Promotion and Protection of All Human Rights, Civil, Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Including the Right to Development (General Assembly)
Report of the Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, and on the right to non-discrimination in this context, Raquel Rolnik. Human Rights Council, 19 January 2011
Addendum
Mission to Kazakhstan* **
Summary
The Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, and on the right to non-discrimination in this context, conducted an official visit to Kazakhstan from 6 to 13 September 2010. The purpose of the mission was to gather first-hand information on the progress made in the implementation of the right to adequate housing and other related human rights in Kazakhstan. In particular, the Special Rapporteur focused on the negative consequences of the global economic and financial crises for the realization of the right to adequate housing and on the mass evictions or displacement of individuals and communities living in the cities of Astana and Almaty or in the surrounding areas. During her visit to Astana and Almaty, the Special Rapporteur met with a wide range of representatives of State and non-State actors and heard the testimonies of several individuals concerning alleged violations of their right to adequate housing.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the significant progress made by the Government in implementing the right to adequate housing at the national level. The measures adopted include, in particular, the incorporation of specific provisions relating to adequate housing into the Constitution, the adoption of a number of legislative and policy measures, namely the 1997 Law on Housing Relations, the State Housing Construction Programme for 2008–2010, and the development of incentive measures such as a housing credit system, subsidies for housing rental payments and the allocation of land plots to individuals and families belonging to low-income and disadvantaged categories of the population.
Despite the progress achieved, a number of key challenges remain. The legal and regulatory framework in the housing sector, and in particular national legislation concerning forced evictions, does not fully comply with existing international human rights standards, such as the general comments of the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Basic Principles and Guidelines on Development-Based Evictions and Displacement. National courts do not apply the provisions of international treaties in practice and do not refer to international human rights standards. Informal settlements are frequently demolished and forced evictions take place without prior notice, any judicial control or supervision, or the provision of adequate compensation or alternative housing. Many citizens and families have been seriously affected by the financial and mortgage crisis. A large number of persons who had invested in shared construction projects were defrauded by private construction companies, which left the country with their savings without completing the construction of residential buildings, while others were evicted or faced the threat of eviction because they were unable to repay loans and mortgage debts. Despite the emergency measures adopted by the State to mitigate the negative consequences of the financial crisis, 42,000 persons who had invested in shared construction projects are still waiting for their apartments.
In conclusion, the Special Rapporteur makes a number of recommendations intended to assist the Government in its efforts to ensure the effective realization of the right to adequate housing.
* The summary of the present document is being circulated in all official languages. The document itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is being circulated only in the language in which it was submitted and in Russian.** Submitted late.
Annex
Report of the Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, and on the right to non-discrimination in this context, on her mission to Kazakhstan (6–13 September 2010)
Contents
I. Introduction
The Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, and on the right to non-discrimination in this context, conducted an official visit to Kazakhstan from 6 to 13 September 2010.
The purpose of the visit was to gather first-hand information on the progress made in the implementation of the right to adequate housing and other related human rights in Kazakhstan. In particular, the Special Rapporteur decided to focus on:
a) the mass evictions or displacement of individuals and communities living in the cities of Astana and Almaty or in the surrounding areas, without the provision of appropriate protection and compensation, and the measures taken by the State to ensure the protection of affected individuals and communities against development-based evictions in connection with urban redevelopment programmes;
b) the impact of the global economic and financial crises on the realization of the right to adequate housing and the measures taken by the State within its jurisdiction to protect the most vulnerable individuals, families and communities from the negative consequences of the crises.
During her visit, the Special Rapporteur met with a number of senior representatives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Agency for Construction and Housing and Communal Services, the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, the local executive authorities (akimats) of Astana and Almaty, the Departments of Internal Affairs of Astana and Almaty, the Supreme Court, the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Ombudsman), the Commission on Human Rights under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the National Commission on Women and Family Affairs under the President. She also heard the testimonies of several individuals concerning alleged violations of their right to adequate housing and met with a large number of representatives of civil society, including social movements and non-governmental organizations, in Astana and Almaty and the surrounding areas.
The Special Rapporteur would like to express her appreciation to the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan for the invitation and for the assistance provided to her throughout the visit. The issuance, in July 2009, of a standing invitation to all special procedures mandate holders, as well as the openness demonstrated by the Government in the period preceding the mission and during its conduct, demonstrate its commitment to promoting and protecting the right to adequate housing and its willingness to cooperate with the international community in addressing the outstanding challenges facing the country in this area. The Special Rapporteur would also like to thank the staff of the Regional Office of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) in Bishkek and the United Nations Development Programme in the Republic of Kazakhstan for their valuable cooperation and assistance in organizing the programme of the mission.
II. Housing situation
In recent years, Kazakhstan has become a powerful economic force in Central Asia, owing to its considerable reserves of oil and natural gas. Economic growth has also ensured the development of other sectors, in particular the construction and banking sectors.
In 1995, the Government decided to move the capital of the newly independent State from Almaty to Astana. This decision was accompanied by the allocation of substantial amounts from the State budget for the creation of a modern, world-class capital. In turn, large-scale urban redevelopment and improvement programmes attracted a large number of internal migrants who moved to the new capital from other regions of the country in search of employment in the construction sector and with the aim of improving their standard of living. According to the population census conducted in 2009, between 1999 and 2009 the population of Astana increased from 328,341 to 613,006. Almaty remains the largest city in Kazakhstan, with a population of approximately 1,365,632 in 2010. Like Astana, Almaty also attracted a significant number of migrant workers who moved to the country's main economic centre following the economic crisis that occurred after the collapse of the Soviet Union. According to official estimates, the rate of internal migration from rural to urban areas exceeds 300,000 people per year.
Owing to its strong economic performance, Kazakhstan has also begun to receive a large number of migrant workers from other Central Asian countries and China. According to official estimates, between half a million and one million foreign workers are present in Kazakhstan, although other sources indicate that the number of migrants is closer to two or three million. Many of these migrants are employed in the construction sector.
As a result of such large-scale migration, the supply of housing and urban land in the country's two main economic centres has decreased significantly, leading to the emergence of a number of informal settlements on the outskirts of both cities. Owing to their informal nature, reliable statistical data on the number of people living in these settlements are unavailable. In some cases, such housing has been built in protected areas or in areas prone to flooding or earthquakes.
In most cases, the informal structures mentioned above lack basic amenities such as kitchens, toilets, electricity and running water, and the people living in them are constantly exposed to the threat of forced eviction by State authorities. The absence of a legal address effectively prevents residents of informal settlements from registering their place of residence, which is an important legal requirement for obtaining a number of social services provided by the State, including social housing.
Since independence, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan has fundamentally changed its housing policy, moving away from an exclusively State-based housing policy towards a new approach under which the State seeks to facilitate home ownership by creating favourable financial conditions to attract foreign investment, as well as banks and financial institutions. In order to stimulate housing construction, the State has made considerable efforts in the area of planning to allocate suitable urban land to private developers and expand access to mortgage lending, thereby enabling citizens to build their own houses and apartments or purchase property in residential complexes constructed with funds from private investors.
The total volume of the housing stock increased from 252.7 million m² in 2004 to 267.8 million m² in 2008. In 2008, the urban housing stock amounted to 153.4 million m² (57 per cent of the total volume). Most new construction is carried out by private developers. The State housing stock decreased from 7.8 million m² in 2004 to 6.4 million m² in 2008. In rural areas, only 1 per cent of the rural housing stock (1.2 million m² in 2008) is State-owned¹. The available data on the structure of the country's housing stock do not, in themselves, provide an indication of the extent of the housing deficit, that is, the number of citizens and families who have no housing or live in housing that does not meet minimum sanitation and safety requirements.
The average amount of total living space per capita has steadily increased over the past decade, from 16.6 m² per person in 2002 to 18.1 m² per person in 2008. Nevertheless, this indicator in rural areas is 16 per cent lower than in urban areas (16.4 m² and 19.7 m² per person, respectively).
The proportion of households connected to the water supply system increased from 52.4 per cent in 2002 to 58.9 per cent in 2008. During the same period, the proportion of households with access to centralized sewage systems and wastewater treatment facilities increased from 41.3 per cent to 47.4 per cent. However, disaggregated statistical data indicate significant inequalities between urban and rural areas; living standards in the latter are substantially lower than in urban areas.
As of October 2010, 10,958 persons belonging to low-income and socially protected categories of the population were living in social housing constructed by local executive authorities or purchased from private developers in accordance with the State Housing Construction Programme for 2005–2007. During the same period, 36,656 families belonging to priority categories received housing constructed with the support of the State housing credit system.
Between 2005 and 2010, the State allocated 49.7 billion tenge (approximately US$331.3 million) for the construction of social housing. During the same period, 150.1 billion tenge (approximately US$1 billion) was allocated from the State budget for the construction of mortgage housing for priority categories of the population.
Like many other countries, Kazakhstan was seriously affected by the international financial crisis. As a result of the State's radical deregulation, which enabled families without stable incomes to obtain mortgage loans, the financial crisis led to the collapse of the entire banking system. According to World Bank data, the annual growth rate of the economy of Kazakhstan, which had reached almost 10 per cent between 2000 and 2007, fell to 3.3 per cent in 2008 and 1.2 per cent in 2009.
The construction sector was one of the first to experience the negative consequences of the global economic downturn. Many construction companies were forced to close, leaving 450 unfinished construction projects. According to Government data, more than 62,000 persons who had invested in shared construction projects were affected by the financial crisis. Approximately 16,000 such investors were defrauded by private construction companies, which left the country with their savings without completing construction, while others were evicted or faced the threat of eviction because they were unable to repay loans and mortgage debts. As a result of the bankruptcy of a large number of enterprises, the real estate crisis affected the entire economy.
The State invested a total of 433.441 billion tenge (approximately US$2.8 billion) to assist persons affected by the financial crisis and facilitate the completion of housing projects. In particular, it established the Samruk-Kazyna Real Estate Fund to provide funding to construction companies in order to complete projects whose implementation had slowed down or stopped because of the financial crisis. A total of US$1.1 billion was allocated from this national fund, including US$937 million in Astana and US$500 million in Almaty.
As of October 2010, thanks to the funds allocated by the State for these purposes, 37 housing construction projects had been completed and 8,265 investors had been able to receive their apartments and houses. However, as of November 2010, construction had still not been completed on 87 buildings, including 42 housing projects in Astana, 26 in Almaty and another 17 in other regions. As a result, almost 20,000 investors were still waiting for their apartments. The Government planned to complete the construction of 51 residential complexes by the end of 2010 (9,932 investors), including 35 projects in Astana and 7 in Almaty.
¹ State Agency for Statistics, Kazakhstan in 2008, Astana, 2009.
III. Legislative and institutional framework
A. International obligations
Kazakhstan is a party to seven major international human rights treaties, including the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Under these treaties, the State has undertaken to take appropriate legislative, administrative, judicial and other measures, to the maximum of its available resources, with a view to progressively achieving the full realization of the right to adequate housing. Such steps include the adoption of legislative and other measures to prevent forced evictions carried out by State authorities or private individuals without appropriate safeguards, adequate compensation or the provision of alternative housing and, where necessary, the imposition of penalties for such acts.
Kazakhstan has signed, although not yet ratified, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which contains provisions concerning the right of persons with disabilities to an adequate standard of living for themselves and their families, including adequate housing, and the identification and elimination of obstacles and barriers to accessibility, including in relation to housing.
Kazakhstan is not a party to the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families, which recognizes, inter alia, the right of migrant workers to housing, including housing provided under social security programmes, on an equal basis with nationals of the State of employment. Kazakhstan has confirmed that it does not intend to ratify the Convention in the near future owing to the far-reaching financial implications that would arise from its implementation².
In accordance with article 4, paragraph 3, of the Constitution, international treaties ratified by Kazakhstan take precedence over national legislation and may be applied directly within the national legal system, except where their application requires the adoption of a law. On 10 July 2008, the Supreme Court adopted a normative resolution on the direct application of international treaties by national courts and tribunals, requiring judges to be guided by the provisions of international treaties to which Kazakhstan is a party³.
² A/HRC/14/10/Add.1, paragraph 1.³ A/HRC/WG.67/KAZ/1, paragraph 22.
B. Legislative and strategic framework
The Constitution, adopted by national referendum on 30 August 1995, has the highest legal force and direct effect throughout the territory of the Republic. Articles 25 and 26 of the Constitution contain provisions relating to housing. Under these provisions, housing is inviolable and citizens may not be deprived of their homes except on the basis of a court decision. In order to meet the housing needs of citizens, the Constitution provides that housing shall be made available to citizens in need of housing from State housing funds at an affordable price, in accordance with the standards established by law.
The National Human Rights Action Plan for 2009–2012 is aimed at strengthening the national system for the promotion and protection of human rights and raising public awareness of human rights and the mechanisms for their protection. The Plan identifies a set of specific measures to address gaps in national legislation and practice and improve coordination among State institutions and non-governmental organizations working in the field of human rights protection.
Kazakhstan has adopted a number of legislative and regulatory acts on housing matters. The Law on Housing Relations (Law No. 94 of 16 April 1997) is the principal regulatory instrument in the housing sector. Other relevant laws include:
a) the Law on Shared Participation in Housing Construction (Law No. 180 of 7 July 2006), which aims to protect the rights of investors in shared construction projects by increasing the responsibility of private developers in the field of shared participation in housing construction;
b) the Law on Individual Housing Construction (Law No. 213 of 3 November 1994), which aims to stimulate the construction of residential houses by allocating land plots to individual developers and improving the engineering and communications infrastructure of residential construction areas;
c) the Law on Housing Construction Savings in the Republic of Kazakhstan (Law No. 110 of 7 December 2000), which establishes a system for providing mortgage housing on preferential terms in order to improve housing affordability for individuals and households belonging to priority categories of citizens (for example, young families with children).
Only citizens are entitled to purchase housing or receive social housing or housing subsidies. In accordance with article 67 of the Law on Housing Relations, housing from the State housing stock or housing rented by a local executive authority from the private housing stock is provided to the following categories of persons and families in need of housing:
a) persons with disabilities and veterans of the Great Patriotic War;
b) persons belonging to low-income and socially protected categories of the population, such as elderly pensioners, orphans and children left without parental care, as well as large families and single-parent families;
c) certain categories of public officials, such as employees of budget-funded organizations and military personnel.
Persons belonging to the above-mentioned categories are entitled to State housing if:
a) they do not own housing anywhere in the territory of the Republic;
b) they have not previously received housing from the State housing stock;
c) they live in dilapidated housing that does not meet the applicable sanitary and technical standards;
d) two or more families live in adjoining, non-isolated residential premises;
e) a family member suffers from certain chronic illnesses.
Under State legislation, low-income families are defined as families whose total monthly income per family member is below the minimum subsistence level, set at 14,952 tenge (approximately US$99) per family member.
Persons recognized as being in need of housing may submit applications for social housing only at their place of residence. Local executive authorities maintain separate registers of the following categories of persons and families recognized as being in need of housing: persons with disabilities and war veterans; low-income and socially protected families; certain categories of employees of budget-funded organizations; and persons living in dilapidated housing. Social housing is provided in accordance with the order established by waiting lists, starting from the date of submission of the application; however, persons with disabilities and war veterans have priority over other categories of families recognized as being in need of housing. Social housing is provided at a rate of no less than 15 m² and no more than 18 m² per person, but not less than a one-room apartment.
Where housing-related expenses exceed 10–15 per cent of a family's total income, local executive authorities also provide housing allowances from the local budget to assist low-income families in covering rent or housing maintenance costs and paying utility bills.
The State Housing Construction Programme for 2008–2010 is aimed at expanding the State housing stock for low-income and socially protected categories of the population by creating favourable conditions, including tax incentives, for attracting private investment in housing construction and promoting public-private partnerships. The Programme provides that at least 100 apartments must be allocated annually in each region, including in the cities of Astana and Almaty, to representatives of low-income and socially protected categories⁴. Such apartments are then distributed among families recognized as being in need of housing in accordance with the Law on Housing Relations.
The above-mentioned Programme is also aimed at facilitating the implementation of the Law on Housing Construction Savings in the Republic of Kazakhstan through the establishment of a housing credit system that will enable local executive authorities to construct social housing financed from the national budget. The housing credit system is intended to facilitate access to adequate housing for persons with average incomes who are able to purchase housing at market prices. Under this system, families recognized as being in need of housing may obtain a housing loan on a long-term basis at an interest rate not exceeding 4 per cent. In order to ensure transparency of procedures and oversight of the fair distribution of housing, the law establishes criteria for selecting applicants for loans and defines income thresholds.
The Programme identifies the following priority categories of the population:
a) young families with children in which both spouses are under 29 years of age;
b) single-parent families in which divorced or widowed parents under 29 years of age are raising children;
c) public officials;
d) certain categories of employees of State institutions who are not public officials (for example, employees of State enterprises).
In addition, Kazakhstan has taken measures to provide housing for rent at affordable prices to low-income families. On the basis of the Law on Amendments and Additions to Certain Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the Development of the Rental Housing Sector, dated 7 July 2006, local executive authorities are entitled to rent residential premises from the private housing stock for subsequent provision to low-income families in need of housing. The Law also provides specific tax incentives for developers and owners of rented buildings in order to reduce the cost of such rental agreements.
Other incentives used by Kazakhstan to improve access to adequate housing include the allocation of land plots for the construction of residential houses and the establishment of a housing construction savings system to facilitate access to mortgage loans for the purchase of housing. Akimats also implement programmes to resettle residents of informal settlements or transform such settlements into formal ones by issuing documents confirming ownership rights and ensuring access to social services.
In 1995, President Nazarbayev announced the launch of a programme to encourage oralmans (foreign citizens or stateless persons of Kazakh ethnicity who permanently reside outside the Republic of Kazakhstan) to return to their historical homeland. The 1997 Law on Population Migration established the legal framework for this policy, which provides for fixed quotas. Repatriates enjoy a number of benefits, including the provision of land plots, assistance in finding employment, access to education and the right to pension provision, social insurance and social benefits, although persons returning outside the quota system face certain restrictions in obtaining such assistance.
⁴ Presidential Decree No. 383 of 20 August 2007.
C. Institutional framework
Kazakhstan is a unitary State with a presidential form of government. Administratively, it consists of 14 regions and two cities of republican significance (the capital, Astana, and Almaty).
The President is the Head of State. He determines the main directions of the State's domestic and foreign policy and represents Kazakhstan within the country and in international relations. He is the guarantor of the unity of the people, the inviolability of the Constitution, and the rights and freedoms of individuals and citizens.
Parliament is the highest representative body of the Republic and exercises legislative functions. It consists of two chambers: the Senate (the upper chamber) and the Mazhilis (the lower chamber).
The Government exercises executive power, heads the system of executive bodies and directs their activities. The Government is a collegial body and is directly accountable to the President of the Republic and, in cases provided for by the Constitution, to Parliament.
The judiciary consists of local and regional courts and the Supreme Court at the national level. The Supreme Court is the highest judicial body in Kazakhstan. All judges, except members of the Supreme Court, are appointed by the President.
The Constitutional Council reviews laws and regulations to determine whether they comply with the Constitution. It also provides official interpretations of constitutional provisions. Two members of the Constitutional Council are appointed by the Senate and the Mazhilis, respectively, while the remaining two members and the Chairperson are appointed by the President.
Akimats are responsible for implementing State policy at the local level. They develop socio-economic development plans and local budgets, manage municipal property and exercise other powers set out in the Constitution and legislation. Akims of regions, cities of republican significance and the capital are appointed by the President with the approval of the local representative body (maslikhat).
The State Agency for Construction and Housing and Communal Services is the central executive body responsible for planning and implementing legislation and policy in the fields of architecture, urban planning and construction, and housing and communal services. In addition, it ensures the development of the draft general scheme for the organization of the territory of the Republic and carries out urban planning assessments relating to the development and implementation of master plans for the development of the capital, cities of republican significance and cities of regional significance with a population of more than 100,000.
The akimat develops and implements master plans for the development of cities. In implementing such plans, the akimat identifies land plots to be allocated for State needs and prepares the expropriation act. In addition, the akimat receives applications for the provision of social housing. It supervises the construction of State housing and private houses for rent to low-income families in need of housing, and maintains and regularly reviews waiting lists. The akimat also contributes to improving access to adequate housing by facilitating the legalization of informal settlements and allocating land plots for private housing construction.
The protection of human rights and freedoms is carried out within the framework of the legislative, executive and judicial branches of government. The independence of the judiciary is proclaimed in article 77 of the Constitution. In addition to judicial protection, all citizens have the right to submit complaints to two national institutions: the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Ombudsman) and the Commission on Human Rights under the President. Neither of these institutions was established in accordance with the Paris Principles relating to the status of national institutions⁵.
The main task of the Office of the Ombudsman, established in 2002, is to consider, within the jurisdiction of the State, complaints from citizens concerning alleged human rights violations committed by officials and State institutions, and to make recommendations regarding the adoption of appropriate measures to eliminate the consequences of such violations⁶. The relevant officials and State institutions are required to duly consider the Ombudsman's recommendations and report within one month on the measures taken to remedy the violations. Between 2003 and 2009, the Ombudsman received a total of 11,879 written and oral complaints.
In 2009, the Ombudsman received 88 communications (5.3 per cent of the total number) concerning alleged violations of the right to adequate housing. During the first half of 2010, the Ombudsman considered 47 housing-related communications. Most complaints concerned violations relating to shared participation in construction and forced evictions for State needs.
The Commission on Human Rights under the President is an advisory body established in 1994 to assist the Head of State in exercising his constitutional powers to protect human rights and fundamental freedoms. In carrying out this function, the Commission may consider individual petitions addressed to the President concerning alleged human rights violations and may issue recommendations to State officials and State institutions regarding the measures that should be taken to remedy such violations. In 2009, the Commission considered 1,137 complaints. As in the case of the Office of the Ombudsman, most housing-related complaints were collective complaints submitted by citizens who had taken out mortgage and housing loans for construction projects that had not been completed because of the financial crisis.
⁵ General Assembly resolution 48/134, annex.⁶ Presidential Decree No. 947 of 19 August 2002.
IV. Positive developments
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the fact that Kazakhstan has ratified or acceded to a number of international human rights treaties that enshrine the right to adequate housing. She also welcomes the fact that, under the Constitution, such treaties take precedence in the event of a conflict with national legislation and may be directly applied by national courts and tribunals.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the legislative and policy measures adopted by the State to strengthen the realization of the right to adequate housing at the national level, including:
a) the adoption of the State Housing Construction Programme for 2008–2010;
b) the adoption of the National Human Rights Action Plan for 2009–2012, which contains a number of recommendations for improving the protection of the housing rights of persons belonging to vulnerable groups, such as persons with disabilities and repatriates;
c) amendments to the Law on Housing Relations recognizing, in accordance with the recommendation of the Committee on the Rights of the Child⁷, the right of children left without parental care to access social housing;
d) the establishment of a housing credit system to enable young families with children and certain categories of public officials with average incomes to purchase housing;
e) the development of a draft housing construction loan programme aimed at providing access to affordable housing for persons who do not belong to the priority categories of the population under the current legislation on housing credit;
f) the adoption of measures to provide affordable rental housing for low-income families in need of housing;
g) the adoption of measures aimed at improving access to land plots and adequate housing for repatriates.
The Special Rapporteur also welcomes the work carried out by the Ombudsman and the Commission on Human Rights under the President to protect persons who claim to have been victims of violations of the right to adequate housing as a result of actions (or omissions) by officials or State institutions. With regard to the Ombudsman, the Special Rapporteur notes with satisfaction that the preparation of a draft law aimed at bringing the status of this institution into line with the Paris Principles had been included in the Government's legislative work plan for the last quarter of 2011.
The Special Rapporteur is also pleased to note the willingness demonstrated by the Government and the efforts it has made to mitigate the consequences of the financial crisis for the effective realization of the right to adequate housing of the citizens and families affected by it. Such efforts include the adoption of a priority action plan to ensure the stability of the mortgage market, the allocation of funds for the refinancing of existing mortgage loans and the establishment of a national fund to complete construction projects.
The Special Rapporteur also welcomes the establishment of a unified coordinating council as an advisory and consultative body under the Government. The mandate of the Council provides for addressing the most pressing issues relating to shared construction, improving legislation in the field of shared construction and protecting the rights of investors in shared construction projects, as well as assisting those investors who have been defrauded by unscrupulous developers in obtaining compensation.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the fact that, as a result of the Government's intervention, a number of families were able to receive their apartments. She also welcomes the legislative measures adopted by Kazakhstan to improve the effectiveness of the protection of investors in shared construction projects and prevent possible abuses by unscrupulous construction companies, including the Law of 11 July 2010 on Amendments and Additions to Certain Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Shared Construction Issues, as well as the regulatory acts implementing this Law.
Finally, the Special Rapporteur wishes to commend the activities of civil society, including social movements and non-governmental organizations, in the housing sector, particularly for their use of international human rights documents as standards for ensuring accountability of public administration bodies at all levels.
⁷ CRC/C/KAZ/CO/3, paragraph 56.
V. Challenges relating to the right to adequate housing
A. Housing legislation and housing policy
The Special Rapporteur shares the concern expressed by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights that the legal framework relating to housing does not ensure the protection of the right to adequate housing in accordance with international human rights standards⁸. In particular, she considers that, under the Constitution and national legislation, the right to housing continues to be interpreted narrowly or restrictively as the right to have a roof over one's head, while housing continues to be regarded as a commodity rather than a human right⁹.
The Special Rapporteur is aware that the provision on the right to adequate housing set out in article 11, paragraph 1, of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights is directly applicable in Kazakhstan and takes precedence in the event of a conflict with national legislation, pursuant to article 4, paragraph 3, of the Constitution. Nevertheless, she notes with concern that, in practice, national courts do not apply the provisions of international treaties and do not refer to international human rights standards, such as the general comments adopted by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
The Special Rapporteur considers that, despite the measures taken by Kazakhstan to implement the right to adequate housing, the State has failed to demonstrate that the measures being taken overall are fully adequate to realize this right for everyone within the shortest possible time and using the maximum available resources¹⁰. In the view of the Special Rapporteur, evidence of this includes the large number of citizens and families who have no housing or live in inadequate conditions, the reduction in the size of the State housing stock and the lengthy waiting period for families on waiting lists to obtain affordable housing from the State housing stock.
The Special Rapporteur regrets that the current National Human Rights Action Plan does not contain a detailed analysis of the situation concerning the realization of the right to adequate housing in the country and does not identify specific steps to ensure its further protection.
⁸ E/C.12/KAZ/CO/1, paragraph 29.⁹ See Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General Comment No. 4 on the right to adequate housing, paragraph 7.¹⁰ Ibid., paragraph 14.
B. Institutional framework
C. Forced Evictions
62. The Special Rapporteur expresses concern about the low level of awareness of the right to adequate housing and, more generally, of economic, social and cultural rights in the country. She also notes that the limited human, financial and technical resources available to the Ombudsman and the Commission on Human Rights under the President effectively impede the efforts undertaken by these institutions to protect and promote the human rights of persons living within the jurisdiction of the State, including their right to adequate housing.
63. The Special Rapporteur notes with concern that, despite the efforts undertaken by Kazakhstan to combat corruption, this phenomenon remains widespread in the country, including within the judicial system.
C. Forced Evictions
64. Pursuant to article 26, paragraph 3, of the Constitution, no one may be deprived of his or her property otherwise than by a court decision. The compulsory alienation of property for State needs in exceptional cases provided for by law may be carried out only on condition of equivalent compensation.
65. The exceptional cases in which compulsory alienation of property for State needs is permitted are listed in article 84 of the Land Code and include:
a) international obligations;
b) allocation of land for defence needs, specially protected natural areas, health-improving, recreational and historical and cultural purposes, and the establishment and operation of special economic zones;
c) development of mineral deposits;
d) construction of roads, electricity transmission lines, communication lines, main pipelines, public engineering and communication networks of populated areas, as well as other facilities of State importance;
e) demolition of dilapidated housing that is in danger of collapse;
f) implementation of master plans for the development of populated areas with regard to the construction of facilities falling within the list of exceptional cases established by this article, as well as the construction of facilities provided for by State and regional programmes and investment projects that ensure State interests and the achievement of socially significant objectives.
66. Article 84 does not contain a precise definition of national and regional programmes or investment projects that ensure State interests and the achievement of socially significant objectives. In accordance with the normative resolution adopted by the Constitutional Council on 28 May 2007, the precise nature of the exceptional cases referred to in this provision must be determined in the light of fundamental constitutional principles, primarily those enshrined in article 26, paragraph 3, of the Constitution.
67. The Special Rapporteur considers that national legislation on forced evictions does not comply with existing international human rights standards, such as General Comment No. 7 on forced evictions, adopted by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in 1997, and the basic principles and guidelines on development-based evictions and displacement developed by the previous Special Rapporteur on adequate housing11. She notes, in particular, that the ambiguity of national legislation regarding the definition of “exceptional circumstances” and “State needs” allows for arbitrary and broad interpretations of these concepts, resulting in a large number of unlawful forced evictions.
68. The authority to make decisions on compulsory alienation is vested in the akimat, which is responsible for implementing master development plans. The akimat’s decision is implemented through the purchase of the property (article 85 of the Land Code). The price of the land plot, the time limits and other conditions of purchase are determined by agreement between the owner or land user and the akimat. The owner or land user has the right to choose between monetary compensation at market value and alternative housing. If the owner or land user disagrees with the decision to purchase the property, the local executive body may file an appropriate claim with the competent court.
69. As a result of legalization programmes implemented by the local executive bodies of Astana and Almaty, a number of residents of informal settlements managed to obtain documents confirming ownership of their housing, which is a necessary condition for the effective exercise of the right to adequate housing. However, a significant number of people were unable to legalize their homes and, as a result, remain under threat of forced eviction. In some cases, families whose homes had been demolished for non-compliance with housing legislation witnessed houses being built on the same plots on the basis of ownership documents allegedly issued by State authorities.
70. Law enforcement practices in the field of forced evictions do not comply with human rights standards. The Special Rapporteur emphasizes that the implementation of master development plans cannot constitute a sufficient legal basis for forced eviction in the absence of an exceptional circumstance provided for by national legislation. She also notes that national courts generally interpret the concepts of “State needs” and “investment projects” very broadly, so as to include investment projects carried out by private construction companies and financed through private investment.
71. The Special Rapporteur regrets that she was unable to obtain updated statistical data on the number of forced evictions carried out in recent years in Almaty and Astana, the number of families affected by them and the percentage of persons who were left homeless as a result of the demolition of their homes.
72. The Special Rapporteur was informed that, in most cases, the monetary compensation provided to the owner or land user is insufficient for evicted families to purchase a suitable home at market prices in the same area. This is due to the fact that, after purchasing land plots for State needs, the akimat may change the zoning classification by transferring agricultural land into the category of urban land, so that private developers can carry out investment projects included in the master development plan. Furthermore, alternative housing is apparently rarely offered to evicted families.
73. Under State legislation, unauthorized structures on vacant plots are subject to demolition by the persons responsible for their construction or at their expense; compensation or the provision of alternative housing in place of demolished structures in informal settlements is not предусмотрено. Following eviction, residents of such settlements often become homeless. In 2006, in the Bakai microdistrict on the outskirts of Almaty, the authorities demolished hundreds of houses, claiming that they had been built illegally. Court orders existed in respect of only 29 of the 350–400 houses demolished, and residents were not actually given prior notice of the planned evictions. In July 2006, a similar attempt to demolish houses in the Shanyrak microdistrict met with strong resistance from the population12.
74. The Special Rapporteur is extremely concerned about the frequent cases of demolition of informal settlements and forced evictions without prior notice, any judicial oversight or assessment, or the provision of adequate compensation or alternative housing. During her mission, she received reports and examined documentary evidence concerning the demolition of housing by State officials using force, in some cases during winter, when temperatures were below zero. She was alarmed by reports that a large number of vulnerable persons, including pregnant women, children and persons with disabilities, had been left homeless as a result of such demolitions.
11 A/HRC/4/18, annex I.
12 See “Kazakhstan/Kyrgyzstan: Exploitation of migrant workers, lack of protection for asylum seekers and refugees”, International Federation for Human Rights, press release, October 2009.
D. Financial and Mortgage Crisis
75. The Special Rapporteur notes with concern that, despite the emergency measures taken by the Government to mitigate the impact of the financial crisis on the effective exercise of the right to adequate housing by affected citizens and families and to complete the construction of projects whose construction had slowed down or stopped as a result of the crisis, 20,000 equity holders are still waiting for their apartments.
76. One of the Government’s most controversial measures is the decision to provide equity holders with no more than one apartment in the relevant residential complex, regardless of the number of apartments purchased, in order to ensure that all persons who had invested in shared-equity housing construction receive at least one dwelling for themselves and their families13. The legality of this measure, which is intended to ensure the stability of the mortgage market and protect participants in shared-equity housing construction, was confirmed by the Yesil District Court of Astana (decision No. 2-947/10 of 5 May 2010). However, the majority of equity holders had invested in more than one apartment in order to provide adequate housing for other family members (elderly parents, children entering into marriage and relatives from rural areas). The Special Rapporteur heard from a large number of citizens affected by this decision.
77. The Special Rapporteur is also seriously concerned about reports of cases of forced eviction resulting from the inability of low-income families to repay their loans and make mortgage payments. As a result of the extrajudicial sale of their property by banks and other financial institutions, some citizens and families have become homeless or have been forced to move into inferior housing14.
13 Government Resolution No. 277 of 1 August 2010.
14 See the Report on the Activities of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2009 (available on the website of the Commission on Human Rights at: http://ombudsman.kz/en), pp. 41–42.
E. Differences between Urban and Rural Areas
78. The Special Rapporteur expresses concern about the significant differences between urban and rural areas in terms of the availability and quality of housing. She notes with concern that high unemployment, declining quality of education and medical services, and limited access to basic services such as safe drinking water and sanitation facilities in rural areas continue to force many citizens and a large number of families to leave their villages in search of employment opportunities and an improved standard of living elsewhere, particularly in Astana and Almaty.
79. According to the information provided to the Special Rapporteur, a significant proportion of housing in rural areas is in a dilapidated condition. There are also substantial differences in access to basic social services, such as the provision of drinking water and improved sanitation facilities. In 2008, 82.5 per cent of urban households were connected to the water supply system, whereas only 24.2 per cent of the rural population had access to water sources. The differences in sanitation are even more significant: 73.5 per cent of persons living in urban areas were connected to the central sewage system, compared with 8.9 per cent in rural areas.
80. Addressing the above-mentioned problems presents particular difficulties in rural areas. Despite a number of programmes implemented by the Government to improve conditions in villages and develop the agricultural sector, the standard of living of the rural population remains considerably lower than that of the urban population. There are several reasons for this, including the residual method of financing the social sector in rural areas (which is particularly relevant during periods of economic downturn) and underdeveloped infrastructure, primarily transport and communication networks.
F. Social Housing
81. The Special Rapporteur notes with concern that, under the Law on Housing Relations, persons belonging to low-income categories of the population or socially protected groups do not enjoy priority in obtaining social housing. Some vulnerable and disadvantaged categories of the population, such as residents of areas prone to natural disasters, are not included in the list of families waiting for housing set out in article 68 of that Law. The text of the Law does not expressly clarify whether homeless persons who do not belong to any socially protected category of the population are entitled to social housing.
82. The Special Rapporteur also notes with concern that categories of civil servants defined in article 67, paragraph 2, of the Law on Housing Relations are entitled to receive social housing on equal terms with low-income categories of the population or socially protected groups, without being required to prove their inability to purchase housing independently.
83. As the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights already noted in its 2010 concluding observations on Kazakhstan, long waiting periods for social housing continue to be a serious problem in the country15. In July 2010, 140,043 citizens were registered on the waiting list for housing from the State housing stock, including 1,432 persons with disabilities and war veterans and 79,536 persons belonging to low-income categories of the population and socially protected groups. In July 2010, 17,461 citizens in Astana and 8,439 citizens in Almaty were registered on the waiting list for State housing. According to the information received, families on the waiting list have to wait up to 10 years to receive an apartment from the State housing stock. According to State authorities, the average waiting period is six to eight years.
G. Vulnerable Groups
1. Migrant Workers
84. The current registration system, which is intended to enable the State to monitor and control the movement of internal migrants and immigrants within the country, requires migrants to register at their place of residence within five days of arrival. Registration at the place of residence requires a valid address. Consequently, persons living in informal settlements without any legal address or occupying residential premises that do not meet applicable sanitary and safety standards are effectively unable to register, although registration is necessary to obtain certain types of social services, including social housing.
15 E/C.12/KAZ/CO/1, paragraph 30.
2. Repatriates
85. Between 1991 and 2009, more than 188,000 repatriate families returned to Kazakhstan, representing approximately 740,000 persons. Every year, 10,000–15,000 ethnic Kazakh families arrive in Kazakhstan. Most repatriates come from Uzbekistan (almost 60 per cent of their total number), Mongolia and China. The majority of repatriates fall under the quota system.
86. In accordance with the Land Code, repatriates are allocated land for individual housing construction in the villages where they live; these lands and buildings become their property after they acquire citizenship of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The Nurly Kosh (“Bright Migration”) Programme for 2009–2011 aims to increase the availability of adequate housing through a preferential lending mechanism16. This programme, which is also based on a quota system, is intended to promote the demographic and socio-economic development of various regions of the country. In 2009, 674 families received housing under this programme.
87. The Special Rapporteur received several reports indicating that abandoned houses allocated to repatriates by the akimat under the resettlement programme were subsequently repossessed when former owners, who had left them because of the economic downturn in the early 1990s, returned and sought judicial restoration of their property rights.
16 A/HRC/WG.6/7/KAZ/1, paragraph 131.
3. Migrants and Asylum Seekers
88. As of July 2010, 597 persons had been granted refugee status in Kazakhstan. The overwhelming majority of refugees (588 persons) came from Afghanistan. The State regularly refuses to grant refugee status to asylum seekers from Uzbekistan, the Russian Federation (Chechens) and China (Uyghurs from the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region). The Government maintains that citizens of the countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) do not, by definition, need refugee status, since they enjoy freedom of movement within the CIS under the visa-free regime. Consequently, they are required to apply to the office of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in the country and, if their application is considered favourably, wait for resettlement in a third country willing to receive them. As a result of this situation, they remain in a state of legal uncertainty, making them vulnerable to harassment by the police and forced return. In addition, they face poor living conditions and economic difficulties and have difficulty finding employment.
89. Statistical data on the housing situation of refugees and asylum seekers are unavailable. According to information provided by UNHCR, most of them live in rented houses or apartments and have access to basic utilities (water, electricity and gas), although the quality of housing varies considerably among families. In general, families that have lived in the Republic of Kazakhstan for a long time and whose members have obtained refugee status live in better conditions than newly arrived persons. Persons forced to live in less favourable economic conditions share housing with members of the same national or ethnic group. Apparently, refugees and asylum seekers do not live in State apartments.
4. Homeless Persons
90. The Special Rapporteur was unable to obtain reliable information on the number of homeless persons in Kazakhstan. The Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, which is the State body responsible for providing assistance and support to homeless persons, does not have statistical data on the number of persons who, for whatever reason, do not have a legal address within the territory of the State. According to civil society organizations, the lack of adequate information is due to the fact that the legislation of Kazakhstan does not contain a definition of a homeless person.
91. Twenty-one social centres for persons without a fixed place of residence have been established in the country. These centres, which are financed from the akimat budget, provide assistance and support to homeless persons. Depending on the specific circumstances, the centres provide them with temporary accommodation, medical care and psychological support, assistance in finding employment or obtaining social benefits. According to the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, these centres received almost 4,000 persons during the first half of 2010. On average, stays at these centres last less than six months, after which the persons staying there return to their families or are referred to other institutions (for example, nursing homes or centres for persons with disabilities).
92. Homeless persons effectively have no access to a number of social services provided by the State for which registration at the place of residence is required.
VI. Conclusions and Recommendations
A. Housing Legislation and Housing Policy
93. The Special Rapporteur recommends that Kazakhstan review and streamline its housing legislation and policy in order to ensure their compliance with international human rights standards and standards relating to adequate housing. Kazakhstan should also reconsider its approach, which is oriented exclusively towards market-based and mortgage-based forms of housing ownership (which was one of the causes of the real estate crisis), and develop a comprehensive national housing policy. Such a policy should provide for various measures, including the use of rental schemes and the upgrading of informal settlements, in order to meet the needs of different segments of society, including the most vulnerable groups, such as low-income families, large families, single mothers with young children, persons with disabilities, elderly persons, migrant workers who are residents of the country, repatriates (oralman), refugees and asylum seekers.
94. All stakeholders should actively participate in the development and implementation of legislation, policies and strategies affecting their interests; to this end, the Government should engage constructively with civil society and human rights groups. In particular, the Special Rapporteur calls upon the Government to take all necessary measures to ensure that individuals and families affected by the mortgage crisis actively participate in the development of solutions intended to address the crisis.
95. Kazakhstan should take all necessary measures to ensure the effective application of international treaties, in particular the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, by national courts.
B. Institutional Framework
96. Human rights education should be improved, particularly with regard to economic, social and cultural rights. The Special Rapporteur recommends that Kazakhstan organize, with the assistance of the OHCHR Regional Office in Bishkek, training and awareness-raising activities for judges, lawyers and government officials in order to familiarize them with economic, social and cultural rights. In developing and implementing such human rights programmes, due attention should be paid to the content and forms of the right to adequate housing, as well as to the housing-related activities of the Special Rapporteur and the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
97. The Special Rapporteur calls upon the Government to finalize the adoption of the draft law aimed at strengthening the independence of the Commission on Human Rights and to bring its status into line with the Paris Principles. Adequate human, financial and technical resources should be allocated to the Commission so that it can perform its functions.
98. The Special Rapporteur reiterates the recommendation of the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights17, which strongly urged Kazakhstan to intensify its efforts to combat corruption. In this regard, she calls upon the State to organize, with the assistance of relevant specialized agencies and programmes and with the support of the donor community, awareness-raising and capacity-building programmes for public officials, including law enforcement officers, prosecutors and judges, on the application of anti-corruption legislation.
17 E/C.12/KAZ/CO/1, paragraph 11.
C. Forced Evictions
99. A comprehensive approach should be adopted to address issues such as forced evictions, security of tenure, the legalization of informal settlements and the upgrading of slums, and to ensure that, before the commencement of urban construction and renewal projects, open, participatory and meaningful consultations are held with residents and communities affected by such projects. In particular, the Special Rapporteur strongly urges Kazakhstan to adopt a specific law on forced evictions, which should be developed in accordance with existing human rights standards, such as General Comment No. 7 of the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the guidelines on development-based evictions, and implemented in accordance with the relevant principles and procedures established under international human rights law.
100. The new law should ensure that forced evictions are carried out only in exceptional circumstances provided for by national legislation and only for the purpose of promoting the general welfare. The circumstances in which an eviction may be justified should be determined by national courts and interpreted restrictively by them. Protection against forced eviction should extend to all vulnerable persons and groups, regardless of whether they have ownership rights to their homes and/or property under domestic law. The implementation of master plans for urban development should in no way be used as justification for forced eviction. A complete moratorium on forced evictions should be introduced until the new law is developed.
101. All persons evicted from their homes should receive adequate compensation and/or be offered appropriate alternative housing. Persons affected by this process should also be given the opportunity, where appropriate, to choose alternative housing in the same area. At the time of relocation, basic services should be available at the relevant locations, including access to drinking water, energy supply, sanitation and hygiene systems, and the necessary infrastructure facilities, including schools, medical centres and transport, should be available.
102. Eviction decisions should be sent to the families concerned in writing and should contain a detailed explanation of the exceptional circumstances necessitating the compulsory alienation of land for State needs. Furthermore, decisions of local executive bodies should clearly indicate the personal details of the persons affected by the process, as well as the land plots to which the forced eviction decision applies.
103. The issue of informal settlements that have emerged on the outskirts of the cities of Astana and Almaty is highly complex and requires the application of a comprehensive approach covering, in particular, education, health care, social benefits and employment. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur would like to reaffirm that forced eviction can be justified only in the presence of absolutely exceptional circumstances and must necessarily comply with the appropriate principles and procedures established under international human rights law. In particular, the Special Rapporteur wishes to emphasize that the State is obliged to take all necessary measures to ensure that citizens do not become homeless or vulnerable to violations of other human rights as a result of eviction, regardless of its legality.
D. Mortgage Crisis
104. The Special Rapporteur considers that the lessons learned by the Government through its efforts to mitigate the negative consequences of the financial crisis for the effective exercise of the right to adequate housing should serve as the basis for a general review of its housing strategies, policies and programmes. The financial crisis demonstrated that creating favourable conditions for attracting foreign investment and supporting financial activities is not, in itself, sufficient to ensure the availability of adequate and affordable housing for all, and that the State needs to establish effective regulation and careful supervision of the activities of the private sector, including financial and construction companies.
105. The State should review its legislation and policies concerning access to mortgage lending for low-income families and ensure that commercial banks and financial institutions take into account the limited repayment capacity of such families. Financial services for low-income categories of the population should be developed in consultation with their representatives, since they are best placed to assess their repayment capacity and ensure the creation of systems that meet their genuine needs.
106. The Special Rapporteur calls upon the State party to continue its efforts aimed at mitigating the consequences of the transfer of mortgaged property into the ownership of the mortgagee and facilitating the completion of residential projects whose construction was hindered by the crisis.
107. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the State to amend its legislation in order to make the extrajudicial sale of a debtor’s only home unlawful.
E. Differences between Urban and Rural Areas
108. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the State party intensify its efforts to eliminate disparities between urban and rural areas and between regions in terms of the availability and quality of housing. She also calls upon the Government to develop and implement, in close cooperation with the local communities concerned, comprehensive programmes and strategies aimed at improving socio-economic conditions in rural areas, with a view to reducing migration from rural to urban areas and alleviating housing problems in Astana and Almaty. Priority measures should include the creation of new jobs and expanding access to education, health care and basic services ensuring the availability of safe drinking water and sanitation facilities.
F. Social Housing
109. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the State to consider introducing amendments to the Law on Housing Relations providing for the priority allocation of social housing to persons belonging to vulnerable and disadvantaged groups of the population. She also recommends reviewing the list contained in article 68 in order to include all vulnerable and disadvantaged groups of the population in terms of access to housing.
110. The Special Rapporteur reminds the State that, in its General Comment No. 4, the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights stated that policies and legislation should not benefit social groups already in an advantageous position at the expense of others (paragraph 11). Accordingly, she recommends that Kazakhstan consider amending its social housing legislation so that social housing is provided only to those citizens and families who are unable to meet their own housing needs.
111. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the State review its housing construction strategy and policy in order to improve the provision of adequate and affordable housing to citizens and families belonging to low-income and socially vulnerable groups. She recommends that the State increase budgetary allocations for the construction of new social housing and develop and implement, within the public and private sectors, a comprehensive set of measures aimed at realizing the right to adequate housing for vulnerable citizens and groups of the population.
G. Vulnerable Groups
112. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the State consider reviewing the existing registration system in order to facilitate the registration of persons who are lawfully present in its territory but are unable to complete the registration process because they lack the legal address required for registration.
113. The Special Rapporteur also recommends that the State party take all appropriate measures to ensure that persons belonging to vulnerable groups, such as non-citizens, internal migrants, refugees and asylum seekers, enjoy equal access to adequate housing with citizens.
Constitution Law Code Normative Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative cases and disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Programme Charter Statute Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages