Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Codes / Commentary to article 80. Non-compliance with the order, standards and poor quality of medical care The Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences

Commentary to article 80. Non-compliance with the order, standards and poor quality of medical care The Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

Commentary to article 80. Non-compliance with the order, standards and poor quality of medical care  The Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences  

     1. Excluded by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 28, 2018 No. 208-VI.

     2. Excluded by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 28, 2018 No. 208-VI.

     3. Failure to comply with the procedure and standards of medical care, failure to perform or improper performance of professional duties by a medical professional due to negligent or unfair treatment of them, if this caused minor harm to health., –  

     They impose a fine on individuals in the amount of twenty, on officials in the amount of forty, on small businesses and non–profit organizations in the amount of fifty, on medium–sized businesses in the amount of seventy–five, on large businesses in the amount of one hundred monthly calculation indices.

     4. The acts provided for in the third part of this article, committed repeatedly within a year after the imposition of an administrative penalty, –  

     They impose a fine on individuals in the amount of forty, on officials in the amount of eighty, on small businesses and non-profit organizations in the amount of one hundred, on medium–sized businesses in the amount of one hundred and fifty, on large businesses in the amount of two hundred monthly calculation indices.

     Part 3. One of the most important tasks of any civilized state is to take care of the health of its citizens, since the health of the population is an integral indicator of social guarantees that characterizes the degree of responsibility of the state towards its citizens. Human life and health are the most important social values, and therefore, issues of the quality of medical care, as well as the responsibility of doctors for improper performance of their professional duties, are closely linked to the problem of protecting the health and life of citizens.

     The generic object of an administrative offense provided for in Article 80 of the Administrative Code is public relations arising in connection with the exercise by citizens of the right to health protection provided for in Article 29 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

     The direct object of an administrative offense is the established procedure, standards of medical care within the framework of the free volume of guaranteed medical care, as well as the provision of paid medical services.

     An additional object is human health. The principles of the preamble to the charter of the World Health Organization state that "it is a state of complete physical, spiritual and social well-being, and not only the absence of diseases or physical defects.".  

     Thus, human health is a certain physiological (somatic and mental) state of the body in which all its components function normally. This condition presupposes the preservation of the anatomical integrity of organs and tissues, their physiological functions, and the absence of diseases and pathological conditions.

     According to the Code "On the Health of the People and the Healthcare System" dated September 18, 2009, the Rules for citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan, oralmans, as well as foreigners and stateless persons permanently residing in the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan, to receive a guaranteed amount of free medical care (Order of the Minister of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 13, 2015 No. 344), "guaranteed the volume of free medical care (hereinafter referred to as GOBMP) – the volume of medical care provided at the expense of budgetary funds according to the list determined by the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan to citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan, oralmans, as well as foreigners and stateless persons permanently residing in the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

     The guaranteed amount of free medical care includes:

     1) Ambulance and air ambulance;

     2) outpatient polyclinic care for socially significant diseases, diseases that pose a danger to others, including:

     1. Primary health care;

     2. consultative and diagnostic assistance in the direction of a primary health care specialist and specialized specialists;

     3) inpatient care for socially significant diseases, diseases that pose a danger to others:

     1. in the direction of a primary health care specialist or a medical organization within the planned number of cases of hospitalization by the authorized body;

     2. for emergency indications – regardless of whether there is a referral from a primary health care specialist or a medical organization.;

     4) inpatient replacement care for socially significant diseases, diseases that pose a danger to others in the direction of a primary health care specialist or a medical organization;

     5) preventive vaccinations.

     Paid medical services are provided by public and private medical organizations, individuals engaged in private medical practice, in accordance with the disease profile and license to engage in medical activities.

     The objective side of the offense is the actions, inactions of a medical professional, expressed in:

     - failure to comply with the procedure and standards of medical care,  

     - failure to fulfill professional duties by a medical professional  

     - improper performance of professional duties by a medical professional.

     When determining the objective side of the composition of an administrative offense under the commented article, it is necessary to take into account the regulatory requirements of a large number of regulatory legal acts. These include the orders of the Minister of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan:

     - No. 450 dated July 3, 2017 "On approval of the Rules of emergency medical care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 452 dated August 2, 2013 "On approval of the Standard of organization of oncological care to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 529 dated September 16, 2013 "On approval of the Standard for the organization of transfusion care to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 657 dated November 14, 2013 "On approval of the Standard of organization of palliative care for the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";  

     - No. 759 dated December 27, 2013 "On approval of the Standard of organization of medical rehabilitation for the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";  

     - No. 765 dated December 30, 2013 "On approval of the Standard of organization of nephrological care to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 95 dated February 8, 2016 "On approval of the Standard for the organization of medical and social assistance in the field of mental health to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";  

     - No. 269 dated May 20, 2014 "On approval of the Standard of organization of nursing care to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 514 dated June 25, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of traumatological and orthopedic care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 666 dated August 14, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of urological and andrological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 761 dated September 29, 2015 "On approval of the rules for inpatient care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 809 dated October 19, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of neurological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 821 dated October 23, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of dermatovenerological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";  

     - No. 822 dated October 23, 2015 "On approval of the Standard for the organization of geriatric and gerontological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 993 dated December 23, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of pulmonological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 1023 dated December 25, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of ophthalmological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 1032 dated December 28, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of medical care for occupational pathology in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 1034 dated December 28, 2015 "On approval of the Standard of organization of neurosurgical care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 85 dated February 3, 2016 "On approval of the Standard of organization of primary health care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 126 dated February 18, 2016 "On approval of the Standard of organization of rheumatology care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 478 dated June 6, 2016 "On approval of the Standard of organization of endocrinological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";  

     - No. 77 dated February 2, 2017 "On approval of the Standard for the organization of TB care in the Republic of Kazakhstan";

     - No. 173 dated April 16, 2018 "On approval of the Standard of organization of obstetric and gynecological care in the Republic of Kazakhstan", etc.

     According to paragraph 70 of Article 1 of the Code, "medical care is a complex of medical services, including medical care, aimed at preserving and restoring public health, as well as alleviating severe manifestations of incurable diseases."

     Medical services are actions of healthcare entities that have a preventive, diagnostic, curative, rehabilitative or palliative orientation towards a specific person (paragraph 71 of Article 1 of the Code).

     Medical services are provided in accordance with the standard of public health services, which is a regulatory legal act that establishes requirements for the provision of public health services, as well as including the characteristics of the process, form, content and outcome of the provision of public health services (paragraphs 37-4 of art. 1 of the Code).

     The procedure for providing medical care is an official regulatory document that sets out a set of organizational measures aimed at ensuring timely provision of adequate quality and full medical care to citizens.

Thus, non-compliance with the procedure and standards of medical care is an action or inaction of a medical professional that violates the established procedure and standards of medical care in terms of the organization, process, form, and content of public health services.  

     The procedures and standards for the organization of medical care in the Republic of Kazakhstan are established by the authorized body in the field of healthcare, which is the central executive body.

     Failure to fulfill professional duties by a medical professional includes failure to provide emergency medical care to citizens if it is necessary to provide it outside a medical organization.  

     Improper performance of professional duties by a medical professional includes:

     - failure to provide medical care in accordance with their official duties;

     -delivery of medicines without a prescription;  

     - delivery of substitute medicines with low effectiveness of medicinal properties, etc.  

     - delivery of expired medicines.

     A prerequisite for bringing a medical professional to administrative responsibility under Article 80 of the Administrative Code is the infliction of minor harm to health as a result of one of the listed actions.

     In the case of moderate harm, serious harm or death to a patient, grounds for bringing him to criminal responsibility under the relevant articles of the Special Part of the Criminal Code arise in relation to a medical professional.  

     According to P. 383 of the Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated April 27, 2017 No. 484 "On approval of the Rules for the organization and conduct of forensic examinations and research in forensic examination bodies", harm to health is understood as a violation of the anatomical integrity of organs (tissues) or their physiological functions (bodily injuries), or diseases or pathological conditions resulting from exposure to various environmental factors: mechanical, physical, chemical, biological, psychogenic, as well as the consequences resulting from defects in medical care, leading to a health disorder or death.

     Minor harm to health refers to harm to human health that has resulted in a short-term health disorder (for a period of no more than twenty-one days) or a minor permanent loss of general ability to work (less than one tenth) (paragraph 13 of art. 3 of the Criminal Code).

     The degree of damage caused to health is established by appointment of a forensic medical examination.

     The subjects of the offense in question may be individuals, officials, small business entities, non-profit organizations, medium-sized and large businesses that provide medical services and meet the qualification requirements for medical activities.  

     As a rule, legal entities are subject to administrative liability in cases of non-compliance of their base with material and technical standards, as a result of which violations, lack of proper control over the provision of medical care, etc. are committed.

     The subjective side of the offense under consideration is characterized by an intentional form of guilt. In relation to the fact of non-fulfillment or improper fulfillment of professional duties by medical and pharmaceutical workers due to negligent or unfair treatment of them, as well as non-compliance with the procedure or standards of medical care (standards of medical care to the population of the Republic of Kazakhstan are approved by the authorized body in the field of healthcare), guilt can be expressed in the form of both direct and indirect intent, and in relation to the consequences of wine, it is characterized by carelessness. Such an act is considered to have been committed intentionally.  

     In accordance with Part 2 of Article 700 of the Administrative Code, cases of administrative offenses under Article 80 (part three) may be considered and administrative penalties imposed by the head of the state body for control in the provision of medical services, his deputies, heads of territorial divisions and their deputies.

     Part 4 of the commented article defines as a qualifying feature the commission of a similar offense repeatedly within a year after the imposition of an administrative penalty under the third part of art. 80 of the Administrative Code.  

     In accordance with Part 1 of Article 684 of the Administrative Code, cases of administrative offenses under Part 4 of Article 80 of the Administrative Code are considered by judges of specialized district and equivalent administrative courts.

Scientific and practical commentary to the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offences (article-by-article) from the Author's team:

     Bachurin Sergey Nikolaevich, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor – chapter 48 (co-authored with E.M. Khakimov);

     Gabdualiev Mereke Trekovich, Candidate of Law – Chapters 11, 21, 22, 23;

     Zhusipbekova Ainur Maratovna, M.yu.n. – chapter 13 (co-authored with Karpekin A.V.); chapters 33, 39 (co-authored with Seitzhanov O.T.);  

     Alexander Vladimirovich Karpekin, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor – chapter 13 (in collaboration with A.M. Zhusipbekova);

     Korneychuk Sergey Vasilyevich – chapters 2; chapter 6 (co-authored with O.T. Seitzhanov, E.M. Khakimov); chapter 8; chapter 25 (co-authored with E.M. Khakimov); articles 457-470, 488, 488-1, 491-506; chapters 28, 30, 52;

     Ilya Petrovich Koryakin, Doctor of Law, Professor – Chapter 49;

     Kisykova Gulnara Bauyrzhanovna, Candidate of Law – chapter 20;

     Omarova Botagoz Akimgereevna, Candidate of Law – chapters 17; chapter 18 (co-authored with B.A. Parmankulova); chapters 26, 31; chapter 32 (co-authored with B.A. Parmankulova);

     Parmankulova Bayan Askhanbaevna – chapter 18 (co-authored with Omarova B.A.); chapters 19, 32 (co-authored with Omarova B.A.); chapter 43 (co-authored with Tukiev A.S.);  

     Podoprigora Roman Anatolyevich, Doctor of Law, Professor - Chapter 24, articles 489, 489-1, 490;

     Porokhov Evgeny Viktorovich, Doctor of Law – Chapters 14, 15, 16, 29, articles 471-475;

     Seitzhanov Olzhas Temirzhanovich, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor, – chapter 4; chapter 5 (co-authored with E. M. Khakimov); chapter 6 (co-authored with S.V. Korneychuk, E.M. Khakimov); chapter 9; chapter 10 (co-authored with B.E. Shaimerdenov, V.V. Filin); chapter 33 (co-authored with Zhusipbekova A.M.); chapter 36 (co-authored with Shaimerdenov B.E.); chapter 39 (co-authored with Zhusipbekova A.M.);

     Smyshlyaev Alexander Sergeevich, PhD. – chapters 38, 40, 42, 43-1 (co-authored with A.S. Tukiev); chapter 44;

     Aslan Sultanovich Tukiev - Candidate of Law, Associate Professor – chapters 1, 3, 35; chapters 38, 40, 42, (co-authored with A.S. Smyshlyaev); chapter 43 (co-authored with B.A. Parmankulova); chapter 43-1 (co-authored with A.S. Smyshlyaev); chapter 44-1 (co-authored with Shipp D.A.); chapter 45; 46 (co-authored with Shipp D.A.); chapter 47;  

     Filin Vladimir Vladimirovich, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor – Chapter 10 (in collaboration with O.T. Seitzhanov, B.E. Shaimerdenov);  

     Yerzhan Maratovich Khakimov, M.yu.n. – chapter 5 (co-authored with O.T. Seitzhanov); chapter 6 (co-authored with O.T. Seitzhanov, S.V. Korneychuk); chapter 7; chapter 25 (co-authored with S.V. Korneychuk); chapters 34, 41; chapter 48 (co-authored with S.N. Bachurin); chapter 53;

     Shaimerdenov Bolat Yerkenovich, M.yu.n., – chapter 10 (co-authored with O.T. Seitzhanov, V.V. Filin); chapter 12; articles 476-487, 507-509; chapter 36 (co-authored with O.T. Seitzhanov); chapters 37, 50, 51.  

     Shipp Denis Alekseevich – chapters 44-1, 46 (in collaboration with A.S. Tukiev).

Date of amendment of the act:  01.01.2020 Date of adoption of the act:  01.01.2020 Place of acceptance:  100050000000 Authority that adopted the act: 103001000000 Region of operation:  100000000000 NPA registration number assigned by the regulatory body:  5 Status of the act:  new Sphere of legal relations:  029000000000 / 028000000000 / 029002000000 / 028004000000 / 029001000000 / 026000000000 / 001000000000 / 001008000000 / 030000000000 The form of the act:  COMM / CODE Legal force:  1900 Language of the Act:  rus  

 

 

 

 

Attention!   

       Law and Law Law Law draws your attention to the fact that this document is basic and does not always meet the requirements of a particular situation. Our lawyers are ready to assist you in legal advice, drawing up any legal document suitable for your situation.  

 For more information,  please contact a Lawyer / Attorney by phone: +7 (708) 971-78-58; +7 (700) 978 5755, +7 (700) 978 5085. 

 

Attorney at Law Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Advice Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Protection Arbitration Law Firm Kazakhstan Law Office  Court Cases