Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Decision / ON THE IMPOSITION OF A FINE FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT INFORMATION (DATA)

ON THE IMPOSITION OF A FINE FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT INFORMATION (DATA)

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

ON THE IMPOSITION OF A FINE FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT INFORMATION (DATA)

Decision of the Board of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated July 7, 2026 No. 83

The Board of the Eurasian Economic Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Commission), in accordance with subparagraph 4 of paragraph 10 and subparagraph 5 of paragraph 16 of the Protocol on General Principles and Rules of Competition (Annex No. 19 to the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union dated May 29, 2014) (hereinafter referred to as the Protocol), paragraph 17 of the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines for Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, approved by Decision No. 118 of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated December 17, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines), and paragraphs 44 and 45 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, approved by Decision No. 99 of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated November 23, 2012, considered the case concerning the failure to submit information (data) requested by the Commission (hereinafter referred to as the case).

Based on the results of reviewing the case materials, relying on the provisions of international treaties and acts in the field of competition forming part of the law of the Eurasian Economic Union, having examined the factual circumstances of the case under consideration and the findings of the commission reviewing the case, set out in the descriptive and reasoning parts of this Decision in accordance with the Annex, and guided by the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines, the Board of the Commission decided:

  1. To recognize:

    a) the omission of Individual Entrepreneur Kan Bogdan Alekseevich (personal data not published) (hereinafter referred to as IE Kan B.A.), expressed in the failure to submit information (data) in response to the Commission's requests, as a violation of the provisions of paragraph 13 of the Protocol, liability for which is provided for in subparagraph 5 of paragraph 16 of the Protocol;

    b) the absence of grounds for terminating the consideration of the case in respect of the person specified in subparagraph "a" of this paragraph.

  2. In accordance with subparagraph 5 of paragraph 16 of the Protocol and the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines, to impose a fine on IE Kan B.A. in the amount of 26,666 Russian rubles and 67 kopecks.

The fine imposed by this Decision shall be paid in accordance with the procedure established by paragraphs 17 and 18 of the Protocol (bank details for payment of fines by business entities (market participants) registered in the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan: budget classification code – 204176, payment purpose code – 913).

  1. The Commission shall inform IE Kan B.A. of the necessity:

    a) pursuant to the second paragraph of paragraph 171 of the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines, to pay the fine specified in paragraph 2 of this Decision in full no later than 60 calendar days from the date this Decision enters into force. In the event of failure to pay the fine within the specified period, the Commission shall take measures aimed at enforcing this Decision in accordance with paragraph 18 of the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines;

    b) pursuant to paragraph 45 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, to notify the Commission of payment of the fine specified in paragraph 2 of this Decision within 30 calendar days from the date of expiry of the period stipulated in subparagraph "a" of this paragraph.

  2. This Decision may be appealed in accordance with the established procedure before the Court of the Eurasian Economic Union.
  3. This Decision shall enter into force upon the expiry of 30 calendar days from the date of its official publication.
Chairman of the Board of the Eurasian Economic CommissionB. Sagintayev
 ANNEX to Decision No. 83 of the Board of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated July 7, 2026

DESCRIPTIVE AND REASONING PARTS

OF DECISION No. 83 OF THE BOARD OF THE EURASIAN ECONOMIC COMMISSION DATED JULY 7, 2026

In accordance with subparagraph 3 of paragraph 10 of the Protocol on General Principles and Rules of Competition (Annex No. 19 to the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union dated May 29, 2014) (hereinafter referred to respectively as the Protocol and the Treaty), in connection with a violation of the provisions of paragraph 13 of the Protocol, the Eurasian Economic Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Commission), by Determination No. 42/opr dated October 14, 2025, initiated a case against Individual Entrepreneur Kan Bogdan Alekseevich (personal data not published) (hereinafter referred to as IE Kan B.A.) on the grounds of failure to submit information (data) (hereinafter referred to as the case) and appointed a commission to review it, consisting of the following members:

Chairman of the commission Maximov S.V. – Director of the Department of Antimonopoly Regulation of the Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Department);

Deputy Chairman of the commission Ivantey I.A. – Deputy Director of the Department;

Members of the commission:

Sumenkov S.S. – Head of the Division for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition of the Department;

Zhusupbekova Sh.T. – Deputy Head of the Division for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition of the Department;

Volkov A.A. – Adviser to the Division for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition of the Department;

Gerdt E.E. – Adviser to the Division for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition of the Department.

Persons participating in the review of the case: representatives of the authorized bodies of the Member States of the Eurasian Economic Union (hereinafter referred to as the Member States), whose competence includes the implementation and (or) conduct of competition (antimonopoly) policy – Baymakanova A.T., Belov A.V., Goloviznina P.O., Morozova M.S., Nugmanov A.M., Sklyarov Y.V., Usova D.E. and Shinybayev T.Kh.

Respondent – IE Kan B.A.

Due to the need to obtain additional information for making a decision, the period for reviewing the case was extended by 60 working days, as recorded in Determination No. 2/opr dated January 15, 2026.

In accordance with paragraph 23 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases of Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, approved by Decision No. 99 of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated November 23, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the Procedure for Reviewing Cases), on April 9, 2026, the Chairman of the commission reviewing the case, Maximov S.V., announced the completion of the review of the case.

The following was established as a result of the review of the case.

On March 19, 2024, the Commission received a letter dated March 19, 2024 No. w/n (incoming No. 4391 dated March 19, 2024) containing an application from the Limited Liability Company Scientific and Production Association "Company "SIVIK" (Russian Federation) concerning possible signs of violations of the general rules of competition in the cross-border market for garage equipment for motor vehicles and trailers (hereinafter referred to as the application).

In connection with the consideration of the application, for the purpose of exercising its powers to suppress violations of the general rules of competition in cross-border markets, and guided by paragraph 13 of the Protocol, the Commission requested IE Kan B.A., by letter dated July 12, 2024 No. 22-324, to submit the necessary information (data) to the Commission by July 25, 2024 (postal identifier No. RS021132418RU – unsuccessful delivery attempts were made on July 31, August 15, August 23 and September 18, 2024, as a result of which the postal item was returned to the Commission), and by letter dated September 2, 2024 No. 22-427, by September 13, 2024 (postal identifier No. RS021132979RU – delivered to the addressee on October 9, 2024). At the same time, the Commission informed IE Kan B.A. of liability for failure to submit or late submission of information (data) provided for in Section XVIII of the Treaty and the Protocol, including failure to submit information (data) at the request of the Commission.

No information was submitted by IE Kan B.A. in response to the Commission's request.

Within the framework of the consideration of the case initiated by Determination No. 7/opr dated March 28, 2025, concerning a violation of paragraph 2 of Article 76 of the Treaty in respect of Individual Entrepreneur "Nik Pro" (Republic of Kazakhstan), following the consideration of the application and the conduct of an investigation, the Commission, guided by paragraph 13 of the Protocol and paragraph 21 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases, requested IE Kan B.A., by letter dated June 20, 2025 No. 22-282 (with copies of the Determination on Postponing the Consideration of a Case Concerning a Violation of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets dated June 20, 2025 No. 27/opr, an extract from the minutes of the meeting of the commission reviewing the case concerning a violation of the general rules of competition in cross-border markets dated June 18, 2025, and the Commission's letters dated July 12, 2024 No. 22-324 and September 2, 2024 No. 22-427 attached thereto), to submit to the Commission, within 5 working days from the date of receipt thereof (by July 21, 2025, taking into account delivery to the addressee on July 14, 2025, according to the tracking information for the postal item with identifier No. RS021137361RU), the information (data) previously requested by the Commission's letters dated July 12, 2024 No. 22-324 and September 2, 2024 No. 22-427, as well as information concerning the application of License Agreement dated April 23, 2024 No. 04-2024578/11-21, under which IE Kan B.A. was granted the right to use the "SIVIK" trademark in accordance with Certificate No. 73477 dated May 24, 2021.

At the same time, the Commission informed IE Kan B.A. of liability for failure to submit or late submission of information (data) provided for in Section XVIII of the Treaty and the Protocol, including failure to submit information (data) at the request of the Commission.

However, the information (data) was not submitted by IE Kan B.A. within the period established by the Commission.

Due to the failure to receive the requested information (data) and the expiry of the deadline for responding to letter dated June 20, 2025 No. 22-282, the Commission, guided by paragraph 13 of the Protocol, once again requested IE Kan B.A., by letter dated August 21, 2025 No. 22-391 (with copies of the Commission's letter dated June 20, 2025 No. 22-282 and Determination No. 36/opr dated August 21, 2025 on Postponing the Consideration of a Case Concerning a Violation of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets attached thereto), to submit to the Commission, within 5 working days from the date of receipt thereof (by September 16, 2025, taking into account delivery to the addressee on September 9, 2025, according to the tracking information for the postal item with identifier No. RS228200373RU), the information (data) previously requested by the Commission's letters dated July 12, 2024 No. 22-324, September 2, 2024 No. 22-427 and June 20, 2025 No. 22-282.

At the same time, IE Kan B.A. was informed by the Commission of liability for failure to submit or late submission of information (data) provided for in Section XVIII of the Treaty and the Protocol, including failure to submit information (data) at the request of the Commission.

However, the information (data) was not submitted within the period established by the Commission.

As a result, by Determination No. 42/opr dated October 14, 2025 (postal identifier No. RS228200775RU – delivered to the addressee on November 5, 2025), the Commission initiated a case against IE Kan B.A. on the grounds of failure to submit information (data) at the request of the Commission set out in the Commission's letters dated June 20, 2025 No. 22-282 and August 21, 2025 No. 22-391.

Within the framework of the meeting of the commission reviewing the case, in Determination No. 49/opr dated November 12, 2025 (letter dated November 13, 2025 No. 22-535), the Commission, guided by paragraph 13 of the Protocol and paragraph 21 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases, requested IE Kan B.A. to submit the information (data) previously requested by the Commission's letters dated June 20, 2025 No. 22-282 and August 21, 2025 No. 22-391, namely the information requested by the Commission's letters dated July 12, 2024 No. 22-324 and September 2, 2024 No. 22-427, as well as information concerning the application of License Agreement dated April 23, 2024 No. 04-2024578/11-21, under which IE Kan B.A. was granted the right to use the "SIVIK" trademark in accordance with Certificate No. 73477 dated May 24, 2021. By the same determination, the Commission requested IE Kan B.A. to submit a response stating whether he acknowledged or denied the existence of a violation in his actions (omissions), together with the legal justification for the relevant position.

No response from IE Kan B.A. was received by the commission reviewing the case.

Within the framework of the review of the case, the following determinations were sent to IE Kan B.A.: dated November 12, 2025 No. 49/opr (sent by letter dated November 13, 2025 No. 22-535, postal identifier No. RS228201113RU – unsuccessful delivery attempts were made on December 15, 19, 23 and 24, 2025, and January 5, 8 and 13, 2026, as a result of which the postal item was returned to the Commission); dated December 10, 2025 No. 53/opr (sent by letter dated December 11, 2025 No. 22-569, postal identifier No. RS228201263RU – unsuccessful delivery attempts were made on January 8, 13 and 20, 2026, as a result of which the postal item was returned to the Commission); dated January 15, 2026 No. 2/opr (sent by letter dated January 15, 2026 No. 22-9, postal identifier No. RS228201422RU – unsuccessful delivery attempts were made on February 5 and March 4, 2026, as a result of which the postal item was returned to the Commission); dated February 25, 2026 No. 10/opr (sent by letter dated February 26, 2026 No. 22-130, postal identifier No. RS228201855RU – unsuccessful delivery attempts were made on March 17, 25 and 27, 2026, as a result of which the postal item was returned to the Commission); dated March 17, 2026 No. 14/opr (sent by letter dated March 18, 2026 No. 22-169, postal identifier No. RS228202365RU – an unsuccessful delivery attempt was made on April 8, 2026); dated March 30, 2026 No. 17/opr (sent by letter dated March 31, 2026 No. 22-189, postal identifier No. RS228202621RU – an unsuccessful delivery attempt was made on April 16, 2026).

In implementation of the reasoned submission of the Commission dated February 18, 2026 No. EM-375/22, sent on the basis of Determination No. 53/opr dated December 10, 2025 for the purpose of ensuring compliance with the procedural rights of IE Kan B.A., the Agency for Protection and Development of Competition of the Republic of Kazakhstan, according to its response dated April 7, 2026 No. 01-14/2033 (incoming No. 6928 dated April 22, 2026), conducted two visits on February 24 and 25, 2026 to the address: (personal data not published) for the purpose of delivering copies of the Commission's letters dated November 13, 2025 No. 22-535 and December 11, 2025 No. 22-569 to IE Kan B.A.; however, the addressee was absent from the specified address.

Taking into account the provisions of subparagraph 7 of paragraph 10 and paragraph 13 of the Protocol, paragraph 1313 of the Procedure for Reviewing Applications (Materials) Concerning Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, approved by Decision No. 97 of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated November 23, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the Procedure for Reviewing Applications), and paragraph 21 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases, when reviewing an application, conducting an investigation, reviewing a case and considering the issue of issuing a warning, the authorized structural unit of the Commission requests the necessary information, including confidential information, from state authorities, local self-government bodies, other bodies or organizations performing their functions in the Member States, as well as legal entities and individuals. In this case, the relevant request shall be deemed to have been sent on behalf of the Commission. Business entities (market participants), non-profit organizations, state authorities, local self-government bodies, other bodies or organizations performing their functions (their officials) of the Member States, and individuals are obliged to submit to the Commission, upon its request and within the established time limits, the information, documents, data and explanations necessary for the Commission in accordance with the powers vested in it.

Thus, within the framework of reviewing the application and the case concerning a violation of the general rules of competition in cross-border markets in respect of Individual Entrepreneur "Nik Pro" (Republic of Kazakhstan), in accordance with the Procedure for Reviewing Applications and the Procedure for Reviewing Cases, while exercising its powers to suppress violations of the general rules of competition in cross-border markets by business entities (market participants) of the Member States and guided by the provisions of the Treaty and the aforementioned procedures, the Commission requested the relevant information (data) from IE Kan B.A.

However, the information (data) requested by the Commission was not submitted by IE Kan B.A. within the time limits established by the Commission. The said information (data) was also not submitted during the review of the case.

The commission reviewing the case considers that the omission of IE Kan B.A. was expressed in the fact that, despite having the opportunity to comply with the provisions of the law of the Eurasian Economic Union regarding the obligation to submit information (data) in response to the Commission's requests, IE Kan B.A. failed to take the necessary and sufficient measures to comply with them, which makes it possible to conclude that IE Kan B.A., through his omission, violated the provisions of paragraph 13 of the Protocol, namely, failed to submit information (data) in response to the Commission's requests.

Within the framework of the review of the case, IE Kan B.A. was provided with the opportunity to exercise all the rights stipulated by paragraph 13 of the Procedure for Reviewing Cases. In addition, he was requested to provide explanations regarding the case, as well as his position on whether he agreed or disagreed with the fact of a violation of the provisions of paragraph 13 of the Protocol. However, IE Kan B.A. did not submit explanations regarding the case or his position on whether he agreed or disagreed with the existence of a violation of the provisions of paragraph 13 of the Protocol in his omission.

IE Kan B.A. and (or) his representative did not participate in the meetings of the commission reviewing the case and did not submit any motions to postpone the date of the meetings of the commission reviewing the case.

There is no information regarding any valid reason for the non-participation of IE Kan B.A. and (or) his representative in the meetings of the commission reviewing the case.

No circumstances preventing IE Kan B.A. from submitting the information (data) requested by the Commission were identified.

According to subparagraph 5 of paragraph 16 of the Protocol, the Commission, in accordance with the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines for Violations of the General Rules of Competition in Cross-Border Markets, approved by Decision No. 118 of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission dated December 17, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines), imposes fines for failure to submit to the Commission information (data) provided for in Section XVIII of the Treaty and the Protocol, including failure to submit information (data) at the request of the Commission, in the following amounts: for individuals – from 10,000 to 15,000 Russian rubles; for officials and individual entrepreneurs – from 10,000 to 60,000 Russian rubles; for legal entities – from 150,000 to 1,000,000 Russian rubles.

IE Kan B.A. failed to submit to the Commission the information (data) requested by the Commission for the first time. In accordance with Annex No. 2 to the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines, this circumstance is taken into account as a mitigating circumstance when calculating the amount of the fine.

No other mitigating circumstances or aggravating circumstances provided for in Annex No. 2 to the Methodology for Calculating and the Procedure for Imposing Fines, which are taken into account when calculating the amount of the fine, were identified.

 Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Statement Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages