.png)
Foreclosure on a Participant’s Share in a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)
📘 I. General Characteristics of the Institution
Foreclosure on a share in an LLP is a non-contractual method of alienating a participant’s share due to their personal debts that are not related to the activities of the LLP.
This represents an exception to the principle that LLP participants are not liable for the obligations of the partnership. However, they remain liable for their personal debts, including their property — such as their share in the charter capital.
📑 II. Commentary on the Content of the Article
🔹 Conditions for Foreclosure
"If the property of a participant is insufficient… creditors may demand the allocation of the share…"
🔍 Foreclosure on a share is allowed only if all of the following conditions are met:
The LLP participant is a debtor under personal obligations;
The debtor has insufficient other property (proven during enforcement proceedings);
The creditor applies for the allocation of the share in accordance with the procedure established by law.
📎 Related legal provisions:
Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Enforcement Proceedings and the Status of Bailiffs”;
Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Article 264 (general rules for foreclosure on property).
📘 Example:If an LLP participant has a debt under a court decision and does not possess other property, a judicial enforcement officer may petition for the allocation of the participant’s share in the LLP in order to sell it and satisfy the debt.
🔹 Form of Realization of the Share
The law does not directly specify the mechanism, but judicial practice and legal logic suggest the following.
Possible methods:
Allocation of the share in kind is impossible (an LLP is an indivisible entity).
Therefore, the share:
is sold at auction;
or is purchased by the LLP itself or by the other participants (if provided by the charter or by a decision of the meeting).
📘 In case of sale:
the buyer of the share may become a participant in the LLP only with the consent of the other participants (if such a requirement is established in the charter — see Article 80 of the Civil Code of the RK);
if consent is not granted, the share is purchased by the partnership itself, and its value is paid to the creditor.
🔹 Rights of the LLP and Other Participants
📘 Within enforcement proceedings:
the LLP has the right to submit objections;
it may propose an alternative buyout of the share at market value;
the participants may exercise the pre-emptive right to purchase the share (by analogy with Article 80 of the Civil Code of the RK).
⚖️ III. Judicial Practice
📌 Example 1:In case No. 2-3941/2022, a judicial enforcement officer applied to the court to allocate the share of a debtor-participant in AgroStroy LLP. The court granted the request, and the share was sold through electronic auction because the debtor had no other property.
📌 Example 2:In case No. 2-2611/2023, the court refused to satisfy the creditor’s claims because there was no evidence of the debtor’s lack of other property (inventory and valuation reports were not provided).
📚 IV. Related Legal Provisions
Legal Provision Content Civil Code of the RK, Article 80 Transfer and sale of a share Civil Code of the RK, Article 264 General rules on foreclosure of property Law of the RK “On LLPs and Additional Liability Partnerships”, Articles 23–24 Foreclosure on a share, consent of participants Law of the RK “On Enforcement Proceedings” Powers of judicial enforcement officers Civil Procedure Code of the RK Application to court for allocation of a share 🌐 V. International Practice
Country Approach Germany (GmbH) A share may be sold by a creditor, but requires the consent of participants France (SARL) Forced sale is possible, but transfer requires approval Russia (LLC) Foreclosure is directly permitted, with a right of participants to buy out the share United States (LLC) Only the right to distributions may be transferred, not management rights 🔍 General trend: balancing the rights of creditors with the protection of the “closed” circle of participants.
📝 VI. Conclusions and Recommendations
Foreclosure on a share in an LLP is an extreme measure, permissible only when other means of enforcement are impossible.
A judicial enforcement officer must:
prove the absence of other property of the debtor;
conduct a valuation of the share;
organize an auction or initiate a buyout.
LLP participants may:
exercise the pre-emptive right to purchase the share;
challenge the forced sale in court if the procedure is violated.
The LLP charter may provide for:
prohibition of transfer of a share without consent;
a procedure for the partnership to buy out the share of a debtor-participant;
mechanisms for valuation and buyout of the share.
Attention!
Law and Law Law Law draws your attention to the fact that this document is basic and does not always meet the requirements of a particular situation. Our lawyers are ready to assist you in legal advice, drawing up any legal document suitable for your situation.
For more information, please contact a Lawyer / Attorney by phone: +7 (708) 971-78-58; +7 (700) 978 5755, +7 (700) 978 5085.
Attorney at Law Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Advice Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Protection Arbitration Law Firm Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases
