as a whole, without regard to the reasonableness of their amount or their impact on the profitability of the business activity.
18. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the 2008 version of the OECD Model Convention applies to the first part of the corresponding paragraph of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention:
27. This paragraph clarifies the general principle set out in paragraph 2 with regard to the expenses of a permanent establishment. It specifically provides that, in calculating the profits of a permanent establishment, deductions must be allowed for expenses incurred at any time for the purposes of the permanent establishment. Clearly, in some cases, it will be necessary to assess or calculate the amount of expenses to be taken into account by ordinary methods. For example, in the case of general administrative expenses incurred at the head office of an enterprise, it may be appropriate to take into account a proportional part based on the share of the permanent establishment's turnover (or possibly gross profit) in the total turnover of the enterprise. Accordingly, it is considered that the amount of expenses to be taken into account as incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment should equal the amount of the actual expenses incurred for those purposes. Deductions allowed to a permanent establishment in respect of any expenses of the enterprise attributable to it are not dependent on the actual reimbursement of such expenses by the permanent establishment.
28. It is sometimes argued that practical difficulties arise from the need to reconcile paragraphs 2 and 3, since paragraph 2 requires that prices between a permanent establishment and its head office should, as a general rule, be established in accordance with the arm's length principle, ensuring that the part making the transfer receives the kind of profit that it could have earned in dealings with an independent enterprise; whereas paragraph 3 provides that deductions for expenses incurred for the purposes of permanent establishments should equal the actual cost of those expenses, generally without the addition of any profit element.
29. In fact, although the application of paragraph 3 may give rise to certain practical difficulties, particularly in relation to the separate enterprise principle and the arm's length principle underlying paragraph 2, there is no fundamental inconsistency between the two paragraphs. Paragraph 3 provides that certain types of expenses must be taken into account as deductions in determining the profits of a permanent establishment, whereas paragraph 2 requires that the profits determined in accordance with the rule concerning the deduction of expenses set out in paragraph 3 should equal the profits that would have been earned by a separate and independent enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions. Thus, while paragraph 3 provides a rule applicable in determining the profits of a permanent establishment, paragraph 2 requires that the profits determined in this manner correspond to the profits that would have been earned by a separate and independent enterprise.
30. Furthermore, paragraph 3 merely determines which expenses are to be attributed to a permanent establishment for the purpose of determining the profits attributable to that permanent establishment. It does not address the question of whether expenses are deductible for tax purposes once they have been attributed, since the conditions for the deductibility of expenses are a matter to be determined under domestic law, subject to the provisions of Article 24 on non-discrimination (in particular, paragraphs 3 and 4 of that Article).
Notwithstanding the above observations, the Committee of Experts notes that some countries may point out that they allow only those deductions that are permitted under their domestic law.
31. In the practical application of these principles to the determination of the profits of a permanent establishment, the question may arise whether particular costs incurred by the enterprise can genuinely be regarded as expenses incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment, having regard to the separate and independent enterprise provision contained in paragraph 2. Although, in general, independent enterprises will seek to realise profits in their dealings with each other and, when transferring property or providing services to each other, will set prices that the open market can bear, there are nevertheless circumstances in which particular property or services cannot be regarded as having been obtained from an independent enterprise, or in which independent enterprises may agree to share the costs of an activity carried out jointly on mutually beneficial terms. In such special circumstances, it may be appropriate to regard any relevant costs incurred by the enterprise as expenses incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment. Difficulties arise in distinguishing such circumstances from cases in which costs incurred by the enterprise should not be regarded as expenses of the permanent establishment and the relevant property or services should, on the basis of the separate enterprise provision, be considered to have been transferred between the head office and the permanent establishment at a price including an element of profit. The question should be framed as follows: does the internal transfer of property or services, whether temporary or permanent, constitute the same kind of transaction as the transfer of property or services for which the enterprise, in the ordinary course of its business activities, would charge a third party a price established in accordance with the arm's length principle, i.e., in the ordinary course of business, including an appropriate profit in the selling price?
32. On the one hand, the answer to this question will be affirmative if such expenditure was initially connected with the performance of a function directly aimed at selling a particular product or service and realising profits through the permanent establishment. On the other hand, the answer will be negative if, having regard to the particular facts and circumstances, it appears that the expenditure was initially connected with the performance of a function essentially aimed at rationalising the general costs of the enterprise or at the ordinary expansion of sales.
33. Where goods are supplied for resale in finished form or as raw materials or semi-finished products, the provisions of paragraph 2 should normally be applied, and the profit calculated in accordance with the arm's length principle should be attributed to the part of the enterprise making the supply. There are, however, exceptions. One example would be a situation in which goods are supplied not for resale but for temporary use in the business, in which case the parts of the enterprise using the material should bear only their respective shares of the costs of such material, for example, in respect of equipment and depreciation expenses attributable to its use by each of those parts of the enterprise. It should, of course, be remembered that merely purchasing goods does not constitute a permanent establishment (paragraph 4(d) of Article 5), so that no question of attributing profits arises in such circumstances.
34. With regard to intangible rights, the rules governing relationships between enterprises belonging to the same group (for example, the payment of royalties or cost-sharing arrangements) cannot be applied to relationships between parts of the same enterprise. Indeed, it may be difficult to attribute the right to intangible “property” exclusively to one part of an enterprise and to argue that this part of the enterprise should receive royalties from other parts as if it were an independent enterprise. Since there is only one legal entity, it is impossible to attribute legal ownership to any particular part of the enterprise, and in practice it will be difficult to attribute the costs of creating such a right exclusively to one part of the enterprise. It is therefore appropriate to regard the costs of creating intangible rights as attributable to all parts of the enterprise that will use them and as having been incurred on behalf of the various parts of the enterprise to which they relate. In such circumstances, the actual costs of creating or acquiring such intangible rights, as well as expenses incurred in connection with such intangible rights, should be allocated among the various parts of the enterprise without any profit mark-up or royalty. In this regard, tax authorities should bear in mind that any possible adverse consequences of research and development activities (for example, liability associated with their results and environmental damage) should also be allocated among the various parts of the enterprise, which, where appropriate, will result in compensatory payments.
35. In the field of services, difficulties may arise in determining whether, in a particular case, the costs of services should be charged to the various parts of the same enterprise at actual cost or at actual cost plus a profit mark-up for the part of the enterprise providing the services. The business activity of an enterprise or one of its parts may consist of providing such services, for which a standard fee may be charged. In that case, the fee for the service should generally be charged at the same rate as that charged to external customers.
36. If the principal activity of a permanent establishment consists of providing particular services to the enterprise to which it belongs, and if such services confer a real benefit on that enterprise and their cost constitutes a substantial part of the enterprise's expenses, the host country may require that a profit margin be included in the amount of the costs. As far as possible, the host country should endeavour to avoid schematic solutions and should instead base its approach on the value of those services in the circumstances existing in each particular case.
37. However, more often the provision of services is merely part of the general management activities of the company as a whole, where, for example, the enterprise provides a general staff training system used by employees of each part of the enterprise. In this case, it will generally be appropriate to treat the costs of providing the service as part of the general administrative expenses of the enterprise as a whole, which should be allocated on the basis of actual costs among the various parts of the enterprise to the extent that such costs are incurred for the purposes of the relevant part of the enterprise, without any mark-up reflecting the profits of another part of the enterprise.
38. The treatment of services provided in the course of the general management of an enterprise raises the question of whether any part of the enterprise's overall profits should be regarded as resulting from proper management. Consider the case where a company has its head office in one country but carries on all its activities through a permanent establishment in another country. In the extreme case, there is a strong likelihood that the only activities carried out at the head office are meetings of the board of directors, while all other activities of the company, apart from purely formal legal acts, are carried out by the permanent establishment. In this case, there are grounds for arguing that at least part of the profits of the entire enterprise is generated by the skilful management and business abilities of the directors and that this part of the enterprise's profits should therefore be attributed to the country in which the head office is located. However, once again, whatever the theoretical merits of this approach may be, practical considerations do not support it. In the case described, management expenses will, of course, be set off against the profits of the permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 3, but, when considering the matter as a whole, it would appear incorrect to pursue this aspect further by deducting and taking into account some notional amount of “management profit”. Therefore, in situations identical to the extreme case mentioned above, no notional amounts, such as management profit, should be taken into account when determining the taxable profits of the permanent establishment.
39. It is, of course, possible that countries in which some part of the overall profits of an enterprise is normally attributed to the head office in order to reflect profits earned through proper management may wish to retain this practice. This Article in no way prevents them from doing so. Nevertheless, as follows from paragraph 38 above, the country in which the permanent establishment is located is in no way required, when calculating the profits attributable to that permanent establishment, to deduct an amount representing the proportionate share of management profits attributed to the head office.
40. It is also possible that, if the country in which the head office of an enterprise is located attributes a certain percentage of the enterprise's profits to the head office solely on account of proper management, while the country in which the permanent establishment is located does not do so, the resulting aggregate amount of profits subject to taxation in the two countries will be excessive. In any such case, the country in which the head office of the enterprise is located should take the initiative in making the necessary adjustments in calculating the tax liabilities in that country, so as to eliminate double taxation entirely.
41. Particularly serious problems arise in connection with the treatment of interest charges. First, there may be amounts that are paid by a permanent establishment to its head office as interest in respect of loans made by the latter to the former. With the exception of financial enterprises, such as banks, it is generally accepted that such internal “interest” should not be taken into account. This is because:
— from a legal point of view, the transfer of capital in return for the payment of interest, together with an obligation to repay the full amount within a specified period, is in fact a formal act that is incompatible with the true legal nature of a permanent establishment.
— from an economic point of view, internal debts and receivables may not exist, since, if an enterprise is financed exclusively or predominantly by equity capital, it should not be permitted to deduct interest that it clearly does not have to pay. If, for example, symmetrical expenses and receipts do not distort the total amount of the enterprise's profits, the partial results may nevertheless be subject to arbitrary adjustments.
42. For these reasons, the general prohibition on deductions in respect of internal debts and receivables should be maintained, subject to the special problems of banks discussed below.
43. A separate problem, however, concerns the deduction of interest on debts actually incurred by the enterprise. Such debts may be wholly or partly connected with the activities of a permanent establishment; loans actually obtained by the enterprise under the relevant contracts may be used for the purposes of either the head office, the permanent establishment, or both. In connection with these debts, the question arises as to how to determine the portion of interest that may be deducted in calculating the profits attributable to the permanent establishment.
44. The approach proposed […] before 1994, namely the direct and indirect proportional allocation of actual debt costs, proved inconvenient in practice, in particular because it was unlikely to be applied uniformly. Furthermore, it is well known that the indirect proportional allocation of total interest payments, or of that part of the interest remaining after certain types of direct allocation, gives rise to practical difficulties. It is also well known that the direct proportional allocation of total interest expenses may not accurately reflect the costs of financing a permanent establishment, since the taxpayer may have control over the accounting for loans and, in order to reflect actual economic indicators, an adjustment may be required, in particular to take account of the fact that an independent enterprise would normally be expected to have a certain level of “free” capital.
Accordingly, the Committee of Experts considers it preferable to seek a practical solution. Such a solution should take into account the capital structure appropriate to both the organisation and the functions performed, including the need to recognise that a separate and independent enterprise should have adequate financing.
Paragraph 4
19. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 4 of Article 7 of the 2008 version of the OECD Model Convention. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 4 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention applies to the corresponding paragraph of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention:
52. In some cases, there has been a practice of determining the profits attributable to a permanent establishment not on the basis of specific accounts or an assessment of profits in accordance with the arm's length principle, but simply by apportioning the total profits of the enterprise using various formulas. This method differs from those provided for in paragraph 2, since it does not attribute profits on the basis of the separate enterprise concept, but rather on the basis of a proportional allocation of the total amount of profits. Indeed, it may produce a numerical result that differs from the result obtained by calculating profits on the basis of specific accounts. Paragraph 4 clarifies that a Contracting State may continue to use such a method if it has generally been adopted in that State, even though the resulting figure may sometimes differ slightly from the results obtained on the basis of specific accounts, provided that the result can fairly be regarded as being in accordance with the principles of this Article. However, it is emphasised that, in general, the profits attributable to a permanent establishment should be determined on the basis of the accounts of the permanent establishment, provided that they reflect the actual facts. It is considered that a method based on the proportional allocation of the total profits is generally less satisfactory than a method that takes into account only the activities of the permanent establishment, and should be used only in exceptional cases where it has become established practice and is accepted in the country as satisfactory by both the tax authorities and taxpayers. Paragraph 4 may, of course, be omitted if neither State uses this method. However, if the Contracting States wish to use a method that has not been part of their ordinary practice in the past, appropriate clarifications should be introduced into this paragraph during bilateral negotiations.
54. The essence of the method of [apportioning] the total profits is that a proportionate share of the profits of the entire enterprise is attributed to one of its parts, on the assumption that all parts of the enterprise have contributed to the overall profitability on the basis of one or more profitability criteria. The differences between such methods arise mainly from differences in the criteria used to determine the appropriate proportional division of the total amount of profits […]. The criteria commonly used may be divided into three main categories, namely those based on the enterprise's revenues, its expenses or its capital structure. The first category includes allocation methods based on turnover or commissions; the second includes methods based on payroll; and the third includes methods based on the proportion of the enterprise's total working capital allocated to each branch or part of the enterprise. Clearly, it is impossible to state in the abstract that any one of these methods is inherently more accurate than the others. The suitability of any particular method will depend on the circumstances to which it is applied. In some enterprises, for example, those providing services or manufacturing patented products with high profit margins, the amount of net profit depends to a large extent on turnover. For insurance enterprises, a proportional allocation of total profits based on the amount of insurance premiums received from policyholders in each of the relevant countries may be appropriate. In the case of an enterprise manufacturing goods using expensive raw materials or labour-intensive processes, profits may be more closely related to expenses. In the case of banking and financial groups, the most appropriate criterion may be a proportional share of the total amount of working capital […]. The general objective of any method of [apportioning] total profits should be to determine the amount of taxable profits as closely as possible to the figures that would have been obtained on the basis of specific accounts. No attempt should be made to establish any particular directive beyond the requirement that the tax authority, in consultation with the authorities of the other countries concerned, should use the method which, in the light of all the known facts, is most likely to produce that result.
55. When using any method of attributing to a part of an enterprise a proportionate share of the total profits of the entire enterprise, the question naturally arises as to the method of calculating the total profits of the enterprise. It is entirely possible that this question may be treated differently under the laws of different countries. This problem cannot be resolved in practice by establishing rigid rules. A provision providing for the allocation of profits on the basis of the method of calculation under the legislation of one particular country is unlikely to be approved; each country concerned should be allowed to calculate profits in accordance with the requirements of its own legislation.
Paragraph 5
20. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 6 of Article 7 of the 2008 version of the OECD Model Convention. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 6 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention applies to the corresponding paragraph of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention:
58. This paragraph is intended to make it clear that a method of allocation, once used, should not be changed merely because another method produces more favourable results in a particular year. One of the objectives of the Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation is to provide an enterprise of a Contracting State with a certain degree of certainty as to the tax treatment that will be afforded to its permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, as well as to the part of the enterprise in its own State that deals with that permanent establishment; accordingly, paragraph 6 guarantees a consistent and uniform tax treatment.
Paragraph 6
21. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 7 of Article 7 of the 2008 version of the OECD Model Convention. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 7 of Article 7 of the 2008 OECD Model Convention applies to the corresponding
paragraph of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention:
59. Although it has been considered unnecessary to define the term “profits” in the Convention, it should nevertheless be borne in mind that this term, as used in this Article and in other Articles of the Convention, has a broad meaning encompassing all income derived from the carrying on of the business activities of an enterprise. This broad meaning is consistent with the use of the term in the tax legislation of most OECD member countries.
60. However, such an interpretation of the term “profits” may give rise to some uncertainty regarding the application of the Convention. If the profits of an enterprise include categories of income dealt with separately in other Articles of the Convention, such as dividends, the question may arise as to whether the taxation of such profits is governed by the special Article on dividends, etc., or by the provisions of this Article.
61. To the extent that the application of this Article and the relevant special Article results in the same tax treatment, this question has no practical significance. In addition, it should be noted that certain special Articles contain specific provisions establishing the priority of the particular Article (see paragraph 4 of Article 6, paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11, paragraph [4] of Article 12 and paragraph 2 of Article 21).
62. However, it would appear appropriate to establish a rule of interpretation in order to clarify the scope of application of this Article in relation to other Articles dealing with specific categories of income. In accordance with the generally accepted practice in existing bilateral conventions, paragraph 7 establishes the priority of the special Articles on dividends, interest, etc. It follows from this rule that this Article will apply to business income that does not belong to the categories of income covered by the special Articles and, in addition, to dividends, interest, etc., which, under paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11, paragraph [4] of Article 12 and paragraph 2 of Article 21, fall within the scope of this Article […]. It is understood that categories of income governed by special Articles may, subject to the provisions of the Convention, be taxed either separately or as business profits in accordance with the tax legislation of the Contracting States.
63. The Contracting States are free to agree bilaterally on specific clarifications or definitions of the term “profits” in order to clarify the distinction between this term and, for example, the concept of dividends. In particular, this may be considered appropriate if the Convention under discussion allows for departures from the definitions contained in the special Articles on dividends, interest and royalties. This may also be desirable where the Contracting States intend to specify that, under the domestic tax law of one or both States, the term “profits” includes particular types of receipts, such as income from the disposal or leasing of an enterprise or movable property used in business activities. In this connection, it may be necessary to consider introducing additional rules for the allocation of such particular types of profits.
22. It should be borne in mind that, in the United Nations Model Convention, payments “for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment” are treated differently. They remain included in the definition of the term “royalties” given in paragraph 3 of Article 12 and, accordingly, under paragraph 6 of Article 7, continue to fall within the scope of Article 12 and not Article 7.
Article 8
INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING AND AIR TRANSPORT
A. General Provisions
- Article 8 of the United Nations Model Convention has two alternative versions — Article 8 (Alternative A) and Article 8 (Alternative B). Article 8 (Alternative A) reproduces Article 8 of the OECD Model Convention. Article 8 (Alternative B) contains substantial substantive changes compared with Article 8 (Alternative A), dealing separately with profits from the operation of aircraft and profits from the operation of ships in paragraphs 1 and 2, respectively. Paragraph 3 reproduces paragraph 2 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention with a minor adjustment to reflect the additional paragraph added in Alternative B.
- With regard to the taxation of profits from the operation of ships in international traffic, many countries have supported the provision set out in Article 8 (Alternative A). In their view, shipping enterprises should not be subject to the tax legislation of a whole range of countries with which their activities are connected; taxation in the State in which the place of effective management is situated is preferable also from the perspective of the various tax authorities. They argued that if each country were to tax a share of the shipping company's profits calculated in accordance with its own rules, the total of those shares could greatly exceed the enterprise's overall income. This would give rise to a serious problem, particularly because taxes in developing countries are in many cases excessively high, whereas the overall profits of shipping enterprises are often quite modest.
- Other countries stated that they were not prepared to forego even a limited amount of revenue from the taxation of foreign shipping enterprises until their own shipping industries had reached a higher level of development. They acknowledged, however, that in such circumstances substantial difficulties arise in determining taxable profits and allocating profits among the various countries concerned that participate in the operation of ships in international traffic.
- Since no general agreement could be reached on the provision concerning the taxation of profits from shipping, the two alternatives contained in the Model Convention are proposed, and the question of such taxation is to be resolved in the course of bilateral negotiations.
- Until 2017, the texts of Article 8 (Alternatives A and B) both referred to the "place of effective management of the enterprise". Taking into account the practice of most countries, the Committee of Experts decided to follow the wording of other Articles and refer instead to the "enterprise of a Contracting State", and the Article (Alternatives A and B) was amended accordingly. However, some countries may prefer to continue using the previous wording and refer to the "State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated".
- Despite the joint decision to recommend Article 8 (Alternative A) and Article 8 (Alternative B) as alternatives, some countries that did not agree with Article 8 (Alternative A) were also unable to accept Article 8 (Alternative B) because of the words "on a regular basis". They argued that some countries might wish to tax either all profits from shipping or all profits from air transport, and that the adoption of Article 8 (Alternative B) could therefore result in a loss of tax revenue, taking into account the limited number of shipping companies or airlines whose place of effective management is situated in those countries. In such cases, questions of taxation should likewise be resolved in the course of bilateral negotiations.
- Depending on the frequency or volume of cross-border transportation, countries may wish, in the course of bilateral negotiations, to extend the provisions of Article 8 to rail or road transport. As explained in paragraph 15 below, they may also wish to extend the application of Article 8 to inland waterway transport.
- [Renumbered]
B. Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 8
(ALTERNATIVES A AND B)
Paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative A)
- This paragraph, which reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 8 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention, is intended to ensure that tax on profits from the operation of ships and aircraft in international traffic is levied by only one State. The essence of this paragraph is that profits are fully exempt from tax at source and are taxable exclusively in the State of residence of the place of effective management of the enterprise engaged in international traffic. It constitutes a separate operative rule for shipping and is not subject to Articles 5 and 7, which concern business profits governed by the permanent establishment rule. The exemption from tax in the State of source is largely based on the fact that the income of such enterprises is earned on the high seas and that the application of the tax legislation of a whole range of countries to them is likely to result in double taxation or, at best, difficulties in allocating income, and also on the fact that exemption from tax in all countries other than their own country will ensure that enterprises are free from taxation in foreign countries if their activities as a whole prove to be unprofitable. The same considerations apply to international air transport. Since many developing countries with maritime borders have no resident shipping companies but do have ports that are used extensively by ships from other countries, they have traditionally objected to this principle of exemption from tax on profits from shipping and have advocated Alternative B.
- The Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Convention notes that, although paragraph 1 is based on the principle that the right to tax remains with the Contracting State of the enterprise, some countries may wish instead to refer to the place of effective management of the enterprise and formulate this paragraph as follows:
Profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic shall be taxable only in the Contracting State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated.
10.1 Countries wishing to refer to the "place of effective management of the enterprise" in paragraph 1 may also wish to consider the specific case where the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated on board a ship, which can be addressed by adding the following provision:
Where the place of effective management of a shipping enterprise is situated on board a ship, it shall be deemed to be situated in the Contracting State in which the ship's home harbour is situated or, if there is no such home harbour, in the Contracting State of which the operator of the ship is a resident.
10.2 As regards the meaning of the term "profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic", the Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Convention identifies two categories of profits that should fall within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 8. The first relates to profits directly derived by the enterprise from the carriage of passengers or cargo in international traffic, and the second relates to profits from activities that permit, facilitate or support international traffic. Within the second category, the Commentary identifies two distinct types of activities: those directly connected with such operations and those not directly connected but "ancillary" to such operations. The Commentary states as follows:
- The profits covered consist primarily of profits derived directly by the enterprise from the carriage of passengers or cargo by ships or aircraft (owned, leased or otherwise at the disposal of the enterprise) that it operates in international traffic. However, with the development of international transport, shipping and air transport enterprises invariably engage in numerous types of activities that permit, facilitate or support their international transport operations. This paragraph also covers profits from activities directly connected with such operations, as well as profits from activities that are not directly connected with the operation of the enterprise's ships or aircraft in international traffic, provided that they are ancillary to such activities.
4.1 Any activity carried on principally in connection with the carriage by the enterprise of passengers or cargo on ships or aircraft operated by it in international traffic should be considered directly connected with such carriage.
4.2 Activities that the enterprise is not required to carry on for the purposes of its own operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, but which make a minor contribution to such operation and are so closely related to it that they should not be regarded as a separate activity or source of income of the enterprise, should be considered ancillary to the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic.
- Applying the above principles, the Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Convention considers a number of activities connected with delivery to the country of destination by any means of domestic transport operated by other enterprises. In this case, any profits derived by the first enterprise from arranging such transportation by other enterprises fall within the scope of this paragraph, even if the profits derived by the other enterprises providing such domestic transportation do not.
- Profits from the leasing of a ship or aircraft chartered with a full crew, personnel and supplies must be treated as profits from the carriage of passengers or cargo. Otherwise, a substantial part of maritime or air transport would fall outside the scope of this provision. However, profits from the leasing of a ship or aircraft chartered without a crew are covered by Article [12], rather than Article 8, except where, for an enterprise engaged in the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, this constitutes an occasional source of income.
- Profits derived by an enterprise from the carriage of passengers or cargo by means other than ships or aircraft operated by it in international traffic fall within the scope of this paragraph to the extent that such carriage is directly connected with, or constitutes an ancillary activity to, the operation by that enterprise of ships or aircraft in international traffic. An example would be an enterprise engaged in international transport that carries some of its passengers or cargo in international traffic on ships or aircraft operated by other enterprises, for example, under code-sharing or slot-chartering arrangements (the rental of a container slot (section) on a container ship), or in order to benefit from an earlier sailing. Another example would be an airline operating a bus service between a city and an airport, principally to provide access to and from the airport for passengers on its international flights.
- Another example would be an enterprise engaged in the carriage of passengers or cargo on ships or aircraft operated in international traffic that undertakes to collect those passengers or that cargo in the country of departure of the journey or to transport or deliver them to the country of destination by any means of domestic transport operated by other enterprises. In this case, any profits derived by the first enterprise from arranging such transportation by other enterprises fall within the scope of this paragraph, even if the profits derived by the other enterprises providing such domestic transportation do not.
- An enterprise frequently sells tickets on behalf of other transport enterprises at a location that it maintains principally for the purpose of selling tickets for transportation on ships or aircraft operated by it in international traffic. Such ticket sales on behalf of other enterprises will either be directly connected with journeys on board ships or aircraft operated by that enterprise (for example, the sale of a ticket issued by another enterprise for a domestic flight connecting with an international flight offered by that enterprise) or will be ancillary to its own sales. Accordingly, profits derived by the first enterprise from the sale of such tickets fall within the scope of this paragraph.
8.1 Advertising that an enterprise may undertake for other enterprises in magazines offered on board ships or aircraft operated by it, or at its places of business (for example, ticket offices), is ancillary to the operation of those ships or aircraft, and profits derived from such advertising fall within the scope of this paragraph.
- Containers are widely used in international transport. Such containers are also frequently used in domestic transport. Profits derived by an enterprise engaged in international transport from the leasing of containers are generally either directly connected with or ancillary to the operation by that enterprise of ships or aircraft in international traffic and, in such cases, fall within the scope of this paragraph. The same conclusion will apply to profits derived by such an enterprise from the short-term storage of such containers (for example, where the enterprise charges a customer for storing a loaded container in a warehouse pending delivery) or from detention charges in the event that containers are not returned on time.
- An enterprise having assets or personnel in a foreign State for the purposes of operating its ships or aircraft in international traffic may derive income from supplying goods or services in that State to other transport enterprises. This may include (for example) the provision of goods and services by engineers, ground staff and equipment maintenance personnel, cargo handlers, catering staff and customer service personnel. If the enterprise supplies such goods or provides such services to other enterprises and such activity is directly connected with or ancillary to the operation by the enterprise of ships or aircraft in international traffic, the profits from the supply of such goods or services to other enterprises will fall within the scope of this paragraph.
10.1 For example, enterprises engaged in international transport may enter into pooling arrangements in order to reduce the costs of maintaining facilities necessary for the operation of their ships or aircraft in other countries. For example, if an air transport enterprise, under an international airline technical pool agreement, agrees to provide spare parts or maintenance services to other airlines landing at a particular location (thereby enabling it to benefit from such services at other locations), the activity carried on under that agreement will be ancillary to the operation of aircraft in international traffic.
- [Deleted]
- This paragraph does not apply to a shipbuilding yard operated in one country by a shipping enterprise having its place of effective management in another country.
- [Renumbered]
- Investment income of shipping, inland waterway or air transport enterprises (for example, income from shares, bonds, equity interests or loans) is subject to the treatment normally applicable to that class of income, except where the investments giving rise to the income are made as an integral part of the activity of operating ships or aircraft in international traffic in a Contracting State, so that the investments may be regarded as directly connected with that activity. Accordingly, this paragraph will apply to interest income derived, for example, from cash required in a Contracting State for the conduct of that activity, or from bonds deposited as security where this is required by law for the conduct of that activity: in such cases, the investments are necessary to ensure the operation of ships or aircraft at that location. However, this paragraph will not apply to interest income derived in the course of cash-flow management or other treasury activities for permanent establishments of the enterprise to which the income does not relate, or for associated enterprises, whether situated within or outside the Contracting State concerned, or for the head office (centralisation of treasury and investment activities), nor will it apply to interest income derived as a result of the short-term investment of profits earned from the local operations of the enterprise where the funds invested are not required for those operations.
14.1 Enterprises engaged in the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic may be required to acquire and use emission allowances and credits for that purpose (the nature of such allowances and credits is explained in paragraph 75.1 of the Commentary on Article 7). Paragraph 1 applies to income derived by such enterprises in respect of such allowances and credits where such income is an integral part of the business of operating ships or aircraft in international traffic, for example, where allowances are acquired for the purposes of operating ships or aircraft, or where allowances acquired for that purpose are subsequently sold when it becomes clear that they will not be needed.
11.1 Some members do not entirely agree with the interpretation of the term "profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic" in paragraphs 10.2 and 11 of this Commentary. Some of these members consider that ancillary activities are not covered by the text of Article 8, since such activities are not mentioned in the text of this Article of the United Nations Model Convention. Others consider that only some of the examples given in the OECD Commentary quoted above fall outside the definition of "profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic".
Paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative B)
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 8 of the OECD Model Convention, with the words "ships or" omitted. Accordingly, this paragraph does not apply to the taxation of profits from the operation of ships in international traffic, but only to the taxation of profits from the operation of aircraft in international traffic. Therefore, the Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative A) remains applicable only insofar as it relates to aircraft.
Paragraph 2 of Article 8 (Alternative B)
- This paragraph permits the taxation of profits from the operation of ships in international traffic in the State of source if the enterprise's activities in that country "are carried on on a regular basis". It also provides a separate operative rule for shipping and is not governed by Articles 5 and 7 concerning business profits subject to the permanent establishment rule. Accordingly, it applies both to regular or frequent and to irregular or occasional calls by ships in the course of transportation, provided that such transportation is carried out according to a schedule or plan and does not occur incidentally. The words "on a regular basis" mean that a ship calls at a particular country in accordance with a schedule or plan in order to collect cargo or passengers.
- The total net profit should generally be determined by the authorities of the country in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated (or the country of residence). The final conditions for its determination may be established as a result of bilateral negotiations. Such negotiations may clarify, for example, whether net profit should be determined before deducting special rebates or allowances that cannot be classified as depreciation deductions but are treated as subsidies to the enterprise. Bilateral negotiations may also clarify that direct subsidies paid to the enterprise by the government should be included in the amount of net profit. During the negotiations, a method may also be developed for identifying losses incurred in previous years for the purpose of determining net profit. To implement this approach, the country of residence provides a certificate specifying the enterprise's net profit from shipping and the amounts of all special items, including losses from previous years, which, in accordance with the arrangement reached as a result of the negotiations, must be included or excluded when calculating the net profit to be allocated, or otherwise taken into account in such calculation. The allocation of taxable profits may be made on the basis of some proportional factor established in the course of bilateral negotiations, preferably a factor based on outbound freight receipts (determined on a uniform basis, with or without deduction of commissions). The percentage reduction in the tax calculated on the basis of the allocated profits is intended to ensure an allocation of income that reflects the costs in terms of management and capital incurred in the country of residence.
Operation of Ships Engaged in Inland Waterway Transport
- Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State derived from transportation by inland waterways fall within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative A) or paragraph 2 of Article 8 (Alternative B) only to the extent that such transportation constitutes international traffic within the meaning of that term as defined in Article 3. However, some countries (for example, countries in which foreign enterprises are permitted to carry out cabotage operations on a river flowing through their territory) may wish to extend the treatment provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 8 (Alternative A) to profits derived from any transportation on rivers, canals and lakes; such countries may do so by including the following provision in their bilateral treaties:
Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transport shall be taxable only in that State.
If such a provision is included, it would be logical to change the title of Article 8 to "Shipping, Inland Waterways Transport and Air Transport".
15.1 Other countries, however, consider that inland waterway transport that is not international should not be treated differently from other types of business activities carried on within their borders. These countries consider that, although inland waterway transport that is not international may give rise to problems of double taxation, such problems can be resolved by means of the rules in Articles 7 and 23 A or 23 B in cases where foreign enterprises are permitted to carry on such transport activities.
- The rules set out in paragraphs 9–11.1 above concerning the taxation of rights and covered profits apply equally to the alternative provision set out in paragraph 15 above. The 2017 Commentary on the OECD Model Convention also states the following:
- The above provision will apply not only to inland waterway transport between two or more countries (in which case it would duplicate paragraph 1), but also to inland waterway transport carried on by an enterprise of one State between two points in another State. The alternative wording set out in paragraph 2 above, under which the right to tax is granted to the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated, is also applicable to the above provision. Where this alternative provision is used, it would be advisable to add a reference to "ships operating on inland waterways" in paragraph 3 of Articles 13 and 22 in order to ensure the same treatment for such ships as for ships and aircraft operated in international traffic (see also paragraph 9.3 of the Commentary on Article 15). Furthermore, the principles and examples set out in paragraphs 4 and 14 above will be applicable, with the necessary adaptations, for the purposes of determining which profits may be considered to have been derived from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transport. Specific tax problems that may arise in connection with inland waterway transport, particularly between neighbouring countries, may also be addressed through special arrangements based on bilateral agreements.
- Although the word "ship" is used in the above alternative provision in relation to inland waterway transport, this reflects the traditional distinction and should not be interpreted as limiting the meaning of the word "ship" used throughout the Convention, which should be given a broad meaning encompassing any vessel used for water navigation.
- A bilateral agreement may also be reached to the effect that profits from the operation of ships engaged in fishing, dredging or towing on the high seas are treated as income falling within the scope of this Article.
Enterprises Not Exclusively Engaged in Shipping or Air Transport
- With regard to enterprises not exclusively engaged in shipping or air transport, the Commentary on Article 8 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention states:
- It follows from the wording of paragraph 1 that enterprises not exclusively engaged in shipping or air transport nevertheless fall within the scope of the provisions of this paragraph in respect of profits derived by them from the operation of ships or aircraft owned by them.
- If such an enterprise has permanent establishments in a foreign State that are exclusively connected with the operation of its ships or aircraft, there is no reason to treat such establishments differently from permanent establishments of enterprises exclusively engaged in shipping or air transport.
- Nor do any difficulties arise in applying the provisions of paragraph 1 if the enterprise has a permanent establishment in another State that is not exclusively engaged in shipping or air transport. If its goods are transported on its own ships to a permanent establishment belonging to it in a foreign State, it would be correct to say that none of the profits derived by the enterprise as a result of performing the functions of its own carrier can properly be taxed in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated. The same should be true even if the permanent establishment maintains facilities for the operation of ships or aircraft (for example, loading berths) or incurs other expenses in connection with the transportation of the enterprise's goods (for example, personnel expenses). In this case, even if certain functions relating to the operation of ships and aircraft in international traffic may be performed by the permanent establishment, the profits attributable to those functions are taxable exclusively in the State to which the enterprise belongs. Any expenses, or a part thereof, incurred in performing such functions must be deducted when calculating the portion of profits that is exempt from tax in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated and must therefore not reduce the portion of profits attributable to the permanent establishment that may be taxed in that State under Article 7.
- Where ships or aircraft are operated in international traffic, the application of the alternative wording in paragraph [10] above to profits arising from such operation is not affected by the fact that the ships or aircraft are operated by a permanent establishment that is not the place of effective management of the enterprise as a whole; accordingly, even if such profits may be attributed to the permanent establishment under Article 7, they shall be taxable only in the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated [...].
- [Deleted]
Paragraph 2 of Article 8 (Alternative A) and Paragraph 3 of Article 8 (Alternative B)
- Paragraph 2 of Article 8 (Alternative A) reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 8 of the OECD Model Convention. Paragraph 3 of Article 8 (Alternative B) reproduces the latter paragraph with one change, namely, the words "paragraph 1" are replaced by the words "paragraphs 1 and 2". The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention states:
- Various forms of international cooperation exist in the field of shipping and air transport. In this area, international cooperation is achieved through pooling agreements or other contracts of a similar type that establish certain rules for the proportional division of income (or profits) from joint ventures.
- In order to clarify the tax treatment of a participant in a pool, joint venture or international operating agency and to resolve any difficulties that may arise, the Contracting States may, if they consider it necessary, agree bilaterally to the following addition:
… but only to the extent of the share of the profits so derived that is attributable to the participant in proportion to its share in the joint operations.
Article 9
ASSOCIATED ENTERPRISES
A. General Provisions
- Article 9 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 9 of the OECD Model Convention, with the exception of paragraph 3. Both Conventions embody the "arm's length" principle, which is the basis for allocating profits derived from transactions between associated enterprises. Article 9 should be considered in conjunction with Article 25 on the mutual agreement procedure and Article 26 on the exchange of information.
- For most countries, the application of the arm's length principle to the allocation of profits between associated enterprises presupposes that domestic legislation permits profits to be determined on the basis of the arm's length principle.
- It should be noted that the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention contains the following general statement on this Article:
- This Article deals with adjustments to profits that may be made for tax purposes where transactions have been entered into between associated enterprises (parent and subsidiary companies and companies under common control) on conditions other than those that would have prevailed between independent enterprises. The Committee has devoted considerable time and effort (and continues to do so) to examining the conditions for the application of this Article, its implications and the various methods that may be used to adjust profits where transactions have been entered into on terms other than those that would have prevailed at arm's length. Its conclusions are set out in the report Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, which is periodically updated to take account of the progress made by the Committee in this area.
- The OECD Commentary further states that the Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations "represent internationally agreed principles and provide guidance on the application of the arm's length principle, the authoritative statement of which is this Article". The Committee considers that these guidelines provide valuable guidance on the application of the arm's length principle under Article 9 of bilateral tax treaties concluded in accordance with the two Conventions. The Committee also considers that, in order to prevent international double taxation of corporate profits, it is essential that a common understanding prevail as to how the arm's length principle should be applied and that the two Model Conventions provide a common framework for preventing and resolving transfer pricing disputes where they may arise. To this end, the Committee has developed the United Nations Practical Manual on Transfer Pricing for Developing Countries, which pays particular attention to the experience of developing countries, reflects the realities of such countries at the relevant stages of their capacity development and ensures consistency with the recommendations contained in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines.
B. Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 9
Paragraph 1
- Paragraph 1 provides that, in the case of associated enterprises, the tax authorities of a Contracting State may, for the purposes of determining tax liabilities, restate the accounts of the enterprises where, as a result of the special relationship between the enterprises, the accounts do not reflect the real taxable profits arising in that State. Clearly, such an adjustment should be permitted, and this paragraph requires no special comment. This provision applies only where special conditions have been made or imposed in the relations between the two enterprises. It is clear that no restatement of accounts followed by adjustments should be made where transactions between associated enterprises have been carried out under normal commercial conditions prevailing in the open market, that is, in other words, at arm's length.
- The Report on "Thin Capitalisation" of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs31 states that there is a relationship between double taxation conventions and domestic rules on thin capitalisation that is relevant to the scope of this Article. Paragraph 3 of the Commentary on Article 9 of the OECD Model Convention states:
a) This Article does not prevent the application of domestic thin capitalisation rules insofar as they treat the profits of the borrower as corresponding to the amount of profits that would have been earned at arm's length;
b) This Article relates not only to the determination of whether the interest rate under a loan agreement is an arm's length rate, but also to whether the loan itself may, on the basis of the available evidence, be regarded as a loan or should be treated as some other form of payment, in particular a contribution to equity capital;
31 Adopted by the OECD Council on 26 November 1986 and reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention, p. (4)-1.
c) The application of thin capitalisation rules should generally not result in the taxable profits of the domestic enterprises concerned being increased beyond the level of profits that would have been earned at arm's length, and this principle should be observed when applying existing double taxation conventions.
The OECD Commentary further states:
- The question arises as to the compatibility with this Model Convention of special procedural rules adopted by some countries in respect of transactions between related parties. For example, the question may arise as to the compatibility with the arm's length principle of the reversal of the burden of proof or of any presumptions sometimes found in domestic legislation. A number of countries interpret this Article as in no way preventing the adjustment of the amount of profits under domestic law on conditions different from those provided for in this Article, and as elevating the arm's length principle to treaty level. Furthermore, almost all Member countries consider that additional information requirements, more stringent than the usual requirements, or even the reversal of the burden of proof, do not constitute discrimination within the meaning of Article 24. However, in some cases the application of the domestic legislation of certain countries may result in adjustments to the amount of profits that are inconsistent with the principles of this Article. This Article allows the Contracting States to resolve such situations through appropriate adjustments (see below), as well as through the mutual agreement procedure.
Paragraph 2
- According to the OECD Commentary, "the restatement of transactions between associated enterprises in the situation envisaged in paragraph 1 may give rise to economic double taxation (the taxation of the same income in the hands of different persons), insofar as an enterprise of State A whose profits are adjusted upwards will be liable to tax on an amount of profits on which its associated enterprise in State B has already been taxed". The OECD Commentary notes that "paragraph 2 provides that in such circumstances State B should make an appropriate adjustment in order to avoid double taxation".32
32 Paragraph 5 of the OECD Commentary on Article 9.
However, according to the OECD Commentary:
- [...] an adjustment is not made automatically in State B simply because the profits in State A have been increased; the adjustment should be made only if State B considers that the amount of adjusted profits correctly reflects the profits that would have been earned if the transaction had been entered into at arm's length. In other words, this paragraph cannot be invoked, and cannot be applied, if the profits of one associated enterprise are increased beyond the level of profits correctly calculated on the basis of the arm's length principle. Therefore, State B is required to adjust the profits of the associated company only if it considers that the adjustment made in State A is justified in principle and as regards the amount involved.
- This paragraph does not specify the method by which the adjustment is to be made. Member countries of the OECD use different methods of granting relief in such circumstances, and therefore the Contracting States may agree bilaterally on any specific rules as a supplement to this Article. Some States, for example, will prefer a system whereby, in the event that the profits of enterprise X in State A are increased to the level that they would have reached at arm's length, the adjustment is made by revising the assessment in respect of associated enterprise Y in State B that includes the profits subjected to double taxation, with a view to reducing taxable profits by the corresponding amount. Other States, in turn, will prefer a provision under which, for the purposes of Article 23, profits subjected to double taxation are treated in the hands of enterprise Y in State B as if they could have been taxed in State A. Accordingly, enterprise Y of State B is entitled to relief in State B under Article 23 in respect of the tax paid by its associated enterprise in State A.
- This paragraph is not intended to regulate so-called "secondary adjustments". Let us assume that the taxable profits of enterprise X in State A have been adjusted upwards in accordance with the principle laid down in paragraph 1. Let us also assume that an adjustment to the profits of enterprise Y in State B has been made in accordance with the principle laid down in paragraph 2. In this case, the situation that would have existed if the transactions had been carried out at arm's length has still not been fully restored, since, in essence, the funds representing the profits that were adjusted are held by enterprise Y rather than enterprise X. It may be argued that, if the transactions had been priced on an arm's length basis, enterprise X would subsequently have wished to transfer those profits to enterprise Y in the form, for example, of dividends or royalties (if enterprise Y is the parent of enterprise X) or in the form, for example, of a loan (if enterprise X is the parent of enterprise Y). In these circumstances, the tax consequences (for example, the application of withholding tax at source) would have been different, depending on the type of income concerned and the provisions of the Article governing the taxation of that income.
- Such secondary adjustments, which are necessary to restore the situation to what it would have been had the transactions been carried out at arm's length, depend on the actual circumstances of each particular case. It should be noted that paragraph 2 in no way prevents such secondary adjustments from being made where they are permitted under the domestic legislation of the Contracting States.
- This paragraph also leaves open the question of whether a time limit should be established after the expiry of which State B would no longer be required to make an appropriate adjustment to the profits of enterprise Y following an upward adjustment to the profits of enterprise X in State A. Some countries consider that the obligation of State B should be unlimited in time, in other words, that no matter how many years back State A goes for the purpose of revising tax assessments, enterprise Y should be equally guaranteed an appropriate adjustment in State B. Other countries consider that an obligation of this kind without a time limit is not appropriate from a practical implementation perspective. In view of this, the issue is not addressed in the text of the Article; however, the Contracting States are given the opportunity, if they consider it necessary, to include provisions in bilateral conventions specifying the period within which State B is required to make an appropriate adjustment [...].
- If a dispute arises between the parties concerning the amount or nature of the appropriate adjustment, they should resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25; the Commentary on that Article contains a number of considerations applicable to adjustments of the profits of associated enterprises made under this Article (in particular, following transfer pricing adjustments), as well as to the corresponding adjustments that must be made under paragraph 2 of this Article [...].
- It has been argued that a corresponding adjustment under paragraph 2 may be very costly for a developing country, which may consider it inappropriate to include paragraph 2 in its treaties. Nevertheless, paragraph 2 constitutes an essential aspect of Article 9, and the absence of a provision on corresponding adjustments would result in double taxation, which is contrary to the objectives of the Convention. Any country should carefully examine the provision on the primary adjustment under paragraph 1 before deciding which corresponding adjustment appropriately reflects the primary adjustment. Some countries have taken the position that it is desirable to exclude the obligation of a State to make a corresponding adjustment where another Contracting State has already adjusted the transfer prices. This result can be achieved by replacing the word "shall" with the word "may". The Contracting States may use whichever word they consider appropriate in the course of bilateral negotiations. However, no general agreement was reached on this issue, and the wording of paragraph 2 was left unchanged.
Paragraph 3
- In 1999, an amendment was made to the United Nations Model Convention consisting of the addition of a new paragraph 3 to Article 9. Under paragraph 2 of Article 9, a country must make an "appropriate adjustment" (a corresponding adjustment) reflecting the change in the transfer price made by the country under paragraph 1 of Article 9. The new paragraph 3 provides that the provisions of paragraph 2 shall not apply where, as a result of judicial, administrative or other legal proceedings, a final decision has been made that one of the enterprises is liable to a penalty for fraud, gross negligence or wilful default in connection with the adjustment of profits under paragraph 1. In other words, where a final decision is made in judicial, administrative or other legal proceedings indicating that, in connection with an adjustment of profits under paragraph 1, one of the enterprises is liable to a penalty for fraud, gross negligence or wilful default, there is no obligation to make a corresponding adjustment under paragraph 2. This approach means that the taxpayer may be subject to both non-tax and tax penalties. Some countries may consider such double punishment excessively severe, although it should be borne in mind that cases in which such penalties are imposed are likely to be exceptional in nature and that this provision will not apply in everyday practice.
Article 10
DIVIDENDS
A. General Provisions
1. Article 10 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces the provisions of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention, with the exception of paragraph 2, which contains substantial differences, and paragraphs 4 and 5, which concern services rendered by independent contractors from a fixed base. Article 10 deals with the taxation of dividends received by a resident of a Contracting State from sources in another Contracting State. Paragraph 1 provides that dividends may be taxed in the State of residence, while paragraph 2 provides that dividends may be taxed in the State of source, but at a limited rate. The term "dividends" is defined in paragraph 3 as generally including the distribution of corporate profits among shareholders. As noted in paragraph 3 of the OECD Commentary, "from the shareholders' point of view, dividends are income from capital which they have provided to the company as shareholders". Paragraph 4 provides that paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply to dividends attributable to a permanent establishment of the recipient in the State of source, while paragraph 5 generally prevents a Contracting State from taxing dividends paid by a company resident in another State, except where the shareholder is a resident of the State levying the tax or where the dividends are attributable to a permanent establishment of the recipient in that State.
B. Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 10
Paragraph 1
2. This paragraph, which reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention, provides that dividends may be taxed in the State of residence of the beneficial owner. However, it does not provide that dividends may be taxed exclusively in that State and therefore leaves open the possibility of taxation by the State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident, that is, the State in which the dividends arise (the State of source). When the United Nations Model Convention was first considered, many members of the Group from developing countries expressed the view that dividends should, in principle, be taxable only in the State of source. According to their position, if both the State of residence and the State of source have the right to tax, the State of residence should grant a full tax credit, irrespective of the amount of foreign tax absorbed, and, where appropriate, a tax sparing credit. One of these members of the Group emphasized that there was no need for a developing country to waive or reduce withholding tax on dividends, particularly if it provided tax incentives and other concessions. However, the Group agreed that dividends may be taxed by the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident. Current treaty practice between developing and developed countries generally reflects this agreed position. Double taxation is eliminated or reduced through a combination of exemption from tax or tax credits in the State of residence and reduced withholding tax rates in the State of source.
3. According to the Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention:
7. […] The term "paid" has a very wide meaning, since the concept of payment means the fulfilment of the obligation to place funds at the disposal of the shareholder in the manner prescribed by contract or customary practice.
8. The Article deals only with dividends paid by a company which is a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State. It therefore does not apply to dividends paid by a company which is a resident of a third State, or to dividends paid by a company which is a resident of a Contracting State and attributable to a permanent establishment which an enterprise of that State has in the territory of the other Contracting State […].
Paragraph 2
4. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention, with certain modifications explained below.
5. The OECD Model Convention limits tax in the State of source to 5 per cent under subparagraph a) for direct investment dividends and to 15 per cent under subparagraph b) for portfolio investment dividends, whereas the United Nations Model Convention leaves it possible for these rates to be established in the course of bilateral negotiations.
6. In addition, the minimum ownership required for direct investment dividends is reduced in subparagraph (a) from 25 per cent to 10 per cent. However, the 10 per cent threshold defining the shareholding required to qualify as a direct investment is given only by way of illustration. At the last consideration of this issue, the former Group of Experts decided to replace "25 per cent" with "10 per cent" in subparagraph (a) as the minimum percentage of capital required for the status of direct investment dividends, since in some developing countries a 50 per cent ownership limit is imposed on non-residents, and 10 per cent represents a substantial part of the permitted ownership share. However, in the course of the 2017 Update, the current Committee of Experts considered that 25 per cent was a more appropriate threshold for direct investments in accordance with the OECD Model Convention.
6.1 In addition, in accordance with the changes to the recommendations contained in the OECD/G20 Final Report on Action 6 (Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances), the Committee considered that, in order to prevent abuse of the reduced withholding rate for direct investment dividends, a 365-day holding-period requirement should be included in subparagraph (a). The requirement to hold the shares for 365 days may be fulfilled either at the time the dividends are paid or after the payment of the dividends. The 2017 OECD Model Convention Commentary contains the following excerpt:
16. Prior to 2017, paragraph 17 of the Commentary on the Article provided that "the reduction provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 should not be granted in cases of abuse of this provision, for example, where a company holding less than 25 per cent of the shares increased its holding shortly before the dividends were paid, primarily for the purpose of obtaining the benefits of the above-mentioned provision, or in other cases where the qualifying holding was created primarily for the purpose of obtaining the reduction". Such abuses were addressed in the Final Report on Action 6 of the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Project. As a result of that report, subparagraph a) was amended to limit its application to situations where the company receiving the dividends directly owns at least 25 per cent of the capital of the company paying the dividends for a period of 365 days that includes the day of payment of the dividends. However, this subparagraph also provides that, in calculating this period, changes in ownership that are the direct result of a corporate reorganization, such as a merger or division, shall not be taken into account. In addition, the addition of Article 29 will address other abuses aimed at obtaining the benefits provided for in subparagraph a).
7. The former Group of Experts did not reach agreement on the maximum tax rates permissible in the State of source. Members of the Group from developing countries, who generally preferred the principle of taxing dividends exclusively in the State of source, considered that the rates prescribed in the OECD Model Convention would result in excessive losses of tax revenue for the State of source. Furthermore, notwithstanding their agreement with the principle of taxation in the State of residence of the beneficial owner, they nevertheless considered that any reduction in withholding tax in the State of source would benefit the foreign investor rather than the treasury of the country of which the beneficial owner was a resident; this could occur when the traditional tax credit method was applied, if such a reduction resulted in the aggregate tax rate in the State of source falling below the rate in the State of residence of the beneficial owner.
8. The former Group of Experts put forward certain considerations that may serve as guidance for countries in negotiating rates of taxation of direct investment dividends in the State of source. If a developed country (of residence) uses a credit system, treaty negotiations may be directed towards determining a withholding tax rate at source which, when combined with the basic corporate income tax rate of the State of source, would produce an aggregate effective rate not exceeding the tax rate of the State of residence. In considering the positions of the parties, it may also be relevant whether the State of residence grants credits for taxes not collected by the State of source under a tax incentive programme. If a developed country uses the exemption method to avoid double taxation, it may seek during bilateral negotiations to limit withholding rates on the grounds that: (a) the exemption itself emphasizes the concept of not taxing inter-company dividends, and limiting withholding rates at source would be consistent with this concept; and (b) the exemption and the resulting departure from tax neutrality in domestic investments benefit the international investor, and limiting withholding rates at source, which also benefits the investor, would be consistent with this aspect of the exemption.
9. Both the State of source and the State of residence should be able to tax dividends on portfolio investment holdings, although, given the relatively small volume of portfolio investments and their apparently less important significance compared with direct investments, issues concerning the tax treatment of such dividends will in some cases give rise to less intensive discussion. The former Group of Experts decided not to recommend a maximum rate, since States of source may differ in their views regarding the importance of portfolio investments and the relevant figures.
10. In 1999, it was noted that treaty practice between developed and developing countries in recent years provided an indication of the level of withholding tax rates on direct and portfolio investments. Traditionally, withholding tax rates on dividends under treaties between developed and developing countries had been higher than those under treaties between developed countries. Thus, whereas the OECD rates for direct and portfolio investments were 5 per cent and 15 per cent, respectively, rates under treaties between developed and developing countries traditionally ranged from 5 per cent to 15 per cent for direct investment dividends and from 15 per cent to 25 per cent for portfolio dividends. Some developing countries consider that short-term losses in tax revenue resulting from low withholding tax rates at source are justified by an increase in the volume of foreign investment in the medium and long term. Thus, a number of modern treaties between developed and developing countries provide for rates in accordance with the OECD Model Convention for direct investments, and in some treaties they are even lower.
11. In addition, certain special features have emerged in treaties between developed and developing countries: (a) tax rates in the two countries may differ, with higher rates being permitted in the developing country; (b) tax rates may be entirely unrestricted; (c) reduced rates may apply only to income from new investments; (d) minimum rates or tax exemptions may apply only to preferred types of investment (for example, "industrial projects" or "innovative investments"); and (e) dividends may be taxed at reduced rates only if the shares have been held for a specified period. In treaties of countries that have adopted an imputation system for taxing corporate income (that is, the inclusion of corporate tax in the tax on a company's income imposed on the shareholder or in personal income tax), instead of the classical system of taxation (that is, separate taxation of the shareholder and the company), special provisions may ensure that imputation credits and tax exemptions granted to domestic shareholders are also extended to shareholders who are residents of another Contracting State.
12. Although rates are determined wholly or partly on the basis of considerations concerning the overall balance of a particular bilateral tax treaty, the following technical factors are often taken into account when establishing rates:
(a) the corporate tax system in the State of source (that is, the extent to which the country applies an integrated or classical system) and the overall amount of tax on distributed profits of the company resulting from the application of that system;
(b) the extent to which the State of residence grants a credit for tax on dividends and on the underlying profits against its own tax, and the overall tax burden on the taxpayer after taking account of relief in both countries;
(c) the extent to which a tax credit in the State of residence is granted in respect of the amount of tax saved in the State of source;
(d) the achievement, from the point of view of the State of source, of a satisfactory balance between increased tax revenue and the attraction of foreign investment.
13. The 2010 OECD Model Convention Commentary contains the following excerpts:
11. If a partnership is treated as a legal person under the domestic law applicable to it, the two Contracting States may agree to amend subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 so that the benefits of the reduced rate granted to parent companies are also extended to such a partnership.
12. The beneficial ownership requirement was introduced into paragraph 2 of Article 10 in order to clarify the meaning of the words "paid… to a resident" as used in paragraph 1 of this Article. It follows clearly from this that the State of source is not obliged to relinquish its right to tax dividends merely because the income was immediately received by a resident of a State with which the State of source has concluded a Convention. The term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense; rather, it should be interpreted in its context and in the light of the object and purpose of the Convention, including the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion.
12.1 Where an item of income is received by a resident of one Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, it would be inconsistent with the object and purpose of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or exemption solely because the immediate recipient of the income is a resident of the other Contracting State. In this situation, the immediate recipient of the income meets the criteria for residence, but, as a result of that status, the possibility of double taxation does not arise, since such recipient is not considered the owner of the income for tax purposes in the State of residence. It would be equally inconsistent with the object and purpose of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or exemption where a resident of one of the Contracting States, other than in an agency or nominee relationship, merely acts as a conduit for another person who is the actual beneficial owner of the income concerned. For these reasons, the report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs entitled "Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Conduit Companies"33 concluded that a conduit company cannot normally be regarded as the beneficial owner if, although it is the formal owner, it has in practice very limited powers which make it, in relation to the income concerned, a mere fiduciary or administrator acting on behalf of the interested parties.
_____________
33 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at p. R(6)-1.
12.2 Provided that the other conditions laid down in this Article are satisfied, the limitation of tax in the State of source continues to apply where there is an intermediary between the beneficial owner and the payer, for example, an agent or nominee, provided that the beneficial owner is a resident of the other Contracting State.
13. The tax rates established in this Article in respect of taxes in the State of source are maximum rates. States may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, agree on lower rates or even agree that taxation shall take place exclusively in the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident. The reduction in rates provided for in paragraph 2 applies only to the taxation of dividends and not to the taxation of the profits of the company paying those dividends.
13.1 Under the domestic law of many States, pension funds and other similar organizations are generally exempt from tax on investment income. In order to achieve neutral treatment of domestic and foreign investments made by such organizations, some States provide on a bilateral basis that income, including dividends, received by such an organization resident in another State is exempt from taxation at source. States wishing to follow this approach may agree on a bilateral basis to a provision worded in a manner corresponding to the provision contained in paragraph 69 of the Commentary on Article 18.
13.2 Similarly, some States refrain from imposing tax on dividends paid in other States to certain of their wholly owned subsidiaries, at least to the extent that such dividends are attributable to activities of a governmental nature. Some States are able to grant such a tax exemption in accordance with their interpretation of the principle of sovereign immunity (see paragraphs 6.38 and 6.39 of the Commentary on Article 1), while others do so under the provisions of their domestic law. States wishing to follow this approach may confirm or clarify the scope of these benefits in their bilateral conventions or grant such an exemption in cases where it cannot be granted on other grounds. This may be done by adding an additional paragraph to the Article along the following lines:
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 2, dividends referred to in paragraph 1 shall be taxable only in the Contracting State of which the recipient is a resident if the beneficial owner of such dividends is the State, or a political subdivision or local authority thereof.
14. The two Contracting States may also agree during bilateral negotiations to [reduce the percentage shareholding required for direct investment dividends]. A reduction in the percentage shareholding is justified, for example, in cases where the State of which the parent company is a resident, under its domestic law, grants that company an exemption from tax on dividends received in respect of a holding of less than 25 per cent in a non-resident subsidiary.
15. In subparagraph a) of paragraph 2, the term "capital" is used for […] [determining the minimum ownership required for direct investment dividends]. The use of this term in this context means that, for the purposes of subparagraph a), it should be used in the same sense as it is used for the purposes of distributing dividends to a shareholder (in particular, a parent company).
a) Therefore, as a general rule, the term "capital" in subparagraph a) should be interpreted in the same sense as under company law. Other elements, in particular reserves, are not taken into account.
b) Capital within the meaning of company law should be stated as the nominal value of all shares, which in most cases is reflected as capital in the company's balance sheet.
c) Differences relating to different classes of issued shares (ordinary shares, preference shares, shares carrying multiple voting rights, non-voting shares, bearer shares, registered shares, etc.) should not be taken into account, since these differences relate more to the nature of the shareholder's rights than to the shareholder's ownership interest in the capital.
d) If a loan or other contribution to a company does not, strictly speaking, constitute capital under company law, but under domestic law or practice ("thin capitalization" or the treatment of a loan as share capital) the income received in respect of such loan or contribution is treated as a dividend within the meaning of Article 10, the value of such loan or contribution shall also be treated as "capital" for the purposes of subparagraph a).
e) In the case of structures that do not have capital within the meaning of company law, capital for the purposes of subparagraph a) shall be regarded as the aggregate of all contributions to that structure which are taken into account for the purposes of distributing profits.
In the course of bilateral negotiations, the Contracting States may depart from the "capital" criterion used in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 and use the "voting rights" criterion instead.
13.1 Treaties concluded before the 2017 Update will not include the new time threshold until they are renegotiated bilaterally or modified under the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting. Accordingly, the following excerpts from the 2010 OECD Model Commentary remain relevant for some treaties:
16. Subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 does not require that the company receiving the dividends must necessarily have owned at least [25] per cent of the capital for a relatively long period before the distribution. This means that, in respect of the shareholding, only the situation prevailing at the time relevant for the creation of the tax liability to which paragraph 2 applies is taken into account, that is, in most cases, the situation existing at the time when the dividends legally become available to the shareholders. The main reason for this is the desire to make the provision as broadly applicable as possible. A requirement that the parent company hold a minimum shareholding for a specified period before the distribution of profits may necessitate extensive information gathering. The domestic law of some OECD member countries provides for a minimum period during which the recipient company must own the shares in order to qualify for an exemption from tax or a tax credit in respect of the dividends received. Accordingly, the Contracting States may include a similar condition in their conventions.
17. The reduction provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 should not be granted in cases of abuse of this provision, for example, where a company holding less than [25] per cent increased its shareholding shortly before the payment of dividends primarily for the purpose of obtaining the benefits of the above-mentioned provision, or where a qualifying shareholding is created primarily for the purpose of obtaining such a reduction. In order to counter such arrangements, the Contracting States may consider it necessary to supplement subparagraph a) with the following provision:
provided that this holding was not acquired primarily for the purpose of obtaining the benefits provided for in this provision.
13.2. The 2010 OECD Commentary, relating to treaties concluded before and after the 2017 Update, states as follows:
18. Paragraph 2 does not specify the tax treatment in the State of source. It therefore leaves that State free to apply its own legislation and, in particular, to levy tax either by withholding at source or by separate assessment.
19. This paragraph does not regulate procedural matters. Each State should be able to apply the procedures provided for under its own legislation. It may either limit the tax immediately to the rates specified in this Article or levy the full amount of tax followed by a refund of the excess […]. Specific issues arise in cases involving three parties (see paragraph 71 of the Commentary on Article 24).
20. It is not specified whether tax relief in the State of source may be conditional upon the dividends being taxed in the State of residence. This issue may be settled in the course of bilateral negotiations.
21. The Article contains no provisions on how the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident should take into account taxation in the State of source of the dividends. This issue is dealt with in Articles 23A and 23B.
22. The following example is commonly given: the beneficial owner of dividends arising in a Contracting State is a company resident in the other Contracting State; its capital is wholly or partly owned by shareholders who are not residents of that other State; it does not normally distribute its profits in the form of dividends; it enjoys a favourable tax regime (a private investment company, a base company). The question may arise whether it is justified to limit the tax in the State of source of the dividends in respect of such a company, as provided for in paragraph 2. It may be advisable to agree on special exceptions to the taxation rule laid down in this Article during bilateral negotiations in order to determine the tax treatment applicable to such companies.
Paragraph 3
14. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 3 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention. The relevant part of the 2010 OECD Model Convention Commentary reads as follows:
23. In view of the considerable differences between the laws of OECD member countries, it is impossible to give a complete and exhaustive definition of the term "dividends". Consequently, the definition merely mentions examples found in the legislation of most member countries, which, in any event, are not interpreted differently in those countries. Their list is incorporated into a general formula. During the revision of the draft Convention of 1963, a thorough study was carried out with a view to finding a solution that did not involve a reference to domestic law. As a result of this study, it was concluded that, in view of the continuing differences between member countries in the fields of company law and tax law, it appeared impossible to formulate a definition of the term "dividends" independently of domestic laws. The Contracting States may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, take into account the particular features of their laws and agree to include in the definition of "dividends" other payments made by companies covered by this Article.
24. The concept of "dividends" is mainly associated with the distribution of funds by companies within the meaning of subparagraph b) of paragraph 1 of Article 3. Accordingly, the definition primarily concerns the distribution of profits in respect of which ownership rights are represented by shares, that is, ownership of an interest in a company with liability limited by shares (a joint-stock company). In this definition, shares include all securities issued by a company that confer a right to participate in the profits of the company without constituting debt-claims; these include, for example, actions de jouissance or droits de jouissance, founders' shares or other rights to participate in profits. In bilateral conventions, this list may, of course, be amended in accordance with the legal particularities of the Contracting States concerned. This may be necessary, in particular, in relation to income from actions de jouissance and founders' shares. On the other hand, debt-claims participating in profits are not included in this category […]; likewise, convertible bonds do not constitute dividends.
25. Article 10 applies not only to dividends as such, but also to interest on loans to the extent that the lender effectively participates in the risks of the company, that is, where repayment depends to a considerable extent on the successful or unsuccessful operations of the enterprise. Therefore, Articles 10 and 11 allow this type of interest to be treated as dividends under domestic thin capitalization rules applied in the borrower State. The question of whether the lender shares in the risks of the enterprise must be decided in each particular case, taking into account all the circumstances, for example, the following:
— the loan substantially exceeds any other contributions to the capital of the enterprise (or was taken out to replace a substantial part of lost capital) and is, to a considerable extent, not matched by realizable assets;
— the lender will participate in any profits of the company;
— repayment of the loan ranks after the claims of other creditors or the payment of dividends;
— the amount or payment of interest will depend on the profits of the company;
— the loan agreement contains no definitive provisions for repayment by a specified date.
26. The legislation of many States treats interests in société à responsabilité limitée (limited liability companies) as equivalent to shares. Similarly, distributions of profits by cooperative societies are generally treated as dividends.
27. Distributions of profits by partnerships do not constitute dividends within the meaning of this definition, except for partnerships to which, in the State in which their place of effective management is situated, a tax regime substantially similar to that applicable to joint-stock companies is applied [for example, in Belgium, Portugal and Spain, and in France in the case of distributions to commanditaires (limited partners) in a société en commandite simple (limited partnership)]. On the other hand, clarifications may be required in bilateral conventions in cases where the tax law of one of the Contracting States gives the owner of a shareholding in a company the right, under certain conditions, to elect to be taxed as a partner in a partnership or, conversely, gives a partner in a partnership the right to elect to be taxed as a shareholder in a company.
28. Payments considered to be dividends may include not only distributions of profits decided upon at the annual general meeting of shareholders, but also other monetary or equivalent payments, such as additional payments in the form of shares, bonuses, profits on liquidation or hidden distributions of profits. The benefits provided for in this Article apply to the extent that the State of which the paying company is a resident taxes such additional payments as dividends. It is immaterial whether such additional amounts are paid out of current profits earned by the company or are derived, for example, from reserves, that is, profits of previous financial years. As a general rule, a distribution of funds by a company that results in a reduction of participation rights, for example, payments representing a repayment of capital in any form whatsoever, is not treated as a dividend.
29. Additional payments to which a shareholding in a company gives entitlement are generally received only by the shareholders themselves. However, if any such additional payments are received by persons who are not shareholders within the meaning of company law, they may constitute dividends if:
— the legal relationship between such persons and the company is equivalent to ownership of shares in the company ("hidden shareholding"); and
— the persons receiving such additional payments are closely related to the shareholder; this applies, for example, where the recipient is a relative of the shareholder or a company belonging to the same group as the company holding the shares.
30. If the shareholder and the person receiving such additional payments are residents of two different States with which the State of source has concluded tax conventions, disagreements may arise as to which of these conventions is applicable in the particular case. A similar problem may arise if the State of source has a convention with one of the States but not with the other. However, this conflict may also affect other types of income, and its resolution should be sought through agreements under the mutual agreement procedure.
Paragraph 4
15. This paragraph, under which paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply to dividends in respect of shares that are effectively connected with a permanent establishment or a fixed base of the recipient in the State of source, reproduces paragraph 4 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention, except that the United Nations Model Convention refers to a company rendering services through an independent contractor from a fixed base. The OECD Commentary notes that paragraph 4 does not recognize the "force of attraction" rule, which would permit the taxation of dividends as business profits if the recipient has a permanent establishment or a fixed base in the State of source, irrespective of whether the shareholding is connected with the permanent establishment or not. Rather, this paragraph permits the taxation of dividends as business profits only "[…] if they are paid in respect of a shareholding which forms part of the assets of the permanent establishment or is otherwise effectively connected with that establishment […]”.34
_____________________
34 Paragraph 31 of the OECD Commentary on Article 10.
The OECD Commentary also notes:
32. It has been suggested that this paragraph may lead to abuse through the transfer of shares to permanent establishments created solely for this purpose in countries offering a favourable tax regime for dividend income. Apart from the fact that such improper transactions may provide grounds for the application of domestic anti-abuse rules, it should be recognized that a particular place may constitute a permanent establishment only if business activities are carried on there, and that the requirement that the shareholding be "effectively connected" with such a place must be satisfied in order for the shareholding to be considered effectively connected with those business activities.
Paragraph 5
16. This paragraph, which prohibits a Contracting State from taxing dividends paid by a company resident in another State solely on the ground that the company derives income or profits in the State levying the tax, reproduces paragraph 5 of Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention, except for the reference to the "main base" in the United Nations Model Convention. The OECD Commentary states as follows:
33. This Article deals only with dividends paid by a company which is a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other State. Some States, however, tax not only dividends paid by companies which are residents of those States, but even the distribution by a non-resident company of profits generated in their territory. Each State is, of course, entitled to tax profits generated in its territory by non-resident companies to the extent provided for in the Convention (in particular, in Article 7). The shareholders of such companies should at least not be subject to the same tax at any rate, except where they are residents of that State and are, naturally, subject to its fiscal sovereignty.
34. Paragraph 5 prohibits the extraterritorial taxation of dividends, that is, the practice whereby States tax dividends distributed by a non-resident company solely because the profits out of which the distribution is made arose in their territory (for example, were realized through a permanent establishment situated there). Of course, the question of extraterritorial taxation does not arise if the State in which the company's profits arise taxes the dividends because they are paid to a shareholder who is a resident of that State or to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] situated in that State.
35. Furthermore, it may be argued that such a provision is not intended to, and cannot, prevent a State from withholding tax at source on dividends distributed by foreign companies if they are paid in cash within its territory. Indeed, in this case, the criterion for the tax liability is the fact that the dividends are paid, rather than the origin of the profits distributed by the company. However, if the person receiving dividends in cash in one Contracting State is a resident of the other Contracting State (which is also the State of residence of the company paying the dividends), that person may, under Article 21, obtain an exemption from tax at source or a refund of that tax in the first State. Similarly, if the beneficial owner of the dividends is a resident of a third State which has concluded a tax convention with the State in which the dividends are paid in cash, that person may, under Article 21 of that Convention, obtain an exemption from tax at source or a refund of that tax in the latter State.
36. Paragraph 5 further provides that non-resident companies shall not be subject to special taxes on undistributed profits.
37. It might be objected that if the country of which the taxpayer is a resident seeks to tax undistributed profits under its controlled foreign company legislation or other rules having a similar effect, it acts contrary to the provisions of paragraph 5. It should, however, be noted that this paragraph is limited to taxation at source and therefore does not concern taxation in the State of residence under corresponding legislation or rules. Moreover, this paragraph concerns only the taxation of the company, not the shareholder.
38. The application of such legislation or rules may, however, complicate the application of Article 23. If income is attributed to the taxpayer, each item of income must be considered under the relevant provisions of the Convention (business profits, interest, royalties). If the amount is treated as a deemed dividend, it is obviously derived from the base company and is therefore income from the country of that company. Even in that case, it is far from clear whether the taxable amount should be treated as a dividend within the meaning of Article 10 or as "other income" within the meaning of Article 21. Some of these laws or rules provide that the taxable amount should be treated as a dividend, with the result that an exemption from tax under a tax convention, for example, an exemption for a branch, also applies to it. It is unclear whether the Convention requires this. If the State of residence considers that this is not the case, it may be accused of preventing the normal application of the branch exemption rule by taxing the dividend (in the form of a "deemed dividend") in advance.
39. If dividends are actually distributed by the base company, the provisions of the bilateral convention concerning dividends must be applied in the usual manner, since this is dividend income within the meaning of the provisions of the Convention. Thus, the country of the base company may apply withholding tax at source to this dividend. The country of which the shareholder is a resident will apply the usual methods of eliminating double taxation (that is, granting tax credits or an exemption from tax). This means that withholding tax on dividends must be credited in the State of residence of the shareholder, even if the distributed profits (dividends) were taxed in previous years under controlled foreign company legislation or other rules having a similar effect. However, the obligation to grant a tax credit in this case remains problematic. As a general rule, the dividend itself is exempt from tax (since tax has already been paid on it under the above-mentioned legislation or rules), and it may be argued that there are no grounds for a tax credit. On the other hand, the objectives of the Convention would be frustrated if tax credits could be avoided simply by anticipating the taxation of dividends under corresponding legislation. According to the general principle set out above, a credit should be granted, although the specific details may depend on the technical features of the legislation or rules concerned and the system for crediting foreign taxes against domestic taxes, as well as on the specifics of the particular case (for example, the period elapsed since the taxation of the "deemed dividends"). However, taxpayers resorting to artificial arrangements do so at their own risk, from which the tax authorities cannot fully protect them.
17. It may be noted that the laws of some countries are aimed at avoiding or reducing economic double taxation, that is, the simultaneous taxation of company profits at the company level and dividends at the shareholder level. It may be advisable to consult the detailed discussion of this issue in paragraphs 40–67 of the Commentary on Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention.
Branch Profits Taxes
18. The inclusion of a provision on branch profits taxes in the revised United Nations Model Convention was discussed at meetings of the former Group of Experts in 1987 and 1992. The issue was subsequently discussed at the 1997 meeting (the eighth meeting) of the former Group of Experts, which considered that, since branch profits taxes exist in only a few countries, this paragraph would be better placed in the Commentary rather than in the main text. The inclusion of provisions concerning branch profits taxes in bilateral double taxation conventions would remain at the discretion of the Contracting States during bilateral negotiations. Developing countries generally did not object to the principle of taxing branch profits, even if they did not impose a branch profits tax.
19. Some members of the Group, referring to the justification for branch profits taxation as a means of achieving approximate parity in taxation in the State of source, irrespective of whether business is conducted in that country through a subsidiary or a branch, argued that this principle should be logically applied throughout the Convention. Thus, contrary to paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention, all expenses of a permanent establishment should be deductible as if that permanent establishment were a separate and distinct enterprise dealing with its head office on a fully independent basis.
20. Another member of the Group from a developed country noted that, in that country, this tax was levied in two separate parts: (i) a tax similar to withholding tax on dividends was imposed on the "dividend equivalent amount" of the branch, approximately equal to the amount that would probably have been distributed as dividends if the branch had been a subsidiary; and (ii) a second tax, similar to withholding tax on interest paid by a subsidiary resident in that country to its foreign parent company, was imposed on the excess portion of the interest deducted by the branch in calculating taxable income over the amount of interest actually paid by the branch. The main purpose of this system is to minimize the influence of tax factors on the decision of a foreign investor to operate in that country in the form of a branch or a subsidiary.
21. If one or both Contracting States impose taxes on branch profits, they may include the following provision in the Convention:
Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Convention, where a company which is a resident of one of the Contracting States has a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, the profits taxable under paragraph 1 of Article 7 may be subject to an additional tax in that other State in accordance with its legislation, but the amount of such tax shall not exceed __ per cent of the amount of those profits.
22. The proposed provision does not specify a recommended maximum rate for branch profits. In practice, the rate applied to direct investment dividends is generally used (for example, the tax rate specified in paragraph 2 (a)). At the meeting of the former Group of Experts in 1991, proponents of branch profits taxation agreed that, in terms of the principles supporting this system, the tax rate on branch profits should be the same as the rate on direct investment dividends. However, in a number of treaties, the branch profits tax rate was equal to the tax rate on portfolio investment dividends (which is usually higher), and in some treaties the tax rate for branches was lower than the rate on direct investment dividends. Although the branch profits tax is a tax on business profits, this provision may be included in Article 10 rather than Article 7, since such tax is intended to be analogous to a tax on dividends.
23. This provision permits the application of a branch profits tax only to profits taxable under paragraph 1 of Article 7 in respect of a permanent establishment. Many treaties further restrict the tax base to the amount of such profits "after deducting income tax and other taxes on income levied in that other State". In other treaties, this phrase is omitted because the concept exists in domestic law.
24. At the meeting of the former Group of Experts in 1991, it was noted that a provision on branch profits taxation could potentially conflict with the non-discrimination provision. Since a branch profits tax is usually a second-level tax imposed on foreign companies, which is not imposed on domestic companies carrying on the same activities, it could technically be regarded as prohibited by Article 24 (Non-Discrimination). However, countries imposing this tax do so by analogy with withholding tax on dividends paid by a subsidiary to its foreign parent company, and therefore consider it appropriate to include an express exception in the Article on non-discrimination permitting a branch profits tax. The Article on non-discrimination in a number of treaties containing provisions on branch profits taxes includes the following paragraph:
Nothing in this Article shall be construed as preventing either of the Contracting States from imposing the tax provided for in paragraph ___ [the provision on branch profits tax] of Article 10 (Dividends).
However, the above provision on branch profits tax makes this provision unnecessary, since it applies "notwithstanding any other provisions of this Convention" and therefore takes precedence over other provisions of the Convention, including Article 24 (Non-Discrimination).
25. Some members of the former Group of Experts pointed to the existence of numerous artificial arrangements used for the purpose of obtaining the benefits of the provisions of Article 10 through, among other things, the creation or transfer of shares or other rights on which dividends are paid. Although the substance-over-form principle, the principle of abuse of rights or any similar principles may be applied to counter such practices, Contracting States wishing to address this issue specifically may agree during negotiations to include the following provision in their bilateral tax treaties:
The provisions of this Article shall not apply if the principal purpose or one of the principal purposes of any person concerned with the creation or transfer of the shares or other rights in respect of which dividends are paid was to obtain the benefits of this Article by means of such creation or transfer.
Article 11
INTEREST
A. General Provisions
1. Article 11 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces the provisions of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention, with the exception of paragraphs 2 and 4, which have been amended, and paragraphs 4 and 5, which contain a reference to services provided by an independent contractor from a fixed base.
2. Interest, which, like dividends, constitutes income from movable capital, may be paid to individuals holding deposits in banks or owning savings certificates, private investors who have purchased bonds, private suppliers or trading companies conducting business with deferred payment terms, financial institutions that have granted loans, or institutional investors holding bonds or debt obligations. Interest may also be paid on loans between associated enterprises.
3. At the domestic level, interest is generally deductible in calculating profits. Any tax on interest is payable by the beneficiary, unless a special agreement provides that it is to be paid by the person making the interest payment. Unlike dividends, interest is not subject to taxation either in the hands of the recipient or the payer. If the latter is required to withhold a certain portion of the interest as tax, the amount withheld constitutes an advance payment towards the tax that the beneficiary will be liable to pay on his or her aggregate income or profits for the relevant financial year, and the beneficiary is entitled to deduct this amount from the tax payable and to obtain a refund of any amount by which the tax withheld exceeds the amount of tax finally assessed as payable. This mechanism prevents the beneficiary from being taxed twice on the same interest.
4. At the international level, where the recipient of interest is a resident of one State and the payer of interest is a resident of another State, the interest is subject to taxation in both countries. Such double taxation may result in a substantial reduction in the net amount of interest received by the beneficiary or, if the payer agrees to bear the cost of the tax withheld at source, increase the financial burden on the payer.
5. The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention notes that, although such double taxation may be eliminated by prohibiting the taxation of interest in the source State or the State of residence,
3. A formula providing for the exclusive right to tax interest to one State — either the State of which the beneficiary is a resident or the State of source — may not receive general approval. Accordingly, a compromise solution was adopted.
It provides that interest may be taxed in the State of residence, but leaves the State of source the right to levy tax if this is provided for under its legislation, and this right implies the possibility for the State of source to waive any taxation of interest paid to non-residents. However, the exercise of this right will be limited by the established ceiling on the amount of such tax […]. The losses which the latter may incur in these circumstances will be compensated for by the relief granted by the State of residence in order to take account of the tax paid in the State of source (see Article 23A or Article 23B).
4. Some countries do not allow the deduction of interest paid for the purposes of calculating the payer's taxable income, except where the recipient is a resident of the same State or is subject to tax in that State. In other cases, such deductions are prohibited. The question of whether such deductions should also be permitted where interest is paid by a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of another Contracting State is addressed in paragraph 4 of Article 24.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 11
Paragraph 1
6. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention, the Commentary to which contains the following:
5. Paragraph 1 establishes the principle that interest arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of another Contracting State may be taxed in that other State. At the same time, it does not grant the exclusive right to tax to the State of residence. The term "paid" has a very broad meaning, since the concept of payment means the fulfilment of an obligation to place funds at the disposal of the creditor in the manner prescribed by the contract or customary practice.
6. This Article concerns only interest arising in one of the Contracting States and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State. It therefore does not apply to interest arising in a third State, or to interest arising in a Contracting State and attributable to a permanent establishment which an enterprise of that State has in the other Contracting State […].
Paragraph 2
7. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention with one significant modification. The OECD Model Convention provides that the tax in the State of source "shall not exceed 10 per cent of the gross amount of the interest", whereas the United Nations Model Convention leaves the determination of the percentage to be decided in the course of bilateral negotiations.
8. When this Article was considered by the former Group of Experts, members of the Group from developing countries expressed the view that the State of source should have the exclusive or at least the primary right to tax interest. According to this view, the State of residence is obliged to prevent double taxation of such income by granting an exemption, a tax credit or other relief. These members of the Group considered that interest should be taxed where it is earned, that is, where the capital is used. Some members of the Group from developed countries expressed the view that the investor's country should have the exclusive right to tax interest, since, in their opinion, this would promote capital mobility and grant the right to tax to the country that is better equipped to assess the taxpayer's circumstances. They also noted that exempting foreign interest from tax in the investor's country might not be in the interests of developing countries, since this could encourage investors to invest their capital in a developing country with a minimum tax rate.
9. Members of the Group from developing countries agreed to the solution of taxation by both the State of residence and the State of source, as set out in paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention, but considered the ceiling of 10 per cent of the gross amount of interest specified in paragraph 2 of that Article to be unacceptable. Since the former Group of Experts was unable to reach a general agreement on another maximum rate, this matter was left to be decided in the course of bilateral negotiations.
10. The decision not to recommend a maximum rate of withholding tax at source may be justified by existing treaty practice. The rates of withholding tax at source on interest in tax treaties between developed and developing countries have a wider range than those applicable to dividends — from complete exemption to 25 per cent. However, some developing countries have reduced the rate of withholding tax at source on interest in order to attract foreign investment; some of them have adopted rates at or below the 10 per cent rate proposed by the OECD.
11. When determining the exact rate of withholding tax at source for the State of source, a number of factors should be taken into account, including the following: the origin of the capital in the State of residence; the likelihood that, because of a high rate in the State of source, creditors may pass the cost of the tax on to borrowers, which would mean an increase in the tax revenues of the State of source at the expense of its own residents rather than foreign creditors; the likelihood that a tax rate exceeding the foreign tax credit limit in the State of residence may discourage investors; the fact that a reduction in the withholding tax rate at source has consequences for the tax and foreign exchange revenues of the State of source; and the principal direction of interest flows (for example, from developing to developed countries).
12. In the course of negotiations on bilateral treaties providing for a general positive rate of withholding tax at source on interest, a reduction in the ceiling or even an exemption from tax is sometimes agreed upon in respect of one or more of the following categories of interest:
(a) interest paid to Governments or public institutions;
(b) interest guaranteed by Governments or public institutions;
(c) interest paid to central banks;
(d) interest paid to banks or other financial institutions;
(e) interest on long-term loans;
(f) interest on loans for the financing of special equipment or public works; or
(g) interest on other types of investment approved by the Government (for example, export financing).
In the case of bank loans and loans granted by financial institutions, the main justification for reducing the rate is the high cost of such loans, particularly the cost of their financing. Since withholding tax at source is levied on a gross basis, it has a high effective rate. If the effective rate is higher than the general tax rate in the country of which the creditor is a resident, the tax burden is often shifted to the borrower through a gross-up clause in the loan agreement. In this case, the tax levied at source is equivalent to an additional tax on residents of the State of source. One way of resolving this problem is to allow the creditor to treat such income as business profits under Article 7, but this approach gives rise to calculation difficulties and administrative issues for banks and tax authorities.
13. A similar justification exists for reducing rates in respect of interest on credit sales. In such cases, the supplier often simply passes on to the purchaser, without charging any additional amount, the cost which the supplier had to pay to a bank or export financing agency for financing the relevant credit. For a person selling equipment on credit, interest represents to a greater extent an element of the selling price than income from invested capital.
14. Furthermore, long-term loans correspond to investments which must be sufficiently profitable to be repaid in instalments over a specified period. In the latter case, interest must be paid out of the proceeds at the same time as instalments towards repayment of the loan principal. Consequently, any excessive tax burden on such interest may be transferred to the book value of capital goods purchased on credit, as a result of which the tax levied on interest may ultimately lead to a reduction in the amount of tax payable on the profits earned by the user of such capital goods.
15. At a meeting of the former Group of Experts in 1991, some members of the Group argued that interest income received by public institutions should be exempt from taxation in the State of source, since such an exemption would facilitate the financing of development projects, particularly in developing countries, by excluding tax issues from negotiations on interest rates. Some members of the Group from developing countries argued that the financing of such projects would increase even further if interest income were also exempt from taxation in the country of which the creditor is a resident.
16. In treaty practice, the exemption of government interest from taxation in the State of source predominates, but there are various technical details in this regard. In some cases, interest income is exempt from tax if it is paid by or to the State; in other cases, only interest paid to the State is exempt. Furthermore, the definition of the term "State" also varies and may include, for example, local authorities, institutions, agencies, central banks and financial institutions owned by the Government.
17. The former Group of Experts noted that long-term loans often require special guarantees because of the difficulties involved in long-term political, economic and monetary forecasting. In addition, most developed countries, in order to ensure full employment in their capital goods manufacturing industries or public works enterprises, adopt various measures to promote long-term loans, including credit insurance or reductions in interest rates by public institutions. These measures may take the form of direct loans from public institutions linked to loans from private banks, or private lending, or more favourable interest payment terms than those applicable to loans granted on the money market. These measures are unlikely to continue to be applied if the benefits are effectively cancelled or reduced as a result of excessive taxation in the debtor country. Thus, not only should interest on loans granted by the Government be exempt from tax, but there are also grounds for exempting interest on long-term loans granted by private banks where such loans are guaranteed or refinanced by the Government or a public institution.
18. The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention contains the following provisions:
9. The requirement of beneficial ownership was introduced in paragraph 2 of Article 11 in order to clarify the meaning of the words "paid to a resident" as used in paragraph 1 of that Article. It follows clearly from this that the State of source is not obliged to relinquish its right to tax dividends merely because the income was immediately received by a resident of a State with which the State of source has concluded a Convention. The term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense; rather, it should be interpreted in context and in the light of the aims and purposes of the Convention, including the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion.
10. Tax relief or exemption in respect of an item of income is granted by the State of source to a resident of another Contracting State in order to wholly or partly avoid the double taxation that could arise as a result of the simultaneous taxation of that income by the State of residence. If an item of income is received by a resident of one Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, it would be inconsistent with the aims and purposes of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or exemption merely because the immediate recipient of the income has the status of a resident of another Contracting State. In this situation, the immediate recipient of the income meets the criteria for residence, but, as a result of that status, the possibility of double taxation does not arise, since such recipient is not regarded as the owner of the income for tax purposes in the State of residence. It would be equally inconsistent with the aims and purposes of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or exemption where a resident of one of the Contracting States, other than in the context of an agency or nominee relationship, merely acts as a conduit for another person who is in fact the beneficial owner of the income in question. For these reasons, the report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs entitled "Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Conduit Companies"35 concluded that a conduit company cannot normally be regarded as the beneficial owner if, although it is the formal owner, it has in practice very limited powers which make it, in respect of the income concerned, merely a fiduciary or administrator acting on behalf of the interested parties.
35 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, p. R (6)-1.
11. Subject to compliance with the other conditions laid down in this Article, the limitation of tax in the State of source continues to apply where there is an intermediary, such as an agent or a nominee, between the beneficial owner and the payer, provided that the beneficial owner is a resident of the other Contracting State (in 1995, an amendment was made to the text of the Model Convention to clarify this point, on which a consensus position was reached by all member countries). States wishing to clarify this provision may do so in the course of bilateral negotiations.
12. This paragraph does not specify the method of taxation in the State of source. It therefore leaves that State free to apply its own legislation and, in particular, to levy tax either by withholding at source or by separate assessment. Procedural matters are not addressed in this Article. Each State should be able to apply the procedure provided for under its legislation […].
13. It is not specified whether tax relief in the State of source should be conditional upon the interest being subject to taxation in the State of residence or not. This issue may be resolved in the course of bilateral negotiations.
14. This Article contains no provisions on how the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident should take into account the taxation of interest in the State of source. This issue is addressed in Articles 23A and 23B.
Paragraph 3
19. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 3 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention. The relevant part of the Commentary on the 2010 OECD Model Convention reads as follows:
18. Paragraph 3 defines the meaning of the term "interest" for the purposes of the tax treatment determined by this Article. This term generally means income from debt-claims of every kind, whether or not secured by mortgage and whether or not carrying a right to participate in profits. The term "debt-claims of every kind" clearly covers cash deposits, cash collateral and government securities, as well as bonds and debentures, although the latter three types are specifically mentioned because of their importance and certain characteristics which may be peculiar to them. On the one hand, it is recognized that interest on mortgages falls within the category of income from movable capital (revenus de capitaux mobiliers), even though some countries treat it as income from immovable property. On the other hand, debt-claims, particularly bonds and debentures, carrying a right to participate in the debtor's profits are nevertheless regarded as loans if the general character of the contract clearly indicates that it is an interest-bearing loan.
19. Interest on profit-participating bonds is generally not regarded as dividends, nor is interest on convertible bonds, until such time as they are actually converted into shares. However, interest on such bonds should be regarded as dividends if the loan effectively participates in the risks of the debtor company […]. In cases of presumed thin capitalization, it is sometimes difficult to distinguish between dividends and interest, and, in order to avoid duplication of the categories of income provided for in Article 10 and Article 11 respectively, it should be noted that the term "interest", as used in Article 11, does not cover items of income provided for in Article 10.
20. With regard, in particular, to government securities, as well as bonds and debentures, the text clarifies that premiums and incentive payments in connection with them constitute interest. In general, the interest on debt securities which may properly be taxed as such in the State of source is everything paid by the issuing institution in excess of the amount paid by the subscriber, that is, accrued interest plus any premium paid on redemption or issue. It follows that, where a bond or debenture is issued at a premium, the difference by which the amount paid by the subscriber exceeds the amount repaid to that subscriber may constitute negative interest, which must be deducted from the taxable amount of interest. On the other hand, any gain or loss realized by the holder of such a security through its sale to another person does not fall within the concept of interest. Depending on the circumstances, such gain or loss may constitute business profits or losses, a capital gain or loss, or income falling within the scope of Article 21.
21. Furthermore, the definition of interest given in the first sentence of paragraph 3 is, in principle, exhaustive. It was decided that it would be preferable not to include an additional reference to domestic law in the text, for the following reasons:
a) the definition covers practically all types of income regarded as interest under various domestic laws;
b) the wording used is more legally reliable and ensures that future amendments to the domestic law of any country will not affect the operation of the Conventions;
c) references to domestic law should be avoided as far as possible in the Model Convention.
Nevertheless, it is still envisaged that, in a bilateral Convention, the two Contracting States may extend the wording set out above and include any income that is taxed as interest under either of their domestic laws but does not fall within the definition, and in these circumstances they may prefer to make a reference to their domestic law.
21.1 The definition of interest given in the first sentence of paragraph 3 generally does not apply to payments made under certain types of non-traditional financial instruments that are not based on debt (for example, an interest rate swap). However, this definition applies to the extent that a loan is deemed to exist under the principle of "substance over form", the principle of "abuse of rights" or any other similar principle.
19.1 Furthermore, in a number of countries, certain non-traditional financial arrangements are treated as debt relationships under domestic law, even though they are not loans in their legal form. The definition of interest set out in paragraph 3 applies to payments made under such financial arrangements.
19.2 The above applies, for example, to Islamic financial instruments in cases where, in economic substance, the contract concluded using such an instrument constitutes a loan (even if it is not a loan in legal form). This may be illustrated by examples of such contracts as "murabaha", "istisna", certain forms of "mudaraba" and "musharaka" contracts (that is, deposit accounts with profit accrual and diminishing "musharaka") and "ijara" (in cases where such a contract is treated as a financial lease), as well as "sukuk" concluded on the basis of such instruments36.
36 The Committee decided to include more detailed information on such instruments in the next edition of the United Nations Manual for the Negotiation of Bilateral Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries.
19.3 Countries which do not have the above-mentioned instruments in their domestic legislation and which generally apply, in substance, an economic approach to taxation issues may nevertheless apply the definition of interest to payments made under these instruments. Conversely, such countries, as well as countries which adhere to a strictly legal approach to taxation issues, may expressly refer to such instruments when defining interest in the Convention. This may be done by inserting the following wording after the first sentence:
This term also includes income from financial arrangements such as Islamic financial instruments where the underlying contract may in substance be classified as a loan.
19.4 It is clear, however, that the above does not apply to Islamic financial instruments where the contract, in its economic substance, cannot be classified as a loan.
19.5 The OECD Commentary then contains the following:
22. The second sentence of paragraph 3 excludes penalties for late payment from the definition of interest, but the Contracting States may omit this sentence and treat such payments as interest in their bilateral Conventions. Penalties imposed under a contract by customs authorities or by court decision constitute payments calculated either in proportion to periods of delay or at a fixed amount; in some cases, they may combine both forms. Even if they are determined in proportion to periods of delay (pro rata temporis), they constitute not so much income from capital as a special form of compensation for losses incurred by the creditor as a result of the debtor's delay in fulfilling its obligations. Moreover, for reasons of legal certainty and practical convenience, it is desirable that all penalties of this kind, in whatever form they are paid, be treated in the same manner. On the other hand, the two Contracting States may exclude from the scope of Article 11 any types of interest which they intend to treat as dividends.
23. Finally, the question arises as to whether annuities should be treated as interest; it is considered that they should not. On the one hand, annuities paid as compensation for past employment are specified in Article 18 and are subject to the rules governing pensions. On the other hand, although it is true that periodic payments under purchased annuities include an interest element on the capital invested in their acquisition as well as a return of capital, and thus periodic payments constitute "civil fruits" (fruits civils) accruing from day to day, many countries would find it difficult to distinguish between the element representing income from capital and the element representing a return of capital, solely for the purpose of taxing the income element under the same category as income from movable capital. Tax legislation often contains provisions classifying annuities as salaries and pensions and providing for the corresponding taxes.
Paragraph 4
20. This paragraph, under which paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply to interest if the recipient has a permanent establishment or a fixed base in the State of source, reproduces paragraph 4 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention with two modifications. First, the United Nations Model Convention contains a reference to a fixed base as well as to a permanent establishment. Second, the OECD version applies only where the debt-claim in respect of which the interest is paid is effectively connected with the permanent establishment or fixed base. Since the United Nations Model Convention, unlike the OECD Model Convention, recognizes the limited application of the "force of attraction" rule provided for in Article 7 in defining income that may be taxed as business profits, a corresponding amendment has been made to paragraph 4 of Article 11 of the United Nations Model Convention. Under this amendment, paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 11 do not apply where the debt-claim is effectively connected with a permanent establishment or fixed base, or with the carrying on in the State of source of activities of the same or a similar kind as those carried on through the permanent establishment.
Paragraph 5
21. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 5 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention, which provides that interest arises in the State of which the payer is a resident, except that the United Nations Model Convention contains a reference to a fixed base as well as to a permanent establishment. In 1999, the first sentence of paragraph 5 was amended in accordance with the OECD Model Convention. However, during the discussions, the former Group of Experts agreed that countries could insert a rule identifying the source of interest as the State in which the loan giving rise to that interest was used. If, in the course of bilateral negotiations, the parties hold differing views regarding the appropriate rule, a possible solution may be a rule that generally recognizes the place of residence of the payer as the source of the interest; however, if the loan is used in a State where the "place of use" rule applies, the interest will be deemed to arise in that State. The OECD Commentary on paragraph 5 of Article 11 contains the following:
26. This paragraph establishes the principle that the State of source of interest is the State of which the payer of the interest is a resident. However, it provides for an exception to this rule in the case of an interest-bearing loan which has an evident economic connection with a permanent establishment belonging to the payer in another Contracting State. If the loan was obtained for the needs of that establishment and it pays the interest thereon, this paragraph provides that the source of the interest is located in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is situated, irrespective of the place of residence of the owner of the permanent establishment, even if that owner is a resident of a third State.
27. In the absence of an economic connection between the loan giving rise to the interest and the permanent establishment, the State in which the latter is situated cannot, on this basis, be regarded as the State in which the interest arises; it is not entitled to tax such interest even within a "taxable quota" proportional to the significance of the activities of the permanent establishment. Such a practice would be contrary to paragraph 5. Furthermore, any departure from the rule laid down in the first sentence of paragraph 5 is justified only if the economic connection between the loan and the permanent establishment is sufficiently clear. In this connection, a number of possible cases may be distinguished:
a) The management of the permanent establishment obtains a loan which it uses for the specific needs of that permanent establishment; it records the loan under liabilities and pays interest thereon directly to the creditor.
b) The head office of the enterprise obtains a loan, and the funds received are used exclusively for the purposes of a permanent establishment located in another country. The interest is serviced by the head office but is ultimately borne by that permanent establishment.
c) The head office of the enterprise obtains a loan, and the funds received are used for the needs of several permanent establishments located in different countries.
In cases a) and b), the conditions laid down in the second sentence of paragraph 5 are fulfilled, and the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located should be regarded as the State in which the interest arises. However, case c) falls outside the scope of the provisions of paragraph 5, which do not allow more than one source to be attributed to the same loan. Furthermore, such a solution would give rise to considerable administrative difficulties and would not enable creditors to calculate the tax on such interest in advance. Nevertheless, the two Contracting States are entitled to limit the application of the last provision of paragraph 5 to case a) or to extend it to case c).interest. Nevertheless, the two Contracting States are entitled to limit the application of the last provision of paragraph 5 to case a) or to extend it to case c).
28. Paragraph 5 does not regulate cases excluded from its provisions where both the beneficial owner and the payer are residents of Contracting States, but the loan is obtained for the needs of a permanent establishment belonging to the payer in a third State and the interest is paid out of the funds of that establishment. Therefore, under the current wording of paragraph 5, only its first sentence will apply in such a case. The interest will be deemed to arise in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident, and not in the third State in whose territory the permanent establishment for which the loan was obtained and from which the interest is payable is located. Thus, the interest will be taxed both in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident and in the Contracting State of which the beneficiary is a resident. However, although double taxation is eliminated between these two States by virtue of the measures provided for in this Article, it will remain between them and the third State if the latter levies withholding tax at source on interest paid by the permanent establishment located in its territory.
29. It was decided not to regulate such a case in the Convention. Accordingly, the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident is not obliged to waive its withholding tax at source in favour of the third State in which the permanent establishment for which the loan was obtained and out of which the interest is paid is located. If the situation were different and the third State did not levy withholding tax at source on interest paid by the permanent establishment, attempts would be made to avoid withholding tax at source in the Contracting State through the use of a permanent establishment located in such a third State. States for which this does not constitute a problem and which may wish to address the problems described in the preceding paragraph may do so by agreeing to use in their bilateral Conventions the alternative wording of paragraph 5 proposed in paragraph 30 below. The double taxation risk referred to may also be avoided by means of a multilateral Convention. Furthermore, if, in the case described in paragraph 28, the State of residence of the payer and the third State in which the permanent establishment for which the loan was obtained and out of which the interest is paid is located jointly claim the right to levy withholding tax at source on the interest, nothing prevents these two States from jointly adopting, where appropriate, together with the State of which the beneficiary is a resident, agreed measures to avoid the double taxation resulting from such claims, using, where necessary, the mutual agreement procedure (as provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 25).
30. As indicated in paragraph 29, such double taxation may be avoided either by means of a multilateral Convention or if the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident and the State of which the payer is a resident agree to the following wording of the second sentence of paragraph 5, as a result of which paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article will not apply to interest which, in such circumstances, would normally fall under Article 7 or Article 21:
However, where the person paying the interest, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a State of which it is not a resident a permanent establishment [or fixed base] which gave rise to the indebtedness on which the interest is paid and such interest is borne by that permanent establishment [or fixed base], then such interest shall be deemed to arise in the State in which that permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated.
31. If, in the course of bilateral negotiations, the two Contracting States have agreed that the exclusive right to tax income shall remain with the State of which the beneficial owner of that income is a resident, then, by virtue of that fact alone, it is inappropriate to insert into the Convention governing their relations the provision of paragraph 5 which defines the State of source of such income. However, it is equally clear that double taxation will not be entirely eliminated in such a case if the payer of interest has in a third State which levies withholding tax on interest at source a permanent establishment for which the loan was obtained and which pays the interest thereon. That case will then be the same as the one considered […] above.
Paragraph 6
22. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 6 of Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention, the Commentary to which states as follows:
32. This paragraph is intended to limit the application of the provisions concerning the taxation of interest where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person, the amount of interest paid exceeds the amount which would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner in the absence of such a relationship. It provides that, in such a case, the provisions of this Article apply only to the latter amount and that the excess portion of the interest remains taxable in accordance with the laws of the two Contracting States, due regard being had to the other provisions of the Convention.
33. It is clear from the text that, for this provision to apply, the excess amount of interest must result from a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between either of them and some other person. Examples include cases where interest is paid to an individual or legal entity that directly or indirectly controls the payer, is directly or indirectly controlled by the payer, or is subject to a group having common interests with it. These examples are also similar to the cases considered in Article 9.
34. On the other hand, the concept of special relationships also covers family or marital relationships and, more generally, a community of interests, as distinct from the legal relationships which give rise to the payment of interest.
35. With regard to the tax treatment applicable to the excess portion of the interest, the exact nature of such excess must be established in accordance with the circumstances of the case in order to determine the category of income to which it should be assigned for the purposes of applying the provisions of the tax legislation of the States concerned and the provisions of the Convention. This paragraph permits only an adjustment of the rate at which interest is charged, and not a reclassification of the loan in such a way as to give it the character of a contribution to share capital. In order for such an adjustment to be possible under paragraph 6 of Article 11, it would be necessary, at a minimum, to delete the restrictive phrase "connected with the debt-claim in respect of which they are paid". If there is a desire to provide greater clarity as to the intentions, words such as "for any reason" may be added after the word "exceeds". Either of these alternative formulations may be used where some or all of the interest payments are excessive because the amount of the loan or the terms associated with it (including the interest rate) differ from those which would have been agreed upon in the absence of the special relationship. Nevertheless, this paragraph may affect not only the recipient but also the payer of the excess interest, and, if permitted by the legislation of the State of source, the excess amount may be disallowed as a deduction, due regard being had to the other applicable provisions of the Convention. If both Contracting States have difficulty in determining which other provisions of the Convention apply in the relevant cases to the excess portion of the interest, nothing prevents them from making additional clarifications to the last sentence of paragraph 6, provided that they do not alter its general meaning.
36. If the principles and rules of their respective laws require both Contracting States to apply different Articles of the Convention for the purposes of taxing the excess portion, they should resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in the Convention in order to resolve the issues.
23. During the most recent consideration of this issue, some members of the former Group of Experts noted that there are a large number of artificial arrangements used for the purpose of obtaining benefits from the provisions of Article 11, particularly through the creation or assignment of debt obligations on which interest is charged. While the principles of "substance over form", "abuse of rights" or any other similar principle may be applied to counteract such practices, Contracting States wishing to address this issue specifically may add the following provision to their bilateral tax treaties in the course of negotiations:
The provisions of this Article shall not apply if the main purpose or one of the main purposes of any person concerned with the creation or assignment of the debt-claim in respect of which the interest is paid is to obtain the benefits of this Article by means of such creation or assignment.
Article 12
ROYALTIES
A. General Considerations
1. Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention, subject to the following exceptions: first, substantial changes have been made to paragraphs 1 and 3; second, paragraphs 2 and 5 are not included in the OECD Model Convention, with the result that the numbering of the paragraphs in the United Nations Model Convention and the OECD Model Convention does not correspond; and third, an editorial amendment has been made to paragraph 4.
2. If the user of a patent or similar property is a resident of one country and pays royalties to the owner of that property, who is a resident of another country, the amount paid by the user is normally subject to withholding tax at source in the user's country — the State of source. The tax of the State of source is levied on the gross amount of the payments without any deduction for related expenses incurred by the owner. Without taking expenses into account, the owner's profit after payment of tax may in some cases amount to only a small percentage of the gross amount of royalties. Consequently, when determining the amount of royalties, the owner may take into account the tax withheld in the State of source, so that the user and the State of source pay more for the use of the patent or similar property than they would have paid if the tax withheld by the State of source had been lower and had been levied taking into account the expenses incurred by the owner. An industrial enterprise or inventor may incur substantial expenditure in creating property that generates royalties, since research and testing require significant capital investment and do not always produce positive results. This makes it difficult to determine the appropriate tax rate that the State of source should apply to the gross amount of royalties paid, particularly because the user may make a lump-sum payment for the use of a patent or similar property in addition to regular royalty payments.
3. The Commentary on Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention contains the following preliminary remarks:
1. In principle, royalties for a licence to use patents and similar property and similar payments constitute income derived by the recipient from leasing. Such leasing may be connected with an industrial or commercial enterprise (for example, the use of a literary work made available by a publishing house), or with the activities of an individual engaged in an independent profession (for example, the use of a patent made available by an inventor), or may be entirely unrelated to the activities of the person granting the right (for example, the use of a patent made available by the heirs of an inventor).
2. Some countries do not allow royalties paid to be deducted for the purposes of assessing tax on the payer, except where the recipient is a resident of the same State or is subject to taxation in that State. In other cases, deductions are prohibited. The question of whether such deductions should be allowed where royalties are paid by a resident of a Contracting State to a resident of another State is considered in paragraph 4 of Article 24.
B. Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 12
Paragraphs 1 and 2
4. In paragraph 1, the word "only" has been omitted from the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention, which provides that "royalties arising in one of the Contracting States and beneficially owned by a resident of the other Contracting State shall be taxable only in that other State". Paragraph 2 is an addition that follows logically from the fundamental provision of paragraph 1 that royalties are taxable in the State of source as well as in the country of residence. By granting the right to tax royalties both to the State of residence and to the State of source, the United Nations Model Convention departs from the principle of the exclusive right of the State of residence to taxation, which is granted to it under the OECD Model Convention. In this connection, it should be noted that several OECD member countries have recorded reservations concerning the approval of taxation of royalties exclusively by the State of residence, as provided for in Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention.
5. The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention contains the following relevant provisions:
4. The requirement of beneficial ownership was introduced in paragraph 1 of Article 12 in order to clarify the application of this Article to payments made to intermediaries. It is clear from this that the State of source is not obliged to relinquish its right to tax dividends merely because the income was immediately received by a resident of a State with which the State of source has concluded a Convention. The term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense; rather, it should be interpreted in its context and in the light of the objects and purposes of the Convention, including the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax avoidance.
4.1 A tax relief or exemption in respect of an item of income is granted by the State of source to a resident of another Contracting State in order to wholly or partly avoid double taxation that might arise as a result of the simultaneous taxation of that income by the State of residence. Where an item of income is received by a resident of one Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, it would be inconsistent with the objects and purposes of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or an exemption merely because the immediate recipient of the income is a resident of another Contracting State. In this situation, the immediate recipient of the income qualifies as a resident, but, as a consequence of that status, the possibility of double taxation does not arise, since such recipient is not regarded as the owner of the income for tax purposes in the State of residence. It would be equally inconsistent with the objects and purposes of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or an exemption where a resident of one of the Contracting States, other than in the context of an agency or nominee relationship, simply acts as a conduit for another person who is the actual beneficial owner of the income in question. For these reasons, the report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs entitled "Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Conduit Companies"37 concluded that a conduit company could not normally be regarded as the beneficial owner if, although it was the formal owner, it had in practice very narrow powers which rendered it, in respect of the income concerned, a mere fiduciary or administrator acting on behalf of the interested parties.
37 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention, at page R(6)-1.
4.2 Provided that the other conditions laid down in this Article are satisfied, the limitation of tax in the State of source continues to apply where there is an intermediary, such as an agent or nominee, between the beneficial owner and the payer, provided that the beneficial owner is a resident of another Contracting State (in 1995, an amendment was made to the text of the Model Convention to clarify this point, on which all member countries reached a consensus). States wishing to clarify this provision may do so in the course of bilateral negotiations.
6. During the discussions of the former Group of Experts in 1999, its members from developing countries stated that, in order to facilitate the conclusion of double taxation agreements between those countries and developed countries, the primary right to tax royalties should be granted to the country in which the income arose, that is, the State of source. Situations may arise in which licences for patents and technologies are granted to developing countries only after they have been fully exploited in other countries and, according to these participants, after the costs incurred in their development have already been largely recovered.
7. Members of the Group from developed countries objected that the assertion that enterprises select their oldest patents for licensing to developing countries was not consistent with reality. An enterprise normally licenses its patents to foreign subsidiaries and therefore selects its latest developments in the hope of expanding existing markets or opening up new ones. Patents are not commodities, but a means of promoting the development of industrial production. Several members of the Group from developed countries emphasized the fundamental importance of the question of whether the country of residence of the owner of a patent or similar property should have the exclusive or primary right to tax royalties paid in respect of such a patent or similar property.
8. Since the Group was unable to reach a general agreement on a specific withholding tax rate to be levied on the gross amount of royalties, that rate should be determined through bilateral negotiations, during which the following considerations may be taken into account:
— First, the State of source should recognize both current expenses attributable to royalties and the costs incurred in creating the property for the use of which royalties are paid. It should be borne in mind that the costs of creating such property are also attributable to the profits derived from other royalties or from past or future activities associated with those costs, and that costs indirectly incurred in creating such property may nevertheless have contributed significantly to its creation.
— Second, if an expense ratio is agreed upon when establishing the gross rate in the State of source, the country of the recipient, which applies the tax credit method, should also, when granting a credit in its own territory, use that ratio to the extent possible. Accordingly, this issue should be considered in accordance with Article 23A or 23B.
9. Other factors may also influence the determination of the withholding tax rate on the gross amount of royalties, including: the need of developing countries for tax revenues and for the preservation of foreign currency; the fact that the flow of royalty payments is almost entirely directed from developing countries to developed countries; the amount of assistance that developed countries should provide to developing countries for various reasons; and the particular importance of providing such assistance in connection with royalty payments; the desirability of preventing the transfer of the tax burden to the licensee through licensing arrangements; the opportunities that taxation at source provides to a developing country to adopt a selective approach to decisions through which it can promote licensing agreements that contribute to its development by reducing rates or granting tax exemptions; the reduction of the risk of tax avoidance through withholding tax at source; the fact that the licensor's country provides the resources and activities necessary for the development of the patent and thus assumes the risks associated with that patent; the desirability of obtaining technology and directing the flow of technology to developing countries; the desirability of expanding the scope of the licensor's activities in exploiting the results of its research; the benefits that developed countries derive from global development as a whole; the relative importance of losses in tax revenues; and the relationship between the decision on royalties and other decisions taken during negotiations.
10. Income from payments for the use of films should not be treated as industrial or commercial profits, but should be considered in the context of royalties. Accordingly, tax will be levied on the gross amount, but expenses will be taken into account when determining the withholding rate. As regards expenses, there are factors that may be considered specifically related to payments for the rental of films. As a rule, the costs of producing a film may be significantly higher, and profits lower, than in the case of industrial royalties. On the other hand, since a significant proportion of the costs of a film is attributable to the high remuneration rates paid to actors and other participants, which are taxed only in the State of residence and not in the State of source, these expenses cannot serve as a basis for a substantial reduction of the tax withheld at source. However, it may be said that these amounts nevertheless constitute the producer's actual costs and should be taken into account, although at the same time all interested countries should join forces to ensure that such income cannot escape taxation. Furthermore, although the deduction of expenses in the State of residence does not mean that these expenses should not be taken into account in the State of source, at some point a different situation may arise with regard to the costs of older films.
11. Some members of the former Group of Experts believe that, since copyright royalties represent cultural activity, they should be exempt from tax in the State of source. However, other members object that the tax will be levied in the State of residence and that a reduction at source will not benefit the author. Other members of the Group expressed support for exempting copyright royalties from tax at source not so much on the grounds of their cultural significance, but rather because the State of residence is better placed to assess the expenses and personal circumstances of the creator of the royalties, including the period of time during which the books or other copyrighted works were created; in certain cases, a reduction of tax by the State of source may be supported on the grounds that the amount of tax is excessive and is not covered by the tax credit granted by the State of residence. However, States of source may reject this approach to the problem. Furthermore, if the person dealing with the State of source is a publisher rather than an author, the arguments in support of exempting the author's income on the grounds of the author's personal circumstances clearly do not apply to the publisher.
Paragraph 3
12. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention, but does not contain the amendment made to it in 1992, which excludes from this Article rental payments for the use of equipment. In addition, paragraph 3 of Article 12 includes payments for sound recordings and royalties that are not included in the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention. The following extracts from the OECD Commentary remain applicable (the text of the paragraphs of the Commentary that differs between the United Nations Model Convention and the OECD Model Convention is indicated in square brackets):
8. Paragraph 2 contains a definition of the term "royalties". In general, it relates to rights or property constituting various forms of literary or artistic property, elements of intellectual property specified in the text, and information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience. The definition refers to payments for the use of, or the right to use, the rights mentioned above, regardless of whether they are registered in a public register or whether such registration is required. The definition covers both payments made under the terms of a licence and compensation that a person is obliged to pay for unauthorized copying or infringement of such a right.
8.4 The following explanations are provided as guidance for determining the scope of Article 12 in relation to other Articles of the Convention, particularly those concerning [the leasing of equipment and] the provision of information.
10. Payments for the use of cinematographic films are also treated as royalties, regardless of whether they are shown in cinemas or on television. However, it may be agreed during bilateral negotiations that payments for the use of cinematographic films will be treated as industrial or commercial profits and, consequently, governed by Articles 7 and 9.
11. In classifying payments received as consideration for information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience as royalties, paragraph 2 refers to the concept of "know-how". Definitions of know-how have been formulated by various specialized bodies and authors. The words "payments ... for information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience" are used in the context of the transfer of certain information that has not been patented and generally does not fall within other categories of intellectual property rights. This generally corresponds to undisclosed industrial, commercial or scientific information derived from previous experience, which has practical application in the activities of an enterprise and from the disclosure of which an economic benefit may be obtained. Since this definition refers to information about previous experience, this Article does not apply to payments for new information obtained as a result of the provision of services at the request of the payer.
Some members of the Committee of Experts consider that there are no grounds for limiting the scope of industrial, commercial or scientific information solely to information derived from previous experience.
The OECD Commentary then contains the following provisions:
11.1 Under a know-how contract, one party agrees to impart to the other party, for use at the latter's own expense, its special knowledge and experience, which remain undisclosed to the public. It is recognized that the transferring party is not required to participate itself in the application of the data communicated to the receiving party, nor does it guarantee the results of such application.
11.2 Thus, this type of contract differs from contracts for the provision of services, under which one party undertakes to use the ordinary skills inherent in that profession to perform work for the other party itself. Payments made under such contracts generally fall within the scope of Article 7 [or, in the case of the United Nations Model Convention, Article 14].
11.3 The need to distinguish between these two types of payments, namely payments for the supply of know-how and payments for the provision of services, sometimes gives rise to practical difficulties. The following criteria are applicable in making this distinction:
— know-how contracts cover information described in paragraph 11 that already exists, or cover the transfer of information of this type after it has been compiled or developed, and include specific provisions concerning the confidentiality of such information.
— in the case of contracts for the provision of services, the supplier undertakes to perform services that may require the supplier to use special knowledge, skills and experience, but do not involve the transfer of such special knowledge, skills or experience to the other party.
— in most cases involving the supply of know-how, the supplier under such a contract generally has practically nothing to do apart from transferring existing information or reproducing existing materials. On the other hand, a contract for the performance of services will, in most cases, involve a significantly higher level of expenditure on the part of the supplier in order to fulfil its contractual obligations. For example, depending on the nature of the services provided, the supplier may have to incur costs for the salaries of employees engaged in research, development, testing, preparation of drawings and other related activities, or payments to subcontractors for the provision of similar services.
11.4 Examples of payments which, in view of the foregoing, should be regarded as compensation not for the provision of know-how but rather for the provision of services include the following:
— payments received as remuneration for after-sales services,
— payments for services provided by the seller to the buyer under a warranty,
— payments for purely technical assistance,
— payments for a list of potential customers where such a list is specially compiled for the payer from publicly available information (however, payment for a confidential list of customers to whom the recipient of the payment has supplied a particular product or service constitutes payment for know-how, since the recipient's dealings with those customers constitute its commercial experience),
— payments for an expert opinion issued by an engineer, lawyer or accountant, and
— payments for consultations provided electronically by technical experts on electronic communications issues or for access, through computer networks, to a troubleshooting database, for example, a database that provides users with software containing publicly available information in response to frequently asked questions and explanations of common problems.
11.5 In the particular case of a contract under which a supplier provides information concerning computer programming, the payment will generally be regarded as consideration for the provision of such information qualifying as know-how only where the payment is made for the purpose of obtaining information representing the ideas and principles underlying a program, such as its logic, algorithms and programming languages or methods, and where such information is provided subject to the condition that the client may not disclose it without appropriate authorization, and where it is covered by the applicable rules on the protection of trade secrets.
11.6 In business practice, contracts are encountered that cover both know-how and the provision of technical assistance. An example of such a contract may be a franchise agreement under which the franchising company transfers its knowledge and experience to the franchisee and, in addition, provides it with various forms of technical assistance, which in certain cases are supported by financial assistance and the supply of goods. The appropriate approach to mixed contracts is, in principle, to divide them on the basis of the information contained in the contract or by making a reasonable proportional allocation of the total amount of remuneration provided for under the contract in accordance with the various parts of everything supplied under the contract, and then to apply the appropriate tax treatment to each part identified in this manner. However, if one part of what is supplied under the contract constitutes, to a large extent, the principal purpose of the contract, while the other parts provided for therein are merely ancillary or mainly insignificant in nature, it may be possible to apply to the entire amount of remuneration the tax treatment applicable to the principal part.
12. Serious problems arise in determining whether payments received as consideration for computer software may be classified as royalties, and this issue is of considerable importance in view of the rapid development of computer technologies in recent years and the volume of cross-border transfers of such technologies. In 1992, amendments were made to the Commentary concerning the description of the principles according to which such classification should be carried out. In 2000, additional amendments were made to paragraphs 12–17 in order to clarify the methods of analysis used to distinguish between business profits and royalties in software transactions. In most cases, this revised analysis will not lead to a different result.
12.1 A software product may be defined as a program or series of programs containing instructions for a computer that are necessary either for the computer's own operational processes (an operating software product) or for the performance of other tasks (an application software product). It may be transferred by various means, for example, in written form, on magnetic tape or disk, or on a laser disk or CD-ROM. It may be standardized for widespread use or specially developed for individual users. It may be transferred as part of hardware or independently in a form that allows it to be used on a variety of hardware.
12.2 The character of payments received in transactions involving the transfer of software depends on the nature of the rights that the acquirer obtains under the particular contract concerning the use and exploitation of the relevant program. Rights to computer software are a form of intellectual property. An analysis of practices in OECD member countries has shown that all of them, with the exception of one, protect rights to software products either directly or indirectly through copyright legislation. Although the term "software" is commonly used to describe both the program in which intellectual property rights (copyright) are vested and the medium on which it is recorded, the copyright legislation of most OECD member countries recognizes the distinction between copyright in a program and the software containing a copy of a copyrighted program. The transfer of rights relating to software takes place in many different ways, ranging from the complete assignment of rights to the sale of a product subject to restrictions on the purposes for which it may be used. Remuneration may also be paid in a variety of ways. These factors make it difficult to distinguish between payments for a software product that should properly be treated as royalties and other types of payments. The difficulty of making this distinction is compounded by the ease with which computer programs can be reproduced, as well as by the fact that the acquisition of software often entails the making of a copy by the acquirer in order to enable the software product to function.
13. In most cases, the recipient's rights will include partial or full rights in respect of the underlying copyright (see paragraphs 13.1 and 15 below), or they may constitute (or be equivalent to) partial or full rights in a copy of the program ("program copy"), regardless of whether such copy is recorded on a tangible medium or supplied electronically (see paragraphs 14–14.2 below). In exceptional cases, the transaction may constitute a transfer of know-how or a secret formula (paragraph 14.3).
13.1 Payments for the acquisition of partial rights in copyright (without the complete assignment of the copyright by the transferor) will constitute royalties where the remuneration is paid for the granting of rights to use the software product in a manner that would, in the absence of such a licence, constitute an infringement of copyright. Examples of such arrangements include licences to reproduce and distribute publicly available software incorporating a copyrighted program, or to modify and release a program to the public. In these circumstances, the payments relate to the right to use the copyright in the software product (that is, the use of rights that would otherwise be the exclusive prerogative of the copyright holder). It should be noted that, where a payment for a software product is properly to be treated as a royalty, difficulties may arise in applying the provisions of this Article concerning copyright to royalties for a software product, since, under the requirements of paragraph 2, the software product must fall within the category of a literary or artistic work or a scientific work. Neither of these categories appears to be entirely appropriate. The copyright laws of many countries resolve this problem by specifically classifying a software product as a literary work or a scientific work. For other countries, the most practical solution appears to be to classify it as a scientific work. Countries that are unable to classify a software product under either of these categories have grounds for adopting in their bilateral treaties a modified version of paragraph 2 that either entirely omits all references to the nature of copyright or specifically refers to software products.
14. In other types of transactions, the rights acquired in respect of copyright are limited to those rights that are necessary to enable the user to operate the program, for example, where the acquirer obtains a limited right to reproduce the program. This situation frequently occurs in transactions involving the acquisition of a copy of a software product. The rights transferred in these cases depend on the nature of the computer programs. They allow the user to make a copy of the program, for example, on the user's computer hard drive or for archival purposes. In this context, it is important to note that the protection afforded by copyright in respect of software products may differ from country to country. In some countries, copying a program onto a computer's hard drive or into its random-access memory without a licence constitutes an infringement of copyright. However, the copyright laws of many countries automatically grant this right to the owner of a software product that incorporates a computer program. Regardless of whether this right is granted by law or on the basis of a licence agreement with the copyright holder, copying the program onto a hard drive or into random-access memory, or creating an archival copy, is an important step in using the program. Thus, rights in respect of these copying activities should not be taken into account when analysing the nature of the transaction for tax purposes in cases where they merely enable the actual use of the program by the user. Under Article 7, payments under such types of transactions are treated as business income.
14.1 The method by which a computer product is transferred to the recipient is irrelevant. For example, it does not matter whether the recipient acquires a computer disk containing a copy of the program or receives a copy of it directly on the hard drive of the recipient's computer through a modem connection. Nor does it matter whether the acquirer is subject to any restrictions on the use of the software product.
14.2 The ease with which computer programs can be reproduced has led to the emergence of product distribution arrangements under which the acquirer obtains the right to make several copies of the program for use solely within its own enterprise. Such arrangements are generally referred to as "site licences", "enterprise licences" or "network licences". Although these arrangements permit the making of several copies of the program, such rights are generally limited to those necessary to enable the program to operate on the licensee's computers or network, while reproduction for other purposes is not permitted under the licence. Payments made under such arrangements are, in most cases, treated as business profits under Article 7.
14.3 Another type of software transfer transaction is the more unusual case where a software company or programmer undertakes to provide information about the ideas and principles underlying the program, such as its logic, algorithms and programming languages or methods. In these cases, payments may be characterized as royalties to the extent that they constitute compensation for the use of, or the right to use, secret formulas or information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience that is not separately protected by copyright. This contrasts with the usual case of acquiring a copy of a program for use by an end user.
14.4 Arrangements between the owner of copyright in a software product and a distribution intermediary often grant the intermediary the right to distribute copies of the software product without the right to reproduce the program. In such transactions, the rights acquired under copyright are limited to those necessary for the commercial intermediary to distribute copies of the software product. In such transactions, distributors pay only for the acquisition of copies of the software product and not for the use of any copyright rights in that software product. Thus, in transactions where a distributor makes payments for the acquisition and distribution of copies of a software product (without the right to reproduce that software product), the rights relating to such distribution activities should not be taken into account when analysing the nature of the transaction for tax purposes. Payments made under such arrangements are, in most cases, treated as business profits under Article 7. This treatment applies regardless of whether the copies of the product being distributed are supplied on tangible media, distributed electronically (without the distributor having the right to reproduce the software product), or whether the software requires minor customization for installation purposes.
15. Where remuneration is paid for the complete transfer of ownership, such a payment cannot constitute a royalty, and the provisions of this Article do not apply in such a case. Difficulties may arise in the case of an assignment of rights, including the following:
— an exclusive right of use for a specific period or within a limited territory;
— additional remuneration related to use;
— remuneration in the form of a substantial lump-sum payment.
16. Each case will depend on its particular facts, but in general, where such a payment is made as compensation for the transfer of rights constituting separate and specific property (which is more likely in the case of rights limited territorially or in terms of duration), such payments will more likely be regarded as business income within the meaning of Article 7 (or Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention) or as capital gains within the meaning of Article 13, rather than royalties within the meaning of Article 12. This follows from the fact that, upon the assignment of property rights, the consideration cannot be paid for the use of rights. The essential nature of the transaction as an assignment cannot be altered by the form of remuneration, payment of remuneration in instalments or, in the opinion of most countries, by the fact that the payments are contingent on unforeseen circumstances.
17. Payments for software may be made under mixed contracts. Examples of such contracts include the sale of computer equipment with embedded software and the granting of the right to use software in combination with the provision of services. The methods described above in paragraph 11 for resolving similar problems concerning royalties for patents and know-how are equally applicable to computer software products. Where necessary, the total amount of remuneration payable under the contract should be divided on the basis of the information contained in the contract or by means of a reasonable proportional allocation, with the appropriate tax treatment applied to each part identified in this way.
17.1 The principles set out above concerning payments for software also apply to transactions involving other types of digital products, such as images, sound or text. The development of electronic commerce has multiplied the number of such transactions. In deciding whether or not royalties arise from payments made in these transactions, the main issue to be resolved is determining what, in substance, is being paid for.
17.2 Under the relevant legislation of some countries, transactions that allow a customer to download digital products electronically may result in the use of copyright by the customer, for example, because the right to make one or more copies of the digital content is granted under the contract. Where remuneration is paid, in substance, for something other than the use of, or the right to use, copyright rights (for example, for the acquisition of other types of contractual rights, data or services), and the use of copyright is limited to those rights necessary to enable the downloading, storage and operation of the product on the customer's computer or network or on another data storage, processing or display device, such use of copyright should not affect the analysis of the nature of the payments for the purposes of applying the definition of "royalties".
17.3 This applies to transactions that allow a customer (which may be an enterprise) to download digital products electronically (for example, software, images, sounds or text) for the customer's own purposes or entertainment. Under such transactions, the payment is, in substance, made for the acquisition of data transmitted in the form of a digital signal and, therefore, does not constitute a royalty, but falls within the scope of Article 7 or Article 13, depending on the circumstances. To the extent that the act of copying a digital signal onto the customer's hard drive or another non-temporary storage medium involves the use of copyright by the customer under the relevant law and contractual arrangements, such copying is merely a means of receiving and storing the digital signal. Such use of copyright is irrelevant for classification purposes, since it does not correspond to what the remuneration is essentially paid for (that is, the acquisition of data transmitted in the form of a digital signal), which is the determining factor for the purposes of identifying royalties. Nor can there be grounds for classifying such transactions as "royalties" if, under the relevant laws and contractual obligations, the creation of a copy is regarded as the use of copyright by the supplier rather than by the customer.
17.4 Conversely, transactions where the principal consideration for the payment is the granting of the right to use copyright in a digital product that is downloaded electronically for this purpose give rise to royalties. This will be the case, for example, where a book publisher wishes to pay for the acquisition of the right to reproduce a copyrighted image that it will download electronically for the purpose of incorporating it into the layout of the cover of a book to be published. In this transaction, the principal consideration for the payment is the acquisition of rights to use copyright in the digital product, that is, the rights to reproduce and distribute the image, rather than merely the acquisition of digital content.
Some members of the Committee of Experts hold the view that the payments referred to in paragraphs 14, 14.1, 14.2, 14.4, 15, 16, 17, 17.2 and 17.3 above of the OECD Commentary may be considered royalties.
The OECD Commentary then contains the following:
18. The above proposals concerning mixed contracts may also apply to certain types of artistic performances and, in particular, to an orchestral concert conducted by a conductor or a solo concert by a musician. The fee for a musical performance together with the payment for its simultaneous radio broadcast would appear to fall within the scope of Article 17. If, under the same or a separate contract, the musical performance is recorded and the performer stipulates that royalties are to be paid to the performer on the sale or public reproduction of those recordings, then that part of the payment received by the performer which corresponds to royalties falls within the scope of Article 12. If, however, the copyright in the sound recording belongs, either by virtue of the relevant copyright law or under the terms of the contract, to the person to whom the performer has contractually agreed to provide services (that is, the musical performance during the recording), or belongs to a third party, then payments under such a contract fall within the scope of Article 7 [or Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention] (for example, if such a performance takes place outside the State of source of the payment) or Article 17, and not under this Article, even if such payments are dependent on sales of sound recordings.
19. It is further stated that variable or fixed payments for the development of mineral deposits, springs or other natural resources are governed by Article 6 and therefore do not fall within the scope of this Article.
13. An amendment was made to paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention (corresponding to paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention) in accordance with the report "Revision of the Model Convention", adopted by the OECD Council on 23 July 1992, consisting of the deletion of the words "or the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment". However, a number of OECD member countries recorded reservations on this issue.
13.1 The reference in Article 12(3) to "industrial, commercial or scientific equipment" relates to circumstances in which the owner of equipment derives profits from allowing another person to use that equipment independently, without the owner establishing any presence in the State where it is used or any place of residence of the user that would satisfy the requirements of Article 5 concerning the existence of a permanent establishment. In respect of this type of business, the equipment, when used by another person, is treated under the United Nations Model Convention as an object having significance similar to that of a permanent establishment.
13.2 The term "equipment" is not defined in this Model Convention. Accordingly, the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 3 apply, meaning that this term may have different meanings in different States. Nevertheless, an essential characteristic is that the equipment is used to perform a task. It is an instrument used by an enterprise, which means that it is not used solely for personal purposes. Thus, for example, a car rented by a tourist would not be considered "equipment". Equipment also cannot include intellectual property, immovable property falling within the scope of Article 6, or property falling within the scope of Article 8. Industrial, commercial or scientific equipment is clearly a subcategory of equipment and may include, outside the context of consumer use, the following (the list is not exhaustive): ships, aircraft, motor vehicles and other means of transport, cranes, containers, satellites, pipelines and cables, etc.
13.3 A clear distinction must be drawn between royalties paid for the use of equipment, which fall within the scope of Article 12, and payments constituting consideration for the sale of equipment, which may fall, in whole or in part depending on the circumstances, within the scope of Articles 7, 11, 13, 14 or 21. Some contracts combine elements of leasing and sale, and it may therefore sometimes be difficult to determine their nature and economic substance. In the case of hire-purchase agreements, leases and other forms of financial leasing, it seems clear that the sale element is of primary importance, since the parties agreed from the outset that ownership of the relevant property would pass from one party to the other, although they made this conditional upon payment of the final instalment. Consequently, payments made by the purchaser/lessee are generally not royalties. Nevertheless, in the case of an operating lease, the sole or at least the principal purpose of the contract is generally leasing, despite the fact that, under the terms of the contract, the lessee has the right to acquire ownership of the relevant equipment during the term of the contract. Therefore, Article 12 normally applies to rental payments made by the lessee, including all rental payments made before the date on which the lessee exercises the option to purchase. Indicators of a financial rather than an operating lease may include the following:
- the lease agreement is long-term and non-cancellable;
- the lease term is likely to cover most (or all) of the useful life of the equipment;
- there is no other likely user of the equipment, or it is not possible to lease the equipment to another lessee;
- the lessee of the equipment acts as its owner;
- the lessee assumes the positive and/or negative risk of, or benefits from, the residual value of the equipment;
- rental payments for the use of the equipment are high, particularly at the initial stage, so that they initially constitute a large part of the amount required to acquire it;
- rental payments significantly exceed the current reasonable rental value and thus compensate for more than merely the use of the property; and
- some part of the rental payments is specifically identified as interest or is otherwise readily recognizable as an interest equivalent.
13.4 As regards satellite communications companies and their customers, the classification of a customer's payment to a satellite communications operator as royalties will largely depend on the specific contractual arrangements. If the owner of a satellite system leases it to another person and that person operates it, the rental fee will constitute royalties for the use of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment. However, in most cases, the customer does not acquire ownership of or control over the satellite equipment, but uses part or all of its capacity. The satellite will continue to be operated by the lessor. In such cases, members of the Group consider that the payments made will be of the nature of payments for transmission services, to which Article 7 or Article 12A applies. Other members of the Group consider that a payment for the use of capacity (or transportation or transmission capacity in the case of pipelines or cables) may be treated as a payment for the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
14. When these issues were considered by the former Group of Experts, it addressed the problems of distinguishing royalties from those types of income that are properly governed by other Articles of the Convention. A member of the Group from one of the developed countries argued that the problem was that the definition of "royalties" did not clearly distinguish between receipts constituting royalties in the strict sense of the term and payments received for intellectual labour and technical services, for example, any research (engineering, geological surveys, etc.). This member of the Group also mentioned the problem of distinguishing royalties, which are similar to income from capital, from payments for services. Given the broad definition of "information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience", some countries seek to treat intellectual labour and technical services as the provision of "information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience" and their remuneration as royalties.
15. In order to avoid this type of difficulty, this member of the Group proposed limiting the definition of royalties by excluding payments received for "information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience". He also proposed drawing up an annexed protocol clarifying that such payments should be regarded as business profits to which the provisions of Article 7 apply, and that payments received for scientific or technical research or surveys, such as geological exploration, or for consultancy or supervisory services, should also be regarded as business profits subject to Article 7. As a result of applying these provisions, the State of source would not be able to tax such payments unless the enterprise had a permanent establishment in that country, and taxes would be levied only on the net income included in such payments that is attributable to that permanent establishment.
16. Some members of the Group from developing countries interpreted the words "information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience" as meaning specialized knowledge that has real property value associated with industrial, commercial or management technologies, transferred in the form of instructions, recommendations, training or formulas, plans or models that make it possible to use or apply experience accumulated in a particular field. They also indicated that, during bilateral negotiations, the definition of the term "royalties" could be extended to include income from the alienation of any such right or property where the consideration is contingent on the productivity, use of such right or property, or disposal thereof. The former Group of Experts agreed that the interpretation of copyright in literary works could include copyrights relating to international news.
Paragraph 4
17. This paragraph reproduces, with amendments, paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention, which provides that paragraph 1 does not apply to royalties beneficially owned by a person who has a permanent establishment38 in the State of source, if the right or property in respect of which the royalties are paid is effectively connected with that permanent establishment39. The former Group of Experts decided to amend paragraph 3 of the OECD Model Convention and introduce a limited "force of attraction" principle. In addition to the royalties excluded from the application of paragraph 1 by paragraph 3 of the OECD Article, paragraph 4 of the United Nations Model Convention excludes royalties received in connection with activities referred to in subparagraph c of paragraph 1 of Article 7 (business activities of the same or a similar kind as those carried on through a permanent establishment in the State of source), even if such activities are not carried on through a permanent establishment or a fixed base. The amendment to the United Nations Model Convention in this paragraph also consists of a reference to paragraph 2, as well as paragraph 1.
38 Or a fixed base; see Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention.
39 See the footnote above.
Paragraph 5
18. This paragraph, which provides that royalties are treated as income arising in the State of which the payer of the royalties is a resident, was introduced into the United Nations Model Convention and is absent from Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention.
19. As with the issue of interest, a number of members of the Group suggested that some countries might wish to replace the rule identifying the source of royalties as the State in which the property or right giving rise to the royalties (patent, etc.) is used. If disagreements arise between the parties during bilateral negotiations concerning the appropriate rule, a possible solution may be a rule that generally recognizes the payer's place of residence as the source of royalties; however, if the right or property in respect of which the royalties are paid is used in a State that applies the place-of-use rule, the royalties will be deemed to arise in that State.
Paragraph 6
20. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 4 of Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention, the Commentary on which states:
22. The purpose of this paragraph is to restrict the application of the provisions concerning the taxation of royalties in cases where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person, the amount of royalties paid exceeds the amount that would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner "at arm's length". It provides that, in such a case, the provisions of this Article apply only to the latter amount and that the portion of the royalties constituting such excess is taxable under the laws of both Contracting States, subject to the other provisions of the Convention. This paragraph permits only an adjustment to the amount of royalties, but not a reclassification of the royalties so as to give them a different character, for example, as a contribution to share capital. In order for such an adjustment to be possible under paragraph 4 of Article 12, it is necessary, at a minimum, to remove the restrictive phrase "having regard to the use, right or information for which they are paid". If greater clarity of intention is considered necessary, a phrase such as "for any reason" may be added after the word "exceeds".
23. It follows from the text that, for this provision to apply, the reason for the payment considered excessive must be the existence of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person. Examples include cases where royalties are paid to an individual or legal entity that directly or indirectly controls the payer, or is directly or indirectly controlled by the payer, or is subject to a group having common interests with the payer. Moreover, these examples are similar to the cases provided for in Article 9.
24. On the other hand, the concept of special relationships also covers family and marital relationships and, in general, any community of interests as distinct from legal relationships that result in the payment of royalties.
25. As regards the tax treatment applicable to the excessive portion of the royalties, the precise nature of such excess must be determined in accordance with the circumstances of each particular case in order to establish the category of income to which it should be assigned for the purposes of applying the provisions of the tax legislation of the respective States and the provisions of the Convention. If the two Contracting States encounter difficulties in determining which other provisions of the Convention are applicable in the relevant cases to the excessive portion of the royalties, nothing prevents them from avoiding such difficulties by introducing additional clarifications in the final sentence of paragraph 4, provided that this does not alter its general meaning.
26. If the principles and rules of their respective laws require the two Contracting States to apply different Articles of the Convention for the purposes of taxing the excessive amount, they should resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in the Convention in order to resolve this problem.
21. When this issue was considered by the former Group of Experts, some members of the Group pointed to the existence of artificial arrangements used in relationships between persons for the purpose of taking advantage of the benefits of the provisions of Article 12 through, among other things, the conclusion or assignment of contracts concerning the use of, rights to, or information relating to intangible assets for which royalties are charged. Although the principle of "substance over form", the principle of "abuse of rights" or other similar principles may be applied to counteract such practices, Contracting States wishing to address this issue specifically may include in their bilateral tax treaty a provision of the following nature:
"The provisions of this Article shall not apply if the main purpose or one of the main purposes of any person concerned with the creation or assignment of the rights in respect of which the royalties are paid is to obtain the benefits of this Article by means of such creation or assignment."
Article 12A
TECHNICAL SERVICE FEES
A. General considerations
1. In 2017, Article 12A was added to the United Nations Model Convention, allowing a Contracting State to tax fees for certain technical services paid to a resident of another Contracting State on a gross basis at a rate to be agreed upon by the Contracting States. Under this Article, a Contracting State has the right to tax fees for technical services if the remuneration is paid by a resident of that State or by a non-resident having a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State, and the fees are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base; it is not necessary for the technical services to be performed in that State. Fees for technical services are defined as remuneration for managerial, technical or consultancy services.
2. Prior to the addition of Article 12A, profits from services received by an enterprise of a Contracting State were taxable exclusively in the State in which that enterprise was resident, except where the enterprise carried on business through a permanent establishment in another State (the source State) or performed professional or independent personal services through a fixed base in the source State. In view of the rapid changes in the modern economy, particularly with regard to cross-border services, an enterprise resident in one State has become able to participate indirectly in the economy of another State without having a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State and without any substantial physical presence in that State. In particular, with the development of means of communication and information technologies, an enterprise of one Contracting State may provide substantial services to customers in another Contracting State and, consequently, maintain a significant economic presence in that State without having a fixed place of business in that State and without being present in that State for any significant period of time. The OECD project on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (hereinafter referred to as BEPS), Action 1: Final Report “Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy” (2015), illustrates the difficulties faced by tax policy makers and tax administration officials in dealing with new digital business models made possible by the digital economy. The Report does not recommend introducing a withholding tax on digital transactions (which include cross-border digital services), nor does it recommend introducing a new tax system in the form of a significant economic presence test. However, it was acknowledged that countries may include such provisions in their tax treaties, together with other additional measures to protect against BEPS.
3. Prior to the introduction of Article 12A, States faced more restrictive rules with regard to the application of tax when technical services were provided abroad. In general, the rules provided for in Articles 7, 5 and 14 of the United Nations Model Convention offer limited opportunities for taxing income from such services, particularly in the absence of a fixed base or permanent establishment in the source State. As noted in these Commentaries, countries interpret these rules differently, which may make their application difficult for all parties.
4. In addition, under Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention, payment for technical services by a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of another Contracting State generally cannot be taxed as royalties by the State in which the payer is located. However, some countries take the view that the expression “information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience” includes certain technical services, as discussed in paragraph 5 below. Article 12 permits the Contracting State in which royalties arise to tax the gross amount of royalty payments at a rate determined through negotiations between the Contracting States. Royalties are defined in paragraph 3 of Article 12 as payments for the use of, or the right to use, any copyright, patent, trademark, design or model, plan, secret formula or process, any industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, or information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience. In other words, royalties are payments for the use of, or the right to use, intellectual property, equipment or scientific technology (information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience). Thus, royalties represent the transfer of the use of, or the right to use, property or innovative technologies. Conversely, when an enterprise provides services to a customer, it generally does not transfer its property, technology or experience to the customer; instead, the enterprise simply performs work for the customer. Under what is commonly referred to as a “mixed contract”, an enterprise may provide a customer with both services and the right to use property or technology. In such situations, in accordance with paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 12 (cited as paragraph 11.6 of the Commentary on Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention), payments under the contract should be divided into separate components — payments for services and royalties — unless one of the elements is merely ancillary and largely insignificant. Agreeing on a tax rate for fees for technical services under Article 12A that is identical to the rate for royalties under Article 12 may help reduce the difficulties associated with mixed contracts, may be useful for developing countries with limited administrative resources, and may reduce potential conflicts in the implementation of this Article.
5. Furthermore, countries interpret the meaning of the expression “information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience” in paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention (the same wording appears in paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention) differently. In some States, the position is taken that services involving the provision of intellectual and technical work are covered by this expression and that, consequently, payments for such services are generally taxable under Article 12. (See paragraphs 14 and 16 of the Commentary on Article 12).
6. The absence of a clear-cut approach to the treatment of fees for technical and other similar services under the provisions of the United Nations Model Convention as it stood before 2017 was undesirable for both taxpayers and tax authorities. It could also give rise to difficult disputes for both taxpayers and administrative authorities, result in the expenditure of limited resources, and lead to irrecoverable double taxation or double non-taxation.
7. Fees for technical services may also result in the erosion of the tax base of countries whose provisions of the United Nations Model Convention do not permit them to tax such fees. Remuneration for technical services is generally deductible in computing the tax base of a country where the payer is a resident of that country or a non-resident with a permanent establishment or fixed base in that country. A reduction or erosion of the tax base of a State as a result of deductions for fees for technical services is generally not objectionable. If the payer is an enterprise, the payments represent legitimate expenses incurred by the payer for the purpose of earning income and should be deductible (provided, of course, that the amount of the payments is reasonable). If a country has the right to tax a non-resident service provider on the fees for technical services received, the reduction of the country's tax base through deductible payments is offset by the country's tax on those fees.
8. Where technical services are provided by an enterprise of one Contracting State to a subsidiary in another Contracting State, there is a possibility that the payments may be higher or lower than the arm's length price of the services. Within a multinational group, remuneration for technical services may sometimes be used to shift profits from a profitable group company resident and operating in one country to another group company resident in a low-tax country. Assume, for example, that Company B (an enterprise resident in Country B, a low-tax country) provides managerial, technical or consultancy services to Company A (a subsidiary resident in Country A, a high-tax country). Assuming that the tax treaty between Countries A and B contains provisions similar to those of the United Nations Model Convention, Company B may avoid having a permanent establishment in Country A by not creating a fixed place of business in Country A and by not providing services in Country A for more than 183 days during any 12-month period. Thus, prior to the adoption of Article 12A, even if Company B was subject to tax on the income from services provided to Company A under the domestic tax law of Country A, that income would not be taxable in Country A as a result of the tax treaty between Country A and Country B. If, for any reason, Company B is not taxed on that income in Country B, or is taxed at a low rate on such income, the multinational enterprise will effectively shift profits from a relatively high-tax country (Country A) to a low-tax country (Country B).
9. Furthermore, the fee paid by Company A to Company B for services is generally deductible by Company A when calculating its taxable income in Country A. This deduction reduces the tax base of Country A, and prior to the adoption of Article 12A, Country A would not have been able to tax the payments made by Company A to Company B, as indicated in paragraph 8 above, in order to offset the effects of the deduction. However, under Article 12A, if the fee for technical services were paid by a resident of Country A or by a non-resident of Country A having a permanent establishment or fixed base in Country A, Country A would have the right to tax that fee.
10. The erosion of the tax base and profit shifting illustrated in the example above are matters of serious concern to both developed and developing countries. However, this problem is particularly serious from the perspective of developing countries, since they are disproportionately importers of technical services and often lack sufficient administrative capacity to monitor or limit such erosion of the tax base and profit shifting through anti-avoidance rules in their domestic legislation and tax treaties.
11. The inability of States to tax fees for technical services provided by non-resident service providers under the provisions of the United Nations Model Convention prior to the addition of Article 12A could, in certain circumstances, give non-resident service providers tax advantages over domestic service providers. Remuneration for technical services provided by domestic service providers is subject to domestic tax at the ordinary rate applicable to business profits. Otherwise, as indicated above, non-resident service providers would not be subject to any domestic tax if they did not have a permanent establishment or fixed base in the country concerned, and they might be subject only to low taxes (or no taxes at all) on remuneration received in their country of residence.
12. In light of these considerations, the United Nations Committee of Experts identified fees for technical services as a priority issue to be addressed as part of its broader project on the taxation of income from the provision of services under the United Nations Model Convention. Following extensive study and discussion, with due consideration given to all arguments for and against expanding taxing rights in respect of services, the Committee decided to add a new Article to the United Nations Model Convention, expanding the taxing rights of States from which remuneration for technical services is paid.
13. The majority of the members of the Committee of Experts rejected the position that a State should have the right to tax income from services received by a resident of another Contracting State on the condition that those services are performed in the first-mentioned State. In particular, the majority rejected the argument that the residence of the person paying for technical services in one of the Contracting States and the deduction of those payments from the tax base of that State do not establish a sufficient connection with that State to justify taxing those payments. In the opinion of the members of the Committee, base erosion provides sufficient grounds for taxing employment income under Article 15 and directors' fees and remuneration of senior executives under Article 16. Although taxation of employment income under Article 15 is limited to employment exercised in the country, Article 16 allows a Contracting State to tax an individual who is located in another Contracting State in respect of payments received by that individual in the capacity of a director or payments received in the capacity of a senior executive of a company resident in the first-mentioned State, irrespective of whether the services were performed in the first-mentioned State or outside it. Furthermore, under Articles 7 and 14, a State has the right to tax income earned outside that State if that income is attributable to a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State.
14. Article 12A may result in certain non-resident service providers being subject to a gross-basis levy on the value of technical services provided to residents of a Contracting State. Countries should be aware of this possibility in the same way that they should be aware of the possibility of a similar levy on interest and royalties under Articles 11 and 12, respectively. The possibility of taxing fees for technical services on a gross basis is a factor that must be taken into account in this regard, along with many other factors. It is also a factor that must be taken into account when establishing the maximum rate of tax imposed by a Contracting State on fees for technical services under paragraph 2 of Article 12A.
15. Taxation of fees for technical services on a gross basis under Article 12A may result in excessive or double taxation. However, the likelihood that remuneration for technical services may be subject to excessive or double taxation is reduced or eliminated under Article 23 (Methods for the Elimination of Double Taxation). Furthermore, the possibility of excessive or double taxation may be taken into account when establishing the maximum rate of tax imposed by a Contracting State on fees for technical services under paragraph 2 of Article 12A and, depending on the agreed rate, the risk of excessive taxation may be entirely eliminated.
16. Notwithstanding the inclusion of Article 12A in the United Nations Model Convention, a significant minority of the members of the Committee disagreed with the above policy justifications for this Article. The members of the Committee mainly disagreed with the justification set out in paragraph 2 above, namely that rapid changes in the modern economy, particularly with regard to cross-border services, enable non-resident service providers to become significantly involved in the economy of another State without a physical presence. Rather, those members of the Committee considered that, in the case of fees for technical services that are not performed in the State of the payer, there is no connection with that State that would justify the taxation of such payment in that State.
17. In the opinion of those members of the Committee, from a policy perspective, taxation of fees for technical services is justified only where the service provider has a sufficient connection with the State of the payer, which is normally demonstrated by the existence of a permanent establishment or fixed base. In other words, in order to justify taxation of technical services in the State, the services must be performed in that State with the level of connection contemplated by Articles 5 (Permanent Establishment), 7 (Business Profits) and 14 (Independent Personal Services).
18. Another argument in favour of including Article 12A is that payments for services are deductible and therefore erode the tax base of the State of the payer. However, in the opinion of the members opposing Article 12A, the mere deduction of a commercially justified payment cannot be equated with base erosion and is therefore not sufficient grounds for taxing that payment in the same State.
19. Those members of the Committee who disagreed with the inclusion of Article 12A in bilateral tax treaties were also concerned that the term “technical services” used in this Article is not precisely defined. Consequently, those members of the Committee were concerned that the application of this Article would lead to increased uncertainty, inconsistent treatment and lengthy disputes between taxpayers and tax authorities.
20. In the opinion of those members of the Committee who disagreed with the inclusion of Article 12A, another problem associated with taxing fees for technical services on a gross basis is that this may result in double taxation. Taxation on a gross basis deprives the taxpayer of the opportunity to take into account the expenses incurred in connection with the provision of services, which would have been deducted if the tax had been levied on a net basis. Thus, there is a possibility that the remedies available in the State of residence for the elimination of double taxation may prove insufficient to fully eliminate the consequences of gross-basis taxation imposed by another State.
21. From the perspective of broader economic policy, those members who opposed the inclusion of Article 12A were concerned that, as a result of the application of this Article, consumers of technical services in the source State might face higher prices for those services, since foreign service providers might pass on the additional tax costs to the consumer through such means as so-called gross-up clauses in contracts. As a rule, a gross-up clause specifies the net amount to be received by the provider, thereby effectively shifting the burden of any withholding tax to the consumer of the services. The use of gross-up clauses may result in the tax being passed on to the consumer and make the purchase of services more expensive. This may place a foreign service provider at a competitive disadvantage, effectively closing access to the market in which such withholding tax is imposed and limiting the consumer's legitimate choice of service provider.
22. In addition, members of the Committee expressed concern that the inclusion of Article 12A would lead to distortions in trade, since the taxation of goods and services would be carried out on different bases. This is because the profits of an exporter of goods are taxable only in the State of its residence, whereas under Article 12A technical services would be subject to what is essentially an import tariff.
23. In general, the members of the Committee disagreed with the analysis set out in paragraphs 2–15 above and regarded any expansion of taxing jurisdiction in respect of fees for technical services as an unjustified shift in the balance of taxation from the place where services are provided to the place where they are consumed. Countries sharing these concerns may wish not to include Article 12A in their bilateral tax treaties.
24. As an alternative, countries wishing to obtain additional taxing rights over fees for technical services but concerned about the broad scope of Article 12A may consider agreeing to amend Article 12 (Royalties) to permit the taxation of certain “fees for included services” — an approach found in a number of bilateral tax treaties between developing and developed countries. The policy rationale for this narrower approach is that, in order to justify taxation by the State from which payment is made, even where the services are not performed in that State, the fee for the services must be directly connected with the use of property for which royalties are paid, as defined in Article 12. The wording of this alternative approach is set out in paragraphs 25 and 26 of the Commentary on Article 12.
25. Nevertheless, the majority of the members of the Committee of Experts expressed the view that the alternative referred to in paragraph 24 is not an acceptable alternative to Article 12A for developing countries, since, in the opinion of the members of the Committee, there is in fact no principled justification for limiting the taxation of fees for technical services to services directly connected with property giving rise to royalties. Furthermore, in the opinion of the members of the Committee, the alternative supported by the minority of the members of the Committee contains many vague terms with uncertain meanings, which may lead to frequent disputes over the interpretation of this provision.
26. Instead, countries concerned about the scope of Article 12A and the uncertainty associated with the definition of “fees for technical services” in paragraph 3 of Article 12A may consider an alternative version of Article 12A under which Article 12A would potentially apply to all fees for services (technical and other services) provided in a Contracting State, as well as to fees for services provided outside that State by closely related persons, except for payments expressly excluded under paragraphs 3(a), (b) and (c). Under this alternative provision, paragraphs 1, 2, 4 and 7 of Article 12A would remain unchanged, except that the term “fees for technical services” in those paragraphs would be replaced by the term “fees for services”. However, paragraphs 3, 5 and 6 would be replaced by the following paragraphs:
3. The term “fees for services” as used in this Article means any payment in consideration for any service, unless the payment is made:
(a) to an employee of the person making the payment;
(b) for teaching at an educational institution or for teaching by an educational institution; or
(c) by an individual for services for the personal use of an individual.
5. For the purposes of this Article, fees for services shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State if:
(a) the services are performed in that State; or
(b) the payer is a resident of that State and the fees are paid to an enterprise or person closely related to the payer, unless the payer carries on business in another Contracting State or a third State through a permanent establishment situated in that other State or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated in that other Contracting State or third State, and such fees are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base; or
(c) the payer has a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State in connection with which the liability to pay the fees for services arose, and such fees are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base and paid to an enterprise or person closely related to the payer.
6. For the purposes of this Article, a person is closely related to an enterprise if, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, one controls the other or both are under the control of the same persons or enterprises. In all cases, a person shall be considered to be closely related to an enterprise if it directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interest in the other enterprise (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 per cent of the aggregate vote and value of the shares of the company or of the beneficial equity interest in the company), or if another person directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interest (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 per cent of the aggregate vote and value of the shares of the company or of the beneficial equity interest in the company) in that person and the enterprise. For the purposes of this Article, an individual is closely related to another individual if that individual is related to the other individual by blood, marriage or adoption.
27. Under this alternative, a State would have the right to tax, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 12A, at the maximum agreed rate, fees for services paid by a resident of that State or by a non-resident with a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State to a resident of another Contracting State, if the fees for services arise in the first-mentioned State. Fees for services would be deemed to arise in a State in accordance with paragraph 5 if:
1. the services are performed in that State; or
2. the services are performed outside that State by a person closely related to the payer.
Thus, the alternative provision would eliminate any disputes as to whether the relevant services fall within the definition of “fees for technical services” in paragraph 3 of Article 12A, since it applies to all fees for services, except for payments excluded under paragraphs 3(a)–(c). Under the alternative provision, a Contracting State would not have the right to tax fees for services paid to service providers resident in another Contracting State who are not closely related to the payer, where the services are performed outside the first-mentioned State. In contrast, under Article 12A, fees for technical services paid to service providers resident in another Contracting State who are not closely related to the payer, for services performed outside the first-mentioned State, would be taxable in the first-mentioned State. However, under the alternative provision, a Contracting State would have the right to tax fees for services performed outside that State if those services are provided by persons closely related to the payer. In many cases, such services provided by persons closely related to the payer represent the most significant risk of base erosion for the country.
28. Under the alternative provision, paragraph 6 contains rules for determining whether a person is closely related to an enterprise and whether an individual is closely related to another individual. The concept of a closely related person should be distinguished from the concept of an “associated enterprise”, which is used for the purposes of Article 9; although these two concepts overlap to some extent, they are not considered equivalent.
29. Having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, it may be concluded that a person is closely related to an enterprise if one controls the other or both are under the control of the same persons or enterprises. This general rule covers, for example, situations in which a person or enterprise controls an enterprise by virtue of a special arrangement that allows that person to exercise rights similar to those it would have if it directly or indirectly owned more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in the enterprise. As in most cases where the plural form is used, the reference to “the same persons or enterprises” at the end of the first sentence of paragraph 6 covers cases where there is only one such person or enterprise.
30. The second sentence of paragraph 6 provides that the concept of a “person closely related to an enterprise” is automatically satisfied in certain circumstances. A person is considered to be closely related to an enterprise if one of them directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in the other, or if a third person directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in both that person and the enterprise. In the case of a company, this condition is satisfied if a person directly or indirectly owns more than 50 per cent of the aggregate vote and value of the shares of the company or of the beneficial interests in the company.
31. The last sentence of paragraph 6 states that persons are closely related if they are related by blood, marriage or adoption. This rule is necessary for situations in which an individual pays for services (other than services for the personal use of the individual) provided by another individual who is not engaged in business. For this purpose, the terms “blood”, “marriage” and “adoption” take their meaning under the domestic law of the country applying the treaty in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 3.
32. Article 12A allows a Contracting State to tax fees for technical services on a gross basis. Many developing countries have limited administrative capacity and need a simple, reliable and efficient method of collecting tax on income from services received by non-residents. A withholding tax imposed on the gross amount of payments made by residents of a country or by non-residents having a permanent establishment or fixed base in that country has proved to be an effective method of collecting tax imposed on non-residents. Such a method of taxation may also simplify compliance for enterprises providing services in another State, since they will not have to calculate their net profits or file tax returns.
33. Article 12A does not require any threshold conditions, such as a permanent establishment, a fixed base or a minimum period of presence in a Contracting State, as a condition for taxing fees for technical services. In this respect, Article 12A differs substantially from Articles 7 and 14. However, in the case of technical services, modern methods of providing services enable non-residents to perform substantial services for customers in another country with virtually no physical presence in that country. The ability to earn income from a country with little or no physical presence in that country, together with concerns about base erosion and profit shifting in connection with the provision of technical services, in the opinion of the majority of the members of the Committee, justifies the absence of any threshold requirement as a condition for a country to tax fees for technical services.
34. Where remuneration for technical services is covered by both Article 12A and Article 7, paragraph 6 of Article 7 provides that the provisions of Article 12A shall prevail. However, this priority of Article 12A does not apply if the beneficial owner of the fees for technical services carries on business through a permanent establishment in the Contracting State in which the fees for technical services arise, and the services are effectively connected with that permanent establishment or with the business activity referred to in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 1 of Article 7. In this situation, paragraph 4 of Article 12A provides that the provisions of Article 7 shall apply instead of Article 12A.
35. Similarly, where remuneration for technical services is covered by both Article 12A and Article 14, paragraph 2 of Article 12A expressly provides that Article 12A shall apply notwithstanding the application of Article 14. However, the priority of Article 12A over Article 14 does not apply if the beneficial owner of the fees for technical services performs independent personal services in the Contracting State in which the fees for technical services arise through a fixed base situated in that State, and the technical services are effectively connected with that fixed base. In this situation, paragraph 4 of Article 12A provides that the provisions of Article 14 shall apply instead of Article 12A.
36. Article 12A does not overlap with Articles 15, 18 and 19, which concern income from employment, pensions and government services, respectively, since the definition of “fees for technical services” in paragraph 3 of Article 12A expressly excludes payments to employees, including pension payments. Thus, for example, payments received by an employee from an employer resident in a country for employment services performed outside that country will not be taxable in that country under paragraph 2 of Article 12A, even if those payments constitute fees for technical services.
37. Since paragraph 2 of Article 12A is subject to the provisions of Articles 8 (Shipping and Air Transport), 16 (Directors' Fees and Remuneration of Senior Executives) and 17 (Artistes and Sportspersons), Article 12A does not apply to fees for technical services to which the provisions of those Articles apply. In general, the taxing rights of a State under Articles 8, 17 or 18 are unlimited, whereas the taxing rights under paragraph 2 of Article 12A are limited to a maximum percentage of gross fees for technical services specified in that provision. The relationship between paragraph 2 of Article 12A and Articles 8, 17 and 18 is discussed further in the Commentary on paragraph 2.
B. Comments on the Paragraphs of Article 12A
Paragraph 1
38. This paragraph provides that fees for technical services arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of another Contracting State may be taxed in that other Contracting State. However, it does not provide that such fees shall be taxable exclusively in the State of residence.
39. In most cases, the person providing technical services receives fees for those services. If the person receiving the fees for technical services is not the person providing those services, the question of who is the proper taxpayer in respect of such fees is determined in accordance with domestic law. Where fees for technical services are paid to a person other than the person providing the services, Article 12A applies to the fees if the recipient is a resident of another Contracting State.
40. The definition of the term "fees for technical services" is provided in paragraph 3 and means any "payment" for managerial, technical or consultancy services. The term "payment" has a broad meaning, consistent with the meaning of the related term "paid" in Articles 10 and 11. As indicated in paragraph 3 of the Commentary on Article 10 (which quotes paragraph 7 of the Commentary on Article 10 of the OECD Model Convention) and paragraph 6 of the Commentary on Article 11 (which quotes paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention), the term payment means the fulfilment of an obligation to place funds at the disposal of the service provider in the manner stipulated by the contract or established practice.
41. Article 12A concerns only fees for technical services arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of another Contracting State. Accordingly, it does not apply to fees for technical services arising in a third State. Paragraphs 5 and 6 specify when fees for technical services are deemed to arise in a Contracting State and when they are not deemed to arise in a Contracting State, respectively. However, unlike Articles 10 and 11, which do not apply to dividends paid by a company resident in a third State or to interest arising in a third State, Article 12A applies to fees for technical services paid by a resident of a Contracting State or a third State that are borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base that the resident has in the other Contracting State.
Paragraph 2
42. This paragraph sets out the principle that the Contracting State in which fees for technical services arise may tax those fees in accordance with the provisions of its domestic law. However, where the beneficial owner of such payments is a resident of another Contracting State, the amount of tax charged by the State in which the fees for technical services arise may not exceed the maximum percentage of the gross amount of the payments established through bilateral negotiations.
43. Read together with Article 23 (Methods for the Elimination of Double Taxation), paragraph 2 establishes the primary right of the State in which fees for technical services arise to tax those fees in accordance with its domestic law (subject to the limitation on the maximum tax rate where the beneficial owner of the fees is a resident of another Contracting State). Accordingly, the State of which the recipient of the fees is a resident is required to prevent double taxation of such fees. Under Article 23 A or 23 B, the State of residence is required to provide relief from double taxation by exempting the fees for technical services from tax or by allowing a credit against the tax payable in the State of residence in respect of the fees for technical services for any tax imposed on those fees by the other Contracting State in accordance with Article 12A. In this regard, where a State applies the credit method of taxation under Article 23 A, it is entitled to apply the credit method under paragraph (2) of Article 23A in respect of items of income taxable under Articles 10, 11, 12 or 12A.
44. The decision not to recommend a maximum tax rate for fees for technical services is consistent with Articles 10, 11 and 12 of the United Nations Model Convention, which concern dividends, interest and royalties, respectively. This decision may be justified by current international practice. The withholding tax rates on technical service fees adopted in bilateral tax treaties between developed and developing countries vary considerably. Accordingly, the maximum tax rate on fees for technical services should be established through bilateral negotiations between the Contracting States.
45. The precise level of withholding tax on fees for technical services should take into account several factors, including the following:
— the possibility that a high withholding tax rate imposed by a State may result in non-resident service providers passing the cost of paying the tax on to customers within the State, which would mean that the State increases its revenue at the expense of its own residents rather than non-resident service providers;
— the possibility that a tax rate exceeding the foreign tax credit limit in the State of residence may discourage investment;
— the possibility that some non-resident service providers may incur high costs in providing technical services, so that a high withholding tax rate on gross fees may result in an excessively effective tax rate on the net income derived from the services;
— the potential benefit of applying the same withholding tax rate to royalties under Article 12 and fees for technical services under Article 12A. See Example 6, paragraphs 97 and 98;
— the fact that a reduction in the withholding tax rate has revenue and foreign exchange implications for the country imposing the tax; and
— the relative flows of payments for technical services (for example, from developing countries to developed countries).
46. Paragraph 2 applies irrespective of the provisions of Article 14. Under Article 14, income from the performance of professional or other independent personal services by a person who is a resident of one Contracting State is taxable by the other Contracting State only if the services are performed through a fixed base regularly available to that person in the other Contracting State, or if the person who is a resident of the other Contracting State is present in that State for 183 days or more during any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal period concerned.
47. Under paragraph 4, where a resident of one Contracting State provides independent personal services (which constitute technical services) in the other Contracting State through a fixed base regularly available to that resident and receives fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3 of Article 12A, Article 14 will apply to those payments in priority to Article 12A. However, where a resident of one Contracting State provides independent personal services (which constitute technical services) in the other Contracting State, but the services are not provided through a fixed base in the other State, the fees for those services are taxable by the other State in accordance with paragraph (2) of Article 12A.
48. Paragraph 2 applies in priority to Article 7 in accordance with paragraph 6 of Article 7. Accordingly, the conditions for taxing the profits of an enterprise under Article 7 do not apply to fees for technical services covered by paragraph 2. Fees for technical services are taxable by a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 2 if the fees arise in that State, regardless of whether the enterprise providing the services has a permanent establishment in that State, provides services similar to those provided through a permanent establishment, or provides technical services in that State. However, by virtue of paragraph 4, where an enterprise of one Contracting State provides technical services through a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State and receives fees for those technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3, Article 7 will apply to those payments in priority to paragraph 2 of Article 12A.
49. The application of paragraph 2 is directly subject to the provisions of Article 8. Certain payments for international sea transport, air transport or inland waterway transport under Article 8 may fall within the definition of "fees for technical services" contained in paragraph 3. This may be the case with respect to ancillary activities that are closely connected with the direct operation of ships and aircraft, as discussed in paragraph 11 of the Commentary on Article 8. To eliminate any uncertainty in this regard, paragraph 2 provides that, in any situation where Article 12A and Article 8 apply to the same services, the provisions of Article 8 shall prevail. Accordingly, any fees for technical services arising from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic or the operation of boats in inland waterways shall be taxable exclusively in accordance with Article 8.
50. Similarly, paragraph 2 is subject to the provisions of Article 16 concerning directors' fees and remuneration of top-level managerial officials. Accordingly, under Article 16, where directors' fees or remuneration of top-level managerial officials are taxable in the Contracting State of which the company paying the fees or remuneration is a resident, Article 12A cannot apply to those fees or remuneration, since paragraph 2 is expressly subject to the provisions of Article 16. The taxing rights of a Contracting State under Article 16 are unlimited, whereas the taxing rights under Article 12A are limited by the maximum tax rate agreed upon in paragraph 2. However, where payments fall outside the scope of Article 16 (because, for example, the fees are paid in respect of services provided by an individual in a capacity other than that of a director or senior officer of the company, such as an independent contractor), the other State is entitled to tax the fees in accordance with paragraph 2.
51. Similarly, paragraph 2 is expressly subject to the provisions of Article 17 concerning entertainers and sportspersons. Although it is unlikely that such activities would fall within the definition of "fees for technical services" provided in paragraph 3, it is important to ensure clarity in this regard. Accordingly, where there is an overlap between the provisions of paragraph 2 and Article 17, Article 17 shall prevail over Article 12A. However, where an entertainer or sportsperson resident in one Contracting State receives payment for technical services from a person resident in another Contracting State, and those fees fall outside the scope of Article 17 (for example, although the payment is made in respect of personal activities as an entertainer or sportsperson, the activities were nevertheless performed outside the country of which the payer is a resident), the first Contracting State is entitled to tax the fees in accordance with paragraph 2.
52. Paragraph 2 includes a beneficial ownership requirement in order to clarify the meaning of the words "paid to a resident" as used in paragraph 1 of the relevant Article. It clarifies that a Contracting State is not required to relinquish its right to tax fees for technical services merely because those fees have been paid directly to a resident of another State with which the first State has concluded a treaty.
53. Since the term "beneficial owner" is included in paragraph 2 to address potential difficulties arising from the use of the words "paid to a resident" in paragraph 1, it is intended that the term be interpreted in this context, rather than in any technical sense that it may have under the domestic law of a particular country. Accordingly, the term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense (for example, in the meaning it has under the trust law of many common law countries40); rather, it should be understood in the context of its application, particularly in relation to the concept of "paid to a resident", and in the light of the objects and purposes of the Convention, including the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion.
40 For example, where the trustees of a discretionary trust do not distribute technical service fees received during a particular period, those trustees, acting in their capacity as trustees (or the trust, if it is recognised as a separate taxpayer), may be the beneficial owners of such fees for the purposes of Article 12A, even if they are not beneficial owners under the relevant law.
54. Relief or exemption in respect of an item of income is granted by a State to a resident of another Contracting State in order to eliminate fully or partially the double taxation that would otherwise arise as a result of the simultaneous taxation of that income by the State of residence. Where income is paid to a resident of a Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, it would be inconsistent with the objects and purposes of the Convention for the State of source to grant tax relief or exemption merely because the immediate recipient of the income has the status of a resident of another Contracting State. The direct recipient of the income qualifies as a resident, but no potential double taxation arises as a consequence of that status, since the recipient is not regarded as the owner of the income for tax purposes in the State of residence.
It would equally be inconsistent with the objects and purposes of the Convention for a State to grant relief or exemption from tax where a resident of a Contracting State acts as an intermediary for another person who actually benefits from the relevant income through means other than agency or nominee arrangements. For these reasons, the report of the OECD Committee on Fiscal Affairs entitled "Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Conduit Companies"41 concludes that a conduit company generally cannot be regarded as the beneficial owner. Although it is the formal owner, in practice it has limited powers that make it, in relation to the relevant income, a fiduciary or administrator acting on behalf of the interested parties.
41 Reproduced on page R(6)-1 of Volume II of the full version of the Model Tax Convention.
55. In these various examples (an agent, a nominee, or a conduit company acting as a fiduciary or administrator), the immediate recipient of the fees for technical services is not the "beneficial owner", since the recipient's right to use the fees is restricted by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the fees received to another person. Such an obligation usually arises from the relevant legal documents, but it may also be established on the basis of facts and circumstances indicating that, in substance, the recipient clearly does not have the right to use and enjoy the fees without being bound by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the fees received to another person. This type of obligation would not include contractual or legal obligations that are independent of the receipt of the fees by the direct recipient, such as an obligation that is independent of the receipt of the fees and that the direct recipient has as a debtor or as a party to financial transactions. In cases where the recipient of fees for technical services genuinely has the right to use and enjoy those fees without being restricted by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the fees received to another person, the recipient is the "beneficial owner" of the payments.
56. The fact that the recipient of fees for technical services is considered to be the beneficial owner of those payments does not mean that the limitation on taxation provided for in paragraph 2 must automatically be granted. Such a limitation on taxation should not apply in cases of abuse of this provision. As explained in the section "Improper Use of the Convention" in the Commentary on Article 1, there are many ways of addressing problems associated with conduit company structures and, more broadly, situations involving treaty shopping. These include specific anti-abuse provisions in domestic law and tax treaties, general anti-abuse rules in domestic law and tax treaties, judicial doctrines such as approaches based on the primacy of substance over form or economic substance, as well as the interpretation of tax treaty provisions. While the concept of "beneficial owner" addresses certain forms of tax evasion (i.e. those involving the interposition of a recipient who is obligated to transfer the fees for technical services to someone else), it does not address other cases of treaty shopping and should therefore not be regarded as in any way limiting the application of other approaches to addressing such cases.
57. From the above explanations concerning the meaning of the term "beneficial owner", it is clear that the meaning attributed to this term in the context of this Article should be distinguished from the other meaning attributed to the term in other documents42 concerning the identification of persons (generally natural persons) who exercise ultimate control over enterprises or assets. This other meaning of the term "beneficial owner" cannot be applied in the context of the Convention. Indeed, that meaning, which refers to natural persons, is inconsistent with the clear wording of subparagraph 2(a) of Article 10, which refers to a situation in which a company is the beneficial owner of dividends. In the context of Articles 10, 11, 12 and 12A, the term "beneficial owner" is intended to address difficulties arising from the use of the word "paid" in relation to dividends, interest, royalties and fees for technical services, rather than difficulties relating to the ownership of the underlying asset, property or right in respect of which those amounts are paid. For this reason, it would be inappropriate, in the context of these Articles, to consider the meaning developed to identify natural persons who exercise "ultimate effective control over a legal entity or arrangement".43
42 38 See, for example, the Financial Action Task Force (hereinafter FATF), "International Standards on Combating Money Laundering and the Financing of Terrorism and Proliferation – FATF Recommendations" (OECD-FATF, Paris, 2012), which sets out in detail the international standard on combating money laundering and contains the following definition of beneficial owner (on page 109): "the natural person(s) who ultimately owns or controls a customer and/or the natural person on whose behalf a transaction is being conducted. It also includes those persons who exercise ultimate effective control over a legal person or arrangement". Similarly, the 2001 OECD Steering Group on Corporate Governance report "Behind the Corporate Veil: Using Corporate Structures for Illicit Purposes" (OECD, Paris, 2001) defines beneficial ownership as follows (on page 14): In this report, "beneficial ownership" refers to the ultimate beneficial ownership or interest of a natural person. In some situations, identifying the beneficial owner may require looking through various intermediary entities and/or individuals until the true owner, who is a natural person, is found. In the case of corporations, ownership belongs to shareholders or members. In partnerships, ownership interests are held by general partners and limited partners. In trusts and foundations, beneficial ownership refers to the beneficiaries, which may also include the holder of the rights of the settlor (the trustee) or the settlor.
43 See the definition of the Financial Action Task Force referred to above.
58. Subject to the other conditions laid down in this Article, the limitation on taxation in the State remains applicable where an intermediary, such as an agent or nominee located in another Contracting State or in a third State, is interposed between the beneficial owner and the payer, but the beneficial owner is a resident of another Contracting State. In 2001 and 2017, amendments were made to the text of the United Nations Model Convention (following amendments made in 1995 and 2014 to the OECD Model Convention) to clarify this point.
Paragraph 3
59. This paragraph does not specify the tax treatment in the State in which the fees for technical services are charged. Accordingly, it leaves that State free to apply its own laws and, in particular, to impose tax either by withholding at source or by individual assessment. As with other provisions of the United Nations Model Convention, procedural matters are not addressed in this Article. Each State may apply the procedure provided for under its domestic law.
60. This paragraph clarifies the meaning of the expression "fees for technical services" for the purposes of Article 12A. The definition of "fees for technical services" contained in paragraph 3 is exhaustive. "Fees for technical services" are limited to the payments described in paragraph 3; other payments for services are not included in this definition and are not covered by Article 12A. See the examples in paragraphs 87–103 below.
61. Article 12A applies only to fees for technical services, and not to all payments for services. In paragraph 3, "fees for technical services" are defined as fees for managerial, technical or consultancy services. Having regard to the ordinary meanings of the terms "managerial", "technical" and "consultancy", the fundamental concept underlying the definition of fees for technical services is that the services must involve the application by the service provider of special knowledge, skills or expertise on behalf of the client, or the transfer of knowledge, skills or expertise to the client, other than the transfer of information falling within the definition of "royalties" in paragraph 3 of Article 12. Ordinary services that do not involve the application of such special knowledge, skills or expertise do not fall within the scope of Article 12A.
62. The ordinary meaning of the term "managerial" implies the application of knowledge, skills or expertise to control or administer the activities of a business enterprise or organisation. Accordingly, where the management of an entire enterprise or a substantial part thereof is contracted out to persons who are not directors, officers or employees of the enterprise, the payments made by the enterprise for those management services will constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3. Similarly, payments made to a consultant for advice relating to the management of an enterprise (or the business of an enterprise) will constitute fees for technical services.
63. The ordinary meaning of the term "technical" implies the application of special knowledge, skills or expertise in relation to a particular art, science, profession or occupation. Accordingly, fees received for services provided by members of regulated professions, such as law, accounting, architecture, medicine, engineering and dentistry, will constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3. Thus, where an individual receives payments for the professional services referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 14 from a resident of a Contracting State, those payments will constitute fees for technical services. If the payments arise in that Contracting State because they are made by a resident of that State or are borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State, such payments will be taxable in that State under paragraph 2, irrespective of the fact that the services are not performed in that State through a fixed base there.
64. Technical services are not limited to the professional services referred to in Article 14, paragraph 2. Services performed by other specialists, such as pharmacists, and members of other professions, such as scientists, teachers, etc., may also constitute technical services where those services involve the provision of special knowledge, skills and expertise.
65. The ordinary meaning of the term "consultancy" implies the provision of advice or services of a specialised nature. Professionals generally provide advice or services that fall within the ordinary meaning of consultancy services, although, as noted in paragraphs 63 and 64, they may also constitute managerial or technical services.
66. The concepts of "managerial", "technical" and "consultancy" do not have precise meanings and may overlap. Thus, for example, services of a technical nature may also be services of a consultancy nature, and managerial services may also be regarded as services of a consultancy nature.
67. The definition of "fees for technical services" does not provide for a reference to the domestic law of a Contracting State. The absence of any reference to domestic law is justified because:
(a) the definition as a whole covers most types of services that are regarded as technical services under the domestic laws of countries that tax such services;
(b) such a reference would introduce a considerable element of uncertainty;
(c) future changes to the domestic law of a country concerning the taxation of fees for technical services could otherwise affect the Convention; and
(e) references to domestic law should be avoided in the United Nations Model Convention wherever possible.
The definition of "fees for technical services" would be inconsistent if the meaning of the terms used therein, particularly the terms "managerial", "technical" and "consultancy", were determined in accordance with the domestic law of the country applying the treaty under paragraph 2 of Article 3.
68. In accordance with the express provision in subparagraph 3(a), fees for technical services for the purposes of Article 12A do not include payments of wages, salaries or other remuneration to an employee of the payer. Where such payments are made by an employer resident in one Contracting State to an employee resident in another Contracting State, they fall within the scope of Article 15 or Article 19 (Government Service) of the Convention. Furthermore, since pensions accrue in connection with previous employment, they are excluded from Article 12A and are governed by Article 18 (Pensions and Social Security Payments), even if the employment involved the provision of technical services to the employer.
69. In accordance with paragraph 3, the definition of fees for technical services does not include payments for teaching at an educational institution or teaching by an educational institution. Accordingly, where an educational institution established in one Contracting State pays for teaching services provided by an individual or enterprise resident in another Contracting State, which would otherwise constitute fees for technical services, the payments made by the educational institution for those teaching services are excluded from the definition of "fees for technical services" under subparagraph 3(b). Furthermore, where an educational institution established in one Contracting State receives payments from an enterprise resident in another Contracting State for teaching services provided by that educational institution to certain employees of the enterprise, the payments received by the educational institution for those teaching services (to the extent that they would otherwise constitute fees for technical services) will not constitute fees for technical services covered by Article 16, by virtue of the specific exclusion in subparagraph 3(b). There is no definition of the term "educational institution" for the purposes of subparagraph 3(b). Accordingly, under paragraph 2 of Article 3 of the Convention, that term will have the meaning assigned to it under the law of the State applying the Convention. The meaning of the term will generally include universities, colleges and other post-secondary educational institutions. Countries in which the term "educational institution" has a very broad or unusual meaning may wish to clarify the meaning of that term in their treaties.
70. Some countries may be concerned that the exclusion in subparagraph 3(b) is excessively broad and uncertain and may be subject to abuse. Such countries may wish to remove the exclusion in subparagraph 3(b) entirely or limit it to teaching services provided as part of a degree-granting programme offered by an educational institution. Such countries may do so by adding the words "as part of a degree-granting programme" or similar words to subparagraph 3(b). In that case, fees received by an educational institution for teaching services of a managerial, technical or consultancy nature that do not form part of a degree-granting programme will constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3.
71. In accordance with subparagraph 3(c), the definition of "fees for technical services" does not include payments made by individuals for services for personal use. Such payments are generally not deductible by those individuals for tax purposes and therefore do not result in the erosion of the tax base of the State in which the fees for technical services arise. Furthermore, imposing withholding obligations on individuals in respect of such payments under domestic law would be difficult to enforce and could cause serious compliance problems for individuals using technical services provided remotely by non-residents.
The definition of "fees for technical services" in paragraph 3 does not exclude income from international sea transport, inland waterways and international air transport, income from entertainment and sporting activities, or pensions and social security payments. However, such income (even if it falls within the definition of "fees for technical services") is not taxable by a State under paragraph 2 if it is taxable under Article 8 (International Shipping and Air Transport), Article 17 (Entertainers and Sportspersons) or Article 18 (Pensions and Social Security Payments), as the case may be, since paragraph 2 is expressly subject to Articles 8, 17 and 18.
72. The definition of "fees for technical services" in paragraph 3 does not exclude income from international sea transport, inland waterways and international air transport, income from entertainment and sporting activities, or pensions and social security payments. However, such income (even if it falls within the definition of "fees for technical services") is not taxable by a State under paragraph 2 if it is taxable under Article 8 (International Shipping and Air Transport), Article 17 (Entertainers and Sportspersons) or Article 18 (Pensions and Social Security Payments), as the case may be, since paragraph 2 is expressly subject to Articles 8, 17 and 18.
73. Reimbursement of expenses differs from an allowance in that a person must account for the expenses actually incurred, and only those actual expenses may be reimbursed. The question is whether payments received as reimbursement of actual expenses incurred in connection with the provision of technical services should be included in the definition of "fees for technical services".
74. First, a person may be reimbursed for expenses incurred in connection with the provision of technical services, but no fee may be paid for those services. For example, a person resident in one Contracting State may be invited to speak at a conference or attend a meeting in another Contracting State and may be reimbursed for his or her travel expenses, but may receive no remuneration. In such circumstances, it appears difficult to justify the application of withholding tax to the reimbursement. However, unless the reimbursement is excluded from the definition of "fees for technical services", paragraph 2 would allow the State in which the fee arises to tax the reimbursement at source at the rate specified in the treaty.
75. Second, a non-resident service provider may be paid a fee and separately reimbursed for all expenses incurred in providing the services. In these circumstances, if the reimbursement of expenses is excluded from the definition of fees for technical services, the tax charged by the State in which the fee arises will be limited to the amount of the fee. In such circumstances, the fee represents the entire net profit of the non-resident from the provision of technical services. However, the maximum tax imposed under paragraph 2 is based on the gross amount of the payments, and the withholding tax rate specified in Article 12A may have been established on the assumption that the fee represents the gross income of the non-resident. As a result, if the reimbursement of expenses is excluded from the definition of fees for technical services, the withholding tax rate agreed upon by the Contracting States may prove to be too low. Furthermore, excluding reimbursements from the definition of fees for technical services may lead to abuse. For example, in order to reduce the withholding tax imposed by the source country, non-resident service providers may receive payments designated as reimbursements that are in fact fees, or may receive reimbursement for expenses that are not normally reimbursed. Preventing this type of abuse would create a significant administrative burden for tax authorities.
76. Third, a non-resident service provider may not be reimbursed for expenses incurred in providing the services. In this case, the amount of the payment received by the non-resident service provider will be greater than the amount of the service provider's net profit. The maximum withholding tax rate under paragraph 2 may have been agreed upon on the assumption that part of the non-resident's expenses would be reimbursed. On the basis of that assumption, the maximum withholding tax rate may be set at a higher level than would otherwise be the case, in order to bring the tax closer to the net profit. Accordingly, if reimbursement of expenses is excluded from the definition of "fees for technical services", the rate established by the treaty may be too high for a non-resident service provider who does not receive reimbursement of expenses.
77. The issues discussed in paragraphs 77 and 78 are illustrated in the example provided in paragraph 80, which shows that the impact of withholding tax based on the gross amount of income from technical services depends in part on whether payments reimbursing expenses are subject to withholding tax and the extent to which service providers recover their expenses.
78. Example: X, a resident of State A, is a management consultant who provides companies with advice on best practices in corporate governance. X enters into a contract to provide services to B Co, a publicly traded company resident in State B, for 60 days at a fee of 5,000 per day, plus reimbursement of reasonable expenses incurred in connection with the provision of the services. X receives from B Co a fee of 300,000 units and 250,000 units as reimbursement of expenses. Accordingly, in this situation, X's net profit from the services provided to B Co is 300,000 units. Assume that States A and B have concluded a tax treaty containing a provision identical to Article 12A of the United Nations Model Convention, which allows withholding tax on fees for technical services at a maximum rate of 5 per cent. On these facts, if it is assumed that the payment reimbursing X's expenses is not considered to be a fee for technical services, State B would be entitled to tax the fee received by X in the amount of 15,000 units, which represents a relatively low tax rate of 5 per cent on X's net profit. Conversely, if it is assumed that the payment reimbursing X's expenses is subject to withholding tax under Article 12A, State B would be entitled to charge tax in the amount of 27,500 units, representing a tax rate of more than 9 per cent of X's net profit. If X received no reimbursement for his expenses, the tax imposed by State B would amount to 15,000 units, corresponding to a tax rate of 30 per cent on X's net profit, regardless of whether payments reimbursing expenses are subject to withholding tax under Article 12A as fees for technical services.
79. It is extremely difficult to predict the average extent to which service providers reimburse their expenses. As a result, any single rule concerning the reimbursement of expenses will operate incorrectly in some situations. On the one hand, if reimbursement of expenses is excluded from the definition of "fees for technical services", the rate agreed upon in the treaty may be too low where most or all of the non-resident's expenses are reimbursed, and too high where no expenses are reimbursed. Furthermore, taxpayers may attempt to present part of the service fee as reimbursement of expenses, and it will be difficult for tax authorities to detect such abuse. On the other hand, if reimbursement of expenses is not excluded, the rate agreed upon in the treaty may be too high where the non-resident's expenses are reimbursed and too low where they are not reimbursed.
80. As a result of the difficulties described in the preceding paragraphs, it was decided to exclude any reference to reimbursement of expenses from the definition of "fees for technical services" in paragraph 3 of Article 12A. However, countries are advised to address this issue in their domestic law and to take it into account when establishing the maximum tax rate under paragraph 2 of Article 12A.
81. Although paragraph 3 defines the phrase "fees for technical services", it does not define the term "services". Similarly, other Articles of the United Nations Model Convention dealing with various types of services do not contain any definition of the term "services". Neither Article 14, which deals with professional and other independent personal services, nor Article 19, which deals with services provided to a Contracting State's government, contains a definition of the term "services". Similarly, the General Agreement on Trade in Services does not contain any definition of the term "services".
82. Although the term "services" in the expression "fees for technical services" is not defined in the context of Article 12A, the term "services" should be understood in its broad sense, in accordance with ordinary usage, and generally includes activities carried out by one person for the benefit of another person for a fee. Such activities may be performed in a wide variety of ways, and the manner in which such services are provided does not change their character for the purposes of Article 12A to the extent that such services fall within the definition of "fees for technical services" in paragraph 3.
83. It is often necessary to distinguish between fees for services, including fees for technical services, and royalties in order to determine whether Article 12 or another Article of the Convention applies (Article 12A in the case of "fees for technical services"). The distinction between fees for services and royalties is generally clear. Under paragraph 3 of Article 12, royalties are payments for the use of, or the right to use, certain types of property or information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience (so-called "know-how"). By contrast, the provision of services does not involve the transfer of the right to use, or the right to use, property. In practice, however, it is often difficult to distinguish between royalties and fees for services, including technical services, particularly in relation to so-called mixed contracts. Guidance on the distinction between fees for services and royalties is provided in paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention, which reproduces paragraphs 11.2–11.6 of the Commentary on Article 12 of the OECD Model Convention. See also paragraphs 100–103 below.
84. The following examples illustrate the application of the definition of "fees for technical services" in paragraph 3.
85. Example 1: X is a resident of State R and a cardiac surgeon. X's practice is conducted mainly in State R, although X occasionally travels to other countries to perform heart operations. X performs an operation in State R on an individual resident in State S. The tax treaty between State R and State S contains a provision identical to Article 12A of the United Nations Model Convention. Although the payments made by the patient, a resident of State S, to X would be considered fees for technical services arising in State S, they are expressly excluded from that definition by subparagraph (c) of paragraph 3. As a result, those payments will not be taxable in State S under paragraph 2 of Article 12A.
86. The result in Example 1 would be the same if X travelled to State S and provided surgical services in State S, unless X provided the services through a fixed base regularly available to X in State S, in which case Article 14 would apply.
87. Example 2: X is a resident of State R and a cardiac surgeon. X's practice is conducted mainly in State R, although X occasionally travels to other countries to perform heart operations. X enters into a contract with a medical services corporation resident in State S under which X agrees to perform heart operations on patients referred to X by the medical corporation. X is not an employee of the medical corporation. The operations are performed both in State S and in State R. The tax treaty between State R and State S contains a provision identical to Article 12A of the United Nations Model Convention. Under paragraph 3 of Article 12A, payments made by the medical corporation, a resident of State S, to X will be treated as fees for technical services arising in State S, irrespective of where the operation is performed—in State S, State R or a third State. As a result, those payments will be taxable in State S under paragraph 2. If X were an employee of the medical corporation, the payments to X would be excluded from the definition of "fees for technical services" under subparagraph 3(a).
88. Example 3: Company R is a resident of State R. Company R's business consists of collecting, organising and maintaining various databases. Company R sells access to these databases to its customers. One of Company R's customers is Company S, a resident of State S. States R and S have concluded a tax treaty containing a provision identical to Article 12A of the United Nations Model Convention. Payments received by Company R from Company S for access to its databases do not constitute fees for technical services under paragraph 3. Although Company R used its knowledge, skills and expertise in creating the database, the services provided by Company R to Company S—access to the database—are ordinary services that do not involve the application of Company R's knowledge, skills and expertise for the benefit of Company S. Accordingly, Article 12A will not apply to the payments.
89. However, if Company S had entered into a contract with Company R under which Company R created a specialised database adapted for use by Company S on the basis of information provided by Company S or collected by Company R, the payments made by Company S to Company R would constitute "fees for technical services" under paragraph 3. In this situation, Company R applies its knowledge, skills and expertise for the benefit of Company S. As a result, the payments will be taxable in State S under paragraph 2. It is irrelevant whether Company R performed all or any part of the services involved in creating the database in State S.
90. Example 4: Company R, a resident of State R, carries on an insurance business in both State R and State S. Company R insures a wide range of risks through standard-form insurance contracts. States R and S have a tax treaty that is consistent with the United Nations Model Convention, including Articles 5, 7 and 12A. Article 12A does not apply because the insurance premiums received by Company R cannot be considered fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3. Although Company R uses its knowledge, skills and expertise to develop various insurance products that are sold to its customers, Company R does not apply its knowledge, skills and expertise directly for the benefit of each individual customer.
91. In Example 4, if Company R issues individual insurance policies covering special risks for certain customers in State S, the insurance premiums received by Company R may be considered fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3. However, Company R will be deemed to have a permanent establishment in State S under paragraph 6 of Article 5 to the extent that it collects premiums or insures risks in State S otherwise than through an independent agent. Accordingly, by virtue of paragraph 4, the income derived from Company R's insurance activities in State S will be taxable in State S under Article 7, and Article 12A will not apply.
Example 5: Company R is a financial institution resident in State R. Company R provides its customers with a wide range of financial services, including accepting deposits, providing loans, credit and debit cards, payment and money transfer services, bank drafts, guarantees, foreign exchange, negotiable instruments, derivatives, investment research and advisory services. Company R conducts its business mainly in State R, but it also has customers in other States, including State S. States R and S have concluded a tax treaty identical to the United Nations Model Convention, including Article 12A.
92. Whether payments received for services provided by a financial institution constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3 depends on the nature of the particular services. Many services provided by financial institutions do not involve the application of any special knowledge, skills or expertise on behalf of a particular customer. Instead, the financial institution uses its knowledge, skills and expertise to develop general products, services or practices that are regularly provided to its customers for a fee. This applies, for example, to payment and money transfer services, bank drafts, currency exchange, debt and credit card servicing, and negotiable instruments.
93. However, where a financial institution uses its knowledge, skills and expertise to conduct research, analysis or provide advice to a particular customer in relation to that customer's specific circumstances, the payments received by the financial institution for those services may constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3. However, if Company R provides the services through a permanent establishment located in State S, the fees received for those services will be taxable in State S under Article 7, rather than Article 12A, by virtue of paragraph 4 (see paragraph 93).
94. Example 6: Company S, an enterprise resident in State S, enters into a contract with Company R, an enterprise resident in State R, for the right to use a patented chemical formula owned by Company R to manufacture an industrial substance. The contract also requires Company R to use its special knowledge and expertise to assist Company S in manufacturing the industrial substance in accordance with the specifications set out in the contract. In particular, Company R will provide its special knowledge and expertise to assist Company S in manufacturing the industrial substance in accordance with the specifications set out in the contract:
— to provide manufacturing procedures and assist Company S in carrying out those procedures; and
— to provide information on the materials, tools and containers required in the manufacturing process.
Company R also undertakes to use its best efforts to enable Company S to manufacture the industrial substance in the quantities and with the characteristics expected by Company S. States S and R have concluded a tax treaty containing provisions identical to those of the United Nations Model Convention, including Article 12A.
In Example 6, the payments made by Company S to Company R for the right to use the patented formula would constitute royalties within the meaning of paragraph 3 of Article 12. However, the payments for the services provided by Company R to Company S would not constitute royalties, since Company R does not transfer its special knowledge, skills or expertise to Company S. In Example 6, Company R uses its special knowledge, skills and expertise on behalf of Company S and guarantees the result of Company S's use of the patented chemical formula. Accordingly, the payments made by Company S to Company R for the services constitute fees for technical services within the meaning of paragraph 3, and State S will be entitled to tax those payments under paragraph 2.
95. As noted in paragraphs 4 and 5 above, under the United Nations Model Convention in its previous version, before 2017, it was difficult, but important, to determine whether certain payments constituted royalties or fees for services. If the payments were royalties, they were taxable in the Contracting State in which they arose under Article 12, subject to the tax rate limitation in paragraph 2 of Article 12. On the other hand, if the payments constituted fees for services, they would be taxable in a Contracting State only if the service provider had a permanent establishment or fixed base in that State and the payments were attributable to that permanent establishment or fixed base under Article 7 or Article 14. Accordingly, the tax liabilities differed significantly depending on whether the payments were classified as royalties or fees for services. Determining whether payments constituted royalties or fees for services was particularly difficult in relation to mixed contracts providing for the transfer of the use of, or the right to use, information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience and the provision of services.
100. The addition of Article 12A to the United Nations Model Convention in 2017 resulted in a potential reduction in the significance of the distinction between royalties and fees for technical services, where the tax rate limitations in paragraph 2 of Article 12 and paragraph 2 of Article 12A are identical. If these tax rates are identical, it will not matter whether payments under mixed contracts are considered royalties for the transfer of technology or fees for technical services. However, if the maximum tax rates under these two Articles differ, it is important to determine whether a particular payment constitutes a royalty taxable under Article 12, a fee for technical services under Article 12A, or some other type of payment.
101. The following example illustrates the distinction between a fee for the transfer of technology (know-how) and a fee for technical services. The considerations to be taken into account when making this distinction are discussed in paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 12.
102. Example 7: Company S, an enterprise resident in State S, enters into a contract with Company R, an enterprise resident in State R, to obtain the right to use a secret formula or process developed by Company R. Under the contract, Company R is required to provide information to Company S under strict conditions and to use its special knowledge and expertise to train Company S's employees in the use of the secret formula or process. States R and S have concluded a tax treaty containing provisions identical to those of the United Nations Model Convention, including Articles 12A and 12A.
103. In Example 7, the payments made by Company S to Company R for the right to use the secret formula or process will constitute payments for "information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience" within the meaning of the definition of "royalties" in paragraph 3 of Article 12. This will be the case even if the information constitutes know-how technology that is not patented or otherwise protected by intellectual property laws. Accordingly, regardless of whether the payments for training are specified separately from the payments for the secret formula or process, or the contract provides for a single payment for both the formula or process and the training, the payments for training will be considered royalties under Article 12, rather than fees for technical services under Article 12A. However, if the training provided by Company R was not necessary for the transfer of the secret formula or process to Company S, and Company S could have obtained such training from other sources, the training would not be considered a transfer of technology, and the pay...
Fees for services shall be considered fees for technical services if they fall within the definition of “fees for technical services” in paragraph 3 of Article 12A.
Paragraph 4
- This paragraph provides that paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply to fees for technical services if the person providing the services has a permanent establishment or a fixed base in the State in which the fees arise and the fees are effectively connected with that permanent establishment or fixed base. In this respect, paragraph 4 is similar to paragraph 4 of Article 10, paragraph 4 of Article 11 and paragraph 4 of Article 12. Thus, where a resident of one Contracting State provides technical services through a permanent establishment or fixed base situated in the other Contracting State, the fees received for those services shall be taxable in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated, in accordance with Article 7 or Article 14, and not in accordance with Article 12A.
- Since Article 7 of the United Nations Model Convention contains a “limited force of attraction” rule, which expands the range of income taxable as business profits, paragraph 4 also renders paragraphs 1 and 2 inapplicable where the fees for technical services are effectively connected with business activities in the State in which the fees arise that are of the same or a similar kind as the activities carried on through the permanent establishment.
This paragraph does not define the meaning of the expression “effectively connected”. As a result, the question of whether fees for technical services are effectively connected with a permanent establishment, a fixed base or business activities similar to those carried on through a permanent establishment must be decided on the basis of all the relevant facts and circumstances in each particular case. In general, fees for technical services will be considered effectively connected with a permanent establishment or fixed base if the technical services are closely related to the permanent establishment or fixed base, or if the business activities are similar to those carried on through the permanent establishment. This will be the case where the payment to the person providing the services is borne by the permanent establishment or fixed base in the State in which the fees arise.
- Where paragraph 4 applies, the fees for technical services are taxable by the State in which they arise as part of the profits attributable to the permanent establishment under Article 7, or the income attributable to the fixed base under Article 14. Thus, paragraph 4 relieves the State in which the payments for technical services arise of the restrictions on its taxing rights imposed by Article 12A. In cases where Article 7 applies as a result of the application of paragraph 4, most countries consider that the State in which the permanent establishment is situated is permitted to tax only the net profits from technical services attributable to the permanent establishment. Article 7 does not prevent the taxation of business profits attributable to a permanent establishment on a gross basis; however, a Contracting State must not discriminate against residents of the other State in violation of paragraph 3 of Article 24 (Non-Discrimination). Similarly, where Article 14 applies, most countries consider that the State in which the fixed base is situated is permitted to tax only the net income derived from the provision of technical services. However, it may be useful for States to clarify these issues during treaty negotiations (see paragraphs 9 and 10 of the Commentary on Article 14).
Paragraphs 5 and 6
Paragraph 5 establishes the principle that the State in which fees for technical services arise for the purposes of Article 12A is the State of which the person making the payments is a resident, or the State in which the payer has a permanent establishment or fixed base, if the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. It is not necessary for the services to be performed in the Contracting State in which the payer is a resident or has a permanent establishment or fixed base. The question of whether a person is a resident of a Contracting State for the purposes of Article 12A is determined in accordance with the provisions of Article 4 of the Convention.
- Where there is an evident economic connection between the technical services provided and the permanent establishment or fixed base of the payer to whom the services are provided, the fees for technical services are deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated. This result applies irrespective of the residence of the owner of the permanent establishment or fixed base, even if the owner is resident in a third State.
- In the absence of an economic connection between the technical services and the permanent establishment or fixed base, payments for technical services are deemed to arise in the Contracting State in which the payer is a resident. If the payer of the fees for technical services is not a resident of a Contracting State, Article 12A does not apply to the fees for technical services, except where the payer has a permanent establishment or fixed base in a Contracting State and there is a clear economic connection between the technical services and the permanent establishment or fixed base. Otherwise, the fees for technical services would effectively be subject to the “force of attraction” principle, which would be inconsistent with the other provisions of the United Nations Model Convention.
- Paragraph 5 is subject to paragraph 6, which provides an exception to the source rule in paragraph 5. Under paragraph 6, fees for technical services paid by a resident of one Contracting State shall not be deemed to arise in that State if that resident (the payer) carries on business through a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State or provides independent personal services through a fixed base in the other Contracting State or in a third State, and the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. Consequently, in such circumstances, the Contracting State in which the payer is a resident shall not be entitled to tax the payments for technical services under paragraph 2.
- The expression “borne by” should be interpreted in the light of the main purpose of paragraphs 5 and 6, which is to establish source rules for fees for technical services. A Contracting State is entitled to tax fees for technical services under paragraph 2 only if the fees arise in that State. The basic source rule in paragraph 5 provides that fees for technical services arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State or if the payer has a permanent establishment or fixed base in the Contracting State and the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. However, the basic rule is limited by the exception rule in paragraph 6, where the payer is a resident of one Contracting State, but the fees for technical services are borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base that the payer has in the other Contracting State.
- If the fees for technical services are paid for the purposes of carrying on business through a permanent establishment or for the purposes of providing independent personal services through a fixed base, such fees will normally be deductible in calculating the profits attributable to the permanent establishment under Article 7 or the income attributable to the fixed base under Article 14. The deduction of fees for technical services provides an objective standard for determining that the payments have a close economic connection with the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
- The fact that the payer has or has not actually claimed a deduction for the amount of the fees for technical services in calculating the profits of the permanent establishment or the income of the fixed base is not necessarily conclusive, since the appropriate criterion is to determine whether any deduction allowed in respect of those services should be taken into account in determining the profits attributable to the permanent establishment or the income attributable to the fixed base. Thus, for example, this criterion will be satisfied even if no amount has actually been deducted as a result of the permanent establishment or fixed base being exempt from tax, or as a result of the payer simply choosing not to claim a deduction to which it was entitled. The test will also be satisfied if the fees for technical services are not deductible for any reason other than that the fees for technical services should not be attributed to the permanent establishment or fixed base.
- The application of paragraphs 5 and 6 may be illustrated by the following examples.
- Example 8: Enterprise R operates under the direction of a resident of State R. Enterprise R provides technical services to Company S, a resident of State S. The tax treaty between State R and State S is identical to the United Nations Model Convention, including Article 12A. Company S carries on business in State S and in State R (or a third State) through a permanent establishment situated there. However, the technical services provided by Enterprise R to Company S relate to the activities of Company S carried on in State S, and not to the activities carried on through the permanent establishment in State R (or the third State).
- In Example 8, since the payments are made by Company S, which is a resident of State S, and are not borne by Company S’s permanent establishment in State R, the fees for technical services shall be deemed to be paid in State S under paragraph 5. Consequently, State S shall have the right to tax the fees for technical services under paragraph 2.
- Example 9: The circumstances are the same as in Example 8, except that the fees for technical services are borne by Company S’s permanent establishment in State R.
In Example 9, since the fees for technical services are borne by Company S’s permanent establishment situated in State R, paragraph 6 applies, under which the fees for technical services are not deemed to arise in State S. Consequently, the fees for technical services are not taxable in State S under paragraph 2, but are taxable exclusively in State R under paragraph 1 of Article 12A.
- In Example 9, Article 12A of the Convention denies State S the right to tax the fees for technical services, notwithstanding the fact that they are paid by a resident of State S. Such a result is justified because the fees relate to the business activities carried on by the resident of State S in State R. In such a situation, where the fees for technical services are deducted in calculating the profits of the enterprise attributable to a permanent establishment situated in the other Contracting State, or in calculating the income from independent personal services performed through a fixed base situated in the other Contracting State, these payments have a closer economic connection with the activities carried on in that other State than with those carried on in State S.
- Example 10: Enterprise T operates under the direction of a resident of State T. Enterprise T carries on business through a permanent establishment situated in State S, or provides independent personal services through a permanent establishment situated in State S, or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated in State S. Enterprise T pays Company R, a resident of State R, for technical services provided by Company R to Enterprise T in connection with its income-generating activities carried on in State S. The payments made by Enterprise T to Company R for technical services are deductible in calculating the profits attributable to Enterprise T’s permanent establishment in State S, or the income attributable to Enterprise T’s fixed base in State S. The tax treaty between State S and State T is identical to the United Nations Model Convention, including Article 12A.
In Example 10, notwithstanding the fact that the fees for technical services are not paid by a resident of State S, they are borne by the permanent establishment or fixed base that Enterprise T has in State S. In such circumstances, the fees for technical services have a close economic connection with the income-generating activities of Enterprise T carried on in State S. Accordingly, the fees are deemed to arise in State S under paragraph 5, and State S is entitled to tax the payments under paragraph 2.
- With respect to interest and royalties, paragraph 21 of the Commentary on Article 11 and paragraph 19 of the Commentary on Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention state that countries may replace the rule defining the source of interest or royalties as the State in which the loan giving rise to the interest, or the property or right giving rise to the royalties, was used. A similar source rule may be substituted for the purposes of Article 12A. Similarly, as suggested in the Commentaries on Articles 11 and 12, where the parties disagree during bilateral negotiations on the appropriate rule, a possible solution may be a rule that generally recognizes the payer’s State of residence as the source of fees for technical services, but where the technical services are used or consumed in a State applying the place-of-use rule, the payment shall be deemed to arise in that State.
- Other alternative rules for determining the source of fees for technical services are also possible. These alternatives include the following:
— The Contracting States may decide not to include paragraph 6. If paragraph 6 is excluded from Article 12A, fees for technical services shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the payer is a resident, even if those fees are paid for the purposes of a permanent establishment or fixed base of the payer situated outside the payer’s State of residence.
— The Contracting States may decide not to include paragraph 6 and to revise paragraph 5 so that fees for technical services shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State only if the payer is a resident of that State and the technical services are used or consumed by the payer in that State; or if the payer is not a resident of a Contracting State, the payer has a permanent establishment or fixed base situated in a Contracting State and the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. In this case, technical services used or consumed by a resident of a Contracting State outside that State shall not be deemed to arise in that State, and that State shall not be entitled to tax the fees for such services under Article 12A. Paragraph 6 would be redundant, since technical services used or consumed outside the Contracting State would include any technical services incurred for the purposes of a permanent establishment or fixed base of a resident situated outside that State.
— Fees for technical services may be deemed to arise in a Contracting State only if the payer is a resident of that State and the technical services are provided in that State, or if the payer, not being a resident of a Contracting State, has a permanent establishment or fixed base situated in a Contracting State and the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. In this case, the Contracting State would be entitled to tax fees for technical services paid by its residents to residents of the other Contracting State if the technical services are provided in that State. In this situation, paragraph 6 would be redundant.
- Paragraph 6 does not provide a solution for the case where the beneficial owner and the payer are residents of Contracting States, but the fees for technical services were incurred for the benefit of a permanent establishment or fixed base owned by the payer in a third State, and the fees for technical services are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base. In such a case, the fees for technical services are deemed to arise in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident under paragraph 5, and not in the third State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated. Thus, the fees for technical services will be taxable both in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident and in the Contracting State of which the beneficial owner is a resident. Although double taxation will be eliminated between these two States, it will not be eliminated between them and the third State if the third State taxes the fees for technical services because they are borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base within its territory. In this respect, paragraph 6 is consistent with paragraph 5 of Article 11 and paragraph 5 of Article 12.
- As explained in paragraph 21 of the Commentary on Article 11 (which cites paragraphs 29 and 30 of the Commentary on Article 11 of the OECD Model Convention), if the third State does not tax the fees for technical services, attempts may be made to avoid taxation in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident by using a permanent establishment or fixed base situated in such a third State. States for which this is not a concern and which wish to address the problem described in the preceding paragraph may do so by agreeing in their bilateral convention to the alternative wording of paragraph 6 proposed in paragraph 127 below.
- As indicated in paragraph 126, the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident and the State of which the person making the payment for technical services is a resident may avoid the double taxation described in paragraph 125 above by agreeing to the following wording of paragraph 6:
- For the purposes of this Article, fees for technical services shall not be deemed to arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State and carries on business in the other Contracting State or a third State through a permanent establishment situated in that other or third State, or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated in that other or third State, and such fees are borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base.
Such wording will ensure that paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply to fees for technical services, since they do not arise in the Contracting State. As a result, such fees for technical services will generally fall under Article 7 or 14.
Paragraph 7
- The purpose of paragraph 7 is to limit the application of the provisions concerning the taxation of fees for technical services in cases where, by reason of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner of the fees, or between both of them and some other person, the amount of the fees paid exceeds the amount that would have been agreed upon by the payer and the beneficial owner if they had entered into an arm’s-length contract. Paragraph 7 provides that in such a case the provisions of the Article shall apply only to the latter-mentioned amount, and the excess portion of the fees for technical services shall remain taxable under the laws of the two Contracting States, due regard being had to the other provisions of the Convention.
- As follows from the text, for this paragraph to apply, the fees for technical services considered excessive must be attributable to a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner of the fees, or between both of them and some other person. Examples of such special relationships include cases where the fees for technical services are paid to an individual or legal entity that directly or indirectly controls the payer, or is directly or indirectly controlled by an individual, or is subject to a group having common interests with an individual. Furthermore, these examples are similar or analogous to the cases covered by Article 9.
- On the other hand, the concept of special relationships also covers blood or marital relationships and, in general, any community of interests as distinct from the legal relationships giving rise to the fees for technical services.
- As regards the tax treatment to be applied to the excess portion of the fees for technical services, the exact nature of such excess must be determined according to the circumstances of each case in order to determine the category of income to which it should be attributed for the purposes of applying the tax laws of the respective States and the provisions of the Convention. Unlike paragraph 6 of Article 11, which, through the restrictive phrase “having regard to the debt-claim for which it is paid”, allows only an adjustment of the rate at which interest is charged, paragraph 7 permits the fees for technical services to be reclassified so as to give them a different character. This paragraph may affect not only the recipient of the fees but also the person paying the excess amount of the fees for technical services; if the law of the State in which the payer is a resident or has a permanent establishment or fixed base permits this, the excess amount may be disallowed as a deduction, having regard to the other applicable provisions of the Convention. If the two Contracting States encounter difficulties in determining which other provisions of the Convention apply, depending on the circumstances, to the excess portion of the fees for technical services, nothing shall prevent them from making additional clarifications to the last sentence of paragraph 7, provided that they do not alter its general meaning.
- Where the principles and rules of the relevant laws require the two Contracting States to apply different Articles of the Convention for the purposes of taxing the excess portion of the fees for technical services, it will be necessary to resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in the Convention in order to resolve the situation.
Article 13
CAPITAL GAINS
A. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS
- Article 13 of the United Nations Model Convention consists of the first four paragraphs of Article 13 of the OECD Model Convention. Paragraph 5 is a separate provision of the United Nations Model Convention. Paragraph 6 corresponds to paragraph 5 of the OECD Model Convention, with the numbering adjusted to take account of the addition of the extra paragraph.
- The text of this Article was developed as a result of a compromise which, in the opinion of the former Group of Experts, would be most acceptable to both developed and developing countries. Some members of the Group from developed countries advocated the use of Article 13 of the OECD Model Convention, which: 1) allows the source country to tax capital gains from the alienation of immovable property and from the alienation of movable property forming part of a permanent establishment or pertaining to a fixed base in connection with the provision of independent personal services; 2) allows capital gains from the alienation of ships or aircraft to be taxed only by the State in which the place of effective management of the relevant enterprise is situated; and 3) leaves the right to tax capital gains from other forms of alienated property to the State of residence. The majority of the Group members from developing countries advocated the right of the source country to tax in cases where the OECD leaves that right to the State of residence.
- With regard to the taxation of capital gains, the following observations made in the preliminary remarks to the Commentary on Article 13 of the 2010 OECD Model Convention remain valid for both developed and developing countries:
- A review of the tax legislation of OECD member countries shows that the taxation of capital gains varies considerably from country to country:
— In some countries, capital gains are not considered taxable income;
— In others, capital gains derived by an enterprise are taxable, whereas capital gains derived by an individual outside the scope of their professional or business activities are not taxable;
— Even where capital gains derived by an individual outside the scope of their professional or business activities are taxable, such taxation is often applied only in specifically defined cases, for example, in respect of gains from the sale of immovable property or speculative income (where an asset is acquired for the purpose of resale).
- In addition, capital gains taxes differ from country to country. In some OECD member countries, capital gains are taxed as ordinary income and are therefore added to income from other sources. This applies in particular to capital gains from the alienation of business assets. However, in a number of OECD member countries, capital gains are subject to special taxes, such as a tax on profits from the alienation of immovable property, a general capital gains tax or a tax on increases in capital value (capital appreciation tax). Such taxes are levied on each capital gain or on the amount of capital gains accrued during the year, in most cases at special rates that do not take into account the taxpayer’s other income (or losses). It is not necessary to describe all these taxes.
- This Article does not deal with the above-mentioned issues. The decision as to whether capital gains are taxable and the manner in which the tax is collected is left to the domestic law of the Contracting States. Nothing in this Article may be interpreted as granting a State the right to tax capital gains if such a right is not provided for under its domestic law. The Article does not specify the type of tax to which it applies; it is understood that the Article should apply to all types of taxes levied by a Contracting State on capital gains. The wording of Article 2 is sufficiently broad to achieve this purpose and to extend its application also to special capital gains taxes.
- The OECD Commentary on Article 13 contains the following general observations:
- The right to tax capital gains from the alienation of property of a particular kind should, as a rule, be granted to the State which, under the Convention, is entitled to tax both the property and the income derived from it. The right to tax gains from the alienation of a business asset should be granted to the same State, irrespective of whether such a gain is a capital gain or a business profit. Accordingly, no distinction is made between capital gains and business profits, and there is no need for special provisions specifying which Article should apply — the Article on capital gains or Article 7 on business profits. However, the decision whether to levy tax on capital gains or ordinary income tax is left to the domestic tax legislation of the State. The Convention does not prescribe a solution to this issue.
- This Article does not contain a detailed definition of capital gains. For the reasons stated above, this is not necessary. The words “alienation of property” are used in relation, in particular, to capital gains arising from the sale or exchange of property, as well as from partial alienation, expropriation, transfer of property to a company in exchange for shares, sale of a right, gift and even the transfer of property upon death.
- Most States levy tax on capital gains from the alienation of fixed assets. However, some tax only so-called realized capital gains. Under certain circumstances, notwithstanding the alienation, no realized capital gain is recognized for tax purposes (for example, where the proceeds from the alienation are used to acquire new assets). The existence or absence of realization of a capital gain must be determined in accordance with the applicable domestic tax law. Where the State having the right to tax does not exercise that right at the time of the alienation, no particular problems arise.
- As a rule, an increase in value not connected with the alienation of a capital asset is not taxed, since, as long as the owner continues to hold that asset, the capital gain exists only on paper. However, there are tax laws under which tax on increases in capital value and the revaluation of business assets is levied even where no alienation takes place.
- Under special circumstances, a tax on increases in capital value may be levied on an asset that has not been alienated. This may occur where the value of a capital asset has increased in such a way that the owner revalues that asset in its accounting records. Such revaluation of assets in the records may also be carried out in the event of a depreciation of the national currency. A number of States levy a special tax on such book profits, reserved amounts, increases in paid-up capital and other revaluations resulting from adjustments of the book value to the actual value of the capital asset. These taxes on increases in capital value (capital appreciation taxes) are governed by the Convention under Article 2.
- If an increase in capital value or a revaluation of assets is taxed, the same principle should, as a rule, apply in the case of the alienation of such assets. It was considered that there was no need to specify such cases expressly in the Article or to establish special rules. The provisions of this Article, as well as Articles 6, 7 and 21, appear to be sufficient. As a rule, the right to tax is granted, in accordance with the above-mentioned provisions, to the State of which the alienating person is a resident, except in the case of immovable property or movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment [or pertaining to a fixed base], in respect of which the primary right to tax belongs to the State in whose territory such property is situated. However, particular attention should be paid to the cases considered in paragraphs 13–17 below.
- In some States, the transfer of an asset from a permanent establishment situated in the territory of that State to a permanent establishment or head office of the same enterprise situated in another State is treated as an alienation of property. This Article does not prevent such States from taxing the profits or gains considered to have arisen in connection with such a transfer, provided, however, that such taxation does not conflict with Article 7.
- The Article makes no distinction based on the origin of the capital gain. Therefore, it covers any capital gain — whether accumulated over a long period in parallel with gradual improvements in economic conditions, or arising over a very short period (speculative income). It also includes capital gains resulting from the depreciation of the national currency. Naturally, the decision on whether to tax such gains is left to the discretion of each State.
- The Article does not specify how capital gains are to be calculated; this is determined by the applicable domestic law. As a rule, capital gains are calculated by deducting the amount of costs from the selling price. For the purpose of determining the amount of costs, all costs associated with acquisition and all expenses for improvements are added to the purchase price. In some cases, the value after depreciation allowances have already been made is taken into account. Some tax laws prescribe the use of a basis other than costs, for example, the value of the asset previously stated by the alienating person for tax purposes.
- Special problems may arise if the taxable base for capital gains differs in the two Contracting States. A capital gain from the alienation of an asset, calculated in one State according to the rules set out in paragraph 12 above, will not necessarily coincide with the capital gain calculated in the other State under the accounting rules applied there. This may occur if one State is entitled to tax the capital gain because it is the State in which the property is situated, while the other is entitled to tax it because the enterprise is a resident of that other State.
- The following example may illustrate this problem. An enterprise of State A acquired immovable property situated in State B. The enterprise may have made depreciation allowances in the accounting records maintained in State A. If such immovable property is sold at a price higher than its value, a capital gain may be realized and, in addition, previously claimed depreciation allowances may be recaptured. State B, in whose territory the immovable property is situated and where no accounting records are maintained, is not obliged, when taxing the income from that immovable property, to take into account the depreciation allowances made in State A. Nor can State B use the value of the immovable property shown in the accounting records maintained in State A instead of the value at the time of alienation. Therefore, State B is not entitled to tax depreciation allowances recaptured separately from the capital gain, as indicated in paragraph 12 above.
- On the other hand, State A, of which the alienating person is a resident, cannot in all cases be required to exempt such book profit fully from its taxes under paragraph 1 of this Article and Article 23A (problems with the application by States of the tax credit method are unlikely to arise). To the extent that such book profit results from the recapture of depreciation allowances previously claimed in State A and which reduced the income or profits taxable in that State A, that State cannot be prevented from taxing such book profit […].
- Additional problems may arise in connection with profits resulting from exchange rate fluctuations between the currencies of State A and State B. Following a devaluation of the currency of State A, enterprises of that State A may or may not be required to increase the book value of assets situated outside the territory of State A. Apart from the devaluation of a State’s currency, so-called foreign exchange gains and losses may arise as a result of ordinary fluctuations in exchange rates. Take, for example, an enterprise of State A that acquired and sold immovable property situated in the territory of State B. If the cost and selling price, both expressed in the currency of State B, are equal, there will be no capital gain in State B. If, during the period between the acquisition and sale of the asset, the value of the currency of State B has increased relative to the currency of State A, a profit will be attributed to such an enterprise in the currency of that State. If the value of the currency of State B has fallen during that period, the alienating person will incur a loss that will not be recognized in State B. Such foreign exchange gains and losses may also arise in connection with receivables and payables under contracts denominated in a foreign currency. If the balance sheet of the permanent establishment situated in State B shows receivables and payables denominated in the currency of State B, gains or losses upon settlement of the debt will not be reflected in the accounting records of the permanent establishment. However, changes in exchange rates may be reflected in the accounts of the head office. If the value of the currency of State B increases (decreases) during the period between the creation of the receivable and its settlement, the enterprise as a whole will realize a gain (incur a loss). The same applies to payables if, during the period from their creation to their settlement, the currency of State B falls (rises) in value.
- The provisions of this Article do not regulate all issues concerning the taxation of such foreign exchange gains. In most cases, such gains are not connected with the alienation of an asset; in many cases, they cannot even be determined by the State to which this Article grants the right to tax capital gains. Accordingly, the question is generally not whether the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is situated has the right to tax, but whether the State of which the taxpayer is a resident should, when applying the exemption method, refrain from taxing foreign exchange gains that in many cases can be reflected nowhere other than in the accounting records of the head office. The answer to the latter question is determined not only by this Article, but also by Article 7 and Article 23A. If, in this case, a difference of opinion between the two States actually results in double taxation, the matter should be resolved in accordance with the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25.
- Furthermore, the question arises as to which Article should apply where the consideration for property sold is paid to the alienating person in the form of a life annuity rather than a fixed price. Should such regular payments, if they exceed the costs, be treated as a gain from the alienation of property or as “items of income” not dealt with under Article 21? Equally strong arguments may be advanced in support of both views and it will probably be difficult to establish one general rule on this issue. Moreover, such problems rarely arise in practice, so it does not appear necessary to establish an appropriate rule and introduce it into the Convention. This issue may be left to be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25 by the Contracting States in which such a problem may arise.
- The Article is not intended to apply to lottery winnings or to premiums and prizes provided for by bonds or debentures.
- The Article primarily concerns gains that may be taxed in the State in whose territory the alienated property is situated. With respect to all other types of capital gains, paragraph [6] grants the right to tax to the State of which the alienating person is a resident.
- Since capital gains are not taxed by all States, it appears appropriate to avoid only actual double taxation of capital gains. Therefore, the Contracting States are entitled to supplement their bilateral convention so that a State relinquishes its right to tax, granted to it under domestic law, only if the other State, which has the right to tax under the Convention, has exercised that right. In this case, the relevant additions should be made to paragraph [6] of this Article. In addition, amendments should be made to Article 23A, as proposed in the [...] Commentary on Article 23A.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE PARAGRAPHS OF ARTICLE 13
Paragraph 1
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 13 of the OECD Model Convention, the Commentary on which states the following:
- Paragraph 1 provides that gains from the alienation of immovable property may be taxed in the State in which it is situated. This rule corresponds to the provisions of Article 6 and paragraph 1 of Article 22. It also applies to immovable property forming part of the assets of an enterprise [or used for the provision of independent personal services]. With regard to the definition of immovable property, paragraph 1 refers to Article 6. Paragraph 1 of Article 13 concerns only gains derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States from the alienation of immovable property situated in the other Contracting State. Therefore, it does not apply to gains derived from the alienation of immovable property situated in the territory of the Contracting State of which the alienating person is a resident within the meaning of Article 4, or situated in a third State; such gains are subject to the provisions of paragraph 5 [paragraph 6 of the United Nations text] (and not to the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 21, as stated in this Commentary prior to 2002).
- The rules of paragraph 1 are supplemented by the provisions of paragraph 4, which applies to income from the alienation of all or part of the shares of a company owning immovable property […].
Paragraph 2
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 13 of the 2010 OECD Model Convention, the Commentary on which states the following:
- Paragraph 2 concerns movable property forming part of the property of a permanent establishment of an enterprise [or pertaining to a fixed base used for the provision of independent personal services]. The term “movable property” means all property other than immovable property referred to in paragraph 1. It also includes intangible property, such as intangible assets, licences, etc. The proceeds from the alienation of such assets may be taxed in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated, which is consistent with the rules concerning business profits [and income from the provision of independent personal services] (Article[s] 7 [and 14]).
- This paragraph clearly states that its provisions apply to the alienation of movable property of a permanent establishment [or fixed base], as well as to the alienation of the permanent establishment itself (separately or together with the entire enterprise) [or the fixed base itself]. If an entire enterprise is alienated, this provision applies to such gain as is considered to have been derived from the alienation of movable property forming part of the property of the permanent establishment. In that case, the provisions of Article 7 should apply with the necessary modifications, without an express reference to them. With regard to the transfer of an asset from a permanent establishment in one State to a permanent establishment (or head office) in another State, see paragraph 10 above.
On the other hand, paragraph 2 is not always applicable to capital gains from the alienation of an interest in an enterprise. This provision applies only to property that was owned by the alienating person, either wholly or jointly with another person. Under the laws of some countries, the principal assets of a partnership are considered to be owned by the partners. However, under certain other laws, partnerships and other associations are treated as legal entities for tax purposes, as distinct from their partners (members), which means that an interest in such enterprises is treated in the same way as shares in a company. Therefore, capital gains from the alienation of such an interest, like capital gains from the alienation of shares, are taxable only in the State of which the alienating person is a resident. The Contracting States may bilaterally agree on rules governing the taxation of capital gains from the alienation of an interest in a partnership.
- Some States take the view that any capital gains from sources situated in their territory should be taxable by them under their domestic law if the alienating person has a permanent establishment in their territory. This concept, sometimes referred to as the “force of attraction of a permanent establishment”, does not underlie paragraph 2. This paragraph merely provides that gains from the alienation of movable property forming part of the property of a permanent establishment [or movable property pertaining to a fixed base used for the provision of independent personal services] may be taxed in the State in which that permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated. Gains from the alienation of any other movable property are taxable only in the State of which the alienating person is a resident, as provided in paragraph [6]. The above explanations are consistent with those set out in the Commentary on Article 7.
Paragraph 3
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 3 of Article 13 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention, the Commentary on which states the following:
- An exception to the provision of paragraph 2 is provided for ships and aircraft operated in international traffic and movable property pertaining to the operation of such ships and aircraft. As a rule, income from the alienation of such property is taxable only in the State of the enterprise operating such ships and aircraft. This rule corresponds to the provisions of Article 8 and paragraph 3 of Article 22. Contracting States that would prefer to grant the exclusive right to tax to the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated may replace paragraph 3 in bilateral conventions with a provision corresponding to the provision proposed in paragraph 2 of the Commentary on Article 8 [paragraph 10 of the Commentary on Article 8 of the United Nations Model Convention].
Paragraph 4
- This paragraph generally corresponds to paragraph 4 of the OECD Model Convention. Prior to the 2017 update, paragraph 4 of the United Nations Model Convention provided as follows:
- Gains from the alienation of shares in the capital of a company or an interest in a partnership, trust or estate, the property of which consists directly or indirectly principally of immovable property situated in a Contracting State, may be taxed in that State. In particular:
(a) Nothing in this paragraph shall apply to a company, partnership, trust or estate, other than a company, partnership, trust or estate engaged in the business of managing immovable property, the property of which consists directly or indirectly principally of immovable property used by such company, partnership, trust or estate in its business activities.
(b) For the purposes of this paragraph, “principally” in relation to the ownership of immovable property means that the value of such immovable property exceeds 50 per cent of the aggregate value of all assets owned by the company, partnership, trust or estate.
Both formulations are intended to prevent the avoidance of taxes on income from the sale of immovable property. Since it is often very easy to avoid taxes on such gains by incorporating a company to hold such property, it is necessary to tax the sale of shares in such a company. This is particularly relevant in cases where ownership of the shares confers the right to occupy the property. To achieve its purpose, paragraph 4 should apply irrespective of whether the company is a resident of the Contracting State in which the immovable property is situated or a resident of another State. In 1999, the former Group of Experts decided to amend paragraph 4 in order to expand its scope to include interests in partnerships, trusts and estates owning immovable property. In 2017, the Committee decided to adopt the updated provision from the OECD Model Convention, since the concept of “comparable interests” is generally equivalent to that previously covered by paragraph 4 of the United Nations Model Convention.
8.1 In addition to introducing the concept of “comparable interests”, paragraph 4 was expanded to cover situations where assets are contributed to an organization shortly before the sale of shares (or comparable interests) in that organization for the purpose of diluting the proportion of the value of those shares (or comparable interests) derived from immovable property situated in the other Contracting State. For this purpose, the question is whether the value of the shares (or comparable interests) was derived principally from immovable property at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, rather than only at the time of the alienation.
8.2 By providing that gains from the alienation of shares or comparable interests that, at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, derived more than 50 per cent of their value directly or indirectly from immovable property situated in a Contracting State may be taxed in that State, paragraph 4 provides that gains from the alienation of such shares or comparable interests and gains from the alienation of the underlying immovable property covered by paragraph 1 are equally subject to taxation in that State.
8.3 Paragraph 4 allows the taxation of the entire gain attributable to shares or comparable interests to which it applies, even if part of the value of those shares or comparable interests is derived from property other than immovable property situated in the source State. In determining whether shares in a company or comparable interests, at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, derived more than 50 per cent of their value directly or indirectly from immovable property situated in a Contracting State, a comparison is generally made between the value of such immovable property and the value of all the property owned by the company, entity or arrangement, without taking into account the debts or other liabilities of the company (whether or not secured by mortgages on the relevant immovable property).
8.4 Having adopted the updated wording of the OECD Model Convention in 2017, the Committee decided to remove paragraph 4(a) from the United Nations Model Convention, since it does not reflect generally accepted practice. It was found that this provision is used very rarely and is difficult to apply. However, during bilateral negotiations, countries may agree to include at the end of paragraph 4 the following words from subparagraph (a), as it existed before the 2017 update:
- Gains derived by a resident of a Contracting State from the alienation of shares or comparable interests, such as interests in a partnership or trust, may be taxed in the other Contracting State if, at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, those shares or comparable interests derived more than 50 per cent of their value directly or indirectly from immovable property, as defined in Article 6, situated in that other State. Nothing contained in this paragraph shall apply to a company, partnership, trust or estate, other than a company, partnership, trust or estate engaged in the business of managing immovable property, the property of which consists directly or indirectly principally of immovable property used by such company, partnership, trust or estate in its business activities.
Paragraph 5
- Some countries take the view that a Contracting State should be able to tax gains from the alienation of shares in a company resident in that State, irrespective of whether the alienation takes place within or outside that State. However, it is recognized that, for administrative reasons, the right to tax should be limited to the alienation of shares in a company in whose capital the person alienating the property held a substantial interest, directly or indirectly, at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation. The determination of what constitutes a substantial interest is left to bilateral negotiations, during which an agreed percentage may be established.
9.1 In 2017, the Committee decided to include a reference to “comparable interests” in paragraph 5 in order to reflect similar changes made to paragraph 4.
- This paragraph provides for the taxation of gains from the alienation of shares and comparable interests, as provided for in the preceding paragraph, but excludes gains from the alienation of shares to which paragraph 4 of Article 13 of the Convention applies. The wording clearly provides that income from the alienation of any number of shares may be taxed in the State of which the company is a resident, provided that the shareholding is substantial at any time during the 12 months preceding the alienation. A substantial shareholding is determined in accordance with the percentage established in the relevant bilateral negotiations. Consequently, even if a substantial shareholding is alienated through several transfers of smaller blocks of shares, the right to tax granted by this paragraph will still apply if the shares transferred were alienated at any time during the 12-month period.
- Questions concerning which transactions give rise to gains from the alienation of shares and how to determine the size of the alienating person’s interest in the capital, in particular how to determine the extent of indirect participation, shall be resolved in accordance with the law of the State imposing tax on such gains. In this regard, indirect participation may include the participation of associated persons attributed to the alienating person. In determining the extent of the alienating person’s direct or indirect participation, it may be appropriate to use the provisions of the laws of the State imposing the tax that are designed to prevent tax avoidance. Alternatively, a broader interpretation of these concepts may be provided in the text of the treaty itself or in accompanying documentation.
- The question of establishing a preferential tax rate (as compared with the ordinary domestic rate) on gains arising from the alienation of shares, other than shares referred to in paragraph 4, that is, shares in companies that do not principally own immovable property, was also considered. Since income arising from the alienation of shares subject to preferential taxation is likely to encourage investment in shares, stimulate foreign direct investment and portfolio investment, and thereby provide impetus to the industrialization of the country, countries may consider discussing this issue during bilateral negotiations and introducing the necessary provisions into bilateral tax treaties.
- The taxation of gains from the alienation of listed shares involves significant costs. In addition, developing countries may consider it economically beneficial to stimulate the growth of their capital markets by foregoing the taxation of gains from the alienation of listed shares. Countries wishing to follow this approach may include the following provision in their bilateral tax treaties:
Gains derived by a resident of a Contracting State from the alienation of shares, other than those referred to in paragraph 4, in a company that is a resident of the other Contracting State, excluding shares that are the subject of active and regular trading on a recognized stock exchange, may be taxed in that other State if the alienating person, at any time during the twelve-month period preceding such alienation, directly or indirectly held at least ____ per cent (the percentage to be determined in bilateral negotiations) of the capital of that company.
Provisions expanding the interpretation of the expressions “active and regular trading” and “recognized stock exchange” may be included in the text of the treaty itself or in accompanying documentation.
- Some countries may consider that a Contracting State of which a company is a resident should be permitted to tax gains from the alienation of its shares only if a substantial part of the company’s assets is situated in that State, and may insist on such a restriction during bilateral negotiations.
- Other countries participating in bilateral negotiations may prefer to exclude paragraph 5 entirely if they consider that, under these circumstances, the taxation of capital gains in the source State may result in double taxation of economic activity within a corporate chain, thereby making it more difficult to attract direct foreign investment. This consideration is particularly relevant for countries that exempt shareholders from tax not only on dividends received from a substantial shareholding but also on capital gains from shares forming part of such a substantial shareholding.
- If countries prefer not to tax gains derived in the course of a corporate reorganization, they are, of course, free to do so.
Paragraph 6
- This paragraph reproduces paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the OECD Model Convention, with an editorial amendment — replacing the words “in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4” with the words “in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5”. Accordingly, the Commentary on paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the 2010 OECD Model Convention, with the necessary modifications, also applies to paragraph 6. The Commentary states the following:
- With respect to gains from the alienation of any property other than that referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3[, 4] and [5], paragraph [6] provides that such gains shall be taxable only in the State of which the alienating person is a resident […].
- This Article contains no special rules concerning gains from the alienation of shares in a company (other than shares in a company covered by paragraph[s] 4 [and 5]) or securities, bonds, debentures, etc. Thus, such gains are taxable only in the State of which the alienating person is a resident.
- If shares are sold by a shareholder to the company issuing them in connection with the liquidation of that company or a reduction in its paid-up capital, the difference between the selling price and the nominal value of the shares may be treated in the State of which that company is a resident as a distribution of accumulated profits rather than as a capital gain. The Article does not prevent the State of which the company is a resident from taxing such a distribution at the rates provided for in Article 10: such taxation is permitted because this difference falls within the definition of the term “dividends” contained in paragraph 3 of Article 10 and interpreted in paragraph 28 of the Commentary on that Article. The same interpretation is possible where bonds and debentures are redeemed by the debtor at a price exceeding their nominal value or the value at which the bonds or debentures were issued; in this case, the difference may constitute interest and, as such, be subject to limited taxation in the State of source of the interest under Article 11 (see also paragraphs 20 and 21 of the Commentary on Article 11).
- There is a need to distinguish between capital gains that may be derived from the alienation of shares acquired under stock options granted to an employee or a member of the board of directors, and the benefit derived from stock options, which are governed by Article 15 or Article 16. The principles underlying this distinction are discussed in paragraphs 12.2–12.5 of the Commentary on Article 15 and paragraph 3.1 of the Commentary on Article 16 [of the OECD Model Convention].
- However, as indicated in paragraph 2 above, the majority of the members of the Group from developing countries proposed the following alternative version of paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the OECD Model Convention:
- Gains from the alienation of any property, other than gains referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4, may be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise, in accordance with the laws of that State.
This alternative is equivalent to stating that either or both States may tax in accordance with their own laws, and that the State of residence will eliminate double taxation in accordance with Article 23. Countries choosing this alternative may, if they wish, specify during bilateral negotiations which particular source rules will apply in determining the place in which the capital gain shall be deemed to arise.
Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 18A
Paragraph 1
4. Under this paragraph, pensions and other similar remuneration paid in consideration of past employment are taxable only in the State of residence of the recipient. Since this paragraph reproduces the text of Article 18 of the OECD Model Convention, the Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary is applicable:
1. Under this Article, pensions paid in consideration of past employment are taxable only in the State of residence of the recipient. Various political and administrative considerations support the principle that the right to tax this type of pension and other similar remuneration should remain with the State of residence. For example, the State of which the recipient of the pension is a resident is in a better position than any other State to take into account the recipient's overall ability to pay tax, which depends mainly on his or her worldwide income and personal circumstances, such as family responsibilities. This solution also makes it possible to avoid imposing on recipients of this type of pension the administrative burden of complying with tax obligations in States other than the State of residence of the recipient.
Scope of the Article
3. The types of payments covered by this Article include pensions paid not only directly to former employees but also to other beneficiaries (for example, widows/widowers, partners or children of employees), as well as other similar payments, such as an annuity paid in consideration of past employment. This Article also applies to pensions paid in consideration of services rendered to the State, a political subdivision thereof or a local authority, which are not covered by the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19. Nevertheless, the Article applies only to those payments made in consideration of past employment; therefore, it does not apply, for example, to an annuity received directly by the annuitant from capital that was not funded through a pension scheme. The Article applies irrespective of the tax treatment of the scheme under which the relevant payments are made; consequently, a payment under a pension scheme that does not qualify for tax relief may nevertheless constitute a "pension or other similar remuneration" (the tax mismatch that may arise in such a situation is discussed below).
4. Various payments may be made to an employee after the termination of the employment relationship. Whether such payments fall within the scope of this Article or not is determined by the nature of those payments, taking into account the facts and circumstances in which they are made, as described in the following two paragraphs. […].
5. Although the term "pension" in its ordinary meaning refers only to periodic payments, the words "other similar remuneration" are sufficiently broad to cover non-periodic payments as well. For example, a lump-sum payment in lieu of periodic pension payments made after the termination of the employment relationship may fall within the scope of the Article.
6. Whether a particular payment should be regarded as other remuneration similar to a pension or as final remuneration for work performed, falling within the scope of Article 15, is a question of fact. For example, if there is evidence that the subject matter of the payment represents a substitute for a pension or compensation for a reduced pension, that payment may be characterised as "other similar remuneration" falling within the scope of this Article. This would be the case where, upon retirement, a person was entitled to choose between receiving a pension or a certain lump-sum amount calculated either on the basis of the total amount of contributions or on the basis of the amount of the pension to which that person would otherwise have been entitled under the applicable rules of the pension scheme. An important factor is the source of the payment: payments made under a pension scheme will generally fall within the scope of this Article. Other factors that could assist in determining whether a payment or series of payments falls within the scope of this Article include the following: whether the payment is made during or after the termination of the employment relationship that gave rise to the payment; whether the recipient continues to work; whether the recipient has reached the normal retirement age for that particular type of employment; the position of other beneficiaries entitled to the same particular type of lump-sum payment; and whether the recipient is simultaneously entitled to receive other pension benefits. A refund of pension contributions (for example, following temporary employment) does not constitute "other similar remuneration" within the meaning of Article 18. Where difficulties arise in the taxation of such payments, the Contracting States should resolve the matter by resorting to the provisions of Article 25.
7. Since this Article relates only to pensions and other similar remuneration paid in consideration of past employment, it does not extend to other types of pensions, such as those paid in consideration of services previously rendered as an independent contractor. Some States, however, extend the scope of this Article to include all types of pensions, including State pensions. States wishing to follow this approach may agree bilaterally to include the relevant provisions.
Cross-border Pension Issues
8. The globalisation of the economy and developments in international communications and transport have significantly increased the international mobility of individuals, both in connection with their employment and for personal reasons. This has greatly increased the importance of cross-border pension issues arising from the interaction of different pension arrangements operating in different States, which were developed primarily on the basis of purely domestic policy considerations. Since these issues frequently affect a large number of people, it is desirable to address them in tax treaties in order to remove obstacles to the international movement of individuals, particularly employees.
9. Many such issues relate to mismatches resulting from differences in the overall tax policies pursued by States with respect to contributions to pension funds. In many States, tax incentives are provided for pension contributions. Such incentives frequently take the form of tax deferral, whereby part of an individual's income contributed to a pension fund, as well as income earned by that fund or any pension rights accrued by that individual, is exempt from taxation. On the other hand, pension benefits paid under these schemes are taxed when received. Other States, however, treat contributions to pension funds in the same way as other forms of savings and do not exempt either the contributions themselves or the income derived from them from taxation; accordingly, following this logic, they do not tax pension benefits. Between these two approaches, there are a wide variety of systems under which contributions, income derived from them, accrued pension rights or pension benefits are partially or entirely exempt from tax.
10. Other problems arise from the existence of substantially different pension arrangements. These arrangements are frequently classified into the following three main categories:
— State social security schemes;
— non-governmental employee pension schemes;
— individual pension schemes.
The interaction between these three categories of pension schemes gives rise to particular difficulties. These difficulties are compounded by the fact that each State may have different tax rules for schemes falling within each of these categories, as well as by the fact that there are significant differences in the extent to which States rely on each of these categories for providing pension benefits to individuals (for example, some States provide pension benefits almost exclusively through their social security systems, whereas others rely primarily on non-governmental employee pension schemes or individual pension schemes).
11. Issues arising from all these differences must be fully taken into account during bilateral negotiations, particularly negotiations concerning the avoidance of double taxation or double non-taxation, and, where necessary, addressed through specific provisions […].
5. Many countries have adopted an approach under which, subject to specific conditions, tax on contributions to pension funds and on income derived from them, or tax on accrued pension rights, is wholly or partially deferred and levied when pension benefits are paid. Other countries, however, treat contributions to pension funds or certain types thereof in the same way as other forms of savings and do not exempt either the contributions themselves or the income derived from them from taxation. Such countries generally do not tax pension benefits. If an individual has received tax relief in a country that has adopted the first approach and, before all or part of the pension benefits are paid, that individual becomes a resident of a country that has adopted the second approach, the mismatch between the approaches of these two countries will result in a situation in which no tax at all is paid on the income concerned. To avoid this undesirable outcome, countries could include in paragraph 1 an additional sentence worded approximately as follows:
However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the other Contracting State if the payment is covered by a pension fund established in that other State or on its behalf, or by a permanent establishment situated therein, and such payment is not subject to taxation in the first-mentioned State under the ordinary rules of its tax legislation.
6. The Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary concerning the exemption of pensions from tax is also applicable to paragraph 1:
22. [S]ome States do not tax pension payments in general or otherwise exempt certain categories or portions of pension payments from tax. In these cases, the provisions of this Article, which provide for the taxation of pensions in the State of residence, may result in that State taxing pensions that were not intended to be taxed and the amount of which was quite likely determined taking into account such tax exemption. This may result in unjustified financial hardship for the recipient of the pension.
23. To avoid problems arising from mismatches of this kind, some States include provisions in their treaties to preserve the tax-exempt treatment of pensions where the recipient is a resident of another Contracting State. These provisions may be limited to specific categories of pensions or may address this issue in a more comprehensive manner. An example of the latter approach would be a provision containing wording approximately as follows:
Notwithstanding any provision of this Convention, any pension or other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State in consideration of past employment exercised in the other Contracting State shall be exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State if such pension or other remuneration would have been exempt from tax in the other State had the recipient been a resident of that other State.
Paragraph 2
7. Under this paragraph, the State of source has the exclusive right to tax pensions and other payments made under a public scheme that forms part of the social security system of that State, its political subdivision or local authority. Countries using the tax credit method as the general method for eliminating double taxation in their treaties are therefore required, as an exception to this method, to exempt from tax such payments made to their residents that are governed by paragraph 2. The exclusive right of the State of source to tax pensions and other payments made under a public scheme that forms part of the social security system is conditional upon the relevant payments being financed wholly or substantially from the tax revenues of the State of source. This applies where future recipients of such payments make no contributions or where compulsory savings through contributions under the social security scheme must be supplemented from the tax revenues of the State of source. However, this situation does not always arise where the social security system operates on the basis of the funding principle rather than the pay-as-you-go principle.
8. The OECD Committee on Fiscal Affairs was unable to reach a consensus on including in the text of Article 18 a provision allowing the State of source to tax payments made under its social security system. Nevertheless, the OECD Commentary proposes an alternative paragraph granting such a right. The Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary is applicable to paragraph 2:
28. Although the above draft provision refers to the social security [system] of each of the Contracting States, there are certain limitations on its scope. The term "social security" generally refers to a system of compulsory protection established by a State with the aim of providing the population with a minimum level of income or pension, or of mitigating the financial consequences of events such as unemployment, industrial injury, illness or death. A common feature of social security systems is that the amount of benefits is determined by the State. Payments that may be covered by this provision include pensions provided to the entire population under a public pension system, old-age pension payments, as well as unemployment, disability, maternity, survivor, sickness, social assistance and family protection benefits paid by the State or by public enterprises established to administer the funds to be distributed. Since there may be substantial differences between the social security systems of the Contracting States, it is important for States intending to use this draft provision to ensure, during bilateral negotiations, that they have a common understanding of the scope of this provision.
9. Some countries using the tax credit method as the general method for eliminating double taxation of income received by their residents may take the view that the State of source should not have the exclusive right to tax payments made under the social security system. In such a case, these countries should replace the words "shall be taxable only" in paragraph 2 of their treaties with the words "may be taxed".
10. Countries seeking to take into account the consequences of privatising their social security systems may propose amendments to the provisions of paragraph 2 in the following wording, in order to bring their privatised systems within the scope of this paragraph:
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, pensions and other payments made under a public scheme or a compulsory private scheme forming an integral part of the social security system of a Contracting State, its political subdivision or local authority shall be taxable only in that State.
Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 18B
11. Some countries consider that pensions paid in consideration of past employment should not be taxable exclusively in the State of residence of the recipient. Various policy considerations support such a rule. Since pensions are essentially deferred compensation for services rendered in the State of source, they should be taxed at source in the same manner as ordinary employment income. Where tax relief is granted for pension contributions, taxation of part of the employment income is deferred until retirement, and the tax thus deferred should be levied even if the individual ceased to be a resident before all or part of the pension benefits have been paid. The flow of pensions between certain developed and developing countries is not balanced in both directions and, in some cases, represents a rather substantial net outflow from developing countries.
12. If the State of source does not grant non-residents any personal allowances, the taxation of pensions at source may result in excessive taxation. This issue should be discussed during negotiations. The Contracting States may agree that, in such cases, the State of source should grant a resident of the other State the same personal allowances, reliefs and deductions for tax purposes as those granted to its own residents, in the same proportion as the pensions and other similar remuneration bear to the worldwide income received by the resident of that other State. A sentence worded approximately as follows may be added to paragraph 2:
The other State shall grant a resident of the first-mentioned State the same personal allowances, reliefs and deductions for tax purposes as it grants to its own residents. These allowances, reliefs and deductions shall be granted in the same proportion as the pensions and other similar remuneration taxable in that State bear to the worldwide income taxable in the first-mentioned State.
13. The State of source may be considered to be the State in which the fund is established, the State in which the relevant employment was performed, or the State in which the claim for tax relief was made. It is quite common for employees of multinational corporations to perform their duties successively in several different countries. In such a case, taxation in the State where the employment was performed or where tax relief was granted would give rise to uncertainty and administrative difficulties for taxpayers and tax authorities, since this would create the possibility of different portions of the same pension being taxed in different States of source. Therefore, a general agreement was reached that taxation of pensions at source should be interpreted as taxation in the place from which the pension payments originate, rather than in the place where the employment was performed or where tax relief was granted.
Paragraph 1
14. This paragraph, while recognising the right of the State of residence of the recipient to tax pensions and other similar remuneration, leaves open the possibility of granting the right to tax, under certain conditions set out in paragraph 2, also to the State of source. In order to determine the scope of Article 18B and take into account cross-border pension issues, paragraph 4 of the Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 18A applies.
Paragraph 2
15. As noted above, the State of source may tax pensions and other similar remuneration paid in consideration of past employment, but only if the relevant payments are made by a resident of that State or by a permanent establishment situated therein.
16. Some countries, however, may take the view that the State that granted tax relief in respect of contributions to a pension fund or accrued pension rights should have the right to tax the resulting pension benefit. This may be the case where countries also grant tax relief in respect of contributions or pension rights in foreign pension funds. The following provision is an example of such wording:
However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the other Contracting State to the extent that they are paid out of contributions that qualified for tax relief in that other State.
As already explained in paragraph 13, this approach may give rise to administrative difficulties, particularly with respect to individuals who have worked in more than one country during their careers. Such difficulties must be resolved in order to avoid situations, for example, in which two countries claim the right to tax the same pension at source.
Paragraph 3
17. Since paragraph 3 of Article 18B is identical to paragraph 2 of Article 18A, the Commentary on the latter (see above) applies in its entirety to the former.
18. Paragraphs 31–69 of the Commentary on Article 18 of the OECD Model Convention address the tax treatment of contributions to foreign pension schemes, as well as the issue of tax obstacles to the transfer of pension rights and the treatment of the exemption from taxation of investment income received by pension funds established in another Contracting State. Including these paragraphs in the Commentary on Article 18 of the United Nations Model Convention would provide a strong positive incentive for potential investors in the country. Recognition of cross-border pension contributions and facilitation of the cross-border transfer of pension rights from one pension scheme to another would also encourage the movement of personnel to foreign countries. Therefore, the Committee considered the following part of the OECD Commentary relevant to Articles 18A and 18B:
Tax Treatment of Contributions to Foreign Pension Schemes [Made by or on Behalf of Employees and Individuals Providing Independent Personal Services]
A. General Remarks
31. A characteristic feature of multinational corporations is that their personnel are expected to work outside their country of residence from time to time. The terms of service under which personnel are assigned to work in other countries are of great importance both to the employer and to the employee. One such term concerns the pension arrangements of the particular employee. Similarly, individuals who move to other countries to provide services as independent contractors frequently encounter cross-border tax problems relating to the pension arrangements they had in their home country.
32. Individuals working abroad often wish to continue contributing to a pension scheme (including a social security scheme providing pension benefits) in their country of residence during their stay in another country. This is due to the fact that switching to another scheme may result in the loss of rights and benefits, and is also associated with many practical difficulties that may arise as a result of arranging pension coverage in several countries.
33. The tax treatment of pension contributions made by individuals working outside their country of residence, or on their behalf, varies from country to country and depends on the circumstances of each particular case. Before being assigned to work abroad or signing an employment contract abroad, such individuals generally receive tax relief for pension contributions in their country of residence. During the period of their employment abroad, tax relief in respect of such contributions is sometimes maintained. For example, if an individual remains a resident and is fully taxable in the country of residence, pension contributions to a scheme established in that country will generally continue to qualify for tax relief. However, contributions paid in the country of residence by an individual working abroad frequently do not qualify for relief either in the country of residence or in the country of temporary stay. In such a case, maintaining participation in a pension scheme in the country of residence during a foreign assignment or contractual employment becomes expensive, if not prohibitively expensive. Paragraph 37 below contains a provision that Member countries may, at their discretion, include in bilateral treaties in order to provide relief in respect of pension contributions made by individuals working outside their country of residence.
34. Some Member countries, however, may not consider that this problem can be resolved through a treaty provision, preferring, in particular, to amend the pension scheme so as to provide for the deduction of contributions for tax purposes in the State of temporary stay. Other countries may oppose the inclusion of such a provision in a treaty where domestic legislation allows tax relief only in respect of contributions paid by residents. In such cases, it would not be appropriate to include the proposed provision in a bilateral treaty.
35. The proposed provision applies to contributions to all types of pension schemes, including individual pension schemes and social security schemes. Many Member countries have concluded bilateral social security totalisation agreements that may help to avoid the problem relating to contributions to social security schemes; however, such agreements generally do not regulate the tax treatment of contributions transferred to other countries. In the case of an occupational pension scheme to which both the employer and the employee contribute, this provision covers both contributions. Furthermore, this provision is not limited to the question of the tax deductibility of contributions, since it regulates all aspects of the tax treatment of contributions in relation to an individual receiving employment income for whom the contribution constitutes income, as well as whether or not investment income received by the individual from the contributions should be taxed. Nevertheless, this provision does not deal with the taxation of income received by pension funds (this issue is addressed in paragraph 69 below). Contracting States wishing to modify the scope of this provision in relation to any of these issues may do so during bilateral negotiations.
B. Purpose of the Provision
36. The purpose of this provision is to ensure that, as far as possible, the tax treatment of contributions to a pension scheme in the country of residence does not create obstacles for individuals wishing to accept an assignment to work abroad. Primarily, this provision is intended to establish general equivalence between the pension schemes of the two countries and subsequently to introduce limits on contributions qualifying for tax exemption, based on the limits provided for under the legislation of both countries.
C. Proposed Provision
37. The following is the text of the proposed provision that could be included in bilateral conventions to address the above-mentioned problem:
1. Contributions to a pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in one Contracting State, made by or on behalf of an individual who provides services in the other Contracting State, shall, for the purposes of determining the tax payable by that individual and the profits of an enterprise that may be taxed in that State, be treated in that State in the same manner and be subject to the same conditions and limitations as contributions made to a pension scheme recognised for tax purposes in that State, provided that:
a) the individual was not a resident of that State and was participating in the pension scheme immediately before beginning to provide services in that State; and
b) the pension scheme is recognised by the competent authority of that State as generally corresponding to a pension scheme recognised for tax purposes by that State.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1:
a) the term "pension scheme" means an arrangement in which the individual participates for the purpose of securing retirement benefits in respect of the services referred to in paragraph 1; and
b) a pension scheme is recognised for tax purposes in a State if contributions to the scheme qualify for tax relief in that State.
38. The above provision is limited to pension schemes established in one of the two Contracting States. Since it is quite common for individuals to work successively in several countries, some States may wish to extend the scope of this provision to cover situations in which an individual moves from one Contracting State to another while continuing to make contributions to a pension scheme established in a third State. Such an extension of the scope may, however, create administrative difficulties if the State of temporary stay does not have access to information concerning such a pension scheme (for example, under the information exchange provisions of a tax treaty concluded with that third State); a situation may also arise in which tax exemption is granted on a non-reciprocal basis, since the third State will not grant similar exemption to an individual making contributions to a pension scheme established in the State of temporary stay. Those States that, despite these difficulties, wish to extend the scope of the proposed provision to cover funds established in third States may do so by adopting an alternative version of the proposed provision, worded approximately as follows:
1. Contributions made by or on behalf of an individual providing services in one Contracting State to a pension scheme:
a) recognised for tax purposes in the other Contracting State,
b) in which the individual was participating immediately before beginning to provide services in the first-mentioned State,
c) in which the individual participated during the period when the individual was providing services in the other State or was a resident of the other State; and
d) which is recognised by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally corresponding to a pension scheme recognised for tax purposes by that State, shall, for the purposes of:
e) determining the tax payable by that individual in the first-mentioned State; and
f) determining the profits of an enterprise that may be taxed in the first-mentioned State,
be treated in that State in the same manner and be subject to the same conditions and limitations as contributions made to a pension scheme recognised for tax purposes in the first-mentioned State.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1:
a) the term "pension scheme" means an arrangement in which the individual participates for the purpose of securing retirement benefits in respect of the services referred to in paragraph 1; and
b) a pension scheme is recognised for tax purposes in a State if contributions to the scheme qualify for tax relief in that State.
D. Characteristics of the Proposed Provision
39. The following paragraphs discuss the main characteristics of the proposed provision set out in paragraph 37 above.
40. Paragraph 1 of the proposed provision contains characteristics of both the individual and the contributions to which the provision applies. It also sets out the principle that contributions made by or on behalf of an individual providing services in one Contracting State (the State of temporary stay) to a particular pension scheme in the other Contracting State (the State of residence) are exempt from taxation in the State of temporary stay on the same conditions and subject to the same limitations as those applicable to the exemption of contributions to pension schemes in the State of temporary stay.
41. Tax relief for contributions to a pension scheme in the country of residence on the conditions specified may be granted either in the country of residence, that is, where the pension scheme is established, or in the country of temporary stay, where the economic activity on the basis of which contributions to the scheme are made is carried out.
42. The solution of granting tax relief in the country of residence may prove ineffective, since the individual may have no taxable income in that country or may have only a small amount of such income. Therefore, for practical reasons, it would be advisable to grant relief in the country of temporary stay, and this is the approach adopted in the proposed provision.
43. In specifying the characteristics of the individual, paragraph 1 clearly provides that, in order to qualify for tax relief in the country of temporary stay, the individual must not have been a resident of the State of temporary stay immediately before arriving there to work.
44. However, paragraph 1 does not restrict the application of the provision solely to individuals who become residents of the country of temporary stay. In many cases, individuals working abroad who remain residents of the country of residence continue to qualify for tax relief there, but this is not always the case. Therefore, the proposed provision applies to non-residents working in the State of temporary stay, as well as to individuals who acquire resident status there. In some Member countries, domestic legislation may restrict tax deductions to contributions covered by residents, and those Member countries may wish to limit the proposed provision accordingly. In addition, States that have a special regime for non-residents (in particular, taxation at a special low rate) may agree during bilateral negotiations to restrict the application of this provision to residents only.
45. If individuals temporarily cease to be residents of the country of temporary stay in order to join a pension scheme in a country with a more favourable tax regime, certain States may wish to introduce a provision that would prevent the possibility of abuse. One option for such a provision could establish a citizenship requirement, which would exclude from the proposed provision individuals who are citizens of the country of temporary stay.
46. As already noted, it is common for individuals to work successively in different countries; for this reason, the proposed provision is not limited to individuals who are residents of the State of residence immediately before providing services in the State of temporary stay. The provision extends to individuals arriving in the State of temporary stay from a third country, since it is limited only to individuals who were not residents of the State of temporary stay before beginning employment there. However, Article 1 limits the scope of the Convention to residents of one or both of the Contracting States. Therefore, an individual who is not a resident of either the State of temporary stay or the State of residence in which the pension scheme is established does not fall within the scope of the Convention between those two States.
47. The proposed provision does not impose any restrictions on the length of time during which an individual may work in the State of temporary stay. It could be argued that, if an individual works in the State of temporary stay for a long period, that State effectively becomes the individual's country of residence, and the provision should no longer apply. Indeed, some States of temporary stay have already restricted tax relief on contributions to foreign pension schemes to cases where individuals are present in that State on a temporary basis.
48. Furthermore, the inclusion of a time limit may help to prevent possible abuses referred to in paragraph 45 above. During bilateral negotiations, individual countries may consider it appropriate to include a limit on the period during which an individual may provide services in the State of temporary stay, after which the tax relief granted under the proposed provision would no longer apply.
49. With regard to the characteristics of the contributions, paragraph 1 provides for a number of conditions. It clearly states that the provision applies only to contributions made by or on behalf of an individual to a pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in the State of residence. The expression "recognised for tax purposes" is defined in subparagraph 2(b) of the proposed provision. The expression "made by or on behalf of an individual" is intended to apply both to contributions made directly by the individual and to contributions made on behalf of that individual by an employer or another party (for example, a spouse). Although paragraph 4 of Article 24 guarantees that employer contributions to a pension fund that is a resident of another Contracting State are deductible for tax purposes under the same conditions as contributions to a resident pension fund, this provision may prove insufficient to ensure equal treatment of employer contributions to domestic and foreign pension funds. This will occur, for example, where employer contributions to a foreign fund are treated as a taxable benefit when received by the employee, or where the tax deductibility of employer contributions depends not on whether or not a fund is a resident, but rather on other conditions (for example, registration with the tax authorities or the existence of branches), which generally result in the exclusion of foreign pension funds. For these reasons, employer contributions are covered by the proposed provision even though paragraph 4 of Article 24 may already ensure an equivalent tax deduction in certain cases.
50. The second condition concerning the characteristics of the contributions is that the contributions must be made to a scheme in the State of residence that is recognised by the competent authority of the State of temporary stay as generally corresponding to a scheme recognised for tax purposes in the State of temporary stay. This condition is based on the assumption that only contributions to recognised schemes can satisfy the requirements for tax relief in Member countries. Of course, this restriction does not necessarily guarantee equivalent tax treatment of contributions paid by an individual while working abroad and contributions paid while working in the country of residence. If the rules of the State of temporary stay concerning the recognition of pension schemes are more restrictive than those applicable in the State of residence, the individual may find that contributions to the pension scheme of the State of residence are subject to less favourable treatment during the period of employment in the State of temporary stay than during the period of employment in the State of residence.
51. However, granting tax relief in respect of contributions that do not, at least in a broad sense, correspond to pension schemes recognised in that country would be contrary to the stated objective of ensuring, as far as possible, equivalent tax treatment of such contributions. This would mean that the amount of tax relief in the State of temporary stay would depend on the legislation of the State of residence. Furthermore, it would be difficult to justify differences in the treatment of individuals working together depending on which pension scheme they contribute to — one in their own country or one abroad (and, if abroad, depending on which country it is). Restricting the application of the proposed provision to schemes that generally correspond to schemes in the country of temporary stay makes it possible to avoid such difficulties.
52. The proposed provision clearly states that the decision as to whether a scheme in the State of residence corresponds to schemes recognised in the State of temporary stay must be made by the competent authority of the State of temporary stay. During bilateral negotiations, certain States may consider it necessary to specify expressly how the competent authority will interpret the term "generally corresponding", for example, how broadly it will be interpreted and what criteria will be applied.
53. Contributions covered by the provision are limited to payments made to schemes in which the individual made contributions before beginning to provide services in the State of temporary stay. This means that contributions to new pension schemes joined by the individual while working in the State of temporary stay are excluded from the scope of the proposed provision.
54. It is recognised, however, that special rules may be required in cases where new pension schemes replace previous ones. For example, in some Member countries, it is common practice that, where a company-employer is acquired by another company, the pension scheme operating in the company in respect of its employees is terminated and a different scheme is introduced by the new employer. Therefore, during bilateral negotiations, certain States may wish to supplement this provision so that it also applies to such substitute schemes; this may be achieved by adding the following subparagraph to paragraph 2 of the proposed provision:
a) a replacement pension scheme that is substantially similar to the pension scheme recognised by the competent authorities of a Contracting State under subparagraph b of paragraph 1 shall be considered to be recognised in the same manner.
55. Paragraph 1 also provides for the granting of tax relief by the State of temporary stay if the characteristics of the individual and the contributions satisfy the conditions of the provision. In brief, contributions must receive tax treatment corresponding to the treatment that would apply to such contributions if they were made to a scheme established in the State of temporary stay. Thus, contributions must qualify for the same tax relief (for example, be deductible for tax purposes) in respect of both the individual and the individual's employer (where the individual is an employee and the contributions are made by the employer) as would apply if such contributions were made to a pension scheme in the State of temporary stay. Furthermore, the same treatment must be granted with respect to the taxation of the employee's employment income arising from the contribution, whether it is made to a foreign or a domestic pension scheme (see paragraph 58 below).
56. Of course, such a measure concerning tax relief does not necessarily ensure equivalent tax treatment of contributions made while the individual is working abroad and contributions made while the individual is working in the country of residence. The same considerations as those set out in paragraphs 50 and 51 above may be cited here. However, such a measure ensures equivalent tax treatment of contributions made by fellow employees. The following example may be given. The country of residence limits the amount of tax relief for pension contributions to 18 per cent of income. The country of temporary stay limits the relief to 20 per cent. The proposed provision in paragraph 37 requires the country of temporary stay to grant relief within the 20 per cent limit established under its domestic legislation. Countries wishing to apply the limitation adopted in the country of residence will have to amend the relevant wording of the provision.
57. The amount and method of granting tax relief will depend on the domestic tax treatment of pension contributions provided for in the State of temporary stay. This will, in particular, determine the following issues: whether such contributions qualify for relief in full or only in part, and whether relief should be granted in the form of a deduction in calculating taxable income (and, if so, which income, for example, in the case of an individual, only employment income [income from independent contractor services], business income, or total income) or in the form of a tax credit.
58. For an individual participating in an occupational pension scheme, receiving an assignment to work abroad may mean not only that the employee's contributions to the pension scheme in the individual's country of residence cease to qualify for tax relief. It may also mean that employer contributions to the pension scheme will be treated as employment income for tax purposes. In some Member countries, employees are taxed on employer contributions to domestic pension schemes during the period of employment in the country of residence, whereas in other countries these contributions remain exempt from tax. Since the proposed provision applies to contributions made by both employees and employers, it guarantees that employer contributions, in the context of the tax liabilities of their employees, receive the same tax treatment as such contributions to domestic pension schemes.
59. Subparagraph 2(a) provides a definition of a pension scheme for the purposes of paragraph 1. It clarifies that, for these purposes, a pension scheme is regarded as an arrangement in which an individual participates in order to secure retirement benefits. These benefits must be provided in respect of services rendered in the State of temporary stay. All the above conditions must apply to the pension scheme in order for it to qualify for tax relief under the proposed provision.
60. Subparagraph 2(a) refers to an individual's participation in a pension scheme for the purpose of securing benefits upon retirement. This definition is intended to ensure that the portion of contributions made to secure benefits that are not related to regular pension payments upon retirement, in particular a lump-sum payment upon retirement, is also covered by the relief provided for under this provision.
61. First of all, a pension scheme is defined as an "arrangement". This broad term is used in order to cover the various forms of pension schemes (including social security schemes, occupational pension schemes and individual pension schemes) that may exist in individual Member countries.
62. Although subparagraph 2(a) specifies that the individual providing the services referred to in paragraph 1 must participate in the scheme, it does not specify the identity of the recipient of the pension benefits secured through participation in that scheme. This is intended to ensure that the portion of contributions that will be used to provide pension benefits to other beneficiaries (for example, widows/widowers, partners and children of employees) is also covered by the tax relief provided for under the proposed provision.
63. The definition of a pension scheme does not distinguish between pensions paid under public occupational pension schemes and pensions paid under similar private schemes. Both are covered by the scope of the provision. Thus, social security schemes fall within the scope of the provision to the extent that contributions to such schemes may be considered to relate to services provided by an individual in the State of temporary stay, whether as an employee or as an independent contractor.
64. Subparagraph 2(b) further defines the expression "recognised for tax purposes". Since the purpose of the provision is to ensure, as far as possible, equally favourable tax treatment of contributions as if the individual were a resident of the State of residence, it appears appropriate to limit the application of the provision to contributions that would qualify for tax relief if the individual had remained in the State of residence. For this purpose, the scope of the provision is limited solely to contributions that satisfy the requirements for tax relief in that State.
65. This method of achieving equal treatment assumes that, in all Member countries, only contributions to recognised pension schemes satisfy the requirements for tax relief. The tax treatment of contributions to pension schemes provided for under the tax systems of Member countries may differ from this assumption. It is recognised that, during bilateral negotiations, individual countries may wish to provide an additional definition of the relevant requirements applicable to pension schemes in such a way as to make them consistent with the relevant domestic legislation of the treaty parties. They may also wish to define other terms used in the provision, such as "provides services" and "renders services".
Tax Obstacles to the Portability of Pension Rights
66. Another issue relevant to the international mobility of labour is the tax consequences that may arise from the transfer of pension rights from a pension scheme established in one Contracting State to another scheme operating in another Contracting State. When an individual moves from one employer to another, the pension rights accumulated by that individual under the pension scheme at the first place of employment are often transferred to another scheme at the second place of employment. Similar arrangements may exist to ensure the portability of pension rights from one individual pension scheme to another individual scheme.
67. Such a transfer of rights usually involves a payment representing the actuarial value of the individual's pension rights at the time of transfer or the value of the contributions and income accumulated under the scheme for the benefit of that individual. Such payments may be made directly from the first scheme to the second; alternatively, the individual may be required to contribute to the new pension scheme all or part of the amount received upon leaving the previous scheme. In both cases, tax systems quite often allow such transfers of funds to be made tax-free where they are purely domestic in nature.
68. Problems may arise, however, where such a transfer of funds is made from a pension scheme operating in one Contracting State to a scheme in another State. In this case, the Contracting State in which the individual resides may consider that the payment arising from the transfer of rights constitutes taxable income. A similar problem arises where a payment is made from a scheme established in a State to which the relevant tax treaty grants the right to tax at source pension payments arising from such schemes, since that State may seek to exercise that right to tax any payment received under such a scheme. Contracting States wishing to resolve this issue may include a provision worded approximately as follows:
Where pension rights or amounts have accrued under a pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in one Contracting State for the benefit of an individual who is a resident of the other Contracting State, any transfer of those rights or amounts to a pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in that other State shall have, in each of those States, the same tax treatment and be subject to the same conditions and limitations as if it were a transfer from one pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in that State to another pension scheme established and recognised for tax purposes in that same State.
The above provision may be amended so as also to cover the transfer of funds from pension funds established and recognised in third States (this may, however, give rise to problems similar to those described in the introductory part of paragraph 38 above).
Exemption from Tax of Pension Fund Income
69. Where two States, under their domestic legislation, follow the same approach of exempting from tax, in ordinary circumstances, investment income of pension funds established in their territories, those States may wish, in order to achieve greater neutrality with respect to the location of capital, to extend such tax exemption to investment income received in the other State by a pension fund established in one State. For this purpose, States sometimes include in their conventions a provision worded approximately as follows:
Notwithstanding any provision of this Convention, income arising in one Contracting State and derived by a resident of the other Contracting State, being an entity established and operating exclusively for the purpose of administering or providing pension benefits and recognised by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally corresponding to a pension scheme recognised for tax purposes by that State, shall be exempt from taxation in that State.
Article 14
INDEPENDENT PERSONAL SERVICES
- Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces in paragraph 1, subparagraph (a), and paragraph 2 the main provisions of Article 14 of the OECD Model Convention (1997 version). Article 14 in its entirety and the Commentary on it were deleted from the OECD Model Convention on 29 April 2000. Subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 allows the source country to tax one situation in addition to the situation contained in paragraph 1 of Article 14 of the 1997 OECD Model Convention. Moreover, whereas the former OECD Model Convention allowed the source country to tax income from independent personal services only if such income was attributable to a fixed base of the taxpayer, the UN Model Convention also allows taxation at source if the taxpayer is present in that country for more than 183 days during any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned.
- During the discussion of Article 14, some members of the Group from developing countries expressed the view that taxation by the source country should not be limited by the criteria of the existence of a fixed base and the duration of presence, and that the only criterion should be the source of income. Some members of the Group from developed countries, on the other hand, considered that the export of professional skills, like the export of tangible goods, should not result in taxation in the country of destination if the person concerned did not have a fixed base in that country comparable to a permanent establishment. They therefore supported the fixed-base criterion, although they also agreed that taxation in the source country was justified where the person providing the services had a prolonged presence in that country. Some members of the Group from developing countries also supported the fixed-base criterion. Other members of the Group from developing countries expressed a preference for a criterion based on the duration of presence.
- During the development of the 1980 Model Convention, several members of the Group from developing countries proposed a third criterion, namely the amount of remuneration. Under this criterion, remuneration for independent personal services could be taxed by the source country if it exceeded a specified amount, irrespective of the existence of a fixed base or the duration of presence in that country.
- As a compromise, the 1980 Model Convention contained three alternative criteria, set out in subparagraphs (a)–(c) of paragraph 1, compliance with any one of which gives the source country the right to tax income derived from the provision of independent personal services by a person who is a resident of another State. However, in 1999, the Group of Experts decided to delete the third criterion, namely the amount of remuneration, set out in subparagraph (c), while retaining subparagraphs (a) and (b).
- Subparagraph (a), which reproduces the sole criterion contained in the OECD Model Convention, provides that income may be taxed if the individual has a fixed base regularly available to him for the purpose of performing his activities. Although the existence of a fixed base gives the right to tax, the amount of income subject to tax is limited to the amount attributable to the fixed base.
- Subparagraph (b), as amended in 1999, extends the source country's right to tax by providing that the source State may levy tax if the person concerned is present in the country for a period or periods aggregating at least 183 days within any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned, even in the absence of a fixed base. However, only income derived from activities performed in that country may be taxed. Before this amendment, the requirement of a minimum period of presence in the Contracting State was defined as a "period or periods aggregating 183 days or more in the fiscal year concerned". One member of the Group from a developed country, however, advocated retaining the previous wording for technical reasons. By virtue of this amendment, the provisions of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 14 were brought into line with those of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 of Article 15 concerning the minimum period of presence in the other Contracting State.
- Before its deletion, subparagraph (c) provided for another criterion for taxation by the source country where neither of the two conditions specified in subparagraphs (a) and (b) was satisfied. It provided that, if the remuneration for services performed in the source country exceeded a certain amount (to be established in the course of bilateral negotiations), the source State could levy tax, but only if that remuneration was derived from a resident of the source country or from a permanent establishment or fixed base of a resident of any other country located in the territory of that country.
- It was noted that any monetary thresholds established in this respect would lose their significance over time as a result of inflation and would have the effect of limiting the amount of potentially valuable services that the country could import. Moreover, a provision of this kind appeared in only six per cent of the existing bilateral tax treaties concluded between 1980 and 1997. Accordingly, it was decided to delete subparagraph (c) from paragraph 1 of Article 14.
- The former Group of Experts discussed the relationship between Article 14 and subparagraph (b) of paragraph 3 of Article 5. It was generally agreed that remuneration paid directly to an individual for activities performed by that individual in an independent capacity was governed by the provisions of Article 14. Payments made to an enterprise for the provision by that enterprise of the services of its employees or other personnel were governed by Articles 5 and 7. Remuneration paid by an enterprise to an individual who performed the work was governed either by Article 14 (if that individual was an independent contractor engaged by the enterprise to perform the activity concerned) or by Article 15 (if that individual was an employee of the enterprise). If the parties consider that further clarification of the relationship between Article 14 and Articles 5 and 7 is necessary, they may provide such clarification during negotiations.
- Since Article 14 of the United Nations Model Convention contains all the essential provisions of Article 14 of the 1977 OECD Model Convention, the previous Commentary on that Article remains applicable. It states:
- The Article is concerned with what are generally referred to as professional services and other activities of an independent character. It excludes industrial and commercial activities as well as professional services performed in employment, for example, a doctor serving as a medical officer of a factory. It should, however, be noted that the Article does not deal with the independent activities of entertainers and sportspersons, which are covered by Article 17.
- The meaning of the term "professional services" is illustrated by examples of typical independent professions. This list is provided solely by way of illustration and is not exhaustive. Difficulties of interpretation arising in special cases may be resolved by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States concerned.
- The provisions of the Article are similar to those concerning business profits and are, in fact, based on the same principles as those in Article 7. Accordingly, the provisions of Article 7 and the Commentary thereon may be used as guidance for the interpretation and application of Article 14. Thus, the principles underlying Article 7, for example, those relating to the allocation of profits between the head office and a permanent establishment, may also be applied to the proportional allocation of profits between the State of residence of the person providing independent services and the State in which those services are performed through a fixed base. Likewise, expenses incurred for the purposes of the fixed base, including administrative and general expenses, should be allowed as deductions in determining the income attributable to the fixed base, just as such expenses incurred for the purposes of a permanent establishment are allowed as deductions [...]. In other respects, Article 7 and the Commentary thereon may also assist in the interpretation of Article 14, for example, on the question whether payments for computer software should be classified as business income under Article 7 or Article 14, or as royalties under Article 12.
- Although Article 7 and Article 14 are based on the same principles, it was decided that the concept of a permanent establishment should be retained for commercial and industrial activities. The term "fixed base" is therefore used. It was considered inappropriate to formulate a definition of this term, but it refers, for example, to a doctor's consulting room or an office of an architect or lawyer. A person providing independent services will probably not, as a rule, have premises of this kind anywhere other than in the State of his residence. However, where a centre of activity, whether of a permanent or temporary nature, exists in another State, that State will have the right to tax the activities of that person.
- The interpretation of Article 14 by some countries differs from the interpretation set out in paragraphs 9 and 10 above. Consequently, such countries may clarify their position and agree on these aspects on a bilateral basis, if they have not already been settled.
Article 15
INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT
- Article 15 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 15 of the OECD Model Convention. The only differences are the title of the OECD Convention Article, which is now worded as "INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT", and the deletion of the reference to a "fixed base" in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 2. These changes result from the deletion of Article 14 from the OECD Model Convention in 2000. The Commentary on Article 15 of the OECD Model Convention reads as follows:
- Paragraph 1 establishes the general rule concerning the taxation of income from employment (other than pensions), according to which such income is taxable in the State where the employment is actually exercised. The question whether or not services are rendered in the exercise of employment may sometimes give rise to difficulties, which are discussed in paragraph 8.1 et seq. Employment is exercised at the place where the employee is physically present when performing the work for which the employment income is paid. One consequence of this is that a resident of a Contracting State who receives remuneration for employment from sources in another State cannot be subject to tax in that other State in respect of such remuneration merely on the ground that the results of his work are used in that other State.
- The only exceptions to the general rule are pensions (Article 18), as well as remuneration and pensions in respect of government service (Article 19). Remuneration of members of boards of directors of companies that is not related to employment falls under Article 16.
2.1 Member countries generally understand the term "wages, salaries and other similar remuneration" to include payments in kind received in connection with employment (for example, employee stock options, the use of housing or a car, health or life insurance and club membership).
2.2 The condition laid down in this Article for taxation by the source State is that wages, salaries and other similar remuneration must be derived from employment exercised in that State. This rule applies irrespective of when such income may be paid, credited or otherwise definitively placed at the disposal of the employee.
- Paragraph 2, however, contains a general exception to the rule laid down in paragraph 1. This exception applies to all individuals [employees] rendering services in employment (sales representatives, construction workers, engineers, etc.), to the extent that their remuneration is not covered by the provisions of other Articles applicable, in particular, to government service or to entertainers and sportspersons.
- For remuneration to qualify for exemption from tax, the three conditions laid down in this paragraph must be satisfied. The first condition is that the exemption is limited to a 183-day period. Furthermore, it is provided that this period must not be exceeded "in any twelve-month period commencing or ending in the fiscal year concerned". This differs from the 1963 Draft Convention and the 1977 Model Convention, which provided that the 183-day period44 must not be exceeded "in the fiscal year concerned", and such wording created difficulties [in cases] where the fiscal years of the Contracting States did not coincide, sometimes allowing opportunities to be created by organizing work in such a way that, for example, employees remained in the State concerned for the last 5.5 months of one year and the first 5.5 months of the following year. The current wording of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 does not permit such an opportunity to be used for tax avoidance. In applying this wording, all possible consecutive twelve-month periods must be considered, including those periods that overlap to some extent with other periods. For example, if an employee is present in one State for 150 days between 1 April 2001 and 31 March 2002, and is present in that State for 210 days between 1 August 2001 and 31 July 2002, the employee will be considered to have been present for more than 183 days during the second of the above-mentioned twelve-month periods, even though the employee does not meet the minimum presence criterion during the first period under consideration and that first period partially overlaps with the second.
44 The same change was introduced in the 1999 United Nations Model Convention.
- Although countries have used different formulas for calculating the 183-day period, there is only one method that is consistent with the wording of this paragraph: the "days of physical presence" method. This method is simple to apply, since a person is either present or not present in the country. It is also relatively easy for the taxpayer to document his presence if evidence is required by the tax authorities. Under this method, the following days are taken into account: any part of a day, the day of arrival, the day of departure and all other days spent in the State where the work is performed, including Saturdays and Sundays, national holidays, weekends before, during and after the work, short breaks (professional training, strikes, lockouts, delays in deliveries), days of illness (if they do not prevent the person from leaving the country and the person would otherwise have qualified for exemption from tax), as well as days of death or illness of family members. However, days spent in the State where the work is performed in transit between two points located outside that State are excluded from the calculation. It follows from these principles that any full day spent outside the State where the work is performed, whether for the purpose of a holiday, a business trip or any other reason, is not taken into account. Any day during which the taxpayer is present in the territory of the State, even for a short period, is considered a day of presence in that State for the purposes of calculating the 183-day period.
5.1 Those days during which the taxpayer is a resident of the source State should not, however, be taken into account in the calculation. Subparagraph (a) should be considered in the context of the first part of paragraph 2, which refers to "remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of employment exercised in the other Contracting State", which does not apply to a person who lives and works in the same State. The words "the recipient is present", found in subparagraph (a), refer to the recipient of such remuneration, and during the period of presence in the source State the person cannot be considered the recipient of remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of employment exercised in another Contracting State. This conclusion may be illustrated by the following examples:
- Example 1. From 1 January to 1 December, individual X lives in State S and is a resident thereof. On 1 January 2002, individual X is employed by an employer who is a resident of State R, and the individual moves to State R, becoming a resident thereof. Subsequently, the individual is sent by his employer on assignment to State S from 15 to 31 March 2002. In this case, individual X is present in State S for 292 days between 1 April 2001 and 31 March 2002, but, since he is a resident of State S from 1 April to 31 December 2001, this first period is not taken into account for the purposes of calculating the periods referred to in subparagraph (a).
- Example 2. From 15 to 31 October 2001, individual Y, a resident of State R, is present in State S for the purpose of preparing for the expansion of the business of firm "ACO" in that country, which is also a resident of State R. On 1 May 2002, individual Y moves to State S, where he becomes a resident and works as a manager of the newly established subsidiary of firm "ACO", a resident of State S. In this case, individual Y is present in State S for 184 days between 15 October 2001 and 14 October 2002; however, since he is a resident of State S from 1 May to 14 October 2002, this latter period is not taken into account for the purposes of calculating the periods referred to in subparagraph (a).
- The second condition is that the employer paying the remuneration must not be a resident of the State in which the employment is exercised. However, some member countries may consider it inappropriate to extend the exception in paragraph 2 to cases where the employer is not a resident of the State in which the employee resides, since in such cases administrative difficulties may arise in determining the employee's employment income or in enforcing the employer's withholding obligations. Contracting States sharing this view may adopt the following alternative wording of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 on a bilateral basis:
b) the remuneration is paid by, or on behalf of, an employer who is a resident of the first-mentioned State; and
6.1 The application of the second condition in the case of fiscally transparent partnerships gives rise to certain difficulties, since such partnerships cannot be considered residents of a Contracting State under Article 4 (see paragraph 8.2 of the Commentary on Article 4). Although it is clear that such a partnership may qualify as an "employer" (particularly under the definitions of that term in the domestic law of certain countries, for example, where an employer is defined as a person responsible for the payment of payroll tax), applying this condition at the partnership level, irrespective of the status of the partners, would render this condition entirely meaningless.
6.2 The object and purpose of subparagraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2 is to avoid source taxation of short-term employment to the extent that employment income is not attributable to income deductible for tax purposes in the source State, since the employer is not taxed in that State because it is neither a resident thereof nor has a permanent establishment therein. These subparagraphs may also be justified on the grounds that introducing a requirement to withhold tax at source in respect of short-term employment in that State may be regarded as an excessive administrative burden where the employer is neither a resident nor has a permanent establishment in that State. In order to achieve a clear interpretation of subparagraph (b), consistent with its content and purpose, it should be considered that, in relation to fiscally transparent partnerships, this subparagraph applies at the level of the partners. Thus, the terms "employer" and "resident" in subparagraph (b) apply at the level of the partners rather than at the level of the fiscally transparent partnership. This approach is consistent with the approach whereby other provisions of a tax treaty should be applied at the level of the individual partners rather than the partnership. Although such an interpretation may create difficulties where the partners reside in different States, such difficulties may be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure, for example, by determining the State in which the partners holding a controlling interest in the partnership reside (that is, the State in which the main part of the tax deduction is claimed).
Some members of the Committee of Experts disagreed with the proposal included in paragraph 6.2 of the above extract from the OECD Commentary that the terms "employer" and "resident" in subparagraph (b) apply at the level of the partners. They challenge the stated justification for this approach, namely that, in cases involving fiscally transparent partnerships, the provisions of tax treaties should be applied at the level of the partners. They consider that a specific provision in the Convention is required to achieve such a result. The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention reads as follows:
- Under the third condition, if the employer has a permanent establishment [or a fixed base, if it provides professional services or carries on other activities of an independent character] in the State in which the employment is exercised, the exemption from tax is granted only if the remuneration is not borne by that permanent establishment [or fixed base which it has in that State]. The phrase "borne by" should be interpreted in the light of the fundamental purpose of subparagraph (c) of this Article, which is to ensure that the exception provided for in paragraph 2 does not apply to remuneration that may give rise to a tax deduction attributable to the principles of Article 7 and to the nature of the remuneration in calculating the profits of the permanent establishment in the State where the employment is exercised.
7.1 The fact that the employer has or has not actually claimed a tax deduction for the remuneration in calculating the profits attributable to the permanent establishment does not necessarily constitute sufficient evidence, since the relevant test is whether the deduction otherwise applicable in respect of the remuneration should be taken into account in determining the profits attributable to the permanent establishment. This test is satisfied, for example, even if the amount is not actually deducted because the permanent establishment is exempt from taxation in the source country or because the employer simply decides not to claim a tax deduction to which it is entitled. This test is also satisfied where the remuneration is not deductible solely by reason of its nature (for example, where a State takes the position that the issue of shares under an employee stock option does not give rise to such a deduction), rather than because it should not be attributed to the permanent establishment.
- There is a direct relationship between the principles underlying the granting of the exception under paragraph 2 and Article 7. Article 7 is based on the principle that an enterprise of one Contracting State should not be taxed in another State unless its business presence in that other State has reached a level sufficient to constitute a permanent establishment. The exception provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15 extends this principle to the taxation of the employees of such an enterprise where the activities of those employees are carried out in the other State for a relatively short period of time. Subparagraphs (b) and (c) clarify that this exception is not intended to apply in cases where employment services are provided to an enterprise whose profits are taxed in one State because it is either a resident of that State or has a permanent establishment therein to which such services are attributable.
8.1 In some cases, difficulties may arise in determining whether services rendered in one State by an individual who is a resident of another State to an enterprise of the first-mentioned State (or to an enterprise having a permanent establishment in that State) are employment services to which Article 15 applies, or services provided by an independent enterprise to which Article 7 applies, or, more generally, in applying the exception. Although the Commentary previously addressed cases where arrangements were structured with the principal purpose of obtaining the benefits of the exception provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15, it was found that similar problems may arise in many other cases unrelated to tax-motivated avoidance transactions, and the Commentary was amended to provide a more comprehensive discussion of these issues.
8.2 In some States, formal contractual relationships cannot be challenged for tax purposes in the absence of evidence of manipulation, and those States, under their domestic law, will consider that services are rendered in employment only where formal employment relationships exist.
8.3 If States where precisely this situation arises are concerned that this approach may result in the granting of benefits under the exception provided for in paragraph 2 in cases involving unintended arrangements (for example, cases of so-called hiring-out of labour), they may adopt the following provision on a bilateral basis, worded approximately as follows:
Paragraph 2 of this Article shall not apply to remuneration derived by a resident of one of the Contracting States in respect of employment exercised in the other Contracting State and paid by, or on behalf of, an employer who is not a resident of that other State where:
a) the recipient provides services in the course of such employment to a person other than the employer, and that person directly or indirectly supervises, directs and controls the manner in which those services are provided; and
b) those services constitute an integral part of the business activities carried on by that person.
8.4 In many States, however, various legislative and judicial rules and criteria have been developed (for example, the "substance over form" rule) for distinguishing cases in which services provided by an individual to an enterprise should be regarded as rendered in an employment relationship (employment contract) from cases in which such services should be regarded as rendered under a contract for the provision of services between two independent enterprises (service contract). This distinction remains relevant for the purposes of applying the provisions of Article 15, in particular the provisions of subparagraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2. Subject to the limit referred to in paragraph 8.11, and unless otherwise provided in the context of a particular Convention, the domestic law of the source State determines whether the services of an individual in that State are rendered in an employment relationship, and that determination governs the application of the Convention by that State.
8.5 In some cases, services rendered by an individual to an enterprise may be regarded as employment services for the purposes of domestic tax law even if such services are provided under a formal contract for the provision of services between the enterprise acquiring the services, on the one hand, and either the individual himself or another enterprise with which the individual has formal employment relations or with which the individual has concluded another formal contract for the provision of services, on the other hand.
8.6 In such cases, the applicable domestic law may disregard the way in which the services concerned are characterized in the formal contracts. In determining whether an employment relationship exists between the individual and the enterprise, that law may place primary emphasis on the nature of the services provided by the individual and their integration into the business activities carried on by that enterprise.
8.7 Since the concept of employment to which Article 15 refers must be determined in accordance with the domestic law of the State applying the Convention (subject to the limit referred to in paragraph 8.11 and unless otherwise provided in the context of a particular Convention), it follows that a State which regards such services as employment services will apply Article 15 accordingly. It may logically be concluded from this that the enterprise to which the services were rendered is in an employment relationship with the individual and should therefore be considered his employer for the purposes of subparagraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2. This conclusion is consistent with the object and purpose of paragraph 2 of Article 15, since in this case it may be argued that the employment services were rendered to a resident of the State in which the services were performed.
8.8 As indicated in paragraph 8.2, even in cases where the domestic law of the State applying the Convention does not permit formal contractual relationships to be challenged and, consequently, does not allow the State to consider that services rendered to a local enterprise by an individual who is formally an employee of a non-resident are provided within an employment relationship (employment contract) with that local enterprise, that State may refuse to apply the exception under paragraph 2 in cases of abuse.
8.9 The various approaches available to States wishing to combat such cases of abuse are discussed in the section "Improper Use of the Convention" in the Commentary on Article 1. As explained in paragraph 9.4 of that Commentary, it has been agreed that States should not grant tax treaty benefits in respect of arrangements that constitute an abuse of the provisions of the Convention. However, as noted in paragraph 9.5 of that Commentary, it should not be assumed without due consideration that this is the case (see also paragraph 22.2 of that Commentary).
8.10 Thus, the approach described in the preceding paragraphs allows the State in which the activities are performed to refuse to apply paragraph 2 in cases of abuse, as well as in cases where, under the concept of employment incorporated into domestic law, the services rendered to a local enterprise by an individual who is formally an employee of a non-resident are performed within an employment relationship (employment contract for services) with that local enterprise. This approach ensures that exemption from double taxation is granted in the State of residence of the individual, even if that State, under its own domestic law, does not consider that an employment relationship exists between that individual and the enterprise to which the services are provided. In fact, if the State of residence recognizes that the concept of employment under the domestic tax law of the source State or the existence of arrangements constituting an abuse of the Convention allows that State to tax the employment income of the individual in accordance with the Convention, it must provide relief from double taxation in accordance with the obligations contained in Articles 23A and 23B (see paragraphs 32.1–32.7 of the Commentary on those Articles). The mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25 may be applied in cases where the State of residence does not agree that the other State has correctly applied the approach described above and, consequently, does not consider that the other State has taxed the relevant income in accordance with the Convention.
8.11 Nevertheless, the conclusion that formal contractual relationships should be disregarded under national law should be reached on the basis of objective criteria. For example, a State cannot claim that, under its domestic law, services are considered to be rendered in employment in cases where the relevant facts and circumstances clearly indicate that those services are provided under a contract for the provision of services concluded between two independent enterprises. The exemption from taxation provided for under paragraph 2 of Article 15 would be rendered meaningless if States were allowed to regard services as employment services in cases where there is clearly no employment relationship, or to deny an enterprise the status of employer in respect of work performed by a non-resident where it is evident that the enterprise provides services through its own personnel to another enterprise in relation to work performed by a resident. Conversely, if services rendered by an individual may properly be regarded by a State as rendered within an employment relationship rather than under a contract for the provision of services concluded between two enterprises, that State must also logically consider that the individual is not carrying on the business activities of the enterprise that is the formal employer of that individual; this approach may be relevant, for example, for the purposes of determining whether an enterprise has a permanent establishment in the place where the individual performs his activities.
8.12 It is not always obvious whether services rendered by an individual may properly be regarded by a State as services rendered within an employment relationship rather than under a contract for the provision of services concluded between two enterprises. Any disagreements between States in this regard should be resolved taking into account the following principles and examples, using the mutual agreement procedure where necessary).
8.13 An important factor is the nature of the services provided by the individual, since it is logical to assume that an employee provides services that form an integral part of the business activities carried on by his employer. It is therefore important to determine whether the services provided by the individual to the enterprise constitute an integral part of the business activities carried on by that enterprise. For this purpose, the key factor will be determining which enterprise bears responsibility or risk for the results of the individual's work. It is clear, however, that this analysis will be relevant only if the services are provided by the individual directly to the enterprise. In cases, for example, where an individual provides services to a contract manufacturer or to an enterprise whose business operations have been outsourced, the services of that individual are not provided to the enterprises that will receive the products or services concerned.
8.14 Where a comparison of the nature of the services provided by the individual with the business activities carried on by his formal employer and by the enterprise to which the services are provided indicates an employment relationship different from the formal contractual relationship, the following additional factors may be relevant in determining whether this conclusion is justified:
- who has the authority to instruct the individual as to the manner in which the work is to be performed;
- who controls and is responsible for the place where the work is performed;
- the remuneration of the individual is directly charged by the formal employer to the enterprise to which the services are provided (see paragraph 8.15 below);
- who places the tools and materials necessary for the work at the individual's disposal;
- who determines the number and qualifications of the persons performing the work;
- who has the right to select the individual to perform the work and to terminate the contractual relationship concluded with that individual for this purpose;
- who has the right to impose disciplinary sanctions relating to the work of the individual;
- who determines the days off and working schedule of the individual.
8.15 Where an individual who is formally an employee of one enterprise provides services to another enterprise, the financial arrangements established between those two enterprises are obviously relevant, although they do not necessarily provide conclusive evidence for the purposes of determining whether the remuneration of that individual is directly charged by his formal employer to the enterprise to which the services are provided. For example, if the fee charged by the enterprise that is the formal employer of the individual represents the remuneration, additional payments and benefits of the employee and other personnel costs relating to the services that the individual provided to the other enterprise, without a profit element or with a profit element calculated as a percentage of such remuneration, additional payments and benefits and other personnel costs, this may be regarded as an indication that the remuneration of that individual is directly charged by his formal employer to the enterprise to which the services are provided. This would not be considered to be the case, however, if the fee charged for the services has no connection with the remuneration of the individual, or if that remuneration is merely one of many factors taken into account in determining the fee for what is in reality a contract for the provision of services (for example, where a consulting firm charges a client a fee based on an hourly rate for the time spent by one of its employees performing a particular contract, and that fee takes into account various expenses of the firm), provided that this is consistent with the arm's length principle where the two enterprises are related. It is important to note, nevertheless, that the question whether the remuneration of the individual is directly charged by his formal employer to the enterprise to which the services are provided is merely one of the auxiliary factors relevant to determining whether the services provided by that individual may properly be regarded by the State as rendered within an employment relationship rather than under a contract for the provision of services concluded between two enterprises.
8.16 Example 1. "Aco", a company resident in State A, enters into a contract with "Bco", a company resident in State B, to provide professional training services. Aco specializes in training employees to use various computer programs, and Bco wishes to train its personnel to use recently acquired software. Mr. X, an employee of Aco who is a resident of State A, is sent to Bco's office in State B to conduct training courses under this contract.
8.17 In this case, State B cannot claim that Mr. X is in an employment relationship with Bco or that Aco is not Mr. X's employer for the purposes of the Convention between States A and B. Mr. X is formally an employee of Aco, and the services he himself provides, when considered in the light of the factors referred to in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, form an integral part of Aco's business activities. The services he provides to Bco are rendered on behalf of Aco under a contract concluded between those two enterprises. Thus, provided that Mr. X is not present in State B for more than 183 days during the relevant twelve-month period and that Aco does not have a permanent establishment in State B that bears the expenses of Mr. X's remuneration, the exemption from taxation provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15 will apply to Mr. X's remuneration.
8.18 Example 2. "Cco", a company resident in State C, is the parent company of a group of companies that includes "Dco", a company resident in State D. Cco has developed a new worldwide marketing strategy for the products of the entire group. In order to ensure that Dco, which sells the group's products, properly understands and follows this strategy, Cco sends one of its employees who developed the strategy, Mr. X, to work at Dco's head office in State D for a period of four months, to advise Dco on its marketing activities and to ensure that Dco's public relations department understands and complies with the worldwide marketing strategy.
8.19 In this case, Cco's business activities include managing the marketing activities of the group of companies worldwide, and the services provided by Mr. X himself form an integral part of those activities. Although it could be argued that Dco could easily hire an employee to perform the function of advising the company on marketing matters, it is quite clear that this function is often performed by a consultant, particularly where specialized knowledge is required for a relatively short period of time. Furthermore, the function of monitoring compliance with the group's worldwide marketing strategy falls within the scope of Cco's business activities rather than those of Dco. Accordingly, the exemption from taxation provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15 should apply in this case, provided that the other conditions for granting such exemption are satisfied.
8.20 Example 3. A multinational corporation owns and operates a worldwide hotel network through a number of subsidiaries. Eco, one of those subsidiaries, is a resident of State E, where it owns and operates a hotel. Mr. X is an employee of Eco and works at that hotel. Fco, another subsidiary of the group, owns and operates a hotel in State F, where there is a shortage of employees who speak a foreign language. For this reason, Mr. X is assigned to work for five months at the reception desk of Fco's hotel. Fco pays Mr. X's travel expenses, while he formally remains an employee of Eco and continues to be paid by Eco. Fco also pays Eco a management services fee calculated on the basis of the amount of Mr. X's remuneration, social security contributions and other additional payments for the relevant period.
8.21 In this case, the work at the reception desk of the hotel in State F, when considered in the light of the factors referred to in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, may be regarded as an integral part of Fco's business activities in operating that hotel, rather than part of Eco's business activities. In accordance with the approach described above, if, under the domestic law of State F, Mr. X's services are regarded as having been rendered to Fco within an employment relationship, State F could logically accept that Fco is Mr. X's employer and that the tax exemption under paragraph 2 of Article 15 does not apply.
8.22 Example 4. "Gco" is a company resident in State G. It carries on business activities consisting of meeting the temporary demand of enterprises for highly qualified specialized personnel. "Hco" is a company resident in State H and provides engineering services at construction sites. In order to perform one of its contracts in State H, Hco requires an engineer for a period of five months. For this purpose, it approaches Gco. Gco selects Mr. X, an engineer and a resident of State X, and employs him under an employment contract for a period of five months. Under a separate contract between Gco and Hco, Gco undertakes to provide Mr. X's services to Hco for the specified period. Under these contracts, Gco will pay Mr. X's remuneration, social security contributions, travel expenses and other payments and charges.
8.23 In this case, Mr. X provides engineering services, whereas Gco carries on business activities consisting of meeting the short-term staffing needs of enterprises. By their nature, the services provided by Mr. X do not form an integral part of the business activities of his formal employer. At the same time, such services form an integral part of Hco's business activities as an engineering firm. In the light of the factors referred to in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, State H may therefore consider, in accordance with the approach described above, that the tax exemption under paragraph 2 of Article 15 does not apply to the remuneration for the engineering services that will be provided in that State.
8.24 Example 5. Ico is a company resident in State I and specializes in providing engineering services. Ico has several full-time engineers in State I. Jco is a smaller engineering firm and a resident of State J, which requires the temporary services of an engineer to complete a contract at a construction site in State J. Ico agrees with Jco that one of Ico's engineers, who is a resident of State I and is not currently engaged in performing any contract concluded by Ico, will work for four months under Jco's contract, under the direct supervision and control of one of Jco's senior engineers. Jco will pay Ico an amount for that engineer equal to his remuneration, social security contributions, travel expenses and other employee benefits for the relevant period, plus a five per cent commission. Jco also undertakes to indemnify Ico against any possible claims relating to the engineer's work during that period.
8.25 In this case, even though Ico carries on business activities involving the provision of engineering services, it is quite clear that the work performed by the engineer at the construction site in State J is carried out on behalf of Jco rather than Ico. The direct supervision and control exercised by Jco over the engineer's work, the fact that Jco assumes responsibility for that work, as well as the fact that it bears the costs of the engineer's remuneration for the relevant period, are factors that could support the conclusion that an employment relationship exists between the engineer and Jco. In accordance with the approach described above, State J may therefore consider that the tax exemption under paragraph 2 of Article 15 does not apply to the remuneration for the engineering services that will be provided in that State.
8.26 Example 6. Kco, a company resident in State K, and Lco, a company resident in State L, are members of the same multinational group of companies. A significant part of the group's activities is organized along functional lines, requiring employees of different group companies to work together under the direction of managers who are located in different States and are employees of other group companies. Ms. X is a resident of State K and an employee of Kco, where she holds the position of senior manager responsible for overseeing human resources functions within the multinational group. Since Ms. X is employed by Kco, Kco acts as the cost centre in which the group's human resources expenses are concentrated; these expenses are periodically recharged to each of the group companies on the basis of a formula that takes into account various factors, such as the number of employees of each company. Ms. X frequently needs to travel on business to other States where the offices of other group companies are located. During the past year, Ms. X spent three months in State L dealing with human resources issues for Lco.
8.27 In this case, the work performed by Ms. X forms part of the activities carried on by Kco for the benefit of the entire multinational group. Such activities, like other activities such as corporate communications, strategy, finance and tax accounting, treasury, information management and legal support, are often centralized within a large group of companies. Thus, the work performed by Ms. X forms an integral part of Kco's business activities. Accordingly, the tax exemption provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15 should apply to Ms. X's remuneration for her work in State L, provided that the other conditions for granting such exemption are satisfied.
8.28 Where, in accordance with the principles and examples set out above, a State properly considers that services provided by an individual in the territory of that State are rendered within an employment relationship rather than under a contract for the provision of services concluded between two enterprises, there may be a risk that enterprises in the two jurisdictions will be required to withhold tax at source on the remuneration of that individual, even though the ultimate objective is to avoid double taxation (see paragraph 8.10 above). This compliance difficulty may be partially reduced by the tax administration ensuring that domestic rules and practices concerning employment are clear, understandable and readily accessible to employers. In addition, this problem may be alleviated if the State of residence allows enterprises to adjust the amount of tax to be withheld quickly, taking into account any exemption from double taxation that is likely to apply to the employee concerned.
- Paragraph 3 of Article 15 reproduces paragraph 3 of Article 15 of the OECD Model Convention as amended in 2017. The relevant part of the Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Convention reads as follows:
- Paragraph 3 applies to the remuneration of crews of ships or aircraft operated in international traffic and provides that such remuneration is taxable only in the State of residence of the employee. The purpose of this amendment was to provide a clearer and administratively simpler rule concerning the taxation of remuneration of such crews.
9.1 At the same time, the definition of international traffic was amended to ensure that it also applies to carriage by a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State. As explained in paragraph 6.1 [paragraph 8.1 of the UN Commentary] of the Commentary on Article 3, this latter amendment allows paragraph 3 of Article 15 to apply to a resident of a Contracting State who receives remuneration in respect of employment exercised aboard a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State.
9.2 However, where the employment is exercised by a resident of one Contracting State aboard a ship or aircraft used exclusively within the other State, it would clearly be inappropriate to grant the exclusive right to tax to the State of residence of the employee. The phrase "except where the ship or aircraft is operated solely within the other Contracting State" ensures that this paragraph does not apply to such an employee, which means that the taxation of that employee's remuneration is governed by the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article.
9.3 As indicated in paragraph 9 above, paragraph 3 applies to crews of ships or aircraft. This is made clear by the reference to employment exercised "as a member of the regular complement of a ship or aircraft". These words are broad enough to cover any employment exercised in the course of the normal operation of a ship or aircraft, including, for example, the activities of restaurant employees aboard a cruise ship or the activities of a flight attendant who works on only one flight before leaving his employment; they do not, however, cover employment that may be exercised aboard a ship or aircraft but is not connected with its operation (for example, an employee of an insurance company selling home and automobile insurance to passengers aboard a cruise ship).
9.4 As explained in paragraph 15 of the Commentary on Article 8, States wishing to apply the same treatment to transportation by rivers, canals and lakes as to sea and air transportation in international traffic may extend the scope of Article 8 to income from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transport. Such States may then wish to apply paragraph 3 of Article 15 to the remuneration of employees engaged on those ships. However, in the case of remuneration received by an employee working aboard a ship engaged in inland waterway transport, paragraph 3 should apply only to the extent that the ship is operated by an enterprise of the State of residence of the employee. Indeed, it would be inappropriate to require one Contracting State to exempt from taxation the remuneration received by an employee who is a resident of another State but works for an enterprise of the first-mentioned State (or of a third State with which the first-mentioned State has not agreed to exempt profits derived from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transport), if that remuneration relates to activities carried on exclusively in that first-mentioned State. Contracting States wishing to resolve this issue could do so by including in their bilateral treaty a separate provision concerning the crews of ships engaged in inland waterway transport, which could be worded as follows:
Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article and Article 1, remuneration received by an individual, whether or not that individual is a resident of a Contracting State, in respect of employment as a member of the regular complement of a ship exercised aboard a ship engaged in inland waterway transport in a Contracting State and operated by an enterprise of the other State shall be taxable only in that other State. However, such remuneration may also be taxed in the first-mentioned State if it is received by a resident of that State.
9.5 As indicated in paragraph 2 [paragraph 10 of the UN Commentary] of the Commentary on Article 8, some States may prefer to assign the exclusive right to tax profits from sea and air transportation to the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated, rather than to the State of residence. If the Contracting States adopt this approach, a similar amendment should be made to the alternative provisions included in paragraphs 9.4 above and 9.6 below, if those provisions are used.
9.6 Some States prefer to allow the remuneration of an employee working aboard a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic to be taxed both by the State of the enterprise operating that ship or aircraft and by the State of residence of the employee. States wishing to do so may formulate paragraph 3 as follows:
- Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article and Article 1, remuneration received by an individual, whether or not that individual is a resident of a Contracting State, in respect of employment as a member of the regular complement of a ship or aircraft exercised aboard a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic by an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that Contracting State. However, if such remuneration is received by a person who is permanently resident in the other Contracting State, it may also be taxed in that other State.
9.7 Some States wishing to adopt this approach may also wish to limit the application of paragraph 3 to employees who are residents of one of the Contracting States, which may be achieved by using the following wording:
- Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, remuneration received by a person who is permanently resident in one Contracting State in respect of employment as a member of the regular complement of a ship or aircraft exercised aboard a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic shall be taxable only in that State. However, if the ship or aircraft is operated by an enterprise of the other Contracting State, such remuneration may also be taxed in that State.
9.8 Under the alternative provision in paragraph 9.6 above, the State of the enterprise has the primary right to tax the employee's remuneration. If the employee is a resident of the other Contracting State, the remuneration may also be taxed in that other State, provided that the latter State is required to provide relief from double taxation in accordance with the provisions of Article 23A or 23B.
9.9 Since this alternative provision allows taxation in the State where the enterprise operating the ship or aircraft is located, it may help to address the situation of employees who work for long periods aboard ships or aircraft operated in international traffic and who may find it advantageous to establish their residence in States that do not tax, or tax only minimally, employment income derived from such work performed outside their territory. However, this provision assumes that the Contracting States are able, under their domestic law, to tax the remuneration of employees working aboard ships or aircraft operated in international traffic solely because the enterprises operating those ships or aircraft are enterprises of those States. If this is not the case, the use of this provision in conjunction with the exemption method for eliminating double taxation will create a risk of double non-taxation. Suppose, for example, that the above provision is included in a treaty between States R and S, that State R uses the exemption method and that an employee who is a resident of State R works on flights between State R and third States operated by an airline that is an enterprise of State S. In this case, if the domestic law of State S does not allow State S to tax the remuneration of airline employees who are not residents of State S and do not work in that State, State S will not be able to exercise the right to tax granted to it, and State R will have to exempt such remuneration from tax, since under the provisions of the Convention State S has the right to tax that remuneration.
9.10 As explained in paragraph 3.1 [paragraph 10.1 of the UN Commentary] of the Commentary on Article 8, it may be provided that the reference to the "place of effective management" in the alternative provision in paragraph 2 [10] of that Commentary applies where the place of effective management of a shipping enterprise is located aboard a ship. Under the domestic law of some member countries, tax is levied on remuneration received by non-resident crew members in respect of employment aboard a ship only if the ship has the nationality of that State. For this reason, conventions concluded between those States provide that the right to tax such remuneration is granted to the State whose nationality the ship has. On the other hand, many States are unable to exercise such a right to tax, and in such cases this provision may result in a situation of non-taxation similar to that described in the preceding paragraph. However, States whose domestic law contains this principle of taxation may agree on a bilateral basis to grant the right to tax remuneration in respect of employment aboard a ship to the State of the ship's nationality.
- It should be noted that there is no special rule concerning the taxation of income of frontier workers or employees working on trucks and trains crossing national borders, since it is more appropriate to resolve problems arising from local conditions directly between the States concerned.
- There is no special provision concerning remuneration received by visiting professors or students working in employment for the purpose of acquiring practical experience. Many conventions contain certain rules governing such situations, the main purpose of which is to promote cultural relations by granting limited tax exemptions. Sometimes exemption from tax is already provided for under domestic tax law. The absence of special rules should not be interpreted as preventing the inclusion of such rules in bilateral conventions if the parties consider it desirable.
Tax treatment of employee stock options
- The different rules applied in countries concerning the taxation of employee stock options create particular problems, which are discussed below. Although many of these problems also arise in relation to other forms of employee remuneration, particularly those based on the value of shares of the employer or a related company, they are most acute in relation to stock options. This is largely because stock options are taxed at a point in time (for example, upon exercise of the option or sale of the shares) that differs from the time when the employees render the services for which such options constitute remuneration.
12.1 As noted in paragraph 2.2, this Article allows the source State to tax that part of the income from stock options which represents remuneration derived from employment exercised in that State, even if the tax is levied at a later date when the employee is no longer employed in that State.
12.2
Although this Article applies to income derived by employees from stock options granted to them, regardless of when such income is taxed, it is necessary to distinguish such employee income from the capital gain that may be derived from the alienation of shares acquired upon the exercise of the option. This Article, and not Article 13, applies to any income derived from the option itself up to the time of its exercise, sale or other alienation (for example, in the event of its cancellation or acquisition by the employer or the issuer). However, upon the exercise or alienation of the option, the employee's income is considered to have been realised, and any subsequent capital gain on the shares acquired (i.e. the increase in the value of the shares accruing after the exercise of the option) is considered to have been derived by the employee in his capacity as an investor-shareholder and falls within the scope of Article 13. In effect, it is at the time of exercise of the option, which the employee received in respect of his employment, that such option ceases to exist and its recipient acquires shareholder status (and usually invests money in order to acquire such status). However, where an exercised option gives the employee the right to acquire shares, the rights to which will not vest finally in him until the end of a specified period of employment, it is appropriate to apply this Article to any increase in value, if any, up to the end of the specified period of employment following the exercise of the option.
12.3
The fact that this Article does not apply to income derived after the exercise or alienation of the option in no way means that the taxation of employment income under domestic law must take place at the time of such exercise or alienation. As already noted, the Article imposes no restrictions as to the time at which the relevant income may be taxed in the State of source. Thus, the State of source may tax the relevant income at the time the option is granted, at the time the option is exercised (or alienated), at the time the shares are sold or at any other time. However, the State of source may tax only income attributable to the option itself and not income relating to the subsequent ownership of shares acquired upon the exercise of that option (except in the circumstances described in the last sentence of the preceding paragraph).
12.4
Since paragraph 1 should be interpreted as referring to any income derived from an option before the time of its exercise, sale or other alienation, it is irrelevant how such income or any part thereof is characterised for domestic tax purposes. As a result, although the Article is interpreted as allowing the State of source to tax income accruing up to the time of the exercise, sale or other alienation of the option, it remains at the discretion of the State to decide how to tax such income, for example, either as employment income or as capital gains. If the State of source decides, for example, to impose a capital gains tax on the option at the time when the employee ceases to be a resident of that State, such tax will be permitted under this Article. The same applies to the State of residence. For example, although that State will have the exclusive right to tax the increase in the value of shares acquired after the exercise of the option, since such treatment would be regarded as falling within the scope of Article 13 of the Convention, it may nevertheless decide to tax such increase as employment income rather than as capital gains under its domestic law.
12.5
Income derived from stock options granted to an employee will generally fall neither within Article 21, which does not apply to income covered by other Articles, nor within Article 18, which applies only to pensions and other similar remuneration, even if the option is exercised after the termination of the employment relationship or retirement.
12.6
Paragraph 1 allows the State of source to tax wages, salaries and other similar remuneration derived from employment exercised in that State. The determination of whether, and to what extent, an employee's stock option is derived from employment in a particular State must be made in each individual case on the basis of all relevant facts and circumstances, including the contractual terms relating to that option (for example, the conditions under which the granted option may be exercised or alienated). For this purpose, the following general principles should be observed.
12.7
The first principle is that, as a general rule, stock options granted to employees should not be considered to relate to any services performed after the employment that is required as a condition for the employee to become entitled to exercise the option. Thus, where a stock option is granted to an employee on the condition that he or she provides services under an employment relationship to the same employer (or a related enterprise) for three years, the employment income derived from that option should generally not be linked to services performed after that three-year period.
12.8
However, in applying this principle, it is important to distinguish between the period of service required for the employee to become entitled to exercise the stock option and a period that merely represents a delay before the option can be exercised (a blocking period). Accordingly, for example, an option granted to an employee on the condition that he or she maintains an employment relationship with the same employer (or an associated enterprise) for three years may be considered to have been derived from services performed during those three years, whereas an option granted to an employee on a particular date without any condition relating to subsequent employment, but with the exercise of the option delayed for three years, should not be regarded as linked to employment during those three years, since the income from such an option accrues to its recipient even if he or she leaves the job immediately after receiving it and waits the required three years before exercising it.
12.9
It is also important to distinguish between a situation in which a period of employment is required as a condition for acquiring the right to exercise the option, that is, for the vesting of the rights to the option, and a situation in which the rights to the option have already vested but the option may be cancelled if it is not exercised before the termination of the employment relationship (or within a short period thereafter). In the latter case, the income from the option should not be regarded as relating to services performed after the rights to exercise it have vested in the employee, since the employee has already received the income and may in fact realise it at any time. A condition under which an exercisable option may be cancelled upon termination of the employment relationship is not a condition for acquiring the benefit but rather a condition under which an already acquired benefit may subsequently be forfeited. This distinction is illustrated by the following examples:
— Example 1. On 1 January 2001, an employee is granted an option to purchase shares. The exercise of the option is conditional upon the employee maintaining an employment relationship with the same employer until 1 January 2003. Once this condition has been fulfilled, the option will be exercisable from 1 January 2003 until 1 January 2010 (a so-called American option⁴⁵). In addition, however, it is provided that any option not previously exercised will be cancelled upon termination of the employment relationship. In this example, the right to exercise the option was acquired on 1 January 2003 (i.e. on the date on which the rights vested), since after that date the employee is not required to complete any additional period of employment in order to acquire the right to exercise the option.
⁴⁵ Under an “American” stock option, the right to purchase shares may be exercised during a specified period (usually several years), whereas under a “European” option this right may be exercised at a particular time (i.e. on a specified date).
— Example 2. On 1 January 2001, an employee is granted an option to purchase shares. The option is exercisable on 1 January 2005 (a so-called European option). This option was granted on the condition that it may be exercised only from 1 January 2005, provided that the employment relationship has not been terminated before that date. In this example, the right to exercise such an option is not acquired until 1 January 2005, that is, on the date of its exercise, since until that date the maintenance of the employment relationship is required in order to acquire the right to exercise the option (i.e. the option to exercise it).
12.10
There are cases in which the first principle may not apply. One such case may arise where a stock option is granted unconditionally to an employee at the time of either entering into an employment relationship, being transferred to another country, or being assigned significant new responsibilities, and in any event the option is clearly linked to the new functions that the employee will perform during a specified period in the future. In such cases, it may be appropriate to consider that the option is linked to those new functions, even if the right to exercise the option vests before the employee begins performing them. There are also cases in which the rights to an option technically vest in the recipient, but the option gives the employee the right to acquire shares, the rights to dispose of which will not vest in the employee until the end of the required period of employment. In such cases, it may be appropriate to consider that the income from the option is linked to the services provided throughout the entire period between the grant of the option and the vesting of the right to dispose of the shares. Under an “American” stock option, the right to purchase shares may be exercised during a specified period (usually several years), whereas under a “European” option this right may be exercised at a particular time (i.e. on a specified date).
12.11
The second principle is that a stock option granted to an employee should be regarded as relating to services performed before the time of its grant only to the extent that the grant of the option is intended as remuneration for services previously performed by the recipient during a specified period. This will be the case, for example, where the remuneration is expressly based on the employee's past performance over a specified period or on the employer's past financial performance, and is conditional upon the employee having maintained an employment relationship with that employer or a related enterprise for a specified period to which those financial results relate. Furthermore, in some cases there may be objective evidence that, during the past period of employment, participants in the employee stock option plan had reasonable expectations that part of their remuneration for that period would be provided in the form of stock options at a later date. Such evidence may include, for example, a consistent practice of the employer of granting similar levels of stock options over a number of years, provided that there are no indications that this practice may be discontinued. Depending on other factors, such evidence may be highly relevant for the purpose of determining whether, and to what extent, the stock option is linked to a past period of employment.
12.12
Where a certain period of employment is required for an employee to become entitled to exercise a stock option, but such requirement is waived in certain circumstances, for example, in the event of termination of the employment relationship by the employer or the employee reaching retirement age, the income from the stock option is considered to be linked only to the period during which services were actually performed when such circumstances have in fact arisen.
12.13
Finally, there may be situations in which certain factors suggest that a stock option granted to an employee is remuneration for past services, while other factors indicate that it relates to future services. In cases of doubt, it should be borne in mind that stock options are usually granted as an incentive for future performance or as a means of retaining valuable employees. Thus, the granting of stock options to employees is primarily linked to future services. Nevertheless, before reaching such a conclusion, all relevant facts and circumstances must be taken into account, and there may be cases in which it can be demonstrated that a stock option is linked to specific combined periods of past and future services (for example, options are granted on the basis of an employee achieving specific performance targets during the previous year, but they become exercisable only if the employee maintains the employment relationship for a further three years).
12.14
Where, on the basis of the principles set out above, a stock option is considered to have been derived from employment in more than one State, it becomes necessary, for the purposes of applying Articles 23A and 23B, to determine what part of the income from such a stock option was derived from employment in each State. In such a case, the employee stock option benefits should be considered to have been derived in a particular country in accordance with the ratio of the number of days during which employment was exercised in that country to the total number of days during which the employment services relating to that stock option were performed. For this purpose, only working days relevant to the stock option plan should be taken into account, for example, those days during which services are provided to the same employer or to other employers whose employment relationships must be taken into account for the purpose of satisfying the employment period requirement necessary to become entitled to exercise the option.
12.15
Member countries have the possibility of departing from the application of the above principles in specific cases (referred to in paragraphs 12.7–12.14) by agreeing on a special approach on a bilateral basis. For example, two countries that primarily tax income at the time of exercise of the option may agree, as a general principle, to attribute income from the option that is primarily linked to future services to services performed by the employee in those two States between the date of grant of the option and the date of its exercise. Thus, in relation to options that cannot be exercised until the employee has provided services to the employer for a specified period, the two States could agree on an approach that attributes the income from the option to each of those States on the basis of the number of days worked by the employee in each State for the benefit of the employer during the period from the date of grant to the date of exercise of the option. Another example would be two countries with similar tax regimes for employee stock options that introduce provisions granting one of the Contracting States the exclusive right to tax employment income, even if a small part of the employment services to which the option relates was performed in the other State. Of course, Member countries should exercise caution when adopting such an approach, since it may result in double taxation or double non-taxation if part of the employment services are performed in a third State that does not apply a similar approach.
3.
Although Articles 14, 15, 19 and 23 may generally be sufficient to avoid double taxation of visiting teachers, some countries may wish to include an article on visiting teachers in their treaties. This matter is discussed in greater detail in paragraphs 10–12 of the Commentary on Article 20.
Article 16
DIRECTORS’ FEES AND REMUNERATION OF TOP-LEVEL MANAGERIAL OFFICIALS
1.
Paragraph 1 of Article 16 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 16 of the OECD Model Convention.
2.
Since paragraph 1 of Article 16 of the United Nations Model Convention fully reproduces Article 16 of the OECD Model Convention, the Commentary on the latter Article accordingly remains applicable and reads as follows:
1. This Article deals with remuneration received by a resident of one of the Contracting States, whether an individual or a legal entity, in the capacity of a member of the board of directors of a company that is a resident of the other Contracting State. Since it is sometimes difficult to determine where the duties are actually performed, the provision refers to duties performed in the State of residence of the company.
1.1 Member countries generally understand the term “fees and other similar payments” to include payments in kind received by a person in his or her capacity as a member of the board of directors of a company (for example, stock options in the company, the use of housing or a car, health or life insurance, and club membership).
2. A member of the board of directors of a company often performs other functions in the company, in particular as an ordinary employee, adviser, consultant, etc. It is clear that this Article does not apply to remuneration paid to such a person for performing these other functions. [This provision is not included in the United Nations Model Convention to the extent that paragraph 2 of Article 16 applies.]
3. In some countries, companies have bodies with functions similar to those of a board of directors. The Contracting States are free to include such bodies of a company in their bilateral conventions in a provision corresponding to Article 16.
3.1 Many of the issues discussed in paragraphs 12–12.15 of the Commentary on Article 15 concerning stock options granted to employees will also arise in the case of stock options granted to members of the boards of directors of companies. Where a stock option is granted to a resident of a Contracting State in his or her capacity as a member of the board of directors of a company that is a resident of the other State, that other State will have the right to tax the part of the income from the stock option that constitutes directors’ fees or similar remuneration (see paragraph 1.1 above), even if the tax is levied at a later time when the person is no longer a member of that board. Although this Article applies to income from a stock option granted to a member of a board of directors regardless of when such income is taxed, it is necessary to distinguish this income from the capital gain that may be derived from the alienation of shares acquired upon the exercise of the option. This Article, and not Article 13, applies to any income derived from the option itself up to the time of its exercise, sale or other alienation (for example, in the event of its cancellation or acquisition by the employer or the issuer). However, upon the exercise or alienation of the option, the income is considered to have been realised, and any subsequent capital gain on the shares acquired (i.e. the increase in the value of the shares accruing after the exercise of the option) is considered to have been derived by the member of the board of directors in his or her capacity as an investor-shareholder and falls within the scope of Article 13. In effect, it is at the time of exercise of the option, which the director received in respect of his or her work in that capacity, that such option ceases to exist and its recipient acquires shareholder status (and usually invests money in order to acquire such status).
3.
Article 16 of the United Nations Model Convention contains another paragraph, which is not included in the OECD Model Convention, concerning the remuneration of top-level managerial officials of companies.
4.
The former Group of Experts decided that where a top-level managerial position in a company that is a resident of one of the Contracting States is occupied by a resident of the other Contracting State, the remuneration paid to such an official is governed by the same principles as directors’ remuneration.
5.
The term “top-level managerial position” refers to a small group of positions involving primary responsibility for the overall management of the affairs of a company, apart from the work of directors. This term covers a person who acts both as a director and as a top-level executive.
Article 17
ENTERTAINERS AND SPORTSPERSONS
1.
Article 17 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 17 of the OECD Model Convention. Unlike the term “entertainer”, the term “sportsperson” is not accompanied by illustrative examples in paragraph 1, but should nevertheless be interpreted broadly in accordance with the spirit and purpose of the Article.
2.
The Commentary on Article 17 of the OECD Model Convention of 2010 reads as follows:
1. Paragraph 1 provides that entertainers and sportspersons who are residents of one of the Contracting States may be taxed in the other Contracting State where their personal activities are exercised, whether on an independent basis or as employees. This provision is an exception to the rules contained in Article [14] and paragraph 2 of Article 15, respectively.
2. This provision makes it possible to avoid practical difficulties that often arise in taxing entertainers and sportspersons performing abroad. Moreover, excessively strict rules may in some cases impede cultural exchange. To overcome these difficulties, the States concerned may, by mutual agreement, limit the application of paragraph 1 to [independent] activities only. For this purpose, it is sufficient to amend the wording of the Article so that the exception relates only to the provisions of Article [14]. In that case, entertainers and sportspersons performing in the course of employment will automatically fall within the scope of Article 15 and will thus be entitled to the tax exemption provided for in paragraph 2 of that Article.
3. Paragraph 1 applies to entertainers and sportspersons. It is impossible to give a precise definition of the term “entertainer”, but paragraph 1 contains examples of persons who are regarded as entertainers. The list of such examples should not be considered exhaustive. On the one hand, the term “entertainer” clearly includes a theatre artist, film actor, actor (including a former sportsperson) appearing in television advertising. This Article may also apply to income derived from political, social, religious or charitable activities where an element of entertainment is present. On the other hand, it does not apply to a visiting speaker at a conference or to administrative or supporting personnel (for example, a cameraman, producer, film director, choreographer, technical staff, the crew accompanying a pop group on tour, etc.). Between these two categories there remains an uncertain category that requires consideration of all aspects of the activities of the person concerned.
4. An individual may direct a performance and participate in it, or may act as a director and producer of a television programme or film while also playing a role in it. In such cases, it is necessary to consider what exactly that person does in the State where the performance takes place. If his or her work in that State consists mainly of performing, the Article should apply to all income derived from that activity in that State. However, if the performing element constitutes an insignificant part of his or her activities in that State, all the income falls outside the scope of the Article. In other cases, the different activities should be divided into separate parts.
5. Although the term “sportsperson” is not precisely defined, it is not limited to participants in traditional sporting events (for example, runners, jumpers and swimmers). It also includes, in particular, golfers, horse riders, footballers, cricketers and tennis players, as well as racing drivers.
6. The Article also applies to income from other activities that are generally considered to be of an entertaining nature, in particular competitions in billiards, bridge and chess tournaments.
7. Income received by an impresario, etc. for organising performances by an entertainer or sportsperson falls outside the scope of this Article, but any income that they receive on behalf of an entertainer or sportsperson undoubtedly falls within its scope.
8. Paragraph 1 applies to income directly or indirectly derived by a particular entertainer or sportsperson. In some cases, the income is not paid directly to that person or to his or her impresario or agent. For example, a member of an orchestra may receive a salary rather than a fee for each individual performance: the Contracting State in which the performance takes place has the right under paragraph 1 to tax the portion of the musician's salary attributable to that performance. Similarly, if an entertainer or sportsperson is employed, for example, by a one-person company, the State in which the performance takes place may tax the corresponding portion of any remuneration paid to that person. Furthermore, if the domestic law of that State “disregards” such enterprises and the income is considered to have accrued directly to the individual, paragraph 1 allows that State to tax income from performances within its territory that has accrued to the legal entity for the benefit of the individual, even if the income has not actually been paid as remuneration to the individual.
9. In addition to fees for actual performances, entertainers and sportspersons often receive income in the form of royalties, sponsorship payments or advertising fees. In general, where there is no direct connection between the income and the public performance of the entertainer in the relevant country, other Articles apply. Royalties for the use of intellectual property rights are generally governed by Article 12 rather than Article 17 (see paragraph 18 of the Commentary on Article 12), but advertising fees and sponsorship payments generally fall outside the scope of Article 12. Article 17 applies to income from advertising participation and sponsorship, etc., that is directly or indirectly connected with activities and performances in that State. Similar income that cannot be attributed to such activities and performances falls within the scope of the standard rules contained in Article [14] or Article 15, depending on the circumstances. Payments received in the event of the cancellation of a performance also fall outside the scope of Article 17 and are governed by Articles 7, [14] or 15, depending on the circumstances.
10. This Article does not specify how such income should be calculated. The amount of any deductions for expenses incurred is determined by the domestic law of the Contracting State. Domestic laws differ from one country to another in this respect, and in some cases they provide for withholding tax at source at a low rate on the gross amount paid to entertainers and sportspersons. Such rules may also apply to income paid to groups or corporate teams, troupes, etc. Some States may, however, consider that taxation of the gross amount may be inappropriate in certain circumstances, even where a reduced rate is applied. These States may wish to allow the taxpayer to be taxed on a net basis. This may be achieved by including a provision drafted along the following lines:
“If a resident of one Contracting State derives income referred to in paragraph 1 or 2, and such income is taxable in the other Contracting State on a gross basis, that individual may, within [a period to be determined by the Contracting States], submit a written request to the other State for such income to be taxed on a net basis in that other State. Such request shall be granted by that other State. In determining the taxable income of such resident in the other State, deductions shall be allowed for such expenses, deductible from the tax base under the domestic law of the other State, as are incurred for the purposes of activities carried out in the other State and are available to a resident of the other State carrying on the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions.”
12.
Paragraph 1 of this Article deals with income derived by individual entertainers and sportspersons from their personal activities. Paragraph 2 deals with situations in which income from their activities accrues to other persons. If the income of an entertainer or sportsperson accrues to another person, and the State of source does not have a statutory right to disregard the person receiving the income for the purpose of taxing that income as the income of the entertainer, the second paragraph provides that the portion of the income that cannot be taxed in the hands of the entertainer may be taxed in the hands of the person receiving the remuneration. If the person receiving the income carries on a business, the tax may be levied by the State of source even if that income is not attributable to a permanent establishment in that State. [If the person receiving the income is an individual, the income may be taxed even in the absence of a fixed base.] However, this is not always the case. There are three main situations of this kind:
a) The first situation is where a management company receives income for the performance of, for example, a group of sportspersons (which is not itself a legal entity).
b) The second situation arises where a team, troupe, orchestra, etc. is a legal entity. Income for performances may be paid to that legal entity. Individual members of the group, orchestra, etc. are taxable under paragraph 1 in the State where the performance is given on any remuneration (or income accrued to them) received in their capacity as participants in the performance; however, if the members of the group receive periodic fixed remuneration and it is difficult to identify the portion of such income attributable to a particular performance, Member countries may decide, on a multilateral or bilateral basis, not to tax it. The element of profit accruing to the legal entity from the performance is taxable under paragraph 2.
c) The third situation concerns certain methods of tax avoidance in cases where remuneration for the performance of an entertainer or sportsperson is paid not to the entertainer or sportsperson personally but to another person, for example, a so-called “star company”, so that the income is not taxed in the State where the activity is carried out, either as income from the personal services of the entertainer or sportsperson or as business profits due to the absence of a permanent establishment. Some countries, under their domestic law, disregard such arrangements and treat the income as having been derived by the entertainer or sportsperson; in such a case, paragraph 1 allows them to tax income derived from activities within their territory. Other countries cannot do this. If the performance takes place in such a country, paragraph 2 allows it to tax the profits derived by the enterprise from the entertainer's or sportsperson's income. However, it may be that the domestic law of some States does not allow them to apply this provision. Such States may agree on other solutions or omit paragraph 2 from their bilateral conventions.
11.1
The application of paragraph 2 is not limited to situations in which both the entertainer or sportsperson and the other person to whom the income accrues, for example, a “star” company, are residents of the same Contracting State. This paragraph allows the State in which the entertainer or sportsperson carries out the activity to tax income derived from that activity and accruing to another person, irrespective of other provisions of the Convention that may apply on other grounds. Thus, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 7, this paragraph allows such a State to tax income derived by a “star” company that is a resident of another Contracting State, even if the entertainer or sportsperson is not a resident of that other State. Conversely, if the income of an entertainer who is a resident of one of the Contracting States accrues to a person, for example, a “star” company that is a resident of a third State with which the State of source has no tax treaty, nothing prevents the Contracting State from taxing such person under its domestic law.
11.2
As a general rule, however, it should be noted that, irrespective of the provisions of Article 17, the Convention does not prevent the application of general anti-avoidance rules provided for under the domestic law of the State of source, which allow that State to tax either the entertainer/sportsperson or the “star” company in cases of abuse, as recognised in paragraph 24 of the Commentary on Article 1.
12.
Where, in the cases referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2, the State of residence of the person receiving the income applies the exemption method for the purpose of eliminating double taxation, that State cannot tax such income even if the State where the activity is carried out is unable to exercise its right to tax. It is therefore understood that in such cases the credit method should be used. The same result may be achieved by providing for a derivative right to tax for the State of residence of the person receiving the income if the State where the activity is carried out is unable to exercise the right it has under paragraphs 1 and 2. The Contracting States may, at their discretion, choose either of these methods to ensure that taxation cannot be avoided.
13.
As a general rule, Article 17 applies where an entertainer or sportsperson is employed by a government and derives income from that government […]. Some conventions contain provisions excluding from the scope of Article 17 entertainers and sportspersons employed by organisations subsidised from public funds.
14.
Some countries may consider it appropriate to exclude from the scope of the Article events financed from public funds. Such countries may include a provision to that effect, but the tax exemption must be based on clearly definable and objective criteria in order to ensure that such exemption is granted only in the cases envisaged. Such a provision may read as follows:
“The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply to income derived from the activities of entertainers or sportspersons carried out in one of the Contracting States if their visit to that State is wholly or mainly financed from public funds of one or both of the Contracting States, their political subdivisions or local authorities. In such a case, the income shall be taxable only in the Contracting State in which the entertainer or sportsperson is a resident.”
3.
When this issue was considered by the former Group of Experts, some members of the Group noted that the examples given in the Commentary on paragraph 2 of Article 17 of the OECD Model Convention should not be interpreted as restricting the scope of taxation solely to the income mentioned in that Commentary. In fact, the wording of the Commentary allows an enterprise in the other Contracting State to be taxed subject to the same limitations as those applicable to entertainers or sportspersons who are residents of one of the Contracting States and carry on activities in the other Contracting State.
4.
On the other hand, members of the Group expressed the view that some countries may wish to narrow the scope of application of paragraph 2.
Article 18
PENSIONS AND SOCIAL SECURITY PAYMENTS
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
1.
Two alternative versions are provided for Article 18 of the United Nations Model Convention — Articles 18A and 18B.
2.
Article 18A, like Article 18 of the OECD Model Convention, grants the State of residence the exclusive right to tax pensions and other similar payments. However, it differs from the OECD Convention Article in that it grants the State of source the exclusive right to tax where the relevant payments are made under a government programme that is part of the social security system of that State, its political subdivision or local authority.
3.
Under Article 18B, the State of source may tax pensions and other similar payments, while the provisions of Article 23A or Article 23B will determine whether the State of residence should exempt such income from tax or allow, by means of a deduction from its own tax on such income, the tax paid in the State of source to be credited. Nevertheless, Article 18 provides for an exclusive right to tax where the payments are made under a government programme that is part of the social security system of the State, its political subdivision or local authority.
B. COMMENTARY ON THE TWO ALTERNATIVE VERSIONS OF ARTICLE 18
Correct the duplicated paragraph numbering
Article 19
GOVERNMENT SERVICE
1. In 2011, the Committee of Experts made certain amendments to Article 19. First, the words "other than pensions" were deleted from paragraph 1. Second, the words "Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1" were added to paragraph 2. Third, in paragraphs 2 and 3, the word "pension" was replaced by the words "pensions and other similar remuneration". As a result, Article 19 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 19 of the OECD Model Convention.
2. Since Article 19 of the United Nations Model Convention includes all the provisions of Article 19 of the OECD Model Convention, the Committee considers the following part of the OECD Commentary to be applicable:
1. This Article applies to salaries, wages and other similar remuneration, as well as pensions, in respect of government service. Similar provisions in earlier bilateral conventions were based on the rules of international courtesy and mutual respect between sovereign States. They were therefore rather limited in scope. However, the importance and scope of Article 19 have increased as a result of the significant expansion of government activities abroad, owing to the growth of the public sector in many countries. Under the original version of paragraph 1 of Article 19 of the 1963 Draft Convention, the paying State was entitled to tax payments made in respect of services rendered to that State, its political subdivisions or local authorities. The expression "may be taxed" was used, and this did not imply an exclusive right to taxation.
2. […] Subparagraph a of paragraphs 1 and 2 was based on the principle that the paying State has the exclusive right to tax the payments. Thus, countries using the credit method as their general method of eliminating double taxation in their conventions are required, as an exception to that method, to exempt from tax such payments to their residents as are governed by paragraphs 1 and 2. If both Contracting States apply the exemption method for the elimination of double taxation, they may continue to use the expression "may be taxed" instead of the expression "shall be taxable only in". Naturally, for such countries, the effect will be the same regardless of which expressions are used. It is understood that the expression "shall be taxable only in" does not prevent a Contracting State from taking into account income exempted under subparagraph a of paragraphs 1 and 2 when determining the rate of tax applicable to income received by its residents from other sources. The principle of granting the exclusive right to tax to the paying State is contained in so many of the conventions currently in force between OECD member countries that it may already be regarded as internationally recognized. It is also consistent with the concept of international courtesy underlying this Article and with the provisions of the Vienna Conventions on Diplomatic Relations and Consular Relations. It should, however, be noted that this Article is not intended to restrict the application of any rules arising under international law concerning diplomatic missions and consular officers (see Article 28), but rather regulates cases not covered by those rules.
2.1 In 1994, a further amendment was made to paragraph 1, replacing the term "remuneration" with the words "salaries, wages and other similar remuneration". This amendment was intended to clarify the scope of this Article, which applies only to government employees and persons receiving pensions in respect of past employment with the State, and not to persons providing services as independent contractors to the State or receiving pensions in respect of such services.
2.2 Member countries generally understand the expression "salaries, wages and other similar remuneration paid" to include benefits in kind received in respect of services rendered to the State, its political subdivisions or local authorities (for example, the use of housing or a car, health or life insurance, and club membership).
3. The provisions of the Article apply to payments made not only by the State, but also by its political subdivisions or local authorities (States, regions, provinces, departments, cantons, districts, municipal districts, municipalities or groups of municipalities, etc.).
4. An exception to the principle of granting the exclusive right to tax to the paying State is contained in subparagraph b of paragraph 1. This should be considered in light of the fact that, under the above-mentioned Vienna Conventions, the receiving State may tax remuneration paid to certain categories of employees of foreign diplomatic missions and consular officers who are permanent residents or nationals of that State. Given that pensions paid to retired government employees should be subject to the same tax treatment as the salaries or wages paid to those employees during their employment, an exception similar to that provided for in subparagraph b of paragraph 1 has also been included in subparagraph b of paragraph 2, which concerns pensions. Since the condition laid down in subparagraph b ii of paragraph 1 cannot apply to a pensioner, the only condition for the receiving State to have the right to tax the pension is that the pensioner must be its resident or national.
5. Under Article 19 of the 1963 Draft Convention, the services rendered to the State, its political subdivisions or local authorities had to be provided "in the discharge of functions of a governmental nature". This expression was deleted from the 1977 Model Convention. However, some OECD member countries considered that this deletion would result in an expansion of the scope of the Article. Contracting States that share this view and consider such an expansion undesirable may continue to use, preferably with clarification, the expression "in the discharge of functions of a governmental nature" in their bilateral conventions.
5.1 While the word "pension", according to the ordinary meaning of that word, applies only to periodic payments, the meaning of the words "other similar remuneration", which were added to paragraph 2 in 2005, is sufficiently broad to cover non-periodic payments. For example, a lump-sum payment in lieu of periodic pension payments made to a former government employee after the termination of employment may fall under paragraph 2 of this Article. Whether a particular lump-sum payment made in such circumstances is to be regarded as other remuneration similar to a pension falling within the scope of paragraph 2, or as final remuneration for work performed falling within the scope of paragraph 1, is a question of fact that may be determined in the light of the factors set out in paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 18.
5.2 It should be noted that the expression "out of funds created by them", used in subparagraph a of paragraph 2, covers situations where a pension is paid not directly by the State, its political subdivision or local authority, but out of separate funds created by them. Furthermore, the initial capital of such a fund need not necessarily be provided by the State, its political subdivision or local authority. This phrase should cover payments made from a private fund established for a government body.
5.3 A problem arises where pensions are paid in compensation for a combination of private and government services. This problem may frequently arise where an individual has been employed in both the private and public sectors and receives the same pension in respect of both periods of employment. This may occur either because the individual participated in the same pension scheme throughout the entire period of employment or because the individual's pension rights were transferred. The significance of this issue may increase as a result of the trend towards greater mobility of workers between the private and public sectors.
5.4 Where a civil servant who rendered services to the State has transferred his or her pension rights from a government scheme to a private scheme, the pension payments will be taxable only under Article 18, since such payments do not meet the technical requirements of paragraph 2 a.
5.5 Where pension rights are transferred in the opposite direction — from a private scheme to a government scheme — some States tax the pension payments in full under Article 19. Other States, however, allocate the pension payments on the basis of the relative source of the pension benefits, so that one part is taxed under Article 18 and the other part under Article 19. Some States consider that if the predominant part of the pension amount comes from one source, the pension should be treated as if it were paid entirely from that source. Nevertheless, it is recognized that such allocation often gives rise to considerable administrative difficulties.
5.6 Contracting States may be concerned about revenue losses or the possibility of double non-taxation if the tax treatment of pensions can be changed by transferring funds between government and private schemes. This can be addressed through allocation; however, in order for such allocation to apply to pension rights transferred from a government scheme to a private scheme, Contracting States may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, consider extending the scope of paragraph 2 a to include that part of any pension or other similar remuneration which is paid in respect of services rendered to the Contracting State, or its political subdivision or local authority. Such a provision could be worded as follows:
2. a) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, that part of any pension or other similar remuneration which is paid in respect of services rendered to a Contracting State, or its political subdivision or local authority, shall be taxable only in that Contracting State.
Alternatively, Contracting States may resolve this problem by applying a single tax treatment to all pensions.
6. Paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply where the services are rendered in connection with a business carried on by the State, one of its political subdivisions or local authorities paying the salaries, wages, pensions or other similar remuneration. In such cases, the ordinary rules apply: Article 15 in respect of salaries and wages, Article 16 in respect of directors' fees and other similar payments, Article 17 in respect of entertainers and sportspersons, and Article 18 in respect of pensions. Contracting States that, for specific reasons, wish to dispense with paragraph 3 in their bilateral conventions may do so by including in paragraphs 1 and 2 services rendered in connection with a business. In view of the specific functions performed by certain government bodies, such as a State railway authority, postal service, State theatres, etc., Contracting States wishing to retain paragraph 3 may agree during bilateral negotiations to include in the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 remuneration paid by such bodies, even if it could be argued that they are carrying on a business.
3. All pensions paid in respect of services rendered to a Contracting State, its political subdivision or local authority fall within the scope of Article 19, even if they are paid under the social security system of one of the States. In most cases, the treatment will be the same regardless of whether Article 18 or 19 applies to such payments. However, in the cases provided for in subparagraph b of paragraph 2 of Article 19 — where the recipient is both a resident and a national of the other Contracting State — the treatment will differ. Under Article 19, government service pensions received by such individuals are taxable only in the country of residence. If they fall under Article 18, they are taxable only in the source country. The purpose of this paragraph is to indicate that a government service pension paid by one country, even under its social security system, to a resident of another country who is also a national of that other country is taxable only in the latter country. Some countries prefer to extend the scope of Article 18 to cover government pensions as well, so that both private and government pensions are subject to the same tax treatment. Where this solution is adopted, paragraph 2 of Article 19 is unnecessary and should be deleted.
4. It was proposed that comments be provided on the tax treatment of a government that pays the expenses of entertainers who are residents of one Contracting State and perform in another Contracting State. However, it was considered that Contracting States may discuss this issue during bilateral negotiations if they so wish. In this connection, reference is made to the Commentaries on Article 17.
Article 20
STUDENTS
1. In its present version, Article 20 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 20 of the OECD Model Convention. In 1999, paragraph 2, which contained provisions concerning grants and scholarships, as well as remuneration for employment not covered by paragraph 1, was deleted.
2. Since Article 20 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 20 of the OECD Model Convention, the following Commentary on the latter Article remains applicable:
1. The rule laid down in this Article concerns certain payments received by students or trainees for the purpose of covering their maintenance, education or training. All such payments received from sources outside the State in which the student or trainee concerned is present are exempt from tax in that State.
2. The word "immediately" was inserted into the 1977 Model Convention to make it clear that the Article does not apply to a person who was a resident of one Contracting State but then became permanently resident in a third State before arriving in the other Contracting State.
3. The Article applies only to payments received for the purposes of the recipient's maintenance, education or training. Accordingly, it does not apply to a payment, or any part thereof, which constitutes remuneration for services rendered by the recipient and to which Article 15 (or [14, or] Article 7 in the case of services rendered by an independent contractor) applies. However, where the recipient's education includes the acquisition of work experience, it is necessary to distinguish between remuneration for services and payments for the recipient's maintenance, education or training. The fact that the amount paid is similar to the amount paid to persons providing similar services who are not students or trainees generally indicates that such payment constitutes remuneration for services. Furthermore, payments for maintenance, education or training should not exceed the level of expenses that are likely to be incurred for the recipient's maintenance, education or training.
4. […] For the purposes of this Article, payments made by or on behalf of a resident of a Contracting State, or borne by a permanent establishment which a person has in that State, are not considered to be made from sources outside that State.
3. The 1980 version of Article 20 of the United Nations Model Convention contained paragraph 2, which read as follows:
(2) In respect of grants, scholarships and remuneration from employment not covered by paragraph 1, the student or trainee referred to in paragraph 1 shall, in addition, be entitled during such education or training to the same exemptions, reliefs or reductions in respect of taxes as are granted to residents of the State visited.
The question of whether paragraph 2 of Article 20 should be deleted from the United Nations Model Convention was discussed for some time by the former Group of Experts. In this connection, it seems appropriate to reproduce paragraphs 25–29 of the report of the former Group of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters on the work of its seventh session, held in December 1995 (ST/ESA/250):
25. At its meeting held in July 1995, the Steering Committee recommended that the Group consider deleting from the Model Convention paragraph 2 of Article 20, which provides that if a visiting student has income not exempt from taxation in the country of arrival under paragraph 1, the student should be entitled, when such non-exempt income is taxed, to the same exemptions, reliefs and reductions as those granted to residents of that country.
26. One participant insisted that this provision be retained because it allows visiting students to be taxed in the same manner as resident students. Another participant objected that such parity is sometimes incomplete, since a resident student is taxed on all income, whereas a visiting student is taxed only on income from sources in the country of residence.
27. A supporter of deleting the provision noted that paragraph 4 (second sentence) of Article 24 states that a country is not required to grant non-residents any personal allowances or other reliefs "by reason of civil status or family responsibilities" that are available to residents; he stated that paragraph 2 of Article 20 is inconsistent with the provisions of Article 24.
28. One participant noted that, as an alternative to subparagraph c of paragraph 1 of Article 14, a treaty could provide for an exemption in the country of residence for the normal period of study in respect of remuneration not exceeding a specified amount per year, but only to the extent that such remuneration is not also exempt in the other State. [Subparagraph c of paragraph 1 of Article 14 was deleted in 1999.]
29. After discussion, it was found that a majority of the members of the Group, though not unanimously, favoured deleting paragraph 2 of Article 20.
4. This issue was reconsidered at the ninth meeting of the former Group of Experts in May 1999, and the Group agreed to delete paragraph 2 of Article 20. Article 20 now corresponds to Article 20 of the OECD Model Convention, with the addition of the word "student".
5. Although in the version set out above paragraph 2 covers grants and scholarships paid from a source in the country of residence, as well as income from employment in the country of residence, the Commentaries on the 1980 Model Convention explain that this paragraph primarily concerns income from employment. This wording was intended to provide visiting students, etc., with exactly the same treatment as students who are residents for tax purposes in the State where they are studying, but no more favourable treatment than that granted to resident students.
6. Practical experience in applying paragraph 2 has shown that, in its present form, it may give rise to complex administrative problems. For example, if a visiting student is liable to tax in the State of residence only in respect of income from sources in that country, and not on all income received in other countries as well, should the visiting student be granted the full allowances available to a resident when the latter is taxed on all income from other countries? Similarly, should a married student whose spouse has not accompanied him or her to that country be entitled to the allowance granted to married persons? These questions cannot be resolved solely on the basis of the wording of paragraph 2 in its present form.
7. A particular issue arising from the inclusion of paragraph 2 concerns the status of a visiting student or trainee as a tax resident under the ordinary rules relating to permanent residence provided for in Article 4. A student pursuing a full-time course of study may become a tax resident of the State of residence; in such a case, the student is liable to tax there in respect of all income and is entitled to all personal allowances without the need to apply any special provision of Article 20.
8. Furthermore, as shown in the Commentary on the 1980 version, there are a number of additional ways in which countries wishing to extend the scope of Article 20 to address specific problems that may arise in particular bilateral situations may proceed during negotiations. Examples are given without proposing any specific wording designed to achieve this objective. The 1980 Commentaries state:
[…] some countries may wish, in the course of bilateral negotiations, to extend the Article by adding a paragraph granting an additional exemption (in addition to the personal exemption or similar relief normally applicable under the domestic law of the Contracting State) in respect of employment income subject to certain conditions. For example, some countries may wish to extend the exemption to remuneration received for services performed in the country where the student or trainee is present, but limit the exemption to a specified amount of remuneration. In determining this amount, countries may take into account the fact that students or trainees may incur additional expenses because they are away from their country of residence. Where the application of the exemption is extended, it would be advisable to introduce a time limit for such exemption in the case of trainees, and possibly to establish a longer period for students, which is permissible in the latter situation.
9. In view of the practical difficulties in applying paragraph 2 and the existence of a number of other issues concerning students and trainees that need to be resolved through bilateral negotiations, the former Group of Experts considered that, rather than attempting to develop comprehensive wording, it would be preferable to delete paragraph 2 from the Convention. Countries wishing to extend the application of Article 20 to sources of income in the country of residence should draft, as far as possible, a brief provision that is consistent with their specific circumstances.
Article concerning teachers
10. During the discussions at the seventh meeting of the former Group of Experts, several participants advocated the inclusion in the Model Convention of an Article concerning visiting teachers. At present, under the Model Convention, visiting teachers fall under Article 14 if their teaching work is performed in an independent capacity; Article 15 if their work is performed under an employment relationship; or Article 19 if the remuneration is paid by a Contracting State. Many treaties contain an additional Article or paragraph specifically concerning teachers and, in some cases, researchers, who are generally exempt from tax in the source country if the duration of their stay does not exceed a specified period. It was noted that Articles 14 and 15 do not generally exempt the remuneration of visiting teachers from taxation at source, since they usually permit taxation at source of persons providing services if the duration of their stay in the host country exceeds 183 days, and many teachers are appointed for longer periods.
11. There were substantial disagreements among the participants regarding the need to include in the United Nations Model Convention a separate Article dealing exclusively with visiting teachers. However, all participants generally agreed that an Article on teachers, if included in the Model Convention, should not exempt teachers from tax both in their country of residence and in their country of stay. One participant proposed a compromise solution to this issue: instead of amending the Model Convention by including a provision on visiting teachers, an addition could be made to the Commentaries, noting that many treaties contain such Articles and recommending that the issue be resolved through bilateral negotiations. Broad consensus was generally reached on this proposal.
12. Accordingly, the former Group of Experts appointed a drafting committee to prepare an addition to the Commentaries on the Convention. Following discussion and amendment, the Group included the following addition in 1999:
The Model Convention contains no special provision concerning remuneration received by visiting professors and other teachers. In the absence of a special provision, Articles 14, 15, 19 or 23 of the Model Convention apply, depending on the circumstances. However, many bilateral conventions contain provisions concerning such persons, the main purpose of which is generally to promote cultural relations and the exchange of knowledge by granting a limited tax exemption to visiting teachers in the country of residence. Sometimes tax exemption is already granted under domestic tax legislation, which many consider to be the most preferable way of resolving problems relating to the double taxation of visiting teachers.
Notwithstanding the application of Articles 14, 15, 19 and 23 for the purpose of eliminating double taxation, some countries may wish to include a special Article on teachers. The diversity of domestic tax legislation in different countries, on the one hand, or the absence of such legislation, on the other, makes it difficult to include a special provision concerning teachers in the Model Convention. However, if, during bilateral negotiations, the Contracting States prefer to include a provision concerning visiting teachers, the following aspects should be taken into account when drafting such a provision:
(a) the purpose of a tax treaty is generally to eliminate double taxation, and double exemption of teachers is undesirable;
(b) it is recommended that the benefits be limited to a maximum period of stay (usually two years), and that the maximum period may be extended in individual cases by mutual agreement between the competent authorities of the Contracting States. It should be determined whether remuneration from an assignment exceeding the maximum period will be taxed from the beginning of the stay or only from the date following the expiry of the maximum period;
(c) whether the benefits should be limited only to teaching services provided at certain institutions "recognized" by the Contracting States in which the work is performed;
(d) whether, in the case of visiting professors and other teachers who also conduct scientific research, the benefits should be limited to remuneration for scientific work carried out in the interests of the State (as opposed to private interests);
(e) whether an individual may be entitled to the benefits under the Article more than once.
Article 21
OTHER INCOME
1. Article 21 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 21 of the OECD Model Convention, except that paragraph 2 of Article 21 of the United Nations Model Convention also covers the case where the income is attributable to a fixed base which the recipient of the income has in the other Contracting State in accordance with Article 14. Article 21 of the United Nations Model Convention also contains an additional paragraph 3, which includes a general provision concerning items of income of a resident of one of the Contracting States that are not dealt with in the preceding Articles and arise in the other Contracting State.
2. The Article applies to types of income that are not expressly dealt with in the preceding Articles (for example, alimony or income from participation in a lottery), as well as income from sources that are not expressly mentioned therein (for example, rent paid by a resident of one Contracting State for the use of immovable property situated in a third State). The Article covers income arising in third States as well as income arising in one of the Contracting States.
Paragraph 1
3. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 1 of Article 21 of the OECD Model Convention. Accordingly, the Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary should apply:
2. Under this paragraph, the exclusive right to tax is granted to the State of residence. Where there are two places of residence, Article 4 also determines the right to tax in respect of income derived in a third State.
3. […] Where income arises in a third State and the recipient of that income is considered to be a resident of both Contracting States under their domestic laws, by virtue of Article 4 the recipient is considered to be a resident of only one Contracting State and is subject to full taxation ("full tax liability") only in that State. In such a case, the other Contracting State may not tax income derived in the third State, even if the recipient is not taxed by the State of which the recipient is considered to be a resident under Article 4. In order to avoid non-taxation, the Contracting States may agree to limit the scope of this Article to income that is taxable in the Contracting State of which the recipient is a resident, and may amend the provisions of this paragraph accordingly […].
Reference is also made to paragraph 5 of the Commentary set out below.
Paragraph 2
4. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 2 of Article 21 of the OECD Model Convention, with the difference that paragraph 2 of Article 21 of the United Nations Model Convention also covers the case where the income is attributable to a fixed base which the recipient of the income has in the other Contracting State in accordance with Article 14: the Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary is applicable (additional comments enclosed in square brackets, which are not part of the OECD Commentary, have been inserted to reflect the difference described above):
4. This paragraph provides an exception to the provisions of paragraph 1 where the income is connected with the activities of a permanent establishment [or fixed base] which a resident of one of the Contracting States has in the other Contracting State. This paragraph includes income from third States. In such a case, the right to tax is granted to the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated. Paragraph 2 does not apply to immovable property in respect of which, under paragraph 4 of Article 6, the preferential right to tax is granted to the State in which the property is situated […]. Therefore, immovable property situated in one of the Contracting States and forming part of the property of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of that State situated in the other Contracting State is taxable only in the first-mentioned State, where the property is situated and of which the recipient of the income is a resident. This is consistent with the rules laid down in Articles 13 and 22 concerning immovable property, since paragraph 2 of those Articles applies only to movable property of a permanent establishment.
5. This paragraph also applies to cases where both the beneficial owner and the payer of the income are residents of the same Contracting State, and the income is attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] which the beneficial owner of the income has in the other Contracting State. In such a case, the right to tax is granted to the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated. If double taxation arises, the State of residence must provide relief in accordance with the provisions of Article 23A or Article 23B. However, a problem may arise in connection with the taxation of dividends or interest in the State of residence in its capacity as the State of source: Articles 7 and 23A do not permit that State to tax such income, whereas, had it been paid to a resident of another State, the first-mentioned State, as the State of source of the dividends or interest, could have taxed such dividends or interest at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11. Contracting States that consider such a situation unacceptable may include in their conventions a provision under which the State of residence will be entitled, in its capacity as the State of source of dividends or interest, to tax such income at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11. The State in which the permanent establishment is situated would grant a credit for such tax under the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B; naturally, this credit should not be granted in cases where the State in which the permanent establishment is situated does not tax dividends or interest attributable to the permanent establishment under its domestic law.
6. Some States that apply the exemption method (Article 23A) may have reason to fear that the treatment granted under paragraph 2 may encourage an enterprise of one of the Contracting States to allocate assets, such as shares, bonds or patents, to a permanent establishment situated in the other Contracting State in order to obtain more favourable tax treatment. To avoid such situations, which some States regard as abusive, they may consider such an arrangement artificial and, for that reason, treat the assets as not effectively connected with the permanent establishment. Some other States may strengthen their position by supplementing paragraph 2 with a condition providing that this paragraph does not apply to cases where transactions are carried out primarily for the purpose of taking advantage of that provision. Furthermore, the requirement that the right or property must be "effectively connected" with such a place requires more than merely recording the right or property in the books of the permanent establishment for accounting purposes.
Paragraph 3
5. This paragraph is an addition to Article 21 of the OECD Model Convention. It is intended to allow the State in which the income arises to tax such income, if this is provided for under its legislation, whereas the provisions of paragraph 1 permit taxation in the State of residence. The simultaneous application of the provisions of these two paragraphs may result in double taxation. In such a situation, the provisions of Article 23A or Article 23B, as appropriate, apply, as in other cases of double taxation. In some cases, paragraphs 2 and 3 may overlap, and they then produce the same result.
6. At the ninth meeting of the former Group of Experts, held in 1999, an extensive discussion took place concerning the inclusion of a new paragraph dealing with financial instruments. Three options were proposed. First, the Contracting States could adopt Article 21 of the United Nations Model Convention with three paragraphs. Second, the Contracting States could adopt paragraph 3 of Article 21, but include in it a reduced tax rate in respect of the income referred to in paragraph 3. Third, the Contracting States could adopt the United Nations Model Convention with only paragraphs 1 and 2. These three options were considered appropriate in this matter. It was noted that the tax treatment of financial products was relevant to options 2 and 3, as discussed in paragraph 7 below.
Optional additional paragraph
7. The Committee considers that the following Commentary on Article 21 of the OECD Model Convention remains applicable:
7. Some countries encounter problems in taxing income arising from certain non-traditional financial instruments where the parties concerned are in special relationships with each other. These countries may wish to add the following paragraph to Article 21:
[4]. Where, by reason of a special relationship between the person referred to in paragraph 1 and some other person, or between them and some third person, the amount of income referred to in paragraph 1 exceeds the amount (if any) which would have been agreed upon between them in the absence of such a relationship, the provisions of this Article shall apply only to the last-mentioned amount. In such a case, the excess part of the income shall remain taxable in accordance with the laws of each Contracting State, due regard being had to the other applicable provisions of this Convention.
The inclusion of this additional paragraph should not affect the tax treatment of innovative financial transactions between independent parties or the tax treatment provided for in other provisions of the Convention.
8. This paragraph limits the operation of the provisions concerning the taxation of income not dealt with in other Articles in the same way as paragraph 6 of Article 11 limits the operation of the provisions concerning the taxation of interest […].
9. Although the limitation may apply to any income that would otherwise fall within the scope of Article 21, in practice it is not intended to apply to such payments as alimony or social security payments; rather, it concerns cases where certain non-traditional financial instruments are structured under such circumstances and on such terms as would not have been adopted in the absence of the special relationship […].
10. The limitation in Article 21 differs from the limitation in Article 11 in two important respects. First, this paragraph allows all payments in respect of non-traditional financial instruments to be treated as excessive where necessary. Second, income that is excluded from the scope of the Article on interest may nevertheless fall within the scope of another Article of the Convention […]. Income that would otherwise be covered by Article 21 is, by definition, not governed by any other Article. Therefore, if the limitation under Article 21 excludes part of the income from the scope of that Article, Articles 6–20 of the Convention do not apply to such income at all, and each Contracting State may tax it in accordance with its domestic law.
11. However, the other provisions of the Convention continue to apply to such income, in particular Article 23 (Elimination of Double Taxation), Article 25 (Mutual Agreement Procedure) and Article 26 (Exchange of Information).
8. Some members of the former Group of Experts noted that artificial arrangements are entered into by persons with the aim of taking advantage of the provisions of Article 21 — particularly where paragraph 3 is absent or provides only for a reduced tax rate in the State of source — in particular through the creation or assignment of rights in respect of which income arises, for example, from financial instruments. Although the principle of "substance over form", the principle of "abuse of rights" or any similar principle may be used to counter such arrangements, Contracting States wishing to regulate this issue specifically may include the following provision in their bilateral tax treaties:
The provisions of this Article shall not apply if the main purpose or one of the main purposes of any person concerned with the creation or assignment of the rights in respect of which the income is paid is to take advantage of this Article by means of such creation or assignment of rights.
9. Countries generally do not include in Article 21 a paragraph specifying where income is deemed to arise for the purposes of paragraph 3. The source of income will be determined under the domestic laws of both Contracting States. Nevertheless, the domestic laws of the Contracting States may differ, and this may result in double taxation (or non-taxation where the State of residence of the beneficial owner applies Article 23A to eliminate double taxation). Countries wishing to eliminate this problem may include a provision in their bilateral tax treaties in the following wording:
Income shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State. However, where the person paying the income, whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment or fixed base in connection with which the obligation to pay the income was incurred, and such income is borne by that permanent establishment or fixed base, such income shall be deemed to arise in the State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated.
Commentary on Chapter IV TAXATION OF CAPITAL
Article 22
CAPITAL
1. In the United Nations Model Convention, Article 22 deals with taxes on capital, excluding taxes on estates, inheritances and gifts, as well as taxes on transfers of property.
2. The former Group of Experts considered whether paragraphs 1 and 4 should remain in square brackets. By general agreement, it was decided that brackets were not required for the first three paragraphs, but should be retained for paragraph 4. Strong arguments were put forward in favour of granting the right to tax to the State in which the property is situated, which would correspond to the tax treatment provided for in the United Nations Model Convention in respect of other income referred to in Article 21. In 1999, it was decided to retain paragraph 4 in square brackets.
3. If the negotiating parties decide to include an Article on the taxation of capital, they will have to determine which wording to use — that of paragraph 4 in square brackets or the wording that leaves the right to tax with the State in which the capital is situated. Where the wording of paragraph 4 in square brackets is used, the Committee considers that the Commentary on Article 22 set out below remains applicable.
1. This Article governs only the taxation of capital, excluding taxes on estates, inheritances and gifts, as well as taxes on transfers of property. The taxes on capital to which this Article applies are specified in Article 2.
2. Taxes on capital are generally an additional tax on income from capital. Consequently, taxes on a particular element of capital may, in principle, be levied only by the State that has the right to tax income from that element of capital. However, it is not possible to rely exclusively on the rules relating to the taxation of such income, since not all Articles concerning income provide for taxation exclusively in one State.
3. Therefore, this Article first lists the property that may be taxed in the State in which it is situated. This category includes the immovable property referred to in Article 6, owned by a resident of one Contracting State and situated in the other Contracting State (paragraph 1), as well as movable property forming part of the property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State, [or attributable to a fixed base which a resident of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State for the purpose of performing services of an independent nature] (paragraph 2).
4. As a general rule, ships and aircraft operated in international traffic, and movable property pertaining to the operation of such ships or aircraft, are taxable only in the State of residence (paragraph 3). This rule corresponds to the provisions of Article 8 and paragraph 3 of Article 13. Contracting States that would prefer to grant the exclusive right to tax to the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is situated may replace paragraph 3 in their bilateral conventions with a provision corresponding to that proposed in paragraph 2 of the Commentary on Article 8. Immovable property pertaining to the operation of ships or aircraft may be taxed in the State in which it is situated, in accordance with the rule set out in paragraph 1.
4.1 Paragraph 3 applies where the enterprise owning the property itself operates the ships, inland waterways vessels or aircraft referred to in that paragraph, whether for the purposes of its own transport operations or by leasing ships, inland waterways vessels or aircraft chartered with full equipment, crew and supplies. This does not, however, apply where the enterprise owning the ships, inland waterways vessels or aircraft does not act as their operator (for example, where the enterprise leases the property to another person, except in cases of occasional bareboat chartering […]). In such a case, the capital is covered by the provisions of paragraphs 2 or 4.
5. As regards elements of capital not falling within those listed in paragraphs 1–3, this Article provides that they are taxable only in the Contracting State of which the person owning them is a resident (paragraph 4).
6. If, in applying the provisions of paragraph 4 to elements of movable property used under usufruct rights, double taxation persists because of inconsistencies between domestic laws, the States concerned may resort to the mutual agreement procedure or resolve the matter through bilateral negotiations.
7. This Article does not contain any rule concerning the deduction of debts. The legislation of OECD member countries differs too widely to permit a common solution to be reached regarding such deductions. The problem of the deduction of debts, which may arise where the taxpayer and the creditor are not residents of the same State, is dealt with in paragraph 4 of Article 24.
Commentary on Chapter V
METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
Article 23
METHODS FOR THE ELIMINATION OF DOUBLE TAXATION
A. GENERAL PROVISIONS
1. The United Nations Model Convention reproduces two alternative versions of Article 23 for the purpose of avoiding double taxation, namely Article 23A on the exemption method and Article 23B on the tax credit method.
2. The method by which a country allows double taxation to be avoided depends primarily on its general tax policy and the structure of its tax system. Due to the differences existing between various tax systems, bilateral tax treaties provide the most flexible instrument for reconciling different tax systems and preventing or mitigating double taxation.
3. During the previous revision of the United Nations Model Convention, members of the Group from developing countries considered that, as measures to avoid double taxation applied by developed countries, depending on the circumstances, either the exemption method or the tax credit method could be used. The exemption method is considered most appropriate where the exclusive right to tax certain income is granted to the source country under the treaty; this method may take the form of exemption with progression. One of the main disadvantages of the foreign income tax credit method, in the view of developing countries, is that the benefit of low taxes in developing countries or special tax incentives granted by such countries may accrue to the treasuries of capital-exporting countries rather than to the foreign investor for whom those incentives are intended. Thus, income from a developing country is transferred to the capital-exporting country.
4. Accordingly, the effectiveness of tax incentive measures introduced in most developing countries depends on the relationship between the tax systems of developing countries and those of capital-exporting countries, which are the sources of investment. For developing countries, it is particularly important to ensure that tax incentive measures do not lose their effectiveness as a result of taxation in capital-exporting countries that use a foreign income tax credit system. To some extent, this undesirable result can be avoided in bilateral treaties through the application of a “tax sparing” credit, whereby the developed country grants a credit not only for tax actually paid, but also for tax that has been saved as a result of the incentive legislation of the developing country. The exemption method also makes it possible to prevent this negative effect. Members of the Group from developing countries considered it necessary to emphasize their understanding that, for such countries, the primary and fundamental objective in the process of negotiating tax treaties is to include either the exemption method or a tax sparing provision. On the other hand, some members of the Group noted that, according to the results of studies, the tax factor alone may not play a decisive role in investment decisions and therefore, in their view, tax sparing may not constitute an appropriate policy.
5. Many members of the Group from both developed and developing countries agreed with the view that tax sparing credits should be included in treaties between developed and developing countries where the developed country applies the credit method. However, some members of the Group expressed the view that, for a variety of reasons, tax sparing credits are not a means of economic development, which would be better promoted through other measures.
6. Although the exemption method for avoiding double taxation eliminates the undesirable effects of taxation in the country of residence on tax incentives provided by the source country, many developed countries are unwilling to include such a system in their treaties. Where the investor's country of residence applies the foreign tax credit principle, the most effective method of preserving the effect of tax incentives and benefits granted by developing countries is the tax sparing credit. Three alternative approaches may be considered to address this problem.
7. First, the domestic legislation of the country granting tax incentives may contain provisions allowing the incentive to be enjoyed only if the taxpayer can demonstrate, to the satisfaction of the tax authorities, that upon remittance of its profits abroad, the legislation of the country to which the profits are remitted will not directly or indirectly tax the income covered by the incentive, or will grant a credit in respect of the tax that was not paid as a result of the incentives.
Such a provision would prevent the benefits of the tax incentive from being transferred, through the taxpayer, from the treasury of the developing country to the treasury of the developed country.
8. Second, a tax convention could contain a provision preventing either Contracting State from taxing profits from activities in the other State of an enterprise that is a resident of that other State and benefits from tax incentives granted by that State, until such profits are repatriated or otherwise transferred, directly or indirectly, to the first-mentioned Contracting State. Thus, in order to remain untaxed, such profits would have to be reinvested in the developing country. It would be necessary to develop certain accounting rules to give effect to this provision, and the repatriation scheme or schedule could be agreed upon by the Contracting States themselves.
9. Third, the first Contracting State could have the right to tax such profits, subject to a condition established in a revenue-sharing agreement, under which the Contracting State in which the income was generated would receive that amount of tax revenue which could reasonably be attributed to the granting of the tax incentive by the source country. This proposal is attractive because it preserves the value of the tax incentive, which results in a loss to the treasury of the developing country, and is also relatively simple to implement in practice. The existing rules of many developed countries concerning the determination of the source and character of foreign income received by their taxpayers may provide a substantial part of the information necessary to determine the tax revenue attributable to the use of the tax incentive.
10. On the other hand, some members of the Group objected that, theoretically, it could be argued that the effectiveness of tax incentive measures adopted by many developing countries partly depends on the relationship between the tax systems of developing countries and those of capital-exporting countries that apply a foreign income tax credit system. This is due to the expectation that tax incentives introduced by a developing country should be “reinforced” by a “tax sparing” credit granted by the developed country. A “tax sparing” credit means a credit granted not only in respect of tax actually paid, but also in respect of tax that was not actually paid as a result of legislation providing for incentive measures.
11. Since the initial publication of the United Nations Model Convention in 1980, various studies have been conducted concerning the economic rationale for tax incentives aimed at encouraging investment. According to some members of the Group, these studies have shown that tax factors alone may not play a decisive role in an enterprise's investment decisions and therefore, in their view, tax sparing cannot be considered an appropriate policy. Other factors play a more important role in shaping the so-called “investment climate” in any country, in particular political and economic stability, the reputation of the judicial system for impartiality, the availability of a skilled workforce, as well as labour legislation and social insurance costs that do not create unforeseen obstacles to the development of an enterprise. It has been argued that tax incentives undermine the tax base and may lead to destructive consequences when neighbouring States engage in competition over tax incentives, attempting to neutralize each other's incentives and beginning to engage in tax manipulation. Moreover, where “reinforcing” credit provisions have been included in tax treaties, there have been cases of artificial transactions designed to benefit from such provisions, resulting in the erosion of the tax base and unforeseen economic distortions in investment decision-making.
12. Despite all this, countries retain the right to adopt such measures to attract investment as they consider useful or unavoidable in view of the pressure arising from the existence of preferential tax regimes, particularly in tax-free zones, in other jurisdictions; although it may be observed that in recent years there has been a trend towards narrowing incentive measures compared with earlier periods. For example, they may be limited to specific areas of economic activity or certain geographical regions, and they are becoming relatively strictly time-limited rather than indefinite. Where developing countries choose to use such tax incentives, some experts from developing countries consider that one of the objectives of negotiations should continue to be the inclusion of a “reinforcing” provision or a “tax sparing” provision in treaties with capital-exporting countries that apply a foreign income tax credit system. A review of tax treaties recently concluded between developed and developing countries shows that they continue to contain tax sparing provisions, although such provisions are becoming more limited in duration than they were previously. Sometimes these provisions contain a “break” or “sunset” clause, providing that the provision will cease to apply, for example, after five years, unless the parties agree to extend it. In the view of some experts from developing countries, when such clauses are included, the capital-importing country should provide, in its domestic legislation and international treaties, some protection against a future decision by its treaty partner not to extend the tax sparing provision. This may be done, in particular, through a so-called “absorbing” tax, that is, a tax or levy intended to reduce the advantage granted through domestic tax incentive legislation by the amount that would otherwise have been transferred to the treasury of the treaty partner in the absence of a tax sparing provision. However, some countries do not grant a foreign tax credit in respect of an “absorbing” tax.
13. The inflow of international investment may also be hindered if the system for eliminating double taxation in a country, although formally complying with Article 23, does not result in the elimination of double taxation in practice. For example, the mechanical features of the system may render foreign tax credits unusable. This is not only inconsistent with the spirit of Article 23, but may also discourage foreign investment.
13.1 The amendment to the wording of paragraph 2 of Article 23A, referring to the part of the tax attributable to items of income “which may be taxed in that other State”, rather than to income “derived from that other State”, is intended to bring the wording of paragraph 2 of Article 23A into line with the wording of paragraph 1 of Article 23B. The change in wording is not intended to alter the meaning of paragraph 2 of Article 23A. Under either wording, the credit for tax levied by the other State is limited to the tax attributable to items of income which the other State is entitled to tax under the provisions of the Convention.
14. The following extracts from the Commentary on Articles 23 and 23B of the OECD Model Convention are applicable to Articles 23 and 23B (additional comments appearing in square brackets, which are not part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention, have been inserted to reflect the differences between the provisions of the OECD Model Convention and those of this Model Convention, and to indicate the applicable paragraph/subparagraph of this Model Convention):
I. PRELIMINARY REMARKS
A. SCOPE OF THE ARTICLES
1. These Articles deal with so-called juridical double taxation, where the same income or capital is taxed in respect of the same person by more than one State.
2. Such cases must be clearly distinguished from so-called economic double taxation, where two different persons are taxed in respect of the same income or capital. If two States wish to resolve problems of economic double taxation, they must do so through bilateral negotiations.
3. International juridical double taxation may arise in three cases:
a) where each Contracting State levies tax on the same person in respect of that person's entire income or capital from different countries (simultaneous full tax liability, see paragraph 4 below);
b) where a person is a resident of one of the Contracting States (R)46 and derives income or owns capital in the other Contracting State (S or E), and both States tax that income or capital (see paragraph 5 below);
__________________________________________
46 Throughout the Commentary on Articles 23A and 23B, the letter R denotes the State of residence within the meaning of the Convention, the letter S denotes the State of source or situs of property, and the letter E denotes the State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated.
c) where each Contracting State taxes the same person, who is not a resident of either Contracting State, on income derived by that person or capital owned by that person in a Contracting State: this situation may arise, in particular, where a non-resident has a permanent establishment [or fixed base] in one of the Contracting States (E), through which that person derives income or owns capital in the other Contracting State (S) (simultaneous limited tax liability, see paragraph 11 below).
4. By virtue of Article 4, the conflict in case a is reduced to case b. This results from the fact that this Article defines the term “resident of a Contracting State” on the basis of the person's tax liability under domestic law by reason of that person's domicile, residence, place of management or any other criterion of a similar nature (paragraph 1 of Article 4), and lists specific criteria in the case of dual residence in order to determine which of the two States is the State of residence (R) within the meaning of the Convention (paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 4).
4.1 Article 4, however, deals only with cases of simultaneous full tax liability. Consequently, the conflict in case a may not be resolved where the same item of income is subject to full tax liability in two countries, but at different times. This problem may be considered in the following example. Assume that a resident of State R1 derives taxable income from an employee stock option granted to that person. State R1 taxes this income at the time the option is granted. The person subsequently becomes a resident of State R2, which taxes this income at the time the option is subsequently exercised. In this case, the person is taxed in each State at the time when that person is a resident of that State, and Article 4 does not address this issue, since there is no simultaneous residence status in the two States.
4.2 The conflict in this situation will be reduced to case b and will be resolved accordingly to the extent that the employment services relating to the option were performed in one of the Contracting States, so as to fall within the scope of taxation by that State under Article 15, since that is the State in which the relevant employment was exercised. Indeed, in such a case, the State in which the services were performed is the State of source for the purposes of eliminating double taxation in the other State. It is irrelevant that the first State does not levy tax at the same time (see paragraph 32.8). It is also irrelevant that this State considers that it taxes in its capacity as the State of residence rather than as the State of source (see the last sentence of paragraph 8).
4.3 If, however, the relevant employment services were not performed in either of these States, the conflict will not constitute a source-residence double taxation conflict. The mutual agreement procedure may be used to resolve such a case. One possible solution would be for the competent authorities of the two States to agree that each State should grant relief from tax in the State of residence in respect of tax levied by the other State on the portion of income related to services performed during the period when the employee was a resident of that other State. Thus, in the example above, if the relevant services were performed in a third State before the person concerned became a resident of State R2, it would be logical for the competent authority of State R2 to agree to grant relief (through either the exemption method or the tax credit method) in respect of the tax imposed by State R1 on the portion of employment income related to services performed in the third State, since at the time those services were performed, the taxpayer was a resident of State R1, and not of State R2, for the purposes of the Convention between those two States.
5. The conflict in case b may be resolved by allocating taxing rights between the Contracting States. Such allocation may be achieved by the State of source or situs of property (S), or the State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated (E), or the State of residence (R), relinquishing its taxing rights, or by dividing the taxing rights between the two States. Such allocation is governed by the provisions of Chapter III and Chapter IV of the Convention in conjunction with the provisions of Article 23A or Article 23B.
6. In respect of certain items of income or capital, the exclusive right to tax is granted to one of the Contracting States, and the relevant Articles provide that the particular item of income or capital “shall be taxable only” in one or the other Contracting State47. The words “shall be taxable only” in one of the Contracting States deprive the other Contracting State of the right to tax, thereby preventing double taxation. The State to which the exclusive right to tax is granted is usually the State in which the taxpayer is a resident within the meaning of Article 4, that is, State R, but under four Articles48 the exclusive right may be granted to the other Contracting State (S), in which the taxpayer is not a resident within the meaning of Article 4.
__________________________________________
47 See the first sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 7, paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 8, paragraphs 3 and [6] of Article 13, [the first sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 14], the first sentence of paragraph 1 and paragraph 2 of Article 15, Article 18 [except paragraphs 1 and 2 of alternative B], paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 19, paragraph 1 of Article 21 and paragraphs 3 and 4 of Article 22.
7. In respect of other items of income or capital, the allocation of taxing rights is not exclusive, and the relevant Article then provides that the particular item of income or capital “may be taxed” in the Contracting State (S or E), in
8. Articles 23A and 23B apply where a resident of State R derives income or owns capital in another Contracting State E or S (which is not the State of residence within the meaning of the Convention) and such income or capital may, under the Convention, be taxed in that other State E or S. Therefore, these Articles apply only to the State of residence and do not prescribe how the Contracting State E or S should proceed.
9. If a resident of a Contracting State R derives income in that same State R through a permanent establishment [or fixed base] which that person has in another Contracting State E, State E may tax such income (other than income from immovable property situated in State R) if it is attributable to that permanent establishment [or fixed base] (paragraph 2 of Article 21). Furthermore, in this case, State R must grant relief under Article 23A or Article 23B in respect of the income attributable to the permanent establishment [or fixed base] situated in State E, notwithstanding that such income originally arises in State R […]. However, if the Contracting States agree to grant State R, which applies the exemption method, a limited right to tax as the State of source of dividends or interest, subject to the limitations provided for in paragraphs 2 of Articles 10 or 11 or 12, then both States must also agree on a credit for the tax that State E will grant in respect of the tax levied in State R under paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B.
9.1 [The following is a slightly modified version of what is currently contained in paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 21] However, where State R applies the exemption method, a problem may arise in relation to the taxation of dividends and interest in the State of residence as the State of source: the combination of Articles 7 and 23A does not allow that State to levy tax on such income, whereas, if it were paid to a resident of another State, State R, acting as the State of source of the dividends or interest, could tax such dividends or interest at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11. Contracting States that consider this position unacceptable may include in their conventions a provision under which the State of residence will have the right, as the State of source of dividends or interest, to levy tax on such income at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11, notwithstanding that it applies the exemption method. The State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated will grant a credit for such tax in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B; of course, such a credit will not be granted where the State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] is situated does not tax dividends or interest attributable to the permanent establishment [or fixed base] under its domestic law.
10. If a resident of State R derives income in a third State through a permanent establishment [or fixed base] which that person has in State E, State E may tax that income (other than income from immovable property situated in the third State) if it is attributable to that permanent establishment [or fixed base] (paragraph 2 of Article 21). State R must grant relief under Article 23A or Article 23B in respect of the income attributable to the permanent establishment [or fixed base] in State E. The Convention contains no provision regarding relief granted by Contracting State E in respect of taxes levied in the third State where the income arises; however, under paragraph 3 of Article 24, any relief provided under the domestic law of State E (other than relief under double taxation conventions) to residents of State E must also be granted to the permanent establishment of an enterprise of State R situated in State E […].
11. The conflict in case c of paragraph 3 above falls outside the scope of the Convention, since under Article 1 it applies only to persons who are residents of one or both States. However, this conflict may be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure (see also paragraph 10 above).
11.1 In some cases, the same income or capital may be taxed in each Contracting State as income or capital of one of its residents. This may occur, for example, where one of the Contracting States taxes the worldwide income of an entity that is a resident of that State, while the other State treats that entity as fiscally transparent and taxes the members of that entity, who are residents of that other State, on their respective shares of income. The phrase “(except where these provisions allow taxation in that other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State)” clarifies that, in such cases, the two States are not required to provide reciprocal relief from tax levied solely on the basis of the taxpayer's residence, and therefore each State is required to provide relief from double taxation only to the extent that taxation by the other State is in accordance with the provisions of the Convention that permit the relevant income to be taxed as income of the State of source or of the State in which the permanent establishment [or fixed base] to which the income is attributable is situated, thereby excluding taxation that would result solely from the person's residence in that other State. Although this result would logically follow from the wording of Articles 23A and 23B even in the absence of this phrase, the addition of this phrase removes any doubts in this respect.
11.2 The principles set out in the preceding paragraph are illustrated by the following examples:
— Example A: An entity established in State R is a resident of State R and is therefore taxed on its worldwide income in that State. State S treats this entity as fiscally transparent and taxes the members of the entity on their respective shares of the income derived through the entity. All members of the entity are residents of State S. All of the entity's income consists of business profits attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] situated in State R. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the legal entity, State R will not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason State S may tax that income under the provisions of the Convention is the residence of the members of the entity. State S, on the other hand, will be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of all of the entity's income, since that income may be taxed in State R under the provisions of Article 7, irrespective of the fact that State R considers the income to have been derived by an entity resident in State R. In determining the amount of income tax paid in State R for the purposes of granting relief from double taxation to the members of the entity under Article 23B, State S must take into account the tax paid by the entity in State R.
— Example B: The same facts as in Example A, except that 30 per cent of the income derived through the entity consists of interest arising in State S and attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] in State R, while the remainder of the income consists of business profits attributable to the same permanent establishment [or fixed base]. In this case, relief from double taxation in respect of business profits other than interest will be granted as described in Example A. In the case of interest, however, State R will have to grant the entity a credit under paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B for the amount of tax on interest paid in State S by all members of the entity, not exceeding the lower of the following two amounts: 10 per cent of the gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax that may be paid in State S under paragraph 2 of Article 11) or the tax payable in State R on such interest (the last part of paragraph 2 of Article 23A and paragraph 1 of Article 23B). State S, on the other hand, will also have to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B to the members of the entity who are residents of State S, since this income may be taxed in State R under the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 7. If State S applies the exemption method provided for in Article 23A, this means that State S will have to exempt from taxation the share of interest attributable to members who are residents of State S (see paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 21 and paragraph 9 of the Commentary on Articles 23A and 23B). If State S applies the credit method under Article 23B, the credit must apply only to that part of the tax payable in State S which exceeds the amount of tax that State S would have been entitled to levy under paragraph 2 of Article 11, and such credit must be granted in respect of the amount of tax paid in State R after deducting the credit that State R itself must grant in respect of the tax payable in State S under paragraph 2 of Article 11.
— Example C: The same facts as in Example A, except that all of the entity's income is derived from immovable property situated in State S. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R will have to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of all of the entity's income, since that income may be taxed in State S under the provisions of Article 6, irrespective of the fact that State S considers the income to have been derived by members who are residents of State S. State S, on the other hand, is not required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B, since the only reason State R may tax the income under the provisions of the Convention is the residence of the entity (the result would be the same even if the income were attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] situated in State R: see the first sentence of paragraph 9 of the Commentary on Articles 23A and 23B).
— Example D: The same facts as in Example A, except that all of the entity's income consists of interest arising in State S which is not attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base]. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R will have to grant the entity a credit under paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B for the amount of tax on interest paid in State S by all members of the entity, not exceeding the lower of the following two amounts: 10 per cent of the gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax that may be paid in State S under paragraph 2 of Article 11) or the tax payable in State R on such interest (the last part of paragraph 2 of Article 23A and paragraph 1 of Article 23B). State S, on the other hand, will not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of the income of the legal entity, since this income does not arise in State R and is not connected with a permanent establishment [or fixed base] in State R, and the only reason State R may tax this income is that the income is also income derived by a resident of State R. Paragraph 1 of Article 11 confirms the right of State R to tax interest as income derived by a legal entity resident in State R.
— Example E: The same facts as in Example D, except that all of the entity's income consists of interest arising in State R. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R will not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason State S may tax this income under the provisions of the Convention is the residence of the members of the entity. State S, on the other hand, will have to grant the members of the entity a credit under paragraph 2 of Article 23A or paragraph 1 of Article 23B for the amount of tax on interest paid by the entity in State R, not exceeding the lower of the following two amounts: 10 per cent of the gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax that may be paid in State R under paragraph 2 of Article 11) or the tax payable in State S on such interest (the last part of paragraph 2 of Article 23A and paragraph 1 of Article 23B). However, State S will not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of tax paid in State R in excess of the maximum amount of tax that may be [levied] under paragraph 2 of Article 11, since the interest is not attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] in State R and the only reason State R may levy such additional tax is that the income is also income derived by a resident of State R. […] [Paragraph 1 of Article 21 confirms the right of State R to tax interest as income derived by an entity resident in State R.]
— Example F: The same facts as in Example D, except that all of the entity's income consists of interest arising in a third State. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R will not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason State S may tax this income under the provisions of the Convention is the residence of the members of the entity. State S will also not be required to grant relief under Article 23A or 23B in respect of the entity's income, since this income does not arise in State R and is not attributable to a permanent establishment [or fixed base] in State R, and the only reason State R may tax this income is that the income is also income derived by a resident of State R. Paragraph 1 of Article 21 confirms the right of State R to tax interest as income derived by an entity resident in State R. Paragraph 1 of Article 21 also confirms the right of State S to tax interest as income derived by members of the entity who are residents of State S.
B. DESCRIPTION OF METHODS FOR ELIMINATING DOUBLE TAXATION
12. Existing conventions provide for two main principles for eliminating double taxation by the State of which the taxpayer is a resident. For the sake of simplicity, only income tax is referred to below; however, these principles apply equally to taxes on capital.
1. The exemption principle
13. Under the exemption principle, the State of residence R does not tax income which, under the Convention, may be taxed in State E or S (as well as, of course, income which is taxable only in State E or S […]).
14. The exemption principle may be applied by two main methods:
a) income which may be taxed in State E or S is not taken into account at all by State R for taxation purposes; State R is not entitled to take the income thus exempted into account when determining the tax on the remaining income; this method is called “full exemption”;
b) income which may be taxed in State E or S is not taxed by State R, but State R retains the right to take that income into account when determining the tax on the remaining income; this method is called “exemption with progression”.
2. The tax credit principle
15. Under the tax credit principle, the State of residence R calculates its tax on the basis of the taxpayer's total income, including income derived in another State E or S which, under the Convention, may be taxed in that other State (but excluding income which is taxable only in State S, see paragraph 6 above). It then deducts from its own tax an amount corresponding to the tax paid in that other State.
16. The tax credit principle may be applied by two main methods:
a) State R allows the total amount of tax paid in the other State on income which may be taxed in that State to be deducted; this method is called the “full tax credit”;
b) the deduction granted by State R in respect of tax paid in the other State is limited to the part of its own tax attributable to the income which may be taxed in that other State; this method is called the “ordinary tax credit”.
17. In essence, the difference between these methods is that under the exemption method the income is considered, whereas under the tax credit method the tax is considered.
C. APPLICATION AND EFFECTS OF THE METHODS
18. A numerical example will help explain the effects of the various methods. Assume that the total amount of income is 100,000, of which 80,000 is derived from one State (the State of residence R), and 20,000 from another State (the State of source S). Assume that in State R the tax rate on income of 100,000 is 35 per cent, and on income of 80,000 it is 30 per cent. Assume further that the tax rate in State S is either 20 per cent — case (i), or 40 per cent — case (ii), so that the tax payable there on 20,000 is 4,000 in case (i) and 8,000 in case (ii).
19. If the taxpayer's total income of 100,000 arises in State R, the tax on it will amount to 35,000. If the taxpayer were to derive the same income, but in the manner described above, and if no relief were granted under the domestic law of State R and no convention existed between State R and State S, the total tax would amount to, in case (i): 35,000 + 4,000 = 39,000, and in case (ii): 35,000 + 8,000 = 43,000.
1. Exemption methods
20. Under the exemption methods, State R limits its taxation to that part of the total income which it is entitled to tax under the various Articles of the Convention, that is, 80,000.
a) Full exemption
State R taxes 80,000 at the tax rate applicable to 80,000, that is, 30 per cent.
| Case (i) | Case (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R, 30% of 80,000 | 24,000 | 24,000 |
| Plus tax in State S | 4,000 | 8,000 |
| Total taxes | 28,000 | 32,000 |
| Relief granted by State R in the amount of | 11,000 | 11,000 |
b) Exemption with progression
State R taxes 80,000 at the tax rate applicable to the total amount of income, wherever it arises (100,000), that is, 35 per cent.
| Case (i) | Case (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R, 35% of 80,000 | 28,000 | 28,000 |
| Plus tax in State S | 4,000 | 8,000 |
| Total taxes | 32,000 | 36,000 |
| Relief granted by State R in the amount of | 7,000 | 7,000 |
21. In both cases, the level of tax in State S does not affect the amount of tax foregone by State R. If the tax on income from State S is lower in State S than the relief granted in State R — cases a (i), a (ii) and b (i) — the taxpayer will be better off compared with the situation in which all of the taxpayer's income had been derived exclusively in State R. In the opposite case — b (ii) — the taxpayer is in a less favourable position.
22. The example also shows that the relief granted where State R applies the full exemption method may exceed the tax levied in State S, even if tax rates in State S are higher than those in State R. This is explained by the fact that under the full exemption method, not only is tax not levied in State R on income derived in State S (35 per cent of 20,000 = 7,000 under the exemption-with-progression method), but the tax on the remaining income (80,000) is also reduced by an amount corresponding to the difference between the rates applicable to the two income levels in State R (35 − 30 = 5 per cent, that is, 5 per cent of 80,000 = 4,000).
2. Tax credit methods
23. Under the tax credit methods, State R retains the right to tax the taxpayer's entire income, but allows a deduction from the tax thus levied.
a) Full tax credit
State R calculates tax on the total income of 100,000 at a rate of 35 per cent and allows a deduction for the tax payable in State S on income derived in State S.
| Case (i) | Case (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R, 35% of 100,000 | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Minus tax in State S | -4,000 | -8,000 |
| Tax payable | 31,000 | 27,000 |
| Total taxes | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Relief granted by State R in the amount of | 4,000 | 8,000 |
b) Ordinary tax credit
State R calculates tax on the total income of 100,000 at a rate of 35 per cent and allows a deduction for the tax payable in State S on income derived in State S, but in any event the amount of the deduction may not exceed that part of the tax in State R attributable to the income derived in State S (maximum credit). The maximum credit will amount to 35 per cent of 20,000 = 7,000.
| Case (i) | Case (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R, 35% of 100,000 | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Minus tax in State S | -4,000 | -8,000 |
| Subject to the maximum credit | — | -7,000 |
| Tax payable | 31,000 | 28,000 |
| Total taxes | 35,000 | 36,000 |
| Relief granted by State R in the amount of | 4,000 | 7,000 |
24. Compared with the exemption methods, the tax credit methods differ in that State R is in no case required to deduct an amount exceeding the amount of tax payable in State S.
25. If the tax payable in State S is lower than the tax in State R attributable to the income derived in State S (maximum credit), the taxpayer will always be liable to pay the same total amount of tax as would have been payable if the taxpayer had been taxed only in State R, that is, as if all of the taxpayer's income had been derived exclusively in State R.
26. The same result is achieved if the tax payable in State S is higher and State R applies the full tax credit method, at least in cases where the total amount of tax payable to State R is equal to or exceeds the amount of tax payable in State S.
27. If the tax payable in State S is higher and the credit is limited (ordinary tax credit), the taxpayer will not receive a deduction for the entire amount of tax paid in State S. In this case, the result will be less favourable to the taxpayer than if all of the taxpayer's income had arisen in State R, and in these circumstances the ordinary tax credit method will have the same effect as the exemption-with-progression method.
Table 23 - 1 Total amount of tax in the various cases shown above
| Total amount of tax | ||
|---|---|---|
| A. All income arising in State R | 35,000 | |
| B. Income arising in two States, namely: 80,000 in State R and 20,000 in State S | Total amount of tax, if tax in State S is: | |
| Without a convention (19)¹ | 39,000 (case (i)) | 43,000 (case (ii)) |
| Full exemption (20a) | 28,000 | 32,000 |
| Exemption with progression (20b) | 32,000 | 36,000 |
| Full tax credit (23a) | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Ordinary tax credit (23b) | 35,000 | 36,000 |
¹ The figures in parentheses refer to the paragraphs of this Commentary.
Table 23 - 1 (continued)
| | If tax in State S amounts to | || - | ------------------------------------- | || | 4,000 (case (i)) | 8,000 (case (ii)) || Without a convention | 0 | 0 || Full exemption (20a)¹ | 11,000 | 11,000 || Exemption with progression (20b) | 7,000 | 7,000 || Full tax credit (23a) | 4,000 | 8,000 || Ordinary tax credit (23b) | 4,000 | 7,000 |
¹ The figures in parentheses refer to the paragraphs of this Commentary.
Table 23 - 2 Amount of tax relinquished by the State of residence
D. METHODS PROPOSED IN THE ARTICLES
28. Both leading principles are used in conventions concluded between OECD member countries. Some States prefer the first, while others prefer the second. In theory, a single principle might be considered more desirable, but in view of the preferences mentioned above, each State has been allowed to make its own choice.
29. On the other hand, it was considered important to limit the number of methods based on each leading principle that may be applied. In view of this limitation, the Articles have been drafted so that countries may choose one of two methods:
- the exemption-with-progression method (Article 23A); and
- the ordinary tax credit method (Article 23B).
30. If the two Contracting States adopt the same method, it will be sufficient to include the relevant Article in the Convention. On the other hand, if the two Contracting States use different methods, both Articles may be combined into one, with the name of each State inserted in the relevant part of the Article according to the method adopted by that State.
31. Contracting States may use a combination of the two methods. In fact, such a combination is necessary for a Contracting State R that generally follows the exemption method in the case of income which, under Articles 10 and 11 [as well as Articles 12 and 12A], may be subject to limited taxation in the other Contracting State S. In such a case, paragraph 2 of Article 23A provides for a credit in respect of the limited tax levied in the other Contracting State S […]. Furthermore, States that generally follow the exemption method may wish to exclude specific items of income from the scope of the exemption and apply the tax credit method to such items of income. In such a case, paragraph 2 of Article 23A may be amended to include those items of income.
32. Both Articles are drafted in general terms and do not provide detailed rules on how the exemption or credit is to be calculated, since these matters are governed by domestic law and established practice. Contracting States that consider it necessary to regulate any matters in the Convention may do so during bilateral negotiations.
E. DIFFERENCES IN QUALIFICATION CRITERIA
32.1
Both Article 23 A and Article 23 B require relief to be granted by means of the exemption method or the credit method, as the case may be, where an item of income or capital may be taxed in the State of source in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. Thus, the State of residence is obliged to apply the exemption or credit method in respect of an item of income or capital if the Convention permits that item to be taxed by the State of source.
32.2
The interpretation of the phrase “may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention”, which is used in both Articles, is particularly important when considering cases where the State of residence and the State of source classify the same item of income or capital differently for the purposes of the provisions of the Convention.
32.3
In this connection, various situations need to be considered. If, owing to differences in domestic law between the State of source and the State of residence, the former applies to a particular item of income or capital provisions of the Convention different from those that the State of residence would apply to the same item of income or capital, the income is nevertheless taxed in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, as interpreted and applied by the State of source. Thus, in this case, both Articles require the State of residence to grant relief from double taxation, notwithstanding differences in qualification criteria arising from differences in domestic law.
32.4
This point can be illustrated by the following example. A partnership established in State E carries on business through a permanent establishment in State E. A partner resident in State R alienates his interest in that partnership. State E treats the partnership as fiscally transparent, whereas State R treats it as a taxable entity. Therefore, State E considers that the alienation of the interest in the partnership constitutes, for the purposes of its Convention with State R, an alienation by the partner of the underlying assets of the business carried on by the partnership, which may be taxed in that State under paragraph 1 or 2 of Article 13. State R, since it treats the partnership as a taxable entity, considers that the alienation of the interest in the partnership is similar to the alienation of an interest in a company, which may not be taxed in State E by virtue of paragraph 5 of Article 13. In such a case, the differences in qualification criteria arise solely from the different treatment of the partnership under the domestic laws of the two States, and State E should be regarded by State R as taxing the income from the alienation “in accordance with the provisions of the Convention” for the purposes of applying Article 23 A or Article 23 B. Thus, State R should grant an exemption under Article 23 A or a tax credit under Article 23 B, irrespective of the fact that, under its domestic law, it treats the income from the alienation as income from the alienation of shares in a legal entity and that, if the qualification of the income by State E were consistent with the qualification criteria of State R, State R would not be required to grant an exemption under Article 23 A or Article 23 B. Therefore, in such a case, double taxation does not arise.
32.5
Articles 23 A and 23 B, however, do not require the State of residence to eliminate double taxation in all cases where the State of source levies tax by applying to an item of income a provision of the Convention different from that which the State of residence considers applicable. For example, in the above example, if, for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 13, State E considers that the partnership carried on business through a fixed place of business, whereas State R considers that paragraph 5 applies because the partnership did not have a fixed place of business in State E, a dispute in fact arises as to whether State E taxed the income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. The same may be said if State E, in applying paragraph 2 of Article 13, interprets the phrase “forming part of the property of the enterprise” in such a way that it includes certain assets that do not fall within the meaning of that phrase according to the interpretation given by State R. Such conflicts, arising from different interpretations of the facts or different interpretations of the provisions of the Convention, should be distinguished from the differences in qualification criteria described in the preceding paragraph, where the difference is based not on a different interpretation of the provisions of the Convention, but on different provisions of domestic law. In the former case, State R may argue that State E has not imposed its tax in accordance with the provisions of the Convention if it has applied its tax on the basis of what State R considers to be an incorrect interpretation of the facts or an incorrect interpretation of the Convention. States should use the provisions of Article 25 (Mutual Agreement Procedure), in particular paragraph 3 thereof, to resolve such conflicts in cases which would otherwise result in unrelieved double taxation.
32.6
The expression “may be taxed in accordance with the provisions of this Convention” should also be interpreted in connection with possible cases of exemption from double taxation that may arise under Article 23 A. If the State of source considers that the provisions of the Convention do not permit it to tax an item of income or capital which it would otherwise have been entitled to tax, the State of residence should, for the purposes of applying paragraph 1 of Article 23 A, consider that the item of income cannot be taxed by the State of source in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, even if the State of residence would apply the Convention differently so as to be entitled to tax that income if it were in the position of the State of source. Thus, under paragraph 1, the State of residence is not required to exempt the item of income from taxation, which is consistent with the main function of Article 23, namely, the elimination of double taxation.
Paragraph 32.6 applies only to the extent that the State of source “applies the provisions of this Convention” to exempt an item of income or capital from taxation. Thus, it is clear that paragraph 32.6 does not apply to cases where, in the absence of any conflicts of qualification criteria, the Convention grants the State of source the right to tax, but that State does not exercise that right under its domestic law. For example, where a developing country grants special tax incentives designed to promote economic development in respect of certain items of income. In such cases, the State of residence must still exempt those items of income from tax in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A (see the cited paragraph 34 of the OECD Commentary on Article 23).
32.7
This situation can be illustrated by considering a variation of the example described above. A partnership established in State E carries on business through a fixed place of business in State E, and a partner resident in State R alienates his interest in that partnership. However, changing the facts of the example, it is now assumed that State E treats the partnership as a taxable entity, whereas State R treats it as fiscally transparent; it is further assumed that State R is the State applying the exemption method. State E, since it treats the partnership as a corporate entity, considers that the alienation of the interest in the partnership is similar to the alienation of an interest in a company, which it cannot tax by virtue of paragraph 5 of Article 13. State R, on the other hand, considers that the alienation of the interest in the partnership should have been taxed by State E as an alienation by the partner of the underlying assets of the business carried on by the partnership, to which paragraphs 1 or 2 of Article 13 would have applied. In determining whether it is obliged to exempt the income under paragraph 1 of Article 23 A, State R must nevertheless take into account that, given the way in which the provisions of the Convention are applied in conjunction with the domestic law of State E, that State may not tax the income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. Thus, State R is not required to exempt the income from tax.
F. Timing differences
32.8
The provisions of the Convention which allow the State of source to tax particular items of income or capital do not impose any restrictions as to when such tax must be levied (see, for example, paragraph 2.2 of the Commentary on Article 15). Since both Articles 23 A and 23 B require relief to be granted where an item of income or capital may be taxed in the State of source in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, it follows that such relief must be granted irrespective of when the tax is levied in the State of source. Thus, the State of residence must grant relief from double taxation by means of the credit or exemption method in respect of such an item of income or capital, even if the State of source taxes it in an earlier or later year. Some States, however, do not follow the wording of Article 23 A or 23 B in their bilateral conventions and link the relief from double taxation which they grant under tax treaties to what is provided for in their domestic law. Nevertheless, these States are expected to seek other means (for example, the mutual agreement procedure) to relieve double taxation that may arise where the State of source levies tax in a different tax year.
II. Commentary on the provisions of Article 23 A (Exemption Method)
Paragraph 1
A. Obligation of the State of Residence to Grant Exemption
33. This Article provides that the State of residence R exempts from tax income and capital which, under the Convention, “may be taxed” in the other State E or S.
34. Accordingly, the State of residence must exempt from tax income and capital which may be taxed in the other State in accordance with the Convention, irrespective of whether the other State has actually exercised its right to tax. This method is considered the most practical, since it relieves the State of residence of the need to investigate the actual position regarding payment of tax in the other State.
35. Sometimes the negotiating States may consider it appropriate, in certain circumstances, for the purpose of avoiding double non-taxation of certain items of income, to make an exception to the unconditional obligation of the State of residence to grant exemption […]. Such a situation may arise where the domestic law of the State of source does not provide for the taxation of certain items of income or capital, or where tax is not actually levied owing to special circumstances, such as the offsetting of losses, an error or the expiry of the limitation period. To prevent double non-taxation of certain items of income, the Contracting States may agree to amend the relevant Article […]. An exception to the general rule may also be provided for in order to ensure a certain degree of reciprocity where one State follows the exemption method and the other follows the tax credit method. Finally, another exception to the general rule may be made if a State wishes to apply the credit method, rather than the exemption method, to particular items of income (see paragraph 31 above).
36. It should also be noted that, as explained in paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 above, Article 23 A does not oblige a Contracting State to exempt income or capital from tax if the only reason why the other Contracting State may tax that income or capital under the provisions of the Convention is that the other State attributes that income or capital to a resident of that other State.
15. Under the United Nations Model Convention, the right to tax in the State of source extends in many cases to income which, under the OECD Model Convention, is taxable only in the State of residence. Consequently, many countries following the exemption method in their bilateral conventions may wish to restrict the application of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A, in particular by limiting the application of the exemption to income on which tax has actually been paid in the State of source, or by applying the tax credit method provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 23 A, rather than the exemption method, to certain items of income. Furthermore, since paragraph 1 of Article 23 A of the United Nations Model Convention has a broader scope than the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention, a State which generally follows the exemption method may choose to apply the tax credit method to particular items of income not mentioned in paragraph 2 of Article 23 A.
16. The Commentary on the OECD Model Convention further states:
B. Alternative Wording of the Article
37. The result of applying the exemption method as formulated in this Article is that the taxable income or capital in the State of residence is reduced by the amount exempted from tax in that State. If, in a particular State, the amount of income determined for the purposes of calculating income tax is used as a measure for other purposes, such as the payment of social benefits, the application of the exemption method in the proposed form may result in such benefits being paid to persons who are not entitled to them. To avoid such consequences, this Article may be amended so that the income in question is included in the taxable income in the State of residence. In such cases, the State of residence must relinquish that part of the total tax which is attributable to the income in question. This procedure will produce the same result as the Article in its proposed wording. States may make such amendments to the draft Article at their discretion. If a State wishes to draft the Article in the form indicated above, paragraph 1 may be worded as follows:
“If a resident of a Contracting State derives income or owns capital which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, is taxable only in the other Contracting State or may be taxed in the other Contracting State, the first-mentioned State shall, subject to the provisions of paragraph 2, allow to be deducted from the income tax or capital tax that part of the income tax or capital tax, as the case may be, which is attributable, as appropriate, to the income derived or the capital owned in such other State.”
If the Article is drafted in this way, paragraph 3 is no longer necessary and may be deleted.
C. Other Issues
38. Article 23 A contains the principle that the State of residence must grant exemption, but does not provide detailed rules as to how such exemption is to be effected. This is consistent with the general structure of the Convention. Articles 6–22 also contain rules relating to the right to tax various types of income or capital, but generally do not define taxable income or capital, deductions, tax rates, etc. (see, however, [paragraph 3 of Article 7 and] Article 24). Experience shows that a number of problems may arise. This is particularly true of Article 23 A. Some of these problems are considered in the following paragraphs. In the absence of a specific provision in the Convention, the domestic law of each of the Contracting States applies. Some conventions contain an express reference to domestic law, but this is, of course, insufficient if the exemption method is not provided for under domestic law. In such cases, Contracting States faced with this problem should establish rules concerning the application of Article 23 A, if necessary after consultations with the competent authority of the other Contracting State (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
1. Amount of the Exemption
39. The amount of income to be exempted from tax in the State of residence is the amount which, in the absence of the Convention, would be subject to domestic income tax under the domestic legislation governing such taxation. It may therefore differ from the amount of income on which tax is levied in the State of source under its domestic law.
40. Normally, the basis for calculating income tax is total net income, that is, gross income less allowable deductions. Therefore, the amount to be exempted is the gross income derived in the State of source less all allowable deductions (fixed or proportional) connected with such income eligible for tax exemption.
41. Problems arise because most countries provide in their tax legislation for additional deductions from total income or from particular items of income for the purpose of determining the taxable amount of income. This problem can be illustrated by the following numerical example:
a) Domestic income (gross less expense deductions) 100
b) Income from another State
(gross less expense deductions) 100
c) Total income 200
d) Deductions in respect of other expenses provided for under the legislation of the State of residence and not related to any income referred to in a or b, in particular insurance premiums and contributions to charitable institutions -20
e) “Net” income 180
f) Personal and family allowances –30
g) Taxable income 150
The question is which amount should be exempted from tax, for example:
— 100 (line b), leaving taxable income of 50;
— 90 (half of line e, in accordance with the ratio between line b and line c), leaving 60 (line f being fully deducted from domestic income);
— 75 (half of line g, in accordance with the ratio between line b and line c), leaving 75;
— or any other amount.
42. A comparison of the legislation and practices of OECD member countries shows that the amount to be exempted varies from country to country. The solution adopted by a State depends on its policy and the structure of its taxes. The intention of a State may be to ensure that its residents fully benefit, in any event, from their personal and family allowances and other benefits. In other States, these tax-free amounts are apportioned. In many States, personal or family allowances form part of the progressive tax scale, are granted as a deduction from tax, or are even absent, while family status is taken into account through a separate tax scale.
43. In view of the wide diversity of tax policies and methods applied in different countries for determining tax, particularly allowances, deductions and similar benefits, it seems appropriate not to propose a single uniform solution in the Convention, but to allow each State to apply its own legislation and methodology. Contracting States which prefer to resolve particular problems in their conventions may, of course, do so in the course of bilateral negotiations. Finally, it is noted that this problem is also of considerable importance for States applying the tax credit method […].
2. Treatment of Losses
44. Some States, when applying Article 23 A, treat losses incurred in another State in the same way as income arising in that State: as the State of residence (State R), they do not allow deductions for losses incurred in respect of immovable property or a permanent establishment situated in another State (E or S). Provided that the other State allows such losses to be carried forward, the taxpayer does not suffer any loss, since he simply cannot claim a double deduction for the same losses both in State E (or S) and in State R. Other States, acting as the State of residence R, may allow losses incurred in State E (or S) to be deducted from the income taxable by them. In such a case, State R is entitled to limit the exemption under paragraph 1 of Article 23 A in respect of profits or income subsequently derived in the other State E (or S), by deducting from such subsequent profits or income the amount of losses previously incurred which the taxpayer may carry forward in State E (or S). Since the solution depends primarily on the domestic law of the Contracting States, and the laws of OECD member countries differ substantially from one another, no solution can be proposed in the Article itself, and the Contracting States may, where necessary, clarify this issue and other issues relating to losses […] bilaterally — either in the Article itself or through the mutual agreement procedure (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
3. Taxation of the Remaining Income
45. In addition to the application of progressive tax rates, which is currently governed by paragraph 3 of Article […], certain problems may arise in connection with specific provisions of tax legislation. For example, some tax laws provide that taxation arises only when a minimum amount of taxable income is reached or exceeded (tax-free threshold). Before the application of the Convention, total income may clearly exceed such a tax-free threshold; but as a result of the exemption under the Convention, which leads to the deduction of tax-exempt income from total taxable income, the remaining amount may fall below that threshold. For the reasons indicated in paragraph 43 above, no uniform solution can be proposed. It should, however, be noted that the problem will not arise if the alternative wording of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A is adopted […].
46. Some States have introduced special systems for taxing corporate income […]. In States applying split-rate corporation tax […], a problem may arise as to whether the exempt income should be deducted from undistributed income (to which the ordinary tax rate applies) or from distributed income (to which the reduced tax rate applies), or whether the exempt income should be allocated partly to distributed and partly to undistributed income. If, under the legislation of a State applying split-rate corporation tax, an additional tax is levied on the parent company in respect of dividends received from a domestic subsidiary but not redistributed (on the grounds that such additional tax compensates for the advantages arising from the reduced tax rate enjoyed by the subsidiary in respect of distributed income), the question arises whether such additional tax may be levied if the subsidiary pays its dividends out of income exempt from tax by virtue of the Convention. Finally, a similar problem may arise in connection with taxes (précompte, advance corporation tax) levied on a company's distributed profits to cover the tax credit granted to shareholders […]. The question is whether such special taxes connected with profit distributions may be levied to the extent that the distribution is made out of tax-exempt profits. These issues may be resolved by the Contracting States in the course of bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 2
47. Under Articles 10 and 11 [as well as Articles 12 and 12A], the right to tax dividends and interest is shared between the State of residence and the State of source. In these cases, the State of residence may, if it so wishes, refrain from levying tax […] and apply the exemption method to the above-mentioned items of income. However, if the State of residence prefers to exercise its right to tax such items of income, it cannot apply the exemption method to eliminate double taxation, since this would mean that it completely relinquishes its right to tax the relevant type of income. For the State of residence, the application of the tax credit method generally appears to be an appropriate solution. Moreover, as already noted in paragraph 31 above, States which generally follow the exemption method may wish to apply the credit method, rather than the exemption method, to particular items of income. Accordingly, this paragraph is drafted in accordance with the ordinary credit method. The Commentary below on Article 23 B applies to paragraph 2 of Article 23 A mutatis mutandis.
48. In the cases referred to in the preceding paragraph, certain maximum percentage limits are established in respect of the tax retained by the State of source. In such cases, the tax rate in the State of residence will very often be higher than the rate in the State of source. Therefore, the limitation of the credit provided for in the second sentence of paragraph 2 under the ordinary credit method will arise only in a limited number of cases. If, in such cases, the Contracting States prefer to waive the limitation and apply the full credit method, they may do so by deleting the second sentence of paragraph 2.
Dividends Received by a Company from a Substantial Shareholding
49. The combined effect of the application of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 10 and Article 23 (Articles 23 A and 23 B, as the case may be) is that the State of residence of the shareholder may tax dividends arising in another State, but it must credit against its own tax on such dividends the tax paid to the State in which the dividends arose, at the rate provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 10. This treatment applies equally where the recipient of the dividends is a parent company receiving dividends from a subsidiary; in such a case, the tax withheld in the State of the subsidiary and credited in the State of the parent company is limited to [___] per cent of the gross amount of the dividends as a result of the application of subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10.
50. These provisions effectively eliminate juridical double taxation of dividends, but do not prevent the repeated taxation of the profits of a company distributed to its parent company — first at the level of the subsidiary and then at the level of the parent company. Such repeated taxation creates a serious obstacle to the development of international investment. Many States have recognised this and have included provisions in their domestic legislation designed to overcome this obstacle. Moreover, such provisions are often included in double taxation conventions.
51. The Committee on Fiscal Affairs considered whether Article 23 of the Convention should be amended to address this problem. Although many States support the inclusion of such a provision in the Model Convention, this intention has encountered a number of difficulties arising from differences in the positions of States and the variety of possible solutions. Some States, concerned about tax avoidance, have preferred to retain the freedom of choice and to deal with this issue solely in their domestic legislation.
52. Ultimately, it seems preferable to leave States free to choose their own approach to resolving this problem. States which prefer to deal with this issue in their conventions generally adopt one of the following approaches:
a) Exemption with progression
The State of which the parent company is a resident exempts from tax dividends received by it from a subsidiary in another State, but may nevertheless take those dividends into account when calculating the tax due from the parent company on the remainder of its income (this provision is often preferred by States applying the exemption method referred to in Article 23 A).
b) Underlying tax credit
In respect of dividends received from a subsidiary, the State of which the parent company is a resident grants the credit provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B, as the case may be, not only in respect of the tax on the dividends as such, but also in respect of the tax paid by the subsidiary on the distributed profits (this provision is often preferred by States applying the income tax credit method referred to in Article 23 B as a general rule).
c) Assimilation to ownership of shares in a domestic subsidiary
Dividends received by a parent company from a foreign subsidiary are subject to the same tax treatment in the State of the parent company as dividends received from a subsidiary which is a resident of that State.
53. If the State of the parent company levies capital taxes, a similar solution should also apply to such taxes.
54. Furthermore, States may themselves establish restrictions and methods for applying these provisions (definition of share ownership and minimum holding period, proportion of dividends considered to compensate for administrative or financial expenses) or make the tax relief granted under a special regime conditional upon the subsidiary carrying on genuine economic activity in the State of which it is a resident, deriving the main part of its income in that State, or being subject to substantial taxation on its profits there.
Paragraph 3
55. The 1963 Draft Convention expressly provides for the application of progressive tax rates by the State of residence (the last sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A), and most conventions concluded between OECD member countries which follow the exemption method adhere to this principle. Under paragraph 3 of Article 23 A, the State of residence retains the right to take into account the amount of income or capital exempted from tax when determining the tax levied on the remaining income or capital. This rule applies even where the tax-exempt income (or items of capital) and the taxable income (or items of capital) accrue to persons (for example, husband and wife) whose income (or items of capital) is jointly taxed under domestic law. This principle of progression applies to income or capital exempted from tax under paragraph 1 of Article 23 A, as well as to income or capital which, under any other provision of the Convention, is “taxable only” in the other Contracting State […]. It is for this reason that, in the 1977 Model Convention, the principle of progression was transferred from paragraph 1 of Article 23 A to a new paragraph 3 of the same Article, which refers to exemption from tax “under any provision of the Convention”.
56. Paragraph 3 of Article 23 A concerns only the State of residence. The wording of the Article does not prevent the State of source from applying the provisions of its domestic law concerning progression.
Paragraph 4
16.1 The Committee considers that the following Commentary on paragraph 4 of Article 23 A of the OECD Model Convention is applicable to paragraph 4 (additional comments, shown in italics in square brackets and not forming part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention, have been inserted to reflect the fact that paragraph 4 also applies where the State of source applies the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 12 to an item of income):
56.1 The purpose of this paragraph is to avoid double non-taxation resulting from disagreements between the State of residence and the State of source concerning the facts of a case or the interpretation of the provisions of the Convention. This paragraph applies where, on the one hand, the State of source interprets the facts of the case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way that an item of income or capital falls within a provision of the Convention which excludes its right to tax that item of income or capital or limits the tax it may levy, while, on the other hand, the State of residence adopts a different interpretation of the facts or the provisions of the Convention and therefore considers that the item of income or capital may be taxed in the State of source in accordance with the Convention, which, in the absence of this paragraph, would result in an obligation on the part of the State of residence to grant an exemption under the provisions of paragraph 1.
56.2 The paragraph applies only to the extent that the State of source has applied the provisions of the Convention to exempt an item of income or capital from tax or has applied the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10, […] 11 [, 12 or 12A] to an item of income. Thus, the paragraph will not apply if the State of source considers that it may tax an item of income or capital under the provisions of the Convention, but tax is not actually levied on such income or capital under the provisions of the domestic law of the State of source. In such a case, the State of residence must exempt that item of income from tax under the provisions of paragraph 1, since the exemption in the State of source is not the result of the application of the provisions of the Convention, but rather of the domestic law of the State of source (see paragraph 34 above). Similarly, if the State of source and the State of residence disagree not only as to the qualification of the income but also as to the amount of such income, paragraph 4 applies only to that part of the income which the State of source exempts from tax through the application of the Convention or to which that State applies paragraph 2 of Article 10, […] 11 [, 12 or 12A].
56.3 Cases in which this paragraph applies should be distinguished from cases where the qualification of an item of income under the domestic law of the State of source interacts with the provisions of the Convention so as to prevent that State from taxing an item of income or capital in circumstances where the qualification of the item of income under the domestic law of the State of residence would not have the same result. In such a case, which is discussed in paragraphs 32.6 and 32.7 above, paragraph 1 does not impose on the State of residence an obligation to grant an exemption, since the item of income cannot be taxed in the State of source in accordance with the Convention. Since paragraph 1 does not apply, the provisions of paragraph 4 are not required in such a case to ensure the right of the State of residence to tax.
16.2 Paragraph 4 applies where the State of source interprets the facts of the case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way that an item of income or capital falls within a provision of the Convention which does not allow the State of source to tax that item, whereas the State of residence adopts a different interpretation according to which the item falls within a provision of the Convention which allows the State of source to tax that item. For example, on the one hand, the State of source considers that services provided by an enterprise of the State of residence through employees are not provided in connection with a single or connected project within its territory for a period exceeding 183 days during any twelve-month period and therefore considers that, under Articles 5 and 7, it cannot tax the income attributable to those services. On the other hand, the State of residence of the enterprise considers that those services are provided in connection with a single or connected project for a period exceeding 183 days in the State of source. The State of residence therefore considers that the income attributable to those services is taxable in the State of source under Articles 5 and 7. In the absence of paragraph 4, the State of residence would, in accordance with its interpretation of the Convention, be required to exempt the income attributable to those services from tax under paragraph 1. In such a case, to the extent that the difference of opinion is not resolved through the mutual agreement procedure (which the taxpayer is unlikely to initiate, since he benefits from this difference of opinion, resulting in non-taxation), paragraph 4 allows the State of residence not to apply paragraph 1, thereby avoiding double non-taxation.
16.3 Paragraph 4 applies only to the extent that the State of source “applies the provisions of this Convention” to exempt income or capital from tax or to limit its right to tax under paragraphs 2 of Articles 10, 11 or 12. It is therefore clear that paragraph 4 will not apply in cases where the Convention grants an unrestricted right to tax to the State of source, but that State does not exercise that right under its domestic law. For example, both Contracting States consider that services are provided in connection with a single or connected project for a period exceeding 183 days in the State of source, and the income attributable to those services is taxable in the State of source under Articles 5 and 7. However, under the domestic law of the State of source, non-residents are taxed only on profits attributable to a permanent establishment situated in that State and, consequently, no tax is levied on the income. In such a case, it cannot be said that the State of source has applied the provisions of the Convention to exempt the income from taxation, since those provisions clearly provide that the income may be taxed by that State. Therefore, paragraph 4 does not apply, and the State of residence must exempt the income from taxation under paragraph 1.
16.4 Paragraph 4 also applies where the State of source interprets the facts of a particular case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way that an item of income falls within the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10, 11 or 12, which provide for limited taxation in the State of source, whereas the State of residence adopts a different interpretation and considers that the item falls within a provision of the Convention which allows the State of source to tax the item without any restrictions. For example, on the one hand, the State of source considers that royalties paid by one of its residents and beneficially owned by a resident of the other Contracting State are taxable at the limited rate provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 12. On the other hand, the State of residence of the beneficial owner considers that the right in respect of which the royalties are paid is effectively connected with a permanent establishment situated in the State of source through which the beneficial owner carries on business. The State of residence therefore considers that the royalties are taxable in the State of source without any restrictions under paragraph 4 of Article 12 and are exempt from taxation under the provisions of paragraph 1. In such a case, to the extent that the disagreement is not resolved through the mutual agreement procedure, paragraph 4 allows the State of residence not to apply paragraph 1.
16.5 Where the State of source applies the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10, 11 or 12, the State of residence must, for the purpose of eliminating double taxation, grant a credit under paragraph 2 of Article 23 A. This must be the case even if the State of residence has interpreted the facts of the particular case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way as to result in the State of source having an unrestricted right to tax the income under the Convention, which would mean that the State of residence would normally be required to exempt that income from tax under the provisions of paragraph 1. The application of the tax credit method in this case is more effective than attempting to determine, through the mutual agreement procedure, how the Convention requires double taxation to be eliminated. The last part of paragraph 4, which is absent from the OECD Convention, has been added for clarity, in order to make this point explicit. Under paragraph 2, some States may require credits to be granted for taxes payable in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of their domestic legislation concerning the granting of foreign tax credits, but without prejudice to the general principle provided for in that paragraph. Such wording generally allows the application of the credit arising under paragraph 4. However, if the reference to domestic law is not limited in this way, the Contracting States should ensure during negotiations that there is no inconsistency between domestic law and the treaty provisions which could prevent the granting of a credit (for example, the domestic law of the State of residence may not provide for a credit for foreign taxes if an item of income is taxed under its domestic law as business profits attributable to a permanent establishment rather than as royalties).
16.6 In cases where the State of source applies the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10, 11 or 12 to income, some States may prefer not to deny the application of the provisions of paragraph 1, notwithstanding the fact that the State of source must limit its tax on such income. These States may limit the scope of paragraph 4 to cases where the State of source applies the provisions of the Convention to exempt income or capital from tax and exclude the part relating to Articles 10, 11 and 12.
16.7 The cited paragraph 56.3 of the OECD Commentary explains that paragraph 1 does not impose on the State of residence an obligation to grant an exemption in cases of differences in qualification requirements and that paragraph 4 is therefore not required to avoid double non-taxation in these cases. However, the State of residence may have an obligation to grant an exemption under paragraph 1 in cases of differences in qualification requirements if that State does not agree with the interpretation set out in cited paragraphs 32.6 and 32.7 of the OECD Commentary on Article 23 concerning the phrase “in accordance with the provisions of this Convention”, or if the wording of paragraph 1 in the relevant bilateral convention differs from that used in the Model Tax Convention and does not permit such an interpretation. In such situations, paragraph 4 also ensures that the State of residence is not required to exempt the relevant income from taxation. Paragraph 19 of the Commentary on Article 23 of the United Nations Model Convention has been deleted.
I would correct the paragraph numberingI would remove duplicated commentary passages
III. Commentary on the Paragraphs
Article 23B (Credit Method)
Paragraph 1
A. Methods
57. Article 23B, which is based on the credit principle, provides for the ordinary credit method: the State of residence (R) allows a deduction from its own tax on the income or capital of its resident in an amount equivalent to the tax paid in the other State E (or S) on the income derived or capital owned in that other State E (or S), but the deduction is limited to the corresponding proportion of its own tax.
58. The ordinary tax credit method is also intended to be applied by a State which follows the exemption method but is required to grant a credit pursuant to paragraph 2 of Article 23A in respect of tax levied at limited rates in the other State on dividends and interest (see paragraph 47 above). The possibility of some modification, as indicated in paragraphs 47 and 48 above (full tax credit), may undoubtedly be considered in the case of dividends and interest paid to a resident of a State which follows the ordinary tax credit method (see paragraph 63 below).
The 2017 OECD Commentary states as follows:
59. The obligation imposed by Article 23B on State R with respect to the credit for tax levied in the other State E (or S) on items of income or capital depends on whether, under the Convention, such items may be taxed in the other State E (or S) […]. Items of income or capital which, under Article 8, paragraph 3 of Article 13, subparagraph a of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 19, and paragraph 3 of Article 22, “shall be taxable only” in the other State are, by definition, exempt from tax in State R […], and the Commentary on Article 23A applies to such exempt income or capital. As regards progression, reference is made to paragraph 2 of this Article […].
The OECD Commentary further states:
60. Article 23B sets out the basic rules of the tax credit method, but does not specify the rules governing the calculation and operation of the credit. This is consistent with the general structure of the Convention. Experience shows that many problems may arise in this regard. Some of them are considered in the following paragraphs. Many States already have detailed provisions in their domestic legislation concerning credits for foreign income tax. Therefore, a number of conventions contain references to the domestic legislation of the Contracting States and, in addition, provide that such domestic provisions shall not affect the principle embodied in Article 23B. If the tax credit method is not applied under the domestic legislation of one of the Contracting States, that State shall establish rules for the application of Article 23B, where necessary, after consultation with the competent authority of the other Contracting State (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
61. The amount of foreign tax which may be credited is the tax actually paid in accordance with the Convention in the other Contracting State. Problems may arise here, for example, where such tax is not calculated on the income for the year in respect of which it is levied, but on the income of the preceding year or on the average income of two or more preceding years. Other problems may arise in connection with differences in methods of determining income or with changes in exchange rates (devaluation or revaluation). However, these problems are unlikely to be resolved by means of a special provision in the Convention.
62. Under the provisions of the second sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 23B, the amount of the credit allowed by the State of residence (R) is limited to that part of the income tax which is attributable to the income derived in State S or E (the so-called maximum credit). This maximum credit may be calculated either by apportioning the total tax on the aggregate amount of income according to the ratio between the income in respect of which the credit is granted and the total amount of income, or by applying the tax rate on the total income to the income in respect of which the credit is granted. In fact, where the tax in State E (or S) is equal to or exceeds the corresponding tax in State R, the credit method will have the same effect as the exemption method with progression. Furthermore, the application of the credit method may give rise to similar problems with regard to the amount of income, tax rate, etc., as those discussed in the Commentary on Article 23A […]. For the same reasons as those mentioned in paragraphs 42 and 43 above, in relation to the credit method it is also desirable not to propose a single uniform solution in the Convention, but to leave each State the right to apply its own legislation and methodology. This also applies to certain additional problems discussed below.
63. The maximum credit is usually calculated on the basis of net income, that is, income in State E (or S) less allowable deductions (fixed or proportional) connected with such income […]. For this reason, the maximum credit may in many cases be lower than the tax actually paid in State E (or S). This is particularly true in cases where, for example, a resident of State R receiving interest in State S has borrowed funds from a third party to finance the loan which generates the interest. Since the interest payable on such borrowed funds may be deducted from the interest received in State S, the amount of net income subject to tax in State R may be very small or there may be no net income at all. This problem may be resolved by applying the full tax credit method in State R, as stated in paragraph 48 above. Another solution could be to exempt such income from tax in State S, as proposed in the Commentary with respect to interest on credit sales and loans granted by banks […].
64. If a resident of State R receives different types of income in State S and the latter State, under its tax legislation, levies tax on only one of those items of income, the maximum credit granted by State R will generally constitute the portion of its tax attributable only to that item of income taxable in State S. However, other solutions are possible, particularly in view of the following broader problem: since a credit must be granted, for example, in respect of several items of income on which tax is levied in State S at different rates, or in respect of income from several States, whether or not they have conventions, the question arises as to whether the maximum credit or credit itself should be calculated separately for each item of income, for each State, or for all foreign income qualifying for the credit under domestic legislation or conventions. Under the “overall credit” system, all foreign income is aggregated into one amount, and the total amount of foreign taxes is credited against the domestic tax payable on all foreign income.
65. Additional problems may arise with respect to losses. A resident of State R receiving income in State E (or S) may incur losses in State R, in State E (or S), or in a third State. For credit purposes, losses incurred in a particular State are generally deducted from other income in that same State. Whether losses incurred outside State R (for example, through a permanent establishment) may be deducted from other income received in State R or in another State depends on the domestic legislation of State R. Problems similar to those mentioned in the Commentary on Article 23A may arise here (see paragraph 44 above). If the total amount of income is derived abroad and there is no income in State R, but only losses which do not exceed the amount of income derived abroad, the total amount of tax levied in State R will then be attributable to income in State S, and the maximum credit granted by State R will constitute the tax levied in State R. Other solutions are possible.
66. The above-mentioned problems depend to a large extent on domestic legislation and practice, and therefore their resolution should be left to the discretion of each State. In this context, it may be noted that some States adopt a very liberal approach to the application of the tax credit method. Some States also consider the possibility of carrying forward unused tax credits or already permit such a possibility. Of course, the Contracting States are entitled, in the course of bilateral negotiations, to amend this Article in order to regulate any of the above-mentioned problems.
67. In situations of so-called thin capitalization, the Model Convention permits the State of the borrowing company, under certain conditions, to treat the payment of interest as a distribution of dividends in accordance with its domestic legislation; the essential condition is that the person granting the loan actually shares the risks borne by the borrowing company. This has two consequences:
— taxation at source of such interest at the rate applicable to dividends (paragraph 2 of Article 10);
— inclusion of such interest in the taxable profits of the lending company.
68. If the relevant conditions are met, the State of residence of the lender is obliged to grant relief in respect of any juridical or economic double taxation of the interest, as if the payment had been a dividend. In such a case, it will grant a credit for the tax actually withheld on such interest in the State of residence of the borrower at the rate applicable to dividends and, in addition, if the lender is the parent company of the borrowing company, extend to such “interest” any additional relief under its parent/subsidiary company regime. This obligation may arise as a result of:
a) the current wording of Article 23 of the Convention, where it provides tax relief in respect of income defined as dividends in Article 10, or items of income governed by Article 10;
b) the context of the Convention, that is, the combination of Articles 9, 10, 11 and 23 and, where necessary, through the mutual agreement procedure:
— if the interest is treated in the State of residence of the borrowing company as dividends under rules which are consistent with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11, and if the State of residence of the lending company agrees with such treatment of the interest and is willing to make the corresponding adjustment;
— if the State of residence of the lending company applies similar thin capitalization rules and, on a reciprocal basis, will treat the payment as a dividend, that is, if the payment is made by a company incorporated in its territory to a resident of the other Contracting State;
— in all other cases where the State of residence of the lending company recognizes that the State of residence of the borrowing company is correct in treating the interest as dividends.
69. With regard to dividends from a substantial shareholding in a company, reference may be made to paragraphs 49–54 above.
The 2017 OECD Commentary states as follows:
69.1. Problems may arise where the Contracting States treat entities such as partnerships differently. Assume, for example, that the State of source treats a partnership as a company, whereas the State of residence of a partner regards it as fiscally transparent. The State of source may, in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Convention, tax the income of the partnership when such income is realized and, subject to the limitations set out in paragraph 2 of Article 10, may also tax the distribution of profits by the partnership to its non-resident partners. The State of residence, however, may tax only the partner’s share of the partnership’s income when such income is realized by the partnership.
69.2. The first question arising in this case is whether the State of residence is obliged under the Convention to grant a credit for the tax levied in the State of source on the partnership, which the latter State regards as a separate taxable entity. The answer to this question should be affirmative. To the extent that the State of residence looks through the income of the partnership to the income of the partner for the purposes of its taxation, it must adopt a consistent approach and transfer the tax paid by the partnership to the partner’s income for the purposes of eliminating the double taxation arising from the taxation of the partner. In other words, if the corporate status accorded to the partnership by the State of source is disregarded by the State of residence for the purposes of taxing the partner’s share of income, that status must similarly be disregarded for the purposes of crediting the foreign tax.
Some members of the Committee of Experts, however, are of the opinion that a specific provision must be included in the Convention in order to achieve this result.
69.3. The second question arising in this case is to what extent the State of residence must grant a credit for the tax levied by the State of source on a distribution of profits which is not taxed in the State of residence. The answer to this question lies in the latter fact. Since the distribution of profits is not taxed in the State of residence, there is simply no tax in that State against which a credit may be granted for the tax levied by the State of source on the distribution of profits. A clear distinction must be made between the receipt of profits and the distribution of such profits, and the State of residence cannot be expected to grant a credit for tax levied by the State of source on the distribution of profits against its own tax levied on the receipt of profits (see the first sentence of paragraph 64 above).
B. Observations concerning Capital Tax
70. Under the wording of paragraph 1, a credit is granted in respect of income tax only against income tax, or in respect of capital tax only against capital tax. Consequently, a credit in respect of and against capital tax will be granted only if a capital tax exists in both Contracting States.
71. In the course of bilateral negotiations, both Contracting States may agree that a tax referred to as a capital tax is, by its nature, very similar to an income tax and may therefore consider it appropriate to permit its credit against income tax and vice versa. There are cases where, because one State does not levy a capital tax, or because both States levy capital taxes only on domestic assets, no double taxation of capital arises. In such cases, it is undoubtedly understood that the reference to the taxation of capital may be omitted. Furthermore, States may consider it appropriate, irrespective of the nature of the taxes covered by the Convention, to permit the credit of the entire amount of tax in the State of source or in the State where the property is situated against the total amount of tax in the State of residence. However, if the Convention covers both taxes on immovable capital and taxes on capital which are similar in nature to income tax, the States may wish to permit a credit against income tax only for the latter capital taxes. In such cases, the States are entitled to amend the proposed Article in order to achieve the desired result.
C. Tax Sparing
72. Some States grant various types of tax incentives to foreign investors in order to attract foreign investment. Where the State of which the foreign investor is a resident applies the tax credit method, the benefit of the tax incentive granted by the State of source may be reduced to the extent that the State of residence, when taxing the income to which the benefit of the incentive relates, allows a credit only for the tax actually paid in the State of source. Similarly, if the State of residence applies the tax exemption method, but makes its application conditional upon taxation by the State of source at a certain level, the reduction of tax by the State of source may have the effect of denying the investor the application of the tax exemption method in its State of residence.
73. In order to avoid such an effect in the State of residence, some States which have adopted tax incentive programmes may include provisions in their conventions which are generally referred to as “tax sparing” provisions. The purpose of these provisions is to allow non-residents to obtain a foreign tax credit for taxes “spared” under the tax incentive programme of the State of source, or to ensure that such taxes are taken into account for the purposes of applying certain conditions which may be contained in tax exemption systems.
74. Tax sparing provisions represent a departure from the provisions of Articles 23A and 23B. Tax sparing provisions may take various forms, for example:
a) the State of residence allows a deduction for the amount of tax which the State of source could levy under its general legislation, or for an amount limited by the Convention (for example, the limitation of rates provided for dividends and interest in Articles 10 and 11), even if the State of source has waived the right to levy such tax in whole or in part under special provisions intended to stimulate its economic development;
b) in response to a reduction of taxes by the State [of source], the State of residence agrees to grant a credit against its tax for an amount (partly non-existent) calculated at a higher rate;
c) the State of residence exempts from tax income derived as a result of tax incentives in the State of source.
17. The Contracting States may, at their discretion, develop other formulas in the course of bilateral negotiations. The following paragraphs of the OECD Commentary prior to the updating of that Commentary in 2000 remain relevant:
76. If one Contracting State agrees to provide special investment incentives in another State which is a developing country, the above provisions will generally be accompanied by guarantees for investors, that is, the Convention will limit the rate of tax which may be applied in the State of source to dividends, interest and royalties.
77. Furthermore, time limits or temporary restrictions may be provided for with respect to the application of the benefits provided for in options a and, possibly, c above: the extended credit (or exemption) may be granted only in respect of incentives which are temporarily available in developing countries, or only in respect of future investments made or contracts concluded (for example, from the date of entry into force of the Convention), or for a specified period of time.
78. Thus, there are many possible solutions to this problem. In fact, the specific effects of the relevant provisions may also differ as a result of other factors, such as the amount included in taxable income in the State of residence (see options a and b above); this may be the net income received (after deduction of the tax actually paid in the State of source), or the net income without deduction of an amount equal to the tax actually paid in the State of source, or the tax which could have been levied under the Convention (at the rates provided for in Articles 10 and 11), or the tax which the State of residence agrees to credit as a deduction.
18. The following extracts from the Commentary on Articles 23A and 23B of the OECD Model Convention are also applicable:
75. The 1998 report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs entitled “Re-examination of the Tax Sparing Issue”49 analyses the tax policy considerations underlying tax sparing provisions and their development. The report identifies a number of problems which call into question the overall usefulness of granting relief for tax spared. These problems relate, in particular, to the following:
— the possibility of abuse arising from tax sparing;
— the effectiveness of tax sparing as an instrument of foreign aid to promote the economic development of the State of source; and
— general problems concerning the manner in which tax sparing may encourage States to use tax incentives.
49 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(14)-1.
Paragraph 2
79. This paragraph was added in order to allow the State of residence to retain the right to take into account the amount of income or capital exempt from tax in that State when determining the tax levied on the remaining part of the income or capital. The right thus retained extends to income or capital which “shall be taxable only” in the other State. Consequently, the principle of progression is guaranteed for the State of residence not only with respect to income or capital which “may be taxed” in the other State, but also with respect to income or capital which “shall be taxable only” in the other State. The Commentary on paragraph 3 of Article 23A concerning the State of source also applies to paragraph 2 of Article 23B.
19. A State which normally applies the tax exemption method may consider that this method should not be applied in cases where the State of source interprets the facts of a particular case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way that an item of income or capital falls under a provision of the Convention which does not permit that State to tax such income or capital, whereas the State of residence applies a different interpretation under which such income or capital falls under a provision permitting the State of source to levy such tax. This may be irrelevant for some States. However, where this is relevant, in order to avoid unintended double non-taxation resulting from differences in interpretation by the State of residence and the State of source, the following provision may be included in Article 23A:
4. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income derived by a resident of a Contracting State or capital owned by such resident if the other Contracting State applies the provisions of this Convention for the purpose of exempting such income or capital from tax, or applies the provisions of paragraph 2 of Articles 10, 11 or 12 to such income; in the latter case, the first-mentioned State shall allow a deduction for the tax provided for in paragraph 2.
The members of the Committee recognized that, in a bilateral Convention between a “tax credit” country and a “tax exemption” country, the decision to include such a provision essentially rests with the tax exemption country; it may be inappropriate to require the State of source to address double non-taxation arising in an arbitrary and unpredictable manner. Where necessary, this provision may be formulated as having a unilateral rather than a reciprocal character.
Commentary on Chapter VI
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Article 24
Non-Discrimination
1. Article 24 of the United Nations Model Convention, with the exception of the reference to another paragraph of Article 12 in paragraph 4, reproduces Article 24 of the OECD Model Convention. The following are the general observations from the OECD Commentary on Article 24:
1. This Article addresses the problem of eliminating tax discrimination in certain precisely defined circumstances. All tax systems include legitimate differences in treatment based, for example, on differences in tax liabilities or ability to pay. The non-discrimination provisions of this Article are intended to achieve a balance between the need to prevent unjustified discrimination and the need to take such legitimate differences in treatment into account. For this reason, the scope of this Article should not be unduly extended to so-called indirect discrimination. For example, while paragraph 1, which covers discrimination on the grounds of nationality, will prevent the application of a different treatment which is in fact a disguised form of discrimination on the grounds of nationality, such as differences in the treatment of individuals depending on whether or not they hold a passport of that State or whether or not they are entitled to obtain one, it cannot be argued that non-residents of a particular State are primarily persons who are not nationals of that State, in order to conclude that differences in treatment based on whether or not a person is a resident constitute indirect discrimination on the grounds of nationality for the purposes of this paragraph.
2. Similarly, the provisions of this Article cannot be interpreted as requiring the granting of most-favoured-nation treatment. If a State has concluded a bilateral or multilateral agreement which grants tax benefits to nationals or residents of another Contracting State (or States) which is (are) a party (parties) to that agreement, nationals or residents of a third State which is not a Contracting State under that agreement cannot claim the granting of such benefits on the basis of a similar non-discrimination provision in a tax convention for the avoidance of double taxation between that third State and the first-mentioned State. Since tax conventions are based on the principle of reciprocity, the tax treatment granted by one Contracting State under a bilateral or multilateral agreement to a resident or national of another Contracting State which is a party to that agreement by virtue of the specific economic relations between those Contracting States cannot be extended to a resident or national of a third State under a tax non-discrimination provision of a tax convention between the first State and the third State.
3. The various provisions of Article 24 prevent differences in tax treatment which are based exclusively on particular circumstances (for example, nationality in the case of paragraph 1). Thus, for these paragraphs to apply, the other relevant aspects must be identical. The different provisions of Article 24 use different wording to achieve this result (for example, “in the same circumstances” in paragraphs 1 and 2, “carrying on the same activities” in paragraph 3, and “similar enterprises” in paragraph 5). Furthermore, although this Article is intended to eliminate differences which are based exclusively on particular circumstances, it is not intended to grant foreign nationals, non-residents, enterprises of other States, or domestic enterprises owned or controlled by non-residents, more favourable tax treatment than that granted to nationals, residents, or domestic enterprises owned or controlled by residents (see, for example, paragraph 34 below).
4. Finally, as shown in paragraph 79 below, the provisions of this Article should be considered in the context of the other Articles of the Convention, so that measures which are required or expressly authorized by the provisions of those Articles cannot be regarded as violating the provisions of this Article, even if they are applied, for example, to payments made to non-residents. On the other hand, however, the fact that a particular measure does not violate the provisions of this Article does not mean that it is authorized by the Convention, since that measure may result in a violation of other Articles of the Convention.
2. The Committee considers that the following extracts from the Commentary on paragraphs 1–4 of Article 24 of the OECD Model Convention are applicable to the corresponding paragraphs of Article 24 (additional comments placed in square brackets, which do not form part of the OECD Model Tax Convention Commentary, have been inserted to reflect the differences between the provisions of the OECD Model Convention and those of this Model Convention, and to indicate the applicable paragraph/subparagraph of this Model Convention):
Paragraph 1
5. This paragraph establishes the principle that discrimination on the grounds of nationality is prohibited for tax purposes and that, on a reciprocal basis, the treatment of nationals of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State may not be less favourable than that accorded to nationals of the latter State who are in the same circumstances.
6. It should be noted that the principle of non-discrimination, in various forms and with a more or less broad scope, was applied in international tax relations long before the emergence of the classical conventions for the avoidance of double taxation at the end of the nineteenth century. Thus, a very large number of agreements of various kinds (consular conventions or conventions on permanent establishment, treaties of friendship or commerce, etc.) concluded between States, particularly in the nineteenth century, with the aim of extending and strengthening the diplomatic protection of their nationals wherever they might reside, contain provisions under which each Contracting State undertakes to accord the nationals of the other State equal treatment with its own nationals. The fact that such provisions were subsequently included in conventions for the avoidance of double taxation in no way affected their original rationale and scope. Paragraph 1 provides that its application is not limited by Article 1 to nationals who are residents of a Contracting State, but, on the contrary, extends to all nationals of each Contracting State, regardless of whether they are residents of either of them. In other words, all nationals of one of the Contracting States are entitled to invoke this provision in the other Contracting State. In particular, this applies to nationals of the Contracting States who are not residents of either of them but are residents of a third State.
7. The expression “in the same circumstances” refers to taxpayers (individuals, legal persons, partnerships and associations) who, from the point of view of the application of ordinary tax laws or regulations, are in substantially similar circumstances both in law and in fact. The expression “in particular with respect to residence” makes it clear that the residence of a taxpayer is one of the factors to be taken into account in determining whether taxpayers are in similar circumstances. The expression “in the same circumstances” is in itself sufficient to establish that a taxpayer who is a resident of one of the Contracting States and a taxpayer who is not a resident of that State are not in the same circumstances. Indeed, although the expression “in particular with respect to residence” was not included in the 1963 Draft Convention or the 1977 Model Convention, the member States consistently maintained, when applying and interpreting the expression “in the same circumstances”, that the residence of the taxpayer must be taken into account. However, when revising the Model Convention, the Committee on Fiscal Affairs considered that a specific reference to the residence of taxpayers would be a useful clarification, since it would avoid possible doubts as to the interpretation of the expression “in the same circumstances” in this respect.
8. Therefore, when applying paragraph 1, the main question is the following: would two persons who are residents of the same State be subject to different treatment solely because of their different nationality? Consequently, if a Contracting State, when granting a tax allowance in connection with family status, makes a distinction between its own nationals depending on whether or not they reside permanently in its territory, that State cannot be considered obliged to grant nationals of the other State who do not reside permanently in its territory the same treatment as it grants to its own resident nationals, but must extend to them the same treatment as that applied to its nationals who are residents of another State. Similarly, paragraph 1 does not apply where a national of one of the Contracting States (State R), who is also a resident of State R, is subject to less favourable tax treatment in the other Contracting State (State S) than a national of State S residing permanently in a third State (for example, as a result of the application of provisions intended to prevent the use of tax haven benefits), since the two persons are not in the same circumstances by virtue of their place of permanent residence.
9. The expression “in the same circumstances” may in certain cases refer to the tax situation of a particular person. This will be the case, for example, where a country imposes a broader tax liability on its nationals, or on some of them, than on non-nationals (this is, for example, a characteristic of the United States tax system). As long as such tax treatment does not in itself constitute a violation of paragraph 1, it cannot be argued that individuals who are not nationals of that State are in the same circumstances as its nationals for the purposes of applying other provisions of that State’s domestic tax legislation in respect of which the taxpayer’s full or limited tax liability would be relevant (for example, the granting of personal allowances).
10. Similarly, the provisions of paragraph 1 should not be interpreted as obliging a State which grants special tax privileges to its public authorities or services as such to extend the same privileges to the public authorities and services of another State.
11. Nor should they be interpreted as imposing an obligation on a State which grants special tax privileges to private non-profit institutions whose activities serve the public interest of that State to extend the same privileges to similar institutions whose activities do not serve its interests.
12. As regards the first of these examples, if a State grants immunity from taxation to its public authorities and services, this is justified by the fact that such authorities and services are an integral part of the State and their circumstances cannot in any way be compared with those of the public authorities and services of another State. Nevertheless, this exception should not apply to State corporations carrying on profit-making activities. To the extent that the latter may be treated on the same basis as private commercial enterprises, the provisions of paragraph 1 apply to them.
13. As regards the second case, where a State grants tax privileges to certain private non-profit institutions, this is clearly justified by the very nature of the activities of such institutions and the benefit which that State and its citizens derive from those activities.
14. Furthermore, paragraph 1 is deliberately formulated in the negative. By providing that nationals of one of the Contracting States may not in the other Contracting State be subjected to taxation or any connected requirement which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which nationals of the latter State are or may be subjected in the same circumstances, this paragraph has the same binding force as if it imposed an obligation on the Contracting State to grant the same treatment to its own nationals. However, since the main purpose of this provision is to prohibit discrimination by one State against nationals of the other State, there is nothing in it which would prevent the first State from granting foreign nationals, for special reasons or in order to comply with a specific provision of a convention for the avoidance of double taxation, namely the requirement to tax the profits of a permanent establishment on the basis of separate accounts in accordance with Article 7 [of the United Nations Model Convention], certain benefits or facilities which are not available to its own nationals. In its current wording, paragraph 1 does not prohibit this.
15. In view of the foregoing, the words “… shall not be subjected … to taxation or any connected requirement which is other or more burdensome…” mean that, where nationals and foreigners in the same circumstances are taxed, such tax must have the same form in terms of the tax base and method of assessment, its rate must be the same and, finally, the tax-related formalities (tax returns, payments, prescribed deadlines, etc.) may not be more stringent for foreigners than for nationals.
16. Considering that the legal relationship between a company and the State under whose laws it is incorporated resembles in certain respects the relationship of nationality in the case of individuals, it seems justified not to provide a special provision for legal persons, partnerships and associations, but to treat them together with individuals in paragraph 1. This is possible by virtue of the definition of the term “national” in subparagraph [f)] of paragraph 1 of Article 3.
17. Under this definition, in relation to a legal person such as a company, a “national of a Contracting State” means a legal person “deriving its status as such from the laws in force in that Contracting State”. A company normally acquires this status under the laws in force in the State in which it is incorporated or registered. However, under the domestic legislation of many countries, incorporation or registration is the criterion, or one of the criteria, for determining the residence of companies for the purposes of Article 4. Since paragraph 1 of Article 24 does not permit differences in tax treatment on the grounds of nationality, but only in respect of individuals or legal persons who are “in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residence”, it is important for the purposes of this paragraph to distinguish differences in tax treatment based exclusively on nationality from differences in tax treatment connected with other circumstances, and in particular with residence. As explained in paragraphs 7 and 8 above, paragraph 1 only prohibits discrimination on the grounds of different nationality and requires all other relevant factors, including the residence of a legal person, to be identical. A distinction in treatment between residents and non-residents is a fundamental feature of national tax systems and tax treaties; when Article 24 is read in the context of the other Articles of the Convention, most of which provide for differences in tax treatment between residents and non-residents, it becomes clear that two companies which are not residents of the same State for the purposes of the Convention (in accordance with the rules of Article 4) are generally not in the same circumstances for the purposes of paragraph 1.
18. While residents and non-residents are generally not in the same circumstances for the purposes of paragraph 1, it is clear, however, that this is not the case where residence is of no relevance whatsoever to the different tax treatment under consideration.
19. The following examples illustrate these principles.
20. Example 1. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies incorporated in that State or having their place of effective management there are considered to be its residents. The tax convention between State A and State B is identical to the present Model Tax Convention. The domestic tax legislation of State A provides that dividends paid by a company incorporated in that country to another company also incorporated in that country are exempt from tax. Since a company incorporated in State B but having its place of effective management in State A is considered to be a resident of State A for the purposes of the Convention between State A and State B, the fact that dividends paid to such a company by a company incorporated in State A would not qualify for such exemption, even though the recipient company is in the same circumstances as a company incorporated in State A with respect to residence, would constitute a violation of paragraph 1 in the absence of other relevant distinguishing circumstances.
21. Example 2. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies incorporated in that State are its residents, whereas companies incorporated abroad are not residents. The tax convention between State A and State B is identical to the present Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that, where a legal person is a resident of both States under paragraph 1 of that Article, that legal person shall be deemed to be a resident of the State in which it is incorporated. The domestic tax legislation of State A provides that dividends paid by a company incorporated in that country to another company also incorporated in that country are exempt from tax. Paragraph 1 does not extend this treatment to dividends paid to a company incorporated in State B. Even if a company incorporated in State A and a company incorporated in State B receiving such dividends are subject to different treatment, these companies are not in the same circumstances with respect to their residence, and residence is a relevant factor in this case (as may be concluded, for example, from paragraph 5 of Article 10, which does not permit subsequent taxation of dividends paid to a non-resident company, but not of those paid to a resident company).
22. Example 3. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies incorporated in that State are its residents. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State B, companies having their place of effective management there are its residents. The tax convention between State A and State B is identical to the present Model Tax Convention. The domestic income tax legislation of State A provides that a non-resident company which is a resident of a State with which State A has no tax agreement permitting the exchange of tax information is subject to an annual tax at a rate of 3 per cent of the value of its immovable property instead of tax on the net income derived from such property. A company incorporated in State B but resident in a State with which State A has no tax agreement permitting the exchange of tax information cannot claim that paragraph 1 prevents the application of the 3 per cent tax levied by State A, since it is subject to a different tax regime compared with a company incorporated in State A. In this case, such a company would not be in the same circumstances with respect to its residence as a company incorporated in State A, and the residence of the company is a relevant factor (for example, for the purposes of access to the information necessary to verify the amount of net income from immovable property derived by a non-resident taxpayer).
23. Example 4. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies incorporated in that State are its residents, whereas companies incorporated abroad are not residents. The tax convention between State A and State B is identical to the present Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that, where a legal person is a resident of both States under paragraph 1 of that Article, that legal person shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which it is incorporated. Under the payroll tax legislation of State A, all companies employing resident employees are subject to payroll tax, with no distinction being made on the grounds of the employer’s residence, but only companies incorporated in State A are entitled to a lower payroll tax rate. In this case, the fact that a company incorporated in State B does not have the same residence as a company incorporated in State A for the purposes of the Convention between States A and B is entirely irrelevant to the differences in payroll tax treatment, and consequently the different tax treatment would constitute a violation of paragraph 1 in the absence of other relevant distinguishing circumstances.
24. Example 5. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies incorporated in that State or having their place of effective management there are residents of that State, whereas companies which do not meet either of these two conditions are considered non-residents. Under the domestic income tax legislation of State B, companies incorporated in that State are residents of that State. The tax convention between State A and State B is identical to the present Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that, where a legal person is a resident of both States under paragraph 1 of that Article, that legal person shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which it is incorporated. Furthermore, the domestic tax legislation of State A also provides that companies incorporated in that State or having their place of effective management there are entitled to consolidate their income for tax purposes if they belong to a group of companies having common shareholders. Company X, which is incorporated in State B, belongs to the same group as two companies incorporated in State A, and all these companies have their place of effective management in State A. Since Company X is not incorporated in State A, it is not permitted to consolidate its income with that of the other two companies.
25. In this case, even if Company X is a resident of State A under the domestic legislation of that State, it is not a resident of State A for the purposes of the Convention by virtue of paragraph 3 of Article 4. Therefore, it will not be in the same circumstances as the other group companies with respect to residence, and paragraph 1 will not allow it to benefit from income consolidation, even if the different tax treatment is due to the fact that Company X is not incorporated in State A. The residence of Company X is clearly a relevant factor with respect to the benefits of income consolidation, since certain provisions of the Convention, such as Articles 7 and 10, will not permit State A to tax certain items of income derived by Company X.
Paragraph 2
26. On 28 September 1954, a number of States concluded in New York the Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and, under Article 29 of that Convention, stateless persons must be accorded the same treatment as nationals. Several OECD member countries are among the States which signed that Convention.
27. However, it should be recognized that the provisions of paragraph 2 in bilateral conventions permit the extension of the treatment accorded to nationals to stateless persons who, by virtue of one of the situations listed in paragraph 2 of Article 1 of the above-mentioned Convention of 28 September 1954, do not fall within the scope of that Convention. On the one hand, this mainly concerns persons who, at the time of signature of the Convention, receive protection or assistance from organs or agencies of the United Nations other than the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and, on the other hand, persons who are residents of a country and enjoy the rights and bear the obligations associated with the status of nationality of that country.
28. The purpose of paragraph 2 is to limit the scope of this provision concerning equal treatment with nationals of a Contracting State to stateless persons who are residents of that State or of the other Contracting State.
29. By thus excluding stateless persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States, this provision does not allow them to enjoy the privileges of one State over the nationals of the other State.
30. However, if the States consider it appropriate in their bilateral relations to extend the application of paragraph 2 to all stateless persons, whether residents or non-residents of a Contracting State, so that in all cases they enjoy the most favourable treatment accorded to nationals of the relevant State, they need only adopt the following text, which does not contain a condition concerning residence in a Contracting State:
Stateless persons shall not be subjected in a Contracting State to taxation or any connected requirement which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which nationals of that State are or may be subjected in the same circumstances, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 1.
31. [...] [In the future, some States may object to the provisions of paragraph 2 as being too liberal in the sense that they entitle stateless persons who are residents of one State to claim equal treatment not only in the other State, but also in their State of residence and thus to enjoy, in particular in the latter State, the benefits of the provisions of conventions for the avoidance of double taxation concluded by that State with third States. If such States wish to avoid these consequences, they will have to] amend paragraph 2 as follows:
Stateless persons who are residents of one of the Contracting States shall not be subjected in the other Contracting State to taxation or any connected requirement which is other or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which nationals of that other Contracting State are or may be subjected in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residence.
32. Finally, it should be understood that the definition of the term “stateless person” used for the purposes of such a provision can only be that given in paragraph 1 of Article 1 of the Convention of 28 September 1954, according to which the term “stateless person” (“apatride”) means “a person who is not considered as a national by any State under the operation of its law.”
Paragraph 3
33. Strictly speaking, the type of discrimination that this paragraph is intended to eliminate is discrimination based not on nationality, but on the actual location of the enterprise. Therefore, it applies without exception and irrespective of nationality to all residents of one of the Contracting States who have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State.
34. First, it seems necessary to clarify that the wording of the first sentence of paragraph 3 should be interpreted to mean that different taxation of non-residents and residents for practical reasons does not constitute discrimination, provided that it does not result in more burdensome taxation of the former compared with the latter. Being formulated in the negative, this provision attaches importance solely to the outcome, while allowing the method of taxation to be adapted to the specific circumstances of tax collection. For example, paragraph 3 does not prevent the application of specific mechanisms used solely for the purpose of determining the profits attributable to a permanent establishment. This paragraph should be considered in the context of the Convention, and in particular paragraph 2 of Article 7 [of the United Nations Model Convention]. It is obvious that rules or administrative practices applied to determine the profits attributable to a permanent establishment, based on the requirements of paragraph 2 of Article 7 [of the United Nations Model Convention], cannot be regarded as a violation of paragraph 3, which is based on the same principle, since it requires that the tax treatment of a permanent establishment be no less favourable than the taxation imposed on domestic enterprises carrying on similar activities.
35. Under the first sentence of paragraph 3, the taxation of a permanent establishment must not be less favourable in the State concerned than the taxation of enterprises of that State carrying on similar activities. The purpose of this provision is to put an end to all forms of discrimination in the tax treatment of permanent establishments compared with resident enterprises belonging to the same sector, in terms of taxes based on commercial activities, and particularly corporate income taxes.
36. In turn, the second sentence of paragraph 3 specifies the conditions under which the principle of equal treatment established in the first sentence should be applied to individuals who are residents of one of the Contracting States and have a permanent establishment in the other State. It is primarily intended to ensure that such persons do not receive greater benefits than residents through personal allowances and deductions related to family status, both in the State of which they are residents, under the application of its domestic legislation, and in the other State, by virtue of the principle of equal treatment. Consequently, the State in which the permanent establishment is located is left with the right to decide whether or not to grant personal allowances and deductions to the persons concerned, in the proportion that the amount of the profits of the permanent establishment represents of the total income from all sources taxable in the other State.
37. It is also obvious that, for the purposes of paragraph 3, the tax treatment in one Contracting State of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State must be comparable to the treatment of an enterprise in the first-mentioned State having a legal structure similar to that of the enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs. Thus, for example, paragraph 3 does not require a State to apply to the profits of a permanent establishment of an enterprise owned by a non-resident individual the same tax rate as that applied to an enterprise in that State owned by a resident company.
38. Similarly, regulated and unregulated activities are generally not considered to be "the same activities" for the purposes of paragraph 3. Thus, for example, paragraph 3 will not require that the tax treatment of a permanent establishment whose activities include borrowing and lending money, but which is not registered as a bank, be no less favourable than that of domestic banks, since the permanent establishment does not carry on the same type of activity. Another example may be activities carried on by the State or its public authorities, which, because they are under the control of the State, cannot be regarded, for the purposes of paragraph 3, as the same type of activity as that carried on by an enterprise of the other State through a permanent establishment.
39. With regard to the first sentence, experience shows that it is difficult to define clearly and comprehensively the substance of the principle of equal treatment, and this has led to considerable differences of opinion regarding many of the consequences of applying this principle. It would appear that the main reason for these difficulties lies in the true nature of a permanent establishment, which is not an independent legal entity, but merely a part of an enterprise having its head office in another State. The position of a permanent establishment differs from that of a domestic enterprise, which is a single entity whose entire activity, together with the corresponding tax consequences, may be fully attributed to the jurisdiction of the State in which its head office is located. The consequences of applying the equal treatment provision will be considered below from the perspective of certain aspects of taxation.
A. Calculation of tax
40. With regard to the tax base, the principle of equal treatment generally has the following consequences:
a) Permanent establishments must have the same right as resident enterprises to deduct business expenses which are generally permitted under tax legislation to be deducted from taxable profits. Such deductions should be allowed without restrictions other than those also imposed on resident enterprises […].
b) Permanent establishments must have the same opportunities with regard to depreciation allowances and reserves. They must be entitled to use without restrictions not only the depreciation allowances normally available to enterprises (straight-line depreciation, declining-balance depreciation), but also special schemes existing in a number of countries ("lump-sum" write-offs, accelerated depreciation, etc.). With regard to reserves, it should be noted that they are sometimes permitted for purposes unrelated to offsetting, in accordance with the principles of commercial accounting, in order to provide for the depreciation of assets, expenses or losses that have not yet arisen but are likely to arise in the near future. Thus, in some countries, enterprises are entitled to set aside funds from taxable profits into "reserves" for investment purposes. If all enterprises or enterprises in a particular industry are entitled to exercise this right, non-resident enterprises should, as a rule, also be entitled to do so under the same conditions in respect of their permanent establishments located in that State, to the extent that the activities to which such reserves relate are taxable in that State.
c) Permanent establishments should also have the same options as resident enterprises in most countries for carrying forward or carrying back losses incurred at the end of an accounting period within a specified period of time (for example, 5 years). It is hardly necessary to clarify that, in the case of a permanent establishment, the losses arising from its own business activities qualify for such carry-forward treatment.
d) Furthermore, the same rules as those applicable to resident enterprises should apply to permanent establishments with regard to the taxation of capital gains realised upon the disposal of assets, both in the course of carrying on business activities and upon their termination.
41. As clearly indicated in subparagraph c) above, the principle of equal treatment under paragraph 3 applies only to the taxation of the permanent establishment's own activities. Consequently, this principle is limited to a comparison between the rules governing the taxation of the permanent establishment's own activities and those applicable to similar types of business activities carried on by independent resident enterprises. It does not extend to rules that take into account relationships between an enterprise and other enterprises (for example, rules permitting the consolidation of income, the transfer of losses or tax-free transfers of assets between companies having a common owner), since the latter rules focus not on the taxation of the enterprise's own business activities, similar to those of the permanent establishment, but rather on the taxation of a resident enterprise within a group of associated enterprises. Such rules are often applied to ensure or facilitate compliance with tax legislation and tax administration requirements within a group of domestic enterprises. It follows that the principle of equal treatment does not apply in this context. For the same reasons, rules relating to the distribution of profits of a resident enterprise cannot be extended to a permanent establishment under paragraph 3, since they do not relate to the business activities of the permanent establishment (see paragraph 59 below).
42. It is also obvious that, in accordance with the arm's length principle, the application of transfer pricing rules to transfers of funds from a permanent establishment to its head office (or vice versa) cannot be considered a violation of paragraph 3, even if such rules do not apply to transfers of funds within an enterprise of the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located. Indeed, the application of the arm's length principle to the determination of the profits attributable to a permanent establishment is strictly governed by paragraph 2 of Article 7 [of the United Nations Model Convention], and that paragraph forms an integral part of the context in which paragraph 3 of Article 24 must be interpreted; moreover, since Article 9 authorises the application of the arm's length principle to transfers of funds between a domestic enterprise and a foreign associated enterprise, it cannot be considered that its application to the financial results of a permanent establishment leads to less favourable taxation than that imposed on an enterprise of the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located.
43. Although the general rules set out above rarely give rise to any problems in relation to the principle of non-discrimination, they do not constitute an exhaustive list of the possible consequences of applying this principle with regard to the determination of the taxable base. The application of this principle appears to be less clear in relation to tax incentive measures introduced by most countries facing such problems as the decentralisation of industry, the development of economically underdeveloped regions or the stimulation of new types of activities necessary for economic expansion, with a view to helping address these problems through tax exemptions, tax allowances or other tax benefits granted to enterprises in order to encourage them to make the investments necessary to achieve officially established objectives.
44. Since such measures promote the achievement of objectives directly related to the economic activities of the State concerned, their benefits should also be available to permanent establishments of enterprises of another State that has concluded a double taxation avoidance convention with the first-mentioned State containing the provisions of Article 24, provided that they have been granted the right to carry on industrial or commercial activities in that State under its domestic legislation or under an international agreement (trade treaty, convention on representations, etc.) concluded between those two States.
45. However, it should be noted that, although non-resident enterprises are entitled to claim these tax benefits in the State concerned, they must satisfy the same conditions and requirements as resident enterprises. Accordingly, they may be denied such benefits if their permanent establishments are unable or unwilling to comply with the specific conditions and requirements attached to those benefits.
46. It is also clear that non-resident enterprises are not entitled to tax benefits associated with activities that, for reasons of national interest, defence, protection of the national economy, etc., are strictly reserved for domestic enterprises, since non-resident enterprises are not permitted to engage in such activities.
47. Finally, the provisions of paragraph 3 should not be interpreted as requiring a State that grants special tax privileges to non-profit institutions whose activities serve the public good of that State specifically to extend the same privileges to permanent establishments of similar institutions whose activities do not serve exclusively the public good of the first-mentioned State.
B. Special treatment of dividends received in connection with the ownership of a shareholding held by a permanent establishment
48. In many countries, special rules exist for the taxation of dividends distributed between companies (the parent-subsidiary regime, the "Schachtelprivileg", the "non bis in idem" rule). The question arises as to whether permanent establishments may also benefit from such treatment under the provisions of paragraph 3 in respect of dividends arising from a shareholding forming part of their assets.
49. Opinions differ on this issue. Some States consider that permanent establishments should be granted such special treatment. They take the view that this regime was introduced in order to avoid economic double taxation of profits earned by a subsidiary and distributed to its parent company. In principle, tax on profits should be levied only once and only on the subsidiary that carries on the activity generating those profits. The parent company should be exempt from tax on such profits when receiving them from the subsidiary or, under the indirect foreign tax credit method, should receive a credit against its tax for the tax paid by the subsidiary. Where shares are held as direct investments of a permanent establishment, the same principle implies that such a permanent establishment receiving dividends from a subsidiary should also be granted special treatment, taking into account that tax on the profits has already been levied on the subsidiary. On the other hand, if this logic is followed, it is difficult to envisage the State in which the head office of the parent company is located itself granting relief in order to avoid double taxation arising from the repeated taxation in the State in which the permanent establishment is located. The State in which the parent company is located and in which no activity generating the profits subject to double taxation is carried on will normally exempt such profits or impose a profit tax that is insufficient to provide a double credit (that is, for both the tax on the profits of the subsidiary and the tax on the profits of the permanent establishment). All this presupposes that the shares owned by the permanent establishment are in fact connected with its activities. Furthermore, an obvious additional condition is that the profits out of which the dividends are distributed must be subject to corporate income tax.
50. Conversely, other States consider that treating permanent establishments in the same way as their own enterprises does not entail any obligation to grant such special treatment to permanent establishments. They justify their position by various arguments. The purpose of such special treatment is to avoid the economic double taxation of dividends, and the corresponding cost should be borne not by the State in which the permanent establishment is located, but by the State of residence of the recipient company, since it has a greater interest in this matter. Another reason put forward relates to the allocation of tax revenues between States. The loss of tax revenue incurred by the State granting such special treatment is partially offset by the taxation of dividends when they are redistributed by the parent company benefiting from such treatment (withholding tax on dividends, shareholder tax). The State that grants such treatment to permanent establishments will not be able to benefit from this compensation. Another argument is that, if such treatment is conditional upon the redistribution of dividends, extending it to permanent establishments would not be justified, since in that case a permanent establishment, which is merely part of a company of another State and does not distribute dividends, would be subject to more favourable treatment than a resident company. Finally, States that consider that paragraph 3 does not entail any obligation to extend such treatment to permanent establishments believe that there is a risk that companies of one State may transfer their shares in companies of another State to their permanent establishments in that other State for the sole purpose of benefiting from such treatment.
51. It must be acknowledged that there may be very sound reasons for a permanent establishment, rather than the enterprise's head office, to own and manage shares, namely:
— because of a necessity arising primarily from a statutory or regulatory requirement obliging banks and financial institutions, as well as insurance companies, to hold a certain portion of their assets, particularly shares, in the countries in which they carry on business, as security for the fulfilment of their obligations;
— or because of commercial expediency, where the shares are held by companies having business relations with the permanent establishment or whose head offices are located in the same country as the permanent establishment;
— or simply because of practical convenience associated with the current trend towards the decentralisation of management functions characteristic of large enterprises.
52. In view of these different positions, as well as the situations just described, States are recommended to clarify their interpretation of the first sentence of paragraph 3 when concluding bilateral conventions. If they so wish, they may clarify their position or modify it in comparison with previous practice in a protocol or any other document attached to the Convention.
53. Such a document may also contain a decision concerning the above-mentioned objection that extending the shareholding regime in State A to permanent establishments of companies resident in State B would result in such companies unjustifiably enjoying privileges compared with other companies resident in the same State whose head offices own shares in the capital of companies resident in State A, in the sense that, although dividends on their shares may be repatriated by the former companies without withholding tax at source, such tax is levied on dividends distributed to the latter companies at a rate of 5 or 15 per cent, depending on the circumstances. Tax neutrality and an equal tax burden between permanent establishments and subsidiaries, as argued by the States concerned, may be ensured by adopting provisions corresponding to paragraphs 2 and 4 of Article 10 in bilateral conventions between State A and State B, so that withholding tax may be levied in State A on dividends paid by companies resident in that State to permanent establishments of companies resident in State B in the same manner as if the dividends had been received directly, that is, by the head offices of the latter companies, namely at the rate of:
— 5 per cent in the case of ownership of a shareholding of at least 25 per cent;
— 15 per cent in all other cases.
It should be noted that paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the United Nations Model Convention differs from the conditions set out above.
54. If, due to the absence of relevant provisions in the domestic legislation of the State concerned, it proves impossible to levy withholding tax at source on dividends paid to permanent establishments, the regime for dividends distributed between companies could be extended to permanent establishments, since its application is limited in such a way that the tax levied by the State of source of the dividends is the same, irrespective of whether the dividends are received by a permanent establishment of a company resident in another State or directly by that company.
C. Structure and rate of tax
55. In countries where enterprises, primarily companies, are taxed on their specific profits, the provisions of paragraph 3 raise certain very specific problems concerning the applicable tax rate in the case of a permanent establishment, owing to the fact that a permanent establishment is merely part of a legal entity that does not fall within the jurisdiction of the State in which the permanent establishment is located.
56. Where the taxation of profits earned by companies resident in a given State is calculated on the basis of a progressive rate scale, such a scale should, in principle, be applied to permanent establishments located in that State. If, when applying the progressive rate scale, the State in which the permanent establishment is located takes into account the profits of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs, such a rule does not conflict with the principle of equal treatment, since resident companies are in fact subject to the same regime […]. Therefore, States that tax their companies in this manner could determine in their bilateral conventions the treatment applicable to permanent establishments.
57. If a tax system based on a progressive rate scale provides for a rule under which a minimum rate is applied to permanent establishments, it cannot be asserted a priori that such a rule is incompatible with the principle of equal treatment. The profits of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs must be taken into account when determining the rate applicable under the progressive scale. The provisions of the first sentence of paragraph 3 are complied with unless the minimum rate is higher.
58. However, even if the profits of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs are taken into account when applying either a progressive rate scale or a minimum rate, this does not conflict with the principle of [the separate and independent enterprise], according to which the profits of a permanent establishment must be determined in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7 [of the United Nations Model Convention]. Therefore, the minimum amount of tax levied in the State in which the permanent establishment is located is the amount that would be payable if it were a separate and independent enterprise, without taking into account the profits of the entire enterprise to which it belongs. Consequently, the State in which the permanent establishment is located may reasonably apply the progressive scale applicable to resident enterprises exclusively to the profits of the permanent establishment, without taking into account the profits of the entire enterprise, if the latter are lower than the profits of the permanent establishment. Similarly, that State may tax the profits of the permanent establishment at the minimum rate, provided that the same rate is applied to resident enterprises, even if, taking into account the profits of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs, a lower amount of tax or no tax at all would result.
59. Since a permanent establishment, by its very nature, does not distribute dividends, the tax treatment of distributions made by the enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs therefore falls outside the scope of paragraph 3. The application of paragraph 3 is limited to the taxation of profits from the activities of the permanent establishment itself and does not extend to the taxation of the enterprise as a whole. This is confirmed by the second sentence of this paragraph, which establishes that tax aspects relating to the taxpayer owning the permanent establishment, such as personal allowances and deductions, fall outside the scope of this paragraph. Thus, issues relating to the various systems for integrating corporate and shareholder taxation (for example, advance corporation tax, précompte mobilier, calculation of income from dividends received from another company, and tax credits associated with such dividends) also fall outside the scope of this paragraph.
60. In some States, the profits of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of another Contracting State are taxed at a higher rate than the profits of enterprises of that State. This additional tax, sometimes referred to as a "branch tax", may be explained by the fact that if a subsidiary of a foreign enterprise earned the same amount of profit as a permanent establishment and then distributed that profit in the form of dividends, such dividends would be subject to an additional tax under paragraph 2 of Article 10. Where such a tax is levied in the form of an additional tax on the profits of a permanent establishment, it should be regarded as a tax on the profits from the activities of the permanent establishment itself, rather than as a tax on the enterprise in its capacity as the owner of the permanent establishment. Consequently, such a tax is contrary to paragraph 3.
Paragraphs 18–24 of the Commentary on Article 10 address the issue of taxes on branch profits and propose an optional provision on the taxation of branch profits, which takes precedence over Article 24.
61. Nevertheless, this situation should be distinguished from the taxation of deductible amounts of income, for example, in the form of interest when calculating the profits of a permanent establishment (for example, a "branch-level interest tax"); in this case, the tax is not levied on the permanent establishment itself, but rather on the enterprise for whose benefit the interest is deemed to have been paid, and therefore such a tax falls outside the scope of paragraph 3 (nevertheless, depending on the circumstances, other provisions, such as Articles 7 and 11, may apply to determine whether such taxation is permitted under the Convention; see the last sentence of paragraph 4).
D. Withholding tax on dividends, interest and royalties received by a permanent establishment
62. Where permanent establishments receive dividends, interest and royalties, such income, pursuant to paragraph [3] of Articles 10 and 11 and paragraph [4] of Article 12 [as well as paragraph 5 of Article 12A], respectively, falls under the provisions of Article 7 and, consequently, subject to the observations set out in paragraph 53 above concerning dividends received in respect of shareholdings held by a permanent establishment, must be included in the taxable profits of such permanent establishments.
63. Under the relevant Commentaries on the above-mentioned provisions of Articles 10, 11 [, 12 and 12A], these provisions exempt the State of source of dividends, interest or royalties received by a permanent establishment from applying any limitation provided for in those Articles, which means—and this is the generally accepted interpretation—that they do not in any way affect the right of the State of source in which the permanent establishment is located to apply its full withholding tax rate.
64. Although this approach does not create any problems in relation to the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 24 in the case of countries where withholding tax is levied on all income irrespective of whether it is paid to residents (permanent establishments, which, like resident enterprises, are permitted to credit such withholding tax against their corporate income tax under Article 7) or non-residents (who are subject to the limitations provided for in Articles 10, 11 [, 12 and 12A]), the situation changes where withholding tax is applied exclusively to income paid to non-residents.
65. Indeed, in the latter case, it is difficult to reconcile the withholding tax with the principle established in paragraph 3, according to which, for the purposes of taxing income derived from or ordinarily connected with business activities—which is recognised in respect of dividends, interest and royalties referred to in paragraph [4] of Articles 10 and 11 and paragraph [4] of Article 12 [and paragraph 5 of Article 12A]—permanent establishments should be subject to the same treatment as resident enterprises and should therefore be subject to corporate income tax only in respect of such income.
66. In any event, it is for the Contracting States themselves to resolve these issues during bilateral negotiations, taking into account their particular circumstances.
E. Credit for foreign taxes
67. In the relevant context, if foreign income is included in the profits attributable to a permanent establishment, then, by virtue of the same principle, it would be appropriate to grant that permanent establishment a credit for the foreign tax attributable to such income, if such a credit is granted to resident enterprises under domestic law.
68. If, in a Contracting State (A) in which a permanent establishment of an enterprise of another Contracting State (B) is located, relief for tax levied in a third State (C) is possible only on the basis of a convention, a more general question arises concerning the extension to the permanent establishment of the provisions on tax credits included in tax conventions concluded with third States. Although a permanent establishment is not itself a legal entity and therefore is not entitled to benefits under such tax conventions, this issue is relevant to the taxation of the permanent establishment. This issue is considered below with reference to the specific case of dividends and interest.
F. Extension to a permanent establishment of the benefits of tax credits under double taxation avoidance conventions concluded with third States
69. If a permanent establishment in one Contracting State, belonging to an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State, receives dividends […], interest [or royalties] from a third State, the question arises as to whether, and to what extent, the Contracting State in which that permanent establishment is located should credit the tax that cannot be offset by the third State.
70. There is general agreement that double taxation arises in such situations and that a way must be found to reduce it. Most Member States are able to grant a tax credit in such cases on the basis of their domestic legislation or under paragraph 3. States that are unable to grant a credit in this manner or that wish to clarify the situation may wish to supplement the relevant provision in their Convention with the Contracting State in which the enterprise having a permanent establishment is resident, by wording allowing the State in which the permanent establishment is located to credit the tax liability in the State in which the income arises, up to an amount not exceeding the amount for which resident enterprises in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located would be entitled to claim a credit under the convention concluded by that Contracting State with the third State. If the tax that cannot be offset under the convention between the third State and the State of residence of the enterprise having a permanent establishment in another Contracting State is lower than the tax levied under the convention between the third State and the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located, only the lower tax paid in the third State shall be credited. This may be achieved by inserting the following words after the first sentence of paragraph 3:
If a permanent establishment in one of the Contracting States, belonging to an enterprise of the other Contracting State, receives dividends, interest or royalties from a third State, and the shareholding or debt-claim in respect of which the dividends, interest or royalties are paid is effectively connected with that permanent establishment, the first-mentioned State shall grant a credit for the tax paid in the third State on the dividends, interest or royalties, as the case may be, by applying the tax rate provided for in the convention on taxes on income and on capital concluded between the State of which the enterprise is a resident and that third State. However, the amount of the credit shall not exceed the amount for which an enterprise resident in the first-mentioned State may claim a credit under the convention on the taxation of income and capital concluded by that State with the third State.
If the Convention also specifies other categories of income that may be taxed in the State in which they arise and in respect of which a tax credit must be granted (for example, royalties under certain conventions), the above provision must then be modified to cover such categories of income.
The following is then stated in the Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Convention:
71. If a permanent establishment located in one of the Contracting States of an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State (the State of residence) receives dividends, interest or royalties from a third State (the State of source) and, under a procedure agreed between the State of residence and the State of source, the State of source requests a certificate of residence for the application of withholding tax at the rate provided for in the convention between the State of source and the State of residence, such certificate must be issued by the latter State. Although such a procedure may be useful if the State of residence applies the credit method, it appears unnecessary if that State applies the exemption method, since income from the third State is not subject to taxation in the State of residence of the enterprise. On the other hand, the State in which the permanent establishment is located could benefit from the certificate-issuing procedure, as it would provide useful information for audit purposes. Situations involving three States also raise the issue of abuse. If the Contracting State of which the enterprise is a resident exempts from tax the profits of a permanent establishment located in another Contracting State, there is a risk that the enterprise may transfer assets, such as shares, bonds or patents, to permanent establishments in States offering more favourable tax treatment and, in certain circumstances, the resulting income may not be taxed in any of the three States. To prevent such a practice, which may be regarded as abusive, a provision may be included in the convention between the State of which the enterprise is a resident and the third State (the State of source), under which the enterprise may claim the benefits provided for in the Convention only if the income received by the permanent establishment located in the other State is subject to ordinary taxation in the State in which the permanent establishment is located.
The following is then stated in the Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Convention:
72. In addition to the typical three-State situation considered here, other cases involving three States also arise, particularly where the State in which the enterprise is located is also the State from which the income attributable to a permanent establishment in another State originates (see also paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 21). Such issues may be resolved by States during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 4
73. This paragraph is intended to put an end to a particular form of discrimination arising from the fact that in some countries the deduction of interest, royalties and other payments, which is permitted without restriction where the recipient is a resident, is restricted or even prohibited where the recipient is a non-resident. The same situation may arise in the area of capital taxation in connection with the indebtedness of a non-resident. However, the Contracting States may, at their discretion, modify this provision in bilateral conventions in order to avoid its application for tax avoidance purposes.
74. Paragraph 4 does not prohibit a country from applying its domestic thin capitalisation rules to the extent that they are compatible with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11. However, if such a regime is based on rules that are incompatible with those Articles and applies only to non-resident creditors (excluding resident creditors), that regime is prohibited by paragraph 4.
75. Furthermore, paragraph 4 does not prohibit additional information requirements in respect of payments made to non-residents, since such requirements are intended to ensure a similar level of compliance and verification in the case of payments made to residents and non-residents.
3. During the discussion of paragraph 4 by the former Group of Experts in the course of the revision of the United Nations Model Convention in 1999, the question was raised as to whether this paragraph was suitable for inclusion in a tax treaty between developed and developing countries. The view was expressed that this paragraph would be unacceptable to countries that make the deductibility of payments made abroad by foreign-owned corporations conditional upon the taxation of the recipient in those countries. After detailed discussion, the Group concluded that the above-mentioned special circumstances should not serve as a basis for including broadly applicable provisions in the treaty and that, in cases where they may create problems, they should be discussed during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 5
4. Since this paragraph reproduces paragraph 5 of Article 24 of the OECD Model Convention, the Committee considers that the following extracts from the Commentary on this paragraph of the OECD Model Convention are fully applicable:
76. This paragraph prohibits one of the Contracting States from providing less favourable treatment to an enterprise whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State. This provision and the discrimination it seeks to eliminate relate only to the taxation of enterprises, and not to the persons who own or control their capital. Its purpose, therefore, is to ensure equal treatment for taxpayers who are residents of the same State, rather than to grant foreign capital equal tax treatment with domestic capital in the hands of partners or shareholders.
77. Since this paragraph relates only to the taxation of resident enterprises and not to the persons who own or control their capital, it follows that this paragraph cannot be interpreted broadly in relation to rules that take into account the relationship between a resident enterprise and other resident enterprises (for example, rules permitting the consolidation of income, the transfer of losses or tax-free transfers of assets between companies having a common owner). For example, if the domestic tax legislation of a State allows a resident company to consolidate its income with that of a resident parent company, paragraph 5 cannot be applied in such a way as to require the State to permit such consolidation between a resident company and a non-resident parent company. This would require a comparison of the combined tax treatment of the resident enterprise and the non-resident enterprise owning its capital with the treatment of a resident enterprise of the same State and a resident person owning its capital, which clearly goes beyond the taxation of the resident enterprise alone.
78. Furthermore, since paragraph 5 is intended to ensure that all resident companies are subject to the same tax treatment regardless of who owns or controls their capital, and since this paragraph is not intended to ensure that distributions made to residents and non-residents are subject to the same tax treatment (see paragraph 76 above), it follows that tax liabilities imposed on a resident company in respect of dividends paid to non-resident shareholders, but not in respect of dividends paid to resident shareholders, cannot be regarded as a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, the difference in treatment does not depend on the fact that the company's capital is owned or controlled by a non-resident, but rather on the fact that dividends paid to non-residents are taxed differently. A similar example is the case where a State taxes resident companies making distributions to their shareholders irrespective of whether those shareholders are residents or non-residents, but, in order to avoid the multiple application of this tax, does not apply such treatment to distributions made to related resident companies that are themselves taxed upon making their own distributions. The fact that the latter exemption does not apply to distributions made to non-resident companies should not be regarded as a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, the differences in tax treatment are not due to the fact that the capital of the resident company is owned or controlled by non-residents, but rather to the fact that it makes distributions to companies that, under the provisions of the Convention, are not subject to the same tax when they redistribute the dividends received from that resident company. In this example, all resident companies enjoy the same tax treatment irrespective of who owns or controls their capital, and the differences in treatment are limited to cases of distributions made in circumstances where taxation of such distributions can be avoided.
79. Since this paragraph prevents discrimination against a resident enterprise solely on the basis of who owns or controls the capital of that enterprise, it would appear, based on the available evidence, that it is not relevant to rules that provide for different treatment of an enterprise depending on whether it pays interest to resident or non-resident creditors. This paragraph does not concern rules based on the relationship between a debtor and a creditor, where the different tax treatment resulting from such rules is not based on whether the capital of the enterprise is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by non-residents. For example, if, under the domestic thin capitalisation rules of a State, a resident enterprise is not entitled to deduct interest paid to an associated non-resident enterprise, that rule does not constitute a violation of paragraph 5 even where it applies to interest payments made to a creditor who owns or controls the capital of the enterprise, provided that the same tax treatment would apply if such interest were paid to an associated non-resident enterprise that does not itself own or control any of the payer's capital. It is clear, however, that such a rule of domestic law may constitute a violation of paragraph 4 if different conditions apply to the deduction of interest paid to residents and non-residents, and therefore, for the purposes of that paragraph, it is important to determine whether the application of that rule is inconsistent with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11 (see paragraph 74 above). This is also important for the purposes of paragraph 5 where thin capitalisation rules apply only to enterprises of one Contracting State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State. Indeed, since the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9 and paragraph 6 of Article 11 form part of the context in which paragraph 5 must be interpreted (as required by Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties), adjustments that are compatible with those provisions cannot be regarded as a violation of paragraph 5.
80. With regard to transfer pricing requests, almost all Member States consider that additional information requirements that appear to be more stringent than ordinary requirements, or even a departure from the principle of the burden of proof, do not constitute discrimination within the meaning of this Article.
5. During the revision of the United Nations Model Convention in 1999, some members of the Group of Experts from developing countries proposed that special measures applicable to foreign-owned enterprises should not be interpreted as prohibited discrimination if the same treatment is applied to all foreign-owned enterprises; they acknowledged that this change represented a substantial departure from the general principle of taxing foreigners on the same basis as nationals; however, the problems associated with compliance with tax obligations in cases involving foreign ownership, as well as the political aspects of the position of foreign-owned enterprises in developing countries, justified such a change. They therefore proposed the following amendment to paragraph 5 of Article 24 of the OECD Model Convention:
5. Enterprises of one of the Contracting States, the capital of which is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State, shall not be subjected in the first-mentioned State to taxation, or to any requirements connected therewith, that are different or more burdensome than the taxation and connected requirements to which other similar enterprises are subjected, the capital of which is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by residents of a third State.
Furthermore, they emphasised that the proposed amendment to paragraph 5 had already been included in certain tax treaties concluded by developed countries. Some members of the Group of Experts from developed countries noted that such a proposal would limit the application of the non-discrimination article solely to eliminating discrimination between enterprises owned by non-residents, thereby permitting discrimination against enterprises owned by non-residents as a class.
6. Some members of the Group from developed countries expressed doubts about the proposed amendment and stated that they considered the Non-Discrimination Article of the OECD Model Convention to be fundamental to the Convention. They recalled that provisions preceding the non-discrimination article of the current OECD Model Convention had existed as far back as the nineteenth century. They considered that changing such a fundamental principle would have significant consequences for international relations in the tax field as a whole. Furthermore, since the proposed amendment was partly motivated by problems associated with compliance with tax obligations in cases involving foreign ownership—which essentially come down to transfer pricing—it was suggested that this problem should be addressed through more appropriate means in other parts of the tax Convention, such as Article 9, concerning associated enterprises.
7. Some members of the Group from developing countries, while recognising the importance and necessity of the Non-Discrimination Article, indicated that certain countries might wish to modify specific paragraphs of this Article during bilateral negotiations. In particular, it was suggested that, owing to the difficulties associated with determining reasonable amounts in the case of transfer payments for royalties, technical assistance fees, head office expenses, etc., a country might decide to refuse deductions for such payments or calculate the deductible amount in accordance with its domestic law where such payments are made by an enterprise located in its territory to a foreign-controlled company, irrespective of whether that company is resident in the other Contracting State or in a third State. Another example was given: a country granting tax incentives to address certain domestic objectives might wish to make the granting of such incentives conditional upon a certain percentage of local ownership in the relevant enterprise. The Group recognised that such special situations should be discussed during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 6
8. Since this paragraph reproduces paragraph 6 of Article 24 of the OECD Model Convention, the Committee considers that the following Commentary on this paragraph of the OECD Model Convention is applicable:
81. This paragraph states that the scope of application of the Article is not limited by the provisions of Article 2. Therefore, this Article applies to taxes of every kind and description imposed by a State, its political subdivisions or local authorities, or on their behalf.
Article 25
MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
A. General Considerations
1. Two alternative versions of Article 25 of the United Nations Model Convention are provided. Version A reproduces Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention with the addition of a second sentence to paragraph 4, but excluding arbitration, as provided for in paragraph 5 of the OECD Model Convention. Version B reproduces Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention with the addition of a second sentence to paragraph 4 and includes mandatory arbitration, as provided for in paragraph 5 of the OECD Model Convention, but with four differences. First, paragraph 5 provides that arbitration proceedings may be initiated if the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on a particular case within three years from the date on which the case was submitted for consideration, rather than within two years, as provided for in the OECD Model Convention. Second, whereas the OECD Model Convention provides that arbitration proceedings must be requested by the person who initiated the case, paragraph 5 states that arbitration proceedings must be requested by the competent authorities of one of the Contracting States (this means that a case should not be referred to arbitration if the competent authorities of both Contracting States consider that the case is not suitable for arbitration and neither of them makes such a request). Third, paragraph 5, unlike the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention, allows the competent authorities to depart from arbitration proceedings if they agree to do so within six months after the decision has been communicated to them. Finally, since Version A does not provide for the possibility of arbitration, there is no need for a footnote similar to that included in the OECD Model Convention, mentioning that, for various reasons, some countries may not include an arbitration provision in their tax treaty.
2. The mutual agreement procedure is intended not only to provide a means of resolving issues relating to the interpretation and application of the Convention, but also to provide (a) a forum in which residents of the respective States may challenge actions that are not in accordance with the Convention and (b) a mechanism for eliminating double taxation in cases not provided for in the Convention. The mutual agreement procedure applies in connection with all Articles of the Convention, in particular Article 7 (Business Profits), Article 9 (Associated Enterprises), Article 11 (Interest), Article 12 (Royalties) and Article 23 (Methods for the Elimination of Double Taxation). Even if a bilateral convention does not contain paragraph 2 of Article 9, the inclusion of paragraph 1 of Article 9 is sufficient to indicate that the intention of the Contracting States is to extend the scope of the Convention to economic double taxation. As a result, most countries consider that, in the absence of provisions similar to those of paragraph 2 of Article 9, economic double taxation arising from profit adjustments due to transfer pricing falls within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25 (see paragraph 9 below, which contains excerpts from paragraph 11 of the OECD Commentary on Article 25). Some countries, however, consider that, in the absence of provisions similar to those of paragraph 2 of Article 9, economic double taxation resulting from transfer pricing adjustments does not fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25. Accordingly, Contracting States that have not included paragraph 2 of Article 9 in their convention should clarify during negotiations the implications of the absence of paragraph 2 for the scope of the mutual agreement procedure. Article 9 of the United Nations Model Convention contains paragraph 3, which provides that the provisions of paragraph 2 shall not apply where, as a result of an adjustment of profits in accordance with paragraph 1, an enterprise has been subjected to penalties for fraud, gross negligence or wilful default. Where the conditions provided for in paragraph 3 are met, the Contracting State is not obliged to make the corresponding adjustments under paragraph 2, and the taxpayer may not initiate the mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 25 to request a corresponding adjustment. However, the taxpayer is entitled to initiate the mutual agreement procedure where it considers that not all the conditions provided for in paragraph 3 have been met or that the adjustment of profits has not been made in accordance with paragraph 1.
3. The decision whether to agree in a bilateral convention to a mutual agreement procedure without mandatory arbitration under Version A or with mandatory arbitration under Version B depends on the political and administrative considerations of each Contracting State and its actual experience with mutual agreement procedures. Countries should analyse in advance the advantages and disadvantages of mandatory or voluntary arbitration (see paragraph 14 below) and assess whether arbitration is suitable for them. Countries with limited experience in the field of mutual agreement procedures may encounter difficulties in determining the implications of adding arbitration to the mutual agreement procedure. Such countries could simply decide not to provide for arbitration at this stage. They may, however, also include an arbitration clause but defer its entry into force until the countries notify each other of the date on which the provision is to enter into force. These countries may also decide that, despite their lack of experience, they are prepared to add arbitration to the mutual agreement procedure in order to provide taxpayers with the assurance that a case submitted for consideration under paragraph 1 of Article 25 will be resolved through mutual agreement if the taxpayer declines the mutual agreement procedure.
4. Members of the Committee supporting Version A indicated mainly the following considerations and arguments:
— only a small number of cases are submitted to the mutual agreement procedure under paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25, and very few of them remain unresolved;
— a number of cases that the competent authorities are unable to resolve through the mutual agreement procedure can be resolved by means of domestic remedies;
— given the lack of experience of many developing countries in the field of mutual agreement procedures, arbitration proceedings may prove unfair to such countries when a dispute arises with more experienced countries;
— the interests of countries that are of such importance to their public policy are unlikely to be guaranteed by private arbitrators in tax matters; arbitrators cannot be expected to compensate for the lack of experience in many developing countries;
— it appears to be extremely difficult to guarantee the neutrality and independence of potential arbitrators;
— it is very difficult to find experienced arbitrators;
— mandatory arbitration is costly and therefore unsuitable for developing countries and countries with economies in transition;
— it is not in the interests of a State to limit its sovereignty in tax matters through mandatory arbitration.
5. Members of the Committee supporting Version B indicated mainly the following considerations and arguments:
— notwithstanding the fact that only a small number of cases remain unresolved, each of these cases represents a situation in which no resolution has been reached, where one competent authority considers that taxation is not in accordance with the Convention and where a significant amount of double taxation may arise;
— arbitration provides greater certainty for taxpayers that their cases can be resolved within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure and will contribute to cross-border investment;
— domestic remedies may not provide adequate and timely resolution of disputes relating to the application of bilateral conventions (the risks of conflicting judicial decisions in both countries and the risks of unilateral interpretation of the Convention based on domestic law);
— the obligation to refer unresolved cases to arbitration after the expiry of a specified period may encourage the efforts of the competent authorities to reach an agreement within that period;
— based on experience under the provisions of the EU Arbitration Convention, the effective use of mandatory arbitration would be sufficiently unusual, and the costs associated with this mechanism should be relatively low; moreover, since arbitration provides greater certainty for taxpayers, this method reduces the number of costly "protective" appeals and domestic court proceedings with uncertain outcomes;
— arbitrators must reach a reasoned and impartial decision and, accordingly, they can take into account the different levels of experience of the countries and overcome the possible lack of experience of some of them;
— there are indeed qualified and impartial arbitrators with different professional backgrounds (government officials, judges, academics and practitioners), as well as from different regions (including developing countries);
— it is in the interests of a State to limit its sovereignty in tax matters through mandatory arbitration.
6. In some countries, constitutional or legislative obstacles may limit the ability of the competent authorities to provide assistance in certain cases through the mutual agreement procedure. Treaty negotiators should discuss any such obstacles of which they are aware. Under Version A, however, the existence of such obstacles should not lead to amendments to this Article that would restrict its scope (particularly if such obstacles are removed in the future): the requirement that the competent authorities "endeavour" to resolve a case does not entail an obligation to reach a resolution and recognises that certain factors may affect the ability of a competent authority to reach a mutual agreement or provide assistance. Under Version B, however, negotiators should ensure that the scope of paragraph 5, which provides for mandatory arbitration, is limited in order to take account of any such restrictions and avoid a situation in which a binding arbitration decision cannot be implemented because of such obstacles.
7. Under Version B, however, the scope of paragraph 5 has already been restricted to take account of possible constitutional or legislative obstacles. In some States where a decision on cases submitted to the mutual agreement procedure has already been rendered by one of their courts or administrative tribunals, domestic law no longer permits mutual agreement on the same issues. To take account of this situation, paragraph 5 provides that unresolved cases may not be referred to arbitration where a court or administrative tribunal of either State has already rendered a decision on those issues. States that have the ability to depart from court decisions in individual cases may delete this sentence. In addition, the domestic law of many States provides that no person may be deprived of remedies available under domestic law. Accordingly, under paragraph 5, the arbitration process applies irrespective of the remedies provided for under the domestic law of the Contracting States, and persons directly affected by a case have the opportunity to reject the mutual agreement for the implementation of the arbitration decision and to use any domestic remedies available to them.
B. Commentary on the Paragraphs of Article 25
Paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 (Versions A and B)
8. These paragraphs reproduce in full the text of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention, with one exception: unlike the United Nations Model Convention, paragraph 1 of the OECD Model Convention allows a case to be presented to the competent authority of either State. However, with regard to the last sentence of paragraph 1, some members of the Committee noted that, during bilateral negotiations, States may wish to agree on a different period for presenting a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State.
9. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of the 2017 OECD Model Convention is applicable to the corresponding paragraphs of Article 25 of Versions A and B (additional comments indicated in square brackets, which do not form part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention, have been inserted to provide further clarification or to reflect differences between the provisions of the OECD Model Convention and those of this Convention):
5.1 The obligation to resolve by mutual agreement cases of taxation not in accordance with the Convention is an integral part of the obligations assumed by a Contracting State upon entering into a tax treaty and must be fulfilled in good faith. In particular, the requirement in paragraph 2 that the competent authority "shall endeavour" to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State means that the competent authorities are obliged to endeavour to resolve the case fairly and objectively on its merits, in accordance with the terms of the Convention and the applicable principles of international law on the interpretation of treaties. [It should be emphasised, however, that the obligation to "endeavour to resolve" a case is not an obligation to reach a resolution: in some rare cases, the competent authorities may be unable to reach an agreement despite all their efforts to resolve the case.]
6.1 Through Article 25, the Contracting States have delegated to the competent authorities a broad range of powers to apply and interpret the provisions of the Convention. Paragraph 2 authorises the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement cases presented by taxpayers in order to avoid taxation that might otherwise arise under domestic law but would not be in accordance with the Convention. Paragraph 3 similarly authorises the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of the Convention, both in individual cases (for example, in relation to the case of a single taxpayer) and more generally (for example, through the joint interpretation of a treaty provision applicable to a large number of taxpayers). Under paragraph 3, the competent authorities may, in particular, enter into a mutual agreement to determine the meaning of a term not defined in the Convention or to supplement or clarify the definition of a particular term, where such an agreement would resolve difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of the Convention. Such circumstances may arise, for example, where a conflict between meanings under the domestic laws of the two States creates difficulties or leads to an unintended or absurd result. […][ In order to ensure the proper resolution of such cases, an agreement reached under paragraph 3 concerning the meaning of a term used in the Convention should prevail over the meaning of that term under the domestic law of each State.]
6.2 More generally, although the status of a mutual agreement reached under Article 25 may differ between States under their domestic laws, it is clear that the principles of international law on the interpretation of treaties, as embodied in Articles 31 and 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, allow the courts of the Contracting States to take such an agreement into account. The purpose of Article 25 is to promote, through consultations and mutual agreement between the competent authorities, the consistent treatment of individual cases and the uniform interpretation and/or application of the provisions of the Convention in both States. Article 25 also authorises the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of the Convention; such a mutual agreement reached under the express mandate contained in paragraph 3 of the Article constitutes objective evidence of the mutual understanding of the competent authorities as to the meaning of the Convention and its provisions. For these reasons, an agreement reached by the competent authorities under Article 25 is a significant consideration that should be taken into account when interpreting the Convention.
6.3 In addition, there are certain cases, however, where the application of specific treaty provisions has been expressly delegated by the Contracting States to the competent authorities, and agreements reached by the competent authorities on these matters legally govern the application of those provisions. Subparagraph d) of paragraph 2 of Article 4, for example, provides that the competent authorities shall settle by mutual agreement certain cases where a person is a resident of both Contracting States under paragraph 1 of that Article. Some treaties similarly delegate to the competent authorities the power to jointly determine the status of various entities or arrangements for the purposes of certain treaty provisions (see, for example, subdivision (i) of subparagraph b) of the proposed provision in paragraph 35 of the Commentary on Article 1) or the power to supplement or amend lists of entities, arrangements or domestic law provisions referred to in those treaties.
The following is also stated in the Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Convention:
7. The rules laid down in paragraphs 1 and 2 provide for the elimination, in a specific case, of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. As is well known, in such cases taxpayers can usually apply to a tax court, either directly or after their claims have been rejected by the tax authorities. Where taxation contrary to the Convention arises from the incorrect application of the Convention in both States, taxpayers are required to bring an action in each State, which entails the corresponding adverse consequences and uncertainty. Paragraph 1 therefore makes available to affected taxpayers, without depriving them of the possibility of using the ordinary remedies available to them, a procedure known as the mutual agreement procedure, since its second stage is aimed at resolving the dispute by mutual agreement, that is, through an agreement between the competent authorities, whereas the first stage takes place exclusively in the State of residence (except in cases where the procedure concerning the application of paragraph 1 of Article 24 is initiated by a taxpayer in the State of which that taxpayer is a national), from the time the objection is lodged until the competent authority makes a decision on the matter.
8. In any event, the mutual agreement procedure constitutes a special procedure that operates outside the framework of domestic law. Consequently, it may be used only in the cases provided for in paragraph 1, that is, where tax has been charged or is to be charged notwithstanding the provisions of the Convention. Thus, if the assessment of tax is contrary both to the Convention and to domestic law, the case is considered under the mutual agreement procedure only to the extent that it concerns the Convention, unless there is a connection between the provisions of the Convention and the provisions of domestic law that have been incorrectly applied.
9. In practice, this procedure is applied in cases (which have so far been the most common) where the measure in question results in double taxation that the Convention is specifically intended to eliminate. Among the most frequent cases, the following should be mentioned:
— issues concerning the attribution of profits to a permanent establishment under paragraph 2 of Article 7;
— taxation in the State of the payer — in cases involving special relationships between the payer and the beneficial owner — of the excess portion of interest and royalties in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, paragraph 6 of Article 11 and paragraph [6 of Article 12 of the United Nations Model Convention];
— cases involving the application of thin capitalisation legislation where the State of the debtor company treats interest as dividends to the extent that such treatment is based on treaty provisions, for example, under Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11;
— cases where a lack of information concerning the taxpayer's actual circumstances leads to the incorrect application of the Convention, particularly with regard to the determination of residence (paragraph 2 of Article 4), the existence of a permanent establishment (Article 5) or the temporary nature of services performed by an employee (paragraph 2 of Article 15).
10. Article 25 also provides a mechanism for consultations between the competent authorities with a view to resolving, in the context of transfer pricing problems, issues not only of juridical double taxation but also of economic double taxation, particularly that arising from the inclusion of profits of associated enterprises under paragraph 1 of Article 9; accordingly, corresponding adjustments made under paragraph 2 of the same Article fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure both for the purpose of determining whether they are justified and for determining their amount.
11. This is, in fact, implicit in paragraph 2 of Article 9, where the relevant bilateral convention contains a provision of this kind. If a bilateral convention does not contain provisions similar to those contained in paragraph 2 of Article 9 (which is usually the case with conventions signed before 1977), the mere fact that the Contracting States have included the text of Article 9 in the Convention — limited to paragraph 1, which generally merely confirms broadly similar provisions of domestic law — indicates an intention to extend the application of the Convention to economic double taxation. As a result, most member countries consider that economic double taxation arising from profit adjustments due to transfer pricing is contrary, at the very least, to the spirit of the Convention and is subject to consideration under the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25.
12. While the mutual agreement procedure has a clear role in resolving issues arising in connection with the types of adjustments referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 9, even in the absence of such a provision, States should endeavour to avoid double taxation, including by granting corresponding adjustments in the cases provided for in paragraph 2. Notwithstanding the possibility of certain differences in positions, States should generally consider a case brought by a taxpayer who has initiated the mutual agreement procedure on the basis of economic double taxation in breach of the provisions of Article 9 as including questions as to whether a corresponding adjustment should be granted even in the absence of a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 9. However, States that do not share this view generally find ways in practice to eliminate economic double taxation in most cases involving bona fide companies by using provisions of their domestic law.
13. The mutual agreement procedure also applies in the absence of double taxation contrary to the Convention, where the taxation being challenged constitutes a direct violation of a provision contained in the Convention. An example would be a situation in which one State taxes a particular type of income in respect of which the Convention grants the exclusive right to tax to the other State, even if the latter is unable to exercise that right because of a gap in its domestic law. Other examples relate to cases where persons who are nationals of one Contracting State but residents of the other State are subject in that other State to a tax treatment that is discriminatory under the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 24.
14. It should be noted that the mutual agreement procedure, unlike the procedure for considering claims under domestic law, may be initiated by a taxpayer without waiting until the tax that the taxpayer considers to be "not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention" has been collected or until the taxpayer has received a notice requiring payment of such tax. In order to use this procedure, it is sufficient for the taxpayer to establish that "actions in one or both of the Contracting States" will result in such taxation and that such taxation is not merely possible but probable. Such actions mean all acts or decisions, whether legislative or regulatory in nature, irrespective of whether they are of general or individual application, which, as a direct and inevitable consequence, result in the collection from the claimant of tax that is contrary to the provisions of the Convention. Thus, for example, if an amendment to the tax legislation of one Contracting State results in a person receiving a particular type of income being subject to taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, that person may initiate the mutual agreement procedure immediately after such legislative amendments have been made and after the person has received the relevant income or there is a high probability that the person will receive it. Other examples include the filing of a return under a self-assessment system or the active examination of a taxpayer's accounts during an audit, to the extent that either of these events creates a probability of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention (for example, if the self-assessment of a taxpayer's accounts required under the domestic law of a Contracting State, in the event that that State proposes an audit under a regime that does not provide for self-assessment, results in the probability of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention, or if circumstances such as the published positions of a Contracting State or its audit practices create a significant probability that the active examination of certain accounts, such as those of the taxpayer concerned, will lead to proposed assessments resulting in the probability of taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention). Another example may be a case where the transfer pricing legislation of a Contracting State requires a taxpayer to report taxable income in an amount greater than that which would arise if the taxpayer used the actual prices in its transactions with a related party in order to comply with the arm's length principle, and where there are serious doubts as to whether the taxpayer's related party will be able to obtain a corresponding adjustment in the other Contracting State in the absence of the mutual agreement procedure. As indicated by the opening words of paragraph 1, whether or not the actions of one or both Contracting States will result in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention must be determined from the taxpayer's perspective. Although the taxpayer's belief that such taxation will arise must be reasonable and based on facts that can be established, the tax authorities should not refuse to consider a request under paragraph 1 solely on the grounds that they do not consider it to have been established that such taxation will occur (for example, on the basis of domestic legal rules relating to the standard of proof based on the "balance of probabilities").
15. Since the first steps in the mutual agreement procedure may be initiated at the earliest stage on the basis of the mere probability of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention, initiating the procedure in this manner will not be considered to constitute the submission of a case to the competent authority for the purpose of determining the commencement of the [three-year] period referred to in paragraph 5 [of Version B of this Article; see paragraph 8 of the Appendix to this Commentary].
16. In order to be accepted for consideration, objections under paragraph 1 must first satisfy the twofold requirement expressly formulated in that paragraph: as a rule, they must be presented to the competent authority of the State of residence of the taxpayer (except in cases where the procedure for the application of paragraph 1 of Article 24 is initiated by the taxpayer in the State of which that taxpayer is a national); in addition, they must be presented to that authority within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the Convention. The Convention contains no specific rules regarding the form in which objections must be presented. The competent authorities may establish such specific procedures as they consider appropriate [paragraph 22 et seq., under the heading "Need for Cooperation by the Person Making the Request", contain a number of suggestions regarding specific procedures]. If no specific procedure has been established, objections may be presented in the same manner as objections concerning taxes are submitted to the tax authorities of the State concerned.
17. The requirements imposed on a taxpayer in relation to submitting a case for consideration to the competent authorities of the State of which the taxpayer is a resident (except in cases where the taxpayer initiates the procedure for the application of paragraph 1 of Article 24 in the State of which that taxpayer is a national) apply generally, irrespective of whether the tax being challenged is levied in that State or in another State, and irrespective of whether it results in double taxation or not. If the taxpayer transfers his or her residence to another Contracting State after the disputed measure or taxation, the taxpayer must nevertheless submit the objection to the competent authority of the State of which the taxpayer was a resident during the year for which such tax was or should have been collected.
18. However, in the aforementioned case where a person who is a national of one State but a resident of another State lodges a complaint on the grounds that the person has been subjected to an action or taxation that is discriminatory under paragraph 1 of Article 24, it would be more appropriate, for obvious reasons, to allow that person, as an exception to the general rule set out above, to submit the objection to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which that person is a national. Finally, an objection must also be submitted to that same competent authority by a person who, without being a resident of a Contracting State, is a national of a Contracting State and whose case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24.
19. On the other hand, the Contracting States may, if they consider it preferable, grant taxpayers the right to submit their case to the competent authority of either of the States. In this case, paragraph 1 should be amended as follows:
1. Where a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result or will result for that person in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, that person may, irrespective of the remedies provided by the domestic law of those States, present the case to the competent authority of either Contracting State. The case must be presented within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention.
20. The three-year time limit established in the second sentence of paragraph 1 for the submission of claims is intended to protect the administrative authorities against late claims. This time limit should be regarded as a minimum, so that the Contracting States are free to agree in their bilateral conventions on a longer period in the interests of taxpayers, for example by analogy with the time limit established in their domestic regulations concerning tax conventions. The Contracting States may omit the second sentence of paragraph 1 if they agree that their domestic regulations automatically apply to such objections and better take account of the interests of the taxpayers concerned, either because they provide for a longer period for submitting claims or because they impose no time limits.
21. The provision establishing the starting point for calculating the three-year limitation period from the date of the "first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention" should be interpreted in the manner most favourable to the taxpayer. Consequently, even if such tax is to be levied directly pursuant to an administrative decision or action of general application, the limitation period begins to run from the date of notification of the individual action that results in such taxation, that is, under the most favourable interpretation, from the actual tax assessment, as confirmed by a notice of assessment, an official demand or another document relating to the collection or payment of such tax. Since a taxpayer has the right to initiate a case as soon as the taxpayer considers that the tax action will result in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, whereas the three-year limitation period begins to run only upon the actual occurrence of the result, there may be cases where the taxpayer is entitled to initiate the mutual agreement procedure before the commencement of that three-year limitation period (see examples of such a situation in paragraph 14 above).
22. In most cases, it is quite clear what constitutes the relevant notice of assessment, official demand or other document relating to the collection or levy of such tax, and there are generally rules of domestic law governing the point in time at which such a notice is deemed to have been "served". Such domestic legislation generally focuses on the time when the notice is sent (the time of dispatch), a specified number of days after it has been sent or the time when it may normally be expected to arrive at the address (both of which constitute presumed times of physical receipt), or the time of its actual physical receipt (the time of actual physical receipt). In the absence of such rules, either the time of actual physical receipt or, where there is no adequate evidence, the time when the notice would normally be expected to arrive at the specified address should be regarded as the time of notification, bearing in mind that this provision should be interpreted in the manner most favourable to the taxpayer.
23. In the case of self-assessment, some form of notice affecting the self-assessment is usually issued (such as notices of liability, refusal or adjustment of a claim for a tax refund), and the starting point for the three-year period will generally be considered to be the time of notification rather than the time when the taxpayer files the self-assessment return. Nevertheless, there may be cases where no notice of liability or similar document is issued. In such cases, the appropriate time of "notification" will be the time when the taxpayer would, in the normal course of events, be considered to have become aware of the taxation that is in fact not in accordance with the Convention. This may occur, for example, when information recording the transfer of funds is first provided to the taxpayer, for instance in an account balance or bank statement. The limitation period begins to run irrespective of whether or not the taxpayer considers at that stage that the taxation is contrary to the Convention, provided that a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position would have been able at that stage to conclude that the taxation was not in accordance with the Convention. In such cases, notification to the taxpayer of the mere fact of taxation is sufficient. If, however, it is only the combination of the self-assessment with certain other circumstances that might lead a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position to conclude that the taxation in question is contrary to the Convention (for example, a court decision in a case similar to that of the taxpayer providing that the taxation is contrary to the provisions of the Convention), the limitation period begins to run only when the last circumstance materialises.
24. Where tax is levied by withholding at source, the limitation period begins to run from the time when the income is paid; however, if the taxpayer proves that the taxpayer became aware of the withholding at a later date, the limitation period will run from that date. Furthermore, if taxation not in accordance with the Convention is caused by a combination of decisions or actions taken in both Contracting States, the limitation period begins to run only from the first notification of the later decision or action. This means that, for example, where one Contracting State levies tax that is not in accordance with the Convention, but the other State grants an exemption from such tax under Article 23A or Article 23B, as a result of which there is no double taxation, the taxpayer will in practice often not initiate the mutual agreement procedure in respect of the action of the first State. If, however, the other State subsequently notifies the taxpayer that the tax exemption has been denied, thereby giving rise to double taxation, a new limitation period begins to run from that notification, since the combined actions of both States in this case result in the taxpayer being subject to double taxation contrary to the provisions of the Convention. In some cases, particularly those of this type, records maintained by the tax authorities may, in the ordinary course, be destroyed before the expiry of the limitation period in accordance with the usual practice of one or both States. The obligations under the Convention do not prevent such destruction of records or require the competent authority to accept the taxpayer's arguments without evidence, but in such cases the taxpayer should be given the opportunity to provide the missing supporting evidence as the mutual agreement procedure progresses, to the extent permitted by domestic law. In some cases, the other Contracting State may be able to provide sufficient supporting evidence under Article 26 of the Model Tax Convention. It is certainly preferable for tax authorities to retain such records throughout the entire period during which the taxpayer may submit a request to initiate the mutual agreement procedure in respect of a particular matter.
25. The three-year period continues to run during any judicial proceedings (including administrative proceedings) under domestic law (for example, in the context of domestic appeal proceedings). This may create difficulties because the taxpayer is effectively placed in a position of having to choose between domestic law and the remedies available under the mutual agreement procedure. Some taxpayers may rely solely on the mutual agreement procedure, but many taxpayers attempt to overcome these difficulties by initiating the mutual agreement procedure while simultaneously commencing proceedings under domestic law, even where domestic proceedings were not initially being actively pursued. This may lead to an inefficient use of the resources of the mutual agreement procedure. Where domestic law permits, some States may wish to address this problem directly by allowing the three-year (or longer) period to be suspended during domestic proceedings. Two approaches, each of which is consistent with Article 25, are: on the one hand, requiring the taxpayer to initiate the mutual agreement procedure without suspending the time limit during domestic proceedings, while the competent authorities should not enter into negotiations on the merits until a final domestic judicial decision has been rendered; or, on the other hand, allowing the competent authorities to enter into negotiations, but without the right to conclude a final agreement until the taxpayer agrees to withdraw the domestic action. This second possibility is discussed in paragraph 42 of this Commentary. In either case, the taxpayer should be informed that one or the other of the aforementioned approaches applies. Irrespective of whether or not the taxpayer considers it necessary to lodge a "protective" appeal under domestic law (for example, because of domestic limitation rules governing the initiation of domestic proceedings), it is often preferable for all parties to adopt an approach under which the mutual agreement procedure is given initial priority in resolving taxpayers' problems and such matters are dealt with on a bilateral basis.
26. Some States may deny a taxpayer the right to initiate the mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 25 in cases where the transactions to which the request relates are considered abusive. This issue is closely related to the issue of "improper use of the Convention", which is discussed [in paragraph 8 et seq. of the Commentary on Article 1 of the United Nations Model Convention]. However, in the absence of a specific provision, there is no general rule denying access to the mutual agreement procedure in cases of alleged abuse. The mere fact that a tax assessment is made under a provision of domestic law aimed at preventing tax avoidance should not be a reason for prohibiting access to the mutual agreement procedure. However, in cases where serious violations of domestic law have occurred, resulting in significant penalties, some States may wish to deny access to the mutual agreement procedure. The circumstances in which a State will deny access to the mutual agreement procedure should be clearly set out in the Convention.⁵⁰
50 The word "shall" appears in the 2017 OECD Convention, even though the remainder of the paragraph is taken from the Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Tax Convention. See also paragraph 2 above regarding access to the mutual agreement procedure where the Convention includes paragraph 3 of Article 9 of the United Nations Model Convention [this footnote does not form part of the OECD paragraph being quoted].
Paragraph 27 of the OECD Commentary on Article 25 is relevant to the following:
- Some States, by virtue of provisions of their constitutional or other domestic law or judicial decisions, consider certain issues to be incapable of being resolved through the mutual agreement procedure in general and, in particular, through the mutual agreement procedure initiated by the taxpayer. An example would be where granting tax relief to a taxpayer would be contrary to a final court decision which the tax authority is required to comply with under the constitution of that State. Nevertheless, it is a generally recognised principle of tax and other treaties that domestic law, even domestic constitutional rules, does not justify failure to fulfil treaty obligations. Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties reflects this general principle of treaty law. It follows that any justification for an action which would otherwise constitute a breach of the Convention must be contained in the provisions of the Convention itself and interpreted in accordance with the generally accepted principles of interpretation of tax treaties. Such justification will be encountered relatively rarely, since it will not merely regulate how the issue is to be resolved by the two States once the matter has actually been taken up under the mutual agreement procedure, but will instead prevent a particular case from even reaching the stage at which it must be considered by both States. Since such a determination may in practice be made by one of the States without consultation with the other State, and since there may consequently be a bilateral solution which is not considered, it is considered that a case brought under a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure should not be dismissed lightly and that such a case requires support from provisions of the Convention agreed upon through negotiations. A competent authority relying on restrictions under domestic law as a reason for not granting access to a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure is required to inform the other competent authority thereof and duly explain the legal basis for its position. In most cases, actual domestic legislative obstacles do not prevent a case from proceeding under the mutual agreement procedure, but where they are capable of clearly and unambiguously preventing the competent authority from resolving the case in such a way as to avoid taxation of the taxpayer that is not in accordance with the Convention, and the other State has no realistic chance of resolving the issue in favour of the taxpayer, the situation should then be made public so that taxpayers do not have false expectations regarding the possible outcomes of this procedure.
The Commentary on the OECD Model Tax Convention further states the following:
- In other cases, the initiation of a mutual agreement procedure may be permitted, but domestic legal obstacles may arise because treaty negotiations may prevent the competent authority from resolving, even partially, the issue raised by the taxpayer. Where such circumstances have a legally restrictive effect on the competent authority in the sense that bilateral negotiations are clearly incapable of resolving the issue, most States will regard this change in circumstances as sufficiently significant to permit the competent authority to discontinue the procedure. In some cases, however, the difficulties may be only temporary, for example, during the period before corrective legislation is adopted, in which case the procedure should be suspended rather than terminated. The two competent authorities need to discuss the difficulties that have arisen and their possible impact on the mutual agreement procedure. There may also be situations where a decision rendered wholly or partly in favour of the taxpayer is binding and its implementation must be supervised by one of the competent authorities, but where there is still scope for discussion under the mutual agreement procedure, for example, on an issue such as the submission by one competent authority to the other of evidence that the latter authority should grant tax relief.
- There are fewer grounds for invoking domestic law as a reason for failing to implement an agreement reached under the mutual agreement procedure. The obligation to implement such agreements is expressly stated in the last sentence of paragraph 2, and any existing obstacles to such implementation must be included in the terms of the agreement itself. Since tax treaty negotiations are conducted against the background of a changing body of domestic law, and such changes are sometimes difficult to predict, and since both parties understand this when negotiating the initial version of the Convention and reaching mutual agreements, subsequent unexpected changes that alter the fundamental basis of the mutual agreement procedure will generally be regarded as requiring the agreement to be revised to the extent necessary. Clearly, where such a change in domestic legislation occurs, which is relatively rare, good faith performance of obligations requires that notification thereof be given as soon as possible and that good faith efforts be made to reach a revised or new mutual agreement to the extent permitted by the newly adopted domestic legislation. In such cases, the taxpayer's request should be treated as a continuing request rather than as a new application for the procedure requested by that person.
- As regards the procedure itself, it is necessary to briefly consider the two separate stages of which it consists (see paragraph 7 above).
- At the first stage, which begins with the submission of the taxpayer's objection, the procedure takes place exclusively at the level of relations between the taxpayer and the competent authorities of the State in which the taxpayer is resident (except where the procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 24 is initiated by the taxpayer in the State of which he is a national). The provisions of paragraph 1 give the taxpayer the right to apply to the competent authority of the State of which he is a resident, regardless of whether he has exhausted all the remedies available to him under the domestic law of each of the two Contracting States. On the other hand, the competent authority is required to decide whether the objection is justified and, if it considers it to be justified, to take action in one of the two forms provided for in paragraph 2.
- If the competent authority, having duly received the claim, recognises that it is justified and considers that the taxation complained of has arisen, wholly or partly, as a result of a measure taken in the State of residence of the taxpayer, it should, where possible, satisfy the taxpayer's claim without delay by making such adjustments or granting such relief as it considers justified. In such a situation, the matter may be resolved without using the mutual agreement procedure. On the other hand, it may consider it necessary to exchange views and information with the competent authority of the other Contracting State in order, for example, to obtain confirmation of its interpretation of the Convention.
- If, however, the competent authority considers that the taxation complained of has arisen wholly or partly as a result of a measure taken in the other State, it will be required — as is clearly apparent from the provisions of paragraph 2 — to initiate the mutual agreement procedure. It is important that the authority fulfil this obligation as soon as possible, particularly in cases where the profits of associated enterprises have been adjusted as a result of a transfer pricing adjustment.
- The taxpayer has the right to submit his case for consideration under paragraph 1 to the competent authority of the State of which he is a resident, regardless of whether he has also brought an action or initiated judicial proceedings under the domestic law of that State. If judicial proceedings are pending, the competent authority of the State of residence should not wait for their final determination, but should respond as to whether it considers the case acceptable for consideration under the mutual agreement procedure. If it decides that the case is acceptable, it should determine whether it can itself reach a satisfactory solution or whether the case should be referred to the competent authority of the other Contracting State. The taxpayer's application for the initiation of a mutual agreement procedure may not be rejected without compelling reasons.
- Even if the action has been finally adjudicated by a court in the State of residence, the taxpayer may still have recourse to the mutual agreement procedure or continue with it. In some States, the competent authority may reach a satisfactory solution which differs from the court's decision. In other States, the competent authority is bound by the court decision. Nevertheless, it may refer the case to the competent authority of the other Contracting State, requesting the latter to take measures with a view to avoiding double taxation.
- At the second stage, which begins when the competent authority to which the taxpayer applied approaches the competent authority of the other State, the procedure takes place at the level of relations between the States, as if the State to which the claim was submitted had supported it. However, although this procedure is undoubtedly a procedure between States, the following questions may be raised:
— do the title of the Article and the terms used in the first sentence of paragraph 2 imply merely a simple mutual agreement procedure or the implementation of a pactum de contrahendo, imposing on the parties only an obligation to negotiate, but in no way obliging them to reach agreement;
— or, on the contrary, should it be regarded (on the basis [in the case of alternative B of this Article] of the existence of the arbitration procedure provided for in paragraph 5 [of that alternative], for the purpose of resolving unresolved issues, or on the assumption that this procedure takes place within a joint commission) as a procedure of a judicial nature, imposing on the parties an obligation to resolve the dispute.
- There is no doubt that paragraph 2 provides for an obligation to negotiate; however, as regards reaching mutual agreement through this procedure, the competent authorities are only required to make every effort, and not to achieve a result. Paragraph 5 [of alternative B], however, provides a mechanism which makes it possible to reach agreement even if there are issues on which the competent authorities have been unable to agree through negotiations.
- In seeking mutual agreement, the competent authorities must first determine their positions in light of the rules of their respective tax laws and the provisions of the Convention, which are binding on them in the same way as they are binding on the taxpayer. If strict compliance with such rules or provisions prevents agreement from being reached, it may reasonably be assumed that the competent authorities, by analogy with international arbitration, are entitled to take considerations of equity into account in order to satisfy the taxpayer's claims.
The Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Tax Convention further states the following:
38.1 The combination of bilateral tax conventions concluded between several States may allow the competent authorities of those States to resolve multilateral cases by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of those conventions. A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either through negotiations on a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or through negotiations on separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
38.2 This may, for example, be the case for determining the appropriate allocation of profits between permanent establishments which an enterprise has in two different States with which the State of residence of the enterprise has tax conventions. In such a case, an adjustment made in respect of transactions between two permanent establishments may affect the taxation of the enterprise in its State of residence. On the basis of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of the tax conventions between the State of residence of the enterprise and the States in which the permanent establishments are located, the competent authority of the State of residence of the enterprise clearly has the authority to seek to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authorities of the States in which the permanent establishments are located and to determine the appropriate attribution of profits to the permanent establishments of its resident in accordance with both tax conventions. If the tax conventions between the State of residence of the enterprise and the States in which the permanent establishments are located contain different versions of Article 7 (for example, the version included in the 2010 OECD Model Tax Convention in one convention and the previous version of Article 7 in another convention), the competent authorities may take into account considerations of equity, as mentioned in paragraph 38 above, in order to find an appropriate solution with a view to ensuring taxation in accordance with the provisions of the applicable conventions.
38.3 This may, for example, be the case where a number of associated enterprises resident in different States are involved in a series of integrated controlled transactions, and bilateral tax treaties exist between the States of residence of all the enterprises. Such a series of integrated controlled transactions may exist, for example, where intellectual property is licensed in a controlled transaction between two members of a multinational enterprise (MNE) group and is then used by the licensee to manufacture goods sold by the licensee to other members of the MNE group. On the basis of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of these tax conventions, the competent authorities of the States of residence of these enterprises clearly have the authority to seek to determine the appropriate commercial transfer prices for the controlled transactions in accordance with the arm's length principle of Article 9.
38.4 As recognised in paragraph 55 below, in the multilateral case described in paragraph 38.2, paragraph 3 of Article 25 of the tax convention between the States in which the Convention is effectively implemented and double taxation which may arise in such a situation is appropriately eliminated.
38.5 The desire for certainty may lead taxpayers to seek multilateral advance pricing agreements ("APAs") in order to determine in advance the transfer pricing of controlled transactions between associated enterprises resident in several States. Where bilateral tax conventions exist between all these States and it appears that the actions of at least one of these States may result in taxation of the taxpayer not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, Article 25 of these conventions allows the competent authorities of these States to negotiate on a multilateral basis an appropriate set of criteria for determining the transfer pricing of controlled transactions. A multilateral APA may be achieved either through negotiations on a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or through negotiations on separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
The Commentary on the 2014 OECD Model Tax Convention further states the following:
- The purpose of the last sentence of paragraph 2 is to allow countries whose domestic law provides for time limits on the adjustment of tax assessments and the refund of tax paid to implement the agreement reached notwithstanding such time limits. However, this provision does not prevent States which, for constitutional reasons or on other legal grounds, cannot override the time limits provided for in domestic law from including in the agreement itself such time limits as are adapted to their domestic limitation periods. In some exceptional cases, a Contracting State may prefer not to adopt such an agreement where its implementation would require disregarding domestic limitation periods. Apart from time limits, other obstacles to the implementation of an agreed solution may also arise, such as a "final court decision". Contracting States are free to include explicit provisions removing such obstacles. As regards the practical implementation of the procedure, tax authorities are generally encouraged to make every effort to ensure that, in any event, implementation of a solution reached through the mutual agreement procedure is not frustrated as a result of delays or, where time limits apply, as a result of the combination of time limits and delays.
- The Committee on Fiscal Affairs has made a number of recommendations concerning problems arising in connection with the corresponding adjustment of profits as a result of transfer pricing adjustments (implementation of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 9), as well as difficulties associated with the application of the mutual agreement procedure in such situations:
a) tax authorities should notify taxpayers as soon as possible of their intention to make a transfer pricing adjustment (and, if the date of such notification is relevant, ensure that a clear formal notification is provided as soon as possible), since it is particularly important to ensure the earliest possible and fullest contacts on all relevant issues between tax authorities and taxpayers within the same jurisdiction and internationally between associated enterprises and the relevant tax authorities;
b) competent authorities should communicate with each other on these matters by all possible means — in writing, by telephone or through personal meetings of representatives, round-table meetings, as they consider most convenient — and seek to develop the most effective ways of resolving the relevant issues. The use of the provisions of Article 26 on the exchange of information should be encouraged in order to assist competent authorities in obtaining detailed factual information on the basis of which a decision may be made;
c) in the course of a mutual agreement procedure concerning transfer pricing issues, the taxpayers concerned should be given all reasonable opportunities to present relevant facts and arguments to the competent authorities, both in writing and orally.
- With regard to the mutual agreement procedure in general, the Committee recommended the following:
a) formalities connected with the initiation and conduct of the mutual agreement procedure should be kept to a minimum, and unnecessary formalities should be eliminated;
b) each case considered under the mutual agreement procedure should be decided specifically on its merits, without reference to the outcomes of other cases;
c) where appropriate, competent authorities should formulate and publish domestic rules, principles and procedures concerning the application of the mutual agreement procedure.
- Finally, it may happen that a mutual agreement procedure is conducted in respect of a taxpayer who has brought an action concerning the same matter before a competent court of one of the Contracting States, and that action has not yet been decided. In such a case, there is no reason to reject the taxpayer's request to defer implementation of the solution agreed upon as a result of the mutual agreement procedure until the court has rendered its decision on that action.51 [One member of the Committee, however, considers that the taxpayer should not be allowed to defer approval of the outcome of the mutual agreement procedure until the court has rendered its decision on the action. Once the competent authorities have reached an agreement, the taxpayer should decide within a reasonable period of time whether to approve the outcome of that agreement.] Furthermore, the competent authorities may reasonably take the position that, where the taxpayer's action concerning a particular aspect, on the facts of which the same taxpayer is requesting a mutual agreement procedure, is still pending, any substantive discussion at the level of the competent authorities should be deferred until the court has ruled. If the taxpayer's request for a mutual agreement procedure relates to tax years other than those covered by the court action but, in substance, concerns the same factual and legal issues, with the result that the court decision may be expected in practice to affect the taxpayer's treatment for those years which are not specifically the subject of the judicial proceedings, the position in practice may be the same as in the case just mentioned. In any event, waiting for a court decision or otherwise suspending the mutual agreement procedure for the duration of formal judicial proceedings under domestic law of appeal will not constitute a breach and will not cause the expiry of [the three-year period referred to in paragraph 5 of alternative B of this Article]. Clearly, if the competent authorities consider in any of the cases mentioned that the matter can be resolved independently of the domestic judicial proceedings (for example, because the competent authority in the State where the proceedings are taking place is not required to comply with the court decision and is not bound by it), the mutual agreement procedure may proceed in the normal manner.
51 As noted in paragraph 45, however, in most countries the mutual agreement procedure cannot be concluded until the taxpayer has given his consent to it and waived domestic remedies. If the taxpayer decides to wait until the domestic judicial proceedings have been completed, there is a risk that the court decision will prevent the competent authority from implementing the proposed agreement and the taxpayer cannot be guaranteed that the proposed agreement will still be available at the conclusion of the judicial proceedings [this footnote does not form part of the OECD paragraph being quoted].
- A different situation arises in the case of ongoing judicial proceedings brought by another taxpayer rather than by the taxpayer requesting the initiation of a mutual agreement procedure. In principle, if the case of the taxpayer requesting the mutual agreement procedure supports action by one or both competent authorities to prevent taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, such action should not be unduly delayed until the law has been generally clarified in the case of another taxpayer, notwithstanding the fact that the taxpayer requesting the mutual agreement procedure may agree to such a delay if such clarification is highly likely to support that taxpayer's case. In other cases, a delay in discussions by the competent authorities under the mutual agreement procedure may be justified in any event, but in such a case the competent authorities should, to the extent possible, seek to prevent adverse developments for the taxpayer. This may be achieved, where permitted by domestic law, by deferring payment of the tax liability during the period of delay in consideration or at least during that part of the period of delay which is beyond the taxpayer's control.
- Depending on domestic procedures, the choice of the method of redress is generally left to the taxpayer and in most cases this involves domestic remedies, such as an appeal to a court or judicial proceedings, which are deferred in favour of the less formal and bilateral mutual agreement procedure.
- As noted above, during the consideration of an action concerning the matter or otherwise, the taxpayer may retain the right to bring such domestic judicial actions, although the competent authorities may still consider that an agreement can be reached. In such cases, however, the comments of either competent authority must be taken into account in order to avoid any discrepancies or contradictions between the court decision and the outcome of the requested mutual agreement procedure, as well as to avoid difficulties or risks of abuse which such discrepancies may entail. Thus, in summary, the implementation of such a mutual agreement should generally be conditional upon:
— the taxpayer's acceptance of the agreed solution; and
— the taxpayer's withdrawal of the court proceedings concerning the issues already resolved under the mutual agreement procedure.
- Some States take the view that a mutual agreement procedure cannot be initiated by a taxpayer until all or part of the disputed tax has been paid. They consider that the requirement to pay tax arrears, which may be fully or partially refunded depending on the outcome of the procedure, is essentially a procedural matter which is not governed by Article 25 and therefore does not constitute a violation thereof. The opposing view, held by many States, is that Article 25 specifies all the actions that a taxpayer must take before the procedure begins and that it does not impose such a requirement. These States find support for their position in the fact that the procedure may be carried out even before the taxpayer is assessed to tax or notified of tax liability (as noted in paragraph 14 above), as well as in the recognition that there is certainly no such requirement in respect of a procedure initiated by the competent authority pursuant to paragraph 3.
The Commentary on the 2017 OECD Model Tax Convention further states the following:
- Article 25 does not provide an entirely clear answer to the question of whether access to a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure may be denied on the grounds that all or part of the disputed tax has not been paid. However, regardless of the position taken on this issue, in applying this Article it should be borne in mind that the mutual agreement procedure ensures the implementation of the substantive provisions of the Convention, that the text of Article 25 should be understood in this context, and that it should also be interpreted in light of the object and purpose of the Convention, including the elimination of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion and tax avoidance.
47.1 Unlike disputes which concern exclusively the application of the domestic law of a Contracting State, disputes resolved through the mutual agreement procedure will in most cases concern double taxation. Therefore, States should, to the extent possible, take cash flow considerations into account when requiring advance payment of an amount which the taxpayer claims has been collected, at least in part, contrary to the provisions of the relevant Convention. Even if the mutual agreement procedure ultimately eliminates any double taxation or other taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, requiring payment of the tax before the conclusion of the mutual agreement procedure may permanently deprive the taxpayer of the time value of money represented by the amount unlawfully collected for the period preceding the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, at least in the relatively common case where the interest policies of the Contracting States concerned do not fully compensate the taxpayer for these costs. Thus, this means that in such cases the mutual agreement procedure will not achieve its objective of fully eliminating, as an economic matter, the burden of double taxation or other taxation not in accordance with the Convention. Moreover, even if this economic burden is ultimately eliminated, requiring the taxpayer to pay tax on the same income to two Contracting States may impose a cash flow burden that is incompatible with the objectives of the Convention to eliminate barriers to cross-border trade and investment. At a minimum, payment of unpaid tax should not be a requirement for initiating a mutual agreement procedure if it is not a requirement before initiating a domestic law review. States may wish to expressly provide for this in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
The suspension of tax assessment and collection procedures during the consideration of any mutual agreement procedure shall be available on the same terms as those applicable to a person using domestic administrative or judicial remedies.
Furthermore, as a minimum requirement, it appears that where a mutual agreement procedure is initiated before tax has been assessed in respect of the taxpayer (for example, pursuant to a tax assessment), a payment demand should be issued only upon such assessment of tax.
- For the reasons described in the preceding paragraph, the suspension of tax collection until the conclusion of the mutual agreement procedure may be a desirable policy. Moreover, requiring payment of the assessed tax as a specific condition for access to the mutual agreement procedure, in order to obtain relief specifically from that tax, is generally incompatible with the policy of ensuring broad access to the mutual agreement procedure for the resolution of such disputes. Another unfortunate consequence of such a requirement may be delays in the resolution of cases if a country is less inclined to engage in good faith discussions under the mutual agreement procedure where the likely outcome may be the refund of taxes already collected. In many States, the suspension of tax assessment and/or collection until the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure may require legislative changes for its implementation. States may also wish to expressly provide for the suspension of tax assessment and collection procedures in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
Tax assessment and collection procedures shall be suspended during the period in which any mutual agreement procedure is under consideration.
In connection with any suspension of tax collection until the conclusion of the mutual agreement procedure, it is important to recall the existence of conservancy measures in respect of taxes under paragraph 4 of Article 27.
48.1 Since there may be significant differences in the procedures for tax assessment and collection under the domestic laws of the Contracting States, it may be important to examine during bilateral negotiations how these procedures will operate in each State before the mutual agreement procedure is resolved, in order to remove any obstacles that such procedures may present to the effective implementation of the Article. If States take the position that payment of tax arrears is a precondition for conducting a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure, this should be brought to the attention of the treaty partner during negotiations on the terms of the Convention. If both States parties to the Convention hold this view, there is unity of position, but there is also a particular risk that the taxpayer may be required to pay the amount twice. Where permitted by domestic law, one option for States to consider in addressing this problem is to place the larger of the two amounts in a trust, escrow or similar bank account until the conclusion of the mutual agreement procedure. An alternative option, which may be sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the competent authorities, may be the provision of a bank guarantee by the taxpayer's bank. As another approach, one State or the other (based, for example, on the timing of the tax assessment or on the status of residence of the State under the treaty) may agree to require payment of an amount not exceeding the difference between the amount paid in the other State and the amount being collected by the first State, if any. Which of these options is available will ultimately depend on the domestic law (including administrative requirements) of the State concerned, but these options should, to the extent possible, be considered in order to ensure the most effective conduct of the mutual agreement procedure. If States require payment of tax arrears as a precondition for conducting a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure or for actively considering the disputed issue under that procedure, they should have effective systems in place for refunding interest on any principal amount that is to be refunded to the taxpayer as a result of a mutual agreement reached by the competent authorities. Any such interest payment should adequately reflect the value of the principal amount and the period during which that amount was unavailable to the taxpayer.
- Paragraph 4 of the Commentary on Article 2 explains that, although most States do not consider interest and administrative penalties related to taxes covered by Article 2 to fall within the scope of that Article, where such interest and administrative penalties are directly related to taxes covered by Article 2, they should be appropriately reduced or cancelled to the same extent that the underlying covered tax is reduced or not charged pursuant to the mutual agreement procedure. Accordingly, a Contracting State which has imposed interest or an administrative penalty calculated by reference to the underlying tax liability (or by reference to some other amount relevant to the determination of the tax, such as the amount of an adjustment or the amount of taxable income), and which subsequently agrees under a mutual agreement procedure pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 to reduce or cancel that underlying tax liability, should proportionately reduce or cancel such interest or administrative penalty.
49.1 Conversely, other administrative penalties (for example, a penalty for failure to comply with proper transfer pricing documentation requirements) may concern matters of compliance with domestic law which are not directly related to the tax liability that is the subject of the request for a mutual agreement procedure. Such administrative penalties generally do not fall within the scope of the procedure under paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article. However, pursuant to paragraph 3 of Article 25, the competent authorities may hold joint consultations and agree in a particular case that a penalty not directly related to taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention was not, or is no longer, justified. For example, if an administrative penalty for negligence, intentional conduct or fraud was imposed as a fixed amount, and it was subsequently established during a mutual agreement procedure that there was no fraudulent intent, intentional conduct or negligence, the competent authorities may agree that the Contracting State which imposed such penalty will cancel it. Pursuant to paragraph 3 of the Article, the competent authorities may also conclude a general mutual agreement under which they will seek, through the mutual agreement procedure, to resolve in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 issues relating to interest and administrative penalties which give rise to difficulties or doubts concerning the application of the Convention. Contracting States may, if they consider it preferable, expressly provide in paragraph 2 of Article 25 for the application of this paragraph to interest and administrative penalties in cases of mutual agreement procedures submitted pursuant to paragraph 1, by adding the following as a second sentence:
The competent authorities shall also endeavour to agree on the application of domestic law provisions concerning interest and administrative penalties relating to the case under consideration.
49.2 Criminal penalties imposed by a prosecutor or a court generally do not fall within the mutual agreement procedure. In many States, the competent authorities have no authority to mitigate or cancel such penalties.
49.3 A mutual agreement often results in the tax liability being maintained in one Contracting State, while the other Contracting State is required to refund all or part of the tax it has collected. In such cases, the taxpayer may bear a significant economic burden if there are differences between the two Contracting States in the rules governing the accrual of interest on tax liabilities and refunds. This will be the case, for example, where the first Contracting State charges late payment interest on the tax that was the subject of the request for a mutual agreement procedure, while the second Contracting State does not pay interest on the overpayment in respect of the amount it is required to refund to the taxpayer. Therefore, Contracting States should seek to adopt flexible approaches to granting relief from interest associated with the tax liability that is the subject of the request for a mutual agreement procedure. Relief from interest would be particularly appropriate during the period in which the taxpayer is undergoing the mutual agreement procedure, bearing in mind that the amount of time required to resolve a case through such a procedure is largely beyond the taxpayer's control. Amendments to the domestic law of a Contracting State may be required to enable the competent authority to grant relief from interest as provided for under the mutual agreement procedure.
49.4 The purpose of the Convention on the avoidance of double taxation and the requirement for States to perform the provisions of the Convention in good faith imply that interest and penalties should not be charged in a manner that seriously discourages taxpayers from initiating a mutual agreement procedure because of the costs and cash flow impact that this would entail. Interest and administrative penalties should not be applied in such a way as to seriously hinder or prevent a taxpayer from taking advantage of the benefits of the Convention, including the right to initiate a mutual agreement procedure as provided for in Article 25. For example, a State's requirements concerning payment of outstanding interest and penalties should not be more burdensome for taxpayers in the context of a mutual agreement procedure than they would be in the context of a taxpayer-initiated review under domestic law.
Paragraph 3 of Article 25 (alternatives A and B)
- This paragraph reproduces Article 25, paragraph 3, of the OECD Model Convention. The Committee considers that the following part of the 2017 OECD Commentary is applicable to this paragraph:
- The first sentence of this paragraph proposes and grants the competent authorities the right to resolve, as far as possible, difficulties arising in connection with the interpretation or application of the Convention through the mutual agreement procedure. These are mostly difficulties of a general nature which concern or may concern a particular category of taxpayers, even if they arise in connection with a specific case, generally one that is subject to consideration under the procedure referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2.
- This provision makes it possible to resolve difficulties arising in connection with the application of the Convention. Such difficulties are not only practical in nature and may not be limited to the initiation and conduct of a procedure concerning tax relief on dividends, interest and royalties in the Contracting State in which they arise, but may also prevent or hinder the normal application of the provisions of the Convention in accordance with the intentions of the negotiators, while the resolution of such problems does not depend on a prior agreement concerning the interpretation of the Convention.
- Under this provision, the competent authorities may, in particular:
— in order to avoid any difficulties, supplement or clarify the definition of terms which have been defined incompletely or ambiguously in the Convention;
— where the legislation of either State has changed without prejudice to the general meaning or affecting the substance of the Convention, resolve any difficulties that may arise from the new tax system resulting from such changes;
— determine whether and under what conditions interest may be treated as dividends under the thin capitalisation rules of the borrowing country and whether it may give rise to relief for the avoidance of double taxation in the State of residence of the lender in the same way as dividends (for example, relief under a parent-subsidiary regime, where a provision for such relief is contained in the relevant bilateral convention);
— conclude bilateral advance pricing agreements (APAs), as well as multilateral APAs with the competent authorities of third States with which each of the Contracting States has concluded a bilateral tax convention, in cases where difficulties or doubts arise in connection with the interpretation or application of the provisions of the conventions (especially in cases where no action by the Contracting States may result in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the convention). A multilateral APA may be concluded either through negotiations on a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or through negotiations on separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements;
— determine the appropriate procedures, conditions and methods for applying paragraphs 1 and 2, as well as the second sentence of this paragraph, to multilateral cases (see paragraphs 38.1–38.5 above and paragraphs 55–55.2 below) and for the participation of third States in the mutual agreement procedure where the resolution of a case may affect, or be affected by, taxation in third States.
- Paragraph 3 confers on the "competent authorities of the Contracting States", that is, generally the Ministers of Finance or their authorised representatives, who usually oversee the implementation of the Convention, the authority to resolve through mutual agreement any difficulties arising in connection with the interpretation of the Convention. However, it is important not to overlook the fact that, depending on the domestic law of the Contracting States, bodies other than the "competent authority" specified in the Convention (the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, courts) may also have the authority to interpret international treaties and agreements, and sometimes these other bodies have exclusive authority.
- Jointly agreed solutions resolving general difficulties relating to the interpretation or application of the Convention are binding on the executive authorities until the competent authorities agree to modify or withdraw the agreed solution.
- The second sentence of paragraph 3 also gives the competent authorities the right to consider cases of double taxation which do not fall within the scope of the provisions of the Convention. In this connection, particular interest attaches to cases where a resident of a third State has permanent establishments in both Contracting States. The second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to consult each other for the purpose of eliminating double taxation which may arise in respect of transactions between permanent establishments. This may be the case, for example, where one or both Contracting States do not have a bilateral tax convention with the third State. Where both Contracting States have a convention with the third State, however, the combination of these two conventions may allow the competent authorities of all three States to resolve the case by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of Article 25 of these conventions (see paragraphs 38.2 and 38.4 above). A multilateral agreement between the competent authorities of all the States involved is the best way to ensure that any double taxation can be eliminated.
55.1 The domestic law of some Contracting States may prevent the Convention from being supplemented by provisions which are expressly or at least implicitly not contained in the Convention. In these situations, the Convention may be supplemented by a protocol dealing with this issue. The second sentence of paragraph 3, however, does not allow the Contracting States to eliminate double taxation where the granting of such relief would be contrary to their respective domestic laws or is not authorised by the provisions of other applicable tax treaties. This sentence allows the Contracting States, only in cases not provided for in the Convention, to consult each other for the purpose of eliminating double taxation in accordance with their respective domestic laws or a tax treaty which one of the Contracting States has concluded with a third State. Thus, for example, in the case of a resident of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States, the second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to agree on the facts and circumstances of the case in order to apply their respective domestic tax laws consistently, particularly with respect to any transactions between these permanent establishments; the Contracting States may grant relief from any double taxation of the profits of such permanent establishments, however, only to the extent permitted by their respective domestic laws or by the provisions of a tax treaty concluded between a Contracting State and that third State (i.e. by applying the provisions of Article 7 and Article 23 of the tax treaty between the Contracting State and the third State). As these examples demonstrate, paragraph 3 thus plays a crucial role in allowing the competent authorities to consult with each other to ensure that tax treaties operate in a coordinated and effective manner.
55.2 According to the first sentence of paragraph 3, the competent authorities may agree on a general basis that they will endeavour to resolve a case presented under paragraph 1 with the competent authority of any third State in circumstances where the taxation of income or capital in that third State may be affected by, or may affect, the resolution of the case. Contracting States wishing to make express provision for multilateral mutual agreement procedures may agree to use the following alternative wording of paragraph 2:
2. The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State with a view to the avoidance of taxation which is not in accordance with the Convention. Where the resolution of the case may be affected by, or may affect, the taxation of income or capital in any third State, the competent authorities shall endeavour to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of any such third State, provided that a tax convention is in force between each of the Contracting States and that third State and the competent authority of that third State agrees, within the three-year period provided for in paragraph 1, to consult with the competent authorities of the Contracting States with a view to resolving the case by mutual agreement. In resolving the case, the competent authorities shall take into account the relevant provisions of this Convention together with the relevant provisions of the tax conventions between the Contracting States and any third State participating in the procedure. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits provided for in the domestic laws of the Contracting States.
Paragraph 4 of Article 25 (Alternatives A and B)
11. This paragraph consists of two sentences, the first of which reproduces the first sentence of paragraph 4 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention, whereas the second sentence is not included therein. In the first sentence, the words "including through a joint commission consisting of themselves or their representatives" were inserted in 1999 after the words "communicate with each other directly", in order to bring this provision into line with the provision of the OECD Model Convention. The second sentence allows the competent authorities to develop bilateral procedures for implementing the mutual agreement procedure. Section C below discusses various procedural aspects of the mutual agreement procedure and contains suggestions concerning procedures that may be adopted by the competent authorities. These suggestions are not exhaustive and should be adapted or supplemented on the basis of the experience and particular circumstances of each country. The Committee considers that the following part of the OECD Commentary is applicable to the first sentence of this paragraph:
56. This paragraph determines how the competent authorities may hold mutual consultations for the purpose of resolving by mutual agreement either a particular case falling within the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 or general problems, in particular those relating to the interpretation or application of the Convention, which are referred to in paragraph 3.
57. First of all, it provides that the competent authorities may communicate with each other directly. Consequently, there is no need to resort to diplomatic channels.
58. The competent authorities may communicate with each other by means of exchanges of letters, fax messages, telephone conversations, face-to-face meetings or any other convenient means. They may, if they so wish, formally establish a joint commission for this purpose.
59. As regards such a joint commission, paragraph 4 leaves it to the discretion of the competent authorities of the Contracting States to determine its composition and rules of procedure.
60. However, although the Contracting States may avoid formalities in this matter, they are nevertheless required to provide taxpayers whose cases are submitted for consideration by a joint commission pursuant to paragraph 2 with certain essential guarantees, namely:
— the right to make representations in writing or orally, either personally or through a representative;
— the right to legal assistance.
61. Nevertheless, disclosure by the taxpayer or his representatives of the materials relating to the case does not appear to be justified, having regard to the special nature of this procedure.
62. Without prejudice to the freedom of choice which the competent authorities enjoy in principle when appointing their representatives to the joint commission, it would be desirable for them to agree to entrust the leadership of each delegation (which may consist of one or more representatives of the service authorised to conduct this procedure) to a senior official or a judge selected primarily for his particular expertise; in practice, it is reasonable to assume that the participation of such persons is likely to facilitate the reaching of an agreement.
Paragraph 5 of Article 25 (Alternative B)
12. Paragraph 5, which is found only in Alternative B of this Article, provides for mandatory arbitration, under which the competent authorities are required to submit unresolved issues to arbitration if one of them so requests after they have been unable to resolve those issues within a specified period of time.
13. This paragraph reproduces paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention, with four differences. First, the paragraph provides that arbitration proceedings may be initiated if the competent authorities are unable to reach an agreement on the case within three years from the date on which the case was submitted to them, rather than within two years, as provided for in the OECD Model Convention. Second, whereas the OECD Model Convention provides that arbitration proceedings must be requested by the person who presented the case, paragraph 5 of Alternative B provides that arbitration must be requested by the competent authorities of one of the Contracting States (which means that the case will not be referred to arbitration if the competent authorities of both Contracting States consider that the case is not suitable for arbitration and neither of them makes such a request). Third, paragraph 5 of Alternative B, unlike the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention, allows the competent authorities to depart from the arbitration decision if they agree on a different solution within six months after that decision has been communicated to them. Finally, whereas the provision of the OECD Model Convention provides that the two-year period begins when all the information required by the competent authorities to consider the case under the mutual agreement procedure has been provided, paragraph 5 of Alternative B provides that the three-year period begins on the date on which the case is submitted to the competent authority of the State to which it was not initially presented.
14. For various reasons, some States consider it inappropriate to undertake to resort to arbitration whenever the competent authority of another Contracting State makes such a request. Such States may, however, wish to include in their treaties a provision on voluntary arbitration, under which both competent authorities must agree in each individual case to refer the case to arbitration before the arbitration proceedings begin. The following provision may serve as an example of such an additional paragraph:
If the competent authorities are unable to resolve a case by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraph 2, the case may, with the agreement of the competent authorities and the person who presented the case in accordance with paragraph 2, be submitted to an arbitral tribunal, provided that any person directly affected by the case agrees in writing to be bound by the decision of the arbitral body. If the competent authorities are unable to resolve certain difficulties or doubts by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraph 3, such difficulties or doubts may also, with the agreement of both competent authorities, be submitted to arbitration. The decision of the arbitral body in a particular case shall be binding on both States in respect of that case. Where general questions concerning difficulties in the interpretation or application of the Convention are submitted to arbitration, the decision of the arbitral body shall be binding on the Contracting States until the competent authorities agree to modify or revoke that decision. The competent authorities shall, by mutual agreement, establish the rules of procedure for such arbitration.
15. Voluntary arbitration provides greater control over the types of issues that are referred to arbitration. In certain circumstances, a competent authority may consider it inappropriate to depart from its position on a particular issue and, consequently, inappropriate to submit that issue for consideration by arbitration. In the case of voluntary arbitration, countries retain greater flexibility with respect to the issues submitted for arbitration and may limit the potential number of cases that may be referred to arbitration, as well as reduce the potential costs of arbitration.
16. Nevertheless, in the case of voluntary arbitration, if the competent authority of one Contracting State refuses to depart from its interpretation of the treaty with respect to certain specific issues, that competent authority may also refuse to submit those issues for consideration by arbitration, with the result that those issues may remain unresolved under the mutual agreement procedure. Arbitration proceedings in respect of issues on which the competent authorities cannot agree are necessary to ensure the effective and consistent resolution of treaty disputes in both States. In this regard, arbitration proceedings that may be requested by either of the competent authorities provide greater assurance that unresolved issues will actually be referred to arbitration than a system of voluntary arbitration, under which the consent of both competent authorities is required.
17. Some States that have decided to include Alternative B in their bilateral treaties may prefer to amend paragraph 5 so that unresolved issues are to be submitted to arbitration at the request of the person who presented the case in accordance with paragraph 1. For this purpose, such States may replace the wording "any unresolved issues arising from the case shall be submitted to arbitration if either of the competent authorities so requests. The person who presented the case shall be notified of the request" with the wording "any unresolved issues arising from the case shall be submitted to arbitration if that person so requests".
18. The Committee considers that the following part of the Commentary on paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention, together with the Annex, is applicable to paragraph 5 of Alternative B (additional comments indicated in square brackets, which do not form part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Convention, have been inserted to reflect the differences described in paragraph 13 above):
63. This paragraph provides that where the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement in accordance with paragraph 2 within [three] years, unresolved issues may, at the request of [one of the competent authorities], be resolved by means of an arbitration process. This process is not dependent on prior authorisation by [both] competent authorities; once the necessary procedural requirements have been fulfilled, the unresolved issues preventing mutual agreement must be submitted to arbitration. [The taxpayer may at any time request the competent authority to submit the unresolved issues in his case to arbitration. However, the competent authority is not obliged to do so. It has discretionary powers in each individual case as to whether or not to request arbitration].
64. The arbitration process provided for in this paragraph is not an alternative or additional means of judicial redress: where the competent authorities reach an agreement that leaves no unresolved issues concerning the application of the Convention, there will be no unresolved issues that could be submitted to arbitration, even if the person who initiated the mutual agreement procedure does not consider that the agreement between the competent authorities provides the correct solution to the case. Thus, this paragraph constitutes an extension of the mutual agreement procedure, which serves to increase the effectiveness of that procedure by ensuring that, if the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on one or more issues preventing the resolution of the case, the case may nevertheless be resolved by submitting those issues to arbitration. Consequently, under this paragraph, the case may continue to be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure while a particular issue preventing the resolution of the case may be decided through the arbitration process. This distinguishes the procedure established in paragraph 5 from other forms of commercial arbitration or arbitration between a State and a private party, where the jurisdiction of the arbitral panel extends to the resolution of the entire case.
65. It should be recognised, however, that in some States the type of arbitration process provided for in this paragraph may be unlawful or may be considered inappropriate from the standpoint of domestic law, policy or administrative considerations. For example, there may be constitutional barriers preventing arbitrators from making decisions on tax matters. In addition, some countries may not be able to include this paragraph in treaties with certain States. For these reasons, this paragraph should be included in the Convention only where each State has concluded that the procedure can be effectively implemented.
66. Furthermore, some States may wish to include paragraph 5 but restrict its application to a narrower range of cases. For example, access to arbitration may be limited to cases primarily involving questions of fact. It may also be possible to provide for the permanent availability of arbitration for issues arising in certain classes of cases, for example, those based to a significant extent on specific facts, such as cases involving transfer pricing and the question of the existence of a permanent establishment, while extending arbitration to other issues on a case-by-case basis.
67. States that are members of the European Union should coordinate the scope of application of paragraph 5 with their obligations under the European Arbitration Convention.
68. [Paragraph 5 allows] arbitration of unresolved issues in all cases dealt with under the mutual agreement procedure that have been presented in accordance with paragraph 1, on the basis that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in taxation of a person that is not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention. Where the mutual agreement procedure is unavailable, for example, because of the existence of serious violations involving substantial penalties (see paragraph 26), it is clear that paragraph 5 does not apply.
69. If two Contracting States that have not included this paragraph in their Convention wish to use an arbitration process for general application or in a particular case, they remain free to do so by mutual agreement. In such a case, the competent authorities may conclude a mutual agreement similar to the model wording set out in the Annex, to which they could add the following first paragraph:
1. Where
a) in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 of the Convention, a person has presented a case to the competent authority of one Contracting State on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in taxation of that person that is not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention; and
b) the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on the resolution of that case in accordance with paragraph 2 of the Article within [three] years from the date on which the case was presented to the competent authority of the other Contracting State,
any unresolved issues arising from that case shall be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the following paragraphs, if [either of the competent authorities so requests. The person who presented the case shall be notified of the request]. These unresolved issues shall not, however, be submitted to arbitration if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by a court or administrative body of either State. If [the competent authorities do not agree on a different solution within six months after the decision has been communicated to them, or if] the person directly affected by the case does not accept the outcome of the mutual agreement procedure implementing the arbitration decision, the competent authorities hereby agree to consider themselves bound by that arbitration decision and to resolve the case in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 25 on the basis of that decision.
This agreement may further regulate various structural and procedural matters discussed in the Annex. Although the competent authorities are consequently required to follow this procedure, such an agreement may be concluded within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure and, therefore, it will remain in force only for as long as the competent authorities adhere to their agreement to follow this procedure for resolving cases that they have been unable to resolve through the traditional mutual agreement procedure.
70. Paragraph 5 provides that [either of the competent authorities] may request that any unresolved issues relating to [a] case be submitted to arbitration, [in which case the person who presented the case to the competent authority of one Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 should be notified of such request. The obligation to notify the person who presented the case is not, however, a condition for the commencement of the arbitration process, and failure to notify that person cannot suspend the arbitration process.] This request may be made at any time after the expiry of the [three]-year period, which begins on the date on which the case is submitted to the competent authority of the other Contracting State. Consequently, referral to arbitration is not automatic; [the competent authorities] may prefer to continue waiting after the expiry of the [three]-year period (for example, in order to allow [themselves] more time to resolve the case in accordance with paragraph 2) or simply not to pursue the case. States may, without restriction, provide for a longer period of time to be required in certain circumstances before such a request may be made.
71. Under paragraph 2 of Article 25, the competent authorities must endeavour to resolve a case presented under paragraph 1 with a view to avoiding taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. Consequently, for the purposes of paragraph 5, a case should not be considered resolved as long as there remains at least one issue on which the competent authorities disagree and which, in the opinion of one of the competent authorities, indicates the existence of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. Accordingly, one of the competent authorities cannot unilaterally decide that such a case is closed and that [the other competent authority] may not request arbitration of the unresolved issues; similarly, the two competent authorities cannot decide that the case is resolved […] if there remain unresolved issues that prevent them from agreeing that taxation contrary to the Convention has occurred. If, however, the two competent authorities agree that the taxation imposed by both States is in accordance with the Convention, that there are no unresolved issues and that the case may be considered resolved even where double taxation may exist, provided that such double taxation is not covered by the provisions of the Convention.
72. The arbitration process is available only in cases where a person considers that taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention has actually resulted from the actions of one or both Contracting States; arbitration is not available, however, in cases where it is alleged that such taxation will ultimately result from such actions, even though the latter cases may be presented to the competent authorities in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article […]. For this purpose, taxation should be regarded as resulting from the actions of one or both Contracting States, for example, as soon as the tax has been paid, assessed or otherwise determined, or even in cases where the taxpayer has been formally notified by the tax authority of its intention to tax a particular part of his income.
73. In its current wording, paragraph 5 provides only for the arbitration of unresolved issues arising in connection with a request submitted under paragraph 1 of this Article. States wishing to extend the scope of application of this paragraph to cover cases to be resolved by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraph 3 of the Article are free to do so. In some cases, the need to resolve a case through the mutual agreement procedure may arise in connection with other specific provisions of the treaty, such as subparagraph 2 d of Article 4. Under that subparagraph, the competent authorities are required in certain cases to settle by mutual agreement the question of the status of a person who is a resident of both Contracting States. As indicated in paragraph 20 of the Commentary on Article 4, such cases should be resolved in accordance with the procedure established in Article 25. If the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on such cases and this results in taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention (under which, for the purposes of the Convention, the person should be a resident of only one State), the taxpayer's case falls under paragraph 1 of Article 25 and, consequently, paragraph 5 becomes applicable.
74. In some States, the competent authorities may have the ability to depart from a court decision on a particular issue arising in connection with a case submitted to the competent authorities. Such States should be able to omit the second sentence of this paragraph.
75. The submission of a case to the competent authority of the other State, which marks the beginning of the [three]-year period referred to in this paragraph, may be made by the person who presented the case to the competent authority of the first State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 (for example, by submitting the case to the competent authority of the other State at the same time or at a later time), or by the competent authority of the first State, which may approach the competent authority of the other State in accordance with paragraph 2 if it is itself unable to arrive at a satisfactory solution to the case. For the purpose of determining the beginning of the [three]-year period, the case shall be considered to have been submitted to the competent authority of the other State if sufficient information has been provided to that competent authority to enable it to decide on the presumed validity of the objection underlying the case. The mutual agreement determining the arrangements for the application of paragraph 5 (see Annex) should specify what type of information is normally sufficient for this purpose.
76. This paragraph also addresses the relationship between the arbitration process and the rights to domestic remedies. In order to ensure the legal validity of the arbitration process and to avoid the risk of conflicting decisions […] the arbitration process [should not be permitted] if the relevant issues […] have already been decided through domestic judicial proceedings in either State (which means that a court or administrative tribunal of one of the Contracting States has already rendered a decision governing those issues and applicable to the person concerned). This is consistent with the approach adopted in most countries with regard to the mutual agreement procedure, under which:
a) a person may not simultaneously request the mutual agreement procedure and make use of domestic remedies. If domestic remedies are still available, the competent authorities will generally either require the taxpayer to agree to suspend the use of those remedies or, if the taxpayer does not agree to this, postpone the mutual agreement procedure until those remedies have been exhausted;
b) if the mutual agreement procedure is used first and a mutual agreement is reached, the taxpayer and other persons directly affected by the case are given the opportunity to reject the agreement and make use of domestic remedies that had previously been suspended; conversely, if those persons prefer to apply the outcome of the agreement, they will be required to waive the exercise of domestic remedies in respect of the issues covered by the treaty;
c) if domestic remedies are used first and they are exhausted in one of the States, the person may use only the mutual agreement procedure for the purpose of obtaining relief from double taxation in the other State. Indeed, once a judicial decision has been rendered in a particular case, most countries consider that this decision cannot be overturned through the mutual agreement procedure and, consequently, restrict the subsequent use of the mutual agreement procedure to obtaining tax relief in the other State.
The same general principles should apply in the case of a mutual agreement procedure that includes one or more issues submitted for arbitration. It may be useful to refer an issue to arbitration if it is known in advance that one of the countries is restricted in the measures it may take in response to an arbitration decision. This will not, however, be the case if the country is able, through the mutual agreement procedure, to depart from a court decision (see paragraph 74), and in such a case paragraph 5 may be adjusted accordingly.
77. The second issue concerns the relationship between existing domestic remedies and arbitration where the taxpayer has not used (or has not exhausted) those remedies. In such a case, the approach most consistent with the basic structure of the mutual agreement procedure would be to apply the same general principles when using arbitration. Consequently, the use of remedies should be suspended until the mutual agreement procedure, including arbitration proceedings in respect of issues that the competent authorities are unable to resolve, has been completed, and the preliminary mutual agreement should then be reached on the basis of the arbitration decision. As in other cases involving the mutual agreement procedure, the outcome of such agreement will then be presented to the taxpayer, who must choose whether to accept the outcome of the agreement, which will require him to waive any remaining domestic remedies, or to reject the outcome of the agreement in order to pursue those remedies further.
78. This approach is consistent with the nature of the arbitration process described in paragraph 5. The purpose of this process is to enable the competent authorities to reach a conclusion on unresolved issues that prevent an agreement from being reached. Where such an agreement is reached through arbitration, the essential part of the mutual agreement procedure remains unchanged.
79. In some cases, this approach will mean that the parties will have to spend time and money on an arbitration process that will result in a mutual agreement that will not be accepted by the taxpayer. In practice, however, experience shows that cases in which a taxpayer rejects a mutual agreement in order to resort to domestic remedies are very rare. Furthermore, in these rare cases, it may be expected that national courts or administrative tribunals will take note of the fact that the taxpayer was offered an administrative solution to his case that would have been binding on both States.
80. In some States, unresolved issues between the competent authorities may be submitted to arbitration only if domestic remedies are no longer available. For the purposes of applying the arbitration approach, these States may consider an alternative approach that requires the person to waive the right to use domestic remedies before arbitration may take place. This may be achieved by replacing the second sentence of the paragraph with the following: "these unresolved issues may not, however, be submitted to arbitration if any person directly affected by the case still has the right, under the domestic law of either State, to submit those issues for determination by the courts or administrative tribunals of that State, or if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by such a court or administrative tribunal". In order to avoid a situation in which the taxpayer is required to waive domestic remedies without any guarantees as to the outcome of the case, it is also important to amend the paragraph so as to include a mechanism that would guarantee, for example, relief from double taxation. In addition, since the taxpayer in this case would be required to waive the right to be heard by national courts, this paragraph should be amended so as to ensure that the taxpayer is provided with sufficient legal safeguards that his participation in the arbitration process will comply with any requirements that may exist under domestic law and that such waiver will be recognised within the applicable legal system (for example, in some countries such a waiver may not be legally effective if the person is not guaranteed the right to give oral testimony during the arbitration process).
81. Paragraph 5 provides that [if both competent authorities do not agree on a different solution within six months after the decision has been communicated to them, or] if the person directly affected by the case does not accept the outcome of the mutual agreement procedure implementing the arbitration decision, that decision shall be binding on both States. Thus, the taxation of any person directly affected by the case must be in accordance with the decision adopted on the issues submitted to arbitration, and the decisions adopted during the arbitration process will be reflected in the mutual agreement that will be presented to those persons.
82. As noted in paragraph 76 b) above, if a mutual agreement is reached before domestic remedies have been exhausted, the competent authorities generally require, as a condition for the application of such agreement, that the persons concerned waive the use of any domestic remedies that remain available to them in respect of the issues covered by the agreement. Without such a waiver, a subsequent court decision may effectively prevent the competent authorities from implementing the agreement. Thus, for the purposes of paragraph 5, if a person to whom the outcome of the mutual agreement procedure implementing the arbitration decision is presented does not agree to waive the use of domestic remedies, that person must be considered not to have accepted the agreement.
83. The arbitration decision is binding only with respect to the specific issues submitted for consideration by arbitration. Although nothing prevents the competent authorities from resolving other similar cases (including cases involving the same persons but relating to other taxable periods) on the basis of that decision, they are not required to do so and, consequently, each State is entitled to adopt a different approach to resolving those other cases.
Paragraph 5 allows the competent authorities to agree on a solution that differs from the decision adopted through arbitration, provided that they do so within six months after the arbitration decision has been communicated to them. Consequently, the arbitration decision is not binding if both competent authorities consider that the decision is inappropriate and are able to agree on a different solution within the prescribed period. A subsequent mutual agreement that differs from the arbitration decision is not permitted under paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Convention, but is permitted under Article 12 of the EU Arbitration Convention.
85. The final sentence of this paragraph leaves the method of applying the arbitration process for the purpose of resolving cases through mutual agreement to be determined. Certain aspects may also be specified in the text of the Article itself, in a Protocol or through an exchange of diplomatic notes. Whatever form such an agreement takes, it must contain structural and procedural rules to be followed in applying this paragraph, taking into account the requirement contained therein that the arbitration decision shall be binding on both States. Ideally, this agreement should be developed simultaneously with the Convention so that it may be signed and enter into application immediately after this paragraph enters into force. Furthermore, since the agreement must contain a detailed description of the procedure to be followed for submitting unresolved issues for consideration by arbitration, it is important to make this agreement public. A model form of such an agreement is provided in the Annex, together with comments on the procedural rules set out therein.
19. At any time after a request for arbitration proceedings has been made in accordance with paragraph 5 and before the arbitrators communicate their decision to the competent authorities, the competent authorities may agree to resolve the remaining unresolved issues that led to the arbitration. In such a case, the case shall be treated as resolved under the mutual agreement procedure, and no arbitration decision shall be issued. Nevertheless, the competent authorities are not permitted to terminate the arbitration process without resolving the case. Otherwise, the legal certainty of the arbitration process would be undermined (for example, the person who presented the case in accordance with paragraph 1 might have refrained from bringing court proceedings because the case had been referred to arbitration).
C. Additional procedural issues relating to the mutual agreement procedure
20. The last sentence of paragraph 4 of Article 25 (Alternatives A and B) allows the competent authorities to develop bilateral procedures for conducting the mutual agreement procedure. The following paragraphs discuss various procedural aspects of the mutual agreement procedure, including suggestions concerning procedures that may be adopted by the competent authorities. These suggestions are not exhaustive and should be adapted and supplemented on the basis of the experience and particular circumstances of each country.
a) Aspects of the mutual agreement procedure requiring regulation
21. In general, the procedural arrangements for reaching a mutual agreement should be suitable for dealing with the many different issues that the competent authorities are expected to consider and should also correspond to the administrative capabilities and resources of those authorities. Such arrangements should not be rigidly structured but, on the contrary, should be sufficiently flexible to facilitate consultations and the reaching of agreement rather than impede them by providing for detailed procedural requirements and mechanisms. However, even relatively simple procedural arrangements should include certain minimum rules that enable taxpayers to understand their basic rights and obligations under the mutual agreement procedure. Such minimum rules should, it would appear, cover matters such as:
— At what precise stage in the consideration of his tax claim may a taxpayer request action by the competent authority under the mutual agreement procedure?
— Is the taxpayer required to follow any particular form when applying to the competent authority?
— Are any time limits applicable to such an application by the taxpayer to the competent authority?
— If the taxpayer applies to the competent authority, is he bound by the decision of the competent authorities and must he waive the right to apply to other administrative or judicial bodies as a condition for conducting the proposed mutual agreement procedure to be undertaken by the competent authorities?
— In what manner, if at all, may the taxpayer participate in the consideration of his case by the competent authority, and what are the requirements concerning the provision of information by the taxpayer?
b) Necessary cooperation by the person making the request
22. The successful completion of the mutual agreement procedure depends to a large extent on the full cooperation of the person making the request. In particular, that person should assist the competent authorities in establishing the facts on which the case is based. For this purpose, the person should ensure full and accurate disclosure of information concerning all relevant facts and supporting evidence known to that person. In particular, where transactions have been carried out in another Contracting State, the person making the request should provide the relevant documents setting out the terms of those transactions and give full information about the facts and circumstances of those transactions.
23. The competent authority may, in particular, require the person making the request to provide the following documents as soon as possible:
— a description of the general circumstances of the case, which should include a description of the business activities of the persons concerned, as well as a description of the contracts and arrangements that provide the general background to the case, such as a shareholders' agreement, partnership agreement, licence agreement or project agreement;
— detailed information concerning the situation that has allegedly resulted, or will result, in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, including, for example, details of transactions or events (such as the payment for or delivery of goods or services) that have been characterised in a particular way by the tax administration of the other Contracting State, together with all relevant documents and, in particular, documents that have been submitted to the tax administration of the other Contracting State;
— the amounts of income and tax in dispute (or estimates thereof);
— the relevant financial statements of the person or persons involved in the transactions or activities under consideration;
— a description of the relevant tax years or periods affected by the case (in each State, where they differ);
— a description of the procedural status of the case in the other Contracting State, for example, whether a tax audit report has been issued, whether a tax assessment has been received, and whether an appeal has been filed or judicial proceedings have been initiated; and
— references to the relevant provisions of the applicable tax treaty and an analysis supporting the claim as to whether taxation that is not in accordance with those provisions exists or will exist (if available, a legal opinion from the tax authorities of the other Contracting State should also be provided).
24. Additional difficulties may arise in obtaining some of the above information if the relevant transactions involve third parties that are not associated enterprises of the person making the request. Furthermore, certain information may not be available at the time the request is submitted. Nevertheless, the information provided at the initial stage should be sufficient to enable the competent authority to which the case is submitted to determine whether the objections are justified. In any event, the competent authority will not be able to initiate the mutual agreement procedure if the person making the request provides insufficient or inadequate information.
25. The mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 25 is available only in cases where a person considers that the actions of one or both States result, or will result, in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. There may be cases where double taxation arises as a result of the taxpayer's failure to comply with procedural rules (for example, the expiry of time limits) without any taxation contrary to the provisions of the Convention; in such cases, the mutual agreement procedure is not applicable.
c) Information on adjustments
26. The competent authorities should decide to what extent information concerning adjustments to the allocation of income should be provided and the time limits within which one competent authority should provide such information to the other competent authority. Such information may therefore relate to adjustments proposed or completed by the tax administration of one country, the enterprises concerned and the general nature of the adjustments.
27. In general, most competent authorities are likely to decide that the automatic transmission of such information is unnecessary or undesirable. The competent authority of the country making the adjustment may consider that collecting the information and putting it into a form suitable for transmission involves certain difficulties and substantial time costs. Furthermore, the other competent authority may consider even the processing of information transmitted in the ordinary course by the first competent authority to be burdensome. Moreover, as a rule, it may be expected that the taxpayer corporation will inform its associated enterprise in the other country where proceedings are being conducted, and the latter will in turn be able to notify its competent authority. Therefore, the consultation system will function more efficiently if the tax administration considering an adjustment that may have an international aspect informs the taxpayer to the greatest extent possible.
28. Some competent authorities, not wishing to receive information on a regular basis about all adjustments in another country, may wish to receive — either from their own taxpayers or from another competent authority — "advance warning" of significant cases or of the existence of substantial activity, in terms of volume or nature, in relation to certain types of cases; similarly, they may wish to transmit such information. In such situations, arrangements for receiving information should be developed. Some competent authorities may wish to extend this advance-warning system to less significant cases, thereby increasing the number of such cases.
d) Requesting consultation by the competent authority at the stage of a proposed or final adjustment
29. Paragraph 1 of this Article includes general rules concerning the presentation of a case by the taxpayer. The competent authority to which the case has been duly submitted should first consider whether it can itself arrive at a satisfactory solution. If it is unable to do so, it should determine at what stage it will consult with the competent authority of the other State.
30. Many competent authorities will prefer, at least initially, that the process should not begin at the stage of a proposed adjustment or even at the stage of a final adjustment. A proposed adjustment may not lead to anything in practice, and even a final adjustment may or may not result in a request for a corresponding adjustment; if it does, such a corresponding adjustment may be made without any difficulties. Consequently, many competent authorities may decide that the consultation process should not be initiated until a corresponding adjustment (or another tax consequence in the second State) has occurred at some stage.
31. However, some competent authorities may prefer that the bilateral process be initiated at an earlier stage, possibly at the stage of a proposed adjustment. This could simplify the consultation process in the sense that no position would initially have been established in the first country. In such a case, the other competent authority should be prepared to discuss the case with the first competent authority at such an early stage. Other competent authorities may wish to allow the taxpayer himself to decide this matter and, accordingly, be prepared to commence the process at any stage, starting with the proposed adjustment.
32. In any event, taxpayers should at least be informed when they may initiate the mutual agreement procedure and to which competent authority they should apply. In addition, taxpayers should be informed of the form in which the request must be submitted, although a simple form will probably suffice.
e) Corresponding adjustments
i) General rule
33. It is recognised that an effective treaty containing a provision on corresponding adjustments based on paragraph 2 of Article 9 should also provide that any procedural or other obstacles contained in domestic law to the making of a corresponding adjustment should be disregarded. Thus, in order to make a corresponding adjustment in accordance with the requirements of the last sentence of paragraph 2 of Article 25, it will be necessary to disregard provisions such as limitation periods and the finality of tax assessments. If a particular country is unable, as a result of the operation of treaty provisions, to disregard such rules of domestic law, this should be provided for in the treaty, although it is to be hoped that, in order to ensure the effectiveness of the treaty, amendments may be made to domestic law to avoid the need for such an exceptional provision.
ii) Procedure for consideration by the competent authority
34. Paragraph 2 of Article 9 does not prescribe a method for making a corresponding adjustment, since this depends on the nature of the initial adjustment and its consequences for the tax payable on the income of the associated enterprise. Thus, the method of making a corresponding adjustment is one aspect of the substantive legal treatment of the initial adjustment. Where a requirement for a corresponding adjustment is established under Article 9, a mutual agreement procedure should be provided for this stage. Consequently, if the tax authorities of the Contracting State from which a corresponding adjustment is requested do not themselves make such a corresponding adjustment, taxpayers should be granted the right to initiate the mutual agreement procedure. When a taxpayer applies to the competent authority of one Contracting State, that authority should be able to decide the matter without consulting the competent authority of the other Contracting State, as provided for in the first part of paragraph 2 of Article 25. For example, that competent authority may be able to decide an issue with potential international implications arising from an adjustment proposed by an administrative division of the State, even if that competent authority represents the national government of that State. Of course, the treaty affects this aspect of domestic law.
35. As a minimum procedural requirement, the competent authorities should specify the extent to which and the manner in which the taxpayer may participate in the procedure for considering his issue by the competent authority. Some countries may wish to allow a reasonable degree of taxpayer participation. Other countries may wish to allow the taxpayer to provide information and even appear in person; still others may limit the taxpayer's participation to the provision of information. It is envisaged that the competent authorities will make the provision of relevant information necessary for deciding the issue a condition for the taxpayer's initiation of this procedure. In addition, some competent authorities may, where appropriate, require that the information provided by the taxpayer be prepared, as far as possible, in accordance with international accounting standards, so that the data submitted are to some extent uniform and objective. It should be noted that rapid progress is being made in the development of international accounting standards, and the work of the competent authorities should contribute to such development. Another aspect of taxpayer participation should be the requirement that a taxpayer who initiates the mutual agreement procedure be informed of the decision of the competent authority.
36. The competent authorities will have to decide how their consultations will take place after this part of the procedure has commenced. It is envisaged that the nature of the consultations will depend on the number and nature of the cases under consideration. The competent authorities should ensure that the consultation procedure is flexible and provide for all means of communication so that the most appropriate means for the particular case may be used at the appropriate time.
37. There are various options, such as informal consultations by means of telecommunications or face-to-face meetings; meetings of technical staff or auditors from the two countries, the conclusions reached at such meetings being accepted or approved by the competent authorities; the appointment of a joint commission to consider complex cases or a series of cases; formal face-to-face meetings of representatives of the competent authorities, etc. It is undesirable to establish time limits for decisions by the competent authorities, since cases may differ in complexity. Nevertheless, the competent authorities should develop working principles that would facilitate the timely consideration of cases and prevent unjustified delays.
38. As noted in paragraphs 25 and 42 of the OECD Commentary cited in paragraph 9 above, an important minimum procedural aspect of the procedure for consideration by the competent authority concerns the consequences of the taxpayer initiating that procedure. Should a taxpayer who initiates this procedure be bound by the decision of the competent authorities in the sense that he waives the right to resort to alternative procedures, such as domestic administrative or judicial proceedings? If the competent authorities wish their procedure to be exclusive and binding, the treaty provisions must be drafted accordingly. It is envisaged that this may be achieved under the general delegation of powers provided for in paragraph 4 of Article 25 by requiring the taxpayer to waive the right to resort to such alternative procedures. However, even in the presence of this paragraph, some countries may consider that their domestic law requires more explicit wording in order to make the decision of the competent authority binding, particularly in view of the existing practice under treaties of not giving binding effect to decisions reached under such a procedure. Some competent authorities may wish to make their actions binding without wishing to expend efforts on reaching agreements whose outcome may be rejected by the taxpayer if he considers it preferable to apply to a court or another authority. Other competent authorities may prefer to follow established practice and not impose obligations on taxpayers, or may not be able to do so under domestic law. It would appear that it would be useful to rely on experience in this matter.
39. The main question relating to the procedure for consideration by the competent authorities is the extent to which the competent authorities should consider themselves obliged to reach agreement on a question submitted to them for consideration. The Convention requires, at a minimum, that consultations be held and provides for an obligation to endeavour to find a solution to eliminate economic double taxation. But must the consultations result in an agreement being reached? It is assumed that, in general, the absence of agreement will place the associated enterprises in a situation where the double taxation may be contrary to the Convention, for example, where one country objects to a corresponding adjustment on the grounds that the initial adjustment was not consistent with the arm's length principle. On the other hand, reaching agreement would mean that a corresponding adjustment would be made, or that the initial adjustment would be modified and, consequently, the corresponding adjustment would also be modified, or perhaps even that the initial adjustment would be withdrawn. Essentially, the general question is the following: should the competent authorities, in the course of consultations, be guided by the need to "agree to an agreement"?
40. In practice, this question does not arise as acutely as it might appear. The experience of most competent authorities shows that, ultimately, they almost always reach an agreement or a solution. Of course, the solution may often be a compromise, but compromise is an essential aspect of the consultation and negotiation process. Thus, in reality, deciding that the consultation procedure between competent authorities should be based on the need to "agree to an agreement" would not be anything fundamentally new for them. However, some countries may regard the formal establishment of this principle as a measure that would have significant legal consequences and may therefore be unwilling to accept this requirement.
41. It is recognised that, in some countries, the process of reaching agreement could be facilitated by allowing the competent authorities, in cases involving extremely complex issues or deadlock situations, to seek, formally or informally, an advisory opinion or other assistance in resolving the dispute from independent experts. Such experts may include individuals who are or have been associated with other tax administrations and possess the necessary expertise in this area. Essentially, it is the personal involvement of these experts that will play a significant positive role. Resorting to external assistance of this kind would be useful even where the competent authorities do not proceed on the basis of the need to "agree to an agreement", since outside assistance, by providing a fresh perspective on the problem, may help resolve a deadlock.
41.1 The possibility of such assistance may include the use of non-binding dispute resolution methods, such as mediation. For countries wishing to use such procedures, several non-binding methods are available that may be used to resolve disputes between the parties at an early or later stage of the competent authority process. Such non-binding dispute resolution mechanisms may range from facilitating the relational aspects of the competent authority process to providing insights or opinions on substantive tax issues under consideration in the dispute. These methods are currently used to resolve tax disputes under the domestic legislation of a number of countries. However, these procedures should be used with due regard to such matters as the timing and duration of the procedures, the mechanism and criteria for selecting the mediator or other such appointed person, and the handling of confidential information.
f) Publication of procedural rules and decisions of the competent authorities
42. The competent authorities should publish the rules they have adopted concerning the conduct of the consultation procedure. The description of these rules should be as comprehensive as possible and should, at a minimum, contain the necessary procedural aspects discussed above.
43. Where a consultation process resolves a substantive legal issue in an important area, which may reasonably be regarded as establishing a guiding principle for the competent authorities, the competent authorities should provide for the publication of that principle or decision in their respective countries.
g) Procedures for implementing adjustments
44. The competent authorities should consider what procedures may be necessary to implement the various adjustments required. For example:
i) The first country may consider postponing payment of the tax to be adjusted or even waiving payment if, for example, a payment or reimbursement of expenses by a related enterprise is prohibited at that time because of currency or other restrictions imposed by the second country;
ii) The first country may consider measures to facilitate the implementation of the adjustment and payment of the reallocated amount. Thus, if income is attributed to a parent corporation and taxed on the basis of a service rendered to a foreign subsidiary, the foreign subsidiary may, to the extent relevant to the country of the parent corporation, open an account in favour of the parent corporation in its books, and the parent corporation will not be subject to a second tax in its country on the opening or payment of the amount due to it. Such a payment should not be treated as a dividend by the subsidiary's country;
iii) The second country may consider measures to facilitate the implementation of the adjustment and payment of the reallocated amount. This may, in particular, involve recognising the payment made as a deductible item, even if there was no legal obligation to make such a payment before the adjustment. In fact, this is one of the aspects of a corresponding adjustment.
h) Unilateral procedures
45. Almost all of the foregoing relates to bilateral procedures to be agreed upon by the competent authorities for the purpose of implementing the mutual agreement procedure. In addition, a competent authority may consider it appropriate to develop certain unilateral rules or procedures concerning its relations with its own taxpayers in order to clarify those relations. These unilateral rules may concern matters such as the form in which a case is to be submitted to the competent authority; allowing taxpayers to approach the competent authority at an early stage, even if bilateral consultations are not required at that stage; whether the competent authority will raise new domestic issues (so-called collateral issues) concerning the relationship between the tax authorities and the taxpayer if the latter approaches the competent authority; and requests for information that will assist the competent authority in considering cases.
46. Unilateral rules concerning the operation of the competent authority do not require the agreement of the other competent authority, since the rules are limited to domestic relations with its own taxpayers. However, it would be advisable to inform the competent authority representing the other party to the Convention of such unilateral rules and to eliminate any significant differences that may arise in such rules under different conventions.
D. Interaction between the Mutual Agreement Procedure and the GATS Dispute Settlement Mechanism
47. In some rare cases, a dispute between countries concerning the application of the national treatment rule under Article XVII of the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) in respect of taxes covered by a tax treaty may result in both the mutual agreement procedure and the GATS dispute settlement mechanism being applicable to the resolution of an issue. This problem, as well as the solution adopted under GATS in respect of tax treaties in force at the time of its entry into force and a possible solution in respect of subsequent tax treaties, are discussed in the following part of the Commentary on Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention, which countries may take into account when negotiating tax treaties:
88. The application of the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), which entered into force on 1 January 1995 and to which all Member countries are parties, raises particular issues with respect to the mutual agreement procedure.
89. Paragraph 3 of Article XXII of GATS provides that a disagreement concerning the application of Article XVII of the Agreement, which provides for the national treatment rule, cannot be dealt with through the dispute settlement mechanisms provided for in Articles XXII and XXIII of the Agreement if the contested measure "falls within the scope of an international agreement between them relating to the avoidance of double taxation" (for example, a tax convention). If a disagreement arises as to whether a measure "falls within the scope of" such an international agreement, paragraph 3 provides that either of the States involved in the dispute may refer the matter to the Council for Trade in Services, which shall refer the dispute to arbitration, the decision of which shall be binding. However, the footnote to paragraph 3 contains an important exception, according to which, if the dispute concerns an international agreement "in existence on the date of entry into force" of the Agreement, the matter may not be referred to the Council for Trade in Services without the consent of both States.
90. Two specific problems relating to tax treaties arise in connection with this paragraph.
91. First, the footnote to this paragraph provides for different treatment of tax conventions concluded before and after the entry into force of GATS, which may often be considered inappropriate, particularly where a convention in force at the time of GATS's entry into force is subsequently revised, or where a protocol concerning a convention in force at that time is concluded thereafter.
92. Secondly, the expression "falls within the scope of" is itself ambiguous, as indicated by the inclusion in paragraph 3 of Article XXII of GATS of both an arbitration procedure and a provision excluding existing conventions from the scope of that procedure for the resolution of disagreements concerning its meaning. Although it seems clear that a country cannot in good faith argue⁵² that a measure concerning a tax to which no provision of a tax convention applies falls within the scope of that convention, it is nevertheless unclear whether this expression extends to all measures concerning taxes covered by all or only some provisions of a tax convention.
_____________________
⁵² The obligation to apply and interpret international treaties in good faith is expressly set out in Articles 26 and 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; therefore, the exception in paragraph 3 of Article XXII of GATS applies only to disputes arising on a good-faith basis.
93. Contracting States may wish to resolve these problems by bilaterally extending the application of the footnote to paragraph 3 of Article XXII of GATS to conventions concluded after the entry into force of GATS. Such a bilateral extension, which would supplement, without in any way impairing, the obligations of the Contracting States under GATS, could be included in the Convention by adding the following provision:
For the purposes of paragraph 3 of Article XXII (Consultations) of the General Agreement on Trade in Services, the Contracting States agree that, notwithstanding that paragraph, any dispute arising between them concerning a measure that falls within the scope of this Convention may be submitted to the Council for Trade in Services, as provided for in that paragraph, only with the consent of both Contracting States. Any disagreement concerning the interpretation of this paragraph shall be resolved in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 25 (Mutual Agreement Procedure) or, if no agreement is reached as a result of that procedure, in accordance with any other procedure agreed upon by both Contracting States.
94. Problems similar to those discussed above may arise in relation to other bilateral or multilateral agreements concerning trade or investment. Contracting States may, at their discretion, amend the proposed provision above during bilateral negotiations in order to ensure that matters relating to taxes covered by the tax convention concluded between them are considered under the mutual agreement procedure rather than through the dispute settlement mechanism provided for in such agreements.
ANNEX TO THE COMMENTARY ON PARAGRAPH 5 OF ARTICLE 25 (ALTERNATIVE B)
Model Mutual Agreement on Arbitration
1. The Committee considers that the following paragraphs of the Annex to the Commentary on paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention are relevant to the application of paragraph 5 of alternative B of this Article. Additional comments, indicated in square brackets, which do not form part of the Commentary on the OECD Model Tax Convention, have been inserted to reflect the differences between the two alternatives to this paragraph, as well as the differences introduced in the model mutual agreement itself, which primarily consist of the following:
— The model mutual agreement set out below provides that, if the competent authorities do not reach agreement in a particular case that an independent determination should be made by an arbitration body, the so-called "last best offer" or "final offer" approach (often referred to as "baseball arbitration") shall apply. This simplified arbitration procedure is less costly. Selecting between the positions of the competent authorities on each of the issues to be decided will be faster than preparing and issuing an independent opinion on each of those issues; moreover, such a selection may require only one independent arbitrator even where the basic rule provides for the presence of three arbitrators.
— The model mutual agreement also provides that a case will not be referred to arbitration if it involves an undetermined amount of tax (which must be determined by the competent authorities). Such cases will be referred to arbitration only if both competent authorities agree that doing so is appropriate (for example, for the purpose of resolving a matter of principle). It is clear, however, that taxpayers expect competent authorities to resolve directly cases involving small amounts of tax and not raising issues of principle.
— In order to guarantee their neutrality, the model agreement provides for a requirement that appointed arbitrators submit a statement declaring that, to the best of their knowledge, there are no circumstances that could give rise to reasonable doubts as to their independence and impartiality, and that they will promptly notify both competent authorities in writing of any such circumstances arising during the arbitration proceedings.
— The model mutual agreement contains certain rules for determining the remuneration of arbitrators.
2. In the OECD paragraphs included in the Annex to the Commentary on Article 25, paragraph 5 is worded as follows:
1. The following is an example of a model form of agreement that the competent authorities may use as a basis for a mutual agreement for the purposes of conducting the arbitration procedure provided for in paragraph 5 [alternative B of this Article]. Paragraphs 2–43 below discuss the various provisions of such an agreement and, in certain cases, identify alternative options that have been proposed. The competent authorities are, of course, free to amend, add to or delete any provisions of this model agreement when concluding a bilateral agreement.
Model Mutual Agreement on the Application of Paragraph 5 of Article 25
The competent authorities of [State A] and [State B] have concluded the following mutual agreement concerning the manner of applying the arbitration procedure provided for in paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the [name of the Convention], which entered into force on [date of entry into force]. The competent authorities may amend or supplement this agreement by an exchange of notes.
1. Request for Arbitration
A request for the submission to arbitration of unresolved issues arising in connection with a case requiring a mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the Convention (Request for Arbitration) must be made in writing and sent to [one competent authority by the other competent authority and to the person who submitted the case to the competent authority of a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25]. The request must contain sufficient information to identify the case. The request must also be accompanied by a written statement from each of the persons who either [initiated the case] or are directly affected by the case, confirming that no decision on the same issues has been rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of either State […].
[A Request for Arbitration may not be submitted by a competent authority where the amount of tax involved in the case requiring the mutual agreement procedure is less than [an amount to be determined bilaterally], unless both competent authorities consider such a submission appropriate (for example, for the purpose of resolving an issue of principle).]
2. Time Limit for Submitting a Case to Arbitration
A Request for Arbitration may be submitted only after the expiry of [three] years from the date on which the case submitted to the competent authority of one Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 was also submitted to the competent authority of the other State. For this purpose, a case shall be considered to have been submitted to the competent authority of the other State only if the following information has been provided: [the necessary information and documents should be specified in the agreement].
3. Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators
Within three months after receipt of the Request for Arbitration by [the other competent authority], the competent authorities shall agree on the issues to be resolved through arbitration and communicate them in writing to the person who [initiated the case]. This shall constitute the "Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators" for the case. Notwithstanding the following paragraphs of this agreement, the competent authorities may also specify in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators procedural rules that are additional to or different from the rules included in these paragraphs and regulate such other matters as may be considered necessary.
4. Failure to Provide the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators
If, within the period specified in paragraph 3 above, [the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators have not been agreed upon by the competent authorities and communicated to the person who initiated the case], each competent authority may, within one month after the expiry of that period, send the other authority a written list of the issues to be resolved by arbitration. All lists submitted in this manner within that period shall constitute the preliminary Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators. Within one month after the appointment of all the arbitrators, as provided for in paragraph 5 below, the arbitrators shall send to the competent authorities and to the person who [initiated the case] a revised version of the preliminary Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators based on the lists submitted in that manner. Within one month after receiving that revised version, both competent authorities shall have the opportunity to agree on different items in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators and communicate them in writing to the arbitrators and to the person who [initiated the case]. If they do so within that period, those other Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators shall constitute the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators for the case. If no other Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators are agreed upon by the competent authorities and communicated in writing within that period, the revised version of the preliminary Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators prepared by the arbitrators shall constitute the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators for the case.
5. Selection of Arbitrators
Within three months after receipt of the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators by the person who [initiated the case], or, if paragraph 4 applies, within four months after receipt of the Request for Arbitration by [the other] competent authority, each competent authority shall appoint one arbitrator. Within two months after the last appointment, the arbitrators appointed in this manner shall appoint a third arbitrator, who shall act as chairperson. If any appointment is not made within the prescribed period, the arbitrator(s) not yet appointed shall be appointed by [the Chairperson of the United Nations Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters or, if the Chairperson is a national or resident of one of the two States involved in the case, by the longest-serving member of that Committee who is not a national or resident of either of those States. Such appointment shall be made] within [one month] after receipt of the relevant request [from either competent authority]. A similar procedure shall apply, with the necessary modifications, if, for any reason, it becomes necessary to replace an arbitrator after the commencement of the arbitration proceedings. Unless otherwise provided for in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, the remuneration of all arbitrators shall be [determined as follows under the simplified arbitration procedure:
— the fees of the arbitrators shall be set at a fixed daily rate of [an amount to be determined bilaterally] and shall be subject to adjustment by the competent authorities;
— for each case, each arbitrator shall receive remuneration for no more than three days of preparation, two days of hearings (including by videoconference) and the travel days necessary to attend the hearings; if, however, the arbitrators consider that they require additional time to properly consider the case, the arbitrators may receive compensation for the additional time;
— in addition, the arbitrators shall be entitled to reimbursement of reasonable expenses with the prior approval of the competent authorities].
6. Simplified Arbitration Procedure
[Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators,] the following rules shall apply to each particular case […]:
[a)] Within two months after the appointment of [the arbitrators or, if paragraph 4 applies, within two months after the expiry of the period during which the competent authorities may agree on and communicate other Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators], each competent authority shall submit in writing [to the arbitrators] its own answers to the questions contained in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators.
[b)] Within [three] months after receipt of the last of the answers from the competent authorities, [the arbitrators] shall decide on each issue included in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators in accordance with one of the two answers received from the competent authorities on that issue and shall notify the competent authorities of their selection, together with a brief explanation of the reasons for that selection. Such decision shall be implemented in accordance with paragraph 19 [below].
7. Eligibility and Appointment of Arbitrators
Any person may be appointed as an arbitrator, including an official of the government of a Contracting State, provided that such person has not been involved in the previous stages of the case that has resulted in the arbitration proceedings. [Prior to their appointment, an arbitrator shall submit a written statement declaring that, to the best of their knowledge, there are no circumstances that could give rise to reasonable doubts as to their impartiality or independence, and that they will promptly notify the competent authorities in writing of any such circumstances arising during the arbitration proceedings.] An arbitrator shall be considered appointed when the letter confirming such appointment has been signed both by the person or persons authorised to appoint the arbitrator and by the arbitrator themselves.
8. Disclosure and Confidentiality of Information
Solely for the purposes of applying the provisions of Articles 25 and 26, as well as the domestic laws of the Contracting States concerning the disclosure and confidentiality of information relating to the case that has resulted in arbitration, each arbitrator shall be appointed as an authorised representative of the competent authority that appointed that arbitrator or, if the arbitrator was not appointed exclusively by one competent authority, as a representative of the competent authority of the Contracting State in which the case that resulted in arbitration was initially initiated. For the purposes of this agreement, if the case that resulted in arbitration was initially submitted simultaneously to both competent authorities, "the competent authority of the Contracting State to which the case that resulted in arbitration was initially submitted" shall mean the competent authority referred to in paragraph 1 of Article 25.
9. Failure to Submit Information in a Timely Manner
Notwithstanding [paragraph 5], if both competent authorities consider that the failure to resolve an issue within the [three]-year period provided for in paragraph 5 of Article 25 is primarily attributable to the failure of the person directly affected by the case to provide relevant information in a timely manner, the competent authorities may postpone the appointment of an arbitrator for a period corresponding to the delay in providing such information.
10. Procedural and Evidentiary Rules
Subject to this agreement and the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, the arbitrators shall adopt such procedural and evidentiary rules as they consider necessary to answer the questions set out in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators. They shall have access to all information necessary to make decisions on the issues submitted to arbitration, including confidential information. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, any information that was not available to the competent authorities before [one of them submitted] the Request for Arbitration shall not be taken into account in making the decision.
[11. Independent Opinion Approach
If the competent authorities include the relevant provision in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, the "independent opinion" approach shall be used instead of the simplified arbitration procedure. Under this approach, the arbitrators shall make their own decision, and the following rules shall apply to the particular case:
a) Unless otherwise provided for in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, the decision of the arbitration panel shall be submitted in writing, indicating the legal sources referred to and the reasoning leading to the outcome. With the consent of the person who initiated the case and both competent authorities, the decision of the arbitration panel shall be published in an edited form without mentioning the names of the parties involved or any details that could disclose their identities, on the understanding that this decision shall have no formal precedential value.
b) The arbitration decision shall be communicated to the competent authorities and to the person who initiated the case within six months from the date on which the chairperson of the arbitration panel notifies the competent authorities and the person who initiated the case in writing that they have received all the information necessary to commence consideration of the case. Notwithstanding the first part of this paragraph, if at any time within two months from the date on which the last arbitrator was appointed, the chairperson of the arbitration panel, with the consent of one of the competent authorities, notifies the other competent authority and the person who initiated the case in writing that they have not received all the information necessary to commence consideration of the case, then:
— if the chairperson of the arbitration panel receives the necessary information within two months after the date on which that notification was sent, the arbitration decision shall be communicated to the competent authorities and to the person who initiated the case within six months from the date on which the chairperson received that information; and
— if the chairperson of the arbitration panel does not receive the necessary information within two months after the date on which that notification was sent, the arbitration decision shall, unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, be made without taking that information into account, even if the chairperson receives it at a later date, and the decision shall be communicated to the competent authorities and to the person who initiated the case within eight months from the date on which that notification was sent.
c) The person who initiated the case may, directly or through their representatives, as appropriate, present their position to the arbitrators in writing to the same extent as that person is entitled to do in the course of the mutual agreement procedure.]
12. Administrative Arrangements
Unless otherwise agreed by the competent authorities, the competent authority to which the case that resulted in arbitration was initially submitted shall be responsible for the administrative arrangements for meetings of the arbitration panel and shall provide the administrative staff necessary for conducting the arbitration proceedings. The administrative staff provided in this manner shall be accountable only to the chairperson of the arbitration panel in respect of any matter relating to those proceedings.
13. Costs
Unless otherwise agreed by the competent authorities:
a) each competent authority and the person who [initiated the case] shall bear the costs relating to its own participation in the arbitration proceedings (including travel expenses and expenses relating to the preparation and presentation of its position);
b) each competent authority shall bear the costs of remunerating the arbitrator appointed exclusively by that competent authority or appointed by [another person] as a result of that competent authority's failure to appoint an arbitrator, including that arbitrator's expenses for travel, communications and secretarial services;
c) the remuneration of the other arbitrators and their expenses for travel, communications and secretarial services necessary for conducting the arbitration proceedings shall be borne equally by the two Contracting States;
d) the costs relating to meetings of the arbitration panel and the administrative staff necessary for conducting the arbitration proceedings shall be borne by the competent authority to which the case that resulted in arbitration was initially submitted or, if it was submitted in both States, shall be shared equally; and
e) all other expenses (including expenses for translation and recording of the proceedings) relating to costs that both competent authorities have agreed to bear shall be shared equally by the two Contracting States.
14. Applicable Legal Principles
The arbitrators shall decide the issues submitted to arbitration in accordance with the applicable provisions of the [Convention] and, subject to those provisions, in accordance with the domestic laws of the Contracting States. Questions of treaty interpretation shall be resolved by the arbitrators in the light of the principles of interpretation contained in Articles 31 and 33 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties […]. The arbitrators shall also consider any other sources that the competent authorities may expressly specify in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators.
15. Arbitration Decision
Where more than one arbitrator is appointed, the arbitration decision shall be determined by a simple majority of the arbitrators. […]
[16. Failure to Communicate the Decision within the Prescribed Time Limits
If the decision has not been communicated to the competent authorities within the period specified in paragraph 6 [b)] or [11 b], the competent authorities may agree to extend that period by no more than six months or, if they fail to do so within one month after the expiry of the period specified in paragraph 6 [b)] or [11 b], they shall appoint a new arbitrator or arbitrators in accordance with paragraph 5 […].]
[17. Final Decision
The arbitration decision shall be final, [unless both competent authorities agree on a different decision within six months after the arbitration decision has been communicated to them or] unless the decision is declared invalid by a court of one of the Contracting States on the grounds of a violation of paragraph 5 of Article 25 or of any procedural rule included in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators or in this agreement that could reasonably have affected the arbitration decision. If the decision is declared invalid for one of these reasons [or if both competent authorities agree on a different decision within six months after the arbitration decision has been communicated to them], the Request for Arbitration shall be deemed not to have been submitted, and the arbitration proceedings shall be deemed not to have taken place (except for the purposes of paragraph 8, "Disclosure and Confidentiality of Information", and paragraph 13, "Costs").
[18. Implementation of the Arbitration Decision
[Unless both competent authorities agree on a different decision, as provided for in paragraph 17 above,] the competent authorities shall implement the arbitration decision within six months after it has been communicated to them by reaching a mutual agreement on the case that resulted in the arbitration.]
[19. Cases in Which No Arbitration Decision Is Issued
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 6, [11] and [16], if, at any time after a Request for Arbitration has been submitted but before the arbitrators have communicated their decision to the competent authorities and to the person who [initiated the case], the competent authorities notify the arbitrators and that person in writing that they have resolved all the unresolved issues described in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, the case shall be considered resolved under the mutual agreement procedure, and no arbitration decision shall be issued.]
This agreement shall apply to any Request for Arbitration under paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the Convention after the entry into force of this provision.
[Date of signature of the agreement]
[Signature of the competent authority of each
Contracting State]
General Approach to the Model Agreement
2. A number of approaches may be used to structure the arbitration process that is used in addition to the mutual agreement procedure. Under one approach, which may be referred to as the "independent opinion" approach, the arbitrators are presented with the facts and arguments of the parties on the basis of the applicable law, after which the arbitrators issue their own independent decision based on a written and reasoned analysis of the available facts and applicable legal sources.
3. Alternatively, under the so-called "last best offer" or "final offer" approach, each competent authority is required to submit to the arbitration panel its proposed resolution of the issue in question, and the arbitration panel must choose between the two proposals submitted to it. There are, of course, a number of differences between these two positions. For example, the arbitrators may reach an independent decision but be required to present their conclusions without issuing a written decision. To some extent, the choice of the appropriate method depends on the type of issue to be resolved.
4. The model agreement set out above takes as its starting point the ["simplified" procedure based on the "last best offer" or "final offer" approach], recognising the fact that most cases, particularly those involving primarily factual issues, can be resolved most effectively [in this manner]. It also provides for an alternative [procedure based on the "independent opinion" approach]. Thus, the competent authorities may agree to use such an [independent opinion procedure] in each individual case. The competent authorities may, of course, adopt this combined approach, that is, adopt the [independent opinion procedure] as the generally applicable procedure and use the [simplified procedure] as an alternative in certain circumstances, or limit themselves to only one of the two approaches.
Request for Arbitration
5. Paragraph 1 of the model agreement specifies the manner in which a Request for Arbitration is to be submitted. Such a request must be made in writing and sent to [one competent authority by the other competent authority and to the person who submitted the case to the competent authority of a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25].
6. In order to establish compliance with the provisions of paragraph 5 of Article 25 (see paragraph 76 of the Commentary on this Article), the request must be accompanied by statements confirming that no decision on these issues has yet been rendered by national courts or administrative tribunals in either of the Contracting States.
7. Since the arbitration procedure is a continuation of the mutual agreement procedure and is intended to resolve cases that cannot be resolved under that procedure, it would be inappropriate to require the person who [initiated the mutual agreement procedure] to reimburse the costs incurred by the competent authorities during the arbitration proceedings. Unlike taxpayers' requests for rulings or other types of advance agreements, for which a fee is sometimes charged, ensuring the resolution of disputes between Contracting States is an obligation of those States, the costs of which they should generally bear.
8. A Request for Arbitration may not be submitted until the expiry of [three] years from the date on which the case requiring the mutual agreement procedure, submitted to the competent authority of one Contracting State, was also submitted to the competent authority of the other Contracting State. Paragraph 2 of the model agreement provides that, for this purpose, a case shall be considered to have been submitted to the competent authority of the other State only if the information specified in that paragraph has been provided. Accordingly, that paragraph should contain a list of the necessary information; as a general rule, this information will correspond to the information and documents required to initiate the mutual agreement procedure [see paragraphs 22–24 above concerning the necessary cooperation on the part of the person submitting the request].
Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators
9. Paragraph 3 of the model agreement refers to the "Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators", which is a document setting out the issues to be decided by the arbitrators. It establishes the procedural framework for the issues to be decided by the arbitration panel. This document should be issued by the competent authorities, which may wish to consult the person who [initiated the mutual agreement procedure] in this regard. If the competent authorities are unable to agree on the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators within the period specified in paragraph 3, some mechanism is necessary to ensure that the procedure can continue. Paragraph 4 provides for such a possibility.
10. Although the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators are generally limited to a specific issue or set of issues, the competent authorities have the option, taking into account the nature of the case and the interrelated nature of the issues, of drafting the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators in such a way that the entire case, rather than only certain specific issues, is submitted to arbitration.
11. The procedural rules provided for in the model agreement shall apply unless the competent authorities specify otherwise in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators. Consequently, the competent authorities have the option of departing from any of these rules or specifying additional rules in each particular case.
Simplified Procedure
12. The ordinary procedure provided for in the model agreement allows for the consideration of issues of either a legal or factual nature, as well as mixed questions of law and fact. [Under this simplified procedure, which takes the form of arbitration based on the so-called "last best offer" or "final offer" approach, each competent authority is required to submit to the arbitrator or arbitrators its own answer to the questions included in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators, and the arbitrator or arbitrators simply select the answer of one of the competent authorities. As with most procedural rules, the competent authorities may amend or supplement the simplified procedure by means of the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators applicable to the particular case.]
13. [Such a simplified procedure is particularly suitable for considering factual issues], for example, determining the amount of the adjustment to the income and tax deductions of the relevant associated parties. Such circumstances often arise in transfer pricing cases where the unresolved issue may simply be the determination of the transfer price or range of prices in accordance with the arm's length principle (although there are other transfer pricing cases involving complex factual issues); there are also cases in which a similar principle may apply, for example, determining the existence of a permanent establishment. In some cases, the solution may be a statement regarding the premises actually occupied, to which the competent authorities should apply the relevant legal principles […].
13.1. The answers submitted by the competent authorities under the simplified procedure may include alternative positions. For example, a competent authority may argue that no permanent establishment exists but nevertheless propose an amount of income to be attributed to the permanent establishment if the arbitrators determine that a permanent establishment does exist.
Selection of Arbitrators
14. Paragraph 5 of the model agreement describes the procedure for selecting arbitrators, unless otherwise provided for in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators drawn up for the particular case (for example, [providing for only one arbitrator] or providing for more than one arbitrator to be appointed by each competent authority). Usually, the two competent authorities appoint one arbitrator each. These appointments must be made within three months after the person who [initiated the mutual agreement procedure] has received the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators (a different deadline is provided for cases in which the competent authorities are unable to agree on the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators within the prescribed period). The arbitrators appointed in this manner shall select the chairperson, who must be appointed within two months from the date of the last of the initial appointments. If the competent authorities fail to appoint an arbitrator within the prescribed period, or if the arbitrators appointed in this manner fail to appoint a third arbitrator within the prescribed period, this paragraph provides that such appointment shall be made by [the Chairperson of the United Nations Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters or, if the Chairperson is a national or resident of one of the two States involved in the case, by the longest-serving member of that Committee who is not a national or resident of either of those States.] The competent authorities may, of course, provide for other ways of resolving such rare situations; however, it appears important to provide for the possibility of an independent appointing authority finding a way out of any deadlock in the selection of arbitrators.
15. There is no need to specify any particular qualifications for an arbitrator in the agreement, since it is in the interests of the competent authorities to engage qualified and suitable persons to perform these functions, and it is in the interests of the arbitrators to have a qualified chairperson. Nevertheless, it may be possible to draw up a list of eligible persons to facilitate the appointment process, and this procedure may be developed by [the United Nations Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters]. It is important that the chairperson of the arbitration panel have experience in dealing with the types of procedural, evidentiary and organisational issues that may arise during arbitration proceedings, as well as familiarity with tax matters. It may be appropriate to appoint representatives of each Contracting State as arbitrators, since they will be familiar with issues of this kind. Thus, there should be an opportunity to appoint government officials to the panel who are not directly involved in the case. Once appointed, it should be clear that the role of the arbitrator is to decide the case on a neutral and objective basis; they no longer act as an advocate for the country that appointed them.
16. Paragraph 9 of the model agreement provides that the appointment of arbitrators may be postponed if both competent authorities agree that the failure to reach a mutual agreement within the [three]-year period is primarily attributable to the lack of cooperation on the part of the person directly affected by the case [see paragraphs 22–24 above concerning the necessary cooperation on the part of the person submitting the request]. In this case, the approach provided for in the model agreement is to allow the competent authorities to postpone the appointment of arbitrators for a period corresponding to the unjustified delay in providing the relevant information. If this information has not been provided at the time the Request for Arbitration is submitted, the period corresponding to the delay in providing the information shall continue to run until such information is finally provided. If, however, the competent authorities have not been provided with the information necessary to decide a particular case, nothing prevents them from deciding that case on the basis of the limited information available to them, thereby preventing any referral to arbitration. In addition, the agreement could provide that, if the taxpayer fails to provide the competent authorities with the information necessary for a proper assessment of the issue within an additional period (for example, one year), that issue shall no longer be eligible for referral to arbitration.
Disclosure and Confidentiality of Information
17. It is important that arbitrators be granted full access to the information necessary to decide the issues submitted to arbitration, but at the same time they must be subject to the same strict confidentiality requirements in respect of that information as those applicable to the competent authorities themselves. The proposed approach to achieving this result, which is included in paragraph 8 of the model agreement, is to make the arbitrators authorised representatives of the competent authorities. This, however, shall be done only for the purposes of applying the relevant provisions of the Convention (for example, Articles 25 and 26) and the provisions of the domestic laws of the Contracting States, which generally contain sanctions applicable in the event of a breach of confidentiality. The appointment of an arbitrator as an authorised representative of a competent authority is generally confirmed by a letter of appointment, but it may be necessary to do this differently if required by domestic law or if the arbitrator is not appointed by a competent authority.
Procedural and Evidentiary Rules
18. The simplest way of establishing evidentiary and other procedural rules governing the arbitration process that are not specified in the agreement or in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators is to instruct the arbitrators to develop such rules specifically for each case. In doing so, the arbitrators may refer to existing arbitration procedures, such as the Arbitration Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce, which regulate many of these matters. The procedural rules should clearly state that, as a general rule, the factual material on which the arbitration panel will base its decision should be established in the course of the mutual agreement procedure. Only in exceptional cases should the arbitration panel be permitted to conduct investigations into factual issues that have not been resolved at the earlier stages of the case.
19. Paragraph 10 of the model agreement follows this approach. Thus, decisions concerning the dates and format of arbitration hearings are made by the arbitrators, unless otherwise provided for in the agreement or in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators. Furthermore, although the arbitrators must have access to all information necessary to make decisions on the issues submitted to arbitration, including confidential information, any information that was not available to the competent authorities should not be taken into account by the arbitrators unless the competent authorities agree otherwise.
Organisational Matters
21. A number of organisational matters need to be resolved in connection with the practical operation of the arbitration procedure. These include the venues for hearings, the language of the proceedings and, possibly, the provision of interpretation, the keeping of records, and technical details such as registration, etc.
22. With regard to the venue and administrative arrangements for arbitration hearings, the simplest solution is to make the competent authority to which the case that resulted in arbitration was initially submitted responsible for these matters. That competent authority should also provide the administrative staff necessary for conducting the arbitration proceedings. This approach is set out in paragraph 12 of the model agreement. It is assumed that, for these purposes, the competent authority will use conference rooms and staff already at its disposal. Nevertheless, the two competent authorities are entitled to agree otherwise (for example, to hold another meeting at a different location with the participation of the competent authorities and arbitrators).
23. It is assumed that the administrative staff provided for conducting the arbitration proceedings will report only to the chairperson of the arbitration panel on any matters relating to those proceedings.
24. The Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators will usually specify the language of the proceedings, the need for interpretation and the type of interpretation. Nevertheless, the need for interpretation or for keeping a record of the hearings may arise only after the proceedings have commenced. In such a case, the competent authorities are entitled to reach an appropriate agreement. In the absence of such an agreement, the arbitrators may, at the request of one competent authority and in accordance with paragraph 10 of the model agreement, decide to provide such interpretation or record-keeping services; in that case, however, the relevant costs shall be borne by the party requesting those services (see the section "Costs" below).
25. Other practical aspects (for example, notification and registration of documents) should be dealt with in a similar manner. Accordingly, any such matter should be resolved by agreement between the competent authorities (ideally, by being included in the Terms of Reference of the Arbitrators) and, in the absence of such an agreement, by a decision of the arbitrators.
Expenses
26. Various expenses may arise in connection with the arbitration proceedings, and it should be clear who should bear these expenses. Paragraph 13 of the Model Agreement, which addresses these matters, is based on the principle that, where a competent authority or a person involved in the case is able to control the amount of a particular expense, that expense should be borne by that party, while other expenses should be shared equally between the two competent authorities.
27. Accordingly, it is logical to provide that each competent authority, as well as the person [who initiated the mutual agreement procedure], should pay for its own participation in the arbitration proceedings. This should include the costs of representation at meetings and the preparation and submission of positions and arguments, both in writing and orally.
28. One of the main expenses of the arbitration proceedings is likely to be the fees payable to the arbitrators. Each competent authority shall bear the costs of remunerating the arbitrator appointed exclusively by that competent authority (or appointed by [another person] as a result of that competent authority's failure to appoint an arbitrator), including that arbitrator's expenses for travel, communications and secretarial services.
29. The fees of the other arbitrators and their expenses for travel, communications and secretarial services, however, shall be borne equally by the competent authorities. The competent authorities will generally agree to bear these expenses at the time of appointing the arbitrators, and this will normally be confirmed in the letter of appointment. Fees should be sufficiently high to ensure that qualified professionals are engaged. One possibility may be to use a fee structure similar to that set out in the Code of Conduct of the European Union Arbitration Convention.
30. Expenses relating to meetings of the arbitration panel, including the costs of the administrative staff required to conduct the arbitration proceedings, should be borne by the competent authority to which the case that gave rise to the arbitration was initially submitted, where that competent authority is required to organize such meetings and provide administrative staff (see paragraph 12 of the Model Agreement). In most cases, this competent authority will use conference rooms and staff already at its disposal, and it would be inappropriate to attempt to allocate part of these expenses to the other competent authority. Obviously, the reference to "expenses relating to meetings" does not include travel and accommodation expenses incurred by participants; these are dealt with above.
31. Other expenses (excluding expenses relating to the participation of taxpayers in the proceedings) should be shared equally between the two competent authorities, provided that the competent authorities have agreed to incur the relevant expenses. This includes expenses relating to translation and the keeping of records, which both competent authorities have agreed to provide. In the absence of such an agreement, the party requesting those particular expenses should pay for them.
32. As indicated in paragraph 13 of the Model Agreement, the competent authorities may, however, agree on a different allocation of expenses [in a particular case]. Such an agreement may be included in the Terms of Reference for the Arbitrators or reached subsequently (for example, where unforeseen expenses arise). [The competent authorities may also agree in the Model Agreement on different methods of allocating the costs of the arbitration procedure, particularly in cases where there are significant differences in the levels of development of the two Contracting States.]
Applicable legal principles
33. A review of the issues on which competent authorities experience difficulties in reaching agreement shows that these generally concern questions of treaty interpretation or the application of the arm's length principle underlying Article 9 and paragraph 2 of Article 7. As provided for in paragraph 14 of the Model Agreement, questions of treaty interpretation are to be resolved by the arbitrators in the light of the principles of interpretation contained in Articles 31 and 33 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties […]. Since Article 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties allows for the extensive use of supplementary means of interpretation, arbitrators in practice have considerable discretion in determining the relevant sources for interpreting treaty provisions.
34. In many cases, the application of the provisions of a tax convention depends on questions of domestic law (for example, the definition of immovable property in paragraph 2 of Article 6 depends primarily on the meaning of that term under domestic law). As a general rule, it would seem inappropriate to ask arbitrators to make determinations on purely domestic legal issues, and this should be taken into account when describing the questions to be resolved that will be included in the Terms of Reference for the Arbitrators. [However, where a question of domestic law directly affects the application of the provisions of a tax convention, the arbitrators may decide that question.]
35. In addition, there may be cases where the competent authorities agree that the interpretation or application of a provision of a tax treaty will depend on a particular document (for example, a memorandum of understanding and mutual agreement concluded after the treaty entered into force), but may disagree on the interpretation of that document. In such a case, the competent authorities may wish to make an express reference to that document in the Terms of Reference for the Arbitrators.
Arbitration decision
36. Paragraph 15 of the Model Agreement provides that, where more than one arbitrator is appointed, the arbitration decision shall be determined by a simple majority of the arbitrators.
38. To address unusual circumstances in which the arbitrators may be unable or unwilling to render an arbitration decision, paragraph [16] provides that, if the decision is not communicated within the prescribed period, the competent authorities may agree to extend the time limit for rendering the arbitration decision or, if they are unable to reach such an agreement within one month, appoint a new arbitrator to consider the case. Where new arbitrators are appointed, the arbitration proceedings shall revert to the stage at which the original arbitrators were appointed and shall continue with the new arbitrators.
Independent opinion approach
3. Under the alternative independent opinion approach provided for in paragraph 11 of the Model Agreement, the person who initiated the mutual agreement procedure may submit written statements to the arbitrators, either directly or through their representatives, to the same extent as they may do during the mutual agreement procedure. With the agreement of the arbitrators, that person may make an oral presentation at the arbitrators' meeting.
4. Where the competent authorities have agreed in a particular case to follow the independent opinion approach, and unless otherwise provided in the Terms of Reference for the Arbitrators, the decision of the arbitration panel shall be presented in writing, indicating the legal sources referred to therein and the arguments that led to that result. It is important that the arbitrators accompany their decision with an explanation of the reasoning that led to it. In order to ensure acceptance of the decision by all interested participants, it is important to demonstrate the method by which the decision was reached.
5. In accordance with paragraph 11(b) of the Model Agreement, the arbitration decision must be communicated to the competent authorities and the person who initiated the mutual agreement procedure within six months from the date on which the chair of the arbitration panel notifies the competent authorities and the person who initiated the mutual agreement procedure in writing that he or she has received all the information necessary to begin considering the case. However, at any time within two months from the date on which the last arbitrator was appointed, the chair of the arbitration panel, with the agreement of one of the competent authorities, may notify the other competent authority and the person who initiated the mutual agreement procedure in writing that he or she has not received all the information necessary to begin considering the case. In such a case, an additional two months shall be allowed for the necessary information to be submitted to the chair. If the chair does not receive the necessary information within that period, the arbitration decision shall be made without taking that information into account (unless the competent authorities agree otherwise). On the other hand, if the chair receives the necessary information within the two-month period, the arbitration decision must be communicated within six months from the date on which the chair receives that information.
6. The Commentary on the OECD Model Agreement on Mutual Agreement Procedure then continues as follows:
Publication of the decision
39. Decisions in individual cases reached under the mutual agreement procedure [and under the simplified arbitration procedure] are generally not made public. However, in the case of reasoned arbitration decisions, [submitted under the independent opinion approach], publication of the decisions would provide additional transparency to the process. Furthermore, although such a decision will in no sense constitute a formal precedent, making this material publicly available may influence the consideration of other cases, thereby avoiding subsequent disputes and leading to a more consistent approach to the same issue.
40. Accordingly, paragraph [11] of the Model Agreement provides for the possibility of publishing the decision [submitted under the independent opinion approach]. However, the decision should be published only if both competent authorities and the person [who initiated the mutual agreement procedure] agree to its publication. Furthermore, in order to preserve the confidentiality of the information disclosed to the competent authorities, publication must be made in a form that does not disclose either the names of the parties or any other element that could help identify them.
Implementation of the decision
41. Following the rendering of a binding decision in the arbitration proceedings on the issues that the competent authorities were unable to resolve, those competent authorities should proceed to conclude a mutual agreement reflecting that decision, which shall be communicated to the persons directly affected by the case. [Both competent authorities may, however, agree on a different solution within six months after the decision has been communicated to them.] In order to avoid further delays, it is envisaged that the mutual agreement incorporating the decision rendered should be finalized and submitted to the taxpayer within six months from the date of receipt of the notification of the decision. This is provided for in paragraph [18] of the Model Agreement.
42. Paragraph 2 of Article 25 provides that the competent authorities are obliged to implement the agreement reached, notwithstanding any time limits in their domestic law. Paragraph 5 of the Article also provides that the arbitration decision shall be binding on both Contracting States [if they are unable to agree on a different solution]. Consequently, a failure to determine the amount of tax in accordance with the agreement or to implement the arbitration decision by concluding a mutual agreement [unless a different solution has been agreed upon] will result in taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention and, as such, will allow the person whose taxation has been affected to seek judicial protection through domestic remedies or by submitting a new request under paragraph 1 of this Article.
43. Paragraph [19] of the Model Agreement governs the situation where the competent authorities are able to resolve the outstanding issues that gave rise to the arbitration before the arbitration decision is rendered. Since the arbitration procedure is an exceptional mechanism for resolving issues that cannot be resolved through the ordinary mutual agreement procedure, it is appropriate to terminate this exceptional mechanism if the competent authorities are able to resolve these issues themselves. The competent authorities may agree to resolve these issues at any time before the arbitration decision is rendered, [and within an additional period of six months thereafter].
Article 26
Exchange of Information
A. General considerations
1. Article 26 sets out the rules under which the exchange of information may be of an unlimited scope, both to facilitate the proper application of treaty provisions and to assist the Contracting States in enforcing their domestic tax laws. Accordingly, the obligation to exchange information under this Article should be interpreted broadly, and the limitations on this obligation should not be extended by analogy to a wider area than that specifically provided for therein. In particular, it should be assumed that this Article requires the Contracting States to promote effective exchange of information.
1.1. In the global economy, cooperation between countries on tax matters is becoming increasingly important, and the reluctance previously displayed by countries to take an interest in the tax laws of other countries has practically disappeared. Article 26 establishes the basis for the effective exchange of information between Contracting States, while Article 27 provides for assistance in the collection of information. The exchange of information for tax purposes is governed by Article 26 (see paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 27). Similarly, the mutual agreement procedure is provided for in Article 25, but the exchange of information for the purposes of conducting the mutual agreement procedure is governed by Article 26. In the view of many developing countries, Article 26 is of crucial importance not only in terms of limiting cross-border cases of tax evasion and tax avoidance, but also in terms of limiting capital flight, which is often carried out through such evasion and avoidance.
1.2. The wording of Article 26 largely coincides with the text of the corresponding article of the OECD Model Convention. Therefore, the OECD Commentary on that Article is generally relevant to the interpretation of Article 26 of the United Nations Model Convention. At the same time, it should be understood that Article 26 was intended to have a broader scope of application than the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention.
1.3. Although Article 26 imposes reciprocal obligations on the Contracting States, it does not allow a developed country to refuse to provide information to a developing country on the grounds that the latter does not have administrative capacities comparable to those of the developed country. Reciprocity should be determined on the basis of the overall results of the operation of the treaty, rather than the results of the application of one Article.
2. It is clear from the text of paragraph 1 of Article 26 that the exchange of information is not limited by the subject matter of Article 1 (Persons Covered) or Article 2 (Taxes Covered). Thus, the information transmitted may concern persons who are not residents of either Contracting State, as well as the assessment and collection or compulsory recovery of taxes not mentioned in Article 2. Some countries may object, for constitutional or other reasons, to extending the scope of paragraph 1 to all taxes. These concerns are addressed in Section B below.
3. By analogy with the amendments made to the OECD Model Convention in 2005, paragraph 1 of Article 26 was divided into three separate paragraphs: paragraphs 1, 2 and 6 in the current version. This amendment to the paragraphs was made for the sake of greater clarity and has no substantive legal effect.
4. In 2011, substantial amendments were made to the text of Article 26 in order to clarify certain points, broaden the scope of the Article and limit the number of exceptions to the obligation to exchange information. In some cases, the purpose of these amendments was not to change the substance of the text, but merely to remove doubts concerning the proper interpretation of the Article. For example, the wording "is necessary" in paragraph 1 was replaced by the expression "may be relevant", in order to clarify the meaning intended by the wording previously used. Conversely, the amendment to the wording of this paragraph to extend the exchange of information to taxes not mentioned in Article 2 was deliberately substantive in nature. Another example of a substantive amendment is the addition of paragraph 4, which removes the requirement concerning domestic taxation of interest.
4.1. Article 26 and the Commentary were further amended in 2014 to take account of recent developments and to provide more detailed consideration of the interpretation of certain provisions of the Article. Following the 2012 update of Article 26 of the OECD Model Convention, paragraph 2 of the Article was amended to allow the competent authorities to use the information received for other purposes, provided that such use is permitted by the laws of both States and the competent authority of the supplying State authorizes such use. Previously, this had been included as an optional provision in paragraph 13.3 of the Commentary.
4.2. In addition, the Commentary was expanded, inter alia, to clarify the standard expression "may be relevant" and to make an express reference to the term "fishing expeditions" as an element in determining the meaning of that expression. The latter term was introduced in the Commentaries on Article 26 of the OECD Model Convention as part of its revision in 2005 and has since given rise to considerable controversy concerning its interpretation. The 2012 update to Article 26 of the OECD Model Convention provided additional guidance on the interpretation of the term. The introduction of the term "fishing expeditions" into this Commentary was not intended as a substantive change, but rather was designed to further clarify the interpretation of the standard expression "may be relevant". The interpretation of the latter standard and the term "fishing expeditions" was developed by adding: general clarifications (see paragraph 7.2), wording concerning the identification of the taxpayer under audit or investigation (see paragraph 7.3), wording concerning requests relating to groups of taxpayers (see paragraph 7.4), and new examples (see paragraphs 10.2(e), 10.2(g), 10.2(h), 10.2(j) and 10.3). As regards group requests, many countries have always interpreted Article 26 as including such requests. However, for some countries, this represented a new interpretation. Other clarifications were added throughout the Commentary.
4.3. In some cases, whether an amendment made to Article 26 is substantive in nature or merely clarificatory depends on the practice previously established in the Contracting States. For example, in some cases, the addition of paragraph 5, which, in particular, prevents a State from invoking laws protecting bank secrecy as a basis for refusing to exchange information, may simply clarify the meaning of the limitations on the exchange of information set out in paragraph 3. In other cases, it may fundamentally change the content of the paragraph. The nature of the amendment in question depends in part on the specific practice already established in the Contracting States. The position set out in the OECD Commentary is that paragraph 5 is primarily clarificatory in nature with respect to treaty provisions concluded by Member States. This issue may be particularly important when interpreting treaties concluded before the amendments to Article 26 were made in 2011.
4.4. One of the differences between the wording of Article 26 and the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Convention is that Article 26 contains the following sentence in paragraph 1: "In particular, information shall be exchanged that would be useful to a Contracting State for the prevention of tax avoidance or evasion." The wording "which would be useful to a Contracting State for the prevention of tax avoidance or evasion" was added in 2011. Members of the Committee, particularly those from developing countries, considered this amendment useful because it clarifies in the text of Article 26 a point that had already been clearly set out in the Commentary and followed from the wording of the last sentence of paragraph 1 in its previous version, which has now been amended and moved to paragraph 6. Setting out the purposes of the exchange of information in the text of Article 26 should assist the Contracting States in properly interpreting this Article.
4.5. Although tax evasion is illegal and tax avoidance is legal, both result in the same outcome, namely, the failure of the government to receive tax revenues, and, by definition, run counter to the objective that the government seeks to achieve when adopting its tax codes. Therefore, mutual assistance in combating tax avoidance is an important aspect of cooperation in tax matters. Furthermore, some forms of aggressive tax avoidance are so similar to tax evasion that a Contracting State can confidently determine whether the information it requests concerns tax evasion or tax avoidance only after receiving that information. Information concerning tax avoidance may be extremely useful to a Contracting State seeking to eliminate possible loopholes in its tax codes.
5. The term "exchange of information" should be understood broadly and should include the exchange of documentation and the exchange of information not related to specific taxpayers, as well as the provision of information by one of the Contracting States regardless of whether information is simultaneously provided by the other Contracting State.
5.1. Where a specific request is received from the competent authority of a Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State should, where possible, provide information under Article 26 in the form of written witness statements and certified copies of unredacted original documents (including books, papers, statements, records, accounts or letters). Under paragraph 3, the requested State may refuse to provide information in the specific form requested if, for example, the form specified in the request is unknown or is not permitted under its laws or administrative practice. Refusal to provide information in the requested form does not affect the obligation to provide the information.
5.2. The Contracting States may wish to use electronic or other means of communication and information technology, including appropriate security systems, in order to improve the timeliness and quality of the exchange of information. Thus, the Contracting States may undertake to provide the requested information in electronic form where this is necessary for the effective exchange of information. Contracting States that are required under their legislation to comply with data protection laws may wish to include provisions in their bilateral treaties governing the protection of personal data transmitted. The issue of data protection concerns the rights and fundamental freedoms of individuals, and in particular the right to privacy of personal information where the automatic processing of personal data is concerned. In no circumstances shall a Contracting State be released from its obligation to exchange information merely because its domestic legislation does not allow it to provide information in the requested form.
5.3. The exchange of information covers all tax matters, without prejudice to the general rules and legal provisions governing the rights of defendants and witnesses in judicial proceedings. The exchange of information on matters relating to tax crimes may also be based on bilateral or multilateral mutual legal assistance treaties (to the extent that they also concern tax crimes).
5.4. Paragraph 6 of Article 26 provides that "the competent authorities shall, through consultation, develop appropriate methods and techniques concerning the matters in respect of which information is exchanged under paragraph 1". This wording authorizes the competent authorities to exchange information in at least three ways: exchange upon specific request, automatic exchange and other forms of exchange, including spontaneous exchange of information.
5.5. Nothing in the United Nations Model Convention prevents the provisions of Article 26 from applying to exchanges of information that took place before the Convention entered into force, provided that assistance in obtaining such information continues to be provided after the Convention enters into force and the provisions of this Article begin to apply. At the same time, the Contracting States may consider it useful to provide clarification as to the extent to which the provisions of the Article apply to such information, particularly in cases where the provisions of the Convention are to apply to taxes assessed or collected from a specified date.
6. The Committee of Experts has proposed several guiding principles governing procedures for using appropriate means of exchanging information (see paragraph 30 below). These guiding principles are presented in the form of an overview of alternative mechanisms available to the competent authorities. The purpose of preparing this overview was not to make it exhaustive or to develop any mandatory procedures for the Contracting States. In practice, the overview is a list of suggested options that the competent authorities could consider when developing procedures for the effective exchange of information.
B. Commentary on the paragraphs of Article 26
Paragraph 1
7. The first sentence of paragraph 1 sets out the general obligation of the Contracting States to exchange information. It provides, subject to the limitations set out in paragraph 3, that the competent authorities shall exchange such information as is "foreseeably relevant" for the proper implementation of the provisions of the Convention or for the administration or enforcement of the domestic laws of the Contracting States concerning taxes, insofar as the taxation under those laws is not contrary to the Convention.
7.1 Before the amendments to Article 26 in 2011, the word "necessary" was used instead of the expression "foreseeably relevant". In the view of the Committee and the authors of the OECD Commentary, these terms have a similar or even identical meaning. In other words, "necessary" information means "appropriate and useful" information, rather than "essential" information. In any event, regardless of the wording chosen, the requesting State is not required to demonstrate its need for the requested information in order for the obligation to provide that information to arise.
7.2 The standard expression "foreseeably relevant" is intended to ensure the widest possible exchange of information on tax matters while, at the same time, clarifying that the Contracting States are not entitled to engage in "fishing expeditions" or to request information about a specific taxpayer that is unlikely to be relevant to that taxpayer's tax affairs. In the context of exchange of information upon request, the standard expression requires that, at the time the request is made, there be a reasonable possibility that the requested information will be relevant; it does not matter whether the information provided ultimately proves to be relevant. Thus, a request cannot be rejected in cases where a definitive assessment of the relevance of the information to the investigation being conducted can be made only after the information has been received. The competent authorities should consult each other in situations where the requested State is unclear about the content of the request, the circumstances that led to its receipt, or the anticipated relevance of the requested information. However, once the requesting State has provided an explanation regarding the anticipated relevance of the requested information, the requested State cannot reject the request or refuse to provide the requested information because it considers that the information is unrelated to the underlying investigation or examination. Where the requested State becomes aware of facts that cast doubt on whether some of the requested information is foreseeably relevant, the competent authorities should consult each other, and the requested State may ask the requesting State to clarify the anticipated relevance in light of those facts. At the same time, paragraph 1 does not require the requested State to provide information in response to requests that constitute "fishing expeditions", i.e. speculative requests that have no apparent connection with an ongoing investigation.
7.3 A request for information does not constitute a "fishing expedition" merely because it does not specify the name or address (or both) of the taxpayer under audit or investigation. The same applies where names are spelled differently or information about names and addresses is presented in a different format. However, where the requesting State does not specify the name or address (or both) of the taxpayer under audit or investigation, the requesting State must include other information sufficient to identify the taxpayer. Similarly, paragraph 1 does not necessarily require a request to include the name and/or address of the person believed to possess the information. In fact, the question of how specific a request must be with respect to such a person generally falls within the scope of paragraphs 3(a) and 3(b) of Article 26.
7.4 The standard expression "foreseeably relevant" may be satisfied both in cases concerning a single taxpayer (identified by name or otherwise) and in cases concerning several taxpayers (identified by name or otherwise). Where a Contracting State conducts an investigation into a specific group of taxpayers under its domestic law, any request related to that investigation will generally serve the "administration or enforcement" of its domestic tax laws and will therefore satisfy the requirements of paragraph 1, provided that it meets the standard of "foreseeable relevance". However, where a request concerns a group of taxpayers who are not individually identified, it will often be more difficult to demonstrate that the request is not a fishing expedition, since the requesting State cannot point to an ongoing investigation into the affairs of a specific taxpayer, which in most cases would, in itself, dispel the impression that the request is random or speculative. Therefore, in such cases, it is necessary for the requesting State to provide a detailed description of the group and the specific facts and circumstances that led to the request, an explanation of the applicable law and the reasons for believing that the taxpayers in the group in respect of whom information is requested have failed to comply with the law, supported by a clear factual basis. In addition, it must be demonstrated that the requested information will assist in determining whether the taxpayers in the group have complied with the law. As shown in example (h) of paragraph 10.2 below, in the case of a group request, a third party will usually, although not necessarily, have actively facilitated non-compliance by the taxpayers included in the group, and in such a case this circumstance should also be described in the request. As shown in example (a) of paragraph 10.3 below, a group request that merely describes the provision of financial services to non-residents and mentions the possibility of non-compliance by non-residents does not meet the standard of foreseeable relevance.
7.5 The Contracting States may agree on alternative wording for the standard of foreseeable relevance that is consistent with the scope of the Article and is therefore understood as requiring effective exchange of information. For example, they may replace the words "foreseeably relevant" with the words "necessary", "relevant" or "may be relevant", provided that these terms are understood as requiring effective exchange of information. In the interests of consistency with the practice adopted by the OECD, the Committee decided to adopt the term "foreseeably relevant", although some members of the Committee preferred the term "may be relevant" on the grounds that its meaning is clearer.
7.6 The information covered by paragraph 1 is not limited to information concerning specific taxpayers. The competent authorities may also exchange other confidential information relating to tax administration and the improvement of compliance with the law; for example, they may provide information on risk analysis methods or schemes for tax evasion or tax avoidance. They may also exchange information obtained about aggressive or abusive tax avoidance schemes, such as those promoted by certain international accounting firms. Furthermore, the competent authorities may exchange information relating to an entire economic sector (for example, the oil, fishing or pharmaceutical industries, the banking sector, etc.), rather than to any particular taxpayer.
8. The scope of the obligation to exchange information is not limited by Articles 1 or 2. That is, this obligation applies not only to information relevant to the proper application of the Convention or to the administration or enforcement of domestic taxes referred to in Article 2, but also to all other domestic taxes, including subnational taxes. In this respect, the United Nations Model Convention and the OECD Model Convention are identical.
8.1 Some members of the Committee expressed concern that the exchange of information in respect of all taxes, particularly subnational taxes, might prove burdensome or might give rise to constitutional and political problems for them. They proposed limiting the obligation to provide information to taxes covered by the Convention, as well as one or two important taxes, such as value added tax (VAT). To achieve this result, paragraph 1 could be replaced by the following wording in paragraph 1:
1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange such information as may be relevant for carrying out the provisions of this Convention or for the administration or enforcement of the domestic laws of the Contracting States concerning the taxes covered by the Convention and [specify particular taxes] of the Contracting States, insofar as the taxation thereunder is not contrary to the Convention.
8.2 The obligation to provide the requested information applies regardless of whether the person in respect of whom the information is requested is a resident of one of the Contracting States or carries on economic activity in one of the Contracting States. For example, a Contracting State may request information about the bank deposits of an individual who is a resident of a third State.
9. The obligation imposed under paragraph 1 is to exchange information effectively. A Contracting State may not evade its obligations under paragraph 1 by means of unreasonable delays, the imposition of unreasonable or burdensome procedural obstacles, or the deliberate adoption of measures that prevent the obtaining of certain information which would otherwise be subject to exchange under paragraph 1.
10. The examples set out in paragraphs 10.1, 10.2 and 10.3 below are intended to illustrate the application of paragraph 1 of Article 26 of the Convention in specific cases. Some of these examples are taken from the examples set out in paragraphs 6, 7, 8 and 8.1 of the OECD Commentary on Article 26, but are not identical to them. In all the examples set out in paragraphs 10.1 and 10.2 below, the requested State (the Contracting State from which information has been requested) is obliged under paragraph 1 of Article 26 of the Convention to provide the requested information. In the examples set out in paragraph 10.3 below, and provided that the requesting State (the Contracting State requesting the information) does not provide any additional information, the requested State is not obliged to provide information in response to the request. The examples are provided for illustrative purposes only. They should be considered in light of the overall purpose of Article 26, namely, not to restrict the scope of the exchange of information, but to permit the exchange of information "to the widest extent possible".
10.1 Application of the Convention between State A and State B (information must be provided):
[Text omitted].
10.2 Application of domestic law (information must be provided):
[Text omitted]
(d) A resident of State A has a bank account in State B, and the income from that account is exempt from taxation under the domestic law of State B. State A may request State B to provide information on the amount of interest income earned on that account;
(e) The tax authorities of State A are conducting a tax investigation into the affairs of Mr. X. On the basis of this investigation, the tax authorities have reason to believe that Mr. X has one or more undeclared bank accounts with Bank B in State B. However, State A believes that, in order to avoid detection, it is possible that the bank accounts may have been opened in the names of the account holder's relatives. Therefore, State A requests information about all accounts with Bank B beneficially owned by Mr. X, as well as all accounts opened in the names of his spouse E and his children K and L;
(f) A financial intermediary invests the money of its account holders in State A, receiving dividends and interest in return. State A requires the financial intermediary to maintain records of its account holders, but does not ordinarily request this information in the course of enforcing its domestic law. State B suspects that some of the financial intermediary's account holders are residents of State B and are subject to taxation under its domestic law. State B may ask State A to obtain for it from the financial intermediary information about the identified taxpayers;
(g) State A has obtained information about all transactions involving foreign credit cards carried out within its territory in a particular year. State A has processed this data and initiated an investigation during which all credit card numbers have been identified for which the frequency and nature of transactions, as well as the type of use during the year, suggest that the cardholders are tax residents of State A. State A cannot obtain these names using the ordinary sources of information available under its domestic tax procedure, because the relevant information is not held or controlled by persons within its jurisdiction. The credit card numbers indicate that the issuer of such cards is Bank B in State B. On the basis of an ongoing request or investigation, State A submits a request to State B for information, asking it to provide the names, addresses and dates of birth of the holders of the specific cards identified in the investigation, and of any other person authorized to sign on those cards. State A provides the relevant individual credit card numbers and further provides the above information in order to demonstrate the foreseeable relevance of the requested information to its investigation and, more generally, to the administration and enforcement of its tax laws;
(h) Company B, which provides financial services, is established in State B. The tax authorities of State A have discovered that B sells a financial product to residents of State A, using false information that this product eliminates the tax liability of State A in respect of income accumulated within the product. The product requires an account to be opened with Company B, through which investments are made. The tax authorities of State A have issued a warning to taxpayers, warning all taxpayers about this product and explaining that it does not produce the purported tax effect and that income earned through the product must be reported. Nevertheless, Company B continues to advertise this product on its website, and State A has evidence that it also sells this product through a network of advisers. State A has already identified several resident taxpayers who invested in this product, all of whom failed to report the income earned from their investments. State A has exhausted all domestic means of obtaining information about the identity of its residents who invested in the product. State A requests the competent authority of State B to provide information about all residents of State A who (i) have an account with B and (ii) have invested in this financial product. In its request, State A provides the above information, including details of the financial product and the status of the investigation concerning it;
(i) A corporation resident in State A has companies located in States B and C. State B considers that the company carrying on business in its territory is shifting profits to a company located in State C. State B may request State A to provide it with information about the profits and expenses of the company located in State C. The domestic law of State A requires the parent company to maintain records of the transactions of its foreign subsidiaries;
(j) Company A, a resident of State A, is owned by foreign unlisted Company B, a resident of State B. The tax authorities of State A suspect that the managers X, Y and Z of Company A directly or indirectly own Company B. If this is the case, the dividends received by Company B from Company A will be taxable in their hands as resident shareholders under State A's controlled foreign company rules. The suspicions are based on information provided to the tax authorities of State A by a former employee of Company A. When confronted with the allegations, the three managers of Company A deny having an ownership interest in Company B. The tax authorities of State A have exhausted all domestic means of obtaining information about the owners of Company B. State A now requests State B to provide information as to whether X, Y and Z are shareholders of Company B. Furthermore, given that ownership in such cases is often exercised, for example, through shell companies and nominee shareholders, State A requests State B to provide information as to whether X, Y and Z hold an indirect ownership interest in Company B. If State B is unable to determine whether X, Y or Z holds such an indirect interest, information about the shareholder(s) is requested in order to continue the investigation. 53
10.3 Enforcement of domestic law (information must not be provided by the requested State, provided that the requesting State does not provide any additional information):
(a) Bank B is a bank incorporated in State B. State A taxes its residents on the basis of their worldwide income. The competent authority of State A asks the competent authority of State B to provide the names, dates and places of birth, account balances (including information about any financial assets held in such accounts) of residents of State A who have an account with Bank B in State B, have signatory authority over an account with Bank B or have a beneficial interest in an account with Bank B. The request states that Bank B is known to have a large group of foreign account holders, but contains no additional information.
(b) Company B is a company incorporated in State B. State A requests the names of all shareholders of Company B who are residents of State A and information about all dividend payments made to such shareholders. The requesting State A states that Company B conducts significant commercial activity in State A and that it is therefore likely to have shareholders who are residents of State A. The request also states that it is well known that taxpayers often fail to disclose information about income or assets from foreign sources.
53 Where State B becomes aware of facts that cast doubt on whether part of the information concerning a shareholder is relevant in the foreseeable future, the competent authorities should consult with each other, and State B may ask State A to clarify the foreseeable relevance in light of those facts, as discussed in paragraph 7.2.
Paragraph 2
11. A Contracting State cannot be expected to provide confidential financial information to another Contracting State unless it is assured that the information will not be disclosed to unauthorized persons. The confidentiality rules of paragraph 2 apply to all types of information received pursuant to paragraph 1, including both information contained in the request and information provided in response to the request. Thus, the confidentiality rules apply, for example, to letters from the competent authorities, including the letter requesting information. At the same time, it is understood that the requested State may disclose the minimum amount of information contained in the letter from the competent authority (but not the letter itself) that is necessary to enable the requested State to obtain or provide the requested information to the requesting State without frustrating the efforts of the requesting State. However, if, under the domestic law of the requested State, judicial proceedings or similar proceedings require disclosure of the letter itself from the competent authority, the competent authority of the requested State may disclose such letter unless the requesting State specifies otherwise. To ensure the confidentiality safeguards necessary for effective information exchange, paragraph 2 provides that information communicated pursuant to the provisions of the Convention shall be treated as secret in the receiving State in the same manner as information obtained under the domestic laws of that State. Sanctions for breaches of such confidentiality in that State shall be governed by the administrative and criminal laws of that State. In situations where the requested State determines that the requesting State is not complying with its obligations regarding the confidentiality of information exchanged pursuant to this Article, the requested State may suspend assistance under this Article until the requesting State provides appropriate assurances that those obligations will indeed be complied with. Where necessary, the competent authorities may enter into special arrangements or memoranda of understanding concerning the confidentiality of information exchanged pursuant to this Article.
12. Of course, information obtained pursuant to Article 26 would be useless or almost useless to the requesting State (the Contracting State requesting the information) if the prohibition on disclosure were absolute. Paragraph 2 provides that information obtained pursuant to Article 26 may be disclosed to persons and authorities involved in the assessment or collection, enforcement or prosecution in respect of, or the consideration of appeals in relation to, the taxes referred to in paragraph 1. In addition, it is understood that the information may also be communicated to the taxpayer, his or her authorized representative, or witnesses in civil or criminal proceedings.
12.1 As indicated in paragraph 12, the information received may be communicated to the persons and authorities referred to therein and, pursuant to the last sentence of paragraph 2 of this Article, may be disclosed by them in public court hearings or in judgments disclosing the name of the taxpayer. If the information is used in a public court hearing or in a court decision and thereby becomes public, it is obvious that, from that moment onwards, it may be quoted from the court records or decisions for other purposes, including as possible evidence. However, such disclosure of information to the public does not mean that the persons and authorities referred to in paragraph 2 may provide additional information received upon request.
12.2 If one or both Contracting States object to information received pursuant to Article 26 being made public by the courts or, after the information has been made public in this manner, to its use for other purposes, they should expressly state this objection in their Convention.
13. In general, information received by a Contracting State may be used only for the purposes specified in paragraph 1. If the information appears valuable to the receiving State for purposes other than those specified in that paragraph, that State may not use the information for such other purposes without the authorization of the competent authority of the supplying State. Such authorization should not be unreasonably withheld.
13.1 In some cases, a Contracting State may prosecute a taxpayer for tax evasion as well as for an additional offence, such as money laundering, arising from the same set of facts. In such circumstances, the receiving State may wish to use the information provided for both purposes.
13.2 Similarly, information received by a Contracting State may not be disclosed to a third country unless the bilateral treaty between the Contracting States contains an express provision permitting such disclosure.
13.3 Information exchanged for tax purposes may be of value to the receiving State for purposes other than those specified in the first and second sentences of paragraph 2 of Article 26. Accordingly, the last sentence of paragraph 2 allows Contracting States to exchange information received for tax purposes, subject to two conditions: first, the information may be used for other purposes under the laws of both States; and, second, the competent authority of the supplying State authorizes such use. This allows the tax authorities of the receiving State to exchange tax information with other law enforcement and judicial authorities of that State in relation to certain priority matters (for example, combating money laundering, corruption and the financing of terrorism). When the receiving State wishes to use the information for an additional purpose (i.e. for purposes unrelated to taxation), the receiving State should specify to the supplying State the other purpose for which it wishes to use the information and confirm that the receiving State may use the information for such other purpose under its laws. Where the supplying State is able to do so, taking into account, among other things, international agreements or other arrangements between the Contracting States concerning mutual assistance between other law enforcement and judicial authorities, the competent authority of the supplying State should generally authorize such use for other purposes if the information could be used for similar purposes in the supplying State. Law enforcement authorities and judicial bodies receiving information pursuant to the last sentence of paragraph 2 should treat that information as confidential in accordance with the principles of paragraph 2.
13.4 It is recognized that Contracting States may wish to achieve the general objective underlying the last sentence of paragraph 2 by other means and may do so by replacing the last sentence of paragraph 2 with the following text:
The competent authority of a Contracting State receiving information pursuant to the provisions of this Article may, with the written consent of the Contracting State that provided the information, also provide such information for use for other purposes permitted under the provisions of an agreement on mutual legal assistance in force between the Contracting States that allows for the exchange of tax information.
14. The OECD Model Convention, as amended in 2005, includes a provision allowing information received pursuant to Article 26 to be exchanged with persons responsible for supervising persons authorized to receive such information. This provision is also included in paragraph 2 of the United Nations Model Convention.
14.1 Disclosure of information should be limited to information necessary for those authorities to perform their supervisory functions. Such supervisory authorities include bodies exercising supervision over tax administration and law enforcement authorities within the general administration of the government of a Contracting State. Such exchange of information is permitted only if persons carrying out supervisory activities are subject to confidentiality requirements at least as stringent as those applicable to employees of the tax administration and law enforcement authorities. The competent authorities may wish to agree on which authorities are included within the meaning of the term supervisory authority in this paragraph.
Paragraph 3
15. Paragraph 3 of Article 26 contains provisions limiting the obligations of the requested State under paragraph 1. However, the limitations provided for in paragraph 3 may be replaced by the provisions contained in paragraphs 4 and 5. The provisions of paragraph 3, considered together with the provisions of paragraphs 4 and 5, should not be interpreted in a manner that would prevent effective exchange of information between the Contracting States. Furthermore, a Contracting State should inform the other Contracting State, before concluding a Convention, of any specific provisions of its laws and administrative practice which, in its view, entitle it to avoid the obligation imposed by paragraph 1 in another manner.
16. Paragraph 3(a), subject to the limitations provided for in paragraphs 4 and 5, clarifies that a Contracting State is not required to go beyond its domestic laws and administrative practice when making information available to another Contracting State. For example, if the requested State is prohibited under its laws or administrative practice from seizing a taxpayer's personal documents without a court order, it is not required to carry out such a seizure without a court order on behalf of the requesting State, even if the requested State may carry out such a seizure without judicial authorization under its laws or administrative practice. The purpose of this rule is to prevent an unintended conflict between the obligations of a Contracting State under Article 26 and its obligations under domestic law.
16.1 Domestic provisions requiring information obtained by tax authorities to be kept confidential should not be interpreted as creating an obstacle to the exchange of information under paragraph 3(a), since the tax authorities of the requesting State are required, pursuant to paragraph 2, to maintain the confidentiality of information received under this Article.
16.2 Paragraph 1 requires the requested State to provide information concerning all taxes of the requesting State, even if the requested State does not impose a comparable tax. Paragraph 3(a) does not remove the obligation to provide information relating to taxes that the requested State does not levy. For example, the requested State cannot avoid fulfilling its obligation to provide information useful to the requesting State in ensuring payment of value-added tax merely because the requested State does not have a value-added tax. Of course, the requested State may avoid fulfilling its obligation to provide such information if it cannot obtain that information under its ordinary administrative procedures within the meaning of paragraph 3(b).
16.3 The purpose of paragraph 3(a) is to avoid traps for the unwary, not to create such traps. A Contracting State that considers itself not obliged to obtain certain types of information on behalf of another Contracting State by virtue of its own laws or administrative practice (including the laws and administrative practice of its subnational governments) should set out its position in writing before the entry into force of the Convention containing Article 26. It should also disclose information about the likely impact of that position on its ability to ensure effective exchange of information. For example, if a Contracting State considers that one of its laws prevents it from providing another Contracting State with information about the beneficial owners of its resident companies or other legal entities, it should give written notice of this position during the negotiations on the Convention, explaining the implications of this law for its obligations regarding mutual assistance. Depending on the facts and circumstances of the particular case, failure to disclose such information may deprive the Contracting State of the right to rely on paragraph 3(a) to avoid fulfilling its obligations under paragraph 1.
16.4 A Contracting State that changes its laws or administrative practice after the entry into force of a Convention containing paragraph 3(a) should notify the other Contracting State of that change in a timely manner. Depending on the facts and circumstances of the case, such a change may constitute a material breach of the Convention. In any event, failure to provide timely notification of such a change may deprive the Contracting State of the right to rely on paragraph 3(a) to avoid its obligations under paragraph 1.
16.5 A Contracting State wishing to broaden the scope of the limitation currently provided for in paragraph 3(a) may amend that paragraph as follows:
(a) to take administrative measures that are inconsistent with the laws and administrative practice of that Contracting State or of the other Contracting State, even if that Contracting State knows and does not disclose that specific provisions of its laws or administrative practice may impede effective exchange of information.
17. The laws of some countries require notification to the person providing the information and/or the taxpayer to whom the request relates before the information is transmitted to another country. Such notification procedures may be an important aspect of the rights afforded under domestic law. In some cases, notification should help prevent errors (for example, in cases of mistaken identity) and facilitate the exchange of information (by allowing taxpayers who have received notification to cooperate voluntarily with the tax authorities of the requesting State). However, notification procedures may not be applied in such a way that, in the particular circumstances of a request, they would completely undermine the efforts of the requesting State to prevent tax evasion. In other words, they should not impede the effective exchange of information or unduly delay it. For example, notification procedures should allow for exceptions to prior notification in cases where the request for information is very urgent or where notification may undermine the chances of success of an investigation conducted by the requesting State.
17.1 A Contracting State that, under its domestic law, is required to notify the person who provided the information and/or the taxpayer that an exchange of information is proposed should inform its treaty partners in writing that it has this requirement and explain its implications for their obligations regarding mutual assistance. Such information should be provided to the other Contracting State before the conclusion of the Convention and thereafter whenever the relevant rules are amended. Depending on the facts and circumstances of the particular case, failure to disclose this information may deprive the Contracting State of the right to rely on paragraph 3(a) to avoid fulfilling its obligations under paragraph 1.
18. As a general rule, the requested State is not required to take administrative measures on behalf of the requesting State that are not permitted under the laws or administrative practice of the requesting State. The purpose of this rule is to prevent the requesting State from using the administrative measures of the requested State to circumvent the restrictions imposed on the requesting State by its own government.
18.1 Different countries will inevitably have different mechanisms for obtaining and providing information. Differences in laws and administrative practice cannot be used by the requested State as grounds for rejecting a request for information, except where such differences substantially limit the legal authority of the requesting State to obtain and provide information if the requesting State itself has received a lawful request from the requesting State. It should be noted that if a Contracting State applies measures under paragraph 5 that are not normally provided for in its domestic laws or practice, for example, to access and exchange banking information, that State is equally entitled to request similar information from the other Contracting State.
18.2 The general rule set out in paragraph 18 does not apply where the legal system or administrative practice of only one country provides for a particular procedure. For example, a Contracting State from which information is requested concerning an administrative ruling or advance pricing arrangement (APA) issued by it cannot invoke the absence of a ruling or APA regime in the requesting State to avoid its obligation to provide such information under paragraph 1.
54 Note: The corresponding wording in the OECD Commentary (see paragraph 15 of the OECD Commentary) contains the following additional sentence: "This would be fully in accordance with the principle of reciprocity underlying subparagraphs (a) and (b) of paragraph 3". One member of the Subcommittee also proposed adding this sentence to the UN Commentary. This sentence was ultimately not added, since it might be interpreted as suggesting that paragraph 3 requires each of the Contracting States to receive reciprocal benefits under Article 26. Such an interpretation would not be consistent with the broader approach to reciprocity adopted by the UN Convention. The clarification that "if a Contracting State applies measures under paragraph 5 that are not normally provided for in its domestic laws or practice, for example, to access and exchange banking information, that State is equally entitled to request similar information from the other Contracting State" is nevertheless useful and relevant in the context of the UN Convention, as it is in the context of the OECD Convention, given that, under the broader approach to reciprocity adopted by the UN Convention, the relevant Contracting State would also be equally entitled to request information from the other Contracting State.
19. Under their domestic laws, most countries recognize that information cannot be obtained from a person to the extent that such person may claim protection against self-incrimination. Accordingly, the requested State may refuse to provide information if its rules on self-incrimination do not allow it to obtain that information or if the rules on self-incrimination of the requesting State would not allow it to obtain such information under similar circumstances. In practice, however, the privilege against self-incrimination is rarely invoked in connection with most requests for information. The privilege against self-incrimination is personal and cannot be claimed by a person who is not themselves at risk of criminal prosecution. In the overwhelming majority of information requests, the purpose is to obtain information from third parties, such as banks, intermediaries or another party to a contract, rather than from the person under investigation. Furthermore, the privilege against self-incrimination generally does not extend to persons other than natural persons.
20. Paragraph 3(b) allows the requested State to avoid the obligation otherwise imposed by paragraph 1 where it cannot obtain the requested information in the course of ordinary administrative activities or where the other Contracting State would not be able to obtain that information in the course of ordinary administrative activities. The purpose of this rule is to prevent the requesting State from imposing an undue burden on the requested State.
20.1 Information is considered available in the course of ordinary administration if it is held by the tax authorities or can be obtained by them through the ordinary tax assessment procedure, which may include special investigations or special examinations of commercial accounts maintained by the taxpayer or other persons. For example, if the requested State, as part of its audit policy, obtains information on the appropriateness of transfer prices used by its taxpayers in transactions with related companies, it is considered that the tax authorities can obtain similar information concerning their taxpayers and related companies on behalf of the requesting State. In this case, it is of course assumed that the tax authorities have the powers and resources necessary to facilitate effective exchange of information. For example, suppose that a Contracting State requests information in connection with an investigation into the tax affairs of a particular taxpayer and indicates in the request that the information may be held by one of several service providers identified in the request and established in the other Contracting State. In that case, the requested State is expected to be able to obtain and provide such information to the extent that the information is held by one of the service providers identified in the request. In responding to a request, the requested State should be guided by the general objective of Article 26, which is to ensure the exchange of information "to the widest possible extent", and may take into account the importance of the requested information to the requesting State in relation to the administrative costs incurred by the requested State.
20.2 Unless the Contracting States have agreed otherwise, it should be assumed that the information requested by a Contracting State could be obtained by that State in a similar situation, unless that State has informed the other Contracting State to the contrary.
20.3 When a Convention is concluded between a developed country and a developing country, it is often assumed that the developed country will have greater administrative capacity than the developing country. Such a difference in administrative capacity is not a basis for either Contracting State to avoid its obligation to provide information under paragraph 1 pursuant to paragraph 3(b). That is, paragraph 3 does not require each of the Contracting States to receive reciprocal benefits under Article 26. By voluntarily accepting the Convention, the Contracting States would appear to have concluded that the Convention, considered as a whole, provides reciprocal benefits to each of them. There is no need to assume that each Article or each paragraph of an Article provides a reciprocal benefit. On the contrary, it is common for a Contracting State to relinquish a benefit provided for in one Article in order to obtain a benefit provided for in another Article.
20.4 Although paragraphs 3(a) and 3(b) do not expressly provide for reciprocity in the receipt of benefits, the OECD Commentary on Article 26 sets out the position that a reciprocity requirement may be inferred from the wording of paragraphs 3(a) and 3(b), the latter of which, in particular, limits the obligation of a Contracting State to provide information that is available in the course of the ordinary administrative activities of that other Contracting State. In essence, the OECD Commentary interprets the term "available" as meaning that the other Contracting State has the actual administrative capacity to obtain such information. An alternative interpretation is that "available" means that the tax administration has the authority to obtain information, regardless of whether it has the capacity to exercise that authority. Countries may wish to make it clear in their treaties that Contracting States are required to exchange information even if one of the Contracting States has significantly less capacity to obtain information about taxpayers. To achieve this result, they could amend subparagraph (b) as follows:
(b) to provide information that cannot be obtained in the course of the ordinary administrative activities of that Contracting State or is not available under the laws of that Contracting State or the other Contracting State.
20.5 Paragraphs 3(a) and 3(b) do not allow the requested State to reject a request to which paragraphs 4 or 5 apply. Paragraph 5 will apply, for example, in situations where the inability of the requested State to obtain information was specifically related to the fact that the requested information was presumed to be held by a bank or other financial institution. Thus, the application of paragraph 5 includes situations in which the powers of the tax authorities to collect information concerning information held by banks and other financial institutions are subject to requirements different from those normally applicable to information held by persons other than banks or other financial institutions. This may be the case, for example, where the tax authorities may exercise their information-gathering powers in respect of information held by banks and other financial institutions only where specific information is available about the taxpayer under investigation. This may also be the case where, for example, the use of information-gathering measures in respect of information held by banks and other financial institutions requires a higher degree of probability that the requested information is held by the person believed to possess the requested information than the degree of probability required for the use of information-gathering measures in respect of information believed to be held by persons other than banks or financial institutions.
21. As a general rule, the requested State may refuse, pursuant to paragraph 3(c), to disclose information that constitutes confidential communications between a lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative acting in that capacity and his or her client, to the extent that such communications are protected from disclosure under domestic law.
21.1 The scope of protected confidential communications should be strictly defined. Such protection does not extend to documents or records transferred to a lawyer, solicitor or other legal representative in an attempt to protect such documents or records from disclosure required by law. Furthermore, information concerning the identity of a person such as a director or beneficial owner of a company is not protected from disclosure. Although the scope of protection afforded under domestic law to the confidentiality of communications may differ between States, the protection provided for in paragraph 3(c) should not be so broad as to prevent effective exchange of information.
21.2 Notwithstanding the provisions of the domestic law of the requested State, that State may refuse to provide requested communications between lawyers, solicitors or other recognized legal representatives and their clients only where and to the extent that such representatives are acting as lawyers, solicitors or other recognized legal representatives, and not in another capacity, for example, as nominee shareholders, trustees, company founders, directors or accountants, or under a power of attorney to represent a company in its business affairs. More specifically, the communication must have been prepared in good faith for the purpose of seeking or providing legal advice or for use in existing or contemplated legal proceedings.
21.3 Under no circumstances may the requested State refuse to disclose information about communications between lawyers, solicitors or other recognized legal representatives and their clients if those persons themselves participated, together with their clients, in a tax evasion scheme.
21.4 A claim that information is protected as confidential communications between a lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative and his or her client must be considered exclusively under the laws of the Contracting State under whose laws the claim arises. Thus, it is not contemplated that the courts of the requested State should consider claims based on the laws of the requesting State.
22. Paragraph 3(c) also permits the requested State to refuse to provide information if disclosure of that information could reveal a trade, business, industrial, commercial or professional secret or a trade process. Before invoking this provision, a Contracting State should carefully weigh whether the interests of the taxpayer actually justify its application. The secrets referred to in this paragraph should not be interpreted too broadly. A broad interpretation of this provision would, in many cases, be incompatible with the purpose of Article 26, since it would render ineffective the exchange of information provided for in this Article.
22.1 A trade secret or manufacturing process generally means information that has significant economic value and that can be used in practice, and whose unauthorized use could result in serious harm (for example, serious financial difficulties). The purpose of the exception to the confidentiality regime is to prevent taxpayers from being unfairly burdened by the exchange of information through disclosure of valuable confidential information to their competitors or potential competitors, thereby significantly reducing the commercial value of that information. Confidential information that once had substantial commercial value may be disclosed if that information no longer has substantial commercial value at the time the information is requested. Information is not confidential within the meaning of paragraph 3(c) merely because its disclosure would embarrass the taxpayer or a third party or could result in the taxpayer having to pay additional taxes or suffer a loss of income due to adverse publicity. A Contracting State may decide to provide the requested information where it considers that there are no reasonable grounds to believe that the taxpayer concerned may suffer adverse consequences incompatible with the exchange of information.
22.2 Confidential information may be disclosed to the requesting State if the requested State determines that the risk of disclosure to the public or competitors is unlikely in view of the confidentiality requirements set out in paragraph 2. A document that is protected from disclosure in its entirety because it contains protected confidential information may be redacted if that confidential information is removed.
22.3 Financial information, including books and accounting records, does not by its nature constitute a trade, business or other secret. However, in certain limited cases, disclosure of financial information may result in the disclosure of a trade, business or other secret. For example, a request for information concerning certain purchasing records may give rise to such a problem if disclosure of that information would reveal a patented formula used in the manufacture of a product. Protection of such information may also extend to information held by third parties. For example, a bank may hold a pending patent application, or a confidential trade process or formula may be described in a loan application or a contract held by the bank. In such circumstances, information relating to the trade, business or other secret should be redacted from the documents, and the remaining financial information should be exchanged accordingly.
23. Paragraph 3(c) provides for a limitation in respect of information that affects the vital interests of the State itself. Under this limitation, Contracting States are not required to provide information the disclosure of which would be contrary to public policy (ordre public). This limitation should be applied only in extreme cases. For example, such a case may arise if a tax investigation in the requesting State was motivated by political, racial or religious persecution. The limitation may also apply where the information constitutes a State secret. For example, there is no requirement to disclose information where the secret services possess confidential information whose disclosure would be contrary to the vital interests of the requested State. Thus, issues of public policy (ordre public) rarely arise in the context of the exchange of information between treaty partners.
24. As discussed above, paragraph 3 may entitle the requested State to refuse to provide information in certain circumstances. However, there is no requirement to invoke any of the limitations provided for in that paragraph. If the requested State declines to exercise its right under paragraph 3 and provides the requested information, the exchange of information remains within the scope of Article 26. Consequently, the information is subject to the confidentiality rules set out in paragraph 2. Furthermore, the affected taxpayer or another third party has no grounds for claiming that the tax authorities of the requested State failed to comply with the obligations to maintain confidentiality imposed on them by national law.
25. Article 26 does not require the existence of criminal activity in either of the Contracting States for the obligation to exchange information to arise. Nevertheless, some international treaties require the existence of such criminal activity. In such treaties, it may be important to provide that the existence of criminal liability in the requesting State is sufficient to trigger the obligation to exchange information. As a precaution, some States that do not restrict their exchange of information to criminal cases may wish to specify expressly in their treaties that dual criminality is not required. To exclude the possibility of including in an international treaty a requirement that the conduct be recognized as a criminal offence in both States, the following paragraph could be added as paragraph 6, and the current paragraph 6 renumbered as paragraph 7:
6. The obligation to exchange information arises under paragraph 1 regardless of whether the person under investigation is suspected of criminal activity or not. Under no circumstances shall the provisions of this Article be interpreted as allowing a Contracting State to refuse to provide information solely on the grounds that the conduct under investigation would not constitute a criminal offence under the laws of that Contracting State if such conduct had taken place in that Contracting State.
Paragraph 4
26. Paragraph 4 was added to the United Nations Model Convention in 2011. It was taken directly from a similar provision of the OECD Model Convention. Consequently, the OECD Commentary on paragraph 4 is fully applicable to the interpretation of paragraph 4 of Article 26. The position set out in the OECD Commentary is that the addition of this paragraph was intended to assist in the interpretation of Article 26 and does not result in any substantial change to the obligations contemplated under the previous version of Article 26.
26.1 Under paragraph 4, the requested State must use its information-gathering measures to obtain the requested information, even if those measures are applied solely for the purpose of providing information to another Contracting State and regardless of whether the information could still be collected or used for domestic tax purposes in the requested Contracting State. Thus, for example, any restrictions on the ability of the requested Contracting State to obtain information from a person for domestic tax purposes at the time of the request (for example, because the limitation period under the domestic law of the requested State has expired or an audit has previously been completed) should not limit its ability to use its information-gathering measures for the purposes of exchanging information. The term "information-gathering measures" means laws and administrative or judicial procedures that enable a Contracting State to obtain and provide the requested information. That is, the requested State is not required to have a domestic tax interest in obtaining the requested information for the obligation to provide information under paragraph 1 to apply. Paragraph 4 does not require the requested Contracting State to provide information in circumstances where it has attempted to obtain the requested information but has discovered that the information no longer exists following the expiry of the domestic record-retention period. However, if the requested information is still available despite the expiry of such retention period, the requested State may not refuse to exchange the available information. Contracting States should ensure that reliable accounting records are retained for five years or more.
26.2 As indicated in the second sentence of paragraph 4, the obligation imposed by this paragraph is generally subject to the limitations contained in paragraph 3. However, an exception applies which prevents the requested State from avoiding its obligation to provide information by virtue of domestic laws or practice that include a requirement for a domestic tax interest. Thus, the requested State cannot avoid its obligation to provide information on the grounds that its domestic laws or practice allow it to provide only information in which it has an interest for its own tax purposes.
26.3 For many countries, the combination of paragraph 4 and their domestic laws provides a sufficient basis for using their information-gathering measures to obtain the requested information even in the absence of an interest on the part of the domestic tax authorities in that information. However, other countries may wish to clarify expressly in the Convention that Contracting States must ensure that their competent authorities have the necessary powers to do so. Contracting States wishing to clarify this point may replace paragraph 4 with the following text:
4. For the purposes of implementing the exchange of information provided for in paragraph 1, each Contracting State shall take the necessary measures, including legislative, regulatory or administrative measures, to ensure that its competent authority has sufficient powers under its domestic law to obtain information for the exchange of information, regardless of whether that Contracting State may require such information for its own tax purposes.
Paragraph 5
27. Paragraph 5 was added to the United Nations Model Convention in 2011. It was taken directly from a similar provision of the OECD Model Convention. Consequently, the OECD Commentary on paragraph 5 is fully applicable to the interpretation of paragraph 5 of Article 26. The discussion below of limitations on confidentiality is largely based on the OECD Commentary. The position set out in the OECD Commentary is that the addition of this paragraph was intended to assist in the interpretation of Article 26 and does not result in any substantial change to the obligations contemplated under the previous version of Article 26.
27.1 Paragraph 1 imposes a positive obligation on a Contracting State to exchange all types of information. Paragraph 5 is intended to ensure that the limitations set out in paragraph 3 cannot be used to prevent the exchange of information held by banks, other financial institutions, nominees, agents and fiduciaries, as well as information concerning ownership.
27.2 Paragraph 5 states that the requested State should not refuse to provide information to the requesting State solely because the requested information is held by a bank or other financial institution. Thus, paragraph 5 overrides paragraph 3 to the extent that paragraph 3 would otherwise allow the requested Contracting State to refuse to provide information on the basis of domestic bank secrecy laws. Access to information held by banks or other financial institutions may be obtained directly or indirectly through judicial or administrative proceedings. The indirect access procedure should not be so burdensome and time-consuming as to impede access to banking information.
27.3 Paragraph 5 also provides that a Contracting State should not refuse to provide information solely because that information is held by persons acting in an agency or fiduciary capacity. For example, if a Contracting State has a law under which all information held by a trustee is treated as "professional secrecy" merely because it is held by a trustee, that State cannot use such law as grounds for refusing to provide information held by the trustee to another Contracting State. A person acts in a "fiduciary capacity" when the business in which that person is engaged, or the money or property managed by that person, is not owned by that person or intended for that person's own benefit, but is used for the benefit of another person, and when the fiduciary has a relationship with that other person that implies and requires confidence and trust on the one hand and good faith on the other. A trustee is a typical example of a person acting in a fiduciary capacity. The term "agency" is very broad and includes all forms of corporate services (for example, company formation agents, trust companies, registered agents and lawyers).
27.4 Paragraph 5 states that a Contracting State should not refuse to provide information solely because the requested information relates to an ownership interest in an entity, including companies and partnerships, foundations or similar organizational structures. Requests for information cannot be rejected solely because domestic laws or practice may treat ownership information as a commercial or other secret.
27.5 Although paragraph 5 limits the ability of the requested State to rely on paragraph 3 to refuse to provide information held by a bank, financial institution, person acting in an agency or fiduciary capacity, or to refuse to provide information relating to ownership interests, this paragraph does not eliminate all the protections provided for in paragraph 3. The requested State may continue to refuse to provide such information if the refusal is based on substantial grounds unrelated to the status of the holder of the requested information as a bank, financial institution, agent, fiduciary or nominee, or to the fact that the information relates to ownership interests.
27.6 Paragraph 5 does not necessarily prevent the requested State from refusing, pursuant to paragraph 3(b), to provide information constituting confidential communications between a lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative and his or her client, even if that person acts in an agency capacity. However, in order to claim protection under paragraph 3(b), the requested State must demonstrate that the communication between the lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative and the client meets all the requirements of that paragraph, including that the communication is protected from disclosure under domestic law, that refusal to provide protection may be challenged in court, that the refusal to disclose is unrelated to the status of the legal representative as an agent, fiduciary or nominee, that any disputed documents were not transferred to the legal representative to avoid disclosure, and that non-disclosure would not impede effective exchange of information.
27.7 Contracting States wishing expressly to specify the protection afforded to confidential communications between a client and a lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative may do so by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 5:
Nothing in the preceding sentence shall prevent a Contracting State from refusing to obtain or provide information that would disclose confidential communications between a client and a lawyer, solicitor or other recognized legal representative, where such communications are protected from disclosure under paragraph 3(b) and where the claim for protection under that paragraph is unrelated to the status of the legal representative as an agent, fiduciary or nominee.
28. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 5:
(a) Company X owns a majority of the shares in subsidiary Y, and both companies are incorporated under the laws of State A. State B is conducting a tax audit of the business transactions of company Y in State B. In the course of this examination, the question of direct and indirect ownership of company Y becomes relevant, and State B sends a request to State A for information on the ownership of any entity in the ownership chain of company Y. In its response, State A should provide State B with information on the ownership of both company X and company Y.
(b) An individual who is taxable in State A has a bank account with Bank B in State B. State A is examining the individual's income tax return and sends a request to State B for all income from the bank account and information on the assets held by Bank B in order to determine whether deposits in the amount of ... constitute untaxed income. State B should provide the requested banking information to State A.
(c) Bank A in State A is suspected of entering into secret written agreements with certain of its depositors requiring the bank to pay interest earned by those depositors to an unrelated offshore bank. State B asks State A to provide copies of these secret letters of agreement. Bank A claims that the letters of agreement are legal documents protected from disclosure under the attorney-client confidentiality law. State A should provide the requested documents.
Paragraph 6
29. The wording of paragraph 6 was taken, with some modifications, from the last sentence of paragraph 1 of the United Nations Model Convention before its amendment in 2011. Paragraph 6 specifically empowers the competent authorities to establish procedures for effective exchange of information. The OECD Model Convention does not contain paragraph 6 or its equivalent. The position set out in the OECD Commentary is that these powers are implicit in Article 26.
29.1 For the purposes of implementing the exchange of information under the preceding paragraphs of this Article, paragraph 6 provides that the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall jointly work to establish procedures for the exchange of information, including routine exchanges, generally in electronic form. Although paragraph 6 does not require them to adopt such arrangements in advance of the need for a specific exchange of information arising, this is strongly recommended to ensure effective exchange of information.
29.2 Some States may wish to specify expressly in their international treaties that the competent authorities are required not only to exchange information upon request but also to make arrangements for automatic and spontaneous exchange of information. These countries may wish to add the following wording at the end of paragraph 6:
In addition to responding to specific requests for information, the competent authorities shall exchange information on a regular and spontaneous basis. They shall agree from time to time on the types of information or documents to be provided on a regular basis.
29.3 Some members of the Committee expressed concern that requests for information from a developed country to a developing country could create an excessive burden for the tax department in the developing country because of differences in the capacity of their tax administrations to obtain and provide information. This problem could be addressed by making the requesting State responsible for substantial extraordinary expenses associated with a request for information. In this context, whether extraordinary expenses incurred in obtaining the requested information are substantial may be determined not by reference to any absolute amount, but by reference to the costs in relation to the overall budget of the tax department from which the information is requested. For example, small absolute costs may be substantial for a tax department with very limited resources, whereas large absolute costs may be insignificant for a well-funded department.
29.4 Countries concerned that developing countries may incur significant expenses may include the following wording at the end of paragraph 6:
Extraordinary expenses incurred in providing information shall be borne by the Contracting Party requesting the information. The competent authorities of the Contracting Parties shall consult with each other in advance if the costs of providing information in connection with a particular request are expected to be extraordinary.
29.5 Countries may wish to improve the efficiency and timeliness of the exchange of information under this Article by agreeing on time limits for providing information. Countries may do so by adding the following wording at the end of paragraph 6:
The competent authorities of the Contracting States may agree on time limits for providing information under this Article. In the absence of such an agreement, information shall be provided as quickly as possible and, except where the delay is caused by legal impediments, within the following time limits:
(a) If the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State already possess the requested information, such information shall be provided to the competent authority of the other Contracting State within two months from the date of receipt of the request for information.
(b) If the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State do not yet possess the requested information, such information shall be provided to the competent authority of the other Contracting State within six months from the date of receipt of the request for information.
Subject to compliance with the other provisions of this Article, the exchange of information shall be considered to have been carried out in accordance with the provisions of this Article even if the information is provided after the expiry of the specified time limits.
29.6 Subparagraphs (a) and (b) of the optional wording at the end of paragraph 6, referred to in paragraph 29.5, establish a generally accepted standard for time limits, which will apply where the competent authorities have not reached another agreement on longer or shorter time limits. The default standard time limits are two months from receipt of the request for information if the requested information is already in the possession of the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State, and six months in all other cases. Notwithstanding the default standard time limits or any other agreed time limits, the competent authorities may reach different agreements in individual cases, for example, where both agree that more time is required. This may arise where the request is complex. In such a case, the competent authority of the requesting Contracting State should not unreasonably reject a request from the competent authority of the requested Contracting State for an extension of time.
If the requested Contracting State is unable to provide the requested information within the prescribed time limit because of legal impediments (for example, because of ongoing court proceedings concerning the validity of the taxpayer's request or ongoing court proceedings concerning domestic notification procedures described in paragraph 17), this would not constitute a breach of the prescribed time limits.
29.7 The additional wording at the end of paragraph 6, referred to in paragraph 29.5, provides that, subject to compliance with the other conditions of this Article, the exchange of information shall be deemed to have been carried out in accordance with the provisions of this Article even if it was provided after the expiry of the specified time limits. This clarifies that no objections to the use or admissibility of information exchanged under this Article may be based on the fact that the exchange of information took place after the expiry of the time limits agreed upon by the competent authorities or the default time limits provided for in this paragraph.
C. Overview of Information Exchange Mechanisms
30. Paragraphs 6–25 of the previous Commentary on Article 26 of the United Nations Model Convention, set out below with some editorial amendments, could be included in a handbook dealing with exchange mechanisms.
Regular Exchange of Information
6. One method of exchanging information is through the regular, or automatic, exchange of information between several countries that are Parties to the Treaty.⁵⁵ Various aspects to which the competent authorities should pay particular attention when developing procedures for such regular exchange of information are discussed below. In considering regular exchange of information, it should be borne in mind that some countries that do not wish to receive such information on a regular basis (or are unable to receive it on a regular basis because the transmitting countries do not regularly collect such information) may prefer to receive this type of information in response to specific requests. In that case, the information discussed in this section may also be provided by the method discussed in the following section, entitled "Transmission of Information in Response to Specific Requests".
____________________________
⁵⁵
____________________________
- The term “transmitting country” means the country transmitting the information, and the term “receiving country” means the country receiving the information.
Information to be transmitted
7. Regular sources of income. Information that is the subject of regular transmission or exchange may include data on regular sources of income transmitted between countries, such as dividends, interest, remuneration (including wages, salaries, fees and commissions), royalties, rents and other possible payments, the regular transmission of which between the two countries concerned constitutes a significant amount. It should be acknowledged that, at present, only a few countries are unable to regularly provide information of this kind because their tax collection procedures do not provide for the collection of the necessary data.
Transactions involving a taxpayer. The regular exchange of information may cover certain significant transactions involving taxpayers:
a) transactions relating to the agreement itself:
— claims submitted by residents of the receiving country for reimbursement of tax paid in the transmitting country;
— claims submitted by residents of the receiving country for exemption from taxes of the transmitting country or for the granting of certain benefits to them;
b) transactions relating to specific aspects of the legislation of the transmitting country: information on income of residents of the receiving country that is subject to special provisions of the national legislation of the transmitting country concerning full or partial tax exemptions;
c) transactions relating to the activities of residents of the receiving country in the transmitting country:
— the opening and closure by residents of the receiving country of offices, branches, etc. in the transmitting country;
— the establishment or liquidation by residents of the receiving country of corporations in the transmitting country;
— the establishment or liquidation by residents of the receiving country of trusts in the transmitting country;
— the opening and closure by residents of the receiving country of bank accounts in the transmitting country;
— property received by residents of the receiving country in the transmitting country by way of inheritance, bequest or gift;
— additional probate procedures in the transmitting country involving residents of the receiving country;
d) general information:
— laws, administrative procedures, etc. of the transmitting country;
— changes in the structure of regular sources of income transmitted between the countries, particularly insofar as they affect the agreement, including interpretations of the provisions of the agreement by administrative authorities and judicial decisions and administrative practice concerning them, or events affecting the application of this agreement;
— activities affecting or distorting the application of the provisions of the agreement, including new techniques or methods of tax evasion or avoidance used by residents of the transmitting or receiving country;
— activities having consequences for the tax system of the receiving country, including new techniques or methods of tax evasion or avoidance used by residents of either country that have a significant impact on the tax system of the receiving country.
General operational aspects to be taken into account
8. The competent authorities should take into account various factors that may affect the operational nature of the regular exchange of information, including its effectiveness. For example:
a) countries that are more interested in receiving information in response to specific requests rather than on a regular basis should, when determining the scope of the information they request, take into account the information listed in this overview in the section dealing with the regular exchange of information;
b) a minimum threshold may be established in order to limit the volume of information of little significance;
c) an annual rotation of the categories of information on sources of income provided on a regular basis may be envisaged: for example, in one year, information may be provided only on dividends, and in the following year, information only on interest, etc.;
d) the regular exchange of information does not necessarily have to be fully symmetrical. Country A may be interested in receiving information on certain items but not on others; Country B may prefer other information; there is no need for both parties to receive information on items in which they have no interest; nor should either of these countries be allowed to refuse to provide information on certain items solely on the grounds that it is not itself interested in receiving equivalent information;
e) although the information exchanged on items of income may not always be significant in terms of identifying income concealed from taxation, the regular exchange of information may provide an indication of the extent to which capital or other assets constituting the sources of the income transmitted are being concealed from taxation;
f) another issue to be resolved is whether information on income should be limited to information about the recipients of payments or whether it should also include information about the payers;
g) another factor to be taken into account is whether this information should cover only residents of the receiving country, also include persons domiciled in that country or its citizens, or be limited to any one of the above categories;
h) the degree of detail of the information provided should be taken into account, for example, the indication of the name of the taxpayer or recipient, occupation, address, etc.;
i) another point to be taken into account is the form and language of the information provided.
Factors to be taken into account by the transmitting country
9. The transmitting country may wish to take into account factors affecting its ability to meet the requirements associated with the regular exchange of information. It is envisaged that consideration of these factors should lead to a more careful selection of the scope of information subject to regular exchange, rather than to a decision not to exchange information that may be practically useful.
10. The factors to be taken into account include the ability of the administrative authorities of the transmitting country to obtain the relevant information. This ability, in turn, is determined by the overall effectiveness of its administrative procedures, the use of tax withholding, the use of information received from payers or other persons, and the overall amount of the costs of obtaining the relevant information.
Factors to be taken into account by the receiving country
11. The receiving country may wish to take into account factors affecting its ability to use the information that may be obtained through the regular exchange of information, such as the ability of the administrative authorities of the receiving country to use this information sufficiently promptly and to effectively match it with their own data on their taxpayers, either on a regular basis or on a sufficiently large scale to justify the regular receipt of such information.
Transmission of information in response to specific requests
12. At present, a widely used method of exchanging information is for one country that is a party to an agreement to request another country to provide specific information. This information may relate to a particular taxpayer and certain aspects of that taxpayer's situation, or to specific types of transactions or activities, or to information of a more general nature. The various aspects to which the competent authorities should pay particular attention when developing procedures for such an exchange of information in response to specific requests are considered below.
Information to be transmitted
13. Specific taxpayers. The scope of information that may be requested from the transmitting country in respect of a particular taxpayer of the receiving country is, in essence, unlimited and depends on the factors affecting the position of that taxpayer within the tax system of the receiving country and on the relationship between that taxpayer and the taxpayer's activities and the transmitting country. It would appear that attempts to determine in advance the specific information that may be provided in the course of an exchange of information in response to a specific request are unlikely to be fruitful or necessary. Accordingly, an agreement on the provision of information in response to specific requests need not provide for any restrictions on the scope, volume or type of information to be provided, subject to the general limitations discussed in this document.
14. A request for the provision of specific information may be prompted by a wide variety of reasons. For example:
a) information is necessary for the final determination of the amount of taxes payable by a taxpayer in the receiving country, where the amount of taxes payable depends on the taxpayer's worldwide income or assets; the nature of the participation of corporations of the receiving country in the share capital of a corporation in the transmitting country; the amount or category of expenses incurred in the transmitting country; and the domicile of an individual or legal entity for tax purposes;
b) information is necessary to establish the accuracy of a taxpayer's tax return submitted to the tax administration of the receiving country, or the accuracy of the taxpayer's claims or the evidence submitted by the taxpayer in support of the tax return, where such tax return gives rise to suspicion or is the subject of an actual investigation;
c) information is necessary to establish the true amount of taxes payable by a taxpayer in the receiving country where there are suspicions that the information provided by the taxpayer concerning the taxes payable is inaccurate.
Specific types of transactions or activities. An exchange of information in response to a specific request is by no means necessarily limited to the provision of information in response to requests concerning specific taxpayers. It may include the provision, upon an appropriate request, of information relating to specific types of transactions or activities. For example:
a) information on the price, cost, commissions or other similar indicators in the transmitting country, which is necessary for the tax authorities of the receiving country either to determine the taxes payable in a particular situation or to develop standards for conducting investigations into relevant taxpayers in situations involving the possible undervaluation or overvaluation of charges for exported or imported goods, the payment of commissions in international transactions, etc.;
b) information on the typical methods by which specific transactions or types of activities are usually carried out in the transmitting country;
c) information on whether a particular type of activity that may affect the position of taxpayers or the amount of taxes payable in the receiving country is carried out in the transmitting country.
15. Economic relations between countries. A specific request may concern information on particular economic relations between countries that may be useful to a country in assessing the effectiveness of the activities of its tax authorities, for example:
a) information on the volume of exports from the transmitting country to the receiving country;
b) information on the volume of imports from the receiving country into the transmitting country;
c) the names of banks conducting transactions in the transmitting country with offices, branches, etc. of residents of the receiving country.
It should be noted that, since information falling within this category, such as data on the volume of exports between countries, is presumably not regarded by the tax authorities of the transmitting country as confidential information, it may be freely disclosed in the receiving country, as provided for in Article 26.
Rules applicable to specific requests
16. The competent authorities should develop rules applicable to the submission of specific requests by the receiving country and the preparation of responses by the transmitting country. These rules should be developed in such a way as to facilitate a systematic and prompt procedure governing such an exchange of information, which would be effective and orderly. Although these rules may be general in nature in the sense that they establish standards or guidelines governing specific procedures relating to a request, they should also allow the competent authorities to discuss specific situations which, in the opinion of either country, require special treatment. These rules should regulate:
a) the degree of specificity of the particulars that must be contained in a request by the receiving country, the form of such request, and the language of the request and response;
b) the extent to which the receiving country must use or exhaust its own administrative procedures and capabilities before submitting a specific request; it is envisaged that the receiving country should make good-faith efforts to obtain the information independently before resorting to the procedure of submitting a specific request;
c) the conditions affecting the nature and scope of the response prepared by the transmitting country. This aspect should include the ability of the transmitting country to provide documentation where the receiving country requires materials in such form for use in judicial or other proceedings, including the proper authentication of documents.
Transmission of information on the initiative of the transmitting country (spontaneous exchange of information)
17. The competent authorities should decide whether, in addition to information obtained through the use of methods of regular exchange of information and the transmission of information in response to specific requests, under which the transmitting country automatically sends information or systematically responds to specific requests from the receiving country, they wish to provide information on the initiative of the transmitting country itself. Such information may be transmitted in cases where the tax authorities of the transmitting country, in the course of their activities, obtain information that they consider important for the receiving country. This information may relate to specific aspects of the position of a particular taxpayer and the relationship of that position to the taxes payable by that taxpayer in the receiving country, or to the taxes payable by other taxpayers in the receiving country. In addition, this information may relate to the dynamics of transactions or the conduct of various taxpayers or groups of taxpayers in the transmitting or receiving country that are highly likely to affect the amount of taxes payable or the assessment and collection of taxes in the receiving country, either by virtue of its domestic legislation or the provisions of an agreement.
18. Guided by the standards governing the exchange of information developed pursuant to the agreement, the competent authorities should decide whether the transmitting country is to be required to develop a constructive procedure and guidelines governing when such information should be transmitted, whether the question of transmitting such information should be decided by the transmitting country, albeit entirely at its own discretion, or whether the question of such transmission should not be considered by the transmitting country at all. Even if a decision is made that the development of a system for transmitting such information is an obligation of the transmitting country, it is envisaged that this country itself will decide, at its own discretion, whether the conditions provided for under this system have been met.
Use of information received
19. The competent authorities will have to decide on the permissible use of the information received. The resolution of this issue essentially depends on the legal requirements set out in Article 26 itself. The extent to which the information may be used depends primarily on the requirements of domestic legislation concerning the disclosure of tax information or other “confidentiality requirements” relating to tax information. At the same time, it is possible that the degree of disclosure or the strictness of restrictions on disclosure in the two countries participating in the exchange of information may differ. However, the possible existence of such differences should not be regarded as improper or as nullifying an exchange of information that would otherwise take place, provided that the countries participating in it are satisfied with this situation arising from Article 26, as agreed by them upon adoption of the Convention.
Recipients of information received as a result of the exchange
20. The competent authorities will have to clearly specify — either by providing a detailed list or by referring to existing comparable rules in the receiving country — who in that country is entitled to receive the information. Under Article 26, information may, for example, be disclosed to:
a) persons or authorities involved in the assessment or collection of taxes covered by the Convention;
b) persons or authorities involved in the enforcement or prosecution for the purpose of enforcing decisions relating to such taxation;
c) administrative tribunals dealing with appeals relating to such taxes;
d) judicial tribunals dealing with cases relating to such taxes;
e) during public court hearings or in judicial decisions, in cases where this information may be made available to the public if a decision is taken that such a step is appropriate;
f) the competent authorities of another country (see the section below entitled “Consultations between several competent authorities”).
Form in which information is provided
21. The permissible degree of disclosure of information may affect the form in which such information is provided in order to make it useful to the receiving country. Thus, if the information may be used by judicial authorities and if, for the purposes of such use, it must have a particular nature or form, the competent authorities will have to decide how to ensure that the information is provided in a form that meets this requirement (see also the commentary concerning documents in the section above dealing with the rules applicable to specific requests).
Consultations between several competent authorities
22. Countries may wish to consider procedures developed by the competent authorities for conducting consultations involving more than two competent authorities under a particular agreement. Thus, if Countries A, B and C are linked by a system of agreements, the competent authorities of A, B and C may wish to hold joint consultations. Holding a joint meeting may be desirable irrespective of whether there is a network of agreements directly linking all three countries. For example, holding a joint meeting may be desirable where there are agreements between A and B, A and C, as well as B and C, or between A and B and B and C, but not between A and C. Countries wishing to have their competent authorities participate in such consultations should establish a legal basis for conducting such consultations by adding to their agreements a provision granting the necessary powers. Some countries may consider that Article 26 permits joint consultations in cases where all three countries are directly linked by bilateral agreements. However, the guidelines56 do not regulate joint consultations where — as in the second situation described above — the system of agreements between the countries is not fully closed. In such a case, it is necessary to add to the agreement a provision authorizing the competent authorities of Country B to provide information received from Country A to the competent authorities of Country C. Such a contractual provision could contain a guarantee that the competent authority of Country A must give its consent to such actions by the competent authority of Country B. It is envisaged that the said authorities will give such consent only in cases where they are satisfied with the provisions of the agreement between B and C governing the maintenance of confidentiality.
56 See the United Nations Manual for the Negotiation of Bilateral Tax Treaties between Developed and Developing Countries [2003], Part Three, Chapter III, Section E. Available at: http://www.un.org/esa/ffd/tax/.
General factors
23. There are a number of general factors affecting the exchange of information in respect of which the competent authorities will need to decide, after careful consideration, whether they should be taken into account either because of their impact on specific operational aspects of the exchange of information or because of their impact on the exchange of information process as a whole. These general factors include those described below.
Factors affecting the implementation of the exchange of information
These factors include the following:
a) the competent authorities should decide on the communication channels for various types of information exchange. One possible method of communication is to authorize an official of one country to visit the other country in person in order to obtain information from the competent authority and discuss it for the purpose of accelerating the information exchange process;
b) some countries may consider it useful and appropriate for one country to station representatives of its tax authorities in another country that is a party to the agreement. Such an arrangement will most likely be determined by powers, an agreement or arrangements, rather than by the Article on the exchange of information in the proposed tax treaty (although this Article may be regarded as regulating this issue if this does not conflict with the domestic legislation of either country), and such an arrangement will determine the conditions governing the presence of such representatives and their functions. In this connection, it should be noted that this process does not necessarily have to be reciprocal, that is, a situation in which Country A has its representatives in Country B, but not vice versa, is entirely permissible if Country A considers this process useful and Country B does not. If arrangements for sending such representatives are in place, the competent authorities may wish to coordinate their activities with these representatives in situations where such coordination makes the information exchange process more effective or where such coordination is considered appropriate for other reasons;
c) some countries may consider it appropriate for one of the employees of the tax authorities of one country to participate directly in a joint or “group” investigation of a particular taxpayer or activity conducted by the tax authority of another country. In most countries, the use of this procedure will most likely be determined by powers, an agreement or arrangements, rather than by the Article on the exchange of information in the proposed treaty, although countries may consider this Article as authorizing the competent authorities to approve the use of this procedure, provided that it does not conflict with the domestic legislation of either country. In any event, if a decision is made to use this procedure, it would appear appropriate to extend to such investigations the safeguards and procedures developed under the Article on the exchange of information in the proposed treaty;
d) procedures for the exchange of information should be developed in such a way as to be sufficiently relevant to the effective implementation of the substantive provisions of the treaty. Thus, the provisions of the treaty concerning transfer pricing and the allocation of income and expenses contain their own requirements for the exchange of information necessary for their effective implementation. The information exchange process should take such requirements into account;
e) the substantive provisions of the treaty should take into account the existence and requirements of information exchange procedures. Thus, if there is an adequate information base for the information exchange process that allows one country to deduct expenses incurred in another country from the taxable amount, the question of the fundamental acceptability of such deductions should be resolved when preparing the treaty;
f) the competent authorities should decide to what extent the costs associated with the information exchange process should be shared or reimbursed jointly.
Factors affecting the structure of the information exchange process
24. These factors include the following:
a) it should be acknowledged that the procedures for the exchange of information developed between Country A and Country B do not necessarily have to coincide with similar procedures for the exchange of information between Country A and Country C or between Country B and Country C. These procedures should primarily meet the needs of the two countries directly participating in the exchange of information and should not fully duplicate, in each case, the procedures used in relations between other countries for the sake of formal uniformity. At the same time, it should be noted that solving the problem of preventing tax evasion and avoidance at the international level will often require international cooperation between the tax authorities of several countries. Consequently, some countries may consider it appropriate to develop procedures and contractual provisions that are sufficiently flexible to enable consultations involving multiple countries and information exchange mechanisms to be conducted within the framework of the cooperation provided for therein;
b) the competent authorities will have to weigh the consequences of the existence of restrictions under the domestic law of the country requesting information from another country whose domestic legislation does not contain similar restrictions. Thus, suppose that Country A requests information from Country B, and the tax authorities in Country B have the ability to approach domestic financial institutions to obtain such information, whereas the tax authorities in Country A are generally not entitled to approach domestic financial institutions to obtain information for tax purposes. How should this issue be treated in Country B? It should be noted that, in this case, Article 26 allows Country B to obtain information from domestic financial institutions and transmit it to Country A. Thus, the domestic legislation of Country B governing the confidentiality of tax information does not prevent it from obtaining and transmitting such information if the relevant decision is made. Accordingly, the question of whether Country B should provide information in response to the request should be decided by that country entirely at its own discretion and may well be the subject of negotiations between the competent authorities. It should be noted that, in practice, many countries provide information in response to requests in similar situations and that this proves genuinely useful in ensuring an effective exchange of information for the purposes of preventing tax avoidance. At the same time, it should also be noted that Country A, which submits requests to other countries for the provision of information in such cases, should in turn acknowledge its own obligation to attempt to amend its domestic legislation in order to strengthen the powers of its own tax authorities at the national level, so that they too may provide information in response to requests from other countries. It should be borne in mind that a country that has signed a tax convention which includes paragraph 5 of Article 26 of the United Nations Model Convention is obliged to provide information to the other party to that Convention irrespective of the provisions of its domestic legislation governing bank secrecy;
c) in addition to the situations of legal imbalance considered above, the competent authorities will have to take into account the consequences of possible disparities arising from differences in other aspects of tax administration and assessment and collection of taxes. Thus, if Country A is unable to provide information in response to requests to the same extent as Country B because of practical problems with tax administration and collection activities in Country A, could the exchange of information be reduced to a level corresponding to the capabilities of Country A? In other words, should Country B, generally or in specific aspects, be prepared to satisfy requests for information received from Country A even in cases where Country A is unable to satisfy requests from Country B? This question is similar to the one considered in the preceding paragraph, and the answer should be the same;
d) it should be noted that Article 26 authorizes the transmitting country to use its own administrative procedures exclusively for the purpose of providing information to the requesting country, even in cases where the person whose information is requested is not a party to tax proceedings in the transmitting country. In addition, for the purposes of the exchange of information, the transmitting country must use its own administrative powers in exactly the same way as if its own taxation were concerned;
e) the competent authorities will have to take into account the effect on the information exchange process of a prevailing belief in one country that the tax system or the system of tax assessment and collection of another country, as a whole or in specific situations, is discriminatory or confiscatory in nature. It is quite possible that a more in-depth analysis of such a belief may lead to the inclusion in the treaty or in domestic legislation of substantive provisions that will entirely eliminate the existing problems, as perceived by the first country, and thereby facilitate the information exchange process. One possible example of such a provision is the regime for non-permanent residents;
f) the competent authorities will have to take into account the possible consequences of the information exchange process for the competitiveness of taxpayers in the respective countries. Thus, if Country A has an agreement with Country B providing for the exchange of information, Country A will have to take into account the impact on the structure or process of information exchange of the fact that Country C does not have a similar agreement with Country B, so that the position of companies of Country C operating in Country B may differ, from a tax perspective, from the position of companies of Country A. Likewise, even where there is an agreement between Countries C and B containing an Article on the exchange of information, a similar difference in the position of companies from different countries from a tax perspective may also arise in cases where the tax authorities of Country A have broader powers to obtain information (for the purpose of exchanging it with Country B) than the tax authorities of Country C, or are more effective in their activities in other respects and thus have access to a greater amount of information. Thus, it appears evident that the proper implementation of the provisions on the exchange of information requires the tax authorities of all countries to make universal efforts to establish and develop, in accordance with the rules of domestic law, their capacity to obtain information and their ability to use the information required for highly effective and fair tax assessment and collection.
Periodic consultations and reviews
25. Since differences in interpretation and application, specific difficulties, and unforeseen problems and situations will inevitably arise, effective and prompt consultations between the competent authorities should be provided for. Such consultations should be held both to consider specific situations and problems and to periodically review the activities provided for under the provision on the exchange of information. Periodic reviews should ensure that the exchange of information is carried out with the required promptness and effectiveness in the interests of meeting the basic requirements for the implementation of the provisions of the treaty and should contribute to adequate compliance with the contractual provisions and the domestic legislation of both countries.
Article 27
ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES
1. This Article provides for rules under which the Contracting States57 may agree to provide mutual assistance in the collection of taxes. In some States, domestic legislation or policy may not permit this form of assistance or may impose restrictions on its provision. At the same time, in certain cases, for administrative reasons, the provision of assistance in the collection of taxes to another State may be considered unjustified or, for the same reason, it may be necessary to limit such assistance. Accordingly, during negotiations, each Contracting State should decide whether assistance should be provided to the other State and, if so, to what extent, taking into account various factors, including:
57 In the text of this Commentary on Article 27, the State requesting assistance is referred to as the “requesting State”, whereas the State to which the request for assistance is addressed is referred to as the “requested State”.
— the position established in domestic legislation on the issue of providing assistance in the collection of taxes of other States;
— whether there is similarity between the tax systems, tax administration and legal standards of the two States and, if so, the degree of such similarity, particularly with regard to the protection of the fundamental rights of taxpayers (for example, the timely and proper delivery of a notice of tax arrears to a taxpayer, the right to maintain the confidentiality of taxpayer information, the right to lodge an appeal, the right to be heard and to present arguments and evidence, the right to assistance from a lawyer of the taxpayer's choice, the right to a fair trial, etc.);
— whether assistance in the collection of taxes will be balanced and mutually beneficial for both States;
— whether the tax administration of each State is capable of ensuring the effective provision of such assistance;
— whether the costs of providing such assistance would be excessively high for the requested State in view of the amount of money involved;
— whether trade and investment flows between the two States are sufficient to justify this form of assistance; or
— whether the list of taxes covered by this Article should be restricted for constitutional or other reasons.
This Article should be included in the Convention only if each State concludes, on the basis of these factors, that all States can agree to provide assistance in the collection of taxes levied by another State.
2. This Article provides for comprehensive assistance in the collection of taxes. Some States may prefer to provide a more limited form of assistance in the collection of taxes. This may be the only form of assistance in the collection of taxes that they are generally able to provide or that they may agree upon in any particular Convention. For example, a State may wish to limit assistance to cases where the benefits under the Convention (for example, a reduction in taxes in the State where income such as interest arises) have been claimed by persons who are not entitled to them. States wishing to provide such limited assistance in the collection of taxes may, without restriction, adopt the following alternative version of the Article on a bilateral basis:
Article 27
ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES
1. The Contracting States shall provide each other with assistance in the collection of taxes to the extent necessary to prevent the use of any exemption or reduced rate of tax granted under this Convention by persons who are not entitled to such benefits. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, determine the manner in which this Article is to be applied.
2. In no case shall the provisions of this Article be construed so as to impose on a Contracting State an obligation:
a) to carry out administrative measures that are contrary to the laws and administrative practice of that or the other Contracting State;
b) to carry out measures that would be contrary to public policy (ordre public).
Clarify the opening numberingSeparate the alternative Article 27 text
Текст извлечён из загруженного Markdown-файла. Ниже привожу полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением исходной структуры, заголовков, нумерации, абзацев, маркированных пунктов, сносок и выделения курсивом.
Перевод выполнен без сокращения содержания и намеренного изменения смысла. Обозначения, пропуски и незаполненные поля оригинала сохранены.
English Translation
Paragraph 1
3. This paragraph contains the principle according to which a Contracting State is obliged to provide assistance to another State in the collection of taxes due to it, provided that the provisions of this Article are complied with. Paragraphs 3 and 4 provide for two forms of such assistance.
4. This paragraph also provides that the assistance rendered under this Article is not limited to Articles 1 and 2. For this reason, assistance must be provided with respect to the collection of tax arrears owed by any person to either Contracting State, regardless of whether or not that person is a resident of a Contracting State. However, some Contracting States may wish to limit the provision of assistance to taxes owed by residents of either Contracting State. Such States may, at their discretion, limit the scope of this Article by deleting the reference to Article 1 from this paragraph.
5. Paragraph 1 of this Article concerns the exchange of information for the purposes of the provisions of this Article. This ensures the confidentiality of information exchanged for the purpose of providing assistance in the collection of taxes.
6. Finally, this paragraph provides that the competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, decide on the details of the practical application of the provisions of this Article.
7. Such an arrangement should, in particular, concern the documentation that must accompany a request for assistance made pursuant to paragraph 3 or 4. It is generally accepted that a request for assistance should be accompanied by such documentation as required under the law of the requested State, or that an agreement on this matter should be reached by the competent authorities of the Contracting States, and that it should be necessary, depending on the circumstances, to collect the tax arrears or to take measures to preserve the tax claims. Such documentation may include, for example, a statement that the claim for the recovery of tax arrears is enforceable and that the debtor is a person who, under the law of the requesting State, cannot prevent its collection, or the submission of an official copy of the international instrument authorizing the enforced collection of tax arrears in the requesting State. In addition, an official translation of this documentation into the language of the requested State should also be provided. Where necessary, it may also be agreed that the instrument authorizing the enforced collection of tax arrears in the requesting State, where appropriate and consistent with the provisions applicable in the requested State, should, as soon as possible after receipt of the request for assistance, be approved, recognized, supplemented or replaced by an instrument authorizing the enforced collection of taxes in the requested State.
8. In addition, an agreement should also be reached on the costs that may be incurred by the requested State in complying with a request made pursuant to paragraph 3 or 4. As a general rule, the costs of collecting tax arrears are charged to the debtor, but it is necessary to determine which State will bear the costs that cannot be recovered from that person. The usual practice in this regard is that, in the absence of an agreement concerning the particular case, ordinary costs incurred by one State in providing assistance to another State are not reimbursed by that other State. Ordinary costs are costs directly and normally associated with the collection of taxes, that is, expected costs arising in the course of the ordinary domestic tax collection procedure. However, in the case of extraordinary costs, the generally accepted practice is that they are borne by the requesting State, unless otherwise agreed bilaterally. Such costs include, for example, costs associated with applying a special type of procedure at the request of another State, or additional costs for the services of experts, interpreters or translators. Most States also consider court proceedings and bankruptcy proceedings to be extraordinary costs. The agreement should provide for a definition of extraordinary costs, and consultations should be held between the Contracting States in any particular case involving possible extraordinary costs. At the same time, it should also be agreed that, as soon as one of the Contracting States anticipates that extraordinary costs may arise, it should inform the other Contracting State and indicate the approximate amount of such costs so that the other State can decide whether those costs are acceptable. Of course, the Contracting States may also provide for the allocation of costs on a basis different from the approach described above; this may be necessary, for example, in the event of the suspension of enforcement or withdrawal of a request for assistance in the collection of tax arrears pursuant to paragraph 7, or where the issue of costs incurred in connection with the provision of assistance in collecting tax arrears has already been resolved by another legal instrument applicable to those States. Finally, the agreement should take into account differences in the level of development of the Contracting States. Accordingly, it may be agreed that all costs, including ordinary costs, will be borne by only one State. In such a case, the Contracting States should reach agreement on the amount of such costs. They may be determined, for example, on the basis of a fixed amount.
9. The competent authorities may also address other practical matters in this agreement, such as:
— Whether a time limit should be established after the expiry of which a request for assistance in respect of the recovery of a particular tax arrear can no longer be made?
— What exchange rate should apply when tax arrears are collected in a currency other than the currency used in the requesting State?
— How should any amount collected pursuant to a request made under paragraph 3 be transferred to the requesting State? or
— Whether a minimum threshold amount should be established below which assistance will not be provided?
Paragraph 2
10. Paragraph 2 defines the term "tax arrears" for the purposes of this Article. This definition applies to any amount of tax arrears in respect of all taxes levied on behalf of the Contracting States, or their political subdivisions or local authorities, but only insofar as the levying of such taxes is not contrary to the Convention or other instruments in force between the Contracting States. It also covers interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or preservation of that amount of tax arrears. Thus, assistance is not limited to taxes generally covered by the Convention under Article 2, as confirmed in paragraph 1.
11. Some Contracting States may prefer to limit the scope of this Article to taxes covered by the Convention under the general rules of Article 2. States wishing to do so should replace paragraphs 1 and 2 with the following paragraphs:
1. The Contracting States shall provide each other with assistance in the recovery of tax arrears. Such assistance shall not be limited by Article 1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, settle the manner of application of this Article.
2. The term "recovery of tax arrears", as used in this Article, means any amount of tax due that is covered by the Convention, together with interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or preservation of such amount.
12. Similarly, some Contracting States may wish to limit the types of taxes to which the provisions of this Article apply and clarify the scope of these provisions by including a detailed list of taxes in the definition. States wishing to do so may, at their discretion, adopt the following definition bilaterally:
The term "recovery of tax arrears", as used in this Article, means any amount of the following taxes due and collected by the Contracting States, together with interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or preservation of such amount:
a) (in State A): \_ \_
b) (in State B): \_ \_
13. In order to ensure that the competent authorities are able to exchange information freely for the purposes of this Article, the Contracting States should take measures to ensure that the text of this Article is drafted in such a way as to permit the exchange of information in respect of any tax covered by this Article.
14. Nothing in this Convention prevents the application of the provisions of this Article to the recovery of tax arrears that arose before the Convention entered into force, since assistance in recovering such arrears is provided after the Convention has entered into force and after the provisions of this Article have become effective. However, the Contracting States may consider it appropriate to clarify the limits of the applicability of the provisions of this Article to such tax arrears, particularly if the provisions governing the entry into force of their Convention stipulate that the provisions of the Convention will apply to taxes imposed or collected from a specified date. States wishing to limit the scope of this Article to tax arrears that arose after the entry into force of the Convention may, at their discretion, freely resolve this matter during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 3
15. This paragraph sets out the conditions under which a request for assistance in the collection of tax arrears may be made. The recovery of tax arrears must be enforceable under the laws of the requesting State, and the debtor must be a person who, at that time, is unable under the laws of that State to prevent the collection of the tax arrears. This will be the case where the requesting State is entitled, under its domestic law, to collect the tax arrears and the person who owes the amount in question has no administrative or judicial remedies available to prevent such collection.
16. In many States, tax arrears are collected even where a right exists to lodge an appeal with an administrative authority or court concerning the validity or amount of the arrears. If, however, the domestic law of the requested State does not permit the collection of tax arrears while an appeal is pending, this paragraph does not permit such collection in the case of tax arrears of another State in respect of which the right of appeal remains in force, even if that right cannot prevent the recovery of the arrears in that other State. Indeed, the phrase "collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its laws relating to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes, as if the tax arrears were tax arrears of that other State" has the effect of making the domestic-law restriction of the requested State applicable to the collection of tax arrears of the other State. However, many States may wish to allow assistance in tax collection in cases where tax arrears may be recovered in the requested State regardless of the existence of a right of appeal, even though the domestic law of the requested State does not permit tax collection in such circumstances. States wishing to do so may, at their discretion, amend paragraph 3 as follows:
If tax arrears of a Contracting State may be enforced under the laws of that State and the debtor in respect of those tax arrears is a person who, at that time, is unable under the laws of that State to prevent their collection, such tax arrears shall, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for enforcement purposes by the competent authority of the other Contracting State for the purpose of collecting the arrears. Such tax arrears shall be collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes, as if those tax arrears were tax arrears owed to that other State that satisfy the conditions allowing that other State to make a request under this paragraph.
17. Paragraph 3 also regulates the methods by which the requested State collects the tax arrears of the requesting State. Subject to such factors as time limitations and priority (see the Commentary on paragraph 5), the requested State is obliged to collect the tax arrears of the requesting State as if they were its own tax arrears, even if at that time it has no need to take measures to collect tax arrears from that taxpayer for its own purposes. As already noted, the phrase "in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes" entails a limitation on assistance in the recovery of tax arrears in respect of which no further rights of appeal exist, if, under the domestic law of the requested State, the collection of that State's own tax arrears is not permitted for as long as such rights continue to exist.
18. It is possible that a request may concern a tax that does not exist in the requested State. Where necessary, the requesting State shall indicate the nature of the tax arrears, the components of those arrears, the date on which the arrears became due and the assets from which the arrears may be recovered. The requested State shall then act in accordance with the procedure applicable to the collection of its own tax that is similar to the tax of the requesting State, or in accordance with any other appropriate procedure if no similar tax exists.
Paragraph 4
19. In order to safeguard the recovery rights of the requesting State in respect of tax arrears, this paragraph enables it to request another State to take measures of conservancy, even if it is not yet able to request assistance in the collection of taxes, for example where the arrears cannot yet be enforced by law or where the debtor still has the right to prevent their collection. This paragraph should be included in conventions only between States that are able to take measures of conservancy under their own laws. Furthermore, States that consider it inappropriate to take measures of conservancy in respect of taxes due to another State may decide not to include this paragraph in their conventions or to limit its scope. In some States, measures of conservancy are referred to as interim measures, and such States may, at their discretion, add these words to this paragraph in order to clarify its scope in the context of their own terminology.
20. One example of measures covered by this paragraph is the seizure or freezing of assets before a final decision is issued in order to ensure that those assets remain available when the tax arrears are subsequently collected. The conditions required for taking measures of conservancy may differ from State to State, but in all cases the amount of the tax arrears must be determined in advance, even if only provisionally or partially. A request for measures of conservancy in respect of specific tax arrears cannot be made until the requesting State itself has taken similar measures in respect of those arrears (see the Commentary on paragraph 8).
21. When making a request for measures of conservancy, the requesting State must indicate in each particular case what stage of the tax assessment or collection process has been reached. The requested State will then have to consider whether its own laws and administrative practice permit it to take measures of conservancy in the circumstances concerned.
Paragraph 5
22. Paragraph 5 provides, for the first time, that the time limitations of the requested State, that is, the time limits after the expiry of which a request for the recovery of tax arrears can no longer be accepted for enforcement or the arrears can no longer be collected, do not apply to tax arrears in respect of which another State has made a request under paragraph 3 or 4. Since paragraph 3 concerns tax arrears that may be enforced and collected under the law of the requesting State, while paragraph 4 concerns tax arrears in respect of which the requesting State may take measures of conservancy, it follows that only the time limitations of the requesting State are applicable.
23. Thus, provided that the tax arrears may still be enforced or collected (paragraph 3), or may serve as a basis for taking measures of conservancy (paragraph 4), in the requesting State, no objection may be raised on the basis of time limitations established under the laws of the requested State against the application of paragraph 3 or 4 to those tax arrears. States that do not agree to waive their own domestic time limitations should make the appropriate amendments to paragraph 5.
24. The Contracting States may agree that, after the expiry of a specified period, the obligation to provide assistance in the recovery of tax arrears shall cease to exist. This period should commence on the date of the original instrument authorizing the enforced recovery of the tax arrears. The laws of some States require the renewal of the instrument authorizing the enforced recovery of tax arrears, and in such cases it is the first instrument that is relevant for the purposes of calculating the period after which the obligation to provide assistance ceases to apply.
25. Paragraph 5 also provides that the rules of both the requested State (first sentence) and the requesting State (second sentence), which establish the priority of their own tax arrears over the claims of other creditors, do not apply to tax arrears in respect of which a request is made under paragraph 3 or 4. Such rules are often included in domestic laws to ensure that tax authorities are able to collect taxes to the fullest extent possible.
26. The rule according to which the priority rules of the requested State do not apply to tax arrears of another State in respect of which a request for assistance has been received applies even where the requested State must, in most cases, treat those arrears as its own under paragraph 3 or paragraph 4. States wishing to provide that tax arrears of another State should have the same priority as that applicable to their own tax arrears may, at their discretion, amend this paragraph by deleting the words "or any priority is given" in the first sentence.
27. The words "by reason of their nature as such" at the end of the first sentence indicate that the time limits and priority rules of the requested State to which this paragraph applies concern only those priorities that relate specifically to unpaid taxes. Thus, this paragraph does not prevent the application of general rules concerning time limitations or priority that apply to all debts (for example, rules giving priority to a claim because it arose or was registered before another claim).
Paragraph 6
28. This paragraph ensures that any legal or administrative objection concerning the existence, validity or amount of tax arrears of the requesting State is not considered by the courts or administrative authorities of the requested State. Accordingly, no judicial or administrative proceedings are initiated in the requested State in respect of these matters, for example proceedings relating to a request for judicial review. The main purpose of this rule is to prevent applications from being made to the administrative or judicial authorities of the requested State seeking a decision on whether the amount of tax arrears, or any part thereof, constitutes a debt under the domestic law of the other State. Any legal action taken by the requested State challenging measures for the recovery of the arrears may, of course, be brought before the competent judicial authorities of that State. States in which difficulties of a constitutional or legal nature may arise in applying this paragraph may amend or exclude it during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 7
29. This paragraph provides that, if, after a request has been received under paragraph 3 or 4, the conditions that applied at the time the request was made cease to apply (for example, the tax arrears can no longer be enforced in the requesting State), the State that made the request must promptly notify the other State of the change in circumstances. Upon receipt of such notification, the requested State may, at its discretion, ask the requesting State either to suspend the execution of its request or to withdraw it. If execution of the request is suspended, such suspension must remain in effect until the requesting State informs the other State that the conditions necessary for making a request in respect of the recovery of the relevant tax arrears have once again been met, or that the State is withdrawing its request.
Paragraph 8
30. This paragraph contains certain limitations on the obligations imposed on the State receiving a request for assistance.
31. The requested State may, at its discretion, refuse to provide assistance in the cases specified in this paragraph. Nevertheless, if it does provide assistance in such cases, it does so under this Article, and its actions cannot be challenged on the ground that the State is not complying with its provisions.
32. First of all, this paragraph clarifies that a Contracting State, in fulfilling its obligations under this Article, is not required to act contrary to its own domestic laws and administrative practice or to the domestic laws and administrative practice of another State. Accordingly, if the requesting State is not authorized under its domestic law to take measures of conservancy, the requested State may refuse to take such measures on behalf of the requesting State. Similarly, if the seizure of property for the purpose of settling tax arrears is not permitted in the requested State, that State is not required under this Article to seize property when providing assistance in the collection of such taxes. However, those types of administrative measures that are permitted for taxation purposes in the requested State must be used, even if they are used exclusively to assist in collecting taxes due to the requesting State.
33. Paragraph 5 of the Article provides that the time limitations of a Contracting State do not apply to tax arrears in respect of which another State has made a request for assistance. Subparagraph (a) is not intended to abolish this principle. Accordingly, the provision of assistance in the recovery of tax arrears after the expiry of the time limits applicable in the requested State will not be regarded as contrary to the laws and administrative practice of that State or of the other Contracting State where the time limits applicable to those arrears have not expired in the requesting State.
34. Subparagraph (b) contains a limitation concerning the taking of measures that are contrary to public policy (ordre public). As in the case of Article 26 (see paragraph 19 of the Commentary on Article 26), it was considered necessary to establish a limitation on assistance that could affect the vital interests of the State itself.
35. Under subparagraph (c), a Contracting State is not obliged to comply with a request if the other State has not taken all reasonable measures for collection or preservation, as the case may be, available to it under its laws or provided for by its administrative practice.
36. Finally, under subparagraph (d), the requested State may also refuse to comply with a request on practical grounds, for example if the costs that may arise in collecting the tax arrears of the requesting State exceed the amount of the arrears due.
37. Some States may wish to add to this paragraph an additional limitation already contained in the joint Multilateral Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters of the Council of Europe and the OECD, which would allow a State to refuse to provide assistance if it considers that the taxes in respect of which assistance is requested are levied contrary to generally accepted principles of taxation.
Article 28
MEMBERS OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR OFFICERS
Article 28 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduces Article 28 of the OECD Model Convention. Accordingly, the Commentary on that Article remains applicable:
1. The purpose of the provision is to ensure that members of diplomatic missions and consular officers receive, under the provisions of a convention for the avoidance of double taxation, treatment no less favourable than that to which they are entitled under international law or special international agreements.
2. The simultaneous application of the provisions of a convention for the avoidance of double taxation and diplomatic and consular privileges granted under the general rules of international law or pursuant to a special international agreement may, in certain circumstances, result in exemption from tax in both Contracting States in respect of income that would otherwise be taxable. An example would be a situation in which a diplomatic agent accredited by State A to State B and receiving royalties or dividends from sources in State A is, under international law, not subject to tax in State B in respect of that income and may also, depending on the provisions of the bilateral convention between the two States, be entitled, as a resident of State B, to an exemption from or reduction of the tax levied on the income in State A. In order to avoid unintended tax benefits, the Contracting States are entitled to adopt an additional provision bilaterally, which could be drafted as follows:
To the extent that, by virtue of tax privileges granted to members of diplomatic missions and consular officers under the general rules of international law or under the provisions of special international agreements, income or capital is not subject to tax in the receiving State, the right to tax shall remain with the sending State.
3. In many OECD member countries, domestic legislation provides that members of diplomatic missions and consular officers are deemed, for tax purposes, to be residents of the sending State during their stay abroad. In bilateral relations between member countries where such domestic provisions apply, it is possible to go further and include special rules in the Convention establishing, for the purposes of the Convention, that the sending State is the State of residence of members of diplomatic missions and consular officers of the Contracting States. The proposed special provision could be worded as follows:
Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 4, an individual who is a member of a diplomatic mission or an employee of a consular post of a Contracting State located in the other Contracting State or in a third State shall be deemed, for the purposes of the Convention, to be a resident of the State that sent him if:
a) under international law, such person is not liable to tax in the receiving State in respect of income from sources outside that State or in respect of capital situated outside that State; and
b) such person is subject in the sending State to the same tax obligations in respect of all income or capital as residents of that State.
4. By virtue of paragraph 1 of Article 4, 58 members of diplomatic missions and consular officers of a third State accredited in a Contracting State are not considered residents of the receiving State if they are subject only to limited taxation in that State […]. This also applies to international organizations established in a Contracting State and their officials, since, as a general rule, they enjoy certain tax privileges either under the convention or agreement establishing the organization or under an agreement between the organization and the State in which it is established. Contracting States wishing to regulate this matter expressly or to prevent undesirable tax benefits may add the following provision to this Article:
58 This paragraph shall not apply to those bilateral agreements that omit the second sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 4.
The Convention shall not apply to international organizations, their bodies or officials, or to persons who are members of a diplomatic mission or consular officers of a third State, who are present in a Contracting State and are not considered residents by either Contracting State in respect of taxes on income or capital.
This means that international organizations, bodies or their officials who, in a Contracting State, are liable only in respect of tax on income from sources situated in that State cannot benefit from the provisions of this Convention.
5. Although honorary officers of consular posts cannot, under the provisions of this Article, benefit from any privileges to which they are not entitled under the general rules of international law (as a rule, the only exemption is from taxes on payments received as compensation for expenses incurred by honorary consuls on behalf of the sending State), the Contracting States are entitled expressly to exclude honorary consuls from the scope of this Article by bilateral agreement.
Article 29
ENTITLEMENT TO BENEFITS
Preliminary remarks
1. As explained in the footnote to the Article, Article 29 reflects the intention of the Contracting States, as set out in the Preamble to the Convention, to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax evasion or avoidance, including through the conclusion of treaty-shopping arrangements. This intention and the wording of the Article are consistent with the minimum standard agreed upon by the participating States under the OECD-G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project and described in paragraph 22 of the report "Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances — Action 6: 2015 Final Report". As indicated in that report, the design of the Article will depend on how the Contracting States seeking to comply with this minimum standard decide to implement it. Depending on their own circumstances, States may wish to adopt only the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9 of the Article; they may instead prefer to adopt paragraphs 1–7 of this Article, which they will supplement with a mechanism covering conduit arrangements not covered by other provisions of the Convention; or they may prefer to include the entire Article in their treaty.
2. A State may prefer the latter approach described above because it combines the flexibility of a general rule, which can prevent a large number of abusive transactions, with the certainty of a more "automatic" rule that prevents transactions known to raise concerns about treaty shopping and that can be easily described by reference to certain characteristics (for example, foreign ownership of an organization). Such a combination should in no way be interpreted as limiting the scope of the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9: a transaction or arrangement should not be considered to fall outside the scope of paragraph 9 merely because the specific anti-abuse rules contained in paragraphs 1–7, which concern only certain cases of treaty shopping that can be easily identified by certain characteristics, do not apply to it.
3. However, a State may prefer to combat "treaty shopping" without applying the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9, relying instead on the specific anti-abuse rules contained in paragraphs 1–7, as well as on a mechanism that will regulate conduit arrangements and will not apply under those paragraphs. This may be the case for a State whose domestic legislation contains strong anti-abuse rules sufficient to combat other forms of treaty abuse.
4. While the version of Article 29 included in the OECD Convention in 2017 contains both a "simplified" and a "detailed" version of the Article, the Committee decided that only the detailed version would be adopted in Article 29 of the United Nations Convention. The detailed version will provide tax treaties concluded by developing countries with more reliable protection against treaty shopping abuse.
5. Paragraphs 4–6 of the Commentary describing the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention state:
4. This Article contains provisions designed to prevent various forms of treaty shopping through which persons who are not residents of a Contracting State may establish an entity that will be resident in that State in order to reduce or eliminate taxation in the other Contracting State by taking advantage of the benefits of a tax treaty concluded between those two States. Allowing persons who are not directly entitled to treaty benefits (such as a reduction or elimination of withholding taxes on dividends, interest or royalties) to obtain those benefits indirectly through treaty shopping would undermine the bilateral and reciprocal nature of tax treaties. If, for example, a State knows that its residents may indirectly benefit from treaties concluded by another State, it may have no interest in granting reciprocal benefits to residents of that other State by concluding a tax treaty. Furthermore, in such a case, the benefits obtained indirectly may be inappropriate in view of the nature of the tax system of the former State; for example, if that State does not levy income tax on a particular type of income, it would be inappropriate for its residents to benefit from the provisions of a tax treaty concluded between two other States that provide for a reduction or elimination of taxation at source on that type of income and that were developed on the assumption that both Contracting States would tax such income.
5. The provisions of paragraphs 1–7 are intended to deny treaty benefits in the case of structures that commonly result in the indirect granting of treaty benefits to persons who are not directly entitled to those benefits, while recognizing that, in certain cases, persons who are not residents of a Contracting State may establish a legal entity in that State for legitimate business reasons. Although these provisions apply regardless of whether a particular structure was established for treaty purposes, the Article allows the competent authority of a Contracting State to grant treaty benefits where other provisions of the Article would otherwise deny those benefits, but the competent authority determines that obtaining benefits under the Convention was not one of the principal purposes of the structure.
6. The Article limits the general scope of application of the other provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 1, under which the Convention applies to persons who are residents of a Contracting State. Paragraph 1 of the Article provides that a resident of a Contracting State is not entitled to the benefits of the Convention unless that resident is a "qualified person" under paragraph 2 or is granted benefits under the provisions of paragraphs 3, 4, 5 or 6. Paragraph 2 defines who is a "qualified person" by reference to the nature or characteristics of various categories of persons; any person to whom this paragraph applies is entitled to all the benefits of the Convention. Under paragraph 3, a person is entitled to the benefits of the Convention with respect to an item of income, even if that person is not a "qualified person" under paragraph 2, if that item of income is derived from or is incidental to the active conduct of a business in the State of residence of that person (subject to certain exceptions). Paragraph 4 is a "derivative benefits" provision that allows certain companies owned by residents of third States to obtain treaty benefits, provided that those residents would have been entitled to equivalent benefits if they had invested directly. Paragraph 5 is a "headquarters company" provision under which a company that is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 may nevertheless claim benefits in respect of certain items of income. Paragraph 6 contains provisions allowing the competent authority of a Contracting State to grant treaty benefits where other provisions of this Article would otherwise deny those benefits. Paragraph 7 includes a number of definitions applicable for the purposes of this Article.
Paragraph 1
Provision denying treaty benefits to a resident of a Contracting State who is not a "qualified person"
6. Paragraph 1 provides that a resident of a Contracting State, as defined in Article 4, shall be entitled to the benefits granted to residents of Contracting States under the Convention only if that resident is a "qualified person" under paragraph 2 or is otherwise granted benefits under paragraphs 3, 4, 5 or 6. The benefits granted to a resident of a Contracting State under the Convention include all limitations on the taxation rights of the Contracting States under Articles 6–22, the elimination of double taxation provided for in Article 23, and the protection afforded to residents of a Contracting State under Article 24. However, this Article does not restrict the availability of treaty benefits under paragraph 2 of Article 9, Article 25 or the few provisions of the Convention that do not require a person to be a resident of a Contracting State in order to benefit from those provisions (for example, the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 24 insofar as they apply to nationals who are not residents of either Contracting State).
7. Paragraphs 8–10 of the Commentary describing the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention state:
8. Paragraph 1 does not in any way extend the scope of the benefits granted by the other provisions of the Convention. Thus, a resident of a Contracting State who is a "qualified person" under paragraph 2 must still satisfy the conditions of the other provisions of the Convention in order to obtain those benefits (for example, a resident must be the beneficial owner of dividends in order to benefit from the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10), and those benefits may be denied or limited under applicable anti-abuse rules, such as the rules set out in paragraphs 8 and 9.
9. Paragraph 1 applies whenever the Convention would otherwise grant a benefit to a resident of a Contracting State. Thus, for example, it applies at the time a resident of a Contracting State receives income to which Article 6 applies, at the time dividends to which Article 10 applies are paid to a resident of a Contracting State, or at any time profits to which Article 7 applies are received. This paragraph requires that, in order to be entitled to a benefit under the relevant provision of the Convention, a resident of a Contracting State must be a "qualified person" within the meaning of paragraph 2 at the relevant time. However, in some cases, the definition of a "qualified person" requires a resident of a Contracting State to satisfy certain conditions over a period of time in order to qualify as a "qualified person" at the relevant time.
10. Since the definition of an "equivalent beneficiary" to be used for the purposes of paragraph 4 of the detailed version concerning derivative benefits will exclude persons who are entitled under another convention to an exemption from taxation by the State of source that is less favourable than the exemption provided under the Convention, that definition will have what is known as a "cliff effect", resulting in the denial of all treaty benefits, even if the difference between the benefits provided under the two conventions is relatively insignificant. In such cases, some States consider it appropriate to provide an exemption from taxation in the State of source similar to the exemption that would have been provided under another convention. Such treatment may be achieved through alternative provisions included in paragraph 147 below, which relate to the taxation of dividends, interest and royalties and constitute provisions mitigating the so-called "cliff effect" where a potential equivalent beneficiary under another convention is entitled to limitations on taxation in the State of source that are less favourable than those provided under the Convention. Instead of denying all treaty benefits in respect of such income, these provisions grant limited benefits that generally correspond to those that would have been available under the other convention. In order to ensure that paragraph 1 does not deny the benefits granted under these alternative provisions, which would be contrary to the purpose of those provisions, such States should adopt another version of paragraph 1, which would read as follows:
Unless otherwise provided in this Article and in the paragraphs of Articles 10, 11 and 12 relating to the so-called "cliff effect", a resident of a Contracting State shall not be entitled to a benefit that would otherwise be granted under this Convention (other than a benefit provided under paragraph 3 of Article 4, paragraph 2 of Article 9 or Article 25) unless such resident is a "qualified person", as defined in paragraph 2, at the time when such benefit would be granted.
Извлечённый текст переведён на английский с сохранением исходной структуры, нумерации, абзацев, заголовков, буквенных и цифровых обозначений, примечаний и ссылок на положения Конвенции ОЭСР.
В исходном Markdown-файле не обнаружены активные гиперссылки формата Markdown; текстовые ссылки и заполнители ссылок сохранены в переводе.
Paragraph 2
Situations in Which a Resident Is a “Qualified Person”
8. Paragraphs 11 and 12 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention provide:
11. Each of the subparagraphs of paragraph 2 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions describes a category of residents who are qualified persons at the time the relevant treaty benefits are claimed.
12. It is contemplated that the provisions of paragraph 2 will be self-executing. Unlike the provisions of paragraph 6, discussed below, no prior ruling or approval by the competent authority is required in order to obtain benefits under paragraph 2. The tax authorities may, of course, determine upon examination that a taxpayer has incorrectly interpreted this paragraph and is not entitled to the benefits claimed.
Subparagraph a): Individuals
9. Paragraph 13 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention provides:
13. Subparagraph a) of both the Simplified and Detailed Versions provides that any individual who is a resident of a Contracting State will be a qualified person [...].
Subparagraph b): Contracting States, Political Subdivisions, and Their Institutions and Agencies
10. Paragraph 14 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention states:
14. Subparagraph b) of both the Simplified and Detailed Versions provides that the Contracting States and any of their political subdivisions or local authorities are qualified persons. These words apply to any part of a State, such as a separate fund established by the State, which does not constitute a separate person and is not owned by it. Under the last part of the subparagraph, a separate legal entity that is a resident of a Contracting State and is an institution or instrumentality of the Contracting State, or of its political subdivision or local authority, will also be a qualified person and will therefore be entitled to all the benefits of the Convention for as long as it qualifies as such. The concept of an “institution or instrumentality” applies only to organizations established by the State (or its political subdivision or local authority) to perform exclusively governmental functions; it does not apply, for example, to a company that acts as an agent of the State for certain purposes but was not established by the State to perform governmental functions. The wording of this subparagraph may need to be adjusted to reflect the different legal nature that government organizations, such as sovereign wealth funds, may have in the Contracting States, as well as the different views that those States may hold regarding the application of Article 4 to such organizations (see paragraphs 50–53 of the Commentary on Article 1 and paragraphs 8.5 and 8.11 of the Commentary on Article 4).
Subparagraph c): Publicly Traded Companies and Legal Entities
11. Paragraphs 16 to 23 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
16. Subparagraph c) recognizes that, because the shares of publicly traded companies and certain legal entities are generally widely held, it is unlikely that these companies and legal entities will be established for the purpose of obtaining treaty benefits.
17. Subparagraph c) provides that a company or legal entity that is a resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person at the time when the Convention grants benefits if, during the taxable period that includes that time, its principal class of shares and any disproportionate class of shares are regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges, provided that the company or legal entity also satisfies at least one of the following additional requirements: first, the principal class of shares of the company or legal entity is primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or legal entity is a resident; or, second, the company's or legal entity's primary place of management and control is in its State of residence. These additional requirements take into account the fact that, although a publicly traded company or legal entity may technically be a resident of a particular State, it may not have sufficient connections with that State to justify allowing such company or legal entity to benefit from the tax treaties concluded by that State. Such a sufficient connection may be established by the fact that the shares of the publicly traded company or legal entity are primarily traded on recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or legal entity; taking into account the fact that the globalization of financial markets means that the shares of listed companies that are residents of certain States are often traded on foreign stock exchanges, the alternative test provides that this sufficient connection may also be established by the fact that the company or legal entity is primarily managed and controlled in its State of residence.
18. A company or legal entity whose principal class of shares is regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange will nevertheless not be entitled to benefits under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 if it has a disproportionately large class of shares that is not regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange.
19. The terms “recognized stock exchange,” “shares,” “principal class of shares,” and “disproportionate class of shares” are defined in paragraph 7. As indicated in those definitions, the term “shares” covers comparable ownership interests in legal entities other than companies to which this subparagraph applies; this includes, for example, publicly traded units in trusts.
20. The regular-trading requirement may be satisfied by trading the issued shares on any recognized exchange or exchanges located in any State. Trading on one or more recognized stock exchanges may be aggregated for the purposes of this requirement; thus, a company or legal entity may satisfy this requirement if its shares are regularly traded, in whole or in part, on a recognized stock exchange located in another Contracting State.
21. Subparagraph (i) includes the additional requirement that the shares of the company or legal entity be primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or legal entity. As a general rule, the principal class of shares of a company or legal entity is “primarily traded” on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of that company or legal entity if, during the relevant taxable year, the number of shares of the principal class of shares of the company or legal entity traded on those stock exchanges exceeds the number of shares of the principal class of the company or legal entity traded on established securities markets in any other State. However, some States consider that the fact that the shares of a company or legal entity that is a resident of a Contracting State are primarily traded on recognized stock exchanges located in other States (for example, in a State belonging to the European Economic Area, within which the rules governing stock exchanges and securities create a single securities market) provides sufficient protection against the use of that company or legal entity for treaty-shopping purposes; States that share this view may make an appropriate modification to subparagraph (i).
22. Subparagraph (ii) provides an alternative requirement applicable to a company or legal entity whose principal class of shares is regularly traded on recognized stock exchanges but is not primarily traded on recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or legal entity. Such a company or legal entity may claim treaty benefits if its “primary place of management and control” (as defined in paragraph 7) is located in its State of residence.
23. The requirements of subparagraph c) must be satisfied throughout the entire taxable period of the company or legal entity. This does not require the shares of the company or legal entity to be traded on the relevant stock exchanges every day of the relevant period. In order for shares to be considered regularly traded on one or more stock exchanges during a taxable period, it is necessary that more than a very small percentage of the shares be actively traded on a sufficiently large number of days included in that period. This criterion would be satisfied, for example, if 10% of the average number of outstanding shares of a particular class of shares of the company were sold during 60 trading days occurring in the company's taxable period. The phrase “taxable period” in subparagraphs c) and e) refers to the period for which an annual tax return must be filed in the State of residence of the company or legal entity. If the domestic law of the Contracting States contains a concept corresponding to “taxable period,” such as “tax year,” they may replace the reference to the taxable period with that other concept.
Subparagraph d): Affiliates of Publicly Traded Companies and Legal Entities
12. Paragraphs 24 to 35 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
24. Subparagraph d) extends the principle underlying subparagraph c) (i.e. that publicly traded companies and legal entities are unlikely to be established for treaty-shopping purposes) to certain companies in which five or fewer publicly traded companies and legal entities hold a controlling interest, subject to additional conditions.
25. In order for a company that is a resident of a Contracting State to be entitled to all the benefits of the Convention under subparagraph d) at a particular point in time, that company must satisfy two conditions applicable to the taxable period that includes that time.
26. First, under subparagraph (i), the company must pass the ownership test. Under this criterion, five or fewer publicly traded companies or legal entities described in subparagraph c) must, throughout the entire taxable period, be the direct or indirect owners of at least 50% of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares of the company (and at least 50% of any disproportionate class of shares). However, if the publicly traded companies or legal entities are indirect owners, each of the intermediate companies or legal entities must either be a resident of the Contracting State from which the benefit is claimed under this Convention,
or be a “qualified intermediate owner.” The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7; under that definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company claiming benefits under subparagraph d).
27. Thus, for example, a company that is a resident of a Contracting State satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (i) if it is wholly owned by a company that is a resident of the same State and satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). Furthermore, if a publicly traded parent company in another Contracting State indirectly owns a company through a chain of subsidiaries, each such subsidiary in the chain, as an intermediate owner, must be a resident of the Contracting State from which the benefit is claimed under this Convention, or a qualified intermediate owner in another Contracting State, in order for the company to pass the ownership test under subparagraph (i).
28. The phrase “50 percent of the aggregate voting power and value of shares,” which is used in subparagraphs d) and f) and elsewhere in paragraphs 1–7, refers to an interest representing at least 50 percent of all voting rights in the relevant company or legal entity and at least 50 percent of the value of all shares in that company or legal entity. Thus, this criterion will not be satisfied by an interest that meets the voting requirement but does not meet the value requirement (or vice versa).
29. Under the second condition, included in subparagraph (ii), the company must also satisfy the base erosion test with respect to any treaty benefits it claims (other than benefits with respect to dividends under Article 10). This base erosion test is satisfied if
— less than 50% of the company's gross income (and less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group, if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits and which are deductible for tax purposes in calculating the company's tax in its State of residence, and
— less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group (if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits and which are deductible for tax purposes in calculating the tax of any member of the tested group in the State of residence of the company claiming treaty benefits.
30. The term “persons who are not entitled to the benefits,” used in the preceding paragraph, refers to any persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to the benefits provided by this Convention under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e) of paragraph 2. Legal entities that are residents of the Contracting States and are therefore persons entitled to the benefits provided by this Convention under this subparagraph or under subparagraph f) of paragraph 2 are not persons who are not entitled to the benefits; this ensures that these entities will not be used in arrangements that could allow investors from third countries to indirectly accumulate a significant amount of base-eroding payments made by a company seeking benefits under this subparagraph. Paragraph 7 contains definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income” used in subparagraph (ii).
31. For the purposes of the base erosion test, deductible payments do not include amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property on an arm's-length basis. To the extent that they may be deducted from the tax base, trust distributions are deductible payments. Depreciation allowances that do not represent payments to or accruals in favour of other persons are not taken into account for this purpose. In addition, in the case of a tested group, deductible payments do not include intra-group payments. Finally, interest payments are not incidental amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and will therefore be taken into account if they are paid to a person who is not entitled to the benefits.
32. The following examples illustrate the application by a Contracting State (referred to in the examples as the “first-mentioned State”) of the base erosion test provided for in subparagraph (ii) of subparagraph d), taking into account the definitions of “tested group” and “gross income” in paragraph 7:
— Example A: Assume that, at all relevant times, R3 is a company wholly owned by another company, R2, which in turn is wholly owned by R1, a publicly traded company satisfying the requirements of subparagraph c). R3, R2, and R1 are all residents of another Contracting State under Article 4 and belong to the same tax-consolidated group. The ownership criterion set out in subparagraph (i) of subparagraph d) is satisfied because R1, a company satisfying the requirements of subparagraph c), indirectly owns at least 50 percent of the aggregate voting power and value of R3 (and at least 50 percent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares of R3), while R2, which is an intermediate owner, is a resident of another Contracting State and is therefore a qualified intermediate owner.
During the taxable period that includes the time when the benefit would otherwise be granted by the first-mentioned State, R3 receives: first, 200 in dividends from a company resident in a third State, which are excluded from R3's gross income in the other Contracting State; and, second, 100 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State, in respect of which R3 seeks the benefits provided under Article 11 of the Convention. R3 makes a base-eroding payment of 49 to a person who is not entitled to the benefits and pays a dividend of 51 to R2. In addition to the dividend of 51 received from R3, R2 receives additional gross receipts of 100 from persons outside the tested group. R2 makes a payment of 51 to a person who is not entitled to the benefits.
In this example, the tested group, as defined in paragraph 7, consists of R3, R2, and R1, since these three companies participate in a tax consolidation regime. In order to be entitled to benefits with respect to the interest arising in the first-mentioned State, R3 and the tested group must pass the base erosion test set out in subparagraph (ii).
R3's gross income, as defined in paragraph 7, is 100 (interest arising in the first-mentioned State), since the dividends of 200 paid to R3 by the company from the third State are not taken into account. Thus, for the taxable period for which R3 claims benefits, less than 50 of R3's gross income is attributable to base-eroding payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits. R3 has made only 49 in base-eroding payments and therefore satisfies the part of the base erosion test that applies to it.
The gross income of the tested group, calculated in accordance with the tax law of the other Contracting State, does not include the dividends of 200 paid to R3 by the company from the third State, nor intra-group transactions (i.e. the dividend of 51 from R3 to R2). Thus, the gross income of the tested group amounts to 200 (100 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State plus 100 received by R2 from persons outside the tested group). Accordingly, during the taxable period in question, the tested group must make less than 100 in base-eroding payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits in order to satisfy the base erosion test under subparagraph (ii).
The base erosion test under subparagraph (ii) is not passed in this example, and P2 will not be a qualified person.
In this example, R3 does not satisfy the requirements of subparagraph d). Although R3's base-eroding payments of 49 to persons who are not entitled to the benefits do not exceed the permitted threshold of less than 50, the total amount of base-eroding payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits made by the tested group, amounting to 100 (49 + 51), exceeds the permitted threshold for base-eroding payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits, which was less than 100.
— Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A, except that R3 receives 100 in dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State, rather than interest arising in that State, and has no other gross income in the taxable year. Since the only treaty benefit sought by R3 is under Article 10 with respect to dividends, R3 is not required to apply the base erosion test under subparagraph (ii). Accordingly, R3 will be a qualified person with respect to the dividends under subparagraph d), since it satisfies the ownership requirements of subparagraph (i).
— Example C: Assume that, at all relevant times, P2 (the relevant company) is a company wholly owned by P1, a publicly traded company that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). P2 and P1 are residents of another Contracting State.
During the taxable year in question, P2's only items of income are 100 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State, in respect of which P2 seeks to claim benefits under Article 11. P2 pays deductible interest of 100 to P1, a person that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). P1 makes a deductible payment during the same taxable period of 100 to ThirdCo, a company resident in State Y. P2, through P1, has indirectly made a base-eroding payment of 100 to a person who is not entitled to the benefits. In this example, the base erosion test under subparagraph (ii) is not satisfied, and P2 will not be a qualified person.
33. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that provisions should be included in their tax treaties denying the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) that benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1), and denying the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic-law provisions providing for a notional deduction for equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). These States may wish to modify the base erosion criterion in subparagraph (ii) to include in the category of “persons who are not entitled to the benefits” persons who, although they are residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions with respect to deductible payments made or accrued to them. This could be done by modifying subparagraph (ii) as follows:
(ii) with respect to benefits under this Convention other than those provided under Article 10, less than 50% of the company's gross income and less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible in that taxable period for tax purposes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (but not including payments to third parties in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions)
A) to persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to the benefits provided by this Convention under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e);
B) to persons who are related to a person referred to in this subparagraph and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”] of this Convention, with respect to the deductible payment; or
C) in the case of an interest payment, to persons who are related to a person referred to in this subparagraph and who benefit from domestic-law deductions described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 concerning notional deductions for equity].
34. The following example illustrates the application of the alternative base erosion test set out in the preceding paragraph:
— Example: Assume the same facts as in Example B in paragraph 32 above, except that R3's only items of income are 100 in royalties received in the State from which treaty benefits are claimed, and in respect of which R3 seeks to claim benefits under Article 12. R3 makes a deductible royalty payment of 100 to R1. At all times, R1 benefits from a special tax regime (as defined in this Convention) with respect to royalties.
The ownership condition under subparagraph (i), set out in subparagraph d), is satisfied because R1, a company satisfying the requirements of subparagraph c), indirectly owns at least 50 percent of the aggregate voting power and value of R3, and R2 is a qualified intermediate owner. However, even though R1 is a person satisfying the requirements of subparagraph c), the deductible royalty payment made by R3 to R1 is a base-eroding payment because R1 is not entitled to the benefits. R1 is a related person with respect to R3 and benefits from a special tax regime with respect to royalty income. In this example, R3 does not satisfy the base erosion criterion under subparagraph (ii), since R3 has made base-eroding payments amounting to 100 percent to a person benefiting from a special tax regime, and the amount of 100 exceeds the permitted threshold for R3's base-eroding payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits (this threshold is exceeded if the total amount of such payments is at least 50).
35. Some other States, however, may consider that there is no need to introduce the condition under subparagraph (ii) concerning base erosion in the case of companies that are predominantly owned by publicly traded companies or legal entities. These States may therefore wish to omit subparagraph d) and use the following alternative version of subparagraph c), which would cover both publicly traded companies or legal entities and companies in which five or fewer publicly traded companies or legal entities hold a controlling interest (States adopting this approach should also renumber the subsequent subparagraphs of paragraph 2 and replace references to subparagraph c) with references to “subparagraph (i) of subparagraph c)” in the wording of the rules concerning ownership/base erosion, derivative benefits, and headquarters companies, in order to avoid the problem described in paragraph 30 above):
c) a company or other legal entity, if throughout the entire taxable period that includes that time
(i) its principal class of shares (and any other separate class of shares) is regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges, and either:
A) its principal class of shares is primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or legal entity is a resident; or
B) the primary place of management and control of the company or legal entity is located in the Contracting State of which it is a resident;
(ii) at least 50% of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares (and at least 50% of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company or legal entity is directly or indirectly owned by five or fewer companies or legal entities entitled to benefits under subparagraph (i) of this subparagraph, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a resident of the Contracting State from which the benefit is claimed under this Convention or is a qualified intermediate owner;
Subparagraph e): Non-Profit Organizations and Recognized Pension Funds
13. Paragraphs 39 and 40 of the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Convention provide:
39. Subparagraph e) of the Detailed Version contains rules under which certain non-profit organizations (to the extent that they are considered residents of a Contracting State, as indicated in paragraphs [8.6 and 8.7] of the Commentary on Article 4 [2014]) and certain recognized pension funds will be entitled to all the benefits of the Convention.
40. The organizations described in subparagraph (i) automatically qualify for treaty benefits regardless of the residence of their owners or members. These organizations generally correspond to those that do not pay tax in their State of residence and that are established and operate exclusively to perform certain social functions (for example, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural, or educational functions). The description of such legal entities, which will be included in subparagraph (i) with respect to each State, will generally refer to the provisions of that State's domestic law describing those legal entities, or to domestic-law factors that make it possible to identify those legal entities. Depending on the wording used, States may also wish to amend subparagraph (i) so that their competent authorities may subsequently agree to modify or supplement the description provided.
14. Not all States include recognized pension funds within the scope of their tax treaties. Such States should omit subparagraphs (ii) and (iii) of subparagraph e) when drafting Article 29. However, States that wish to clarify the application of a tax treaty to recognized pension funds may wish to define the term “recognized pension fund” in Article 3. Such a definition could be formulated as follows and included as a subparagraph in paragraph 1 of that Article:
the term “recognized pension fund” of a State means an entity or arrangement established in that State that is treated as a separate person under the tax laws of that State and:
(i) that is established and operated exclusively or almost exclusively to administer or provide pension benefits and supplementary or ancillary benefits to individuals and that is regulated as such by that State or one of its political subdivisions or local authorities; or
(ii) that is established and operated exclusively or almost exclusively to invest funds for the benefit of entities or arrangements referred to in subparagraph (i).
States that, under their domestic law, do not recognize a pension fund as a legal entity could replace the introductory wording of the above definition with the following:
the term “recognized pension fund” of a State means an entity or arrangement established in that State under the laws of that State and:
Such States should also ensure that the definition of “resident” in paragraph 1 of Article 4 includes such an entity or arrangement (see paragraph 7 of the Commentary on paragraph 1 of Article 4).
15. Paragraphs 41 and 42 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
41. Under subparagraph (ii), a recognized pension fund that falls within subparagraph (i) of the definition of that term in paragraph 1 of Article 3 (which forms part of the definition applicable to an organization that administers or provides pension benefits and supplementary or ancillary benefits to individuals) will be entitled to treaty benefits if more than 50 percent of the beneficial interests in that person are owned by individuals who are residents of either Contracting State, or if more than a certain percentage of those beneficial interests, as determined in bilateral negotiations, are owned by such residents or by individuals who are residents of third States, provided that, in the latter case, two additional conditions are met: first, those individuals are entitled to benefits under a comprehensive tax treaty concluded between that third State and the State of source; and, second, that treaty provides for an equal or greater reduction of taxes withheld at source on interest and dividends received by pension funds of that third State. For the purposes of this provision, the term “beneficial interests in that person” should be understood as referring to the interests of persons entitled to receive pension benefits from the fund. However, some States consider that the risk of treaty shopping by recognized pension funds does not justify the compliance costs associated with requiring funds to identify the treaty residence and entitlements of individuals entitled to receive pension benefits. States that share this view may appropriately amend subparagraphs (ii) and (iii) and may, for example, simply replace these two subparagraphs with one subparagraph stating that the entity “is a recognized pension fund,” which, like the provision contained in the Simplified Version, ensures that any recognized pension fund covered by the definition in paragraph 1 of Article 3 automatically qualifies as a “qualified person.”
42. Subparagraph (iii) applies to so-called “funds of funds,” which are referred to in subparagraph (ii) of the definition of “recognized pension fund” in paragraph 1 of Article 3. These are funds that do not directly provide pension benefits to individuals but are established and operated to invest funds on behalf of recognized pension funds that themselves fall within subparagraph (i) of the definition of “recognized pension fund.” However, subparagraph (iii) applies only if substantially all of the income of such a “fund of funds” is derived from investments made on behalf of recognized pension funds entitled to benefits under subparagraph (ii).
Subparagraph f): Ownership/Base Erosion
16. Paragraphs 46 to 54 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
46. Subparagraph f) of the Detailed Version provides an additional method of qualifying for treaty benefits, which applies to legal entities of any ownership structure that are residents of a Contracting State. The test provided for in subparagraph f), the so-called ownership and base erosion test, consists of two parts; both parts must be satisfied for a resident to be entitled to treaty benefits under subparagraph f).
47. Under subparagraph (i), which forms part of the ownership test, 50 percent or more of the aggregate voting power and value of the outstanding shares (and at least 50 percent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) must be owned by the person, directly or indirectly, at the time when the relevant treaty benefit would otherwise be granted and on at least half of the days of the twelve-month period that includes that time, by persons who are residents of the Contracting State of which that person is a resident and who themselves are entitled to treaty benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e). However, in the case of indirect owners, each intermediate owner must be a qualified intermediate owner. The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7; under that definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company claiming benefits under subparagraph f).
48. Although subparagraph f) is generally relevant in the case of privately held companies, it may also apply to a legal entity, such as a trust, that is a resident of a Contracting State and otherwise satisfies the requirements of this subparagraph. Under the definition of shares in paragraph 7, the reference to “shares” in the case of legal entities that are not companies means interests comparable to shares; generally, this refers to beneficial interests in a trust. For the purposes of subparagraph (i), the beneficial interests in a trust will be considered to be owned by its owners in proportion to each owner's actuarial interest in the trust. The interest of an owner entitled to receive the remainder of the trust will be 100 percent less the aggregate interest held by the income beneficiaries. An owner's interest in a trust will not be considered to be owned by a person entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e) if it is not possible to determine the owner's actuarial interest. Consequently, if it is not possible to determine the actuarial interests of the owners in a trust, the ownership criterion under subparagraph (i) cannot be satisfied unless all possible owners are persons entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e).
49. Subparagraph (ii) constitutes the base erosion test, which is generally similar to the base erosion test in subparagraph (ii) of subparagraph d), except for the fact that, unlike that other test, it also applies to a person seeking benefits under Article 10. This base erosion test is satisfied if
— less than 50% of the company's gross income (and less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group, if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits and which are deductible for tax purposes in calculating the company's tax in its State of residence, and
— less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group (if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments to persons who are not entitled to the benefits and which are deductible for tax purposes in calculating the tax of any member of the tested group in the State of residence of the company claiming treaty benefits.
50. The term “persons who are not entitled to the benefits,” used in the preceding paragraph, refers to any persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to the benefits provided by this Convention under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e) of paragraph 2. In addition, paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income” used in subparagraph (ii).
51. The base erosion test under subparagraph (ii), unlike the test under subparagraph d), applies when a person wishes to obtain benefits provided under Article 10. For the purposes of subparagraph (ii), such a person must include in its gross income any dividends received, even if the dividends are effectively exempt from tax in the State of residence of that person. This is provided for in subparagraph (i) of the definition of “gross income” in paragraph 7.
52. As with the base erosion test under subparagraph d), for the purposes of applying the test under subparagraph (ii), deductible payments (i.e. base-eroding payments) do not include amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property. To the extent that they may be deducted from the tax base under the tax laws of the State of residence of the person, trust distributions constitute such base-eroding payments. Depreciation and amortization allowances that do not represent payments to or accruals in favour of other persons are not taken into account for the purposes of subparagraph (ii). In addition, in the case of a tested group, deductible payments do not include intra-group payments. Finally, interest payments are not incidental amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and will therefore be taken into account if they are paid to a person who is not entitled to the benefits.
53. As explained in paragraph 33 above, which applies to the base erosion test provided for in subparagraph d), States that wish to deny the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons that benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes,” and to deny the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic-law provisions providing for a notional deduction for equity, may also modify the base erosion criterion under subparagraph (ii) to include in the category of “persons who are not entitled to the benefits” persons who, although they are residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions with respect to deductible payments made or accrued to them. This could be done by modifying subparagraph (ii) as follows:
(ii) less than 50% of the company's gross income and less than 50% of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible in that taxable period for tax purposes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (but not including arm's-length payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions)
A) to persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to the benefits provided by this Convention under subparagraphs a), b), c), or e);
B) to persons who are related to a person referred to in this subparagraph and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”] of this Convention, with respect to the deductible payment; or
C) in the case of an interest payment, to persons who are related to a person referred to in this subparagraph and who benefit from the notional deductions described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 concerning notional deductions for equity].;
Ниже приведён перевод извлечённого текста на английский язык. Сохранены исходная структура, нумерация пунктов, буквенные и римские обозначения, абзацы, выделение курсивом, специальные символы и ссылки в квадратных скобках. Содержание не сокращается.
English Translation
54. The following examples illustrate the application by a Contracting State (referred to in the examples as the “first-mentioned State”) of the base erosion test provided for in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph f), taking into account the definitions of “tested group” and “gross income” in paragraph 7:
- Example A: Assume that, during all relevant periods, R2 (an entity seeking to obtain treaty benefits pursuant to subparagraph f)) is a subsidiary of R1, which, in turn, is wholly owned by an individual Z. R1, R2 and Z are residents of another Contracting State within the meaning of Article 4. R2 and R1 are members of the same tax consolidated group. The ownership test referred to in subdivision (i) of subparagraph f) is satisfied because Z, a person meeting the requirements of subparagraph a), indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of R2, and R1 is a qualifying intermediate owner.
During the relevant taxable period, R2 receives 50 in tax-exempt dividends paid by a company resident in a third State and 50 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State. R2 pays deductible interest in the amount of 24 to non-qualifying persons and pays dividends in the amount of 51 to R1. In addition to the dividends in the amount of 51 that it receives from R2, R1 receives additional income in the amount of 100 from persons outside the tested group. R1 pays deductible interest in the amount of 51 to a non-qualifying person.
R2 seeks to claim the benefits provided for under Article 11 of the Convention, but not Article 10. For the purposes of applying the base erosion test, the tested group consists of R1 and R2. The gross income of the tested group for this purpose amounts to 150 (50 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State, plus 100 in additional income from persons outside the tested group).
R2 made a base-eroding payment in the amount of 24, and R1 made a base-eroding payment in the amount of 51 to non-qualifying persons. The base-eroding payments of the tested group amount to a total of 75 (24 + 51), which is at least 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group of 150. Accordingly, the base erosion test is not satisfied, and R2 is not a qualified person under subparagraph f).
- Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A above, except that the income in respect of which R2 seeks to qualify as a qualified person consists of 50 in dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State, instead of 50 in interest arising in that State.
For this purpose, the gross income of R2 amounts to 100 (50 in dividends paid by a company resident in a third State and 50 in dividends paid by a company in the first-mentioned State). The gross income of the tested group amounts to 200 (R2's gross income of 100 plus R1's income of 100 from persons outside the tested group).
R2 made a base-eroding payment in the amount of 24, and R1 made a base-eroding payment in the amount of 51. The amount of base-eroding payments made by R2 is 24, which is less than 50 per cent of R2's gross income of 100. In addition, the base-eroding payments of the tested group amount to 75 (24 + 51), which is less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group of 200.
Accordingly, in this example, the base erosion test under subdivision (ii) is satisfied, and R2 should be a qualified person under subparagraph f) for the purposes of obtaining the lower rate of taxation on dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State.
Subparagraph g): Collective Investment Vehicles
17. Countries wishing to introduce a rule governing entitlement to benefits for “collective investment vehicles” could include such a rule in subparagraph g) of paragraph 2. The inclusion of such a rule could be a useful tool for facilitating foreign portfolio investment, although, in developing any such rule, countries should not seek to create opportunities for treaty shopping through the use of collective investment vehicles.
Paragraph 3
Active Conduct of Business
18. Paragraphs 68 to 77 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide as follows:
68. Paragraph 3 of both the simplified and detailed versions sets out an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State may obtain treaty benefits with respect to certain items of income connected with the active conduct of a business carried on in its State of residence. This paragraph recognizes that where an entity that is a resident of a Contracting State actively conducts business in that State, including business conducted by related persons, and derives income from another Contracting State that results from or is incidental to that business, the granting of treaty benefits with respect to such income does not give rise to treaty-shopping concerns, regardless of the nature and form of ownership of the entity. This paragraph will provide treaty benefits in a large number of situations in which such benefits would otherwise be denied under paragraph 1 because the entity is not a “qualified person” under paragraph 2.
69. A resident of a Contracting State may claim benefits under paragraph 3 notwithstanding that it is not a person entitled to benefits under paragraph 2. Under the active conduct of business test set out in paragraph 3, a person (generally a company) will be entitled to treaty benefits if it satisfies two conditions: first, it engages in the active conduct of a business in its State of residence and, second, the payment in respect of which benefits are claimed is connected with that business. In certain cases, an additional requirement must be satisfied, namely that the business be substantial in relation to the activity carried on in the State from which the income is derived.
70. Subparagraph a) establishes the general rule that a resident of a Contracting State carrying on an active business in that State may enjoy the benefits of the Convention with respect to an item of income derived in the other Contracting State. However, the item of income must arise from or be incidental to that business.
71. The term “business” is not defined [...] and, under the general rule of paragraph 2 of Article 3, must therefore be given the meaning that it has under domestic law. An entity will generally be considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business only if the persons through whom it acts (such as the officers or employees of the company) carry out substantial managerial and operational activities.
72. Under subparagraph a), investment activities or investment management activities carried on for the resident's own account are not considered to constitute a business, unless such activities are part of the banking business, insurance business or securities business carried on by a bank or financial institution that the Contracting States would regard as similar to a bank (for example, a credit union or building society), an insurance company or a registered securities dealer, respectively.
Such activities carried on by a person other than a bank (or a financial institution agreed upon by the Contracting States), an insurance company or a registered securities dealer will not be considered to constitute the active conduct of a business. Nor will they be considered to constitute the active conduct of a business if they are carried on by a bank (or a financial institution agreed upon by the Contracting States), an insurance company or a registered securities dealer, but not as part of that enterprise's banking, insurance or dealing business.
73. In addition, subdivisions (i)–(iv) of subparagraph a) identify specific functions which, whether performed individually or in combination, will not be considered to constitute the active conduct of a business in a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3, even if all such functions are performed in that same State. These include:
(i) acting as a holding company;
(ii) providing general supervision or administration of a group of companies;
(iii) providing group financing (including cash pooling); and
(iv) making or managing investments, except where such activities are carried on by a regulated bank (or a financial institution agreed upon by the Contracting States), an insurance company or a registered securities dealer in the ordinary course of its business as such.
This list of activities is intended to clarify that the administrative support functions of multinational enterprises, as well as activities carried on as a holding company, do not form part of the active conduct of a business and, consequently, income resulting from or incidental to such activities cannot qualify for treaty benefits under paragraph 3. However, some States consider that some or all of the activities listed in subdivisions (i)–(iv) should be included in the concept of the active conduct of a business, and those States may therefore wish to adopt a different wording for subparagraph a).
74. Whether an item of income is derived from the active conduct of a business by a company in its State of residence must be determined on the basis of the facts and circumstances. As a general rule, an item of income arises from the active conduct of a business in the State of residence if there is a factual connection between the actively conducted business and the item of income in respect of which benefits are claimed.
For example, if a company conducts research and development in its State of residence and develops a patent for a new technological process, royalties from the licensing of the patent will be factually connected with the active conduct of a business in the State of residence. In the case of dividends or interest paid to a parent company, the activities of the paying company will be relevant in determining whether the dividends or interest arise from the active conduct of a business by the parent company in its State of residence.
75. For the purposes of determining whether the activities of the paying company in the State of source have the required factual connection with the actively conducted business in the State of residence, it will be important to compare the lines of business in each State. The line of business in the State of source may be upstream or downstream in relation to the activities carried on in the State of residence.
Thus, an enterprise in the State of source may provide inputs for a production process carried on in the State of residence, or an enterprise in the State of source may sell the output of a production process carried on by the resident. The following examples illustrate these principles:
- Example A: ACO is a company resident in State A and actively conducts a business in that State consisting of the manufacture of Product X. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B. BCO purchases Product X from ACO and distributes it to customers in State B. Since BCO's activity of distributing Product X is factually connected with ACO's manufacture of that product, the dividends paid by BCO to ACO will be considered to be derived from ACO's business.
- Example B: ACO is a company resident in State A that operates a major research and development centre in State A, developing intellectual property that it licenses to its affiliates around the world, including BCO. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B. BCO manufactures and sells products developed by ACO in State B. Since the activities carried on by BCO are factually connected with ACO's active business in State A, the royalties paid by BCO to ACO for the use of its intellectual property will be considered to be connected with ACO's business.
- Example C: ACO is a company resident in State A and actively conducts a manufacturing business in State A that requires the use of Commodity X. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B, which has large deposits of Commodity X. BCO extracts Commodity X and sells it to ACO, which uses that commodity to manufacture goods and sells them on the open market. Since the business activities carried on by BCO provide ACO with inputs for the manufacture of its goods, BCO's business is factually connected with ACO's manufacturing activities in State A. The dividends paid by BCO to ACO will be considered to be derived from ACO's business.
76. An item of income derived in the State of source is “incidental” to the business carried on in the State of residence if the generation of that item of income facilitates the conduct of the business in the State of residence. An example of incidental income is income derived from the temporary investment of a person's working capital in its State of residence in securities issued by persons in the State of source.
77. Subparagraph b) of paragraph 3 contains an additional condition to the general rule set out in subparagraph a) in cases where the business generating the income in question is carried on either by the person deriving the income or by a related person in the State of source. Subparagraph b) provides that the business carried on in the State of residence must, in such circumstances, be substantial in relation to the activity carried on in the State of source.
The determination of substantiality is based on all the facts and circumstances, including the relative sizes of the businesses in each Contracting State, the relative sizes of the economies and markets in the two States, the nature of the activities carried on in each State, and the relative contributions made to that business in each State.
19. Paragraphs 78–81 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide as follows:
78. The determination of whether subparagraph b) applies is made separately for each item of income derived from the State of source, taking into account the business in the State of residence from which that item of income arises. It is therefore possible that a person will be entitled to the benefits of the Convention with respect to one item of income but not with respect to another. If a resident of a Contracting State is entitled to treaty benefits with respect to a particular item of income under paragraph 3, that person is entitled to all the benefits of the Convention to the extent that they affect the taxation of that item of income in the State of source.
79. However, the substantiality requirement under subparagraph b) will not apply if the business generating the item of income in question is not carried on in the State of source by the resident seeking benefits or by a person related to that resident.
For example, if a small research firm in one State develops a process that it licenses to a very large pharmaceutical manufacturer in another State, which is not a related person in relation to the small research firm, the size of the research firm's business in the first State will not need to be compared with the size of the manufacturer's business. Similarly, a small bank in one State that provides a loan to a very large company that is not a related person and carries on business in another State will not be required to satisfy the substantiality test in order to qualify for treaty benefits under paragraph 3.
80. Subparagraph c) provides rules for attributing activities carried on by related persons for the purposes of applying the substantive rules of subparagraphs a) and b). These rules therefore apply for the purposes of determining whether a person satisfies the requirement under subparagraph a) that it be engaged in the active conduct of a business and that the item of income arise from that active business, as well as for the purposes of making the comparison required under the “substantiality” requirement in subparagraph b). The term “related person” is defined in paragraph 7.
81. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 3 with respect to activities carried on by related persons:
- Example A: PARENTCO is a resident of a third State and is the parent company of HOLDCO, which is itself the parent company of OPCO1 and OPCO2. OPCO1 and HOLDCO are residents of State A. OPCO2 is a resident of State B. OPCO1 and OPCO2 are engaged in the manufacture of the same product in their respective States of residence. HOLDCO manages the group's investments and is considered not to be engaged in the active conduct of a business. HOLDCO receives dividends from OPCO2.
Under subparagraph c), HOLDCO is considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business because it carries on the activities of OPCO1, which is engaged in the active conduct of a business. Thus, HOLDCO is treated as carrying on an active business in State A.
Nevertheless, the fact that HOLDCO's deemed business is the same as the business of OPCO2 is not sufficient to demonstrate that the dividends paid by OPCO2 are factually connected with HOLDCO's actively conducted business. Accordingly, such dividends will not benefit from the reduced withholding tax rates provided for under Article 10 of the Convention between States A and B by virtue of paragraph 3.
- Example B: ACO is a company resident in State A and actively conducts manufacturing activities in State A that require the use of Commodity X. All the shares of ACO are owned by HOLDCO, also a resident of State A, which also owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B, where there is a large supply of Commodity X. BCO extracts Commodity X and sells it to ACO, which uses that commodity to manufacture goods that it sells on the open market.
HOLDCO is considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business because, under subparagraph c), it is deemed to carry on the activities of ACO. Since the activities carried on by BCO provide inputs for use in HOLDCO's deemed active business, BCO's business is considered to be factually connected with HOLDCO's deemed manufacturing business. Consequently, the dividends paid by BCO to HOLDCO will be derived from HOLDCO's deemed active conduct of a business.
Paragraph 4
Derivative Benefits
20. Paragraphs 83 to 91 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide as follows:
83. The wording of the derivative benefits provision in a Convention that follows the detailed version depends on the views of the Contracting States regarding the treaty-shopping opportunities that may arise from the application of such a provision to residents of States whose tax systems provide for certain preferential regimes.
84. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that their tax treaties should include provisions preventing the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) that benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1), and denying the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic law provisions providing for a notional deduction in respect of equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1).
These States may wish to ensure that any derivative benefits provisions included in their Conventions do not allow base-eroding payments to be made to such related persons, even if they qualify as equivalent beneficiaries. States sharing these views will likely wish to adopt a derivative benefits paragraph worded as follows:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to benefits that would otherwise be provided by this Convention if:
a) at the time when the benefit would otherwise be provided, and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 95 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of its shares (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) is owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualifying intermediate owner; and
b) less than 50 per cent of the person's gross income and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time, as determined in the Contracting State of which the person is a resident, is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of taxation covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the person is a resident (but excluding arm's length payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions),
(i) to persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries;
(ii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries only
by virtue of paragraph 5 of this Article or a substantially similar provision of an applicable comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation;
(iii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, who are related persons with respect to the company described in this paragraph, and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”], with respect to the deductible payment, provided that, where the relevant comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation does not contain a definition of a special tax regime that is similar to the definition of that term included in this Convention, the principles of that definition shall apply, but without regard to the requirement contained in subdivision v) of that definition; or
(iv) in the case of an interest payment, to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, who are related persons with respect to the company described in this paragraph, and who benefit from notional deductions of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 that deals with notional deductions in respect of equity].
85. States that, however, do not consider that provisions concerning special tax regimes and notional deductions in respect of equity should be included in their tax treaties may prefer to use the following version of the derivative benefits paragraph:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to benefits that would otherwise be provided by this Convention if:
a) at the time when the benefit would otherwise be provided, and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 95 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of its shares (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) is owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualifying intermediate owner; and
b) less than 50 per cent of the person's gross income and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time, as determined in the Contracting State of which the person is a resident, is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of taxation covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the person is a resident (but excluding arm's length payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions)
(i) to persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries; or
(ii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries only by virtue of paragraph 5 of this Article or a substantially similar provision of the relevant
comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation;
86. Some States may, however, consider that derivative benefits provisions worded in accordance with the provision included in the preceding paragraph create unacceptable treaty-shopping risks with respect to payments that are deductible in the State of source. Rather than providing no derivative benefits at all, these States may prefer to limit the scope of this provision to dividends, which are generally not deductible. States sharing this view may amend the first part of the alternative provision as follows:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to the benefits that would otherwise be granted under Article 10:
87. Notwithstanding the formulation proposed in paragraph 84 or paragraph 85 above, paragraph 4 on derivative benefits establishes an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State that is not a person qualifying under paragraph 2 may obtain treaty benefits with respect to certain types of income. In general, this derivative benefits test entitles a company that is a resident of a Contracting State to treaty benefits if 95 per cent of the voting power and value of its shares are owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries, and the company satisfies the base erosion test. The requirement that at least 95 per cent of the voting power and value of the company claiming treaty benefits under paragraph 4 be owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries is intended to avoid the administrative burden associated with determining whether a large number of shareholders are equivalent beneficiaries, while being consistent with the purpose of the derivative benefits test for holding companies of multinational groups in the situations contemplated by this provision.
88. Subparagraph a) sets out the ownership test. Under this test, seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries must own, directly or indirectly, shares representing at least 95 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the company, and at least 50 per cent of the shares of any disproportionate class, on at least half of the days of any twelve-month period that includes the date on which the benefits would otherwise be granted. In the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner must be a qualified intermediate owner. The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7 (see paragraphs 151–154 below); the following example illustrates the application of this definition in the context of paragraph 4:
— Example: HOLDCO, a company resident in State A, is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of ZCO, a company resident in State Z, which is itself a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of XCO, a resident of State X. The principal class of shares of XCO is primarily and regularly traded on a stock exchange in State X. HOLDCO is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 of the treaty between States A and B because it is a subsidiary of a company resident in, and publicly traded in, a third State. HOLDCO does not carry on an active business in State A and therefore is not entitled to any benefits under paragraph 3. HOLDCO derives and owns an interest arising in State B that would otherwise be entitled to the benefits provided under Article 11 of the treaty between States A and B. Assume that, by virtue of the provisions of the income tax convention between States B and X, XCO qualifies as an equivalent beneficiary under the definition of that term included in the agreement between States A and B.
Although XCO indirectly owns all the shares of HOLDCO, ZCO, as an intermediate owner, must satisfy the requirements of the definition of “qualified intermediate owner” in paragraph 7 of the treaty between States A and B in order for HOLDCO to benefit from Article 11 of the treaty between States A and B with respect to the interest it received from State B. If there is no comprehensive double taxation convention in force in State Z (or, if the definition of qualified intermediate owner is drafted as proposed in paragraph 153 below, such a convention is in force but does not contain provisions concerning special tax regimes and notional deductions), ZCO will not be a qualified intermediate owner, and the requirements of subparagraph a) will not be met, with the result that HOLDCO will not be entitled under paragraph 4 to benefit from the convention.
89. Subparagraph b) sets out the base erosion test applicable for the purposes of paragraph 4. This test is generally similar to the base erosion test described in subdivision ii) of subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, except that the list of disqualified persons is different (see below). The base erosion test set out in subparagraph b) is considered to be satisfied if:
— less than 50 per cent of the company's gross income (and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group, if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of deductible payments to disqualified persons for tax purposes in calculating the company's tax in its State of residence; and
— less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group (if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of deductible payments to disqualified persons for tax purposes in calculating the tax of any member of the tested group in the State of residence of the company claiming treaty benefits.
90. Paragraph 7 contains definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income”, which are used in subparagraph b). In addition, the term “disqualified persons”, used in the preceding paragraph, refers to:
— if paragraph 4 is drafted as set out in paragraph 84 above, persons that are not equivalent beneficiaries under the definition of that term in paragraph 7, as well as persons that are equivalent beneficiaries under that definition but fall into one of the following three categories:
1. they are equivalent beneficiaries solely because they are the headquarters company under paragraph 5 of this Convention or the relevant convention;
2. they are persons related (as defined in paragraph 7) to the company seeking treaty benefits under paragraph 4 and benefit from a special tax regime with respect to the payment; or
3. with respect to an interest payment, they are related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) to the company seeking treaty benefits under paragraph 4 and receive notional deductions for equity.
— if paragraph 4 is drafted as set out in paragraph 85 above, persons that are not equivalent beneficiaries under the definition of that term in paragraph 7, as well as persons that are equivalent beneficiaries under that definition solely because they are the headquarters company under paragraph 5 of this Convention or the relevant convention.
91. The base erosion test described in paragraph 4 is illustrated below:
— Example: Company X, a resident of State X, owns Company Y, a resident of State Y. Company Y owns Company B, a resident of State B, which is seeking benefits under the agreement between States A and B pursuant to paragraph 4. Company X is an equivalent beneficiary, and Company Y is a qualified intermediate owner under the definitions of these terms in paragraph 7 of the treaty between States A and B. Accordingly, Company B would satisfy the ownership requirement set out in subparagraph a) because, first, Company X, an equivalent beneficiary, indirectly owns shares representing at least 95 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of Company B, and at least 50 per cent of the shares of any disproportionate class (as defined in paragraph 7), and, second, each intermediate owner (i.e. Company Y) is a qualified intermediate owner. The gross income of Company B for the taxable period under consideration consists 100 per cent of interest received in State A and 200 per cent of dividends received in a third State, which are exempt from taxation under the laws of State B. Company B seeks treaty benefits with respect to the 100 per cent of interest. Under the laws of State B, Companies B, Y and X are not permitted to participate in a tax consolidation regime or any other regime that would allow the three companies to share profits or losses, and there is no loss-sharing regime. Accordingly, in this example, there is no tested group. The gross income of Company B is 100 (interest arising in State A). Company B will fail the base erosion test set out in subparagraph b) if Company B makes base-eroding payments of at least 50 to disqualified persons, as indicated in the preceding paragraph.
Paragraph 5
Company Headquarters
21. Paragraphs 92 to 100 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide as follows:
92. Paragraph 5 sets out an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State that is a headquarters company and is not a qualified person under paragraph 2 may obtain treaty benefits with respect to dividends and interest paid by members of the company's multinational corporate group. A company's multinational corporate group means the company itself and its direct and indirect subsidiaries (and does not include higher-tier companies).
93. A company claiming benefits as a headquarters company must satisfy six conditions. First, under subparagraph a), the place of effective management and control of the headquarters company, as defined in paragraph 7, must be in the Contracting State of which it is a resident. The same test applies to publicly traded companies. Subdivision (ii) of the definition of “place of effective management and control” allows for the possibility that, in certain limited cases, the management of a subgroup (for example, a subgroup responsible for a regional area) may be exercised to a greater extent by a company that is not the top-tier company of the entire group of related companies, and that, in certain narrow cases, a lower-tier company may satisfy the headquarters test.
94. Second, under subparagraph b), the multinational corporate group must consist of companies that are residents of and actively carry on business (as defined in paragraph 3) in at least four States (including either of the Contracting States), and the businesses carried on in each of those four States (or groups of States) must generate at least 10 per cent of the group's gross income. The application of this requirement is illustrated by the following example:
— Example: Company X is a resident of State X and a member of a multinational corporate group consisting of itself and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, which are residents of States X, A, B, C, D, E and F. The gross income derived by each of these companies for Years 01 and 02 is as follows:
Download
| State | Year 01 | Year 02 |
|---|---|---|
| X | 45 | 60 |
| A | 25 | 12 |
| B | 10 | 20 |
| C | 10 | 12 |
| D | 7 | 10 |
| E | 10 | 9 |
| F | 5 | 7 |
| Total | 112 | 130 |
For Year 01, 10 per cent of the gross income of this group is 11.20. Only the companies in States X and A satisfy the requirements of subparagraph b) for that year. Other States may be combined into groups to satisfy this requirement. Since States B and C have combined gross income of 20, and States D, E and F have combined gross income of 22, these two groups of States may be treated as the third and fourth members of the group for the purposes of subparagraph b).
Starting from the second year, 10 per cent of gross income amounts to 13. Only the companies in States X and B satisfy this requirement. Since States A and C have combined gross income of 24, and States D, E and F have combined gross income of 26, these two groups of States may be treated as the third and fourth members of the group for the purposes of subparagraph b). The fact that State A has replaced State B in the group is irrelevant for this purpose. The composition of the group may change from year to year.
95. Third, under subparagraph c), the businesses of the multinational corporate group carried on in any State other than the Contracting State of residence of that company must generate less than 50 per cent of the group's gross income (as defined in paragraph 7). A company whose multinational corporate group generates 50 per cent or more of the group's gross income in the Contracting State of origin does not satisfy this condition.
96. Fourth, under subparagraph d), no more than 25 per cent of the company's gross income may be derived in another Contracting State. Unlike the third condition described in the preceding paragraph, this condition concerns only the gross income derived by the company claiming headquarters status and not the gross income derived by the members of its multinational corporate group.
97. Fifth, under subparagraph e), such a company must be subject to the same income tax rules in its Contracting State of residence as the persons referred to in paragraph 3. Accordingly, such a company must be subject to the general corporate taxation rules applicable to companies that actively carry on business in the Contracting State of residence, and not to a regime for headquarters companies.
98. Sixth, under subparagraph f), such a company must pass the base erosion test, which is generally similar to the base erosion test described in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, except that base-eroding payments do not include payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank that is not a related person to the company. For example, unlike the base erosion test described in subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, interest payments made by a company to a bank that is not related to the company would not be treated as base-eroding payments for the purposes of applying the base erosion test under paragraph 5. Paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income”, which are used for the purposes of this base erosion test.
99. As explained in paragraph 33 above, which applies to the base erosion test provided for in subparagraph d) of paragraph 2, States that wish to deny the application of specific treaty provisions with respect to income paid to related persons that benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes”, and to deny the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic law provisions providing for a notional deduction for equity, may also need to amend the base erosion test set out in subparagraph f) to include in the category of “disqualified persons” persons who, although residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions with respect to deductible payments made or accrued to them. This could be done by amending subparagraph f) as follows:
f) less than 50 per cent of the gross income of such company and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for tax purposes under the Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (but excluding arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, or payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank that is not a related person to such company, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions):
(i) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States entitled to the benefits of the Convention under subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2;
(ii) to persons who are related persons with respect to such company and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”], with respect to the deductible payment; or
(iii) with respect to an interest payment, to persons who are related persons with respect to the company referred to in this paragraph and who benefit from notional deductions of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 that relates to notional deductions for equity].
100. The six conditions of paragraph 5 must be tested with respect to the taxable year in which the company received the dividends or interest for which it seeks benefits under the Convention. A company that does not satisfy the second, third or fourth conditions described above with respect to the relevant taxable year may nevertheless be treated as a headquarters company if it satisfies those conditions by averaging the required ratios over the preceding four taxable periods (which do not include the taxable period in which the payment for which treaty benefits are claimed is made).
Paragraph 6
Discretionary Relief
22. Paragraphs 101–112 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
101. Both paragraph 5 of the simplified version and paragraph 6 of the detailed version provide that, if, under the preceding paragraphs of the Article, a resident of a Contracting State is not entitled to the benefits provided for under the Convention, that resident may request the competent authority of the State in which the benefits have been denied under those paragraphs to grant those benefits. The only difference between the simplified and detailed versions concerns the cross-reference to the paragraphs of the Article under which the benefits of the Convention are otherwise granted.
102. Where a request is made under paragraph 5 (simplified version) or paragraph 6 (detailed version), the competent authority to which the request is addressed may grant the benefits provided for under this Convention, or benefits with respect to a specific item of income or capital, having regard to the object and purpose of this Convention, but only if the person making the request demonstrates to the competent authority that neither the creation, acquisition or maintenance of that person, nor the conduct of its operations, had as one of its principal purposes the obtaining of benefits under this Convention. Accordingly, persons who establish operations in one of the Contracting States with the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention will not be granted benefits under the Convention pursuant to this paragraph.
105. Although it is not possible to provide a detailed list of all the facts and circumstances that would be relevant to the application of this paragraph, examples of such facts and circumstances include the history, structure, ownership and operations of the resident making the request, whether that resident is a long-established legal entity that was recently acquired by non-residents for non-tax reasons, whether the resident carries on substantial business activities, whether the income of the resident in respect of which benefits are requested is subject to double taxation, and whether the establishment or use of the resident results in the exemption from taxation or reduction of taxation of income.
106. The reference to “one of its principal purposes” in this paragraph means that obtaining benefits under a tax treaty does not necessarily have to be the sole or dominant purpose of the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the person and the conduct of its operations. It is sufficient that at least one of the principal purposes is to obtain treaty benefits. If the competent authority, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, determines that obtaining benefits under the Convention was not a principal consideration and would not have justified the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the person and the conduct of its operations, it may grant that person those benefits or benefits with respect to a particular item of income or capital. Where, however, the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the person and the conduct of its operations are carried out with a view to obtaining similar benefits under a number of international treaties, it should not be assumed that obtaining benefits under other international treaties would prevent the consideration of obtaining benefits under one international treaty as one of the principal purposes of those operations.
107. Although a request under this paragraph will normally be made by a resident of a Contracting State to the competent authority of the other Contracting State, there may be cases where a resident of a Contracting State may apply to the competent authority of its own State of residence for relief under this paragraph. This would be the case where the treaty benefits requested are provided by the State of residence, for example, benefits arising from the provisions of Articles 23 A and 23 B concerning the elimination of double taxation.
108. This paragraph gives broad discretionary powers to the competent authority and, as long as the competent authority exercises those discretionary powers in accordance with the requirements of this paragraph, the competent authority's decision cannot be considered an action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention (see paragraph 1 of Article 25). However, this paragraph requires the competent authority to consider the relevant facts and circumstances before making a decision and to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or denying a request for benefits made by a resident of that other State. The first requirement is intended to ensure that the competent authority considers each request on its merits, while the requirement to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State is intended to ensure that the Contracting States deal consistently with similar cases and base their decisions on the facts and circumstances of the particular case. However, this consultation process does not require the competent authority to which the request was addressed to obtain the agreement of the competent authority with which it consults.
109. The competent authority to which a request is made under this paragraph may grant benefits, but it may then grant all the benefits provided for under the Convention to the taxpayer making the request, or it may grant only certain benefits. For example, it may grant benefits only with respect to a specific item of income in a manner similar to paragraph 3. In addition, the competent authority may impose conditions, such as setting time limits on the duration of any benefits granted.
110. A request for a ruling under this paragraph may be made before (for example, by means of a ruling request) or after the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the person in respect of whom the request is made. However, the request must be made before the benefits can be claimed. If the competent authority decides that benefits should be allowed, it is expected that the benefits will be granted retroactively to the later of the date of entry into force of the relevant treaty provision or the date of establishment or acquisition of the person in respect of whom the request is made, provided that all relevant facts and circumstances are confirmed and justify the granting of retroactive benefits.
111. The competent authority receiving a request for relief under this paragraph should process that request promptly.
112. In order to reduce the financial consequences of considering requests for discretionary relief and to prevent unreasonable requests, a Contracting State may consider it useful to publish guidelines on the types of cases that it considers to fall within the scope of discretionary relief, as well as those that do not. However, any administrative requirements imposed by a Contracting State on applicants should not discourage persons from making requests if they believe that they have a reasonable chance of convincing the competent authority that benefits should be granted.
Paragraph 7
Definitions
23. Paragraph 113 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provides:
113. Paragraph 6 of the simplified version and paragraph 7 of the detailed version contain a number of definitions that apply for the purposes of those paragraphs themselves, as well as the preceding paragraphs of the Article. These definitions supplement the definitions contained in Articles 3, 4 and 5 of the Convention, which apply throughout the Convention.
Commentary on the definition of “recognised stock exchange”
24. Paragraphs 116 to 120 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
116. The definition of “recognised stock exchange” in the detailed version includes, in subparagraph (i), stock exchanges that both Contracting States agree to identify at the time of signing the Convention. Although this will generally include stock exchanges established in the Contracting States, on which shares of companies listed on the exchange and legal entities that are residents of those States are actively traded, the stock exchanges to be specified in the definition do not necessarily have to be established in either State. This means that the globalisation of financial markets and the prominence of certain major financial centres have resulted in the shares of many publicly traded companies being actively traded on more than one stock exchange, as well as on stock exchanges located outside the State of residence of those companies.
117. The list to be included in subparagraph (i) may include the names of specific stock exchanges. It may also include a general description of a number of stock exchanges, each of which would constitute a “recognised stock exchange”. For example, in the case of the United States, such a general description could read: “any stock exchange registered with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission as a national securities exchange under the United States Securities Exchange Act of 1934”. If the Contracting States wish to cover stock exchanges of the European Union that are officially recognised as such, such a general description could read: “any stock exchange established in States that are members of the European Union or parties to the Agreement on the European Economic Area and that are regulated by the European Union Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (Directive 2004/39/EC, as amended) or any subsequent directive”.
118. Subparagraph (ii) of the definition allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to supplement, by means of a subsequent agreement, the list of stock exchanges specified in the definition at the time of signature of the Convention.
119. Stock exchanges to be included in this definition must have listing requirements that ensure that shares of companies listed on that stock exchange are genuinely publicly traded. In determining whether a stock exchange should be included in the definition or subsequently added to the list pursuant to an agreement with the competent authority referred to in the preceding paragraph, the following factors should be taken into account:
— What are the requirements/standards for listing a company on the stock exchange?
— What are the requirements/standards for continued listing on the stock exchange, including minimum financial standards?
— What are the annual/interim disclosure and/or filing requirements for companies whose shares are traded on the stock exchange?
— What is the volume of shares traded on the stock exchange during a calendar year?
— Do the rules governing the stock exchange ensure active trading in listed shares? If so, how?
— Are companies listed on the stock exchange required to disclose, on an ongoing basis, financial information and information about events that may have a material impact on their financial position?
— Is information about trading volumes and the total ownership of shares in companies listed on the stock exchange publicly available?
— Does the stock exchange impose any minimum size requirements, such as minimum market capitalisation or number of employees, for companies whose shares are traded on the exchange?
— Does the stock exchange establish a required minimum percentage of government ownership? If so, what is the minimum amount?
— In order for a company to be listed on the stock exchange, must the company's shares be freely transferable and fully paid up?
— Is the stock exchange required to disclose the share prices of its listed companies over a specified period of time? Is the stock exchange regulated or supervised by a governmental authority of the State in which it is located?
— [In the case of adding a new stock exchange to the existing list:] Why does a company prefer to list on the new exchange rather than on another exchange, including those exchanges that are already “recognised stock exchanges” under the tax treaty? For example, are the corporate governance and financial disclosure requirements less stringent?
— [In the case of adding a new stock exchange to the existing list:] Is the new stock exchange a more efficient means of raising capital, and if so, why?
The term “shares”
Commentary on the definition of “shares” in the simplified and detailed versions
25. Paragraph 120 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provides:
120. Neither the simplified nor the detailed version contains an exhaustive definition of the term “shares”, which, under paragraph 2 of Article 3, should generally have the meaning that it has under the domestic law of the State applying this Article. However, subparagraph b) provides that the term “shares”, when used in relation to legal entities that do not issue shares (for example, trusts), refers to ownership interests that are comparable to shares. Generally, these are beneficial interests that entitle their holders to a share of the income or assets of the enterprise.
The term “principal class of shares”
Commentary on the definition of “principal class of shares” in the detailed version
26. Paragraphs 122–125 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
122. The definition of the term “principal class of shares” in the detailed version refers to the ordinary shares of a company or other entity, but only if those shares represent the majority of the voting power and value of the company or entity. If a company or entity has only one class of shares, that class of shares will naturally constitute its “principal class of shares”. If a company or entity has more than one class of shares, it is necessary to determine which class or classes constitute the “principal class of shares”, which will be the class of shares or any combination of classes of shares that together represent a majority of the total voting power and value of the company or entity. If the company or entity does not have a class of ordinary shares representing a majority of its total voting power and value, the “principal class of shares” will be any combination of classes of shares that together represent a majority of the voting power and value of the company or entity. Although, in a particular case involving a company with several classes of shares, it may be possible to identify more than one group of classes that would represent a majority of the company's total voting power and value, only one such group needs to be identified that satisfies the conditions of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 for the company to be entitled to treaty benefits under that provision (the company or entity will not be denied benefits even if a second group of shares could be identified that represents a majority of the voting power and value of the company or entity but does not satisfy the conditions of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2).
123. In some States, certain publicly traded companies are governed by a dual-listed company arrangement, and those States may wish to clarify the treatment of such companies to ensure that they are not inadvertently denied treaty benefits as a result of the definition of “principal class of shares”. The term “dual-listed company arrangement” refers to an arrangement adopted by certain publicly traded companies that reflects common management, operations, shareholder rights, objectives and mission through a series of agreements between two parent companies, each of which has its own stock exchange listing, as well as special provisions in their respective constitutional documents, including, in some cases, for example, the creation of special voting shares. Under these structures, the position of the shareholders of each parent company is, to the extent possible, the same as if they held shares in a single company, with the same entitlement to dividends and the same rights to participate in the assets of the companies listed on the two exchanges in the event of their liquidation. Therefore, States wishing to improve the position of such companies may wish to add the following sentence to the definition of “principal class of shares”:
In the case of a company that is a party to a dual-listed company arrangement, the principal class of shares shall be determined after excluding special voting shares that were issued as a means of creating such a dual-listed company arrangement.
124. This additional sentence could be supplemented by the following definition of the term “dual-listed company arrangement”:
The term “dual-listed company arrangement” means an arrangement under which two publicly listed companies, while maintaining their status as separate legal entities, their ownership interests and their listings, coordinate their strategic directions and the economic interests of their respective shareholders through:
(i) the appointment of common (or substantially identical) boards of directors, except where this is prevented by applicable regulatory requirements;
(ii) the management of the operations of the two companies on a unified basis;
(iii) equal payments to shareholders in accordance with the equalisation ratio applied between the two companies, including in the event of the liquidation of one or both companies;
(iv) the shareholders of both companies effectively voting as a single decision-making body on material matters affecting their common interests; and
(v) cross-guarantees or similar financial support for each other's material obligations or operations, except where the operation of applicable regulatory requirements prevents such implementation.
125. Other States, however, may prefer not to include any specific references to dual-listed company arrangements in the Article because of possible concerns about the use of similar arrangements for treaty shopping and may therefore prefer to consider legitimate dual-listed company arrangements on a case-by-case basis through other provisions of the Article, including the discretionary relief provision contained in paragraph 6.
The term “related person”
27. Paragraphs 126 and 127 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
126. The term “related person” is used in paragraph 3 of the simplified version and in various parts of the detailed version. Although this definition is somewhat similar to the definition of “closely related” in Article 5, the main difference is that direct or indirect ownership of exactly 50 per cent of the beneficial interests may result in one person being “related” to another person, whereas the definition of “closely related” requires direct or indirect ownership of more than 50 per cent of the ownership interests.
127. As indicated in paragraph 33 above, some States consider that provisions should be included in their tax treaties to prohibit the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons that benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1) and to deny the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic law provisions providing for a notional deduction for equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). If such provisions are included in the Convention, the Contracting States may also consider it more appropriate to include the definition of “related person” in Article 3, which contains definitions applicable throughout the Convention.
The term “equivalent beneficiary”
28. Paragraphs 131 to 143 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
131. The definition of “equivalent beneficiary” in the detailed version applies for the purposes of the derivative benefits test in paragraph 4, but may also apply for the purposes of subparagraph g) of paragraph 2, concerning collective investment vehicles, depending on how that subparagraph is drafted (see paragraph 56 above).
132. This definition recognises three different categories of persons that qualify as “equivalent beneficiaries”.
133. The first category (subparagraph (i) of the definition) covers residents of third States who would be entitled to all the benefits of a comprehensive income tax treaty between the State of residence of that person and the State in which the benefits are sought (hereinafter referred to as the “tested treaty”) under provisions that are substantially similar to the rules set out in subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2. A company may also be an equivalent beneficiary under subparagraph (i) if it is entitled to benefits under a treaty pursuant to a headquarters company test under the tested treaty that is substantially similar to paragraph 5, but only if the benefits sought by the company relate to interest or dividends paid by a company that is a member of the equivalent beneficiary's multinational corporate group. If the tested treaty does not contain a comprehensive limitation on benefits provision, the requirements of paragraph A) of subparagraph (i) are also met if the third-State resident applies the tested treaty as if that treaty included the provisions of subparagraphs a), b), c) and e) of paragraph 2 (including the relevant definitions for the purposes of applying the provisions of those subparagraphs), and one of the limitations on the granting of benefits by reason of one of the included subparagraphs would be satisfied.
134. The following examples illustrate the application of subparagraph (i) of the definition:
— Example A: HOLDCO, a resident of State R, is a subsidiary of XCO, a resident of State X. The principal class of shares of XCO is substantially and regularly traded on the X Stock Exchange, a stock exchange located in State X. HOLDCO is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 of the Convention between States S and R because it is a subsidiary of a company that is a resident of a third State and is publicly traded in that State. HOLDCO does not carry on an active business in State R and therefore is not entitled to any benefits under paragraph 3. HOLDCO derives and owns interest arising in States that would otherwise be subject to the 10 per cent rate provided for in Article 11 of the Convention between States S and R. In order to determine whether HOLDCO is entitled to benefits under the derivative benefits test provided for in paragraph 4 of that Convention, it is necessary to determine whether XCO meets the definition of an equivalent beneficiary provided for in paragraph 7. The income tax treaty between States S and X contains a comprehensive limitation on benefits provision, including a rule for companies whose shares are substantially and regularly traded on the X Stock Exchange, which is substantially similar to subparagraph c) of paragraph 2. Accordingly, XCO satisfies the requirement of paragraph A) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. Under the Convention concluded between States S and X, interest arising in either State is also subject to the 10 per cent rate specified in Article 11, and therefore XCO satisfies the requirement of paragraph B) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. Accordingly, XCO is an equivalent beneficiary.
— Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A, except that the income tax treaty between States S and X does not contain a comprehensive limitation on benefits provision. Accordingly, for the purposes of determining whether XCO is an equivalent beneficiary, that treaty is applied as if it contained the provisions of subparagraphs a), b), c) and e) of paragraph 2 (including the relevant definitions for the purposes of applying those subparagraphs) of this Convention. If a recognised stock exchange under this Convention includes the X Stock Exchange, the principal class of shares of XCO would be primarily traded on a recognised stock exchange located in the State of residence of XCO. Consequently, XCO would satisfy subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 and would be an equivalent beneficiary. However, if the X Stock Exchange is not included in this Convention as a recognised stock exchange, XCO would not be an equivalent beneficiary.
135. A resident of a third State cannot be an equivalent beneficiary if that person satisfies only:
— the publicly traded company affiliate test that is substantially similar to subparagraph d) of paragraph 2;
— the ownership/base erosion test that is substantially similar to subparagraph f) of paragraph 2;
— the active business test that is substantially similar to paragraph 3;
— the derivative benefits test that is substantially similar to paragraph 4;
— the granting of discretionary benefits that is substantially similar to paragraph 6; or
— any other limitation on the granting of benefits under the tested treaty that is not a test under this Convention, since such a resident would not be a qualified person under provisions substantially similar to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 of this Article.
136. Some States may wish to limit, and in some cases deny, treaty benefits to individuals who are taxed on a remittance basis or on a fixed-fee/lump-sum basis. If this is provided for in the Convention between the Contracting States, those States may also wish to prevent such individuals resident in third States from qualifying as “equivalent beneficiaries”. This could be done by amending paragraph A) of subparagraph (i) as follows:
A) the resident is entitled to all the benefits of a comprehensive income tax treaty between that State and the Contracting State from which the benefits of this Convention are sought under provisions that are substantially similar to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2, or, where the benefit sought relates to interest or dividends paid by a member of the resident's multinational corporate group, the resident is entitled to benefits under provisions substantially similar to paragraph 5 of this Article in such treaty, provided that, if such treaty does not contain a detailed Limitation on Benefits Article, the resident would be entitled to the benefits of this Convention on the basis of subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 if such resident were a resident of one of the Contracting States within the meaning of Article 4. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, an individual
1) who is subject to tax in the State of residence of that individual on foreign-source income or income received only on a remittance basis or on a similar basis, or
2) whose tax is determined in that State, in whole or in part, on the basis of a fixed fee, “lump sum” or a similar basis,
shall not be considered an equivalent beneficiary; and
137. Subparagraph B) 1) of subparagraph (i) requires that the equivalent beneficiary be entitled, under the tested treaty, domestic law or any international agreement, to a tax rate on the type of income received by the company claiming benefits under paragraph 4 that is less than or equal to the tax rate applicable under this Convention to the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4. Accordingly, the following rates must be used for the comparison: first, the tax rate that the source State could impose under the Convention on income paid to that company if it were entitled to benefits; and, second, the tax rate that the source State could impose if the potential equivalent beneficiary received the income directly in the source State.
- As described above, subparagraph B) 1) provides that any reduced rates of taxation provided for under domestic law or any international agreement shall be taken into account. This rule recognizes that withholding taxes on many intra-group dividends, interest and royalties may be eliminated, for example, under the provisions of the European Union Parent-Subsidiary Directive and the Interest and Royalties Directive, rather than under an income tax convention. This is illustrated by the following example:
— Example: EUCO1, a company resident in State EU1, wholly owns ACO, a resident of State A. ACO wholly owns EUCO2, a resident of State EU2, and receives interest arising in State EU2. The income tax convention between States A and EU2 contains a detailed definition of equivalent beneficiary and exempts interest from taxation at source. EU1 and EU2 are members of the European Union. Under the Interest and Royalties Directive, interest paid by EUCO2 to EUCO1 may not be taxed by EU2. Accordingly, EUCO1 satisfies subparagraph B) 1) of section (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary in the income tax convention between States A and EU2, even if the income tax convention between States EU1 and EU2 permits taxation at source of the interest.
59 Council Directive 2011/96/EU of 30 November 2011 on the common system of taxation applicable in the case of parent companies and subsidiaries of different Member States, as amended; Council Directive 2003/49/EC of 3 June 2003 on a common system of taxation applicable to interest and royalty payments made between associated companies of different Member States.
- Subparagraph B) 1) (I) of section (i) establishes a rule applicable to dividends that allows an individual to be treated as a company for the purposes of the rate comparison test referred to in subparagraph B) 1). Since dividends received by individuals are not eligible for the lower rate provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10, whereas a company may be eligible for that lower rate subject to certain conditions, in the absence of this provision individual shareholders of a company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 would generally not qualify as equivalent beneficiaries in respect of dividends received from a substantial participation in other companies. By treating individuals as companies for the purposes of the rate comparison test, this rule allows a company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 to take into account shares owned, directly or indirectly, by an individual as if such shares were owned by a company described in subparagraph c) of paragraph 2, for the purposes of determining whether the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 is at least 95 per cent owned by equivalent beneficiaries.
- In order to qualify for the application of the rule set out in subparagraph B) 1) I), the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 must be engaged in the active conduct of a business in its State of residence. The rule treats an individual shareholder who otherwise meets the requirements of subparagraph A) of section (i) as if it were a company described in subparagraph c) of paragraph 2, but only if the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 is actively conducting business in its State of residence that is substantial in relation to, and similar or complementary to, the business generating the income with respect to which the dividends are paid. The test described in subparagraph B) 1) I) is similar to the active conduct of business test under paragraph 3, but is not exactly the same, since it does not require that the income from the source State “emanate” from the business actively conducted by the company for the purposes of obtaining derivative benefits under paragraph 4. The phrase “active conduct of a business” has the same meaning as in subparagraph a) of paragraph 3 and therefore does not include the activities described in subparagraphs (i)-(iv) of that subparagraph. For the purposes of determining whether the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 is engaged in the active conduct of a business in a Contracting State, activities conducted by a person related to that company shall be deemed to be conducted by the company. The phrase “substantial in relation to” has the same meaning as in subparagraph c) of paragraph 3. However, this substantiality requirement must be applied regardless of whether the dividends are received from a related person. On the other hand, dividends received in the other Contracting State do not necessarily have to result from the active conduct of business by the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4, as required under subparagraph a) of paragraph 3 in order to obtain benefits, since the active business is conducted in the Contracting State of residence. For the purposes of subparagraph B) 1) I), the active business conducted in the State of residence need only be “similar or complementary” to the active business conducted in the source State, and not “the same or complementary” to the active business conducted in the source State.
- The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph B) 1) I):
— Example: RCO is a company resident in State R. RCO is engaged in the active conduct of a business in State R that is similar to the business of SCO, a company resident in State S. RCO has been a resident of State R for 13 months and has also owned 25 per cent of the capital of SCO for 13 months. Individual Y is the sole shareholder of RCO and a resident of State Y. Paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the income tax conventions between States S and Y and between States S and R is identical to the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Tax Convention. Accordingly, RCO satisfies the requirements set out in subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 with respect to the lower rate applicable to dividends. In the absence of subparagraph B) 1) I), however, RCO would not be entitled to that lower rate, since individual Y would be entitled to the 15 per cent rate (under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10) only if it received dividends directly from SCO. By virtue of subparagraph B) 1) I), however, Y must be treated as a company within the meaning of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R for the purposes of the rate comparison test, which means that RCO would satisfy the rate comparison requirement. Accordingly, subject to the satisfaction of all other requirements (such as the base erosion test and the beneficial ownership requirement provided for in Article 10), RCO would be entitled to the lower rate provided for in Article 10 of the income tax convention between States S and R with respect to dividends paid by SCO.
- Subparagraph B) 1) II) establishes a rule for determining the percentage of the capital of the company paying dividends that a potential equivalent beneficiary is deemed to own for the purposes of the rate comparison test, which, like subparagraph B) 1) I), will affect entitlement to the lower tax rate under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 for an equivalent beneficiary if it received dividends directly. For these purposes, in applying the rate comparison test described in subsection B) 1), indirect ownership of the capital of the company paying dividends by a potential equivalent beneficiary shall be treated as direct ownership. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph B) 1) II):
— Example: XCO and YCO directly own 50 per cent each of the shares of RCO, a company resident in State R. For 13 months, RCO has owned 25 per cent of the capital of SCO and has been a resident of State R. State S has income tax conventions with States R, X and Y; paragraph 2 of Article 10 of these income tax conventions is identical to the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Tax Convention. XCO is a resident of State X and would qualify as a qualified person under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R. YCO is a resident of State Y and would also qualify as a qualified person under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R. Accordingly, both XCO and YCO would satisfy subparagraph A) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. However, for the purposes of determining the rate of tax on dividends paid by SCO to which XCO and YCO would be entitled under their respective tax conventions with the relevant States, each of XCO and YCO is deemed, pursuant to subparagraph B) 1) II), to own directly 12.5 per cent of the capital of SCO (50 per cent of 25 per cent of SCO's shares equals 12.5 per cent, representing the sum of the respective indirect interests of XCO and YCO in the capital of SCO that are treated as direct ownership). Accordingly, XCO and YCO would not be entitled to the lower rate of tax referred to in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 and would therefore not be considered equivalent beneficiaries, since they do not satisfy the rate comparison test under subparagraph B) 1) (see, however, paragraph [147] below for alternative provisions that would allow RCO to benefit from the 15 per cent rate referred to in subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the income tax convention between States S and R).
- Subparagraph B) 2) of section (i) establishes rules for obtaining derivative benefits for items of income that fall within the scope of Articles 7, 13 or 21. A potential equivalent...
- Paragraphs 144 to 147 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
- Subparagraph C) of section (ii) provides an additional limitation where an item of income is received through an entity that is treated as fiscally transparent under the laws of the Contracting State in which the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 is resident. In such a case, notwithstanding that the resident may satisfy the requirements of subparagraphs A) or B), based on a comparison of the terms of the tested convention with the terms of the convention under which the company seeks to obtain derivative benefits, the resident will not satisfy the requirements of this subparagraph if the relevant portion of the income would not be treated as income of that resident under a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 1 if, instead of being paid to the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4, the item of income in respect of which that company claims benefits had been paid directly to that resident. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph C):
— Example: RCO, a publicly traded company resident in State R, owns shares in SCO, a company resident in State S, through P, a partnership organized in State S. P is fiscally transparent under the domestic tax laws of State S and is treated as a company under the domestic tax laws of State R. Accordingly, under the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 1, dividends paid by SCO through P would not be considered to be received by RCO and would therefore not be eligible for a reduction in the amount of withholding tax in State S under Article 10. RCO interposes XCO, a resident of State X, between itself and P. Under the domestic tax laws of State X, P is fiscally transparent and, therefore, XCO is considered to receive the dividends paid by SCO to P.
The income tax convention between States S and X contains the detailed version of paragraphs 1-7 of Article 29. In order to benefit from the reduced withholding tax on dividends provided for in that convention, XCO must satisfy the requirements for derivative benefits. Although the dividend rates under paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the convention between States S and X are the same as the dividend rates under Article 10 of the convention between States S and R, and subparagraph A) of section (ii) would be satisfied, the dividends would not be considered to have been received by RCO if RCO, and not XCO, had owned SCO through partnership P. Accordingly, by virtue of subparagraph C), RCO is not an equivalent beneficiary and, for this reason, XCO is not entitled to derivative benefits under paragraph 4 in respect of dividends paid by SCO through P.
- The second category of persons qualifying as “equivalent beneficiaries” (section (ii) of the definition) applies to persons that are residents of the same Contracting State as the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4. Such persons will be considered equivalent beneficiaries if they are entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 or under paragraph 5 as a headquarters company. However, a headquarters company will be an equivalent beneficiary of the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4 only if it receives interest or dividends from a member of the multinational corporate group of the headquarters company. However, for any resident satisfying the requirements of paragraph 5 as a headquarters company that receives dividends or interest from another Contracting State, the rate comparison test applies. This requirement is intended to ensure that the headquarters company is entitled to at least the same treaty benefits in respect of dividends or interest as the company seeking to obtain derivative benefits under paragraph 4, so that, if, for example, Article 11 generally exempts interest from taxation at source but does not do so in respect of interest paid to the headquarters company by a member of that company's multinational group, the headquarters company will not be an equivalent beneficiary of a company that would otherwise be entitled to the treaty exemption from taxation at source applicable to a similar interest payment.
- The third category of persons qualifying as “equivalent beneficiaries” (section (iii) of the definition) applies to persons that are residents of the Contracting State of source. Such persons will be considered equivalent beneficiaries if they are entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2, provided that such residents own, in aggregate, no more than 25 per cent of the voting rights and value of the shares (and any disproportionate class of shares, as defined in paragraph 7) of the company seeking derivative benefits. In accordance with the ownership requirement set out in subparagraph a) of paragraph 4, ownership may be direct or indirect, but in the case of indirect ownership each intermediate owner must be a “qualified intermediate owner” within the meaning of the definition of that term in paragraph 7 (see below).
- As explained in paragraph 10 above, where paragraph 4 on derivative benefits applies, the definition of equivalent beneficiary excludes persons who, under another convention, are entitled to an exemption from taxation by the State of source that is not as favourable as the exemption provided for under the Convention. Some States may wish to eliminate the resulting so-called “cliff effect” associated with the denial of all treaty benefits, even where the difference in benefits provided under the two conventions is relatively small, by providing for taxation by the State of source at a rate similar to that which would have been provided under the other convention. Such a regime could be achieved through the following alternative provisions concerning the taxation of dividends, interest and royalties, which provide limited benefits generally corresponding to those that would have been available under the other convention:
Provision on dividends to be added to Article 10
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4 of this Article, where a company seeks to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 of this Convention in respect of dividends, if such company does not satisfy the criteria of that paragraph solely because of:
a) the requirement of subsection B) of section (i) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29; or
b) the requirement in section (ii) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 that a person entitled to benefits under paragraph 5 of Article 29 would be entitled to a rate of tax on dividends that is lower than or equal to the rate applicable under paragraph 2 of this Article;
such company may be taxed in the Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident and in accordance with the laws of that Contracting State. However, in such cases, the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate of tax applicable to the persons referred to in the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 (notwithstanding the requirements specified in subparagraphs a) and b) of this paragraph) if such persons had received the dividends directly. For the purposes of this paragraph:
c) indirect ownership by such persons of the voting shares of the company paying the dividends shall be treated as direct ownership; and
d) a person referred to in section (iii) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be treated as being entitled to the limitation of tax to which such person would have been entitled if such person were a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the dividends.
Provision on interest to be added to Article 11
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4 of this Article, where a company seeks to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 in respect of an interest payment, if such company does not satisfy the criteria of that paragraph solely because of:
a) the requirement of subsection B) of section (i) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29; or
b) the requirement in section (ii) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 that a person entitled to benefits under paragraph 5 of Article 22 would be entitled to a rate of tax on interest that is lower than or equal to the rate applicable under paragraph 2 of this Article;
such company may be taxed by the Contracting State in which the interest arises in accordance with the laws of that State. However, in such cases, the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate of tax applicable to the persons referred to in the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 (notwithstanding the requirements specified in subparagraphs a) and b) of this paragraph) if such persons had received the interest directly. For the purposes of this paragraph, a person referred to in section (iii) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be treated as being entitled to the limitation of tax to which such person would have been entitled if such person were a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the interest.
Provision on royalties to be added to Article 12
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 3 of this Article, where a company seeks to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 in respect of royalties, if such company does not satisfy the criteria of that paragraph solely because of the requirement of subsection B) of section (i) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29, such company may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the royalties arise and in accordance with the laws of that State, except that the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate of tax to which the persons referred to in the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 (notwithstanding the requirement of subsection B) of section (i) of that definition) would have been entitled if such persons had received the royalties directly. For the purposes of this paragraph, a person referred to in section (iii) of the definition of the term “equivalent beneficiary” in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be treated as being entitled to the limitation of tax to which such person would have been entitled if such person were a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the royalties.
The term “disproportionate class of shares”
- Paragraph 148 of the Commentary on the detailed version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provides:
- Under the definition of the term “disproportionate class of shares”, which is used in the ownership test in various parts of the Article, a company or other entity has a disproportionate class of shares if it has outstanding shares that are subject to terms or other arrangements that entitle the holder of those shares to receive a greater portion of the income of the company or entity derived in another Contracting State than the portion to which the holder would have been entitled in the absence of such terms or arrangements. Thus, for example, a company resident in one Contracting State has a “disproportionate class of shares” if some of its outstanding shares are “tracking shares” that pay dividends based on a formula that approximately corresponds to the return earned by the company on its assets used in the other Contracting State. This is illustrated by the following example:
— Example: ACO is a company resident in State A. ACO has issued ordinary and preferred shares. The ordinary shares are listed and regularly traded on the principal stock exchange of State A. The preferred shares are non-voting and entitle their holders only to receive dividends equal in amount to the interest payments that ACO receives from unrelated borrowers in State B. The preferred shares are wholly owned by one shareholder who is a resident of a third State with which State B has no tax convention. The ordinary shares account for more than 50 per cent of the value of ACO and 100 per cent of the voting rights. Since the holder of the preferred shares is entitled to receive payments corresponding to the interest income earned by ACO in State B, the preferred shares constitute a “disproportionate class of shares” and, since these shares are not regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange, ACO will not be entitled to benefits under subparagraph c) of this provision of paragraph 2.
The term “place of effective management and control”
31. Paragraphs 149 and 150 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
149. The term “place of effective management and control” is relevant for the purposes of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 and paragraph 5 of the detailed version. This term should be distinguished from the concept of “place of effective management”, which was used prior to 2017 in paragraph 3 of Article 4 and in various provisions, including Article 8, applicable to the operation of ships and aircraft. The concept of “place of effective management” has been interpreted by some States as the place where the most senior person or group of persons (for example, the board of directors) make the key management and commercial decisions necessary for the conduct of the company’s business. The concept of “place of effective management and control”, by contrast, refers to the place where day-to-day responsibility for the management of the company or entity (and its direct and indirect subsidiaries) is exercised.
150. The place of effective management and control of a company or entity will be in the State of residence of that company or entity only if the following two conditions are met:
— First, under subdivision (i), executive directors and senior management employees have day-to-day responsibility for making the majority of the strategic, financial and operational policy decisions for the company or entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, as well as for the personnel who support such management in preparing and making those decisions, and these activities are performed to a greater extent in that State than in any other State or any third State. Thus, the test examines the overall activities of the relevant persons to determine where those activities are performed. In most cases, a necessary but insufficient condition is that the chief executive officer and other senior executives are usually located in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident.
— Second, executive directors and senior management employees have day-to-day responsibility for making a greater number of strategic, financial and operational policy decisions for the company and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the employees who assist such management in making those decisions perform more of the necessary day-to-day activities than the officers or employees of any other company or entity.
Term “qualified intermediate owner”
32. Paragraphs 151 to 154 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
151. The definition of “qualified intermediate owner” in the detailed version applies for the purposes of the ownership tests set out in subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2, as well as under the derivative benefits rule set out in paragraph 4.
152. Under subdivision (i) of this definition, a qualified intermediate owner is an entity that is a resident of a third State which has concluded a comprehensive income tax treaty with the Contracting State from which treaty benefits are requested.
153. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that their tax treaties should include provisions denying the application of specific treaty provisions to income derived under regimes that constitute “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85-100 of the Commentary on Article 1) and denying the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related parties that benefit from domestic legislation providing for a notional deduction for equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). These States may wish to limit the scope of subdivision (i) so that it applies only to residents of third States with which the State requesting treaty benefits has concluded comprehensive income tax treaties and which do not benefit from special tax regimes or notional interest deductions. This could be achieved by amending subdivision (i) as follows:
(i) a resident of a State that has in force with the Contracting State from which benefits under this Convention are requested a comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation and that does not benefit from any:
A) special tax regime, provided that, if the relevant comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation does not contain a definition of a special tax regime similar to the provisions included in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention containing the definition of “special tax regime”], the principles for determining the provisions provided for in this Convention shall apply, but without taking into account the requirement of paragraph (v) of that definition; or
B) notional interest deduction of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions for equity]; or
154. Under subdivision (ii) of the definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company to which the relevant ownership test under subparagraphs d) or f) of paragraph 2 or the derivative benefits rule of paragraph 4 applies.
Term “tested group”
33. Paragraph 155 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provides:
155. This subparagraph defines the term “tested group” for the purposes of the base erosion rules set out in subdivision (ii) of subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2 and in paragraphs 4 and 5. The tested group must consist of the tested company to which the relevant base erosion rule applies (referred to as the “tested resident”) and any company that either participates as a member with that tested resident in a tax consolidation, fiscal unity or similar regime that allows members of the group to share profits or losses, or any company that, during the relevant taxable period, shares losses with the tested resident, is entitled to group relief or is subject to another loss-sharing regime. If there is no tested group, the relevant base erosion tests applicable to the tested group do not apply.
Term “gross income”
34. Paragraphs 156 and 157 of the Commentary on the Detailed Version of Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
156. This subparagraph defines the term “gross income” for the purposes of applying the base erosion rules in subdivision (ii) of subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2 and in paragraphs 4 and 5. The starting point for calculating gross income is gross receipts, as determined in the Contracting State of residence of the relevant entity for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefit will be granted. If an enterprise carries on a business that involves the manufacture or sale of goods, “gross income” means gross receipts reduced by the cost of goods sold. If the tested subsidiary is engaged in providing non-financial services, “gross income” means such gross receipts reduced by the direct costs of obtaining those receipts.
157. Subdivision (i) of the definition further provides that, except for the determination of benefits in respect of dividends under Article 10, gross income shall not include any portion of any dividends that are effectively exempt from tax in the Contracting State of residence of the person, whether by way of deductions or otherwise, regardless of the State of residence of the company paying those dividends. Subdivision (ii) provides that, except for the portion of any dividends that is subject to tax, the gross income of the tested group shall not take into account any transactions between companies within the tested group.
Paragraph 8
35. Paragraphs 161-168 of the Commentary on Article 29 of the OECD Model Tax Convention provide:
161. As mentioned in paragraph 32 of the Commentary on Article 10, paragraph 25 of the Commentary on Article 11 and paragraph 21 of the Commentary on Article 12, the transfer of shares, debt claims, rights or property to permanent establishments set up exclusively for that purpose in countries may give rise to potential abuses where those countries do not tax income derived from such assets or offer a preferential tax regime for them. Where the State of residence exempts from tax profits attributable to such permanent establishments located in third jurisdictions, the source State should not be expected to grant treaty benefits in respect of such income. The proposed paragraph, which applies where a Contracting State exempts from tax the income of enterprises of that State attributable to permanent establishments located in third countries, provides that treaty benefits shall not be granted in such cases. However, this rule does not apply if:
— the income is subject to significant taxation in the State in which the permanent establishment is located; or
— the income results from, or is incidental to, the active conduct of a business through the permanent establishment, other than an investment business that is not carried on by a bank, insurance company, registered legal entity or securities dealer.
162. Under subparagraph c), in any case where the benefits provided for in this paragraph are denied, a resident of a Contracting State receiving the relevant income may request the competent authority of the other Contracting State to grant those benefits. The competent authority receiving such a request may, at its discretion, grant those benefits if it considers that this would be justified; however, before granting or refusing the request, it must consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State.
163. The following example illustrates the type of situation in which this paragraph is intended to apply. An enterprise of a Contracting State establishes a permanent establishment in a third jurisdiction that does not tax the profits of the permanent establishment or taxes them at a low rate. The profits attributable to the permanent establishment are exempt from taxation in the first-mentioned State either under a provision similar to Article 23 A included in a tax treaty between that State and the jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located, or under the domestic law of the first-mentioned State. The enterprise receives interest arising in the other Contracting State, which is included in the profits attributable to the permanent establishment. Assuming that the conditions for the application of Article 11 are met, in the absence of paragraph 8, the State in which the interest arises would be required to grant the benefits of the limitation on taxation provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 11, despite the fact that the interest is exempt from taxation in the first-mentioned State and is practically not taxed in the third jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located. In such a situation, treaty benefits will be denied in respect of that income, except where the exception in subparagraph b), applicable to income that results from or is incidental to the active conduct of a business, applies to the relevant income, or where those benefits are granted under the discretionary benefits provisions of subparagraph c) by the competent authority of the State in which the interest arises.
164. The reference to the word “income” in subdivision (i) means that this provision applies regardless of whether the relevant income constitutes business profits. Thus, this rule applies where an enterprise of one Contracting State receives income from the other Contracting State and the first-mentioned State considers the right or property in respect of which the income is paid to be effectively connected with a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction (including pursuant to a provision such as paragraph 2 of Article 21 in a treaty between the first-mentioned State and the third jurisdiction).
165. Subject to the conditions in subdivisions (i) and (ii), subparagraph a) denies benefits that would otherwise apply under the other provisions of the Convention if the relevant item of income is treated as part of the profits of a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction and the amount of tax imposed on that item of income in that third jurisdiction is less than the lesser of the following two amounts: (a) the amount of that item of income multiplied by the minimum rate that the Contracting States have bilaterally established for the purposes of this paragraph; and (b) 60 per cent of the amount of tax that would have been imposed on that item of income in the State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment had been located in that State.
166. The phrase “amount of that item of income” refers to the amount of the relevant income after deducting all expenses attributable to that item of income that are deductible under the laws of the relevant jurisdiction. Thus, for the purposes of determining the tax in the third jurisdiction attributable to that item of income, the total tax applicable to the profits of the permanent establishment located in that jurisdiction will first be calculated after deducting all expenses that are deductible under the laws of that jurisdiction in determining the amount of taxable profits attributable to the permanent establishment. In such a case, the tax applicable to the relevant amount of the item of income will be determined by multiplying the total tax applicable to the profits of the permanent establishment by the ratio of the net amount of the item of income (i.e. the total amount of the item of income less the deductions for expenses deducted in calculating the taxable profits of the permanent establishment that are directly or proportionately attributable to that item of income) to the taxable profits of the permanent establishment. A similar calculation will be made for the purposes of determining the tax that would have been imposed on that item of income in the Contracting State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment had been located in that State; in that case, expenses that are deductible under the laws of the Contracting State will be deducted.
167. For the purposes of the exception included in subparagraph b), the reference to income that “results from the active conduct of a business or is incidental thereto” should be interpreted as indicated in paragraphs 74-76 above.
168. Instead of adopting the wording of paragraph 8, some States may prefer a more comprehensive solution that would not be limited to situations where an enterprise of a Contracting State is exempt in that State from tax on profits attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction, and that would not include a tax exception applicable to income that results from or is incidental to the active conduct of a business, nor require the calculation of the tax that would have been paid in the State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment had been located in that State. In such a case, the rule would apply whenever income derived in one Contracting State and attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction is subject to combined taxation in the State of the enterprise and the jurisdiction of the permanent establishment at an effective rate that is lower than the lesser of the rates determined on a bilateral basis and 60 per cent of the general corporate tax rate in the State where the enterprise is located. The following is an example of a rule that could be used for this purpose:
Where an enterprise of one Contracting State derives income from the other Contracting State and the first-mentioned State treats that income as profits attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction, the benefits provided for in this Convention shall not apply to such income if that income is subject to a combined effective tax rate in the first-mentioned State and the jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located that is lower than the lesser of [the rate to be determined on a bilateral basis] or 60 per cent of the general corporate income tax rate and the general statutory corporate income tax rate in force in the first-mentioned State. If, pursuant to the preceding sentence, benefits under this Convention are denied in respect of any item of income derived by a resident of a Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, in response to a request by that resident, such competent authority determines that the granting of such benefits is justified in light of the reasons why such resident did not satisfy the requirements of this paragraph (such as the existence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which a request is made under the preceding sentence must consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or refusing the request.
Paragraph 9
36. Prior to the 2017 Update, the United Nations Model Convention did not contain a general anti-abuse rule, but provided optional text for inclusion in the Commentary on Article 1 in paragraph 36. As part of the 2017 Update, the Committee decided that the United Nations Model Convention should include a general anti-abuse rule as paragraph 9 of Article 29. Accordingly, paragraphs 14-24 of the Commentary on Article 1 are primarily relevant to those bilateral tax treaties that do not contain a general anti-abuse rule similar to this paragraph.
37. Paragraph 9 corresponds to the general anti-abuse rule [recommended by the OECD/G20 in the Final Report on Action 6 (Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances) and] added to the OECD Model Convention as paragraph 9 of Article 29. Accordingly, the Committee determined that paragraphs 169-186 of the Commentary on paragraph 9 of Article 29 of the OECD Model Convention are also relevant for the purposes of paragraph 9 of this Article. These paragraphs, with the corresponding modifications reflecting the inclusion of a general anti-abuse rule in paragraph 9 of this Article of the United Nations Model Convention, are reproduced below.
169. Paragraph 9 reflects the guidance contained in paragraphs [22-25] of the Commentary on Article 1. According to this guidance, the benefits of a tax treaty should not be available where one of the principal purposes of certain transactions or arrangements is to obtain a benefit under a tax treaty and obtaining that benefit in such circumstances would be contrary to the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the tax treaty. Paragraph 9 incorporates the principles underlying those paragraphs into the Convention itself, in order to allow States to address cases of improper use of the Convention even where their domestic law does not allow them to do so under paragraph [22] of the Commentary on Article 1; it also confirms the application of these principles for States whose domestic law already allows them to address such cases.
170. The provisions of paragraph 9 result in the denial of a benefit under a tax treaty where one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction is to obtain a benefit under the Convention. However, in such a case, the final part of the paragraph provides the person who would otherwise be denied the benefit with the opportunity to establish that obtaining the benefit in the circumstances would be in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
171. Paragraph 9 supplements and in no way limits the scope of paragraphs 1-7 (the limitation on benefits rule): a benefit denied under those paragraphs is not a “benefit under the Convention” that is also denied under paragraph 9. Furthermore, the guidance contained in the Commentary on paragraph 9 should not be used to interpret paragraphs 1-7, and vice versa.
172. Conversely, the fact that a person is entitled to benefits under paragraphs 1-7 does not mean that those benefits cannot be denied under paragraph 9. Paragraphs 1-7 are rules that primarily concern the legal nature, ownership and general activities of residents of a Contracting State. As illustrated by the example in the following paragraph, these rules do not imply that a transaction or arrangement entered into by such a resident cannot constitute an improper use of a treaty provision.
173. Paragraph 9 should be considered in the context of paragraphs 1-7 and the rest of the Convention, including its preamble. This is particularly important for determining the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the Convention. Assume, for example, that a publicly traded company, whose shares are regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident, derives income from the other Contracting State. As long as that company is a “qualified person”, as defined in paragraph 2, it is clear that the benefits of the Convention should not be denied solely on the basis of the ownership structure of that company, for example, because the majority of its shareholders are not residents of the same State. The purpose of subparagraph 2 c) is to establish a threshold for the treaty entitlement of publicly traded companies whose shares are owned by residents of different States. However, the fact that such a company is a qualified person does not mean that benefits cannot be denied under paragraph 9 for reasons unrelated to the ownership of that company’s shares. Assume, for example, that such a publicly traded company is a bank that enters into an intermediary financing arrangement designed to indirectly provide a resident of a third State with the benefit of a lower withholding tax rate under a tax treaty. In this case, paragraph 9 would apply to deny that benefit, since subparagraph 2 c), when considered in the context of the rest of the Convention and, in particular, its preamble, cannot be regarded as having a common purpose of the two Contracting States to authorize treaty-shopping transactions by publicly traded companies.
174. The provisions of paragraph 9 establish that a Contracting State may deny tax treaty benefits where, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, it is reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction was to obtain a benefit under a tax treaty. This provision is intended to ensure that tax treaties are applied in accordance with the purpose for which they were concluded, namely, to provide benefits in respect of bona fide exchanges of goods and services and movements of capital and persons, as opposed to arrangements whose principal purpose is to secure a more favourable tax treatment.
175. The term “benefit” includes all limitations (for example, a reduction in tax, an exemption, a deferral or a refund) on taxation imposed by the State of source under Articles 6-22 of the Convention, the relief from double taxation provided for in Article 23, and the protection afforded to residents and nationals of a Contracting State under Article 24 or any other similar limitations. This includes, for example, limitations on the taxation rights of a Contracting State in respect of dividends, interest or royalties arising in that State and paid to a resident of the other State (who is the beneficial owner) under Articles 10, 11, 12 or 12A. It also includes limitations on the rights of a Contracting State to tax capital gains derived from the alienation of movable property situated in that State by a resident of the other State under Article 13. If a tax treaty provides for other limitations (for example, a tax sparing provision), the provisions of this Article also apply to that benefit.
176. The phrase “that directly or indirectly resulted in that benefit” is deliberately broad and is intended to include situations where a person claiming the application of benefits under a tax treaty does so in respect of a transaction that is not the one that was undertaken for one of the principal purposes of obtaining that treaty benefit. This is illustrated by the following example:
TCO, a company resident in State T, acquired all the shares and debt of SCO, a company resident in State S, which had previously been owned by SCO’s parent company. These included a loan granted to SCO at an annual interest rate of 4 per cent, payable on demand. State T does not have a tax treaty with State S and, therefore, any interest paid by SCO to TCO is subject to withholding tax at the rate of 25 per cent under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax treaty between State R and State S, no withholding tax is imposed on interest paid by a company resident in one Contracting State and beneficially owned by a company resident in the other State; furthermore, that treaty does not contain provisions similar to paragraphs 1-6. TCO decides to transfer the loan to RCO, a subsidiary resident in State R, in exchange for three promissory notes payable on demand, bearing interest at 3.9 per cent.
In this example, while RCO claims the benefit of the treaty between State R and State S in respect of a loan that was entered into for bona fide commercial reasons, if the facts of the case show that one of the principal purposes of TCO in transferring the loan to RCO was to enable RCO to obtain a benefit under the treaty between State R and State S, the provision denying that benefit will apply, since that benefit is an indirect result of the transfer of the loan.
177. The terms “arrangement or transaction” should be interpreted broadly and include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions, whether or not legally enforceable. In particular, they include the creation, assignment, acquisition or transfer of the income itself or of the property or rights in respect of which that income accrues. These terms also cover arrangements concerning the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of a person deriving income, including the qualification of that person as a resident of one of the Contracting States, and include steps that persons may take independently to establish residence. An example of an “arrangement” would be taking steps to ensure that meetings of a company’s board of directors are held in another country in order to claim that the company has changed its place of residence. A single transaction may give rise to a benefit, or it may be carried out in conjunction with a more complex series of transactions that, taken together, give rise to a benefit. In both cases, the provisions of paragraph 9 may apply.
178. In determining whether obtaining benefits under the Convention was one of the principal purposes of any person involved in or party to an arrangement or transaction, it is important to undertake an objective analysis of the aims and purposes of all persons involved in carrying out that arrangement or transaction or who are parties to it. The purposes of an arrangement or transaction are a question of fact that can only be answered by examining all the circumstances surrounding the arrangement or event in each particular case. It is not necessary to seek compelling evidence of the intentions of a person involved in an arrangement or transaction, but, following an objective analysis of the relevant facts and circumstances, it must be reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement or transaction was to obtain benefits under a tax treaty. However, it should not be lightly assumed that obtaining a benefit under a tax treaty was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction, and a simple analysis of the consequences of an arrangement will generally not be sufficient to conclude that this was its purpose. Nevertheless, where an arrangement can reasonably be explained only by the benefit derived from a tax treaty, it may be concluded that one of the principal purposes of that arrangement was to obtain that benefit.
179. A person cannot avoid the application of this paragraph simply by asserting that the arrangement or transaction was not entered into or structured for the purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention. The evidence must be weighed to determine whether it is reasonable to conclude that the arrangement or transaction was entered into for such a purpose. The determination requires reasonableness, implying that the possibility of different interpretations of events must be considered objectively.
180. The reference to “one of the principal purposes” in paragraph 9 means that obtaining a benefit under a tax treaty does not necessarily have to be the sole or dominant purpose of a particular arrangement or transaction. It is sufficient that obtaining such a benefit is at least one of the principal purposes. For example, a person may sell immovable property for various reasons, but if, before the sale, that person becomes a resident of one of the Contracting States and one of the principal purposes of doing so is to obtain a benefit under a tax treaty, paragraph 9 may apply, notwithstanding the fact that there may be other principal purposes for changing the place of residence, such as facilitating the sale of the property or reinvesting the proceeds of the alienation.
181. A purpose will not be a principal purpose if, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, it is reasonable to conclude that obtaining a benefit was not a principal consideration and would not have justified entering into any arrangement or transaction that, by itself or together with other transactions, resulted in that benefit. In particular, where an arrangement is inextricably linked to a core commercial activity and its form was not determined by considerations of obtaining a benefit, it is unlikely that obtaining that benefit will be considered a principal purpose. However, where an arrangement is entered into for the purpose of obtaining similar benefits under a number of tax treaties, it should not be assumed that obtaining benefits under other tax treaties will prevent obtaining a benefit under any particular tax treaty from being considered one of the principal purposes of that arrangement. Assume, for example, that a taxpayer resident in State A enters into an intermediary arrangement with a financial institution resident in State B in order for that financial institution to invest, ultimately on behalf of that taxpayer, in bonds issued in a large number of States with which State B, but not State A, has tax treaties. If the facts and circumstances indicate that the arrangement was entered into for the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under those tax treaties, it should not be considered that obtaining benefits under any particular treaty was not one of the principal purposes of that arrangement. Similarly, purposes relating to the avoidance of domestic law should not be used to argue that obtaining a treaty benefit is merely an ancillary element of such purposes.
182. The following examples illustrate the application of this paragraph (the examples included in paragraph 186 below should also be taken into account when determining whether and when this paragraph will apply in the case of the location of pipelines) [...].
— Example A: TCO, a company resident in State T, owns shares in SCO, a company resident in State S, which are listed on the stock exchange of State C. State T does not have a tax treaty with State S and, therefore, any dividends paid by SCO to TCO are subject to withholding tax on dividends at the rate of 25 per cent under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax treaty between State R and State S, no withholding tax is imposed on dividends paid by a company resident in one Contracting State and beneficially owned by a company resident in the other State. TCO enters into an arrangement with RCO, an independent financial institution resident in State R, under which TCO assigns to RCO the right to receive dividends that have been declared but not yet paid by SCO.
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it would be reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement under which TCO assigned the right to receive dividends to RCO was to obtain for RCO the exemption from withholding tax on dividends provided for under the tax treaty between States R and S, and granting the benefit of that exemption under this arrangement would be contrary to the object and purpose of the tax treaty.
— Example B: SCO, a company resident in State S, is a subsidiary of TCO, a company resident in State T. State T does not have a tax treaty with State S and, therefore, any dividends paid by SCO to TCO are subject to withholding tax on dividends at the rate of 25 per cent under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax treaty between State R and State S, the applicable withholding tax rate on dividends paid by a company of State S to a resident of State R is 5 per cent. TCO therefore enters into an arrangement with RCO, a financial institution resident in State R and a qualified person under subparagraph 3 a) of this Article, under which RCO acquires a usufruct right over newly issued non-voting preference shares of SCO for a period of three years. TCO is the sole owner of these shares. The usufruct right entitles RCO to receive the dividends attributable to those preference shares. The amount paid by RCO for the acquisition of the usufruct corresponds to the present value of the dividends to be paid on the preference shares over a three-year period (discounted at the rate at which TCO could borrow from RCO).
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it would be reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement under which RCO acquired the usufruct right over the preference shares issued by SCO was to obtain the benefit of the 5 per cent limitation on withholding tax applicable to dividends under the tax treaty between State R and State S, and granting the benefit of that limitation under this purchase arrangement would be contrary to the object and purpose of the tax treaty.
— Example C: RCO, a company resident in State R, is engaged in the manufacture of electronic devices, and its business is expanding rapidly. The company is currently considering establishing a manufacturing facility in a developing country in order to benefit from lower production costs. Following a preliminary analysis, potential locations in three different countries have been identified. All three countries have similar economic and political environments. After taking into consideration the fact that State S is the only one of these countries with which State R has a tax treaty, the decision is made to build the factory in that State.
In this example, although the decision to invest in State S was made taking into account the benefits provided under the tax treaty between State R and State S, it is clear that the principal purposes of the investment and the construction of the factory are related to the expansion of RCO’s business and the lower production costs in that country. In this example, it cannot reasonably be concluded that one of the principal purposes of constructing the factory is to obtain treaty benefits. Furthermore, given that the general purpose of tax treaties is to encourage cross-border investment, obtaining benefits under the treaty between State R and State S in respect of the investment in the factory constructed in State S is consistent with the object and purpose of the provisions of that treaty.
— Example D: RCO, a collective investment company resident in State R, manages a diversified portfolio of investments in international financial markets. Currently, 15 per cent of RCO’s portfolio consists of shares in companies resident in State S, in respect of which the company receives annual dividends. Under the tax treaty between State R and State S, the withholding tax rate on dividends is reduced from 30 to 10 per cent. When making investment decisions, RCO takes into account the availability of tax benefits provided under State R’s extensive network of tax treaties. Most of RCO’s investors are residents of State R, although a number of investors (the “minority investors”) are residents of States with which State S does not have tax treaties. The investors’ decisions to invest in RCO are not driven by any particular investments made by RCO, and RCO’s investment strategy is not dependent on the tax positions of its investors. RCO distributes almost all of its income to its investors annually and pays tax in State R on income not distributed during the year. When deciding to invest in shares of companies resident in State S, RCO took into account the availability of benefits under the tax treaty between State R and State S in respect of dividends, but this alone would not be sufficient for paragraph 9 to apply. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment, and therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to investments, it is necessary to consider the context in which the investments were made. In this example, unless RCO’s investments form part of an arrangement or are connected with another transaction undertaken for the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefit of the tax treaty between State R and State S.
— Example E: RCO, a company resident in State R, has held 24 per cent of the shares in SCO, a company resident in State S, for the past five years. Following the entry into force of the tax treaty between States R and S (Article 10 of which is identical to Article 10 of this Convention), RCO decides to increase its shareholding in SCO to 25 per cent. The facts and circumstances show that the decision to acquire these additional shares was made primarily in order to obtain the benefit of the lower tax rate provided for in Article 10(2)a) of the treaty.
In this case, one of the principal purposes of the transaction through which the additional shares are acquired is clearly to obtain the benefit under Article 10(2)a), and paragraph 9 will not apply because it can be established that granting such a benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the object and purpose of Article 10(2)a). This subparagraph uses an arbitrary threshold of 25 per cent for the purpose of determining which shareholders are entitled to the benefit of the reduced rate of tax on dividends, and granting benefits under this subparagraph to a taxpayer who actually increases its participation in the company to satisfy this requirement is consistent with that approach.
— Example F: TCO is a publicly traded company resident in State T. TCO’s information technology business, established in State T, has grown significantly over the past several years as a result of the aggressive mergers and acquisitions policy pursued by TCO’s management. RCO, a company resident in State R (a State that has concluded numerous tax treaties providing for no or low withholding taxation on dividends and royalties), is the family holding company of a group that is also actively engaged in the information technology sector. Almost all of RCO’s shares are owned by residents of State R who are relatives of the entrepreneur who launched and developed the RCO group’s business. RCO’s principal assets are shares in subsidiaries located in neighbouring countries, including SCO, a company resident in State S, as well as patents developed in State R and licensed to those subsidiaries.
TCO, which has long been interested in acquiring the business of the RCO group and its patent portfolio, makes an offer to purchase all of the shares in RCO. In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it would be reasonable to conclude that the principal purposes of acquiring RCO are related to the expansion of TCO’s business and do not include obtaining benefits under the treaty between States R and S. The fact that RCO operates primarily as a holding company does not change this result. It is possible that, following the acquisition of the shares in RCO, TCO’s management will consider the benefits of the tax treaty concluded between States R and S and decide to retain the shares in SCO and the patents licensed to SCO in RCO. However, this would not constitute a purpose related to the relevant transaction, which is the acquisition of the shares in RCO.
— Example G: TCO, a company resident in State T, is a publicly traded company resident in State T. It directly or indirectly owns a number of subsidiaries in different countries. Most of these companies carry out the commercial activities of the TCO group in local markets. In one region, TCO owns shares in five such companies, each located in a different neighbouring State. TCO is considering establishing a regional company for the purpose of providing group services to these companies, including management services such as accounting, legal advice and human resources; financial and treasury services such as foreign exchange risk management and the organization of hedging transactions; as well as certain other non-financing services. After considering possible locations, TCO decides to establish the regional company RCO in State R. This decision is primarily driven by the availability of a skilled workforce, a reliable legal system, a favourable business environment, political stability, membership in a regional group, a developed banking sector and State R’s comprehensive network of tax treaties, including tax treaties with the five States in which TCO owns subsidiaries.
In this example, a simple analysis of the consequences of the arrangements for future payments by the subsidiaries to the regional company would not permit a conclusion to be drawn as to the purposes of the establishment of RCO by TCO. Assuming that the intra-group services provided by RCO, including the making of decisions necessary for the conduct of business, constitute a genuine business through which RCO performs significant economic functions using real assets and assuming real risks, and that the business is carried on by RCO through its own personnel located in State R, it would be unreasonable to deny the benefits of the treaties concluded between State R and the five States in which the subsidiaries operate, unless other facts indicate that RCO was established for other tax purposes or RCO enters into specific transactions to which paragraph 9 would otherwise apply (see also Example F in paragraph [15] below in relation to interest and other remuneration that RCO may receive as a result of its group financing activities).
— Example H: TCO is a company resident in State T whose shares are listed on the stock exchange of State T. It is the parent company of a multinational enterprise engaged in various activities throughout the world (wholesale and retail trade, manufacturing, investment, finance, etc.). Transportation difficulties, time differences, the limited number of personnel fluent in foreign languages and the overseas location of business partners make it difficult for TCO to manage its foreign operations from State T. TCO therefore establishes RCO, a subsidiary resident in State R (a country with developed international trade and financial markets and a large number of highly qualified personnel), as a base for developing its foreign operations. RCO carries on various business activities, such as wholesale and retail trade, manufacturing, financing, as well as domestic and international investments. RCO has the human and financial resources (in various areas such as law, finance, accounting, taxation, risk management, auditing and internal control) necessary to carry on these activities. It is clear that RCO’s activities constitute the active conduct of a business in State R. As part of its activities, RCO also engages in the development of new production facilities in State S. For this purpose, it contributes equity capital and provides loans to SCO, a subsidiary resident in State S that RCO has established to own these facilities. RCO will receive dividends and interest from SCO.
In this example, RCO was established for business reasons.
On the basis of these facts and in the absence of other facts indicating that one of the principal purposes of establishing RCO or financing SCO was to obtain benefits under the treaty between States R and S, paragraph 9 will not apply to these transactions.
— Example I: RCO, a company resident in State R, is one of several collective management organizations that issue licences on behalf of neighbouring performers and copyright owners for the public performance of music or its broadcasting by radio, television or the Internet. SCO, a company resident in State S, carries on similar activities in State S. Performers and copyright owners from different countries appoint RCO or SCO as their agent to issue licences and collect royalties in respect of the copyright and related rights that they own; RCO and SCO distribute to each copyright owner the amount of royalties they receive on that owner’s behalf, less a commission (in most cases, the amount distributed to each copyright owner is relatively small). RCO has entered into an agreement with SCO under which SCO issues licences to users in State S and distributes royalties to RCO in respect of the rights managed by RCO; RCO does the same in State R in respect of the rights managed by SCO. SCO has agreed with the tax authorities of State S that it will withhold tax on royalties from payments it makes to RCO on the basis of the applicable treaties between State S and the State of residence of each copyright owner represented by RCO, using information provided by RCO, since those copyright owners are the beneficial owners of the royalties paid by SCO to RCO.
In this example, it is clear that the arrangements between the copyright owners and RCO and SCO, as well as those between SCO and RCO, were entered into for the efficient administration of licensing and collection of royalties in respect of a large number of small transactions. Although one of the purposes of entering into such arrangements may well be to ensure that withholding tax is levied at the correct treaty rate without requiring each individual copyright owner to apply for refunds of small payments, which would be burdensome and costly, it is clear that such a purpose, which serves to facilitate the correct and efficient application of tax treaties, is consistent with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the applicable treaties.
— Example J: RCO, a company resident in State R, has successfully submitted a bid to construct a power plant for SCO, an independent company resident in State S. The construction project is expected to last 22 months. During the negotiations for the conclusion of the contract, the project is divided into two separate contracts, each lasting 11 months. The first contract is concluded with RCO and the second with SUBCO, a newly incorporated wholly owned subsidiary of RCO resident in State R. At SCO’s request, which wished to ensure that RCO would be contractually liable for the performance of both contracts, the contractual arrangements are structured so that RCO is jointly and severally liable with SUBCO for the performance of SUBCO’s contractual obligations under the SUBCO-SCO contract.
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it would be reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of entering into a separate contract under which SUBCO agreed to perform part of the construction project was to obtain for RCO and SUBCO the benefit of the rule provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the tax treaty between State R and State S. Granting the benefit of that rule in these circumstances would be contrary to the object and purpose of that paragraph, since the time limitation provided for in that paragraph would otherwise be rendered meaningless.
— Example K: RCO, a company resident in State R, is a wholly owned subsidiary of a Fund, an institutional investor resident in State T, which was established and is regulated in State T. RCO carries on its activities exclusively for the purpose of earning investment income as a regional investment platform for the Fund by acquiring and managing a diversified portfolio of private market investments located in countries belonging to a regional group that includes State R. The decision to establish the regional investment platform in State R was primarily driven by the availability of directors familiar with regional business practices and regulations, the availability of a qualified multilingual workforce, State R’s membership in the regional group and the use of the common currency of that group, as well as State R’s extensive network of tax treaties, including its tax treaty with State S, which provides for low withholding tax rates. RCO employs an experienced team of local managers who review the Fund’s investment recommendations, approve and monitor investments, perform treasury functions, maintain RCO’s accounting records and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements in the States where the investments are made. RCO’s board of directors is appointed by the Fund and consists mostly of directors resident in State R who have experience in investment management, as well as members of the Fund’s global management team. RCO pays taxes and files tax returns in State R. RCO is currently considering making an investment in SCO, a company resident in State S. The investment in SCO will constitute only part of RCO’s overall investment portfolio, which includes investments in a number of countries other than State S that are also members of the same regional group. Under the tax treaty between States R and S, the withholding tax rate on dividends is reduced from 30 to 5 per cent. Under the tax treaty between States S and T, the withholding tax rate on dividends is 10 per cent.
In deciding whether or not to invest in SCO, RCO takes into account the availability of benefits under the tax treaty between State R and State S in respect of dividends, but this alone is not sufficient for paragraph 9 to apply. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment, and therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to investments, it is necessary to consider the context in which the investments were made, including the reasons for establishing RCO in State R, as well as the investment functions and other activities carried on in State R. In this example, in the absence of other facts or circumstances indicating that RCO’s investments form part of an arrangement or are connected with another transaction undertaken for the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefits of the tax treaty between State R and State S.
— Example L: RCO, a securitization company resident in State R, was established by a bank that sold RCO a portfolio of loans and other receivables due from borrowers located in a number of jurisdictions. RCO is entirely debt-financed. RCO has issued a single share, which is held in trust and has no economic value. RCO’s debt financing was raised through the issuance of bonds that are widely held by third-party investors. The bonds are listed on a recognized stock exchange, allowing them to be traded on the secondary market, and are held through a clearing system. In accordance with regulatory requirements, the bank also retained a small percentage of the debt securities widely held and issued by RCO. Currently, 60 per cent of RCO’s portfolio consists of receivables from small and medium-sized enterprises resident in State S, in respect of which RCO regularly receives interest. The bank is resident in State T, which has a tax treaty with State S providing benefits equivalent to those provided under the international tax treaty. Under the tax treaty between States R and S, the withholding tax rate on interest is reduced from 30 to 10 per cent.
When establishing RCO, the bank took into account a large number of considerations, including the existence of a sound securitization framework in State R and other relevant legislation, the availability of qualified personnel and support services in State R, as well as the availability of tax benefits under State R’s extensive network of tax treaties. The decisions of investors to invest in RCO are not dependent on any specific investments made by RCO, and RCO’s investment strategy is not dependent on the tax positions of its investors. RCO is taxed in State R on the income it receives and is entitled to a full deduction for interest payments to investors.
When deciding to sell the receivables from enterprises resident in State S, the bank and RCO considered the availability of benefits under the tax treaty between State R and State S in respect of interest, but this alone would not be sufficient for paragraph 9 to apply. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment, and therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to investments, it is necessary to consider the context in which the investments were made. In this example, in the absence of other facts or circumstances indicating that RCO’s investments form part of an arrangement or are connected with another transaction undertaken for the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefit of the tax treaty of the State.
— Example M: A real estate fund, a partnership of State S that is treated as fiscally transparent under the domestic tax law of State S, is established to invest in a portfolio of real estate investments in a specific geographical area. The real estate fund is managed by a regulated fund manager and is offered to institutional investors, such as pension schemes and sovereign wealth funds, under the fund’s investment mandate. A number of investors resident in different jurisdictions invest in the real estate fund. The investment strategy of the real estate fund, as set out in the fund’s marketing materials, is not determined by the tax positions of the investors, but is based on investing in certain real estate assets, maximizing their value and generating profits through the realization of investments. The investments of the real estate fund are made through a holding company, RCO, established in State R. RCO owns and manages all the real estate assets of the real estate fund and provides debt and/or equity financing for the underlying investments. RCO was established for a number of commercial and legal reasons, such as protecting the real estate fund from liabilities and potential claims in respect of the fund’s real estate assets, as well as facilitating debt financing (including from third-party lenders) and the creation, management and disposal of investments. It is also established for the purpose of addressing claims for exemption from withholding tax under any applicable tax treaty. This is an important function of RCO because, from an administrative perspective, it is easier for a single company to obtain treaty benefits than to require each institutional investor to submit its own claims for treaty benefits, particularly where the treaty benefits to which each investor is entitled in respect of a particular item of income are small. After considering possible locations, the real estate fund decides to establish RCO in State R. This decision was primarily driven by State R’s political stability, its regulatory framework, familiarity with lenders and investors, access to qualified personnel and State R’s extensive network of tax treaties, including its treaties with other States within the specific geographical area in which investments are intended to be made. However, RCO does not obtain treaty benefits that are more favourable than those to which its investors would have been entitled had they made the same investments directly in those States and obtained treaty benefits under the treaties concluded by their States of residence.
In this example, although the decision to locate RCO in State R is made in light of the availability of benefits under the tax treaties between State R and the States within the specific geographical area in which investments are intended to be made, it is clear that RCO’s real estate investments are made for commercial purposes in accordance with the fund’s investment mandate. Furthermore, RCO does not obtain any treaty benefits that are more favourable than those to which its investors would have been entitled, and each State in which RCO’s real estate investments are made is permitted to tax income derived directly from those investments. In the absence of other facts or circumstances indicating that RCO’s investments form part of an arrangement or relate to another transaction undertaken for the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny the benefits of the tax treaties between RCO and the States in which RCO’s real estate investments are located.
38. The following examples also illustrate the application of paragraph 9:
Example N: TCO, a resident of State T, is a member of a multinational group of companies that provides various cleaning and waste management services to businesses in State T as well as in other countries. TCO enters into a contract with SCO, a company resident in State S, to provide its services at three SCO business centres in State S for a period of 180 working days. Subsequently, when TCO has spent 150 working days in State S, TCO and SCO begin negotiations to extend the contract for a further 90 days. Under the amended contract, TCO transfers its rights and obligations under the contract to SUBCO, a wholly-owned subsidiary of TCO and also a resident of State T. SUBCO provides the required services to SCO for 90 days under the amended contract with the assistance of personnel supplied by TCO. The tax treaty between States T and S contains a provision identical to subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5. Both TCO and SUBCO claim the benefit provided for in subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5 on the grounds that neither of them provides services in State S for more than 183 days during any 12-month period.
In this example, the facts and circumstances may indicate that the principal purpose of limiting the duration of the services provided by TCO in State S to 180 days was to avoid creating a permanent establishment in State S and to benefit from the time threshold specified in subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5. However, the general anti-abuse rule set out in paragraph 9 of the Article would not apply in this example if TCO's services in State S were limited to 180 days, since the granting of the benefits provided for in subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5 in this situation is in accordance with its object and purpose. Subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5 establishes a time threshold for the existence of a permanent establishment of more than 183 working days during any 12-month period, and the granting of the benefit provided for in that subparagraph to a taxpayer who limits its activities in the form of providing services in the country to a period below the threshold. This result is consistent with the result in Example E above.
However, based on the transfer of TCO's rights and obligations under the contract to SUBCO as part of the contract extension, and in the absence of any other relevant facts and circumstances, it would be reasonable to conclude that one of the principal purposes of the transfer to SUBCO is to obtain the benefit of the time threshold for both the parent company and the subsidiary. If TCO had continued to provide services in State S under the contract extension, TCO would have exceeded the time threshold established in subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5 and would have been deemed to have a PE in State S. Granting TCO and SUBCO the benefit provided for in subparagraph (3)(b) of Article 5 under such an artificial contract-splitting arrangement would be contrary to the object and purpose of the Convention.
39. The OECD Commentary continues as follows:
183. In a number of countries, the application of the general anti-abuse rule contained in domestic law is subject, in one form or another, to approval. In some cases, this process provides for an internal expedited review of disputes concerning such provisions by senior officials of the administration. In other cases, this process allows advisory panels to submit their opinions to the administration regarding the application of the rule. Such approval processes reflect the serious nature of disputes in this area and contribute to overall consistency in the application of the rule. Countries may wish to establish a similar form of administrative process that would ensure that paragraph 9 is applied only after approval at a senior administrative level.
184. In addition, some countries consider that, where a person is denied a treaty benefit under paragraph 9, the competent authority of the Contracting State that would otherwise have granted that benefit should be able to treat that person as being entitled to that benefit or to other benefits in respect of the relevant item of income or capital, if such benefits would have been granted to that person in the absence of the transaction or arrangement that resulted in the application of paragraph 9. To provide for this possibility, such countries may include the following additional paragraph in their bilateral treaties:
10. Where a person has been denied a benefit provided for under this Convention in accordance with paragraph 9, the competent authority of the Contracting State that would otherwise have granted that benefit shall nevertheless treat that person as being entitled to that benefit or to other benefits in respect of a particular item of income or capital if such competent authority, upon request by that person and after consideration of the relevant facts and circumstances, determines that such benefits would have been granted to that person in the absence of the transaction or arrangement referred to in paragraph 9. The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request is made shall consult with the competent authority of the other State before rejecting a request made under this paragraph by a person who is a resident of that other State.
185. For the purposes of this alternative provision, the determination of whether benefits would have been granted in the absence of the transaction or arrangement referred to in paragraph 9, and the determination of the benefits to be granted, are left to the discretion of the competent authority to which the request is submitted. The alternative provision grants the competent authority broad discretionary powers for the purposes of making such determinations. Nevertheless, the provision requires the competent authority to consider the relevant facts and circumstances before making a decision and to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before rejecting a request for benefits where that request was made by a resident of that other State. The first requirement is intended to ensure that the competent authority considers each request on its merits, while the requirement to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, where the request is made by a resident of that other State, should ensure consistent treatment by the Contracting States of similar cases and the possibility of justifying its decision on the basis of the facts and circumstances of the particular case. However, this consultation process does not require the competent authority to which the request was submitted to obtain the agreement of the competent authority with which it consults.
186. The following example illustrates the application of this alternative provision. Assume that an individual who is a resident of State R and owns shares in a company resident in State S assigns the right to receive dividends declared by that company to another company resident in State R, which owns more than 25 per cent of the capital of the distributing company, with the principal purpose of obtaining the reduced withholding tax rate provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10. In such a case, if it is determined that the benefit provided for in that subparagraph should be denied in accordance with paragraph 9, the alternative provision would allow the competent authority of State S to grant the benefit of the reduced rate provided for in subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 if that competent authority determines that such benefit would have been granted in the absence of the assignment to the other company of the right to receive the dividends.
187. For various reasons, some countries may not be able to adopt the rule included in paragraph 9. However, in order to effectively address the problem of all forms of treaty shopping, these countries will need to supplement the limitation-on-benefits rule contained in paragraphs 1-7 with rules that address treaty-shopping strategies commonly referred to as "conduit arrangements", which are not covered by those paragraphs. These rules would address such conduit arrangements by denying the benefits of the provisions of the Convention, or some of them (for example, the provisions of Articles 7, 10, 11, 12 and 21), in respect of any income received under or as part of a conduit arrangement. They may also take the form of domestic anti-abuse rules or judicial doctrines that would achieve a similar result. The following are examples of conduit arrangements that should be covered by such rules, as well as examples of transactions that should not be treated as conduit arrangements for this purpose:
— Example A: RCO, a publicly traded company resident in State R, owns all the shares of SCO, a company resident in State S. TCO, a company resident in State T that does not have a tax treaty with State S, would like to acquire a minority interest in SCO but considers that the domestic withholding tax on dividends imposed by State S would make the investment unprofitable. RCO proposes that SCO instead issue preferred shares with a fixed return of 4 per cent plus a contingent return of 20 per cent of SCO's net profits. The preferred shares are redeemable after 20 years. TCO will enter into a separate agreement with RCO under which it will pay RCO an amount equal to the issue price of the preferred shares and will receive from RCO, after 20 years, the redemption price of the shares. During the 20-year period, RCO will pay TCO an amount equal to 3.75 per cent of the issue price plus 20 per cent of SCO's net profits.
This transaction constitutes a conduit arrangement to which the above rules should apply, since one of the principal purposes of RCO's participation in the transaction was to achieve a reduction in the withholding tax payable by TCO.
— Example B: SCO, a company resident in State S, has issued only one class of shares, which is wholly owned by RCO, a company resident in State R. RCO also has only one class of shares outstanding, all of which are owned by TCO, a company resident in State T that does not have a tax treaty with State S. RCO is engaged in the manufacture of electronics, and SCO is RCO's exclusive distributor in State S. RCO is engaged in the manufacture of electronics, and SCO is RCO's exclusive distributor in State S. Under paragraph 3 of the limitation-on-benefits rule, RCO will be entitled to benefits in respect of dividends received from SCO even if RCO's shares are owned by a resident of a third country.
This example concerns an ordinary commercial structure in which RCO and SCO carry on genuine economic activities in States R and S. The payment of dividends by subsidiaries such as SCO is an ordinary commercial transaction. In the absence of evidence indicating that one of the principal purposes of establishing this structure was to channel dividends from SCO to TCO, this structure would not constitute a conduit arrangement.
— Example C: TCO, a company resident in State T that does not have a tax treaty with State S, grants a loan of 1,000,000 to SCO, a company resident in State S and a wholly-owned subsidiary of TCO, in exchange for a promissory note issued by SCO. TCO subsequently realizes that it can avoid the withholding tax on interest imposed by State S by assigning the promissory note to its subsidiary RCO, a resident of State R (the treaty between States R and S does not permit withholding taxation of interest under certain circumstances). TCO therefore assigns the promissory note to RCO in exchange for a promissory note issued by RCO to TCO. The promissory note issued by TCO bears interest at a rate of 7 per cent, while the promissory note issued by RCO bears interest at a rate of 6 per cent.
— The transaction as a result of which RCO acquired the promissory note issued by SCO constitutes a conduit arrangement because it was structured in such a way as to eliminate the withholding tax that TCO would otherwise have paid to State S.
— Example D: TCO, a company resident in State T that does not have a tax treaty with State S, owns all the shares of SCO, a company resident in State S. For a long time, TCO has conducted all its banking operations through RCO, a bank resident in State R that is not associated with TCO or SCO, because the banking system in State T is relatively underdeveloped. As a result, TCO tends to maintain a large deposit with RCO. When SCO needs a loan to finance an acquisition, TCO suggests that SCO approach RCO, which is already familiar with the business carried on by TCO and SCO. SCO discusses the possibility of obtaining a loan with several banks, all of which offer terms similar to those offered by RCO, but ultimately enters into an agreement with RCO, partly because the interest paid to RCO is not subject to withholding tax in State S under the treaty between States S and R, whereas interest paid to banks resident in State T is subject to tax in State S.
The fact that the benefits of the treaty between States R and S are available if SCO borrows from RCO, and that similar benefits may not be available if it borrows elsewhere, is undoubtedly a factor influencing SCO's decision (which may be influenced by advice given to it by TCO, its 100 per cent shareholder). It may even be a decisive factor in the sense that, all other things being equal, the availability of treaty benefits may tip the balance in favour of borrowing from RCO rather than from another lender. However, the question of whether obtaining treaty benefits was one of the principal purposes of the transaction must be determined in light of the specific facts and circumstances. On the facts presented above, RCO is not associated with TCO and SCO, and there is no indication that the interest paid by SCO is in any way channelled to TCO. The fact that TCO has historically maintained large deposits with RCO is also a factor indicating that the loan to SCO is not accompanied by a specific deposit from TCO. In light of the facts presented, the transaction is unlikely to constitute a conduit arrangement.
However, if RCO's decision to grant a loan to SCO had depended on TCO providing a corresponding collateral deposit to secure the loan, such that RCO would not have entered into the transaction on substantially the same terms in the absence of that deposit, the facts would indicate that TCO was indirectly providing a loan to SCO by routing it through a bank in State R, in which case the transaction would constitute a conduit arrangement.
— Example E: RCO, a publicly traded company incorporated in State R, is a holding company for a manufacturing group operating in a highly competitive technological field. The manufacturing group conducts research through subsidiaries located throughout the world. Any patents developed by a subsidiary are licensed by that subsidiary to RCO, which then licenses the technology to its subsidiaries that need it. RCO retains only a small spread in respect of the royalties received, so that most of the profit goes to the subsidiary that bore the risk associated with developing the technology. TCO, a company located in a State with which State S does not have a tax treaty, has developed technology that will significantly increase the profitability of all RCO subsidiaries, including SCO, a company resident in State S. In accordance with its usual practice, RCO licenses the technology from TCO and sublicenses it to its subsidiaries. SCO pays royalties to RCO, virtually the entire amount of which is remitted to TCO.
In this example, there is no indication that RCO established its licensing business in order to reduce withholding tax in State S. Since RCO conforms to the group's standard commercial organization and conduct in the way it structures its licensing and sublicensing activities, and it is assumed that the same structure is used in relation to other subsidiaries carrying on similar activities in countries where treaties providing similar or more favourable benefits are in force, the arrangement between SCO, RCO and TCO does not constitute a conduit arrangement.
— Example F: TCO is a publicly traded company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S. TCO is the parent company of an international group of companies, including RCO, a company resident in State R, and SCO, a company resident in State S. SCO carries on an active business in State S. RCO is responsible for coordinating the financing of all TCO subsidiaries. RCO operates a centralized cash management system for TCO and its subsidiaries, which records all intercompany accounts payable and receivable. RCO is responsible for making or receiving any cash payments required to carry out transactions between its subsidiaries and unrelated parties. RCO enters into interest rate and currency contracts as necessary to manage the risks arising from mismatches between incoming and outgoing cash flows. RCO's activities are intended to (and can reasonably be expected to) reduce operating, overhead and other fixed costs. RCO employs 50 people, including clerical and other office staff, located in State R; this number of employees reflects the scale of RCO's business activities. TCO lends RCO 15 million in Currency A (worth 10 million in Currency B) in exchange for a 10-year promissory note bearing interest at 5 per cent per annum. On the same day, RCO lends SCO 10 million in Currency B in exchange for a 10-year promissory note bearing interest at 5 per cent per annum. RCO does not enter into long-term hedging transactions in respect of these financial transactions, but manages the interest rate and currency risk arising from these transactions on a daily, weekly or quarterly basis by entering into forward currency contracts.
In this example, RCO appears to carry on genuine activities, performing substantial economic functions, using real assets and assuming real risks; it also carries on significant activities in relation to transactions with TCO and SCO, which appear to be typical of RCO's ordinary treasury activities. RCO also bears interest rate and currency risk. On the basis of these facts, and in the absence of other facts indicating that one of the principal purposes of these loans was to avoid withholding tax in State S, the loan from TCO to RCO and the loan from RCO to SCO do not constitute conduit arrangements.
40. In paragraphs 119 and 120 of the Commentary on Article 1, the Committee acknowledges the general importance of appropriate mechanisms for the administration and interpretation of tax treaties in minimizing the risks of tax abuse. These mechanisms are particularly important with respect to general anti-abuse rules, both in domestic law and in tax conventions. General anti-abuse rules inevitably contain an element of uncertainty, which may adversely affect legitimate cross-border trade and investment. Countries may wish to consider ways of reducing uncertainty for taxpayers through various means, such as applying the Article only after approval by senior officials of the tax administration, as discussed in paragraph 182 above, an advance ruling procedure, or the provision by the tax authority of guidance to taxpayers on how it intends to apply paragraph 9 of the Article. Similarly, as noted in paragraph 120 of the Commentary on Article 1, a strong and independent judicial system will help provide taxpayers with confidence in the objective application of this Article. Likewise, the effective application of the mutual agreement procedure will ensure that disputes concerning the application of paragraph 9 of the Article are resolved in accordance with internationally recognized principles, so as to preserve the integrity of tax treaties.
Commentary on Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
Articles 30 and 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE AND TERMINATION
Articles 30 and 31 of the United Nations Model Convention reproduce Articles 30 and 31 of the OECD Model Convention. Accordingly, the Commentaries on the latter Articles remain applicable:
1. These provisions concerning the procedure for entry into force, ratification and termination are drafted for bilateral conventions and correspond to the rules normally contained in international treaties.
2. Some Contracting States may require an additional provision in the first paragraph of Article 30 specifying which authorities must give their consent to ratification. Other Contracting States may agree that this Article should contain an indication that entry into force occurs after an exchange of notes confirming that each State has completed the procedures necessary for such entry into force.
3. The Contracting States themselves may decide that the Convention shall enter into force after a specified period following the exchange of instruments of ratification or following confirmation that each State has completed the procedures necessary for such entry into force.
4. No provisions have been drafted concerning the date of entry into force or termination of the Convention, since such provisions depend largely on the domestic law of the States concerned. Some States assess tax on income derived in the current year, others on income derived in the preceding year, while in others the fiscal year differs from the calendar year. In addition, some conventions provide, in respect of taxes levied by withholding at source, for an application or termination date that differs from the date applicable to taxes levied by assessment.
5. Since it would be desirable for the Convention to remain in force for at least a certain period, the Article on termination may provide that notice of termination may only be given after a mutually agreed year has been established. The Contracting States are free to specify the earliest year in which notice of termination may be given, or even to agree not to specify such a year.
Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages