Consequences of the Appearance of a Person Declared Deceased

📘 1. General Description of the Article

Article 32 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan regulates the restoration of the rights of a person previously declared deceased in the event of their appearance or discovery as being alive. This provision is aimed at restoring justice, returning property, as well as protecting bona fide purchasers and maintaining a balance of interests among all participants in civil turnover.

📌 The situations governed by Article 32 are highly specific: they concern a so-called “resurrected citizen” who was legally considered deceased but later returned.

⚖️ 2. Conditions for Application of the Article

📌 The decision may be annulled at any time, regardless of the statute of limitations, which confirms the continuity of a person’s legal status.

🔁 3. Annulment of the Court Decision (Part 1)

“In the event of the appearance of the citizen … the relevant decision shall be annulled by the court.”

The procedure for annulment is regulated by Article 323 of the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan (CPC RK):

• The application may be filed by the “reappeared” citizen himself or by an interested person;
• The court considers the case according to rules similar to those applied in cases on declaring a person deceased;
• From the moment the decision enters into legal force, the following are annulled:
  • the legal consequences of declaring the person deceased;
  • guardianship (if it was established);
  • termination of marriage (if it was dissolved on this ground — see Article 17 of the Marriage and Family Code of the RK).

📦 4. Return of Property (Parts 2–6)

🔹 Part 2: Gratuitous Acquisition

“The citizen may demand the return of preserved property …”

If the property was transferred gratuitously (inheritance, gift, etc.), the citizen has the right to demand its return in kind, provided that the property has been preserved.

🔹 Part 3: Sale of Property by an Heir

“The right to claim the unpaid portion of the amount passes to the reappeared person …”

If the property was sold and the buyer has not fully paid its price, the right to receive the remaining unpaid portion of the price passes to the reappeared owner.

📌 This applies, for example, in cases of installment payments, credit purchases, or partial payment.

🔹 Part 4: Onerous Acquisition — Knowledge That the Person Is Alive

“They are obliged to return the property … if they knew …”

If the property was transferred under an onerous transaction (for example, a sale contract), the acquirer is obliged to:

• return the property if it remains in his possession; or
• compensate its value if:
  • the property was destroyed or alienated, and
  • it is proven that the acquirer knew that the citizen was alive.

🔹 Part 5: Liability of the Alienating Party

“The alienator who knew that the person was alive bears joint and several liability …”

If an heir or other legal successor sold the property while knowing that the citizen was alive:

• he bears joint and several liability together with the buyer;
• both are obliged to return the property or compensate its value.

📌 The purpose of this provision is to prevent abuse by heirs who may use the legal declaration of death for personal gain.

🔹 Part 6: Property Transferred to the State

“… the amount obtained from the sale of the property shall be returned …”

If the property passed to the state as escheat (inheritance in the absence of heirs) and was subsequently sold, the reappeared citizen is entitled to:

• the amount received from the sale of the property,
• taking into account the market value as of the date of payment.

📌 This allows inflation and price increases to be considered, ensuring real compensation.

📚 5. Related Legal Provisions

🧾 6. Examples from Judicial Practice

🔹 Example 1: East Kazakhstan, 2021

A citizen was declared deceased after disappearing during a hunting trip in 2015. In 2020, he returned alive. The heirs sold the house. The court satisfied the claim for recovery of the unpaid portion of the sale price.

🔹 Example 2: Almaty, 2023

A woman was declared deceased after a flood. Her apartment passed to the state and was later sold at auction. After her return in 2022, she was paid compensation based on the market value of the apartment at the time of restitution.

⚠️ 7. Issues of Interpretation and Disputes

🌍 8. International Approaches

✅ Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR, Article 8, Protocol No. 1):Recognizes the right to restoration of property and legal personality in cases of rehabilitation of legal status.

✅ UNIDROIT Principles on inheritance and bona fide purchasers:Recommend protecting the rights of the reappeared owner while also taking into account the balance of interests of third parties who acted in good faith.

✅ 9. Conclusion

Article 32 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan constitutes an important guarantee for the legal restoration of a person mistakenly declared deceased. It:

• ensures annulment of the court decision;
• restores property and personal rights;
• introduces a differentiated approach to the return of property depending on the nature of acquisition (onerous/gratuitous, bona fide/bad faith);
• regulates situations where property has been lost or transferred to the state.

🔹 This provision represents a balance between justice, stability of civil turnover, and protection of the individual.

Attention!   

       Law and Law Law Law draws your attention to the fact that this document is basic and does not always meet the requirements of a particular situation. Our lawyers are ready to assist you in legal advice, drawing up any legal document suitable for your situation.  

 For more information, please contact a Lawyer / Attorney by phone: +7 (708) 971-78-58; +7 (700) 978 5755, +7 (700) 978 5085. 

Attorney at Law Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Advice Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Protection Arbitration Law Firm Kazakhstan Law Office  Court Cases