Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (General Assembly)
Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, Manfred Nowak. Human Rights Council, 16 December 2009.
Mission to Kazakhstan*
\* The summary of this report is circulated in all official languages. The report itself, contained in the annex to the summary, is circulated only in the language of submission and in Russian. The addendum to the report is circulated as received.
Summary
The Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, Manfred Nowak, visited Kazakhstan from 5 to 13 May 2009.
The Special Rapporteur expresses his appreciation to the Government for extending an invitation, which he interprets as a sign of the country's genuine interest in an objective assessment of the situation. He notes that, since gaining independence in 1991, Kazakhstan has acceded to numerous international human rights treaties, demonstrating its commitment to reforming its legal framework and policies. At the same time, he observed that considerable efforts had been made to prepare various detention facilities and prisoners for his inspections, which runs counter to the very idea of independent fact-finding and unannounced visits. This also complicates the task of objectively assessing conditions of detention and the situation with regard to the use of torture.
Although physical conditions of detention and food in prisons appear to have been brought into line with international minimum standards in recent years, one of the key requirements of international human rights law, namely that penitentiary systems should aim at the rehabilitation and reintegration of offenders rather than their punishment, has not been fulfilled; the statutory restriction on contacts with the outside world directly contradicts this principle. Another important issue of concern is that the existing hierarchy among prisoners appears to lead to discrimination and, in some cases, violence.
The same applies to pretrial detention facilities and places of imprisonment. Conditions in pretrial detention facilities under the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the National Security Committee and the Ministry of Justice appear to have improved in terms of physical conditions of detention and food. However, the almost complete prohibition on contact with the outside world, often for extended periods, clearly contradicts the principle of the presumption of innocence and results in excessive psychological pressure on suspects.
On the basis of discussions held with government officials, judges, lawyers and representatives of civil society, as well as interviews with victims of violence and persons deprived of their liberty, the Special Rapporteur concludes that the use of violence and ill-treatment is unlikely to be limited to isolated cases. He received numerous credible reports of suspects being beaten with fists, plastic bottles filled with sand, police batons and feet, as well as being suffocated with plastic bags and gas masks in order to obtain confessions from them. In a number of cases, these reports were corroborated by forensic medical evidence.
With regard to the legal framework and safeguards, the Special Rapporteur welcomes the fact that torture is classified as a criminal offence, although its existing definition needs to be brought into full conformity with the Convention against Torture, and that safeguards are generally provided for by law and formally respected. However, in order for these safeguards to be effective, all participants in the administration of criminal justice must fully discharge their duties, eliminate the implementation gap and condemn cases of torture, which is not currently practised.
In light of all the above, the Special Rapporteur recommends that the Government of Kazakhstan fully implement its obligations under international human rights law. In particular, he strongly urges the Government to establish an independent and effective national preventive mechanism, provided with the necessary human and other resources, and to regard it as an ally in joint efforts to ascertain the actual situation in places of deprivation of liberty. He also recommends adopting an approach to the penitentiary system that provides for the genuine rehabilitation and reintegration of offenders. Accessible and trustworthy mechanisms for submitting and considering complaints must be ensured; a mechanism should be established for the prompt and impartial investigation of allegations of torture and ill-treatment, independent of the alleged perpetrators; the actual time of arrest should be recorded and the periods of police custody reduced and brought into line with international standards; temporary detention facilities should be transferred from the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs to that of the Ministry of Justice; and the burden of proving that a confession was not obtained through torture should be placed on the prosecutor.
Annex
Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
Mission to the Republic of Kazakhstan (5–13 May 2009)
Contents
| Sections | Paragraphs |
|---|---|
| I. Introduction | 1–9 |
| II. Legal framework | 10–18 |
| A. International level | 10 |
| B. Regional level | 11 |
| C. National level | 12–18 |
| III. Assessment of the situation | 19–44 |
| A. Acts of torture and ill-treatment in places of detention | 19–24 |
| B. Conditions in places of detention | 25–36 |
| C. Women | 37–38 |
| D. Children | 39–43 |
| E. Principle of non-refoulement | 44 |
| IV. Main causes | 45–71 |
| A. Punitive penitentiary policy | 45–48 |
| B. Ineffectiveness of protection mechanisms | 49–63 |
| C. Weakness of preventive measures | 64–69 |
| D. Assessment of police performance and corruption | 70–71 |
| V. Conclusions and recommendations | 72–85 |
| A. Conclusions | 72–78 |
| B. Recommendations | 79–85 |
Addendum
Places of detention visited and interviews conducted
I. Introduction
1. The Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, Manfred Nowak, visited Kazakhstan from 5 to 13 May 2009 at the invitation of the Government.
2. The purpose of the visit was to assess the situation with regard to the use of torture and ill-treatment in the country, including conditions of detention, and to offer assistance to the Government in its efforts to improve the administration of justice system. The Special Rapporteur is fully aware that Kazakhstan inherited many of the problems of the Soviet criminal justice system, which was punitive in nature and aimed more at providing a source of cheap labour than at rehabilitating prisoners. These factors probably account for the still relatively strong tendency to place persons of all age groups in specialized institutions; frankly speaking, he has rarely visited a country in which so many different State bodies have had jurisdiction over places of deprivation of liberty in which such a large number of prisoners are held. Nevertheless, he notes that Kazakhstan has made progress in institution-building and the protection of human rights since gaining independence in 1991.
3. The Special Rapporteur regards the fact that the Government extended an invitation to him and provided full access as a sign of its genuine interest in an objective assessment of the situation and in recommendations aimed at improving the existing circumstances. He is particularly grateful that, from the very beginning of his visit, the relevant State authorities provided him with documents authorizing access to all places of detention without prior notification, as well as the conduct of private interviews with prisoners. He would like to thank the Government for providing him with comprehensive statistical information on the penitentiary system and cases of torture recorded in the past.
4. At the same time, however, he notes that considerable efforts were made to prepare places of detention and prisoners for his inspections. Although he assumes that most of these preparatory measures were undertaken with good intentions, they run counter to the very idea of unannounced visits to such places and independent fact-finding. The latter is possible only if there is an opportunity to objectively observe the daily course of events in places of detention. Unfortunately, this was not the case in most of the places he visited in Kazakhstan, as it was obvious that the management of detention facilities and the persons held there were expecting the arrival of the Special Rapporteur. Many of the places he visited had recently been painted; in some colonies, prisoners had been released from quarantine cells and punishment cells in anticipation of the Special Rapporteur's arrival, staged concerts had been organized (in the absence of an audience), etc. He also noted with concern that some prisoners may have been intimidated into refraining from speaking openly with him.
5. Compliance with established fact-finding principles, including visits to places of detention without prior notification, is of crucial importance not only because it is necessary for a full assessment of the situation; it is also of particular importance in light of the recent ratification of the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture, which provides for the establishment of a national preventive mechanism, an independent body with a mandate to conduct unannounced visits at any time to all places of detention and to communicate confidentially with all persons deprived of their liberty. While representing a significant step forward, this measure will be maximally effective only if the fact-finding methodology is fully observed in practice and its independence is guaranteed.
6. The Special Rapporteur held meetings with the State Secretary, representing the President of Kazakhstan on foreign affairs matters; the Minister of Internal Affairs; the Minister of Labour and Social Protection and the Chairperson of the National Commission for Women and Family-Demographic Policy; the Chairman of the Agency for Combating Economic and Corruption Crimes (financial police); the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs; the Deputy Minister of Defence; two Deputy Ministers of Justice; the Deputy Chairman of the National Security Committee; and the Deputy Prosecutor General. In addition, the Special Rapporteur met with the head of the penitentiary authorities, the Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights under the President, representatives of the Ministry of Health and staff of all the institutions visited. The Special Rapporteur visited Astana, Almaty, Karaganda and the surrounding areas, and inspected various places of detention, including colonies, police stations, a temporary detention facility for minors and psychiatric hospitals (see addendum). Due to a lack of time, he was unable to visit other regions.
7. The Special Rapporteur also met with the Chairman of the Supreme Court, the Human Rights Commissioner, representatives of civil society, including non-governmental organizations, persons held in places of detention and victims of violence. In addition, he held meetings with the United Nations country team, representatives of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), the delegation of the European Commission and other representatives of the diplomatic community.
8. The Special Rapporteur expresses his appreciation to the Office of the Resident Coordinator and the entire United Nations team for their invaluable assistance before and during his mission, including the translators and drivers; the forensic medical expert, Dr. Duarte Nuno Vieira; and Isabella Tschan and Roland Schmidt from the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of Human Rights in Vienna.
9. At the end of his mission, the Special Rapporteur presented the Government with his preliminary findings. An advance version of the present report was sent to the Government on 4 November 2009, and the Government's response was received on 4 December 2009. The Special Rapporteur would like to thank the country's authorities for their comprehensive and constructive response. He welcomes the Government's statement that an "Action Plan" is being developed to implement the recommendations of the Committee against Torture, which also covers a number of issues raised in his report.
II. Legal framework
A. International level
10. Kazakhstan is a party to the main United Nations human rights treaties prohibiting torture and ill-treatment, including the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. Kazakhstan is a party to the 1949 Geneva Conventions and the Additional Protocols thereto of 1977. Kazakhstan has not ratified the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. It should be particularly noted that, in October 2008, Kazakhstan ratified the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture. However, the Government intends to make a declaration pursuant to article 24 of the Optional Protocol concerning the temporary postponement of the implementation of its obligations, as the law establishing the NPM is still under discussion.
B. Regional level
11. Kazakhstan is a participating State of the OSCE and is expected to chair that organization in 2010. By becoming a participating State of the OSCE, Kazakhstan assumed numerous political commitments in the field of human rights. It is also a party to regional agreements, mainly in the area of security cooperation, such as the Convention on Legal Assistance and Legal Relations in Civil, Family and Criminal Matters and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization.
C. National level
1. Constitution of Kazakhstan
12. Section II of the Constitution of Kazakhstan lists a number of human rights, including the right to life, the right not to be discriminated against, the right to freedom of religion, conscience and expression, and the right to health protection. The prohibition of torture is enshrined in article 17. In addition, article 16 guarantees the right to personal liberty, establishes a maximum period of police detention of 72 hours, and contains provisions concerning legal assistance and the right to appeal.
2. Prohibition of torture under national legislation
13. Torture is prohibited under article 347-1 of the Criminal Code. Its definition is narrower than the definition contained in article 1 of the Convention against Torture, since criminal liability applies only to public officials, while torture committed by any other persons acting in an official capacity, or by persons acting at the instigation of or with the knowledge or tacit consent of public officials, is not classified as a criminal offence. Furthermore, unlike article 1 of the Convention against Torture, which refers to "lawful sanctions", the note to article 347-1 states that "physical and mental suffering caused as a result of lawful actions of officials shall not be considered torture". The term "lawful actions" is of concern because of its vagueness. The Supreme Court and the Prosecutor's Office assured the Special Representative that the issue of revising article 347-1 is currently under consideration. This initiative deserves full approval.
14. The Criminal Code contains a number of other provisions under which law enforcement officers may be prosecuted for improper treatment. Articles 307 and 308 criminalize "abuse of official powers" and "exceeding authority or official powers", respectively, and provide for various types of punishment, including imprisonment for up to two and up to five years, respectively. In addition, article 107 classifies as a criminal offence the "infliction [by private individuals] of physical or mental suffering through systematic beatings or other violent acts", and the use of torture is mentioned as an aggravating circumstance. Such an offence is punishable, in particular, by "restriction of liberty for a term of up to five years or imprisonment for a term of three to seven years". Domestic legislation does not contain any provisions establishing the principle of universal jurisdiction in accordance with articles 5 (2) and 7 of the Convention against Torture.
15. Article 10.9 of the Penal Enforcement Code provides that "persons serving sentences have the right to courteous treatment by staff members. They must not be subjected to cruel or degrading treatment. Coercive measures may be applied only on lawful grounds".
3. Safeguards
16. Article 4 of the Law on the Procedure and Conditions of Detention of Suspects and Accused Persons establishes the following guiding principles for the detention of persons: legality, the presumption of innocence, equality of citizens before the law, humanism, respect for the honour and dignity of the individual and the norms of international law. The Law also provides that detention must not be accompanied by actions intended to cause physical or mental suffering to suspects and accused persons.
17. Articles 138.1 and 70.3 of the Criminal Procedure Code guarantee detained persons the right to inform their families and to have access to a defence lawyer. Articles 14 (2) and 68 (3) (1) of the Code establish that a suspect may not be held in custody for more than 72 hours without a court decision. Under article 134 of the Code, a record must be drawn up. The detained person must then be read this document and informed of his or her rights, after which the person must sign the document. Article 134 (1) of the Code requires the responsible official to notify the prosecutor in writing of the fact of detention within twelve hours from the time the detention record is drawn up.
4. Death penalty
18. Article 15.2 of the Constitution provides that "the death penalty shall be established by law as an exceptional punishment for especially grave crimes, with the convicted person being granted the right to petition for pardon". Article 49 of the Criminal Code lists the relevant crimes. On 1 January 2004, an indefinite presidential moratorium on the use of the death penalty entered into force. According to official sources, the last execution of a death sentence took place on 1 December 2003. The last death sentence was handed down on 31 August 2006. On 6 December 2007, the remaining 31 death sentences were commuted to life imprisonment.
III. Assessment of the situation
A. Acts of torture and ill-treatment in places of detention
1. Penitentiary institutions and pretrial detention facilities under the authority of the National Security Committee
19. The Special Rapporteur received reports of cases of ill-treatment and corporal punishment in penitentiary institutions.¹ One of the colonies repeatedly mentioned in this context (and referred to by prisoners as the "Kazakhstan Guantanamo") is UK-161/3 in Zhitikara. The Special Rapporteur received reports that "problematic" prisoners are sent there and subjected to beatings and other forms of physical and mental violence in order to "break" them. According to some reports, the rape of prisoners by their cellmates is used as a means of exerting pressure on them. He is deeply concerned by reports that some persons were sent there after meeting with him during his visit.
20. According to numerous reports, staff members, including senior management, at one of the colonies, the Stepnogorsk prison hospital (ETs-166/18), participate in so-called medical "examinations" of newly arrived prisoners. The Special Rapporteur received consistent accounts of how colony staff, with the assistance of prisoners cooperating with the management, beat newly arrived prisoners and forcibly insert a rubber tube into their anus, allegedly for medical and hygienic purposes. Rapes were also reported. Such treatment is further aggravated by the fact that many of the persons arriving at this hospital are ill. Some of those interviewed indicated that this "reception of newcomers" was intended to exploit their "weaknesses", namely their health conditions. Prisoners in several institutions stated that they were so afraid of returning to this prison hospital that they preferred to refuse medical assistance altogether.
21. Furthermore, staff members in women's and juvenile colonies appear to be directly involved in corporal punishment. Such punishments include beatings with hands, fists and police batons, as well as more "sophisticated" measures, such as locking prisoners in a cold punishment cell overnight without blankets or bedding.
¹ In this regard, the Government referred to article 31 of the Law on Justice Bodies, which regulates the use of "special means and physical force", and stated that an internal investigation is required in any case where they are used.
2. Police custody
22. Following interviews with police officers, judges, lawyers and representatives of civil society, victims of violence and persons deprived of their liberty, the Special Rapporteur concluded that the use of torture and ill-treatment clearly extends beyond isolated cases. Despite the fact that his fact-finding work was hampered by the prior preparation and intimidation of prisoners, he received numerous credible allegations of suspects being beaten with hands, fists, feet, plastic bottles filled with sand and police batons, as well as being suffocated with plastic bags and gas masks in order to obtain confessions from them. In several cases, these allegations were corroborated by forensic medical evidence. Torture and improper treatment are most often applied in such a way as to avoid leaving marks on the body (by striking the soles of the feet and the kidneys with flexible objects) and are frequently accompanied by threats to add further charges to those already existing, which would result in an increase in the suspect's prison sentence. Numerous reports were also received concerning threats against family members.
23. Furthermore, repeated allegations were received that detainees who refused to confess to committing a crime were threatened with being placed in a cell with so-called "outcasts", where they could be subjected to sexual harassment or rape and consequently rejected by the majority of the prison population.
3. Armed forces
24. The Ministry of Defence informed the Special Rapporteur that 117 cases of "non-statutory relations" (which is practically synonymous with "hazing") had been recorded in 2008. As a result of these incidents, five people committed suicide. Investigations were conducted into these cases and the files were transferred to a tribunal: in one case, a suspended sentence of one year was handed down; in another, a prison sentence of four years; in two cases, the perpetrators were sentenced to six years' imprisonment; and in one case, a decision had not yet been made. In another case, an officer who inflicted grievous bodily harm on another officer, resulting in death, was sentenced to four years' imprisonment. During the first three months of 2009, 27 cases of "non-statutory relations" were recorded, representing an improvement compared with the 43 such cases recorded during the same period in 2008. The Special Rapporteur emphasizes that acts of harassment of soldiers by other military personnel may be considered torture if they meet the criteria set out in article 1 of the Convention against Torture, particularly where their purpose is punishment or intimidation.
B. Conditions in places of detention
1. Penitentiary institutions and pretrial detention facilities under the authority of the National Security Committee
25. As at 1 April 2009, the total number of persons held in facilities under the authority of the Ministry of Justice was 60,858 (excluding temporary detention facilities and pretrial detention facilities of the National Security Committee). Nevertheless, prison sentences remain lengthy and, despite a reduction in the prison population over the past decade, 382 persons per 100,000 inhabitants are held in penitentiary institutions, which is more than three times the European average and considerably higher than the corresponding figures in other post-Soviet States.
26. In general, physical conditions of detention and food had been brought into line with international minimum standards. In the opinion of the Special Rapporteur, cleanliness and order were maintained in most of the places he visited (which had been prepared for his visit). In "colony"-type places of deprivation of liberty (the sleeping quarters of which are designed for 20–100 persons), prisoners are generally allowed to move freely within a designated area and communicate with other prisoners, which is undoubtedly a positive aspect. On the other hand, the shared dormitory system may threaten the personal safety of prisoners. The Special Rapporteur also visited a special-regime colony in Arshaly (ETs-166/5), where a shift system is applied (half of the prisoners remain in their cells while the other half may take walks in a small yard).
27. Although most pretrial detention facilities are under the authority of the Ministry of Justice, four such institutions remain under the authority of the National Security Committee. As a rule, they are buildings with cells containing between three and eight beds and limited opportunities for movement (prisoners generally remain in their cells for 23 hours a day); prisoners are provided with one hour of collective exercise with their cellmates in a small yard surrounded by walls and covered at the top with a grille. Although most facilities have running water and new sanitary equipment, prisoners are still often deprived of the opportunity to have privacy. In most places, showers can be taken only once a week or once every 10 days.
28. The Special Rapporteur learned that hierarchical relations among prisoners are a legacy of the Soviet era. Those who do not comply with this hierarchy and the "thieves' laws" prevailing there are subjected to violence and discrimination by other prisoners, with the consent and sometimes the approval and active instigation of the prison administration. As a result, violence, including sexual violence (for example, against so-called "outcasts", who are excluded from the prison community), is reportedly widespread among prisoners. In addition, there are two types of prison colonies in Kazakhstan: "black" and "red" zones. In "red" zones, prison management maintains order by using some prisoners to intimidate others. In "black" zones, the administration simply delegates the task of maintaining discipline to the prisoners themselves. Both practices are incompatible with international standards. The Special Rapporteur recalls that violence among prisoners may be regarded as torture or ill-treatment where the State fails to take sufficient measures to prevent it.
29. A professional and responsible approach to the management of the healthcare system has made it possible to achieve progress in combating tuberculosis (3,133 cases were recorded during the first three months of 2009, compared with 3,806 cases during the same period in 2008). Nevertheless, problems relating to the provision of medical care persist. The Special Rapporteur received complaints that serious illnesses were not treated or that their treatment was delayed for long periods; it was also alleged that some doctors, penitentiary institution staff and medical personnel demanded money for providing medical assistance, sometimes even in cases of serious illnesses. According to official data, 99 persons died in penitentiary institutions during the first three months of 2009 (14 fewer than in 2008); 35 of them died of tuberculosis, 16 as a result of injuries, poisoning and suicide, and 48 from somatic pathologies. In addition, the number of HIV-infected persons increased from 1,675 during the first three months of 2008 to 2,073 during the same period in 2009. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur expresses concern that there are no needle-exchange programmes or substitution therapy programmes for persons suffering from drug dependence in places of deprivation of liberty in Kazakhstan.
30. One concern shared by a number of penitentiary administration staff members is that many convicted persons serve their sentences far away from their homes and families. On the one hand, the traditional location of penitentiary institutions in the north of the country means that many residents of southern Kazakhstan are sent north to serve their sentences. On the other hand, the remote location of penitentiary centres often makes visits by family members difficult; for example, the prison in Arkalyk, the only institution with a cell-based system for holding particularly dangerous criminals, is located so far away that the Special Rapporteur was unable to visit it within the limited time available to him.
2. Police stations
31. Many facilities under the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs have undergone significant structural improvements. Most of the suspects interviewed by the Special Rapporteur stated that they received three meals a day and had some access to medical assistance. At the same time, he received allegations that, in many cases, the requirement to provide the minimum amount of time for walks and physical exercise, as prescribed by international minimum standards (one hour per day), was not observed. In some institutions, persons held in custody reported that they were allowed to go for walks for only 20 minutes a day. Furthermore, in many cases, sanitary facilities do not meet the required standards: toilets in cells are often open and do not provide privacy, while showers can be used only once a week.
32. Given that a relatively large number of persons are held by the police for extended periods, sometimes for up to several months (for example, while awaiting the processing of documents or during an investigation and trial), the almost complete absence of contact with the outside world places excessive psychological pressure on suspects and, in the opinion of the Special Rapporteur, clearly contradicts the principle of the presumption of innocence.
33. At the reception and distribution centre in Almaty, where persons without documents are held (including many citizens of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan), there are tiny cells that are poorly ventilated and receive virtually no daylight. It was alleged that detainees were poorly fed and allowed to go for walks for only 15 minutes a day. Such conditions clearly do not meet international minimum standards, particularly given that persons may be held there for up to 30 days without a court decision; since they may subsequently be arrested again, they may face another 30-day period of detention.
3. Institutions under the authority of other ministries
34. The Special Rapporteur visited the psychoneurological centre in Talgar, under the authority of the Department for Coordination of Employment and Social Programmes of Almaty Region, where persons aged between 18 and 40 with serious mental illnesses and disabilities are accommodated. This centre is in good condition, is clean and is well equipped. According to staff members, patients who are able to move around can spend most of their time outside in a large garden. The Special Rapporteur received a number of allegations of ill-treatment, although it is difficult to assess how widespread this practice is. He expresses concern about complaints of excessive use of tranquillizers in cases where patients fail to comply with instructions, as well as reports of a large number of patients who died in 2008 after being transferred there from other institutions. He also received allegations of cases of starvation in 2008. The procedure for admitting patients to this centre and reviewing such decisions², as well as the absence of any independent monitoring of the centre, are also matters of concern.
35. The Special Rapporteur also visited a specialized psychiatric hospital in Aktas (Almaty Region), to which repeat offenders who are unable to account for their actions are sent by court order; they are held there for an indefinite period until a judge decides on their release on the basis of a recommendation from a commission consisting of five qualified doctors. The hospital is clean but requires repairs and in many respects resembles a prison colony. The Special Rapporteur did not receive any allegations of ill-treatment or violence. The isolation cells are located within the general units, and the persons held there can communicate with other people. Prisoners repeatedly complained about the poor quality of food and the complete ban on smoking, which, although based on commendable considerations, is perceived as a severe restriction.
36. Under paragraph 2 of article 14 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the compulsory placement of a person who is not held in pretrial detention in a medical institution for the purpose of conducting a forensic psychiatric examination is permitted only by court order. Furthermore, the compulsory placement of a person who is not held in pretrial detention in a medical institution for the purpose of conducting a forensic medical examination is permitted by court order or with the authorization of a prosecutor. The law does not specify the maximum duration of such treatment; the process lacks transparency and, apparently, there is no possibility of challenging such a decision. The Special Rapporteur received allegations that, in some cases, such placement in a medical institution is used to exert pressure on suspects or accused persons. He welcomes the assurances received from the Government that the current practice is being reviewed.
² The Government indicated that these allegations were not true but did not provide any data on the number of deaths in 2008.
C. Women
1. Violence against women
37. With regard to violence against women, the Special Rapporteur has previously stated that, in his view, the concept of "acquiescence" used in the Convention against Torture, in addition to obligations relating to protection, implies an obligation on the part of the State to prevent acts of torture in the private sphere, and has recalled that the principle of "due diligence" should be applied when examining the question of whether a State has complied with its obligations (A/HRC/7/3, paragraph 68). According to reports, violence against women, particularly domestic violence, is widespread. It is most often concealed, and measures are taken only in cases where domestic violence results in serious bodily injuries. According to the Prosecutor's Office, virtually no relevant statistical information is collected, as there is no law requiring this. However, the Government of Kazakhstan has taken steps to combat this phenomenon. For example, in 1999, units for the protection of women against violence were established within the structure of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, and 128 staff members currently work in these units. These units cooperate closely with the 24 crisis centres operating in the country. Training for internal affairs personnel is regularly conducted. Although the Criminal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code contain provisions on offences for which prosecution may be initiated in cases of violence against women, including domestic violence, little has been done to ensure victims' access to justice. The Special Rapporteur expresses satisfaction that the adoption of a draft law on domestic violence, which had been under consideration for many years, was planned for 2009. However, the draft law appears to provide mainly for the prosecution of acts of domestic violence, while ignoring aspects of its prevention and the protection of victims (for example, it does not provide for any infrastructure for the temporary accommodation of victims of domestic violence and the provision of support to them). It is also questionable that, under this draft law, any prosecution must be initiated on the basis of a complaint by the victim, which may result in pressure being exerted on her if the perpetrator attempts to force her to withdraw the complaint.
2. Women in detention
38. The Special Rapporteur received a number of allegations of threats against women accused of committing crimes, particularly threats directed at their children. He received reports of women suspected or accused of drug-related offences, as well as foreign women, being beaten and subjected to other forms of violence by law enforcement officers, including having bags placed over their heads and being subjected to electric shocks. In penitentiary institutions, he received credible allegations of corporal punishment being applied to women. Due to the smaller number of colonies for women, persons held there are generally even more isolated from their families and friends than male prisoners.
D. Children
1. Violence against children
39. Article 10 of Law No. 345-II on the Rights of the Child of 8 August 2002 proclaims the child's right to life, personal liberty, inviolability of dignity and privacy, and establishes the obligation of the State to protect children from physical and/or mental violence, cruel, rough or degrading treatment, sexual acts, etc. At the same time, the problem of violence against children, particularly in the private sphere, has been very little studied, and there appear to be no effective mechanisms in the country to combat such violence³. Although the aforementioned draft law on combating domestic violence may provide a response to some of these concerns, it is not without shortcomings; for example, it does not provide for an obligation on healthcare workers to report cases of violence against children.
³ See also CRC/C/KAZ/CO/3, paragraphs 34 and 36.
2. Juvenile justice
40. Under article 15 of the Criminal Code, criminal liability for serious crimes begins at the age of fourteen; for other crimes, it begins at the age of sixteen. Article 491 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides that an order for the arrest of a minor may be issued only in exceptional cases involving the commission of a serious or especially serious crime, and that the duration of his or her detention may not exceed six months. Articles 71.2 and 79 of the Code, as well as chapter 52, list the safeguards applicable at different stages of criminal proceedings involving minors (limitations on the duration of interrogations, the presence of a legal representative, the right to remain silent, etc.). At the same time, the Special Rapporteur learned that many of these safeguards are observed only formally and that the practice of beating minors with fists and police batons during arrest is widespread, most often before the fact of detention is officially registered. During this period, children are frequently handcuffed to radiators for several hours, sometimes for the entire night.
41. The Special Rapporteur learned with satisfaction that, on 18 August 2008, the President approved the Concept for the Development of the Juvenile Justice System, which, with reference to the Beijing Rules, provides for the establishment of a juvenile justice system during the period 2009–2011, and in particular the establishment of specialized juvenile courts, a juvenile police service, a specialized bar, a special inspection for the enforcement of non-custodial sentences, the improvement of coordination mechanisms, as well as the incorporation of social and psychological assistance services into the juvenile justice system. He hopes that such a comprehensive approach will significantly improve minors' actual access to justice and contribute to the eradication of torture and ill-treatment of children.
3. Children in Places of Deprivation of Liberty
42. The Special Rapporteur visited the juvenile correctional facility in Almaty (LA-155/6), the physical conditions of detention in which appeared to be good (taking into account the intensive preparations carried out in anticipation of his visit). The children attend school, have opportunities for recreational activities and did not express any serious complaints about the quality of food or medical care. At the same time, the Special Rapporteur received allegations that corporal punishment was inflicted on minors in this facility, in particular that they were regularly subjected to severe beatings with fists and batons by prison guards. The Special Rapporteur is also very concerned about the strict restrictions on visits by family members (under the rules, inmates are entitled to three two-day visits and three short-term visits per year). Such a restrictive policy towards minors clearly contradicts the fundamental requirement that the best interests of the child should be the primary consideration in all measures taken by the State.
43. The Special Rapporteur also inspected the temporary isolation, adaptation and rehabilitation centre in Karaganda. These institutions, which are under the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, were established to address a number of tasks, including the detention of children under the age of sixteen suspected of having committed minor offences, and the placement of children who have lost their parents or legal guardians, as well as homeless and neglected children⁴. The placement of children suspected of offences in such institutions may be ordered by the Commission on Minors' Affairs, an administrative body consisting of representatives of the police, the Department of Education, the Department of Health, local self-government bodies and civil society.
The Special Rapporteur regrets that children were subjected to intimidation and instructed as to what exactly they should say during his visit. He is concerned that children between the ages of three and eighteen are held together at the centre. Upon arrival, most children have their heads shaved. Furthermore, they apparently are not allowed to spend much time outdoors and, although there is a garden surrounding the centre, they are permitted to walk only in a small courtyard and have no toys.
The Special Rapporteur is extremely concerned by credible reports that staff at the centre regularly subject children to corporal punishment if they refuse to comply with their instructions. According to reports, caregivers frequently hit children on the head with a bunch of keys or the wooden back of a chair and strike them on the upper part of the body. In addition, the fact that, pursuant to a prosecutor's decision, children may be placed in such centres for 30 days (plus an additional three weeks in the event of an outbreak of any disease) is inconsistent with international standards.
Despite the conduct of a number of internal inspections and the holding of several staff members of centres in other cities accountable for using force against the children whom they are supposed to protect, the Special Rapporteur regrets the lack of transparency surrounding such measures and the absence of independent monitoring.
⁴ See the Law on the prevention of offences among minors and the prevention of child neglect and homelessness, and the Charter of the Temporary Isolation, Adaptation and Rehabilitation Centres.
E. Principle of Non-Refoulement
44. Although Kazakhstan is a party to the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and cooperates closely with the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, domestic legislation contains no provisions establishing the principle of non-refoulement, as provided for in article 3 of the Convention against Torture. In this regard, concern is also caused by the fact that asylum-seekers from the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) are generally not recognized as refugees⁵, even when their applications are well-founded. Furthermore, although, under the law, any decision of a State body may be challenged in court, in practice there are no clear procedures to ensure access to justice in cases involving extradition and deportation. A law on refugees is currently being drafted.
⁵ This is often done with reference to the 1993 Minsk Convention on Legal Assistance and Legal Relations in Civil, Family and Criminal Matters (the Minsk Convention) and the 2000 Minsk Agreement on Visa-Free Travel. It is argued that citizens of CIS States residing in the territory of other CIS States enjoy the same rights as their citizens, whereas in reality the Minsk Convention is intended to regulate relations between the administrative bodies, particularly the courts and law enforcement agencies, of the contracting parties.
IV. Main Causes
A. Punitive Penal Policy
45. Recognizing that imprisonment as such entails certain restrictions on human rights, the Special Rapporteur notes that the legal principles and penal policy applied in Kazakhstan are primarily punitive in nature rather than aimed at the reintegration of prisoners into society, as required by paragraph 3 of article 10 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
For example, the Code of Criminal Procedure is based on the idea that different regimes of imprisonment serve as a form of punishment, and its provisions impose strict restrictions on contacts with the outside world. In this regard, concern is caused by the recently introduced punishment of life imprisonment, which leaves prisoners with virtually no hope of release. According to the Ministry of Justice, at the time of the visit, 71 persons were serving life sentences (69 in the Zhetykara colony).
Another disturbing fact is that most prisoners perceive transfer to certain penal institutions as a punishment. Such informal additional punitive measures are contrary to international norms, according to which, even when a person has been sentenced to imprisonment, their other human rights should be affected to the minimum extent possible. The Government of Kazakhstan indicated that a reform of the penal system based on the principles of rehabilitative work with convicted persons and their reintegration into society is currently under way.
46. The right of persons held in pretrial detention to communicate with the outside world also appears to be severely restricted (articles 17 and 19 of the Law on the Procedure and Conditions of Detention of Suspects and Accused Persons). In addition, the Special Rapporteur was informed that permission for such contact is frequently refused. The fact that persons held in police custody for extended periods, sometimes for up to several months, are deprived of the possibility of receiving visits subjects them to unnecessary suffering.
47. Furthermore, only a very small proportion of prisoners appear to have the opportunity to engage in any useful activity. Despite the highly commendable fact that schools and vocational training colleges exist in some facilities, few of the persons interviewed by the Special Rapporteur reported having had the opportunity to receive education there.
48. One of the main reasons for disciplinary punishment appears to be prisoners' refusal to perform the mandatory two hours of work on the maintenance and improvement of the colony, as prescribed by the rules. In response to such refusal, the prison administration may impose penalties, including criminal sanctions resulting in an extension of the sentence (see article 360 of the Criminal Code). The Special Rapporteur learned of a case in which the original prison sentence of one prisoner was extended by more than 10 years. Such excessive penalties for disciplinary violations clearly demonstrate that the penal system is unable to deal appropriately with offences committed by prisoners.
B. Ineffectiveness of Protection Mechanisms
1. Complaint Channels
49. The law provides for several mechanisms for submitting complaints (articles 177, 183.1 and 184 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and article 10.2 of the Penal Enforcement Code). Article 183 of the Code of Criminal Procedure expressly provides for the obligation to register a report of any crime. Article 192.4-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that, in cases falling under article 347-1 of the Criminal Code, the preliminary investigation is conducted by the internal affairs or national security body that initiated the criminal proceedings. The law does not specify which particular body should conduct such an investigation; in most cases, the police investigate reports of acts of torture allegedly committed by their own officers; the same applies to the National Security Committee and the financial police⁶.
50. The Human Rights Commissioner (a position established by presidential decree in 2002) is empowered to receive complaints, which he may subsequently forward to the competent authorities with a request to take administrative measures or initiate criminal proceedings against the alleged offenders. In 2008, the Commissioner received 38 complaints concerning police officers who had humiliated the human dignity of detained persons. These complaints were referred to the Internal Security Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. An analysis conducted by that Department showed that, in eight out of ten cases, the facts stated in citizens' complaints were not confirmed⁷.
51. The Special Rapporteur asked all senior officials of the police authorities and the National Security Committee, as well as the heads of penal institutions, whether they had received any complaints of ill-treatment during the previous five years. The overwhelming majority stated that they had never heard of such allegations. At the same time, the almost complete absence of official complaints gives rise to suspicion that no genuine mechanism for receiving and examining them exists in the country; on the contrary, most prisoners appear to avoid filing complaints because they do not trust the system or fear punishment. In the opinion of the Special Rapporteur, there is no independent body in the country authorized to conduct prompt investigations, and the overwhelming majority of complaints are almost automatically dismissed.
52. A number of issues giving rise to concern in this regard are examined below.
a) Burden of proof and independent medical examinations
53. One of the key problems identified by the Special Rapporteur in this area concerns the burden of proof. According to international standards, where allegations of torture or other forms of ill-treatment are made by an accused person during a trial, the burden of proof rests with the prosecution, which must convincingly demonstrate that the confession was not obtained through unlawful means, including torture or similar forms of ill-treatment⁸.
It is quite clear that a person in detention has no possibility of collecting and documenting evidence while being deprived of access to an independent medical examination. Although medical personnel of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the prison administration conduct an initial examination upon the arrival of the person concerned, they are clearly unable to take any independent action against colleagues with whom they meet every day at work⁹. Thus, an examination conducted by such personnel cannot be considered independent; accordingly, the examination should be conducted by an external medical expert.
However, given that such an examination requires authorization from a supervisory authority, for example, investigators, prosecutors or the prison administration, that authority has every opportunity to delay the issuance of the relevant authorization, waiting for the physical injuries sustained as a result of torture to heal by the time the examination is conducted. In addition, the Special Rapporteur was informed that, where an examination is conducted outside a detention facility, the law enforcement officer handling the case usually accompanies the detainee and remains nearby throughout the examination. Another obstacle is the fact that the relevant costs must be paid by the detainee. Clearly, such a situation does not contribute to establishing the truth.
An additional problem is that the forensic medical expert must determine the severity of the bodily injuries, which makes it possible to classify the potential crime, and in this regard has considerable opportunities to induce medical personnel to underestimate the severity of the injuries. In fact, the Special Rapporteur received allegations that this does indeed occur.
b) Absence of official investigations
54. Although most pretrial detention facilities have been transferred to the authority of the Ministry of Justice, conversations conducted by the Special Rapporteur in detention facilities made it clear that their staff do not consider it their responsibility to identify cases of torture or ill-treatment by law enforcement authorities, let alone to take any measures in this regard.
c) Role of prosecutors, judges and lawyers
55. Despite a number of reforms, the dual role of prosecutors continues to cause major problems: on the one hand, they support the official charges prepared by the police following the preliminary criminal investigation; on the other hand, they are obliged to monitor compliance with the law by the criminal justice authorities and law enforcement officers and to protect the rights of citizens and residents of the country.
This leads to a paradoxical situation in which, when allegations of torture or ill-treatment arise at later stages of criminal proceedings and the case is referred to the prosecutor's office, the prosecutor, by demanding an appropriate investigation, effectively acknowledges that he has failed to fulfil his supervisory role. In this regard, prosecutors, despite having a certain degree of formal control over police actions, appear in many situations to be inclined to ignore gross violations.
56. Despite a number of steps taken to raise judges' awareness of the problem of torture, judges are often perceived as persons who are formally present at certain stages of criminal proceedings merely to legitimize decisions of the prosecutor's office, rather than to seek to establish the truth and conduct an effective investigation into allegations of torture.
The overwhelming majority of interviewees stated that neither at the first hearing, at which a decision was made on pretrial detention, nor during the trial itself had any judge asked them what treatment they had been subjected to during the initial period of detention. Moreover, where victims reported torture or ill-treatment, such allegations were generally suppressed.
The Special Rapporteur repeatedly heard that the court monitoring project conducted under the auspices of the OSCE had proved very useful in ensuring fairer trials, particularly in the only case in which an acquittal was delivered on the grounds that torture had been found to have been used during the investigation (see the case of Mr. Poliyenko in the Addendum).
57. The Special Rapporteur received numerous complaints concerning the role of lawyers in the examination of criminal cases. According to the general opinion, lawyers are corrupt, ineffective, "part of the system" and unwilling to defend the rights of their clients. As for "State-appointed lawyers", they are frequently reported to be present only at court hearings and are not trusted. In many cases, interviewees indicated that their lawyers simply ignored allegations of torture.
d) Detention in police custody
58. Although, by law, the period of detention at a police station should not exceed 72 hours (in rural areas, in the event of transportation difficulties, 10 days), the detention period may be extended at certain stages of the process, for example, if the detained person has no documents or is sent back to their city for additional investigation or trial.
In reality, many persons are repeatedly transferred between temporary detention facilities and pretrial detention centres; accused persons may be repeatedly returned to the place where their first interrogation took place. Even if, at a certain stage, long after the expiry of the initial period of detention, they submit a complaint concerning the use of torture, they may be returned to the place where the persons who tortured them work; such a prospect is certainly not conducive to detainees filing complaints.
e) Threats and intimidation by law enforcement officers
59. Many of the detained persons interviewed by the Special Rapporteur stated that they had been threatened with additional charges, an increase in their prison sentence and, in some cases, sexual violence by fellow inmates in order to force them to withdraw their complaints or sign a statement indicating that they had no complaints or that they had sustained injuries while resisting arrest.
He also learned that, in some cases, threats were made against the families of detainees, for example, that they would also be arrested or that everything would be disclosed to the child's friends. Such conduct, apart from being contrary to international standards, renders any system for submitting and examining complaints meaningless and must be firmly addressed.
f) Evidence obtained through torture
60. Article 77(9) of the Constitution and article 116(1)(1) of the country's Criminal Code prohibit the use in court of evidence obtained through torture. Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur has no information about any cases in which evidence was excluded because it had been established that it was obtained through torture.
A disturbing feature of the system, which was repeatedly brought to the attention of the Special Rapporteur, is that, in the interests of crime detection rates, persons who have previously been convicted are frequently accused of committing crimes, and the relevant cases are simply fabricated, often through the use of physical violence to obtain confessions, to which several fabricated pieces of evidence are subsequently added.
⁶ According to the Government, within the framework of the development of the "Plan of Measures", an interdepartmental group is currently discussing how to ensure that investigations into allegations of torture are conducted by a body that is not connected with the body investigating the case brought against the alleged victim.
⁷ See the Report on the Activities of the Human Rights Commissioner of Kazakhstan in 2008; available on the website of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Kazakhstan (www.mvd.kz).
⁸ See E/CN.4/2003/68, paragraph 26.
⁹ According to the Government, the possibility of establishing a medical service independent of the Ministries of Internal Affairs and Justice is currently being considered within the framework of the development of the "Plan of Measures".
2. Prosecution and Sanctions against Persons Allegedly Responsible for Torture, and Rehabilitation Measures
61. Information provided to the Special Rapporteur by various law enforcement agencies shows that article 347.1 has been applied in a number of cases in recent years (see the table below).
| Year | Case | Results |
|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Infliction of bodily injuries by a police inspector from East Kazakhstan Region on a suspect for the purpose of obtaining confessional statements | Sentenced to 18 months of imprisonment. |
| 2006 | Use of violence by three police officers from Astana for the purpose of obtaining confessional statements | Two police officers were sentenced to three years of imprisonment, and one to two years. |
| Use of physical violence against detainees by two police officers from Pavlodar | The examination of the case was not completed owing to the disappearance of the alleged perpetrators. | |
| Initiation of proceedings | The case was soon closed because the alleged victims withdrew their complaints. | |
| 2005 | Conviction of three police officers from Pavlodar for applying torture that resulted in the death of a detainee | One police officer was sentenced to four years of imprisonment, and another to three years of suspended imprisonment. |
62. The Special Rapporteur wishes to emphasize that the investigations and prosecutions described in the table can be regarded only as first steps. The number of officially initiated cases in no way reflects the true scale of the prevalence of torture and ill-treatment in the country. Furthermore, the penalties imposed appear to be disproportionate to the seriousness of the crime.
63. Unfortunately, the domestic legislation of Kazakhstan does not provide for a legal obligation to pay financial compensation or provide rehabilitation to victims of torture. Although article 40 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for compensation for damage caused as a result of unlawful actions by the body conducting or carrying out criminal prosecution, the list of such unlawful actions does not include torture or ill-treatment.
The Supreme Court Resolution of 9 July 1999 (No. 7) on the practice of applying legislation concerning compensation for harm caused by unlawful actions of bodies conducting criminal proceedings, which serves as guidance for judges, refers to the "use of violence, cruel and degrading treatment" and lists "arrested, accused and convicted persons" as persons entitled to compensation.
At the same time, article 923 of the Civil Code appears to restrict the actions and conditions that entitle victims to receive compensation, since torture and ill-treatment are not mentioned in the relevant list. Furthermore, civil proceedings may commence only after criminal prosecution has been initiated against the offender or perpetrator; this clearly contradicts the requirements of article 14 of the Convention against Torture.
The Special Rapporteur has no information about any case in which victims of torture have received compensation or rehabilitation, even where the fact of torture was established by a criminal court.
C. Weakness of Preventive Measures
1. Monitoring and Inspections
64. The principal supervisory role is performed by the prosecutor's office. The Deputy Prosecutor General informed the Special Rapporteur that prosecutors conduct inspections practically every day, sometimes also at night and on weekends. Several specially appointed prosecutors are responsible for monitoring places of detention. In addition, all law enforcement agencies have their own internal security departments, which conduct unannounced inspections. However, no public information is available on the results of these activities.
65. A number of other monitoring mechanisms operate in Kazakhstan. The Human Rights Commissioner has the right to visit any place where persons deprived of their liberty are held. In practice, the Commissioner and his staff visit police temporary detention facilities, pretrial detention centres, prison colonies and psychiatric hospitals. However, owing to the lack of independence and the limited human and other resources available to him, his monitoring activities are carried out irregularly and have only a limited impact.
66. At the end of 2008, the Working Group on the Examination of Cases of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, which meets under the auspices of the Human Rights Commissioner and consists of senior officials from most relevant State bodies, as well as heads of international and national non-governmental organizations, organized visits to pretrial and temporary detention centres and colonies in Almaty and Almaty Region, subsequently submitting a report on the results of those visits to the Presidential Administration.
The report appears to have focused primarily on conditions which, according to the assessment of the Commissioner, did not comply with the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners¹⁰. According to the Government, the Working Group continued visiting a number of regions in 2009.
67. As regards civil society, public monitoring commissions consisting of 91 civil society representatives have been established in each of the 15 regions. These commissions are authorized to conduct monitoring visits to places of detention under the authority of the Ministry of Justice. In Almaty, a project is being implemented under which civil society representatives monitor temporary detention facilities (under the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs).
Although these mechanisms carry out important work, they do not appear to cover the entire territory of the country and are primarily focused on monitoring conditions of detention rather than establishing facts related to the use of torture.
¹⁰ See the Report on the Activities of the Human Rights Commissioner of Kazakhstan in 2008, cited above, pp. 22, 61.
2. Safeguards
68. Overall, the Special Rapporteur concluded that most of the existing safeguards are formally observed. In all the places he visited, registers of detainees were maintained, and most detainees indicated that, at various stages of detention and the judicial process, they had met with judges, prosecutors and defence counsel, as required by law.
At the same time, in practice, many of these safeguards prove ineffective; a significant gap in this regard is the fact that the actual moment of detention and arrival at the police station is not recorded, which makes it impossible to establish whether the maximum initial period of detention, which must not exceed three hours, is being observed.
Moreover, the Special Rapporteur received numerous allegations that the first few hours of (unregistered) detention are used by law enforcement agencies to obtain confessional statements through torture. This situation is further aggravated by the fact that, at this stage, detainees do not have the right of access to a lawyer¹¹.
69. One of the most important safeguards in the context of preventing torture and ill-treatment is supervision by an independent judge at the early stage of detention. Although in 2008 Kazakhstan transferred the function of authorizing arrests to the judicial authorities, the Committee against Torture expressed the view that this does not constitute a full-fledged habeas corpus procedure consistent with international standards (CAT/C/KAZ/CO/2, paragraph 9 (c)).
¹¹ The Government noted that a number of recommendations, including the recommendation concerning the immediate registration of persons deprived of their liberty upon arrest and the provision of immediate access to their lawyers, had been reflected in the draft regulatory resolution of the Supreme Court on the application of criminal and criminal procedural legislation in matters relating to combating torture or degrading forms of treatment and punishment.
In addition, the Government indicated that the following legislative amendments could be envisaged:
- establishing criminal liability for falsification of the periods of detention of persons;
- including in the Code of Criminal Procedure the following provisions concerning procedural aspects of investigating complaints of torture and ill-treatment:
- ensuring that prisoners' complaints addressed to the preventive mechanism, the prosecutor or the court must be submitted in a sealed envelope without inspection of correspondence;
- the duties of the prosecutor supervising compliance with the law during preliminary investigations in criminal cases;
- reducing the periods of pretrial detention of accused persons;
- introducing judicial authorization for the placement of persons in reception and distribution centres and temporary isolation, adaptation and rehabilitation centres for minors; and
- making the examination of persons for bodily injuries and other traces of torture in the absence of police officers and prosecutors a mandatory principle.
D. Assessment of Police Performance and Corruption
70. The Special Rapporteur received numerous mutually consistent allegations that corruption is deeply entrenched in the criminal justice system. According to a number of sources, at every stage, from the police and courts to detention centres and prisons, corruption is practically an institutionalized practice¹².
71. Many sources reported the existence of an unofficial quota of cases that police officers are required to "solve" in order for their performance to receive a positive assessment. Such a system of evaluation may lead police officers to use unlawful methods to solve cases.
Indeed, many interviewees indicated that, although the law requires the existence of corroborating evidence, confessional statements continue to be regarded as the most valuable evidence. Furthermore, corroborating evidence, including witness statements, is sometimes also obtained through the use of force and intimidation.
¹² Kazakhstan ranked 145th in the 2008 Corruption Perceptions Index compiled by Transparency International.
V. Conclusions and Recommendations
A. Conclusions
72. Kazakhstan has made significant progress in reforming its legal foundations and institutions since gaining independence in 1991. By acceding to international treaties, it has demonstrated to its citizens, as well as to the international community, that human rights must be given priority. A number of steps have been taken to integrate these international standards into the national legal framework, in particular through the criminalization of torture (although its definition is too narrow and the punishment for this crime is disproportionate to its seriousness).
Nevertheless, a significant gap remains between legislation and the actual situation.
73. The active efforts made by the administrations of places of detention to prepare for the Special Rapporteur's visit, as well as the intimidation of persons held there and the instructions given to them regarding what information they should provide, significantly complicated the Special Rapporteur's task of reaching objective conclusions.
Taking this fact into account and relying on the results of discussions with public officials, judges, lawyers and representatives of civil society, as well as interviews with victims of violence and persons deprived of their liberty, frequently corroborated by forensic medical examination data, the Special Rapporteur concludes that the use of torture and ill-treatment clearly extends beyond isolated cases.
He received numerous credible allegations of suspects being beaten with hands, fists and feet, plastic bottles filled with sand and police batons, as well as of suffocation using plastic bags and gas masks for the purpose of obtaining confessional statements from them. In several cases, these reports were corroborated by forensic medical examination data.
74. Acts of torture are facilitated by the inaction of prosecutors, judges, Ministry of Justice officials, doctors and lawyers in the face of allegations of torture and ill-treatment, as well as by the insufficient effectiveness of inspection and supervisory mechanisms.
In the opinion of the Special Rapporteur, evidence obtained through torture (including threats) or ill-treatment is widely used as a basis for conviction.
75. Conditions of detention in penal institutions and police stations have improved in recent years. Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur remains concerned about the widespread and clearly pronounced punitive approach adopted in penal policy and practice, including the imposition of excessively long prison sentences and the use of regimes in which restrictions on contact with the outside world are widely applied as a form of punishment.
76. Although the Special Rapporteur acknowledges that the situation does not amount to complete impunity, he considers the existing mechanisms for submitting and examining complaints to be ineffective. The burden of proof rests with the alleged victim of ill-treatment; this is precisely why only a small number of perpetrators are actually held accountable. He also identified significant gaps with regard to the State's obligations to provide compensation and rehabilitation.
77. The Special Rapporteur noted that some independent monitoring is conducted in Kazakhstan, but it is fragmented in nature and does not cover a significant proportion of institutions. He warmly welcomes the ratification of the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture and the planned establishment of a national preventive mechanism.
78. With regard to violence against women, the Special Rapporteur is concerned about the insufficient preventive and protective measures taken by the State in the interests of victims of domestic violence, as well as the lack of widespread awareness of this problem. Children are extremely vulnerable to corporal punishment and require enhanced protection.
B. Recommendations
79. Recognizing the progress achieved by Kazakhstan in recent years, the Special Rapporteur, guided by a spirit of cooperation, recommends that the following steps be taken to ensure full compliance with the relevant international obligations.
In view of Kazakhstan's forthcoming chairmanship of the OSCE in 2010, translating international norms into tangible changes in people's lives, including the lives of persons held "behind bars", is an extremely important task.
1. Impunity
80. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities take the following measures:
a) publicly condemn torture and ill-treatment and unequivocally state that the use of torture is a serious crime, thereby helping to reverse the current situation in which offenders are easily deprived of their liberty (sometimes for very lengthy periods), while law enforcement officers who violate the law receive lenient sentences;
b) amend the legislation to ensure that torture is classified as a serious crime and is subject to appropriate penalties¹³, and bring the definition of torture into full conformity with the definition contained in the Convention against Torture;
c) establish channels for submitting complaints that are accessible in practice, ensure that an official investigation is initiated whenever there are any indications of the use of torture, and protect complainants from persecution;
d) establish an effective and independent mechanism for criminal investigation and prosecution that is in no way connected with the authorities conducting the investigation or prosecution in the case against the alleged victim;
e) permit access to independent medical examinations at all stages of criminal proceedings without interference or the presence of law enforcement or prosecutorial officers; and ensure independent medical examinations of persons deprived of their liberty, particularly upon their admission to a place of detention or their transfer from another place of deprivation of liberty;
f) ensure that the future legislation on refugees duly takes into account the principle of non-refoulement enshrined in article 3 of the Convention against Torture.
2. Safeguards and Rehabilitation
81. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities take the following measures:
a) register persons deprived of their liberty at the moment of their detention, and ensure that they have access to lawyers and the possibility of notifying family members immediately from the moment of deprivation of liberty;
b) reduce the period of detention in police custody in accordance with international standards (not more than 48 hours);
c) strengthen the independence of judges and lawyers; ensure that, in practice, evidence obtained through torture cannot be used as evidence in any hearings and that persons convicted on the basis of evidence obtained through torture are acquitted and released; and continue the monitoring of courts conducted under the auspices of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe;
d) shift the burden of proof to the prosecution, which must convincingly demonstrate that confessional statements were not obtained through the use of any coercive measures, and consider the possibility of organizing video and audio recording of interrogations;
e) incorporate into domestic legislation provisions on the right of victims of torture and ill-treatment to compensation for damage, and ensure the functioning of clearly defined enforcement mechanisms.
¹³ The Government assured the Special Rapporteur that this process had already begun.
3. Institutional Reforms
82. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities take the following measures:
a) continue and accelerate the reform of the prosecutor's office, the police and the penal system in order to transform them into transparent bodies clearly oriented towards serving the interests of their clients, including through modernized and demilitarized training;
b) transfer temporary detention facilities from the authority of the Ministry of Internal Affairs¹⁴ and pretrial detention centres from the authority of the National Security Committee¹⁵ to the authority of the Ministry of Justice, and raise awareness among Ministry of Justice staff regarding their role in preventing torture and ill-treatment;
c) develop a system for the enforcement of sentences that is genuinely aimed at the rehabilitation and reintegration of offenders, in particular through the abolition of restrictive prison rules and regimes, including for persons sentenced to lengthy terms of imprisonment, and the provision of the widest possible contacts with the outside world;
d) continue efforts to strengthen non-custodial pretrial and post-trial measures, particularly, but not exclusively, with regard to minors; and provide the probation service with sufficient human and other resources¹⁶;
e) establish a national preventive mechanism as an independent institution in full conformity with the Paris Principles and provide it with sufficient human and other resources;
f) ensure that medical personnel in places of detention are genuinely independent of the administration of justice, i.e. transfer them from the authority of the Ministry of Justice to the authority of the Ministry of Health.
¹⁴ According to the Government, this issue is under consideration, but implementation of this measure will require substantial material investment.
¹⁵ The Government indicated that the detention of persons accused of espionage or treason in institutions not under the authority of the National Security Committee would require enhanced security arrangements, since many of these persons possess State secrets, and this would make it difficult to ensure that such secrets are not disclosed if they are detained together with other detainees.
¹⁶ According to the Government, criminal enforcement inspections are being strengthened.
4. Women
83. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities adopt a law on domestic violence in full conformity with international standards. The law should focus not only on prosecution but also on preventive measures; ensure official investigations into alleged acts of domestic violence and provide adequate funding for the support infrastructure for victims of domestic violence and trafficking in persons; and establish a national database of cases of violence against women.
5. Children
84. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities take the following measures:
a) explicitly prohibit corporal punishment of children by law in all circumstances;
b) raise the age of criminal responsibility and establish a juvenile justice system based on respect for the best interests of the child; and abandon the practice of placing minors in temporary detention facilities;
c) request technical assistance and other forms of support from the United Nations Interagency Panel on Juvenile Justice, which includes the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, the United Nations Children's Fund, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and non-governmental organizations, for the purpose of implementing these reforms.
6. Health-Care Institutions/Psychiatric Hospitals and Harm Reduction
85. The Special Rapporteur recommends that the relevant authorities take the following measures:
a) ensure compliance with existing safeguards for patients, in particular their right to free and informed consent to treatment in accordance with international standards (see also A/63/175); change the terminology used to describe different types of disabilities, in particular abandoning the word "idiots"; ratify the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities; use placement in specialized institutions only as a measure of last resort; permit independent monitoring of all institutions; and ensure that all deaths in such institutions are investigated by an independent body in accordance with the principle of transparency;
b) initiate harm reduction programmes for persons deprived of their liberty who suffer from drug dependence, including by providing them with substitute medication and organizing programmes for the exchange of used syringes in places of detention.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Programme Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages