Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Report / Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (General Assembly) Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, Gulnara Shahinian. Human Rights Council, 26 August 2014

Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (General Assembly) Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, Gulnara Shahinian. Human Rights Council, 26 August 2014

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (General Assembly)

Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, Gulnara Shahinian. Human Rights Council, 26 August 2014

Addendum

Follow-up mission to Kazakhstan*

Summary

Pursuant to the mandate provided for in Human Rights Council resolution 24/3 and at the invitation of the Government of Kazakhstan, the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, visited Kazakhstan from 25 to 27 March 2014 in the context of follow-up activities. In the present report, she assesses new developments that have taken place since her first visit in September 2012 and the Government's initiatives to combat forced and bonded labour, as well as the worst forms of child labour, and reviews the measures adopted in the areas of regulatory frameworks and the labour inspection system. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the prompt action taken in response to some of her recommendations, but draws attention to the fact that a number of problems remain unresolved and require further measures.

Demand for labour is increasing in Kazakhstan in a number of sectors where contemporary forms of slavery, as well as forced and bonded labour, persist, particularly in the tobacco, cotton-growing and construction industries. In accordance with the recommendations made by the Special Rapporteur following her first visit, the Government has simplified the procedure for issuing work permits in order to facilitate the regularization of the status of migrant workers and seasonal workers. The Special Rapporteur nevertheless found that this procedure remains complicated and that the introduction of certain new requirements may inadvertently lead to adverse consequences, since they make it more difficult for migrant workers to obtain formal employment and thereby render them more vulnerable to arbitrary treatment. Amendments to the legislation on combating trafficking in persons introduced in 2013 now contain specific references to forced labour; however, the new Criminal Code, the draft of which was under development at the time of the Special Rapporteur's visit, does not provide for criminal liability for forced labour. In combating contemporary forms of slavery, it is essential that slavery and slavery-like practices, including domestic servitude, forced and bonded labour, as well as forced early marriages, be clearly established as criminal offences in the Criminal Code.

Certain progress has been made in eliminating the worst forms of child labour. In 2012, the Ministry of Education issued Order No. 398, which allows children of migrant workers, including seasonal workers, to attend school with the same rights as Kazakh children. Nevertheless, this order does not remove barriers to access to education, including the requirement for identity documents for children of undocumented seasonal workers. The same applies to ensuring access to medical services for migrant workers and their family members, beyond emergency medical care, irrespective of their migration status.

The labour inspection system, which plays a key role in identifying slavery and slavery-like practices, must continue to be strengthened and provide for regular and unannounced inspections by appropriately trained inspectors. The Special Rapporteur was also concerned about the recent introduction of a moratorium on occupational safety inspections until January 2015.

\* The summary of the present report is circulated in all official languages. The report itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is circulated only in the language of submission and in Russian.

** Submitted late.

Annex

[English and Russian only]

Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, following her follow-up mission to Kazakhstan (25–27 March 2014)

Contents

Paragraphs

I. Introduction.................................................1–3 II. General context..........................................4–8 III. Progress in the implementation of measures to combat slavery........9–51 A. Forced and bonded labour, as well as the worst forms of child labour...................................................9–33 B. Regulatory measures.....................34–46 C. Labour inspections.....................................47–51 IV. Conclusions and recommendations.................................52–68 A. Recommendations to the Government.........................54–66 B. Recommendations to the business community...........................67 C. Recommendations to the international community................68

I. Introduction

1. The Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences, undertook an official visit to Kazakhstan from 25 to 27 March 2014 in the context of follow-up activities to her 2012 visit¹, with a view to assessing new developments and initiatives undertaken by the Government in response to her recommendations. In particular, the purpose of her visit was to discuss the measures adopted and their impact on the eradication of slavery and slavery-like practices, such as forced and bonded labour. In this regard, the purpose of her visit was also to gather information on existing contemporary forms of slavery in the country, with a view to reviewing legislation relating to contemporary forms of slavery and eliminating the causes and consequences of such practices. During her visit, the Special Rapporteur held meetings with various government authorities, law enforcement agencies, international and non-governmental organizations, trade unions, community representatives, commercial enterprises and other actors whose activities are aimed at combating all forms of slavery. She also held extensive consultations with the Minister of Internal Affairs, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, representatives of the Ministry of Justice and the Prosecutor General, and other senior officials, as well as representatives of civil society, trade unions, the private enterprise Philip Morris Kazakhstan and the United Nations country team.

2. The Special Rapporteur expresses her gratitude to the Government of Kazakhstan for its invitation, as well as for the assistance and cooperation provided before and during her visit. She is sincerely grateful for all the support extended to her and expresses her appreciation for the continuation, in a spirit of cooperation, of the dialogue on the issue of slavery, with a view to further intensifying efforts to eradicate contemporary forms of slavery in Kazakhstan, particularly forced labour, bonded labour and the worst forms of child labour. In addition, she expresses her deep appreciation to the Ministry of Internal Affairs for the assistance provided and to the United Nations country team and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) for their support in organizing the visit.

3. At the end of her visit, the Special Rapporteur shared her preliminary findings with the Government.

_____________________________________________________________________

¹ See A/HRC/24/43/Add.1.

II. General context

4. Kazakhstan's economy is considered the largest in Central Asia, mainly owing to its natural resources, particularly oil and natural gas, as well as its agricultural land (vegetable, tobacco and cotton plantations). Economic growth has supported the development of other sectors, particularly construction and home-based work, which has resulted in a demand for labour resources exceeding the size of the national workforce. Owing to these economic achievements and the employment opportunities offered, Kazakhstan has become one of the main destination countries for migrant workers and seasonal workers, particularly those arriving from neighbouring countries such as Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, as well as China.

5. Although there is currently no reliable information or accurate statistical data, estimates indicate that between 2 and 3 million migrants work in Kazakhstan. Given that a large proportion of the workforce is employed on plantations and in construction, workers arriving from neighbouring countries are mainly employed in sectors where they are most vulnerable to contemporary forms of slavery.

6. The existing migration policy and its implementation system are at an early stage of development, administratively overburdened and continue to be structured and regulated in accordance with protection and security parameters, which severely restricts opportunities for authorized and lawful employment. The formalization of employment relationships would provide the best protection against contemporary forms of slavery for seasonal workers and migrant workers.

7. Government authorities point out that, in seeking to bring the informal sector of the economy under regulatory control and transform it into the formal sector, they have been compelled to rely on rules requiring the regulation of migration through a significant reduction in the quota for migrant workers (by approximately half) and the application of an open policy giving preference to the employment of their own citizens. Under the quota system, individual work permits are issued not to migrants but to employers, which places migrants in a position of dependence on employers and deprives them of the opportunity to regularize their legal status independently or to seek another employer if they encounter arbitrary treatment. Despite the visa-free regime between Kazakhstan and neighbouring countries belonging to the Commonwealth of Independent States, migrant workers are still required to register with the migration police in order to reside lawfully in the country's territory; permanent registration is one of the conditions for obtaining access to economic and social rights.

8. In order to regularize their status, migrant workers need a migration card, which enables them to obtain official registration at their place of residence and a work permit. In addition, their employer must hold an official licence authorizing the employment of foreign nationals.

III. Progress in the implementation of measures to combat slavery

A. Forced and bonded labour, as well as the worst forms of child labour

9. The complexity of the regulatory and legal framework has led to the emergence of irregular labour migration, which represents a serious problem in Kazakhstan, since migrants working illegally are most vulnerable to forced and bonded labour.

10. Demand for labour is increasing in a number of sectors in Kazakhstan where contemporary forms of slavery exist; in particular, forced and bonded labour continue to persist in the tobacco, cotton-growing and construction industries. Most migrants arrive for approximately six months to harvest tobacco and cotton.

11. Child labour is widespread among both the children of migrant workers and Kazakh children. On tobacco and cotton plantations, children account for more than half of the total workforce.²

12. Progress has been made in combating the worst forms of child labour, as well as forced and bonded labour on tobacco plantations. However, working conditions in tobacco cultivation remain largely unsatisfactory, including long working hours with virtually no breaks and inadequate provision of housing, water, food, sanitation and hygiene facilities. Furthermore, workers in the tobacco industry work in hot weather during the summer and are exposed to pesticides and the risk of contracting green tobacco sickness, which is caused by the absorption of nicotine through the skin when it comes into contact with wet tobacco leaves. Children working in the cotton-growing and tobacco industries are particularly exposed to hazardous working conditions that adversely affect their developing bodies. Hazardous working conditions associated with tobacco and cotton production are of particular concern in the case of migrant workers without official status, since, following the introduction of an individual identification number, they and their family members have access only to emergency medical care.

13. Furthermore, the confiscation of identity documents, which is prohibited under existing legislation in Kazakhstan, as well as deliberate delays in the payment of wages at the end of the season, a widespread practice on tobacco plantations, further exacerbate migrant workers' dependence on employers, given that if migrant workers decide to leave a farm before the harvest is completed, they are forced to forfeit the money owed to them for work already performed.

14. The Special Rapporteur remains concerned that, despite targeted efforts and support from the tobacco industry, as well as steps taken to strengthen the protection of migrant workers employed in the tobacco industry, the threat of debt bondage and cases of hazardous child labour continue to exist on some farms.

15. As part of the follow-up to her previous visit, the Special Rapporteur met with representatives of Philip Morris Kazakhstan (PMK) to continue the dialogue that had been initiated with the company in 2012. PMK, a subsidiary of Philip Morris International, one of the world's largest tobacco manufacturing companies, is the sole purchaser of tobacco in Enbekshikazakh district of Almaty region, the main tobacco-growing area in Kazakhstan, and, in this capacity, bears a particular responsibility for ensuring that neither child labour nor forced or bonded labour is used on tobacco plantations.

16. PMK emphasized that the Special Rapporteur's visit in 2012 had helped to keep the issue of forced labour at the forefront of the Government's attention, as well as to intensify efforts to eradicate this form of slavery in the tobacco industry through joint action by a number of stakeholders, including the Government, PMK and non-governmental organizations.

17. PMK emphasized its commitment to combating child labour, bonded labour and forced labour and reported on a number of measures taken in this regard. PMK also added that it could not resolve certain problems on its own.

18. PMK uses standard written contracts concluded between farmers working with PMK and hired workers in order to ensure compliance with the legislation of Kazakhstan and prevent the worst forms of child labour, forced labour and the forcible retention of workers' identity documents. The contracts contain provisions on the minimum wage and other labour standards.

19. PMK has also undertaken other initiatives, such as financing programmes to prevent child labour, including the establishment of summer camps for children of migrant workers and children of farmers working in the tobacco industry who are not migrants, a kindergarten and a community centre with playgrounds in remote farming areas, as well as vocational and technical training for children over the age of 15.

20. PMK drew particular attention to the annual “Best Farmer” award, which is intended to encourage the dissemination of best practices among farmers in terms of quantity and quality, as well as working conditions. One of the mandatory conditions for participation in the competition is the absence of child labour and the conclusion of written employment contracts.

21. Another means of addressing the problems existing in the tobacco industry is the organization of a round table at the State level, jointly funded by PMK and the Ministry of Labour, with the participation of the Ministry of Education, non-governmental organizations, farmers and international organizations.

22. Despite the efforts mentioned above, PMK acknowledged that reports of the use of child labour on tobacco plantations continued to be received, although their number had decreased. PMK promised to provide the Special Rapporteur with accurate figures and data for her information, although nothing had yet been received by her. PMK explained that, in the following year, in cases where the use of child labour was confirmed, the size of the land plots cultivated by the farmers concerned who worked with PMK would be reduced by 10 per cent as a punitive measure. In addition, non-governmental organizations play a crucial role not only in preventing the use of child labour, bonded labour or forced labour, but also in taking responsive measures in cases identified.

23. In particular, the Local Community Foundation, which brings together non-governmental organizations and acts as their “ears and eyes”, monitors the situation on the ground on a collective basis. The Foundation also acts as an intermediary between workers and employers and provides a “hotline” service, established in March 2012, for all migrant workers employed in the tobacco and vegetable production sectors. It also operates a mobile team that visits locations following the receipt of complaints.

24. Furthermore, PMK has established staff positions for field officers and agronomists who receive training on issues relating to child labour, the withholding of passports, housing conditions and children's access to education, and who also monitor tobacco quality and compliance with labour standards. They conduct inspections or visit tobacco farms without prior notice. They also examine payroll records to ensure that workers are not employed under conditions of debt bondage. Nevertheless, PMK acknowledged that occupational safety inspections alone were insufficient and that errors could occur during inspections owing to time constraints.

25. Since migrant workers have little knowledge of the necessary legal documents and assistance programmes available to them, PMK has also taken measures to raise their awareness, printed brochures on slavery conventions and informed migrant workers about their rights.

26. Of all the projects envisaged under the 2012–2014 action plan, only approximately 10 per cent have been implemented to date. Although PMK is a sponsor, it cannot independently select partners for the practical implementation of projects and is required to follow a complicated State tender procedure for the selection of the least expensive partner.

27. Since the previous visit of the Special Rapporteur, some progress has been made in eliminating the worst forms of child labour. In 2012, the Ministry of Education issued Order No. 398, which allows children of migrant workers, including seasonal workers, to attend school with the same rights as Kazakh children.³

28. At the same time, the Special Rapporteur notes that Order No. 398 does not remove barriers to access to education, including the requirement for identity documents for children of undocumented seasonal workers. Domestic legislation must be brought into conformity with the State's international obligations concerning the provision of universal and unhindered access to the right to education.

29. In 2012, the National Coordinating Council for Combating Child Labour approved a joint action plan and a joint work plan for 2012–2014 aimed at eliminating the worst forms of child labour in Kazakhstan and implementing the International Labour Organization (ILO) Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182). In addition, the Council completed a review of Kazakhstan's legislation and policy measures, particularly action plans, as well as State and national programmes in the areas of child labour and youth employment, in order to facilitate future joint work by the Government and its partners to address these issues.

30. The Special Rapporteur was also informed that, in 2013, systems for monitoring the situation regarding the use of child labour had been launched on a pilot basis in five villages and that direct services had been provided to children at risk or subjected to the worst forms of child labour.

31. The Government also conducted a public awareness campaign on hazardous forms of child labour in Almaty and South Kazakhstan regions.

32. In May 2013, a regional workshop was held on improving the regulation of migration policy at the local level. The event was jointly organized by the administration of South Kazakhstan region, the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization and the United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. In November 2013, the first Regional Forum on Migration was held in Almaty with the aim of strengthening regional cooperation and partnership with Kyrgyzstan in the implementation of bilateral agreements relating to labour migration.

33. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the initiatives undertaken by the Government of Kazakhstan to address demand-related problems in the area of forced labour and slavery-like working conditions at the regional level. Regional cooperation, dialogue and the exchange of best practices are fundamental elements in combating the exploitation of migrants.

_____________________________________________________________________

² See International Labour Organization, International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour and Centre for the Study of Public Opinion, Child Labour in the Tobacco-Growing and Cotton-Growing Sectors of Agriculture in Kazakhstan, situation assessment report, Almaty, 2006.

³ See A/HRC/24/43/Add.1, paragraph 97.

B. Measures for Regulatory Framework

34. There are two major categories of migrants: ethnic Kazakhs (“oralman”) who previously lived abroad and returned to their historical homeland; and unskilled or semi-skilled migrant workers arriving mainly from neighbouring countries. The latter category is most commonly referred to as “gastarbeiters” (“guest workers”); this is the Russified version of the German word “Gastarbeiter”, used in the plural. However, unlike in the German context, “gastarbeiters” have neither official legal status nor social protection.⁴

35. At present, there are no data reflecting the actual number of migrant workers employed in Kazakhstan due to methodological shortcomings in the documentation of migrants. The calculation of the number of migrants carried out by the Ministry of Internal Affairs is based on an analysis of entry and exit stamps placed in migration cards, without distinguishing between those who are merely transiting through the country and those who remain there. Furthermore, the collection of data on migrants is complicated by their mobility, as well as by the instability of their legal status, which fluctuates between illegal and legal, sometimes without their knowledge. There is an evident need for a clear methodology, as well as reliable information and statistical data.

36. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the Government’s agreement with her recommendation regarding the need to amend the complicated and time-consuming procedure for issuing work permits, which significantly restricts opportunities for formal employment and consequently exacerbates the vulnerability of migrants. She welcomes the Government’s initiative to introduce amendments to migration legislation. As emphasized in her previous report, simplifying the procedure for issuing work permits is one of the most important instruments for legalizing the status of migrant workers.

37. The change in State policy that occurred in 2009 placed migrant workers employed in the tobacco industry in a particularly vulnerable position, leaving them unprotected against arbitrary treatment, as they lost the opportunity to obtain formal employment. In addition, many employers failed to register workers because of bureaucratic red tape, as well as their unwillingness to pay the taxes associated with hiring workers.

38. In 2013, a new law was adopted introducing amendments and additions to a number of legislative acts in the field of labour migration, prepared by the Ministry of Internal Affairs for the purpose of regulating the activities of migrant workers. The law introduced amendments to the Labour Code, the Code on Taxes and Other Mandatory Payments, as well as the Law on Migration.

39. A work permit is issued to a migrant worker who is a citizen of a State with which agreements on visa-free entry and stay have been concluded, for a period of up to three months, with the possibility of extension for a period of up to one year. Under the amendments introduced to the Law on Migration, it is now possible to hire up to five migrant workers and seasonal workers at one time without having to undergo the entire registration procedure separately in each case. Although this measure is intended to facilitate the formalization of the legal status of migrant workers, there are concerns that the establishment of a limit of five migrant workers may inadvertently lead to corrupt practices.

40. The amendments also resulted in changes to the taxation of migrant workers, from whom income tax is no longer withheld at source. In practice, this amendment introduced a requirement for advance payment of income tax in the amount of two monthly calculation indices in order to obtain a work permit. The amendment may lead to an increase in the number of undocumented workers and make them more vulnerable to debt bondage.

41. With the exception of the right to apply for an extension of a work permit, the law establishes only the obligations of migrant workers, including seasonal workers. The law should also enshrine, in accordance with international human rights standards, the right to just and favourable conditions of work,⁵ including the rights to fair wages and remuneration, safe and healthy working conditions, equal opportunities for promotion, rest, reasonable limitation of working hours and holidays. The law should also guarantee the right to form and join trade unions.

42. Article 128 of the Criminal Code of 1997 establishes criminal liability for all forms of trafficking in persons for the purposes of sexual and other forms of exploitation. This is the only criminal offence — “exploitation” — that is presented in a general form and does not contain a specific definition of the various contemporary forms of slavery and slavery-like practices. Forced marriage, coercion to continue marital cohabitation and preventing a woman from marrying of her own free will are not criminal offences under the Criminal Code.

43. In 2013, amendments were introduced to the legislation of Kazakhstan concerning human trafficking. The Law on Amendments and Additions to Certain Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Issues Relating to Combating Human Trafficking provides definitions of the concept of “exploitation” in articles 126, 128 and 133, and also establishes the concept of “forced labour” as follows: “forced labour means any work or service required of a person under the threat of any punishment, for which that person has not voluntarily offered his or her services, except in cases established by the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan”.

44. In 2012, the Supreme Court issued a resolution stating that persons who have become victims of human trafficking may not be held criminally liable for offences committed as a result of their having been subjected to trafficking. In practice, however, law enforcement agencies do not always respond appropriately; investigations are not conducted thoroughly, and persons who have become victims of human trafficking are treated inattentively and disrespectfully or are treated as criminals, being held liable for violations of migration legislation and/or deported. Unsatisfactory law enforcement undermines any efforts to adopt effective rules and provisions.

45. Labour inspectors do not identify victims of human trafficking because, in their view, human trafficking is a crime falling within the jurisdiction of the migration police and therefore does not fall within their remit.

46. The Special Rapporteur received information from the Prosecutor General indicating that new draft Criminal Code and Criminal Procedure Code were being prepared. According to information received from non-governmental sources, the new Code does not directly establish criminal liability for forced labour. In combating contemporary forms of slavery, it is of great importance to clearly establish slavery and slavery-like practices as criminal offences in the Criminal Code, including domestic servitude, forced and bonded labour, as well as forced early marriages. The lower chamber of Parliament adopted the new Criminal Code and Criminal Procedure Code on 9 April 2014; they will enter into force in January 2015.

 

⁴ In German, the term “Gastarbeiter” has a very narrow meaning and cannot be transferred to the legal and sociocultural context of Kazakhstan. The category of “Gastarbeiter” referred to workers who were legally employed and who, in the 1950s, were actively recruited to perform contract work in Germany and enjoyed legal and social protection. See also Institute of Developing Countries/Japan External Trade Organization, “Exploring Informal Networks in Kazakhstan: A Multidimensional Approach”, 2013 (available at: www.ide.go.jp/Japanese/Publish/Download/Report/2012/pdf/C24_contents.pdf), chap. II.

⁵ International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, article 7.

C. Labour Inspections

47. Labour inspectors in Kazakhstan monitor compliance with labour legislation and inform employers of violations of the law. They are also entitled to identify the causes of such violations and issue recommendations for their elimination.

48. Labour inspectors are not authorized to visit enterprises on their own initiative; they may conduct inspections only within the framework of scheduled activities or in response to complaints submitted by individuals, legal entities or State authorities concerning violations of labour legislation, or in cases where a threat to the life or health of workers arises. Anonymous complaints are not considered grounds for unscheduled inspections. Furthermore, labour inspectors rarely conduct follow-up inspections to monitor compliance with requirements.

49. The Labour Code establishes a limit on the number of inspections to which companies may be subjected. Large enterprises may be inspected only once a year, while small and medium-sized enterprises may be inspected only once every three years. In 2008 and the first half of 2009, a moratorium was declared on scheduled inspection visits (including inspections conducted by other agencies).

50. The procedure for conducting scheduled inspections for the coming year is determined on the basis of a “blacklist” of enterprises compiled by the State Labour Inspectorate. Companies may be removed from the list if they are able to demonstrate that conditions have improved (according to available information, this was precisely the case with “FMK”).

51. By decree of the President of Kazakhstan, a new moratorium on inspections of small and medium-sized enterprises was declared from 2 April 2014 until 1 January 2015. As explained to the Special Rapporteur, this measure was adopted because inspections slow the pace of economic development, and the declaration of a moratorium would help improve the conditions for conducting business activities in Kazakhstan. The Special Rapporteur disagrees with these arguments.

IV. Conclusions and Recommendations

52. The Special Rapporteur highly commends the Government’s commitment to joint efforts to combat all forms of slavery and slavery-like practices, as well as the efforts undertaken in this regard. She expresses the hope that the Government will continue along the path of cooperation. The Special Rapporteur also welcomes the fact that, shortly after her first visit to the country in September 2012, the Government not only took note of some of her recommendations, but also endorsed and implemented them.

53. The Government should adopt a comprehensive and systematic approach at the legislative and policy levels to eradicate contemporary forms of slavery. Such an approach should be holistic, consistent and effective, and should involve reviewing and analysing all existing laws, policies, programmes and working methods in this area in order to ensure further optimized action. The Special Rapporteur also emphasizes the need to conduct a substantive survey and collect disaggregated information and statistical data using a methodology that would allow for the maximum possible coverage of all forms of slavery and slavery-like practices in all their complexity, while ensuring the confidentiality of personal data and respect for the right to privacy.

A. Recommendations to the Government

1. Legislation, Policies and Programmes

54. The Special Rapporteur reiterates her view that existing legislation concerning slavery should be reviewed in order to bring it into line with international standards by including a comprehensive and clear list of all forms of slavery, including forced and bonded labour, as well as the worst forms of child labour and domestic servitude. The penalties established by law should be proportionate to the offence committed, and effective mechanisms should also be established to protect the rights of persons who have become victims of slavery, including their rights to compensation and reintegration. It is equally important that schemes for providing protection, paying compensation and facilitating reintegration be enshrined in legislation. The Special Rapporteur also emphasizes the need for the urgent establishment of law enforcement and monitoring mechanisms to ensure the full-scale implementation of laws and policies aimed at eradicating all forms of slavery in the country.

55. With regard to the protection and rehabilitation of persons who have become victims of human trafficking, the Government should allocate funds for the development of support services and protection mechanisms, as well as provide victims of human trafficking with financial assistance to help them overcome their experiences and return to normal life. The implementation of legislation aimed at combating slavery should be based on an approach that gives priority to victims, focusing not only on conducting investigations and prosecuting persons engaged in human trafficking, but also on providing support to victims.

56. The regulatory and legal framework of Kazakhstan is insufficiently clear and consistent. For example, article 2 of the new Law on Migration refers to “other laws” regulating migration issues but does not specify which laws are meant. Such ambiguity creates difficulties in the enforcement and application of laws. Accordingly, this shortcoming must be remedied by ensuring that laws referring to “other laws” regulating migration issues contain a list of such laws, specifying their titles and, where possible, the particular provisions concerned. Legal provisions must be predictable, clear and consistent with the principle of legal certainty. Furthermore, laws must clearly specify the particular conditions under which other regulatory legal acts may take precedence. Exceptions should include restrictions on the scope of application of primary legislative acts, which should take precedence over the provisions of other regulatory legal acts. The Special Rapporteur was pleased to learn that the Government recognizes the need to review existing legislation in order to establish a systematic protection mechanism, and notes its willingness to receive expert advisory assistance in this regard in the field of legislative drafting.

57. Although the Law on Amendments and Additions to Certain Legislative Acts Concerning Labour Migration simplified the procedure for issuing work permits, the procedure nevertheless remains complicated and requires further review. The list of required documents is still very long. The amendments also provide for the possibility of hiring five migrant workers without having to repeat the entire registration procedure in each individual case. Migrant workers employed under such an arrangement obtain official status. The Special Rapporteur nevertheless expresses concern that setting a limit of five workers may inadvertently lead to corrupt practices. In addition, the amendments introduce a requirement for advance payment of income tax in order to obtain a work permit, which may force migrant workers to remain with an employer against their will. If the payment is made by the employer, this may create the impression that the worker is the employer’s property, which must not be allowed.

58. The new Law on Migration should enshrine the rights of migrant workers and seasonal workers in accordance with international human rights standards, including the right to just and favourable conditions of work, including fair wages and remuneration, working conditions that meet occupational safety and health requirements, equal opportunities for promotion and rest, reasonable working hours and leave. The law should also enshrine the right to form and join trade unions.

59. The Special Rapporteur is extremely concerned about the introduction of a moratorium on inspection visits to small and medium-sized enterprises until 1 January 2015.

60. The Government should strengthen the system of labour inspections, in particular the mandate of the Committee for Control and Social Protection of the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population, and allocate sufficient human, financial and technical resources to ensure regular inspections by occupational safety inspectors and systematic investigations into cases of forced labour whenever such reports are received. Instruments should be developed to enable complaints to be considered urgently and appropriate responses to be taken. The number and scope of occupational safety inspections conducted without prior notification should be increased in the agricultural and construction industries, as well as in the services sector, and their regularity should be ensured as a key component of efforts to combat slavery and slavery-like practices, particularly forced labour and the worst forms of child labour. Such inspections should not be scheduled in advance or communicated to the enterprises where they are to be conducted. Inspections should be carried out by appropriately trained inspectors and without prior notification, in accordance with the international obligations undertaken by the State. In combating hazardous forms of child labour, labour inspectors should use the relevant ILO tools concerning international labour standards, as well as guidelines on labour regulation and occupational safety inspections, and provide information to employers and workers on the use of hazardous child labour, including advisory assistance on its elimination. Follow-up inspections should also be conducted to monitor the results achieved and ensure compliance with established requirements. Furthermore, as part of efforts to raise awareness, information on the activities of labour inspectors in combating slavery and on the rights of local workers and migrants should be regularly prepared and disseminated.

61. Forced and bonded labour continue to exist in the tobacco, cotton-growing and construction industries. Some progress has been achieved in the tobacco industry through targeted policies and support for the tobacco industry, as well as measures taken to strengthen the protection of migrant workers employed in the tobacco industry. The Government’s efforts should also cover other sectors, particularly cotton farming and the construction industry. The Special Rapporteur would also like to remind the Government and companies of the need to apply the Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.

62. The Special Rapporteur welcomes the issuance of an order guaranteeing access to education for all children residing in the territory of Kazakhstan, which enables the children of seasonal workers to attend school. She notes, however, that the order has not been fully implemented, since it does not eliminate barriers to access to education, including the requirement to provide identity documents for children of undocumented seasonal workers. The same applies to ensuring access to medical services for migrant workers and their family members, beyond the provision of emergency medical care, regardless of their migration status. Domestic legislation should be brought into line with the international obligations undertaken by the State with regard to the universal and unhindered exercise of the right to education and the provision of equal health protection for all persons within its territory, in accordance with the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

63. The Government should ratify the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families and the relevant ILO conventions on migrant workers, namely the Migration for Employment Convention (Revised), 1949 (No. 97), and the Migrant Workers (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, 1975 (No. 143). The Government should also reconsider its position and ratify the ILO Domestic Workers Convention, 2011 (No. 189), concerning decent work for domestic workers.

64. The Special Rapporteur reiterates the need to establish an effective system for the direct submission of complaints by migrant workers and all persons affected by violations of their labour rights, and for the thorough consideration of such complaints. Information about this complaints mechanism should be disseminated throughout the country, particularly in regions with a higher proportion of migrant workers; it should also be made available in languages they understand. The Office of the country’s Human Rights Commissioner should provide assistance in obtaining compensation for persons who have become victims of slavery.

65. A special compensation mechanism should be established, including a special fund for persons who have become victims of contemporary forms of slavery.

2. Awareness-Raising and Training

66. The Special Rapporteur reiterates the importance of bringing information about the nature of slavery and other slavery-like practices, as well as mechanisms for protecting victims, to the attention of the general public and relevant officials. Information about anti-slavery laws should be disseminated and made accessible for consultation, and the conventions on slavery should be published in the official gazette. In addition to disseminating information, special training should also be provided to judges, investigators, prosecutors, police officers and labour inspectors, including through human rights education, so that they acquire the knowledge necessary to identify slavery and slavery-like practices. The Special Rapporteur was pleased to learn that the Government recognizes the existence of such a need and has expressed its willingness to receive assistance in this regard.

B. Recommendations to the Business Community

67. The Special Rapporteur remains concerned about the widespread prevalence of forced and bonded labour, as well as the worst forms of child labour, in the tobacco, cotton-growing and construction industries, and calls upon enterprises to comply with international standards prohibiting the use of child and forced labour, as well as the Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Enterprises should incorporate human rights principles, including provisions on the prevention of and protection against slavery and slavery-like practices, into all contracts they conclude with farmers, suppliers and subcontractors.

C. Recommendations to the International Community

68. The Special Rapporteur noted the positive and significant role played by the international community in carrying out work aimed at combating slavery and slavery-like practices with all interested parties in Kazakhstan. She calls upon the international community to continue supporting this work and the work of civil society in Kazakhstan. Furthermore, she strongly urges the international community to assist Kazakhstan in addressing its information gaps by providing assistance in analysing information concerning contemporary forms of slavery and slavery-like practices. The Special Rapporteur calls upon the international community to respond positively to requests from the Government for assistance, particularly in the areas of training and legislative drafting, as well as human rights-oriented regulatory measures.

 

Constitution Law Code Regulatory Decree Order Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Programme Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages