Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Report / CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS, INCLUDING QUESTIONS OF THE INDEPENDENCE OF JUDGES, THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE AND IMPUNITY Report of the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers, Mr. Leandro Despouy. Commission on Human Rights, 7 January 2005.

CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS, INCLUDING QUESTIONS OF THE INDEPENDENCE OF JUDGES, THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE AND IMPUNITY Report of the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers, Mr. Leandro Despouy. Commission on Human Rights, 7 January 2005.

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS, INCLUDING QUESTIONS OF THE INDEPENDENCE OF JUDGES, THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE AND IMPUNITY

 Report of the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers, Mr. Leandro Despouy. Commission on Human Rights, 7 January 2005.

Addendum

MISSION TO KAZAKHSTAN*

Summary

At the kind invitation of the Government of Kazakhstan, the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers visited the country from 11 to 17 June 2004. He held substantive discussions with government officials and met freely with a wide range of individuals who provided him with detailed background information and analyses of the state of the judicial system. He expresses his deep appreciation to all his interlocutors.

Owing to the United Nations restrictions on the length of documentation, the presentation of facts has been kept to a minimum. Nevertheless, the report attempts to outline the overall picture of institutional and legal changes affecting the judicial system since 1991. It draws attention to such important measures as the establishment, in December 2003, of a moratorium on the execution of death sentences, which give reason to hope that the situation is moving in the right direction. However, it also demonstrates that the judicial system remains highly dependent, both institutionally and in practice, on the executive branch and influential business circles. Clearly, the principal bottleneck is the role of the prosecutor, since the prosecutor may participate in the consideration of both criminal and civil cases; plays a decisive role in decisions concerning detention; may appeal against a court decision even where proceedings have been terminated; and has the authority to suspend the enforcement of a court judgment for up to two months. No progress can be made in ensuring judicial independence until fundamental changes are introduced to redistribute the powers and competences of the prosecutor, the judge and the defence counsel. At the same time, in addition to the need for further reforms, the main unresolved problems appear to stem from an entrenched "culture" influencing the functioning of the judicial system and are related to the need to develop a new culture that ensures the independence, efficiency and fairness of the courts.

Judicial corruption remains a major cause for concern, and the priority task is to eradicate it immediately and decisively. Another essential task concerns improving the level of legal education and training in order to enhance the professionalism of judges and lawyers. In this regard, support from the international community is needed to improve the work of the Judicial Academy and organize training in international human rights law and international principles of judicial proceedings.

Despite the critical observations contained in the report, it reflects the Special Rapporteur's conviction that favourable conditions exist in Kazakhstan for the rapid implementation of positive institutional changes, primarily aimed at eliminating the remaining obstacles to ensuring the independence of judges.

Indeed, the dialogue held with the authorities demonstrates their understanding of the problems facing them and their willingness to actively seek solutions. In view of these positive conditions, the recommendations contained in this report are intended to lay the groundwork for future dialogue. The Special Rapporteur hopes that, notwithstanding their limitations due to the length of this report, they will meet the expectations and serve as support for all those striving to establish an independent judicial system that deserves the trust and respect of the people.

  • The summary of the report is being circulated in all official languages. The report itself is contained in the annex to this document and is circulated in English and Russian only.

 

Annex

REPORT SUBMITTED BY THE SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON THE INDEPENDENCE OF JUDGES AND LAWYERS, MR. LEANDRO DESPOUY, FOLLOWING HIS MISSION TO KAZAKHSTAN (11–17 JUNE 2004)

CONTENTS

 Paragraphs
Introduction1–4
I. MAIN FACTS5–67
A. General political and legal conditions5–7
B. Judicial system8–9
C. Other relevant institutions10–15
D. Major recent reforms and changes affecting the judicial system16–26
E. Proportion of women and representatives of ethnic minorities in the judiciary27–28
F. Equal access to courts29
G. Judges30–39
H. Prosecutor's Office40–47
I. Legal profession48
J. Conduct of judicial proceedings49–54
K. Working conditions of judges55–59
L. Transparency and accountability60–66
M. Judicial system and political opposition67
II. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS68–90
A. Conclusions68–71
B. Recommendations72–90

Introduction

1. In accordance with his mandate, the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers visited Kazakhstan from 11 to 17 June 2004 at the kind invitation of the Government of that country.

2. The visit was prompted by repeated allegations that, despite the considerable efforts made by the Government and the reforms it had carried out since 1991, judges continued to be dependent on political pressure and administrative directives, were vulnerable to corruption, and that further reforms were necessary to ensure an adequate level of training and professionalism among judges, as well as their independence, fairness and transparency in the functioning of the judiciary. These allegations warranted cross-checking through a country visit in order to assess the situation and discuss ways of improving it.

3. The Special Rapporteur met with the Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Minister of Justice, the Minister of the Interior and the Deputy Minister of Education. He held extensive consultations with a wide range of judges and other officials: the President of the Supreme Court, the President of the Constitutional Council, the Deputy Prosecutor-General, the National Ombudsman, the Chairperson of the National Commission on Family Affairs, the Chairperson of the National Commission on Human Rights, the President of the Judicial Academy, the Deputy President of the Almaty City Court, the President of the Union of Judges of Kazakhstan, the President of the Almaty City Bar Association, the President of the Union of Lawyers, the Rector of the Kazakhstan University of Humanities and Law, and a number of judges and lawyers working in regional and district courts.

He met with representatives of various local non-governmental organizations (NGOs), in particular the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law, the Almaty Helsinki Foundation, the organizations "Legal Initiative", "Street Law – Kazakhstan", the Centre for Legal Assistance to Ethnic Minorities and the organization "Women in the Legal System".

He visited the local offices of the following United Nations bodies: the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the United Nations Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) and the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF).

He met with representatives of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and the European Union (EU). He also met with representatives of various international organizations and national cooperation agencies: the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), the American Bar Association and the Central and East European Law Initiative (ABA/CEELI), which submitted its 2004 report entitled "The State of Judicial Reform in Kazakhstan", the Prison Reform International (PRI), the Soros Foundation and Transparency International.

4. The Special Rapporteur is extremely grateful to the Government of Kazakhstan for providing him with a unique opportunity, with its assistance, to become acquainted with the current state of the judicial system and the latest changes affecting it. He is grateful to the Government for its comprehensive cooperation and for providing an opportunity to engage in a very frank and open dialogue, which demonstrated the Government's understanding of current problems and its willingness to address them. He was able to meet with everyone he wished to meet, without restrictions or obstacles of any kind, including NGOs carrying out exceptionally valuable work.

He expresses his deep appreciation to each person with whom he met for the information and analysis provided concerning current trends and future reform needs. He hopes that his recommendations will meet the main expectations and serve as support for all those working in the Government, the judicial system and civil society who strive to establish an independent, efficient and transparent judicial system, and that they will also provide a basis for fruitful dialogue and positive results in the future.

I. MAIN FACTS

A. General political and legal conditions

5. Kazakhstan gained independence in 1991 after 70 years as part of the former Soviet Union and is seeking to develop institutions that meet international standards of good governance. Since independence, the country has been led by President Nursultan A. Nazarbayev (re-elected in 1999 for a further term ending in 2006), who initiated the adoption of a new Constitution in 1995, replacing the first post-Soviet Constitution of 1993 and providing for a system of government with a strong presidential authority. Article 3, paragraph 3, of the Constitution contains the following guarantee: "No one shall have the right to appropriate power in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Appropriation of power shall be prosecuted under the law."

6. Section VII of the Constitution is devoted to matters relating to the courts and the administration of justice, and the principal law regulating the judicial system is Constitutional Law No. 132 of 25 December 2000, "On the Judicial System and Status of Judges of the Republic of Kazakhstan" ("the Law on the Judicial System"). Judicial proceedings are governed by the Criminal Code of 1997, the Criminal Procedure Code of 1997 and the Penal Enforcement Code of 1998.

7. Kazakhstan is a party to the following human rights treaties: the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women. In December 2003, Kazakhstan signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, but has not yet ratified them. In this connection, it should be noted that article 4, paragraph 3, of the Constitution provides: "International treaties ratified by the Republic shall have priority over its laws and shall be directly applicable, except where it follows from an international treaty that its application requires the promulgation of a law."

B. Judicial system

8. Kazakhstan is divided into 14 regions (administrative regions), each headed by an akim (governor) appointed by the President of the Republic. The cities of Almaty and Astana have the same status as a region. Each region is divided into districts. Thus, the country has three levels of jurisdiction:

(i) In accordance with article 81 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court "is the highest judicial body for civil, criminal and other cases within the jurisdiction of courts of general jurisdiction, exercises, in the procedural forms established by law, supervisory authority over their activities and provides explanations on matters of judicial practice".

Pursuant to article 82, the President, chairpersons of chambers and judges of the Supreme Court "shall be elected by the Senate upon the recommendation of the President of the Republic, based on the recommendation of the Supreme Judicial Council of the Republic".

The 48 members of the Court sit in panels consisting of between three and nine judges, depending on the nature of the case, and may also sit in plenary session to adopt advisory opinions for lower courts. The Court comprises three chambers dealing respectively with civil cases, criminal cases and supervisory matters (see website www.supcourt.kz);

(ii) The 16 regional courts (one in each of the 14 regions and, in addition, in Almaty and Astana), employing a total of 572 judges, may act as appellate courts and also as courts of first instance in cases involving serious criminal offences, such as murder.

In accordance with article 82, paragraph 2, of the Constitution, "the chairpersons of regional and equivalent courts, chairpersons of chambers and judges of regional and equivalent courts shall be appointed by the President of the Republic upon the recommendation of the Supreme Judicial Council of the Republic";

(iii) The 260 district courts, employing a total of 1,851 judges, function as courts of first instance.

In accordance with article 82, paragraph 3, of the Constitution, the chairpersons and judges of these courts "shall be appointed by the President of the Republic upon the recommendation of the Minister of Justice, based on the recommendation of the Qualification Collegium of Justice".

District courts do not officially have separate divisions, although a practice has developed whereby most judges specialize either in criminal or in civil cases. Cases are heard by a single judge or by a panel of three judges.

9. In addition, 16 economic courts equivalent to district courts have been established (one for each region, including Almaty and Astana), which deal with commercial disputes. Military courts also operate at regional and district levels and hear cases relating to the armed forces and military personnel. Finally, Kazakhstan is seeking to establish a number of specialized courts:

(i) Administrative courts have been established in Almaty and Astana on an experimental basis to hear cases relating to administrative offences;

(ii) A specialized juvenile justice system has been established in Almaty and Almaty Region, which is to be extended subsequently throughout the country. For the time being, certain judges of district and regional courts specialize in hearing cases involving juveniles.

C. Other relevant institutions

10. Constitutional Council. This quasi-judicial institution was established under article 71 of the Constitution as the successor to the Constitutional Court envisaged by the 1993 Constitution. Its organization and activities are governed by a Constitutional Law. Its seven members are appointed for a term of six years, with their mandates being renewed every three years: the Chairperson is appointed by the President of the Republic and has a casting vote; two members of the Council are appointed by the President, two by the Chairperson of the Senate and two by the Chairperson of the Mazhilis (the lower house of Parliament).

During their term of office, members of the Council may not be arrested, brought by force, subjected to administrative penalties imposed by a court, or prosecuted for criminal offences without the consent of Parliament, except in cases of arrest at the scene of a crime or the commission of "serious crimes".

The functions of the Council are set out in article 72 of the Constitution. The concerns expressed to the Special Rapporteur during his discussions were as follows:

(i) The Council does not have jurisdiction to examine the constitutionality of presidential decrees; and

(ii) Under article 73, paragraph 4, of the Constitution, the President of the Republic has the right to reject decisions of the Council. Although the Constitution provides that the President's objections may be overridden by a two-thirds majority of the Council's members, in practice, given that three of the seven Council members are appointed by the President, the power to reject decisions constitutes a powerful instrument of influence over the Council.

11. Supreme Judicial Council. Article 82, paragraph 4, of the Constitution provides that this institution "shall be chaired by the President of the Republic and shall consist of the President of the Constitutional Council, the President of the Supreme Court, the Prosecutor-General, the Minister of Justice, members of the Senate, judges and other persons appointed by the President of the Republic".

Its status, procedure for formation and organization of work are determined by law and, according to the information received by the Special Rapporteur, are largely dependent on the President of the Republic, to whom it submits quarterly recommendations concerning the appointment of chairpersons of regional and equivalent courts, chairpersons of chambers and judges of regional and equivalent courts.

Allegations were made concerning a lack of transparency and corruption, including instances of monetary payments for obtaining judicial positions.

12. Qualification Collegium of Justice. The Collegium was established pursuant to article 82, paragraph 4, of the Constitution, which provides that it is an "autonomous and independent institution formed from members of the Mazhilis, judges, prosecutors, law professors and legal scholars, and employees of the justice authorities". Its status, formation procedure and organization of work are determined by law.

Apparently, its recommendations are generally supported by the Minister of Justice and the President of the Republic. According to allegations, there are no clear criteria or transparency in the Collegium's decision-making process, instances of corruption exist, and there is a shortage of support staff to assist its fourteen members.

13. Judicial Academy. The Academy was established in 2001 and enjoys government support. Its budget is financed from the national budget. It provides professional training for future judges and continuing professional development for serving judges; in 2003, approximately 400 judges attended one-month refresher courses.

High expectations were associated with its establishment, and efforts are currently being made to obtain international support and assistance.

At present, training focuses primarily on existing judicial practice, while new legislation and problems, as well as relevant international human rights standards and principles relating to the work of judges, are still insufficiently taken into account or not taken into account at all.

14. Human Rights Commission under the President. Established in 1994 as an advisory body directly accountable to the President of the Republic.

Its status and terms of reference are defined in a number of presidential decrees, the latest of which, dated 20 March 2004, expanded its membership to include additional representatives of NGOs, universities and the legal profession, allowing them to participate in its work alongside representatives of the Government, Parliament and the judiciary.

It advises the President on:

(i) The development of policies, State programmes and concepts in the field of human rights;

(ii) Institutional frameworks and legislation concerning the protection of human rights;

(iii) Accession to human rights treaties and participation in international cooperation;

(iv) Human rights mechanisms and procedures and the improvement of law enforcement practice; and

(v) The development of human rights education.

It examines complaints and prepares recommendations for ensuring the protection of violated rights (more than 700 complaints were considered in 2003).

According to reports, it enjoys the respect of all actors in the judicial system, international and national organizations and, most importantly, broad sections of the public, since complaints submitted to it generally receive attention and are investigated, and complainants receive a response.

Unfortunately, however, no statistical data are available that could help assess the Commission's workload and the effectiveness of its activities. Nevertheless, it is regarded as a mechanism capable of influencing the courts so that they address human rights issues.

15. National Ombudsman. This institution was established in 2002 pursuant to a Presidential Decree.

According to the information received, during the first two years of its activities the Ombudsman received more than 1,200 complaints, 27 per cent of which reportedly concerned shortcomings in the functioning of the courts and corruption, 5.5 per cent concerned non-enforcement of court decisions, and 3 per cent concerned unjustified delays in judicial proceedings.

This may be explained by the fact that the public has an incorrect understanding of the Ombudsman as a mechanism for hearing appeals.

There appears to be overlap and duplication in the powers granted respectively to the Human Rights Commission under the President and the Ombudsman, primarily in the area of monitoring compliance with human rights.

According to reports, the Ombudsman usually forwards complaints to the prosecutor or the relevant court without properly informing the individual complainants concerned.

D. Major recent reforms and changes affecting the judicial system

16. Since 1991, President Nazarbayev has carried out major reforms, primarily in the economic sphere. Recognizing that economic and institutional changes are interrelated, the following may be identified as the most important reforms and changes relating to the judicial system:

17. Legal reforms. Constitutional Law No. 132, "On the Judicial System and Status of Judges of the Republic of Kazakhstan" (hereinafter, "the Law on the Judicial System"), was adopted on 25 December 2000; the Criminal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code were reformed in 1997, and amendments were made to the Penal Enforcement Code in 1998.

In 2002, Parliament adopted Law No. 363 amending the Criminal Procedure Code with a view to further strengthening the protection of human rights both at the preliminary investigation stage and during judicial proceedings.

Articles 68 and 69 of the Code currently provide for the right to have a telephone message transmitted immediately, the right to a private meeting with defence counsel, the right to choose defence counsel, the right to lodge a complaint, the right to the assistance of an interpreter, the right to know the substance of the charges, the right to remain silent, the right to receive a copy of the court judgment, and so forth.

18. Protection of human rights. The organization "Street Law" has published a brochure in Russian and Kazakh entitled "Information about Your Rights", which sets out in detail the fundamental rights of every citizen.

The International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law has also published a brochure entitled "Citizens' Rights in Court".

It would be desirable to ensure wide distribution of both brochures, including in schools and universities.

19. Pre-trial detention. Kazakhstan previously had one of the highest rates of pre-trial detention in the world, but this rate has declined as a result of reforms to the Criminal Procedure Code.

This positive trend is partly attributable to the fact that, in 2004, responsibility for pre-trial detention facilities was transferred from the Ministry of the Interior to the Ministry of Justice.

Nevertheless, the number of persons held in pre-trial detention remains excessively high and, at the time of the visit, stood at between 6,000 and 8,000 persons, or approximately 15 per cent of the total prison population.

20. Moratorium on the execution of death sentences. In December 2003, the Senate proposed the introduction of a moratorium on the execution of death sentences.

In January 2004, a Presidential Decree extended the duration of the moratorium, and amendments were made to the Criminal Code to replace the death penalty with life imprisonment.

Together with all human rights organizations, the Special Rapporteur welcomes this decision, particularly in view of the fact that 40 people were executed in 1999, 22 in 2000 and 15 in 2001.

Since the introduction of the moratorium, only one death sentence has been imposed, and it was commuted by the Supreme Court to life imprisonment.

21. Criminalization of violence against women and girls and trafficking in women. Kazakhstan is a party to CEDAW, and UNIFEM is actively working jointly with the National Commission on Family Affairs to adopt gender-neutral legislation establishing the principles of gender equality.

In May 2003, Parliament adopted amendments to the Criminal Code providing for specific penalties for trafficking in persons, particularly women.

The Minister of the Interior initiated a Special National Programme to combat violence against women through district-level police authorities.

At the time of the visit, the Ministry had submitted a draft law on domestic violence to Parliament.

Apparently, this problem had never been taken seriously by the police authorities and the judicial system, and local human rights institutions and organizations expressed their hope that legislative change would serve as a stimulus for positive developments.

22. Prison sentences. In 2000, Kazakhstan ranked third in the world in terms of the number of prisoners.

The country has now moved to nineteenth place in terms of the number of prisoners as a result of a number of reforms, which included:

(i) The transfer of the prison system, including persons held in pre-trial detention, from the Ministry of the Interior to the Ministry of Justice, thereby improving accountability and increasing the efficiency of management;

(ii) The decriminalization of a number of offences and the introduction of probation, community service and other alternative forms of punishment.

23. Proposal to introduce trial by jury. Article 75, paragraph 2, of the Constitution provides that "in cases stipulated by law, criminal proceedings shall be conducted with the participation of jurors".

In September 2002, Presidential Decree No. 949, "On the Concept of Legal Policy", endorsed the future participation of jurors in judicial proceedings.

The draft law proposes the participation of jurors in the trial of certain "serious" crimes at the regional court level and provides for the possibility of extending this practice to other offences at a later stage.

The French system (jury trial) is regarded as the most interesting example to follow.

24. Legal education and raising awareness of ethical standards.

During the Soviet era, there were only two legal educational institutions, with approximately 350 students.

In 2003, approximately 150 educational institutions were registered, with nearly 65,000 students enrolled and 16,000 law school graduates.

Nevertheless, the quality of legal education is adversely affected by a shortage of qualified teaching staff and excessive theoretical emphasis in education. Furthermore, some lecturers are alleged to accept bribes from individuals seeking admission in excess of the established quotas.

The curricula of law schools need to be updated to reflect legal reforms; in addition, there is a need for continuing legal education, since many judges, prosecutors and lawyers are not fully informed about the latest legal reforms affecting their day-to-day activities.

Under these circumstances, the Ministry of Education has introduced an exchange programme with foreign law schools and adopted additional measures for the certification of second-year students to ensure that their knowledge meets minimum standards before they proceed to their final year of study.

Finally, although the Ministry of Education has approved the inclusion of certain aspects of human rights law in the curricula of law schools, apparently no specific human rights law course is currently offered, either as an elective or as a compulsory subject.

The same situation exists with regard to international humanitarian law and international refugee law.

International principles relating to lawyers and judges and the treatment of prisoners are also widely disregarded, as are the provisions of the Code of Judicial Ethics developed by the Union of Judges.

The Ministry of Education has acknowledged this situation and plans to implement reforms aimed at raising standards in legal education and professional ethics.

25. Legal aid. The Union of Lawyers, a voluntary organization of lawyers, provides free consultations and receives nominal financial remuneration from the Government.

Eight legal clinics operate within law faculties and provide free legal consultations to low-income citizens; this also enables students to gain practical experience.

The Soros Foundation, ABA/CEELI and USAID are currently financing legal aid projects.

26. Administrative and financial support for the judicial system. The Supreme Court independently manages its budget.

As regards lower-level courts, as a result of a number of reforms, certain administrative functions and financial support provided to the judicial system have been transferred from the Ministry of Justice to the Judicial Administration Committee of the Supreme Court.

According to reports, this measure has expanded the capabilities of the courts and enabled them to manage their budgets more effectively (which amounted to 0.91 per cent of the national budget in 2003) and determine expenditure items.

All these measures have resulted in an increase in the salaries of Supreme Court judges, housing allowances (although some judges would prefer to own private housing and receive higher salaries), and the opportunity to purchase office equipment and renovate court buildings.

E. Proportion of women and representatives of ethnic minorities in the judiciary

27. According to official statistics, in 2002 women accounted for 16.7 per cent of graduates of higher educational institutions who had obtained a legal education, compared with 13.1 per cent for men.

Women are adequately represented in the judiciary, with the exception of the higher courts.

In 2002, the proportion of women judges was distributed as follows:

  • Supreme Court — 34%;
  • Regional courts — 52%;
  • District courts — 49%.

Women accounted for 50 per cent of the positions of chairpersons of regional courts and 11 per cent of the positions of chairpersons of district courts.

28. The total population of Kazakhstan is 17 million and includes 56 per cent ethnic Kazakhs and a large number of ethnic groups, of which 32 per cent are ethnic Slavs (Russians, Ukrainians and Belarusians).

There is no open ethnic conflict between the various ethnic groups, although some individuals expressed concern about the potential danger associated with fairly widespread perceptions that ethnic Kazakhs enjoy economic and political advantages over citizens of other ethnic backgrounds.

Furthermore, only Kazakh and Russian are official languages of the country.

According to reports, Russians and other minorities are underrepresented in the judiciary, although the situation is satisfactory in certain courts and in certain regions of the country.

No statistical data were received in this regard.

F. Equal access to courts

29. In principle, equal access is guaranteed by law.

Nevertheless, no statistical data were provided concerning the actual accessibility of courts for such groups as persons with disabilities, minorities, women and children.

G. Judges

30. As in other countries of the former Soviet Union, the judicial system has historically been closely linked to the State and regarded as an institution responsible for implementing State interests.

As a rule, judges were viewed with suspicion, which led to the adoption of the "Law on the Judicial System" in 2000 (see paragraph 17 above).

31. Qualifications and professional training. During the Soviet era, judges were "elected": candidates were nominated by the Communist Party, and only party members participated in the voting.

Under the current system, in order to hold judicial office, article 79, paragraph 3, of the Constitution requires a person to be a citizen of the Republic, have reached the age of 25, possess a higher legal education, have at least two years of professional experience in the legal field and pass a qualification examination.

Article 29, paragraph 1, of the Law on the Judicial System provides that a candidate for appointment as a district court judge must undergo an internship at a court and receive a positive assessment from the plenary session of the regional court.

Article 29, paragraph 2, provides that a candidate for appointment as a regional court judge or a Supreme Court judge must have at least five years of professional experience in the legal field, including at least two years as a judge.

Since 2001, the Judicial Academy has conducted refresher courses for serving judges, and in September 2004 the first group of future judges began studying for a master's degree.

Such training should become compulsory for future judges, while serving judges should be required to attend two- to three-week training courses every three to five years.

The Union of Judges, a national association representing virtually all judges, also works to improve the qualifications of serving judges. Individual courts organize one-week or one-month training courses at which new laws, decisions and resolutions of the Supreme Court are discussed and judicial errors or cases involving the reversal of judicial decisions are examined.

32. Appointment and tenure. The President of the Republic exercises decisive influence over the appointment process (see paragraph 8 above).

Every five years, judges must be reappointed by the President.

According to reports, the reappointment process may be associated with abuse, coercion and self-censorship, since continued tenure may depend on how judges decide cases, as explained below in paragraph 34.

33. Promotion. The principal legal criteria are ability, integrity and experience.

Nevertheless, according to reports, this process is far from complying with the principles of transparency, fairness and objectivity.

34. Termination of office and disciplinary measures. While the appointment and termination of the powers of Supreme Court judges fall within the competence of Parliament, regional and district court judges are subject to disciplinary proceedings and possible disciplinary measures, as well as reappointment by the President of the Republic every five years.

The relevant provisions of the Law on the Judicial System are vague; combined with the powers of the President, they may lead to abuse in terms of dismissing or punishing judges, particularly those who adopt a politically independent position.

Judges feel vulnerable in their positions when they deliver acquittals that create the possibility for individuals to bring financial claims against the State, or when their judgments are overturned following an appeal.

Thus, judges who have delivered a large number of judgments contrary to the interests of the State may be required to prove that they have not accepted bribes and may be subjected to disciplinary measures or not reappointed by the President.

This problem, which may explain the small proportion of acquittals in Kazakhstan, accounting for approximately 1 per cent (see paragraph 53 below), was identified by judges and lawyers, as well as various organizations, particularly ABA/CEELI, as a serious defect in the legal system; it was even acknowledged by certain government officials.

35. Judicial ethics. Professional training in this area falls far short of international standards, particularly the Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct (E/CN.4/2003/65, annex).

In order to help raise low domestic standards, the Union of Judges has developed a Code of Judicial Ethics.

This initiative deserves high praise; nevertheless, its impact remains limited because, according to reports, many judges ignore the Code or act as though they are unaware of the document.

36. Judicial immunity. Judicial immunity is protected by law, but may be lifted by the President of the Republic.

37. Remuneration of judges. Pursuant to article 47, paragraph 2, of the Law on the Judicial System, the President of the Republic determines the salaries of judges but is not entitled to reduce their official salaries.

In 2002, salaries were increased, and judges are currently considered to be the highest-paid public officials.

Judges of regional and district courts complained that there was still a considerable difference in remuneration between judges at different levels and that, despite the increase in salaries, there were difficulties in attracting and retaining judges in rural courts.

As a result, the minimum requirements for the appointment of judges remain quite low, particularly in rural areas, which has a direct impact on the quality of the administration of justice.

38. Protection against threats and harassment. As a rule, judges have no complaints concerning their personal safety.

However, court buildings are poorly guarded or not guarded at all.

39. Creation of new judicial posts. The President of the Republic has exclusive powers to create new judicial posts upon the recommendation of the Judicial Administration Committee of the Supreme Court.

Since 2001, 600 judicial posts have been created, including 300 in 2003 alone.

The Committee is seeking the creation of additional judicial posts, since it is well known that the average annual caseload of most judges is twice the reasonable quota for the number of cases to be heard.

H. Prosecutor's Office

40. In accordance with the Law on the Prosecutor's Office, the Prosecutor's Office carries out its activities independently of other State bodies and officials and is accountable only to the President of the Republic.

Article 83, paragraph 1, of the Constitution provides that "the Prosecutor's Office, on behalf of the State, exercises supreme supervision over the precise and uniform application of laws, decrees of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan and other regulatory legal acts throughout the territory of the Republic, over the legality of operational-search activities, inquiries and investigations, administrative and enforcement proceedings, takes measures to identify and eliminate any violations of the law, and also challenges laws and other legal acts that contradict the Constitution and laws of the Republic. The Prosecutor's Office represents the interests of the State in court and, in cases, in the manner and within the limits established by law, conducts criminal prosecution."

41. De facto and de jure, virtually no reforms have been carried out in the Prosecutor's Office since Soviet times, and it continues to retain a strong position and influence, particularly in rural areas.

42. Powers relating to arrest, detention, searches and seizure. Article 16, paragraph 2, of the Constitution and article 150, paragraph 1, of the Criminal Procedure Code provide that authorization for arrest and detention must be issued by courts or prosecutors.

In practice, the issuance of such authorizations falls within the exclusive competence of the Prosecutor's Office.

The period of detention by the police may be up to 72 hours.

Under article 153 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the initial period of pre-trial detention may not exceed two months, except in exceptional cases.

Where such exceptional circumstances exist, the period of pre-trial detention may be extended by the district prosecutor and equivalent prosecutors to three months, and subsequently to six months.

In the latter case, the Deputy Prosecutor-General may extend the period of detention to nine months.

Finally, the Prosecutor-General may extend the period of pre-trial detention to 12 months.

The accused may appeal this decision to a court, but, according to reports, this rarely occurs in practice.

43. Duration of detention. Although the period of detention of up to 72 hours may be extended by a decision of the Prosecutor's Office, courts have very limited opportunities to take action in response to complaints and appeals lodged by detainees.

The Constitutional Council reported 3,788 cases of unlawful detention in 2002 and stated that 19 out of 63 law enforcement officers had been convicted in 41 criminal cases.

44. Judicial proceedings. In civil cases, the Prosecutor's Office has the right to intervene at any stage of judicial proceedings, even in cases where the State has no specific and legitimate interest in the matter.

According to reports, such intervention occurs with some regularity, particularly where economic interests are involved.

It forms part of the regrettable struggle over powers between judges and prosecutors and, according to allegations, in certain cases this circumstance encourages individuals with political or financial influence to approach the Prosecutor's Office (possibly offering a bribe) to request intervention and an appeal against a decision contrary to their interests.

Conversely, certain categories of criminal offences are considered without the participation of the Prosecutor's Office, and criminal prosecution in respect of them may be initiated only upon the applications of private individuals.

These include not only minor offences but also serious crimes such as rape and domestic violence, the prosecution of which should in fact be regarded as a duty of the State.

45. Right of appeal. There are disparities between the right of the Prosecutor's Office and the right of a convicted person to appeal to a higher court.

The Prosecutor's Office has an automatic right to appeal to a higher court, whereas the accused must first be granted permission to appeal.

46. Temporary suspension of the enforcement of court decisions. Although amendments were made in 2002 to article 466 of the Criminal Procedure Code and article 396 of the Civil Procedure Code, the Prosecutor-General and the President of the Supreme Court retained the right to suspend the enforcement of a sentence, court decision or judicial act for up to two months in both criminal and civil cases.

47. The above facts reflect the dominant role played by the prosecutor throughout the judicial process: the prosecutor may participate in the consideration of both criminal and civil cases; plays a decisive role at the pre-trial detention stage; unlike defence counsel, may appeal against a court decision even when the case has already been closed; and even has the right to suspend the enforcement of a court decision or judgment for up to two months.

All this confirms that the prosecutor exercises decisive influence over the outcome of judicial proceedings.

I. Legal profession

48. Under the Soviet system, defence counsel did not play a significant role in judicial proceedings.

As a result, the country did not develop a historical tradition of effective defence.

Despite important reforms, the legal profession remains the weakest and most passive component of the judicial system.

Many defence lawyers have acquired a reputation for lacking adequate legal training, knowledge or sufficient awareness of the latest changes in legislation and jurisprudence, as well as international human rights law and principles of judicial proceedings, and consequently for lacking the necessary preparation and qualifications to represent their clients.

Furthermore, lawyers have very limited rights to collect evidence, which reduces their ability to compete with the prosecutor on an equal footing and influence the judicial process.

There are 16 local bar associations in Kazakhstan: one for each region and one each for the cities of Almaty and Astana, which operate quite independently; according to reports, they do not exert significant influence within their respective areas or over other major actors in the judicial system.

They have adopted their own codes of professional ethics, but, according to allegations, defence lawyers are divided into two categories: "red lawyers", who actively defend the rights of their clients, and "black lawyers", who prepare documents confirming that they have met with their clients and advised them of their rights, but in fact provide no consultations and, moreover, actually assist investigators or prosecutors in establishing the guilt of their clients, often receiving bribes in return.

Clearly, information about such a division within the ranks of defence lawyers themselves has a seriously negative impact on the legal profession and on public confidence in it.

J. Conduct of judicial proceedings

49. Presumption of innocence. Article 77, paragraph 3, of the Constitution provides for the presumption of innocence and states that the accused is not required to prove his or her innocence.

In practice, compliance with this principle is seriously undermined by the conduct of judicial proceedings and the excessive powers of the prosecutor in relation to the detention of suspects.

50. Preliminary investigation and detention. In accordance with article 84 of the Constitution, inquiries and preliminary investigations in criminal cases are conducted by special bodies and are separate from the courts and the Prosecutor's Office.

At the same time, as explained above in paragraph 42, the prosecutor has decisive influence over the duration of pre-trial detention.

51. Access to a lawyer and exercise of the rights of the defence. Article 16, paragraph 3, of the Constitution guarantees due process and the right of every citizen to defence.

However, according to reports, many accused persons are unaware of this right.

Furthermore, it appears that in practice defence lawyers often fail to insist on their right to represent their clients and meet with them in private, and even fail to lodge complaints when access to their clients is denied.

As a result, the rights of accused persons are frequently not respected, despite the clear provisions contained in the Criminal Procedure Code.

In addition, there is no official system of public defenders.

The functions of providing publicly funded defence to accused persons are either assigned to a selected group of lawyers who receive very modest remuneration (US$2 per hour) and whose professional experience as lawyers may vary considerably, or to several NGOs, particularly the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law and the organization "Women in the Legal System", which provide legal services in individual cases.

52. Confessions and allegations of torture. Kazakhstan has ratified the Convention against Torture, and article 17 of the Constitution and article 116 of the Criminal Procedure Code prohibit the consideration of evidence obtained under duress.

Nevertheless, according to reports, torture remains widespread.

The Government openly acknowledged that there had been cases in which the police conducted superficial investigations, destroyed evidence, intimidated victims and witnesses, either inducing them to refuse to testify or forcing them to withdraw statements they had already made.

According to the information received, police activities are currently based on an instruction requiring a high rate of "solved crimes".

Investigators frequently resort to unjustified and even unlawful "pressure" against persons held in custody in order to induce them to make confessions and thereby achieve successful performance indicators.

The Minister of the Interior demonstrated exceptional determination in seeking to correct this situation and approached UNDP with a request to develop a programme for training police officers in human rights.

It would be advisable to use a similar programme for judges, since some of them have allegedly been reluctant to apply the new anti-torture legislation.

Apparently, such a response is the result of a lack of awareness of the new laws and, at the same time, the persistence of a mindset inherited from the Soviet era, when judges considered their role to be the fight against crime on behalf of the State rather than the protection of individual rights.

According to reports, this practice has resulted in judges quite frequently refusing to take into account oral testimony or physical evidence that may indicate that the accused has been subjected to torture or inhuman treatment by law enforcement officers.

Under these circumstances, it becomes understandable why, despite the legal right of the accused or his or her lawyer to lodge complaints on such grounds, they do not exercise this right in practice because they are too afraid of the possible consequences.

53. Proportion of acquittals, rehabilitation and compensation in cases of acquittal. Of the 62,602 cases considered by the courts in 2003, acquittals were delivered in only 73 cases.

Taking into account the fact that many of these cases involved several accused persons, the estimated proportion of acquittals does not exceed 1 per cent.

As already mentioned in paragraph 34 above, this may be explained, among other things, by the strong influence exerted on judges and their fear of losing their jobs.

The Special Rapporteur was also informed that an acquittal is regarded as an indirect admission of shortcomings in the work of the police, particularly procedural violations, and that judges may fear a possible reaction from the police and the Prosecutor's Office.

He was also informed of the absence of measures for the rehabilitation of persons acquitted after being charged with criminal offences and of Kazakhstan's poor practice concerning the payment of compensation for damage resulting from unlawful charges or unlawful detention.

A study conducted by the Supreme Court shows that, in the case of 17 acquittals delivered between January 2002 and September 2003, only three accused persons received compensation and one accused person received an apology, although none of them received a copy of the judgment or information on how to obtain compensation.

Of the 104 persons who applied for compensation in civil proceedings, the applications of only 76 persons were granted in full or in part.

54. Consideration of appeals. Kazakh legislation provides for judicial review of appeals against court decisions.

At the same time, as already noted, prosecutors may submit special appeals in cases that have already been closed, whereas defence counsel do not enjoy this right.

Furthermore, the prosecutor may suspend the enforcement of court decisions pending a decision on the aforementioned appeals.

In practice, the proportion of judgments that are reversed or modified remains low: in 2003, 0.7 per cent of criminal decisions at district court level were reversed and 3.7 per cent were modified; in civil cases, 1.2 per cent of decisions were reversed and 0.9 per cent were modified.

K. Working conditions of judges

55. Human and material resources. The Judicial Administration Committee of the Supreme Court has made efforts to provide each judge with a separate office, a secretary and a computer, in addition to the recent increase in judges' salaries.

Overall, there are no complaints in this regard.

56. Courtrooms. Kazakhstan has allocated significant financial resources to ensure a sufficient number of courtrooms and create relatively favourable working conditions.

Nevertheless, a number of judges and lawyers noted that, given the number of cases being heard, there is still a shortage of courtrooms.

As a result, judicial proceedings are conducted in the judge's office rather than in a courtroom, which obviously prevents relatives and friends of the accused and members of the public, including journalists, from following the proceedings.

Furthermore, many courtrooms are still equipped with cages in which defendants in criminal cases are held, which is contrary to the principle of the presumption of innocence.

57. Security. As a rule, courts are very poorly equipped in terms of security because of a shortage of guards and metal detectors, as well as support staff and court enforcement officers necessary to maintain order in courtrooms and enforce court decisions.

In addition, most judges' offices can be entered without undergoing any security checks.

58. Availability of current legislation. The Judicial Administration Committee of the Supreme Court distributes copies of laws to all courts and seeks to ensure their availability in both paper and electronic formats.

Many courts have already been connected to the "Zakon" legal database, which will soon be accessible from all computer systems installed in the courts.

The work in this direction deserves the highest praise.

Nevertheless, some interlocutors expressed dissatisfaction with the fact that, in practice, this system is not yet functioning optimally.

59. Method of case allocation. A computerized system for the random allocation of cases based on a number of criteria, particularly taking into account the workload of judges, has been introduced.

It has replaced the practice under which the court chairperson determined the procedure for allocating cases or even personally allocated them.

However, the court chairperson apparently retains the authority to allocate and withdraw cases in relation to specific judges, which may in practice give rise to serious abuses.

L. Transparency and accountability

60. Archiving and retrieval of cases. Although the Judicial Administration Committee of the Supreme Court is currently making efforts to introduce a computerized system, most courts continue to use a manual system, which is generally considered adequate in view of the workload.

Nevertheless, as the workload increases (by 28.7 per cent between 2002 and 2003), the use of computers may soon become necessary, including a system for identifying unjustified cases, which, fortunately, do not constitute a major problem in Kazakhstan.

61. Access to court records and the texts of sentences and court decisions. According to reports, the publication and dissemination of Supreme Court rulings have not become routine practice.

Only certain individual court decisions are made available to the public (mainly through the Court's website), and their publication may involve considerable delays.

Some decisions of regional courts are available, but there is no opportunity to consult decisions of district and other lower-level courts.

Concern is also caused by the fact that draft decisions generally do not contain specific references to the factual circumstances and relevant legal provisions and place emphasis on the prosecutor's arguments to the detriment of the defence arguments.

According to allegations, court hearing records fully reflect the prosecutor's submissions but omit the testimony of defence witnesses and the questions, objections and arguments put forward by defence counsel.

62. Access to judicial statistics. Responsibility for maintaining judicial statistical data in Kazakhstan is officially assigned to the Prosecutor-General's Office.

Such statistical data are not always freely accessible or available.

Furthermore, according to allegations, most judges are reluctant to provide statistical data relating to the cases they hear.

All this obviously constitutes a serious gap in the judicial system.

63. Public and media access to judicial proceedings and participation of trial observers. Although public and media access to judicial proceedings is adequately protected by law, according to the information received, these guarantees are not always respected in practice, particularly in criminal cases.

According to reports, relatives of the parties to judicial proceedings or members of the public are frequently questioned about the reasons for their wish to attend a trial.

At the same time, courts of first instance appear to demonstrate a greater degree of openness than higher courts.

Participation in judicial proceedings as an "independent official observer" requires special authorization.

ABA/CEELI reported difficulties encountered in this regard and the reluctance of certain judges to establish a dialogue with its representatives.

The Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law published a report in 2004 entitled "Compliance with Citizens' Procedural Rights in District Courts of Astana", based on a study conducted by 24 qualified trial observers who attended more than 900 court hearings.

The report identifies various procedural violations of the principles of a fair trial, which are primarily caused by the fact that the prosecutor and defence lawyers do not have equal status.

Positive developments include recent decisions of the Supreme Court requiring judges to facilitate access to courtrooms and the participation of relatives and the media in judicial proceedings.

This should help ensure greater transparency and accountability of the courts and, consequently, increase public confidence in the judicial system.

64. Public access to records of court hearings. Such access is not guaranteed by law, as a result of which nothing prevents the chairperson of a court from refusing a third party access to records of court hearings.

65. Code of Judicial Ethics. According to reports, most judges are unaware of the Code developed by their Union, and virtually no training in judicial ethics is provided.

Nevertheless, under an instruction adopted by the Supreme Court in October 2002, chairpersons of regional courts are required to exclude ex parte communications and direct testimony given by individuals and representatives of legal organizations.

66. Corruption and bribery. Under the Criminal Code, the giving and receiving of bribes constitute criminal offences.

Furthermore, as a measure to combat corruption, the Government has established economic administrative courts.

The Ministries of Justice and the Interior have increased the salaries of judges and police officers, respectively, in order to combat bribery, the most intolerable form of corruption.

However, lawyers in particular insisted that the Soviet practice known as "telephone justice" had not yet been eradicated.

All interlocutors acknowledged that judges at all levels of the judicial system had an extremely negative reputation among the public, which generally regarded the system as an area plagued by corruption.

During meetings with judges, it was acknowledged that each year only a few bribery cases resulted in a judge being removed from office, while in most cases they simply "fall apart" due to a lack of evidence.

However, according to OSCE statistics, approximately 50 per cent of complaints received during the first half of 2004 concerned corruption within the police or judicial authorities.

Many interlocutors insisted that corruption and bribery in fact affected the Government, the police, the judicial system, the Prosecutor's Office and the legal profession, including educational institutions providing legal education at all levels.

M. Judicial system and political opposition

67. Article 20 of the Constitution guarantees everyone the right to freedom of expression.

However, according to reports, freedom of expression is closely controlled by the Government.

The Special Rapporteur continues to monitor a number of court cases involving members of the political opposition, journalists and other activists.

This reflects potential abuses by judges in relation to the control of political opposition or dissenters and undermines the principle of the rule of law.

II. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

A. Conclusions

68. In less than a decade, Kazakhstan has gained sovereignty and undergone profound transformations, moving from an authoritarian system to a more democratic institutional system and from a centrally planned economy to a market economy.

At the same time, Kazakh society, comprising approximately one hundred different ethnic groups, has also undergone profound changes, and any observer can notice the clash between old and new customs and conditions.

At present, the transition processes in this country, with a population of approximately 17 million (the largest in Eurasia and one of the countries richest in natural resources such as uranium, oil and gas), must be analysed against the background of the profound transformations taking place throughout the region under the influence of the entire range of factors associated with major economic and geopolitical interests, as well as in the light of the numerous risks existing in the region.

69. Although the reforms carried out in recent years have primarily focused on the economy, they have also brought about fundamental changes in the institutional sphere.

The Special Rapporteur welcomes the qualitative breakthrough achieved through the courage and determination of the Government.

There is no doubt that, since 1991, important steps have been taken in the judicial sphere, enabling Kazakhstan to move away from a system in which the administration of justice was largely dependent on political priorities, administrative instructions and even personal connections, towards a more solid foundation based on legal norms.

Nevertheless, it cannot be overlooked that, directly or indirectly, the executive branch continues to play an almost equally dominant role in the judicial system as it did under the previous regime, albeit in a different political context and on a different institutional basis.

This trend has even intensified with the establishment of a strong presidential system following the adoption of the new Constitution in 1995.

70. Nothing reflects the situation in the functioning of the judicial system more clearly than the persistence of the dominant role of the prosecutor throughout the judicial process, at precisely the time when the entire system should be brought into a high degree of compliance with fundamental international principles.

Under the previous regime, the judicial system and judicial personnel operated within a hierarchical system of subordination and under the close control of Communist Party authorities.

Today, their activities are placed within an institutional framework based on the principle of the separation of powers, but the role of the prosecutor, as in former times, remains dominant.

There can be no doubt that this situation constitutes the main obstacle to democratic development and gives rise to the principal violations that continue to characterize the judicial system as a whole.

It would be extremely regrettable if, as a result of these circumstances, the important reforms carried out to improve the functioning of the judicial system ultimately led only to functional improvements without simultaneously increasing its independence from structures closely associated with those in power.

In this regard, one worrying symptom is the extremely low number of acquittals, amounting to approximately one per cent.

Apparently, this situation is attributable less to the strictness of the law than to the difficulties faced by defence lawyers and the very manner in which the judicial system operates, since judicial judgments continue to depend to a considerable extent on the arguments put forward by prosecutors.

At the same time, this situation is also related to insufficient knowledge and weak application of international human rights principles, or the complete absence of references to them.

Some interlocutors explained this circumstance by the passivity of civil society, which tends to adhere to the mindset of the past.

71. Going beyond the analysis set out above, the Special Rapporteur is convinced that Kazakhstan is a country capable, at the institutional level, of implementing rapid and positive changes, particularly in the judicial system, by removing the obstacles to the independence of judges and lawyers.

Guided by this consideration, the Special Rapporteur submits the following recommendations.

B. Recommendations

72. Judicial and structural reforms: The existence of a professional and independent judicial system is not a privilege of judges but a fundamental right of society.

Accordingly, in order for Kazakhstan to be regarded as a genuinely democratic State, it is of paramount importance to restructure the legal system, which may even include constitutional reforms, making it possible to ensure a fairer distribution of powers among the branches of government and, above all, to strengthen the independence of the judiciary.

Drawing on the example of other presidential systems, the Special Rapporteur considers that this can be achieved without changing the nature of presidential power within the political system.

In this regard, the following issues are of fundamental importance:

(i) The process of appointing judges at all levels of the judicial system, their tenure, removal from office and salaries must not remain practically within the exclusive competence of the President of the Republic;

(ii) The powers of the prosecutor, which are clearly excessively broad and constitute the principal bottleneck in ensuring the independence of the judiciary;

(iii) The composition and functioning of the Supreme Judicial Council, which is under the exclusive control of the President of the Republic;

(iv) The weakness of the Constitutional Council, which is unable to serve as a counterbalance to the influence of the President of the Republic because it does not have the right to examine presidential decrees and its decisions may be rejected by the President.

73. Ratification of international human rights instruments and related legal measures. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the measures taken by Kazakhstan since 1991 to accede to a number of international human rights instruments, particularly the signing of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.

He strongly recommends that the authorities ensure their immediate ratification without any reservations, as well as accession to the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

He recommends that amendments be made to national legislation, where necessary, in order to bring it into conformity with international standards.

Taking into account Kazakhstan's exceptionally important and highly commendable initiative to abolish the death penalty, he strongly recommends that the authorities consider taking similar measures with regard to the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, aiming at the abolition of the death penalty.

Furthermore, he strongly recommends that they consider taking similar steps with regard to the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture.

He strongly recommends that the Supreme Court take the lead in the field of human rights by including references to the above-mentioned instruments in its decisions, as permitted under article 4, paragraph 3, of the Constitution, and calls upon all judges to apply international human rights standards.

74. Legal education and training in law and human rights. Urgent measures should be taken, together with the allocation of the necessary funding, to improve the standard of legal education and introduce continuing legal education and professional training in order to enhance the professionalism of prosecutors, judges and lawyers and ensure the application of new laws and amendments to existing laws.

In this regard, the Special Rapporteur welcomes the establishment of the Judicial Academy and strongly recommends that the international community provide support to this institution.

It is indispensable for improving the efficiency of the judicial system and ensuring its compliance with national and international standards and principles.

To this end, separate compulsory courses in international human rights law, international humanitarian law and international refugee law should be included in the curricula of national legal educational institutions.

Programmes of compulsory continuing professional training in these three areas of public international law should also be developed for serving judges, prosecutors and lawyers, who should deepen their knowledge of the various international principles relating to the judicial system.

These measures should be combined with human rights training for law enforcement officers, as well as public awareness campaigns aimed at developing a collective human rights culture consistent with the constitutional principles and objectives of the country.

75. Freedom of expression. All lawyers, judges and prosecutors require special training on freedom of expression in order to deepen their knowledge of the scope and application of this right by the press, political opponents and NGOs.

76. Torture and ill-treatment. All judicial personnel must, in every case:

(i) Conduct prompt and impartial investigations into all allegations of torture;

(ii) Properly investigate any failure to prosecute alleged perpetrators in accordance with the requirements of articles 12 and 13 of the Convention against Torture;

(iii) Exercise their powers to exclude statements obtained under duress or through torture from consideration as evidence.

In this regard, appropriate professional training must also be provided to law enforcement officers.

77. Availability of legal reference materials, national statistical data and collections of judicial decisions. Current efforts to promptly provide court libraries and legal libraries with recently adopted legal instruments and to disseminate them in electronic format should be continued.

This activity should also be combined with measures to disseminate all relevant international legal instruments, principles, and national and international publications on legal matters.

Special efforts should be made to improve the quality of compilations and ensure the availability of reliable and regularly updated statistical data and collections of judicial decisions.

Furthermore, it would be advisable for judicial statistical data to be disseminated directly by the State statistical agency or the Ministry of Justice rather than by the Prosecutor-General's Office, as is currently the case.

78. Gender awareness. While welcoming the reforms undertaken to raise awareness of gender issues and promote women's rights in Kazakhstan, which appears to be a country that could serve as a model for many other countries in the region, the Special Rapporteur believes that further progress may be achieved in the future through close cooperation between UNIFEM, the National Commission on Family and Women and the relevant NGOs.

All court personnel should receive substantial training in gender issues, and in this regard the UNIFEM initiative to distribute a judicial training manual on issues relating to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women should be welcomed and encouraged.

It is highly desirable to improve the gender composition at the higher levels of the judicial system, particularly at the level of the Supreme Court.

79. Prosecutor. Kazakhstan needs to amend article 16, paragraph 2, of the Constitution and make fundamental amendments to the Criminal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code in order to reduce the prosecutor's dominant powers throughout the judicial process and ensure, both in legislation and in practice, a fairer balance between the functions of the prosecutor, defence counsel and judge.

In particular, the powers to authorize arrests, searches and seizures should be transferred from the prosecutor to the judge.

80. Judges. Further amendments should be made to the Law on the Status of Judges in order to improve the professional level of judges not only through education and continuing professional training provided by the Judicial Academy but also by creating stable conditions for their professional activities as such and ensuring guarantees of tenure and stability of their position.

All this should result in judges no longer fearing for their positions when, guided by principles, they acquit a suspect instead of complying with the prosecutor's demand for a sentence, or when their judgments are overturned on appeal.

The issue of disciplinary sanctions against judges should be immediately separated from the issue of their delivery of judicial judgments or decisions in cases on appeal.

Furthermore, efforts should be made to ensure that any acts of corruption result in appropriate punishment under the law.

Finally, the salaries of judges should be reviewed further in order to ensure greater balance between courts at different levels and encourage interest in filling judicial positions in rural areas.

81. Defence. Defence lawyers should be granted the right to full access to evidence in order to prepare their case for trial already at the pre-trial stage of proceedings.

Their role during judicial proceedings should be enhanced so that they can effectively compete with the prosecutor.

Another advisable reform would be the establishment of a national system of public defenders.

The Special Rapporteur refers to principle 3 of the Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers, according to which "Governments shall ensure the provision of sufficient funding and other resources for legal services to the poor and, as necessary, to other disadvantaged persons. Professional associations of lawyers shall cooperate in the organization and provision of services, facilities and other resources."

Finally, local bar associations should be granted the status of professional self-governing bodies: at present, they are not permitted to carry out licensing, accreditation or disciplinary supervision.

82. Pre-trial detention. Although the Government has made substantial progress in this area, additional measures are necessary to ensure that pre-trial detention becomes the exception rather than the rule.

The Criminal Procedure Code needs to be reformed in order to reduce the period of prolonged pre-trial detention, which is currently determined by the Prosecutor's Office, and ensure that decisions on the duration of prolonged pre-trial detention are taken by judicial authorities.

83. Death penalty. Transforming the current moratorium into the abolition of the death penalty would constitute a highly positive development in line with the existing global trend.

It would be particularly positive to combine such a measure with ratification of the Optional Protocol aimed at abolishing the death penalty.

84. Criminalization of exploitation and violence against women. Measures should be adopted to criminalize all forms of exploitation and violence against women, including domestic violence, which should be regarded as a matter of public interest.

Work on the draft law to combat domestic violence should be continued with full determination, and its wording should be formulated in such a way that the Prosecutor's Office and the judicial authorities regard such acts as serious offences, so that complainants are no longer forced to seek decisions on their cases through private prosecution.

The preliminary investigation stage is of decisive importance for ensuring the effective application of this future law.

85. Jury trial. Current efforts to establish a jury trial system should be continued in order to strengthen the independence of decision-making and encourage the involvement of civil society in the administration of justice, thereby ensuring public confidence.

86. Ethical standards, transparency and accountability. In order to ensure public confidence in the judicial system, decisive and immediate measures should be taken to develop an effective and enforceable code of professional ethics and strengthen accountability.

The prevention of corruption and punishment for corrupt practices and bribery at all levels of the judicial system and within the legal education system are clearly matters of the highest priority.

The preparation and implementation of anti-corruption initiatives, possibly with the assistance of the international community, should focus on eradicating the root causes of the traditional practices in courts that encourage corruption and on applying appropriate penalties.

87. Access to courts. The Government should do everything possible to guarantee access to courts for everyone, particularly in rural areas.

It should organize public awareness campaigns aimed at increasing public awareness and confidence, particularly among organizations representing the interests of children, women, minorities and persons with disabilities, that the legal system ensures the rule of law, can restore violated rights and provides remedies.

88. Public access to records of court hearings. Such access should be ensured by law in the future.

89. Juvenile justice. The Government should immediately begin implementing its plan for legal reforms aimed at establishing a separate juvenile justice system while continuing its joint work with UNICEF on the development of a national Code on the Rights of the Child.

The Ministry of Justice should continue reforming the system of penalties so that juveniles are given alternative forms of punishment that make it possible to avoid imprisonment in cases involving minor offences and do not make imprisonment mandatory in cases involving more serious offences.

This will make it possible to minimize the number of children drawn into the criminal justice system.

90. National Ombudsman. The mandates of the Human Rights Commission under the President and the Ombudsman should be defined more clearly.

It would be desirable for this work to be carried out by law rather than on the basis of presidential decrees.

Reform of the Ombudsman institution should aim to ensure compliance with the Paris Principles.

Public information and awareness-raising concerning the role of the Ombudsman should be improved, and the Ombudsman, in turn, should respond more promptly to any complaints submitted by an accused person or his or her lawyer and seek to ensure thorough and immediate investigations and, where necessary, the punishment of those responsible for violations.

 

 

Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages