Model Convention on Taxes on Income and Capital
The Convention of November 21, 2017
content
POSITIONS OF NON-OECD COUNTRIES ON THE MODEL CONVENTION (ON TAXATION) OECD (ON AVOIDANCE OF DOUBLE TAXATION)
APPENDIX RECOMMENDATION OF THE OECD COUNCIL ON THE MODEL TAX CONVENTION ON INCOME AND ON CAPITAL
introduction
1. International legal double taxation can generally be defined as the collection of comparable taxes in two (or more) States from the same taxpayer in respect of the same subject and for the same periods. Its detrimental effects on the exchange of goods and services and the movement of capital, technology and people are so well known that it is hardly worth emphasizing the importance of removing the obstacles that double taxation creates for the development of economic relations between countries.
2. It has long been recognized in the member countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development that it is desirable to clarify, standardize and confirm the financial situation of taxpayers engaged in commercial, industrial, financial or any other activity in other countries by applying common solutions to identical cases of double taxation by all countries. These countries have also long recognized the need to improve administrative cooperation in tax matters, in particular through the exchange of information and assistance in tax collection, in order to prevent and avoid tax evasion.
3. These are the main objectives of the OECD Model Convention on Income and Capital Taxes, which provides the means to address on a uniform basis the most common problems arising in the field of international legal double taxation. In accordance with the recommendations of the OECD Council,1 When concluding or revising bilateral conventions, OECD member countries should comply with this Model Convention as interpreted in the commentaries thereto and subject to the reservations contained therein, and their tax authorities should follow these comments that change from time to time and take into account the comments on them when applying and interpretation of the provisions of their bilateral tax conventions based on the Model Convention.
But. Historical background
4. Progress had already been made in eliminating double taxation through bilateral conventions or unilateral measures when, on February 25, 1955, the Council of the Organization for European Economic Cooperation (OEEC) adopted its first Recommendation on Double Taxation. At that time, 70 bilateral general conventions were signed between the countries that are now members of the OECD. This was largely due to the work begun in 1921 by the League of Nations. This work led to the drafting of the first Model Bilateral Convention in 1928, and finally to the Model Conventions of Mexico (1943) and London (1946), the principles of which, with some variations, were followed in many bilateral conventions concluded or revised over the next decade. However, none of these Model Conventions has been fully and unanimously adopted. Moreover, they contained significant discrepancies and certain gaps on a number of essential issues.
5. The growing economic interdependence and cooperation of the EAEU member States in the post-war period increasingly clearly demonstrate the importance of measures to prevent international double taxation. It was recognized that there was a need to expand the network of bilateral tax conventions to all the member countries of the OEEC, and then the OECD, some of which have so far concluded a very small number of conventions, and some have not concluded them at all. At the same time, the harmonization of these conventions in accordance with uniform principles, definitions, rules and methods, as well as the harmonization of a common interpretation, became increasingly desirable.
_________________________
1 cm.Application
6. It was against this new background that, in 1956, the Fiscal Committee began work on drafting a convention that would effectively address the double taxation problems existing between OECD member countries and that would be acceptable to all member countries. Between 1958 and 1961, the Fiscal Committee prepared four interim Reports before submitting a final Report in 1963, entitled Draft Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation of Income and Capital.1 On July 30, 1963, the OECD Council adopted a Recommendation on the Avoidance of Double Taxation and called on the Governments of the member countries to comply with this Draft Convention when concluding or revising bilateral agreements between them.
7. When submitting its Report in 1963, the OECD Fiscal Committee assumed that the Draft Convention could be revised at a later stage after further study. Such a review was also necessary to take into account the experience gained by member countries in the negotiation and practical application of bilateral conventions, changes in the tax systems of member countries, the strengthening of international financial relations and the development of new business sectors and the emergence of new complex business organizations at the international level. For all these reasons, the Fiscal Committee, and after 1971, its successor, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs, undertook a revision of the 1963 Draft Convention and its commentaries. This led to the publication of a new Model Convention and Commentaries in 1977.[2]
8. The factors that led to the revision of the 1963 draft Convention continued to exert their influence, and in many respects the pressure to update and adapt the Model Convention to changing economic conditions gradually increased. New technologies have been developed, and at the same time fundamental changes have taken place in the way cross-border transactions are carried out. Methods of tax evasion and avoidance have become more sophisticated. Globalization and economic liberalization in the OECD countries also accelerated rapidly in the 1980s. Thus, in the course of its regular work programme, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs and, in particular, its Working Group No. 1 after 1977 continued to study various issues directly or indirectly related to the 1977 Model Convention. This work resulted in a number of reports, some of which recommended amendments to the Model Convention and its Commentaries.3
9. In 1991, recognizing that the revision of the Model Convention and the Commentaries had become an ongoing process, the Committee on Budget and Finance adopted the concept of a non-permanent Model Convention, which provided for the possibility of periodic updates and amendments without waiting for a full revision. For this reason, it was decided to publish a revised and updated version of the Model Convention, which would take into account the work done since 1977 by including many of the recommendations made in the above-mentioned reports.
10.As the impact of the Model Convention has spread far beyond the OECD member countries, the Committee also decided that the revision process should be open to take advantage of contributions from non-member countries, other international organizations and other stakeholders. It was indicated that such external contributions would assist the Committee on Budget and Finance in its ongoing task of updating the Model Convention in line with the evolution of international tax rules and principles.
11. This led to the publication in 1992 of a Model Convention with inserts. As opposed to
___________________________
1 Draft Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation of Income and Capital, OECD, Paris, 1963.
2 Draft Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation of Income and Capital, OECD, Paris, 1977.
3 Some of these reports have been published and included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes
Of the 1963 Draft Convention and the 1977 Model Convention, the revised Model Convention was not the culmination of a comprehensive revision, but rather the first step of an ongoing revision process designed to be updated periodically and thus ensure that the Model Convention continues to accurately reflect the views of member countries at any given time.
11.1 In one of these updates, issued in 1997, the positions of a number of non-member countries of the Model Convention were added to the second volume in recognition of the growing influence of the Model Convention outside the OECD countries (see below). At the same time, copies of a number of previous reports of the Committee were added, which resulted in amendments to the Model Convention.
11.2 Since the publication of the first non-permanent version in 1992, the Model Convention has been updated 10 times (in 1994, 1995, 1997, 2000, 2002, 2005, 2008, 2010, 2014 and 2017). The latest such update, which was adopted in 2017, included a large number of changes resulting from the OECD/G20 project on the dilution of the tax base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation (BEPS) and, in particular, from the final reports on Activities 2, 6, 7 and 141 prepared under this project.
V. The impact of the OECD Model Convention
12. Since 1963, the OECD Model Convention has had broad implications for the negotiation, application and interpretation of tax conventions.
12. Since 1963, the OECD Model Tax Convention has had far-reaching consequences for the negotiation, application and interpretation of tax conventions.
13. Firstly, OECD member countries generally comply with the Model Convention when concluding or revising bilateral conventions. The progress achieved in eliminating double taxation between member countries can be measured by the increase in the number of conventions concluded or revised since 1957 in accordance with the Recommendations of the OECD Council. However, the importance of the Model Convention should be measured not only by the number of conventions concluded between member countries, but also by the fact that, in accordance with the Recommendations of the OECD Council, these conventions follow a common model and, in most cases, the main provisions of the Model Convention. The existence of the Model Convention has facilitated bilateral negotiations between OECD member countries and made it possible to achieve the desired consistency between their bilateral conventions, in the interests of both taxpayers and public authorities.
14. Secondly, the influence of the Model Convention has extended far beyond the OECD area. It has been used as the main reference document in negotiations between member and non-member countries, and even between non-member countries, as well as in the work of other international organisations, both worldwide and regional, in the field of double taxation and related issues. In particular, it was used as the basis for the initial development and subsequent revision of the United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention
1 OECD (2015), Neutralising the Effects of Hybrid Mismatch Arrangements, Action 2 – 2015 Final Report, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241138-en; OECD (2015), Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances, Action 6 – 2015 Final Report, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241695-en; OECD (2015), Preventing the Artificial Avoidance of Permanent Establishment Status, Action 7 – 2015 Final Report, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241220-en; OECD (2015), Making Dispute Resolution Mechanisms More Effective, Action 14 – 2015 Final Report, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241633-en.
between Developed and Developing Countries,¹ which reproduces a substantial part of the provisions and Commentaries of the OECD Model Convention. Recognising the growing influence of the Model Convention in non-member countries, it was decided in 1997 to add to the Model Convention the positions of a number of these countries on its provisions and Commentaries.
15. Thirdly, the worldwide recognition of the provisions of the Model Convention and their inclusion in most bilateral conventions has helped make the Commentaries on the provisions of the Model Convention a widely recognised guide to the interpretation and application of the provisions of existing bilateral conventions. This has facilitated the interpretation and compliance with these bilateral conventions in accordance with common principles. As the network of tax treaties continues to expand, the importance of such a commonly accepted guide increases.
C. Tax Policy Considerations Relevant to the Decision to Conclude a Double Taxation Convention or Amend an Existing Convention
15.1 In 1997, the OECD Council adopted a recommendation that the governments of member countries should continue their efforts to conclude bilateral tax treaties with those member countries and, where appropriate, with non-member countries with which they had not yet concluded such conventions. Although the question of whether or not to conclude a double taxation convention with another country is decided by each State on the basis of various factors, including both tax and non-tax considerations, tax policy considerations will generally play a key role in that decision. The following paragraphs describe some of these tax policy considerations, which are relevant not only to the question of whether a State should conclude a treaty with another State, but also to the question of whether a State should seek to amend or replace an existing treaty or even, in extreme cases, terminate a treaty (bearing in mind the fact that treaty termination often has a negative impact on a large number of taxpayers who are not concerned with the situations that lead to the termination of the treaty).
15.2 Since the main purpose of double taxation conventions is to prevent double taxation in order to reduce tax obstacles to cross-border services, trade and investment, the existence of risks of double taxation arising from the interaction of the tax systems of the two States concerned will be a primary tax policy consideration. Such risks of double taxation will generally be more significant where there is a substantial level of existing or planned cross-border trade and investment between the two States. Most of the provisions of double taxation conventions are aimed at eliminating double taxation by allocating taxing rights between the two States. It is assumed that, when a State accepts provisions of a convention that restrict its right to tax items of income, it generally does so on the understanding that those items of income are subject to taxation in the other State. If a State does not levy income tax or levies low taxes, other States should consider whether there are risks of double taxation that, in themselves, justify the conclusion of a double taxation convention. States should also consider whether there are elements of the other State's tax system that may increase the risk of non-taxation, which may include tax benefits restricted to the domestic economy.
1 United Nations Model Double Taxation Convention between Developed and Developing Countries, United Nations Publications, New York, first edition 1980, third edition 2011.
15.3 Accordingly, two States considering the conclusion of a double taxation convention should assess the extent to which a risk of double taxation actually exists in cross-border situations involving their residents. Most cases of residence-based double taxation can be eliminated through domestic provisions for relief from double taxation (usually in the form of an exemption or a credit method), which operate without the need to conclude double taxation conventions. Although these domestic provisions are likely to address most forms of juridical double taxation arising in the State of residence, they will not cover all cases of double taxation, particularly where there are substantial differences in the source rules of the two States or where the domestic law of those States does not permit unilateral relief from economic double taxation (for example, in the case of a transfer pricing adjustment made in another State).
15.4 Another tax policy consideration relevant to the conclusion of a double taxation convention is the risk of excessive taxation that may arise as a result of high income taxes in the State of source. Although mechanisms for the elimination of double taxation generally ensure that such high taxes in the State of source do not result in double taxation, to the extent that such taxes levied in the State of source exceed the amount of tax normally levied on profits in the State of residence, they may have an adverse effect on cross-border trade and investment.
15.5 Additional tax aspects that should be taken into account when considering the conclusion of a double taxation convention include the various features of double taxation conventions that encourage and strengthen economic ties between countries, such as protection against discriminatory tax treatment of foreign investment, as provided for by the non-discrimination rules of Article 24, greater certainty regarding the tax treatment of taxpayers entitled to the benefits of the convention, and the fact that double taxation conventions provide, through the mutual agreement procedure, together with the possibility for the Contracting States to resort to arbitration, a mechanism for resolving cross-border tax disputes.
15.6 An important objective of double taxation conventions is the prevention of tax evasion and avoidance. States should also consider whether their potential treaty partners are willing and able to effectively implement the provisions of double taxation conventions concerning administrative assistance, such as the possibility of exchanging tax information, which is a key aspect to be taken into account when deciding whether or not to conclude such a double taxation convention. The ability and willingness of a State to provide assistance in tax collection will also be an important factor to consider. However, it should be noted that, in the absence of any actual risk of double taxation, these administrative provisions alone may not provide a sufficient tax policy basis for the existence of a double taxation convention, since such administrative assistance may be provided through more targeted alternative agreements, such as the conclusion of a tax information exchange agreement or participation in the Multilateral Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters.¹
1 Available at: http://www.oecd.org/ctp/exchange-of-tax-information/ENG-Amended-Convention.pdf
D. Presentation of the Model Convention
Title of the Model Convention
16. Both the 1963 Draft Convention and the 1977 Model Convention included a reference to the elimination of double taxation in the title of the Model Convention. Recognising the fact that the Model Convention does not deal exclusively with the elimination of double taxation, but also addresses other issues, such as the prevention of tax evasion and avoidance, as well as non-discrimination, it was decided in 1992 to use a shorter title that did not contain this reference. This change was made both on the cover page of this publication and in the Model Convention itself. However, it was understood that the practice of many member countries should continue to include in the title a reference either to the elimination of double taxation or to the elimination of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion, since both approaches emphasise these important objectives of the Convention.
16.1 As a result of the work carried out under the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, in 2014 the Committee decided to change the title of the Convention and include a preamble. The amendments made expressly recognise that the objectives of the Convention are not limited to the elimination of double taxation and that the Contracting States do not intend the provisions of the Convention to create opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax evasion and avoidance. Taking into account the particular concern regarding base erosion and profit shifting arising from arrangements involving the use of double taxation conventions, it was also decided to expressly refer to such arrangements as one example of tax evasion that should not result from double taxation conventions, it being understood that this was only one example of the tax evasion that the Contracting States intend to prevent.
16.2 Since the title and preamble form part of the context of the Convention² and constitute a general statement of the object and purpose of the Convention, they should play an important role in interpreting the provisions of the Convention. According to the general rule of treaty interpretation contained in Article 31(1) of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, "a treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose."
2 See Article 31(2) of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
General Provisions of the Model Convention
17. The Model Convention first describes its scope (Chapter I) and defines certain terms (Chapter II). The main body consists of Chapters III to V, which determine the extent to which each of the two Contracting States may tax income and capital and how international juridical double taxation is to be eliminated. These are followed by Special Provisions (Chapter VI) and Final Provisions (entry into force and termination).
Scope and Definitions
18. The Convention applies to all persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States (Article 1). It deals with taxes on income and on capital, which are described in general terms in Article 2. Chapter II provides definitions of certain terms used in more than one Article of the Convention. Other terms, such as "dividends", "interest", "royalties" and "immovable property", are defined in the Articles dealing with those matters.
Taxation of Income and Capital
19. For the purposes of eliminating double taxation, the Convention establishes two categories of rules. Firstly, Articles 6–21 determine, in respect of various classes of income, the respective taxing rights of the State of source or situs and the State of residence, while Article 22 does the same in respect of capital. In the case of a number of items of income and capital, the exclusive right to tax is granted to one of the Contracting States. Thus, the other Contracting State may not tax those items, thereby avoiding double taxation. As a general rule, this exclusive taxing right is granted to the State of residence. In respect of other items of income and capital, the taxing right is not exclusive. With regard to two classes of income (dividends and interest), although both States have the right to tax, the amount of tax that may be levied in the State of source is limited. Secondly, since these provisions grant the State of source or the State of residence full or limited taxing rights, the State of residence must provide relief from taxation in order to avoid double taxation; this is the purpose of Articles 23 A and 23 B. The Convention leaves it to the Contracting States to choose between two methods of relief: the exemption method and the credit method.
20. Income and capital may be divided into three classes according to the treatment applied to each class in the State of source or situs:
- income and capital that may be taxed without any limitations in the State of source or situs,
- income that may be subject to limited taxation in the State of source, and
- income and capital that may not be taxed in the State of source or situs.
21 . The following are the classes of income and capital that can be taxed without any restrictions in the State of origin or place of operation.:
– income from immovable property located in that State (including income from agriculture or forestry), income from the alienation of such property and the capital representing it (Articles 6 and paragraph 1 of Articles 13 and 22), as well as income from the alienation of shares amounting to more than 50 percent of their value (paragraph 4 of Article 13);
– profits of a permanent establishment located in that State, profits from the alienation of such permanent establishment and capital representing movable property forming part of the commercial property of such permanent establishment (Articles 7 and paragraph 2 of Articles 13 and 22); however, an exception is made if the permanent establishment is maintained for the purposes of international navigation and international air traffic (see paragraph 23 below);
– income from the activities of artists and athletes carried out in that State, regardless of whether such income is accrued to the artist or athlete himself or another person (Article 17);
– remuneration of directors paid by a company that is a resident of that State (Article 16);
– remuneration for work in the private sector carried out in that State, except in cases where the employee is present there for a period not exceeding 183 days in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the relevant financial year, and subject to certain conditions.;
– subject to certain conditions, remuneration and pensions paid for public service (Article 19).
22 . The income classes that may be subject to limited taxation in the source State are listed below.:
- Dividends: Provided that the ownership in respect of which the dividends are paid is not linked to a permanent establishment in the source State, that State must limit its tax to 5 percent of the total amount of dividends if the beneficial owner is a company that directly owns for 365 days at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying the dividends. dividends and up to 15 percent of their total amount in other cases (Article 10);
- Interest: With the same caveat as in the case of dividends, the source State must limit its tax to 10 percent of the total amount of interest, excluding any interest exceeding the usual amount (Article 11).
23. Other items of income or capital may not be taxed in the State of origin or place of operation; as a rule, they are subject to taxation only in the State of residence of the taxpayer. This applies, for example, to royalties (Article 12), income from the sale of shares or securities (paragraph 5 of Article 13, with the exception of paragraph 4 of Article 13), remuneration for work performed on board a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic (paragraph 3 of Article 15), pensions in the private sector (Article 18), payments received by the student for the purposes of his education or professional training (Article 20), and capital represented by shares or securities (paragraph 4 of Article 22). Similarly, profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, profits from the alienation of such ships and the capital represented by them are subject to taxation only in the State of residence (Articles 8 and paragraph 3 of Articles 13 and 22). Profits from activities that are not related to a permanent establishment in the State of origin are also subject to taxation only in the State of residence (paragraph 1 of Article 7).
24 . If a resident of one Contracting State receives income from sources in the other Contracting State or owns capital located there, which, in accordance with the Convention, is subject to taxation only in the State of residence, the problem of double taxation does not arise, since the State of source or place of business must refrain from taxation of this income or capital.
25 . If, on the contrary, income or capital may, in accordance with the Convention, be taxed with or without restrictions in the State of origin or place of operation, the State of residence is obliged to eliminate double taxation. This can be done using one of the following two methods:
– Exemption method: Income or capital that is subject to taxation in the State of origin or place of business is exempt from tax in the State of residence, but may be taken into account when determining the tax rate applied to the taxpayer's residual income or capital;
– Credit method: Income or capital that is subject to taxation in the State of origin or place of business is subject to taxation in the State of residence, but the tax levied in the State of origin or place of business is credited against the tax levied on such income or capital by the State of Residence.
25.1 It follows from the preceding explanations that throughout the Convention, the words "may be taxed in" a Contracting State mean that that State has been granted the right to tax income to which the relevant provision applies, and that these words do not affect the taxation law of the other Contracting State, except in cases where Article 23 A or 23 B applies. when this other State is the State of Residence.
Special provisions
26 . The Convention has a number of special provisions. These provisions relate to:
– Elimination of tax discrimination in various circumstances (Article 24);
– Establishing a mutual agreement procedure to eliminate double taxation and resolve conflicts of interpretation of the Convention (Article 25);
– Exchange of information between the tax authorities of the Contracting States (Article 26);
– Assistance of the Contracting States in collecting each other's taxes (Article 27);
– Tax treatment for employees of diplomatic missions and consular institutions in accordance with international law (Article 28);
– The right to benefits under the Convention (Article 29);
– Territorial extension of the Convention (Article 30).
General remarks on the Model Convention
27 The Model Convention seeks, whenever possible, to specify a single rule for each situation. However, on some issues, it was considered necessary to leave in the Convention a certain degree of flexibility compatible with the effective implementation of the Model Convention. Thus, member States have a certain freedom, for example, regarding the establishment of withholding tax rates on dividends and interest, as well as the choice of a method to eliminate double taxation. Moreover, for some cases, alternative or additional provisions are mentioned in the Comments.
Comments on Articles
28 Each article of the Convention is accompanied by a detailed Commentary intended to illustrate or interpret its provisions.
29 Since the Comments were drafted and agreed upon by experts appointed to the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs by the Governments of the member countries, they are of particular importance in the development of international financial law. Although the Commentaries are not intended to be attached in any way to conventions signed by member countries, which, unlike the Model Convention, are legally binding international instruments, they can nevertheless be of great help in the application and interpretation of conventions and, in particular, in the resolution of any disputes.
29.1 The tax authorities of the member States regularly seek Comments when interpreting bilateral tax agreements. Comments are useful both in solving everyday issues and in solving larger problems related to the policies and objectives underlying the various provisions. Tax officials attach great importance to the recommendations contained in the Comments.
29.2 Similarly, taxpayers make extensive use of Comments when conducting their business and planning business transactions and investments. Comments are particularly important in countries where there is no procedure for obtaining a preliminary decision on tax matters from the tax authority, in which case Comments may be the only available source of interpretation.
29.3 Bilateral agreements on the avoidance of double taxation are also attracting more and more judicial attention. Courts are increasingly using Comments when making their decisions. Information gathered by the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs shows that the Comments were quoted in the published decisions of the courts of the vast majority of member countries. In many decisions, the Comments were quoted and analyzed in detail and often played a key role in the court's deliberations. The Committee expects this trend to continue as the worldwide network of double taxation agreements continues to grow, and as Commentaries become even more widely recognized as an important interpretative reference.
30 . Comments to the Commentaries are sometimes inserted at the request of Member countries that cannot agree with the interpretation given in the Commentary to the relevant Article. Thus, these comments do not express any disagreement with the text of the Convention, but effectively indicate how these countries will apply the provisions of the Article in question. Since the comments relate to the interpretation of the Articles cited in the Comments, no comments are needed to indicate a country's desire to change the wording of an alternative or additional provision that the Comments allow countries to include in their bilateral conventions.
Reservations of some member States on certain provisions of the Convention
31. Although all member countries agree on the objectives and main provisions of the Model Convention, almost all of them have made reservations on certain provisions, which are recorded in the Comments to the relevant Articles. There was no need for countries to make reservations indicating their intention to use alternative or additional provisions that the Commentaries allow countries to include in their bilateral conventions, or to change the wording of a provision in the Model Convention to confirm or include the interpretation of that provision put forward in the Commentary. It is understood that to the extent that a member country has made reservations, other member countries, when concluding bilateral conventions with the former, will retain their freedom of action in accordance with the principle of reciprocity.
32 The Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs considers that these reservations should be considered against the background of a very wide range of issues on which agreement was reached during the drafting of this Convention.
Connection to previous versions
33 . In developing the 1977 Model Convention, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs examined the problems of conflict of interpretation that might arise as a result of changes in the Articles and Commentaries to the 1963 Draft Convention. At the time, the Committee considered that the existing conventions should, as far as possible, be interpreted in the spirit of the revised Commentaries, even though the provisions of those Conventions had not yet incorporated the more precise wording of the 1977 Model Convention. It was also pointed out that Member States wishing to clarify their positions in this regard could do so through an exchange of letters between the competent authorities in accordance with the mutual agreement procedure and that even in the absence of such an exchange of letters, these authorities could use mutual agreement procedures to confirm this interpretation in specific cases.
34 . The Committee considers that the amendments to the Articles of the Model Convention and the Commentaries introduced since 1977 should be interpreted in a similar manner.
35 . Needless to say, amendments to the articles of the Model Convention and amendments to the Commentaries that are a direct result of these amendments are not relevant to the interpretation or application of previously concluded conventions if the provisions of these conventions differ in substance from the amended Articles (see, for example, paragraph 4 of the Commentary to Article 5). However, other changes or additions to the Comments are usually applicable to the interpretation and application of conventions concluded before their adoption, as they reflect the consensus of OECD member countries on the correct interpretation of existing provisions and their application in specific situations.
36 . Although the Committee considers that the amendments to the Comments should be relevant to the interpretation and application of conventions concluded prior to the adoption of these amendments, it does not agree with any form of interpretation to the contrary, which necessarily follows from the amendment of the article of the Model Convention or the Comments, that the previous wording led to consequences different from those of the amended wording. Many amendments are intended simply to clarify, rather than change, the meaning of Articles or Comments, and such interpretations to the contrary in such cases will clearly be incorrect.
36.1 The tax authorities of the Member States follow the general principles set out in the previous four paragraphs. Accordingly, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Issues considers that taxpayers may also find it useful to review later versions of the Comments when interpreting earlier agreements.
The Multilateral Convention
37 . When preparing the Draft 1963 Convention and the 1977 Model Convention, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs considered the possibility of concluding a multilateral tax convention and concluded that this would be very difficult. However, he acknowledged that some groups of Member countries could explore the possibility of concluding such a convention among themselves on the basis of a Model Convention, taking into account some changes that they might consider necessary to meet their specific objectives.
38 . The Scandinavian Income and Capital Convention, concluded by Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden, which was concluded in 1983 and replaced in 1987, 1989 and 1996.1 is a practical example of such a multilateral convention between a group of participating countries and strictly follows the provisions of the Model Convention.
39 .There is also an up-to-date Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters, which was developed in the Council of Europe on the basis of the first draft prepared by the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs. This Convention entered into force on April 1, 1995. Another relevant multilateral convention is the Multilateral Convention on the Implementation of Measures Related to Tax Agreements in order to Counteract the Dilution of the Tax Base and the Withdrawal of Profits from Taxation, which was developed to facilitate the implementation of treaty-related measures arising from the OECD/G20 project on the dilution of the tax Base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation, and which was opened for signature on December 31, 2016.
40 . Despite these multilateral conventions, there is no reason to believe that the conclusion of a multilateral tax convention involving a large number of countries, which could replace the network of existing bilateral tax conventions, could now be considered feasible. The Committee therefore considers that bilateral conventions continue to be a more appropriate way to ensure the elimination of double taxation at the international level.
_____________________________
1 The Faroe Islands have also signed the 1989 and 1996 Conventions.
Tax evasion and avoidance: improper use of conventions
41 . Issues related to the misuse of tax conventions and international tax evasion have been a constant concern of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs since the publication of the Draft Convention in 1963. Over the years, a number of provisions have been added or amended to the Model Convention (for example, Article 29, added in 2017) to address various forms of tax evasion and avoidance. The Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs will continue to monitor the application of double taxation agreements to ensure that, as stated in the preamble to the Convention, the provisions of the Convention are not used for tax evasion or avoidance purposes.
MODEL CONVENTION ON INCOME AND CAPITAL TAXES BRIEF INFORMATION ON THE CONVENTION
Title and preamble
Chapter I
SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
Article 1 Covered persons
Article 2 Taxes covered
Article 3 General definitions
Article 4 Resident
Chapter II
DEFINITIONS
Article 5 Permanent establishment
Chapter III
TAXATION OF INCOME
Article 6 Income from immovable property
Article 7 Commercial profit
Article 8 International shipping and air transport
Article 9 Associated enterprises
Article 10 Dividends
Article 11 Interest
Article 12 Royalties
Article 13 Capital gains
Article 14 [Deleted]
Article 15 Income from employment
Article 16 Remuneration of directors
Article 17 Entertainment industry workers and athletes
Article 18 Pension
Article 19 Public services Article 20 Students
Article 21 Other income
Article 22 Capital
Chapter IV
TAXATION OF CAPITAL
Chapter V
METHODS OF ELIMINATING DOUBLE TAXATION
Article 23 A Release method Article 23 B Credit method
Article 24 Non-discrimination
Chapter VI
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Article 25 Mutual agreement procedure Article 26 Information exchange
Article 27 Assistance in tax collection
Article 28 Employees of diplomatic missions and consular institutions Article 29 The right to benefits
Article 30 Territorial expansion
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
Article 31 Entry into force Article 32 Termination
TITLE OF the conventionconvention between (State A) and (State B)on the elimination of double taxation with respect to taxes on income and capital and the prevention of tax evasion and avoidance
PREAMBLE TO THE CONVENTION
(State A) and (State B),
Desiring to further develop their economic relations and strengthen cooperation in tax matters,
Intending to conclude a Convention on the Elimination of Double Taxation with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital, without creating opportunities for tax exemption or tax reduction through tax evasion or avoidance (including through contractual agreements aimed at obtaining the benefits provided for in this Convention for the indirect benefit of residents of third countries),
We have agreed on the following:
Chapter I
SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION
ARTICLE 1 COVERED PERSONS
1. This Convention applies to persons residing in one or both of the Contracting States.
2. For the purposes of this Convention, income earned by a legal person or organization that is considered to be fully or partially financially transparent in accordance with the tax laws of any of the Contracting States shall be considered income of a resident of a Contracting State, but only to the extent that the income is considered for tax purposes by that State as income of a resident of that State.
3. This Convention shall not affect the taxation of a Contracting State in respect of its residents, with the exception of the benefits granted in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 7, paragraph 2 of Article 9 and Articles 19, 20, 23 [A] [B], 24, 25 and 28.
ARTICLE 2 TAXES COVERED
1. This Convention shall apply to taxes on income and on capital imposed on behalf of a Contracting State or of its administrative-territorial units or local authorities, irrespective of the manner in which they are levied.
2. Taxes on income and on capital are all taxes imposed on total income, on total capital, or on elements of income or capital, including taxes on profits from the alienation of movable or immovable property, taxes on the total amount of wages or salaries paid by enterprises, as well as taxes on capital gains.
3. The existing taxes to which the Convention applies, in particular: (a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
4. This Convention shall also apply to any identical or substantially similar taxes that are imposed after the date of signature of the Convention in addition to or in place of the existing taxes. The competent authorities of the Contracting States must notify each other of any significant changes introduced into their tax legislation.
Chapter II
DEFINITIONS
ARTICLE 3 GENERAL DEFINITIONS
1. For the purposes of this Convention, unless the context requires otherwise.:
(a) The term "person" includes an individual, a company, and any other body of persons;
b) the term "company" means any corporate association or any entity that is treated as a corporate association for tax purposes;
c) the term "enterprise" applies to the conduct of any business;
(d) The terms "enterprise of a Contracting State" and "enterprise of the other Contracting State" mean respectively an enterprise operated by a resident of one Contracting State and an enterprise operated by a resident of the other Contracting State;
(e) The term "international carriage" means any carriage by ship or aircraft, except when the ship or aircraft is used exclusively between locations in a Contracting State and the enterprise that operates the ship or aircraft is not an enterprise of that State.;
(f) The term "competent authority" means:
(i) (in State A):
(ii) (in State B):
(g) The term "national" in relation to a Contracting State means:
(i) any natural person having the nationality of that Contracting State; and
(ii) any legal person, partnership or association which has acquired its status as such on the basis of the laws in force in that Contracting State.;
h) The term "business" includes the provision of professional services and other independent activities.
(i) The term "recognized pension fund" of a State means an organization or structure established in that State that is treated as a separate entity in accordance with the tax laws of that State; and:
(i) which is established and operates solely or almost exclusively for the administration or provision of pension benefits and supplementary or side benefits to individuals and which is regulated as such by that State, one of its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities; or
(ii) which is created and operated solely or almost exclusively for the purpose of investing funds for the benefit of the organizations or entities specified in subsection (i).
2. With regard to the application of the Convention at any time by a Contracting State, any term not defined therein must, unless the context requires otherwise or the competent authorities agree on a different meaning in accordance with the provisions of Article 25, have the meaning it had at that time under the laws of that State for tax purposes, to to which the Convention applies. Any meaning under the applicable tax laws of that State takes precedence over the meaning assigned to the term under other laws of that State.
ARTICLE 4 RESIDENT
1. For the purposes of this Convention, the term "resident of a Contracting State" means any person who, under the laws of that State, is liable to tax therein by reason of his residence, residence, place of management or any other criterion of a similar nature, and also includes that State and any of its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities, as well as the recognized pension fund of this State. However, this term does not include any person who is subject to taxation in that State solely in respect of income from sources in that State or capital located therein.
2. If by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1 an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, his status shall be determined as follows:
a) he is considered a resident only of the State in which he has affordable permanent housing; if he has affordable permanent housing in both States, he is considered a resident only of the State with which his personal and economic relations are closer (center of vital interests);
b) if the State in which he has his center of vital interests cannot be determined, or if he does not have permanent residence in any of these States, he is considered a resident only of the State in which he habitually resides.;
(c) If he has his habitual residence in both States or in neither of them, he is considered to be a resident only of the State of which he is a national.;
(d) If he is a national of both States or of neither of them, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall settle the matter by mutual agreement.
3. Where by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1 a person other than an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to determine by mutual agreement the Contracting State in which such person is deemed to be resident for the purposes of the Convention, taking into account the seat of its permanent executive authority, the place where registered or otherwise established, and any other relevant factors. In the absence of such an agreement, such person shall not be entitled to any of the benefits or tax exemptions provided for in this Convention, except to the extent and in such manner as may be agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States.
ARTICLE 5 PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT
For the purposes of this Convention, the term "permanent establishment" means a fixed place of business through which the activities of an enterprise are carried out in whole or in part.
1. The term "permanent establishment" includes, in particular:
a) Management location;
b) branch office:
c) office;
d) the factory;
e) a workshop, and
f) a mine, an oil or gas well, a quarry or any other place of extraction of natural resources.
2. A construction site or a construction or installation facility is a permanent establishment only if its duration exceeds twelve months.
3. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this article, the term "permanent establishment" is not considered to include:
a) the use of premises solely for the purpose of storing, displaying or delivering goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
b) maintaining stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purposes of storage, display or delivery;
(c) Maintaining stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purposes of processing by another enterprise;
d) the maintenance of a permanent place of business solely for the purpose of acquiring goods or merchandise or collecting information for the enterprise;
e) the maintenance of a permanent place of business solely for the purpose of conducting any other activity for the enterprise;
(f) The maintenance of a permanent place of business solely for any combination of the activities referred to in subparagraphs (a) to (e),
provided that such activities or, in the case of subparagraph (f), the general activities of the permanent place of business are preparatory or auxiliary in nature.
4.1 Paragraph 4 does not apply to a fixed place of business used or maintained by an enterprise if the same enterprise or an enterprise closely related to it carries on business at the same place or in another place in the same Contracting State.
and
(a) This place or another place constitutes a permanent establishment of an enterprise or a closely related enterprise in accordance with the provisions of this Article, or
(b) A common activity resulting from a combination of activities carried out by two enterprises in one location or by the same enterprise or closely related enterprises in two locations is not preparatory or supportive in nature.,
provided that business activities carried out by two enterprises in the same location or by the same enterprise or closely related enterprises in two locations represent complementary functions that are part of a coordinated business operation.
5. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 6, when a person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise and in doing so usually enters into contracts or plays a major role leading to the conclusion of contracts, which are usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise, and these contracts are concluded
a) on behalf of the enterprise or
(b) To transfer ownership or grant the right to use property owned by that enterprise or which the enterprise is entitled to use, or
c) for the provision of services by this enterprise,
that enterprise shall be deemed to have a permanent establishment in that State in respect of any activities that that person carries out for the enterprise, except in cases where the activities of such person are limited to those referred to in paragraph 4, which, if carried out through a permanent place of business (other than a permanent place of business to which paragraph 4.1 applies), does not transform this permanent place of business into a permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of this paragraph.
6. Paragraph 5 does not apply if a person acting in one Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise of the other Contracting State conducts business in the first-mentioned State as an independent agent and acts on behalf of the enterprise in the ordinary course of business. However, if a person acts solely or almost exclusively on behalf of one or more enterprises with which he is closely associated, this person should not be considered an independent agent within the meaning of this paragraph in relation to any such enterprise.
7. The fact that a company that is a resident of one Contracting State controls or is controlled by a company that is a resident of the other Contracting State or that conducts business in that other State (whether through a permanent establishment or otherwise) should not in itself be considered by one company to be a permanent establishment of the other.
8. For the purposes of this Article, a natural or legal person is closely linked to an enterprise if, based on all relevant facts and circumstances, one controls the other or both are controlled by the same persons or enterprises. In any case, an individual or legal entity is considered to be closely related to an enterprise if one of them directly or indirectly owns more than 50 percent of the beneficial interest in the other (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 percent of the total number of votes and the value of the company's shares or the beneficial interest in the company's capital) or if another individual or legal entity directly or indirectly owns more than 50 percent of the beneficial interest (or, in the case of a company, more than 50 percent of the total number of votes and the value of the company's shares or the beneficial interest in the company's capital) in this person and the enterprise or two enterprises.
Chapter III
TAXATION OF INCOME
ARTICLE 6
INCOME FROM REAL ESTATE
1. Income earned by a resident of one Contracting State from immovable property (including income from agriculture or forestry) located in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. The term "immovable property" has the meaning that it has in accordance with the laws of the Contracting State in which such property is located. The term in any case includes property ancillary to immovable property, livestock and equipment used in agriculture and forestry, rights to which the provisions of common law relating to land ownership apply, the usufruct of immovable property and rights to variable or fixed payments as compensation for mining or the right to develop deposits. minerals, sources, and other natural resources; ships and aircraft are not considered immovable property.
3. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall apply to income derived from the direct use, rental or use of immovable property in any other form.
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 3 shall also apply to income from immovable property of an enterprise.
ARTICLE 7
COMMERCIAL PROFIT
1. The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State are taxable only in that State, unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment located there. If an enterprise carries on business as described above, profits attributable to a permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 may be taxed in that other State.
2. For the purposes of this Article and Article [23 A] [23 B], the profits attributed in each Contracting State to the permanent establishment referred to in paragraph 1 are the profits that it could expect, in particular, in relations with other parts of the enterprise if it were a separate and independent enterprise engaged in that activity. the same or similar activities on the same or similar terms, taking into account the functions performed, the assets used and the risks assumed by the enterprise through a permanent establishment and through other parts of the enterprise.
3. If, in accordance with paragraph 2, a Contracting State adjusts profits relating to a permanent establishment of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States and taxes accordingly the profits of the enterprise that are taxed in the other State, the other State shall, to the extent necessary to eliminate double taxation on those profits, make appropriate an adjustment to the amount of tax levied on this profit. In determining such an adjustment, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall, if necessary, consult with each other.
4. If profits include types of income that are specifically mentioned in other articles of this Convention, the provisions of these articles shall not be affected by the provisions of this article.
ARTICLE 8
INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING AND AIR TRANSPORTATION
1. The profits of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic are subject to taxation only in that State.
2. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall also apply to profits from participation in an association, joint venture or international commercial shipping agency.
ARTICLE 9
ASSOCIATED COMPANIES
1. If
(a) An enterprise of one Contracting State participates directly or indirectly in the management, control or capital of an enterprise of the other Contracting State, or
(b) The same persons are directly or indirectly involved in the management, control or capital of an enterprise of one Contracting State and an enterprise of the other Contracting State,
and in any case, conditions are created or established between two enterprises in their commercial or financial relations that differ from those that would be established between independent enterprises, then any profit that, if not for these conditions, was credited to one of the enterprises, but by virtue of these conditions was not accrued in this way, may be included in the profits of this enterprise and taxed accordingly.
2. If a Contracting State includes in the profits of an enterprise of that State - and taxes accordingly - Profits on which an enterprise of the other Contracting State is taxed in that other State, and the profits thus included are profits that would have accrued to an enterprise of the first-mentioned State if the conditions established between the two enterprises had been such as would have been established between independent enterprises, that other State shall make appropriate contributions. an adjustment to the amount of tax levied on this profit. In determining such an adjustment, the other provisions of this Convention shall be taken into account, and the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall consult with each other, if necessary.
ARTICLE 10
DIVIDENDS
1. Dividends paid by a company which is a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. However, dividends paid by a company that is a resident of one Contracting State may also be taxed in that State according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the dividends is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed:
a) 5 percent of the total amount of dividends, if the beneficiary owner is a company that directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying dividends during a 365-day period that includes the day of payment of dividends (for the purposes of calculating this period, changes in ownership rights that may be a direct result of corporate reorganization, such as a merger or separation, of a company holding shares or paying dividends);
b) 15 percent of the total amount of dividends in all other cases.
The competent authorities of the Contracting States will determine by mutual agreement how these restrictions will be applied. This paragraph does not affect the taxation of the company in respect of profits from which dividends are paid.
3. The term "dividends" used in this article means income from shares, shares with the right to receive a dividend or rights to shares with the right to receive a dividend, shares of mining companies, founding shares or other rights that are not debt claims, profit sharing, as well as income from other corporate rights that are subject to the same taxation as income from shares in accordance with the laws of the State in which the distribution company is a resident.
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the dividends, who is a resident of one Contracting State, conducts business in the other Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident through a permanent establishment located there and the holding company in respect of which the dividends are paid, is actually associated with such permanent establishment.
In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 shall apply.
5. If a company that is a resident of one Contracting State receives profits or income from the other Contracting State, that other State may not tax the dividends paid by the company, except in cases where such dividends are paid to a resident of that other Contracting State or if the holding company in respect of which the dividends are paid is actually affiliated with a permanent establishment located in in this other State, and does not tax the company's undistributed profits on the company's undistributed profits., even if the dividends paid or retained earnings consist wholly or partly of profits or income arising in such other State.
ARTICLE 11
percentages
1. Interest arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. However, interest arising in one Contracting State may also be taxed in that State according to the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the interest is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed 10 per cent of the total amount of the interest. The competent authorities of the Contracting States will determine by mutual agreement how these restrictions will be applied.
3. The term "interest" used in this Article means income from debt claims of any kind, regardless of whether it is secured by mortgage collateral and has the right to participate in the debtor's profits, and in particular income from government securities and income from bonds or debentures, including premiums and prices related to such securities, bonds or debentures. Late payment penalties are not considered interest for the purposes of this Article.
4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the interest, who is a resident of one Contracting State, conducts business in the other Contracting State in which the interest arises through a permanent establishment located there, and the debt claim in respect of which the interest is being paid is actually linked to such permanent establishment. In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 shall apply.
5. Interest shall be deemed to arise in a Contracting State if the payer is a resident of that State. However, if the person paying the interest, regardless of whether he is a resident of a Contracting State or not, has a permanent establishment in a Contracting State in connection with which an interest-bearing debt has arisen and such interest is accrued by such permanent establishment, such interest shall be deemed to arise in the State in which he is located. permanent representative office.
6. If, due to a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and any other person, the amount of interest, taking into account the claim for payment of the debt on which they are being paid, exceeds the amount that could have been agreed between the payer and the beneficial owner, in the absence of such a relationship, the provisions of this The articles apply only to the last specified amount. In such a case, the excess part of the payments will continue to be subject to taxation in accordance with the laws of each Contracting State, taking into account the other provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 12
ROYALTIES
1. Royalties arising in one Contracting State and actually owned by a resident of the other Contracting State shall be taxable only in that other State.
2. The term "royalties", as used in this Article, means payments of any kind received as remuneration for the use or right to use any copyrights in literary, artistic or scientific works, including cinematographic films, any patent, trademark, design or model, plan, secret formula or process, or information concerning industrial, commercial, or scientific experience.
3. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the royalties, who is a resident of one Contracting State, conducts business in the other Contracting State in which the royalties arise through a permanent establishment located there, and the debt claim in respect of which the royalties are paid is actually linked to such permanent establishment. In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 shall apply.
4. If, due to a special relationship between the payer and the beneficiary owner or between both of them and any other person, the amount of royalties, taking into account the use, rights or information for which they are paid, exceeds the amount that could have been agreed between the payer and the beneficiary owner, in the absence of such a relationship, the provisions This Article applies only to the last specified amount. In such a case, the excess part of the payments will continue to be subject to taxation in accordance with the laws of each Contracting State, taking into account the other provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 13
CAPITAL GAINS
1. Capital gains earned by a resident of a Contracting State from the alienation of immovable property referred to in Article 6 and located in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. Capital gains from the alienation of movable property forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State, including such gains from the alienation of such permanent establishment (individually or with the entire enterprise), may be taxed in that other State.
3. Capital gains which an enterprise of a Contracting State which operates ships or aircraft in international traffic obtains from the alienation of such ships or aircraft or movable property relating to the operation of such ships or aircraft shall be taxable only in that State.
4. Capital gains earned by a resident of one Contracting State from the alienation of shares or comparable interests, such as shares in a partnership or trust, may be taxed in the other Contracting State if at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, those shares or comparable interests received more than 50 percent of their value, directly or indirectly of immovable property, as defined in Article 6, located in that other State.
5. Capital gains from the alienation of any property other than those referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 shall be taxable only in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident.
[ARTICLE 14 - SERVICES OF INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS]
[DELETED]
ARTICLE 15
INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT
1. Subject to the provisions of Articles 16, 18 and 19, salaries and other similar remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of an employment shall be taxable only in that State unless the employment is exercised in the other Contracting State. If the employment is carried out in this way, the remuneration received in connection with it may be taxed in that other State.
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of an employment exercised in the other Contracting State shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State if:
(a) The recipient is present in another State for a period or periods not exceeding a total of 183 days in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the relevant financial year, and
b) the remuneration is paid by or on behalf of an employer who is not a resident of another State, and
c) the remuneration is not paid by a permanent establishment that the employer has in another State.
3. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, remuneration earned by a resident of a Contracting State as a member of the regular staff of a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic, with the exception of work on board a ship or aircraft operated exclusively within the other Contracting State, shall be taxable only in the first Contracting State.
ARTICLE 16
REMUNERATION OF DIRECTORS
Directors' fees and other similar payments received by a resident of a Contracting State in his capacity as a member of the board of directors of a company that is a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
ARTICLE 17
ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY WORKERS AND ATHLETES
1. Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 15, income earned by a resident of a Contracting State as an employee of the entertainment industry, in particular in theater, cinema, radio or television, or as a musician or athlete, from personal activities of that resident carried on in the other Contracting State, may be taxed in that other State..
2. Where income from personal activities exercised by an entertainer or a sportsman acting as such accrues not to an entertainment worker or sportsman but to another person, that income may, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 15, be taxed in the Contracting State in which the activities of the entertainer or sportsman are carried on.
ARTICLE 18
pension
Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State in respect of past employment shall be taxable only in that State.
ARTICLE 19
PUBLIC SERVICE
1. (a) Salaries, wages and other similar remuneration paid by a Contracting State or a political subdivision or local authority thereof to an individual in respect of services rendered to that State, its subdivision or local authority shall be taxable only in that State.
(b) However, such salaries, wages and other similar remuneration shall be taxable only in the other Contracting State if the services are rendered in that State and the individual is a resident of that State who:
(i) is a national of that State; or
(ii) has not become a resident of that State solely for the purpose of rendering services.
2. (a) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, pensions and other similar remuneration paid by a Contracting State or a political subdivision or local authority thereof to an individual in respect of services rendered to that State, its subdivision or local authority shall be taxable only in that State.
(b) However, such pensions and other similar remuneration shall be taxable only in the other Contracting State if the individual is a resident of and a national of that State.
3. The provisions of Articles 15, 16, 17, and 18 shall apply to salaries, salaries, pensions, and other similar remuneration in respect of services rendered in connection with commercial activities carried on by a Contracting State or a political subdivision or local authority thereof.
ARTICLE 20
STUDENTS
Payments which a student or trainee who is or was immediately prior to visiting a Contracting State a resident of the other Contracting State and who is in the first-mentioned State solely for the purpose of education or vocational training receives for the purposes of his maintenance, education or vocational training shall not be taxable in that State, provided that such payments originate from sources outside this State.
ARTICLE 21
OTHER INCOME
1. Articles of income of a resident of a Contracting State, wherever they arise, which are not mentioned in the preceding articles of this Convention, shall be taxable only in that State.
2. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income other than income from immovable property, as defined in paragraph 2 of Article 6, if the recipient of such income, being a resident of a Contracting State, conducts business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment located therein and the right or property in respect of which the income is paid is actually related with such a permanent representation. In such a case, the provisions of Article 7 shall apply.
Chapter IV
TAXATION OF CAPITAL
ARTICLE 22
CAPITAL
1. Capital represented by immovable property referred to in Article 6 owned by a resident of a Contracting State and located in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. Capital represented by movable property forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
3. The capital of an enterprise of a Contracting State which operates ships or aircraft in international traffic represented by such ships or aircraft, as well as movable property pertaining to the operation of such ships or aircraft, shall be taxable only in that State.
4. All other elements of the capital of a resident of a Contracting State are taxable only in that State.
Chapter V
METHODS OF ELIMINATING DOUBLE TAXATION
ARTICLE 23 A
THE METHOD OF LIBERATION
1. If a resident of a Contracting State earns income or owns capital that may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention (except in cases where these provisions permit taxation in that other State only because the income is also income earned by a resident of that State, or because the capital is also capital owned by a resident of this State), The first-mentioned State, subject to the provisions of paragraphs 2 and 3, shall exempt such income or capital from tax.
2. If a resident of a Contracting State receives items of income that may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of Articles 10 and 11 (except in cases where these provisions permit taxation in that other State solely because the income is also income earned by a resident of that State), the first-mentioned State shall allow as The deduction from the income tax of this resident is to determine the amount equal to the tax paid in this other State. However, such a deduction should not exceed the portion of the tax that was calculated before the deduction and that relates to such items of income earned in that other State.
3. Where, in accordance with any provision of the Convention, income or capital earned belonging to a resident of a Contracting State is exempt from tax in that State, that State may nevertheless, in calculating the amount of tax on the remaining income or capital of that resident, take into account the exempt income or capital.
4. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply to income or capital earned owned by a resident of a Contracting State if the other Contracting State applies the provisions of this Convention to exempt such income or capital from tax or applies the provisions of paragraph 2 of Articles 10 or 11 to such income.
ARTICLE 23
B THE CREDIT METHOD
1. If a resident of one Contracting State earns income or owns capital that may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention (except in cases where these provisions permit taxation in that other State only because the income is also income earned by a resident of that State, or because the capital is also capital owned by a resident of that State), the first-mentioned State approves:
(a) As a deduction from the income tax of that resident, an amount equal to the income tax paid in that other State;
(b) As a deduction from the capital tax of that resident, an amount equal to the capital tax paid in that other State;
However, such a deduction in any case should not exceed that portion of the income tax or capital tax calculated before the deduction, which relates, as the case may be, to income or capital that may be taxed in that other State.
2. If, in accordance with any provision of the Convention, income or capital earned belonging to a resident of a Contracting State is exempt from tax in that State, that State may nevertheless take into account the exempt income or capital when calculating the amount of tax on the remaining income or capital of that resident.
Chapter VI
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 24
NON-DISCRIMINATION
1. Nationals of one Contracting State shall not be subjected in the other Contracting State to any taxation or any related requirement that is different or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which nationals of that other State may be subjected in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residency. This provision, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 1, also applies to persons who are not residents of one or both of the Contracting States.
2. Stateless persons who are residents of a Contracting State shall not be subjected in the other Contracting State to any taxation or any related requirement that is different or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which nationals of that other State may be subjected in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residences.
3. The taxation of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State shall not be less favourable in that other State than the taxation of enterprises of that other State engaged in the same activity. This provision should not be interpreted as obliging one Contracting State to provide residents of the other Contracting State with any personal benefits and discounts for tax purposes in connection with the civil status or family responsibilities that it provides to its residents.
4. Except where the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9, paragraph 6 of Article 11 or paragraph 4 of Article 12 apply, interest, royalties and other payments paid by an enterprise of a Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State shall, for the purposes of determining the taxable profits of such enterprise, be deductible on the same terms as if they had been paid a resident of the first mentioned State. Similarly, any debts owed by an enterprise of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State shall be deductible for the purpose of determining the taxable capital of such enterprise on the same terms as if they had been transferred to a resident of the first-mentioned Contracting State.
5. Enterprises of a Contracting State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State shall not be subject in the first-mentioned State to any taxation or any related requirement which is other or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which they are subject or may be subject. other similar enterprises of the first mentioned State have been subjected.
6. The provisions of this Article, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 2, shall apply to taxes of any kind.
ARTICLE 25
MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
1. If a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result or will result in taxation for him that is not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, he may, regardless of the remedies provided for by the domestic law of those States, submit his case to the competent authority of either Contracting State. The application must be submitted within three years from the date of the first notification of actions leading to taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention.
2. The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State with a view to avoiding taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. Any agreement reached will be implemented regardless of the time limits set by the domestic legislation of the Contracting States.
3. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to resolve by mutual agreement any problems or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of the Convention. They may also hold joint consultations on the elimination of double taxation in cases not provided for by the Convention.
4. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may communicate with each other directly, including through a joint commission composed of themselves or their representatives, with a view to reaching an agreement within the meaning of the preceding paragraphs.
5. If
(a) In accordance with paragraph 1, a person has submitted a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State on the ground that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in taxation for that person not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, and
(b) The competent authorities cannot reach an agreement on the resolution of the case in accordance with paragraph 2 within two years from the date on which all the information required by the competent authorities to review the case has been provided to both such competent authorities.,
Any unresolved issues arising from the case must be submitted to arbitration upon the written request of the person. However, these unresolved issues are not subject to arbitration if the decision on these issues has already been rendered by a court or an administrative court of any State. Except in cases where the person directly affected by the case does not accept a mutual agreement that implements the award, this award is binding on both Contracting States and must be implemented, despite any time restrictions provided for by the domestic legislation of those States. The competent authorities of the Contracting States will determine by mutual agreement the method of application of these paragraphs.
ARTICLE 26
INFORMATION EXCHANGE
1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange such information as may be relevant to the implementation of the provisions of this Convention or to the administration or enforcement of national legislation relating to taxes of any kind levied on behalf of the Contracting States or their administrative-territorial units or local authorities, provided that taxation under them does not conflict with the Convention. The exchange of information is not limited to Articles 1 and 2.
2. Any information received by a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 shall be considered secret in the same way as information received under the domestic law of that State and shall be disclosed only to persons or authorities (including courts and administrative authorities) involved in the assessment or collection, enforcement or prosecution of regarding the consideration of appeals in respect of taxes referred to in paragraph 1, or to the supervision of the above. Such persons or authorities should use the information only for these purposes. They may disclose information in public court proceedings or in court decisions. Notwithstanding the above, information received by a Contracting State may be used for other purposes if permitted by the laws of both States and the competent authority of the State providing the information authorizes such use.
3. In no case may the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 be interpreted as imposing on a Contracting State the following obligations::
(a) To carry out administrative measures contrary to the laws and administrative practices of one or the other Contracting State;
(b) To provide information that cannot be obtained in accordance with the laws or in the ordinary course of administrative practice of that or the other Contracting State;
c) provide information that would disclose any trade, business, industrial, commercial or professional secret or trade process, or information the disclosure of which would be contrary to government policy (ordre public).
4. If information is requested by one Contracting State in accordance with this Article, the other Contracting State shall use its information-gathering facilities to obtain the requested information, even if that other State may not require such information for its own tax purposes. The obligation contained in the previous sentence is subject to the limitations of paragraph 3, but such limitations can in no case be interpreted as allowing a Contracting State to refuse to provide information simply because it has no intrinsic interest in such information.
5. In no case should the provisions of paragraph 3 be interpreted as allowing a Contracting State to refuse to provide information solely on the grounds that this information belongs to a bank, other financial institution, nominee holder or a person acting for the agency or as a trustee, or because it concerns ownership interests.
ARTICLE 27
ASSISTANCE IN COLLECTING TAXES 1
1. The Contracting States will assist each other in collecting tax arrears. This assistance is not limited to Articles 1 and 2. The competent authorities of the Contracting States will, by mutual agreement, determine the manner of application of this Article.
2. The term "tax arrears" used in this Article means the amount due in respect of taxes of any kind levied on behalf of the Contracting States or their administrative-territorial units or local authorities, unless taxation on them is contrary to this Convention or any other instrument to which the Contracting States are parties, as well as interest, administrative fines and collection or storage costs associated with such an amount.
3. If a tax debt of a Contracting State is enforceable under the laws of that State and belongs to a person who at that time could not, under the laws of that State, prevent its collection, such tax debt must, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for collection purposes by the competent authority of the other Contracting State. This tax debt must be collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its legislation applicable to the collection and collection of its own taxes, as if the tax debt were the tax debt of that other State.
4. If a tax debt of a Contracting State constitutes a claim in respect of which that State may, in accordance with its legislation, take measures to ensure its recovery, such tax debt must, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for the purpose of taking conservation measures by the competent authority of the other Contracting State. This other State shall take measures to preserve this tax debt in accordance with the provisions of its legislation, as if the tax debt were a tax debt of this other State, even if, at the time of application of such measures, the tax debt is not enforceable in the first-mentioned State or is owed to a person who has the right to prevent its collection.
_______________________
1 In some countries, domestic legislation, policies or administrative arrangements may not allow or justify the type of assistance provided for in this Article, or may require that
This type of assistance was limited, for example, to countries with similar tax systems or tax authorities, or in relation to taxes covered. For this reason, an Article should be included in the Convention only if each State concludes that, based on the factors described in paragraph 1 of the Commentary to the Article, they can agree to assist in the collection of taxes levied by another State.
5. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 3 and 4, tax arrears accepted by a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3 or 4 shall not be subject to time restrictions and shall not be given any priority applicable to tax arrears under the laws of that State by virtue of its nature as such. In addition, tax arrears accepted by a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3 or 4 shall not have any priority in that State applicable to such tax arrears under the laws of the other Contracting State.
6. Judicial proceedings concerning the existence, validity or amount of tax arrears of one Contracting State shall not be considered in the courts or administrative authorities of the other Contracting State.
7. If at any time after a Contracting State has submitted a request in accordance with paragraph 3 or 4 and before the other Contracting State has collected and transferred the relevant tax arrears to the first-mentioned State, the relevant tax arrears shall cease to be
(a) In the case of a request under paragraph 3, a tax debt of the first-mentioned State, which is enforceable in accordance with the laws of that State and is owed to a person who at that time could not, in accordance with the laws of that State, prevent its collection; or
(b) In the case of a request in accordance with paragraph 4, a tax debt of the first-mentioned State, in respect of which that State may, in accordance with its laws, take conservation measures to ensure its recovery
The competent authority of the first-mentioned State shall immediately notify the competent authority of the other State of this fact, and, at the option of the other State, the first-mentioned State shall either suspend or withdraw its request.
8. In no case may the provisions of this Article be interpreted as imposing an obligation on a Contracting State.:
(a) To carry out administrative measures contrary to the laws and administrative practices of one or the other Contracting State;
b) take measures contrary to State policy (public order);
(c) Provide assistance if the other Contracting State has not taken all reasonable recovery or retention measures, as appropriate, available in accordance with its legislation or administrative practice;
(d) To provide assistance in cases where the administrative burden for that State is clearly disproportionate to the benefits that the other Contracting State may derive.
ARTICLE 28
EMPLOYEES OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR OFFICES
Nothing in this Convention affects the tax privileges of employees of diplomatic missions or consular institutions in accordance with the general rules of international law or in accordance with the provisions of special agreements.
ARTICLE 29
THE RIGHT TO BENEFITS 1
1. [A provision which, subject to paragraphs 3-5, restricts contractual benefits to a resident of a Contracting State who is a "qualified person" as defined in paragraph 2].
2. [Definition of situations where a resident is a qualified person who covers
– an individual;
– The Contracting State, its administrative-territorial entities, their agencies and bodies;
– certain public companies and organizations;
– some affiliated companies of public companies and organizations;
– some non-profit organizations and recognized pension funds;
– other enterprises that meet certain ownership and dilution requirements;
– some collective investment funds.]
3. [A provision that provides contractual benefits to a certain income earned by a person who is not a qualified person if that person is actively engaged in business in the State of Residence and the income comes from that business or is secondary].
4. [A provision that grants contractual benefits to a person who is not a qualified person, if at least more than the agreed share of this legal entity belongs to certain persons who are entitled to equal benefits].
5. [Provision granting contractual benefits to a person who qualifies as
"a company with a central office"].
6. [A provision that allows the competent authority of a Contracting State to grant certain contractual benefits to a person if other benefits have been denied in accordance with paragraph 1].
7. [Definitions applicable for the purposes of paragraphs 1-7].
8. a) If
(i) an enterprise of one Contracting State receives income from the other Contracting State, and the first-mentioned State considers such income
___________________________________
1 The drafting of this Article will depend on how the Contracting States decide to implement their common intention, reflected in the preamble to the Convention and included in the minimum standard agreed within the framework of the OECD/G20 project on the dilution of the tax base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation, in order to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for tax avoidance or reduction taxation through tax evasion or avoidanc 1 The drafting of this Article will depend on how the Contracting States decide to implement their common intention, reflected in the preamble to the Convention and included in the minimum standard agreed within the framework of the OECD/G20 project on the dilution of the tax base and the withdrrofits from taxation, in order to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for tax avoidance or reduction through tax evasion or avoidance, including through purchase arrangements. This can be done either by adopting paragraph 9 alone, or by adopting the detailed version of paragraphs 1 to 7 described in the Commentary to Article 29, together with the implementation of the mechanism for preventing secret passages, as described in paragraph 187 of this Commentary, or by adopting paragraph 9 together with any changes to paragraphs 1-7 described in the Commentary to Article 29.
income as related to the permanent establishment of the enterprise located in a third jurisdiction, and
(ii) profits related to this permanent establishment are exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State,
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-menti The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than tlowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item ofThe benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be posThe benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
The benefits under this Convention shall not apply to any item of income for which the tax in a third jurisdiction is less than the lowest of [the rate to be determined bilaterally] the amount of that item of income and 60 per cent of the tax to be applied in the first-mentioned State to that item of income if that permanent establishment is located in the first the mentioned State. In such a case, any income to which the provisions of this paragraph apply will continue to be taxable in accordance with the domestic law of the other State, notwithstanding any other provisions of the Convention.
b) The preceding provisions of this paragraph shall not apply if the income received from another State comes from the active conduct of business carried out through a permanent establishment (other than the business of investing, managing or simply storing investments at the enterprise's own expense, unless these activities are banking, insurance or securities transactions carried out by a bank, insurance company, or a registered securities dealer, respectively).
(c) If benefits under this Convention are denied in accordance with the preceding provisions of this paragraph in respect of an item of income earned by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, upon request by such resident, such competent authority determines that The provision of such benefits is justified in the light of the reasons why such a resident did not meet the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the presence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request was sent in accordance with the previous proposal should consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before accepting or rejecting the request.
9. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a benefit under this Convention in respect of an item of income or capital is not granted if there are grounds to conclude, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining this benefit was one of the main objectives of any arrangement or transaction that directly or indirectly led to to this benefit, unless it is established that the granting of this benefit in these circumstances would be consistent with the purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
ARTICLE 30
TERRITORIAL EXPANSION1
1. This Convention may extend in whole or with any necessary modifications [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) that is specifically excluded from the scope of application of the Convention or] to any State or territory for whose international relations (State A) or (State B) is responsible, which Levies taxes similar in nature to those to which the Convention applies. Any such extension shall enter into force on such date and shall be subject to such modifications and conditions, including termination conditions, as may be specified and agreed upon between the Contracting States in annexes to be exchanged through diplomatic channels or by any other means in accordance with their constitutional procedures.
2. Unless both Contracting States have agreed otherwise, the termination of the Convention by one of them in accordance with Article 32 shall also terminate, in accordance with the procedure provided for in that article, the application of the Convention [to any part of the territory of (State A) or (State B) or] in any State or territory in which it is located. It was distributed in accordance with this Article.
_________________________
1 The words in parentheses have the meaning when a special provision excludes a part of the territory of a Contracting State from the scope of application of the Convention.
Chapter VII
FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 31
ENTRY INTO FORCE
1. This Convention is subject to ratification and the instruments of ratification will be exchanged as soon as possible.
2. The Convention enters into force after the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions apply.:
a) (in State A): .
b) (in State B): .
ARTICLE 32
TERMINATION
This Convention shall remain in force until its termination by a Contracting State. Any Contracting State may terminate the Convention through diplomatic channels by giving notice of such termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year following the year in which the Convention ceases to be in force.:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
FINAL CAVEATION1
____________________________________
1 The final reservation regarding the signature must be drawn up in accordance with the constitutional procedure of both Contracting States.
COMMENTS ON THE ARTICLES OF THE MODEL CONVENTION ON TAXES
Point 1
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 1 CONCERNING THE PERSONS TO WHOM IT APPLIES
OPERATION OF THE CONVENTION
1. Whereas many conventions concluded in the first half of the 20th century were applicable to "nationals" of Contracting States, conventions concluded subsequently almost always apply to "residents" of one or both Contracting States, regardless of nationality. This approach is reflected in paragraph 1. The term "resident" is defined in Article 4. However, the fact that a person is a resident of a Contracting State does not mean that that person is automatically entitled to benefits under the Convention, since some or all of these benefits may be denied in accordance with various provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
2. This paragraph examines the situation with the income of legal entities or entities that one or both of the Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent for tax purposes. The provisions of this paragraph ensure that the income of such organizations or structures is considered for the purposes of the Convention in accordance with the principles reflected in the 1999 report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships".1 Therefore, this report provides recommendations and examples of how this provision should be interpreted and applied in various situations.
3. However, the report dealt exclusively with partnerships, and although the Committee recognized that many of the principles included in the report could also apply to other non-corporate legal entities, it expressed its intention to explore the application of the Model Convention on Taxes to such other entities at a later stage. As stated in paragraph 37 of the report, the Committee was particularly concerned about "cases where national tax legislation creates transitional situations where a partnership is partly considered a taxable entity and partly not accounted for for tax purposes." According to the report
Although this may create practical difficulties for a very limited number of partnerships, it is a more important issue in the case of other organizations such as trusts. For this reason, the Committee decided to address this issue in the context of the follow-up to this report.
4. Paragraph 2 addresses this particular situation by referring to organizations that
"fully or partially" are considered transparent for tax purposes. Thus, this paragraph not only serves to confirm the conclusions of the Partnership Report, but also expands the application of these conclusions to situations that were not directly covered by the report (subject to the application of special provisions concerning collective investment funds, see paragraphs 22-48 below).
5. This paragraph not only guarantees that the benefits provided for in the Convention are provided in appropriate cases, but also guarantees that these benefits are not provided if none of the Contracting States considers the income of the organization or organization as the income of one of its residents in accordance with its domestic law. Thus, the paragraph confirms the conclusions of the report in this case (see, for example, example 3 of the report). In addition, as recognized in the report, States should not be expected to provide benefits to a bilateral tax convention in cases where they cannot verify whether a person is actually eligible for these benefits. Thus, if a legal entity is established in a jurisdiction from which a Contracting State cannot obtain tax information, then in order to be able to benefit from the Convention, that State must be provided with all the necessary information. In such a case, the Contracting State may well decide to use the reimbursement mechanism for the purposes of applying the benefits under the Convention, even if it normally applies these benefits at the time of payment of the relevant income. However, in most cases, it will be possible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
ible to obtain relevant information and apply the benefits of the Convention during income taxation (see, for example, paragraphs 43-45 below, which discuss a similar issue in the context of collective investment funds).
________________________
1 Reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R (15)-1.
6. The following example illustrates the application of this paragraph:
Example: State A and State B have concluded an agreement identical to the Model Tax Convention. State A considers that a legal entity incorporated in State B is a company and taxes that legal entity on the interest it receives from a debtor resident in State A. However, according to the domestic legislation of State B, a legal entity is considered a partnership, and two members of this organization who share all its income equally are taxed for half of the interest. One of the members is a resident of State B, and the other is a resident of a country with which States A and B do not have a treaty. This paragraph provides that in such a case, half of the interest for the purposes of Article 11 is considered to be the income of a resident of State B.
7. The reference to "income earned by or through an organization or association" has a broad meaning and covers any income earned by or through an organization or association, regardless of the point of view of each Contracting State as to who receives this income for domestic tax purposes and regardless of whether that organization or association is a legal entity. or represents a person as defined in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 1 of Article 3. It will cover, for example, the income of any partnership or trust that one or both Contracting States consider to be fully or partially financially transparent. In addition, as shown in Example 2 of the report, it does not matter where the organization or association is established: this paragraph applies to an organization established in a third State to the extent that, according to the internal tax legislation of one of the Contracting States, the enterprise is considered to be fully or partially financially transparent, and the income of this enterprise belongs to a resident of this State.
8. The word "income" should have the broad meaning it has for the purposes of the Convention and therefore applies to the various items of income covered by Chapter III of the Convention (Taxation of income), including, for example, business profits and capital gains.
9. The term "transparent for tax purposes" used in this paragraph refers to situations where, under the domestic law of a Contracting State, the income (or part thereof) of an enterprise or organization is taxed not at the level of the organization or association, but at the level of persons interested in that organization or association. This usually happens when the amount of tax payable on the share of income of an organization or association is determined separately depending on the personal characteristics of the person entitled to this share, as a result of which the tax will depend on whether the person is taxed on other income that he has, on personal benefits. to which this person is entitled, and at the tax rate applicable to this person; in addition, the nature and source, as well as the timing of the realization of income for tax purposes, will not depend on the fact that it was received through an organization or association. The fact that income is calculated at the enterprise or organization level before the share is transferred to a person will not affect this result.1 States wishing to clarify the definition of "transparent for tax purposes" in their bilateral conventions may, at their discretion, include a definition of this term based on the explanations provided above.
10 . In the case of an organization or entity that, according to the domestic legislation of one of the Contracting States, is considered partially transparent for tax purposes, only part of the income of a legal entity or agreement may be taxed at the level of persons who have a stake in such an enterprise or entity, as described in the previous paragraph, while the rest will be subject tostill subject to taxation at the organization or educational level. For example, in some countries, some trusts and limited liability partnerships are considered (i.e. in some countries, part of the income earned through the trust, which is distributed among the beneficiaries, is taxed by these beneficiaries, while the part of this income that accumulates is taxed by the trust or the trustees; Similarly, in some countries, income earned through a limited partnership is taxed by the full partner in respect of that partner's share of that income, but is considered income of the limited partnership in respect of the limited partner's share of the income). To the extent that the organization or entity qualifies as a resident of a Contracting State, this paragraph will ensure that the benefits of the contract also apply to the share of income attributed to the organization or entity under the domestic law of that State (subject to any anti-abuse provisions such as the benefit limitation rule).
_________________________
1 See paragraphs 37-40 of the report "Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships", reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R(15)-1.
11 . Like other provisions of the Convention, this provision applies separately to each item of income of an organization or entity. Suppose, for example, that the document establishing the trust stipulates that all dividends received by the trust should be distributed among the beneficiary during its lifetime, but should accumulate subsequently. If one of the Contracting States considers that, in such a case, the beneficiary is taxed on the dividends distributed to that beneficiary, but that the trustees are taxed on the dividends that will accumulate, this paragraph will apply differently to these two categories of dividends, even if both types of dividends are received within one month.
12 By providing that the income to which it applies will be considered the income of a resident of a Contracting State for the purposes of the Convention, this paragraph ensures that the relevant income relates to that resident for the purposes of applying the various distributive rules of the Convention. Thus, depending on the nature of the income, this would allow income to be considered, for example, as "earned income" for the purposes of Articles 6, 13 and 17.,
"profits of the enterprise" for the purposes of Articles 7, 8 and 9 (see also paragraph 4 of the Commentary to Article 3) or dividends or interest "paid" for the purposes of Articles 10 and 11. The fact that income is considered to have been earned by a resident of a Contracting State for the purposes of the Convention also means that if the income constitutes a share of the income of an enterprise in which that resident participates, such income should be considered to be the income of an enterprise carried on by that resident (for example, for the purposes of defining an enterprise of a Contracting State in Articles 3 and paragraph 2 of Article 21).
13 Although this paragraph ensures that the various distributive rules of the Convention apply to the extent that the income of tax-transparent entities is considered under domestic law as the income of a resident of a Contracting State, this paragraph does not prejudge the question of whether the recipient is the owner-beneficiary of the relevant income. If, for example, a partnership that is transparent for tax purposes receives dividends as an agent or nominee holder of a person who is not a partner, the fact that the dividends can be considered as income of a resident of a Contracting State in accordance with the domestic law of that State does not prevent the Source State from considering that neither the partnership nor the partners are owners-beneficiaries of the dividends.
14 This paragraph applies only for the purposes of the Convention and therefore does not require a Contracting State to change the way in which it distributes income or characterizes organizations for the purposes of its domestic law. In the example given in paragraph 6 above, although paragraph 2 provides that for the purposes of Article 11, half of the interest should be treated as income of a resident of State B, this will only affect the maximum amount of tax that State A will be able to collect on the interest and will not change the fact that the tax of State A will be paid an organization. Thus, if we assume that the domestic law of State A provides for a 30 percent withheld tax on interest, the effect of paragraph 2 will be to significantly reduce the amount of tax that State A will levy on interest (so that half of the interest will be taxed at the rate of 30 percent and half at the rate of 10 percent in accordance with with an agreement between States A and B) and will not change the fact that the organization is a relevant taxpayer for the purposes of the domestic legislation of State A. In addition, this provision does not exhaustively address all contractual issues that may arise due to the legal nature of certain entities and arrangements, and therefore other provisions may need to be supplemented to address such issues (for example, a provision confirming that a trust can qualify as a resident of a Contracting State, despite the fact that in accordance with with the trust laws of many countries, a trust is not a "person").
15 As confirmed in paragraph 3, paragraph 2 in no way restricts the right of a State to tax its residents. This conclusion is consistent with how the double taxation agreements were interpreted in relation to partnerships (see paragraph 6.1 of this Commentary as amended after 2000 and before the inclusion of paragraph 3 in 2017). 16. However, paragraphs 2 and 3 do not limit the obligation of the Contracting States to exempt themselves from double taxation in accordance with Articles 23 A and 23 B, when the income of a resident of that State may be taxed by another State in accordance with the Convention. However, there may be cases where the same income is taxed by each Contracting State as income of one of its residents and where an exemption from double taxation is required in respect of tax paid by another person. If, for example, one of the Contracting States taxes the global income of an organization that is a resident of that State, while the other State considers that legal entity transparent for tax purposes and taxes the members of that organization who are residents of that other State on the corresponding share of income, the double taxation exemption will have to take into account the tax, which is paid by different taxpayers in the two Countries. In such a case, however, it will be important to determine, in accordance with Articles 23 A and 23 B, to what extent the income of a resident of one Contracting State "may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention (except in cases where these provisions permit taxation in that other State solely because the income it is also the income earned by a resident of this State [...])". In general, this requirement will lead to the fact that one State will have to grant double taxation exemption only to the extent that the provisions of the Convention allow another State to tax the relevant income as the State of origin or as the State where there is a permanent establishment to which this income belongs (see paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B).
Point 3
17 . Although some provisions of the Convention (for example, Articles 23 A and 23 B) are clearly intended to influence how a Contracting State taxes its residents, the purpose of most provisions of the Convention is to limit the right of a Contracting State to tax residents of another Contracting State. However, in some limited cases, it has been argued that certain provisions could be interpreted as limiting the right of a Contracting State to tax its residents in cases where this was not planned (see, for example, paragraph 81 below, which deals with the situation of controlled foreign companies).
18 . Paragraph 3 confirms the general principle that the Convention does not limit the right of a Contracting State to tax its residents, except in cases where this is provided for, and lists the provisions in respect of which this principle does not apply.
19 . The exceptions listed in this way are intended to cover all cases where the Convention provides that a Contracting State may be forced to provide contractual benefits to its residents (whether these or similar benefits are provided in accordance with the domestic law of that State). These provisions:
– Paragraph 3 of Article 7, which requires a Contracting State to provide an enterprise of that State with an appropriate adjustment, after an initial adjustment made by another Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7, to the amount of tax levied on the profits of a permanent establishment of the enterprise.
– Paragraph 2 of Article 9, which requires a Contracting State to provide an appropriate adjustment to an enterprise of that State after the initial adjustment made by the other Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 9, in the amount of the tax levied on the profits of the associated enterprise.
– Article 19, which may affect how a Contracting State taxes an individual who is a resident of that State if that individual earns income from services rendered to another Contracting State or its political subdivision or local authority.
– Article 20, which may affect how a Contracting State taxes an individual residing in that State if that person is also a student who meets the conditions of this Article.
– Articles 23 A and 23 B, which require a Contracting State to exempt its residents from double taxation in respect of income that the other State may tax in accordance with the Convention (including profits relating to a permanent establishment located in the other Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7).
– Article 24, which protects residents of a Contracting State from certain discriminatory taxation practices on the part of that State (for example, rules distinguishing between two persons on the basis of their nationality).
– Article 25, which allows residents of a Contracting State to require that the competent authority of that State deal with cases of taxation not in accordance with the Convention.
– Article 28, which may affect how a Contracting State taxes an individual residing in that State if that person is a member of a diplomatic mission or consular institution of another Contracting State.
20 . The list of exceptions included in paragraph 3 should include any other provision that the Contracting States may agree to include in their bilateral convention if it is expected that this provision will affect taxation by the Contracting State of its residents. For example, if the Contracting States agree, in accordance with paragraph 27 of the Commentary to Article 18, to include in their bilateral convention a provision according to which pensions and other payments made in accordance with the social security legislation of a Contracting State are taxable only in that State, they should include a reference to this provision in the list of exceptions included to point 3. Other examples include alternative provisions in paragraphs 23, 30, 37, 38 and 68 of the Commentary to Article 18, as these provisions provide benefits that are normally intended to be provided to an individual who participated in a foreign pension scheme before becoming a resident of a Contracting State.
21 The term "resident" used in paragraph 3 and throughout the Convention is defined in Article 4. If, in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 4, a person is considered to be a resident of both Contracting States on the basis of the domestic laws of those States, paragraphs 2 and 3 of this Article usually allow one State of residence to be defined for the purposes of the Convention. Paragraph 3 therefore does not apply to a natural or legal person who is a resident of one of the Contracting States under the laws of that State but who, for the purposes of the Convention, is considered to be a resident only of the other Contracting State.
Cross-border issues related to collective investment funds
22. Most countries have faced problems with internal taxation arising from groups of small investors who pool their funds into collective investment funds. In general, the purpose of such systems is to ensure neutrality between direct investments and investments through a collective investment fund. Although these systems usually work successfully when investors, collective investment funds, and investments are located in the same country, difficulties often arise when one or more of these parties or investments are located in different countries. These difficulties are discussed in the report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Issues, entitled
"Provision of contractual benefits in respect of income from collective investment funds",1 the main conclusions of which are presented below. For the purposes of the Report and for this discussion, the term "collective investment funds" is limited to funds that are widespread, have a diversified portfolio of securities, and are subject to investor protection laws in the country in which they are established.
Application of the convention to collective investment funds
23. The main question that arises in a cross-border context is whether a collective investment fund should qualify for the benefits of the Convention as such. In order to do this in accordance with the treaties, which, like the Convention, do not contain a special provision concerning collective investment funds, the collective investment fund must qualify as a "person" who is
a "resident" of a Contracting State, and with respect to the application of Articles 10 and 11 is the "beneficial owner" of the income received.
24. Determining whether a collective investment fund should be considered a "person" begins with the legal form of a collective investment fund, which varies significantly from country to country and for different types of funds. In many countries, most collective investment funds are in the form of a company. In others, collective investment funds are usually trusts. Thirdly, many collective investment funds are simple contractual entities or a form of joint ownership. In most cases, collective investment funds will be considered as a taxpayer or a "person" for the purposes of the tax legislation of the State in which it is established; for example, in some countries where a collective investment fund is usually created in the form of a trust, the trust itself, or the trustees acting collectively in their capacity as such, are considered for internal tax purposes. legislation as taxpayers or individuals. Taking into account the broad meaning given to the term "person", the fact that the tax legislation of the country in which such a collective investment fund is established treats it as a taxpayer indicates that for the purposes of the agreement, the collective investment fund is
"face." Contracting States wishing to explicitly clarify that in these circumstances such collective investment funds are persons for the purposes of their conventions may bilaterally agree to change the definition of "persons" to include them.
25. Whether a collective investment fund is a "resident" of a Contracting State does not depend on its legal form (provided that it qualifies as a person), but on its tax regime in the State in which it is established. Although the ongoing goal of national collective investment fund regimes is to ensure that there is only one level of tax, either at the level of the collective investment fund or at the investor level, there are a number of different ways in which States achieve this goal. In some States, holders of shares in a collective investment fund, rather than the collective investment fund itself, are required to tax the income earned by such a collective investment fund. Such a tax-transparent collective investment fund will not be considered as a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established, since it is not subject to taxation in that State.
______________________________
1 Is reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R(24)-1.
26 . In contrast, in other States, a collective investment fund is taxable in principle, but its income may be completely exempt from taxes, for example, if the collective investment fund meets certain criteria regarding its purpose, activity or activities, which may include minimum allocation requirements, its sources of income, and sometimes its fields of activity. More often than not, collective investment funds are subject to taxation, but the tax base is reduced in many different ways with reference to payments made to investors. Deductions for distribution usually mean that the tax is not actually paid. In other Countries, collective investment funds are taxed at a special low tax rate. Finally, some States fully tax collective investment funds, but with integration at the investor level in order to avoid double taxation of income from collective investment funds. For those countries that adhere to the view reflected in paragraph 8.11 of the Commentary to Article 4 that a person may be subject to taxation even if the State in which he is established does not levy taxes, the collective investment fund will be considered as a resident of the State in which it is established in all these cases, because the fund collective investment is subject to comprehensive taxation in this State. Even if the income of a collective investment fund is taxed at a zero rate or is exempt from tax, the requirements that should be considered permanent can be met if the requirements for obtaining such a lower rate or tax exemption are sufficiently stringent.
27 . Those countries that adhere to the alternative view reflected in paragraph 8.12 of the Commentary to Article 4, that a tax-exempt organization is therefore not taxable, cannot consider some or all of the collective investment funds described in the previous paragraph as residents of the State in which they were established. States adhering to the latter view and those States negotiating with such States are encouraged to address this issue in their bilateral negotiations.
28 . Some countries doubt whether a collective investment fund, even if it is an "individual" and a "resident", can be considered the owner-beneficiary of the income received. Since a "collective investment fund", as defined in paragraph 22 above, must be widespread, have a diversified portfolio of securities and be subject to investor protection laws in the country in which it is established, such a collective investment fund or its managers often perform important functions in relation to investments and asset management of a collective investment fund. Moreover, the position of an investor in a collective investment fund differs significantly, both from a legal and economic point of view, from the position of an investor who owns the underlying assets, so it would be inappropriate to consider an investor in such a collective investment fund as the owner-beneficiary of the income received by the collective investment fund. Accordingly, an instrument that meets the definition of a widespread collective investment fund will also be considered as the beneficial owner of the dividends and interest received if the managers of the collective investment fund have broad powers to manage assets that generate such income (except in cases where an individual who is a resident of this State, who would receive income under the same conditions). under certain circumstances, it would not be considered its beneficial owner).
29 . Since these principles are necessarily general, their application to a particular type of collective investment fund may not be clear to the collective investment fund, investors, and intermediaries. Any uncertainty about the right to participate in the agreement is particularly problematic for the collective investment fund, which must take into account the amounts expected to be received, including any tax benefits provided for by the agreement, when calculating the net asset value ("net asset value"). The ABA, which is usually calculated daily, is the basis for prices used for contributions and repayments. If the income tax benefits eventually received by the collective investment fund do not match its initial assumptions about the amount and timing of such income tax benefits, there will be a discrepancy between the actual value of assets and the value of net assets used by investors who have bought, sold or redeemed their shares in the collective investment fund.
30 . In order to provide greater certainty in accordance with existing treaties, the tax authorities may wish to reach a mutual agreement clarifying the treatment of certain types of collective investment funds in their respective States. As for some types of collective investment funds, such a mutual agreement may simply confirm that the collective investment fund meets the technical requirements discussed above and is therefore eligible for benefits. In other cases, a mutual agreement could provide the collective investment fund with an administratively feasible way to make claims against eligible investors (see the discussion of this issue in paragraphs 36-40 of the report "Provision of contractual benefits in respect of income from collective Investment funds"). Of course, a mutual agreement could not reduce the benefits that would otherwise be available to the collective investment fund in accordance with the terms of the agreement.
Policy issues arising from the current approach to collective investment funds
31 . The same circumstances suggest that the parties to the contract negotiations explicitly considered the approach to collective investment funds. Thus, even if it turns out that collective investment funds in each of the Contracting States will be eligible for benefits, it may be advisable to publicly confirm this position (for example, through an exchange of letters) in order to ensure certainty. It may also be appropriate to explicitly provide for contractual rights for collective investment funds, including, for example, the following provision:
Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a collective investment fund established in one Contracting State and receiving income arising in the other Contracting State shall, for the purposes of applying the Convention to such income, be treated as an individual who is a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established and as the beneficial owner of the income it receives (provided that if an individual who is a resident of the first-mentioned State received income under the same circumstances, such an individual would be considered its beneficial owner). For the purposes of this paragraph, the term "collective investment fund" means, in the case of [State A], [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], as well as any other investment fund, organization or entity established in any of the Contracting States, which the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to consider as the collective investment fund for the purposes of this paragraph.
32. However, when negotiating new treaties or amendments to existing treaties, the Contracting States will not be limited to clarifying the results of the application of other contractual provisions to collective investment funds, but may modify these results to the extent necessary to achieve policy objectives. For example, in the context of a specific bilateral agreement, technical analysis may lead to the fact that collective investment funds located in one of the Contracting States are eligible for benefits, while collective investment funds in the other Contracting State are not. This may make the contract unbalanced, although whether this is actually the case will depend on the specific circumstances. If this is the case, the Contracting States should try to reach an equitable solution. If the practical result in each of the Contracting States is that the majority of collective investment funds do not actually pay taxes, then the Contracting States should try to overcome differences in legal form that could otherwise lead to individuals in one State being eligible for benefits, while those in the other others will be deprived of them. On the other hand, differences in the legal form and tax regime in the two Contracting States may mean that it is appropriate to treat collective investment funds in the two States differently. When comparing the taxation of collective investment funds in the two States, taxation in the source State and at the investor level should be taken into account, and not just taxation of the collective investment fund itself. The goal is to achieve neutrality between direct investment and investments through collective investment funds in an international context, just as the goal of most domestic regulations regarding the treatment of collective investment funds is to achieve such neutrality in a fully domestic context. 33. A Contracting State may also wish to consider whether the existing contractual provisions are sufficient to prevent the potential use of collective investment funds for personal gain. It is quite possible that a collective investment fund will be able to meet all the requirements to qualify for contractual benefits on its own, even if in practice its income is not heavily taxed or not taxed at all. In this case, the collective investment fund may provide residents of third countries with the opportunity to receive contractual benefits that would not be available if they invested directly. Accordingly, it may be advisable to limit the benefits that might otherwise be available to such a collective investment fund, either through generally applicable rules against abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements (as discussed below in the section "Misuse of the Convention"), or through a special provision relating to collective investment funds.
34.In deciding whether such a provision is necessary, the Contracting States will want to consider the economic characteristics, including the potential for abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements, represented by the various types of collective investment funds prevailing in each of the Contracting States. For example, a collective investment fund that is not subject to taxation in the State in which it is established may pose a greater risk of abusing the provisions of international tax agreements than one in which the collective investment fund itself is subject to taxation at the organizational level or where payments to non-resident investors are subject to withholding tax.
Possible provisions changing the approach to collective investment funds
35. If the Contracting States have agreed that a specific provision concerning the collective investment fund is necessary to solve the problems described in paragraphs 32-34, they may include the following provision in the bilateral agreement:
(a) Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a collective investment fund established in one Contracting State and receiving income arising in the other Contracting State shall, for the purposes of the application of the Convention to such income, be treated as an individual who is a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established and as the beneficial owner of the income that it receives (provided that if an individual who is a resident of the first-mentioned State had received income under the same circumstances, such an individual would be considered its beneficial owner), but only to the extent that the beneficial shares in the collective investment mechanism belong to the respective beneficiaries.
b) For the purposes of this paragraph:
(i) the term "collective investment fund" means, in the case of [State A], [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], as well as any other investment fund, organization or entity established in any of the Contracting States, which the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to consider as a fund collective investment for the purposes of this paragraph; and
(ii) the term "relevant beneficiary" means a resident of the Contracting State in which the collective investment fund is established and a resident of any other State with which the Contracting State in which the income arises has an income tax agreement that provides for an effective and comprehensive exchange of information that, if he had received a specific item of income, in respect of which benefits are requested in accordance with this Convention, in accordance with this Convention or in accordance with the domestic law of the Contracting State in which the income arises, would be entitled to a tax rate in respect of that income item that is at least as low as the rate declared by the collective investment fund in respect of that income item in accordance with this Convention.
36 . It is expected that the Contracting States will provide, in subsection (b) (i), specific cross-references to the relevant provisions of tax or securities legislation relating to collective investment funds. When deciding which regime should be applied to specific collective investment funds, Contracting States should take into account the policy considerations described above. The negotiators may agree that the economic differences in approaches to collective investment funds in the two Contracting States or even in one Contracting State justify the differential treatment in the agreement for the avoidance of double taxation. In this case, some combination of the provisions of this section may be included in the contract.
37 . The result of allowing benefits for a collective investment fund to the extent that it belongs to the "relevant beneficiaries" as defined in subsection (b) (ii) is to ensure that investors who would be eligible for benefits in respect of income received from the Source State if they received income directly, did not find themselves in a worse position by investing through a collective investment fund located in a third country. Thus, this approach serves the purpose of neutrality between direct investments and investments through collective investment funds. This also reduces the risk of double taxation between the Source State and the investor's State of Residence, if there is a double taxation avoidance agreement between them. This is beneficial for investors, especially from smaller countries, which will therefore receive a wider range of investment instruments. It also increases economies of scale, which is the main economic advantage of investing through collective investment funds. Finally, the application of this approach significantly simplifies compliance verification procedures. In many cases, almost all investors in collective investment funds will be "relevant beneficiaries", given the degree of coverage of bilateral agreements and the fact that the rates in these agreements are almost always 10-15 percent of the portfolio's dividends.
38. At the same time, this provision does not allow investors to use collective investment funds to achieve a better position in the double taxation agreement than they could achieve through direct investment. This is achieved by comparing the rates in determining the "appropriate beneficiary". Accordingly, a comparison is appropriate between the rate declared by the collective investment fund and the rate that the investor could demand if he received income directly. For example, suppose that a collective investment fund established in State B receives dividends from a company resident in State A. Sixty-five percent of the investors in the collective investment fund are individual residents of State B; ten percent are pension funds established in State C, and 25 percent are individual residents of State C. According to the agreement, for the Avoidance of Double Taxation A-B, portfolio dividends are subject to a maximum withholding tax rate of ten percent. In accordance with the agreement for the avoidance of double taxation A-C, pension funds are exempt from taxation in the source State, and dividends from other portfolios are taxed at a maximum tax rate of 15 percent. Both the A-B and A-C treaties include effective and comprehensive information exchange provisions. Based on these facts, 75 percent of the investors in the collective investment fund - individual residents of State B and pension funds established in State C - are the relevant beneficiaries.
39 . The source State may also be concerned about the potential tax deferral that may arise in relation to a collective investment fund that is tax-free or low-taxed and can accumulate its income rather than distribute it on a current basis. Such States may be tempted to limit the benefits for the collective investment fund to the proportion of the collective investment fund's investors who are currently taxed on their share of the collective investment fund's income. However, it turned out that this approach is difficult to apply in practice to widespread collective investment funds. Those States that are concerned about the possibility of such a delay may wish to agree on provisions that extend benefits only to those collective investment funds that are currently required to distribute profits. However, other States may be less concerned about the possibility of a delay. They may hold the view that even if an investor is currently not taxed on income earned by the collective investment fund, he will eventually be taxed either on distribution or on any capital gains if he sells his share in the collective investment fund before the collective investment fund distributes the income. These States may wish to agree on provisions that provide benefits for collective investment funds, even if they are not required to allocate their income on a recurring basis. Moreover, in many Countries, the tax rate on investment income is not much higher than the rate of deduction of dividends under the contract, therefore, the tax deferral in the State of residence, if any, will be insignificant due to receiving such income through an investment fund, rather than directly. In addition, many States have taken steps to ensure current taxation of investment income earned by their residents through investment funds, regardless of whether the funds accumulate this income, which further reduces the likelihood of such a delay. When considering an approach to collective investment funds that are not currently required to distribute income, States may want to consider whether these or other factors address the problems described above so that the restrictions described here are not actually necessary.
40 . Some States believe that accounting for all eligible investors, including investors in third Countries, will change the bilateral nature of double taxation agreements. These States may choose to grant contractual benefits to collective investment funds only to the extent that the investors in the collective investment funds are residents of the Contracting State in which such collective investment funds are established. In this case, the provision will be formulated as follows:
(a) Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a collective investment fund established in one Contracting State and receiving income arising in the other Contracting State shall, for the purposes of the application of the Convention to such income, be treated as an individual who is a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established and as the beneficial owner of the income that it receives (provided that if an individual who is a resident of the first-mentioned State had received income under the same circumstances, such an individual would be considered its beneficial owner), but only to the extent that the beneficial shares in the collective investment mechanism belong to residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment fund is established.
b) For the purposes of this paragraph, the term "collective investment fund" means, in the case of [State A], [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], as well as any other investment fund, organization or entity established in any of the Contracting States, which the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to consider as the collective investment fund for the purposes of this paragraph.
41 . Although the purely proportional approach outlined in paragraphs 35 and 40 protects against abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements, it can also impose a significant administrative burden, since the collective investment fund tries to determine the rights of each investor under the agreement. A Contracting State may decide that the fact that a significant part of the investors of the collective investment fund are eligible to participate in the contract is an adequate protection against abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements, and thus it is advisable to set a threshold of ownership above which benefits will be provided for all income received by the collective investment fund. The inclusion of such a threshold would also reduce some of the procedural difficulties that might otherwise arise. Therefore, if desired, the following sentence may be added at the end of subparagraph (a):
However, if at least [ ] percent of the beneficial interests in the collective investment fund belong to [the relevant beneficiaries] [residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment fund is established], the collective investment fund should be considered as an individual who is a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established and is the beneficiary owner of all income. which it receives (provided that if an individual who is a resident of the first-mentioned State, received income under the same circumstances, such an individual would be considered its beneficial owner).
42 . In some cases, Contracting States may wish to adopt a different approach from that proposed in paragraphs 31, 35 and 40 with respect to certain types of collective investment funds, and consider the collective investment fund as making claims on behalf of investors rather than on its own behalf. This may be true, for example, if a significant percentage of the owners of shares in a collective investment fund as a whole or a class of shares are pension funds that are exempt from tax in the country of origin in accordance with the terms of the relevant agreement, similar to that described in paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18. To ensure that investors do not lose the benefits of the preferential rates to which they would be entitled if they invested directly, the Contracting States could agree to the following provision with respect to such collective investment funds (although probably adopting one of the approaches described in paragraphs 31, 35 or 40 for other types of collective investment funds):
(a) The collective investment fund described in subparagraph (c), which is established in one Contracting State and receives income arising in the other Contracting State, is not considered to be a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established, but may claim tax benefits, exemptions or other benefits on behalf of the owners of beneficial interests in the collective investment fund; which would be available to such owners in accordance with this Convention if they received such income directly.
(b) A collective investment fund may not file claims for benefits in accordance with subparagraph (a) on behalf of any beneficial owner in such a collective investment fund if the owner himself has filed an individual claim for benefits in respect of income earned by the collective investment fund.
c) In the case of [State A], a [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], as well as any other investment fund, this paragraph applies to an organization or entity established in any Contracting State to which the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to apply this paragraph.
However, this provision restricts the collective investment fund to making claims on behalf of residents of the same Contracting State in which such a collective investment fund is established. If, for the reasons described in paragraph 37, the Contracting States consider it desirable to allow the collective investment fund to make claims on behalf of eligible residents of third States, this may be achieved by replacing the words "this Convention" in subparagraph (a) with "any Convention to which another Contracting State is a Party". If, as expected, the Contracting States agree that the approach provided for in this paragraph will apply only to certain types of collective investment funds, it will be necessary to ensure that the types of collective investment funds listed in subparagraph (c) do not include any of the types of collective investment funds listed in the more general provision, such as like points 31, 35 or 40. Thus, the regime of a collective investment fund of a certain type will be fixed, not elective. Countries wishing to allow individual collective investment funds, or collective investment funds as a whole, or with respect to one or more classes of shares in collective investment funds to choose their treatment may amend the paragraph accordingly.
43 . In accordance with the approach outlined in paragraphs 35 and 40 or paragraph 42, the collective investment fund will need to determine the percentage of equity holders who would be eligible for benefits if they invested directly. Since ownership of shares in the collective investment fund changes regularly, and such ownership is often carried out through intermediaries, the collective investment fund and its managers often do not themselves know the names and contractual status of the beneficial owners of the shares. It would be impractical for a collective investment fund to collect such information from relevant intermediaries on a daily basis. Accordingly, Contracting States should be prepared to adopt practical and reliable approaches that do not require such daily monitoring.
44 . For example, in many countries, the collective investment industry is mainly domestic, where the vast majority of investors live in the country in which such a collective investment fund is established. In some cases, tax regulations discourage foreign investment by levying withholding income taxes on distributions, or securities laws severely restrict supply to non-residents. Governments should consider whether these or other circumstances provide sufficient protection against investments by residents of third countries who are not eligible to participate in the agreement. For example, it may be appropriate to assume that a collective investment fund belongs to residents of the State in which it is established if the collective investment fund has a limited distribution of its shares or units in the State in which it is established or in other States that provide similar benefits in their contracts with the Source State.
45 . In other cases, shares in the collective investment fund are offered to investors in many countries. Although the identity of individual investors will change on a daily basis, the proportion of investors in the collective investment fund eligible to participate in the agreement is likely to change relatively slowly. Accordingly, it would be reasonable to require the collective investment fund to collect information from other intermediaries on the specified dates, allowing the collective investment fund to determine the proportion of investors eligible to participate in the agreement. This information may be required at the end of a calendar or financial year, or if market conditions suggest a high turnover of property. It may be required more often, but not more often than at the end of each calendar quarter. Then the collective investment fund can file a claim based on the average amount of these amounts over an agreed period of time. When adopting such procedures, evaluation dates should be chosen with care so that the collective investment fund has enough time to update the information it provides to other payers so that the correct amount is retained at the beginning of each relevant period.
46 . An alternative approach would provide that a collective investment fund that is traded on the market in the Contracting State in which it is established will be eligible for contractual benefits regardless of the place of residence of its investors. This provision was justified by the fact that a collective investment fund traded on the market cannot be effectively used to abuse the provisions of international tax agreements, since the shareholders or holders of shares of such a collective investment fund cannot individually exercise control over it. The relevant provision could read as follows:
(a) Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Convention, a collective investment fund established in one Contracting State and receiving income arising in the other Contracting State shall, for the purposes of the application of the Convention to such income, be treated as an individual who is a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established and as the beneficial owner of the income that it receives (provided that if an individual who is a resident of the first-mentioned State had received income under the same circumstances, such an individual would be considered its beneficial owner) if the main class of shares or units in a collective investment fund is registered and regularly traded on a regulated stock exchange in that State.
b) For the purposes of this paragraph, the term "collective investment fund" means, in the case of [State A], [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], as well as any other investment fund, organization or entity established in any of the Contracting States, which the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to consider as the collective investment fund for the purposes of this paragraph.
47 . Each of the provisions of paragraphs 31, 35, 40 and 46 treats the collective investment fund as a resident and beneficiary owner of the income it receives for the purposes of applying the Convention to such income, which is characterized by the simplicity of providing one reduced retention rate for each type of income. However, as confirmed by paragraph 3 of this Article, these provisions in no way limit the right of the Source State to tax its residents who are investors in the collective investment fund. Obviously, these provisions are intended to regulate the taxation of the source of income of collective investment funds, and not the taxation of its investors based on the principle of residency.
48 . In addition, each of these provisions is intended only to ensure that the specific characteristics of the collective investment fund do not lead to it being treated differently from the beneficial owner of the income received. Thus, the collective investment fund will be considered as the owner-beneficiary of all income received. However, this provision is not intended to place the collective investment fund in a different or better position than other investors with respect to aspects of the beneficial ownership requirement that are unrelated to the collective investment fund's status as such. Accordingly, if an individual receiving an income item under certain circumstances will not be considered the beneficial owner of this income, a collective investment fund receiving this income under the same circumstances cannot be considered the beneficial owner of the income. This result is confirmed by the bracketing, which restricts the application of the provision to situations in which an individual would be considered the owner-beneficiary of income under the same circumstances.
Application of the Convention to States, their subdivisions and enterprises under full ownership
49 . Paragraph 1 of Article 4 provides that the Contracting States themselves, their administrative-territorial entities and local authorities are included in the definition of "resident of a Contracting State" and, therefore, are entitled to the benefits of the Convention (paragraph 8.4 of the Commentary to Article 4 explains that the inclusion of these words in 1995 confirmed the previous common understanding of most Countries -members).
50 . However, problems may arise in the case of organizations established and wholly owned by the State, one of its administrative-territorial entities, or local authorities. Some of these organizations may receive significant income from other countries, and therefore it may be important to determine whether double taxation agreements apply to them (for example, in the case of sovereign investment funds: see paragraph
8.5 Comments to Article 4). In many cases, these organizations are completely exempt from taxes, and the question may arise as to whether they are eligible for benefits under double taxation avoidance agreements concluded by the State in which they were established. To clarify this issue, some States are changing the definition of "resident of a Contracting State" in paragraph 1 of Article 4 and include in this definition
"legally approved body", "agency or institution" or "legal entity under public law" [personne morale de droit public] A State, political subdivision, or local government body, which will thus cover fully owned enterprises that are not considered part of the State or its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities.
51 . In addition, many States include specific provisions in their bilateral conventions that grant exemptions to other States and certain State-owned entities, such as central banks, in respect of certain items of income, such as interest (see paragraph 13.2 of the Commentary to Article 10 and paragraph
7.4 Comments to Article 11). The provisions of treaties granting tax exemption in respect of income of pension funds (see paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18) may similarly apply to pension funds that are wholly owned by the State, depending on the wording of these provisions and the nature of the fund.
52 . However, the application of the Convention to each Contracting State, its political subdivisions and local authorities (and their statutory bodies, agencies or institutions in the case of bilateral treaties that apply to such entities) should not be interpreted as affecting in any way the possible application by each State of the principle of sovereign immunity in accordance with customary international law. According to this principle, a sovereign State (including its organs, property and activities), as a rule, has immunity from the jurisdiction of the courts of another sovereign State. However, there is no consensus on the exact limits of the principle of sovereign immunity at the international level. Most States, for example, do not recognize that the principle applies to commercial activities, and many States do not recognize any application of this principle in tax matters. Thus, there are significant differences between States in the extent to which this principle applies to taxation. Even among States that recognize its possible application in tax matters, some apply it only to the extent that it is incorporated into domestic law, while others apply it as customary international law, but subject to important limitations. The Convention does not prejudge the question of whether and to what extent the principle of sovereign immunity applies to persons covered by Article 1 and taxes covered by Article 2, and therefore each Contracting State has the right to apply its own interpretation of this principle, provided that the final taxation, if any, is consistent with the provisions of its bilateral tax agreements.
53 . States often take various factors into account when considering whether and to what extent tax benefits should be provided through specific treaty provisions or domestic legislation, or through the application of the doctrine of sovereign immunity to income earned by other States, their political subdivisions, local governments or their statutory bodies, agencies or institutions. These factors may include, for example, the question of whether this type of income will be exempt from taxation on a reciprocal basis, whether income will be received from government rather than commercial activities, whether the recipient's assets and income will be used for public purposes, regardless of whether there is a possibility that they may benefit. to a non-governmental person and whether income has been received from a portfolio or direct investments.
Improper use of the Convention
54 . The main purpose of the double taxation conventions is to facilitate, by eliminating international double taxation, the exchange of goods and services, as well as the movement of capital and people. As confirmed in the preamble to this Convention, this is also part of the objectives of the tax conventions for the prevention and avoidance of tax evasion.
55 . The expansion of the network of tax conventions increases the risk of abuse by facilitating the use of mechanisms aimed at benefiting both from the tax benefits available under certain national laws and from the tax benefits provided by these conventions.
56 . This may be the case, for example, if an individual (regardless of whether he is a resident of a Contracting State) acts through a legal entity established in the State primarily to receive contractual benefits that will not be available directly. Another case may be an individual who has both his permanent place of residence and all his economic interests in a Contracting State, including a significant stake in a company in that State, and who, in order to sell shares and avoid taxation of capital gains from alienation in that State (by virtue of paragraph 5 of Article 13) transfers his permanent residence to another Contracting State, where such income is subject to little or no tax.
Solving the problem of tax evasion through tax agreements
57. Paragraph 9 of Article 29 and the special contractual rules on combating abuse included in tax agreements are aimed at these and other transactions and agreements concluded in order to obtain benefits under the contract in inappropriate circumstances. However, if the tax convention does not include such rules, the question may arise whether the benefits of the tax convention should be provided for transactions that violate the provisions of this convention.
58 . Many States address this issue, taking into account the fact that taxes are ultimately levied in accordance with the provisions of domestic legislation, limited (and in some rare cases expanded) by the provisions of tax agreements. Thus, any abuse of the provisions of the tax convention can also be characterized as an abuse of the provisions of the domestic legislation under which the tax will be levied. For these States, the question arises whether the provisions of the tax agreements may prevent the application of the provisions of domestic legislation on combating abuse, which is a question that is addressed in paragraphs 66-80 below. As explained in these paragraphs, as a rule, there are no contradictions between such rules and the provisions of tax agreements.
59 . Other States prefer to consider some violations as violations of the convention itself rather than domestic legislation. However, these States believe that the proper structure of tax agreements allows them to ignore illegal transactions, such as those that are concluded in order to obtain unforeseen benefits in accordance with the provisions of these agreements. This interpretation follows from the purpose of tax agreements, as well as the obligation to interpret them in good faith (see Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties).
60 . Thus, according to both approaches, States are not required to provide benefits provided for by the Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation in cases where the agreements reached violate the provisions of the tax agreement.
61 . However, it is important to note that one should not frivolously assume that the taxpayer is performing the above-mentioned illegal operations. The guiding principle is that the benefits of the convention for the Avoidance of double taxation should not be available if the main purpose of concluding certain transactions or arrangements was to ensure a more favorable tax situation and obtaining this more favorable treatment in these circumstances would be contrary to the purpose of the relevant provisions. This principle applies regardless of the provisions of paragraph 9 of Article 29, which only confirm it.
62 . The possible application of these principles or paragraph 9 of Article 29 does not mean that there is no need to include specific provisions in tax agreements aimed at preventing certain forms of tax evasion. In cases where specific avoidance methods have been identified or where the use of such methods is particularly problematic, it will often be useful to add provisions to the Convention that focus directly on the relevant avoidance strategy. In addition, this will be necessary if a State that adheres to the point of view set out in paragraph 58 above considers that its domestic legislation lacks the rules or principles for preventing evasion necessary for the proper application of such a strategy.
63 . For example, some forms of tax evasion are already explicitly addressed in the Convention, for example by introducing the concept of "beneficial owner" (in Articles 10, 11 and 12) and special provisions such as paragraph 2 of Article 17 concerning so-called artistic companies. Similar issues are also mentioned in the Comments to Article 10 (paragraphs 17 and 22), Article 11 (paragraph 12) and Article 12 (paragraph 7).
64 .In addition, in some cases, claims for contractual benefits from subsidiaries, in particular companies established in offshore zones or enjoying harmful preferential treatment, may be denied if a thorough examination of the facts and circumstances of the case shows that the location of the subsidiary's permanent executive body is not in its intended State of residence., rather, in the State of residence of the parent company, to make her a resident of this latter State for domestic legislation and contractual purposes (this will be relevant if the domestic law of the State uses the place of management of a legal entity or a similar criterion to determine its place of residence/stay).
65 . A careful examination of the facts and circumstances of the case may also show that the subsidiary was managed in the State of residence of its parent company in such a way that the subsidiary had a permanent establishment (for example, having a place of management) in that State, to which all or a significant part of the profits could be properly attributed.
Solving the problem of tax evasion through internal rules against tax evasion and legal doctrines
66 . Internal rules against tax evasion and legal doctrines can also be used to review transactions and arrangements entered into to obtain contractual benefits in inappropriate circumstances. These rules and doctrines may also apply to situations where transactions or arrangements are entered into with the aim of violating both domestic legislation and tax agreements.
67 . For these reasons, internal rules against tax evasion and legal doctrines play an important role in preventing contractual benefits from being granted in inappropriate circumstances. However, the application of such internal rules and doctrines against tax evasion raises the issue of possible conflicts with the provisions of treaties, in particular when the provisions of the treaty are used to facilitate the abuse of domestic legislation (for example, when it is claimed that the provisions of the treaty protect the taxpayer from the application of certain internal rules against tax evasion). This issue is discussed below in relation to specific legislative rules against tax evasion, general legislative rules against tax evasion, and judicial doctrines.
Special legislative rules against tax evasion
68. Tax authorities seeking to address the problem of improper use of the double taxation agreement may first consider applying specific anti-tax evasion rules included in their national tax legislation.
69 . Many of the specific rules contained in domestic legislation against tax evasion are mainly applied in international situations and may be relevant to the application of double taxation agreements. For example, the rules for countering insufficient capitalization may be applied to limit the deduction of interest payments that reduce the base for residents of the treaty's member countries.; transfer pricing rules (even if they are not primarily developed as rules against tax evasion) can prevent the artificial transfer of income from a resident enterprise to an enterprise that is a resident of a contracting state; exit tax rules can prevent capital gains tax evasion by changing one's place of residence to realization of tax-exempt capital gains; Rules for excluding dividends may prevent the evasion of domestic taxes on dividends at the source of payment through operations aimed at converting dividends into tax-exempt capital gains; and rules aimed at countering fraudulent schemes may prevent certain termination transactions involving the use of fraudulent schemes.
70 . As a rule, if the application of the provisions of national legislation and the provisions of agreements on the avoidance of double taxation gives contradictory results, it is assumed that the provisions of agreements on the avoidance of double taxation prevail. This is a logical consequence of the "pacta sunt servanda" principle included in Article 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. Thus, if the application of specific rules against tax evasion contained in domestic legislation should lead to a tax regime that does not comply with the provisions of the agreement for the avoidance of double taxation and contradicts the provisions of this treaty, the provisions of such an agreement shall prevail in accordance with public international law. 17
71 . However, as explained below, such conflicts can often be avoided, and each case needs to be analyzed taking into account specific circumstances.
72 . First, the contract may explicitly authorize the application of certain types of internal rules against tax evasion. For example, Article 9 explicitly authorizes the application of internal rules in the circumstances defined by this Article. In addition, many treaties contain specific provisions indicating that there is no conflict or allowing the application of internal rules even in the event of conflict. This will be the case, for example, with a treaty rule that explicitly authorizes the application of the rule of insufficient capitalization contained in the domestic legislation of one or both Contracting States.
73 . Secondly, many provisions of the Convention depend on the application of domestic legislation. This applies, for example, to determining a person's residence (see paragraph 1 of Article 4), determining what constitutes immovable property (see paragraph 2 of Article 6), and determining when income from corporate rights can be considered as dividends (see paragraph 3 of Article 10). More generally, Article 3, paragraph 2, gives importance to domestic rules for the purpose of defining the meanings of terms that are not defined in the Convention. Therefore, in many cases, the application of specific anti-tax evasion rules contained in domestic legislation will influence how the provisions of the treaty are applied rather than produce contradictory results. This will be the case, for example, if a provision of domestic law considers the profits earned by a shareholder when a company repurchases part of its shares as dividends: although such a buyback can be considered an alienation for the purposes of paragraph 5 of Article 13, paragraph 28 of the Commentary to Article 10 recognizes that such profits will amount to dividends for the purposes of Article 10, if, according to domestic legislation, profits are considered as dividends.
_____________________________________
17 In accordance with article 60 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, "a substantial violation by one of the parties to a bilateral treaty gives the other party the right to invoke the violation as a basis for termination of the treaty or the total or partial suspension of its operation."
74. Thirdly, the application of the provisions of the agreement for the avoidance of double taxation in cases of abuse of these provisions may be refused in accordance with paragraph 9 of Article 29 or, in the case of a treaty that does not include this paragraph, in accordance with the principles set out in paragraphs 60 and 61 above. In this case, there will be no conflict with the provisions of the agreement if the benefits under the agreement are denied both in accordance with paragraph 9 of Article 29 (or the principles set out in paragraphs 60 and 61 above) and with the relevant internal rules against tax evasion. However, internal rules against tax evasion are often developed based on objective facts, such as a certain level of ownership of shares or a certain ratio of borrowed funds to equity. While this facilitates their application and provides greater certainty, it can sometimes lead to the application of such a rule in cases where the rule contradicts a provision of the Convention and where Article 29, paragraph 9, does not apply to negate the benefits of this provision (and where the principles of paragraphs 60 and 61 above also do not apply). In this case, the Convention will not allow the application of internal rules to the extent of conflict. An example of such a case would be a situation where a rule of domestic law adopted by State A to prevent temporary change of residence for tax purposes would provide for taxation of an individual who is a resident of State B in respect of profits from the alienation of property located in a third State, if that individual was a resident of State A at the time of acquisition was a resident of State A for at least seven of the 10 years preceding such alienation. In such a case, to the extent that paragraph 5 of Article 13 prevents that person from being taxed by State A upon alienation of property, the Convention will prevent the application of this internal rule, unless the benefits under paragraph 5 of Article 13 can be denied in that particular case in accordance with paragraph 9 of Article 29 or the principles of paragraphs 60 and 61 above. 75. Fourth, the application of the provisions of the double taxation agreement may be refused in accordance with judicial doctrines or principles applicable to the interpretation of the treaty (see paragraph 78 below). In this case, there will be no conflict with the provisions of the agreement if the benefits associated with it are denied both with the correct interpretation of the agreement and as a result of the application of domestic rules against tax evasion. Let's assume, for example, that the domestic legislation of State A provides for taxation of profits earned from the alienation of shares in a domestic company in which the alienating person owns more than 25 percent of the capital, if this alienator was a resident of State A for at least seven of the 10 years preceding the alienation. For 2 years, a person who has been a resident of State A for the previous 10 years becomes a resident of State B. Shortly after this person becomes a resident of State B, he sells all the shares of a small company that he previously established in State A. However, the facts show that all the components of the sale were completed in year 1, that at that time the buyer provided the seller with an interest-free "loan" corresponding to the sale price, that the buyer cancelled the loan when the shares were sold to him during year 2, and that the buyer exercised de facto control over the company with 1 year old. Despite the fact that otherwise the profit from the sale of shares could fall under paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the agreement between State A and State B, the circumstances of the transfer of shares are such that the alienation during the 2nd year is fiction in the meaning given to this term by the courts of State A. In this case, if the doctrine of a fictitious transaction developed by the courts of State A does not contradict the rules of treaty interpretation, it will be possible to apply this doctrine in interpreting paragraph 5 of Article 13 of the treaty between State A and State B, which will allow State A to tax the relevant profits in accordance with the rule of domestic law.
General legislative provisions against tax evasion
76. Many countries have incorporated general anti-tax evasion legislation into their domestic legislation, designed to prevent collusion that is not properly addressed through specific anti-tax evasion rules or legal doctrines.
77 . The application of such general rules against tax evasion also raises the issue of a possible conflict with the provisions of the agreement on the avoidance of double taxation. However, in the vast majority of cases, such a conflict does not arise. First, conflicts will be prevented for reasons similar to those described in paragraphs 72 and 73 above. In addition, if the main aspects of these general internal rules against tax evasion comply with the principle of paragraph 61 above and, therefore, are similar to the main aspects of paragraph 9 of Article 29, which includes this guideline, it is obvious that a conflict will not be possible, since the corresponding general internal rule against tax evasion, will apply in the same circumstances in which the benefits of the Convention are denied in accordance with paragraph 9 of article 29, or, in the case of a treaty that does not include this paragraph, in accordance with the guiding principle of paragraph 61 above.
Legal doctrines that are part of domestic legislation
78 . In the process of interpreting tax legislation in cases involving tax evasion, courts in many countries have developed a number of legal doctrines or principles of interpretation. These include doctrines such as the predominance of content over form, economic meaning, fiction, business purpose, step-by-step transaction, abuse of the law, and "fraus legis." These doctrines and principles of interpretation, which vary from country to country and evolve over time based on clarifications or changes resulting from subsequent court decisions, are essentially opinions expressed by courts on how tax legislation should be interpreted. Although the interpretation of agreements for the avoidance of double taxation is governed by the general rules systematized in Articles 31-33 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, these general rules do not prevent the application of similar legal doctrines and principles to the interpretation of the provisions of agreements for the avoidance of double taxation. If, for example, the courts of one country have determined that, from the point of view of legal interpretation, the provisions on domestic taxation should be applied on the basis of the economic meaning of certain transactions, there is nothing that would prevent the application of a similar approach with respect to the application of the provisions of the agreement on the avoidance of double taxation to similar transactions. This is confirmed by the example in paragraph 75 above.
79 . As a general rule, and taking into account paragraph 61, the previous analysis leads to the conclusion that there will be no conflict between tax conventions and judicial doctrines against tax evasion, or general internal rules against tax evasion. For example, to the extent that the application of a general internal rule against tax evasion or a judicial doctrine such as "predominance of content over form" or "economic sense" leads to a reassessment of income or a redefinition of the taxpayer who is considered to be the recipient of such income, the provisions of the Convention will apply subject to these changes..
80 . Although these rules do not contradict tax agreements, there is an agreement that member countries must carefully comply with specific obligations set out in double taxation agreements until there is clear evidence that the agreements are being violated.
Regulations on controlled foreign companies
81 . A significant number of countries have adopted regulations on controlled foreign companies to address issues related to the use of foreign base companies. Although the structure of this type of legislation varies significantly from country to country, a common feature of these rules, which are currently internationally recognized as a legitimate tool for protecting the domestic tax base, is that they result in a Contracting State taxing its residents on income related to their participation in certain foreign organizations. Sometimes, on the basis of a certain interpretation of the provisions of the Convention, such as paragraph 1 of Article 7 and paragraph 5 of Article 10, it has been argued that this general feature of legislation on controlled foreign companies contradicts these provisions. Since such legislation leads to taxation by the State of its residents, paragraph 3 of Article 1 confirms that it does not contradict tax agreements. The same conclusion should be reached with regard to conventions that do not contain a provision similar to paragraph 3 of Article 1.; For the reasons set out in paragraphs 14 of the Commentary to Article 7 and 37 of the Commentary to Article 10, the interpretation that these articles would prevent the application of the provisions on controlled foreign companies does not correspond to the text of paragraph 1 of Article 7 and paragraph 5 of Article 10. This is also not done when such provisions are read in their context. Thus, although some countries have found it useful to explicitly clarify in their conventions that legislation on controlled foreign companies does not contradict the Convention, such clarification is not required. It is recognized that the legislation on controlled foreign companies structured in this way does not contradict the provisions of the Convention.
Limitation of contractual benefits in respect of income that is subject to certain features of the tax system of another State
82 . As indicated in paragraph 15.2 of the Introduction
It is assumed that when a State accepts the provisions of an agreement limiting its right to tax elements of income, it usually does so on the understanding that these elements of income are subject to taxation in another State. If a State does not levy income taxes or levies low taxes, other States should consider whether there are double taxation risks that in themselves justify the conclusion of a double taxation agreement. States should also consider whether there are elements of another State's tax system that may increase the risk of non-taxation, which may include tax advantages limited by the domestic economy.
83 . A State may conclude that certain characteristics of the tax system of another State are not sufficient to prevent the conclusion of a tax agreement, but may wish to prevent the application of this agreement to income that, due to these features, is not taxed or is subject to low taxes. If the relevant features of the tax system of another State are known during the negotiation of a contract, provisions can be developed that specifically deny contractual benefits to income that benefits from these characteristics (see, for example, paragraph 108 below).
84 . However, such features can be introduced into the tax system of a contractual partner only after the conclusion of a double taxation agreement, or they can be discovered only after the entry into force of the agreement. Thus, when concluding a double taxation agreement, a Contracting State may be concerned about the specifics of the tax system of a contractual partner, which it does not know at that time or which may later become part of the tax system of this contractual partner. The provisions on controlled foreign companies (see paragraph 81 above) and other approaches discussed in the previous section, "Improper use of the Convention," may help address some of these features, but since the difficulties created by these characteristics arise from the structure of the tax legislation of the contracting parties, not the strategy of tax evasion Developed by taxpayers or their advisers, the Contracting States may wish to resolve these difficulties through specific treaty provisions. The following are examples of provisions that can be adopted for this purpose.
Regulations on special tax regimes
85 . Provisions may be included in a double taxation agreement to deny the application of specific provisions of the treaty in relation to income derived from regimes that meet the criteria of the general definition of "special tax regimes". For example, the benefits specified in the provisions of Articles 11 and 12 may be waived in respect of interest and royalties that would have been received from a related person if such interest and royalties had proved beneficial in the State of residence of their beneficial owner under such a special tax regime.; This can be done by adding the following provision to Articles 11 and 12 (which may be amended to take into account the circumstances of the Contracting States or for inclusion in other Articles of the Convention):
Notwithstanding the provisions of [(in the case of Article 11): paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4] [(in the case of Article 12): paragraph 1, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 3] of this Article, [interest] [royalties] arising in a Contracting State and actually owned by a resident a resident of the other Contracting State associated with the payer may be taxed in the first Contracting State in accordance with its domestic law if such a resident benefits from a special tax regime in respect of [interest] [royalties] in the State, of which he is a resident.
For the purposes of the above provision, a reference to a resident who is "related" to the payer should be interpreted in accordance with the definition of "related person" contained in the commentary to paragraph 7 of Article 29. As indicated in paragraph 127 of this Commentary, if the above provision is included in the Convention, it would be advisable to include this definition in paragraph 1 of Article 3, which includes definitions that apply throughout the Convention. However, some States may prefer to replace the reference to a resident who is "related" to the payer with a reference to a resident who is "closely related" to the payer, with the main difference being that, unlike the definition of
The definition of a "closely related" person contained in paragraph 8 of Article 5 does not apply if a person directly or indirectly owns exactly 50 percent of the total number of votes and the value of another person (if the definition of a "closely related" person is used for the purposes of the above provision, it would be more appropriate to include this definition in paragraph 1 of Article 3).
86 . In addition, the above provision will require the definition of a "special tax regime", which could be formulated as follows and added to the list of general definitions included in paragraph 1 of Article 3.:
The term "special tax regime" means any law, regulation or administrative practice in a Contracting State in respect of the tax described in Article 2 that meets all of the following conditions:
(i) leads to one or more of the following results:
A) preferential tax rate of interest, royalties or any combination thereof in comparison with income from the sale of goods or services;
B) a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties, or any combination thereof, without a comparable reduction in income from the sale of goods or services, by allowing:
1) exceptions to gross revenue;
2) deductions without regard to any relevant payment or obligation to make payment;
3) retention of paid or accrued dividends; or;
4) taxation incompatible with the principles of Articles 7 or 9; or
(C) A preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base of the type described in sub-paragraphs 1), 2), 3) or 4) of paragraph (B) of this subdivision in respect of substantially all of the company's income or substantially all of the company's income from foreign sources for companies that are not active in that Contracting State;
(ii) in the case of any preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base for royalties, does not result in such benefits for
(A) The amount of scientific research and development work carried out in a Contracting State; or
B) expenses (excluding any costs related to subcontracting to a related party or any acquisition costs) that the beneficiary incurs for the purposes of actual research and development;
(iii) the tax rate is generally expected to be less than the lesser of the following:
(A) [The rate is to be determined bilaterally]; or
(B) 60 per cent of the total prescribed corporate tax rate applicable in the other Contracting State;
(iv) does not apply primarily to:
A) Recognized pension funds;
B) organizations that are established and supported solely for religious, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural or educational purposes.
(C) Persons whose taxation reaches a uniform level of taxation for the person or its shareholders (with a delay of not more than one year) who own a diversified portfolio of securities that are subject to investor protection regulation in a Contracting State and in which shares are sold primarily to retail investors; or
D) persons whose taxation reaches the uniform level of taxation of the person or its shareholders (with a delay of no more than one year) and who primarily own real estate; and
(v) after consultation with the first-mentioned Contracting State, it has been determined by the other Contracting State through diplomatic channels to the first-mentioned Contracting State as meeting the requirements of subsections (i) to (iv) of this subparagraph.
No law, regulation or administrative practice shall be considered as a special tax regime until 30 days after the date on which the other Contracting State issues a written public notification defining the regime as satisfying subsections (i) - (iv) of this subparagraph.
87 . The above definition of the term "special tax regime" applies to any legislation, regulation, or administrative practice (including prevailing practice) that exists before or enters into force after the signing of the agreement and that satisfies all of the following five conditions.
88 . According to the first condition described in subsection (i) of the definition, the mode should lead to one or more of the following results::
A. preferential tax rate of interest, royalties, or any combination thereof compared to income from the sale of goods or services;
B. a certain permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties, or any combination thereof, without a comparable decrease in sales or service income; or
C. a preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of virtually all of the company's income or virtually all of the company's income from foreign sources for companies that are not active in that Contracting State; This part of the definition is intended to identify regimes that tend to tax mobile income more advantageously than non-mobile income.
89 . As provided in paragraph (A), subsection (i) must be implemented if the regime provides for a preferential tax rate for interest, royalties, or a combination thereof compared to income from sales or services. For example, this condition is met by a regime that provides a preferential tax rate on royalty income earned by resident companies, but does not provide such a preferential rate for income from sales or services. In addition, a regime that provides a preferential tax rate for all income classes (although in fact such a preferential rate is available mainly for interest, royalties, or a combination thereof) satisfies subsection (i), despite the fact that this approach is clearly not limited to these income classes. For example, the administrative practice of the tax authority to issue routine rulings setting a preferential tax rate for companies that claim to receive primarily interest income (for example, group finance companies) satisfies the requirements of subsection (i), even if rulings such as technical matters provide for a preferential rate for all forms of income.
90 .Similarly, the provisions presented in subsection (i) (B) should be respected if the regime provides for a permanent reduction in the tax base in respect of interest, royalties, or a combination thereof, compared with income from the sale of goods or services in one or more of the following ways: exclusion from gross revenue (for example, automatic fixed reduction of the amount of royalties included in income, while such a reduction is also not available for income from the sale of goods or services); withholding without an appropriate payment or obligation to make a payment; withholding of paid or accrued dividends; or taxation incompatible with the principles of Articles 7 or 9 of the Convention. An example of a tax regime that results in taxation incompatible with the principles of Article 9 is a regime in which interest income will not accrue on a non-interest-bearing promissory note owned by a company resident in a Contracting State and issued by an associated enterprise that is a resident of the other Contracting State.
91 . The constant reduction of the State's tax base is not only due to the difference in time factors. For example, the fact that a particular country does not tax interest until it is actually paid, rather than when it is accrued economically, is not considered a regime that ensures a permanent reduction in the tax base, since such a rule is a common difference in time factors. However, a regime that has involved excessive deferral for many years should be considered as providing for a permanent reduction in the tax base, since such a rule essentially represents a permanent difference in the base of the country collecting the tax.
92. Alternatively, as provided in paragraph (C), subsection (i) should be implemented if the regime provides for a preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base (of the type described above) for virtually all income or virtually all income from foreign sources for companies that are not active in a Contracting State.. For example, regimes that provide preferential tax rates only for the income of group financing companies or holding companies usually meet the requirements of subsection (i).
93 . A favorable tax system regime that normally applies to all income (in particular, income from sales and services) and in all industries should not comply with subsection (i). Examples of generally applicable provisions that do not comply with subsection (i) include regimes allowing standard deductions, accelerated depreciation, corporate tax consolidation, deductions of dividends received, loss carry-over, and foreign tax credits.
94 . The second condition described in subsection (ii) of the definition applies only to royalties and is satisfied if the regime does not result in benefits either from the volume of research activities that are carried out in a Contracting State or from costs (with the exception of any costs that relate to subcontracting with a related party or any acquisition costs) that The beneficiary is responsible for the purposes of actual research and development. Subsection (ii) is intended to ensure that royalties benefiting from "patent box" or "innovation box" regimes are eligible for contractual benefits only if such regimes satisfy one of these two requirements. However, some States would prefer that the requirements of subsection (ii) be limited and implemented only if the regime favours the amount of research and development work carried out in a Contracting State. States that share this view may prefer to use the following alternative version of subsection (ii):
(ii) in the case of any preferential tax rate or a permanent reduction in the tax base for royalties, such benefits are not conditional on the amount of research and development work carried out in a Contracting State.;
According to any version of subsection (ii), royalty regimes that have been reviewed by the OECD Forum on Harmful Tax Practices and have not been identified as "actually harmful" generally do not comply with subsection (ii) and, if so, will not be considered special tax regimes.
95 . The third condition described in subsection (iii) of the definition requires that the regime is generally expected to result in a tax rate that is less than the lowest of the rates agreed upon bilaterally between the Contracting States and 60 percent of the total prescribed corporate tax rate applicable in a Contracting State that considers the other State's regime as a potential "special tax regime".
96 . States may find it useful to clarify the reference to the "tax rate" for the purposes of subsection (iii) by including the following in a document reflecting an agreed interpretation of the treaty:
With the exception of the cases indicated below, the tax rate is determined on the basis of the principles of taxation of income of the Contracting State that introduced the regime in question. Therefore, in the case of a regime that provides only a preferential tax rate, the expected tax rate under the regime should normally be equal to such a preferential rate. In the case of a regime that provides only for a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate should be equal to the established company tax rate normally applied in a Contracting State to companies subject to this regime, minus the product of such a rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base (with the base tax base determined in accordance with the principles of the Contracting State, but without taking into account any permanent reductions in the tax base described in paragraph (B) of subsection ((i)), which is usually expected from the regime. For example, a regime that typically provides for a 20 percent permanent reduction in a company's tax base will have a tax rate equal to the current established company tax rate, reduced by 20 percent of such a statutory rate. In the case of a regime that provides for both a preferential tax rate and a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate will be based on a preferential tax rate reduced by the product of such a rate and a percentage reduction in the tax base.
97 . The above explains that the tax rate is determined based on the principles of taxation of income of the Contracting State that introduced the regime in question. Therefore, in the case of a regime that provides only a preferential tax rate, the expected tax rate under the regime should normally be equal to such a preferential rate. In the case of a regime that provides only for a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate will be equal to the established company tax rate normally applied in a Contracting State to companies subject to this regime, minus the product of such a rate and the percentage reduction in the tax base (with the base tax base determined in accordance with the principles of the Contracting State, but without taking into account any permanent reductions in the tax base described in paragraph (B) of subsection ((i)), which is normally expected from the regime. For example, a regime that typically provides for a 20 percent permanent reduction in a company's tax base will have a tax rate equal to the current established company tax rate, reduced by 20 percent of such a statutory rate. Consequently, if the applicable statutory company tax rate in force in a Contracting State was 25 percent, the tax rate resulting from such a regime would be 20 percent (25 - (25 x 0.20)). In the case of a regime that provides for both a preferential tax rate and a permanent reduction in the tax base, the tax rate will be based on a preferential tax rate reduced by the product of such a rate and a percentage reduction in the tax base.
98 . The fourth condition described in subsection (iv) of the definition stipulates that the regime should not be considered as a special tax regime if it applies mainly to pension funds or organizations that are established and supported solely for religious, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural or educational purposes. In accordance with subsection (iv), the regime should also not be considered as a special tax regime if it applies mainly to persons whose taxation reaches a single level of taxation for the person or its shareholders (with a delay of no more than one year) who own a diversified portfolio of securities that are subject to investor protection regulation in The state of residence and the shares in which are sold primarily to retail investors. As a rule, this corresponds to the collective investment funds mentioned in paragraph 22 above. The other exception provided for in subsection (iv) relates to regimes that apply mainly to persons whose taxation reaches a uniform level of taxation for the person or its shareholders (with a delay of no more than one year) and who primarily own real estate.
99 . The fifth condition described in subsection (v) of the definition stipulates that a Contracting State that wishes to treat another State's regime as a "special tax regime" must first consult with the other Contracting State and notify that State through diplomatic channels that it has determined that the regime meets the other conditions of the definition.
100. The final part of the definition requires that a Contracting State that wishes to treat another State's regime as a "special tax regime" issue a written public notice stating that the regime satisfies the definition. For the purposes of the Convention, a special tax regime is considered as such 30 days after the date of such written public notification.
Regulations on subsequent changes in domestic legislation
101. Although the provision on special tax regimes proposed above will address the issue of targeted tax regimes, it will not address changes of a more general nature that may be introduced into the domestic legislation of a contractual partner after the conclusion of a double taxation agreement and which could have prevented the conclusion of the agreement if they had existed at that time. the time. For example, some Contracting States may be concerned if the total tax rate that another State levies on corporate income falls below what they consider acceptable for the purposes of concluding a double taxation agreement. Some States may also be concerned if a State that taxes most types of foreign income at the time of the conclusion of a double taxation agreement subsequently decides to exempt such income from tax in cases where it is received by a resident company. The following is an example of a provision that would solve these problems, with the understanding that the specifics of this provision should be limited or expanded to take into account the specific issues of concern to each State.:
1. If at any time after the signing of this Convention a Contracting State.
a) reduces the general statutory corporate income tax rate, which applies to almost all income of resident companies, as a result of which this rate becomes lower than the lowest of the
(ii) [the rate is to be determined bilaterally]; or
(iii) 60 per cent of the total prescribed corporate tax rate applicable in the other Contracting State; or
(b) The first-mentioned Contracting State grants tax exemption to resident companies for virtually all income from foreign sources (including interest and royalties),
The Contracting States should consult with each other with a view to amending this Convention in order to restore the proper distribution of tax rights between the Contracting States. If such consultations do not yield any results, the other State may notify the first-mentioned State through diplomatic channels that it ceases to apply the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 and
21. In such a case, the provisions of such Articles in respect of payments to companies resident in both Contracting States shall cease to apply six months after the date on which the other Contracting State issues a written public notification that it ceases to apply the provisions of these Articles.
2. To determine the total established company tax rate:
(a) Discounts on publicly available deductions based on a percentage of what would otherwise be taxable income and other similar mechanisms should be taken into account to achieve a reduction in the overall tax rate; and
b) are not taken into account:
(ii) a tax that is applied to a company only after distribution by such company or applied to shareholders; and
(iii) the amount of tax to be refunded when the company distributes dividends.
102. Such a proposed provision provides that if, at any time after the signing of the Convention, any of the Contracting States introduces certain changes to domestic legislation, the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 and 21 may cease to apply to payments to companies if, after consultation, the Contracting States fail to agree on amendments to the Convention to restore the proper distribution of tax rights. between the Contracting States.
103. Paragraph 1 of the proposed regulation discusses two types of subsequent changes that a State may make to the tax rules applicable to companies resident in that State after signing a double taxation agreement. The first type is when this State reduces the general statutory corporate income tax rate, which applies to almost all income of resident companies, as a result of which such a rate becomes lower than the lower one, which must be determined on a bilateral basis, or 60 percent of the total corporate income tax rate applied in another State.
104. For the purposes of paragraph 1, "general established corporate income tax rate" means the general corporate income tax rate provided for by law; if company tax rates are differentiated, this refers to the highest marginal rate, provided that such a rate applies to a significant portion of corporate taxpayers and was not established simply to circumvent the application of this Article.. The general statutory corporate income tax rate applicable to business profits in general or to so-called "commercial income" (broadly including income from manufacturing, services, or trade in goods) should be considered applicable to virtually all income of resident companies, even if narrow income categories (including income from portfolio investments or other passive activities). The reduced tax rate, which applies only to capital gains, does not fall within the scope of this Article.; The distinction between profits from entrepreneurial activity and capital gains is made in accordance with the domestic legislation of the State of residence. Paragraph 2 addresses specific issues that may arise when determining the general corporate income tax rate set by the State. Subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 provides that paragraph 1 applies equally to the reduction of the general statutory corporate income tax rate, as well as to other changes in domestic legislation that would have the same effect if another mechanism were used. For example, if the statutory corporate income tax rate in a Contracting State was 20 percent, but after signing the Convention, companies resident in a Contracting State are allowed to claim deductions amounting to 50 percent of what would otherwise be their taxable income, the total statutory corporate income tax rate would be 10 percent (20 - (20 x 0.50)). Similarly, if the statutory corporate income tax rate in a Contracting State was 20 percent, but after signing the Convention, companies resident in a Contracting State are allowed to deduct an amount equal to a percentage of their capital up to 50 percent of what would otherwise be their taxable income. As a rule, most companies can use the maximum possible deduction, resulting in a total income tax rate of 10%. Subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 sets out taxes that should not be taken into account when determining the general statutory corporate income tax rate. First, as provided in subsection (i) of subparagraph (b), taxes levied at the company or shareholder level when the company distributes profits should not be taken into account when determining the total corporate income tax rate (for example, if resident companies are not subject to taxation at the company level until distribution has been made, and the tax levied on distribution will not be considered part of the total corporate income tax rate). Secondly, as provided in subsection (ii) of subparagraph (b), any corporate tax amounts that, according to the domestic legislation of the country, would be reimbursable in the distribution of company income should not be taken into account for the purposes of determining the total prescribed corporate income tax rate.
105. The second type of subsequent changes in domestic tax legislation, covered by paragraph 1, is when a State grants tax exemption to companies resident in that State in respect of virtually all income from foreign sources (including interest and royalties) received by those companies. The reference to exemption for almost all income from foreign sources received by a resident company is intended to describe a tax system according to which income (including income from interest and royalties) from sources outside the State is exempt from tax solely on the grounds that its source is located outside that State (the so-called "territorial" systems). The reference does not include taxation systems according to which only dividends from foreign sources or business profits from foreign permanent representative offices are exempt from tax by the State of residence (the so-called "dividend exemption" systems).
106. When any subsequent change in domestic legislation occurs, the Contracting States shall first consult with a view to amending the Convention in order to restore the proper distribution of tax rights between the two Contracting States. If, after such consultations, the Contracting States agree on amendments or agree that the distribution of tax rights in accordance with the Convention is not violated by the relevant amendments made to the domestic legislation of one of the States, paragraph 1 has no further application. However, if such consultations do not produce any results after a reasonable period of time, the other State may, through diplomatic channels, notify the State whose domestic law has changed of the termination of the application of the provisions of Articles 10, 11, 12 and 21. After such diplomatic notification has been made, for the application of paragraph 1, the source State must, by written public notification, declare that it ceases to apply the provisions of these Articles. Six months after the date of such written public notification, the provisions of these articles in respect of payments to companies that are residents of either State shall cease to be in force in both Contracting States.
Regulations on conditional contributions to capital
107. One example of a tax regime in respect of which contractual benefits may be limited relates to the provisions of domestic legislation that provide for a conditional deduction in respect of capital. Contracting States that agree to prevent the application of the provisions of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons who benefit from such contingent deductions may do so by adding the following provision to Article 11:
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1 of this Article, interest arising in one Contracting State and lawfully owned by a resident of the other Contracting State who is related to the payer (as defined in paragraph 8 of Article 5) may be taxed in the first-mentioned Contracting State in accordance with domestic law if such a resident benefits at any time the time during the tax year in which the interest is paid, from the notional deductions in respect of the amounts that the Contracting State, which the beneficiary owner is a resident of, considers as capital.
The clarifications in paragraph 85 above regarding the reference to a resident who is "related" to the payer are equally applicable to the above provision.
Regulations on taxation based on money transfers
108. Another example of a tax regime in respect of which contractual benefits may be limited is taxation based on money transfers. According to the domestic legislation of some States, persons who qualify as residents but do not have what is considered a permanent connection with the State (sometimes referred to as permanent residence) are taxed only on income received from sources outside the State, to the extent that this income is actually repatriated or transferred there. Thus, such persons are not subject to possible double taxation to the extent that the foreign income is not transferred to their State of residence, and it may be considered inappropriate to provide them with the benefits of the Convention's provisions on such income. Contracting States that agree to limit the application of the provisions of the Convention to income actually taxable in the hands of these persons may do so by adding the following provision to the Convention:
If, in accordance with any provision of this Convention, income arising in one Contracting State is exempt from tax in whole or in part in that State and in accordance with the laws in force in the other Contracting State, the person in respect of said income shall be taxable by reference to the amount of such income transferred or received in that other State. In that State, and not with reference to its full amount, any exemption provided for in the provisions of this Convention applies only to that part of the income., which is taxable in the other Contracting State.
In some States, the application of this provision may create administrative difficulties if a significant period of time elapses between the time when income is generated in one Contracting State and the time when it is taxed by the other Contracting State in the hands of a resident of that other State. States concerned about these difficulties may subordinate the rule to the last part of the above provision, that is, the rule that the income in question will be eligible for benefits in the first-mentioned State only if it is taxed in another State, provided that the income must be taxed in that other State for a certain period of time from the date of income in the first mentioned State.
Source-based taxation restrictions: procedural aspects
109. A number of Articles of the Convention restrict the right of a State to tax income earned on its territory. As noted in paragraph 19 of the Commentary to article 10 on the taxation of dividends, the Convention does not regulate procedural matters, and each State is free to use the procedure provided for in its domestic law to apply the restrictions provided for in the Convention. Thus, a State may automatically limit the amount of tax it levies in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Convention, subject to possible preliminary verification of the right to a contract, or it may levy a tax provided for in its domestic law and subsequently reimburse a portion of that tax that exceeds the amount it may levy in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. As a rule, the first approach is the most preferable to ensure the rapid implementation of taxpayer benefits under the contract. If a compensation system is needed, it should be based on the observed difficulties in determining the right to benefits under the contract. In addition, when the second approach is applied, it is extremely important that the refund is made quickly, especially if no interest is paid on the refund amount, since any unjustified delay in returning these funds is a direct cost to the taxpayer.
Note to the Comment
110. With regard to paragraph 81, Switzerland considers that legislation on controlled foreign corporations may, depending on the relevant concept, contradict the spirit of Article 7.
Reservations to the Article
111. The United States reserves the right, with some exceptions, to tax its citizens and residents, including some former citizens and permanent residents, without regard to the provisions of the Convention.
112. Canada reserves the right to restrict the legal entities or entities referred to in paragraph 2 to those established in one of the Contracting States.
113. France reserves the right not to include or amend paragraph 2 of its agreements in such a way as to indicate in which situations it will recognize the tax transparency of organizations located in another Contracting State or in a third State.
114. Germany reserves the right not to include paragraph 2 in its agreements.
115. Portugal reserves the right not to include paragraph 2 in its agreements due to the administrative difficulties associated with some of the solutions proposed in the report.
"Application of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes to Partnerships" (as in some cases indicated in the report itself).
116. Ireland reserves the right not to include paragraph 3 in its conventions, as well as to amend paragraph 2 so as to provide that this paragraph will not be interpreted as affecting the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents.
117. France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Luxembourg and Switzerland reserve the right not to include paragraph 3 in their agreements.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 2 ON TAXES COVERED BY THE CONVENTION
1. This article is intended to make terminology and symbols relating to taxes covered by the Convention more acceptable and precise, which will ensure the identification of taxes of the Contracting States to which the Convention applies, in order to maximize the scope of the Convention by including, as far as possible, in accordance with the domestic laws of the Contracting States taxes, charged by their political subdivisions or local authorities, to avoid the need to conclude a new convention in case of changes in the domestic legislation of the Contracting States, and to ensure that each Contracting State is notified of significant changes in the tax legislation of the other State.
Point 1
2. This paragraph defines the scope of the Convention: taxes on income and on capital; therefore, the overly inaccurate term "direct taxes" has been deleted. It does not matter on behalf of which authorities such taxes are levied; it can be the State itself or its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities (States, regions, provinces, divisions, districts, regions, municipal divisions, Kreise, municipalities or groups of municipalities, etc.). The method of tax collection also does not matter: direct accrual or deduction from the source, in the form of additional taxes or additional fees, or in the form of additional taxes (cents additionnels), etc.
Item 2
3. This paragraph defines taxes on income and on capital. Such taxes include taxes on total income and on income elements, on total capital and on capital elements. In addition, it includes taxes on profits and gains from the alienation of movable or immovable property, as well as taxes on capital appreciation. Finally, this definition applies to taxes on the total amount of wages or salaries paid by businesses ("payroll taxes"; in Germany, "Lohnsummensteuer"; in France, "taxe sur les salaires"). Social contributions or any other fees paid in cases where there is a direct link between the fee and the individual benefits received should not be considered as "taxes on the total amount of wages."
4. Obviously, a State that has the right to tax an item of income or capital in accordance with the Convention may levy taxes imposed by its legislation along with any additional duties or charges: surcharges, costs, interest, fines, etc. It was not considered necessary to indicate this in the article, since it is obvious that the Contracting State that has the right to levy the tax may also levy additional duties or charges related to the basic fee. Most States, however, do not consider that interest and penalties, in addition to the taxes provided for in Article 2, are themselves included in the scope of Article 2 and, accordingly, generally do not consider such interest and penalties to be payments to which the provisions relating to the taxation rights of the source State (or place of operation) or The State of Residence, including restrictions on taxation by the State of origin and the obligation of the State of Residence to eliminate double taxation. However, if taxation is abolished or reduced in accordance with a mutual agreement in accordance with Article 25, the interest and administrative penalties associated with such taxation must be withdrawn or reduced to the extent that they are directly related to taxation (i.e. tax liability), which is reduced by mutual agreement. This may be the case, for example, when an additional fee is calculated with reference to the amount of the underlying tax liability, and the competent authorities agree that all or part of the basic taxation does not comply with the provisions of the Convention. This may also be the case, for example, when administrative fines are imposed in connection with a transfer pricing adjustment, and this adjustment is canceled because it is considered to be inconsistent with paragraph 1 of Article 9.
5. The article does not mention "ordinary taxes" or "emergency taxes." Normally, the inclusion of extraordinary taxes in the Model Convention may be considered justified, but experience shows that such taxes are usually levied in very special circumstances. In addition, it is quite difficult to define them. They can be extraordinary for various reasons; their imposition, collection procedure, rates, goals, etc. If so, it seems preferable not to include emergency taxes in the article. However, since this is not intended to exclude extraordinary taxes from all agreements, ordinary taxes were also not mentioned. Thus, the Contracting States may limit the scope of the convention to ordinary taxes, or may extend it to emergency taxes or even establish special provisions.
Point 3
6. This paragraph lists the taxes in effect at the time of signing the Convention. The list is not exhaustive. It serves as an illustration of the previous paragraphs of the Article. In principle, this is a complete list of taxes levied in each State at the time of signing and subject to the Convention.
6.1 Some member countries do not include paragraphs 1 and 2 in their bilateral conventions. These countries prefer to simply list the taxes in full in each country to which the Convention will apply, and clarify that the Convention will also apply to subsequent taxes similar to those listed. Countries wishing to follow this approach may use the following wording:
1. Taxes to which the Convention applies:
a) (in State A):
b) (in State B):
2. This Convention shall also apply to any identical or substantially similar taxes that are imposed after the date of signature of the Convention in addition to or in place of the taxes listed in paragraph 1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States must notify each other of any significant changes introduced into their tax legislation.
As mentioned in paragraph 3 above, social contributions and similar charges should be excluded from the list of taxes covered by the agreement.
Item 4
7. Since the list of taxes in paragraph 3 is purely declarative, this paragraph provides that the Convention should also apply to all identical or substantially similar taxes that are levied in a Contracting State after the date of signature of the Convention in addition to, or in place of, the existing taxes in that State.
8. Each State undertakes to notify each other of any significant changes made to its tax legislation, providing, for example, detailed information on new or replaced taxes. Member countries are encouraged to report on other important developments, such as new regulations or court decisions; many countries are already following this practice. Contracting States may also extend the notification requirement to any significant changes in other laws that affect their obligations under the agreement.; Contracting States wishing to do so may replace the last sentence of the paragraph with the following:
The competent authorities of the Contracting States will notify each other of any significant changes that have been made to their tax laws or other laws affecting their obligations under the Convention.
Note to the Comment
9. Portugal does not follow the interpretation of the last three sentences of paragraph 4 of the Commentary to Article 2. Portugal considers that interest and fines are not taxes covered by the Convention and, therefore, cannot be considered in the framework of the mutual agreement procedure.
Reservations to the Article
10 . Canada, Chile and the United States retain their positions in the part of paragraph 1 that states that the Convention should apply to taxes of administrative-territorial entities or local authorities.
11 . Australia, Japan and Korea retain their position in the part of paragraph 1 that states that the Convention applies to taxes on capital.
12. Greece and Latvia are of the opinion that "taxes on the total amount of wages paid by enterprises" should not be considered as taxes on income and, therefore, are not subject to the Convention.
COMMENT TO ARTICLE 3 ON GENERAL DEFINITIONS
1. This Article brings together a number of general provisions necessary for the interpretation of the terms used in the Convention. However, the meaning of some important terms is explained in other parts of the Convention. Thus, the terms "resident" and "permanent establishment" are defined in Articles 4 and 5, respectively, and the interpretation of certain terms contained in articles on special categories of income ("income from immovable property", "dividends", etc.) is clarified by the provisions contained in these Articles. In addition to the definitions contained in the Article, the Contracting States may, on a bilateral basis, agree on definitions of the terms "Contracting State" and "other Contracting State". In addition, the Contracting States may bilaterally agree to include references to continental shelves in possible definitions of "Contracting States".
Point 1
The term "person"
2. The definition of the term "person" given in subparagraph (a) is not exhaustive and should be interpreted as indicating that the term "person" is used in a very broad sense (see, in particular, Articles 1 and 4). The definition explicitly mentions individuals, companies, and other groups of individuals. From the meaning assigned to the term "company" by the definition contained in subparagraph (b), it follows that the term "person", among other things, includes any legal entity that, although not registered, is considered for tax purposes as a corporate association. Thus, for example, a foundation (Stiftung) may fall under the meaning of the term "person". Partnerships will also be treated as "entities" either because they fall under the definition of "companies" or, if they don't, because they make up other groups of individuals.
The term "company"
3. The term "company" means primarily any legal entity. In addition, this term covers any other taxable unit that is treated as a legal entity for the purposes of the tax laws of the Contracting State of which it is a resident. The definition is based on the Article on Dividends. The term "company" is relevant only to this Article, paragraphs 7 and 8 of Article 5 and Articles 16 and 29.
The term "enterprise"
4. The question of whether an activity is carried out in an enterprise or is considered to constitute an enterprise in itself has always been interpreted in accordance with the provisions of the domestic legislation of the Contracting States. Therefore, an exhaustive definition of the term "enterprise" has not been attempted in this Article. However, provided that the term "enterprise" is applied to the conduct of any business. Since the term "business" is clearly defined as including the provision of professional services and other activities of an independent nature, it clarifies that the provision of professional services or other activities of an independent nature should be considered an enterprise, regardless of the meaning of this term in domestic legislation. States that consider such an explanation unnecessary may exclude the definition of the term "enterprise" from their bilateral agreements.
The term "international transportation"
5. The definition of the term "international transport" is based on the principle set out in paragraph 1 of Article 8, according to which the right to tax the profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of ships or aircraft in international transport belongs only to that State due to the special nature of business in the field of international transport. However, as indicated in the Commentary to paragraph 1 of Article 8, Contracting States may, on a bilateral basis, include in subparagraph (e) a reference to the State in which the permanent executive body of the enterprise is located. In such a case, the definition should read as follows: "The term "international carriage" means any carriage by ship or aircraft, except in cases where the ship or aircraft is operated exclusively between locations in a Contracting State in which the enterprise that operates the ship or aircraft does not have a permanent executive office.".
6. The definition of the term "international transportation" is broader than it is usually understood. The broader definition is intended to preserve for the State of the enterprise the right to tax exclusively domestic transportation, as well as international transportation between third Countries, and to allow another Contracting State to tax transportation exclusively within its borders. This intention can be explained by the following illustration. Suppose an enterprise of one Contracting State, through an agent in another Contracting State, sells tickets for a flight that is completely restricted within the first mentioned State or, alternatively, within a third State. The article does not allow another State to tax the profits of any flight. Another State is allowed to tax such an enterprise of the first-mentioned State only if the activity is limited exclusively to locations in that other State.
6.1 In 2017, the definition was amended to ensure that it also applies to carriage on a ship or aircraft operated by a third-country enterprise. Although this amendment does not affect the application of Article 8, which concerns only the profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State, it allows paragraph 3 of Article 15 to apply to a resident of a Contracting State who receives remuneration from working on board a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State.
6.2 A ship or aircraft is operated exclusively between locations in a State for a particular flight if the place of departure and the place of arrival of the ship or aircraft are located in that State. However, this definition applies in cases where the journey of a ship or aircraft between locations in a State is part of a longer voyage of that ship or aircraft with a point of departure or arrival located outside that State. For example, if, as part of the same flight, an aircraft first flies between a point in one Contracting State and a point in another Contracting State, and then continues to another destination also located in that other Contracting State, the first and second stages of this flight will be part of the flight that falls under the definition of "international transportation".
6.3 Some States are of the view that the definition of "international carriage" should rather refer to carriage as the journey of a passenger or cargo in such a way that any movement of a passenger or cargo solely between two locations in the same Contracting State should not be considered in accordance with the definition, even if the voyage is performed by sea or an aircraft that is used for international transportation. The Contracting States that adhere to this point of view may bilaterally agree to exclude the reference to "ship or aircraft" from the first part of the exclusion included in the definition in order to use the following definition:
(e) The term "international carriage" means any carriage by ship or aircraft, except in cases where such transport is used exclusively between locations in a Contracting State and the enterprise that operates the ship or aircraft is not an enterprise of that State.;
6.4 The definition of "international traffic" does not apply when a ship or aircraft is operated between two locations in a Contracting State and the enterprise that operates such ship or aircraft is not an enterprise of that State, even if part of the transportation is carried out outside that State. Thus, for example, a cruise that starts and ends in this Country, without making stops at a foreign port, is not an international passenger transportation. Contracting States wishing to explicitly clarify this point in their conventions may agree on a bilateral basis to amend the definition accordingly.
The term "competent authority"
7. The definition of the term "competent authority" recognizes that in some OECD member countries, the implementation of double taxation agreements is not exclusively the responsibility of the highest tax authorities; some issues are reserved or may be transferred to other authorities. This definition allows each Contracting State to designate one or more competent authorities.
The term "citizen"
8. The definition of the term "citizen" simply stipulates that, in relation to a Contracting State, this term applies to any natural person having the nationality or nationality of that Contracting State. It was not considered necessary to include in the text of the Convention any more precise definition of the terms "nationality" and "nationality", nor did it seem necessary to make any special comments on the meaning and application of these words. Obviously, when defining what is meant by "citizen" in the case of an individual, reference must be made to the meaning in which the term is commonly used and to the specific rules of each State regarding the acquisition or loss of citizenship.
9. Subparagraph (g) refers more specifically to legal entities, partnerships, partnerships and associations. By stating that any legal entity, partnership or association that has obtained its status as such on the basis of current legislation in a Contracting State is considered a citizen, this provision eliminates the difficulties that often arise. When determining the nationality of companies, some States pay less attention to the legislation governing the company's activities than to the origin of the capital at the expense of which the company was created, or the nationality of individuals or legal entities controlling it.
10 . Moreover, given the legal relations that arise between a company and the State under whose legislation it is organized, which from certain points of view is very similar to the relationship of citizenship in the case of individuals, it seems justified not to consider legal entities, partnerships and associations in a special position, but to liken them to individuals under the term "citizen".
10.1 The separate mention of partnerships in subparagraph (g) does not contradict the partnership's status as a person in accordance with subparagraph (a). According to the domestic legislation of some countries, a legal entity may be a "person" but not a "legal entity" for tax purposes. An explicit statement is necessary to avoid confusion.
The term "business"
10.2 The Convention does not provide an exhaustive definition of the term "business", which, according to paragraph 2, should normally have the meaning it has under the domestic law of the State applying the Convention. However, subparagraph (h) explicitly provides that this term includes the provision of professional services and other activities of an independent nature. This provision was added in 2000.
simultaneously with the removal of Article 14 of the Convention on independent personal services. This addition, which ensures that the term "business" includes the performance of activities previously covered by Article 14, was intended to prevent the term "business" from being interpreted in a limited way to exclude the performance of professional services or other activities of an independent nature in States where domestic law does not provide that the provision of such services or the actions may represent a business. Contracting States for which this is not the case may, on a bilateral basis, agree to exclude the definition.
The term "recognized pension fund"
10.3 The definition of the term "recognized pension fund" contained in subparagraph (i) was included in 2017, when the term was added to paragraph 1 of Article 4, to ensure that a pension fund meeting this definition is considered to be a resident of the Contracting State in which it is established.
10.4 The effect of the definition of "recognized pension fund" and the reference to this term in paragraph 1 of Article 4 will depend to a large extent on domestic legislation, as well as on the legal characteristics of pension funds established in each Contracting State, as well as in other provisions of the Convention where this definition may be appropriate.
10.5 In some States, a fund may be established within the framework of a legal entity (for example, a company engaged in commercial activities, an insurance company, or the State itself, or its political subdivision or local government) with the primary purpose of providing pension benefits to individuals, such as employees of this organization or other employers, or investing funds for the benefit of others recognized pension funds. However, such a fund may not be a separate "entity" (as defined in subparagraph (a)) in accordance with the tax laws of the State in which it is established, and if so, it will not meet the definition of a recognized pension fund. However, to the extent that the income received from the investment assets of this fund relates, in accordance with the domestic law of the State in which it is established, to a legal entity (for example, a company engaged in commercial activities, an insurance company or the State) within which such a fund was established, the provisions of the Convention will apply to this income to the extent that the legal entity itself qualifies as a resident of a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 4. As explained in paragraphs 8.7–8.10 of the Commentary to Article 4, the inclusion of the term "recognized pension fund" in paragraph 1 of Article 4 is not relevant to such a fund.
10.6 There are also some States in which a fund established for the primary purpose of providing pension benefits to individuals is not formally a separate entity in accordance with the tax laws of the State in which it is established, but where these tax laws provide that the fund's investment assets are separate and separate property, income from which is not distributed between persons for tax purposes. These States may wish to ensure that their domestic legislation and the definition of "person" in subparagraph (a) are broad enough to include such a fund in order to ensure that the Convention applicable to persons who are residents of Contracting States applies to income earned through these funds.
10.7 As indicated in paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18, if two Contracting States adhere to the same approach to general exemption from taxation for investment income of pension funds established in their territories, these States may include in their convention a provision extending this exemption to investment income that a pension fund established in one In another State, receives in another State. In this case, the definition of a "recognized pension fund" can be used for this purpose. However, if this is the case, it is necessary to ensure that the fund described in paragraph 10.5 above can qualify as a "recognized pension fund" in itself, despite the fact that it is not a separate "entity" in accordance with the tax laws of the State in which it is established. However, this would require that, for the purposes of the Convention, the assets and income of such a fund be treated as assets and income of an individual so that, for example:
– the fund could represent a person for the purposes of Article 1 and all relevant provisions of the Convention;
– the assets and income of the fund were considered the assets and income of an individual, and not of the person within whom the fund was established, so that, for example, for the purposes of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10, any part of the capital of the company paying dividends to the fund, which is held through the fund, is not combined with the capital of the same company, which is owned by the person in which the fund is established, but which does not pass through the fund;
– for the purposes of Articles 6 to 21, the income of the fund was considered as received and actually owned by the fund itself, and not by the person within whose framework the fund was established;
– the fund's right to benefits under the contract in accordance with the provisions on the limitation of benefits of Article 29 was determined without taking into account the right to benefits under the contract of the person under which the fund was established.
10.8 The following is an example of a provision that can be added to the definition
a "recognized pension fund" for this purpose:
If an entity established in a Contracting State constitutes a recognized pension fund in accordance with subsection (i) or (ii), if it is treated as a separate entity under the tax laws of that State, it should be treated, for the purposes of this Convention, as a separate entity treated as such under the tax laws of that State. of this State, and all assets and income to which such a structure applies should be considered as assets and income received by this individual, and not by another person.
10.9 The first part of the definition of a "recognized pension fund" refers to "a legal entity or structure established in that State". There are significant differences in the legal and organizational characteristics of pension funds around the world, so it is necessary to adopt a broad formulation. The reference to "structure" is intended, among other things, to cover cases where pension payments are provided through foundations, such as a trust, which, according to the relevant Trusts Act, will not constitute a legal entity: the definition will apply as long as the trust or trustee body is treated as a separate entity for tax purposes. recognized as a separate entity. However, it is required that the organization or structure be considered as a separate entity in accordance with the tax legislation of the State in which they are established: if this is not the case, there is no need to decide on the residence of the pension fund itself, since the income of this fund is considered for tax purposes as the income of another person (see paragraph 10.5 above).
10.10 Subparagraph (i) provides that in order to qualify as a "recognized pension fund", an organization or structure must be established and operate solely or almost exclusively to manage or provide pension and additional or side benefits to individuals. It doesn't matter how many people are eligible for such pension benefits: a recognized pension fund can be created, for example, for a large group of employees or for a single individual entrepreneur. States may replace the phrase "pension and supplementary or secondary benefits" with another wording, such as "pension and similar benefits", provided that this wording is interpreted broadly and includes benefits such as funeral allowances.
10.11 The phrase "exclusively or almost exclusively" clarifies that all or almost all of the activities of a recognized pension fund should be related to the management or provision of pension benefits and additional or side benefits to individuals. The words "almost exclusively" mean that a very small part of the pension fund's activities may include activities that are not only related to the administration or provision of such benefits (for example, the promotion of pension fund services). However, some States have a broader view of the term
A "recognized pension fund" and may wish, for example, to include organizations or mechanisms established and operating solely or almost exclusively for the provision of pensions and benefits, such as disability pensions, that are not related to retirement. These States are free to amend the definition to adapt it to their circumstances. However, such States should take into account the fact that, as indicated in paragraph 10.7 above, the definition of a recognized pension fund may be used for the purposes of provisions exempting from withholding taxation investment income that a pension fund established in one State receives in another State; therefore, it will be important for these States to ensure that the scope of this exemption was not inadvertently expanded by the changes made to the definition.
"a recognized pension fund."
10.12 An enterprise or structure should be established and operated solely or almost exclusively for the purpose of managing or providing pension and additional or side payments to individuals. A pension paid upon retirement from active work or when an employee reaches retirement age may be a typical example.
10.13 In many Countries, pension funds provide a number of benefits that are not strictly related to retirement. The phrase "additional or secondary payments" is intended specifically to cover such payments. The words "additional or secondary" make it clear that such benefits are provided in addition to pension benefits: a fund that will be established primarily to provide benefits that are not pension benefits, therefore, will not meet the definition. Although it is not possible to provide an exhaustive list of all benefits that could qualify as "additional or secondary benefits", the following are typical examples of such benefits:
– payments made as a result of the death or disability of an individual;
– pension or other types of payments to the surviving family members of the deceased person who was entitled to pension benefits;
– payments to an individual with an incurable disease;
– compensation payments in case of prolonged illness or unemployment;
– housing benefits, such as a loan at a reduced rate provided to the payer of pension contributions from accumulated pension contributions for the purchase of a primary residence;
– educational benefits, such as the withdrawal of accumulated pension contributions that a pensioner will be allowed to make to finance their education or the education of their children;
– providing financial advice to depositors of pension contributions.
10.14 Subparagraph (i) also requires that an organization or structure established and operating solely or almost exclusively to manage or provide pension and additional or side benefits to individuals be "regulated as such". The requirement is intended to limit the definition of organizations or structures that are subject to certain conditions imposed by the State in which they are established (or by one of its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities), in order to ensure that the organization or structure is used as an investment tool for the purpose of providing pension benefits to individuals. and additional or side benefits. Thus, this part of the definition excludes an organization such as a private company, which can be established and used by a person to invest funds for the purpose of providing pension benefits to persons associated with or employed by that person, but is not subject to a special regime or rules established by the State, political subdivision or local authority regarding the use of this a legal entity as a means of providing pension benefits. It does not matter whether the tax legislation or other legal documents (for example, legislation establishing the state organization that will manage the state pension fund) provide for the regulatory framework that the organization or structure is subject to; it is important that the organization or structure is recognized by law as a mechanism created to finance pension payments for individuals, and was subject to conditions designed to ensure its use for this purpose.
10.15 An example of an organization or structure that would meet the requirements of the definition of a "recognized pension fund" is an agency or instrument of a State established solely or almost exclusively to manage or provide pension benefits and additional or side benefits within the social security system in accordance with the laws of that State. Another example would be a company or other legal entity established in a State for the purpose of managing or providing pension and additional or side benefits to individuals and whose only assets include funds covered by a pension scheme regulated by the tax legislation of that State, which provides that income from this scheme is exempt from tax. The definition of a recognized pension fund will apply to that company or legal entity, regardless of whether that company or legal entity otherwise qualifies as a resident of a Contracting State because it is "liable to tax therein" by virtue of the criteria referred to in the first sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 4, for example because it is required to pay tax. from any income not received under the scheme (see paragraphs 8.8–8.10 of the Commentary to Article 4).
10.16 Subparagraph (i) of the definition applies regardless of whether the benefits to which it relates are granted to persons who are residents of the State in which the organization or structure is established, or residents of other States. Despite the fact that the general rule against tax evasion contained in paragraph 9 of Article 29 concerns possible problems related to the use of double taxation treaties that may arise in connection with this aspect of the rule, States that do not include this general rule in their treaties or for which it is Of particular concern, the definition of a "recognized pension fund" may include conditions similar to those contained in subsection (ii) of subparagraph (e) of paragraph 2 of the detailed version of the benefit limitation rule., specified in the Commentary to Article 29.
10.17 Subsection (ii) of the definition covers organizations or structures that pension funds included in subsection (i) use for indirect investment. Pension funds often invest together with other pension funds, pooling their assets into specific organizations or structures, and may, for various commercial, legal, or regulatory reasons, invest through wholly owned organizations or structures that are residents of the same State. Since such structures and organizations act only as intermediaries when investing funds used to provide pension benefits to individuals, it is advisable to consider them as pension funds investing through them.
10.18 The phrase "exclusively or almost exclusively" found in subsection (ii) makes it clear that all or almost all of the activities of such an intermediary organization or structure should be related to investments in organizations or structures that qualify as recognized pension funds within division (i). The words "almost exclusively" mean that a very small part of the activities of such organizations or structures may include other activities, such as investing in pension funds that are established in other States and therefore do not fall under subsection (i). States in which intermediary organizations or entities typically invest funds received from pension funds established in other States may expand the scope of subsection (ii) to include the case where a significant portion of the funds is invested by the intermediary organization or entity in favor of pension funds established in other States; these States can resolve any problems. related to the abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements that may arise as a result of the provisions of Article 29.
Item 2
11 .This paragraph provides a general rule of interpretation for terms used in the Convention but not defined in it. However, the question arises as to which legislation should be invoked to determine the meaning of terms not defined in the Convention. Moreover, the choice is made between the legislation in force at the time of signing the Convention and the legislation in force at the time of application of the Convention, i.e. when the tax is levied. The Committee on Budget and Finance concluded that the latter interpretation should prevail, and in 1995 amended the Model Convention to make this clear.
12 . However, paragraph 2 states that the meaning of an indefinite term under domestic law applies only if the context does not require an alternative interpretation and the competent authorities disagree with the other meaning in accordance with the provisions of Article 25. The context is determined, in particular, by the intention of the Contracting States when signing the Convention, as well as the meaning of the term in the legislation of another Contracting State (an implicit reference to the principle of reciprocity on which the Convention is based). Thus, the wording of the article gives the competent authorities some freedom of action.
13 . Consequently, the wording of paragraph 2 provides a satisfactory balance between, on the one hand, the need to ensure the permanence of the obligations that States assumed when signing the convention (since a State should not be allowed to render the convention partially invalid by subsequently changing the scope of terms not defined in the Convention in domestic legislation), and, on the other hand, the need to be able to apply the Convention. in a convenient and practical way (the need to refer to outdated concepts should be avoided).
13.1 Paragraph 2 was amended in 1995 to better reflect the common and consistent understanding of the Member States. For the purposes of paragraph 2, the meaning of any term not defined in the Convention may be ascertained by reference to the meaning it has for the purposes of any relevant provision of the domestic law of a Contracting State, whether or not it is a tax law. However, if a term is defined differently for the purposes of different laws of a Contracting State, the meaning given to that term for the purposes of laws laying down taxes to which the Convention applies shall prevail over all others, including those laid down for the purposes of other tax laws.
13.2 The Commentary was also amended in 1995 to provide that States that may enter into mutual agreements (in accordance with the provisions of Article 25 and, in particular, paragraph 3 thereof) that establish the meaning of terms not defined in the Convention should take such agreements into account when interpreting these terms. In 2017, the wording of paragraph 2 was changed to eliminate any doubt that in the case where a mutual agreement reached in accordance with Article 25 indicates that the competent authorities have agreed on the general meaning of an indefinite term, the meaning of this term in domestic law will not be applicable, as in the case of when the term is defined in the Convention or when the context requires a meaning other than that provided for by domestic law. However, some States consider that this exception should apply only in the case of agreements reached in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 25; these States may replace the phrase "in accordance with the provisions of Article 25" with "in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 25". Other States consider that, according to their legislation, the competent authorities cannot be empowered to agree on the meaning of terms that would prevent reference to the meanings of these terms in domestic law; these States may omit the phrase
"or the competent authorities agree to use a different meaning in accordance with the provisions of Article 25."
Reservations to the Article
14 . Italy and Portugal reserve the right not to include definitions in sub-paragraphs 1 (c) and (h) ("enterprise" and "business"), as they reserve the right to include articles on taxation of independent personal services.
15. Turkey reserves the right to use the following definition of the term "international transportation": "The term "international transportation" means any transportation on a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a Contracting State, except in cases when the ship or aircraft is operated exclusively between locations in another Contracting State."
16 . Israel reserves the right to include a trust in the definition of a "person."
17 . Chile and Mexico reserve the right not to include the definition of a "recognized pension fund" in subparagraph (i) of paragraph 1, since, due to the variety of legal mechanisms for providing pension benefits, the decision to include a pension fund as a resident in a tax agreement is best discussed bilaterally between the Contracting States.
18 . Israel reserves the right not to limit the definition of a "recognized pension fund" to an individual in accordance with tax law.
19 . Portugal reserves the right not to include in its agreements the definition in subparagraph (i) of paragraph 1 ("recognized pension fund"), as it reserves the right not to explicitly include "recognized pension fund" in paragraph 1 of Article 4 and to treat pension funds in accordance with the general definition of "resident" or special provisions, agreed upon on a bilateral basis.
COMMENT TO ARTICLE 4 ON THE DEFINITION OF A RESIDENT
I. Preliminary remarks
1. The term "resident of a Contracting State" performs various functions and is of great importance in three cases:
(a) In identifying the persons to whom the Agreement applies;
b) when resolving cases of double taxation due to dual residency;
c) in cases where double taxation results from taxation in the State of Residence and in the State of origin or place of operation.
2. The article is intended to define the meaning of the term "resident of a Contracting State" and to resolve cases of dual residency. To clarify the scope of the Article, below are some general comments related to two typical cases of conflict, that is, between two places of residence and between the place of residence and the source or place of action. In both cases, the conflict arises because, according to their domestic law, one or both of the Contracting States declare that the person concerned is resident in their territory.
3. As a rule, the domestic legislation of various States imposes comprehensive tax liability - "full tax liability" - based on taxpayers' personal attachment to the relevant State ("State of Residence"). Such tax liability does not apply only to persons who "reside" in the State in the sense in which "residency" is usually understood in legislation (private law) 3. As a rule, the domestic legislation of various States imposes comprehensive tax liability - "full tax liability" - based on taxpayers' personal attachment to the relevant State ("State of Residence"). Such tax liability does not apply only to persons who "reside" in the State in the sense in which "residency" is usually understood in legislation (private law). Cases of full tax liability also apply, for example, to persons who permanently reside in the territory of the State, or perhaps only for a certain period. Some legislative acts impose full tax liability on individuals who provide services on board ships whose home port is located in the State.
4. Conventions for the avoidance of double taxation usually do not relate to the domestic legislation of the Contracting States, which establishes the conditions under which a person 4. Conventions for the avoidance of double taxation usually do not relate to the domestic legislation of the Contracting States, which establishes the conditions under which a person should be considered a "resident" from a tax point of view and, therefore, fully taxable in that State. They do not set standards that the provisions of domestic legislation on "residency" must comply with in order for full tax liability requirements to be accepted between the Contracting States. In this regard, States fully adhere to domestic legislation.
5. This is quite clearly evident in cases where there is no conflict between the two residences, but when such a conflict exists only between the place of residence and the source or place of action. But the same approach applies to conflicts between two residences. The only difference in these cases is that it is impossible to resolve the conflict by referring to the concept of residency 5. This is quite clearly evident in cases where there is no conflict between the two residences, but when such a conflict exists only between the place of residence and the source or place of action. But the same approach applies to conflicts between two residences. The only difference in these cases is that it is impossible to resolve the conflict by referring to the concept of residency adopted in the domestic legislation of the respective States. In these cases, the Convention should establish special provisions defining which of the two concepts of residency should be preferred.
6. An example will clarify such a case. An individual has a permanent home in State A, where his wife and children live. He has been in State B for more than six months and, in accordance with the laws of the latter State, is taxed as a resident of that
7. In this particular case, the Article (in accordance with paragraph 2) gives preference to the requirement of State A. However, this does not mean that the Article establishes special rules for "residency" and that the domestic legislation of State B is ignored because it is incompatible with such rules. The fact is that in the event of such a conflict, a choice must necessarily be made between two requirements, and it is on this point that the Article offers special rules.
Commentary on the provisions of the Article
Point 1
8. Paragraph 1 defines the expression "resident of a Contracting State" for the purposes of the Convention. This definition refers to the concept of residency adopted in domestic legislation (see Preliminary Remarks). As criteria for taxation as a resident, the definition mentions: domicile, residency, place of management, or any other criterion of a similar nature. As for individuals, this definition is aimed at covering various forms of personal attachment to the State, which in domestic tax legislation form the basis of comprehensive taxation (full tax liability). It also covers cases where, according to the tax legislation of a State, a person is considered a resident of that State and, therefore, is fully subject to taxation in it (for example, diplomats or other persons in public service).
8.1 However, in accordance with the provisions of the second sentence of paragraph 1, a person should not be considered a "resident of a Contracting State" within the meaning of the Convention if, although he does not reside in that State, he is considered a resident under domestic law. Nevertheless, it is subject to taxation, which is limited only to income from sources in this State or capital located in it. This situation exists in some States with respect to individuals, for example, in the case of foreign diplomats and consular staff working on their territory.
8.2 According to its wording and nature, the second sentence also excludes from the definition of a resident of a Contracting State foreign companies that are exempt from tax on their foreign income due to privileges intended to attract conduit companies. It also excludes companies and other persons who do not bear full tax liability in a Contracting State, since they, being residents of that State in accordance with the tax laws of that State, are considered residents of the other State in accordance with an agreement between the two States. Of course, excluding certain companies or other persons from the definition would not prevent the Contracting States from exchanging information about their activities (see paragraph 2 of the Commentary to Article 26). Undoubtedly, States may consider it advisable to develop a spontaneous exchange of information about individuals who seek to receive unforeseen benefits under the contract.
8.3 However, the application of the second sentence is fraught with difficulties and limitations. It should be interpreted in connection with its object and purpose, which is to exclude persons who are not subject to comprehensive taxation (full tax liability) in the State, since otherwise it could exclude from the scope of the Convention all residents of countries applying the territorial principle of taxation, which was clearly not planned.
8.4 According to the general opinion of the majority of member States, the Government of each State, as well as any of its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities, is a resident of that State for the purposes of the Convention. Until 1995, the Model Convention did not explicitly state this; in 1995, Article 4 was amended to bring the text of the Model Convention in line with this understanding.
8.5 This raises the question of the application of paragraph 1 to sovereign investment funds, which are special purpose investment funds or mechanisms established by the State or a political entity for macroeconomic purposes. These funds hold or manage assets to achieve financial goals and use a set of investment strategies that include investments in foreign financial assets. They are usually formed from balance of payments surpluses, official foreign exchange transactions, privatization revenues, budget surpluses, or revenues from commodity exports.1 Whether a sovereign investment fund qualifies as a "resident of a Contracting State" depends on the facts and circumstances of each case. For example, if a sovereign investment fund is an integral part of a State, it is likely to fall within the scope of the expression "The State and any of its administrative-territorial entities or local authorities" in Article 4. In other cases, paragraphs 8.11 and 8.12 below will be appropriate. States may wish to resolve this issue during bilateral negotiations, especially with regard to whether a sovereign investment fund qualifies as a "person" and is "taxable" for the purposes of the relevant tax agreement (see also paragraphs 50-53 of the Commentary to Article 1).
8.6 Paragraph 1 also explicitly refers to a "recognized pension fund". Most Member States have long considered that a pension fund established in a Contracting State is a resident of that State, regardless of the fact that it may be subject to limited or complete exemption from taxation in that State. Until 2017, this opinion was reflected in the previous version of paragraph 8.6, which referred to "pension funds, charities and other organizations" as organizations that most States considered to be residents. In 2017, paragraph 1 of the Article was amended to eliminate any doubts about the fact that a pension fund that meets the definition of a "recognized pension fund" in paragraph 1 of Article 3 is a resident of the Contracting State in which it was established.
8.7 As indicated in paragraph 10.4 of the Commentary to Article 3, the effect of the definition of "recognized pension fund" and the reference to this term in paragraph 1 of Article 4 will depend to a large extent on domestic legislation, as well as on the legal characteristics of pension funds established in each Contracting State. The type of fund established within a legal entity, which is described in paragraph 10.5 of the Commentary to Article 3, will not fall under the definition of "recognized pension fund", which applies to a legal entity or a structure that represents a separate entity. However, since the income of these funds relates to the legal entity of which it is a part, the provisions of the Convention will apply to this income to the extent that the legal entity itself qualifies as a resident of a Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1 of the Article.
8.8 However, if the fund is a "person" who is different from any other person by whom or for whose benefit it was established and managed, the definition of "recognized pension fund" would be appropriate, and, to the extent that the conditions of this definition are fulfilled, the fund itself would be a "resident of a Contracting State". This will be the case in many countries, since such funds are "taxable in them" by virtue of the criteria mentioned in the first sentence of paragraph 1, as interpreted by the Contracting States, or, if this is not the case, by virtue of the specific inclusion of the term
_____________________
1 This definition is taken from: International Working Group of Sovereign Funds,
Sovereign Investment Funds - Generally accepted principles and practices - "Santiago Principles", October 2008, Appendix 1. "Recognized pension fund" in paragraph 1.
8.9 Of course, Contracting States may omit the reference to "recognized pension funds" in paragraph 1 if they conclude that income from pension structures established in both States is received by persons who otherwise qualify as residents of the Contracting States. Although they may prefer to leave this link in the paragraph just to eliminate any ambiguity.
8.10 Given the variety of structures through which pension benefits are provided, it will often be useful for Contracting States to review the main types of pension structures used in each State and clarify whether the definition of "recognized pension fund" applies to each type of structure and, more generally, how the provisions of the tax convention between these States apply to these agreements. This can be done during negotiations on this convention or subsequently as part of a mutual agreement procedure.
8.11 Paragraph 1 refers to persons who are "taxable" in a Contracting State under its laws by virtue of various criteria. In many States, a person is considered to be subject to comprehensive taxation, even if the Contracting State does not actually levy the tax. For example, charities and other organizations may be exempt from tax, but they are exempt only if they meet all the exemption requirements specified in the tax legislation. They are therefore subject to the tax laws of the Contracting State. In addition, if they do not meet the specified standards, they are also required to pay tax. Most States will consider such organizations as residents for the purposes of the Convention (see, for example, paragraph 1 of Article 10 and paragraph 5 of Article 11).
8.12 However, in some States, these organizations are not considered taxable if they are exempt from tax in accordance with domestic tax legislation. These States may not consider such organizations as residents for the purposes of the convention unless these organizations are directly covered by the Convention. The Contracting States adhering to this point of view are free to resolve this issue during their bilateral negotiations.
8.13 If a State ignores a partnership for tax purposes and treats it as transparent, taxing the partners on their share of the partnership's income, the partnership itself is not subject to taxation and, therefore, cannot be considered a resident of that State. However, in this case, paragraph 2 of Article 1 clarifies that the Convention will apply to the income of a partnership to the extent that the income is considered for tax purposes by that State as the income of a partner who is a resident of that State. The same approach will apply to the income of other organizations or structures that are considered transparent for tax purposes under the tax legislation of a Contracting State (see paragraphs 2-16 of the Commentary to Article 1).
Item 2
9. This paragraph applies when, by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1, an individual is a resident of both Contracting States.
10 . To resolve this conflict, special rules should be established that give preference to attachment to one State over attachment to another State. As far as possible, the preference criterion should be of such a nature that there can be no doubt that the person concerned will satisfy it only in one State. At the same time, it should reflect such an attachment so that it is considered natural that the right to taxation passes to this particular State. The facts to which the special rules will apply are those that exist during the period when the taxpayer's place of residence affects tax obligations, which may be less than the entire tax period. For example, during one calendar year, an individual is a resident of State A in accordance with the tax laws of that State from January 1 to March 31, and then moves to State B. Since an individual resides in State B for more than 183 days, according to the tax laws of State B, this person is considered a resident of State B for the entire year. Applying the special rules for the period from January 1 to March 31, the individual was a resident of State A. Therefore, both State A and State B must treat an individual as a resident of State A during this period and as a resident of State B from April 1 to December 31.
11 . The Article gives preference to a Contracting State in which an individual has an affordable permanent home. This criterion is often sufficient to resolve a conflict, for example, if an individual has permanent residence in one Contracting State and has only resided in the other Contracting State for a certain period of time.
12 . Thus, subparagraph (a) means that when applying the Convention (that is, in the case of a conflict between the laws of the two States), it is considered that the place of residence is the place where an individual has a house; this dwelling must be permanent, that is, the person must have organized and maintained it for permanent use, unlike staying in a certain place under conditions where it is obvious that the stay should be short-term.
13 . As for the concept of a house, it should be noted that any form of house can be taken into account (a house or apartment rented or owned by an individual; a rented room). The permanence of the house is very important; this means that the individual has arranged for the dwelling to be available to him at any time continuously, and not from time to time for the purpose of staying, which for reasons of this is necessarily short-term (leisure travel, business trips, educational trips, attending courses, etc.). For example, a house owned by an individual cannot be considered accessible to that person during the period when the house was leased and actually transferred to an unrelated party, so that person no longer owns the house and is unable to stay there.
14 . If an individual has permanent residence in both Contracting States, paragraph 2 gives preference to the State with which the person's personal and economic relations are closer, which is understood as the center of his vital interests. In cases where the place of residence cannot be determined by reference to this rule, paragraph 2 provides for permanent residence first and then citizenship as additional criteria. If the individual is a national of both States or of neither of them, the issue shall be resolved by mutual agreement between the States concerned in accordance with the procedure set out in Article 25.
15 .If an individual has a permanent home in both Contracting States, it is necessary to examine the facts in order to establish which of the two States his personal and economic relations are closer. Thus, his family and social connections, his occupation, political, cultural or other activities, the location of the company, the place from where he manages his property, etc. will be taken into account. The circumstances need to be considered as a whole, but, nevertheless, it is obvious that considerations based on the personal actions of an individual should be given special attention. If a person who has a house in one State organizes a second one in another, while maintaining the first one, then the fact that he keeps the first house in the environment where he has always lived, where he has worked and where he has a family and property, can, together with other elements, demonstrate that the center of his vital interests it was preserved in the first State.
16 . Subparagraph (b) establishes a secondary criterion for two completely different situations:
a) the case when an individual has affordable permanent housing in both Contracting States and it is impossible to determine which of them is the center of his vital interests;
(b) The case where an individual does not have a permanent home in either of the Contracting States.
Preference shall be given to the Contracting State in which the person normally resides.
17 . In the first situation, when an individual has affordable permanent housing in both States, the fact of permanent residence in one State, rather than in the other, thus acts as a circumstance that, in case of doubt about where this person's center of vital interests is located, tips the scales in the direction of the State in which which this person is more often.
For this purpose, it is necessary to take into account that the individual remains not only in permanent housing in this State, but also in any other place in the same State.
18 . The second situation is when an individual does not have permanent housing in any of the Contracting States, as, for example, in the case when such a person moves from one hotel to another. In this case, the entire period of stay in the State should also be taken into account without the need to clarify the reasons.
19 . The application of the criterion provided for in subparagraph (b) requires determining whether the person was habitually resident, in the sense that during a given period he was habitually present in one of the two States, but not in the other; it is not sufficient to simply determine in which of the two Contracting States the person spent more days during that period. the period. As used in the French version of subparagraph (b), the phrase "séjourné de facade habituelle" provides a convenient understanding of the meaning of the term "permanent residence" - a concept that refers to the frequency, duration and regularity of stay, which is part of the established routine of an individual's life and is therefore more than temporary. As recognized in subparagraph (c), an individual may have permanent residence in two States, which would be the case if that person had habitually stayed in each State for the relevant period, regardless of the fact that he has spent more days in one State than in the other. Suppose, for example, that for five years an individual has owned a house in both State A and State B, but the facts do not allow us to determine the State in which the center of vital interests of such a person is located. This individual works in State A, where he usually lives, but returns to State B for two days a month and once a year for a three-week vacation. In this case, his permanent place of residence will be considered State A, not B. However, let's assume that for the same period of five years, a person works for short periods of time in State A, where he returns 15 times a year to stay for two weeks, and the rest of the time he is present in State B the rest of the time (also let's assume that the circumstances of the case do not allow to determine the state in which the center of this person's vital interests is located). In this case, his permanent place of residence will be determined by both State A and State B.
19.1 Subparagraph (b) does not specify the time period for determining whether an individual has permanent residence in one or both States. The definition should cover a sufficient period of time so that it is possible to establish the frequency, duration and regularity of the stay, which is part of the established routine of a person's life. However, you should carefully consider the time period during which there have been no major changes in personal circumstances that would clearly affect the decision (for example, separation or divorce). The relevant period for determining whether an individual has permanent residence in one or both States will not always correspond to the period of dual residency, especially when such a period of dual residency is very short. This is confirmed by the following example. Let's assume that an individual residing in State C moves to State D to work elsewhere for 190 days. During this 190-day period, he is considered a resident of States C and D according to their domestic tax laws. An individual who has resided in State C for many years prior to moving to State D remains in State D for the duration of his employment and returns to State C for permanent residence at the end of the 190-day period. During the period of employment in State D, this individual has no available permanent residence in either State C or State D. In this example, when determining whether an individual has permanent residence in one or both States, it would be advisable to consider a period of time exceeding the 190-day period of dual residency in order to establish the frequency, duration and regularity of stay that were part of the established routine life of such an individual.
20. If, in the two situations referred to in subparagraph (b), an individual has permanent residence in both Contracting States or in neither of them, preference shall be given to the State of which he is a national. If, in these cases, the natural person is still a national of both Contracting States or of neither of them, subparagraph (d) imposes on the competent authorities the obligation to resolve the difficulties by mutual agreement in accordance with the procedure established in Article 25.
Point 3
21. This clause applies to companies and other associations of individuals, regardless of whether they are legal entities or not. In practice, a company, etc., can rarely be subject to taxation as a resident of more than one State, but, of course, this is possible if, for example, one State attaches great importance to registration, and another to the location of a permanent executive body. Thus, in the case of companies, etc., special rules regarding preferences should also be established.
22. When paragraph 3 was first drafted, it was considered that attaching importance to such a formal criterion as registration would not be an adequate solution, and preference was given to a rule based on the location of the permanent executive body, which should have been based on the place where the company was actually managed, etc.
23. However, in 2017, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs acknowledged that, although situations of dual residence of legal entities, with the exception of individuals, were relatively rare, there were a number of cases of tax evasion involving companies with dual residents. Therefore, the Committee concluded that the best solution to the problem of dual residency of legal entities would be an individual consideration of such situations on a case-by-case basis.
24. Based on these considerations, the current version of paragraph 3 provides that the competent authorities of the Contracting States will seek, by mutual agreement, to resolve cases of dual residence of a person who is not an individual.
24.1 It is expected that the competent authorities that should apply paragraph 3 will take into account various factors, for example, the location where meetings of the board of directors of the person or a similar body are usually held, where the CEO and other senior managers usually carry out their activities, where senior management carries out the day-to-day management of the person, where the headquarters is located this person, the laws of which country regulate the legal status of the person where accounting records are kept, whether there will be a definition of that, whether a legal entity is a resident of one but not the other Contracting State for the purposes of the Convention is at risk of misuse of the provisions of the Convention, etc. Countries that believe that competent authorities should not have the authority to address such cases of dual residency without specifying the factors that should be used for this purpose may wish to supplement the provision by specifying those or other factors that they consider important.
24.2 A determination in accordance with paragraph 3 is usually requested by the person concerned through the mechanism provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25. Such a request may be made as soon as it is probable that the person concerned will be considered a resident of each Contracting State in accordance with paragraph 1. In connection with the notification requirement in paragraph 1 of Article 25, it must in any case be made within three years from the date of the first notification to that person of tax measures taken by one or both States that indicate that that person has been denied benefits or privileges because of his dual residency status without so that the competent authorities have previously tried to determine a single State of residence in accordance with paragraph 3. The competent authorities to which the request for determining the place of residence is submitted in accordance with paragraph 3 must immediately consider it and inform the taxpayer of their response as soon as possible.
24.3 Since the facts on which the decision will be based may change over time, the competent authorities that make a decision in accordance with this provision should specify the time period covered by such a decision.
24.4 The last sentence of paragraph 3 provides that, in the absence of a determination by the competent authorities, a person with dual residence is not entitled to any relief or exemption from taxes under the Convention, except to the extent and in such a manner as may be agreed by the competent authorities. However, this will not prevent the taxpayer from being considered a resident of each Contracting State for purposes other than providing this person with benefits or exemptions under the contract. This would mean, for example, that the condition of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 of Article 15 would not be fulfilled in respect of an employee of a person who is a resident of one of the Contracting States and carries on work in another State. Similarly, if the person is a company, for the purposes of applying Article 10 to the dividends it will pay, it will be considered a resident of each State.
24.5 However, some States consider that in cases of dual residence of legal entities, it is preferable to apply a rule based on the "location of the permanent executive body", which was included in the Convention before 2017. These States also believe that this rule can be interpreted in a way that prevents abuse. States that share this point of view and agree on how the concept of "location of a permanent executive body" should be interpreted may, at their discretion, include the following version of paragraph 3 in their bilateral treaties:
If by reason of the provisions of paragraph 1 a person other than an individual is a resident of both Contracting States, then he shall be deemed to be a resident only of the State in which his permanent executive office is located.
Comments on the Comment
25. Chile would like to clarify that, with regard to paragraph 8.12, organizations that are not considered residents may also include pension funds, unless otherwise expressly provided by the convention.
26. Spain, due to the fact that, according to its domestic legislation, the financial year coincides with the calendar year, and there is no possibility of ending the financial period due to a change in the taxpayer's place of residence, will not be able to act in accordance with paragraph 10 of the Commentary to Article 4. In this case, a mutual agreement procedure will be required to establish the date from which the taxpayer will be considered a resident of one of the Contracting States.
27. Hungary cannot fully share the interpretation of paragraph 19 of the Commentary on the term "permanent residence". Hungary believes that during the verification of a person's permanent place of residence, priority should be given to comparing the number of days spent in each State over a certain period of time.
Reservations to the Article
28. Japan and Korea maintain their position with regard to the provisions of this and other articles of the Model Convention on Taxes, which directly or indirectly relate to the location of the permanent executive body. Instead of the term "location of a permanent executive body," these countries want to use the term "head office" in their agreements.
29. France does not agree with the general principle that if the tax due from a partnership is determined based on the personal characteristics of the partners, these partners are entitled to benefits under tax agreements concluded by the States of which they are residents in relation to income that "passes through" this partnership. For this reason, France reserves the right to amend this Article in its tax agreements to specify that French partnerships should be considered residents of France, taking into account their legal and tax characteristics, as well as to specify in what situations and under what conditions.
"passing through" partnerships located in another Contracting State or in a third State will be entitled to benefit from France's recognition of their "passing through" nature.
30. France reserves the right not to include a reference to "recognized pension funds" in paragraph 1 and thus treat pension funds in the same way as other organizations that do not meet the residency requirements.
31. The United States reserves the right to use place-of-incorporation verification to determine the residence of a corporation and, otherwise, to deny companies with dual residents certain benefits under the Convention.
32. Portugal and Sweden reserve the right not to include the words "as well as the recognized pension fund of this State" in paragraph 1 and to consider pension funds in accordance with the general definition of "resident" or special provisions agreed upon on a bilateral basis.
33. Israel reserves the right to include a separate provision regarding a trust that is resident in both Contracting States.
34. Estonia and Latvia reserve the right to include in paragraph 1 the place of incorporation of the company or a similar criterion.
35. Japan reserves the right to delete the phrase "except to the extent and in such a manner as may be agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States" in paragraph 3.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 5
REGARDING THE DEFINITION OF PERMANENT REPRESENTATION
1. Primarily, the concept of permanent establishment; used to define the right of a State to tax the profits of an enterprise of another Contracting State. According to Article 7, a Contracting State may not tax the profits of an enterprise of the other Contracting State unless it conducts its business through a permanent establishment located in it.
2. Until 2000, income for the provision of professional services or other independent activities was regulated by a separate article, i.e. Article 14. The provisions of this Article were similar to those governing the profits of an enterprise, but this Article did not use the concept of "permanent establishment", but the concept of
"permanent base", since it was initially believed that the first concept should be reserved for commercial and industrial activities. The deletion of Article 14 in 2000 reflected the fact that there should have been no difference between the concept of permanent establishment used in Article 7 and the concept of a permanent base used in Article 14, as well as between the methods of calculating profits and taxes set out in Articles 7 and 14. Thus, the deletion of Article 14 meant that everything that had previously been considered a permanent base now fell under the definition of a permanent establishment.
3. In 2017, a number of changes were made to the text of this Commentary. Some of these changes were intended to clarify the interpretation of the Article and, as such, should be taken into account for the purposes of interpreting and applying conventions concluded before their adoption, as they reflect the consensus of OECD member countries on the correct interpretation of existing provisions and their application in specific situations (see paragraph 35 of the Introduction).
4. The amendments to this commentary related to the addition of paragraph 4.1 and the amendment of paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of this Article, which were introduced as a result of the adoption of the report on Action 7 of the OECD/G20 project on the dilution of the tax base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation, were, however, only intended and, as such, do not affect the interpretation of the former provisions of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes and the treaties in which these provisions are included, in particular with regard to the interpretation of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the Article in the form in which they were presented before these amendments (see paragraph 4 of this Report)
5. In many countries, a foreign enterprise may have a permit or should be required to register for the purposes of value added tax or goods and services tax (VAT/GST), regardless of whether it has a permanent place of business in that State through which activities are carried out in whole or in part, or whether it is considered to have a permanent establishment in in that State, in accordance with paragraph 5 of Article 5. However, the VAT/GST regime itself is irrelevant for the purposes of interpreting and applying the definition of permanent establishment in the Convention; therefore, when applying this definition, no conclusions should be drawn based on the regime of a foreign enterprise for VAT/GST purposes, including the fact that a foreign enterprise is registered for VAT purposes./GST.1
___________________________________________
1 See paragraph 337 of the BEPS Project Action 1 Report ("... it is important to emphasize that registration for VAT purposes does not depend on determining whether a permanent establishment exists for income tax purposes."), OECD (2015), Solving Tax Problems of the Digital Economy, Event 1 - 2015 Final Report, OECD/G20 Project on the dilution of the tax base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation, OECD Publishing House, Paris, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787 / 9789264241046-en. Footnote 24 to the International VAT/GST Guidelines ("For the purposes of these Guidelines, it is assumed that an enterprise includes a permanent place of business with a sufficient level of infrastructure in terms of people, systems and assets to be able to receive and/or make reserves. Registration for VAT purposes alone is not an institution for the purposes of this Guide. Countries are encouraged to publish information about what constitutes an "enterprise" in accordance with their domestic VAT legislation."), OECD (2017), International VAT/GST Regulations, OECD Publishing House, Paris, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264271401-en .
Point 1
6. Paragraph 1 provides a general definition of the term "permanent establishment", which highlights the main characteristics of a permanent establishment in the sense of the Convention, that is, a separate "place of business", a "permanent place of business". In the paragraph, the term
A "permanent establishment" is defined as a permanent place of business through which the activities of an enterprise are carried out in whole or in part. Thus, this definition contains the following conditions:
– the presence of a "place of business", i.e. an object such as office space, or, in some cases, machinery or equipment;
– this place of business activity should be
"permanent", i.e. it must be organized as an independent object with a certain degree of permanence.;
– carrying out the company's activities through such a permanent place of business. This usually means that persons who depend on the enterprise in one way or another (personnel) carry out the activities of the enterprise in the State in which the permanent place of business is located.
7. Perhaps it can be argued that within the framework of the general definition, one more characteristic feature of a permanent establishment should also be mentioned, which in the past was sometimes given some importance, namely that a permanent establishment should be of a production nature, i.e. contribute to the profit of the enterprise. This characteristic feature is not reflected in the present definition. It is safe to assume that within the framework of a well-established business activity, each participant contributes to overall productivity. Of course, not in every case any enterprise that has a broader context of the entire organization.
As a result, a "production facility" is a permanent establishment to which profits can be properly attributed for tax purposes in a particular territory (cf. Comment to paragraph 4).
8. It is also important to note that the way of doing business has evolved over the years, so the facts and agreements applicable at a certain point in time may no longer matter after the way of doing business in a given State has changed. Obviously, the question of whether a permanent establishment exists in a State for a certain period should be determined on the basis of the circumstances applicable during that period, rather than those applicable during the past or future period, for example, the period preceding the adoption of new arrangements that have changed the way business is conducted.
9. In addition, the determination of whether an enterprise of one Contracting State has a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State should be made independently of the determination of which provisions of the Convention apply to the profits earned by that enterprise. For example, a farm or apartment rental office located in one Contracting State and operated by a resident of the other Contracting State may constitute a permanent establishment, regardless of whether the profits relating to such a permanent establishment would constitute income from immovable property covered by Article 6.; Although the presence of a permanent establishment in such cases may not be relevant to the application of Article 6, it will remain relevant for the purposes of other provisions, such as paragraphs 4 and 5 of Article 11, subparagraph (c) of paragraph 2 of Article 15 and paragraph 3 of Article 24.
10. The term "place of business activity" includes any office premises, facilities or installations used for carrying out business activities of an enterprise, regardless of whether they are used exclusively for this purpose. The availability of a place of business can also be discussed in the case when office space is not available or is not required for the conduct of business activities of an enterprise that makes do with its existing certain areas. The question of whether these office premises, facilities or installations belong to the enterprise, are leased by it or are otherwise at its disposal does not matter. Thus, the place of business may mean a shipment of goods on the market or any permanently used area in a customs warehouse (for example, for storing goods subject to duty). In addition, the place of business may be located in the office premises of another company. This applies, for example, in cases where certain office premises (or part of them) belonging to another enterprise are permanently at the disposal of a foreign enterprise.
11. As noted above, the very fact that an enterprise has at its disposal certain areas that are used for conducting business is sufficient to consider these areas as a place of business. Thus, no formal legal right to use this place is required. For example, a permanent establishment may exist in the event that an enterprise illegally occupies a certain premises from which it carries out its business activities.
12. Although no formal legal right to use a particular location is required for a particular location to be a permanent establishment, the mere presence of an enterprise at a particular location does not necessarily mean that the location is at the disposal of that enterprise. The decision on whether a location can be considered to be at the disposal of an enterprise in such a way that it can constitute a "place of business through which the activities of [this] enterprise are carried out in whole or in part" will depend on whether that enterprise has effective authority to use the location, as well as the extent to which the enterprise is present in this place and the types of activities it performs there. This is confirmed by the following examples. If an enterprise has the exclusive legal right to use a certain place, which is used only for conducting its own business activities (for example, if this place is in its legal possession), then this place is clearly at the disposal of the enterprise. This will also be the case when an enterprise is allowed to use a certain location that belongs to another enterprise or that is used by several enterprises, and carries out its business activities in this location on an ongoing basis for a long period of time. However, this does not apply to cases where the presence of an enterprise in any place is so intermittent or accidental that this place cannot be considered the place of business of such an enterprise (for example, when employees of the enterprise have access to the premises of associated enterprises that they often visit, but do not work in these premises for a long period of time). If an enterprise does not have the right to be present in any place and, in fact, does not use this place, such a place is clearly not at the disposal of the enterprise.; Thus, for example, it cannot be considered that a factory that is owned and used exclusively by a supplier or manufacturer under a contract is at the disposal of an enterprise that receives goods produced at that factory, just because all these goods are used in the business activities of such an enterprise (see also paragraphs 65, 66 and 121 below). It is also important to remember that even if the place is a place of business through which the company's activities are partially carried out, this place will not be considered a permanent establishment if paragraph 4 applies to business activities carried out in this place.
13. To illustrate these principles, the following additional examples can be given of a situation where representatives of one enterprise are present on the territory of another enterprise.
14. The first example is an example of a merchant who regularly visits a large client to receive orders and at the same time meets with the purchasing director in his office. In this case, the client's premises are not at the disposal of the enterprise for which this merchant works, and therefore are not a permanent place of business through which this enterprise carries out its business activities (however, depending on the circumstances, according to paragraph 5, the presence of a permanent representative office may be presumed).
15. The second example is an example of an employee of a company who is allowed to use an office at the head office of another company (for example, a newly acquired branch) for a long time to ensure that the latter company fulfills its obligations under contracts concluded with the first company. In this case, the employee carries out activities related to the business activities of the first company, and the office at his disposal at the head office of the other company will be a permanent representative office of his employer, provided that this office will be at his disposal for a sufficiently long time to be considered
"permanent place of business" (see paragraphs 28-34), and that the activities carried out in this office are not limited to the types of activities listed in paragraph 4 of the Article.
16. The third example is an example of a cargo carrier that has been using a loading dock in a buyer's warehouse on a daily basis for a number of years to deliver goods purchased by that buyer. In this case, the presence of the cargo carrier company at the loading area will be so limited that this company cannot consider the specified site as available to it, so that this site can be considered a permanent representative office of this enterprise.
17. The fourth example is that of a house painter who has been working three days a week in a large office building of his main client for two years. In this case, the presence of the painter in this office building, where he performs the most important functions of his business (i.e. paints the walls), is the permanent representation of this painter.
18. Even if part of the business of an enterprise can be carried out in a place such as an individual's home office, this should not automatically lead to the conclusion that this place is at the disposal of this enterprise simply because this place is used by an individual (for example, an employee) who works at the enterprise. Whether the head office will be at the disposal of the company will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. In many cases, doing business in the home of an individual (for example, an employee) will be so intermittent or casual that the home will not be considered a place at the disposal of the enterprise (see paragraph 12 above). However, if the home office is used on a permanent basis to conduct the business of an enterprise, and it is clear from the facts and circumstances that the enterprise required an individual to use this location to conduct the business of the enterprise (for example, by not providing an office to an employee in circumstances where the nature of the work clearly requires an office), the home office may be considered to be at the disposal of businesses.
19. A striking example is a non-resident consultant who has been present in a given State for an extended period of time, where he carries out most of the business activities of his own consulting company from an office located in his home in that State; in this case, such a head office is a place at the disposal of the enterprise. However, if an employee of the border territories performs most of his work from his home located in one State, rather than from an office provided to him in another State, one should not assume that the house is at the disposal of the enterprise, since the enterprise did not require that the house be used for business activities. However, it should be noted that, since the vast majority of employees live in a State where their employer has one or more enterprises at their disposal, to which these employees report, the question of whether the head office is a place at the disposal of the enterprise is rarely a practical problem. In addition, activities performed in the home office will often be simply ancillary and, therefore, will fall under the exclusion of paragraph 4.
20. The words "through which" should be interpreted broadly as referring to any situation where entrepreneurial activity is carried out at a specific point at the disposal of the enterprise for this purpose. So, for example, it will be considered that an enterprise engaged in asphalting a road carries out its business activities "through" the point where this activity is carried out.
21. According to the definition, the place of business should be "permanent". Thus, there should usually be a connection between the place of business and a specific geographical point. It does not matter how long an enterprise of one of the Contracting States has been operating in the other Contracting State, as long as it does not do so in a specific location, however, this does not mean that the equipment representing the place of business must actually be attached to the place where it is located. It is sufficient that this equipment is permanently located at a specific site (see, however, paragraph 57 below).
22. In cases where the nature of the business carried out by an enterprise requires frequent movement of this activity between neighboring locations, it may be difficult to determine a single "place of business" (if an enterprise operates from two locations and the remaining requirements of Article 5 are met, then, of course, it will be considered that the enterprise it has two permanent representative offices). As recognized in paragraphs 51 and 57 below, a single place of business is generally considered to exist in cases where, given the nature of the business activity, it is possible to consider the specific area within which the business is located as forming a commercially and geographically unified whole with respect to that activity.
23. This principle can be illustrated by the following examples. It is obvious that the mine represents a single place of business, even though activities may move from place to place within the mine, which can be very large, since from the point of view of the mining enterprise, the mine represents a single geographical and commercial unit. Similarly, an "office and hotel complex" in which a consulting firm regularly rents various office premises can be considered a single place of business for this firm, since in this case the building represents a geographical whole, and the hotel is a single place of business for this consulting firm. For the same reason, a pedestrian street, an outdoor market, or a fair, in various parts of which a merchant regularly sets up his tent, represents a single place of business for this merchant.
24. On the contrary, in the absence of commercial unity, the fact that certain activities can be carried out within a limited geographical area should not give grounds to consider this area as a single place of business. For example, when a painter consistently performs work under a number of unrelated contracts for several unrelated clients in a large office building, so that it cannot be argued that this is a single building repainting project, the building should not be considered a single place of business for the purposes of said activity. However, in the case of a house painter who, working under a single contract, performs work in the entire building for a single client, this activity represents a single project for said house painter, in which case the building as a whole can be considered as a single place of business for the purposes of said activity, since in this case it will represent commercially and geographically a single whole.
25. Conversely, an area in which activities are carried out within the framework of a single project, which from a commercial point of view is a single whole, may not have the necessary geographical unity that allows this area to be considered a single place of business. For example, when a consultant works in different branches in different locations as part of a single bank employee training project, each such branch should be considered separately. However, if a consultant moves from one office to another within the same department, he should be considered remaining in the same place of business activity. The location of one department has geographical unity, which is absent when the consultant moves between departments located at different points.
26. A vessel operating in international waters or in one or more States is not a fixed and therefore not a permanent place of business (unless the operation of the vessel is limited to a specific territory characterized by commercial and geographical consistency). Business activities carried out on board such a vessel, such as the operation of a shop or restaurant, should be treated equally for the purposes of determining whether paragraph 1 applies (paragraph 5, however, may apply to some of these activities, for example, when contracts are concluded when such shops or restaurants operate in the territory of a State).
27. Obviously, a permanent establishment can be considered located in one of the Contracting States if the place of business is located on the territory of that State. The question of whether a satellite in geostationary orbit can be a permanent mission of the satellite operator is partly related to the question of how far the territory of States extends into outer space. None of the Member countries will agree that the location of these satellites may be part of the territory of one of the Contracting States in accordance with applicable international law and, therefore, they could be considered as permanent missions located in that State. In addition, a specific area in which it is possible to receive satellite signals (the satellite coverage area) cannot be considered as being at the disposal of the satellite operator, which would make this area the place of business of the satellite operator.
28. Since the place of business must be permanent, a permanent establishment can be considered operational only if the place of business is to a certain extent permanent, i.e. if it is not purely temporary. The place of business may, however, be a permanent establishment even if, in practice, it exists for a very short period of time, since the nature of the business activity is such that it will only be carried out for that short period of time. Sometimes it is difficult to determine if this is really the case. Although, from the point of view of time requirements, today it is not necessary to say that the practice followed by the member countries is consistent, experience shows that usually permanent missions are not considered to operate in situations where business activities are carried out in a particular country through an office that operates for less than six months (on the contrary, as practice shows that in many cases a permanent establishment is considered to exist if it has been operating for more than six months). One exception concerns repetitive activities; in such cases, each period during which a given location is used must be combined with the number of times that location is used (which can last for years). Another exception concerns activities of the nature of entrepreneurial activity carried out exclusively in a given country; in this situation, entrepreneurial activity may be short-lived due to its nature, but since it is carried out entirely in a given country, its connection with that country is stronger. For administrative convenience, countries may wish to take this practice into account when settling disputes over whether a particular place of business that has existed for only a short period of time is a permanent establishment.
29. One exception to general practice concerns repetitive activities; in such cases, each period during which a given location is used must be combined with the number of times that location is used (which can last for years). This exception is confirmed by the following example. An enterprise of State P conducts drilling operations in a remote Arctic area in State C. Seasonal conditions in this place do not allow such operations to be carried out for more than three months a year, but they are expected to last five years. In this case, given the nature of the activity at that location, it can be assumed that, due to the repetitive nature of the activity, the temporary requirements for permanent representation have been met, regardless of the fact that any permanent presence lasts less than six months; the time requirement can be fulfilled similarly in the case of shorter repetitive periods of time that will be they are dictated by the specifics of the relevant activity.
30. Another exception concerns activities of the nature of entrepreneurial activity carried out exclusively in a given country; in this situation, entrepreneurial activity may be short-lived due to its nature, but since it is carried out entirely in a given country, its connection with that country is stronger. This exception is confirmed by the following example. A resident of State R has learned that a television documentary will be filmed in a remote village in State S, where her parents still own a large house. The documentary will require the presence of several actors and technicians in this village for four months. This resident contractually agrees with the producer of the documentary to provide catering services to actors and technicians for a four-month period, and in accordance with this contract, she uses her parents' house as a dining room, in which she works as an individual entrepreneur during this period. This is the only business activity that she conducted, therefore, after this period, the company ceases to exist; the dining room, therefore, will be the only place where the business of this enterprise will be fully carried out. In this case, we can assume that the time requirements for a permanent representative office have been met, since Solovaya has been working throughout the entire existence of this particular enterprise. However, this will not be the situation where a resident company of State R, which operates various catering establishments in State R, will operate a cafeteria in State S during the four-month production of the documentary. In this case, the company's activities, which are constantly conducted in State R, are only temporarily carried out in State S.
31. For administrative convenience, countries may wish to take these practices, as reflected in paragraphs 28-30, into account when resolving differences on whether a particular place of business, which has existed for only a short period of time, is a permanent establishment.
32. As indicated in paragraphs 44 and 55, the temporary termination of activities cannot be considered the closure of a permanent establishment. In addition, as stated in paragraph 6, when a particular place of business is used for very limited periods of time, but such use occurs regularly for a long time, such a place of business should not be considered as being purely temporary.
33. In addition, there may be cases when a particular place of business is used for very short periods of time by a number of similar enterprises run by the same person or related persons, in an attempt to create the impression that this place is used by each particular enterprise exclusively for a short period of time. In such cases, the observations in paragraphs 52 and 53 regarding procedures designed to circumvent the twelve-month period provided for in paragraph 3 will be valid.
34. If a place of business, which from the very beginning was created exclusively for use for a short period of time so that it would not be considered a permanent establishment, continues to operate for a period that no longer allows it to be considered temporary, then this place becomes a permanent place of business and, retrospectively, a permanent establishment. A place of business can also be considered a permanent establishment from the moment it was established, even if in reality such a place existed only for a very short period of time due to the fact that due to special circumstances (for example, the death of a taxpayer, lack of investment) it was prematurely liquidated.
35. In order for the place of business to be a permanent establishment, the enterprise that uses it must fully or partially carry out its business activities through it. As noted in paragraph 3 above, the activity does not necessarily have to be of a production nature. In addition, these activities do not have to be continuous in the sense that operations should be continuous, but operations should be carried out on a regular basis.
36. If tangible property such as facilities, industrial, commercial or scientific (PTN) equipment and buildings, or intangible property such as patents, technological procedures and similar property, are leased or leased to third parties through a permanent place of business maintained by an enterprise of one of the Contracting States in another State, then this The activity, as a rule, leads to the fact that the place of business activity is considered a permanent establishment. The same can be said with regard to the receipt of capital through a permanent place of business. If an enterprise of one of the States rents or leases facilities, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, buildings or intangible property to an enterprise of another State, without carrying out such leasing or leasing activities through a permanent place of business in another State, then the leased facilities, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment buildings or intangible property as such will not constitute a permanent establishment of the lessor, provided that the contract is limited to the simple rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, etc. This also applies to cases where, for example, the lessor provides personnel for the operation of the equipment after installation work, provided that the duties of these personnel are limited exclusively to the operation and maintenance of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment under the management, responsibility or control of the lessee. If such personnel have a broader range of responsibilities, for example, they participate in making decisions regarding the work for which the equipment is used, or if such personnel operate, maintain, inspect and maintain equipment under the responsibility and control of the lessor, then the activities of such a lessor may go beyond the usual rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and It may represent an entrepreneurial activity. In such a case, if the criterion of permanence is met, it can be assumed that a permanent establishment exists. If such activities are related to or of a similar nature to the activities referred to in paragraph 3, a twelve-month time limit shall apply. Other cases should be determined according to the circumstances.
37. Container leasing is a special case of long—term lease of industrial or commercial equipment, which, however, has its own characteristics. The issue of determining the circumstances in which a container leasing company should be considered to have a permanent establishment in another State is discussed in more detail in the report entitled "Taxation of income received from leasing containers".20
38. Another example where an enterprise cannot be considered to be operating, in whole or in part, through its place of business is when the telecommunications operator of a Contracting State enters into a roaming agreement with a foreign operator to allow its users to connect to the telecommunications network of a foreign operator. According to such an agreement, a user who is located outside the geographical coverage of that user's home network can automatically make and receive voice calls, send and receive data, or access other services using someone else's network. The foreign network operator then bills the operator of that user's home network for this usage. According to a typical roaming agreement, the home network operator simply transfers calls to a foreign operator's network and does not work, and does not have physical access to this network. For these reasons, any place where a foreign network is located cannot be considered as being at the disposal of a home network operator and, therefore, cannot be a permanent representative office of this operator.
39. There are different ways in which an enterprise can conduct its business. In most cases, the company's activities are carried out by an entrepreneur or persons employed at this enterprise (personnel). Such personnel include employees and others who receive instructions from the company (for example, hired agents). The authority of such personnel in their dealings with third parties is irrelevant. It does not matter whether the employed agent is authorized to conclude contracts if he works at the permanent place of business of the enterprise (see item 100 below). However, as explained in paragraph 8.11 of the Commentary to Article 15, there may be cases where persons officially employed by an enterprise will actually conduct the business of another enterprise and, therefore, the first enterprise should not be considered as operating in the place where these persons will perform this work. Within a multinational group, it is quite common for employees of one company to be temporarily transferred to another company in the group and engage in activities that clearly relate to the business of that other company. In such cases, administrative reasons (for example, the need to maintain seniority or pension rights) often prevent a change in the employment contract. The analysis described in paragraphs 8.13 to 8.15 of the Commentary to Article 15 will be relevant in order to distinguish these cases from other cases where employees of a foreign enterprise carry out their own business activities at this enterprise.
40. The company can also operate through subcontractors acting independently or together with employees of the company. In this case, a permanent establishment will exist for the enterprise only if the other conditions of Article 5 are met (however, this does not address the separate issue of what profits relate to such a permanent establishment). In the context of paragraph 1, the existence of a permanent establishment in these circumstances will require these subcontractors to carry out the work of the enterprise at a permanent place of business, which is at the disposal of the enterprise. Whether this enterprise has a permanent place of business at its disposal, where subcontractors carry out the work of the enterprise, will be determined on the basis of the instructions in paragraph 12.; however, in the absence of employees of the enterprise, it will be necessary to show that such a place is at the disposal of the enterprise on the basis of other factors showing that the enterprise clearly has effective authority to use this site, for example, because the enterprise owns or legally owns this place and controls access to it and its use. Paragraph 54 illustrates this situation in the case of a construction site; it could have happened in other situations. An example would be a case where an enterprise that owns a small hotel and rents out hotel rooms via the Internet has subcontracted the operation of the hotel to a company that receives remuneration based on the "cost plus" principle.
___________________________
20 Is reproduced in volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Convention on Taxes on page R(3)-1.
41. But a permanent establishment may also exist if the business activities of the enterprise are carried out mainly through automated equipment, and the activities of the staff are limited to the adjustment, operation, control and maintenance of such equipment. Thus, the question of whether slot machines and vending machines and similar mechanisms installed by an enterprise of one State in another State can be considered a permanent establishment depends on whether this enterprise is engaged in any business activity other than the initial installation of such machines. A permanent establishment does not exist if the company simply installs automatic machines and then rents them out to other companies. However, a permanent establishment may exist if the company that installs the machines also provides their operation and maintenance at its own expense. This also applies in cases where such machines are operated and serviced by an agent employed by the company.
42. It follows from the definition of "enterprises of a Contracting State" in Article 3 that the term used in Article 7 and the term "enterprise" used in Article 5 refer to any form of enterprise operated by a resident of a Contracting State, regardless of whether the enterprise is legally established as a company, partnership, individual an enterprise or other legal form. Different enterprises may cooperate within the same project, and the question of whether their cooperation forms a separate enterprise (for example, in the form of a partnership) is a matter that depends on the facts and domestic legislation of each State. Obviously, if two individuals, each of whom runs a separate enterprise, decide to create a company in which these individuals are shareholders, the company is a legal entity that will deal with what becomes another separate enterprise. However, it often happens that different enterprises simply agree that each of them should carry out a separate part of the same project, and that these enterprises will not jointly conduct business activities, will not share their profits, and will not be responsible for each other's project-related activities, even if they can share the overall result of the project or the reward for the actions that will be performed in the context of this project. In this case, it would be difficult to consider that a separate enterprise has been created. Although such an agreement would be referred to as a "joint venture" in many countries, the meaning of the term "joint venture" depends on domestic law, and therefore it is possible that in some countries the term "joint venture" would refer to a distinct entity.
43. In the case of an enterprise that takes the form of a tax-transparent partnership, the enterprise is managed by each partner and, therefore, with respect to the respective partners' profit shares, is an enterprise of each Contracting State of which the resident is a partner. If such a partnership has a permanent establishment in a Contracting State, each partner's share of the profits attributable to the permanent establishment will, for the purposes of Article 7, be the profits earned by the enterprise of the Contracting State in which that partner is resident (see also paragraph 56 below).
44. The existence of a permanent representative office begins from the moment when it begins to carry out its business activities through a permanent place of business. This happens as soon as the company begins to engage in activities at the place of business for which such a place should be constantly used. The period of time during which an enterprise establishes this permanent place of business should not be taken into account, provided that this activity is significantly different from the activity for which this place should be constantly used. A permanent establishment ceases to exist with the liquidation of its permanent place of business or the termination of any activities carried out through it, i.e. when all actions and measures related to the former activities of the permanent mission are terminated (termination of current business operations, maintenance and repair of facilities). At the same time, the temporary termination of operations cannot be considered a closure. If a permanent place of business is leased to another company, then, as a rule, it will only be engaged in servicing this enterprise, and not the lessor.; as a rule, the permanent representative office of the lessor ceases to exist, except in cases when it continues to engage in independent entrepreneurial activity through a permanent place of business.
Item 2
45. This paragraph contains a list (by no means exhaustive) of examples of commercial enterprises, each of which can be considered as constituting a permanent establishment in accordance with paragraph 1, provided that it meets the requirements of this paragraph. Since these examples should be considered in the context of the general definition given in paragraph 1, the listed terms are "place of management", "branch", "office", etc. Such commercial enterprises should be interpreted in such a way that they are permanent establishments only if they meet the requirements of paragraph 1 and are not commercial enterprises to which paragraph 4 applies.
46. The term "management location" is mentioned separately because it is not necessarily an "office". However, if the laws of two Contracting States do not contain the concept of a "place of management" as opposed to an "office", there is no need to refer to the first term in their bilateral convention.
47. Subparagraph (f) provides that mines, oil or gas wells, quarries or any other place of extraction of natural resources are permanent representations. The term "any other place of extraction of natural resources" should be interpreted broadly. It includes, for example, all hydrocarbon production sites on land or at sea.
48. Subparagraph (f) refers to the extraction of natural resources, but does not mention the exploration of such resources, whether onshore or offshore. Consequently, whenever income from such activities is considered to be business profit, the question of whether this activity is carried out through a permanent establishment is regulated by paragraph 1. However, since it has proved impossible to achieve consensus on the main issues of who owns tax rights and which category income from exploration activities belongs to, the Contracting States may agree to include special provisions. For example, they may agree that an enterprise of one of the Contracting States, in connection with its activities for the exploration of natural resources in a place or area of the other Contracting State:
(a) Is deemed not to have a permanent establishment in that other State; or
(b) Is considered to be carrying out such activities through a permanent establishment in that other State; or
c) is considered to be carrying out such activities through a permanent establishment in that other State if the duration of such activities exceeds the prescribed period.
In addition, the Contracting States may agree to extend some other rule to income from such activities.
Point 3
49. This paragraph explicitly provides that a construction site or a construction or installation facility is a permanent establishment only if the duration of the related work exceeds 12 months. Any of those facilities that do not meet this condition is not in itself a permanent establishment, even if it includes a structure, such as an office or workshop within the meaning of paragraph 2, related to construction activities. However, when such an office or workshop is used for a number of construction projects and the activities carried out by such a structure are not limited to the types mentioned in paragraph 4, this structure will be considered a permanent establishment, subject to the remaining provisions of this article, even if none of the facilities provides for work related to the construction site or construction or installation facility., lasting more than 12 months. Therefore, in this situation, the location of the workshop or office will be different from that of a site or facility that is never considered a permanent establishment, and it is important to ensure that profits properly related to the functions performed through this office or workshop are attributed to the permanent establishment, taking into account the assets used and the risks assumed through this office or workshop. a workshop belonging to a permanent mission. This may include profits attributed to functions performed in connection with various construction sites, but only to the extent that these functions properly relate to the office.
50. The term "construction site or construction or installation facility" includes not only the construction of buildings, but also the construction of roads, bridges and canals, major repairs (not limited to simple routine or cosmetic repairs) of buildings, roads, bridges or canals, laying pipelines, excavation and dredging. In addition, the term
The "installation facility" is not limited to installation within the framework of construction; it also includes the installation of new equipment, such as complex mechanisms, in existing buildings or in outdoor areas. Paragraph 3 also covers work on the design of the construction site and supervision of the construction of buildings. States wishing to amend the text of this paragraph to clearly reflect the latter provision may do so in their bilateral agreements.
51. Testing for a period of 12 months is applied to each individual site or facility. When determining the duration of a site or facility, the time previously spent by the relevant contractor on other sites or facilities that are completely unrelated to it should not be taken into account. A construction site should be considered a single entity, even if it was created on the basis of several contracts, provided that it clearly represents a single entity from a commercial and geographical point of view. Subject to this provision, the construction site is a single entity, even if orders were placed by several persons (for example, for a number of houses).
52. The twelve-month threshold allows for abuse: there have been cases where companies (mainly contractors or subcontractors working on the continental shelf or engaged in activities related to the exploration and development of the continental shelf) divide their contracts into several parts, each of which covers a period of less than twelve months and relates to a separate company that, however, it belongs to the same group. In addition to the fact that such abuses may, depending on the circumstances, be subject to legislative or judicial rules against tax evasion, these violations can also be eliminated by applying the rule on non-abuse of paragraph 9 of Article 29, as shown by example J in paragraph 182 of the Commentary to Article 29. Nevertheless, some States may wish to directly combat such abuses. Moreover, States that do not include paragraph 9 of Article 29 in their treaties should include an additional provision governing the division of contracts. Such a position can, for example, be formulated as follows:
For the sole purpose of determining whether the twelve-month period specified in paragraph 3 has been exceeded,
(a) If an enterprise of one Contracting State carries on business in the other Contracting State in a place that constitutes a construction site or a construction or installation project and this activity is carried out for one or more periods of time that collectively exceed 30 days but not more than twelve months, and
(b) Related activities are carried out at the same construction site or at the same construction or installation facility for different periods of time, each exceeding 30 days, by one or more enterprises closely associated with the first-mentioned enterprise, these different periods of time should be added to the period of time during which the first-mentioned enterprise conducted activities at this construction site or construction or installation facility.
The concept of "closely related enterprises", which is used in the above provision, is defined in paragraph 8 of the Article (see paragraphs 119-121 below).
53. For the purposes of the alternative provision in paragraph 52, determining whether an activity is related will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. Factors that may be of particular importance for this purpose include the following:
– Have contracts covering different types of activities been concluded with the same person or related persons;
– is the conclusion of additional agreements with a person a logical consequence of the previous agreement concluded with this person or related persons;
– would the activity be covered by one contract without taking into account tax planning;
– Are the types of work under different contracts the same?;
– whether the same employees carry out activities under different contracts.
54. The site exists from the moment when the contractor begins his work, including any preparatory work, in the country where the construction is to be carried out, for example, when he creates a design bureau for construction. If the enterprise (general contractor) that has undertaken the implementation of the entire facility transfers parts of this facility under a subcontract agreement to other enterprises (subcontractors), then the time spent by the subcontractor working on the construction site should be considered as the time spent by the general contractor on the construction of the facility for the purpose of determining the presence of a permanent representative office for the general contractor. In this case, the site should be considered to be at the disposal of the general contractor during the time spent at that site by any subcontractor, if circumstances indicate that during that time the general contractor clearly has the construction site at his disposal for reasons such as the fact that he is the rightful owner of the site, controls access to and use of it and bears overall responsibility for what happens in that place during that period. The subcontractor himself has a permanent representative office on the site if the duration of his activity on it exceeds twelve months.
55 . In general, the site exists until the completion or final termination of work. Thus, the period during which a building or its facilities are tested by a contractor or subcontractor should usually be included in the period during which the construction site exists. In practice, the transfer of a building or facilities to a client usually represents the end of the work period, provided that the contractor and subcontractors no longer work on the facility after its transfer for completion purposes. The temporary suspension of work cannot be considered the termination of the site's existence. When determining the duration of the site's existence, seasonal or other temporary interruptions should be taken into account. Seasonal breaks include breaks caused by bad weather. A temporary break may be caused, for example, by a shortage of materials or labor difficulties. So, for example, if a contractor started road work on May 1, suspended this work on November 1 due to bad weather conditions or lack of materials and resumed it on February 1 of the following year, completing the construction of the road on June 1, then his construction site is considered a permanent establishment, since between the date of commencement of work (May 1) and the date of Thirteen months have passed since its final completion (on June 1 of the following year). Work performed on the site after completion of construction work in accordance with a warranty that requires the company to carry out repairs is usually not included in the initial construction period. However, depending on the circumstances, any subsequent work (including work performed under warranty) performed at the facility over an extended period of time may need to be taken into account to determine whether such work is performed through a separate permanent establishment. For example, if, after the completion of a technologically advanced construction project, the contractor's or subcontractor's employees remain on the construction site for four weeks to train the owner's employees, such training work is not considered work performed for the purpose of completing the construction project. Concerns related to the division of contracts in order to avoid the inclusion of subsequent construction work in the initial construction project are addressed in paragraph 52 above.
56. In the case of tax-transparent partnerships, the twelve-month criterion is applied at the partnership level in relation to its own activities. If the period of time spent on the site by the partners and employees of this partnership exceeds twelve months, then in this case the company managed by the partnership will be considered a permanent establishment. Thus, for tax purposes, each partner's share of the company's profits earned by the partnership will be considered to have a permanent establishment, regardless of how much time they have physically spent on the site. Suppose, for example, that a resident of State A and a resident of State B are partners in a partnership established in State B that carries out its construction activities on a construction site located in State C for 10 months. Although the double taxation agreement between States A and C is identical to the OECD Model, Paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the treaty between State B and State C stipulates that a construction site is a permanent establishment only if it has existed for more than 8 months. In this case, the time frame of each agreement will be applied at the partnership level, but only with respect to each partner's share of the profits provided for in this agreement.; Since contracts provide for different time thresholds, State C will have the right to tax the share of partnership profits attributable to a partner who is a resident of State B, but will not have the right to tax the share attributable to a partner who is a resident of State A. This is a consequence of the fact that, although the provisions of Paragraph 3 of each contract apply at the level of the same enterprise (i.e. partnership), the result differs with respect to the different shares of the partnership's profits depending on the time: the threshold of the contract that applies to each share.
57. The very nature of the construction or installation facility may be such that it forces the contractor to constantly or at least from time to time change the location of its activities as work is carried out on the site. This may be the case, for example, during the construction of roads or canals, dredging waterways or laying pipelines. By analogy, in cases where parts of a large structure, such as an offshore platform, are assembled at different points in a country and transported to another point in the same country for final installation, this work is considered part of a single facility. In such cases, the absence of a workforce in any particular location for twelve months makes no difference. The activities carried out in each specific location are part of a single facility, and this facility should be considered a permanent establishment if the duration of the related work as a whole is more than twelve months.
Item 4
58. This paragraph lists a number of business activities that are considered exceptions to the general definition set out in paragraph 1, and which, when carried out through permanent locations, are insufficient for these locations to constitute permanent representative offices. The final part of the Paragraph states that these exceptions apply only if the listed activities are preparatory or auxiliary in nature. Since subparagraph (e) applies to any activity that is not otherwise specified in the Paragraph (provided that this activity is preparatory or auxiliary in nature), the provisions of the Paragraph actually constitute a general limitation on the scope of the definition of permanent establishment contained in paragraph 1 and, when read with this Paragraph, constitute a more selective check by which It is possible to determine what constitutes a permanent establishment. To a large extent, these provisions limit the definition in paragraph 1 and exclude from its rather broad scope a number of permanent places of business, which, due to the fact that business activities carried out through these places are only preparatory or auxiliary in nature, should not be considered permanent representations. It is recognized that such a place of business could well contribute to increasing the productivity of the enterprise, however, the services provided by it are so far removed from the place of actual profit realization that it is difficult to attribute any profit to this permanent place of business. In addition, subparagraph (f) provides that a combination of the activities referred to in subparagraphs (a) to (e) in the same permanent place of business is considered not to constitute a permanent establishment, provided (as expressed in the final part of the paragraph) that the overall activity of the permanent place of business as a result of such a combination has a preparatory character. or an auxiliary character. Thus, the provisions of paragraph 4 are intended to prevent an enterprise of one State from being taxed in another State if it engages in activities of an exclusively preparatory or auxiliary nature in that other State. The provisions of paragraph 4.1 (see (See below) complement this principle by ensuring that the preparatory or auxiliary nature of activities carried out at a fixed place of business should be considered in the light of other activities that constitute additional functions that are part of a cohesive business and that the same enterprise or closely related enterprises conduct in the same State.
59. It is often difficult to distinguish between activities that are preparatory or supportive in nature and those that are not. The crucial criterion is whether the activity of the most permanent place of business constitutes an essential and significant part of the activity of the enterprise as a whole. Each specific case will have to be assessed taking into account its specific features. One way or another, the activity of a permanent place of business, the general purpose of which is identical to the general purpose of the enterprise as a whole, does not belong to preparatory or auxiliary.
60. As a rule, preparatory activities are activities that are carried out taking into account what constitutes a significant and significant part of the company's activities as a whole. Since preparatory activities precede other activities, they will often be carried out over a relatively short period, the duration of which is determined by the nature of the company's core business. However, this is not always the case, as it is possible to continue activities in a given location for a significant period of time in order to prepare for activities that will be carried out elsewhere. If, for example, a construction company trains its employees in one location before sending these employees to work in remote workplaces located in other countries, the training that takes place in the first location is a preparatory activity for that enterprise. On the other hand, ancillary activities usually correspond to activities that are carried out to support a substantial and significant part of the enterprise's activities as a whole, but are not part of it. It is unlikely that an activity requiring a significant proportion of the assets or employees of an enterprise can be considered as having an auxiliary character.
61. Sub-paragraphs (a) to (e) relate to activities carried out for the enterprise itself. Consequently, a permanent establishment would exist if such activities were carried out on behalf of other enterprises in the same permanent place of business. If, for example, an enterprise that has an office to advertise its products or services was also required to advertise on behalf of other enterprises in that location, that office would be considered a permanent representation of the enterprise that supports it.
62. Subparagraph (a) refers to a permanent place of business consisting of premises used by an enterprise for the storage, display or delivery of its products or goods. Whether the activities carried out at such a place of business will be preparatory or auxiliary in nature will need to be determined in the light of factors that include the overall business activities of the enterprise. If, for example, an enterprise in State R maintains a very large warehouse in State S, in which a significant number of employees work for the primary purpose of storing and delivering goods belonging to the enterprise, which such an enterprise sells online to customers in State S, paragraph 4 will not apply to this warehouse, since storage and delivery operations that They are carried out through this warehouse, which is an important asset and requires a certain number of employees., They form an important part of the company's sales/distribution activities and therefore do not have a preparatory or auxiliary character.
63. Subparagraph (a) will cover, for example, a customs warehouse with special gas installations that a fruit exporter from one State maintains in another State for the sole purpose of storing fruit in a controlled environment during the customs clearance process in that other State. This will also cover the permanent place of business that the company maintains solely for the delivery of spare parts to customers for equipment sold to those customers. However, paragraph 4 will not apply if the enterprise has a permanent place of business to supply spare parts to customers for equipment supplied to those customers and, in addition, for the maintenance or repair of such equipment, as this goes beyond the net delivery referred to in subparagraph (a) and will not constitute preparatory work. or auxiliary actions, since these after-sales activities constitute an essential and significant part of the company's services to customers.
64. Questions may arise regarding the application of the definition of permanent establishment to facilities such as cables or pipelines that cross a country's territory. Apart from the fact that the income earned by the owner or operator of such facilities from their use by other enterprises is regulated by Article 6, according to Paragraph 2 of which they are considered immovable property, the question may arise whether subparagraph (a) applies to them. In cases where these facilities are used to transport property belonging to other enterprises, subparagraph (a), the scope of which is limited to the delivery of products or goods belonging to the enterprise using the facility, will not apply to the owner or operator of these facilities. Subparagraph (e) will also not be applicable to this enterprise, since the cable line or pipeline is not used exclusively for the benefit of this enterprise and their use is not preparatory or auxiliary, given the nature of the activities carried out by this enterprise. The situation changes, however, in cases where an enterprise owns and operates a cable line or pipeline crossing the territory of a particular country solely for the purpose of transporting its own property and such transportation is just a side activity in relation to the business activities carried out by this enterprise, as is the case with an enterprise that It is engaged in oil refining and which owns and operates a pipeline crossing the territory of a particular country, exclusively for transporting their own oil to their own refinery located in another country. In that case, subparagraph (a) would be applicable. A separate issue is whether a cable or pipeline can represent a permanent establishment for a customer of a cable or pipeline operator, that is, an enterprise whose data, capacity, or property is transferred or transported from one location to another. In this case, the company simply receives transmission or transportation services provided by the cable or pipeline operator and does not have the cable or pipeline at its disposal. As a result, the cable or pipeline cannot be considered a permanent establishment of this enterprise.
65. Subparagraph (b) refers to the maintenance of stocks of goods or merchandise owned by the enterprise. This subparagraph is not relevant to cases where a stock of goods or products belonging to an enterprise is maintained by another person at facilities operated by that other person, and the enterprise does not have such facilities at its disposal, since the place where the stocks are stored cannot therefore be a permanent establishment of that enterprise. If, for example, a logistics company operates a warehouse in State S and permanently stores goods or products in that warehouse belonging to an enterprise in State R with which the logistics company does not have a close relationship, the warehouse is not a permanent place of business owned by an enterprise of State R, and therefore subparagraph (b) does not have values. However, if this enterprise is given unrestricted access to a separate part of the warehouse for the purpose of checking and servicing the goods or products stored there, subparagraph (b) applies, and the question of the existence of a permanent establishment will depend on whether these actions are preparatory or auxiliary.
66. For the purposes of applying subparagraphs (a) and (b), it does not matter whether storage or delivery takes place before or after the sale of the goods or products, provided that the goods or products belong to the enterprise as long as they are in the appropriate location (for example, the subparagraphs may apply regardless of the fact that some of the goods that are stored in some place, they have already been sold, provided that ownership of these goods passes to the buyer only during or after delivery). Subparagraphs (a) and (b) also cover situations where an object is used or a stock of goods or products is maintained for any combination of storage, display and delivery, since the means used to deliver goods will almost always also be used to store these goods for at least a short period. For the purposes of subparagraphs (a) to (d), the words "goods" and "products" refer to tangible property and do not cover, for example, real estate and data (although the subparagraphs will apply to tangible products that include data such as CDs and DVDs).
67. Subparagraph (c) concerns the situation when stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to one enterprise are processed on behalf of that enterprise or at its expense by another enterprise. As explained in paragraph 65, the mere presence of goods or products belonging to an enterprise does not mean that the permanent place of business where these goods or products are stored is at the disposal of that enterprise. If, for example, a stock owned by RCO, an enterprise of State R, is maintained by a manufacturer of intermediates located in State S, there is no permanent place of business at the disposal of RCO for the purposes of processing by this manufacturer of intermediates, and the place where the stocks are stored cannot be a permanent representative office of RCO. However, if the RCO is given unrestricted access to a particular piece of equipment from an intermediate manufacturer for the purpose of checking and servicing the goods stored therein, subparagraph (c) will apply and it will be necessary to determine whether the maintenance of this inventory by the RCO is preparatory or auxiliary activity. This will be the case if the RCO is simply a distributor of products produced by other enterprises, since in this case the simple maintenance of inventory for processing purposes by another enterprise will not constitute an essential and significant part of the overall activities of the RCO. In such a case, if paragraph 4.1 does not apply, paragraph 4 will consider that there is no permanent establishment in relation to such a permanent place of business, which is at the disposal of the enterprise of State R for the purpose of servicing its own goods, which will be processed by the manufacturer of intermediate products.
68. The first part of subparagraph (d) refers to the case when the premises are used solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise for the enterprise. Since this exception applies only when such an action is preparatory or auxiliary in nature, it usually does not apply in the case of a fixed place of business used for the purchase of goods or merchandise, when the general activity of the enterprise consists in the sale of these goods and where procurement is the main function in the enterprise. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 4 in the case of permanent locations where procurement activities are carried out:
- Example 1: RCO is a resident company of State R, which is a major buyer of certain agricultural products produced in State S, which RCO sells from State R to distributors located in different countries. In State S, the RCO has a purchasing department. The staff working in this office are experienced buyers who have special knowledge about this type of product and who visit manufacturers in State S, determine the type/quality of products according to international standards (which is a complex process requiring special skills and knowledge) and conclude various types of contracts (spot or preliminary) for purchase of RCO products. Although in this example, the only activity performed through the office is the purchase of products for the RCO, which is an activity covered by subparagraph (d), paragraph 4 does not apply, and therefore the office is a permanent establishment, since this procurement function forms an integral and significant part of the overall activities of the RCO.
- Example 2: RCO, a resident company of State R that operates a number of large discount stores, maintains an office in State S for two years for the purposes of researching the local market and lobbying the government for changes that will allow RCO to open stores in State S. During this period, RCO employees purchase supplies for their office from time to time. In this example, paragraph 4 applies, since subparagraph (f) applies to activities carried out through the office (since subparagraphs (d) and (e) would apply to procurement, research and lobbying if each of these activities were the only one carried out in the office), and the overall activities of the office are preparatory in nature.
69. The second part of subparagraph (d) refers to a permanent place of business, which is used exclusively for collecting information about the enterprise. An enterprise often needs to collect information before deciding whether and how to conduct its main business in the State. If an enterprise does this without having a permanent place of business in that State, subparagraph (d) is obviously irrelevant. However, if a permanent place of business is maintained solely for this purpose, subparagraph (d) will be appropriate and it will be necessary to determine whether the collection of information goes beyond the preparatory or auxiliary threshold. If, for example, an investment fund opens an office in a State solely to collect information about possible investment opportunities in that State, collecting information through that office will be a preparatory activity. The same conclusion will be drawn in the case of an insurance company that creates an office solely to collect information, such as statistics, data on risks in a particular market, and in the case of a newspaper bureau established in the state solely to collect information about possible news without engaging in any advertising activities: in both cases, information collection will be a preparatory event.
70. Subparagraph (e) applies to a permanent place of business maintained solely for the purpose of conducting any activity for the enterprise that is not explicitly specified in subparagraphs (a) to (d); as long as this activity is preparatory or auxiliary in nature, this place of business is not considered a permanent establishment. The wording of this subparagraph eliminates the need to compile an exhaustive list of activities to which this paragraph may apply. The examples listed in sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) are simply general examples of the actions covered by the paragraph, as they are often preparatory or auxiliary in nature.
71. Examples of places of business covered by subparagraph (e) are permanent places of business used solely for the purpose of advertising, providing information, research activities or servicing patent agreements or know-how agreements, if such activities are preparatory or auxiliary in nature. However, paragraph 4 will not apply if the permanent place of business used to provide information provides not only information, but also plans, etc., specifically designed for the purposes of an individual client. The same applies when any scientific research organization is engaged in production activities. Similarly, if the purpose of an enterprise is to provide services in the field of patents and know-how, then the permanent place of business of that enterprise carrying out such activities cannot benefit from the benefits under paragraph 4. A permanent place of business performing the functions of managing an enterprise or even only a part of the enterprise, or any group of concern, It cannot be considered to be engaged in preparatory or auxiliary activities, since such management activities exceed this level. If an enterprise with an international network establishes a so-called "management office" in the State in which it maintains subsidiaries, permanent representative offices, agents or licensees, while such an office performs supervisory and coordinating functions for all departments of the enterprise located in the relevant region, subparagraph (e) will not apply to this "management office" since the management function of the enterprise, even if it covers only a certain area of the concern's activity, forms an essential part of the economic activity of the enterprise and, Therefore, in no way can it be considered as an activity having a preparatory or auxiliary character within the meaning of paragraph 4.
72. In addition, if a company that sells goods worldwide opens an office in a State, and employees working in that office are actively involved in negotiating important parts of contracts for the sale of goods to customers in that State, without the usual contracting or primary role leading to the conclusion of contracts (for example, participating in the decision-making process). decisions regarding the type, quality or quantity of products covered by these contracts), Such activities usually form an essential part of the business operations of an enterprise and should not be considered preparatory or auxiliary in the meaning of subparagraph (e) of paragraph 4. If the conditions of paragraph 1 are met, such an office will be considered a permanent establishment.
73. As noted in paragraph 58 above, paragraph 4 is intended to provide exceptions to the general definition in paragraph 1 concerning permanent places of business that engage in activities of a preparatory or auxiliary nature. Thus, in accordance with subparagraph (f), the fact that one permanent place of business combines any of the activities mentioned in subparagraphs (a) to (e) does not in itself imply the existence of a permanent establishment. Since the combined activities of such a permanent place of business have only a preparatory or auxiliary character, it should be assumed that a permanent establishment does not exist. Combinations of such activities should be considered not from a rigid perspective, but in the light of specific circumstances.
74. If the provisions of sub-paragraph 4.1 on combating fragmentation do not apply (see below), sub-paragraph (f) is not relevant in the case where an enterprise has several permanent places of business to which sub-paragraphs (a) to (e) apply, since in such a case each place of business must be considered separately and in isolation in order to decide whether there is a whether there is a permanent representative office.
75. The permanent places of business to which paragraph 4 applies are not permanent representative offices as long as the commercial activities carried out through these permanent places of business are limited to the activities referred to in this paragraph. This can be said even if the contracts necessary for the establishment and implementation of entrepreneurial activities are concluded with those who are responsible for the places of business themselves. The conclusion of such contracts by these employees will not constitute a permanent establishment of the enterprise in accordance with paragraph 5 if the conclusion of these contracts satisfies the conditions of paragraph 4 (see paragraph 97 below). An example would be when the head of a place of business where preparatory or ancillary research is conducted enters into contracts necessary to establish and maintain that place of business as part of the activities carried out at that location.
76. If a permanent place of business is not considered a permanent establishment on the basis of paragraph 4, this exception also applies to the transfer of movable property forming part of the property of the enterprise at the disposal of the place of business upon termination of the enterprise's activities at such facility (see paragraph 4 above and paragraph 2 of Article 13). If, for example, the display of goods is excluded on the basis of subparagraphs (a) and (b), then the sale of goods at the end of a trade fair or conference is regulated by subparagraph (e), since such sale is only an auxiliary activity. Such an exception, of course, does not apply to sales of goods that were not actually shown at the fair or conference.
77. If paragraph 4 does not apply, due to the fact that the permanent place of business used by the enterprise for the activities listed in this Paragraph is also used for other activities beyond preparatory or auxiliary, this place of business represents a single permanent establishment of the enterprise and the profits attributable to the permanent establishment in respect of both activities., may be taxed in the State in which this permanent establishment is located.
78. Some States consider that certain types of activities mentioned in paragraph 4 are essentially preparatory or auxiliary, and, in order to provide greater confidence for both tax authorities and taxpayers, consider that these types of activities should not be subject to the condition that they are preparatory or auxiliary in nature. Any concerns about the improper use of these exclusions are resolved in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 4.1. States that share this view may amend paragraph 4 as follows (and may also agree to remove certain activities listed in subparagraphs (a) to (d) below if they consider that these activities should be subject to preparatory or auxiliary conditions in subparagraph (e)):
4. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this article, the term "permanent establishment" is not considered to include:
a) the use of premises solely for the purpose of storing, displaying or delivering goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
b) maintaining stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purposes of storage, display or delivery;
(c) Maintaining stocks of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purposes of processing by another enterprise;
d) the maintenance of a permanent place of business solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise, or collecting information for the enterprise;
(e) The maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of conducting for the enterprise any other activity not specified in subparagraphs (a) to (d), provided that such activity is of a preparatory or auxiliary nature; or
(f) The maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for any combination of the activities referred to in subparagraphs (a) to (e), provided that the overall activities of the fixed place of business resulting from such combination are preparatory or auxiliary in nature.
Paragraph 4.1
79. The purpose of clause 4.1 is to prevent an enterprise or a group of closely related enterprises from breaking down an integrated business operation into several small operations in order to prove that each of them is simply engaged in preparatory or auxiliary activities. In accordance with paragraph 4.1, the exceptions provided for in paragraph 4 do not apply to a place of business that would otherwise constitute a permanent establishment if the activities carried out at that location and other activities of the same enterprise or closely related enterprises carried out in that or another location in the same State would perform additional functions that are part of an agreed business transaction. However, for the application of paragraph 4.1, at least one of the locations where this activity is carried out must be a permanent establishment, or, if this is not the case, the overall activity resulting from a combination of the relevant activities must go beyond what is simply preparatory or auxiliary.
80. The provisions of paragraph 8 apply to determine whether an enterprise is closely related to another enterprise (see paragraphs 119-121 below).
81. The following example illustrates the application of paragraph 4.1.:
— Example A: RCO, a resident bank of State R, has a number of branches in State S, which are permanent representative offices. He also has a separate office in State S, where several employees verify information provided by customers who have applied for a loan at these different branches. The results of the checks performed by the employees are sent to the RCO headquarters in State R, where other employees analyze the information included in the loan applications and submit reports to the branches where loan decisions are made. In this case, the exceptions of paragraph 4 will not apply to the office, because the other location (i.e. any of the other branches where the loan applications are submitted) is the permanent representative office of the RCO in State S, and the business activities carried out by the RCO in the office and the corresponding branch are complementary functions that are part of the agreed business operations (for example, providing loans to customers in State S).
— Example B: RCO, a resident company of the State of R, manufactures and sells household appliances. SCO, a resident of State S, which is a 100% subsidiary of RCO, owns a store where it sells household appliances purchased from RCO. RCO also owns a small warehouse in State S, where several large items are stored, identical to some of those displayed in the SCO-owned store. When a customer buys such a large item from SCO, SCO employees go to the warehouse where they pick up the item before delivering it to the customer; The ownership of the goods is acquired by SCO from RCO only when the goods leave the warehouse. In this case, paragraph 4.1 prevents the exceptions of Paragraph 4 from being applied to the warehouse, and therefore it is not necessary to determine whether Paragraph 4 and, in particular, subparagraph (a) apply to the warehouse. The conditions of application of clause 4.1 are fulfilled because
• SCO and RCO are closely related enterprises;
• An SCO store is an SCO permanent establishment (the definition of a permanent establishment is not limited to situations where a resident of one Contracting State uses or maintains a permanent place of business in another State; it applies equally when an enterprise of one State uses or maintains a permanent place of business in the same State); and
• The business activities carried out by RCO in its warehouse and SCO in its store represent additional functions that are part of a cohesive business operation (i.e., storing goods in one place for the purpose of delivering these goods as part of the obligations arising from the sale of these goods through another location in the same State).
Item 5
82. It is a generally accepted principle that an enterprise should be considered as having a permanent establishment in a State if, under certain conditions, there is a person acting on its behalf, even if the enterprise does not have a permanent place of business in that State within the meaning of paragraphs 1 and 2. This provision is intended to give the State the right to levy taxes in such cases. cases. Thus, paragraph 5 provides for the conditions under which an enterprise is considered to have a permanent establishment in relation to any activity of a person acting on its behalf.
83. Persons whose activities may create a permanent establishment for an enterprise are persons, regardless of whether they are employees of the enterprise, acting on its behalf and not performing these actions in carrying out business activities as an independent agent subject to Paragraph 6. Such persons may be both individuals and companies., and they do not necessarily have to be residents of the State or have an office on its territory where they carry out activities on behalf of the enterprise. It would be contrary to the interests of international economic relations to stipulate that any person's activity on behalf of an enterprise would lead to the establishment of a permanent representative office of the enterprise. This interpretation is limited to persons who, due to the nature of their activities, involve the enterprise to a certain extent in business activities on the territory of the relevant State. Thus, paragraph 5 proceeds from the fact that only persons who usually conclude contracts in the name of the company, or who must be executed by the company, or who usually play the main role leading to the signing of such contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company, can take actions leading to the establishment of a permanent representative office of the company. In this case, the actions of a person on behalf of the enterprise, since they lead to the conclusion of contracts and go beyond simple advertising, are sufficient to conclude that the enterprise is involved in business activities in the relevant State. The use of the term "permanent establishment" in this context, of course, assumes that the conclusion of contracts by this person, or as a direct result of the actions of this person, occurs repeatedly, and not in individual cases.
84. To apply paragraph 5, all of the following conditions must be met::
— a person acts in a Contracting State of the contract on behalf of the enterprise;
— at the same time, this person usually enters into contracts, or usually plays the main role leading to the signing of such contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company, and
— these contracts are concluded either in the name of the enterprise, or for the transfer of ownership or the granting of the right to use property belonging to this enterprise, or which the enterprise has the right to use, or for the provision of services by this enterprise.
85. Even if these conditions are met, paragraph 5 does not apply if the activity carried out by a person on behalf of the enterprise falls within the scope of an independent agent, with the exception of paragraph 6, or is limited to the activities referred to in paragraph 4, which, when carried out through a permanent place of business, is not considered to establish a permanent establishment. This last exception is explained by the fact that, according to paragraph 4, the maintenance of a permanent office solely for preparatory or auxiliary purposes is not considered a permanent establishment, and a person whose activities are limited to these purposes should also not establish a permanent establishment. If, for example, a person acts solely as a procurement agent for an enterprise, and usually enters into procurement contracts on behalf of that enterprise, paragraph 5 does not apply, even if that person is not independent of the enterprise, as long as such activities are preparatory or auxiliary (see paragraph 68 above).
86. A person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise if that person engages the enterprise to a certain extent in business activities in the relevant State. For example, this happens when an agent acts on behalf of a principal, a partner acts on behalf of a partnership, a director acts on behalf of a company, or an employee acts on behalf of an employer. A person cannot be called acting on behalf of an enterprise if the actions performed by this person do not have a direct or indirect impact on the enterprise. As stated in paragraph 83, a person acting on behalf of an enterprise may be a company; in this case, the actions of the employees and directors of that company are considered together to determine whether and to what extent the company is acting on behalf of the enterprise.
87. The phrase "concludes contracts" focuses on situations where, according to the relevant law governing the conclusion of contracts, the contract is considered to have been concluded by a person. A contract may be concluded without any active discussion of the terms of the contract; this happens, for example, when the relevant law stipulates that the contract is concluded due to the acceptance by a person on behalf of the company of a proposal to conclude a standard contract with this company, made by a third party. In addition, a contract, according to the relevant law, may be concluded in a State, even if the contract is concluded outside its territory; if, for example, the contract is concluded as a result of the acceptance by a person acting on behalf of an enterprise of a proposal to conclude a contract made by a third party, the fact that the contract is signed outside that State does not It doesn't matter. In addition, a person who conducts negotiations in a State with respect to all elements and details of a contract in a manner binding on the enterprise may be called concluding a contract in that State, even if the contract is signed by another person outside its territory.
88. The phrase "or usually plays a major role leading to the signing of such contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise" implies situations in which the conclusion of the contract is a direct result of actions performed by a person in a Contracting State on behalf of the enterprise, even in cases where, according to the relevant law, this person does not conclude the contract. in this State. Although the phrase "concludes contracts" is a fairly well-known criterion based on contract law, it was considered necessary to supplement it with a criterion focusing on the main activity carried out in one State in order to consider cases where the conclusion of contracts is obviously a direct result of this activity, although the relevant rules of contract law provide that the contract It is concluded outside the State. The phrase should be interpreted taking into account the object and purpose of paragraph 5, which should cover cases when the activity carried out by a person in a State is aimed at the regular conclusion of contracts to be executed by a foreign state, i.e. when the person acts as a sales specialist of the enterprise. Thus, the main role leading to the conclusion of a contract is usually related to the actions of the person who convinced the third party to conclude a contract with the enterprise. The words "contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise" clarify that if such a primary role is performed in a given State, the actions of that person fall within the scope of paragraph 5, even if contracts are not formally concluded in the State, for example, if contracts outside the State are usually subject to verification and approval, and such verification does not lead to changes in key aspects of these agreements.
89. Thus, the phrase "usually plays a major role leading to the signing of contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company" is used, for example, in cases where a person requests and receives (but does not formally complete) orders sent directly to the warehouse from which goods belonging to the company are shipped, and the company usually approves these transactions. However, it does not apply if a person simply promotes and sells the goods or services of an enterprise in a way that does not directly lead to the conclusion of contracts. For example, if representatives of a pharmaceutical company actively advertise medicines produced by this company, contacting doctors who subsequently prescribe these medicines, such marketing activities do not directly lead to the conclusion of contracts between doctors and the company, and therefore the Clause does not apply, even if sales of these medicines increase significantly as a result of such marketing activities.
90. Below is another example illustrating the application of Paragraph 5. RCO, a company that is a resident of the State of R, distributes various products and services worldwide through its websites. SCO, a company that is a resident of State S, is a wholly owned subsidiary of RCO. SCO employees send emails, make phone calls, or visit large organizations to convince them to buy RCO products and services, and are therefore responsible for large bills in the State.; SCO employees, whose salaries are partly based on the income earned by RCO from the owners of these accounts, use their relationship-building skills to try to anticipate the needs of the owners of these accounts and convince them to purchase the products and services offered by RCO. When an SCO employee persuades one of these account holders to purchase a certain amount of goods or services, the employee indicates the price to be paid for that amount, notes that the contract must be concluded with RCO online before RCO provides the goods or services, and explains the standard terms of RCO contracts, including the fixed price structure used by RCO, which the employee has no right to change. The account holder then enters into this agreement online for the amount that he has agreed with the SCO employee, in accordance with the price structure provided by this employee. In this example, SCO employees play a major role leading to the conclusion of an agreement between the account holder and the RCO, and such agreements are usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company.
The fact that SCO employees cannot change the terms of contracts does not mean that the conclusion of contracts is not a direct result of the activities they carry out on behalf of the company, convincing the account holder to accept these standard terms, which are an important element leading to the conclusion of contracts between the account holder and the RCO.
91. The wording of subparagraphs (a), (b) and (c) ensures the application of paragraph 5 not only to contracts that create legally binding rights and obligations between the enterprise on whose behalf the person acts and the third parties with whom these contracts are concluded, but also to contracts that create obligations that will actually be performed by this enterprise., and not by the person who is obligated to do so under the contract.
92. A typical case covered by these sub-paragraphs is when contracts are concluded with clients by an agent, partner, or employee of an enterprise to create legally valid rights and obligations between the enterprise and these clients. These sub-paragraphs also cover cases where contracts concluded by a person acting on behalf of an enterprise do not bind that enterprise with legal obligations to third parties with whom these contracts were concluded, but are contracts for the transfer of ownership or the granting of the right to use property belonging to that enterprise, or which that enterprise is entitled to use, or for provision of services by this company. A typical example is the contracts that a "commission agent" enters into with third parties under a commission agreement with a foreign company, according to which the commission agent will act on behalf of the company, but at the same time will conclude contracts on his behalf that do not create legally valid rights and obligations between the foreign company and third parties., even if the results of an agreement between a commission agent and a foreign enterprise imply the direct transfer to these third parties by a foreign enterprise of the right of ownership or use of property belonging to this enterprise, or which it has the right to use.
93. The reference to "in-name" contracts in subparagraph (a) does not limit the application of this subparagraph to contracts that are literally concluded in the name of an enterprise; for example, it may be used in certain situations where the name of the enterprise is not disclosed in the written contract.
94. The most important condition for the application of subparagraphs (b) and (c) is that the person who usually enters into contracts or usually plays the main role leading to the signing of contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise, acts on behalf of the enterprise in such a way that the parts of the contracts relating to the transfer of ownership or use of property, or the provision of services will be performed by the company, not by a person acting on behalf of the company.
95. For the purposes of subparagraph (b), it does not matter whether the relevant property existed or was owned by the enterprise at the time of the conclusion of contracts between the person acting on behalf of the enterprise and third parties. For example, a person acting on behalf of an enterprise may sell property that the enterprise will produce later before delivering it directly to customers. In addition, the reference to "property" covers any tangible and intangible property.
96. The cases to which paragraph 5 applies should be distinguished from situations where a person enters into contracts on his own behalf and, in order to fulfill obligations arising from these contracts, receives goods or services from other enterprises or applies to other enterprises for the supply of these goods or services. In these cases, the person does not act "on behalf" of such other enterprises and does not conclude contracts on behalf of these enterprises either for the transfer to third parties of ownership or use of property belonging to these enterprises, or which they are entitled to use, or for the provision of services by such other enterprises. If, for example, a company acts as a distributor of products in a particular market, and at the same time sells products to customers purchased from the enterprise (including associated enterprises), it does not act on behalf of this enterprise and does not sell property owned by this enterprise, since the property sold to customers belongs to the distributor. This is also the case in cases where the distributor acts as a so-called "distributor with a limited set of functions and risks" (and not as an agent, for example), but only if the transfer of ownership of property sold by this distributor "with a limited set of functions and risks" is transferred from the company to the distributor and from distributor to the client (regardless of the duration of the distributor's ownership of the sold object) in such a way that the distributor receives a profit from the sale, rather than remuneration, for example, in the form of a commission.
97. The contracts referred to in Paragraph 5 include contracts related to transactions that constitute business activities typical of an enterprise. This provision does not apply in cases where, for example, a person has entered into employment contracts for the company to assist them in the company's activities, or if the person has entered into similar contracts on behalf of the company that relate only to internal operations. Moreover, the fact that a person enters into contracts usually or usually plays a major role leading to the signing of contracts, which are usually concluded without the essential fact that the person was present or even participated in negotiations between the enterprise and the client in the State, is not enough to conclude that the person entered into contracts or played a significant role. the main role leading to the signing of contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company. However, the fact that a person was present or even participated in such negotiations may be relevant in determining the specific functions performed by that person on behalf of the company.
98. The requirement that an agent should "normally" conclude contracts or play a major role leading to the signing of contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise, reflects the fundamental principle of Article 5, according to which the presence provided by the enterprise in a Contracting State must be more than temporary if the enterprise is to be considered as having a permanent a representative office and, consequently, a taxable presence in a given State. The amount and frequency of actions required to conclude that an agent "usually" enters into contracts or plays a major role leading to the signing of contracts that are usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the company will depend on the nature of the contracts and the business activities of the principal. It is impossible to establish an exact frequency criterion. Nevertheless, the same factors that were discussed in paragraphs 28-30 will be relevant in making this decision.
99. Subject to the requirements set out in paragraph 5, a permanent establishment of an enterprise exists to the extent that the person acts on behalf of the latter, i.e. not only to the extent that the person enters into contracts or plays a major role leading to the signing of contracts, usually concluded without significant changes on the part of the enterprise.
100. According to paragraph 5, only persons who meet certain conditions may establish a permanent establishment; all other persons are excluded. However, it should be borne in mind that paragraph 5 simply provides an alternative criterion for whether an enterprise has a permanent establishment in a State. If it can be proved that the enterprise has a permanent establishment within the meaning of paragraphs 1 and 2 (subject to the provisions of paragraph 4), then there is no need to prove that the responsible person falls within the scope of paragraph 5.
101. Although one of the consequences of paragraph 5 is usually that the rights and obligations arising from the contracts referred to in Paragraph will be transferred to the permanent establishment arising from Paragraph (see paragraph 21 of the Commentary to Article 7), it is important to note that this does not mean that all profits derived from the performance of these contracts contracts, should be attributed to the account of the permanent mission. The determination of profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment and resulting from the application of paragraph 5 is governed by the rules set out in Article 7.; Of course, this will require that the activities carried out by other enterprises and the rest of the enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs are properly paid so that the profits attributed to the permanent establishment in accordance with Article 7 include only the funds received by the permanent establishment, as if it were a separate and independent enterprise carrying out the activities that paragraph 5 attributes to this permanent mission.
Item 6
102. If an enterprise of a Contracting State carries out business transactions through an independent agent engaged in business activities as such, it may not be taxed in the other Contracting State in respect of those transactions if the agent is acting in the ordinary course of business (see paragraph 83). The activity of such an agent, representing a separate and independent enterprise, should not lead to the identification of the fact of the presence of a permanent representative office of a foreign enterprise.
103. The exception to the provisions of Paragraph 6 applies only in cases where a person acts on behalf of an enterprise in the course of carrying out business activities as an independent agent. Therefore, it will not apply if a person acts on behalf of an enterprise in another capacity, for example, when an employee acts on behalf of his employer or a partner acts on behalf of a partnership. As explained in paragraph 8.1 of the Commentary to Article 15, it is sometimes difficult to determine whether services provided by an individual are recruitment and recruitment services or services provided by an individual enterprise; the provisions of Paragraphs 8.2 - 8.28 of the Commentary to Article 15 may be used for this purpose. However, if a person acts on behalf of an enterprise in the course of carrying out his own business activities, and not as an employee, the provisions of Paragraph 6 apply only if that person performs these actions as an independent agent.; As explained in paragraph 111 below, the probability of such an independent status is lower if the person's activities are carried out entirely or almost entirely on behalf of a single enterprise or closely related enterprises.
104. The independence of a person acting as an agent from the represented enterprise is related to the extent of his obligations to the enterprise. If a person's commercial activity for the benefit of an enterprise is carried out with the provision of detailed instructions or comprehensive control by the enterprise, such a person cannot be considered independent of the enterprise. Another important criterion is the bearer of entrepreneurial risk: a person or an enterprise represented by them. In any case, the last sentence of Paragraph 6 provides that, under certain circumstances, a person should not be considered an independent agent (see paragraphs 119-121). When deciding whether an agent to whom this last sentence does not apply can be considered independent, the following considerations must be taken into account.
105. It should be noted that if the last sentence of Paragraph 6 does not apply because the subsidiary does not act solely or practically exclusively on behalf of closely related enterprises, the control exercised by the parent company in relation to it as a shareholder is not taken into account when assessing the dependence or other parameters of the subsidiary as an agent of the parent company. This corresponds to the rule set out in paragraph 7 of Article 5 (see also paragraph 113).
106. An independent agent is usually responsible to his principal for the results of his work, but is not subject to significant control over the way this work is carried out. The principal should not give him detailed instructions regarding the performance of the work. The fact that the principal relies on the agent's special skills and knowledge proves the agent's independence.
107. Restrictions on the scope of business activities that an agent can conduct have a clear impact on the scope of the agent's powers. However, such restrictions do not apply to dependence, which is determined by assessing the agent's degree of freedom when conducting business on behalf of the principal within the scope of the powers provided by the contract.
108. A feature of the contract may be that the agent will provide the principal with important information in connection with the conduct of business activities under the contract. This in itself is not a sufficient criterion for determining the agent's dependence, except in cases where information is provided in the process of obtaining approval of a business method from the principal. Providing information that aims only to ensure that the contract is clearly executed and that good relations with the principal are maintained is not a sign of dependence.
109. Another factor to consider when determining the independence status is the number of principals represented by the agent. As noted in Paragraph 111, independent status is less likely if the agent's activities are carried out entirely or almost entirely on behalf of the enterprise during the life of the business or a long period. However, this fact alone is not decisive. To determine whether the agent's actions represent an autonomous business activity carried out by this agent, during which he bears risks and receives remuneration through the use of his entrepreneurial skills and knowledge, all facts and circumstances should be taken into account. If an agent acts on behalf of several principals in the normal course of business, and none of them has priority over the business activities carried out by the agent, dependence may exist if the principals act in concert to ensure control of the agent's actions in the course of conducting business on their behalf.
110. An independent agent cannot be described as acting as an agent in the normal course of business if he carries out activities unrelated to his intermediary activities. If, for example, a company acting on its behalf as a distributor of several companies also acts as an agent of another company, then the activities that the company carries out as a distributor will not be considered part of the activities that the company carries out in the ordinary course of business as an agent for the purposes of applying the provisions of Paragraph 6. However, activities that fall within the ordinary course of business carried out by an enterprise as an agent will include intermediary activities that, in accordance with generally accepted practice in a particular business sector, are sometimes carried out as an agent and sometimes on their own behalf, provided that these types of intermediary activities are, in fact,, are indistinguishable from each other.
If, for example, a broker-dealer in the financial sector carries out various types of market intermediation activities in a similar way, but, depending on the needs of clients, sometimes carries it out as an agent of another enterprise, and sometimes on his own behalf, the broker-dealer will be considered acting as an agent in the normal course of business if he carries out such diverse market intermediary activities.
111. The last sentence of Paragraph 6 provides that a person is not considered an independent agent if he acts solely or practically exclusively on behalf of one or more closely related enterprises. However, this last sentence does not mean that Paragraph 6 will automatically apply in cases where a person acts on behalf of one or more enterprises with which the person has no close connection. The provisions of Paragraph 6 require that a person conduct business activities as an independent agent and act within the normal course of that business activity. Independent status is less likely if a person's activities are fully or almost completely carried out on behalf of only one enterprise (or a group of closely related enterprises) during the lifetime of the person's business or a long period. However, if a person acts solely on behalf of one enterprise with which he has no close connection for a short period (for example, at the beginning of the business activity of this person), the application of the provisions of Paragraph 6 is possible. As indicated in Paragraph 109, all facts and circumstances should be taken into account to determine whether a person's activity is conducting business as an independent agent.
112. The last sentence of Paragraph 6 applies only if a person acts "exclusively or practically exclusively" on behalf of closely related enterprises, as defined in Paragraph 8. This means that if a person's activities on behalf of businesses with which they are not closely associated do not constitute an important part of that person's business activities, that person will not be considered an independent agent. If, for example, sales transactions concluded by an agent on behalf of businesses with which he does not have a close relationship account for less than 10 percent of all sales transactions concluded by him as an agent acting on behalf of other businesses, this agent should be considered acting “exclusively or practically exclusively” on behalf of the companies closely related to him.
113. The rule set out in the last sentence of Paragraph 6, and the fact that the definition of "closely related" in Paragraph 8 covers situations where one company controls or is controlled by another company, in no way limit the scope of Paragraph 7 of Article 5. According to the explanation given in Paragraph 117, a subsidiary may act on behalf of its parent company in such a way that the parent company will be considered to have a permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 5.; In this case, a subsidiary acting solely or practically exclusively on behalf of its parent company will not be able to benefit from the exception for an "independent agent" provided for in Paragraph 6. However, this does not imply that the parent-subsidiary relationship precludes the application of the requirements of Paragraph 5. And also that such a relationship by itself is enough to conclude that any of these requirements have been met.
114. According to the definition of "permanent establishment", an insurance company of one State may be taxed in another State in connection with its insurance activities if it has a permanent office as defined in Paragraph 1, or if it operates through a person, as described in Paragraph 5. Since agencies of foreign insurance companies sometimes do not meet any of the above requirements, it is possible that these companies carry out large-scale activities in the State without taxing their profits from such activities in that State. To eliminate this possibility, various conventions concluded by OECD member countries before 2017 include a provision stipulating that insurance companies of a State are considered to have a permanent establishment in another State if they receive contributions in that other State through an agent established in it and other than an agent who is already a permanent establishment by virtue of Paragraph 5, or insure the risks located on its territory through such an agent. The decision on whether to include a provision for these reasons in the convention will depend on the factual and legal situation prevailing in the affected Contracting States. In addition, the changes in Paragraphs 5 and 6 introduced in 2017 eliminated some of the problems that such a provision should address. For this reason, such a provision is often not provided for. Given this fact, it is not advisable to include a proposal of this kind in the Model Convention.
Item 7
115. It is generally accepted that the existence of a subsidiary company does not in itself mean that this subsidiary is a permanent representative office of its parent company. This follows from the principle that such a subsidiary is an independent legal entity for tax purposes. Even the fact that the trade or business activities carried out by the subsidiary are managed by the parent company does not make the subsidiary a permanent representative office of the parent company.
116. However, in accordance with the rules of Paragraphs 1-5 of the Article, it may turn out that the parent company has a permanent establishment in the State in which the subsidiary has an office. Thus, any space or premises belonging to a subsidiary that is at the disposal of the parent company (see Paragraphs 10-19 above) and represent a permanent office through which the parent company carries out its own business activities, will constitute a permanent representative office of the parent company in accordance with Paragraph 1, taking into account Paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Article (see, for example, Paragraph 15 above). In addition, in accordance with Paragraph 5, the parent company is considered to have a permanent establishment in the State in respect of any activity carried out by its subsidiary on its behalf, if the conditions of this Paragraph are met (see Paragraphs 82-99), except in cases where the provisions of Paragraph 6 of the Article apply.
117. The same principles apply to any company belonging to an international group, so that any company can have a permanent establishment in the State in whose territory it operates (see paragraphs 10-19) and uses premises owned by another company in the group, or if the previous company is considered to have a permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 5 of the Article (see Paragraphs 82-99). Nevertheless, according to the rules of Paragraphs 1 or 5 of the Article, the fact of the presence of a permanent representative office should be established separately for each company of the group. Thus, the presence of a permanent representative office of a group company in one State will have nothing to do with whether another group company has its permanent representative office in that State.
118. Although premises belonging to a company that is a member of an international group may be made available to another company in the group and, in accordance with the other terms of Article 5, may be a permanent establishment of that other company, if the business activities of that other company are carried out through that location, a distinction should be drawn between this case and the frequent situation when the company, which is a member of an international group, provides services (for example, management services) to another group company as part of its own business activities, carried out in premises not owned by this other company, and with the involvement of its own staff. In this case, the place of service provision is not at the disposal of the latter company and does not represent the business activities of this company carried out through this place. Therefore, this place cannot be considered a permanent representative office of the company to which the services are provided. Indeed, the fact that a company's own business in a certain location can bring economic benefits to another company's business does not mean that the latter company carries out its business activities through this location: it is obvious that a company that only purchases manufactured parts or services provided by another company in another country will not have a permanent representative office in this country. for any reason, even if it benefits from the production of these parts or the provision of services.
Item 8
119. Paragraph 8 explains the meaning of the concept of a person or enterprise "closely related to the enterprise" for the purposes of the Article, and in particular Paragraphs 4.1 and 6. This concept should be distinguished from the concept of "associated enterprises" used for the purposes of Article 9; although the two concepts have a certain degree of similarity, they are not considered equivalent.
120. The first part of Paragraph 8 includes a general definition of a person or enterprise closely related to the enterprise. It provides that a person or an enterprise is closely related to an enterprise if, on the basis of all relevant facts and circumstances, one of them controls the other, or both are under the control of the same persons or enterprises. This general rule covers, for example, situations where a person or company controls an enterprise on the basis of a special agreement allowing that person or company to exercise rights similar to those it would have if it directly or indirectly owned more than 50 percent of the beneficial interest in the enterprise. As with most plural uses, the reference to "the same persons or enterprises" at the end of the first sentence of Paragraph 8 includes cases where there is only one such person or enterprise.
121. The second part of Paragraph 8 provides that the requirements for identifying a person or enterprise closely related to the enterprise are automatically complied with in certain cases. According to this second part, a person or an enterprise is considered to be closely related to an enterprise if one of them directly or indirectly owns more than 50 percent of the beneficial interests in the other, or if a third party directly or indirectly owns more than 50 percent of the beneficial interests in both the person and the enterprise, as well as in both enterprises. In the case of a company, this condition is met if a person directly or indirectly owns more than a percentage of the total number of votes and the value of the company's shares or the beneficial ownership interest in the company. Electronic commerce
122. There have been discussions about whether the simple use of computing equipment in the State in carrying out operations in the field of electronic commerce can constitute a permanent establishment. This issue raises a number of questions regarding the provisions of the Article.
123. Although the place where an enterprise uses automated equipment may be a permanent establishment in the territory of the State in which it is located (see below), it is necessary to distinguish between computing equipment that can be installed in such a location in such a way as to be a permanent establishment in certain circumstances, and data and software used or stored on this equipment. For example, an Internet website, which is a combination of software and electronic data, is not in itself a tangible asset. Thus, it does not have a location that can constitute a “place of business”, since there is no "facility, for example, premises, or, in some cases, machinery or equipment" (see paragraph 6) in relation to the relevant software and data that make up this website. On the other hand, the server on which the website is stored and through which it is accessed is a piece of equipment with a physical location, which, therefore, can be a “permanent office” of the enterprise operating this server.
124. The distinction between a website and the server on which it is stored and used is important, since the company operating the server may differ from the company conducting its business activities through the website. For example, the website through which an enterprise carries out its business activities is often hosted on the server of an Internet service provider (ISP). Although the amount paid to the PI under such agreements may depend on the amount of disk space used to store the software and data needed for the website, these agreements usually do not result in the server and its location being placed at the disposal of the enterprise (see paragraphs 10-19), even if the enterprise can determine that her website should be on a specific server in a specific location. In this case, the company is not even physically present in this location, since the website does not have a physical location. In these cases, it cannot be assumed that the company acquired the office on the basis of such a placement agreement. However, if an enterprise conducting business through a website has a server at its own disposal, for example, owns (or leases) and operates a server on which the website is stored and used, the location of the server may be a permanent representative office of the enterprise, if other requirements of the Article are met.
125. Computing equipment in a particular location may be a permanent establishment only if it meets the requirements for a permanent establishment. In the case of a server, it is not the ability to move the server that matters, but its actual movement. To constitute a permanent place of business, the server must be located in a specific location for a period sufficient to become such a permanent location as defined in Paragraph 1.
126. Another question is whether the business activities of an enterprise can be considered to be partially or completely carried out in a place where the enterprise has equipment at its disposal, such as a server. The question of whether the business activities of an enterprise are carried out partially or completely with the help of such equipment must be considered on a case-by-case basis, and it is necessary to establish whether it can be said that thanks to such equipment the enterprise has facilities at its disposal where the business activities of the enterprise are carried out.
127. If an enterprise uses computing equipment in a specific location, a permanent establishment may exist, even if the personnel of that enterprise are not required to operate the equipment in that location. The presence of staff is not necessary to consider an enterprise to be partially or fully engaged in its business activities in any place, if in fact no staff is required to conduct business in this place. This conclusion applies to e-commerce to the same extent as to other activities in which the equipment functions automatically, such as automatic pumping equipment used in the exploitation of natural resources.
128. Another issue relates to the fact that a permanent establishment cannot be considered to exist if the electronic commerce operations carried out through the ancillary activities described in Paragraph 4. The question of whether a specific activity carried out in such a location falls within the scope of Paragraph 4 needs to be examined on a case-by-case basis, taking into account different functions performed by the enterprise using this equipment. The following are examples of activities that are usually considered preparatory or auxiliary:
- providing a communication channel, very similar to a telephone line, between suppliers and customers;
- advertising of goods or services;
- transfer of information through a mirror server for security and efficiency purposes;
- collecting market data for the company;
- providing information.
129. However, if such functions themselves form an important and essential part of the business activities of the enterprise as a whole, or if other basic functions of the enterprise are performed using computing equipment, they go beyond the scope of the activities covered by Paragraph 4, and if the equipment is a permanent place of business of the enterprise (as already discussed in Paragraphs 123 - 127), in this case, a permanent establishment will exist.
130. The composition of the main functions of a particular enterprise has a clear dependence on the nature of the business activities carried out by this enterprise. For example, some PIUS use their own servers to host websites or other purposes of other enterprises. For such PIUS, the operation of their servers in order to provide services to customers is an important part of their commercial activities and cannot be considered preparatory or auxiliary activities. Another example is an enterprise (sometimes called an "online seller") that sells goods over the Internet. In this case, the company does not operate servers, and the simple fact that it can operate them in a specific location is not enough to conclude that the activities carried out in this location are more than preparatory and auxiliary activities. What needs to be done in this case is to study the nature of the activities carried out in this place in connection with the business activities of the enterprise. If such actions are simply preparatory or auxiliary to online sales activities (for example, the location is used to operate a server hosting a website that is often used solely for advertising, displaying product catalogs, or providing information to potential customers), then the provisions of Paragraph 4 apply, and the location is not permanent a representative office. However, if typical sales-related functions are performed at a given location (for example, entering into a contract with a customer, processing payments, and delivering goods are performed automatically using the equipment located there), such actions cannot be considered purely preparatory or auxiliary.
131. The final question is whether the provisions of Paragraph 5 can be applied in order to regard the PIU as a permanent establishment. As already mentioned, PIUS often provide services for hosting websites of other enterprises on their own servers. Then the question may arise as to whether it is possible to apply the provisions of Paragraph 5 to regard such PIU as permanent representations of enterprises conducting electronic commerce through websites operating through servers owned and managed by these PIU. Although this may occur in extremely unusual circumstances, Paragraph 5 usually does not apply, since the PIU is not an agent of the enterprises that own the websites, since they do not enter into contracts and do not play a major role leading to the signing of contracts on behalf of these enterprises, or for the transfer of property belonging to these enterprises, or the provision of services these companies, or because they will be operating as an independent agent in the normal course of business, as evidenced by the fact that they host the websites of many different companies. It is also clear that, since the website through which the enterprise carries out its business activities is not itself a “person” as defined in Article 3, the provisions of Paragraph 5 cannot be applied to recognize the existence of a permanent establishment by virtue of the website being an agent of the enterprise for the purposes of this Paragraph.
Taxation of services
132. The combined effect of this Article and Article 7 is that profits from services rendered in the territory of a Contracting State by an enterprise of the other Contracting State are not taxable in the former State unless they are credited to the account of a permanent establishment located in its territory (provided that they do not fall within the scope of other Articles of the Convention, allowing such taxation). This result, in which a given profit is taxed only in another State, is supported by various policy and administrative considerations. This corresponds to the principle of Article 7, according to which, until an enterprise of one State establishes a permanent establishment in another State, it should not be considered participating in the economic life of that State to the extent that it falls under the tax jurisdiction of that other State. In addition, as a rule, the provision of services, with a few exceptions for certain types of services (for example, those covered by Articles 8 and 17), should be treated in the same way as other business activities, and therefore the same type of taxation for a permanent establishment should be applied to any business activity, including the provision of independent services.
133. One of the above-mentioned administrative considerations is that the expansion of cases where taxation is permitted based on the principle of the source of profit from services rendered in the territory of a Contracting State by an enterprise of the other Contracting State will lead to an increase in requirements and an increase in the administrative burden on enterprises and tax authorities. This would pose a particular problem for services provided to clients who are not commercial enterprises, which would not need to be reported to the tax authorities of the country of origin in order to apply for a deduction for business costs. Since the rules that have usually been developed for this purpose are based on the amount of time spent in a given State, both tax authorities and enterprises will have to take into account the time spent in the country by the personnel of enterprises providing these services, and these enterprises will face the risk of establishing a permanent establishment in unforeseen circumstances in cases where they they will not be able to determine in advance how long the staff will be in a particular country (for example, in situations where, when such presence is extended due to unforeseen difficulties or at the request of the client). These cases create certain difficulties with compliance, as they require the company to comply with a number of administrative requirements related to permanent establishment retroactively. These issues relate to the need to maintain accounting books and records, employee taxation (for example, the need to make deductions from a source of income in another country), as well as other non-income tax requirements.
134. In addition, taxation based on the principle of the source of profit from services rendered in the territory of a Contracting State by an enterprise of the other Contracting State that does not have a permanent office in the first State will create difficulties in determining the profits to be taxed and collecting the appropriate tax. In most cases, the company does not have the accounting records and assets normally associated with a permanent establishment, and, in addition, there is no dependent agent who can handle compliance with the requirements for providing and collecting information. Moreover, although it is customary in the domestic legislation of States to tax profits from services rendered on their territory, this does not always represent the optimal policy of a tax agreement.
135. However, some States are reluctant to accept the principle of exclusive taxation depending on residence in relation to those services that are not attributed to a permanent establishment located in their territory, but are carried out in that territory. These States propose to amend the Article in order, under certain circumstances, to preserve the right of taxation based on the principle of source in relation to profits derived from the provision of such services. States that believe that additional taxation rights based on the source principle should be distributed in relation to services provided on their territory, according to the agreement, use various arguments to support their position.
136. These States may consider that profits from services provided in a particular State should be taxed in that State based on generally accepted principles for determining when the source of business profits should be considered to be within the jurisdiction. They believe that, from the exclusive point of view of the purely political issue of the source of profit from business activities, the State in which the services are provided should have the right to tax, even if these services do not relate to the account of a permanent establishment, as defined in Article 5. They would point out that the domestic legislation of many countries provides for the taxation of services provided in these countries, even in the absence of a permanent establishment (even if services provided for very short periods are not always taxed in practice).
137. These States are concerned that some service companies do not require a permanent office on their territory to ensure a significant level of business activity, and therefore consider that such additional rights are appropriate.
138. In addition, these States believe that even if the taxation of profits of non-resident enterprises that are not attributed to permanent missions causes certain compliance difficulties, as well as administrative difficulties, these difficulties do not justify exemption from taxation of profits derived from the provision of any services by such enterprises in their territory. Those who support this point of view may refer to the mechanisms already in place in some States to ensure taxation of services provided in those States but not attributed to permanent missions (such mechanisms are based on the requirements for resident taxpayers to report on the amounts paid to non-residents for services provided in those States, and possibly withhold tax on them).
139. However, it should be noted that all Contracting States agree that a State should not be entitled to taxation based on the principle of source in respect of income earned from the provision of services by a non-resident outside the territory of the State. According to taxation agreements, profits from the sale of goods that are simply imported by a resident of a country and are not produced or distributed through a permanent establishment in that country are not subject to taxation on its territory, and the same principle applies to services. The mere fact that the person paying remuneration for services is a resident of the State, or that such remuneration is received by a permanent establishment located in that State, or that the result of the services is used on the territory of the State, is not a sufficient reason to guarantee the granting of rights to this State to tax income.
140. Another important issue on which there is general agreement relates to the determination of the amount from which the tax should be levied. In the case of services not related to employment (and subject to possible exceptions, for example, Article 17), only profits earned from the provision of services are taxed. Thus, the provisions sometimes included in bilateral agreements that allow the State to tax the gross amount of fees paid for certain services if the fee payer is a resident of that State do not seem to provide an optimal way to tax services. Firstly, since these provisions are not limited to services provided in the State where the source is located, they allow the State to tax business activities not carried out in that State. Secondly, these rules make it possible to tax gross payments for services rather than profits from them.
141. In addition, the Contracting States agree that, in order to comply with the requirements and for other reasons, it is advisable not to allow the State to tax profits from services provided on their territory in certain circumstances (for example, if such services are provided for a very short period).
142. For this reason, the Committee considered it important to limit the circumstances in which States that disagree with the conclusions set out in Paragraph 132 could, if desired, ensure that profits from services provided in the territory of a Contracting State by an enterprise of another Contracting State are taxed by that State even in the absence of a permanent establishment, definition which is listed in Article 5, to which this profit belongs.
143. Obviously, such taxation should not apply to services provided outside the territory of the State, and should apply only to profits from the provision of such services, and not to payments for their provision. In addition, the decision to allow such taxation is made only if there is a minimal presence in the State.
144. The following is an example of a provision that would meet such requirements; States may bilaterally agree to include such a provision in their tax agreements:
Notwithstanding the provisions of Paragraphs 1, 2 and 3, if an enterprise of a Contracting State provides services in the other Contracting State
(a) Through an individual present in that other State for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days over any period of twelve months, and more than 50 per cent of the gross income related to the active business activities of the enterprise during that period or periods is derived from the provision of services in that other State through this individual, or
b) for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days over any period of twelve months, and these services are provided for a single project or related projects through one or more individuals present and providing such services in that other State,
the activity of providing these services in that other State shall be considered to be carried out through a permanent establishment located in that other State, except in cases where these Services are limited to those referred to in Paragraph 4, which, when provided through a permanent place of business (other than the place to which the provisions of Paragraph 4.1 apply), do not This place is a permanent mission in accordance with the provisions of this Paragraph. For the purposes of this Paragraph, services provided by an individual on behalf of one enterprise should not be considered to be provided by another enterprise through that individual, except in cases where that other enterprise controls or provides guidance on the manner in which the individual provides those services.
145. This alternative provision expands the definition of a permanent establishment, which allows income from services provided by enterprises run by non-residents to be taxed, but does so in accordance with the principles described in Paragraph 143. The following Paragraph discusses various aspects of the alternative provision; obviously, these Paragraphs do not apply in the case of contracts that do not include these provisions, and therefore do not allow the establishment of a permanent establishment solely because the conditions described in this provision have been fulfilled.
146. This provision presupposes the existence of a permanent establishment in cases where it would otherwise not exist in accordance with the definition given in Paragraph 1 and the examples in Paragraph 2. For this reason, it is applied despite the existence of these Points. As in the case of Paragraph 5 of the Article, the provision provides an additional basis under which an enterprise can be recognized as having a permanent establishment in the State.; For example, it may be applied when a consultant provides services in a country for a long period, but in different locations that do not meet the requirements of Paragraph 1 for establishing one or more permanent representative offices. If it is possible to prove that an enterprise has a permanent establishment within the meaning of Paragraphs 1 and 2 (subject to the provisions of Paragraph 4), then there is no need to apply the provision to find a permanent establishment. Since the provision simply creates a permanent establishment in situations where it would not otherwise exist, it does not provide an alternative definition of permanent establishment and obviously cannot limit the scope of the definition given in paragraph 1 and the examples from Paragraph 2.
147. The provision also applies notwithstanding Paragraph 3. Thus, an enterprise can be considered to have a permanent establishment, since it provides services in the country during the periods provided for in the proposed Paragraph, even if the various places where these services are provided do not constitute permanent representative offices according to Paragraph 3. This result is illustrated by the following example. An individual entrepreneur who is a resident of one of the Contracting States provides services and is present in the other Contracting State for more than 183 days of one period of twelve months, but his services are provided for equal periods in a place that is not a construction site (and not related to a construction or installation project), as well as on two non-construction sites. interconnected construction sites, each of which exists for less than the period stipulated in Paragraph 3. Although, according to Paragraph 3, the two sites do not constitute permanent representative offices, according to the proposed Paragraph, applied regardless of the provisions of Paragraph 3, an enterprise managed by this person will be considered to have a permanent establishment (since the person is an individual entrepreneur, it should be assumed that in relation to his enterprise the criterion of 50 percent of gross income will be respected).
148. Another example is a large construction company implementing a construction project in a country. If the project is carried out on the same site, the regulation should not have a serious impact if the period required for the site to become a permanent establishment does not significantly differ from the period required for the application of the regulation. States that wish to apply an alternative provision may therefore wish to consider specifying the same periods in this provision and in paragraph 3 of Article 5.; If a shorter period is used in an alternative provision, then in practice this will narrow the scope of Paragraph 3.
149. However, the situation may change if the project or related projects are carried out in different parts of the country. If the individual sites where the project is being implemented have not existed long enough for each of them to become a permanent establishment (see, however, paragraph 57), the permanent establishment is still considered to exist if the conditions of the alternative position are met. This result corresponds to the purpose of the regulation, which is to tax foreign enterprises based on the source principle that have been present in the country for a sufficiently long period, despite the fact that they have been present in a particular place of the country for not long enough for it to become a permanent place of business of the enterprise. However, some States may consider that paragraph 3 should take precedence over the alternative provision and wish to amend the provision accordingly.
150. The suggested Paragraph is used only in relation to services. Its scope of application does not include other types of activities that are not services. Thus, for example, the Clause will not apply to a foreign enterprise engaged in fishing in the territorial waters of a State and receiving income from the sale of its catch (in some contracts, however, specific provisions may cover activities such as fishing and oil production).
151. The Regulation applies to services provided by the company. Therefore, the company must provide services to third parties. Of course, the provision cannot imply that an enterprise has a permanent establishment just because services are provided to it. For example, a person may provide services to his employer without that employer providing any services (for example, an employee providing manufacturing services to an enterprise selling manufactured goods). Another example is when employees of one company provide services in one country to an associated company in accordance with detailed instructions and under strict supervision from the second company; in this case, assuming that the services in question are not provided in the interests of any third party, the second company itself does not provide services. to which the regulation may apply.
152. In addition, the provision applies only to services provided in the State by a foreign enterprise. It does not matter whether the relevant services are provided to a resident of the State; what matters is that the services are provided on the territory of the State through an individual located in that State.
153. The alternative provision does not specify that services should be provided "through staff or other personnel employed by staff"; this phrase is often found in bilateral agreements. It simply implies that the services should be provided by the enterprise. As already explained in Paragraph 39, the business activities of an enterprise (which, in the context of the Paragraph, should include services provided in the territory of a Contracting State) "are carried out by an entrepreneur or persons whose work is paid by the enterprise (staff). This staff includes employees and other persons who receive instructions from the company (for example, dependent agents)." For the purposes of the alternative provision, the persons through whom the company provides services will therefore be the persons referred to in Paragraph 39, subject to the exception given in the last sentence of this provision (see paragraph 164).
154. The alternative provision would apply in two different sets of circumstances. Subparagraph (a) considers the duration of the presence of the person through whom the enterprise receives most of its income, similar to subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 of Article 15; subparagraph (b) considers the duration of the activity of the persons through whom the services are provided.
155. Subparagraph (a) mainly deals with enterprises managed by a single individual. However, it also covers cases where an enterprise, during the relevant period or periods, receives most of its profits from services provided by one person. Such an extension is necessary to avoid using different approaches, for example, in the case when services are provided by an individual, and in the case when similar services are provided by a company, all shares of which belong to a single employee of this company.
156. The subparagraph may be applied in various situations where an enterprise provides services through an individual, for example, when services are provided by an individual entrepreneur, a partner in a partnership, an employee of a company, etc. The main conditions are listed below:
— the individual through whom the services are provided is in the State for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days during any period of twelve months, and
— more than 50 percent of the gross income attributed to the active business activities of the enterprise during the period or periods of presence was obtained through the provision of services in this State through this person.
157. The first condition is related to the number of days a person has been in the Territory. Since the wording is similar to that given in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 of Article 15, the principles applied to the calculation of days of stay for the purposes of this Paragraph also apply to the calculation of days of stay for the purposes of the proposed Paragraph.
158. For the purposes of the second condition, according to which more than 50 percent of the gross income attributed to the active business activities of the enterprise during the relevant period or periods must originate from the provision of services in that State through that person, the gross income attributed to the active business activities of the enterprise will be the amount that the enterprise has charged or It must charge for its active business activities, regardless of when the invoices will actually be issued, as well as the rules of domestic legislation regarding, when these incomes need to be accounted for for tax purposes. Such active business activities are not limited to activities related to the provision of services. Gross income attributed to “active business activities” obviously does not include income earned from passive investments, including, for example, receiving interest and dividends from investing available funds. However, States may prefer to use another criterion, for example, "50 percent of an enterprise's profit from commercial activities during this period or periods is derived from the provision of services" or "services are an important part of the enterprise's business activities" to identify an enterprise that receives most of its income from services provided by a person on the their territories.
159. The following examples illustrate the application of subparagraph (a) (it is assumed that an alternative provision was included in the agreement between States R and S):
- Example 1: W, a resident of the State of R, is a consultant who carries out his business activities on his own behalf (i.e. this company is an individual entrepreneur). Between February 2, 00 and February 1, 01 she was in State S for a period or periods of 190 days, and during that period all income from her business activities came from services provided by her in State S. Since subparagraph (a) applies in this situation, these services should be considered to be provided through a permanent establishment in State S.
- Example 2: X, a resident of the State of R, is one of two shareholders and employees of XCO, a resident company of the State of R providing engineering services. Between December 20, 00 and December 19, 01, X was in State S for a period or periods of 190 days, and during this period, 70 percent of XCO's total gross income came from active business activities and was generated through services provided by X in State S. Since subparagraph (a) applies in this situation, these services should be considered to be provided through the permanent representative office of XCO in State S.
- Example 3: X and Y, residents of the State of R, are two partners of X&Y, a partnership established in the State of R that provides legal services. For tax purposes, the State does not consider partnerships to be fiscally transparent entities. Between July 15, 00 and July 14, 01, Y was in State S for a period or periods of 240 days, and during that period, 55 percent of all X&Y royalties attributed to X&Y's active business activities were earned through services provided by Y in the State S. In this situation, subparagraph (a) applies, and for the purposes of taxing X and Y, services provided by Y are considered to have been provided through a permanent establishment in State S.
- Example 4: Z, a resident of the State of R, is one of the 10 employees of ACO, a resident company of the State of R providing accounting services. Between April 10, 00 and April 9, 01, Z was in State S for a period or periods of 190 days, and during that period, 12 percent of ACO's total gross income attributable to its active business activities was generated through services provided by Z in State S. In this situation, subparagraph (a) does not apply, and, except in the case of subparagraph (b) to the ACO, the alternative provision does not consider the ACO to have a permanent establishment in State S.
160. Subparagraph (b) deals with a situation where an enterprise provides services in a Contracting State for a specific project (or related projects) through one or more persons for a substantial period. The period or periods referred to in this subparagraph apply to an enterprise, not individuals. Therefore, it is not necessary for the same person or persons to provide services and be present during these periods. As long as on the specified day the enterprise provides its services through at least one person who performs these actions and is present in the State, this day is included in the period or periods mentioned in the subparagraph. However, it is obvious that a day is counted as one day, regardless of the number of people providing such services to the company during that day.
161. The reference to "an enterprise ... providing these services for the same project" should be interpreted from the point of view of the enterprise providing the services. Thus, an enterprise may have two different projects to provide services to the same client (for example, providing tax advice and training in a non-tax area), and although they may relate to the same client's project, these services cannot be considered to be provided under the same project.
162. The reference to "related projects" is intended for cases when services are provided within the framework of separate projects implemented by the enterprise, but these projects are commercially related (see paragraphs 24 and 25). Determining whether projects are related will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case, and factors usually considered for this purpose include:
— are the projects included in the same basic agreement;
— are the projects included in different agreements, are these different agreements concluded with one person or related parties, and were there reasonable prerequisites for concluding additional agreements when concluding the first agreement;
— is the nature of work on different projects the same?;
— whether the same persons provide services for different projects.
163. Subparagraph (b) requires that, during the relevant periods, the enterprise provides services through persons providing such services in that other State. For this purpose, the period during which persons provide services means the period during which such services are actually provided, which usually corresponds to the working days of these persons. An enterprise that agrees to provide access to staff in cases where the client needs the services of such staff, and charges the client a waiting fee for this, provides services through appropriate persons, even if they are idle on business days on which their services are provided.
164. As indicated in Paragraph 153 above, for the purposes of an alternative position, the persons through whom the company provides services are the persons specified in Paragraph 39 above. However, if a person provides services on behalf of one enterprise, the exception given in the last sentence of the regulation clarifies that the services provided by that person will be counted for another enterprise only if that person performs the work under supervision, control, or in accordance with the instructions of the last mentioned enterprise. Thus, for example, if a company that has agreed to provide services to third parties under a contract provides these services through employees of a separate enterprise (for example, an enterprise providing freelance services), then services provided through such employees will not be counted for the purposes of applying subparagraph b) to a company that has concluded a contract for the provision of services to third parties. to the sides. This rule applies regardless of whether an individual company is affiliated or independent of the company that entered into the contract.
165. The following examples illustrate the application of subparagraph (b) (it is assumed that an alternative provision was included in the agreement between the R and S States):
- Example 1: X, a resident company of State R, has agreed with company Y to conduct geological exploration in various locations on the territory of State S, where company Y has the right to conduct exploration work. Between May 15, 00 and May 14, 01, this exploration was carried out for more than 185 working days by X's employees and individual entrepreneurs, to whom X entrusted part of the work, but under supervision, control, and in accordance with X's instructions. Since subparagraph (b) applies in this situation, these services should be considered to be provided through a permanent establishment of X in State S.
- Example 2: Y, a resident of State T, is one of two shareholders and employees of WYCO, a resident company of State R that provides training services. Between June 10, 00 and June 9, 01, Y provides services in State S under an agreement that WYCO has concluded with a company that is a resident of State S for the training of employees of this company. These services are provided in the territory of State S for more than 185 business days. During the period of Y's stay in the territory of State S, profits from these services account for 40 percent of WYCO's gross income from its active business activities. Although subparagraph (a) does not apply in this situation, subparagraph (b) applies, and these services should be considered to be provided through a permanent representative office of WYCO in State S.
- Example 3: ZCO, a resident of State R, contracted OCO, a resident of State S, to provide technical support to its customers by phone. OCO operates a call center for a number of companies similar to ZCO. From January 1, 00, to December 31, 00, OCO employees provide technical support to various ZCO clients. Since OCO employees are not under the supervision or control of ZCO and do not follow its instructions, for the purposes of subparagraph b), ZCO cannot be considered to provide services in the territory of State S through these employees. In addition, although the services provided by OCO employees to various ZCO clients are similar, they are provided under different contracts concluded by ZCO with unrelated clients: therefore, these services cannot be considered to be provided for the same or related projects.
166. The 183-day threshold provided for in the alternative provision may lead to the same type of abuse as described in Paragraph 52 above. As indicated in this Paragraph, in addition to the fact that such abuses may, depending on the circumstances, fall within the scope of legislative or judicial norms aimed at countering tax evasion, these abuses can be eliminated by applying the anti-tax rule given in Paragraph 9 of Article 29. However, some States may prefer to address this issue by including a specific provision in the Article. Such a provision could be formulated as follows:
For the purposes of Paragraph [x], if an enterprise of a Contracting State providing services in the territory of another Contracting State has, for any period, a close relationship with another enterprise providing generally similar services in that other State for the same project or related projects through one or more persons who, during the period during this period, they are present and provide services in this State., During this period, the company mentioned first is considered to be providing services in another State within the framework of the same project or related projects through these persons.
167. According to the regulation, activities carried out in another State by the persons referred to in subparagraph (a) or (b) through whom the enterprise provides services during the period or periods referred to in these subparagraphs are considered to be carried out through a permanent establishment that the enterprise has in that other State. Thus, an enterprise is considered to have a permanent establishment in this other State for the purposes of all the provisions of the Agreement (including, for example, Paragraph 5 of Article 11 and Paragraph 2 of Article 15), and profits derived from the provision of these services in another State are attributed to the account of this permanent establishment, and therefore are subject to taxation in in this State according to Article 7.
168. Considering the activity of providing the relevant services as carried out through a permanent establishment that the enterprise has in the territory of a Contracting State, the provision allows for the application of Article 7 and, consequently, the taxation of profits attributable to that activity by that State. As a rule, it is important to ensure that only profits earned from service activities are taxed.; Although there may be certain exceptions, it would negatively affect international trade in services if payments received for the provision of these services were taxed regardless of the direct or indirect costs incurred for the purpose of providing these services.
169. This alternative provision will not apply if the services provided are limited to those referred to in Paragraph 4 of Article 5, which, if provided through a permanent place of business, would not make that place a permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of this Paragraph. Since the provision relates to the provision of services by an enterprise and does not cover services provided by the enterprise itself, most of the provisions of Paragraph 4 do not seem to be relevant. However, it may turn out that the services provided are exclusively preparatory or auxiliary in nature (for example, providing information to potential clients if it is only preparation for conducting the normal business activities of the enterprise; see paragraph 71 above), and in this case it is logical not to consider the provision of these services as a permanent establishment.
Comments on the Comment
170. With regard to Paragraph 64, Germany remains in its opinion as to whether, and if so, under what circumstances, the acquisition of the right to dispose of the capacity of pipelines or the capacity of technical installations, lines and cables for the transmission of electricity or communication systems (including the transmission of radio and television programs) belonging to an unrelated third party took place, could lead to the disposal of a pipeline, cable, or line as a permanent place of business.
171. With regard to Paragraph 104, Mexico believes that in determining whether an agent has an independent status for the purposes of Paragraph 6 of the Article, the principle of “at arm's length" should also be taken into account, and wishes to add language to its agreements, if necessary, to clarify how the Paragraph should be interpreted.
172. Germany, with regard to Paragraph 50, sentence 3, is of the view that a business activity limited to on-site planning and monitoring of a construction project can constitute a permanent establishment only if it meets the requirements specified in paragraph 1 of Article 5.
173. Italy and Portugal consider it necessary to take into account that, regardless of the meaning given to the third sentence of Paragraph 2 regarding the tax calculation method, the new version of the model, i.e. the deletion of Article 14, will not affect national systems.
174. The Czech Republic has a number of clarifications and reservations regarding the report on "Issues arising in connection with Article 5 of the OECD Model Tax Convention". In particular, the Czech Republic does not agree with the interpretation given in Paragraphs 24 (first part of Paragraph) and 25 (first part of Paragraph). In accordance with its policy, these examples can also be considered as components of a permanent establishment if services are provided on its territory for an extended period.
175. With regard to Paragraph 50, the Czech Republic uses a narrower interpretation of the concept of "installation project", and thus limits it to installation and assembly related to the construction project. In addition, the Czech Republic adheres to the interpretation that supervisory activities automatically fall under Paragraph 3 of Article 5 only if they are carried out by a construction company. Otherwise, it falls under its scope only if such an activity is explicitly mentioned in this special provision. If the installation project is not related to the construction project, and if the supervisory activity is carried out by an enterprise that is not a construction company and is not explicitly mentioned in Paragraph 3 of Article 5, then the rules regarding the taxation of income received from the provision of other services automatically apply to this activity.
176. With regard to Paragraphs 122 to 131, the United Kingdom is of the opinion that a server used by an online retailer, either alone or in conjunction with websites, cannot in itself constitute a permanent establishment.
177. Chile and Greece do not adhere to all the interpretations given in Paragraphs 122-131.
178. Germany does not agree with the interpretation of the "example of an artist" given in Paragraph 17, which it considers to be inconsistent with the principle set out in the first sentence of Paragraph 12, thus not contributing to the establishment of a permanent establishment under Article 5, paragraph 1 of the Model Convention. As for the example described in Paragraph 25, Germany would insist that the consultant manage the offices used in addition to his simple presence during the training.
179. Germany remains of the opinion regarding the scope and scope of application of the indications in sentence 2 of Paragraph 28 and Paragraphs 29 and 30, considering that in order to assume a permanent place of business, the necessary degree of permanence requires a certain minimum period of presence during the relevant year, regardless of the repetitive or other nature of the activity. In particular, Germany does not agree with the criterion of economic connectivity described in sentence 1 of Paragraph 30, intended to justify an exception to the minimum presence and duration requirements.
180. Germany, with regard to Paragraph 98 (with reference to Paragraphs 83 and 28-30), attaches increased importance to the minimum duration of representation of an enterprise under Article 5, Paragraph 5, of the Model Convention in the absence of the agent's residence and/or permanent place of business in the country of income. In these cases, Germany therefore holds particularly narrow views on the applicability of the factors mentioned in paragraphs 28-30.
181. Italy wishes to clarify that, with regard to Paragraphs 97, 116, 117 and 118, its jurisprudence should be taken into account when interpreting the cases covered by them.
182. Mexico and Portugal wish to reserve the right not to adhere to the position set out in Paragraphs 122-131.
183. Turkey remains unconvinced as to whether the activity referred to in Paragraphs 122-131 is a permanent establishment, and if so, under what circumstances.
184. Finland and Sweden consider that if a State decides to include in the agreement an alternative version of Paragraph 4 of Article 5 from Paragraph 78 of the Commentary, then there is no need to also include Paragraph 4.1 of Article 5 in the agreement.
185. Germany remains unconvinced about the application of the first sentence of Paragraph 9.
186. Greece does not adhere to all the interpretations given in paragraph 45.
Reservations to the Article
187. The United States reserves the right to adhere to the versions of Paragraphs 5 and 6 as they existed prior to the updating of the Model Tax Convention in 2017.
Point 1
188. Australia reserves the right to consider an enterprise as having a permanent establishment in a State if it carries out activities related to natural resources or uses a significant amount of equipment in that State with a certain degree of continuity, or if a person acting in that State on behalf of the enterprise produces or processes goods in that State owned by the company.
189. Given the particular challenges in applying the provisions of the Model Convention to offshore oil and gas exploration and use, as well as related activities, Canada, Denmark, Ireland, Latvia, Norway and the United Kingdom reserve the right to include provisions related to such activities in a special article.
190. Chile reserves the right to consider that the company has a permanent establishment, under certain circumstances in which the services are provided.
191. The Czech Republic and Slovakia, while agreeing to the requirement of Paragraph 1 on a "permanent place of business", reserve the right to propose in the course of bilateral negotiations specific provisions clarifying the application of this principle to long-term service arrangements.
192. Greece reserves the right to consider an enterprise as having a permanent establishment in Greece if the enterprise carries out planning, supervision or consulting activities in connection with the presence of a construction site or construction/installation project lasting more than six months, if the enterprise uses scientific equipment or equipment in Greece for more than three months during exploration or extraction of natural resources, or if the company implements more than one separate project, each of which lasts less than six months., during the same period (i.e. during the calendar year).
193. Greece reserves the right to introduce special provisions concerning activities at sea.
194. Estonia and Mexico reserve the right to tax individuals who provide professional services or carry out other independent activities if they are present in these States for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days in any period of twelve months.
195. New Zealand reserves the right to include provisions according to which a permanent establishment is recognized as existing if the enterprise has been engaged in activities related to the extraction or exploitation of natural resources for more than six months, or has leased a significant amount of equipment.
196. Turkey reserves the right to consider a person as having a permanent establishment in its territory if the person provides professional services and other independent activities, including planning, supervision or consulting, with a certain degree of continuity, either directly or through employees of a separate enterprise.
197. Latvia reserves the right to consider any person providing professional services or carrying out other activities of an independent nature as having a permanent establishment if the person is present in the State for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days in any period of twelve months.
Item 2
198. Canada, Chile and Israel reserve the right to replace the word "production" in subparagraph 2 (e) with the words "related to exploration or exploitation".
199. Greece reserves the right to include Paragraph 2 of Article 5 in the form in which it was drafted in the 1963 draft Convention.
200. Greece and Mexico reserve the right to replace the word "mining" in subparagraph 2 (e) with the words "related to mining, exploration or exploitation".
Point 3
201. Australia, Chile, Greece, Korea, New Zealand, Portugal and Turkey remain of the same opinion regarding Paragraph 3 and consider that any construction site or construction/installation project that has been operating for more than six months should be considered a permanent establishment.
202. Australia reserves the right to consider an enterprise to have a permanent establishment in a State if it carries out supervision or consulting activities in that State for more than 183 days in any period of twelve months for a construction site or construction/installation project in that State.
203. Korea stands by its opinion to be able to tax an enterprise that carries out supervisory activities for more than six months for a construction site or a construction/installation project lasting more than six months.
204. Slovenia reserves the right to include related supervision or consulting activities in Paragraph 3 of the Article.
205. Mexico and Slovakia reserve the right to tax an enterprise that carries out supervisory activities for more than six months for a construction site or a construction/assembly/installation project.
206. Mexico and Slovakia remain of the same opinion with regard to Paragraph 3 and consider that any construction site or construction/assembly/installation project with activities lasting more than six months should be considered a permanent establishment.
207. Poland and Slovenia reserve the right to replace the phrase "construction or installation project" with the phrase "construction/assembly/installation project".
208. Portugal reserves the right to consider an enterprise to have a permanent establishment in Portugal if the enterprise carries out activities involving planning, supervision, consulting, any additional work or any other activity for a construction site or construction/installation project that has been in existence for more than six months, if such activities or work also continue for more than six months.
209. The United States reserves the right to add a "drilling rig or vessel used for the exploration of natural resources" to activities meeting the twelve-month threshold set out in Paragraph 3.
Item 4
210. Chile reserves the right to amend Paragraph 4 by deleting subparagraph (e), replacing the text of subparagraph (e) with "maintaining a permanent place of business solely for the purpose of advertising, providing information, scientific research or other similar activities for the enterprise", and deleting the phrase "or, in the case of subparagraph (e), the work of the permanent place of business as a whole" from the last part of Paragraph 4.
211. Mexico reserves the right to delete subparagraph (e) of Paragraph 4 from the Article in order to decide on the possibility of a permanent establishment if there is a permanent place of business for a combination of any of the activities specified in subparagraphs (a) to (e) of Paragraph 4.
Paragraph 4.1
212. Finland, Luxembourg, Sweden and Switzerland reserve the right not to include Clause 4.1 in their agreements.
Item 5
213. Finland, Germany, Luxembourg, Sweden and Switzerland reserve the right to use the previous version of Paragraph 5 of Article 5 (i.e., the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately prior to its update in 2017).
Item 6
214. Finland, Luxembourg and Sweden reserve the right to use the previous version of Paragraph 6 of Article 5 (i.e., the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately prior to its update in 2017).
215. Germany reserves the right to use the previous version of Paragraph 6 (i.e., the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately before its update in 2017), since it does not agree that a person should not be considered an independent agent just because that person acts solely or almost exclusively on behalf of one or several closely related businesses.
Item 8
216. Finland and Sweden reserve the right not to include Paragraph 8 in their agreements.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 6
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF INCOME FROM REAL ESTATE
1. Paragraph 1 grants the right to tax income from real estate to the State of origin, i.e. the State in whose territory the property generating such income is located. This is due to the fact that there is always a very close economic relationship between the source of this income and the source State. Although income from agriculture or forestry is included in Article 6, the Contracting States may agree in their bilateral agreements to treat such income in accordance with Article 7. Article 6 applies only to income earned by a resident of a Contracting State from immovable property located in the other Contracting State. Consequently, it does not apply to income from immovable property located in the territory of a Contracting State, the recipient of which is a resident within the meaning of Article 4 located in the territory of a third State; the provisions of Paragraph 1 of Article 21 apply to such income.
2. The definition of immovable property based on the legislation of the State in which the property is located, as provided for in Paragraph 2, will help to avoid difficulties in interpreting the question of whether an asset or a right should be considered as immovable property. However, this Paragraph specifically lists assets and rights that should always be considered real estate. In fact, such assets and rights are already considered immovable property according to the laws or tax rules of most OECD member countries. At the same time, the Clause stipulates that ships and aircraft should never be considered immovable property. No special provisions have been included with respect to income from debt secured by immovable property, as this issue is regulated by Article 11.
2.1 The phrase "including income from agriculture or forestry" in Paragraph 1 expands the scope of Article 6 to include not only income derived from immovable property as defined in Paragraph 2, but also income generated by activities constituting agriculture or forestry. Income from agriculture and forestry includes not only income earned by an enterprise involved in agricultural or forestry production, but also income that is an integral part of agricultural or forestry activities, such as income earned from the acquisition or trade of carbon quotas (the essence of these quotas is explained in Paragraph 75.1 of the Commentary to Article 7) if such an acquisition or trade is an integral part of the implementation of agricultural or forestry activities, for example, in cases where quotas are acquired for the purpose of carrying out this activity, or if quotas acquired for this purpose will subsequently be sold if it becomes obvious that they are not necessary.
3. Paragraph 3 states that the general rule applies regardless of the form of exploitation of real estate. Paragraph 4 clarifies that the provisions of Paragraphs 1 and 3 also apply to income from immovable property of industrial, commercial and other enterprises. However, income in the form of distributions from real estate investment trusts (REITs) raises certain issues, which are discussed in Paragraphs 67.1 - 67.7 of the Commentary to Article 10.
4. In this regard, it should be noted that the right of the source State to taxation takes precedence over the right of another State to taxation, and also applies if, in the case of an enterprise, income is derived from immovable property only indirectly. This does not prevent income from immovable property, if it was received through a permanent establishment, from being considered the income of an enterprise, but ensures that income from immovable property is taxed in the State in which the property is located, even if such property is not part of a permanent establishment located in that State. It should also be noted that the provisions of the Article do not prejudice the application of domestic legislation regarding the way income from immovable property is taxed.
Reservations to the Article
5. Finland and Latvia reserve the right to tax the income of shareholders in resident companies from the direct use, leasing or use in any other form of the right to use immovable property located in their countries and owned by the company, if such right is based on the ownership of shares or other corporate rights in the company.
6. France wishes to retain the possibility of applying the provisions of its domestic legislation relating to the taxation of income from shares or rights that it considers income from immovable property.
7. Spain reserves the right to tax income from any form of application of the right to use real estate located in Spain, if such right is related to the ownership of shares or other corporate rights in the company that owns the property.
8. Canada and Latvia reserve the right to include in Paragraph 3 a reference to income from the alienation of immovable property.
9. New Zealand reserves the right to include fisheries and rights related to all natural resources in accordance with this Article.
10. The United States reserves the right to add a Paragraph to Article 6 that allows a resident of a Contracting State to choose to tax income from real estate from the other Contracting State on a net basis.
11. Australia reserves the right to include rights related to all natural resources in accordance with this Article.
12. Mexico reserves the right to consider as immovable property any right that allows the use of immovable property located in the territory of a Contracting State, if such use is related to the division of time, since, according to its domestic legislation, such a right is not considered immovable property.
13. Estonia reserves the right to include in the definition of “immovable property” any right of claim in respect of immovable property, since such a right cannot be included in the meaning of this concept provided for by its domestic legislation.
14. Israel and Latvia reserve the right to include in Paragraph 2 "any option or similar right to acquire immovable property."
15. Portugal reserves the right to extend the scope of Article 6 to include income from movable property or income derived from the provision of services related to the use or right to use immovable property, any of which, according to the tax laws of the Contracting State in whose territory the property is located, is equivalent to income from immovable property.
16. Greece reserves the right, in addition to ships, to include a ship in the definition provided for in Paragraph 2.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 7
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF CORPORATE PROFITS
I. Preliminary remarks
1. This Article distributes the rights to taxation in respect of the commercial profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State to the extent that these profits are not regulated by other rules in accordance with the Articles of the Agreement. It contains the basic principle according to which, if an enterprise of a Contracting State does not have a permanent establishment in another State, the commercial profits of that enterprise may not be taxed by that other State, except in cases where such profits fall under special categories of income in respect of which other Articles of the Agreement grant that other State The State has the right to tax.
2. Therefore, Article 5, which includes the definition of a permanent establishment, refers to the determination of whether the commercial profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State may be taxed in the other State. However, this Article does not in itself allocate taxation rights: if an enterprise of a Contracting State carries out activities in the territory of another Contracting State through a permanent establishment located there, it is necessary to determine what constitutes profit, if any, that the other State may tax. Article 7 answers this question by defining that another State may tax Profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment.
3. The principles underlying Article 7, and in particular Paragraph 2 of the Article, have a long history. When the OECD first began to explore what criteria should be applied when attributing profits to the permanent mission account, this issue had already been addressed in many tax agreements and various models developed by the League of Nations. The principles of independence and disinterest on which Paragraph 2 is based have already been incorporated into these agreements and models, and the OECD considered it sufficient to restate these principles with some minor amendments and modifications, mainly for clarification purposes.
4. Nevertheless, practical experience has shown that there were significant differences in the interpretation of these general principles and other provisions of earlier versions of Article 7. This lack of generally accepted interpretation has created problems of double taxation and non-taxation. Over the years, the Committee on Budget and Finance has spent a lot of time and effort trying to ensure a more consistent interpretation and application of the rules of the Article. Minor changes in the wording of the Article and a number of changes in the Commentary were made when the Model Tax Convention was adopted in 1977. In 1984, a report was published in which this issue was considered in the specific case of banks.1 In 1987, noting that the establishment of profits attributed to the permanent mission account could lead to some uncertainty, the Committee examined this issue, as a result of which a report entitled “Attribution of income to permanent missions”2 was adopted in 1993, and the Commentary was subsequently amended.
5. Despite this work, the practice of countries within and outside the OECD regarding the allocation of profits to permanent missions, as well as the interpretation of Article 7 by these countries, still have significant differences. The Committee recognized the need for greater certainty for taxpayers: in its report, the Transfer Pricing Guidelines for International Enterprises and Tax Authorities 3 ("OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines") He noted that further work will be aimed at applying the principle of “at arm's length" to permanent missions. This work resulted in the preparation of a report in 2008 entitled Attribution of profits to permanent missions (the "2008 Report").
____________________
1 "Taxation of multinational banking enterprises", in Transfer pricing and Multinational Enterprises: Three Taxation Issues, OECD, Paris, 1984.
2 Attribution of income to Permanent Missions, Problems of International Taxation No. 5, OECD, Paris, 1994; included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(13)-1
3 The original text of this report was adopted by the OECD Council on 27 June.
6. The approach developed in the 2008 Report was not limited to the original intent or historical practice and interpretation of Article 7. Instead, the focus was on formulating the most optimal approach to allocating profits to the permanent establishment account in accordance with Article 7, taking into account modern international transactions and trade. After the approval of the 2008 Report, the Committee considered that the instructions included in it represented a better approach to allocating profits to permanent missions than previously. However, he also acknowledged that there were differences between some of the conclusions set out in the 2008 Report and the interpretations of Article 7 previously given in this Commentary.
7. In order to ensure maximum certainty on how to allocate profits to permanent missions, the Committee decided to reflect the conclusions of the G. Report in full in the new version of Article 7, together with the attached Commentary, for use during negotiations on future treaties and amendments to existing ones. In addition, in order to interpret the agreements already concluded on the basis of the previous version of Article 7 with greater certainty, the Committee decided that it was necessary to prepare an updated version of the Commentary to this previous version of the Article in order to take into account those aspects of the report that did not contradict the Commentary in the form in which they existed before the adoption of the 2008 Report.
8. A new version of the Article, which now appears in the Model Tax Convention, was adopted in 2010. At the same time, the Committee approved a new version of the 2008 Report to ensure that the conclusions of this report were consistent with the new wording and renumbering of this new version of the Article. Although the conclusions and interpretations included in the revised report were adopted in this way in 20101. (hereinafter referred to as the “Report"), identical to those given in the 2008 Report, this revised version takes into account the currently existing version of the Article (The Appendix to this Commentary for historical reference includes the text of the previous version of Article 7 and this Commentary in the form in which they existed before the adoption of the current version of the Article).
9. Thus, the current version of the Article reflects the approach developed in the Report and should be interpreted in accordance with the guidelines contained therein. The Report examines the allocation of profits to the account of both permanent missions in general (Part I of the Report) and, in particular, permanent missions of enterprises operating in the financial sector, where trade through a permanent mission is widespread (Part II of the Report, which concerns permanent missions of banks, Part III, which concerns permanent missions of enterprises engaged in global trade, and Part IV relating to permanent representations of insurance companies).
__________________
1 Attribution of profits to Permanent Missions, OECD, Paris, 2010
Commentary on the provisions of the Article
Point 1
10. Paragraph 1 includes rules for the allocation of rights to tax the commercial profits of enterprises of each Contracting State. First, it states that if an enterprise of a Contracting State does not have a permanent establishment in the territory of another State, the commercial profits of that enterprise cannot be taxed by that other State. Secondly, it provides that if an enterprise carries out activities in another State through a permanent establishment located there, the profits attributed to the account of the permanent establishment, as defined in Paragraph 2, may be taxed by that other State. However, according to the definition below, Paragraph 4 restricts the application of these rules, providing that Article 7 does not affect the application of other Articles of the Convention that provide special rules for certain categories of profits (for example, those derived from the operation of ships and aircraft in international traffic) or certain categories of income that may also constitute commercial profits. (for example, income earned by an enterprise in connection with the personal activities of an artist or athlete).
11 The first principle underlying Paragraph 1, i.e. The fact that the profits of an enterprise of one Contracting State should not be taxed in another State, except in cases where the enterprise carries on business in that other State through a permanent establishment located there, has a long history and reflects the international consensus that, as a rule, as long as the enterprise of one State It will not have a permanent representative office in another State, and in fact it should not be considered participating in the economic life of that other State to the extent that, which would give this other State the right to tax the profits of the enterprise.
12 . The second principle, reflected in the second sentence of the Paragraph, is that the right of a State to tax when a permanent establishment exists on its territory does not apply to profits that an enterprise may receive in that State, but which are not attributed to the permanent establishment. This is an issue that has had different points of view throughout history. Some time ago, several countries followed the principle of a common “force of attraction”, according to which income such as other commercial profits, dividends, interest and royalties arising from sources on their territory were fully taxed on their part if the beneficiary had a permanent establishment there, even if such income was clearly not related to the account of this permanent mission. Although some bilateral tax agreements include a limited norm aimed at countering tax evasion and based on a limited gravity approach that applies only to commercial profits generated from activities similar to those carried out by a permanent mission, in the practice of international tax agreements, the general gravity approach described above has currently been rejected. The principle that is now generally accepted in double taxation agreements is based on the view that when taxing profits that a foreign enterprise receives from a particular State, the tax authorities of that State should consider individual sources of profit that the enterprise receives in their State and apply to each the criterion of permanent establishment, taking into account the possible application of others Articles of the Convention. This solution allows for a more simplified and efficient tax management and compliance with the requirements of tax legislation, and it is more adapted to the way business is usually conducted. Modern businesses have a very complex organization. There are a significant number of companies, each of which is engaged in a wide range of activities and conducts large-scale business in many countries. A company may establish a permanent representative office in another country through which it carries out production activities, while another part of the same company sells various goods in that other country through independent agents. A given company may have quite compelling commercial reasons for doing so: for example, they may be based on the historical structure of its business or commercial convenience. If the country in whose territory the permanent establishment is located wished to attempt to identify and tax the revenue components of each transaction carried out through independent agents in order to combine these profits with the profits of the permanent establishment, then such an approach would create serious obstacles to normal commercial activities and would be contrary to the objectives of the Convention.
13. As indicated in the second sentence of Paragraph 1, profits credited to the account of a permanent establishment are determined in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 2, which gives the meaning of the phrase “profits credited to the account of a permanent establishment” in Paragraph 1. Since Paragraph 1 grants the right of taxation to the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located only in respect of profits attributed to that permanent establishment, therefore, subject to the application of other Articles of the Convention, this Paragraph does not allow that State to tax the profits of an enterprise of the other Contracting State not attributed to the permanent establishment.
14 . The purpose of Paragraph 1 is to limit the right of one Contracting State to tax the commercial profits of enterprises of the other Contracting State. As confirmed by Paragraph 3 of Article 1, Paragraph does not limit the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents in accordance with the provisions on controlled foreign companies contained in its domestic legislation, even if such a tax levied on these residents can be calculated taking into account the part of the profits of an enterprise that is a resident of the other Contracting State, which is related to the participation of these residents in this enterprise. The tax that a State imposes on its residents in this way does not reduce the profits of an enterprise in another State, and thus cannot be considered levied on such profits (see also paragraph 81 of the Commentary to Article 1).
Item 2
15. Paragraph 2 sets out the basic rule for determining the profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment. According to the Paragraph, this profit is the profit that could be expected from a permanent establishment if it were a separate and independent enterprise carrying out the same or similar activities on the same or similar terms, taking into account the functions, assets and risks performed, used and accepted by the permanent establishment and other divisions of the enterprise. In addition, the Paragraph clarifies that this rule applies to transactions between a permanent establishment and other business units.
16. Thus, the basic approach included in the Paragraph for determining which profit is considered to be attributed to a permanent establishment requires determining profit in accordance with the assumption that a permanent establishment is a separate enterprise and that such an enterprise is independent of the rest of the enterprise of which it is part, as well as from any other faces. The second part of this assumption corresponds to the "at arm's length" principle, which, according to the provisions of Article 9, is also applied to adjust the profits of associated enterprises (see paragraph 1 of the Commentary to Article 9).
17. Paragraph 2 does not attempt to distribute the total profits of the entire enterprise to the permanent establishment and other parts of it, but instead requires that the profits attributed to the permanent establishment be determined as if it were a separate enterprise. Therefore, profits can be attributed to the account of a permanent establishment, even if the company as a whole has never made a profit. Conversely, the provisions of Paragraph 2 may lead to the fact that profits will not be attributed to the account of a permanent establishment, even if the enterprise as a whole has made a profit.
18. However, it is clear that if an enterprise of a Contracting State has a permanent establishment in another Contracting State, the former State has an interest in the correct application of the Directive of Paragraph 2 by the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located. Since this Directive applies to both Contracting States, the State of the enterprise must, in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B, eliminate double taxation of profits properly attributed to the permanent establishment (see paragraph 27 below). In other words, if the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located attempts to tax profits that are not attributed to the permanent establishment in accordance with Article 7, this may lead to double taxation of profits that should be taxed only in the State of the enterprise.
19. As indicated in Paragraphs 8 and 9 above, Article 7, as currently drafted, reflects the approach developed in the Report approved by the Committee on Budget and Finance in 2010. The Report mainly addresses the application of the separate and independent enterprise assumption that underlies Paragraph 2, and the main purpose of the changes made to this Paragraph after the approval of the Report was to ensure that profits attributed to the permanent establishment were consistent with the approach outlined in this Report. The Report therefore provides detailed guidance on how to determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 2.
20. As explained in the Report, the allocation of profits to the account of a permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 2 will follow the calculation of profits (or losses) from all its activities, including transactions with independent enterprises, with related enterprises (with direct application of the OECD Guidelines on Transfer Pricing) and with all other parts of the enterprise. This analysis includes two steps described below. The order of listing the elements of each of these two stages does not have the character of a prescription, since different elements may be interrelated (for example, the risk is initially attributed to a permanent establishment, since it performs the functions of controlling persons associated with assuming this risk, but the recognition and characterization of a subsequent transaction between a permanent establishment and another part of the enterprise, which manages risk, may lead to the transfer of risk and auxiliary capital to another part of the enterprise).
21. At the first stage, a functional and factual analysis is carried out, which will lead to:
— granting to a permanent establishment, depending on the situation, the rights and obligations arising from transactions between the enterprise of which the permanent establishment is a part and individual enterprises;
— identification of important supervisory functions related to the assignment of economic ownership of assets and the assignment of economic ownership of assets to a permanent mission;
— definition of the functions of supervisors related to risk acceptance and attribution of risks to the account of the permanent mission;
— definition of other functions of the permanent mission;
— recognition and determination of the nature of transactions between a permanent establishment and other parts of the same enterprise that can be properly recognized after passing the threshold criterion specified in Paragraph 26; and
— allocation of capital based on assets and risks attributed to the account of a permanent establishment.
22. In the second stage, any transactions with associated enterprises attributed to a permanent establishment are assessed in accordance with the OECD Guidelines on Transfer Pricing, and these Guidelines are applied by analogy with transactions between a permanent establishment and other business units of which it is a part. The process involves setting prices for these recognized transactions on standard commercial terms by:
— determining compatibility between transactions and uncontrolled transactions, established by applying the compatibility factors set out in the Manuals, directly (characteristics of property or services, economic situation and business strategies) or by analogy (functional analysis, terms of the contract), taking into account the specific factual circumstances of the permanent establishment; and
— applying, by analogy, one of the methods described in the Manual to obtain market value for transactions between a permanent establishment and other divisions of the enterprise, taking into account the functions, assets and risks performed and attributed to the permanent establishment and other parts of the enterprise.
23. Each of these transactions is discussed in more detail in the Report, in particular, with regard to the allocation of profits to the permanent representative offices of companies operating in the financial sector, where trade through a permanent representative office is widespread (see Part II of the Report, where permanent representative offices of banks are considered; Part III, where permanent representative offices of enterprises engaged in global trade, and Part IV, which deals with permanent representative offices of insurance companies).
24. Paragraph 2 specifically refers to transactions between a permanent establishment and other divisions of an enterprise of which the permanent establishment is a part, in order to emphasize that the assumption of a separate and independent enterprise set out in Paragraph requires that these transactions be treated in the same way as similar transactions between independent enterprises. However, this specific reference to transactions between permanent missions and other business units does not limit the scope of the Paragraph. If a transaction between an enterprise and an associated enterprise directly affects the determination of the profit attributed to the permanent establishment (for example, the purchase by the permanent establishment of goods from the associated enterprise that will be sold through the permanent establishment), Paragraph 2 also requires that, for the purpose of calculating the profit attributed to the permanent establishment, the terms of the transaction if necessary, they were adjusted to reflect the terms of a similar transaction between independent enterprises. For example, suppose that a permanent establishment located in the territory of State S and owned by an enterprise of State R acquires property from an associated enterprise of State T. If the price stipulated in the contract between the two associated enterprises exceeds the amount agreed between the independent enterprises, Paragraph 2 of Article 7 of the agreement between State R and State S gives State S the right to adjust the profit attributed to the permanent establishment account to reflect the amount that the separate and independent enterprise would pay for this property. In this case, the State of R will also be able to adjust the profits of the enterprise of the State of R in accordance with Paragraph 1 of Article 9 of the agreement between the States of R and T, which will lead to the application of the appropriate mechanism for adjusting Paragraph 2 of Article 9 of this agreement.
25. Transactions between a permanent establishment and other divisions of the enterprise of which it is a part have no legal consequences for the enterprise as a whole. This implies the need for a more thorough study for these transactions than for transactions between two associated enterprises. It also implies a more thorough review of documentation (in case of unavoidable absence, for example, of binding contracts) that might otherwise exist.
26. As a rule, it is not expected that documentation requirements will be more burdensome in connection with such transactions than in transactions between associated enterprises. Moreover, as in the case of transfer pricing documentation specified in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines, the requirements should not be applied in such a way as to impose costs and burdens on taxpayers that are disproportionate to the circumstances. However, given the unique nature of the transaction, countries would like to require taxpayers to clearly demonstrate that recognition of the transaction would be appropriate. For example, accounting records and up-to-date documentation reflecting a transaction that conveys economically significant risks, responsibilities and benefits could be used as a starting point for profit-sharing purposes. Taxpayers are advised to prepare such documentation, as this can significantly reduce the likelihood of disagreements regarding the application of this approach. The tax authorities would apply such documentation regardless of its lack of legal force, in cases where:
— the documentation corresponds to the economic essence of the activities carried out at the enterprise, as revealed by functional and factual analysis; the agreements documented in relation to the transaction, considered as a whole, do not differ from those that would be approved by comparable independent enterprises operating in a commercially rational manner, or, if there is such a difference, the structure, The information provided in the taxpayer's documentation does not actually prevent the tax authority from determining an acceptable transfer price.; and the transaction presented in the taxpayer's documentation does not violate the principles of the approach outlined in the Report, for example, with the aim of transferring risks, separating them from functions.
27. The opening words of Paragraph 2 and the phrase "in each Contracting State" indicate that Paragraph 2 applies not only for the purpose of determining the profits that the Contracting State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located may tax in accordance with the last sentence of Paragraph 1, but also for the application of Articles 23 A and 23 B to others. By a Contracting State. If an enterprise of one State carries on business through a permanent establishment in another State, the first-mentioned State must either exempt from taxation the profits attributed to the permanent establishment (Article 23 A) or provide a subsidy for the payment of the tax on these profits levied by the other State (Article 23 B). In accordance with both of these Articles, this State must determine the profits attributed to the account of the permanent establishment in such a way as to ensure exemption from double taxation, and also to comply with the provisions of Paragraph 2 for this purpose.
28. The assumption of a separate and independent enterprise provided for in Paragraph 2 is limited to determining the profits attributed to the permanent establishment. It does not apply to the creation of theoretical income for an enterprise, which a Contracting State could tax as such in accordance with its domestic law, arguing that such income falls within the scope of another Article of the Convention, which, in accordance with Paragraph 4 of Article 7, allows the taxation of this income regardless of the provisions of Paragraph 1 of Article 7.. Suppose, for example, that the circumstances of a particular case justify the view that the economic ownership of a building used by a permanent mission should be attributed to the head office (see Paragraph 75, Part I of the Report). In such a case, paragraph 2 may require deduction of the estimated rent when determining the profit of the permanent establishment. However, such an assumption cannot be interpreted as generating income from immovable property for the purposes of Article 6. Indeed, the assumption set out in Paragraph 2 does not change the nature of the income earned by the enterprise; it is used only to determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment for the purposes of Articles 7, 23 A and 23 B. Similarly, the fact that, in accordance with paragraph 2, conditional interest may be deducted when determining profits attributed to a permanent establishment does not mean that any interest has been paid to the enterprise of which the permanent establishment is a part for the purposes of Paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 11. The assumption of a separate and independent enterprise does not apply to Article 11, and, for the purposes of this Article, one part of an enterprise cannot be considered paying interest to another part of the same enterprise. However, it is obvious that if the interest paid by an enterprise to another person is paid on a mortgage incurred in connection with a permanent establishment of the enterprise, and is paid by that establishment, such a real interest payment in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 11 may be taxed by the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located. Furthermore, if the transfer of assets between a permanent establishment and the rest of the enterprise is considered a transaction for the purposes of Paragraph 2 of Article 7, Article 13 does not prevent States from taxing profits from such a transaction if such taxation is carried out in accordance with the provisions of Article 7 (see paragraphs 4, 8 and 10 of the Commentary to Article 13).
29. Some States consider that, for political reasons, the assumption of a separate and independent enterprise set out in Paragraph 2 should not be limited to the application of Articles 7, 23 A and 23 B, but should also be used in the interpretation and application of other Articles of the Convention to ensure that permanent missions are, as far as possible, the same approach as for subsidiaries. Consequently, these States may consider that contingent transaction fees, which, in accordance with Paragraph 2, are deductible in calculating the profits of a permanent establishment, should, for the purposes of other Articles of the Convention, be treated in the same way as payments that a subsidiary would pay to its parent company. In this regard, these States may wish to include in their tax agreements provisions according to which fees for domestic transactions should be recognized for the purposes of Articles 6 and 11 (however, it should be noted that taxes are levied in accordance with these provisions only to the extent provided for by domestic law). Alternatively, these States may decide to provide that domestic transactions are not recognized in situations where an equivalent transaction between two separate enterprises would generate income subject to Articles 6 or 11 (however, in this case it is important to ensure that an appropriate proportion of the costs related to what would otherwise be recognized as a transaction, related to the account of the relevant part of the enterprise). However, States considering these alternatives should take into account the fact that, due to special considerations applicable to internal interest charges between different parts of a financial enterprise (for example, a bank), transactions leading to such charges would have been recognized long before the adoption of the current version of the Article.
30. Paragraph 2 defines the profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment for the purposes of the rule set out in Paragraph 1, which distributes the rights to tax these profits. Once the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 7 have been established, the domestic law of each Contracting State must determine whether and how such profits will be taxed, subject to the requirements of Paragraph 2 and other provisions of the Convention. Paragraph 2 does not address the question of whether expenses are deductible from the tax base when calculating the taxable income of an enterprise in any of the Contracting States. The conditions for deducting expenses should be determined by domestic law in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, and in particular Article 24, paragraph 3 (see paragraphs 33 and 34 below).
31. For example, while domestic legislation ignores the recognition of transactions that must be recognized in order to determine profits attributed to a permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 2, or does not allow deduction of expenses that were not incurred solely for the benefit of a permanent establishment, it is obvious that the provisions of Paragraph 2 violate the rules preventing The deduction of certain categories of expenses (for example, representative expenses), or stipulating when specific expenses should be deducted, is not affected by Paragraph 2. However, some difficulties may arise in making such a distinction, as in the case of restrictions under domestic law based on when expenses or income components were actually paid. Since, for example, an internal transaction does not imply an actual transfer or payment between two different persons, when applying such restrictions of domestic law, it is usually necessary to take into account the nature of the transaction and, therefore, treat the corresponding transfer or payment as if they were carried out between two different persons.
32. Differences in the domestic legislation of the two States on issues such as depreciation rates, timing of income recognition and restrictions on deduction of certain expenses, as a rule, usually result in a different amount of income tax in each State, even if, for the purposes of the Convention, the amount of profit attributed to the permanent establishment account will be calculated based on Paragraph 2 in both States (see also paragraphs 39-43 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B). Thus, even if Paragraph 2 applies equally to the Contracting State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located (for the purposes of Paragraph 1) and to the other Contracting State (for the purposes of Articles 23 A or 23 B), it is likely that the amount of taxable income in respect of which the State in whose territory the Permanent establishment is located the company has a permanent establishment, will collect tax from the enterprise of a Contracting State, during a given tax period it will differ from the amount of taxable income., in respect of which the former State will have to grant an exemption in accordance with Articles 23 A or 23 B. In addition, in cases where the difference is caused by differences in domestic legislation regarding the types of expenses to be deducted, as opposed to the difference in the timing of recognition of these expenses, it will be permanent.
33. In taxing profits credited to the account of a permanent establishment located in its territory, a Contracting State will nevertheless have to take into account the provisions of Paragraph 3 of Article 24. This Paragraph, inter alia, requires that the deduction be applied to expenses under the same conditions, regardless of whether they were incurred for the purposes of a permanent establishment located in the territory of a Contracting State or for the purposes of an enterprise of that State. As stated in Paragraph 40 of the Commentary to Article 24: Permanent missions should be granted the same right as resident enterprises to deduct trading expenses, which, as a rule, tax legislation allows to deduct from taxable profits. Such deductions should be allowed without any restrictions other than those that also apply to resident enterprises.
34. The requirement set out in paragraph 3 of Article 24 remains unchanged, regardless of how the expenses incurred by the enterprise in favor of the permanent establishment are accounted for for the purposes of Paragraph 2 of Article 7. In some cases, it would be unreasonable to assume that the transaction was concluded between different parts of the company. In such cases, the expenses incurred by the enterprise for the purposes of the activities carried out by the permanent establishment will be directly deducted when determining the profit of the permanent establishment (for example, the salary of a local builder hired and paid locally to work exclusively on a construction site representing a permanent establishment of a foreign enterprise). In other cases, the expenses incurred by the enterprise will relate to functions performed by other parts of the enterprise in part or in full for the benefit of the permanent establishment, and when determining the profit attributed to the permanent establishment, the corresponding expenses will be deducted (for example, overhead costs related to administrative functions performed by the head office for the benefit of the permanent establishment). In both cases, paragraph 3 of Article 24, with respect to a permanent establishment, will require that expenses be deductible under the same conditions that apply to the enterprise of that State. Thus, for tax purposes, any expenses directly or indirectly incurred by an enterprise in favor of a permanent establishment should be subject to the same conditions as for similar expenses incurred by an enterprise of that State. This rule will apply regardless of whether the expenses incurred for the purposes of Paragraph 2 of this Article 7 relate directly to the account of the permanent establishment (first example) or to another part of the enterprise, but the contingent costs are attributed to the account of the permanent establishment (second example).
35. Paragraph 3 of Article 5 establishes a special rule for a permanent place of business, which is a construction site or a construction/installation project. Such a permanent place of business is a permanent establishment only if it exists for more than twelve months. Experience has shown that such types of permanent missions can create special problems when allocating profits to their account in accordance with Article 7.
36. These problems mainly arise when other parts of the enterprise or related parties provide goods or services in connection with the presence of a construction site or a construction/installation project. Although any permanent establishment may encounter these problems, they are most acutely felt on construction sites and during construction/installation projects. In these circumstances, it is necessary to pay close attention to the general principle that profits are credited to the account of a permanent establishment only in relation to the activities carried out by the enterprise through this permanent establishment.
37. For example, if these goods are supplied by other parts of the enterprise, then the profit generated by such delivery is not the result of activities carried out through a permanent establishment and is not credited to its account. Similarly, profits earned from the provision of services (for example, planning, designing, drawing up drawings or providing technical advice) by business units operating outside the State in which the permanent establishment is located are not the result of activities carried out through the permanent establishment and are not attributed to it.
38. Article 7, in the form in which it existed before 2010, included the following Paragraph 3: In determining the profit of a permanent establishment, expenses incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment, including administrative and general administrative expenses incurred in this way, may be deducted both in the State in which the permanent establishment is located and elsewhere. Although the original purpose of the Paragraph was to clarify that Paragraph 2 requires that expenses directly or indirectly incurred for the benefit of a permanent establishment be taken into account in determining the profits of a permanent establishment, even if these expenses were incurred outside the State in which the permanent establishment is located, it has sometimes been interpreted as limiting the deduction of expenses indirectly incurred for the benefit of permanent representative office, the actual amount of expenses.
39. This is especially true in the case of general and administrative expenses, which were explicitly mentioned in this Paragraph. According to the previous version of Paragraph 2, as interpreted in the Commentary, this was generally not a problem, since the share of the general and administrative expenses of the enterprise could usually be distributed to the permanent mission only on the basis of the initial cost.
40. However, as currently drafted, Paragraph 2 requires the recognition and determination of the market price of transactions through which one part of an enterprise performs functions in favor of a permanent establishment (for example, by assisting in day-to-day management). Paragraph 2 requires the application of a deduction of the market rate of payment for these transactions, as opposed to a deduction limited to the amount of expenses. Therefore, the previous Paragraph 3 was deleted in order to avoid its misinterpretation as limiting the deduction to the amount of the expenses themselves. This exception does not affect the requirement in Paragraph 2 that, when determining the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account, all relevant expenses should be taken into account, wherever they may be incurred. Depending on the circumstances, this is done by deducting expenses in full or in part, or by deducting the market rate of payment in the case of a transaction between a permanent establishment and another division of the enterprise.
41. In the form in which it existed before 2010, Article 7 also included a provision allowing profits to be attributed to a permanent establishment based on the distribution of the total profits of the enterprise among its various parts. However, this method was applied only to the extent that its application was typical for the Contracting State and the result was consistent with the principles of Article 7. According to the Committee, methods other than the distribution of the total profit of the enterprise can be applied even in the most difficult cases. In this regard, the Committee decided to delete this provision, since it has become quite rarely applied, and also because of concerns that it would be extremely difficult to ensure that the result of its application corresponds to the principle of “at arm's length".
42. At the same time, the Committee also decided to delete another provision found in the previous version of the Article, according to which profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment should have been "determined on the basis of the same method from year to year, unless there were compelling and sufficient grounds to the contrary." This provision, which was supposed to ensure a continuous and principled approach, was appropriate as long as it allowed for the profit attributed to the permanent establishment to be determined using direct or indirect methods, or even on the basis of the distribution of the total profits of the enterprise among its various parts. However, the new approach developed by the Committee does not allow the use of such fundamentally different methods, and therefore there is no need for such a provision.
43. The last provision, which was deleted from the Article at the same time, stipulated that “no profit should be attributed to the account of a permanent establishment simply because it purchased the goods of the enterprise.” In subparagraph 4 (d) Article 5, as amended at that time, provided that if an enterprise of a Contracting State maintains a permanent place of business in another State solely for the purchase of goods for its own purposes, such activity in that place should not be considered to be at a level that allows taxation in that other State (amendments introduced by the scope of this exception was limited to Article 5 in 2017). However, in cases where subparagraph 4 (d) was not applied because the enterprise carried out other activities through this place of business, which, therefore, was a permanent establishment, it was advisable to attribute profits to all functions performed in this place. Indeed, if the procurement activity was carried out by an independent company, the buyer would receive remuneration for his services on market terms. In addition, since tax exemption limited to procurement activities undertaken for the benefit of the enterprise requires that expenses incurred for the purpose of carrying out these activities be excluded in determining the profits of a permanent establishment, such exclusion may lead to administrative problems. Therefore, the Committee considered that the provision according to which no profit should be attributed to the account of the permanent mission simply because of the purchase of the company's goods did not comply with the principle of “at arm's length" and should not be included in the Article.
Point 3
44. The combination of Articles 7 (which restricts the right to taxation of the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located) and 23 A and 23 B (which oblige another State to exempt from double taxation) ensures exemption from double taxation of profits properly attributed to the permanent establishment. Such a result may require the two States to resolve differences based on differences in interpretation of Paragraph 2, and it is important to ensure that mechanisms are available to resolve all such differences to the extent necessary to eliminate double taxation.
45. As already mentioned, the need for the two Contracting States to reach a common understanding on the application of Paragraph 2 in order to eliminate the risk of double taxation led the Committee to develop detailed guidance on the interpretation of this Paragraph. This guidance is reflected in the Report, which is based on the principles of the OECD Guidelines on Transfer Pricing.
46. The risks of double taxation can usually be avoided, since the taxpayer will determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account in the same way in each Contracting State and in accordance with Paragraph 2 in the interpretation of the Report, which will ensure the same result for the purposes of Articles 7 and 23 A or 23 B (see paragraph 66). If each State agrees that the taxpayer has performed these actions, it should not adjust the profit to obtain a different result in accordance with Paragraph 2. This can be illustrated by the following example.
47. Example. The manufacturing plant of the enterprise of State R, located in State R, transferred the goods for sale to the permanent representative office of the enterprise located in the territory of State S. In order to determine the profit attributed to the permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 2, the Report stipulates that the transaction must be recognized and that a notional market price must be determined for this transaction. The documentation of the enterprise, which meets the requirements of functional and factual analysis, which was used by the taxpayer as the basis for calculating his taxable income in each State, shows that a transaction was made for the sale of goods by a factory in State R to a permanent establishment in State S, and that a conditional market price was used to determine the profit attributed to the permanent establishment at 100. Both States agree that the recognition of the transaction and the price used by the taxpayer is consistent with the principles of the OECD Transfer Pricing Report and Guidelines. In this case, both States should not adjust profits for the reason that it was necessary to apply a different market price; if it is confirmed that the taxpayer has fulfilled the requirements of Paragraph 2, the tax authorities of both States cannot substitute their decision for the taxpayer's decision on what to consider market conditions. In this example, the fact that the same market price was used in both States and that both States recognize this price for the purposes of applying the Convention guarantees the elimination of any double taxation with respect to this transaction in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B.
48. In the previous example, both States agreed that the recognition of the transaction and the price used by the taxpayer were consistent with the principles of the OECD Transfer Pricing Report and Guidelines. However, the Contracting States do not always reach such an agreement. In some cases, the OECD Report and Guidance on Transfer Pricing allow for different interpretations of Paragraph 2, and if, otherwise, these different interpretations could lead to double taxation, it is important to ensure exemption from such double taxation. Paragraph 3 provides for a special mechanism for this purpose.
49. For example, as explained in Paragraphs 105-171 of Part I of the Report, Paragraph 2 allows for different approaches to determining, based on the allocation of “free” capital to the permanent establishment account, interest expenses attributed to the permanent establishment account. The Committee recognized that this could pose problems, particularly for financial institutions. It was decided that in this and other cases, where the two Contracting States interpret Paragraph 2 differently and it is not possible to determine which interpretation does not comply with Paragraph 2, it is important to ensure the elimination of any such double taxation that would otherwise be caused by different interpretations.
50. Paragraph 3 will ensure that this result is achieved. However, it is important to note that there are quite a few cases when it will be necessary to refer to this Point.
51. First, as explained in Paragraph 46 above, if a taxpayer has determined the profit attributable to a permanent establishment in the same way in each Contracting State, and both States have agreed that he has done so in accordance with Paragraph 2 in the interpretation of the Report, no profit adjustments to achieve a different result in accordance with Paragraph 2 is not allowed.
52. Secondly, paragraph 3 is not intended to limit in any way the remedies already available to ensure that each Contracting State fulfills its obligations under Articles 7 and 23 A or 23 B. For example, if the determination by a Contracting State of the profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment located in that State does not comply with Paragraph 2, the taxpayer will be able to use the available remedies provided by domestic law, as well as the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25, to take into account that fact. that the taxpayer has not been taxed by that State in accordance with the Convention. Similarly, these remedies are also available if, for the purposes of Article 23 A or 23 B, another State fails to determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 2 and thus fails to comply with the provisions of that Article.
53. However, if the taxpayer has not determined the profit attributed to the permanent establishment account in accordance with Paragraph 2, each State has the right to make adjustments to ensure compliance with this Paragraph. If one State makes an adjustment in accordance with Paragraph 2, this Paragraph will certainly allow the other State to make an equivalent adjustment in order to avoid double taxation by applying Paragraph 2 and Article 23 A or 23 B together (see paragraph 65 below). However, it may happen that the domestic legislation of that other State (for example, in the territory of which a permanent establishment is located) may not allow it to make such changes, or that State may have no reason to carry out such actions on its own if they result in a reduction in the amount of profit that was previously taxed in that State. It may also happen that, as mentioned above, two Contracting States adopt different interpretations of Paragraph 2, and it will be impossible to determine which of them does not comply with Paragraph 2.
54. Such problems are discussed in Paragraph 3. The following example illustrates the application of this Paragraph.
56. However, if State S does not agree that the adjustment made by State R complies with Paragraph 2, it will not consider that it should make the adjustment. In such a case, the question of whether State S should make an adjustment in accordance with Paragraph 3 (if the adjustment by State R is justified by Paragraph 2), or whether State R should refrain from making the initial adjustment (if it is not justified by Paragraph 2), should be resolved in accordance with the mutual agreement procedure under Paragraph 1. Article 25, using, if necessary, the arbitration provision of Paragraph 5 of Article 25 (insofar as it concerns, whether or not the actions of one or both of the Contracting States have led to the taxation of the taxpayer not in accordance with the Convention). Using this procedure, two States will be able to agree on the same market price, which may be one of the prices offered by the taxpayer and the two States, or may differ from them.
57. As the example from Paragraph 55 shows, Paragraph 3 addresses the issue that the Convention does not provide sufficient protection against double taxation in certain situations where two Contracting States adopt different interpretations of Paragraph 2 of Article 7, and each State may be considered to be taxing "in accordance with" the Convention. Paragraph 3 guarantees that in such a case an exemption from double taxation will be granted, which coincides with the general objectives of the Convention.
58. Paragraph 3 has basic features in common with Paragraph 2 of Article 9. First, it applies to each State with respect to adjustments made by another State. Therefore, it is applied on the principle of reciprocity if the initial adjustment was made by the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, or by another State. In addition, it is applied only in cases where one of the States has made an adjustment.
59. As in the case of Paragraph 2 of Article 9, the corresponding adjustment should not be automatically made in accordance with Paragraph 3 just because one of the Contracting States adjusted the profits attributed to the permanent establishment. An appropriate adjustment is required only if the other State considers that the adjusted profit corresponds to Paragraph 2. In other words, Paragraph 3 cannot be used and should not be applied if the profit attributed to the account of a permanent establishment is adjusted to a level different from that which would have been if the profit had been correctly calculated in accordance with the principles of Paragraph 2. Regardless of which State makes the initial adjustment, the other State is obliged to make the appropriate adjustment only if it considers that the adjusted profit correctly reflects what the profit would be if the transactions of the permanent mission were transactions on market terms. Therefore, the other State is obliged to make such an appropriate adjustment only if it considers that the initial adjustment is justified both in principle and in relation to the amount.
59.1 According to the domestic legislation of some countries, in appropriate circumstances, a taxpayer may be allowed to amend a previously filed tax return in order to adjust the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account to reflect the distribution of profits, i.e., in the taxpayer's opinion, in accordance with the principles of a separate legal entity and disinterest underlying Article 7. If they have been made in good faith, such adjustments may contribute to the proper allocation of profits to the account of a permanent establishment in accordance with Paragraph 2. However, double taxation may occur, for example, if such an adjustment, on the initiative of the taxpayer, increases profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment located in one Contracting State, but in another No corresponding adjustment has been made in the Contracting State. The elimination of such double taxation falls within the scope of Paragraph 3. Indeed, if the increased profits in the first-mentioned State were taxed, it may be considered that this State adjusted the profits attributed to the account of the permanent establishment and taxed the profits that were subject to taxation in another State. In these circumstances, Article 25 allows the authorized bodies of the Contracting States to conduct joint consultations to eliminate double taxation.; The authorized bodies may, accordingly, if available, apply a mutual agreement procedure to determine whether the initial adjustment meets the conditions of Paragraph 2, and if so, determine the amount of the corresponding adjustment of the amount of tax levied on profits credited to the account of the permanent establishment in order to avoid double taxation.
60. Paragraph 3 does not specify the method by which the appropriate adjustment should be made. If the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located has made the initial adjustment, the adjustment provided for in Paragraph 3 may be made in another State by adjusting the amount of income to be tax-exempt in accordance with Article 23 A or the subsidy to be provided in accordance with Article 23 B. If the initial adjustment was made by that other State, the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located may make the adjustment provided for in Paragraph 3 by reviewing the amount of taxation imposed on the enterprise by the other State in order to reduce taxable income by the appropriate amount.
61. The issue of so-called "secondary adjustments" discussed in Paragraph 8 of the Commentary to Article 9 does not arise in the case of adjustments under Paragraph 3. As indicated in Paragraph 28 above, the determination of profits attributed to a permanent establishment is relevant only for the purposes of Articles 7 and 23 A and 23 B and does not affect Application of other Articles of the Convention.
62. Like paragraph 2 of Article 9, Paragraph 3 leaves open the question of whether there should be a period after which a State will not be required to make an appropriate adjustment to the profits attributed to the permanent establishment after the upward revision of these profits in another State. Some States consider that this obligation should be indefinite.; in other words, no matter how many years have passed since the State made the initial adjustment, the company must fairly provide the appropriate adjustment in another State. Other States consider that such an indefinite commitment is impractical from a practical point of view. This issue was not addressed either in the text of Paragraph 2 of Article 9 or in Paragraph 3, however, the Contracting States may, if desired, include in bilateral agreements provisions concerning the length of the period during which the State is obliged to make appropriate adjustments (see paragraphs 39, 40 and 41 of the Commentary to Article 25 on this issue). The Contracting States may also wish to resolve this issue by means of a provision limiting the length of the period during which adjustments may be made in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7.; such a solution avoids double taxation, which could otherwise arise in the absence of an adjustment in another State in accordance with Paragraph 3 of the Article after an adjustment by the first State in accordance with Paragraph 2. Contracting States wishing to achieve this result may bilaterally agree to include the following Paragraph after Paragraph 4.:
5. A Contracting State shall not make adjustments to profits credited to the account of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States after [a bilaterally agreed period] from the end of the tax year in which the profits would have been credited to the account of the permanent establishment. The provisions of this Paragraph should not apply in cases of fraud, gross negligence, or intentional default.
63. There may be cases where an initial adjustment made by one State does not require an immediate corresponding adjustment of the amount of tax levied on profits in another State (for example, if an initial adjustment of profits attributed to a permanent establishment made by one State affects the determination of the amount of losses attributed to the rest of the enterprise in another State). The authorized authorities may, in accordance with the second sentence of Paragraph 3, determine the impact that the initial adjustment will have on the tax that will be payable in another State before it is actually collected; in fact, in order to avoid the problem described in the previous Paragraph, the authorized authorities may wish to apply a mutual agreement procedure as soon as possible. opportunities to determine to what extent appropriate adjustments may be required in another State at a later stage.
64. If a dispute arises between the parties concerned regarding the amount and nature of the relevant adjustment, the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25 should be applied, as in the case of adjustments in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 9. In fact, as shown in the example from Paragraph 55 above, if one of the two Contracting States adjusts the profits attributed to the permanent establishment account without the other State providing the appropriate adjustment to the extent necessary to avoid double taxation, the taxpayer will be able to use the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Paragraph 1 of Article 25. and, if necessary, the arbitration provision of Paragraph 5 of Article 25, in order to require the authorized bodies to agree to, that either the initial adjustment made by one State or the failure of another State to make the appropriate adjustment does not comply with the provisions of the Convention (the arbitration provision of Paragraph 5 of Article 25 will play a crucial role in cases where the competent authorities would otherwise not be able to agree, since it will ensure that issues preventing an agreement are resolved through arbitration).
65. Paragraph 3 applies only to the extent necessary to eliminate double taxation of profits resulting from adjustments. Suppose, for example, that the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located adjusts the profit that the taxpayer has credited to the permanent establishment to reflect the fact that the transaction price between the permanent establishment and the rest of the enterprise does not comply with the "at arm's length" principle. Let's assume that another State also agrees that the price used by the taxpayer was not a market price. In this case, the joint application of Paragraph 2 and Article 23 A or 23 B will require the other State to allocate adjusted profits to the permanent establishment account, which will reflect the market price, in order to grant double taxation exemption. In this case, paragraph 3 will only be relevant if States adopt different interpretations of what should be the correct market price.
66. Paragraph 3 applies only to differences in the definition of profits attributed to a permanent establishment, as a result of which the same part of the profits is distributed among different parts of the enterprise in accordance with the Article. As already explained (see paragraphs 30 and 31 above), Article 7 does not address the issue of calculating the taxable income, but instead discusses the distribution of profits in order to distribute taxation rights between the two Contracting States. Thus, the Article serves only for the distribution of income and expenses for the purpose of allocating tax rights and does not decide in advance which income is subject to taxation and which expenses are deductible, which is within the competence of domestic legislation, as long as the provisions of Paragraph 2 are respected. If the profit attributed to the account of a permanent establishment is the same in each State, the amount included in the taxable income from which tax will be levied in each State for the specified tax period may vary due to differences in domestic legislation, for example, regarding the recognition of income and the deduction of expenses. Since these different rules of domestic law apply only to profits credited to the account of each State, they do not in themselves lead to double taxation for the purposes of Paragraph 3.
67. In addition, paragraph 3 does not apply to affect the calculation of the tax exemption or the amount of the subsidy in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B, except for the purpose of granting an exemption from double taxation, which would otherwise be unavailable, for tax paid in the Contracting State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located., for the profit attributed to the account of a permanent establishment in that State. Therefore, this Paragraph does not apply in cases where this profit has been fully exempt from taxation by another State, or if the tax paid in the first-mentioned State has been fully credited to the tax account in another State in accordance with the domestic law of that other State and in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B.
68. Some States may prefer that the cases covered by Paragraph 3 be resolved through a mutual agreement procedure (failure to comply with this requirement leads to the application of the arbitration provision of Paragraph 5 of Article 25) if the State does not unilaterally agree to make the appropriate adjustment, without any consideration of the preferred position of the adjusting State in relation to the market price or the method. In this regard, these States would prefer a provision that would always give the State the opportunity to discuss with the adjusting State the applicable market price or method. States sharing this view may prefer to use the following alternative version of Paragraph 3:
If, in accordance with Paragraph 2, a Contracting State adjusts the profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of one of the Contracting States and taxes accordingly the profits of the enterprise that are taxable in the other State, the other Contracting State must, to the extent necessary to eliminate double taxation of those profits, make the appropriate an adjustment if it agrees with the adjustment made by the first mentioned State; If the other Contracting State does not agree to this, the Contracting States must eliminate any double taxation arising in this regard by mutual agreement.
69. This alternative version is intended to ensure that the State, which is invited to make an appropriate adjustment, should always be able to require that this be done as part of a mutual agreement procedure. This version differs significantly from Paragraph 3 in that it does not create a legal obligation for that State to agree to make the appropriate adjustment, even if it considers an adjustment made by another State to comply with Paragraph 2. The regulation always gives the State the opportunity to discuss with another State the most acceptable market price or method. If the State in question does not unilaterally agree to make the appropriate adjustment, this version of Paragraph 3 would ensure that the taxpayer has the right to use the mutual agreement procedure to resolve the case. Moreover, if a mutual agreement procedure is initiated in such a case, the provision imposes on the Contracting States a counter-legal obligation to eliminate double taxation by mutual agreement, even if it does not provide for a material standard governing which of the States is obliged to compromise in order to achieve mutual agreement. If two Contracting States do not reach an agreement on the elimination of double taxation, they both violate their contractual obligations. Thus, the obligation to eliminate such cases of double taxation by mutual agreement is stricter than the norm of Paragraph 2 of Article 25, which only requires authorized bodies to “try” to settle the case by mutual agreement.
70. If the Contracting States bilaterally agree to replace Paragraph 3 with the above alternative, the comments made in Paragraphs 66 and 67 with respect to Paragraph 3 will also apply to this provision.
Item 4
71. Although it was not considered necessary to define the concept of “profit” in the Convention, nevertheless, it should be understood that when used in this Article and elsewhere in this Convention, this concept has a broader meaning, including all income received as a result of the company's activities. This broad meaning corresponds to the use of the concept in the legislation of most OECD member countries.
72. In the absence of Paragraph 4, such an interpretation of the concept of “profit” may lead to some uncertainty regarding the application of the Convention. If the profits of an enterprise include income categories that are dealt with separately in other Articles of the Convention, for example, dividends, the question might arise as to which Article should apply to these income categories, for example, in the case of dividends, this Article or Article 10.
73. If the application of this Article and another relevant Article leads to the application of the same taxation regime, this issue is of little practical importance. In addition, other Articles of the Convention specifically address this issue with respect to certain types of income (for example, Article 6, paragraph 4, Articles 10 and 11, paragraph 4, Article 12, paragraph 3, Article 17, paragraphs 1 and 2, and Article 21, paragraph 2).
74. However, the issue may arise with respect to other types of income, and therefore it was decided to include an interpretative rule ensuring that Articles applicable to specific income categories take precedence over Article 7. It follows from this rule that Article 7 will apply to commercial profits that do not belong to income categories covered by these other Articles, and, in addition, to income, which, in accordance with Paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11, Paragraph 3 of Article 12 and Paragraph 2 of Article 21, falls within the scope of Article 7. However, this rule does not regulate the manner in which income should be classified for the purposes of domestic law; thus, if a Contracting State may tax an item of income in accordance with other Articles of this Convention, that State may, for the purposes of domestic taxation, characterize such income at its discretion (i.e. as business profits or as a special income category), provided that the taxation regime of this income item complies with the provisions of the Convention. It should also be noted that if an enterprise of a Contracting State receives income from immovable property through a permanent establishment located in another State, that other State may not tax that income if it was received from immovable property located in the territory of the first-mentioned State or a third State (see paragraph 4 of the Commentary to Article 21 and Paragraphs 9 and 10 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B).
The Contracting States may bilaterally agree on special explanations or definitions concerning the concept of "profit" in order to clarify the difference between this concept and, for example, the concept of dividends. In particular, these actions may be considered appropriate if the agreement under discussion deviates from the definitions in the Articles relating to dividends, interest and royalties.
75.1 Emissions trading programmes have been implemented in a number of countries as part of the international strategy to combat global warming. According to these programs, certain types of economic activities that produce greenhouse gases may require emission permits, and benefits granted for projects to reduce or remove emissions in other countries may be recognized. Given the international nature of certain quota trading programs (for example, the EU Emissions Trading System), these programs pose a particular problem within the framework of the Model Tax Convention, primarily with regard to accounting for income from issuing and trading emission permits and benefits. These issues are explored in the committee's report “Tax Agreement Issues related to Emissions Permits/benefits.”1 As explained in this report, income earned from the issuance or trading of emissions permits and benefits is usually covered by Articles 7 and 13. However, in certain circumstances, such income may fall within the scope of Articles 6, 8 or 21 (see paragraph 2.1 of the Commentary to Article 6 and Paragraph 14.1 of the Commentary to Article 8).
75. Finally, it should be noted that two categories of profits that were previously covered by other Articles of the Convention now fall within the scope of Article 7. Firstly, although the definition of the concept of "royalties" is in Paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the Draft Convention of 1963 and the Model Tax Convention of 1977. This definition included payments “for the use or right to use industrial, commercial or scientific equipment”, a reference to these payments was subsequently removed from this definition to ensure that income from the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, including income from the rental of containers, would be subject to the provisions of Article 7 or Article 8 (see paragraph 9 Comments to this Article), depending on the situation, rather than Article 12; the result that the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs considers appropriate, taking into account the nature of such income.
76. Secondly, before 2000, income from the provision of professional services and other independent activities was considered in a separate Article, i.e. in Article 14. The provisions of this Article were similar to those applied to commercial profits, but Article 14 used the concept of a permanent base rather than a permanent establishment, since it was initially believed that the latter concept should apply to commercial and industrial activities. However, it was not always clear which activities fell within the scope of Article 14 rather than Article 7. The deletion of Article 14 in 2000 reflected the fact that there were no perceived differences between the concepts of permanent establishment in Article 7 and a permanent base in Article 14, or between the way profits and taxes were calculated, according to which the provisions of Article 7 or 14 were applied. As a result of the deletion of Article 14, income earned from the provision of professional services or other independent activities is now considered as commercial profit in accordance with Article 7. This was confirmed by the addition of the definition of “business” to Article 3, which explicitly stipulates that this concept includes professional services or other activities of an independent nature.
________________________
1 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(25)-1.
Comments on the Comment
77. Italy and Portugal consider it important to take into account that, regardless of the importance attached to the fourth sentence of Paragraph 77, with regard to the tax calculation method, the new version of the model, i.e. the deletion of Article 14, does not affect national systems.
78. [Deleted]
79. [Deleted]
80. [Deleted]
81. Sweden wishes to clarify that, in its opinion, the various approaches to the allocation of "free" capital included in the Report Attributing profits to permanent missions will not necessarily lead to an "arm's length" outcome. Therefore, considering the facts and circumstances of each case, in many cases Sweden will not consider that the amount of interest deduction resulting from these approaches corresponds to the principle of "at arm's length". If differing views on the allocation of "free" capital lead to double taxation, the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25 should be applied.
82. Referring to Paragraphs 27 and 65, the United States would like to clarify how they will eliminate double taxation resulting from the application of Paragraph 2 of Article 7. If a taxpayer can prove to an authorized body of the United States that he has not been exempt from such double taxation after applying mechanisms in accordance with U.S. domestic law, such as the use of restrictions for a foreign tax credit created by other transactions, the United States will exempt it from such additional double taxation.
83. Turkey does not share the view expressed in paragraph 28 of the Commentary to Article 7.
Reservations to the Article
84. Australia reserves the right to include a provision authorizing the application of its domestic legislation to the taxation of profits from any form of insurance activity.
85. Australia reserves the right to include a provision clarifying its right to tax a share of commercial profits to which a resident of the other Contracting State has a beneficial right, if these profits were received by the trustee of property managed by proxy (other than certain mutual funds, which are considered companies for tax purposes in Australia), from the implementation of activities in Australia through a permanent representative office.
86. Korea and Portugal reserve the right to tax persons providing professional services or carrying out other independent activities if they are present on their territory for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days in any period of twelve months, even if these persons do not have a permanent establishment (or permanent base) accessible by to provide such services or activities to them.
87. Italy, Portugal and Turkey reserve the right to tax persons providing independent personal services in accordance with a separate article corresponding to Article 14 as amended before its exclusion in 2000. In the case of Turkey, the question of whether persons other than individuals should be included in this article is determined by bilateral agreements.
88. The United States reserves the right to amend Article 7 to ensure that, in applying Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article, any income or profits attributed to a permanent establishment during its existence may be taxed by the Contracting State in whose territory the permanent establishment exists, even if payments are deferred until then. until the permanent establishment ceases to exist. The United States also wishes to point out that it reserves the right to apply such a rule in accordance with Articles 10, 11, 12, 13 and 21.
89. Turkey reserves the right to tax the income from the rental of containers with withholding tax in all cases. In the case of the application of Articles 5 and 7 to such income, Turkey would like to apply the permanent establishment rule to the cases of a simple depot, a depot agency and an operational branch.
90. Norway and the United States reserve the right to treat income from the use, maintenance or rental of containers used in international transportation in accordance with Article 8 in the same way as income from sea and air transportation.
91. Australia and Portugal reserve the right, in bilateral negotiations, to propose a provision that, if the information available to the authorized body of a Contracting State is insufficient to determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment of an enterprise, the authorized body may apply to that enterprise for this purpose the provisions of the tax legislation of that State, with the proviso that this The legislation will be applied as far as the information available to the authorized body allows, in accordance with the principles of this Article.
92. Mexico reserves the right to tax in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located the commercial profits derived from the sale of goods carried out directly by its head office located in the other Contracting State, provided that these goods are similar or similar to those sold through that permanent establishment. The Government of Mexico will apply this rule only to protect against abuse, and not as a general principle of “gravity.”; Thus, the rule does not apply if the company proves that the sales were made for reasons other than obtaining benefits in accordance with the Convention.
93. The Czech Republic reserves the right to add a provision to Paragraph 3 limiting possible appropriate adjustments in bona fide transactions.
94. New Zealand reserves the right to use the previous version of Article 7, subject to its comments and reservations to this version (i.e., the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately prior to the update of the Model Tax Convention in 2010), as it does not agree with the approach reflected in Part I of the 2010 Report. Allocation of profits to the account of permanent missions. Therefore, she disapproves of the changes to the Commentary to the Article made through this update.
95. Austria, Chile, Greece, Mexico, Slovakia and Turkey reserve the right to use the previous version of Article 7, i.e. the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately prior to the update of the Model Tax Convention in 2010. Therefore, they do not approve of the changes to the Commentary to the Article made through this update.
96. Portugal reserves the right to continue to approve the text of the Article in its agreements as amended until 2010, until its domestic legislation is adapted to the new approach.
97. Slovenia reserves the right to indicate that a possible adjustment will be made in accordance with Paragraph 3 only if it is deemed justified.
98. Australia reserves the right to use the previous version of Article 7, subject to its comments and reservations to this version (i.e., the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately prior to the update of the Model Tax Convention in 2010).
99. Latvia reserves the right to use the previous version of Article 7, i.e. the version included in the Model Tax Convention immediately before the update of the Model Tax Convention in 2010, taking into account its position on this version (see the Appendix to the Positions of non-OECD countries on Article 7.
application
THE PREVIOUS VERSION OF ARTICLE 7 AND ITS COMMENTARY
The text of Article 7 and its Commentary, as amended by July 22, 2010, is given below. This previous version of the Article and Commentary is provided below for historical reference, as it will continue to be relevant in the application and interpretation of bilateral tax agreements concluded prior to this date.
ARTICLE 7
COMMERCIAL PROFIT
1. The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State, except in cases where the enterprise carries on business in the territory of the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment located there. If an enterprise carries out business activities in accordance with the above, the profits of the enterprise may be taxed in another State, but only in the part that relates to this permanent establishment.
2. In accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 3, if an enterprise of a Contracting State carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment located there, in each Contracting State, the profits that could be expected to be generated if it were a separate enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities in those territories shall be attributed to that permanent establishment. under the same or similar conditions, and completely independent of the enterprise of which it is a permanent representative office.
3. When determining the profit of a permanent establishment, expenses incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment, including representative and general administrative expenses incurred in this way, both in the territory of the State where the permanent establishment is located and in any other place, are allowed as deductions.
4. To the extent that it is customary in a Contracting State to determine the profits attributed to a permanent establishment on the basis of the distribution of the total profits of the enterprise among its various parts, none of the provisions of Paragraph 2 prevents that Contracting State from determining taxable profits by such a generally accepted distribution; nevertheless, the method of distribution adopted should be as follows to ensure that the result conforms to the principles contained in this Article.
5. No profit should be credited to the account of a permanent establishment simply because of the purchase of goods for the enterprise by this permanent establishment.
6. For the purposes of the preceding Paragraphs, profits credited to the account of a permanent establishment should be determined using the same method from year to year, except in cases where there is a compelling and sufficient reason to the contrary.
7. If profits include income items considered separately in other Articles of this Convention, the provisions of these Articles shall not affect the provisions of this Article.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 7
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF COMMERCIAL PROFITS
I. Preliminary remarks
1. This Article is in many ways a continuation of the corollary of Article 5 on the definition of permanent establishment. The criterion of permanent establishment is usually used in international agreements on the avoidance of double taxation to determine whether a certain type of income should be taxed in its country of origin, however, the criterion alone does not provide a complete solution to the problem of double taxation of commercial profits.; To prevent such double taxation, it is necessary to supplement the definition of a permanent establishment with an agreed set of rules on the basis of which profits attributed to the permanent establishment account should be calculated. In other words, if an enterprise of a Contracting State carries out business activities in the territory of another Contracting State, the authorities of that second State should ask themselves two questions before taxing the profits of the enterprise: the first question is whether the enterprise has a permanent establishment in their country.; if the answer is yes, then the second question is what is the profit from which the permanent establishment should pay tax, if any. Article 7 concerns the rules to be used in determining the answer to this second question. The rules for determining the profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State trading with an enterprise of the other Contracting State, if both of them are associated, are dealt with in Article 9.
2. Articles 7 and 9 do not provide specific details, and they did not represent much novelty when they were adopted by the OECD. The question of which criteria should be used when allocating profits to the account of a permanent mission, and how to distribute profits from transactions between associated enterprises, had to be addressed in many conventions on avoidance of double taxation and in various models developed by the League of Nations before the OECD first addressed this issue, and the decisions taken generally corresponded to the standard the scheme.
3. It is generally accepted that the basic principles on which this standard scheme is based are well-founded, and when the OECD first began to study this issue, it was decided that it would be sufficient to restate them with minor amendments and modifications, mainly to provide greater clarity. The two Articles include a number of directives. They do not establish, and because of their nature, they should not be expected to do so, a set of precise rules for solving all kinds of problems that may arise when an enterprise in one State makes a profit in another. Modern trade can be organized in countless ways, and it would be impossible to provide an exhaustive list of rules for solving all kinds of possible problems within the rather narrow framework of a single Article of the convention for the avoidance of double taxation.
4. Nevertheless, it must be recognized that there were significant differences in the interpretation of the general directives of Article 7 and the provisions of earlier agreements and models on which the Article is based. This lack of a common interpretation of Article 7 may lead to problems of double taxation and non-taxation. For this reason, it is important for the tax authorities to agree on mutually consistent methods of solving these problems, using, where appropriate, the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25.
5. Therefore, over the years, the Committee on Budget and Finance has spent a significant amount of time and effort trying to ensure a more consistent interpretation and application of the rules of the Article. Minor changes in the wording of the Article and a number of changes in the Commentary were made when the Model Tax Convention was adopted in 1977. A report addressing this issue in a specific case of banks was published in 19841. In 1987, noting that the definition of profits attributed to permanent missions could lead to some uncertainty, the Committee investigated the issue, which led to the adoption in 1993 of a report entitled "Attribution of profits to permanent missions"2 and subsequent amendments to the Commentary.
_______________________________
1 "Taxation of multinational banking enterprises", in the book "Transfer Pricing and Multinational Enterprises. Three Issues of Taxation", OECD, Paris, 1984.
2 Reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(13)-1.
6. Despite the work carried out, the practices of countries within and outside the OECD regarding the allocation of profits to permanent missions, as well as the interpretations of Article 7 adopted in these countries, still differed significantly. The Committee recognized the need to provide the taxpayer with greater certainty: in its report on Transfer Pricing Guidelines for International Enterprises and Tax Authorities, adopted in 1995, it indicated that further work would be aimed at applying the “at arm's length" principle to permanent missions. This work led to the publication in 2008 of a report entitled Attributing profits to Permanent Missions. The approach developed in this report was not limited to the original intent or historical practice and interpretation of Article 7. Instead, attention was focused on formulating the most optimal approach to allocating profits to the permanent establishment account in accordance with Article 7, taking into account modern international transactions and trade.
7. The approach proposed in this Report concerns attributing profits both to permanent missions in general (Part I of the Report) and, in particular, to permanent missions of companies operating in the financial sector, where trade through permanent missions is widespread (Part II of the Report, concerning permanent missions of banks, Part III, concerning permanent representative offices of enterprises engaged in global trade, and Part IV concerning permanent representative offices of enterprises engaged in insurance activities). The Committee considers that the guidance included in the Report represents a better approach to allocating profits to permanent missions than previously applied. However, he acknowledges that there are differences between some of the conclusions of the Report and the interpretations of the Article previously given in this Commentary. For this reason, this Commentary has been amended to include a number of conclusions of the Report that do not contradict the previous version of this Commentary, which prescribed specific approaches in some areas and left considerable leeway in others. Thus, the Report represents internationally agreed principles, and, to the extent that it does not contradict this Commentary, provides guidance on the application of the “at arm's length" principle included in the Article.
8. Before 2000, income from the provision of professional services and other independent activities was considered in a separate Article, i.e. in Article 14. The provisions of this Article were similar to those applied to commercial profits, but Article 14 used the concept of a permanent base rather than a permanent establishment, since it was initially believed that the latter concept should apply to commercial and industrial activities. However, it was not always clear which activities fell within the scope of Article 14 rather than Article 7. The deletion of Article 14 in 2000 reflected the fact that there were no perceived differences between the concepts of permanent establishment in Article 7 and a permanent base in Article 14, or between the way profits and taxes were calculated, according to which the provisions of Article 7 or 14 were applied. As a result of the deletion of Article 14, income earned from the provision of professional services or other independent activities is now considered as commercial profit in accordance with Article 7. This was confirmed by the addition of the definition of “business” to Article 3, which explicitly stipulates that this concept includes professional services or other activities of an independent nature.
II. Commentary to the provisions of Article 1
9. This paragraph addresses two issues. First, it restates the generally accepted principle of double taxation agreements that an enterprise of one State should not be taxed in another State if it does not conduct business in that other State through a permanent establishment located there. It is hardly worth discussing the merits of this principle here. Perhaps it would be enough to say that when resolving international financial issues, it is accepted that until an enterprise of one State establishes a permanent establishment in another State, it should in fact not be considered participating in the economic life of that other State if it falls under the tax jurisdiction of that other State.
10. The second principle reflected in the second sentence of the Paragraph is that the right to taxation belonging to the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located does not apply to profits that the enterprise may receive from that State, but which are not attributed to the permanent establishment. This is an issue that has had different points of view throughout history. Some time ago, several countries followed the principle of a common “force of attraction”, according to which income such as other commercial profits, dividends, interest and royalties arising from sources on their territory were fully taxed on their part if the beneficiary had a permanent establishment there, even if such income was clearly not related to the account of this permanent mission. Although some bilateral tax agreements include a limited norm aimed at countering tax evasion and based on a limited gravity approach that applies only to commercial profits generated from activities similar to those carried out by a permanent mission, in the practice of international tax agreements, the general gravity approach described above has currently been rejected. The principle that is now generally accepted in double taxation agreements is based on the view that when taxing profits that a foreign enterprise receives from a particular State, the tax authorities of that State should consider individual sources of profit that the enterprise receives in their State and apply to each the criterion of permanent establishment, taking into account the possible application of others Articles of the Convention. This solution allows for a more simplified and efficient tax management and compliance with the requirements of tax legislation, and it is more adapted to the way business is usually conducted. Modern businesses have a very complex organization. There are a significant number of companies, each of which is engaged in a wide range of activities and conducts large-scale business in many countries. A company may establish a permanent representative office in another country through which it carries out production activities, while another part of the same company sells various goods in that other country through independent agents. A given company may have quite compelling commercial reasons for doing so: for example, they may be based on the historical structure of its business or commercial convenience. If the country in whose territory the permanent establishment is located wished to attempt to identify and tax the revenue components of each transaction carried out through independent agents in order to combine these profits with the profits of the permanent establishment, then such an approach would create serious obstacles to normal commercial activities and would be contrary to the objectives of the Convention.
11. Referring to the portion of the company's profits attributed to the permanent establishment account, the second sentence of Paragraph 1 refers directly to Paragraph 2, which provides guidance on determining which profits should be attributed to the permanent establishment account. Since paragraph 2 is part of the context in which the proposal should be considered, it should not be interpreted in a way that may contradict Paragraph 2, for example, as limiting the amount of profit that can be attributed to the account of a permanent establishment to the amount of profit of the enterprise as a whole. Thus, although Paragraph 1 provides that a Contracting State may tax the profits of an enterprise of the other Contracting State only if they relate to the account of a permanent establishment located in the first State, it is Paragraph 2 that defines the meaning of the phrase “profits attributed to the account of a permanent establishment". In other words, the instructions provided for in Paragraph 2 may lead to the allocation of profits to the account of a permanent establishment, even if the company as a whole has never made a profit.; Conversely, they can lead to the fact that no profit will be attributed to the permanent establishment, even if the company as a whole has made a profit.
12. It is clear, however, that the Contracting State of the enterprise is interested in the correct application of the provisions of Paragraph 2 by the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located. Since the guidelines apply to both Contracting States, the State of the enterprise must, in accordance with Article 23, eliminate double taxation of profits properly attributed to the permanent establishment. In other words, if the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located attempts to tax profits that are not attributed to the permanent establishment in accordance with Article 7, this may lead to double taxation of profits that should be properly taxed only in the State of the enterprise.
13. The purpose of paragraph 1 is to provide for the limits of the application of the right of one Contracting State to tax the commercial profits of enterprises of the other Contracting State. The paragraph does not limit the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents in accordance with the provisions on controlled foreign companies provided for by its domestic law, even if such tax levied on these residents is calculated taking into account a portion of the profits of an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State related to the participation of these residents in the enterprise. A tax levied in this way by a State on its own residents does not reduce the profits of an enterprise of another State, and therefore cannot be considered levied on such profits (see also Paragraph 23 of the Commentary to Article 1 and Paragraphs 37-39 of the Commentary to Article 10).
Item 2
14 . This Paragraph contains the main instructions that are supposed to be used as the basis for attributing profits to the account of a permanent establishment. This paragraph includes the view that the profit attributed to a permanent establishment is the profit that that permanent establishment would have received if, instead of dealing with the rest of the enterprise, it had dealt with a completely separate enterprise on terms and prices prevailing in the regular market. This corresponds to the “at arm's length" principle discussed in the Commentary to Article 9. Typically, the profit determined in this way represents the same profit that would be expected using standard proper accounting processes.
15 . The provisions of the Paragraph require that this principle be applied by each Contracting State. Obviously, this does not mean that the amount in respect of which the enterprise will be taxed in the source State for a given period will be exactly the same as the amount of income for which another State will have to grant an exemption in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B. Differences between the domestic laws of the two States regarding issues such as depreciation rates, the timing of income recognition and restrictions on the deduction of certain expenses, which, in accordance with Paragraph 3 of this Article, usually lead to different amounts of taxable income in each State.
16 . In the vast majority of cases, the trading accounts of a permanent representative office, which usually exist if only because a well-managed company usually wants to know what the profitability of its various departments is, will be used to determine the profits properly attributed to the account of this representative office. In exceptional cases, separate accounts may not exist (see paragraphs 51-55 below). However, if such accounts exist, they will naturally become the starting point for any adjustment processes if an adjustment is required to obtain the amount of profit properly attributed to the permanent establishment account in accordance with the instructions contained in Paragraph 2. Perhaps it should be emphasized that these guidelines do not justify the construction of hypothetical profit indicators from scratch.; It is always necessary to start with the actual facts of the situation, evident from the business documentation of the permanent mission, and, if necessary, adjust the profit figures obtained due to these facts. Nevertheless, as noted in Paragraph 19 below and explained in Paragraph 39 of Part I of the Report, Attributing profits to permanent missions, records and documentation must meet certain requirements in order to be considered as reflecting the actual situation.
17 . In order to determine whether such an adjustment is required in accordance with Paragraph 2, it will be necessary to determine the profit that would have been earned if the permanent establishment had been a separate enterprise engaged in similar or similar activities on similar or similar terms and operated completely independently of the rest of the enterprise. Sections D-2 and D-3 of Part I of the Report on the allocation of profits to permanent missions describe a two-step approach by which this should be done. This approach will make it possible to calculate the profit attributed to all activities carried out through a permanent establishment, including transactions with other independent enterprises, transactions with associated enterprises, and transactions (for example, internal transfer of capital or property, or internal provision of services — see, for example, paragraphs 31 and 32) with other parts of the enterprise (in according to the second stage mentioned above), according to the instructions of Paragraph 2.
18. The first step of this approach requires the identification of activities carried out through a permanent establishment. This should be done through functional and factual analysis (for this purpose, the recommendations contained in the Transfer Pricing Guidelines for International Enterprises and Tax Authorities will be relevant). As part of this first step, economically significant activities and responsibilities undertaken through a permanent establishment will be identified. This analysis should, as far as appropriate, consider the activities and responsibilities carried out through a permanent establishment in the context of the activities and responsibilities carried out by the enterprise as a whole, in particular those parts of the enterprise that are involved in transactions with a permanent establishment. As part of the second step of this approach, remuneration for any of these transactions will be determined by applying, by analogy, the principles developed for the application of the “at arm's length" principle between associated enterprises (these principles are set out in the Transfer Pricing Guidelines for International Enterprises and Tax Authorities), taking into account the functions, assets and risks performed, used and accepted by the company through a permanent representative office and through the rest of the company.
19 . There may be a question about the extent to which accounting records should be relied upon if they are based on agreements between the head office and its permanent establishment (or between permanent missions). Obviously, such internal agreements cannot be considered legally binding agreements. However, if the trading accounts of the head office and the permanent representative office are drawn up symmetrically on the basis of such agreements, and these agreements reflect the functions performed by the various parts of the enterprise, the tax authorities may accept these trading accounts. However, accounts should not be considered to be drawn up symmetrically if the amounts of transactions or methods of attributing profits or expenses in the books of a permanent establishment do not exactly correspond to the amounts or methods of attributing profits or expenses in the books of the head office, taking into account the national or functional currency in which the enterprise recorded its transactions. In addition, as explained in Paragraph 16, records and documentation must meet certain requirements in order to be considered representative of the actual situation. For example, if trading accounts are based on internal agreements reflecting purely artificial arrangements instead of the real economic functions of various parts of the enterprise, these agreements should simply be ignored and accounts adjusted accordingly. One such case is if a permanent establishment involved in sales, in accordance with such an internal agreement, received the role of a principal (assuming all risks and being entitled to all profits from sales), when in fact the permanent establishment in question was nothing more than an intermediary or agent (bearing limited risks and having the right to only for a limited share of the income received), or, conversely, received the role of an intermediary or agent, when in fact he was not a principal.
20 . Thus, it can be concluded that accounting records and related documentation that meet the above requirements are a useful starting point for the purposes of attributing profits to the account of a permanent establishment. Taxpayers are advised to draw up such documentation, as this can significantly reduce the likelihood of a disagreement. Section D-2 (vi) (b) of Part I of the Report Attribution of profits to permanent missions discusses the conditions under which the tax authorities will use such documentation.
21 . Taxable profits may be earned if an asset, regardless of whether it is a stock of goods, which is part of the property of a permanent establishment located in the territory of a State, is transferred to a permanent establishment or the head office of the same enterprise located in another State. Article 7 allows the former State to tax profits that are considered to have arisen in connection with such a transfer. Such profit can be determined according to the following. In cases where such a transfer occurs, regardless of whether it is permanent, the question arises as to when the taxable profit will be received. In practice, if such property has a significant market value and may appear on the balance sheet of the importing permanent establishment or other part of the enterprise after the tax year during which the transfer took place, then as far as the enterprise as a whole is concerned, taxable profits will not necessarily be generated during the tax year in which the transfer in question took place. However, the very fact that the property leaves the scope of tax jurisdiction may lead to the taxation of accumulated profits attributed to the account of this property, since the concept of receipt depends on the domestic legislation of the country.
22 . If the States in whose territory permanent representative offices operate tax the profits received from internal transfers as soon as they have been made, even if these profits are not actually received until the next fiscal year, there will inevitably be a delay between the time the tax is paid abroad and the time it is recorded in the country where the company's head office is located. The delay is a serious problem, especially if a permanent establishment transfers its fixed assets, or, in the case of liquidation, its entire stock of working equipment, to another division of the enterprise of which it is a part. In such cases, the country in which the head office is located must, in each case, seek a bilateral solution with an external country where there is a serious risk of excessive taxation.
23 . Paragraph 3 of Article 5 establishes special rules for a permanent place of business, which is a construction site or a construction/installation project. Such a permanent place of business is a permanent establishment only if it has existed for more than twelve months. Experience shows that such types of permanent representative offices can lead to special problems in attributing income to their account in accordance with Article 7.
24 . These problems mainly arise when other parts of the enterprise or related parties provide goods or services in connection with the presence of a construction site or a construction/installation project. Although any permanent establishment may encounter these problems, they are most acutely felt on construction sites and during construction/installation projects. In these circumstances, it is necessary to pay close attention to the general principle that profits are credited to the account of a permanent establishment only in relation to the activities carried out by the enterprise through this permanent establishment.
25 . For example, if these goods are supplied by other parts of the enterprise, then the profit generated by such delivery is not the result of activities carried out through a permanent establishment and is not credited to its account. Similarly, profits earned from the provision of services (for example, planning, designing, drawing up drawings or providing technical advice) by business units operating outside the State in which the permanent establishment is located are not the result of activities carried out through the permanent establishment and are not attributed to it.
26 . If, in accordance with Paragraph 5 of Article 5, a permanent establishment of an enterprise of a Contracting State is considered to exist in the territory of another Contracting State in connection with the activities of a so-called dependent agent (see Paragraph 32 of the Commentary to Article 5), the principles used for attributing profits to other types of permanent representative offices will be applied for attributing profits about this permanent mission. As a first step, the actions taken by the dependent agent in favor of the enterprise will be established through a functional and factual analysis that determines the functions performed by the dependent agent on his own behalf and on behalf of the enterprise. The dependent agent and the company on whose behalf he acts represent two separate potential taxpayers. On the one hand, the dependent agent will receive his own income or profit from activities carried out on his own behalf for the benefit of the enterprise.; if the agent is itself a resident of one of the Contracting States, the provisions of the Convention (including Article 9 if the agent is an enterprise associated with the enterprise on whose behalf it acts) they will relate to the taxation of such income or profit. On the other hand, the assets and risks of the enterprise related to the functions performed by the dependent agent on behalf of this enterprise will be attributed to the account of the implied permanent establishment of the enterprise (i.e. the activities that the dependent agent carries out for the benefit of this enterprise), together with capital sufficient to support these assets and risks. Profits will then be attributed to the account of the implied permanent establishment based on these assets, risks and capital; these profits will be separated and will not be included in income or profits properly attributed to the account of the dependent agent itself (see section D-5 of Part I of the Report Attribution of profits to permanent missions).
Point 3
27 . This Paragraph clarifies the general guidelines set out in Paragraph 2 with regard to the expenses of the permanent mission. The Paragraph specifically recognizes that when calculating the profits of a permanent establishment, it is necessary to make allowances for expenses incurred anywhere for the purposes of the permanent establishment. Obviously, in some cases it will be necessary to estimate or calculate using conventional methods the amount that needs to be taken into account. In the case of, for example, general administrative expenses incurred at the head office of an enterprise, it may be advisable to take into account the proportional part based on the ratio of the turnover of the permanent establishment (or, possibly, gross profit) to the turnover of the enterprise as a whole. In this regard, it is considered that the amount of expenses that must be accounted for as incurred for the purposes of permanent establishment should represent the actual amount incurred in this way. The deduction available to the permanent mission for any expenses of the enterprise attributed to its account does not depend on the actual reimbursement of such expenses by the permanent mission.
28 . It was sometimes suggested that the need to coordinate Paragraphs 2 and 3 created practical difficulties, since Paragraph 2 required that prices between a permanent establishment and the head office should usually be set on a market basis, giving the transferor the kind of profit that could be expected if he dealt with an independent enterprise, although the wording of Paragraph 3 suggests that the deduction of expenses incurred for the purposes of permanent missions should be the actual amount of these expenses, usually without adding any element of profit.
29 . In fact, although the application of Paragraph 3 may lead to some practical difficulties, especially with regard to the principles of individual enterprise and disinterest underlying Paragraph 2, there is no difference between the two Paragraphs. Paragraph 3 states that, when determining the profit of a permanent establishment, certain expenses should be allowed as deductions, while Paragraph 2 provides that the profit determined in accordance with the rule given in Paragraph 3 concerning the deduction of expenses should be considered the profit that would be received by a separate enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities on the same or similar terms. Thus, although Paragraph 3 provides for a rule applying to the determination of the profits of a permanent establishment, Paragraph 2 requires that the profits so determined correspond to the profits that a separate and independent enterprise would receive.
30 . In addition, paragraph 3 only defines which expenses should be attributed to the account of the permanent establishment for the purpose of determining the profit attributed to the account of this permanent establishment. It does not address the issue of whether these expenses are deductible after they are credited to the account when calculating the taxable income of a permanent establishment, since the conditions for deducting expenses are determined by domestic law, taking into account the rules of Article 24 regarding Non-Discrimination (in particular, Paragraphs 3 and 4 of this Article).
31 . When applying these principles to the practical determination of the profits of a permanent establishment, the question may arise as to whether the specific costs incurred by the enterprise can actually be considered as expenses incurred for the purposes of the permanent establishment, taking into account the principles of the individual enterprise and disinterest given in Paragraph 2. Although, in general, independent enterprises in their transactions with each other try to make a profit and, by transferring property or providing services to each other, set prices in accordance with the open market, nevertheless, there are circumstances in which it cannot be assumed that a particular property or service could be obtained from an independent enterprise, or when independent Businesses may agree to share the costs of certain activities carried out jointly for their mutual benefit. In these specific circumstances, it may be appropriate to treat any related expenses incurred by the enterprise as expenses incurred by the permanent establishment. The difficulty arises in distinguishing between these circumstances and cases where the costs incurred by the enterprise should not be considered expenses of a permanent establishment, but the relevant property or service should be considered transferred between the head office and the permanent establishment at a price, including the profit element, based on the principle of separate and independent enterprises. The question should be whether the internal transfer of property and services, both temporary and final, is of the same type as those for which the company, in the normal course of business, would have charged a market price to a third party, i.e. by routinely including the corresponding profit in the sale price.
32 . On the one hand, the answer to this question will be positive if the costs were initially incurred in carrying out a function whose immediate purpose is to sell a specific product or service and make a profit through a permanent establishment. On the other hand, the answer will be no if, based on the facts and circumstances of a particular case, it turns out that the costs were initially incurred in carrying out a function whose important purpose is to rationalize the overall costs of the enterprise or increase its sales as a whole.
33 . If goods are supplied for resale both in finished form and in the form of raw materials or semi-finished products, it is usually advisable to apply the provisions of Paragraph 2 and distribute profits to the account of the supplying division of the enterprise, calculated taking into account the principle of “at arm's length". However, even here there may be exceptions. One example would be a situation where goods are not supplied for resale, but for temporary use in trade, so it may be appropriate for business units sharing materials to pay only their share of the costs of such materials; for example, in the case of equipment, depreciation costs associated with its use each of these divisions. Of course, one should not forget that the mere fact of purchasing goods does not constitute a permanent establishment (subparagraph 4 d) Article 5), so in such circumstances, the issue of profit sharing does not arise.
34 . In the case of intangible rights, rules concerning relations between enterprises of the same group (for example, royalty payments or cost-sharing arrangements) cannot apply to relations between parts of the same enterprise. Indeed, it can be extremely difficult to allocate “ownership” of an intangible right exclusively to one part of an enterprise and argue that this part of the enterprise should receive royalties from other parts, as if it were an independent enterprise. Since there is only one legal entity, it is impossible to assign legal ownership to any particular part of the enterprise, and from a practical point of view, it is often difficult to attribute the costs of creation solely to one part of the enterprise. Therefore, it may be preferable to consider the costs of creating intangible rights as attributable to all parts of the enterprise that will use them, and incurred on behalf of the various parts of the enterprise to which they correspondingly relate. In such circumstances, it would be advisable to distribute among the various parts of the enterprise the actual costs of creating or acquiring such intangible rights, as well as the costs subsequently incurred in respect of such intangible rights, without any profit margins or royalties. At the same time, the tax authorities should be aware that the possible negative consequences associated with any research and development (for example, liability related to products and environmental damage) should also be distributed among different parts of the enterprise, thus, in appropriate cases, leading to a compensation fee.
35 . The service sector is an area where it may be difficult to determine whether, in a particular case, a service fee should be charged between different parts of one enterprise at its actual cost or at this cost plus a surcharge in order to attribute profits to the part of the enterprise that provides the service. The trade carried out by the enterprise or its part may include the provision of such services, and a standard rate may be charged for their provision. In this case, it is usually advisable to charge for the service at the same rate as that charged to the external client.
36 . If the main activity of a permanent establishment is to provide specific services to the enterprise to which it belongs, and if these services provide the enterprise with a real advantage, and their costs represent a significant part of the enterprise's expenses, the country of location may require that the unit profit be included in the amount of expenses. Whenever possible, the host country should try to avoid schematic solutions and rely on the cost of these services in the given circumstances of each case.
37. However, more often than not, the provision of services is simply part of the overall management of the company as a whole, for example, when an enterprise implements a common training system, and employees of all departments of the enterprise benefit from this. In such a case, it is usually advisable to consider the cost of providing services as part of the total administrative costs of the enterprise as a whole, which should be distributed based on actual costs between the various parts of the enterprise to the extent that the costs were incurred for the purposes of these parts of the enterprise, without any allowances for attributing profits to another part of the enterprise.
38 . When considering the services provided during the general management of an enterprise, the question arises whether any part of the total profit of the enterprise should be considered to have arisen as a result of proper management. Let's consider the case of a company whose head office is located in one country, but all its activities are carried out through a permanent representative office located in another country. In extreme cases, it may well happen that only meetings of directors were held at the head office, and all other activities of the company, except for purely formal legal activities, were carried out at the permanent mission. In this case, there is something to say about the point of view that at least part of the profit of the entire enterprise was obtained due to the skillful management and business qualities of the directors, and therefore part of the profit of the enterprise should relate to the country in which the head office is located. If the company was managed by a management company, then, undoubtedly, such a company charged a fee for its services, which could simply represent a percentage of the company's profits. But whatever the theoretical advantages of such a course, practical considerations speak against them. In the above case, the management costs would, of course, be compared with the profit of the permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 3, but when the issue is considered as a whole, it is considered that it would be wrong to move forward by subtracting and taking into account some conditional figure as "management profit". In cases similar to the extreme case mentioned above, therefore, no conditional figures should be taken into account as management profits when determining the taxable profits of a permanent establishment.
39 . Of course, it may happen that countries where it is customary to distribute some of the total profits of an enterprise to its head office in order to present the profits from effective management, will wish to continue to make such distributions. None of the provisions of the Article is intended to prevent this. Nevertheless, it follows from what is said in Paragraph 38 above that the country in whose territory the permanent establishment is located is in no way obligated to deduct, when calculating the profits attributed to the account of this permanent establishment, the amount that should represent a proportional part of the profits from the management attributed to the head office.
40 . It is likely that if the country in which the company's head office is located distributes to the head office a certain percentage of the company's profits only in terms of effective management, while the country where the permanent establishment is located does not do so, the total amount to be taxed in the two countries will be more than it should be. In any case, the country in which the company's head office is located should take the initiative to organize such adjustments in calculating tax liability in that country that may be necessary to eliminate double taxation.
41. Consideration of interest charges raises special questions. Firstly, there may be amounts that, under the name of interest, are charged by the head office from its permanent representative office in respect of internal "loans" from the first to the second. With the exception of financial enterprises such as banks, it is generally accepted that such internal "interest" does not require recognition. This happens for the following reasons:
From a legal point of view, the transfer of capital to pay interest and the obligation to pay the full amount on time is actually a formal act incompatible with the actual legal nature of a permanent establishment.
— From an economic point of view, internal debts and monetary claims may not exist, because if an enterprise is financed solely or primarily from its own funds, it should not be allowed to deduct interest charges, which it obviously should not pay. Although, admittedly, symmetrical accruals and receipts will not distort the overall profit of the enterprise, the interim results may well be changed arbitrarily.
42. For this reason, the ban on deductions for domestic debts and monetary claims should continue to apply generally, taking into account the special situation of banks as indicated below.
43. Another issue is the deduction of interest on debts actually incurred by the company. Such debts may partially or completely relate to the activities of a permanent establishment; indeed, loans provided by the enterprise will serve the purposes of the head office, the permanent establishment, or both. In connection with these debts, the question arises how to determine the part of the interest that should be deducted when calculating the profit attributed to the permanent establishment account.
44 . The approach proposed in this Commentary before 1994, namely the direct and indirect allocation of actual debt charges, did not provide a practical solution, primarily because it is unlikely to be applied uniformly. In addition, it is well known that the indirect allocation of the total amount of interest payments, or the portion of interest that remains after certain direct distributions, faces practical difficulties. It is also well known that the direct allocation of total interest expenses may not accurately reflect the costs of financing a permanent establishment, since the taxpayer may be able to control where loans are registered, and adjustments may be needed to reflect the real economic situation, in particular, the fact that an independent enterprise is usually expected to have a certain level of "free" capital.
45 . Consequently, most participating countries believe that it would be preferable to seek a practical solution that takes into account a capital structure suitable for both the organization and the functions performed. This appropriate capital structure will take into account the fact that a permanent establishment requires a certain amount of financing to carry out its activities, consisting of "free" capital and interest-bearing debt. Thus, the goal is to transfer to the account of the permanent mission the amount of interest without interest after the allocation of the corresponding amount of "free" capital in order to support the functions, assets and risks of the permanent mission. According to the "at arm's length" principle, a permanent establishment must have sufficient capital to support its functions, the assets of which it is the economic owner, and the risks it has assumed. In the financial sector, regulations provide for minimum levels of regulatory capital to ensure that there is a financial cushion in case any of the risks typical of a business lead to financial losses. Capital provides a similar cushion to protect against risk crystallization in non-financial sectors.
46. As explained in section D-2 (v)b) In Part I of the Report, the allocation of profits to permanent missions, there are various acceptable approaches to the allocation of "free" capital that can produce results consistent with the "at arm's length" principle. Each approach has its own strengths and weaknesses, which become more or less significant depending on the facts and circumstances of specific cases. Different methods use different starting points to determine the amount of "free" capital attributable to a permanent establishment, which either place greater emphasis on the actual structure of the enterprise of which the permanent establishment is a part, or, alternatively, on the capital structures of comparable independent enterprises. The key to allocating "free" capital is recognition:
— the existence of strengths and weaknesses of any approach, and in which cases they are likely to be present;
— that there is not a single market amount of "free" capital, but a number of potential capital distributions within which it is possible to find the amount of "free" capital that corresponds to the basic principles outlined above.
47. At the same time, it is recognized that there are various acceptable approaches to attribution
The transfer of "free" capital to the account of a permanent mission, which can give a result corresponding to the principle of “at arm's length", may lead to the problem of double taxation. The main problem, which is particularly acute for financial institutions, is that if the domestic legislation of the State in which the permanent establishment is located and the State of the enterprise require different acceptable approaches to allocating the market amount of available capital to the permanent establishment account, the amount of profit calculated by the State of the permanent establishment may be higher. than the amount of profit calculated by the State of the enterprise for the purposes of exemption from double taxation.
48. Given the importance of this issue, the Committee has begun to find a practical solution. The OECD member countries therefore agreed to adopt, for the purpose of determining the amount of the interest deduction to be used in calculating the exemption from double taxation, the allocation of capital received from the application of the approach used by the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, if the following conditions are met: first, if the difference in the distribution of capital between this State and the State of the enterprise occurs due to contradictions in the choice of capital allocation methods provided for by domestic legislation., and secondly, if there is an agreement that the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located has used a permitted approach to the allocation of capital, and there is also an agreement that this approach gives a result consistent with the principle of “at arm's length" in a particular case. The OECD member countries consider that they can achieve this result through their own domestic legislation, through the interpretation of Articles 7 and 23, or by using the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25, and in particular the opportunity offered by this Article, to resolve any issues related to the application or interpretation of their tax agreements.
49. As already mentioned, special considerations apply to internal interest charges on loans between different parts of a financial institution (for example, a bank), since the provision and receipt of loans is closely related to the normal activities of such enterprises. This issue, as well as other issues related to the application of Article 7 to permanent missions of banks and enterprises engaged in global trade, is discussed in Parts II and III of the Report Attribution of profits to permanent missions.
50. The definition of investment assets attributed to the account of a permanent establishment through which insurance activities are carried out also raises certain issues, which are discussed in Part IV of the Report.
51. It is usually found that adequate reports exist or can be created for each part or department of the enterprise so that profits or expenses, adjusted if necessary, can be distributed to the account of a specific part of the enterprise with a significant degree of accuracy. It is considered that this distribution method is generally preferable in cases where it is advisable to use it. However, there are circumstances in which this may not happen, and Paragraphs 2 and 3 in no way imply that other methods cannot be properly applied, where appropriate, to generate profits for a permanent establishment based on the principle of a "separate enterprise". For example, it may well be that it is most convenient to determine the profits of insurance companies using special calculation methods, for example, by applying appropriate coefficients to the gross premiums received from policyholders in the relevant country. Again, in the case of a relatively small enterprise operating on both sides of the border between two countries, there may not be adequate reports for a permanent establishment or the means to create them. There may also be other cases where the affairs of a permanent mission are so closely linked to the affairs of the head office that they cannot be untangled on any strict basis of branch accounts. If in such cases it has been accepted to evaluate the commercial profit of a permanent establishment based on a suitable criterion, it may be quite acceptable to continue following this method, despite the fact that the assessment made in this way may not have such a high degree of measurement accuracy as adequate reports. Even if such a course was not customary, in exceptional cases it may be necessary for practical reasons to estimate commercial profits based on other methods.
Item 4
52. In some cases, there is a practice of determining the profit attributed to the account of a permanent establishment, not on the basis of individual accounts or estimating commercial profits, but by simply distributing the total profit of the enterprise taking into account various formulas. This method differs from those provided for in Paragraph 2, since it does not imply the distribution of profits based on the principle of an individual enterprise, but on the basis of the distribution of total profits.; Indeed, this could produce a result in digital terms that would differ from the result obtained by calculating on the basis of individual accounts. Paragraph 4 clarifies that such a method may continue to be used by a Participating State if its application is accepted in that State, even if the data obtained using it sometimes differs to some extent from those obtained for individual accounts, provided that it can be fairly argued that the result is consistent with the principles contained in this Article. At the same time, it is emphasized that, in general, the profit to be attributed to the account of a permanent mission should be determined taking into account the accounts of the representative office, if they reflect real facts. It is considered that a distribution method based on the distribution of total profits is generally not as appropriate as a method that takes into account only the activities of a permanent establishment, and should be used only in exceptional cases when it has historically developed and is generally accepted in the relevant country by tax authorities and taxpayers as a satisfactory method. It is understood that Paragraph 4 can be deleted if none of the States uses this method. However, if the Contracting States wish to be able to use a method that was not customary in the past, the Paragraph should be amended through bilateral negotiations for explanatory purposes.
53. We believe that within the framework of this Commentary it would be inappropriate to attempt to discuss in detail the many different methods involving the distribution of total profits adopted for this purpose in specific areas. These methods have been well documented in international taxation agreements. However, it might be useful to briefly list some of the main types and provide some general guidance on their use.
54. An important feature of the method involving the distribution of total profits is that a proportional portion of the profits of the entire enterprise is distributed to its parts, while it is assumed that all parts of the enterprise have contributed based on the criterion or criteria adopted in relation to the profitability of the entire enterprise. The difference between one of these methods and the other arises mainly due to the different criteria used to determine the correct proportion of the total profit. It would be fair to say that the criteria usually applied can be divided into three main categories, namely, based on the company's income, expenses or capital structure. The first category covers distribution methods based on turnover or commission, the second on wages, and the third on the share of the total working capital of the enterprise distributed to each branch or division. Of course, it is impossible to say from scratch that any of these methods is more accurate than the others.; The appropriateness of a particular method will depend on the circumstances to which it is applied. In the case of some enterprises, such as those providing services or manufacturing patented products with high profitability, net profit will largely depend on turnover. It may be advisable for insurance companies to distribute the total profits, taking into account the premiums received from policyholders in each of the respective countries. In the case of an enterprise producing goods with high cost of raw materials or labor, profits may be more closely related to expenses. In the case of banking and financial concerns, the most appropriate criterion may be the share of total working capital. It is considered that the general purpose of any method involving the distribution of total profits should be to obtain taxable profit figures as close as possible to those that would be obtained on the basis of individual accounts, and that it would be undesirable to try to formulate any specific instructions in this regard other than those that the tax authority should determine after consultations with the authorities of other relevant countries on the use of the method that, taking into account all known facts, seems most likely to achieve such a result..
55. The use of any method that distributes a share of the total profit to the parts of the enterprise, of course, raises the question of the method that should be used in calculating the total profit of the enterprise. This issue may well be considered in different ways in accordance with the laws of different countries. This is not a problem that it would be worthwhile to try to solve by setting strict rules. It is unlikely that it will be accepted that the profits to be distributed should be profits calculated in accordance with the legislation of a particular country.; Each interested country should be given the right to calculate profits in accordance with the provisions of its own legislation.
Item 5
56 . Paragraph 4 of Article 5 lists a number of examples of activities that, even if carried out through a permanent place of business, are not considered to be included in the concept of "permanent establishment". When considering the rules for distributing profits to a permanent establishment, the most important of these examples is the activity referred to in paragraph 5 of this Article, i.e. the procurement department.
57 . Paragraph 5, of course, does not apply to an organization established solely for the purpose of procurement; such an organization is not a permanent establishment, and therefore the profit-sharing provisions of this Article do not apply. This Paragraph considers a permanent establishment, which, although engaged in other activities, is also engaged in procurement for its head office. In this case, the Clause stipulates that the profit of a permanent establishment should not be increased by adding to it a conditional amount of profit from purchases. It follows from this, of course, that any expenses related to procurement activities will also be excluded when calculating the taxable profit of a permanent establishment.
Item 6
58 . The purpose of this paragraph is to make it clear that the allocation method once used should not change simply because in a particular year some other method yields more favorable results. One of the objectives of the agreement for the avoidance of double taxation is to give an enterprise of a Contracting State some degree of certainty about the tax treatment that will be provided to its permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, as well as to that part of the enterprise in its State of Incorporation that does business with the permanent establishment; for this reason, Paragraph 6 guarantees continuity and consistency of the tax regime.
Item 7
59 . Although it was not considered necessary to define the concept of "profit" in the Convention, nevertheless, it should be understood that when used in this Article and elsewhere in the Convention, this term has a broad meaning, including all income received from the activities of the enterprise. This broad meaning corresponds to the use of the term in the tax laws of most OECD member countries.
60 . However, such an interpretation of the concept of "profit" may lead to some uncertainty regarding the application of the Convention. If the profit of an enterprise includes income categories considered separately in other Articles of the Convention, for example, dividends, then the question may be asked whether the taxation of this profit is regulated by a special Article on dividends, etc., or by the provisions of this Article.
61 . If the application of this Article and the corresponding special Article lead to the emergence of the same tax regime, then this issue is of little practical importance. In addition, it should be noted that some of the special Articles contain specific provisions giving priority to a specific Article (see paragraph 4 of Article 6, Paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11, Paragraph 3 of Article 12 and Paragraph 2 of Article 21).
62 . Nevertheless, it seemed desirable to establish an interpretative rule in order to clarify the scope of application of this Article in relation to other Articles relating to a certain category of income. In accordance with the practice usually followed in existing bilateral agreements, Paragraph 7 primarily gives preference to special Items related to dividends, interest, etc. It follows from the rule that this Article will apply to commercial profits that do not belong to the income categories covered by the special Articles, and, in addition, to dividends, interest, etc., which, in accordance with Paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11, Paragraph 3 of Article 12 and Paragraph 2 of Article 21, are subject to this Articles (see Paragraphs 12-18 of the Commentary to Article 12, which discusses the principles governing whether, in the specific case of software, payments should be classified as commercial profits under Article 7 or as capital gains under Article 13, on the one hand, or as royalties under Article 12, on the other hand). It is understood that income items included in special Articles may, subject to the provisions of the Convention, be taxed either separately or as commercial profits in accordance with the laws of the Contracting States.
63 . The Contracting States may, on a bilateral basis, agree on special explanations or definitions concerning the concept of "profit" in order to clarify the difference between this term and the so-called concept of dividends. In particular, this may be considered appropriate if the agreement under discussion deviates from the definitions given in the special articles regarding dividends, interest and royalties. It may also be considered appropriate if the Contracting States wish to notify that, according to the domestic tax laws of one or both States, the term "profit" includes special classes of income, such as income from the sale or lease of a business or movable property used in business activities. In this regard, it may be necessary to consider whether it is appropriate to include additional rules for the distribution of such special profits.
64 . It should also be noted that, although the definition of "royalties" is in paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the draft 1963 Convention and the 1977 Model Convention. included payments "for the use or right to use industrial, commercial or scientific equipment", the reference to these payments was subsequently removed from this definition in order to ensure that income from the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, including income from the rental of containers, would be subject to the provisions of Article 7 rather than Article 12. which is a result that the Committee on Budget and Finance considers appropriate, given the nature of such income.
Comments on the Comment
65 . Italy and Portugal consider it important to take into account that, regardless of the meaning given in the fourth sentence of Paragraph 8, with regard to the tax calculation method, the new version of the model, i.e. the deletion of Article 14, does not affect national systems.
66. Belgium cannot share the views expressed in paragraph 13 of the Commentary. Belgium considers that the application of legislation on controlled foreign companies is contrary to the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 7. This is especially the case when a Contracting State taxes one of its residents on income earned by a foreign organization using an assumption that attributes to that resident, in proportion to his participation in the capital of a foreign organization, the income earned by that organization. Thus, this State increases the tax base of its resident, including income earned by a non-resident in a foreign organization that is not taxed by this State in accordance with Paragraph 1 of Article 7. Thus, this Contracting State ignores the legal personality of a foreign organization and acts in violation of Paragraph 1 of Article 7.
67. Luxembourg does not agree with the interpretation in Paragraph 13, which provides that Paragraph 1 of Article 7 does not limit the right of a Contracting State to tax its own residents in accordance with the provisions on controlled foreign companies contained in its domestic legislation, since such an interpretation calls into question the fundamental principle set out in Paragraph 1 of Article 7.
68. With regard to paragraph 13, Ireland expresses its general comment in paragraph 27.5 of the Commentary to Article 1.
69. With regard to paragraph 45, Greece notes that Greek domestic law does not provide for any rules or methods for allocating "free" capital to permanent missions. In respect of loans provided by the enterprise, which partially or completely relate to the activities of the permanent mission, Greece allows the deduction of that part of the interest, which corresponds to the amount of the loan provided by the head office and actually transferred to the permanent mission.
70 . Portugal wishes to reserve the right not to adhere to the point of view set out in paragraph 45 of the Commentary to Article 7, except in cases where there are specific provisions of domestic law providing for certain levels of "free" capital for permanent missions.
71 . With regard to Paragraph 46, Sweden wishes to clarify that, in its opinion, the various approaches to the allocation of "free" capital that the Paragraph considers "acceptable" will not necessarily lead to an outcome in accordance with the “at arm's length" principle. Consequently, when considering the facts and circumstances of each case to determine whether the amount of interest deduction resulting from these approaches is consistent with the "at arm's length" principle, Sweden in many cases will not consider that the approach of other States is consistent with the "at arm's length" principle. Sweden is of the opinion that double taxation will often occur in this regard, requiring the use of a mutual agreement procedure.
72. Portugal wishes to reserve the right not to follow the "symmetrical" approach described in Paragraph 48 of the Commentary to Article 7, since Portuguese domestic law does not provide for any rules or methods for allocating "free" capital to permanent missions. When eliminating double taxation in accordance with Article 23, Portugal, as the country of registration, determines the amount of profit attributed to the permanent establishment account in accordance with domestic legislation.
73 . Germany, Japan and the United States, while agreeing with the practical solution described in Paragraph 48, wish to clarify how this agreement will be implemented. Neither Germany, Japan, nor the United States can automatically accept for all purposes all calculations of the State in which the permanent mission is located. In cases involving Germany or Japan, the second condition described in Paragraph 48 must be satisfied through a mutual agreement procedure in accordance with Article 25. In the case of Japan and the United States, a taxpayer wishing to obtain an additional restriction on a foreign tax credit must do so through a mutual agreement procedure, in which the taxpayer will have to prove to the authorized body of Japan or the United States, depending on the situation, that the double taxation of the profits of a permanent establishment resulting from a contradictory choice of capital allocation methods by domestic legislation, was not eliminated after the mechanisms were applied in accordance with their domestic legislation, such as using the restriction of a foreign tax credit created by other transactions.
74 . With regard to Paragraphs 6 and 7, New Zealand notes that it does not agree with the approach proposed for attributing profits to permanent missions in general, as indicated in Part I of the Report, Attributing profits to permanent missions.
Reservations to the Article
75 . Australia, Chile and New Zealand reserve the right to include a provision authorizing the application of their domestic laws regarding the taxation of profits from any form of insurance activity.
76 . Australia and New Zealand reserve the right to include a provision clarifying their right to tax a share of the commercial profits to which a resident of a Contracting State has a beneficial right if these profits were received by the trustee of the property managed by proxy (except for certain mutual funds, which for tax purposes in Australia and New Zealand are considered companies), from operating in Australia or New Zealand, depending on the situation, through a permanent representative office.
77 . Korea and Portugal reserve the right to tax persons providing professional services or carrying out other independent activities if they are present on their territory for a period or periods totaling more than 183 days in any period of twelve months, even if these persons do not have a permanent establishment (or permanent base) accessible by to provide such services or activities to them.
78 . Chile, Italy and Portugal reserve the right to tax persons providing independent personal services in accordance with a separate article corresponding to Article 14 as amended before its exclusion in 2000.
79 . The United States reserves the right to amend Article 7 to provide that, in applying Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article, any income or profits attributed to a permanent establishment during its existence may be taxed by the Contracting State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, even if payments are deferred until The permanent mission will not cease to exist. The United States also wishes to point out that it reserves the right to apply such a rule also in accordance with Articles 11, 12, 13 and 21.
80. Turkey reserves the right to tax the income from the rental of containers with withholding tax in all cases. In the case of the application of Articles 5 and 7 to such income, Turkey would like to apply the permanent establishment rule to the cases of a simple depot, a depot agency and an operational branch.
81 . Norway and the United States reserve the right to treat income from the use, maintenance or rental of containers used in international transportation in accordance with Article 8 in the same way as income from sea and air transportation.
82 . Australia and Portugal reserve the right, in bilateral negotiations, to propose a provision that, if the information available to the authorized body of a Contracting State is insufficient to determine the profits attributed to the permanent establishment of an enterprise, the authorized body may apply to that enterprise for this purpose the provisions of the tax legislation of that State, with the proviso that this The legislation will be applied as far as the information available to the authorized body allows, in accordance with the principles of this Article.
83 . Mexico reserves the right to tax in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located the commercial profits derived from the sale of goods carried out directly by its head office located in the other Contracting State, provided that these goods are similar or similar to those sold through that permanent establishment. The Government of Mexico will apply this rule only to protect against abuse, and not as a general principle of "gravity 83 . Mexico reserves the right to tax in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located the commercial profits derived from the sale of goods carried out directly by its head office located in the other Contracting State, provided that these goods are similar or similar to those sold through that permanent establishment. The Government of Mexico will apply this rule only to protect against abuse, and not as a general principle of "gravity"; Thus, the rule does not apply if the company proves that the sales were made for reasons other than obtaining benefits in accordance with the Convention.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 8
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF PROFITS FROM INTERNATIONAL TRANSPORTATION BY SEA AND AIR
Point 1
1. The purpose of Paragraph 1 concerning profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic is to ensure th1. The purpose of Paragraph 1 concerning profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic is to ensure that such profits are taxable only in one State. The Provision is based on the principle that the right to taxation should remain with the Contracting State of the enterprise. The definition of "international communication" is given in subparagraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 3.
2. Until 2017, Parag 2. Until 2017, Paragraph 1 stipulated that the rights to taxation should remain with the Contracting State in whose territory the actual location of the company's management bodies was located. Nevertheless, a review of the contractual practices of countries within and outside the OECD showed that most of these States preferred to transfer the right to taxation to the State of the enterprise, and the article was amended accordingly. Nevertheless, some Staheless, some States prefer to continue using the previous wording and grant the exclusive right to taxation to the State in whose territory the actual location of the company's management bodies is located. Such States may replace the rule as follows:
Profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic are subject to taxation only by the State in whose territory the actual location of the company's management bodies is located.
3. States wishing to use an alternative formulation in paragraph 2 above may also wish to consider the specific case where the actual location of the management of an enterprise is located on board a ship, which can be done by adding the following provision:
If the actual seat of the management of the enterprise engaged in tranIf the actual seat of the management of the enterprise engaged in transportation is located on board the ship, it is considered to be located in the territory of the Contracting State where the ship's home harbor is located, or, if there is no such harbor, in the territory of the Contracting State of which the shipowner is a resident.
4. The covered profit consists, first of all, of the profit directly received by the enterprise from the transportation of passengers or cargo by sea or aircr 4. The covered profit consists, first of all, of the profit directly received by the enterprise from the transportation of passengers or cargo by sea or aircraft (own, leased, or otherwise at the disposal of the enterprise), which it operates in international transportation. However, as international transportation develops, companies engaged in maritime and air transportation are constantly carrying out a wide range of activities to allow, facilitate or support their international transportation. The paragraph also cragraph also covers profits from activities directly related to such operations, as well as profits from activities not directly related to the operation of ships or aircraft of the enterprise in international traffic, if they constitute ancillary activities in this regard.
4.1 Any activity carried out primarily in connection with the carriage of passengers or goods by an enterprise by sea or by air, which it operates i
4.2 Activities that the enterprise does not need to carry out for the purposes of its own operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, but which make little contribution to such operation and are so closely related to such operation that they are not considered a separate business or a source of income for the enterprise, should be considered auxiliary to the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic.
4.3 Taking these principles into account, the following Paragraphs discuss the extent to which Paragraph 1 applies to specific activities that may be carried out by an enterprise involved in the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic.
5. Profits earned from leasing a fully equipped, crewed, and supplied marine or aircraft for charter flights should be considered as profits from the transportation of passengers or cargo. Otherwise, most shipping or air traffic would not be covered by this provision. However, Article 7, rather than 8, applies to profits from the lease of a ship or aircraft on the basis of a contract for the chartering of a vessel without a crew, except in cases where it is an ancillary activity of an enterprise engaged in the international operation of ships or aircraft.
6. The profits earned by an enterprise from the transportation of passengers or goods in a manner other than transportation by sea or by air, which it operates in international transportation, are subject to the Paragraph if such transportation is directly related to the operation of this enterprise, ships or aircraft in international transportation or is an auxiliary activity. One example would be an enterprise involved in international transportation that carries out international transportation of some of its passengers or cargo by sea or by air, operated by other enterprises, for example, in accordance with codeshare or slot charter agreements, or to take advantage of an earlier voyage. Another example is an airline that provides bus services connecting a city with an airport, mainly to provide access to and from that airport for passengers on its international flights.
7. Another example is an enterprise engaged in the transportation of passengers or cargo by sea or by air in international traffic, which undertakes to pick up these passengers or cargo in the country from which the transportation is carried out, or to transport or deliver them to the country of destination by any type of land transportation carried out by these enterprises 7. Another example is an enterprise engaged in the transportation of passengers or cargo by sea or by air in international traffic, which undertakes to pick up these passengers or cargo in the country from which the transportation is carried out, or to transport or deliver them to the country of destination by any type of land transportation carried out by these enterprises. In this case, any profit earned by the first enterprise from organizing such transportation with the help of other enterprises is subject to the Paragraph even if other enterprises engaged in such overland transportation do not make a profit.
8. An enterprise often sells tickets on behalf of other transport companies at the location it serves, mainly to sell tickets for flights of ships or aircraft that it operates internationally. Such ticket sales on behalf of other enterprises will either be directly related to flight 8. An enterprise often sells tickets on behalf of other transport companies at the location it serves, mainly to sell tickets for flights of ships or aircraft that it operates internationally. Such ticket sales on behalf of other enterprisewl either be directly related to flighs of ships or aircraft operated by the enterprise (for example, the sale of tickets issued by another enterprise for the domestic segment of an international flight offered by the enterprise), or will be an auxiliary activity for its own sales. Therefore, the profit earned by the first company from the sale of such tickets falls under the Paragraph.
8.1 Advertising that an enterprise may place for other enterprises in magazines offered on board ships or aircraft operated by it, or in its places of operation (for example, ticket offices), is an auxiliary activity in relation to the operation of these vessels, and the profit earned through such advertising is subject to Paragraph.
9. Containers are widely used in international traffic. Such containers are often used for land transportation. The profit earned by an enterprise engaged in international transportation from the rental of containers is usually either directly related to or accompanies the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, and in this case falls within the scope of the Paragraph. The same conclusion will apply to the profits earned by such an enterprise from the short-term storage of such containers (for example, when the enterprise charges a customer for storing a loaded container in a warehouse while awaiting delivery) or from fines due to forced delays in the return of containers.
10. An enterprise that has assets or personnel in a foreign country for the purpose of operating its ships or aircraft in int 10. An enterprise that has assets or personnel in a foreign country for the purpose of operating its ships or aircraft in international traffic may receive income from the provision of goods or services in that State to other transport enterprises. This may include (for example) the provision of goods and services by engineers, ground staff and equipment maintenance personnel, movers, food store staff and customer service personnel. If an enterprise provides such goods or services to other enterprises, and such activity is directly related to or accompanies the operation of the enterprise's ships or aircraft, profits from the provision of such goods or services to other enterprises are subject to Paragraph.
10.1 For example, international transportation companies may enter into resource pooling agreements to reduce the cost of maintaining facilities required to operate their ships or aircraft in other countries. For example, if an airline, in accordance with an international airline Technical Pool agreement, agrees to provide spare parts or maintenance services to other airlines whose aircraft land at a certain locatiample, if an airline, in accordance with an international airline Technical Pool agreement, agrees to provide spare parts or maintenance services to other airlines whose aircraft land at a certain location (which allows it to use these services in other locations), the activities carried out in accordance with this agreement are related to the operation of the aircraft in international traffic.
11. [Deleted]
12 . This paragraph does not apply to shipyards operated in one country by a shipping company whose actual management offices are located in another country.
13 . [Number changed]
14 . Investment income from shipping or air transport enterprises (for example, income from stocks, bonds or loans) is subject to the treatment normally applied to this class of income, except in cases where income-generating investments are carried out 14 . Investment income from shipping or air transport enterprises (for example, income from stocks, bonds or lois subject to the treatment normally applied to this class o come, except in cases where income-generating investments are carried out as an integral part of doing business or operating ships or aircraft in international traffic in a Contracting State, as that investments can be considered directly related to such exploitation. Thus, the Paragraph will apply to interest income earned, for example, from funds required in a Contracting State to carry out such business activities, or bonds placed as collateral, if required by law to carry out business activities: in such cases, investments are necessary to allow the operation of ships or aircraft at this location. However, the Paragraph will not apply to interest income earned in the course of working with cash flows or other treasury activities for permanent representative offices of an enterprise to which the income doHowever, the Paragraph will not apply to interest income earned in the course of working with cash flows or other treasury activities for permanent representative offices of an enterprise to which the income does not relate, or for associated enterprises, regardless of whether they are located in or outside the territory of a Contracting State, or for the head office (centralization of treasury and investment activities), as well as interest income generated by short-term investments of profits generated as a result of local business activities, if there is no need for invested funds to conduct such activities.
14.1 Enterprises operating ships or aircraft in international traffic may be required to acquire and use emission permits and benefits for this purpose (the nature of these permits and bene 14.1 Enterprises operating ships or aircraft in international traffic may be required to acquire and use emission per benefits for this purpose (the nature of these permits and benefits is explained in Paragraph 75.1 of the Commentary to Article 7). Paragraph 1 applies to income earned by such enterprises in connection with such permits and benefits if such income is an integral part of carrying on business activities for the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, for example, if peraph 1 appliecome earned by such enterprises in connection with such permits and benefits if such income is an integral part of carrying on business activities for the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic, for example, if permits are acquired for the purpose of operating ships or aircraft, or if permits acquired for this purpose are subsequently they will
Operation of boats involved in transportation on inland waterways
15 . States wishing to apply the same regime to transportation by rivers, canals and lakes as to transportation by sea and air in international traffic can do so by including the following provision in their bilateral agreements:
Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation of vessels engaged in inland waterway transport are taxable only in that State.
16 . The above provision will apply not only to inland waterway transport between two or more countries (in which case it overlaps with Paragraph 1), but also to inland waterway transport carried out by an enterprise of one State between two locations in another State. The alternative wording given in Paragraph 2 above, according to which the right to tax is granted to the State in whose territory the actual location of the management bodies of the enterprise is located, also applies to the above provision. If this alternative provision is used, it would be advisable to add a reference to "vessels engaged in inland waterway transport" in Paragraph 3 of Articles 13 and 22 to ensure that such vessels are treated in the same way as ships and aircraft engaged in international transport (see also paragraph 9.3 of the Commentary to the Article 15). In addition, the principles and examples included in Paragraphs 4 and 14 above will be applied, with necessary modifications, for the purpose of determining what profits can be considered to be earned from the operation of boats engaged in inland waterway transportation. Specific tax problems that may arise in connection with transportation by inland waterways, in particular between neighboring States, can also be resolved through the adoption of a bilateral agreement.
17 . Although the above alternative provision uses the word "vessel" in relation to inland waterway transport, this reflects a traditional distinction that should not be interpreted as limiting in any way the meaning of the word "vessel" used in the Convention, which should have a broad meaning encompassing any vessel used for navigation on water.
18 . The Parties may also agree bilaterally that profits from the operation of vessels engaged in fishing, dredging or towing on the high seas should be considered income covered by this Article.
Enterprises that are not exclusively engaged in transportation by sea or air
19 . It follows from the wording of Paragraph 1 that enterprises that are not exclusively engaged in transportation by sea or by air, nevertheless, fall under the scope of this Paragraph with respect to the profits they receive from the operation of their ships or aircraft.
20 . If such an enterprise has permanent representative offices in a foreign country engaged exclusively in the operation of its ships or aircraft, there is no reason to consider such representative offices in a different way than permanent representative offices of enterprises engaged exclusively in maritime or air transportation.
21 . There is also no difficulty in applying the provisions of Paragraph 1 if the enterprise has a permanent establishment in another State that is not exclusively engaged in maritime or air transport. If his goods are transported on his own ships to a permanent establishment owned by him in the territory of a foreign State, it would be correct to say that no profit earned by the enterprise as a result of operating as its own carrier can be properly taxed in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located. The same should be true even if a permanent establishment maintains installations for the operation of ships or aircraft (for example, cargo berths) or incurs other costs in connection with the transportation of the company's goods (for example, personnel costs). In this case, even if certain functions related to the operation of aircraft and ships in international traffic can be performed by a permanent establishment, profits related to these functions are subject to tax exclusively in the State to which the enterprise belongs. Any expenses or part thereof incurred in the performance of such functions must be deducted in calculating that part of the profit that is not taxable in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, and thus will not reduce the part of the profit attributed to the permanent establishment that may be taxed in that State in accordance with with Article 7.
22 . If ships or aircraft are operated in international traffic, the application of the alternative wording from Paragraph 2 above to the profits derived from such operation should not be affected by the fact that ships or aircraft are operated by a permanent establishment that is not the actual location of the management bodies of the entire enterprise.; Thus, even if such profits can be attributed to the account of a permanent establishment in accordance with Article 7, they are subject to taxation in the State in whose territory the actual location of the management bodies of the enterprise is located (this result is confirmed by Paragraph 4 of Article 7).
Item 2
23 . There are various forms of international cooperation in the field of transportation by sea or by air. In this area, international cooperation is ensured through the conclusion of agreements on mutual commercial activities or other similar agreements that establish certain rules for the distribution of proceeds (or profits) from joint business activities.
24 . In order to clarify the position of the pool participant, the joint venture or the international operating service regarding taxation and to cope with any possible difficulties, the Contracting States may bilaterally add, if necessary, the following:
... but only to that part of the profit thus obtained, which is distributed to the participant in proportion to his share in the joint operation.
25 .[The number has been changed, amendments have been made]
Comments on the Comment
26 . [Number changed, amendments made]
27. [Deleted]
28. Greece and Portugal remain divided on the application of this Article to income from related activities (see paragraphs 4-10.1, 14 and 14.1).
29 . Germany, Greece, Mexico and Turkey remain opposed to the application of the Article to income from domestic passenger or cargo transportation, as well as container transportation (see paragraphs 4, 6, 7 and 9 above).
30. Greece will apply Article 12 to payments from the lease of a ship or aircraft based on a bareboat charter agreement.
Reservations to the Article
31 . Canada, Hungary, Mexico, and New Zealand reserve the right to tax as profits from domestic transportation profits earned from the transportation of passengers or cargo taken on board at one location in their respective country for unloading at another location in the same country. New Zealand also reserves the right to tax profits from other coastal and continental shelf activities as profits from inland transportation.
32 . Latvia reserves the right, in exceptional cases, to apply the rule of permanent representation with respect to profits earned from the operation of ships in international traffic.
33 . Denmark, Norway and Sweden reserve the right to include special provisions regarding the profits generated by the Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS) air transport consortium.
34. [Deleted]
35. In view of its special situation in the field of shipping, Greece will retain its freedom of action with respect to the provisions of the Convention relating to profits from the operation of ships in international traffic.
36. Mexico reserves the right to withhold income tax from the provision of housing.
[Deleted]
37. [Deleted]
38 . Australia reserves the right to tax profits from the transportation of passengers or cargo taken on board at one point in Australia for unloading in Australia.
39 . The United States reserves the right to include within the scope of Paragraph 1 income from the lease of ships and aircraft on a full and bareboat charter basis if the ships or aircraft are operated in international traffic by the lessee, or if the rental income is related to profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic. The United States also reserves the right to include income from the use, maintenance, or rental of containers used in international transportation within the scope of the Paragraph.
40 . Slovakia reserves the right to tax profits from the rental of ships, aircraft, and containers in accordance with Article 12.
41 . Ireland reserves the right to include in the scope of the Article income from the lease of ships or aircraft on the basis of bareboat charter, if the ships or aircraft are operated in international traffic by the lessee, or if the rental income is related to profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic.
42. Turkey reserves the right to expand the scope of the Article to cover road transport and to amend the definition of "international transport" in Article 3 accordingly.
43. Latvia reserves the right to include a provision ensuring that profits from bareboat charter rentals of ships or aircraft, as well as from container rentals, are treated in the same way as income covered by Paragraph 1, if such profits are related to international transportation.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 9
REGARDING TAXATION OF ASSOCIATED ENTERPRISES
1. This Article discusses profit adjustments that can be made for tax purposes if transactions were concluded between associated enterprises (parent and subsidiary companies, as well as companies under common management) on terms other than market conditions. The Committee has spent a lot of time and effort (and continues to do so) studying the conditions for the application of this Article, its consequences, and various techniques that can be used to adjust profits if transactions were concluded on conditions other than market conditions. Its findings are outlined in a report entitled Transfer Pricing Guidelines for International Enterprises and Tax Authorities,1 which is periodically updated to reflect the progress of the Committee's work in this area. The report presents internationally recognized principles and provides guidelines for the application of the “at arm's length" principle, the authoritative expression of which is the Article.
Point 1
2. This Paragraph provides that the tax authorities of a Contracting State may, for the purpose of calculating the tax obligations of associated enterprises, rewrite the accounts of enterprises if, as a result of the special relationship between the enterprises, the accounts do not show the true taxable profits arising in that State. Obviously, in such circumstances, it is advisable to allow an adjustment. The provisions of this Paragraph apply only if special conditions have been established or set between the two enterprises. The rewriting of accounts of associated enterprises is not allowed if transactions between the two enterprises were carried out on the usual commercial terms of the open market (on market terms).
3. As discussed in the report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs on "Thin capitalization",2 there is a relationship between tax agreements and internal regulations on thin capitalization relevant to the scope of the Article. The Committee considers that:
a) The article does not prevent the application of national regulations on thin capitalization, if their effect is to assimilate the borrower's profit to an amount corresponding to the profit that would be obtained in a market situation;
b) The article may be applied not only in determining which interest rate stipulated in the loan agreement is the market rate, but also whether a loan can be considered a prima facie loan, or whether it should be considered as some other type of payment, in particular, a contribution to the authorized capital;
c) the application of rules aimed at solving the problem of "thin" capitalization, as a rule, should not lead to an increase in the taxable profit of the relevant domestic enterprise to a level exceeding the market profit, and this principle should be respected when applying the relevant tax agreements.
4. The question arises whether the special regulations adopted by some countries for transactions between related parties comply with the Convention. For example, the question may arise whether the transfer of the burden of proof or presumptions of any kind, sometimes found in domestic legislation, corresponds to the principle of “at arm's length". A number of countries interpret the Article in such a way that it in no way prevents the adjustment of profits in accordance with national legislation under conditions other than those of the Article, and has the function of raising the principle of “at arm's length" to the level of agreements. In addition, almost all participating countries consider that additional information requirements that would be stricter than the standard ones, or even a shift in the burden of proof, would not constitute discrimination within the meaning of Article 24. However, in some cases, the application of national legislation in some countries may lead to profit adjustments that are inconsistent with the principles of the Article. The Article allows the Contracting States to resolve such situations through appropriate adjustments (see below) and in accordance with the mutual agreement procedure.
____________________
1 The original text of this report was approved by the OECD Council on June 27, 1995. Published in a page format under the heading Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, OECD, Paris, 1995.
2 Approved by the OECD Council on November 26, 1986 and included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(4)-1.
Item 2
5. The rewriting of transactions between associated enterprises in the situation provided for in Paragraph 1 may lead to economic double taxation (taxation of the same income from different persons) if an enterprise of State A, whose profits are being revised upward, will be taxed on the amount of profits that have already been taxed by its associated enterprise in the State B. Paragraph 2 provides that, in these circumstances, State B must make appropriate adjustments to eliminate double taxation.
6. However, it should be noted that the adjustment should not be made automatically in State B simply because profits in State A have increased; the adjustment should only be made if State B believes that the adjusted profit figures correctly reflect what the profit would have been if the transactions had been carried out on market conditions. In other words, this clause cannot be invoked and should not be applied in cases where the profit of one associated enterprise increases to a level higher than that which would have been achieved if it had been correctly calculated on a strictly commercial basis. Thus, State B is obliged to adjust the profits of the dependent company only if it considers that the adjustment made in State A is justified both in principle and in relation to the amount.
6.1 In accordance with the domestic legislation of some countries, under certain circumstances, a taxpayer may be allowed to amend a previously filed tax return in order to adjust the transaction price between associated companies to indicate a price that, in the taxpayer's opinion, is the market price. If they are made in good faith, such adjustments can make it easier for taxpayers to provide taxable income data in accordance with the “at arm's length" principle. However, economic double taxation may occur, for example, if such an adjustment initiated by a taxpayer increases the profits of an enterprise in one Contracting State, but no corresponding adjustment has been made to the profits of the associated enterprise in the other Contracting State. The elimination of such double taxation falls within the scope of Paragraph 2. Indeed, if taxes were levied on increased profits in the first-mentioned State, that State may be considered to have included in the profits of an enterprise of that State and taxed profits in respect of which an enterprise of another State was taxed. In these circumstances, Article 25 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to conduct joint consultations to eliminate double taxation.; The authorized bodies may, accordingly, if necessary, use a mutual agreement procedure to determine whether the initial adjustment meets the conditions of Paragraph 1, and, if so, to determine the amount of the corresponding adjustment to the amount of tax accrued in another State on this profit, in order to eliminate double taxation.
7. The Paragraph does not specifically specify the method by which the adjustment should be made. The OECD member countries use various methods to ensure exemption from double taxation in these circumstances, and in this regard, the Contracting States can bilaterally agree on any specific rules that they wish to include in the Article. For example, some States may prefer a system according to which, if the profit of enterprise X in State A has increased to the level it would have on a commercial basis, the adjustment should be made by restoring the valuation of associated enterprise Y in State B, containing the double-taxed profit, in order to reduce the taxed profit by the appropriate amount.. On the other hand, some other States would prefer to provide that, for the purposes of Article 23, double-taxed profits are treated by an enterprise Y of State B as if they were taxed in State A; accordingly, an enterprise of State B is eligible for exemption in State B in accordance with Article 23 in respect of tax. paid by its associated enterprise in State A.
8. The purpose of this Paragraph is not to address what might be called “secondary adjustments.” Let's assume that an upward revision has been made to the taxable profits of enterprise X in State A in accordance with the principle set out in Paragraph 1, and let's also assume that an adjustment has been made to the profits of enterprise Y in State B in accordance with the principle set out in Paragraph 2. The position has still not been restored exactly to the level it would have had if the transactions had been carried out at market prices, since in fact the money representing the profit to be adjusted is held by enterprise Y, not enterprise X. It can be argued that if pricing was applied based on market conditions, and enterprise X subsequently wished to transfer this profit to enterprise Y, it would do so, for example, in the form of dividends or royalties (if enterprise Y was the parent company of enterprise X), or, for example, in the form of a loan (if enterprise X was the parent company of enterprise Y), and that in these circumstances there could be other tax consequences (for example, the use of withholding tax), depending on the type of income involved and the provisions of the Article relating to such income.
9. These secondary adjustments, which would be required to accurately establish the situation as if it were in the case of transactions on market conditions, depend on the facts of a particular case. It should be noted that none of the provisions of Paragraph 2 prevents the introduction of such secondary adjustments if they are permitted by the domestic legislation of the Contracting States.
10. This Paragraph also leaves open the question of whether there should be a period after which State B will not be required to make an appropriate adjustment to the profits of enterprise Y after the upward revision of the profits of enterprise X in State A. Some States consider that the obligation of State B should be indefinite; in other words, no matter how many years have passed since State A revised the estimates, Enterprise Y should fairly provide the appropriate adjustment in State B. Other States consider that such an indefinite commitment is impractical from a practical point of view. Therefore, in these circumstances, this issue was not addressed in the text of the Article, but the Contracting States may, if they wish, include in bilateral agreements provisions concerning the length of the period during which State B is required to make appropriate adjustments (see paragraphs 39, 40 and 41 of the Commentary to Article 25 on this issue). The Contracting States may also wish to resolve this issue by means of a provision limiting the length of the period during which adjustments may be made in accordance with Paragraph 1; such a solution avoids the economic double taxation that might otherwise arise in the absence of an appropriate adjustment after the initial adjustment. Contracting States wishing to achieve this result may bilaterally agree to include the following Paragraph after Paragraph 2.:
3. A Contracting State shall not include in the profits of an enterprise, and tax accordingly, profits that would have accrued to the enterprise but, by virtue of the conditions specified in paragraph 1, were not so accrued after the expiration of [a period agreed upon bilaterally] from the end of the tax year in which the profits were to be accrued. the company. The provisions of this Paragraph should not apply in cases of fraud, gross negligence, or intentional default.
11. If there is a dispute between the parties concerned regarding the amount and nature of the appropriate adjustment, the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25 should be applied.; The commentary to this Article contains a number of considerations applicable to adjustments to the profits of associated enterprises made on the basis of this Article (in particular, after adjusting transfer prices), and to the corresponding adjustments that must subsequently be made in accordance with Paragraph 2 of the Article (see, in particular, Paragraphs 10, 11, 12, 33, 34, 40 and 41 Comments to Article 25).
12. [Number changed]
13. [Deleted]
14. [Deleted]
Note to the Comment
15. The United States notes that there may be acceptable ways to address thin capitalization cases, in addition to changing the nature of the financial instrument from debt to equity and the nature of the payment from interest to dividend. For example, in appropriate cases, the nature of the instrument (as debt) and the nature of the payment (as interest) may remain unchanged, but the taxing State may defer the deduction of interest paid, which would otherwise be allowed to be taken into account when calculating the borrower's net income.
Reservations to the Article
16. The Czech Republic reserves the right not to include Paragraph 2 in its agreements, but in the course of negotiations it is ready to accept this Paragraph, and at the same time add a third Paragraph limiting the potential corresponding adjustment to cases of fair transactions.
17. [Deleted]
17.1 Italy reserves the right to include in its agreements a provision according to which it will make adjustments in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 9 only in accordance with the procedure provided for in the article on mutual agreement of the relevant agreement.
18. Australia reserves the right to propose a provision stating that if the information available to the authorized body of a Contracting State is insufficient to determine the profits attributed to the enterprise, the authorized body may apply to that enterprise the provisions of the tax legislation of that State for this purpose, with the proviso that this legislation will be applied as far as the information allows. available to the authorized body, in accordance with the principles of this Article.
19. Hungary and Slovenia reserve the right to indicate in Paragraph 2 that an appropriate adjustment will be made only if they consider the initial adjustment to be justified.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 10
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF DIVIDENDS
I. Preliminary remarks
1. "Dividends" usually refers to the distribution of profits to shareholders by companies with limited liability companies,1 limited liability companies, 2 limited liability companies3 or other joint-stock companies.4 In accordance with the laws of the OECD member countries, such joint-stock companies are legal entities with a legal personality independent of all their shareholders. In this regard, they differ from partnerships, since the latter do not have legal personality in most countries.
2. Many States consider that profits from commercial activities carried out by the partnership are profits earned through their own efforts; for them, they represent commercial profits. Thus, these States consider partnerships to be transparent for tax purposes, and partners are usually taxed on their personal share of the partnership's capital and profits.
3. The shareholder has a different position; he is not a trader, and the company's profits do not belong to him; therefore, they cannot be attributed to his account. He is personally taxed only in respect of profits distributed by the company (except for the provisions of the laws of some countries relating to the taxation of retained earnings in some cases). From the shareholders' point of view, dividends represent income from the capital they have provided to the company as its shareholders.
Commentary to the provisions of Article 1
4. Paragraph 1 does not prescribe any principle of taxation of dividends either exclusively in the State of which the beneficiary is a resident, or exclusively in the State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident.
5. In general, taxation of dividends exclusively in the Source State is unacceptable. Moreover, there are some States in which dividends are not taxed at source, although, as a rule, all States tax residents in respect of the dividends they receive from non-resident companies.
6. On the other hand, as a rule, it is impossible to tax dividends exclusively in the State of which the beneficiary is a resident. This would be more consistent with the nature of dividends, which represent investment income, but the assumption that there is any prospect of reaching an agreement that all taxation of dividends at source should be discontinued does not seem realistic.
7. For this reason, Paragraph 1 simply states that dividends may be taxed in the State of which the beneficiary is a resident. The term “paid” has a very broad meaning, since the concept of payment means fulfilling an obligation to place funds at the disposal of a shareholder in accordance with the procedure stipulated by the contract or customs.
8. The Article deals only with dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State, and therefore it does not apply to dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a third State. Dividends paid by a company which is a resident of a Contracting State and credited to the account of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of that State has in the territory of the other Contracting State may be taxed by the first-mentioned State.
______________________
1Sociétés anonymes (Joint stock companies).
2 Sociétés en commandite par actions (Limited partnerships based on shares)
3 Sociétés à responsabilité limitée (Limited liability partnerships).
4 Sociétés de capitaux (Camaraderie representing the kap associations)I.talov
States in accordance with Paragraph 2, but may also be taxed by another State in accordance with Paragraph 1 of Article 7 (see paragraphs 9 and 9.1 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B regarding the exemption from double taxation in such cases).
Item 2
9. Paragraph 2 grants the right to taxation to the State of the source of the dividends, i.e. the State in which the company paying the dividends is resident; however, this right to taxation is significantly limited. According to subparagraph b), the tax rate is limited to 15 percent, which seems to be an acceptable maximum value. A higher rate can hardly be justified, since the source State can already tax the company's profits.
10. On the other hand, a lower rate (5 percent) is explicitly provided for in subparagraph (a) in respect of dividends paid by a subsidiary of its parent company. If a company of one of the States directly owns, for a period of 365 days, including the day of payment of the dividend, a share of at least 25 percent in a company of another State, it would be reasonable that the payment of this dividend by a subsidiary of a foreign parent company should be subject to lower taxes in order to avoid re-taxation and promote international investment. The implementation of this intention depends on the tax treatment of dividends in the State of which the parent company is resident (see paragraphs 49-54 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B).
11. Until 2017, subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2 referred to a company "other than a partnership". This exception has been removed to recognize the fact that if a partnership is considered a company for tax purposes in the State in whose territory it was established, it would be appropriate for another State to provide the benefits of subparagraph (a) to that partnership. Indeed, a legal person or an agreement (for example, a partnership) that is treated as a company for tax purposes is classified as a company in accordance with the definition given in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 3, and if it is a resident of a Contracting State, it is therefore entitled to the benefits provided by subparagraph (a).) Paragraph 2 in respect of dividends paid by a company resident in another State, provided that it directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of that company. This conclusion remains true regardless of the fact that the State of the source of dividends may consider this person or agreement to be transparent for tax purposes. This conclusion is confirmed by the regulation on organizations that are transparent for tax purposes in Paragraph 2 of Article 1.
11.1 This provision also ensures that a portion of dividends received by an organization or agreement that is transparent for tax purposes, considered as income of a participant in that organization or agreement for tax purposes by the State of which that participant is a resident, will be considered a dividend paid to that participant for the purposes of Article 10 (see paragraph 12 of the Commentary to Article 1). If, for example, a company resident in State A pays a dividend to a partnership that State B considers to be a tax-transparent enterprise, the portion of that dividend that State B considers to be the income of a partner resident in State B will, for the purposes of Paragraph 2 of the agreement between States A and B, be considered a dividend paid to a resident of State B. In addition, for the purposes of applying subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2 in such a case, a participant who is a company must be considered the direct owner in proportion to his share in a tax-transparent enterprise or agreement of the portion of the capital of the dividend-paying company that he owns through that organization or agreement, and to determine whether the participant directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying dividends, this part of the capital is added to other parts of this capital, which this participant may directly own in another way. In this case, for the purposes of applying the requirement that at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying dividends must be owned for a period of 365 days, it will be necessary to take into account both the period during which the participant owns the relevant share in a tax-transparent enterprise or agreement, and the period during which where a portion of the capital of the company paying the dividend was in the possession of that enterprise or agreement: if any of the periods does not meet the 365-day period requirement, subparagraph (a) will not apply, and subparagraph (b) will therefore apply to the relevant portion of the dividend. States may clarify the application of subparagraph (a) in these circumstances by adding the provision set out below:
If a dividend paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State is considered, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 1, to be the income of another company that is a resident of the other Contracting States, since that other company is a party to a tax-transparent enterprise or agreement referred to in this Paragraph, that other company must, for the purposes of applying subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2 Articles
10 is considered to be the direct owner of this part of the capital of the company paying the dividend, which is owned by a tax-transparent enterprise or agreement, which corresponds to the share in the capital of this tax-transparent enterprise or agreement, which belongs to this other company.
12. The beneficial ownership requirement was included in Paragraph 2 of Article 10 to clarify the meaning of the words "paid... to the resident", used in Paragraph 1 of the Article. It explains that the source State is not obligated to waive the right to tax income from dividends simply because this income was paid directly to a resident of the State with which the Source State entered into an agreement.
12.1 Since the term "beneficiary owner" was added to eliminate potential difficulties associated with the use of the words "paid... resident" in Paragraph 1, it was intended to be interpreted in this context, and not to mean any technical meaning that it might have in accordance with the domestic legislation of a particular country (in fact, when added to the Paragraph, this term did not have a precise definition in the legislation of many countries). In this regard, the term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense (for example, in the meaning it has under the trust legislation of many common law countries1); rather, it should be understood according to the context, in particular with regard to the words "paid... resident" and taking into account the object and objectives of the Convention, including the prevention of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion.
12.2 If an income item is paid to a resident of the Contracting States acting as an agent or nominee owner, the source State would conflict with the object and purpose of the Convention if it granted a benefit or exemption solely on the basis of the status of a direct recipient of income as a resident of the Contracting States. The direct recipient of income in this situation is classified as a resident, but this status does not lead to the potential occurrence of double taxation, since the recipients are not considered as owners of income for tax purposes in the State of residence.
12.3 The source State would equally conflict with the object and purpose of the Convention by granting a benefit or exemption if a resident of the Contracting States, other than through the agency or nominee holder, acts simply as an intermediary for another person who actually benefits from the relevant income. For this reason, the report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Issues entitled
The "Agreements for the avoidance of double taxation and the use" of intermediary Companies2 conclude that, usually, an intermediary company should not be considered as a beneficiary owner if, although being a formal owner, in practice it has very narrow powers that make it, in relation to the relevant income, simply a fiduciary or a manager acting on behalf of interested parties.
__________________
1 For example, if the trustees of a discretionary trust do not distribute dividends earned during a certain period, these trustees, acting as such (or the trust, if recognized as a separate taxpayer), may constitute beneficial owners of such income for the purposes of Article 10, even if they are not beneficial owners under the relevant legislation. about trusts.
2 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(6)-1.
12.4 In these various examples (agent, nominee holder, intermediary company acting as fiduciary or manager), the direct recipient of the dividend is not the "owner beneficiary", since the recipient's right to use the dividends is limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person. Such an obligation usually follows from the relevant documents, but it can also be established on the basis of facts and circumstances indicating that, in essence, the recipient clearly has no right to use the dividend, without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person. This type of obligation will not include contractual or legal obligations that are independent of receipt of payment by the direct recipient, such as an obligation that is independent of receipt of payment and that is assigned to the direct recipient as a debtor or party to a financial transaction, or a standard distribution obligation used in pension programs and collective investment organizations that have the right to receive benefits under the contract in accordance with the principles of Paragraphs 22-48 of the Commentary to Article 1. If the recipient of the dividend has the right to use the dividend without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person, he is the "owner of the beneficiary" of this dividend. It should also be noted that Article 10 refers to the beneficial owner of the dividend, and not the owner of the shares, which in some cases may be different.
12.5 The fact that the recipient of the dividend is considered to be the actual owner of this dividend does not mean, however, that the taxation restriction provided for in Paragraph 2 should be applied automatically. This tax restriction should not be provided in cases of abuse of this provision (see also paragraph 22 below). The provisions of Article 29 and the principles set out in the section on "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 will be applied to prevent abuse, including situations of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements when the recipient is the owner of the beneficiary of dividends. Although the concept of "beneficiary owner" addresses several forms of tax evasion (for example, involving the introduction of a recipient who is obligated to transfer dividends to someone else), it does not address other forms of abuse, for example, certain types of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements that are governed by these provisions and principles, and therefore should not be considered in any way limiting the application of other approaches to the consideration of such cases.
12.6 The above explanations regarding the meaning of the term "beneficial owner" clearly show that the meaning given to this term in the context of the Article needs to be distinguished from the other meaning in which this term has been used in the context of other instruments1 considering the identification of persons (usually individuals) who carry out real
_____________________________
1 See, for example, the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, International Standards on Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Financing the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction – FATF Recommendations (OECD-FATF, Paris, 2012), where
2 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(6)-1.
12.4 In these various examples (agent, nominee holder, intermediary company acting as fiduciary or manager), the direct recipient of the dividend is not the "owner beneficiary", since the recipient's right to use the dividends is limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person. Such an obligation usually follows from the relevant documents, but it can also be established on the basis of facts and circumstances indicating that, in essence, the recipient clearly has no right to use the dividend, without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person. This type of obligation will not include contractual or legal obligations that are independent of receipt of payment by the direct recipient, such as an obligation that is independent of receipt of payment and that is assigned to the direct recipient as a debtor or party to a financial transaction, or a standard distribution obligation used in pension programs and collective investment organizations that have the right to receive benefits under the contract in accordance with the principles of Paragraphs 22-48 of the Commentary to Article 1. If the recipient of the dividend has the right to use the dividend without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person, he is the "owner of the beneficiary" of this dividend. It should also be noted that Article 10 refers to the beneficial owner of the dividend, and not the owner of the shares, which in some cases may be different.
12.5 The fact that the recipient of the dividend is considered to be the actual owner of this dividend does not mean, however, that the taxation restriction provided for in Paragraph 2 should be applied automatically. This tax restriction should not be provided in cases of abuse of this provision (see also paragraph 22 below). The provisions of Article 29 and the principles set out in the section on "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 will be applied to prevent abuse, including situations of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements when the recipient is the owner of the beneficiary of dividends. Although the concept of "beneficiary owner" addresses several forms of tax evasion (for example, involving the introduction of a recipient who is obligated to transfer dividends to someone else), it does not address other forms of abuse, for example, certain types of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements that are governed by these provisions and principles, and therefore should not be considered in any way limiting the application of other approaches to the consideration of such cases.
12.6 The above explanations regarding the meaning of the term "beneficial owner" clearly show that the meaning given to this term in the context of the Article needs to be distinguished from the other meaning in which this term has been used in the context of other instruments1 considering the identification of persons (usually individuals) who carry out real
_____________________________
1 See, for example, the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, International Standards on Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Financing the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction – FATF Recommendations (OECD-FATF, Paris, 2012), where
The international anti-money laundering standards are described in detail and the following definition of beneficial owner is provided (on page 110): “an individual(s) who are the real owners or exercise real control over the client and/or the person on whose behalf the transaction is being conducted. This concept also includes persons who exercise real effective control over a legal entity or an agreement.” Similarly, in the 2001 report The OECD Coordination Group on Corporate Governance, "Behind the Corporate Veil: The Use of Corporate Structures for Illegal Purposes" (OECD, Paris, 2001), contains the following definition of beneficial ownership (on page 14):
In this report, "beneficial ownership" means the actual beneficial ownership or share of an individual. In some situations, determining the beneficial owner may involve searching through various intermediary organizations or individuals until the real owner, who is an individual, is found. In relation to corporations, ownership belongs to the shareholders or participants. In the case of partnerships, the shares belong to full and limited partners. In the case of trusts and foundations, beneficial ownership refers to the beneficiaries, which may also include the founder or founder.
control over legal entities or assets. This other meaning of the term "beneficial owner" cannot be applied in the context of the Article. Indeed, this meaning, which refers to individuals (i.e. people), cannot be consistent with the direct wording of subparagraph 2 (a), which refers to a situation where the company is the owner beneficiary of the dividend. In the context of Article 10, the term "beneficial owner" is intended to address difficulties arising from the use of the word "paid" in relation to dividends, rather than difficulties related to ownership of shares in the company paying those dividends. For this reason, in the context of this Article, it would be inappropriate to consider the meaning developed to designate persons who exercise "real effective control over a legal entity or an agreement."1
_________________________
1 See the definition of the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering in the previous note.
12.7 In accordance with other conditions established by the Article and other provisions of the Convention, the limitation of taxation in the Source State is allowed if an intermediary, for example, an agent or nominee holder located in a Contracting State or a third State, is located between the recipient and the payer, but the beneficiary owner is a resident of another Contracting State (in the text of the Model in 1995 Amendments were made in 2014 to clarify this point, which is the consistent position of all participating countries).
13. The tax rates set by the Article for taxes in the Source State are the maximum rates. In the course of bilateral negotiations, States can agree on lower rates, or even taxation exclusively in the State of which the recipient is a resident. The reduction of the rates provided for in Paragraph 2 applies exclusively to the taxation of dividends, and not to the taxation of the profits of the company paying the dividends.
13.1 In accordance with the domestic legislation of many States, pension funds and similar organizations are generally exempt from taxes on their investment income. In order to achieve a neutral attitude towards domestic and foreign investments of these organizations, some States bilaterally stipulate that this income, including dividends received by such an organization resident in another State, should be exempt from taxation on the basis of the source principle. States wishing to do so may bilaterally agree on a provision developed in accordance with Paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18.
13.2 Similarly, some States refrain from taxing dividends paid to other States and to some of their wholly owned enterprises, at least if such dividends are derived from government activities. Some States may grant such an exemption in accordance with their interpretation of the principle of sovereign immunity (see paragraphs 52 and 53 of the Commentary to Article 1); others may do so in accordance with the provisions of their domestic legislation. States wishing to do so may, within the framework of their bilateral agreements, confirm or clarify the scope of such exemptions, or grant such an exemption in cases where it would otherwise be unavailable. This can be done by including an additional Paragraph in the Article as follows::
Notwithstanding the provisions of Paragraph 2, dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in the other Contracting State if the beneficial owner of the dividends is that State or its administrative-territorial unit or local authority.
14. The two Contracting States may also, in the course of bilateral negotiations, agree on a share of ownership that will be lower than that specified in the Article. A smaller share, for example, is justified in cases where the State of which the parent company is a resident, in accordance with its domestic legislation, grants such a company an exemption in respect of dividends received from owning a share of less than 25 percent in a non-resident subsidiary.
15. In subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2, the term "capital" is used in relation to the taxation regime of dividends, i.e. the distribution of profits to shareholders. The use of this term in this context implies that, for the purposes of subparagraph (a), it should be used in the sense in which it was used for distribution purposes to the shareholder (in the specific case, the parent company).
a) Thus, as a rule, the term "capital" in subparagraph (a) should be understood in the same way as it is understood in corporate law. Other elements, in particular reserves, should not be taken into account.
b) Capital, as it is understood in corporate law, should be indicated in the form of the nominal value of all shares, which in most cases will be shown as capital in the company's balance sheet.
c) There is no need to take into account differences related to different classes of issued shares (ordinary shares, preferred shares, shares with multiple voting rights, shares without voting rights, bearer shares, registered shares, etc.), since such differences relate more to the nature of the shareholder's rights than to the extent of his ownership of capital.
d) When a loan or other contribution is not strictly capital in accordance with corporate law, but on the basis of domestic legislation or established practice ("thin capitalization", or absorption of a loan by equity), the income received in relation to it is considered as a dividend in accordance with Article 10, the amount of such loan or the contribution is also accounted for as “capital” within the meaning of subparagraph (A).
e) In the case of organizations that do not have capital in the meaning of this term used in corporate law, for the purposes of subparagraph (a), capital should be understood as the total amount of all contributions to the organization accounted for for profit-sharing purposes.
In bilateral negotiations, the Contracting States may deviate from the criterion
the "capital" used in subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2, and instead apply the criterion of "voting rights".
16. Until 2017, Paragraph 17 of the Commentary to the Article stipulated that “[the reduction provided for in subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2 should not be granted in cases of abuse of this provision, for example, if a company with a share of less than 25 percent increased its share shortly before the dividends became due, mainly to ensure the advantages provided by the above-mentioned provision, or otherwise, if the availability of a qualified share was organized primarily for the purpose of obtaining such a reduction.” Such abuses were addressed in the final report on the Action 62 of the OECD/G20 Draft On the dilution of the tax base and the withdrawal of profits from taxation. As a result of this report, subparagraph (a) was amended to limit its application in situations where the company receiving dividends directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying dividends for a period of 365 days, including the day of payment of dividends. However, the subparagraph also stipulates that when calculating this period, changes in ownership directly related to the reorganization of the company, such as a merger or separation, should not be taken into account. In addition, the addition of Article 29 will regulate other abuses aimed at obtaining the benefits provided by subparagraph (a).
17. According to the domestic legislation of some States, it is possible to make portfolio investments in shares of companies in a given State through certain collective investment organizations established in that State that do not pay tax on investment income. In such cases, a non-resident company owning at least 25 percent of the capital of such an organization may be provided with a lower rate provided for in Paragraph
a) in respect of dividends paid by that organization, even if that organization does not own at least 25 percent of the capital of any company from which it receives dividends. States for which this is a problem can prevent such an outcome by including in Paragraph
______________________
1 OECD (2015), Prevention of contractual benefits in inappropriate circumstances, Action 6 - Final Report 2015, en.OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241695-en
2 the rule formulated in the following lines (see also paragraph 67.4 below, applicable to distributions made by real estate investment funds): Subparagraph (a) should not apply to dividends paid by a company that is a resident of [the name of the State], which is [a description of the type of collective investment organization to which this rule should apply].
18. Paragraph 2 does not say anything about the taxation regime in the source State. Thus, the State has the right to apply its own laws, and, in particular, to tax either by withholding tax from the source of income payment, or by using an individual assessment.
19. The Paragraph does not address the issue of procedures. Each State should be able to apply the procedure provided for by its legislation. It can either immediately limit its tax to the rates provided for in the Article, or tax it in full and make a refund (see, however, paragraph 109 of the Commentary to Article 1). Potential abuses arising in connection with situations where dividends paid by a company resident in a Contracting State are credited to the account of a permanent establishment that an enterprise of another State has in the territory of a third State are dealt with in Paragraph 8 of Article 29. Other issues arise in connection with tripartite cases (see paragraph 71 of the Commentary to Article 24).
20. In addition, the Paragraph does not specify whether the benefit in the Source State should be due to the fact that dividends are subject to taxation in the State of Residence. This issue can be resolved through bilateral negotiations.
21. The article does not contain provisions on how the State of which the beneficiary is a resident should provide for taxation in the State of the source of dividends. This issue is addressed in Articles 23 A and 23 B.
22. The OECD/G20 draft On the Dilution of the Tax Base and the Withdrawal of Profits from Taxation, and, in particular, the final report on Action 61 prepared under this project, examined a number of abuses related to such cases as the following: the beneficial owner of dividends arising in the territory of a Contracting State is a company resident in another Of a Contracting State; all or part of its capital belongs to shareholders residing outside that other State; its business does not consist in distributing its profits in the form of dividends; and it enjoys a preferential tax regime (private investment company, basic company). In addition to the fact that Article 29, which was included in the Convention as a result of the submission of the final report on Action 6, addresses aspects of this case related to the abuse of provisions of international tax agreements, States wishing to waive the benefits of Article 10 for dividends that enjoy preferential tax treatment in the State of residence may consider including their agreements include provisions similar to those described in paragraphs 82-100 of the Commentary to Article 1.
Point 3
23. Due to the huge differences between the laws of the OECD member countries, it is impossible to give a complete and exhaustive definition of "dividends". Consequently, the definition simply mentions examples that can be found in the laws of most member States and which, in any case, are not interpreted differently in them. After the enumeration, the general formula follows. During the revision of the 1963 draft Convention, a thorough study was conducted in order to find a solution unrelated to domestic legislation. As a result of this study, it was concluded that, given the still existing differences between member countries in the field of corporate law and tax law, it is not possible to develop a definition of the concept of dividends, independent of domestic legislation. The Contracting States may, in the framework of bilateral negotiations, take into account the specifics of their
1 OECD (2015), Prevention of contractual benefits in inappropriate circumstances, Action 6 - Final Report 2015, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241695-en
to agree on the inclusion of other payments of companies covered by the Article in the definition of "dividends".
24. The concept of dividends mainly concerns distributions made by companies within the meaning of subparagraph (b) of Paragraph 1 of Article 3. Therefore, the definition refers primarily to the distribution of profits, the ownership of which is represented by shares, that is, shares in a limited liability company (joint stock company). This definition includes in the concept of shares all securities issued by companies that have the right to participate in the profits of companies that are not debt claims.; These are, for example, shares with the right to receive a dividend or the right to receive dividends, founding shares or other profit-sharing rights. Of course, in bilateral conventions, this list can be adapted to the legal situation in the respective Contracting States. In particular, this may be necessary in relation to income from shares with the right to receive a dividend and founding shares. On the other hand, debt claims participating in profits are not included in this category (see paragraph 19 of the Commentary to Article 11); Similarly, interest on convertible bonds is not considered a dividend.
25. Article 10 deals not only with dividends as such, but also with interest on loans, since the lender actually shares the risks to which the company is exposed, i.e. when the payment largely depends on the success or failure of the business of the enterprise. Thus, Articles 10 and 11 do not prohibit treating this type of interest as dividends in accordance with national thin-cap regulations applicable in the borrower's country. The question of whether the depositor of the loan shares the risks that the company assumes should be determined on a case-by-case basis, taking into account all the circumstances, for example, listed below:
—the loan significantly exceeds any other contribution to the company's capital (or was taken to replace a significant part of the lost capital) and is largely not comparable to the assets being repaid.;
—the lender will participate in any profits of the company;
—repayment of the loan is subordinated to the claims of other creditors or the payment of dividends;
—the amount or payment of interest will depend on the company's profits;
—the loan agreement does not contain fixed provisions regarding repayment by a certain date.
26. In accordance with the legislation of many states, participation in a limited liability company is equivalent to having shares. Similarly, the distribution of profits by cooperative societies is usually considered as dividends.
27. The distribution of profits by partnerships does not constitute dividends within the meaning of the definition, except in cases where partnerships in the territory of the State where their actual governing bodies are located are subject to a tax regime largely similar to that applied to companies with limited liability by shares (for example, in Belgium, Portugal and Spain, as well as in France regarding the distributions of commanditaires (contributing partner) to sociétés en commandite simple (simple limited partnership). On the other hand, clarifications in bilateral conventions may be required in cases where the tax legislation of a Contracting State gives the owner of shares in a company the right to choose taxation as a partner in a partnership in certain circumstances, or, conversely, gives the partner in the partnership the right to choose taxation as the owner of shares in the company.
28. Payments considered as dividends may include not only the distribution of profits by resolution of the annual general meetings of shareholders, but also other payments in the form of money or cash equivalents, for example, bonus shares, bonuses, profits from liquidation or redemption of shares (see paragraph 31 of the Commentary to Article 13) and disguised distribution of profits. The benefits provided for in the Article apply as long as the State of which the paying company is a resident taxes such payments as residents. It does not matter whether any such benefits are paid out of the current profits earned by the company, or whether they are derived, for example, from reserves, that is, profits from previous financial years. Usually, dividends are not considered payments made by a company that lead to a reduction in membership rights, for example, payments representing capital refunds in any form are not considered dividends.
29. As a rule, the benefits that participation in the company entitles are available exclusively to the shareholders themselves. However, if some of these benefits are available to non-shareholders, as described in corporate law, they may constitute dividends if:
— the legal relationship between such persons and the company is equivalent to a share in the company ("hidden shares"); and
— the persons receiving such payments are closely related to the shareholder; this is the case, for example, when the recipient is a relative of the shareholder or is a company belonging to the same group as the company holding the shares.
30. If the shareholder and the person receiving such benefits are residents of two different States with which the Source State has concluded agreements, there may be disagreement as to which of these agreements should apply. A similar problem may arise when the Source State has entered into an agreement with one of the States, but not with the other. However, in this case, a conflict arises that may affect other types of income, and its solution can be found only in the case of an agreement within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure.
Item 4
31. Some States consider that dividends, interest and royalties arising from sources in their territory and payable to individuals or legal entities who are residents of other States are outside the scope of an agreement adopted to prevent their taxation both in the source State and the State of which the beneficiary is a resident, if the beneficiary has permanent residence. representation in the first State. Paragraph 4 is not based on the concept that is sometimes referred to as the “force of attraction of a permanent mission.” It does not provide that dividends received by a resident of a Contracting State from a source located in another State should, by virtue of a kind of legal presumption, or even fiction, relate to a permanent establishment that this resident may have in the latter State, so that the said State will not be obliged to limit its taxation in such a case. This paragraph only provides that in the Source State, dividends are taxed as part of the profits of a permanent establishment owned by a beneficiary who is a resident of another State if they are paid in respect of the assets of the permanent establishment or are otherwise actually related to that establishment. In this case, Paragraph 4 exempts the State of the source of dividends from any restrictions in accordance with the Article. The above clarifications correspond to the clarifications contained in the Commentary to Article 7.
32. It was suggested that this Clause could lead to abuse through the transfer of shares to permanent missions established solely for this purpose in countries that offer preferential treatment in respect of dividend income. Apart from the fact that the provisions of Article 29 (and, in particular, Paragraph 8 of this Article) and the principles set out in the section "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 usually prevent such illegal transactions, it should be recognized that a particular location can constitute a permanent establishment only if it is carried out commercial activity, and as explained below, the requirement that stock ownership be "actually linked" to such a place requires more, rather than simply registering the ownership of shares in the books of a permanent mission for accounting purposes.
32.1 The share in respect of which dividends are paid is actually linked to the permanent establishment and, therefore, is part of its production assets if the "economic" ownership of the share is transferred to this permanent establishment in accordance with the principles developed in the Committee's report entitled Attribution of profits to permanent missions (see, in particular, paragraphs 72-97 of Part I of the report) for the purposes of
___________________________
1 Attribution of profits to the account of permanent Missions, OECD, Paris, 2010
application of Paragraph 2 of Article 7. In the context of this Paragraph, "economic" ownership of a share means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of an individual enterprise, with associated benefits and burdens (for example, the right to dividends related to ownership of a share and potential gains or losses from an increase or decrease in the value of the share).
32.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether the share is actually linked to the permanent establishment should take into account the recommendations set out in Part IV of the Committee's report on whether income or profit from this share is taken into account when determining the income of the permanent establishment from the amount of investment assets attributed to its account (see, in particular, Paragraphs 165 - 170 of Part IV). These recommendations are of a general nature, therefore, the tax authorities should consider the possibility of applying a flexible and pragmatic approach that would take into account the reasonable and consistent application of these recommendations by the enterprise in order to identify specific assets that are actually associated with a permanent establishment.
Item 5
33. This Article deals only with dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State to a resident of another State. However, some States tax not only dividends paid by companies that are their residents, but also distributions of profits made on their territory by non-resident companies. Of course, each State has the right to tax profits arising on its territory, which were received by non-resident companies, in the cases provided for in the Convention (in particular, in Article 7). Shareholders of such companies should not be taxed at any rate, except in cases where they are residents of the State, and thus naturally fall under its tax sovereignty.
34. Paragraph 5 excludes the extraterritorial taxation of dividends, i.e. the practice according to which States tax dividends distributed by a non-resident company only because the corporate profits from which the distributions are made were received on their territory (for example, through a permanent representative office located there). Of course, the issue of extraterritorial taxation does not arise if the country of the source of corporate profits taxes dividends for the reason that they are paid to a shareholder who is a resident of that State or a permanent establishment located in that State.
35. Moreover, it can be argued that such a provision is not intended and cannot lead to the fact that the State will not be able to impose withholding tax on dividends distributed by foreign companies if they are cashed out on its territory. Indeed, in this case, the criterion of tax liability is the fact of payment of dividends, and not the origin of corporate profits intended for distribution. However, if a person cashing dividends in a Contracting State is a resident of the other Contracting State (of which the distributing company is a resident), he may, in accordance with Article 21, receive an exemption or refund of withholding tax in the first-mentioned State. Similarly, if the recipient of dividends is a resident of a third State that has concluded a double taxation agreement with the State in whose territory the dividends are being cashed, he may, in accordance with Article 21, receive an exemption or refund of withholding tax in the latter-mentioned State.
36. Paragraph 5 also stipulates that non-resident companies should not be subject to special taxes on retained earnings.
37. As confirmed in Paragraph 3 of Article 1, Paragraph 5 cannot be interpreted as preventing the State of which the taxpayer is a resident from taxing this taxpayer in accordance with its legislation on controlled foreign companies, as well as other regulations having a similar effect with respect to profits that have not been distributed by a foreign company. Moreover, it should be noted that the Clause is limited to taxation at source, and thus has no relation to taxation at the place of residence in accordance with such legislation or regulations. In addition, the Paragraph deals only with the taxation of the company, not the shareholder.
38. The application of such legislation or regulations may, however, complicate the application of Article 23. If income were attributed to the taxpayer, then each income item would have to be treated in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Convention (commercial profits, interest, royalties). If the amount is considered a conditional dividend, then obviously it was received from the base company, thus representing income from that company's country. Even in this case, it is unclear whether the taxable amount should be considered as a dividend within the meaning of Article 10 or as "other income" within the meaning of Article 21. According to some of these laws or regulations, the amount to be taxed is treated as a dividend, as a result of which it is also subject to the tax exemption provided for in the tax agreement, for example, the exemption related to membership. It is doubtful that this is required by Convention. If the country of residence believes this is not the case, it can be accused of impeding the normal functioning of the membership exemption by taxing the dividend in advance (in the form of a "conditional dividend").
39. In cases where the dividends are actually distributed by the underlying company, the provisions of the bilateral agreement regarding dividends should be applied in the usual way, since there is income from dividends as defined in the agreement. Thus, the country of the base company can tax the dividends at source. The country in which the shareholder is resident will apply the usual methods to eliminate double taxation (i.e. the provision of tax relief or tax exemption). This means that with respect to withholding tax levied on a dividend, the benefit must be provided in the country where the shareholder is resident, even if the distributed profit (dividend) was taxed years earlier in accordance with the legislation on controlled foreign companies or other rules of a similar effect. However, the obligation to provide benefits in this case is not indisputable. As a rule, dividends as such are exempt from taxation (since they have already been taxed in accordance with the relevant legislation or regulations) and it could be argued that there are no grounds for granting a tax benefit. On the other hand, achieving the objective of the agreement would be difficult if the provision of tax relief could be avoided simply by waiting for the taxation of dividends in accordance with the opposing legislation. The general principle outlined above suggests that a benefit should be granted, although the details may depend on the technical specifics of the relevant legislation or regulations and the system for offsetting foreign taxes against domestic taxes, as well as the specific case (for example, the time elapsed since the "conditional dividend" was taxed). Nevertheless, taxpayers who resort to artificial arrangements are taking risks from which the tax authorities cannot fully protect them.
III. The influence of the peculiarities of the domestic legislation of individual countries
40. The laws of some countries aim to avoid or mitigate economic double taxation, i.e. the simultaneous taxation of company profits at the company level and dividends at the shareholder level. This can be achieved using various methods.:
—Corporate income tax on distributed profits may be levied at a lower rate than on retained earnings;
—a benefit may be provided when calculating a shareholder's personal tax;
dividends can only be taxed once, distributed profits are not taxed at the company level.
The Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs examined whether the specifics of the tax legislation of the member States justify decisions other than those contained in the Model Convention.
A. Dividends distributed to individuals
41. Unlike the concept of legal double taxation, which usually has a fairly precise meaning, the concept of economic double taxation is less specific. Some States do not recognize the validity of this concept, while others, of which there are many more, do not consider it necessary to eliminate economic double taxation at the state level (dividends distributed by resident companies to resident shareholders). Therefore, since the concept of economic double taxation is not clearly defined enough to serve as a basis for analysis, it seems appropriate to explore the problem from a more general economic point of view, i.e. from the point of view of the impact that various systems of mitigation of such double taxation may have on the international movement of capital. To this end, it is necessary, in particular, to find out what distortions and differences can create different national systems.; However, it is also necessary to take into account the implications for the budgets of States and effective financial control, not forgetting the principle of reciprocity underlying each agreement. When considering all these aspects, it became obvious that the burden of corporate income tax cannot be completely overlooked.
1. States using the classical system
42. The Committee recognized that economic double taxation should not be eliminated at the international level if it has not been eliminated at the national level. Therefore, he believes that in relations between two States with a classical system, that is, States that do not grant exemption from economic double taxation, the corresponding levels of corporate income tax in the Contracting States should not affect the withholding tax rate on dividends in the Source State (the rate limited to 15 percent in accordance with the subparagraph b) of Paragraph 2 of Article 10). Consequently, the solution recommended in the Model Convention remains fully applicable in this case.
2. States that apply a corporate income tax with two rates
43. These States levy corporate income taxes at different rates at different rates depending on what the company does with its profits: a high rate is set for any retained earnings, and a lower rate is set for distributed profits.
44. None of these States, in the course of negotiations on agreements for the avoidance of double taxation, has obtained, on the basis of its double corporate income tax rate, the right to levy withholding tax of more than 15 percent (see subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of the Article
10) in respect of dividends paid by its companies to a shareholder who is a resident individual of another State.
45. The Committee considered whether such a State (State B) should be recognized as having the right to levy withholding tax in excess of 15 percent on dividends distributed by its companies to residents of a State with a classical system (State A), provided that the excess in excess of 15 percent, which would be intended to offset with respect to the relevant shareholder, the effect of a lower corporate income tax rate on the distributed profits of companies in State B will not be counted against the tax payable by the shareholder in State A, of which he is a resident.
46. Most of the participating countries believe that the average level of corporate income tax should be taken into account in State B, and that such an average level should be considered as an analogue of the levy levied in the form of a flat-rate tax on companies resident in State A. In addition, the collection by State B of additional withholding tax on a source of income for which no benefit has been granted in State A would create double discrimination: on the one hand, dividends distributed by a company resident in State B will be subject to higher taxes when distributed to residents of State A than when distributed to residents of State B, and, On the other hand, a resident of State A would pay a higher personal tax on dividends from State B than on his dividends from State A. Therefore, the idea of a "balancing tax" was not accepted by the Committee.
3. States granting exemption at the shareholder level
47. In these States, a company is taxed in respect of its total profits, both distributed and undistributed, and dividends are taxed by a resident shareholder (who is an individual); the latter, however, is eligible for an exemption, usually in the form of a tax benefit, in respect of his personal tax, on the basis of that, at least in the normal way, dividends were already taxed on company profits as part of the company's profits.
48. The domestic legislation of these States does not provide for the extension of tax benefits to the international sphere. Benefits can only be granted to residents and only in respect of dividends from domestic sources. Nevertheless, as indicated below, some of the States in a number of conventions have extended the right to tax benefits provided for in their legislation to residents of another Contracting State.
49. In many States that grant an exemption at the shareholder level, a resident shareholder receives a benefit to confirm that the profits from which the dividends are paid have already been taxed by the company. A resident shareholder is taxed in respect of his dividend, which is subject to a tax benefit; this benefit is offset against the tax payable and may be eligible for a refund. In some agreements on the avoidance of double taxation, some countries applying this system have agreed to extend benefits to shareholders who are residents of another Contracting State. Although most of the States that have agreed to such an extension of benefits have done so on a reciprocal basis, some countries have concluded agreements in which they unilaterally extend preferential benefits to residents of another Contracting State.
50. Some States that also provide benefits at the shareholder level require that, according to their systems, corporate income tax remains generally a true corporate income tax in that it is levied solely based on the situation in the company, without any consideration of the identity and residence of the shareholder, as well as that, if accrued in this way, it would be intended for the Ministry of Finance. The tax benefit provided to the shareholder is intended to mitigate his personal tax obligations, and in no way represents an adjustment to the company's tax. Therefore, a refund is not provided if the tax benefit exceeds this personal tax.
51. The Committee was unable to reach a consensus on whether the State systems mentioned in paragraph 50 above demonstrated a fundamental difference that could justify different decisions at the international level.
52. Some member countries were of the opinion that there was no such fundamental difference. This opinion leads to the conclusion that the States mentioned in Paragraph 50 should agree to extend the tax relief to non-resident shareholders, at least on a reciprocal basis, in the same way as some of the States mentioned in Paragraph 49. Such a decision usually ensures neutrality with respect to dividends distributed by companies in these countries, with the same treatment given to resident and non-resident shareholders. On the other hand, with respect to shareholders who are residents of a Contracting State (in particular, a State with a classical system), it will encourage investments in a State that provides benefits at the shareholder level, since residents of the first State would receive a tax benefit (in fact, a refund of corporate income tax) on dividends from another State, while while they did not receive any in respect of dividends in their own country. However, these consequences are similar to those that arise between a State applying a double-rate corporate income tax and a State with a classical system, or between two States with a classical system, one of which applies a lower corporate income tax rate than the other (paragraphs 42 and 43-46 above).
53. On the other hand, many participating countries emphasized the fact that determining the true nature of the tax benefit provided under the systems of the States mentioned in Paragraph 50 above indicates a simple reduction in the personal income tax of a shareholder in recognition of the fact that his dividend usually already includes the company's income tax. The tax benefit is provided once and for all (forfaitaire), and therefore is not in exact proportion to the actual income tax of the company, corresponding to the profits from which the dividends are paid. A refund is not provided if the tax benefit exceeds the personal income tax.
54. Since the benefit is not in fact a refund of corporate income tax, but rather a reduction in personal income tax, the issue of extending the benefit to non-resident shareholders who are not subject to personal income tax in their respective countries is not taken into account. Nevertheless, on the other hand, based on this reasoning, the question deserves attention whether States providing benefits at the shareholder level should be exempt from personal income tax levied on resident shareholders in respect of foreign dividends. In this regard, it should be noted that the answer will be yes if we consider the issue from the point of view of neutrality regarding the source of dividends; otherwise, residents of these States will be invited to purchase shares in their own country, and not abroad. However, such an extension of tax benefits would contradict the principle of reciprocity: thus, the corresponding State would not only unilaterally incur budget losses (allowing the application of tax benefits in excess of withholding tax levied in another State), but would also do so without any economic compensation, since it would not stimulate residents of another State. A State may purchase shares on its own territory.
55. To answer these objections, one could, among other possibilities, assume that the Source State, which would collect corporate income tax on dividends distributed by resident companies, should bear the cost of tax benefits that would allow the State providing benefits at the shareholder level by transferring funds to this State. However, since States are unlikely to approve of such transfers, this would be easier to achieve through a “composite” arrangement, according to which the source State would waive all withholding taxes on dividends paid to residents of another State, and the latter would then provide a non-withholding tax of 15 percent for its own tax. (abolished in the Source State), and a tax benefit similar to the one it provides in respect of dividends from an internal source.
56. When everything is carefully thought out, it seems that the problem can only be solved through bilateral negotiations, where it is possible to better assess the advantages and disadvantages that each Contracting State receives from using the Convention.
57. [Deleted]
58. [Deleted]
B. Dividends distributed to companies
59. The above comments on dividends paid to individuals usually apply to dividends paid to companies that own less than 25% of the capital of the company paying the dividends. Consideration of dividends paid to collective investment organizations raises special issues addressed in Paragraphs 22 to 48 of the Commentary to Article 1.
60. With regard to dividends paid to companies that own at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying the dividends, the Committee examined the extent to which the taxation systems of specific companies referred to in paragraphs 42 and below apply to the taxation of dividends paid by a subsidiary.
61. Various opinions were expressed during the discussion. Opinions differ even when the discussion is limited to taxation of subsidiaries and parent companies. They differ even more if the discussion takes into account more general economic considerations and affects the taxation of shareholders of the parent company.
62. In their bilateral conventions, the States adopted various decisions that were motivated by economic goals and the specifics of the legal situation in these States, budgetary considerations, as well as a number of other factors. Accordingly, no generally accepted principles have emerged. Nevertheless, the Committee reviewed the situation with more widespread corporate tax systems.
1. The classical system in the State of the subsidiary (Paragraph 42)
63. The provisions of the Convention were developed for application in cases where the State in which the distributing company is resident has a so-called "classical" company taxation system, namely, a system in which distributed profits do not give the right to receive any benefits at the company or shareholder level (except for the purpose of avoiding re-taxation of dividends between companies).
2. The two-rate corporate income tax system in the State of the subsidiary
(Paragraphs 43-46)
64. States of this type charge companies a tax on distributed profits at a lower rate than on retained earnings, which reduces the company's tax burden on profits distributed by a subsidiary of its parent company. In view of this situation, most of these States, in accordance with their agreements, have set withholding tax rates at 10 or 15 percent, and in some cases even over 15 percent. The Committee was unable to reach an opinion on this issue, the solution of which remains for bilateral negotiations.
3. Imputation system in the State of the subsidiary (Paragraphs 47 et seq.)
65. In such States, the company is taxed in respect of all its profits, both distributed and undistributed; shareholders who are residents of the State of which the distributing company itself is resident are taxed on the dividends distributed by it, but receive a tax benefit, given the fact that the distributed profits were taxed at the company level.
66. The question was considered whether States of this kind should extend the benefits of tax benefits to shareholders of parent companies that are residents of another State, or even provide tax benefits directly to such parent companies. The Committee was unable to reach an opinion on this issue, the solution of which remains for bilateral negotiations.
67. If in such a system profits, both distributed and undistributed, are taxed at the same rate, the system does not differ from the "classical" one at the level of the distributing company. Consequently, the State of which the subsidiary is a resident may levy withholding tax only at the rate provided for in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2.
IV. Distributions from real estate investment trusts
67.1 In many States, most portfolio investments in real estate are made through real estate investment trusts (REITs). A REIT can be broadly described as a company with a wide range of shareholders, a trust, or a contractual or fiduciary arrangement that generates income primarily through long-term investments in real estate, distributes most of its income annually, and does not pay income tax on income related to real estate distributed in this way. The fact that the REIT does not pay tax on such income is related to tax regulations that provide for a uniform level of taxation for investors in the REIT.
67.2 The importance and globalization of investments in and through REITs has led the Committee on Fiscal Affairs to examine tax arrangements arising from such investments. The results of this work are reflected in the report entitled "Issues of tax agreements related to REITs."1
67.3 One of the issues discussed in the report is the tax arrangement regime for cross-border distributions through REITs. In the case of a small investor in a REIT, he has no control over the real estate acquired by the REIT and has no connection to that property. Despite the fact that the REIT itself will not pay tax on its distributed income, it may therefore be appropriate to consider that such an investor did not invest in real estate, but rather simply invested in the company, and should be considered as receiving a portfolio dividend. This approach will also reflect the mixed features of REIT investments, which combine features of both stocks and bonds. In contrast, a larger investor in a REIT will have a more specific interest in the real estate acquired by the REIT; for this investor, an investment in the REIT may be considered as a substitute for an investment in the property that is the underlying asset of the REIT. In this situation, it would be inappropriate to limit taxation based on the principle of the source of distributions from the REIT, since the REIT itself will not pay tax on its income.
________________________
1 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(23)-1.
67.4 States wishing to achieve such a result may bilaterally agree to replace Paragraph 2 of the Article with the following provision:
2. However, dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State may also be taxed in that State in accordance with the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the dividends is a resident of another Contracting State (other than the owner of the beneficial dividends paid by a company that is a REIT in which such person is directly or indirectly owns capital amounting to at least 10 percent of the value of the total capital in this company), the tax levied in this way should not exceed:
67.3 One of the issues discussed in the report is the tax arrangement regime for cross-border distributions through REITs. In the case of a small investor in a REIT, he has no control over the real estate acquired by the REIT and has no connection to that property. Despite the fact that the REIT itself will not pay tax on its distributed income, it may therefore be appropriate to consider that such an investor did not invest in real estate, but rather simply invested in the company, and should be considered as receiving a portfolio dividend. This approach will also reflect the mixed features of REIT investments, which combine features of both stocks and bonds. In contrast, a larger investor in a REIT will have a more specific interest in the real estate acquired by the REIT; for this investor, an investment in the REIT may be considered as a substitute for an investment in the property that is the underlying asset of the REIT. In this situation, it would be inappropriate to limit taxation based on the principle of the source of distributions from the REIT, since the REIT itself will not pay tax on its income.
________________________
1 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(23)-1.
67.4 States wishing to achieve such a result may bilaterally agree to replace Paragraph 2 of the Article with the following provision:
2. However, dividends paid by a company that is a resident of a Contracting State may also be taxed in that State in accordance with the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the dividends is a resident of another Contracting State (other than the owner of the beneficial dividends paid by a company that is a REIT in which such person is directly or indirectly owns capital amounting to at least 10 percent of the value of the total capital in this company), the tax levied in this way should not exceed:
a) 5 percent of the gross amount of dividends, if the beneficiary owner is a company that directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying the dividends (other than the paying company, which is a REIT) for a period of 365 days, including the day of payment of the dividend (for the purposes of calculating this period should not take into account changes in ownership directly related to the reorganization of the company, for example, a merger or separation, which owns a share or pays a dividend);
b) 15 percent of the gross amount of dividends in all other cases.
According to this provision, a major investor in a REIT is an investor who directly or indirectly owns capital that is at least 10 percent of the value of the entire capital of the REIT. However, States can bilaterally agree on the application of a different threshold. The provision also applies to all distributions made by REIT; However, in the case of capital gains allocation, the domestic legislation of some countries provides for a different threshold for distinguishing between a large investor and a small investor eligible for taxation at the rate applicable to portfolio dividends, and these countries may wish to amend this provision to preserve this distinction in their agreements. After all, since it would be impractical to limit taxation at the source of REIT distribution to a large investor, the wording of the subparagraph
(a) Excludes dividends paid by the REIT from its scope of application; thus, the subparagraph may never apply to such dividends, even if a company that did not own capital amounting to 10 percent or more of the value of the REIT's capital owned at least 25 percent of its capital calculated in accordance with Paragraph 15 above. The source State will thus be able to tax such distributions to large investors, regardless of the restrictions in subparagraphs (A) and (b).
67.5 If, however, REITs established in a Contracting State do not qualify as companies that are residents of a Contracting State, the regulation will need to be amended to ensure that it applies to distributions from such REITs.
67.6 For example, if the REIT is a company that does not qualify as a resident of the State, in order to achieve this result, Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article will need to be amended as follows:
1. Dividends paid by a resident company or a REIT organized under the laws of a Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. However, dividends may also be taxed in the territory and in accordance with the laws of the Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident, or, in the case of a REIT under whose laws it was organized, but if the owner of the beneficial dividends is a resident of another Contracting State (other than the owner of the beneficial dividends paid a company that is a REIT in which such a person directly or indirectly owns capital amounting to at least, 10 percent of the value of the total capital in this company), the tax levied in this way should not exceed), the tax levied in this way should not exceed:
a) 5 percent of the gross amount of dividends, if the beneficiary owner is a company that directly owns at least 25 percent of the capital of the company paying the dividends (other than the paying company, which is a REIT) for a period of 365 days, including the day of payment of the dividend (for the purposes of calculating this period should not take into account changes in ownership directly related to the reorganization of the company, for example, a merger or separation, which owns a share or pays a dividend);
b) 15 percent of the gross amount of dividends in all other cases.
Similarly, to achieve a result where the REIT has a trust or contractual or fiduciary arrangement structure and does not qualify as a company, States may bilaterally agree to add an additional provision to the alternative version of Paragraph 2 set out in Paragraph 67.4 above, worded as follows:
For the purposes of this Convention, if a REIT organized in accordance with the laws of a Contracting State distributes income to a resident of the other Contracting State who is the owner and beneficiary of the distribution, the distribution of this income should be considered as a dividend paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State.
According to this additional provision, the relevant distribution will be considered as a dividend, and therefore not as another type of income (for example, income from real estate or capital gains) for the purposes of applying Article 10 and other Articles of the Convention. However, it is clear that this will not change the characterization of this distribution for the purposes of domestic legislation, so that consideration under domestic law will not be affected, except for the purposes of applying the restrictions imposed by the relevant provisions of the Convention.
Note to the Comment
68 . Canada and the United Kingdom do not adhere to the provisions of Paragraph 24 above. According to their legislation, certain interest payments are considered as dividends, and therefore are included in the definition of dividends.
Item 2
Reservations to the Article
69 . Japan reserves the right not to apply the direct dividend investment rate to dividends deductible in calculating the taxable income of a company paying dividends in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident.
70 . The United States reserves the right to provide a 5 percent tax rate on dividends only if the ownership and residency requirements have been met for the prescribed time periods.
71 . The United States reserves the right to tax, in accordance with its domestic law, dividends paid by an "expatriate legal entity" to a related person for up to ten years.
72 . The United States reserves the right to provide that shareholders of certain end-to-end tax entities, such as Regulated Investment Companies and Real Estate Investment Trusts, are not provided with a direct dividend investment rate, even if they would meet the requirements based on their ownership interest.
73 . Germany and Portugal reserve the right to exclude partnerships from the scope of subparagraph (a) of Paragraph 2, in accordance with the wording of the Model Tax Convention until 2017.
74 . Given its special taxation system, Chile retains discretion over the provisions of the Convention regarding the rate and form of profit sharing by companies.
75 . Israel, Latvia, Mexico, Portugal and Turkey remain unconvinced about the tax rates under Paragraph 2.
76 . Australia, Estonia, Japan and Latvia reserve the right not to include the requirement that the competent authorities establish by mutual agreement the method of application of Paragraph 2.
77 . Poland stands by its opinion regarding the minimum ownership share (25 percent) and tax rates (5 percent and 15 percent).
77.1 Luxembourg reserves the right not to include the period of ownership provided for in paragraph 2 (a).
Point 3
78 . Belgium reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to explicitly include income, even if it is paid in the form of interest, which should be subject to the same taxation regime as income from shares in accordance with its domestic legislation.
79 . Denmark reserves the right, in certain cases, to consider the sale price received from the sale of shares as dividends.
80 . France and Mexico reserve the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to cover all income subject to taxation upon distribution.
81 . Canada and Germany reserve the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to include certain interest payments that are treated as distributions under their domestic laws.
81.1 Portugal reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to include certain payments made under profit-sharing agreements, which are treated as distributions under its domestic law.
81.2 Chile and Luxembourg reserve the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to cover certain payments that are considered as distribution of dividends in accordance with their domestic legislation.
82 Israel reserves the right to exclude payments made by a real estate investment trust that is a resident of Israel from the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 and to tax these payments in accordance with its domestic legislation.
82.1 Estonia, Japan and Latvia reserve the right to change the words "income from other corporate rights" to "income from other rights" in Paragraph 3.
82.2 Australia reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in Paragraph 3 to include other amounts subject to the same taxation regime as income from shares under its domestic law.
Item 5
83 . Canada and the United States reserve the right to levy their branch income tax on the company's income credited to the account of the permanent representative office located in these countries. Canada also reserves the right to levy this tax on profits related to the alienation of real estate located in Canada by a real estate trading company.
84. [Deleted]
85.Turkey reserves the right to tax, in accordance with the procedure provided for in paragraph 2 of this Article, a portion of the profits of a company of another Contracting State engaged in business activities through a permanent establishment located in Turkey, which remains after taxation in accordance with Article 7.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 11
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF INTEREST
I. Preliminary remarks
1. "Interest" usually means remuneration for the money provided, which belongs to the category of "income from movable capital" (revenus de capitaux mobiliers). Unlike dividends, interest is not subject to double economic taxation, that is, it is not taxed by both the debtor and the creditor. Unless otherwise stipulated in the contract, the payment of interest tax is borne by the recipient. If it happens that the debtor undertakes to pay any tax levied at the source, then this is equivalent to if he agreed to pay his creditor additional interest corresponding to such a tax.
2. But, like dividends, interest on bonds, debentures, or loans usually attracts a tax levied by withholding on interest payments. In fact, this method is usually used for practical reasons, since the tax collected at the source may be an advance on the tax payable by the recipient in relation to his total income or profit. If, in this case, the recipient is a resident of the country where the withholding deduction is applied, any double taxation they face is eliminated through internal measures. The situation will be completely different if he is a resident of another country: in this case, he is taxed on interest twice, the first time by the State of origin, the second time by the State of which he is a resident. Obviously, double taxation on it can significantly reduce the interest on the money lent and thus hinder the movement of capital and the development of international investments.
3. One cannot be sure of obtaining universal approval for a formula that leaves the exclusive taxation of interest to one State, be it the State of residence of the beneficiary or the State of the source. Therefore, a compromise decision was made. It provides that interest may be taxed in the State of residence, but reserves for the Source State the right to levy taxes if provided for by its legislation, and this right implies that the Source State may waive all taxes. on interest paid to non-residents. However, his use of this right will be limited to a limit that his tax cannot exceed, but it goes without saying that the Contracting States may agree to accept an even lower tax rate in the source State. The sacrifice that the latter State will accept in such circumstances will be accompanied by the provision of benefits from the State of Residence in order to take into account the tax levied in the State of origin (see Articles 23 A or 23 B).
4. Some countries do not allow the deduction of interest paid for the purposes of taxation of the payer, except in cases where the recipient is also a resident of the same State or is subject to tax in that State. Otherwise, the deduction is prohibited. The question of whether a deduction should also be allowed in cases where interest is paid by a resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State is dealt with in paragraph 4 of article 24.
Commentary to the provisions of Article 1
5. Paragraph 1 establishes the principle that interest arising in one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in the latter State. At the same time, it does not provide for the exclusive right to taxation in favor of the State of Residence. The term "paid" has a very broad meaning, since the concept of payment includes the fulfillment of an obligation to place funds at the disposal of the creditor in accordance with the procedure stipulated by the contract or customs.
6. The Article deals only with interest arising in a Contracting State, and therefore it does not apply to interest arising in the territory of a third State. Interest arising in the territory of a Contracting State which is credited to the account of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of that State has in the other Contracting State may be taxed by the first-mentioned State in accordance with Paragraph 2, but may also be taxed by the other State in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 7 (see para. Paragraphs 9 and 9.1 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B concerning the exemption from double taxation in such cases).
Item 2
7. Paragraph 2 reserves the right to tax interest for the State in whose territory the interest arises, but restricts the application of this right by setting a limit for the tax, which should not exceed 10 percent. This rate can be considered a reasonable maximum, given that the source State already has the right to tax profits or income earned on its territory as a result of investments financed from borrowed capital. The Contracting States may, through bilateral negotiations, agree on a lower tax or exclusive taxation in the State of which the beneficiary is a resident in respect of all interest payments, or, as explained below, in respect of certain specific income categories.
7.1 In some cases, the approach adopted in Paragraph 2, which permits taxation based on the source of interest payments, may constitute an obstacle to international trade or may be considered unacceptable for other reasons. For example, if the recipient of interest borrowed money to finance an interest-bearing operation, the profit earned in the form of interest will be much less than the nominal amount of interest received; if the interest paid is equal to or exceeds the interest received, then there will be no profit or even loss. In this case, the problem cannot be solved by the State of Residence, since in this State, where the recipient is taxed in respect of the net profit received from the transaction, a small amount of tax will be levied, or it will not be levied at all. This problem arises because the tax in the source State is usually levied on the gross amount of interest, regardless of the expenses incurred to obtain such interest. In order to avoid this problem, creditors in practice seek to shift the burden of the tax levied by the Source State on the debtor in relation to interest, and therefore increase the interest rate imposed on the debtor, whose financial burden then increases by the amount corresponding to the tax payable in the source State.
7.2 The Contracting States may wish to include an additional Paragraph to provide for the exclusive taxation of a certain percentage in the State of which the recipient is a resident. The preamble of this Paragraph, followed by sub-paragraphs describing the various percentages to which this regime applies (see below), can be formulated as follows:
3. Notwithstanding the provisions of Paragraph 2, the interest referred to in Paragraph 1 shall be taxable only in the Contracting State of which the recipient is a resident if the beneficial owner of the interest is a resident of that State, and:
a. [Description of the relevant interest category] ...
7.3 The following are some interest categories that Contracting States may wish to consider for the purposes of Paragraph 7.2 above.
Interest paid to the State, its administrative-territorial units and central banks
7.4 Some States refrain from levying taxes on income earned by other States and some of their wholly owned enterprises (for example, a central bank established as a separate organization), at least to the extent that such income is derived from government activities. Some States may grant such an exemption in accordance with their interpretation of the principle of sovereign immunity (see paragraphs 52 and 53 of the Commentary to Article 1); Others may do so in accordance with the provisions of their own domestic legislation. In their bilateral agreements, many States wish to confirm or clarify the extent of such percentage exemptions, or to grant such an exemption when it would otherwise be unavailable. States wishing to do so may therefore agree to include the following category of interest in the Clause providing for the exemption of a certain percentage from taxation in the source State:
a) this State or the central bank, its administrative-territorial unit or local authority;
The percentage paid by the State or its administrative-territorial units
7.5 If the interest payer is the State itself, its administrative-territorial unit, or a body established by law, the end result may well be that the tax levied on the source principle may actually be paid by that State if the lender increases the interest rate to reimburse the tax levied on the source principle. In this case, any benefits to the State, which taxes interest based on the source principle, will be balanced by an increase in its borrowing costs. For this reason, many States provide for such interest to be exempt from any taxes based on the source principle. States wishing to do so may agree to include the following category of interest in the Clause providing for the exemption of a certain percentage from taxation in the Source State:
b) if the interest is paid by the State in whose territory it originates, or by its administrative-territorial unit, local authority or a body established by law.;
In this proposed provision, the phrase "an authority established by law" refers to any Government agency. Depending on domestic legislation and the terminology used, some States may prefer to use phrases such as "agency or public authority" or "legal entity under public law" [personne morale de droit public] in relation to such an institution.
Interest paid in accordance with export financing programs
7.6 In order to stimulate international trade, many States have established export financing programs or agencies that can either directly provide export credits or insure or guarantee export credits provided by commercial lenders. Since this type of financing is supported by government funds, a number of States provide on a bilateral basis that interest arising on loans covered by these programs is exempt from taxation based on the source principle. States wishing to do so may agree to include the following category of interest in the Clause providing for the exemption of a certain percentage from taxation in the Source State:
c) if interest is paid in respect of a loan, debt claim or loan that is owed, made, provided, guaranteed or insured by that State or its administrative territorial unit, local government or export financing agency;
Interest paid to financial institutions
7.7 The problem described in Paragraph 7.1, which mainly arises because the source State usually taxes the gross amount of interest, and thus ignores the actual amount of income received from the transaction on which interest was paid, is of particular importance in the case of financial institutions. For example, a bank usually finances a loan that it provides with funds lent to it, in particular funds accepted on deposit. Since the source State usually ignores the value of funds for the bank when determining the amount of tax payable on interest, the amount of tax may interfere with the transaction, except in cases where the amount of this tax is paid by the debtor. For this reason, many States provide that interest paid to a financial institution, such as a bank, is exempt from any tax based on the source principle. States wishing to do so may agree to include the following category of interest in the Clause providing for the exemption of a certain percentage from taxation in the Source State:
d) Financial institution;
Interest on sales on credit
7.8 The disadvantages described in Paragraph 7.1 also often arise in the case of equipment sales on credit and other commercial sales on credit. In such cases, the supplier very often simply transfers to the customer, without any additional fees, the price that he himself will have to pay to the bank or the export financing agency to finance the loan. In these cases, interest is more an element of the selling price than a return on invested capital. In fact, in many cases, the interest included in the contributions due will be difficult to separate from the actual sale price. Therefore, States may wish to include the interest arising from such sales on credit in a Clause providing for the exemption of certain interest from taxation in the source State, which they can do by adding the following subparagraph:
e) if the interest is paid in respect of debt arising from the sale of any equipment, goods or services on credit;
7.9 The types of credit sales mentioned in this proposed provision include the sale of not only complete units, but also their individual components. Sales financed through a common line of credit provided by the seller to the buyer also constitute sales on credit for the purposes of the regulation. In addition, it does not matter whether the interest is agreed separately in addition to the sale price or included from the very beginning in the amount paid in installments.
Interest paid to certain tax-exempt entities (for example, pension funds)
Interest paid to certain tax-exempt entities (for example, pension funds)
7.10 In accordance with the domestic legislation of many States, pension funds and similar organizations are generally exempt from paying taxes on their investment income. In order to achieve a neutral attitude towards domestic and foreign investments of these organizations, some States provide on a bilateral basis that income, including interest earned by such a legal entity resident in another State, is also exempt from taxation based on the source principle. States wishing to do so may agree bilaterally on a provision developed in accordance with Paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18.
7.11 If the Contracting States do not wish to fully exempt any or all of the above categories of interest from taxation in the Source State, they may wish to apply to them a lower tax rate than that provided for in Paragraph 2 (however, this solution does not seem practical enough in the case of interest paid by the State, its administrative-territorial unit or a body established by law). In this case, paragraph 2 can be formulated as follows:
2. However, interest arising in one Contracting State may also be taxed in that State in accordance with the laws of that State, but if the beneficial owner of the interest is a resident of the other Contracting State, the tax so charged shall not exceed:
a) [lower tax rate] percent of the gross amount of interest in the case of interest paid by [description of the relevant interest category] ...
b) 10 per cent of the gross amount of interest in all other cases.
The competent authorities of the Contracting States must, by mutual agreement, determine the method of applying this restriction.
If the Contracting States agree to exempt some of the above categories of interest from taxation, this alternative provision will be followed by paragraph 3, as proposed in paragraph 7.2 above.
7.12 Contracting States may add to the interest categories listed in the above Paragraphs other categories in respect of which the imposition of a tax in the source State may seem undesirable to them.
8. The OECD/G20 Draft On the Dilution of the Tax Base and the Withdrawal of Profits from Taxation, and in particular the final report on Action 61 prepared under this draft, examined a number of abuses related to cases such as the following: the beneficial owner of interest arising in a Contracting State is a resident company of the other Contracting State; all or part of its capital belongs to shareholders outside that other State; its practice is not to distribute its profits in the form of dividends; preferential tax treatment is applied to it. Although Article 29, which was incorporated into the Convention as a result of the publication of the final report on Action 6, addresses aspects of this case related to the abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements, States wishing to waive the benefits of Article 11 with respect to interest to which preferential tax treatment is applied in the State of residence may consider including provisions in their agreements, similar to those described in Paragraphs 82-100 of the Commentary to Article 1.
9. The beneficiary owner requirement was included in Paragraph 2 of Article 11 to clarify the meaning of the words "paid to a resident" as they are used in Paragraph 1 of the Article. It clarifies that the source State is not obligated to waive the right to tax interest income just because this income was paid directly to a resident of the State with which the Source State entered into an agreement.
9.1 Since the term "beneficiary owner" was added to eliminate potential difficulties associated with the use of the words "paid to a resident" in Paragraph 1, it was intended to be interpreted in this context rather than to indicate any technical meaning it might have under the domestic law of a particular country (in fact, if in addition to the Paragraph, this term was not precisely defined in the legislation of many countries). In this regard, the term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense (for example, in the meaning it has under the trust legislation of many common law countries2); rather, it should be understood according to the context, in particular with regard to the words "paid to a resident" and taking into account the object and the objectives of the Convention, including the prevention of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion.
10. A benefit or exemption in respect of an income item is granted by the State of origin to a resident of the other Contracting State for the total or partial avoidance of double taxation that would otherwise arise as a result of the simultaneous taxation of that income by the State of residence. If an income item is paid to a resident of a Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, the source State would conflict with the object and purpose of the Convention if it granted a benefit or exemption solely on the basis of the status of a direct recipient of income as a resident of a Contracting State. The direct recipient of income in this situation is classified as a resident, but this status does not lead to the potential occurrence of double taxation, since the recipients are not considered as owners of income for tax purposes in the State of residence.
_______________________
1 OECD (2015), Prevention of contractual benefits in inappropriate circumstances, Action 6 - Final Report 2015, OECD Publishing, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241695-en .
2 For example, if the trustees of a discretionary trust do not distribute dividends earned during a certain period, these trustees, acting as such (or the trust, if recognized as a separate taxpayer), may constitute beneficial owners of such income for the purposes of Article 11, even if they are not beneficial owners according to the relevant legislation on trusts.
10.1 The source State would equally conflict with the object and purpose of the Convention by granting a benefit or exemption if a resident of a Contracting State, other than through the agency or nominee holder, acts simply as an intermediary for another person who actually benefits from the relevant income. For this reason, the report of the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs entitled "Agreements on the avoidance of double taxation and the use of intermediary companies"1 states that usually an intermediary company should not be considered as a beneficiary owner if, although being a formal owner, in practice it has very narrow powers that make it in relation to the relevant income, simply by a fiduciary or a manager acting on behalf of the interested parties.
10.2 In these various examples (agent, nominee holder, intermediary company acting as fiduciary or manager), the direct recipient of the dividend is not the "owner beneficiary" because the recipient's right to use the interest is limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person. Such an obligation usually follows from the relevant documents, but it can also be established on the basis of facts and circumstances indicating that, in essence, the recipient clearly has no right to use the interest, without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person. This type of obligation will not include contractual or legal obligations that are independent of receipt of payment by the direct recipient, such as an obligation that is independent of receipt of payment and that is assigned to the direct recipient as a debtor or party to a financial transaction, or a standard distribution obligation used in pension programs and collective investment organizations that have the right to receive benefits under the contract in accordance with the principles of Paragraphs 22-48 of the Commentary to Article 1. If the recipient of the interest has the right to use the interest without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the payment received to another person, he is the "owner beneficiary" of this interest. It should also be noted that Article 11 refers to the owner, the beneficiary of interest, and not the owner of the debt claim in respect of which interest is paid, which in some cases may be different.
10.3 The fact that the recipient of the interest payment is considered to be the actual owner of this interest does not mean, however, that the taxation restriction provided for in Paragraph 2 should be applied automatically. This tax restriction should not be provided in cases of abuse of this provision (see also paragraph 8 above). The provisions of Article 29 and the principles set out in the section on "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 will be applied to prevent abuse, including situations of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements when the recipient is the owner of the beneficiary of interest. Although in concept
The "beneficiary owner" addresses several forms of tax evasion (for example, involving the introduction of a recipient who is required to transfer a percentage to someone else), it does not address other forms of abuse, for example, certain types of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements that are governed by these provisions and principles, and therefore should not be considered as any kind ofor in any way limiting the application of other approaches to the consideration of such cases.
___________________________
1 Is included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(6)-1.
10.4 The above explanations regarding the meaning of the term "beneficiary's owner" clearly show that the meaning given to this term in the context of the Article needs to be distinguished from the other meaning in which this term has been used in the context of other instruments1 considering the identification of persons (usually individuals) who exercise real control over legal entities or assets. This other meaning of the term "beneficiary's owner" cannot be applied in the context of the Article. Indeed, this is the meaning in which we are talking about individuals (i.e. people) cannot be consistent with the direct wording of subparagraph 2 (a) of Article 10, which refers to a situation where the company is the owner of the beneficiary of the dividend. In the context of Articles 10 and 11, the term "beneficiary's owner" is intended to address difficulties arising from the use of the word "paid" in relation to dividends and interest, rather than difficulties related to ownership of shares or debt claims on which dividends or interest are paid. For this reason, in the context of this Article, it would be inappropriate to consider the meaning developed to designate persons who exercise "real effective control over a legal entity or agreement."2
11 . In accordance with other conditions established by the Article and other provisions of the Convention, the limitation of taxation in the Source State is allowed if an intermediary, for example, an agent or nominee holder located in a Contracting State or a third State, is located between the recipient and the payer, but the beneficiary's owner is a resident of another Contracting State (in the text of the Model in 1995 and Amendments were made in 2014 to clarify this point, which is the consistent position of all participating countries).
12 . The Paragraph does not say anything about the taxation regime in the source State. Thus, this gives this State the right to apply its own laws and, in particular, to levy taxes either by deduction at source or by individual assessment. This Article does not address procedural issues. Each State should be able to apply the procedure provided for in its own legislation (see, however,
_______________________
1 See, for example, the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, International Standards on Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Financing the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction – FATF Recommendations (OECD-FATF, Paris, 2012),
which sets out in detail international anti-money laundering standards and contains the following definition of beneficial owner (on page 110): "an individual(s) who are the real owners or exercise real control over the client and/or the person on whose behalf the transaction is being made. This concept also includes persons who exercise real effective control over a legal entity or an agreement." Similarly, in the 2001 report The OECD Coordination Group on Corporate Governance, "Behind the Corporate Veil: the Use of Corporate Structures for Illegal Purposes" (OECD, Paris, 2001), contains the following definition of beneficial ownership (on page 14):
In this report, "beneficial ownership" means the actual beneficial ownership or share of an individual. In some situations, the identification of the beneficial owner may involve searching through various intermediary organizations or individuals until the real owner, who is an individual, is found. In relation to corporations, ownership belongs to the shareholders or participants. In the case of partnerships, the shares belong to full and limited partners. In the case of trusts and foundations, beneficial ownership refers to the beneficiaries, which may also include the founder or founder.
2 See the definition of the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering in the previous note.
Paragraph 109 of the Commentary to Article 1). Potential abuses arising in situations where interest arising in a Contracting State is attributed to a permanent establishment that an enterprise of another State has in a third State are dealt with in paragraph 8 of Article 29. Other issues arise in connection with tripartite cases (see paragraph 71 of the Commentary to Article 24).
13 . It does not specify whether the exemption in the State of origin should be conditioned on the fact that the interest is taxed in the State of Residence. This issue should be resolved through bilateral negotiations.
14 . The article does not contain provisions on how the recipient's State of residence should take into account taxation in the State of the source of interest. This issue is addressed in Articles 23 A and 23 B.
15. [Deleted]
16. [The number has been changed and amendments have been made]
17. [The number has been changed and amendments have been made]
Point 3
18. Paragraph 3 provides the meaning in which the term "percentage" should be used to apply the taxation regime defined in the Article. This term generally refers to income from debt claims of any kind, regardless of whether they are secured by a mortgage and whether they give the right to participate in profits. The term "debt claims of any kind" obviously covers monetary contributions and collateral in the form of money, as well as government securities, bonds and debentures, although the last three types are specifically mentioned because of their importance and some of the features they may have. On the one hand, it is recognized that mortgage interest belongs to the category of income from movable capital (revenus de capitaux mobiliers), although in some countries it is equated with income from real estate. On the other hand, debt claims and, in particular, bonds and debentures that give the right to participate in the debtor's profits are nevertheless considered loans if the general nature of the contract clearly indicates an interest-bearing loan.
19. Interest on company profit-sharing bonds should generally not be treated as dividends, as should interest on convertible bonds, until the bonds are actually converted into shares. However, interest on such bonds should be considered as dividends if the loan actually shares the risks of the debtor company (see, among other things, paragraph 25 of the Commentary to Article 10). In situations of alleged thin capitalization, it is sometimes difficult to distinguish between dividends and interest, and in order to avoid any duplication between the income categories discussed in Articles 10 and 11, respectively, it should be noted that the term "interest", as used in Article 11, does not include income items discussed in Article 10.
20. With regard, in particular, to government securities, bonds and debentures, the text indicates that the premiums or prizes associated with them represent interest. In general, what amounts to interest earned on loan collateral and can be properly taxed as such in the source State is anything that the institution issuing the loan pays in excess of the amount paid by the subscriber, that is, accrued interest plus any premium paid on repayment or release. It follows that if a bond or debenture was issued at a price above par, the excess of the amount paid by the subscriber over the amount paid to him may constitute negative interest, which must be deducted from the declared interest when determining the taxable interest. On the other hand, the definition of interest does not cover any profit or loss that cannot be attributed to the difference between what the issuer has received and paid (for example, a profit or loss that does not represent accrued interest or an initial issue discount or premium that the holder of a security, such as a bond or debenture, receives by by selling them to another person or by paying off the principal amount of the security that he acquired from the previous owner for an amount that differs from the amount received by the issuer of the security). Such profit or loss may, as the case may be, constitute commercial profit or loss, capital gains or capital losses, or income covered by Article 21.
20.1 The amount that the bond seller will receive will usually include interest that has been accrued but has not yet been paid at the time of the bond sale. In most cases, the source State will not attempt to tax such accrued interest at the time of disposal, and will tax the buyer of the bond or debenture only in respect of the full amount of interest subsequently paid (it is usually assumed that in this case, the price that the acquirer pays for the bond takes into account the acquirer's future tax liability for interest, accrued in favor of the seller at the time of alienation). However, under certain circumstances, some States tax the seller of the bond in respect of the interest accrued at the time of disposal (for example, if the bond is sold to a tax-exempt entity). Such accrued interest falls under the definition of interest, and therefore may be taxed by the source State. In this case, this State should not tax the same amount again from the bond buyer when the interest payment period subsequently comes.
21. In addition, the definition of percentage contained in the first sentence of paragraph 3 is, in principle, exhaustive. It is preferable not to include an auxiliary reference to domestic legislation in the text; this is justified by the following considerations:
a) The definition covers almost all types of income that are considered as interest in various domestic legislation;
(b) The formula used provides greater legal security and ensures that the conventions will not be affected by future changes in any country's domestic legislation.;
(c) References to domestic legislation should be avoided in the Model Convention as much as possible.
However, it remains understood that in a bilateral convention, two Contracting States may expand the convention used to include any income that is taxed as interest under any of their domestic laws but which is not covered by the definition, and in these circumstances may consider it preferable to refer to their domestic laws. laws.
21.1 The definition of "interest" contained in the first sentence of paragraph 3 does not normally apply to payments made under certain types of non-traditional financial instruments that do not have underlying debt (for example, an interest rate swap). However, the definition will apply to the extent that the loan is considered to exist in accordance with the "content above form" rule, the "abuse of rights" principle, or any similar doctrine.
22. The second sentence of paragraph 3 excludes late payment penalties from the definition of interest, but Contracting States may omit this sentence and treat penalty payments as interest in their bilateral conventions. Fines, which can be paid under a contract, in accordance with tradition or a labor decision, consist either of payments calculated in proportion to the time elapsed, or of fixed amounts; in certain cases, both forms of payment can be combined. Even if they are determined in proportion to time, they represent not so much income from capital as a special form of compensation for losses incurred by the creditor as a result of the debtor's delay in fulfilling its obligations. Moreover, considerations of legal security and practical convenience make it advisable to place all penalties of this kind, in whatever form they may be paid, on the same basis for the purposes of their taxation. On the other hand, the two Contracting States may exclude from the scope of application of Article 11 any types of interest that they intend to treat as dividends.
23. Finally, the question arises whether annuities should be equated to interest; it is assumed that they are not. On the one hand, annuities provided as remuneration for past work are mentioned in Article 18 and are subject to the rules governing pensions. On the other hand, indeed, installments on purchased annuities include a percentage element on the purchase capital, as well as a return on capital, and such installments represent "civic fruits" that accumulate from day to day. However, in many countries, it would be difficult to distinguish between an element representing income from capital and an element representing a return on capital, in order to simply tax an element of income in the same category as income from movable capital. Taxation laws often contain special provisions classifying annuities as wages, salaries, and pensions and taxing them accordingly.
Item 4
24. Some States consider that dividends, interest and royalties arising from sources in their territory and paid to natural or legal persons who are residents of other States are not subject to an agreement concluded to prevent their taxation both in the source State and in the beneficiary's State of residence, if the beneficiary has a permanent establishment. in the first state. Paragraph 4 is not based on such a concept, which is sometimes called the "force of attraction of a permanent mission." It does not provide that interest arising from a resident of one Contracting State from a source located in another State should, by virtue of a kind of legal presumption or even fiction, be associated with a permanent establishment that that resident may have in the latter State, so that the said State would not be obliged to limit its taxation in such a case.. This paragraph only provides that in the source State, interest is subject to taxation as part of the profits of a permanent establishment located there, owned by a beneficiary who is a resident of another State, if it is paid in respect of debt claims forming part of the assets of the permanent establishment or otherwise effectively related to that establishment. In this case, paragraph 4 exempts the State of the source of interest from any restrictions provided for in this article. The above explanations are consistent with those provided in the Commentary to Article 7.
25. It was suggested that this clause could lead to abuse by providing loans to permanent missions established solely for this purpose in countries that offer preferential tax treatment for interest income. In addition to the fact that the provisions of Article 29 (and, in particular, paragraph 8 of this Article) and the principles set out in the section on "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 [Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments, OECD, Paris, 2010 (Attribution of profits to permanent missions, OECD, Paris, 2010 d).], usually prevent the commission of such illegal transactions, it is necessary to recognize that a particular location can constitute a permanent establishment only if business activities are carried out there, and, as explained below, the requirement that, For a debt claim to be "actually linked" to such a location requires more than just registering the debt claim in the books of a permanent establishment for accounting purposes.
25.1 A debt claim in respect of which interest is paid is actually linked to a permanent establishment and, therefore, is part of its production assets if the "economic" ownership of the debt claim is transferred to that permanent establishment in accordance with the principles developed in the Committee's report entitled Attribution of profits to permanent missions (see, in particular, paragraphs 72-97 of Part I of the report) for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 7. In the context of this paragraph, "economic" ownership of a debt claim means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of an individual enterprise, with associated benefits and burdens (for example, the right to interest related to ownership of a debt claim and potential gains or losses from an increase or decrease in the value of the debt claim).
25.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether a debt claim is actually related to a permanent establishment should take into account the recommendations set out in Part IV of the Committee's report on whether income or profit from this debt claim is taken into account when determining the income of a permanent establishment from the amount of investments attributed to it assets (see, in particular, paragraphs 165 - 170 of Part IV). These recommendations are of a general nature, therefore, the tax authorities should consider the possibility of applying a flexible and pragmatic approach that would take into account the reasonable and consistent application of these recommendations by the enterprise in order to identify specific assets that are actually associated with a permanent establishment.
Item 5
26. This paragraph establishes the principle that the State of the source of interest is the State of which the payer of interest is a resident. However, it provides for an exception to this rule in the case of interest-bearing loans that have an obvious economic connection with a permanent establishment owned by an interest payer in another Contracting State. If the loan was provided for the needs of this representative office and the interest is paid by the latter, the paragraph determines that the source of interest is located in the territory of the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located, not counting the place of residence of the owner of the permanent establishment, even if he is a resident of a third State.
27. If there is no economic link between the interest-bearing loan and the permanent establishment, the State in which the latter is located cannot therefore be considered the State in which the interest arises; it has no right to tax such interest, even within the framework of the "proportion of taxable income or goods" proportional to the importance of the permanent establishment.. Such a practice would be incompatible with paragraph 5. In addition, any deviation from the rule set out in the first sentence of paragraph 5 is justified only in cases where the economic link between the loan and the permanent establishment is sufficiently clear. In this regard, there are several possible cases:
a) The management of the permanent mission has entered into a loan agreement, which it uses for the specific needs of the permanent mission; it reflects it in its liabilities and pays interest on it directly to the lender.
b) The head office of the enterprise has concluded a loan agreement, the profits of which are used exclusively for the purposes of a permanent establishment located in another country. The interest is serviced by the head office, but is fully paid by the permanent mission.
c) The head office of the enterprise enters into a loan agreement, and the profits from it are used for the purposes of several permanent representative offices located in different countries.
In cases (a) and (b), the conditions set out in the second sentence of paragraph 5 are fulfilled, and the State in which the permanent establishment is located should be considered as the State in which interest is incurred. However, case c) does not fall under the provisions of paragraph 5, the text of which does not allow more than one source to be attributed to the same loan. In addition, such a decision would lead to significant administrative complications and would make it impossible for creditors to calculate in advance the amount of tax to be levied on interest. However, two Contracting States may limit the application of the final provision of paragraph 5 to case (a) or extend it to case (c).
28. Paragraph 5 does not provide any solution for the case that it excludes from its provisions, when both the beneficiary and the payer are indeed residents of the Contracting States, but the loan was taken out for the needs of a permanent establishment owned by the payer in a third State, and interest is paid by that establishment. Thus, in the current wording of paragraph 5, only its first sentence will apply in this case. The interest will be deemed to have arisen in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident, and not in the third State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, in whose favor the loan was taken out and which pays the interest. Thus, interest will be taxable both in the Contracting State of which the payer is a resident and in the Contracting State of which the beneficiary is a resident. However, although double taxation will be excluded between these two States by virtue of the agreements provided for in the Article, it will not be excluded between them and a third State if the latter taxes the interest on the loan at the source, if they are paid by a permanent mission in its territory.
29. It was decided not to consider this case under the Convention. Consequently, the Member State of which the payer is a resident is not obligated to waive its withholding tax in favor of a third State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, for which the loan was taken out and which pays interest. If this were not the case and a third State would not tax withholding interest paid by a permanent establishment, attempts could be made to avoid withholding taxation in a Contracting State by using a permanent establishment located in such a third State. States for which this is not a problem and which wish to address the issue described in the above paragraph may do so by agreeing to use in their bilateral agreement the alternative wording of paragraph 5 proposed in the paragraph below.
30. The double taxation risk just mentioned could also be avoided through the conclusion of multilateral agreements. In addition, if, in the case described in paragraph 28, the State of which the payer is a resident and the third State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, in whose favor the loan was taken out, and which pays interest, jointly claim the right to withhold tax on interest, then nothing prevents these two States, Where appropriate, together with the State of which the beneficiary is a resident, take measures to avoid double taxation that would arise as a result of such claims, applying, if necessary, the procedure for mutual agreement (as provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 25); see paragraphs 38.1 and 55-55.2 of the Commentary to Article 25).
30. As mentioned in paragraph 29, any such double taxation could be avoided either through a multilateral agreement or if the State of which the beneficiary is resident and the State of which the payer is resident agree to formulate the second sentence of paragraph 5 as follows, which would ensure that paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article do not apply to interest that In this case, they usually fall under Articles 7 or 21.:
However, in cases where the person paying the interest, regardless of whether he is a resident of a Contracting State, has a permanent establishment in a State other than the one of which he is a resident, in connection with which an interest debt has arisen and such interest is being paid by that permanent establishment, then It is considered that such interests arise in the State in which the permanent establishment is located.
31. If two Contracting States, in the course of bilateral negotiations, agree to reserve for the State in which the recipient of income resides the exclusive right to tax such income, then it obviously makes no sense to include in the convention fixing their relations the provision of paragraph 5 defining the State of the source of such income. However, it is equally obvious that in this case it will not be possible to completely avoid double taxation if the interest payer has a permanent establishment in a third country that collects withholding tax on interest, for which the loan was taken out and which paid the interest due on it. In this case, the situation would be the same as in paragraphs 28-30 above.
Item 6
32. The purpose of this paragraph is to limit the effect of the provisions relating to the taxation of interest in cases where, by virtue of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person, the amount of interest paid exceeds the amount that would have been agreed by the payer and the beneficial owner if they had applied market conditions. It provides that in such a case the provisions of the Article shall apply only to the last mentioned amount and that the excess part of the interest shall continue to be taxed in accordance with the laws of the two Contracting States, with due regard to the other provisions of the Convention.
33. It is clear from the text that for the application of this paragraph, interest withheld excessively must be conditioned by a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person. Examples include cases where interest is paid to an individual or legal entity that directly or indirectly exercises control over the payer, or is directly or indirectly controlled by him, or is subordinate to a group that has common interests with him. In addition, these examples are similar or similar to the cases provided for in Article 9.
34. On the other hand, the concept of a special relationship also covers blood or marital relations and, in general, any community of interests, in contrast to legal relations, as a result of which interest is paid.
35. With regard to the taxation regime applicable to the excess part of interest, the exact nature of such excess will need to be determined depending on the circumstances of each specific case in order to determine the category of income to which it should be attributed for the purposes of applying the provisions of the tax legislation of the respective States and the provisions of the Convention. This clause allows only the adjustment of the interest rate, and not the reclassification of the loan in such a way as to give it the character of a contribution to equity. In order for such an adjustment to be possible in accordance with paragraph 6 of Article 11, it would be necessary, at a minimum, to delete the limiting phrase "taking into account the debt claim for which it is being paid". If it seems appropriate to provide greater clarity of intent, the phrase "for any reason" may be added after the word "exceeds". Any of these alternative versions will apply in cases where part or all of the interest payment is excessive because the loan amount or the terms associated with it (including the interest rate) cannot be agreed upon in the absence of a special relationship. However, this paragraph may affect not only the recipient, but also the payer of excessive interest, and if the legislation of the source State allows it, the excess amount may be rejected as a deduction, with due regard to other applicable provisions of the Convention. If two Contracting States have difficulty defining other provisions of the Convention applicable, as appropriate, to the excess part of the interest, there is nothing that could prevent them from including additional explanations in the last sentence of paragraph 6, if they do not change its general meaning.
36. If the principles and rules of their respective legislations oblige two Contracting States to apply different Articles of the Convention in order to tax the surplus, then it will be necessary to resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in the Convention to solve this problem.
Note to the Comment
37. Canada and the United Kingdom do not adhere to paragraph 18 above. According to their domestic legislation, certain interest payments are treated as distributions and are therefore treated in accordance with article 10.
Reservations to the Article
Item 2
38. Chile, Hungary, Israel, Latvia, Mexico, Portugal, Slovakia and Turkey remain unconvinced about the rate provided for in paragraph 2.
39. The United States reserves the right to impose its branch income tax on interest related to the company's profits attributed to the account of a permanent representative office located in the United States.
40. The United States reserves the right to tax certain forms of conditional interest at the rate applicable to portfolio dividends in accordance with subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10. They also reserve the right to tax in accordance with their legislation.: 1) the form of interest, which is an "excess inclusion in respect of the residual interest of a company specializing in real estate investments"; and 2) interest paid by an "expatriate legal entity" to a related person for a period of up to ten years.
40.1 Estonia, Japan and Latvia reserve the right not to include the requirement that the competent authorities establish by mutual agreement the procedure for the application of paragraph 2.
Point 3
41. Mexico reserves the right to treat other types of income as interest, such as income earned from financial leasing and factoring agreements.
42. Belgium, Canada, Estonia, Ireland and Latvia reserve the right to amend the definition of interest to ensure that interest payments considered as distributions under their domestic laws fall within the scope of Article 10.
43. Canada, Chile, and Norway reserve the right to remove references to debt claims that entitle them to participate in the debtor's profits.
44. Chile, Greece and Spain reserve the right to expand the definition of interest by including a reference to their domestic legislation in accordance with the definition contained in the draft 1963 Convention.
45. Australia reserves the right to expand the definition of interest to include income to which, according to its domestic legislation, the same taxation regime should apply as income from borrowed funds.
45.1 The United States reserves the right to amend the definition of interest to include all income to which the same taxation regime should apply as income from money lent in accordance with the laws of the Contracting State in whose territory the income arises, and to indicate that this income, considered in Article 10, should not be considered as a percentage.
Item 6
46. Mexico reserves the right to include a provision regarding the accounting of interest earned from compensation loans as a protection against abuse.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 12 ON THE TAXATION OF ROYALTIES
I. Preliminary remarks
1. In principle, royalties in respect of licenses for the use of patents and similar property and similar payments are the recipient's income from the issuance of the permit. A permit may be granted in connection with an enterprise (for example, the use of copyright in literary works granted by a publisher or the use of a patent granted by an inventor) or completely independently of any activity of the person granting it (for example, the use of a patent granted by the inventor's heirs).
2. Some countries do not allow the deduction of royalties paid for the taxpayer's tax purposes, except in cases where the recipient is also a resident of the same State or is subject to taxation in that State. Otherwise, deduction is prohibited. The question of whether a deduction should be allowed in cases where royalties are paid by a resident of a Contracting State to a resident of another State is dealt with in paragraph 4 of Article 24.
II. Commentary on the provisions of the Article
Point 1
3. Paragraph 1 establishes the principle of exclusive taxation of royalties in the State of which the beneficial owner is a resident. The only exception to this principle is the exception made in the cases discussed in paragraph 3.
4. The requirement of beneficial ownership has been included in paragraph 1 of Article 12 to clarify how this article applies to payments made to intermediaries. It is clear from it that the source State is not obligated to waive the rights to tax royalty income just because this income was paid directly to a resident of the State with which the source State concluded the convention. Thus, the term "beneficial owner" is not used in a narrow technical sense (as, for example, in the meaning it has in the trust legislation of many common law countries[1- For example, if the trustees of a discretionary trust do not distribute royalties earned during a certain period, these managers, acting in their function as such (or a trust, if recognized by a separate taxpayer), may represent the beneficial owner of such income for the purposes of Article 12., even if they are not the beneficial owners according to the relevant legislation on trusts.Rather, it should be understood in the context and in the light of the objectives and objectives of the Convention, including the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion and avoidance of taxation..
4.1 A benefit or exemption in respect of an income item is granted by the State of origin to a resident of the other Contracting State in order to avoid, in whole or in part, double taxation that would otherwise arise as a result of the simultaneous imposition of this tax by the State of Residence. If an income item is paid to a resident of a Contracting State acting as an agent or nominee, the source State would conflict with the object and purpose of the Convention if it granted a benefit or exemption solely on the basis of the status of a direct recipient of income as a resident of a Contracting State. The direct recipient of income in this situation is classified as a resident, but this status does not lead to the potential occurrence of double taxation, since the recipients are not considered as owners of income for tax purposes in the State of residence.
4.2 It would also be incompatible with the aims and purpose of the Convention if the source State provided a benefit or exemption when a resident of a Contracting State, without entering into an agency or nominal relationship, simply acts as an intermediary for another person who actually benefits from the relevant income. For these reasons, in the report of the Committee on Tax Affairs, entitled "Double Taxation Conventions and the Use of Intermediary Companies" [1-Included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(6)-1], it is concluded that an intermediary company cannot usually be considered as a beneficial owner, even if it is the formal owner, but in practice has very narrow powers that make it a simple fiduciary or manager acting on behalf of interested parties in relation to the relevant income.
4.3 In these various examples (agent, nominee holder, intermediary company acting as fiduciary or manager), the direct recipient of royalties is not the "beneficial owner", since the recipient's right to use royalties is limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person. Such an obligation usually follows from the relevant documents, but it can also be established on the basis of facts and circumstances indicating that, in essence, the recipient clearly has no right to use the royalties, without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person. This type of obligation will not include contractual or legal obligations that are independent of receipt of payment by the direct recipient, such as an obligation that is independent of receipt of payment and that is assigned to the direct recipient as a debtor or party to a financial transaction, or a standard distribution obligation used in pension programs and collective investment organizations that have the right to receive benefits under the contract in accordance with the principles of paragraphs 22-48 of the Commentary to Article 1. If the recipient of the royalties has the right to use the royalties without being limited by a contractual or legal obligation to transfer the received payment to another person, he is the "beneficial owner" of these royalties. It should also be noted that Article 12 refers to the beneficial owner of the royalties, and not the owner of the right or property in respect of which the royalties are paid, which in some cases may be different.
4.4 The fact that the recipient of royalties is considered to be the actual owner of these royalties does not mean, however, that the taxation restriction provided for in paragraph 2 should be applied automatically. This tax restriction should not be provided in cases of abuse of this provision (see also paragraph 7 below). The provisions of Article 29 and the principles set out in the section on "Misuse of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 will be applied to prevent abuse, including situations of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements when the recipient is the owner-beneficiary of royalties. Although the concept of “beneficial owner” addresses several forms of tax evasion (for example, involving the introduction of a recipient who is obligated to transfer royalties to someone else), it does not address other forms of abuse, for example, certain types of abuse of the provisions of international tax agreements that are governed by these provisions and principles, and therefore does not They should be considered in some way limiting the application of other approaches to the consideration of such cases.
4.5 The above explanations regarding the meaning of the term “beneficial owner” clearly show that the meaning given to this term in the context of the Article must be distinguished from the other meaning in which this term was used in the context of other instruments [1-See, for example, the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, International Standards on Combating combating money laundering, terrorist financing and proliferation - FATF (OECD) Recommendations - FATF, Paris, 2012), which sets out in detail international anti-money laundering standards and contains the following definition of the beneficial owner (on page 110): “an individual(s) who are the real owners or exercise real control over the client and/or the person on whose behalf the transaction is being conducted. This concept also includes persons who exercise real effective control over a legal entity or an agreement.” Similarly, in the 2001 report The OECD Coordination Group on Corporate Governance, Behind the "Corporate Veil": the use of corporate structures for illegal purposes (OECD, Paris, 2001), contains the following definition of beneficial ownership (on page 14):
In this report, "beneficial ownership" means the actual beneficial ownership or share of an individual. In some situations, the identification of the beneficial owner may involve searching through various intermediary organizations or individuals until the real owner, who is an individual, is found. In relation to corporations, ownership belongs to the shareholders or participants. In the case of partnerships, the shares belong to full and limited partners. In the case of trusts and foundations, beneficial ownership refers to the beneficiaries, which may also include the founder or founder.], considering the identification of persons (usually individuals) who exercise real control over legal entities or assets. This other meaning of the term "beneficial owner" cannot be applied in the context of the Article. Indeed, this is the meaning in which we are talking about individuals (i.e. people) cannot be consistent with the direct wording of subparagraph 2 (a) of Article 10, which refers to a situation where the company is the beneficial owner of the dividend. The term "beneficial owner" is intended to eliminate difficulties arising from the use of the word "paid" in paragraph 1 of Articles 10 and 11, as well as similarly applied in paragraph 1 of Article 12 of the 1977 Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation. with respect to dividends, interest, and royalties, and not difficulties related to ownership of shares, debt claims, property, or rights in respect of which those dividends, interest, or royalties are paid. For this reason, in the context of this Article, it would be inappropriate to consider the meaning developed to designate persons who exercise "real effective control over a legal entity or an agreement."[2-See. Definition of the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, given in the previous note.]
4.6 Subject to the other conditions provided for in this article and other provisions of the Convention, tax exemption in the source State remains available if an intermediary, such as an agent or nominee located in a Contracting State or in a third State, acts between the beneficiary and the payer in cases where the beneficiary owner is a resident of the other Contracting State. (the text of the Model was changed in 1997 to clarify this point, which has become the consistent position of all member countries).
5. The Article deals only with royalties arising in a Contracting State, the beneficial owner of which is a resident of the other Contracting State. Consequently, it does not apply to royalties arising in a third State, as well as to royalties arising in a Contracting State that are attributed to the permanent mission of that State in another Contracting State (for these cases, see paragraphs 4-6 of the Commentary to Article 21). Potential abuses arising in situations where royalties arising in a Contracting State are attributed to a permanent establishment that an enterprise of another State has in a third State are dealt with in paragraph 8 of Article 29. Procedural issues are not addressed in this Article. Each State should be able to apply the procedure provided for by its own legislation. Other issues arise in connection with tripartite cases (see paragraph 71 of the Commentary to Article 24).
6. This paragraph does not specify whether tax exemption in the State of origin should be conditional on the fact that royalties are taxed in the State of residence. This issue can be resolved during bilateral negotiations.
7. The OECD/G20 project "Base Dilution and Profit Redistribution (BEPS)" and, in particular, the final reports on Actions 5, 6 and 8-10 [1-OECD (2015), More effective counteraction to adverse tax practices, taking into account transparency and content, Final Report on Action 5 - 2015, OECD Publishing House, Paris. DOI: http:// dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241190-en; OECD (2015), Prevention of contractual benefits in inappropriate circumstances, Action 6 - 2015 Final Report, OECD Publishing House, Paris, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241695-en and the OECD (2015), Reconciling transfer pricing outcomes with value creation, Actions 8-
10 - 2015 Final Reports, OECD Publishing House, Paris. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264241244-en The experts prepared within the framework of this project examined a number of abuses related to cases such as the following: the beneficial owner of royalties arising in one Contracting State is a company resident in another Contracting State; all or part of its capital belongs to shareholders resident outside that other State; its practice does not provide for the distribution of profits in the form of dividends; and she enjoys preferential tax treatment. While article 29, which was incorporated into the Convention as a result of the preparation of the final report on Action 6, addresses aspects of the "purchase" of a contract in this case, States wishing to deny the benefits of article 12 with respect to royalties that enjoy preferential tax treatment in the State of residence may consider including provisions such as those described in paragraphs 82-100 of the Commentary to article 1.
Item 2
8. Paragraph 2 contains a definition of the term "royalties". In general, they relate to rights or property constituting various forms of literary and artistic property, elements of intellectual property specified in the text, and information related to industrial, commercial, or scientific experience. The definition applies to payments for the use or the right to use the mentioned rights, regardless of whether they have been registered or whether they should be registered in the State register. The definition covers both payments made under a license and compensation that a person will be required to pay for copying fraudulently or violating a right.
8.1 This definition, however, does not apply to payments that, although based on the number of times a right belonging to one person has been granted to another person who does not own the right or the right to use it (see, for example, paragraph 18 below).
8.2 If the payment is a refund for the transfer of full ownership of the property element mentioned in the definition, then the payment does not constitute a refund "for the use or right to use" of this property, and therefore cannot constitute royalties. As noted in paragraphs 15 and 16 below with respect to software, difficulties may arise in the case of the transfer of rights that may be considered part of the ownership element mentioned in the definition if these rights are transferred in a manner that appears to be alienation. For example, this may be the exclusive granting of all intellectual property rights for a limited period of time, or all non-property rights in a limited geographical area in a transaction formalized as a sale. Each case will depend on the specific facts and will need to be examined taking into account national intellectual property legislation applicable to the relevant type of property, as well as national legislation on what is considered alienation, but in general, if the payment is made in compensation for the alienation of rights constituting a separate and specific property (which more likely in the case of geographical rather than time constraints), such payments are most likely, will represent commercial profits in accordance with Article 7 or capital gains in accordance with Article 13, rather than royalties in accordance with Article 12. This follows from the fact that if the right of ownership is alienated, then compensation cannot be carried out for the use of rights. The basic nature of the transaction as an alienation cannot be changed by the form of remuneration, payment of remuneration in installments or, in the opinion of most countries, by the fact that payments are related to unforeseen circumstances.
8.3 The word "payment" used in the definition has a very broad meaning, since the term payment means the fulfillment of an obligation to place funds at the disposal of the creditor in accordance with the procedure stipulated by the contract or custom.
8.4 As a guide, some explanations are provided below to define the scope of Article 12 in relation to the scope of other Articles of the Convention, in particular with regard to the provision of information.
8.5 If the information specified in paragraph 2 is provided or the right to use the type of property specified in this paragraph is granted, the person who owns this information or property may agree not to provide this information or the right to anyone else. Payments made as compensation for such consent are payments made to ensure the exclusivity of such information or the right to use the property, as appropriate. Being payments "of any kind received as a refund for ... the right to use "property" or for information", these payments fall under the definition of royalties.
9. Although the definition of the term "royalties" in the 1963 draft Convention and the 1977 Model Convention included payments "for the use or right to use industrial, commercial or scientific equipment", the reference to these payments was subsequently deleted from the definition. Taking into account the nature of income from the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, including the rental of containers, the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs decided to exclude income from such a lease from the definition of royalties, and therefore exclude it from the scope of Article 12, in order to ensure that it falls under the rules of taxation of commercial profits, defined in Articles 5 and 7.
9.1 Satellite operators and their clients (including broadcasting and telecommunications companies) often enter into "repeater lease" agreements, under which the satellite operator allows the client to use the satellite repeater's capabilities to transmit a signal over long distances. Payments made by customers in accordance with standard "repeater lease" agreements are made to use the repeater's transmitting capacity, and will not constitute royalties as defined in paragraph 2: these payments are not made as compensation for the use or right to use property, or for information referred to in the definition (they cannot be For example, consider payments for information, either for the use or the right to use a secret process., because no information about satellite technology is transmitted to the client). With regard to contracts that include the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific (ICS) equipment in the definition of royalties, the payment characteristics will largely depend on the relevant contractual agreements. Although the relevant contracts often mention the "lease" of a repeater, in most cases the client does not acquire physical ownership of the repeater, but only its transmitting capacity: the satellite is controlled by the lessor, and the lessee does not have access to the repeater allocated to him. Thus, in such cases, payments made by customers will be in the nature of payments for services to which Article 7 applies, rather than payments for the use or right to use ICS equipment. Another, but much less frequent transaction will be that the satellite owner leases it to another party so that it can manage it and either use it for its own purposes or offer its data transfer capabilities to third parties. In this case, the payment made by the satellite operator to the satellite owner may well be considered a payment for the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment. Similar considerations apply to payments made for the lease or purchase of the capacity of cables for the transmission of electricity or communications (for example, through a contract granting the inalienable right to use such capacity), as well as pipelines (for example, for the transportation of gas and oil).
9.2 In addition, payments made by a telecommunications network operator to another network operator in accordance with a typical "roaming" agreement (see paragraph 38 of the Commentary to Article 5), will not constitute royalties in accordance with the definition of paragraph 2, since these payments are not made as compensation for the use or right to use property, or for information mentioned in the definition (they cannot, for example, be considered as payments for the use or right to use secret the process, since no secret technology is used or transferred to the operator). This conclusion remains true even in the case of contracts that include the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific (ICS) equipment in the definition of royalties, since the operator who pays the fee under the roaming agreement pays the amount not for the use or right to use the visited network, to which he does not have physical access, but for telecommunications services provided by a foreign network operator.
9.3 Payments for the use or right to use all or some parts of the radio frequency spectrum (for example, in accordance with the so-called "spectrum use license", which allows the owner to transmit multimedia content in certain frequency ranges of the electromagnetic spectrum), do not constitute payments for the use or right to use property, or for information, which are mentioned in determining the royalties from paragraph 2. This conclusion remains true even in the case of contracts that include the lease of industrial, commercial, or scientific (ICS) equipment in the definition of royalties, since payments are not made for the use or right to use any equipment.
10. Movie rentals are also considered royalties, regardless of whether the films are shown in cinemas or on television. However, in the course of bilateral negotiations, it may be agreed that film rents are treated as commercial profits and, as a result, are subject to the provisions of articles 7 and 9.
10.1 Payments that are made solely as compensation for obtaining exclusive distribution rights to a product or service in the relevant territory do not constitute royalties, since they are not made in compensation for the use or right to use an element of property included in the definition. These payments, which are best considered to be made to increase sales revenue, are more likely to fall within the scope of Article 7. An example of such a payment is a payment from a clothing distributor who is a resident of one Contracting State and pays a certain amount to a manufacturer of branded shirts who is a resident of another State as compensation for the exclusive right to sell branded shirts produced by that manufacturer abroad in the territory of the first State. In this example, the resident distributor does not pay the amount for the right to use the trade name or trademark under which the shirts are sold.; he simply gets the exclusive right to sell the shirts he buys from the manufacturer in the State of which he is a resident.
10.2 A payment cannot be described as being made "for the use or right to use" a sample, model, or plan if the payment is intended to develop a sample, model, or plan that does not yet exist. In this case, the payment is made as a refund for the services that will lead to the development of this sample, model or plan, and thus falls under the scope of Article 7. This will be the case even if the designer of the sample, model, or plan (for example, an architect) retains all rights, including copyright, to that sample, model, or plan. However, if the owner of the copyright to previously developed plans simply grants someone the right to modify or reproduce those plans without actually doing any work, the payment received by that owner in return for granting the right to such use of the plans will constitute royalties.
11. When classifying payments received as remuneration for information related to industrial, commercial or scientific experience, paragraph 2 refers to the concept of "know-how". Various specialized bodies and authors have formulated definitions of know-how. The words "payments ... for information related to industrial, commercial or scientific experience" are used in the context of the transfer of certain information that has not been patented and usually does not fall under other categories of intellectual property rights. As a rule, this is undisclosed information of an industrial, commercial or scientific nature, obtained from previous experience, which has practical application in the company's activities and the disclosure of which can bring economic benefits. Since the definition refers to information related to previous experience, the Article does not apply to payments for new information obtained as a result of providing services at the request of the payer.
11.1 Within the framework of the know-how transfer agreement, one of the parties agrees to transfer to the other party its special knowledge and experience, which are not disclosed to the public, so that it can use them to its advantage. It is recognized that the grantor is not obligated to play any role in the application of the formulas provided to the licensee, and that it does not guarantee the result.
11.2 Thus, this type of contract differs from service contracts in which one of the parties undertakes to use their usual professional skills to independently perform work for the benefit of the other party. Payments made under recent agreements are usually subject to Article 7.
11.3 The need to distinguish between these two types of payments, i.e. payments for the provision of know-how and payments for the provision of services, sometimes creates practical difficulties. The following criteria are applicable for making such a distinction:
— Contracts for the supply of know-how relate to the information described in paragraph 11 that already exists, or relate to the provision of such information after its development and creation, and include specific provisions regarding the confidentiality of this information.
— In the case of service contracts, the supplier undertakes to provide services that may require special knowledge, skills and experience from this supplier, but not transfer such special knowledge, skills or experience to another party.
— In most cases related to the provision of know-how, as a rule, the supplier is practically not required to perform any actions under the contract other than providing existing information or reproducing existing materials. On the other hand, a service contract in most cases involves significantly higher costs for the supplier to fulfill its contractual obligations. For example, a supplier, depending on the nature of the services provided, may be required to bear the costs of paying salaries to employees involved in research, design, testing, drawing up drawings and other related activities, as well as making payments to subcontractors for the provision of such services.
11.4 Examples of payments that should therefore be considered as being received as compensation not for the provision of know-how, but for the provision of services include:
— payments received as a refund for after-sales service,
— payments for services provided by the seller to the buyer under warranty,
— payment for purely technical assistance,
— payments for a list of potential customers, if such a list is compiled specifically for the payer based on publicly available information (payment for a confidential list of customers to whom the payee has provided a specific product or service, however, will constitute a payment for know-how, since it will relate to the payee's commercial experience in transactions with these clients),
— payment for the opinion provided by an engineer, lawyer or accountant, and
— payment for advice provided electronically, for electronic communication with technical specialists, or for access via computer networks to a troubleshooting database, for example, a database that provides non-confidential information to software users in response to frequently asked questions or common problems.
11.5 In the specific case of a contract involving the provision of information related to computer programming by the supplier, payment will generally be considered made only for the provision of such information, which is know-how, if this is done for the purpose of acquiring information representing the ideas and principles underlying the program, such as logic, algorithms or programming languages and techniques, if such information is provided under the condition, that the client will not disclose it without permission and any available trade secret protection applies to it.
11.6 In business practice, there are contracts that cover both know-how and technical assistance. One example of this type of agreement is a franchise agreement, where the franchisor shares his knowledge and experience with the recipient of the franchise and, in addition, provides him with various technical assistance, which in certain cases is supported by financial assistance and supplies of goods. An appropriate approach to mixed contracts is, in principle, to break down, based on the information contained in the contract or by means of an objective distribution, the total amount of compensation provided in accordance with the various parts of what is provided under the contract, and then apply an appropriate tax regime to each part determined in this way. If, however, one of the parts of what is provided under the contract represents the main purpose of the contract, and the other parts are only auxiliary and insignificant, then the regime applicable to the main part should, as a rule, apply to the entire amount of compensation.
12. The question of whether payments received as remuneration for computer software can be classified as royalties is a complex issue, but it is of great importance given the rapid development of computer technology in recent years and the scale of transfer of such technology across national borders. In 1992, the Commentary was amended to describe the principles according to which such classification should be carried out. In 2000, paragraphs 12-17 were further amended to clarify the analysis that distinguishes between commercial profits and royalties in software transactions. In most cases, the revised analysis leads to the same results.
12.1 Software can be described as a program or a series of programs that contain instructions for a computer that are necessary either for the computer's own work processes (operating software) or for performing other tasks (application software). It can be transmitted using various media, for example, in written or electronic form, on magnetic tape or disc, on a laser disc or CD-ROM. The software can be standardized using a wide range of applications or adapted to specific users. It can be transmitted as an integral part of computer equipment or in an independent form, available for use on various equipment.
12.2 The nature of payments received under transactions related to the transfer of computer software depends on the nature of the rights acquired by the recipient in accordance with a specific agreement on the use and operation of the program. Rights in computer programs are a form of intellectual property. A study of the practices of OECD countries has shown that all but one of them protect the rights to computer programs directly or indirectly in accordance with copyright law. Although the term “software” is widely used to describe both programs that contain intellectual property rights (copyrights) and the media on which they are embodied, the copyright legislation of most OECD countries recognizes a distinction between copyright in a program and software that includes a copy of a copyrighted program.. The transfer of rights in relation to the software takes place in various ways, from the complete alienation of copyright rights in the program to the sale of a product subject to restrictions on use. Refunds can also be paid in various forms. These factors can make it difficult to define the boundary between software payments, which should properly be considered as royalties, and other types of payments. The difficulty of determining is compounded by the ease of reproduction of computer programs and the fact that the purchase of software often entails the creation of a copy by the acquirer in order to make it possible for the software to function.
13. The rights of the recipient will in most cases include partial or full rights to the underlying copyright (see paragraphs 13.1 and 15 below), or they may be (or be equivalent to) partial or full rights to a copy of the program ("copy of the program"), regardless of whether such a copy is stored on a tangible medium or provided electronically (see paragraphs 14-14.2 below). In exceptional cases, the transaction may be a transfer of "know-how" or a secret formula (clause 14.3).
13.1 Payments made for the acquisition of partial copyright rights (without full alienation of copyright by the transferor) will constitute royalties if the refund relates to the granting of rights to use the program in a manner that would constitute copyright infringement without such a license. Examples of such arrangements include licenses to reproduce and distribute to the public software that includes copyrighted software, or to modify and publicly display software. In these circumstances, payments are made for the right to use copyrights in the program (i.e., to use rights that would otherwise be the exclusive prerogative of the copyright holder). It should be noted that in cases where payment for software should appropriately be considered as royalties, it may be difficult to apply the provisions of the copyright article to payments for software, since paragraph 2 requires that software be classified as a literary, artistic or scientific work. None of these categories seem to be suitable enough. Copyright laws in many countries address this problem by specifically classifying software as a literary or scientific work. For other countries, the most acceptable approach may be to treat it as scientific work. Countries for which it is impossible to assign software to any of these categories may adopt in their bilateral agreements an amended version of paragraph 2, which either omits all references to the nature of copyright or specifically refers to the software.
14. In other types of transactions, the rights acquired in relation to copyright are limited to those necessary to enable the user to use the program, for example, when the recipient is granted limited rights to reproduce the program. This is a common situation in transactions for the purchase of a copy of the program. The rights transferred in these cases depend on the nature of the computer programs. They allow the user to copy the program, for example, to the hard drive of the user's computer or for archiving. In this context, it is important to note that the protection granted to computer programs under copyright law may vary from country to country. In some countries, copying a program to a computer's hard drive or RAM without a license would constitute copyright infringement. However, copyright laws in many countries automatically grant this right to the owner of software that includes a computer program. Regardless of whether this right is granted in accordance with the law or a license agreement with the copyright owner, copying the program to a computer's hard disk or RAM, as well as creating archived copies, is an important step in using the program. Therefore, when analyzing the nature of the transaction for tax purposes, the rights regarding these acts of copying should be ignored if they simply ensure the effective operation of the program by the user. Payments for these types of transactions will be considered as commercial profit in accordance with Article 7.
14.1 The method of transmission of the computer program to the recipient does not matter. For example, it doesn't matter whether the recipient receives a computer disk containing a copy of the program or directly receives a copy on their computer's hard drive via a modem connection. It also does not matter that there may be restrictions on the use for which the recipient can use the software.
14.2 The ease of reproduction of computer programs has led to distribution agreements under which the recipient receives the rights to create multiple copies of the program for use only within their own business. Such agreements are commonly referred to as "installation licenses," "enterprise licenses," or "network licenses." Although these agreements allow the creation of multiple copies of the program, such rights are usually limited to those necessary to ensure that the program works on the licensee's computers or network, and reproduction for any other purpose is not permitted under the license. Payments under such agreements will in most cases be considered as commercial profit in accordance with Article 7.
14.3 Another type of transaction involving the transfer of software is the more unusual case where a software company or programmer agrees to provide information about the ideas and principles underlying the program, such as logic, algorithms, programming languages or techniques. In these cases, payments can be characterized as royalties if they represent remuneration for the use or right to use secret formulas or for information related to industrial, commercial or scientific experience that cannot be separately protected by copyright. This is different from the usual cases where a copy of the program is purchased for use by the end user.
14.4 Agreements between the Software copyright holder and the distribution intermediary often grant the distribution intermediary the right to distribute copies of the program without the right to reproduce the program. In these transactions, the rights acquired with respect to copyrights are limited to those required by a commercial intermediary to distribute copies of the software. In such transactions, distributors only pay for the purchase of copies of the software and do not use any copyright rights to the software. Thus, in transactions where the distributor makes payments to purchase and distribute copies of the software (without the right to reproduce the software), the rights in respect of these distribution activities should not be taken into account when analyzing the nature of the transaction for tax purposes. Payments for these types of transactions will be considered as commercial profit in accordance with Article 7. This will happen regardless of whether the distributed copies are provided on tangible media or distributed electronically (without the distributor's right to reproduce the software), or whether minor adjustments need to be made to install the software.
15. If compensation is paid for the transfer of full ownership of copyright rights, then the payment cannot constitute royalties, and the provisions of the Article do not apply. Difficulties may arise in cases where there is a transfer of rights that includes:
— the exclusive right to use copyrights for a specific period or in a limited geographical area;
— additional remuneration related to the use of;
— compensation in the form of a significant lump sum payment.
— the exclusive right to use copyrights for a specific period or in a limited geographical area;
— additional remuneration related to the use of;
— compensation in the form of a significant lump sum payment.
16. Each case will depend on the specific facts, but in general, if a payment is made as compensation for the transfer of rights constituting a separate and specific property (which is more likely in the case of geographical rather than time constraints), such payments are likely to constitute commercial profits in accordance with Article 7 or capital gains in accordance with according to Article 13, not royalties according to Article 12. This follows from the fact that if the right of ownership is alienated, then compensation cannot be carried out for the use of rights. The basic nature of the transaction as an alienation cannot be changed by the form of remuneration, payment of remuneration in installments or, in the opinion of most countries, by the fact that payments are related to unforeseen circumstances.
17. Payments for the software can be made under mixed contracts. Examples of such contracts include the sale of computer equipment with embedded software and the assignment of the right to use the software in conjunction with the provision of services. The methods described in paragraph 11.6 above to solve similar problems with respect to patent fees and know-how are equally applicable to computer software. If necessary, the total amount of compensation payable under the contract should be divided based on the information contained in the contract, or through a reasonable distribution with the appropriate tax treatment applied to each distributed part.
17.1 The principles outlined above regarding software payments also apply to transactions involving other types of digital products, such as images, sounds, or text. The development of electronic commerce has increased the number of such transactions. When deciding whether payments resulting from these transactions amount to royalties, the main issue that needs to be resolved is to determine what the payment is essentially for.
17.2 According to the relevant legislation of some countries, transactions that allow the customer to download digital products electronically may lead to the use of copyrights by the buyer, for example, because the contract grants the right to create one or more copies of digital content. If the refund is essentially related to something other than the use or right to use copyright rights (for example, the acquisition of other types of rights, data, or services under a contract), and the use of copyright is limited to the rights necessary to enable downloading, storing, and working on the user's computer, network, or other Such use of copyright should not affect the analysis of the nature of the payment for the purposes of applying the definition of "royalties".
17.3 This applies to transactions that allow a customer (which may be an enterprise) to download electronically digital products (such as software, images, sounds, or text) for their own use. In these transactions, the payment is mainly intended to purchase data transmitted in the form of a digital signal, and therefore does not constitute a royalty, but falls under Article 7 or Article 13, as appropriate. If the act of copying a digital signal to a customer's hard drive or other temporary storage medium involves the use of copyrights by the customer in accordance with relevant legislation and contractual agreements, such copying is simply a means by which the digital signal is recorded and stored. Such copyright usage is irrelevant for classification purposes, as it does not correspond to what is primarily considered payment (i.e. to receive data transmitted as a digital signal), which is a determining factor for the purposes of determining royalties. There would also be no reason to classify such transactions as "royalties" if, according to the relevant legislation and contractual agreements, the creation of a copy is considered as the use of copyright by the supplier and not by the client.
17.4 On the contrary, transactions in which an essential payment condition is the granting of the right to use copyright in a digital product uploaded electronically for this purpose will result in royalties. This applies, for example, to a book publisher who pays for the purchase of the right to reproduce a copyrighted image, which he downloads electronically to be placed on the cover of a book he is publishing. In this transaction, an essential condition for making a payment is the acquisition of the right to use copyright in a digital product, i.e. the rights to reproduce and distribute an image, and not just the acquisition of digital content.
18. The suggestions made above regarding mixed contracts may also apply to certain performances by artists and, in particular, to an orchestral concert conducted by a conductor or a concert given by a musician. The fee for a musical performance, together with the payment for any simultaneous radio broadcast, appears to fall under the scope of Article 17. If a concert is recorded under the same or a separate contract, and the performer stipulates that royalties for the sale or public reproduction of recordings should be paid to him on the basis of his sound recording copyrights, then that part of the payment received by him, which consists of these royalties, falls under the scope of Article 12. However, if the copyright to the sound recording, by virtue of the relevant copyright law or the terms of the contract, belongs to the person with whom the contractor has agreed to provide his services (i.e. a concert at the time of recording), or to a third party, then payments made under such an agreement are subject to Articles 7 (for example, if the performance takes place outside the State of the source of payment) or 17, and not this Article, even if these payments are conditional on the sale of recordings.
19. It is further stated that variable or fixed payments for the development of mineral deposits, sources or other natural resources are regulated by Article 6 and therefore do not fall within the scope of this Article.
Point 3
20. Some States consider that dividends, interest and royalties arising from sources in their territory and payable to natural or legal persons who are residents of other States are outside the scope of an agreement concluded to prevent their taxation both in the source State and in the beneficiary's State of residence, when the beneficiary has a permanent establishment in the former The state. Paragraph 3 is not based on a concept that is sometimes referred to as the “gravity of a permanent establishment.” It does not provide that royalties received by a resident of a Contracting State from a source in another State should, by virtue of a legal presumption or even fiction, relate to a permanent establishment that the resident may have in the latter State, so that the said State would not be obliged to limit its taxation in this case. The paragraph simply provides that in the Source State, royalties are taxed as part of the profits of a permanent establishment owned there by a beneficiary who is a resident of another State, if they are paid in respect of rights or property forming part of the assets of the permanent establishment, or otherwise actually related to that representation. In this case, paragraph 3 exempts the State of the royalty source from any restrictions in accordance with the Article. The above explanations are consistent with those contained in the Commentary to Article 7.
21. It was suggested that this paragraph could lead to abuse through the transfer of rights or property to permanent missions established solely for this purpose in countries that offer preferential treatment for royalty income. Apart from the fact that the provisions of Article 29 (and, in particular, paragraph 8 of this Article) and the principles set out in the section "Improper use of the Convention" of the Commentary to Article 1 usually prevent such illegal transactions, it should be recognized that a particular location can constitute a permanent establishment only if it is carried out commercial activity, and as explained below, the requirement that the right or property be "actually linked" to such a place requires more, rather than simply registering rights or property in the books of a permanent mission for accounting purposes.
21.1 The right or property in respect of which royalties are paid will actually be associated with the permanent establishment and, therefore, will form part of its business assets if the "economic" ownership of this right or property is attributed to this permanent establishment in accordance with the principles developed in the Committee's report "Attribution of profits to permanent missions"1 (see, in particular, paragraphs 72-97 of Part I of the report) for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of article 7. In the context of this paragraph, "economic" ownership of a right or property means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of a separate enterprise with associated benefits and encumbrances (for example, the right to royalties related to ownership of the right or property, the right to any available depreciation and potential exposure to gains or losses from an increase or decrease in the value of that right or property).
21.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether a right or property is effectively linked to a permanent establishment is carried out with due regard to the guidelines set out in part IV of the Committee's report on whether income or profit from this right or property is taken into account when determining the profitability of a permanent establishment based on the amount of investment assets attributed to it (see, in particular, paragraphs 165-170 of Part IV). Since these recommendations are of a general nature, tax authorities should consider adopting a flexible and pragmatic approach that would take into account the reasonable and consistent application of these recommendations by the enterprise for the purpose of identifying specific assets that are effectively associated with a permanent establishment.
Item 4
22. The purpose of this paragraph is to limit the use of provisions relating to the taxation of royalties in cases where, due to the special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner, or between both of them and another person, the amount of royalties paid exceeds the amount that would have been agreed by the payer and the beneficial owner if they had applied market conditions. It provides that in such a case the provisions of the Article shall apply only to the last mentioned amount and that the excess part of the royalties shall continue to be taxed in accordance with the laws of the two Contracting States, with due regard to the other provisions of the Convention. The clause allows only the adjustment of the amount of royalties, and not the reclassification of royalties in such a way as to give them a different character, for example, a contribution to equity. In order for such an adjustment to be possible in accordance with paragraph 4 of Article 12, it would be necessary, at a minimum, to delete the restrictive phrase "with respect to the use, rights or information for which they are paid". If it seems appropriate to provide greater clarity of intent, the phrase "for any reason" may be added after the word "exceeds".
___________________________
1 Attribution of profits to Permanent Missions, OECD, Paris, 2010
23. It is clear from the text that for the application of this paragraph, payments withheld excessively must be conditioned by a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner or between both of them and some other person. Examples include cases where royalties are paid to an individual or legal entity that directly or indirectly exercises control over the payer, or is directly or indirectly controlled by him, or is subordinate to a group that has common interests with him. In addition, these examples are similar or similar to the cases provided for in Article 9.
24. On the other hand, the concept of a special relationship also covers blood or marital relations, and in general any community of interests, as opposed to legal relations leading to the payment of royalties.
25. With regard to the taxation regime applicable to the excess part of royalties, the exact nature of such excess will need to be determined depending on the circumstances of each specific case in order to determine the category of income to which it should be attributed for the purposes of applying the provisions of the tax legislation of the respective States and the provisions of the Convention. If two Contracting States have difficulty defining other provisions of the Convention applicable, as appropriate, to the excess portion of royalties, there is nothing that could prevent them from including additional explanations in the last sentence of paragraph 4, if they do not change its general meaning.
26. If the principles and rules of their respective legislations oblige two Contracting States to apply different Articles of the Convention in order to tax the surplus, then it will be necessary to resort to the mutual agreement procedure provided for in the Convention to solve this problem.
Comments on the Comment
27. Italy and Spain do not follow the interpretation in paragraph 8.2. They are of the opinion that payments in compensation for the transfer of ownership of the element mentioned in the definition of royalties are subject to the Article if not full ownership is transferred. Italy also adheres to this view with respect to paragraphs 15 and 16.
27.1 With regard to paragraph 10.1, Italy considers that if contracts grant exclusive distribution rights to a product or service together with other rights listed in the definition of royalties, the portion of the payment made under these contracts as compensation for exclusive distribution rights to the product or service may, depending on the circumstances, fall under subject to the Article.
28. Mexico, Portugal and Spain do not adhere to the interpretation in paragraphs 14, 14.4, 15, 16 and 17.1 - 17.4. Mexico, Portugal and Spain consider that payments related to the software fall within the scope of the Article if the rights to the Software are not fully transferred, or if payments are made in compensation for the right to use the copyright to the software for commercial use (with the exception of payments for the right to distribute standardized copies of the software, not including the right to individual customization or reproduction), or if they relate to software purchased for commercial use by the buyer, when, in this latter case, the software is not fully standardized, but is adapted to the customer in some way.
29. Mexico does not follow the interpretation in paragraph 8.2. Mexico is of the opinion that payments in compensation for the transfer of rights presented as alienation (i.e. rights limited geographically or in time) fall within the scope of this Article, since not all rights inherent in the property element specified in the definition are transferred.
30. Slovakia does not adhere to the interpretation in paragraphs 14, 15 and 17. Slovakia considers that payments related to software are subject to the Article if not all rights to the software are transferred, or if payments are made in compensation for the right to use copyright in the software for commercial use, or if they relate to software purchased for personal or commercial use by the buyer. when, in this latter case, the software is not fully standardized, but is adapted to the customer in some way.
31. Greece does not adhere to the interpretation in paragraphs 14 and 15 above. Greece considers that payments related to software fall within the scope of this Article if payments are made in compensation for use (or the right to use) Software for commercial use, or for personal and business purposes of the buyer.
31.1 With regard to paragraph 14, Korea is of the view that the paragraph may ignore the fact that know-how may be transferred in the form of computer software. Thus, Korea considers that know-how transferred by non-residents through software or computer program should be considered in accordance with Article 12.
31.2 Italy does not agree that the interpretation in paragraph 14.4 will apply in all cases. It will consider each case taking into account all the circumstances, including the rights granted in relation to acts of distribution.
31.3 With regard to paragraph 9.1, Germany remains of the opinion as to whether, and if so, under what circumstances, payments made to acquire the right to dispose of the transportation capacity of pipelines or the capacity of technical installations, lines or cables for the transmission of electricity or communications (including the broadcasting of radio and television programs) can be considered as payments for the purpose of renting industrial, commercial, or scientific equipment.
31.4 Greece does not adhere to the interpretation of the sixth dash in paragraph 11.4 and considers that all relevant payments fall within the scope of the Article.
31.5 Greece does not follow the interpretation in paragraphs 17.2 and 17.3, since payments related to the download of computer software should be considered as royalties, even if these products are purchased for personal or business purposes of the buyer.
31.6 With regard to paragraph 9.1, Chile and Mexico remain divided as to whether, and if so, under what circumstances, payments may be made to acquire the right to dispose of the transportation capacity of pipelines or the capacity of technical installations, lines or cables for the transmission of electricity or communications (including the broadcasting of radio and television programs), be considered as payments for the purpose of renting industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
31.7 Turkey remains of the opinion as to whether, and if so, under what circumstances, the payments referred to in paragraphs 9.1, 9.3, 10.1 and 10.2 should constitute royalties.
Point 1
Reservations to the Article
32. The United States reserves the right to tax, in accordance with its domestic law, royalties paid by an "expatriate legal entity" to a related person for a period of ten years.
32.1 Latvia reserves the right to impose withholding tax on royalties if the recipient of the income is a natural person resident in a Contracting State.
33. Greece cannot accept a provision that would prevent it from including in bilateral agreements on the avoidance of double taxation a clause granting it the right to tax royalties at a rate of up to 10 percent.
34. The Czech Republic reserves the right to tax royalties at a rate of 10%, which, according to Czech law, have a source in the Czech Republic. The Czech Republic also reserves the right to apply a tax regime to payments for use or the right to use software rights that is different from the regime provided for copyrights.
35. Canada remains committed to paragraph 1 and wishes to maintain the 10% withholding tax rate in its bilateral agreements. However, Canada would be willing to grant tax relief on royalties in respect of cultural, dramatic, musical or artistic works, but not including royalties in respect of motion pictures and works on film or videotape or other means of reproduction for use in connection with television. Canada would also be willing, in most cases, to grant an exemption from payment of royalties in respect of computer software, patents and know-how.
36. Australia, Chile, Korea, Mexico, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia and Turkey reserve the right to impose withholding tax on royalties.
37. Italy reserves the right to tax royalties at source, but is prepared to provide favorable treatment for certain royalties (for example, royalties). Italy also reserves the right to apply a tax regime different from that provided for copyright in relation to the use or the right to use software rights.
Item 2
38. Greece reserves the right to include the payments mentioned in paragraphs 9.1, 9.2 and 9.3 in the definition of royalties.
39. Australia reserves the right to change the definition of royalties to include payments or loans that are considered royalties under its domestic law.
40. Canada, Chile, the Czech Republic, Latvia and Slovakia reserve the right to add the words “for the use or the right to use industrial, commercial or scientific equipment” in paragraph 2.
41. Greece, Italy and Mexico reserve the right to continue to include income earned from the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and containers in the definition of "royalties", as provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the 1977 Model Convention.
41.1 Poland reserves the right to include in the definition of "royalties" income derived from the use or the right to use industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and containers.
42. New Zealand reserves the right to impose withholding tax on the source of income from the rental of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and containers.
43. Excluded]
44. [Excluded]
45. [Excluded]
46. Turkey reserves the right to withhold tax on rental income from industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
46.1 Mexico and the United States reserve the right to consider royalties as profits derived from the alienation of property described in paragraph 2 of the Article, that these profits depend on the productivity, use or alienation of property.
47. [Excluded]
Other reservations
48. Australia, Belgium, Canada, Chile, the Czech Republic, Estonia, France, Israel, Latvia, Mexico, Slovakia and Slovenia reserve the right, in order to fill what they consider to be a gap in the Article, to propose a provision defining the source of royalties by analogy with the provisions of paragraph 5 of Article 11, which addresses the same problem in in the case of percentages.
49. Mexico reserves the right to propose a provision according to which royalties will be considered to arise in a Contracting State if such royalties relate to the use or right to use in that Contracting State any property or right described in paragraph 2 of Article 12.
50. Slovakia reserves the right to apply a tax regime different from that provided for copyright in relation to the use or the right to use software rights.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 13
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF CAPITAL GAINS
I. Preliminary remarks
1. A comparison of the tax laws of the OECD Contracting States shows that the taxation of capital gains varies significantly from country to country:
— in some countries, capital gains are not considered taxable income;
— in other countries, capital gains accrued to an enterprise are taxable, but capital gains earned by an individual outside of his commercial or business activities are not taxable.;
— even if the capital gains earned by an individual outside of his commercial or entrepreneurial activities are taxable, such taxation is often applied only in specific cases, for example, profits from the sale of real estate or speculative profits (if the asset was purchased for resale).
2. In addition, taxes on capital gains vary from country to country. In some OECD countries, capital gains are taxed as ordinary income and are therefore added to income from other sources. This is especially true for the capital gains earned from the disposal of the company's assets. However, in a number of OECD member countries, capital gains are subject to special taxes, such as taxes on gains from the alienation of real estate, or general taxes on capital gains, or taxes on capital appreciation (incremental taxes). Such taxes are levied on each capital gain or amount of capital gain accrued during the year, mainly at special rates that do not take into account other income (or losses) of the taxpayer. There is no need to describe all these taxes.
3. The article does not address the above issues. The decision on whether and how capital gains should be taxed remains with the domestic law of each Contracting State. This Article cannot in any way be interpreted as giving the State the right to tax capital gains, unless such a right is provided for by its domestic legislation.
3.1 The Article does not specify which type of tax it refers to. It is understood that this Article should apply to all types of taxes levied by a Contracting State on capital gains. The wording of Article 2 is broad enough to achieve this goal and also includes special taxes on capital gains. In addition, in cases where the article allows a Contracting State to tax capital gains, this right applies to all profits, and not only to that part of them that accumulated after the entry into force of the agreement (taking into account conflicting provisions that may be agreed upon during bilateral negotiations), even in the case of a new an agreement that replaces the previous one, which did not allow such taxation.
II. Commentary on the provisions of the Article
General notes
4. Usually, the right to tax capital gains on property of this type is granted to the State, which, in accordance with the Convention, has the right to tax both this property and the income derived from it. The right to tax profits from the alienation of a commercial asset should be granted to the same State, regardless of whether such profits are capital gains or commercial gains. Accordingly, no distinction is made between capital gains and commercial profits, and there is no need for special provisions as to whether the Capital Gains Clause or Article 7 on taxation of commercial profits should apply. However, the decision on whether to levy income tax on capital or ordinary income is left to the discretion of the domestic legislation of the taxing State. The Convention does not provide a solution to this issue.
5. The article does not provide a detailed definition of the return on capital. This is not necessary for the reasons mentioned above. The words "alienation of property" are used, in particular, to cover capital gains derived from the sale or exchange of property, as well as as a result of partial alienation, expropriation, transfer of a company in exchange for shares, sale of a right, donation, and even transfer of property after death.
6. Most States that tax capital gains do so when disposing of fixed assets. However, some of them tax only the so-called realized capital gains. In certain circumstances, despite the disposal, no realized capital gains are recognized for tax purposes (for example, when proceeds from the disposal are used to purchase new assets). The availability of sales must be determined in accordance with the applicable domestic tax legislation. There are no special problems when the state, which has the right to tax, does not implement it at the time of alienation.
7. As a rule, an increase in value that is not related to the alienation of fixed assets is not taxable, since as long as the owner still owns the asset, capital gains exist only on paper. However, there are tax laws according to which capital appreciation and revaluation of business assets are taxed, even if there is no alienation.
8. Special circumstances may lead to taxation of capital appreciation of assets that have not been disposed of. This may be the case if the value of the underlying asset has increased in such a way that the owner proceeds to revalue this asset in his books. Such a revaluation of assets in the books may occur in the event of a devaluation of the national currency. A number of States levy special taxes on such balance sheet profits, amounts deferred to the reserve, increases in paid-up capital and other revaluations as a result of adjusting the book value to reflect the intrinsic value of the underlying asset. These capital appreciation taxes (incremental taxes) are subject to the Convention in accordance with Article 2.
9. In cases where capital appreciation and revaluation of commercial assets are taxable, the same principle should generally apply as in the case of disposal of such assets. It was considered inappropriate to explicitly mention such cases in the article or to establish special rules. The provisions of this Article, as well as Articles 6, 7 and 21, seem sufficient. As a rule, the right to taxation is granted by the above provisions to the State of which the alienator is a resident, except that in the case of immovable property or movable property that is part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment, the preferential right to taxation belongs to the State in which such property is located. However, special attention should be paid to the cases discussed in paragraphs 13-17 below.
10. In some States, the transfer of an asset from a permanent establishment located in the territory of such a State to a permanent establishment or head office of the same enterprise located in another State is equivalent to the alienation of property. The Article does not prevent these States from taxing profits or income deemed to arise from such transfers, provided, however, that such taxation is consistent with Article 7.
11. The article makes no distinction as to the origin of capital gains. Thus, all capital gains are covered, both accumulated over a long period of time in parallel with a steady improvement in economic conditions, and accumulated over a very short period (speculative gain). Capital gains related to the depreciation of the national currency are also covered. Of course, the decision on whether to tax such income remains with each State.
12. This article does not specify how the return on capital is calculated, as this remains at the discretion of the current domestic legislation. As a rule, the return on capital is calculated by deducting the cost from the sale price. To calculate the cost, all the costs associated with the purchase and all the costs of improvements are added to the purchase price. In some cases, the cost is taken into account after deducting the already mentioned depreciation charges. Some tax laws prescribe a different base instead of the value, for example, the value previously reported by the alienator of the asset for capital taxation purposes.
13. Particular problems may arise in cases where the basis for taxation of capital gains in the two Contracting States is not uniform. Capital gains from the disposal of an asset calculated in one State in accordance with the rules mentioned in paragraph 12 above may not necessarily coincide with capital gains calculated in another State in accordance with the accounting rules applied here. This can happen when one State has the right to tax capital gains because it is the State of Location, while another State has the right to tax because the enterprise is a resident of that other State.
14. This problem can be illustrated by the following example: an enterprise of State A has acquired real estate located in State B. The company could make depreciation charges to the books kept in State A. If such real estate is sold at a price exceeding cost, capital gains can be realized, and, in addition, previously provided depreciation charges can be restored. State B, in which the immovable property is located and where accounting books are not maintained, should not take into account, when taxing income from immovable property, depreciation charges registered in State A. Also, State B cannot replace the value of immovable property reflected in accounting books kept in State A with the value at the time of alienation. Thus, State B cannot tax depreciation deductions realized in addition to the capital gains mentioned in paragraph 12 above.
15. On the other hand, State A, of which the alienator is a resident, may not be required in all cases to fully exempt such balance sheet profits from its taxes in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article and Article 23 A (for States applying the tax relief method, it is unlikely that any problems will arise). If such a balance sheet gain is due to the realization of depreciation charges previously announced in State A and reduced the income or profit subject to taxation in such State A, that State may not be deprived of the right to tax such balance sheet profit. This situation corresponds to that discussed in paragraph 44 of the Commentary to Article 23 A.
16. Further problems may arise in connection with profits due to changes in the exchange rate between the currencies of State A and State B. After the devaluation of the currency of State A, enterprises of State A may or may be forced to increase the book value of assets located outside the territory of State A. In addition to any devaluation of the currency of the State, ordinary exchange rate fluctuations can lead to so-called foreign exchange gains or losses. Take, for example, an enterprise of State A that has bought and sold real estate located in State B. If the value and the selling price expressed in the currency of State B are equal, then there will be no return on capital in State B. If the value of the currency of State B has increased between the purchase and sale of an asset in relation to the currency of State A, the profit will be credited to such an enterprise in the currency of that State. If at the same time the value of the currency of State B has decreased, the alienator will incur losses that will not be recognized in State B. Such foreign currency gains or losses may also arise from claims and debts denominated in foreign currencies. If the balance sheet of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of State A located in State B reflects claims and debts denominated in the currency of State B, then no profits or losses on payments are reflected in the books of the permanent establishment. However, changes in the exchange rate may be reflected in the accounts of the head office. If the value of the State's currency has increased (fallen) between the time of the claim and its repayment, the company as a whole will make a profit (incur a loss). This is also true of debts if, in the period between their origination and repayment, the currency of the State has fallen (increased) in value.
17. The provisions of the Article do not resolve all issues related to the taxation of such foreign currency profits. In most cases, this profit is not related to the disposal of the asset; often it is not even determined in the State, which, in accordance with the Article, is granted the right to tax capital gains. Accordingly, the question, as a rule, is not whether the State in which the permanent establishment is located has the right to taxation, but whether the State in which the taxpayer is a resident should refrain from taxation of such foreign currency profits, which in many cases are reflected only in accounting books, when applying the tax exemption method., stored at the head office. The answer to this last question depends not only on the Article, but also on Articles 7 and 23 A. If, in a particular case, differences of opinion between the two States lead to de facto double taxation, this case should be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25.
18. In addition, the question arises which Article should be applied in the case when an annuity is paid for the sold property during the alienator's lifetime, rather than a fixed price. Should such annuity payments, if they exceed expenses, be considered as profits from the alienation of property or as “income not considered" in accordance with Article 21? Both opinions can be supported by arguments of equal strength, and it seems difficult to make a single decision on this issue. In addition, such problems are rare in practice, so it seems unnecessary to establish a rule for its inclusion in the Convention. Contracting States that may participate in the consideration of such an issue may be given the right to make a decision through the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25.
19. This Article does not apply to lottery prizes, or to awards and prizes related to bonds or debentures.
20. Paragraphs 1-4 of the Article primarily relate to profits from the alienation of certain categories of property. With respect to all other capital gains, paragraph 5 grants the right to taxation to the State of which the alienator is a resident.
21. Since capital gains are not taxed by any State, it may be considered advisable to avoid only the actual double taxation of capital gains. Consequently, the Contracting States may supplement their bilateral agreements in such a way that a State must waive its right to taxation granted to it by domestic law only if it is used by another State to which the right to taxation is granted by the Convention. In this case, paragraph 5 of the Article should be supplemented accordingly. In addition, the amendments proposed in paragraph 35 of the Commentary to Article 23A should be made to Article 23a.
Point 1
22. Paragraph 1 states that profits from the alienation of immovable property may be taxed in the State in which it is located. This rule complies with the provisions of Article 6 and paragraph 1 of Article 22. This also applies to real estate, which is part of the company's assets. With regard to the definition of immovable property, paragraph 1 refers to Article 6. Paragraph 1 of Article 13 refers only to the profits that a resident of a Contracting State receives from the alienation of immovable property located in the other Contracting State. Therefore, it does not apply to profits resulting from the alienation of immovable property located in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident within the meaning of Article 4, or located in a third State; the provisions of paragraph 5 apply to such profits (and not, as mentioned in this commentary as amended before 2002, the provisions of paragraph 1 Of Article 21).
23. The norms of paragraph 1 are supplemented by the norms from paragraph 4, which applies to profits from the sale of shares or comparable shares, more than 50 percent of the value of which is in real estate (see paragraphs 28.3 - 28.12 below).
Item 2
24. Paragraph 2 deals with movable property that is part of the commercial property of a permanent representative office of an enterprise. The term “movable property" means all property other than immovable property, which is considered in paragraph 1. It also includes intangible assets such as goodwill, licenses, emissions permits, etc. Profits from the alienation of such assets may be taxed in the State in whose territory the permanent establishment is located, which complies with the rules on commercial profits (Article 7).
25. The paragraph clearly states that its rules apply to the alienation of movable property of a permanent establishment, as well as to the alienation of a permanent establishment as such (separately or with the entire enterprise). If the entire enterprise is alienated, this rule applies to such profits, which are considered to be the result of the alienation of movable property forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment. In this case, the rules of article 7 should be applied with the necessary modifications without direct reference to them. With regard to the transfer of an asset from a permanent establishment in one State to a permanent establishment (or head office) in another State, see paragraph 10 above.
26. On the other hand, paragraph 2 may not always apply to capital gains from the alienation of participation in an enterprise. If an enterprise carries on its activities in the form of an organization or agreement that is considered transparent for tax purposes in accordance with the tax laws of a Contracting State, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 13, that State will be permitted to tax income derived from the alienation of movable property forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment of the enterprise located in that State., even in cases where these revenues arise as a result of the alienation of the enterprise as a whole (see See also paragraph 2 of Article 1 and paragraphs 2-16 of the Commentary to Article 1). However, if an enterprise carries on its activities in the form of an organization or agreement that a State considers to be a separate taxpayer resident in one of the Contracting States, that State should treat the alienation of participation in such an organization or agreement in the same way as the shares of a company to which paragraphs 4 or 5 of this Article apply. Paragraphs 32.4 to 32.7 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B address situations where the domestic laws of the two Contracting States differ in this regard.
27. Some States consider that all capital gains arising from sources in their territory should be subject to taxation in accordance with their domestic legislation if the alienator has a permanent establishment in their territory. Paragraph 2 is not based on a concept that is sometimes referred to as the “gravity of a permanent establishment.” The paragraph simply provides that profits from the alienation of movable property that is part of the commercial profits of a permanent establishment may be taxed in the State where the permanent establishment is located. Profits from the alienation of all other movable property are taxable only in the State of which the alienator is a resident, in accordance with paragraph 5. The above explanations are consistent with those provided in the Commentary to Article 7.
27.1 For the purposes of this paragraph, property will be included in the commercial profits of a permanent establishment if the "economic" ownership of property is transferred to that permanent establishment in accordance with the principles developed in the Committee's report entitled Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments [1 Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments, OECD, Paris, 2010.(Attribution of profits to Permanent Establishments permanent Missions, OECD, Paris, 2010)] (see, in particular, paragraphs 72-97 of Part I of the report) for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 7. In the context of this paragraph, "economic" ownership of property means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of an individual enterprise, with associated benefits and burdens (for example, the right to interest related to ownership of a debt claim and potential gains or losses from an increase or decrease in the value of the debt claim). The mere fact that the property was registered on the balance sheet of a permanent establishment for accounting purposes will not be sufficient to conclude that it is actually related to that permanent establishment.
27.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether the property is actually linked to the permanent establishment should take into account the recommendations set out in Part IV of the Committee's report on whether income or profit from this property is taken into account when determining the income of the permanent establishment from the amount of investment assets attributed to its account (see, in particular, paragraphs 165 - 170 of Part IV). These recommendations are of a general nature, therefore, the tax authorities should consider the possibility of applying a flexible and pragmatic approach that would take into account the reasonable and consistent application of these recommendations by the enterprise in order to identify specific assets that are actually associated with a permanent establishment.
Point 3
28. An exception to rule 2 is provided for ships and aircraft operated in international traffic and movable property related to the operation of such ships and aircraft. As a rule, income from the alienation of such assets is taxed only in the State of the enterprise operating such vessels and aircraft. This rule complies with the provisions of Article 8 and paragraph 3 of Article 22. Contracting States that would prefer to grant the exclusive right to taxation to the State in whose territory the actual location of the management bodies of the enterprise is located may, within the framework of bilateral agreements, replace paragraph 3 with a provision corresponding to that proposed in paragraph 2 of the Commentary to Article 8.
28.1 Paragraph 3 applies if the company alienating the property itself operates the ships or aircraft referred to in paragraph, both for its own transportation activities and when renting ships or aircraft on charter terms, fully equipped, supplied and staffed. However, it does not apply in cases where an enterprise that owns ships or aircraft does not operate them (for example, if the enterprise leases property to another person, unless this is an accidental bareboat charter lease in accordance with paragraph 5 of the Commentary to Article 8). In this case, the profits earned by the true owner of the property or related movable property will be covered by paragraphs 2 or 5.
28.2 [Excluded]
Item 4
28.3 Providing that profits from the alienation of shares or comparable shares that at any time during the 365-day period preceding the alienation directly or indirectly receive more than 50 percent of their value from immovable property located in a Participating State may be taxed in that State, paragraph 4 provides that income from the alienation of such shares shares or comparable shares and gains from the alienation of major immovable property that fall within the scope of paragraph 1 shall be equally taxable in that State.
28.4 Paragraph 4 allows for the taxation of all profits related to shares or comparable interests to which it applies, even if part of the value of those shares or comparable interests is derived from property other than immovable property located in the State of origin. It is usually determined whether shares or comparable interests receive at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation more than 50 percent of their value directly or indirectly from immovable property located in a Contracting State by comparing the value of such immovable property with the value of all property owned by a company, a legal entity or an agreement, without accounting for debts or other obligations (regardless of whether they are secured by a mortgage on the relevant real estate or not).
28.5 Until 2017, paragraph 4 applied only in the case of divestment of shares, but the Commentary provided that States could expand its scope to also cover profits from divestment of shares in other organizations, such as partnerships or trusts that do not issue shares, provided that the value of these shares is similarly derived primarily from from real estate. In 2017, a link to “comparable shares" was added for this purpose. At the same time, this paragraph has been amended to cover situations where shares or comparable shares derive their value primarily from real estate at any time during the 365 days preceding the sale, and not just at the time of the sale. This amendment was introduced in order to address situations where assets are transferred to an enterprise shortly before the sale of shares or other comparable interests in that enterprise, in order to reduce the share of the value of those shares or interests derived from immovable property located in a Contracting State.
28.6 In their bilateral agreements, many States either expand or narrow the scope of this paragraph. For example, States may increase or decrease the percentage of the value of shares or comparable shares that must be directly or indirectly derived from real estate in order to apply this provision. This can be done simply by replacing "50 percent" with the percentage that these States would agree to. Another change that some States may agree to make is to limit the application of this provision to cases where the alienator has a certain level of involvement in the organization.
28.7 In addition, some States consider that the paragraph should not apply to profits earned from the sale of shares in companies or interests in organizations or agreements listed on an approved stock exchange of one of the States, to profits earned from the sale of shares or comparable shares during the reorganization of the company, or if immovable property, from which shares or comparable shares derive their value is real estate (for example, a mine or a hotel) where business activities are conducted. States may provide for one or more of these exceptions.
28.8 Another possible exception concerns shares or comparable shares owned by pension funds and similar organizations. In accordance with the domestic legislation of many States, pension funds and similar organizations are usually exempt from paying tax on their investment income. In order to ensure a neutral regime with respect to domestic and foreign investments of these entities, some States provide on a bilateral basis that income earned by such a resident entity of another State, which included capital gains on shares or comparable shares referred to in paragraph 4, is exempt from taxation based on the source principle. States wishing to do so may agree bilaterally on a provision formulated in accordance with the provision contained in paragraph 69 of the Commentary to Article 18.
28.9 Since the clause applies in any case where, at any time during the 365 days preceding the disposal of shares or comparable shares, these shares or comparable shares directly or indirectly receive more than 50 percent of their value from immovable property, this clause will apply when shares are disposed of within 365 days after the day when the immovable property, the value of which is taken into account for the purposes of this paragraph, has itself been alienated by the company or another entity. Some States consider that in such a case, since the alienation of immovable property is taxable in accordance with paragraph 1 in the State where it is located, it would not be appropriate to take into account the value of that property when determining whether paragraph 4 should apply to profits from the subsequent alienation of shares or comparable interests. Suppose, for example, that an individual X, a resident of State R, owns all shares of XCO, a company resident in State R. XCO's main asset is real estate located in the State of S. In January 00, the property is sold to XCO and the State taxes the profits in accordance with paragraph 1. At the end of 00, X dies, which, according to the domestic legislation of the State of S, leads to the alienation of XCO shares for tax purposes. In this case, some States consider that the value of the alienated immovable property should not be taken into account when applying paragraph 4 to shares alienated as a result of X's death. These States may, on a bilateral basis, agree to replace paragraph 4 with the following provision::
4. Profits earned by a resident of a Contracting State from the alienation of shares or comparable shares, such as shares in a partnership or trust, may be taxed in the other Contracting State if at any time during the 365 days preceding the alienation, these shares or comparable shares directly or indirectly received more than 50 percent of their value from immovable property, definition which is referred to in Article 6, located in that other State (with the exception of immovable property or part thereof, which was alienated between this period and the period of alienation of shares or comparable shares, until no part of the value of these shares or comparable shares is obtained directly or indirectly from this immovable property or part of it that was alienated during this subsequent alienation).
States concerned that the exclusion provided for in this proposed provision could be violated by arranging sales between related parties may consider limiting its scope to divestitures between unrelated parties. In addition, States whose domestic tax legislation does not recognize capital gains in certain types of alienation may remove such alienation from the scope of the exception included in the proposed provision.
28.10 Finally, another possible exception concerns shares and comparable shares in a real estate investment trust (see paragraphs 67.1-67.7 of the Commentary to Article 10 for information on REITs). Although it does not seem appropriate to make an exception to paragraph 4 in the case of the alienation of a large investor's stake in a REIT, which may be considered as the alienation of a substitute for direct investment in real estate, an exception to paragraph 4 for the alienation of a small investor's stake in a REIT may be considered appropriate.
28.11 As discussed in paragraph 67.3 of the Commentary to Article 10, it may be appropriate to consider a small investor's share in a REIT as collateral rather than as indirect ownership of real estate. In this regard, in practice it would be very difficult to manage the application of taxation based on the principle of source of profit to small shares in widespread REITs. In addition, since REITs, unlike other organizations that derive their value primarily from real estate, are required to distribute most of their profits, it is unlikely that there will be significant residual profits to which capital gains tax will apply (compared to other organizations). States that share this point of view may agree on a bilateral basis to add words such as "with the exception of shares or comparable shares owned by a person who directly or indirectly owns shares or participation interests amounting to less than 10 percent of all shares or participation interests in an organization" before the phrase "may be taxed in this other State". if this organization is a REIT."
28.12 However, some States consider that paragraph 4 was intended to apply to any profits from the disposal of shares or similar interests in an enterprise that derives its value primarily from immovable property, and that there would be no reason to distinguish between a REIT and a public enterprise with respect to the application of this paragraph, especially given that that the REIT is not taxed on its income. These States consider that as long as there is no exception for the disposal of shares or similar interests in listed entities (see paragraph 28.7 above), there should be no special exception for interests in REITs.
28.13 Since the domestic legislation of some States does not allow them to tax income covered by paragraph 4, States applying the exemption method should carefully ensure that the inclusion of this paragraph does not lead to a double exemption of these incomes. These States may wish to exclude these profits from the scope of the exemption and apply the benefits method as proposed in paragraph 35 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B.
Item 5
29. With regard to income from the alienation of any property not specified in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4, paragraph 5 provides that they are subject to taxation only in the State of which the alienator is a resident. This is in accordance with the rules set out in Article 22.
30. This Article does not contain any special rules regarding income from the alienation of company shares (with the exception of the company's shares specified in paragraph 4), securities, bonds, debentures, etc. Thus, such income is subject to taxation only in the State of which the alienator is a resident.
31. If the shares are disposed of by a shareholder in connection with the liquidation of the issuing company, the repurchase of shares or a reduction in the paid-up capital of this company, the difference between the proceeds received by the shareholder and the nominal value of the shares may be considered in the State of which the company is a resident as a distribution of accumulated profits, and not as a return on capital. The article does not prevent the State of which the company is a resident from taxing such distributions at the rates provided for in Article 10: such taxation is permitted, since this difference is included in the definition of "dividends" contained in paragraph 3 of Article 10 and interpreted in paragraph 28 of the Commentary thereto, if the domestic legislation of that State considers such a difference as a stock income. As explained in paragraphs 32.1 - 32.7 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B, if the State of the issuing company considers the difference as a dividend, the State of residence of the shareholder is obliged to ensure exemption from double taxation, even if such a difference represents a return on capital in accordance with its own domestic legislation. The same interpretation may apply if the bonds or debentures are repaid by the debtor at a price that is higher than the face value or the value at which the bonds or debentures were issued.; In such a case, the difference may constitute interest and, therefore, be subject to limited taxation in the State of the source of interest in accordance with Article 11 (see also paragraphs 20 and 21 of the Commentary to Article 11).
32. It is necessary to distinguish the capital gains that can be obtained as a result of the disposal of shares acquired through the use of a stock option granted to an employee or a member of the board of directors from the profits earned from a stock option, which are covered by Articles 15 or 16. The principles according to which this distinction is made are discussed in paragraphs 12.2 - 12.5 of the Commentary to Article 15 and paragraph 3 of the Commentary to Article 16.
Note to the Comment
32.1 With regard to paragraph 3.1, Austria and Germany are of the opinion that, upon the entry into force of the new agreement, these countries cannot be deprived of the right to tax capital gains earned in these countries prior to the date of entry into force of the new tax agreement.
Reservations to the Article
33. Spain reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of shares or other rights if ownership of such shares or rights directly or indirectly gives the right to use real estate located in Spain.
34. Sweden reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of property by an individual who was a resident of Sweden at any time during the ten years preceding such alienation.
35. Finland reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of shares or other corporate rights in Finnish companies if the ownership of such shares or other corporate rights gives the right to use real estate located in Finland and owned by the company.
36. France may accept the provisions of paragraph 5, but wishes to retain the possibility of applying the provisions of its legislation relating to the taxation of profits from the alienation of shares or rights forming part of a substantial participation in a French company.
37. The United States reserves the right to include a provision providing for an increase in the base of an individual's property, the value of which was taxed in accordance with the exit tax regime.
38. New Zealand remains committed to paragraphs 3 and 5.
39. Chile reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of shares or other corporate rights in its companies.
40. Turkey reserves the right, in accordance with its legislation, to tax capital gains resulting from the alienation on its territory of movable capital and any property other than the property referred to in paragraph 2.
41. Notwithstanding paragraph 5 of this Article, if the sale price of shares is considered a dividend in accordance with Danish law, Denmark reserves the right to tax that sale price as a dividend in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 10.
42. Latvia reserves the right to include in a special Article provisions concerning capital gains related to activities carried out on the shelf of a Contracting State in connection with the exploration or exploitation of the seabed, its subsoil and its natural resources.
43. Denmark, Ireland, Norway and the United Kingdom reserve the right to include in a special Article provisions concerning capital gains related to the exploration and exploitation of hydrocarbons on the shelf and related activities.
43.1 Greece reserves the right to include in a special Article provisions concerning capital gains related to the exploration and exploitation of the shelf and related activities.
44. Denmark, Norway and Sweden reserve the right to include special provisions regarding capital gains earned by the Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS) air transport consortium.
45. Korea reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of shares or other rights forming part of a substantial participation in a resident company.
46. The United States wants to retain the right to apply its tax on certain real estate income in accordance with the law on foreign investment in real estate.
47. Taking into account its special situation in shipping, Greece will retain freedom of action with respect to the provisions of the Convention concerning capital gains from the alienation of ships in international traffic and movable property related to the operation of such ships.
48. Ireland reserves the right to tax profits from the alienation of property by an individual who was a resident of Ireland at any time during the five years preceding such alienation.
49. Mexico remains committed to maintaining the possibility of applying the provisions of its own legislation regarding the taxation of profits from the sale of shares or comparable shares in a company that is a resident of Mexico.
50. The United States reserves the right to include proceeds from the disposal of containers within the scope of paragraph 3 of this Article.
51. Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Switzerland reserve the right not to include paragraph 4 in their agreements.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 14
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF INDEPENDENT PERSONAL SERVICES
[Article 14 was removed from the Model Tax Convention on April 29, 2000 on the basis of a report entitled "Issues related to Article 14 of the OECD Model Tax Convention" (approved by the Committee on Budgetary and Financial Affairs on January 27, 2000 and included in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(16)-1). This decision emphasized that there were no perceived differences between the concepts of permanent establishment used in Article 7 and the permanent base used in Article 14, or between the methods of calculating profit and tax according to which Article 7 or 14 applied. In addition, it was not always clear which activities fell within the scope of Article 14 unlike Article 7. As a consequence of the deletion of Article 14, income derived from the provision of professional services or other independent activities is now considered in Article 7 as part of commercial profits.]
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 15
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT 1
Point 1
1. Paragraph 1 establishes a general rule regarding the taxation of income from employment (other than pensions), according to which such income is subject to taxation in the State where the employment is actually carried out. The question of whether services are provided in the course of employment or not can sometimes cause difficulties, which are discussed in paragraph 8.1 et seq. Employment is carried out in the place where the employee is physically present during the performance of work for which income from hired labor is paid. One of the consequences of this is that a resident of a Contracting State who receives remuneration for employment from sources in another State may not be taxed in that other State in respect of such remuneration solely on the basis that the results of his work are used in that other State.
2. Exceptions to the general rule are only the remuneration of crew members of ships and aircraft operated in international traffic (paragraph 3 of Article 15), pensions (Article 18), as well as remuneration and pensions of civil servants (Article 19). Remuneration of members of the boards of directors of companies that is not related to employment is subject to Article 16.
2.1 Member Countries generally understand the term "wages, salaries and other similar types of remuneration" to include payments in kind received in connection with employment (for example, stock options, housing or car use, health or life insurance and club membership).
2.2 The condition stipulated in this Article regarding taxation by the source State states that wages, salaries and other similar types of remuneration must be obtained as a result of employment in that State. This rule applies regardless of when these incomes can be paid, offset, or otherwise definitively placed at the disposal of an employee.
2.3 In some cases, it may be difficult to determine how much of a salary, salary or other similar type of remuneration is earned through employment in a given State. Paragraphs 12.6 to 12.13 below address this issue regarding the granting of options to employees who are employed in other countries. The problem may also arise in the case of payments made after termination of employment. Such payments may raise questions about the tax contract in various cross-border situations, including cases where such payments are made to cross-border employees, i.e. employees who have worked in different countries during their careers, or employees who have been sent to work abroad and repatriate shortly before being laid off. Regardless of the terminology used to describe these payments, it is important to determine the real nature of each such payment based on the facts and circumstances of each case in order to determine whether the payment is a "salary, salary or other similar remuneration", and
_______________________
1 Before 2000, the title of Article 15 referred to "Dependent personal services", in contrast to the title of Article 14, which referred to "Independent personal services". As a result of the cancellation of the last
articles (see the history of Article 14 in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention) The title of Article 15 has been changed to "Employment", the term most often used to describe the activities to which this article applies. This change should not have affected the scope of the article in any way.]
The extent to which a payment or part of it can be considered to have been received as a result of employment in a given State. The following paragraphs discuss these issues in relation to the various types of payments that are often made after termination of employment (dismissal).
2.4 Any remuneration paid after dismissal for work performed prior to dismissal (for example, wages or bonuses for the last period of employment or commissions for sales made during this period) will be considered received from the State in which the relevant employment activity was carried out.
2.5 Payment for unused vacation days/ sick days accumulated during the last year of employment is part of the remuneration for the period of work that resulted in vacation or sick leave. Upon termination of employment, an employee may also be entitled to pay for vacation and sick leave days that have not been used in previous years. In the absence of facts and circumstances to the contrary, the payment received after dismissal as compensation for vacation and sick days not used in previous years should be considered the benefit to which the employee was entitled during the last 12 months of employment, distributed proportionally at the place of work during this period. One situation in which a different conclusion would be justified would be that, based on the taxpayer's employment record, it would be established that these vacation and sick days clearly relate to specific periods of past employment, and that the payment represents remuneration for these periods of employment. However, States should take into account the fact that a former employee may have previously been taxed for these vacation and sick days at the time of their accrual. Let's assume, for example, that according to the domestic tax legislation of a State, vacation and sick days granted in connection with periods of employment performed in the territory of that State are considered taxable benefits during the fiscal year during which the relevant employment was performed and are taxed accordingly. In this case, the State of residence of the former employee at the time of the subsequent payment for vacation days / sick days will have to provide an exemption from double taxation for such payment, as well as any State in which the former employee may have worked during the last year of employment, should also take into account that any payments for unused vacation days / sick days for previous years, which were already taxed on an accrual basis, did not relate to employment carried out during the last year.
2.6 In some cases, the employer is required (by law or by contract) to notify the employee in advance before dismissal. If an employee is ordered not to work after such notification and is simply paid remuneration for the period of notice of impending dismissal, such remuneration is clearly received in relation to the employment and therefore constitutes remuneration "obtained as a result of the employment" and falls within the scope of paragraph 1. In this case, it should be assumed that the remuneration received originates from the State in which, it is reasonable to assume, the employee worked during the warning period. The determination of where, it is reasonable to assume, the employee worked during the warning period should be based on all existing facts and circumstances. In most cases, this will be the last place where the employee worked for a significant period of time before being fired.; In addition, it is completely inappropriate to take into account the estimated period of employment in a State in which an employee could carry out work, but has not actually worked for a significant period of time.
2.7 Another situation is that an employer is required (by law or by contract) to pay severance pay (also called "termination pay") to an employee whose job has been terminated. Such a payment is often, but not always, calculated based on the period of the employer's previous employment. In the absence of facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, such severance pay should be considered as remuneration provided for in this Article for the last 12 months of work, distributed proportionally at the place of work during this period.; As such, it represents remuneration received for such employment and falls within the scope of the last sentence of paragraph 1.
2.8 An individual whose employment has been terminated may have legitimate grounds to claim that the employment was terminated in violation of an employment contract, law, or collective agreement; there may also be other legitimate grounds for claiming damages, depending on the circumstances of the dismissal. This individual may receive a court order or settlement as compensation for violating relevant contractual or legal obligations. The treatment of the tax contract will depend on how much damage will be compensated as a result of the award of compensation. For example, damages incurred due to insufficient notice of termination or due to the fact that severance payments required by law or contract were not paid should be considered a replacement as a reward that compensates for this damage. However, punitive damages or damages awarded on grounds such as discriminatory treatment or damage to reputation should be treated differently.; These payments are usually covered by Article 21.
2.9 In accordance with the provisions of the employment contract or post-dismissal settlement, a former employee may receive a payment for the obligation not to work for a competitor of his former employer. This commitment is almost always limited in time and often geographically. Despite the fact that such a payment is directly related to the employment and is therefore a "reward received as a result of the employment", in most cases it will not represent a reward received as a result of the employment performed before the dismissal. For this reason, it will usually be taxed only in the State where the recipient resides at the time of receipt of the payment. However, if such a post-dismissal payment is essentially a reward for activities performed during employment (which may be the case, for example, when an obligation not to work for a competitor is of little or no value to a former employee), the payment should be considered as remuneration received for activities performed during the relevant period. the period of employment. In addition, in some States, part of an employee's monthly salary for the duration of the employment is compensation for the obligation not to work for a competitor for a certain period of time after dismissal, so that no separate payment is made for such an obligation after dismissal; in this case, the provisions of the first part of this paragraph do not apply, and part of the remuneration, Any remuneration received during employment related to this obligation should be treated in the same way as the rest of this remuneration.
2.10 As explained in paragraphs 4 to 6 of the Commentary to Article 18, after termination of employment, various payments may be made in respect of pension contributions or pension rights of the former employee. According to paragraph 6 of this Commentary, "whether a specific payment should be considered as another remuneration similar to a pension, or as a final remuneration for work performed that falls within the scope of Article 15, is a matter of fact." This paragraph provides an example of "reimbursement of pension contributions (for example, after temporary employment)" as a payment that would not fall within the scope of Article 18. To the extent that such reimbursement would constitute additional remuneration for termination of previous employment, it would fall within the scope of Article 15 and should be considered as received from the State in which the employment was performed when such employment was terminated.
2.11 Payments may be made after dismissal in accordance with various deferred remuneration agreements. Such payment should be considered as remuneration provided for in Article 15 and, to the extent that it can be linked to a specific period of previous employment in that State, should be considered as a result of employment performed in that State. Since many States would not allow deferred payment of the remuneration tax for employment, even if the payment of this remuneration is deferred, it will be important for States to avoid double taxation with respect to taxes on deferred remuneration payments received after dismissal.
2.12 After termination of employment, various payments may be made in the form of incentive compensation in general and stock options in particular. Although the contractual treatment of each such payment will depend on its own characteristics, the principles set out in paragraphs 12 to 12.15, which relate specifically to stock options, will help in considering other forms of incentive compensation.
2.13 An employee may be entitled to health and life insurance for a specified period after termination of his employment. He/she may also be eligible for other benefits, such as the services of an employment consultant or recruitment agency. In the absence of facts or circumstances indicating otherwise, such benefits should be considered as remuneration falling within the scope of the Article, which comes from the State in which the employment was performed when the employment was terminated (and, consequently, when the obligation to pay such benefits arose).
2.14 Another type of payment that can be made upon or after dismissal is a compensation payment for the loss of future earnings due to injury or disability sustained during employment. The treatment of the tax contract in relation to such a payment will depend on the legal context in which it was made. For example, payments under the social security system, such as the employee's compensation fund, may fall under Articles 18, 19 or 21 (see paragraph 24 of the Commentary to Article 18). The payment, which will constitute a pension payment, will fall under the scope of Article 18. A payment made due to the fact that an employee has legitimate grounds to demand compensation from his employer for work-related illness or injury usually falls under the scope of Article 21. A payment made by an employer in accordance with the terms of an employment contract, even if the illness or injury is not related to the employment, or the employer is not responsible for this illness or injury, should be considered in the same way as severance pay: in the absence of facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, such payment should be considered as remuneration., which falls under the scope of the Article, for the last 12 months of work, distributed proportionally by place of work during this period. However, short-term disability payments made during work should be treated in the same way as sick days payments during work; such payments would fall within the scope of Article 15 (Article 17 in the case of artists and athletes) and would be taxed in the State in which the employee normally performed the work before how he got sick or injured.
2.15 Upon termination, the seller may receive a payment due to the loss of future commissions. The treatment of the tax contract in relation to such a payment will depend on the legal context in which the payment is made. Depending on the circumstances, this payment may represent deferred remuneration to which the seller was entitled in connection with previous sales, or it may be made in accordance with the provision of the employment contract according to which the seller is entitled to receive commissions from any future sales of the company to the client whom the seller brought to the employer; in both cases, the payment It should be considered as remuneration for services related to employment, which gave the right to receive a commission. The payment, which would be compensation for future commissions that the seller would probably have received if he had continued to work for the same employer, could also be compensation for wrongful termination or a form of severance pay; in this case, the payment should be treated accordingly.
2.16 As part of a transitional agreement leading to termination, an employee may receive a full or reduced salary for the period during which the employee is not employed. If the salary is paid by the employer for the period during which the employee is not supposed to work, even if the employment has not been terminated, the salary is still received by virtue of the employment and therefore represents remuneration "received as a result of the employment" and falls under the paragraph 1. The remuneration received in such a case should be considered as received from the State in which, it is reasonable to assume, the employee worked during this period, and most often this is the State in which the employment was performed before the termination of employment.
Item 2
3. Paragraph 2 contains a general exception to the rule set out in paragraph 1. This exception applies to all individuals providing employment services (sales representatives, construction workers, engineers, etc.), to the extent that their remuneration does not fall under the provisions of other Articles applicable, in particular, to government employees or to artists and athletes.
4. In order for remuneration to be eligible for tax exemption, the three conditions set out in this paragraph must be met. The first condition is that the release is limited to a period of 183 days. In addition, it stipulates that this period may not be exceeded "in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the relevant fiscal year." This is in contrast to the Draft Convention of 1963 and the Model Convention of 1977, which stipulated that the 183-day period should not be exceeded "in the relevant financial year", and this formulation created difficulties if the financial years of the Contracting States did not coincide, sometimes allowing for opportunities in the sense of organizing work in such a way that For example, employees stayed in this State for the last 5.5 months of one year and the first 5.5 months of the following year. The current wording of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 does not allow using such an opportunity to avoid taxation. When applying this formulation, it is necessary to consider all possible periods of twelve consecutive months, even those periods that overlap others to a certain extent. For example, if an employee stays in one State for 150 days, between April 1, 2001 and March 31, 2002, and is present in it for
210 days — from August 1, 2001 and July 31, 2002, the employee will be considered to have been present for a period of more than 183 days during the second twelve-month period mentioned above, even though he does not meet the criterion of minimum presence in the first period under review and this first period partially overlaps the second.
4.1 A reference to the "relevant financial year" should be interpreted as a reference to the financial year of the Contracting State in which a resident of the other Contracting State carried out his employment and during which the relevant employment services were provided. Let's assume, for example, that the fiscal year of State C runs from January 1 to December 31, and that a resident of State P resides and performs employment in State C from August 1, 2000 to February 28, 2001. By virtue of subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2, any twelve-month period that begins from January 1 to December 31, 2000 or ends from January 1 to December 31, 2001, and which includes any part of the period of provision of employment services, will be appropriate. For example, the twelve-month period from August 1, 2000 to July 31, 2001, which begins in fiscal year 2000 and during which a person has been in a State for more than 183 days, will include employment services provided in that State between August 1 and December 31, 2000.; Similarly, the twelve-month period from March 1, 2000 to February 28, 2001, which ends in fiscal year 2001, during which a person has been in the State for more than 183 days, will include employment services provided in that state between January 1 and February 28, 2001. The taxation of remuneration for related services does not necessarily have to take place in the relevant financial year: as explained in paragraphs 2.2 above and 12.1 below, the Article allows the State to tax remuneration received as a result of employment in that State in a particular year, even if remuneration for such services is received or tax is levied in another year.
5. Although Member countries have used different formulas to calculate the 183-day period, there is only one way that corresponds to the text of this paragraph: the method of determining "days of physical presence". This method is easy to apply because the person is either present or not present in the country. It is also quite easy for a taxpayer to document their presence if evidence is required for the tax authorities. According to this method, the following days are taken into account: part of the day, day of arrival, day of departure and all other days spent in the state of work, including Saturdays and Sundays, national holidays, weekends before, during and after work, short breaks (training, strikes, lockouts, delays in deliveries), sick days (if they did not prevent the person from leaving the country, and otherwise they would meet the criteria for tax exemption), as well as days of death or illness of family members. However, days spent in transit in the State of performance of work en route between two points located outside the State of performance of work are excluded from the calculation. It follows from these principles that the entire full day spent outside the country of work, whether due to vacation, business trip, or any other reason, is not taken into account. Any day, part of which, even a small one, a taxpayer is present on the territory of a State, is considered a day of presence in that State for the purposes of calculating the 183-day period.
5.1 However, the days during which the taxpayer is a resident of the source State should not be taken into account in the calculations. Subparagraph (a) should be read in the context of the first part of paragraph 2, which refers to "remuneration received by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of employment exercised in the other Contracting State", which does not apply to a person residing and working in the same State. The words "the recipient is located" found in subparagraph (a) refer to the recipient of such remuneration, and during the period of stay in the source State, the person cannot be considered a recipient of remuneration received by a resident of a Contracting State for employment performed in the other Contracting State. This conclusion can be illustrated by the following examples:
— Example 1. From January 1 to December 1, person X resides in and is a resident of State C. On January 1, 2002, person X is hired by an employer who is a resident of State P, and this person moves to State P, becoming its resident. Subsequently, person X is seconded by his employer to the State from March 15 to March 31, 2002. In this case, person X is present in State C for 292 days, from April 1, 2001 to March 31, 2002, but since he is a resident of State C from April 1 to December 31, 2001, this first period is not taken into account for the purposes of calculating the periods specified in subparagraph (a).
— Example 2. From October 15 to October 31, 2001, person Y is a resident of State P, is present in State C to prepare for the expansion of ACO's business in this country, also a resident of State R. On May 1, 2002, person Y moves to State C, where he becomes a resident and works as a manager of the newly established a subsidiary of the company "ACO" — a resident of the state of S. In this case, person Y is present in State C for 184 days, from October 15, 2001 to October 14, 2002, however, since he is a resident of State C from May 1 to October 14, 2002, this latter period is not taken into account for the purposes of calculating the periods specified in subparagraph (a).
6. The second condition is that the employer paying the remuneration must not be a resident of the State in which the employment is carried out. Some Member States may, however, consider that it would be inappropriate to extend the exception provided for in paragraph 2 to cases where the employer is not a resident of the employee's State of permanent residence, since in such a case administrative difficulties may arise in determining the income from the employee's employment or in ensuring the fulfillment of the employer's retention obligations. taxes. Contracting States sharing this opinion may, at their discretion, adopt bilaterally the following alternative wording of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2:
(b) The remuneration is paid by or on behalf of an employer who is a resident of the first-mentioned State; and
6.1 The application of the second condition in the case of financially transparent partnerships creates certain difficulties, since such partnerships cannot be considered residents of a Contracting State in accordance with Article 4 (see paragraph 8.8 of the Commentary to Article 4). Although it is obvious that such a partnership can qualify as an "employer" (especially in accordance with the definitions of this term in the domestic legislation of some countries, for example, when an employer is defined as a person responsible for paying payroll tax), therefore, the application of this condition at the partnership level, regardless of the position of the participants in the partnership, makes it the condition is completely meaningless.
6.2 The purpose and purpose of sub-paragraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2 is to avoid taxation at the source of short-term employment to the extent that it is not allowed to classify labor income as taxable income in the source State, since the employer is not taxed in that State, since he is not his a resident and does not have a permanent representative office in it. These sub-paragraphs may also be justified by the fact that the introduction of an withholding tax deduction requirement in relation to short-term employment in a given State may be considered an excessive administrative burden when the employer is not a resident and does not have a permanent establishment in that State. In order to achieve a clear interpretation of subparagraph (b), which would correspond to its content and purpose, it should be assumed that this subparagraph applies to financially transparent partnerships at the level of partnership participants. Thus, the terms "employer" and "resident" in subparagraph (b) are applied at the partnership level, and not at the level of a financially transparent partnership.
6.3 This approach is consistent with the approach that other provisions of the tax convention should be applied at the level of individual partnerships rather than partnerships. Although such an interpretation may create difficulties when the partners reside in different States, such difficulties can be resolved through a mutual agreement procedure, defining, for example, the State in which the participants of the partnership who own a controlling stake in the partnership reside (that is, the State in which the bulk of the tax deduction is claimed).
7. According to the third condition, if an employer has a permanent establishment in the State in which the employment is carried out, then tax exemption is granted only on condition that the remuneration costs are not borne by such a permanent establishment. The phrase "incurs expenses" should be interpreted in the light of the fundamental purpose of subparagraph (c) of this Article, which is to ensure that the exception provided for in paragraph 2 does not apply to remuneration that may lead to a tax deduction related to the principles of Article 7 and to the nature of remuneration in calculating the profits of a permanent establishment in the State where the employment is carried out.
7.1 The fact that an employer has actually claimed or not claimed a tax deduction for remuneration when calculating profits related to a permanent establishment is not necessarily sufficient evidence, since the relevant verification criterion is whether an otherwise applicable deduction for remuneration should be taken into account when determining profits related to a permanent establishment. This criterion is met, for example, even if the amount is not actually withheld due to the exemption of the permanent establishment from taxation in the country of origin, or if the employer simply decides not to claim the tax deduction to which he is entitled. This criterion is also met if remuneration is not deductible only because of its nature (for example, when the government holds the position that issuing shares in accordance with the employee stock option does not lead to such a deduction), and not because it should not be attributed to a permanent establishment.
7.2 For the purposes of determining the profits attributable to a permanent establishment in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7, remuneration paid to an employee of an enterprise of a Contracting State for employment services rendered in another State for the benefit of a permanent establishment of an enterprise located in that other State may, taking into account the circumstances, result either in direct deduction or to deduct a conditional fee, for example, for services rendered to a permanent establishment by another part of the enterprise. In the latter case, since the conditional fee required by the legal fiction of a separate and independent enterprise, applicable in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7, is only a mechanism provided for in this paragraph for the sole purpose of determining the profits attributable to the permanent establishment, this fiction does not affect the determination of whether remuneration is paid by the permanent establishment.
8. There is a direct link between the principles underlying the granting of the exemption under paragraph 2 and Article 7. Article 7 is based on the principle that an enterprise of one Contracting State should not be taxed in the other State if its business presence in that other State has reached a level sufficient to constitute a permanent establishment. The exception provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15 extends this principle to the taxation of employees of such an enterprise when the activities of these employees are carried out in another State for a relatively short period of time. Subparagraphs (b) and (c) clarify that this exception is not intended to apply in cases where employment services are provided to an enterprise whose profits are taxable in one State because it is either a resident of that State or has a permanent establishment in that State to which such services relate.
8.1 In some cases, it may be difficult to determine whether services provided in one State by an individual resident of another State to an enterprise of that first State (or an enterprise with a permanent establishment in that State) are employment services to which Article 15 applies, or services provided by an independent enterprise to to which Article 7 applies or, more generally, when an exception is applied. Although the Commentary previously regulated cases where agreements were structured with the main purpose of taking advantage of the exclusion provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 15, it was found that similar problems could arise in many other cases not related to motivated tax avoidance transactions, and the Commentary was amended to ensure a more comprehensive discussion of these issues.
8.2 In some States, a formal contractual relationship cannot be questioned with respect to tax purposes unless there is any evidence of manipulation, and these States, in accordance with their domestic legislation, will consider that employment services are provided only if there is a formal employment relationship.
8.3 If States experiencing exactly this situation are concerned that such an approach may lead to the provision of benefits from the exclusion provided for in paragraph 2 in cases of unintended acts (for example, in cases of so-called labor hire), they may bilaterally adopt a provision formulated approximately as follows:
Paragraph 2 of this Article shall not apply to remuneration received by a resident of one of the Contracting States for an employment performed in the other Contracting State and paid by or on behalf of an employer who is not a resident of that other State if:
(a) The recipient provides services in the course of such employment to a person other than the employer, and that person directly or indirectly oversees, directs and controls the manner in which these services are provided; and
b) these services are an integral part of the business activities carried out by this person.
8.4 In many States, however, various legislative and judicial rules and criteria have been developed (for example, the rule of "precedence of content over form") in order to separate those cases where services provided by an individual to an enterprise should be considered as provided within the framework of an employment relationship (employment contract) from those where such services should They are considered to be provided under a service agreement between two independent enterprises (a service agreement). This distinction remains relevant in the application of the provisions of Article 15, in particular the provisions of sub-paragraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2. Subject to the limit specified in paragraph 8.11, and unless otherwise specified in the context of a specific convention, the domestic law of the source State determines whether an individual's services are provided in that State as part of an employment relationship, and it is this definition that governs the application of the Convention by that State.
8.5 In some cases, services rendered by an individual to an enterprise may be considered employment services for the purposes of domestic tax legislation, even if these services are provided under a formal service agreement between the enterprise acquiring the services, on the one hand, and either the person himself or another enterprise with which the person has a formal employment relationship, or with whom this person has entered into another formal contract for the provision of services, on the other hand.
8.6 In such cases, the applicable domestic legislation may ignore how these services are characterized in formal contracts. In order to establish the existence of an employment relationship between an individual and an enterprise, this legislation may focus on the nature of the services provided by an individual and their inclusion in the business activities carried out by that enterprise.
8.7 Since the concept of employment referred to in Article 15 must be defined in accordance with the domestic law of the State applying the Convention (subject to the limit specified in paragraph 8.11 and unless otherwise specified in the context of the specific Convention), it follows that a State that considers such services as employment services, will apply Article 15 accordingly. From this, it can be logically concluded that the company to which the services were rendered is in an employment relationship with an individual in order to be considered his employer for the purposes of sub-paragraphs (b) and (c) of paragraph 2. This conclusion is consistent with the aims and objectives of paragraph 2 of Article 15, since in this case it can be argued that the employment services were provided to a resident of the State where these services were performed.
8.8 As indicated in paragraph 8.2, even in cases where the domestic law of the State applying the Convention does not allow the formal contractual relationship to be called into question and, therefore, does not allow the State to consider that services provided to a local enterprise by an individual who is formally an employee of a non-resident are provided within the framework of an employment relationship (an employment contract for services) with a local enterprise, this State has the opportunity to refuse to apply the exception under paragraph 2 in cases of abuse, as recognized in paragraph 9 of Article 29 (see also paragraphs 54 to 80 of the Commentary to Article 1).
8.9 [Excluded]
8.10 Thus, the approach described in the preceding paragraphs allows the State in which the business is carried out to waive the application of paragraph 2 in cases of abuse, as well as in cases where, in accordance with the concept of employment laid down in domestic legislation, services provided to a local enterprise by an individual who is formally an employee of a non-resident are carried out as part of an employment relationship (an employment contract for services) with this local enterprise. This approach ensures that the exemption from double taxation is granted in the State of residence of an individual, even if that State, according to its own domestic legislation, does not consider that there is an employment relationship between that person and the company to which the services are provided. In fact, if the State of permanent residence recognizes that the concept of employment in the domestic tax legislation of the source State or the existence of schemes that abuse the Convention allows that State to tax the labor income of an individual in accordance with the Convention, it must grant double taxation exemption in accordance with the obligations included in articles 23A and 23B (see paragraphs 32.1 to 32.7 of the Commentary to these Articles). The mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25 may be applied in cases where the State of permanent residence does not agree that the other State has correctly applied the approach described above and, therefore, does not consider that the other State has taxed the relevant income in accordance with the Convention.
8.11 However, the conclusion that formal contractual relations under national law should not be taken into account should be based on objective criteria. For example, a State cannot claim that, according to its domestic law, services are considered to be provided for hire in cases where the relevant facts and circumstances clearly indicate that these services are provided on the basis of a service contract concluded between two independent enterprises. The tax exemption granted in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 15 will be meaningless if States are allowed to consider certain services as employment services in cases of an apparent absence of employment relations or to deny employer status to an enterprise for work performed by a non-resident when it is obvious that this enterprise provides services through its own staff. to any company in relation to the work carried out by the resident. Conversely, if services provided by an individual can be properly considered by the State as provided within the framework of an employment relationship, and not in accordance with a service agreement between two enterprises, then this state should also logically assume that the individual does not conduct business activities of the enterprise, which is the formal employer of this person.; This approach may be relevant, for example, for the purposes of determining whether an enterprise has a permanent establishment in the place where an individual operates.
8.12 It is not always clear whether services provided by an individual can legitimately be considered by the State as services provided within the framework of an employment relationship, rather than in accordance with a service agreement concluded between two enterprises. In this case, any differences between States should be resolved taking into account the following principles and examples, using, if necessary, a mutual agreement procedure).
8.13 An important factor is the nature of the services provided by an individual, since it is logical to assume that an employee provides services that are an integral part of the business activities carried out by his employer. That is why it is important to establish whether the services provided by an individual to this enterprise are an integral part of the business activities of the enterprise. For this purpose, the key factor will be to determine which company is responsible or at risk for the results of an individual's work. However, it is obvious that this analysis will be relevant only if the services are provided by an individual directly to the enterprise.
In cases where, for example, an individual provides a contractor to a manufacturer or an enterprise whose business operations are outsourced, the services of this person are not provided to those enterprises that will receive the products or services in question.
8.14 In cases where a comparison of the nature of the services provided by an individual with the business activities carried out by his formal employer and the company to which the services are provided indicates an employment relationship other than a formal contractual relationship, the following additional factors may be relevant to determine whether this is true:
— who has the authority to give instructions to an individual regarding how to perform work;
— who controls and is responsible for the place where the work is performed;
— the remuneration of an individual is directly charged by the formal employer from the company to which the services are provided (see paragraph 8.15, below);
— who provides the individual with the necessary tools and materials for work;
— who determines the number and qualifications of people doing the work;
— who has the right to choose an individual to perform the work and terminate the contractual relationship concluded with him for this purpose;
— who has the right to impose disciplinary sanctions related to the work of this individual;
— who determines the weekends and work schedule of this individual.
8.15 When an individual who is formally an employee of one enterprise provides services to another enterprise, the financial schemes established between the two enterprises are obviously important, although they do not necessarily provide convincing evidence for the purpose of determining whether the remuneration of this person is directly charged by his formal employer from the enterprise to which the services are provided. For example, if the fee charged by the company is — the formal employer of a person is remuneration, additional payments and benefits to an employee and other personnel costs related to the services that the person provided to another company, without an element of profit or with an element of profit, which is calculated as a percentage of such remuneration, additional payments and benefits and other personnel costs, it can be consider it a sign that the remuneration of this individual is directly charged by his formal employer from the company to which the services are provided. This cannot be considered such a case, however, if the fee charged for services has nothing to do with the remuneration of an individual, or if this remuneration is only one of many factors taken into account when setting fees for what is actually a service agreement (for example, when a consulting firm charges a fee based on the hourly rate for the time spent by one of its employees on fulfilling a specific contract, and this fee takes into account the various expenses of this company), provided, that this corresponds to the principle of "at arm's length" if the two companies are related. It is important to note, however, that the question of whether an individual's remuneration is charged by his formal employer directly from the enterprise to which the services are provided is only one of the auxiliary factors that are important in determining whether the services provided by this person can legitimately be considered by the State as provided within the framework of an employment relationship, and not in accordance with the service agreement concluded between the two companies.
8.16 Example 1: Aco, a company resident in State A, enters into a contract with Bco, a company resident in State B, to provide training services. The Aco specializes in training people to use various computer programs, and the Bco wants to train its staff to use newly acquired software. X, an Aco employee residing in State A, is sent to the Bco office in State B to conduct training courses as part of the contract.
8.17 In this case, State B will not be able to assert that X is in an employment relationship with Bco or that Aco is not X's employer for the purposes of the convention between States A and B. X is formally an employee of the Aco, whose own services, when viewed in the light of the factors specified in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, form an integral part of the Aco's business activities. The services he provides to Bco are provided on behalf of the Aco in accordance with the contract concluded between the two companies. Thus, provided that X stays in State B for no more than 183 days during any relevant twelve-month period and that Ako does not have a permanent establishment in State B that bears the costs of X's remuneration, the exception provided for in paragraph 2 of article 15 will apply to X's remuneration.
8.18 Example 2: Cco, a company resident in State C, is the parent company of a group of companies that includes Dco, a company resident in State D. Cco has developed a new international marketing strategy for the group's products. To ensure that this strategy is well understood and followed by Dco, which sells the group's products, Cco sends X, one of its employees who participated in the development of the strategy, to Dco headquarters for four months to advise Dco on marketing issues and ensure that the Dco communications department understands and adheres to the worldwide marketing strategy..
8.19 In this case, Cco's activities include managing the Group's international marketing activities, and X's services are an integral part of these activities. Although it can be argued that a Dco could easily hire an employee to perform the function of advising a company on marketing issues, it is obvious that such a function is often performed by a consultant, especially when specialized knowledge is required for a relatively short period of time. In addition, the function of monitoring compliance with the group's international marketing strategy belongs to the Cco business, not the Dco. Thus, the exception provided for in paragraph 2 of article 15 should be applied provided that other conditions for this exception are met.
8.20 Example 3: A multinational corporation owns and operates hotels around the world through a number of subsidiaries. Eco, one of these subsidiaries, is a resident of State E, where it owns and operates the hotel. X is an Eco employee working at this hotel. Fco, another subsidiary of the group, owns and operates a hotel in the state of F, where there is a shortage of staff with knowledge of foreign languages. For this reason, X is sent to work at the reception desk at the Fco Hotel for five months. The Fco pays the travel expenses of X, who remains officially employed and paid by Eco, and pays Eco a management fee based on X's remuneration, social contributions, and other labor benefits for the relevant period.
8.21 In this case, working at the hotel's reception desk in State F, if considered in the light of the factors specified in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, may be considered an integral part of the Fco's management of this hotel, and not the Eco's activities. According to the approach described above, if, according to the domestic legislation of State F, services X are considered to have been provided by the Fco within the framework of an employment relationship, State F may logically assume that the Fco is the employer of X, and the exception to paragraph 2 of article 15 will not apply.
8.22 Example 4: Gco is a resident company of State G. She is engaged in activities to meet the temporary business needs of highly specialized staff. Hco is a resident company of State H that provides engineering services on construction sites. To fulfill one of its contracts in State H, Hco needs an engineer for a period of five months. For this purpose, she applies to the Gco company. Gco hires Engineer X, who lives in State X, and employs him under a five-month employment contract. According to a separate agreement between Gco and Hco, Gco agrees to provide X services to Hco during this period. In accordance with these agreements, Gco pays X remuneration, social contributions, travel expenses and other benefits and payments related to employment.
8.23 In this case, X provides engineering services, while Gco is engaged in meeting short-term business needs. By their nature, the services provided by X are not an integral part of the business activities of his official employer. However, these services are an integral part of the activities of the Hco engineering firm. In the light of the factors set out in paragraphs 8.13 and 8.14, State H may consider that, with the above approach, the exception to paragraph 2 of article 15 will not apply to remuneration for the services of an engineer to be rendered in that State.
8.24 Example 5: Ico is a resident company of State I specializing in providing engineering services. The Ico employs several engineers on an ongoing basis. Jco, a smaller engineering firm residing in State J, requires the temporary services of an engineer to fulfill a contract at a construction site in State J. The Ico agrees with the Jco that one of the Ico engineers, who is a resident of State I and is temporarily not employed in the contracts concluded by the Ico, will work for four months under the Jco contract under the direct supervision and supervision of one of the senior engineers of the Jco. Jco will pay the Ico an amount equal to the remuneration, social contributions, travel expenses and other labor benefits of this engineer for the relevant period, as well as a 5% commission. The Jco also agrees to reimburse the Ico for any possible claims related to the engineer's work during this time period.
8.25 In this case, even if the Ico is engaged in providing engineering services, it is obvious that the work performed by the engineer at the construction site in the state of J is carried out on behalf of the Jco, not the Ico. The direct supervision and control carried out by the Ico over the engineer's work, the fact that the Ico assumes responsibility for this work and bears the costs of paying the engineer for the relevant period, are factors that can confirm the conclusion that the engineer is in an employment relationship with the Ico. In accordance with the approach described above, State J may therefore consider that the exception to paragraph 2 of article 15 will not apply to remuneration for the services of an engineer to be rendered in that State.
8.26 Example 6: Kco, a company resident in State K, and Lco, a company resident in State L, are part of the same multinational group of companies. Most of the group's activities are based on a functional principle, which requires employees from different companies in the group to work together under the guidance of managers who are located in different countries and work for other companies in the group. X is a resident of K State who works for Kco; she is a senior manager responsible for overseeing human resources functions in a multinational group. Since X works for Kco, Kco acts as the cost center for the group's human resources; periodically, these costs are attributed to each of the group's companies based on a formula that takes into account various factors, such as the number of employees in each company. X often has to travel to other states where the offices of other companies in the group are located. During the last year, X spent three months on staff at L to resolve issues related to personnel at Lco.
8.27 In this case, the work performed by X is part of the activities that Kco carries out for its multinational group. These activities, like other activities such as corporate communications, strategy, finance and taxes, treasury, information management and legal support, are often centralized within a large group of companies. Thus, the work that X does is an integral part of Kco's business. Thus, the exception to paragraph 2 of article 15 should apply to remuneration received by X for her work in State L, provided that other conditions for this exception are met.
8.28 In the event that, in accordance with the above principles and examples, a State legitimately considers that the services provided by an individual in the territory of that State are provided within the framework of an employment relationship and not under a service agreement concluded between two enterprises, there may be a risk that enterprises in two jurisdictions They will be required to withhold withholding tax on the remuneration of this individual, even despite the ultimate goal of avoiding double taxation (see paragraph 8.10 above). This difficulty in complying with regulations can be partially reduced by the tax administration, ensuring that internal regulations and practices regarding employment are clear and understandable to employers and easily accessible to them. In addition, this problem can be mitigated if the State of permanent residence allows enterprises to quickly adjust the amount of tax to be withheld, taking into account any exemption from double taxation, which is likely to apply to an employee.
Point 3
9. Paragraph 3 applies to the remuneration of crew members of ships or aircraft operated in international traffic and states that such remuneration should be taxable only in the State of which the employee is a resident. The principle of exclusive taxation in the State of residence of the employee was included in this paragraph through an amendment introduced in 2017. The purpose of this amendment was to provide a clearer and administratively simplified rule regarding the taxation of the remuneration of such crew members.
9.1 At the same time, the definition of international carriage has been changed to ensure that it also applies to carriage on a ship or aircraft operated by a third-country enterprise. As explained in paragraph 6.1 of the Commentary to Article 3, this latest amendment makes it possible to apply paragraph 3 of Article 15 to a resident of a Contracting State who receives remuneration from employment on board a ship or aircraft operated by an enterprise of a third State.
9.2 However, if the employment is carried out by a resident of a Contracting State on board a ship or aircraft operated exclusively in the territory of another State, it would be clearly inappropriate to grant exclusive taxation rights to the State of permanent residence of the employee. The phrase "except on board a ship or aircraft operated exclusively in the other Contracting State" ensures that this paragraph does not apply to such an employee, which means that the taxation of the employee's remuneration is subject to the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article.
9.3 As stated in paragraph 9 above, paragraph 3 applies to crew members of ships and aircraft. This is evidenced by the reference to employment carried out "as a member of the regular staff of a marine or aircraft." These words have a broad enough meaning to cover any employment activity performed during the normal operation of a ship or aircraft, including, for example, the activities of restaurant staff on board a cruise ship or the activities of a flight attendant who will only work on one flight before termination of employment.; However, they will not cover employment activities that can be carried out on board a ship or aircraft, but are not related to its work (for example, an employee of an insurance company who sells housing and car insurance to cruise ship passengers).
9.4 As explained in paragraph 15 of the Commentary to Article 8, States wishing to apply the same regime to river, canal and lake transport as to international maritime and air transport may extend the scope of Article 8 to cover profits from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transport. These States may then wish to apply paragraph 3 of Article 15 to the remuneration of employees employed on these vessels. However, in the case of remuneration received by an employee working on board a vessel engaged in inland waterway transportation, paragraph 3 should apply only if the vessel is operated by an enterprise of the State of which the employee is a resident. Indeed, it would be inappropriate to require one Contracting State to exempt from taxation remuneration received by employees who are residents of another State but work in an enterprise of the first-mentioned State (or a third State with which the first-mentioned State has not agreed to exempt from taxation profits derived from the operation of ships engaged in inland waterway transportation) if this remuneration relates to activities carried out exclusively in that first-mentioned State. The Contracting States could solve this problem by including in their bilateral agreement a separate provision concerning the crews of ships engaged in inland waterway transportation, which would be formulated as follows:
Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article and Article 1, remuneration received by an individual, whether or not he is a resident of a Contracting State, in respect of work as a member of a regular ship's company that is carried out on board a ship engaged in inland waterway transportation in one Contracting State and operated by an enterprise of the other State, shall be subject to taxed only in this other state. However, such remuneration may also be taxed in the first-mentioned State if it is received by a resident of that State.
9.5 As indicated in paragraph 2 of the Commentary to Article 8, some States may prefer to transfer the exclusive right to tax profits from maritime and air transportation to the State in which the place of actual management of the enterprise is located, rather than to the State of residence. If Contracting States follow this approach, a similar change should be made to the alternative provisions included in paragraphs 9.4 above and 9.6 below, if these provisions are used.
9.6 Some States prefer to allow taxation of the remuneration of an employee who works on board a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic, both by the State of the enterprise that operates such a ship or aircraft and by the State of residence of such employee. States wishing to do so may draft paragraph 3 as follows:
Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article and Article 1, remuneration received by an individual, whether or not he is a resident of a Contracting State, in respect of work as a member of the regular staff of a ship or aircraft, which is carried out on board a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic by an enterprise of a Contracting State, shall be subject to taxable only in that Contracting State. However, if such remuneration is received by a resident of the other Contracting State, it may also be taxed in that other State.
9.7 Some States wishing to adopt this approach may also wish to limit the application of paragraph 3 to employees who are residents of one of the Contracting States, which can be done using the following wording:
Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of work as a member of the regular staff of a ship or aircraft carried out on board a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic shall be taxable only in that State. However, if the ship or aircraft is operated by an enterprise of the other Contracting State, such remuneration may also be taxed in the other State.
9.8 According to the alternative provision in paragraph 9.6 above, the Contracting State of the enterprise has the preferential right to tax the employee's remuneration. If the employee is a resident of the other Contracting State, the remuneration may also be taxed in that other State, subject to that State's obligation to exempt itself from double taxation in accordance with the provisions of articles 23 A or 23 B.
9.9 Since this alternative provision permits taxation in the State of the enterprise that operates the ship or aircraft, it may help resolve the situation of employees who work a lot on board ships or aircraft operated in international traffic, and who may benefit from becoming residents of States that do not levy or levy small taxes. from income earned from performing work for hire outside their territory. However, this provision assumes that Contracting States have the opportunity, in accordance with their domestic legislation, to tax the remuneration of employees working on board ships or aircraft operated in international traffic only because the enterprises that operate these ships or aircraft are enterprises of these States. If this is not the case, using this provision in conjunction with the double taxation exemption method may create a risk of non-taxation. Suppose, for example, that the above provision was included in an agreement between States P and C, therefore, State P follows the exemption method, and an employee who is a resident of State P works on flights between State P and third Countries operated by an airline that is an enterprise of State C. In this case, if the domestic legislation of State C does not allow State C to tax the remuneration of employees of the airline who are not residents of State C and do not work in it, State C will not be able to exercise the tax right granted to it, but State P will be obliged to exempt such remuneration from tax, because in accordance with the provisions of the Convention State C has the right to tax this remuneration.
9.10 As explained in paragraph 3 of the Commentary to Article 8, it may be provided that the reference to "place of actual management" in the alternative provision in paragraph 2 of this Commentary is applicable if the place of actual management of a shipping enterprise is on board a ship. According to the domestic legislation of a number of countries, the tax is levied on remuneration received by non-resident crew members in connection with employment on board ships, only if the ship is operated under the flag of such a State. For this reason, the Conventions concluded between these States provide that the right to tax such remuneration is granted to the flag State of the vessel. On the other hand, many States are unable to exercise such a right to taxation, and in such cases this provision may lead to a non-taxation situation similar to that described in the previous paragraph. However, States that have such a taxation principle in their domestic legislation may agree bilaterally to grant the right to tax remuneration in connection with employment on board a ship to the flag State of the ship.
10. It should be noted that there is no special rule regarding taxation of income of border workers or hired workers working on trucks and trains crossing State borders, since it is more appropriate to solve problems arising from local conditions directly by the States concerned.
11. There is no special provision for remuneration received by visiting professors or students who are employed to gain practical experience. Many Conventions contain certain rules governing such situations, the main purpose of which is to promote cultural ties by providing a limited tax exemption. Sometimes tax exemption is already provided for in domestic tax legislation. The absence of specific rules should not be interpreted as an obstacle to the inclusion of such rules in bilateral Conventions, if the parties consider it desirable.
Tax treatment of employee options
12. The different rules in force in countries regarding the taxation of stock options provided to employees create special problems, which are discussed below. Although many of these problems arise in relation to other forms of employee compensation, especially those based on the value of the shares of an employer or a related company, they are most acute in relation to stock options. This is largely due to the fact that stock options are taxed at that point in time (for example, when exercising an option or selling shares), which differs from the time when employees provide the services for which such options are rewarded.
12.1 As noted in paragraph 2.2, this Article allows the source State to tax that portion of income from stock options that represents remuneration derived from employment performed in that State, even if the tax is levied at a later date when the employee is no longer employed in that State.
12.2 Although this Article applies to income earned by employees from stock options granted to them, regardless of when that income is taxed, there is a need to distinguish that employee's income from capital gains that may be earned from the disposal of shares acquired during the exercise of the option. It is this Article, and not Article 13, that applies to any income from the option itself until it is exercised, sold, or otherwise disposed of (for example, in the event of its cancellation or acquisition by an employer or issuer). However, upon the exercise or disposal of the option, the employee's income is considered realized and any subsequent capital gain from the acquired shares (that is, the value of the shares that accumulates after the exercise of the option) is considered received by the employee in his capacity as an investor-shareholder and falls under the scope of Article 13. In fact, it is at the time of the exercise of the option that the employee received for his work for hire, such an option ceases to exist and its recipient acquires the status of a shareholder (and usually invests money to obtain such status). However, if the exercised option gives the employee the right to purchase shares, the rights to which will not be permanently transferred to him until the end of the established period of employment, it is legitimate to apply this Article to the increase in value, if any, after the expiration of the established period of employment following the exercise of the option.
12.3 The fact that this Article does not apply to income earned after the exercise or disposal of an option does not in any way mean that taxation of income from employment in accordance with domestic law should be carried out at the time of such exercise or disposal. As already noted, the Article does not impose any restrictions on the time periods when the relevant income can be taxed in the source State. Thus, the source State may tax the relevant income at the time the option is granted, at the time the option is exercised (or disposed of), at the time the shares are sold, or at any other time. However, the source State may tax only income related to the option itself, and not income related to subsequent ownership of shares acquired after the exercise of this option (with the exception of the circumstances described in the last sentence of the previous paragraph).
12.4 Since paragraph 1 should be interpreted as referring to any income earned from an option prior to its exercise, sale or other disposal, it does not matter how such income or any part of it is characterized for internal taxation purposes. As a result, despite the interpretation of the article as allowing the source State to tax income accrued up to the time of the exercise, sale or other disposal of the option, it remains at the discretion of the State to decide how to tax such income, for example, either as income from employment or as income from capital gains. If the source State decides, for example, to impose a capital gains tax on an option at the time when the employee ceases to be a resident of that State, then such a tax will be allowed in accordance with this article. The same applies to the State of permanent residence. For example, although this State will have the exclusive right to tax the increase in the value of shares received after the exercise of the option, since this procedure will be considered as falling under Article 13 of the Convention, it may well decide to tax such an increase as income from employment rather than as capital gains in accordance with its domestic legislation.
12.5 Income arising from stock options granted to an employee, as a rule, does not fall under either Article 21, which does not apply to income covered by other Articles, or Article 18, which applies only to pensions and other similar types of remuneration, even if the option is exercised after termination of employment or retirement retirement.
12.6 Paragraph 1 allows the source State to tax wages, salaries and other similar remuneration derived from employment in that State. The determination of whether and to what extent an employee's stock option is derived from employment in a particular State should be made on a case-by-case basis based on all relevant facts and circumstances, including the contractual terms associated with that option (for example, the conditions under which the option granted may be exercised or disposed of). To achieve this goal, the following general principles must be followed.
12.7 The first principle is that, as a general rule, stock options provided to employees should not be considered as related to any services upon completion of employment, which is required as a condition for the employee to exercise this option. Thus, when a stock option is granted to an employee on the condition that he will provide services under an employment relationship to the same employer (or a related company) for three years, the income from employment earned from this option should generally not be linked to the services performed after that period. a three-year period.
12.8 However, when applying this principle, it is important to distinguish between the length of service required for an employee to exercise a stock option and the period that is only a delay before the option can be exercised (the blocked period). Therefore, for example, an option granted to an employee on the condition that he maintains an employment relationship with the same employer (or an associated company) for three years may be considered received for services performed during those three years, while an option that is granted to an employee on a certain date without any- or the conditions of his subsequent employment, but subject to the exercise of the option with a delay of three years, should not be considered as linked to employment during these three years, since the income from such an option is accrued in favor of its recipient, even if he resigns from his job immediately after receiving it and waits the necessary three years before exercising it.
12.9 It is also important to distinguish between a situation where the length of employment is required as a condition for acquiring the right to exercise an option, that is, for the transfer of rights to an option, and a situation where the rights to an option have already been transferred, but it may be cancelled if it is not exercised before the termination of the employment relationship (or in for a short period after that). In the latter case, the income from the option should not be considered as related to services rendered after the employee has transferred the rights to exercise it, since the employee has already received income and can actually realize it at any time. The condition under which an option to be exercised can be cancelled upon termination of the employment relationship is not a condition for the acquisition of benefits, but rather a condition under which this already acquired benefit can be subsequently lost. This difference can be demonstrated by the following examples:
— Example 1: On January 1, 2001, an employee was granted an option to purchase shares. The option is subject to the employee's continued employment relationship with the same employer until January 1, 2003. Upon fulfillment of this condition, the option will be subject to execution starting from January 1, 2003 to January 1, 2010 (the so-called American option [1 - By
Under the "American" option, the right to purchase shares can be exercised over a certain period (usually several years), while under the European option, this right can only be exercised at a certain point (i.e., on a certain date) in respect of capital represented by aircraft operated in international traffic when they belong to a consortium. Scandinavian Airlines Air Transport System (SAS).]). In addition, however, there is a condition that any previously unfulfilled option will be cancelled upon termination of the employment relationship. In this example, the right to exercise the option was acquired on January 1, 2003 (that is, from the date of transfer of rights to it), since after that, the employee does not require any additional period of employment to obtain the right to exercise the option.
— Example 2: On January 1, 2001, an employee was granted an option to purchase shares. The option is subject to exercise on January 1, 2005 (the so-called European option). This option was granted on the condition that it can be exercised only from January 1, 2005, if the employment relationship has not been terminated before that date. In this example, the right to exercise such an option is not acquired until January 1, 2005, that is, on the date of its exercise, since before that date it is necessary to maintain the employment relationship in order to obtain the right to exercise the option (that is, the option to exercise it).
12.10 There are cases where this first principle may not be applicable. One such case may be the granting of a stock option without conditions to an employee when applying for a job, transferring to another country, or assigning him significant new responsibilities, and in each case the option clearly refers to new functions that the employee must perform during a certain future period. In this case, it may be appropriate to consider that the option belongs to these new functions, even if the right to exercise the option is acquired prior to their exercise. In addition, there are cases when an option is endowed with technical rights, but at the same time it gives the right to purchase shares, which will not be granted until the end of the required employment period. In such cases, it is advisable to assume that the benefit of the option relates to the services provided during the entire period between the granting of the option and the acquisition of rights to shares.
12.11 The second principle is that a stock option provided to an employee should be considered only as relating to services provided prior to the time of its provision, to the extent that the provision of the option is intended as a reward for the provision of such services by the recipient during a certain period. This situation will occur, for example, when remuneration is explicitly based on the employee's previous performance over a certain period or on the employer's previous financial performance, and is based on the employee's employment experience with this employer or a related company during a certain period to which these financial indicators relate. In addition, in some cases, there may be objective evidence that during the past period of employment, there were reasonable expectations among the participants in the employee stock options plan that part of their remuneration for this period of stock options would be provided in the form of stock options at a later date. Such evidence may include, for example, consistent practice by an employer who has provided similar levels of stock options over a number of years, provided there is no indication that this practice may be discontinued. Depending on other factors, such evidence may be very relevant for the purposes of determining whether there is a link between the stock option and the previous period of operation and the degree of such a link.
12.12 If in order for an employee to obtain the right to exercise a stock option, a certain length of employment is required, but such a requirement does not apply in certain circumstances, for example, in the event of termination of employment by the employer or the employee reaching retirement age, income from the stock option is considered related only to the period of actual provision of services, when such circumstances actually they have developed.
12.13 Finally, there may be situations in which some factors may suggest that the stock option provided to the employee is a reward for past services, but other factors indicate that it relates to future services. In case of doubt, it should be taken into account that stock options are usually provided as an incentive for future activities or as a way to retain valuable employees. Thus, the provision of stock options to employees is primarily related to future services. Nevertheless, before making such a conclusion, it is necessary to take into account all relevant facts and circumstances, and there may be cases where it can be demonstrated that a stock option is associated with a total of certain periods of previous and future services (for example, options are granted based on the employee's achievement of specific benchmarks for the previous year, but they are open to be executed only when the employee retains the employment relationship for another three years).
12.14 When, based on the principles set out above, a stock option is considered to have been obtained for employment in more than one State, for the purposes of applying articles 23A and 23B, it becomes necessary to determine how much of the income from such a stock option is derived from employment in each State. In this case, the benefits provided to the employee in the form of a stock option should be considered received in a particular country according to the ratio of the number of days during which the employment was performed in that country to the total number of days during which the employment services related to the stock option were performed. For this purpose, only those working days that are relevant to the stock option plan should be taken into account, for example, those days during which services are provided to the same employer or other employers, the employment relationship with which should be taken into account in order to fulfill the requirement for the period of employment required for obtaining the right to exercise the option.
12.15 Member countries have the opportunity to deviate from the application of the above principles in specific cases (indicated in paragraphs 12.7 to 12.14) by agreeing on a special approach on a bilateral basis. For example, two countries that levy taxes primarily at the time of option exercise may agree, as a general principle, to attribute income from the option, primarily related to future services, to services performed by an employee in these two countries between the date the option is granted and the date it is exercised. Thus, with regard to options that are not subject to exercise until the employee provides services to the employer within a certain period of time, these two States could agree on an approach that assigns income from the option to each of these States based on the number of days worked by such an employee in each State in the interests of the employer. during the period from the grant date to the option exercise date. Another example would be two countries with similar tax regimes provided to stock option employees, which introduce provisions giving one of the Contracting States the exclusive right to tax income from employment, even if a small part of the labor services to which the option relates were provided in another State. Of course, Member States should be careful when adopting this approach, as it may lead to double taxation or double non-taxation if part of the employment is carried out in a third Country that does not apply a similar approach.
Comments on the Comment
13. France considers that paragraph 8.13 should not be interpreted as sufficient in itself to call into question the formal contractual relationship. If, in accordance with paragraph 8.13, the services provided by an individual form an integral part of the business of the enterprise to which these services are provided, the situation should be analyzed in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 8.14.
13.1 With regard to paragraph 6.2, Germany is of the opinion that the partnership as such should be considered as an employer (as in accordance with the national legislation of most OECD member States, even if these States do not tax the partnership as such). In this case, the residence of the partnership should be determined hypothetically, as if the partnership were subject to taxation according to one of the criteria mentioned in paragraph 1 of Article 4.
Reservations to the Article
14. Slovenia reserves the right to add an Article that examines the situation of teachers, professors and researchers under various conditions and to amend paragraph 1 of Article 15 accordingly.
15. Denmark, Norway and Sweden reserve the right to include special provisions regarding remuneration for work performed on board an aircraft operating international air transportation by the Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS).
16. Norway reserves the right to include in paragraph 2 an explicit reference to income earned by employees of one Contracting State working in the other Contracting State, in order to ensure that it is understood that the exception in paragraph 2 does not apply in situations of "international labour hire" (see paragraph 8 above).
17. Ireland, Norway and the United Kingdom reserve the right to include in a special Article provisions on income earned from employment in connection with the exploration and development of hydrocarbons on the shelf and related activities.
18. Latvia reserves the right to include in a special Article provisions on income derived from dependent personal services related to activities carried out offshore in a Contracting State in connection with exploration or exploitation of the seabed, its subsoil and their natural resources.
19. Switzerland reserves its position on subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 and wishes to include in its agreements the words "in the relevant financial year" instead of the words "in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the relevant financial year".
20. In view of the special situation with regard to shipping, Greece will retain its discretion regarding the provisions of the Convention concerning the remuneration of crew members of ships operated in international traffic.
21. Greece reserves the right to include special provisions regarding income from offshore employment.
22. With respect to paragraph 3, Turkey reserves the right to tax exclusively remuneration received in connection with an employment performed on board a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic by an enterprise with a permanent residence in Turkey.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 16
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF DIRECTORS' REMUNERATION
1. This Article concerns remuneration received by a resident of one of the Contracting States, whether an individual or a legal entity, as a member of the board of directors of a company that is a resident of the other Contracting State. Since it is sometimes difficult to determine where exactly the duties are performed, the regulation refers to duties performed in the company's State of residence.
1.1 Member Countries generally understand the term "remuneration and other similar payments" to include payments in kind received by a person in his capacity as a member of the company's board of directors (for example, options to purchase shares in the company, use of housing or a car, health or life insurance and membership in a club).
2. A member of the company's board of directors often performs other functions in the company, in particular, as a simple employee, adviser, consultant, etc. It is clear that this Article does not apply to remuneration paid to such a person for performing these other functions.
3. In some countries, there are company bodies with functions similar to the board of directors. The Contracting States have the right to include such company bodies in their bilateral conventions in a provision corresponding to Article 16.
3.1 Many of the issues discussed in paragraphs 12 to 12.15 of the Commentary to Article 15 in relation to stock options granted to employees will also arise in the case of stock options granted to members of the boards of directors of companies. In the event that a stock option is granted to a resident of a Contracting State in his capacity as a member of the board of directors of a company that is a resident of another State, that other State will be entitled to tax a portion of the income from the stock option, which is a director's remuneration or similar payment (see paragraph 1.1 above), even if the tax is levied in more than later time, when this person is no longer a member of this board of directors. Although this article applies to income from a stock option granted to a member of the board of directors, regardless of when this income is taxed, there is a need to distinguish this income from capital gains that can be obtained from the disposal of shares acquired during the exercise of the option. It is this article, and not Article 13, that applies to any income from the option itself until it is exercised, sold, or otherwise disposed of (for example, in the event of its cancellation or acquisition by an employer or issuer). However, upon the exercise or disposal of the option, the income is considered realized, and any subsequent capital gain from the acquired shares (that is, the value of the shares that accumulates after the exercise of the option) is considered received by a member of the board of directors in his capacity as an investor-shareholder, and is subject to Article 13. In fact, it is at the time of the exercise of the option that the director received for his work in this capacity, such an option ceases to exist and its recipient acquires the status of a shareholder (and usually invests money to obtain such status).
Reservations to the Article
4. Estonia and Latvia reserve the right to tax, in accordance with this Article, any remuneration of a member of the board of directors or any other similar body of a resident company.
5. The United States will require that any tax levied on such fees be limited to income earned from services provided in the country of origin.
6. Belgium reserves the right to declare that the remuneration that the person referred to in Article 16 receives in relation to day-to-day activities, as well as the remuneration that a partner of the company, other than a company with equity, receives for his personal activities for the company, is taxable in accordance with the provisions of Article 15.
7. Greece reserves the right to apply Article 16 to the remuneration of a partner who acts as a manager of a Greek limited liability company or a Greek partnership.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 17
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF ARTISTS AND ATHLETES
Point 1
1. Paragraph 1 provides that entertainers and athletes who are residents of one of the Contracting States may be taxed in the other Contracting State where their personal activities are carried out both independently and for hire. This provision is an exception to the rules contained in Article 7 (over which it takes precedence by virtue of paragraph 4 of this Article) and paragraph 2 of Article 15, respectively.
2. This provision makes it possible to avoid the practical difficulties that often arise when taxing artists and athletes performing abroad. Moreover, too strict standards may in some cases interfere with cultural exchange. In order to overcome these difficulties, the States concerned may, by common agreement, limit the application of paragraph 1 to business activities only. To do this, it is sufficient to replace the words "notwithstanding the provisions of Article 15" with "subject to the provisions of Article 15" in paragraphs 1 and 2. In this case, artists and athletes performing during the period of employment automatically fall under the scope of Article 15 and thus receive the right to tax exemption provided for in paragraph 2 of this Article.
3. Paragraph 1 applies to artists and athletes. To give a precise definition of the term
"artist" is not possible, but paragraph 1 contains examples of who is considered an artist. The list of these examples should not be considered exhaustive. On the one hand, the term "artist" clearly refers to a theater, film, or actor actor (including a former athlete) who appears in television commercials. This article may also apply to income earned from activities of a political, social, religious or charitable nature, if it contains an element of entertainment. On the other hand, it does not apply to a visiting speaker at a conference, or administrative or support staff (for example, a cinematographer, producer, film director, choreographer, technical staff, a crew accompanying a pop group on tour, etc.). Between those and others, there remains an indefinite category that needs to be considered all aspects of the activity. the relevant person.
4. An individual may direct and participate in a performance, or may act as a director and producer of a television program or film, while simultaneously playing a role in it. In such cases, it is necessary to consider what exactly this person is doing in the State where the representation takes place. If his work in this State is mainly limited to performances, the Article should apply to all income from this activity received in such a State. However, if the executive element is an insignificant part of his activities in this State, then the entire income falls out of the scope of the Article. In other cases, the activities should be divided into parts.
5. Although the term "athlete" is not precisely defined, it is not limited to participants in traditional sporting events (for example, runners, jumpers, swimmers). It also includes, among others, golfers, equestrians, soccer players, cricketers and tennis players, as well as racers.
6. The Article also applies to income from other activities that are generally considered to be of an entertainment nature, in particular from billiards, bridge and chess tournaments.
7. The income earned by an impresario, etc., for organizing performances of an artist or athlete is outside the scope of this article, but, undoubtedly, any income they receive on behalf of the artist or athlete falls under its scope.
8. Paragraph 1 applies to income earned directly or indirectly by a particular artist or athlete. In some cases, income is not paid directly to this person, or to his impresario or agent. For example, a member of an orchestra may receive a salary rather than a fee for each individual performance: The Contracting State where the performance takes place has the right, in accordance with paragraph 1, to tax the share of the musician's salary that relates to such a performance. Similarly, if an artist or athlete is employed, for example, by a single-person company, the State in which the performance takes place may tax the appropriate share of any remuneration paid to him. In addition, if the domestic legislation of that State "does not take into account" such legal entities and income is considered to be accrued directly to an individual, paragraph 1 allows that State to tax income from performances on its territory accrued to a legal entity in favor of an individual, even if the income is not actually paid as remuneration to an individual.
8.1 Clause applies regardless of who makes the payment of income. For example, it applies to prizes and awards paid by a national federation, association, or league that a team or individual may receive in connection with a specific sporting event.
9. In addition to the fee for the actual performance, artists and athletes often receive income in the form of royalties, either sponsorship or advertising fees. In general, if there is no direct link between income and the performer's public performance in the relevant country, other Articles apply. Such a close relationship is usually found where it is not reasonable to assume that income would have been generated if these actions had not been performed. This relationship may be related to the time of the event that generates income (for example, a payment received by a professional golfer for an interview given during a tournament in which he participates) or the nature of the remuneration for the payment of income (for example, payment to a star tennis player for using his photo on posters advertising the tournament, in which he will participate in). Royalties for the use of intellectual property rights are generally regulated by Article 12 rather than Article 17 (see paragraph 18 of the Commentary to Article 12), but in general, advertising fees and sponsorship are outside the scope of Article 12.Article 17 applies to income from participation in advertising and sponsorship, etc., which is directly or indirectly related to activities and performances in a given State (for example, payments made to a tennis player for wearing a tennis shirt with the sponsor's logo, trademark or brand during a match). Such a close relationship may be evident from contractual agreements that relate to participation in these events or a number of unspecified events.; In the latter case, the Contracting State in which one or more of these events are held may tax a portion of the relevant income from advertising or sponsorship (as would be the case, for example, in the case of remuneration for a number of unspecified performances; see paragraphs 9.2 and 9.3). Similar income, which cannot be attributed to such activities and performances, is subject to the application of the standard norms contained in Article 7 or Article 15, depending on the situation. Payments received in the event of cancellation of a submission also fall outside the scope of Article 17 and are subject to Articles 7 or 15, as appropriate. Various payments may be made in connection with the sale of goods; While the payment to an artist or athlete of a share of income from the sale of goods closely related to public performance but not constituting a fee is usually covered by Article 17, commercial payments received from sales in a country that are not closely related to performances in that country and which do not constitute royalties are usually covered subject to article 7 (or article 15 if the employee receives such income).
9.1 In addition to the above examples, there are a number of cases where it may be difficult to determine whether a particular item of income has been earned by a person as an artist or athlete as a result of that person's personal activities as such. In such cases, the following principles can be applied:
— A reference to an "artist or athlete" includes anyone who acts as such, even at a single event. Thus, Article 17 may apply to an amateur who has won a monetary sports prize, or to a person who is not an actor but receives remuneration for a once-in-a-lifetime appearance in a television advertisement or movie.
— As noted in the previous paragraphs, the activity of an artist or athlete includes not only appearing at an entertainment or sporting event in a given State, but also, for example, advertising or interviews in that State that are closely related to such an appearance.
— Simply reporting or commenting on an entertainment or sporting event in which the reporter himself is not involved is not the activity of an artist or athlete acting as such. For example, the fee that a former or injured athlete would receive for offering comments during a broadcast of a sporting event in which that person does not participate would not be covered by Article 17.
— Preparation, such as rehearsals and training, is part of the normal activities of artists and athletes. If an artist or athlete is paid remuneration for the time spent on rehearsals, training, or similar training in the state (which would be quite common for working artists and athletes, but could also happen for a self-employed person, such as an opera singer, whose contract would require participation in a certain number of rehearsals), the appropriate remuneration, as well as remuneration for the time spent traveling in this State for the purpose of performances, rehearsals and training (or similar training), will be subject to the Article. This will apply regardless of whether such a rehearsal, training session, or similar preparation is related to specific public performances taking place in that State (for example, the remuneration that will be paid for participation in pre-season training camps will be covered).
9.2 Artists and athletes often operate in different countries, so it is necessary to determine how much of their income is derived from activities carried out in each State. Although such a definition should be based on the facts and circumstances of each case, the following general principles will apply for this purpose:
— An element of income that is closely related to a specific activity carried out by an artist or athlete in a State (for example, a prize paid to the winner of a sports competition held in that State; a daily allowance paid in connection with participation in a tournament or training phase held in that State; a payment made to a musician for a concert held in the State), will be considered to have been obtained as a result of activities carried out in that State.
— As indicated in paragraph 1 of the Commentary to Article 15, employment is carried out where the employee is physically present during the performance of the activity for which remuneration is paid. If the remuneration received by an artist or athlete employed by a team, troupe, or orchestra covers various activities that will be performed over a period of time (for example, an annual salary covering various activities such as training or rehearsals; traveling with the team, troupe, or orchestra; participating in a match or public performance, and T. in the absence of any indication that the remuneration or part of it should be distributed differently, it would be appropriate to distribute this salary or remuneration based on the working days spent in each State in which the artist or athlete was required by his employment contract to perform this activity.
9.3 The following examples illustrate these principles:
— Example 1: A self-employed singer is paid a fixed amount for the number of concerts to be given in different countries, plus 5% of ticket sales for each concert. In this case, it would be advisable to allocate a fixed amount based on the number of concerts held in each State, but distribute payments based on ticket sales based on the venue of the concerts that led to each such payment.
— Example 2: A cyclist is hired by a team. According to his employment contract, he has to travel with the team, appear at some public press conferences organized by the team, and participate in training sessions and races that take place in different countries. He is paid a fixed annual salary plus bonuses based on his performance in certain races.
9.4 Payments for simultaneous broadcasting of an artist or athlete's performance made directly to or for the benefit of the performer (for example, payments made to the performer's star troupe) are subject to Article 17 (see the Commentary to Article 12, which also applies to payments for the subsequent sale or public reproduction of recordings of the performance). However, if a payment is made to a third party (for example, the owner of broadcast rights) and this payment does not benefit the performer, the payment is not related to the performer's personal activities and, therefore, is not income earned by the person as an artist or athlete from that person's personal activities as such. For example, if the organizer of a football tournament owns all intellectual property rights to the event and, as such, receives payments for broadcast rights related to the event, Article 17 does not apply to these payments.; Similarly, Article 17 will not apply to any part of these payments that will be distributed among the participating teams and will not be redistributed among the players, and that is not otherwise paid in favor of the players. Whether such payments would constitute royalties covered by Article 12 would depend, among other things, on the legal nature of such broadcast rights, in particular under the relevant copyright law.
9.5 Artists and athletes often receive, directly or indirectly (for example, through payments made to the star troupe of an artist or athlete), a substantial portion of their income in the form of payments for the use or right to use their "image rights", for example, the use of their name, signature or personal image. If such use of the rights to the image of an artist or athlete is not closely related to the activities of the artist or athlete in a particular State, the corresponding payments, as a rule, do not fall under the scope of article 17 (see paragraph 9 above). However, there may be cases where payments to an artist or athlete who is a resident of a Contracting State, or to another person for the use or right to use the rights to the image of that artist or athlete, constitute, in essence, remuneration for the activities of the artist or athlete, which fall within the scope of Article 17 and are carried out in the other Contracting State. In such cases, the provisions of paragraph 1 or 2, as the case may be, shall apply.
10. This Article does not mention how such income should be calculated. The amount of any deductions for expenses incurred is determined by the domestic law of the Contracting State. In this regard, the domestic legislation of different countries differs from one another, and in some cases provides for withholding taxation at a low rate based on the gross amount paid to artists and athletes. Such rules may also apply to income paid to groups or corporate teams, troupes, etc. However, some States may consider taxation of the gross amount to be inappropriate in some circumstances, even if a reduced rate is applied. These States may want to allow the taxpayer to be taxed on a net basis. This can be done by including a paragraph roughly as follows:
If a resident of a Contracting State receives income referred to in paragraph 1 or 2 and such income is taxable in the other Contracting State on a gross basis, such individual may, within [a period to be determined by the Contracting States], send a written request to the other State for the taxation of that income on a net basis in that other State. Such a request must be satisfied in that other State. When determining the taxable income of such a resident in another State, tax deductions must be allowed for such expenses that are deductible from the tax base in accordance with the domestic law of another State that are incurred in connection with activities carried out in another State and that are possible for a resident of another State engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions. similar conditions.
10.1 Some States may also consider it inappropriate to apply Article 17 to a non-resident entertainer or athlete who would otherwise not be subject to taxation in a Contracting State (for example, in accordance with the provisions of Article 7 or 15) and who, during a given tax year, receives only small amounts of income from activities carried out in that State. the state. States wishing to exclude such situations from the scope of Article 17 may do so using an alternative version of paragraph 1 as follows:
Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 15, income earned by a resident of a Contracting State as a theater, motion picture, radio or television artist, musician or athlete from his personal activities as such exercised in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State, except in cases where the gross amount of such income earned by that State income earned by a resident from these activities carried out during the tax year in the other Contracting State does not exceed the amount equivalent to [15,000 special drawing rights of the IMF], expressed in the currency of that other State at the beginning of that tax year, or in any other amount agreed upon by the competent authorities in respect of such tax year prior to its commencement.
10.2 The amount indicated in the above provision is for illustrative purposes only. The reference to the "IMF special drawing rights" avoids referring to the currency of one of the two Contracting States and is intended to provide an amount that remains relatively constant in size regardless of currency fluctuations in each State (the IMF Special drawing rights (SDRs) are based on a basket of currencies that are periodically reviewed and easily expressed in most convertible currencies currencies). In addition, for ease of administration, the proposed provision stipulates that the limit applied in a State for a given tax year is the amount converted into the currency of that State at the beginning of that year. The proposed provision also allows the competent authorities to change the amount when they deem it appropriate.; However, instead of accepting an unchanged amount, some States may prefer to adopt an objective mechanism that would allow for periodic changes (this could be done, for example, by replacing the amount with a formula such as "50 percent of average GDP per capita for OECD countries, according to the OECD").
10.3 The proposed provision does not prevent Contracting States from collecting tax at the time of receipt of the relevant income and reimbursing it after the end of the year after it is determined that the minimum amount has not been exceeded.
10.4 The proposed provision applies only to paragraph 1 (the application of the rule to other persons covered by paragraph 2 may contribute to the fragmentation of contracts between many related parties in order to multiply the benefits of exclusion). In addition, this provision restricts only the right to additional taxation recognized in Article 17 and does not affect the rights of the source of taxation that are otherwise available in accordance with Articles 7 and 15. Thus, it does not prevent taxation to the extent that the artist has a permanent establishment in the State of origin or has been in that State for more than 183 days (or works for an employer who is a resident of that State or has a permanent establishment in that State).
11. Paragraph 1 of this article concerns the income earned by individual artists and athletes from their personal activities. Paragraph 2 regulates situations when income from their activities is credited to other persons. If the income of an artist or athlete is credited to another person, and the source State does not have the right provided for in the law not to take into account the person receiving the income in order to tax this income as the income of the performer, paragraph 2 provides that the share of income that cannot be taxed from the performer may be taxed from the person, receiving a reward. If the person receiving the income carries out business activities, the tax may be levied by the country of origin, even if this income does not relate to a permanent establishment in that country. But this does not always happen. There are three main situations of this kind:
a) The first situation is that the management company receives income for the performance of, for example, a group of athletes (which itself is not a legal entity).
b) The second situation occurs when a team, troupe, orchestra, etc. is a legal entity. Income for performances can be paid to this legal entity. Individual members of a band, orchestra, etc. are subject to taxation in accordance with paragraph 1 in the State where the performance was given, on any remuneration (or accrued income) received as participants in the performance.; However, if group members are paid periodic fixed remuneration and it is difficult to allocate a share of such income related to a particular performance, member countries may decide, multilaterally or bilaterally, not to tax it. The element of profit accrued for the performance of a legal entity is subject to taxation in accordance with paragraph 2.
c) The third situation is related to some ways of avoiding taxes in cases where remuneration for the performance of an artist or athlete is paid not to the artist or athlete himself, but to another person, for example, to a so-called artistic company, in such a way that income is not taxed in the State where the activity is carried out, nor as income from personal services an artist or an athlete, nor as a profit of the company due to the lack of permanent representation. Some countries do not take such schemes into account in their domestic legislation and treat income as earned by an artist or athlete; in this case, paragraph 1 allows them to tax income earned from activities in their territory. Other countries cannot do this.
If the performance takes place in such a country, paragraph 2 allows it to tax the profits earned from the income of the artist or athlete by the enterprise. However, it may turn out that the domestic legislation of some States does not allow them to apply such a provision. These States may agree on other solutions or not include paragraph 2 in their bilateral Conventions.
11.1 The application of paragraph 2 is not limited to situations where both the entertainer or athlete and another person to whom income is accrued, such as a star company, are residents of the same Contracting State. This paragraph allows the State in which the activities of an artist or athlete are carried out to tax income earned from these activities and accrued to another person, regardless of other provisions of the Convention that may apply on other grounds. Thus, despite the provisions of Article 7, this paragraph allows such a State to tax income earned by a "star" company resident in another Contracting State, even if the artist or athlete is not a resident of that other State. Conversely, if the income of an artist resident in one of the Contracting States is credited to a certain person, for example, a "star" company resident in a third State with which the source State does not have a tax convention, nothing prevents the Contracting State from taxing such a person in accordance with its domestic legislation.
11.2 However, paragraph 2 does not apply to prize money that the owner of the horse or the team that owns the race car receives based on the results of the horse or car during races or races held during a certain period. In this case, the prize money is not paid for the personal actions of the jockey or rider, but for actions related to the ownership and training of the horse or the design, assembly, ownership and maintenance of the car. Such prize money is not earned as a result of the personal activities of the jockey or rider and is not covered by Article 17. However, it is clear that if the owner or team receives remuneration for the personal activities of the jockey or rider, this income may be taxed in the hands of the jockey or rider in accordance with paragraph 1 (see paragraph 7 above).
11.3 However, as a general rule, it should be noted that, regardless of Article 7, the Convention does not prevent the application of the general rules against evasion provided for in the domestic law of the source State, which allows that State to tax both the artist/athlete and the star company in unlawful cases, as described in paragraphs 76 to 79 of the Commentary to Article 1. In addition, paragraph 9 of the Article
29 will prevent the provision of benefits under provisions such as articles 7 and 15 in these unlawful cases.
11.4 Paragraph 2 covers income that can be considered to be earned from the personal activities of an artist or athlete. Although it covers the income earned by an enterprise that is paid to perform such activities (such as a sports team or orchestra), it clearly does not cover the income of all enterprises that are involved in the production of entertainment or sporting events. For example, the income earned by an independent concert promoter from ticket sales and advertising is not covered by clause 2.
11.5 Although the Article does not specify how the income provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 should be calculated and provides for the determination of any deductions at the discretion of the domestic law of a Contracting State (see paragraph 10 above), income earned in respect of the personal activities of an athlete or entertainer should not be taxed twice when applying these two paragraphs. This would be an important consideration if, for example, paragraph 2 allows a Contracting State to tax an artist's star company on payments received by that company in respect of activities performed by the artist in that State, and paragraph 1 also allows that State to tax a portion of the remuneration paid by that company to the artist for employment that may reasonably be attributed to such an activity. In this case, a Contracting State may, depending on its domestic law, either tax only the company or the artist on all income related to these activities, or tax each of them on a portion of the income, for example, by taxing income earned by the company, but allowing the deduction of the corresponding portion of the remuneration paid to the artist. and taxing the part that is at the disposal of the artist.
Additional considerations regarding paragraphs 1 and 2
12. If, in the cases provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2, in order to avoid double taxation, the State of residence of the person receiving the income applies a tax exemption method, that State may not tax such income, even if the State where the activity is carried out cannot exercise its right to taxation. Therefore, it is assumed that in such cases, the tax offset method should be used. The same result can be achieved by providing for a derivative tax right for the State of residence of the person receiving the income, if the State where the activity is carried out cannot exercise the right it has under paragraphs 1 and 2. Contracting States may, at their discretion, choose any of these methods to ensure that it is impossible to avoid taxation.
13. As a rule, Article 17 applies when an artist or athlete is employed by a Government and receives income from that Government, see paragraph 6 of the Commentary to Article 19. Some Conventions contain provisions excluding from the scope of application of Article 17 artists and athletes working in organizations that are subsidized from public funds.
14. Some countries may consider it appropriate to exclude activities funded by public funds from the scope of the article. Such countries may include a provision for this, but tax exemption should be based on clearly definable and objective criteria to ensure that such exemption is granted only in the prescribed cases. This situation may look like this:
The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply to income derived from the activities of artists or athletes carried out in one of the Contracting States if their trip to that State is fully or mostly financed from public funds of one or both of the Contracting States, their administrative-territorial entities or local authorities. In such a case, the income is taxable only in the Contracting State of which the entertainer or athlete is a resident.
14.1 In addition, given the administrative difficulties associated with attributing to specific types of activities carried out in a State the total remuneration for the employment of individual members of a foreign team, troupe or orchestra, as well as the taxation of the relevant part of this remuneration, some States may consider it appropriate not to tax such remuneration. Although a State may unilaterally decide to exempt such remuneration from tax, such a unilateral decision will not be reciprocal and may cause the problem described in paragraph 12 above if the exemption method is used by the State of residence of the person receiving such income. Thus, these States may consider it appropriate to exclude such remuneration from the scope of the article. Although paragraph 2 above indicates that one solution may be to change the text of the Article so that it does not apply to income from employment, some States may prefer a narrower exception dealing with cases that they often encounter in practice. The following is an example of a provision applicable to members of a sports team that can be used for this purpose.:
The provisions of Article 17 shall not apply to income earned by a person permanently resident in one Contracting State in respect of the personal activities of an individual engaged in the other Contracting State as an athlete belonging to a team of the first-mentioned State that participates in a match organized in the other State by the league to which that team belongs.
Comments on the Comment
15. Regarding the examples given in paragraph 3, Turkey considers that the activity of a model acting as such (for example, a model presenting clothes during a fashion show or photo shoot) falls within the scope of this Article with respect to the characteristics and appearance of this activity.
15.1 France considers that the statement in the first sentence of paragraph 13, which is at odds with the wording before the 1995 revision, is incorrect because it does not correspond to reality in order to characterize the social activity in question a priori as a business and, in particular, cultural events – which, as a rule, do not pursue the goal of profit. In addition, this statement does not agree with the second sentence of the same paragraph or with paragraph 14, which explicitly provides for the right to apply a special exemption regime from the public activity in question: if it applies generally to business activities, such a regime would be unjustified, since it contradicts fiscal neutrality and the principle of equal taxation.
15.2 Switzerland does not share the view expressed in paragraph 9 of the Commentary, which provides that Article 17 will apply to income from advertising or sponsorship that is closely related to performances in that State. Switzerland considers that income from advertising or sponsorship falls under the standard rules of Article 7 or Article 15, as appropriate, even if such income is closely related to performances in that State. In addition, Switzerland considers that income from the sale of goods and income in the form of payments for the use or right to use image rights (paragraph 9.5 of the Commentary) do not fall within the scope of Article 17.
15.3 Chile and Mexico consider it necessary to clarify that in the case of the third example in paragraph 9.1, with respect to fees received by a former athlete, such fees may be subject to Article 17, even if the former Athlete does not participate in a sporting event, when these fees are paid for entertainment activities and the former athlete acts as an entertainer.
Reservations to the Article
16. Canada, Switzerland and the United States consider that paragraph 2 of the Article should apply only to the cases mentioned in subparagraph (c) of paragraph 11 above, and these countries reserve the right to propose amendments in this regard.
17. Germany reserves the right to include a provision according to which income earned by a person from the transfer of rights to live broadcast or other commercial use of the personal activities of artists or athletes may be taxed in the State in which the artist or athlete carries out personal activities.
18. According to the doctrine and contractual practice of France, the income that an athlete or artist receives from using his image is inseparable from his professional activities and, therefore, must be taxed in the State in which such income arises. Therefore, France reserves the right to include in its bilateral agreements an additional clause allowing taxation of a source of income from activities that cannot be separated from professional fame.
19. [Excluded]
20. The United States reserves the right to limit paragraph 1 to situations where an artist or athlete earns a certain amount.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 18
REGARDING THE TAXATION OF PENSIONS
1. According to this Article, pensions paid as compensation for personal work are taxed only in the recipient's State of permanent residence. Various political and administrative considerations support the principle that the right to taxation in respect of this type of pension and other similar remuneration should remain with the State of permanent residence. For example, the State of which the pension recipient is a resident is in a better position than any other State in terms of the recipient's overall ability to pay tax, which mainly depends on his worldwide income and personal circumstances such as family responsibilities. This decision also makes it possible to avoid imposing on recipients of this type of pension the administrative burden of meeting tax obligations in countries other than the recipient's State of permanent residence.
2. However, some States do not want to accept the principle of exclusive taxation of pensions at the place of residence and offer alternatives to this Article. Some of these alternatives and the issues they raise are discussed in paragraphs c
12 to 21 below, which address various considerations related to the allocation of tax rights in relation to pension benefits and the reasons supporting the Article as it is formulated.
Scope of the Article
3. The types of payments covered by this Article include pensions paid not only directly to former employees, but also to other recipients (for example, widows/widowers, associates or children of employees), and other similar payments, such as annuities paid as compensation for past employment. This Article also applies to pensions in compensation for services rendered to the State, its administrative-territorial entity or local authorities, which are not subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19. However, the Article applies only to those payments that are paid as compensation for past employment; therefore, it does not apply, for example, to annuities received directly by the annuitant from capital that was not funded by the pension insurance program. The article applies regardless of the tax regime in relation to such a scheme, according to which the corresponding payments are made.; Therefore, a payment under a pension program that does not qualify for tax benefits may nevertheless constitute a "pension or other similar remuneration" (the tax discrepancy that may arise in such a situation is discussed below). Similarly, the Article applies regardless of whether the corresponding payments are made from a "recognized pension fund" as defined in subparagraph (i) of paragraph 1 of Article 3.
4. Various payments may be made to the employee after termination of the employment relationship. Whether such payments fall within the scope of this Article or not is determined by the nature of such payments, taking into account the facts and circumstances in which they are made, as described in the following two paragraphs (see also paragraphs 2.3 to 2.16 of the Commentary to Article 15, which relate to the application of the Convention to a number of such payments).
5. While the term "pension" in the usual sense of the word applies only to recurring payments, the words "other similar remuneration" are broad enough to cover non-recurring payments. For example, the Article may cover a lump sum payment instead of periodic pension payments, which is carried out after the termination of the employment relationship.
6. If any particular payment is to be considered as another remuneration, similar to a pension, or as final remuneration for work performed that falls under Article 15, it is a matter of fact. For example, if there is evidence that the subject of the payment is a replacement for a pension or compensation for a reduced pension, then this payment can be described as "other similar remuneration" that falls within the scope of this Article. This will happen if, after retirement, a person had the right to choose between paying a pension or a lump sum calculated either based on the total amount of contributions or on the amount of pension to which that person would otherwise be entitled in accordance with the current rules of the pension program. An important factor is the source of the payment; payments to the pension program, as a rule, fall under the scope of this Article. Other factors that could help in determining whether a particular payment or series of payments falls under this Heading include the following: whether the payment is made during or after the termination of the employment relationship that led to this payment; whether the recipient continues to work; whether the recipient has reached the usual retirement age in relation to this particular type of employment; the status of other recipients eligible for the same specific type of lump sum; and whether the recipient is simultaneously eligible for other retirement benefits. Reimbursement of pension contributions (for example, after temporary employment) does not constitute
"other similar remuneration" in accordance with Article 18. If difficulties arise in the taxation of such payments, the Contracting States should resolve the issue by referring to the provisions of Article 25.
7. Since this Article applies only to pensions and other similar remuneration that are paid as compensation for past employment, it does not apply to other types of pensions, such as those paid as compensation for previously rendered independent personal services. However, some States are expanding the scope of this Article to include all types of pensions, including State pensions. States wishing to follow this path may agree on a bilateral basis on the inclusion of relevant provisions.
Cross-border issues related to pensions
8. The globalization of the economy and the development of international relations and transport have significantly increased the international mobility of people, both related to their work and for personal reasons. This has significantly increased the importance of cross-border issues related to the interaction of various pension provision mechanisms that operate in different States and which were developed mainly based on purely domestic political considerations. Since these issues often affect a large number of people, it is desirable to address them in tax conventions in order to remove obstacles to the international movement of people, and in particular employees.
9. Many of these issues relate to inconsistencies resulting from differences in the overall tax policies that States pursue regarding contributions to pension funds. Many States provide tax incentives for pension contributions. Such incentives often take the form of deferred tax payments so that a portion of an individual's income contributed to a pension fund, as well as income received from such a fund or any pension rights accrued to such a person, are exempt from taxes. On the other hand, pension payments under these schemes are taxed upon receipt. At the same time, however, other States treat contributions to pension funds on an equal basis with other types of savings and do not exempt from taxes either these contributions themselves or income from them; thus, logically speaking, they do not tax pension payments. Between these two approaches, there are a wide variety of systems in which contributions, income on them, accrued pension rights or pension payments are partially or completely tax-exempt.
10. Other problems arise from the existence of pension payment schemes that differ significantly from each other. These schemes are often classified into the following three main categories:
— Government social security programs;
— non-governmental employee pension programs;
— individual pension programs.
The interaction between these three categories of pension schemes is particularly difficult. These difficulties are compounded by the fact that each State may have different tax rules for schemes in each of these categories, as well as the fact that there are significant differences in the extent to which States rely on each of these categories to ensure tax payments to individuals (for example, some States provide pension benefits). Payments are almost exclusively through their social security systems, while others rely primarily on non-government employee retirement benefits or individual retirement programs).
11. The issues arising from all these differences must be fully taken into account in the course of bilateral negotiations, in particular on the avoidance of double taxation or double taxation avoidance, and, if necessary, settled through special provisions. The following sections address some of these cross-border issues.
Distribution of tax rights in relation to pension payments
12. As explained in paragraph 9 above, many States have adopted an approach according to which, subject to various restrictions, the tax is fully or partially deferred for contributions and income to pension schemes or for the accumulation of pension rights, but is reimbursed when pension benefits are paid.
13. Some of these States consider that, since the deduction of pension contributions represents a deferral of taxation of a portion of income from employment that persists until retirement, they should be able to reimburse the tax deferred in this way if the individual has ceased to be a resident before paying all or part of the pension benefits. This point of view is especially common in cases where benefits are paid in a lump sum or over a short period of time, as this increases the risks of double taxation avoidance.
14. If another State, of which this individual then becomes a resident, applies a similar approach and, therefore, taxes these pension benefits upon receipt, the problem primarily lies in the distribution of tax rights between the two states. However, if an individual becomes a resident of a State that uses a different approach to avoid taxing pension benefits, the discrepancy between the approaches adopted by the two states will lead to a situation where taxes will never be paid on the corresponding income.
15. For these reasons, some States are seeking to include alternative provisions in their tax conventions designed to ensure either exclusive or limited rights of the source of taxation in respect of pensions in connection with past employment. The following are examples of provisions that some members have adopted as a result of these political and administrative considerations; States may agree bilaterally to include such provisions:
a) Provisions allowing the exclusive taxation of source pension payments
According to this provision, the Article is compiled as follows:
Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid in that Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State in respect of past employment shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State.
(b) Provisions allowing non-exclusive taxation of source pension payments
According to this provision, the source State is granted the right to tax pension payments, and the rules of Article 23A or 23B result in this right being either exclusive or simply prior to the law of the State of residence. In this case, the Article is formatted as follows:
Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State in respect of past employment shall be taxable only in that State. However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the other Contracting State if the payment is made in that State.
(c) Provisions allowing limited taxation of source pensions
According to this provision, the source State is granted the right to tax pension payments, but this right is limited by a limit, usually expressed as a percentage of the payment. In this case, the Article is formatted as follows:
1. Subject to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 19, pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State in respect of past employment may be taxed in that State.
2. However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise and according to the laws of that State, but the tax so charged shall not exceed [percentage] of the total amount paid.
When using such a provision, a reference to paragraph 2 of Article 18 is added to paragraph 2 of Article 23A to ensure that the State of residence, if it applies the exemption method, is allowed to tax pension payments, but it is necessary to provide a set-off of the tax levied by the source State.
(d) Provisions allowing the taxation of source pension payments only if the State of residence does not tax these payments.
This provision is used by States that are primarily concerned about the structural inconsistency described in paragraph 14 above. Then paragraph 2 is added as follows:
2. However, such pensions and other similar remuneration may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise, provided that such payments are not taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the usual rules of its taxation laws.
16. In addition to the reasons outlined in paragraphs 13 and 14 above, various political and administrative considerations should be taken into account when considering such provisions.
17. First, the State of residence is in a better position to ensure adequate taxation of pension payments, since it is easier for this State to take into account global income and, consequently, the recipient's overall ability to pay tax in order to request appropriate rates and individual benefits. On the contrary, taxation of pensions at source may well lead to excessive taxation when the source State levies the final tax on the total amount paid. If small taxes are levied in the country of residence or they are not levied at all (for example, due to existing benefits), the pensioner may not be able to claim a tax offset in the state of residence for the tax to be paid. However, some States have tried to solve this problem by paying their individual benefits to non-residents, who receive almost all of their income from these States. In addition, some States have allowed the taxation of pension payments to non-resident recipients at the marginal rate that would be applicable if that recipient were taxed on global income (however, this system is fraught with administrative difficulties, since it requires determining the amount of a non-resident's global income only for the purpose of determining the applicable tax rate).
18. Secondly, equity considerations may be relevant, since the level of pensions paid in the source State is usually set based on local tax rates. In this situation, a person who emigrated to another country with different tax rates will be either at an advantage or disadvantage, receiving an after-tax pension that will differ from that provided for in the pension program.
19. Thirdly, alternative provisions, according to which there are either exclusive or limited rights of the source of taxation in relation to pensions, require the definition of the State of the source of the pension. Since a simple reference to a pension "paid in" a Contracting State can be interpreted as meaning either a pension paid by a fund established in that State or a pension received for work performed in that State, States using such wording should clarify how it should be interpreted and applied.
19.1 At the conceptual level, the source State can be considered the State in which the fund was established, the State in which the relevant work was performed, or the State in which deductions were requested. Each of these approaches will cause difficulties if individuals who work in more than one State change their place of residence during their career or receive a pension from funds established in a State other than the one in which they worked. For example, many people currently spend a significant portion of their careers outside the State in which their pension funds were established and from which their retirement benefits are ultimately paid. In this case, it would seem difficult to justify considering the State in which the fund is established as the source State. The alternative of considering the State where the work was performed or the deductions requested as the source State would resolve this issue, but would create administrative difficulties for both taxpayers and tax authorities, especially if individuals have worked in many states throughout their careers, as this would create the possibility that different parts of the Different source states will have the same pension.
19.2 States that wish to use provisions according to which there are either exclusive or limited tax source rights in relation to pensions should take these issues into account when determining the source State of pensions. Therefore, they should resolve the administrative difficulties that will arise in connection with the rule they adopt for this purpose, for example, to avoid situations where two States will claim the right to a source of taxation in respect of the same pension.
20. Fourth, another argument against these alternative provisions is that exclusive taxation by the State of residence means that pensioners only need to comply with the tax rules of their State of residence with respect to payments provided for in Article 18. However, if limited or exclusive taxation of the source of pensions is permitted, the pensioner will have to comply with the tax rules of both Contracting States..
21. However, the exclusive taxation of a resident may raise concerns about the failure to report income from a foreign pension. However, information exchange, combined with adequate taxpayer compliance systems, will reduce the frequency of non-reporting of overseas pension payments.
Tax-exempt pensions
22. As mentioned in paragraph 9 above, some States do not tax pension payments in general or otherwise exempt certain categories or parts of pension payments from taxation. In these cases, the provisions of the Article that provides for the taxation of pensions in the State of residence may lead to the taxation by that State of pensions that should not have been taxed, and the amount of which could well have been determined taking into account this exemption. This can lead to unjustified financial difficulties for the pension recipient.
23. In order to avoid problems arising from such inconsistencies, some States include in their tax agreements provisions for maintaining the pension exemption regime when the recipient is a resident of another Contracting State. These provisions may be limited to certain categories of pensions or may address the problem in a more comprehensive manner. An example of the latter approach may be the following wording:
Notwithstanding any provision of this Convention, any pension or other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State in respect of past employment performed in the other Contracting State shall be exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State if that pension or other remuneration would have been exempt from tax in the other State if the recipient was a resident of that other State.
Issues related to statutory social security programs
24. Depending on the circumstances, social benefits may fall within the scope of this Article as "pensions and other similar remuneration in connection with past employment", in accordance with Article 19 as "pension(s) paid by a Contracting State or from funds established by it... in respect of services rendered to that State ..." or in accordance with Article 21 as "income items... not mentioned in previous Articles." Social benefits are covered by this Article if they are paid in connection with past employment, unless paragraph 2 of Article 19 applies (see below). Social security benefits can be said to be paid "in connection with past employment" if employment is a condition for receiving this payment. For example, this will be the case if the relevant social security program provides for the following:
- the amount of the pension is determined based only on the length of employment or income from employment, or both, if the years when the person did not work did not lead to pension payments.,
- the amount of the pension is determined on the basis of contributions to the program, which are made subject to employment and depending on the period of employment, or
- the amount of the pension is determined based on the length of employment and either contributions to the program, or the investment income of the program, or both items.
25. Paragraph 2 of Article 19 will apply to social benefits covered by Article 18, except for the fact that the employment in the past, for which it was paid, represented services provided to the State, its political subdivision or local government, other than the services specified in paragraph 3 of Article 19.
26. Social benefits that do not fall within the scope of Article 18 or 19 are subject to Article 21. This may be the case, for example, with respect to payments to the self-employed, as well as pensions based solely on resources, age, or disability, which may be paid regardless of past employment or factors related to past employment (for example, length of employment or contributions made during employment for hire).
27. However, some States consider pensions paid under the State pension scheme, which is part of their social security system, similar to State pensions. On this basis, such States argue that the source State, i.e. the State from which the pension is paid, should have the right to tax all such pensions. Many Conventions concluded by these States contain provisions in this regard, sometimes also including other payments made in accordance with the social security legislation of the source State. The Contracting States adhering to this point of view may, on a bilateral basis, agree on an additional paragraph to the Article granting the source State the right to tax payments made in accordance with its legislation on social security. Such a clause may be drafted as follows:
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, pensions and other payments made in accordance with the social security laws of a Contracting State may be taxed in that State.
If the State of which the recipient of such payments is a resident applies the tax exemption method, the payments will be taxed only in the source State, while States using the offset method may tax the payments and account for the tax levied in the source State. Some States that use the tax offset method as a general method in their agreements may, however, consider that the source State should have the exclusive right to tax such payments. Therefore, such States should replace the words "should be taxed" with the words "may be taxed" in the above wording of the regulation.
28. Although the above-mentioned wording of the regulation applies to the social security legislation of each Contracting State, there are limits to its scope.
"Social security" usually refers to a compulsory insurance system that a government introduces to provide its population with a minimum income or retirement benefits, or to mitigate the financial consequences of events such as unemployment, work-related injuries, illness, or death. A common feature of social security systems is that the amount of benefits is determined by the State. Payments that may be covered by this provision include pensions available to the public under the state pension system, old-age pension payments, as well as payments for unemployment, disability, pregnancy and childbirth, survivor's benefits, illnesses, social assistance and family protection payments that are made by the State or government organizations. created to manage distributable funds. Since there may be significant differences in the social security systems of the Contracting States, it is important that States intending to use this version of the provision ensure during bilateral negotiations that they have a common understanding of what the provision will cover.
Issues related to individual pension programs
29. In many Countries, preferential tax treatment (usually in the form of deferred taxation described in paragraph 9 above) is available to some individual private savings programs created to provide retirement benefits. These individual retirement programs are usually available to individuals who do not have access to employment-related retirement programs.; However, they may also be available to self-employed workers who wish to supplement the retirement benefits they will receive as part of their social security and employment-related retirement programs. These programs take various legal forms. For example, these can be bank savings accounts, individual investment funds, or individually designed full life insurance policies. Their common feature is a preferential tax regime, in which the amount of contributions is limited.
30. The application of such programmes raises many cross-border issues regarding employment-related programmes, such as the tax regime in one Contracting State with respect to contributions to such a programme established in another State (see paragraphs 31-65 below). However, there may be issues that are specific to individual pension schemes and that may need to be resolved individually during negotiations on a bilateral convention. One of these issues is the tax regime in each State in relation to income earned under such a program established in another State. Many States have rules (such as the rules of foreign investment funds (FIF), which, under certain circumstances, attribute the income of a trust to the founder or beneficiary, or rules that provide for income taxes on certain types of investments, including full life insurance policies), which, under certain circumstances, may lead to income taxation. received as part of an individual pension program established abroad. States that consider such a result unacceptable in light of their approach to taxation of retirement savings may wish to prevent such taxation. The provision on this issue, which is limited to those programs that are recognized as individual pension programs, could be formulated as follows:
For the purposes of calculating the tax payable in one Contracting State by an individual who is a resident of that State and who was previously a resident of the other Contracting State, any income earned under the agreement,
(a) Entered into with a person registered outside the first-mentioned State in order to secure pension payments for that person,
b) in which the person participates and participated when he was a resident of another State,
c) which is recognized by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally consistent with an individual pension program recognized as such for tax purposes by that State,
It is considered as income received within the framework of an individual pension program established in this state. This clause in no way restricts the taxation of any income distributed according to the mechanism.
Tax treatment for contributions to foreign pension programs
A. General remarks
31. A feature of multinational corporations is that their staff is expected to work outside the country of residence from time to time. The conditions of service under which staff are sent to work in other countries are very important for both the employer and the employee. One of these conditions is the pension provision of a particular employee. Similarly, individuals who move to other countries to provide services as independent contractors often face cross-border tax problems related to the retirement conditions they had in their home country.
32. Persons working abroad often want to continue contributing to the pension program (including the social insurance program providing pension benefits) in the country of residence during their stay in another country. This is due to the fact that switching to another program can lead to the loss of rights and benefits, and is also associated with many practical difficulties that may arise as a result of obtaining pension benefits in several countries.
33. The tax treatment provided to pension contributions made by or on behalf of individuals working outside their country differs from country to country and depends on the circumstances of each individual case. Before being appointed to work or signing an employment contract abroad, these individuals usually receive a tax benefit on account of pension contributions in the country of residence. In some cases, tax benefits for such contributions are retained while such a person is working abroad. For example, if an individual remains a resident and is fully taxed in the country of residence, pension contributions to a program provided for in that country are usually still subject to tax relief. However, contributions paid in the country of residence by a person working abroad are often not subject to benefits either in the country of residence or in the host country. In this case, maintaining participation in the pension program in the country of residence during a business trip abroad or working under a contract is expensive, if not prohibitively expensive. Paragraph 37 below contains a provision that Member States may, at their discretion, include in bilateral agreements in order to provide benefits for pension contributions from individuals working outside the country of residence.
34. However, some member States may not consider that this problem can be solved through the provisions of the treaty, preferring, in particular, to amend the pension program in order to ensure the deduction of contributions from taxes in the host State. Other countries may oppose the inclusion of such a provision in the treaty if domestic legislation allows tax benefits only for contributions paid by residents. In such cases, it is not advisable to include the proposed provision in a bilateral agreement.
35. The proposed regulation regulates contributions to all types of pension programs, including individual pension programs, as well as social insurance programs. Many member countries have concluded bilateral agreements on pooling social insurance, which can help avoid the problem of contributions to social insurance programs; however, these agreements usually do not regulate the tax treatment of contributions sent to other countries. In the case of a corporate pension program to which both the employer and the employee contribute, this provision covers both of these contributions. In addition, this provision is not limited to the issue of tax deduction of contributions, as it regulates all aspects of the tax regime of contributions in relation to an individual receiving income from a pension program. Thus, this provision deals with issues such as whether or not the income from the employee's employment, which is a contribution, should be taxed, and whether or not the investment income of an individual received from contributions should be taxed. However, this provision does not apply to the taxation of pension fund income (this issue is discussed in paragraph 69 below). Contracting States wishing to change the scope of application of this provision in relation to any of these issues may do so through bilateral negotiations.
B. Purpose of the provision
36. The purpose of this provision is to ensure that, to the maximum extent possible, due to the tax regime of contributions to the pension program in the country of residence, obstacles are created for individuals in their desire to accept a job assignment abroad. First of all, this provision is aimed at establishing the general equivalence of the pension programs of these two countries and at the subsequent introduction of restrictions on contributions for which tax exemption applies, based on the restrictions provided for in the legislation of both countries.
C. Proposed position
37. The text of the proposed provision that could be included in bilateral Conventions to address the above-mentioned problem is given below.:
1. Contributions to a pension program established and recognized for tax purposes in one Contracting State that are made by or on behalf of an individual providing services in the other Contracting State must, for the purpose of determining the tax payable by that person and the profits of the enterprise that may be taxed in that State, have in that State the State has the same treatment and is subject to the same conditions and restrictions as contributions made to a pension program that is recognized for tax purposes in that State, provided that:
(a) The individual was not a resident of that State and participated in a pension scheme immediately prior to the commencement of services in that State; and
b) the pension scheme is recognized by the competent authority of that State as generally conforming to the pension scheme recognized as such for tax purposes by that State.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1:
(a) The term "pension scheme" means the mechanism in which the individual participates in order to ensure the payment of post-retirement benefits in connection with the provision of services referred to in paragraph 1; and
b) a pension program is recognized for tax purposes in a State if contributions to the program meet the tax reduction requirements in that State.
38. The above provision is limited to pension schemes established in one of the two Contracting States. Since it is quite common for individuals to work consecutively in several countries, some States may wish to expand the scope of this provision to cover situations where an individual moves from one Contracting State to another while continuing to contribute to a pension program established in a third State. Such an extension of the scope may, however, create administrative difficulties if the receiving State does not have access to information related to such a pension program (for example, in accordance with the provisions on the exchange of information of a tax convention concluded with such a third State); there may also be a situation where tax exemption will be granted on a non-reciprocal basis, since A third State will not grant a similar exemption to an individual who contributes to a pension program established in the host State. Those States that, despite these difficulties, wish to expand the scope of the proposed provision to cover funds established in third States may do so by adopting an alternative version of the proposed provision along the following lines:
1. Contributions made by or on behalf of an individual providing services in a Contracting State to a pension program:
a) recognized for tax purposes in the other Contracting State;
(b) In which the individual was involved immediately prior to the commencement of the provision of services in the first-mentioned State;
(c) In which the individual was involved during the period when the individual was providing services in another State or was a resident of another State; and
d) which is recognized by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally conforming to a pension program recognized as such for tax purposes by that State,
must be used for the purposes of:
(e) Determining the tax payable by such person in the first-mentioned State, and
(f) Determining the profits of an enterprise that may be taxed in the first-mentioned State,
have the same treatment in this State and be subject to the same conditions and restrictions as contributions made to a pension program that is recognized for tax purposes in the first-mentioned State.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1:
(a) The term "pension scheme" means the mechanism in which the individual participates in order to ensure the payment of post-retirement benefits in connection with the provision of services referred to in paragraph 1; and
b) a pension program is recognized for tax purposes in a State if contributions to the program meet the tax reduction requirements in that State.
38. The above provision is limited to pension schemes established in one of the two Contracting States. Since it is quite common for individuals to work consecutively in several countries, some States may wish to expand the scope of this provision to cover situations where an individual moves from one Contracting State to another while continuing to contribute to a pension program established in a third State. Such an extension of the scope may, however, create administrative difficulties if the receiving State does not have access to information related to such a pension program (for example, in accordance with the provisions on the exchange of information of a tax convention concluded with such a third State); there may also be a situation where tax exemption will be granted on a non-reciprocal basis, since A third State will not grant a similar exemption to an individual who contributes to a pension program established in the host State. Those States that, despite these difficulties, wish to expand the scope of the proposed provision to cover funds established in third States may do so by adopting an alternative version of the proposed provision along the following lines:
1. Contributions made by or on behalf of an individual providing services in a Contracting State to a pension program:
a) recognized for tax purposes in the other Contracting State;
(b) In which the individual was involved immediately prior to the commencement of the provision of services in the first-mentioned State;
(c) In which the individual was involved during the period when the individual was providing services in another State or was a resident of another State; and
d) which is recognized by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally conforming to a pension program recognized as such for tax purposes by that State,
must be used for the purposes of:
(e) Determining the tax payable by such person in the first-mentioned State, and
(f) Determining the profits of an enterprise that may be taxed in the first-mentioned State,
have the same treatment in this State and be subject to the same conditions and restrictions as contributions made to a pension program that is recognized for tax purposes in the first-mentioned State.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1:
(a) The term "pension scheme" means the mechanism in which the individual participates in order to ensure the payment of post-retirement benefits in connection with the provision of services referred to in paragraph 1; and
b) a pension program is recognized for tax purposes in a State if contributions to the program meet the tax reduction requirements in that State.
D. Characteristics of the proposed position
39. The following paragraphs discuss the main characteristics of the proposed provision set out in paragraph 37 above.
40. Paragraph 1 of the proposed regulation contains the characteristics of both the individual himself and the contributions to which this provision applies. It also sets out the principle that contributions made by an individual or on behalf of an individual providing services in one Contracting State (the State of residence) to a specific pension program in the other Contracting State (the State of residence) are exempt from taxation in the receiving State on the terms and with the same restrictions as provided for regarding the exemption of contributions to pension programs of the host State.
41. Tax relief on contributions to the pension program in the country of residence under the specified conditions can be provided either in the country of residence, that is, where the pension program is implemented, or in the host country, where the economic activity on the basis of which contributions to the program are made is carried out.
42. The decision to grant a tax discount in the country of residence may be ineffective, since an individual may not have taxable income in that country or may have a small income. Therefore, for practical reasons, it would be advisable to provide a discount in the host country, and this is the option adopted in the proposed regulation.
43. By pointing out the characteristics of an individual, paragraph 1 explicitly states that an individual should not be a resident of the host country immediately before arriving there to work.
44. However, paragraph 1 does not limit the application of the provision only to individuals who become residents in the host country. In many cases, individuals who work abroad and remain residents of the country of residence still meet the requirements for a tax discount there, but this does not always happen. Therefore, the proposed provision applies to non-residents working in the host State, as well as to persons who acquire resident status there. In some Member States, domestic legislation may limit tax deductions to contributions made by residents, and these member States may wish to limit the proposed provision accordingly. In addition, States with special treatment for non-residents (in particular, taxation at a special low rate) may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, agree to limit the application of this provision only to residents.
45. If individuals temporarily cease to be residents in the host country in order to join a pension program in a country with more preferential treatment, individual States may wish to introduce a provision that would prevent the possibility of abuse. One of the options for such a provision could provide for the condition of citizenship, which would be able to exclude persons who are citizens of the host country from the proposed provision.
46. As already noted, it is common practice for individuals to work consistently in different countries; for this reason, the proposed provision is not limited to individuals who are residents of the State of residence immediately prior to providing services in the receiving State. The provision applies to persons coming to the host State from a third country, as it is limited only to those persons who were not residents of the host country before starting employment in it. However, Article 1 restricts the scope of application of the Convention to residents of one or both Contracting States. Therefore, a person who is not a resident of either the host State or the country of residence where the pension program operates is not subject to the Convention between these two States.
47. The proposed provision does not set limits on the length of time during which an individual can work in the receiving State. It can be argued that if a person works in the host State for a long time, this State becomes in fact the country of his residence, and the provision should no longer apply. Indeed, some host States have already limited the tax discount on contributions to foreign pension programs to cases where individuals are present in that State on a temporary basis.
48. In addition, the inclusion of a time limit may help prevent possible abuses, as indicated in paragraph 45 above. In the course of bilateral negotiations, individual countries may consider it appropriate to include a time limit on the period during which an individual can provide services in the host State, after which the tax discounts provided in accordance with the proposed provision are no longer valid.
49. Considering the characteristics of contributions, paragraph 1 provides for a number of conditions. It clearly states that the provision applies only to contributions made by or on behalf of an individual to a pension program established and recognized for tax purposes in the country of residence. The expression "recognized for tax purposes" is defined in subparagraph 2b of the proposed regulation; this expression is not related to the definition of the term
The term "recognized pension fund" is used in subparagraph (i) of paragraph 1 of Article 3 and therefore applies regardless of whether the pension program is a "recognized pension fund". The expression "made by or on behalf of an individual" is intended to apply both to contributions that are made directly by an individual and to contributions that are made on behalf of such a person by an employer or another party (for example, a spouse). Although paragraph 4 of Article 24 guarantees that contributions from an employer to a pension fund that is a resident of the other Contracting State (regardless of whether it is a "recognized pension fund") are tax deductible under the same conditions as contributions to a resident pension fund, this provision may not be sufficient to ensure the same the regime of employer contributions to domestic and foreign pension funds. This will happen, for example, when an employer's contributions to a foreign fund are considered a taxable payment upon receipt by an employee, or when the tax deduction of an employer's contributions does not depend on whether a particular fund is resident or not, but rather on other conditions (for example, registration with the tax authorities government agencies or the presence of branches), which usually lead to the exclusion of foreign pension funds. For these reasons, employer contributions are covered by the proposed provision, even though Article 24, paragraph 4, may already provide a similar tax deduction in some cases.
50. The second condition regarding the characteristics of contributions is that contributions must be made to a program of the State of residence recognized by the competent authority of the receiving State as generally consistent with a program recognized as such for tax purposes in the receiving State. This condition is based on the fact that only contributions to recognized programs can meet the requirements for a tax rebate in member countries. Of course, this restriction does not necessarily guarantee equivalent tax treatment for contributions paid by an individual while working abroad and contributions paid while working in the country of residence. If the rules of the host State regarding the recognition of pension programs are more restrictive than those in force in the State of residence, an individual may consider that contributions to the pension program of his State of residence are subject to less favorable treatment during his work in the host State than during his work in the State of residence.
51. However, providing a tax discount for contributions that, at least in a broad sense, do not correspond to recognized pension programs in a given country would be contrary to the stated goal of ensuring equivalent tax treatment for such contributions as much as possible. This would mean that the amount of the tax discount in the host State would depend on the legislation of the State of residence. In addition, it is hardly possible to justify differences in the treatment of individuals working together, depending on which pension program they contribute to — in their own country or abroad (and if abroad, then depending on which country it is). Limiting the application of the proposed provision to programs that generally correspond to programs in the host country avoids such difficulties.
52. The proposed provision clearly states that it is up to the competent authority of the receiving State to decide whether a program in the State of residence corresponds to recognized programs in the receiving State. In the course of bilateral negotiations, individual States may consider it necessary to specify explicitly how the competent authority will interpret the term "generally appropriate", for example, how broadly it is interpreted and what criteria are applied.
53. Contributions covered by the regulation are limited to payments to programs to which an individual has contributed prior to the provision of services in the host State. This means that contributions to new pension schemes that a person joins while working in the host country are excluded from the proposed provision.
54. However, it is recognized that special rules may be required in cases where new pension schemes replace previous ones. For example, in some member States, there is a practice according to which, in the event of the acquisition of an employer company by another company, the company's existing pension program for its employees is terminated and another program is introduced by the new employer. Therefore, in the course of bilateral negotiations, individual States may wish to supplement this provision so that it applies to such sub-institutional programs.; This can be done by adding the following subparagraph to paragraph 2 of the proposed regulation:
(c) A pension scheme used instead, which is substantially similar to a pension scheme recognized by the competent authorities of a Contracting State in accordance with subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1, shall be deemed to be a recognized pension scheme in the same way.
55. Paragraph 1 also provides for the provision of a tax benefit by the host State if the characteristics of the individual and contributions fall under the terms of the provision. In short, contributions should have a tax regime that corresponds to the regime that such contributions would have if they were included in a program established in the host State. Thus, contributions should be subject to the same tax benefit (for example, tax deductible) for both an individual and his employer (when such a person is employed and contributions are made by the employer) as if such contributions were made to a pension program in the host State. In addition, the same treatment should be provided for the taxation of an employee's income from employment derived from a contribution to either a foreign or a local pension program (see paragraph 58 below).
56. Of course, such a measure in relation to a tax benefit does not necessarily provide equivalent tax treatment for contributions made during the period of an individual's work abroad and contributions made during his work in the country of residence. The same considerations can be given here as in paragraphs 50 and 51 above. However, such a measure provides an equivalent tax treatment for contributions made by co-workers. Let's give the following example. The country of residence limits the amount of the tax discount on pension contributions to 18 percent of income. The host country limits the discount to 20 percent. The proposed provision in paragraph 37 requires the host country to provide a discount within the 20 per cent established in its domestic legislation. Countries that wish to take advantage of the restriction adopted in the country of residence will have to amend the relevant wording of the regulation.
57. The amount and method of granting the tax benefit will depend on the internal tax regime of pension contributions provided for in the host State. This, in particular, will solve the following issues:: do such contributions meet the requirements for applying the benefit in full or only partially, and should the benefit be provided in the form of a tax deduction when calculating taxable income (and if so, what kind of income, for example, in relation to an individual, only income from employment, or from commercial income, or from all income) or in the form of a tax offset.
58. For an individual who participates in a work-related pension program (a professional pension program), getting a job abroad may mean not only that the employee's contributions to the pension program in his country of residence will no longer meet the requirements for receiving a tax benefit. This may also mean that contributions to the pension program made by the employer will be treated for tax purposes as income from employment. In some member States, employees are taxed on the employer's contributions to local pension schemes for the period of employment in the country of residence, while in other countries these contributions remain exempt from tax. Since the proposed regulation applies to contributions from both employees and employers, it ensures that contributions from employers in the context of the tax obligations of their employees are given the same tax treatment that applies to such contributions to domestic pension schemes.
59. Subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 defines a pension program for the purposes of paragraph 1. It clarifies that for these purposes, a pension program is considered as a mechanism in which an individual making payments participates to ensure retirement payments. These payments must be made in respect of services rendered in the receiving State. All of the above conditions should apply to the pension program so that it can meet the requirements for a tax benefit under the proposed regulation.
60. Subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 refers to the participation of an individual in a pension program to ensure retirement benefits. This definition is intended to ensure that the portion of contributions made to secure payments that does not relate to regular retirement pension payments, in particular the lump sum payment upon retirement, is also subject to the benefits provided for in this regulation.
61. First of all, the pension program is defined as a "mechanism". This broad term is used to cover the various forms of pension schemes (both social insurance and occupational or individual pension schemes) that may exist in individual member countries.
62. Although subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 indicates that an individual who provides the services specified in paragraph 1 must participate in this program, the identity of the recipient of pension payments secured by participation in this program is not indicated. This is done in order to ensure that the portion of contributions that will go to pension payments to other beneficiaries (for example, widows/widowers, associates and children of employees) also falls under the tax relief provided for in the proposed regulation.
63. The definition of a pension program does not distinguish between pensions paid from State occupational pension programs and pensions from similar private programs. Both fall within the scope of the regulation. Thus, social insurance programs fall within the scope of the provision to the extent that contributions to such programs can be considered to relate to services provided by an individual in the receiving State as both an employee and an independent contractor.
64. Subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 defines the expression "recognized for tax purposes" more fully. Since the purpose of the regulation is to ensure, as far as possible, an equally favorable tax regime for contributions, as if an individual were a resident in his country of residence, it seems appropriate to limit the application of the provision to contributions that would meet the requirements for tax relief if the individual remained in the country of residence. For this purpose, the scope of the regulation is limited only to such contributions that meet the requirements for a tax benefit in that State. As explained in paragraph 49 above, the recognition of a pension plan for tax purposes is not related to the question of whether a pension plan is a "recognized pension fund" as defined in subparagraph (i) of paragraph 1 of Article 3.
65. This method of achieving the same treatment assumes that in all Member States, only contributions to recognized pension schemes meet the requirements for tax relief. The tax treatment of contributions to pension schemes provided for in the taxation systems of member countries may differ from this assumption. It is recognized that in the course of bilateral negotiations, individual countries may wish to provide an additional definition of the relevant requirements for pension programs in such a way that it is consistent with the relevant domestic legislation of the parties to the agreement. They may also wish to define other terms used in the regulation, such as "provides services" and "provides services".
Tax obstacles in transferring pension rights
66. Another issue related to international labor mobility is the tax consequences that may arise as a result of the transfer of pension rights from a pension program established in one Contracting State to another program operating in the other Contracting State. When an individual moves from one employer to another, the pension rights accumulated by that person in the pension program at the first place of work are often transferred to another program at the second place of work. Similar mechanisms may exist to ensure the portability of pension rights from one individual pension program to another individual program.
67. Such a transfer of rights usually involves some kind of payment, which is the actuarial value of an individual's pension rights at the time of the transfer or the value of contributions and income that have accumulated in the program in favor of this person. Such payments can be made directly from the first program to the second; alternatively, they can be made by requiring an individual to contribute to the new pension program all or part of the amount received upon withdrawal from the previous program. In both cases, tax systems quite often allow tax-free transfer of such funds when it is purely internal in nature.
68. Problems may arise, however, when such a transfer of funds is carried out from a pension program operating in one Contracting State to a program in another State. In this case, the Contracting State in which the individual resides may consider that the payment arising from the transfer of rights is taxable income. A similar problem arises when a payment is made from a program established in a State that is granted withholding tax rights by the relevant tax convention for pension payments arising from such programs, since that State may require such taxation rights to apply to any payments received under such a program. Contracting States wishing to resolve this issue may include a provision roughly as follows::
In the case of accumulation of pension rights or amounts in a pension program established and recognized for tax purposes in one Contracting State for the benefit of an individual who is a resident of the other Contracting State, any transfer of these rights or amounts to a pension program established and recognized for tax purposes in that other State must take place in each of these States have the same taxation regime and are subject to the same conditions and restrictions as if they were implemented from the same pension program., established and recognized for tax purposes in that State, to another pension program established and recognized for tax purposes in the same State. The above provision may be amended to also cover the transfer of funds from pension funds established and recognized in third countries (this, however, may cause problems similar to those described in the preamble to paragraph 38 above).
Tax exemption for pension fund income
69. When two States, according to their domestic legislation, follow the same approach of tax exemption in the usual cases of investment income of pension funds established in their territories, these States, in order to achieve greater neutrality with respect to the location of capital, may wish to extend such tax exemption with respect to investment income that a pension fund established in one State, receives it in another country. To this end, States sometimes include in their conventions a provision along the following lines::
Notwithstanding any provision of this Convention, income arising in a Contracting State from which a resident of the other Contracting State receives, created and operated solely for the purpose of administering or making pension payments, and recognized by the competent authority of the first-mentioned State as generally consistent with a pension program recognized as such for tax purposes by that State, shall be exempt from taxation in this state.
As explained in paragraphs 10.7 and 10.8 of the Commentary to Article 3, States may prefer to simply refer to the income of a "recognized pension fund" when drafting such a provision.
Comments on the Comment
70. With regard to paragraphs 24 and 26, the Netherlands is of the view that social security payments may in some cases fall within the scope of Article 15 if they are paid while employment is ongoing.
71. With regard to paragraph 24, Germany considers that if the amount of the social security pension is determined on the basis of contributions to the program from the employee, this pension cannot be considered as falling within the scope of Article 18.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 19
REGARDING THE COLLECTION OF TAX ON REMUNERATION FOR PUBLIC SERVICE
1. The provisions of this article relate to salaries, salaries, pensions and other types of remuneration for public service. Similar provisions in the old bilateral Conventions were formulated in order to comply with the rules of international etiquette and mutual respect between sovereign States, so they were very limited in scope. However, the importance and scope of Article 19 have grown due to the fact that, as a result of the growth of the public sector in many countries, government activities abroad have significantly expanded. According to the original version of paragraph 1 of article 19 of the Draft 1963 Convention, the paying State was entitled to tax payments made for services rendered to that State or its political subdivision or local authority. The expression "may be taxed" was used, which did not mean the exclusive right to taxation.
2. In the 1977 Model Convention, paragraph 1 was divided into two paragraphs: paragraph 1, concerning salaries, wages and other similar remuneration other than pensions, and paragraph 2, concerning pensions. Unlike the original provision, paragraphs 1 and 2 (a) are based on the principle that the paying State has the exclusive right to tax payments. Thus, countries using the set-off method as a general method of exemption from double taxation in their Conventions, as an exception to this method, are required to exempt from taxation such payments for their residents, which are dealt with in paragraphs 1 and 2. If both Contracting States apply the method of exemption from double taxation, they may continue to use the expression "may be taxed" instead of "subject only to taxation". Of course, the effect is the same for such countries, regardless of which of these expressions they use. It is understood that the expression "subject only to taxation" does not prevent a Contracting State from taking into account income exempt in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 (a) when determining the tax rate applicable to the taxation of income earned by its residents from other sources. The principle of granting the exclusive right to taxation to the paying State is contained in many existing Conventions between OECD member countries.; Therefore, we can say that the principle has been adopted internationally. The principle also corresponds to the concept of international etiquette underlying this article and the provisions of the Vienna Conventions on Diplomatic and Consular Relations. It should be noted, however, that this article is not intended to limit the operation of any rules deriving from international law in the case of diplomatic missions and consular posts (see article 28), but rather concerns cases not covered by such rules.
2.1 In 1994, paragraph 1 was further amended to replace the term "remuneration" with the words "salary, salary and other similar remuneration". This amendment was intended to clarify the scope of the article, which applies exclusively to civil servants and persons receiving a pension for public service in the past, and not to persons providing independent services to the State or receiving a pension in connection with the provision of such services in the past.
2.2 In general, Member States consider that the term "salary, salary and similar remuneration paid" also includes remuneration in non-monetary form received in connection with services rendered to a subdivision of the State apparatus, an executive body or its local representative office (for example, the use of a place of residence or a car, medical insurance or life insurance, club membership).
3. The provisions of this article apply to payments made not only by subdivisions of the State apparatus, executive bodies or local authorities (in constituent States or States, provinces, departments, cantons, districts, districts, municipalities or groups of municipalities, etc.).
4. An exception to the principle of granting exclusive tax powers to the paying State is contained in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1. Against this background, it should be noted that, in accordance with the above-mentioned Conventions, the host State is allowed to tax remuneration paid to certain categories of employees of foreign diplomatic missions and consular institutions who are permanent residents or citizens of that State. Considering that pensions paid to retired civil servants should be considered for tax purposes as wages or salary/salary paid to such employees during the period of employment, an exception similar to that contained in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 1 is also included in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 2 concerning pensions. Since the condition set out in subsection (b) (ii) of paragraph 1 cannot be valid for a pensioner, the only prerequisite for a recipient State to have the right to tax a pension is that the pensioner must be a resident or citizen of such a State.
5. According to article 19 of the 1963 draft Convention, services rendered to a State, political subdivision or local authority were to be provided "in the performance of governmental functions". This expression was deleted from the 1977 Model Convention. However, some OECD member countries believe that such an exception will lead to an expansion of the scope of this article. Contracting States that adhere to this view and consider such an extension undesirable may continue to use the expression "in the performance of governmental functions" in their bilateral Conventions, specifying this expression as much as possible.
5.1 Although the word "pension" in the usual meaning of the word covers only recurring payments, the words "other similar remuneration", which were added to paragraph 2 in 2005, are sufficient to cover non-recurring payments as well. For example, a lump sum payment instead of periodic pension payments, which is made to a former civil servant after termination of employment, may fall under paragraph 2 of this article. Should a specific lump sum payment made in these circumstances be considered as another remuneration similar to a pension covered by paragraph 2, or as a final remuneration for work performed covered by paragraph 1?,
— an issue that can be resolved taking into account the factors presented in paragraph 5 of the commentary to article 18.
5.2 It should be noted that the expression "from funds created" in subparagraph (a) of paragraph 2 implies, among other things, a situation where a pension is paid not directly by the State, an executive body or a local authority, but from separate funds created by a State body. In addition, the initial capital of the fund should not be provided by the State, a political subdivision or a local authority. This expression covers payments from a private fund created for a government agency.
5.3 The problem arises when pensions are paid for the provision of both private and public services. This issue can often arise in cases where a person has worked in both the private and public sectors and receives one pension for both periods of work. This can happen either because a person has participated in the same project throughout their entire career, or because pension rights can be transferred. The trend towards greater mobility between the private and public sectors may increase the importance of this issue.
5.4 If a civil servant who has provided services to the State has transferred the right to a pension from the public system to a private one, pension payments will be taxed only in accordance with article 18, since such payment does not meet the technical requirement of subparagraph 2 (a).
5.5 In cases where the transfer is carried out in the opposite direction and pension rights are transferred from the private sector to the public sector, some States tax all pension payments in accordance with Article 19. However, other States distribute pension payments based on the relative source of pension rights in such a way that both parts are taxed in accordance with article
18. At the same time, some States believe that if one source represents the main amount of a pension, such a pension should be considered as being paid exclusively from this source. Nevertheless, it is generally recognized that distribution often causes significant administrative difficulties.
5.6 Contracting States may be concerned about the loss of income or the possibility of double taxation if the pension rights regime can be changed by transferring the fund between public and private schemes. This can be countered by the distribution; However, in order for the allocation to be applied to pension rights that are transferred from the public to the private system, the Contracting States may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, consider extending subparagraph 2 (a) to that part of any pension or other similar remuneration that is paid in connection with services rendered to a Contracting State or its political subdivision or to the local authority. This position can be formulated as follows:
2. (a) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, a portion of any pension or other similar remuneration which is paid in respect of services rendered to a Contracting State or to a political subdivision or local authority thereof shall be taxable only in that Contracting State.
Alternatively, the Contracting States can solve this problem by establishing a pension regime common to all.
6. Paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply if the services are provided in connection with entrepreneurial activities carried out by the State, one of its political subdivisions or local authorities that pay salaries, salaries, pensions or other similar remuneration. In such cases, the usual rules apply.: Article 15 for salaries and salaries, Article 16 for remuneration to directors and other similar payments, Article 17 for artists and athletes, and Article 18 for pensions. Contracting States wishing, for specific reasons, to waive paragraph 3 in their bilateral Conventions may do so by including in paragraphs 1 and 2 services provided in connection with business activities. Taking into account the specific functions performed by some government agencies, for example, state railways, post offices, state theaters, etc. For example, Contracting States wishing to retain paragraph 3 may, in the course of bilateral negotiations, agree to include salaries, salaries, pensions and other similar remuneration in the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 paid by such bodies, even if it can be said that they carry out business activities.
A comment about the comment
7. The Netherlands does not adhere to the interpretation given in paragraphs 5.4 and 5.6. The distribution of pension payments based on the relative source of pension rights, as well as private or public employment in the Netherlands is possible if pension rights are transferred from the public pension system to the private one.
Reservations about this article
8. Germany reserves the right to include a provision covering services provided to special private law institutions serving public purposes and funded from public budgets, such as the Goethe Institute or the German Academic Exchange Service, as well as remuneration paid to a specialist or volunteer sent to a Contracting State under a development assistance program for public services in accordance with with Article 19.
9. The United States reserves the right to amend the text, indicating that its application is not limited to article 1.
10. [Deleted]
11. France reserves the right to specify in its Conventions that salaries, salaries and other similar remuneration paid by Contracting States, its executive bodies and local subdivisions to an individual for services rendered to that State, subdivision or authority are taxable only in that State if the individual is a national of both Contracting States. Furthermore, France should leave the position regarding subsection (b) (ii) of paragraph 1 unchanged in view of the difficulties arising from this provision.
12. [Deleted]
13. France considers that the scope of application of Article 19 should cover the following areas:
— remuneration paid by public legal entities of the state or its political subdivision or local government body, since the identity of the payer is less significant than the public nature of the income.;
— public remuneration of entertainers and athletes in accordance with the wording in the Model Convention before 1995 (without applying the criterion of business activity, which is rarely appropriate in these cases), unless Article 17 contains a provision similar to that proposed in paragraph 14 of the commentary to Article 17.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 20
ABOUT STUDENT TAXATION
1. The rule outlined in this article concerns certain maintenance and tuition payments received by students or interns. All payments received from sources outside the State in which the student or intern in question is located are not taxable in that State.
2. The word "immediately" was included in the 1977 Model Convention in order to clarify that this article does not apply to a person who was once a resident of a Contracting State but subsequently changed his place of residence by moving to a third State before visiting another Contracting State.
3. The article applies only to payments received for the purpose of maintenance or education of the recipient. Therefore, it does not apply to a payment or any part of it that is remuneration for services rendered by the recipient; such payment is governed by Article 15 (or Article 7 in the case of independent services). However, in cases where the recipient's education involves work experience, it is necessary to distinguish between paying for services and paying for the recipient's maintenance, education, or professional training. The fact that the amount paid is similar to the amount paid to persons providing similar services who are not students or interns usually indicates that the payment is a reward for services. In addition, payments for maintenance, education or professional training should not exceed the level of expenses that may be incurred in the case of maintenance, education or professional training of the recipient.
4. This article applies only to payments received from sources outside the State where the student or trainee is present solely for the purpose of education or professional training. Payments coming from sources within that State are covered by other articles of the Convention: for example, if, during their stay in the first-mentioned State, a student or intern remains a resident of another State in accordance with Article 4, payments such as grants or scholarships that are not covered by other provisions of the Convention (for example, Article 15), will be taxed only in the State of his residence in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 21. For the purposes of this article, payments made by or on behalf of a resident of a Contracting State or carried out by a permanent establishment which such person has in that State shall not be deemed to originate from sources outside that State.
Reservations about this article
5. Estonia and Latvia reserve the right to amend this article regarding any student or intern.
6. With respect to the intern, Japan reserves the right to limit the tax exemption period to one year in accordance with this article.
7. The United States reserves the right to grant partial exemption from income tax on personal services rendered by students and interns, as well as to define the term "intern."
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 21
ON TAXATION OF OTHER INCOME
1.1 This article establishes a general rule concerning income not dealt with in previous articles of the Convention. The income in question is not only the income of a class that is not directly considered, but also income from sources that are not directly mentioned. The scope of this article is not limited to income originating in a Contracting State; it also applies to income from third Countries. If, for example, a person who is a resident of two Contracting States in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 4 is deemed to be a resident of only one of those States in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 or 3 of that article, this article shall not allow the other State to tax that person on income arising in third States, even if a person is a resident of another State within the framework of domestic law (see See also paragraph 8.2 of the commentary to Article 4 regarding the operation of paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 4 for the purposes of Conventions concluded between another State and third States).
Point 1
2. In accordance with this paragraph, the exclusive right to taxation is granted to the host State. In the event of a conflict between the two host States, Article 4 distributes the right of taxation in respect of the income of the third State.
3. The rule set out in this paragraph applies regardless of whether the right to taxation is exercised by the receiving State, and therefore, when income comes from another Contracting State, that State may not levy tax, even if the income is not taxed in the first-mentioned State. Similarly, where income arises in a third State and the recipient of that income is treated as a resident of both Contracting States in accordance with their domestic laws, the application of Article 4 will result in the recipient being treated as a resident of only one Contracting State and being subject to comprehensive taxation ("full tax liability") only in that State. In this case, the other Contracting State may not tax income received from a third State, even if the recipient is not taxed in the State of which he is considered a resident in accordance with Article 4. In order to avoid non-payment of taxes, the Contracting States may agree to limit the scope of application of this Article to income taxable in the Contracting State of which he is a resident. the recipient, and may change the provisions of this paragraph accordingly. In fact, this problem is only a particular aspect of the general problem discussed in paragraphs 34 and 35 of the commentary to Article 23 A.
Item 2
4. This paragraph provides for an exception to the provisions of paragraph 1 where the income is related to the activities of a permanent establishment which a resident of one Contracting State has in the other such State. This item includes income from third countries. In such a case, the right to levy the tax is granted to the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located. Paragraph 2 does not apply to immovable property in respect of which, according to paragraph 4 of Article 6, the State of permanent residence has a preferential right to levy taxes (see paragraphs 3 and 4 of the commentary to Article 6). Thus, immovable property located in one Contracting State and forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of that State located in the other Contracting State is subject to taxation only in the first-mentioned State in which such property is located and of which the recipient of the income is a resident. The above is consistent with the rules set out in Articles 13 and 22 with respect to immovable property, since paragraph 2 of these articles applies only to movable property of a permanent mission.
5. This paragraph also covers cases not dealt with in the previous articles of the Convention where the beneficiary and the payer of the income are residents of the same Contracting State and the income is attributed to a permanent establishment located in the other Contracting State. In this case, the right to levy the tax is granted to the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located. In cases where double taxation occurs, the receiving State must provide relief in accordance with the provisions of Article 23A or 23B (see paragraph 9 of the commentary to these Articles). Articles 23 A and 23 B.
5.1 For the purposes of this paragraph, the right or property in respect of which income is paid is actually linked to a permanent establishment if
The "economic" ownership of this right or property will be transferred to this permanent mission in accordance with the principles elaborated in the committee's report entitled "Securing profits for permanent missions" (see in particular paragraphs 72-97 of Part I of the report) for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 7. In the context of this paragraph, "economic" ownership of a right or property means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of a separate enterprise with associated benefits and encumbrances (for example, the right to income related to ownership of that right or property, the right to any available depreciation, potential profit or possible loss from appreciation or depreciation of that right or property).
5.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether any right or property is actually related to the permanent establishment is carried out with due regard to the guidelines set out in part IV of the committee's report on whether income from this right or property is taken into account when determining the profitability of a permanent establishment from the amount attributed the list of investment assets (see, in particular, paragraphs 165-170 of Part IV). As these guidelines are general in nature, tax authorities should consider adopting a flexible and pragmatic approach that would take into account the reasonable and consistent application of these guidelines by the enterprise in order to identify specific assets associated with a permanent establishment.
6. Some States applying the relief method (Article 23A) may have reason to suspect that the treatment provided in paragraph 2 may encourage an enterprise of a Contracting State to transfer assets such as shares, bonds or patents to a permanent establishment located in another Contracting State in order to be subject to a more favourable tax regime. the mode. Apart from the fact that paragraph 9 of Article 29 negates the advantages of Article 23A in the case of arrangements made for this purpose, it is important to note that the requirement that such assets be "securely attached" to such a permanent establishment requires more than just the reflection of these assets in the books of the permanent establishment for accounting purposes. (see paragraphs 5.1 and 5.2 above).
7. Some countries face difficulties in considering income arising from certain non-traditional financial documents when the parties to such a document are in a special relationship. Such countries may wish to add the following paragraph to article 21::
3. If, by virtue of a special relationship between the person referred to in paragraph 1 and any other person, or between both of them and any third person, the amount of income referred to in paragraph 1 exceeds the amount (if any) that would have been agreed between them in the absence of such a relationship, the provisions of this The articles apply only to the last specified amount. In such a case, the excess part of the income remains taxable in accordance with the laws of each Contracting State, with due regard to the other applicable provisions of this Convention.
The inclusion of this additional paragraph should have no effect on the treatment of new type of financial transactions between independent persons or in accordance with other provisions of the Convention.
8. This paragraph restricts the effect of provisions relating to the taxation of income not dealt with in other articles, just as paragraph 6 of Article 11 restricts the effect of provisions relating to the taxation of interest. In general, the principles set out in paragraphs 32-34 of the commentary to Article 11 are applicable to this paragraph.
9. Although this restriction may apply to any income that would otherwise fall within the scope of Article 21, it does not provide that in practice it is likely to apply to payments such as alimony or social security payments, but it is likely to be most appropriate in cases where certain non-traditional financial instruments They are concluded in such circumstances and on such conditions that they would not have been concluded in the absence of a special relationship (see paragraph 21.1 of the commentary to Article 21).
10. The limitation of article 21 differs from the limitation of article 11 in two important respects. First, if there are necessary circumstances, this clause allows that all payments under an unconventional financial agreement are considered excessive. Secondly, income that is excluded from the scope of the percentage article may still be subject to another article of the Convention, as explained in paragraphs 35-36 of the commentary to article 11. Income to which Article 21 would otherwise apply is, by definition, not covered by any other article. Thus, if the restriction provided for in Article 21 excludes a part of income from the scope of this article, articles 6-20 of the Convention do not apply to this income at all, and each Contracting State may tax such income in accordance with its domestic law.
11. However, other provisions of the Convention will continue to apply to such income, such as Article 23 ("Exemption from double taxation"), Article 25 ("Mutual agreement procedure") and Article 26 ("Exchange of information").
12. [Deleted]
Reservations about this article
13. Australia, Canada, Mexico, New Zealand, the Slovak Republic and Chile maintain their position on this article unchanged and would like to retain the right to tax income derived from sources in their own country.
14. Finland and Sweden would like to retain the right to tax certain annuities and similar payments to non-residents if such payments are made from pension insurance issued in their respective country.
15. The UK wishes to retain the right to tax revenues paid by its residents to non-residents in the form of income from the management of trusts or the estate of deceased persons.
16. Japan reserves the right to tax income from a specific contractual arrangement that provides a basis for deduction in order to determine the taxpayer's taxable income in the Contracting State of which he is a resident.
17. The United States reserves the right to provide for an exemption from alimony payments in both States.
18. The United States reserves the right, in accordance with its domestic law, to tax guarantee fees characterized as other income paid by an "expatriate legal entity" to a related person for a period of up to ten years.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 22
ON CAPITAL TAXATION
1. This article considers only taxes on capital, excluding taxes on property and inheritance, as well as on gifts and transfer fees. The taxes on capital considered in this article relate to the taxes specified in article 2.
2. Capital taxes are usually additional taxation of capital income. Consequently, taxes on this element of capital can be levied exclusively by the State, which has the right to tax income from this element of capital. However, one cannot refer only to the rules concerning the taxation of this class of income, since not all income items are subject to taxation exclusively in one State.
3. Thus, the article lists the first objects of property that can be taxed in the state in which such objects are located. This category includes immovable property referred to in article 6 owned by a resident of a Contracting State and located in the other Contracting State (paragraph 1) and movable property forming part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of a Contracting State in the other Contracting State (paragraph 2).
3.1 For the purposes of this paragraph, the property in respect of which income is paid is actually linked to a permanent establishment if the "economic" ownership of this right or property is transferred to that permanent establishment in accordance with the principles developed in the committee's report entitled "Securing profits for permanent missions" (see, in particular, paragraphs 72-97 of part (I of the report) for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 7. In the context of this paragraph, "economic" ownership of a right or property means the equivalent of ownership for income tax purposes of a separate enterprise with associated benefits and encumbrances (for example, the right to income related to ownership of that right or property, the right to any available depreciation, potential profit or possible loss from appreciation or depreciation of that right or property). Therefore, the mere fact that the property was accounted for for accounting purposes in the balance sheet prepared for the permanent establishment is not sufficient to conclude that it is actually related to this permanent establishment.
3.2 In the case of a permanent establishment of an enterprise engaged in insurance activities, the determination of whether any right or property is actually related to the permanent establishment is carried out with due regard to the guidelines set out in part IV of the committee's report on whether income from this right or property is taken into account when determining the profitability of a permanent establishment from the amount attributed investment assets (see, in particular, paragraphs 165-170 of Part IV). Since these guidelines are general in nature, tax authorities should consider adopting a flexible and pragmatic approach that takes into account the reasonable and consistent application of these guidelines by the enterprise in order to identify specific assets that form part of the commercial property of a permanent establishment.
4. As a general rule, ships and aircraft operated in international traffic and movable property related to the operation of such ships or aircraft are subject to taxation only in the receiving State (paragraph 3). This rule complies with the provisions of Article 8 and paragraph 3 of Article 13. Contracting States that would prefer to grant exclusive tax rights to the State in which the place of effective management of the enterprise is located may, with respect to a bilateral Convention, replace paragraph 3 with a provision corresponding to that proposed in paragraph 2 of the commentary to Article 8. Immovable property related to the operation of ships or aircraft may be taxed in the State in which it is located in accordance with the rule set out in paragraph 1.
4.1 Paragraph 3 applies in cases where the company owning the property itself operates the ships or aircraft referred to in this paragraph, whether for its own transportation activities or when renting ships or aircraft on charter terms, fully equipped, manned and staffed. However, it does not apply in cases where an enterprise that owns ships or aircraft does not operate them (for example, when an enterprise leases property to another person, except in cases of irregular rental of a vessel without crew (bareboat), as indicated in paragraph 5 of the commentary to Article 8). In this case, the capital is considered in paragraph 2 or 4.
5. With regard to capital elements other than those listed in paragraphs 1-3, this article provides that they are subject to taxation only in the Contracting State of which the person who owns such elements is a resident (paragraph 4).
6. If the provisions of paragraph 4 apply to elements of movable property subject to usufruct and double taxation persists due to inconsistencies between domestic laws, the States concerned may resort to a mutual agreement procedure or resolve this issue through bilateral negotiations.
7. The article does not provide for any rule providing for withholding on account of debt payment. The laws of the OECD member countries are too different for a common solution to be found for such retention. The problem of debt retention, which may arise when the taxpayer and the creditor are not residents of the same State, is dealt with in paragraph 4 of Article 24.
8. [Renumbered, modified]
Reservations about this article
9. Finland reserves the right to tax shares or other corporate rights in Finnish companies if the ownership of such shares or other corporate rights gives the right to use immovable property located in Finland and owned by the company.
10. New Zealand, Portugal and Turkey leave their position on this article unchanged, namely, the position on capital taxes in these countries.
11. France may accept the provisions of paragraph 4, but wishes to retain the possibility of applying the provisions of its legislation with respect to taxation of shares or rights to a significant interest in a company resident in France, or shares or rights of companies whose assets consist primarily of immovable property located in France.
12. Denmark, Norway and Sweden reserve the right to include special provisions regarding the capital represented by aircraft operated in international traffic if they belong to the Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS) air transport consortium.
13. Spain reserves the right to tax capital represented by shares or other rights in a company whose assets consist primarily of immovable property located in Spain, shares or other corporate rights granting its owner the right to use immovable property located in Spain, or shares or other rights constituting a significant ownership interest in a company based in Spain.
14. In view of its special position in the field of navigation, Greece will retain freedom of action with respect to the provisions of the Convention concerning capital represented by ships in international traffic and movable property related to the operation of such ships.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLES 23 A AND 23 B
REGARDING THE METHODS OF ELIMINATING DOUBLE TAXATION
I. Preliminary remarks
A. Scope of the Articles
1.1 These articles relate to the so-called legal double taxation, when the same income or capital is taxed in the hands of the same person by more than one State.
2. This case should be especially distinguished from the so-called economic double taxation, that is, when two different persons are taxed on the same income or capital. If problems arise in the field of economic double taxation, the States concerned should resolve them during bilateral negotiations.
3. International legal double taxation may arise in three cases::
a) if each Contracting State taxes the same person on his income or capital, regardless of the place and sources of their formation (simultaneous full liability for the tax, see paragraph 4 below);
(b) If the person is a resident of a Contracting State (R) [1-For the entire commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B, the letter "R" means the State of residence within the meaning of the Convention, "S" means the State of origin or residence, and
"E" is the State in which the permanent establishment is located, which is subject to full taxation in two countries, but at different times.] and receives income from or owns capital in the other Contracting State (S or E), both States shall tax that income or capital (see paragraph 5 below);
(c) If each Contracting State taxes the same person, who is not a resident of either Contracting State, on income derived from one Contracting State or capital owned by the other Contracting State.; This may be the case, for example, when a non-resident person has a permanent establishment in one Contracting State(s) through which he receives income from the other Contracting State or owns capital in the other Contracting State (a parallel limited tax liability, see paragraph 11 below).
4. The conflict in case a) is reduced to a conflict in case b) by virtue of Article 4. This is because in this article the term "resident of a Contracting State" is defined by reference to the tax liability of a person under domestic law by virtue of his place of residence, residence, place of management or any other criterion of a similar nature (paragraph 1 of Article 4) and by establishing special rules in the case of dual residence to determine which of the two States, it is the host State (R) within the meaning of the Convention (paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 4).
4.1 However, Article 4 applies only to cases of simultaneous full liability to the tax authorities. Thus, the conflict in case a) cannot be resolved if the same income item is subject to full taxation in two countries, but at different times. The following example illustrates this problem. Let's assume that a resident of State R1 receives taxable income from an employee stock option granted to this person. The R1 state levies taxes on the income from the option. Subsequently, the person becomes a resident of the country R2, which taxes this income upon its subsequent receipt. In this case, the person is taxed by each State at the time when he is a resident of that State, and Article 4 does not address this issue, since the person did not reside in these two States at the same time.
4.2 The conflict in this situation is accidental (b) and is therefore resolved to the extent that the employment services to which this option relates were provided in one of the Contracting States so that that State can be taxed in accordance with Article 15, since it is the State in which the relevant activity is carried out.. In this case, the State in which the services were provided is the source State to eliminate the situation of double taxation by another State. It does not matter that the first State does not collect the tax at the same time (see paragraph 32.8). It also does not matter that this State considers that it levies the tax, being the State of residence, but the source State (see the last sentence of paragraph 8).
4.3 However, if the relevant employment services have not been provided in either State, then the conflict does not involve double taxation of the resident source, and as confirmed by the phrase "except to the extent that these provisions allow taxation by that other State solely because the income is also income earned by a resident of that State.""contained in paragraph 1 of Articles 23A and 23b, any resulting double taxation is outside the scope of these articles. The mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 25 may be used to consider such a case. One of the possible grounds for resolving this case would be the agreement of the competent authorities of the two States that each State should provide benefits in respect of the residence tax levied by the other State in terms of benefits related to services rendered during the period when the employee was a resident of the other State. Thus, in the above example, if the relevant services were provided in a third State before the person became a resident of the R2 State, it would be logical for the competent authority of the R2 State to agree to grant a benefit (either using the offset method or the exemption method) for the tax of the R1 State levied on part of the benefit. unemployment related to services provided in a third State, since at the time of the provision of these services, the taxpayer was a resident of State R1, and not State R2 within the framework of the Convention between these two States.
5. In the case of (b), the conflict may be resolved by allocating the right to taxation between the Contracting States. Such distribution can be carried out by waiving the right to taxation either by the State of the source or place(s), or by the position of the permanent mission (E), or by the State of residence (R), or by dividing the right to taxation between the two States. Such allocation is governed by the provisions of Chapters III and IV of the Convention in conjunction with the provisions of Articles 23 A or 23 B.
6. In respect of certain items of income or capital, the exclusive right to taxation is granted to one of the Contracting States, and the relevant article states that this income or capital is "subject to taxation only" in one of the Contracting States. [1 - See the first sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 7, paragraph 1 of Article 8, paragraph 1 of Article 12, paragraphs 3 and 5 of Article 13, the first sentence of paragraph 1, as well as paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 15, Article 18, paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 19, paragraph 1 of Article 21 and paragraphs 3 and 4 of Article 22. The words "subject to taxation only" in one Contracting State exclude the possibility of taxation in the other Contracting State, thus avoiding double taxation. The State to which the exclusive right to taxation is granted is usually the State of which the taxpayer is resident within the meaning of Article 4, that is, State R, but in Article 19 [2 - See subparagraph (a) of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 19.] the exclusive right may be granted to another Contracting State (S), a resident of which the taxpayer is not within the meaning of Article 4.
7. With respect to other items of income or capital, the assignment of the right to taxation is not exclusive, and the relevant article then states that the relevant income or capital "may be taxed" in a Contracting State of which the taxpayer is not a resident within the meaning of Article 4. In this case, the receiving State (R) must provide benefits to prevent double taxation. Paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 23 A and paragraph 1 of Article 23 B are intended to provide the necessary benefits.
8. Articles 23 A and 23 B apply to a situation in which a resident of State R receives income or holds capital in another Contracting State E or S (which is not a receiving State within the meaning of the Convention) and that such income or capital may be taxed in that other State E or S in accordance with the Convention. Thus, these articles apply only to the receiving State and do not prescribe how another State E or C should act.
9. If a resident of a Contracting State R receives income from the same State R through a permanent establishment which he has in the other Contracting State E, the State E may tax such income (with the exception of income from immovable property located in the State R) if it relates to the said permanent establishment (paragraph 1 of Article 7 and paragraph 2 of Article 21). In this case, State R must also grant a benefit in accordance with Article 23 A or Article 23 B in respect of income related to a permanent establishment located in State E, despite the fact that this income originally originates in State R (see also paragraph 5 of the commentary to Article 21). However, if the Contracting States agree to grant State R a limited right to taxation as the State of origin of the source or interest within the limits set out in paragraph 2 of Article 10 or 11, the two States must also agree on a set-off provided by State E for the payment of the tax levied by State R in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 23 (A) or Paragraph 1 of Article 23 B.
9.1 However, in cases where State R applies the exemption method, there may be a problem with the taxation of dividends and interest in the receiving State and in the State of the source of income: the combination of Articles 7 and 23a does not allow that State to levy tax on this income, whereas if it were paid to a resident of another State, then State R, which is the State of the source of dividends or interest, could tax such dividends or interest at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11. Contracting States that consider such a provision unacceptable may include in their Conventions a provision according to which the receiving State has the right, as the State of origin of dividends or interest, to levy tax on such income at the rates provided for in paragraph 2 of Articles 10 and 11, despite the fact that it applies the exemption method. The State in which the permanent establishment is located would have deducted the payment of such tax in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B.; Of course, such a set-off is not provided in cases where the State in which the permanent establishment is located does not tax the dividends or interest owed to the permanent establishment in accordance with its domestic legislation.
10. If a resident of State R receives income from a third State through a permanent establishment in State E, State E may tax such income (with the exception of income from immovable property located in a third State) if it relates to such a permanent establishment (paragraph 1 of Articles 7 and paragraph 2 of Article 21). State P is obliged to satisfy the requirements under Article 23 or Article 23B in respect of profits related to a permanent establishment in State E. The Convention does not provide for a Contracting State to grant benefits for taxes levied in a third State where income arises; however, in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 24, any benefit provided for in the domestic legislation of State E (excluding the Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation) for residents of State E is also granted to a permanent mission in State E. enterprises of State R (see paragraphs 67-72 of the commentary to Article 24).
11. The conflict in the case of paragraph 3 (c) above is outside the scope of the Convention, since, according to Article 1, it applies only to persons who are residents of one or both States. However, the conflict can be resolved by applying a mutual agreement procedure (see also paragraph 10 above).
11.1 In some cases, the same income or capital may be taxed by each Contracting State as the income or capital of one of its residents. This may happen, for example, in cases where one of the Contracting States taxes the global income of an entity that is a resident of that State, while the other State considers that entity to be financially transparent and taxes members of that entity who are residents of that other State on their respective share of income. The phrase "(except to the extent that these provisions permit taxation by another State solely because the income is also income earned by a resident of that State or because the capital is also capital owned by a resident of that State)" clarifies that in such cases the two States are not required to mutually exempt each other from taxes levied solely on the basis of the taxpayer's place of residence, and therefore each State is obliged to exempt from double taxation only to the extent, to which extent taxation by another State complies with the provisions of the Convention allowing the taxation of the relevant income or capital as the State of origin or as the State in which there is a permanent establishment to which this income or capital is due, thereby excluding taxation that would be solely the result of the person's stay in another State. Although this result would logically follow from the wording of Articles 23 A and 23 B, even in the absence of this phrase, the addition of this phrase removes any doubt in this regard.
11.2 The principles outlined in the previous paragraph are illustrated by the following examples:
— Example A: An organization established in State R is a resident of State R and is therefore taxed on its global income in that State. State S considers this organization to be transparent for tax purposes and taxes the members of this organization on their respective share of income earned through this organization. All members of the organization are residents of State S. The entire income of the enterprise is a commercial profit related to a permanent establishment located in the State of R. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R is not required to provide benefits in accordance with Articles 23 A or 23 B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason why State S can tax this income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is the place of residence of the entity's members. State S, on the other hand, is obligated to grant relief in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B in respect of the entity's entire income, since this income may be taxed in State R in accordance with the provisions of Article 7, regardless of the fact that State R considers that the income was received by an entity resident in State R. In determining the amount of income tax paid in State R for the purpose of granting double taxation relief to members of the entity in accordance with Article 23 B, State S must take into account the tax paid by the entity in State R.
— Example B: The same facts apply as in Example A, except that 30 percent of the income earned through the organization is interest arising in State S and attributed to the permanent establishment in State R, and the rest of the income is commercial profit attributed to that State the same permanent representative office. In this case, double taxation exemption will be provided for commercial profits other than interest, as described in Example A. However, in the case of interest, the State R is obliged to provide a set-off to the entity in accordance with paragraph 2 of this article. Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B for the amount of tax on interest paid in State S by all members of the organization, not exceeding the lower 10 percent gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax that can be paid in State S in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 11) or tax payable in State R for these percentages (the last part of paragraph 2 of the Article
23 (A) and paragraph 1 of Article 23 (B). State S, on the other hand, is also obliged to provide benefits in accordance with Articles 23 A or 23 B to members of the organization who are residents of State S, since this income may be taxed by State R in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 7. If State S applies the withdrawal method provided for in Article 23 A, then this assumes that State S needs to exempt from payment the share of interest due to members who are residents of State S (see Paragraph 5 of the commentary to Article 21 and paragraph 9 of the commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B). If State S applies the set-off method referred to in Article 23 B, the set-off applies only to that part of the tax payable in State S which exceeds the amount of tax that State S would be entitled to levy in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 11, and this set-off must be provided for the amount of tax paid in State R, after deducting the offset that State R itself must provide for the amount of tax payable in State S in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 11.
— Example B: The same facts apply as in Example A, except that the entity's entire income is derived from real estate located in State C. In this case, in determining the tax payable by the entity, State R is required to grant a benefit in accordance with Article 23 A or 23 B in respect of the entity's entire income, since this income may be taxed in State S in accordance with the provisions of Article 6, regardless of the fact that State S considers that the income is received by the members, who are residents of State S. State S, on the other hand, is not obligated to grant a benefit under Articles 23 A and 23 B, since the only reason why State R can tax income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is because of the entity's residence (the result would be the same even if the income were attributed to permanent residence a representative office located in State R (see the first sentence of paragraph 9 of the commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B).
— Example D: The same facts apply as in Example A, except that the entity's entire income is interest arising in State S and does not relate to the permanent establishment in any way. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R is obliged to provide the entity with a set-off in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B for the amount of tax on interest paid in State S by all members of the entity, not exceeding less than 10 percent of the gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax which may be paid in State S in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article
11) or the tax payable in State R on this interest (the last part of paragraph 2 of Article 23 A and paragraph 1 of Article 23 B). State S, on the other hand, is not obligated to provide benefits under Articles 23 A or 23 B in respect of an entity's income, since this income does not originate in State R and does not relate to a permanent establishment in State R, and the only reason why State R can tax this income is that that income is also income earned by a resident of State R. Paragraph 1 of Article 11 confirms the right of the State of R to tax interest as income earned by a resident of the State of R.
— Example E: The same facts apply as in Example D, except that the entity's entire income is interest generated in State R. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R is not required to provide benefits in accordance with Articles 23 A or 23 B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason why State S can tax this income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is the place of residence of the entity's members. State S, on the other hand, is required to provide members with a set-off in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B for the amount of interest tax paid by the entity in State R, not exceeding the lower of 10 percent of the gross amount of interest (which is the maximum amount of tax that can be paid in State R in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 11) or the tax payable in State S on this interest (the last part of paragraph 2 of Article 23 A and paragraph 1 of Article 23 B). State S, however, is not obligated to grant benefits under Articles 23 A or 23 B in respect of tax paid in State R in excess of the maximum amount of tax that can be paid in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 11, since interest does not relate to permanent establishment in State R, and the only reason why The State of R may levy such an additional tax, is that income is also income earned by a resident of the State of R.
— Example E: The same facts apply as in Example D, except that the entity's entire income is interest arising in a third country. In this case, when determining the tax payable by the entity, State R is not required to provide benefits in accordance with Articles 23 A or 23 B in respect of the entity's income, since the only reason why State S can tax this income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is the place of residence of the entity's members. The State is also not obligated to provide benefits in accordance with Article 23 or 23 B in respect of the income of the organization, since the income does not originate in State R and cannot be attributed to a permanent establishment in State R. The only reason why the State of R can tax such income is that this income is received by a resident of the State of R. Paragraph 1 of Article 21 confirms the right of the State of R to tax interest, i.e. income received by a person resident of the State of R. Paragraph 1 of Article 21 also confirms the right of State S to tax interest, i.e. income earned by a person resident of State S.
Description of methods for eliminating double taxation
12. In existing Conventions, two leading principles are applied to eliminate double taxation by the State of which the taxpayer is a resident. For the sake of simplification, the following only refers to income taxes; however, these principles apply equally to capital taxes.
1. The principle of exemption from liability
13. In accordance with the principle of exemption, the receiving State of R does not tax income that can be taxed in State E or S in accordance with the Convention (as well as income that is taxed only in State E or S; see paragraph 6 above).
14. The principle of liberation can be applied in two main ways:
a) income that can be taxed in State E or S is not taken into account by State R at all for its taxation purposes; State R does not have the right to take into account the income thus exempted when determining the tax to be levied on the rest of the income; this method is called "full exemption from payment";
b) income that can be taxed in State E or S is not taxed in State R, but State R reserves the right to take this income into account when determining the tax to be levied on the rest of the income; this method is called "progressive exemption".
2. The principle of offsetting
15. In accordance with the principle of offsetting, the receiving State R calculates its tax on the basis of the taxpayer's total income, including income from another State E or S that may be taxed in that other State in accordance with the Convention (but not including income that is taxable only in State S; see paragraph 6 above). He then allows you to deduct from his own tax the tax paid in another state.
16. The principle of offsetting can be applied in two main ways:
a) State R allows a deduction from the total amount of tax paid in another State on income that may be taxed in that State; this method is called a "full offset";
b) The deduction provided by State R for taxes paid in another State is limited to that part of its own tax that corresponds to income that can be taxed in another State; this method is called "ordinary offsetting".
17. The fundamental difference between these methods is that the tax exemption method is income—oriented, while the offsetting methods are tax-oriented.
Operation and Effects of the Application of the Methods
18. Specific examples always facilitate the explanation of the operation of the various methods. Let us assume that the total income amounts to 100,000, of which 80,000 is derived from one State (the State of residence R) and 20,000 from another State (the State of source S). Let us assume that in State R the tax rate on income of 100,000 is 35 per cent, and on income of 80,000 it is 30 per cent. Let us further assume that the tax rate in State S is either 20 per cent — case (i), or 40 per cent — case (ii), and that, at this rate, the tax payable in respect of 20,000 amounts to 4,000 in case (i) or 8,000 in case (ii), respectively.
19. If the taxpayer's total income in State R amounts to 100,000, the tax on such income will amount to 35,000. If that person had income in the same amount, but derived in the manner indicated above, and if the domestic legislation of State R provided for no relief and no agreements existed between State R and State S, the total amount of tax would be, in case (i): 35,000 plus 4,000 = 39,000, and in case (ii): 35,000 plus 8,000 = 43,000.
1. Methods of Exemption
20. Under the exemption method, State R limits its taxation to that part of the total income which it is entitled to tax under the various Articles of the Convention, i.e. 80,000.
a) Full exemption
State R taxes 80,000 at the tax rate applicable to 80,000, i.e. 30 per cent.
| Example (i) | Example (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R amounts to 30% of 80,000 | 24,000 | 24,000 |
| Plus tax in State S | 4,000 | 8,000 |
| Total amount of taxes | 28,000 | 32,000 |
| Relief granted by State R | 11,000 | 11,000 |
b) Exemption with progression
State R taxes 80,000 at the tax rate applicable to the total income, wherever it arises (100,000), i.e. 35 per cent.
| Example (i) | Example (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R amounts to 35% of 80,000 | 28,000 | 28,000 |
| Plus tax in State S | 4,000 | 8,000 |
| Total amount of taxes | 32,000 | 36,000 |
| Relief granted by State R | 7,000 | 7,000 |
21. In both cases, the level of taxation in State S does not affect the amount of tax paid in State R. If the tax on income from State S in State S is lower than the relief granted by State R — cases a (i), a (ii) and b (i) — the taxpayer will be in a more favourable position than if his total income had been derived exclusively from State R. In the opposite case — case b (ii) — the taxpayer will be in a less favourable position.
22. This example also shows that the exemption granted in cases where State R applies the full exemption method may be greater than the tax levied in State S, even if the tax rates in State S are higher than those in State R. This is because under the full exemption method, not only is the tax of State R on income from State S waived (35% of 20,000 = 7,000; as in the case of exemption), but the tax on the remaining income (80,000) is also reduced by an amount corresponding to the difference between the rates at the two income levels in State R (35 minus 30 = 5% applied to 80,000 = 4,000).
2. Credit Method
23. Under the credit method, State R retains the right to tax the taxpayer's entire income, but allows a deduction from the tax thus imposed.
a) Full credit
State R calculates the tax on the total income of 100,000 US dollars at the rate of 35 per cent and allows a deduction for the tax on income from S payable in State S.
| Example (i) | Example (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R amounts to 35% of 100,000 | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Less tax in State S | - 4,000 | - 8,000 |
| Tax payable | 31,000 | 27,000 |
| Total amount of taxes | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Relief granted by State R | 4,000 | 8,000 |
b) Ordinary credit
State R calculates the tax on the total income of 100,000 at the rate of 35% and allows a deduction for the tax payable in State S on income from S, but in no case allows more than the part of the tax in State R attributable to income from S (maximum credit). The maximum credit will amount to 35% of 20,000 = 7,000.
| Example (i) | Example (ii) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax in State R amounts to 35% of 100,000 | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Less tax in State S | - 4,000 | |
| Less maximum credit | - 7,000 | |
| Tax payable | 31,000 | 28,000 |
| Total amount of taxes | 35,000 | 36,000 |
| Relief granted by State R | 4,000 | 7,000 |
24. A characteristic feature of the credit method, as compared with the exemption methods, is that State R is not required to allow a deduction in an amount greater than the amount of tax payable in State S.
25. If the tax payable in State S is lower than the tax of State R corresponding to the income from State S (maximum credit), the taxpayer is required to pay the same total amount of taxes as he would have had to pay if he had been taxed only in State R.
26. The same result is achieved when the tax payable in State S is higher, while State R applies the full credit method, at least as long as the total tax payable to State R is also as high as or higher than the amount of tax payable in State S.
27. If the tax payable in State S is higher and the credit is limited (ordinary credit), the taxpayer will not receive a deduction for the entire tax paid in State S. In such a case, the result would be less favourable for the taxpayer than if all his income had arisen in State R, and in these circumstances the ordinary credit method would have the same effect as the exemption with progression method.
Table 23-1. Total amount of tax in the cases illustrated above
A. All income arising in State R
Total amount of tax = 35,000
B. Income derived in two States, namely 80,000 in State R and 20,000 in State S
Total tax if tax is paid in State S:
| 4,000 (case (i)) | 8,000 (case (ii)) | |
|---|---|---|
| Outside the Convention (19)ᵃ | 39,000 | 43,000 |
| Full exemption (20a) | 28,000 | 32,000 |
| Exemption with progression (20b) | 32,000 | 36,000 |
| Full credit (23a) | 35,000 | 35,000 |
| Ordinary credit (23b) | 35,000 | 36,000 |
The figures in parentheses refer to the paragraphs of this Commentary.
Table 23-2. Amount of tax paid in the State of residence
If tax is paid in State S:
| 4,000 (case (i)) | 8,000 (case (ii)) | |
|---|---|---|
| Outside the Convention | 0 | 0 |
| Full exemption (20a)ᵃ | 11,000 | 11,000 |
| Exemption with progression (20b) | 7,000 | 7,000 |
| Full credit (23a) | 4,000 | 8,000 |
| Ordinary credit (23b) | 4,000 | 7,000 |
ᵃ The figures in parentheses refer to the paragraphs of this Commentary.
D. Methods Proposed in the Articles
28. The Convention concluded between OECD member countries is based on two leading principles. Some States give preference to the first, while others give preference to the second. Theoretically, one of the principles could be considered more desirable, but, in view of the aforementioned preferences, each State independently makes its choice in favour of one or the other.
29. On the other hand, it was considered important to limit the number of methods based on each leading principle that would be used. In view of this limitation, the Articles were drafted in such a way as to enable member countries to choose freely between two methods:
— the exemption with progression method (Article 23 A); and
— the ordinary credit method (Article 23 B).
30. If two Contracting States apply the same method, it is sufficient to include the relevant Article in the Convention. On the other hand, if two Contracting States apply different methods, both Articles may be combined into one, and the name of the State must be included in each relevant part of the Article in accordance with the method adopted by that State.
31. Contracting States may use a combination of these two methods. Such a combination is indeed necessary for Contracting State R, which generally applies the exemption method in the case of income which, under Articles 10 and 11, may be subject to limited taxation in State S. In such a case, Article 23 A provides in paragraph 2 for a credit in respect of the limited tax levied in the other Contracting State (however, adjustments to paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 23 A may be necessary in the case of distributions from real estate investment trusts (REITs), if the Contracting States have adopted provisions similar to those set out in paragraphs 67.1–67.7 of the Commentary on Article 10). Furthermore, States which generally apply the exemption method may wish to exclude specific Articles of income from its application and apply the credit method to such Articles. In such a case, paragraph 2 of Article 23 A could be amended to include such Articles of income.
31.1 One example of a case in which paragraph 2 may be amended in this way is where a State which generally applies the exemption method considers that this method should not apply to Articles of income which benefit from a preferential tax regime in the other State by virtue of a tax measure introduced in that State after the date of signature of the Convention. To include these Articles of income, paragraph 2 could be amended as follows:
- Where a resident of a Contracting State derives income,
a) which may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of Articles 10 and 11 (except where these provisions permit taxation by the other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State), or
b) which may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention (except where these provisions permit taxation by that other State solely because the income is also income derived by a resident of that State), but which benefits from a preferential tax regime in that other State by virtue of a tax measure,
(i) which was adopted in the other Contracting State after the signing of the Convention, and
(ii) in respect of which that State notified the competent authorities of the other Contracting State prior to the receipt of the income and after consultations with that other State,
the first-mentioned State shall allow as a deduction from the tax on the income of that resident an amount equal to the tax paid in the other State. However, such deduction shall not exceed that part of the tax, calculated before the deduction is granted, which is attributable to such item of income derived in the other State.
32. The two Articles referred to above are drafted in general terms and do not contain detailed rules on how the exemption or credit should be calculated, since this is left to the applicable domestic legislation and practice. Contracting States which consider it necessary to regulate any particular issue in the Convention itself reserve the right to do so in the course of bilateral negotiations.
Restore the original table markersPreserve the source heading hierarchy
Qualification conflict
32.1 Articles 23 A and 23 B require that benefits be provided by way of exemption or set-off, depending on the circumstances in which an item of income or capital may be taxed by the State of origin in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. Thus, the receiving State is obliged to apply the exemption or credit method in respect of an income or capital item if the Convention allows taxation of this item by the source State.
32.2 The interpretation of the phrase "may be taxed in the other Contracting State in accordance with the provisions of this Convention", which is used in both articles, is particularly important when considering cases where, under the provisions of the Convention, the receiving State and the source State classify the same item of income or capital differently.
32.3 Various situations need to be considered in this regard. If, due to differences in domestic legislation between the State of source and the State of residence, the former applies to a particular item of income or capital the provisions of the Convention that differ from those that the State of residence would apply to the same item of income or capital, the income is still taxed in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, as interpreted and applied by the source State. Thus, in this case, both articles require that the exemption from double taxation be granted by the host State, despite the conflict of qualifications resulting from these differences in domestic law.
32.4 This issue can be illustrated by the following example. Entrepreneurial activity is carried out through a permanent representative office of an enterprise established in State E. A partner residing in State R alienates his share in such an enterprise. State E considers the enterprise to be transparent for tax purposes, while State R considers it to be a taxable entity. Therefore, State E considers that the alienation of a share in a partnership is, for the purposes of its Convention with State R, the alienation by a partner of the main assets of a commercial enterprise carried out by the enterprise, which may be taxed by that State in accordance with paragraphs 1 or 2 of Article 13. State R, considering an enterprise to be a taxable entity, considers that the alienation of a share in an enterprise is akin to the alienation of a share in a company that cannot be taxed by State E by virtue of paragraph 5 of Article 13. In such a case, the conflict of qualifications arises solely from the different partnership regime in the domestic legislation of the two States, and State e should consider that State R taxes profits from alienation "in accordance with the provisions of the Convention" for the purposes of applying Article 23 A or Article 23 B. Therefore, State R must grant an exemption in accordance with Article 23 A or grant a loan in accordance with Article 23 B, regardless of the fact that, according to its own domestic law, it considers profits from alienation as income from the alienation of shares of a legal entity and that if the qualification of State E income corresponded to the income of State R, the State R should not have provided benefits under Article 23 A or Article 23 B. Therefore, there will be no double taxation in this case.
32.5 However, Articles 23 A and 23 B do not require the receiving State to exclude double taxation in all cases where the source State has imposed its tax by applying a Convention provision to an income item other than that which the receiving State considers applicable. For example, in the above example, if, for the purposes of applying paragraph 2 of Article 13, State E considers that the enterprise carried out commercial activities through a permanent commercial establishment, but State R considers that paragraph 5 applies because the enterprise did not have a permanent commercial establishment in State E, a dispute actually arises as to whether State E income tax in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. The same can be said if, in applying paragraph 2 of Article 13, State E interprets the phrase "an integral part of commercial property" in such a way as to include certain assets that would not fall within the meaning of this phrase according to the interpretation given to it by State R. Such conflicts, which arise as a result of different interpretations of facts or different interpretations of the provisions of the Convention, should be distinguished from the conflicts of qualifications described in the above-mentioned paragraph, when the discrepancy is based not on a different interpretation of the provisions of the Convention, but on different provisions of domestic law. In the first case, State R may claim that State E did not impose its tax in accordance with the provisions of the Convention if it applied its tax on the basis of what State R considers to be a misinterpretation of the facts or a misinterpretation of the Convention. States should apply the provisions of Article 25 (mutual agreement procedure) and, in particular, paragraph 3 thereof to resolve such conflicts in cases that would otherwise lead to unjustified double taxation.
32.6 The phrase "may be taxed in accordance with the provisions of this Convention" should also be interpreted in connection with possible cases of double non-payment of tax that may arise in accordance with Article 23 A. If the source State considers that the provisions of the Convention do not allow it to tax any item of income or capital that it would otherwise be entitled to tax, the receiving State should, for the purposes of applying paragraph 1 of Article 23 a, consider that this Item of income cannot be taxed by the source State in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. even if the receiving State would apply the Convention provides otherwise, in order to have the right to tax this income if it were in the position of the source State. Thus, the receiving State is not obliged, in accordance with paragraph 1, to exempt this income item, which is consistent with the main function of Article 23, which is to eliminate double taxation.
32.7 This situation is well illustrated by one of the examples described above. A commercial enterprise is carried out through a permanent commercial representative office in State E, established in that State, and a partner residing in State R alienates his share in this enterprise. However, by changing the facts of this example, it is assumed that State E considers the enterprise as a taxable organization, while State R considers it as an entity that is transparent for tax purposes.; It is further assumed that State R is a State applying the liberation method. State E, considering an enterprise to be a taxable entity, considers that the alienation of a share in an enterprise is akin to the alienation of a share in a company that cannot be taxed by virtue of paragraph 5 of Article 13. State R, on the other hand, considers that the alienation of an equity interest in an enterprise should have been taxed by State e as the alienation by a partner of the underlying assets of a commercial establishment, where paragraphs 1 or 2 of Article 13 would apply. In determining whether there is an obligation to exempt income from tax in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 23a, State R should be aware that, given how the provisions of the Convention are applied in conjunction with the domestic law of State E, that State cannot tax income in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. Thus, the State of R is not obligated to exempt this income from taxes.
Time mismatch
32.8 The provisions of the Convention allowing the source State to tax specific items of income or capital do not provide for any restrictions on when such a tax should be levied (see, for example, paragraph 2.2 of the commentary to Article 15). Since both Articles 23A and 23 require that a benefit be granted in cases where an item of income or capital may be taxed by the source State in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, it follows that such a benefit should be granted regardless of when the tax is levied by the source State. Therefore, the State of residence must ensure exemption from double taxation by offsetting or exempting such an item of income or capital, even if the source State taxes it in the previous or next year. However, some States do not follow the wording of Articles 23 A or 23 B of their bilateral Conventions and link the exemption from double taxation granted by them in accordance with the tax Conventions with the rules provided for in their domestic legislation. However, these countries are expected to look for other ways (for example, a mutual agreement procedure) to avoid double taxation, which might otherwise arise in cases where the source State levies taxes in a different tax year.
II. Commentary on the provisions of Article 23A (method of exemption from payment) Point 1
The obligation of the receiving State to grant tax exemption
33. The article establishes that the receiving State of R exempts from taxation income and capital that "may be taxed" in another State of E or S in accordance with the Convention.
34. Therefore, the State of residence should exempt from taxation income and capital that may be taxed by another State in accordance with the Convention, regardless of whether the right to taxation is exercised by that other State. This method is considered the most practical because it exempts the host State from conducting investigations into the actual tax situation in another State.
34.1 The obligation imposed on the State of residence to exempt a specific item of income or capital from tax depends on whether that item can be taxed by the State of origin in accordance with the Convention. Paragraphs 32.1-32.7 above specify how this condition should be interpreted. However, if this condition is fulfilled, the obligation may be considered as absolute, with the exception of paragraphs 2 and 4 of Article 23 A. Paragraph 2 concerns the case already mentioned in paragraph 31 above, namely income items that may be subject to limited taxation only in the source State. For such income items, this paragraph provides for a set-off method (see paragraph 47 below). Paragraph 4 deals with the case of certain conflicts of qualifications that would lead to double non-payment of tax as a result of the application of the Convention if the receiving State were required to grant an exemption from payment of such tax (see paragraphs 56.1-56.3 below).
35. Sometimes Contracting States may consider it reasonable in certain circumstances, in order to avoid double non-payment of tax, to make an exception to the absolute obligation of the receiving State to grant an exemption in cases where none of paragraphs 3 or 4 applies. This may be the case when a tax on specific items of income or capital is not provided for in accordance with the domestic legislation of the source State, or the tax is not levied effectively due to special circumstances such as offsetting losses, an error, or the expiration of a statutory deadline. In order to avoid double non-payment of taxes on specific income items, the Contracting States may agree to amend the relevant article (see paragraph 9 of the commentary to Article 15 and paragraph 12 of the commentary to Article 17; in the opposite case, where benefits in the source State are subject to actual taxation in the receiving State, see paragraph 20 of the commentary to Article 10, paragraph 10 of the commentary to Article 11, paragraph 6 of the commentary to Article 12, paragraph 21 of the commentary to Article 13 and paragraph 3 of the commentary to Article 21). It would also be possible to make an exception to the general rule in order to achieve a certain reciprocity, when one of the States uses the exemption method and the other uses the set—off method. Finally, another exception to the general rule may be made in cases where the State wishes to apply the tax offset method to specific income items rather than exemption from payment (see paragraph 31 above).
36. It should also be noted that, as explained in paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 above, Article 23A does not oblige a Contracting State to exempt income or capital from taxation if the only reason why another Contracting State may tax that income or capital in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is that the other State attributes that income or capital to income or capital for a resident of another country.
Alternative wording of the article
37. One of the consequences of the tax exemption method as formulated in this article is that taxable income or capital in the receiving State is reduced by the amount exempt in that State. If, in a particular State, the amount of income determined for income tax purposes is used as a measure for other purposes, such as social benefits, the application of the exemption method in the proposed form may lead to the fact that such benefits may be provided to persons who should not receive them. To avoid such consequences, the article may be amended so that the relevant income is included in the taxable income in the host State. In such cases, the receiving State must waive that part of the total tax that corresponds to the specified income. Following this procedure will lead to the result indicated in the article. States may be given the freedom to make such changes to the draft article. If a State wishes to supplement the draft of this article, as indicated above, paragraph 1 may be worded as follows:
If a resident of a Contracting State earns income or owns capital which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, is taxable only or may be taxed in the other Contracting State, the first-mentioned State, subject to the provisions of paragraph 2, shall allow the deduction from income tax or capital tax of that part of the income tax or capital tax, respectively, which is applicable, depending on the circumstances, to income derived from capital or owned by capital in another State. If this article is formulated in this way, then paragraph 3 is unnecessary and can be omitted.
Other difficulties
38. Article 23A contains the principle that the receiving State is obliged to grant an exemption from payment, but it does not contain detailed rules on how such an exemption should be implemented. This pattern can be traced throughout the plan of the Convention. Articles 6-22 also establish rules that establish the right to taxation in relation to various types of income or capital, without, as a rule, referring to the definition of taxable income or capital, deductions, tax rates, etc. (however, see Article 24). Experience shows that this is where various difficulties can arise. This is especially true of Article 23 A. Some of these issues are discussed in the following paragraphs. In the absence of a specific provision in the Convention, the domestic laws of each Contracting State shall apply. Some Conventions contain a direct reference to domestic legislation, but, of course, this will not help in cases where the method of exemption from payment is not used in domestic legislation. In such cases, the Contracting States that face this problem should establish rules for the application of Article 23a, if necessary, after consulting with the competent authority of the other Contracting State (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
1. The amount of income exempt from taxation
39. The amount of income exempt from tax by the State of residence is the amount that, if not for the Convention, would be subject to domestic income tax in accordance with the domestic legislation governing such a tax. Therefore, it may differ from the amount of income taxed in the source State in accordance with its domestic legislation.
40. Usually, the basis for calculating income taxes is total net income, i.e. gross income minus allowable deductions. Thus, the gross income earned in the source State is exempt, minus any allowable deductions (defined or proportional) related to such income.
41. Problems arise due to the fact that most countries in their tax legislation provide for additional deductions from the total amount of income or specific income items to generate taxable income. The problem can be illustrated with a numerical example.:
34. Therefore, the State of residence should exempt from taxation income and capital that may be taxed by another State in accordance with the Convention, regardless of whether the right to taxation is exercised by that other State. This method is considered the most practical because it exempts the host State from conducting investigations into the actual tax situation in another State.
34.1 The obligation imposed on the State of residence to exempt a specific item of income or capital from tax depends on whether that item can be taxed by the State of origin in accordance with the Convention. Paragraphs 32.1-32.7 above specify how this condition should be interpreted. However, if this condition is fulfilled, the obligation may be considered as absolute, with the exception of paragraphs 2 and 4 of Article 23 A. Paragraph 2 concerns the case already mentioned in paragraph 31 above, namely income items that may be subject to limited taxation only in the source State. For such income items, this paragraph provides for a set-off method (see paragraph 47 below). Paragraph 4 deals with the case of certain conflicts of qualifications that would lead to double non-payment of tax as a result of the application of the Convention if the receiving State were required to grant an exemption from payment of such tax (see paragraphs 56.1-56.3 below).
35. Sometimes Contracting States may consider it reasonable in certain circumstances, in order to avoid double non-payment of tax, to make an exception to the absolute obligation of the receiving State to grant an exemption in cases where none of paragraphs 3 or 4 applies. This may be the case when a tax on specific items of income or capital is not provided for in accordance with the domestic legislation of the source State, or the tax is not levied effectively due to special circumstances such as offsetting losses, an error, or the expiration of a statutory deadline. In order to avoid double non-payment of taxes on specific income items, the Contracting States may agree to amend the relevant article (see paragraph 9 of the commentary to Article 15 and paragraph 12 of the commentary to Article 17; in the opposite case, where benefits in the source State are subject to actual taxation in the receiving State, see paragraph 20 of the commentary to Article 10, paragraph 10 of the commentary to Article 11, paragraph 6 of the commentary to Article 12, paragraph 21 of the commentary to Article 13 and paragraph 3 of the commentary to Article 21). It would also be possible to make an exception to the general rule in order to achieve a certain reciprocity, when one of the States uses the exemption method and the other uses the set—off method. Finally, another exception to the general rule may be made in cases where the State wishes to apply the tax offset method to specific income items rather than exemption from payment (see paragraph 31 above).
36. It should also be noted that, as explained in paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 above, Article 23A does not oblige a Contracting State to exempt income or capital from taxation if the only reason why another Contracting State may tax that income or capital in accordance with the provisions of the Convention is that the other State attributes that income or capital to income or capital for a resident of another country.
Alternative wording of the article
37. One of the consequences of the tax exemption method as formulated in this article is that taxable income or capital in the receiving State is reduced by the amount exempt in that State. If, in a particular State, the amount of income determined for income tax purposes is used as a measure for other purposes, such as social benefits, the application of the exemption method in the proposed form may lead to the fact that such benefits may be provided to persons who should not receive them. To avoid such consequences, the article may be amended so that the relevant income is included in the taxable income in the host State. In such cases, the receiving State must waive that part of the total tax that corresponds to the specified income. Following this procedure will lead to the result indicated in the article. States may be given the freedom to make such changes to the draft article. If a State wishes to supplement the draft of this article, as indicated above, paragraph 1 may be worded as follows:
If a resident of a Contracting State earns income or owns capital which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, is taxable only or may be taxed in the other Contracting State, the first-mentioned State, subject to the provisions of paragraph 2, shall allow the deduction from income tax or capital tax of that part of the income tax or capital tax, respectively, which is applicable, depending on the circumstances, to income derived from capital or owned by capital in another State. If this article is formulated in this way, then paragraph 3 is unnecessary and can be omitted.
Other difficulties
38. Article 23A contains the principle that the receiving State is obliged to grant an exemption from payment, but it does not contain detailed rules on how such an exemption should be implemented. This pattern can be traced throughout the plan of the Convention. Articles 6-22 also establish rules that establish the right to taxation in relation to various types of income or capital, without, as a rule, referring to the definition of taxable income or capital, deductions, tax rates, etc. (however, see Article 24). Experience shows that this is where various difficulties can arise. This is especially true of Article 23 A. Some of these issues are discussed in the following paragraphs. In the absence of a specific provision in the Convention, the domestic laws of each Contracting State shall apply. Some Conventions contain a direct reference to domestic legislation, but, of course, this will not help in cases where the method of exemption from payment is not used in domestic legislation. In such cases, the Contracting States that face this problem should establish rules for the application of Article 23a, if necessary, after consulting with the competent authority of the other Contracting State (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
1. The amount of income exempt from taxation
39. The amount of income exempt from tax by the State of residence is the amount that, if not for the Convention, would be subject to domestic income tax in accordance with the domestic legislation governing such a tax. Therefore, it may differ from the amount of income taxed in the source State in accordance with its domestic legislation.
40. Usually, the basis for calculating income taxes is total net income, i.e. gross income minus allowable deductions. Thus, the gross income earned in the source State is exempt, minus any allowable deductions (defined or proportional) related to such income.
41. Problems arise due to the fact that most countries in their tax legislation provide for additional deductions from the total amount of income or specific income items to generate taxable income. The problem can be illustrated with a numerical example.:
Ниже приведён полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением структуры, нумерации, заголовков, абзацев, обозначений и всех числовых значений.
English Translation
| a) Domestic income (gross less allowable expenses) | 100 |
|---|---|
| b) Income from another State (gross less allowable expenses) | 100 |
| c) Total income | 200 |
| d) Contributions towards other expenses provided for under the legislation of the State of residence, which are not related to any income under Articles A or B, such as insurance contributions or payments to social institutions | -20 |
| e) “Net” income | 180 |
| f) Personal and family allowances | -30 |
| g) Income subject to taxation | 150 |
The question is what amount should be exempted from tax, for example:
— 100 (line b), in which case the taxable amount is 50;
— 90 (half of line e, following the ratio between lines b and c), in which case the taxable amount is 60 (line f is deducted entirely from domestic income);
— 75 (half of line g, following the ratio between lines b and c), in which case the taxable amount is 75;
— any other amount.
42. A comparison of the legislation and practice of OECD Member countries shows that the amount to be exempted from tax differs considerably from one country to another. The solution adopted by a State will depend on the policy pursued by that State and on its tax structure. A State may seek to ensure that its residents always benefit from all personal and family allowances and other deductions. In other States, these tax-free amounts are apportioned. In many States, personal or family allowances form part of the progressive tax scale, are granted in the form of a tax deduction, or are not granted at all, and family status is taken into account through separate tax scales.
43. In view of the wide variety of fiscal policies and methods in different States with regard to the determination of tax, particularly deductions, allowances and similar reliefs, it is preferable not to propose a clear-cut and uniform solution in the Convention, but to leave each State free to apply its own legislation and methods. Contracting States which prefer to have particular problems resolved in their Convention may, of course, do so in the course of bilateral negotiations. Finally, attention is drawn to the fact that this problem is also relevant to States applying the credit method (see paragraph 62 below).
2. Compensation for losses
44. Some States, when applying Article 23 A, treat losses incurred in another State in the same way as income derived in that State: as the State of residence (State R), they do not allow the deduction of losses incurred in connection with immovable property or a permanent establishment situated in another State (E or S). Provided that this other State allows such losses to be carried forward, the taxpayer will not be placed at a disadvantage, since the taxpayer will simply be unable to claim a double deduction for the same loss, namely in State E (or S) and in State R. Other States may, in their capacity as State of residence R, allow the deduction of losses incurred in State E (or S) from the income they assess. In such a case, State R should be entitled to limit the exemption provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 23 A in respect of profits or income subsequently derived in the other State E (or other States), by deducting from such subsequent profits or income the amount of previous losses which the taxpayer may carry forward in State E (or S). Since the solution depends primarily on the domestic legislation of the Contracting States, and since the laws of OECD Member countries differ considerably from one another, no solution can be proposed in the Article itself, as the Contracting States may, if they consider it necessary, clarify the above-mentioned issue and other problems relating to losses (see paragraph 62 below concerning the credit method) on a bilateral basis, either within the framework of the Article itself or through the mutual agreement procedure (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
3. Taxation of the remaining part of the income
45. In addition to the application of progressive tax rates, which are currently dealt with in paragraph 3 of this Article (see paragraphs 55 and 56 below), certain problems may arise in connection with specific provisions of tax legislation. For example, some tax laws provide that taxation begins only when a minimum amount of taxable income is reached or exceeded (the tax exemption threshold). Total income before the application of the Convention may clearly exceed such a tax-free threshold, but, as a result of the exemption arising from the application of the Convention, which leads to the deduction of exempt income from total taxable income, the remaining taxable income may be reduced to an amount below that threshold. For the reasons indicated in paragraph 43 above, no uniform solution can be proposed. However, it may be noted that the problem will not arise if the alternative wording of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A is adopted (as indicated in paragraph 37 above).
46. Some States have introduced special systems for taxing corporate income (see paragraphs 40–67 of the Commentary on Article 10). In States applying a split-rate corporate tax (paragraph 43 of that Commentary), a problem may arise as to whether the income to be exempted should be deducted from undistributed income (to which the ordinary tax rate applies) or from distributed income (to which a reduced tax rate applies), or whether the income to be exempted should be deducted from undistributed income (to which a reduced tax rate applies). The tax exemption should be allocated partly to distributed income and partly to undistributed income. If, under the legislation of a State applying a split-rate corporate tax, the parent company levies an additional tax on dividends which it has received from a domestic subsidiary but does not redistribute (on the grounds that such additional tax is a compensation for the lower tax rate granted to the subsidiary upon distribution of dividends), the question arises whether such additional tax may be levied if the subsidiary pays its dividends out of income exempt from tax under the Convention. Finally, a similar problem may arise in connection with taxes (précompte, advance corporate tax) levied on the distributed profits of a corporation to cover the tax credit due to shareholders (see paragraph 47 of the Commentary on Article 10). The question is whether such special taxes connected with the distribution of profits may be levied where the distribution is made out of profits exempt from taxation. The Contracting States should settle these issues through bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 2
47. Under Articles 10 and 11, the right to tax dividends and interest is divided between the State of residence and the State of source. In these cases, the State of residence is entitled not to tax such income if it so wishes (see, for example, paragraphs 72–78 below), and to apply the exemption method also to the above-mentioned items of income. However, if the State of residence prefers to exercise its right to tax such items of income, it cannot apply the exemption method to eliminate double taxation, since doing so would mean completely relinquishing its right to tax the relevant income. For the State of residence, the application of the credit method generally appears to be a satisfactory solution. Furthermore, as already indicated in paragraph 31 above, States which generally apply the exemption method may wish to apply the credit method, rather than the exemption method, to specific items of income. Consequently, this paragraph is drafted in accordance with the ordinary credit method. The Commentary on Article 23 B applies here and below, mutatis mutandis (Latin: after the necessary changes have been made), to paragraph 2 of Article 23 A.
48. In the cases referred to in the preceding paragraph, certain maximum rates are established for the tax withheld in the State of source. In such cases, the tax rate in the State of residence will very often be higher than the rate in the State of source. Therefore, the limitation of the deduction established in the second sentence of paragraph 2 and corresponding to the ordinary credit method is relevant only in a limited number of cases. If, in such cases, the Contracting States prefer to waive this limitation and apply the full credit method, they may do so by deleting the second sentence of paragraph 2.
Dividends from substantial holdings in a company
49. The combined effect of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 10 and Article 23 (Article 23 A or 23 B, as the case may be) is that the State of residence of the shareholder is permitted to tax dividends arising in another State, but it must credit against its own tax on such dividends the tax collected by the State in which the dividends arise at the rate established in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 10. This treatment also applies where the recipient of the dividends is a parent company receiving dividends from a subsidiary; in this case, the tax withheld in the State of the subsidiary and credited in the State of the parent company is limited to 5 per cent of the gross amount of the dividends as a result of the application of subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10.
50. These provisions make it possible to avoid juridical double taxation of dividends, but they do not prevent repeated corporate taxation of the profits distributed to the parent company: first at the level of the subsidiary and then at the level of the parent company. Such repeated taxation creates a very serious obstacle to the development of international investment. Many States have recognised this and have included provisions in their domestic legislation designed to remove this obstacle. Furthermore, the relevant provisions are frequently included in double taxation conventions.
51. The Committee on Fiscal Affairs considered whether it would be appropriate to amend Article 23 of the Convention in order to deal with this issue. Although many States expressed support for the inclusion of such a provision in the Model Convention, this encountered numerous difficulties resulting from differences of opinion among States and the diversity of possible solutions. Some States, fearing tax avoidance, preferred to retain their freedom of action and deal with this issue only in their domestic legislation.
52. Ultimately, it was considered preferable to leave States free to choose their own solution to the problem. For States which prefer to deal with the problem in their conventions, the solutions will most often follow one of the principles set out below:
а) Exemption with progression
The State of which the parent company is a resident exempts from tax the dividends which it receives from its subsidiary in another State, but may nevertheless take these dividends into account when calculating the tax payable by the parent company on its remaining income (this provision is often preferred by States applying the exemption method referred to in Article 23 A).
б) Credit for underlying tax
With regard to dividends received from a subsidiary, the State of which the parent company is a resident grants a credit, as provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 23 A or paragraph 1 of Article 23 B, as the case may be, not only for the tax on the dividends themselves, but also for the tax paid by the parent company on the distributed profits (this provision is often preferred by States applying, as a general rule, the credit method referred to in Article 23 B).
в) Assimilation to a domestic subsidiary holding
Dividends which the parent company receives from a foreign subsidiary are treated in the State of the parent company, for tax purposes, in the same way as dividends received from a subsidiary which is a resident of that State.
53. Where the State of the parent company levies capital taxes, a similar solution should also be applied to such taxes.
54. Furthermore, States are free to establish limits and methods for applying these provisions (definition and minimum duration of share ownership, the proportion of dividends considered to be covered by administrative or financial expenses) or to establish exemptions granted under a special regime, provided that the subsidiary carries out genuine economic activity in the State of which it is a resident, or derives the greater part of its income in that State, or is subject to substantial tax on profits in that State.
Paragraph 3
55. The 1963 Draft Convention expressly provided for the application of progressive tax rates by the State of residence (the last sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 23 A), and most conventions concluded between OECD Member countries which apply the exemption method follow this principle. Under paragraph 3 of Article 23 A, the State of residence retains the right to take into account the amount of exempt income or capital when determining the tax to be levied on the remaining income or capital. This rule applies even in cases where the income (or items of capital) exempt from tax and the taxable income (or items of capital) relate to persons (for example, husband and wife) whose income (or capital) is jointly taxed under domestic law. This progression principle applies to income or capital exempt from taxation under paragraph 1 of Article 23 A, as well as to income or capital which, under any other provision of the Convention, “may be taxed only” in the other Contracting State (see paragraph 6 above). It was for this reason that, in the 1977 Model Convention, the progression principle was moved from paragraph 1 of Article 23 A to a new paragraph 3 of that Article, and a reference was made to exemption “under any provision of the Convention”.
56. Paragraph 3 of Article 23 A relates only to the State of residence. The form of the Article does not prejudice the application by the State of source of the provisions of its domestic law concerning advancement.
Paragraph 4
56.1 The purpose of this paragraph is to avoid double non-taxation resulting from disagreements between the State of residence and the State of source concerning the facts of a case or the interpretation of the provisions of the Convention. This paragraph applies where, on the one hand, the State of source interprets the facts of the case or the provisions of the Convention in such a way that an item of income or capital falls under a provision of the Convention which eliminates its right to tax that item or limits the tax which it may impose, while, on the other hand, the State of residence adopts a different interpretation of the facts or provisions of the Convention and therefore considers that the relevant item may be taxed in the State of source under the Convention, which, in the absence of this paragraph, would result in an obligation for the State of residence to grant an exemption under the provisions of paragraph 1.
56.2 This paragraph applies only to the extent that the State of source has applied the provisions of the Convention to exempt an item of income or capital from tax, or has applied the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10 or 11 to an item of income. Thus, this paragraph will not apply if the State of source considers that it may tax an item of income or capital under the provisions of the Convention, but, under the provisions of its domestic law, tax on such income or capital is not actually paid. In such a case, the State of residence must exempt that item of income from tax under the provisions of paragraph 1, since the exemption in the State of source results not from the application of the provisions of the Convention but from the domestic law of the State of source (see paragraph 34 above). Similarly, if the States of source and residence disagree not only with regard to the classification of the income but also with regard to the amount of such income, paragraph 4 applies only to that part of the income which the State of source exempts from tax as a result of the application of the Convention or to which that State applies paragraph 2 of Article 10 or 11.
56.3 Cases in which this paragraph applies should be distinguished from cases where the classification of an item of income under the domestic law of the State of source interacts with the provisions of the Convention, preventing that State from taxing the item of income or capital in circumstances where the classification of that item under the domestic law of the State of residence would not lead to the same result. In such a case, which is dealt with in paragraphs 32.6 and 32.7 above, paragraph 1 does not impose on the State of residence an obligation to grant an exemption, since the item of income cannot be taxed in the State of source under the Convention. Since paragraph 1 does not apply, the provisions of paragraph 4 are not required in such a case to ensure the right of the State of residence to tax.
iii. Commentary on the provisions of Article 23 B (credit method)
Paragraph 1
A. Methods
57. Article 23 B, which is based on the principle of credit, corresponds to the ordinary credit method: the State of residence (R) allows, as a deduction from its own tax on the income or capital of its resident, an amount equal to the tax paid in the other State E (or S) on the income or capital of its resident derived from that other State E (or other States), or on capital owned by that resident and situated there, but the deduction is limited to the corresponding proportion of its own tax.
58. It is assumed that the ordinary credit method will also be applied with respect to a State which uses the exemption method but which, under paragraph 2 of Article 23 A, must credit the tax levied at limited rates in another State on dividends and interest (see paragraph 47 above). The possibility of making certain modifications mentioned in paragraphs 47 and 48 above (full credit) may, of course, also be relevant in the case of dividends and interest paid to a resident of a State which has adopted the ordinary credit method (see also paragraph 63 below).
59. The obligation imposed by Article 23 B on State R to credit tax levied in another State E (or other States) on an item of income or capital depends on whether that item may be taxed in State E (or other States) under the Convention. Paragraphs 32.1–32.7 above discuss how this condition should be interpreted. Items of income which, under subparagraph a) of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 19, “may be taxed only” in the other State are exempt from taxation in State R from the outset (see paragraph 6 above), and the Commentary on Article 23 A applies to such exempt income. As regards progression, reference is made to paragraph 2 of the Article (and paragraph 79 below).
60. Article 23 B establishes the basic rules of the credit method, but does not contain detailed rules for calculating and using the credit. This is consistent with the general structure of the Convention. Experience shows that numerous problems may arise. Some of them are discussed in the following paragraphs. Many States already have detailed rules in their domestic legislation concerning the crediting of foreign taxes. Accordingly, a number of conventions contain a reference to the domestic legislation of the Contracting States and additionally provide that such domestic rules must not affect the principle set out in Article 23 B. If the credit method is not used in the domestic legislation of a Contracting State, that State must establish rules for applying Article 23 B, where necessary after consultation with the competent authority of the other Contracting State (paragraph 3 of Article 25).
61. The amount of foreign tax for which a credit must be allowed is the tax actually paid in accordance with the Convention in the other Contracting State (excluding the amount of tax paid in that other State solely because the income or capital is also income derived by a resident of that State or capital owned by a resident of that State). Problems may arise, for example, where such tax is calculated not on the income for the year in respect of which it is levied, but on the income of the preceding year or on the average income of two or more preceding years. Other problems may arise in connection with different methods of determining income or with changes in exchange rates (devaluation or revaluation). However, such problems are unlikely to be resolved by means of a special provision in the Convention.
62. Under the provisions of the second sentence of paragraph 1 of Article 23 B, the deduction which State R must allow is limited to that part of the income tax which corresponds to the income derived in State S or E (the so-called “maximum deduction”). Such maximum deduction may be calculated either by apportioning the total amount of tax on aggregate income according to the ratio between the income for which the credit is granted and the total income, or by applying the tax rate on aggregate income to the income for which the credit is granted. In fact, in cases where the tax in State E (or S) is equal to or exceeds the corresponding tax in State R, the credit method will have the same effect as the exemption method with progression. Similar problems may also arise under the credit method in relation to the amount of income, tax rates, etc., as indicated in the Commentary on Article 23 A (see, in particular, paragraphs 39–41 and 44 above). For the same reasons as those mentioned in paragraphs 42 and 43 above, it is preferable that the credit method should not propose a clear-cut and uniform solution in the Convention, but should leave each State free to apply its own legislation and methods. This is also true of certain other problems considered below.
63. The maximum deduction is usually calculated on net income, i.e. income from State E (or States S), less allowable deductions (specific or proportional) connected with such income (see paragraph 40 above). For this reason, in many cases the maximum amount of the deduction may be lower than the tax actually paid in State E (or S). This may be particularly relevant where, for example, a resident of State R receiving interest from State S has borrowed funds from a third party to finance the loan which generates the interest. Since the interest payable on such borrowed funds may be set off against the interest received from State S, the amount of net income taxable in State R may be very small or may even be nil. As explained in paragraph 7.1 of the Commentary on Article 11, in this case the problem cannot be resolved by State R, since little or no tax will be levied in that State. One possible solution would be to exempt such interest from tax in the States, as proposed in paragraphs 7–7.12 of the Commentary on Article 11.
64. If a resident of State R derives different types of income from State S, and the latter, under its tax legislation, taxes only one of these items, the maximum deduction which State R may allow will normally be that part of its tax which relates only to that particular item of income among the items taxed in State S. However, other solutions are possible, particularly in view of the following broader problem: where a credit must be granted, for example, in respect of several items of income taxed in the States at different rates, or in respect of income from several States, whether or not covered by conventions, the question arises as to whether the maximum deduction or credit should be calculated separately for each item of income, for each country, or for all foreign income. Under a “global credit” system, all foreign income is aggregated, and the total amount of foreign taxes is credited against the domestic tax corresponding to the total foreign income.
65. In the case of losses, additional problems may arise. A resident of State R deriving income from State E (or S) may incur losses in State R, in State E (or S), or in a third State. For tax credit purposes, a loss incurred in a particular State will generally be set off against other income in the same State. Whether losses incurred outside State R (for example, in a permanent establishment) may be deducted from other income, regardless of whether such income is derived in State R or not, depends on the domestic legislation of State R. Similar problems may arise here, as mentioned in the Commentary on Article 23 A (paragraph 44 above). Where total income is derived from abroad and no income arises in State R other than a loss which does not exceed the foreign income, the total amount of tax levied in State R will correspond to the income in State S and, consequently, the maximum deduction which State R may allow will be equal to the tax levied in State R. Other solutions are possible.
66. The above-mentioned problems depend to a large extent on domestic legislation and practice, and therefore the solution should be left to each State. In this context, it may be noted that some States are quite liberal in applying the credit method. Some States have also considered or have already adopted the possibility of carrying forward unused tax credits. The Contracting States may, of course, make amendments to the Article during bilateral negotiations in order to resolve any of the above-mentioned problems.
67. In situations involving so-called “thin capitalisation”, the Model Convention allows the State in which the borrowing company is situated, under certain conditions, to treat the payment of interest as a payment of dividends under its domestic legislation; the essential condition is that the person granting the loan must effectively share in the risks incurred by the borrowing company. This has two consequences:
— taxation at source of such “interest” at the rate applicable to dividends (paragraph 2 of Article 10);
— inclusion of such “interest” in the taxable profits of the lending company.
68. Provided that the relevant conditions are met, the State of residence of the lender will be obliged to exempt the interest from any juridical or economic double taxation, as if the payment had in fact been a dividend. It must then credit the amount of tax actually withheld on such interest in the State of residence of the borrower at the rate applicable to dividends and, furthermore, if the lender is the parent company of the borrowing company, apply to such “interest” any additional relief under the parent/subsidiary regime. This obligation may arise:
a) from the actual wording of Article 23 of the Convention, where it provides for exemption from tax in respect of income defined in Article 10 as dividends, or items of income treated as such under Article 10;
b) from the context of the Convention, i.e. from the combination of Articles 9, 10, 11 and 23, and, where necessary, through the mutual agreement procedure:
— if the interest has been treated as dividends in the State of residence of the borrowing company under rules which are consistent with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11, and if the State of residence of the lender agrees that it has been properly treated as dividends and is prepared to apply the corresponding dividend treatment;
— where the State of residence of the lender applies similar thin capitalisation rules and treats the payment as a dividend in the reciprocal situation, i.e. if the payment were made by a company established in its territory to a resident of another Contracting State;
— in all other cases where the State of residence of the lender recognises that the State of residence of the borrower was justified in treating the interest as dividends.
69. With regard to dividends from a substantial shareholding in a company, reference is made to paragraphs 49–54 above.
69.1 Problems may arise in cases where the Contracting States treat entities such as partnerships differently. Assume, for example, that the State in which a partnership is established treats that partnership as a company, whereas the State of residence of the partner treats it as fiscally transparent. The State in which the partnership is situated may, under the applicable provisions of the Convention, tax the partnership's income when it is realised and, subject to the limitations provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 10, may also tax the distribution of the partnership's profits to its non-resident partners. However, the State of residence of the partner taxes that partner's share of the partnership's income only when that income is realised by the partnership.
69.2 The first question arising in this case is whether the State of residence of the partner, which taxes the partner on his share of the partnership's income, is required under the Convention to credit the tax levied on the partnership in the State of the partnership, which is treated by that State as a separate taxable entity. The answer to this question must be affirmative to the extent that the income may be taxed in the State of the partnership under the provisions of the Convention permitting taxation of the relevant income as income of the State of source or of the State in which there is a permanent establishment to which that income is attributable (see also paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 above). To the extent that the State of residence of the partner attributes the partnership's income to the partner for the purposes of taxing that partner's share of the income, it must also adopt a consistent approach and attribute to the partner the tax paid by the partnership (but only to the extent that such tax is paid under the provisions of the Convention permitting taxation at source) for the purposes of eliminating the double taxation arising from the taxation of the partner. In other words, if the corporate status granted to the partnership by the State of source is disregarded by the State of residence for the purposes of taxing the partner on his share of the income, it must also be disregarded for the purposes of the foreign tax credit.
69.3 The second question arising in this case is to what extent the State of residence of the partner must credit the tax levied by the State of the partnership on a distribution which is not taxed in the State of residence. The answer to this question is contained in the final fact. Since the distribution is not taxed in the State of residence of the partner, there is simply no tax in that State against which the tax levied by the State of the partnership on the distribution can be credited. A clear distinction must be made between the receipt of profits and the distribution of those profits, and the State of residence of the partner should not be expected to credit the tax levied by the State of the partnership on the distribution against its own tax levied on the receipt of profits (see the first sentence of paragraph 64 above).
B. Remarks concerning capital tax
70. Under the wording of paragraph 1, income tax may be credited only against income tax, and capital tax only against capital tax. Consequently, capital tax may be credited only if a capital tax exists in both Contracting States.
71. During bilateral negotiations, the two Contracting States may agree that a tax called a capital tax is, by its nature, closely connected with income tax and may therefore wish to credit it against income tax and vice versa. In some cases, since one State does not levy capital tax or both States levy capital tax only on domestic assets, no double taxation of capital arises. In such cases, it is understood, of course, that the reference to the taxation of capital may be deleted. Furthermore, States may consider it desirable, irrespective of the nature of the taxes levied under the Convention, to allow the total amount of tax in the State of source or situs to be credited against the total amount of tax in the State of residence. However, where the Convention includes both taxes on real capital and taxes on capital which are, in essence, income taxes, States may wish to credit against income tax only taxes on the latter type of capital. In such cases, States may modify the proposed Article at their discretion in order to achieve the desired result.
C. Tax sparing
72. Some States grant foreign investors various types of tax incentives with the aim of attracting foreign investment. Where the State of residence of the foreign investor applies the credit method, the benefit of the incentives granted by the State of source may be reduced to the extent that the State of residence, when taxing income derived as a result of the application of such incentives, allows a deduction only for the tax actually paid in the State of source. Similarly, if the State of residence applies the exemption method but establishes a certain level of taxation in the State of source, the granting of tax incentives by the State of source may result in the investor being denied the application of the exemption method in the State of residence.
73. To avoid any such consequences in the State of residence, some States which have adopted tax incentive programmes wish to include in their conventions provisions commonly referred to as “tax sparing” provisions. The purpose of these provisions is to allow non-residents to obtain a foreign tax credit for taxes which have been “saved” under the incentive programme of the State of source, or to ensure that such taxes are taken into account for the purposes of applying certain conditions which may be attached to exemption systems.
74. Tax sparing provisions represent a departure from the provisions of Articles 23 A and 23 B. Tax sparing provisions may take various forms, for example:
a) the State of residence allows as a deduction the amount of tax which the State of source could have levied under its general legislation, or such amount as is limited by the Convention (for example, the rate limitations provided for dividends and interest in Articles 10 and 11), even if the State of source has wholly or partly waived that tax under special provisions designed to promote its economic development;
b) as compensation for the reduction of tax by the State of source, the State of residence agrees to allow a deduction from its own tax of an amount (partly fictitious) determined at a higher rate;
c) the State of residence exempts from tax income which has benefited from tax incentives in the State of source.
75. The 1998 Report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs, entitled “Tax Sparing: A Reconsideration”¹ — reproduced in Volume II of the full version of the OECD Model Tax Convention on page R(14)-1 — analyses the tax policy considerations underlying tax sparing provisions and their development. The report identifies a number of problems which call into question the overall usefulness of granting tax sparing relief. These problems relate, in particular, to:
— the possibility of abuse associated with tax sparing;
— the effectiveness of tax sparing as an instrument of foreign aid promoting the economic development of the source country; and
— the general concern that tax sparing may encourage States to use tax incentives.
76. Experience shows that tax sparing is highly vulnerable to taxpayer abuse, which may prove costly both to the State of residence and to the State of source. Such abuse is difficult to detect. Furthermore, even where it is detected, it is difficult for the State of residence to respond quickly to such abuse. The process of repealing or amending existing tax incentives to prevent such abuse is often slow and burdensome.
77. Furthermore, tax sparing is not necessarily an effective instrument for promoting economic development. The reduction or elimination of tax incentives by the State of residence generally occurs only if profits are repatriated. Thus, by encouraging the repatriation of profits, tax sparing may become an inherent incentive for foreign investors to participate in short-term investment projects and a disincentive to conducting activities in the State of source on a long-term basis. In addition, foreign tax incentive systems are usually designed to allow foreign investors, when calculating their foreign tax credit, to offset to some extent the reduction in tax resulting from the application of a particular tax incentive against higher taxes paid in another country, so that, ultimately, no additional tax is levied by the State of residence as a result of the tax incentive.
78. Finally, the accelerating integration of national economies has led to many segments of national tax bases becoming more geographically mobile. These developments have prompted some States to introduce tax regimes whose main purpose is to undermine the tax bases of other countries. These types of tax incentives are specifically designed for highly mobile financial and other services which are particularly sensitive to tax differences. The potentially harmful effects of such regimes may be aggravated by the presence in international treaties of poorly designed tax sparing provisions. This is particularly true where a State introduces a tax regime after the conclusion of international treaties and adapts that regime in such a way as to ensure that it falls within the scope of an existing tax sparing provision.
78.1 The Committee concluded that Member countries should not necessarily refrain from adopting tax incentives. However, the Committee expressed the view that tax incentives should be considered only in relation to States whose level of economic development is significantly lower than that of OECD Member countries. Member countries should use objective economic criteria to identify States eligible for tax sparing. Where States agree to include a tax sparing provision, they are recommended to follow the recommendations set out in Section VI of the report on tax sparing. The use of these “best practices” will minimise the possibility of abuse of such provisions, ensuring that they apply exclusively to genuine investments aimed at developing the domestic infrastructure of the State of source. A narrowly drafted provision applicable to genuine investments will also prevent harmful tax competition for geographically mobile activities.
Paragraph 2
79. This paragraph was added in order to allow the State of residence to retain the right to take into account the amount of income or capital exempt from tax in that State when determining the tax to be levied on the remaining income or capital. The right thus retained extends to income or capital which
“may be taxed only” in the other State. Thus, the principle of progression is preserved for the State of residence not only in respect of income or capital which “may be taxed” in the other State, but also in respect of income or capital which “may be taxed only” in that other State. The Commentary on paragraph 3 of Article 23 A concerning the State of source also applies to paragraph 2 of Article 23 B.
Comments on the comment
80. The Netherlands, in principle, supports the resolution of situations involving both double taxation and double taxation evasion due to conflicts of qualifications between the Contracting States, since, in the opinion of the Netherlands, such situations are not provided for by the Contracting States and, moreover, contradict the object and purpose of the tax agreement. However, the Netherlands does not agree with the interpretation given in paragraphs 32.4 and 32.6 of the wording "in accordance with the provisions of this Convention" in Articles 23 A and 23 B of the Convention, according to which, in cases of conflicts of qualification caused by differences in domestic legislation between the State of origin and the State of residence, as a rule, the reservation given by the State of origin, will prevail for the purposes of application by the State of residence of Articles 23 A or 23 B. The Netherlands would like to reserve the right to determine the decision and how to apply it in the event of a certain conflict of qualifications, taking into account the circumstances of the cases under consideration and the relationship with the relevant Contracting State. Thus, the Netherlands will adhere to the specified interpretation contained in paragraphs 32.4 and 32.6 only to the extent that this is explicitly confirmed in a specific tax agreement, as a result of mutual agreement between the competent authorities, as implied in Article 25 of the Convention, or as a unilateral policy.
81. Switzerland reserves the right not to apply the rules set out in paragraph 32.3 in cases where a conflict of qualifications arises as a result of changes in the domestic legislation of the State of origin after the conclusion of the Convention.
82. The United States does not agree with the last sentence of paragraph 11.1 of the Commentary.
Reservations about the Article
83. In accordance with its reservations to paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 1, France reserves the right not to include in paragraph 1 of articles 23 A and 23 B the amendments provided for in the updated version of the 2017 Model Tax Convention concerning the elimination of double taxation in the presence of a financially transparent legal entity.
84. Luxembourg reserves the right not to include in paragraph 1 the changes provided for in the updated version of the 2017 Model Tax Convention.
85. The United States reserves the right not to include in paragraph 1 the bracketed phrase "(except in cases where these provisions allow taxation by that other State solely because income is also income earned by a resident of that State, or because capital is also capital owned by a resident of that State)". In addition, the United States would like to express the view that paragraph 1, which was added to address the so-called
"double economic taxation" does not correspond to paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Commentary, which clarifies that Article 23 concerns only the so-called "double legal taxation".
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 24
REGARDING NON-DISCRIMINATION
General remarks
1. This article is devoted to the elimination of tax discrimination under certain circumstances. All tax systems provide for legitimate differences based, for example, on differences in tax obligations or ability to pay. The non-discrimination provisions contained in the article aim to balance the need to prevent unjustified discrimination with the need to take into account these legitimate differences. For this reason, the article should not be overly expanded to cover so-called "indirect" discrimination. For example, although paragraph 1, which deals with discrimination on the basis of nationality, would prevent other treatment that is actually a hidden form of discrimination on the basis of nationality, such as different treatment of individuals depending on whether they have a passport issued by the State or are entitled to it, it is impossible to argue that non-residents of this state are primarily persons who are not citizens of this state, in order to conclude that, that different treatment based on place of residence indirectly constitutes discrimination based on nationality for the purposes of this paragraph.
2. Similarly, the provisions of this article cannot be interpreted as requiring most-favored-nation treatment. If a State has concluded a bilateral or multilateral agreement that provides tax benefits to citizens or residents of another Contracting State(s) that is a party to this agreement, citizens or residents of a third State that is not a Contracting State to this agreement may not claim these benefits due to a similar non-discrimination provision of the convention for the avoidance of double Taxation between the third State and the first mentioned State. Since tax agreements are based on the principle of reciprocity, tax treatment granted by one Contracting State in accordance with a bilateral or multilateral agreement to a resident or national of another Contracting State Party to this agreement by virtue of special economic relations between these Contracting States cannot be extended to a resident or citizen of a third State in accordance with the provisions of the tax convention on the prevention of discrimination between the first and third States.
3. The various provisions of Article 24 prevent differences in tax treatment that are based solely on certain specific grounds (e.g. nationality, in the case of paragraph 1). Thus, for the application of these points, the other relevant aspects must be the same. Different provisions of Article 24 use different formulations to achieve this result (for example, "under the same circumstances" in paragraphs 1 and 2; "carrying out the same activity" in paragraph 3;
"similar enterprises" in paragraph 5). In addition, although this article is aimed at eliminating differences based solely on certain grounds, it is not aimed at providing foreign citizens, non-residents, enterprises of other States, or national enterprises owned or controlled by non-residents with a more favorable tax regime than citizens, residents, or domestic enterprises owned or controlled by residents (see for example, paragraph 34 below).
4. Finally, as shown in paragraph 79 below, the provisions of this article should be read in the context of other articles of the Convention so that measures that are prescribed or expressly permitted by the provisions of these articles cannot be considered in violation of the provisions of the Article, even if they are applied only if they are applied in accordance with the provisions of this article, for example, concerns payments to non-residents. However, on the other hand, the fact that a particular measure does not violate the provisions of this article does not mean that it is permitted by the Convention, since this measure may violate other articles of the Convention.
Point 1
5. This paragraph establishes the principle that discrimination on the basis of nationality is prohibited for tax purposes and that, subject to reciprocity, nationals of one Contracting State may not be treated less favourably in the other Contracting State than nationals of the latter State in the same circumstances.
6. It should be noted that the principle of non-discrimination, under various names and with a more or less wide scope of application, was applied in international financial relations long before the classical conventions on the avoidance of double taxation appeared at the end of the 19th century. Thus, a huge number of agreements of various kinds (consular conventions or conventions on establishment, treaties of friendship or trade, etc.) concluded by States, especially in the 19th century, in order to expand and strengthen the diplomatic protection of their citizens, wherever they live, contain provisions according to which each of the two contracting States States undertake to provide citizens of another State with equal treatment with their own citizens. The fact that such provisions were subsequently incorporated into the double taxation conventions did not in any way affect their initial rationale and scope of application. The text of paragraph 1 provides that the application of this paragraph is not limited by Article 1 exclusively to nationals who are residents of a Contracting State, but, on the contrary, applies to all nationals of each Contracting State, regardless of whether they are residents of one of them or not. In other words, all citizens of one Contracting State have the right to take advantage of this provision in relation to the other Contracting State. This is true, in particular, for citizens of the Contracting States who are not residents of any of them, but reside in a third State.
7. The expression "under the same circumstances" refers to taxpayers (individuals and legal entities, partnerships and associations) who, from the point of view of the application of ordinary tax legislation and regulations, are in substantially similar circumstances both in law and in fact. The expression "in particular with regard to the place of residence" clearly indicates that the taxpayer's place of residence is one of the factors relevant in determining whether taxpayers are in similar circumstances. The expression "in the same circumstances" would in itself be sufficient to establish that a taxpayer who is a resident of a Contracting State and a taxpayer who is not a resident of that State are in different circumstances. In fact, although the expression "in particular with regard to the place of residence" did not appear in the draft 1963 Convention or in the 1977 Model Convention, the participating countries, when applying and interpreting the expression "in the same circumstances", consistently adhered to the view that the taxpayer's place of residence should be taken into account. However, when revising the Model Convention, the Committee on Tax Affairs considered that a specific reference to the taxpayers' place of residence would be a useful clarification, as it would avoid any possible doubts about the interpretation of the expression "in the same circumstances" in this regard.
8. Thus, in applying paragraph 1, the main question is whether two persons who are residents of the same State are treated differently solely because they have different nationalities. Consequently, if a Contracting State, when exempting from taxation in connection with family responsibilities, distinguishes between its citizens depending on whether they reside in its territory or not, that State cannot be obliged to provide citizens of another State who do not reside in its territory with the same treatment that it provides to its citizens. residents are citizens, but it undertakes to provide them with the same treatment as is provided to its citizens residing in another State. Similarly, paragraph 1 does not apply if a national of a Contracting State (State R), who is also a resident of State R, is taxed on less favorable terms in the other Contracting State (State S) than a citizen of State S residing in a third State (for example, as a result of applying provisions aimed at countering the use of tax havens), since these two persons are in different circumstances regarding their place of residence.
9. The expression "under the same circumstances" may in some cases refer to a person's tax status. This would be the case, for example, if a country imposed stricter tax obligations on its citizens or some of them than on non-citizens (this, for example, is a feature of the United States tax system). As long as such treatment does not in itself constitute a violation of paragraph 1, it cannot be argued that persons who are not citizens of that State are in the same circumstances as its citizens for the purposes of applying other provisions of the domestic tax legislation of that State to which a comprehensive tax code or limited tax liability applies. the responsibility of the taxpayer would be appropriate (for example, providing personal benefits).
10. Similarly, the provisions of paragraph 1 should not be interpreted as obliging a State that grants special tax benefits to its own government agencies or services as such to extend the same privileges to government agencies and services of another State.
11. They should also not be interpreted as obliging a State that provides special tax benefits to non-profit private institutions whose activities are carried out for the public benefit specific to that State to extend the same benefits to similar institutions whose activities are not aimed at its benefit.
12. In the first of these two cases, if the State grants tax immunity to its own government agencies and services, this is justified, since such agencies and services are an integral part of the State, and their conditions in no case can be comparable with those of government agencies and services in another country. However, this clause does not apply to State-owned corporations engaged in profitable activities. To the extent that they can be considered as private business enterprises, the provisions of paragraph 1 will apply to them.
13. As for the second case, if the State provides tax incentives to certain private non-profit institutions, this is clearly justified by the very nature of the activities of these institutions and the benefits that this State and its citizens will receive from these activities.
14. In addition, paragraph 1 was intentionally worded in a negative way. Providing that nationals of one Contracting State may not be subject in the other Contracting State to any taxation or any related requirements that are different or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which nationals of the other Contracting State are or may be subject under the same circumstances, this paragraph has the following effect Meaning: the same binding force, as if it required Contracting States to provide the same treatment to their respective citizens. However, since the main purpose of this paragraph is to prohibit discrimination in one State against citizens of another, nothing prevents the former State from granting foreign citizenship to persons for its own special reasons or in order to comply with a special provision of the convention for the avoidance of double taxation, such as, in particular, the requirement that the profits of permanent missions should be taxed. tax in accordance with Article 7, certain benefits or allowances that are not available to its own citizens. In the form in which it is formulated, paragraph 1 does not prohibit this.
15. In view of the above remark, the words "... should not be subjected to... to any taxation or any related requirement that is different or more burdensome ..." means that when a tax is levied on citizens and foreigners under the same circumstances, it must be in the same form both with respect to the basis of collection and the method of accrual, its rate must be the same and, finally, the formalities, tax-related matters (declarations, payments, deadlines, etc.) should not be more burdensome for foreigners than for citizens of the country.
16. In view of the legal relations that arise between a company and the State under whose legislation it is established, which from certain points of view are closely related to citizenship relations in the case of individuals, it seems justified not to consider legal entities, partnerships and associations in a special position, but to assimilate them with individuals in accordance with paragraph 1. This result is achieved by defining the term "national" in subparagraph (g) of paragraph 1 of Article 3.
17. By virtue of this definition, in the case of a legal entity such as a company, "national of a Contracting State" means a legal entity "whose status is derived from the laws in force in that Contracting State". The company, as a rule, obtains its status in accordance with the laws in force in the state in which it was registered. However, according to the domestic legislation of many countries, incorporation or registration is a criterion or one of the criteria for determining the place of residence of companies for the purposes of Article 4. Since paragraph 1 of Article 24 prohibits different treatment based on nationality, but only in relation to natural or legal persons "who are in the same circumstances, in particular with regard to their place of residence," for the purposes of this paragraph, it is important to distinguish different treatment based solely on nationality from other treatment related to other circumstances and, in particular, in particular, with the place of residence. As explained in paragraphs 7 and 8 above, paragraph 1 prohibits discrimination based solely on differences in nationality and requires that all other relevant factors, including the residence of a legal entity, be the same. The different treatment of residents and non-residents is an important feature of national tax systems and tax agreements.; If we consider Article 24 in the context of other articles of the Convention, most of which provide for different treatment for residents and non-residents, it becomes clear that two companies that are not residents of the same State for the purposes of the Convention (according to the rules of Article 4) are usually not in such circumstances for the purposes of paragraph 1..
18. Although residents and non-residents tend to be in different circumstances for the purposes of paragraph 1, it is clear that this is not the case where residence has nothing to do with the different treatment in question.
19. The following examples illustrate these principles.
20. Example 1: According to the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies registered in that State or with effective management in that State are residents of that State. According to the domestic income tax legislation of State B, only companies that have a place of effective management in this State are its residents. The Tax Agreement between State A and State B is identical to this Model Tax Agreement.
The internal tax legislation of State A provides that dividends paid to a company incorporated in that country by another company incorporated in that country are exempt from taxation. Since a company incorporated in State B, which would have effective management in State A, would be a resident of State A for the purposes of the Convention between State A and State B, the fact that dividends paid to such a company by a company incorporated in State A would not be subject to this exception, even if the company-the recipient is in the same circumstances as the company registered in State A with respect to its residence, this would constitute a violation of paragraph 1 in the absence of other relevant exceptional circumstances.
21. Example 2: According to the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies registered in that State are residents of that State, while companies registered abroad are non-residents. The Tax Convention between States A and B is identical to this Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that if a legal entity is a resident of both States in accordance with paragraph 1 of this article, this legal entity is considered to be a resident of the State in which it was registered. The internal tax legislation of State A provides that dividends paid to a company incorporated in that country by another company incorporated in that country are exempt from taxation. Paragraph 1 does not extend this regime to dividends paid to a company incorporated in State B. Even if a company incorporated in State A and a company incorporated in State B that receive such dividends are treated differently, these companies are in different circumstances with respect to their place of residence, and the place of residence in this case is an important factor (as can be concluded, for example, from paragraph 5 Article 10, which would prevent the subsequent taxation of dividends paid by a non-resident company but not paid by a resident company).
22. Example 3: According to the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies registered in that State are residents of that State. According to the internal tax legislation of State B, companies whose managers are located in this state are its residents. The Tax Agreement between States A and B is identical to this Model Tax Agreement. The internal tax legislation of State A provides that a non-resident company that is a resident of a State with which State A does not have a tax agreement allowing the exchange of tax information is subject to an annual tax of 3% of the value of its immovable property, and not a tax on the net income received from this property. A company incorporated in State B, but which is a resident of a State with which State A does not have a tax agreement allowing the exchange of tax information, cannot claim that paragraph 1 prevents the application of the 3% tax levied by State A, since it is treated differently from a company registered in State A. State A. In this case, such a company will not be in the same circumstances with respect to its place of residence as a company registered in State A, and the place of residence of the company will be important (for example, for the purposes of accessing information necessary to verify the net income from real estate received by a non-resident taxpayer).
23. Example 4: According to the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies registered in that State are residents of State A, while companies registered abroad are non-residents. The Tax Convention between States A and B is identical to this Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that if a legal entity is a resident of both States in accordance with paragraph 1 of this article, this legal entity is considered to be a resident of the State in which it was registered. According to the Payroll Tax Law of State A, all companies employing resident employees are subject to payroll tax, which makes no distinction depending on the employer's place of residence, but stipulates that only companies registered in State A can benefit from a lower payroll tax rate. In this case, the fact that a company incorporated in State B will not have the same place of residence as a company incorporated in State A, for the purposes of Convention A-B, has nothing to do with the different tax treatment in relation to payroll tax, and that, therefore, the different treatment there would be a violation of paragraph 1. There are no other relevant other circumstances.
24. Example 5: According to the domestic income tax legislation of State A, companies registered in that State or with effective management in that State are residents of that State, and companies that do not meet either of these two conditions are non-residents. According to the domestic legislation of the State on income tax, companies registered in this state are residents of this state. The Tax Convention of State A - State B is identical to this Model Tax Convention, except that paragraph 3 of Article 4 provides that if a legal entity is a resident of both States in accordance with paragraph 1 of this article, such a legal entity is considered to be a resident only of the State in which it was incorporated. The internal tax legislation of the State also provides that companies that have been registered and that have a place for effective management in this state have the right to consolidate their income for tax purposes if they are part of a group of companies with common shareholders. Company X, which was incorporated in State B, belongs to the same group as the two companies incorporated in State A, and all of these companies are effectively managed in State A. Because it was not registered in State A, Company X is not allowed to consolidate its earnings with those of the other two companies.
25. In this case, even if Company X is a resident of State A in accordance with the domestic law of that State, it is not a resident of State A for the purposes of the Convention by virtue of paragraph 3 of Article 4. Thus, it will not be in the same conditions as other companies in the group with respect to residency, and paragraph 1 will not allow it to take advantage of consolidation, even if the different treatment is the result of the fact that company X was not registered in State A. The residency of company X is certainly important in relation to the benefits of consolidation, since some provisions of the Convention, such as Articles 7 and 10, do not allow State A to tax certain types of income earned by company X.
Item 2
26. On 28 September 1954, a number of States concluded the Convention on the Status of Stateless Persons in New York, according to Article 29 of which stateless persons should be granted national treatment. The number of countries that have signed the Convention includes several OECD member countries.
27. It should be recognized, however, that the provisions of paragraph 2 of the bilateral convention will allow national treatment to be extended to stateless persons who, because they are in one of the situations listed in paragraph 2 of Article 1 of the aforementioned Convention of September 28, 1954, are not covered by this Convention. This mainly applies, on the one hand, to persons who, at the time of signing this Convention, receive protection or assistance from United Nations bodies or agencies other than the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, and, on the other hand, to persons who are residents of the country and who enjoy rights and obligations there. arising from the citizenship of that country, and to which these rights apply.
28. The purpose of paragraph 2 is to limit the scope of the provision concerning equal treatment of nationals of a Contracting State exclusively to stateless persons who are residents of that or the other Contracting State.
29. Thus excluding stateless persons who are not residents of any of the Contracting States, this provision does not allow them to enjoy privileges in one State in comparison with citizens of another State.
30. However, if States considered it desirable in their bilateral relations to extend the application of paragraph 2 to all stateless persons, regardless of whether they are residents of a Contracting State or not, so that in all cases they would enjoy the most favourable treatment accorded to nationals of the State concerned, they would only need to adopt the following text, which does not contain any conditions regarding residence in a Contracting State: Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 1, Stateless persons shall not be subject in a Contracting State to any taxation or any related requirements that are different or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which nationals of that State are or may be subject in the same circumstances, in particular with regard to residence.
31. Some States may consider that the provisions of paragraph 2 are too liberal, since they give stateless persons who are residents of one State the right to demand equal treatment not only in another State, but also in their State of permanent residence, and thus benefit, in particular, from the provisions of conventions on the avoidance of double taxation in the latter. concluded by him with third countries. States wishing to avoid this latter consequence may amend paragraph 2 to read as follows:
Stateless persons who are residents of one Contracting State shall not be subject in the other Contracting State to any taxation or any related requirements that are different or more burdensome than taxation and related requirements to which citizens of that other State are or may be subject in the same circumstances, in particular in particular, with regard to residence, be exposed.
32. Finally, it should be understood that the definition of the term "stateless person" to be used for the purposes of such a provision can only be that contained in paragraph 1 of Article 1 of the Convention of 28 September 1954, which defines a stateless person as "a person who is not a national of any State in accordance with its legislation".
Point 3
33. Strictly speaking, the type of discrimination that this paragraph is intended to end is discrimination based not on nationality, but on the actual location of the enterprise. This therefore applies to all residents of a Contracting State who have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, without distinction of any kind and regardless of their nationality.
34. It seems necessary, first of all, to clarify that the wording of the first sentence of paragraph 3 should be interpreted in the sense that it does not discriminate against non-resident persons for practical reasons other than resident persons, provided that this does not lead to more burdensome taxation for resident persons in the first the first case is better than the second one. In the negative form in which the relevant provision is formulated, only the result matters, while the tax regime can be adapted to the specific circumstances under which the tax is levied. For example, paragraph 3 does not preclude the use of special mechanisms that are used only for the purpose of determining profits due to a permanent establishment. This paragraph should be read in the context of the Convention and, in particular, paragraph 2 of Article 7, which provides that profits due to a permanent establishment are profits that could be expected to be received by a separate and independent enterprise engaged in the same or similar activities on the same or similar terms. Obviously, rules or administrative practices aimed at determining profits related to a permanent establishment based on the requirements of paragraph 2 of Article 7 cannot be considered a violation of paragraph 3, which is based on the same principle, since it requires that the taxation of a permanent establishment be no less favorable than that provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 7. and it is charged from a domestic enterprise engaged in similar activities.
35. According to the provisions of the first sentence of paragraph 3, the taxation of a permanent establishment in the relevant State should be no less favorable than the taxation of enterprises of that State engaged in similar activities. The purpose of this provision is to put an end to any discrimination against permanent representative offices in comparison with resident enterprises belonging to the same sector of activity in relation to taxes related to entrepreneurial activity, and especially taxes on business profits.
36. However, the second sentence of paragraph 3 specifies the conditions under which the principle of equal treatment set out in the first sentence should apply to natural persons who are residents of a Contracting State and have a permanent establishment in another State. It is mainly aimed at ensuring that such persons do not receive greater benefits than permanent residents due to the right to personal allowances and family allowances, both in the State of which they are residents, due to the application of its domestic legislation, and in another State due to the principle of equal treatment. Consequently, this leaves it to the State in which the permanent establishment is located to decide whether or not to grant personal benefits and allowances to interested persons in the proportion in which the amount of profit of the permanent establishment is correlated with the global income taxed in another State.
37. It is also clear that, for the purposes of paragraph 3, the taxation regime of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State in one Contracting State should be compared with the taxation regime of an enterprise of the first-mentioned State, which has a legal structure similar to that of an enterprise in the other Contracting State to which the permanent establishment belongs. For example, paragraph 3 does not require a State to apply to the profits of a permanent establishment of an enterprise operated by a non-resident individual the same tax rate that applies to an enterprise of that State operated by a resident company.
38. Similarly, regulated and unregulated activities are generally not "the same activity" for the purposes of paragraph 3. Thus, for example, paragraph 3 does not require that taxation of a permanent establishment whose activities include borrowing and lending funds, but which is not registered as a bank, should not It is less favorable than the taxation of local banks, since the permanent representative office does not carry out similar activities. Another example is an activity carried out by a State or its State authorities, which, controlled by the State, cannot be considered for the purposes of paragraph 3 as similar to an activity carried out by an enterprise of another State through a permanent establishment.
39. As for the first sentence, experience has shown that it has been difficult to clearly and fully define the essence of the principle of equal treatment, and this has led to significant differences of opinion on many of the implications of this principle. The main reason for the difficulties, apparently, lies in the actual nature of the permanent establishment, which is not a separate legal entity, but only a part of an enterprise whose head office is located in another country. The situation with a permanent mission differs from that of a domestic enterprise, which is a single entity, all of whose activities, with their financial consequences, can be fully attributed to the jurisdiction of the State in which its head office is located. The effects of the equal treatment clause will be discussed below in several aspects of tax collection.
A. Accrual of taxes
40. As for the basis of tax assessment, the principle of equal treatment usually has the following consequences:
a) Permanent missions should be given the same right as resident enterprises to deduct trading expenses, which are generally allowed by tax legislation to deduct from taxable profits. Such deductions should be allowed without any restrictions other than those also imposed on resident enterprises (see also paragraphs 33 and 34 of the commentary to Article 7).
(b) Permanent missions should be provided with the same benefits in respect of depreciation and reserves. They should have the right, without restrictions, to use not only depreciation charges that are usually provided to enterprises (linear depreciation, balance depreciation with reduction), but also special systems that exist in a number of countries ("wholesale" depreciation, accelerated depreciation, etc.). As for reserves, it should be noted that they are sometimes created for purposes other than offsetting
— in accordance with the principles of commercial accounting — depreciation of assets, expenses or losses that have not yet occurred, but due to circumstances may occur in the near future. Thus, in some countries, enterprises have the right to create reserves for investments from taxable profits. When such a right is enjoyed by all enterprises or all enterprises in a given sector of activity, as a rule, non-resident enterprises should also enjoy it under the same conditions with respect to their permanent representative offices located in the relevant State, insofar as it concerns the activities to which they relate. such reserves, which could be relevant, are subject to taxation in that State.
c) Permanent missions should also have the ability, available to resident enterprises in most countries, to transfer losses incurred at the end of the reporting period forward or backward over a certain period of time (for example, 5 years). It is hardly necessary to specify that in the case of permanent representative offices, it is the losses from their own business activities that will be eligible for such a transfer.
(d) In addition, permanent missions should be subject to the same rules as resident enterprises with respect to the taxation of capital gains resulting from the disposal of assets, whether during or after the termination of operations.
41. As clearly stated in subparagraph (c) above, the principle of equal treatment set out in paragraph 3 applies only to taxation of the permanent establishment's own activities. Thus, this principle is limited to comparing the rules governing the taxation of the activities of one's own permanent establishment with the rules applicable to similar commercial activities carried out by an independent resident enterprise. It does not apply to rules that take into account the relationship between an enterprise and other enterprises (for example, income taxes that allow for consolidation, transfer of losses, or tax-free transfer of property between jointly owned companies), since the latter rules are not aimed at taxing an enterprise's own business activities similar to those of a permanent establishment, but instead, on taxation of a resident enterprise as part of the common ownership of groups of associated enterprises. Such rules are often used to ensure or simplify compliance with tax laws and administration within a national group. It follows that the principle of equal treatment is inapplicable. For the same reasons, the rules concerning the distribution of profits of a resident enterprise cannot be extended to a permanent establishment in accordance with paragraph 3, since they do not relate to the commercial activities of a permanent establishment (see paragraph 59 below).
42. In addition, it is clear that the application of transfer pricing rules based on the "at arm's length" standard in the case of transfers from a permanent mission to its head office (or vice versa) cannot be considered a violation of paragraph 3, even if such rules do not apply to transfers within the organization. the enterprise of the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located. Indeed, the application of the principle of impartiality to the determination of profits due to a permanent establishment is provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 7, and this paragraph is part of the context in which paragraph 3 of Article 24 should be interpreted.; In addition, since Article 9 permits the application of the principle of equality of the parties to the transfer of funds between a domestic enterprise and a related foreign enterprise, it cannot be considered that its application in the case of a permanent establishment leads to less favorable taxation than taxation levied on an enterprise of the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located in the city center.
43. Although the general rules mentioned above rarely cause any difficulties regarding the principle of non-discrimination, they do not provide an exhaustive list of possible consequences of applying this principle in determining the tax base. The application of this principle may be less obvious in the case of tax incentive measures that most countries, faced with problems such as industrial decentralization, the development of economically backward regions, or the promotion of new activities necessary for economic expansion, have introduced to facilitate the solution of these problems through tax incentives, reductions, or other tax advantages provided to enterprises. to invest, which corresponds to the official goals.
44. Since such measures are aimed at achieving goals directly related to the economic activities of the State concerned, it would be appropriate if their effect were extended to permanent representative offices of enterprises of another State that has a convention on the avoidance of double taxation with the former, which enshrines the provisions of Article 24, after they are granted the right to engage in entrepreneurial activity in that State. the State or in accordance with its legislation, or in accordance with an international agreement (trade agreements, conventions on the establishment of representative offices, etc.) concluded between the two states.
45. It should be noted, however, that although non-resident enterprises are eligible to claim these tax benefits in the relevant State, they must meet the same conditions and requirements as resident enterprises. Therefore, they may be denied such benefits if their permanent missions are unable or refuse to comply with the special conditions and requirements related to their provision.
46. In addition, it goes without saying that non-resident enterprises are not entitled to tax benefits related to activities that are strictly assigned to domestic enterprises for reasons of national interests, defense, protection of the national economy, etc., since non-resident enterprises are not allowed to participate in such activities.
47. Finally, the provisions of paragraph 3 should not be interpreted as obliging a State that grants special tax benefits to non-profit institutions whose activities are carried out for the public benefit specific to that State to extend the same benefits to permanent missions of similar institutions of another State whose activities are not solely aimed at the public benefit of the first-mentioned State.
B. Special treatment of dividends received in respect of permanent representative office holdings
48 . In many countries, there are special rules for the taxation of dividends distributed between companies (parent company-subsidiary regime, Schachtelprivileg, non bis in idem rule). The question arises whether, by virtue of the provisions of paragraph 3, such a regime should be applied by permanent missions in respect of dividends on holdings that make up part of their assets.
49 . Opinions differ on this point. Some States believe that special treatment should be given to permanent missions. They believe that such a regime was introduced in order to avoid double taxation of profits earned by the subsidiary and distributed between the parent company. In general, income tax should be levied once, in the hands of a subsidiary engaged in profit-making activities. The parent company should be exempt from paying tax on such profits earned from the subsidiary, or should be exempt from paying tax levied by the subsidiary in accordance with the indirect credit method. In cases where shares are held as direct investments by a permanent establishment, the same principle implies that such a permanent establishment receiving dividends from a subsidiary should also be given special treatment due to the fact that income tax has already been levied on the subsidiary. On the other hand, with this approach, it is hardly possible to grant the State in which the parent company's head office is located an exemption from double taxation caused by the second tax levy in the State of permanent establishment. The State of the parent company, in which there were no activities leading to the receipt of double taxable profits, usually exempts these profits from taxation or levies income tax, which is insufficient for double offsetting (i.e. for the income tax of a subsidiary, as well as for such tax on a permanent establishment). All of the above assumes that the shares owned by the permanent mission are effectively linked to its activities. In addition, an obvious additional condition is that the profits from which the dividends are distributed must be subject to income tax.
50 . Other States, on the contrary, consider that the joining of permanent missions to their own enterprises does not entail any obligation to grant special treatment to the former. They justify their position for various reasons. The purpose of the special regime is to avoid economic double taxation of dividends, and it is the State of residence of the recipient company, rather than the State of permanent establishment, that should bear its costs, since it is more interested in achieving this goal. Another reason is related to the distribution of tax revenues between States. The loss of tax revenues incurred by the state when applying such a special regime is partially offset by taxation of dividends when they are redistributed by the parent company that used such a regime (withheld tax on dividends, shareholders' tax). The State providing such treatment to permanent missions does not benefit from such compensation. Another argument is that if such a regime is conditioned by the redistribution of dividends, then its extension to permanent representative offices is not justified, since in this case a permanent representative office, which is only part of a company in another state and does not distribute dividends, has a more favorable regime than a resident company. Finally, States that consider that paragraph 3 does not entail any obligation to extend such a regime to permanent missions argue that there is a risk that companies of one State may transfer their assets in companies of another State to their permanent missions in that other State for the sole purpose of taking advantage of such a regime.
51 . The fact remains that there may be very good reasons for the holding to be owned and operated by a permanent mission rather than the head office of the enterprise, namely,
— the reasons arising mainly from the legal or regulatory obligation of banks, financial institutions and insurance companies to keep on deposits in the countries where they operate, a certain amount of assets, in particular shares, as security for the fulfillment of their obligations;
— for reasons of expediency, when the holdings are located in companies that have business relations with a permanent mission or whose head offices are located in the same country as the permanent mission;
— for reasons of practical convenience, in line with the current trend towards decentralizing management functions in large enterprises.
52 . In view of these differences of opinion, as well as the situations just described, it would be advisable for States, when concluding bilateral Conventions, to clarify the interpretation they give to the first sentence of paragraph 3. The Parties may, if they wish, clarify their position or change it from their previous practice in the protocol or any other document attached to it. Conventions.
53 . Such a document could also provide a solution to satisfy the objection mentioned above that extending the asset ownership regime in a State (A) to permanent representative offices of companies that are residents of another State (B) leads to such companies unjustifiably enjoying preferential treatment compared to other companies that are residents of that State. the same state and whose head offices own assets in the capital of companies that are residents of the state and, Since dividends on their shares can be repatriated by the first companies without paying withholding tax, such tax is levied on dividends distributed to the last companies at a rate of 5 or 15% of their value, depending on the circumstances. Tax neutrality and equality of the tax burden between permanent missions and subsidiaries, as advocated by the States concerned, can be ensured by adapting the provisions of paragraphs 2 and 4 of Article 10 in a bilateral Convention between States a and B in order to allow income tax to be levied in State A on dividends paid by companies that are residents of that State., permanent missions of companies that are residents of State b, in the same way as if they came directly, i.e.:
— 5% in case of ownership of at least 25%; — 15% in all other cases.
54 . If, due to the lack of relevant provisions in the domestic legislation of the State concerned, it is impossible to levy a withheld tax on dividends paid to permanent missions there, the dividend distribution regime may be extended to permanent missions if its application is limited so that the tax levied by the State of the source of the dividends is the same regardless of whether the dividends are received by the permanent mission a company that is a resident of another state, or obtained directly from such a company.
C. Structure and tax rate
55 . In countries where enterprises, mainly companies, are subject to income taxes specific to them, the provisions of paragraph 3 raise some specific issues with respect to the rate applied in the case of permanent missions, related to the fact that a permanent establishment is only part of a legal entity that is not under the jurisdiction of the State in which the permanent establishment is located. representative office.
56 . When the taxation of profits of companies that are residents of a given State is calculated on a progressive scale of rates, such a scale should, in principle, apply to permanent establishments located in that State. If, when applying the progressive scale, the State of permanent establishment takes into account the profits of the entire company that owns such a permanent establishment, then this rule does not seem to contradict the rule of equal treatment, since resident companies are actually treated equally (see paragraphs 55, 56 and 79 of the Commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B). Therefore, States that tax their own companies in this way can determine the regime applicable to permanent missions within the framework of bilateral Conventions.
57 . When a tax system based on a progressive rate scale includes a rule that the minimum rate applies to permanent establishments, it cannot be a priori argued that such a rule is incompatible with the principle of equal treatment. The profit of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs must be taken into account when determining the rate applied according to the progressive scale. The provisions of the first sentence of paragraph 3 are not respected only if the minimum bid is higher.
58 . However, even if the profits of the entire enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs are taken into account when applying either a progressive rate scale or a minimum rate, this should not contradict the principle of a separate and independent enterprise, according to which the profits of the permanent establishment should be determined in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7. Thus, the minimum amount of tax levied in the State where a permanent establishment is located is the amount that would be due if it were a separate and independent enterprise, excluding the profits of the entire enterprise to which it belongs. Thus, the State in which the permanent establishment is located has the right to apply the progressive scale applied to resident enterprises exclusively to the profits of the permanent establishment, leaving aside the profits of the entire enterprise when the latter is less than the profits of the permanent establishment. This State may also tax the profits of a permanent establishment at a minimum rate, provided that the same rate also applies to resident enterprises, even if accounting for the profits of the entire enterprise to which it belongs leads to a reduction in the amount of tax or no tax at all.
59 . Since a permanent establishment, by its very nature, does not distribute dividends, the tax regime of distribution carried out by the enterprise to which the permanent establishment belongs thus goes beyond paragraph 3. Paragraph 3 is limited to taxation of profits from the activities of the permanent establishment itself and does not apply to taxation of the enterprise as a whole. This is confirmed by the second sentence of the paragraph, which confirms that tax aspects related to a taxpayer owning a permanent establishment, such as personal allowances and deductions, are outside the scope of this paragraph. Thus, issues related to various systems for integrating corporate and equity taxes (for example, the advance corporate tax, the précompte mobilier, the calculation of corporate income after income tax and the corresponding tax benefits for dividends) are beyond the scope of this paragraph.
60 . In some States, the profits of a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State are taxed at a higher rate than the profits of enterprises of that State. This additional tax, sometimes referred to as the "branch tax", can be explained by the fact that if a subsidiary of a foreign enterprise has received the same profit as a permanent establishment and subsequently distributed this profit as dividends, then additional tax is levied on these dividends in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 10. If such a tax is expressed simply as an additional tax payable on the profits of a permanent establishment, then it should be considered as a tax levied on the profits from the activities of the permanent establishment itself, and not as a tax on the enterprise in its capacity as the owner of the permanent establishment. Thus, such a tax contradicts paragraph 3.
61 . However, this situation should be distinguished from the situation with a tax that is levied on amounts deducted, for example, in the form of interest, when calculating the profits of a permanent establishment (for example, "industry-level interest tax"); in this case, the tax is levied not from the permanent establishment itself, but from the enterprise that is considered to be interest is paid, and therefore falls outside the scope of paragraph 3 (however, depending on the circumstances, other provisions, such as those of articles 7 and 11, may be relevant to determining whether such a tax is permitted by the Convention; see paragraph 4).
D. Withholding of tax on dividends, interest and royalties received by a permanent mission
62 . When permanent missions receive dividends, interest or royalties, such income, by virtue of paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11 and paragraph 3 of Article 12, respectively, is subject to the provisions of Article 7 and, therefore, subject to the comments made in paragraph 53 above regarding dividends received on shares of permanent missions, is included to the taxable profits of such permanent representative offices (see paragraph 74 of the commentary to Article 7).
63 . According to the relevant comments to the above-mentioned provisions of articles 10, 11 and 12 (see paragraphs 31, 24 and 20, respectively), these provisions exempt the State of source of dividends, interest or royalties received by the permanent mission from applying any restriction provided for in these articles, which means — and this is the generally accepted interpretation - that they leave completely The right of the source State, where the permanent establishment is located, to apply its withheld tax at the full rate is not affected.
64 . Although this approach does not create any problems with respect to the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 24 in the case of countries where withheld tax is levied on all such income, regardless of whether they are paid to residents (permanent institutions such as resident enterprises that are allowed to offset such withheld tax against income tax due by virtue of Article 7) or non-residents (subject to the restrictions provided for in Articles 10, 11 and 12), the situation differs when the withheld tax is applied exclusively to income paid to non-residents.
65 . In this latter case, it is actually difficult to reconcile the withholding tax with the principle set out in paragraph 3, according to which, for the purposes of taxation of income derived from or normally associated with their activities, as is recognized in the case of dividends, interest and royalties referred to in paragraph 4 of articles 10 and 11 and in paragraph 3 of Article 12, — permanent establishments should be considered as resident enterprises and, therefore, in respect of such income, they should be taxed exclusively on profits.
64. Although this approach does not pose any problems with respect to the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 24 in the case of countries where withheld tax is levied on all such income, regardless of whether it is paid to residents (permanent institutions, such as resident enterprises, which are allowed to offset such withheld tax against income tax due in by virtue of Article 7) or to non-residents (subject to the restrictions provided for in Articles 10, 11 and 12), the situation differs when the withheld tax is applied exclusively to income paid to non-residents.
65 . In this latter case, it is actually difficult to reconcile the withholding tax with the principle set out in paragraph 3, according to which, for the purposes of taxation of income derived from or normally associated with their activities, as is recognized in the case of dividends, interest and royalties referred to in paragraph 4 of articles 10 and 11 and in paragraph 3 of Article 12, — permanent establishments should be considered as resident enterprises and, therefore, in respect of such income, they should be taxed exclusively on profits.
66 . In any case, the Contracting States experiencing this difficulty should resolve it in the course of bilateral negotiations, taking into account their special circumstances.
E. Offsetting the amount of foreign tax
67 . In this regard, when foreign income is included in the profits attributable to a permanent establishment, by virtue of the same principle, it is legitimate to provide a permanent establishment with a loan for the foreign tax levied on such income, when such a loan is provided to resident enterprises in accordance with domestic law.
68 . If in a Contracting State (A) in which a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State (B) is located, a credit for a tax levied in a third State (C) can only be authorized by virtue of the Convention, then the more general question arises of extending to permanent missions the credit benefits provided for in the tax Conventions concluded with third countries. Although a permanent establishment is not a person in itself and therefore is not entitled to the benefits provided for in these tax Conventions, this issue is relevant to the taxation of a permanent establishment. This issue is discussed below in the special case of dividends and interest.
F. Extending to permanent missions the benefits of the credit provisions of the Conventions on the Avoidance of Double Taxation concluded with Third Countries
69 . When a permanent establishment in a Contracting State of an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State receives dividends or interest from a third State, the question arises as to whether and to what extent the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located should transfer taxes that cannot be collected from the third State.
70 . There is agreement that double taxation arises in these situations and that some method of exemption from it should be found. Most Member States can provide loans in these cases on the basis of their domestic legislation or in accordance with paragraph 3. States that are unable to provide credit in this way or that wish to clarify the situation may wish to supplement the provision of their Convention with the Contracting State in which the enterprise is resident with wording that allows the State in which the permanent establishment is located to credit a tax liability in the State in which the income originates for an amount not exceeding which are resident enterprises in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located, may be required on the basis of a Convention with a third State. If the tax that cannot be levied in accordance with the Convention between a third State and the State of residence of an enterprise having a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State is lower than the tax levied in accordance with the Convention between the third State and the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located, then only the lower tax levied in the third state. This result would be achieved by adding the following words after the first sentence of paragraph 3:
When a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State in a Contracting State receives dividends or interest from a third State and the ownership or debt claim in respect of which the dividends or interest are paid is actually linked to that permanent establishment, the first-mentioned State shall grant a tax credit in respect of the tax paid in the third State on the dividends or interest, depending on circumstances, by applying the tax rate, provided for by the Convention on Taxes on Income and Capital between the State of which the enterprise is a resident and a third State. However, the amount of the set-off must not exceed the amount that an enterprise that is a resident of the first-mentioned State may require in accordance with the Income and Capital Convention of that State with a Third State.
If the Convention also provides for other categories of income that may be taxed in the State in which they arise and for which credit should be provided (for example, royalties in some Conventions), then the above provision should be amended to cover them as well.
71 . If a permanent establishment of an enterprise resident in a Contracting State (State of residence) located in a Contracting State receives dividends, interest or royalties from a third State (source State) and in accordance with a procedure agreed between the State of residence and the source State, the source State shall request a residence certificate for the application of withheld tax at the rate provided for in the Convention. between the State of origin and the State of residence, This certificate must be issued by the last State. Although this procedure may be useful in cases where the State of residence uses the credit method, it does not seem to serve the purpose when that State uses the exemption method, since income from a third State is not subject to taxation in the State of residence of the enterprise. On the other hand, the State in which the permanent establishment is located may benefit from participating in the certification procedure, as this procedure will provide useful information for audit purposes. Another question that arises in the case of triangular cases is,
— this is a question of abuse. For example, if a Contracting State applies the exemption method provided for in Article 23a to profits relating to a permanent establishment located in a third State that does not tax passive income arising in the other Contracting State but relating to such a permanent establishment, there is a risk that such income will not be taxed in either State. from three states. This issue is dealt with in paragraph 8 of Article 29.
72 . In addition to the typical three-way situation discussed here, other similar cases arise, in particular one in which the State of the enterprise is also the State from which the income attributed to the permanent establishment in another State originates (see also paragraph 5 of the commentary to Article 21 and paragraphs 9 and 9.1 of the commentary to Articles 23 A and 23 B). States can resolve such issues during bilateral negotiations.
Item 4
73 . This paragraph is intended to put an end to a certain form of discrimination due to the fact that in some countries the deduction of interest, royalties and other payments, allowed without restrictions when the recipient is a resident, is limited or even prohibited when he is a non-resident. A similar situation is observed in the field of capital taxation when it comes to debts owed to non-residents. However, Contracting States may amend this provision in bilateral Conventions to avoid its use for tax evasion purposes.
74 . Paragraph 4 does not prohibit the borrower's country from applying its internal thin capitalization rules to the extent that they are compatible with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article
11. However, if such a regime follows from rules that are incompatible with these articles and that apply only to non-resident creditors (with the exception of resident creditors), then such a regime is prohibited by paragraph 4.
75 . In addition, paragraph 4 does not prohibit additional information requirements for payments made to non-residents, as these requirements are designed to ensure the same level of compliance and verification in the case of payments to residents and non-residents.
Item 5
76 . This paragraph prohibits a Contracting State from granting less favourable treatment to an enterprise whose capital is wholly or partly, directly or indirectly owned or controlled by one or more residents of the other Contracting State. This provision stopped discrimination regarding taxation of only enterprises, and not persons who own or control their capital. Therefore, its purpose is to ensure equal treatment for taxpayers residing in the same State and not to subject foreign capital held by partners or shareholders to the same treatment that applies to domestic capital.
77 . Since this paragraph concerns only the taxation of resident enterprises, and not persons who own or control their capital, it follows that it cannot be interpreted as extending the benefits of rules that take into account the relationship between a resident enterprise and other resident enterprises (for example, rules allowing for consolidation, loss transfer, or tax-free transfer property between companies that are jointly owned). For example, if the domestic tax legislation of one State allows a resident company to consolidate its income with that of the resident parent company, then paragraph 5 cannot force the State to allow such consolidation between the resident company and the non-resident parent company. This will require comparing the combined treatment of a resident enterprise and a non-resident holding its capital with the treatment of a resident enterprise of the same State and a resident holding its capital, which clearly goes beyond the taxation of a resident enterprise only.
78 . In addition, since paragraph 5 is aimed at ensuring equal treatment for all resident companies, regardless of who owns or controls their capital, and is not aimed at ensuring equal treatment for the distribution of funds between residents and non-residents (see paragraph 76 above), it follows that the tax withholding obligations imposed on a resident company in respect of dividends paid to non-resident shareholders, but not in respect of dividends paid to resident shareholders, may not be considered a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, the different treatment does not depend on the fact that the company's capital is owned or controlled by non-residents, but rather on the fact that dividends paid to non-residents are taxed differently. A similar example would be a State that taxes resident companies that distribute funds to their shareholders, regardless of whether they are residents or non-residents, but which, in order to avoid repeated application of this tax, will not apply it to distributions made to related resident companies that are themselves taxed on their own distributions. The fact that the latter exception does not apply to distributions between non-resident companies should not be considered a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, we are not talking about the fact that the capital of a resident company belongs to or is controlled by non-residents, but that it is distributed among companies that, in accordance with the provisions of the agreement, cannot be subject to the same tax when redistributing dividends received from this resident company. In this example, all resident companies are treated equally regardless of who owns or controls their capital, and the different treatment is limited to cases where distributions are made in circumstances where the distribution tax could have been avoided.
79 . Since this clause prevents discrimination against a resident enterprise based solely on who owns or controls the capital of that enterprise, prima facie is irrelevant to the rules providing for Different treatment for an enterprise depending on whether it pays interest to resident or non-resident creditors. This paragraph does not apply to rules based on the relationship between the debtor and the creditor, as long as the regime resulting from these rules is not based on whether non-residents own the capital of the enterprise in whole or in part, directly or indirectly, or control it. For example, if, according to the internal thin capitalization rules of a State, a resident enterprise is not allowed to deduct interest paid to a non-resident associate, then this rule does not violate paragraph 5 even in cases where it applies to interest payments to a creditor who owns or controls the capital of the enterprise, provided that the regime is the same. if the interest was paid to a non-resident associate that does not itself own or control any of the payer's capital. However, it is clear that such a rule of domestic law may violate paragraph 4 to the extent that different conditions apply for the deduction of interest paid to residents and non-residents, and therefore, for the purposes of this paragraph, it is important to determine whether the application of this rule is compatible with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11 (see paragraph 74 above). This is also important for the purposes of paragraph 5 in the case of thin capitalization rules, which will apply only to enterprises of a Contracting State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by non-residents. Indeed, since the provisions of Article 9, paragraph 1, or Article 11, paragraph 6, are part of the context in which paragraph 5 is to be interpreted (as required by Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties), amendments compatible with these provisions cannot be considered as violating the provisions of paragraph 5.
80 . In the case of transfer pricing requests, almost all Member States consider that additional information requirements that would be more stringent than the usual requirements, or even the removal of the burden of proof, would not constitute discrimination within the meaning of this article.
Item 6
81 . This paragraph states that the scope of application of this article is not limited by the provisions of Article 2. Thus, this article applies to taxes of any kind and type levied by or on behalf of the State, its political subdivisions or local authorities.
82. [Deleted]
A comment about the comment
83.The United States notes that its non-resident citizens are not in the same circumstances as other non-residents because the United States taxes its non-resident citizens on their global income.
84. [Deleted]
Reservations about this Article
85 . Canada and New Zealand leave their positions on this article unchanged.
86 . Australia reserves the right to propose amendments to ensure that Australia can continue to apply certain provisions of its domestic legislation regarding income tax collection.
87 . The United States reserves the right to apply its own domestic industry tax.
Point 1
88 . France would like to reserve the possibility of applying the provisions of paragraph 1 only to individuals, taking into account French case law and the fact that paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 already provide companies with broad protection against discrimination.
89 . Chile and the United Kingdom leave the position on the second sentence of paragraph 1 unchanged.
Item 2
90. Chile, Estonia, Japan, Switzerland and the United States of America reserve the right not to include paragraph 2 in their Conventions.
Point 3
90.1 In view of its special taxation system, Chile retains freedom of action with respect to the provisions of the Convention concerning the amount and form of distribution of profits by permanent missions.
Item 4
91. France accepts the provisions of paragraph 4, but would like to reserve the possibility of applying the provisions of its domestic legislation with respect to limiting the deduction of interest paid by a French company to an associated or related company.
Item 6
92. Chile, Greece and the United Kingdom reserve the right to limit the application of this article to taxes covered by the Convention.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 25 ON THE MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
I. Preliminary remarks
1. This article establishes a procedure for mutual agreement to resolve difficulties arising from the application of the Convention in the broadest sense of the word.
2. Firstly, in paragraphs 1 and 2 it provides that the competent authorities shall seek by mutual agreement to regulate the situation of taxpayers who are subject to taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention.
3. In paragraph 3, he also proposes and authorizes the competent authorities of the two States to resolve by mutual agreement problems related to the interpretation or application of the Convention and, in addition, to hold joint consultations to eliminate double taxation in cases not provided for by the Convention.
4. As for the practical application of the mutual agreement procedure, the article in paragraph 4 only authorizes the competent authorities to communicate with each other directly, without using diplomatic channels, and, if it seems appropriate to them, to conduct an oral exchange of views through a joint commission specially appointed for this purpose. Article 26 applies to the exchange of information for the purposes of the provisions of this article. This ensures the confidentiality of information exchanged for the purposes of the mutual agreement procedure.
5. Finally, paragraph 5 provides for a mechanism allowing a taxpayer to apply to arbitration on unresolved issues that have prevented the competent authorities from reaching mutual agreement within two years. Although the mutual agreement procedure provides a generally effective and efficient method for resolving disputes arising under the Convention, there may be cases where the competent authorities cannot agree that taxation by both States is consistent with the Convention. The arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 allows such cases to be resolved by independently resolving unresolved issues, which allows for mutual agreement. This process is an integral part of the mutual agreement procedure and does not represent an alternative way to resolve disputes concerning the application of the Convention.
5.1 The obligation to resolve, by mutual agreement, cases of taxation that do not comply with the Convention is an integral part of the obligations assumed by a Contracting State when concluding a tax treaty and must be fulfilled in good faith. In particular, the requirement in paragraph 2 that the competent authority "seek" to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State means that the competent authorities are obliged to seek to resolve the case in a fair and objective manner on the merits in accordance with the provisions of the Convention and applicable principles of international law concerning the interpretation of treaties.
6. Since this article sets out only general rules concerning the mutual agreement procedure, the following comments are intended to clarify the purpose of such rules, as well as expand them, if necessary, by referring, in particular, to the rules and practices applied at the international level when conducting mutual agreement procedures or at the domestic level when conducting procedures existing in most OECD member countries to address controversial tax requirements. In particular, since paragraph 5 explicitly requires the competent authorities to agree on the procedure for the application of the arbitration process, which it provides, the following comments discuss in detail the various procedural aspects of this process. The annex to this commentary contains an approximate form of agreement that the competent authorities can use as a basis for regulating the application of the arbitration process.; This annex addresses various structural and procedural issues, discusses various provisions of the model agreement, and in some cases suggests alternatives.
6.1 In accordance with Article 25, the Contracting States have delegated broad powers to the competent authorities with regard to the application and interpretation of the provisions of the Convention. Paragraph 2 authorizes the competent authorities to resolve, by mutual agreement, cases submitted by taxpayers for the purpose of tax evasion, which otherwise might arise from domestic legislation but would not comply with the Convention. Paragraph 3 similarly authorizes the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts concerning the interpretation or application of the Convention, both in individual cases (for example, in relation to a single taxpayer) and more generally (for example, by jointly interpreting a treaty provision applicable to a large number of taxpayers). In accordance with paragraph 3, the competent authorities may, in particular, conclude a mutual agreement on the definition of a term not defined in the Convention, or on supplementing or clarifying the definition of a certain term, if such an agreement would eliminate difficulties or doubts arising in connection with the interpretation or application of the Convention. Such circumstances may arise, for example, in cases where a conflict of values in accordance with the domestic legislation of the two States creates difficulties or leads to an unintended or absurd result. As explicitly recognized in paragraph 2 of Article 3, an agreement reached in accordance with paragraph 3 with respect to the meaning of a term used in the Convention takes precedence over the domestic law of each State with respect to the meaning of that term.
6.2 More generally, although the status under domestic law of the mutual agreement reached under Article 25 may vary between States, it is clear that the principles of international law regarding the interpretation of treaties, as set out in Articles 31 and 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, allow national courts to take such an agreement into account. The purpose of Article 25 is to promote, through consultation and mutual agreement between the competent authorities, the consistent consideration of individual cases and the same interpretation and/or application of the provisions of the Convention in both States. Article 25 also authorizes the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts regarding the interpretation or application of the Convention.; Such mutual agreement, reached in accordance with the direct mandate contained in paragraph 3 of this article, constitutes objective evidence of mutual understanding between the competent authorities of the meaning of the Convention and its terms. For these reasons, the agreement reached by the competent authorities in accordance with Article 25 must be taken into account for the purposes of interpreting the Convention.
6.3 In addition, in some cases, the application of certain contractual provisions is directly delegated by the Contracting States to the competent authorities, and agreements reached by the competent authorities in these matters legally regulate the application of these provisions. Subparagraph (d) of paragraph 2 of Article 4, for example, provides that the competent authorities shall resolve by mutual agreement certain cases where an individual is a resident of both Contracting States in accordance with paragraph 1 of this article. Some treaties similarly delegate to competent authorities the authority to jointly determine the status of various entities or arrangements for the purposes of certain contractual provisions (see, for example, subsection (i) of subparagraph (b) of the proposed provision in paragraph 35 of the commentary to Article 1) or the authority to supplement or amend the lists of entities, arrangements or provisions of domestic law mentioned in these treaties.
II. Commentary on the provisions of this Article
Paragraphs 1 and 2
7. The rules set out in paragraphs 1 and 2 provide for an exception in a specific case of taxation that does not comply with the Convention. As you know, in such cases, taxpayers can usually apply to the Tax Court either immediately or after their objections are rejected by the tax authorities. When taxation that does not comply with the Convention arises from the improper application of the Convention in both States, taxpayers are then required to sue in each State with all the disadvantages and uncertainties that such a situation entails. Thus, paragraph 1 provides the affected taxpayers, without depriving them of the usual remedies, with a procedure called the mutual agreement procedure, since it aims at its second stage to resolve the dispute on an agreed basis, that is, by agreement between the competent authorities, and the first stage is conducted exclusively in one of the Contracting States from the moment of submission. objections before a decision is taken by the competent authority on the matter.
8. In any case, the mutual agreement procedure is certainly a special procedure that goes beyond the scope of domestic legislation. It follows from this that it can be put into effect only in cases falling within the scope of paragraph 1, that is, in cases where the tax has been assessed or levied in violation of the provisions of the Convention. Thus, if a tax was levied in violation of both the Convention and domestic law, then this case is subject to a mutual agreement procedure only to the extent that the Convention is affected, unless there is a link between the norms of the Convention and the norms of domestic law that were applied incorrectly.
9. In practice, this procedure applies to cases — by far the most numerous — when the measure in question leads to double taxation, which is the specific purpose of the Convention to avoid. Among the most common cases, the following should be mentioned:
—issues related to the assignment of profits to a permanent establishment in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 7;
— taxation in the payer's State, in the case of a special relationship between the payer and the beneficial owner, of an excessive portion of interest and royalties provided for in the provisions of Article 9, paragraph 6 of Article 11 or paragraph 4
of this Article 12;
— cases of application of legislation in relation to thin capitalization, when the debtor company's State considers interest as dividends, since such a regime is based on the provisions of the Convention, corresponding, for example, to Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11;
— cases where the lack of information about the taxpayer's actual situation has led to incorrect application of the Convention, especially with regard to determining the place of residence (paragraph 2 of Article 4), the presence of a permanent establishment (Article 5) or the temporary nature of the services provided by the employee (paragraph 2 of Article 15).
10. Article 25 also provides for a mechanism allowing competent authorities to consult with each other in order to resolve, in the context of transfer pricing issues, not only problems of legal double taxation, but also problems of economic double taxation, and especially problems arising from the inclusion of profits of associated enterprises in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 9.; Thus, the relevant adjustments to be made in accordance with paragraph 2 of the same article are subject to the mutual agreement procedure both in terms of assessing their validity and determining their size.
11. This is actually implied in the wording of paragraph 2 of Article 9 when the bilateral Convention in question contains a reservation of this kind. When a bilateral Convention does not contain rules similar to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 9 (as is usually the case in the case of Conventions signed before 1977), the very fact that the Contracting States have included in the Convention the text of Article 9, limited to paragraph 1, which usually only confirms generally similar rules existing in domestic legislation, indicates The intention was for the Convention to cover economic double taxation. As a result, most member States consider that the economic double taxation resulting from the adjustment of profits due to transfer pricing does not comply at least with the spirit of the Convention and is subject to the mutual agreement procedure established in accordance with Article 25.
12. Although the mutual agreement procedure plays a clear role in resolving issues arising from the types of adjustments referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 9, it follows that even in the absence of such a provision, States should strive to avoid double taxation, including by making appropriate adjustments in the cases provided for in paragraph 2. Although there may be some differences of opinion, States usually consider a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure based on economic double taxation, contrary to the provisions of Article 9, covering the issues of whether an appropriate adjustment should have been provided for, even in the absence of a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 9. However, States that do not share this point of view, in practice, find ways to eliminate economic double taxation in most cases with the participation of bona fide companies, using the provisions of their domestic legislation.
13. The mutual agreement procedure is also applied in the absence of any double taxation contrary to the Convention, if the disputed taxation directly contradicts any norm of the Convention. This is the case when one State taxes a certain type of income, in respect of which the Convention grants the exclusive right to tax another State, even if the latter is unable to exercise it due to gaps in its domestic legislation. Another category of cases concerns persons who, being nationals of one Contracting State but residents of another State, are subject in that other State to a tax regime that is discriminatory in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 24.
14. It should be noted that the mutual agreement procedure, unlike the procedure for challenging claims under domestic law, can be put into effect by a taxpayer without waiting for him to be charged or notified of taxation, which he considers "not in accordance with the Convention." In order to be able to put this procedure into effect, he must, and this is sufficient, establish that "the actions of one or both of the Contracting States" will lead to such taxation and that such taxation appears to be a risk that is not only possible, but also probable. Such actions mean all acts or decisions of a legislative or regulatory nature that have a general or individual application and have the direct and necessary effect of levying tax on the applicant contrary to the provisions of the Convention. So, for example, if a change in the tax legislation of a Contracting State leads to the fact that a person receiving a certain type of income is subject to taxation not in accordance with the Convention, then this person may introduce a mutual agreement procedure as soon as the law is amended and this person receives the appropriate income or it becomes probable that this the person will receive this income. Other examples include submitting a declaration to a self-assessment system or actively examining a taxpayer's specific position in reporting during an audit to the extent that any event creates the possibility of taxation not in accordance with the Convention (for example, when a taxpayer's position in self-assessment reporting, which he must take in accordance with the domestic law of a Contracting State, if proposed by this State as an assessment, will lead to the likelihood of taxation not in accordance with the Convention or when such circumstances, as the published positions of a Contracting State or its audit practice create a significant likelihood that an active study of a particular position, for example, a taxpayer, will lead to proposed estimates that will lead to the likelihood of taxation not in accordance with the Convention). Another example would be the case where the transfer pricing law of a Contracting State requires a taxpayer to report taxable income in an amount greater than would be the result of the actual prices used by the taxpayer in his transactions with a related party, in order to comply with the arm's length principle and in cases where there is substantial doubt that that the related party of the taxpayer will be able to obtain an appropriate adjustment in the other Contracting State in the absence of a mutual agreement procedure. Such actions can also be understood as adjustments initiated by a bona fide taxpayer, which are permitted in accordance with the domestic legislation of some countries and which allow the taxpayer, under appropriate circumstances, to amend a previously filed tax return in order to reflect the price of a controlled transaction or to attribute profits to a permanent establishment, that is, in the taxpayer's opinion, in accordance with the arm's length principle. (see paragraph 6.1 of the commentary to Article 9 and paragraph 59.1 of the commentary to Article 7). As indicated in the introductory words of paragraph 1, the question of whether the actions of one or both Contracting States will lead to taxation that does not comply with the Convention must be decided from the taxpayer's point of view. Although a taxpayer's belief that such taxation has taken place must be justified and based on facts that can be established, the tax authorities should not refuse to consider a request in accordance with paragraph 1 just because they believe that it has not been proven (for example, in accordance with the provisions of domestic legislation on evidence "balance of probabilities"), that such taxation takes place.
15 . Since the first steps in the mutual agreement procedure can be taken at a very early stage based on the simple probability of taxation not complying with the Convention, the initiation of the procedure in this way is not considered to be the start date for the purposes of determining the beginning of the two-year period referred to in paragraph 5 of this article. Paragraph 75 below explains when the specified two-year period begins.
16 . To be acceptable, objections submitted in accordance with paragraph 1 must first satisfy the two requirements explicitly stated in this paragraph: they must be submitted to the competent authority of any Contracting State, and they must be submitted in this way within three years after the first notification of an action that entails taxation that does not comply with Conventions. The Convention does not establish any special rules regarding the form of objections. The competent authorities may prescribe special procedures that they consider appropriate. Unless a special procedure is established, objections may be submitted in the same way as tax objections are submitted to the tax authorities of the relevant State.
17. The opportunity provided to the taxpayer to present his case to the competent authority of any Contracting State is intended to strengthen the general principle that access to the mutual agreement procedure should be as wide as possible and provide flexibility. This option is also intended to ensure that the decision on whether to proceed to the second stage of the mutual agreement procedure (i.e. to be discussed by the competent authorities of both Contracting States) is open for consideration by both competent authorities. Paragraph 1 allows a person to present his case to the competent authority of any Contracting State; it does not prevent a person from presenting his case to the competent authorities of both Contracting States at the same time (see paragraph 75 below). If a person submits his case to the competent authorities of both Contracting States, he must inform both competent authorities accordingly in order to facilitate a coordinated approach to the case.
18 . On the other hand, the Contracting States may consider that taxpayers should not be able to present their cases to the competent authority of any of the States, but should first of all be required to present their cases to the competent authority of the State of which they are a resident. However, in cases where a person who is a national of one State but a resident of another complains that he has been subjected to taxation (or any related requirement) in that other State that is discriminatory in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 24, it seems more appropriate, for obvious reasons, to allow him as an exception. from an alternative rule obliging a taxpayer to submit his case to the competent authority of his State of residence, to submit an objection to the competent authority of the Contracting State, of which he is a citizen. Similarly, it would be more appropriate for an objection to be submitted to the same competent authority by a person who, while not a resident of a Contracting State, is a national of a Contracting State and whose case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24. In order to take into account the alternative rule and exception for cases falling within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24, paragraph 1 should be changed as follows:
1. If a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result in or will result in taxation for him not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, he may, regardless of the remedies provided for by the domestic law of those States, submit his case to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a resident, or, if his case falls under subject to paragraph 1 of Article 24, to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a national. The case must be submitted within three years from the date of the first notification of an action that resulted in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention.
Contracting States that prefer this alternative rule should take appropriate measures to ensure wide access to the mutual agreement procedure and proper consideration by both competent authorities of the decision on whether to proceed to the second stage of the mutual agreement procedure.
19 . If a taxpayer becomes a resident of a State after taxation which he considers to be inconsistent with the Convention, he must nevertheless submit an objection, in accordance with the alternative rule contained in paragraph 18 above, to the competent authority of the other State of which he was a resident during the period in respect of which such taxation was or is being levied.
20 . The three-year deadline for submitting objections set out in the second sentence of paragraph 1 is intended to protect Administrations from late objections. This period should be considered as the minimum so that the Contracting States can freely agree in their bilateral Conventions on a longer period in the interests of taxpayers, for example, by analogy, in particular, with the time limits established by their respective domestic regulations on tax conventions. The Contracting States may delete the second sentence of paragraph 1 if they agree that their respective domestic rules automatically apply to such objections and are more favourable in their consequences for the taxpayers concerned, either because they allow a longer period for submitting objections, or because they do not set any time limits for such objections. goals.
21 . The provision setting as the starting point of the three-year period the date of the "first notification of actions leading to taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention" should be interpreted in the most favorable way for the taxpayer. Thus, even if such taxation should be levied directly in accordance with an administrative decision or an act of general application, the period begins to apply only from the date of notification of the individual action giving rise to such taxation, that is, in the most favorable interpretation, from the act of taxation itself, as evidenced by the assessment notification or official requirement or other document on collection or collection of taxes. Since a taxpayer has the right to file a claim as soon as he considers that taxation will lead to taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, and the three-year period begins only when this result has materialized, there will be cases when the taxpayer has the right to initiate a mutual agreement procedure before the beginning of the three-year period (see examples of such a situation given in paragraph 14 above).
22 . In most cases, it is clear what constitutes an appropriate assessment notice, official requirement, or other instrument for collecting or collecting taxes, and there will usually be rules of domestic law governing when this notice is considered "given." Such domestic legislation usually takes into account the time when the notification was sent (the time of dispatch), the specific number of days after it was sent, the time when it is expected to arrive at the address to which it was sent (both of which are the time of the intended physical receipt), or the time when it is actually physically received (the time of the actual physical receiving). In the absence of such rules, either the moment of actual physical receipt, or, if this is not sufficiently proven, the moment when the notification is usually expected to arrive at the appropriate address, should usually be considered as the moment of notification, bearing in mind that this provision should be interpreted in the most favorable way for the taxpayer.
23 . In cases of self-assessment, there is usually some kind of notification that affects this assessment (for example, a notification of liability or a waiver or adjustment of a claim for compensation), and, as a rule, the time of notification, rather than the time when the taxpayer submits the self-assessment declaration, is the starting point for the three-year period. If a taxpayer pays additional tax in connection with the filing of an amended declaration reflecting a good-faith adjustment initiated by the taxpayer (as described in paragraph 14 above), the starting point of the three-year period is usually notification of the assessment or obligation arising from the amended declaration, rather than the time of payment of the additional tax. However, there may be cases where there is no notification of liability or the like. In such cases, the relevant moment of "notification" is considered to be the one when the taxpayer is aware of taxation that actually does not comply with the Convention. Such a situation may arise, for example, when information about the transfer of funds is provided to the taxpayer for the first time, for example, in a bank balance sheet or statement. Time is running out regardless of whether the taxpayer actually considers taxation at this stage to be contrary to the Convention, provided that a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position would be able to conclude at this stage that taxation does not comply with the Convention. In such cases, it is sufficient to notify the taxpayer of the fact of taxation. However, in cases where only a combination of self-assessment with some other circumstance could have led a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position to conclude that taxation was contrary to the Convention (for example, a court decision determining the imposition of tax in a case similar to that of a taxpayer contrary to the provisions of the Convention), time begins to flow only when the latter circumstance materializes.
24. If the tax is collected by deduction from the source, the period is calculated from the date of payment of income, however, if the taxpayer proves that only later he learned that the deduction was made, the period is calculated from that date. In cases where the totality of decisions or actions taken in both Contracting States results in taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention, the time limit begins to apply only from the moment of the first notification of the most recent decision or action. This means that if, for example, a Contracting State levies a tax that does not comply with the Convention, but the other State provides a tax relief in accordance with Article 23A or Article 23B in order to avoid double taxation, the taxpayer in practice often does not initiate a mutual agreement procedure with respect to the actions of the first State. However, if the other State subsequently notifies the taxpayer of the refusal of tax exemption, which leads to double taxation, a new period begins with this notification, since joint actions of both States result in the taxpayer being subjected to double taxation in violation of the provisions of the Convention. In some cases, especially of this kind, in accordance with the usual practice of one or both States, records kept by the tax authorities can usually be destroyed before the deadline. The obligations under the Convention do not prevent such destruction and do not require the competent authority to accept the taxpayer's arguments without evidence, but in such cases the taxpayer should be given the opportunity to make up for the lack of evidence, since the mutual agreement procedure continues, to the extent permitted by domestic law. In some cases, the other Contracting State may provide sufficient evidence in accordance with Article 26 of the Model Tax Convention. It is preferable that such records are kept by the tax authorities for the entire period during which a taxpayer can request the initiation of a mutual agreement procedure on a specific issue.
25 . This three-year period continues during any domestic legal (including administrative) proceedings (for example, domestic appeals proceedings). Such a situation may create difficulties, effectively requiring the taxpayer to choose between domestic legislation and procedures for mutual coordination of legal remedies. Some taxpayers may rely solely on the mutual agreement procedure, but many taxpayers will try to overcome these difficulties by initiating the mutual agreement procedure and at the same time initiating the operation of domestic legislation, even if the domestic legislation process is not actively conducted initially. This may lead to inefficient use of the resources of the mutual agreement procedure. Where domestic law allows, some States may wish to specifically address this issue by allowing a three-year (or longer) suspension period during domestic law proceedings. Two approaches, each of which is consistent with Article 25, consist, on the one hand, in requiring the taxpayer to initiate a mutual agreement procedure without suspension during internal proceedings, but so that the competent authorities do not enter into negotiations until the final determination of the effect of domestic legislation, or, on the other hand, that for the competent authorities to enter into negotiations, but without a final settlement of the agreement, unless the taxpayer agrees to revoke the domestic legislation. The second possibility is discussed in paragraph
42 of this commentary. In any of these cases, the taxpayer should be aware that an appropriate approach is being applied. Regardless of whether a taxpayer considers that there is a need to file a "protective" appeal in accordance with domestic law (due, for example, to internal restrictive requirements for bringing lawsuits under domestic law), the preferred approach for all parties is often that the mutual agreement procedure should be the initial focus for resolving issues. the taxpayer and for this on a bilateral basis.
26 . Some States may refuse a taxpayer the opportunity to initiate a mutual agreement procedure in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 in cases where the transactions to which the request relates are considered unlawful. This issue is closely related to the issue of "improper use of the Convention" discussed in paragraph 54 and subsequent paragraphs of the commentary to Article 1. However, in the absence of a special provision, there is no general rule prohibiting perceived offensive situations from proceeding to a mutual agreement procedure. The simple fact that the tax is collected in accordance with the provision of domestic legislation on tax evasion should not serve as a basis for denying access to a mutual agreement. However, in cases where serious violations of domestic law are involved, resulting in significant fines, some States may wish to deny access to the mutual agreement procedure. The circumstances in which a State denies access to a mutual agreement procedure should be set out in the Convention.
27. Some States consider that certain issues cannot be resolved within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure as a whole, or at least within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure initiated by taxpayers, due to the provisions or decisions of Constitutional or other domestic legislation. An example is a case where the provision of benefits to a taxpayer contradicts the final court decision, which the tax authority is required to comply with in accordance with the Constitution of that State. A generally accepted general principle for tax and other contracts is that domestic law, even domestic constitutional law, does not justify non-fulfillment of contractual obligations. Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties reflects the general principle of treaty law. It follows that any justification for what would otherwise be a violation of the Convention must be found in terms of the Convention itself, as interpreted in accordance with accepted principles of interpretation of tax treaties. Such an excuse would be rare, since it would not only determine how the issue would be dealt with by both States once it was within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure, but would also prevent even reaching the stage when it would be considered by both States. Since in practice such a decision can be made by one of the States without consulting the other, and since there may be a bilateral decision, which therefore remains unresolved, the view that the issue is not subject to a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure should be supported by the terms of the Convention in the form in which they were agreed. The competent authority, relying on the obstacle of domestic legislation as a reason for refusing to initiate a mutual agreement procedure for a taxpayer, should inform the other competent authority about this and properly explain the legal basis of its position. As a rule, genuine obstacles to domestic legislation do not prevent the issue from entering into a mutual agreement procedure, but if they clearly and unambiguously prevent the competent authority from resolving the issue in such a way as to avoid taxation of the taxpayer, which does not comply with the Convention, and there is no real chance that another state will resolve the issue for the taxpayer, then such a The situation should be made public to taxpayers so that taxpayers do not have false expectations about the likely results of this procedure.
28. In other cases, it would be possible to allow the initiation of a mutual agreement procedure, but issues of internal law that arose after the conclusion of the contract may prevent the competent authority from resolving, even partially, the issue raised by the taxpayer. In cases where such events have a legally constraining effect on the competent authority, so that bilateral discussions clearly cannot resolve the issue, most States will agree that such a change in circumstances is significant enough to allow that competent authority to withdraw from the procedure. However, in some cases, the difficulties may only be temporary; for example, while the amendment legislation is being adopted, in which case the procedure should be suspended rather than terminated. The two competent authorities need to discuss this difficulty and its possible impact on the mutual approval procedure. There will also be situations where a decision in full or in part in favor of the taxpayer is mandatory and must be made by one of the competent authorities, but when there is still an opportunity for discussion by mutual agreement, for example, when one competent authority demonstrates to another that the latter should provide assistance.
29. There is less reason to rely on domestic legislation in case of non-fulfillment of an agreement reached under the mutual agreement procedure. The obligation to implement such agreements is explicitly stated in the last sentence of paragraph 2, and obstacles to implementation that already exist should generally be included in the terms of the agreement itself. Since negotiations on tax Conventions are conducted against the background of a changing body of domestic legislation, which is sometimes difficult to predict, and since both sides are aware of this when discussing the original Convention and reaching mutual agreement, subsequent unexpected changes that change the fundamental basis of the mutual agreement will usually be considered as requiring revision of the agreement to the extent that it It is necessary. Obviously, where there is a development of this type of domestic law, which should only rarely occur, obligations of good faith require that it be notified as soon as possible, and good-faith efforts should be made to seek a revised or new mutual agreement to the extent that domestic law allows. In these cases, the taxpayer's claim should be considered as still valid, and not as a requirement for a new application from this person.
30. As for the procedure itself, it is necessary to briefly consider the two separate stages into which it is divided (see paragraph 7 above).
31. At the first stage, which begins with the submission of the taxpayer's objections, the procedure takes place exclusively at the level of transactions between the taxpayer and the competent authorities of the State to which the case was submitted. The provisions of paragraph 1 grant the taxpayer concerned the right to apply to the competent authority of any State, regardless of whether all legal remedies available under the domestic legislation of each of the two States have been exhausted. On the other hand, the competent authority is obliged to consider whether the objection is justified and, if it appears to be justified, to take a decision on it in one of the two forms provided for in paragraph 2.
31.1 Determination of "whether an objection is submitted...justified", requires the competent authority to which the case was submitted to make a preliminary assessment of the taxpayer's objection in order to determine whether taxation in both Contracting States complies with the provisions of the Convention. It is appropriate to consider that the objection is justified in cases where taxation that does not comply with the Convention exists or will exist in any of the Contracting States.
32. If the competent authority, which has been duly contacted, recognizes that the complaint is justified and considers that the tax against which the complaint is filed is fully or partially due to measures taken in that State, it should settle the complaint as soon as possible by making such adjustments or allowing such benefits as appear justified. In this situation, the issue can be resolved without going beyond the first (unilateral) stage of the mutual agreement procedure. On the other hand, it may be useful to exchange views and information with the competent authority of another Contracting State in order, for example, to confirm this interpretation of the Convention.
33. However, if it appears to this competent authority that the taxation complained of is fully or partially due to a measure taken in another State, it is obliged, moreover, it is obliged, as can be seen from the provisions of paragraph 2, to initiate the second (bilateral) stage of the mutual agreement procedure. It is important that the relevant competent authority fulfills this duty as quickly as possible, especially in cases where the profits of associated enterprises have been adjusted as a result of transfer pricing adjustments.
34. A taxpayer has the right to submit his case in accordance with paragraph 1 to the competent authority of any State, regardless of whether he could also file a claim or initiate legal proceedings in accordance with the domestic legislation of one (or both) States. If a lawsuit is pending in the State to which the claim is made, the competent authority of that State should not wait for the final court decision, but should inform whether it considers the case acceptable for the mutual agreement procedure. If he makes such a decision, he must determine whether he can come to a satisfactory solution on his own or whether the case should be referred to the competent authority of another Contracting State. A taxpayer's application for the introduction of a mutual agreement procedure cannot be rejected without valid reasons.
35. If the claim has been definitively reviewed by a court in any State, the taxpayer may even wish to submit or pursue the claim in accordance with the mutual agreement procedure. In some States, the competent authority may arrive at a satisfactory solution that departs from the court's decision. In other States, the competent authority is bound by a court decision (that is, it is legally obliged to follow the court decision) or does not deviate from the court decision due to administrative policy or practice. Nevertheless, he may submit the case to the competent authority of the other Contracting State and request it to take measures to avoid double taxation.
36. At the second stage, which begins with an appeal from the competent authority of another State to the competent authority to which the taxpayer has applied, the procedure is now carried out at the level of relations between states, as if, so to speak, the State to which the complaint was filed supported it. Despite the fact that this is an interstate procedure, on the other hand, the following questions can be asked:
— is this, as the title of the article and the terms used in the first sentence of paragraph 2 suggest, nothing more than a simple mutual agreement procedure, or is it an exercise of pactum de contrahendo, which imposes on the parties a simple obligation to negotiate, but in no way imposes on them the obligation to reach an agreement;
— or, on the contrary, it should be considered (based on the arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 to resolve unresolved issues, or based on the assumption that the procedure is carried out within the framework of a joint commission) as a procedure of a jurisdictional nature, which imposes on the parties the obligation to resolve the dispute.
37. Paragraph 2 undoubtedly entails the obligation to negotiate; but with regard to reaching mutual agreement through procedure, the competent authorities are simply obliged to make every effort, not to achieve a result. However, paragraph 5 provides for a mechanism that will allow an agreement to be reached, even if there are issues on which the competent authorities have not been able to reach an agreement through negotiations.
38 . In seeking mutual agreement, the competent authorities must, of course, first of all determine their position in the light of the norms of their respective tax legislation and the provisions of the Convention, which are binding on them as much as on the taxpayer. If the strict application of such rules or regulations precludes the possibility of concluding any agreement, it can reasonably be assumed that the competent authorities, as in the case of international arbitration, may, by way of subsidiary liability, take into account considerations of fairness to ensure the satisfaction of the taxpayer.
38.1 A combination of bilateral tax conventions concluded between several States may allow the competent authorities of these States to resolve multilateral cases by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of these Conventions. A multilateral mutual agreement can be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned, or by concluding separate but consecutive bilateral mutual agreements.
38.2 This may be the case, for example, to determine the appropriate distribution of profits between permanent representative offices that an enterprise has in two different States with which the State of the enterprise has tax agreements. In this case, the adjustment made in relation to transactions between the two permanent missions may affect the taxation of the enterprise in the host State. On the basis of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of the tax Conventions between the State of the enterprise and the States in which the permanent missions are located, the competent authority of the State of the enterprise undoubtedly has the authority to seek to settle the case by mutual agreement with the competent authorities of the States in which the permanent missions are located and to determine the appropriate distribution of profits to the permanent missions of its resident in accordance with both tax conventions. If tax agreements between the State of the enterprise and the States in which permanent missions are located contain different versions of Article 7 (for example, the version included in the OECD Convention in 2010 in one Convention and the previous version of Article 7 in another Convention), the competent authorities may take into account the equity considerations mentioned in paragraph 38 above, with in order to find an appropriate solution to ensure taxation in accordance with the provisions of the applicable Conventions.
38.3 The situation occurs when a number of associated enterprises of different States are involved in a number of integrated controlled transactions and there are bilateral tax agreements between the States of all enterprises. Such a series of integrated controlled transactions may exist, for example, when intellectual property is licensed as part of a controlled transaction between two members of a multinational enterprise group (MNP) and then used by the licensee to produce goods sold by the licensee to other members of the MNP group. Based on paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of these tax Conventions, the competent authorities of the States in which these enterprises are located certainly have the authority to seek to determine appropriate transfer prices for controlled transactions at arm's length in accordance with the arm's length principle of Article 9.
38.4 As recognized in paragraph 55 below, in the multilateral case described in paragraph 38.2, paragraph 3 of Article 25 of the Tax Convention between the States in which permanent missions are located allows these two States to hold joint consultations to ensure the effective operation of the Convention and the proper elimination of double taxation that may occur in such a situation.
38.5 The desire for certainty may lead taxpayers to seek multilateral pre-pricing agreements (APAs) to determine in advance the transfer pricing of controlled transactions between associated enterprises of several States. In cases where there are bilateral tax conventions between all these States and it appears that the actions of at least one of these States may lead a taxpayer to be taxed outside of the provisions of the Convention, Article 25 of these Conventions allows the competent authorities of these States to negotiate on a multilateral basis on an appropriate set of criteria for determining transfer pricing for controlled transactions. A multilateral mutual agreement can be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned, or by concluding separate but consecutive bilateral mutual agreements.
39 . The purpose of the last sentence of paragraph 2 is to enable countries with time constraints in their domestic legislation regarding adjustments to assessed contributions and tax refunds to implement the agreement despite such time constraints. However, this provision does not prevent those States that, for constitutional or other legal reasons, cannot cancel the time limits established in domestic legislation, from including in the mutual agreement itself such time limits that are adapted to their internal statute of limitations (see See also paragraph 62 of the commentary to Article 7 and paragraph 10 of the commentary to Article 9, which offer an alternative approach addressing this issue in the Convention). In some extreme cases, a Contracting State may choose not to enter into a mutual agreement, the implementation of which would require disregard for the internal limitation period (subject to the possible application of paragraph 5, when such a procedure would prevent the resolution of the case by mutual agreement). In addition to time constraints, there may be other obstacles, such as "final judgments" for the agreement to enter into force. The Contracting States may freely agree on firm provisions concerning the removal of such obstacles. With regard to the practical implementation of this procedure, it is generally recommended that the tax authorities make every effort to ensure that, as far as possible, the mutual agreement procedure is in no case disrupted by operational delays or, in the case of time constraints, the combined effects of time constraints and operational delays.
40 . The Financial Affairs Committee made a number of recommendations on the problems arising from the corresponding profit adjustments after the transfer pricing adjustment (implementation of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 9), as well as on the difficulties of applying the mutual agreement procedure in such situations.:
a) The tax authorities should notify taxpayers as soon as possible of their intention to make a transfer pricing adjustment (and, if the date of any such notification may be important, provide clear official notification as soon as possible), as it is especially useful to ensure that all relevant issues are handled as early and fully as possible between the tax authorities and taxpayers within the of the same jurisdiction and across national borders between the associated enterprises and the relevant tax authorities.
(b) Competent authorities should interact with each other on these issues as flexibly as possible, whether in writing, by telephone, in person or at a round table, whichever is most appropriate, and should strive to develop the most effective ways to address the relevant issues. The use of the provisions of Article 26 on the exchange of information should be encouraged to assist a public authority in obtaining high-quality factual information on the basis of which a decision can be made.
c) During the proceedings under a mutual agreement on transfer pricing, interested taxpayers should be provided with all reasonable opportunities to present relevant facts and arguments to the competent authorities, both in writing and orally.
41 . With regard to the mutual agreement procedure in general, the committee makes the following recommendations:
(a) The formalities related to the establishment and implementation of a mutual agreement procedure should be minimized and any unnecessary formalities eliminated.
b) Each case should be decided by mutual agreement on its individual merits, and not by referring to any balance of outcomes in other cases.
(c) Competent authorities should, where appropriate, formulate and publish internal rules, guidelines and procedures regarding the use of the mutual agreement procedure.
42 . A case may arise in the case of a mutual agreement with respect to a taxpayer who has filed a claim for the same purpose with the competent court of any Contracting State, and such a claim is still pending. In this case, there is no reason for the taxpayer to refuse to satisfy the request for a postponement of the decision agreed upon as a result of the mutual agreement procedure until the court makes a decision on this claim. In addition, the competent authorities may reasonably assume that in cases where a taxpayer's claim continues on a specific issue on which the same taxpayer seeks mutual agreement, any in-depth discussions at the level of the competent authorities should await a judicial decision. If the taxpayer's requirement for a mutual agreement procedure applies to different tax years than the lawsuit, but essentially to the same factual and legal issues, so that in practice it is expected that the court's decision will affect the treatment of the taxpayer in years that are not specifically the subject of legal proceedings, then in practice the position may be the same as in the cases just mentioned. In any case, the pending court decision or other suspension of the mutual agreement procedure will not violate or lead to the expiration of the two-year period specified in paragraph 5 of this Article. Of course, if the competent authorities consider that in any case the issue can be resolved independently of the domestic legal proceedings (since, for example, the competent authority against which the court decision is being made will not be legally bound or limited by the court decision), then the mutual agreement procedure can continue as usual. The competent authority may be legally deprived of the right to conduct taxation if the court has ruled that such taxation does not comply with the provisions of the tax treaty. On the contrary, in some countries, the competent authority would not be legally deprived of the right to grant tax exemption, despite the court's decision that such taxation complies with the provisions of the tax treaty. In such a case, nothing (for example, administrative policy or practice) should prevent the competent authorities from reaching a mutual agreement according to which the Contracting State exempts from taxation, considered by the competent authorities as inconsistent with the provisions of the tax treaty, and thus derogate from the decision rendered by the court of the State.
43. The situation is also different if a lawsuit is being conducted on an issue, but this claim was filed by another taxpayer, and not by the one who seeks to initiate a mutual agreement procedure. If the case of a taxpayer who seeks to resolve the issue by mutual agreement supports the actions of one or both competent authorities to prevent taxation that does not comply with the Convention, this should not be unreasonably postponed until a general clarification of the law follows the example of another taxpayer, although a taxpayer seeking mutual agreement may agree to this if the clarification is likely to favors the cause of this taxpayer. In other cases, delaying discussions by the competent authorities within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure may be justified in all circumstances, but the competent authorities should be aware of the time limits imposed by paragraph 5 and should, as far as possible, seek to prevent adverse consequences for the taxpayer seeking mutual agreement in such a case. This can be done, if domestic legislation allows it, by delaying the payment of the amount owed during the delay, or at least during the part of the delay that is beyond the taxpayer's control.
44 . Depending on domestic procedures, the choice of compensation usually belongs to the taxpayer, and in most cases it is the internal provisions on recourse, such as appeals or court proceedings, that are postponed in favor of the less formal and bilateral nature of the mutual agreement procedure.
45 . As noted above, a taxpayer may file a claim on any issue, or the taxpayer may reserve the right to take such action under domestic law, but the competent authorities may still consider that an agreement can be reached. In such cases, however, it is necessary to take into account the concerns of the specific competent authority in order to avoid any discrepancies or contradictions between the court's decision and the mutual agreement sought, with difficulties or risks of abuse that they may entail. In short, therefore, the implementation of such a mutual agreement, as a rule, should be the subject of:
— acceptance by the taxpayer of such a mutual agreement, as well as
— the taxpayer's refusal to file a claim on issues settled by mutual agreement of the parties.
45.1 In some States, audit calculations may be used as a mechanism to facilitate the closure of audit files. As follows from the phrase
As a "settlement", there are usually concessions made by both the taxpayer and the participating tax administration, which can create difficult issues when the audit includes issues related to the interpretation or application of the tax treaty, which can potentially be resolved through a mutual agreement procedure. One of the concessions of tax administrations is sometimes a restriction on the taxpayer's further application, which in some cases may include an agreement by the taxpayer not to initiate a mutual agreement procedure on issues covered by the audit settlement. Double taxation can often be the result of such arrangements that do not allow the competent authorities to reach a bilateral settlement through a mutual agreement procedure and may indeed lead to the other Contracting State waiving an exemption under its domestic law in respect of tax paid to the first Contracting State after completion of the audit. Thus, as part of the audit settlement, a taxpayer should not be required to waive the right provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25 to submit a case to the competent authority, as this may hinder the proper application of the tax treaty. However, for the purposes of this paragraph, "audit settlement" does not include the settlement of a contractual dispute resulting from an administrative or legislative dispute resolution/resolution process that is independent of the audit and examination functions and that can only be accessed at the request of the taxpayer. Countries should inform their contractual partners about such administrative or statutory processes and should explicitly address the implications of these processes for the map in their public guidance on such processes and in their public policy guidance on the map.
46 . Some States believe that a mutual agreement procedure cannot be initiated by a taxpayer until all or a certain part of the disputed tax amount has been paid. Such States consider that the requirement to pay outstanding taxes, which are due in whole or in part, depending on the outcome of the procedure, is essentially a procedural issue not regulated by Article 25 and is therefore consistent with it. The opposite point of view, which is held by many States, is that Article 25 specifies everything that a taxpayer must do before starting the procedure, and that it does not impose such a requirement. Such States find support for their point of view in the fact that the procedure can be carried out even before the taxpayer has been taxed or notified of the obligation (as noted in paragraph 14 above), and in recognizing that there is clearly no such requirement for a procedure initiated by a competent authority in accordance with paragraph 3.
47 . Article 25 does not provide an absolutely clear answer to the question of whether a taxpayer can be refused to initiate a mutual agreement procedure on the grounds that the necessary payment of all or part of the disputed tax has not been made. However, regardless of what opinion is adopted on this issue, in implementing this article, it should be recognized that the mutual agreement procedure supports the main provisions of the Convention and that, therefore, the text of Article 25 should be understood in the context and in the light of the object and objectives of the Convention, including the prevention of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion and tax evasion. taxes.
47.1 Unlike disputes that are exclusively related to the application of the domestic legislation of a Contracting State, disputes that are considered under the mutual agreement procedure are in most cases related to double taxation. Therefore, States should, as far as possible, take into account cash flow issues by requesting an advance payment of an amount that, according to the taxpayer, was at least partially recovered contrary to the provisions of the relevant Convention. Even if the mutual agreement procedure ultimately eliminates any double taxation or other taxation that does not comply with the Convention, the requirement to pay tax before concluding a mutual agreement procedure may permanently cost the taxpayer the time value of money represented by an amount improperly imposed during the period before the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, at least in a fairly common case., when the relevant interest rate policy of the respective Contracting States does not fully compensate the taxpayer for these costs. Thus, this means that in such cases, the mutual agreement procedure will not achieve the goal of completely eliminating the burden of double taxation or other taxation that does not comply with the Convention. Moreover, even if this economic burden is eventually lifted, the requirement that a taxpayer pay taxes on the same income to two Contracting States may impose a burden on cash flows that is incompatible with the objectives of the Convention to remove barriers to cross-border trade and investment. At a minimum, payment of the outstanding tax should not be a requirement for the commencement of the mutual agreement procedure, unless this is a requirement prior to the start of the revision of domestic legislation. States may wish to explicitly provide for this in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
The suspension of assessment and recovery procedures during the period during which any proceedings under a mutual agreement are pending is carried out under the same conditions that apply to a person using internal administrative or judicial remedies.
It also seems, at a minimum, that if the mutual agreement procedure is initiated before the taxpayer pays the tax (for example, as a result of an assessment), then payment should be required only after it is taxed.
48. For the reasons described in the preceding paragraph, suspending the collection of tax pending the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure may be a desirable policy. Moreover, any requirement to pay the tax assessment specifically as a condition for obtaining access to the mutual agreement procedure for the purpose of obtaining relief from that very tax would generally be incompatible with the policy of ensuring broad access to the mutual agreement procedure for the resolution of such disputes. Another unfortunate complication arising from such a requirement may be delays in resolving cases if a country is less willing to engage in good-faith discussions under the mutual agreement procedure when the likely outcome may be a refund of taxes already collected. In many States, suspending the assessment and/or collection of tax pending the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure may require legislative amendments in order to implement it. States may also wish to expressly provide for the suspension of assessment and collection procedures in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
The assessment and collection procedures shall be suspended during the period in which any mutual agreement proceedings are pending.
In connection with any suspension of tax collection pending the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, it is important to recall the existence of preservation measures under paragraph 4 of Article 27.
48.1 Since there may be significant differences in the procedures for assessment and collection under the domestic laws of the Contracting States, it may be important during bilateral negotiations to examine how these procedures will operate in each State pending the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, in order to eliminate any obstacles that such procedures may create to the effective implementation of this Article. For example, if a State considers that payment of the outstanding tax is a prerequisite for a taxpayer to initiate a mutual agreement procedure, this should be brought to the attention of its treaty partner during negotiations on the terms of the Convention. Where both Contracting States take this view, there is a common understanding, but there is also a particular risk that the taxpayer will be required to pay the amount twice. Where permitted under domestic law (or by a treaty provision similar to the one contained in the preceding paragraph), one possibility that States could consider in order to address this problem would be for the higher of the two amounts to be held in trust, in escrow or in a similar arrangement until the completion of the mutual agreement procedure. Alternatively, a bank guarantee provided by the taxpayer's bank may be sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the competent authorities. As another approach, one or the other State (determined, for example, by the timing of the assessments or by the status of the State of residence under the treaty) could agree to require payment of no more than the difference between the amount paid to the other State and the amount it claims, if any. Which of these possibilities is available ultimately depends on the domestic law (including administrative requirements) of the particular State and the provisions of the applicable treaty, but these are precisely the options that should, to the extent possible, be considered in seeking to ensure the most effective functioning of the mutual agreement procedure. Where States require some payment of outstanding tax as a prerequisite for a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure or for the active consideration of a matter under that procedure, they should have an effective system for paying interest on any principal amount that is to be refunded to the taxpayer as a result of a mutual agreement reached by the competent authorities. Any such payment of interest should adequately reflect the cost of the principal amount and the period of time during which that amount was unavailable to the taxpayer.
49. Paragraph 4 of the Commentary on Article 2 explains that, although most States do not consider interest and administrative penalties related to taxes covered by Article 2 to fall within the scope of Article 2 in their own right, where such interest and administrative penalties are directly related to taxes covered by Article 2, they should be appropriately reduced or cancelled to the same extent as the underlying covered tax is reduced or cancelled under the mutual agreement procedure. Accordingly, a Contracting State that has imposed interest or an administrative penalty calculated by reference to the underlying tax liability (or by reference to any other amount relevant to the determination of the tax, such as the amount of an adjustment or the amount of taxable income) and that subsequently agrees under the mutual agreement procedure pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 to reduce or cancel that underlying tax liability should proportionately reduce or cancel such interest or administrative penalty.
49.1 In contrast, other administrative penalties (for example, a penalty for failure to provide proper transfer pricing documentation) may concern matters of compliance with domestic law that are not directly related to the tax liability that is the subject of the request for a mutual agreement procedure. Such administrative penalties will generally not fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article. However, under paragraph 3 of Article 25, the competent authorities may consult together and agree in a particular case that a penalty not directly related to taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention was not, or is no longer, justified. For example, if an administrative penalty for negligence, wilful conduct or fraud was imposed in a fixed amount and it is subsequently agreed in a mutual agreement procedure that there was no fraudulent intent, wilful conduct or negligence, the competent authorities may agree that the Contracting State that imposed such penalty should withdraw it. Under paragraph 3 of this Article, the competent authorities may also conclude a general mutual agreement under which they will seek, through the mutual agreement procedure, to resolve in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 issues relating to interest and administrative penalties that give rise to difficulties or doubts concerning the application of the Convention. Contracting States may, if they consider it preferable, expressly provide in paragraph 2 of Article 25 for the application of this paragraph to interest and administrative penalties in cases of mutual agreement procedures presented under paragraph 1, by adding the following text to the second sentence:
The competent authorities shall also endeavour to agree on the application of the provisions of domestic law concerning interest and administrative penalties related to the case.
49.2 Criminal penalties imposed by a prosecutor or a court generally do not fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure. In many States, the competent authorities have no legal authority to reduce or cancel such penalties.
49.3 A mutual agreement often results in the tax liability being maintained in one Contracting State, while the other Contracting State is required to refund all or part of the tax it has collected. In such cases, the taxpayer may bear a significant economic burden if there are asymmetries in the way interest is charged on tax liabilities and refunds in the two Contracting States, for example, where the first Contracting State charges late-payment interest on the tax that was the subject of the request for a mutual agreement procedure, while the second Contracting State does not pay overpayment interest on the amount it is required to refund to the taxpayer. Contracting States should therefore seek to adopt flexible approaches to ensure relief from interest related to the tax liability that is the subject of a request for a mutual agreement procedure. Relief from interest would be particularly appropriate for the period during which the taxpayer is engaged in the mutual agreement procedure, given that the amount of time required to resolve a case through the mutual agreement procedure is, for the most part, beyond the taxpayer's control. Amendments to the domestic law of a Contracting State may be required to enable the competent authority to grant relief from interest as agreed under the mutual agreement procedure.
49.4 The purpose of the Convention is to avoid double taxation, and the requirement for States to perform their obligations under the Convention in good faith implies that interest and penalties should not be imposed in such a way as to effectively discourage taxpayers from initiating a mutual agreement procedure because of the associated costs and cash-flow consequences. Interest and administrative penalties should not be applied in a manner that seriously discourages or undermines taxpayers' confidence in the benefits of the Convention, including the right to initiate a mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25. For example, a State's requirements for the payment of outstanding penalties and interest should not be more burdensome for taxpayers in the context of a mutual agreement procedure than they would be in the context of a taxpayer-initiated domestic law review.
Paragraph 3
50. The first sentence of this paragraph proposes and authorizes the competent authorities to resolve, wherever possible, by mutual agreement any difficulties of interpretation or application. These are, in essence, difficulties of a general nature that concern or may concern a particular category of taxpayers, even if they have arisen in connection with an individual case that would normally fall under the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2.
51. This provision makes it possible to resolve difficulties arising in connection with the application of the Convention. Such difficulties include not only practical difficulties that may arise in establishing and implementing procedures for exemption from tax withheld on dividends, interest and royalties in the Contracting State in which they arise, but also those that may impair or hinder the normal operation of the provisions of the Convention as intended by the negotiating parties, the resolution of which does not depend on prior agreement regarding the interpretation of the Convention.
52. Under this provision, the competent authorities may, in particular:
— In the event of an incomplete or ambiguous definition of a term in the Convention, supplement or clarify its definition in order to eliminate any difficulties.
— Where the legislation of a State has been amended without upsetting the balance of or affecting the substance of the Convention, resolve any difficulties that may arise in connection with the new tax system resulting from such amendments.
— For the purpose of determining whether, and if so, under what conditions, interest may be treated as dividends under thin capitalization rules in the borrower State and whether it qualifies for relief from double taxation in the creditor's State of residence in the same way as dividends (for example, an exemption under the parent-subsidiary regime, where such an exemption is provided for in the relevant bilateral Convention).
— For the purpose of entering into bilateral advance pricing agreements (APAs), as well as concluding multilateral agreements with the competent authorities of third States with which each of the Contracting States has concluded a bilateral tax Convention, in cases where difficulties or doubts arise regarding the interpretation or application of the Conventions (particularly in cases where no action by the Contracting States could result in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention). A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or by concluding separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
— To determine the appropriate procedures, conditions and terms for the application of paragraphs 1 and 2, as well as the second sentence of this paragraph, to multilateral cases (see paragraphs 38.1–38.5 above and paragraphs 55–55.2 below) and to the participation of third States in the mutual agreement procedure where the resolution of a case may affect, or be affected by, taxation in third States.
53. Paragraph 3 confers upon the “competent authorities of the Contracting States”, that is, generally, the Ministers of Finance or their authorized representatives, who are normally responsible for the implementation of the Convention, the authority to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties arising in connection with the interpretation of the Convention. However, it is important not to lose sight of the fact that, depending on the domestic law of the Contracting States, other authorities (the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, courts) are entitled to interpret international treaties and agreements, as well as the “competent authority” referred to in the Convention, and that this is sometimes the exclusive right of such other authorities.
54. Mutual agreements resolving general difficulties of interpretation or application are binding on the administrations until such time as the competent authorities agree to amend or revoke the mutual agreement.
55. The second sentence of paragraph 3 also allows the competent authorities to consider cases of double taxation that do not fall within the scope of the provisions of the Convention. Of particular interest in this regard is the case of a resident of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States. The second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to consult with each other in order to eliminate double taxation that may arise in respect of transactions between permanent establishments. This may be the case, for example, where one or both of the Contracting States do not have a bilateral tax Convention with the third State. If both Contracting States have a Convention with the third State, however, the combination of these two Conventions may allow the competent authorities of all three States to resolve the case by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of Article 25 of these Conventions (see paragraphs 38.2 and 38.4 above). A multilateral agreement between the competent authorities of all the States involved is the best way to ensure that any double taxation is eliminated.
55.1. The domestic legislation of some Contracting States prevents the supplementation of the Convention with respect to matters that are not expressly or implicitly addressed in the Convention. In such cases, the Convention could be supplemented by a Protocol devoted to that matter. However, the second sentence of paragraph 3 does not allow the Contracting States to eliminate double taxation in cases where the granting of such relief would be contrary to their respective domestic legislation or would not be permitted under the provisions of other applicable tax treaties. This sentence allows the Contracting States, only in cases not covered by the Convention, to consult with each other in order to eliminate double taxation in accordance with their respective domestic laws or in accordance with a tax treaty concluded by one of the Contracting States with a third State. Thus, for example, in the case of an enterprise of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States, the second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to agree on the facts and circumstances of the case in order to ensure the consistent application of their respective domestic tax legislation, particularly with regard to any transactions between those permanent establishments; however, the Contracting States may relieve any double taxation of the profits of such permanent establishments only to the extent permitted by their respective domestic legislation or by the provisions of the Tax Treaty concluded between the Contracting State and that third State (i.e. Articles 7 and 23 of the Tax Treaty between the Contracting State and the third State). Thus, as these examples demonstrate, paragraph 3 plays a crucial role in ensuring that consultations with the competent authorities can take place in order to ensure the coordinated and effective functioning of tax treaties.
55.2. Under the first sentence of paragraph 3, the competent authorities may agree on a general basis that they will endeavour to resolve a case submitted under paragraph 1 with the competent authority of any third State in circumstances where taxation of income or capital in that third State may affect, or be affected by, the resolution of that case. Contracting States wishing to expressly provide for multilateral mutual agreement procedures may agree to use the following alternative wording of paragraph 2:
2. The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State with a view to avoiding taxation which is not in accordance with the Convention. If the resolution of the case may affect, or be affected by, taxation of income or capital in any third State, the competent authorities shall endeavour to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of any such third State, provided that a tax Convention is in force between each of the Contracting States and that third State, and that the competent authority of that third State agrees, within the three-year period provided for in paragraph 1, to consult with the competent authorities of the Contracting States in order to resolve the case by mutual agreement. In resolving the case, the competent authorities shall take into account the relevant provisions of this Convention together with the relevant provisions of the tax Conventions between the Contracting States and any third State participating in the procedure. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits provided for in the domestic laws of the Contracting States.
Paragraph 4
This paragraph determines how the competent authorities may conduct joint consultations in order to resolve by mutual agreement either an individual case falling within the procedure defined in paragraphs 1 and 2 or general issues relating, in particular, to the interpretation or application of the Convention and referred to in paragraph 3.
57. First, it provides that the competent authorities may communicate directly with each other. Therefore, there is no need to transmit information through diplomatic channels.
58. The competent authorities may communicate with each other by means of letters, facsimile transmission, telephone conversations, direct meetings or any other convenient means. Such authorities may, if they so wish, formally establish a joint commission for this purpose.
59. As regards this joint commission, paragraph 4 leaves it to the competent authorities of the Contracting States to determine the number of members and the rules of procedure of this body.
60. However, although the Contracting States may avoid any formalities in this area, they are nevertheless required to provide taxpayers whose cases are being considered by the joint commission under paragraph 2 with certain essential safeguards, namely:
— The right to make written or oral representations, either personally or through a representative;
— The right to legal assistance.
61. However, disclosure of the case documents to the taxpayer or their representatives does not appear appropriate in view of the special nature of the procedure.
62. Without prejudice to the freedom of choice which the competent authorities in principle enjoy when appointing their representatives to the Joint Commission, it would be desirable for them to agree to entrust the chairmanship of each delegation, which may include one or more representatives of the service responsible for the procedure, to a senior official or judge selected primarily on the basis of their particular expertise; it is reasonable to assume that the participation of such persons is likely to facilitate the reaching of an agreement.
Paragraph 5
63. This paragraph provides that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach an agreement under paragraph 2 within two years, the unresolved issues shall, upon written request by the person who submitted the case, be resolved through arbitration. This process does not depend on the prior approval of the competent authorities: once the necessary procedural requirements have been fulfilled, the unresolved issues preventing the conclusion of a mutual agreement must be submitted to arbitration.
64. The arbitration process provided for in this paragraph is neither an alternative nor an additional remedy: if the competent authorities have reached an agreement that leaves no unresolved issues regarding the application of the Convention, there are no unresolved issues that may be submitted to arbitration, even if the person who requested mutual agreement does not consider that the agreement reached by the competent authorities provides the correct resolution of the case. Thus, this paragraph constitutes an extension of the mutual agreement procedure, which serves to increase the effectiveness of that procedure by ensuring that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on one or more issues preventing the resolution of the case, the case may nevertheless still be resolved by submitting those issues to arbitration. Thus, under this paragraph, the resolution of the case continues to be carried out through the mutual agreement procedure, while the determination of a specific issue preventing agreement on the case is considered in arbitration proceedings. This distinguishes the process established in paragraph 5 from other forms of commercial or public-private arbitration, in which the jurisdiction of the arbitral panel extends to the resolution of the entire case.
65. In this latter case, it in fact appears difficult to reconcile the levying of tax at source with the principle set out in paragraph 3, according to which, for the purposes of taxing income derived from their activities or normally associated with them—as recognized in the case of dividends, interest and royalties referred to in paragraph 4 of Articles 10 and 11 and paragraph 3 of Article 12—permanent establishments must be treated as resident enterprises and, consequently, such income must be taxed exclusively as profits.
66. In any event, Contracting States experiencing this difficulty should resolve it through bilateral negotiations, taking into account their particular circumstances.
E. Credit for Foreign Tax
67. In this connection, where foreign income is included in the profits attributable to a permanent establishment, it is justified, on the basis of the same principle, to grant the permanent establishment a credit for foreign tax levied on such income, where such a credit is granted to resident enterprises under domestic law.
68. If, in a Contracting State (A) in which a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State (B) is located, a credit for tax levied in a third State (C) may be allowed only by virtue of a Convention, a more general question arises as to the extension to permanent establishments of the tax credit benefits provided for under tax Conventions concluded with third States. Although a permanent establishment is not itself a person and therefore is not entitled to the benefits provided for under these tax Conventions, this issue is relevant to the taxation of the permanent establishment. This issue is considered below in the specific case of dividends and interest.
F. Extension to Permanent Establishments of the Benefits of Tax Credit Provisions of Double Taxation Conventions Concluded with Third States
69. Where a permanent establishment in one Contracting State of an enterprise resident in the other Contracting State receives dividends or interest from a third State, the question arises as to whether, and to what extent, the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located should credit the tax that cannot be collected from the third State.
70. There is agreement that double taxation arises in these situations and that some method of relief should be found. Most member countries may grant credits in these cases on the basis of their domestic legislation or under paragraph 3. States that are unable to grant a credit in this manner or that wish to clarify the situation may wish to supplement the provision of their Convention with the Contracting State in which the enterprise is resident with wording allowing the State in which the permanent establishment is located to credit the tax liability in the State in which the income arises in an amount not exceeding the amount that resident enterprises in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located may claim under the Convention with the third State. If the tax that cannot be collected under the Convention between the third State and the State of residence of the enterprise having a permanent establishment in another Contracting State is lower than the tax levied under the Convention between the third State and the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is located, only the lower tax levied in the third State shall be credited. This result would be achieved by adding the following words after the first sentence of paragraph 3:
Where a permanent establishment of an enterprise of the other Contracting State in a Contracting State receives dividends or interest from a third State and the ownership or debt-claim in respect of which the dividends or interest are paid is effectively connected with that permanent establishment, the first-mentioned State shall grant a tax credit in respect of the tax paid in the third State on the dividends or interest, as the case may be, by applying the tax rate provided for in the Convention on income and capital between the State of which the enterprise is a resident and the third State. However, the amount of the credit shall not exceed the amount that an enterprise resident in the first-mentioned State may claim under the Convention on income and capital between that State and the third State.
If the Convention also provides for other categories of income that may be taxed in the State in which they arise and for which a credit should be granted (for example, royalties under certain Conventions), the above provision should be amended to cover them as well.
71. If a permanent establishment of an enterprise resident in a Contracting State (the State of residence), located in the other Contracting State, receives dividends, interest or royalties from a third State (the State of source) and, under the procedure agreed between the State of residence and the State of source, the State of source requests a certificate of residence for the application of withholding tax at the rate provided for under the Convention between the State of source and the State of residence, such certificate should be issued by the latter State. Although this procedure may be useful in cases where the State of residence uses the credit method, it does not appear to serve any purpose where that State uses the exemption method, since income from the third State is not subject to taxation in the State of residence of the enterprise. On the other hand, the State in which the permanent establishment is located may benefit from participating in the certification procedure, since this procedure will provide useful information for audit purposes. Another issue that arises in triangular cases,
— is the issue of abuse. For example, if a Contracting State applies the exemption method provided for in Article 23 A to profits attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third State that does not tax passive income arising in another Contracting State but attributable to such permanent establishment, there is a risk that such income will not be taxed in any of the three States. This issue is considered in paragraph 8 of Article 29.
72. In addition to the typical three-party situation considered here, other similar cases arise, in particular one in which the State of the enterprise is also the State from which the income attributable to a permanent establishment in another State originates (see also paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 21 and paragraphs 9 and 9.1 of the Commentary on Articles 23 A and 23 B). States may resolve similar issues through bilateral negotiations.
Item 4
73 . This paragraph is intended to put an end to a certain form of discrimination due to the fact that in some countries the deduction of interest, royalties and other payments, allowed without restrictions when the recipient is a resident, is limited or even prohibited when he is a non-resident. A similar situation is observed in the field of capital taxation when it comes to debts owed to non-residents. However, Contracting States may amend this provision in bilateral Conventions to avoid its use for tax evasion purposes.
74 . Paragraph 4 does not prohibit the borrower's country from applying its internal thin capitalization rules to the extent that they are compatible with paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article
11. However, if such a regime follows from rules that are incompatible with these articles and that apply only to non-resident creditors (with the exception of resident creditors), then such a regime is prohibited by paragraph 4.
75 . In addition, paragraph 4 does not prohibit additional information requirements for payments made to non-residents, as these requirements are designed to ensure the same level of compliance and verification in the case of payments to residents and non-residents.
Item 5
76 . This paragraph prohibits a Contracting State from granting less favourable treatment to an enterprise whose capital is wholly or partly, directly or indirectly owned or controlled by one or more residents of the other Contracting State. This provision stopped discrimination regarding taxation of only enterprises, and not persons who own or control their capital. Therefore, its purpose is to ensure equal treatment for taxpayers residing in the same State and not to subject foreign capital held by partners or shareholders to the same treatment that applies to domestic capital.
77 . Since this paragraph concerns only the taxation of resident enterprises, and not persons who own or control their capital, it follows that it cannot be interpreted as extending the benefits of rules that take into account the relationship between a resident enterprise and other resident enterprises (for example, rules allowing for consolidation, loss transfer, or tax-free transfer property between companies that are jointly owned). For example, if the domestic tax legislation of one State allows a resident company to consolidate its income with that of the resident parent company, then paragraph 5 cannot force the State to allow such consolidation between the resident company and the non-resident parent company. This will require comparing the combined treatment of a resident enterprise and a non-resident holding its capital with the treatment of a resident enterprise of the same State and a resident holding its capital, which clearly goes beyond the taxation of a resident enterprise only.
78 . In addition, since paragraph 5 is aimed at ensuring equal treatment for all resident companies, regardless of who owns or controls their capital, and is not aimed at ensuring equal treatment for the distribution of funds between residents and non-residents (see paragraph 76 above), it follows that the tax withholding obligations imposed on a resident company in respect of dividends paid to non-resident shareholders, but not in respect of dividends paid to resident shareholders, may not be considered a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, the different treatment does not depend on the fact that the company's capital is owned or controlled by non-residents, but rather on the fact that dividends paid to non-residents are taxed differently. A similar example would be a State that taxes resident companies that distribute funds to their shareholders, regardless of whether they are residents or non-residents, but which, in order to avoid repeated application of this tax, will not apply it to distributions made to related resident companies that are themselves taxed on their own distributions. The fact that the latter exception does not apply to distributions between non-resident companies should not be considered a violation of paragraph 5. In this case, we are not talking about the fact that the capital of a resident company belongs to or is controlled by non-residents, but that it is distributed among companies that, in accordance with the provisions of the agreement, cannot be subject to the same tax when redistributing dividends received from this resident company. In this example, all resident companies are treated equally regardless of who owns or controls their capital, and the different treatment is limited to cases where distributions are made in circumstances where the distribution tax could have been avoided.
79 . Since this clause prevents discrimination against a resident enterprise based solely on who owns or controls the capital of that enterprise, prima facie is irrelevant to the rules providing for Different treatment for an enterprise depending on whether it pays interest to resident or non-resident creditors. This paragraph does not apply to rules based on the relationship between the debtor and the creditor, as long as the regime resulting from these rules is not based on whether non-residents own the capital of the enterprise in whole or in part, directly or indirectly, or control it. For example, if, according to the internal thin capitalization rules of a State, a resident enterprise is not allowed to deduct interest paid to a non-resident associate, then this rule does not violate paragraph 5 even in cases where it applies to interest payments to a creditor who owns or controls the capital of the enterprise, provided that the regime is the same. if the interest was paid to a non-resident associate that does not itself own or control any of the payer's capital. However, it is clear that such a rule of domestic law may violate paragraph 4 to the extent that different conditions apply for the deduction of interest paid to residents and non-residents, and therefore, for the purposes of this paragraph, it is important to determine whether the application of this rule is compatible with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11 (see paragraph 74 above). This is also important for the purposes of paragraph 5 in the case of thin capitalization rules, which will apply only to enterprises of a Contracting State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by non-residents. Indeed, since the provisions of Article 9, paragraph 1, or Article 11, paragraph 6, are part of the context in which paragraph 5 is to be interpreted (as required by Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties), amendments compatible with these provisions cannot be considered as violating the provisions of paragraph 5.
80 . In the case of transfer pricing requests, almost all Member States consider that additional information requirements that would be more stringent than the usual requirements, or even the removal of the burden of proof, would not constitute discrimination within the meaning of this article.
Item 6
81 . This paragraph states that the scope of application of this article is not limited by the provisions of Article 2. Thus, this article applies to taxes of any kind and type levied by or on behalf of the State, its political subdivisions or local authorities.
82. [Deleted]
A comment about the comment
83.The United States notes that its non-resident citizens are not in the same circumstances as other non-residents, as the United States taxes its non-resident citizens on their global income.
84. [Deleted]
Reservations about this Article
85 . Canada and New Zealand leave their positions on this article unchanged.
86 . Australia reserves the right to propose amendments to ensure that Australia can continue to apply certain provisions of its domestic legislation regarding income tax collection.
87 . The United States reserves the right to apply its own domestic industry tax.
Point 1
88 . France would like to reserve the possibility of applying the provisions of paragraph 1 only to individuals, taking into account French case law and the fact that paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 already provide companies with broad protection against discrimination.
89 . Chile and the United Kingdom leave the position on the second sentence of paragraph 1 unchanged.
Item 2
90. Chile, Estonia, Japan, Switzerland and the United States of America reserve the right not to include paragraph 2 in their Conventions.
Point 3
90.1 In view of its special taxation system, Chile retains freedom of action with respect to the provisions of the Convention concerning the amount and form of distribution of profits by permanent missions.
Item 4
91. France accepts the provisions of paragraph 4, but would like to reserve the possibility of applying the provisions of its domestic legislation with respect to limiting the deduction of interest paid by a French company to an associated or related company.
Item 6
92. Chile, Greece and the United Kingdom reserve the right to limit the application of this article to taxes covered by the Convention.
COMMENTARY TO ARTICLE 25 ON THE MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE
I. Preliminary remarks
1. This article establishes a procedure for mutual agreement to resolve difficulties arising from the application of the Convention in the broadest sense of the word.
2. Firstly, in paragraphs 1 and 2, it provides that the competent authorities shall seek by mutual agreement to regulate the situation of taxpayers who are subject to taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention.
3. In paragraph 3, he also proposes and authorizes the competent authorities of the two States to resolve by mutual agreement problems related to the interpretation or application of the Convention and, in addition, to hold joint consultations to eliminate double taxation in cases not provided for by the Convention.
4. As for the practical application of the mutual agreement procedure, the article in paragraph 4 only authorizes the competent authorities to communicate with each other directly, without using diplomatic channels, and, if it seems appropriate to them, to conduct an oral exchange of views through a joint commission specially appointed for this purpose. Article 26 applies to the exchange of information for the purposes of the provisions of this article. This ensures the confidentiality of information exchanged for the purposes of the mutual agreement procedure.
5. Finally, paragraph 5 provides for a mechanism allowing a taxpayer to apply to arbitration on unresolved issues that have prevented the competent authorities from reaching mutual agreement within two years. Although the mutual agreement procedure provides a generally effective and efficient method for resolving disputes arising under the Convention, there may be cases where the competent authorities cannot agree that taxation by both States is consistent with the Convention. The arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 allows such cases to be resolved by independently resolving unresolved issues, which allows for mutual agreement. This process is an integral part of the mutual agreement procedure and does not represent an alternative way to resolve disputes concerning the application of the Convention.
5.1 The obligation to resolve, by mutual agreement, cases of taxation that do not comply with the Convention is an integral part of the obligations assumed by a Contracting State when concluding a tax treaty and must be fulfilled in good faith. In particular, the requirement in paragraph 2 that the competent authority "seek" to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State means that the competent authorities are obliged to seek to resolve the case in a fair and objective manner on the merits in accordance with the provisions of the Convention and applicable principles of international law concerning the interpretation of treaties.
6. Since this article sets out only general rules concerning the mutual agreement procedure, the following comments are intended to clarify the purpose of such rules, as well as expand them, if necessary, by referring, in particular, to the rules and practices applied at the international level when conducting mutual agreement procedures or at the domestic level when conducting procedures existing in most OECD member countries to address controversial tax requirements. In particular, since paragraph 5 explicitly requires the competent authorities to agree on the procedure for the application of the arbitration process, which it provides, the following comments discuss in detail the various procedural aspects of this process. The annex to this commentary contains an approximate form of agreement that the competent authorities can use as a basis for regulating the application of the arbitration process.; This annex addresses various structural and procedural issues, discusses various provisions of the model agreement, and in some cases suggests alternatives.
6.1 In accordance with Article 25, the Contracting States have delegated broad powers to the competent authorities with regard to the application and interpretation of the provisions of the Convention. Paragraph 2 authorizes the competent authorities to resolve, by mutual agreement, cases submitted by taxpayers for the purpose of tax evasion, which otherwise might arise from domestic legislation but would not comply with the Convention. Paragraph 3 similarly authorizes the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts concerning the interpretation or application of the Convention, both in individual cases (for example, in relation to a single taxpayer) and more generally (for example, by jointly interpreting a treaty provision applicable to a large number of taxpayers). In accordance with paragraph 3, the competent authorities may, in particular, conclude a mutual agreement on the definition of a term not defined in the Convention, or on supplementing or clarifying the definition of a certain term, if such an agreement would eliminate difficulties or doubts arising in connection with the interpretation or application of the Convention. Such circumstances may arise, for example, in cases where a conflict of values in accordance with the domestic legislation of the two States creates difficulties or leads to an unintended or absurd result. As explicitly recognized in paragraph 2 of Article 3, an agreement reached in accordance with paragraph 3 with respect to the meaning of a term used in the Convention takes precedence over the domestic law of each State with respect to the meaning of that term.
6.2 More generally, although the status under domestic law of the mutual agreement reached under Article 25 may vary between States, it is clear that the principles of international law regarding the interpretation of treaties, as set out in Articles 31 and 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, allow national courts to take such an agreement into account. The purpose of Article 25 is to promote, through consultation and mutual agreement between the competent authorities, the consistent consideration of individual cases and the same interpretation and/or application of the provisions of the Convention in both States. Article 25 also authorizes the competent authorities to resolve by mutual agreement difficulties or doubts regarding the interpretation or application of the Convention.; Such mutual agreement, reached in accordance with the direct mandate contained in paragraph 3 of this article, constitutes objective evidence of mutual understanding between the competent authorities of the meaning of the Convention and its terms. For these reasons, the agreement reached by the competent authorities in accordance with Article 25 must be taken into account for the purposes of interpreting the Convention.
6.3 In addition, in some cases, the application of certain contractual provisions is directly delegated by the Contracting States to the competent authorities, and agreements reached by the competent authorities in these matters legally regulate the application of these provisions. Subparagraph (d) of paragraph 2 of Article 4, for example, provides that the competent authorities shall resolve by mutual agreement certain cases where an individual is a resident of both Contracting States in accordance with paragraph 1 of this article. Some treaties similarly delegate to competent authorities the authority to jointly determine the status of various entities or arrangements for the purposes of certain contractual provisions (see, for example, subsection (i) of subparagraph (b) of the proposed provision in paragraph 35 of the commentary to Article 1) or the authority to supplement or amend the lists of entities, arrangements or provisions of domestic law mentioned in these treaties.
II. Commentary on the Provisions of this Article
Paragraphs 1 and 2
7. The rules set out in paragraphs 1 and 2 provide for an exception in a specific case of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. As is well known, in such cases taxpayers can generally appeal to the Tax Court, either directly or after their objections have been rejected by the tax authorities. Where taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention arises as a result of the incorrect application of the Convention in both States, taxpayers are then required to litigate in each State, with all the disadvantages and uncertainties that such a situation entails. Thus, paragraph 1 provides affected taxpayers, without depriving them of their ordinary legal remedies, with a procedure known as the mutual agreement procedure, since its purpose, at the second stage, is to resolve the dispute on an agreed basis, that is, by agreement between the competent authorities, while the first stage is conducted exclusively in one of the Contracting States, from the time the objection is submitted until a decision thereon is taken by the competent authority concerned.
8. In any event, the mutual agreement procedure is undoubtedly a special procedure that goes beyond the scope of domestic law. It follows that it can be set in motion only in cases falling within the scope of paragraph 1, that is, cases in which tax has been imposed or is being levied in violation of the provisions of the Convention. Thus, if the levying of tax has been carried out in violation of both the Convention and domestic law, the case is subject to the mutual agreement procedure only to the extent that the Convention is affected, unless there is a connecting link between the provisions of the Convention and the provisions of domestic law that have been incorrectly applied.
9. In practice, this procedure applies to cases — undoubtedly the most numerous — in which the measure in question results in double taxation, the avoidance of which is a specific objective of the Convention. Among the most common cases, the following should be mentioned:
— questions concerning the attribution of profits to a permanent establishment under paragraph 2 of Article 7;
— taxation in the State of the payer — in the case of special relationships between the payer and the beneficial owner — of the excess portion of interest and royalties referred to in the provisions of Article 9, paragraph 6 of Article 11 or paragraph 4 of Article 12;
— cases involving the application of thin capitalization legislation, where the State of the debtor company treats interest as dividends, since such a treatment is based on provisions of the Convention corresponding, for example, to Article 9 or paragraph 6 of Article 11;
— cases where the absence of information about the taxpayer's actual circumstances has led to the incorrect application of the Convention, particularly with regard to determining residence (paragraph 2 of Article 4), the existence of a permanent establishment (Article 5), or the temporary nature of services rendered by an employee (paragraph 2 of Article 15).
10. Article 25 also provides for a mechanism allowing the competent authorities to consult with each other in order to resolve, in the context of transfer pricing issues, not only problems of juridical double taxation but also problems of economic double taxation, and in particular problems arising from the inclusion of profits of associated enterprises under paragraph 1 of Article 9; accordingly, the corresponding adjustments to be made under paragraph 2 of the same Article fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure, both with regard to assessing their justification and determining their amount.
11. This is, in fact, implicit in the wording of paragraph 2 of Article 9, where the bilateral Convention concerned contains a provision of this kind. Where the bilateral Convention does not contain rules similar to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 9 (as is generally the case with Conventions signed before 1977), the mere fact that the Contracting States have included in the Convention the text of Article 9, limited to the text of paragraph 1, which usually merely confirms generally similar rules existing under domestic law, indicates that the intention was for the Convention to cover economic double taxation. As a result, most Member countries consider that economic double taxation arising from a transfer pricing adjustment is contrary, at least, to the spirit of the Convention and falls within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure established under Article 25.
12. Although the mutual agreement procedure plays a clear role in resolving issues arising in connection with the types of adjustments referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 9, it follows that even in the absence of such a provision, States should endeavour to avoid double taxation, including by making corresponding adjustments in the cases provided for in paragraph 2. Although there may be some differences of opinion, States generally regard a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure based on economic double taxation contrary to the provisions of Article 9 as covering the question of whether a corresponding adjustment should have been made, even in the absence of a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 9. However, States that do not share this view in practice find means of eliminating economic double taxation in most cases involving bona fide companies by using the provisions of their domestic law.
13. The mutual agreement procedure also applies in the absence of any double taxation contrary to the Convention, where the taxation challenged directly contradicts any provision of the Convention. This is the case where one State taxes a particular type of income in respect of which the Convention grants the exclusive right to tax to the other State, even if the latter is unable to exercise that right because of gaps in its domestic legislation. Another category of cases concerns persons who, being nationals of one Contracting State but residents of another State, are subjected in that other State to a tax treatment that is discriminatory under the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 24.
14. It should be noted that the mutual agreement procedure, unlike the procedure for contesting tax assessments under domestic law, may be initiated by the taxpayer without waiting for an assessment or notification of taxation that he considers to be "not in accordance with the Convention" to be issued to him. In order to be able to initiate this procedure, it is sufficient for him to establish that "the actions of one or both of the Contracting States" will result in such taxation and that such taxation appears to be a risk that is not merely possible but probable. Such actions mean all acts or decisions of a legislative or regulatory nature, whether of general or individual application, whose direct and necessary consequence is the levying of tax on the applicant contrary to the provisions of the Convention. Thus, for example, if an amendment to the tax legislation of a Contracting State results in a person receiving a particular type of income becoming subject to taxation in a manner that is not in accordance with the Convention, that person may initiate the mutual agreement procedure as soon as the law has been amended and that person receives the relevant income or it becomes probable that the person will receive that income. Other examples include the filing of a return under a self-assessment system or the active examination of a particular position taken by a taxpayer in a tax return during an audit, to the extent that either event creates the likelihood of taxation not in accordance with the Convention (for example, where the position taken by the taxpayer in a self-assessment return, which the taxpayer is required to adopt under the domestic law of a Contracting State, if proposed by that State as an assessment, would create the likelihood of taxation not in accordance with the Convention, or where circumstances such as published positions of a Contracting State or its audit practices create a significant likelihood that the active examination of a particular position taken by the taxpayer will lead to proposed assessments that would create the likelihood of taxation not in accordance with the Convention). Another example may be a case where the transfer pricing legislation of a Contracting State requires a taxpayer to report taxable income in an amount greater than that which would result from the actual prices used by the taxpayer in its transactions with a related party, for the purpose of complying with the arm's length principle, and where there is substantial doubt that the taxpayer's related party will be able to obtain a corresponding adjustment in the other Contracting State in the absence of the mutual agreement procedure. Such actions may also be understood to include bona fide adjustments initiated by the taxpayer, which are permitted under the domestic law of some countries and allow the taxpayer, in appropriate circumstances, to amend a previously filed tax return in order to reflect the price of a controlled transaction or the attribution of profits to a permanent establishment, that is, in the taxpayer's view, in accordance with the arm's length principle (see paragraph 6.1 of the Commentary on Article 9 and paragraph 59.1 of the Commentary on Article 7). As indicated in the opening words of paragraph 1, the question of whether the actions of one or both of the Contracting States will result in taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention must be determined from the taxpayer's perspective. Although the taxpayer's belief that such taxation exists must be reasonable and based on facts that can be established, the tax authorities should not refuse to consider a request under paragraph 1 merely because they consider that such taxation has not been proven (for example, under domestic rules of evidence based on the "balance of probabilities" standard).
15. Since the first steps in the mutual agreement procedure may be taken at a very early stage on the basis of a mere likelihood of taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention, the initiation of the procedure in this manner is not considered to constitute the starting date for the purposes of determining the commencement of the two-year period referred to in paragraph 5 of this Article. Paragraph 75 below explains when the said two-year period begins.
16. In order to be admissible, objections submitted under paragraph 1 must first satisfy the twofold requirement expressly set out in that paragraph: they must be submitted to the competent authority of either Contracting State, and they must be submitted within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the Convention. The Convention does not establish any specific rules regarding the form of objections. The competent authorities may prescribe such special procedures as they consider appropriate. Where no specific procedure has been established, objections may be submitted in the same manner as objections concerning taxes are submitted to the tax authorities of the State concerned.
17. The possibility granted to the taxpayer to present his case to the competent authority of either Contracting State is intended to strengthen the general principle that access to the mutual agreement procedure should be as broad as possible and should ensure flexibility. This option is also intended to ensure that the decision on whether to proceed to the second stage of the mutual agreement procedure (i.e. to be discussed by the competent authorities of both Contracting States) remains open to consideration by both competent authorities. Paragraph 1 allows a person to present his case to the competent authority of either Contracting State; it does not prevent a person from presenting his case to the competent authorities of both Contracting States simultaneously (see paragraph 75 below). If a person presents his case to the competent authorities of both Contracting States, he should duly inform both competent authorities of this in order to facilitate a coordinated approach to the case.
18. On the other hand, Contracting States may consider that taxpayers should not be allowed to present their cases to the competent authority of either State, but should first be required to present their cases to the competent authority of the State of which they are residents. However, where a person who is a national of one State but a resident of another complains that he has been subjected in that other State to taxation (or any related requirement) that is discriminatory under paragraph 1 of Article 24, it would appear more appropriate, for obvious reasons, to allow him, by way of an exception to the alternative rule requiring the taxpayer to present his case to the competent authority of the State in which he resides, to submit an objection to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a national. Similarly, it would appear more appropriate for an objection to be submitted to the same competent authority by a person who, although not a resident of a Contracting State, is a national of a Contracting State and whose case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24. In order to accommodate the alternative rule and the exception for cases falling within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24, paragraph 1 should be amended as follows:
1. Where a person considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting States result or will result for him in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, he may, irrespective of the remedies provided by the domestic law of those States, present his case to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a resident or, if his case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 24, to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is a national. The case must be presented within three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention.
Contracting States that prefer this alternative rule should take appropriate measures to ensure broad access to the mutual agreement procedure and proper consideration by both competent authorities of the decision on whether to proceed to the second stage of the mutual agreement procedure.
19. If a taxpayer becomes a resident of a State after being subjected to taxation that he considers not to be in accordance with the Convention, he should, under the alternative rule contained in paragraph 18 above, nevertheless submit an objection to the competent authority of the other State of which he was a resident during the period in respect of which such taxation was imposed or is being levied.
20. The three-year period for submitting objections established in the second sentence of paragraph 1 is intended to protect administrations against late objections. This period should be regarded as a minimum, so that Contracting States remain free to agree in their bilateral Conventions on a longer period in the interests of taxpayers, for example, by analogy, in particular, with the time limits established by their respective domestic regulations concerning tax conventions. Contracting States may omit the second sentence of paragraph 1 if they agree that their respective domestic rules automatically apply to such objections and are more favourable in their effects for the taxpayers concerned, either because they allow a longer period for submitting objections or because they do not establish any time limits for this purpose.
21. The provision establishing the date of the "first notification of the actions resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention" as the starting point of the three-year period should be interpreted in the manner most favourable to the taxpayer. Thus, even if such taxation is to be levied directly pursuant to an administrative decision or an act of general application, the period begins to run only from the date of notification of the individual action giving rise to such taxation, that is, under the most favourable interpretation, from the date of the tax assessment itself, as evidenced by a notice of assessment, an official demand or another document relating to the collection or levying of the tax. Since the taxpayer is entitled to bring a claim as soon as he considers that the taxation will result in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, whereas the three-year period begins only when that result has materialized, there will be cases in which the taxpayer is entitled to initiate the mutual agreement procedure before the three-year period begins (see the examples of such a situation given in paragraph 14 above).
22. In most cases, it is clear what constitutes the relevant notice of assessment, official demand or other instrument for collecting or levying tax, and there will usually be domestic law rules governing when such notice is considered to have been "given". Such domestic legislation generally takes into account the time when the notice is sent (time of dispatch), a specific number of days after it is sent, the time when it is expected to arrive at the address to which it was sent (both of which are times of presumed physical receipt), or the time when it is actually physically received (time of actual physical receipt). In the absence of such rules, either the time of actual physical receipt or, if this cannot be sufficiently established, the time when the notice would normally be expected to arrive at the relevant address should generally be regarded as the time of notification, bearing in mind that this provision should be interpreted in the manner most favourable to the taxpayer.
23. In cases of self-assessment, there is usually some notification affecting that assessment (for example, a notice of liability or a notice of refusal or adjustment of a refund claim), and, as a general rule, the time of notification, rather than the time when the taxpayer files the self-assessment return, is the starting point for the three-year period. If a taxpayer pays additional tax in connection with the filing of an amended return reflecting a bona fide adjustment initiated by the taxpayer (as described in paragraph 14 above), the starting point of the three-year period is generally the notification of the assessment or liability arising from the amended return, rather than the time of payment of the additional tax. However, there may be cases where there is no notification of liability or anything similar. In such cases, the relevant moment of "notification" is considered to be the moment when the taxpayer becomes aware of the taxation that is in fact not in accordance with the Convention. Such a situation may arise, for example, where information about a transfer of funds is first provided to the taxpayer, for example, in a bank balance or statement. The period begins to run irrespective of whether the taxpayer actually considers the taxation at that stage to be contrary to the Convention, provided that a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position would have been able at that stage to conclude that the taxation was not in accordance with the Convention. In such cases, notification to the taxpayer of the fact of taxation is sufficient. However, where only the combination of a self-assessment and some other circumstance could cause a reasonably prudent person in the taxpayer's position to conclude that the taxation was contrary to the Convention (for example, a court decision determining that the imposition of a tax in a case analogous to that of the taxpayer was contrary to the provisions of the Convention), the period begins to run only when the latter circumstance materializes.
24. If tax is levied by withholding at source, the period is calculated from the date of payment of the income; however, if the taxpayer proves that he became aware of the withholding only at a later date, the period is calculated from that date. Where a combination of decisions or actions taken in both Contracting States results in taxation not in accordance with the Convention, the period begins to run only from the date of the first notification of the most recent decision or action itself. This means that if, for example, a Contracting State levies tax that is not in accordance with the Convention, but the other State grants relief from such tax under Article 23 A or Article 23 B so that there is no double taxation, the taxpayer will often not, in practice, initiate the mutual agreement procedure in respect of the actions of the first State. However, if the other State subsequently notifies the taxpayer of its refusal to grant relief from tax, resulting in double taxation, a new period begins from that notification, since the combined actions of both States result in the taxpayer being subjected to double taxation in violation of the provisions of the Convention. In some cases, particularly of this kind, in accordance with the usual practice of one or both States, records held by the tax authorities may normally be destroyed before the expiry of the prescribed period. The obligations under the Convention do not prevent such destruction and do not require the competent authority to accept the taxpayer's arguments without evidence, but in such cases the taxpayer should be given an opportunity to make up for the lack of evidence as the mutual agreement procedure continues, to the extent permitted by domestic law. In some cases, the other Contracting State may provide sufficient evidence under Article 26 of the OECD Model Tax Convention. It is preferable for such records to be retained by the tax authorities throughout the entire period during which the taxpayer may request the initiation of the mutual agreement procedure in respect of a particular matter.
25. This three-year period continues to run throughout any domestic legal (including administrative) proceedings (for example, domestic appeal proceedings). Such a situation may create difficulties, effectively requiring the taxpayer to choose between domestic law remedies and the mutual agreement procedure. Some taxpayers may rely exclusively on the mutual agreement procedure, but many taxpayers will attempt to overcome these difficulties by initiating the mutual agreement procedure and simultaneously pursuing an action under domestic law, even if the domestic law proceedings are not initially being actively pursued. This may lead to an inefficient use of the resources of the mutual agreement procedure. Where domestic law permits, some States may wish to address this issue specifically by allowing the three-year (or longer) period to be suspended during domestic law proceedings. Two approaches, each of which is consistent with Article 25, are, on the one hand, to require the taxpayer to initiate the mutual agreement procedure without suspension during domestic proceedings, but for the competent authorities not to enter into negotiations until the domestic law action has been finally determined, or, on the other hand, for the competent authorities to enter into negotiations, but without finalizing an agreement unless the taxpayer agrees to withdraw the domestic law action. The second possibility is discussed in paragraph 42 of this Commentary. In either case, the taxpayer should be informed that the relevant approach is being applied. Regardless of whether the taxpayer considers it necessary to lodge a "protective" appeal under domestic law (for example, because of domestic time limits for bringing actions), the preferred approach for all parties is often for the mutual agreement procedure to be the initial focus for resolving the taxpayer's issues on a bilateral basis.
26. Some States may deny a taxpayer the possibility of initiating the mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 25 in cases where the transactions to which the request relates are regarded as abusive. This issue is closely related to the question of "improper use of the Convention", discussed in paragraph 54 and following paragraphs of the Commentary on Article 1. However, in the absence of a specific provision, there is no general rule prohibiting situations perceived as abusive from proceeding to the mutual agreement procedure. The mere fact that tax is levied pursuant to a provision of domestic law concerning tax avoidance should not constitute grounds for denying access to the mutual agreement procedure. However, in cases involving serious violations of domestic law resulting in significant penalties, some States may wish to deny access to the mutual agreement procedure. The circumstances in which a State denies access to the mutual agreement procedure should be set out in the Convention.
27. Some States consider that certain issues are not subject to resolution under the mutual agreement procedure in general or, at least, under the mutual agreement procedure initiated by taxpayers, by virtue of provisions or decisions of constitutional or other domestic law. An example would be a case where granting relief to a taxpayer would be contrary to a final court decision that the tax authority is required to comply with under the Constitution of that State. A generally recognized general principle of tax and other treaties is that domestic law, even domestic constitutional law, does not justify the failure to fulfil treaty obligations. Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties reflects the general principle of treaty law. It follows that any justification for what would otherwise constitute a violation of the Convention must be found in the terms of the Convention itself, as interpreted in accordance with the accepted principles of interpretation of tax treaties. Such a justification would be rare, since it would not merely determine how the matter would be dealt with by both States once it had entered the mutual agreement procedure, but would also prevent the matter from even reaching the stage at which it would be considered by both States. Since, in practice, such a decision may be taken by one of the States without consulting the other, and since there may be a bilateral solution that consequently remains unexplored, the view that a matter is not subject to a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure must be supported by the terms of the Convention as agreed. A competent authority relying on an obstacle under domestic law as grounds for denying a taxpayer access to the mutual agreement procedure must inform the other competent authority thereof and duly explain the legal basis for its position. As a general rule, genuine obstacles under domestic law do not prevent a matter from entering the mutual agreement procedure, but if they clearly and unambiguously prevent the competent authority from resolving the matter in such a way as to avoid taxation of the taxpayer that is not in accordance with the Convention, and there is no real prospect that the other State will resolve the matter in favour of the taxpayer, such a situation should be made public so that taxpayers do not have false expectations regarding the likely outcome of the procedure.
28. In other cases, it may be possible to allow the initiation of the mutual agreement procedure, but issues of domestic law arising after the conclusion of the treaty may prevent the competent authority from resolving, even partially, the matter raised by the taxpayer. Where such developments have a legally restrictive effect on the competent authority, so that bilateral discussions clearly cannot resolve the matter, most States would agree that such a change in circumstances is sufficiently significant to allow that competent authority to withdraw from the procedure. However, in some cases the difficulties may be merely temporary; for example, while amending legislation is being adopted, in which case the procedure should be suspended rather than terminated. The two competent authorities need to discuss this difficulty and its possible impact on the mutual agreement procedure. There will also be situations where a decision wholly or partially in favour of the taxpayer is mandatory and must be taken by one of the competent authorities, but where there is still scope for mutual agreement discussions, for example, where one competent authority demonstrates to the other that the latter should provide assistance.
29. There is less justification for relying on domestic law in the event of failure to implement an agreement reached under the mutual agreement procedure. The obligation to implement such agreements is unequivocally set out in the last sentence of paragraph 2, and obstacles to implementation that already exist should generally be included in the terms of the agreement itself. Since negotiations on tax Conventions take place against the background of a changing body of domestic law, which is sometimes difficult to predict, and since both parties are aware of this when discussing the original Convention and reaching a mutual agreement, subsequent unexpected changes that alter the fundamental basis of the mutual agreement will generally be regarded as requiring the agreement to be revised to the extent necessary. Clearly, where developments in domestic law of this kind occur, which should happen only in rare cases, the obligations of good faith require that they be notified as soon as possible and that good-faith efforts be made to find a revised or new mutual agreement to the extent permitted by domestic law. In these cases, the taxpayer's request should be regarded as still pending, rather than requiring a new request from that person.
30. As regards the procedure itself, it is necessary to briefly consider the two separate stages into which it is divided (see paragraph 7 above).
31. At the first stage, which begins with the submission of the taxpayer's objection, the procedure takes place exclusively at the level of dealings between the taxpayer and the competent authorities of the State to which the case has been presented. The provisions of paragraph 1 grant the taxpayer concerned the right to apply to the competent authority of either State, regardless of whether all remedies available under the domestic law of each of the two States have been exhausted. On the other hand, the competent authority is obliged to consider whether the objection is justified and, if it appears to be justified, to decide on it in one of the two forms provided for in paragraph 2.
31.1 The determination of whether an objection “appears to be justified” requires the competent authority to which the case has been presented to make a preliminary assessment of the taxpayer’s objection in order to determine whether the taxation in both Contracting States is in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. It is appropriate to consider that an objection is justified in cases where, in either of the Contracting States, taxation exists or will exist that is not in accordance with the Convention.
32. If the competent authority to which the case has been duly presented considers that the complaint is justified and considers that the tax complained of is wholly or partly attributable to measures taken in that State, it should grant the complaint as quickly as possible by making such adjustments or allowing such relief as appear to be justified. In this situation, the matter may be resolved without proceeding beyond the first (unilateral) stage of the mutual agreement procedure. On the other hand, an exchange of views and information with the competent authority of the other Contracting State may be useful, for example, in order to confirm the interpretation of the Convention in question.
33. However, if that competent authority considers that the taxation complained of is wholly or partly attributable to a measure taken in the other State, it is obliged, moreover, as is apparent from the provisions of paragraph 2, to initiate the second (bilateral) stage of the mutual agreement procedure. It is important that the competent authority concerned fulfil this obligation as quickly as possible, particularly in cases where the profits of associated enterprises have been adjusted as a result of a transfer pricing adjustment.
34. The taxpayer has the right to present its case under paragraph 1 to the competent authority of either State, regardless of whether it could also have brought an action or initiated judicial proceedings under the domestic law of one (or both) States. If judicial proceedings are pending in the State against which the claim is made, the competent authority of that State should not wait for a final judicial decision, but should indicate whether it considers the case acceptable for the mutual agreement procedure. If it takes such a decision, it should determine whether it can itself arrive at a satisfactory solution or whether the case should be referred to the competent authority of the other Contracting State. A taxpayer’s request to initiate the mutual agreement procedure cannot be rejected without valid reasons.
35. If the claim has been finally decided by a court in either State, the taxpayer may nevertheless wish to present or pursue the claim under the mutual agreement procedure. In some States, the competent authority may arrive at a satisfactory solution that departs from the court’s decision. In other States, the competent authority is bound by the court’s decision (that is, it is legally required to follow the court’s decision) or does not depart from the court’s decision as a matter of administrative policy or practice. Nevertheless, it may present the case to the competent authority of the other Contracting State and ask it to take measures to eliminate double taxation.
36. At the second stage, which begins when the competent authority of the other State approaches the competent authority to which the taxpayer presented the case, the procedure is henceforth conducted at the level of relations between the States, as if, so to speak, the State to which the complaint was submitted had supported it. Although this is an inter-State procedure, on the other hand, the following questions may be raised:
— whether this is, as follows from the title of the Article and the terms used in the first sentence of paragraph 2, no more than a simple mutual agreement procedure or constitutes the implementation of a pactum de contrahendo, imposing on the parties merely an obligation to negotiate, but in no way an obligation to reach an agreement;
— or whether, on the contrary, it should be regarded (in view of the arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 for resolving unresolved issues or on the assumption that the procedure is conducted within the framework of a joint commission) as a procedure of a jurisdictional nature, imposing on the parties an obligation to resolve the dispute.
37. Paragraph 2 undoubtedly entails an obligation to negotiate; however, as regards reaching mutual agreement through the procedure, the competent authorities are merely required to use their best endeavours, and not to achieve a result. However, paragraph 5 provides for a mechanism that will make it possible to reach an agreement even if there are issues on which the competent authorities have been unable to reach agreement through negotiations.
38. In seeking mutual agreement, the competent authorities must, of course, first determine their positions in the light of the rules of their respective tax laws and the provisions of the Convention, which are binding on them to the same extent as they are on the taxpayer. If the strict application of such rules or provisions precludes the possibility of reaching any agreement, it may reasonably be considered that the competent authorities, as in the case of international arbitration, may, on a subsidiary basis, take considerations of fairness into account in order to ensure a satisfactory outcome for the taxpayer.
38.1 The combination of bilateral tax Conventions concluded between several States may enable the competent authorities of those States to resolve multilateral cases by mutual agreement in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of those Conventions. A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or by concluding separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
38.2 This may, for example, be the case where it is necessary to determine the appropriate allocation of profits between permanent establishments that an enterprise has in two different States with which the enterprise’s State has tax treaties. In this case, an adjustment made in respect of transactions between two permanent establishments may affect the taxation of the enterprise in the State in which it is resident. On the basis of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of the tax Conventions between the enterprise’s State and the States in which the permanent establishments are located, the competent authority of the enterprise’s State undoubtedly has the authority to seek to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authorities of the States in which the permanent establishments are located and to determine the appropriate allocation of profits to the permanent establishments of its resident in accordance with both tax Conventions. If the tax treaties between the enterprise’s State and the States in which the permanent establishments are located contain different versions of Article 7 (for example, the version included in the OECD Convention in 2010 in one Convention and the previous version of Article 7 in another Convention), the competent authorities may take into account the considerations of fairness referred to in paragraph 38 above in order to find an appropriate solution with a view to ensuring taxation in accordance with the provisions of the applicable Conventions.
38.3 This situation arises where a number of associated enterprises from different States are involved in a series of integrated controlled transactions and bilateral tax treaties exist between the States of all the enterprises. Such a series of integrated controlled transactions may exist, for example, where intellectual property is licensed under a controlled transaction between two members of a multinational enterprise (MNE) group and is then used by the licensee to manufacture goods that the licensee sells to other members of the MNE group. On the basis of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 of these tax Conventions, the competent authorities of the States in which these enterprises are located undoubtedly have the authority to seek to determine the appropriate arm’s length transfer prices for the controlled transactions in accordance with the arm’s length principle of Article 9.
38.4 As acknowledged in paragraph 55 below, in the multilateral case described in paragraph 38.2, paragraph 3 of Article 25 of the tax Convention between the States in which the permanent establishments are located allows these two States to conduct joint consultations to ensure the effective operation of the Convention and the proper elimination of double taxation that may arise in such a situation.
38.5 The desire for certainty may lead taxpayers to seek multilateral advance pricing agreements (APAs) in order to determine in advance the transfer pricing of controlled transactions between associated enterprises in several States. Where bilateral tax Conventions exist between all these States and it appears that the actions of at least one of these States may result in taxation of the taxpayer that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, Article 25 of these Conventions allows the competent authorities of these States to negotiate on a multilateral basis an appropriate set of criteria for determining the transfer pricing of controlled transactions. A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or by concluding separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
39. The purpose of the last sentence of paragraph 2 is to enable countries whose domestic laws contain time limits relating to the adjustment of assessments and the refund of taxes to implement the agreement notwithstanding such time limits. However, this provision does not prevent those States which, on constitutional or other legal grounds, cannot waive the time limits established under domestic law from including in the mutual agreement itself such time limits as are adapted to their domestic limitation period (see also paragraph 62 of the Commentary on Article 7 and paragraph 10 of the Commentary on Article 9, which suggest an alternative approach that addresses this issue in the Convention). In some extreme cases, a Contracting State may prefer not to conclude a mutual agreement the implementation of which would require it to disregard a domestic limitation period (subject to the possible application of paragraph 5 where such a course of action would prevent the resolution of the case by mutual agreement). In addition to time limits, other obstacles may exist, such as “final court decisions”, to the implementation of an agreement. Contracting States are free to agree on firm provisions concerning the removal of such obstacles. As regards the practical implementation of this procedure, it is generally recommended that the tax authorities make every effort to ensure that, as far as possible, the mutual agreement procedure is in no way disrupted by operational delays or, in the case of time limits, by the combined effect of time limits and operational delays.
40. The Committee on Fiscal Affairs has made a number of recommendations concerning problems arising in connection with corresponding adjustments to profits following a transfer pricing adjustment (implementation of paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 9), as well as difficulties in applying the mutual agreement procedure in such situations:
a) Tax authorities should notify taxpayers as quickly as possible of their intention to make a transfer pricing adjustment (and, if the date of any such notification may be important, ensure that formal notification is given as quickly as possible), since it is particularly useful to ensure the earliest possible and most complete contacts on all relevant issues between tax authorities and taxpayers within one jurisdiction and across national borders between associated enterprises and the relevant tax authorities.
b) Competent authorities should interact with each other on these issues in the most flexible manner possible, whether in writing, by telephone, in person or at a round table, depending on what is most appropriate, and should seek to develop the most effective ways of resolving the relevant issues. The use of the provisions of Article 26 on the exchange of information should be encouraged in order to assist the tax authority in obtaining high-quality factual information on the basis of which a decision can be made.
c) In the course of mutual agreement proceedings concerning transfer pricing issues, the taxpayers concerned should be given every reasonable opportunity to present the relevant facts and arguments to the competent authorities, both in writing and orally.
41. With regard to the mutual agreement procedure in general, the Committee makes the following recommendations:
a) Formalities relating to the establishment and implementation of the mutual agreement procedure should be kept to a minimum, and any unnecessary formalities should be eliminated.
b) Each mutual agreement case should be resolved on its individual merits and not by reference to any balance of results in other cases.
c) Competent authorities should, where appropriate, formulate and publish domestic rules, guidelines and procedures concerning the use of the mutual agreement procedure.
42. A case may arise where a mutual agreement is concluded in respect of a taxpayer who has brought an action for the same purpose before a competent court of either Contracting State, and that action is still pending. In such a case, there is no reason to refuse the taxpayer’s request to defer the implementation of the decision agreed upon as a result of the mutual agreement procedure until the court has delivered its decision on that action. Furthermore, the competent authorities may reasonably proceed on the assumption that, where the taxpayer’s action is continuing in respect of a specific issue on which the same taxpayer is seeking mutual agreement, any in-depth discussions at the level of the competent authorities should await the court’s decision. If the taxpayer’s request for the mutual agreement procedure relates to different tax years from those covered by the judicial action, but concerns essentially the same factual and legal issues, so that in practice the court’s decision is expected to affect the treatment of the taxpayer in years not specifically covered by the judicial proceedings, the practical position may be the same as in the cases just mentioned. In any event, waiting for the court’s decision or otherwise suspending the mutual agreement procedure will not interrupt or cause the expiry of the two-year period referred to in paragraph 5 of this Article. Of course, if the competent authorities consider that the matter can in any event be resolved independently of domestic judicial proceedings (because, for example, the competent authority against which the judicial decision is directed will not be legally bound by or restricted by the court’s decision), the mutual agreement procedure may continue in the ordinary course. A competent authority may be legally precluded from pursuing taxation if a court has ruled that such taxation is not in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty. Conversely, in some countries, the competent authority would not be legally precluded from granting relief from taxation, notwithstanding a court decision that such taxation is in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty. In such a case, nothing (such as administrative policy or practice) should prevent the competent authorities from reaching a mutual agreement under which the Contracting State exempts from taxation that the competent authorities consider not to be in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty, thereby departing from the decision rendered by the court of the State.
43. The situation is also different if judicial proceedings are pending on an issue, but the action was brought by another taxpayer and not by the taxpayer seeking to initiate the mutual agreement procedure. If the case of the taxpayer seeking to resolve the issue by mutual agreement supports the actions of one or both competent authorities in preventing taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention, it should not be unduly delayed pending a general clarification of the law based on the example of another taxpayer, although the taxpayer seeking mutual agreement may agree to this if the clarification is likely to favour that taxpayer’s case. In other cases, delaying discussions by the competent authorities within the mutual agreement procedure may be justified in all the circumstances, but the competent authorities should bear in mind the time limits imposed by paragraph 5 and should, as far as possible, seek to prevent adverse consequences for the taxpayer seeking mutual agreement in such a case. This may be done, where permitted by domestic law, by deferring payment of the amount of the tax liability during the delay or, at least, during that part of the delay which is beyond the taxpayer’s control.
44. Depending on domestic procedures, the choice of remedy usually belongs to the taxpayer, and in most cases it is domestic provisions on recourse, such as appeals or judicial proceedings, that are deferred in favour of the less formal and bilateral nature of the mutual agreement procedure.
45. As noted above, a taxpayer may bring an action on an issue or may reserve the right to take such action under domestic law; however, the competent authorities may still consider that an agreement can be reached. In such cases, however, the concerns of the particular competent authority must be taken into account in order to avoid any discrepancies or contradictions between the court’s decision and the mutual agreement being sought, together with the difficulties or risks of abuse that they may entail. In short, therefore, the implementation of such a mutual agreement should generally be subject to:
— the taxpayer’s acceptance of such a mutual agreement; and
— the taxpayer’s withdrawal of the action concerning the issues settled by mutual agreement between the parties.
45.1 In some States, audit settlements may be used as a mechanism to facilitate the closure of audit files. As follows from the term “settlement”, there are usually concessions made by both the taxpayer and the tax administration concerned, which may give rise to difficult issues where the audit includes matters relating to the interpretation or application of a tax treaty that could potentially be resolved through the mutual agreement procedure. One of the concessions made by tax administrations is sometimes a restriction on further recourse by the taxpayer, which in some cases may include an agreement by the taxpayer not to initiate the mutual agreement procedure in respect of matters covered by the audit settlement. Double taxation may frequently result from such arrangements, which prevent the competent authorities from reaching a bilateral settlement through the mutual agreement procedure and may indeed lead the other Contracting State to refuse relief under its domestic law in respect of tax paid to the first Contracting State following the completion of the audit. Accordingly, a taxpayer should not be required, as part of an audit settlement, to waive the right provided for in paragraph 1 of Article 25 to present its case to the competent authority, since this may impede the proper application of the tax treaty. However, for the purposes of this paragraph, an “audit settlement” does not include the settlement of a treaty dispute resulting from an administrative or statutory dispute resolution/settlement process that is independent of audit and examination functions and is accessible only at the taxpayer’s request. Countries should inform their treaty partners of such administrative or statutory processes and should expressly address the implications of these processes for MAP in their public guidance on such processes and in their public policy guidance on MAP.
46. Some States consider that the mutual agreement procedure cannot be initiated by a taxpayer until all or a specified part of the disputed amount of tax has been paid. Such States consider that the requirement to pay outstanding taxes, in full or in part depending on the outcome of the procedure, is essentially a procedural matter not governed by Article 25 and is therefore consistent with it. The opposing view, held by many States, is that Article 25 specifies everything that a taxpayer must do before the procedure begins and that it imposes no such requirement. These States find support for their position in the fact that the procedure may be carried out even before the taxpayer has been taxed or notified of a liability (as noted in paragraph 14 above), and in the recognition that no such requirement is expressly provided for in respect of a procedure initiated by a competent authority under paragraph 3.
47. Article 25 does not provide an absolutely clear answer to the question of whether a taxpayer may be denied access to the mutual agreement procedure on the grounds that the required payment of all or part of the disputed tax has not been made. However, regardless of which view is adopted on this issue, in applying this Article it should be recognised that the mutual agreement procedure supports the fundamental provisions of the Convention and that the text of Article 25 should therefore be interpreted in context and in the light of the object and purpose of the Convention, including the prevention of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion and tax avoidance.
47.1 Unlike disputes relating exclusively to the application of the domestic law of a Contracting State, disputes dealt with under the mutual agreement procedure in most cases involve double taxation. Accordingly, States should, as far as possible, take cash flow issues into account when requiring an advance payment of an amount which, according to the taxpayer, has been levied, at least in part, contrary to the provisions of the relevant Convention. Even if the mutual agreement procedure ultimately eliminates any double taxation or other taxation not in accordance with the Convention, requiring payment of the tax before the conclusion of the mutual agreement procedure may permanently cost the taxpayer the time value of the money represented by the amount improperly levied during the period prior to the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, at least in the fairly common case where the relevant interest policies of the Contracting States concerned do not fully compensate the taxpayer for these costs. This means that, in such cases, the mutual agreement procedure will fail to achieve its objective of fully eliminating, in economic terms, the burden of double taxation or other taxation not in accordance with the Convention. Moreover, even if this economic burden is ultimately removed, requiring a taxpayer to pay taxes on the same income to two Contracting States may impose a cash flow burden that is incompatible with the objectives of the Convention of eliminating barriers to cross-border trade and investment. At a minimum, payment of outstanding tax should not be a requirement for initiating the mutual agreement procedure if it is not a requirement for initiating a review under domestic law. States may wish to expressly provide for this in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
“Assessment and collection procedures shall be suspended during the period in which any mutual agreement proceedings are pending, under the same conditions as those applicable to a person pursuing domestic administrative or judicial remedies.”
It also appears that, at a minimum, if the mutual agreement procedure is initiated before the taxpayer pays the tax (for example, as a result of an assessment), payment should be required only after the tax has been assessed.
48. For the reasons described in the preceding paragraph, the suspension of tax collection until the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure may be a desirable policy. Furthermore, any requirement to pay a tax assessment specifically as a condition for obtaining access to the mutual agreement procedure for the purpose of obtaining relief from that very tax would generally be incompatible with the policy of ensuring broad access to the mutual agreement procedure for resolving such disputes. Another unfortunate complication of such a requirement may be delays in resolving cases if a country is less willing to engage in good-faith discussions under the mutual agreement procedure where the likely outcome may be the refund of taxes already collected. In many States, the suspension of tax assessment and/or collection until the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure may require legislative amendments in order to implement it. States may also wish to expressly provide for the suspension of assessment and collection procedures in the Convention by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 2:
“Assessment and collection procedures shall be suspended during the period in which any mutual agreement proceedings are pending.”
In connection with any suspension of tax collection until the resolution of the mutual agreement procedure, it is important to recall the existence of preservation measures under paragraph 4 of Article 27.
48.1 Since there may be significant differences in the assessment and collection procedures under the domestic laws of the Contracting States, during bilateral negotiations it may be important to examine how these procedures will operate in each State before the mutual agreement procedure is resolved, in order to eliminate any obstacles that such procedures may create to the effective implementation of this Article. For example, if a State considers that payment of outstanding tax is a prerequisite for a taxpayer to initiate the mutual agreement procedure, this should be brought to the attention of the treaty partner during negotiations on the terms of the Convention. Where both Contracting States take this view, there is a common understanding, but also a particular risk that the taxpayer will be required to pay the amount twice. Where permitted by domestic law (or by a treaty provision similar to that contained in the preceding paragraph), one possibility that States could consider in order to address this problem is for the higher of the two amounts to be held in trust, escrow or a similar arrangement until the mutual agreement procedure has been completed. Alternatively, a bank guarantee provided by the taxpayer’s bank may be sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the competent authorities. As another approach, one or the other State (determined, for example, by the timing of the assessments or the status of the State of residence under the treaty) may agree to require payment of no more than the difference between the amount paid to the other State and the amount it is claiming, if any. Which of these possibilities is available ultimately depends on the domestic law (including administrative requirements) of the particular State and the provisions of the applicable treaty, but these are precisely the options that should, as far as possible, be considered in seeking to ensure the most effective operation of the mutual agreement procedure. Where States require some payment of outstanding tax as a prerequisite for a taxpayer-initiated mutual agreement procedure or for the active consideration of an issue under that procedure, they should have an effective system for refunding interest on any principal amount that becomes refundable to the taxpayer as a result of a mutual agreement reached by the competent authorities. Any such payment of interest should adequately reflect the cost of the principal amount and the period of time during which that amount was unavailable to the taxpayer.
49. Paragraph 4 of the Commentary on Article 2 explains that, although most States do not consider interest and administrative penalties relating to taxes covered by Article 2 to be covered by Article 2 in their own right, where such interest and administrative penalties are directly related to taxes covered by Article 2, they should be appropriately reduced or cancelled to the same extent as the underlying covered tax is reduced or cancelled under the mutual agreement procedure. Consequently, a Contracting State that has imposed interest or an administrative penalty calculated by reference to the underlying tax liability (or by reference to any other amount relevant to the determination of the tax, such as the amount of an adjustment or the amount of taxable income) and that subsequently agrees under the mutual agreement procedure pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 25 to reduce or cancel that underlying tax liability should proportionately reduce or cancel such interest or administrative penalty.
49.1 In contrast, other administrative penalties (for example, a penalty for failure to provide proper transfer pricing documentation) may relate to domestic compliance issues that are not directly connected with the tax liability that is the subject of a request for the mutual agreement procedure. Such administrative penalties generally do not fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article. However, under paragraph 3 of Article 25, the competent authorities may consult jointly and agree in a particular case that a penalty not directly related to taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention was not or is no longer justified. For example, if an administrative penalty for negligence, wilful conduct or fraud was imposed in a fixed amount and it was subsequently agreed in the mutual agreement procedure that there had been no fraudulent intent, wilful conduct or negligence, the competent authorities may agree that the Contracting State that imposed such a penalty should withdraw it. Under paragraph 3 of this Article, the competent authorities may also conclude a general mutual agreement under which they will seek, through the mutual agreement procedure, to resolve under paragraphs 1 and 2 issues relating to interest and administrative penalties that give rise to difficulties or doubts concerning the application of the Convention. Contracting States may, if they consider it preferable, expressly provide in paragraph 2 of Article 25 for the application of this paragraph to interest and administrative penalties in mutual agreement procedure cases presented under paragraph 1 by adding the following text to the second sentence:
“The competent authorities shall also endeavour to agree on the application of the provisions of domestic law concerning interest and administrative penalties relating to the case.”
49.2 Criminal penalties imposed by a prosecutor or a court generally do not fall within the scope of the mutual agreement procedure. In many States, the competent authorities have no legal authority to reduce or cancel these penalties.
49.3 A mutual agreement often results in the tax liability being retained in one Contracting State, while the other Contracting State is required to refund all or part of the tax it has collected. In such cases, the taxpayer may bear a significant economic burden if there are asymmetries in the way interest is charged on tax liabilities and refunds in the two Contracting States, for example, where the first Contracting State charges late-payment interest on the tax that was the subject of the request for the mutual agreement procedure, while the second Contracting State does not pay overpayment interest on the amount it is required to refund to the taxpayer. Contracting States should therefore seek to adopt flexible approaches to ensure relief from interest relating to the tax liability that is the subject of a request for the mutual agreement procedure. Relief from interest would be particularly appropriate for the period during which the taxpayer is involved in the mutual agreement procedure, given that the amount of time required to resolve a case through the mutual agreement procedure is, for the most part, beyond the taxpayer’s control. Amendments to the domestic law of a Contracting State may be required in order to enable the competent authority to grant relief from interest agreed upon under the mutual agreement procedure.
49.4 The purpose of the Convention, which is to avoid double taxation, and the requirement that States perform their Conventions in good faith imply that interest and penalty payments should not be imposed in such a way as effectively to discourage taxpayers from initiating the mutual agreement procedure because of the associated costs and cash flow consequences. Interest and administrative penalties should not be applied in such a way as to seriously undermine or negate taxpayers’ confidence in the benefits of the Convention, including the right to initiate the mutual agreement procedure provided for in Article 25. For example, a State’s requirements concerning the payment of outstanding penalties and interest should not be more burdensome for taxpayers in the context of the mutual agreement procedure than they would be in the context of a taxpayer-initiated review under domestic law.
Add a concise heading and overviewClarify the Article 25 progression
Paragraph 3
50. The first sentence of this paragraph invites and authorizes the competent authorities to resolve, where possible, difficulties of interpretation or application by mutual agreement. These are essentially difficulties of a general nature that concern or may concern a particular category of taxpayers, even if they have arisen in connection with an individual case that would normally fall under the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2.
51. This provision makes it possible to resolve difficulties arising in connection with the application of the Convention. Such difficulties include not only practical difficulties that may arise in connection with the establishment and implementation of procedures for granting exemption from tax withheld on dividends, interest and royalties in the Contracting State in which they arise, but also difficulties that may impair or hinder the normal operation of the provisions of the Convention as intended by the negotiators, the resolution of which does not depend on prior agreement regarding the interpretation of the Convention.
52. Under this provision, the competent authorities may, in particular:
— In the event of an incomplete or ambiguous definition of a term in the Convention, supplement or clarify its definition in order to eliminate any difficulties.
— Where the legislation of a State has been amended without prejudice to the balance or substance of the Convention, resolve any difficulties that may arise in connection with the new tax system resulting from such amendments.
— For the purpose of determining whether, and if so, under what conditions, interest may be treated as dividends under the thin capitalization rules in the borrower’s country and whether it qualifies for relief from double taxation in the creditor’s country of residence in the same manner as dividends (for example, exemption under the parent-subsidiary regime, where such exemption is provided for in the relevant bilateral Convention).
— For the purpose of concluding bilateral advance pricing agreements (APAs), as well as multilateral agreements with the competent authorities of third States with which each of the Contracting States has concluded a bilateral tax Convention, in cases where difficulties or doubts arise regarding the interpretation or application of the Conventions (particularly in cases where no action by the Contracting States could result in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention). A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or by concluding separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
— Determine appropriate procedures, conditions and terms for the application of paragraphs 1 and 2, as well as the second sentence of this paragraph, to multilateral cases (see paragraphs 38.1–38.5 above and paragraphs 55–55.2 below) and to the participation of third States in the mutual agreement procedure where the resolution of a case may affect, or be affected by, taxation in third States.
53. Paragraph 3 confers upon the “competent authorities of the Contracting States”, that is, generally, the Ministers of Finance or their authorized representatives, who are usually responsible for the implementation of the Convention, the authority to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties arising in connection with the interpretation of the Convention. However, it is important not to overlook the fact that, depending on the domestic law of the Contracting States, other authorities (the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, courts) may have the authority to interpret international treaties and agreements, as well as the “competent authority” specified in the Convention, and that this may sometimes be the exclusive right of such other authorities.
54. Mutual agreements resolving general difficulties of interpretation or application are binding on the administrations until such time as the competent authorities agree to amend or revoke the mutual agreement.
55. The second sentence of paragraph 3 also allows the competent authorities to consider cases of double taxation that do not fall within the scope of the provisions of the Convention. Of particular interest in this regard is the case of a resident of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States. The second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to consult each other with a view to eliminating double taxation that may arise in respect of transactions between the permanent establishments. This may be the case, for example, where one or both Contracting States do not have a bilateral tax Convention with the third State. If both Contracting States have a Convention with the third State, however, the combination of these two Conventions may allow the competent authorities of all three States to resolve the case by mutual agreement under paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of Article 25 of those Conventions (see paragraphs 38.2 and 38.4 above). A multilateral agreement between the competent authorities of all the States involved is the best way to ensure that any double taxation is eliminated.
55.1 The domestic law of some Contracting States prevents the supplementation of the Convention with respect to matters that are not expressly or implicitly addressed in the Convention. In such cases, the Convention could be supplemented by a Protocol dealing with the matter in question. However, the second sentence of paragraph 3 does not allow the Contracting States to eliminate double taxation in cases where the granting of such relief would be contrary to their respective domestic laws or would not be permitted under the provisions of other applicable tax treaties. This sentence allows the Contracting States only, in cases not covered by the Convention, to consult each other with a view to eliminating double taxation in accordance with their respective domestic laws or in accordance with a tax treaty concluded by one of the Contracting States with a third State. Thus, for example, in the case of an enterprise of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States, the second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to agree on the facts and circumstances of the case in order to ensure the consistent application of their respective domestic tax laws, particularly with respect to any transactions between those permanent establishments; however, the Contracting States may relieve any double taxation of the profits of those permanent establishments only to the extent permitted by their respective domestic laws or by the provisions of the Tax Treaty concluded between the Contracting State and that third State (i.e. Articles 7 and 23 of the Tax Treaty between the Contracting State and the third State). Thus, as these examples demonstrate, paragraph 3 plays a crucial role in ensuring that consultations with the competent authorities can be conducted to ensure the coordinated and effective operation of tax treaties.
55.2 Under the first sentence of paragraph 3, the competent authorities may agree, on a general basis, that they will endeavour to resolve a case presented under paragraph 1 with the competent authority of any third State in circumstances where taxation of income or capital in that third State may affect, or be affected by, the resolution of that case. Contracting States wishing to expressly provide for multilateral mutual agreement procedures may agree to use the following alternative wording of paragraph 2:
2. The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State with a view to avoiding taxation which is not in accordance with the Convention. If the resolution of the case may affect, or be affected by, the taxation of income or capital in any third State, the competent authorities shall endeavour to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of any such third State, provided that a tax Convention is in force between each of the Contracting States and that third State, and that the competent authority of that third State agrees, within the three-year period provided for in paragraph 1, to consult with the competent authorities of the Contracting States with a view to resolving the case by mutual agreement. In resolving the case, the competent authorities shall take into account the relevant provisions of this Convention together with the relevant provisions of the tax Conventions between the Contracting States and any third State participating in the procedure. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits imposed by the domestic laws of the Contracting States.
Paragraph 4
This paragraph determines how the competent authorities may conduct joint consultations for the purpose of resolving by mutual agreement either an individual case falling within the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 or general issues concerning, in particular, the interpretation or application of the Convention referred to in paragraph 3.
57. First, it provides that the competent authorities may communicate directly with each other. Therefore, there is no need to transmit information through diplomatic channels.
58. The competent authorities may communicate with each other by means of letters, facsimile transmission, telephone conversations, direct meetings or any other convenient means. Such authorities may, if they so wish, formally establish a joint commission for this purpose.
59. As regards this joint commission, paragraph 4 leaves it to the competent authorities of the Contracting States to determine the number of members and the rules of procedure of this body.
60. However, although the Contracting States may avoid any formalities in this area, they are nevertheless required to provide taxpayers whose cases are being considered by a joint commission under paragraph 2 with certain essential guarantees, namely:
— The right to make written or oral representations, personally or through a representative;
— The right to legal assistance.
61. However, disclosure of the case documents to the taxpayer or their representatives does not appear appropriate in view of the special nature of the procedure.
62. Without prejudice to the freedom of choice which the competent authorities generally enjoy in appointing their representatives to the Joint Commission, it would be desirable for them to agree to entrust the chairmanship of each delegation, which may include one or more representatives of the service responsible for the procedure, to a senior official or a judge selected primarily on the basis of their particular expertise; it is reasonable to assume that the participation of such persons is likely to facilitate the reaching of an agreement.
Paragraph 5
63. This paragraph provides that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach an agreement under paragraph 2 within two years, the unresolved issues shall, at the written request of the person who presented the case, be resolved through arbitration. This process does not depend on the prior consent of the competent authorities: once the necessary procedural requirements have been met, the unresolved issues preventing the conclusion of a mutual agreement must be submitted to arbitration.
64. The arbitration process provided for in this paragraph is not an alternative or additional remedy: if the competent authorities have reached an agreement that leaves no unresolved issues concerning the application of the Convention, there are no unresolved issues that can be submitted to arbitration, even if the person who requested mutual agreement does not consider that the agreement reached by the competent authorities provides the correct resolution of the case. Thus, this paragraph extends the mutual agreement procedure, serving to enhance its effectiveness by ensuring that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on one or more issues preventing the resolution of the case, the case may nevertheless still be resolved by submitting those issues to arbitration. Accordingly, under this paragraph, the resolution of the case continues to take place through mutual agreement, while the determination of a specific issue preventing agreement on the case is dealt with through arbitration. This distinguishes the process established in paragraph 5 from other forms of commercial or public-private arbitration, in which the jurisdiction of the arbitral panel extends to the resolution of the entire case.
65. Until 2017, the footnote to paragraph 5 stated that, in some States, domestic law, political or administrative considerations might not permit or justify the type of arbitration process provided for in this paragraph, and gave as an example constitutional barriers preventing arbitrators from deciding tax matters. However, the footnote was deleted in recognition of the importance of including an arbitration mechanism that ensures the resolution of disputes between competent authorities in cases where such disputes would otherwise prevent the mutual agreement procedure from fulfilling its function.
65.1 Paragraph 5 includes the essential conditions of the arbitration process. The last sentence of this paragraph expressly requires the competent authorities to agree on the manner in which this process is to be applied, and it is therefore expected that most procedural aspects of this process will be determined by agreement between the competent authorities (see paragraph 85 below and the model “mutual agreement on arbitration” included in the Annex). However, some States may prefer to include certain of these procedural aspects in the Convention itself. Although this makes the arbitration provision more complex, a State may consider that the importance of certain aspects (such as the rules concerning the appointment of arbitrators and the confidentiality of information communicated to them) is such that these matters should be addressed in the Convention itself. Part VI of the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (“Multilateral Instrument”), which was opened for signature on 31 December 2016, is a good example of a Convention that includes many procedural aspects of the arbitration process.
66. Some States may wish to include paragraph 5 but restrict its application to a narrower range of cases. For example, access to arbitration may be limited to cases involving issues that are primarily factual in nature. It could also be provided that arbitration is always available to consider issues arising in certain classes of cases, such as cases involving transfer pricing or the question of the existence of a permanent establishment, while extending arbitration to other issues on a case-by-case basis. States wishing to restrict the application of paragraph 5 should bear in mind that any substantial restriction on the scope of the Arbitration Provision may limit its effectiveness in ensuring the resolution of unresolved issues arising in a mutual agreement procedure case.
66.1 If paragraph 5 is included in a new Convention replacing the provisions of a previous Convention that included an arbitration provision, or to which Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument applies, the Contracting States should clarify whether paragraph 5 of the new Convention applies to cases involving provisions of that previous Convention. If it does not, the Contracting States should ensure that the arbitration provision of the previous Convention or Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument, as the case may be, continues to apply, so as to ensure arbitration of unresolved issues arising under the provisions of that previous Convention.
67. In addition, States that are members of the European Union may wish to coordinate the scope of paragraph 5 with their obligations under legal instruments applicable to those members. Such coordination should ensure the possibility of arbitration under such a legal instrument, even if paragraph 5 has a narrower scope. This could be done, for example, by including the following additional paragraph in Article 25:
Paragraph 5 shall not affect the fulfilment of broader obligations arising under any other legal instrument applicable to the Contracting States and relating to the arbitration of unresolved issues referred to in that paragraph.
Coordination should also ensure that unresolved issues falling within the scope of paragraph 5 are not subject to arbitration proceedings both under this paragraph and under any other legal instrument.
68. The taxpayer should be able to request arbitration of unresolved issues in all cases considered under the mutual agreement procedure that have been presented under paragraph 1 on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention. Where no mutual agreement procedure is available, for example, because of the existence of serious violations involving substantial penalties (see paragraph 26), it is clear that paragraph 5 does not apply.
69. If two Contracting States that have not included this paragraph in their Convention wish to implement an arbitration process for general application or for the consideration of a specific case, they may still do so by mutual agreement. In this case, the competent authorities may conclude a mutual agreement in accordance with the model wording provided in the Annex, to which they would add the following first paragraph:
1. The present agreement
a) whereas, in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 of the Convention, a person has presented a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted, for that person, in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention; and
b) whereas the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on the resolution of that case under paragraph 2 of this Article within two years from the date on which all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case has been provided to both competent authorities, any unresolved issues arising from the case shall be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the following paragraphs, if the person so requests in writing.
However, those unresolved issues shall not be submitted to arbitration if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of either State. If the person directly affected by the case does not agree to the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision, the competent authorities hereby agree to consider themselves bound by the arbitration decision and to resolve the case in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 25 on the basis of that decision.
This agreement will address the various structural and procedural issues discussed in the Annex. Although the competent authorities will thus be bound by such a process, the agreement is given as part of the mutual agreement procedure and therefore remains in effect only for as long as the competent authorities continue to agree to follow this process for resolving cases that they have been unable to resolve through the traditional mutual agreement procedure.
70. Paragraph 5 provides that a person who has presented a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State under paragraph 1 on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in that person being taxed not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention may request in writing that any unresolved issues arising in connection with that case be submitted to arbitration. This request may be submitted at any time after the expiry of the two-year period commencing on the date on which all information necessary for the competent authorities to consider the case has been provided to both competent authorities. Thus, referral to arbitration is not automatic; the person who presented the case may prefer to wait after the expiry of the two-year period (for example, to allow the competent authorities more time to resolve the case under paragraph 2) or simply not to pursue the case further.
70.1 States that consider the two-year period to be too short may amend this provision to allow an arbitration request to be submitted only after three years. In addition, States are entitled to provide that, in certain circumstances, a longer period of time will be required before a request may be submitted in a particular case. This could be done, for example, by allowing the competent authorities to agree, in each individual case, on a different period before the expiry of those two years; this could be achieved by formulating subparagraph b) as follows:
b) the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on the resolution of that case under paragraph 2 within two years from the date on which all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case has been provided to both competent authorities (unless, before the expiry of that period, the competent authorities of the Contracting States have agreed on a different period in respect of that case and have notified the person who presented the case of such agreement).
70.2 States may also wish to provide that this two-year period is suspended in cases where the mutual agreement procedure itself is suspended. This may occur, for example, where a mutual agreement procedure case concerns one or more issues that are also pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal and a Contracting State does not allow the taxpayer to pursue both the mutual agreement procedure and proceedings before a court or administrative tribunal simultaneously (see paragraph 76). It may also happen that one competent authority agrees with the person who presented the case to suspend the mutual agreement procedure (for example, because of serious illness or some other personal difficulties). To address such cases, the following provision could be added to paragraph 5:
If the competent authority has suspended the mutual agreement procedure referred to in paragraph 1 because the case concerning one or more of the same issues is pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the case pending before the court or Administrative Tribunal has been suspended or withdrawn. Furthermore, if the person who presented the case and the competent authority have agreed to suspend the mutual agreement procedure, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the suspension is lifted.
70.3 In some cases, after the taxpayer has provided the initial information necessary for the consideration of the merits of the case, the competent authorities may need to request additional information from the taxpayer. For example, after the period provided for in subparagraph b) has commenced and following further analysis of the case, a competent authority may determine that it requires additional information in order to reach agreement on how to resolve the issue. In such cases, the failure of the person directly affected by the case to provide such additional information in a timely manner may delay or prevent the competent authorities from resolving the issue. This issue may be addressed through the alternative wording of subparagraph b) proposed in paragraph 70.1 above, which allows the competent authorities to agree on different time limits in each individual case. Alternatively, it could be addressed in a mutual agreement that would regulate the manner in which the Arbitration Provision is applied, for example, by providing that the two-year period is extended if both competent authorities agree that the person directly affected by the case has failed to provide in a timely manner any additional material information requested by either competent authority after the commencement of the period provided for in subparagraph b) (see Article 7 of the model mutual agreement in the Annex; a similar provision could instead be added to the Convention itself if the alternative provision in paragraph 70.1 is not used).
71. Under paragraph 2 of Article 25, the competent authorities must endeavour to resolve the case presented under paragraph 1 with a view to avoiding taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. Therefore, for the purposes of paragraph 5, a case should not be considered resolved as long as there remains at least one issue on which the competent authorities disagree and which, in the opinion of one of the competent authorities, indicates that taxation not in accordance with the Convention has occurred. Accordingly, one competent authority cannot unilaterally decide that such a case is closed and that the person concerned cannot request arbitration of the unresolved issues; similarly, the two competent authorities cannot consider the case to have been settled and refuse a request for arbitration if there are still unresolved issues preventing them from agreeing that no taxation contrary to the Convention has occurred. However, where both competent authorities agree that taxation by both States has been carried out in accordance with the Convention, there are no unresolved issues, and the case may be considered resolved, even where double taxation may exist that is not governed by the provisions of the Convention.
72. The arbitration process is available only in cases where the person considers that taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention has actually resulted from the actions of one or both Contracting States; however, it is not available in cases where it is alleged that such taxation will ultimately result from such actions, even though the latter cases may be presented to the competent authorities under paragraph 1 of this Article (see paragraph 70 above). For this purpose, taxation should be regarded as resulting from the actions of one or both Contracting States as soon as, for example, tax has been paid, assessed or otherwise determined, or even where the taxpayer has been formally notified by the tax authorities that they intend to tax a particular item of income.
73. In its current wording, paragraph 5 provides only for the arbitration of unresolved issues arising in connection with a request submitted under paragraph 1 of this Article. States wishing to extend the scope of this paragraph also to mutual agreement cases arising under paragraph 3 of this Article are free to do so. In some cases, a mutual agreement case may arise from other specific treaty provisions, such as subparagraph 2 d) of Article 4. Under that subparagraph, the competent authorities are required in certain cases to settle by mutual agreement the question of the status of an individual who is a resident of both Contracting States. As indicated in paragraph 20 of the Commentary on Article 4, such cases should be resolved in accordance with the procedure established in Article 25. If the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on such a case and this results in taxation not in accordance with the Convention (under which the individual should be a resident of only one State for the purposes of the Convention), the taxpayer’s case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 25 and, consequently, paragraph 5 applies.
74. In some States, the competent authorities may depart from a court decision on a particular issue arising from a case presented to the competent authorities. Therefore, those States should be able to omit the second sentence of this paragraph and, if they wish to use the alternative provision in paragraph 70.2 above, amend it as follows:
If the competent authority has suspended the mutual agreement procedure referred to in paragraph 1 because the case concerning one or more of the same issues is pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the case pending before the court or Administrative Tribunal has been suspended or withdrawn. Furthermore, if the person who presented the case and the competent authority have agreed to suspend the mutual agreement procedure, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the suspension is lifted.
75. For the purposes of determining the commencement of the two-year period, all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case shall be deemed to have been provided to both competent authorities only if sufficient information has been submitted to both competent authorities to enable them to determine whether the objection underlying the case is justified. A mutual agreement governing the manner in which paragraph 5 is to be applied should clarify the process to be used to determine this commencement date and should specify what type of information will generally be sufficient for this purpose. The model mutual agreement included in the Annex assumes a process similar to that used in Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument. States that consider that the rules for determining the commencement date of the two-year period should be included directly in the Convention may do so, for example, by including provisions similar to those in paragraphs 5–9 of Article 19 of the Multilateral Instrument.
76. This paragraph also addresses the relationship between the arbitration process and the rights to domestic remedies. In order for the arbitration process to be effective and to avoid the risk of conflicting decisions, a person should not be permitted to continue the arbitration process if the issues submitted to arbitration have already been decided in domestic judicial proceedings in either State (which means that a court or administrative tribunal of one of the Contracting States has already rendered a decision concerning those issues that is applicable to that person). This is consistent with the approach adopted by most countries with regard to the mutual agreement procedure, under which:
a) A person cannot use the mutual agreement procedure and domestic remedies simultaneously. Where domestic remedies are still available, the competent authorities generally either require the taxpayer to agree to suspend those remedies or, if the taxpayer does not agree, defer the mutual agreement procedure until those remedies have been exhausted.
b) Where the mutual agreement procedure is conducted first and a mutual agreement is reached, the taxpayer and other persons directly affected by the case are given the opportunity to reject the agreement and pursue the suspended domestic remedies; conversely, if those persons prefer the agreement to be implemented, they will have to waive the use of domestic remedies in respect of the issues covered by the agreement.
c) Where domestic remedies are first used and exhausted in one State, the person may use the mutual agreement procedure only to obtain relief from double taxation in the other State. Indeed, after a legal decision has been rendered in a particular case, most countries consider it impossible to overturn that decision through the mutual agreement procedure and would therefore limit any subsequent application of the mutual agreement procedure to attempts to obtain relief in the other State.
The same general principles should apply in the case of a mutual agreement procedure that includes one or more issues submitted to arbitration. Referral of a case to an arbitral tribunal is unreasonable if it is known in advance that one of the countries is constrained in its response to the arbitration decision. However, this would not be the case if a country were able to depart from a court decision within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure (see paragraph 74), in which case paragraph 5 could be adjusted accordingly.
77. The second issue concerns the relationship between existing domestic remedies and arbitration in cases where those remedies have not been exhausted. In this case, the approach most consistent with the basic structure of the mutual agreement procedure would be to apply the same general principles when it comes to arbitration. Thus, the exercise of remedies would be suspended until completion of the mutual agreement procedure, including arbitration of the issues that the competent authorities are unable to resolve, and a preliminary mutual agreement is reached on the basis of that decision. As in other cases involving the mutual agreement procedure, this agreement is then presented to the taxpayer, who must decide whether to accept the agreement, which would require waiving any remaining domestic remedies, or reject the agreement and pursue those remedies.
78. This approach is consistent with the nature of the arbitration process set out in paragraph 5. The purpose of this process is to enable the competent authorities to reach a conclusion on unresolved issues preventing an agreement. Where such an agreement is reached through arbitration, the substantive nature of the mutual agreement remains unchanged.
79. In some cases, this approach means that the parties will have to spend time and resources on an arbitration process that will result in a mutual agreement that is not accepted by the taxpayer. However, practical experience shows that there are very few cases in which the taxpayer refuses the mutual agreement in order to resort to domestic remedies. Furthermore, in these rare cases, it could be expected that the national courts or administrative tribunals would take note of the fact that the taxpayer had been offered an administrative resolution of their case that would have been binding on both States.
79.1 As noted in paragraph 76 a) above, most States do not allow a person to use the mutual agreement procedure and domestic remedies simultaneously. However, some States may allow a person to pursue both the mutual agreement procedure and proceedings before a court or administrative tribunal simultaneously in respect of the same issues; in those States, there is a possibility that a decision on the issue or issues submitted to arbitration may be rendered by a court or administrative tribunal after the arbitration request has been submitted but before the arbitral panel has rendered its decision. Such States may wish to expressly provide that the arbitration process shall be terminated in such circumstances in order to avoid difficulties that may subsequently arise in implementing the mutual agreement giving effect to the subsequent arbitration decision (see paragraph 76 above). For this purpose, the following wording could be added to paragraph 5:
If, at any time after a request for arbitration has been submitted and before the arbitral panel has rendered its decision to the competent authorities of the Contracting States, a decision on the matter is rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of one of the Contracting States, the arbitration process shall be terminated.
80. In some States, unresolved issues between the competent authorities may be submitted to arbitration only if domestic remedies are no longer available. In order to implement the arbitration approach, these States could consider an alternative approach requiring the person to waive the right to use domestic remedies before arbitration can take place. This could be done by replacing the second sentence of the paragraph with the following:
“however, those unresolved issues shall not be submitted to arbitration if any person directly affected by the case still has the right under the domestic law of either State to request the courts or administrative tribunals of that State to decide those issues or if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by such a court or administrative tribunal”.
In order to avoid a situation in which the taxpayer must waive domestic remedies without any guarantees regarding the outcome of the case, it would then also be important to amend this paragraph to include a mechanism that would guarantee, for example, that double taxation is actually relieved. Furthermore, since the taxpayer would then be waiving the right to be heard by the national courts, this paragraph should also be amended to ensure that the taxpayer is provided with sufficient legal safeguards regarding their participation in the arbitration process to satisfy any requirements that may exist under domestic law for such a waiver to be acceptable within the applicable legal system (for example, in some countries such a waiver may be ineffective if the person is not guaranteed the right to be heard orally during the arbitration proceedings).
80.1 Some States consider that taxpayers and their advisers should not disclose any information obtained during arbitration proceedings. States that share this view may freely include the following provision, based on paragraph 5 of Article 23 of the multilateral instrument:
Before arbitration proceedings begin, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall ensure that each person who presented the case and their advisers agree in writing not to disclose to any other person any information received during the arbitration proceedings either from the competent authority or from the arbitration panel. The mutual agreement procedure and the arbitration proceedings relating to the case shall be terminated if, at any time after the submission of the request for arbitration and before the arbitration panel has rendered its decision, the competent authorities determine that the person who presented the case or one of that person's advisers has materially breached this agreement.
81. Paragraph 5 provides that, if the person directly affected by the case does not accept the mutual agreement that implements the arbitration decision, that decision shall be binding on both States. Accordingly, the taxation of any person directly affected by the case must be consistent with the decision reached on the issues submitted to arbitration, and the decisions taken in the arbitration proceedings will be reflected in the mutual agreement presented to those persons. However, if the arbitration decision is found to be invalid by the courts of one of the Contracting States because of a violation of paragraph 5 of Article 25 or any procedural rule, that arbitration decision shall not be binding on either State (see also Article 11 of the sample mutual agreement, which addresses this issue).
82. As noted in subparagraph 76 b) above, where a mutual agreement is reached before domestic remedies have been exhausted, the competent authorities will generally require, as a condition for the application of the agreement, that the affected persons waive the use of any domestic remedies that may still be available in respect of the issues covered by the agreement. Without such a waiver, a subsequent court decision could indeed prevent the competent authorities from implementing the agreement. Accordingly, for the purposes of paragraph 5, if the person to whom the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision has been presented does not agree to waive the use of domestic remedies, that person shall be considered not to have accepted the agreement. If the mutual agreement is not accepted or is deemed not to have been accepted, the case shall not be considered further by the competent authorities.
82.1 For greater certainty, some States may wish to reflect the conclusions of paragraphs 81 and 82 above in the text of their Conventions, which could be done by adding an additional paragraph worded approximately as follows:
For the purposes of paragraph 5:
a) a mutual agreement implementing an arbitration decision in a case shall be deemed not to have been accepted by the person directly affected by that case if any person directly affected by that case does not, within 60 days from the date on which the notification of the mutual agreement was sent to that person, withdraw all issues resolved in the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision from consideration by any court or administrative tribunal or otherwise terminate, in accordance with that mutual agreement, any pending judicial or administrative proceedings concerning such issues; and
b) the decision shall not be binding on the Contracting States if:
(i) a final decision of the courts of one of the Contracting States declares the arbitration decision invalid. In such a case, the request for arbitration under paragraph 5 shall be deemed not to have been submitted, and the arbitration proceedings shall be deemed not to have taken place (except for any applicable provisions concerning the confidentiality of information and the payment of costs relating to arbitration). In such a case, a new request for arbitration may be submitted, unless the competent authorities agree that such a new request should not be permitted; or (ii) the person directly affected by the case conducts judicial proceedings before any court or administrative tribunal on issues that were resolved in the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision.
83. An arbitration decision is binding only with respect to the specific issues submitted to arbitration. Although nothing prevents the competent authorities from resolving other similar cases (including cases involving the same persons but different tax periods) on the basis of that decision, there is no obligation to do so, and therefore each State is entitled to adopt a different approach to the consideration of those other cases.
84. Some States may wish to allow the competent authorities to depart from the arbitration decision, provided that they are able to agree on another solution that would resolve all outstanding issues preventing the resolution of the case under the mutual agreement procedure (this is, for example, permitted under Article 12 of the EU Arbitration Convention). States wishing to do so may amend the third sentence of this paragraph as follows:
... If the person directly affected by the case does not accept the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision, or the competent authorities do not agree on another resolution of all outstanding issues arising from the case within three months after the decision has been communicated to them, the arbitration decision shall be binding on both States and shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits provided for under the domestic laws of those States.
85. The last sentence of this paragraph leaves the manner of implementing the arbitration process to be determined by mutual agreement between the parties. As indicated in paragraph 65.1 above, some States may prefer to include certain procedural aspects of the arbitration process in the Convention itself; other States may wish to regulate them through a protocol or an exchange of diplomatic notes. However, it should be noted that resolving these issues on the basis of a mutual agreement provides greater flexibility with regard to subsequent amendments that may become necessary as the Contracting States gain experience in applying the arbitration provisions. Whatever form the agreement takes, it should set out the structural and procedural rules to be followed in applying this paragraph, taking into account the requirement contained therein that the arbitration decision be binding on both States. Ideally, this agreement should be prepared at the same time as the Convention, so that it can be signed and applied immediately upon the entry into force of this paragraph. Furthermore, since the agreement will contain detailed information on the process to be followed for submitting unresolved issues to arbitration, it would be important for this agreement to be made public. A sample such procedural mutual agreement is provided in the Annex, together with comments on the procedural rules it proposes.
Use of Other Supplementary Dispute Resolution Mechanisms
86. Regardless of whether paragraph 5 is included in the Convention or the arbitration process is carried out otherwise using the procedure described in paragraph 69 above, it is clear that supplementary dispute resolution mechanisms other than arbitration may be implemented on an ad hoc basis within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure. Where there are disagreements regarding the relative merits of the positions of the two competent authorities, the case may be facilitated if the issues are clarified by a mediator. In such situations, the mediator hears the positions of each party and then expresses an opinion on the strengths and weaknesses of each party's position. This helps each party to better understand its own position and that of the other party. Some tax authorities currently use mediation successfully to resolve domestic disputes, and extending such methods to mutual agreement procedures may prove useful.
87. Where the issue is purely factual, the case may be referred to an expert whose mandate is limited to making the necessary factual determinations. This is often done in judicial proceedings, when factual issues are referred to an independent party who makes factual findings that are then submitted to the court. Unlike the dispute resolution mechanism established in paragraph 5, these procedures are not binding on the parties, but may nevertheless be useful in enabling them to reach a decision before the issue is referred to arbitration under that paragraph.
III. Interaction of the Mutual Agreement Procedure with the Dispute Resolution Mechanism Provided for under the General Agreement on Trade in Services
88. The application of the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), which entered into force on 1 January 1995 and to which all member countries are signatories, raises particular concerns in connection with the mutual agreement procedure.
89. Paragraph 3 of Article XXII of the GATS provides that a dispute concerning the application of Article XVII of the Agreement — the national treatment rule — may not be considered under the dispute resolution mechanisms provided for in Articles XXII and XXIII of the Agreement if the contested measure "falls within the scope of an international agreement between them for the avoidance of double taxation" (for example, a tax Convention). In the event of a disagreement as to whether a measure "falls within the scope" of such an international agreement, paragraph 3 further provides that any State involved in the dispute may refer the matter to the Council for Trade in Services, which shall refer the dispute to binding arbitration. However, the footnote to paragraph 3 contains an important exception, namely that if the dispute concerns an international agreement "which exists at the time of entry into force of the Agreement", the matter may not be referred to the Council for Trade in Services unless both States agree to do so.
90. Two particular problems concerning tax treaties arise in connection with this paragraph.
91. First, the footnote provides for different treatment of tax Conventions concluded before and after the entry into force of the GATS, which may be considered inappropriate, particularly in cases where a Convention that existed at the time the GATS entered into force is subsequently revised or where a protocol is concluded after that date in relation to an existing Convention.
92. Second, the phrase "falls within the scope" is inherently ambiguous, as evidenced by the inclusion in paragraph 3 of Article XXII of the GATS of both an arbitration procedure and a clause exempting previously existing Conventions from its application for the purpose of resolving disagreements relating to its meaning. Although it seems clear that a country cannot in good faith¹ claim that a measure relating to a tax to which no provision of a tax Convention applies falls within the scope of that Convention, it is unclear whether this phrase covers all measures relating to taxes covered by all or only some provisions of the tax Convention.
¹ The obligation to apply and interpret treaties in good faith is expressly recognized in Articles 26 and 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; accordingly, the exception contained in paragraph 3 of Article XXII of the GATS applies only to disputes concerning good faith.
93. Contracting States may wish to avoid these difficulties by extending, on a bilateral basis, the application of the footnote to paragraph 3 of Article XXII of the GATS to Conventions concluded after the entry into force of the GATS. Such bilateral extension, which would supplement — but in no way violate — the obligations of the Contracting States under the GATS, could be included in the Convention by adding the following provision:
For the purposes of paragraph 3 of Article XXII (Consultations) of the General Agreement on Trade in Services, the Contracting States agree that, notwithstanding that paragraph, any dispute between them as to whether a measure falls within the scope of this Convention may be referred to the Council for Trade in Services, as provided for in that paragraph, only with the agreement of both Contracting States. Any doubts regarding the interpretation of this paragraph shall be resolved in accordance with paragraph 3 of Article 25 or, in the absence of agreement under that procedure, in accordance with any other procedure agreed upon by both Contracting States.
94. Problems similar to those discussed above may arise in connection with other bilateral or multilateral agreements relating to trade or investment. During their bilateral negotiations, Contracting States may amend the proposed provision above in order to ensure that issues concerning taxes covered by their tax Convention are dealt with under the mutual agreement procedure rather than through the dispute settlement mechanism of such agreements.
Observation on the Commentary
95. Hungary does not fully share the interpretation contained in paragraph 27 of the Commentary on Article 25 and is unable to conduct a mutual agreement procedure in cases where a Hungarian court has already ruled on the merits of the case.
95.1 With regard to paragraphs 21–24, Chile wishes to clarify that the starting point of the three-year period — the date of the "first notification" — is the moment when the tax administration first notifies the taxpayer of the proposed adjustment, unless an earlier date applies, as discussed in paragraphs 21–24.
95.2 Chile reserves its position with respect to the cases discussed in paragraph 23 and takes the view that the three-year period begins upon the filing of an amended return.
95.3 With regard to paragraph 26, France does not share the interpretation that the circumstances in which a Contracting State denies access to the mutual agreement procedure, particularly in cases involving double taxation associated with serious penalties that have become final, must necessarily be specified in the Convention.
95.4 Portugal does not share the interpretation contained in paragraph 49 of the Commentary on Article 25. Portugal takes the view that interest and penalties are not taxes covered by the Convention and therefore cannot be considered under the mutual agreement procedure.
Reservations on this Article
96. Switzerland reserves its position on the second sentence of paragraph 2. It considers that the granting of relief and refunds under a mutual agreement should continue to be subject to the time limits established by its domestic law. Switzerland is prepared to agree to alternative treaty provisions that limit the period within which a Contracting State may make adjustments under paragraph 1 of Article 9 or paragraph 2 of Article 7, in order to avoid late adjustments.
97. Denmark, Israel, Korea, Mexico and Turkey reserve the right not to include paragraph 5 in their Conventions.
98. Mexico and Poland reserve their positions on the second sentence of paragraph 2. These countries consider that the granting of relief and refunds under a mutual agreement should be subject to the time limits established by their domestic laws.
99. With regard to paragraph 2, Turkey, for the purpose of regulating tax refund claims, reserves the right to require its taxpayers to submit an application to the competent tax office within one year, requesting a refund of taxes arising from a mutual agreement reached, starting from the date of notification of the results of such agreement.
100. Canada reserves the right to include a provision similar to those referred to in paragraph 62 of the Commentary on Article 7 and paragraph 10 of the Commentary on Article 9, which effectively establishes a time limit within which a Contracting State may make an adjustment to the income of an enterprise.
101. Hungary reserves its position on the last sentence of paragraph 1, since it cannot agree to conduct a mutual agreement procedure in the case of a request submitted to its competent authority outside the limitation period provided for under its domestic law.
102. For political and administrative reasons, Hungary and Chile reserve the right not to include paragraph 5 in their Conventions.
103. Australia reserves the right to exclude a case presented under the mutual agreement procedure article from the scope of paragraph 5 to the extent that any unresolved issue relates to the application of Australia's general anti-avoidance rules contained in Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 and Division 67 of the Fringe Benefits Tax Assessment Act 1986.
ANNEX
SAMPLE MUTUAL AGREEMENT ON ARBITRATION
1. The following is a sample form of agreement that the competent authorities may use as a basis for a mutual agreement on the implementation of the arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 of this Article (see paragraph 85 above). Paragraphs 2–48 below discuss the various provisions of the agreement and, in some cases, propose alternative options. The competent authorities are, of course, free to amend, add or delete any provisions of this sample agreement when concluding their bilateral agreement.
Mutual Agreement on the Implementation of Paragraph 5 of Article 25
The competent authorities of [State A] and [State B] have entered into the following mutual agreement establishing the arrangements for the implementation of the arbitration process provided for in paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the [name of Convention], which entered into force on [date of entry into force]. The competent authorities may amend or supplement this agreement by an exchange of letters between them.
1. Request for Submission of a Case to Arbitration
A request for the submission of unresolved issues arising from a case under the mutual agreement procedure to arbitration in accordance with paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the Convention ("request for arbitration") shall be made in writing and addressed to one or both competent authorities. The request shall contain sufficient information to establish the circumstances of the case. The request shall also be accompanied by a written statement from each of the persons making the request or directly affected by the case, stating that no court or administrative tribunal of either State has rendered a decision on the same issues. Within
10 days after receipt of the request, the competent authority that received it without any indication that it was also sent to the other competent authority shall forward a copy of that request and the accompanying statements to the other competent authority.
2. Start Date of the Two-Year Period
1. A request for arbitration may be submitted only after the expiry of two years from the date on which all information necessary for the competent authorities to consider the case has been provided to both competent authorities (hereinafter referred to as the "Start Date"). For this purpose, the information required by the competent authorities to consider the case shall include: [the necessary details and documents shall be specified in the agreement].
2. The following rules shall apply for determining the Start Date:
a) The competent authority that receives the initial request for a mutual agreement procedure under paragraph 1 of Article 25 of the Convention shall, within 60 days after receipt of the request:
(i) send a notification to the person who presented the case confirming that it has received the request; and
(ii) send a notification of the request, together with a copy of the request, to the competent authority of the other Contracting State.
b) Within 90 days after receipt of the request for a mutual agreement procedure (or its copy from the competent authority of the other Contracting State), each competent authority shall either:
(i) notify the person who presented the case and the other competent authority that it has received the information necessary to consider the merits of the case; or
(ii) request additional information from that person for this purpose.
c) If, pursuant to subsection (ii) of subparagraph b) above, one or both competent authorities have requested additional information from the person who presented the case that is necessary to consider the merits of the case, the competent authority that requested the additional information shall, within 90 days after receipt of the additional information from that person, notify that person and the other competent authority either within 90 days after receipt of the additional information from that person, or within 90 days after receipt of the additional information from that person:
(i) that it has received the requested information; or
(ii) that some of the requested information is still missing.
d) If neither competent authority has requested additional information pursuant to subsection (ii) of subparagraph b) above, the Start Date shall be the earlier of the following dates:
(i) the date on which both competent authorities notified the person who presented the case pursuant to subsection (i) of subparagraph b) above; and
(ii) the date that is 90 days after the notification by the competent authority of the other Contracting State pursuant to subsection (ii) of subparagraph a) above.
e) If additional information has been requested pursuant to subsection (ii) of subparagraph b) above, the Start Date shall be the earlier of the following dates:
(i) the latest date on which the competent authorities that requested additional information notified the person who presented the case and the other competent authority pursuant to subsection (i) of subparagraph c) above; and
(ii) the date that is 90 days after both competent authorities have received all the information requested by either competent authority from the person who presented the case.
However, if one or both competent authorities issue the notification referred to in subsection (ii) of subparagraph c) above, such notification shall be treated as a request for additional information pursuant to subsection (ii) of subparagraph b).
[Scope of authority: As explained in paragraphs 15.1–15.5 of the explanations following this sample agreement, the agreement may also provide for the adoption of a "scope of authority"]
3. Selection and Appointment of Arbitrators
1. The arbitration panel shall consist of three independent arbitrators with special expertise or experience in international tax matters. Each arbitrator appointed to the arbitration panel shall be impartial and independent of the competent authorities, tax administrations and ministries of finance of the Contracting States, as well as of all persons directly affected by the case (and their advisers), at the time of appointment, shall maintain such impartiality and independence throughout the proceedings, and shall avoid any conduct for a reasonable period of time thereafter that may undermine the appearance of the arbitrators' impartiality and independence in relation to the proceedings.
2. Within 60 days after receipt of the request for arbitration (or a copy thereof) by both competent authorities, the competent authorities shall each appoint one arbitrator. Within 60 days after the last appointment, the arbitrators so appointed shall appoint a third arbitrator, who shall act as chairperson. The chairperson shall not be a citizen or resident of either Contracting State.
3. If any appointment is not made within the required period, the arbitrator or arbitrators not yet appointed shall be appointed by the highest-ranking official of the Centre for Tax Policy and Administration of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development who is not a citizen of either Contracting State, within 10 days after receipt of the relevant request from the person who submitted the request for arbitration. The same procedure shall apply, with the necessary modifications, if for any reason an arbitrator needs to be replaced after the commencement of the arbitration proceedings.
4. An arbitrator shall be deemed to have been appointed if a letter confirming the appointment, signed by the arbitrator and by the person or persons authorized to appoint that arbitrator, has been sent to both competent authorities.
4. Arbitration Proceedings
1. Within 60 days after the appointment of the chairperson of the arbitration panel (unless, before the expiry of this period, the competent authorities agree on another period or agree to use the approach described in Article 5 in relation to the case concerned), the competent authority of each Contracting State shall submit to each arbitrator and to the other competent authority a proposed resolution addressing all unresolved issues in the case (taking into account any agreements previously reached between the competent authorities in that case). The proposed resolution shall be limited to the disposition of specific monetary amounts (for example, income) or, if specified, the maximum amount of tax that may be levied under the provisions of the Convention, for each adjustment or similar issue in the case. Where the competent authorities of the Contracting States have been unable to agree on the conditions for the application of a particular provision of the Convention (hereinafter referred to as a "threshold question"), for example, whether an individual is a resident or whether a permanent establishment exists, the competent authorities may submit alternative proposed resolutions on issues whose determination depends on the resolution of such threshold questions.
2. The competent authority of each Contracting State may also submit to the arbitrators and the other competent authority, within the period provided for in paragraph 1, a supporting position paper for consideration by the arbitrators.
3. Each competent authority may also submit to the arbitrators and the other competent authority, within 120 days after the appointment of the chairperson of the arbitration panel, a response submission addressing the proposed resolution and accompanying position paper submitted by the other competent authority.
4. To the extent possible, the arbitrators shall use teleconferences and videoconferences to communicate with each other and with both competent authorities. If an in-person meeting is necessary and involves additional costs, the chairperson shall contact the competent authorities, which shall decide on the time and place of the meeting and communicate this information to the arbitrators.
5. The arbitration panel shall select as its decision one of the proposed resolutions of the case submitted by the competent authorities in respect of each issue and any threshold questions, and shall not include any reasoning or other explanation of that decision. The arbitration decision shall be adopted by a simple majority of the arbitrators. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the arbitration decision shall be transmitted in writing to the competent authorities of the Contracting States within 60 days after the decision has been adopted or, if no response submission has been made, within 150 days after the appointment of the chairperson of the arbitration panel. The arbitration decision shall have no precedential value.
5. Optional Arbitration Proceedings
1. If, within 60 days after the appointment of the chairperson of the arbitration panel, the competent authorities agree to use the approach described in this Article in relation to the case, each competent authority shall submit to the arbitration panel and the other competent authority, within 120 days after that election, any information that it considers necessary for the panel to make its decision. This information shall include a description of the facts and unresolved issues to be determined, as well as the competent authority's position on those issues and the arguments supporting that position. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the arbitration panel may not take into account any information that was not available to both competent authorities before both competent authorities received the request for arbitration (or a copy thereof).
2. The person who submitted the request for arbitration may, either directly or through their representatives, present their position to the arbitrators in writing to the same extent as they may do in the course of the mutual agreement procedure. In addition, if all competent authorities and the arbitrators agree, the person may present their position orally during the arbitration proceedings.
3. Within 30 days after the chairperson informs the competent authorities of the need to hold a meeting of the arbitration panel, the competent authorities shall decide when and where that meeting will be held and shall communicate this information to the arbitrators.
4. The arbitrators shall decide the issues submitted to arbitration in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Convention and, subject to those provisions, the domestic laws of the Contracting States. The arbitrators shall also consider any other sources that the competent authorities of the Contracting States may expressly specify by mutual agreement.
5. Subject to the provisions of the Convention and this agreement, the arbitrators shall adopt such procedural and evidentiary rules as they consider necessary to decide the unresolved issues submitted to arbitration.
6. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the arbitration decision shall be transmitted in writing to the competent authorities of the Contracting States within 365 days after the date of appointment of the chairperson and shall contain references to the legal sources and arguments that led to its resolution. The arbitration decision shall be adopted by a simple majority of the arbitrators. The arbitration decision shall have no precedential value. With the consent of the person who submitted the request for arbitration and both competent authorities, the decision of the arbitration panel shall be made public in edited form, without identifying the names of the parties involved or any details that could reveal their identities, and with an indication that the decision has no formal precedential value.
6. Exchange of Information and Confidentiality
1. Solely for the purposes of applying the provisions of Articles 25 and 26 and the domestic laws of the Contracting States concerning the exchange and confidentiality of information relating to the case giving rise to the arbitration proceedings, each arbitrator and a maximum of three staff members per arbitrator (and potential arbitrators solely to the extent necessary to verify their ability to meet the requirements applicable to arbitrators) shall be designated as authorized representatives of the competent authority that appointed that arbitrator or, if that arbitrator was not appointed by a competent authority, of both competent authorities.
2. Upon designating a person as its authorized representative pursuant to paragraph 1, the competent authority of a Contracting State shall ensure that such person agrees in writing to treat any information relating to the arbitration proceedings in accordance with the confidentiality requirements of the Convention and the applicable laws of that Contracting State.
Paragraph 3
50. The first sentence of this paragraph invites and authorizes the competent authorities to resolve, where possible, difficulties of interpretation or application by mutual agreement. These are essentially difficulties of a general nature that concern or may concern a particular category of taxpayers, even if they have arisen in connection with an individual case that would normally fall under the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2.
51. This provision makes it possible to resolve difficulties arising in connection with the application of the Convention. Such difficulties include not only practical difficulties that may arise in connection with the establishment and implementation of procedures for granting exemption from tax withheld on dividends, interest and royalties in the Contracting State in which they arise, but also difficulties that may impair or hinder the normal operation of the provisions of the Convention as intended by the negotiators, the resolution of which does not depend on prior agreement regarding the interpretation of the Convention.
52. Under this provision, the competent authorities may, in particular:
— In the event of an incomplete or ambiguous definition of a term in the Convention, supplement or clarify its definition in order to eliminate any difficulties.
— Where the legislation of a State has been amended without prejudice to the balance or substance of the Convention, resolve any difficulties that may arise in connection with the new tax system resulting from such amendments.
— For the purpose of determining whether, and if so, under what conditions, interest may be treated as dividends under the thin capitalization rules in the borrower’s country and whether it qualifies for relief from double taxation in the creditor’s country of residence in the same manner as dividends (for example, exemption under the parent-subsidiary regime, where such exemption is provided for in the relevant bilateral Convention).
— For the purpose of concluding bilateral advance pricing agreements (APAs), as well as multilateral agreements with the competent authorities of third States with which each of the Contracting States has concluded a bilateral tax Convention, in cases where difficulties or doubts arise regarding the interpretation or application of the Conventions (particularly in cases where no action by the Contracting States could result in taxation that is not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention). A multilateral mutual agreement may be reached either by concluding a single agreement between all the competent authorities of the States concerned or by concluding separate but successive bilateral mutual agreements.
— Determine appropriate procedures, conditions and terms for the application of paragraphs 1 and 2, as well as the second sentence of this paragraph, to multilateral cases (see paragraphs 38.1–38.5 above and paragraphs 55–55.2 below) and to the participation of third States in the mutual agreement procedure where the resolution of a case may affect, or be affected by, taxation in third States.
53. Paragraph 3 confers upon the “competent authorities of the Contracting States”, that is, generally, the Ministers of Finance or their authorized representatives, who are usually responsible for the implementation of the Convention, the authority to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties arising in connection with the interpretation of the Convention. However, it is important not to overlook the fact that, depending on the domestic law of the Contracting States, other authorities (the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, courts) may have the authority to interpret international treaties and agreements, as well as the “competent authority” specified in the Convention, and that this may sometimes be the exclusive right of such other authorities.
54. Mutual agreements resolving general difficulties of interpretation or application are binding on the administrations until such time as the competent authorities agree to amend or revoke the mutual agreement.
55. The second sentence of paragraph 3 also allows the competent authorities to consider cases of double taxation that do not fall within the scope of the provisions of the Convention. Of particular interest in this regard is the case of a resident of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States. The second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to consult each other with a view to eliminating double taxation that may arise in respect of transactions between the permanent establishments. This may be the case, for example, where one or both Contracting States do not have a bilateral tax Convention with the third State. If both Contracting States have a Convention with the third State, however, the combination of these two Conventions may allow the competent authorities of all three States to resolve the case by mutual agreement under paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of Article 25 of those Conventions (see paragraphs 38.2 and 38.4 above). A multilateral agreement between the competent authorities of all the States involved is the best way to ensure that any double taxation is eliminated.
55.1 The domestic law of some Contracting States prevents the supplementation of the Convention with respect to matters that are not expressly or implicitly addressed in the Convention. In such cases, the Convention could be supplemented by a Protocol dealing with the matter in question. However, the second sentence of paragraph 3 does not allow the Contracting States to eliminate double taxation in cases where the granting of such relief would be contrary to their respective domestic laws or would not be permitted under the provisions of other applicable tax treaties. This sentence allows the Contracting States only, in cases not covered by the Convention, to consult each other with a view to eliminating double taxation in accordance with their respective domestic laws or in accordance with a tax treaty concluded by one of the Contracting States with a third State. Thus, for example, in the case of an enterprise of a third State having permanent establishments in both Contracting States, the second sentence of paragraph 3 allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to agree on the facts and circumstances of the case in order to ensure the consistent application of their respective domestic tax laws, particularly with respect to any transactions between those permanent establishments; however, the Contracting States may relieve any double taxation of the profits of those permanent establishments only to the extent permitted by their respective domestic laws or by the provisions of the Tax Treaty concluded between the Contracting State and that third State (i.e. Articles 7 and 23 of the Tax Treaty between the Contracting State and the third State). Thus, as these examples demonstrate, paragraph 3 plays a crucial role in ensuring that consultations with the competent authorities can be conducted to ensure the coordinated and effective operation of tax treaties.
55.2 Under the first sentence of paragraph 3, the competent authorities may agree, on a general basis, that they will endeavour to resolve a case presented under paragraph 1 with the competent authority of any third State in circumstances where taxation of income or capital in that third State may affect, or be affected by, the resolution of that case. Contracting States wishing to expressly provide for multilateral mutual agreement procedures may agree to use the following alternative wording of paragraph 2:
2. The competent authority shall endeavour, if the objection appears to it to be justified and if it is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State with a view to avoiding taxation which is not in accordance with the Convention. If the resolution of the case may affect, or be affected by, the taxation of income or capital in any third State, the competent authorities shall endeavour to resolve the case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of any such third State, provided that a tax Convention is in force between each of the Contracting States and that third State, and that the competent authority of that third State agrees, within the three-year period provided for in paragraph 1, to consult with the competent authorities of the Contracting States with a view to resolving the case by mutual agreement. In resolving the case, the competent authorities shall take into account the relevant provisions of this Convention together with the relevant provisions of the tax Conventions between the Contracting States and any third State participating in the procedure. Any agreement reached shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits imposed by the domestic laws of the Contracting States.
Paragraph 4
This paragraph determines how the competent authorities may conduct joint consultations for the purpose of resolving by mutual agreement either an individual case falling within the procedure provided for in paragraphs 1 and 2 or general issues concerning, in particular, the interpretation or application of the Convention referred to in paragraph 3.
57. First, it provides that the competent authorities may communicate directly with each other. Therefore, there is no need to transmit information through diplomatic channels.
58. The competent authorities may communicate with each other by means of letters, facsimile transmission, telephone conversations, direct meetings or any other convenient means. Such authorities may, if they so wish, formally establish a joint commission for this purpose.
59. As regards this joint commission, paragraph 4 leaves it to the competent authorities of the Contracting States to determine the number of members and the rules of procedure of this body.
60. However, although the Contracting States may avoid any formalities in this area, they are nevertheless required to provide taxpayers whose cases are being considered by a joint commission under paragraph 2 with certain essential guarantees, namely:
— The right to make written or oral representations, personally or through a representative;
— The right to legal assistance.
61. However, disclosure of the case documents to the taxpayer or their representatives does not appear appropriate in view of the special nature of the procedure.
62. Without prejudice to the freedom of choice which the competent authorities generally enjoy in appointing their representatives to the Joint Commission, it would be desirable for them to agree to entrust the chairmanship of each delegation, which may include one or more representatives of the service responsible for the procedure, to a senior official or a judge selected primarily on the basis of their particular expertise; it is reasonable to assume that the participation of such persons is likely to facilitate the reaching of an agreement.
Paragraph 5
63. This paragraph provides that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach an agreement under paragraph 2 within two years, the unresolved issues shall, at the written request of the person who presented the case, be resolved through arbitration. This process does not depend on the prior consent of the competent authorities: once the necessary procedural requirements have been met, the unresolved issues preventing the conclusion of a mutual agreement must be submitted to arbitration.
64. The arbitration process provided for in this paragraph is not an alternative or additional remedy: if the competent authorities have reached an agreement that leaves no unresolved issues concerning the application of the Convention, there are no unresolved issues that can be submitted to arbitration, even if the person who requested mutual agreement does not consider that the agreement reached by the competent authorities provides the correct resolution of the case. Thus, this paragraph extends the mutual agreement procedure, serving to enhance its effectiveness by ensuring that, where the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on one or more issues preventing the resolution of the case, the case may nevertheless still be resolved by submitting those issues to arbitration. Accordingly, under this paragraph, the resolution of the case continues to take place through mutual agreement, while the determination of a specific issue preventing agreement on the case is dealt with through arbitration. This distinguishes the process established in paragraph 5 from other forms of commercial or public-private arbitration, in which the jurisdiction of the arbitral panel extends to the resolution of the entire case.
65. Until 2017, the footnote to paragraph 5 stated that, in some States, domestic law, political or administrative considerations might not permit or justify the type of arbitration process provided for in this paragraph, and gave as an example constitutional barriers preventing arbitrators from deciding tax matters. However, the footnote was deleted in recognition of the importance of including an arbitration mechanism that ensures the resolution of disputes between competent authorities in cases where such disputes would otherwise prevent the mutual agreement procedure from fulfilling its function.
65.1 Paragraph 5 includes the essential conditions of the arbitration process. The last sentence of this paragraph expressly requires the competent authorities to agree on the manner in which this process is to be applied, and it is therefore expected that most procedural aspects of this process will be determined by agreement between the competent authorities (see paragraph 85 below and the model “mutual agreement on arbitration” included in the Annex). However, some States may prefer to include certain of these procedural aspects in the Convention itself. Although this makes the arbitration provision more complex, a State may consider that the importance of certain aspects (such as the rules concerning the appointment of arbitrators and the confidentiality of information communicated to them) is such that these matters should be addressed in the Convention itself. Part VI of the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (“Multilateral Instrument”), which was opened for signature on 31 December 2016, is a good example of a Convention that includes many procedural aspects of the arbitration process.
66. Some States may wish to include paragraph 5 but restrict its application to a narrower range of cases. For example, access to arbitration may be limited to cases involving issues that are primarily factual in nature. It could also be provided that arbitration is always available to consider issues arising in certain classes of cases, such as cases involving transfer pricing or the question of the existence of a permanent establishment, while extending arbitration to other issues on a case-by-case basis. States wishing to restrict the application of paragraph 5 should bear in mind that any substantial restriction on the scope of the Arbitration Provision may limit its effectiveness in ensuring the resolution of unresolved issues arising in a mutual agreement procedure case.
66.1 If paragraph 5 is included in a new Convention replacing the provisions of a previous Convention that included an arbitration provision, or to which Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument applies, the Contracting States should clarify whether paragraph 5 of the new Convention applies to cases involving provisions of that previous Convention. If it does not, the Contracting States should ensure that the arbitration provision of the previous Convention or Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument, as the case may be, continues to apply, so as to ensure arbitration of unresolved issues arising under the provisions of that previous Convention.
67. In addition, States that are members of the European Union may wish to coordinate the scope of paragraph 5 with their obligations under legal instruments applicable to those members. Such coordination should ensure the possibility of arbitration under such a legal instrument, even if paragraph 5 has a narrower scope. This could be done, for example, by including the following additional paragraph in Article 25:
Paragraph 5 shall not affect the fulfilment of broader obligations arising under any other legal instrument applicable to the Contracting States and relating to the arbitration of unresolved issues referred to in that paragraph.
Coordination should also ensure that unresolved issues falling within the scope of paragraph 5 are not subject to arbitration proceedings both under this paragraph and under any other legal instrument.
68. The taxpayer should be able to request arbitration of unresolved issues in all cases considered under the mutual agreement procedure that have been presented under paragraph 1 on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention. Where no mutual agreement procedure is available, for example, because of the existence of serious violations involving substantial penalties (see paragraph 26), it is clear that paragraph 5 does not apply.
69. If two Contracting States that have not included this paragraph in their Convention wish to implement an arbitration process for general application or for the consideration of a specific case, they may still do so by mutual agreement. In this case, the competent authorities may conclude a mutual agreement in accordance with the model wording provided in the Annex, to which they would add the following first paragraph:
1. The present agreement
a) whereas, in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 25 of the Convention, a person has presented a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted, for that person, in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention; and
b) whereas the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on the resolution of that case under paragraph 2 of this Article within two years from the date on which all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case has been provided to both competent authorities, any unresolved issues arising from the case shall be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the following paragraphs, if the person so requests in writing.
However, those unresolved issues shall not be submitted to arbitration if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of either State. If the person directly affected by the case does not agree to the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration decision, the competent authorities hereby agree to consider themselves bound by the arbitration decision and to resolve the case in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 25 on the basis of that decision.
This agreement will address the various structural and procedural issues discussed in the Annex. Although the competent authorities will thus be bound by such a process, the agreement is given as part of the mutual agreement procedure and therefore remains in effect only for as long as the competent authorities continue to agree to follow this process for resolving cases that they have been unable to resolve through the traditional mutual agreement procedure.
70. Paragraph 5 provides that a person who has presented a case to the competent authority of a Contracting State under paragraph 1 on the grounds that the actions of one or both Contracting States have resulted in that person being taxed not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention may request in writing that any unresolved issues arising in connection with that case be submitted to arbitration. This request may be submitted at any time after the expiry of the two-year period commencing on the date on which all information necessary for the competent authorities to consider the case has been provided to both competent authorities. Thus, referral to arbitration is not automatic; the person who presented the case may prefer to wait after the expiry of the two-year period (for example, to allow the competent authorities more time to resolve the case under paragraph 2) or simply not to pursue the case further.
70.1 States that consider the two-year period to be too short may amend this provision to allow an arbitration request to be submitted only after three years. In addition, States are entitled to provide that, in certain circumstances, a longer period of time will be required before a request may be submitted in a particular case. This could be done, for example, by allowing the competent authorities to agree, in each individual case, on a different period before the expiry of those two years; this could be achieved by formulating subparagraph b) as follows:
b) the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on the resolution of that case under paragraph 2 within two years from the date on which all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case has been provided to both competent authorities (unless, before the expiry of that period, the competent authorities of the Contracting States have agreed on a different period in respect of that case and have notified the person who presented the case of such agreement).
70.2 States may also wish to provide that this two-year period is suspended in cases where the mutual agreement procedure itself is suspended. This may occur, for example, where a mutual agreement procedure case concerns one or more issues that are also pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal and a Contracting State does not allow the taxpayer to pursue both the mutual agreement procedure and proceedings before a court or administrative tribunal simultaneously (see paragraph 76). It may also happen that one competent authority agrees with the person who presented the case to suspend the mutual agreement procedure (for example, because of serious illness or some other personal difficulties). To address such cases, the following provision could be added to paragraph 5:
If the competent authority has suspended the mutual agreement procedure referred to in paragraph 1 because the case concerning one or more of the same issues is pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the case pending before the court or Administrative Tribunal has been suspended or withdrawn. Furthermore, if the person who presented the case and the competent authority have agreed to suspend the mutual agreement procedure, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the suspension is lifted.
70.3 In some cases, after the taxpayer has provided the initial information necessary for the consideration of the merits of the case, the competent authorities may need to request additional information from the taxpayer. For example, after the period provided for in subparagraph b) has commenced and following further analysis of the case, a competent authority may determine that it requires additional information in order to reach agreement on how to resolve the issue. In such cases, the failure of the person directly affected by the case to provide such additional information in a timely manner may delay or prevent the competent authorities from resolving the issue. This issue may be addressed through the alternative wording of subparagraph b) proposed in paragraph 70.1 above, which allows the competent authorities to agree on different time limits in each individual case. Alternatively, it could be addressed in a mutual agreement that would regulate the manner in which the Arbitration Provision is applied, for example, by providing that the two-year period is extended if both competent authorities agree that the person directly affected by the case has failed to provide in a timely manner any additional material information requested by either competent authority after the commencement of the period provided for in subparagraph b) (see Article 7 of the model mutual agreement in the Annex; a similar provision could instead be added to the Convention itself if the alternative provision in paragraph 70.1 is not used).
71. Under paragraph 2 of Article 25, the competent authorities must endeavour to resolve the case presented under paragraph 1 with a view to avoiding taxation that is not in accordance with the Convention. Therefore, for the purposes of paragraph 5, a case should not be considered resolved as long as there remains at least one issue on which the competent authorities disagree and which, in the opinion of one of the competent authorities, indicates that taxation not in accordance with the Convention has occurred. Accordingly, one competent authority cannot unilaterally decide that such a case is closed and that the person concerned cannot request arbitration of the unresolved issues; similarly, the two competent authorities cannot consider the case to have been settled and refuse a request for arbitration if there are still unresolved issues preventing them from agreeing that no taxation contrary to the Convention has occurred. However, where both competent authorities agree that taxation by both States has been carried out in accordance with the Convention, there are no unresolved issues, and the case may be considered resolved, even where double taxation may exist that is not governed by the provisions of the Convention.
72. The arbitration process is available only in cases where the person considers that taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention has actually resulted from the actions of one or both Contracting States; however, it is not available in cases where it is alleged that such taxation will ultimately result from such actions, even though the latter cases may be presented to the competent authorities under paragraph 1 of this Article (see paragraph 70 above). For this purpose, taxation should be regarded as resulting from the actions of one or both Contracting States as soon as, for example, tax has been paid, assessed or otherwise determined, or even where the taxpayer has been formally notified by the tax authorities that they intend to tax a particular item of income.
73. In its current wording, paragraph 5 provides only for the arbitration of unresolved issues arising in connection with a request submitted under paragraph 1 of this Article. States wishing to extend the scope of this paragraph also to mutual agreement cases arising under paragraph 3 of this Article are free to do so. In some cases, a mutual agreement case may arise from other specific treaty provisions, such as subparagraph 2 d) of Article 4. Under that subparagraph, the competent authorities are required in certain cases to settle by mutual agreement the question of the status of an individual who is a resident of both Contracting States. As indicated in paragraph 20 of the Commentary on Article 4, such cases should be resolved in accordance with the procedure established in Article 25. If the competent authorities are unable to reach agreement on such a case and this results in taxation not in accordance with the Convention (under which the individual should be a resident of only one State for the purposes of the Convention), the taxpayer’s case falls within the scope of paragraph 1 of Article 25 and, consequently, paragraph 5 applies.
74. In some States, the competent authorities may depart from a court decision on a particular issue arising from a case presented to the competent authorities. Therefore, those States should be able to omit the second sentence of this paragraph and, if they wish to use the alternative provision in paragraph 70.2 above, amend it as follows:
If the competent authority has suspended the mutual agreement procedure referred to in paragraph 1 because the case concerning one or more of the same issues is pending before a court or Administrative Tribunal, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the case pending before the court or Administrative Tribunal has been suspended or withdrawn. Furthermore, if the person who presented the case and the competent authority have agreed to suspend the mutual agreement procedure, the period provided for in subparagraph b) shall cease to run until the suspension is lifted.
75. For the purposes of determining the commencement of the two-year period, all information required by the competent authorities for the consideration of the case shall be deemed to have been provided to both competent authorities only if sufficient information has been submitted to both competent authorities to enable them to determine whether the objection underlying the case is justified. A mutual agreement governing the manner in which paragraph 5 is to be applied should clarify the process to be used to determine this commencement date and should specify what type of information will generally be sufficient for this purpose. The model mutual agreement included in the Annex assumes a process similar to that used in Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument. States that consider that the rules for determining the commencement date of the two-year period should be included directly in the Convention may do so, for example, by including provisions similar to those in paragraphs 5–9 of Article 19 of the Multilateral Instrument.
76. This paragraph also addresses the relationship between the arbitration process and the rights to domestic remedies. In order for the arbitration process to be effective and to avoid the risk of conflicting decisions, a person should not be permitted to continue the arbitration process if the issues submitted to arbitration have already been decided in domestic judicial proceedings in either State (which means that a court or administrative tribunal of one of the Contracting States has already rendered a decision concerning those issues that is applicable to that person). This is consistent with the approach adopted by most countries with regard to the mutual agreement procedure, under which:
a) A person cannot use the mutual agreement procedure and domestic remedies simultaneously. Where domestic remedies are still available, the competent authorities generally either require the taxpayer to agree to suspend those remedies or, if the taxpayer does not agree, defer the mutual agreement procedure until those remedies have been exhausted.
b) Where the mutual agreement procedure is conducted first and a mutual agreement is reached, the taxpayer and other persons directly affected by the case are given the opportunity to reject the agreement and pursue the suspended domestic remedies; conversely, if those persons prefer the agreement to be implemented, they will have to waive the use of domestic remedies in respect of the issues covered by the agreement.
c) Where domestic remedies are first used and exhausted in one State, the person may use the mutual agreement procedure only to obtain relief from double taxation in the other State. Indeed, after a legal decision has been rendered in a particular case, most countries consider it impossible to overturn that decision through the mutual agreement procedure and would therefore limit any subsequent application of the mutual agreement procedure to attempts to obtain relief in the other State.
The same general principles should apply in the case of a mutual agreement procedure that includes one or more issues submitted to arbitration. Referral of a case to an arbitral tribunal is unreasonable if it is known in advance that one of the countries is constrained in its response to the arbitration decision. However, this would not be the case if a country were able to depart from a court decision within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure (see paragraph 74), in which case paragraph 5 could be adjusted accordingly.
77. The second issue concerns the relationship between existing domestic remedies and arbitration in cases where those remedies have not been exhausted. In this case, the approach most consistent with the basic structure of the mutual agreement procedure would be to apply the same general principles when it comes to arbitration. Thus, the exercise of remedies would be suspended until completion of the mutual agreement procedure, including arbitration of the issues that the competent authorities are unable to resolve, and a preliminary mutual agreement is reached on the basis of that decision. As in other cases involving the mutual agreement procedure, this agreement is then presented to the taxpayer, who must decide whether to accept the agreement, which would require waiving any remaining domestic remedies, or reject the agreement and pursue those remedies.
78. This approach is consistent with the nature of the arbitration process set out in paragraph 5. The purpose of this process is to enable the competent authorities to reach a conclusion on unresolved issues preventing an agreement. Where such an agreement is reached through arbitration, the substantive nature of the mutual agreement remains unchanged.
79. In some cases, this approach means that the parties will have to spend time and resources on an arbitration process that will result in a mutual agreement that is not accepted by the taxpayer. However, practical experience shows that there are very few cases in which the taxpayer refuses the mutual agreement in order to resort to domestic remedies. Furthermore, in these rare cases, it could be expected that the national courts or administrative tribunals would take note of the fact that the taxpayer had been offered an administrative resolution of their case that would have been binding on both States.
79.1 As noted in paragraph 76 a) above, most States do not allow a person to use the mutual agreement procedure and domestic remedies simultaneously. However, some States may allow a person to pursue both the mutual agreement procedure and proceedings before a court or administrative tribunal simultaneously in respect of the same issues; in those States, there is a possibility that a decision on the issue or issues submitted to arbitration may be rendered by a court or administrative tribunal after the arbitration request has been submitted but before the arbitral panel has rendered its decision. Such States may wish to expressly provide that the arbitration process shall be terminated in such circumstances in order to avoid difficulties that may subsequently arise in implementing the mutual agreement giving effect to the subsequent arbitration decision (see paragraph 76 above). For this purpose, the following wording could be added to paragraph 5:
If, at any time after a request for arbitration has been submitted and before the arbitral panel has rendered its decision to the competent authorities of the Contracting States, a decision on the matter is rendered by a court or administrative tribunal of one of the Contracting States, the arbitration process shall be terminated.
80. In some States, unresolved issues between the competent authorities may be submitted to arbitration only if domestic remedies are no longer available. In order to implement the arbitration approach, these States could consider an alternative approach requiring the person to waive the right to use domestic remedies before arbitration can take place. This could be done by replacing the second sentence of the paragraph with the following:
“however, those unresolved issues shall not be submitted to arbitration if any person directly affected by the case still has the right under the domestic law of either State to request the courts or administrative tribunals of that State to decide those issues or if a decision on those issues has already been rendered by such a court or administrative tribunal”.
In order to avoid a situation in which the taxpayer must waive domestic remedies without any guarantees regarding the outcome of the case, it would then also be important to amend this paragraph to include a mechanism that would guarantee, for example, that double taxation is actually relieved. Furthermore, since the taxpayer would then be waiving the right to be heard by the national courts, this paragraph should also be amended to ensure that the taxpayer is provided with sufficient legal safeguards regarding their participation in the arbitration process to satisfy any requirements that may exist under domestic law for such a waiver to be acceptable within the applicable legal system (for example, in some countries such a waiver may be ineffective if the person is not guaranteed the right to be heard orally during the arbitration proceedings).
7. Suspension of the Time Limit in the Event of Failure to Provide Information in a Timely Manner
If both competent authorities agree that the person directly affected by the case has failed to provide, in a timely manner, any additional material information requested by either competent authority after the commencement date of the two-year period referred to in paragraph 1 of Article 2, the period provided for in that paragraph shall be extended by a period equal to the period beginning on the date of the request for information and ending on the date on which that information is provided.
8. Costs
Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise:
a) each competent authority and the person who requested arbitration shall bear the costs associated with its own participation in the arbitration proceedings (including travel expenses and expenses relating to the preparation and presentation of its submissions);
b) each competent authority shall bear the remuneration of the arbitrator appointed exclusively by that competent authority or appointed by the senior official of the Centre for Tax Policy and Administration of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development who is not a national of either Contracting State because that competent authority failed to appoint that arbitrator, as well as that arbitrator's travel expenses, communication expenses and administrative expenses;
c) the remuneration of the chair of the arbitration panel, as well as the travel, telecommunications and administrative expenses of that chair, shall be borne equally by the two competent authorities;
d) any other expenses relating to a meeting of the arbitration panel shall be borne by the competent authority hosting that meeting; and
e) any other expenses relating to costs that both competent authorities have agreed to incur shall be borne equally by the two competent authorities.
9. Failure to Communicate the Decision Within the Prescribed Time Limit
If the decision has not been communicated to the competent authorities within the period provided for in paragraph 5 of Article 4 or paragraph 6 of Article 5, as the case may be, or within any other period agreed upon by the competent authorities, the competent authorities may agree to appoint new arbitrators in accordance with Article 3. For the purposes of the subsequent application of Article 3, the date of conclusion of such an agreement shall be deemed to be the date on which the request for arbitration was received by both competent authorities.
10. If the Arbitration Decision Is Not to Be Delivered
If, at any time after the submission of a request for arbitration and before the arbitrators deliver their decision to the competent authorities, the competent authorities notify the arbitrators in writing:
a) that the issues submitted for arbitration have been finally resolved; or
b) that the person who submitted the case has withdrawn the request for arbitration or the request for the mutual agreement procedure;
then no arbitration decision shall be delivered, and the mutual agreement procedure shall be deemed to have been completed.
11. Final Decision
The arbitration decision shall be final unless it is found by a court of one of the Contracting States to be invalid by reason of a violation of paragraph 5 of Article 25 or for any other reason. If the decision is found to be invalid and cannot take effect, the request for arbitration shall be deemed not to have been submitted, and the arbitration proceedings shall be deemed not to have taken place (except for the purposes of Articles 6 "Exchange of Information and Confidentiality" and 8 "Costs").
12. Implementation of the Arbitration Decision
The competent authorities shall implement the arbitration decision within 180 days after its communication to them by reaching a mutual agreement on the case that gave rise to the arbitration proceedings.
This Agreement shall apply to any request for arbitration submitted pursuant to paragraph 5 of Article 25 of the Convention after the entry into force of that provision.
[Date of signature of the Agreement]
[Signature of the competent authority of each Contracting State]
General Approach to Drafting the Model Agreement
2. There are two main approaches that may be followed in developing an arbitration process to be used in addition to the mutual agreement procedure. Under one approach, known as the "last best offer" or "final offer" approach, each competent authority would be required to submit to the arbitration panel its proposed resolution of the issue in question, and the arbitration panel would choose between the two proposals submitted to it. Alternatively, under an approach that could be called the "independent opinion" approach, the arbitrators would be presented with the facts and arguments of the parties, based on the applicable law, and would then make their own independent decision based on a written, reasoned analysis of the relevant facts and applicable legal sources.
3. Each of these two approaches has its advantages and disadvantages, and the choice of approach depends on a number of policy considerations that are often specific to each State. In addition, it is clear that there are a number of variations of these two approaches. For example, the arbitrators could issue an independent decision without being required to provide a written decision, but merely their conclusions. To some extent, the appropriate method may also depend on the type of issue to be decided.
4. The Agreement set out above takes the "last best offer" approach as its starting point, which is therefore the generally applicable procedure, but, recognising the fact that in some cases, particularly those involving complex legal issues, the competent authorities may prefer to obtain a more detailed decision, it also provides for an alternative "independent opinion" procedure. Accordingly, the competent authorities may agree to use this independent opinion procedure on a case-by-case basis. The competent authorities may, of course, adopt this combined approach, adopt the independent opinion approach as the generally applicable procedure with the last best offer approach as an option, or limit themselves to only one of the two approaches.
Request for Arbitration
5. Article 1 of the Model Agreement provides for the procedure for submitting a request for arbitration. Such a request must be submitted in writing to one of the competent authorities involved in the case. That competent authority must then inform the other competent authority within 10 days of receiving the request.
6. In order to establish that the conditions of paragraph 5 of Article 25 have been met (see paragraph 76 of the Commentary on this Article), the request must be accompanied by statements indicating that no decisions on these issues have yet been rendered by national courts or administrative tribunals in either of the Contracting States.
7. Since the arbitration process is a continuation of the mutual agreement procedure, intended to deal with cases that cannot be resolved under that procedure, it does not seem appropriate to require the person requesting arbitration to pay a fee for submitting such a request or to reimburse the costs incurred by the competent authorities in the course of the arbitration proceedings. Unlike taxpayer requests for rulings or other types of advance agreements, for which a fee is sometimes charged, ensuring the resolution of disputes between Contracting States is the responsibility of those States, which should generally bear the costs.
Commencement Date of the Two-Year Period
8. A request for arbitration may be submitted only after the expiry of two years from the date on which both competent authorities have been provided with all the information necessary for the competent authorities to consider the case (hereinafter referred to as the "Commencement Date"). Paragraph 1 of Article 2 of the Model Agreement refers to the information required for this purpose. This paragraph should include a list of the information required by the competent authorities; in general, this information will correspond to the information and documents that were necessary to commence consideration of the case. The published guidance of a Contracting State will usually specify the information that will be required for this purpose. In such cases, it is assumed that the competent authorities will generally mutually agree to list or otherwise identify the information included in that guidance as the information that will be required by each Contracting State.
9. Paragraph 2 of the drafting of Article 2 describes the procedures to be followed in order to determine the exact date on which the two-year period begins.
10. Subparagraph a) provides that the competent authority that received the initial request for the mutual agreement procedure must, within 60 days of receiving that request, notify the person who submitted the case that the request has been received and forward a notification of the request, together with a copy of the request, to the other competent authority.
11. Under subparagraph b), the competent authority must notify the person who submitted the case and the other competent authority that it has received all the information necessary to consider the case on its merits, or request additional information for that purpose from the person who submitted the case, within 90 days of the date on which it received the initial request or notification of the request, as the case may be.
12. Where one or both competent authorities request additional information, subparagraph c) provides that, after receiving such information, the competent authority requesting the information shall have 90 days to notify the person submitting the case and the other competent authority that it has received all the necessary information or that the requested information is still missing.
13. The commencement date of the two-year period depends on whether such additional information has been requested. Where no request for additional information has been made, subparagraph d) provides that the commencement date shall be the earlier of: i) the date on which both competent authorities notified the person who submitted the case that all the necessary information had been received (i.e. the date on which the second of the two competent authorities gave such notification); and ii) 90 days after the date on which the competent authority to which the request for the mutual agreement procedure was initially submitted notified the other competent authority of that request.
14. Where additional information has been requested, subparagraph e) provides that, in general, the commencement date shall be the earlier of: i) the latest date on which the competent authorities that requested the additional information notified the taxpayer and the other competent authority that such information had been received; and ii) the date that is 90 days after both competent authorities have received the additional information from the person who submitted the case. If any competent authority notifies the taxpayer and the other competent authority that some of the requested information is still missing, such notification shall be treated as a request for additional information.
15. In some cases, after the taxpayer has provided the initial information necessary for consideration of the case on its merits, the competent authorities may need to request additional information from the taxpayer. In such cases, the failure of the person directly affected by the case (i.e. the person who submitted the initial request for the mutual agreement procedure or the person whose tax liability is directly affected by the case) to provide such additional information in a timely manner may delay or prevent the competent authorities from resolving the case. To address such cases, Article 7 of the Model Agreement provides that the two-year period shall be extended if both competent authorities agree that the person directly affected by the case has failed to provide, in a timely manner, any additional material information requested by either competent authority after the commencement of that period. In such a case, that period shall be extended by a period equal to the period beginning on the date of the request for information and ending on the date on which that information is finally provided.
Scope
15.1 Although the Model Agreement does not expressly contain provisions for adopting a "scope" as the first step of the arbitration process, the competent authorities may consider it appropriate to include such provisions in the mutual agreement implementing the arbitration process. These provisions could be formulated as follows:
Scope
1. Within 60 days after both competent authorities have received the request for arbitration (or a copy thereof), the competent authorities shall agree on the issues to be resolved by the arbitration panel and communicate them in writing to the person who requested arbitration. This shall constitute the "scope" for that case. Notwithstanding the following paragraphs of this Agreement, the competent authorities may also provide in the terms of reference for procedural rules that are additional to or different from those included in these paragraphs and that concern such other matters as may be considered appropriate.
2. If the terms of reference have not been communicated to the person who requested arbitration within the period specified in paragraph 1 above, that person and each competent authority may, within 30 days after the expiry of that period, communicate to each other in writing a list of the issues to be resolved by arbitration. All lists communicated in this manner during that period shall constitute the preliminary terms of reference. Within 30 days after all the arbitrators have been appointed, as provided for in the following paragraphs of this Agreement, the chair shall send the competent authorities and the person who requested arbitration a revised version of the preliminary terms of reference based on the lists submitted in this manner. Within 30 days after both competent authorities have received the revised version, they shall have the opportunity to agree on different terms of reference and communicate them in writing to the arbitrators and the person who requested arbitration. If they do so within the specified period, those different terms shall constitute the terms of reference for that case. If, during that period, the competent authorities have not agreed on different terms of reference and communicated them in writing, the revised version of the preliminary terms of reference prepared by the arbitrators shall constitute the terms of reference for that case.
15.2 If such provisions are included in the Agreement, it will be necessary to extend the period within which each competent authority is required to appoint an arbitrator under Article 3 of the Model Mutual Agreement. This period could, for example, be extended to 90 days, which would allow the competent authorities to take the agreed terms of reference into account when selecting their respective arbitrators.
15.3 The "scope" would be a document setting out the issues to be resolved by the arbitrators. It would establish the jurisdictional basis for the issues to be decided by the arbitration panel. It would be established by the competent authorities, which may wish to consult the person who requested arbitration in this regard. If the competent authorities are unable to agree on the terms of reference within the period provided for in proposed paragraph 1 above, a mechanism will be required to ensure that the procedure can continue. Proposed paragraph 2 above provides for such a possibility.
15.4 Although the terms of reference will generally be limited to a specific issue or set of issues, the competent authorities may, having regard to the nature of the case and the interconnected nature of the issues, develop the terms of reference in such a way that the entire case (rather than only certain specific issues) is submitted to arbitration.
15.5 As indicated in proposed paragraph 1 above, the procedural rules provided for in the Model Agreement shall apply unless the competent authorities provide otherwise in the terms of reference. Accordingly, the competent authorities could, in accordance with the terms of reference, depart from any of these rules (including, for example, the rules on the appointment and remuneration of arbitrators) or provide for additional rules in a particular case.
Selection and Appointment of Arbitrators
16. Article 3 of the Model Agreement describes the procedure for selecting arbitrators. As a general rule, each of the two competent authorities appoints one arbitrator. These appointments must be made within 60 days after both competent authorities have received the request for arbitration. The arbitrators appointed in this manner shall select the chair, who must be appointed within 60 days after the date of the last of the initial appointments. If the competent authorities fail to appoint an arbitrator within the required period, or if the arbitrators appointed in this manner fail to appoint the third arbitrator within the required period, the paragraph provides that the appointment shall be made by the senior official of the Centre for Tax Policy and Administration of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development who is not a national of either Contracting State. The competent authorities may, of course, provide for other ways of resolving these rare situations, but it seems important to provide for an independent competent authority to resolve any deadlock in the selection of arbitrators.
17. Paragraph 1 of Article 3 provides for the requirements that each arbitrator must satisfy. Arbitrators must have expertise or experience in international tax matters; however, unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, there is no requirement that each arbitrator have experience as a judge or arbitrator. In addition, at the time of accepting his or her appointment, each arbitrator must be impartial and independent of the competent authorities, tax administrations and ministries of finance (or the corresponding equivalent ministries or departments, regardless of their designation) of the Contracting States, as well as of all persons directly affected by the case and their advisers. Each arbitrator must also maintain his or her impartiality and independence throughout the proceedings and must, for a reasonable period of time thereafter, avoid conduct that may undermine the appearance of impartiality and independence of the arbitrators in relation to the proceedings. Such conduct would include, for example, accepting employment with one of the persons directly affected by the case shortly after the arbitration decision has been rendered in that case. The competent authorities are free to agree on additional details regarding the applicable standards of impartiality and independence. For example, the competent authorities may wish to require any prospective arbitrator to disclose to the competent authorities any fact or circumstance that may call into question the impartiality or independence of that prospective arbitrator. The competent authorities may also wish to agree on rules governing a situation in which an arbitrator is unable to perform his or her duties as a result of illness or incapacity, failure to comply with the standards of impartiality and independence, or for any other reason.
18. Paragraph 4 of Article 3 clarifies when an arbitrator is deemed to have been appointed, which is relevant for the purposes of other provisions referring to the date of appointment of one or more arbitrators. An appointment shall be deemed to have been made when a letter confirming the appointment, signed by both the arbitrator and the person or persons authorised to appoint that arbitrator under paragraphs 2 and 3 of this Article, has been sent to both competent authorities.
Arbitration Process
19. Article 4 provides for the rules that shall apply to the arbitration process unless, within 60 days after the appointment of the chair of the arbitration panel, the competent authorities agree to use the optional approach under Article 5 in respect of the case concerned.
20. As indicated in paragraph 4 above, the arbitration process proposed in the Model Agreement follows the "last best offer" approach. Paragraph 1 of this Article provides that the first step in this process is for the competent authority of each Contracting State to submit to each arbitrator, within 60 days after the appointment of the chair (or within any other period agreed upon by the competent authorities before the expiry of that 60-day period), a proposed resolution addressing all unresolved issues in the case in a manner consistent with any previous agreements reached by the competent authorities in that case. For each adjustment or similar issue in the case, the proposed resolution shall include only the determination of specific monetary amounts (for example, income) or the maximum amount of tax that may be levied under the provisions of the Convention. In some cases, however, the unresolved issues will include questions as to whether the conditions for the application of a particular provision of the Convention have been satisfied. If the unresolved issues in a case include such a "threshold question", such as whether a person is a resident of a Contracting State or whether an enterprise of a Contracting State has a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, the competent authorities may submit their proposed answers to the threshold question (i.e. Yes or No). If there are other unresolved issues whose resolution depends on the answer to the threshold question, the competent authorities are also expected to submit alternative proposed resolutions of those remaining issues.
21. As explained in paragraph 2 of this Article, the proposed resolutions submitted by the competent authorities of each Contracting State may be supported by a position paper, which must be submitted within the same period.
22. Paragraph 3 provides that each competent authority may also submit, within 120 days after the appointment of the chair, a response to the proposed resolution and supporting position paper submitted by the other competent authority. The response submission and accompanying position paper are intended solely to address the positions and arguments of the other competent authority and are not intended to give the competent authority an opportunity to put forward additional arguments in support of its own position.
23. Given the nature of the "last best offer" process, an in-person meeting of the arbitrators will generally not be necessary, and the arbitrators will be able to communicate with one another and with both competent authorities by telephone or videoconference. This is provided for in paragraph 4, which adds that, if an in-person meeting involving additional costs is necessary, the chair shall first contact the competent authorities, which shall then decide when and where that meeting should be held.
24. Paragraph 5 provides that the arbitration panel shall select as its decision one of the proposed resolutions submitted by the competent authorities. In a case involving one or more threshold questions, the arbitration panel shall decide the threshold questions and then adopt one of the alternative proposed resolutions submitted by the competent authorities. The decision shall be made by a simple majority of the arbitrators and shall contain no reasons or explanations. In view of the objective of arbitration as a simplified method of resolving disputes between competent authorities, the decision shall be issued in writing to the competent authorities and may not be used as a precedent in relation to any other cases. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the arbitration decision shall be delivered within 60 days after the arbitrators receive the last response submission or, if no response submission has been made, within 150 days after the appointment of the chair.
Optional Arbitration Process
- Article 5 establishes rules for the “independent opinion” procedure which, in accordance with the Model Agreement, the competent authorities may use in each particular case. These elections must be made within 60 days after the appointment of the chair of the arbitration panel.
- Paragraph 1 of this Article provides that, if the competent authorities have made such elections, each competent authority must submit to the arbitration panel and to the other competent authority, within 120 days after these elections, any information that it considers necessary for the panel to reach its decision. This information is expected to include a description of the facts and issues to be decided, the position of the competent authority on those issues, and the arguments supporting that position. Unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the arbitration panel may not take into account any information that was not available to both competent authorities before both competent authorities received the request for arbitration (or a copy thereof).
- It is expected that one or more meetings of the arbitration panel and both competent authorities will be required to discuss the case. Paragraph 3 provides that the competent authorities shall decide when and where each such meeting will be held within 30 days after the chair of the arbitration panel has informed them of the need for such a meeting.
- Paragraph 2 provides that the person requesting arbitration, either directly or through their representatives, has the right to submit a written presentation of their position to the arbitrators to the same extent as that person may submit such a presentation during the mutual agreement procedure and, if all the competent authorities and the arbitrators agree, to make an oral presentation during a meeting of the arbitrators. Thus, the participation in the arbitration process of the person who requested arbitration depends on what the competent authorities agree upon within the framework of the mutual agreement procedure and during the arbitration process.
- The simplest way to establish procedural rules governing the “independent opinion” arbitration process that have not yet been agreed upon by the competent authorities is to allow the arbitrators to develop such rules on an ad hoc basis. In doing so, the arbitrators may freely refer to existing arbitration procedures. The procedural rules should specify that, unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the factual material on which the arbitration panel will base its decision shall be developed through the mutual agreement procedure (see the last sentence of paragraph 1 of this Article). Paragraph 5 of this Article follows this approach. Thus, decisions regarding the format of arbitration hearings will be made by the arbitrators, unless the competent authorities agree otherwise.
- In accordance with paragraph 4 of this Article, the arbitrators shall decide the questions submitted to arbitration in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Convention and, subject to those provisions, the domestic laws of the Contracting States. In this regard, the arbitration panel will consider the application of domestic law only to the extent necessary to determine whether a Contracting State is correctly applying the provisions of the Convention.
- As indicated in paragraph 4, the competent authorities may also, by mutual agreement, determine other sources of law or authorities to be considered by the arbitration panel. Issues on which the competent authorities experience difficulties in reaching agreement often include questions of treaty interpretation or questions relating to the application of the arm’s length principle underlying Article 9 and paragraph 2 of Article 7. Therefore, the competent authorities may wish to provide that questions of treaty interpretation should be decided by the arbitrators in the light of the principles of interpretation contained in Articles 31–33 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, taking into account the Commentary on the OECD Model Tax Convention, as periodically amended, as explained in paragraphs 28–36.1 of the Introduction. They could also provide that questions relating to the application of the arm’s length principle should similarly be decided in the light of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations. Since Article 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties permits broad recourse to supplementary means of interpretation, arbitrators will, in practice, have considerable discretion in determining the appropriate sources for interpreting treaty provisions. In addition, there may be cases where the competent authorities agree that the interpretation or application of a provision of a Tax Treaty depends on a particular document (for example, a memorandum of understanding or a mutual agreement concluded after the entry into force of the treaty), but may disagree on the interpretation of that document. In such a case, the competent authorities may wish to make an express reference to that document.
- Paragraph 6 of this Article provides that, unless the competent authorities agree otherwise, the decision of the arbitration panel shall be delivered to the competent authorities in writing within 365 days after the date of appointment of the chair. The decision will identify the sources of law relied upon and the reasoning that led to its outcome. It will also generally include a description of the relevant facts and circumstances of the case, a clear statement of the positions of both competent authorities, and a brief summary of the proceedings. The arbitration decision shall be adopted by a simple majority of the arbitrators. As with the “last best offer” approach, the decision will have no precedential value, but paragraph 6 provides for the possibility of publication of the decision. However, such publication should take place only if both the competent authorities and the person who submitted the request for arbitration agree to it. Furthermore, in order to preserve the confidentiality of the information communicated to the competent authorities, publication must be made in a form that does not disclose the names of the parties or any elements that could help identify them. Decisions in individual cases reached under the mutual agreement procedure are generally not made public, but in the case of reasoned arbitration decisions, publication of such decisions will provide additional transparency to the process. Moreover, although such a decision would in no way constitute a formal precedent, the availability of the material in the public domain could influence the conduct of other cases, helping to avoid subsequent disputes and leading to a more uniform approach to the same issue.
Transmission of Information and Confidentiality
- It is important that the arbitrators be given full access to the information necessary to decide the issues submitted to arbitration, while at the same time that this information be subject to the same strict confidentiality requirements as those applicable to the competent authorities themselves. The proposed approach to achieving this result, which is set out in Article 6 of the Model Agreement, is to make the arbitrators authorized representatives of the competent authorities. However, this will be done solely for the purposes of applying the relevant provisions of the Convention (for example, Articles 25 and 26) and the provisions of the domestic laws of the Contracting States, which generally include penalties applicable in cases of breach of confidentiality.
Suspension of the Time Limit in the Case of Untimely Provision of Information
- As indicated in paragraph 15 above, Article 7 of the Model Agreement provides that the two-year period referred to in paragraph 1 of Article 2 may be extended if both competent authorities agree that the person directly affected by the case has failed to provide, in a timely manner, any additional material information requested by either competent authority after the commencement of that two-year period. In such a case, the approach adopted in the Model Agreement is to extend that two-year period by a period equal to the period beginning on the date of the request for information and ending on the date on which that information is provided. However, in cases where the competent authorities are not provided with the information necessary to resolve a particular case, nothing prevents them from resolving the case on the basis of the limited information available to them, thereby preventing any access to arbitration. Furthermore, the agreement could provide that if, within an additional period (for example, one year), the taxpayer still has not provided the additional material information requested by either competent authority, the issue will no longer be eligible for referral to arbitration.
Costs
- Various costs may arise in connection with the arbitration process, and it should be clear who is to bear those costs. Article 8 of the Model Agreement, which deals with this issue, is based on the principle that where a competent authority or a person involved in the case can control the amount of a particular cost, that cost should be borne by that party, while other costs should be borne equally by the two competent authorities.
- Accordingly, it seems logical to provide that each competent authority, as well as the person requesting arbitration, should bear the costs of its own participation in the arbitration proceedings. This will include the costs of representation at meetings, as well as the preparation and submission of the position and arguments, whether in writing or orally. This is provided for in subparagraph (a).
- The fees payable to the arbitrators will probably constitute one of the major costs of the arbitration process. As indicated in subparagraph (b), each competent authority shall bear the remuneration of the arbitrator appointed exclusively by that competent authority (or appointed by the senior official of the OECD Centre for Tax Policy and Administration because that competent authority failed to appoint such an arbitrator), as well as that arbitrator’s travel, telecommunications and administrative expenses.
- However, subparagraph (c) provides that the fees and travel, telecommunications and administrative expenses of the chair of the arbitration panel shall be borne equally by the competent authorities. The competent authorities will normally agree to assume these costs at the time of appointing the arbitrators, and this is generally confirmed in the letter of appointment. The fees should be sufficiently high to enable specialists with the appropriate qualifications to be engaged.
- The competent authorities may also wish to include in the agreement a schedule of fees payable to the arbitrators. They are free to agree on the establishment of such fees in a manner that reflects the particular circumstances of the Contracting States, their special relationship and the type of arbitration process. The competent authorities have used various fee schedules as resources for this purpose, including the fee schedule established by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes and the fee schedule provided for in the revised Code of Conduct for Arbitration under the EU Convention. The agreement may also limit the number of trips and the number of days for which the arbitrators will be compensated.
- The costs associated with any meeting of the arbitration panel, including the costs of administrative staff required to prepare and conduct that meeting, as well as the costs associated with the use of facilities for holding meetings, shall be borne by the competent authority hosting that meeting. In most cases, that competent authority will use meeting facilities and staff already at its disposal, and it does not seem appropriate to attempt to transfer part of these costs to the other competent authority. Clearly, the reference to “costs associated with meetings” does not include travel and accommodation expenses incurred by participants; these are addressed above.
- Other costs (excluding any costs associated with the participation of taxpayers in the process) shall be borne equally by the two competent authorities, provided that they have agreed to incur the relevant costs. This would include, for example, translation and registration costs that both competent authorities have agreed to provide. It would also include the costs of holding a meeting of the arbitration panel agreed upon by both competent authorities but not organized by either of them. In the absence of an agreement between the competent authorities, the party requesting that particular costs be incurred shall pay them.
- As indicated at the beginning of Article 8, the competent authorities may, however, depart from these Rules and agree on a different allocation of costs in respect of a particular case or particular costs.
Failure to Communicate the Decision Within the Prescribed Time Limit
- To address unusual circumstances in which the arbitrators may be unable or unwilling to deliver an arbitration decision, Article 9 provides that if the decision is not communicated within the period specified in paragraph 5 of Article 4 or paragraph 6 of Article 5, or within any other period agreed upon by the competent authorities, the competent authorities may agree to appoint new arbitrators to consider the case. In such a case, the date of that agreement between the competent authorities shall, for the purposes of the process described in Articles 4 and 5, be treated as the date of the request for arbitration.
Failure to Deliver an Arbitration Decision
- Article 10 of the Model Agreement primarily addresses the situation in which the competent authorities may resolve the unresolved issues that led to the arbitration proceedings before a decision is rendered. Since the arbitration process is an exceptional mechanism for resolving issues that cannot be resolved under the ordinary mutual agreement procedure, it is appropriate to terminate this exceptional mechanism if the competent authorities are able to resolve those issues themselves. The competent authorities may agree to resolve these issues at any time before the arbitration decision is rendered. Article 10 also provides that the arbitration process and the mutual agreement procedure shall automatically terminate if, before the decision is rendered, the person who submitted the case withdraws either their request for arbitration or their request for the mutual agreement procedure.
Final Decision
- Article 11 addresses the situation in which an arbitration decision is found by the courts of one of the Contracting States to have no legal force as a result of a breach of paragraph 5 of Article 25 or for any other reason. The decision cannot take effect, the request for arbitration shall be deemed not to have been submitted, and the arbitration process shall be deemed not to have taken place (except for the purposes of Articles 6, “Transmission of Information and Confidentiality”, and 8, “Costs”). In this case, the taxpayer may immediately submit a new request for arbitration, since the two-year period for submitting such a request has already expired. However, the competent authorities may also provide that such a request shall not be allowed in certain cases, for example, where the taxpayer’s actions were the main reason why the arbitration decision was invalidated.
- Article 11 is not intended to provide independent grounds for invalidating an arbitration decision where such grounds do not exist under the domestic laws of the Contracting States. Instead, it is intended to ensure that, where a court of one of the Contracting States invalidates an arbitration decision on the basis of such existing rules, the other Contracting State is not required to implement that decision. This may occur under the domestic laws of certain States, for example, where there has been a procedural violation (such as a breach of the requirements of impartiality or independence applicable to arbitrators) that has materially affected the outcome of the arbitration process. However, since the arbitration decision is final, it is not expected that a court will invalidate an arbitration decision merely because it disagrees with the outcome of the arbitration process.
Restore the source formatting exactlyPreserve all original paragraph spacing
Implementation of the Decision Reached
47. Once the arbitration process has provided a binding resolution of the issues that the competent authorities have been unable to resolve, the competent authorities will proceed to conclude a mutual agreement reflecting that decision, which will be presented to the persons directly affected by the case. In order to avoid further delays, it is suggested that the mutual agreement incorporating the decision reached should be finalised and presented to the taxpayer within 180 days after the date on which the decision is communicated. This is provided for in Article 12 of the Model Agreement.
48. Paragraph 2 of Article 25 provides that the competent authorities are required to implement any agreement reached, notwithstanding any time limits provided for under their domestic laws. Paragraph 5 of the Article also provides that the arbitration decision shall be binding on both Contracting States. Thus, a failure to assess taxpayers in accordance with the agreement or to implement the arbitration decision by concluding a mutual agreement will result in taxation not in accordance with the Convention and, as such, will allow the person whose taxation is affected to seek remedies under domestic law or to submit a new request under paragraph 1 of this Article.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 26 CONCERNING THE EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION
Preliminary remarks
1. There are good reasons for including provisions concerning co-operation between the tax administrations of the two Contracting States in the Convention for the avoidance of double taxation. First, it seems desirable to provide administrative assistance for the purpose of ascertaining facts to which the rules of the Convention are to be applied. Moreover, in view of the increasing internationalisation of economic relations, Contracting States have an increasingly strong interest in the reciprocal provision of information on the basis of which domestic tax laws are to be administered, even where no specific Article of the Convention is involved.
2. Thus, this Article contains rules under which information may be exchanged to the widest possible extent, with a view to establishing an appropriate basis for the administration of the domestic tax laws of the Contracting States and the application of specific provisions of the Convention. The text of the Article makes it clear that the exchange of information is not restricted by Articles 1 and 2, so that the information may include information about non-residents and may relate to the administration or enforcement of taxes not referred to in Article 2.
3. The question of administrative assistance for the collection of taxes is dealt with in Article 27, but the exchange of information for collection purposes is governed by Article 26 (see paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 27). Similarly, mutual agreement procedures are dealt with in Article 25, but the exchange of information for the purposes of a mutual agreement procedure is governed by Article 26 (see paragraph 4 of the Commentary on Article 25).
4. In 2002, the Committee on Fiscal Affairs undertook a comprehensive review of Article 26 to ensure that it reflected current country practices. This review also took into account recent developments, such as the Model Agreement on Exchange of Information on Tax Matters developed by the OECD Global Forum Working Group on Effective Exchange of Information and the ideal standard for access to bank information described in the report “Improving Access to Bank Information for Tax Purposes”¹. As a result, a number of changes were made to both the text of the Article and the Commentary in 2005.
4.1 Many of the changes subsequently made to the Article were not intended to alter its substance, but were made to remove doubts as to its proper interpretation. For example, the change from “necessary” to “foreseeably relevant” and the inclusion in paragraph 1 of the words “for the administration or enforcement” were made to achieve consistency with the Model Agreement on Exchange of Information on Tax Matters and were not intended to change the operation of this provision. Paragraph 4 was added to incorporate into the text of the Article a general understanding previously expressed in the Commentary (see paragraph 19.6). Paragraph 5 was added to reflect the practice of the vast majority of OECD member countries (see paragraph 19.10). On the other hand, the inclusion in paragraph 2 of the words “or the oversight of the foregoing” represents a reversal of the previous rule.
4.2 The Commentary was also substantially expanded. This expansion partly reflects the addition of paragraphs 4 and 5 to this Article. Other changes were also made to the Commentary to take account of developments and country practices and, more generally, to remove doubts as to the proper interpretation of this Article.
¹ OECD, Paris, 2000.
4.3 This Article and the Commentary were further amended in 2012 to take account of recent developments and to further elaborate on the interpretation of certain provisions of this Article. Paragraph 2 of this Article was amended to allow competent authorities to use the information received for other purposes, provided that such use is permitted under the laws of both States and the competent authority of the supplying State authorises such use. Previously, this provision had been included as an optional provision in paragraph 12.3 of the Commentary.
4.4 The Commentary was expanded to interpret the term “foreseeably relevant” and the term “fishing expedition” by adding: general explanations (see paragraph 5), wording concerning the identification of the taxpayer under examination or investigation (see paragraph 5.1), wording concerning requests relating to groups of taxpayers (see paragraph 5.2) and new examples (see subparagraphs e) – h) of paragraph 8 and paragraph 8.1). The Commentary further provides for an optional default standard concerning the time limits within which information is to be provided, where the competent authorities have not agreed otherwise (see paragraphs 10.4–10.6), and that, in accordance with the principle of reciprocity, if a Contracting State applies, under paragraph 5, measures not normally provided for under its domestic law or practice, such as access to bank information and the exchange thereof, that State is equally entitled to request similar information from the other Contracting State (see paragraph 15). Other clarifications were added to paragraphs 3, 5.3, 6, 11, 12, 12.3, 12.4, 16, 16.1 and 19.7.
II. Commentary on the provisions of this Article
Paragraph 1
5. The main rule concerning the exchange of information is contained in the first sentence of this paragraph. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange such information as is foreseeably relevant for the proper application of the provisions of the Convention or of the domestic laws of the Contracting States concerning taxes of every kind and description imposed by those States, even where, in the latter case, there is no need to apply any specific Article of the Convention. The “foreseeably relevant” standard is intended to provide for the widest possible exchange of information in tax matters while at the same time clarifying that the Contracting States are not at liberty to engage in “fishing expeditions” or to request information that is unlikely to be relevant to the tax affairs of a given taxpayer. In the context of information exchange upon request, the standard requires that, at the time the request is made, there be a reasonable possibility that the requested information will be relevant; whether the information, once provided, actually proves to be relevant is immaterial. A request therefore cannot be declined in cases where an assessment of the relevance of the information to an ongoing investigation can only be made after the information has been received. The competent authorities should consult in situations in which the content of the request, the circumstances that led to the request, or the foreseeable relevance of the requested information are not clear to the requested State. However, once the requesting State has provided an explanation concerning the foreseeable relevance of the requested information, the requested State may not decline the request or refuse to provide the requested information because it considers that the information is not relevant to the underlying investigation or examination. In cases where the requested State becomes aware of facts that call into question whether part of the requested information is foreseeably relevant, the competent authorities should consult, and the requested State may ask the requesting State to clarify the foreseeable relevance in light of those facts. At the same time, paragraph 1 does not require the requested State to provide information in response to requests that constitute “fishing expeditions”, i.e. speculative requests that have no apparent connection with an open inquiry or investigation.
5.1 As is the case under the *Model Agreement on Exchange of Information on Tax Matters*¹, a request for information does not constitute a fishing expedition merely because it does not provide the name or address (or both) of the taxpayer under examination or investigation. The same is true where names are spelt differently or information concerning names and addresses is provided in a different format. However, where the requesting State does not provide the name or address (or both) of the taxpayer under examination or investigation, the requesting State must include other information sufficient to identify the taxpayer. Similarly, paragraph 1 does not necessarily require that the request indicate the name and/or address of the person believed to be in possession of the information. In fact, the question of how specific a request must be with respect to such a person generally falls within the scope of subparagraphs a) and b) of paragraph 3 of Article 26.
5.2 The “foreseeable relevance” standard may be met both in cases concerning one taxpayer (identified by name or otherwise) and in cases concerning several taxpayers (identified by name or otherwise). Where a Contracting State is conducting an investigation into a specific group of taxpayers in accordance with its laws, any request relating to that investigation will generally serve the purposes of the “administration or enforcement” of its domestic tax laws and will thus meet the requirements of paragraph 1, provided that it satisfies the “foreseeable relevance” standard. However, where a request concerns a group of taxpayers who are not individually identified, it will often be more difficult to establish that the request does not constitute a fishing expedition, since the requesting State cannot point to an ongoing investigation into the affairs of specific taxpayers, which in most cases would in itself dispel the notion that the request is random or speculative. Therefore, in such cases, the requesting State must provide a detailed description of the group and the specific facts and circumstances that have led to the request, an explanation of the applicable law and the reasons why there are grounds to believe that the taxpayers in the group in respect of whom the information is requested have not complied with that law, supported by a clear factual basis. In addition, it must provide confirmation that the requested information will assist in determining whether the taxpayers belonging to the group have complied with the law. As shown in the example in subparagraph h) of paragraph 8, in the case of a group request, a third party will generally, although not necessarily, be actively contributing to the non-compliance of the taxpayers in the group, and this circumstance should also be described in the request. Moreover, as shown in the example in subparagraph a) of paragraph 8.1, a group request that merely describes the provision of financial services to non-residents and refers to the possibility of non-compliance by non-resident clients does not meet the foreseeable relevance standard.
5.3 Contracting States may agree on an alternative wording of the foreseeable relevance standard that is consistent with the scope of this Article and is therefore understood to require effective exchange of information (for example, by replacing the words “is foreseeably relevant” with the words “is necessary”, “is relevant” or “may be relevant”). The scope of the exchange of information covers all tax matters, without prejudice to the general rules and legal provisions governing the rights of defendants and witnesses in judicial proceedings. The exchange of information in criminal tax cases may also be based on bilateral or multilateral mutual legal assistance treaties (to the extent that they also apply to tax crimes). In order to keep the exchange of information within the framework of the Convention, a limitation is established on the exchange of information so that information is provided only to the extent that taxation under the relevant domestic tax law does not contravene the Convention.
¹ See paragraph 58 of the Commentary.
5.4 The information covered by paragraph 1 is not limited to information concerning specific taxpayers. The competent authorities may also exchange other confidential information relating to tax administration and improving compliance, such as risk analysis techniques or schemes for tax avoidance or tax evasion.
5.5 The possibilities of assistance provided by this Article are neither limited nor restricted to those contained in existing international agreements or other arrangements between the Contracting States concerning co-operation in tax matters. Since the exchange of information concerning the application of customs duties has a legal basis in other international instruments, the provisions of those more specialised instruments will generally prevail, and the exchange of information concerning customs duties is, in practice, not governed by this Article.
6. The following examples are intended to clarify the principles discussed in paragraphs 5, 5.1 and 5.2 above. In the examples referred to in paragraphs 7 and 8, information may be exchanged under paragraph 1 of Article 26. In the examples referred to in paragraph 8.1, and assuming that no additional information is provided, the Contracting States are not required to provide information in response to a request for information. The examples are purely illustrative in nature. They should be viewed in light of the general objective of Article 26, which is not to restrict the scope of the exchange of information but to ensure that information can be exchanged “to the widest possible extent”.
7. Application of the Convention
a) In applying Article 12, State A, of which the beneficial owner is a resident, requests information from State B, of which the payer is a resident, concerning the amount of royalties transferred.
b) Conversely, in order to grant the exemption provided for in Article 12, State B asks State A whether the recipient of the amounts paid is in fact a resident of the latter State and the beneficial owner of the royalties.
c) Similarly, information may be required for the proper allocation of taxable profits between associated enterprises in different States or for the adjustment of profits reflected in the accounts of a permanent establishment in one State and in the accounts of the head office in another State (Articles 7, 9, 23 A and 23 B).
d) Information may be required for the purposes of applying Article 25.
e) In applying Articles 15 and 23, State A, of which the employee is a resident, informs State B, where the work is performed for more than 183 days, of the amount exempted from taxation in State A.
8. Enforcement of domestic law
a) A company in State A supplies goods to an independent company in State B. State A wishes to ascertain from State B the price paid by the company in State B for the goods, for the purpose of the proper application of the provisions of its domestic law.
b) A company in State A sells goods through a company in State C (possibly in a low-tax country) to a company in State B. These companies may or may not be associated. There is no Convention between State A and State C, nor is there any Convention between State B and State C. Under the Convention between State A and State B, State A, for the purpose of ensuring the proper application of the provisions of its domestic law to the profits earned by the company located in its territory, asks State B what price the company in State B paid for the goods.
c) For the purposes of taxing a company located in its territory, State A requests information from State B under the Convention between State A and State B concerning the prices charged by a company in State B, or by a group of companies in State B, with which the company in State A has no business dealings, so that it can verify the prices charged by the company in State A through direct comparison (e.g. the prices charged by a company or group of companies holding a dominant position). It should be noted that the exchange of information in this case may be complex and delicate, particularly in view of the provisions of subparagraph c) of paragraph 3 concerning commercial and other secrets.
d) State A, for the purpose of verifying tax deductions claimed by a company located in its territory for services performed by a company resident in State B, requests confirmation that the cost of the services has been properly recorded in the books and records of the company in State B.
e) The tax authorities of State A are conducting a tax investigation concerning Mr X. On the basis of this investigation, the tax authorities have indications that Mr X has one or more undeclared bank accounts with Bank B in State B. However, State A has found that, in order to avoid detection, bank accounts may well be opened in the names of relatives of the beneficial owner. State A therefore requests information concerning all accounts with Bank B in State B of which Mr X is the beneficial owner, as well as all accounts held in the names of his wife E and his children K and L.
f) State A has obtained information concerning all foreign credit card transactions carried out in its territory during a particular year. State A has processed this data and commenced an investigation which has identified all credit card numbers for which the frequency and nature of the transactions, as well as the type of use during that year, indicate that the cardholders were tax residents of State A. State A cannot obtain these names using the regular sources of information available under its domestic tax procedure because the relevant information is not in the possession or under the control of persons within its jurisdiction. The credit card numbers identify Bank B in State B as the issuer of the cards. On the basis of an open request or investigation, State A submits a request for information to State B, requesting the name, address and date of birth of the holders of the specific cards identified in its investigation, as well as of any other person authorised to sign for those cards. State A provides the relevant individual credit card numbers and further provides the above information in order to demonstrate the foreseeable relevance of the requested information to its investigation and, more generally, to the administration and enforcement of its tax laws.
g) Company A, a resident of State A, is owned by foreign unincorporated Company B, a resident of State B. The tax authorities of State A suspect that the managers X, Y and Z of Company A directly or indirectly own Company B. If this were the case, the dividends received by Company B from Company A would be taxable in their hands as resident shareholders under State A's controlled foreign company rules. The suspicion is based on information provided to the tax authorities of State A by a former employee of Company A. When confronted with these allegations, the three managers of Company A deny having any ownership interest in Company B. The tax authorities of State A have exhausted the means available to them for obtaining information about the ownership of Company B. State A now requests information from State B as to whether X, Y and Z are shareholders of Company B. In addition, given that ownership in such cases is often exercised through, for example, shell companies and nominee shareholders, it requests information from State B as to whether X, Y and Z are indirect owners of an ownership interest in Company B. If State B cannot determine whether X, Y or Z has an indirect interest, information is requested concerning the shareholder(s) in order to continue the investigation¹.
h) Financial services provider B is registered in State B. The tax authorities of State A have discovered that B sells a financial product to residents of State A using misleading information suggesting that the product eliminates State A income tax liability on income accrued within the product. The product requires an account to be opened with Company B through which the investment is made. The tax authorities of State A have issued a warning to taxpayers, alerting all taxpayers to the product and explaining that it does not achieve the intended tax effect and that income derived from the product must be reported. Nevertheless, B continues to sell the product on its website, and State A has evidence that it also sells the product through a network of advisers. State A has already identified several resident taxpayers who have invested in the product, all of whom have failed to report the income derived from their investments. State A has exhausted its domestic means of obtaining information concerning the identity of its residents who have invested in this product. State A requests from the competent authority of State B information concerning all residents of State A who (i) have an account with Bank B and (ii) have invested funds in the financial product. In its request, State A provides the above information, including detailed information about the financial product and the progress of its investigation.
8.1 Situations in which Contracting States are not required to provide information in response to a request for information, assuming that no additional information is provided
a) Bank B is a bank incorporated in State B. State A taxes its residents on the basis of their worldwide income. The competent authority of State A asks the competent authority of State B to provide the names, dates and places of birth, and account balances (including information concerning any financial assets held in such accounts) of residents of State A who have an account with Bank B in State B, hold signatory authority over an account with Bank B in State B, or have a beneficial interest in an account with Bank B in State B. The request states that Bank B is known to have a large group of foreign account holders, but contains no additional information.
b) Company B is a company incorporated in State B. State A requests the names of all shareholders of Company B who are residents of State A, as well as information concerning all dividend payments made to such shareholders. The requesting State A states that Company B has substantial business activity in State A and is therefore likely to have shareholders who are residents of State A. The request further states that it is well known that taxpayers often fail to disclose foreign-source income or assets.
9. The rule set out in paragraph 1 allows information to be exchanged in three different ways:
a) upon request, it being understood that, except in special cases, primary reliance should be placed on the regular sources of information available under the domestic tax procedure before a request for information is made to another State;
b) automatically, for example, where information concerning one or various categories of income having their source in one Contracting State and received in another Contracting State is systematically transmitted to the other State*;* see OECD Council Recommendations C(97)29/FINAL of 13 March 1997 (Recommendation on the Use of Tax Identification Numbers in an International Context) and C(2001)28/FINAL of 22 March 2001 (Recommendation on the Use of the OECD Model Memorandum of Understanding on Automatic Exchange of Information for Tax Purposes);
c) spontaneously, for example, where a State has acquired, as a result of certain investigations, information which it believes to be of interest to the other State.
9.1 These three forms of exchange (upon request, automatic and spontaneous) may also be combined. It should also be emphasised that this Article does not limit the possibilities for exchanging information to these methods and that the Contracting States may use other methods to obtain information that may be relevant to both Contracting States, such as simultaneous examinations, tax examinations abroad and industry-wide exchanges of information. These methods are fully described in publication¹, 1994, and may be summarised as follows:
— a simultaneous examination is an arrangement between two or more parties whereby each of them examines, simultaneously and within its own territory, the tax affairs of the taxpayer(s) in which they have a common or related interest, with a view to exchanging any relevant information thereby obtained (see OECD Council Recommendation C(92)81 of 23 July 1992 concerning the OECD Model Agreement for the Conduct of Simultaneous Examinations);
— a tax examination abroad allows information to be obtained in the presence of representatives of the competent authority of the requesting Contracting State. To the extent permitted by its domestic law, a Contracting State may authorise authorised representatives
¹ [Reference as in the original text; publication details are not specified in the supplied excerpt.]
Exchange of Tax Information Between OECD Member Countries: A Review of Current Practices — OECD, Paris
A competent authority of the other Contracting State may enter the first Contracting State for the purpose of interviewing individuals or examining their books and records, as well as being present during such interviews or examinations conducted by the tax authorities of the first Contracting State, in accordance with procedures mutually agreed upon by the competent authorities. Such a request may arise, for example, in cases where a taxpayer in one Contracting State is permitted to maintain accounting records in the other Contracting State. This type of assistance is provided on a reciprocal basis. The laws and practices of different countries vary with regard to the extent of the rights granted to foreign tax officials. For example, there are countries in which a foreign tax official is prohibited from taking any active part in an investigation or examination on the territory of the country; there are also countries in which such participation is possible only with the consent of the taxpayer. The Joint Council of Europe/OECD Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters specifically addresses tax examinations abroad in its Article 9;
— industry-wide exchange of information is the exchange of tax information, particularly information relating to an entire sector of the economy (for example, the oil or pharmaceutical industry, the banking sector, etc.), rather than information relating to specific taxpayers.
10. The decision as to how the exchange of information agreed upon in the Convention will be carried out may be made by the competent authorities of the Contracting States. For example, the Contracting States may wish to use electronic or other communication and information technologies, including appropriate security systems, to improve the timeliness and quality of the exchange of information. Contracting States that are required under their domestic law to comply with data protection laws may wish to include provisions in their bilateral Conventions concerning the protection of personal data transmitted. Data protection concerns the rights and fundamental freedoms of individuals and, in particular, the right to privacy with regard to the automatic processing of personal data. See, for example, the Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of Individuals with regard to Automatic Processing of Personal Data of 28 January 1981.
10.1 Prior to 2000, this paragraph permitted only the exchange of information and the use of information in relation to taxes covered by the Convention in accordance with the general rules of Article 2. As worded, this paragraph did not oblige the requested State to comply with a request for information concerning the imposition of a sales tax, since such a tax was not covered by the Convention. This paragraph was subsequently amended to extend it to the exchange of information concerning any tax levied on behalf of the Contracting States or their political subdivisions or local authorities, and to permit the use of exchanged information for the purposes of administering all such taxes. However, some Contracting States may be unable to exchange information or use information received from a treaty partner in relation to taxes that are not covered by the Convention under the general rules of Article 2. Such States are free to limit the scope of paragraph 1 of this Article to taxes covered by the Convention.
10.2 In certain cases, a Contracting State may need to obtain information in a particular form in order to satisfy its evidentiary or other legal requirements. Such forms may include witness testimony and certified copies of original documents. Contracting States should endeavour, to the extent possible, to comply with such requests. Under paragraph 3, the requested State may refuse to provide information in the particular form requested if, for example, the requested form is not known or is not permitted under its laws or administrative practice. Refusal to provide information in the requested form does not affect the obligation to provide the information.
10.3 Nothing in the Convention prevents the provisions of this Article from applying to the exchange of information that existed prior to the entry into force of the Convention, provided that assistance with respect to such information is provided after the entry into force of the Convention and the entry into force of the provisions of this Article. However, the Contracting States may find it useful to clarify the extent to which the provisions of this Article apply to such information, particularly where the provisions of this Convention will apply to taxes arising or levied in respect of a specific period of time.
10.4 The Contracting States may wish to improve the efficiency and timeliness of the exchange of information under this Article by agreeing on time limits for providing information. The Contracting States may do so by adding the following wording to the text of the Convention as Article:
6. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may agree on time limits for the provision of information under this Article. In the absence of such an agreement, the information shall be provided as quickly as possible and, except where the delay is caused by legal impediments, within the following time limits:
a) If the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State already have the requested information in their possession, such information shall be provided to the competent authority of the other Contracting State within two months from the date of receipt of the request for information;
b) If the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State do not yet have the requested information in their possession, such information shall be provided to the competent authority of the other Contracting State within six months from the date of receipt of the request for information.
Subject to compliance with the other conditions of this Article, the exchange of information shall be considered to have been carried out in accordance with the provisions of this Article even if it is provided after the expiry of the specified time limits.
10.5 The provisions of subparagraphs a) and b) of optional paragraph 6, referred to in paragraph 10.4, establish a default standard for time limits, which will apply in cases where the competent authorities have not entered into another agreement providing for longer or shorter time limits. The default standard time limits are two months from the receipt of the request for information if the requested information is already in the possession of the tax authorities of the requested Contracting State, and six months in all other cases. Notwithstanding the default time limits or any other agreed time limits, the competent authorities may reach different agreements on a case-by-case basis, for example, where they both agree that more time is required. This may arise where the request is complex. In such a case, the competent authority of the requesting Contracting State should not unreasonably refuse to grant the request of the competent authority of the requested Contracting State for an extension of time. If the requested Contracting State is unable to provide the requested information within the prescribed time limit due to legal impediments (for example, ongoing judicial proceedings concerning a taxpayer's challenge to the validity of the request or ongoing judicial proceedings concerning a domestic notification procedure of the type described in paragraph 14.1), this shall not constitute a breach of the time limits.
10.6 The final sentence of optional paragraph 6, referred to in paragraph 10.4, which states: "subject to compliance with the other conditions of this Article, information shall be considered to have been exchanged in accordance with the provisions of this Article even if it is provided after the expiry of those time limits", clearly indicates that no objections to the use or admissibility of information exchanged under this Article may be based on the fact that the information was exchanged after the expiry of the time limits agreed upon by the competent authorities or the default time limits provided for in this paragraph.
Paragraph 2
11. Mutual assistance between tax administrations is possible only if each administration is confident that the other administration will treat the information received in the course of their cooperation with due regard for confidentiality. The confidentiality rules set out in paragraph 2 apply to all types of information received under paragraph 1, including both information contained in the request and information transmitted in response to the request. Thus, the confidentiality rules apply, for example, to letters from competent authorities, including letters requesting information. At the same time, it is understood that the requested State may disclose the minimum information contained in the letter of the competent authority (but not the letter itself) that is necessary for the requested State to obtain or provide the requested information to the requesting State without undermining the efforts of the requesting State. However, if judicial proceedings or similar actions under the domestic law of the requested State require disclosure of the letter of the competent authority itself, the competent authority of the requested State may disclose such letter unless the requesting State indicates otherwise. The preservation of secrecy in the receiving Contracting State is a matter of domestic law. Therefore, paragraph 2 provides that information transmitted under the provisions of the Convention shall be treated as secret in the receiving State in the same manner as information obtained under the domestic law of that State. Sanctions for breaches of such secrecy in that State shall be governed by the administrative and criminal laws of that State. In situations where the requested State determines that the requesting State is not fulfilling its obligations regarding the confidentiality of information exchanged under this Article, the requested State may suspend the provision of assistance under this Article until the requesting State provides appropriate assurances that such obligations will indeed be respected. Where necessary, the competent authorities may conclude specific agreements or memoranda of understanding concerning the confidentiality of information exchanged under this Article.
12. Subject to the provisions of paragraphs 12.3 and 12.4, the information received may be disclosed only to persons and authorities concerned with the assessment or collection, enforcement or prosecution in respect of, the determination of appeals in relation to, taxes in respect of which information may be exchanged under the first sentence of paragraph 1, or the supervision of the foregoing. This means that information may also be disclosed to the taxpayer, their representative or witnesses. It also means that information may be disclosed to governmental or judicial authorities empowered to decide whether such information should be provided to the taxpayer, their representative or witnesses. Information received by a Contracting State may be used by such persons or authorities only for the purposes mentioned in paragraph 2. Furthermore, information covered by paragraph 1, whether or not it is specific to individual taxpayers, shall not be disclosed to persons or authorities not mentioned in paragraph 2, regardless of domestic disclosure laws, such as freedom of information or other legislation that provides broader access to government documents.
12.1 Information may also be disclosed to supervisory authorities. Such supervisory authorities include bodies responsible for supervising tax administration and law enforcement authorities within the general government administration of a Contracting State. However, during their bilateral negotiations, the Contracting States may depart from this principle and agree to exclude disclosure of information to such supervisory authorities.
12.2 Information received by a Contracting State may not be disclosed to a third country unless the bilateral treaty between the Contracting States contains an express provision permitting such disclosure.
12.3 Information exchanged for tax purposes may be of value to the receiving State for purposes other than those referred to in the first and second sentences of paragraph 2 of Article 26. Thus, the last sentence of paragraph 2 allows Contracting States to exchange information obtained for tax purposes, subject to two conditions: first, such information may be used for other purposes under the laws of both States and, second, the competent authority of the supplying State authorises such use. It allows the tax authorities of the receiving State to share tax information with other law enforcement and judicial authorities of that State in certain high-priority matters (for example, combating money laundering, corruption and the financing of terrorism). Where the receiving State wishes to use the information for an additional purpose (i.e. a non-tax purpose), the receiving State must indicate to the supplying State the other purpose for which it wishes to use the information and confirm that the receiving State is permitted to use the information for such other purpose under its laws. In cases where the supplying State is able to do so, taking into account, in particular, international agreements or other arrangements between the Contracting States concerning mutual assistance between other law enforcement and judicial authorities, the competent authority of the supplying State should generally authorise such use for other purposes if the information may be used for similar purposes in the supplying State. Law enforcement and judicial authorities receiving information under the last sentence of paragraph 2 must treat such information as confidential in accordance with the principles of paragraph 2.
12.4 It is recognised that Contracting States may wish to achieve the general objective underlying the last sentence of paragraph 2 by other means, and they may do so by replacing the last sentence of paragraph 2 with the following text:
The competent authority of a Contracting State receiving information under the provisions of this Article may, with the written consent of the Contracting State that provided the information, also provide such information for use for other purposes permitted under the provisions of a mutual legal assistance treaty in force between the Contracting States that allows for the exchange of tax information.
13. As indicated in paragraph 12, the information received may be made available to the persons and authorities specified therein and, under the third sentence of paragraph 2 of this Article, may be disclosed by them in public court proceedings or in judicial decisions identifying the taxpayer by name. Once the information is used in public court proceedings or in judicial decisions and thereby becomes publicly available, it is clear that, from that point onwards, such information may be cited from court records or decisions for other purposes, including as potential evidence. However, this does not mean that the persons and authorities mentioned in paragraph 2 have the right to provide additional information received upon request. If one or both Contracting States object to the information being made public by the courts in this manner or, after the information has been made public in this manner, to its use for other purposes because this is not the usual procedure under their domestic laws, they should expressly state this in their Convention.
Paragraph 3
14. This paragraph contains certain limitations on the basic rule in favour of the requested State. First, this paragraph clarifies that a Contracting State is not required to go beyond its domestic laws and administrative practices when making information available to another Contracting State. However, domestic provisions concerning tax secrecy must not be interpreted as preventing the exchange of information under this Article. As mentioned above, the authorities of the requesting State are required to maintain the confidentiality of information received under this Article.
14.1 The laws of some countries provide for notification procedures whereby the person who provided the information and/or the taxpayer to whom the request relates must be notified before the information is provided. Such notification procedures may be an important aspect of the rights provided under domestic law. They may help prevent errors (for example, in cases of mistaken identification) and facilitate the exchange (by allowing taxpayers who have received notification to cooperate voluntarily with the tax authorities of the requesting State). At the same time, notification procedures should not be applied in such a way that, in the particular circumstances of the request, they undermine the efforts of the requesting State. In other words, they should not prevent or unduly delay the effective exchange of information. For example, notification procedures should allow for exceptions to prior notification, such as in cases where the request for information is very urgent or where notification could undermine the chances of success of an investigation conducted by the requesting State. A Contracting State that is required under its domestic law to notify the person who provided the information and/or the taxpayer that an exchange of information is proposed must inform its treaty partners in writing that it has this requirement and what the consequences are for its obligations regarding mutual assistance. Such information should be provided to the other Contracting State upon the conclusion of the Convention and subsequently whenever the relevant rules are amended.
15. Furthermore, the requested State is not required to go so far as to take administrative measures that are not permitted under the laws or practices of the requesting State, or to provide information that cannot be obtained under the laws or in the course of the ordinary administrative activities of the requesting State. It follows that a Contracting State cannot take advantage of the information system of another Contracting State if it is broader than its own system. Thus, a State may refuse to provide information in cases where the requesting State is not legally able to obtain or provide such information, or where the administrative practice of the requesting State (for example, the failure to provide sufficient administrative resources) results in a lack of reciprocity. At the same time, it is recognised that an overly strict application of the principle of reciprocity may hinder the effective exchange of information and that reciprocity should be interpreted broadly and pragmatically. Different countries will necessarily have different mechanisms for obtaining and providing information. Differences in practices and procedures should not be used as grounds for refusing a request unless the consequences of such differences substantially limit the overall ability of the requesting State to obtain and provide information, if the requesting State itself received a legitimate request from the requested State. It should be noted that if a Contracting State applies measures under paragraph 5 that are not normally provided for under its domestic laws or practices, such as access to and exchange of banking information, that State has an equal right to request similar information from the other Contracting State. This would be entirely consistent with the principle of reciprocity underlying subparagraphs a) and b) of paragraph 3.
15.1 The principle of reciprocity does not apply in cases where the legal system or administrative practice of only one country provides for a particular procedure. For example, a country that is requested to provide information cannot point to the absence of a ruling regime in the country requesting the information and refuse to provide information about a decision adopted by it on the grounds of reciprocity. Of course, where the requested information itself cannot be obtained under the laws or in the course of the ordinary administrative practice of the requesting State, the requested State may reject such a request.
15.2 Most countries recognise under their domestic laws that information cannot be obtained from a person to the extent that such person may claim the privilege against self-incrimination. Therefore, the requested State may refuse to provide information if the requesting State, under its own rules concerning self-incrimination, would not have been able to obtain such information in similar circumstances. In practice, however, the privilege against self-incrimination should have virtually no application in connection with most requests for information. The privilege against self-incrimination is personal and cannot be claimed by a person who is not themselves at risk of criminal prosecution. The overwhelming majority of requests for information are directed at obtaining information from third parties, such as banks, intermediaries or another party to a contract, rather than from the person under investigation. Furthermore, the privilege against self-incrimination generally does not extend to persons other than natural persons.
16. Information is considered to be obtainable in the course of ordinary administrative activities if it is in the possession of the tax authorities or can be obtained by them in the course of the ordinary tax assessment procedure, which may include conducting special investigations or special examinations of the business accounts of the taxpayer or other persons, provided that the tax authorities would conduct similar investigations or examinations for their own purposes. This paragraph assumes, of course, that the tax authorities have the powers and resources necessary to facilitate the effective exchange of information. For example, suppose that a Contracting State requests information in connection with an investigation into the tax affairs of a particular taxpayer and indicates in the request that such information may be held by one of several service providers identified in the request and established in another Contracting State. In this case, the requested State is expected to be able to obtain and provide such information to the extent that it is held by one of the service providers identified in the request. In responding to the request, the requested State should be guided by the overall objective of Article 26, which is to permit the exchange of information "to the widest possible extent", and may take into account the importance of the requested information to the requesting State in relation to the administrative burden on the requested State.
16.1 Subparagraphs a) and b) of paragraph 3 do not permit the requested State to refuse a request where paragraph 4 or 5 applies. Paragraph 5 will apply, for example, in situations where the inability of the requested State to obtain information is specifically related to the fact that the requested information is considered to be held by a bank or other financial institution. Thus, the application of paragraph 5 includes situations in which the powers of the tax authorities to collect information held by banks and other financial institutions are subject to requirements different from those that normally apply to information held by persons who are not banks or other financial institutions. This may be the case, for example, where the tax authorities may exercise their information-gathering powers with respect to information held by banks and other financial institutions only where specific information exists about a taxpayer who is under investigation or examination. This also applies in cases where, for example, the use of information-gathering measures in relation to information held by banks and other financial institutions requires a higher degree of certainty that the requested information is held by the person presumed to possess the requested information than the degree of certainty required for the use of information-gathering measures in relation to information presumed to be held by persons who are not banks or financial institutions.
17. The requested State is entitled to refuse to provide information in the cases specified in the paragraphs above. However, if it provides the requested information, it remains within the framework of the information exchange agreement enshrined in the Convention; consequently, no objection may be raised on the grounds that the State has failed to comply with its obligation to maintain confidentiality.
18. If the structure of the information systems of the two Contracting States is very different, the conditions provided for in subparagraphs a) and d) of paragraph 3 will result in the Contracting States exchanging very little information or possibly no information at all. In such a case, the Contracting States may consider it appropriate to broaden the scope of the exchange of information.
18.1 Unless the Contracting States have agreed otherwise, it may be assumed that the requested information could be obtained by the requesting State in a similar situation, unless that State has indicated otherwise.
19. In addition to the limitations mentioned above, subparagraph c) of paragraph 3 contains a safeguard concerning the disclosure of certain confidential information. The secrets referred to in this subparagraph should not be interpreted too broadly. Before invoking this provision, a Contracting State should carefully consider whether the interests of the taxpayer genuinely justify its application. Otherwise, it is clear that an overly broad interpretation would, in many cases, render ineffective the exchange of information provided for in the Convention. The observations made in paragraph 17 above also apply in this case. The requested State is granted a certain degree of discretion to refuse the requested information in order to protect the interests of its taxpayers, but if it deliberately provides the information, the taxpayer cannot claim that the confidentiality rules have been violated.
19.1 When considering the application of secrecy rules, a Contracting State should also take into account the confidentiality rules contained in paragraph 2 of the Article. The domestic laws and practices of the requesting State, together with the obligations imposed under paragraph 2, may ensure that the information cannot be used for the types of unauthorised purposes against which the rules concerning commercial or other secrets are intended to provide protection. Thus, a Contracting State may decide to provide the information if it considers that there are no reasonable grounds to believe that the relevant taxpayer may suffer any adverse consequences inconsistent with the exchange of information.
19.2 In most cases of information exchange, no issue arises concerning commercial, business or other secrets. A commercial or business secret generally refers to facts and circumstances of substantial economic significance that can be used in practice and whose unauthorised use could result in serious harm (for example, could lead to financial difficulties). The assessment, calculation or collection of taxes as such cannot be considered to result in serious harm. Financial information, including books and accounting records, is not by its nature a commercial, business or other secret. However, in certain limited cases, the disclosure of financial information may result in the disclosure of a commercial, business or other secret. For example, a request for information concerning certain procurement records may raise such an issue if the disclosure of such information reveals a patented formula used in the manufacture of a product. The protection of such information may also extend to information held by third parties. For example, a bank may hold a patent application for safekeeping, or a secret trade process or formula may be described in a loan application or in a contract held by the bank. In such circumstances, the details of the trade, business or other secret should be redacted from the documents, and the remaining financial information should be exchanged accordingly.
19.3 The requested State may refuse to disclose information concerning confidential communications between lawyers, solicitors or other recognised legal representatives acting in their capacity as such and their clients, to the extent that such communications are protected from disclosure under domestic law. However, the scope of protection afforded to such confidential communications should be narrowly defined. This protection does not extend to documents or records transferred to a lawyer, solicitor or other recognised legal representative in an attempt to protect such documents or records from disclosure required by law. Furthermore, information concerning the identity of a person, such as a director or beneficial owner of a company, is generally not protected as confidential information. Although the scope of protection afforded to confidential communications may vary between States, it should not be excessively broad so as to impede the effective exchange of information. Communications between lawyers, solicitors or other recognised legal representatives and their clients are confidential only if and to the extent that such representatives act as lawyers, solicitors or other recognised legal representatives, and not in another capacity, such as nominee shareholders, trustees, founders, company directors or persons authorised by power of attorney to represent a company in its business affairs. A claim that information is protected as a confidential communication between a lawyer, solicitor or other recognised legal representative and their client must be considered exclusively in the Contracting State under whose laws it arises. Thus, it is not envisaged that the courts of the requested State should rule on claims based on the laws of the requesting State.
19.4 Contracting States wishing to expressly specify the protection afforded to confidential communications between a client and a lawyer, solicitor or other recognised legal representative may do so by adding the following text at the end of paragraph 3:
d) to obtain or provide information that would disclose confidential communications between a client and a lawyer, solicitor or other recognised legal representative, where such communications are:
(i) made for the purpose of seeking or providing legal advice; or
(ii) made for the purpose of use in existing or contemplated legal proceedings.
19.5 Paragraph 3 also contains a limitation concerning information relating to the vital interests of the State itself. For this purpose, it provides that Contracting States are not required to provide information the disclosure of which would be contrary to public policy (ordre public). However, this limitation should be relevant only in extreme cases. For example, such a case may arise if a tax investigation in the requesting State was motivated by political, racial or religious persecution. This limitation may also apply in cases where the information constitutes a State secret, such as confidential information held by the intelligence services, the disclosure of which would be contrary to the vital interests of the requested State. Thus, issues of public policy (ordre public) rarely arise in the context of the exchange of information between treaty partners.
Paragraph 4
19.6 Paragraph 4 was added in 2005 and expressly provides for the obligation to exchange information in situations where the requested information is not required by the requested State for domestic tax purposes. Before the addition of paragraph 4, this obligation was not expressly stated in the Article, but it was confirmed by the practice of Member countries, which demonstrated that, when collecting information requested by a treaty partner, Contracting States frequently use special investigative powers provided for under their laws for the purposes of administering their domestic taxes, even where they themselves do not need that information for those purposes. This principle is also set out in the report on Improving Access to Bank Information for Tax Purposes¹.
19.7 Under paragraph 4, Contracting States must use their information-gathering measures even where they are applied solely for the purpose of providing information to another Contracting State and regardless of whether that information can still be collected or used for domestic tax purposes in the requested Contracting State. Thus, for example, any restrictions on the ability of the requested Contracting State to obtain information from a person for domestic tax purposes at the time of the request (e.g. due to the expiry of the limitation period under the domestic law of the requested State or the prior completion of an audit) should not restrict its ability to use its information-gathering measures for the purposes of exchanging information. The term "information-gathering measures" means laws and administrative or judicial procedures that enable a Contracting State to obtain and provide the requested information. Paragraph 4 does not require the requested Contracting State to provide information in circumstances where it has attempted to obtain the requested information but considers that the information no longer exists following the expiry of the domestic record-retention period. However, where the requested information is still available notwithstanding the expiry of such retention period, the requested State cannot refuse to exchange the information that is available. Contracting States should ensure that reliable accounting records are maintained for five years or more.
¹ OECD, Paris, 2000 (at paragraph 21 b).
19.8 The second sentence of paragraph 4 indicates that the obligation contained in paragraph 4 is subject to the limitations of paragraph 3, but also provides that such limitations cannot be interpreted as a basis for refusing to provide information where the laws or practices of a country include a domestic tax interest requirement. Thus, although the requested State cannot rely on paragraph 3 and claim that, under its domestic law or practice, it provides information in which it has an interest only for its own tax purposes, it may, for example, refuse to provide information to the extent that providing such information would disclose a trade secret.
19.9 For many countries, the combination of paragraph 4 and their domestic laws provides a sufficient basis for using their information-gathering measures to obtain the requested information even in the absence of a domestic tax interest in that information. However, other countries may wish to clarify expressly in the Convention that Contracting States must ensure that their competent authorities have the necessary powers to do so. Contracting States wishing to clarify this paragraph may replace paragraph 4 with the following text:
- For the purpose of carrying out the exchange of information provided for in paragraph 1, each Contracting State shall take the necessary measures, including legislative, regulatory or administrative measures, to ensure that its competent authority has sufficient powers under its domestic law to obtain information for exchange purposes, regardless of whether that Contracting State may need such information for its own tax purposes.
Paragraph 5
19.10 Paragraph 1 imposes a direct obligation on a Contracting State to exchange all types of information. Paragraph 5 is intended to ensure that the limitations in paragraph 3 cannot be used to prevent the exchange of information held by banks, other financial institutions, nominees, agents and fiduciaries, as well as information concerning ownership interests. Although paragraph 5, which was added in 2005, represents a structural change to this Article, it should not be interpreted as implying that the previous version of this Article did not permit the exchange of such information. The overwhelming majority of OECD Member countries were already exchanging such information under the previous version of this Article, and the addition of paragraph 5 merely reflects current practice.
19.11 Paragraph 5 provides that a Contracting State shall not refuse to provide information to a treaty partner solely because that information is held by a bank or another financial institution. Thus, paragraph 5 overrides paragraph 3 to the extent that paragraph 3 would otherwise allow the requested Contracting State to refuse to provide information on the grounds of bank secrecy. The addition of this paragraph to the Article reflects the international trend in this area, as reflected in the Model Agreement on Exchange of Information on Tax Matters and described in the report on Improving Access to Bank Information for Tax Purposes¹. In accordance with that report, access to information held by banks or other financial institutions may be obtained directly or indirectly through a judicial or administrative process. The indirect access procedure must not be so burdensome and time-consuming as to constitute an obstacle to access to bank information.
¹ OECD, Paris, 2000.
19.12 Paragraph 5 also provides that a Contracting State shall not refuse to provide information solely because that information is held by persons acting in an agency or fiduciary capacity. For example, if a Contracting State has a law under which all information held by a fiduciary is treated as "professional secrecy" solely because it is held by a fiduciary, that State cannot use such a law as a basis for refusing to provide information to another Contracting State. A person is generally said to act in a "fiduciary capacity" where the business conducted by that person, or the money or property managed by that person, does not belong to that person or serve that person's own benefit, but is conducted or managed for the benefit of another person with whom the fiduciary has a relationship involving and requiring trust and confidence on the one hand and good faith on the other, such as a trustee. The term "agency" is very broad and includes all forms of corporate service providers (e.g. company formation agents, trust companies, registered agents, lawyers).
19.13 Finally, paragraph 5 provides that a Contracting State shall not refuse to provide information solely because it relates to an ownership interest in a person, including companies and partnerships, foundations or similar organisational structures. Requests for information cannot be rejected solely because national laws or practices may treat ownership information as a commercial or other secret.
19.14 Paragraph 5 does not prevent a Contracting State from relying on paragraph 3 to refuse to provide information held by a bank, financial institution, person acting in an agency or fiduciary capacity, or information concerning ownership interests. However, such a refusal must be based on reasons unrelated to the status of the person as a bank, financial institution, agent, fiduciary or nominee, or to the fact that the information relates to ownership interests. For example, a legal representative acting on behalf of a client may act in an agency capacity, but with respect to any information protected as a confidential communication between lawyers, attorneys or other recognised legal representatives and their clients, paragraph 3 continues to provide a possible basis for refusing to provide such information.
19.15 The application of paragraph 5 is illustrated by the following examples:
a) Company X owns a majority of the shares in its subsidiary Y, and both companies are incorporated under the laws of State A. State B is conducting a tax audit of the business transactions of company Y in State B. In the course of this audit, the question of both direct and indirect ownership of company Y becomes relevant, and State B requests State A to provide information on the ownership of any person in the ownership chain of company Y. In its response, State A must provide State B with ownership information concerning both company X and company Y.
b) An individual who is subject to taxation in State A has a bank account with bank B in State B. State A is examining the individual's income tax return and requests State B to provide all information on the income and assets in the bank account held by bank B in order to determine whether deposits consisted of untaxed earned income. State B must provide the requested banking information to State A.
- [Deleted]
Commentary on the Comment
- In connection with paragraph 15.1, Greece wishes to clarify that, pursuant to Article 28 of the Greek Constitution, international tax treaties apply on the basis of reciprocity.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 27 CONCERNING ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES
- This Article establishes the rules under which Contracting States¹ may agree to assist each other in the collection of taxes. In some States, domestic law or policy may prevent this form of assistance or impose restrictions on it. In addition, in certain cases, administrative considerations may not justify providing assistance in the collection of taxes to another State or may similarly limit such assistance. Therefore, during negotiations, each Contracting State will need to decide whether, and to what extent, it should provide assistance to the other State, taking into account various factors, including the following:
— the position adopted under domestic law with respect to providing assistance in the collection of taxes of other States;
— the extent to which the tax systems, tax administrations and legal standards of the two States are similar, particularly with regard to the protection of the fundamental rights of taxpayers (e.g. timely and adequate notification of claims against the taxpayer, the right to confidentiality of taxpayer information, the right to appeal, the right to be heard and to present arguments and evidence, the right to assistance from a lawyer of the taxpayer's choice, the right to a fair trial, etc.);
— whether assistance in the collection of taxes provides balanced and reciprocal benefits for both States;
— the ability of a particular State to provide such assistance;
— whether trade and investment flows between the two States are sufficient to justify this form of assistance;
— information concerning constitutional or other reasons for restricting the application of the provisions of this Article to taxes.
This Article should be included in the Convention only where each State concludes that, having regard to these factors, it can agree to provide assistance in the collection of taxes levied by the other State.
- The Article provides for comprehensive assistance in collection. Some States may prefer to provide a more limited form of assistance in collection. This may be the only form of assistance in collection that they are generally able to provide or that they may agree to provide under a particular Convention. For example, a State may wish to limit assistance to cases where the benefits of the Convention (e.g. a reduction in tax in the State where the income arises, such as interest) have been claimed by persons who are not entitled to them. States wishing to provide such limited assistance in collection are free to adopt, on a bilateral basis, an alternative Article drafted along the following lines:
¹ Throughout this Commentary on Article 27, the State requesting assistance is referred to as the "requesting State", and the State from which assistance is requested is referred to as the "requested State".
Article 27
ASSISTANCE IN THE COLLECTION OF TAXES
- The Contracting States shall lend assistance to each other in the collection of taxes to the extent necessary to ensure that any exemption or reduced rate of tax granted under this Convention is not enjoyed by persons who are not entitled to such benefits. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, settle the mode of application of this Article.
- In no case shall the provisions of this Article be construed so as to impose on a Contracting State the obligation:
a) to carry out administrative measures at variance with the laws and administrative practice of that or of the other Contracting State;
b) to carry out measures which would be contrary to public policy (ordre public).
Paragraph 1
- This paragraph sets out the principle that a Contracting State is obliged to assist the other State in the collection of taxes due to it, subject to the conditions of this Article. Paragraphs 3 and 4 provide for the two forms that this assistance will take.
- This paragraph also provides that assistance under this Article is not limited by Articles 1 and 2. Assistance must therefore be provided in respect of a claim for revenue due to a Contracting State by any person, regardless of whether that person is a resident of a Contracting State or not. However, some Contracting States may wish to limit assistance to taxes owed by residents of either Contracting State. Such States are entitled to limit the scope of this Article by deleting the reference to Article 1 from this paragraph.
- Article 26 applies to the exchange of information for the purposes of the provisions of this Article. This ensures the confidentiality of information exchanged for the purposes of providing assistance in collection.
- Finally, this paragraph provides that the competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, settle the details of the practical application of the provisions of this Article.
- Such an agreement should, in particular, address the documentation that must accompany a request made under paragraphs 3 or 4. It is common practice to agree that a request for assistance will be accompanied by such documentation as is required under the law of the requested State or as agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States, and as is necessary for carrying out, as the case may be, the collection of revenue claims or measures of conservancy. Such documentation may include, for example, a statement that the revenue claim is enforceable and is owed by a person who, under the law of the requesting State, cannot prevent its collection, or an official copy of the instrument authorising enforcement in the requesting State. An official translation of the documentation into the language of the requested State should also be provided. Where appropriate, it could also be agreed that the instrument authorising enforcement in the requesting State shall, where appropriate and in accordance with the provisions in force in the requested State, be accepted, recognised, supplemented or replaced as soon as possible after the date of receipt of the request for assistance by an instrument authorising enforcement in the latter State.
- The agreement should also address the question of the costs that will be incurred by the requested State in complying with a request made under paragraphs 3 or 4. As a general rule, the costs of collecting the revenue claim are borne by the debtor, but it is necessary to determine which State will bear costs that cannot be recovered from that person. The usual practice in this respect is to provide that, in the absence of an agreement specific to a particular case, ordinary costs incurred by a State in providing assistance to another State will not be reimbursed by that other State. Ordinary costs are those directly and normally associated with collection, i.e. those expected to arise in the course of ordinary domestic collection procedures. However, in the case of extraordinary costs, the practice is for these to be borne by the requesting State, unless otherwise agreed on a bilateral basis. Such costs would include, for example, costs incurred where a particular type of procedure is used at the request of the other State, or additional costs for experts, oral or written translators. Most States also regard court costs and bankruptcy proceedings as extraordinary costs. The agreement should contain a definition of extraordinary costs, and consultations between the Contracting States should take place in any particular case where extraordinary costs may arise. It should also be agreed that, as soon as a Contracting State anticipates that extraordinary costs may be incurred, it shall inform the other Contracting State and indicate the estimated amount of such costs, so that the other State may decide whether it is willing to bear such costs. Of course, the Contracting States may also provide for costs to be allocated on a basis other than that described above; this may be necessary, for example, where a request for assistance in collection is suspended or withdrawn under paragraph 7, or where the question of costs incurred in providing assistance in collection is already addressed in another legal instrument applicable to those States.
- In the agreement, the competent authorities may also address other practical matters, such as:
— whether a time limit should be established after which a request for assistance may no longer be made in respect of a particular revenue claim;
— what exchange rate should apply where the revenue claim is collected in a currency other than that used in the requesting State;
— how the amount collected pursuant to a request under paragraph 3 should be transferred to the requesting State.
Paragraph 2
- Paragraph 2 defines the term "revenue claim" for the purposes of this Article. This definition applies to any amount owed in respect of all taxes levied on behalf of the Contracting States or their political subdivisions or local authorities, but only to the extent that the taxation is not contrary to the Convention or any other instrument in force between the Contracting States. It also applies to interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or conservancy relating to such amount. Thus, assistance is not limited to taxes to which the Convention generally applies under Article 2, as confirmed in paragraph 1.
- Some Contracting States may prefer to limit the application of Article 2 to taxes covered by the Convention under the general rules of Article 2. States wishing to do so should replace paragraphs 1 and 2 with the following text:
- The Contracting States shall lend assistance to each other in the collection of revenue claims. Such assistance shall not be limited by Article 1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may, by mutual agreement, settle the mode of application of this Article.
- The term "revenue claim" as used in this Article means any amount owed in respect of taxes covered by the Convention, together with interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or conservancy relating to such amount.
- Similarly, some Contracting States may wish to limit the types of taxes to which the provisions of this Article will apply, or to clarify the scope of these provisions by including a detailed list of taxes in the definition. States wishing to do so are free to adopt, on a bilateral basis, the following definition:
The term "revenue claim" as used in this Article means an amount owed in respect of the following taxes levied by the Contracting States, to the extent that the taxation is not contrary to this Convention or any other instrument to which the Contracting States are parties, together with interest, administrative penalties and costs of collection or conservancy relating to such amount:
a) (in State A):…
b) (in State B):…
- To ensure that the competent authorities are able to freely transmit information for the purposes of this Article, Contracting States should ensure that Article 26 is drafted in such a way as to permit the exchange of information in respect of any tax to which this Article applies.
- Nothing in the Convention prevents the provisions of this Article from applying to revenue claims arising before the entry into force of the Convention, provided that assistance in respect of those claims is provided after the entry into force of the Convention and the entry into force of the provisions of this Article. However, Contracting States may find it useful to clarify the extent to which the provisions of this Article apply to such claims, particularly where the provisions of this Convention will have effect in respect of taxes arising or levied from a specified period of time. States wishing to limit the application of this Article to claims arising after the entry into force of the Convention may also do so during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 3
- This paragraph sets out the conditions under which a request for assistance in collection may be made. The revenue claim must be enforceable under the laws of the requesting State and must be owed by a person who, at that time, cannot prevent its collection under the laws of that State. This will be the case where the requesting State is entitled under its domestic law to collect the revenue claim and the person to whom the amount is owed has no administrative or judicial rights to prevent such collection.
- In many States, a revenue claim may be collected even where a right of appeal to an administrative authority or court concerning the merits or amount of the claim still exists. However, if the domestic law of the requested State does not allow it to collect its own revenue claims while appeals are still pending, this paragraph does not authorise it to do so in the case of revenue claims of another State in respect of which such rights of appeal still exist, even if those rights do not prevent collection in that other State. Indeed, the phrase "it shall be collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes as if the revenue claim were a revenue claim of that other State" means that the domestic law of the requested State limits the application of assistance to the collection of the revenue claim of the other State. However, many States may wish to allow assistance in collection in cases where the revenue claim may be collected in the requesting State notwithstanding the existence of a right of appeal, even if the domestic law of the requested State prevents collection in such circumstances. States wishing to do so may amend paragraph 3 as follows:
Where a revenue claim of a Contracting State is enforceable under the laws of that State and is owed by a person who, at that time, cannot prevent its collection under the laws of that State, that revenue claim shall, at the request of the competent authority of that State, be accepted for purposes of collection by the competent authority of the other Contracting State. That revenue claim shall be collected by that other State in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes as if the revenue claim were a revenue claim of that other State that satisfied the conditions allowing that other State to make a request under this paragraph.
- Paragraph 3 also regulates the manner in which the requested State receives the revenue claim of the requesting State. Except in cases concerning time limits and priority (see Commentary on paragraph 5), the requested State is obliged to collect the revenue claim of the requesting State as if it were its own revenue claim, even if, at that time, it had no need to take collection action in respect of that taxpayer for its own purposes. As already mentioned, the phrase "in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes" limits assistance to the collection of claims in respect of which no further rights of appeal exist, if, under the domestic law of the requested State, collection of that State's own revenue claims is not permitted while such rights still exist.
- It is entirely possible that a request may concern a tax that does not exist in the requested State. The requesting State shall indicate, where appropriate, the nature of the revenue claim, the components of the revenue claim, the date on which the claim expires, and the assets from which the revenue claim may be collected. The requested State will then follow the procedure applicable to a similar tax claim of its own or any other appropriate procedure if no similar tax exists.
Add a concise overview before the commentarySeparate commentary from model treaty text
Paragraph 4
19. In order to protect the rights of a Contracting State to collect taxes, this paragraph allows that State to request another State to take measures of conservancy even where it cannot yet request assistance in collection, for example, where the revenue claim is not yet enforceable or where the debtor still has the right to prevent its collection. This paragraph should only be included in Conventions between States that are able to take measures of conservancy under their own domestic laws. In addition, States that consider it inappropriate to take measures of conservancy in respect of taxes due to another State may decide not to include this paragraph in their Conventions or to restrict its scope. In some States, measures of conservancy are referred to as "interim measures", and such States are free to add these words to this paragraph in order to clarify its scope in accordance with their own terminology.
20. One example of measures to which this paragraph applies is the seizure or freezing of assets before a final judicial decision has been rendered, in order to ensure that those assets will still be available when collection may subsequently be carried out. The conditions required for taking measures of conservancy may vary from one State to another, but in all cases the amount of the revenue claim must have been determined in advance, at least provisionally or partially. A request for measures of conservancy in respect of a particular revenue claim may not be made unless the requesting State itself is able to take such measures in respect of that claim (see the Commentary on paragraph 8).
21. When making a request for measures of conservancy, the requesting State should indicate, in each particular case, what stage has been reached in the assessment or collection process. The requested State will then have to consider whether, in such a case, its own laws and administrative practice allow it to take measures of conservancy.
Paragraph 5
22. Paragraph 5 first provides that the time limits of the requested State, i.e. the time limits beyond which a revenue claim can no longer be enforced or collected, do not apply to a revenue claim in respect of which another State has made a request under paragraph 3 or 4. Since paragraph 3 refers to revenue claims that are enforceable in the requesting State, and paragraph 4 to revenue claims in respect of which the requesting State may take measures of conservancy, it follows that only the time limits of the requesting State apply.
23. Thus, as long as the revenue claim can still be enforced or collected (paragraph 3) or measures of conservancy can still be taken in respect of it (paragraph 4) in the requesting State, no objections based on the time limits provided for under the legislation of the requested State may be raised against the application of paragraph 3 or 4 to that revenue claim. States that cannot agree to disregard their own domestic time limits should amend paragraph 5 accordingly.
24. Contracting States may agree that, after a certain period of time has elapsed, the obligation to provide assistance in the collection of revenue claims shall cease to exist. This period should begin on the date of the original instrument authorising enforcement. The legislation of some States requires the renewal of the validity of the enforcement instrument, in which case the first instrument is the one that is taken into account for the purposes of calculating the period of time after which the obligation to provide assistance ceases.
25. Paragraph 5 also provides that the rules of both the requested State (first sentence) and the requesting State (second sentence), which give priority to their own revenue claims over the claims of other creditors, do not apply to a revenue claim in respect of which a request has been made under paragraph 3 or 4. Such rules are often included in domestic legislation to ensure that the tax authorities can collect taxes to the fullest extent possible.
26. The rule whereby the priority rules of the requested State do not apply to a revenue claim of another State in respect of which a request for assistance has been made applies even where the requested State must generally treat that claim as its own revenue claim under paragraphs 3 and 4. States wishing to provide that revenue claims of another State should have the same priority as that accorded to their own revenue claims may amend this paragraph by deleting the words "or giving priority" in the first sentence.
27. The words "by reason of their nature as such" in the sentence indicate that the time limits and priority rules of the requested State to which this paragraph applies are only those that specifically relate to unpaid taxes. Thus, this paragraph does not prevent the application of general rules concerning time limits or priority that would apply to all debts (for example, rules giving priority to a claim on the grounds that the claim arose or was registered before another).
Paragraph 6
28. This paragraph ensures that any legal or administrative objection concerning the existence, validity or amount of the revenue claim of the requesting State is not considered by the courts and administrative authorities of the requested State. Thus, no legal or administrative proceedings, such as a request for judicial review, may be brought in the requested State in respect of these matters. The main purpose of this rule is to prevent the administrative or judicial authorities of the requested State from being asked to decide questions concerning whether an amount, or any part thereof, is due under the domestic law of another State. States in which this paragraph may give rise to constitutional or legal difficulties may amend or exclude it during bilateral negotiations.
Paragraph 7
29. This paragraph provides that if, after a request has been made under paragraph 3 or 4, the conditions applicable when such request was made cease to apply (for example, the revenue claim ceases to be enforceable in the requesting State), the State that made the request must promptly notify the other State of this change in circumstances. Upon receipt of such notification, the requested State has the option of asking the requesting State either to suspend or to withdraw the request. If the request is suspended, the suspension must remain in effect until the State that made the request informs the other State that the conditions necessary for making a request in respect of the relevant revenue claim are once again satisfied or that it is withdrawing its request.
Paragraph 8
30. This paragraph contains certain limitations on the obligations imposed on the State receiving a request for assistance.
31. The requested State is entitled to refuse to provide assistance in the cases referred to in the preceding paragraphs. However, if it does provide assistance in those cases, it remains within the scope of this Article, and no objection may be raised that the State has failed to comply with the provisions of this Article.
32. First, this paragraph clarifies that a Contracting State is not obliged to go beyond the limits of its own domestic laws and administrative practice or those of the other State in fulfilling its obligations under this Article. Thus, if the requesting State does not have domestic powers to take measures of conservancy, the requested State may refuse to take such measures on behalf of the requesting State. Similarly, if the seizure of assets to satisfy a revenue claim is not permitted in the requested State, that State is not obliged to seize assets when providing assistance in collection under the provisions of this Article. However, the types of administrative measures permitted for taxation purposes in the requested State must be used, even if they are applied exclusively for the purpose of assisting in the collection of taxes due to the requesting State.
33. Paragraph 5 of this Article provides that the time limits established by a Contracting State shall not apply to a revenue claim in respect of which another State has requested assistance. Subparagraph a) is not intended to contradict this principle. Thus, the provision of assistance in respect of a revenue claim after the expiry of the time limit applicable in the requested State will not be considered contrary to the laws and administrative practice of that or the other Contracting State in cases where the time limits applicable to that claim have not expired in the requesting State.
34. Subparagraph b) includes a limitation on the taking of measures that would be contrary to public policy (ordre public). As in the case of Article 26 (see paragraph 19 of the Commentary on Article 26), it was considered necessary to provide for a limitation on assistance that could affect the vital interests of the State itself.
35. Under subparagraph c), a Contracting State is not obliged to comply with a request if the other State has not taken all reasonable measures for collection or conservancy, as the case may be, available under its laws or administrative practice.
36. Finally, under subparagraph d), the requested State may also reject a request for practical reasons, for example, if the costs it would incur in collecting the revenue claim of the requesting State exceed the amount of that revenue claim.
37. Some States may wish to add another limitation to this paragraph, which is already contained in the joint Council of Europe-OECD Multilateral Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters, allowing a State not to provide assistance if it considers that the taxes in respect of which assistance is requested are levied contrary to generally accepted taxation principles.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 28
CONCERNING MEMBERS OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR POSTS
1. The purpose of this provision is to ensure that members of diplomatic missions and consular posts receive, under the provisions of the Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation, treatment no less favourable than that to which they are entitled under international law or special international agreements.
2. The simultaneous application of the provisions of a Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and diplomatic and consular privileges granted under the general rules of international law or in accordance with a special international agreement may, in certain circumstances, result in tax being payable in both Contracting States which would otherwise not have been payable. By way of illustration, it may be mentioned that, for example, a diplomatic agent accredited by State A to State B and receiving royalties or dividends from sources in State A will, under international law, not be subject to tax in State B in respect of that income and may also, depending on the provisions of the bilateral Convention between the two States, be entitled, as a resident of State B, to exemption from tax levied on the income in State A. In order to avoid unintended tax benefits, the Contracting States may, on a bilateral basis, adopt an additional provision, which could be formulated as follows:
Since, by virtue of the tax privileges granted to members of diplomatic missions and consular posts under the general rules of international law or the provisions of special international agreements, income or capital is not subject to tax in the State of residence, the right to tax shall remain with the sending State.
3. In many OECD member countries, domestic legislation contains provisions under which members of diplomatic missions and consular posts stationed abroad are deemed to be residents of the State they represent for tax purposes. In bilateral relations between States where provisions of this kind apply at the domestic level, a further step may be taken by including in the Convention specific rules establishing the sending State as the State of residence, for Convention purposes, of members of diplomatic missions and consular posts of the Contracting States. The special provision proposed here could be formulated as follows:
Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 4, an individual who is a member of a diplomatic mission or consular post of a Contracting State situated in the other Contracting State or in a third State shall be deemed, for the purposes of this Convention, to be a resident of the State which he represents if:
a) under international law, he is not liable to tax in the host State in respect of income from sources outside that State or in respect of capital situated outside that State, and
b) he is subject in the sending State to the same obligations in respect of tax on his total income or capital as are residents of that State.
4. By virtue of paragraph 1 of Article 4, members of diplomatic missions and consular posts of a third State accredited to a Contracting State are not considered residents of the host State if they are subject to limited taxation in that State (see paragraph 8 of the Commentary on Article 4). This consideration also applies to international organisations established in a Contracting State and their officials, since they generally enjoy certain tax privileges either under the Convention or treaty establishing the organisation, or under an agreement between the organisation and the State in which it is established. Contracting States wishing to expressly regulate this matter or prevent undesirable tax benefits may add the following provision to this Article:
This Convention shall not apply to international organisations, their organs or officials, or to persons who are members of a diplomatic mission or consular post of a third State situated in a Contracting State and who are not residents of either of the Contracting States, in respect of taxes on income or capital.
This means that international organisations, organs or officials who are liable in a Contracting State only in respect of income from sources in that State should not benefit from the provisions of the Convention.
5. Although honorary consuls do not enjoy privileges under this Article or under the general rules of international law (there is usually only an exemption from taxation in respect of payments received as reimbursement of expenses incurred by honorary consuls on behalf of the State they represent), the Contracting States may expressly exclude honorary consular officers from the scope of this Article by bilateral agreement.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 29
CONCERNING ENTITLEMENT TO BENEFITS
I. Preliminary remarks
1. As explained in the footnote to this Article, Article 29 reflects the intention of the Contracting States, as stated in the preamble to the Convention, to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through tax evasion, including through the abuse of the provisions of international tax treaties. This intention and the wording of the Article are consistent with the minimum standard agreed upon under the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, which is described in paragraph 22 of the report "Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances", Action 6 – 2015 Final Report. In accordance with that report, the drafting of the Article depends on how the Contracting States implement this minimum standard. Depending on their own circumstances, States may adopt only the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9 of this Article, or adopt the detailed version of paragraphs 1–7 described below, which they may supplement with a rule addressing arrangements involving conduit mechanisms not covered by the provisions of the Convention, or they may prefer to include in their Conventions the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9 together with any of the options of paragraphs 1–7 described below.
2. A State may prefer the latter approach described above because it combines the flexibility of a general rule, which can prevent a large number of abusive transactions through an "automatic" rule preventing transactions that are known to raise concerns about the abuse of tax treaty provisions and which can easily be described by reference to certain characteristics (e.g. ownership by a foreign enterprise). This approach is reflected in the "simplified version" of paragraphs 1–7 set out below, which is used only in combination with the general rule in paragraph 9. Such a combination should not be interpreted as limiting the scope of the general anti-abuse rule in paragraph 9: a transaction or arrangement should not be regarded as falling outside the scope of paragraph 9 merely because the specific anti-abuse rules in paragraphs 1–7, which concern only certain cases of abuse of tax treaty provisions that can easily be identified by reference to certain characteristics, are not applicable.
3. A State may, however, prefer to address concerns relating to the abuse of tax treaty provisions without using the general anti-abuse rule contained in paragraph 9, relying instead on the specific anti-abuse rules contained in paragraphs 1–7, together with a rule addressing conduit arrangements, for which the application of these paragraphs is not necessarily required. This may arise where the domestic legislation of a State includes strict anti-abuse rules that are sufficient to address other forms of abuse of treaty provisions. States adopting this approach should ensure that the version of paragraphs 1–7 that they include in their bilateral Conventions is sufficiently robust to prevent most forms of abuse of tax treaty provisions. For this reason, the following paragraphs set out various versions of the provisions of paragraphs 1–7, with the more robust version of these paragraphs referred to above being called the "detailed version". States that do not wish to include paragraph 9 for the reasons set out in this paragraph should adopt the detailed version, as opposed to the "simplified" version, subject to any modifications mentioned in the Commentary below.
4. This Article contains provisions preventing various forms of abuse of tax treaty provisions whereby persons who are not residents of a Contracting State may establish an entity that is a resident of that State for the purpose of reducing or eliminating taxation in the other Contracting State through the benefits of a tax treaty concluded between those two States. Allowing persons who are not directly entitled to treaty benefits (e.g. a reduction or elimination of withholding taxes on dividends, interest or royalties) to obtain such benefits indirectly through the abuse of tax treaty provisions undermines the bilateral and reciprocal nature of tax treaties. If, for example, a State knows that its residents may indirectly benefit from treaties concluded by another State, it may have little incentive to grant reciprocal benefits to residents of that other State through the conclusion of a tax treaty. Furthermore, in such a case, the benefits that may be obtained indirectly may be unacceptable in light of the nature of the tax system of the first State; if, for example, that State does not levy income tax on a particular type of income, it would be unacceptable for its residents to benefit from the provisions of a tax treaty concluded between two other States that provides for a reduction or elimination of source taxation on that type of income, which was designed on the assumption that the two Contracting States would tax such income.
5. The provisions of paragraphs 1–7 are intended to deny treaty benefits in respect of structures that indirectly grant treaty benefits to persons who are not directly entitled to those benefits, while recognising that, in some cases, persons who are not residents of a Contracting State may establish an entity in that State for legitimate commercial reasons. Although these provisions apply regardless of whether a particular structure was adopted for the purpose of abusing tax treaty provisions or not, the Article allows the competent authority of a Contracting State to grant treaty benefits where other provisions of this Article deny those benefits, but the competent authority determines that obtaining benefits under this Convention was not one of the principal purposes of the structure.
6. This Article limits the general scope of application of the other provisions of the Convention, including the provisions of Article 1, under which the Convention applies to persons who are residents of a Contracting State. Paragraph 1 of this Article provides that a resident of a Contracting State is not entitled to benefits under the Convention unless that resident is a "qualified person" under paragraph 2 or unless benefits are granted under the provisions of paragraphs 3, 4, 5 or 6. Paragraph 2 determines who may constitute a "qualified person", based on the nature or characteristics of various categories of persons; any person to whom this paragraph applies is entitled to all the benefits of the Convention. Under paragraph 3, a person is entitled to benefits under this Convention with respect to an item of income, even if that person is not a "qualified person" under paragraph 2, if that item of income is derived from the active conduct of a business in the State of residence of that person (subject to certain exceptions). Paragraph 4 is a "derivative benefits" provision, which allows certain entities owned by residents of third States to obtain treaty benefits, provided that those residents would be entitled to equivalent benefits if they had invested directly. Paragraph 5 is a "headquarters company" provision, under which a company that is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 may nevertheless claim benefits under certain Articles in respect of certain items of income. Paragraph 6 includes provisions allowing the competent authorities of a Contracting State to grant treaty benefits where other provisions of this Article deny those benefits. Paragraph 7 includes a number of definitions applicable for the purposes of this Article.
Paragraph 1: provision restricting the treaty benefits of a resident of a Contracting State who is a "qualified person".
Simplified and detailed versions
1. Unless otherwise provided in this Article, a resident of a Contracting State shall not be entitled to a benefit that would otherwise be granted under this Convention (other than a benefit under paragraph 3 of Article 4, paragraph 2 of Article 9 or Article 25) unless such resident is a "qualified person", as defined in paragraph 2, at the time when the benefit would be granted.
Commentary on Paragraph 1 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions
1. Paragraph 1 of both the Simplified and Detailed Versions provides that a resident of a Contracting State, as defined in Article 4, is entitled to the benefits granted to residents of a Contracting State under the Convention only if it is a “qualified person” under paragraph 2 or if the benefits are otherwise granted under paragraphs 3, 4, 5 or 6. The benefits granted to a resident of a Contracting State under the Convention include all limitations on the taxation rights of the Contracting States under Articles 6–22, the elimination of double taxation provided for in Article 23, and the protection afforded to residents of a Contracting State under Article 24. This Article does not limit the availability of treaty benefits under paragraph 3 of Article 4, paragraph 2 of Article 9 or Article 25, or under certain provisions of the Convention that do not require a person to be a resident of a Contracting State in order to benefit from those provisions (for example, the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 24 to the extent that they apply to citizens who are not residents of the Contracting States). Although the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 7 share the general characteristics of paragraph 2 of Article 9, the availability of the benefits provided for in paragraph 3 of Article 7 is limited by paragraph 1 of Article 29, since the elimination of double taxation under Article 7 depends to a large extent on the provisions of paragraph 2 of this Article (see paragraphs 40–57 of the Commentary on Article 7), and it would be unreasonable to be more generous with respect to the benefits granted under paragraph 3 of Article 7 than with respect to the benefits granted under paragraph 2 of this Article.
8. Paragraph 1 in no way expands the scope of the benefits granted by other provisions of the Convention. Thus, a resident of a Contracting State who is a “qualified person” under paragraph 2 must still satisfy the conditions of the other provisions of the Convention in order to obtain those benefits (for example, such resident must be the beneficial owner of dividends in order to benefit from the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 10), and such benefits may be denied or limited in accordance with applicable anti-abuse rules, such as those in paragraphs 8 and 9.
9. Paragraph 1 applies whenever the Convention otherwise grants benefits to a resident of a Contracting State. Thus, for example, it applies when income to which Article 6 applies is derived by a resident of a Contracting State, when dividends to which Article 10 applies are paid to a resident of a Contracting State, or at any time when profits to which Article 7 applies are derived. This paragraph requires that, in order to be entitled to the benefits provided for under the relevant provision of the Convention, a resident of a Contracting State must be a “qualified person” within the meaning of paragraph 2 at the relevant point in time. However, in certain cases, the definition of a “qualified person” requires that a resident of a Contracting State satisfy certain conditions over a specified period of time in order to be considered a “qualified person” at a given point in time.
10. Since the definition of an “equivalent beneficiary”, which is to be used for the purposes of paragraph 4 of the Detailed Version concerning derivative benefits, excludes persons who, under another convention, are entitled to an exemption from taxation by the State of source that is not as favourable as the exemption provided for under the Convention, this definition has what is known as a “cliff effect”, depriving such persons of all treaty benefits, even if the difference between the exemptions granted under the two conventions is relatively insignificant. In such cases, some States consider it appropriate to provide an exemption from taxation by the State of source that is equivalent to the exemption available under the other convention. Such treatment may be achieved through alternative provisions included in paragraph 147 below, which relate to the taxation of dividends, interest and royalties and constitute provisions that mitigate the so-called “cliff effect” where a potential equivalent beneficiary under another convention is entitled to limitations on taxation by the State of source that are less favourable than those provided for under the Convention. Instead of denying all treaty benefits with respect to such income, these provisions grant limited benefits that generally correspond to those that may be available under the other convention. To ensure that paragraph 1 does not prohibit the benefits granted under these alternative provisions, which would be contrary to the purpose of those provisions, such States should adopt another version of paragraph 1, which should be worded as follows:
Except as provided in this Article and in [reference to the paragraphs of Articles 10, 11 and 12 that relate to the so-called “cliff effect”], a resident of a Contracting State shall not be entitled to the benefits otherwise granted under this Convention (other than the benefits under paragraph 3 of Article 4, paragraph 2 of Article 9 or Article 25) unless such resident is a “qualified person”, as defined in paragraph 2, at the time the benefit is granted.
Paragraph 2: Situations in Which a Resident Is a Qualified Person
Simplified and Detailed Versions
2. A resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person at the time when the Convention would otherwise grant benefits if, at that time, the resident is:
Commentary on the Preamble to Paragraph 2 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions
11. Each of the subparagraphs of paragraph 2 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions describes a category of residents who are qualified persons at the time they claim the relevant treaty benefits.
12. The provisions of paragraph 2 are intended to take effect immediately. Unlike the provisions of paragraph 5 (Simplified Version) / paragraph 6 (Detailed Version), discussed below, a claim to benefits under paragraph 2 does not require a prior decision or approval by the competent authority. Of course, following an examination, the tax authorities may determine that the taxpayer has incorrectly interpreted this paragraph and is not entitled to the benefits claimed.
Subparagraph a): Individuals
Simplified and Detailed Versions
a) an individual;
Commentary on Subparagraph a) of Paragraph 2 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions
13. Subparagraph a) of both the Simplified and Detailed Versions provides that any individual who is a resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person. As explained in paragraph 61 below, under certain provisions of a treaty, a collective investment vehicle must be treated as an individual for the purposes of applying the relevant treaty; in such a case, that collective investment vehicle will constitute a qualified person under subparagraph a).
Subparagraph b): Contracting States, Political Subdivisions, Their Authorities and Agencies
Simplified and Detailed Versions
b) a Contracting State, any political subdivision or local authority thereof, or any agency or instrumentality of such State, political subdivision or local authority;
Commentary on Subparagraph b) of Paragraph 2 of the Simplified and Detailed Versions
14. Subparagraph b) of both the Simplified and Detailed Versions provides that the Contracting States and any of their political subdivisions or local authorities are qualified persons. This applies to any part of a State, for example, a separate fund established by the State that is not a separate person and is not owned by it. Under the last part of this subparagraph, a separate legal entity that is a resident of a Contracting State and is an agency or instrumentality of a Contracting State, its political subdivision or local authority is also a qualified person and, therefore, is entitled to all the benefits of the Convention for as long as it qualifies as such. The concept of an “agency or instrumentality” is limited to organizations established by the State (or its political subdivision or local authority) to perform functions of an exclusively governmental nature; it does not apply, for example, to a company that acts as an agent of the State for certain purposes but was not established by the State to perform functions of a governmental nature. The wording of this subparagraph may need to be modified to reflect the different legal nature that State-owned enterprises, such as sovereign wealth funds, may have in the Contracting States, as well as the different views that those States may hold regarding the application of Article 4 to such organizations (see paragraphs 50–53 of the Commentary on Article 1 and paragraphs 8.5 and 8.11 of the Commentary on Article 4).
Subparagraph c): Publicly Traded Companies and Organizations
Simplified Version
c) a company or other entity, if the principal class of its shares is regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges;
Detailed Version
c) a company or other entity, if, throughout the taxable period that includes that time, the principal class of its shares (and any disproportionate class of shares) is regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges, and either:
(i) its principal class of shares is primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or entity is a resident; or
(ii) the company's or entity's primary place of management and control is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident;
Commentary on Subparagraph c) of Paragraph 2 of the Simplified Version
15. Subparagraph c) of the Simplified Version states that, since the shares of publicly traded companies and certain entities are generally widely available to the public, such companies and entities are unlikely to be established for the purpose of abusing the provisions of tax treaties.
The terms “shares”, “principal class of shares” and “recognized stock exchange” are defined in paragraph 6; as indicated in the definition of “shares”, this term includes comparable equity interests in entities other than companies to which this subparagraph applies; this includes, for example, listed unit trusts.
Commentary on Subparagraph c) of Paragraph 2 of the Detailed Version
16. Subparagraph c) states that, since the shares of publicly traded companies and certain entities are generally widely available to the public, there is little likelihood that such companies and entities are established for the purpose of abusing the provisions of tax treaties.
17. Subparagraph c) provides that a company or entity that is a resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person at the time the benefits of the Convention are granted if, throughout the taxable period that includes that time, its principal class of shares and any disproportionate class of shares are regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges, provided that the company or entity also satisfies at least one of the following additional requirements: the company's or entity's principal class of shares is primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or entity is a resident, or the company's or entity's primary place of management and control is in the country of its residence. These additional requirements take into account the fact that, although a publicly traded company or entity may technically be a resident of a particular State, it may not have sufficient connections with that State to justify allowing such company or entity to obtain treaty benefits concluded by that State. Such connections may be established by the fact that the shares of the publicly traded company or entity are primarily traded on recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or entity; given the fact that the internationalization of financial markets means that the shares of companies listed on stock exchanges and resident in certain States are often traded on foreign stock exchanges, the alternative criterion provides that this connection may also be established by the fact that the company or entity is primarily managed and controlled in its State of residence.
18. A company or entity whose principal class of shares is regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange will nevertheless not be entitled to benefits under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 if it has a disproportionate class of shares that is not regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange.
19. The terms “recognized stock exchange”, “shares”, “principal class of shares” and “disproportionate class of shares” are defined in paragraph 7. As indicated in these definitions, the term “shares” includes comparable equity interests in entities other than companies to which the subparagraph applies; this includes, for example, listed unit trusts.
20. The regular trading requirement may be satisfied by trading the issued shares on any recognized exchange or exchanges located in any State. Trading on one or more recognized stock exchanges may be aggregated for the purposes of this requirement; thus, a company or entity may satisfy this requirement if its shares are regularly traded, wholly or partly, on a recognized stock exchange located in another Contracting State.
21. Subdivision (i) includes an additional requirement that the shares of the company or entity be primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or entity. As a general rule, the principal class of shares of a company or entity is “primarily traded” on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of that company or entity if, during the relevant taxable year, the number of shares of the principal class of shares of the company or entity traded on those stock exchanges exceeds the number of shares of the principal class of shares of the company or entity traded on established securities markets in any other State. Some States, however, consider that the shares of a company or entity that is a resident of one Contracting State are primarily traded on recognized stock exchanges located in other States (for example, in a State that is part of the European Economic Area, within which the rules governing stock exchanges and securities create a single securities trading market), which provides sufficient protection against the use of such company or entity for the purpose of abusing the provisions of tax treaties; States sharing this view may modify subdivision (i) accordingly.
22. Subdivision (ii) provides an alternative requirement applicable to a company or entity whose principal class of shares is regularly traded on recognized stock exchanges but is traded to only a limited extent on recognized stock exchanges located in the State of residence of the company or entity. Such a company or entity may qualify for treaty benefits if its “primary place of management and control” (as defined in paragraph 7) is located in its State of residence.
23. The requirements of subparagraph c) must be satisfied throughout the taxable period of the company or entity. It is not necessary for the shares of the company or entity to be traded on the relevant stock exchanges every day of the relevant period. In order for shares to be considered regularly traded on one or more stock exchanges during a taxable period, more than a minimal percentage of the shares must be actively traded on a sufficiently large number of days included in that period. This criterion will be satisfied if, for example, 10% of the average number of outstanding shares of a particular class of shares of the company are sold during 60 trading days occurring within the company's taxable period. The expression “taxable period” in subparagraphs c) and f) refers to the period for which an annual tax return must be filed in the State of residence of the company or entity. If the Contracting States have a concept in their domestic law corresponding to “taxable period” in their domestic legislation, such as “tax year”, they may replace the reference to taxable period with another term.
Subparagraph d) (Detailed Version): Subsidiaries of Publicly Traded Companies and Organizations
Detailed Version Only
d) a company, if:
(i) throughout the taxable period that includes that time, at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of the shares (and at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) in the company are owned directly or indirectly by five or fewer companies or entities entitled to benefits under subparagraph c) of this paragraph, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a resident of the Contracting State from which it receives benefits under this Convention; and
(ii) with respect to the benefits under this Convention, other than Article 10, less than 50 per cent of the company's gross income and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident (excluding payments made to unrelated persons in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e);
Commentary on Subparagraph d) of Paragraph 2 of the Detailed Version
24. Subparagraph d) extends the principle underlying subparagraph c) (i.e. that publicly traded companies and entities are unlikely to be established for the purpose of obtaining benefits under tax treaties) to certain companies in which five or fewer publicly traded companies and entities hold a controlling interest, subject to additional conditions.
25. In order for a company that is a resident of a Contracting State to be entitled to all the benefits of the Convention under subparagraph d) at a given point in time, that company must satisfy two conditions applicable to the taxable period that includes that point in time.
26. First, under subdivision (i), the company must satisfy the ownership test. Under this test, five or fewer publicly traded companies or entities described in subparagraph c) must, throughout the relevant taxable period, be the direct or indirect owners of at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of the company's shares (and at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares). However, if the publicly traded companies or entities are indirect owners, each of the intermediate companies or entities must either be a resident of the Contracting State from which the benefits are derived under this Convention or be a “qualified intermediate owner”. The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7; under that definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company claiming benefits under subparagraph d).
27. Thus, for example, a company that is a resident of a Contracting State satisfies the requirements of subdivision (i) if it is wholly owned by a company that is a resident of the same State and satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). Furthermore, if a publicly traded parent company of another Contracting State indirectly owns a company through a chain of subsidiaries, each such subsidiary in the chain, acting as an intermediate owner, must be a resident of the Contracting State receiving benefits under this Convention or a qualified intermediate owner in order for the company to satisfy the ownership test in subdivision (i).
28. The expression “50 per cent of the total voting power and value of the shares”, which is used in subparagraphs d) and f) and in other parts of paragraphs 1 to 7, refers to an interest representing at least 50 per cent of all the voting rights in the relevant company or entity and at least 50 per cent of the value of all the shares of that company or entity. Thus, this criterion will not be satisfied by an interest that meets the voting requirement without meeting the value requirement (or vice versa).
29. Under the second condition, included in subdivision (ii), the company must also satisfy the base erosion test with respect to any treaty benefits it claims (other than benefits with respect to dividends under Article 10). The base erosion test is considered to be satisfied if:
- less than 50 per cent of the company's gross income (and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group, if any) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, to persons in the form of payments deductible in calculating the company's tax base in its State of residence; and
- less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested company (if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, to inappropriate persons in the form of payments deductible from the tax base in the State of residence of the company claiming treaty benefits.
30. The term “inappropriate persons”, used in the preceding paragraph, refers to any persons other than residents of each Contracting State who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2. Consequently, organizations that are residents of the Contracting States and are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to this subparagraph or subparagraph f) of paragraph 2 are not entitled to benefits; this ensures that such organizations are not involved in arrangements that may allow investors from third countries to indirectly accumulate a significant amount of base-eroding payments made by the company seeking benefits under this subparagraph. Paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income”, which are used in subdivision (ii).
31. For the purposes of determining whether the base erosion test is satisfied, deductible payments do not include arm's-length amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property. To the extent that they are deductible from the tax base, trust distributions constitute deductible payments. A tax depreciation deduction that does not represent a payment to or accrual in favour of another person is not taken into account for this purpose. Furthermore, in the case of a tested group, deductible payments do not include intra-group payments. Finally, interest payments are not arm's-length amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and will therefore be taken into account if they are made to an inappropriate person.
32. The following examples illustrate the application of the base erosion test under subdivision (ii) of subparagraph d) by a Contracting State (referred to in the examples as the “first-mentioned State”), taking into account the definitions of “tested group” and “gross income” in paragraph 7:
— Example A: Assume that, at any given time, R3 is a company wholly owned by another company, R2, which in turn is wholly owned by R1, a publicly traded company that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). R3, R2 and R1 are all residents of the other Contracting State under Article 4, and all are members of the same consolidated taxpayer group. The ownership test in subdivision (i) of subparagraph d) is satisfied because R1, a company that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c), indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of R3 (and at least 50 per cent of the total voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares of R3), and R2, which is an intermediate owner, is a resident of the other Contracting State and is therefore a qualified intermediate owner.
During the taxable period that includes the time when the benefit is otherwise granted by the first-mentioned State, R3 receives: 200 in dividends from a company resident in a third State, which are excluded from R3's gross income in the other Contracting State; and 100 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State, for which R3 claims benefits under Article 11 of the Convention. R3 makes a base-eroding payment of 49 to an inappropriate person and pays dividends of 51 to R2. In addition to the dividend of 51 that it receives from R3, R2 receives additional gross receipts of 100 from persons outside the tested group. R2 makes a base-eroding payment of 51 to an inappropriate person.
In this example, the tested group, as defined in paragraph 7, consists of R3, R2 and R1, since the three companies participate in tax consolidation. In order to be entitled to benefits with respect to the interest arising in the first-mentioned State, R3 and the tested group must satisfy the base erosion test under subdivision (ii).
R3's gross income, as defined in paragraph 7, amounts to 100 (interest arising in the first-mentioned State), since the dividends of 200 paid to R3 by a company in a third State are excluded. Thus, during the taxable period in which R3 claims benefits, less than 50 of R3's gross income is attributable to payments to inappropriate persons. R3 has made only 49 in base-eroding payments and therefore satisfies the part of the base erosion test that applies to it.
The gross income of the tested group, calculated in accordance with tax law, excludes the 200 in dividends paid to R3 by a company in a third State, as well as intra-group transactions (i.e. the dividend of 51 from R3 to R2). Thus, the gross income of the tested group amounts to 200 (100 in interest arising in the first-mentioned State, plus 100 received by R2 from persons outside the tested group). Accordingly, during the taxable period under consideration, the tested group must make less than 100 in base-eroding payments to inappropriate persons in order to satisfy the base erosion test under subdivision (ii).
In this example, R3 does not satisfy the requirements of subparagraph d). Although R3 made 49 in base-eroding payments to inappropriate persons, and this amount does not exceed the permissible limit of less than 50, the total amount of base-eroding payments made by the tested group to inappropriate persons, amounting to 100 (49 + 51), exceeds the permissible limit for base-eroding payments to inappropriate persons for the tested group.
— Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A, except that R3 receives 100 in dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State, rather than interest arising in that State, and has no other gross income during the taxable period. Since the treaty benefits and benefits sought by R3 under Article 10 relate to dividends, R3 is not required to apply the base erosion test under subdivision (ii). Accordingly, R3 is a qualified person with respect to dividends under subparagraph d), since it satisfies the ownership test in subdivision (i).
— Example C: Assume that, at any given time, P2 (the relevant company) is a company wholly owned by P1, a publicly traded company that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c). P2 and P1 are residents of the other Contracting State.
During the taxable period under consideration, P2's only income consists of interest of 100 arising in the first-mentioned State, with respect to which P2 claims benefits under Article 11. P2 makes a deductible interest payment of 100 to P1, a person satisfying the requirements of subparagraph c). P1 makes a deductible payment of 100 during the same taxable period to a third company, a company resident in State Y. P2 has indirectly made, through P1, a base-eroding payment of 100 to an inappropriate person. In this example, the base erosion test under subdivision (ii) is not satisfied, and P2 is not a qualified person.
33. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that provisions should be included in their tax treaties prohibiting the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) that benefit from legal regimes constituting “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1), and prohibiting the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from provisions of domestic law providing for a notional deduction in respect of equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). These States may wish to modify the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) to include in the category of “impermissible recipients” persons who, although they are residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions in respect of deductible payments made or accrued to them. This may be done by modifying subdivision (ii) as follows:
(ii) with respect to benefits under this Convention, other than Article 10, less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the company and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible in that taxable period for the purposes of taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident (excluding commercial payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions)
A) to persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e);
B) to persons related to a person described in this subparagraph and benefiting from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”] of this Convention, in respect of the deduction from the tax base; or in respect of the payment of interest
C) to persons related to a person referred to in this subparagraph and benefiting from the notional deductions referred to in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions in respect of equity].
34. The following example illustrates the application of the alternative wording of the base erosion test included in the preceding paragraph:
— Example: assume the same facts as in Example B in paragraph 32 above, except that the only type of income of R3 is 100 in royalties arising in the State from which treaty benefits are requested, in respect of which R3 claims benefits under Article 12. R3 makes a deductible royalty payment of 100 to R1. At all times, R1 benefits from a special tax regime (as defined in this Convention) in respect of royalties.
The ownership condition in subdivision (i) of subparagraph d) is satisfied because R1, a company meeting the requirements of subparagraph c), indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of R3 and R2 is a qualified intermediate owner. However, even though R1 is a person meeting the requirements of subparagraph c), the deductible royalty paid by R3 to R1 is a base-eroding payment because R1 is an impermissible recipient. R1 is a related person in relation to R3 and benefits from a special tax regime in respect of royalty income. In this example, R3 does not satisfy the base erosion test under subdivision (ii), because R3 made base-eroding payments of 100 to a person benefiting from a special tax regime, and the amount of 100 exceeds the limit of base-eroding payments to impermissible recipients permitted for R3 (this limit is exceeded if the amount of such payments is at least 50).
35. However, other States may consider that there is no need to introduce a base erosion test under subdivision (ii) in the case of companies that are mainly owned by publicly traded companies or entities. Accordingly, these States may wish to omit subparagraph d) and use the following version of subparagraph c), which would cover both publicly traded companies or entities and companies in which five or fewer publicly traded companies or entities hold a controlling interest (States adopting this approach should also renumber the subsequent subparagraphs of paragraph 2 and replace references to “subparagraph c)” with references to “subdivision (i) of subparagraph c)” in the wording of the “base erosion”, “derivative benefits” and headquarters company rules, in order to avoid the problem described in paragraph 30 above):
c) a company or entity, if, during the taxable period that includes that time
(i) its principal class of shares (and any disproportionate class of shares) is regularly traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges, and either:
A) its principal class of shares is primarily traded on one or more recognized stock exchanges located in the Contracting State of which the company or entity is a resident; or
B) the company's or entity's primary place of management and control is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident; or
(ii) at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the shares (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company or entity is directly or indirectly owned by five or fewer companies or entities entitled to benefits pursuant to subdivision (i) of this subparagraph, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a resident of the Contracting State from which benefits are requested under this Convention or is a qualified intermediate owner
Subparagraph d) (Simplified version)/e) (Detailed version): Non-profit organizations and recognized pension funds
Simplified version
d) a person other than an individual that:
(i) is [agreed description of the relevant non-profit organizations in each Contracting State],
(ii) is a recognized pension fund;
Detailed version
e) a person other than an individual that:
(i) is [agreed description of the relevant non-profit organizations in each Contracting State],
(ii) is a recognized pension fund to which subdivision (i) of the definition of recognized pension fund in paragraph 1 of Article 3 applies, provided that more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in that person are owned by individuals who are residents of either Contracting State or more than [percentage] of the beneficial interests in that person are owned by persons resident in a Contracting State or in any other State, in respect of which the following conditions are satisfied
A) persons who are residents of that other State are entitled to benefits under a comprehensive tax convention for the avoidance of double taxation between that other State and the State from which benefits are requested under this Convention, and
B) with respect to income referred to in Articles 10 and 11 of this Convention, if the person were a resident of that other State entitled to all the benefits of that other Convention, that person would be entitled under that Convention to a tax rate in respect of the particular class of income for which benefits are requested under this Convention that is not lower than the rate applicable under this Convention; or
(iii) is a recognized pension fund to which subdivision (ii) of the definition of recognized pension fund in paragraph 1 of Article 3 applies, provided that it is established and operated exclusively or almost exclusively for the purpose of investing funds for the benefit of organizations or arrangements referred to in the preceding subdivision;
Commentary on subparagraph d) of paragraph 2 of the Simplified version
36. Subparagraph d) of the Simplified version establishes rules under which certain non-profit organizations (to the extent that they qualify as residents of a Contracting State, as explained in paragraph 8.11 of the Commentary on Article 4) and recognized pension funds are entitled to all the benefits of the Convention.
37. The description of these entities, which is included in subdivision (i) in respect of each State, refers to the provisions of the domestic law of the State describing these entities or to domestic-law factors that make it possible to identify these entities. Depending on the wording used, States may also wish to modify subdivision (i) to allow their competent authorities subsequently to agree on a modification or addition to the description provided.
38. Subdivision (ii) refers to any organization that qualifies as a “recognized pension fund” under the definition of that term in paragraph 1 of Article 3.
Commentary on subparagraph d) of paragraph 2 of the Detailed version
39. Subparagraph e) of the Detailed version establishes rules under which certain non-profit organizations (to the extent that they qualify as residents of a Contracting State, as explained in paragraph 8.11 of the Commentary on Article 4) and certain recognized pension funds are entitled to all the benefits of the Convention.
40. The entities described in subdivision (i) automatically qualify for treaty benefits regardless of the place of residence of their beneficiaries or members. These organizations generally correspond to those that do not pay taxes in their State of residence and are established and operated exclusively for the performance of certain social functions (for example, charitable, scientific, artistic, cultural or educational functions). The description of these entities, which is included in subdivision (i) in respect of each State, usually refers to the provisions of the domestic law of that State describing these entities or to domestic-law factors that make it possible to identify these entities. Depending on the wording used, States may also wish to modify subdivision (i) to allow their competent authorities subsequently to agree on a modification or addition to the description provided.
41. Under subdivision (ii), a recognized pension fund falling within subdivision (i) of the definition of that term in paragraph 1 of Article 3 (which is part of the definition applicable to an organization that manages or provides supplementary pension benefits for individuals) is entitled to treaty benefits if more than 50 per cent of the beneficial interests in that person are owned by individuals resident in one of the Contracting States, or if more than a specified percentage of those beneficial interests, to be determined in the course of bilateral negotiations, are owned by residents or individuals who are residents of third States, provided that, in the latter case, two additional conditions are met: those persons are entitled to benefits under a comprehensive tax convention concluded between that third State and the State of source, and that Convention provides for a similar or greater reduction of taxes withheld at source on interest and dividends received by pension funds of that third State. For the purposes of this provision, the term “beneficial interests in that person” should be understood as referring to the interests held by persons entitled to receive pension benefits from the fund. Some States, however, consider that the risk that recognized pension funds may abuse the provisions of tax treaties does not justify the costs of requiring funds to determine the treaty residence and entitlement to benefits of persons entitled to receive pension benefits. States sharing this view may modify subdivisions (ii) and (iii) accordingly and may, for example, replace these two subdivisions with one stating that the person “is a recognized pension fund”, which, like the provision contained in the Simplified version, would ensure that any recognized pension fund falling within the definition contained in paragraph 1 of Article 3 would automatically be considered a “qualified person”.
42. Subdivision (iii) applies to so-called “funds of funds”, which are referred to in subdivision (ii) of the definition of “recognized pension fund” in paragraph 1 of Article 3. These are funds that do not directly provide pension benefits to individuals but are established and used to invest funds on behalf of recognized pension funds that themselves fall within subdivision (i) of the definition of “recognized pension fund”. Subdivision (iii) applies only if substantially all of the income of such a “fund of funds” is derived from investments made for the benefit of recognized pension funds that qualify for benefits under subdivision (ii).
Subparagraph e) (Simplified version)/f) (Detailed version): Base erosion/ownership
Simplified version
e) a person other than an individual, if, at that time and on at least half of the days of a twelve-month period that includes that time, persons who are residents of that Contracting State and entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a) to d) own, directly or indirectly, at least 50 per cent of the shares in the person;
Detailed version
f) a person other than an individual, if
(i) at that time and on at least half of the days of a twelve-month period that includes that time, persons who are residents of that Contracting State and entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) own, directly or indirectly, shares representing at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) of the shares in that person, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualified intermediate owner, and
(ii) less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the person and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the person is a resident (excluding commercial payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions) to persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of this paragraph;
Commentary on subparagraph e) of paragraph 2 of the Simplified version
43. Subparagraph e) of the Simplified version provides an additional method of qualifying for treaty benefits, which applies to any form of organization that is a resident of a Contracting State. Under this subparagraph, any organization that is a resident of a Contracting State is entitled to treaty benefits if, at the time when the relevant treaty benefits would otherwise be granted, and on at least half of the days of a twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 50 per cent of the shares in that organization are owned, directly or indirectly, by persons who are residents of that Contracting State and who are themselves entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to the preceding subparagraphs of paragraph 2 (i.e. subparagraphs a), b), c) or d) of the Simplified version).
44. According to the definition of the term “shares” in paragraph 7, this term covers comparable interests in organizations other than companies to which this subparagraph applies; this includes, for example, mutual funds.
45. Unlike the corresponding provision in subparagraph f) of the Detailed version, subparagraph e) of the Simplified version does not require the enterprise to also satisfy the base erosion test. Furthermore, in the case of indirect ownership, it imposes no requirements applicable to intermediate owners.
Commentary on subparagraph e) of paragraph 2 of the Detailed version
46. Subparagraph f) of the Detailed version provides an additional method of qualifying for treaty benefits, which applies to any form of organization that is a resident of a Contracting State. The test provided for in subparagraph f), the so-called ownership and base erosion test, consists of two parts; both parts must be satisfied for a resident to be entitled to treaty benefits under subparagraph f).
47. Under subdivision (i), which forms part of the ownership test, 50 per cent or more of the aggregate voting power and value of the issued shares (and at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of any disproportionate class of shares) must be owned, directly or indirectly, at the time when the relevant treaty benefit would otherwise be granted and on at least half of the days of the twelve-month period that includes that time, by persons who are residents of the Contracting State and who are entitled to treaty benefits pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e).
However, in the case of indirect owners, each intermediate owner must be a qualified intermediate owner. The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7; under this definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company claiming benefits under subparagraph f).
48. Although subparagraph f) generally applies to privately held companies, it may also apply to an entity such as, for example, a trust company that is a resident of a Contracting State and otherwise satisfies the requirements of the subparagraph. According to the definition of shares in paragraph 7, the reference to “shares” in the case of entities other than companies means interests comparable to shares; this generally concerns beneficial interests in a trust company. For the purposes of subdivision (i), beneficial interests in a trust company are treated as being owned by its beneficiaries in proportion to each beneficiary's actuarial percentage of the trust company. The interest of a beneficiary entitled to the remainder of the trust is equal to 100 per cent less the aggregate percentages held by income beneficiaries. A beneficiary's interest in a trust is not considered to be owned by a person entitled to benefits pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) if the beneficiary's actuarial percentage cannot be determined. Consequently, if the actuarial percentages of the beneficiaries of a trust cannot be determined, the ownership test under subdivision (i) cannot be satisfied unless all possible beneficiaries are persons entitled to benefits pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e).
49. Subdivision (ii) forms part of the base erosion test, which is generally similar to the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph d), except for the fact that, unlike that other test, it also applies to a person seeking benefits under Article 10. For the purposes of subdivision (ii), such a person includes in its gross income any dividends received, even if the dividends are actually exempt from taxation in the State of residence of that person. This is provided for in subdivision (i) of the definition of “gross income” in paragraph 7.
50. The term “impermissible recipients”, used in the preceding paragraph, refers to all persons other than residents of either Contracting State who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2. In addition, paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income”, which are used in subdivision (ii).
51. The base erosion test in subdivision (ii), unlike the test in subparagraph d), applies where a person wishes to obtain benefits provided for in Article 10. For the purposes of subdivision (ii), such a person includes in its gross income any dividends received, even if the dividends are actually exempt from taxation in the State of residence of that person. This is provided for in subdivision (i) of the definition of “gross income” in paragraph 7.
52. As in the case of the base erosion test in subparagraph d), for the purposes of applying the test in subdivision (ii), deductible (i.e. base-reducing) payments do not include commercial amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business in respect of services or tangible property. To the extent that they are deductible from the taxable base under the tax law of the State of residence of the person, trust distributions constitute such base-eroding payments. Depreciation charges that do not constitute payments to or accruals in favour of other persons are not taken into account for the purposes of subdivision (ii). Furthermore, in the case of a tested group, deductible payments do not include intra-group payments. Finally, interest payments are not commercial amounts paid or accrued in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and are therefore taken into account if made to an impermissible recipient.
53. As explained in paragraph 33 above, which applies to the base erosion test in subparagraph d), States that do not wish to apply specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons benefiting from regimes that constitute “special tax regimes”, and that refuse to apply Article 11 to interest paid to related persons benefiting from provisions of domestic law providing for notional deductions in respect of equity, may also wish to modify the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) to include in the category of “impermissible recipients” persons who, although they are residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions in respect of deductible payments made or accrued to them. This may be done by modifying subdivision (ii) as follows:
(ii) less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the company and less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group for the taxable period that includes that time is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible in that taxable period for the purposes of taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident (excluding commercial payments made in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions)
A) to persons who are not residents of either Contracting State and who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e);
B) to persons related to a person described in this subparagraph who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”], in respect of the deduction; or
C) in respect of the payment of interest, to persons related to a person described in this subparagraph who benefit from the deductions described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions in respect of equity];
54. The following examples illustrate the application of the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph f) by a Contracting State (referred to in the examples as the “first-mentioned State”), taking into account the definitions of “tested group” and “gross income” in paragraph 7: \
- Example A: Assume that at any time R2 (the organization seeking treaty benefits under subparagraph f)) is a wholly owned subsidiary of R1, which, in turn, is wholly owned by Z, an individual. R1, R2 and Z are residents of the other Contracting State within the meaning of Article 4. R2 and R1 are members of the same tax consolidated group. The ownership test in subdivision (i) of subparagraph f) is satisfied because Z, a qualified person under subparagraph a), indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of R2, and R1 is a qualified intermediate owner. During the relevant taxable period, R2 has 50 of tax-exempt dividends paid by a company resident in a third State and 50 of interest arising in the first-mentioned State. R2 pays deductible interest of 24 to an inappropriate person and pays 51 in dividends to R1. In addition to the 51 in dividends that it receives from R2, R1 receives additional income of 100 from persons outside the tested group. R1 makes a deductible interest payment of 51 to an inappropriate person. R2 claims benefits under Article 11 of the Convention, but not under Article 10. For the purposes of applying the base erosion test to the tested group, the tested group consists of R1 and R2. The gross income of the tested group for this purpose is 150 (50 of interest arising in the first-mentioned State, plus 100 of additional income from persons outside the tested group). R2 made a base-eroding payment of 24, and R1 made a base-eroding payment of 51 to inappropriate persons. The base-eroding payments of the tested group amount to 75 (24 + 51), which is at least 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group of 150. Accordingly, the base erosion test is not satisfied, and R2 is not a qualified person under subparagraph e).
- Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A above, except that the income in respect of which R2 seeks to qualify is 50 of dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State, instead of 50 of interest arising in that State. For this purpose, the gross income of R2 is 100 (50 of dividends paid by a company resident in a third State and 50 of dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State). The gross income of the tested group is 200 (R2's gross income of 100 plus R1's income of 100 from persons outside the tested group). R2 made a base-eroding payment of 24, and R1 made a base-eroding payment of 51. The base-eroding payments of R2 amount to 24, which is less than 50 per cent of R2's gross income of 100. In addition, the base-eroding payments of the tested group in total amount to 75 (24 + 51), which is less than 50 per cent of the gross income of the tested group of 200. Accordingly, in this example, the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) is satisfied, and R2 is a qualified person under subparagraph f) for the purposes of obtaining the lower rate of taxation on dividends paid by a company resident in the first-mentioned State.
Subparagraph g): Collective investment vehicles
Expanded version only
g) [possible provision on collective investment vehicles]¹
Commentary on subparagraph g) of paragraph 2 of the expanded version
55. As indicated in the footnote to subparagraph g), whether a specific rule concerning collective investment vehicles (CIVs) should be included in paragraph 2, and if so, how that rule should be drafted, depends on how the Convention applies to CIVs and on the use of CIVs in each Contracting State.² Although such a rule is not required in respect of an entity that otherwise constitutes a "qualified person" under other parts of paragraph 2, a specific rule is often required because a CIV may not be entitled to treaty benefits under any of the other provisions of paragraph 2, or under paragraphs 3, 4 or 5, because:
¹ This subparagraph should be drafted (or omitted) on the basis of how collective investment vehicles are treated under the Convention and how they are used and treated in each Contracting State: see the Commentary on this subparagraph and paragraphs 22–48 of the Commentary on Article 1.
² See also paragraphs 67.1–67.7 of the Commentary on Article 10 and the report Tax Treaty Issues Related to REITs, which deal with the treaty entitlement of real estate investment trusts (REITs). With respect to the application of the definition of "resident of a Contracting State" to REITs, see paragraphs 8–9 of the report Tax Treaty Issues Related to REITs.
- in many cases, interests in CIVs are not publicly traded (although such interests are widely distributed);
- these interests are held by residents of third States;
- payments made by CIVs are deductible payments;
- the CIV is used for investment purposes rather than for "carrying on an active business", as defined in paragraph 3;
- the CIV does not satisfy the ownership test provided for in paragraph 4; and
- the CIV does not qualify as a headquarters company under paragraph 5.
56. Paragraphs 22–48 of the Commentary on Article 1 discuss various factors that should be taken into account for the purposes of determining the treaty entitlement of CIVs and are therefore relevant in determining whether a provision on CIVs should be included in paragraph 2 and how it should be drafted. These paragraphs include alternative provisions that may be used to provide appropriate treatment for CIVs that exist in each Contracting State. As explained below, the use of these provisions may mean that there is no need to include a specific rule on CIVs in paragraph 2, although it is important to ensure that, in such a case, the definition of "equivalent beneficiary", if that term is used for the purposes of one of these alternative provisions, is adapted to reflect the definition included in paragraph 7.
57. If included, subparagraph g) will address cases where a Contracting State agrees that CIVs established in the other Contracting State are residents of that other State within the meaning of the analysis set out in paragraphs 23–26 of the Commentary on Article 1 (such agreement may be confirmed by mutual agreement, as provided for in paragraph 30 of the Commentary on Article 1, or may result from judicial or administrative decisions). The provisions of the Article, including subparagraph g), are not relevant to CIVs that do not qualify as residents of a Contracting State according to the analysis in paragraphs 23–26 of the Commentary on Article 1. Furthermore, the provisions of subparagraph g) are not relevant in cases where the treaty entitlement of a CIV is dealt with under a treaty provision similar to one of the alternative provisions in paragraphs 31, 35, 40, 41 and 46 of the Commentary on Article 1.
58. As explained in paragraphs 33 and 34 of the Commentary on Article 1, Contracting States wishing to consider the entitlement of CIVs to treaty benefits may wish to consider the economic characteristics, including the possibility of choosing the most advantageous tax treaties, of the different types of CIVs used in each Contracting State.
59. As a result of such an analysis, they may conclude that the tax treatment of CIVs established in the two States does not give rise to concerns about treaty shopping and include in their bilateral treaty the alternative provision in paragraph 31 of the Commentary on Article 1, which would expressly provide for the treaty entitlement of CIVs established in each State, while at the same time ensuring that they are qualified persons under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of the Article (since a CIV to which this alternative provision would apply would be treated as an individual). In such a case, subparagraph g) should be omitted. States that share the view that CIVs established in those two States do not give rise to concerns about abuse of tax treaty provisions, but which do not include in their treaty the alternative provision in paragraph 31 of the Commentary on Article 1, should ensure that any CIV that is a resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person. In this case, subparagraph g) should be drafted as follows:
g) a collective investment vehicle [the definition of "collective investment vehicle" would then be included in paragraph 7];
60. Contracting States may, however, conclude that CIVs provide an opportunity for residents of third States to obtain treaty benefits that would not be available if those residents invested directly and may therefore prefer subparagraph g) in a form that ensures that CIVs that are residents of a Contracting State constitute qualified persons, but only to the extent that the beneficial interests in the CIV are owned by equivalent beneficiaries. In this case, subparagraph g) should be drafted as follows:
g) a collective investment vehicle, but only to the extent that, at that time, the beneficial interests in the collective investment vehicle are owned by [residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment vehicle is established,]¹ equivalent beneficiaries;
61. Such a regime corresponds to the regime that would result from including in the tax treaty a provision similar to the alternative provision in paragraph 35 of the Commentary on Article 1. As explained in paragraphs 32–38 of the Commentary on Article 1, the inclusion of this alternative provision would provide a more comprehensive solution to the treaty issues arising in connection with CIVs, since it would address concerns relating to treaty shopping while at the same time clarifying the tax treatment of CIVs in both Contracting States. If this alternative provision is included in the tax treaty, subparagraph g) will not be necessary in respect of CIVs to which that alternative provision will apply: since that alternative provision provides that a CIV to which it applies is treated as an individual (to the extent that the beneficial interests in that CIV are owned by equivalent beneficiaries), that CIV will constitute a qualified person under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of the Article.
62. The approach described in the two preceding paragraphs, like the approach described in paragraphs 35, 40 and 42 of the Commentary on Article 1, requires a CIV, when claiming a benefit in respect of a particular item of income, to determine the proportion of its interest holders who would be entitled to benefits if they invested directly. However, as indicated in paragraph 43 of the Commentary on Article 1, ownership of interests in a CIV changes regularly, and such interests are often held through intermediaries. For this reason, the CIV and its managers often do not know the identities and treaty status of the beneficial owners of the interests. Consequently, it is impractical for a CIV to collect such information from the relevant intermediaries every time the CIV receives income. Accordingly, Contracting States should adopt practical and reliable approaches that do not require such daily monitoring. As indicated in paragraph 45 of the Commentary on Article 1, the proportion of investors in a CIV changes relatively slowly, even though the identities of individual investors may change daily. For this reason, the calculation of the extent to which beneficial interests in a CIV are owned by equivalent beneficiaries should be made at regular intervals, with a calculation made at a given time applying to payments received until the next calculation. This is consistent with the approach described in paragraph 45 of the Commentary on Article 1, according to which:
It is reasonable to require a CIV to collect from other intermediaries, on specified dates, information enabling the CIV to determine the proportion of investors entitled to treaty benefits. This information may be required at the end of a calendar or financial year or, if market conditions indicate a high turnover of ownership, it may be requested more frequently, but no more frequently than at the end of each calendar quarter. The CIV may then make a claim on the basis of the average of these amounts over an agreed period of time. In carrying out such procedures, care should be taken in selecting the calculation dates to ensure that the CIV has sufficient time to update the information it provides to other payers so that the correct amount is withheld at the beginning of each relevant period.
¹ The words "residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment vehicle is established" will not be required if the definition of "equivalent beneficiary" used for the purposes of the provision is adapted accordingly.
63. Another view that Contracting States may adopt with respect to CIVs is expressed in paragraph 40 of the Commentary on Article 1. Contracting States that hold this view may draft subparagraph g) in such a way that a CIV that is a resident of a Contracting State is a qualified person only to the extent that the beneficial interests in that CIV are owned by residents of the Contracting State in which the CIV is established. In this case, subparagraph g) should be drafted as follows:
g) a collective investment vehicle, but only to the extent that, at that time, the beneficial interests in the collective investment vehicle are owned by residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment vehicle is established.
Since the inclusion of the alternative provision in paragraph 40 of the Commentary on Article 1 would produce the same result with respect to CIVs to which it would apply, subparagraph g) would not be necessary if that alternative provision were included in the treaty with respect to CIVs to which that provision would apply.
64. A variation of the preceding approach is to consider that a CIV that is a resident of a Contracting State should constitute a qualified person if the majority of the beneficial interests in that CIV are owned by individuals who are residents of the Contracting State in which the CIV is established. This result may be achieved by omitting subparagraph g) and relying on the application of subparagraph f) (the ownership and base erosion test).
65. Another possible option that Contracting States may adopt is that a substantial proportion of the investors in a CIV are entitled to treaty benefits, which provides sufficient protection against abuse of tax treaty provisions, and that it is therefore appropriate to establish an ownership threshold above which benefits will be granted in respect of all income received by the CIV. An alternative provision ensuring the inclusion of the result in paragraph 41 of the Commentary on Article 1 and subparagraph g) would not be necessary if Contracting States included that provision in their bilateral treaty with respect to CIVs to which that provision would apply. If that provision is not included in the treaty, the scope of application of subparagraph g) may be extended to achieve a similar result by referring to "a collective investment vehicle, but only if [the percentage interest to be determined bilaterally]" per cent of the beneficial interests in the collective investment vehicle are owned by residents of the Contracting State in which the collective investment vehicle is established and equivalent beneficiaries".
66. Similarly, Contracting States may use the alternative provision in paragraph 46 of the Commentary on Article 1 if they consider that "publicly traded collective investment vehicles cannot be effectively used for abuse of tax treaty provisions because the shareholders or unit holders of such a collective investment vehicle cannot individually exercise control over it". In such a case, subparagraph g) would not be necessary in respect of CIVs to which the alternative provision would apply. States that share this view but have not included the alternative provision in their conventions may draft subparagraph g) as follows:
g) a collective investment vehicle, if the principal class of shares in the collective investment vehicle is listed and regularly traded on a recognised stock exchange.
67. Finally, as explained in paragraph 39 of the Commentary on Article 1, States that share the concern described in that paragraph regarding the potential deferral of tax payments that may arise in respect of CIVs that are exempt from tax or subject to low taxation and that may accumulate income rather than distribute it as it arises may wish to agree on provisions that extend benefits only to those CIVs that are currently required to distribute profits. Depending on their wording, these provisions may make subparagraph g) unnecessary.
Paragraph 3: Carrying on an active business
Simplified and expanded versions
3. a) A resident of a Contracting State shall be entitled to benefits under this Convention with respect to an item of income derived from the other Contracting State, regardless of whether the resident is a qualified person, if the resident is engaged in the active conduct of a business in the first-mentioned State and the income derived from the other State is derived in connection with, or is incidental to, that business. For the purposes of this Article, the term "active conduct of a business" shall not include the following activities, or any combination thereof:
(i) operating as a holding company;
(ii) providing general supervision or administration of a group of companies;
(iii) providing group financing (including cash pooling); or
(iv) making or managing investments, unless these activities are carried on by a bank or [list financial institutions similar to banks that the Contracting States agree to treat as such], an insurance enterprise or a registered securities dealer in the ordinary course of its business.
b) If a resident of a Contracting State derives an item of income from a business activity carried on by that resident in the other Contracting State, or derives an item of income arising in the other State from a related person, the conditions described in subparagraph a) shall be considered satisfied with respect to that item only if the business activity carried on by the resident in the first-mentioned State to which the item is related is substantial in relation to the same or complementary business activity carried on by the resident or such related person in the other Contracting State. Whether a business activity is substantial for the purposes of this paragraph shall be determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances.
c) For the purposes of applying this paragraph, activities conducted by related persons with respect to a resident of a Contracting State shall be deemed to be conducted by such resident.
Commentary on paragraph 3 of the simplified and expanded versions
68. Paragraph 3 of both the simplified and expanded versions sets out an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State may obtain treaty benefits with respect to certain items of income connected with an active business carried on in its State of residence. This paragraph provides that where an entity resident in one Contracting State actively carries on a business in that State, including activities carried on by related persons, and derives income from the other Contracting State that is derived in connection with, or is incidental to, that business, the granting of treaty benefits with respect to such income does not raise concerns about abuse of tax treaty provisions, regardless of the nature and form of ownership of the enterprise. This paragraph will provide treaty benefits in a large number of situations where benefits are denied under paragraph 1 because the entity is not a "qualified person" under paragraph 2.
69. A resident of a Contracting State is entitled to benefits under paragraph 3 notwithstanding the fact that it is not a qualified person under paragraph 2. Under the active conduct test provided for in paragraph 3, a person (usually a company) is entitled to treaty benefits if it satisfies two conditions: it is engaged in the active conduct of a business in its State of residence, and the payment in respect of which benefits are claimed is connected with that business. In certain cases, an additional requirement must be met, namely that the size of the business must be substantial in relation to the activity in the State of source giving rise to the income.
70. Subparagraph a) establishes the general rule that a resident of a Contracting State carrying on an active business in that State may obtain Convention benefits with respect to an item of income derived from the other Contracting State. However, the item of income must arise from, or be connected with, that business.
71. The term "business activity" is not defined (except for the limited purpose of clarifying that it includes the performance of professional services and other activities of an independent character; see subparagraph h) of paragraph 1 of Article 3) and therefore, in accordance with the general rule in paragraph 2 of Article 3, it should be given the meaning that it has under domestic law. As a general rule, an entity is considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business only if the persons through whom it acts (for example, the officers or employees of a company) carry out substantial managerial and operational activities of the company.
72. Subdivisions (i)–(iv) of subparagraph a) identify specific functions that, either by themselves or in combination, are considered not to constitute the active conduct of a business in a Contracting State for the purposes of paragraph 3, even if all these functions are performed in one State. These include: (i) operating as a holding company; (ii) providing general supervision or administration of a group of companies; (iii) providing group financing (including cash pooling); and (iv) making or managing investments, unless these activities are carried on by a regulated bank (or a financial institution agreed upon by the Contracting States), an insurance company or a registered securities dealer in the ordinary course of its business.
73. This list of activities is intended to clarify that organizational support functions for multinational companies, as well as activities carried on as a holding company, do not constitute the active conduct of a business and that, therefore, income derived from such activities or incidental to such activities cannot qualify for treaty benefits under paragraph 3. However, some States consider that some or all of the activities listed in subdivisions (i)–(iv) should be included in what constitutes the active conduct of a business and, therefore, those States may wish to adopt a different wording of subparagraph a).
74. Whether an item of income is derived from the active conduct of a business in the State of residence is determined on the basis of the facts and circumstances. As a general rule, an item of income is derived from the active conduct of a business in the State of residence if there is an actual connection between the active business activity and the item of income in respect of which benefits are claimed. For example, if a company conducts research and development in its State of residence and develops a patent for a new technology, royalties from licensing the patent will be factually connected with the active conduct of a business in the State of residence. In the case of dividends or interest paid to a parent company, the activities of the paying company are relevant in determining whether the dividends or interest are derived from the active conduct of a business by the parent company in its State of residence.
75. For the purposes of determining whether the activity of the paying company in the State of source has the required factual connection with the active conduct of a business in the State of residence, it is important to compare the nature of the business in each State. The business activity in the State of source may provide resources for a production process that takes place in the State of residence, or the business activity in the State of source may sell products of a production process carried on by the resident. The following examples illustrate these principles:
- Example A: ACO is a company resident in State A and is engaged in the active conduct of a business in that State consisting of the manufacture of product X. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B. BCO purchases product X from ACO and distributes it to customers in State B. Since BCO's distribution activity is factually connected with ACO's manufacture of that product, the dividends paid by BCO to ACO will be considered to be derived from ACO's business activity.
- Example B: ACO is a company resident in State A that operates a large research and development centre in State A, which develops intellectual property that it licenses to subsidiaries or associated enterprises throughout the world, including BCO. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B. BCO manufactures and sells products developed by ACO in State B. Since the activities carried on by BCO are factually connected with the active business activity carried on by ACO in State A, the royalties paid by BCO to ACO for the use of its intellectual property will be considered to be derived from ACO's business activity.
- Example C: ACO is a company resident in State A and is engaged in the active conduct of a business in State A that requires the use of commodity X. ACO owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B, which owns a large stock of commodity X. BCO extracts commodity X and sells it to ACO, which uses the commodity to manufacture products that it sells on the open market. Since the business activity carried on by BCO provides the inputs for ACO to use in manufacturing its products, BCO's activity is factually connected with ACO's manufacturing activity in State A. The dividends paid by BCO to ACO will be considered to be derived from ACO's business activity.
76. An item of income derived in the State of source is "incidental" to the business activity carried on in the State of residence if the production of that item contributes to the conduct of the business activity in the State of residence. An example of incidental income is income derived from the temporary investment of a person's working capital in securities issued by persons in the State of source.
77. Subparagraph b) of paragraph 3 sets out an additional condition to the general rule in subparagraph a) in cases where the business activity giving rise to the relevant item of income is carried on either by the person deriving the income or by a related person in the State of source. Subparagraph b) provides that in such circumstances, the business activity carried on in the State of residence must be substantial in relation to the activity in the State of source. Whether the activity is substantial is determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances, including the comparative sizes of the businesses in each Contracting State, the relative sizes of the economies and markets in the two States, the nature of the activities carried on in each State, and the relative contributions made to the actual business activity in each State.
78. The determination of whether subparagraph b) applies is made separately for each item of income derived in the State of source, by reference to the business activity in the State of residence from which that item of income is derived. Consequently, it is possible that a person is entitled to Convention benefits with respect to one item of income but not another. If a resident of a Contracting State is entitled to treaty benefits with respect to a particular item of income under paragraph 3, the resident is entitled to all Convention benefits to the extent that they affect the taxation of that item of income in the State of source.
79. The substantiality requirement under subparagraph b) does not apply if the activity giving rise to the relevant item of income is not carried on in the State of source by the resident seeking benefits or by a person related to that resident in the State of source. For example, if a small research firm in one State develops a process that it licenses to a large pharmaceutical manufacturer in another State that is not related to the small research firm, the research firm is not required to pass the substantiality test in relation to the size of the manufacturer's business activity. Similarly, a small bank in one State that makes a loan to a large company that is not a related person and that carries on business in another State is not required to pass a substantiality test in order to qualify for treaty benefits under paragraph 3.
80. Subparagraph c) establishes attribution rules in respect of activities carried on by related persons for the purposes of applying the basic rules in subparagraphs a) and b). Thus, these rules apply for the purposes of determining whether a person satisfies the requirement in subparagraph a) that it is engaged in the active conduct of a business and that the item of income is derived from that active business activity, as well as for the purposes of making the comparison required by the "substantiality" requirement in subparagraph b). The term "related person" is defined in paragraph 7.
81. The following examples illustrate the application of paragraph 3 with respect to activities carried on by related persons:
- Example A: PARENTCO is a resident of a third State and is the parent company of HOLDCO, which is itself the parent company of OPCO1 and OPCO2. OPCO1 and HOLDCO are residents of State A. OPCO2 is a resident of State B. OPCO1 and OPCO2 are engaged in the manufacture of the same product in their respective States of residence. HOLDCO manages the group's investments and is considered not to be engaged in the active conduct of a business. HOLDCO receives dividends from OPCO2. Under subparagraph c), HOLDCO is considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business because it is deemed to carry on the activities of OPCO1, which is engaged in the active conduct of a business. Accordingly, HOLDCO is treated as participating in the active conduct of a business in State A. Nevertheless, the fact that the deemed activity of HOLDCO coincides with the activity of OPCO2 is not sufficient evidence that the dividends paid by OPCO2 are factually connected with HOLDCO's active business activity. Accordingly, such dividends cannot benefit from the reduced rates of withholding tax provided for under Article 10 of the Convention between States A and B by virtue of paragraph 3.
- Example B: ACO is a company resident in State A and is engaged in the active conduct of a business in State A that requires the use of commodity X. All the shares of ACO are owned by HOLDCO, also a resident of State A, which also owns 100 per cent of the shares of BCO, a company resident in State B, where there is a large stock of commodity X. BCO extracts commodity X and sells it to ACO, which uses the commodity to manufacture products that are sold on the open market. HOLDCO is considered to be engaged in the active conduct of a business because, under subparagraph c), it is deemed to carry on the activities of ACO. Since the business activity carried on by BCO provides the inputs for use in HOLDCO's deemed active business activity, BCO's activity is considered to be factually connected with HOLDCO's deemed manufacturing business, and therefore the dividends paid by BCO to HOLDCO are considered to be derived from HOLDCO's deemed active business activity.
Paragraph 4: Derivative Benefits
Simplified Version
4. A resident of a Contracting State that is not a qualified person shall nevertheless be entitled to benefits that would otherwise be accorded by this Convention with respect to an item of income if, at the time when such benefits would otherwise be accorded, and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, persons who are equivalent beneficiaries own, directly or indirectly, at least 75 percent of the shares of the resident.
Expanded Version
[The question of how to formulate the paragraph on derivative benefits in a Convention that follows the detailed version is addressed in the Commentary below.]
Commentary on Paragraph 4 of the Simplified Version
82. Paragraph 4 of the simplified version establishes a derivative benefits test that is potentially applicable to all treaty benefits, although it must be applied separately to each item of income. This derivative benefits test entitles companies and organizations that are residents of a Contracting State but do not meet the criteria under paragraph 2 to treaty benefits with respect to an item of income if, at the time when the benefit would otherwise be accorded with respect to that item of income and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 75 percent of the shares (as defined in paragraph 7) of such company or organization are owned, directly or indirectly, by persons who satisfy the definition of an “equivalent beneficiary” contained in paragraph 7. The definition of “equivalent beneficiary,” which is decisive for the application of paragraph 4, generally refers to persons who would be entitled to equivalent or more favorable benefits from the State of source if they received the same income directly (subject to the conditions included in that definition).
Commentary on Paragraph 4 of the Expanded Version
83. The drafting of the paragraph on derivative benefits in a Convention that follows the expanded version depends on the views of the Contracting States regarding the potential for obtaining benefits under tax treaties that may arise from this paragraph in relation to residents of States whose tax systems include certain preferential provisions.
84. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that provisions should be included in their tax conventions prohibiting the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) who benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes” (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1), and prohibiting the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons who benefit from provisions of domestic law providing for notional deductions in respect of equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). These States may wish for any derivative benefits provisions included in their conventions to prohibit base-eroding payments to such related persons, even if they qualify as equivalent beneficiaries. States sharing these views may adopt the following version of the derivative benefits paragraph:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to the benefits that would otherwise be accorded by this Convention if:
a) at the time when the benefit would otherwise be accorded, and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 95 percent of the aggregate number of votes and value of its shares (and at least 50 percent of the aggregate number of votes and value of any disproportionate class of shares) is owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualified intermediate owner; and
b) less than 50 percent of the person's gross income and less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group is paid or accrued for the taxable period that includes that time, as defined in the Contracting State of residence of the person, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the person (excluding arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions):
i) to persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries;
ii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries only by virtue of paragraph 5 of this Article or a substantially similar provision of an applicable comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation;
iii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, who are related persons with respect to the company described in this paragraph, and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”], with respect to the deductible payment, provided that the relevant comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation does not contain a definition of a special tax regime similar to the definition of that term included in this Convention, in which case the principles of that definition shall apply, but without regard to the requirement in subparagraph (v) of that definition; or
iv) in the case of interest payments, to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, who are related persons with respect to the company described in this paragraph, and who benefit from notional deductions of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions in respect of equity].
85. States that do not consider that provisions concerning special tax regimes and notional deductions in respect of equity should be included in their tax treaties may prefer to use the following version of the derivative benefits paragraph:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to the benefits that would otherwise be accorded by this Convention if:
a) at the time when the benefit would otherwise be accorded, and on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes that time, at least 95 percent of the aggregate number of votes and value of its shares (and at least 50 percent of the aggregate number of votes and value of any disproportionate class of shares) is owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer persons who are equivalent beneficiaries, provided that, in the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner is a qualified intermediate owner; and
b) less than 50 percent of the person's gross income and less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group is paid or accrued for the taxable period that includes that time, as defined in the Contracting State of residence of the person, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the person (excluding arm's length payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions):
i) to persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries; or
ii) to persons who are equivalent beneficiaries only by virtue of paragraph 5 of this Article or a substantially similar provision of an applicable comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation.
86. However, some States may consider that the provisions of the derivative benefits paragraph drafted in accordance with the provisions included in the preceding paragraph create unacceptable risks of abuse of tax treaty provisions in respect of payments that are deductible in the State of source. Rather than denying all derivative benefits, these States may limit the scope of application of this provision to dividends, which are generally not deductible. States sharing this view may formulate the first part of the alternative provision as follows:
4. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State shall also be entitled to the benefits that would otherwise be accorded under Article 10 if:
87. Regardless of whether it is formulated in accordance with paragraph 84 or paragraph 85 above, paragraph 4 on derivative benefits establishes an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State that is not a qualified person under paragraph 2 may obtain treaty benefits with respect to certain items of income. In general, the derivative benefits test entitles a company that is a resident of a Contracting State to treaty benefits if 95 percent of the votes and value of its shares are owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries and the company satisfies the base erosion test. The requirement that at least 95 percent of the votes and value of the company claiming treaty benefits under paragraph 4 be owned, directly or indirectly, by seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries is intended to avoid the administrative burden associated with determining whether a large number of shareholders are equivalent beneficiaries; it is also consistent with the objective of the derivative benefits test, which is to grant benefits to holding companies of multinational groups in the situations contemplated by the provision.
88. Subparagraph a) establishes the ownership test. Under this test, seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries must directly or indirectly own shares representing at least 95 percent of the total number of votes and value of the company, and at least 50 percent of any disproportionate class of shares, on at least half the days of any twelve-month period that includes the date on which the benefits would otherwise be accorded. In the case of indirect ownership, each intermediate owner must satisfy the definition of “qualified intermediate owner.” The term “qualified intermediate owner” is defined in paragraph 7 (see paragraphs 151–154 below); the following example illustrates the application of this definition in the context of paragraph 4:
- Example: HOLDCO, a company resident in State A, is a wholly owned subsidiary of ZCO, a company resident in State Z, which is itself a direct subsidiary of XCO, a resident of State X. The principal class of shares of XCO is primarily and regularly traded on a stock exchange in State X. HOLDCO is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 of the treaty between States A and B because it is a subsidiary of a company resident in, and listed on a stock exchange in, a third State. HOLDCO does not conduct active business activities in State A and is therefore not entitled to any benefits under paragraph 3. HOLDCO receives interest arising in State B, in respect of which it would otherwise be entitled to benefits under Article 11 of the Convention between States A and B. Assume that, under the provisions of the income tax convention between State B and State X, XCO qualifies as an equivalent beneficiary under the definition of that term included in the Convention between States A and B.
Although XCO indirectly owns all the shares of HOLDCO, ZCO, as an intermediate owner, must satisfy the definition of “qualified intermediate owner” under paragraph 7 of the Convention between States A and B for HOLDCO to be entitled to the benefits of Article 11 of the Convention between States A and B in respect of the interest received by it from State B. If there is no comprehensive agreement for the avoidance of double taxation in force in State Z (or, if the definition of qualified intermediate owner is formulated as proposed in paragraph 153 below, such an agreement is in force but ZCO benefits from a “special tax regime” or notional deductions in respect of equity), ZCO will not be a qualified intermediate owner, and the requirements of subparagraph a) will not be satisfied; consequently, HOLDCO will not be entitled to treaty benefits under paragraph 4.
89. Subparagraph b) establishes the base erosion test applicable for the purposes of paragraph 4. This test is similar to the base erosion test in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, except that the list of disqualified persons differs (see below). The base erosion test in subparagraph b) is considered satisfied if:
- less than 50 percent of the company's gross income (and less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group, if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed, paid or accrued is paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of deductible payments for tax purposes in calculating the company's tax in its State of residence, to disqualified persons; and
- less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group (if there is a tested group) for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are claimed, paid or accrued is paid, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for tax purposes in calculating the tax of any member of the tested group in the State of residence of the company claiming treaty benefits, to disqualified persons.
90. Paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income,” which are used in subparagraph b). In addition, the term “disqualified persons,” used in the preceding paragraph, refers to:
- if paragraph 4 is drafted as indicated in paragraph 84 above, persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries under the definition of that term in paragraph 7, as well as persons who are equivalent beneficiaries under that definition but fall within one of the following three categories:
1. they are equivalent beneficiaries by virtue of being a parent company under paragraph 5 of this Convention or the relevant Convention;
2. they are related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) with the company seeking treaty benefits under paragraph 4 and benefit from a special tax regime in respect of the payment; or
3. in the case of interest payments, they are related persons (as defined in paragraph 7) with the company seeking treaty benefits under paragraph 4 and benefit from notional deductions in respect of equity.
- if paragraph 4 is drafted as indicated in paragraph 85 above, persons who are not equivalent beneficiaries under the definition of that term in paragraph 7, as well as persons who are equivalent beneficiaries under that definition solely on the basis that they are a parent company under paragraph 5 of this Convention or the relevant Convention.
91. The following illustrates the base erosion test under paragraph 4:
- Example: Company X, a resident of State X, owns Company Y, a resident of State Y. Company Y owns Company B, a resident of State B, which seeks to obtain benefits under the Convention between States A and B pursuant to paragraph 4. Company X is an equivalent beneficiary, and Company Y is a qualified intermediate owner under the definitions of these terms in paragraph 7 of the Convention between States A and B. Accordingly, Company B satisfies the ownership test under subparagraph a), because, first, Company X, an equivalent beneficiary, indirectly owns shares representing at least 95 percent of the aggregate number of votes and value of Company B, and at least 50 percent of any disproportionate class of shares (as defined in paragraph 7), and, second, each intermediate owner (i.e., Company Y) is a qualified intermediate owner.
The gross income of Company B for the relevant taxable period consists of 100 arising in State A and 200 in dividends from a third State, which are exempt from tax under the laws of State B. Company B claims treaty benefits in respect of 100. Under the laws of State B, Company B, Company Y and Company X are not entitled to participate in a common tax consolidation or other regime that would allow the three companies to share profits or losses, and they are not subject to any loss-sharing regime. Accordingly, there is no tested group in this example. The gross income of Company B is 100 (interest arising in State A). Company B will not satisfy the base erosion test under subparagraph b) if Company B makes base-eroding payments of at least 50 to the disqualified persons described in the preceding paragraph.
Paragraph 5: Parent Company
Expanded Version Only
5. A company that is a resident of a Contracting State and that functions as the parent company of a multinational group of companies consisting of such company and its direct and indirect subsidiaries shall be entitled to benefits under this Convention with respect to dividends and interest paid by members of that multinational corporate group, regardless of whether the resident is a qualified person. For this purpose, a company shall be considered a parent company only if:
a) the primary place of management and control of such company is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident;
b) the multinational corporate group consists of companies that are residents of and carry on active business activities in at least four States, and the business activities carried on in each of the four States (or four groups of States) generate at least 10 percent of the gross income of the group;
c) the activities of the multinational corporate group carried on in any one State other than the Contracting State of residence of such company generate less than 50 percent of the gross income of the group;
d) no more than 25 percent of the gross income of such company is derived from the other Contracting State;
e) such company is subject to the same income tax rules in its Contracting State of residence as persons referred to in paragraph 3 of this Article; and
f) less than 50 percent of the gross income of such company and less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group are paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (excluding payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, or payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank that is not a related person with respect to such company, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions), to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States and who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2.
If the requirements of subparagraphs b), c) or d) of this paragraph are not met in the relevant taxable period, they shall be deemed to be met if the required ratios are satisfied when averaging the gross income of the previous four taxable periods.
Commentary on Paragraph 5 of the Expanded Version
92. Paragraph 5 sets out an alternative test under which a resident of a Contracting State that is a parent company and is not a qualified person under paragraph 2 may obtain treaty benefits with respect to dividends and interest paid by members of the multinational corporate group. The multinational corporate group of a parent company means the company and its direct and indirect subsidiaries (and does not include higher-tier companies).
93. A company claiming benefits as a parent company must satisfy six conditions. First, under subparagraph a), the primary place of management and control of the parent company, as defined in paragraph 7, must be located in the Contracting State of which it is a resident. The same test applies to companies listed on stock exchanges. Subdivision (ii) of the definition of “primary place of management and control” allows for the possibility that, in certain limited cases, the management of a subgroup (for example, a subgroup responsible for a region) may be exercised to a greater extent by a company that is not the top-tier company of the entire group of related companies, and in certain cases a lower-tier company may satisfy the parent company test.
94. Second, under subparagraph b), the multinational corporate group must consist of resident companies carrying on active business activities (as defined in paragraph 3) in at least four States (including either of the Contracting States), and the enterprises carrying on business activities in each of the four States (or four groups of States) must generate at least 10% of the gross income of the group. The application of this requirement is illustrated by the following example:
- Example: Company X is a resident of State X and is a member of a multinational corporate group consisting of itself and its direct and indirect subsidiaries resident in States X, A, B, C, D, E and F. The gross income earned by each of these companies for Year 01 and Year 02 is as follows:
| State | Year 01 | Year 02 |
|---|---|---|
| X | 45 | 60 |
| A | 25 | 12 |
| B | 10 | 20 |
| C | 10 | 12 |
| D | 7 | 10 |
| E | 10 | 9 |
| F | 5 | 7 |
| Total | 112 | 130 |
During Year 01, 10 percent of the gross income of this group amounts to 11.20. Only the companies in States X and A satisfy the requirements of subparagraph b) in that year. The remaining States may be combined into groups to satisfy this requirement. Since States B and C have combined gross income of 20, and States D, E and F have combined gross income of 22, these two groups of States may be treated as the third and fourth members of the group for the purposes of subparagraph b).
During Year 02, 10 percent of the gross income amounts to 13. Only the companies in States X and B satisfy this requirement. Since States A and C have combined gross income of 24, and States D, E and F have combined gross income of 26, these two groups of States may be treated as the third and fourth members of the group for the purposes of subparagraph b). The fact that State A replaced State B in the group is irrelevant for this purpose. The composition of the groups may change annually.
95. Third, under subparagraph c), the enterprises of the multinational corporate group operating in any one State other than the Contracting State of residence of such company must generate less than 50 percent of the gross income (as defined in paragraph 7) of the group. A company whose multinational corporate group generates 50 percent or more of the group's gross income in the Contracting State of source does not satisfy this condition.
96. Fourth, under subparagraph d), no more than 25 percent of the company's gross income may be derived from the other Contracting State. Unlike the third condition described in the preceding paragraph, this condition considers only the gross income derived by the company seeking to obtain parent company status, and not the gross income derived by members of its multinational corporate group.
97. Fifth, under subparagraph e), such company must be subject to the same income tax rules in its Contracting State of residence as the persons described in paragraph 3. Accordingly, such company must be subject to the general corporate tax rules applicable to companies engaged in active business activities in the Contracting State of residence, rather than the rules applicable to parent companies.
98. Sixth, under subparagraph f), such company must satisfy the base erosion test, which is generally similar to the base erosion test described in subdivision (ii) of subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, except that base-eroding payments do not include payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank that is not a related person with respect to the company. For example, unlike the base erosion test in subparagraph f) of paragraph 2, interest payments made by a company to a bank that is not a related person with respect to the company will not be treated as a base-eroding payment under paragraph 5. Paragraph 7 includes definitions of the terms “tested group” and “gross income,” which are used for the purposes of the base erosion test.
99. As explained in paragraph 33 above, which applies to the base erosion test in subparagraph d) of paragraph 2, States that prohibit the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons who benefit from regimes constituting “special tax regimes,” and prohibit the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons who benefit from domestic law provisions providing for notional deductions in respect of equity, may need to amend the base erosion test provided for in subparagraph f) to include in the category of “disqualified persons” persons who, although they are residents of one of the Contracting States, benefit from such special tax regimes or notional deductions in respect of equity on the payments made or accrued to them. This may be done by amending subparagraph f) as follows:
f) less than 50 percent of the gross income of such company and less than 50 percent of the gross income of the tested group are paid or accrued, directly or indirectly, in the form of payments that are deductible for the purposes of the taxes covered by this Convention in the Contracting State of residence of the company (excluding payments in the ordinary course of business for services or tangible property, or payments in respect of financial obligations to a bank that is not a related person with respect to such company, and, in the case of a tested group, excluding intra-group transactions):
i) to persons who are not residents of either of the Contracting States and who are entitled to benefits under this Convention pursuant to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2;
ii) to persons who are related to such company and who benefit from a special tax regime, as defined in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of “special tax regime”], with respect to the deductible payment; or
iii) in the case of interest payments, to persons who are related persons with respect to the company referred to in this paragraph and who benefit from notional deductions of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions in respect of equity].
100. The six conditions of paragraph 5 must be tested with respect to the taxable year in which the company received the dividends or interest for which it claims benefits under the Convention. A company that does not satisfy the second, third or fourth conditions described above for the relevant taxable year may nevertheless be considered a parent company if it satisfies those conditions by averaging the required ratios for the previous four taxable periods (which do not include the taxable period that includes the payment for which treaty benefits are claimed).
Paragraph 5 (Simplified Version) / Paragraph 6 (Expanded Version): Discretionary Relief
Simplified and Expanded Versions
5/6. If a resident of a Contracting State is not a qualified person under the provisions of paragraph 2 of this Article and is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 3 [or 4 (Simplified Version)] [, 4 or 5 (Expanded Version)], the competent authority of the Contracting State that has denied benefits under the preceding provisions of this Convention may nevertheless grant benefits under this Convention or benefits with respect to a specific item of income or capital, having regard to the object and purpose of this Convention, but only if such resident demonstrates to the satisfaction of such competent authority that neither its establishment, acquisition, maintenance nor the conduct of its operations had as one of its principal purposes the obtaining of benefits under this Convention. The competent authority of the Contracting State to which a request has been made under this paragraph by a resident of the other State shall consult with the competent authority of that other State before granting or denying the request.
Commentary on Paragraph 5 (Simplified Version) / Paragraph 6 (Expanded Version)
101. Paragraph 5 of the simplified version and paragraph 6 of the expanded version provide that, where a resident of a Contracting State is not entitled to benefits under the Convention pursuant to the preceding paragraphs of the Article, that resident may request the competent authority of the State that denied it benefits under those paragraphs to grant such benefits. The only difference between the simplified and expanded versions concerns the cross-reference to the paragraphs of the Article under which the benefits of the Convention would otherwise be granted.
102. Where a request is made under paragraph 5 (Simplified Version) or paragraph 6 (Expanded Version), the competent authority to which the request is submitted may grant the benefits provided for by this Convention, or benefits with respect to a specific item of income or capital, having regard to the object and purpose of this Convention, but only if the person making the request demonstrates to the satisfaction of the competent authority that neither its establishment, acquisition, maintenance nor the conduct of its operations had as one of its principal purposes the obtaining of benefits under this Convention. Thus, persons who carry out transactions in one of the Contracting States with the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention will not be granted Convention benefits under this paragraph.
103. In order to obtain benefits under this paragraph, a person must establish to the satisfaction of the competent authority of the State from which the benefits are claimed that, first, there were clear non-tax commercial reasons for its establishment, acquisition, maintenance and the conduct of its operations and, second, the granting of benefits would not be contrary to the object and purpose of the Convention. For the purposes of determining whether neither the establishment, acquisition, maintenance nor the conduct of the operations of a resident of a Contracting State had as one of its principal purposes the obtaining of benefits under the Convention, one of the factors that the competent authority will generally take into account is whether the resident has a genuine non-tax connection with its State of residence. For example, in the case of a resident subsidiary whose parent company is resident in a third State, the fact that the relevant withholding tax rate provided for under the Convention is at least as low as the corresponding withholding tax rate under the income tax agreement between the State of source and the third State does not, by itself, constitute evidence of a connection or relationship with the other Contracting State. Likewise, a relationship or connection with a Contracting State to the Convention cannot be established merely from the desire to benefit from favorable domestic laws of the Contracting State, including the existence of a network of tax conventions.
104. Furthermore, discretionary relief will generally not be granted if the requested relief would result in no tax or minimal taxation on an item of income in both the State of residence of the applicant and the State of source, taking into account the domestic legislation of both Contracting States, the provisions, object and purpose of the Convention. For example, the elimination of double taxation may occur through the use of a hybrid financial instrument that generates a deduction in the State of source, where the income from that instrument is treated as exempt from tax in the State of residence. On the other hand, the fact that there is no tax or minimal taxation in both States may not be contrary to the object and purpose of the Convention in the case of dividends paid by a company resident in one State to a company resident in the other State that owns a substantial part of the shares of the paying company, where the provisions of the Convention indicate that the Contracting States intended such dividends to be subject to low taxation or no taxation at all in both States.
105. Although it is impossible to provide a detailed list of all the facts and circumstances that may be relevant to the application of this paragraph, examples of such facts and circumstances include the history, structure, ownership and activities of the resident making the request; whether that resident is a long-established organization or one recently acquired by non-residents for non-tax reasons; whether the resident carries on active business activities; whether the income of the resident for which benefits are requested is subject to double taxation; and whether the establishment or use of the resident results in the exemption from taxation or reduction of taxation of income.
106. The reference to “one of its principal purposes” in this paragraph means that obtaining benefits under a tax treaty need not be the sole or dominant purpose for the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of an organization and the conduct of its operations. It is sufficient that at least one of the principal purposes was to obtain treaty benefits. If the competent authority determines, taking into account all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining benefits under the Convention was not a principal purpose and could not have served as a basis for the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the organization and the conduct of its operations, it may grant that person those benefits or benefits with respect to a specific item of income or capital. However, if the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of an organization and the conduct of its operations are undertaken for the purpose of obtaining similar benefits under a number of conventions, obtaining benefits under other conventions should not be considered to prevent the obtaining of benefits under one convention from being regarded as one of the principal purposes of those operations.
107. Although a request under this paragraph will usually be made by a resident of one Contracting State to the competent authority of the other Contracting State, there may be cases where a resident of one Contracting State may request assistance under this paragraph from the competent authority of the State of which it is a resident. This will be the case where the treaty benefits requested are provided by the State of residence, for example, benefits under the provisions of Articles 23 A and 23 B concerning the elimination of double taxation.
108. This paragraph provides a wide range of discretionary assistance by the competent authority and, provided that the competent authority exercises this discretionary assistance in accordance with the requirements of this paragraph, the decision of the competent authority cannot be considered an action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the Convention (see paragraph 1 of Article 25). However, this paragraph requires the competent authority to consider the relevant facts and circumstances before making a decision and to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or denying a request for benefits made by a resident of that other State. The first requirement is intended to ensure that the competent authority considers each request on its merits, while the requirement to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State is intended to ensure that the Contracting States treat similar cases consistently and can substantiate their decisions on the basis of the facts and circumstances of the particular case. However, the consultation process does not require the competent authority to which the request has been submitted to obtain the consent of the competent authority with which it is consulting.
109. The competent authority to which a request is submitted under this paragraph may grant the taxpayer making the request all the benefits provided for by the Convention or may grant only certain benefits. For example, it may grant benefits only with respect to a particular item of income, in a manner similar to paragraph 3. In addition, the competent authority may impose conditions, such as setting time limits on the duration of any assistance granted.
110. A request for a determination under this paragraph may be made before (for example, by means of a request for a ruling) or after the establishment, acquisition or maintenance of the person in respect of whom the request is made. However, the request must be submitted before benefits may be claimed. If the competent authority determines that benefits may be granted, it is expected that the benefits will be granted retroactively to the later of the date of entry into force of the relevant treaty provision or the date of establishment or acquisition of the person in respect of whom the request is made, assuming that all relevant facts and circumstances justify the application of the benefits.
111. The competent authority that receives a request for benefits under this paragraph should process that request promptly.
112. To reduce the resource implications of considering requests for discretionary assistance and to prevent frequent requests, a Contracting State may consider it useful to publish guidance on the types of cases that it considers will and will not meet the criteria for discretionary assistance. However, any administrative requirements that a Contracting State imposes on applicants should not prevent persons from submitting requests if they believe that they have a chance of satisfying the competent authority's requirements for granting benefits.
Paragraph 6 (Simplified Version) / 7 (Detailed Version): Definitions
Definitions (Preamble)
Simplified and Detailed Versions
6/7. For the purposes of this and the preceding paragraphs of this Article:
113. Paragraph 6 of the Simplified Version and paragraph 7 of the Detailed Version include a number of definitions that apply for the purposes of these paragraphs themselves, as well as the preceding paragraphs of the Article. These definitions supplement the definitions contained in Articles 3, 4 and 5 of the Convention, which apply throughout the Convention.
The term "recognised stock exchange"
Simplified Version
a) the term "recognised stock exchange" means:
(i) any stock exchange established and regulated as such under the laws of either Contracting State; and
(ii) any other stock exchange agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States;
Detailed Version
a) the term "recognised stock exchange" means:
(i) [list of stock exchanges agreed upon at the time of signature]; and
(ii) any other stock exchange agreed upon by the competent authorities of the Contracting States;
Commentary on the definition of "recognised stock exchange" in the Simplified Version
114. Subparagraph (i) of the definition of "recognised stock exchange" in the Simplified Version applies to all stock exchanges established and regulated as such under the laws of either Contracting State. No list of stock exchanges established in each of these States is required for this general reference.
115. Subparagraph (ii) of the definition allows the competent authorities to agree to treat any other stock exchange as a "recognised stock exchange" for the purposes of paragraphs 1 to 6 of the Article. The possibility of treating stock exchanges established in third States as "recognised stock exchanges" takes into account the fact that the globalisation of financial markets and the prominence of certain major financial centres have resulted in the shares of many exchange-listed companies being actively traded on more than one stock exchange and on stock exchanges established outside the Contracting States. The agreement referred to in subparagraph (ii) may be reached during negotiations on the Convention or at any time thereafter. Paragraphs 117 and 119 below provide further explanations regarding the application of the definition of "recognised stock exchange" to stock exchanges established outside the Contracting States.
Commentary on the definition of "recognised stock exchange" in the Detailed Version
116. The definition of "recognised stock exchange" in the Detailed Version includes in subparagraph (i) stock exchanges that both Contracting States agree to identify at the time of signature of the Convention. Although this will generally include stock exchanges established in the Contracting States on which shares of companies and entities listed on the exchanges and resident in those States are actively traded, the stock exchanges to be specified in the definition do not necessarily have to be established in one of the Contracting States. This recognises that the globalisation of financial markets and the prominence of certain major financial centres have resulted in the shares of many exchange-listed companies being actively traded on more than one stock exchange and on stock exchanges located outside the State of residence of those companies.
117. The list to be included in subparagraph (i) may include the names of specific stock exchanges. It may also include a general description of a number of stock exchanges, each of which would constitute a "recognised stock exchange". For example, in the case of the United States, such a general description could read as follows: "any stock exchange registered with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission as a national securities exchange under the United States Securities Exchange Act of 1934". If the Contracting States wish to cover stock exchanges in the European Union that are officially recognised as such, such a general description could read as follows:
"any stock exchange established in States that are members of the European Union or parties to the Agreement on the European Economic Area and that are regulated by the European Union Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (Directive 2004/39/EC, as amended) or any subsequent Directive".
118. Subparagraph (ii) of the definition allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States to supplement, by means of a subsequent agreement, the list of stock exchanges specified in the definition at the time of signature of the Convention.
119. Stock exchanges to be included in the definition should establish listing requirements that ensure that shares of companies listed on that stock exchange are genuinely listed. In determining whether a stock exchange should be specified in the definition or subsequently added to the list on the basis of an agreement with the competent authority referred to in the preceding paragraph, the following factors should be taken into account:
- What are the requirements/standards regarding the conditions for obtaining a stock exchange listing?
- What are the requirements/standards for maintaining a listing on the stock exchange, including minimum financial standards?
- What are the annual/interim requirements for the publication of financial statements and/or the filing of tax returns by companies whose shares are traded on the stock exchange?
- What is the volume of shares traded on the stock exchange during a calendar year?
- Do the rules of the stock exchange ensure active trading in listed shares? If so, how?
- Are companies listed on the stock exchange required to disclose financial information on an ongoing basis and information about events that may have a material impact on their financial position?
- Is information on trading volumes and the total number of shares of companies listed on the stock exchange publicly available?
- Does the stock exchange impose any minimum size requirements, such as minimum market capitalisation or number of employees, on companies whose shares are traded on the exchange?
- Does the stock exchange impose any minimum state ownership requirements? If so, what is the minimum percentage?
- In order for a company to be listed on the stock exchange, must its shares be freely transferable and fully paid up?
- Is the stock exchange required to disclose the share prices of its listed companies at specified intervals?
- Is the stock exchange regulated or supervised by a government authority of the State in which it is located?
- [In the case of adding a new stock exchange to the existing list:] Why does the company prefer listing on the new exchange rather than on another exchange, including those exchanges that are already "recognised stock exchanges" under the tax treaty? Are there less stringent corporate governance and financial disclosure requirements?
- [In the case of adding a new stock exchange to the existing list:] Does the new stock exchange provide a more effective mechanism for raising capital, and if so, why?
The term "shares"
Simplified and Detailed Versions
b) in the case of persons other than companies, the term "shares" means interests comparable to shares;
Commentary on the definition of "shares" in the Simplified and Detailed Versions
120. Neither the Simplified Version nor the Detailed Version contains an exhaustive definition of the term "shares", which, pursuant to paragraph 2 of Article 3, must have the meaning that it has under the domestic law of the State applying this Article. Subparagraph b), however, provides that the term "shares", when used in relation to entities that do not issue shares (for example, trusts), refers to ownership interests that are comparable to shares. These will generally be beneficial interests that entitle their holders to a share of the income or assets of the enterprise.
The term "principal class of shares"
Simplified Version
c) the term "principal class of shares" means the class or classes of shares of a company or entity that represent the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity;
Detailed Version
c) the term "principal class of shares" means the ordinary shares of a company or entity, provided that such class of shares represents the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity. If no single class of ordinary shares represents the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity, the "principal class of shares" shall be the classes that, taken together, represent the majority of the aggregate voting power and value;
Commentary on the definition of "principal class of shares" in the Simplified Version
121. The definition of the term "principal class of shares" in the Simplified Version is consistent with the definition included in the Detailed Version, but instead of expressly addressing the case where no single class of ordinary shares represents the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity, this issue is addressed through the expression "class or classes of shares".
Commentary on the definition of "principal class of shares" in the Detailed Version
122. The detailed definition of the term "principal class of shares" refers to the ordinary shares of a company or entity, but only where those shares represent the majority of the voting rights as well as the value of the company or entity. If a company or entity has only one class of shares, that class of shares will constitute its "principal class of shares". If a company or entity has more than one class of shares, it is necessary to determine which class or classes constitute the "principal class of shares", which will be the class of shares or any combination of classes of shares that, taken together, represent the majority of the total number of votes and value of the company or entity. If the company or entity has no class of ordinary shares representing the majority of its aggregate voting power and value, the "principal class of shares" shall be any combination of classes of shares that, taken together, represent the majority of the voting power and value of the company or entity. Although, in a particular case involving a company with several classes of shares, there may be more than one group of classes that represent the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company, it is only necessary to identify one such group that satisfies the requirements of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 for the company to be entitled to treaty benefits under that provision (the company or entity will not be denied benefits even if a second group of shares representing the majority of the aggregate voting power and value of the company or entity, which does not satisfy the requirements of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2, can be identified).
123. In some States, certain exchange-listed companies are governed by a dual-listed company arrangement (listing of shares on two stock exchanges), and these States may wish to address the position of such companies to ensure that they are not unintentionally denied treaty benefits because of the definition of "principal class of shares". The term "dual-listed company" refers to an arrangement adopted by certain exchange-listed companies that reflects common management, business operations, shareholder rights, objectives and business purposes through a series of agreements between two parent companies, each of which is listed on a stock exchange and has special provisions in its respective constitutional documents, including, in some cases, for example, the creation of special voting shares. Under these structures, the position of the shareholders of the parent companies is, to the extent possible, the same as if they owned shares in a single company, with identical rights to receive dividends and identical rights to participate in the assets of the dual-listed companies in the event of liquidation. Therefore, States wishing to address the position of such companies may wish to add the following sentence to the definition of "principal class of shares":
In the case of a company participating in a dual-listed company arrangement, the principal class of shares shall be determined after excluding special voting shares that have been issued as a means of creating such a dual-listed company arrangement.
124. This additional sentence may be supplemented by the following definition:
The term "dual-listed company arrangement" means an arrangement under which two exchange-listed companies, while retaining their separate corporate status, share capital and listing, agree to align their strategic directions and the economic interests of their respective shareholders through:
(i) the appointment of common (or substantially identical) boards of directors, except where the relevant regulatory requirements prevent this;
(ii) the management of the activities of the two companies on a unified basis;
(iii) equal distributions to shareholders in accordance with an equalisation ratio applied by the two companies, including in the event of the liquidation of either or both companies;
(iv) the voting of shareholders of both companies as a single body on matters of material importance affecting their common interests; and
(v) cross-guarantees or similar financial support for material obligations or activities of each other, except where the relevant regulatory requirements prevent such guarantees or financial support.
125. However, other States may prefer not to include any specific reference to dual-listed company arrangements in the Article because of possible concerns about the use of similar arrangements for treaty shopping purposes and may therefore prefer to consider legitimate dual-listed company arrangements on a case-by-case basis through other provisions of the Article, including the discretionary relief provision contained in paragraph 6.
The term "related person"
Simplified and Detailed Versions
d) two persons shall be considered "related persons" if one of them directly or indirectly owns at least 50 per cent of the beneficial interest in the other (or, in the case of a company, at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the company's shares), or if at least 50 per cent of the beneficial interest in each person (or, in the case of a company, at least 50 per cent of the aggregate voting power and value of the company's shares) is directly or indirectly owned by another person. In any case, one person shall be related to another if, based on all the relevant facts and circumstances, one person controls the other or both are controlled by the same person or persons.
Commentary on the definition of "related person" in the Simplified and Detailed Versions
126. The term "related person" is used in paragraph 3 of the Simplified Version and in various paragraphs of the Detailed Version. Although the definition is somewhat similar to the definition of "closely related" in Article 5, the main difference is that direct or indirect ownership of exactly 50% of the beneficial interests may result in a person being "related" to another person, whereas the definition of "closely related" requires direct or indirect ownership of more than 50% of the beneficial interests.
127. As indicated in paragraph 33 above, some States consider that their tax treaties should include provisions denying the application of specific treaty provisions to income paid to related persons benefiting from regimes that constitute "special tax regimes" (see paragraphs 85–100 of the Commentary on Article 1) and denying the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons that benefit from domestic law provisions providing for a notional deduction in respect of equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). If such provisions are included in the Convention, the Contracting States may consider it more appropriate to include the definition of "related person" in Article 3, which contains definitions that apply throughout the Convention.
The term "equivalent beneficiary"
Simplified Version
e) the term "equivalent beneficiary" means any person who would be entitled to benefits with respect to an item of income provided by a Contracting State under the domestic law of that Contracting State, this Convention or any other international agreement that are equivalent to or more favourable than the benefits provided with respect to that item of income under this Convention. For the purposes of determining whether a person is an equivalent beneficiary with respect to dividends received by a company, that person shall be considered to be a company and to own the same capital of the company paying the dividends as the capital owned by the company claiming benefits with respect to the dividends.
Detailed Version
e) the term "equivalent beneficiary" means:
(i) a resident of any State, provided that:
A) the resident is entitled to all the benefits of a comprehensive tax convention on income taxation between that State and the Contracting State in which benefits are claimed under this Convention, pursuant to provisions similar to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 or, where the benefit claimed relates to interest or dividends paid by a member of a multinational corporate group of the resident, the resident is entitled to benefits under provisions substantially similar to paragraph 5 of this Article, provided that, if such convention does not contain a comprehensive limitation on benefits Article, that convention shall apply as if the provisions of subparagraphs a), b), c) and e) of paragraph 2 (including the definitions relevant to the application of the criteria in such subparagraphs) were contained in that convention; and
B) 1) with respect to income referred to in Articles 10, 11 or 12, if the resident had received such income directly, the resident would be entitled under this Convention, a provision of domestic law or any international agreement to a tax rate on such income, with respect to which benefits are claimed under this Convention, that is lower than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention. With respect to a company seeking under paragraph 4 to obtain the benefits of Article 10 in respect of dividends, for the purposes of this subparagraph:
I) if the resident is an individual, and the company carries on an active trade or business in the Contracting State of which it is a resident that is substantial in relation to the activity generating the income from which the dividends are paid and is similar to or complementary with that trade or business, then that individual shall be treated as a company. The activities carried on by a person that is a related person with respect to the company seeking benefits shall be considered to be carried on by that company. The substantiality of the trade or business shall be determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances; and
II) if the resident is a company (including an individual treated as a company), for the purposes of determining whether the resident is entitled to a tax rate that is lower than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention, the resident's indirect ownership of the capital of the company paying the dividends shall be treated as direct ownership; or
2) with respect to an item of income referred to in Articles 7, 13 or 21 of this Convention, the resident is entitled to benefits under this Convention that are at least as favourable as the benefits claimed under this Convention; and
C) notwithstanding that the resident may satisfy the requirements of subparagraphs A) and B) of this subdivision, if the item of income was derived through an entity that is treated as fiscally transparent under the laws of the Contracting State of residence of the company seeking benefits, if the item of income would not be treated as income of the resident under a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 1, had the resident, rather than the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4 of this Article, itself owned the entity through which the company derives the income, that resident shall not be considered an equivalent beneficiary with respect to that item of income;
(ii) a resident of the same Contracting State as the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4 of this Article, who is entitled to all the benefits of this Convention by virtue of subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 or, where the benefit claimed relates to interest or dividends paid by a member of a multinational corporate group of the resident, who is entitled to benefits under paragraph 5, provided that, in the case of a resident described in paragraph 5, if the resident had received such interest or dividends directly, the resident would be entitled to a tax rate on such income that is lower than or equal to the rate applicable under this Convention to the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4; or
(iii) a resident of the Contracting State in which benefits are claimed under this Convention who is entitled to all the benefits of this Convention on the basis of subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2, provided that the aggregate voting power and value of the shares (and of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company claiming benefits under paragraph 4 does not exceed 25 per cent of the total voting power and value of the shares (and of any disproportionate class of shares) of the company;
Commentary on the definition of "equivalent beneficiary" in the Simplified Version
128. The definition of "equivalent beneficiary" in the Simplified Version applies only for the purposes of paragraph 4 on derivative benefits. This paragraph allows an entity that is a resident of a Contracting State and is not a qualified person to obtain treaty benefits with respect to an item of income if persons who meet the definition of "equivalent beneficiary" directly or indirectly own more than 75 per cent of the beneficial interest in that entity.
129. Under the definition, an equivalent beneficiary is any person who, if it received the relevant item of income directly, would be entitled in the Contracting State to benefits equivalent to or more favourable than the benefits provided with respect to that item of income by that Contracting State under the Convention. These equivalent or more favourable benefits may arise under the domestic law of that State, this Convention itself or any other international agreement to which that State is a party.
130. The last sentence of the definition applies for the purposes of determining the percentage of the capital of the company paying the dividends that a potential equivalent beneficiary owns in that company. This is relevant for the purposes of comparing the benefits provided for dividends under the Convention with the benefits to which that potential equivalent beneficiary would be entitled if it received the dividends directly (for example, 5 per cent under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 or 15 per cent under subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10). Under the last sentence, the potential equivalent beneficiary is considered to be a company owning the same capital in the company paying the dividends as the capital owned by the company seeking to obtain the benefits of paragraph 4 (while paragraph 4 may apply to entities that are not companies, the difference between the rates under Article 10 is relevant only with respect to dividends paid to a company).
Commentary on the definition of "equivalent beneficiary" in the Detailed Version
131. The definition of "equivalent beneficiary" in the Detailed Version applies for the purposes of satisfying the derivative benefits test in paragraph 4, but also applies for the purposes of subparagraph g) of paragraph 2, concerning collective investment vehicles, depending on how that subparagraph is drafted (see paragraph 56 above).
132. The definition recognises three different categories of persons who qualify as "equivalent beneficiaries".
133. The first category (subdivision (i) of the definition) covers residents of third States who are entitled to all the benefits under a comprehensive income tax treaty between the State of residence of that person and the State in which benefits are claimed (hereinafter referred to as the "tested treaty") pursuant to provisions that are substantially similar to the rules in subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2. A company may also be an equivalent beneficiary under subdivision (i) if it is entitled to benefits under the treaty pursuant to a headquarters company test under the tested treaty that is substantially similar to paragraph 5, but only where the benefits claimed by the company relate to interest or dividends paid by a member of the multinational corporate group of the equivalent beneficiary. If the tested treaty does not contain a comprehensive limitation on benefits Article, the requirements of subdivision (i), subparagraph A), are also satisfied if the resident of the third State applies the tested treaty as if that treaty included the provisions of subparagraphs a), b), c) and e) of paragraph 2 (including the relevant definitions for the purposes of applying the provisions of those subparagraphs) and satisfied one of the limitation on benefits provisions by virtue of one of the included subparagraphs.
134. The following examples illustrate the application of subparagraph (i) of the definition:
- Example A: HOLDCO, a resident of State R, is a wholly owned subsidiary of XCO, a resident of State X. The principal class of shares of XCO is listed and regularly traded on a stock exchange in X, a stock exchange located in State X. HOLDCO is not entitled to benefits under paragraph 2 of the Convention between States S and R because it is a subsidiary of a company that is a resident of a third State and is listed on its stock exchange. HOLDCO does not carry on an active business in State R and, therefore, is not entitled to any benefits under paragraph 3. HOLDCO receives interest arising in State S and beneficially owns it, which would otherwise be subject to the 10 per cent rate under Article 11 of the Convention between States S and R. In order to determine whether HOLDCO is entitled to benefits under the derivative benefits test in paragraph 4 of this Convention, it is necessary to determine whether XCO satisfies the definition of an equivalent beneficiary in paragraph 7. The income tax convention between States S and X contains a comprehensive limitation on benefits provision, including a rule for companies whose principal class of shares is listed and regularly traded on a stock exchange in X, which is substantially similar to subparagraph c) of paragraph 2. Accordingly, XCO satisfies the requirements of paragraph A) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. Under the Convention between States S and X, interest arising in any State would also be subject to the 10 per cent rate under Article 11. Therefore, XCO satisfies the requirements of paragraph B) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. Accordingly, XCO is an equivalent beneficiary.
- Example B: Assume the same facts as in Example A, except that the income tax convention between States S and X does not include a comprehensive limitation on benefits provision. Accordingly, for the purpose of determining whether XCO is an equivalent beneficiary, that convention must be applied as if it contained the provisions of subparagraphs a), b), c) and e) of paragraph 2 (including the relevant definitions for the purposes of applying those subparagraphs) of this Convention. If this Convention defines a recognized stock exchange as including the stock exchange in X, the principal class of shares of XCO is listed on a recognized stock exchange located in the State of residence of XCO. Consequently, XCO satisfies subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 and is an equivalent beneficiary. However, if the stock exchange in X is not included in this Convention as a recognized stock exchange, XCO is not an equivalent beneficiary.
135. A resident of a third State cannot be an equivalent beneficiary if that person satisfies:
- a publicly traded company affiliate test similar to that in subparagraph d) of paragraph 2;
- an ownership and base erosion test similar to that in subparagraph f) of paragraph 2;
- a collective investment vehicle test similar to the one that may be included in subparagraph g) of paragraph 2;
- an active business test similar to that in paragraph 3;
- a derivative benefits test similar to that in paragraph 4;
- a discretionary relief provision similar to that in paragraph 6; or
- any other limitation on benefits provision of the tested convention that is not a test under this Convention, since such a resident is not a qualified person under provisions that are substantially similar to subparagraph a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 of this Article.
136. Some States may wish to limit, and in some cases prohibit, treaty benefits for individuals who are taxed on a remittance basis or on a fixed-rate/forfait basis (a predetermined amount). Where this is provided for in the Convention between the Contracting States, these States may also wish to prevent such individuals who are residents of third States from qualifying as "equivalent beneficiaries". This may be done by amending paragraph A) of subparagraph (i) as follows:
A) the resident is entitled to all the benefits of a comprehensive income tax convention between that State and the Contracting State from which benefits are claimed under this Convention, under provisions that are substantially similar to subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 or, where the benefit claimed relates to interest or dividends paid by a member of the resident's multinational corporate group, the resident is entitled to benefits under provisions that are substantially similar to paragraph 5 of this Convention, provided that, if such convention does not contain detailed limitations with respect to the benefits article, the resident would be entitled to benefits under this Convention on the basis of subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 if such resident were a resident of one of the Contracting States within the meaning of Article 4.
Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, an individual
- who is subject to taxation in the State of residence of that individual on income or profits from foreign sources only on a remittance basis or on a similar basis, or
- whose tax is determined in that State wholly or partly on a fixed, "forfait" or similar basis,
shall not be considered an equivalent beneficiary; and
137. Subparagraph B) 1) of subparagraph (i) requires an equivalent beneficiary to be entitled to a tax rate on the category of income received by the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4, either under the tested convention, domestic law or any international agreement, that is less than or equal to the tax rate applicable under this Convention to the company seeking benefits under paragraph 4. Thus, the following rates are compared: the tax rate that the source State may impose under the Convention on income paid to that company if it is entitled to benefits; and the tax rate that the source State may impose if the potential equivalent beneficiary receives the income directly from the source State.
138. As described above, subparagraph B) 1) provides that any reduced rates of taxation provided for under domestic law or any international agreement will be taken into account. This rule recognizes that withholding taxes on many intercompany dividends, interest and royalties may be eliminated, for example, under the provisions of the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive and the EU Interest and Royalties Directive¹, rather than under an income tax convention. This is illustrated by the following example:
- Example: EUCO1, a company resident in State EU1, wholly owns ACO, a resident of State A. ACO wholly owns EUCO2, a resident of State EU2, and receives interest arising in State EU2. The income tax convention between States A and EU2 contains a detailed definition of equivalent beneficiary and exempts interest from source taxation. States EU1 and EU2 are members of the European Union. Under the Interest and Royalties Directive, interest paid by EUCO2 to EUCO1 cannot be taxed by State EU2. Accordingly, EUCO1 satisfies subparagraph B) 1) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary in the income tax convention between States A and EU2, even if the income tax convention between States EU1 and EU2 permits source taxation of interest.
139. Subparagraph B) 1) I) of subparagraph (i) provides a rule applicable to dividends that allows an individual to be treated as a company for the purposes of the comparative test in subparagraph B) 1). Since dividends beneficially owned by individuals are not entitled to the lower rate provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10, whereas a company may be entitled to that lower rate if certain conditions are met, in the absence of this provision, the individual shareholders of a company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 could not be considered equivalent beneficiaries in respect of dividends received from a substantial participation in other companies. By treating individuals as companies for the purposes of the rate comparison test, this rule allows a company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 to take into account shares directly or indirectly owned by an individual as if such shares were owned by a company described in subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 for the purpose of determining whether the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 is 95 per cent owned by equivalent beneficiaries.
140. In order to be entitled to apply the rule in subparagraph B) 1) I), the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 must carry on an active business in its State of residence. The rule treats an individual shareholder who otherwise satisfies the requirements of subparagraph A) of subparagraph (i) as a company described in subparagraph c) of paragraph 2, but only if the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 carries on an active business in its State of residence that is substantial in relation to, and similar to or complementary with, the business activity that generates the income from which the dividends are paid. The test in subparagraph B) 1) I) is similar to the active business test under paragraph 3, except that it does not require the income from the source State to "emanate" from the active business of the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4. The term "active business" has the same meaning as in subparagraph a) of paragraph 3 and therefore does not include the activities described in subparagraphs (i)-(iv) of that subparagraph. For the purpose of determining whether the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 carries on an active business in a Contracting State, activities carried on by a person related to that company shall be deemed to be carried on by the company. The expression "substantial in relation to" has the same meaning as in subparagraph c) of paragraph 3. This substantiality requirement must be applied regardless of whether the dividend is received from a related person. On the other hand, dividends received from another Contracting State do not necessarily have to emanate from the active business of the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4, as required under subparagraph a) of paragraph 3, in order to qualify for benefits, since the active business carried on in the Contracting State of residence for the purposes of subparagraph B) 1) I) need only be "similar to or complementary with" the active business carried on in the source State, rather than "identical to or complementary with" that active business carried on in the source State.
¹ Council Directive 2011/96/EU of 30 November 2011 on the common system of taxation applicable in the case of parent companies and subsidiaries of different Member States, as amended; Council Directive 2003/49/EC of 3 June 2003 on a common system of taxation applicable to interest and royalty payments made between associated companies of different Member States.
141. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph B) 1) I):
- Example: RCO is a company resident in State R. RCO carries on an active business in State R that is similar to the business carried on by SCO, a company resident in State S. RCO has been a resident of State R for 13 months and has also owned 25% of the capital of SCO for 13 months. Individual Y is the sole shareholder of RCO and a resident of State Y. Paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the income tax convention between States S and Y and between States S and R is identical to the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital. Accordingly, RCO satisfies the requirements set out in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 with respect to the lower rate applicable to dividends. However, in the absence of subparagraph B) 1) I), RCO would not be entitled to that lower rate because individual Y would be entitled to the 15 per cent rate (under subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10) if receiving dividends directly from SCO. However, under subparagraph B) 1) I), Y must be treated as a company within the meaning of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R for the purposes of the rate comparison test, which means that RCO satisfies the rate comparison test. Thus, provided that all other requirements (such as the base erosion test and the beneficial ownership requirement under Article 10) are met, RCO would be entitled to the lower rate provided for under Article 10 of the income tax convention between States S and R with respect to dividends paid by SCO.
142. Subparagraph B) 1) II) of subparagraph (i) contains a rule for determining the percentage of the capital of the company paying the dividends that a potential equivalent beneficiary would own for the purposes of the rate comparison test, which, like subparagraph B) 1) I), will affect entitlement to the lower tax rate under subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the equivalent beneficiary if it were to receive the dividends directly. For the purposes of the rate comparison test described in subparagraph B) 1), indirect ownership by a potential equivalent beneficiary of the capital of the company paying the dividends must be treated as direct ownership. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph B) 1) II):
- Example: XCO and YCO directly own 50 per cent of the capital of RCO, a company resident in State R. For 13 months, RCO has owned 25 per cent of the capital of SCO and has been a resident of State R. State S has income tax conventions with States R, X and Y; paragraph 2 of Article 10 of these income tax conventions is identical to the corresponding provision of the OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital. XCO is a resident of State X and is a qualified person under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R. YCO is a resident of State Y and is also a qualified person under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of the income tax convention between States S and R. Consequently, both XCO and YCO satisfy subparagraph A) of the definition of equivalent beneficiary. However, for the purpose of determining the tax rate on dividends paid by SCO to which XCO and YCO are entitled under their respective tax conventions with State S, each of XCO and YCO is treated under subparagraph B) 1) II) as directly owning 12.5% of the capital of SCO (50% of the 25 per cent shareholding in SCO equals 12.5%, the amount of the corresponding indirect ownership of XCO and YCO in the capital of SCO that is treated as direct ownership). Consequently, XCO and YCO are not entitled to the lower tax rate provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 and are therefore not considered equivalent beneficiaries, since they do not satisfy the rate comparison test under subparagraph B) 1) (see paragraph 147 below concerning alternative provisions that allow RCO to benefit from the 15 per cent rate under subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the income tax convention between States S and R).
143. Subparagraph B) 2) of subparagraph (i) provides rules for obtaining derivative benefits for categories of income covered by Articles 7, 13 or 21. A potential equivalent beneficiary is entitled to benefits under the tested convention that are at least as favourable as those applicable under the Convention to such business profits or other income. Thus, the following benefits are compared: first, the benefits that the source State would grant to the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 if it were entitled to benefits under the relevant income article; and, second, the benefits that the source State would grant to the potential equivalent beneficiary if it received the income directly. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph B) 2):
- Example: RCO is a company resident in State R that is wholly owned by XCO, a publicly traded company resident in State X. RCO has a contract to construct a large office complex in State S. Under the terms of the income tax convention between States S and R, a construction site constitutes a permanent establishment only if it exists for more than twelve months. However, under the terms of the income tax convention between States S and X, a construction site constitutes a permanent establishment only if it exists for more than six months. If the construction site exists for more than six months but less than 12 months, XCO is not an equivalent beneficiary because it is not entitled to the same protection under Article 5 of the income tax convention between States S and X as that provided under Article 5 of the income tax convention between States S and R.
144. Subparagraph C) of subparagraph (i) provides an additional limitation where an item of income has been derived through an entity that is treated as fiscally transparent under the laws of the Contracting State of residence of the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4. In such a case, notwithstanding that the resident may satisfy the requirements of subparagraphs A) or B) on the basis of a comparison of the terms of the tested convention with the terms of the convention under which the company seeks derivative benefits, the resident does not satisfy the requirements of this subparagraph unless the relevant item of income is treated as the income of that resident under a provision similar to paragraph 2 of Article 1, if that resident, rather than the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4, had been paid that item of income in respect of which the company claims benefits. The following example illustrates the application of subparagraph C):
Example: RCO, a publicly traded company resident in State R, owns shares in SCO, a company resident in State S, through P, a partnership organized in State S. P is fiscally transparent under the domestic tax law of State S and is treated as a company under the domestic tax law of State R. Under the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 1, dividends paid by SCO through P would not be considered to have been received by RCO and would therefore not be entitled to a reduction of source taxation in State S under Article 10. RCO interposes XCO, a resident of State X, between itself and P. Under the domestic tax law of State X, P is fiscally transparent for tax purposes, and XCO is therefore considered to receive the dividends paid by SCO to P.
The income tax convention between States S and X contains a detailed version of paragraphs 1–7 of Article 29. In order to benefit from a reduction in tax withheld at source on dividends under this Convention, XCO must satisfy the derivative benefits test. Although the dividend rates under paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the convention between States S and X are the same as those under Article 10 of the convention between States S and R, and subparagraph A) of subparagraph (i) would be satisfied, the dividends would not be considered to have been received by RCO if RCO, rather than XCO, owned SCO through partnership P. Accordingly, by virtue of subparagraph C), RCO is not an equivalent beneficiary, and for this reason XCO is not entitled to derivative benefits under paragraph 4 with respect to dividends paid by SCO through P.
145. The second category of persons who qualify as an "equivalent beneficiary" (subparagraph (ii) of the definition) applies to persons who are residents of the same Contracting State as the company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4. Such persons are equivalent beneficiaries if they are entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2 or under paragraph 5 as a headquarters company. However, a headquarters company is an equivalent beneficiary of a company seeking derivative benefits under paragraph 4 only if the company seeking derivative benefits receives interest or dividends from a member of the headquarters company's multinational corporate group. Nevertheless, the rate comparison test applies to any resident satisfying the headquarters company test in paragraph 5 that receives dividends or interest from another Contracting State. This requirement is intended to ensure that the headquarters company is entitled to at least the same treaty benefits with respect to dividends or interest as the company claiming derivative benefits under paragraph 4, so that, for example, where Article 11 of the Convention generally exempts interest from source taxation but does not do so in respect of interest paid to the headquarters company by a member of that company's multinational group, the headquarters company will not be an equivalent beneficiary of a company that would otherwise be entitled to the exemption from source taxation provided for under the Convention on a similar interest payment.
146. The third category of persons who qualify as an "equivalent beneficiary" (subparagraph (iii) of the definition) applies to persons who are residents of the Contracting State of source. Such persons are equivalent beneficiaries if they are entitled to benefits under subparagraphs a), b), c) or e) of paragraph 2, provided that the ownership by such residents of the aggregate voting power and value of shares (and any disproportionate class of shares, as defined in paragraph 7) of the company claiming derivative benefits does not exceed 25 per cent. Under the ownership requirement in subparagraph a) of paragraph 4, ownership may be direct or indirect, but in the case of indirect ownership each intermediate owner must be a "qualified intermediate owner" within the meaning of the definition of that term in paragraph 7 (see below).
147. As explained in paragraph 10 above, in the case of the application of paragraph 4 on derivative benefits, the definition of equivalent beneficiary excludes persons who, under another convention, are entitled to an exemption from taxation by the source State that is not as favourable as the exemption from taxation provided for under this Convention. Some States may wish to eliminate the resulting so-called "cliff effect" associated with the denial of all treaty benefits, even where the difference in benefits provided under the two conventions is relatively insignificant, by providing for the source State to grant an exemption from taxation similar to the exemption that would have been granted under the other convention. Such treatment may be achieved through the alternative provisions set out below, which relate to the taxation of dividends, interest and royalties and provide limited benefits that generally correspond to those that would be available under the other convention:
Dividend provision supplementing Article 10
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4 of this Article, in the case of a company seeking to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 of this Convention with respect to dividends, if such company does not satisfy the requirements of this paragraph solely because of:
a) the requirements of paragraph B) of subparagraph (i) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29; or
b) the requirements of subparagraph (ii) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29, that a person entitled to benefits under paragraph 5 of Article 29 is entitled to a tax rate on dividends that is less than or equal to the rate applicable under paragraph 2 of this Article;
such company may be taxed in the Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident and in accordance with the laws of that Contracting State. In such cases, however, the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate among the tax rates to which the persons referred to in the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 are entitled if they receive the dividends directly (notwithstanding the requirements referred to in subparagraphs a) and b) of this paragraph). For the purposes of this paragraph:
c) indirect ownership by such persons of the voting shares of the company paying the dividends shall be treated as direct ownership; and
d) a person described in subparagraph (iii) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be treated as being entitled to the limitation of tax to which such person would be entitled if it were a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the dividends.
Provision on Interest Added to Article 11
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 4 of this Article, where a company seeks to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 with respect to interest payments, if such company fails to meet the criteria of that paragraph solely because of:
a) the requirements of paragraph B) of subdivision (i) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29; or
b) the requirements in subdivision (ii) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 that a person entitled to benefits under paragraph 5 of Article 29 is entitled to a tax rate on interest that is less than or equal to the rate applicable under paragraph 2 of this Article;
such company may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the interest arises in accordance with the laws of that State. In such cases, however, the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate among the tax rates to which the persons referred to in the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 (notwithstanding the requirements set out in subparagraphs a) and b) of this paragraph) would be entitled if they received the interest directly. For the purposes of this paragraph, a person described in subdivision (iii) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be considered as being entitled to a limitation on tax if it is a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the interest.
Provision on Royalties Added to Article 12
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, but subject to the provisions of paragraph 3 of this Article, in the case of a company seeking to satisfy the requirements of paragraph 4 of Article 29 with respect to royalties, if such company fails to satisfy the criteria of that paragraph solely by reason of the requirement in paragraph B) of subdivision (i) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29, such company may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the royalties arise and in accordance with the laws of that State, except that the tax so charged shall not exceed the highest rate among the tax rates to which the persons referred to in the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 (notwithstanding the requirement of paragraph B) of subdivision (i) of that definition) would be entitled if they received the royalties directly. For the purposes of this paragraph, a person described in subdivision (iii) of the definition of the term "equivalent beneficiary" in subparagraph e) of paragraph 7 of Article 29 shall be considered as being entitled to the limitation on tax to which it would be entitled if it were a resident of the same Contracting State as the company receiving the royalties.
Term "Disproportionate Class of Shares"
Only the Detailed Version
f) the term "disproportionate class of shares" means any class of shares of a company or other entity that is a resident of one of the Contracting States which gives a shareholder the right to a disproportionately greater participation, by way of dividends, redemption payments or otherwise, in the income derived from the other Contracting State by specific assets or activities of the company;
Commentary on the Definition of "Disproportionate Class of Shares" in the Detailed Version
148. Under the definition of the term "disproportionate class of shares", which is used in the ownership test in various parts of the Article, a company or other entity has a disproportionate class of shares if it has outstanding shares that are subject to terms or other arrangements that give the holder of those shares the right to receive a greater portion of the income derived by the company or other entity in another Contracting State than the portion to which the holder would have been entitled in the absence of such terms or arrangements.
Thus, for example, a company resident in one Contracting State has a "disproportionate class of shares" if some of the outstanding shares of that company are "tracking shares" that pay dividends according to a formula that approximately corresponds to the income of the company from its assets used in another Contracting State. This is illustrated by the following example:
- Example: ACO is a company resident in State A. ACO has issued ordinary and preferred shares. The ordinary shares are listed and regularly traded on the principal stock exchange of State A. The preferred shares have no voting rights and entitle their holders only to receive dividends equal to the amount of interest payments that ACO receives from unrelated borrowers in State B. The shares are wholly owned by a single shareholder who is a resident of a third State with which State B does not have a tax treaty. The ordinary shares account for more than 50% of the value of ACO and 100% of its voting rights. Since the owner of the preferred shares is entitled to receive payments corresponding to the interest income of ACO arising in State B, the preferred shares constitute a "disproportionate class of shares" and, since these shares are not regularly traded on a recognised stock exchange, ACO is not entitled to benefits under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2.
Term "Place of Effective Management and Control"
Only the Detailed Version
g) the "place of effective management and control" of a company or other entity is in the Contracting State of which it is a resident only if:
(i) the senior officers and senior management of the company or other entity have day-to-day responsibility for making more of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company or other entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the personnel conduct the day-to-day activities necessary for the preparation and making of those decisions, in the majority of cases in that Contracting State rather than in any other State; and
(ii) such senior officers and senior management employees have day-to-day responsibility for making more of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company or other entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the personnel of such persons conduct more of the day-to-day activities necessary for the preparation and making of those decisions than the officers or employees of any other company or other entity;
Commentary on the Definition of "Place of Effective Management and Control" in the Detailed Version
149. The term "place of effective management and control" is applicable for the purposes of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 and paragraph 5 of the detailed version. This term should be distinguished from the concept of the "place where the effective executive body is located", which was used before 2017 in paragraph 3 of Article 4 and in various provisions, including Article 8, applicable to the operation of ships and aircraft. The concept of the "place where the effective executive body is located" was interpreted by some States as the place where the highest-ranking person or group of persons (for example, the board of directors) made the key management and commercial decisions necessary for the conduct of business. The concept of the place of effective management and control, by contrast, refers to the place where the day-to-day management of the company or other entity (as well as its direct and indirect subsidiaries) is carried out.
150. The place of effective management and control of a company or other entity is in the State of residence of that company or other entity only if the following two conditions are met:
- First, under subdivision (i), the senior officers and senior management of the company have day-to-day responsibility for making more of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company or other entity and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the personnel who support management in the preparation and making of such decisions perform their activities, in the majority of cases, in that Contracting State rather than in any other State. Thus, the criterion focuses on the overall activities of the relevant persons in order to determine where those activities are performed. In most cases, this is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for the chief executive officer and other senior officers to be generally located in the Contracting State of which the company is a resident.
- Second, the senior officers and senior management employees have day-to-day responsibility for making more of the decisions on the strategic, financial and operational policies of the company and its direct and indirect subsidiaries, and the personnel who support such management in making these decisions perform more of the day-to-day activities necessary for the preparation and making of those decisions than the officers or employees of any other company or other entity.
Term "Qualified Intermediate Owner"
Only the Detailed Version
h) the term "qualified intermediate owner" means an intermediate owner that is either:
(i) a resident of a State that has in force with the Contracting State from which benefits are claimed under this Convention a comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation; or
(ii) a resident of the same Contracting State as the company applying the test under subparagraph d) or f) of paragraph 2 or paragraph 4 to determine whether it is entitled to benefits under the Convention;
Commentary on the Definition of "Qualified Intermediate Owner" in the Detailed Version
151. The definition of "qualified intermediate owner" in the detailed version applies for the purposes of the ownership test referred to in subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2, as well as the derivative benefits rule in paragraph 4.
152. Under subdivision (i) of this definition, a qualified intermediate owner is a legal entity resident in a third State that has an effective comprehensive income tax treaty with the Contracting State from which treaty benefits are claimed.
153. As indicated in the Commentary on Article 1, some States consider that their tax treaties should include provisions prohibiting the application of specific treaty provisions to income derived from regimes that constitute "special tax regimes" (see paragraphs 85-100 of the Commentary on Article 1) and prohibiting the application of Article 11 to interest paid to related persons who benefit from provisions of domestic law providing for a notional deduction in respect of equity (see paragraph 107 of the Commentary on Article 1). These States may restrict the scope of application of subdivision (i) so that it applies only to residents of third States with which the State from which treaty benefits are claimed has concluded comprehensive income tax treaties and which do not benefit from a special tax regime or notional interest deductions. This may be done by amending subdivision (i) as follows:
(i) a resident of a State that has in force with the Contracting State from which benefits are claimed under this Convention a comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation and that does not benefit from:
A) a special tax regime, provided that the relevant comprehensive convention for the avoidance of double taxation does not contain a definition of a special tax regime similar to the provisions included in [reference to the paragraph of the Convention that includes the definition of "special tax regime"], and the principles of the definition provided for in this Convention apply to it, but without taking into account the requirement of paragraph (v) of this definition; or
B) notional deductions of the type described in [reference to the paragraph of Article 11 dealing with notional deductions in respect of equity]; or
154. Under subdivision (ii) of the definition, a qualified intermediate owner also includes a resident of the same Contracting State as the company to which the relevant ownership test under subparagraph d) or f) of paragraph 2 or under the derivative benefits rule in paragraph 4 applies.
Term "Tested Group"
Only the Detailed Version
i) the term "tested group" means a resident of a Contracting State to which the test under subparagraph d) or f) of paragraph 2 or under paragraph 4 or 5 applies to determine whether it is entitled to benefits under the Convention (the "tested resident"), and any company or permanent establishment that:
(i) participates as a member together with the tested resident in a tax consolidation, fiscal unity or similar regime that allows group members to share profits or losses; or
(ii) shares losses with the tested resident under a group or other loss-sharing regime in the relevant taxable period;
Commentary on the Definition of "Tested Group" in the Detailed Version
155. This subparagraph defines the term "tested group" for the purposes of the base erosion rules in subdivision (ii) of subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2 and in paragraphs 4 and 5. The tested group must consist of the tested company to which the relevant base erosion rule applies (referred to as the "tested resident") and any company that either participates as a member together with that tested resident in a tax consolidation, fiscal unity or similar regime that allows group members to share profits or losses, or any company that shares losses with the tested resident during the relevant taxable period under a tax consolidation or other loss-sharing regime. If there is no tested group, the relevant base erosion test applicable to the tested group does not apply.
Term "Gross Income"
Only the Detailed Version
j) the term "gross income" means gross receipts as determined in the Contracting State of residence of the person for the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are granted, except that where the person carries on a business that includes the manufacture or sale of goods,
"gross income" means such gross receipts reduced by the cost of goods sold, and where the person carries on a business of providing non-financial services, "gross income" means gross receipts reduced by the direct costs incurred to generate such receipts, provided that:
(i) except where relevant for determining benefits under Article 10 of this Convention, gross income does not include that portion of dividends that is effectively exempt from tax in the Contracting State of residence of the person, whether by way of deductions or otherwise; and
(ii) except for the portion of dividends that is taxable, the gross income of the tested group does not take into account transactions between companies within the tested group;
Commentary on the Definition of "Gross Income" in the Detailed Version
156. This subparagraph defines the term "gross income" for the purposes of the base erosion rules in subdivision (ii) of subparagraphs d) and f) of paragraph 2 and in paragraphs 4 and 5. The starting point for calculating gross income is gross receipts as determined in the Contracting State of residence of the relevant entity during the taxable period that includes the time when the benefits are granted. If the company carries on a business that includes the manufacture or sale of goods, "gross income" means gross receipts reduced by the cost of goods sold. If the tested entity is engaged in the provision of non-financial services, "gross income" means such gross receipts reduced by the direct costs incurred to generate such income.
157. Subdivision (i) of the definition further provides that, except for determining benefits in respect of dividends under Article 10, gross income does not include that portion of any dividends that is effectively exempt from tax in the Contracting State of residence of the person, whether by way of deductions or otherwise, irrespective of the State of residence of the company paying those dividends. Subdivision (ii) provides that, except for the portion of dividends that is taxable, the gross income of the tested group does not take into account any transactions between companies within the tested group.
Term "Collective Investment Vehicle"
Only the Detailed Version
k) [possible definition of "collective investment vehicle"]¹.
Commentary on the Definition of "Collective Investment Vehicle" in the Detailed Version
158. As indicated in the footnote to this subparagraph, the definition of "collective investment vehicle" should be included if a provision concerning a collective investment vehicle is included in subparagraph g) of paragraph 2. This definition should identify the collective investment vehicle of each Contracting State to which this provision applies, and it may be worded as follows:
the term "collective investment vehicle" means, in the case of [State A], [ ] and, in the case of [State B], [ ], any other investment fund, arrangement or entity established in either Contracting State that the competent authorities of the Contracting States agree to treat as a collective investment vehicle for the purposes of this Article;
159. As explained in paragraph 36 of the Commentary on Article 1, it is intended that the open parts of this definition include cross-references to the relevant provisions of the tax or securities legislation of each State that define the CIVs to which subparagraph g) of paragraph 2 applies.
Paragraph 7 (Simplified Version): Procedure for Making a Claim to Be Determined by the Competent Authorities
Only the Simplified Version
7. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may by mutual agreement settle the mode of application of this Article.
¹ The definition of the term "collective investment vehicle" should be added if a provision concerning collective investment vehicles is included in paragraph 2 (see subparagraph g) of paragraph 2).
Commentary on Paragraph 7 of the Simplified Version
160. Paragraph 7 of the simplified version allows the competent authorities of the Contracting States, by mutual agreement, to settle the mode of application of the provisions of the preceding paragraphs of the Article. They may, for example, agree on procedural aspects of dealing with a request for treaty benefits under the provisions of paragraph 5 on discretionary relief.
Paragraph 8
161. As mentioned in paragraph 32 of the Commentary on Article 10, paragraph 25 of the Commentary on Article 11 and paragraph 21 of the Commentary on Article 12, potential abuses arise as a result of the transfer of shares, debt-claims, rights or property to a permanent establishment created exclusively for this purpose in countries that do not tax income from such assets or offer a preferential tax regime for such income. If the State of residence exempts from tax the profits attributable to such permanent establishments located in third jurisdictions, the State of source should not grant treaty benefits in respect of such income. This paragraph, which applies where a Contracting State exempts from tax the income of an enterprise of that State that is attributable to permanent establishments located in third jurisdictions, provides that treaty benefits will not be granted in such cases. However, this rule does not apply if
- the income is subject to a substantial level of taxation in the State in which the permanent establishment is located, or
- the income is derived from an active business carried on through the permanent establishment or is incidental thereto, with the exception of an investment business that is not carried on by a bank, insurance company or registered securities dealer.
162. Under subparagraph c), in any case where benefits are denied pursuant to this paragraph, a resident of a Contracting State who receives the relevant income may request that the competent authority of the other Contracting State grant those benefits. The competent authority receiving such a request may, at its discretion, grant those benefits if it considers this justified; however, it must consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or denying the request.
163. The following example illustrates the type of situation in which this paragraph is intended to apply. An enterprise of a Contracting State establishes a permanent establishment in a third jurisdiction that does not tax, or taxes at a low rate, the profits of the permanent establishment. The profits attributable to the permanent establishment are exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State either under a provision similar to Article 23 A included in the tax convention between that State and the jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located, or under the domestic law of the first-mentioned State. The enterprise receives interest from another Contracting State, which is included in the profits attributable to the permanent establishment. Assuming that the conditions for the application of Article 11 are met, the State in which the interest arises would, in the absence of paragraph 8, be required to grant the benefits of the limitation on taxation provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 11, notwithstanding the fact that the interest is exempt from tax in the first-mentioned State and is subject to little or no tax in the third jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located. In this situation, the benefits of the Convention will be denied in respect of that income, except where the exception in subparagraph b), applicable to income derived from or incidental to an active business, applies to the relevant income or where those benefits are granted under the discretionary relief provision provided for in subparagraph c) by the competent authority of the State in which the interest arises.
164. The reference to the word "income" in subdivision (i) means that the provision applies irrespective of whether the relevant income constitutes business profits. Thus, the rule applies where an enterprise of one Contracting State derives income from another Contracting State and the first-mentioned State considers the right or property in respect of which the income is paid to be effectively connected with a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction (including pursuant to provisions such as paragraph 2 of Article 21 of the treaty between the first-mentioned State and the third jurisdiction).
165. Where the conditions in subdivisions (i) and (ii) are met, subparagraph a) denies the benefits that would otherwise apply under the other provisions of the Convention if the relevant category of income is treated as part of the profits of a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction and the amount of tax charged on that category of income in that third jurisdiction is less than the lesser of the following two amounts: a) the amount of that category of income multiplied by the minimum rate that the Contracting States have bilaterally agreed upon for the purposes of this paragraph, and b) 60 per cent of the amount of tax that would have been imposed on that category of income in the State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment had been located in that State.
166. The phrase "the amount of that category of income" refers to the amount of the relevant income after deducting all expenses attributable to that category of income that are deductible under the law of the relevant jurisdiction. Thus, for the purposes of determining the tax in the third jurisdiction attributable to that category of income, the total tax applicable to the profits of the permanent establishment located in that jurisdiction will be calculated after deducting all expenses that are deductible under the law of that jurisdiction in determining the taxable profits attributable to the permanent establishment. The tax applicable to the relevant amount of the category of income is then determined by multiplying the total tax applicable to the profits of the permanent establishment by the ratio of the net amount of the category of income (i.e. the gross amount of the category of income less the expenses deductible in calculating the taxable profits of the permanent establishment that are directly or proportionately attributable to that category of income) to the taxable profits of the permanent establishment. A similar calculation is made for the purposes of determining the tax that would be charged on that category of income in the Contracting State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment were located in that State; in this case, the expenses deductible under the law of that State are deducted.
167. For the purposes of the exception included in subparagraph b), the reference to income that "is derived from an active business or is incidental thereto" should be interpreted as indicated in paragraphs 74–76 above.
168. Instead of adopting the wording of paragraph 8, some States may prefer a more comprehensive solution that is not limited to situations where an enterprise of a Contracting State is exempt in that State from tax on profits attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction, that does not include an exception applicable to income arising from an active business or incidental thereto, and that does not require an assessment of the tax that would have been paid in the State of the enterprise if the permanent establishment had been located in that State. In such a case, the rule applies whenever income derived in one Contracting State and attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction is subject to combined taxation in the State of the enterprise and the jurisdiction of the permanent establishment at an effective rate that is lower than the lower rate determined on a bilateral basis and which is 60 per cent of the general corporate income tax rate in the State in which the enterprise is located. The following is an example of a rule that could be used for this purpose:
If an enterprise of a Contracting State derives income from the other Contracting State and the first-mentioned Contracting State treats that income as profits attributable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction, the benefits of this Convention shall not apply to that income if the income is subject to a combined effective tax rate in the first-mentioned Contracting State and the jurisdiction in which the permanent establishment is located that is lower than the lesser of [the rate determined on a bilateral basis] or 60 per cent of the general statutory corporate income tax rate applicable in the first-mentioned Contracting State. If the benefits of this Convention are denied pursuant to the preceding sentence in respect of an item of income derived by a resident of one Contracting State, the competent authority of the other Contracting State may nevertheless grant those benefits in respect of that item of income if, in response to a request by such resident, that competent authority determines that the granting of such benefits is justified in light of the reasons why such resident did not satisfy the requirements of this paragraph (for example, the existence of losses). The competent authority of the Contracting State to which a request has been made pursuant to the preceding sentence must consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before granting or denying the request.
Paragraph 9
169. Paragraph 9 reflects the guidance contained in paragraphs 61 and 76–80 of the Commentary on Article 1.
According to that guidance, tax treaty benefits should not be granted where one of the principal purposes of certain transactions or arrangements is to abuse the provisions of tax treaties and the granting of benefits in the circumstances would be contrary to the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the tax convention. Paragraph 9 incorporates the principles underlying those paragraphs into the Convention itself, in order to allow States to address cases of improper use of the Convention even where their domestic law does not permit them to do so under paragraphs 76–80 of the Commentary on Article 1; it also confirms the application of these principles to States whose domestic law already allows them to address such cases.
170. The provisions of paragraph 9 result in the denial of benefits under a tax convention where one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction is to obtain benefits under the convention. However, in this case, the last part of the paragraph allows a person who would otherwise be denied benefits the opportunity to establish that the granting of benefits in the circumstances is in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of this Convention.
171. Paragraph 9 supplements and in no way limits the scope or application of the provisions of paragraphs 1–7 (the limitation on benefits rule) and paragraph 8 (the rule applicable to a permanent establishment located in a third jurisdiction): a benefit denied under those paragraphs is not a "benefit under the Convention" that would also be denied under paragraph 9. Moreover, the guidance contained in the Commentary on paragraph 9 should not be used to interpret paragraphs 1 to 8, and vice versa.
172. Conversely, the fact that a person is entitled to benefits under paragraphs 1–7 does not mean that those benefits cannot be denied under paragraph 9. Paragraphs 1–7 constitute rules that focus primarily on the legal nature, ownership and general activities of residents of a Contracting State. As illustrated by the example in the following paragraph, these rules do not imply that a transaction or arrangement entered into by such a resident cannot constitute an improper use of a treaty provision.
173. Paragraph 9 should be considered in the context of paragraphs 1–7 and the rest of the Convention, including its preamble. This is particularly important for the purposes of determining the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the Convention. Assume, for example, that a publicly traded company whose shares are regularly traded on a recognized stock exchange in a Contracting State of which the company is a resident derives income from another Contracting State. As long as that company is a "qualified person" as defined in paragraph 2, it is clear that the benefits of the convention should not be denied solely on the basis of the ownership structure of that company, for example, because the majority of the company's shareholders are not residents of the same State. The object and purpose of subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 is to establish a threshold for treaty entitlement for publicly traded companies whose shares are owned by residents of different States. However, the fact that such a company is a qualified person does not mean that benefits cannot be denied under paragraph 9 for reasons unrelated to the ownership of the company's shares. Assume, for example, that such a publicly traded company is a bank that enters into a conduit financing arrangement designed to indirectly provide a resident of a third State with the benefit of lower source taxation under a tax treaty. In this case, paragraph 9 applies to deny the benefits, since subparagraph c) of paragraph 2, considered in the context of the rest of the Convention and, in particular, its preamble, cannot be regarded as having the common objective of the two Contracting States of authorizing commercial transactions entered into by publicly traded companies.
174. The provisions of paragraph 9 establish that a Contracting State may deny the benefits of a tax convention if it can be concluded, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, that one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction was to obtain a benefit under the tax convention. This provision is intended to ensure that tax conventions are applied in accordance with the purpose for which they were concluded, i.e. to provide benefits in respect of bona fide exchanges of goods and services and movements of capital and persons, as opposed to arrangements whose principal purpose is to secure a more favourable tax treatment.
175. The term "benefit" includes all limitations (for example, a reduction in tax, an exemption, a deferral or a refund) on taxation imposed by the State of source under Articles 6–22 of the Convention, the elimination of double taxation provided for in Article 23, and the protection afforded to residents and nationals of a Contracting State under Article 24 or any other similar limitations. This includes, for example, limitations on the taxing rights of a Contracting State in respect of dividends, interest or royalties arising in that State and paid to a resident of the other State (who is the beneficial owner) under Articles 10, 11 or 12. It also includes limitations on the taxing rights of a Contracting State in respect of capital gains derived from the alienation of movable property located in that State by a resident of the other State under Article 13. If a tax convention includes other limitations (such as a tax-sparing provision), the provisions of this Article also apply to that benefit.
176. The expression "directly or indirectly resulted in that benefit" is deliberately broad and is intended to include situations where a person claiming the application of benefits under a tax treaty may do so in respect of a transaction that is not itself a transaction entered into with one of the principal purposes of obtaining that treaty benefit. This is illustrated by the following example:
TCO, a company resident in State T, acquired all the shares and debt of SCO, a company resident in State S, which had previously been owned by SCO's parent company. These included a loan granted to SCO at an annual interest rate of 4 per cent, repayable on demand. State T has no tax treaty with State S, and therefore any interest paid by SCO to TCO is subject to withholding tax on interest at a rate of 25 per cent under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax convention between State S and State R, there is no withholding tax on interest paid by a company resident in the Contracting State of source where the interest is paid by a company resident in one Contracting State and is beneficially owned by a company resident in the other State; moreover, that treaty does not contain provisions similar to paragraphs 1–7. TCO decides to transfer the loan to RCO, a subsidiary resident in State R, in exchange for three demand promissory notes on which interest is paid at a rate of 3.9 per cent.
In this example, while RCO claims the benefits of the treaty between State R and State S in respect of the loan, which was entered into for commercial reasons, if the circumstances of the case show that one of TCO's principal purposes in transferring its loan to RCO was to obtain the benefit of the convention between State R and State S, then the provision denying that benefit will apply, since that benefit will have indirectly resulted from the transfer of the loan.
177. The terms "arrangement or transaction" should be interpreted broadly and include any agreement, arrangement, scheme, transaction or series of transactions, regardless of whether they are legally enforceable. In particular, they include the creation, assignment, acquisition or transfer of the income itself or of the property or rights in respect of which the income accrues. These terms also cover arrangements concerning the creation, acquisition or maintenance of the person receiving the income, including the qualification of that person as a resident of one of the Contracting States, and include steps that persons may take to establish their place of residence. An example of an "arrangement" may be steps taken to ensure that meetings of a company's board of directors are held in another country so that it can be claimed that the company has changed its place of residence. A single transaction may result in a benefit, or it may operate in conjunction with a more complex series of transactions that together result in a benefit. In both cases, the provisions of paragraph 9 apply.
178. In determining whether one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction is to obtain benefits under the Convention, it is important to conduct an objective analysis of the purposes and objectives of all persons involved in creating such an arrangement or transaction. The question of what the purposes of an arrangement or transaction are can only be answered by considering all the circumstances relating to the arrangement or transaction on a case-by-case basis. It is not necessary to find compelling evidence of the intention of a person associated with the arrangement or transaction, but, following an objective analysis of the relevant facts and circumstances, it must be concluded that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement or transaction was to abuse the provisions of tax conventions. However, it should not be lightly assumed that abuse of the provisions of a tax convention is one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction, and a mere analysis of the effects of an arrangement will generally not be sufficient to conclude what its purposes were. However, where an arrangement can reasonably be explained only by the benefit arising under the treaty, it may be concluded that one of the principal purposes of that arrangement was to obtain that benefit.
179. A person cannot avoid the application of this paragraph by claiming that the arrangement or transaction was not entered into or organized for the purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention. All the evidence must be weighed in order to determine whether the arrangement or transaction was entered into or organized for such a purpose. The determination requires reasonableness, assuming that the possibility of different interpretations of events has been considered objectively.
180. The reference to "one of the principal purposes" in paragraph 9 means that obtaining a benefit under a tax convention does not necessarily have to be the sole or dominant purpose of a particular arrangement or transaction. It is sufficient that obtaining a benefit is at least one of the principal purposes. For example, a person may sell immovable property for various reasons, but if, prior to the sale, that person becomes a resident of one of the Contracting States and one of the principal purposes for doing so is to obtain a benefit under a tax convention, paragraph 9 may apply, notwithstanding that there may also be other principal purposes for changing the place of residence, such as facilitating the sale of the property or the reinvestment of the proceeds of the alienation.
181. A purpose is not a principal purpose if, having regard to all the relevant facts and circumstances, it can be concluded that obtaining the benefit was not a principal purpose and would not have justified entering into any arrangement or transaction that, either by itself or together with other transactions, resulted in the benefit. In particular, where an arrangement is inextricably linked to a core commercial activity and its form is not driven by the purpose of obtaining a benefit, it is unlikely that obtaining that benefit will be considered a principal purpose. However, where an arrangement is entered into for the purpose of obtaining similar benefits under a number of treaties, it should not be considered that obtaining benefits under other treaties means that obtaining a benefit under one treaty is not a principal purpose of that arrangement. Assume, for example, that a taxpayer resident in State A enters into an arrangement with a financial institution resident in State B for that financial institution to invest in bonds issued by the taxpayer in a large number of States with which State B, but not State A, has tax treaties. If the facts and circumstances show that the arrangement was entered into with the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under those tax treaties, it should not be considered that obtaining a benefit under one particular treaty was not one of the principal purposes of that arrangement. Similarly, purposes relating to the avoidance of domestic law should not be used to argue that obtaining a treaty benefit is merely incidental to those purposes.
182. The following examples illustrate the application of the paragraph (the examples included in paragraph 187 below should also be taken into account when determining whether and when this paragraph will apply in the case of conduit arrangements). When reading these examples, it should be borne in mind that the application of paragraph 9 is determined on the basis of the facts and circumstances of each particular case. Accordingly, the examples below are purely illustrative and should not be interpreted as establishing conditions or requirements that similar transactions must satisfy in order to avoid the application of the provisions of paragraph 9:
Example A: TCO, a company resident in State T, owns shares in SCO, a company listed on the stock exchange of State S. State T has no tax treaty with State S and, therefore, any dividends paid by SCO to TCO are subject to withholding tax on dividends at a rate of 25% under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax convention between State R and State S, no withholding tax is levied on dividends paid by a company resident in a Contracting State. TCO enters into an arrangement with RCO, an independent financial institution resident in State R, under which TCO transfers to RCO the right to receive dividends that have been declared but not yet paid by SCO.
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it may be concluded that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement under which TCO transferred the right to receive dividends to RCO was to obtain the benefit of the exemption from withholding tax on dividends provided for under the tax convention between State R and State S, and that granting the benefit of that exemption under this arrangement would be contrary to the object and purpose of the tax convention.
Example B: SCO, a company resident in State S, is a subsidiary of TCO, a company resident in State T. State T has no tax treaties with State S and, therefore, any dividends paid by SCO to TCO are subject to withholding tax on dividends at a rate of 25 per cent under the domestic law of State S. However, under the tax convention between State R and State S, the applicable withholding tax rate on dividends paid by a company of State S to a resident of State R is 5 per cent. Accordingly, TCO enters into an arrangement with RCO, a financial institution resident in State R and a qualified person under subparagraph c) of paragraph 2 of this Article, under which RCO acquires the usufruct of newly issued preferred shares of SCO for a period of three years. TCO is the sole owner of these shares. The usufruct gives RCO the right to receive dividends on these preferred shares. The amount paid by RCO for the acquisition of the usufruct corresponds to the present value of the dividends payable on the preferred shares over a period of three years (taking into account a discount at the rate at which TCO can borrow from RCO).
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it may be concluded that one of the principal purposes of the arrangement under which RCO acquired the usufruct of the preferred shares issued by SCO was to obtain the benefit of the 5 per cent limitation applicable to withholding tax on dividends under the tax convention between State R and State S, and that obtaining the benefit of this limitation under this contractual trading arrangement would be contrary to the object and purpose of the tax convention.
Example C: RCO, a company resident in State R, is engaged in the manufacture of electronic devices, and its business is expanding rapidly. It is currently considering establishing a manufacturing facility in a developing country in order to benefit from lower production costs. Following a preliminary analysis, possible locations in three different countries are identified. All three countries have similar economic and political conditions. After taking into account the fact that State S is the only one of these countries with which State R has tax treaties, the decision is made to build the plant in that State.
In this example, although the decision to invest in State S is made in light of the benefits provided by the tax convention between State R and State S, it is clear that the principal purposes of the investment and the construction of the plant relate to the expansion of RCO's business and the reduction of production costs in that country. In this example, the construction of the plant cannot be considered to have obtaining treaty benefits as one of its principal purposes. Furthermore, given that the general purpose of tax conventions is to encourage cross-border investment, obtaining benefits under the convention between State R and State S for an investment in a plant constructed in State S is consistent with the object and purpose of the provisions of that convention.
- Example D: RCO, a collective investment fund resident in State R, manages a diversified portfolio of investments in the international financial market. RCO currently holds 15 per cent of its portfolio in shares of companies resident in State S, from which it receives annual dividends. Under the tax treaty between State R and State S, the withholding tax rate on dividends is reduced from 30 to 10 per cent. RCO's investment decisions take into account the availability of tax benefits provided under State R's extensive network of tax treaties. Most investors in RCO are residents of State R, but a number of investors (minority investors) are residents of States with which State S has no tax treaties. Investors' decisions to invest in RCO are not driven by any specific investments made by RCO, and RCO's investment strategy is not determined by the tax position of its investors. RCO distributes almost all of its income to its investors annually and pays tax in State R on income not distributed during the year. When deciding to invest in shares of companies resident in State S, RCO considered the availability of benefits under the tax convention between State R and State S in respect of dividends, but this alone is not sufficient for paragraph 9 to apply. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment and, therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to the investments, the context in which the investments were made must be taken into account. In this example, if RCO's investments are not part of an arrangement or connected with another transaction undertaken with the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefits of the tax treaty between State R and State S.
Example E: RCO is a company resident in State R and has held 24 per cent of the shares in SCO, a company resident in State S, for the past 5 years. Following the entry into force of the tax treaty between States R and S (Article 10 is identical to Article 10 of this Model), RCO decides to increase its shareholding in SCO to 25 per cent. The facts and circumstances show that the decision to acquire these additional shares was made primarily in order to obtain the benefit of the lower tax rate provided for in paragraph 2 a) of Article 10 of the treaty.
In this case, although one of the principal purposes of the transaction through which the additional shares are acquired is clearly to obtain the benefit of paragraph 2 a) of Article 10, paragraph 9 does not apply because it can be established that granting this benefit in the circumstances is consistent with the object and purpose of paragraph 2 a) of Article 10. That subparagraph uses an arbitrary threshold of 25 per cent for the purposes of determining which shareholders are entitled to the benefits of the lower dividend tax rate and, under this approach, benefits under that subparagraph are granted to a taxpayer who actually increases its shareholding in a company to satisfy this requirement.
- Example F: TCO is a publicly traded company resident in State T. TCO's information technology business, which originated in State T, has grown significantly over the past few years as a result of the aggressive mergers and acquisitions policy pursued by TCO's management. RCO, a company resident in State R (a State that has concluded numerous tax treaties providing for zero or low taxation of dividends and royalties), is the family holding company of a group that is also actively engaged in the information technology sector. Virtually all the shares in RCO are owned by residents of State R who are relatives of the entrepreneur who started and developed the business of the RCO group. RCO's principal assets are shares in subsidiaries located in neighbouring countries, including SCO, a company resident in State S, as well as patents developed in State R and licensed to those subsidiaries. TCO, which has long been interested in acquiring the business of the RCO group and its patent portfolio, makes an offer to acquire all the shares in RCO.
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it may be concluded that the principal purposes of acquiring RCO are related to the expansion of the TCO group's business and do not include obtaining benefits under the Convention between State R and State S. The fact that RCO operates primarily as a holding company does not change this result. It is possible that, following the acquisition of the shares of RCO, TCO's management will consider the benefits of the tax treaty concluded between State R and State S before deciding whether to retain in RCO the shares of SCO and the patents licensed by SCO. However, this would not be a purpose related to the relevant transaction, which is the acquisition of the shares of RCO.
- Example G: TCO, a company resident in State T, is a publicly listed company resident in State T. It directly or indirectly owns a number of subsidiaries in different countries. Most of these companies carry out the TCO group's activities in local markets. In one region, TCO owns shares in five such companies, each of which is located in a different neighbouring State. TCO is considering establishing a regional company for the purpose of providing group services to these companies, including management services such as accounting, legal advice and human resources management; financial and treasury services, such as foreign exchange risk management and the arrangement of hedging transactions; as well as certain other non-financing services. After considering possible locations, TCO decides to establish regional company RCO in State R. This decision is primarily driven by a skilled workforce, a reliable legal system, a business-friendly environment, political stability, membership in a regional grouping, a developed banking sector and State R's comprehensive network of double taxation agreements, including its tax treaties with the five States in which TCO owns subsidiaries, which provide for low withholding tax rates.
In this example, a simple analysis of the impact of the treaties on the future payments made by the subsidiaries to the regional company would not be sufficient to determine the purposes for which TCO established RCO. Assuming that the intra-group services provided by RCO, including the making of decisions necessary for conducting its business activities, constitute genuine commercial activities through which RCO performs its significant economic functions, using real assets and assuming real risks, and that these activities are carried out by RCO through its own personnel located in State R, it would be unreasonable to deny the benefits of the treaties concluded between State R and the five States in which the subsidiaries operate, unless other facts indicate that RCO was established for other tax purposes or unless RCO enters into specific transactions to which paragraph 9 would otherwise apply (see also Example F in paragraph 187 below concerning interest and other remuneration that RCO may receive from its group financing activities).
- Example H: TCO is a company resident in State T, listed on the stock exchange of State T. It is the parent company of a multinational enterprise carrying out various types of commercial activities throughout the world (wholesale trade, retail trade, manufacturing, investment, finance, etc.). Transportation issues, time differences, limited availability of personnel fluent in foreign languages and the foreign location of business partners make it difficult for TCO to manage its foreign operations from State T. Therefore, TCO establishes RCO, a subsidiary resident in State R (a country with developed international trade and financial markets and an abundance of highly qualified personnel), as a base for developing its foreign commercial activities. RCO carries out a variety of commercial activities, such as wholesale and retail trade, manufacturing, financing, as well as domestic and international investments. RCO has the human and financial resources (in various areas, such as legal, financial, accounting, tax, risk management, audit and internal control) necessary to carry out these activities. It is clear that RCO's activities constitute the active conduct of a business in State R. As part of its activities, RCO is also engaged in developing new manufacturing facilities in State S. For this purpose, it contributes equity capital to and provides loans to SCO, a subsidiary resident in State S established by RCO to own these facilities. RCO will receive dividends and interest from SCO.
In this example, RCO was established for reasons of business efficiency, and its financing of SCO through equity capital and loans forms part of RCO's active conduct of business in State R. On the basis of these facts, and in the absence of other facts indicating that one of the principal purposes of establishing RCO or financing SCO was to obtain benefits under the Convention between State R and State S, paragraph 9 will not apply to these transactions.
- Example I: RCO, a company resident in State R, is one of a number of collective management organisations that issue licences on behalf of neighbouring performers and rights holders for the public performance of music or its broadcasting by radio, television or the Internet. SCO, a company resident in State S, carries out similar activities in State S. Performers and rights holders from different countries appoint RCO or SCO as their agent for issuing licences and receiving royalties in respect of the copyright and related rights owned by them; RCO and SCO distribute to each rights holder the amount of royalties they receive on behalf of that rights holder, less a commission (in most cases, the amount distributed to each rights holder is relatively small). RCO has an agreement with SCO under which SCO grants licences to users in State S and distributes RCO's royalties in respect of the rights managed by RCO; RCO does the same in State R in respect of the rights managed by SCO. SCO has agreed with the tax administration of State S that it will process withholding tax on royalties on payments it makes to RCO on the basis of the applicable treaties between State S and the State of residence of each rights holder represented by RCO, using information provided by RCO, since those rights holders are the beneficial owners of the royalties paid by SCO to RCO.
In this example, it is clear that the arrangements between the rights holders and RCO and SCO, as well as between SCO and RCO, were established for the efficient administration of the granting of licences and the collection of royalties in respect of a large number of small transactions. Although one of the purposes of entering into these arrangements may be to ensure that withholding tax is collected at the correct treaty rate without requiring each individual rights holder to submit a claim for a refund of small payments, which would be burdensome and costly, it is clear that such a purpose, which contributes to the correct and efficient application of tax treaties, is consistent with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions of the applicable treaties.
- Example J: RCO is a company resident in State R. It has successfully tendered for the construction of a power plant for SCO, an independent company resident in State S. The construction project is expected to last 22 months. During the contract negotiations, the project is divided into two separate contracts, each lasting 11 months. The first contract is concluded with RCO, and the second with SUBCO, a newly incorporated subsidiary of RCO resident in State R. At the request of SCO, which wished to ensure that RCO would be contractually liable for the performance of both contracts, the contractual arrangements provide that RCO is jointly and severally liable with SUBCO for the performance of SUBCO's contractual obligations under the SUBCO-SCO contract.
In this example, in the absence of other facts and circumstances indicating otherwise, it may be concluded that one of the principal purposes of entering into a separate contract under which SUBCO agreed to perform part of the construction project was to obtain for RCO and SUBCO the benefit of the application of the rule contained in paragraph 3 of Article 5 of the tax Convention between State R and State S. Granting the benefit of this rule in these circumstances would be contrary to the object and purpose of that paragraph, since otherwise the time limit provided for in that paragraph would be meaningless.
- Example K: RCO, a company resident in State R, is a wholly owned subsidiary of a Fund, an institutional investor resident in State T, which was established and is regulated in State T. RCO operates exclusively to earn investment income as a regional investment platform for the Fund by acquiring and managing a diversified portfolio of private market investments located in countries of a regional grouping that includes State R. The decision to establish the regional investment platform in State R was driven by the availability of directors with knowledge of regional business practices and regulations, the availability of a qualified multilingual workforce, State R's membership in the regional grouping and State R's extensive network of tax treaties, including its tax treaty with State S, which provides for low rates of income tax. RCO employs an experienced local management team to review the Fund's investment recommendations and performs various other functions, which may, depending on the circumstances, include approving and monitoring investments, performing treasury functions, maintaining RCO's books and records and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements in the States in which it invests. The board of directors of RCO is appointed by the Fund and consists of a majority of directors resident in State R who have experience in investment management, as well as members of the Fund's global management team. RCO pays taxes and files tax returns in State R. RCO is currently considering investing in SCO, a company resident in State S. The investment in SCO will constitute only part of RCO's overall investment portfolio, which includes investments in a number of countries in addition to State S, which is also a member of the same regional grouping. Under the tax treaty between State R and State S, the withholding tax rate on dividends is reduced from 30 per cent to 5 per cent. Under the tax treaty between State S and State T, the withholding tax rate on dividends is 10 per cent. In deciding whether or not to invest in SCO, RCO takes into account the availability of the benefit under the tax Convention between State R and State S in respect of dividends, but this alone would not be sufficient to trigger the application of paragraph 9. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment and, therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to the investment, it is necessary to consider the context in which the investment was made, including the reasons for establishing RCO in State R, as well as the investment functions and other activities carried out in State R.
In this example, in the absence of other facts or circumstances showing that RCO's investment forms part of an arrangement or is connected with another transaction undertaken with the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefit of the tax Convention between State R and State S.
- Example L: RCO, a securitisation company resident in State R, was established by a bank, which sold RCO a portfolio of loans and other receivables from debtors located in a number of jurisdictions. RCO is entirely debt-financed. RCO issued one share, which is held in trust and has no economic value. RCO's debt financing was raised through the issuance of bonds that are widely held by third-party investors. The bonds are listed on a recognised stock exchange, allowing them to be traded on the secondary market, and are held through a clearing system. In accordance with regulatory requirements, the bank also retained a small portion of the publicly distributed debt securities issued by RCO. RCO currently holds 60 per cent of its portfolio of receivables from small and medium-sized enterprises resident in State S, in respect of which RCO regularly receives interest payments. The bank is resident in State T, which has a tax treaty with State S providing benefits equivalent to those available under the tax treaty between State R and State S. Under the tax treaty between State R and State S, the withholding tax rate on interest is limited to 10 per cent (the domestic law of State S provides for withholding tax at a rate of 30 per cent). When establishing RCO, the bank took into account a large number of considerations, including the sound securitisation framework of State R, its securitisation company and other relevant legislation, the availability of qualified and experienced personnel and support services in State R, as well as the availability of tax benefits provided under State R's extensive network of tax treaties.
R. Investors' decisions to invest in RCO are not determined by any specific investments made by RCO, and RCO's investment strategy is not determined by the tax position of its investors. RCO is taxed in State R on the income it receives and is entitled to a full deduction for the interest payments made to investors. In deciding to sell the receivables of enterprises resident in State S, the bank and RCO considered the availability of the benefit under the tax Convention between State R and State S in respect of interest, but this alone would not be sufficient to trigger the application of paragraph 9. The purpose of tax treaties is to provide benefits to encourage cross-border investment and, therefore, in determining whether paragraph 9 applies to the investment, it is necessary to consider the context in which the investment was made. In this example, in the absence of other facts or circumstances showing that RCO's investment forms part of an arrangement or is connected with another transaction undertaken with the principal purpose of obtaining a benefit under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny RCO the benefit of the tax Convention between State R and State S.
- Example M: A Real Estate Fund, a partnership of State C that is treated as tax transparent under the domestic tax law of State C, is established to invest in a portfolio of real estate investments in a specific geographical area. The Real Estate Fund is managed by a regulated fund manager and marketed to institutional investors, such as pension schemes and sovereign wealth funds, on the basis of the Fund's investment mandate. A number of investors resident in different jurisdictions invest in the Real Estate Fund. The investment strategy of the Real Estate Fund, as set out in the Fund's marketing materials, is not determined by the tax position of its investors, but is based on investing in specific real estate assets, maximising their value and realising capital appreciation through the disposal of investments. The investments of the Real Estate Fund are made through holding company RCO, established in State R. RCO manages all of the Fund's real estate assets and indirectly owns these assets through wholly owned companies resident in the States where the real estate assets are located; it also provides debt and/or equity financing to these local companies, which directly own the relevant investments. RCO is established for a number of commercial and legal reasons, such as protecting the Real Estate Fund from liabilities and potential claims in respect of the Fund's real estate assets, as well as facilitating debt financing (including from third-party lenders) and the establishment, management and disposal of investments. It is also established for the purpose of administering claims for exemption from withholding tax under any applicable tax treaty. This is an important function of RCO, since administratively it is easier for one company to obtain treaty benefits than for each institutional investor to process its own claim for benefits, particularly where the treaty benefit to which each investor is entitled in respect of a particular item of income is a small amount. After analysing possible locations, the Real Estate Fund decided to establish RCO in State R. This decision was primarily driven by State R's political stability, its regulatory and legal system, the knowledge of lenders and investors, access to qualified personnel and State R's extensive network of tax treaties, including its treaties with other States within the specific geographical area targeted for investment. RCO, however, does not obtain treaty benefits that are more favourable than those to which its investors would have been entitled if they had made the same investments directly in those States and obtained treaty benefits under the treaties concluded by the States of which they are residents.
In this example, although the decision to locate RCO in State R is made in light of the existence of benefits under the tax treaties between State R and the States within the specific geographical area targeted for investment, it is clear that RCO's investments in real estate are made for commercial purposes in accordance with the Fund's investment mandate. In addition, RCO does not obtain any treaty benefits that are more favourable than those to which its investors would have been entitled, and each State in which RCO's real estate investments are made may tax the income derived directly from those investments. In the absence of other facts or circumstances indicating that RCO's investments form part of an arrangement or are connected with another transaction undertaken with the principal purpose of obtaining benefits under the Convention, it would be unreasonable to deny the benefits of the tax treaties between State R and the States in which RCO's real estate investments are located.
183. In a number of States, the application of a general anti-abuse rule provided for under domestic law is subject to a particular form of approval. In some cases, the procedure provides for the internal escalation of disputes concerning such provisions to senior officials within the administration. In other cases, the procedure allows advisory panels to express their views to the administration on the application of the rule. These types of approval procedures reflect the serious nature of disputes in this area and contribute to overall consistency in the application of the rule. States may wish to establish a similar administrative procedure that would ensure that paragraph 9 is applied only after approval at a senior level of the administration.
184. In addition, some States consider that where a person is denied treaty benefits under paragraph 9, the competent authority of the Contracting State that would otherwise have granted those benefits should treat that person as being entitled to those benefits or to different benefits in respect of the relevant item of income or capital, if such benefits would have been granted to that person in the absence of the transaction or arrangement that resulted in the application of paragraph 9. To allow for this possibility, such States may include the following additional paragraph in their bilateral treaties:
10. Where a benefit under this Convention has been denied to a person pursuant to paragraph 9, the competent authority of the Contracting State that would otherwise have granted that benefit shall nevertheless treat that person as being entitled to that benefit or to other benefits in respect of a specific item of income or capital, if such competent authority, upon request by that person and after consideration of the relevant facts and circumstances, determines that such benefits would have been granted to that person in the absence of the transaction or arrangement referred to in paragraph 9. The competent authority of the Contracting State to which the request has been made shall consult with the competent authority of the other State before rejecting a request made under this paragraph by a resident of that other State.
185. For the purposes of this alternative provision, the determination of whether benefits would have been granted in the absence of the transaction or arrangement referred to in paragraph 9, and the determination of the benefits to be granted, are left to the discretion of the competent authority to which the request is made. The alternative provision gives the competent authority broad discretionary powers in making these determinations. However, this provision requires the competent authority to consider the relevant facts and circumstances and to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State before rejecting a request for benefits where that request has been made by a person resident in that other State. The first requirement is intended to ensure that the competent authority carefully considers each request, while the requirement to consult with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, where the request is made by a person resident in that other State, should ensure that the Contracting States consider similar cases consistently and may base their decisions on the facts and circumstances of the particular case. However, the consultation process does not require the competent authority to which the request has been made to obtain the agreement of the competent authority with which it consults.
186. The following example illustrates the application of this alternative provision. Assume that an individual who is a resident of State R and owns shares in a company resident in State S transfers the right to receive dividends declared by that company to another company resident in State R, which owns more than 10 per cent of the capital of the paying company, with the principal purpose of obtaining the reduced withholding tax rate provided for in subparagraph a) of paragraph 2 of Article 10. In such a case, if it is determined that the benefit should be denied under paragraph 9, the alternative provision would allow the competent authority of State S to grant the benefit of the reduced rate provided for in subparagraph b) of paragraph 2 of Article 10, if that competent authority determines that such benefit would have been granted in the absence of the transfer to the other company of the right to receive dividends.
187. For various reasons, some States may be unable to adopt the rule included in paragraph 9. However, in order to effectively address all forms of treaty abuse, these States need to supplement the limitation-on-benefits rule contained in paragraphs 1–7 with rules that will address transaction strategies commonly referred to as "conduit arrangements", which would not be covered by those paragraphs. These rules would address such conduit arrangements without taking into account the benefits of the provisions of the Convention or some of them (for example, Articles 7, 10, 11, 12 and 21) in respect of any income derived pursuant to or as part of the conduit arrangements. They may also take the form of domestic anti-abuse rules or judicial doctrines that would achieve a similar result. The following are examples of conduit arrangements that should be addressed by such rules, as well as examples of transactions that should not be treated as conduit arrangements for this purpose:
- Example A: RCO, a publicly listed company resident in State R, owns all the shares of SCO, a company resident in State S. TCO, a company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S, wishes to acquire a minority shareholding in SCO but considers that the domestic dividend tax imposed by State S would make the investment unprofitable. RCO instead offers to issue preference shares to RCO with a fixed return of 4 per cent plus a contingent return of 20 per cent of SCO's net profits. The preference shares are redeemable after 20 years. TCO enters into a separate agreement with RCO under which it will pay RCO an amount equal to the issue price of the preference shares and will receive from RCO, after 20 years, the redemption price of the shares. During the 20-year period, RCO pays TCO an amount equal to 3.75 per cent of the issue price plus 20 per cent of SCO's net profits. This arrangement constitutes a conduit arrangement that is addressed by the rules referred to above, since one of the principal purposes of RCO's participation in the transaction was to reduce the withholding tax for TCO.
- Example B: SCO, a company resident in State S, has issued only one class of shares, 100 per cent of which are owned by RCO, a company resident in State R. RCO also has only one class of shares outstanding, all of which are owned by TCO, a company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S. RCO is engaged in the manufacture of electronic products, and SCO acts as RCO's exclusive distributor in State S. Under paragraph 3 of the limitation-on-benefits rule, RCO is entitled to benefits in respect of dividends received from SCO, even though RCO's shares are owned by a resident of a third State.
This example relates to a trading structure and arrangement in which RCO and SCO carry out genuine economic activities in States R and S. The payment of dividends by subsidiaries such as SCO is a normal commercial transaction. In the absence of evidence demonstrating that one of the principal purposes of establishing this structure was to channel dividends from SCO to TCO, this structure would not constitute a conduit arrangement.
- Example C: TCO, a company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S, lends 1,000,000 to SCO, a company resident in State S that is a wholly owned subsidiary of TCO, in exchange for a promissory note issued by SCO. TCO subsequently realises that it can avoid the withholding tax on interest imposed by State S by transferring the promissory note to its wholly owned subsidiary RCO, resident in State R (the agreement between States R and S does not permit the taxation of interest at source in certain circumstances). TCO therefore transfers the promissory note to RCO in exchange for a promissory note issued by RCO to TCO. The interest rate on the note issued by SCO is 7 per cent, while the interest rate on the note issued by RCO is 6 per cent. The transaction through which RCO acquired the promissory note issued by SCO constitutes a conduit arrangement, since it was structured in such a way as to reduce the withholding tax that TCO would otherwise have paid to State S.
- Example D: TCO, a company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S, owns all the shares of SCO, a company resident in State S. TCO has long conducted all its banking operations with RCO, a bank resident in State R that is not related to TCO or SCO, because the banking system in State T is relatively unsophisticated. As a result, TCO holds a large deposit with RCO. When SCO requires a loan to finance an acquisition, TCO proposes that SCO enter into a transaction with RCO, which is already familiar with the activities carried out by TCO and SCO. SCO discusses the loan with several different banks, all on terms similar to those offered by RCO, but ultimately takes out the loan with RCO, partly because the interest paid to RCO would not be subject to withholding tax in State S under the agreement between States S and R, whereas interest paid to banks resident in State T would be subject to tax in State S.
The fact that the benefits of the treaty between States R and S become available if SCO borrows from RCO, and that similar benefits may not be available if it borrows elsewhere, is a significant factor in SCO's decision (which may be influenced by recommendations made to it by its 100 per cent shareholder, TCO). This may be a decisive factor in the sense that, all other things being equal, the availability of treaty benefits may change the decision in favour of RCO rather than another bank. However, the question of whether obtaining treaty benefits is one of the principal purposes of the transaction must be determined by reference to the specific facts and circumstances. On the facts presented above, RCO is not related to TCO or SCO, and there is no indication that the interest paid by SCO is in any way passed on to TCO. The fact that TCO held large deposits with RCO is also a factor indicating that the loan to SCO is not matched by a specific deposit from TCO. Thus, in light of the specific facts presented, the transaction is unlikely to constitute a conduit arrangement. If, however, RCO's decision to lend to SCO depended on TCO providing a corresponding security deposit to secure the loan, such that RCO would not have entered into the transaction on substantially the same terms in the absence of that deposit, the facts would indicate that TCO was indirectly lending to SCO by routing the loan through a bank in State R, in which case the transaction would constitute a conduit arrangement.
- Example E: RCO, a publicly listed company resident in State R, is a holding company of a manufacturing group operating in a highly competitive technology sector. The manufacturing group conducts research through subsidiaries located throughout the world. Any patents developed by a subsidiary are licensed by that subsidiary to RCO, which then sublicenses the technology to its subsidiaries that need it. RCO retains only a small amount of income in respect of the royalties received, so that most of the profits accrue to the subsidiary that assumed the risk in relation to the development of the technology. TCO, a company located in a State with which State S does not have a tax treaty, has developed a process that will substantially increase the profitability of all RCO's subsidiaries, including SCO, a company resident in State S. In accordance with its usual practice, RCO licenses the technology from TCO and sublicenses the technology to its subsidiaries. SCO pays royalties to RCO, almost the entire amount of which is paid to TCO.
In this example, there is no indication that RCO established its licensing business in order to reduce the withholding tax payable in State S. Since RCO follows the group's standard commercial organisation and behaviour in the way it structures its licensing and sublicensing activities, and it is assumed that the same structure is used in respect of other subsidiaries carrying out similar activities in countries that have treaties offering similar or more favourable benefits, the arrangement between SCO, RCO and TCO does not constitute a conduit arrangement.
- Example F: TCO is a publicly traded company resident in State T, which does not have a tax treaty with State S. TCO is the parent company of a worldwide group of companies that includes RCO, a company resident in State R, and SCO, a company resident in State S. SCO carries out active commercial activities in State S. RCO is responsible for coordinating the financing of all TCO subsidiaries. RCO maintains a centralised cash management system for TCO and its subsidiaries, in which it records all intercompany payables and receivables. RCO is responsible for making or receiving any cash payments required for transactions between its affiliates and unrelated parties. RCO enters into interest rate and foreign exchange contracts as necessary to manage risks arising from mismatches between incoming and outgoing cash flows. RCO's activities are intended (as is evident) to reduce operating costs, overheads and other fixed costs. RCO employs 50 staff members, including administrative and other back-office personnel, located in State R; this number of employees reflects the scale of RCO's commercial activities. TCO lends 15 million in Currency A (equivalent to 10 million in Currency B) to RCO in exchange for a 10-year note bearing interest at 5 per cent per annum. On the same day, RCO lends 10 million in Currency B to SCO in exchange for a 10-year note bearing interest at 5 per cent per annum. RCO does not enter into long-term hedging transactions in respect of these financial transactions but manages the interest rate and foreign exchange risk arising from the transactions on a daily, weekly or quarterly basis by entering into foreign exchange forward contracts.
In this example, RCO carries out genuine commercial activities, performing significant economic functions, using real assets and assuming real risks; it also carries out significant activities in relation to transactions with TCO and SCO, which are typical of RCO's activities. RCO also bears interest rate and foreign exchange risks. On the basis of these facts, and in the absence of other facts indicating that one of the principal purposes of these loans was to avoid tax in State S, the loan from TCO to RCO and the loan from RCO to SCO do not constitute a conduit arrangement.
Commentary on the Article
188. The United States does not agree with the statement contained in paragraph 77 that, when applying the substantiality requirement of subparagraph b) of paragraph 3, the relative sizes of the economies and markets of the two States should be taken into account.
Reservations on the Article
189. Belgium, Hungary, Luxembourg and Switzerland reserve the right not to include paragraph 8 in their treaties.
190. Portugal reserves the right not to include subparagraph c) of paragraph 8 in its treaties.
191. The United States reserves the right to expand the scope of paragraph 8 to include income attributable to a permanent establishment in the State of source and permanent establishments in States that do not have a tax treaty with the State of source, regardless of the tax rate, unless the State of residence includes that income in its tax base.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 30
EXTENSION OF THE TERRITORIAL SCOPE OF APPLICATION OF THE CONVENTION
- Some conventions for the avoidance of double taxation specify the territories to which they apply. Some of them also provide that their provisions may be extended to other territories and determine when and how this may be done. A provision of this kind is of particular value to States that have overseas territories or are responsible for the international relations of other States or territories, in particular because it recognizes that such an extension may be effected by an exchange of diplomatic notes. It is also relevant where the provisions of the Convention are extended to that part of the territory of a Contracting State which, by virtue of a special provision, has been excluded from the scope of application of the Convention. The Article providing that an extension may be effected by any other means in accordance with the constitutional procedures of the States is drafted in a form that is constitutionally acceptable to all OECD member countries affected by this provision. The only preliminary condition for extending the provisions of the Convention to any State or territory is that it imposes taxes similar to those to which the Convention applies.
- The Article provides that the application of the Convention may be extended either in its entirety or with any necessary modifications, that such extension shall take effect from such date and subject to such conditions as may be agreed upon between the Contracting States, and that the termination of the Convention shall automatically terminate its application in respect of any States or territories to which it has been extended, unless the Contracting States have agreed otherwise.
Reservation on this Article
- The United States reserves the right not to follow Article 30.
COMMENTARY ON ARTICLES 31 AND 32
CONCERNING THE ENTRY INTO FORCE AND TERMINATION OF THE CONVENTION
- These provisions concerning the procedure for entry into force, ratification and termination have been drafted for bilateral conventions and are consistent with the rules normally contained in international treaties.
- Some Contracting States may require an additional provision in the first paragraph of Article 31 specifying the authorities whose consent is required for ratification. Other Contracting States may agree that the Article should specify that entry into force shall take place following an exchange of notes confirming that each State has completed the procedures necessary for the Convention to enter into force.
- The Contracting States may agree that the Convention shall enter into force after the expiry of a specified period following the exchange of instruments of ratification or following confirmation that each State has completed the procedures necessary for entry into force.
- No provisions have been drafted concerning the date on which the Convention shall enter into force or cease to have effect, since such provisions depend on the domestic legislation of the Contracting States concerned. Some States tax income derived in the current year, others tax income derived during the preceding year, while in other States the fiscal year differs from the calendar year. Furthermore, some conventions provide, in respect of taxes levied by withholding at source, for a commencement or termination date that differs from the date applicable to taxes levied by assessment.
- Since it is advantageous for the Convention to remain in force for at least a certain period, the Article on termination provides that notice of termination may be given only after a certain year, which is to be determined by bilateral agreement. The Contracting States may decide on the earliest year in which such notice may be given, or even agree not to specify such a year, if they so wish.
OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION (ABRIDGED VERSION) © OECD 2017
POSITIONS OF NON-OECD COUNTRIES ON THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION (ON TAXATION) (FOR THE AVOIDANCE OF DOUBLE TAXATION)
INTRODUCTION
- When, in 1991, the Committee on Fiscal Affairs adopted the concept of a provisional Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital, it was decided that, since the influence of the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital extended far beyond OECD member countries, the ongoing process of updating the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital would be open to contributions from non-OECD countries.
- In accordance with this decision, in 1996 the Committee on Fiscal Affairs decided to hold annual meetings, which enabled experts from member countries and certain non-OECD countries to discuss issues relating to the negotiation, application and interpretation of tax conventions. Recognizing that non-OECD countries could participate in the development of the Model Convention only if they retained the right to disagree with its content, the Committee also decided that these countries, like member countries, would have the opportunity to identify areas in which they disagreed with the text of an Article or with the explanation provided in the Commentary.
- This led to the inclusion in the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital of this section, which sets out the positions of a number of non-OECD countries on the Articles of the Model Convention and the Commentaries thereon. It is envisaged that this document will be updated periodically, like the remainder of the Model Convention, in order to reflect changes in the views of the participating countries.
- This section sets out the positions of the following non-OECD countries on the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital.
Download
| Albania | Argentina | Armenia |
|---|---|---|
| Azerbaijan | Belarus | Brazil |
| Bulgaria | Colombia | Costa Rica |
| Croatia | Democratic Republic of the Congo | Gabon |
| Georgia | Hong Kong, China | India |
| Indonesia | Côte d'Ivoire | Kazakhstan |
| Lithuania | Malaysia | Morocco |
| People's Republic of China | Philippines | Romania |
| Russia | Serbia | Singapore |
| South Africa | Thailand | Tunisia |
| Ukraine | United Arab Emirates | Vietnam |
- Although these countries generally agree with the text of the Articles of the Model Tax Convention and the interpretations presented in the Commentaries, there are certain areas of disagreement for each of them. For each Article of the Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation on Income and on Capital presented in this section, it is indicated where a country disagrees with the text of the Article and where it disagrees with the explanation given in the Commentary concerning the Article. In the case of observations and reservations by member countries, no reference is made to instances where a country wishes to supplement the text of an Article with provisions that do not conflict with that Article, particularly where such provisions are proposed as alternatives in the Commentary, or where an explanation is proposed that does not conflict with the Commentary.
62 Indonesia and the People's Republic of China wish to clarify expressly that, in negotiations with other countries, they will not be bound by their stated positions included in this section.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 1 (PERSONS COVERED) AND THE COMMENTARY
- The Philippines reserves the right to tax its citizens in accordance with its domestic legislation.
- Costa Rica, Serbia and Singapore reserve their position on paragraph 2.
- India reserves the right not to include paragraph 2 of Article 1 in its tax treaties.
- Costa Rica, Serbia and Singapore reserve their position on paragraph 3.
Position on the Commentary
- India disagrees with the view expressed in paragraph 7 of the Commentary on Article 1 that the term "income derived by or through an entity or arrangement" includes income derived by or through an entity or arrangement that may not be a resident of either Contracting State. India considers that this term includes only such income as is derived by or through entities or arrangements that are residents of one or both Contracting States.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 2 (TAXES COVERED) AND THE COMMENTARY
Paragraph 1
- Wherever the terms "capital" and "movable property" appear in the Convention, Belarus reserves the right to replace these terms, which do not exist in its domestic legislation, with the terms "property" and "property other than immovable property", respectively.
- Brazil reserves its position with respect to that part of paragraph 1 which states that the Convention applies to taxes imposed on behalf of political subdivisions or local authorities, as well as with respect to the final part of the paragraph, which reads "irrespective of the manner in which they are levied".
2.1 Argentina, Colombia and Costa Rica reserve the right not to include in paragraph 1 taxes imposed on behalf of political subdivisions or local authorities.
- Since they do not have a capital tax, Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore reserve the right not to include any references to such a tax in paragraph 1.
- Romania reserves the right to include taxes imposed on behalf of political subdivisions.
- South Africa reserves its position with respect to that part of paragraph 1 which states that the Convention applies to taxes imposed by local authorities.
5.1 Georgia reserves the right to include taxes imposed on behalf of political subdivisions and local self-government authorities.
5.2 Colombia reserves the right to limit the application of the Convention to taxes on capital to the extent that, during the relevant fiscal year, both Contracting States levy taxes on the same capital or on the same elements of capital.
Paragraph 2
- Brazil wishes to use in its treaties a definition of income tax in accordance with its constitutional legislation. Accordingly, it reserves the right not to include paragraph 2 in its treaties.
- Armenia, Lithuania, Romania and Tunisia take the view that "taxes on the total amounts of wages or salaries paid by enterprises" should not be regarded as taxes on income and therefore reserve the right not to include these words in paragraph 2.
- Costa Rica and Ukraine reserve their position with respect to that part of paragraph 2 which states that the Convention applies to taxes on capital gains.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 3 (GENERAL DEFINITIONS) AND THE COMMENTARY
- With regard to the definition of "company", Albania and Belarus reserve the right to replace the concept of "company", which does not exist in their domestic legislation, with "any legal person or any entity which is treated as a separate entity for tax purposes".
- [Deleted]
- With regard to the definition of the term "national", Albania, Romania and Russia reserve the right to replace the term "nationality" with "citizenship", since the term "nationality" does not mean "citizenship" under their legislation.
- Bulgaria reserves the right to propose, during bilateral negotiations, the insertion of the word "also" between the words "business" and "includes" in subparagraph h) of paragraph 1 of the Article.
4.1 Argentina, Azerbaijan, Brazil, Costa Rica, Lithuania and Singapore reserve the right not to include the definitions of "enterprise" and "business" in paragraph 1 of Article 3, since they reserve the right to include an Article dealing with the taxation of independent personal services.
- With regard to the definition of "international traffic", Bulgaria and Croatia reserve the right to extend the scope of the definition to include road and rail transport in bilateral conventions.
- Serbia reserves the right to extend the scope of the definition of "international traffic" to road transport in bilateral conventions.
- Thailand reserves the right to include in the definition of "person" any legal person which is treated as a taxable unit under the tax legislation in force in either Contracting State.
- India and South Africa reserve the right to include in the definition of "person" only those legal persons which are treated as a taxable unit under the tax legislation in force in the respective Contracting States.
- India reserves the right to include definitions of "tax year" and "fiscal year".
- With regard to the definition of the term "national", Costa Rica reserves the right to replace the concepts of partnerships and associations with the concept of a "group of persons".
- Hong Kong, China reserves its position with regard to the definition of the term "national" in subparagraph g) of paragraph 1, since Hong Kong, China, is not a sovereign State. Where the term "national" appears in Articles 4, 19, 24 and 25, Hong Kong, China, reserves the right to use alternative provisions based on the concepts of "right of abode" and "registered or incorporated".
- India reserves the right not to include subdivision (ii) of the definition of "recognized pension fund".
- Colombia reserves the right to extend the scope of the definition of "recognized pension fund" to cover pension funds.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 4 (RESIDENT) AND THE COMMENTARY
Paragraph 1
- Albania, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Bulgaria, Colombia, Costa Rica, Indonesia, Lithuania, Russia, Thailand, Ukraine and Vietnam reserve the right to include the place of registration or a similar criterion (registration in the case of Belarus and Vietnam) in paragraph 1.
- The United Arab Emirates reserve the right to adopt their own definition of residence in their bilateral conventions and are not obliged to follow Article 4.
2.1 Hong Kong, China reserves the right to modify the definition of "resident" in its bilateral agreements, since it is not a sovereign State and levies taxes on a territorial basis.
- Indonesia reserves the right to justify the inclusion of a pension fund in the definition of "resident", provided that the pension fund is subject to taxation in the State of residence.
3.1 Malaysia and Singapore reserve the right not to include the second sentence of paragraph 1 in their treaties.
- Russia and India reserve the right to amend the Article in their tax treaties to provide that their partnerships should be treated as residents of their countries, taking into account their legal and tax characteristics.
4.1 Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco and Tunisia disagree with the general principle that, where the tax payable by a partnership is determined on the basis of the personal characteristics of the partners, those partners are entitled to the benefits of tax treaties concluded by the States of which they are residents in respect of income "flowing through" that partnership. Under their domestic legislation, a partnership is considered to be liable to tax, even if, technically, such tax is levied on the partners or, in the case of Morocco, on the principal partner; for this reason, Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco and Tunisia reserve the right to amend this Article in their tax conventions to provide that their partnerships should be residents of their countries, taking into account their legal and tax characteristics.
Paragraph 2
4.2 Singapore reserves the right to replace subparagraph d) with the following text: "d) in any other case, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall settle the question by mutual agreement".
4.3 Kazakhstan reserves the right to replace subparagraph d) with: "d) where the status of an individual cannot be determined by reason of subparagraphs a) to c) of this paragraph, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall settle the question by mutual agreement".
Paragraph 3
- Armenia, Bulgaria, Russia, Thailand and Vietnam reserve the right to use the place of registration (registration in the case of Vietnam) as a criterion for paragraph 3.
- Azerbaijan reserves the right to use the term "registration (place of registration)" or the term "place of location of the permanently functioning executive body" as a criterion for determining the residence of a person in paragraph 3.
- For the purpose of determining the residence of a person, other than an individual, having dual nationality, Singapore reserves the right to include a provision referring to the place of location of the permanently functioning executive body and, where this cannot be determined, requiring that the matter be settled by mutual agreement.
- Costa Rica reserves the right to deny treaty benefits to persons, other than individuals, having dual nationality.
8.1 Costa Rica reserves the right to add "domicile" and "place of registration of the person or firm" to the factors listed in paragraph 3.
Positions on the Commentary
Paragraph 2
- In the view of Vietnam, the personal and economic relations referred to in paragraphs 14 and 15 of the Commentary should be separated and priority should be given to one over the other. For Vietnam, economic relations, particularly the criterion of the country in which employment activities are carried out, are more important in determining the State of residence for treaty purposes in the case of an individual with dual nationality.
9.1 In the case of Gabon, since the expression "and economic relations", used in paragraphs 13, 14 and 15 of the Commentary, is ambiguous, these two types of relations should be distinguished and priority should be given to one over the other. Consequently, the State in which employment activities are carried out should take precedence over personal relations for the purpose of determining the State of residence of an individual.
Positions on the Article
- [Deleted]
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 5 (PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT) AND THE COMMENTARY
Preserve the source formatting exactlyTranslate the remaining source text
Paragraph 2
- In addition to the extraction of natural resources, Argentina, Brazil, Gabon, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco, the Philippines, Russia, Thailand, Tunisia and the United Arab Emirates reserve the right to refer to the “exploration” of such resources in paragraph 2.
2.1 Indonesia reserves the right to add to paragraph 2 an area for the exploration and exploitation of natural resources, as well as a drilling rig or working vessel used for the extraction and exploitation of natural resources.
2.2 Colombia and Costa Rica reserve the right to replace the word “extraction” with the words
“connected with the extraction or exploitation” in subparagraph 2 f).
- India and Indonesia reserve the right to add additional subparagraphs to paragraph 2 covering a sales outlet and a farm, plantation or other place where agricultural, forestry, plantation or related activities are carried on.
- Vietnam, India, Indonesia and Thailand reserve the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 covering a warehouse in the case of a person providing warehousing facilities to other persons.
- Armenia and Ukraine reserve the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 covering an installation or structure for the exploration of natural resources and a warehouse or other structure used for the sale of goods.
- Gabon and Vietnam reserve the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 covering facilities or equipment used for the exploration of natural resources.
6.1 Argentina, Gabon and Côte d’Ivoire reserve the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 covering places where fishing activities are carried on.
6.2 Kazakhstan reserves the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 covering a quarry, installation and structure for the exploration of natural resources.
6.3 Azerbaijan reserves the right to add an additional subparagraph to paragraph 2 concerning an installation, structure or vessel used for the exploration of natural resources.
Paragraph 3
- [Deleted]
- Argentina, Armenia, Brazil, Colombia, Georgia, Thailand and Vietnam maintain their position on paragraph 3 because they consider that any building site or construction, assembly or installation project that lasts for more than six months should be regarded as a permanent establishment.
- Albania, Costa Rica, the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Hong Kong, China maintain their position on paragraph 3 and consider that any building site or construction, assembly or installation project, or supervisory or consultancy activities connected therewith, constitutes a permanent establishment if such site, project or activity lasts for more than six months.
9.1 Serbia reserves the right to consider any building site, construction, assembly or installation project, or supervisory or consultancy activities connected therewith, to constitute a permanent establishment if such site, project or activity lasts for more than twelve months.
- Bulgaria, Gabon, Côte d’Ivoire, Malaysia, Morocco, the People’s Republic of China, South Africa and Tunisia reserve the right to agree on the period of time after the expiry of which any building site or construction, assembly or installation project is regarded as a permanent establishment under paragraph 3.
- Vietnam, Argentina, Malaysia, the People’s Republic of China, Singapore, South Africa and Thailand reserve the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if the enterprise carries on supervisory activities in connection with a building site or construction, assembly or installation project that constitutes a permanent establishment under paragraph
3 (in the case of Malaysia, the period for this permanent establishment is to be agreed separately).
11.1 India and Indonesia reserve the right to replace “construction or installation project” with “construction, assembly or installation project, or supervisory activities connected therewith” and reserve the right to agree on the period of time during which they must continue in order to constitute a permanent establishment.
- Argentina reserves the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if it provides services, including consultancy services, through its employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for that purpose, but only if activities of that nature continue in the country for a period exceeding six months in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the fiscal year concerned.
- Gabon, India, Indonesia, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco and Tunisia reserve the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if it provides services, including consultancy services, through its employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for that purpose, but only if activities of that nature continue within the same project or a connected project for a period or periods the aggregate of which exceeds the period to be agreed upon.
13.1 Singapore reserves the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if the enterprise provides services through its employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for that purpose, but only if the employees or other personnel are present in the State for the same project or a connected project for a period or periods the aggregate of which exceeds the period to be agreed upon.
- Albania, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Lithuania, Serbia, South Africa, Thailand, Vietnam and Hong Kong, China reserve the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if it provides services, including consultancy services, through its employees or other personnel engaged by the enterprise for that purpose, but only if activities of that nature continue (for the same or a connected project [except in the case of Armenia]) within the country for a period or periods the aggregate of which exceeds six months within any twelve-month period.
14.1 The Democratic Republic of the Congo, Gabon, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco, South Africa and Tunisia reserve the right to consider any person performing professional services or other activities of an independent character as having a permanent establishment if that person is present in the State for a period or periods exceeding in the aggregate 183 days in any twelve-month period.
14.2 Lithuania reserves the right to include specific provisions concerning permanent establishments relating to activities carried on in a Contracting State in connection with the exploration or exploitation of natural resources.
14.3 Argentina reserves the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if the enterprise carries on activities in that State connected with the development or extraction of natural resources, including fishing activities, without a fixed place of business for a period exceeding three months in any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the fiscal year concerned.
14.4 Indonesia reserves the right to include a provision under which a permanent establishment exists if, for more than an agreed period, an installation, drilling rig or vessel is used for the exploration of natural resources.
14.5 Indonesia, the United Arab Emirates and Vietnam reserve the right to tax income derived from activities connected with the exploration and extraction of natural resources.
14.6 South Africa reserves the right to include a provision under which a permanent establishment is deemed to exist if, for more than six months, an enterprise carries on activities connected with the exploration or extraction of natural resources.
14.7 India reserves the right to include in Article 5 a provision stating that an enterprise having a significant economic presence in a Contracting State, based on the criteria defined in Chapter VII of the Final Report on Action 1 of the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, is deemed to have a permanent establishment in that State.
14.8 Colombia reserves the right to consider an enterprise as having a permanent establishment whenever it carries on activities in the other Contracting State in connection with the exploration or extraction of natural resources, as well as in certain circumstances where services are provided.
Paragraph 4
- Azerbaijan, Albania, Armenia, Gabon, India, Indonesia, Côte d’Ivoire, Malaysia, Morocco, Russia, Thailand, Tunisia, Ukraine and Vietnam maintain their position on paragraph 4 because they consider that the term “delivery” should be deleted from subparagraphs a) and b).
- Albania and Thailand maintain their position on subparagraph 4 f).
16.1 [Deleted]
16.2 The Democratic Republic of the Congo maintains its position on subparagraphs 4 d), e) and f).
Paragraph 5
- Albania, Argentina, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Gabon, India, Indonesia, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco, Russia, Thailand, Tunisia, Ukraine and Vietnam reserve the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if a person acting on behalf of the enterprise habitually maintains a stock of goods or merchandise in the Contracting State from which that person regularly delivers goods on behalf of the enterprise.
17.1 India, Malaysia and Thailand reserve the right to treat an enterprise of one Contracting State as having a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State if a person habitually secures orders in the other Contracting State wholly or almost wholly for the enterprise.
17.2 Indonesia reserves the right to treat an enterprise as having a permanent establishment if a person acting on behalf of the enterprise, who is not an independent agent, manufactures or processes for the enterprise goods belonging to the enterprise.
17.3 Singapore reserves the right to use the version of paragraph 5 included in the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital immediately before the 2017 update of the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital.
17.4 India reserves the right not to include the words “in the ordinary course” in paragraph 5 of Article 5.
Paragraph 6
- Azerbaijan, Albania, Gabon, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco, Serbia, Thailand, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to clarify that an agent whose activities are carried on wholly or almost wholly on behalf of one enterprise is not considered to be an independent agent.
- Colombia, Gabon, India, Indonesia, Côte d’Ivoire, Morocco, Russia, Thailand, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to provide that an insurance enterprise of a Contracting State is deemed, except in cases of reinsurance (except in the case of India), to have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State if it collects premiums in the territory of that other State or insures risks situated there through a person who is not an independent agent to whom paragraph 6 applies.
19.1 India reserves the right not to include the words “with which it is closely related” in paragraph 6 of Article 5.
19.2 Singapore reserves the right to use the version of paragraph 6 included in the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital immediately before the 2017 update of the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital.
Positions on the Commentary
- Argentina, India, Morocco and Vietnam disagree with the expression “the twelve-month test applies to each separate site or project” contained in paragraph 51 of the Commentary. They consider that a series of consecutive short-term sites or projects operated by a contractor will result in the creation of a permanent establishment in the country concerned.
- Bulgaria, Serbia and Singapore will add their views to paragraph 97 of the Commentary on Article 5, stating that a person authorised to negotiate the principal elements and details of a contract, and not necessarily all the elements and details of the contract, on behalf of a foreign resident may be considered to conclude contracts.
- Bulgaria does not adhere to the interpretation given in paragraph 50 of the Commentary on Article 5 and considers that supervision of a building site or construction project, if carried out by another person, is not covered by paragraph 3 of this Article unless expressly provided for.
- Brazil disagrees with the interpretation presented in paragraphs 122–131 concerning electronic commerce, particularly in view of the principle of taxation at source of payments under its legislation.
- India considers it necessary to take into account that, regardless of the meaning attributed to the third sentence of paragraph 2 — insofar as the method of calculating taxes is concerned — the new wording of the Model, i.e. the deletion of Article 14, does not affect domestic systems.
- Azerbaijan, India and Malaysia disagree with the interpretation given in paragraphs 24 (first part of the paragraph) and 25 (first part of the paragraph); they consider that these examples may also be regarded as permanent establishments.
25.1 Argentina disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 24.
25.2 Singapore disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 25 (first part of the paragraph) and considers that the example given may constitute a permanent establishment.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 36; it considers that tangible or intangible property in itself may constitute a permanent establishment of the lessor in certain circumstances.
26.1 Argentina disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 36; it considers that the leasing of tangible or intangible property in itself may constitute a permanent establishment of the lessor in certain circumstances, particularly where the lessor provides personnel after installation to operate the equipment.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 41; it considers that, in certain circumstances, commercial or scientific equipment may constitute a permanent establishment of the lessor.
- India does not adhere to the explanation given in paragraphs 45 and 146 concerning the list of examples in paragraph 2 of the Article; it considers that these examples may be regarded as permanent establishments a priori.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 71; it does not include scientific research in the list of examples of activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
- India disagrees with the opinion expressed in paragraph 111 of the Commentary on Article 5 that, in certain cases, a person acting exclusively on behalf of an enterprise may be considered an independent agent. India considers that such a person cannot be considered an independent agent.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 97; it considers that the fact of a person's presence or absence at negotiations in the State between the enterprise and the client may, in certain circumstances, be sufficient to conclude that the person exercised in that State authority to conclude contracts on behalf of the enterprise. India also considers that a person authorised to negotiate the principal elements and details of a contract, and not necessarily all the elements and details of the contract, on behalf of a foreign resident, may be regarded as exercising authority to conclude contracts.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 118; it considers that if a company (enterprise) that is a resident of one State is a member of a multinational group and is engaged in the manufacture or provision of services for and on behalf of another company (enterprise) of the same group that is a resident of another State, the first company may constitute a permanent establishment of the latter, provided that the other requirements of Article 5 are met.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 123; it considers that a website may constitute a permanent establishment, resulting in a significant economic presence of the enterprise.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 124; it considers that, depending on the facts, an enterprise may be considered to have acquired a place of business through a website on any equipment if opening the website on that equipment involves downloading automated software, such as cookies, which use that equipment to collect data from that equipment, process it in any way or transmit it to the enterprise.
34.1 Argentina disagrees with the statement made in paragraph 134 that taxation by a State of profits from services performed in its territory does not necessarily constitute optimal tax treaty policy.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraphs 135 and 136, according to which a service permanent establishment will be created only if services are provided in the State of source. It considers that the provision of services is sufficient to create a service permanent establishment.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraphs 139 and 167; it considers that taxing rights may exist in a State even if services are provided by non-residents outside that State. It also considers that the taxation principle applicable to profits from the sale of goods may not apply to income from the provision of services.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 140 that only profits derived from services should be taxed and that provisions included in bilateral conventions allowing a State to tax the gross amount of fees paid for certain services are not an appropriate way of taxing services.
- India disagrees with the conclusions given in paragraph 143 that taxation should not extend to services provided outside the territory of the State; that taxation should apply only to profits from those services and not to payments for them; and that there should be a minimum level of presence in the State before such taxation is permitted.
38.1 Argentina does not fully agree with the explanation given in paragraphs 139, 140 and 143.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 152; it considers that the physical presence of a person is not essential for the provision of services in a State.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraphs 161 and 164.
- India disagrees with the interpretation given in Example 3 of paragraph 165 concerning the taxation of ZCO.
- Brazil disagrees with the interpretation provided in paragraphs 132–169 of the Commentary concerning the taxation of services, particularly in view of the principle of taxation at source of payments enshrined in its legislation.
- India disagrees with the interpretation of paragraph 27 of the Commentary on Article 5, according to which satellite communication in the space of the source country cannot be regarded as a permanent establishment. India considers that, in such a case, the source State not only contributes to its customer base but also provides the infrastructure for receiving satellite television broadcasts or telecommunications processes.
India also considers that satellite communication extends across both international and national space. The communication has a fixed location, has value and can be used for commercial purposes. Accordingly, it may be regarded as a fixed place of business within the territory under the jurisdiction of the country of origin.
- India disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 38 of the Commentary on Article 5, since it considers that a roaming call is an integrated process requiring the combined use of various units of equipment located in the country of origin and the country of residence, and that the proposed distinction in paragraph 38 is neither envisaged by the wording of Article 5 nor logical.
- India disagrees with the interpretation of the last two sentences of paragraph 64 of the Commentary on Article 5, according to which even submarine cables and pipelines located under the territorial jurisdiction of the source country cannot be regarded as a permanent establishment of an enterprise.
- With regard to paragraph 104, Colombia considers that the arm’s length principle should also be taken into account when determining whether an agent has independent status for the purposes of paragraph 6 of this Article and wishes, where necessary, to add wording to its conventions clarifying how this paragraph should be interpreted.
- Malaysia disagrees with the last example in paragraph 89 concerning representatives of a pharmaceutical enterprise and considers that they may constitute a permanent establishment, particularly if the representative also negotiates the principal elements and details of the contract, and not necessarily all the elements and details of the contract, on behalf of a foreign resident.
- Brazil does not adhere to the interpretation of paragraphs 51 and 52 concerning the twelve-month period.
- India disagrees with the explanation given in paragraph 55, since it considers that any work carried out at a site shortly after the completion of construction work, including repair work carried out under a warranty, may be considered part of the initial construction period for the purpose of determining whether a potential discrepancy exists.
- India disagrees with the explanation given in paragraph 69, since it considers that the collection of data for the purpose of determining or quantifying risk by an enterprise engaged in risk management, such as insurance, is not an activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
- India disagrees with the explanation given in paragraph 74, since it considers that even in cases where the anti-fragmentation rule does not apply, an enterprise cannot divide an integral operational activity into several smaller operations in order to argue that each of them is connected only with preparatory or auxiliary activities.
- India disagrees with the explanation given in paragraph 96, since it considers that the sale of goods belonging to the enterprise by a subsidiary or a closely related enterprise, particularly where such enterprises do not bear risks, for example, a so-called “low-risk distributor”, may result in the creation of a permanent establishment of the enterprise whose goods are sold.
- India disagrees with the opinion expressed in paragraph 5 of the Commentary on Article 5 that the VAT/GST regime (Goods and Services Tax) is in itself irrelevant to the purpose of interpreting and applying the definition of a permanent establishment. India considers that the VAT/GST regime (Goods and Services Tax) may constitute an important factor for this purpose.
Fix paragraph numbering and headingsRepair awkward and broken line breaks
54. India does not agree with the opinion expressed in paragraph 12 of the Commentary on Article 5 that, if an enterprise has no right to be present at a particular location and does not in fact use that location, that location cannot be considered to be at the disposal of the enterprise. India considers that, in certain circumstances, such a location may be considered to be at the disposal of the enterprise.
55. India does not agree with the opinion expressed in paragraph 19 of the Commentary on Article 5 that, where an employee from a frontier area performs most of his work from his home, which is located in one State, rather than from an office provided to him in the other State, his home should not be considered to be at the disposal of the enterprise. India considers that, in such a case, the employee's home may be considered to be at the disposal of the enterprise for the purposes of applying Article 5.
56. India does not agree with the opinion expressed in the last two sentences of paragraph 30 of the Commentary on Article 5. India considers that the operation of catering enterprises in the example given therein satisfies the time requirements for the creation of a permanent establishment.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 6
(INCOME FROM IMMOVABLE PROPERTY) AND COMMENTARY
Positions on the Article
Paragraph 1
1. India and Indonesia wish to include the words "including income from agriculture or forestry" in bilateral negotiations.
1.1 Costa Rica reserves the right to include income derived from forestry activities in the definition of "immovable property" in paragraph 1.
Paragraph 2
2. Having regard to the meaning of the term "immovable property" under its domestic law,
Belarus reserves the right to omit the second sentence of this paragraph.
2.1 Lithuania reserves the right to include in the definition of the term "immovable property" any option or similar right to acquire immovable property.
2.2 Colombia reserves the right to include rights relating to all natural resources in this Article. Colombia also reserves the right to amend the definition of "immovable property" to include other property.
3. Lithuania reserves the right to amend the second sentence of the definition of the term "immovable property" to clarify that this sentence does not apply for the purposes of domestic law.
3.1 Morocco wishes to preserve the possibility of applying the provisions of its domestic law concerning the taxation of income from shares or rights which are treated therein as income from immovable property.
3.2 Costa Rica reserves the right to include in paragraph 2 rights relating to the exploration and exploitation of immovable property, as well as any right to use or exploit immovable property situated in a Contracting State where such use or exploitation is connected with timesharing, since under its domestic law such a right is not considered to be immovable property.
Paragraph 3
4. Lithuania reserves the right to include in paragraph 3 a reference to income from the alienation of immovable property.
5. Lithuania also reserves the right to tax the income of shareholders of companies resident in that State from the direct use, letting or use in any other form of a right to use immovable property situated in their country and owned by the company, where such right is based on the ownership of shares or other corporate rights in the company.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 7
(BUSINESS PROFITS) AND COMMENTARY
Positions on the Article
1. Argentina, Azerbaijan, Brazil, Bulgaria, Costa Rica, Indonesia, Malaysia, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa and Thailand reserve the right to use the previous version of Article 7, i.e. the version that was included in the Model Tax Convention immediately before the 2010 Update, subject to their positions on that previous version (see Appendix below).
1.1 India reserves the right to use the previous version of Article 7, i.e. the version that was included in the Model Tax Convention immediately before the 2010 Update, subject to its position on that previous version (see Appendix below). It does not agree with the approach to the attribution of profits to permanent establishments reflected in the revised Article, its Commentary and the subsequent changes to the Commentary on other Articles (i.e. paragraph 21 of the Commentary on Article 8, paragraphs 32.1 and 32.2 of the Commentary on Article 10, paragraphs 25.1 and 25.2 of the Commentary on Article 11, paragraphs 21.1 and 21.2 of the Commentary on Article 12, paragraphs 27.1 and 27.2 of the Commentary on Article 13, paragraph 7.2 of the Commentary on paragraphs 5.1 and 5.2 of Article 15 of the Commentary on Article 21, paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 of the Commentary on Article 22 and subparagraph 40 a) of the Commentary on Article 24).
1.2 Argentina and Indonesia reserve the right to include in the Convention a special provision that would allow them to apply their domestic legislation concerning the taxation of profits of insurance and reinsurance companies, even in the absence of a permanent establishment.
1.3 Although the People's Republic of China understands and respects the separate and independent enterprise principle underlying the new version of Article 7, in view of its tax administration capabilities, it reserves the right to adopt the previous version of the Article and, in certain cases, to resort to simpler methods of calculating the profits attributable to a permanent establishment.
1.4 Colombia reserves the right to use the previous version of Article 7, i.e. the version that was included in the Model Tax Convention immediately before the 2010 Update, and not to take into account the changes to the Commentary on the Article introduced by that Update.
2. Malaysia, Thailand and Ukraine reserve the right to add a provision stating that, where the information available to the competent authority of a Contracting State is insufficient to determine the profits attributable to a permanent establishment of an enterprise, the competent authority may apply to that enterprise the provisions of the tax legislation of that State, provided that such legislation is applied, to the extent permitted by the information available to the competent authority, in accordance with the principles of this Article.
2.1 Albania, Argentina, Azerbaijan, Brazil, Costa Rica, Croatia, Gabon, Indonesia, Côte d'Ivoire, Lithuania, Malaysia, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, Thailand, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to retain in their conventions a specific Article concerning the taxation of "independent personal services". Accordingly, a reservation is also made with respect to all corresponding changes to the Articles and Commentaries that were amended as a result of the deletion of Article 14.
2.2 [Deleted]
2.3 Tunisia reserves the right to propose during bilateral negotiations the addition of a criterion for the taxation of independent personal services in the State of source, in accordance with former Article 14, based on the amount of remuneration paid (to be determined through bilateral negotiations).
3. Argentina, Morocco and Thailand reserve the right to tax, in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated, business profits derived from the sale of goods that are the same as or similar to those sold through the permanent establishment situated in that State, or from other business activities carried on in that State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment. They will apply this rule only as a safeguard against abuse and not as a general "force of attraction" rule. Accordingly, the rule will not apply where the enterprise proves that the sales or activities were carried out for reasons other than obtaining benefits under the Convention.
3.1 Indonesia reserves the right to tax, in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated, business profits derived from the sale of goods that are the same as or similar to those sold through that permanent establishment, or from other activities carried on in that State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment.
4. Albania, Costa Rica and Vietnam reserve the right to tax, in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated, business profits derived from the sale of goods that are the same as or similar to those sold through the permanent establishment situated in that State, or from other business activities carried on in that State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment.
4.1 Morocco and the Philippines reserve the right to establish a duration-of-stay criterion and a fixed-base criterion when determining whether an individual providing personal services is subject to taxation.
4.2 The United Arab Emirates reserve the right to include in their conventions a special provision that would allow them to apply their domestic legislation to all activities relating to the exploration, extraction or exploitation of natural resources, including oil activities, as well as the provision of services in connection with such activities, where these activities are carried on in their territory.
5. Argentina reserves the right to provide that a Contracting State is not required to allow the deduction of expenses incurred abroad which cannot reasonably be attributed to the activities carried on by the permanent establishment, having regard to the general principles contained in its domestic legislation concerning executive and administrative expenses for ancillary services.
6. Azerbaijan and Singapore reserve the right to add a paragraph clarifying that expenses allowed as deductions by a Contracting State include only those expenses which would be deductible if the permanent establishment were a separate enterprise of that Contracting State.
7. Armenia, Lithuania and Serbia reserve the right to add to paragraph 2 a clarification that expenses allowed as deductions by a Contracting State include only those expenses which are deductible under the domestic law of that State.
8. Serbia reserves the right to specify that any possible adjustment will be made only if it is considered justified.
9. Colombia reserves the right to amend Article 7 to provide that, in applying paragraphs 1 and 2 of that Article, profits attributable to a permanent establishment during the period of its existence may be taxed by the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment exists, even if payment is deferred until after the permanent establishment ceases to exist.
10. Costa Rica reserves the right to add a provision concerning expenses allowed as deductions.
11. [Deleted]
Positions on the Commentary
12. Argentina, Brazil, Bulgaria, Indonesia, Malaysia, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa and Thailand will interpret Article 7 as it was read before the 2010 Update, in accordance with the relevant Commentary as it stood before that Update.
13. Argentina considers that the "separate approach" and the arm's length principle should be applied symmetrically to transactions between a permanent establishment and the head office of an enterprise — both for the purpose of determining the correct attribution of profits (deduction of expenses) to the permanent establishment and for the taxation of the head office's profits from those transactions — in accordance with the fiction that the permanent establishment is a separate enterprise and that such an enterprise is independent of the rest of the enterprise of which it forms part.
14. India does not agree with the last sentence of paragraph 75.1 to the effect that income from the issuance and sale of emission permits and quotas is not covered by the scope of Article 8 even in the circumstances referred to in paragraph 14.1 of the Commentary on Article 8.
APPENDIX
PROVISIONS OF THE PREVIOUS VERSION OF ARTICLE 7 AND COMMENTARY
The following sets out the text of the positions of non-OECD countries on Article 7 and its Commentary as they stood before 22 July 2010. The previous version of the positions on Article 7 and its Commentary is reproduced for historical reference, since it remains relevant to the application and interpretation of bilateral tax conventions which use the previous version of the Article.
Positions on the Article
1. Argentina and Chile reserve the right to include in the Convention a special provision that would allow them to apply their domestic legislation concerning the taxation of profits of insurance and reinsurance companies.
2. Malaysia, Thailand and Ukraine reserve the right to add a provision stating that, where the information available to the competent authority of a Contracting State is insufficient to determine the profits attributable to a permanent establishment of an enterprise, the competent authority may apply to that enterprise the provisions of the tax legislation of that State, provided that such legislation is applied, to the extent permitted by the information available to the competent authority, in accordance with the principles of this Article.
2.1 Albania, Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Croatia, Gabon, India, Côte d'Ivoire, Malaysia, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, Russia, Serbia, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to retain in their conventions a specific Article concerning the taxation of "independent personal services". Accordingly, a reservation is also made with respect to all corresponding changes to the Articles and Commentaries that were made as a result of the deletion of Article 14.
2.2 Bulgaria reserves the right to propose during bilateral negotiations replacing the term "profits" in this Article with the term "business profits", provided that the latter is defined in Article 3.
2.3 Tunisia reserves the right to propose during bilateral negotiations the addition of a criterion for the taxation of independent personal services in the State of source, in accordance with former Article 14, based on the amount of remuneration paid (to be determined through bilateral negotiations).
Paragraphs 1 and 2
3. Argentina, Morocco and Thailand reserve the right to tax, in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated, business profits derived from the sale of goods that are the same as or similar to those sold through the permanent establishment situated in that State, or from other business activities carried on in that State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment. They will apply this rule only as a safeguard against abuse and not as a general "force of attraction" rule. Accordingly, the rule will not apply where the enterprise proves that the sales or activities were carried out for reasons other than obtaining benefits under the Convention.
4. Albania and Vietnam reserve the right to tax, in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated, business profits derived from the sale of goods that are the same as or similar to those sold through the permanent establishment situated in that State, or from other business activities carried on in that State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through that permanent establishment.
4.1 Morocco and the Philippines reserve the right to establish a duration-of-stay criterion and a fixed-base criterion when determining whether an individual providing personal services is subject to taxation.
4.2 Chile and India reserve the right to amend Article 7 to provide that, in applying paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Article, any income or profits attributable to a permanent establishment during the period of its existence may be taxed by the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment exists, even if payment is deferred until after the permanent establishment ceases to exist. In addition, India also reserves the right to apply such a rule under Articles 11, 12, 13 and 21.
Paragraph 3
5. With respect to paragraph 3, Argentina reserves the right to provide that a Contracting State is not required to allow the deduction of expenses incurred abroad which cannot reasonably be attributed to the activities carried on by the permanent establishment, having regard to the general principles contained in its domestic legislation concerning executive and administrative expenses for ancillary services.
6. Brazil maintains its position concerning the words "whether in the State in which the permanent establishment is situated or elsewhere" contained in paragraph 3.
7. Armenia, India, Lithuania and Slovenia reserve the right to add to paragraph 3 a clarification that expenses allowed as deductions by a Contracting State include only those expenses which are deductible under the domestic law of that State.
7.1 Estonia and Latvia reserve the right to add to paragraph 3 a clarification that expenses allowed as deductions by a Contracting State include only those expenses which would be deductible if the permanent establishment were a separate enterprise of that Contracting State.
8. Ukraine and Vietnam reserve the right to add to paragraph 3 a clarification that this paragraph refers to actual expenses incurred by the enterprise (other than interest in the case of a banking enterprise).
Paragraph 4
9. Brazil reserves the right not to accept paragraph 4.
Paragraph 5
10. Vietnam reserves the right not to accept paragraph 5.
Paragraph 6
11. Brazil reserves the right not to accept paragraph 6.
Positions on the Commentary
12. India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 25.
13. With respect to paragraphs 41–50 of the Commentary on Article 7, Chile does not adhere to specific methods provided as rules concerning the amount of profits attributable to a permanent establishment; such methods should be established in accordance with and comply with domestic law (including foreign exchange legislation).
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 8
(INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING AND AIR TRANSPORT) AND COMMENTARY
Positions on the Article
1. Armenia and Lithuania reserve the right, in exceptional cases, to apply the permanent establishment rule to profits derived from the operation of ships in international traffic.
Paragraph 1
2. The Philippines reserve the right to provide for the taxation of profits from shipping and air transport in accordance with domestic law.
2.1 Indonesia reserves the right to allow the State of source to tax profits from the operation of ships in international traffic, provided that the shipping activities connected with such operations in that State are more than occasional and are subject to certain restrictions.
3. Albania, Argentina and Bulgaria reserve the right to tax profits from the carriage of passengers or cargo taken on board at one place in the relevant country for discharge at another place in the same country.
4. South Africa reserves the right to include in paragraph 1 profits from the leasing of containers.
4.1 Azerbaijan reserves the right to include a provision providing for the taxation of profits from the leasing of containers in the same manner as profits from international transport where such profits are ancillary or incidental to international transport.
5. Thailand reserves the right to provide for the taxation of shipping profits in accordance with domestic law.
5.1 India reserves the right to apply Article 12, rather than Article 8, to profits from the leasing of ships or aircraft on a bareboat basis.
6. South Africa and Ukraine reserve the right to include a provision ensuring that profits from the leasing of ships or aircraft without crew and, in the case of Ukraine, from the leasing of containers, are treated in the same manner as income covered by paragraph 1 where such profits are incidental to international transport.
6.1 Bulgaria, Croatia, Russia and South Africa reserve the right to extend the scope of the Article to international road and rail transport in bilateral conventions.
6.2 Morocco reserves the right to provide for the taxation of profits derived by an enterprise engaged in international transport from the leasing of containers that is ancillary or incidental to its international operation of ships and aircraft covered by this Article.
6.3 Serbia reserves the right, during negotiations, to propose that the leasing of containers, even where it is directly connected with or ancillary to international transport, be treated as a separate activity from international shipping or air transport and, consequently, be excluded from the scope of the Article.
6.4 Serbia reserves the right to extend the scope of the Article to include international road transport in bilateral conventions.
6.5 Vietnam reserves the right to provide that the taxing right with respect to income derived from international transport be allocated on a 50/50 basis.
6.6 The United Arab Emirates reserve the right to include in their bilateral agreements a provision confirming that income from the sale of tickets on behalf of other enterprises, income derived from the sale of technical services to third parties, income from bank deposits and other investments, such as bonds, shares and other debt obligations, falls within the scope of Article 8, provided that such income is incidental to the activities of air transport enterprises engaged in international transport.
7. Costa Rica reserves the right to include within the scope of “profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic” income derived from (a) the temporary leasing of ships or aircraft on an unladen basis and (b) the use or leasing of containers (including trailers and auxiliary equipment used for transporting containers).
Positions on the Commentary
8. Vietnam disagrees with the interpretation presented in paragraph 5 of the Commentary.
9. Vietnam disagrees with the interpretation presented in paragraph 10 of the Commentary concerning the unanticipated leasing of containers.
10. Brazil, India and Malaysia maintain their position concerning the application of this Article to income from ancillary activities (see paragraphs 4–10.1).
11. Singapore maintains its position concerning the application of this Article to income from ancillary activities. It considers that Article 8 does not cover any ancillary activities that are not expressly mentioned in Singapore's tax conventions.
12. India disagrees with the view that income derived by an enterprise from trading in emission permits and allowances in the example provided in paragraph 14.1 is covered by Article 8.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 9
(ASSOCIATED ENTERPRISES) AND COMMENTARY
1. Brazil, Vietnam and Thailand reserve the right not to include paragraph 2 in their conventions.
2. Bulgaria and Russia reserve the right to replace “shall” with “may” in the first sentence of paragraph 2 of their conventions.
3. Azerbaijan, Malaysia and Serbia reserve the right to specify in paragraph 2 that an appropriate adjustment shall be made if the adjustment is considered justified.
4. Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco and Tunisia reserve the right not to include paragraph 2 in their conventions, except where the obligation to make an adjustment does not apply in cases of fraud, wilful default or negligence. In such a case, Tunisia reserves the right to limit the adjustment to periods not covered by its domestic statute of limitations.
5. Russia reserves the right not to include paragraph 2 in its conventions but is prepared, during negotiations, to accept this paragraph on the understanding that the other Contracting State is required to make an adjustment to the amount of tax only to the extent that it agrees, unilaterally or through the mutual agreement procedure, with the adjustment of profits made by the first-mentioned State.
6. Argentina reserves the right to add a provision stating that any corresponding adjustment to the amount of tax charged on those profits may not be made in cases of fraud, wilful default or negligence.
Position on the Commentary
7. With respect to paragraph 1 of the Commentary on Article 9, Brazil reserves the right to provide in its domestic legislation for an approach involving the use of a fixed margin derived from industry practice, in accordance with the arm's length principle. In this regard, it reserves the right not to adhere to the provisions of the Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations where those provisions conflict with such an approach.
Positions on the Article
Paragraph 2
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 10 (DIVIDENDS) AND COMMENTARY
1. Thailand reserves the right to apply a 10 per cent withholding tax rate in the case referred to in subparagraph (a).
2. Singapore maintains its position on the period criterion included in subparagraph 2(a).
3. Bulgaria, India, Lithuania, Malaysia, Russia, Serbia and Singapore reserve the right not to include the requirement that the competent authorities determine by mutual agreement the mode of application of paragraph 2.
3.1 Azerbaijan reserves the right not to include in its bilateral conventions the sentence providing that the competent authorities shall determine the mode of application of paragraph 2 by mutual agreement, since it uses uniform rules for the implementation of all its bilateral conventions.
4. [Deleted]
5. Azerbaijan and Romania reserve the right to tax all dividends referred to in this paragraph at a single rate agreed upon during negotiations.
6. Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco, Russia, South Africa and Tunisia maintain their position on the rates of tax in paragraph 2 and the minimum percentage for a holding under subparagraph (a).
7. Colombia, Serbia and Vietnam reserve the right to tax all dividends referred to in paragraph 2 at a single rate of not less than 10 per cent.
7.1 Argentina reserves the right to include in its bilateral treaties a provision stating that the tax rate referred to in paragraph 2 shall not apply where a local company distributes profits exceeding the total amount of accumulated taxable profits at the end of the financial year immediately preceding the date of distribution, on the understanding that the taxation of dividends exceeding accumulated profits is considered taxation at the company level.
7.2 Argentina, India and Indonesia reserve the right to establish the tax rate during bilateral negotiations.
7.3 Costa Rica reserves the right to increase the tax rates on dividends in its bilateral conventions.
Paragraph 3
8. Argentina, Russia and Tunisia reserve the right to include a provision allowing them to apply thin capitalisation measures in accordance with their domestic legislation, irrespective of any other provisions of the Convention.
9. Since their legislation does not provide for such concepts as dividend-bearing rights and shares, mining company shares and founders' shares, Albania, Armenia, Bulgaria, Belarus, Malaysia and Serbia reserve the right to exclude them from paragraph 3.
10. Bulgaria reserves the right to replace the words “income from other corporate rights” with “income from other rights” in paragraph 3.
10.1 Morocco reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in paragraph 3 by adding the words “and other assimilated income” after the words “as well as income from other corporate rights” and before the words “which is subject to the same taxation…”.
10.2 India reserves the right to amend the definition of the term “dividends”.
10.3 Argentina reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in paragraph 3 to cover certain payments that are treated as dividend distributions under its domestic legislation.
10.4 Bulgaria reserves the right to propose, during bilateral negotiations, the inclusion of a paragraph providing that dividends which are treated as hidden profit distributions under its legislation shall continue to be taxed in accordance with its legislation, notwithstanding the exemption from liability under paragraph 2 of the Article.
10.5 Costa Rica reserves the right to expand the definition of dividends in paragraph 3 to cover all income subject to the distribution tax regime under its domestic legislation.
Paragraph 5
11. Argentina, Kazakhstan, Morocco, Russia and Tunisia reserve the right to apply a branch profits tax.
12. Brazil reserves the right to levy withholding tax on the profits of a permanent establishment at the same tax rate as that provided for in paragraph 2, in accordance with the traditional rule of the Brazilian income tax system.
13. Thailand reserves the right to levy a tax on the remittance of profits from a permanent establishment at the same rate as that provided for in subparagraph 2(a).
14. Indonesia reserves the right to apply a branch profits tax, but such branch profits tax shall not affect the provisions contained in any production-sharing contracts relating to oil and gas and contracts for work in other mining sectors.
14.1 Colombia reserves the right to apply its domestic rules on the taxation of dividends distributed out of profits that were not taxed at the company level, and to levy a tax on the remittance of profits attributable to permanent establishments that were not subject to taxation in Colombia.
Position on the Commentary
15. India does not adhere to the interpretation set out in paragraph 24. Under its domestic legislation, certain payments are treated as distributions and are therefore included in the definition of dividends.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 11 (INTEREST) AND COMMENTARY
1. Bulgaria and Ukraine reserve the right to exclude from the scope of the Article interest on a debt-claim where the principal purpose, or one of the principal purposes, of any person concerned with the creation or assignment of the debt-claim in respect of which the interest is paid is to take advantage of this Article rather than for bona fide commercial reasons.
Paragraph 2
2. Argentina, Brazil, Costa Rica, India, Côte d'Ivoire, Latvia, the Philippines, Romania, Thailand and Ukraine maintain their positions on the rate provided for in paragraph 2.
3. Brazil reserves the right to add to its agreements a paragraph concerning interest paid to the government of a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions, its local authorities or any institution (including a financial institution) wholly owned by that government, providing that such interest shall be taxable only in the State of residence of the creditor. However, where interest is paid by the government of a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions, its local authority or any institution (including a financial institution) wholly owned by that government, such interest shall be taxable only in that Contracting State (i.e. the State of source).
4. Bulgaria, India, Lithuania, Malaysia, Russia, Serbia and Singapore reserve the right not to include the requirement that the competent authorities determine by mutual agreement the mode of application of paragraph 2.
4.1 Azerbaijan reserves the right not to include in its bilateral conventions the sentence providing that the competent authorities shall determine the mode of application of paragraph 2 by mutual agreement, since it uses uniform rules for the implementation of all its bilateral conventions.
Paragraph 3
5. Brazil, Thailand and Ukraine reserve the right to treat late payment penalties as interest for the purposes of this Article in accordance with their domestic legislation.
6. Malaysia reserves the right to exclude premiums or prizes from the definition of interest in accordance with the treatment of such payments under its domestic legislation.
7. Brazil and Thailand reserve the right to treat as interest any other income assimilated to income from money lent under the tax legislation of the Contracting State in which the income arises.
7.1 Bulgaria, Morocco and Tunisia reserve the right to amend the definition of interest to clarify that interest payments treated as distributions under their domestic legislation fall within the scope of Article 10.
7.2 Costa Rica reserves the right to expand the definition of interest to include other types of income, such as income derived from financial leasing contracts and factoring agreements.
Paragraph 4
8. Brazil reserves the right to provide that, where interest is paid to a permanent establishment of a resident of another Contracting State situated in a third State, the limitation on the rate of taxation of interest referred to in paragraph 2 shall not apply.
8.1 Morocco reserves the right to include in paragraph 4 a reference to other commercial activities carried on in another State that are of the same or a similar kind as the activities carried on through the permanent establishment.
Positions on the Commentary
9. Malaysia disagrees with paragraph 20 of the Commentary, since under Malaysian domestic legislation premiums or prizes are not taxable.
10. India reserves the right to treat the interest component of credit sales (described in paragraphs 7.8 and 7.9) as interest.
11. India does not adhere to the interpretation set out in paragraph 20 and reserves the right to treat the difference between the redemption price and the issue price in accordance with its domestic legislation.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 12 (ROYALTIES) AND ITS COMMENTARY
1. Bulgaria and Ukraine reserve the right to exclude from the scope of this Article royalties arising from property or rights created or transferred principally for the purpose of taking advantage of this Article rather than for bona fide commercial reasons.
2. [Deleted]
Paragraph 1
3. Albania, Argentina, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Brazil, Bulgaria, Colombia, Costa Rica, Croatia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Gabon, Indonesia, Côte d'Ivoire, Kazakhstan, Malaysia, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, the Philippines, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa, Thailand, Tunisia, Ukraine, Vietnam and Hong Kong, China reserve the right to tax royalties at source.
3.1 Costa Rica reserves the right to retain the 10-percent withholding tax rate in its bilateral conventions.
4. Armenia reserves the right to tax royalties for copyrights in literary, scientific and artistic works at a reduced rate.
4.1 India reserves the right to: tax royalties and fees for technical services at source; define them, in particular, by reference to its domestic law; determine the source of such payments, which may extend beyond the source determined under paragraph 5 of Article 11, and amend paragraphs 3 and 4 accordingly.
Paragraph 2
5. Argentina, Brazil, Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco, Russia, Thailand and Tunisia reserve the right to continue including in the definition of royalties income derived from the leasing of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and containers, as provided for in paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the 1977 Model Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation.
6. Vietnam, Thailand and the Philippines reserve the right to include fees for technical services in the definition of royalties.
7. Argentina, Brazil, Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire and Tunisia reserve the right to include fees for technical assistance and technical services in the definition of "royalties".
7.1 Morocco reserves the right to include in the definition of royalties payments for services, technical assistance, technical and economic studies and all types of service fees.
7.2 Colombia reserves the right to include payments received for the provision of technical assistance, technical and consultancy services in the definition of royalties.
8. Azerbaijan, Albania, Armenia, Belarus, Brazil, Bulgaria, Colombia, Costa Rica, India, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Malaysia, the People's Republic of China, the Philippines, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Thailand and Vietnam reserve the right to include in the definition of royalties payments for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
8.1 Serbia reserves the right to include in the definition of royalties income derived from the leasing of ships or aircraft under bareboat charter arrangements and containers.
8.2 Malaysia reserves the right to include in the definition of royalties income derived from the leasing of containers, ships or aircraft, including the leasing of airport slots, time charters, voyage charters or bareboat charters, irrespective of whether such charters include a crew, or whether the equipment is equipped or supplied.
9. Belarus reserves the right to include a reference to means of transport in the definition of royalties.
10. Argentina, Brazil, Morocco and Romania reserve the right to include in the definition of royalties payments for transmissions by satellite, cable, fibre-optic or similar technology.
10.1 Argentina and Vietnam reserve the right to include in the definition of royalties payments for the use of, or the right to use, "films, tapes or digital media used for radio or television broadcasting".
11. Albania, Malaysia, Serbia and Vietnam reserve the right to regulate fees for technical services in a separate article similar to Article 12.
12. Albania, Argentina, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Brazil, Bulgaria, Colombia, Croatia, Gabon, Indonesia, Côte d'Ivoire, Kazakhstan, Lithuania, Malaysia, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, the Philippines, Romania, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa, Thailand, Tunisia, Ukraine, Vietnam and Hong Kong, China reserve the right to fill what they consider to be a gap in this Article and to add a provision determining the source of royalties by analogy with the provisions of paragraph 5 of Article 11, which deals with the same issue in the case of interest.
12.1 Morocco reserves the right to include in this paragraph a reference to other business activities carried on in the other State of the same or similar kind as those carried on through a permanent establishment.
12.2 The Democratic Republic of the Congo and Malaysia maintain their position regarding the treatment of software.
12.3 Kazakhstan reserves the right to include in the definition of royalties payments for the use of, or the right to use, software.
Positions on the Commentary
13. Argentina, Morocco, Serbia and Tunisia disagree with the interpretation in paragraphs 14 and 15 of the Commentary. They take the view that payments relating to software fall within the scope of the Article if all rights to the software are not transferred, or if the payments are consideration for the right to use the copyright in the software for commercial exploitation, or if they relate to software acquired for the purchaser's personal or commercial use.
14. Vietnam disagrees with paragraph 9 of the Commentary. Even if the phrase "for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment" is not included in paragraph 2 and income from the leasing of equipment falls within the scope of Article 7, the fact that an enterprise of a Contracting State leases heavy equipment to a person resident in Vietnam would constitute a permanent establishment of that enterprise in Vietnam.
15. Brazil disagrees with the interpretation set out in paragraphs 17.1–17.4, particularly in view of the principle of taxation at source of payments established under its legislation.
16. Malaysia cannot agree with the new additional sentence in paragraph 11.2, namely: "payments made under the latest contracts generally fall within the scope of Article 7". Malaysia regards payments for the provision of services as a special type of income under its domestic law, rather than as income from business activities.
17. India maintains its position regarding the interpretations presented in paragraphs 8.2, 10.1, 10.2, 14, 14.1, 14.2, 14.4, 15, 16 and 17.3; it considers that some of the payments mentioned may constitute royalties.
17.1 Colombia disagrees with the interpretations set out in paragraphs 8.2, 13.1, 14, 14.1, 14.2, 14.4, 15, 16 and 17.3; under its tax legislation, some of the payments mentioned may constitute royalties.
18. India disagrees with the interpretation according to which information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience is limited to previous experience only.
19. Malaysia disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 14.2, since Malaysia considers that licence fees for the rights to distribute software constitute royalties.
20. India disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 9.1 of the Commentary on Article 12, according to which fees for the leasing of a transponder do not constitute royalties. This interpretation is contrary to India's position that income from the leasing of a transponder constitutes royalties for equipment, taxable both under India's domestic law and under its agreements with many countries. It is also contrary to India's position that fees for the use of a transponder constitute fees for the use of a process, resulting in the payment of royalties under Article 12. India also disagrees with the conclusion contained in the paragraph concerning submarine cables and pipelines, since it considers that submarine cables and pipelines constitute industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, and that payments for their use constitute royalties for equipment.
21. India disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 9.2 of the Commentary on Article 12. It considers that a roaming call constitutes the use of a process. Accordingly, payment made for the use of that process constitutes royalties for the purposes of the Article.
India also considers that payment for a roaming call constitutes royalties because it is a fee for the use of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
22. India disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 9.3 of the Commentary on Article 12. It considers that a licence fee for the use of spectrum constitutes royalties taxable both under India's domestic law and under its treaties with many countries.
23. Azerbaijan and the People's Republic of China disagree with the interpretation in paragraph 10.1, as they consider that certain payments for exclusive rights to distribute a product or service in a given territory may be regarded as royalties.
24. Bulgaria disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 14.4 of the Commentary on Article 12 and considers that a distribution intermediary who distributes software to customers and requests from the copyright holder of the software, or from another person entitled to copy the software, copies of the software in respect of those customers, whether on a physical medium or electronically, makes use of the copyright in the software product.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 13 (CAPITAL GAINS) AND COMMENTARY
1. Argentina and Brazil reserve the right to tax at source gains from the alienation of property situated in a Contracting State, other than property referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4.
2. The People's Republic of China, Serbia and Thailand reserve the right to tax income from the alienation of shares or rights that form part of a substantial participation in a resident company.
3. Singapore maintains its position on the period criterion included in paragraph 4.
3.1 Lithuania reserves the right to include special provisions concerning capital gains attributable to activities carried on in a Contracting State in connection with the exploration for or exploitation of natural resources.
4. Lithuania reserves the right to limit the application of paragraph 3 to enterprises operating ships and aircraft in international traffic.
5. Colombia, Costa Rica, India and Vietnam reserve the right to tax gains from the alienation of shares or rights in a company that is resident in their respective countries.
6. Bulgaria reserves the right to tax gains from the alienation of shares or rights in a company that is resident in Bulgaria, except for shares listed on a regulated stock exchange.
7. Bulgaria reserves the right to extend the scope of this provision to cover gains from the alienation of railway and road vehicles.
8. Vietnam reserves the right to amend paragraph 4 so that the immovable property concerned constitutes only 30 percent of all the assets owned by the company.
9. Serbia reserves the right to extend the scope of this provision to cover gains from the alienation of motor vehicles operated in international traffic.
10. India maintains its position on paragraph 4.
11. Lithuania reserves the right not to include paragraph 4 in its conventions.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 14 (INDEPENDENT PERSONAL SERVICES) AND COMMENTARY
[All positions on Article 14 were deleted on 29 April 2000, when Article 14 itself was deleted from the OECD Model Tax Convention in accordance with the report entitled
"Issues Related to Article 14 of the OECD Model Tax Convention", which was adopted by the OECD Committee on Fiscal Affairs on 27 January 2000.]
Positions on the Article
1. [Deleted]
2. [Deleted]
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 15 (INCOME FROM EMPLOYMENT) AND COMMENTARY
3. Lithuania reserves the right to include special provisions concerning income derived from employment services connected with activities carried on in a Contracting State in connection with the exploration for or exploitation of natural resources.
4. Serbia reserves the right to propose a separate paragraph providing that remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State if the remuneration is paid in respect of employment exercised in the other Contracting State at a building site, construction or installation project for an agreed period during which the site or project does not constitute a permanent establishment in that other State.
5. India reserves the right to determine the period of presence referred to in this paragraph through bilateral negotiations.
5.1 The United Arab Emirates reserve the right to amend paragraph 3 to specify that remuneration derived in respect of employment exercised aboard an aircraft operated in international traffic (including the aircraft crew and ground staff) shall be taxable exclusively in the State in which the aircraft operator is resident.
5.2 Azerbaijan reserves the right to provide that remuneration derived in respect of employment exercised aboard ships or aircraft shall be taxable only in the State in which their operator is resident.
5.3 Hong Kong, China, reserves the right to amend paragraph 3 to provide that remuneration of an employee working aboard a ship or aircraft operated in international traffic shall be taxable only in the State in which the enterprise operating such ship or aircraft is resident.
Positions on the Commentary
6. India disagrees with the interpretation set out in paragraph 6.2, since it does not recognise the concept of a partner being treated as an employer in the case of a partnership that is fiscally transparent.
7. India and the People's Republic of China disagree with the interpretation set out in paragraph 2.9, since they take the view that payment received by an employee as compensation for an obligation not to work for a competitor of the former employer constitutes payment received for employment activities carried out before the termination of employment, and that such payment may be taxed in the Contracting State where the employment activities were carried out before such termination.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 16 (DIRECTORS' FEES) AND COMMENTARY
1. Albania, Azerbaijan, Bulgaria, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Indonesia, Lithuania and Serbia reserve the right to tax under this Article any remuneration received by a member of the board of directors or any other similar body of a company resident in their respective countries.
2. [Deleted]
3. Morocco reserves the right to tax under this Article any remuneration received by a member of the board of directors or any other similar body of a resident company. Morocco also reserves the right to extend the application of the Article to remuneration received by senior employees.
4. Vietnam, Indonesia and Malaysia reserve the right to extend the application of the Article to remuneration received by senior executives.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 17 (ENTERTAINERS AND SPORTSPERSONS) AND COMMENTARY
Positions on the Article
1. The Philippines and Russia reserve the right to exclude from the scope of paragraph 1 entertainers and sportspersons working for organisations subsidised from public funds.
2. India reserves the right to include performers, as well as non-performing artists, within the scope of the term "entertainers".
Positions on the Commentary
3. Argentina and Brazil disagree with the interpretation in paragraph 3 according to which Article 17 should not apply to a model acting as such and presenting clothes during a fashion show. They consider that, in certain circumstances, a fashion show may have an entertainment character. Thus, income derived by a model from participating in such a show may be included under Article 17 (as opposed to income derived by a model from other activities, such as photo shoots, where the activity performed clearly does not have an entertainment character).
3.1 Malaysia disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 3 according to which Article 17 should not apply to a model acting as such and presenting clothes during a fashion show.
4. Brazil, Malaysia and the People's Republic of China disagree with the interpretation set out in paragraph 3, since they consider that speakers at conferences, in particular former politicians, may fall within the scope of Article 17 if their speeches have an entertainment character.
5. Argentina disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 9.1, since it considers that in certain cases the fee that a former or injured sportsperson would receive for providing commentary during the broadcast of a sporting event in which that person is not participating may be derived from the personal activities of that person of an entertainment character. In such cases, the person is offered the work (and the corresponding income) because of their fame as a sportsperson, rather than because of their reputation as a commentator, and, consequently, such income falls within the scope of Article 17.
6. India disagrees with the interpretation in paragraph 3 according to which Article 17 should not apply to a model acting as such and presenting clothes during a fashion show. India considers that, in certain circumstances, a fashion show may have an entertainment character and accordingly fall within the scope of Article 17.
7. India disagrees with the interpretation given in paragraph 9, which limits the scope of Article 17 to personal activities closely connected with the performance. India considers that any remuneration received by an entertainer or sportsperson for any personal activity, including a performance, falls within the scope of Article 17.
8. India disagrees with the third example in paragraph 9.1 concerning the coverage or commentary on activities during the broadcasting of an entertainment or sporting event, since it considers that such activities fall within the scope of Article 17.
9. Brazil and India disagree with the interpretation set out in paragraph 11.2. They consider that prize money in such races is paid for the personal activities of the jockey and racing driver and falls within the scope of Article 17.
10. With regard to paragraph 14 of the Commentary, India considers that the phrase "personal activities as such" in paragraph 1 of Article 17 would not include activities financed from public funds, and that the alternative provision included in paragraph 14 merely confirms this view.
Position on the Article
1. [Deleted]
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 18 (PENSIONS) AND COMMENTARIES
2. Brazil, Bulgaria, Côte d'Ivoire, South Africa and Ukraine reserve the right to include an explicit reference to annuities in paragraph 1.
Position on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 19 (GOVERNMENT SERVICE) AND COMMENTARIES
1. Argentina reserves the right to tax pensions from sources referred to in subparagraph 2 b).
Position on the Commentary
2. India does not agree that government bodies, such as state railways and post offices, carry on commercial activities.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 20 (STUDENTS) AND COMMENTARIES
1. Albania, Brazil and Serbia reserve the right to add a second paragraph providing that visiting students shall be granted the same tax exemptions or reliefs as those granted to residents in respect of any grants, scholarships and payments for employment services.
2. Lithuania and Morocco reserve the right to refer to any pupil and trainee in this Article.
3. Georgia reserves the right to propose a separate paragraph providing that remuneration received by a student or trainee who is or was, immediately before visiting a Contracting State, a resident of another Contracting State, from employment exercised by that student or trainee in the first-mentioned State for a period or periods not exceeding two years shall not be taxable in the first-mentioned State, provided that the employment is directly related to the studies pursued by the student or trainee in the first-mentioned State.
4. Vietnam reserves the right to provide that remuneration for services rendered by a student or trainee in a Contracting State shall be exempt from tax in that State, provided that such services are related to the student's or trainee's education.
5. Thailand reserves the right to provide that remuneration for services rendered by a student or trainee in a Contracting State shall not be taxable in that State, provided that such remuneration does not exceed a specified amount to be agreed upon and that such services are related to the student's or trainee's education.
6. Brazil, Bulgaria, Costa Rica, India, Côte d'Ivoire, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, the Philippines, Serbia, Thailand, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to add an Article dealing with the situation of teachers, professors and researchers, subject to various conditions, and to make corresponding changes to paragraph 1 of Article 15.
7. Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire and Tunisia reserve the right to provide that remuneration for services rendered by a student or trainee in the visited State shall not be taxable in that State, provided that such remuneration is received for the purposes of the student's or trainee's maintenance or education.
8. Morocco reserves the right to add a second paragraph providing that remuneration from employment received in the visited State shall not be taxable in that State or, where it is taxable, that visiting students shall be granted the same tax exemptions or reliefs as those granted to residents.
9. India and Hong Kong, China reserve the right to exclude the term "trainee" from this Article.
10. India reserves the right to provide that remuneration for services rendered by a student in a Contracting State shall not be taxable in that State, provided that such services are directly related to the student's education, and to make corresponding changes to paragraph 1 of Article 15.
11. India reserves the right to limit the tax exemption provided for in this Article to a period of six years.
Position on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 21 (OTHER INCOME) AND COMMENTARIES
1. Albania, Argentina, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Gabon, India, Indonesia, Côte d'Ivoire, Malaysia, Morocco, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, South Africa, Thailand and Vietnam maintain their positions on this Article because they wish to preserve the right to tax income derived from sources in their respective countries.
Positions on the Article
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 22 (CAPITAL) AND COMMENTARIES
1. Argentina reserves the right to tax capital situated in its territory, with the exception of property referred to in paragraph 3.
2. Brazil, Bulgaria, Indonesia, Malaysia, the People's Republic of China, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam maintain their positions on the Article if and when they levy taxes on capital.
3. India reserves the right to tax capital in accordance with its domestic law.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLES 23 A AND 23 B (EXEMPTION METHOD AND CREDIT METHOD) AND COMMENTARIES
Positions on the Article
1. Albania, Argentina, Brazil, India, Côte d'Ivoire, Malaysia, Morocco, the People's Republic of China, Serbia, Thailand, Tunisia and Vietnam reserve the right to add provisions concerning tax exemptions in respect of tax incentives provided for under their respective domestic laws.
2. Argentina and Vietnam reserve the right to add an appropriate credit in respect of part or all of the income covered by Articles 10, 11 and 12, whereby tax shall be deemed to have been paid for the purposes of the Article on the elimination of double taxation at a specified rate, to be agreed upon, of the gross income.
3. Brazil reserves the right to add an appropriate credit in respect of part or all of the income covered by Articles 11 and 12, whereby tax shall be deemed to have been paid for the purposes of the Article on the elimination of double taxation at a specified rate, to be agreed upon, of the gross income.
4. Brazil and Tunisia reserve the right to provide that income covered by Article 10 shall be exempt from tax or shall be entitled to an appropriate credit in the other Contracting State.
5. Brazil maintains its position on paragraph 4 of Article 23 A.
Positions on the Article
Paragraph 1
1. [Deleted]
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 24 (NON-DISCRIMINATION) AND COMMENTARIES
2. Brazil, Vietnam, Colombia, Romania, Russia, Singapore and Thailand maintain their position on the second sentence of paragraph 1.
2.1 Bulgaria reserves the right to omit the words "other or" in the first sentence of paragraph 1.
2.2 Indonesia, Malaysia and Tunisia reserve the right to limit the scope of application of this Article to residents of the Contracting States.
2.3 Singapore reserves the right to add a provision stating that the granting of tax incentives to its nationals, designed to promote economic or social development, shall not be regarded as discriminatory.
Paragraph 2
3. [Deleted]
4. Albania, Bulgaria, India, Malaysia, the Philippines, Russia, Serbia, Singapore and Vietnam reserve the right not to include paragraph 2 in their conventions.
Paragraph 3
5. Argentina reserves the right to apply a branch profits tax.
6. Brazil maintains its position on paragraph 3 because royalties paid by a permanent establishment located in Brazil to its head office abroad are not deductible under its legislation.
7. Thailand reserves the right to apply a tax on the remittance of profits and a special tax regime in respect of agricultural production activities.
7.1 Morocco reserves the right to add a paragraph stating that nothing in this Article shall be construed as preventing Morocco from applying its branch tax, its domestic thin capitalisation rules and its transfer pricing rules.
7.2 Argentina reserves the right to provide in paragraph 3 that no benefits or reliefs provided for under its domestic law shall be granted where this would result in the transfer of taxes to foreign tax administrations.
7.3 Colombia reserves the right to levy a tax on the remittance of profits attributable to permanent establishments.
Paragraph 4
8. Vietnam maintains its position on this paragraph in the case of interest payments to non-residents that are not subject to withholding tax at source.
8.1 Malaysia maintains its position on this paragraph in the case of payments of interest, royalties or fees for technical services to non-residents where the withholding tax at source has not been deducted.
8.2 Singapore maintains its position on this paragraph in the case of interest payments to non-residents where the withholding tax at source has not been deducted.
8.3 Argentina reserves the right not to include paragraph 4 of Article 24.
Paragraph 5
9. Brazil reserves the right to insert, after the words "other similar enterprises of the first-mentioned State", the words "the capital of which is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of a third State".
Paragraph 6
10. Albania, Argentina, Brazil, Bulgaria, Colombia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Romania, Serbia, Singapore, Thailand, Tunisia, Vietnam and Ukraine reserve the right to limit the scope of application of the Article to taxes covered by the Convention.
Positions on the Commentary
11. India, Malaysia and Singapore maintain their position with respect to the interpretation set out in paragraph 44.
11.1 Argentina does not agree with the interpretation in paragraph 44, since Argentina considers that paragraph 3 of Article 24 does not prevent a State from establishing, on any grounds, a preferential tax regime to which only residents may be entitled.
12. India reserves the right to add a paragraph explaining that this provision cannot be interpreted as preventing a Contracting State from taxing the profits of a permanent establishment which an enterprise of the other Contracting State has in the first-mentioned State at a tax rate higher than the rate of tax imposed on the profits of a similar enterprise of the first-mentioned Contracting State, and as being inconsistent with the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 7 (as it read before the 2010 Update of the Model Tax Convention).
Positions on the Article
Paragraph 1
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 25 (MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE) AND COMMENTARIES
1. The Philippines and Thailand maintain their positions on the last sentence of paragraph 1.
1.1 Kazakhstan maintains its position on the second sentence of paragraph 1 and reserves the right to supplement the paragraph with the following sentence: "In the case of judicial proceedings, the court's decision may not be reviewed by the competent authority of Kazakhstan".
Paragraph 2
2. Bulgaria, Thailand and the Philippines maintain their positions on the second sentence of paragraph 2.
These countries consider that the implementation of relief and refunds under a mutual agreement should remain subject to the time limits laid down in their domestic laws.
Paragraph 3
3. Thailand, Tunisia and Ukraine maintain their position on the second sentence of paragraph 3 on the grounds that, under their respective laws, they do not have the authority to eliminate double taxation in cases not provided for by the Convention.
Paragraph 4
4. Brazil, Malaysia, the People's Republic of China, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Ukraine reserve the right to omit the words "including through a joint commission consisting of themselves or their representatives".
Paragraph 5
4.1 Brazil, India, Indonesia, the People's Republic of China, Serbia, South Africa and Hong Kong, China reserve the right not to include paragraph 5 in their conventions.
4.2 Singapore reserves the right to make amendments to paragraph 5 of its agreements.
Positions on the Commentary
5. India does not agree with the interpretation given in paragraph 6.1, since it considers that a term not defined in the treaty can only have the meaning that it has under the law of the State applying the Convention and cannot be defined by the competent authorities under Article 25 when resolving, by mutual agreement, difficulties or doubts concerning the interpretation or application of the Convention.
6. Argentina considers that paragraph 1 of the Article does not oblige the competent authorities to initiate or accept a case for resolution through the mutual agreement procedure where the taxpayer claims that taxation is not in accordance with the Convention in relation to a hypothetical case rather than an actual case.
7. With respect to paragraph 25, India considers that the competent authorities may reach an agreement under Article 25 while a domestic legal action is pending. However, the taxpayer has the option of accepting or rejecting the decision resolving the dispute. If the taxpayer accepts the decision resolving the dispute, the taxpayer must withdraw the domestic legal action.
8. India does not agree with the opinion expressed in paragraph 42 that a taxpayer may be allowed to defer acceptance of a decision agreed upon as a result of the mutual agreement procedure until the court has delivered its judgment on that action.
9. With respect to paragraphs 86 and 87, since Brazil has a very strict policy of preserving tax secrecy, which prevents the disclosure of information relating to a third party's case, it considers that mutual agreement procedures should not be discussed and conducted by anyone other than the competent authorities of the Contracting States, which should make every effort to reach an appropriate bilateral solution.
10. India does not agree with the interpretation given in paragraph 14, since it disagrees with the view that the mutual agreement procedure may be initiated where taxation appears to be a probable risk. India considers that it may be initiated only when taxation constitutes an obvious risk.
11. India does not agree with the view that all circumstances in which a State denies access to the mutual agreement procedure must be expressly specified in the Convention. It considers that, in certain cases, the wording of Article 25 will allow access to the mutual agreement procedure to be denied.
Positions on the Article
1. [Deleted]
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 26 (EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION) AND COMMENTARIES
2. India reserves the right to include documents or certified copies of documents covered by this Article.
2.1 Morocco and Thailand reserve the right not to include the words "The exchange of information is not restricted by Articles 1 and 2" in paragraph 1.
Position on the Commentary
3. With respect to paragraph 10.3 of the Commentary, Hong Kong, China wishes to clarify its position concerning the exchange of information relating to periods preceding the entry into force of a bilateral agreement. In accordance with the requirements of its domestic law, Hong Kong, China will exchange information relating to tax periods only after the agreement has entered into force.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 28 (MEMBERS OF DIPLOMATIC MISSIONS AND CONSULAR POSTS) AND COMMENTARIES
Position on the Article
1. Given that Hong Kong, China is not a sovereign State but a Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China, Hong Kong, China reserves the right to replace "diplomatic missions" with "government missions" in this Article.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 29 (ENTITLEMENT TO BENEFITS) AND COMMENTARIES
1. India reserves the right to limit the granting of derivative benefits under paragraph 4 of Article 29 to equivalent beneficiaries who directly own shares in the resident.
2. Singapore maintains its position on paragraph 8.
3. Indonesia reserves the right to consider Article 29 in the context of bilateral negotiations.
POSITIONS ON ARTICLE 30 (TERRITORIAL EXTENSION) AND ITS COMMENTARIES
1. Indonesia, Malaysia, the People's Republic of China, Singapore and Thailand maintain their position on this Article.
COUNCIL,
ANNEX
OECD COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION CONCERNING THE MODEL TAX CONVENTION ON INCOME AND ON CAPITAL
(Adopted by the Council on 23 October 1997)
Having regard to Article 5(b) of the Convention on the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development of 14 December 1960;
Having regard to the Recommendation of the Council of 31 March 1994 concerning the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital [C(94)11/FINAL] and the Recommendation of the Council of 21 September 1995 amending the Annex to the previous Recommendation [C(95)132/FINAL];
Having regard to the report of the Committee on Fiscal Affairs of 24 June 1997 entitled "The 1997 Update of the Model Tax Convention" [DAFFE/CFA/WP1(97)10/REV2] (hereinafter referred to as the "1997 Report");
Considering the need to eliminate obstacles to the free movement of goods, services, capital and persons between countries which are created by international juridical double taxation, through the conclusion of appropriate conventions for this purpose;
Considering also the need to harmonise existing bilateral conventions on the basis of uniform principles, definitions, rules and methods, and to extend the existing network of such conventions to all Member countries and, where appropriate, to non-member countries;
Considering further the need to encourage the general application and interpretation of the provisions of tax conventions based on the provisions of the Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital (hereinafter referred to as the "Model Tax Convention");
Considering that the efforts undertaken in this direction by Member countries have already produced substantial results and that the proposed amendments to the Model Tax Convention will make it possible to confirm and extend existing international cooperation on tax matters;
Having regard to the Model Tax Convention and its Commentaries (as last amended in the 1997 Report), which may be amended from time to time;
I. RECOMMENDS that the governments of Member countries:
1. Continue their efforts to conclude bilateral tax conventions on income and on capital with those Member countries and, where appropriate, non-member countries with which they have not yet concluded such agreements, and review those existing conventions which no longer reflect modern needs;
2. When concluding new bilateral conventions or revising existing bilateral conventions, proceed in accordance with the Model Tax Convention and its Commentaries;
3. When applying and interpreting the provisions of their bilateral tax conventions based on these Articles, have their tax authorities be guided by the Commentaries on the Articles of the Model Tax Convention, as amended from time to time.
II. INVITES the governments of Member countries to continue to notify the Committee on Fiscal Affairs of their reservations on the Articles and observations on the Commentaries.
III. INSTRUCTS the Committee on Fiscal Affairs to continue its ongoing review of situations in which the provisions set out in the Model Tax Convention or its Commentaries may require changes in the light of experience gained by Member countries, and to make appropriate proposals for periodic updates.
IV. DECIDES to repeal Council Recommendations C(94)11/FINAL of 31 March 1994 and C(95)132/FINAL of 21 September 1995.
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT
The OECD is a unique forum where governments work together to address the economic, social and environmental challenges of globalisation. The OECD is also at the forefront of efforts to understand and help governments respond to new developments and challenges, such as corporate governance, the information economy and the challenges posed by an ageing population. The Organisation provides an environment in which governments can compare policy experiences, seek answers to common problems, identify best practices and work to coordinate domestic and international policies.
OECD Member countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Chile, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, Korea, Latvia, Luxembourg, Mexico, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovak Republic, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States. The European Union takes part in the work of the OECD.
OECD Publishing widely disseminates the results of the Organisation's collection of statistical data and research on economic, social and environmental issues, as well as Conventions, guidelines and standards agreed upon by its members.
OECD PUBLISHING, 2, rue André-Pascal, 75775 PARIS CEDEX 16
(23 2017 53 1 P) ISBN 978-92-64-28794-5-2017
MODEL TAX CONVENTION ON INCOME AND ON CAPITAL: CONDENSED VERSION
Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages