Promotion and Protection of All Human Rights, Civil, Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Including the Right to Development (General Assembly)
Report of the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief, Heiner Bielefeldt. Human Rights Council, 23 December 2014
Addendum
Mission to Kazakhstan*
Summary
In the present report, the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief sets out the main findings resulting from his visit to Kazakhstan from 25 March to 4 April 2014. While emphasizing that religious diversity is generally recognized in the country, he noted negative attitudes towards certain non-traditional religious communities. The State exercises strict control over religious activities with a view to preventing extremism and combating “sects”, which, in its view, undermine the well-being of the population. Many of the measures adopted in this regard are not in conformity with international standards concerning freedom of religion or belief. Furthermore, the mandatory registration of religious communities, combined with closely interconnected requirements, substantially restricts the freedom to practise religion, which is exercised in the absence of legal certainty.
* The summary of the present report is circulated in all official languages. The report itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is circulated only in the language in which it was submitted and in Russian.
Annex
[English and Russian only]
** Report of the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief, Heiner Bielefeldt**
Contents Paragraphs [I. Introduction](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z1)...................................................1 [II. General observations](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z2)........................................2-15 [A. A society of religious pluralism](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z10).........................2-6 B. The State's awareness of its role in ensuring religious[pluralism](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z16)........................................................7–8 [C. Constitutional provisions](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z19)...................................9–15 [III. Challenges to the universal provision of security and[public order](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z3)...........................................16–23 [A. Concerns regarding religious extremism](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z27)..........16–19 [B. The issue of restrictions on freedom of religion or belief](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z32)....20–23 [IV. Mandatory administrative authorizations for religious[activities](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z4).....................................................24–40 A. Mandatory registration as a religious[association](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z37).....................................................24–31 [B. Theological criteria in registration decisions](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z46) .......32–34 [C. Registration of missionary activities](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z50).................35–37 [D. Import and distribution of religious literature](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z54)..........38–39 [E. Obstacles to religious charitable activities](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z57)................................................................40 V. Combating religious hatred and religious[extremism](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z5)....................................................41–51 A. Combating religious hatred constituting[incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z59)...........41–43 [B. Lack of clear definitions of criminal offences](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z63)................................................................44–51 VI. Educational efforts both in schools and outside[schools](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z6)............................................................52–64 A. Drawing a distinction between religious education and information about religion...........................................52–53 [B. Information about religion as part of the school curriculum](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z75)....54–57 [C. The issue of anti-sectarian campaigns](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z80)................58–59 [D. Promoting “religious literacy” among the population](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z83)..........60–62 [E. Religious upbringing of young people](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z87)........................63–64 [VII. Conclusions and recommendations](https://old.adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/O1400000005#z7) ...............................65–69
I. Introduction
1. The Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief, Heiner Bielefeldt, visited Kazakhstan from 25 March to 4 April 2014. First of all, he would like to express his gratitude for the standing invitation extended by the Government of Kazakhstan to all special procedures of the Human Rights Council. He would like to express his particular appreciation to the numerous interlocutors from various government institutions, a wide range of civil society organizations, a number of academics and various religious communities. Discussions took place in Astana, Almaty and Karaganda. The exchange of views, experiences and assessments with the various interlocutors took place in a constructive atmosphere. The United Nations country team in Astana played a key role in facilitating the organization of the visit and establishing important contacts with various government institutions, civil society organizations and religious communities. The Special Rapporteur would like to take this opportunity to once again express his appreciation to the United Nations Resident Coordinator and his team, and in particular to the Human Rights Programme Officer.
II. General observations
A. A society of religious pluralism
2. Representatives of the Government and civil society repeatedly emphasized that, despite its rich and long history, Kazakhstan remains a young country. Since gaining independence in 1991, Kazakhstan has experienced rapid and promising transformations, including unprecedentedly high rates of economic growth, the establishment of new State institutions, the development of numerous civil society organizations, the further development of ethnic, cultural and religious pluralism, and a revival of religious life, which has been reflected, in particular, in the construction of a number of impressive new religious buildings. 3. Religious pluralism is a distinctive feature of Kazakh society, with roots extending deep into history and perhaps even into prehistoric times. During discussions on this issue, many of the Special Rapporteur's interlocutors noted the culture of religious tolerance that has existed in the country since time immemorial. Some of them also particularly emphasized the country's “nomadic” traditions of hospitality and openness towards other people. Today, the two major faiths — Sunni Islam (the Hanafi school of thought) and Orthodoxy (the Russian Orthodox Church) — together with a number of smaller communities, define the country's religious composition. Muslims constitute the majority of the population, approximately 70 per cent, while Orthodox Christians are estimated to account for almost 25 per cent. Smaller communities include Catholics, Lutherans, Baptists, Methodists, Seventh-day Adventists, New Apostolics, Pentecostals, Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, Shiites, members of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, Baha'is, Buddhists, Scientologists and Krishna devotees. It should not be forgotten that there may also be a large number of atheists and agnostics, or people who are indifferent to religious beliefs and affiliations. Some of the above-mentioned communities have existed in Kazakhstan for several centuries, while others appeared on its territory at a later stage. According to the Special Rapporteur, many share the view that, as a rule, favourable relations exist between different religious communities. Cases of interreligious clashes appear to be extremely rare, and the population generally perceives religious diversity as an entirely natural phenomenon in Kazakhstan. 4. However, this generally positive attitude does not extend equally to members of non-traditional communities. According to a survey conducted by the Agency for Religious Affairs, the population as a whole displays varying degrees of goodwill towards traditional and non-traditional religious communities. Members of communities considered “non-traditional” reported that they sometimes encounter public scepticism, suspicion and discrimination. For example, they may find it difficult to rent a building or premises for community meetings or religious worship. Although government representatives generally avoid using the terms “traditional” and “non-traditional” when discussing this subject, except when referring to the regular high-level meetings of religious leaders held in Kazakhstan, none of them denied the existence of negative attitudes towards religious groups considered not to belong to the national “traditional set”. Furthermore, widespread concerns about religious extremism, which is often associated with certain Islamic movements, as well as concerns about the influence of “sects”, which are generally associated with small non-traditional groups, undermine the prevailing atmosphere of religious tolerance in society. 5. In Kazakhstan, religious pluralism and ethnic pluralism are virtually inseparable. While ethnic Kazakhs, who constitute the main ethnic group, generally consider themselves Muslims, ethnic Russians (who constitute the second-largest group) usually consider themselves Orthodox Christians. However, such perceptions and self-identification are not always reflected in active religious practice. Religion often appears to serve as an indicator of ethnic affiliation and vice versa. This complex religious pluralism is widely regarded as a solid foundation on which Kazakhstan's future should be built. A reflection of this ethno-religious pluralism is the Assembly of the People of Kazakhstan, headed by the country's President, which convenes at the national level at least once a year and brings together representatives of all segments of the population. 6. Conversion from one religion to another or to atheism is possible without any State interference. Although missionary activities aimed at converting people to one's faith are strictly controlled by the State, changing one's religion in itself does not entail any State sanctions. At the same time, given the close interconnection between religion and ethnicity, changing one's inherited religion may also be perceived as a break with one's ethnic and family environment, which may lead to social ostracism.
B. The State's awareness of its role in ensuring religious pluralism
7. On the international stage, Kazakhstan seeks to serve as a bridge between various international and regional organizations, as well as between the world's different religions. Since early 2013, Kazakhstan has been a member of the United Nations Human Rights Council. It is also a member of the United Nations Alliance of Civilizations. Kazakhstan plays an active role in the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe and takes pride in having chaired that Organization in 2010. Although Kazakhstan is not officially a member of the Council of Europe, it participates in the work of the European Commission for Democracy through Law (“Venice Commission”), which is intended to promote the dissemination of the principles of the rule of law throughout the States of Europe and the Eurasian region. In addition, Kazakhstan is a member of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, and the country's Government has demonstrated its commitment to strengthening the human rights component of that Organization. Finally, the Government takes particular pride in its role as host of the regular meetings of the Congress of Leaders of World and Traditional Religions. 8. Thus, Kazakhstan's political aspirations on the international stage and at the national level are linked to the promotion of friendly relations between representatives of different religions. This commitment to interreligious dialogue is largely attributable to the existing and newly revitalized pluralism in the country and the Government's experience in ensuring that pluralism. Established in 2011, the Agency for Religious Affairs plays an important role in facilitating meetings of various religious councils at both the regional and national levels. Such meetings are held at least four times a year. In addition to closed meetings for official members, some meetings are also open to non-members. Some representatives of religious minorities clearly acknowledged the Government's efforts in this area and suggested that, without the active role of the State, religious communities would probably meet less frequently.
C. Constitutional provisions
9. Kazakhstan considers itself a secular State that does not favour any particular religion or any particular beliefs. The secular character of the State is a defining feature under the 1995 Constitution. In accordance with article 1, paragraph 1, of the Constitution, “The Republic of Kazakhstan proclaims itself to be a democratic, secular, legal and social State whose highest values are the individual, his or her life, rights and freedoms”. Furthermore, in accordance with article 5, paragraph 4, of the Constitution, the activities of political parties on religious grounds are not permitted. 10. The secular character of the State was mentioned during numerous discussions with representatives of the Government and civil society organizations. In this regard, the Agency for Religious Affairs referred to public opinion polls indicating that the population widely supports the secular character of the State. Ideas about establishing a religious State, such as an Islamic State similar to those existing in some neighbouring countries, appear to be extremely unpopular. 11. Furthermore, the secular character of the State is widely perceived as a necessary condition for the Government to play an authoritative role in ensuring religious diversity. During discussions, government officials emphasized that the secular nature of Kazakhstan did not reflect a negative attitude towards religions, as was the case during the Soviet regime, but rather served as a guarantee of the State's neutral attitude towards the various religions existing in the country. At the same time, although government representatives clearly emphasized the need to prevent religions from exerting excessive influence on secular State institutions, they generally paid considerably less attention to the need to protect religious communities from excessive State control. This particular understanding of secularism is also reflected in political practice. The Government pursues a restrictive policy aimed at preventing religion from entering State institutions in any way, including public schools, administrative bodies and military institutions. For example, there are no military chaplains in the army. At the same time, the State adopts a fairly strict position with regard to controlling the activities of religious organizations, particularly non-traditional communities. During discussions on secularism, the Special Rapporteur recommended adopting a less restrictive position and applying a more favourable practice under which State institutions would create an open and inclusive environment to ensure the diversity of religions and beliefs in the public sphere as well. 12. The Constitution contains a number of human rights provisions, some of which are particularly important for the practice of ensuring freedom of religion or belief. Article 14 establishes the principles of equality and non-discrimination. Among the grounds of discrimination expressly prohibited under that article are “attitude towards religion” and “beliefs”. Article 19 guarantees everyone the right to determine and indicate, or not to indicate, their religious affiliation. The most important provision of the Constitution concerning freedom of religion or belief is article 22, which states: “1. Everyone shall have the right to freedom of conscience. 2. The exercise of the right to freedom of conscience must not result in or restrict universal human and civil rights and obligations to the State.” Furthermore, in accordance with article 39 of the Constitution, the right to freedom of conscience shall not be restricted under any circumstances. 13. The wording used in article 22 of the Constitution is clearly narrower than the wording contained in article 18 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which Kazakhstan ratified in 2006. While article 18 of the Covenant broadly covers the freedom of thought, conscience, religion or belief of every person in various manifestations of private and public life, at both the individual and collective levels, article 22 of the Constitution merely refers to the freedom of conscience of every person. Furthermore, in comparison with article 22, paragraph 2, of the Constitution, under which the question of possible restrictions remains fairly open, the criteria for restricting the freedom to manifest one's religion or beliefs, as established in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant, are defined more precisely and clearly. 14. Under the Constitution, international human rights treaties take precedence over conflicting domestic laws, with the exception of the Constitution, which remains the supreme law of the country. While article 4, paragraph 2, establishes the highest legal authority of the Constitution as the document having “the highest legal force” in Kazakhstan, article 4, paragraph 3, provides that “International treaties ratified by the Republic shall have priority over its laws and shall be directly applicable, except in cases where it follows from an international treaty that a law must be adopted for its application”. 15. A number of State institutions, including the Commission on Human Rights under the President and the Ombudsman, are authorized to monitor the human rights situation in the country on the basis of constitutional and international standards. At present, the Ombudsman has an office only in the capital, although the establishment of corresponding regional offices is currently under discussion.
III. Challenges to the universal provision of security and public order
A. Concerns regarding religious extremism
16. The active role of the Government in ensuring religious pluralism appears to be largely motivated by concerns about religious extremism. In addition to civil servants, similar concerns were also expressed by employees of civil society organizations and representatives of religious communities. In the context of religious wars, violent clashes on religious grounds and even terrorist acts occurring in some countries neighbouring Kazakhstan, the current concerns are certainly understandable. 17. Several academics agreed that, owing to the Soviet legacy, most believers do not have a deep understanding of their own religious traditions and may therefore, in their view, be susceptible to the influence of superficial slogans of religious radicalism. The almost inseparable intertwining of religious and ethnic pluralism in Kazakhstan may intensify security concerns. 18. During numerous discussions, particularly with government representatives, such key words as stability, tranquillity and harmony were frequently heard. The Special Rapporteur agrees that the political stability that has generally been maintained in Kazakhstan since independence is an achievement worthy of praise and further development. At the same time, a strong emphasis on stability may lead, and does lead, to human rights standards, including freedom of religion or belief, being subordinated to broadly defined considerations of security and public order. This even overshadows the high normative status of human rights, including freedom of religion or belief, as inalienable rights. 19. The Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize once again that freedom of religion or belief is not merely the result of effective State policies to ensure diversity, but has the status of a universal right belonging to all people. Everyone must be able to practise their religion or beliefs at the individual and collective levels, in private or in public. Possession of this freedom is the right of every person, which exists prior to and ultimately independently of any administrative authorization. Furthermore, there are various ways in which people express their freedom of religion or belief. These include traditional and less traditional forms of religious practice, information and communication activities within and outside one's religious community, education at the family and community levels, organized charitable activities, the import and distribution of religious literature, and the establishment of appropriate religious infrastructure facilities. It has been reported that these freedoms are restricted by law and in practice, primarily with regard to members of so-called “non-traditional” communities.
B. The issue of restrictions on freedom of religion or belief
20. During discussions with government representatives, they all agreed that it could not be said that freedom of religion or belief, apart from its fully protected internal dimension (forum internum), was entirely free from restrictions. However, disagreements were repeatedly noted regarding where the boundary should be drawn. Fortunately, international human rights law provides clear guidance in this regard. What is decisive is that the burden of proof always rests with those advocating restrictions, rather than with those defending or exercising the human right to freedom. In other words, the relationship between a person's right to freedom and restrictions on that right must remain the same as the relationship between a rule and an exception to it. In cases of doubt, the rule prevails, and any recognition of exceptions always requires additional justification, both at the level of empirical evidence and at the level of normative arguments. 21. Restrictions on freedom of religion or belief cannot be lawful unless they meet all the criteria established in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant. Accordingly, they must be prescribed by law; they must be clearly necessary (that is, they must constitute a measure of last resort) to achieve a legitimate aim; and they must remain proportionate, which means, among other things, that they must be limited to the minimum interference necessary to achieve one of the legitimate aims. Furthermore, restrictions must not be associated with any discriminatory intent or consequences. 22. During discussions with government representatives, the Special Rapporteur frequently observed a different starting point for considering the relationship between the right to freedom and its possible restrictions. Instead of assessing the legitimacy of State-imposed restrictions in light of the recognized status of universal human rights, the idea appears to be widespread that the exercise of freedom of religion or belief, and even the basic elements of this human right, requires special State authorization, which one government representative largely compared to the issuance of a driver's licence. Rather than applying State-imposed restrictions only as a measure of last resort involving the minimum possible interference, some government representatives advocated broad State intervention and control measures. Such restrictive tendencies are also reflected in Kazakhstan's legislation, including the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, which entered into force on 11 October 2011. The corresponding negative consequences for the full exercise of freedom of religion or belief by every person are reflected in many of the reports received. 23. The Special Rapporteur is convinced that there is no inherent contradiction between the human right to freedom and the State's obligation to ensure peace or stability within its territory, which is undoubtedly extremely difficult to achieve on a broader regional scale in Central Asia. By fully respecting human rights, including freedom of religion or belief, the State can in fact enhance its authority as a guarantor of peace based on the “recognition of the inherent dignity” of all members of the human family, as stated in the preamble to the first international human rights document in history, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948. Furthermore, full respect for human rights creates the best conditions for strengthening trust within society, as well as between State institutions and the population as a whole. In combating such scourges as religious hatred and religious extremism, the State must also always fully respect human rights, including freedom of thought, conscience, religion or belief, which are nevertheless considered inalienable rights. Any restrictions imposed on a human right, where necessary, must be justified in light of the specific normative status of that right and must comply with all the criteria established in article 18 of the Covenant and other relevant provisions¹.
¹ Restrictions must comply with article 4 of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination and article 18, paragraph 3, article 19, paragraph 3, and article 20 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, as well as Security Council resolution 1624 and various relevant resolutions of the Human Rights Council and the General Assembly and the practice of treaty bodies.
IV. Mandatory administrative authorizations for religious activities
A. Mandatory registration as a religious association
24. During many discussions, one of the main issues concerned the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations. This new law, which replaced the old law of 1992, notes the historical role of the Hanafi school of thought and Orthodoxy in the development of the cultural and spiritual life of Kazakhstan, and also recognizes other religions. Furthermore, the Agency for Religious Affairs mentioned above was established pursuant to the 2011 Law and constitutes the State body responsible for State regulation of religious activities. 25. The main distinguishing feature of the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations is the requirement introduced for all religious communities to register within a specified period (i.e. within one year) in order to retain or obtain the status of a registered religious association at the national, regional or local levels. While government representatives noted that many States apply the practice of registering religious organizations, members of certain religious communities or civil society organizations criticized the 2011 Law as the main source of the lack of legal certainty and administrative repression. 26. Before beginning the discussion of this issue, the Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize once again that registration procedures must be based on a clear understanding that the right to freedom of religion or belief, by virtue of its nature as a human right, belongs to all people from birth and can never become dependent on any specific State action to approve or administratively register it. In other words, freedom of religion or belief cannot be “created” through any administrative procedures. Rather, registration must serve the purposes of this human right, the existence of which precedes any registration. On the basis of this general understanding, registration should not be a mandatory legal requirement, but a service offered by the State. In this regard, the situation of unregistered religious communities serves as a test of the important question of how the normative status of freedom of religion or belief is understood in general. 27. Although most religious communities in Kazakhstan were able to successfully, or at least partially, re-register following the entry into force of the 2011 Law, some applications were not granted. A number of communities lost their previous legal status, while others were not registered at all. There are also examples of several small groups (for example, some Evangelical communities) which, as a matter of principle, generally refuse official State registration. Other religious communities managed to register at the local level but were unable to obtain registration at the regional and national levels. The main reason for this situation is the relatively high requirements established for registration at the national level. 28. The main problem associated with the organization of religious registration is that unregistered religious groups are virtually unable to perform any collective religious functions in Kazakhstan. Any form of their activities, including even communal prayers and the performance of rituals in private homes, is considered illegal and may entail serious administrative penalties. Such punitive measures are indeed applied in practice and sometimes result in the payment of substantial fines imposed under articles 374-1 and 375 of the Administrative Code, disproportionately affecting non-traditional communities. The Special Rapporteur also heard credible accounts of police raids on the premises of certain unregistered groups, during which computers, literature, mobile telephones and other property were confiscated. It should be noted that registration under the Law on Public Associations cannot be an acceptable alternative for those associations that have been unable to register under the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, since the status of a public (secular) association, which is much easier to obtain than registration as a religious association, does not allow associations to perform religious functions. Consequently, unregistered religious communities and their members suffer serious violations of their freedom of religion or belief. They are particularly vulnerable to intimidation by law enforcement authorities and live in constant fear of possible sanctions being imposed against them. 29. The Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations also restricts the religious activities of communities whose registration status is legally valid only within a specific territory. Given the high requirements for national registration, at present only communities belonging to Sunni Islam, the Russian Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church have the status of religious associations throughout the country, while other re-registered communities have managed to obtain registration only at the local and/or regional levels. This means that their community practices are considered lawful only within certain territorial boundaries in the country. The performance of religious worship outside those territorial boundaries may give rise to legal problems, including administrative penalties. It appears that the likelihood of punitive measures being applied in practice depends on the general reputation of the particular religious community in society. In this case, the traditional or non-traditional nature of the religion once again becomes the decisive factor. While traditional religious communities can generally carry out their activities without any problems, non-traditional and small communities face a considerably greater risk of punitive measures being applied if they conduct activities outside the specified territorial boundaries. The Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize that even representatives of minorities who generally described their relations with State authorities as “constructive” complained about the lack of legal clarity and the corresponding negative consequences for their religious community life. 30. One of the objectives of the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations appears to have been to obtain the ability to exercise clear oversight over the activities of religious denominations in Kazakhstan. The Special Rapporteur was informed that there are currently 18 religions or denominations in the country. However, the possibility of assessing the extent of religious pluralism in the country in practice is questionable. From the perspective of freedom of religion or belief, what is primarily necessary is an inclusive system that provides for broad self-understanding by people as individuals and in their relationships with others within communities. The Special Rapporteur gained a clear impression that religious diversity in Kazakhstan is not limited to the 18 denominations that constitute the official religious composition of the population. 31. Communities belonging to the majority religion, Islam, are usually represented by the Spiritual Administration of Muslims of Kazakhstan (SAMK). Most of the Muslims with whom the Special Rapporteur was able to discuss this issue gave a positive assessment of the role of the SAMK. However, there are certain Islamic minorities which, for various reasons, insist on obtaining independent status. For example, members of the Tatar-Bashkir community at the “Din-Muhammad” mosque in Petropavlovsk, North Kazakhstan Region, believe that their distinctive linguistic and spiritual heritage can be better preserved if they remain an organization independent of the SAMK. This community at the “Din-Muhammad” mosque submitted an application for re-registration in accordance with the deadlines established by the 2011 Law. As a result, the State began to exert serious pressure on the community and its imam to join the SAMK. Because of the community's unwillingness to comply, it was denied registration. On 12 September 2013, the Court of Appeal issued a decision ordering its compulsory dissolution. It is reported that, although the mosque itself remains open for prayer, the community has been legally dissolved, and the SAMK is expected to appoint a new imam in the near future.
B. Theological criteria in registration decisions
32. The Special Rapporteur received information from the Government indicating that decisions on applications for registration or re-registration as religious associations are always made in a spirit of scientific neutrality, without taking any theological criteria into account. This is also consistent with the State's self-understanding as a secular State, as set out in article 1 of the Constitution. However, the Special Rapporteur learned of at least one case of a clear departure from this principle, which may indicate the existence of a broader problem. The application for re-registration submitted by the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community was rejected on the basis of a decision unequivocally formulated from the theological perspective of Sunni Islam. Although the entire document is written in religious language, it refers to a decision by the main religious body of Sunni Muslims, the Muslim World League, denying Ahmadis the right to identify themselves as Muslims. 33. The criteria for determining the essential elements of a particular religion generally continue to give rise to disagreements within different religions. Freedom of religion or belief allows for such disagreements to the extent that they do not result in discriminatory, hostile or violent acts. Thus, religious communities may peacefully separate from other religious branches or schools which, in their view, depart from the fundamental principles of their faith. However, the State cannot intervene and give legal force to certain theological interpretations through measures adopted under administrative law. In recognizing the freedom of religion or belief of every person, the starting point must be people's self-understanding and their own perception of their beliefs. 34. After losing its status as a religious association under the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, a small group consisting of several hundred people, effectively ceased carrying out any community activities in Kazakhstan. Its meetings, if they are organized at all, can only be held underground. Members of this community constantly fear possible police raids and legal sanctions. In addition to the obvious shortcomings identified during the examination of the application of this small community, its situation also demonstrates the negative consequences of mandatory registration in general and, consequently, the clear need for reforms.
C. Registration of missionary activities
35. The Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations requires private individuals, including citizens of Kazakhstan, who engage in religious activities of a certain degree of public significance to register as “missionaries”. Failure to comply with this requirement constitutes an offence punishable by law. Since registration of missionary activities is valid for only one year, it must be renewed annually. Furthermore, the concept of “missionary activity” appears to be vaguely defined, and there is a lack of consistency in administrative practice. While representatives of traditional religious communities can, in practice, actively perform their religious functions without special missionary permits, members of smaller groups have been effectively penalized merely for speaking about their faith or publicly answering questions. It is reported that the term “missionary activity” is sometimes used so broadly that it encompasses virtually all forms of witnessing and providing information about faith. The lack of legal clarity in this important area appears to create a sense of insecurity and being left “in limbo”, as one interlocutor belonging to a religious minority community put it. These provisions particularly concern Jehovah's Witnesses, who, within the framework of their religious doctrine, consider it their duty to spread their beliefs among other people. The Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize once again that concerns about the restrictive consequences of registration requirements were expressed by members of various communities, including communities that stated that they maintained constructive relations with local, regional or national institutions and participated in meetings of various religious councils held under the auspices of the Agency for Religious Affairs. 36. In accordance with international standards, freedom of religion or belief clearly includes the right to disseminate one's beliefs, exchange information within and across religious and denominational boundaries, and seek to convert other people to one's faith without coercion. This also covers missionary activities in the broadest sense. Without taking into account more specific visa-related issues concerning non-citizens wishing to enter the country from abroad, such activities generally do not require official State approval, particularly when carried out by citizens or permanent residents of the country. 37. The legal and practical problems associated with mandatory registration are further exacerbated by the fact that all forms of expression of beliefs are often classified as “missionary activity”. Thus, the lack of legal certainty seriously restricts an extremely broad area of religious practice, particularly in the case of representatives of “non-traditional” religious minorities. Furthermore, even individuals who have permission to engage in missionary activities may encounter problems when travelling beyond the territorial boundaries within which their community has registered status. As mentioned earlier, only communities belonging to Sunni Muslims, the Russian Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church have national registration, while all other communities are officially recognized only within the territory of a particular district and region, beyond which any overt and communal activity may be considered “illegal” under the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations. Another problem arises when a certain amount of time is required to renew a permit, creating an additional factor of legal uncertainty during the waiting period.
D. Import and distribution of religious literature
38. This issue concerns the importation of religious literature, for which State consent is again required if the volume of imported materials exceeds the threshold established for personal use (i.e. three copies of a book). According to the Agency for Religious Affairs, in the overwhelming majority of cases such authorization can be obtained without particular difficulty. The Special Rapporteur was informed by the Government that the State intervenes in this area primarily to prevent religious hatred and religious extremism. Although he shares the view that religious hatred and religious extremism are serious problems requiring State action, the question remains open as to whether the measures adopted meet the criteria set out in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant and other relevant international standards. Having examined examples provided by various religious communities that had encountered problems relating to the import and distribution of religious literature, the Special Rapporteur became convinced that the restrictions imposed on the importation of such materials into Kazakhstan are disproportionate to the objectives pursued. For example, in 2012 and 2013, Jehovah's Witnesses submitted applications to import a number of religious publications, including monthly magazines published by their community. It is reported that the Agency for Religious Affairs prohibited the importation of some of these publications. In its decision of 31 January 2013, the Agency explained that the publications prohibited from being imported called for the rejection of secular education, encouraged the breakdown of families and contained ideas that could cause indignation among members of traditional Christian communities (for example, the view that the Bible does not mention the Holy Trinity). The Agency suggested that Jehovah's Witnesses amend the content of the publications and submit the amended versions for approval. 39. Shops selling religious literature must also hold a special licence. According to information provided by the Agency for Religious Affairs, the number of shops authorized to sell religious literature exceeds 250 throughout the country, and applications for licences are generally granted without any problems. At the same time, although government representatives claim that, in practice, religious communities do not encounter serious problems in obtaining the literature they need, the very existence of a requirement to obtain special authorization indicates that the understanding of the relationship between the fundamental right to freedom and its restrictions has been turned upside down. Instead of proceeding from the understanding that freedom of religion or belief has the status of a human right, restrictions on which must be justified in light of the criteria set out in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant, in Kazakhstan persons wishing to exercise their right to use, import or distribute religious literature must request special authorization from the State. This is contrary to international standards concerning freedom of religion and belief. Furthermore, the restrictive provisions violate the right to freedom of expression, as enshrined in article 19 of the Covenant.
E. Obstacles to Religious Charitable Activities
Representatives of religious communities also reported problems that they encounter when attempting to organize charitable activities. This may be explained by a narrow understanding of religion or belief exclusively as the performance of religious worship and rituals. At the same time, many believers and religious organizations regard charitable activities as part of their mission, both for the benefit of their own communities and beyond them. The Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize that the right to manifest one's religion or belief, as provided for in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant, concerns “practice” in a broad sense and therefore also encompasses charitable activities. Furthermore, in accordance with article 6 (b) of the Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief (1981), the right to freedom of thought, conscience, religion or belief includes, inter alia, “the right to establish and maintain appropriate charitable or humanitarian institutions”.
V. Combating Religious Hatred and Religious Extremism
A. Combating Religious Hatred Constituting Incitement to Discrimination, Hostility or Violence
The Special Rapporteur notes the Government's efforts to combat religious hatred, intolerance and extremism. Stability in Kazakhstan, particularly in comparison with certain neighbouring States suffering from violent religious conflicts, is a great asset that must be carefully preserved. During discussions with various stakeholders, including civil society organizations, the Special Rapporteur gained the impression that there is broad agreement on the need to remain vigilant and to adopt appropriate policy measures in this area.
During some discussions held with government representatives, the Special Rapporteur expressed his views on the Rabat Plan of Action on the prohibition of advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence, adopted in October 2012 under the auspices of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights². The Rabat Plan of Action has received broad support from the international community, including Kazakhstan. As its title indicates, the document addresses measures that Governments and other stakeholders should adopt to combat acts of incitement to hatred. While the Rabat Plan of Action proposes a broad range of measures in this area for States to take, it also establishes a high threshold for restrictive legal measures in order to fully safeguard freedom of expression and other communicative human rights. The main message of the Rabat Plan of Action is a call for the creative use of freedom of expression to combat “hate speech” through “positive speech” and to counter those who incite hatred through advocacy and awareness-raising. Responsible officials in government authorities, religious communities, civil society organizations, the media and other organizations should jointly and unequivocally speak out against incitement to hatred and openly demonstrate solidarity with the groups affected.
Kazakhstan's commitment to interreligious dialogue is consistent with some of the key recommendations contained in the Rabat Plan of Action. As mentioned earlier, the Government's involvement in this area includes national efforts to establish cooperation with religious communities and to organize meetings of religious leaders, which have already been held in Kazakhstan four times. The Fifth Congress of Leaders of World and Traditional Religions will take place in Astana in 2015.
² A/HRC/22/17/Add.4, addendum.
B. Lack of Clear Definitions of Criminal Offences
In combating religious hatred, Kazakhstan also uses criminal penalties. In this context, human rights concerns arise from the overly broad terminology used in certain articles of the Law on Counteracting Extremism, the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences. During his visit, the Special Rapporteur learned that the existing Criminal Code and Code of Administrative Offences would soon be replaced by a new Criminal Code and a new Code of Administrative Offences, which had been adopted in July 2014 and would enter into force on 1 January 2015. During the visit, the Special Rapporteur gained the impression that the forthcoming reforms, which were discussed with a number of government representatives, would provide an opportunity for significant changes and greater clarity. However, upon examining the new versions of the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences, the Special Rapporteur noted with disappointment that this opportunity had not been taken. He hopes that it is not yet too late to introduce the amendments necessary to bring the legislation into line with international standards.
The Criminal Code (both its current version and the new version) provides for penalties ranging from substantial fines to imprisonment for up to seven years for offences related to extremism, including incitement to religious enmity or discord, insulting the religious feelings of citizens, and promoting the superiority or inferiority of citizens on the basis of their attitude towards religion³; for establishing and leading an illegal religious association whose activities involve violence against citizens or otherwise cause harm to their health, or incite citizens to refuse to perform their civic duties, as well as participating in such an association; for establishing, leading or participating in a religious party or public organization that proclaims or implements religious intolerance or exclusivity in practice⁴; and for organizing or participating in the activities of an organization prohibited or dissolved by court decision in connection with the commission of extremism⁵.
Many of these provisions do not contain clear definitions and are interpreted quite broadly. Perhaps the most striking example is article 164 of the current Criminal Code (article 174 of the new Criminal Code). In this article, the concept of “incitement to religious enmity” is conflated with a number of other phenomena, such as “insulting religious feelings”. Given its broad wording, even statements concerning exclusivity or superiority made on behalf of individual religions could fall under this article. However, because of the broad interpretation of the constituent elements of criminal offences, any undesirable religious statements perceived as offensive by a section of society or by certain government authorities may result in criminal penalties, including imprisonment. This creates legal uncertainty, with corresponding negative consequences for freedom of expression and freedom of religion or belief.
The threat of punishment is real, not hypothetical. Article 164 of the Criminal Code has been applied repeatedly in practice, and a number of persons convicted under this article remain in prison. During discussions with representatives of civil society organizations working in this field, the Special Rapporteur was informed of deeply concerning cases involving accusations against representatives of various religious communities, which resulted in interrogations, administrative detention and lengthy periods of pretrial detention. Although he was unable to examine all the individual cases brought to his attention, the Special Rapporteur is convinced that article 164 of the current Criminal Code gives rise to serious concerns because of the excessively broad interpretation of the offences it contains. Therefore, from the perspective of his mandate, he would also like to endorse the recommendation on this matter made by the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination in March 2014 in its concluding observations on Kazakhstan's periodic report. The Committee recommended that the State party “clearly define criminal offences, in particular in article 164 of the Criminal Code, so that they do not lead to unjustified or disproportionate restrictions on freedom of expression, including that of minority communities”⁶. This recommendation will remain applicable to the new Criminal Code, particularly article 174.
Article 337-1 of the current Criminal Code (article 404 of the new Criminal Code), which concerns associations accused of engaging in extremism, including religious extremism, raises similar concerns. Again, there is no doubt that the Government should take active measures to combat religious extremism, particularly organized religious extremism, and that the Criminal Code may be one of the various instruments used for this purpose. However, article 337-1 of the Criminal Code (and its new equivalent) first and foremost lacks a clear definition of the term “religious extremism”. Without such a definition, this provision gives unlimited scope for the application of punitive measures against individuals or groups of individuals who may appear suspicious to certain government authorities, including law enforcement agencies. Once again, this danger is not merely hypothetical.
On 18 February 2005, Kazakhstan adopted the Law on Counteracting Extremism, which, inter alia, defines religious extremism and measures for its prevention. Under the Law, religious extremism is understood as incitement to religious enmity or discord, including that associated with violence or calls for violence, as well as the application of any religious practice that poses a threat to the security, life, health, morality or rights and freedoms of citizens⁷. Furthermore, extremist (religious) propaganda is defined in the Law as deliberate actions aimed at inciting religious discord or insulting the religious feelings of citizens. The Law authorizes the Agency for Religious Affairs and local and district executive authorities to examine the activities of missionaries and religious associations that violate the legislation on counteracting extremism and to take preventive measures against them⁸. The Special Rapporteur is concerned that the definition of religious extremism in Kazakhstan's Law on Counteracting Extremism is excessively broad and vague, thereby creating conditions for its arbitrary application.
In addition, both the current and the new Codes of Administrative Offences provide for penalties ranging from substantial fines to detention for the publication, possession, import, transportation and distribution of materials aimed at inciting religious discord⁹; for leading, financing and participating in the activities of unregistered religious associations, as well as associations whose activities have been suspended or prohibited¹⁰; for violating legislation concerning religious activities and religious organizations, including failure to comply with requirements relating to the conduct of religious rites, ceremonies and gatherings, the import, publication and/or distribution of religious literature, as well as the construction of places of worship; engaging in missionary activities without registration (authorization); a foreign national leading a religious organization without approval from the authorized body; and the participation of minors in the activities of a religious organization without the consent of both parents¹¹. The Code of Administrative Offences also provides for a wide range of penalties for religious organizations, including fines, suspension of activities and a complete ban on the organization's activities for violating legislation concerning religious activities and religious organizations, including failure to comply with financial requirements or safety regulations¹².
During discussions concerning criminal and/or administrative proceedings, some civil society organizations complained about the lack of transparency and fairness in the procedures. They noted that it was difficult for accused persons and their lawyers to obtain important documents on which the charges were based. The Special Rapporteur was also informed of cases of excessively lengthy administrative detention and pretrial detention, as well as unacceptable conditions of detention. Concerns were also expressed that psychiatric treatment was being used as a means of discipline, control and punishment of persons suspected of holding and promoting religious beliefs considered dangerous. This situation further aggravates the negative impact of vague provisions of criminal law on freedom of expression and freedom of religion or belief.
³ Article 164 of the 1997 Criminal Code and article 174 of the 2014 Criminal Code.⁴ Article 337 of the 1997 Criminal Code and article 404 of the 2014 Criminal Code.⁵ Article 337-1 of the 1997 Criminal Code and article 404 of the 2014 Criminal Code.⁶ CERD/C/KAZ/CO/6-7, para. 13.⁷ Article 1 of the Law on Counteracting Extremism.⁸ Article 6 of the Law on Counteracting Extremism.⁹ Articles 343 and 344 of the 2001 Code of Administrative Offences and article 453 of the 2014 Code of Administrative Offences.¹⁰ Articles 374-1 of the 2001 Code of Administrative Offences and article 489 of the 2014 Code of Administrative Offences.¹¹ Ibid.¹² Ibid.
VI. Educational Efforts in Schools and Beyond
A. Distinguishing Between Religious Education and Information about Religions
During discussions on education, reference was made to the Toledo Guiding Principles on Teaching about Religions and Beliefs in Public Schools, developed by the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe¹³. The Toledo Guiding Principles make a clear distinction between education intended to familiarize students with their own religious traditions and education intended to broaden students' general knowledge of religion. While the former may be defined as “religious instruction”, the latter may be called “teaching about religions”. Whereas “religious instruction” is based on the principles of a particular faith, “teaching about religions” must be provided in a neutral and impartial manner. Mixing or combining the two types of education may result in serious violations of freedom of religion or belief, particularly in the context of compulsory schooling.
Since public schools in Kazakhstan are secular, the school curriculum includes only general information about religions and does not provide religious instruction concerning any particular faith. Therefore, religious communities are entirely responsible for familiarizing the younger generation with specific religious traditions.
¹³ The Toledo Guiding Principles, published in 2007, were developed by the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) and its Advisory Council of Experts on Freedom of Religion or Belief.
B. Information about Religions as Part of the School Curriculum
As already mentioned, Kazakhstan adheres to a clear understanding of secularism, which is also reflected in its school curriculum. The Ministry of Education introduced religious education in the form of information about religions only a few years ago. At present, this subject is taught for one year in the ninth grade. The Ministry does not intend to extend this period. During discussions on this subject with teachers in schools, the Special Rapporteur concluded that the topic arouses considerable interest among students, who would like to learn more about religions. This subject is generally taught on school premises and, according to the information received, does not include visits to places of worship or religious sites located near schools.
The textbook for ninth-grade students on this subject contains a neutral description of various world religions. However, the chapter devoted to “new religious movements” is written in a tone that clearly warns students about the danger of being converted or manipulated in connection with a particular type of religious movement. No specific religious groups are identified in this chapter.
Although the dangers discussed in the textbooks certainly exist, they should not be associated with any particular religion, such as “new religious movements”. Unfortunately, the history of religions is rich in examples of the use of force, coercion and manipulation by traditional and new religions, large and small communities, organized groups, as well as less organized movements. Associating “destructive” tendencies exclusively with one type of religion may contribute to the entrenchment of prejudices against small groups, often referred to as sects. On closer examination, this category of small groups and new religious movements encompasses a broad range of different religions and beliefs, which should be considered in accordance with their distinctive characteristics.
During his visit to the city of Karaganda, the Special Rapporteur discussed history curricula, including the history of repression during the totalitarian regime. He learned that during the Soviet era many political opponents and dissidents were exiled to Karaganda, and many of them were held in concentration camps. He held extensive discussions on the importance of teaching history as part of broader human rights education programmes, both in schools and outside them. Such human rights education should cover the entire spectrum of human rights, including freedom of religion or belief.
C. The Problem of Anti-Sect Campaigns
Members of small religious communities repeatedly expressed concern about anti-sect campaigns organized by municipal “anti-sect centres”. There appears to be a prevailing opinion in society that certain religious communities, particularly small and less traditional communities, pose a threat to people's health and well-being. In many cases, such concerns are not based on any factual evidence. The Special Rapporteur saw several campaign brochures devoted to specific communities that contained no reliable facts.
Under the right to freedom of religion or belief, Governments have an obligation to eliminate negative stereotypes and create an atmosphere of mutual respect among different religious groups. Issuing public warnings against particular communities may amount to an infringement of the freedom of religion or belief of members of those groups. Such measures are permissible only where they meet all the criteria for restrictions on the freedom to manifest one's religion or belief established in article 18, paragraph 3, of the Covenant, including the principle of proportionality. Furthermore, in order to ensure fair treatment of the religious communities concerned, all available facts and data must be approached with great care. The Special Rapporteur is convinced that the examples of anti-sect activities brought to his attention do not meet these criteria.
D. Promoting “Religious Literacy” among the Population
In view of the importance of sound religious knowledge and understanding for overcoming negative stereotypes and ensuring peaceful coexistence in conditions of religious pluralism, religious education programmes should extend beyond school education and be accessible to broad sections of the population.
The Special Rapporteur met with representatives of several organizations engaged in promoting “religious literacy” in society. Some of them work closely with the Agency for Religious Affairs. They engage in various activities: familiarizing people with the richness of religious traditions, ensuring a deeper understanding of religious diversity, promoting interfaith dialogue and strengthening resilience to religious hatred and extremism. Their objectives clearly overlap. As experts explain, one of the fundamental principles in this area is that religious extremists, although they generally claim to represent a “pure” version of their faith, often demonstrate a rather narrow understanding of religious views and ideas. Disseminating knowledge and raising awareness could help people learn not to be influenced by these simplistic slogans. The need to promote “religious literacy” is often associated with the Soviet past, which led to a sharp restriction of religious practice and knowledge in society.
The Special Rapporteur acknowledges initiatives aimed at promoting “religious literacy” in society. He considers this positive approach to be far more productive than campaigns conducted by anti-sect centres, which, in his view, give rise to serious problems. The Toledo Guiding Principles contain criteria that may also be used in developing religious literacy programmes, including those conducted outside public schools.
E. Religious Education of Young People
In the absence of religious instruction, as discussed in section VI.A above, the task of informing the younger generation in Kazakhstan about their own religion rests entirely with religious communities. Representatives of various communities described how they carry out this task. Some expressed concern that the lack of legal certainty in the broad area of religious manifestations under the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations also affects their educational efforts. The Special Rapporteur was informed of cases in which private religious schools had been closed by the authorities on the grounds of alleged violations of the law. One of the reasons cited was that religious communities engaged in educating the younger generation should not call their activities “teaching”. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur would like to reiterate that freedom of religious education is one of the key elements of freedom of religion or belief under article 18 of the Covenant, as well as article 6 (e) of the Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief.
According to reports, minors participating in religious services must have written permission from both parents. In practice, it is difficult for providers of religious services to ask young people to produce such permission, as this may cause them to feel alienated. This is another example of legal uncertainty that impedes the full activities of religious communities, particularly small and non-traditional minorities. Representatives of religious communities, including traditional communities that generally enjoy good relations with the government authority, expressed support for greater legal clarity, based on the understanding that education and instruction are among the fundamental elements of the human right to freedom of religion or belief.
VII. Conclusions and Recommendations
Government representatives repeatedly emphasized that Kazakhstan had embarked on a process of rapid and far-reaching transformation. The country seeks to fully realize its potential as a “bridge” between different geographical and cultural regions, as well as between international and regional organizations. Reforms are already being implemented at the national level, including in the legislative sphere. In this context, the Special Rapporteur noted encouraging statements expressing a commitment to further developing a culture of peaceful interethnic and interreligious coexistence, which has had a major influence on the country's history. Following the dissolution of the Soviet Union, religious life in Kazakhstan experienced a revival, manifested, inter alia, in the construction of impressive religious buildings.
The Agency for Religious Affairs, established in 2011 as the central government body responsible for implementing State regulation of the religious sphere, plays an active role in managing religious diversity at both the national and regional levels. A significant part of its activities, such as facilitating interreligious meetings, is supported by many representatives of religious communities, including minority communities. At the same time, the Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, adopted in 2011, contains restrictive elements that are contrary to international standards on freedom of religion or belief. The most obvious problem concerns mandatory official registration. The absence of such status means that a religious community is considered “illegal”, which has far-reaching negative consequences for the exercise of the right to freedom of religion or belief. Furthermore, even communities that are officially registered suffer to some extent from legal uncertainty, particularly in connection with the official restriction of permitted religious activities to predetermined subject matters and territorial boundaries. Overall, the 2011 Law is based on the assumption that the exercise of fundamental aspects of freedom of religion depends on specific government approval, thereby turning upside down the relationship between freedom and restrictions that is normally understood in the context of human rights.
Although Kazakhstan generally supports religious pluralism, members of small non-traditional religious communities, often referred to as sects, continue to face suspicion, distrust and discrimination in society. Furthermore, certain provisions of the current and new versions of the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences aimed at combating religious hatred and religious extremism contain vague definitions, thereby creating an atmosphere of legal uncertainty, which is further aggravated by deficiencies in criminal proceedings, lengthy periods of pretrial detention and related problems. Similar problems are characteristic of the 2005 Law on Counteracting Extremism.
At present, information about religion plays a rather limited role in public school education. The textbooks used for this purpose contain ambiguous wording and warnings concerning non-traditional religious movements. Some initiatives undertaken to promote “religious literacy” in society may play a positive role in empowering individuals to make their own decisions on matters of religion and belief.
In view of the above, the Special Rapporteur makes the following recommendations:
a) Public discussion of the concept of secularism in Kazakhstan should contribute to changing the currently prevailing restrictive interpretation, according to which secularism is understood as an instrument for restricting manifestations of freedom of religion or belief to predetermined and strictly controlled territorial boundaries. A secular Constitution based on the principle of freedom of religion or belief for all should create opportunities for the development of existing and emerging religious pluralism in a society free from fear and discrimination. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the Government consider amending the relevant provisions of the Constitution in order to bring them into line with article 18 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In this regard, an open discussion of a comprehensive understanding of the secular nature of the State may also help overcome restrictive approaches within administrative and law enforcement authorities.
b) The Government should bring the provisions of its Constitution concerning freedom of religion or belief into full conformity with article 18 of the Covenant and other relevant international human rights standards.
c) The Government is currently organizing and preparing for the Fifth Congress of Leaders of World and Traditional Religions. The Special Rapporteur urges those responsible for organizing this event not to limit participation to traditional religions and to invite representatives of other communities. Although men usually serve as leaders, women should also play an active role in conducting the dialogue, including women theologians from various faiths. This could serve as a signal for further broadening understanding and recognition of diversity in society.
d) Above all, the Special Rapporteur would like to recommend substantial amendments to the 2011 Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, based on the understanding that registration should serve to ensure freedom of religion or belief, which, as a universal human right, belongs to every individual before any specific administrative approval measures are taken and independently of them. The most important change is that registration should be optional rather than a mandatory requirement for religious communities to carry out their activities. Unregistered communities should be able to carry out their activities without discrimination and without fear of intimidation.
e) Registration of those religious communities that wish to obtain the relevant status should be carried out in the spirit of serving freedom of religion or belief. Procedures should be prompt, transparent, fair and free from excessive bureaucratic complications. Decisions concerning registration status should in no way reflect the views of a competing religious group.
f) The thresholds for registration at different levels (local, regional and national) should be established in such a way as to enable minorities to fully exercise their activities throughout the country. The requirement to register missionary activities, as well as the practice of issuing permits for the import and distribution of religious literature, should also be carefully reviewed. During this process, the views of religious communities and civil society organizations working in this field should be sought.
g) When amending the 2011 Law on Religious Activities and Religious Associations, particular attention should be paid to the needs of religious communities in educating the younger generation, which requires the establishment of appropriate infrastructure in educational institutions. Private religious schools and similar institutions should be able to operate freely and without unjustified administrative requirements.
h) Religious communities should be able to provide humanitarian and charitable services to their followers and/or society as a whole.
i) Religious or spiritual communities that, for whatever reason, do not have the status of recognized religious communities, or do not wish to obtain such status, should have a genuine opportunity to obtain an alternative form of legal status that would enable them to perform important community functions appropriately.
j) Overly broad definitions of offences related to incitement to religious discord and extremism, which may adversely affect the exercise of freedom of religion or belief in conjunction with freedom of expression, should be replaced with clear definitions that do not allow for broad interpretation. This applies to both the Criminal Code and the Code of Administrative Offences, as well as the 2005 Law on Counteracting Extremism. Following the adoption of the new Criminal Code and the new Code of Administrative Offences (in July 2014), the need for reforms aimed at ensuring greater clarity remains. The Rabat Plan of Action (launched by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights in 2012) may be used as a practical guide in this area.
k) The Special Rapporteur urges the Ministry of Education to continue working on religious education programmes for students, including beyond the ninth grade. School education plays a key role in promoting an atmosphere of religious tolerance. The Special Rapporteur also highly commends the recent initiatives aimed at promoting “religious literacy” among the population as a whole.
l) The Government should discontinue the practice of combating sects, which fuels negative stereotypes about new religious movements. Information about religious beliefs and communities, particularly that presented as part of school education, should be fair and accurate. In this context, the Special Rapporteur welcomes the Toledo Guiding Principles on Teaching about Religions and Beliefs in Public Schools, developed by the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe.
m) The Government should promote the further strengthening of national and regional human rights protection infrastructure, for example, by establishing regional offices of the Ombudsman institution.
n) The Special Rapporteur shares the view expressed by many interlocutors that strict adherence to the principles of the rule of law creates the best conditions for combating negative phenomena such as religious extremism and religious hatred, since respect for the rule of law helps strengthen trust within society and between government institutions and the population as a whole.
o) Confidence-building measures are also contained in the Rabat Plan of Action. It would be beneficial for the Government to hold broad consultations with civil society organizations, the media, religious communities and other stakeholders on how best to apply the Rabat Plan of Action to the specific situation in Kazakhstan.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Protection Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Programme Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages