Commentary on Article 30. Excess of a Participant in a Criminal Offense under the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
An excess of a participant is recognized as the commission by a person of a criminal offense that is not covered by the intent of the other participants. The other participants shall not be subject to criminal liability for such excess.
Pursuant to Article 30 of the Criminal Code, an excess of a participant is recognized as the commission by a person of a criminal offense that is not covered by the intent of the other participants. An excess may be committed by any participant in a criminal offense (the perpetrator, organizer, instigator, or accomplice). The participants are held liable only for those acts that were covered by their intent. Since one of the subjective elements of complicity is the unity of intent among all participants, meaning that each of them is aware of the act in the commission of which they are participating, an excess by any one of them excludes the liability of the others. For example, if the perpetrator, in addition to committing a residential burglary agreed upon with the other participants, also kills the homeowner who suddenly appears, without this having been agreed upon with the other participants, this constitutes an excess of a participant in a criminal offense.
Depending on the degree to which the perpetrator deviates from the agreement reached between the participants, quantitative and qualitative excesses are distinguished. In certain cases, while committing an act agreed upon with the other participants, the perpetrator goes beyond the scope of the agreement either with regard to a qualifying circumstance or with regard to the form of the offense. In other cases, the perpetrator commits a different criminal offense instead of the agreed one, causing harm to a different protected legal interest (for example, rape instead of theft).
In the case of a quantitative excess, a more dangerous but homogeneous crime is committed, which infringes upon the same homogeneous protected legal interest (for example, life and health are different but homogeneous protected legal interests). Causing harm to two protected legal interests instead of one should also be recognized as a quantitative excess. A qualitative excess means causing harm to a different, non-homogeneous protected legal interest. The practical significance of distinguishing between quantitative and qualitative excesses by the perpetrator lies mainly in determining the legal classification of the acts of those participants whose intent did not encompass the perpetrator's excess. In the case of a quantitative excess by the perpetrator, the instigator shall be liable for instigating the crime that they encouraged the perpetrator to commit. Thus, if the instigator encouraged the perpetrator to use violence against the victim (for example, to inflict moderate bodily harm), but the instigator's intent did not encompass depriving the victim of life, the instigator shall be held liable for instigating the infliction of moderate bodily harm (Article 107 of the Criminal Code), even if the perpetrator commits murder. In the case of a qualitative excess, when the perpetrator decides to commit a different, non-homogeneous crime, complicity as such is absent, and the instigator's actions may be classified only as preparation for a crime (unsuccessful instigation).
It should be borne in mind that an excess by the perpetrator presupposes a difference in the direction of the intent of the participants. If, however, the direction of their intent is identical, but the perpetrator is actually unable to carry out the objective elements of the crime, there is no excess by the perpetrator in such a situation. Instigation to a crime whose commission is interrupted at the stage of attempt is classified with reference to both Article 24 and Article 28 of the Criminal Code.
The actions of a person who has committed a crime not covered by the intent of the other participants cannot be classified as having been committed as part of a group (a group of persons, a group of persons acting upon prior agreement, an organized group, a criminal community, or a criminal organization). Thus, where a person, being a member of a criminal organization or criminal community, commits a crime that was not covered by the intent of the other members of the criminal organization or criminal community, that person's actions in this respect, as an excess by the perpetrator, shall be classified under the relevant article of the Special Part of the Criminal Code without reference to Articles 262 and 263 of the Criminal Code, provided that the act committed by that person was not connected with the plans of the criminal organization or criminal community.
In this case, the other participants shall not be subject to criminal liability for the excess. In other words, an excess by the perpetrator means going beyond the agreed scope, that is, independently committing a criminal offense outside the intent of the other participants. Such an offense may be more serious or less serious compared with the act that the participants had agreed to commit (for example, the perpetrator was supposed to commit a residential burglary but, in addition to the burglary, also commits murder).
The rules for classifying crimes in cases of an excess by the perpetrator are addressed in the Regulatory Resolution of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 11, 2003, “On Judicial Practice in Cases of Theft,” according to which: “If a group of persons acting upon prior agreement intended to commit theft or robbery, and one of the participants, in the course of committing the criminal offense, used or threatened to use violence dangerous to the life or health of the victim (an excess by a participant in a criminal offense), that person's actions shall be classified as armed robbery, while the actions of the other participants in the criminal offense shall be classified, respectively, as theft or robbery, provided that they did not directly facilitate the use of violence or take advantage of such violence to take possession of the victim's property” (paragraph 9).
Commentary to the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2021, by Isidor Shamilovich Borchashvili, Honored Figure of Kazakhstan, Doctor of Law, Professor, Academician of the Kazakhstan National Academy of Natural Sciences, member of the Scientific Advisory Councils under the Constitutional Council of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan, member of the working group on reform of the law enforcement system under the Security Council of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Honored Employee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Advocate Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative cases and disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Statute Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages