Comments to article 169. Change of the subject or the basis of the claim, increase or decrease of the claims of the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
1. The plaintiff has the right to change the basis or subject of the claim, increase or decrease the amount of the claims by submitting a written application before the completion of the preparation of the case for trial or before the court is removed to the conference room, if there is no need for additional procedural actions. A change in the basis or subject of a claim, an increase or decrease in the amount of claims may be filed after compliance with the pre-trial dispute settlement procedure, if such procedure is established by law or provided for by a contract.
2. Simultaneous or in any sequence, a change in the subject and the basis of the claim means that the plaintiff submits a new claim and the plaintiff rejects the previously filed claim, which entails the termination of proceedings on the previously filed statement of claim. Simultaneous or in any sequence change of the subject and the basis of the claim is allowed in case of conclusion of an agreement on settlement of the dispute (conflict) by mediation.
3. The court may not, on its own initiative, change the subject matter or the basis of the claim.1. The plaintiff has the right to change the basis or subject of the claim, increase or decrease the amount of the claims by submitting a written application before the completion of the preparation of the case for trial. Such actions are carried out precisely at the stage of preparing the case, so that the other party can also prepare for the process, and there are no grounds for postponing the proceedings.The implementation of such actions before the court is removed to the conference room is rather an exception to the rule. These may be cases when, for objective reasons, the defendant did not participate in the stage of preparing the case for trial and appeared only at the court session. It is possible that the parties have reached an agreement within the framework of conciliation procedures, the terms of which require a change in the basis or subject of the claim, an increase or decrease in the amount of claims. However, an important condition for the satisfaction of such a request is the absence of the need for additional procedural actions.If a pre-trial dispute settlement procedure is established by law or provided for by a contract for claims that are being changed, such changes may be announced only after compliance with this procedure. For example, the bank filed a lawsuit with the court for early recovery of the entire amount owed on the loan due to the defendant's violation of the terms and maturity dates. At the court hearing, the bank changes the subject of the claim for termination of the contract on the same grounds. In this case, consideration of claims for termination of the contract is possible only after a preliminary settlement of the dispute in accordance with the requirements of paragraph two of Article 402 of the Civil Code.2. Simultaneous or in any sequence, a change in the subject and the basis of the claim means that the plaintiff submits a new claim and the plaintiff rejects the previously filed claim, which entails the termination of proceedings on the previously filed statement of claim. The court clarifies the legal consequences of simultaneously changing the subject matter and grounds of the claim provided for in the commented norm, and clarifies the position on the claim. In pursuance of this rule, the judge selects from the plaintiff an application for termination of the proceedings in connection with the rejection of the claim and explains its legal consequences provided for in the second part of Article 278 of the CPC.
If the plaintiff does not waive the claim in writing, but insists on changing both the grounds and the subject of the claim, the court may also terminate the proceedings in connection with the plaintiff's rejection of the claim, since new claims are actually being filed, having recorded the fact of the plaintiff's rejection of the claim in the ways established by Chapter 26 of the CPC. A civil case on a new claim is initiated and considered in accordance with the procedure provided for by the CPC. It is possible that the plaintiff may ask the court to return the application without consideration on the grounds specified in subparagraph 8) of Article 279 of the CPC. Simultaneous or in any sequence change of the subject and the basis of the claim is allowed only in case of conclusion of an agreement on settlement of the dispute (conflict) by way of mediation. Such provisions allow the parties to overcome the conflict and go beyond the subject matter and the basis of the claim, which is consistent with the goals of mediation. In this case, the proceedings are terminated in connection with the approval of the agreement on the settlement of the dispute (conflict) by mediation.3. The court may not, on its own initiative, change the subject matter or the basis of the claim. The parties themselves choose the right to choose the method of protection, therefore, court intervention in the content of the claims is not provided.
LIBRARY OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
Astana, 2016
UDC 347 (574)
By 63
ISBN 978-601-236-042-4
Constitution Law Code Standard Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal service Legal advice Civil Criminal Administrative cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases